TECHNICAL REPORT DATA
                            '(Pttase read Instruction* on the revene btfort completing]
 1. REPORT NO.
  EPA/600/8-88/055
              3. RECIPIENT'S ACCESSION NO.
                   PB88-178926
4. TITLE AND SUBTITLE
                                                           6. REPORT DATE
   Health  Effects Assessment  for Tin and Compounds
                                                           6. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION CODE
7. AUTHOR(S)
                                                           «. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION REPORT NO
9. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION NAME ANO ADDRESS
                                                           10. PROGRAM ELEMENT MO.
                                                           11. CONTRACT/GRANT NO.
12. SPONSORING AGENCY NAME ANO ADDRESS
 Environmental  Criteria and Assessment  Office
 Office of  Research and Development
 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
 Cincinnati.  OH  45268	
              13. TYPE OF REPORT ANO PERIOD COVERED
              14. SPONSORING AGENCY CODE
                EPA/600/22
15. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES
16. ABSTRACT
   This  report summarizes and evaluates  information relevant to a  preliminary interim
 assessment  of adverse health effects  associated with specific chemicals  or compounds.
 The Office  of Emergency and Remedial  Response (Superfund) uses these  documents in
 preparing cost-benefit analyses  under Executive Order 12991 for decision-making under
 CERCLA.  All  estimates of acceptable  intakes and carcinogenic potency presented in
 this document should be considered  as preliminary and reflect limited resources
 allocated to  this project.  The  intent in these assessments is to  suggest acceptable
 exposure levels whenever sufficient data are available.  The interim  values presented
 reflect the relative degree of hazard associated with exposure or  risk to the
 chemical(s) addressed.  Whenever possible, two categories of values have been
 estimated for systemic toxicants (toxicants for which cancer is not the  endpoint of
 concern).   The first, RfDs or subchronic reference dose, is an estimate  of an exposure
 level that  would not be expected to cause adverse effects when exposure  occurs during
 a limited time interval.  The RfD is  an estimate of an exposure level  that would not
 be expected to cause adverse effects  when exposure occurs for a significant portion
 of the  lifespan.   For compounds  for which there is sufficient evidence of
 carcinogenicity,  qi*s have been  computed, if appropriate, based on oral  and
 inhalation  data if available.
 7.
                                KEY WORDS ANO DOCUMENT ANALYSIS
                  DESCRIPTORS
b.lOENTIFIERS/OPEN ENDED TERMS  C. COSATI Field/Group
 s. DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT

  Public
19. SECURITY CLASS (This Report)

  Unclassified
21. NO. OF PAGES
                                              20. SECURITY CLASS fTMspage)
                                                Unclassified
                           22. PRICE
EPA Form 2220-1 (R«v. 4-77)   PREVIOUS EDITION is OBSOLETE

-------
                                             EPA/600/8-88/055
                                             May,  1987
          HEALTH EFFECTS ASSESSMENT
            FOR TIN AND COMPOUNDS
ENVIRONMENTAL CRITERIA AND ASSESSMENT OFFICE
OFFICE OF HEALTH AND ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT
      OFFICE OF RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT
    U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
            CINCINNATI, OH 45268

-------
                                  DISCLAIMER

                                        #
    This   document   has   been   reviewed   1n   accordance  wUh   the  U.S.
Environmental  Protection  Agency's  peer  and administrative  review  policies
and approved for publication.  Mention of trade names or  commercial  products
does not constitute endorsement  or  recommendation  for  use.
                                      11

-------
                                    PREFACE
    This  report  summarizes  and evaluates Information relevant  to  a  prelimi-
nary  Interim assessment of  adverse  health effects  associated  with  tin  and
compounds.   All   estimates  of  acceptable  Intakes  and  carcinogenic  potency
presented  1n  this  document  should   be  considered  preliminary and  reflect
limited  resources  allocated  to  this  project.    Pertinent  toxlcologlc  and
environmental  data  were located  through  on-Hne  literature searches  of  the
TOXLINE and  the  CHEMFATE/OATALOG data bases.   The  basic  literature  searched
supporting this  document  1s current  up  to  May,  1986.  Secondary  sources  of
Information  have also been  relied upon  In  the  preparation  of  this  report  and
represent  large-scale  health assessment efforts  that entail extensive  peer
and Agency review.  The following Office of Health  and  Environmental  Assess-
ment (OHEA)  sources have been extensively utilized:

    U.S.  EPA.   1979.   Mini-Reviews  on  the Cardnogenldty,  Mutagenlc-
    Hy,  Teratogen1c1ty and Chronic  Toxlclty of  Selected  Compounds.
    Prepared  by  the  Environmental   Criteria  and  Assessment   Office,
    Cincinnati, OH.

    The Intent 1n  these assessments  1s  to  suggest  acceptable  exposure levels
whenever  sufficient data were  available.   Values  were not derived or larger
uncertainty  factors  were employed  when the variable data  were limited  1n
scope   tending   to  generate  conservative  (I.e.,   protective)   estimates.
Nevertheless,  the  Interim  values  presented  reflect  the  relative  degree  of
hazard associated with exposure or risk to the  chemlcal(s)  addressed.
                                                          .»
    Whenever  possible,  two  categories  of  values  have been  estimated  for
systemic  toxicants  (toxicants  for  which  cancer   1s  not  the  endpolnt  of
concern).   The  first,  RfD$   (formerly AIS) or  subchronlc  reference dose,  1s
an estimate  of an  exposure  level  that would not be expected  to  cause  adverse
effects when exposure occurs  during a limited time  Interval  (I.e.,  for  an
Interval  that  does not constitute  a significant   portion  of the  Hfespan).
This type  of exposure  estimate has"not been extensively used,  or  rigorously
defined,  as  previous  risk  assessment efforts  have been  primarily  directed
towards exposures  from  toxicants  In  ambient  air  or water  where  lifetime
exposure   1s  assumed.   Animal  data   used  for   RFD$  estimates   generally
Include exposures  with  durations  of  30-90 days.   Subchronlc  human data  are
rarely  available.   Reported exposures are usually  from chronic  occupational
exposure  situations  or  from  reports  of acute accidental  exposure.  These
values  are   developed   for   both   Inhalation  (RfD$j)   and   oral   (RfD$Q)
exposures.

    The  RfD   (formerly  AIC)  Is  similar  In concept  and  addresses  chronic
exposure.   It 1s an estimate of an exposure level  that  would  not be  expected
to cause  adverse effects  when exposure  occurs for a significant  portion  of
the Hfespan [see U.S. EPA (1980)   for a discussion  of  this concept].   The
RfD  1s route-specific  and   estimates acceptable  exposure  for  either  oral
(RfDg)  or  Inhalation   (RfDj)  with  the  Implicit   assumption  that  exposure
b> other routes 1s Insignificant.
                                      111

-------
    Composite  scores  (CSs)   for  noncarclnogens  have  also  been  calculated
where  data  permitted.   These  values  are  used  for  Identifying  reportable
quantities and  the methodology  for  their  development  Is  explained 1n  U.S.
EPA (1983).

    For compounds  for  which  there Is sufficient evidence  of  cardnogenldty
RfD$ and  RfD values are  not derived.   For a  discussion of  risk  assessment
methodology  for  carcinogens   refer  to  U.S.  EPA (1980).   Since  cancer   1s  a
process that  1s  not characterized by a  threshold,  any  exposure  contributes
an  Increment  of  risk.   For  carcinogens, q-|*s  have  been computed,  1f appro-
priate, based on oral and Inhalation  data  1f  available.
                                     1v

-------
                                   ABSTRACT
    In  order  to  place  the  risk  assessment  evaluation  1n proper  context,
refer  to the  preface of  this  document.  The  preface outlines  limitations
applicable  to  all   documents  of  this  series  as  well   as  the  appropriate
Interpretation and use of the quantitative estimates presented.

    Several  chronic   and  subchronlc  oral  studies  have  been  performed  with
several  Inorganic  salts of  tin.   No  adverse effects  were noted  In  rats  or
mice  fed diets containing  2000  ppm  stannous chloride  for 105 weeks  1n one
study  (NTP,  1982).   An RfD of 0.62  mg/kg/day (43.4 mg/day)  was  derived from
the NOEL  In  rats  1n  the  NTP  (1982) study.   This  RfO Is supporte'd by evidence
Indicating  that ordinary dietary  levels of  tin  1n  humans consuming moderate
amounts  of canned food range from 1-38 mg/day without adverse effects.

    A  CS of  28.7  was calculated based on  hlstologlcal effects 1n livers and
kidneys  of rats  treated  with 5 ppm  tin  as stannous  chloride In  the drinking
water for life (Schroeder et al., 1968).

