United States
Environmental Protection
Agency
Office Of Water
(4303)
EPA821-R-95-015
February 1995
vvEPA
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis Of
Proposed Effluent Limitations
Guidelines For The
Pharmaceutical Manufacturing
Industry
-------
-------
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
of Proposed Effluent Guidelines
for the Pharmaceutical Manufacturing Industry
Final Report
Engineering and Analysis Division
Office of Science and Technology
Office of Water
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
Washington, DC 20460
February 1995
-------
-------
CONTENTS
Page
SECTION ONE INTRODUCTION 1-1
SECTION TWO BACKGROUND METHODOLOGY 2-1
2.1 Pollutants of Concern 2-2
2.2 Toxic Weighting Factors 2-2
2.3 PoUution Control Options 2-6
2.4 Pollutant Removals 2-10
2.4.1 Water and Air Pollutant Removals 2-10
2.5 Annualized Costs of Compliance 2-13
2.6 Calculation of the Cost-effectiveness Values 2-15
2.7 Comparisons of Cost-effectiveness Values 2-17
SECTION THREE RESULTS 3-1
3.1 Best Available Technology—Direct Dischargers 3-1
3.1.1 A/C Facilities 3-1
3.1.2 B/D Facilities 3-2
3.2 Pretreatment Standards For Existing
Sources—Indirect Dischargers 3-2
3.2.1 A/C Facilities 3-2
3.2.2 B/D Facilities 3-4
SECTION FOUR COMPARISON OF COST-EFFECTIVENESS VALUES
WITH PROMULGATED RULES 4-1
SECTION FIVE REFERENCES 5-1
-------
CONTENTS (cent.)
'age
APPENDIX A POLLUTANT LOADINGS AND REDUCTIONS FOR
DIRECT DISCHARGERS A-l
APPENDIX B POLLUTANT LOADINGS AND REDUCTIONS FOR
INDIRECT DISCHARGERS B-l
APPENDIX C CALCULATIONS FOR COMPUTING AIR EMISSIONS REDUCTIONSC-1
APPENDIX D COST-EFFECTIVENESS RESULTS USING THE
ALTERNATIVE PWF APPROACH D-l
u
-------
SECTION ONE
INTRODUCTION
This analysis is submitted in support of the effluent limitations guidelines and standards
for the Pharmaceutical Manufacturing Industry. The report analyzes the cost-effectiveness of 11
regulatory options organized into four regulatory groupings. This document compares the total
annualized cost incurred for each of the regulatory options within each grouping to the
corresponding effectiveness of that option in reducing the discharge of pollutants. The
effectiveness measure used is pounds of pollutant removed weighted by an estimate of the
relative toxicity of the pollutant. The rationale for this measure, referred to as "pound
equivalents (PE) removed," is described later in this document.
Section Two discusses the cost-effectiveness methodology used and identifies the
pollutants included in the analysis, presenting their toxic weighting factors and removal
efficiencies. Section Three presents the results of the analysis. In Section Four, the cost-
effectiveness values are compared to cost-effectiveness values for other promulgated rules.
Appendices present data on pollutants, pollutant removals., annualized costs, and other, more
detailed information.
1-1
-------
-------
SECTION TWO
BACKGROUND METHODOLOGY
Cost effectiveness (CE) is defined as the incremental annualized cost of a pollution
control option in an industry or industry subcategory per incremental pound-equivalent of
pollutant (i.e., pound of pollutant adjusted for toxiciry) removed by that control option. A cost-
effectiveness analysis is used to analyze effluent limitation guidelines to enable various regulatory
options to be compared either among options or to other benchmarks such as guidelines for
other industries. The cost-effectiveness value derived in the analysis represents the unit cost of
removing the next pound-equivalent of pollutant.
A number of steps must be undertaken before a cost-effectiveness analysis can be
performed. There are five steps that define the analysis or generate data for use in the cost-
effectiveness calculation:
• Determine the wastewater pollutants of concern (priority and other pollutants)
• Estimate the relative toxic weights (the adjustments to pounds of pollutants to
reflect toxicity) of the pollutants of concern.
• Define the regulatory pollution control options.
• Calculate pollutant removals for each pollution control option.
• Determine the annualized cost of each pollution control option.
All of these factors are used in the calculation of the cost-effectiveness values, which can
then be compared for each of the regulatory options under consideration. The following sections
discuss the five preliminary steps and the cost-effectiveness calculation and comparison
-methodologies.
2-1
-------
2.1 POLLUTANTS OF CONCERN
Under the effluent limitation guidelines for the pharmaceutical industry, 55 pollutants are
regulated. Some of the factors considered in selecting pollutants for regulation include toxicity,
frequency of occurrence, and amount of pollutant in the wastestream. The list of regulated
pollutants is presented in Table 2-1.
2.2 TOXIC WEIGHTING FACTORS
Toxic weighting factors (TWFs) are used to calculate copper-based pound-equivalents,
and are derived from chronic aquatic life criteria (or toxic effect levels) and human health
criteria (or toxic effect levels) established for the consumption of fish. For carcinogenic
substances, the human health risk level is set at 10'5 (i.e., protective to a level allowing 1 in
100,000 excess lifetime cancer cases over background). These toxicity levels are related to a
benchmark value, or toxicity level associated with a single pollutant. Copper, a toxic metal
commonly detected and removed from industrial effluent, was selected as the benchmark
pollutant (Le., the basis to which others are compared). EPA used copper previously in TWF
calculations for the cost-effectiveness analysis of effluent guidelines. While the water quality
criterion for copper was revised in 1984 (to 12.0/tg/L), the TWF method uses the former criterion
(5.6 pg/L) to facilitate comparisons with cost-effectiveness values calculated for other regulations.
The former criterion for copper (5.6 jig/L) was reported in the 1980 Ambient Water Quality
Criteria for Copper document (U.S. EPA, 1980).
In the TWF method, a TWF for aquatic life effects and a TWF for human health effects
are added for pollutants of concern. The calculation is performed by dividing aquatic life and
human health criteria (or toxic effect levels) for each pollutant, expressed as a concentration in
micrograms per liter (pg/L), into the former copper criterion of 5.6 jig/L:
TWF,
5.6
nomol
5.6
AQ HHOO
2-2
-------
TABLE 2-1
TOXIC WEIGHTING FACTORS AND REMOVAL EFFICIENCIES
FOR REGULATED POLLUTANTS
Pollutant
Code
CN-
3
9
10
11
12
15
25
26
27
29
35
37
39
43
48
51
55
58
60
61
62
64
66
67
70
71
77
79
80
82
84
87
93
94
95
96
97
Pollutant
Name
Cyanide
Acentonitrile
Ammonia -(aqueous)
N-Amyl Acetate
Amyl Alcohol (1-Pentanol)
Aniline
Benzene
2-Butanone (MEK)
N-Butyl Acetate
N-Butyl Alcohol (1-Butanol).
tert-Butyl Alcohol
Chlorobenzene
Chloroform
Chloromethane
Cyclohexane
o-Dichiorobenzene
1 ,2-Dichloroethane
Diethylamine
Diethyl ether
N,N-Dimethylacetamide
Dimethylamine
N,N-Dimethylaniline
N,N-Dimethylfonnamide
Dimethyl sulfoxide
1,4-Dioxane
Ethanol
Ethyl acetate
Ethylene glycol
Formaldehyde
Formamide
Furfural
N-Heptane
N-Hexane
Isobutyraldehyde (2-Methyl propanal)
Isopropanol (2-propanol)
Isopropyl Acetate
Isopropyl Ether
Methanol
Toxic
Weighting
Factor
1.1E+00
2.8E-02
3.7E-03
8.6E-04
1.6E-04
1.5E+00
4.8E-01
3.3E-03
3.1E-03
1.7E-03
3.2E-05
1.1E-02
9.9E-02
2.1E-01
9.0E-03
1.2E-02
1.5E+00
2.8E-04
8.8E-04
2.1E-06
6.2E-04
8.3E-02
1.6E-03
1.6E-06
1.7E-01
5.8E-04
7.6E-04
1.6E-04
3.1E-03
6.6E-02
6.2E-02
3.1E-02
2.1E-03
5.6E-03
6.9E-05
6.1E-04
2.9E-04
POTW
Removal
Efficiency
0.50
0.83
~
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
— '
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
0.79
—
. _
0.79
0.75
—
—
~
0.57
0.85.
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
2-3
-------
TABLE 2-1 (cont.)
Pollutant
Code
99
101
102
103
105
106
113
114
115
117
118
124
129
130
134
' 136
Pollutant
Name
Methylamine
Methyl Cellosolve (2-Methoxyethanol)
Methylene Chloride (Dichloromethane)
Methyl- Formate
Methyl Isobutyl Ketone (MTBK)
2-Methyl Pyridine (2-Picoline)
Petroleum Naphtha
Phenol
Polyethylene Glycol 600
N-Proponal (1-Proponal)
Acetone
Pyridine
Tetrahydrofuran
Toluene
Trichlorofluoromethane
Triethylamine
Weighting
Factor
3.4E-04
4.0E-02
1.2E-01
8.9E-06
3.4E-03
1.4E-04
6.7E-02
2.8E-02
5.6E-05
2.7E-05
1.6E-03
1.6E-01
7.0E-03
6.4E-03
1.5E-03
1.5E-04
4.3E-03
POTW
Removal
Efficiency
~
— •
—
--
--
—
~
0.97
0.57
--
--
—
—••
-"
— -
~
"
2-4
-------
where:
nonvol
TWF,
AQ
HHOO
Toxic weighting factor for nonvolatile pollutants
Chronic aquatic life value (figfL)
Human health (ingesting organisms only) value (jig/L)
VOC emission reductions are included in this cost-effectiveness analysis. The equation to
calculate TWFs for volatiles follows the same method used in the Cost-Effectiveness Analysis for
the Organic Chemicals, Plastics, and Synthetic Fibers Industry (U.S. EPA, 1987). This equation
was constructed to include in TWFs all exposure to humans associated with the presence of
volatile toxic pollutants in the industry's wastewater. This modification applies only to the
volatile pollutants; the calculation of the TWFs for nonvolatile pollutants is as described above.
As discussed in the Cost-Effectiveness Analysis for the Organic Chemicals, Plastics, and
Synthetic Fibers Industry (U.S. EPA, 1987), VOCs have the potential to volatilize from wastewater
effluent into the atmosphere during wastewater treatment. Although removed from the final
wastewater discharge, the subsequent air load can increase the exposure of humans to pollutants
through the inhalation pathway of exposure. Ideally, a weighting factor for VOCs would
incorporate both air and water criteria or toxic effect levels. This approach is not readily
feasible, however, because the criteria are expressed in different units (jigfm3 versus jig/L).
Therefore, proxy criteria for air are developed by: (1) substituting the average quantity of water
ingested (2 L/day) for the average amount of air inhaled (20 m3/day) and (2) using oral cancer
slope potency factors and oral reference doses to represent toxicity from inhalation. With these
modifications, the proxy criteria for air become equivalent to the calculated water quality criteria
for ingesting water and organisms (as represented by HHWO). The equation used here to
calculate TWFs is the same as above, except that HHOO is replaced with HHWO in
consideration of the additional human health risk from the potential presence of VOCs in the
air:
TWF..., = — +
5.6
vol
AQ HHWO
2-5
-------
where:
AQ
HHWO
Toxicity weighting factor for volatile pollutants
Chronic aquatic life value (fig/L)
Human health (ingesting water and organisms) value
The differences between TWFVol and TWFnonvol are summarized in Table 2-2.
EPA also has developed an alternative weighting factor for water-based effluents. These
alternative weighting factors, known as pollutant weighting factors (PWFs), are discussed in
Appendix D. Results of the cost-effectiveness analysis using PWFs also is presented in
Appendix D.
23 POLLUTION CONTROL OPTIONS
The pollution control options investigated are divided into those for direct dischargers
and those for indirect dischargers. Within each type of discharger, additional distinctions are
made. First, all technology options are divided between industry subcategories, with A and C
industry subcategories (representing facilities that use fermentation or biological and chemical
synthesis processes) being distinguished from B and D industry subcategories (representing
facilities that use biological and natural extraction processes or that are formulators of
pharmaceutical products). For direct dischargers, the technologies are then further broken down
into BFT, BCT, BAT, and NSPS options, of which only the BAT options are considered in the
cost-effectiveness analysis; for indirect dischargers, PSES technology options are examined.
NSPS and PSNS options are identical to the more stringent BAT and PSES options for each
group of facilities. Thus the relative cost-effectiveness of these options will be similar to that for
the more stringent options in each regulatory grouping.
Table 2-3 presents the regulatory options addressed in this analysis and defines the
technologies associated with each option. The abbreviations used to briefly identify the options
2-6
-------
TABLE 2-2
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN TWF,,,OIWOI AND TWF,
vol
Feature
Benchmark Value
(numerator)
Carcinogenic Risk Level
Human Health Exposure
Aquatic Life Effects vs.
Human Health Effects
TWFnonvoI
5.6 (former freshwater
chronic criterion for
copper)
lO'5 (1 in 100,000 excess
cancer cases)
Fish consumption only
Effects are added
TWFTOI
5.6 (former freshwater
chronic criterion for
copper)
10'5 (1 in 100,000 excess
cancer cases)
Drinking water and fish
consumption
Effects are added
2-7
-------
TABLE 2-3
REGULATORY OPTIONS CONSIDERED IN THE ECONOMIC IMPACT ANALYSIS
Type of
Option
Name
Description
" . * ^ •> $ y- > -Direct Dischargers " ',''"'' f'"'
Best
Available
Technology
New. Source
Performance
Standard
BAT-A/C#1
BAT-A/C#2 •
BAT-A/C#3
BAT-A/C#4
BAT-B/D#1
BAT-B/D#2
BAT-B/D#3
BAT-B/D#4
NSPS-A/C#1
NSPS-A/C#2
NSPS-B/D#1
NSPS-B/D#2
Advanced biological treatment + cyanide destruction with
nitrification where necessary
Advanced biological treatment + cyanide destruction + in-
plant steam stripping
Advanced biological treatment + cyanide destruction + in-
plant steam stripping/distillation
Advanced biological treatment + cyanide destruction + in-
plant steam stripping\distillation + activated carbon
Advanced biological treatment
Advanced biological treatment + in-plant steam stripping
Advanced biological treatment + in-plant steam
stripping/distillation
Advanced biological treatment 4- in-plant steam
stripping/distillation + activated carbon
Advanced biological treatment + cyanide destruction + in-
plant steam stripping/distillation
Advanced biological treatment + cyanide destruction + in-
plant steam stripping/distillation + activated carbon
Advanced biological treatment + in-plant steam
stripping/distillation
Advanced biological treatment + in-plant steam
stripping/distillation + activated carbon
2-8
-------
Type of
Option
Name
Description
Indirect Dischargers ,
Pretreatment
Standards for
Existing
Sources
Pretreatment
Standard for
New Sources
PSES-A/C#1
PSES-A/C#2
PSES-A/C#3
PSES-A/C#4
PSES-B/D#1
PSES-B/D#2
PSES-B/D#3
PSNS-A/C#1
PSNS-A/C#2
PSNS-A/C#3
PSNS-B/D#1
PSNS-B/D#2
In-plant steam stripping + cyanide destruction
In-plant steam stripping/distillation + cyanide destruction
In-plant steam stripping/distillation + cyanide destruction +
end-of-pipe advanced biological treatment with nitrification
In-plant steam stripping/distillation + cyanide destruction +
end-of-pipe advanced biological treatment with nitrification +
activated carbon
In-plant steam stripping
In-plant steam stripping/distillation
In-plant steam stripping/distillation + activated carbon
In-plant steam stripping/distillation + cyanide destruction
In-plant steam stripping/distillation + cyanide destruction +
end-of-pipe advanced biological treatment
In-plant steam stripping/distillation + cyanide destruction +
end-of-pipe advanced biological treatment + activated carbon
In-plant steam stripping/distillation
In-plant steam stripping/distillation -f activated carbon
2-9
-------
(e.g., BAT-A/C#1, which represents the BAT control technology Option 1 for the industry
subgroup consisting of facilities using the A and/or C production processes) are introduced in
this table. Although 15 BAT and PSES options are listed in Table 2-3, BAT-A/C#4, BAT-
B/D#4, PSES-A/C#4, and PSES-B/D#3 could not be analyzed for cost-effectiveness. These
options remove only chemical oxygen demand (COD) incrementally. COD has no TWFs
associated with it, and thus no pound equivalent can be calculated. Additionally, there are
implicitly four no-action alternatives, one for each regulatory grouping. Costs, removals, and
thus cost-per-pound equivalent for the four no-action alternatives are zero. Not including the
no-action alternatives, a total of 11 separate regulatory options were evaluated, six for direct
dischargers (BAT-A/C#1, BAT-A/C#2, BAT-A/C#3, BAT-B/D#1, BAT-B/D#2, and BAT-
B/D#3) and five for indirect dischargers (PSES-A/C#1, PSES-A/C#2, PSES-A/C#3, PSES-
B/D#1, andPSES-B/D#2).x
None of these options is a zero-discharge option. Zero discharge options were eliminated
because EPA determined that they were not technologically feasible.
2.4 POLLUTANT REMOVALS
The pollutant loadings have been calculated for each facility under each regulatory option
for comparison with baseline loadings. The baseline and post-regulatory loadings for direct and
indirect dischargers affected under each regulatory option are presented in Appendix A and
Appendix B, respectively.
JFour NSPS options and four PSNS options are presented in Table 2-3 only because they are
equivalent to some of the BAT and PSES options. Because they are equivalent to certain BAT
and PSES options, the relative cost-effectiveness should be the same or less costly. BPT and
BCT options cannot be analyzed in a cost-effectiveness analysis because they regulate
conventional pollutants that do not have TWFs associated with them. BCT has its own cost
analysis procedure.
2-10
-------
2.4.1 Water and Air Pollutant Removals
Under this cost-effectiveness analysis, pollutant load reductions were calculated for water
and air under each of the regulatory options. Final pollutant loadings in water were calculated
for direct and indirect dischargers using data from the Section 308 Survey database. The Section
308 Survey requested information from facilities on the fate of raw chemicals used in their
manufacturing processes. The survey requested from each facility an estimate of the quantity of
raw materials going into product, emitted into air as in-plant fugitive emissions, emitted into air
from wastewater collection and treatment, degraded or destroyed, discharged in wastewater, and
otherwise disposed.
Air pollutant loads for both direct and indirect dischargers were estimated from the air
emissions reported in the Section 308 Survey or were estimated as current air emissions from the
WATER? modeling effort. The calculation of pollutant removals from water and air under
specific regulatory options is discussed below.
2.4.1.1 Calculation of Pollutant Removals from Water and Air for Direct Dischargers
The methodology followed in developing cost-effectiveness values for direct dischargers
under each regulatory option included the following specific methods for calculating water and air
pollutant load reductions:
For subcategory A/C and B/D facilities, under BAT Option 1 which includes
advanced biological treatment (BAT-A/C#1 and BAT-B/D#1), water load
reductions were developed by comparing each facility's current discharge load
(according to the Section 308 Survey database) to their proposed load under the
regulatory option.
For subcategory A/C and B/D facilities, lander BAT Options 2 and 3, which
include in-plant steam stripping and in-plant steam stripping/distillation,
-respectively, followed by advanced biological treatment (BAT-A/C#2 and 3 and
BAT-B/D#2 and 3), water load reductions were developed by comparing each
facility's current discharge load (according to the Section 308 Survey database) to
their proposed load under the regulatory option. In addition, credit was given
for removal of air pollutant loads that were estimated as current air emissions
2-11
-------
from the January 1994 WATER? modeling effort conducted by Radian
Corporation.
For a complete discussion of the determination of air emission estimates for direct
dischargers, see Appendix C.
2.4.13 Calculation ofPottutant Removals from Water and Air for Indirect Dischargers
The methodology followed in developing cost-effectiveness values for indirect dischargers
under each regulatory option included the following specific methods for calculating water and air
pollutant load reductions:
• For subcategory A/C and B/D facilities, under PSES Options 1 and 2, which
include in-plant steam stripping and in-plant steam stripping/distillation,
respectively (PSES-A/C#1 and 2 and PSES-B/D#1 and 2), water load reductions
were developed by comparing each facility's current discharge load (according to
the Section 308 Survey database) to its proposed load after treatment under the
regulatory option. In addition, credit was given for removal of air pollutant
loads that were estimated as current air emissions from the January 1994
WATER? modeling effort conducted by Radian Corporation.
• For subcategory A/C facilities, under PSES Option 3, which includes in-plant
steam stripping/distillation followed by advanced biological treatment (PSES-
A/C#3), water load reductions were developed by comparing each facility's
current discharge load (according to the Section 308 Survey database) to its
proposed load after treatment under the regulatory option. In addition, credit
was given for removal of air pollutant loads that were estimated as current air
emissions from the January 1994 WATER? modeling effort conducted by
Radian Corporation.2
For a complete discussion of the determination of air emission estimates for indirect
dischargers, see Appendix C.
2Air reductions were calculated only for the in-plant steam stripping options. These
reductions were also assigned to steam stripping/distillation options, since air reductions for these
options would be as good as or better than those calculated for the steam stripping options.
2-12
-------
One additional step must be undertaken to calculate final reductions in nonvolatile
pollutant loadings for indirect dischargers because of the ability of POTWs to remove pollutants
(volatile pollutants are not removed by POTWs since they are volatilized before reaching
POTWs). Thus water removals for indirect dischargers take into account the POTW removal
efficiencies as well. POTW removal credit is not given to volatile compounds with a Henry's
Law Constant greater to or equal to 2.7E-06 atm/gmole/m3. Significant emission of these
compounds to the air is expected from conveyance systems or open primary treatment units prior
to reaching a POTW's biological treatment unit. Table 2-1 presents the POTW removal
efficiencies for nine nonvolatile pollutants. The POTW removal efficiencies are used as follows.
If a facility is discharging 100 pounds of cadmium in its effluent stream to a POTW and the
POTW has a removal efficiency for cadmium of 38 percent, then the cadmium discharged to
surface waters is only 62 pounds. If the regulation results in a reduction of cadmium in the
effluent stream such that total cadmium discharged to the POTW is 50 pounds, then the amount
discharged to surface waters is calculated as 50 pounds multiplied by the POTW removal
efficiency factor (1 - 0.38, or 0.62 times 50 pounds equals 31 pounds). The cost-effectiveness
calculations then reflect the fact that the actual reduction of pollutant discharged to surface
water is not 50 pounds (the change in the amount discharged to the POTW), but 31 pounds (the
change in the amount actually discharged to surface water).
2.4.1.3 Calculation of Pound Equivalents
Following the calculation of pollutant removals for both direct and indirect dischargers,
the removals are then weighted using the TWFs and are reported in pound-equivalents (see
Appendix A and Appendix B for pound-equivalent removals by facility and option). Total
removals for each regulatory option are then calculated by summing the removals for each
pollutant for each facility affected by each option (weighted where necessary using survey
weights). Total pollutant removals estimated to be achieved under each regulatory option are
presented in Table 2-4.
2-13
-------
TABLE 2-4
ESTIMATED POLLUTANT LOADINGS BY TYPE OF FACILITY
Regulatory
Option
Raw
Load
Ob)
Current
Load
Ob)
Total Load
Reduction
Ob)
A/C Direct Dischargers
BAT-A/C#1
BAT-A/C#2
BAT-A/C33
77,906,785
5,133,649
4,894,776
18,507,551
18,521,319
B/D Direct Dischargers
BAT-B/D#1
BAT-B/D#2
BAT-B/D#3
109,252
23,230
22,610
39,175
39,227
A/C Indirect Dischargers
PSES-A/C#1
PSES-A/C#2
PSES-A/C#3
90,181,808
33,181,762
38,029,217
50,981,759
51,807,047
B/D Indirect Dischargers
PSES-B/D#1
PSES-B/D#2
7,424,870
1,934,646
4,378,836
4,990,451
Source: Section 308 Survey data and Radian Corp. estimates.
2-14
-------
2.5 ANNUALIZED COSTS OF COMPLIANCE
Under each regulatory option, annualized costs of compliance have been developed (see
Economic Impact Analysis of Effluent Guidelines and Limitations on the Pharmaceutical Industry
[U.S. EPA, 1995]). the derivation of these costs is summarized briefly below.
Two groups of costs were derived for each of the affected facilities under each of the
regulatory options: capital costs, which include capital equipment, delivery and installation of
equipment including site work, site work prior to installation, engineering and necessary ancillary
equipment and activities (piping, painting, electrical hookups, etc.); and recurring costs, which
include operating and maintenance costs (O&M) (which include O&M labor and materials,
chemical use, and sludge handling and disposal, if applicable) and electricity usage costs. The
capital costs are then amortized over the lifetime of the equipment, to produce an annual cost3.
Unlike annual costs derived in the Economic Impact Analysis, where tax shields and an average
cost of capital for industry was used to model impacts on industry, annual costs in this cost-
effectiveness analysis are derived using no tax shields and the 7 percent discount rate suggested
by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) as an appropriate discount rate (OMB, 1992).
These annualized capital costs are added to the recurring costs to produce a total annual
compliance cost for each facility affected under each regulatory option. Aggregate annual costs
for each regulatory option are used in the calculation of the cost-effectiveness values. The total
BAT/PSES aggregate annual costs by option are presented in Table 2-5. Because BAT costs
discussed in the Economic Impact Analysis include the cost of meeting BPT requirements, and
costs of meeting BPT requirements are not subject to cost-effectiveness analysis, BPT costs must
be removed before the cost-effectiveness analysis is performed. Table 2-5, therefore, also shows
the costs of meeting BAT requirements incremental to BPT requirements.
3These annualized costs are pretax costs to approximate the total cost to society of these
options.
2-15
-------
TABLE 2-5
ESTIMATED ANNUAL PRETAX COSTS
($1994)
Regulatory
Option
Costs Incremental
toBPT
Requirements
Total
Annual Costs*
A/C Direct Dischargers
BAT-A/C#1
BAT-A/C#2
BAT-A/C#3
$6,483,706
$43,110,277
$69,998,301
$11,587,494
$47,615,810
$74,503,833
B/D Direct Dischargers
BAT-B/D#1
BAT-B/D#2
BAT-B/D#3
$610,103
$1,158,324
$2,467,029
$1,340,763
$1,281,807
$2,592,335
A/C Indirect Dischargers
PSES-A/C#1
PSES-A/C#2
PSES-AO3
$61,644,960
$104,462,558
$138,330,479
$61,648,606
$104,466,204
$138,330,479
B/D Indirect Dischargers
PSES-B/D#1
PSES-B/D#2
$13,159,463
$18,980,956
$13,281,233
$23,097,128
Source: ERG and Radian Corp. estimates.
* Includes BPT costs.
2-16
-------
2.6 CALCULATION OF THE COST-EFFECTTVENESS VALUES
Cost-effectiveness values are calculated separately for direct and indirect dischargers, for
A/C facilities and B/D facilities and for BAT vs. PSES options. This scheme leads to the
following four analytical groupings: BAT-A/C options, BAT-B/D options, PSES-A/C options,
and PSES-B/D options. Within each of these groups, the options are ranked in ascending order
of pound-equivalents of pollutants removed. Under each of these analytical groupings, the cost-
effectiveness value for a particular control option is calculated as the ratio of incremental annual
cost of that option to the incremental pound equivalents removed by that option. The
incremental effectiveness can be viewed both in comparison to the baseline scenario and to
another regulatory option. Cost-effectiveness values are reported in units of dollars per pound-
equivalent of pollutant removed.
