United States       Off ice of        430-9-83-001
          Environmental Protection    Water Program Operations
          A9encV         Washington DC 20460
»EPA     Addendum to
          1982 Needs Survey:


          Cost Estimates
          for Control of
          Combined Sewer Discharge
          to Marine Bays and Estuaries

-------
                  ADDENDUM  TO

             THE  1932  NEEDS SURVEY
                COST ESTIMATES
                FOR CONTROL OF
           COMBINED SEWER DISCHARGE
         TO MARINE BAYS AND ESTUARIES
                March 1, 1983
                 Prepared  by:

Priority ana Needs Assessment Branch (WH-595
        Facility  Requirements Division
     Office of Water Program Operations
    U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
           Washington,  D.C.   20460
               (202) 382-7251

-------

-------
                             i  TO  THE  1382  NEEDS  SURVEY
                        COST  ESTIMATES  FOK  CONTROL  OF
                         wOridlNEO  SEUEK  DISCHARGE TO
                         MARINE BAYS AND ESTUARIES
 i.  PUKPOSE MQ SCOPE

    Tin's report is suomitted in compliance with Amendment  29 of  the
 Conference Report on the FY 1983 Appropriations for  HUD and Independent
 Agencies \Conference Report No. 92-549, Public Law 97-272):  This
 legislation also appropriated  $30 million for control of combined  sewer
 overflows iCSOs) affecting marine waters.  The separate marine CSO fund
 rfds autnorizea in section 201(n)[2] of the Clean Water Act, enacted as a
 part of tne t-iunicipal Wastewater Treatment Construction Grant Amendments
 of  1961(P.L. 97-117).  Section 201(n)(2) states in part that:

         "...the Administrator snail  have available...funds...to address
         water quality problems of marine bays and estuaries subject to
         lower levels of water quality due to the impacts  of discharges
         from combined storm water and sanitary sewer overflows  from
         adjacent uroan complexes..."

    T.iis report is presented as an addendum to the 1982 Needs Survey
 suomitted to Congress on December 31, 1982.  The 1982 Needs Survey
 considered all  categories of need for construction of publicly-owned
 wascewater treatment facilities including all Category V (CSO) needs on a
 Stdte-Dy-State Dasis.  This addendum, extracted entirely from the  1982
 ,-
-------
     Tne  Construction  Grant  Regulation  requires the Administrator to
 estaolisn  priorities  for project applications with demonstrated water
 quality  benefits based upon tne following criteria:

     (1)  Extent of water use benefits  that would result, including
         swimming and shell fishing;

     U)  Relationship of water quality improvements to project costs; and

     (3)  National or regional  significance.

     EPA will soon publish procedural and technical  guidance on marine CSO
applications and the demonstration of water quality benefits.

     Tne dollar needs for each  facility and supporting information are
reported in this addendum.   Included are data related to the combined
sewer system such as total  area,  population  served, and the name of the
municipality.  Also provided is information  on the  receiving water such
as tne type of receiving water, the receiving water name,  and the most
stringent receiving water use  objective.

    All  cost estimates reported here are  expressed  in January 1982
dollars.

-------
 il.  f«ATIu;;AL 5UHMARY OF NEEDS FOR CONTROL OF POTENTIAL MARINE  CSO
     DISCHARGE

     Seventeen States have a total of 115 combined sewer  facilities
affecting the tidal waters of bays and estuaries that are potentially
marine.  A CSO facility is defined as existing treatment works  tributary
to an area served by combined sewers designed to transport both
stormwater and sanitary sewage.  The total 115 CSO facilities serve
16.6 million people, 526,000 acres of urban land, and 1,869 overflow
points.  Tne CSO control needs for these facilities total about
$11.6 billion.

     Taole A presents a national  summary of State needs for control of
potential marine CSO's; the total number of CSO points, combined sewer
area and 19<30 population served in each State; and the total Category Y
needs.

     Nationally, only 10 percent of all  CSO facilities affect potential
marine Days and estuaries.  However, these facilities account for about
31 percent of total Category V needs and 38 percent of the total
population served by combined sewers.  Three States (Massachusetts, New
Jersey, and New York) have estimated marine CSO pollution control needs
greater than SI  oil!ion eacn.

     Figure 1  illustrates the geographic distribution of the subject
comoined sewer facilities, while  Figure 2 illustrates the geographic
distribution of their CSO pollution abatement needs (in dollars).

-------
                                                         Table  A
                NATIONAL  SUMMARY  OF  POTENTIAL  CSO  POLLUTION  CONTROL NEEDS FOR MARINE BAYS AND ESTUARIES

State
Alaska
California
Connecticut
Do lav/a re
Uiscrict of Columbia
Georgia
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
New Hampshire
New Jersey
iJew York
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
Virginia
Washington
U.S. TOTALS 1
Number
ot
CSU Points
2
31
225
53
!39
1
128
14
201
12
266
3^2
12
207
88
.1
1-J7
,8 09
Number of
Combi ned
Sewer Systems
2
1
9
4
1
1
17
1
13
3
25
18
2
2
3
o
10
115
Combined
Sewer Area
(acres)
324
15,660
16,706
8,426
14,713
135
20,809
330
44,033
3,039
101,413
203,269
1,320
47,513
9,544
11,364
27,377
525,975
1980
Population
Served
4,860
473,000
311,064
88,668
489,093
18,210
133,240
2,100
1,285,890
34,080
1,634,202
9,226,386
5,796
1,962,102
220,550
417,815
246,862
16,553,918

Total Needs Estimate
(in Thousands; January 1982 Dollars)
$ 18,388
460,600
581,211
290,836
68,119
4,492
385,228
5,023
1,140,045
62,606
1,706,576
5,270,712*
16,951
804,015
279,200
208,562
289,715
11,592,279
•*,-.
 State of iJew York estimate includes an adjustment of $2.2 billion  in  the  total  Category  V needs estimates
                                                      to $7-8 bil

-------
I////.
AK,
         FIGURE 1. GEOGRAPHIC DISTRIBUTION OF POTENTIAL MARINE CSO FACILITIES

-------
AK//
                                                                                                               NJ
                                                                                                             $1.7066
         NOTE: All needs expressed
               in millions of January
               1982 dollars.
           FIGURE 2. GEOGRAPHIC DISTRIBUTION OF ESTIMATED POTENTIAL MARINE CSO CONTROL NEEDS

-------
 i.i.  FAwU*TY  ESTIMATES  OF  POTENTIAL  MARINE  CSO  CONTROL  NEEDS

       A.   introduction

           THIS  section presents  the CSO  pollution control  needs  for  each  of
 tne 115  facilities potentially affecting marine  bays  and  estuaries.   The
 facility estimates and supporting data are grouped by  State  in alphabetical
 order  and  are  reported in Tables 1 througn 17  in Appendix  A.

         The needs estimates for about 92 percent (106 facilities) of the
 potential  marine CSO facilities were  developed using  an automated needs
 estimation.program.  This program is  summarized  briefly in Appendix  B of
 tnis addendum and described fully in  Appendix A  of the 1982  Needs Survey
 Report to  Congress.  Estimates for tne remaining 8 percent (9 facilities)
 were taken from an available facilities  plan or  similar documents listed  in
 Appendix C.