-------
                               ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
    The  Initial  draft  of  this  report  was  prepared  by  Syracuse  Research
Corporation  under Contract No.  68-03-3112  for EPA's  Environmental  Criteria
and  Assessment Office,  Cincinnati,  OH.   Or.  Christopher  DeRosa and  Karen
Blackburn  were the  Technical  Project  Monitors  and  John  Helms  (Office  of
Toxic  Substances) was  the Project  Officer.   The final  documents   In  this
series  were prepared  for  the  Office  of  Emergency  and Remedial  Response,
Washington, DC.

    Scientists  from  the following U.S. EPA  offices provided  review  comments
for this document series:

         Environmental Criteria and Assessment Office, Cincinnati, OH
         Carcinogen Assessment Group
         Office of A1r Quality Planning and Standards
         Office of Solid Waste
         Office of Toxic Substances
         Office of Drinking Water

Editorial review  for the document series was  provided  by the following:

    Judith Olsen and Erma Durden
    Environmental  Criteria and Assessment Office
    Cincinnati, OH

Technical  support services  for  the document  series  was  provided  by  the
following:

    Bette Zwayer,  Oacky Bohanon and K1m Davidson
    Environmental  Criteria and Assessment Office
    Cincinnati, OH
                                      v1

-------
TABLE OF CONTENTS

1.
2.


3.










4.






5.
6.




ENVIRONMENTAL CHEMISTRY AND FATE 	
ABSORPTION FACTORS IN HUMANS AND EXPERIMENTAL ANIMALS . . .
2.1. ORAL 	 	 	
2.2. INHALATION 	
TOXICITY IN HUMANS AND EXPERIMENTAL ANIMALS 	
3.1. SUBCHRONIC 	 	 	 	
3.1.1. Oral 	 	
3.1.2. Inhalation 	
3.2. CHRONIC 	 	
3.2.1. Oral. . 	 	 	 	
3.2.2. Inhalation 	 	 	
3.3. TERATOGENICITY AND OTHER REPRODUCTIVE EFFECTS...'. .
3.3.1. Oral 	 	 	 	
3.3.2. Inhalation 	 	 	
3.4. TOXICANT INTERACTIONS. 	 	 	 	 	
CARCINOGENICITY 	 	 	 	 	 .
4.1. HUMAN DATA 	 	 	 	
4.2. BIOASSAYS 	 	 	 	
4.2.1. Oral 	 	 	
4.2.2. Inhalation 	 	 	
4.3. OTHER RELEVANT DATA 	 	 	 	 	
4.4. WEIGHT OF EVIDENCE 	
REGULATORY STANDARDS AND CRITERIA .... 	
RISK ASSESSMENT 	 	 	
6.1. SUBCHRONIC REFERENCE DOSE (RfDs) 	
6.1.1. Oral (RfDso) 	
6.1.2. Inhalation (RfDci) 	
Paqe
. . . 1
. . . 4
. . . 4
. . . 4
. . . 5
. . . 5
. . . 5
. . . 10
. . . 10
. . . 10
. . . 12
. . . 12
. . . 12
. . . 12
. . . 12
. . . 13
. . . 13
. . . 13
. . . 13
. . . 14
. . . 15
. . . 15
. . . 16
. . . 17
, . . 17
. . . 17
. . . 18

-------
                               TABLE OF CONTENTS
                                                                        Page
     6.2.   REFERENCE DOSE  (RfO)	   18
            6.2.1.   Oral (RfD0)	   18
            6.2.2.   Inhalation (RfOi) 	   20
     6.3.   CARCINOGENIC POTENCY  (q-|*)	   21
            6.3.1.   Oral	   21
            6.3.2.   Inhalation	   21
 7.  REFERENCES	   22
APPENDIX: Summary Table for Tin and Compounds	   30

-------
                             LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
CAS                     Chemical Abstract Service
CS                      Composite score
DNA                     Oeoxyrlbonuclelc add
MED                     Minimum effective dose
NOAEL                   No-observed-adverse-effect level
ppm                     Parts per million
RfD                     Reference dose
RfOj                    Inhalation reference dose
RfDg                    Oral reference dose
RfD$                    Subchronlc reference dose
RfD§i                   Subchronlc Inhalation reference dose
RfD$0                   Subchronlc oral reference dose
RVj                     Dose-rating value
RVe                     Effect-rating value
TLV                     Threshold limit value
                                      1x

-------
                      1.   ENVIRONMENTAL CHEMISTRY AND FATE

    Tin  Is a  metallic  element  that  belongs  to Group  IV A  of  the periodic
 table.   Tin occurs  In  the  earth's crust  as  nine different  minerals.   The
 most  commercially significant  ores of  tin are cassHeMte  (SnO_) and  the
 complex  sulfldlc  ores.
    Tin  with  a  valence  of  +2  and  +4  forms stannous  [I.e.,   tin  (II)]
 compounds  and  stannic  [I.e.,  tin  (IV)]  compounds.   Types of  tin  compounds
 Include  those  that  contain  tin  (II)  and tin  (IV) compounds,  complex  stan-
 nltes   (HSnX_)   and   stannates  (M.SnX,),  coordination  complexes,  organic
            J                      e.   0
 tin  salts  where  the  tin  Is  not  bonded  through  carbon,  and  organotln
 compounds,  which contain ohe-to-four  carbon  atoms  bonded  directly to  tin
 (G1tl1t2 and Moran,  1983).
    Physical  properties  of  tin  and  some  of  Us  compounds  are  listed  In
 Table 1-1.
    The  most  environmentally   Important  processes  for  the  degradation  of
 organotln   compounds  are   probably   photodegradatlon   with   sunlight   and
 mlcroblal  degradation.   At  the levels that organotln compounds  are found  1n
 the environment,  they will  eventually be converted to  oxides  or hydroxides,
 carbonates  or  hydrated  cations  (Blunden and  Chapman,   1982).   The rate  of
 removal  of aliphatic  groups  from tin compounds  reportedly decreases  with
 Increasing  size  of   the group,  and  unsaturated   and  aromatic  groups   are
 cleaved  more  rapidly (Strand,  1983).   In air,  tin Is  commonly  found asso-
 ciated  with dust particles  (Bleler,  1984).   The deposition   half-life  Is
 usually on  the order  of  days for dust particles, depending upon the particle
 size  and  characteristics  (Nrlagu,  1979).   Detection  of  methyl  tins  In
 rainwater  (Strand,  1983) Indicates  that  these compounds  may be removed  by


0106h                               -1-                              10/27/86

-------
























t/l
c
3



S
CJ


£

gj

e

*
,.
_

tf»
0)
5
o
0.
^_
»H
u
g





























^
*•» — ••
k. r- •!
41 — X.

2 "2 -S.
O
^^


en
e •*•
— c —

— • o «
o a. — .
OB




C — ' —
— CO
>— o •— •
oi a.












O











w u.
^•» ^^
U 3 S.
^ u en
E 01 —
|oS


w

^_ ,_
21
41 k.
i— O
O u.
X
w
01
1
Z

CO
^c
<->




^
c
3

g-
£




01

^
3
O
VI
C

o
r-
CM
CM
1
O

CM
CM





CM
CO
CM

..
U r—

fc
o
-C <«


Ol 41
,*_
JZ U
9 *"
u 19

•fi 41
3 S
W
Ol

n: —
en 3


en
-o
so








c
V,

1^1
1
1
o

^>
r-










e
h-


01

^
3
O
v«
c

v§
IT

— o
ja a
3 03
VI ^>




o




















41

^
3


a»
wO
d






CM
O
c
V)
un
i
O
CM
03
CM
00



01

M
O


~
^
'eT
h-
-
O


o
o
o

O"

00




CM
kfl
SO





»
CM


















01

2
•»


o

e><
03





CM

r \
e
Crt

03
en
fln
t
CM

(•«
^~


01
"
o

^g
u

^^
e
H-
0
CM
^•w

a
§

o"

CO





^r
Z

Ol
VI
O
o o
Ol to
^3 A
41
^
^*


^«
in
u
u

£
VI
^•i
§
^

Ol

1 t.
Ol 41

S 0
* °-


kn
f^
CM





^
O

c


CO
1
kT>
1
00
00

p»


41

kW
f^
3
VI
~
^
C
H-

~
^
O3

•"•
CM
O

o



o

CM
^"





CM
03
03
j~

£}
3
W

U

f~
A
1
3n
(O
U
O»


rfl
pMB
g








C


e
i
kf>
on
1
^f
^K
CO
<—


01
•o
kV
^—
3
in

^.
e


^— _
> <

ao


o

CM





^g
X
w*
Of
wt
1
o
u O
Ol 0






pp»
•o
c
o
en

41


8

^HK
^
^^

•o
"e
en


CM
03
CM
03






^
^J

i

*•*
41




U
2
3

O


kO

1
^f
kn




A

r*










^
-2
v%
^^
u
VI
VI
0)


O
'o
u


^^
CM
on




t %
c
v>
en
3=
CO
"

^~
in

03

o



0)
•o

o

*""* £
>. u
c. —
s^
— c
h- •-















































01
^B
J
Ol
o
•c
Ol
•**
u

•o
c

VI
VI
Ol
3
oo
en
p—

in

41

i

e
O)