For the purpose of comparing cost-effectiveness values of options under review to those
of other promulgated rules, compliance costs used in the cost-effectiveness analysis are adjusted
to 1981 dollars using Engineering News Record's Construction Cost Index (CCI). This adjustment
factor is calculated as follows:
Adjustment factor = 1981 CCI/1990 CCI = 3,535/4,732 = 0.7470
The equation to calculate cost-effectiveness is:
_ATCk-ATCk_l
where:
CEk=
ATCk
Cost effectiveness of Option k
Total annualized treatment cost under Option k
Pound-equivalents removed by Option k
2-17
-------
The numerator of the equation, ATQ. minus ATC^, is simply the incremental annualized
treatment cost in going from Option k-1 (an option that removes fewer pound-equivalent
pollutants) to Option k (an option that removes more pound-equivalent pollutants). The
denominator is similarly the incremental removals achieved in going from Option k-1 to k. Thus,
cost-effectiveness measures the incremental unit cost of pollutant removal of Option k (in pound-
equivalents) in comparison to Option k-1.
Nonincremental cost-effectiveness values can also be derived by setting ATC^ to zero
and the pollutant loadings (PEjc.j) are set to the current loading. These values are used to
compare an option to previously promulgated effluent limitations guidelines.
2.7 COMPARISONS OF COST-EFFECTIVENESS VALUES
Because the options are ranked in ascending order of pound-equivalents of pollutants
removed, any option that has higher costs but lower removals than another option can be
identified immediately (the cost-effectiveness value for the next option becomes negative). When
negative values are computed for Option k, Option k-1 will be noted as "dominated" (having a
higher cost and lower removals than Option k). Option k-1 is then remoyed from the cost-
effectiveness calculations, and all cost-effectiveness values within a regulatory grouping are then
recalculated without the "dominated" option. This process continues until all "dominated"
options are eliminated. The remaining options can then be presented in terms of their
incremental cost-effectiveness values and are considered viable options for regulatory
consideration.
2-18
-------
SECTION THREE
RESULTS
The cost-effectiveness analysis is based on the Agency's estimates of the cost of
compliance and wastewater pollution removals associated, with eight BAT options for direct
dischargers—four for facilities with fermentation or chemical synthesis processes (the A and C
facilities) and four for facilities with biological and natural extraction processes or which
formulate pharmaceuticals (the B and D facilities). For indirect dischargers the analysis
calculates cost-effectiveness values for seven PSES options, four for A/C facilities and three for
B/D facilities. A total of four options (BAT-A/C#4, BAT-B/D#4, PSES-A/C#4, and PSES-
B/D#3 cannot be evaluated for cost-effectiveness, however, because they only remove COD
incrementally for which a pound-equivalent cannot be calculated. Thus 11 options organized into
four regulatory groupings are analyzed (see Section Two for more details).
The following sections present a brief description of the technologies used in each of the
four regulatory groupings, and, for each grouping, cost-effectiveness data and results are
presented in a table. Note that there are implicit no-action alternatives associated with each
group of options that have costs, removals, and costs-per-pound equivalents of zero. These no-
action alternatives assume only BPT is met. BPT requirements are not analyzed for cost
effectiveness. Thus, the first option in each grouping is incremental from a no-action baseline.
3.1 BEST AVAILABLE TECHNOLOGY—DIRECT DISCHARGERS
3.1.1 A/C Facilities
Three BAT options were evaluated for A/C facilities. BAT-A/C#1 involves the use of
cyanide destruction technology (where necessary) and advanced biological treatment (including
nitrification for ammonia where necessary). BAT-A/C#2 adds to this option in-plant steam
3-1
-------
stripping. BAT-A/C#3 replaces the in-plant steam stripping in Option 2 with in-plant steam
stripping/distillation.
As shown in Table 3-1, the. incremental cost-effectiveness values for these options range
from $20 to $63,375/lb. eq. The proposed regulatory option, BAT-A/C#2, has an incremental
cost-effectiveness value of $68/lb. eq.
3.1.2 B/D Facilities
Three BAT options were evaluated for B/D facilities. BAT-B/D#1 involves the use of
advanced biological" treatment. BAT-B/D#2 adds to this option in-plant steam stripping. BAT-
B/D#3 replaces in-plant steam stripping in Option 2 with in-plant steam stripping/distillation.
As shown in Table 3-1, the incremental cost-effectiveness values for these options range
from $4,544 to $29 million/lb. eq. The cost-effectiveness value of the selected regulatory option
BAT-B/D#1 is $4,544/lb. eq. Since BAT-B/D#1 is equivalent to the proposed. BPT standard,
BAT for B/D directs is set equal to BPT. The costs shown for BAT-B/D#1 in Table 3-1 are
attributable to small incremental operating and maintenance costs and monitoring costs and
amount to $400,000 (1981 $) or about 0.3 percent of the total cost of the proposed effluent
guideline. Because the technology for BPT is identical to that for BAT, however, EPA considers
BAT effectively equal to BPT.
3.2 PRETREATMENT STANDARDS FOR EXISTING SOURCES—INDIRECT
DISCHARGERS
3.2.1 A/C Facilities
Three PSES options were evaluated for A/C facilities. PSES-A/C#1 involves the use of
in-plant steam stripping and cyanide destruction technology (where necessary). PSES-A/C#2
replaces in-plant steam stripping in Option 1 with in-plant steam stripping/distillation. PSES-
3-2
-------
TABLE 3-1
INCREMENTAL COST-EFFECTTVENESS VALUES FOR ALL REGULATORY OPTIONS
USING SECTION 308 SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE ANALYSIS FOR WATER REMOVALS*
TWF (Volatile) Toxic Weighting Factor, Air Removals, All Facilities
Options
Incremental
Annual
Pretax Costs
(1981$)
Incremental
Pollutant
Removals
Ob)
Incremental
Pollutant
Removals
Ob-eq)
Incremental
Cost
Effectiveness
(1981$/lb-eq)
A/C Direct Dischargers
BAT-A/C#1
BAT-A/C#2
BAT-AO3
4,237,618
23,938,377
17,573,462
4,894,776
13,535,367
13,768
208,092
350,444
277
20
68
63,375
i B/D Direct Dischargers
BAT-B/D#1
BAT-B/D#2
BAT-B/D#3
398,751
358,306
855,343
22,610
22,542
51
88
48
0
4,544
7,434
28,578,484
A/C Indirect Dischargers
PSES-A/C#1
PSES-A/C#2
PSES-A/C33
40,289,885
27,984,706
22,135,381
38,33 1,249
12,650,511
825,288
850,728
34,801
9,575
47
804
2,312
B/D Indirect Dischargers
PSES-B/D#1
PSES-B/D#2
8,600,756
6.415.468
4,378,836
611.615
89,400
434
96
14.785
* Air load reductions ate determined from WATER7 emissions estimates, as discussed in Section Two.
Note: No cost-effectiveness analysis was conducted for BAT A/C#4,PSES A/C#4 and PSES B/D#3 since
this option is designed for COD removal and COD cannot be evaluated on a pound equivalent basis.
3-3
-------
A/C#3 includes advanced biological treatment, in addition to in-plant steam stripping/distillation
and cyanide destruction technology (where necessary).
As shown in Table 3-1, the cost-effectiveness values for these options range from $47 to
$2,312/lb. eq. The proposed regulatory option, PSES-A/C#1, has an incremental cost-
effectiveness value of $47/lb. eq.
B/D Facilities
Two PSES options were evaluated for B/D facilities. PSES-B/D#1 involves the use of in-
plant steam stripping and PSES-B/D#2 involves the use of in-plant steam stripping/distillation.
As shown in Table 3-1, the incremental cost-effectiveness value for the proposed
regulatory option (PSES-B/D#1) is $96/lb. eq.
3-4
-------
SECTION FOUR
COMPARISON OF COST-EFFECTIVENESS VALUES WITH
PROMULGATED RULES
Table 4-1 presents the cost-effectiveness values for effluent limitations guidelines and
standards issued for direct dischargers under BAT in other industries. For the A/C direct
dischargers, the cost-effectiveness values for the proposed option is $68/lb.eq. The cost-
effectiveness value for BAT-A/C#2 is within the range shown for other effluent guidelines. For
B/D direct dischargers the selected option is effectively set at BAT = BPT.
Table 4-2 presents the cost-effectiveness values for effluent limitations guidelines issued
for indirect dischargers under PSES in other industries. For A/C indirects, the cost effectiveness
value for the proposed option is $47/lb.eq. For B/D indirects the value is $96/lb.eq. The values
for PSES-A/C#1 and PSES-B/D#1 are within the range shown for other effluent guidelines.
4-1
-------
TABLE 4-1
INDUSTRY COMPARISON OF BAT COST-EFFECTIVENESS FOR DIRECT DISCHARGERS
(Toxic and Nonconventional Pollutants Only; Copper-Based Weights*; $ 1981)
Industry
Battery Manufacturing
Coil Coating
Copper Forming
Electronics I
Electronics n
Foundries
Inorganic Chemicals I
Inorganic Chemicals II
Iron & Steel
Learner Tanning
MeW Finishing
Nonferrous Metals Forming
Nonferrous Metals Mfg I
Nonferrous Metals Mfg H
Offshore Oil and Gas
OCPSF"
Pesticides
Pharmaceuticals A/C
B/D
Plastics Molding & Forming
Porcelain Enameling
Petroleum Refining
Pulp & Paper'1
Textile Mills
PE Currently
Discharged
(thousands)
1,340
4.126
12
BAT=BPT
2,289
70
9
NA
2,308
32,503
605
40.746
259
3,305
34
6,653
1,004
3.628
54.225
2,461
560
0.1
44
1.086
BAT=BPT
1.330
BAT=BPT
PE Remaining at
Selected Option
(thousands)
90
5
0.2
BAT=BPT
9
8
3
NA
39
1,290
27
1,040
112
3,268
2
313
12
2,218
9,735
371
2
negligible
41
63
BAT=BPT
748
BAT=BPT
Cost-Effectiveness of
Selected Optkm(s)
($/PE removed)
121
2
10
BAT=BPT
49
27
404
NA
84
<1
6
2
BAT=BPT
12
69
4
6
34"
5
15
68
BAT=BPT
BAT=BPT
6
BAT=BPT
18
BAT=BPT
"Although toxic weighting factors for priority pollutants varied across these rules, this table reflects
the cost-effectiveness at the time of regulation.
lFor produced water only; for produced sand and drilling fluids and drill cuttings, BAT=NSPS.
'Reflects costs and removals of both air and water pollutants.
dPCB control for Deink subcategory only.
4-2
-------
TABLE 4-2
INDUSTRY COMPARISON OF PSES COST-EFFECTIVENESS FOR INDIRECT DISCHARGERS
(Toxic and Nonconventional Pollutants Only; Copper-Based Weights3; $ 1981)
Industry
Aluminum Forming
Battery Manufacturing
Canmaking
Coal Miningb
Coil Coating
Copper Forming
Electronics I
Electronics n
Foundries
Inorganic Chemicals I
Inorganic Chemicals n
Iron & Steel
Leather Tanning
Metal Finishing
Nonferrous Metals Forming
Nonferrous Metals Mfg I
Nonferrous Metals Mfg n
Offshore Oil and Gasb
OCPSF
Pharmaceuticals A/C
B/D
Plastics Molding & Forming
Porcelain Enameling
Pulp & Paper
PE Currently
Discharged (To
Surface Waters)
(thousands)
1.602
1,152
252
NA
2.503
34
75
260
2.136
3.971
4.760
5.599
16,830
11.680
189
3,187
38
NA
5,210
897
90
NA
1565
NA
PE Remaining at
Selected Option (To
Surface Waters
(thousands)
18
5
5
NA
10
4
35
24
18
3,004
6
1,404
1,899
755
5
19
0.41
NA
72
47
0.5
NA
96
NA
Cost-Effectiveness of
Selected Option(s)
Beyond BPT
($/PE removed)
155
15
38
NAC
10
10
14
14
116
9
<1
6
111
10
90
15
12
NA
34
47
96
NA
14
' NA
"Although toxic weighting factors for'priority pollutants varied across these rules, this table reflects the
cost-effectiveness at the tune of regulation.
blndustry has no known or expected indirect dischargers.
cNA=Pretreatment Standards not promulgated, or no incremental costs will be incurred.
4-3
-------
-------
SECTION FIVE
REFERENCES
OMB. 1992. Guidelines and Discount Rates for Benefit-Cost Analysis of Federal Programs.
Office of Management and Budget, Circular No. A-94, revised, October 29.
U.S. EPA. 1995. Economic Impact Study of Effluent Guidelines and Limitations on the
Pharmaceutical Industry.
U.S. EPA. 1987. Cost-Effectiveness Analysis for the Organic Chemicals, Plastics, and Synthetic
Fibers Industry.
U.S. EPA, 1980. Ambient Water Quality Criteria for Copper. EPA 440/5-80-036.
5-1
-------
-------
APPENDIX A
POLLUTANT LOADINGS AND REDUCTIONS FOR
DIRECT DISCHARGERS
A-l
-------
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for BAT Option 1 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
June 30,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 7/20/94)
Facility Poll.
Code Code
30010 9
30010 29
30010 43
30010 64
30010 70
30010 71
30010 77
30010 79
30010 80
30010 87
30010 97
30010 102
30010 103
30010 129
30010 130
Total Organics
30050 94
30050 97
Total Organics
30060 9
30060 79
30060 94
30060 97
30060 114
30060 124
30060 118
Total Organics
30159 43
30159 58
30159 62
30159 70
30159 71
30159 82
Raw Loadings
(lbs/yr)
929,926
86,997
118,687
1,150
448,942
265,258
39,701
49,690
1,002
3,243
145,291
1,528,924
2,377
0
12,011
2,703,273
28,790
21,862
50,652
7,000
300
150
150
9,000
50
8,400
18,050
128
530
0
163
16
131
308 Quest.
Current Load
ttbs/vr)
158,804
2,844
0
0
0
12,409
0
577
109
2,027
0
14,972
634
0
0
33,572
24,995
0
24,995
7,000
300
150
150
9,000
50
8,400
18,050
1
14
0
1
1
4
BAT Option 1
Proposed Load
(Ibs/yr)
9,892
2,844
0
0
0
2,932
0
577
109
20
0
348
634
0
0
7,464
43
0
43
155
21
17
61
1
1
5
105
1
14
0
1
1
4
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/yr)
148,912
0
0
0
0
9,477
0
0
0
2,007
0
14,624
0
0
0
26,108
24,952
0
24,952
6,845
279
133
89
8,999
49
8,395
17,945
0
0
0
0
0
0
A-3
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for BAT Option 1 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
June 30,1994 Version (QA/QC MKW 7/20/94)
Facility Poll.
Code Code
30159 94
30159 96
30159 97
30159 124
30159 129
30159 130
30159 139
30159 77
30159 118
Total Organics
30227 9
30227 70
30227 79
30227 114
Total Organics
30345 43
30345 71
30345 94
30345 97
30345 99
30345 118
30345 130
Total Org?"iies
30347 118
Total Organics
30487 37
30487 43
30487 51
30487 61
30487 64
30487 66
30487 70
Raw Loadings
(Ibs/yr)
480
78
515
0
0
139
139
1,998
1,004
5,321
4
15,357
500
1,370
17,227
156,499
207,348
2,472,281
1,890,354
479,484
10,790
932
5,217,688
113,906
113,906
5,679
13,083
16
21,177
80,646
87,992
90,719
308 Quest.
Current Load
(Ibs/yr)
9
1
4
0
0
2
12
39
18
106
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1,007
0
25
0
1,032
1,320
1,320
46
0
3
756
136
5,040
1,454
BAT Option 1
Proposed Load
abs/vr)
9
1
4
0
0
2
3
39
18
97
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
321
0
25
0
346
1
1
1
0
3
6
1
121
121
Water Load
Reduction
dbs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
9
0
0
9
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
686
0
0
0
686
1,319
1,319
45
0
0
750
135
4,919
1,333
A-4
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for BAT Option 1 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
June 30,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 7/20/94)
Facility Poll.
Code Code
30487 71
30487 80
30487 87
30487 93
30487 94
30487 97
30487 102
30487 118
30487 129
30487 130
30487 136
30487 139
Total Organics
30540 CN-
30540 9
30540 43
30540 70
30540 71
30540 79
30540 94
30540 95
30540 97
30540 103
30540 106
30540 118
30540 139
30540 60
30540 37
30540 113
30540 58
Total Organics
30542 CN-
30542 9
30542 3
30542 10
Raw Loadings
Obs/yr)
346,650
2,335
2,106
8,501
1,094,906
1,066,087
38,985
964,267
33,648
593,080
6,615
2,693
4,459,185
312
235,967
5,460
923,729
545,623
1,450
361,063
527,801
931,289
605,573
98,800
601,730
719,794
7,460
695
728
780
5331,975
16,082
453,800
8,700
3,578
308 Quest.
Current Load
(Ibs/vr)
0
0
0
0
5,050
1,714
0
0
0
1,442
0
0
15,641
1
17,600
50
180
10,698
218
7,221
10,556
0
9,209
48,800
1,730
850
746
0
0
0
90,258
3
420,000
3,400
3,578
BAT Option 1
Proposed Load
abs/vr)
0
0
0
0
34
121
0
0
0
1
0
0
410
1
5,319
21
180
1,577
218
589
1,051
0
1,577
105
164
21
23
0
0
0
5,526
2
53,235
105
3,578
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/yr)
0
0
0
0
5,016
1,593
0
0
0
1,441
0
0
15,231
0
12,281
29
0
9,121
0
6,632
9,505
0
7,632
48,695
1,566
829
723
0
0
0
84,732
1
366,765
3,295
0
A-5
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for BAT Option 1 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
June 30,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 7/20/94)
Facility Poll.
30542 12
30542 25
30542 26
30542 27
30542 37
30542 64
30542 70
30542 71
30542 77
30542 79
30542 82
30542 84
30542 87
30542 94
30542 96
30542 97
30542 99
30542 102
30542 105
30542 117
30542 129
30542 130
30542 136
30542 139
30542 39
30567 CN-
30567 84
30567 97
30567 129
30567 130
30567 136
30600 9.
30600 70
Raw Loadings
flbs/vf)
36,400
765
763,200
392,049
920
0
473,300
718,600
3,700
554,600
15,800
63,050
8,250
793,800
800
2,435,000
23,400
120,000
13,900
1,101
109,100
120,000
172,800
40
193,194
7,026,047
25,322
0
1,618
95
3,952
0
5,665
184,878
2,305
308 Quest.
Current Load
abs/vr)
0
765
97,500
392,049
920
0
447,000
28,400
1,900
20,000
15,400
50
10
295,000
800
1,900,000
23,400
120,000
11,000
1,101
88,100
120,000
98,600
40
140,000
3,809,013
24
0
160
0
50
0
210
184,328
2,305
BAT Option 1
Proposed Load
Qbs/vrt
0
765
10,521
5,260
210
0
21,042
15,781
1,900
7,154
15,400
50
10
5,892
800
21,042
1,052
1,873
631
1,101
25,671
210
1,052
' 40
1,094
142,233
1
0
9
0
0
0
9
745
295
Water Load
Reduction
abs/vri
0
0
86,979
386,789
710
0
425,958
12,619
0
12,846
0
0
0
289,108
0
1,878,958
22,348
118,127
10,369
0
62,429
119,790
97,548
0
138,906
3,666,780
23
0
151
0
50
0
201
183,583
2,010
A-6
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for BAT Option 1 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
June 30,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 7/20/94)
Facility PoU.
Code Code
30600 94
30600 102
30600 118
Total Organics
30623 CN-
30623 25
30623 37
30623 39
30623 51
30623 58
30623 64
30623 70
30623 79
30623 84
30623 87
30623 97
30623 102
30623 118
30623 124
30623 129
30623 130
30623 136
Total Organics
30701 37
30701 43
30701 51
30701 70
30701 71
30701 118
30701 130
Total Organics
30762 9
30762 3
Raw Loadings
(Ibs/yr)
124,796
0
46,381
173,482
17
12,868
23,466
1,410
50,983
21,054
1,088,822
865,209
95,260
0
997,106
977,715
237,957
48,066
3,500
39,598
76,038
12,065
4,551,117
371,245
26,455
103,616
906,753
879,635
989,204
268,961
3,545,869
632,000
896,000
308 Quest.
Current Load
(Ibs/vr)
123,013
0
7,433
132,751
17
143
172
70
315
86
0
0
86
0
0
143
315
1,087
0
1,892
86
0
4,395
880
0
103,616
661
0
1,543
0
106,700
30,000
4,900
BAT Option 1
Proposed Load
(Ibs/vr)
82
0
23
400
2
60
12
61
75
86
0
0
86
0
0
143
105
92
0
1,436
12
0
2,167
27
0
172
661
0
210
0
1,070
1,821
4
Water Load
Reduction
Obs/vr)
122,931
0
7,410
132,351
15
83
160
9
240
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
210
995
0
456
74
0
2^28
853
0
103,444
0
0
1,333
0
105,630
28,179
4,896
A-7
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for BAT Option 1 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
June 30,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 7/20/94)
Facility
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
Poll.
Code
11
43
51
58
64
70
71
87
94
97
102
124
130
136
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
- „ 31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
3
11
10
25
35
37
43
58
60
64
66
70
71
80
82
84
87
94
95
97
99
102
114
118
Raw Loadings
(Ibs/vr)
54,000
19,200
431,500
242,400
3,400,800
422,500
965,000
827,930
428,950
21,414,000
6,148;000
609,300
2,330,000
408,600
38.598,180
22,104
0
330,293
0
10,959
0
0
207
0
38
0
220
75
0
2,125
0
143
143
0
49,619
5,879
1,131
354,350
2,740
308 Quest
Current Load
flbs/yr)
53,000
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
9,100
0
0
0
67,000
720
0
2,493
0
0
0
0
207
0
38
0
0
75
0
0
0
143
143
0
2,673
0
1,131
0
171
BAT Option 1
Proposed Load
abs/vr)
720
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
64
0
0
0
787
18
0
2,493
0
0
0
0
207
0
38
0
0
75
0
0
0
18
143
0
2,673
0
316
0
171
Water Load
Reduction
Obs/vr)
52,280
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
9,036
0
0
0
66,213
702
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
125
0
0
0
0
815
0
0
A-8
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for BAT Option 1 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
June 30,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 7/20/94)
308 Quest. BAT Option 1 Water Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings
Code Code
31040 124
31040 129
31040 130
31040 136
31040 139
Total Organics
31056 15
31056 94
31056 97
31056 118
31056 130
Total Organics
Total A/C Organics
for Directs ab/yr)
Total Cyanide
(Ib/yr)
Total Ammonium
Hydroxide (Ib/yr)
abs/vr)
5,079
816
689
0
1,530
788,140
1,700
91,000
203,200
2,293,200 .
226,600
2,815,700
75,421,477
41,733
2,443,575
Current Load Proposed Load
(lbs/vr)
0
816
689
0
1,530
10,829
0
0
0
0
0
0
4,315,872
45
817,732
abs/vr)
0
816
36
0
36
7,039
0
0
0
0
0
0
167,699
7
71,168
Reduction
abs/vr)
0
0
653
0
1,494
3,790
0
0
0
0
0
0
4,148,173
38
746,564
Footnotes:
(1) The process wastewater flow for facility 30542 has been
adjusted to better reflect their process flow without the use
of barometric condensers.
(2) The following A/C direct facilities do not discharge
process wastewater containing the nonconventional pollutants
that are candidates for regulation. These facilities are,
therefore, not included in this table.
Facilities: 30339,30368,30369,30387,30524,30903, and 31057
A-9
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for New BAT Option 2 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MKW)
Facility
Code
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
Total
30050
30050
30060
30060
30060
30060
30060
30060
30060
Total
30159
30159
30159
30159
30159
30159
30159
Poll.
Code
9
29
43
64
70
71
77
79
80
87
97
102
103
129
130
94
97
9
79
94
97
114
124
118
43
58
62
70
71
82
94
Raw Loadings
(Ibs/vrt
929,926
86,997
118,687
1,150
448,942
265,258
39,701
49,690
1,002
3,243
145,291
1,528,924
2,377
0
12,011
3 633,199
28,790
21,862
50,652
7,000
300
150
150
9,000
50
8,400
25,050
128
530
0
163
16
131
480
308 Quest
Current Load
flbs/vr)
158,804
2,844
0
0
0
12,409
0
577
109
2,027
0
14,972
634
0
0
192,376
24,995
0
24,995
7,000
300
150
150
9,000
50
8,400
25,050
1
14
0
1
1
4
9
BAT Option 2a
Proposed Load
flbs/vr)
2,385
1,955
0
0
0
1,955
0
577
109
20
0
39
634
0
0
7,673
8
0
8
37
21
3
31
1
1
3
96
1
14
0
1
1
4
9
Water Load
Reduction
Obs/vr)
156,419
889
0
0
0
10,454
0
0
0
2,007
0
14,933
0
0
0
184,703
24,987
0
24,987
6,963
279
147
119
8,999
49
8,397
24,954
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
771,122 *
23,000 **
116,952
18
330,602
237,564
7
1,784
138
1,216*
50,699
1,505,755
1,743 *
0
11,792
3,052,392
3,705 *
10,119
13,824
0*
0*
0*
0*
0*
0*
0*
0
43
71
0
5
1
7
12
A-10
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for New BAT Option 2 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
Facility
Code
30159
30159
30159
30159
30159
30159
30159
30159
Total
30227
30227
30227
30227
Total
30345
30345
30345
30345
30345
30345
30345
Total
30347
Total
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
Poll.
