TECHNICAL REPORT DATA
                            (Jntmrrtmd frutnictioru on tHe rtvtnt btfart completing;
    p   NO.
  uPA/600/8-88/020
                             2.
             3. RECIPIENT'S ACCESSION NO
                  PB88-179460/AS
4. TITLE AND SUBTITLE
                                                           5. REPORT DATE
  Health Effects  Assessment for  beryllium and Compounds
                                                           •. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION CODE
  AUTMOR(S)
                                                            PERFORMING ORGANIZATION REPORT NO
9. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION NAME AND AOORESS
                                                           10. PROGRAM ELEMENT NO.
                                                           11. CONTRACT/GRANT NO.
12. SPONSORING AGENCY NAME AND AOORESS
 Environmental Criteria  and Assessment Office
 Office of Research  and  Development
 U.S. Environmental  Protection Agency
 Cincinnati. QH   45268	
              13. TYPE Of REPORT ANO PERIOD COVERED
              14. SPONSORING AGENCY CODE
                EPA/600/22
15 SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES
16. ABSTRACT
   This report summarizes and evaluates information relevant to a preliminary  interim
 assessment of adverse health effects associated  with specific chemicals or  compounds.
 The Office of Emergency and Remedial Response  (Superfund) uses these documents  in
 preparing cost-benefit analyses under Executive  Order 12991 for decision-making under
 CERCLA.  All estimates of acceptable intakes and.carcinogenic potency presented in
 this document should  be considered as preliminary and reflect limited resources
 allocated to this  project.  The intent in these  assessments is to suggest acceptable
 exposure levels  whenever sufficient data are available.   The interim values presented
 reflect the relative  degree of hazard associated with exposure or risk to the
 chemical(s) addressed.  Whenever possible,  two categories of values have been
 estimated for systemic toxicants (toxicants for  which cancer is not the endpoint of
 concern).  The first, RfDs or subchronic reference dose, is an estimate of  an exposure
 level that would not  be expected to cause adverse effects when exposure occurs  during
 a limited time interval.  The RfD is an estimate of an exposure level that  would not
 be expected to cause  adverse effects when exposure occurs for a significant portion
 of the lifespan.   For compounds for which there  is sufficient evidence of
 carcinogenicity, qi*s have been computed, if appropriate, based on oral and
 inhalation data  if available.
7.
                               KEY WORDS ANO DOCUMENT ANALYSIS
                 DESCRIPTORS
b IDENTIFIERS/OPEN ENDED TERMS  C. COSATI Field/Croup
8. DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT

  Public
i9. SECURITY CLASS (THuRtportl

  Unclassified
                                                                        21. NO. OF PAGES
                                              20. SECURITY CLASS (This page)
                                                Unclassified
                                                                        22. PRICE
EPA POT* 2220-1 (*•». 4-77)   PREVIOUS KOITIOM it OMOIETK
                                                                      t/J

-------
                                              EPA/600/8-88/020
                                              July,  1987
          HEALTH  EFFECTS  ASSESSMENT
         FOR  BERYLLIUM  AND  COMPOUNDS
ENVIRONMENTAL  CRITERIA AND ASSESSMENT OFFICE
OFFICE OF HEALTH AND ENVIRONMENTAL  ASSESSMENT
      OFFICE  OF  RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT
    U.S.  ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
             CINCINNATI, OH 45268
                            ,  ,  PT.OAction Agency
             U S. Environmental Frv>—-^
             .,-' ,  •-r, 5, Library (^ f>"1^


             Chicag0riL~'J' 60604

-------
                                  DISCLAIMER
    This   document   has   been  reviewed   In  accordance   with   the   U.S.
Environmental  Protection  Agency's  peer and  administrative  review policies
and approved for publication.  Mention  of  trade names  or  commercial products
does not constitute endorsement or recommendation  for use.
                                       11

-------
                                    PREFACE
    This  report  presents  a  brief  summary  and  evaluation of  Information
relevant  to  a  preliminary  Interim  assessment  of  adverse health  effects
associated  with  beryllium  and  compounds.   All  estimates  of  acceptable
Intakes  and  carcinogenic  potency  presented  In  this   document  should  be
considered  as  preliminary  reflecting  limited  resources  allocated  to  this
project.  Pertinent  toxlcologlc and environmental  data  were located through
on-line  literature  searches  of   the  Chemical  Abstracts,  TOXLINE   and  the
CHEMFATE/OATALOG  data  bases.   The basic  literature searched supporting this
document  1s current  up to Hay, 1986.   Secondary sources of Information have
also been relied  upon  In the preparation  of  this report and represent large
scale  health  assessment  efforts  that  entail   extensive  peer  and  Agency
review.   The  following Office of  Health  and  Environmental Assessment (OHEA)
sources have been extensively utilized:

    U.S.  EPA.   1980a.   Ambient  Water  Quality  Criteria  Document  for
    Beryllium.   Prepared  by  the Office  of  Health  and  Environmental
    Assessment,  Environmental  Criteria  and  Assessment  Office,  Cincin-
    nati, OH  for  the  Office  of  Water  Regulations  and  Standards,  Wash-
    ington,  DC.  EPA 440/5-80-024.  NTIS PB81-117350.