2

«^j

m
^
fH>
i?

































































«••,
n
03
en
—
e 01
O fQ
f
C >



— 0
— • II

0 <
0106h
-2-
10/27/86

-------
wet  deposition  and  the  volatile  organotln  compounds  may  transport  long
distances.   In  water,  tin has been observed  to  partition Into sediments and
bloconcentrate  1n  aquatic organisms  (Strand,  1983).    Stannous compounds are
unstable  In  dilute aqueous solution.
    Above  pH 6, stannous  solutions  oxidize very rapidly.   The  chemistry  of
tin  (IV)  compounds  Is substantially different.  They  are stable In solution
(Banks, 1969).   Environmental  methylatlon  of  tin may explain the presence  of
methyl  tin compounds  1n  natural  water  and  sediment  samples (Rapsoman1k1s and
Weber,  1985).   Methylatlon  may  result 1n  the  formation of  volatile  tetra-
methyl  tin  [vapor  pressure  100 mm Hg  at 23°C (Perry and Green,  1984], which
may  account  for  the  worldwide  occurrence of methyl  tin compounds  (Rapso-
manlkls and  Weber, 1985).
    Information  regarding the  environmental  chemistry  and  fate of tin and
Us compounds 1n soil could  not be located  1n the available literature.
0106h                               -3-                              10/27/86

-------
           2.  ABSORPTION FACTORS IN HUMANS  AND  EXPERIMENTAL ANIMALS
2.1.   ORAL
    In general,  tin  compounds  are not absorbed well  from  the  gastrointesti-
nal tract.   Volunteers  1n a balance experiment given diets containing  0.11
or 49.67  mg  tin (as  stannous chloride) dally for  20  days  appeared  to absorb
50 and 3% of the tin, respectively,  as estimated  from dietary  and  fecal  tin
recovery  (Johnson and Greger, 1982).   Using  tin 113  (a gamma  emitter),  Hlles
(1974) demonstrated  that  female rats absorbed  2.85 and  0.64X of a  single
oral  dose  (20  mg)  of  either   Sn  (II)  or  Sn  (IV),  respectively.    These
estimates were  based on recovery  of radioactivity In the urine  and  several
tissues 48 hours  after  treatment.  Tin compounds   tested Included  tin  (II  or
IV) fluoride,  tin (II or  IV) citrate, and  tin (II)  pyrophosphate.   Kutzner
and  Brode (1971)  reported  that  rats  and  rabbits  absorbed <2% of  orally
administered  tin  from stannous  chloride.   Kojlma   et  al. (1978)  demonstrated
that dtrlc  acid or  other organic  adds  can Increase the absorption  of  tin
from the gastrointestinal tract  of rats.
2.2.   INHALATION
    Schafer  and  Femfert (1984)   reported  that  data regarding the  absorption
of Inhaled Inorganic  tin are limited.  There have  been reports  of the devel-
opment of stannosls, a benign form of pneumoconlosls  resulting  from exposure
to dust  or  fumes of  tin oxide  (Pendergrass  and Pryde,  1948; Bartak  et  al.,
1948;  Cutter  et  al., 1949);  however, upon examination of  tissues  from  a  man
with pneumoconlosls  who had  been  exposed  occupatlonally  to stannic  oxide,
Dundon and Hughes  (1950)  concluded that  the amount of tin absorbed from  the
lungs  was Insignificant.
0106h                               -4-                              02/04/87

-------
                3.  TOXICITY IN HUMANS AND EXPERIMENTAL ANIMALS

     Discussions  of toxldty In  this  document are restricted  to  tin and Us
 Inorganic  salts  and  compounds.  The  manifestations  of  toxldty associated
 with  these  compounds  are similar and suggest that toxldty 1s due to the tin
 moiety.   There   are  a  number  of  organotln  compounds   that  will  not  be
 discussed  because they  exhibit markedly different toxic  effects,  which are
 not  clearly associated with  the tin moiety, but  are  more likely associated
 with  the organic  compound  per  se  (ACGIH, 1986).
 3.1.   SUBCHRONIC
 3.1.1.   Oral.    DeGroot  et  al.  (1972)  fed  various   compounds  of  tin  to
 weanling Wlstar  rats for  either  4 or 13 weeks.   Groups  of  10 males  and 10
 females  were  fed  diets  containing  0,  0.03, 0.10, 0.30  or  1.0% of stannic
 oxide,  stannous   oxide,  stannous orthophosphate,   stannous  oxalate,  stannous
 sulflde,  stannous chloride,  stannous  sulfate, stannous  oleate  or  stannous
 tartrate for  28  days.  Additional  groups  of 10 males  and  10 females were fed
 either  stannous  chloride  or  stannous  oxide  1n the  diet  at  the  levels  pre-
 viously  mentioned  for   90 days.   Endpolnts  monitored  Included  mortality,
 growth,  food  consumption  and  utilization, hematology,  urinalysis,  serum
 biochemistries,  and  gross  and  microscopic  pathology.   No  compound-related
 adverse effects were observed  among  rats  fed stannic oxide,  stannous sulflde
 or  stannous  oleate  for  4 weeks.   Anemia  and  reductions  In growth,  food
 consumption  and  food use  efficiency were  observed,  however, among  rats  fed
 either 0.3  or 1%  of  stannous  chloride,  orthophosphate,  sulfate, oxalate or
 tartrate;   microscopic   evidence of  liver  damage (homogeneous  liver  cell
 cytoplasm;   slight but definite oval cell  type hyperplasla  of bile  ducts)
 also  was  observed  1n males  and  females  fed  1.0%  of  the  same  compounds.


0106h                               -5-                              02/04/87

-------
Similar  hepatic  changes,   though  of  lesser  Intensity  and  frequency,  were
observed among  rats  fed  0.3% stannous  chloride,  stannous  oxalate or stannous
orthophosphate.   Females  given  stannous orthophosphate  had a  dose-related
Increase 1n relative liver weight at >0.1%.
    No  compound-related  adverse effects were  observed  among rats  fed  stan-
nous oxide  for  13 weeks.  In  the  13-week study  with  stannous  chloride,  rats
fed  1.0% were  killed  after  8  weeks  on   test  because  of  high  mortality.
Necropsy  of these  rats  revealed  anemia, distinct  liver changes  (described
above),  severe  pancreatic  atrophy, enteritis, moderate  testlcular  degenera-
tion,  "a  spongy state of  the  white matter  of the brain" and  acute broncho-
pneumonia.  DeGroot  et al.  (1972)  speculated  that some  of these  changes  were
due  to  starvation.   Poor   appetite  and reduced  growth  were  also  observed
among  rats  fed  0.3% stannous chloride, but  these changes were observed  only
for  the  first  2 weeks.  Thereafter,  growth and food consumption  among  rats
fed  0.3% were  similar  to  controls.   Slight  anemia  (males  only)  and  liver
changes  (described  above)  were  also  observed among  rats  fed  0.3%.    No
compound-related adverse effects  were observed among rats  fed 0.03  or  0.1%
stannous chloride  for  13  weeks.   DeGroot et  al. (1972)  concluded  that  0.1%
of tin  compounds  1n the diet  (22-33 mg  of  tln/kg/day;  estimated by Investi-
gators) was a "no-effect-level."
    FrHsch et al.  (1977)  fed  groups  of  10  male  Sprague-Dawley rats either 0
or 0.5 g tin/100 g  (50  ppm)  food  for  1 month.  Stannous  chloride  was  the
source  of   tin.   Tin-fed  rats  had  decreased  food  consumption  and  growth,
marked anemia and marked gastrointestinal Irritation.
    Dreef-Van Der  Meulen et al. (1974)  fed groups  of 10 male and  10 female
weanling Wlstar  rats diets  containing  up   to  0.8%  stannous  chloride for  13
weeks.   Animals  of  the  test group were accustomed to  the  Ingestlon of  the


