------- About Com ALc/A IF ^V^,, ,. fe&?"' •''• " h- -"srttHttvi• , ------- Conservation! It's About Community A Land Ethic for Today April 1998 marks the fiftieth anniversary of the death of Aldo Leopold, and 1999 the fiftieth anniversary of the publication of Leopold's landmark book, A Sand County Almanac. On these occasions and throughout this period, conservationists whose work has been inspired, defined, and shaped by Leopold's work and words will pause to commemorate his many contributions, to reexamine his thoughts, and to.rededicate themselves to the conservation cause. At century's end, we as conservationists call upon ourselves and others to take time to reflect upon the fate of the places that give our lives meaning, and to take action to secure our natural heritage for future generations. "We abuse land because we regard it as a commodity belonging to us. When we see land as a community to which we belong, we may begin to use it with love and respect." These words from Leopold's introduction to A Sand County Almanac capture what we believe to be an essential theme as humanity enters the new millenium: the need to reconcile human social, economic, and spiritual values and the ecological functions, biological diversity, and beauty of the natural world that supports us all. To sustain vital human communities within the context of healthy natural landscapes, watersheds, and plant and animal communities - to achieve what Leopold called "harmony with land" - will demand constant effort and stout spirits. We believe that the best way to commemorate Leopold's work, and that of countless other conservationists of the 20th century, is to accept this challenge as we enter the 21st. "A land ethic," Leopold wrote, "changes the role of Homo sapiens from conqueror of the land community to plain member and citizen of it. It implies respect for his fellow members, and also respect for the community as such." Leopold realized that such change could happen only over time, that the important thing is to continually strive toward that end. He held that unless such change occurs, our increasing human demands would work to diminish not only the natural world, but our own lives within it. At this time, as we recognize Leopold's legacy, we affirm this commitment to conservation, and accept the challenge to extend it. ------- ------- A Vision For Today by Mark Van Putten, President National Wildlife Federation There are some who can live without wild things, and some who cannot. These essays are the delights and dilemmas of one who cannot. - Aldo Leopold Earth Day this year falls on the fiftieth anniversary of Aldo Leopold's death. Leopold died of a heart attack on April 21, 1948, fighting a fire that threatened his beloved retreat, "the Shack," near Madison, Wisconsin. No epitaph better sums up his life than these opening words from the preface to A Sand County Almanac, which was published the year after his death. Few people have had more influence on the cause of conservation than did Leopold. He was among America's first professional foresters; he fathered the profession of wildlife management; he taught a generation of ecological scientists; he raised a family of dedicated conservationists; he and his family restored the barren sand prairie at the Shack and he helped found the National Wildlife Federation and other environmental organizations. But, he did much more. He developed a new way of thinking about our relationship with the natural world. Grounded in rigorous science yet voiced with the soul-deep passion of one who cannot live in a world without wild things, Leopold's "land ethic" gave the environmental movement a moral force similar to this century's other great causes, civil and women's rights. "A thing is right," Leopold wrote, "when it tends to preserve the integrity, stability, and beauty of the biotic community. It is wrong when it tends otherwise." Leopold's land ethic changed forever our view of the rightful role of the human species "from conqueror of the land community to plain member and citizen of it." As an ethic, our responsibility to the land community requires individual and collective action to protect and restore our land, water, air and wildlife resources. Our actions, Leopold understood, derive from sound environmental education, must be based on scientific understanding, and should harness economic incentives. ------- These principles have always been and will remain hallmarks of the National Wildlife Federation. For over sixty years, NWF has supported professional, science-based management of wildlife and its habitat; our volunteer board of directors has included some of America's foremost wildlife, fisheries and ecological scientists. NWF has always believed that a sound economy and a healthy environment go hand in hand. And, of course, NWF has consistently been a leader in the field of environmental education with our children's publications like Ranger Rick®, our film and television programs, teacher training, National Wildlife Week®, and our community-based education programs in our eleven regional offices and with our 45 state affiliates. But, Leopold warned that education, science and economics are not enough. "[Q]uit thinking about decent land-use as solely an economic problem," he urged. Beware, he warned scientists, that one does not become "as callous as an undertaker to the mysteries at which he officiates." And, he argued that more education is not always better if it only "urges enlightened self-interest" and "defines no right and wrong, assigns no obligations, calls for no sacrifice, implies no change in the current philosophy of values." NWF's true strength is and always has been the shared values of our members and supporters committed to making a place for wildlife in our modern world. While few of us are as eloquent as Leopold, like him we know that we and our children cannot live without "wild things" and we accept the sacred responsibility to conserve and restore the land community on which all life depends. This essay may be reprinted for publication. For permission, please call (703) 790-4085 O ------- A Pledge to Live the Land Ethic I pledge to make this the year that I develop a habit of considering more than my own short-term interests or bottom line. I will make a habit of thinking how my actions will affect our entire community and our long-term well-being. I pledge to consider the aesthetic consequences of my behavior, as well as the economic. I pledge to bear in mind how my decisions about the environment will affect the community that we leave to our children and grandchildren. Signed, Date To register your support, visit our website at http://www.aldo.org. ------- ------- Instructions For Using These Materials As one way to celebrate the life and work of Aldo Leopold 50 years after the publication of A Sand County Almanac, a coalition of organizations united in their concern for the environment has sponsored the production of "Conservation: It's About Community." This kit is intended to be a true grassroots vehicle for building localized conservation commitment and support. But having the kit in hand is only the first step. Please use it. And call upon your conservation colleagues to do the same. There are countless civic groups, PTAs, religious groups, garden clubs and other organizations in your own community that are hungry for speakers to address their members about important issues. What could be more important than the conservation of the places we know and love? What speech could be more helpful than one which would show them how to make a real conservation ethic part of their daily lives? You can deliver these valuable gifts. Having