Code
96
97
124
129
130
139
77
118
9
70
79
114
43
71
94
97
99
118
130
118
37
43
51
61
64
66
70
71
80
Raw Loadings
(Ibs/vr)
78
515
0
0
139
139
1,998
1,004
5321
4
15,357
500
1,370
17,231
156,499
207,348
2,472,281
1,890,354
479,484
10,790
932
5,217,688
113,906
113,906
5,679
13,083
16
21,177
80,646
87,992
90,719
346,650
2,335
308 Quest.
Current Load
(lbs/vr)
1
4
0
0
2
12
39
18
106
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1,007
0
25
0
JL,032
1,320
1,320
46
0
3
756
136
5,040
1,454
0
0
BAT Option 2a
Proposed Load
(lbs/yr)
1
4
0
0
2
3
39
15
94
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
161
0
16
0
177
1
1
1
0
2
6
1
121
94
0
0
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
9
0
3
12
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
846
0
9
0
855
1,319
1,319
45
0
1
750
135
4,919
1,360
0
0
Air Load
Reduction
(lbs/yr)
16
5
0
0
31
32
0
19
242
0
133
0
0
133
155,036
189,436
1,538,043
787,054
478,179
8,014
926
3,156,688
109,786
109,786
15
0
10
244
44
2,562
468
0
0
A-ll
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for New BAT Option 2 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest BAT Option 2a Water Load
Facility
Code
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
Total
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
Poll Raw Loadings
Code
87
93
94
97
102
118
129
130
136
139
CN-
9
43
70
71
79
94
95
97
103
106
118
139
60
37
113
58
CN-
" 9
3
10
12
25
(lbs/vr)
2,106
8,501
1,094,906
1,066,087
38,985
964,267
33,648
593,080
6,615
2,693
4,459,185
312
235,967
5,460
923,729
545,623
1,450
361,063
527,801
931,289
605,573
98,800
601,730
719,794
7,460
695
728
780
5,567,942
16,082
453,800
8,700
3,578
36,400
765
Current Load Proposed Load
flbs/vrt
0
0
5,050
1,714
0
0
0
1,442
0
0
15,641
1
17,600
50
180
10,698
218
7,221
10,556
0
9,209
48,800
1,730
850
746
0
0
0
107,858
3
420,000
3,400
3,578
0
765
flbs/vri
0
0
6
61
0
0
0
1
0
0
293
1
1,282
21
180
1,051
218
105
1,051
0
1,051
105
105
21
23
0
0
0
5,215
2
12,835
105
3,578
0
765
Air Load
Reduction Reduction
flbs/vr)
0
0
5,044
1,653
0
0
0
1,441
0
0
15,348
0
16,318
29
0
9,647
0
7,116
9,505
0
8,158
48,695
1,625
829
723
0
0
0
102,643
1
407,165
3,295
(0)
0
0
flbs/vr)
0
0
1,442
1,932
0
0
0
1,624
0
0
8,341
0
218,367 *
5,208
414,230
388,216
17
101,931
442,826
130,408
588,185
1,072
243,334
675,377
2,268
656
524**
642
3,213,261
0
3,757
20
0 *
11
0*
A-12
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for New BAT Option 2 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
Facility
Code
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
Total
30567
30567
30567
30567
30567
30567
Total
30600
30600
30600
30600
Poll.
Code
26
27
37
64
70
71
77
79
82
84
87
94
96
97
99
102
105
117
129
130
136
139
39
CN-
84
97
129
130
136
9
70
94
102
Raw Loadings
(Ibs/vr)
763,200
392,049
920
0
473,300
718,600
3,700
554,600
15,800
63,050
8,250
793,800
800
2,435,000
23,400
120,000
13,900
1,101
109,100
120,000
172,800
40
193,194
7,479,847
25,322
0
1,618
95
3,952
0
5,665
184,878
2,305
124,796
0
308 Quest
Current Load
(Ibs/yr)
97,500
392,049
920
0
447,000
28,400
1,900
20,000
15,400
50
10
295,000
800
1,900,000
23,400
120,000
11,000
1,101
88,100
120,000
98,600
40
140,000
4,229,013
24
0
160
0
50
0
210
184,328
2,305
123,013
0
BAT Option 2a
Proposed Load
Obs/vr)
10,521
5,260
210
0
16,244
10,521
1,900
7,154
14,119
50
10
1,052
800
10,521
1,052
210
105
1,101
1,515
210
1,052
40
1,052
101,984
1
0
5
0
0
0
5
180
227
15
0
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vrt
86,979
386,789
710
0
430,756
17,879
0
12,846
1,281
0
0
293,948
0
1,889,479
22,348
119,790
10,895
(0)
86,585
119,790
97,548
0
138,948
4,127,029
23
0
155
0
50
0
205
184,148
2,078
122,998
0
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/yr)
2,092
0 *
0 *
0
1,183
2,067
0
65
44
187
25
1,300
0 *
2,754
0 *
0 *
40
0 *
279
0 *
462
0
539
14,825
0
0
171
15
1,174
0
1,360
550 *
0*
1,783 *
0
A-13
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for New BAT Option 2 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Faculties
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings
308 Quest. BAT Option 2a Water Load Air Load
Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
(Ibs/vr) (Ibs/vrt
30600
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
Total
30701
30701
30701
30701
30701
30701
30701
30762
30762
30762
30762
118
CN-
25
37
39
51
58
64
70
79
84
87
• 97
102
118
124
129
130
136
37
43
51
70
71
118
130
9
3
11
43
46,381
358,360
17
12,868
23,466
1,410
50,983
21,054
1,088,822
865,209
95,260
0
997,106
. 977,715
237,957
48,066
3,500
39,598
76,038
12,065
4551 117
371,245
26,455
103,616
906,753
879,635
989,204
268,961
3,545,869
632,000
896,000
54,000
19,200
7,433
317,079
17
143
172
70
315
86
0
0
86
0
0
143
315
1,087
0
1,892
86
0
4.395
880
0
103,616
661
0
1,543
0
106,700
30,000
4,900
53,000
0
15
437
2
60
12
59
17
86
0
0
86
0
0
143
12
59
0
85
12
0
630
27
0
40
661
0
135
0
862
439
4
360
0
7,418
316,642
15
83
160
11
298
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
303
1,028
0
1,807
74
0
3,765
853
0
103,576
0
0
1,408
0
105,838
29,561
4,896
52,640
0
38,948 *
4L281
0
11,463
22,934
1,340 *
49,279
19,596
15,717
621,165
3,182
0
989,635
324,907
233,373
32,581
2,208
30,939
73,904
10,609
2.442,832
79,786
6,505
0 *
27,451
65,341
27,465
43,821
250,369
0
100
1,000
0
A-14
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for New BAT Option 2 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest. BAT Option 2a Water Load
Facility
Code
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
Total
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
Poll. Raw Loadings
Code
51
58
64
70
71
87
94
97
102
124
130
136
3
11
10
25
35
37
43
58
60
64
66
70
71
80
82
84
87
94
95
97
99
102
114
118
124
129
(Ibs/yr)
431,500
242,400
3,400,800
422,500
965,000
827,930
428,950
21,414,000
6,148,000
609,300
2,330,000
408,600
39,230,180
22,104
0
330,293
0
10,959
0
0
207
0
38
0
220
75
0
2,125
0
143
143
0
49,619
5,879
1,131
354,350
2,740
5,079
816
Current Load Proposed Load
(lbs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
9,100
0
0
0
97,000
720
0
2,493
0
0
0
0
207
0
38
0
0
75
0
0
0
143
143
0
2,673
0
1,131
0
171
0
816
(lbs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
7
0
0
0
810
18
0
1,775
0
0
0
0
207
0
38
0
0
75
0
0
0
18
143
0
1,775
0
36
0
171
0
256
Reduction
(lbs/yr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
9,093
0
0
0
96,190
702
0
718
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
125
0
0
898
0
1,095
0
0
0
560
Air Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
100
0
0
0
1,200
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
A-15
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for New BAT Option 2 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
Facility Poll.
Code Code
31040 130
31040 136
31040 139
31056 15
31056 94
31056 97
31056 118
31056 130
Total A/C
Total Cyanide
(Ib/yr)
Raw Loadings
abs/vrt
689
0
1,530
788,140
1,700
91,000
203,200
2,293,200
226,600
2,815,700
77,865,052
41,733
308 Quest.
Current Load
flbs/vr)
689
0
1,530
10,829
0
0
0
0
0
0
5,133,604
45
BAT Option 2a
Proposed Load
(Ibs/vr)
36
0
36
4,582
0
0
0
0
0
0
122,866
6
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
653
0
1,494
6,247
0
0
0
0
0
0
5,010,738
39
Air Load
Reduction
abs/vr)
0
0
0
0
789
30,705
54,927
927,382
99,029
1,112,832
13,419,366
0
Footnotes:
(1) The process wastewater flow for facility 30542 has been
adjusted to better reflect their process flow without the use
of barometric condensers.
(2) The following A/C direct facilities do not discharge
process wastewater containing the nonconventional pollutants
that are candidates for regulation. These facilities are,
therefore, not included in this table.
Facilities: 30339,30368,30369,30387,30524,30903, and 31057
* The air load reduction was calculated as the raw load minus the current load since the summation
of the air load reduction calculated through WATER 7 and the current load was equal to an amount
greater than the raw load.
** These pollutants were not modelled using WATER 7, so their air load reductions are listed as reported
in their questionnaire.
A-16
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis from Current to BAT Option 3 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
June 30,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 7/20/94)
Facility
Code
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
30010
308 Quest. BAT Option 2 Water Load
Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction
Code flbs/vr) (Ibs/vr) (Ibs/vr) (lbs/vr)
9
29
43
64
70
71
77
79
80
87
97
102
103
129
130
929,926
86,997
118,687
1,150
448,942
265,258
39,701
49,690
1,002
3,243
145,291
1,528,924
2,377
0
12,011
-158,804
2,844
0
0
0
12,409
0
577
109
2,027
0
14,972
634
0
0
2,385
1,955
0
0
0
1,955
0
577
109
20
0
39
634
0
0
156,419
889
0
0
0
10,454
0
0
0
2,007
0
14,933
0
0
0
Air Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
771,122 *
23,000 **
116,952
17
330,602
237,564
7
1,784
138
1,216 *
50,699
1,505,756
1,743 *
0
11,793
Total
Total Organics
3,633,199
192,376
50,652
24,995
7,673
184,703 3,052,393
30050
30050
94
97
28,790
21,862
24,995
0
8
0
24,987
0
3,795 *
10,306
24,987
14,101
30060
30060
30060
30060
30060
30060
30060
9
79
94
97
114
124
118
7,000
300
150
150
9,000
50
8,400
7,000
300
150
150
9,000
50
8,400
37
21
3
31
1
1
3
6,963
279
147
119
8,999
49
8,397
0 *
0 *
0*
0*
0*
0 *
0*
Total
25,050
25,050
96
24,954
30159
30159
30159
30159
30159
30159
30159
43
58
62
70
71
82
94
128
530
0
163
16
131
480
1
14
0
1
1
4 .
9
1
14
0 .
1
1
4
9
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
43
71
0
5
1
8
13
A-17
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis from Current to BAT Option 3 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
June 30,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 7/20/94)
308 Quest. BAT Option 2 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
(Ibs/vrt flbs/vrt (lbs/vr)
30159 96
30159 97
30159 124
30159 129
30159 130
30159 139
30159 77
30159 118
30227 9
30227 70
30227 79
30227 114
30345 43
30345 71
30345 94
30345 97
30345 99
30345 118
30345 130
30347 118
30487 37
30487 43
30487 51
30487 61
30487 64
30487 66
30487 70
30487 71
78
515
0
0
139
139
1,998
1,004
5321
4
15,357
500
1,370
17,227
156,499
207,348
2,472,281
1,890,354
479,484
10,790
932
5.217,688
113,906
113,906
5,679
13,083
16
21,177
80,646
87,992
90,719
346,650
1
4
0
0
2
12
39
18
106
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1,007
0
25
0
1,032
1,320
1,320
46
0
3
756
136
5,040
1,454
0
1
4
0
0
2
3
39
15
94
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
.0
161
0
16
0
177
1
1
1
0
1
6
1
121
61
0
0
0
0
0
0
9
0
3
12
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
846
0
9
0
855
1,319
1,319
45
0
2
750
135
4,919
1,393
0
16
5
0
0
31
31
0
19
243
0
133
0
0
133
155,035
189,436
1,538,043
787,054
478,179
8,014
926
3,156,687
109,786
109,786
15
0
10
244
44
2,562
468
0
A-18
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis from Current to BAT Option 3 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
June 30,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 7/20/94)
Facility
Code
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
30487
Poll.
Code
80
87
93
94
97
102
118
129
130
136
139
Total Organics
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
30540
Total
30542
30542
30542
30542
30542
CN-
9
43
70
71
79
94
95
97
103
106
118
139
60
37
113
58
CN-
9
3
10
12
Raw Loadings
(lbs/vr)
2,335
2,106
8,501
1,094,906
1,066,087
38,985
964,267
33,648
593,080
6,615
2,693
4,459,185
312
235,967
5,460
923,729
545,623
1,450
361,063
527,801
931,289
605,573
98,800
601,730
719,794
7,460
695
728
780
5,567,942
16,082
453,800
8,700
3,578
36,400
308 Quest.
Current Load
(Ibs/vr)
0
0
0
5,050
1,714
0
0
0
1,442
0
0
15,641
1
17,600
50
180
10,698
218
7,221
10,556
0
9,209
48,800
1,730
850
746
0
0
0
107,858
3
420,000
3,400
3,578
0
BAT Option 2
Proposed Load
abs/vr)
0
0
0
6
61
0
0
0
1
0
0
259
1
1,282
21
180
1,051
218
105
1,051
0
1,051
105
105
21
23
0
0
0
5,215
2
12,835
105
3,578
0
Water Load
Reduction
abs/vr)
0
0
0
5,044
1,653
0
0
0
1,441
0
0
15,382
0
16,318
29
0
9,647
0
7,116
9,505
0
8,158
48,695
1,625
829
723
0
0
0
102,643
1
407,165
3,295
0
0
Air Load
Reduction
Gbs/vr)
0
0
0
1,442
1,932
0
0
0
1,624
0
0
8,341
0
218,367 *
5,356
426,016
399,262
17
104,832
455,425
134,119
596,364 *
1,103
250,257
694,593
2,333
675
524 **
660
3,289,903
0
3,757
20
0 *
11
A-19
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis from Current to BAT Option 3 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
June 30,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 7/20/94)
308 Quest. BAT Option 2 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code (Ibs/vr)
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis from Current to BAT Option 3 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
June 30,1994 Version (QA/QC MKW 7/20/94)
Facility
Code
30600
30600
Total
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
30623
Poll.
Code
102
118
CN-
25
37
39
51
58
64
70
79
84
87
97
102
118
124
129
130
136
Total Orj*anics
30701
30701
30701
30701
30701
30701
30701
37
43
51
70
71
118
130
Total Or^anics
30762
30762
30762
9
3
11
Raw Loadings
abs/vr)
0
46,381
358,360
17
12,868
23,466
1,410
50,983
21,054
1,088,822
865,209
95,260
0
997,106
977,715
237,957
48,066
3,500
39,598
76,038
12,065
4,551,117
371,245
26,455
103,616
906,753
879,635
989,204
268,961
3,545,869
632,000
896,000
54,000
308 Quest.
Current Load
abs/vr)
0
7,433
317,079
17
143
172
70
315
86
0
0
86
0
0
143
315
1,087
0
1,892
86
0
4,395
880
0
103,616
661
0
1,543
0
106,700
30,000
4,900
53,000
BAT Option 2
Proposed Load
Gbs/vr)
0
15
356
2
59
12
59
12
59
0
0
86
0
0
143
12
59
0
85
12
0
596
27
0
27
661
0
135
0
849
439
4
360
Water Load
Reduction
abs/vr)
0
7,418
316,723
15
84
160
11
303
27
0
0
0
0
0
0
303
1,028
0
1,807
74
0
3,799
853
0
103,589
0
0
1,408
0
105,851
29,561
4,896
52,640
Air Load
Reduction
abs/vr)
0
38,948 *
41,281
0
11,463
22,934
1,340 *
49,279
19,596
15,716
621,165
3,182
0
989,635
324,907
233,373
32,581
2,208
30,939
73,904
10,609
2,442,831
79,786
6,505
0*
27,939
65,340
27,466
43,821
250,857
0
100
1,000
A-21
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis from Current to BAT Option 3 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Facilities
June 30,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 7/20/94)
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings
308 Quest. BAT Option 2 Water Load Air Load
Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
(lbs/vr) flbs/vrt Qbs/yr)
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
30762
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
31040
43
51
58
64
70
71
87
94
97
102
124
130
136
3
11
10
25
35
37
43
58
60
64
66
70
71
80
82
84
87
94
95
97
99
102
114
118
124
19,200
431,500
242,400
3,400,800
422,500
965,000
827,930
428,950
21,414,000
6,148,000
609,300
2,330,000
408,600
39,230,180
22,104
0
330,293
0
10,959
0
0
207
0
38
0
220
75
0
2,125
0
143
143
0
49,619
5,879
1,131
354,350
2,740
5,079
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
9,100
0
0
0
97,000
720
0
2,493
0
0
0
0
207
0
38
0
0
75
0
0
0
143
143
0
2,673
0
1,131
0
171
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
7
0
0
0
810
18
0
1,775
0
0
0
0
178
0
38
0
0
75
0
0
0
18
143
0
1,775
0
36
0
171
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
9,093
0
0
0
96,190
702
0
718
0
0
0
0
29
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
125
0
0
898
0
1,095
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
100
0
0
0
1,200
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
A-22
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis from Current to BAT Option 3 (Appendix A)
A/C Direct Discharge Faculties
June 30,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 7/20/94)
308 Quest. BAT Option 2
Facility Poll.
Code Code
31040
31040
31040
31040
Total Organics
31056
31056
31056
31056
31056
Total Organics
129
130
136
139
15
94
97
118
130
Raw Loadings
(Ibs/vr)
816
689
0
1,530
788,140
1,700
91,000
203,200
2,293,200
226,600
2,815,700
Current Load Proposed Load
(lbs/vr)
816
689
0
1,530
10,829
0
0
0
0
0
0
(Ibs/vr)
256
36
0
36
4,553
0
0
0
0
0
0
Water Load
Reduction
abs/vr)
560
653
0
1,494
6,276
0
0
0
0
0
0
Air Load
Reduction
abs/yr)
0
0
0
0
0
789
30,705
54,927
927,382
99,029
1,112,832
Total A/C Organics 77,865,048 5,133,604 109,098 5,024,506 13,496,774
for Directs (Ib/yr)
Total Cyanide 41,733 45 6 39 0
Ob/yr)
Footnotes:
(1) The process wastewater flow for facility 30542 has been
adjusted to better reflect their process flow without the use
of barometric condensers.
(2) The following A/C direct facilities do not discharge
process wastewater containing the nonconventional pollutants
that are candidates for regulation. These facilities are,
therefore, not included in this table.
Facilities: 30339,30368,30369,30387,30524,30903, and 31057
* The air load reduction was calculated as the raw load minus the current load since the summation
of the air load reduction calculated through WATER 7 and the current load was equal to an amount
greater than the raw load.
** These pollutants were not modelled using WATER 7, so their air load reductions are listed as reported
in their questionnaire.
A-23
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for BAT Option 1 (Appendix A)
B/D Direct Discharge Facilities
July 8,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 7/20/94)
Facility Poll.
Code Code
30029 94
Total Organics
30167 9
30167 27
30167 70
30167 94
30167 97
Total Organics
30282 70
30282 79
30282 94
30282 97
30282 114
30282 115
30282 118
Total Organics
30299 102
Total Organics
30410 70
30410 114
Total Orgfltt'cs
30527 70
Total Organics
30631 9
30631 3
30631 70
30631 79
30631 94
30631 97
Raw Loadings
abs/vr)
22,500
22,500
0
0
16,325
678
360
17,363
377
229
281
98
0
200
8
1,193
25
25
50,000
5
50,005
832
832
28
0
0
1
14,560
0
308 Quest.
Current Load
abs/vr)
0
0
0
0
7,450
0
0
7,450
377
229
281
98
0
200
8
1,193
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
14,560
0
BAT Option 1
Proposed Load
abs/vr)
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
1
. 185
63
52
98
0
200
8
605
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
11
0
Water Load
Reduction
abs/vr)
0
0
0
0
7,449
0
0
7,449
192
166
229
0
0
0
0
588
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
14,549
0
A-24
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for BAT Option 1 (Appendix A)
B/D Direct Discharge Facilities
July 8,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 7/20/94)
308 Quest. BAT Option 1 Water Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction
.Code Code (lbs/vr) (lbs/yr) (lbs/vr) (lbs/vr)
30631 102
30631 130
Total Organics
30664 94
30664 114
30664 118
Total Organics
0
0
14,561
653
1,806
146
2,605
0
0
14,560
0
0
0
0
0
0
11
0
0
0
0
0
0
14,549
0
0
0
0
30789 70 140 27
Total Organics 140 27
Total B/D Organics 109,224 23,230
for Directs Qb/yr)
Total Ammonium 28 0
Hydroxide (Ib/yr)
Footnotes:
(1) Facilities 30527 and 31142 are cofreaters; ie. use the same
treatment system. Therefore they have been combined on this table
to avoid any double counting.
(2) The following B/D direct facilities do not discharge process
wastewater containing the nonconventional pollutants that are
candidates for regulation. These facilities are, therefore,
not included in this table.
Facilities: 30188,30235,30277,30350, and 31142
620
0
24
24
22,610
0
A-25
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for New BAT Option 2 (Appendix A)
B/D Direct Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest. BAT Option 2a Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code (Ibs/yr) (Ibs/yr) (lbs/vr) Qbs/yr) (Ibs/yr)
30029
Total
30167
30167
30167
30167
30167
Total
30282
30282
30282
30282
30282
30282
30282
Total
30299
Total
30410
30410
Total
30527
Total
30631
30631
30631
30631
30631
30631
94
9
27
70
94
97
70
79
94
97
114
115
118
102
70
114
70
9
3
70
79
94
97
22,500
22500
0
0
16,325
678
360
17,363
377
229
281
98
0
200
8
1 193
25
25
50,000
5
50,005
832
832
28
0
0
1
14,560
0
0
0
0
0
7,450
0
0
7,450
377
229
281
98
0
200
8
1,193
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
14,560
.0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
1
142
63
9
92
0
200
8
515
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0
0
0
0
0
7,449
0
0
7,449
235
166
272
6
0
0
0
678
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
14,558
0
5,977
5,977
0
0
2,888
37
29
2,954
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0
0
0 *
0
25
25
12,837
0
12,837
305
305
28
0
0
0
0 *
0
A-26
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for New BAT Option 2 (Appendix A)
B/D Direct Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest BAT Option 2a Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code (Ibs/yr) Qbs/yr) Qbs/yr) (Ibs/yr) (Ibs/yr)
30631
30631
Total
30664
30664
30664
Total
30789
Total
102
130
94
114
118
70
Total B/D Directs
db/yr)
0
0
14,589
653
1,806
146
2,605
140
140
109,252
0
0
14,560
0
0
0
0
27
27
23,230
0
0
2
0
0
0
0
2
2
520
0
0
14,558
0
0
0
0
25
25
22,710
0
0
28
300
1
14
315
1
1
22,442
Footnotes:
(1) Facilities 30527 and 31142 are cotreaters; ie. use the same
treatment system. Therefore they have been combined on this table
to avoid any double counting.
(2) The following B/D direct facilities do not discharge process
wastewater containing the nonconventional pollutants that are
candidates for regulation. These facilities are, therefore,
not included in this table.
Facflities: 30188,30235,30277,30350, and 31142
* The air load reduction was calculated as the raw load minus the current load since the summation
of the air load reduction calculated through WATER7 and the current load was equal to an amount
greater than the raw load.
A-27
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for BAT Option 3 (Appendix A)
B/D Direct Discharge Facilities
July 8,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 7/20/94)
308 Quest. BAT Option 2 Water Load Airload
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code
30029 94
30167 9
30167 27
30167 70
30167 94
30167 97
30282 70
30282 79
30282 94
30282 97
30282 114
30282 115
30282 118
30299 102
Total Orsanics
30410 70
30410 114
30527 70
30631 9
30631 3
30631 70
30631 79
30631 94
30631 97
(lbs/vr)
22,500
22,500
0
0
16,325
678
360
17,363
377
229
281
98
0
200
8
1,193
25
25
50,000
5
50,005
832
832
28
0
0
1
14,560
0
flhs/vr> (Ibsfvf) abs/vr) flbs/ST)
0
0
0
0
7,450
0
0
7,450
377
229
281
98
0
200
8
1,193
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
14,560
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
1
92
63
9
92
0
200
8
465
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0
0
0
0
0
7,449 .
0
0
7,449
285
166
272
6
0
0
0
728
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
14,558
0
0
0
0
0
2,888
37
29
2,954
0 *
0 *
0 *
0*
0
0
0*
0
25
25
12,837
0
12,837
305
305
28
0
0
0
0 *
0
A-28
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for BAT Option 3 (Appendix A)
B/D Direct Discharge Facilities
July 8,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 7/20/94)
308 Quest. BAT Option 2 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code (Ibs/vr) (lbs/vr) (lbs/vr) flbs/vr) (Ibs/vrt
30631 102
30631 130
Total
30664 94
30664 114
30664 118
Total Organics
30789 70
Total Organics
Total B/D Directs
db/yr)
Total Ammonium
Hydroxide (Ib/yr)
0
0
14,589
653
1,806
146
2,605
140
140
109,252
28
0
0
14,560
0
0
0
0
27
27
23,230
0
0
0
2
0
0
0
0
1
1
468
0
0
0
14,558
0
0
0
0
26
26
22,762
0
0
0
28
300
1
14
315
1
1
16,465
28
Footnotes:
(1) Facilities 30527 and 31142 are cotreaters; ie. use the same
treatment system. Therefore they have been combined on this table
to avoid any double counting.
(2) The following B/D direct facilities do not discharge process
wastewater containing the nonconventional pollutants that are
candidates for regulation. These facilities are, therefore,
not included in this table.
Facilities: 30188,30235,30277,30350, and 31142
*_The air load reduction was calculated as the raw load minus the current load since the summation
of the air load reduction calculated through WATER7 and the current load was equal to an amount
greater than the raw load.
A-29
-------
-------
APPENDIX B
POLLUTANT LOADINGS AND BJEDUCTIONS FOR
INDIRECT DISCHARGERS
B-l
-------
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
Facility
Code
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
Total Organics
30031
Total Organics
30033 x
30033
30033
30033
30033
30033
30033
30033
Total Organics
30047 .
30047
30047
30047 -
30047
30047
30047
30047
30047
Poll.
Code
9
3
27
64
70
94
97
101
102
105
118
136
70
77
94
95
97
101
117
118
129
9
27
66
67
70
71
77
79
94.