0106h                               -6-                              02/04/87

-------
 tin  by Increasing  the  dietary level from 0.1%  In  week 1  with weekly  Incre-
 ments  of  0.1% to  a  final  level  of 0.8% (TWA  equivalent Intake  of  246 mg
 tln/kg/day).   Controls  were maintained on the basal  diet.  During the first
 weeks  of  the experiment  (1-4)  when  tin  levels  were low,  no distinct differ-
 ences  occurred  between  test  and  control  groups.   Effects   attributed  to
 stannous  chloride  Included  slight reduction 1n growth  {males only),   slight
 anemia,  Increased relative  liver  and  kidney weights, gastrointestinal Irri-
 tation,  hlstologlc changes  In the  liver and pancreatic atrophy.  Decreased
 serum  alkaline  phosphatase  activity,  Increased   relative weights  of  the
 heart,  adrenals  and  thyroid,  and activated appearance  of thyroid follicles
 were  observed  among  rats   fed  stannous  chloride,  but  these effects  were
 considered  to  be  of questionable  toxlcologlcal significance.
    Janssen  et  al.  (1985)  demonstrated  that  tin-Induced changes   1n  the
 gastrointestinal  tract  are  Independent  of   food Intake.   Groups   of  10 male
 Wlstar  rats were  fed 0,  250 or  500 ppm  tin (from  stannous chloride)  for  4
 weeks.  A  fourth  group  was  pair-fed  with  the 500 ppm tin  group.  In a second
 study,  groups  of  four  male  Wlstar  rats  were  fed  either  0  or  900 ppm  tin
 (from  stannous  chloride)  for  4 weeks.    Dose-related   decreases  1n  body
 weight, food consumption, and food  utilization  were  observed  1n  all  tin-fed
 groups and  1n  the reduced  Intake  (pair-fed) group.   The growth reduction 1n
 the  pair-fed group was  comparable  with  the 500  ppm  tin-fed  group.   Hemo-
 globin concentrations were  also reduced  1n  tin-fed  rats.   Increased relative
 weights  of  the   stomach,  cecum  and  colon  appeared  to  be  caused  by  the
 decrease  In  body weight, due  either to  food restriction  or to tin feeding.
 Increased relative weight of  small Intestine was In part caused by decreased
 body weight.   Comparison  of the  reduced-diet  group and  the  500  ppm  group
 suggested  that  tin feeding resulted  1n  Increased  absolute  weights  of  the


0106h                               -7-                              02/04/87

-------
small  Intestine.   Changes  Indicative  of  Increased cell  turnover  (Increased
migration  of  epithelial  cells  along  the  flllus,  formation  of  ridge-like
v1ll1,  decreased  number  of  v1H1  per unit  surface) were  observed 1n  the
small Intestines of rats fed tin.
    OeGroot  (1973) examined  the  effects  of dietary  Iron and  copper on  the
hematologlcal  and  growth  changes  caused by stannous  chloride  1n a  series  of
4- to 6-week  studies  on weanling Wlstar rats.  In  a  6-week  study,  groups  of
10 males  and  10 females were fed 0 or  5300 ppm  tin (from stannous  chloride)
1n  standard  diets  or   In diets  supplemented  with  copper or  Iron  or  both.
Significant reduction  1n  growth  and  hemoglobin  levels were  observed  In  rats
exposed  to  tin In  the  standard  diets.    Supplementary  Iron   (200  ppm)  or
copper  (75 ppm) or both retarded these effects.  In  a study where  groups  of
10  male rats  were fed 0,  150, t500  or 1500  ppm  tin wHh  or without  high
levels  of copper  and   Iron  (10  times  the  required  amount),  there were  no
effects on hemoglobin,  serum Iron or  Iron-binding  capacity; the only effect
was  decreased   growth  1n  rats  In  the  two  higher  dose  groups.   In  another
4-week  study,  groups  of 10  males and 10 females  were fed 0, 50, 150 or  500
ppm  tin  (from  stannous chloride) 1n  diets  that  were adequate In copper  and
either marginally  adequate  or high 1n  Iron.   Decreased growth,  food  consump-
tion and  efficiency,  hemoglobin  and  serum Iron were  observed  among  rats  fed
500 ppm,  regardless  of the  Iron content of the diet; however,  these  effects
were  more  severe  among  rats  fed  the  diet  with marginal  Iron   content.
Decreased  Iron binding capacity was observed among rats  fed 500 ppm tin  1n
the diet  with  marginal Iron  content.   Among  rats fed 150 ppm tin,  the  only
effects were  reduced  hemoglobin 1n males  (both  levels  of Iron) and  reduced
body weight  In females (high Iron only).   No effects on  growth  or  the  blood
were observed  1n rats  fed 50  ppm tin  with  any level of  Iron  1n the  diet.   In


0106h                               -8-                              02/04/87

-------
 another  study,  groups  of 10 male and 10 female rats were fed either 0 or 150
 ppm  tin  In diets adequate  In  Iron  with three different  levels  of copper for
 4  weeks.   A  decrease  1n  hemoglobin  and serum  Iron  levels was  observed  In
 rats  fed tin and  3  ppm copper  and  1n  males fed tin with  6  ppm copper, but
 not  1n  females  fed tin  and  either  6  or 50 ppm copper or males  fed tin with
 50 ppm copper.
    Yamaguchl et  al.  (1980) gavaged groups  of  six  weanling male Wlstar rats
 with  0,  0.3,  1.0 or  3.0 mg  tin/kg  every  12  hours for 90 days.   Tin was
 administered  as  stannous chloride In an HC1  solution.   The variables evalu-
 ated  Included enzyme  activities In the  serum,  liver, femur and  kidneys, and
 calcium  content  of the  femur.   Rats  gavaged with  3.0 mg/kg  had significant
 decreases  In  relative weight  of the femur,  calcium content of  the  femoral
 dlaphysls  and  eplphysls,   calcium  concentration,  lactic   dehydrogenase  and
 alkaline  phosphatase  activities  In  the  serum,  and  succlnate  dehydrogenase
 activity  1n the liver.  Significantly  reduced  sucdnlc  hydrogenase activity
 1n the liver  and  significant reductions 1n  calcium  content  and  add phospha-
 tase  activity 1n  the  femur were observed among  rats  gavaged  with 1.0 mg/kg.
 A  slight  but  not  significant decrease  1n the calcium content of the  femoral
 eplphysls was seen  1n  rats treated with 0.3  mg/kg.   Yamaguchl et al.  (1980)
 considered 0.6 mg/kg/day (0.3 mg/kg, twice dally) to be  the  no-effect  level.
    Yamaguchl et al. (1981)  conducted a study with  weanling male Wlstar rats
 to assess the effects  of tin on bone.   Groups  of 10 rats were fed diets con-
 taining  0,  10,  50,  100 or 250  ppm tin  (from stannous chloride)  for 90 days.
 Significant  decreases   1n   serum calcium  and  Inorganic phosphate,  and  1n
 femoral calcium content  and  add phosphatase activity were observed  1n  rats
 fed 100  or  250  ppm.   Rats  fed  50 ppm  tin  had significantly reduced  serum
calcium and femoral caldum.  No effects were observed among rats fed  10 ppm.


0106h                               -9-                              02/04/87

-------
    Savolalnen  and  Valkonen  (1986)   Investigated  the  effects  of  stannous
chloride  on  brain and muscular  chollnesterase  In male  Wlstar  rats.   Groups
of 30  male  rats,  averaging 0.365 kg  In  body  weight,  were  given  0,  0.44 (100
mg/l),   Ul   (250   mg/l)   or   2.22  mM   (500   mg/l)   stannous   chloride
(SnCl_«2H_0)  1n  drinking  water  for  1-18  weeks.   Groups  of  five  rats
were killed and examined  after  1,  4,  8,  12, 15  and 18 weeks of treatment.   A
significant Increase  1n  brain acetylchollnesterase activity was  observed  1n
the  high-dose  group  after  only  1  week  of  treatment.   Dose-related  and
significant Increases  1n  both  brain  and  muscle  acetylchollnesterase activity
were observed among  rats  exposed to  both 1.11  and  2.22 mM stannous chloride
after  18  weeks   of   treatment.   Tin concentration  1n  brain  tissue  rose
steadily over the experimental period.
3.1.2.   Inhalation.    Data  pertaining   to   subchronlc  Inhalation  of   tin
compounds could not be located In the available  literature.
3.2.    CHRONIC
3.2.1.   Oral.  No  compound-related  effects  on  growth,  survival   or  hlsto-
loglcal  appearance  of tissues  were  observed among  groups  of F344 rats  or
B6C3F1 mice  (50/sex/spedes)  fed either  1000 or  2000  ppm  stannous  chloride
In  the  diet  for  105 weeks  (NTP,  1982);   however,  male  control  mice  had
significant lower  survival  than  both low- and  high-dose  male mice (64,  84
and  90%  of control,  low- and  high-dose  males  survived  to the  end of  the
study).
    Schroeder and Balassa  (1967)  gave 5  ppm  tin  as stannous chloride  In the
drinking  water  to  Charles  River CO mice  for life  beginning  at  weaning.
Dietary  tin  concentration was 0.28  ppm.   The  treated  gr^jp consisted  of  54
males and 54  females.   A group of 59  males and 79  females  was maintained  as
controls.   There  were no  compound-related  effects  on growth,,  mortality,