       B.  Facility Estimates

           The  first tai< in developing  tne facility needs estimate  was to
 determine  wnicn of 1,084 combined sewer  facilities in  the  United States
 uiscnarge  to potential  marine bays and estuaries.  This was accomplished  in
 a tnree-step procedure.  First, the 1982 Needs Survey  inventory of combined
 sewers was searched to identify all  facilities which discharge to tidally
 influenced Days and estuaries.  Second,  the 1982 Needs Survey stream use
 aata was searcned to determine wnicn  CSO areas were classified as tidal or
marine oy  tne State Water Quality standards.   Finally, each facility  with
 an uncertain classification was located  on a USGS Hydrologic Unit Map.  Map
 inspection indicated wnether the receiving water is influenced by ocean
 tides.  Appropriate corrections then were made to the  1982 Needs Survey
data file.  This procedure resulted in the identification of 17 States
naviny 115 CSO facilities affecting tidal bays and estuaries that are
potentially marine.

      Tne  taules in Appendix A are presented  in two  parts.  Part A reports
 tne location of the facility,  the characteristics of the comoined sewer
service area as well  as the estimated CSO control needs,  and the basis for
 tnat estimate.   Also reported  in Part A is the general type of receiving
water ana the receiving water  name.

      Eden facility appearing  in Part A of Tables 1  through 17 is described
as follows:

      i.   Autnority/Facility Number.   The authority/facility  serving  the
          combined  sewer system.

      2.   Au tnori ty/Fac i1i ty Name.   The official  name of  the  authority with
          major responsioility  for operation  of tne  combined  sewer system.
                                                                s-we
         system is iocatea.

-------
      4<   lonioined  Sewer  Area.   The  area  (in  acres)  served  directly  by the
          combined  sewer  system.

      'J-   Comoined  Sewer  Population.  Total number of  people  residing  in
          tne area  drained directly  by the combined  sewer system.

      °-   Receiving Water Type.  Physical classification of the  receiving
          water according to general characteristics.  Possible  types  are
          estuary /bay or ocean.  Freshwater systems'  (i.e.,  streams and
          lakes) are not included in these tables.

      7.   Receiving Water Name.  Name of major receiving water which is
          subject to periodic combined sewer overflow.

      3.   Needs.  Estimated capital needs for CSO control in  thousands of
          January 1982 dollars.  These estimates are total remaining needs
          and include an allowance for planning and design as well as
          construction.  The development of these needs estimates is
          discussed in Appendix B.

      Part B of the tables presents details of the basis of estimates  and
tne generic receiving water use.  This information is provided because it
was used  in tne needs estimation program.  The estimation procedure
involved  four general  steps:  (1)  identification of the major water body
segment receiving CSOs in a metropolitan area; (2) identification of  the
State designated stream use classification(s) for the segment; (3)
matcnin-j  of each State stream use  to a generic stream use;  and (4)
estimation of the level  of CSO control  needed to maintain the stream use.

      Eden designated item appearing in Part B of Tables 1  through 17  is
defined as follows:

      1 •  Ajznori ty/Faci 1 i ty Numoer.   Same as  Part A.

      ^-  basis  of Estimate.   Each  Category V  needs estimate is based
         either on a facilities plan or  on the Category  V needs estimation
         program (NEP).   The needs estimation program estimates the  cost
         of CSO control  necessary  to protect  the State designated
         receiving water use and compares this cost  to the  alternative
         cost of sewer separation.   The  least cost alternative is then
         selected.   The  six  possible basis of estimate are  defined as
         follows:
         i.    *es*he*1cs - V.'E?

         b.    Public  Health - ME?

         c.    Fish and  Wil-di-ife  -  NEP

-------
    a.    Recreation - fJEF

    e.    Sewer Separation - MEP
         Facility Plan
3.   Limiting Generic Use.  Tin's is tne general description of the
    most stringent, receiving water use which controls the required
    level  of CSU pollution control.  The generic use is a function of
    the official State-designated Water Quality Standards.

-------

-------
              APPENDIX A
STATE TABLES WITH FACILITY ESTIMATES OF



      POTENTIAL MARINE CSO NEEDS

-------
                         I'AKT  A
       -ir  / i ACILITY
hllNtlEH         MAKE
                          NEEDS SUUVEY

                          ALASKA
           BSTIIIATt  OK NAhlNE  CSO COHTHUL HEEDS
CITY  HAflK               	   CODIIINED  SEWEH	
                         AHtA  (AC.)     POPULATION
 0^-1,102-001   .IIINEAU,  1)0 l(OUl, II  UK
 02-012^-OUI   l.HtLOVA, C1TT 01-

ST ATI  TOTALS
                                    JUNEAU
                                    CORDOVA
                                 32U
                                   M
U,BOU
   60
                                                                     321
                                                                                  4,860
                                                                                                                   flikCII  I,  IVbJ
                                                                                                                   TAULL  1
                  HtCtlVIKG  UiTKU	
                    HAflt
                                                                                             TYPE
EST/UAY   UASTIHEAO
EST/BAY   PRIHCE  WILLIAM SOUMU
(1  1000)

  Jb, tbl
     i'n

  IB.JUU
                                 PAKI  8

                        AUIMOKlTV/FAClLlTY
                              NUMbtK

                           02-oio<;-ooi
          DESIGNATED RECEH/IMG  WATER USE L  8ASIS OF  NEfcOS ESTIMATE

                BASIS  UF ESTIMATE                     LIMITING GENbHIC USE
                                                    RECKtATIUN - NcP
                                                    KECKrATlQN - NcP
                                                       SHELLFI SH  PROTECTION
                                                       SHELLFISH  PROTECTION

-------
   AUTHORITY / FUCILITK
                    NAHI:
 o«. 20 12-002

STAlK 'I01ALS
C1T1
                                   HKliUS SUHVBt

                                CALlKumilA
                   KSTlfUTK Of IUU1HE CSO COHTHOL KKBUi
                                  ----  COBBINED StMtB  ----
                                  AhK»  (AC.)     POPULATION
Clt.Cu
             MtANClSCU
                                      IS,660

                                      1^.660
                                            M7J.OOO

                                            173,000
                                                                                                                       rUMCM  1,  141* J
                                                                                                                       TAULE 2
	HKCKJVIMU
 TTPE     HANI!

KST/bAT  SJ.M fHAMClSCU DAI
(t  1000)

 460.600

 460.60U
                                     PAKT

                                    Y/l^A
                                  NUMdEK
                              RECEIVING WATfcR OSfc  t  BASIS OF  NttOS ESTIMATE

                        bASIS UP ESTIMATE                   LIMITING GENiRIC USE
                                                        FACILITY  PLAN
                                                                                              SHELLFISH PKOreCTICN

-------
                                                                                                                      HAMCll  1.  I'Jo I
                                                                                                                            3
MlTllillil TY
 lei.Hi I It
0
a-
()•
0'
0
0-
I)'
0-
0
- 0 1 '.0
-0 ) /O
-01. '11
-Oil 10
-o%i iu
-li) »0
- 1010
-1 1 10
- l.'bO
001
001
001
001
001
00 1
001
001
00 1
KA-.-1UTY
   MAUL
             IH.KIHf  ClTlf
                          in
             KlUIILEfOUN TOWN
             MM  HAVtN LITY 01
             SOII WALK  '1UUN OF
             NliliWltll  Cl'llf OK
             poiiTLAHt TOWN in-
             1.111 LKil  Cl I* L.K
                                           N(,MR
                        IIN 11)1. El'tl1111
                        OfcHBi
                        IIAUrKOMl)
                        tllUULKTOWH
                        MKW IUVKN
                        NOUWil.K
                        (IOIIUICII
                        COHTLAND
                        .SUr.LTOH
                                    COMMKCTJCUT
                                 UK M All INK CSO COHTHOL  NfcKbS
                                      	  CUHUIMEO SKULK 	
                                      AML»  (AC.)     F01-ULAT1UM
J, JUO
300
2,992
H'M
3,6bU
i2b
1,000
21
9 BO
bo, OOo
11,000
110,000
0.011
ai, 300
15,800
23,000
ISO
0,800
EbT/UAY
EST/b».T
EST/ttA»
EST/BAY
EST/BAV
EST/BAY
E^T/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
                                                                  	HtCUVIiG  MATLK
                                                                   TTPE     NKlt .
                                                                               UK1UUEPOHT
                                                                               HUUSITUIIIC H
                                                                               CONHKCTICUT U
                                                                               CONNECTICUT UIVtK
                                                                               MEW IIAVBM  HAUbUb
                                                                               NUHUALK  HAKUOU
                                                                               THANES U
                                                                               CONNECTICUT UlltU
                                                                               HOUSATOHIC R1VLB
                                                                                                        (I  1000)