encouraged people to live by a new "land ethic," you can then ask them to pledge their commitment using the pledge form found behind TAB 1. You can also register that pledge on our website: http://www.aldo.org By doing so, you will demonstrate the strength of this new commitment to our earth. Sponsoring groups will keep track of the pledges and maintain the site for visits by anyone who wants to learn more about the celebration of Aldo Leopold's life and ideals. Links to sponsoring groups will also be included. Using the materials provided in this speakers' kit will make it easy for you to give a 20- minute slide presentation appropriate for community groups of all sorts. Give some thought to what clubs and organizations meet in your town, and contact them to line up a speaking engagement. To make a presentation using these materials, prepare in advance by loading the numbered photos (located behind TAB 5) into a slide projector carousel. Sharing the fundamentals of Aldo Leopold's land ethic with your audience is as easy as reading the appropriate script provided, advancing from image to image as indicated by the small black arrows built into the script. The pledge found behind TAB 1 may be copied and distributed to adult audiences for each person to sign and keep as a reminder of what it means to live according to the land ethic. ------- The kit includes two scripts: one aimed at adults (see TAB 3) and the other more appropriate for schoolchildren from about sixth grade up (TAB 4). The primary difference between the two, aside from slight changes in wording, is that we have eliminated the pledge from the script for children, as well as any messages that may interpreted as laying a "guilt trip." The slides may be used in the same order for both presentations, with the exception that the presentation for children does not use the last two slides. You will notice that at the end of the slide show there are bold portions of text in brackets. These are areas which you may tailor to address your organization's messages and opportunities or talk about local environmental issues of immediate concern. Thinking through the following will help you develop this section. 1. Summarize an environmental issue or problem affecting your local area. 2 . What kinds of solutions does your organization offer, if any? 3 . If none, what ways - big or small - can you think of for people to help overcome this environmental challenge (ie. planting trees, picking up litter, writing to their congressional representative, etc.)? The answers you give here are all you'll need to put together an effective portion of the presentation tailored to the local area. Providing slides to illustrate your points will give your remarks even greater impact. As an example of how to structure your ending, the following page shows what the National Wildlife Federation has scripted to introduce its Backyard Wildlife Habitat program. ------- Sample Localized Conclusion I'd like to talk a little bit about a very unique opportunity for you to begin applying Leopold's land ethic starting right in your own backyard. The National Wildlife Federation's Backyard Wildlife Habitat program began in 1973 as a way to encourage people to plan their landscaping with the needs of wildlife in mind. Habitat restoration is critical for wildlife in urban and suburban settings where commercial and residential development infringe on the natural areas that wildlife need in order to survive. The program recognizes the efforts of those who "garden for wildlife. " Providing wildlife habitat is easy and fun. Under the guidelines of the program, a Backyard Wildlife Habitat must offer wildlife four key elements: food, water, shelter, and places to raise young. The program features a packet full of suggestions and advice on how to go about building a Backyard Wildlife Habitat, no matter where you live. All kinds of gardens have been certified, from a small apartment balcony to a 6,500-acre forest. With more than 20,000 habitats certified by the program, the National Wildlife Federation provides information and assistance to schools, businesses, and community groups - as well as to homeowners. By helping to restore important wildlife habitat, people who build Backyard Wildlife Habitats are living up to the ideals of Leopold's land ethic. What's more, they 're giving themselves the opportunity to observe and "listen to " the land a little more closely. If you would prefer to stick with the script, you may simply skip over the "local focus" section of the presentation and begin the concluding remarks found on the page that follows it. In order for this communication to have greatest impact, however, it will be your emphasis on local issues and opportunities that will go furthest toward "bringing the message home." We urge you to spend a little time personalizing and localizing the presentation in any way you can. To solicit speaking opportunities before local and civic groups, churches, etc. you might consider sending a mailing along the lines of the following example. You can simply fill in the blanks, make copies and mail to appropriate groups. To increase you effectiveness, consider customizing the letter to address the specific interests of target groups or to make it a better fit with your own organization. ------- Sample Letter MEETING SPEAKERS AVAILABLE: HELP YOUR MEMBERS UNDERSTAND THE LINKS BETWEEN CONSERVATION AND COMMUNITY Dear Neighbor: Discussions of conservation or environmental topics are often heated debates over individual issues: Should specific parkland be expanded? Should a factory be allowed? What is often missing is the context within which these kinds of decisions must be made; a context which allows us to consider what is right for the community of which we are all a part. I am writing to offer your group the opportunity to step back and think about that broader context. Knowing of your interest in issues affecting our community, I would like to offer the services of a [group name] member to make a fascinating presentation at one of your group's upcoming meetings. Conservation: It's About Community is a slide presentation created by a coalition of national conservation organizations to help groups around the country explore the issue of "conservation ethics" in our everyday lives. The presentation uses the "land ethic" of conservationist Aldo Leopold - the 50th anniversary of whose death and posthumous publication of a. A Sand County Almanac are being marked this year - to prompt audiences to consider how their own sense of responsibility to their neighbors, their community and the environment are factored into the decisions they make every day. It is enlightening, thought provoking and a great opportunity for your members to learn about an important conservation figure as well as about the thoughts and activities of their neighbors in [group name]. I hope you will take us up on this offer to to address your group. If you would like more information or to schedule a presentation, please contact me at: [contact information]. Sincerely, ------- Conservation: It's About Community A Land Ethic for Today INTRODUCTORY REMARKS Thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak with you today about what conservation really is and about its role in our lives. In my discussion, I'll be emphasizing the critical work of a man named Aldo Leopold. Though he died about 50 years ago, his thoughts on the relationship between people and the rest of nature have guided concerned citizens like me for decades. In recent years we've come to realize that issues that used to seem distant and unconnected to our lives - things like water and air quality - actually