Raw Loadings
(lbs/yr)
1,485
56,590
212,390
64,050
9,730
1,444,650
382,797
996,660
3
383,040
1,900
97,077
3,648,886
5,100
5,100
179,079
943,365
153,952
496,894
745,772
1,778
179,349
215,310
2,915,499
3
1
17
1
395
1
9
1
3,463
308 Quest
Current Load
(lbs/vr)
0
26,500
16,200
6,407
0
73,160
340,400
442,700
0
1,300
1,900
4,852
913,419
100
100
219
22,005
18
354
1,072
0
49
150
23,867
3
1
17
1
395
1
9
1
3,463
PSES Option la
Proposed Load
(Ibs/vr)
0
26,500
16,200
6,407
0
73,160
340,400
1,441
0
1,300
1,900
4,852
472,160
59
59
219
22,005
18
354
340
0
49
150
23,135
3
1
17
1
395
1
9
1
3,463
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/yr)
0
0
(0)
0
0
(0)
(0)
441,259
0
(0)
(0)
(0)
441,259
41
41
0
(0)
0
0
732
0
0
0
732
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
(0)
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
1,173
0 **
101,947
0**
4,184
457,376
42,397 *
478,397
3
183,859
Q *
43,685
1,311,848
0
0
0 **
1,415
119,328
397,515
578,048
1,378
147,066
166,887
1,411,637
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-3
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest. PSES Option la Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
30047
30047
30047
30067
30071
30071
30071
30071
30071
30071
30071
30071
30071
30071
30071
30071
TTotfll Orpfmics
30094
30094
30094
30094
30094
30094
30094
30094
30094
Total Qrpatiics
30107
97
117
136
118
9
27
51
55
64
67
70
71
94
97
102
130
9
51
58
70
94
97
102
118
130
9
Obs/vr)
54
2
2
3,945
39
39
4,230
231
2,003
35,420
7,193
5,830
47,724
30,375
8,378
204,125
3,845
41,810
386 934
5
10
50
6,200
5,000
1,600
500
1,200
1
14561
73,798
flbs/vf)
54
2
2
3,945
39
39
0
231
2,003
35,420
7,193
5,830
47,724
30,375
8,378
204,125
3,845
41,810
386,934
5
10
50
6,200
5,000
1,600
500
1,200
1
14,561
66,843
Obs/vr)
54
2
2
3,945
18
18
0
231
2,003
3,338
7,193
5,830
47,724
3,338
8,378
204,125
111
145
282,415
5
10
50
6,200
5,000
1,600
77
1,200
1
14,137
2,570
Reduction Reduction
abs/vrt abs/vr)
0
0
0
0
21
21
0
0
0
32,082
0
(0)
(0)
27,037
(0)
(0)
3,734
41,665
104,519
0
0
0
(0)
(0)
0
423
0
0
424
64,273
0
0
0
0
0
0
3,308
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-4
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
Facility
Code
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
308 Quest PSES Option la Water Load Air Load
Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code (lbs/yr) (lbs/yr) (lbs/vr) (Ibs/vr) (Ibs/vr)
35
48
64
70
82
94
95
97
99
101
102
118
124
130
136
139
1,123
2,199
19,074
233,585
30
112,852
126
1,672
5,557
739
4,213
62,068
209
450
25,791
599
1,123
2,199
19,074
233,585
0
112,852
126
1,672
0
739
4,213
62,068
0
450
0
599
26
779
19,074
91,114
0
19,806
126
1,672
0
130
26
779
0
34
0
26
1,097
1,420
0
142,471
0
93,046
0
0
0
609
4,187
61,289
0
416
0
573
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Total Organics
Total Organics
Total Organics
Total Organics
470,287
438,700
133,591
305,109
30110
30110
30110
30110
30110
30110
30110
30110
51
70
79
97
102
103
118
130
81
173
7,814
1,683
142
25,916
1,564
660
81
173
0
1,683
142
0
1,564
660
81
173
0
1,683
26
0
785
34
0
0
0
0
116 .
0
779
626
0
0
0 **
0
0
-5 •
0
0
38,033
4,303
2,782
1,521
30117
30117
30117
3
97
118
200
2,001
2,000
200
2,001
2,000
200
2,001
177
0
0
1,823
0
0
0
4,201
4,201
1378
1,823
30119
30119
66
70
2
160
2
160
2
2
0
158
0
0
162
162
158
B-5
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest. PSES Option la Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141 -
30141
30141
30141
Total Organics
9
58
61
64
70
71
79
84
93
94
97
102
114
118
129
130
136
CN
9
3
29
70
71
79
84
94
97
99
102
105
118
129
130
139
(Ibs/vr) abs/vr) abs/yrt (lbs/vr)
109,125
250
5
555
114,700
11,555
1,760
10
830
57,630
229,512
4,760
4,060
' 40,505
6,810
11,805
1,055
485,802
7
98,520
5
5
13,055 ,
805
5
60
10,055
6,005
305
10
5,055
15,055
60
110
4,505
55,095
5
0
0
550
0
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
0
605
1
7,500
0
5
13,000
750
0
55
10,000
6,000
300
5
5,000
15,000
55
55
. 4,500
54.725
5
0
0
550
0
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
0
605
0
4,799
0
5
13,000
750
0
48
10,000
6,000
300
5
1,454
1,454
55
55
48
33,174
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2,701
0
0
(0)
0
0
7
(0)
(0)
0
0
3,546
13,546
0
0
4,452
21,551
(Ibs/yr)
103,669
230
3
0 **
113,553
10,977
0**
5 *
643
86
183,610
3,689
0**
33,214
5,278
11,451
907
363,646
0
11,696
0
0
55 *
21
0
4
55
5 *
5 *
1
55 *
55 *
1
7
5 *
269
B-6
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest PSES Option la Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code (Ibs/yr) (Ibs/vr) (Ibs/vr) (Ibs/yr) (lbs/yr)
30172
Total Organics
30197
30197
Total Organics
30228
30228
Total Organics
30229
30229
30229
30229
Total Organics
30233
30233
Total Organics
30314
Total Organics
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
97
12
139
118
130
70
77
79
94
70
114
70
9
12
25
27
29
37
62
64
70
29,963
29,963
15
10
25
2,950
2,246
5,196
5
112
5
5
127
6,551
1,424
7,975
1,160
1,160
359,401
0
11,791
0
80,159
4,396
0
164,252
41,970
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
5
112
5
5
127
695
151
846
1,160
1,160
306,656
0
11,791
0
80,159
3,996
0
163,967
41,970
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
112
5
0
119
695
151
846
1,160
1,160
24,871
0
11,791
0
80,159
25
0
163,967
41,970
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
3
0
0
5
8
0
0
0
0
0
281,785
0
0
0
(0)
3,971
0
0
(0)
13,375
13,375
0
0
0
30
64
95
0
0
0
0
0
5,726
0 **
5,726
0
0
19,803
0
0
0
0 *
220
0
21
0 *
B-7
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest. PSES Option la
Facility
Code
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
Poll.
Code
71
84
87
93
94
96
97
102
103
114
118
124
129
130
136
Total Orsanics
30331
30331
30331
30331
30331
30331
30331
30331
30331
30331
30331
Total Organi
30360
30360
9
3
10
58
61
71
87
97
118
130
136
67
97
Total Organics
130366
30366
30366
43
94
97
Raw Loadings
abs/vr)
5
738
4,707
35,649
80,614
0
2,126,790
21,856
2,773
0
405,328
2,710
6,431
15,445
0
3 005 615
3,425
31,265
189,935
296,137
660,600
1,075,938
1,094,602
29,016
74,002
175,993
123,632
3,751,120
250
28
278
4,542
994,942
914,731
Current Load
abs/vr)
5
738
4,707
35,649
47,336
0
2,126,790
21,856
2,773
0
275,707
2,710
6,431
15,445
0
2,842,031
3,425
6
180,720
0
660,593
40,704
0
1,201
5,403
3
123,630
1,012,260
120
6
126
140
596,965
475,517
B-8
Proposed Load
Gbs/vr)
5
251
251
7,537
47,336
0
2,126,790
251
2,773
0
7,537
2,512
3,768
327
0
2,497,250
627
6
190
0
4,835
190
0
1,201
190
3
190
6,805
120
6
126
20
15,352
275,660
Water Load
Reduction
abs/vr)
(0)
487
4,456
28,112
(0)
0
(0)
21,605
(0)
0
268,170
198
2,663
15,118
0
344,781
2,798
0
180,530
0
655,758
40,514
0
0
5,213
0
123,440
1,005,455
0
0
0
120
581,613
199,857
Air Load
Reduction
abs/vr)
0 *
0*
0 *
0 *
530
0
0 *
0 *
0 *
0
4,175
0
0 *
0 *
0
4,946
0 *
0 **
9,215 *
273,819
7 *
968,928
1,094,355
17,295
60,686
171,246
2 *
2,595,552
130 *
22
152
227
10,374
3,325
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest. PSES Option la
Facility
Code
30366
30366
30366
30366
30366
Total Organics
30377
30377
30377
30377
Total Organics
30398
30398
30398
30398
30398
30398
30398
Total Organics
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code
102
118
129
130
139
67
70
94
114
9
70
94
95
97
118
130
9
27
55
60
64
71
94
97
102
105
115
118
136
139
(Ibs/yr)
12,905
290
5,988
148
10,070
1,943,616
0
15
361
30
406
41,189
149,076
507,625
10,322
620,096
7,030
3,000
U97,149
375,000
450
148,899
631,400
1,634
9,850
22,850
13,098
908,300
300
56,200
127,424
333,500
1,600
(lbs/vr)
2,581
145
5,988
148
8,820
1,090,304
0
15
361
30
406
37,846
149,076
507,625
10,322
620,096
7,030
3,000
1,297,149
0
150
147,400
631,300
1,100
8,500
21,000
499
143,500
145
56,200
63,600
329,000
1,500
(lbs/yr)
20
145
302
26
20
291,545
0
15
361
30
406
12,774
149,076
98,450
3,871
620,096
3,871
168
875,531
0
150
298
631,300
1,100
298
7,575
499
10
145
56,200
298
298
10
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
2,561
0
5,686
122
8,800
798,759
0
0
0
0
0
25,072
(0)
409,175
6,451
(0)
3,159
2,832
421,618
0
0
147,102
0
0
8,202
13,425
0
143,490
0
0
63,302
328,702
1,490
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/yr)
8,709
5
0 *
0 *
1,250 *
23,890
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
150
499
0 **
0 **
250
250
499
200
. 145
0
24
100
50
B-9
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MKW)
308 Quest PSES Option la Water Load Air Load
Faculty Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code Obs/vf)
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest. PSES Option la
Facility
Code
30528
Total Organics
30536
30536
Total Organics
30543
30543
30543
30543
30543
Total Organics
30557
30557
Total Organics
30607
30607
30607
30607
Total Organics
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code
130
9
3
9
70
94
97
102
9
70
9
94
97
130
9
25
26
39
62
77
84
(lbs/yr)
5
79,905
6,462
2,000
2,000
1,056
110
11
22
33
176
537
1,112
1,112
180
117,859
118,702
1,143
237,704
19,377
5,362
967
5,148
12,019
13,339
1,941
Obs/vr)
5
79,905
6,462
0
0
1,056
110
11
22
33
176
0
0
0
0
116,359
114,202
1,143
231,704
0
5,362
967
134
0
13,339
1,941
(lbs/yr)
1
13,635
376
0
0
1
31
7
22
0
59
0
0
0
0
4,456
80,008
8
84,472
0
2,371
59
2
0
13,339
2
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
4
66,270
6,086
0
0
1,055
79
4
0
33
117
0
0
0
0
111,903
34,194
1,135
147,232
0
2,991
908
132
0
0
1,939
Air Load
Reduction
(lbs/yr)
0
0
0
0
0
0 *
0 *
0
0
0 *
0
0
0
0
0
1,500
4,500
0
6,000
15
0 *
0
1
2
0*
0
B-ll
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest. PSES Option la Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code (Ibs/vrt
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
Facility
Code
Total Organics
30665
30665
30665
30665
30665
30665
30665
30665
Total Organics
30685
Total Organics
30690
30690
30690
30690
30690
30690
30690
30690
Total Organics
30704
30704
Total Organics
30722
30722
30722
Total Organics
Poll.
Code
9
37
67
79
94
114
115
118
79
9
70
94
97
117
118
130
139
9
94
70
94
97
Raw Loadings
(Ibs/vri
1,497,347
7
7
1
903
8
43
120
588
1,670
0
0
8,600
1,990
8,063
2,311
1,463
5,151
2,584
1,582
23,144
309,469
1
1
15,690
872
872
17,434
308 Quest.
Current Load
(Ibs/vr)
1,497,198
7
7
1
903
8
43
120
588
1,670
0
0
8,600
1,990
8,063
2,311
1,463
5,151
2,584
1,582
23,144
0
0
0
15,690
872
872
17,434
PSES Option la
Proposed Load
flbs/yr)
419,279
7
7
1
903
8
43
120
588
1,668
. 0
0
666
1,990
5,131
2,311
1,463
202
9
7
11,111
0
0
0
15,690
872
872
17,434
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
1,077,919
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0
0
7,934
0
2,932
0
0
4,949
2,575
1,575
12,033
0
0
0
(0)
0
0
0
Air Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
, 0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
293,996
0
0
0 *
0
0
0
B-13
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest PSES Option la Water Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code Code
30738
Total Organics
30741
30741
Total Organics
30756
30756
30756
Total Organics
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
94
70
115
79
94
97
3
10
11
27
37
55
64
66
70
71
84
87
94
95
96
97
99
101
102
115
118
129
130
136
139
(Ibs/yr)
15,853
15,853
21,180
516
21,696
100
200
174,911
175,211
26,326
444,557
1,036
1,002
204,315
169
44,621
37,524
493,438
14,222
14,350
1,162
400,469
9,226
6,130
1,438,398
103
12,519
1,165,026
7,631
2,935,237
63,085
109,150
1,070
245
(Ibs/yr)
15,853
15,853
21,180
516
21,696
100
200
174,911
175,211
1,316
22,228
52
50
204
17
4,462
3,752
24,672
712
717
58
20,024
461
613
71,920
10
626
8,155
763
293,523
3,154
110
107
12
(lbs/vr)
31
31
2,493
516
3,009
100
200
30,003
30,303
1,316
8,848
52
50
29
17
4,462
3,752
24,672
712
295
58
20,024
461
613
71,920
10
626
295
763
8,848
3,154
110
107
12
Reduction
(lbs/yr)
15,822
15,822
18,687
0
18,687
0
0
144,908
144,908
0
13,380
0
0
175
0
0
0
(0)
0
422
0
(0)
0
0
(0)
0
0
7,860
0
284,675
0
0
0
0
Air Load
Reduction
(ibs/vr)
0
0
0 *
0 *
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-14
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest PSES Option la Water Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code Code
flbs/vr)
abs/vr)
abs/vr)
Reduction
abs/vr)
Air Load
Reduction
Gbs/vr)
Total Organics
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
Total Organics
30793
30793
30793
Total Organics
30803
30803
30803
30803 -
30803
30803
30803
30803
30803
CN
9
3
12
15
25
29
35
48
64
70
77
94
97
102
118
124
129
130
70
94
102
37
66
70
71
84
95
97
102
130
7,431,011
981
26,400
241,000
4,400
121,400
130
8,400
2,500
19,300
12,600
160,000
123,000
60,000
3,699,000
240,000
259,700
2,700
5,100
20,200
4,979,430
16,042
48,200
11,169
75,411
1,016
737
75
66
100
25
3,432
50
0
457,718
981
26,400
241,000
4,400
120,200
130
8,400
2,500
19,300
12,600
160,000
123,000
60,000
3,699,000
240,000
259,700
2,700
5,100
20,000
4,978,030
9,342
6,500
169
16,011
0
737
75
44
100
25
3,432
50
0
151,205
38
24,919
241,000
4,400
252
130
8,400
252
7,551
12,600
160,000
123,000
60,000
3,448,345
252
7,551
2,517
3,776
327
4,080,352
9,342
6,500
14
15,856
0
737
75
44
9
25
3,432
9
0
306,513
943
1,481
0
(0)
119,948
0
(0)
2,248
11,749
0
(0)
0
(0)
250,655
239,748
252,149
183
1,324
19,673
897,678
(0)
(0)
155
155
0
0
0
0
91
0
(0)
41
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
5
14
3
23
0
0
0
0
0
0
0*
0
0
B-15
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest PSES Option la Water Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code Code
(lbs/vr)
(Ibs/yr)
abs/vr)
Air Load
Reduction Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
(Ibs/yr)
Total Organics
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
Total Orp3Tl'Cf
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
10
11
60
64
66
70
71
84
94
97
102
118
129
130
136
139
3
25
26
27
29
51
58
61
64
66
70
71
79
84
87
94
96
97
102
5,501
5,481
27,522
39,254
2,038
23,050
5,830
10,373
1,427
106,668
246,433
60,702
142,997
56,062
9,223
1,768
1,282
740,110
125,400
2,200
0
79,200
119,000
4,400
0
0
50,000
0
2,200
440,000
741,400
11,000
2,200
220,000
0
1,012,000
28,600
4,463
5,481
27,441
39,128
2,038
23,037
5,520
9,706
1,383
102,520
217,999
45,377
120,072
50,526
9,039
1,697
1,276
662,240
114,400
0
0
77,000
7,000
2,200
0
0
50,000
0
0
0
279,400
11,000
0
0
0
257,400
22,000
4,331
494
12,553
39,128
2,038
23,037
5,520
494
16
12,553
217,999
16
. 494
247
21
494
16
315,120
114,400
0
0
77,000
7,000
1,349
0
0
50,000
0
0
0
279,400
45
0
0
0
257,400
45
132
4,987
14,888
0
0
0
(0)
9,212
1,367
89,967
(0)
45,361
119,578
50,279
9,018
1,203
1,260
347,120
0
0
0
(0)
(0)
851
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
10,955
0
0
0
(0)
21,955
0
0 *
81
0 **
0 *
0**
310 *
667 *
44 *
4,148 *
28,434 *
15,325 *
22,925 *
5,536 *
184*
71 *
6 *
77,731
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-16
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest PSES Option la
Facility
Code
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
Total Organics
30851
30851
30851
30851
30851
Total Organics
30864
30864
30864
30864
30864
30864
30864
Total Organics
30884
30884
30884
30884
30884
30884
30884
30884
30884
30884
30884
Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code
117
118
124
129
130
136
139
CN
9
70
94
97
62
70
79
94
95
97
130
CN
29
35
43
66
70
71
80
94
97
102
(IbsAr)
6,000
94,600
0
160,600
257,400
22,000
132,000
3,510,200
35
40
805,494
1,309
101,792
908,595
111,000
15,000
0
11,000
2,000
7,000
7,000
153,000
74,026
4,424
79,194
17,240
200,284
1,267,295
58,257
173,584
17,290
273,029
27,582
dbs/yr)
6,000
0
0
0
4,400
0
6,600
837,400
0
0
782,336
1,273
99,000
882,609
10,000
10,000
0
10,000
1,000
5,000
5,000
41,000
84
0
100
0
200,084
145,903
113
688
101
48,290
0
(lbs/yr)
6,000
0
0
0
58
0
45
792,742
0
0
196,887
1,273
99,000
297,160
10,000
10,000
0
10,000
1,000
5,000
76
36,076
22
0
71
0
200,084
145,903
113
688
101
48,290
0
Water Load
Reduction
dbs/vr)
(0)
0
0
0
4,342
0
6,555
44,658
0
0
585,449
0
(0)
585,449
(0)
(0)
0
(0)
0
(0)
4,924
4,924
63
0
29
0
0
(0)
0
0
0
(0)
0
Air Load
Reduction
Obs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
23,158 *
36*
2,792 *
25,986
22
2
0
2
0
1
1
29
0
0
0
0
0
272,686
0
0
0
93,667
0
B-17
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MKW)
308 Quest PSES Option la Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code (Ibs/vrt flbs/vr> (lbs/vr) Obs/vr) (Ibs/vrt
30884
30884
30885
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910 -
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
129
130
79
CN
9
27
29
43
55
70
84
94
97
118
129
130
136
139
9
3
12
27
35
55
60
64
66
70
71
77
9,276
85,936
2.213,390
5
5
0
24,370
2,990
520
300
30,040
63,090
10
188,020
22,520
102,890
1,000
210
72,130
70
483,790
292
4,085
186
166,257
1,893
2,193
243
81
1,164
10,193
11,160
2,774
0
9,521
404,799
5
5
0
0
2,990
0
300
0
63,090
10
188,020
22,520
102,890
1,000
210
0
70
381,100
291
4,080
184
158,340
1,883
2,188
240
80
1,162
10,187
11,070
2,771
0
93
395,343
5
5
0
0
2,990
0
10
0
33,382
10
7,256
22,520
285
143
12
0
10
66,617
291
4,080
184
158,340
95
2,188
240
80
1,162
10,187
2,849
2,771
0
9,428
9,457
0
0
0
0
(0)
0
290
0
29,708
0
180,764
(0)
102,605
857
198
0
60
314,483
0
0
0
(0)
1,788
0
0
0
0
(0)
8,221
0
0
76,415
442,768
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1 *
0**
2 *
7,917 *
10 *
5 *
0 **
0**
0**
6*
90*
0 **
B-18
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MKW)
308 Quest. PSES Option la
Facility
Code
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
Total Organics
30918
30918
30918
30918
30918
30918
30918
30918
Total Organics
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code
79
84
94
95
97
102
105
124
129
130
134
136
9
27
66
70
79
94
97
130
9
37
58
60
64
66
67
71
87
97
102
118
124
(Ibs/vr)
155
11,971
44,370
2,863
180,676
2,625
548
1,265
1,916
25,932
5,770
2,350
480,670
47,060
50,897
464
47,250
100
4,601
630,940
4,276
738,528
732,486
132,790
370
6,118
84,859
14,320
18,221
51,768
1,564
516,995
96,453
201,561
52,553
(lbs/vr)
153
11,935
44,268
2,857
172,072
2,500
522
1,260
1,910
24,697
3,850
2,345
460,554
100
48,450
70
45,000
100
4,382
599,800
4,072
701,874
0
132,785
370
6,118
84,859
14,320
18,221
51,762
1,556
516,737
96,440
201,447
52,551
Gbs/vr)
153
95
44,268
2,849
172,072
95
522
950
1,424
123
95
2,345
407,165
100
48,450
70
45,000
100
4,382
340,238
32
438,272
0
5
370
6,118
84,859
14,320
18,221
1,488
50
516,738
50
1,488
496
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
11,840
(0)
8
(0)
2,405
0
310
486
24,574
3,755
0
53,389
0
(0)
0
(0)
0
(0)
259,562
4,040
263,602
0
132,780
(0)
0
0
0
(0)
50,274
1,506
(0)
96,390
199,958
52,055
Air Load
Reduction
Qbs/yr)
0**
36 *
102 *
6 *
8,604*
125 *
26 *
5 *
6 *
1,235 *
1,920 *
5 *
20,100
2,593
2,447 *
0**
432
0
30
2,063
122
5,094
40,360
5 *
0 *
0 *
0*
0*
0 *
6 *
8 *
258 *
13 *
114*
0
B-19
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest PSES Option la Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
30931
30931
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
129
136
9
27
55
64
67
70
84
94
97
102
105
117
118
124
136
9
3
12
25
37
51
64
66
70
71
79
80
87
94
97
99
Qbs/vr)
118,233
25,882
1.321,687
637,235
101,191
34,943
11,387
44,736
1,416,214
15,039
2,496,391
2,977,748
3,341,683
1,395,610
6,109
4,739,273
2,007
805,823
17,388,154
55,764
18,270
25,950
95
145,922
58
230,826
40,410
881,118
252,226
760
100,843
13,146
62,622
318,062
14,841
(lbs/vr)
118,172
25,881
1.321,219
0
130
0
0
250
50
10
50
510
20
10
0
150
5
25
1,210
39,862
1
1
0
39,763
0
454
0
114,170
20,116
0
1,651
0
4,419
4,421
0
flbs/yf)
744
1,488
646,434
0
130
0
0
250
50
10
50
510
20
10
0
150
5
25
1,210
10,812
1
1
0
11
0
454
0
114,170
3,276
0
1,651
0
4,419
4,421
0
Reduction Reduction
abs/vr)
117,428
24,393
674,785
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
29,050
0
(0)
0
39,752
0
0
0
(0)
16,840
0
0
0
(0)
(0)
0
(Ibs/yr)
61 *
1 *
466
503,416
48,572
16,773
0 **
21,473
608,972
9,926
790,357
458,573
2,940,681
669,893
2,932
1,277,234
963
362,620
7,208,969
15,902 *
0 **
20,114
74
106,159 *
45
0**
0 **
766,948 *
232,110 *
0 **
78,163
13,146
94
254,450
11,503
B-20
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
Facility
Code
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
Total Organics
30965
30965
30965
Total Organics
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
Total Organics
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
Poll.
Code
102
118
124
130
136
94
97
118
9
3
27
62
64
71
94
97
102
105
118
130
27
55
64
70
71
79
87
97
102
118
124
Raw Loadings
(lbs/vr)
60,860
1,396,453
108,320
1,759,472
12,037
5,442,289
282,890
32,158
9,775
324,823
1,060,800
4,400
184,800
8,155
0
2,200
446,600
297,000
387,200
396,000
541,200
2,200
2,269,755
172,575
65,652
54,433
505,145
328,904
29,649
343,512
670,795
519,832
864,341
151,243
308 Quest.
Current Load
(Ibs/yr)
23,000
137,932
82
29,888
17
375,914
16,973
1,162
391
18,526
0
4,400
184,800
8,155
0
2,200
446,600
204,600
387,200
396,000
541,200
2,200
2,177,355
171,174
32,826
29,077
38,538
27,533
29,649
2,128
633,157
38,466
193,920
150,875
PSES Option la
Proposed Load
(lbs/yr)
109
3,276
82
142
17
132,029
2,451
1,162
96
3,709
0
4,400
6,401
356
0
14
356
6,401
0
14
14
1
17,957
171,174
392
29,077
38,538
392
29,649
13
178,922
13
392
131
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
22,891
134,656
0
29,746
(0)
243,885
14,522
0
295
14,817
0
0
178,399
7,799
0
2,186
446,244
198,199
387,200
395,986
541,186
2,199
2,159,398
(0)
32,434
0
(0)
27,141
0
2,115
454,235
38,453
193,528
150,744
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/yr)
37,860 *
1,145,091
83,959
1,706,688
10,352
4,466,756
57,485
1,222
283
58,990
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-21
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest. PSES Option la Water Load Airload
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction -
Code Code
31029
Total Organics
31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
• 31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
Total Organics
31042
Total Organics
31053
31053
Total OrgrffNcs
31063
Total Organics
31092
31092
31092
31092
31092
31092
31092
31092
130
9
3
37
58
64
70
71
94
97
102
113
118
113
79
114
113
3
55
70
80
94
97
102
105
flbs/vri
23
3,706,104
480
10
17
64
63
1,056
8
429
2,065
26
168
60
3,966
260,445
260,445
356
10
366
318,182
318,182
27,373
1,215
5,635
78,234
10,887
1,457
98,632
15,738
abs/vr)
23
1,347,366
480
10
15
34
63
1,016
8
414
2,055
20
138
60
3,833
260,445
260,445
356
0
356
0
0
1,291
122
0
4,736
0
0
1,556
646
flbs/yr)
17
448,709
5
10
0
2
63
184
2
40
720
0
138
2
1,160
260,445
260,445
356
0
356
0
0
1,291
75
0
1,910
0
0
3
75
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest. PSES Option la Water Load Airload
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code (lbs/yr) (lbs/vr) (lbs/vr) (lbs/vr) (lbs/vr)
31092
Total Organics
31108
31108
31108
Total Organics
31110
31110
31110
31110
31110
Total Organics
31112
31112
Total Organics
31113
31113
31113
31113
31113'
Total Organics
31120
31120
31120
31120
31120
31120
118
9
61
136
9
70
97
117
130
71
130
9
55
94
97
118
9
11
27
70
94
97
44,585
283,756
2,575
776
5,905
6,681
3,023
45,961
51,000
3,974
7,025
107,960
0
120
120
8,192
5,817
54,134
4,410
6,734
71,095
122,000
23,400
680
440,900
13,900
182,100
246
8,597
0
0
0
0
3,023
45,961
51,000
3,974
7,025
107,960
0
120
120
0
47
54,134
4,410
6,734
65,325
0
23,400
680
440,900
13,900
182,000
75
3,429
0
0
0
0
145
5,125
20,002
3,974
2
29,102
0
11
11
0
47
7,202
4,410
283
11,942
0
7,508
680
34,540
7,508
134,813
171
5,168
0
0
0
0
2,878
40,836
30,998
(0)
7,023
78,858
0
109
109
0
0
46,932
(0)
6,451
53,383
0
15,892
0
406,360
6,392
47,187
18,686
138,071
2,446
512
5,078
5,590
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
6
1
0*
0 *
0 *
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-23
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
Facility
Poll.