    U.S.  EPA.    1986a.    Health   Assessment   Document  for  Beryllium.
    Prepared  by  the  Office  of  Health  and   Environmental  Assessment,
    Environmental Criteria  and  Assessment Office,  Cincinnati,  OH.   EPA
    600/8-84/0268.

    U.S.  EPA.   1986b.   Drinking Water  Criteria  Document for Beryllium.
    Prepared  by  the  Office  of  Health  and   Environmental  Assessment,
    Environmental  Criteria  and  Assessment Office,  Cincinnati, OH  for
    the Office of Drinking Water, Washington, DC.

    U.S.  EPA.   1986c.   Integrated  Risk  Information  System  (IRIS).
    Reference  Dose  (RfD)  for   Oral   Exposure  for  Beryllium.   Online
    (verification  date 12/02/85).  Office of Health  and Environmental
    Assessment,   Environmental    Criteria   and   Assessment    Office,
    Cincinnati, OH.

    The Intent  In these assessments Is  to suggest acceptable exposure levels
for  noncardnogens  and  risk   cancer   potency   estimates  for  carcinogens
whenever sufficient  data  were available.  Values were not derived  or larger
uncertainty  factors  were employed  when  the  variable data  were limited  In
scope  tending   to   generate   conservative   (I.e.,   protective)   estimates.
Nevertheless,   the Interim  values  presented  reflect  the  relative  degree  of
hazard or risk associated with exposure to the chemlcal(s) addressed.

    Whenever  possible, two  categories  of values  have  been  estimated  for
systemic  toxicants  (toxicants  for  which  cancer  1s not  the  endpolnt  of
concern).  The  first,  RfD$ (formerly AIS) or subchronlc  reference  dose.  Is
an estimate of  an exposure  level  that  would  not  be expected to cause adverse
effects when  exposure  occurs  during  a  limited  time  Interval  (I.e.,  for  an
Interval that  does not  constitute a significant portion of the  llfespan).
                                      111

-------
This type  of  exposure estimate has not been  extensively  used,  or rigorously'
defined,  as  previous  risk  assessment efforts  have been  primarily  directed
towards  exposures  from  toxicants  In  ambient  air  or  water where  lifetime
exposure   1s  assumed.   Animal   data  used   for   RFO§  estimates  generally
Include  exposures  with durations of  30-90  days.   Subchronlc human  data are
rarely  available.   Reported  exposures are usually  from chronic occupational
exposure  situations  or  from  reports  of acute accidental  exposure.   These
values   are   developed  for   both   Inhalation  (RfD$i)   and   oral   (RfD$o)
exposures.

    The  RfD   (formerly AIC)  Is   similar  In  concept  and  addresses  chronic
exposure.  It Is an  estimate  of  an  exposure  level  that would not be expected
to cause  adverse  effects when exposure  occurs for a  significant portion of
the llfespan  [see  U.S. EPA  (1980b)  for  a discussion  of  this  concept].   The-
RfD  Is  route-specific and  estimates acceptable  exposure  for  either  oral
(RfDg)  or  Inhalation  (RfDj)  with  the  Implicit   assumption   that  exposure
by other routes Is  Insignificant.

    Composite  scores  (CSs)   for  noncarclnogens  have  also  been  calculated
where  data permitted.   These  values are  used  for   Identifying reportable
quantities and  the methodology .for  their development  Is  explained  1n  U.S.
EPA (1984).

    For  compounds  for which there 1s sufficient evidence  of carc1nogen1c1ty
RfD$ and RfD  values  are  not derived.  For  a discussion  of  risk assessment
methodology for  carcinogens  refer  to  U.S.  EPA (1980b).   Since  cancer  1s  a
process  that  Is  not characterized  by  a  threshold, any exposure contributes
an Increment  of  risk.  For  carcinogens,  q-j*s have been computed,  1f appro-
priate, based on oral and Inhalation data.l.f available.
                                      1v

-------
                                   ABSTRACT


    In  order  to  place  the  risk  assessment  evaluation  In proper  context,
refer  to  the preface  of  this  document.   The  preface  outlines  limitations
applicable to all documents  of  this  series  as well as the appropriate Inter-
pretation and use of the quantitative estimates presented.