hit close to home. No matter where we live, we're linked to nature in an important way: We're all part of what Leopold called the land community. Think about what the word "community" means to you. Most of you probably think of a community in terms of the people who live in it - your friends, neighbors, and acquaintances. Many of us show support for our community in various ways, like volunteering at a charity or just by helping out when neighbors need us. We make this kind of effort because we feel it's the right thing to do. Fifty years ago, Aldo Leopold, an American forester and wildlife biologist, wrote a book called yl Sand County Almanac. In his foreword, Leopold wrote, "When we see land as a community to which we belong, we may begin to use it with love and respect." His thoughts about the meaning of community challenge our assumptions in ways that are as relevant to our lives today as they were back in 1948. Leopold suggested that the community includes more than we might think. It includes the environment and everything in it - the plants, animals, soils, and waters. He said that people are actually members of this land community - ------- the most powerful members, in fact. And he said that because people have the unique ability to make decisions that affect the land, we are also responsible for its health. In other words, we should be as just as mindful about caring for the land as we are about maintaining our relationships with other people. Leopold said that "conservation is a state of harmony between man and land" It is about being a good citizen of the land community, To consider the environmental consequences of our behavior before we act and then to be as gentle with the land as we possibly can, is the right thing to do. It's easy to feel kind of overwhelmed by the suggestion that the health of the land is your personal responsibility. After all, the environment is so vast, what difference could the actions of one person really make? The land ethic does demand something of each of us. Small changes that you and I make in the way we think about and interact with the environment day-to-day can add up to big benefits to the land community. And by protecting the land we protect ourselves and we ensure the well-being of future generations. Living according to the land ethic means keeping the needs of wildlife in mind when we landscape our backyards. It means taking the time to learn about the environmental issues that hit close to home and then doing what; we can to help. It means that when we need to build a road, we build it in a way that preserves as much of the area's natural biological and aesthetic valu.e as possible. Aldo Leopold's land ethic suggests that before we act in a way that might have any kind of impact on the environment, we are responsible for weighing what would be best for the land against what we need or want from the land With this in mind, let's look more closely at the land ethic - which is really an ethic for today. ------- SLIDE PRESENTATION In the course of everyday life it's not always obvious that the landscape speaks to us. We see the same old landmarks on our way to work or school every day - the same trees, or rocks or hills - and probably don't think too much about them. When Aldo Leopold walked through the woods with his father as a child, he paid close attention to what he saw. -^3 He kept a journal in which he recorded what birds he spotted and even made illustrations of some of his favorites, like this wren. Leopold's habit of meticulous observation led to the development of the ideas I'll be speaking about today. By paying closer attention to our own surroundings we can begin to make sense of the clues that are right there in front of us. Clues that remind us how we are connected to the land and what we need to do to keep our "land community" healthy. -^5 Here's one example of a clue. Recently, people in many suburban areas in the U.S. have noticed what seems to be an increase in deer populations. But if we stop for a minute to wonder why we're suddenly seeing more deer in our neighborhoods, all Slide 1: street shot Slide 2: AL as a child Slide 3: AL drawing Slide 4: person near tree Slide 5: deer face ------- logical conclusions point right back at us. ^6 Deer populations have become so large that the animals are altering the composition of our forests. Their browsing has even affected shrubs around houses in the suburbs. Through their more frequent excursions into our streets and onto our yards, they tell us something about our behavior. -^7 Signs that we're more connected to nature than we realize are all around us. We just have to pay attention. Aldo Leopold continued to learn from the land throughout his education and career. After receiving a Master of forestry degree from Yale University in 1909, he headed to the Southwest to work for the U.S. Forest Service. Over the next 20 years, he played a critical role in managing the nation's forestlands for the benefit of future generations. ^9 Leopold's love for the wilderness grew during his years spent outdoors in the Southwest. ^10 He helped start a number of private conservation groups like the Izaak Walton League, The Wilderness Society and the National Wildlife Federation that continue today to make a difference for the environment. ^11 Leopold moved to the Midwest in 1924, and Slide 6: four deer Slide 7: gray squirrel Slide 8: AL adult portrait Slide 9: rural Southwest scene Slide 10: AL with fish Slide 11: AL at the Shack ------- four years later left the Forest Service to survey wildlife populations and habitats. Then he joined the staff of the University of Wisconsin, Madison as the world's first Professor of Game Management, where he stayed until his death in 1948. ^12 Despite the demands of his work and a growing family, Aldo Leopold always made time to get out into wild country - and to write about it. ^13 His books, including A Sand County Almanac, showcase his superior writing skills and keen gifts of observation. + 14 Published in 1949, A Sand County Almanac begins with descriptions of the natural world based on Leopold's own observations, and then leads to his conclusions about our connection to it. ^15 The crucial element in this book, the part that speaks to us most urgently, even fifty years later, is Leopold's land ethic. Leopold defines an ethic as "a limitation on freedom of action in the struggle for existence." ^16 That may sound complex, but basically it just means that we have an obligation to look out for more than what seems at first to be in our own best interest. -)H7 The reality, he tells us, is that looking out for the entire land community is in our own best interest, because it's the land that sustains us. The land ethic, in other words, suggests that self-interest and responsibility Slide 12: ski tracks in snow Slide 13: AL outside Slide 14: b&w landscape Slide 15: wood storks Slide 16: oily bird Slide 17: recycling bin ------- to others are inter-connected +18 We already live by certain ethical limitations every day without really giving it too much thought. The thing that sets these limitations is called society. +19 Living up to society's standards of behavior means that in some cases we might not be able to do exactly what we want to do, but most of the time we're not even conscious of keeping our impulses in check. +20 Ethical standards change and evolve, which is why there's hope for a land ethic. In our society we've addressed everything from the expectation to be a productive member of the community to the broader topic of equality. I doubt that today an African-American woman would be ordered to give up her seat on a bus for a white man, as Rosa