Code Code
31120
31120
31120
31120
Total Organics
31121
31121
31121
31121
31121
Total Organics
31145
Total Organics
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
99
102
118
130
70
71
94
97
139
70
CN
9
3
26
60
64
70
71
77
94
97
102
114
115
118
124
Total Organics
31164
9
Raw Loadings
(Ibs/vr)
414,000
145,600
40,000
37,000
097,580
40,900
41,600
5,600
1,321,000
100
1,409,200
35,024
35024
17
17,636
30,617
414,459
300
100
1,518
40
10
9
177
1
0
29,440
153,979
3
630,653
150,266
308 Quest.
Current Load
flbs/vr)
0
136,600
40,000
37,000
874,480
0
0
0
0
0
0
31,134
31,134
17
2,636
30,617
414,459
300
100
1,518
30
10
9
147
1
0
29,440
153,949
3
630,583
17,751
PSES Option la
Proposed Load
abs/vrt
0
10
295
13
185,367
0
0
0
0
0
0
2,723
2,723
2
2,636
30,617
1,439
300
100
1,518
30
10
9
147
1
0
29,440
1,439
3
65,052
1,633
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
136,590
39,705
36,987
689,113
0
0
0
0
0
0
28,411
28,411
15
0
0
413,020
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
152,510
0
565,532
16,118
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
40,566
41,474
9
1,315,626
1
1,397,675
3,890
3,890
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
10
0
0
30
0
0
0
30
0
70
8,280
B-24
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
308 Quest. PSES Option la
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code Code
31164 10
31164 11
31164 27
31164 37
31164 60
31164 64
31164 66
31164 70
31164 71
31164 94
31164 97
31164 99
31164 102
31164 114
31164 129
31164 130
31164 136
Total Organics
A/C Organics
(Ib/yr) subtot. 1
(lb/yr) subtot. 2
(Ib/yr) Total
Total CN (Ib/yr)
Total Ammonium
Hydroxide (Ib/yr)
Grand Total
(Ibs/vr)
0
83,620
2,265
517
368,272
2,906
502,000
399,684
1,911
115,881
1,064,462
11,218
6,833
427
25,098
5,510
1,350
2,591,954
43,038,511
42,447,773
85,486,284
75,065
4,620,458
90,181,808
(lbs/vr)
0
83,620
2,265
517
368,272
2,906
502,000
399,684
1,911
115,881
1,064,462
0
6,833
427
25,098
5,510
1,350
2,580,736
19,972,725
12,677,101
32,649,827
1,084
530,851
33,181,762
(lbs/vr)
0
12,588
2,265
2
368,272
2,906
502,000
57,908
495
12,588
226,023
0
16
427
247
21
495
1,186,253
11,655,339
4,636,528
16,291,866
62
89,142
16,381,071
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
71,032
0
515
0
0
0
341,776
1,416
103,293
838,439
0
6,817
0
24,851
5,489
855
1,394,483
8,317,387
8,040,573
16,357,960
1,021
441,709
16,800,691
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
0
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
1,363
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
1,363
6,718,320
13,775,819
20,494,139
0
1,036,932
21,531,072
Footnotes:
(1) The following A/C indirect facilities do not discharge process
wastewater containing the pollutants that are candidates
for regulation. These facilities are, therefore, not included
in this table.
Facilities: 30199,30602,30648,30662,30668,30715,30719,30946,30989,31105
B-25
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 Version (MRW)
Facility
Code
308 Quest PSES Option la Water Load Air Load
Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code (Ibs/yr) (lbs/vr) (Ibs/vr) Qbs/vr) (Ibs/vr)
* The air load reduction was calculated as the raw load minus the current load since the summation
of the air load reduction calculated through WATER? and the current load was equal to an amount
greater than the raw load.
** The air load reduction was assumed to be 0 even if WATER? gave it a load reduction because the
constituent is not strippable.
B-26
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
Facility Poll.
. Code Code
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
Total Organics
30031
Total Organics
30033
30033
30033
30033
30033
30033
30033
30033
Total Organics
30047
30047
30047
30047
30047
30047
30047
30047
30047
9
3
27
64
70
94
97
101
102
105
118
136
70
77
94
95
97
101
117
118
129
9
27
66
67
70
71
77
79
94
Raw Loadings
Obs/yr)
1,485
56,590
212,390
64,050
9,730
1,444,650
382,797
996,660
3
383,040
1,900
97,077
3,648,886
5,100
5,100
179,079
943,365
153,952
496,894
745,772
1,778
179,349
215,310
2,915,499
3
1
17
1
395
1
9
1
3,463
308 Quest
Current Load
(lbs/yr)
0
26,500
16,200
6,407
0
73,160
340,400
442,700
0
1,300
1,900
4,852
913,419
100
100
219
22,005
18
354
1,072
0
49
150
23,867
3
1
17
1
395
1
9
1
3,463
PSES Option 1
Proposed Load
(Ibs/vr)
0
26,500
4,092
6,407
0
4,092
4,092
288
0
1,124
1,124
1,124
48,845
0
0
219
965
18
354
68
0
49
150
1,823
3
1
17
1
99
1
9
1
99
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
0
12,108
0
0
69,068
336,308
442,412
0
176
776
3,728
864,574
100
100
0
21,040
0
0
1,004
0
0
0
22,044
0
0
0
0
296
0
0
0
3,364
Air Load
Reduction
Obs/vr)
1,173
0 **
101,947
0 **
4,184
457,376
42,397 *
478,397
3
183,859
0*
43,685
1,311,848
0
0
0 **
1,415
119,328
397,515
578,048
1,378
147,066
166,887
1,411,637
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-27
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 1 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code (Ibs/vrt (lbs/vr) (Ibs/vr) Gbs/vr) Qbs/vr)
30047 97
30047 117
30047 136
30067 118
30071 9
30071 27
30071 51
30071 55
30071 64
30071 67
30071 70
30071 71
30071 94
30071 97
30071 102
30071 130
30094 9
30094 51
30094 58
30094 70
30094 94
30094 97
30094 102
30094 118
30094 130
30107 9
54
2
2
3,945
39
39
4,230
231
2,003
35,420
7,193
5,830
47,724
30,375
8,378
204,125
3,845
41,810
386,934
5
10
50
6,200
5,000
1,600
500
1,200
1
14,561
73,798
54
2
2
3,945
39
39
0
231
2,003
35,420
7,193
5,830
47,724
30,375
8,378
204,125
3,845
41,810
386,934
5
10
50
6,200
5,000
1,600
500
1,200
1
14,561
66,843
54
2
2
285
2
2
0
231
434
434
7,193
1,580
1,580
556
1,580
1,580
111
145
15.423
5
10
50
1,093
1,093
1,093
77
300
1
3,716
2,570
0
0
0
3,660
37
37
0
0
1,570
34,986
0
4,250
46,144
29,819
6,798
202,545
3,734
41,665
371,511
0
0
0
5,107
3,907
507
423
900
0
10,845
64,273
0
0
0
0
0
0
3,308
0*
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-28
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 1 Water Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code Code
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
Total Organics
30110
30110
30110
30110
30110
30110
30110
30110
Total Organics
30117
30117
30117
Total Organics
30119
30119
Total Organics
35
48
64
70
82
94
95
97
99
101
102
118
124
130
136
139
51
70
79
97
102
103
118
130
3
97
118
66
70
(Ibs/vr)
1,123
2,199
19,074
233,585
30
112,852
126
1,672
5,557
739
4,213
62,068
209
450
25,791
599
470,287
81
173
7,814
1,683
142
25,916
1,564
660
38,033
200
2,001
2,000
4,201
2
160
162
(Ibs/vri
1,123
2,199
19,074
233,585
0
112,852
126
1,672
0
739
4,213
62,068
0
450
0
599
438,700
81
173
0
1,683
142
0
1,564
660
4,303
200
2,001
2,000
4,201
2
160
162
(Ifos/vr)
26
101
19,074
369
0
369
126
369
0
26
26
101
0
34
0
26
20,64-6
81
173
0
372
26
0
102
34
788
200
84
23
307
2
0
2
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
1,097
2,098
0
233,216
0
112,483
0
1,303
0
713
4,187
61,967
0
416
0
573
418,054
0
0
0
1,311
116
0
1,462
626
3,515
0
1,917
1,977
3,894
0
160
160
Air Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 **
0
0
5
0
0
6
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-29
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 1 Water Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code Code
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
Total Organics
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
Total Organics
9
58
61
64
70
71
79
84
93
94
97
102
114
118
129
130
136
CN
9
3
29
70
71
79
84
94
97
99
102
105
118
129
130
139
abs/vr)
109,125
250
5
555
114,700
11,555
1,760
10
830
57,630
229,512
4,760
4,060
40,505
6,810
11,805
1,055
485,802
7
98,520
5
5
13,055
805
5
60
10,055
6,005
305
10
5,055
15,055
60
110
4,505
55,095
abs/vr)
5
0
0
550
0
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
0
605
1
7,500
0
5
13,000
750
0
55
10,000
6,000
300
5
5,000
15,000
55
55
4,500
54,725
Qbs/vr)
5
0
0
550
0
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
0
605
0
4,799
0
5
688
242
0
48
688
688
300
5
189
189
55
55
48
3,201
Reduction
abs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2,701
0
0
12,312
508
0
7
9,312
5,312
0
0
4,811
14,811
0
0
4,452
51,524
Air Load
Reduction
abs/vr)
103,669
230
3
0 **
113,553
10,977
0 **
5 *
643
86
183,610
3,689
0 **
33,214
5,278
11,451
907
363,646
0
11,696
0
0
55 *
21
0
4
55
5 *
5 *
1
55 *
55*
1
7
5 *
269
B-30
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest PSES Option 1 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code
30172
Total Organics
30228
30228
Total Organics
30229
30229
30229
30229
Total Organics
30233
30233
Total Organics
30314
Total Organics
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
97
118
130
70
77
79
94
70
114
70
9
12
25
27
29
37
62
64
70
71
84
87
93
94
(Ibs/vr)
29,963
29,963
2,950
2,246
5,196
5
112
5
5
127
6,551
1,424
7,975
1,160
1,160
359,401
0
11,791
0
80,159
4,396
0
164,252
41,970
5
738
4,707
35,649
80,614
(Ibs/yr)
0
0
0
0
0
5
112
5
5
127
695
151
846
1,160
1,160
306,656
0
11,791
0
80,159
3,996
0
163,967
41,970
5
738
4,707
35,649
47,336
Obs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
112
5
0
117
24
151
175
8
8
24,871
0
11,791
0
3,567
25
0
163,967
3,567
4
251
251
980
3,567
(lbs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
5
0
0
5
10
671
0
671
1,152
1,152
281,785
0
0
0
76,592
3,971
0
0
38,403
0
487
4,456
34,669
43,769
(lbs/yr)
13,375
13,375
30
64
95
0
0
0
0
0
5,726
0 **
5,726
0
0
19,803
0
0
0
0 *
220
0
21
0 *
0*
0 *
0 *
0 *
530
B-31
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings
30329 96
30329 97
30329 102
30329 103
. 30329 114
30329 118
30329 124
30329 129
30329 130
30329 136
30331 9
30331 3
30331 10
30331 58
30331 61
30331 71
30331 87
30331 97
30331 118
30331 130
30331 136
30360 67
30360 97
30366 43
30366 , 94
30366 97
30366 102
30366 118
30366 129
30366 130
30366 139
(lbs/yr)
0
2,126,790
21,856
2,773
0
405,328
2,710
6,431
15,445
0
3,005,615
3,425
31,265
189,935
296,137
660,600
1,075,938
1,094,602
29,016
74,002
175,993
123,632
3,751,120
250
28
278
4,542
994,942
914,731
12,905
290
5,988
148
10,070
308 Quest.
Current Load
Qbs/vr)
0
2,126,790
21,856
2,773
0
275,707
2,710
6,431
15,445
0
2,842,031
3,425
6
180,720
0
660,593
40,704
0
1,201
5,403
3
123,630
1,012,260
120
6
126
140
596,965
475,517
2,581
145
5,988
148
8,820
PSES Option 1
Proposed Load
(lbs/vr)
0
3,567
251
1,256
0
980
2,512
3,768
327
0
200,634
627
6
32
0
90
32
0
90
25
3
25
302
31
6
37
20
286
286
20
78
302
26
20
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
2,123,223
21,605
1,517
0
274,727
198
2,663
15,118
0
2,641,397
2,798
0
180,688
0
660,503
40,672
0
1,111
5,378
0
123,605
1,011,958
89
0
89
120
596,679
475,231
2,561
67
5,686
122
8,800
Air Load
Reduction
nbs/vr)
0
0 *
0 *
0 *
0
4,175
0 *
0 *
0 *
0
4,946
0 *
0 **
9,215 *
273,819
7 *
968,928
1,094,355
17,295
60,686
171,246
2 *
2,595,552
130 *
22
152
227
10,374
3,325
8,709
5
0*
0*
1,250 *
B-32
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 1
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code Code
Obs/vr)
(Ibs/vrt
(Ibs/yr)
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/yr)
Air Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
Total Organics
30377
30377
30377
30377
Total Organics
30398
30398
30398
30398
30398
30398
30398
Total Organics
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
Total Organics
30457
67
70
94
114
9
70
94
95
97
118
130
9
27
55
60
64
71
94
97
102
105
115
118
136
139
9
1,943,616
0
' 15
361
30
406
41,189
149,076
507,625
10,322
620,096
7,030
3,000
1,297,149
375,000
450
148,899
631,400
1,634
9,850
22,850
13,098
908,300
300
56,200
127,424
333,500
1,600
2,255,505
36,700
1,090,304
0
15
361
30
406
37,846
149,076
507,625
10,322
620,096
7,030
3,000
1,297,149
0
150
147,400
631,300
1,100
8,500
21,000
499
143,500
145
56,200
63,600
329,000
1,500
1,403,894
0
1,038
0
11
11
30
52
12,774
1,832
1,832
645
1,832
503
168
6,813
0
141
39
631,300
1,100
50
141
141
10
39
56,200
39
39
10
689,247
0
1,089,266
0
4
350
0
354
25,072
147,244
505,793
9,677
618,264
6,527
2,832
1,290,336
0
9
147,361
0
0
8,450
20,859
358
143,490
106
0
63,561
328,961
1,490
714,647
0
23,890
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
150
499
0 **
0 **
250
250
499
200
145
0
24
100
50
2,167
28,895
B-33
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 1 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30504
30504
30504
30504
30504
30504
30504
30504
30504
30504
30528
30528
30528
30528
Total Organics
30536
3
58
64
70
71
84
87
94
95
97
102
118
129
130
136
139
9
11
27
64
70
94
97
118
129
130
27
70
77
130
9
7,100
14,200
48,800
12,000
87,000
17,700
106,000
22,800
70,600
755,200
6,900
367,600
132,800
347,800
7,900
1,500
2,005,900
25,374
9,041
1,655
2,144
3,987
8,578
43,000
69,000
8,578
236
146,219
2,100
69,500
8,300
5
79905
6,462
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
31,700
200
0
0
2,900
0
0
34,800
0
9,041
1,655
2,144
3,987
8,578
43,000
69,00,0
8,578
236
146,219
2,100
69,500
8,300
5
79,905
6,462
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
100
7
0
0
9
0
0
116
0
584
584
2,144
584
584
584
160
617
53
5,894
13
13
8,300
1
8,327
376
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
31,600
193
0
0
2,891
0
0
34,684
0
8,457
1,071
0
3,403
7,994
42,416
68,840
7,961
183
140,325
2,087
69,487
0
4
71,578
6,086
0**
9,665
0 **
5,173
50,553
11,617
77,429
9,807
45,301
205,262
6,042
187,780
61,318
223,616
3,542
996
898,103
1,183
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-34
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest PSES Option 1
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code Code
30536
Total Organics
30543
30543
30543
30543
30543
Total Organics
30557
30557
Total Organics
30607
30607
30607
30607
Total Organics
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
3
9
70
94
97
102
9
70
9
94
97
130
9
25
26
39
62
77
84
94
97
102
118
130
(lbs/vr)
2,000
2,000
1,056
110
11
22
33
176
537
1,112
1,112
180
117,859
118,702
1,143
237,704
19,377
5,362
967
5,148
12,019
13,339
1,941
101,121
190,000
64
112,606
26,000
(lbs/yr)
0
0
1,056
110
11
22
33
176
0
0
0
0
116,359
114,202
1,143
231,704
0
5,362
967
134
0
13,339
1,941
101,121
190,000
64
112,606
26,000
(Ibs/yr)
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
83
83
8
173
0
510
10
2
0
13,339
2
28
28
2
8
3
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/yr)
0
0
1,055
110
11
22
33
176
0
0
0
0
116,276
114,119
1,135
231,531
0
4,852
957
132
0
0
1,939
101,093
189,972
62
112,598
25,997
Air Load
Reduction
Qbs/yr)
0
0
0 *
0 *
0
0
0 *
0
0
0
0
0
1,500
4,500
0
6,000
15
0*
0
1
2
0 *
0
0 *
0 *
0
0 *
0 *
B-35
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 1 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code abs/vrt (lbs/yr) (Ibs/vr) (lbs/vr) (lbs/vr)
30618
30618
30618
30618
30618
30618
30618
30618
30618
30618
30618
30618
Total Orpine"
30619
30619
30619
Total Qrpari'c*'
30639
30639
30639
30639
30639
30639
30639
30639
Total Orsanics
30665
30665
9
55
60
70
94
96
97
102
105
118
130
136
9
70
114
9
64
70
94
97
114
118
130
9
37
468,567
3,990
1,222
333,929
21,200
36,240
10,600
163,950
13,950
220,320
318,900
975
153,894
1,275 180
1,900
500
550
1050
252,006
50
1,411,290
958
70,000
149
11,300
3,600
1 497 347
7
7
451,534
0
0
0
21,200
35,940
10,350
163,500
13,200
219,570
318,400
825
42,420
825,405
1,900
500
550
1,050
0
50
1,411,290
958
70,000
0
11,300
3,600
1,497,198
7
7
B-36
13,930
0
0
0
750
750
206
750
53
206
206
69
206
3,198
1,900
377
550
927
0
50
1,397
958
1,397
0
384
128
4,312
7
7
437,604
0
0
0
20,450
35,190
-10,144
162,750
13,147
219,364
318,194
756
42,214
822,207
0
123
0
123
0
0
1,409,893
0
68,603
0
10,916
3,472
1,492.886
0
0
4
0
0
0
0
300
250
450
750
750
500
150
0
3,150
0*
0
0
0
189
0 .
0 *
0
0 *
0
0*
0 *
0
0
0
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 1
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code Code
30665
30665
30665
30665
30665
30665
Total Organics
30685
Total Organics
30690
30690
30690
30690
30690
30690
30690
30690
Total Organics
30704
30704
Total Organics
30722
30722
30722
Total Organics
30738
Total Organics
67
79
94
114
115
118
79
9
70
94
97
117
118
130
139
9
94
70
94
97
94
(lbs/vr)
1
903
8
43
120
588
1,670
0
0
8,600
1,990
8,063
2,311
1,463
5,151
2,584
1,582
23,144
309,469
1
1
15,690
872
872
17,434
15,853
15,853
(Ibs/vr)
1
903
8
43
120
588
1,670
0
0
8,600
1,990
8,063
2,311
1,463
5,151
2,584
1,582
23,144
0
0
0
15,690
872
872
17,434
15,853
15,853
(Ibs/yr)
1
903
8
43
120
373
1,453
0
0
666
95
95
95
95
26
9
7
424
0
0
0
100
100
100
300
1
1
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
215
217
0
0
7,934
1,895
7,968
2,216
1,368
5,125
2,575
1,575
22,720
0
0
0
15,590
772
111
17,134
15,852
15,852
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 *
0
0
0
0
0
B-37
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 1 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
30741
30741
30756
30756
30756
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
Total Organics
30767
30767
70
115
79
94
97
3
10
11
27
37
55
64 .
66
70
71
84
87
94
95
96
97
99
101
102
115
118
129
130
136
139
CN
9
flbs/vr)
21,180
516
21.696
100
200
174,911
175,211
26,326
444,557
1,036
1,002
204,315
169
44,621
37,524
493,438
14,222
14,350
1,162
400,469
9,226
6,130
1,438,398
103
12,519
1,165,026
7,631
2,935,237
63,085
109,150
1,070
245
7431,011
981
26,400
flbs/yr)
21,180
516
21,696
100
200
174,911
175,211
1,316
22,228
52
50
204
17
4,462
3,752
24,672
712
717
58
20,024
461
613
71,920
10
626
8,155
763
293,523
3,154
110
107
12
457,718
981
26,400
flbs/yr)
10
516
526
100
31
31
162
1,316
1,475
52
50
29
17
4,462
3,752
4,188
712
295
58
4,188
461
613
4,188
10
295
295
763
1,150
3,154
110
107
12
31,751
38
24,919
Reduction Reduction
flbs/vrt flbs/vr)
21,170
0
21.170
0
169
174,880
175.049
0
20,753
0
0
175
0
0
0
20,484
0
422
0
15,836
0
0
67,732
0
331
7,860
0
292,373
0
0
0
0
425,967
943
1,481
0 *
0 *
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-38
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 1
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code Code
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
Total Organics
30793
30793
30793
Total Organics
30803
30803
30803
30803
30803
30803
30803
30803
30803
Total Organics
30819
30819
3
12
15
25
29
35
48
64
70
77
94
97
102
118
124
129
130
70
94
102
37
66
70
71
84
95
97
102
130
10
11
(lbs/yr)
241,000
4,400
121,400
130
8,400
2,500
19,300
12,600
160,000
123,000
60,000
3,699,000
240,000
259,700
2,700
5,100
20,200
4,979,430
16,042
48,200
11,169
75,411
1,016
737
75
66
100
25
3,432
50
0
5,501
5,481
27,522
(Ibs/vr)
241,000
4,400
120,200
130
8,400
2,500
19,300
12,600
160,000
123,000
60,000
3,699,000
240,000
259,700
2,700
5,100
20,000
4,978,030
9,342
6,500
169
16,011
0
737
75
44
100
25
3,432
50
0
4,463
5,481
27,441
(Ibs/vr)
241,000
3,574
252
130
3,574
252
982
12,600
3,574
123,000
3,574
3,574
252
982
2,517
3,776
327
403,939
199
199
14
412
0
737
75
44
9
25
127
9
0
1,026
82
234
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
0
826
119,948
0
4,826
2,248
18,318
0
156,426
0
56,426
3,695,426
239,748
258,718
183
1,324
19,673
4,574,091
9,143
6,301
155
15,599
0
0
0
0
91
0
3,305
41
0
3,437
5,399
27,207
Air Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
5
14
3
23
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 *
0
0
0
0 *
81
B-39
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 1 Water Load Airload
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
•30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
60
64
66
70
71
84
94
97
102
118
129
130
136
n9
3
25
26
27
29
51
58
61
64
66
70
71
79
84
87
94
96
97
102
117
118
124
129
130
39,254
2,038
23,050
5,830
10,373
1,427
106,668
246,433
60,702
142,997
56,062
9,223
1,768
1,282
740,110
125,400
2,200
. 0
79,200
119,000
4,400
0
0
50,000
0
2,200
440,000
741,400
11,000
2,200
220,000
. 0
1,012,000
28,600
6,000
94,600
0
160,600
257,400
flbs/vrt
39,128
2,038
23,037
5,520
9,706
1,383
102,520
217,999
45,377
120,072
50,526
9,039
1,697
1,276
662,240
114,400
0
0
77,000
7,000
2,200
0
0
50,000
0
0
0
279,400
11,000
0
0
0
257,400
22,000
6,000
0
0
0
4,400
(Ibs/vr)
39,128
2,038
23,037
234
82
16
234
234
16
64
247
21
64
16
65,748
114,400
0
0
639
639
175
0
0
50,000
0
0
0
279,400
45
0
0
0
639
45
639
0
0
0
58
Reduction Reduction
flbs/vrt (Ibs/vr)
0
0
0
5,286
9,624
1,367
102,286
217,765
45,361
120,008
50,279
9,018
1,633
1,260
596,492
0
0
0
76,361
6,361
2,025
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
10,955
0
0
0
256,761
21,955
5,361
0
0
0
4,342
0 **
0 *
0 **
310 *
667 *
44 *
4,148 *
28,434 *
15,325 *
22,925 *
5,536 *
184 *
71 *
6 *
77,731
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-40
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
Facility Poll.
Code Code
30832 136
30832 139
Total Organics
30851 CN
30851 9
30851 70
30851 94
30851 97
Total Organics
30864 62
30864 70
30864 79
30864 94
30864 95
30864 97
30864 130
Total Organics
30884 CN
30884 29
30884 35
30884 43
30884 66
30884 70
30884 71
30884 80
30884 94
30884 97
30884 _. .102
30884 129
30884 130
Total Organics
Raw Loadings
(Ibs/vr)
22,000
132,000
3,510,200
35
40
805,494
1,309
101,792
908,595
111,000
15,000
0
11,000
2,000
7,000
7,000
153,000
74,026
4,424
79,194
17,240
200,284
1,267,295
58,257
173,584
17,290
273,029
27,582
9,276
85,936
2,213,390
308 Quest.
Current Load
Obs/vr)
0
6,600
837,400
0
0
782,336
1,273
99,000
882,609
10,000
10,000
0
10,000
1,000
5,000
5,000
41,000
84
0
100
0
200,084
145,903
113
688
101
48,290
0
0
9,521
404,799
PSES Option 1
Proposed Load
Obs/vr)
0
45
446,723
0
0
797
797
797
2,390
829
829
0
829
292
829
76
3,685
22
0
71
0
200,084
1,015
113
688
101
1,015
0
0
93
203.180
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
6,555
390,677
0
0
781,539
476
98,203
880,219
9,171
9,171
0
9,171
708
4,171
4,924
37,315
63
0
29
0
0
144,888
0
0
0
47,275
0
0
9,428
201.619
Air Load
Reduction
Obs/yr)
0
0
0
0
2
23,158 *
36 *
2,792 *
25,986
22
2
0
2
0
1
1
29
0
0
0
0
0
272,686
0
0
0
93,667
0
0
76,415
442,768
B-41
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Faculties
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 1 Water Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code Code
30885
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
79
CN
9
27
29
43
55
70
84
94
97
118
129
130
136
1^9
9
3
12
27
35
55
60
64
66
70
71
77
79
84
94
95
97
Qbs/vr)
5
5
0
24,370
2,990
520
300
30,040
63,090 .
