EPA
             Enyirorn-.entai P-ctectscn
             Agency
            'ecyaccrs arc
            Wasnmgren. CDC
             Watw
Chromium
             Water Quality Standards
             Criteria Summaries:
             A Compilation
             of State/Federal Criteria
f*SS

-------

-------
                            DISCLAIMER

     .This publication was prepared by Battelle under  contract   to
the  U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (Contract   68-03-3534).
Secondary information sources were used to compile data  presented
in this document.   Each State was given an opportunity to   review
and provide  comments on a draft of this information document.   In
no  event  shall  either the United States or  Battelle   have   any
responsibility  or liability for any use, misuse, or reliance upon
the  information   contained herein, nor does  either  warrant   or
otherwise represent in any way the accuracy, adequacy,   efficacy
or applicability  of th« contents hereof.                       ;

     The  reader  should consult the water quality standards of  a
particular State  for oxact regulatory language applicable to'that
State.   Copies of State water quality standards may  be  obtained
from  -the   State's  Water  Pollution  Control  Agency  \ or    its
equivalent.                              ,

     Additional information may also be obtained from the:

                         Standards Branch
             Criteria and- Standards Division (HH-585)  .           '
             Office of Water Regulations and Standards
              U.S.  Environmental Protection Agency
                     •Washington, D.C.  20460
                           202-475-7315
     This document may b* obtained only from the National Technical
Information Service (NTIS) at the following address:

                National Technical Information Service
                       5285 Front Royal Road          ,
                    Springfield, Virginia 22161
                         703-487-4650

     The NTIS order number is:  PB89-14I584	   '   	   ;v

-------
INTRODUCTION

This  digest  is   compiled to provide general information  to  the  public  as veil
as  to   Federal,   State,   and  local  officials.   It  contains excerpts  from  the
individual    Federal-State   vater  quality  standards   establishing pollutant
specific criteria  for interstate surface vaters.  The vmter quality standards
program   is   implemented  by  the  U.  S.  Environmental Protection Agency vhere
responsibility   for   providing   vater   quality recommendations, approving
State-adopted  standards  for  interstate   vaters,  evaluating adherence 'to  the
standards,   and  overseeing  enforcement  of  standards compliance, has  b««n
mandated by  Congress.

Standards,   a nationvide strategy for surface vater quality management,  contain
three  major  elements:   the use (recreation, drinking  vater, fish and  vildlife
propagation,   industrial,   or  agricultural) to be made of the navigable vater;
criteria 1:0  protect   these  uses;  and an an ti degradation statement to  protect
existing high quality  vaters,  from degradation by the addition of pollutants.
Guidance Jior the development of standards by individual States is contained in
tvo  EPA documents entitled ffater Quality  Standards Handbook  (1983) and  Quality
Criteria for Water (1986).

Chromium is  an   element   rarely  found  in  natural vaters.  It has oxidation
states   ranging from Cr~  to Cr* ,  of vhich the trivalent  form is most  commonly
found  in nature.     Chrooium  salts, primarily chromateat and dichromates,  are
used  extensively  in  metal finishing, textile, and leath«r tanning industries.
They are also used in  pigments,  fungicides, and vood  pr*s«rvativ«s.

Chromium, has  been shovn  to  be  an  essential trace element for humans even
though   it   has  been   shovn  to be toxic  in some instances.   Chromium  has been
found  to produce  toxic   effects  in  aquatic  life  vfaon  in relatively high
concentrations.                        '     .
The 1986 Qxmlity Criteria for gater rec
ids the folloving:
Ghromium(VI)
    human health
         SCI ug/1
         chronic                      "       acute
    freshviiter aquatic organism and their uses
         11 ug/1                             16 ug/1
    saltvaner aquatic organisms and their uses
         50 ug/1                             1100 ug/1

Chromium(in)
    human health
         170 mf/1
         chronic                             acute
                                            Ur8.8190[ln(hardn«ss) ]*3.688>
    saltvacer  aquatic organisms and their uses
         no  criteria can be derived
                                      -2-

-------
Sine.  vat«r  quality  standards   »r«   revis«d   fro«  tia.  to  tim.
proc^urw  s«t forth in' th« Cl«an Vat.r  Act, indiv!duai!ntr?.s in rt
                                    -3-

-------
                                   REFERENCES

 5   California Water Quality  Standards by River Basins, ca. 1973


     For  sore detailed information on selected' basins, sub-basins and stretches

     Standard^?*       °°       *****  "*"   tO  C*liforni* St*<« **ter Quality


 12  Idaho  Department  of  Health  and  Welfare Rules and Regulations, Title 1
     Chapter    2,   "Water   Quality   Standard*   and   Wastevater   Treatment
     Requirements', 1980.


 25  Missouri  Water  Quality  Standards, 10 CS1 20-7.031, Rule of Department of
     Natural Resources: Division 20 - Clean Water Commission.


 31  Water  Quality  Standards  for  Interstate  and  Intrastate  Streams in Nev
     Mexico, State of Nev Mexico Water Quality Control Commission, 1988.


 35  JS0 »Va5*r  Q"*11^  Standards,  Chapter 3745-1 of the Administrative Code,
     Ohio Environmental Protection Agency, 1985.


 42  Tennessee's  Water  Quality  Criteria  and  Stream  Use Classifications for
     Interstate  and  Intrastate Streams,  Tennessee Water Quality Control Board:
     Department of Health and Environment, 1987.
43
Texas  Surface  Water  Quality  Standards,  Texas  Water  Commission.
Change, 1988.
                                                                            Rule
44  Utah   Standards  of  Quality  for  Waters of the State,- Wastcvater Disposal
    Regulations:   Part  XX,   State  of  Utah,  Department of Health* Division of
    Environmental Health,  1988.


46  Virginia Water Quality Standards, State Water Control Board,  1987.

51  Water  Quality Standards  for  American Samoa,  1984,  pp. 16-18.

52  Water   Quality   Standards   of  the  District  of  Columbia,   Chapter  42,
    Department  of Consumer. and Regulatory Affairs, 1985, Section  4206.1.

53  Revised   Guam Water  Quality  Standards,   Guam  Environmental  Protection
    Agency, 31984,  pp.  7, 12-13.


54  CommonvefLlth   of   Northern  Mariana  Islands Marine and Fresh Water Quality
    Standard!!,  Cosewnvcalth  Register, Vol.  8 No. 5,  1986, pp.  4464-4468.

55  Puerto  Rico   Water Quality  Standards  Regulation,  Environmental Quality
    Board, 1983.
56  ?£Sn"  auad  Pr**h  ¥mt€r   Quality  Standard  Regulations,  Trust Territory,
    1986, pp. 5,8—10.


57  Jmt?r .Q"*11^  Standards   for   the  Coastal  Waters of the Virgin. Is lands,
    Title 12, Chapter 7,  Subchapter  186,   1985,  p. 263.

-------
 ENmONMENT  REPORTER,  The  Bureau  of National Affairs, Inc. Washington, D.C.



                           9, 1982, 701:1003-1004, Juae 26, 1981, 701:1005-1010,


 2   Pages 706:1005-1009, Novenber 7, 1986                    •

 3   Pages 711:1002-1003, 1016-1019, 1021, February 7, 1986

 4   Pages 716:1004-1005, August 30, 1985

 6   Pages 726:1005-1006, March 22, 1985, 726:1011, August 22, 1986

 7   Pages 731:1002,  1006-1007,  May 14,  1982

 8   Pages 736:1001,  1006-1010,  March 28, 1986

 9   Pages 746:1010.1-1010.3,  Septeaber  5, 1986                           '  ,

 10   Pages 751:0504-0505, Decustxsr 27, 1985

 11   Page  756:1002,  S«pteab«r 20,  19B5


 13   Pages 766:0505-0506, 0514,  March 28, 1986* 766:0507-0508, May 25,  1984


                                            10,  1986, 771:1003-1006,  Auguj: 10,
     o    T,
    1984, 771:1007T1009,  Oeeoaber 26,  1980  .

15  Pages 776:1005-1006,  February 13,  1987

16  Pages 781:1011-1012,  March  27,  1987

17  Pages 786:1007-1010,  Kov«ab«r 29,  1985

18  Pages 791:1005-1006,  January  18, 1985
      *                        "
19  Pages 796:0104-0109>  0127-0128, April  18,  1986

20  Page 801:1002, April  19,  1985

21  Page 806*1002, June 21, 1985

22  Pages 811:1003-1004,  February 13,  1987

23  Pages 816:1003-1010,  Jun« 25,  1982


24  Pages 821:1002-1003,  Octob€r  25, 1985

26  Pages 831:1004-1009,  April  19,  1985

27  Pages 836:1003-1006,  March  27,  1987

                  .   ' '  •             -5-          .

-------
 28
'  108?'
                                                       22' "85, 841:1005, 1008,
 29  Pages 846:1002-1004, 1008-1009, October 5, 1984


 30  Pa^ea 851:1004, 1009-1010, 1017-1019, 1021, April 11, 1986


 32  Pages 861:1007-1012, 1017-1018, 1032-1036, Noveaber 29, 1985


 33  Pages 866:1006, December 27,. 1985, 866:1009-1013, August 29, 1986


 34  Pages 871:1002-1004, June 7, 1985


 36  Pages 881:1003-1008, 1014, S«pteaber 26, 1986


 37  Pages S86: 1006- 1047, May 9, 1986


 38  Pages 391:1004-1005, August 9,  1985


 39  Pages 901:1002-1005, 1012-1015, August 9,  1985


 40  Pages <>06:1004,  1006-1009,  Noveab«r 29,  1985


 41  Pages 911:1003-1005, March 22,  1985


 45  Page  931:1006,  March 22,  1985


 47   Pages 941: 1002L-1005 , Octob«r 21,  1983
   •                         '             ''»,»            '.

48   Pages 946:1002,  1008, August  10,  1984


49   Page  931:1002,  March 13,  1987


50   Page  956:1005, July  5,  1985


52   Pages 741:1002-1003,  March  28,  1986
                                     -6-

-------
 State and Tatar Qse
 Chrcedua Criteria Values
 All

 All
 Public Water Supply
Svimaing  and  Other
Vhole Body  Vater-
Contact Sports
Shellfish Harvesting
Fish And Vildlife
 Not specified         .  '       .

 Minimi*  conditions  narrative:   State vaters shall be
 fr**    ^f00   substances   attributable   to   sevage,
 industrial  vastes or other vastes in concentrations or
 combinations  vhich  aro  toxic  or  harmful  to'human,
 animal  or aquatic life to the extent commensurate vith
 the designated usage of such vaters.

 Toxic   substances •  narrative:    Only  such  amounts,
 vhether  alone  or in combination vith^other substances
 as  vill  not render the vaters unsafe or unsuitable as
 •    source   of   vater   supply   for - drinking   or
 food-processing   purposes,    or.   injurious  to  fish,
 vildlife  and  aquatic  life,   or  adversely affect the
 aesthetic  value  of  vaters  for  any  use  under this
 classification.

 Toxic substances narrative:  -Only such amounts,
 vhether alone or in combination vith  other substances
 or  vastes,   as   vill  not  render  the vater unsafe or
 unsuitable  for   sviMing   and vater-contact sports; be
 injurious  to fish,  vildlife and aquatic life or,  vhere
 applicable,   shrimp  and crabs} impair th« palatability
 ox  fisa,  or vhcre applicable,  shrimp and crabs;  impair
 the   vaters   for  any  other usage established for this
 classification  or-  unreasonably  affect  the aesthetic
 valusi of  vaters  for any use  under this classification.

 Toxic  substances   narrative:     Only  such  amounts,
 vhether   alone or in  combination  vith other substances,
 as  vili   not  b«  injurious  to  fish and aquatic  life,
 including shriap  and   crabs;  affect the marketability
 of  fish   and  shellfish,  including   shrimp and crabs;
 exceed  one-tenth of  the 96^hour  median  tolerance  limit
 for   fish,   aquatic life or  shellfish,  including shrimp
 end erab«.

Toxic   substances    narrative:     Only   such  amounts,
vhether   alone or in  combination  vith other substances,
as  vill  not  be  injurious   to  fish and  aquatic  life,
 including  shrimp and crabs  in  estuarine or salt vaters
or  the propagation thereof; not  to exceed one-tenth of
 the   96-hour  median  tolerance   limit   for   fish   and
aquatic  life, f including  shrimp  and crabs in  salt  and
estuarine    vaters,    except    that    other    limiting
concentrations,  may   be  used   vhen factually justified
and approved by  the Commission.

-------
 StateandJJater QM
 Chromium Criteria Values
 Agricultural & Indus-
 trial Vater Supply
 Industrial Operations
 Navigation
 Toxic substances narrative:   Only such amounts  as  vill
 not  render  the  vaters  unsuitable  for  agricultural
 irrigation,  livestock  vatering,  industrial  cooling
 industrial  process  vater  supply  purposes,  and fish
 survival,  nor interfere vith dovnstream vater uses.

 Toxic  substances narrative:   Only such amounts as vill
 not   render   the  vaters  unsuitable  for  industrial
 cooling and  industrial process  vater supply purposes,
 nor interfere vith dovnstreaji vater uses.

 Toxic  substances narrative:   Only such aaounts as vill
 not  render  the  vmters  unsuitable  for  agricultural
 irrigation,   livestock  vatering,   industrial  cooling,
 and  industrial  process  vmter   supply purposes,  vhere
 applicable,  nor interfere vith dovnstream vater uses.
All

I. Fresh Water
   (A) Water  Supply
       (1) drinking,
culinary & food
processing.
Not specified

Toxic substances narrative:   Shall not exceed Alaska
Drinking Eater Standards or 2PA Quality Criteria  for
Vater.                                  	
      (ii) agricultural Toxic substances narratives   Same is I.(A)(i)  vhere
incl. irrigation and    contact  vith a product destined for subsequent human
stock,vmtering          consumption is present.  Same as I.(C)  or F7PCA Vattr
                        Quality     CriteriaCVQC/PgPCA)    as    applicable—to
                        substancesforstockvaters.   Concentrations   for
                        irrigation   vaters  thall not exce«d (VQC/FgPCA) or VQC
                        1972.	     —'
     (iii) aquaculture
Toxic  substances narrativ«t  Shall not individually or
in  combination  exceed  0.01 times the lovest measured
96-hour  U"    for life stages of species identified by
th«   departlent   as   being   the   aost   sensitive,
biologically  isportaat  to  the  situation  or  exceed
criteria  cited  ia  EPA  Quality Criteria for Water or
Alaska     Drinking     Water    Standards,vhichev«r
concentrationis  less.Substancesshall  not  be
present  or exceed concentrations vhich individually or
ia  combination  impart  undesirable  odor  or taste to
fish  or  other  aquatic  organisms  as  determined  by
either bioossay or organoleptic tests.

-------
  State and Water 0»e     Chroniiai Criteria Value*
        (iv)  industrial,
  including may vater
  supplies  used in asso-
  ciation vith  a manu-
  facturing of  production
  enterprise  (other than
  food processing),  in-   -
  eluding mining,  placer
  mining, energy produc-
  tion or development.

   (B) Water Recreation
       (i) contact
  recreation.

      (ii) secondary
 recreation

   (C) Grovth And Propa-
 gation Of Pish, Shell-
 fish, Other  Aquatic
 Life, And Wildlife
 Including Vaterfovl  ,
 And  Furbearers
 Toxic  substances narratives
 present vhich  pose hazards
  Substances  shall not  be
to worker contact.
 Toxic substances narrative:  Same as I.(A)(i).
II. Marine  Water
   (A) Water Supply
      (i) aquaculture

      (ii)  seafood-
processing
 Toxic substances narrative:  Substances shall not be
 present vhich pose hazards to incidental human contact.