Parks was in 1955. Civil rights has been adopted as an ethic. +21 What's interesting is that Leopold says the ethical standards we practice so effortlessly with respect to each other really extend to all of nature, from the most common animal •^•22 to the most spectacular canyon lands. He says we must think ourselves as part of - not masters of - a land community that includes us, every living species, the soil and the water. To some extent, the application of an ethic toward that broader community has already begun to take root. +23 Slide 1?: "Pedestrian Crossing" Slide 19: "No Trespassing'1 Slide 20: Rosa Parks Slide 21: boy with animal Slide 22: Grand Canyon ------- Twenty years ago it was a lot more common than it is today to see people just toss their trash onto the street. These days, society exerts pressure on us to "put litter in its place. " It's commonly accepted that littering ruins the aesthetics of the land While throwing a soda can out a car window might be easier than pulling over to find a recycling bin, we make the small effort to do the right thing. Almost without even thinking about it. Even so, we still have a lot of progress to make before we can say as a society that we've fully signed on to a land ethic. ^25 We must do more for the environment than put litter in its place before we're even halfway there. Which leads me back to the question of what it really means to be a member of the land community - what, exactly, we must do. ^26 Leopold tells us that, "A thing is right when it tends to preserve the integrity, stability, and beauty of the biotic community. It is wrong when it tends otherwise." r^27 So this means that we must find solutions that work for people and maintain as much of the land's natural health and beauty as possible. Take a look around you and judge for yourself what works for people and the rest of nature. +28 Slide 23: trash in forest Slide 24: person with hawk Slide 25: Valdez cleanup Slide 26: waterfall Slide 27: boy fishing ------- Notice that I say both people and nature. Leopold didn't set up the land ethic as an "either/or" proposition. If you were to pledge today to start being a citizen of the land community it wouldn't mean that you'd never cut down another tree or even build another factory. r>29 But you would think twice about how best to do those things with the least negative impact on your land community. "^30 It's important to remember that if we're to live according to the land ethic, we would have to drop certain assumptions. We'd have to take on the challenge of thinking and acting differently about such things as our stewardship of land. We're accustomed to thinking that the land is ours, and that this gives us the right to use it simply as we choose. Stories of early settlers conquering the land and reaping the benefits of its natural resources are legendary in American history. Mastery of the land seems to be part of "the American way. " +32 For a long time, that's meant that we've been tuned in to the bottom line while tuning out the messages the land is sending us. We've put our short-term economic priorities first, above the welfare of the environment and Slide 28: Backyard Habitat Slide 29: bulldozer Slide 30: landfill Slide 31: bison Slide 32: dead fish ------- future generations. And when we regard the environment upon which we depend as nothing but raw materials for the taking, we tend to discount the full range of benefits we derive from it. "^33 Think of some of the issues you hear about on the news every night. Over-fishing, air pollution, water pollution, and many wildlife management problems are just a few examples of the challenges we face that are the direct results of human beings basing environmental decisions on narrow economic priorities alone. ^34 In making our decisions about how best to interact with the environment, each of us must consider more than how to get the quickest dollar value out of the land. We must determine what outcome would be best for the land and factor that in, too. •^35 To consider what's in the best interest of the environment and then to act with that in mind upholds the principles of the land ethic. This doesn't mean giving up the right to own property. What it really means is recognizing our responsibility to take better care of that property and our community at the same time. "^36 In A Sand County Almanac, Leopold warns that efforts to exploit the land are not only bad for the environment, but that they will also prove to be harmful to human beings. Slicle33: captive wolf Slide 34: water lilies Slide 35: wolf pup Slide 36: pitcher plant ------- That's actually a pretty intuitive idea. Examples are all around us. +37 Think again for a moment about the suburban deer population problem. With more and more deer coming closer and closer to our homes and streets, a couple of things have happened +38 Lyme disease, which can be spread through the bite of the deer tick, is becoming more common. More people are getting injured in car collisions with deer that have wandered onto the roads. And large populations of deer feeding in condensed areas lead to loss of certain forest trees, like hemlock. +39 In moving aggressively into deer habitat, we have changed the way things used to work in nature, and we're beginning to see some examples of why ignoring the needs of this member of the land community isn't necessarily the best thing for deer or for people. +40 We're used to thinking of human beings as self-reliant and in control of the natural environment. Biologically, though, we're just part of the web of life, just members of the land community, not very good masters of it. So our own well-being depends on the health of the rest of the system. When we damage one part of the environment by contributing to the Slide 37: deer Slide 38: deer Slide 39: new condos Slide 40: spiderweb Hide 41: river ------- extinction of a species or the pollution of a river, for instance, we hurt ourselves. Of course, we might not feel the negative impact of our actions immediately - or even in our own lifetime. In fact, we might consider the short-term economic benefits worth the risk. But the consequences of mistreating the environment will eventually show up, and can be economically costly. +42 When people make an effort to practice the land ethic, great things can happen for the environment and for people. Thirty years ago, fewer than 3,000 bald eagles remained in the United States, due in large part to the use by humans of the pesticide DDT. When eagles ate fish that had ingested insects poisoned by DDT the egg shells they produced were too weak to protect the chicks growing inside. Bald eagle populations plummeted because many chicks died before they hatched. ^43 Today, there are more than twice as many eagles in the U.S. as there were in 1968. When people realized the detrimental impact of DDT use on bald eagle populations, the pesticide was banned, and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service launched a program to introduce newly hatched chicks to healthy eagle habitat. ^44 Slide 42: bald eagle Slide 43: eagles with young ------- Because they are at the top of the food chain, the health of bald eagle populations is a good indicator of the health of the ecosystem overall. By making the effort to correct behavior that was resulting in diminishing bald eagle populations, we made things better for ourselves, too. ^>45 Think of land and society together as a single body, as different, and yet as connected as heart and bones. Just as a heart condition impairs the overall well-being of a person with perfectly healthy bones, an ailing environment cripples the human community. Just because your