                                                                                                         I 14,000
                                                                                                          1 I.VjU
                                                                                                         171, JO^:
                                                                                                          JJ.bub
                                                                    16,706
                                                                                  311,061
          r-AHT b


AUfMOKlIY/FACILI TV
                                              uLceiviNG  wAitR

                                         BASIS Ot-  fcSIIMAlt
                                                                                  c UASIS OF Nttus e

                                                                                             LIMllIN'i GtNfcRIC USE
Ov-Ol^O-001
t.V-OJYu-OiM
GV —u o^» I — Ool
P9-OBJ 1-OJl
       Ll-001
      .o-OOl
       u-OOl
       u-OJl
       (,-Odl
                                                      FACILITY PLAN
                                                      (UCHtAIION  -  Hif
                                                      RECKEAIION  -  NEP
                                                      HtCKbATION  -  NfcP
                                                      RfcCKEAIIUN  -  NfcP
                                                      KcCRtATION  -  NbP
                                                      KcCKtAflON  -  NtP
                                                      REC8EAT1ON  -  Hcf
                                                      KECKEAIION  -  NtH
                                                                                SHELLF1SH
                                                                                SHELLFISH
                                                                                FULL bODY
                                                                                SHELLFISH
                                                                                SHELLF1 SH
                                                                                SHtLLFI Srt
                                                                                SHELLFISH
                                                                                SHELLFI SH
                                                                               PHOTECIIUN
                                                                               PROTECTION
                                                                               PKOTECT10N
                                                                               CONTACT  (HfcC.I
                                                                               PROTECUON
                                                                               PROTtCTION
                                                                               PROTECTION
                                                                               PROTECTION
                                                                               PROTECTION

-------
                          I'AHT  A
MITHOMI T«  / IHCIHTY
 -nlBltt:lt         NAWt
 »0-<>00')-IH>1    .BAK.KI, Cii't oh
 Ki-^1017-001   iiLKOHo crrr of
 10-..01M-001   , Klltb ^tULUAGK  ^»^
 10^,10 <•/-<> 01   >ILnINuT,,M U !•  C f

1.TBTI  ItiTAI.b
                     19112 NEtUS SUkVKY

                         DELAMAUE
           KSTIfUTK  OF flAfllNL'  CSO COHTMOL MtKOS
C1T» I4M1V                	   CunuIMtO  SEMtH	
                         AhEA  (AC.)     POPULATION
bKAKollU
niLfoRn
LE«Eb
WILNIHGTOM
  2HQ
  310
  yoO
6 . 9 J6
                                         U.M2I>
                                                          60O
                                                        n.ubo
                                                        2.b20
                                                       80.36B
                                             88,660
                                                                                                                     HiHCM 1.
                                                                                                                     TAbLL 4
                                                                  NAHE

                                                        KST/BAT  MiNTICOKI: K IV til
                                                        rbr/BAY  IUSPILLIOM Hittb
                                                        KST/BA»  LEWIS  BtHOBOTH CAHAL
                                                        tST/DAY  BUAMDYWIIIE CkttK
                                                                                                                                   |t  10OO)

                                                                                                                                       > -411
                                                                                                                                      d'ni
                                                                                                                                     10.'-*^
                                                                                                                                    26-*! Jib

                                                                                                                                    290. bJt,
                                 HAKf  U
                                             OtSlONAIED RfcCtlVINO  WAIcK Uic  t  3ASIi  Oh  N£tl)i, fcbllMATE

                                                                                           LIMITING GENEKIC ust
10-OUOV-OOl
10-001 /-OOl
                     SEPARATION  - NEf
               KEChtAIION - NfcP
               SEWcK SfcPAKAJlUN  - NtP
               KE^REATION - Nfcp
                                                                                           SHtLLFIiH  PROftCllUN
                                                                                           SMcLLFISH  PROTECTION
                                                                                           iHELLHiri  PKOItCTION
                                                                                           SHELLhlifi  PROTECTION

-------
    •ill nil>l, I TY  /   K.U 1LI I'Y
     * II .111 Ml           NAfU
CITY NAfll-
 II  o>nl 1- <>Ul

if:. n:
                          I'  t-NVIh  ..I.UV-
 I'jii^ MH i<:;  SUKV tr

L'Jl''!-  "f   LD i. ii mil A
UP  flAMNl C^O" CONTHoL
     ----   COnUlNbD SKWKK  ----
            (AC.)      I'UPULATION
           it.y u
           m, 71J
                                                                                                                                             LII  1.
                                                                                                                                         TiULt ft
                                                                                   U  HATtll
                                                                  TYI'K

                                                                 f^T/BAt   I'OTudAC  UlYLlC
                                                                                                                                                          (t
                                                                                                              ou, 1 19

                                                                                                              CD. Hi
                                                i       DtSIGNATcJ  KtCclVlNG  WAI iK USi. (.  dAMb Oh NEtUS  tSTlMAlt

                              AJlnUKlI»/f ACIL1TY          BASIS Ul-  fcMIHAIE                       LIMITING GtNtHfC
                                  1l-OJ.1-Oul
                                                              FAClLIIlf  PLAN
                                                                                                           AOUATIC  FISH  L
                                                                                                                                         (G6U.I

-------
                                                                           SUUVLY
   AllTIIGKlTY /  FACILITY
    Mil ,111 Hi         NMIK
                 SAVANNAH, CJTY oh
iTAI't  TOTALS
               KSTirtATr Of  flAHINt  CSU CONTUOL NKtDS
    CITY  MAIH                ----   COBUIKKb  StWKH  ----
                                    (kC.|     I'Ol'ULtTIOIl
                                         SAVANNAH
                                      U'j

                                      135
1U.210

IB, 2 10
                                                                                                                          HAkCU  I,
                                                                                                                          TtbLt «
	NKCKlVINo. MATltt	
 TYPK     MARE  •

EST/BAY  VKKHU*  hlYtK
                                                                                                                                         (» 100U)
                                                                                                                                                             cn
                           AUIHJKJ TY/l-ACIL I 1 Y
                                  NUMDtK
                              13-C
PAKT  b      OtSluNATtD KECtlVING  WATtK USfc  t 8ASIS  Of NEEDS  ESTIMATE

                   U«SIi OF  fcSUMATt                    LIMITING GENERIC USE
                                                        KUiiLlC  HcALTH  -  NEP
                                                                                               RAW  DOMESTIC  MATER  SUPPLY

-------
tUTIIOHl TY / FACILITY
                         I'A, Id  A
                    I'll** NF.EOS  .SURVEY

                          fljmre
           EVT1HATI  OK BAKltlYT^O CONTROL HttDS
CITY NAI1K
                                                                                                               HAkCH  1,
                                                                                                               TAULE  7
NUItltn