 Toxic substances narrative:  Shall not individually or
 in coabination exceed 0.01 times the lovest measured
 96-hour LC5Q for life stages of species identified by
 the department as-being the most sensitive,
 biologically important to the location, or exceed
 criteria  cited  in  EPA  Quality Criteria for Water or
 Alaska     Drinking     Water    Standards'	vhichever
 concentration   is  lest.substances  shall  not  be
 present  or exceed concentrations vhich individually or
 in  combination  impart  undesirable- odor  or taste to
 fish  or  other  aquatic -organisms-  as  detemined  by
 either bioassay or organoleptic tests.
Toxic substances  narratives  Same  as  I.(A)(iii).

Toxic substances  narrative:  , Shall not  exceed  EPA
Quality   Criteria   fog  Water  as   applicable  to   the
                         suostanee.
    (iii) indu*trial,
including any vater
supplies us«4 in assoc-
iation vith a maim-
facturing or production
enterprise (other  than
food processing) includ-
ing mining, placer
mining, energy pro-
duction or development.
Toxic substances narrative:   Same as I.(A)(iv).
  (8) Water Recreation
      (i) contact
recreation
Toxic substancos narrative:  Shall not exceed EPA,
Quality Criteria for Water as applicable to
constituent.
                                     -f-

-------
State and Water ge
                          Chromium Criteria
        (ii)  secondary    Toxic  substances  narrative:  Same as I
 recreation
   (C) Grovth And Propa- Toxic substances narrative:
 gation Of Fish, Shell-
 fish, Aquatic Liile And
 Wildlife Including Sea-
 birds, Waterfovl And
 Furbearers.
                                                     Same as I.(C),
   (D) Harvesting For
 Consumption Of Rav
 Mollusks Or Other Rav
 Aquatic Life
                       Toxic  substances narrative:   Same as  I.(C)  but
                       excluding  the  phrase  "or Alaska Drinking Water
                       Standards."      ,                       .	
 Arizona3
                         (as Or hexavalent plus trivalent)
 Domestic and Recreation 0.050 S mg/1 (Sofilterable residue)
.Aquatic and Vildlife

Agricultural

An Effluent
Dominated Waters

Vest .Fork .of* the •
Little 'Colorado  River
above Government Springs
                       0.050 S mg/1 (S»filtcrable residue)

                       1.000 T mg/1 (T»total residues)

                       (tri fc hex) 0.05 eg/1 dissolved


                       0.01 mg/1 dissolved
Oak Creek  and  Its  West   5 ug/1 dissolved
Pork
                         Toxic  substances  narrative:  All surface vaters shall
                         be  fre«  froa  toxic,   corrosive, or other deleterious
                         substances   attributable  to  domestic  or  industrial
                         vastt  or  other  controllable  sources at levels or in
                         combinations  sufficient  to be toxic to human,  animal,
                         plant,    or   aipiatie  life.    Vith  respect  to  fish
                         toxicity,  receiving  vaters outside mixing zones shall
                         not   have  a concentration of toxic materials exceeding
                         1/10  of  the  96-hour  LC50,  vhere  the  bioassay  is
                         conducted  using  fish  inhabiting the receiving vaters
                         and    vhere   vnter  quality  conditions  (temperature,
                         hardness,   pfl,   dissolved  oxygen,  etc.)  approximate
                         those  of  the  stream or lake as closely as practical.
                         Compliance  shall  be  indicated  vhen survival  of test
                         group  organisms  is  not less than that of the  control
                         group   organisms   exposed  to  an  appropriate  vater
                         sample.
                                      -10-

-------
  State and 7ater
 'Cartadua Criteria Valuta         .          ,    '    ••  -

 a.    No  p«rson  shall  cause- toxic  substances, to be
 present   at   concentrations   vhich   interfere  vith
 designated protected uses.

 b.    Compliance vith, a. (above) shall be determined on
 a sito-specific basis for each discharge.

 c.    To  determine  compliance  vith  this Section and
 other   vater   quality  standards,  and  to  determine
 vhethar  toxic,  carcinogenic,  mutagenie, teratogenic
 corrosive,    or    oth«zvis«   deleterious   substances
 attributable  to  pollutants, effluent, savage or vaste
 in   concentrations  or  combinations  vhich  interfere
 directly  or  indirectly  vith protected uses are being
 discharged,    the   Department  may  require  chemical,
 physical,   biological,.radiological or other testing by
 dischargers.
 Arfcj
All

All
 Not  specified
                            '        -               *
 Toxic   materials   shall  not   be  present  in receiving
 vaters,   after  mixing,  in  such  quantities  as to be
 toxic   to  huaan,   animal,  plant or aquatic life or to
 interfere  vith   th«   normal   propagation,   grovth  and
 survival   of  the  indigenous  aquatic biota.   ¥ithin  the
 mixing  zone  there  may. be  a zone of initial dilution
 vhich.  exceeds  the  acute  toxicity.     In no instance
 shall   tha  entire   mixing;   zone  be  acutely  toxic.
 Compound*  knoira   to   b«   persistent,   cumulative,
 carcinogenic  or   to  exhibit  synergism vith other vaste
 or   stream  components    shall   be  addressed  on  a
 case-by-case  basis.   Permitting of all toxic materials
 anall   b« • ia  accordance vith the toxic implementation
 strategy  fouad in  the Continuing Planning Process.
California5

Doeestic Vater Supply

Agricultural us«o in
Basin 2 only

Ocean Vaters only
0.05 ajj/1

1.0 mf/1


0.002 off/1 -.6-month Median>

0.008 Bsj/1 - Daily Maximum

0.02 ms/l - Instantaneous Maximum
                                      -11-

-------
  State and Water Pi

  An
 Chroedua Criteria Val

 All   vators   shall   be   «aint*in«d  free  of  toxic
 substance  in  concentrations  that  are  toxic to, or
 that  produce  detrimental  physiological  responses in
 human,  plant,  animal,  or  aquatic  life.  Compliance
 with  this  objective  vill  b«  determined  by  use^f
 indicator  organisms,  analyses  of  species diversitv
 population  density,  growth  anomalies,  bioaaaaya  of
 appropriate  duration  or  other appropriate methods aa
 sp«cifi«d by th« Regional Board.

 Thj  .furvival   of  aquatic - li£«  in  surfac.  vat.ra
 s«bj«ct«d  to  a vut* discharg«,  or other controllable
 w*t«r  quality factor*, shall not  1* lass than that for
 j?* ».****  V*t"r  bod7 *" ***** unaffactad by the vaate
 discharge,   or  when  necessary for other control vatur
 that   is   consistent   with   the   requirements  for
 "experiaental  vater" as described in "Standard Methoda
 for  the Exaaination  of Vater and Vastevattr",  latest
 edition.   As a Biniaua,  coaplianco vith this objective
 as   stated   in the previous sentence shall be tvaluated
 vith a 96-hour bioassay.                       • .   v""°

 In    addition,    effluent   liaits   based  upon   acute
 bioassays    of   effluents  vill  be  prescribed   vhert
 appropriate,    additional   numerical  receiving   vattr
 objectives   for  specific toxicants vill be established
 as    sufficient   data  becosM  available/  and .  source
 control  of  toxie  substances vill be encouraged.
Colorado
Aquatic  Life (1)(3)(4)  Trivalents  Acute « «<°-819tln(h**dn«s)]«-3.688)
                                     Chronic . «<0-819(ln(hardness)]+1.561)
Agriculture (2)
                         Bexavaleatt
Trivaleat:
& Hexavmlent
Drinking Vater Supply   Trivaleat:
(2>                      & Hexavalent
Acute « 16 ug/1
Chronic « 11 ug/1

100 ug/1 30-day avg.


50 ug/l 1-day avg.
All
Except  where  authorised, by permits, BHP's  or  plans  of
operation  approved by  the Division, State vatcrs  shall
be  free  fro*  substances attributable  to huaan-caused
point  source or nonpoint source discharges  in  aaounts,
concentrations  or  cosUiinations  which  are harmful  to
beneficial  uses  or  toxic to humans, animals,  plants,
or aquatic life.
                                      -12-

-------
  State  and  ?ater Us*
  Caroaiua Criteria Values
                          Footnot«a:
                          (1)    H«tals    for   aquatic   life   us.   art   stated   as
                          dissolved unl«ss  otherwise specified.                 **

                          (2)  totals   for  agriculture  and   domestic   uses   ar,
                          stated as total recov*rable  unless  otherwise' specified.

                          (3)  Hardness  values   to  be  used  in-  equations  are in
                          mg/1  a*  calcium carbonate.   The  hardness values used
                          in  calculating   the  appropriate metal standard  should
                          be  based  on the lover 95 per  cent  confidence  limit  of
                          the  mean  hardness  value  at  the  periodic   lov flov
                          criteria  as  determined  fro.  a regression analysis  of
                          site-specific  data.   vhere  insufficient site-specific
                          data  exists - to  define the mean hardness value  at  the
                          periodic  lov  flov  criteria,  representative  regional
                         data  shall b« used to perform  the regression analysis.
                         where  a  regression  analysis  is  not  appropriate, a
                         site-specific  method should be used.   In calculating a
                         hardness  value,  regression  analyses  should  not  be
                         extrapolated past the point that data exist.
                              Both  acute  and chronic numbers adopted as stream
                         standards  arc levels not to be exceeded acre than once
                         every three years on the average.
Coaaocticut'

All

All
 Not: specified .      *         •       .

 Toxic  substances  narrative:   General  Policy  11.   The
 vatera  shall  b«  free   from   chemical  constituents in
 concentrations  or   combinations vhich vould  be harmful
 to   human,   animal or  aquatic  life   for   the   most
 seaaitive  and  governing vater use  class.  Criteria for
 cn«sieal    constituents    contained    in    guidelines
 published  by  the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
 shall  (xi considered.  In areas vhere fisheries are the
 governing  consideration  and numerical  limits  have not
 beeffl   established,   bioassays  may  be necessary  to
 establish    limits   on   toxic   substances.       The
 recoaaandations  for  bioassay  procedures  contained in
 "Standard  Hethods   for  the  Examination   of Vater and
 tfastevater"  and  the  application factors  contained in
 SPA vmter quality guidelines shall be considerad.

 For   surface  waters  classified  for   use  as  public
 drinking   vater,     th«   rav  vater  sources  must   be
 maintained   at   a  quality  as  defined   by  criteria
'developed  by  the U.S.  EPA in accordance vith  the  Safe
 Drinking  Water  Act  (P. A.  93-523)  or  the  State  of
 Connttctieut  (Section  19-13-B102 of the Regulations  of
 Connecticut   State   Agencies),   whichever   is   more
                                     -13-

-------
 State mad Water Us*
                         Chroaitai Criteria Val
 Coastal And Marine
 Vat«r Uses
 (Classes SA,  SB,  & SC)
                         stringent,  so  that criteria for finish«d water can b«
                         met after conventional treatment.

                         Toxic substanc«s narrative:  None in concentrations or
                         combinations vhich would be harmful to human, animal
                         or  aquatic  lift or which would make the waters unsafe
                         or-   unsuitable   for   fish   or  shellfish  or  their
                         propagation,   impair  the  palatability  of  same,  or
                         impair  the  waters  for  any  other uses. (See General
                         Policy 11. above)
Delaware0

All                      Not specified

General  Stream          Toxic substances narrative:  All surface waters of the
Criteria                State  shall  be  free  from substances attributable to
                         wastes  of industrial, municipal, agricultural or other
                         anthropogonic   origin, „ such   as   any   pollutants,
                         including  those  of  toxic  nature,  that may interfere
                         with  attainment  of  designated  uses  of  the  water,
                         impart  undesirable  odors,  tastes,   or  colors to the
                         water  or  to  aquatic  life  found  therein,  endanger
                         public  health,  or  result  in  dominance  of nuisance
                         species.

Stream Quality Criteria Toxic substances narrative:  None in concentrations
(General Criteria  For    that may Interfere with attainment of designated uses
                         of  the water, endanger public health, or* result in
                         dominance  of  nuisance  species.   -The  following EPA
                         publications,  or  any  other sources de«*ed acceptable
                         by   the  Department,  may.  be  used  as  guidelines for
                         applying these Standards to discharges in the State:
                         (1) Water Quality Criteria 1972 (March, 1973),
                         (2) Quality Criteria For later (July, 1976),
                         (3)      Water      Quality     Criteria     Documents,
                             (BPA-440/5-80-015  through  5-80-079), published in

                         (4)
Freshwater iind  Salt-
water Streans)
Public Water Supply
                                  Water      Quality     Criteria     Documents,
                             (BFA-440/5-84-028     through     5-84-033,     and
                             5-85-001), published in 1985.

                         Waters  shall  be  free froa substances (except natural
                         iaperitieit)  that,   alone  or in combination with other
                         substanceii,   result   in   concentrations   of   toxic
                         substance*  in the treated water that may be harmful to
                         human   h«alth.      The  EPA  Water  Quality  Criteria
                         Documents,    (EPA-440/5-80-015through5-80-079)
                         published  in  1980, (or other sources as determined by
                         the  Department)  shall  be  used  as guidelines in the
                         determination of acceptable concentrations.
                                      -14-

-------
        mad
  EKES Waters
  Chrtmiim Criteria Values         ,


  levels SubstM1C8S  n*rr*tiv«s   Shall not exceed natural

  (ERZS   -   Exceptional   Recreational   or  Ecological
  Significance)                               •  .;  •  * •    .
 Florid*3

 All
All  * -
  Minimum criteria for surface vaters:
  All   surface   vaters of  the  State shall'at  all  .times  at
  all  places  be  free  from:

  Domestic,    industrial,     agricultural,     or   other
  Ban-induced    non-thermal    components   of  discharges
  vhich,   alone  or   in combination vitti  other  substances
  or   in   combination vith other  components of  discharges
  (vhether thermal or non-thermal);              i

      Are acutely .toxic; or

      Are   present    in   concentrations   vhich   are
      carcinogenic,   mutagenic,  or  teratogenie  to  human
      beings    or to   significant,  locally  occurring,
      vildlife  or aquatic species;  or

      Pos«  a   serious  danger   to   the  public  health,
      safety, or  velfare.

 Genexal  critaria for  surface nater quality (applied  to
 all  surface  vaters   except  vithin  zones of  a'ixing):
.Substances   in   concentrations   vhich    injure,  are
 chronically  toxic  to, or produce adverse physiological
 or  behavioral response in huaans1, animals, or  plants  -
 non« shall be present.

 Shall  not  exceed  0.50  ag/1  hexavalent  or  1.0 ng/1
 total  in  effluent discharge and shall not exceed 0.05
 •I/I. total  after  reasonable  mixing in the receiving
 vater.                          •        .
Georgia

All


All
       10
 In*tr*««   concentrations  shall  not  exceed  20  ug/.i
 (total)  except vithin established mixing zones.

 Toxic substances  narrative:  All vaters shall be fre«
 from  toxic  substances discharged from municipalities,
 industries  or other sources in amounts, concentrations
 or   combinations  vhich  are harmful to humans, animals
 or  aquatic life.
                                      -15-

-------
  State mad ffiater
 Chroedua Criteria Values
  Drinking ffater Suppli«s Toxic  substances  narrative   No  aaterial  or'substance
                          in  such  concentration  that,   after   treatment, would
                          exceed    the   requirements    of    the  Environmental
                          Protection  Division  and the  latest edition of  Federal
                          Drinking Water .Standards.                        ^«Q«rai
 Recreation; Fishing,
 Propagation Of Fish,
 Shellfish, Game And
 Other Aquatic Life.