heart is giving you trouble doesn't mean you'd be better off without it. Each part of an organism contributes something to the welfare of the system as a whole. "^47 When part of our body is sick we concentrate on curing it, knowing that only by fixing that specific illness will we feel completely better. Similarly, a damaged environment cries out for healing, and unless we take the time and make the effort to bring about a cure, the whole land community - which includes human society - will suffer. Leopold wrote that, "harmony with the land is like harmony with a friend; you cannot cherish his right hand and chop off his left. That is to say you cannot love game Slide 44: soaring eagle Slide 45: anatomy Slide 46: surgeons Hide 47: sick child Slide 48: goose with chicks ------- and hate predators; you cannot conserve the waters and waste the ranges; you cannot build the forest and mine the farm. " ^49 In other words, only by accepting the entire natural world - in all its diversity - as good and as worthy of continued existence can you and I claim to practice the land ethic. To be a solid citizen of the land community, we must get into the habit of balancing our needs with those of the community in every decision we make and every action we take, and that includes the needs of the natural community. r>51 There are hints all around us that we are connected to the land. By paying attention to them and taking responsibility for our own attitudes and behavior we can all play a role in creating a greater degree of harmony between people and the rest of the natural system. ^52 When we take up the challenge of caring for the land, the outlook for a good quality of life for us and for future generations brightens. Let's all make the decision to do the right thing. -^53 We can begin by making a pledge to ourselves and our neighbors to make this the year that we develop a habit of Slide 49: snake lide 50: alligator Slide 51: kids with birdhouse Slide 52: sunset Slide 53: pledge ------- considering more than our own short-term interests or bottom line. Let's begin to think about how our actions will affect our entire community and our own long-term well-being. Let's weigh the aesthetic consequences of our behavior against the economic. Let's pledge to bear in mind how our decisions about the environment will affect the community that we leave to our children and grandchildren. **54 You can make this pledge to yourself, or I can give you a pledge to sign to join in an alliance for conservation that's nationwide. But when we do these things, we'll be starting to live the land ethic. End of packaged presentation Slide 54: howling wolf LOCAL FOCUS - Continue with your own short slide presentation, if possible. Here's how you might get started: Here in [name of town] we have an opportunity to help create a land ethic, first in our daily lives, and then more broadly to the issue/problem of [Summarize issue/problem/opportunity. See instructions, TAB 1] in our collective backyard. In [name of town/community], [insert detailed description of local problem or opportunity]. Because it [state impact of issue on environment], you and I, as conservation-minded citizens consider [local problem a bad thing or opportunity a good thing]. According to the land ethic, we must act ------- accordingly. [Suggest what audience can do to address issue/problem.] The year 1999 will mark the fiftieth anniversary of the publication of Aldo Leopold's yl Sand County Almanac. It's quite possible that the importance of adopting a system of principles to guide our interaction with the land has never been more crucial. The land is crying out for a cure, and each of us must choose whether or not we will answer. CONCLUDING REMARKS When you hear about the latest decision the powers-that-be have made regarding the environment, it might seem to have little relevance to you and your life. "So what if the government removes wolves from Yellowstone," you might think. "I live in [name of town]. What does it have to do with me? Actually, the environment and the decisions that affect it are about you. What happens to the environment has a direct impact on the quality of your life. We are all part of the land community. We're linked to it and dependent on it. So as you can see, conservation is really about community. As members of the land community, each of us has stake in the health of the environment. We must assume responsibility for our own actions and make a habit of behaving ethically in relation to the land. To do otherwise, as Leopold warns, is to hurt ourselves and generations to come. Change isn't always comfortable. But it is a necessary part of survival. To ensure the health of the environment for tomorrow we must begin today to embrace Leopold's land ethic - to accept our role and our responsibilities as members of the land community instead of conquerors of it. I appreciate the opportunity to speak to you, and I hope I've convinced you that conservation really is about us and our community. If I have, you can join [name of your group] and work with us to make a difference. You can ------- get started on [local issue/opportunity discussed]. Of you can act on whatever issue moves you. But please, take some positive action and do it with your own land ethic in mind Our community and our future depends on t. Thank you. ------- Conservation: It's About Community A Land Ethic for Today This version uses slides 1 through 52 only. INTRODUCTORY REMARKS Thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak with you today about what conservation really is and about its role in our lives. Throughout my talk today, I'll be mentioning the work of a man named Aldo Leopold. Even though he died about 50 years ago, his thoughts on the relationship between people and the rest of nature have helped guide concerned citizens like me for decades. I bet that sometimes it seems to you that the kinds of issues I'm involved in, things like water and air quality, don't really affect you. Actually, environmental issues are near and dear to all people. No matter where we live, we're connected to nature in a very important way: We're all part of what Leopold called the land community. Think about what the word "community" means to you. Most of you probably think of a community in terms of the people who live in it — your friends and your neighbors. People show support for their community in many different ways, such as volunteering at a charity or just by helping out when neighbors need us. We make this kind of effort because we feel it's the right thing to do. Fifty years ago, Aldo Leopold wrote a book called A Sand County Almanac which makes us think a little bit differently about what "community" really means. In his foreword, Leopold wrote, "When we see land as a community to which we belong, we may begin to use it with love and respect." Leopold suggested that the community includes more than we might think. It includes the environment and everything in it - the plants, animals, soils, and ------- waters. He said that people are actually members of this land community - the most powerful members, in fact. And he said that because people have the unique ability to make decisions that affect the land, we are also responsible for its health. In other words, we should be as just as thoughtful about caring for the land as we are about maintaining our friendships. Leopold said that "conservation is a state of harmony between man and land." It's about being a good citizen of the land community. To think about what the environmental consequences of our behavior might be before we act and then to be as gentle with the land as we possibly can, is the right thing to