0106h                               -10-                             02/04/87

-------
 grossly  examined  tissues  or  hlstologlcally  examined  tissues  from hearts,
 lungs,  kidneys,  livers  and  spleens.   Although stannous  tin  accumulated 1n
 the  spleen and  to a  lesser  extent the  heart,  no compound-related toxldty
 was observed.
    Schroeder  et  al.  (1968)  gave  5  ppm  tin as  stannous  chloride  In the
 drinking water  to 56 male  and  56 female Long Evans rats for life.  The diet
 contained  0.28  ppm tin.   A group of 56 males  and  76 females were maintained,
 though  because  some  experiments  Involved  "general   anesthesia   and  blood
 letting",  some  of the rats (-20) were  not  necropsled.   Endpolnts evaluated
 In  the  study Included  mortality, growth,  longevity,  serum  glucose, urinary
 protein and  glucose, gross pathology,  and  microscopic  examination of liver,
 kidney, lungs,  heart  and spleen.  The mean Hfespan of females given tin was
 significantly reduced 1n  comparison  with female  controls.  Tin-fed  rats of
 both  sexes  had  Increased  Incidences  of  fatty   degeneration  of   the  liver
 (37/80  treated   vs.  27/88  controls)  and  vacuolar changes  1n  the proximal
 convoluted tubules of the kidney  (26/81  treated vs. 16/88 controls).
    Roe et  al.   (1965) conducted an 80-week  study with  Inbred  August hooded
 rats, but  Interpretation  of  the results  1s  complicated by changes  1n  dose
 schedule and  the  presence  of chronic  murlne pneumonia  1n most of the  rats
 alive from 1 year to  the end  of  the  study.  Nursing  rats were  fed  diets
 containing either  no  tin or 2% sodium chlorostannate  from the time they gave
 birth until  their offspring  were weaned.  The  weanlings were  continued  on
 the test diets  as follows.   Rats whose dams  were fed  2% sodium chlorostan-
 nate  (19 males  and 18 females)  showed no signs of toxldty at  weaning,  and
were  fed 2%  sodium chlorostannate In the diet for 7 weeks,  the  control  diet
 for 4 weeks,  then continued on  the  test diet (2%) for  the  remainder  of the
 study.  A  group of 20 males  and 20 females  was maintained  as  controls.   No
nonneoplastlc effects were observed 1n rats fed 2% sodium chlorostannate. •

0106h                               -11-                             02/04/87

-------
3.2.2.   Inhalation.  Other  than  case reports of stannosls  (see  Chapter  2),
data  pertaining to  chronic  Inhalation of  tin  could not  be located  1n  the
available literature.
3.3.   TERAT06ENICITY AND OTHER REPRODUCTIVE EFFECTS
3.3.1.   Oral.  DeGroot  et  al.  (1973) reported moderate  testlcular  degener-
ation  In  male Wlstar rats fed  1% stannous  chloride 1n  the  diet  for  8 weeks
(see Section 3.1.1.).
3.3.2.   Inhalation.  Data pertaining to  the teratogenldty or reproductive
toxlclty of  Inhaled compounds  of  tin could not be located  1n  the  available
literature.
3.4.   TOXICANT INTERACTIONS
    Tin affects the  homeostasls of  essential  metals  such  as  copper,  Iron  and
zinc.  DeGroot  (1973) and DeGroot  et  al.  (1972)  observed  that  the anemia  and
growth retardation observed  In  rats fed t1n-fort1fled diets  could be retard-
ed or  Inhibited by  Including high levels of  copper or  Iron  (or both)  In  the
diet.  Injection of  tin  and  Iron Into jejunal  loops from  rats  resulted  1n  a
decreased absorption of  water and  Iron  (Schafer  and  Forth,  1983).  There  was
no  effect  of  tin  on zinc  uptake  1n humans when  tin  and  zinc  were  given
together orally 1n  ratios  of 2:1, 4:1 or 8:1,  but  zinc uptake  was  Inhibited
when  tin.  Iron  and zinc  were administered  1n  ratios  of  1:1:1 and  2:1:1
(Solomons et al., 1983).  Oral  exposure to  tin  also  changed  the distribution
of copper, Iron and  zinc In  the organs  (Greger  and  Johnson,  1981; Chm1eln1ka
et al., 1981; Dwlwedl et al., 1980; Chlba  et al., 1984).
0106h                               -12-                             02/04/87

-------
                              4.  CARCINOGENICITY
4.1.   HUMAN DATA
    Data pertaining  to  the carcinogenic  potential  of Inhaled or Ingested tin
1n humans could not  be  located  1n  the available  literature.
4.2.   BIOASSAYS
4.2.1.   Oral.   NTP  (1982)  conducted  a bloassay  on stannous  chloride  with
F344  rats  and B6C3F1 mice.   Groups  of 50 males and  females of each species
were  fed  0, 1000  or 2000 ppm  stannous  chloride In  the  diet  for  105 weeks.
Growth and  survival  were  comparable  among  all groups of controls and treated
animals,  except  that survival  In male  control  mice was  significantly  less
than  that   In  tin-fed   male  mice  (64,  84  and  98% of  the  control,  low- and
high-dose  male mice survived to  the  end  of  the  study).   The  Incidence  of
C-cell  adenomas   but   not  carcinomas   of  the  thyroid  was  significantly
Increased  In  treated male rats  In  comparison  with  matched  controls  (2/50,
9/49,  9/50  In  control,  low- and  high-dose  groups,  respectively).    The
combined  Incidence  of  C-cell   adenomas  and  carcinomas  was  significantly
elevated above that  of  the matched  controls  1n  both low- and high-dose  male
rats  (2/50, 13/49,  8/50  for controls, low- and  high-dose  groups,  respec-
tively).  When  the  combined  Incidence  of  C-cell adenomas and  carcinomas  In
the treated  groups are compared  with  historical controls,  the  Incidence  1n
the low-dose group remains significant but that In  the high-dose  group  does
not.  The historical control Incidence was 11.1%  (32/288),  2.3% (8/288)  and
8.3%  (24/288)  for  combined  adenoma  or  carcinoma,  carcinoma and  adenoma,
respectively.  Since the  Incidence of C-cell carcinomas  or  adenomas  was  not
significantly  elevated  In the high-dose group  In  comparison with  historical
controls, and  since  the Incidence  of C-cell  hyperplasla did  not differ among
control and treated male rats  (control,  1/50; low  dose,  1/49;  high dose,


0106h                               -13-                             10/27/86

-------
2/50),  NTP (1982)  concluded  that  stannous  chloride did  not cause  thyroid
tumors  In  either  sex of either species.  NTP  (1982)  concluded  that  stannous
chloride 1s not carcinogenic to either F344 rats or B6C3F1  mice.
    NTP  (1982)  reported that 2-year  oral  studies  conducted by  Schroeder  et
al.  (1968) on Long  Evans  rats and  Schroeder  and  Balassa  (1967)  on  Charles
River  mice  were  Inadequate  to  assess  the  carc1nogen1c1ty   of  stannous
chloride since only  low levels of  compound were tested  (0.28 ppm In  feed  and
5  ppm  1n  water)  and  since  hlstopathologlcal  examination was  limited  to
selected  tissues.   These  studies  concluded  that  stannous  chloride  was  not
carcinogenic.
    Innes  et  al.  (1969) failed to  observe  an  Increased Incidence of  tumors
1n mice given trlphenyltln acetate by gavage  and 1n the  diet for  18 months.
    Roe et al.  (1965)  tentatively concluded  that diets containing 2%  sodium
chlorostannate or  0.5-1% stannous  2-ethyl hexoate  were not  carcinogenic  to
Inbred  August hooded   rats  (see  Section  3.2.1.).   Three  malignant  tumors
(mammary adenocardnoma,  uterine  pleomorphlc sarcoma, adenocardmoma  In  the
jaw)  were  observed  among  30 rats  fed  2% sodium  chloroastannate.  No  neo-
plasms  were  observed among  30  controls  or  among  rats  that survived  for  >1
year  on a diet  that contained 0.5-1.0% stannous  2-ethyl   hexoate.    Inter-
pretation  of  the  results  of this  study, however, are complicated  by  changes
In dose  schedule  and by the presence of chronic murlne pneumonia  In most  of
the rats 1n the study.
4.2.2.   Inhalation.   Data  pertaining  to   the  carcinogenic  potential   of
Inhaled tin could not be located In the available literature.
Q106h                               -14-                             02/04/87

-------
 4.3.   OTHER  RELEVANT  DATA
    McLean  et al.  (1983) demonstrated  that  tin  (II)  from stannous chloride,
 but  not  tin   (IV)  from  stannic  chloride  caused  alkaline  sucrose  gradient
 detectable  damage  to  DNA In Chinese hamster ovary cells.  Stannous chloride,
 stannic  chloride and  sodium stannate  did  not  Induce mutations  In  repair-
 deficient   strains   of  Badlus  subtnis   (N1sh1oka,  1975).   Tr1phenylt1n
 acetate  and trlphenyltln hydroxide  did  not Induce mutations 1n oral  dominant
 lethal studies on mice  (Epstein et al., 1972).
 4.4.   WEIGHT OF EVIDENCE
    Based  on   the  negative  results  of  the NTP (1982) bloassay  1n both  rats
 and mice,  stannous chloride  can  be classified 1n  IARC  Group 3 or U.S.  EPA
 Group  D, I.e.,  Inadequate  evidence  to  refute or  demonstrate  a  carcinogenic
 potential  U.S. EPA (1986)  Guidelines for  Carcinogen  Risk Assessment.   While
 the  NTP  (1982)  concluded  that  Us  rat  and  mice  studies  did  not  show  a
 carcinogenic  response,  this conclusion  has some weaknesses.   Other bloassays
 while  flawed  are not  adequate for further evaluation  either.  The  Inhalation
 route  has   not  been  evaluated  and  DNA  damage has been  shown 1n one  test.
 These  factors  combined make  the  available  evidence  Inadequate  to  either
 demonstrate  or  refute  a  carcinogenic   potential  for  stannous  chloride  1n
 humans.  Since other  compounds  of tin  have  not been  tested for  carcinogenic
 potential,  tin In general  should be classified  In  U.S.  EPA  Group D,  I.e.,
 not classified as to the human carcinogenic potential
0106h                               -15-                             04/29/87