 Agricultural
 Industrial
 Navigation
 Toxic wastes narrative:  None in concentrations that
 would harm nan, fish and game or other beneficial
 aquatic life.
 Toxic  substances  narrative:    None in concentrations
 that  vould interfere vith or adversely affect uses for
 *«neral  agricultural  purposes  or  would prevent fish
 survival.

 Toxic  substances  narrative:    None in concentrations
 that  vould  prevent  fish  survival  or interfere with
 legitimate and beneficial industrial uses.
 Toxic  substances  narrative:
 that   vould  damage  vessels,
 otherwise interfere with c
Hawaii

All

All
       11
Idaho12

AH

Domestic Vattir Supply
 None  in  concen t ra t i ons
 prevent fish survival or
srcial navigation.
Not specified

Toxic  substances   narrative:   All waters, shall  be free
of  substances  attributable to  domestic,  industrial,  or
other    controllable    sources    as   follovs:     toxic
substances  at   levels  or combinations sufficient  to  b«
toxic  or  harmful  to   human,  animal,  plant  or  aquatic
life  or in  amounts   sufficient to  interfere with any
beneficial use  of the vater.
     As  a  minimum, a  phytoplankton  bioassay test or a
96-hour  bioassay   shall be required.   Survival  of test
organisms  shall  not   be  lets  than  that in controls
vhich utilize appropriate experimental vater.
Not specified

Max. allovnble concentration: 0.050 mg/1

The  follovinf  general  vater  quality  standards vill
apply   to  waters  of   the  State,  both  surface   and
underground,   in   addition    to   the  water   quality
standard*   set   forth   for   specifically   classified
                                      -16-

-------
 St*t« and Tatar Use     Caroailiai Criteria Valu«s
                         waters.    As  a result of man-caused point or nonpoint
                         source   discharge,   vaters  of  the  State  oust  not
                         contain:
                         .01  Hazardous
                         concentrations
                         significance  or
                         protected beneficial uses.
                                         Materials;  (see  Section 01-2003,19.)  in
                                           found    to    be  of   public   health
                                            to,  adversely  affect  designated   or
                         •02  Deleterious  Materials;  (see Section 01-2003,07.)
                         in  concentrationsthat impair designated or protected
                         beneficial usos without being hazardous.
 niinoi*13

 General  Use
                         Total hexavalcnt
                         Total trivalent
0.05 mg/1
1.0  mg/1
                         Toxic  substances  narrative:     Any substance toxic to
                         aquatic  life shall not exceed one-tenth of the 96-hour
                         median  tolerance limit (96-hr.  TL ) for native fish or
                         essential   fish   food  organisms,   except  for  USEPA
                         registered  pesticides approved  for  aquatic application
                         and  applied pursuant to specified condition*.
Public And Pood          0.05  ag/1
Processing Water  Supply

Secondary Contact and    Total hexavaltnt
Indigenous Aquatic Life  Total trivalent
Effluent Standards
                         Hexavalent
                         Total
0.3 mg/1
1.0 mg/1

0.1 mg/1
1.0 mg/1
                         (a)  No  person   shall  cause or allov the concentration
                         of  chromium   ia   any   effluent  to  exceed  the  above
                         levels,  subject   to   the  averaging rules contained in
                         S«ctioa 304.104(a).                              ,

                         (b)  Discharges of hexavmlent chromium shall  bo  subject
                         to  the  averaging rule  of Section 304.104 modified as
                         follovs:    monthly averages shall  not exceed 0.1  ng/1;
                         daily  composites  shall  not exceed 0.3 mg/1;  and,  grab
                                shall  not  exceed  1.0 mg/1.
TTVfHa^


All


All
                        Not specified

                        Toxic  substances  narrative:    All  waters  at  all  times
                        and  at  all  places,  including  the  mixing  zone  ,  shall
                        m««t   the   minimum   conditions  of  being  free   from
                                     -17-

-------
  State and fater Us«
 Chromium Criteria	

 substances   attributable   to  municipal,  industrial,
 agricultural,  and  other  land  use practices or other
 discharges  vhich  are in amounts sufficient to injure,
 be  acutely  toxic  to  or  othervise  produce  serious
 SZJS  Pft!i0l°giC^  r«aP°na«  in  humans, animals,
 aquatic   life  or  plants.    As  a  guideline,  toxic
 substances  should  be  limited  to  the 96-hour meSi™
 lethal  concentration  (LC30)  for biota significant to
 the    indigenous    aquatic    community    or   other
 representative  organisms.    This subsection shall not
 apply  to  the  chemical  control  of aquatic plants or
 animals-  vhen  that  control  is subject to approval by
 the   Indiana   Department   of  Natural  Resources  as
 provided   by  the  Pish  and  Vildlife  Act  (1C  1971,
 14—2-1).

 u ,.,At,.  *?  tlBM»  *11 vaters outside of aixing zones
 shall  be free of substances in concentrations vhich on
 the  basis   of  scientific  data  are  believed  to  be
 sufficient   to  injure,   be chronically toxic to,  or be
 carcinogenic,   mutagenic,   or  teratogenic  to  humans,
 animals,  aquatic life,  or plants.
 Aquatic Life
These'  standards  are  applicable  at
vaters  outside of the aixing zone:
                                                                any  point  in  the
                         Toxic  substances  narrative:  Concentrations  shall  not
                         exceed   one-tenth   of    the   96-hour  median   lethal
                         concentration  for important indigenous aquatic  sp«ci«s
                         or other representative organisms.
                              Contaminants.    vhich    are    known     to     be
                         bioaccumulative  and  toxic;  on the basis of  ayailabl*
                         scientific    data,    shall    not   be   present    in
                         concentrations    vhich    vould    result     in   'the
                         bioaccumulation    or    bioconcentration    of    such
                         contaminants   or   their   degradation   products    in
                         important  indigenous  aquatic  species to Federal Pood
                         and   Dnif   Administration  action  levels  or  levels
                         producing  deleterious effects prohibited in subsection
Potable  Supply
The
                                                                        chemica
Ohio River Main  Stem
and the Interstate
Portion Of The Vabash
River
Chemical    substances   narrative:
constituents  in  the vaters shall not be  present  after
conventional  treatment  in  such  levels  as  to  prevent
meeting  the  Drinking  Water   Standards adopted by  ch«
Board,.

0.03 mg/1 (hexavalent)
                                      -18-

-------
  State  and  Vmter Urn*

  L*k« Michigan  and Con-
  tiguous Harbor Areas
 Grand Calumet River;
 Indiana Harbor
 Chroedum Criteria 7aln
-------
  State and ffater Us*
  Chroedum Criteria
                          Toxic  substances narrative:   All waters,  at all
                             rltah
                          attributable  to  vastewater discharges or agricultural
                          Practices  in  concentrations or combinations which are
                          toxic or harmful to human,  animal,  or plant life.

 Wildlife,  Fish, Aquatic  0.05  ag/1 (total hexavalent)
 And Semiaquatic Life,
 Secondary  Contact        Toxic substances narrative:   All substances toxic  or
 (C1*" B)                detrimental    to  aquatic   life   shall   be  limited  to
                          nontoxie  or   nondetrimental   concentrations   in  the
                          surface  water.
 Potable water Supply
 (Class C)
       16
in

All
Aquatic Li fit
 0.05 ag/1 (total hexavalent)

 Toxic  substances  narrative:   All substances toxic or
 detrimental  to  humans  or  detrimental  to  treatment
 process  shall be limited to nontoxie or nondetriaental
 concentrations in the surface water.
 Not specified

 General  criteria:     An surface waters jrtmll be fr««,
 at  ,an  times,   fro* the harmful - effectn of substances
 that   originate   fro«  artificial  sources  and  that
 produce   any   public   health   hazards  or  nuisance
 conditions,    or  impairment  of  uses.     The  harmful
 effects   may   result  from  any  concentration  of  a
 substance  that   causes  toxic  effects,   alone  or  in
 combination    with   other   artificial   or   natural
 subatancea.    Such  substances  shan   be  limited  to
 concentrations  in  the receiving water  that will not be
 harmful to human, animal,  or plant life.

 Toxic subntances narrative:
 (ii) The   waters of   the  state shall not be toxic as  a
 result  ofi  the   effects of substances originating from
 artificial  sources,   whether  alone  or  in .combination
 vith other artificial or natural substances.

 (iii)   Criteria   for   the   protection  of predators,  in
 term*   of  toxic levels   in  fish, published  in "Vater
Quality  Criteria"  (National  Academy  of  Engineering,
 1973),  which  is hereby adopted by reference,  shall  be
used   as  guidelines   in   assessing  toxicity   due   to
b i oaccuteula t i on.
                                     -20-

-------
  State  and  V»ter  Os«
                         Caroaiua Criteria Values
 Domestic Vater Supply
                         (iv>  Vhen   criteria  for  single  compounds  have  not  been
                         published   or   are  incomplete, or vhen  complex  mixtures
                         can   result  in  ^interactions   among   substances,   the
                         department   shall    utilize   laboratory    and   field
                         bioassessment   methods   and  procedures   to establish
                         site-specific  vater quality criteria.

                         Any   concentration  of   a  substance   from   artificial
                         sources  that,  alone or .in  combination  vith  other
                     ...  artificial   or natural substances,  causes  toxic effects
                         on    humans   shall  be'   limited    to    non-harmful
                         concentration*.                               .  .

Consumptive Recreation   Substances      that     can    bioaccumulate   through
                         bioconesntration  or  bioaagnification  to toxic levels
                         in  aquatic  life, semiaquatic life  or vildlife  consumed
                         by  humans   shall   b«  limited   in  surface  vaters  to
                         concentrations  that  vill  result  in no harm to humans
                        upon  consumption.  PDA action levels defined in K.A.R
                        28-16-28b(b)(19)  for  toxic  substances in  fish flesh/
                     ,   vhich  are   hereby  adopted by reference, shall b« used
                        as guidelines  to determine protection of this use.
Agricultural  Irrigation 0.1 mg/1 chromium (VI)

Agricultural  Livestock  1.0 ag/1 chroaium (VI)
         17
Jtentucfcy

All
Vansvater Aquatic
Habitat, Coldvtter
Aquatic Habitat
                       .Surface  vaters shall not b« aesthetically or othervise
                        degraded  by  substances  that  injure,  b« toxic to or
                        produce  adverse  physiological or behavioral responses
                        in humans,  animals, fish, and other aquatic life.

                        Toxic substances narrative:
                        1. Th
-------
 State and 7ater Ose
 Chro«dun Criteria Val

 used  .instead  of  the  0.1  and 0.01 factors listed in
 this subsection upon approval by the cabinet.

 4. 100 ug/1 total recoverable
 Doaestic Water Supply   0.05 mg/1 total recoverable
 Mixing Zones
 Toxic  substances  narrative:   Concentrations of toxic
 substances  which  exceed the ninety-six (96) hour LC50
 tests-  .for  representative indigenous aquatic organisms
 are  not  allowed  at any point within the mixing zone.
 A  zone,  of  initial  dilution  nay  be  assigned  on a
 case-by-case  basis  at  the discretion of the cabinet.
 Concentrations   of   toxic   substances  which  exceed
 one-third  (1/3) the ninety-six (96) hour LC30 or other
 appropriate  LC50  tests  for representative indigenous
 aquatic  organisms  are  to  be  met at the edge of the
 zone   of  initial  dilution.    Chronic criteria for the
 protection  of  aquatic  life are to be met at the edge
 of  the allowable Mixing zone.
All
Not  specified

General  Criteria  narrative:   All waters shall be free
fro* such  concentrations  of substances attributable to
•wastewmtar   or   other  'discharges  sufficient  to injure,
be   toxic or producedemonstrated  adverse physiological
response    in    humans,    animals,    fish,    shellfish,
wildlife, or plants.

Toxic  substances  narrative:    Shall not be  present in
quantities   that alone  or in  combination will  be toxic
to   plans: or aninal life.  Concentrations of  persistent
toxic  substances  for   which  no numerical  criteria are
given  in   the   Standards  shall not  exceed the 96-hour
LCSO/100    (one-hundredth    of  the    96-hour    LCSO).
Persistent   toxic  substances   are  defined  herein  as
refractory   substances   subject to  very limited or no
biodegradation   and/or   detoxification  and  subject to
food  chain  bioaceuaulation;   they include but are not
United  to  pesticides,  PCS'a  and  heavy metals  that are
designated    by   EPA    as    priority  pollutants.
Concentrations   of  non-persistent, biodegradable toxic
substances   for   which   no numerical  criteria are given
in   the standards,  shall not exceed the 96-hour LC50/10
(one-tenth   of   the 96-hour  LCSO).  Bioassay  techniques
comparable   with those  given in  the latest  edition of
Standards  Methods  for  the  Examination  of Water and
Va*tev*t«r   win be  used in  evaluating toxicity using
specific  methods,  dilutions,   and  species  of aquatic
animals best suited to the area of  concern.

             -22-

-------
  State and Sater Dae
  Chromium Criteria Values
 Maine

 All

 All
       19
 Classes B-l, B-2, C,
 D, SD
 Classes  SA,  SB-1,
 SB-2,  SC
All
 Not specified
 Sit" J^n b* K° ?isP°sal of *"y »*tter or substance
 that  contains  chemical constituents vhich are harmful
 to  humans,  animals or aquatic life or vhich adversely
 affect any other vater use in  the classes.   .

 There shall b« no disposal of  sevage, industrial

 UM *!* s°r  Oth'f  !°tM  in  SUch vmttrs' •««?«' ^ose
 which  have received treataent for the adequate removal
 of  vaste  constituents  including, but not limited to,
 solids,    color,   turbidity,   taste,  odor  or  toxic
 material,  such  that  these   treated  vast es  vill not
 lover  the  standards  or  alter  the  usages  of these
 classifications,  nor  shall such disposal of sevage or
 vaste  be  injurious  to  aquatic  life  or render such
 dangerous for human consumption.