do. Leopold's definition of community might seem a little overwhelming or far-fetched to you. After all, the environment is so huge, what difference could the actions of one person really make? The land ethic doesn't demand as much of us as it might sound. But it does ask something of each of us. Small changes that you and I make in the way we think about and interact with the environment day-to-day can add up to big benefits to the land community. And by protecting the land we protect ourselves. Living according to the land ethic means keeping the needs of wildlife in mind when we plant our gardens. It means taking the time to learn about the environmental issues that hit close to home and then helping out if we can. It means that when we need to build a road, we build it in a way that preserves as much of the area's natural beauty as possible. Aldo Leopold's land ethic suggests that before we act in a way that might have any kind of impact on the environment, we should weigh what would be best for the land against what we need or want from the land. With this in mind, let's look more closely at the land ethic - which is really an ethic for today. ------- SLIDE PRESENTATION Sometimes we don't notice that the landscape is speaking to us. You see the same old landmarks on your way to school every day - the same trees, or rocks or hills - and probably don't think too much about them. ' When Aldo Leopold walked through the woods with his father as a child, he paid close attention to what he saw. ^3 He kept a journal in which he recorded what birds he spotted and even made illustrations of some of his favorites, like this wren. Leopold's habit of careful observation led to some of the ideas I'll be talking about today. By paying closer attention to our own surroundings we can begin to make sense of the clues that are right there in front of us. Clues that remind us how we are connected to the land and what we need to do to keep our "land community" healthy. -^5 Here's one example of a clue. Recently, people in many suburban areas in the U.S. have noticed what seems to be an increase in deer populations. But why are we suddenly seeing more deer in our neighborhoods?1 ^6 The behavior of deer Slide 1: street shot Slide 2: AL as a child Slide 3: AL drawing Slide 4: person near tree Slide 5: deer face Slide 6: four deer ------- has changed as the landscape has changed. Their numbers have become so great they are affecting our forests. People have removed the predators such as wolves and bears that once kept deer populations under control. By visiting our streets and our yards more frequently deer tell us something about our behavior. r^7 Signs that we're more connected to nature than we realize are all around us. We just have to pay attention. ^8 Aldo Leopold continued to learn from the land throughout his education and career. After receiving a degree in forestry from Yale University, he headed to the Southwest to work for the U.S. Forest Service. Over the next 20 years, he played an important role in managing the nation's forestlands for future generations. ^9 Leopold's love for the wilderness grew during the time he spent outdoors in the Southwest. -^10 He helped start a number of private conservation groups like the Izaak Walton League, The Wilderness Society and the National Wildlife Federation that continue today to make a difference for the environment. What kinds of things do conservation groups do that help the environment? ^11 Slide 7: gray squirrel Slide 8: AL adult portrait Slide 9: rural Southwest scene Slide 10: AL with fish Slide 11: AL at the Shack ------- Leopold moved to the Midwest in 1924, and four years later left the Forest Service to survey wildlife populations and habitats. Then he joined the staff of the University of Wisconsin, Madison, as the world's first , Professor of Game Management, where he stayed until his death in 1948. +12 Even though he had a challenging career and a growing family, Aldo Leopold always made time to get out into wild country - and to write about it. +13 His books, including .4 Sand County Almanac show what a great writer and keen observer he was. One of the things that help him become such a good writer was keeping a journal of the things he saw outside. Do any of you keep a journal like Aldo Leopold did? +14 Leopold's most famous book, A Sand County Almanac, begins with descriptions of the natural world based on Leopold's own observations, and then leads to his conclusions about our connection to it. The key idea in^l Sand County Almanac, the part that speaks to us most urgently, even fifty years later, is Leopold's land ethic. An ethic is a way of behaving that is good for more than just one person. +16 Actually, Leopold tells us that looking out for the land community is in our own best Slide 12: ski tracks in snow Slide 13: AL outside Slide 14: b&w landscape Slide 15: wood storks Slide 16: oily bird ------- interest. Because it's the land that eventually takes care of us. ^17 When you get right down to it, we already live by certain limitations every day without really giving it too much thought. ^18 The thing that sets these limitations is called society. Living up to society's standards of behavior means that in some cases we might not be able to do exactly what we want to do, but most of the time we're not even conscious of making an effort to be a good citizen. ^19 Can you think of an example? Ethical standards change all the time. I doubt that today an African-American woman would be ordered to give up her seat on a bus for a white man, as Rosa Parks was in 1955. Her courageous refusal to move sparked the civil rights movement, which has been adopted as an ethic. What's interesting is that Leopold says the ethical standards we practice so easily with respect to each other really should be applied to all of nature, from the most common animal "^22 to the most spectacular canyon lands. He says we must think ourselves as part of - not masters of - a land community that includes us, every living species, the soil and the water. We can already see ways in which an ethic has begun to show up in our attitudes about the Slide 17: recycling bin Slide 18: "Pedestrian Crossing" Slide 19: "No Trespassing'1 Slide 20: Rosa Parks Hide 21: boy with animal Hide 22: Grand Canyon ------- environment. Can you think of an example of an ethical standard we use with people that we could apply to animals? -^23 Twenty years ago it was a lot more common than it is today to see people just toss their trash onto the street. These days, society at large expects us to "put litter in its place." It's commonly accepted that littering ruins the beauty of the land. While throwing a soda can out a car window might be easier than pulling over to find a recycling bin, we know that littering is wrong, so we make the small effort to do the right thing. Almost without even thinking about it. Just imagine how it would look outside if everyone littered! H^24 Even so, we must do more for the environment than put litter in its place before we can say as a society that we're living up to a land ethic. Who can think of another example of how people take care of the environment? -^25 That leads us back to the question of what it really means to be a good member of the land community. ^26 Leopold suggests that we must find solutions that work for people and maintain as much of the land's original health and beauty as possible. -^27 Take a look around you and judge for what yourself works for people and the rest of the Slide 23: trash in forest Slide 24: person with hawk Slide 25: Valdez cleanup Slide 26: waterfall Slide 27: boy fishing ------- natural system. Notice that I say both