-------
                    5.   REGULATORY  STANDARDS AND CRITERIA

    OSHA  (1985)  and  ACGIH  (1986)  recommended  a TLV  of  2 mg/m3 for  occupa-
tional  exposure  to   Inorganic  compounds  of  tin  except  stannate  (SnH.).
ACGIH (1986) stated that  the recommended TLV 1s designed  to  protect  against
stannosls.
0106h                               -16-                             02/04/87

-------
                              6.  RISK ASSESSMENT
 6.1.    SUBCHRONIC  REFERENCE  DOSE  (RfD$)
 6.1.1.   Oral    (RfDcn).     Although   several    subchronlc   studies    with
                     oU
 Inorganic  tin  have  been  performed  DeGroot  et  al.,  1972;   Dreef-Van  Der
 Meulen,  1974;  Yamaguchl  et  al., 1980,  1981;  Janssen,  1985;  Savolalnen and
 Valkonen,  1986), only  the  studies   by  DeGroot  et al.  (1972)  and Savolalnen
 and  Valkonen  (1986)  are sufficient for risk  assessment.   In  the  study by
 Savolalnen and  Valkonen (1986),  male Wlstar rats (6/group) were given either
 0,  100,  250 or  500  mg/l   (0,  8.3,  20.8  or   41.6  mg  tln/kg/day)  stannous
 chloride  In  their  drinking  water  for 18 weeks.  Tin  exposure  resulted  1n a
 dose-related  Increase  1n brain  and  muscle  acetylchollnesterase activity at
 the  two highest  doses.  There  was  no  effect  on  brain   or  muscle  acetyl-
 chollnesterase  activity at  the  low  dose.   Weight  gain of  the exposed  rats
 did  not differ  from  controls  at any  exposure level.  No  other  parameters
 were measured.   The  actual  tin  content of the  food or water (before addition
 of  SnCl-)  was  not measured.   A NOEL  of 100  mg/l  (8.3 mg  tln/kg/day)  and
 a LOAEL of 250 mg/l (20.8 mg/kg/day)  were defined 1n this study.
    DeGroot  et  al.  (1972) fed stannous  oxide or  stannous  chloride to  groups
 of  10  male  and 10  female Wlstar  rats at dietary  levels  of  0,  0.03,  0.1, 0.3
 and  1.0%  for   90   days.    Individual  body  weights,  organ  weights,   serum
 chemistry,  haematology, urlnalysls  and gross   and  microscopic  pathology  of
 selected  organs  were  measured.   The  feeding  of  stannous  oxide  at  various
 dietary levels  up  to  1.0% did  not  result In any significant  changes  1n any
 of  the  parameters  examined.   Rats fed diets containing  1%  stannous  chloride
 showed  growth  retardation within  the first  2 weeks  of exposure.  Growth was
 completely stopped  by week   4 1n  males and  In  females after week  6.   Slight
 anemia, reduced  testes weight and  liver pathology were observed  among  rats
0106h                               -17-                             05/14/87

-------
fed 0.3%  stannous  chloride.   No compound-related  effects were observed among
rats fed  0.03  or  0.1% stannous  chloride for 13 weeks.  The authors concluded
that the  0.1X dose level (22-33 mg/kg/day estimated) was a NOEL.
    Although  the  subchronlc  studies  by  Savolalnen  and Valkonen  (1986)  and
OeGroot   et  al.  (1972)  are  sufficient  for  risk  assessment,  the  RfOcn
                                                                           wU
derived from  either  study  (0.08  or  0.33 mg/kg/day) would be  lower  than  the
value  recommended for  the  RfDQ.  Therefore,  the  RfDQ  of  Q.,62  mg/kg/day
or 43.4 mg/day 1s recommended for the
6.1.2.   Inhalation  (RfDSI).   There were  no  data available  on  the  effects
of  tin  Inhaled by animals.  ACGIH  (1986)  has  recommended TLV of  2  mg/m3  to
protect  against  stannosls.   Since  there are  no  appropriate  data  on  the
Inhalation toxlclty of tin, an RfO-j cannot be derived.
6.2.   REFERENCE DOSE (RfD)
6.2.1.   Oral   (RfDJ.     Long-term  oral   animal   studies    (NTP,    1982;
Schroeder  et  al . , 1968)  are available  for  the  derivation of  an RfDQ  for
Inorganic  tin.  In the NTP  (1982)  study,  groups  of 50 F344 rats  and B6C3F1
mice  of  each  sex  were  fed  diets  containing  0,  1000  or 2000  ppm  stannous
chloride for 105 weeks.   No  compound-related effects were observed on growth
rate,  survival or  hlstopathology  of  tissue  at either dose  level  among
tin-fed  mice  or   rats.    In  the  second  study  (Schroeder  et  al.,  1968),
Long-Evans rats  (56/sex) were  given  5  ppm tin  In  their drinking water  for
life.   Their  diet  contained 0.28  ppm  tin.   Mean  Hfespan   of  tin-exposed
females was  significantly reduced when compared  with  controls.   Tin-exposed
rats  of  both  sexes  had  Increased  Incidences  of  fatty degeneration of  the
liver and vacuolar changes 1n the kidney.
0106h                               -18-                             05/15/87

-------
     The  risk assessment  for  oral  exposure to  tin 1s -complicated by  several
 factors.   Studies  of human dietary Intake of tin  Indicate  that  1f only  fresh
 meat,  cereals  and  vegetables  are  eaten, an  Individual  Ingests  0.1-1.0 mg
 tin/kg  bw/day  {Schroeder  et  al.t  1964; Upton  et al., 1966).  If, however,
 moderate   levels  of  canned   fruit  juices,  fish  and  vegetables  are  eaten,
 dietary  Intake of  tin may reach  38  mg/day (Tlpton  et  al., 1966;  Plscator,
 1979).   Increasing  the  proportion  of  canned  food 1n  the  diet  may Increase
 dietary  Intakes  to  500  ppm,  equivalent  to 14 mg/kg/day, assuming  a   food
 factor  for humans  of 0.028 (U.S. EPA, 1985).  An  average dally  human  dietary
 Intake  of  tin  was  calculated  by Schroeder-, et al.  (1964) to  be  4  mg/day.
 Illness  1n humans  has not been associated  with  levels of Inorganic  tin 1n
 the  diet  of  1-38  mg/day  (Lourla et al.,  1972), but  acute  tin poisoning has
 been associated with levels  >1370 ppm  In  Individual  food  Hems (Schafer and
 Femfert,  1984).  A  level  of  250  mg  of  Inorganic tin/kg  of  canned food 1s
 generally  accepted  as  a maximum tolerance  level.
    An  RfDQ  of 38 mg/day  or   0.54  mg/kg/day  could  be   derived using the
 human dietary Intake level for  tin  of 38 mg/day as a NOAEL.  Assuming that a
 large proportion  of the population.  Including  subgroups  are exposed to  this
 level,  no  uncertainty factor  would  be  applied.   However,  because  actual
 exposure  to  this   level   1s   unknown,  and  because the  effects of  marginal
 dietary deficiencies  or marked  excesses  of other nutrients  that may Interact
 with tin  have not  been studied  1n  humans  and  no long-term human studies are
 available,  an  RfDQ  based  on  dietary   levels  In  humans  would be  Inappro-
 priate.
    An RfDQ  could  be  derived based  on  the LOAEL  of  0.7  mg/kg/day  for liver
 degeneration,  vacuolatlon of renal  tubules and decreased  survival  In  rats
 exposed to  5  ppm  tin 1n  their drinking  water and 0.28 ppm  diet (Schroeder et