 There 'shall be no  toxic vastes, deleterious
 substances,   colored  or  other vaste or heated liquids,
 discharged  to  vaters  of these  classifications either
 singly  or  in  combinations   vith  other substances or
 vaste*  in  such  amounts or  at such temperatures as to
 be  injurious  to   edible  fish  or shellfish or to the
 culture   or propagation thereof,  or vhich in any manner
 shall  adversely .affect  the  flavor,   color,   odor or
 sanitary   condition  thereof;   and  othervise  none  in-
 sufficient   amounts  to  make  the  vaters  unsafe  or
 unsuitable  for  bathing  or   impair the vaters for any
 other  best  usage  as determined for the  specific vaters
 vhich  are assigned  to  these classes.
                                /   -                 ~
 Toxic   substances    narrative:      No   person,   firm,
 corporation    or   other   legal   entity  shall   place,
 deposit,   discharge  or  spill, directly or indirectly,
 onto   the  inland   or  tidal vaters of  this State,  or on
 the  ice   thereof,   or  on  the  banks  thereof so  that  the
 same  may  flov  or b« vashed into  such  vaters,  or in
 suca  manner   that  the  drainage therefrom  may  flov  into
 such vaters:             ,

Any   other    toxic   substance   in   any  amount  or
 concentration    greater    than   that    identified   or
 regulated,   including   complete   prohibition  of  such
substance,   by   the    board.     In  identifying  and
regulating  such toxic  substances,  the board shall  take
 into   account   the  toxicity   of   the   substance,  its
persistence  and  degradability, the usual or potential
presence  of any organism affected by such substance in
any  vaters  of  the  State,  the   importance  of  such
                                     -23-

-------
 State  and  7«t«r QM
  Ghroedua Criteria Values
 Maryland

 An

 "All
         20
                          organism   and   the  nature  and extent of  the effect of
                          such  substance on  such organisms, either alone-or in
                          co«bination  vith  substances  alr«ady in  the
                          vaters or  the discharge.
 Not specified      •

 Toxic  substances  narrative:  The waters of this state
 •ay   not   b«  polluted  by  high-temperature,  toxic,
 corrosive,     or    other    deleterious    substances
 attributable  to  sevage,  industrial  waste,  or other
 vaate in concentrations or combinations vhichs
 (a)  interfere  directly or indirectly vith vater uses;
     , or
 (b)  are  harmful  to  human,  animal, plant or aquatic
      life*
                         Toxic  materials  criteria  are  established to protect
                         freahvater  aquatic  life,  saltvmter
                         human ho<h.
                                        aquatic  life or

All
Rot  specified

For   each  claas,  the most sensitive beneficial uses are
identified  and   minimum  criteria for vater quality in
the   vmter column are established.   In interpreting and
applying   the minimum criteria in 314 CHR 4.03(4), the
Division   shall   consider  local  conditions including,
but  not limited  tot

(a)   the characteristics of the biological community;

(b)    temperature,   veather,   flov,   and   physical and
chemical characteristics;  and

(c)      synergistic   and  antagonistic    effects of
combinations  of pollutants.

Th«  Division vill   use  the   EPA  criteria established
pursuant   to  Section  304
-------
 Sfit« tad gater (7«e
 All
Michigan

All

All
        22
 Chroaiua Criteria Values

 the  provisions  of the specifically listed criteria in
 these standards shall apply.:

 Other  constituents  narrative:    Waters shall be free
 fro.  pollutants  in    concentrations  or combinations
 tnat
 (a)   exceed   the   recomaended  limits'  on  the  most
 sensitive receiving water use;
                         (b)    injure,    are   toxic
                         physiological   or  behavioral
                         aquatic life;  or
                               to,  or  produce  adverse
                                responses  in  humans or
                         (e).   exceed    site-specific   safe   exposure   levels
                         determined  by  bioassay  using sensitive species.
 Not specified

 R 323.1057 Toxic substances narrative:  Rule 57.

 (1)  Toxic  substances  shall  not  be   present   in the
 waters   of  the state at levels which art or may becoae
 injurious   to  the  public  health/safety, or welfare;
 plant  and animal life;  or the designate uses of those
 waters.    Allovable levels of toxic substances shall be
 determined   by   the   commission,   using  appropriate
 scientific data.   .           ...

 (2)   All of the folloving provisions apply for purposes
 of   developing   allowable levels of toxic substances in
 th«  surface  vaters  of  the state applicable ,to point
 source  discharge  permits  issued  pursuant to  Act No.
 243   of  the  Public  Acts  of  1929, a* amended,  being
 §323.1 et  seq.  of the Michigan Compiled Lavs:

 (a)   Water  quality-based  effluent limits  developed
 pursuant   to  this subrule shall be used only  vhen they
 are   sore  restrictive than technology-based limitations
 required pursuant to R 323.2137 and R 323.2140.

 (b)  The   toxic   substances to which this subrule shall
 apply   are  those   on  the  1984  Michigan  critical
 materials   register'established pursuant to Act  No.  245
 of   the. Public   Acts of 1929,  as amended,  being $323.1
 et   seq.   of  the  Michigan Compiled Laws;  the priority
 pollutants    and    hazardous   chemicals  in 40   C.F.R.
 §122.21,    appendix  D  (1983);   and any  other  toxic
substances  as   the  commission  may determine   are of
 concern at  a  specific site.
                                     -25-

-------
State and ¥ater Use
Chro«iua Criteria Val
                      . (c)   Allowable  levels  of  toxic  substances  in  th«
                        surface  water  after  a  discharge  is  mixed with the
                        receiving  stream  volu»e specified in R 323.1082 shall
                        be  determined by applying an adequate margin of safety
                        to  the  KATC,  NOAEL,  or other appropriate effect end
                        points,  based  on  knowledge  of  the  behavior of the
                        toxic   substance,  characteristics  of  the  receives
                        vater,  and the organisms to be protected.

                        (d)   In   addition   to   restrictions   pursuant   to
                        subdivision   (c)  of  this  subrule,   a  discharge  of
                        carcinogens,   not  determined  to  cause  cancer  by  a
                        threshold  mechanism,   shall not create a  level of risk
                        to  the  public health greater than 1  in 100,000 in the
                        surface   vater   after   mixing   vith  the  allowable
                        receiving  stream  volume specified in R 323.1082.   The
                        commission may  require a greater degree  of protection
                        pursuant    to    R  323.1098  where  achievable  through
                        utilization of  control  measures  already  in place or
                        where otherwise determined necessary.

                        (e)  Guidelines  shall  be  adopted pursuant to Act No.
                        306  of  the   Public   Acts  of  1969,  as amended,  being
                        §24.201  et seq.  of the Michigan Compiled  Lavs, setting
                        forth   procedures   to   be   used • by staff  in  the
                        development of  recommendations  to  the  commission on
                        allovablft  levels  of   toxic substances and  the minimum
                        data  necessary  to derive  such recommendations.   The
                      'cosaUssion  may  require  the-  applicant to  provide the
                        minimus  data    when    otherwise   not available   for
                        derivation  of  the allowable levels of  toxic  substances.

                        (f)   For existing discharges,  the commission  say  issue
                       a  scheduled  abatement   permit   pursuant  to R 323.2145
                       upon   a  determination   by  the  commission  that   the
                       applicant   has  demonstrated  that  each  of  the  following
                       conditions  is met:

                        (i)  IfflMdiate  attainment  of  the allowable level  of a
                       toxic  substance   is   not   economically or  technically
                       feasible.

                       (ii) No prudent alternative exists.

                       (iii)  During   the  period  of scheduled abatement,  the
                       permitted   discharge   will  be   consistent   with   the
                       protection of the  public health,  safety, and welfare.

                       (iv)   Reasonable   progress   will   be   madt  toward
                       compliance  with  this  rule  over  the  term of  the  permit,
                       as provided for in a schedule  in  the permit.
                                    -26-

-------
 State and Water use

 Minnesota23

 Domestic (Classes
 A, B, C, & D)

 Fisheries and Rec-
 reation

 All
 Chroaiun Cri t eria 7alu«
 0.05 mg/1 (hexavalent)
 Class A
 Classes B and C
0.02 Bg/1
0.05 ag/1
 All
Agriculture and WiId-
life  (Class B)

Limited Resource Value
Waters
 For  contaminants  other  than heat, the 96-hour median
 tolerance  limit  for  indigenous  fish  and  fish food
 organisms  should  not  be exceeded at any point in the
 mixing zone.

 Toxic  substances  narrative:    No discharges at levels
 acutely  toxic  to  humans  or  other  animals or plant
 life, or directly damaging to  real property.
          i                 '                '
 Toxic substances narrative:  None at levels  harmful
 either directly or indirectly.

.Unspecified substances shall not be allowed  in such
 quantities  or  concentrations   that  will  impair  the
 specified uses.
Mississippi24

Public Water Supply

All
0.05 ttff/1  (hexavalent)

Toxic  substances  narrative:-  Waters  shall be free from
substances   attributable    to  municipal,   industrial,
agricultural  or   other  discharges  in concentrations  or
combinations  which  are '  toxic   or  harmful to  humans,
animals or aquatic life.

There  shall  be   no substances  added,, whether alone  or
in  combination vith other substances, that  vill impair
the  use  of  waters  from that  which it  is  classified.
The  concentration of toxic  pollutants shall not exceed
one-teatfl  (l/10th)  of  the  96-hour median tolerance
limit  based  on   available  data.   The concentration  of
toxic  pollutants  that are cumulative and/or persistent
•ay  be  further limited on  a  case-by-case basis,  where
such data is available.
     Available  references   to  be  used  in  determining
tbxieity  limitation* shall  include,  but  not be  limited
to   Quality '  Criteria  for  Water  (Section 30A(a)),
Federal  Regulations  under  Section  307,   and  Federal
Regulations  under  Section  1412   of the Public Bealth
Service  Act  as amended by  the  Safe  Drinking Water Act
(Pub.   L.  93-523).  The use of  such  information should
be  limited  to  that part applicable to  the indigenous
aquatic coamunity  found  in the State  of Mississippi,
                                     -27-

-------
 State and 7nter


Missouri25

Aquatic Lifa

Drinking Water
Supply

Irrigation

Groundvater
                                  Criteria 7alu«
Effluent  Regulation*
Subsurface  ¥
-------
 State and Yater  use

 Montana26

 All

 Vater Supply (Class A-
 Closed)
 Vater Supply (Classes
 A-l,  B-l,  -B-2, B-3)
 Pish,  Aquatic Lif«,
 Vildlife,  Agriculture,
 Recreation In And On
 The  Water  (Class C-3)

 Fish,  Aquatic Life,
 Vildlife,.  Agriculture
 Recreation In And On
 The  Water  (Classes C-l,
 C-2)

Agricultural  and In-
 dustrial (other  than
Pood Processing)
 (Class E)
All Classes except  (A-
Closed and E)
 Chrtniiua Criteria Valu«
 Not specified

 Toxic substances narrative:  NO increases of toxic or
 other  deleterious  substances,  pesticides and orranic
 and  inorganic  materials including heavy metals,  above
 naturally occurring concentrations, are allowed.

 Toxic substances narrative:  Concentrations of toxic
 or  other  deleterious substances which would remain in
 the  vater  after conventional water treatment must not
 exceed  the maximum contaminant levels set forth  in the
 1975  National Interim Priaary Drinking Vater Standards
 (40  CFR  Part 141) or subsequent revisions or the 1979
 National  Secondary  Drinking  Vater  Standards (40 CFR
 Part 143)  or subsequent revisions.

 Saae as  above                                      •
Toxic substances narrative:  Concentrations  of  toxic or-
other deleterious  substances mist  not  exceed levels
which render  the waters harmful, detrimental or
injurious  to  public health.                   ,
Toxic substances narrative:  Concentrations  of  toxic  or
deleterious substances, pathogens,  pesticides and
organic and inorganic materials  including  heavy"
eetala,  mist  be  less   than  those  demonstrated  to  be
deleterious  to  livestock  or   plants  or  to humans who
may  census*  such  livestock or plants  or to adversely
affect other, indicated uses.

The maxima allowable concentrations  of  toxic or
deleterious  substances   also  must not  exceed  acute  or
chronic  problem  levels  as  revealed   by  bioassay  or
oti*r  sethods.  The values listed  in EPA  Vater Quality
Criteria  documents (Federal Register Vol. 45,  No. 231,
Friday,  Nove»oer  28, 1980, pages  79318 - 79379)  shall
ba  used  as a guide to determine problem  levels unless
local  conditions  .oakt these values  inappropriate.   In
accordance  with  section 75-5-306(1),  MCA, it .is not
necessary  that  wastes be treated  to a  purer condition
than the natural condition of the receiving  water.
                                     -29-

-------
  State  and  Water U««
 Ghroaioa Criteria Values
 All

 Aquatic Life
 Public Drinking Vater
Agri cultural
Aesthetics  and Public
Health
 Not completely specified

 Toxic  substances  narrative:    Surface  waters of the
 State  shall  be  free  fro*  toxic substances in toxic
 amounts.    No toxic substances alone or in combination
 with  other  substances in concentrations rendering,the
 receiving  vater  unsafe or unsuitable for aquatic life
 vill  be allowed.  (In implementing these criteria, the
 Department  vill  follov  procedures  outlines  in  the
 State's  Continuing  Planning Process which comply vith
 th«  federal vater quality standards, 40 C.F.R.  §131.11
 (1986)).

 0.05 *g/l
 Toxic   substances   narrative:       Vastes   or  toxic
 substancas  introduced  directly or indirectly by huaan
 activity  in  concentrations that vould degrade  the use
 (i.e.,   would produce undesirable physiological  effects
 in humans) shall not be allowed.

 Toxic   substances   narrative:       Vastes   or  toxic
 substancas  introduced  directly or indirectly by huaan
 activity  in  concentrations that vould degrade  the use
 (i.e.,   vould produce undesirable physiological  effects
 in crops or livestock) shall not be allowed.

.Toxic substances narrative:   Surface water* shall b«
 fr«tt   o£ '  radionuclides   or   toxic   substance*  in
 concentrations   or   combinations  which  may  product
 undesirable physiological responses in humans.
Nevada28

All

Humbolt River
  Municipal or
    Domestic Supply

  Preshv&titr Aquatic
    Life

  Irrigation
0.02 mg/l

(Total)    (H«x)   mg/1
0.03


0.72

0.1
0.05
0.021
  Watering Of Livestock
    and Propagation  Of   1.0
    Wildlife
All
Toxic  substances   narrative:   Waters must be free from
toxic    substances   attributable   to   domestic   or

             -30-


-------
 State mod Vater 0«e     Garoedua Criteria Valuea
Drinking Vater Supply
(vith treatment by
disinfection only)
Suitable For Aquatic
Life Habitat, Vildlife
Propagation, Agricul-
tural, Recreation,
Boating, Esthetics
(Class A)

Drinking Water Supply
(vith treataaot by
disinfection and fil-
tration only), Agri-
cultural, Aquatic
Life And Vildlife
Propagation, Recrea-
tion, Industrial and
Esthetics (Class B)
 industrial   v&ste   or   other   controllable   sources  at
 levels   or   combinations   sufficient   to  be  toxic  to
 human,   aniaal,  plant  or aquatic   life or in  amounts
 sufficient   to  interfere vith  any  beneficial use of  the
 vater.

 The   presence   of   toxic   materials   in a vater  must be
 evaluated   by   use   of  a 96-hour bioassay.   Survival of
 test  organisas  must   not be  less than that in  control
 tests vhich .utilize   appropriate control  vater.  The
 test  organisas  and control vater must be specified by
 the   department.     In  addition, acute bioassays may be
 required  ,to determine effluent  limitations  and  the
 exact test  aethod to be used must be defined by  the
 department.     Failure  to determine presence of toxic
'materials    by   these   methods   shall  not preclude
 determination  of   excessive   levels  of toxic materials
 on the basis of other criteria or  methods.

 Wastes    from    municipal,    industrial    or   .other
 controllable  sources   containing    arsenic,   barium,-
 boron,  cadmium,  chromium,  cyanide,  fluoride,  lead,
 selenium,  silver,   copper and zinc that are reasonably
 amenable   to   treatment   or  control  must   not  be
 discharged   untreated   or   uncontrolled into the vaters
 of  Nevada   (including  the Colorado River  System). In
 addition,    the   limits    for concentrations   of   the
 chemical   constituents   must provide  vater   quality
 consistent  .vith the mandatory requirements  of the 1962
 Public Health Service Drinking Vater  Standards.