people and nature. Leopold doesn't set up the land ethic as an "either/or" situation. If you were to decide today to start being a citizen of the land community it wouldn't mean that you'd never be able to cut down a tree or even build a factory. ->29 But you would think twice about how to do those things in a way that does the least amount of harm to the land It's important to remember that if we're to live according to the land ethic, we would have to let go of certain ideas that we're used to taking for granted. We'd have to take on the challenge of thinking and acting differently about such things as our ownership of land. *>31 We're used to thinking that the land is ours, and that this gives us the right to use it simply as we choose. You find stories of early settlers conquering the land and using its natural resources throughout American history. Taking control of the land seems to be part of "the American way." For a long time, that's meant that some people have been tuned in to how they can make money from the land while tuning out the messages the land is sending them. Some Slide 28: Backyard Habitat- Slide 29: bulldozer Slide 30: landfill Slide 31: bison Slide 32: dead fish ------- people have put their short-term desire to make money above the welfare of the environment. ^33 Think of some of the issues you hear about on the news every night. Over-fishing, air pollution, water pollution that causes problems for people and wildlife, and many wildlife management problems are just a few examples of the challenges we face that result from human beings basing environmental decisions on economic priorities alone. In making our decisions about how best to interact with the environment, each of us should consider more than how to get the quickest dollar value out of the land We should determine what outcome would be best for the land and think about that, too. To consider what is best for the environment and then to act with that in mind, upholds the principles of the land ethic. This doesn't mean giving up the right to use or own property. What it really means is taking better care of that property and our community at the same time. In A Sand County Almanac, Leopold warns that efforts to use up the land are not only bad for the environment, but that they might also prove to be harmful to people. Slide 33: captive wolf Slide 34: water lilies Slide 35: wolf pup Slide 36: pitcher plant ------- That's actually a pretty simple idea. There are examples all around us. - Think again about the deer population problem I talked about a minute ago. With more and more deer coming closer and closer to our houses and streets, a couple of things have happened ^38 Lyme disease, that can be spread through the bite of the deer tick, is becoming more common. More people are getting seriously injured in car collisions with deer that have wandered onto the roads. Large populations of deer feeding in condensed areas lead to loss of certain forest trees, like hemlock. And when there's not enough left to eat, some deer starve. ^39 By moving into deer habitat and eliminating their natural enemies, people have changed the way things used to work in nature. We're beginning to see some examples of why this isn't necessarily the best thing for deer or for people. We're used to thinking of people as being in control of the natural environment. Fact is, people are really just part of the web of life, plain old members of the land community, not veiy good masters of it. So our own well-being depends on the health of the rest of the system. When we damage one part of the Slide 37: deer Slide 38: more deer Slide 39: new condos Slide 40: spiderweb Slide 41: river ------- environment by contributing to the extinction of a species or the pollution of a river, for instance, we feel the consequences ourselves. Some people might consider the short-term benefits worth the long-term risk, but the consequences of hurting the environment eventually show up, and when they do, they tend to be expensive to fix. +42 When people make an effort to practice the land ethic, great things can happen for the environment and for people. Thirty years ago, fewer than 3,000 bald eagles remained in the United States, due in part of the use by humans of a pesticide called DDT. When eagles ate fish that had ingested insects poisoned by DDT, the egg shells they produced were too weak to protect the chicks growing inside. Bald eagle populations dropped because many chicks died before they hatched. Today, there are more than twice as many eagles in the U.S. as there were in 1968. When people realized how bad DDT was for bald eagles, the pesticide was banned. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service also began a new program to introduce newly-hatched chicks into healthy eagle habitat. Because bald eagles are at the top of the Slide 42: bald eagle Slide 41i_eagles with young Slide 44: soaring eagle ------- food chain, their health is a good indicator of the environment's overall health. By making the effort to correct behavior that was hurting bald eagle populations, people made things better for themselves, too. Think of land and society together as a single body, as different, and yet as connected as your nose and your feet. Just as a cold makes a person feel sick even if their feet are healthy, a damaged environment hurts the human community. Just because a person has a cold doesn't mean they'd be better off without their nose! Each part of a body contributes something to the well-being of the whole body. ">47 When part of our body is sick we focus on curing it, because we know that only by fixing that specific problem will we feel completely better. Likewise, a damaged environment cries out for healing, and unless people take the time and make the effort to cure it, the whole land community - which includes human society - will not be completely healthy. ->48 Leopold wrote that "harmony with the land is like harmony with a friend; you cannot cherish his right hand and chop off his left. That is to say you cannot love game and Slide 45: anatomy Slide 46: surgeons Slide 47: sick child Slide 48: goose with chicks ------- hate predators; you cannot build the forest and mine the farm." ^49 In other words, only by accepting the entire natural world - in all its variety - as good and as worthy of continued existence, can a person claim to practice the land ethic. To be a solid citizen of the land community, people should get into the habit of considering the needs of the whole community in every decision we make and every action we take, and that includes the needs of the natural community. ^51 There are hints all around us that we are connected to the land. By paying attention to them and taking responsibility for our own attitudes and behavior we can all play a role in restoring the balance between people and the rest of nature. When we take up the challenge to care for the land, the outlook for a good quality of life for us and for the future brightens. Leopold said that it's important for people to do their best to live up to the principles of the land ethic. Can you think of something you can do to live up to the land ethic? Slide 49: snake Slide 50: alligator Slide 51: kids with birdhouse Slide 52: sunset End of packaged presentation ------- LOCAL FOCUS - Continue with your own short slide presentation, if possible. Here's how you might get started: Here in [name of town], we have an opportunity to create a land ethic, first in our daily lives, and then to the [issue/problem] of [Summarize issue/ problem/opportunity. See instructions, TAB 1] here in our town. In [name of town/community], [insert detailed description of local problem