10
188,020
22,520
102,890
1,000
210
72,130
70
483,790
292
4,085
186
166,257
1,893
2,193
243
81
1,164
10,193
11,160
2,774
155
11,971
44,370
2,863
180,676
Qbs/vr)
5
5
0
0
2,990
0
300
0
63,090
10
188,020
22,520
102,890
1,000
210
0
70
381,100
291
4,080
184
158,340
1,883
2,188
240
80
1,162
10,187
11,070
2,771
153
11,935
44,268
2,857
172,072
(Ibs/vrt
5
5
0
0
135
0
10
0
135
10
135
135
37
143
12
0
10
761
291
4,080
184
1,348
95
370
240
80
1,162
1,348
475
2,771
153
95
1,348
475
1,348
Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
0
0
0
0
2,855
0
290
0
62,955
0
187,885
22,385
102,853
857
198
0
60
380,339
0
0
0
156,992
1,788
1,818
0
0
0
8,839
10,595
0
0
11,840
42,920
2,382
170,724
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1 *
0 **
2*
7,917 *
10*
5 *
0**
0 **
0**
6*
90 *
0**
0 **
36 *
102 *
6 *
8,604 *
B-42
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest PSES Option 1
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code Code
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
Total Organics
30918
30918
30918
30918
30918
30918
30918
30918
Total Organics
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
Total Organics
102
105
124
129
130
134
136
9
27
66
70
79
94
97
130
9
37
58
60
64
66
67
71
87
97
102
118
124
129
136
(Ibs/vr)
2,625
548
1,265
1,916
25,932
5,770
2,350
480,670
47,060
50,897
464
47,250
100
4,601
630,940
4,276
738,528
732,486
132,790
370
6,118
84,859
14,320
18,221
51,768
1,564
516,995
96,453
201,561
52,553
118,233
25,882
1,321,687
(Ibs/yr)
2,500
522
1,260
1,910
24,697
3,850
2,345
460,554
100
48,450
70
45,000
100
4,382
599,800
4,072
701,874
0
132,785
370
6,118
84,859
14,320
18,221
51,762
1,556
516,737
96,440
201,447
52,551
118,172
25,881
1,321,219
(Ibs/vr)
95
370
950
1,424
123
95
370
19,001
100
353
70
353
100
353
353
32
1,613
0
5
193
6,118
84,859
14,320
704
248
50
704
50
193
496
744
193
108,879
Water Load
Reduction
Obs/vr)
2,405
152
310
486
24,574
3,755
1,975
441,553
0
48,097
0
44,647
0
4,029
599,447
4,040
700,261
0
132,780
176
0
0
0
17,516
51,514
1,506
516,033
96,390
201,253
52,055
117,428
25,688
1,212,341
Air Load
Reduction
Obs/vr)
125 *
26 *
5 *
6 *
1,235 *
1,920 *
5 *
20,100
2,593
2,447 *
0 **
432
0
30
2,063
122
5,094
40,360
5 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0*
0 *
6 *
8 *
258 *
13 *
114 *
0
61 *
1 *
466
B-43
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
Facility
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
Poll. Raw Loadings
Code
9
27
55
64
67
70
84
94
97
102
105
117
118
124
136
Total Orsanics
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
.30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954.
30954
30954
30954
30954
9
3
12
25
37
51
64
66
70
71
79
80
87
94
97
-. 99
102
118
124
130
136
Qbs/vr)
637,235
101,191
34,943
11,387
44,736
1,416,214
15,039
2,496,391
2,977,748
3,341,683
1,395,610
6,109
4,739,273
2,007
805,823
17 388 154
55,764
18,270
25,950
95
145,922
58
230,826
40,410
881,118
252,226
760
100,843
13,146
62,622
318,062
14,841
60,860
1,396,453
' 108,320
1,759,472
12,037
308 Quest
Current Load
(Ibs/vrt
0
130
0
0
250
50
10
50
510
20
10
0
150
5
25
1,210
39,862
1
1
0
39,763
0
454
0
114,170
20,116
0
1,651
0
4,419
4,421
0
23,000
137,932
82
29,888
17
PSES Option 1
Proposed Load
Qbs/vr)
0
130
0
0
250
50
10
50
339
20
10
0
93
5
25
982
10,812
1
1
0
11
0
454
0
1,551
546
0
1,551
0
1,551
1,551
0
109
426
82
142
16
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
171
0
0
0
57
0
0
228
29,050
0
0
0
39,752
0
0
0
112,619
19,570
0
100
0
2,868
2,870
0
22,891
137,506
0
29,746
0
Air Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
503,416
48,572
16,773
0 **
21,473
608,972
9,926
790,357
458,573
2,940,681
669,893
2,932
1,277,234
963
362,620
7,208,969
15,902 *
0 **
20,114
74
106,159 *
45
0 **
0**
766,948 *
232,110 *
0 **
78,163
13,146
94
254,450
11,503
37,860 *
1,145,091
83,959
1,706,688
10,352
B-44
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 1
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code Code
dbs/vr)
(lbs/yr)
(Ibs/vr)
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
Air Load
Reduction
(lbs/yr)
Total Organics
30965
30965
30965
Total Organics
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
Total Organics
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
Total Organics
31030
94
97
118
9
3
27
62
64
71
94
97
102
105
118
130
-
27
55
64
70
71
79
87
97
102
118
124
130
9
5,442,289
282,890
32,158
9,775
324,823
1,060,800
4,400
184,800
8,155
0
2,200
446,600
297,000
387,200
396,000
541,200
2,200
2,269,755
172,575
65,652
54,433
505,145
328,904
29,649
343,512
670,795
519,832
864,341
151,243
23
3,706,104
480
375,914
16,973
1,162
391
18,526
0
4,400
184,800
8,155
0
2,200
446,600
204,600
387,200
396,000
541,200
2,200
2,177,355
171,174
32,826
29,077
38,538
27,533
29,649
2,128
633,157
38,466
193,920
150,875
23
1,347,366
480
7,991
46
46
13
104
0
4,400
7
7
0
2
7
7
0
2
2
1
4,434
185
51
29,077
185
65
29,649
13
185
13
51
131
17
59,623
5
367,924
16,927
1,116
378
18,422
0
0
184,793
8,148
0
2,198
446,593
204,593
387,200
395,998
541,198
2,199
2,172,921
170,989
32,775
0
38,353
27,468
0
2,115
632,972
38,453
193,869
150,744
6
1,287,743
475
4,466,756
57,485
1,222
283
58,990
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-45
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest PSES Option 1 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code Code
31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
31042
Total Organics
31053
• 31053
Totsl Orcduics
31063
31092
31092
31092
31092
31092
31092
31092
31092
31092
Total OrgfNi'fis
31108
3
37
58
64
70
71
94
97
102
113
118
113
79
114
113
3
55
70
80
94
97
102
105
118
9
(Ibs/vrt
10
17
64
63
1,056
8
429
2,065
26
168
60
3,966
260,445
260445
356
10
366
318,182
318,182
27,373
1,215
5,635
78,234
10,887
1,457
98,632
15,738
44,585
283,756
2,575
(Ibs/vr)
10
15
34
63
1,016
8
414
2,055
20
138
60
3,833
260,445
260,445
356
0
356
0
0
1,291
122
0
4,736
0
0
1,556
646
246
8,597
0
abs/vr)
10
0
0
63
1
0
1
1
0
1
0
77
3,317
3,317
356
0
356
0
0
1,291
10
0
36
0
0
3
10
10
1,358
0
Reduction Reduction
abs/vr)
0
15
34
0
1,015
8
413
2,054
20
137
60
3,756
257,128
257,128
0
0
0
0
0
0
112
0
4,700
0
0
1,553
636
236
7,239
0
(lbs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 **
1,093 *
2,561
27,296
8,823
941
63,579
15,092 *
18,686
138,071
0
B-46
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 1
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code Code
31108
31108
Total Organics
31110
31110
31110
31110
31110
Total Organics
31112
31112
Total Organics
31.113
31113
31113
31113
31113
Total Organics
31120
31120
31120
31120
31120
31120
31120
31120
' 31120
31120
61
136
9
70
97
117
130
71
130
9
55
94
97
118
9
11
27
70
94
97
99
102
118
130
(lbs/vr)
776
5,905
6,681
3,023
45,961
51,000
3,974
7,025
107,960
0
120
120
8,192
5,817
54,134
4,410
6,734
71,095
122,000
23,400
680
440,900
13,900
182,100
414,000
145,600
40,000
37,000
abs/vr)
0
0
0
3,023
45,961
51,000
3,974
7,025
107,960
0
120
120
0
47
54,134
4,410
6,734
65,325
0
23,400
680
440,900
13,900
182,000
0
136,600
40,000
37,000
Qbs/vr)
0
0
0
145
21
21
21
2
64
0
11
11
0
37
134
134
37
342
0
140
140
140
140
140
0
10
38
13
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/yr)
0
0
0
2,878
45,940
50,979
3,953
7,023
107,896
0
109
109
0
10
54,000
4,276
6,697
64,983
0
23,260
540
440,760
13,760
181,860
0
136,590
39,962
36,987
Air Load
Reduction
abs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
6
1
0 *
0 *
0 *
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-47
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings
31121 70
31121 71
31121 94
31121 97
31121 139
31145 70
31163 CN
31163 9
31163 3
31163 26
31163 60
31163 64
31163 70
31163 71
31163 77
31163 94
31163 97
31163 102
31163 114
31163 115
31163 118
31163 124
31164 9
31164 10
31164 11
31164 27
31164 37
31164 60
1.297,580
40,900
41,600
5,600
1,321,000
100
1,409,200
35,024
17
17,636
30,617
414,459
300
100
1,518
40
10
9
177
1
0
29,440
153,979
3
630,653
150,266
0
83,620
2,265
517
368,272
308 Quest.
Current Load
874,480
0
0
0
0
0
0
31,134
31.134
17
2,636
30,617
414,459
300
100
1,518
30
10
9
147
1
0
29,440
153,949
3
630,583
17,751
0
83,620
2,265
517
368,272
PSES Option 1
Proposed Load
flbs/vr)
760
0
0
0
0
0
0
11
11
2
2,636
30,617
240
300
100
681
30
10
9
147
1
0
29,440
187
3
61,764
1,633
0
234
234
2
368,272
Water Load
Reduction
dbs/vr)
873,720
0
0
0
0
0
0
31,123
31,123
15
0
0
414,219
0
0
837
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
153,762
0
568,819
16,118
0
83,386
2,031
515
0
Air Load
Reduction
abs/vf)
0
40,566
41,474
9
1,315,626
1
1,397,675
3,890
3,890
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
10
0
0
30
0
0
0
30
0
70
8,280
0
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
B-48
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
308 Quest PSES Option 1
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code Code
31164 64
31164 66
31164 70
31164 71
31164 94
31164 97
31164 99
31164 102
31164 114
31164 129
31164 130
31164 136
Total Organics
A/C Organics
(Ib/yr) subtot 1
(lb/yr) subtot. 2
(lb/yr) Total
Total CN(lb/yr)
Total Ammonium
Hydroxide (lb/yr)
Grand Total
(Ibs/vr)
2,906
502,000
399,684
1,911
115,881
1,064,462
11,218
6,833
427
25,098
5,510
1,350
2,591,954
43,038,486
42,447,773
85,486,259
75,065
4,620,458
90,181,783
(lbs/yr)
2,906
502,000
399,684
1,911
115,881
1,064,462
0
6,833
427
25,098
5,510
1,350
2,580,736
19,972,725
12,677,101
32,649,826
1,084
530,851
33,181,761
(Ibs/vr)
2,906
502,000
234
82
234
234
0
16
427
247
21
64
875,210
1,983,407
1,355,916
3,339,323
62
89,142
3,428,527
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/yr)
0
0
399,450
1,829
115,647
1,064,228
0
6,817
0
24,851
5,489
1,286
1,705,526
17,989,318
11,321,185
29310,503
1,021
441,709
29,753,234
Air Load
Reduction
abs/vr)
0
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
1,363
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
1,363
6,718,320
13,770,229
20,488,549
0
740,490
21,229,040
Footnotes:
(1) The following A/C indirect facilities do not discharge process
wastewater containing the pollutants that are candidates
for regulation. These facilities are, therefore, not included
in this table.
Facilities: 30197,30199,30602,30648,30662,30668,30715,
30719,30946,30989, and 31105
* The air load reduction was calculated as the raw load minus the current load since the summation
of the air load reduction calculated through WATER7 and the current load was equal to an amount
greater than the raw load.
** The air load reduction was assumed to be 0 even if WAYER7 gave it a load reduction because the
B-49
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/4/94)
Facility
Code
Poll
Code
Raw Loadings
(Ibs/vr)
308 Quest
Current Load
flbs/vr)
PSES Option 1
Proposed Load
(Ibs/vr)
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/yr)
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
constituent is not strippable.
B-50
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
Facility
Code
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
30022
Total Organics
30031
Total Organics
30033
30033
30033
30033
30033
30033
30033
30033
Total Organics
30047
30047
30047
30047
30047
30047
30047
30047
30047
Poll.
Code
9
3
27
64
70
94
97
101
102
105
118
136
70
77
94
95
97
101
117
118
129
9
27
66
67
70
71
77
79
94
Raw Loadings
(lbs/yr)
1,485
56,590
212,390
64,050
9,730
1,444,650
382,797
996,660
3
383,040
1,900
97,077
3,648,886
5,100
5,100
179,079
943,365
153,952
496,894
745,772
1,778
179,349
215,310
2,915,499
3
1
17
1
395
1
9
1
3,463
308 Quest.
Current Load
(Ibs/vr)
0
26,500
16,200
6,407
0
73,160
340,400
442,700
0
1,300
1,900
4,852
913,419
100
100
219
22,005
18
354
1,072
0
49
150
23,867
3
1
17
1
395
1
9
1
3,463
PSES Option 2
Proposed Load
(lbs/yr)
0
26,500
144
32
0
144
1,441
1,441
0
14
144
144
30,005
0
0
219
34
18
340
340
. 0
34
49
1,033
3
1
17
1
35
1
9
1
3
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
0
16,056
6,375
0
73,016
338,959
441,259
0
1,286
1,756
4,708
883,414
100
100
0
21,971
0
14
732
0
15
101
22,834
0
0
0
0
360
0
0
0
3,460
Air Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
1,173
0**
101,947
0 **
4,184
457,376
42,397 *
478,397
3
183,859
0 *
43,685
1,311,848
0
0
0 **
1,415
119,328
397,515
578,048
1,378
147,066
166,887
1,411,637
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-51
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 2 Water Load
Facility Poll Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code Code
30047
30047
30047
Total Organics
30067
Total Organics
30071
30071
30071
30071
30071
30071
30071
30071
30071
30071
30071
30071
Total Organics
30094
30094
30094
30094
30094
30094
30094
30094
30094
Total Organics
30107
97
117
136
118
9
27
51
55
64
67
70
71
94
97
102
130
9
51
58
70
94
97
102
118
130
9
(Ibs/yr)
54
2
2
3.945
39
39
4,230
231
2,003
35,420
7,193
5,830
47,724
30,375
8,378
204,125
3,845
41,810
386,934
5
10
50
6,200
5,000
1,600
500
1,200
1
14,561
73,798
Qbs/yr)
54
2
2
3,945
39
39
0
231
2,003
35,420
7,193
5,830
47,724
30,375
8,378
204,125
3,845
41,810
386,934
5
10
50
6,200
5,000
1,600
500
1,200
1
14,561
66,843
Clbs/vr)
35
2
2
106
0
0
0
56
11
11
12
56
556
556
56
556
11
11
1,893
5
8
38
385
38
385
8
38
1
901
158
Reduction
(Ibs/vrt
19
0
0
3,839
39
39
0
175
1,992
35,409
7,181
5,774
47,168
29,819
8,322
203,569
3,834
41,799
385,042
0
2
12
5,815
4,962
1215
492
1,162
0
13,660
66,685
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
3,308
0 *
0*
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0*
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-52
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 2
Facility
Code
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
30107
Total Organics
30110
30110
30110
30110
30110
30110
30110
30110
Total Organics
30117
30117
30117
Total Organics
30119
30119
Total Organics
Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code
35
48
64
70
82
94
95
97
99
101
102
118
124
130
136
139
51
70
79
97
102
103
118
130
3
97
118
66
70
(lbs/vr)
1,123
2,199
19,074
233,585
30
112,852
126
1,672
5,557
739
4,213
62,068
209
450
25,791
599
470,287
81
173
7,814
1,683
142
25,916
1,564
660
38,033
200
2,001
2,000
4,201
2
160
162
abs/vr)
1,123
2,199
19,074
233,585
0
112,852
126
1,672
0
739
4,213
62,068
0
450
0
599
438,700
81
173
0
1,683
142
0
1,564
660
4,303
200
2,001
2,000
4,201
2
160
162
(lbs/vr)
3
0
3
130
0
13
126
130
0
130
3
13
0
3
0
3
555
3
131
0
131
3
0
13
3
283
200
29
3
232
0
0
0
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/yr)
1,120
2,199
19,071
233,455
0
112,839
0
1,542
0
609
4,210
62,055
0
447
0
596
438,145
78
42
0
1,552
139
0
1,551
657
4,020
0
1,972
1,997
3,969
2
160
162
Air Load
Reduction
(lbs/yr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
. 0
0
0
0
0 **
0
0
5
0
0
6
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-53
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
308 Quest PSES
Option 2 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code (Ibs/vrt (Ibs/vrt (Ibs/vrt dbs/vr) (lbs/vr)
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30125
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
30141
Total Qrpsmics
9
58
61
64
70
71
79
84
93
94
97
102
114
118
129
130
136
CN
9
3
29
70
71
79
84
94
97
99
102
105
118
129
130
139
109,125
250
5
555
114,700
11,555
1,760
io
830
57,630
229,512
4,760
4,060
40,505
6,810
11,805
1,055
485,802
7
98,520
5
5
13,055
805
5
60
10,055
6,005
305
10
5,055
15,055
60
110
4,505
55,095
5
0
0
550
0
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
0
605.
1
7,500
0
5
13,000
750
0
55
10,000
6,000
300
5
5,000
15,000
55
55
4,500
54,725
5
0
0
1
0
5
5
1
5
5
5
1
5
5
5
1
0
44
0
296
0
5
242
242
0
2
24
242
24
5
2
24
35
5
5
859
0
0
0
549
0
0
0
4
0
0
0
4
0
0
0
4
0
561
0
7,204
0
0
12,758
508
0
53
9,976
5,758
276
0
4,998
14,976
20
50
4,495
53,866
103,669
230
3
0**
113,553
10,977
0 **
5 *
643
86
183,610
3,689
0 **
33,214
5,278
11,451
907
363,646
0
11,696
0
0
55*
21
0
4
55
5 *
5 *
1
55 *
55 *
1
7
5 *
269
B-54
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 2
Facility
Code
30172
Total Organics
30228
30228
Total Organics
30229
30229
30229
30229
Total Organics
30233
30233
Total Organics
30314
Total Organics
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code
97
118
130
70
77
79
94
70
114
70
9
12
25
27
29
37
62
64
70
71
84
87
93
94
dbs/yr)
29,963
29,963
2,950
2,246
5,196
5
112
5
5
127
6,551
1,424
7,975
1,160
1,160
359,401
0
11,791
0
80,159
4,396
0
164,252
41,970
5
738
4,707
35,649
80,614
(lbs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
5
112
5
5
127
695
151
846
1,160
1,160
306,656
0
11,791
0
80,159
3,996
0
163,967
41,970
5
738
4,707
35,649
47,336
(Ibs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
8
151
159
3
3
1,532
0
126
0
1,256
25
0
28
1,256
4
13
13
452
126
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
5
112
5
5
127
687
0
687
1,157
1,157
305,124
0
11,665
0
78,903
3,971
0
163,939
40,714
0
725
4,694
35,197
47,210
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/yr)
13,375
13,375
30
64
95
0
0
0
0
0
5,726
0 **
5,726
0
0
19,803
0
0
0
0 *
220
0
21
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0*
530
B-55
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
Facility Poll.
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30329
30331
30331
30331
30331
30331
30331
30331
30331
30331
30331
30331
30360
30360
30366
30366
30366
30366
30366
30366
30366
30366
96
97
102
103
114
118
124
129
130
136
9
3
10
58
61
71
87
97
118
130
136
67
97
43
94
97
102
118
129
130
139
Raw Loadings
(Ibs/vr)
0
2,126,790
21,856
2,773
0
405,328
2,710
6,431
15,445
0
3,005,615
3,425
31,265
189,935
. 296,137
660,600
1,075,938
1,094,602
29,016
74,002
175,993
123,632
3,751,120
250
28
278
4,542
994,942
914,731
12,905
290
5,988
148
10,070
308 Quest.
Current Load
(lbs/vr)
0
2,126,790
21,856
2,773
0
275,707
2,710
6,431
15,445
0
2,842,031
3,425
6
180,720
0
660,593
40,704
0
1,201
5,403
3
123,630
1,012,260
120
6
126
140
596,965
475,517
2,581
145
5,988
148
8,820
PSES Option 2
Proposed Load
flbs/vf)
0
1,256
25
1,256
0
126
25
181
25
0
6,192
39
6
32
0
3
32
0
32
3
1
3
111
1
6
7
2
10
101
2
10
14
2
2
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
2,125,534
21,831
1,517
0
275,581
2,685
6,250
15,420
0
2,835,839
3,386
0
180,688
0
660,590
40,672
0
1,169
5,400
2
123,627
1,012,149
119
0
119
138
596,955
475,416
2,579
135
5,974
146
8,818
Air Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
0 *
0 *
0*
0
4,175
0 *•
0 *
0 *
0
4,946
0*
0 **
9,215 *
273,819
7 *
968,928
1,094,355
17,295
60,686
171,246
2 *
2,595,552
130 *
22
152
227
10,374
3,325
8,709
5
0 *
0 *
1,250 *
B-56
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 2
Facility
Code
Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code
(Ibs/vr)
(Ibs/yr)
Obs/vr)
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/yr)
Air Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
Total Organics
30377
30377
30377
30377
Total Organics
30398
30398
30398
30398
30398
30398
30398
Total Organics
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
30431
Total Organics
30457
67
70
94
114
9
70
94
95
97
118
130
9
27
55
60
64
71
94
97
102
105
115
118
136
139
9
1,943,616
0
15
361
30
406
41,189
149,076
507,625
10,322
620,096
7,030
3,000
1,297,149
375,000
450
148,899
631,400
1,634
9,850
22,850
13,098
908,300
300
56,200
127,424
333,500
1,600
2,255,505
36,700
1,090,304
0
15
361
30
406
37,846
149,076
507,625 .
10,322
620,096
7,030
3,000
1,297,149
0
150
147,400
631,300
1,100
8,500
21,000
499
143,500
145
56,200
63,600
329,000
1,500 .
1,403,894
0
143
0
4
0
30
34
787
645
65
645
645
65
13
2,077
0
5
1
1
1
50
5
50
1
0
56,200
5
5
1
56,325
0
1,090,161
0
11
361
0
371
37,059
148,431
507,560
9,677
619,451
6,965
2,987
1,295,072
0
145
147,399
631,299
1,099
8,450
20,995
449
143,499
145
0
63,595
328,995
1,499
1,347,569
0
23,890
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
150
499
0**
0 **
250
250
499
200
145
0
24
100
50
2,167
28,895
B-57
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Faculties
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
308 Quest PSES Option 2 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code
'30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
30457
Total OrganJcs
30504
30504
30504
30504
30504
30504
30504
30504
30504
30504
Total Organics
30528
30528
30528
30528
Total Organics
30536
3
58
64
70
71
84
87
94
95
97
102
118
129
130
136
139
9
11
.27
64
70
94
97
118
129
130
27
70
77
130
9
flbs/vr)
7,100
14,200
48,800
12,000
87,000
17,700
106,000
22,800
70,600
755,200
6,900
367,600
132,800
347,800
7,900
1,500
2 005,900
25,374
9,041
1,655
2,144
3,987
8,578
43,000
69,000
8,578
236
146,219
2,100
69,500
8,300
5
79,905
6,462
(lbs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
31,700
200
0
0
2,900
0
0
34,800
0
9,041
1,655
2,144
3,987
8,578
43,000
69,000
8,578
236
146,219
2,100
69,500
8,300
5
79,905
6,462
flbs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
35
1
0
0
1
0
0
36
0
206
21
5
206
21
206
21
30
4
717
0
5
9
0
14
23
(Ibs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
31,665
199
0
0
2,899
0
0
34,764
. 0
8,835
1,634
2,139
3,781
8,557
42,794
68,979
8,548
232
145,502
2,100
69,495
8,291
5
79,891
6,439
(Ibs/vrt
0**
9,665
0 **
5,173
50,553
11,617
77,429
9,807
45,301
205,262
6,042
187,780
61,318
223,616
3,542
996
898,103
1,183
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0*
0*
0*
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-58
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 2
Facility
Code
30536
Total Organics
30543
30543
30543
30543
30543
Total Organics
30557
30557
Total Organics
30607
30607
30607
30607
Total Organics
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
30610
Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code
3
9
70
94
97
102
9
70
9
94
97
130
9
25
26
39
62
77
84
94
97
102
118
130
(lbs/vr)
2,000
2,000
1,056
110
11
22
33
176
537
1,112
1,112
180
117,859
118,702
1,143
237,704
19,377
5,362
967
5,148
12,019
13,339
1,941
101,121
190,000
64
112,606
26,000
(lbs/yr)
0
0
1,056
110
11
22
33
176
0
0
0
0
116,359
114,202
1,143
231,704
0
5,362
967
134
0
13,339
1,941
101,121
190,000
64
112,606
26,000
(Ibs/yr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
3
29
1
33
0
1
10
1
0
20
0
1
10
0
1
0
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/yr)
0
0
1,056
110
11
22
33
176
0
0
0
0
116,356
114,173
1,142
231,671
0
5,361
957
133
0
13,319
1,941
101,120
189,990
64
112,605
26,000
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/yr)
0
0
0 *
0 *
0
0
0 *
0
0
0
0
0
1,500
4,500
0
6,000
15
0 *
0
1
2
0 *
0
0 *
0 *
0
0*
0*
B-59
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
308 Quest. PSES,Option2 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
30618
30618
30618
30618
30618
30618
30618
30618
30618
30618
30618
30618
30619
30619
30619
30639
30639
30639
30639
30639
30639
30639
30639
30665
30665
9
55
60
70
94
96
97
102
105
118
130
136
9
70
114
9
64
70
94
97
114
118
130
9
37
468,567
3,990
1,222
333,929
21,200
36,240
10,600
163,950
13,950
220,320
318,900
975
153,894
1.275.180
1,900
500
550
1,050
252,006
50
1,411,290
958
70,000
149
11,300
3,600
1.497,347
7
7
451,534
0
0
0
21,200
35,940
10,350
163,500
13,200
219,570
318,400
825
42,420
825,405
1,900
500
550
1.050
0
50
1,411,290
958
70,000
0
11,300
3,600
1,497,198
7
7
44
0
0
0
264
26
26
264
5
3
26
5
26
647
162
133
550
683
0
11
492
49
492
0
49
10
1,102
7
7
451,490
0
0
0
20,936
35,914
10,324
163,236
13,195
219,567
318,374
820
42,394
824,758
1,738
367
0
367
0
39
1,410,798
909
69,508
0
11,251
3,590
1.496,096
0
0
4
0
0
0
0
300
250
450
750
750
500
150
0
3,150
0*
0
0
0
189
0
0 *
0
0 *
0
0 *
0 *
0
0
0
B-60
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 2
Facility
Code
30665
30665
30665
30665
30665
30665
Total Organics
30685
Total Organics
30690
30690
30690
30690
30690
30690
30690
30690
Total Organics
30704
30704
Total Organics
30722
30722
30722
Total Organics
30738
Total Organics
Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code
67
79
94
114
115
118
79
9
70
94
97
117
118
130
139
9
94
70
94
97
94
(lbs/yr)
1
903
8
43
120
588
1,670
0
0
8,600
1,990
8,063
2,311
1,463
5,151
2,584
1,582
23,144
309,469
1
1
15,690
872
872
17,434
15,853
15,853
abs/vr)
1
903
8
43
120
588
1,670
0
0
8,600
1,990
8,063
2,311
1,463
5,151
2,584
1,582
23,144
0
0
0
15,690
872
872
17,434
15,853
15,853
abs/vr)
1
325
8
43
120
48
551
0
0
41
34
3
34
3
3
1
1
79
0
0
0
35
4
35
74
0
0
Water Load
Air Load
Reduction Reduction
Obs/vr)
0
578
0
0
0
540
1,119
0
0
8,559
1,956
8,060
2,277
1,460
5,148
2,583
1,581
23,065
0
0
0
15,655
868
837
17,360
15,853
15853
Obs/yr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 *
0
0
0
0
o
B-61
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 2 Water Load
Facility
Code
30741
30741
Total Orpsnic1
30756
30756
30756
Total Organic
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
30759
Total Organic
30767
30767
Poll Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code
70
115
3
79
94
97
s
3
10
11
27
37
55
64
66
70
71
84
87
94
95
96
97
99
101
102
115
118
129
130
136
139
CN
9
(Ibs/yr)
21,180
516
21696
100
200
174,911
175,211
26,326
444,557
1,036
1,002
204,315
169
44,621
37,524
493,438
14,222
14,350
1,162
400,469
9,226
6,130
1,438,398
103
12,519
1,165,026
7,631
2,935,237
63,085
109,150
1,070
245
7,431,011
981
26,400
(Ibs/yr)
21,180
516
21,696
100
200
174,911
175,211
1,316
22,228
52
50
204
17
4,462
3,752
24,672
712
717
58
20,024
461
613
71,920
10
626
8,155
763
293,523
3,154
110
107
12
457,718
981
26,400
(lbs/yr)
4
516
519
7
1
11
19
1,316
1,475
52
50
29
17
32
2,949
1,475
712
15
15
147
461
147
1,475
10
626
29
763
147
212
29
107
12
12,303
38
1,535
Reduction
abs/vr)
21,176
*o
21,177
93
199
174,900
175,192
0
20,753
0
0
175
0
4,430
803
23,197
0
702
43
19,877
0
466
70,445
0
0
8,126
0
293,376
2,942
81
0
0
445,415
943
24,865
Air Load
Reduction
abs/vr)
0*
0*
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-62
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
Facility
Code
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
30767
Total Organics
30793
30793
30793
Total Organics
30803 '
30803
30803
30803
30803
30803
30803
30803
30803
Total Organics
30819
30819
Poll.