0106h                               -19-                             05/14/87

-------
al.,  1968).   The  application  of  an  uncertainty  factor  of  1000  (TOO  to
account  for 1ntra- and  1nterspec1es  extrapolation  and  10  for the use  of  a
LOAEL)  to   the LOAEL  would result  In  an RfDQ  of  0.0007 mg/kg/day  or  0.049
mg/day  for  a  70  kg   human.   This  RfDQ  1s  questionable  as  only one  dose
level  was   used   In  the  study  and  several  subchronlc  and   chronic  studies
suggest NOEL and NOAELs at much higher levels In rats, mice and humans.
    Using  the  NOEL of  2000 ppm  (62 mg/kg/day) for rats exposed  to  stannous
chloride 1n the  diet   for  2 years  (NTP,  1982), an RfOQ  of 0.62  mg/kg/day  or
43.4  mg/day can   be derived  by the  application  of  an uncertainty factor  of
100.   This RfDg  1s  further  supported  by  dietary tin  Intake level  of  0.54
mg/kg/day   (38 mg/day)  at which  no  adverse  effects  1n  humans  have  been
associated.
    It  1s   possible to derive a  CS  for  tin.  The  highest  value, 28.7,  Is
derived  from the  study of Schroeder  et al.  (1968) on  the basis of  fatty
degeneration of  the liver, vacuollzatlon  of the renal tubules  and decreased
longevity  1n  female Long-Evans rats  given  5 ppm tin In drinking  water  (0.7
mg/kg/day)   for   life.   An  RV  of  7  was   assigned  on  the   basis  of  these
effects.   A higher RV  was not  assigned  for decreased  longevity  since  this
effect  was  not   reported  1n  rats  or mice exposed  to 2000  ppm  stannous
chloride 1n the   diet  for  105 weeks  (NTP,   1982).  An MED  of 8.4 mg/day  Is
derived by  multiplying  the animal  dose, 0.7  mg/kg/day, by  the product  of the
cube  root  of the  ratio of  animal  (0.35 kg)  to human  reference weight  and the
human  reference  weight  (70  kg).   The  MED  of 8.4 mg/day  corresponds  to  an
RVd of 4.1.  Multiplying the RVd  by the RVg  yields  a  CS  of  28.7.
6.2.2.   Inhalation (RfD,).   There  were  no data  available   on  the  Inhala-
tion  of  tin  1n  animals;  therefore,  an RfD,  for  tin cannot be  derived.  A
TLV  of  2   mg/m3   by  ACGIH  (1986)  and  OSHA  (1985   has  been  recommended.
0106h                               -20-                             05/15/87

-------
 ACGIH  (1986)  did  not  report  how  this  particular  level  of  exposure was
 determined,  but  1t  Is  Intended to  be protective  of  stannosls.
 6.3.    CARCINOGENIC POTENCY
 6.3.1.    Oral.   Since  compounds of  tin have  Inadequate  evidence from  which
 to  assess the human carcinogenic  potential  (NTP,  1982; Innes et al., 1969),
 no  potency  factor 1s derived.
 6.3.2.    Inhalation.   Since  there were  no  data available  on  the  carcino-
 genic potential  of  Inhaled tin,  no potency factor 1s  derived.
0106h                               -21-                             05/15/87

-------
                                7.  REFERENCES

ACGIH  (American Conference  of  Governmental  Industrial Hyg1en1sts).   1986.
Documentation of the  Threshold  Limit  Values  and  Biological  Exposure Indices,
5th ed.  Cincinnati, OH.  p. 574.

Banks, C.K.   1969.  Tin  compounds.  |n,:  K1rk-0thmer  Encyclopedia  of Chemical
Technology,  2nd ed.,  Vol.  20,  A. Standen,  Ed.   John  Wiley and  Sons,  Inc.,
New York.  p. 309.

Bartak,  F.,  M.  Tomecka  and 0.  Tomlsek.  1948.    Stannlosls  (pneumoconlosls
due to tin).   Cas.  Lek.  Cesk.   87: 915-292.   (Cited 1n Schafer  and Femfert,
1984)

Bleler,  A.   1984.    Colloids.    In,:   Klrk-Othmer  Encyclopedia  of  Chemical
Technology,  3rd ed.,  Vol. Supplement, M.  Grayson and   D. Eckroth,  Ed.   John
Wiley and Sons, Inc.,  New York.  p. 252.

Blunden,   S.J.   and  A.H.   Chapman.   1982.  The  environmental  degradation  of
organotln compounds.  A review.  Sd.  Technol. Lett.   3: 267-272.

Chlba, M.,  K.  Oglhara,  Y.  Inaba,  T. N1sh1ma  and M.  K1kuch1.   1984.   The
organ distribution of tin  and  the effect of  tin  on concentrations of several
essential elements  1n rabbit.  Toxicology.  31(1): 23-32.
0106h                               -22-                             02/04/87

-------
 Chm1eln1cka,  J.,  J.A.  Szymanska and J. Snlec.   1981.  Distribution  of  tin In
 rats  and disturbances  In  the  metabolism  of zinc and  copper  due  to repeated
 exposure  to  SnClp.   Arch.  Toxlcol.   47:  263-268.    (Cited  1n Schafer  and
 Femfert, 1984)

 Cutter,  H.C., VI.U.  Faller,  J.B.  Stocklen  and  W.L.  Wilson.   1949.   Benign
 pneumoconlosls  In  a tin  oxide recovery  plant.   J.  Ind. Hyg.  31:  139-141.
 (Cited In Shafer and Femfert, 1984)

 DeGroot,  A.P.  1973.  Subacute  toxldty  of  Inorganic  tin  as  Influenced  by
 dietary  levels of Iron and copper.  Food Cosmet Toxlcol.  11(6): 955-962.

 DeGroot, A.P.,  V.J.  Feron and H.P. T11.  1972.   Short-term  toxldty  studies
 on  some  salts  and  oxides  of  tin  1n  rats.   Food  Cosmet.  Toxlcol.   11(1):
 19-30.

 Dreef-Van  der Meulen,  H.C.,  V.J.  Feron  and  H.P.  Til.   1974.   Pancreatic
 atrophy  and   other  pathological  changes  In  rats  following  the  feeding  of
 stannous chloride.   Pathol. Eur.  9(3): 185-192.

 Dundon,  C.C.  and  J.P.  Hughes.   1950.   Stannic oxide pneumoconlosls.   Am.  J.
 Roentgenol. Radium Ther.   63: 797-812.   (Cited In Schafer  and Femfert,  1984)

 Dwlwedl, R.S., G. Kaur, R.K. Jalswal and  R.C.  SrWastava.   1980.   The  effect
 of  metals  salts  on the  distribution  of  1ron-59 In  rats:  Manganese  (II),
 nickel (II)  and  tin (II).   Acta  Pharmacol.  Toxlcol.   47: 33-37.   (CUed  In
 Schafer and Femfert, 1984)


0106h                               -23-                            02/04/87

-------
Epstein, S.,  E.  Arnold,  0.  Andrea,  W. Bass and Y. Bishop.  1972.  Detection
of  chemical  mutagens by  the  dominant lethal assay  1n  the mouse.  Toxlcol.
Appl. Pharmacol.  23: 288-325.   (G1ted 1n  U.S. EPA, 1979)

FrHsch, P.,  B.G.  DeSalnt  and  R.  Derache.  1977.   Nutritional  and  toxlco-
loglcal study of rats fed a  diet containing tin.  Toxicology.  8(2): 165-175.
(French with English abstract)

GHlltz,  H.H.  and   M.K.  Moran.   1983.   Tin   compounds.   JJK  K1rk-0thmer
Encyclopedia  of  Chemical Technology,  3rd  ed.,  Vol.  23,  M. Grayson  and  0.
Eckroth, Ed.  John WHey and Sons,  Inc., New York.    p. 42, 53.

Greger,  J.L.   and  M.A.  Johnson.   1981.   Effect   of dietary  tin on  zinc.
Copper and Iron utilization  In  rats.   Food  Cosmet Toxlcol.  19(2): 163-166.

HUes, R.A.   1974.   Absorption,  distribution and  excretion of  Inorganic tin
1n rats.  Toxlcol.  Appl.  Pharmacol.   27(2):  366-379.

Innes, 0., B.  inland,  M.  Valeric,  et al.   1969.  Bloassay of  pesticides and
Industrial  chemicals  for tumorlgenldty  In mice:  A preliminary  note.   J.
Natl. Cancer Inst.   42:  1101-1114.   (Cited  In U.S. EPA, 1979)

Janssen, P.J.,  H.C.  Bosland,  J.P.  van Hees,  B.J.  SpU,  M.I.  Williams  and
C.F. Kuper.   1985.   Effects of  feeding stannous chloride  on different parts
of the gastrointestinal tract of the rat.   Toxlcol. Appl. Pharmacol.   78(1):
19-28.
0106h                               -24-                             02/04/87

-------
 Johnson,  M.A. and  J.I.  Greger.   1982.   Effects of  dietary  tin on  tin  and
 calcium metabolism of adult males.  Am. J. CUn. Nutr.  35(4): 655-660.