or opportunity]. Because it [state impact of issue on environment], you and I might conside'r [local problem a bad thing or opportunity a good thing]. According to the land ethic, we should act accordingly. [Suggest what audience can do to address issue/ problem.] It's possible that it has never been more important than it is today to live by a system of principles to guide our interaction with the land. The environment is crying out for a cure, and each of us can choose whether or not we will answer. CONCLUDING REMARKS When you hear about the latest decision that politicians have made about the environment, it might seem to have little importance to you and your life. "So what?" you might think. "What does it have to do with me?" Actually, the environment and the decisions that affect it are about you. What happens to the environment has a direct impact on the quality of your life. We are all part of the land community. We're linked to it and dependent on it. So as you can see, conservation is really about community. As members of the land community, each of us has stake in the health of the environment. We have the opportunity to assume responsibility for our own actions and ------- make a habit of behaving ethically in relation to the land Change isn't always comfortable. But it is a necessary part of survival. To ensure the health of the environment for tomorrow people can begin today to embrace Leopold's land ethic - to accept our role and our responsibilities as members of the land community instead of conquerors of it. I appreciate the opportunity to speak to you, and I hope I've helped you understand that conservation really is about us and our community. Thank you. ------- ------- CONSERVATION: IT'S ABOUT COMMUNITY A Land Ethic for Today Photo Credits 1. Street view, Jackson Hole Wyoming, by Steve Chase, FWS. 2. Aldo Leopold as a young boy, ®University of Wisconsin-Madison Archives. 3. Drawing of a wren by Aldo Leopold, ©University of "Wisconsin-Madison Archives. 4. FWS personnel showing size of tree by Hollingsworth, FWS. 5. Deer, by Ryan Hagerty, FWS. 6. Whitetail deer, National Wildlife Federation. 7. Gray Eastern squirrel, by Ryan Hagerty, FWS. 8. Adult portrait of Aldo Leopold, ®University of Wisconsin-Madison Archives. 9. Scene in rural New Mexico, circa 1915, ®University of Wisconsin-Madison Archives. 10. Leopold with a fish, ®University of Wisconsin-Madison Archives. 11. Leopold exiting Shack, circa 1940, ®University of Wisconsin-Madison Archives. 12. Cross country ski trail near the Shack, late 1930s, ®University of Wisconsin-Madison Archives. 13. Leopold strolling with wife Estella and daughter near the Shack, circa 1940 ®University of Wisconsin-Madison Archives. 14. Hunting area near "Tome"; New Mexico, circa 1920, ® University of Wisconsin- Madison Archives. 15. Wood storks, by Ryan Hagerty, FWS. 16. Oiled black Scoter, by Jill Parker, FWS. 17. Recycling bin, National Wildlife Federation. 18. Pedestrian crossing sign, National Wildlife Federation. 19. No Trespassing sign, National Wildlife Federation 20. Rosa Parks leaves with attorney Langford, 1956, UPI/Corbis-Bettmann. 21. Small boy and kangaroo rat by Steve Van Riper, FWS. 22. Arizona landscape, by George Gentry, FWS. 23. Litter, by Ryan Hagerty, FWS. 24. Red tail hawk, by Doug Canfield, FWS. 25. Cleanup at Exxon Valdez, by Jill Parker, FWS. 26. Waterfall, by George Gentry, FWS. 27. Young boy fishing, by Roger L. Hamman, FWS. 28. Backyard Wildlife Habitat, National Wildlife Federation. 29. Bulldozer, National Wildlife Federation. 30. Landfill, ®1998 CMSP. All Rights Reserved. No reproduction allowed. 31. Bison, 1983, National Wildlife Federation. 32. Water pollution fish kill by W. French, FWS. 33. Wolf relocation, by LuRay Parker, FWS. 34. Water lilies, by Ryan Hagerty, FWS. 35. Mexican wolf pup, by Ryan Hagerty, FWS. ------- 36. Endangered pitcher plant, by George Gentry, FWS. 37. White-tailed deer, by Fred Youngblood, FWS. 38. White-tailed deer, 1983, National Wildlife Federation. 39. New condominiums, National Wildlife Federation. 40. Spiderweb at sunrise, by Bill West, FWS. 41. Bald cypress, by Ryan Hagerty, FWS. 42. Bald eagle, by George Gentry, FWS. 43. Eagles' nest, by Gerry Atwell, FWS. 44. Bald eagle, by Al Milliken, FWS. 45. Brain, heart, kidney, vascular illustration, ©1998 CMSP. All Rights Reserved. No reproduction allowed. 46. Surgeons in a circle, ©1998 CMSP. All Rights Reserved. No reproduction allowed. 47. Child with chicken pox, ©1998 CMSP. All Rights Reserved. No reproduction allowed. 48. Canada goose with chicks, by George Gentry, FWS. 49. Rattlesnake, by Tom Smylie, FWS. 50. Alligator, by Jill Parker, FWS. 51. Kids building wood duck habitat, by George Gentry, FWS. 52. Altamaha River, by George Gentry, FWS. 53. Land ethic pledge, National Wildlife Federation. 54. Eastern Timber wolf, by L. David Mech, FWS. ------- List of Further Resources For more information on Aldo Leopold and the land ethic, visit http://www.aldo.org or contact the following organizations: Aldo Leopold Foundation E-12919 Levee Road Baraboo, WI 53913 (608)355-0279 Aldo Leopold Nature Center 300 Femrite Drive Monona, WI 53716 Leopold Center for Sustainable Agriculture 209 Curtiss Hall Iowa State University Ames, IA 50011 Leopold Education Project 1783 Buerkle Circle St. Paul, MN 55110 (612) 773-2000 http://www.lep.org Potomac Overlook Park 2845 Marcey Rd, Arlington, VA 22207 (703) 528-5406 University of Wisconsin - Madison Archives (photos) B134 Memorial Library 728 State Street Madison, WI 53706 Conservation groups: International Crane Foundation P.O. Box 447 Baraboo, WI 53913 (608) 356-9462 ------- The Izaak Walton League of America 707 Conservation Ln. Gaithersburg, MD 20878 (301) 548-0150 National Wildlife Federation 8925 Leesburg Pike Vienna, VA 22184 (703) 790-4085 (communications department) http://www.nwf.org North American Association for Environmental Education 1255 23rd St,NW Suite 400 Washington, DC 20037 (202) 884-8912 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 401 M Street, S.W. Washington, DC 20460 http://www.epa.gov U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service National Conservation Training Center Route 1, Box 166 Shepardstown, WV 25443 (304) 876-1600 U.S. Forest Service P.O. Box 96090 Washington, DC 20090 (202) 205-0957 The Wilderness Society 900 17th Street, NW Washington, DC 20006 (202) 833-2300 http://www.wilderness.org ------- Acknowledgments "Conservation: It's About Community" was developed by the National Wildlife Federation in coordination with the following organizations: Aldo Leopold Foundation Aldo Leopold Nature Center International Crane Foundation Izaak Walton League Leopold Center for Sustainable Agriculture Leopold Education Project ; North American Association for Environmental Education Potomac Overlook Park U.S. Environmental Protection Agency U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Conservation Training Center U.S. Forest Service Wilderness Society Special thanks to: Jeff Miller of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Conservation Training Center for designing this kit. The University of Wisconsin - Madison Archives for contributing photographs from their Leopold Collection, and to Bernie Schermetzler for photo research assistance. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service for lending numerous images to this effort and to Elizabeth Jackson of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Conservation Training Center for photo research assistance. "Conservation: It's About Community" is printed with soy ink on recycled paper. Printing by Custom Print, Inc., Slide duplication by Washington Slide. ------- ------- |