United States
Environmental Protection
Agency
Office of Water
Vail Code 4304
EPA-822-F-93-C10
December, 1993
FACT SHEET
FLUORIDE IN DRINKING WATER
Fluoride occurs naturally In water. It is also added to drinking water to reduce tooth decay
State agencies or local public water supply authorities make the decision as to whether or not to add
fluoride to specific drinking water supplies.
Drinking Water Standards
Fluoride in drinking water is regulated under
Section 1412 of the Safe Drinking Water Act
(SDWA). When regulating a contaminant
under this Act, EPA promulgates both a
Maximum Contaminant Level Goal (MCLG, a
nonenforceable health goal), and a Maximum
Contaminant Level (MCL, which is a federally
enforceable standard). The MCL is set as
close to the MCLG as technically feasible
taking costs and other factors into
consideration. When establishing an MCLG,
the Act requires EPA to protect against
adverse health effects with a margin of safety.
The SDWA leaves the question of what
constitutes an adverse health effect to EPA.
EPA may also promulgate nonenforceable
secondary standards which are designed to
protect the public welfare. Secondary
standards are usually based on aesthetic
considerations such as taste or odor.
Fluoride Standards
In 1986, EPA promulgated both the fluoride
MCLG and MCL at 4 mg/l. This level protects
humans from crippling skeletal fluorosis, an
adverse health effect.
At the same time, EPA also set a
nonenforceable Secondary Maximum
Contaminant Level of 2 mg/l for fluoride in
drinking water to protect against objectionable
dental fluorosis (i.e., a staining and/or pitting
of the teeth). While community water systems
are not required to reduce the level of fluoride
if it exceeds 2 mg/l, they are required to
distribute a public notice which advises that
children are likely to develop objectionable
dental fluorosis. In developing the MCL and
the MCLG at 4 mg/l (vs. 2 mg/l to protect
against dental fluorosis), EPA concluded that
dental fluorosis is a cosmetic effect and not an
adverse health effect.
Fluoride Review
In 1992, as part of an ongoing review of
fluoride, EPA requested the National Academy
of Sciences (MAS) to review fluoride toxicity
and exposure data. In addition, EPA signed a
consent decree in 1992 with Citizens
Interested in Bull Run, Inc. concerning a review
of the fluoride standard.
The National Academy of Sciences completed
the fluoride review in August 1993. Among
other points, they concluded that:
• The current 4 mg/l MCLG and MCL Is appro-
priate as an Interim standard pending receipt
of additional data, and
• The question of whether dental fluorosis is
an adverse effect is a decision for regulatory
agencies.
Findings and Conclusions
Based on the NAS review and other studies,
there are no data available at this time to
conclude that the fluoride drinking water
standards should be revised.
EPA has requested that the U.S. Department of
Health and Human Services address whether
dental fluorosis should be considered an
adverse health effect or a cosmetic effect
which may Impact the MCLG and MCL
standards. EPA has also asked the U. S.
Department of Health and Human Services to
explore ways to reduce fluoride exposure
when it exceeds beneficial levels.
------- |