2-1 0002-001
2 3 0001-001
.'3 0007-001
23 00 15-001
2 J O017-001
2 3 00:>i>-001
23 0021-001
2 3 0022-001
2 3 OOlo-OOl
23 0051-001
2 3 O0b6-O01
2 3-0097-001
2 301 12-001
23 01 13-001
2 J 01 ld-001
23 012o-ti01
23 0117-001
VT A'l I. TiiTA LS

N A f. K

POM TLA HI) I'WU
SOUTH I'OltTLANU CITY
HlUbtfOHl), CITY uF
WESTBHOOK I>WD
SACO CITY Oh
OAK MAHROU TOWN OF
BATH CITY OF
BELFAST PHD
KENNhllUNK StWfcW CIST
flACHIAi. TOWU OF
HOCK LAS Li CITY OF
6ASTPOHT CITY OF
CALAIS CITY OF
CAHDEN TOWN OF
FALHOUTII TOW1I OF
KITTKHY, TOWN OF
rilOHASTON TOKN OF




PORTLAND
SOUTH PORTLAND
BIKUL'FOHU
WES TB HOOK
BAR IIAai'OH
BELFAST
KENNEBIINK
HACIIIAS
uOCKLAMlj CITY OF
EASTPORT
CALAIS
CAHD£N
HLHOUTII
RITTEBT
THOH ASTON



AHLA (AC.)
1.77S
2,521
^.000
162
770
765
1, /OO
100
IbO
250
619
5. 120
650
77
110
32
20,809


POPULATION
5U,OOu
11,000
12,000
3,500
7,500
2,775
9,500
600
5,000
3.000
6,675
1.500
3,000
1,000
310
1,100
750
133,210


TYPE
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
tST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY


IECEIVINC UATEfc 	
NAnt
CASCO BAY
CASCO .BAY
SACO BIVEM
PHESUHPSCOT B
SACO BIVER
FBENCllnAH BAY
KENNEbeC ESTUARY
ATLANTIC OCEAM
HOUSAH BIYtB
HACHIAS B1YKB
BOCKLAMD UABBOB
COBSCOUK BAY
ST CHOIX B
PUOBSCOT BAT
CASCO BAY
PISCATAQOA B
ST GEORGE HIKLH


• teuL.
|> 1000)
113, ai7
35^09
11,520
15,123
10.396
29.171
2.621
S.711
5.371
12.B1U
13. 177
16.059
3.391
1.217
1.292
91B
385, 22b

                               f AKI b
                            NUMtitR
                                          DES10NA1EO KtCcItflNG MAI ER  USc t bASIS OF NEtOS  ESTIMATE

                                                 dASIS UF ESTIMATE                   LIMITING GENERIC USE
                          i-ijOi 1-031
                        23-OOil-Ool
                        
-------
                              I'AKT A
   AlirllUIUTf / t ACILITlf
    Niinitt.it          NAHK
                ( AHbUIUut l
C1TI NAME


CAHUHII>UE
             StIIIVRJ

     nAIHfLAMl)
Of lUhlME CSO  CONTUOL  MKKD5
     	  CuHUINtD SEUKH 	
     AHb'A  (AC.)     POPULATION
SI'Al't
                         330

                         330
                                               2,100

                                               I. 100
                                                                                                                        MifcCU 1,
                                                                                                                        TAbLt B
	k EC LI VI Hu  HATtB
 Ttl'E     NAHt

tST/blT  CHOPTAUK
                                                                                        KKELlb
                                                                                      (» 1000)
                                                                                                                                                             CO
                                     PART  t»

                           AUTnOKITV/FAClLlIY
                                  NUMdtK
DESIGNATED RbCtlVlNG WATtR USfc C  BASIS Of  NEfcUS ESTIMATE

       BASIS OF  ESTIMATE                    LIMITING GENERIC USt
                                                        RECREATION - NEP
                                                                                               SHELLFISH PROTECTIUN

-------
A
2 -t_
2',-
2'.-
2:.-
2'.-
2;,-
2 !>-
iiTHithl I'Y
NllrlllLH
10 JU-001
1034-0 111
iOio-ooi
10 72-0 1)1
>u7:>-oui
iUVO-001
>0 91-0 O1
1101-001
I105-001
11 It. -001
IJ2U-001
1231-001
ToTAI b
I'AHT »
/ I ACILITY
NA.1t
1 YNK CITY OK
IIAV fl.SU LL CITY OK
lAWUCNCt CITY oh
HEW ULUFOKD CITY OF
..LOUCKSTKK LITY 01
HULL TOW* OF
< IflbttlDGe CITY or
1 ALL B1VEH CITY Of
liHESUUHY TuUN OF
CHELSEA CITY OF
liHOOKLIBE TOWN Ut
nCTIO DIST COHB
OltEHVILLE CITY OF
1'J»iJ HIEUi MJIIVKY
HAiiSACIIUbLTTS
ESTIHATE
CITY MAHK
LYNN
IIAVEHtllLL
LAWUtNCfc
NEW BEDFOHD
uLOUCKSTKH
HULL
CAHUKIDGE
FALL HIVEH
AHESbUHY
CHELSEA
bHOOKLlNE
BOSTON
SOtlEIIVlLLE
OK IUI11NK
AMLA (
5
J
14
1
3
3
17
1
11
CSO CONTHOL Ntt
ConUINbl) SEHkK
AC.) I-01'ULAl
,570 514.
,000 11,
,200 IS.
.500 101.
300 15.
233 1,
. 1«9 55.
.BIO 92.
500 8.
.217 30.
.190 5fa.
,017 692.
,217 60.
,03J
,,«,
US
ION
ooo
600
000
000
500
500
000
600
BOO
600
200
200
890


TYPE
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
tST/BAY
EST/BAY
tST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
EST/BAY
ftAUOl 1. 1
TibLE 9
HARE
LYNN HAUUOOH
HthHIIUCK fUVEU
SPICKETT BI»EK
BU2ZAHDS HAY
GLOUCESTER HAkBOfe
nASSACHOSETTS BAY
CI1AHLES 8
MOUNT UGPt'BAY
HEMHIHACK KIVEB
HYSTIC H
CHARLES H
BOSTON HA&BOH
HYSTIC R
1U)
NEEDS
(t 1000)
1 1,000
120.' 505
126. 7B9
12.100
6, BIB
162^965
1b,a29
21.307
330^000
21.307
1. 110,
015
AUTHJK1TY/FACIL1TY
      NOHUtH
       :-001
       -001
25-OOA0-001
2b-00/2-OOl
      5-001
      J-Ojl
      1-001
i5-01ul-U01
25-01o5-031
25-Olio-uol
      b-001
      i-001
     RECEIVING ^ATEK OSfc fc BASIS  Of  NEEUS ESTIMATE