 None  (zero)
Toxic substances narrative:  Only such amounts as vill
not render receiving vaters  injurious to  fish or
vildlife or impair the receiving vaters for any
beneficial uses established  for this class.
                                      -31-

-------
State and Vater Use
                          Chromium Criteria
 Drinking Water  Supply
 (following complete
 treatment) Agricul-
 tural, Aquatic  Life,
 Vildlife Propagation,
 Recreation;, Esthetics
 and Industrial  (Class C)

 Boating and Esthetics,
 Aquatic Ufa, Vildlife
 Propagation,  Agricul-
 tural and Industrial
 (except for Food
 Processing Purposes)
 (Class D)
                        Same us last
                        Toxic'substances  narrative:   Only such amounts  as  vill
                        not  impair receiving waters  for  any  beneficial  use
                        established for this class.
 Rev Hampshire

 All
              29
                       Not specified
Water Supply
(Clui A)

All  Other  Uses
(Classes B and C)
                       Toxic substances narrmtivej , No patmstially toxic
                       substances unless naturally occurring.

                       Toxic substances narrative:  No potentially toxic
                       substances in toxic concentrations or combinations,
Pish Life
All
Bioassay Procedures
                       Toxic  substances narrative:  All surface vaters of the
                       state  shall be free from chemicals and other materials
                       and   conditions  inimical  to  fish  life  or  to  the
                       maintenance of fish life.

                       Substances   potentially   toxic   are   evaluated   in
                       accordance  vita EPA's published water quality criteria
                       for  64  toxic  substances  dated November 1980.  Toxic
                       limits  are  to be set utilizing bioassay procedures as
                       outlined in CP1 Vol. 45, No. 231, November 28, 1980.

                       When  establishing  limits  on toxic substances for the
                       protection  of  aquatic  life, "Appendix B - Guidelines
                       for  Deriving Water Quality Criteria for the Protection
                       of  Aquatic  Life  and Its Uses," CPR Vol. 45. No.  231,
                       November   28,   1980,  vill  be  utilized.    Bioassay
                       procedures   and  analysis  shall  be  consistent  vith
                       'Methods  for  Measuring  Acute  Toxicity  of Effluents
                       (third   edition)'   published  by  EPA,   or  equivalent
                       protocol as approved by the Commission.

                       Bioassay  procedures  and  application  factors used in
                       establishing  limits  on  toxic  substances shall,  as a
                       minimus,   be  no less rigorous than the recommendations
                                     -32-

-------
 State mod Water Ose     Caroedu» Criteria Valuta
 Nev Jersey

 All
           30
 FW-1  Waters


 PL  Waters
FW-2 Waters
FW-2, S2, and SC
Vaters
Zones 1C-6
                         for  bioaasays and application factors contained in the
                         National  Technical  Advisory Committee's report to the
                         Secretary  of  the  Interior on WATER QUALTTT CRITERIA
                         April 1, 1968 or latest revision thereof.
 Toxic    substances   narrative:     Toxic  substances   in
 vaturs   of   the   State   shall  not'be  at levels  that  are
 toxic    to    humans   or   the   aquatic  biota,   or   that
 biomccuaulate in  the   aquatic   biota   so  as  to render
 th«« unfit  for human consumption.

 Surface; vater   quality  criteria  shall  be maintained as
 to quality  in their  natural    state.

 Surface  vater   quality  criteria  shall  be maintained as
 to  quality  in   their   existing   state or  that quality
 necessary   to attain or  protect  the  designated  uses,
 vhiehaver is  acre stringent.

 50 ug/1
 None  vhich would cause  standards  for drinking  vater to
 be exceeded after appropriate  treatment.

 Toxic substances  narrative:  None,  either.
 alone or in combination  vith other  sub-
 stances,  in  such concentrations as to  affect humans or'
 be-  detrimental   to   the natural aquatic  biota, produce
 undesirable  aquatic life,  or  vhich  vould render  the
 vaters unsuitable for the designated  uses.
     Toxic    substances   shall   not   be  present   in
 concentrations   that  cause acute or chronic toxicity to
 aquatic  biota,   or  bioaccunulate vithin  an organism to
 concentrations   that  exert  a  toxic  effect   on   that
 organise or reader it unfit for consumption.
     Th«    concentrations   of   nonpersisteht  :toxic
 substances  in   th«   State's  vaters  shall not exceed
 one-twentieth (0.05)  of  the acute  definitive LCSO or
 BCSO  value,  as  deterained  by  appropriate bioassays
 conducted in  accordance  vith N.J.A.C. 7:18.
     The  concentrations of persistent  toxic substances
 in  the  State's  vaters shall not  exceed one-hundredth
 (0.01)  of  the acute definitive LC50 or  EC50 value,  as
deterainod    by   appropriate  bioassays  conducted   in
 accordance  vith N.J.A.C. 7:18.

General  criteria narrative:    The  vaters  shall  not
 contain     substances    attributable   to   municipal,
 industrial,   or   other   discharges  in concentrations  or
 asouats  sufficient   to  preclude   the  specified  vater
 us«s  to  xbe  protected.    Within  this requirement  the
vaters  shall  be substantially free  from substances in
                                     -33-

-------
State and ¥ater OM
  Ghro«iu« Criteria•Val
                        concentrations  or  combinations  vhich  are  toxic  or
                        harmful  to  human,  animal, pUnt, or      ic Uf*  °*
                        that  product  color,  taste,  or odor in the vater  or
                        that taint fish or shellfish flesh.                '  °r
                        .»^n-,u°  CMV sh*11  concentrations  of substances
                        exceed  those  valu«s  given  for  rejection  of  vater
                        supplia,  in  the  United  States Public Health      "
                        Drinking Water Standards.
         FV-1   Vaters  »
        PI. Vaters «
        PU-2  Vatera
        SE-1  Waters  •
        SE-2  Vatttrs
        SX--3   V&ters
        SC  ?atera
      set .  wide  for  posterity to represent the natural
  aquatic,  environment  and its associated biota; primary
  mad    secondary   contact   recreation;   maintenance,
  migration   and   propagation   of   the   natural  and
  established  aquatic  biota;   and  any other reasonable
  uses*

  cranberry  bog  vater  supply  and  other  agricultural
  uses;   maintenance,   migration  and  propagation of the
  natural   and  established biota  indigenous   to  this
  unique  ecological  system; public potable  vater supply
  (after  treatment);   primary   and secondary recreation:
  and  any other reasonable  uses.

 •  maintenance,  migration  and  propagation of the natural
  •ad     established   biota;    primary   and   secondary
  recreation;   industrial   and  agricultural vater supply
  public  potable vater supply  (after treatment);  and any
 other reasonable.uses.

      Shellfish  harvesting;  maintenance,  migration and
 propagation   of the   natural   and  established  biota;
 primary  and  secondary   contact   recreation;   and   any
 other reasonable uses.

«  maintenance,  migration  and propagation  of the  natural
 and  established   biota;  migration  of diadromous  fish;
 oaintenanec   of vildlife; secondary  contact  recreation;
 and any other reasonable  uses.

  »    secondary  contact  recreation;  maintenance   and
 migration  of fish populations; migration of diadromous
 fish;   maintenance   of   vildlife;   and   any other
 reasonable uses.

       Shellfish  harvesting; maintenance, migration  and
 propagation  of  the natural and established biota;  and
 any other  reasonable uses.
       Zones   lC,lD,lB-*gricultisral, industrial and public vater supply after
                       reasonable   treatment;   vildlife;   maintenance   and
                       propagation  of  resident  gamefish  and  other aquatic
                       biota;   spavning  and  nursery  habitat  for anadromous
                       fish;    passage   of   anadromous   fish;  primary  and
                       secondary contact recreation.
                                    -34-

-------
  St*tf tad Fattr
               Chroaiua  Criteria Values
Zone 2 -


Zone 3 -


Zone 4 -       same  as  Zone  3  except agricultural and public vater


Zones 5 and 6- sane as Zone 4 plus primary contact recreation.
                          same  as^ above plus navigation,  but minus spawning and
                          nursery habitat for anadromous fish.

                          saa« as Zone 2  except primary contact recreation.


                          su^Jly"  ZC
 H«v Mexico

 All

 All
           31
               Not specified           ,   ,

               Toxic  substances narrative: Toxic substances such  as,
              .but  not  limited  to  •,   pesticides, herbicides, heavy
               metals,    and   orgsnics,    shall  not  be  present  in
               receiving  waters  in  -concentrations which will change
               th«  ecological  conditions  of  receiving waters to an
               extent  detrimental  to  man  ore  other  organisms  of
               direct   or   indirect   commercial,    recreation,   or
               aesthetic   value.       Tqxicities   of  substances  in
               receiving  waters  will  be  determined  by appropriate.
               bioassay  technique*,  or  other  acceptable wans, for
               th«  particular  fora  of  aquatic  life vfaich is to be
               preserved  vita  the concentration* of toxic substances
             .not  to   exceed  52  o£ the LC-50.provided that:   ;oxic
               substancea   which,   tarotigh  uptake in the aquatic food
               chain and/or  storage in  plant and animal tissues, can
               be   magnified to  levels which are toxic to man or other
               organisms,   shall  not be  present  in  concentrations
               which   result  in   this   biological   magnification  or
               exc««d  U   of  the  LC-50.   Vaters designated for use as
               domestic water  supplie*   shall not  contain substance*
               in   concentration*   tat exceed drinking water standard*
               *«t    forth  in    Section  202.B  of  the  New  »«xico
              Regulation* Governing Water Supplies.
        .32
Hatr York'
                         Chromiua
AA;AA-s;A;A-s  (Human)    50   ug/1
AA;AA-s;A;A-s  (Aquatic)  *
B;C                      *
D                        **
              * -
 «xp<0'819
-%<°'819
     all   standards
  acid-soluble form
                                           (PP« hardness)] +' 1.561)
                                                            * 3.688)
                                                   except   (Human)   apply
                                      -35-

-------
  State and Vater Hs«     Caroaiua Criteria
 Saline Surface Vaters
         SA, SB, SC
                          Chromium (VI)  (Acid-Solubl«)
 AA;AA-s;A;A-s  (Aquatic)  H  ug/1
 B;C                      11                ,
 D                        16
 SA;SB;SC                 54
 SD                       1,200                                    .

 GA                       0.05 Bg/1 hexavalent

 Effluent Standards For   0.10 mg/1 hexavalent
 Discharges To Class GA
 Vaters                          .' '                  .

 Fresh Surface Vaters    Toxic  substances narrative:  Nona in amounts  that vill
                         b«  injurious  to fishlife or vhich in any manner shall
                         adversely  affect the flavor, color or odor thereof, or
                         impair  the vaters for any best usage as determined for
                         the specific vaters vhich are assigned to each class.

                         Toxic substances narrative:  None in amounts that vill
                         interfere   vith   use  for  primary  (SA  and  SB)  or
                         secondary  (SC)  contact  recreation  or  that  vill be
                         injurious  to  edible  fish or shellfish or the culture
                         or  propagation  thereof,  or vhich in any manner shall
                         adversely  affect  the  flavor,  color, odor or sanitary
                         condition  thereof  or  impair  Use vaters for any best
                         usage  aa  determined for the specific vaters vhich are
                         assigned to each class.

                         Toxic substances narrative:  None alone or in
                         combination   vith   other   substances  or  vastes  in
                         sufficient   amounts  to prevent survival of fish life or
                         impair   the   vaters  for  any   other  best  usage  as
                         determined   for  the specific vaters  vhich are assigned
                         to this class.

Class A-Sp«cial Vaters  Toxic subntances  narrative:  None in  amounts that vill
International Boundary   interfere vith  use for primary contact recreation or
 *t€rs                   d»«  **13-   be   injurious to  the grovth and propagation
                        of  fish, or vhich in any manner shall adversely  affect
                         th«   flavor,  color,   or  odor  thereof  or  impair  the
                        vaters   for   any  other best usage as  determined for  the
                        specific  vaters vhich are assigned to  this class.
Saline Surface Vaters
Class  SD
Class I
Secondary Contact Rec-
reation and Any Other
Usage Except Primary
Contact Recreation and
Shellfishinj[ For Market
Purposes
                        Toxic subntances  narrative:   None in amounts that  vill
                        interfere vith use  for  secondary contact  recreation or
                        that vill be  injurious  to  edible fish or  shellfish or
                        the culture or propagation thereof,  or vhich in  any
                        •anner shall  adversely  affect the flavor,  color, odor
                        or sanitary condition thereof or impair the  vaters for
                        any  best  usage  as determined  for  the specific vaters
                        vhich are assigned  to this class.
                                      -36-

-------
 State and Water Use

 Class II
 All Uses Hot Primarily
 Recreation, Shellfish
 Culture, Or The Devel-
 opment Of Fish Life
 Class GA
 Fresh Ground Waters
 Potable Vater Supply
 Class GSA
 Saline Waters
 Conversion To Fresh
 Potable Waters;  Source
 Of  Potable Mineral
 Vaters;  Rav Material
 For The Manufacture Of
 Sodium Chloride

 Class  GSB
 Receiving Water  For
 Disposal  Of Wastes
North Carolina33

Fresh Surface Waters

Tidal Salt Waters

All -
 Chromium Criteria Values

 Toxic substances narrative:  None alone or in
 combination vith other substances or vastes in
 sufficient amounts to be injurious to edible fish
 and shellfish, or the culture or propagation thereof,
 or  vhich shall in any manner affect the flavor, color
 odor  or  sanitary  condition of such fish or shellfish
 so ^as to injuriously affect the sale thereof, or vhich
 !h*^f/!US?  ****  ^7  t0  the  Public  and Private
 shellfisheries of this State.

 Toxic substances narrative:  None vhich may impair the
 quality of the ground vaters to render them unsafe or
 unsuitable  for  a  potable  vater  supply or vhich may
 cause  or contribute to a condition in contravention of
 standard* for other classified vaters of the State'.

 Toxic substances narratives  None vhich may impair the
 vaters for use as sources of saline vaters for the best
 usage or as to cause or contribute to a condition in
 contravention of standards for other classified vaters
 of the State.
Toxic  substances  narrative:   None  vhich may be
deleterious, harmful,  detrimental  or  injurious to the
public health, safety or  velfare  or  vhich may cause or
cbntrioute   to   a    condition    in   contravention  of
standards for other  classified vaters of the State.
50 us/1

20 ug/1

Toxic   substance   narrative   [Rule   .0208(a)]:    The
concentration  of  toxic  substances   in   the  receiving
vmter,   (either   alone   or   in   combination,  vhen
affirmatively  deaonstrated  to be non-bioaccumulative)
vhen  not  specified  elsevhere   in this  Section,  shall
not  exceed the concentration specified by the fraction
of  the  96-hour  LC50 value vhich predicts a  no effect
chronic  level (as determined by  the use  of established
acute/chronic  ratios).  If an acceptable acute/chronic
ratio  is  not  available,  then  that  toxic  substance
shall  not  exceed  one-one  hundredth  (0.01)  of  the
96-hour  LC50  or  if  it is affirmatively deaonstrated
that . a. toxic substance has. a half-life of less than 96
hours   or   is   not   bioaccusnilative,    the maximum
concentration  shall not exceed one-tventieth  (0.05) of
the  96-hour LC50.  If it is affirmatively deaonstrated
                                     -37-

-------
 State and Water Use
 Fresh Surface Waters
Tidal  Salt  Vaters
            •Si *
5orth Dakota

All Classes (I,  IA,
II, and III)

All
 Chroaium Criteria Values

 that  th«  standard for a particular toxic substance as
 specified  in  Rule  .0211  or .0212 of this Section is
 inappropriate   for  a  specific  streu  segment,   the
 commission  may  revise  the  applicable  standard  on a
 case-by-ease  basis  in  accordance vith the provisions
 of  Section  U3-214.1 of the General Statutes of North
 Carolina.