Code
3
12
15
25
29
35
48
64
70
77
94
97
102
118
124
129
130
70
94
102
37
66
70
71
84
95
97
102
130
10
11
Raw Loadings
(lbs/vr)
241,000
4,400
121,400
130
8,400
2,500
19,300
12,600
160,000
123,000
60,000
3,699,000
240,000
259,700
2,700
5,100
20,200
4,979,430
16,042
48,200
11,169
75,411
1,016
737
75
66
100
25
3,432
50
0
5,501
5,481
27,522
308 Quest.
Current Load
(lbs/yr)
241,000
4,400
120,200
130
8,400
2,500
19,300
12,600
160,000
123,000
60,000
3,699,000
240,000
259,700
2,700
5,100
20,000
4,978,030
9,342
6,500
169
16,011
0
737
75
44
100
25
3,432
50
0
4,463
5,481
27,441
PSES Option 2
Proposed Load
(Ibs/vr)
241,000
25
25
126
1,259
25
3
28
1,259
2,517
126
1,259
25
126
25
181
25
248,033
70
7
1
78
0
89
45
44
0
25
45
1
0
249
82
82
Water Load
Reduction
Obs/yr)
0
4,375
120,175
4
7,141
2,475
19,297
12,572
158,741
120,483
59,874
3,697,741
239,975
259,574
2,675
4,919
19,975
4,729,997
9,272
6,493
168
15,933
0
648
30
0
100
0
3,387
49
0
4,214
5,399
27,359
Air Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
5
14
3
23
0
0
0
0
0
0
0*
0
0
0
0*
81
B-63
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Faculties
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 2 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819
30819 '
30819
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
30832
60
64
66
70
71
84
94
97
102
118
129
130
136
139
3
25
26
27
29
51
58
61
64
66
70
71
79
84
87
94
96
97
102
117
118
124
129
130
39,254
2,038
23,050
5,830
10,373
1,427
106,668
246,433
60,702
142,997
56,062
9,223
1,768
1,282
740,110
125,400
2,200
0
79,200
119,000
4,400
0
0
50,000
0
2,200
440,000
741,400
11,000
2,200
220,000
-0
1,012,000
28,600
6,000
94,600
0
160,600
257,400
flbs/vr)
39,128
2,038
23,037
5,520
9,706
1,383
102,520
217,999.
45,377
120,072
50,526
9,039
1,697
1,276
662,240
114,400
0
0
77,000
7,000
2,200
0
0
50,000
0
0
0
279,400
11,000
0
0
0
257,400
22,000
6,000
0
0
0
4,400
abs/vr)
2
2
165
82
82
1
8
82
2
8
12
- 2
8
2
622
114,400
0
0
22
225
4
0
0
5
0
0
0
153
2
0
0
0
225
4
22
0
0
0
4
Reduction Reduction
abs/vr) (Ibs/vr)
39,126
2,036
22,872
5,438
9,624
1,382
102,512
217,917
45,375
120,064
50,514
9,037
1,689
1,274
661,618
0
0
0
76,978
6,775
2,196
0
0
49,995
0
0
0
279,247
10,998
0
0
0
257,175
21,996
5,978
0
0
0
4,396
0 **
0 *
0 **
310 *
667 *
44 *
4,148 *
28,434 *
15,325 *
22,925 *
5,536 *
184 *
71 *
6 *
77,731
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-64
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
Facility
Code
30832
30832
Total Organics
30851
30851
30851
30851
30851
Total Organics
30864
30864
30864
30864
30864
30864
30864
Total Organics
30884
30884
30884
30884
30884
30884
30884
30884
30884
30884
30884 -
30884
30884
Total Organics
Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed I-oad
Code
136
139
CN
9
70
94
97
62
70
79
94
95
97
130
CN
29
35
43
66
70
71
80
94
97
102
129
130
(Ibs/yr)
22,000
132,000
3,510,200
35
40
805,494
1,309
101,792
908,595
111,000
15,000
0
11,000
2,000
7,000
7,000
153,000
74,026
4,424
79,194
17,240
200,284
1,267,295
58,257
173,584
17,290
273,029
27,582
9,276
85,936
2,213,390
Obs/vrt
0
6,600
837,400
0
0
782,336
1,273
99,000
882,609
10,000
10,000
0
10,000
1,000
5,000
5,000
41,000
84
0
100
0
200,084
145,903
113
688
101
48,290
0
0
9,521
404,799
(lbs/vr)
0
4
115,073
0
0
280
28
280
589
29
292
0
29
292
292
6
940
22
0
7
0
715
357
113
357
36
357
0
0
7
1,950
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
6,596
722,327
0
0
782,056
1,245
98,720
882,020
9,971
9,708
0
9,971
708
4,708
4,994
40,060
63
0
93
0
199,369
145,546
0
331
65
47,933
0
0
9,514
402,849
Reduction
(lbs/yr)
0
0
0
0
2
23,158 *
36*
2,792 *
25,986
22
2
0
2
0
1
1
29
0
0
0
0
0
272,686
0
0
0
93,667
0
0
76,415
442,768
B-65
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 2 Water Load
Facility
Code
30885
Total Qrganics
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
30905
Total Organics
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
Poll Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code
79
CN
9
27
29
43
55
70
84
94
97
118
129
130
136
139
9
3
12
27
35
55
60
64
66
70
71
77
79
84
94
95
97
(lbs/vr)
5
5
0
24,370
2,990
520
300
30,040
63,090
10
188,020
22,520
102,890
1,000
210
72,130
70
483,790
292
4,085
186
166,257
1,893
2,193
243
81
1,164
10,193
11,160
2,774
155
11,971
44,370
2,863
180,676
(Ibs/vr)
5
5
0
0
2,990
0
300
0
63,090
10
188,020
22,520
102,890
1,000
210
0
70
381,100
291
4,080
184
158,340
1,883
2,188
240
80
1,162
10,187
11,070
2,771
153
11,935
44,268
2,857
172,072
(Ibs/vr)
0
0
0
0
5
0
1
0
48
0
5
48
5
7
1
0
1
120
291
4,080
9
47
9
9
10
10
950
475
475
950
153
5
47
475
475
Reduction
dbs/vr)
5
5
0
0
2,985
0
299
0
63,042
10
188,015
22,472
102,885
993
209
0
69
380,980
0
0
175
158,293
1,874
2,179
230
70
212
9,712
10,595
1,821
0
11,930
44,221
2,382
171,597
Air Load
Reduction
Obs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1 *
0 **
2*
7,917 *
10*
5 *
0**
0 **
0**
6*
90 *
0**
0**
36*
102*
6*
8,604*
B-66
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 2
Facility
Code
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
30910
Total Organics
30918
30918
30918
30918
30918
30918
30918
30918
Total Organics
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
30931
Total Organics
Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code
102
105
124
129
130
134
136
9
27
66
70
79
94
97
130
9
37
58
60
64
66
67
71
87
97
102
118
124
129
136
(lbs/vr)
2,625
548
1,265
1,916
25,932
5,770
2,350
480,670
47,060
50,897
464
47,250
100
4,601
630,940
4,276
738,528
732,486
132,790
370
6,118
84,859
14,320
18,221
51,768
1,564
516,995
96,453
201,561
52,553
118,233
25,882
1,321,687
(lbs/vr)
2,500
522
1,260
1,910
24,697
3,850
2,345
460,554
100
48,450
70
45,000
100
4,382
599,800
4,072
701,874
0
132,785
370
6,118
84,859
14,320
18,221
51,762
1,556
516,737
96,440
201,447
52,551
118,172
25,881
1.32U19
(lbs/yr)
9
5
9
68
9
95
47
8,424
100
12
70
124
84
12
124
2
430
0
5
25
5
5
496
25
248
2
248
5
25
5
36
25
1,155
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/yr)
2,491
517
1,251
1,842
24,688
3,755
2,298
452,130
0
48,438
0
44,876
16
4,370
599,676
4,070
701,444
0
132,780
345
6,112
84,854
13,824
18,196
51,514
1,553
516,489
96,435
201,422
52,546
118,136
25,857
1,320,064
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vrt
125 *
26 *
5 *
6 *
1,235 *
1,920 *
5 *
20,100
2,593
2,447 *
0 **
432
0
30
2,063
122
5,094
40,360
5 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
6*
8 *
258 *
13*
114 *
0
61 *
1 *
466
B-67
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
Facility
Code
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
30949
Poll.
Code
9
27
55
64
67
70
84
94
97
102
105
117
118
124
136
Total Orsanics
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
30954
9
3
12
25
37
51
64
66
70
71
79
80
87
94
97
99
102
118
124
130
136
Raw Loadings
(Ibs/vf)
637,235
101,191
34,943
11,387
44,736
1,416,214
15,039
2,496,391
2,977,748
3,341,683
1,395,610
6,109
4,739,273
2,007
805,823
17 388 154
55,764
18,270
25,950
95
145,922
58
230,826
40,410
881,118
252,226
760
100,843
13,146
62,622
318,062
14,841
60,860
1,396,453
108,320
1,759,472
12,037
308 Quest
Current Load
(Ibs/vr)
0
130
0
0
250
50
10
50
510
20
10
0
150
5
25
1,210
39,862
1
1
0
39,763
0
454
0
114,170
20,116
0
1,651
0
4,419
4,421
0
23,000
137,932
82
29,888
17
PSES Option 2
Proposed Load
(Ibs/vr)
0
12
0
0
12
50
1
12
119
2
1
0
12
2
12
236
666
1
0
0
11
0
12
0
546
546
0
546
0
55
546
0
11
55
11
11
16
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
0
118
0
0
238
0
9
38
391
18
9
0
138
3
13
974
39,196
0
0
0
39,752
0
442
0
113,624
19,570
0
1,105
0
4,364
3,875
0
22,989
137,877
71
29,877
0
Air Load
Reduction
abs/vr)
503,416
48,572
16,773
0**
21,473
608,972
9,926
790,357
458,573
2,940,681
669,893
2,932
1,277,234
963
362,620
7.208,969
15,902 *
0 **
20,114
74
106,159 *
45
0 **
0**
766,948 *
232,110 *
0**
78,163
13,146
94
254,450
11,503
37,860 *
1,145,091
83,959
1,706,688
10,352
B-68
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
Facility
Code
Poll.
Code
Raw Loadings
(lbs/vr)
308 Quest
Current Load
Obs/vr)
PSES Option 2
Proposed Load
(Ibs/vr)
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/yr)
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
Total Organics
30965
30965
30965
Total Organics
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
30977
Total Organics
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
31029
Total Organics
31030
94
97
118
9
3
27
62
64
71
94
97
102
105
118
130
27
55
64
70
71
79
87
97
102
118
124
130
9
5,442,289
282,890
32,158
9,775
324,823
1,060,800
4,400
184,800
8,155
0
2,200
446,600
297,000
387,200
396,000
541,200
2,200
2,269,755
172,575
65,652
54,433
505,145
328,904
29,649
343,512
670,795
519,832
864,341
151,243
23
3,706,104
480
375,914
16,973
1,162
391
18,526
0
4,400
184,800
8,155
0
2,200
446,600
204,600
387,200
396,000
541,200
2,200
2,177,355
171,174
32,826
29,077
38,538
27,533
29,649
2,128
633,157
38,466
193,920
150,875
23
1,347,366
480
2,367
2
16
2
19
0
4,400
0
0
0
2
0
2
0
0
0
0
4,406
7
1
1
65
65
44
1
65
1
7
1
1
261
0
373,547
16,971
1,146
389
18,507
0
0
184,800
8,155
0
2,198
446,600
204,598
387,200
396,000
541,200
2,200
2,172,949
171,167
32,825
29,076
38,473
27,468
29,605
2,127
633,092
.38,465
193,913
150,874
22
1,347,105
480
4,466,756
57,485
1,222
283
58,990
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-69
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
308 Quest PSES Option 2 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
31030
31042
31053
31053
31063
31092
31092
31092
31092
31092
31092
31092
31092
31092
31108
3
37
58
64
70
71
94
97
102
113
118
113
79
114
113
3
55
70
80
94
97
102
105
118
9
(Ibs/vr)
10
17
64
63
1,056
8
429
2,065
26
168
60
3,966
260,445
260.445
356
10
366
318,182
318,182
27,373
1,215
5,635
78,234
10,887
1,457
98,632
15,738
44,585
283,756
2,575
(lbs/vr) ttbs/vri
10
15
34
63
1,016
8
414
2,055
20
138
60
3,833
260,445
260,445
356
0
356
0
0
1,291
122
0
4,736
0
0
1,556
646
246
8,597
0
10
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
11
23
23
7
0
7
0
0
1,291
0
0
13
0
0
0
0
1
1,305
0
flbs/vr) Qbs/vr)
0
15
34
63
1,016
8
414
2,055
20
138
60
3,822
260,422
260,422
349
0
349
0
0
0
122
0
4,723
0
0
1,556
646
245
7,292
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 **
1,093 *
2,561
27,296
8,823
941
63,579
15,092 *
18,686
138,071
0
B-70
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
308 Quest PSES Option 2
Facility
Code
31108
31108
Total Organics
31110
31110
31110
31110
31110
Total Organics
31112
31112
Total Organics
31113
31113
31113
31113
31113
Total Organics
31120
31120
31120
31120
31120
31120
31120
31120
31120
31120
Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load
Code
61
136
9
70
97
117
130
71
130
9
55
94
97
118
9
11
27
70
94
97
99
102
118
130
(lbs/vr)
776
5,905
6,681
3,023
45,961
51,000
3,974
7,025
107,960
0
120
120
8,192
5,817
54,134
4,410
6,734
71,095
122,000
23,400
680
440,900
13,900
182,100
414,000
145,600
40,000
37,000
(Ibs/yr)
0
0
0
3,023
45,961
51,000
3,974
7,025
107,960
0
120
120
0
47
54,134
4,410
6,734
65,325
0
23,400
680
440,900
13,900
182,000
0
136,600
40,000
37,000
(lbs/yr)
0
0
0
9
7
7
1
0
15
0
1
1
0
1
5
47
5
58
0
49
5
49
5
49
0
1
5
1
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/yr)
0
0
0
3,014
45,954
50,993
3,973
7,025
107,945
0
119
119
0
46
54,129
4,363
6,729
65,267
0
23,351
675
440,851
13,895
181,951
0
136,599
39,995
36,999
Air Load
Reduction
Qbs/yr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
o
6
1
0 *
0 *
0 *
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-71
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
Facility Poll.
31121
31121
31121
31121
31121
31145
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31163
31164
31164
31164
31164
31164
31164
70
71
94
97
139
70
CN
9
3
26
60
64
70
71
77
94
97
102
114
115
118
17.4
9
10
11
27
37
60
Raw Loadings
abs/vr)
1.297,580
40,900
41,600
5,600
1,321,000
100
1,409,200
35,024
35,024
17
17,636
30,617
414,459
300
100
1,518
40
10
9
177
1
0
29,440
153,979
3
630,653
150,266
0
83,620
2,265
. 517
368,272
308 Quest.
Current Load
abs/vr)
874,480
0
0
0
0
0
0
31,134
31,134
17
2,636
30,617
414,459
300
100
1,518
30
10
9
147
1
0
29,440
153,949
3
630,583
17,751
0
83,620
2,265
517
368,272
PSES Option 2
Proposed Load
flbs/yr)
164
0
0
0
0
0
0
4
4
2
293
30,617
240
5
5
240
30
10
9
147
1
0
29,440
24
3
60,771
101
0
82
8
2
2
Water Load
Reduction
abs/vr)
874,316
0
0
0
0
0
0
31,130
31,130
15
2,343
0
414,219
295
95
1,278
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
153,925
0
569,812
17,650
0
83,538
2,257
515
368,270
Air Load
Reduction
abs/vr)
0
40,566
- 41,474
9
1,315,626
1
1,397,675
3,890
3,890
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
10
0
0
30
0
0
0
30
0
70
8,280
0
0 *
0 *
0*
0 *
B-72
-------
Cost Effectiveness for PSES Option 3 (Appendix B)
A/C Indirect Discharge Facilities
July 28,1994 Version (QA/QC MRW 8/8/94)
308 Quest. PSES Option 2
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings
Code Code
31164 64
31164 66
31164 70
31164 71
31164 94
31164 97
31164 99
31164 102
31164 114
31164 129
31164 130
31164 136
Total Organics
A/C Organics
(Ib/yr) subtot. 1
(Ib/yr) subtot. 2
(Ib/yr) Total
Total CN (Ib/yr)
Total Ammonium
Hydroxide Ob/yr)
Grand Total
(lbs/yr)
2,906
502,000
399,684
1,911
115,881
1,064,462
11,218
6,833
427
25,098
5,510
1,350
2,591,954
43,038,486
42,447,773
85,486,259
75,065
4,620,458
90,181,783
Current Load Proposed Load
(lbs/vr)
2,906
502,000
399,684
1,911
115,881
1,064,462
0
6,833
427
25,098
5,510
1,350
2,580,736
19,972,725
12,677,101
32,649,826
1,084
530,851
33,181,761
(lbs/vr)
2
165
82
82
8
82
0
2
427
12
2
8
967
481,841
84,224
566,065
62
6,053
572,180
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/yr)
2,904
501,835
399,602
1,829
115,873
1,064,380
0
6,831
0
25,086
5,508
1,342
2,579,769
19,490,884
12,592,877
32,083,761
1,021
524,799
32,609,582
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vr)
0
0 *
0 *
0*
0 *
0 *
1,363
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
0 *
1,363
6,718,320
13,770,229
20,488,549
0
740,490
21,229,040
Footnote:
(1) The following A/C indirect facilities do not discharge process
wastewater containing the nonconventional pollutants that are candidates
for regulation. These facilities are, therefore, not included
in fhis table.
Facilities: 30197,30199,30602,30648,30662,30668,30715,30719
30946,30989, and 31105
* The air load reduction was calculated as the raw load minus the current load since the summation
of the air load reduction calculated through WATER7 and the current load was equal to an amount
greater than the raw load.
** The air load reduction was assumed to be 0 even if WATER7 gave it a load reduction because the
constituent is not strippable.
B-73
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 (KMM)
308 Quest. PSES Option la Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code abs/vr) abs/vr) abs/vr) abs/vr) abs/vr)
30008
Total Orps^ics
30013
Total Organics
30028
30062
30062
Total Organics
30074
30074
30088
30088
30088
30088
30088
Total OrpflPTC?
30090
Total Organics
30093
30093
Total Organics
30106
30106
70
97
70
70
94
94
97
27
70
87
94
97
94
70
94
97
102
1
1
1,119
1 119
1
1
185
1,450
1,635
31,900
8,920
40,820
100
23,000
100
100
1,000
24300
1
1
46
30
76
616
272
1
1
1,119
1,119
1
1
0
0
0
30,305
8,474
38,779
100
23,000
100
100
1,000
24,300
1
1
46
30
76
480
0
1
1
286
286
1
1
0
0
0
414
7,430
- 7,844
100
3,295
1
100
1,000
4,496
1
1
46
30
76
363
0
0
0
833
833
0
0
0
0
0
29,891
1,044
30,935
0
19,705
99
0
0
19,804
0
0
0
0
0
117
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1,595 *
446*
2,041
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-74
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 (KMM)
308 Quest. PSES Option la Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings
Code Code (Ibs/vr)
Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
(Ibs/yr) (lbs/vr) (lbs/yr) flbs/yr)
Total Organics
30111 70
Total Organics
30116 70
Total Organics
30118 94
Total Organics
30122 71
30122 94
30122 97
Total Organics
30124 66
30124 70
30124 79
30124 94
30124 136
Total Organics
30138 9
Total
30147 37
30147 70
30147 94
30147 97
30147 102
Total Organics
888
3,616
3,616
110
110
72
72
2,660
11,175
295
14,130
1
16
479
200
2
698
121
121
20
384
187
25
110
726
480
3,616
3,616
110
110
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
11
24
100
1
137
0
0
10
374
177
15
100
676
363
3,616
3,616
110
110
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
11
24
100
1
137
0
0
0
374
177
15
1
567
117
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
10
0
0
0
99
109
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
5 *
9
100 *
1 *
115
0
0
10*
10 *
10 *
10 *
10 *
50
B-75
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 (KMM)
308 Quest PSES Option la Water Load Airload
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
(Ibs/yr) Qbs/vr) (Ibs/vr) ffl>s/vr)
30170 37
30170 70
30170 97
30170 118
30176 79
30176 94
30176 97
30184 70
30185 71
30185 94
30185 114
30200 114
30204 70
30207 94
30217 58
30217 79
30217 130
19
360
19
80
478
122
486
446
1,054
350
350
2
300
1
303
92
92
37
37
1,256
1,256
586
460
5
1,051
19
360
19
80
478
61
146
134
341
350
350
2
300 .
1
303
92
92
37
37
625
625
586
460
5
1,051
0
360
19
5
384
61
146
134
341
350
350
0
.2
1
3
92
92
37
37
625
625
586
460
5
1,051
19
0
0
74
93
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
298
0
300
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
631 *
631
0
0
0
0
B-76
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 (KMM)
Facility Poll.