UASIS Ur ESTIMATE                  LIMITING GENERIC  USE
                           FACILITY PLAN
                           KECKEATIUN - Nlir
                           HEcrtEAUUN - NEF
                           KECREAT10N - NEi>
                           KECREAIIQN - MEP
                           KcCKEAII()N - NEf
                           FISH L MlLOLlFt  -  NtP
                           RECKEAIION - N6P
                           RECREATION - NEP
                           FISH t WILDLIFE -  NEP
                           FISH C MILOLlrE -  NtP
                           FACILITY PLAN
                           FISH C MILOLlFc -  NEH
                                    RtCREATlON IGtN.)
                                    SHELLFISH PROTECTION
                                    SHELLFISH PROTECTION
                                    SHELLFISH PROTECTION
                                    FULL  ttOOY CONTACT  tREC.I
                                    SHELLFISH PROTECTION
                                    AUOAI1C FISri t WILDLIFE  CGEN.I
                                    SHELLFISH PROTECTION
                                    SHELLFISH PROTECTION
                                    AUUATIC FISH C WILDLIFE  tGfcN.I
                                    AQUATIC FISH t WILDLIFE  iGEN.)
                                    AOUAIIC FISH t WILDLIFE  (GEN.I
                                    AQUATIC FISH t WILDLIFE  (GEN.I

-------
 3 i .1071,-oul
 I I .1(111 l-ODl
 J I tiO'Hi-OUl

jTA'll   TOTALS
/ KAC1LIIV
      NAIU:

  I.IL'ltll UuAUIl Lit- Jt.Ll
  I'OHTb MOUTH  CITY oK
  .OHtHSUllHTII CITY of
                                         CITY
                      I9HJ MKEOS  SUNVEY

                        HKW IIAHPSIIIHK
           ESTIMATE OK HAMTNl CSO CONTHOL lltEDii
                          	  COnillNtO  SEWEH	
                          AHti  (AC.)     POPULATION
IXtTKII
POIITSBOUTII
  SOU
1. 389
1. 150
                                                                         3.039
 V.OtlO
lb.000
 9,000
                                                                                       34.0UO
                                                                                                                           NAMCII  I.  IV.u
                                                                                                                           liULt to
                   MATtH
 TYPE     MARE

CbT/UAY  SOUAHSCUTT
esr/BAY  PISCATAUU*
KST/bAT  SALNUN FALLS
                                                                                                                                          (*  IOUO)
                                                                                                                                                              f\)
                                                                                                                                                              O
                                        HART ti      OcSIGNAIcO RECEIVING  WATER USE  I BASIS Uh NEEOS ESTIMATE

                              AUlMLlRlTV/FAULIT*         BASIi OP  ESTIMATE:                    LIMITING GENERIC USE
                                 3J-CCbi-OJl
                                 JH-OOSK.-OCH
                 HtCKEATION  - NtP
                 RtCRtAlIUN  - NEC
                 HcCREAIION  - NfcP
                         SHELLFISH PROTECTION
                         VlELLFlSrl PROTECTION
                         SHdLLFISH PROTECTION

-------



Mil IIOHITY
NlinUtK
1H~ loUS-OU 1
.11- nm<*-0i) i
i M- Ull>_>-00 1
1 M- 111 90-001
3i-ii n-ooi
3M-i i b8-ooi
3i- 1 u.b-oo;
au- i 1*5-001
31-1 1U7-OOI
3 1- 1 1 'JO -001
31-1.; .12-001
3i-l.< J5-001
3l-IV45-t>01
3i-iv->s-oo:'
3 t~\J 66-001
31-11 16-002
31-Kt 21-001
3'l- 1321-002
3 t- U21-OOJ
3'4-|J'>6-OOI
J1-IM25-001
3'I-|117-O01
J1-l1->3-001
3'1-| UKS CITY BAYONNE
CtllTEUKT BOHO Of
ci I CK:,J i/t PAHK BOku
E NEWAIIK UOHU UK
EI-.JICWATE U BGHO OK
El 1 ZABETII CITY Of
GurTt)Nbt:nu TOWN ut
IIAIIHISON TOWN Of
HlillGKEN CITY
T>
NtilClll UkdCKh TW1'
PtilTH ABOOY CITY Of
UkloM CITY SA
WU-.IIAWKEN TWP
Ml .T NY HUN STP
Jt.ilSKY CITY SA-tAST
MbU BRUNSWICK CITY

CAR I B
tins KEEiin suit
HEW JEMhtY
KSTIflATK OK BAHINt CSO
•BI BANCtt 1.
TibLt 11

CONTHOL NEEDS
CITY M&Mt 	 COIIDIMED SEWKII 	 	 	 ui/r-hiufyr u i t-vu
AHtA (AC.) I'OruLATIOM TYPE MAKE
LITTLE fEKHY 20,Sb1
.It hit T CITY 6.582
KtWAUK 2b.781
UAIIUAY q 15
UAYONNE 2.iOO
CAHTE8ET 1,662
currsiut PIMK itob
LAST MEUAHK 59
tDGEWATKII Oia
ELIZABETH 1,118
bUTTLUOKHU |QM
HAUUISOK 1,016
HOUOKEH 1)00
SOUTH KEAHNT 1,476
LINDEN 945
MtWAlIK 11,»-liVO-UJl
3s-l22<;-OJl
J-.-1235-Odl
3<.-l<:-.l>-O()l
3-i-12bs-OJi!
i'.- l^oo-OO I
3<.-13lo-0.>2
j'>-li2'i-'jji
j^-l j2^-ou<;
3^-1 3^*1 -OJJ
3<,-13^fc-011
3<.-I
1,706.576 >-•





























-------









I'lll.' Nt:tl).S ^UhVK

neu Y( 1'uOI-OOI
.16 2001-O01
,»6 2»01- 00'.
K, ?OOI-00<.
36 21)01-00 /
J6- 2n01--00o
.16 2001-00-1
16- 2001-0 10
36 2001-011
36-2001-0 12
36- 2001-01 i
)6- 2001-01'!
J6- 3002-001
36 3n 19-001
3«.- 3056-001
36-3117-001
SI A'JE TOTAL!.


/ t kC I LITY
NAfll.
UliKKAII »!'
ttllKEAU OK
tl.lKUf.0 oK
H./HhAU OK
HI! It KAU OK
BUREAU OK
UHKEAU OK
UllHEAU OK
bilhtll) OK
UiiUEAU OK
BUHK.AU Of
BIIHL'&U OK
UIIUEAU Ot
bllllEAU OK
Bl A CON
['..IICIIKttl':.
cl'IY N A fH

WPC UbU YOHK
UI'C HUNTS POINT
UPC UI'T Ull A^'lOllIA
UI'C NUU YOIIK
UPC NEW YOHK
UPC UP1 UK BHOOKLYN
WTC UIT UK BROOKLYN
UPC UPT UK SVATEN ISLAND
UPC LP'l Uh BIIOOKLYN
UPC DPT Ull LHoOKLTN
UPC UPT WH OUt^bNS
UPC HtW TOHK
WPC NEW YUHK
WPC NEW YOBK
UCACON
It CITY OK POUGIIKkEPSIE
NIKIlUhull CITY OK NtWflOKC
Y..NKE1CJ DP



W YOMKEKS



__ _ _ — t'i\ MH I M
L f\ *. t U fc- L.
^-WnillBii^t^ _r t. • t. II 	
AKK.A (AC.) POPULATION
16, 719
17, BOO
16,100
15,960
23,132
5,700
3,500
15,000
11,200
12,610
16,300
6,015
21.913
5.500
3,100
2,300
2, 110
2.300
203,269


HART U DESIGNATED KhCtlVING WATER








































AOIHOK1 IV/FAclL 11 Y
NOMutH
>6-20Ol-J(H
J6-2001-J02
36-^001-003
36-2001-00^,
3o-2uoi-ao3
.»6-20f l-03o
36-2OO1-JO7
J6-2001-008
36-^^0 1-J09
J6-






