 Kojlma,  S.,  K. SaHo and  M.  Klyozuml.  1978.   Studies  on poisonous  metals:
 IV.  Absorption of stannic chloride  from  rat alimentary  tract  and  effect  of
 various  food components on  Us absorption.   Yabugakw Zasshl.   98:  495-502.
 (Cited 1n Schafer and Femferf,  1984)

 Kutzner,  J.  and  K.H.  Brode.    1971.   Resorptlon and excretion  of  tin after
 oral  administration  of  tln-113.   Nucl.  Med.  10(3): 286-297.   (German  with
 English abstract)

 Lourla,  D.B., M.M.  Joselow  and  A.A.  Browder.   1972.    Human  toxlclty  of
 certain trace elements.  Ann. Intern. Hed.  76: 307-319.

 McLean,  J.R.N.,   O.K.  Blakey,  G.R.   Douglas  and  J.G.   Kaplan.   1983.  The
 effect  of stannous  and stannic  (tin) chloride on  DNA  In  Chinese  hamster
 ovary cells.  Mutat. Res.  119(2): 195-201.

 N1sh1oka, H.   1975.  Mutagenlc activities of  metal  compounds  In  bacteria.
 Mutat. Res.   31:  185-189.  (Cited In U.S.  EPA, 1979)

 NMagu, J.O.  1979.  Copper In  the atmosphere and  precipitation.   Ir»:  Copper
 Environment, J.O. Nrlagu, Ed.   John Wiley  and Sons, NY.   p. 43-75.
0106h                               -25-                             02/04/87

-------
NTP   {National   Toxicology   Program).    1982.    Cardnogenesls   bloassay   of
stannous chloride (CAS No. 7772-99-8)  1n  F344/N  rats  and  B6C3F1/N  mice  (feed
study).   NCI/NTP Tech.  Rep.  Ser. No.  231.  (Also  published  as DHHS  (NIH)
publ. Iss NIH 82-1787 and NTIS PB 82-242-553)  p. 149.

OSHA  (Occupational  Safety and  Health  Administration).   1985".   OSHA  Occupa-
tional Standards: Permissible Exposure Limits.   29 CFR 1910.1000.

Pendergrass, E.P. and  A.W.  Pryde.  1948.   Benign pneumoconlosls due to  tin
oxide.  J.  Ind.  Hyg.  Toxlcol.   30:  119-123.  (Cited  1n Schafer  and  Femfert,
1984)

Perry, R.H. and  0.  Green, Ed.   1984.   Perry's Chemical Engineers' Handbook,
6th ed.  McGraw-Hill Book Co.,  New York.   p. 3-49.

Plscator, M.   1979.   In.: Handbook on  the Toxicology of Metals, L.  FMberg,
G.  Nordberg and  V.B.  Vouk,  Ed.  Elsevler,  North  Holland,  Amsterdam,  New
York.  (Cited In Schafer  and  Femfert,  1984;  Underwood, 1977)

Rapsomanlkls,  S. and  J.H.  Weber.    1985.   Environmental  Implications   of
methylatlon of tin  (II)  and  methytln  (IV)  Ions  1n  the presence  of manganese
dioxide.  Environ. Sc1. Technol.  19:  352-356.

Roe,  F.J.,  E.  Boyland  and K.  MllUcan.   1965.   Effects of oral administra-
tion  of  two  tin compounds  to  rats  over  prolonged  periods.   Food  Cosmet.
Toxlcol.  3(2): 277-280.
0106h                               -26-                             02/04/87

-------
 Savolalnen,  H.  and S. Valkonen.   1986.   Dose-dependent  brain  tin concentra-
 tion  1n  rats  given  stannous  chloride  1n drinking  water.   Toxlcol.  Lett.
 30(1):  35-39.

 Schafer,  S.G.  and U.  Femfert.   1984.  Tin  —  A  toxic heavy  metal?  A review
 of  the  literature.  Regul. Toxlcol. Pharmacol.  4(1): 57-69.

 Schafer,  S.G. and W.  Forth.  1983.  The  Influence of tin, nickel and cadmium
 on  the  Intestinal absorption of Iron.  Ecotoxlcol.  Environ. Saf.   7:  87-95.
 (CHed  In Schafer and Femfert,  1984)

 Schroeder,  H.  and J.  Balassa.   1967.   Arsenic,  germanium,  tin  and  vanadium
 In  mice.    Effects  on growth,  survival   and  tissue  levels.   J.  Nutr.   92:
 245-252.

                          x
 Schroeder,  H.A.,  3.J.   Balassa  and   I.H.  Tlpton.   1964.   Abnormal  trace
 elements  1ri man.  Tin.   J. Chron.  D1s.  17: 483-502.  (Cited In  Schafer  and
 Forth, 1983)

 Schroeder,  M.,  M. Kanlsawa, D.  Frost and  M.  MHchener.  1968.   Germanium,
 tin and  arsenic   In rats:  Effects  on  growth,  survival,  pathological  lesions
 and llfespan.  J. Nutr.   96:  37-45.

 Schwartz,  K.,  D.B.  Milne  and  E.  Vlnyard.    1970.   No  title  provided.
 Blochem. Blophys. Res. Commun.   40: 22.  (Cited 1n Underwood, 1977)
0106h                               -27-                             02/04/87

-------
Solomons,  N.H.,   J.S.  March1n1,  R.M.  Duarte-Pavaro,  H.  Vannuchl  and J.E.
Outra de OHvelra.  1983.  Studies on the bloavallabUHy of zinc  In humans:
Intestinal Interaction of tin and zinc.   Am.  J.  CUn. Nutr.  37(4):  566-571.

Strand,  J.A.   1983.   Biological fate and effects  of  organotln compounds   1n
the  marine environment.   TR83-1 Seattle,  Washington.   Nav.  Reserve  Cent.
NTIS AD-A133890.   23 p.

Upton,  I.,  P.L.  Stewart and  P.G.  Martin.   1966.  Trace  elements 1n  diets
and excreta.   Health  Phys.   12: 1683-1689.   (Cited  1n  Schafer and Femfert,
1984)

Underwood, E.J.   1977.  Trace  Elements  1n  Human and Animal  Nutrition,  4th
ed.  Academic Press, NY.  345 p.

ILS.  EPA.    1979.   Mini-Reviews  on   the  CarclnogenlcHy,   MutagenlcHy  and
Chronic  Tox1c1ty  of Selected Compounds.  Prepared  by  the  Office  of  Health
and Environmental Assessment,  Environmental  Criteria  and  Assessment Office,
Cincinnati, OH.

U.S.  EPA.   1980.   Guidelines  and Methodology  Used 1n  the  Preparation  of
Health  Effect Assessment  Chapters  of  the  Consent   Decree   Water  Quality
Criteria Documents.   Federal  Register.   45(231):  49347-49357.
0106h                               -28-                             04/29/87

-------
U.S.  EPA.   1983.  Methodology and  Guidelines  for  Reportable Quantity Deter-
minations  Based  on Chronic Tox1c1ty Data.   Prepared  by the Office of Health
and  Environmental  Assessment, Environmental Criteria  and Assessment Office,
Cincinnati,  OH  for  the  Office  of  Solid Waste  and  Emergency  Response,
Washington, DC.

U.S.  EPA.   1985.   Reference Values  for  Risk  Assessment.   Prepared  by  the
Office  of  Health  and Environmental  Assessment,  Environmental  Criteria  and
Assessment Office, Cincinnati, OH.

U.S.  EPA.    1986.    Guidelines   for  Carcinogenic  Risk Assessment.   Federal
Register.  51(185): 33992-34003.

Weast,  R.C.,  Ed.   1983.   CRC  Handbook  of  Chemistry  and Physics,  64th  ed.
CRC Press Inc., Boca Raton, FL.  p. B-150, B-151.

Yamaguchl,  M.,  R.  SaHo and  S.  Okada.  1980.   Dose-effect  of  Inorganic  tin
on biochemical Indices In rats.  Toxicology.  16(3): 267-273.

Yamaguchl,  M.,  K.  Sug11  and  S.  Okada.   1981.   Inorganic  tin  1n  the  diet
affects the femur 1n rats.  Toxlcol. Lett.  9(3): 207-209.
0106h                               -29-                             04/29/87

-------
          8:   £
                               u
                               e
                               oi
                               u
                               01
                              tfcc
                               01
                            o  —
                            a a >.

                            41 ae -a
                            w    "^
                            c  w o>
                            n  o 1
                            u    »—

                            tk Ik
                            oi ac
                              u
                              Ol
                              u
                              at
                                                 co
                                                 en
                                                 13
                                                 u
                                                             tSl

                                            o     o
                                          CN* —   rv —
             i oi     «< •-•

01 ^ M r—


   01 i— C
>v f O 01  II
— -. 3 l_
•*   U    Ol


u- o > o oe
                               •o
                               C L.
                                O



                               Ol •» >>
                               •** Ol tQ


                               2^-5
                                    Ol
                               C C Jt
            v> ao «»•


            Q.03 01
            0-cvi u. -a

            ui o i— ce
                                            CO      U
                                                             o
                                                             V)
                                           : —   ee —
                                                                              » <

                                                                              £
0106h
       -30-
                                                                                                             05/14/87

-------