Code Code
30258 102
Total Organics
30267 70
Total Organics
30269 94
Total Organics
30278 10
30278 70
30278 79
30278 95
30278 102
30278 118
Total Organics
30318 94
30318 97
30318 118
Total Organics
30349 70
30349 97
30349 102
Total Organics
30355 70
Total Organics
30359 9
30359 58
30359 70
30359 94
Raw Loadings
flbs/vr)
5,747
5,747
50
50
26,253
26,253
824,830
867,979
292
225,593
720,435
883,816
3,522,945
20
2
300
322
124
41
661
826
1
1
1
3
2
47
308 Quest.
Current Load
Obs/yr)
5,747
5,747
50
50
0
0
82,483
86,798
29
22,559
4,578
38,964
235,411
20
2
300
322
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
3
2
47
PSES Option la
Proposed Load
(lbs/yr)
0
0
50
50
0
0
4,233
86,798
29
4,233
141
4,233
99,667
20
2
16
38
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
2
32
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
5,747
5,747
0
0
0
0
78,250
0
0
18,326
4,437
34,731
135,744
0
0
284
284
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
0
15
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vrt
0
0
0
0
0
0
-613,441
488,051
0
181,156
677,998
771,587
2,732,232
0
0
0
0
24
3
79
107
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-77
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 (KMM)
308 Quest. PSES Option la Water Load Airload
Facility Poll Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
-- - - - . , „ , ^ (Ibs/vrt Qbs/yr)
30359 114
30359 115
30384 70
30384 114
30438
30438
30450
30485
30485
30485
30485
30499
'30499
30499
30499
30499
30547
30548
30548 -
66
79
97
27
66
79
94
70
94
97
102
113
70
70
94
1
1
55
13
0
14
4
1
5
60
60
1
350
563
310
1,224
3
99
1,132
1,166
145
2,545
57,450
57,450
23,789
15,362
1
1
55
13
0
14
4
1
5
60
60
1
350
7
310
668
0
0
0
0
0
0
57,450
57,450
21,994
15,362
1
1
38
13
0
14
4
1
5
60
60
1
350
7
17
.375
0
0
0
0
0
0
57,450
57,450
5,272
1,146
0
0
17
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
293
293
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
16,722
14,216
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-78
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 (KMM)
308 Quest. PSES Option la Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll.
Code Code
Total Organics
30550
30550
30550
30550
30550
Total Organics
30553
Total Organics
30566
30566
30566
30566
30566
Total Organics
30577
Total Organics
30584
30584
30584
30584
30584
Total Organics
30611
30611
30611
30611
Total Organics
70
87
94
118
130
70
70
71
94
97
102
97
27
94
97
102
114
70
94
97
102
Raw Loadings
(lbs/vr)
39,151
254
11
1,363
53
1
1,682
5
5
7
0
19
0
40
66
16,000
16,000
1
656
122
915
0
1,694
109,500
100
4,100
100
113,800
Current Load Proposed Load
(lbs/vr)
37,356
157
0
1,363
30
0
1,550
5
5
7
0
19
0
36
62
16,000
16,000
0
0
0
0
0
0
109,500
100
4,100
100
113,800
Gbs/vr)
6,418
157
0
64
3
0
223
5
5
6
0
19
0
0
26
16,000
16,000
0
0
0
0
0
0
109,500
100
4,100
50
113,750
Reduction
flbs/vr)
30,938
0
0
1,299
27
0
1,327
0
0
0
0
0
0
36
36
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
50
50
Reduction
(lbs/yr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 *
0
0*
0 *
4 *
4
0
0
1 *
656 *
122 *
915 *
0 *
1,694
0
0
0
0
0
B-79
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Faculties
December 12,1994 (EMM)
308 Quest. PSES Option la Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code abs/vri dbs/vr) (Ibs/vrt abs/vrt flbs/vr)
30637
30642
30642
30642
30642
30670
30670
30674
30674
30674
30692
30694
30694
30694
30694
30694
70
70
94
113
118
70
94
37
94
97
70
37
71
94
97
118
30720
30720 -
30720
30720
30720
Total
9
70
94
114
115
338
338
2,204
4,939
1
4
7.148
3,961
7,336
11,297
1
10,733
46
10,780
5,000
5.000
37
12,012
688,270
1,965
665,148
1.367,432
8
1,820
6
8
150
1,992
338
338
0
197
0
0
197
3,961
7,336
11,297
1
0
0
1
5,000
5.000
2
0
3,938
0
748
4.688
8
1,820
6
8
150
1,992
B-80
73
73
0
197
0
0
197
3,961
4,199
8,160
0
0
0
0
1,391
1,391
0
0
589
0
23
612
8
1,820
6
8
150
1,992
265
265
0
0
0
0
0
0
3,137
3,137
1
0
0
1
3,609
3,609
2
0
3,349
0
725
4,076
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 *
0
1,257
1,895
0
2
3,155
0
0
0
0*
1,482
4
1,486
0
0
33
3,862
138,439
159
194,388
336,882
0
0
0
0
0
0
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Faculties
December 12,1994 (KMM)
308 Quest. PSES Option la Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code (Ibs/yr) Qbs/yr) dbsAr) (Ibs/yr) (Ibs/vr)
30735 9
30735 70
30735 79
30735 114
30735 115
Total
30760 94
30760 97
30760 102
Total Organics
30764 77
Total Organics
30768 70
Total Organics
30778 94
Total Organics
30822 27
30822 70
30822 94
30822 102
Total Organics
30850 70
30850 94
30850 97
30850 102
30850 134
Total Organics
16
100
1
25
25
167
1
0
0
1
10,550
10,550
115
115
502
502
7
16,915
3,101
540
20,563
449
6,237
51
24,517
17,381
48,635
16
100
1
25
25
167
1
0
0
1
10,550
10,550
115
115
502
502
7
16,915
3,101
170
20,193
5
100
1
230
0
336
16
100
1
25
25
167
0
0
0
1
10,550
10,550
115
115
502
502
7
16,915
3,101
9
20,032
5
100
1
6
0
112
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
161
161
0
0
0
224
0
224
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
5
B-81
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 (KMM)
308 Quest. PSES Option la Water Load Air Load
Facility PolL Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code (Ibs/vr) Qbs/yr) (Ibs/yr) flbs/vrt (lbs/vr)
30867
Total Organics
30870
Total Organics
30871
30871
30871
Total Organics
30900
30900
Total Organics
30911
30911
Total Org^nics
30922
Total Orgafics
30925
30925
Total Organics
30930
30930
70
79
70
94
118
94
102
70
77
94
70
97
114
124
Total Organics
30941
30941
70
97
156
156
500
500
147
4,112
188
4,447
70
160
230
532,853
7,467
540,320
5,843
5,843
715
38
752
587
1,803
2,390
195,854
9,640
156
156
500
500
147
3,618
0
3,765
70
160
230
532,853
7,467
540.320
5,843
5,843
0
0
0
587
1,803
2,390
190,623
9,400
156
156
500
500
147
56
0
203
29
0
29
148,374
7,467
155,841
3,502
3,502
0
0
0
587
27
614
994
3,878
0
0
0
0
0
3,562
0
3,562
41
160
201
384,479
0
384,479
2,341
2,341
0
0
0
0
1,776
1,776
189,629
5,522
0
0
0
0
0
494 *
0
494
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-82
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 (KMM)
308 Quest PSES Option la Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code (Ibs/yr) Qbs/yr) Gbs/vr) (Ibs/vr) flbs/vrt
Total Organics
30944 9
30944 118
Total
30956 70
Total Organics
30996 70
30996 97
30996 102
Total Organics
30997 70
30997 118
Total Organics
31004 118
Total Organics
31005 70
31005 77
Total Organics
31007 94
31007 97
31007 102
Total Organics
31017 70
31017 71
31017 94
205,494
106
' 11
117
784
784
105,615
1
4,219
109,835
562,000
54,000
616,000
3,000
3,000
213
44
257
15,800
200
510
16,510
5
1
1
200,023
0
11
11
784
784
105,615
1
4,219
109,835
112,400
0
112,400
3,000
3,000
213
44
257
900
100
255
1,255
5
1
1
4,872
0
1
1
784
784
9,044
1
3
9,047
7,322
0
7,322
0
0
213
44
257
900
100
1
1,001
5
1
1
195,151
0
10
10
0
0
96,571
0
4,216
100,788
105,078
0
105,078
3,000
3,000
0
0
0
0
0
254
254
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
3
48
51
0
0
0 *
0
0
758
10
24
792
0
0
0
B-83
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 (KMM)
308 Quest. PSES Option la Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
(lbs/yr) (Ibs/vrt (lbs/vr) (lbs/vr)
31017 97
31045 70
31045 94
31045 96
31098 94
31103 118
31123 87
31123 97
31123 102
31123 118
31123 130
31130 9
31130 70
31156 66
31156 70
31156 115
Total Orsanics
SUM1
SUM 2
Total B/D Organics
1
8
5,700
15,000
350
21,050
30
30
4
4
14,513
54,041
21,473
502
2,270
92799
50
2,800
2,850
0
112
5
117
5,286,981
1 703,859
6,990,841
1
8
5,700
15,000
350
21,050
30
30
3
3
0
3,841
0
0
0
3,841
0
2,800
2,800
0
112
5
117
564,807
1,040,315
1,605,123
1
8
2,974
647
25
3,646
2
2
0
0
0
3,841
0
0
0
3,841
0
732
732
0
8
5
13
327,092
223,684
550,776
0
0
2,726
14,353
325
17,404
28
28
3
3
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2,068
2,068
0
104
0
104
237,715
816,632
1,054,347
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1 *
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
3,078,397
1,343
3,079,741
B-84
-------
Cost Effectiveness for New PSES Option 1 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
December 12,1994 (KMM)
Facility Poll.
Code Code
Raw Loadings
abs/vr)
308 Quest
Current Load
abs/vr)
PSES Option la
Proposed Load
abs/vr)
Water Load
Reduction
abs/vr)
Air Load
Reduction
abs/vr)
forlndirects Gb/yr)
Footnote:
(1) The following B/D indirect facilities do not discharge process wastewater
containing the organic pollutants that are candidates for
regulation. These facilities are, therefore, not included in
this table.
Facilities: 30007,30019,30059,30209,30212,30221,
30232,30241,30279,30324,30357,30370,30401,30493,
30569,30597,30612,30633,30652,30766,30872,30915,
31071,31078,31119,31133,31138, and 31153.
* The air load reduction was calculated as the raw load minus the current load since the summation
of the air load reduction calculated through WATER 7 and the current load was equal to an amount
greater than the raw load.
B-85
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
September 8,1994
308 Quest. PSES Option 1 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code (Ibs/vr) (Ibs/vr) dbs/vrt abs/vrt (Ibs/vrt
30008 70
30013 97
Total Ofpsniic^
30028 70
30062 70
30062 94
30074 94
30074 97
30088 27
30088 70
30088 87
30088 94
30088 97
30090 94
Total Organics
30093 70
30093 94
Total Organics
30106 97
30106 102
1
1
1,119
1 119
1
1
185
1,450
1,635
31,900
8,920
40,820
100
23,000
100
100
1,000
24,300
1
1
46
30
76
616
272
1
1
1,119
1,119
1
1
0
0
0
30,305
8,474
38,779
100
23,000
100
100
1,000
24.300
1
1
46
30
76
480
0
B-86
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
8
8
15
13
13
1
13
13
54
1
1
1
1
2
0
0
1
1
1,119
1.119
1
1
0
0
0
30,297
8,466
38,764
87
22,987
99
87
987
24.246
0
0
45
29
74
480
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1,595
446
2?041
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
September 8,1994
308 Quest. PSES Option 1
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings
Code Code
(Ibs/yr)
Current Load Propiosed Load
(lbs/yr)
(Ibs/vr)
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/yr)
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/yr)
Total Organics
30111 70
Total Organics
30116 70
Total Organics
30118 94
Total Organics
30122 71
30122 94
30122 97
Total Organics
30124 66
30124 70
30124 79
30124 94
30124 136
Total Organics
30138 9
Total Organics
30147 37
30147 70
30147 94
30147 97
30147 102
Total Organics
888
3,616
3,616
110
110
72
72
2,660
11,175
295
14,130
1
16
479
200
2
698
121
121
20
384
187
25
110
726
480
3,616
3,616
110
110
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
11
24
100
1
137
0
0
10
374
177
15
100
676
0
17
17
110
110
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
11
24
50
1
87
0
0
0
12
12
12
1
36
480
3,599
3,599
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
50
0
50
0
0
10
362
165
3
99
640
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
5
9
100
1
115
0
0
10
10
10
10
10
50
B-87
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
September 8,1994
308 Quest. PSES Option 1 Water Load Airload
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code flbs/vr) flbs/vrt nbs/vr) dbs/vrt • dbs/yr)
30170
30170
30170
30170 1
30176
30176
30176
30184
30185
30185
37
70
97
18
79
94
97
70
71
94
30185 114
30200 114
30204
30207
30217
30217
30217
70
94
58
79
130
19
360
19
80
122
486
446
350
350
2
300
1
303
92
92
37
37
1,256
586
460
5
1,051
19
360
19
80
478
61
146
134
341
350
350
2
300
1
303
92
92
37
37
625
625
586
460
5
1.051
B-88
0
2
2
1
5
61
30
30
120
36
36
0
0
1
1
92
92
0
0
17
17
226
460
5
691
19
358
17
79
472
0
116
104
221
314
314
2
300
0
302
0
0
36
36
608
608
360
0
0
360
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
631
631
0
0
0
0
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
September 8,1994
Facility Poll.
Code Code
30258 102
Total Organics
30267 70
Total Organics
30269 94
Total Organics
30278 10
30278 70
30278 79
30278 95
30278 102
30278 118
Total Organics
30318 94
30318 97
30318 118
Total Organics
30349 70
30349 97
30349 102
Total Organics
30355 70
Total Organics
30359 9
30359 58
30359 70
30359 94
Raw Loadings
(Ibs/yr)
5,747
5,747
50
50
26,253
26,253
824,830
867,979
292
225,593
720,435
883,816
3,522,945
20
2
300
322
124
41
661
826
1
1
1
3
2
47
308 Quest
Current Load
abs/vr)
5,747
5,747
50
50
0
0
82,483
86,798
29
22,559
4,578
38,964
235,411
20
2
300
322
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
3
2
47
PSES Option 1
Proposed Load
flbs/vr)
0
0
1
1
0
0
705
2,004
29
705
141
550
4,135
8
2
2
12
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
0
1
1
Water Load
Reduction
(lbs/yr)
5,747
5,747
49
49
0
0
81,778
84,794
0
21,854
4,437
38,414
231,276
12
0
298
310
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
3
1
46
Air Load
Reduction
(Ibs/yr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
613,441
488,051
0
181,156
677,998
771,587
2,732,232
0
0
0
0
24
3
79
107
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-89
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
September 8,1994
308 Quest. PSES Option 1 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code Qbs/vf) Obs/vr) flbs/vf) (Ibs/vrt flbs/vrt
30359
30359
Total
30384
30384
Total Org^n'cs
30438
30438
Total Organics
30450
Total Organics
30485
30485
30485
30485
Total Organics
30499
30499
30499
30499
30499
Total Organics
30547
Total Organics
30548
30548
114
115
70
114
66
79
97
27
66
79
94
70
94
97
102
113
70
70
94
1
1
55
13
0
14
4
1
5
60
60
1
350
563
310
1,224
3
99
1,132
1,166
145
2,545
57,450
57,450
23,789
15,362
1
1
55
13
0
14
4
1
5
60
60
1
350
7
310
668
0
0
0
0
0
0
57,450
57,450
21,994
15,362
1
1
4
0
0
0
4
1
5
18
18
0
350
7
0
358
0
0
0
0
0
0
295
295
21
21
0
0
51
13
0
13
0
0
0
42
42
1
0
0
310
310
0
0
0
0
0
0
57,155
57,155
21,973
15,341
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-90
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
September 3,1994
308 Quest PSES Option 1 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code (lbs/vr) (lbs/vr) Obs/vr) (lbs/vr) (Ibs/vrt
Total Organics
30550 70
30550 87
30550 94
30550 118
30550 130
Total Organics
30553 70
Total Organics
30566 70
30566 71
30566 94
30566 97
30566 102
Total Organics
30577 97
Total Organics
30584 27
30584 94
30584 97
30584 102
30584 114
Total Organics
30611 70
30611 - 94
30611 97
30611 102
Total Organics
39,151
254
11
1,363
53
1
1,682
5
5
7
0
19
0
40
66
16,000
16,000
1
656
122
915
0
1,694
109,500
100
4,100
100
113,800
37,356
157
0
1,363
30
0
1,550
5
5
7
0
19
0
36
62
16,000
16,000
0
0
0
0
0
0
109,500
100
4,100
100
113,800
43
1
0
1
0
0
3
5
5
2
0
2
0
0
5
72
72
0
0
0
0
0
0
711
100
711
50
1,572
37,313
156
0
1,362
30
0
1,547
0
0
4
0
17
0
36
57
15,928
15,928
0
0
0
0
0
0
108,789
0
3,389
50
112,228
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
4
4
0
0
1
656
122
915
0
1,694
0
0
0
0
0
B-91
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
September 8,1994
308 Quest. PSES Option 1 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code
30637 70
30642 70
30642 94
30642 113
30642 118
Total Orpjfics
30670 70
30670 94
30674 37
30674 94
30674 97
30692 70
Total Orsanics
30694 37
30694 71
30694 94
30694 97
30694 118
Total Orgfln'cR
30720 9
30720 70
30720 94
30720 114
30720 115
Total
(Ibs/yf)
338
338
2,204
4,939
1
4
7,148
3,961
7,336
11,297
1
10,733
46
10,780
5,000
5,000
37
12,012
688,270
1,965
665,148
1,367,432
8
1,820
6
8
150
1,992
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
Septembers, 1994
308 Quest PSES Option 1
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings
Code Code
, 30735 9
30735 70
30735 79
30735 114
30735 115
Total Organics
30760 94
30760 97
30760 102
Total Organics
30764 77
Total Organics
30768 70
Total Organics
30778 94
Total Organics
30822 27
30822 70
30822 94
30822 102
Total Organics
30850 70 .
30850 94
30850 97
30850 102
30850 134
Total Organics
(Ibs/vr)
16
100
1
25
25
167
1
0
0
1
10,550
10,550
115
115
502
502
7
16,915
3,101
540
20,563
449
6,237
51
24,517
17,381
48,635
Current Load Proposed Load
(Ibs/yr)
16
100
1
25
25
167
1
0
0
1
10,550
10,550
115
115
502
502
7
16,915
3,101
170
20,193
5
100
1
230
0
336
flbs/yr)
16
7
1
25
25
74
0
0
0
1
10,550
10,550
1
1
49
49
7
130
130
9
277
5
92
1
6
0
104
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/vrt
0
93
0
0
0
93
0
0
0
0
0
0
114
114
453
453
0
16,785
2,971
161
19,916
0
8
0
224
0
232
Air Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
5
B-93
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
September 8,1994
308 Quest. PSES Option 1 Water Load Airload
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code (Ibs/vr) (Ibs/vf) flbs/vrt (Ibs/vrt (lbs/vr)
30867 70
30870 79
30871 70
30871 94
30871 118
30900 94
30900 102
30911 70
30911 77
30922 94
30925 70
30925 97
30930 114
30930 -124
30941 70
30941 97
156
156
500
500
147
4,112
188
4,447
70
160
230
532,853
7,467
540,320
5,843
5,843
715
38
752
587
1,803
2,390
195,854
9,640
156
156
500
500
147
3,618
0
3,765
70
160
230
532,853
7,467
540,320
5,843
5,843
o.
0
0
587
1,803
2,390
190,623
9,400
4
4
500
500
1
1
0
2
1
0
1
600
7,467
8,067
65
65
0
0
0
587
27
614
4
4
152
152
0
0
146
3,617
0
3,763
69
160
229
532,253
0
532.253
5,778
5,778
0
0
0
0
1,776
1,776
190,619
9,396
0
0
0
0
0
494
0
494
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
B-94
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
September 8,1994
308 Quest. PSES Option 1 Water Load Air Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction Reduction
Code Code Obs/vr) (Ibs/vrt (Ibs/vf) (lbs/vr) abs/vr)
Total Organics
30944 9
30944 118
Total Organics
30956 70
Total Organics
30996 70
30996 97
30996 102
Total Organics
30997 70
30997 118
Total Organics
31004 118
Total Organics
31005 70
31005 77
Total Organics
31007 94
31007 97
31007 102
Total Organics
31017 70
31017 71
31017 94
205,494
106
•11
117
784
784
105,615
1
4,219
109,835
562,000
54,000
616,000
3,000
3,000
213
44
257
15,800
200
510
16,510
5
1
1
200,023
0
11
11
784
784
105,615
1
4,219
109,835
112,400
0
112,400
3,000
3,000
213
44
257
900
100
255
1,255
5
1
1
8
0
0
0
30
30
37
1
3
40
30
0
30
0
0
1
44
45
18
18
1
37
5
1
1
200,015
0
11
11
754
754
105,578
0
4,216
109 795
112,370
0
112370
3,000
3,000
212
0
212
882
82
254
1218
0
0
0
o
0
0
o
0
o
0
0
0
o
3
48
51
0
o
0
0
o
758
10
24
792
0
0
0
B-95
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
September 8,1994
308 Quest. PSES Option 1 Water Load
Facility Poll. Raw Loadings Current Load Proposed Load Reduction
Code Code (Ibs/yr) (lbs/vr) (Ibs/yr) (Ibs/vr)
31017
Total Organics
31045
31045
31045
Total Organics
31098
Total Organics
31103
Total Organics
31123
31123
31123
31123
31123
Total Organics
31130
31130
Total Organics
31156
31156
31156
Total Organics
SXJM1
SUM 2
97
70
94
96
94
118
87
97
102
118
130
9
70
66
70
115
1
8
5,700
15,000
350
21,050
30
30
4
4
14,513
54,041
21,473
502
2,270
92,799
50
2,800
2,850
0
112
5
117
5,286,981
1,703,859
1
8
5,700
15,000
350
21,050
30
30
3
3
0
3,841
0
0
0
3,841
0
2,800
2,800
0
112
5
117
564,807
1,040,315
1
8
12
12
3
27
0
0
0
0
0
33
0
0
0
33
0
3
3
0
0
5
5
8,331
20,501
0
0
5,688
14,988
347
21,023
30
30
3
3
0
3,808
0
0
0
3,808
0
2,797
2,797
0
112
0
112
556,476
1,019,814
Air Load
Reduction
(lbs/vr)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
3,078,397
1,343
B-96
-------
Cost Effectiveness Analysis for PSES Option 2 (Appendix B)
B/D Indirect Discharge Facilities
September 8,1994
Facility Poll.
Code Code
Total B/D Organics
for Indirects (Ib/yr)
Raw Loadings
(Ibs/vr)
6,990,841
308 Quest.
Current Load
(lbs/vr)
1,605,123
PSES 'Option 1
Proposed Load
Obs/vr)
28,832
Water Load
Reduction
(Ibs/yr)
1,576,290
Air Load
Reduction
Qbs/yr)
3,079,741
Footnote:
(1) The following B/D indirect facilities do not discharge process wastewater
containing the organic pollutants that are candidates for
regulation. These facilities are, therefore, not included in
this table.
Facilities: 30007,30019,30059,30209,30212,30221,
30232,30241,30279,30324,30357,30370,30401,30493,
30569,30597,30612,30633,30652,30766,30872,30915,
31071,31078,31119,31133,31138, and31153.
B-97
-------
-------
APPENDIX C
CALCULATIONS FOR COMPUTING AIR EMISSION REDUCTIONS
C-l
-------
-------
PROJECT
cnnicrr
CALCULATION SHEET
CALCNQ.
DATE.
CHECKED
JOB NO.
OF.
.SHEETS
"bit?
fc.7/- E iW
^
Fbr
net be.
in. laloit- V2-
3og>
•
-(he.
«p
o«ui.
for
-rrzrm
J
were.
Ahcdr
Table 3-2-
wa.sk
-------
RADIAN
COKfOKJLTION
CALCULATION SHEET
SIGNATUHg Mft yU £. . U| 11)g-H" DATE
SUBJECT
• -
C-l/i I J
JOB NO.
Ai
r
SHEHT_
CALC. NO..
_DATE_
&y%-
OP
_SKEHTS
&&-'
S
B
3
S)
£
p
R?r
AJ&.
N/6
Open ETQ IN i
-brt . .—
/O
-for
) fcr
at
ft>\JL *fa£iliffvi
a!)
f"
C
&-A CLU
lead
-fo brdo^
05-
' to b ib
0£- Cpen 65?.
£•
/is
0
-------
CALCULATION SHEET
SIGNATURE.
PROJECT—
SUBJECr__
OATE_
. CHECXEO.
CALC NO..
OATE_
JOB NO._
SHser -3/3
OF_
.SHEETS
pO//Cu/tZK/S /AJr
«7 /
and
-for
cue
for
m Tabte. 5-2.
c-s
-------
r
RADIAN
COKPOKATIOM
fiifliMnme Mftt^g-J
CALCULATION SHEET
C*LCL NO..
DATE.
Vca Is
JOB wn
H-PrTBTZ-T- Pnr PHf^/
SHPCT
OP
GAA
JnL
1-
°[
10
114-
0 -OOCM
55
0, CCO2.
0,0001.
37
0,000^
o.cccn.
0,CCO~L
SV:
101.
0,OCO\
0,0001
0,0001.
0,0007-
a ro*o
= o,
C-6
0,0001.
-------
nom
CALCULATION SHEET
SIGNATURE MflyU £ . Ul I I
PROJECT P h Ay /rWdLnh "m I s
DATE
CALC. NO..
v/
JOB NO._
SHEET
OF_
.SHEETS
(c)
wj
trt -
£Q
»»'Vv.
/
3
"I
7o
11
71
102.
10*3
I If
to
O, COS
0. 11.
O. i?Z
o.cooi
0-0
^.
0, 12-
t?.
c.ocfii
c>.c4i
0,010
0.003(0
o.on
O .Olfo
O.Olo
o ,
0 . O2-O
O.COTO
o. cc<
0.0033
0,2.5
Q.ojl
C-7
-------
r
RADIAN
COK*»OKJLTIOM
PROJECT-
SUBJECT.
CALCULATION SHEET
g..
DATE_
i~cfl Is
AiV g-
CHECKED,
JOB NO..
CALC.NO.
.DATE.
OF.
.SHEETS
V
/f
12.
IS
Z5
3-5
fot
^o
17
/S
D^u'kd
O.Co
O.co
0,00
Oc9D
0,00
^,00
0,CD
OcOO
0,00
=. O.oSO
C-8
-------
C-DHVOB ATI <
SlGNATUHg
PROJECT
SUBJECT
CALCUUT10N SHEET'
OU.C.NQ.
PATE
JOB NO..
Aa
r
SH£:Er
2/l.
DATE.
OF_
.SHEETS
Op
en EG. vs-
li-H\
i.
~~io
10
-------
RADIAN
T IOM
SUBJECT.
CALCULATION SHEET
CHE<
JOB NO.
CALCNO.
DATE.
OP_
.SHEETS
) pj
J i ° 4- z.c -
3
(o
"I
11
ll&
(50
O.^tZ
0/10
Los
O.to
0/17
I. oo
O.CGl?
/.oo
iv,
[2..4Q - o, T75s/
dok.t$-
C-10
-------
RADIAN
C^M»0«J»TIOM
CALCULATION SHEET
CALC. NO.
PROJECT
JOB NCX
SHEET.
OF_
.SHEETS
w /°+2/'Trefl.1>tenfc
M^Uiled
a,u\ z-
L
^ 2.
3
ss
11
I-}
loz.
o ,032
0,13
0,1*1
Q. IS
0,2.1
131
\
C-ll
-------
-------
APPENDIX D
COST-EFFECTIVENESS RESULTS
USING THE ALTERNATIVE PWF APPROACH
D-l
-------
-------
APPENDIX D
COST-EFFECTIVENESS RESULTS
USING THE ALTERNATIVE PWF APPROACH
The pollutant weighting factor (PWF) method is an alternative to the TWF method for
assessing water-based effects. PWFs are derived from the more protective of either the chronic
aquatic life criteria (or toxic effect levels) or the human health criteria (or toxic effect levels)
established for the consumption of water and fish. For carcinogenic substances, the human
health risk level is 1Q-6 (i.e., protective to a level allowing 1 in 1,000,000 excess lifetime cancer
cases over background). In contrast to TWFs, PWFs are not related to a benchmark pollutant.
PWFs are derived by taking the reciprocal of the more stringent (smallest value) of the aquatic
life or human health criterion or toxic effect level, both expressed in concentration units of
micrograms per liter (jtg/L):
PWF = _L, ifAQ
-------
TABLE D-l
INCREMENTAL COST-EFFECTIVENESS VALUES FOR ALL REGULATORY OPTIONS
USING SECTION 308 SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE ANALYSIS FOR WATER REMOVALS*
Options
Incremental
Annual
Costs
($)
Incremental
Pollutant
Removals
Ob)
Incremental
Pollutant
Removals
Ob-eq)
Incremental
Cost
Effectiveness
(S/lb-eq)
A/C Direct Dischargers
BAT-A/C#1
BAT-A/C#2
BAT-A/C#3
4,237,618
23,938,377
17,573,462
4,894,776
13,535,367
13,768
356,906
533,122
85
12
45
205,744
B/D Direct Dischargers
BAT-B/D#1
BAT-B/D#2
BAT-B/D#3
398,751
358,306
855,343
22,610
22,542
51
16
13
0
25,485
26,649
160,039,509
A/C Indirect Dischargers
PSES-A7C#1
PSES-A/C#2
PSES-A/C#3
40,289,885
27,984,706
22,135,381
38,331,249
12,952,543
825,288
1,119,419
18,672
4,348
36
1,499
5,091
B/D Indirect Dischargers
PSES-B/D#1
PSES-B/D#2
8,600,756
6,415,468
4,378,836
611,615
151,787
77
57
82,878
* Air load reductions are determined from WATER7 emissions estimates, as discussed in Section Two.
Note: No cost-effectiveness analysis was conducted for BAT A/C#4,PSES A/CM and PSES B/D#3 since
this option is designed for COD removal and COD cannot be evaluated on a pound equivalent basis.
D-4
-------
BAT-B/D#1, has a cost-effectiveness value of $25,485/lb. eq.; the proposed A/C indirect
discharge options, PSES-A/C#1, has an incremental cost-effectiveness value of $36/lb. eq.; and
the proposed B/D indirect discharge option, PSES-B/D#1, has an incremental cost-effectiveness
value of $57/lb. eq.
D-5
-------
------- |