-------
AUTHORITY
 NUllllKK
  I -1)0711 -001
STA1-- 1UTAI.S
                FACILITY
                   MAHK
             » uub HA If CITY  01-
             N OK TH UB»D  CITY  <
                                       CIVY
                                                                  NKEOS SUH»KT
           ISTIBATt  Of  tIARItlE  CSO COMTWUL  NtEDS
                         ----   conumto stuKR  ----
                               (»C.|     PUPULITIOK
COOli  UAY  CITY
NORTH  MEND
1 10
910
                                                                      1,320
                                                                                  2.2K3

                                                                                  i.,796
                                                                                                                     HA HUH 1,  196 j
                                                                                                                     TABLL 13
                       	HtCLIVIMU WATCH
                        TYPE
EST/IUI
EST/DAY
COOS  BAY
COOS  BAT
                                       Kttbi
                                     (» 1UOO)
                                       PAHT o

                             AUllUKllY/t-AClLlfY
                                   NUMDtK
                                tl-OUV't-COl
                                                           RtCcIVlNG MAIER  USt  C bASIS  W  N660S tSTlMAIE

                                                      BASli OF  tSIIHATE                   LIMITING GENERIC USE
                                                      KECKtATIUN  - NEP
                                                      SfcMtR iEPAKAIION - NfcP
                                                       FULL  BODY CONTACT (REC.I
                                                       FULL  BODY CONTACT (REC.I

-------
                             PAhT  A
              / FACILITY
                    HAMS
                                               1-KMHSTLVANlA
                                   ESTIMATE OK (1AK1NE CSO CONTROL NKEDS
                        Cin MANF                	  COdblNtU SEMEB  	
                                                 AUtA  (AC.)     POPULATION
                                                                                                                      HA yell 1,  19bJ
                                                                                                                      TAOLt 14
 <( 2-OHH2-00 I
 M2-O09M-001
STATL  1OTALS
LI LCOItA
PlIILAOCLPHIA WI'C U1V
CIIL^Ttll
I'll I LA DELI'HI A
 1.913
4t>.bOU
                                                                     MV.tlJ
                                                                 1.926.170

                                                                 1.962.102
 TTPK

EST/BAT
EST/bAI
HtCtlflKG B»TtB	
  »LHt

  DKLAMAit kl¥ tliTUAUI
  DELAHABE HI ft*
(»  10UO)

 2i,39^
 778.623

 BOM, 011,
                         fAKT b

               AUfriUKlIY/FAC1L1 IY
                     NUMbtK

                  W -OudJ-OJl
                                                     OESJGMAltD  KbCelVING  WATfcR USE C  BASIS OH NEEDS ESTIMATE

                                                           UASIi OF tSUMATb                   LIMITING GENERIC  USfc
                                                           FISH  L  rflUULlf-L  - NEP
                                                           FISH  t  WlLbLIFE  - NEP
                                                                                 HARM MATEK FISHERY
                                                                                 WARM WATER FISHERY

-------
   »n mom 1»
    NII mi i H

 'I 'I -Oil I'i -Oil I
 'l II (11120-001
 'i 'i o,IJ2 -00 I

if A I h  TOT* 1 '.
    NAUli

N i  NIOKI  LIT*  or
I'kUTUCKfcT
HMII1»(.AN. liA'
           I'lIU'  NEHIS  SUIIVEY

             Mlolib I SLA Mil
KSTlNATt  Uf""flAHlNK CUO COMTHOL Mh'tUS
                	  ClinUINb'O SEMIiH	
                I.I.KA  (AC.)     HOI'ULATIOH
        Nt KI'OHT
        PAMTUCKKT
        l'Ki)Vl DtMCt
                          U
                      J.291
                                         y, ;>
 io,oou
 77.000
11  1.550
                                                        220,550
                                                                                              HA Ml II 1,  l'«. I
                                                                                              TAbLL IS
                                                                             HtCKIVIMi; WITKU
 TTHK

KST/UAY   NtVPOKT lUHI.uUH
EST/BAY   BLACKSTOHl: U
tST/8»Y   1'HOVIUtHCt U
  Xltbl,
(t  1000)

  1J./OU
 11'(,0uo
 m /.uuu
                                                                                                                                     ro
                                                                                                                                     en
                                                 ust t
            rv
NUrltJLK
                               L>F  tSJJMATt
                                            ot- NEEDS  ESTIMATE

                                              LlNIIINl, UtNtKIC
                                   PLAN
                        rACILIfV  CLAN
                        FAC1L1IY  fLAN
                                              HULL BUOY CUNTACI  IRcC.t
                                              SHtLLFlSN PROTECTION
                                              SHELLFISH PROTECTION

-------
                 —     a » 3
              .10     » ^ »
              JO     j r* ~
              *t o      »  «  »
              JJ —     a f 3
              a        o IN —
           a
           o
 -S

 S 4l
 -I -1
 a a
VI
2
a
          -1 14 i
          3 w 3
          O z
          u —
             a —
          OS'
             3 U
          o u «
                      .a a  u
                       C E  H
                       « <  O
                         .
                       f. I- H
                       '.I « VI
                      i" VI

                      M 3
                      w M
                      z I-  a
                      o a  x
                      c a  <
                      — i  X
•.1
   A.

U O


a **
                                                                                         26
                                                                                                         I     2
                                                                                                         ta*     UJ

                                                                                                         I-     U
                                                                                                        LU     O

                                                                                                               2
                                                                                                        •-U     Z
                                                                                                        2     -"
                                                                                                        31


                                                                                                        -J
                                                                               <    JJ
                                                                               I    »-
                                                                                     <

                                                                               *j    r
                                                                               2    -•
                                                                               •••    ^

                                                                               >    vi
                                                                                                        <
                                                                                                              i/i
                                                                                                        a    -
                                                                                                        2
                                                                                                        O
                                                                                                x u u
                                                                                                   'JJ UJ
                                                                                                C9 » te
                                                                                                   o o
                                                                                                r a x
                                                                                                vi a. i

                                                                                                • X

— 2


2
                                                                                                                       O  T O
                                                                                                                       O  O O
                                                                                                                        I   I    I
                                                                                                                       O O  C
                                                                                                                        I   t   I
            - =     - ^ C.     p
            e c     o o —     ?•
                      ft S* J",    f.

-------
  AilTIIOHI TT
               I-AC)L1T»
-> I dU IU-Ol)l
b ( ttOllO-001
b » oiuo-ooi
b 3 - ») 1 1') -0 01
b J -OUl

b J-i)71b-001
 b 1-J920-001
 b 3-0990-001

STI.TIJ TOTALS
                            I'AKT  A
AMkCltUTEj  liU'l' I". W.
IlKI. LTHI.MAn ,  CITT Of
IILAINb  M/.rtH f. bgWhH
IIHEtlEIITON,  CITT OK
•.DNtlNDS  1'WU
ni>yui;.B, CITT  or
HAHTSVlLLt,  CITT Of
.-.KTHO-StATTLE
.>LTI)l-U., CITT  OF
I'OHT ANGELLS.CITY Of
                                       CITY MAn^
          I'll!.  NEED!)  SUUVET