 Toxic,   substances   narrative  [Rule  .0211(b)(3)(L)]:
 Only  such  amounts,   vhether  alone  or in combination
 vith  other substances or vastes as vill not render the
 vaters     injurious   to   public   health,    secondary
 recreation,   or  to  aquatic  life and wildlife (either
 through    chronic  or   acute   exposure   or  through
 bioaccumulation),   or   impair   the  vaters  for   any
 designated  uses;   any toxic substance or complex vaste
 vill be  considered   acutely  toxic  at instreaa vaste
 concentrations  greater  than  one third of the 96-hour
 LC50 value;  acceptable levels of chronic exposure may
 be  determined  by  test procedures deemed appropriate by
 the  director.

 Toxic    substances   narrative  [Rule  .0212(b)(3)(L)]:
 Only such  amounts,   vhether  alone  or in combination
 vith other  substances or vastes as vill not render the
 vaters   injurious   to  aquatic  life  and  vildlife, or
 iapair the vaters  for any designated uses.
0.05 mf/1
Toxic  substances  narrative*     Free   from   substances
attributable   to   municipal,    industrial,   or   other
discharge*  or agricultural practices  in  concentrations
or  combinations  vhich  are  toxic; or  harmful to  human,
aniaal, plant or resident aquatic biota.

Mixing   zone*  narratives    The 96-hour  LC 50  for
indigenous  or  resident  fish  and  fish  food organisms
shall not be exceeded at any  point in  the mixing  zone.

Sampling  and  testing narrative:  Bioasaay tests shall
be  performed in accordance vith  procedures outlined  in
the   latest  edition  of  "Standard  Methods  for  the
Examination  of Water and wastevater",  published  by  the
American  public  health  association,  or in  accordance
vith  tests  or  analytical   procedures  that have been
found  to be equal or acre applicable  by  the  department
or  the  environmental  protection   agency.     Bioassay
studies  shall  be  made  using   A   sensitive  resident
species.

             -38-

-------
 Starg and ¥«r«r Ose
 Qiroaiu« Criteria Values
 Ohio35

 All Lake Brie Uses

 All Ohio River Uses


 Public Water Supply

 Agricultural Water
 Supply


 Aquatic Lif« Habitat

 Nuisance Prevention


 Aquatic Lift Habitat

 Nuisance Prevention

All
 0.050 mg/1 (total)

 0.05 ag/1  (hexavalent)

 Total Chromium
 50 ug/1
 100 ug/1 (max.)
 Hexavalent Chromium
 10 ug/1 (30-day ave.)

 19 Ug/1 (max.)

 Trivalent Chromium
 water hardness dependent

 water hardness dependent

 General  narrative:  /Free from substances entering the
 waters   as   a   result   of   human   activities   in
 concentrations  that  ore  toxic  or  harmful to human,
 animal  or  aquatic  life  and/or are rapidly lethal in
 the mixing zone.'

 Antidegradation  policy:  Present ambient vater quality
 in  state,  resource waters will not be degraded for all
 substances  determined to be toxic or to interfere vith
 any  designated  use  as  determined by the director of
 Ohio Environmental Protection Agency.       .

-Toxic   substances   narrative:     All  pollutants  or
 combinations  of  pollutants not specifically mentioned
 in  thia  rule, shall not exceed water quality criteria
 derived  according  to  the  procedures  set  forth  in
 "Draft   Guidelines  for  Deriving  Numerical  Na.tional
 Wat«r  Quality  Criteria  for the Protection of Aquatic
 Life   and   Its.  Uses,*  United  States  environmental
 protection  agency,  July  5, 1983, or, if insufficient
 data  prevent  the  us«  of  this  procedure, shall not
 exceed,   at  anytime,  one-tenth, or, for pollutants or
 combinations  of  pollutants  which  are  known  to  be
 persistent  toxicants  in  the aquatic environment, one
 one-hundredth  of  the ninety-six-hour median tolerance
 limit  (TL«)  or  LCj0  for  any representative aquatic
 species.     However,  more Stringent application factors
 shall  be  imposed  whore  justified  by "Ambient Vater
 Quality     Criteria"    documents,    United    States
 environmental   protection   agency,   1980;   "Quality
                                     -39-

-------
  State and ¥ater us*
 Chromium  Criteria Values
 Ohio Hiver
                          Criteria  for  Water,"  U.S.  environmental  protection
                          agency,  1976; "Water Quality Criteria 1972, "-National
                          Academy   of   Sciences"   and   "National  Acadeay  of
                                          1973;  or  °th«r
                                           coerance
 A .      j                             or LC,-n shall be
 determined  by static or dynaaic bioassays performed in
 accordance  with  methods outlined in "Standard Methods
 for   th«   Examination   of.  Water  and  Vastevater,"
 fifteenth     edition,    "American    Public    Health
 Association,"  "American  Water  Works Association" and
 th«  "Vat«r  Pollution  Control  Federation,  1981"; or
 performed  in  accordance  vith  procedures outlined in
  Method*   of   Acute   Toxicity   Tests   vith   Pish,
 Macroinv«rtebrate*   and   Amphibians,"  United  States
 environmental  protection  agency  660/3-75-009.   Tests
 vill  be  conducted  using  actual  effluent,  receiving
 vater   and  representative  aquatic  species   whenever
 possible.

 Free  from substances in concentrations vhich  are toxic
 or   harmful  to  humans,   animals,   or  fish  and other
 aquatic   life  vhich  vould  in  any  Banner  adversely
 affect   the  flavor,   color,  odor,  or edibility of fish
 «nd   other aquatic life,  vildlife or livestock or vfaicfa
 are  othervise detrimental to  the designated  uses.

 Toxic substances  narrative:
  .(»)    Ncn-cumulative   substances  -  not   to  exceed
 one-tenth     (0.1)     the  ninety-six-hour    LC.n   of
 representative important  species   indigenous  15  the
 Ohio  river.

  (b)    Cumulative   substances   -   not  to   exceed  one
 one-hundredth   (0.01)  of  the   ninety-six-hour LC.- of
 representative important  species   indigenous  to  the
Ohio river.

  (e)  Other   limiting concentrations may be  used vhen
justified  oa   the  basis of   available  evidence  and
approved   by   the  appropriate regulatory  agency  or
agencies.
All

Public And Private
Vater Supplies
Not specified

0.050 mg/1
Th«  surface
as   public
maintained
              waters  of the State which are designated
              and   private  water  supplies  shall  be
             so   that   they   vill   not   be   toxic,
                         carcinogenic,  mutagenic,  or teratogenic to humans.
                                      -40-

-------
State and Water U*«
 Chromium Criteria Values
Fish and Wildlife
Propagation
 Toxic substances narrative:  Assigning concentration
 limits   for   the   Pish   and   Wildlife  Propagation
 beneficial  use  is very complex.  Limits are generally
 assigned  based  upon laboratory bioassay voric designed
 to  determine the 96-hour LC5Q for a. particular aquatic
 species.    There  are  s«v.§^l  physical, chemical and
 biological  problems vhich arise vhen attempts are made
 to  develop  vater  quality standards based upon single
 maximum   concentration   values.    For  this  reason,
 numerical  concentration  limits  are developed in this
 section   for   specified   toxics.    For  toxics  not
 specified,   or  vhere  data  is  not  available  in the
 folloving   table,    concentrations  for  nonpersistent
 toxic  substances listed in Appendix C shall not exceed
 0.1  of  the  96-hour  LC..  for  sensitive  indigenous
 sp«cies>      Concentrations  of  persistent  toxicants
 listed  in   Appendix  C  shall  not  exceed 0.05 of the
 96-hour  LC5Q   for   sensitive   indigenous  species.
 Concentration!  of   bioaccumulative toxicants listed  in
 Appendix C  shall   not  exceed 0.01 of the 96-hour LC
 for  sensitive  indigenous   species.   Bioassay data for
 Pimephales   promclas  (fathead  minnov)   and/or L«pomis
 macrochirus  (bluegill)   shall  be  used  in determining
 compliance  vith  the  above criteria.
      Du«   to    interaction*   vith   vater  chemistry,
 toxicity   of  sows   substances  to  aquatic  organisms
 varies, across  the State.

      50  ug/I       •  .             .

 Toxicity to  Aquatic Organisms:   The  surface vaters  of
 the  State   outside  the  mixing zone but vithin"the .zone
 of  passage  shall   b« maintained so  that they vill not
 be  toxic   to  fishes and other terrestrial and aquatic
 lif«.    Toxic  substances  in  surface vaters of the State
 shall    not    b«  present  in   quantities  vhich  allov
 significant  bioaccumilation and/or biomagnification  in
 the  food   chain.     If   substances exhibit  synergistic
 effects  vhea  combined,  toxicity  tests  described  in
 this  setction  may   tui  used  to   detect   the  increased
 toxicity.
     No  toxicity  shall  be  alloved dovnstreaa from .the
 mixing   zone   as  determined by a forty-eight  (48)  hour
 static   test   using appropriate laboratory  animals
 conducted  in  accordance  vith  "Methods for  Measuring
 th«  Acute  Toxicity  of  Effluents  to   Freshvater and
 Marine Organisms," EPA-600/4-85-013 (Rev.  March,  1985).
     In  addition,  no  toxicity   shall   be  alloved  as
 wmsured   using   in-situ   bioassay   vith   sensitive
 indigenous   fishes   ("An  In-Situ Method  for Evaluating
Acute   Toxicity   in   Aquatic   Environment."    Noble
Foundation  and  Okla.  Dept. ffldlf. Cons. Symposium  on
Pond  Mgt.f   Okla.  City,  Aug. 1985).  In-situ  testing
nut  be  conducted   over  a  period of ninety-six (96)
                                    -41-

-------
 State and Vater Use
 Chroaioa Criteria Values
 Primary Contact
 Recreation
 Secondary Contact
 Recreation
All
Oregon

An
      37
All
 hours  unless  statistically significant differences in
 •ortality  occur "in a shorter period of time.  Toxieity
 of   vaters   may   be   determined  using  statistical
 differences  for  a total mortality betveen control and
 presumed  impact  sites.-  Chronic toxicity shall not be
 alloved   in   vaters   of   the  State  ("Methods  for
 Estimating   the  Chronic  Toxicity  of  Effluents  and
 Receiving     Vaters    to    Freshwater    Organisms, "
 EPA-600/4-85-OU).    If significant nor tali ty does not
 occur  at.  the  presuaed  impact site vithin ninety-six
 (96)   hours,  a benthic macro invertebrate survey may be
 performed to determine lov-level persistent toxicity.

 The vaters shall not contain chemical,  physical or
 biological   substances   in  concentrations  that  are
 irritating  to  skin  or  sense  organs or are toxic or
 cause illness upon ingest ion by human beings.

 Vaters shall be maintained to be free from human
 pathogens  in  numbers vhich may produce adverse health
 effects in humans.

 Mixing  zones  narrative:     The concentration of toxic
 substances  in  a  mixing  zone  shall   not  exceed the
 96-hour LCjg f°r sensitive indigenous species.
General  vater  quality   standards   applicable   to   all
vaters  except  vhere  superseded   (belov)   by   special
vater  quality  standards  applicable   to   specifically
designated vaters:

Hot specified

Special  vater  quality   standard   applicable to: North
Coast-Lowir  Columbia  Basin,  Mid   Coast Basin, Umpqua
Basin,  South  Coast  Basin,  Rogue Basin,  Villamettc
Basin,  Sandy  Basin, Hood  Basin, Oeschutes  Basin, John
Day  Basin,  Umatilla  Basin, Valla Valla Basin, Grande
Ronda . Basin, Povder Basin, Malheur River Basin, Ovyhe*
Basin,  Kalhcur  Lake  Basin,  Goose and   Summer Lakes
Basis, and Klamath Basia

0.02 mg/1

The  creation  of  tastes  or  odors or toxic or other
conditions  that  are  deleterious   to  fish to  other
aquatic  life  or  affect  the  potability   of drinking
vater  or  the  palatability of fish or shellfish shall
not be alloved.
                                      -42-

-------
 State and Tatar  Urn*      Chroaiun  Criteria  Values
 Pennsylvania

 All.

 All
             38
                         Vhere     industrial,     commercial,   or   agricultural
                         effluents    contain     significant    quantities    of
                         potentially    toxic  elements,   treatment  requirements
                         .shall  be  determined  utilizing appropriate bioassays.
 Not to exceed 0.05 ng/1 as hexavalent chromium.

 General  vater  quality  narrative:    Water  shall not
 contain  substances  attributable  to point or nonpoint
 source  vaste  discharges  in  concentration or amounts
 sufficient  to be inimical or harmful to the vater uses
 to  be protected or to hxaaan, animal, plant, or aquatic
 lift.
 Rhode Island39

 Fresh Water Aquatic Life
Saltvater Aquatic  Life
Class A
Classes B and C
Class D
Chronic   «('819  I1* 
-------
  State and Water Use
 Chroedu» Criteria
 Classes A,,BrC,D
 Class SA
 Class SB
 Class SC
Classes A, B, C, D,
SA, SB, SC
 Waters  shall  be  fr««  fro.  ch«mical constituents in
 concentrations  or  combinations vhich could be hatful
 to  human,  animal, or aquatic lif« for the appropriate
 "°r   "l!?*1^  ^  *overain«  v««r  clJs  w.  or
 unfavorably alter the biota.

 None  in  concentrations or combinations vhich would be
 harmful  to  human,  animal  or  aquatic  life or which
             th* V*ttrs UM*f« or unsuitable for fish or
     ;<~°%   th*ir    Pf°P«*»ti°n.   impair   the
 palatability  of  same,  or  impair  th« waters for any
 other uses.

 None  in  concentrations or combinations which would be
 harmful  to   human,   animal  or  aquatic  life or which
 ^f*,*^*  th" "»*•» unsafe or unsuitable for fish or
 shellfish or  their  propagation,   or impair the water
 for any other usage assigned to this Class.

 None  in  concentrations or combinations which  would be
 harmful  to   human,   animal  or  aquatic  life  or which
 would^ make  the waters unsafe or unsuitable  for fish or
 shellfish or  their  propagation,   or impair the water
 for any  other  usage  assigned  to  this  Class.  The
 ambient  concentration  of   a pollutant in a water body
 designated    as   suitable   for  fish   and/or  wildlife
 habitat  shall  not   exceed  the R.I.  DEM  Ambient  Water
 Quality  Guidelines   for  the . protection  of   aquatic
 organisms  from  chronic effects,   unless  the chronic
 guideline  is  modified by the Director based on results
 of   bioassay.  tests   conducted  in   accordance  with  the
 terms  and conditions  provided in  Appendix  C.

 12  an  aquatic  tozieity value has  not been
 established   in   the   R.I.   DEM  Ambient   Water Quality
 Guidelines,   then  the  level of any "priority  pollutant"
 shall  not exceed  the  "detection  limits" in  the ambient
vat«r   unless    the   discharger  demonstrates   to  the
satisfaction    of    tn«    Director    that   a   higher
 concentration   vill   not   adversely  effect  the  most
sensitive use of  the water  body.

Classes A,B,C,D are fresh vaters.
                        Classes  SAVSB,SC are
                     sea waters.

-------
  St«t« and "gater UM
  Chromium Criteria Values
  South Carolina40
                  •

  All


  All
 Cl&sses AA and SAA
 Classes A-Trout and
 B-Trout
 Classes  A and  SB
Classes B and SC
Class SA
 Not  specified

 Toxic  substances  narrative:    All  ground vaters and
 surface  waters  of  the  State  shall  at  all

 isfPriiof  aov' •*•• fr~  «r«-tSi
 attributable  to  sevage,  industrial  waste,  or other
 waste   in   concentrations   or   combinations   vhich
 interfere-  vith  classified  water  uses (except within
 mixing  zones  as described in the South Carolina Vater
 Quality  Standards),   existing  water uses or which a"
 harmful to huaan,  animal, plant or aquatic life.

 Toxic  substances  narrative:   Natural conditions will
 be  maintained  and  protected  as feasible,  within the
 Department's statutory authority.           ,

 Toxic substances narrative:   None  alone or in
 combination   with   other   substances  or  wastes  in
 sufficient   amounts  to   be   injurious  to  reproducing
 trout  populations or  in  any manner adversely  affect
 the  taste,   color, odor,  or sanitary condition thereof
 or  impair   the  waters   for  any   other  best  usage  as
 determined   for   the  specific waters  which ar*  assigned
 to this class.

 Toxic  .substances    narrative:     None  alon.  or  in
 combination   with    other   substances  or  wastes  in
 sufficient   amounts   to   make  the   waters  unsafe  or
 unsuitable   for  primary contact  recreation or  to  iepeir
 the  vaters  for any  other best  usage as  determined for
 the specific waters which  are  assigned  to  this  class.

 Toxic  substances    narratives     None   alone  or  in
 combination   vith    other  substances  or  wastes   in
 sufficient   amounts .to  be  harmful  to  the surviral  Of
 frmshvat«r(B)  and  marine(SC)   fauna and  flora  or the
 cultura  or  propagation   thereof;  to adversely  affect
 th«   taste,  color, odor,  or sanitary condition of  fish
 for   human   consumption;   to make  the  (B) waters  unsafe
 or  unsuitable   for   A  source of drinking water  supply
 aftor   conventional  treatment;   to  make  the   vaters
 unsafe  or unsuitable for  secondary contact recreation;
 or  to  impair   the  vaters for any other best  usage as
 determined   for  the specific waters which art  assigned
 to this class.

Toxic   substances   narrative:     None  alone  or  in
 combination   with   other   substances  or  wastes  in
sufficient  amounts   to  adversely  affect  'the  -taste,
color,  odor,  or sanitary condition of clams, mussels,
or  oysters for human consumption;  or impair the waters

             -45-                  .

-------
  State and ?ater Use




  Class GA

  Class GB


  Class GC
  Chroedua Criteria	

  for    any  other   best  usage  ms   determined  for   th«
  specific vaters vhich are  assigned  to  this class.

  Toxic  substances  narrative:  None alloved.

  Chemicals   narrative:    As  set  forth   in  the  Statel
  Primary  Drinking  ffater Regulations  R.61-58.5' B?(2)

  Toxic, substances  narrative:  None  vhich  interfere vithl
  «ny  existing  use of an underground source  of drinking
 South Dmkotm41

 All

 Domestic 7ater Supply


 All
         42
T«

All

Domestic V*ter Supply
 Not specified

 0.05   nf/1      The  applicable  criterion  is  to  be
 maintained at all times, vithout exception.

 Toxic  substances  narrative:  Substances vhich produce
 concentrations   of  any  substance  toxic  to  humans,
 animals,   plants,or  aquatic life may not be discharged
 2r_,C?UMd  t0  **  di*ehar*«
-------
and 7«t«r Use
                          Chroaltai Criteria Valu«
              '           shf11    include,  but  not  b«  limited   to:    Quality
                         Criteria   for  Water   (Section  304(a)  Of  PL 92-500)-
                         Federal  Regulations   under  Section  307 of PL 92 500-
                         and  Federal  Regulations  under  Section  U12  of thi
                         ??"?  S€Alth  S€rvlc«  Ac<  «  amended  by  the Safe
                         Drinking Water, Act (PL 93-523).

 Industrial Vater Supply Toxic  substances  narrative:    The  vaters  shall not
                         contain    toxic   substances   whether   alone   or  in
                         combination   vith   other   substances,   vhich   vill
                         adversely, affect industrial processing.
 Fish and Aquatic Life
Recreation
Irrigation
Livestock Watering and
Wildlife
                  Toxic  Substances   Narrative:     The  vaters  shall not
                  contain   substances   or   combination  of  substances
                  including  disease  causing agents   vhich,   by   vay of
                  either   direct   exposure  of  indirect exposure  through
                  food    chains   may  cause  death,  disease,   behavioral
                  abnormalities,       cancer,       genetic     mutations,
                  physiological   malfunctions  (including malfunctions in
                  reproduction),   physical  deformations,   or restrict or
                  impair    grovth in  fish  or   aquatic  life  or  their
                  offspring.,      In   no  event  shall   the  diversity  or
                  productivity    of   biota  significant   to  the  aquatic
                  community  of   the  receiving  stream  be  decreased.
                  References   to   b«   used    in  determining toxicity
                  limitation*  snail  include  but  not   be  limited  to:
                  Quality   Criteria   for  Water  (Section 304(»)  of Public
                  Lav   92-500),   Federal Regulations under Section 307 of
                  Public    Lav  92-500,   and  Federal   Regulations  under
                  S«ction   U12   of   the  Public Health  Service   Act u
                  eacnded   by  the   Safe  Drinking  Water Act  (Public Lav
                  93-523).    The use  of  such information  should  be
                  limited   to    that   part  applicable   to  the  aquatic
                  community found   vithin the, receiving stream or vaters
                 under consideration.

                 Toxic  substances   narrative:    The   vater   shall  not
                  contain   toxic   substance*    vhether   alone   or  in
                 combination  vith  otn«r  substances,   that  vill render
                  th«  vmters  unsafe   or  unsuitable  for  vater  contact
                 activities,  or vill  propose toxic conditions  that  vill
                 adversely affect men  or  animal.

                 Toxic  substances  narrative:    The   vaters   shall not
                 contain   toxic  substances  that  vill   produce  toxic
                 condition* that vill  affect  the vater  for irrigation.
                                    ''          •                     • .  > •
                 Toxic substances narrative:  The vaters shall  not
                 contain   toxic   substances    vhether    alone    or  in
                 combination  vith  other   substances,  that vill  produce
                 toxic   conditions   that   vill  affect   the  vater   for
                 livestock vmtering and vildlife.
                                     -47-

-------
 State and Vater D»e
 Chroedum Criteria
 Effluent  Limitations    3.0 mg/1 (total)
 (Industrial Vastevater
 Treatment Plants)
Texas43

All Prtsh Vater
AH
 Chronic . t(°-8190[ln(aardn«ss)]*1.561)

 Hexavalent
 Acute  •> 16 ug/1
 Chronic » 11  ug/1

 (d)     Toxic   parameters.     Surface  vaters  vill  not  be
 toxic   to  man,  or   to   terrestrial   or   aquatic life.
 Additional standards requirements for  toxic  aaterials
 art  specified  in   5307.6   of   this  title (relating  to
 Toxic  Materials).

 5307.6.    TOHC MATERIALS.

 (a)  Application.     Standards and procedures  set forth
 in  this   section  apply  to all  vater   in the  state,
 except  us indicated in  5307.8  of this  title  (relating
 to  Application of  Standards) and $307'.9  of this title
 (relating to  Determination of Standards Attainment).

 (b)  General  provisions.

 (1)  Vater in  the  state shall  not be acutely toxic  to
 aquatic   life except  in small zones of initial dilution
 at   discharge  points,   in accordance  vith  $307.8
 (relating to  Application of  Standards).

 (2)  Vat«r ia  the   state   vith designated  or existing
 aquatic   life  use*   shall,   not  b« chronically toxic  to
 aquatic    life,   except  in mixing  zones  and   belov
 critical    lov-flov    conditions,  in  accordance vith
 5307.8  of this  title  (relating  to  Application   of
 Standards).

 (3)  Vatcr   in   the state shall  be  maintained   to
 preclude    adverse    toxic    effects  on   human  health
 resulting  from  contact  recreation,  consumption   of
Aquatic   organisms,   or  consumption  of drinking vater
after  reasonable  treatment.    In  addition   to other
provisions  of   this   section,   permitted  discharges  or
other  controllable   sources shall  not   cause maximum
 contaminant   levels  for public drinking vater  supplies,
as  established  in  the federal  Safe Drinking  Vater Act
 (42  United   States   Code 300f et seq.), to  be exceeded
after  reasonable treatment  by a vater supply  traataent

-------
State and ?ater P««
                          Chroalua  Criteria Values
                        plant.      The  .commission   will  utilize  available
                        inv«sti*ativ«  and  regulatory  Mans  to  identify and
                                 sources  of  toxic  pollutants  which cause or
                                °tratially C*US" th* foll°vin* guidelines to be
                                                               '
                         control
                         (A)  pA  maximuB contaminant levels  for drinking water
                         suppli«a; and                                   *

                         (B)  U.S.    Pood and Drug Adnini strati on Action Uvels
                         for toxic concmntrations.in fish and  sh«llfish tissu«.,
 Doa«stic Source

 Aquatic Vildlif*
 Classes 3A,3B,3C 6 3D
.Agriculture

All
                        0.05  «g/l

                        11  Uf/1 •- 4  day avg.
                        16  ug/1  - 1  hour avg.

                        210 ug/1 - 4 day avg.
                        1700  -ug/1 -  1 hour
                       0,10
Hexavalent
                                                  Trivalent (hardness depend)
                       Toxic  subatances  nanrative:   It  shall be unlawful,  and
                       a  violation  of   theue   regulations,  for any person to
                       discharge, or   place   any  vaste   or other substance in
                       suca  a  vay  as   vili  be  or may becohe offensive;  or
                       condition*  which   produce  undesirable aquatic life'or
                       vhieh  produce  objectionable   tastes  in edible aquatic
                       organises?  or  concentrations or  combinations  which
                       produce    undesirable   physiological   responses   in
                       desirable  resident  fish,  or other  desirable aquatic
                       Ufa,   as   determined   by bioassay   or  other  tests
                       performed   ia   accordance yith  standard  procedures
                       determined by the  Committee.
Verssont

All
       45
                       Hot specified

                       Toxic  substances  narrative:   The waters  of  the  state
                       shall  be  managed  so  as   to prevent  the  discharge  of
                       radioactive   or   toxic   -wastes   in   concentrations,
                       quantities   or   combinations   that    may   create   a
                       significant  likelihood  of  an adverse  impact on  human
                       health  or  acute or chronic toxicity to aquatic biota,
                       fish  or vildlife. .Unless otherwise specified by  these
                                      -49-

-------
 State and Vater U*«
 Chromium Criteria Valu
                                               es
                         rules,   the   Secretary  shall  determine  limits  for
                         dischargas   containing  radioactive  or  toxic  wastes
                         based   on   the   results   of   biological '  toxicity
                         assessments  and  the  appropriate available scientific
                         data* ' including but not limited to:

                              1.  The  current  edition  of the EPA publications
                         "Quality  Criteria  for  Vater"  and  the  1980 Ambient
                         Water. Quality Criteria Documents ("Vhite Books")

                              2.  The  Vermont  State Health Regulation, Part 5,
                         Chapter   3  "Radiological  Health",  effective  as  of
                         12/10/77

                              3. 10 CPB, 50, Appendix I

                         In  establishing  such  limits the Secretary shall give
                         consideration  to  the potential for bioaccumulation as
                         well  as  any  antagonistic or synergistic relationship
                         that  may exist between the wastes being discharged and
                         the  concentration  of  other wastes or constituents in
                         the  receiving  waters.    The discharge of radioactive
                         wastes  shall  not  exceed  the lowest limits which are
                         reasonably achievable.
Virginia46

Public "ffat«r  Supply
0.05 mg/1
Surface Vater
(Chronic Criteria  For
The Protection Of
Aquatic Lite)
All
freshwater     11 ug/1  Hexavalent, Dissolved
saltwater      50 ug/1

freshwater     ,0,819(ln
-------
 State and Water 0«e    ^ QirtMlua Criteria Values

          .47
 All
 Not specified
 Extraordinary(Class AA) Toxic substances narrative:  Toxic, radioactive  or
 and Lake Class Waters   deleterious  material concentrations shall be less than
                         thosa   vhich   adversely  affect,  public  health,  the
                         natural  aquatic  environment,  or  the desirability of
                         the vater for any use.       •
 Excellent (Class A),
 Good (Class B),  Fair
 (Class C) Waters
 All
 Toxie  substances narrative:   Toxic,  radioactive,  or
 deleterious  material concentrations  shall be belov
 those  of  public  health significance,  or vhich
 say  cause   acute  or  chronic  toxic conditions  to the
 aquatic   biota,  or  vhich  nay adversely affect any vater
 'use.   • '-        •      -,     ' • ••              •
                           f

 Deleterious    concentrations  of    toxic*    or    other
 nonradioactive  materials,   shall  be determined  by the
 department   in  consideration of  the Quality Criteria
 for  Water,  published by  USEPA 1976,  and  as  revised,  as
 the  authoritative   source   for  criteria and/or other
 relevant  information,  if  justified.
West Virgini*1

AU
Category A

Category Bl and B3

Category B2
Trout Waters
No  sevfege,  industrial  vastes or  other vastes  present
in  any  of  the  vatars  of   the.  State shall  cause  or
materially  contributa  to  concentrations  of materials
harmful,  hazardous or toxic  to man,  animal, or  aquatic
life.   .      '    •   .

Hexavalent Chromium (Total)
            '                              .       ,'.   \  •
Hot to exceed 50 ug/1

Not to exceed 10 ug/1
    \              ...
Trout vaters not to exceed 7.2 ug/1
Wiccoosin'

All

All
         49
Not specified

Toxie    substances    narrative:       Substances    in
concentrations  or  combinations  vhich  are   toxic   or
harmful  to  humans  shall  not  be  present  in amounts
found  to  be  of public health significance*  nor shall
substances  be  present  in  amounts  vhich are acutely
harnful to animal, plant or aquatic lift.
                                      -31-

-------
  State and Water DM
 Chroedun Criteria 7alu«
 Fish and  Aquatic  Life
Public Water Supply
 Toxic     substances     narrative:        Unauthorized
 concentrations  of  substances  are  not permitted that
 alone  or  in  combination vith other materials present
 are   toxic  to  fish  or  other  aquatic  life.    The
 determination  of  the toxicity of a substance shall be
 based   upon   the   available  scientific  data  base.
 References  to be used in determining the toxicity of-a
 substance shall include, but are not limited to:

 1.  "Quality  Criteria  for  Wat«r"..  EPA-UO/ 9-76-003.
 United    States   Environmental   Protection   Agency,
 Washington,  D.C.,1976, and                           y

 2.   "Water    Quality  Criteria  19.72".   EPA-R3-73-033
 National  Academy .of  Sciences,   National  Academy  of
 Engineering.       united   States  Government  Printing
 Office,  Washington,  D.C.,  1974.

 3.  Questions   concerning  the  permissible   levels,  or
 changes   in  the same,  of a substance,  or combination of
 substances,  of  undefined  toxicity  to fish and other
 biota shall   be resolved in accordance  vith he methods
 specified in   "Water Quality Criteria 1972", "Standard
 Methods   for   the Examination of  Water and Wastevater",
 Uth    Edition,     1975    (American   Public   Health
 Association,   Nev York)   or  other methods  approved by
 the  department  of natural resources.

 Toxic substances narrative:   The intake vater supply
 vill  txt  such  that  by  appropriate   treatment   and
 adequate  safeguards   it   vill «*«t   the Public Health
 Service  Drinking Water Standards,  1962.