             MA.'.lll NuTON
EbTlKATE OK NAH1NE CSO CONTUOL  NEEDS
              	  COMBINED SEHEH	
              A lit A  (AC.)     POPULATION
                                        HLLLlM<;ifkn
                                        HLAINE WA 9U230
                                        liKkHENTON
                                        LDrtUHlC,
                                       HAHYSVILLE
                                       SEATTLE
                                       VI ANGELES
                                                                                                                     rUKCII  1,
                                                                                                                     TAbLt 17
                                                                                                                               ISbJ
122
1.101
300
1,932
2,100
333
320
19,000
1.280
289
9IU
3,998
U11
9,616
21,600
1.000
1,300
19b,000
6,500
6,116
EST/BAT
EST/BAT
EST/OAY
EST/BAT
EST/BAT
EST/BAT
EST/BAT
EST/BAT
EST/BAT
EST/BA T
                                                                                              	UECLlVlMt,  MATE*
                                                                                               TJPE     NAHt
                                                      uutnts ciuxntu
                                                      DELLIHUIIAH BAT
                                                      UHATTON IIAbBOM
                                                      PUUET SOUND
                                                      HJiiKT SOUND
                                                      CHEIIALIS RIVEU
                                                      EUEI  SLOUGH
                                                      PUGET SOUND ET.  AL.
                                                      BUDD  INLET
                                                      ST OF JUAN DL TUCA
                                                                    27.377
                                 216,862
                                          t. JUO
                                         J3.0^7
                                         19. Jbl
                                          i.b7l
                                          G.SbM
                                        112,000
                                         2b,7b!«
                                          B.002

                                        289,71b
                                    l^AKf
                          AOlHtJRlIY/FACILiTY
                                 NUMUtR
          RECEIVING WATfcM USE  t  OASIS OF  NEEDS ESTIMATE

     OASIS OF tSIIMATE                   LIMITING GENERIC USE
                             t>3-O030-001
                             M-ooei-oai
                             53-Olou-OOl
                             53-0115-001
                             43-Ujc.i-O'Jl
                             53-077&-U02
    RECftEATIUN -  NtP
    SEWtft  SEPARATION - NEP
    StwtR  SEPARATION - NEP
    HECKCATION -  NEP
    RECREATION -  N6P
    SL^fc*  SEPARATION - NEP
    RECREATION -  NEP
    FACILITY PLAN
    RECREATION -  NEP
    KECRcATION -  NcH
SH6LLFI SM
SHELLFISH
SHELLFISH
SHELLFISH
SHELLFISH
SH6LLF1 SH
SHELLFISH
SHELLFISH
SH6LLFI SH
SHcLLFISn
                                                                                                        PROTECTION
                                                                                                        PROIEC new
                                                                                                        PROTECTION
                                                                                                        PROTECTION
                                                                                                        PROTECTION
                                                                                                        PROTECTION
                                                                                                        PROTECTION
                                                                                                        PROTECTION
                                                                                                        PROTECTION
                                                                                                        PROTECTION

-------
                  28
              APPENDIX B
DEVELOPMENT OF 1982 CSO NEEDS ESTIMATE

-------
                                      29
                                 APPENDIX B

                   DEVELOPMENT OF 1982 CSO NEEDS ESTIMATE

     A.   Introduction

          A detailed discussion of the procedure, assumptions, and methods
used to develop Category V needs estimates is reported in Appendix A of
tue  13J2  heeds Survey report.  This section summarizes the material
presented in the main report including a discussion of the technologies
considered in development of tne Category Y needs estimates.

        If an adequate facility plan estimate was available for a given
facility, tnis estimate was used as the basis for establishing Category Y
neeus.  Otherwise, Category V needs were established based on one of four
control levels.  The control level  chosen was a function of the
designated receiving water use for the receiving segment.  The rare
exception occurred when the estimated cost of sewer separation was less
chan tne cost of the selected control  level.  In this case, the Category V
needs for that facility were based on the cost of sewer separation.  Both
we control  levels and the associated water use objectives are:

            Level  of Control            Generic Stream Use

            Aesthetics                  Navigation
                                        Agricultural  Water Supply
                                        Industrial  Water Supply

            Puolic Health               Domestic Water Supply
                                        Partial  Body Contact Recreation
                                        Noncontact Recreation

            Fisn and Wildlife           Warmwater Fisheries
                                        Coldwater Fisheries
                                        General  Fish and Wildlife

            Recreation                  General  Recreation
                                        Full  Body Contact Recreation
                                        Shellfish Protection

        The  pollutant removal  objectives and technologies used to develop
         Y cost estimates for the four levels  of control  are described  as
follows:

        1.  Aesthetics.   The objectives  of the Aesthetics level  of
            tc.itrc1  2^  tc  -srncve 'lea tables,  coarse  debris,  and
            40  percent of the annual  BOD and SS  load  generated by a
            combined sewer system.   The  Aesthetics  level  is  considers-

            tiie  minimum level  of  control.

-------
                                 30
             s  level cost estimates are based on a  least cost
    ioptimum) mix of combined  sewer flushing and a  storage/treatment
    system utilizing physical/cnemical treatment.

 i.  Puplic riealtn.  The objective of the Public Health level of
    control  is  to remove 90 percent of the annual fecal coliform  load
    generated oy a combined sewer system.

    Category  Y  Puolic Health level cost estimates are based  on an
    optimum  combination of CSO storage with pumping and chlorination
    of the discharge sized to capture and kill 90 percent of the
    fecal coliform bacteria generated by the combined sewer  system.
    Tnis level  of control will  also result in significant reductions
    in annual BOD and SS loads due to the sedimentation achieved  in
    tne storage facility.

 3.  Fi^sn and Wildlife.  The objective of tne Fish and Wildlife level
    of control  is to achieve and maintain a fishery in the receiving
    water.   This level of control is based on removal  of BOD and  SS
    whicn may vary from 4U to 90 percent depending on the dry-weather
    pollutant contribution as well as background receiving water
    quality.

    Tne needs estimate is based on a mix of CSO control  technologies
    as determined by an automated optimization procedure which
    accounts for site-specific  conditions.   Control  technologies
   considered  include streetsweeping,  combined sewer flushing, and
    storage/treatment systems.   The treatment options include five
   different levels of physical/chemical  treatment as well  as four
   different alternatives for  modification,  expansion,  and  upgrade
   of existing biological  wastewater treatment plants.   The
   optimization procedure selects the  least costly combination of
    tne above technologies that will  achieve the desired degree of
   CSu pollution control.

4. Recreation.   The objective  of the  Recreation level of control  is
   to provide  receiving water  quality  suitable for full  body contact
   recreation as well  as for a viable  fishery.   In  addition to the
   pollutants  removed for Fish and Wildlife,  the  Recreation level
   will  provide for a 95 percent reduction in fecal coliform
   bacteria  generated by the combined  sewer system.

   Cdte9ory  V Recreation level  cost estimates are  based on an
   optimum combination of storage and  treatment sized to capture  and
   kill  95 percent of the  annual  CSO  fecal  coliform load.   The
    crca^eri* jpc;o;i u5cG is  int  $aiiic  as  cne  treatment option
   selected  for Fish  and Wildlife.   This  ensures  that BOD  and SS
   removals  required  for fish  ana wildlife protection will  also be
   ootdinea  at tne  Recreation  level.

-------
                                      31


        3.   CSO Control Technologies

             As discussed briefly above, a wide range of CSO control
tecnnologies are considered in estimating Category V needs.  These
technologies can be classified as Best Management Practices (BMP) or
structural controls.  BMPs are characterized by low capital costs and
nign operation and maintenance costs.  The BMPs considered in the 1982
r^eds Survey include streetsweeping and combined sewer flushing.  In both
cases pollutants are removed from the combined sewer watershed and are,
mere fore, unavailable for washoff to the receiving water during
rainfall/runoff events.

             The structural  CSO controls considered are wet-weather
treatment systems which are required to collect the CSO at individual
overflow points and to transport the intercepted flow to central storage
facilities.  Cost estimates for CSO storage include an allowance for
aeration and for facilitating cleanout during dry weather.