 Concentrations    of   other  constituents  must   not   be
 hasardoua to health.
       .50
All

All
Hot specified

Toxic  substances  narrative:    Toxic  or  potentially
toxic  materials  attributable   to or influenced  by  the
activitios  of  man shall not be present  in any Wyoming
surface  vaters in concentrations or combinations vhich
would  djuMge  or impair the normal grovth, function  or
reproduction  of  human, animal, .plant or aquatic life.
Unless  otherwise specified in  these Standards, maximum
allovsbltt  concentrations  shall be based on  the  latest
edition  of  Quality  Criteria   for Water, published  by
EPA
     or  its  successor  agency,
accepted scientific information.
                                                           and/ or more generally
                                      -52-

-------
 5far* tad 7«t«r Use
 Chroedum Criteria Value*
                         In  those  cases vhere maximum allowable concentrations
                         must  b«  determined  through bioassay, the appropriate
                         protocol  and  application  factors  as outlined in the
                         lat«st   edition   of   Standard   Methods   for    the
                         Examination  of  Water  and Vastevater or other method?
                         approved  by the EPA. s'  ''
                            be  used.  The  bioassay  shall
be   conducted  with   an   ecologically   or  economically
important    sensitive   resident   specie   in   the   most
sensitive   portion of its life cycle,  if  applicable,  as
a   test organism.  Makeup water for  the analysis should
be   constituted  so as to approximate  the most  probable
chemical  and physical characteristics  of the  receiving
vater  in   question.   The observed 96-hour LC50 is  then
to   be  aultiplied  by  an application  factor,  vhere
established  by   EPA,    to    determine    the   "safe"
concentrations  for   the  compound  in  question.  Vhere
appropriate application  factors  have  not  yet   been
established,  the  method for  deriving  said application
factor .shall  be  that  described  in the*  latest edition
of  Standard Methods or other methods approved by EPA.

Toxic  substances  specifically designed  to   kill  or
eliminate    problem-causing    aquatic   life   (such  as
mosquito  larvae  or   heavy  plant grovth in irrigation
ditches)  may  be  added to surface  vaters of  the  State
provided     such   substances   are   administered    in
accordance   vith label directions.   Hovever, compliance
Vith  label directions shall not exempt any person  from
the  p«nalty provisions of V.S.  35-ll-901(b).
 *  *                                  •           •
This  Section  shall   not apply   to  the  use  -of  fish
toxicants by the Wyoming Game  and  Fish  Department.
is@rics& S&aoa

All Fresh Surface
Vater, Babaynents,
Open Coastal Water,
And Oceanic Waters
(shall apply as a
minisua withia the
zone of aixinfj)
They shall be free froa substances and  conditions  or
combinations thereof attributable to scvage,
induatriml vastea, or other activities  of man vhich
Bay be toxic to husans, other animals,  plants, and,
aquatic life.

Substances of unknovn toxicity:

(a)  All effluents containing materials attributable  to
the  activities  of man shall be considered harmful and
not  permissible  until  acceptable bioassay tests have
shovn  otherwise.  It  is the obligation of th« persons
producing  the  effluent  to  demonstrate  that  it   is
harmless,  at  the request of the Environmental Quality
Comaission.

(b)  Compliance vith Section VI, A-4 of these standards
vill  be  determined  by  use  of  indicator organisms,
                                      -53-

-------
  Scat•  «nd  Vater DM
 Ghroaixni Criteria Val
                          analysis   of   species   diversity,  population  density,
                          grovth  anomalies,  bioassays  of  appropriate duration or
                          other   appropriate   methods   as   specified  by  the
                          Environmental  Quality  Commission.

                          (c)  The   survival   of aquatic-life-  in any vattrs shall
                          not  b* less than that for  the saae  vater body in areas
                          unaffected  by  sevage,  industrial wastes  or  other
                          activities of man,   or,   vhen  necessary,  for  other
                          control  vater that is consistent vith the requirements
                          for  "Experimental   Vater"  as   described  in  Standard
                          Methods  for   the   Examination   of Vater and VaiTevaTer
                          (latest  available   edition).  As a  minimum, compliance
                         vith  th«  objective as stated in the previous sentence
                          shall bo evaluated  vith a 96  hour bioassay.

                          (d)  In  addition,  effluent  limits  based  upon acute
                         bioassays   of   effluents  vill  be  prescribed  where
                         appropriate,   additional   numerical  receiving  water
                         limits  including   the  vater , quality criteria used to
                         support    toxic  effluent  standards  identified  under
                         Section  307 (a) of the Federal Vater Pollution Control
                         Act   of   1972,    as  amended,  vill  apply;  further,
                         numerical   receiving   vater   Units   for   specific
                         toxicants   vill  be  established  as  sufficient  data
                         biconas   available;   and   sourcn  control  of  toxic
                         substances vill be  encouraged.
District  of Colombia

All
                     52
Toxic   substances    narrative:     The   vuters  of  the
District  shall  be  free  from  substances  attributable to
point    or    non-point   source*   discharged    in
concentrations   that   injure,  are   toxic  to  or  produce
adverse   physiological    or   behavioral  responses   in
humans, plants or aniaals.

Those  criteria  listed  under  th«  category of Toxics
ahmll   b«   applicable    only  to   protection  of  the
designated  beneficial  use   for periods  of less than
nin*ty-iix  (96)  hours.    The  determination  of  the
criteria  needed  to   protect  the  beneficial use for a
longer  period  of  time  shall  be made on a case  by case
basis and my be more stringent.
Class C (Aquatic Lift,   0.01 mg/1 (hexavalent)
Vaterfovl, Shore Birds,
And ¥ater Oriented Wild-
life)
Class D (Public Vater
Supply)
0.05 mg/1 (hexavalent)
Waters shall be free from  toxicants  and
other  substances  in  concentrations  that
                                                                      cannot  be
                                      -54-

-------
 Stat«  and  ffater  use
 Chroaium Grit aria, Values
                         reduced    to    levels   safe   for  distribution   by   the
                         «eistin«    or   ^presently    proposed   water  . treatment
                         facilities which  use these waters.
Class G (Groundvaters)
GUM
All
    53
Waters   shall
substances   in
b«
                      free  from  toxicants  and  other
                concentrations  which  might  present a
health hazard or render the groundwaters unusable
General  criteria;    All  waters  .shall  be  free  from
substances,    condition*   or   combinations  -  thereof
attributable  to  domostic,  commercial  and industrial
discharge*  or  agricultural, construction and land-use
practices  or  other human activities that aro toxic or
harmful   to   humans,  animals,  plants  or  desirable
aquatic life.

Analytical  testing methods for these criteria shall be
in   accordance   vith  the  most  recent  editions  of
Standard  Methods  for  the  Examination  of  Vater and
                        tfastevater  (APHA,  AtfVA,  VPCF),
                        Analysis   of  ffater  and  Tastes
                        Protection  Agency),  andother
                        G2?A  and
                        accuracy.
                                   Methods for Chemical
                                   (U.S.Environmental
                                    thod* acceptable to
           poasessing adequate procedural precision and
                        Effects  of.  toxic,  or. other deleterious substances at
                        levels  or  combinations  sufficient  to  b«  toxic  or
                        harmful  ,to  human,  animal, plant or aquatic life or in
                        amount*  sufficient  to  interfere  vith any beneficial
                        use  of  the water,  shall be evaluated as a minimum, by
                        uae  of  a  96-hour  bioas*ay  a* described in tae most
                        recant  edition of Standard Methods for the Examination
                        of  y«ter  and  gaatevater.  Survival al tm*t aryaalJSt
                        •haii  no«bo less than that of controls vhich utilize
                        appropriate  water.     Failure to determine presence of
                        toxic  substances  by  this  method  shall not preclude
                        determination  of  excessive levels of toxic substances
                        oa the basis of other criteria or method*.

                        Toxit  substance*  narrative*    In  order  to  provide
                        Bsxious  protoetion  for  the  propagation  of fish and
                        wildlife,    concentrations    of    toxic   substances
                        (p«r*i*tent '   or    non-persistent,    cumulative   or
                        non-cusnilativ«);  (a)  shall  not  exceed  0.05  of the
                        96-hotir.  LC.Q  at  any  time  or  place, nor should the
                        24-hour   average  concentration  exceed  0.01  of  the
                        96-feour   LC50   or,    (b)   shall  not  exceed  levels
                        calculated  6y  multiplying the appropriate application
                        factor  by  the 9£-hour LC.. values determined by using
                        the   mo*t   sensitive   species  of  aquatic  organism
                        .-Affected.    Whichever  value (a or b) is less shall be
                                     -55-

-------
 State and later Us*
 Chroaiua Criteria Valuaa

 the  maximum allowable concentration,  unless this value
 exceeds   th«   Maxima   Numerical   Limit,'  then  the
 numerical  limit shall constitute the  maximum allowable1
 concentration.

 NOTE:     Whenever  natural  concentrations of any toxic
 substance  or  element  occur  and  exceed  the  limits
 established    in   these   standards,    this   greater
 concentration  shall  constitute  the   limit,  provided
 that    this  natural  concentration vas  not  directly
 affected  by Ban-induced causes.
Mariana

All
All Surfac« Waters
General  criteria:  An waters  shall  be  free  from  toxic
or   other  deleterious   substances   at   levels  or   in
combinations  sufficient   to  be   toxic   or   harmful  to
human,  animal,  plant,   or aquatic life, or  ia amounts
sufficient  to  interfere  with any  beneficial  use of the
water.

Toxic   substances   narrative:    Criteria   for   toxic
substances  are given as  either a  maximum concentration
or   are   determined   by  multiplying • the   stated
application  factor  by the concentration determined  to
be  lethal  to  50Z  of   the  most sensitive  indigenous
organism  after 96 hours  of exposure  (96 LC^).  The  96
LC«Q  values  shall  be   determined   by   using bioassay
procedures  consistent  with  those   described  in  the
latest  edition of Standard Methods for  the Examination
of Water and Wastewater.            !    - —
                        ,     9€  LC«g  value*  shall be determined  by using the
                        mo*t  sensitive indigenous organism  to  the  substance in
                        question.    Then  both  an  application  factor   and a
                        maximum  concentration are given,  the leaser of the two
                        resulting  concentrations  shall   constitute  the  water
                        quality standard*.

                        Max, cone, level
                        mg/1
                        0.05
          ug/1
          50.0
                                 toxic  standards:  No substance or combination
                        of  substances  including  oil  and  petroleum products
                        shall  b«  present  in  surface  water  in amounts  that
                        exceed  0.01  times the 96 LC5Q concentration unless  it
                        can  ba  demonstrated  to  the Department that a higher
                        concentration  has no adverse effect, chronic or acute,
                        on the intended uses of the water body in question.
                                     -56-

-------
 State  end  ffater Os*
Chromium Criteria Val
                         General considerationss

                         (a)   Analytical   testing  methods   for   these   criteria
                         shall  b«  in accordance vith the eost  recent  editions
                         of   Standard   Methods   for the Examination of Water  and
                         Wastevater,andothermethods.publishedby
                         knowledgeable   authorities   and   possessing   adequate
                         procedural  precision and accuracy.

                         (b)   Effects   of  toxic or other deleterious substances
                         at   levels  or  combinations   sufficient to be  toxic or
                         harmful  to  human,  animal, plant  or aquatic life or in
                         amounts  sufficient  to  interfere  vith any beneficial
                         use   of  the   vater, shall b« evaluated  as a minimum by
                         use   of  a  96-hour  bioassay  as  described in  the most
                         recent    editions   of    Standard    Methods  for    the
                         Examination  of  Water  and Wastevater.  Survival of test
                         organisms  shallnot   belessthan that in  controls
                         vhich  utilize appropriate vater.   Failure to determine
                         presence of   toxic  substances by  this method shall  not
                         preclude determination  of  excessive   levels  of toxic
                         substances  on the basis of other criteria or methods.
                                                         r     '
                         (c)   Pollutant  discharges shall be controlled  so as "to
                         protact  not   only  th«  vaters receiving the discharge
                         directly,   but also  those vatera into vhich th« initial
                         receiving waters may flov.
             .+6,
Puerto
                        Hexavalent .(Cr*0)
SB, SC (Coastal Waters) 50.0  ug/1
SD (Surface Waters)

An
                        50.0  ug/1
                         Total (Cr)
                    300.0 ug/1

                     50.0 ug/1
                        Toxic  substances narrative:   The vaters of Puerto Rico
                        shall  not   contain  any  substance  in a concentration
                        vhich    is    toxic   or   vhich   produces  undesirable
                        physiological  responses in human, fish or other animal
                        life,  and plants.

                        The  vaters   of  Puerto  Rico,  shall not contain tvo or
                        more   substances  vhoav  combination  is toxic or vhich
                        vill     produce    chronic    or    other   undesirable
                        physiological   responses  in  humans,  fish  or  other
                               lifa  and plants.
Trust Territory

All
               .56
General  criteria:    All  vaters  shall   be   free  from
substances  and  conditions attributable  the  activities
of  man  that  may  be  toxic  or  cause   irritation to
humans, animals or plants.
                                      -57-

-------
State and U'ater use
 Caro«iu« Criteria Vali
                        Toxic   substances   narrative:    Criteria'  for  toxic
                        substances  are given as either a maximum concentration
                        or   «*•/  determined   by   multiplying   the   stated
                        application  factor  by the concentration determined to
                        be  lethal  to  50Z  of  the  aost sensitive indigenous
                        organism  after  96  hours  of exposure (96 LC).  96 LC
                        value*   shall   be   determined   by   using  bioassay
                        procedures  consistent  vith  those  described  in  the
                        latest  edition of Standard Methods for the Examination
                        of  Tatar  and  vastevater.96 LC 50 values shall be
                        determined  by  usingtie  most  sensitive  indigenous
                        organisa  to  the  substance in question.   When both an
                        application  factor  and  a  maximum  concentration are
                        given,   the  lesser  o*  the  tvo  shall constitute the
                        vater quality standard.
                        Marine
                        Limit
                        30~ug/l
           Factor
ClassJ.   Class 2

     11 Ug/1   11 Uff/1
            0.01

General  considerations:

(1)  All lie t hod*   of  sample  collection,  preservation,
and  analysis  used to  determine  compliance vith these
standards   shall   be in  accordance vith those specified
in  th«  current   edition   of   Standard Methods for the
Examination  of...  Vater   and  ffaatevater  or  a« :hods
specified by EPA in 40 CFE  Part 136,  as appropriate.

Saaples  should  be collected  at approximately equal
intervals   and    under   those   conditions  of  tide,
rainfall,   and  tia«  of day   vhen  pollution  is aost
likely to be aaxiaua.

(2)  Vhen«v«r  natural   conditions are  of  lover quality
than  an  assigned  vater quality  criteria,  the natural
conditions  shall constitute the vater quality criteria.

(3)  Whenever  2   numeric criteria are  in  conflict,  the
•ore  stringent  criteria   shall  constitute  the vater
quality criteria.
                            Pollutant   discharges   to either surface or ground
                       vaters  shall   be   controlled  so  as  to protect not only
                       the  receiving   vater   but  also those vaters into vhich
                       the initial receiving vaters may  flov.
                                    -58-

-------
and Yatvr CM
                         Chro«lu« Criteria Valun
Virgin



All
              57
                            -4K-                    b*  frM  of  substances
                        attributmbl*    to   nninicipml,    industrial,  or  other

                        discharge  or  vastes in concentrations.or combinations

                        n^ i *f* i  tOXlC   °r   Vhich   P?»f»»««  undesirable
                        5n!i? ?fJ      f"P°n3«s  in  human,   'fish,  and  oth.r
                        animal lif«, and  plants.
                                     -59-

-------

-------