             Treatment options considered in the Category V needs
estimating procedure include construction of new physical/chemical
treatment facilities designed to treat CSO only, and modification,
expansion, and/or upgrade of existing dry-weather biological  treatment
facilities designed to treat both dry-weather flow and CSO.  A total  of
nine different treatment levels are considered.  The first five levels
are pnysical/chemical  treatment systems and the remaining four levels are
various dry-weather treatment system modifications.   A summary of CSO
control  technologies considered in development of Category  V  needs
estimates by  level  of control  is summarized in Table B.

             Grant applicants for the separate marine CSO correction  fund
are not limited to the CSO control  technologies evaluated in  the 1982
Needs Survey  estimation of CSO control  needs.   A detailed study of  site
specific factors may recommend more appropriate and  cost-effective
technologies.

-------
                                                         Table  B
                                           SUMMARY  OF  CSO CONTROL TECHNOLOGIES
                                                 USED  TO  CALCULATE NEEDS
   Level of
                                                      Control Technology
Aesthetics

Public lied I ih

Fish and Wi Idlife

Recreation

Sewer Separation
Streetsweeping

X

Sewer
Flushing
X

X

Storage
X
X
X
X
Treatment^
X
X
X
X
Wet-Weather
Interceptors
X
X
X
X
Sewer
Separation




     1 Treatment options include construction of new physical/chemical treatment facilities designed to treat CSO
      only anwirl concentrators, and high rate filtration.  High rate filtration, the sewer flushing
      equipment, and die swirl concentrator are newly emerging CSO control technologies.

-------
               APPENDIX C
AVAILABLE PLANNING DOCUMENTS SUPPORTING



 POTENTIAL MARINE CSO NEEDS ESTIMATES

-------
                             APPENDIX C

        AVAILABLE  PLANNING DOCUMENTS SUPPORTING  POTENTIALLY
                     MARINE CSO WEEDS ESTIMATES
H.   Boston, Massachusetts

     1.   Kaufman, Herbert L. and Lai, Fu-hsiung.  1980.   "Review of
          Alternatives for Evaluation of Sewer Flushing, Dorchester
        '  Area-Boston," EPA 600/2-3.0-118.

     2.   McGinn, Josepn M.  1978.  "Analysis of Urban Stormwater
          Runoff and Combined Sev/er Overflows in the Boston
          Metropolitan Area,1 Metropolitan Area Planning Council.

     3.   Metcalf & Eddy, Inc.  1975.  "Wastewater Engineering and
          Management Plan for Boston Harbor-Eastern Massachusetts
          Metropolitan Area,  EMMA Study, Technical  Vol. 7 Combined
          Sewer Overflow Regulation," for Metropolitan District
          Commission.

     4.   Metcalf & Eddy, Inc.  1976.  "Wastewater Engineering and
          Management Plan for Boston Harbor-Eastern Massachusetts
          Metropolitan Area,  EMMA Study, Main Report," for
          Metropolitan District Commission.

     5.   Proceedings, Third  Session,  Conference in the Matter of
          Pollution of the Navigable Waters of Boston Harbor and its
          Tributaries -Massachusetts, Environmental  Protection Agency.
          October 1971.

3.   Bridgeport, Connecticut

     Watermation,  Inc., and Kasper & Associates.   1973. "Facility
     r-lan,  City of Bridgeport,  Connecticut Wastewater Collection and
     Treatment Facilities," for the  City of Bridgeport, Connecticut.

«.   ,'tewport,  Rhode Island

     Metcalf & Eddy, December 29,  1971 ."Summary  Report, City of
     Newport,  RI".   Facility  plan  initiated by RI  4/24/74.
     Ron 'Ajcoff of CH2M Hill  was contact.

-------
                             35
  ' City of Philadelphia,
         Sewer Overflow Control," for Philadelphia Water
uepartment, Water Pollution Control Division.

Providence. Rhode Island

i.   Anderson-Nichols and Co., Inc., and Waterman Engineering
     to., iy//.   Combined Sewer Management Report, City of
     Proviaence,  Rhode Island, Study of Sewerage Improvements."

2.   Anderson-Nichols and Co., Inc., and Waterman Engineering
     X0;' ]'^7S-  .steP ]  Facilities Plan Engineering Report,
     «ity or Providence,  Rhode Island."

3.   CE Maguire,  Inc., 1932.   "Engineering  Study and
     Environmental  Inforriation Document  f~r  r-^^e^ c=',v=»*
     Overflow  No.  2  in Providence,  Rhode Island/1 Draft' Report
     to the  riarragansett  Say  Water  Quality Management District
     uommi ssion.
               1'  Galli  and  Hayden,  Harding  and  Buchanan,  1332.
              ary  Design Report,  Volume  I  Pollution  Abatement
     Project  vomined  Sewer  Overflow No. 9,  City  of  Providence

-------
                                 36
 rt.    ban  Francisco,  California

      1.   Malcolm  Pirnie,  Inc.   1980.   "Wastewater  Program  Overview
          for  the  City and  County of San  Francisco,  California,"
          white  Plains,  U.Y., January.

      2.   City and County of San Francisco, Department of Public
          Works, and J.  8.  Gilbert & Associates, 1975.   "-Overview
          Facilities Plan,  August 1975, San Francisco Master Plan
          Wastewater Management."

      3.   City and County of San Francisco, Department of Public
          Works, 1971.   "San Francisco Master Plan for Wastewater
          Management," September 15, 1971.

      4.   State Water Resources Control Board and Regional Water
          Quality Control Board, San Francisco Bay Region (2), 1975.
          "Water Quality Control Plan,  San Francisco Bay Basin (2)."
          Parts I and II, April.

 I.    Seattle, Washington

      1.   Brown and Caldwell Consulting Engineers.   January 1979.
          "Combined Sewer Overflow Control Program," for Municipality
          of Metropolitan Seattle.

      I.   "City of Seattle Department of Engineering Final  Facility
          Plan for Sewage Collection System Modification." February
          1980.

J.   Washington,  D.C.

     1.   CHZM Hill-Williams and Sneladia.  "Infiltration/Inflow
          Analysis.  Anacostia  Main  Interceptor Drainage  Basin."
          District of Columbia,  Department of  Environmental  Services.
          October 1973.

     2.   Hetcalf and Eddy,  Engineers.   "Reconnaissance Study  of
          Combined  Sewer  Overflows and  Storm Sewer  Discharges."
          District  of Columbia  Department  of Environmental  Services,
          Engineering and Construction  Administration.  March  1973.

     3.   Northern  Virginia  Planning  District  Cojmission  ?nd the
          Virginia  Polytechnic  Institute and State  University.' ~
          "Washington f-Tetropolitan Area Urban  Runoff  Demonstration
          Project Grant Application  to  EPA."   Metropolitan Washington
          Council of  Governments Water  Resources  Planning Board.

-------
                       37
O'Brien and Gere Engineers, Inc. ."Tas< 2 Report:
Uterdture ana Data Base Review.  Phase I  Combined Sewer
Overflow Study, Potomac Anacostia Interceptor System."
Department of Environmental Services, Government of the
District of Columbia.  May 1978.

Roy F. Weston, Inc.  "Combined Sewer Overflow Abatement
Alternatives, Washington, D.C."  Water Quality Office, U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency.  August 1970.

Roy F. Weston, Inc.  "Conceptual Engineering Report-Kingman
Lake Project."  Federal  Water  Quality Administration,
Department of the Interior.  August 1970.

-------