    Beryllium has  been  shown  to be  carcinogenic  In  experimental  animals
following  Inhalation  exposure.   Epidemiology  studies  of  beryllium  workers
are  Inadequate  to  demonstate  or refute   that  beryllium  Is  a  carcinogen.
Using the U.S.  EPA  (1986d) weight of evidence  ranking system,  beryllium has
been Judged  to  be a Group  B2 carcinogen.   I.e., a  probable human carcinogen
as  supported by  a sufficient   level  of   animal   data.    U.S.  EPA  (1986a)
calculated  Inhalation  risk  estimates  from  studies   1n  which  animals  were
exposed  to   beryllium  compounds  with  higher  solubilities,  although  these
estimates have not  been  finalized nor  1s there  a recommendation as yet as to
the  best  characterization  of  the  Inhalation  cancer  risk.   Risk  estimate
values are given 1n the Appendix.

    The   U.S.   EPA   (1986b)   has  recommended   an   oral  q-j*  of   4.88
(mg/kg/day)'1  for  beryllium  based  on   the  evidence   presented   In  the
Schroeder and Kitchener (1975a) study.

-------
                               ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS                              *


    The  Initial  draft  of  this  report  was  prepared  by  Syracuse  Research
Corporation under  Contract No.  68-03-3112  for EPA's  Environmental  Criteria
and  Assessment  Office,  Cincinnati,  OH.   Dr. Christopher  OeRosa and  Karen
Blackburn  were  the  Technical  Project  Monitors   and  John  Helms  (Office  of
Toxic  Substances)  was  the Project  Officer.  The  final  documents   In  this
series  were prepared  for  the  Office  of  Emergency  and Remedial  Response,
Washington, DC.

    Scientists from  the following  U.S. EPA  offices provided  review  comments
for this document series:

         Environmental Criteria and Assessment Office, Cincinnati, OH
         Carcinogen Assessment Group
         Office of A1r Quality Planning and Standards
         Office of Solid Waste
         Office of Toxic Substances
         Office of Drinking Water

Editorial review for the document series was provided  by the following:

    Judith Olsen and Erma Durden
    Environmental Criteria and Assessment Office
    Cincinnati.  OH

Technical  support  services  for  the  document series  was provided by  the
following:

    Bette Zwayer, Jacky Bohanon and K1m Davidson
    Environmental Criteria and Assessment Office
    Cincinnati,  OH
                                      v1

-------
TABLE OF CONTENTS

1.
2.


3.








4.








5.
6.




ENVIRONMENTAL CHEMISTRY AND FATE 	
ABSORPTION FACTORS IN HUMANS AND EXPERIMENTAL ANIMALS . . . .
2.1. ORAL 	 ,
2.2. INHALATION 	 ,
TOXICITY IN HUMANS AND EXPERIMENTAL ANIMALS 	 ,
3.1. SUBCHRONIC 	
3.1.1. Oral 	
3.1.2. Inhalation 	 ,
3.2. CHRONIC 	 ,
3.2.1. Oral 	
3.2.2. Inhalation 	
3.3. TERATOGENICITY AND OTHER REPRODUCTIVE EFFECTS. . . . ,
3.4. TOXICANT INTERACTIONS 	
CARCINOGENICITY 	
4.1. HUMAN DATA 	 	 ,
4.1.1. Oral 	
4.1.2. Inhalation 	 	
4.2. BIOASSAYS 	
4.2.1. Oral 	 	
4.2.2. Inhalation 	 ,
4.3. OTHER RELEVANT DATA 	 ,
4.4. WEIGHT OF EVIDENCE 	
REGULATORY STANDARDS AND CRITERIA 	
RISK ASSESSMENT 	
6.1. SUBCHRONIC REFERENCE DOSE (RfDs) 	
6.1.1. Oral (RfDso) 	
6.1.2. Inhalation (RfDci) 	
Page
. . . 1
4
. . . 4
, , 5
7
7
. . . 7
7
9
. . . 9
. . . 10
. . . 14
14
, , , 15
. . . -15
. . . 15
15
17
. . . 17
. . . 20
. . . 20
. . . 26
, , , 28
. . . 29
30
. . . 30
. . . 30

-------
                               TABLE  OF  CONTENTS
                                                                        Page
     6.2.   REFERENCE DOSE (RfD)	   30
            6.2.1.   Oral (RfD0)	   30
            6.2.2.   Inhalation (RfDj) 	   30
     6.3.   CARCINOGENIC POTENCY (q-|*) . .	   30
            6.3.1.   Oral	   30
            6.3.2.   Inhalation	   32
 7.  REFERENCES	   38
APPENDIX: Summary Table for Beryllium and Compounds	   57

-------
                               LIST OF TABLES
No.                               Title                                Page
1-1     Physical Properties of Beryllium and Some of Its Compounds. .    2
4-1     Comparison of Study Cohorts and Subcohorts of Two
        Beryllium Companies 	   18
4-2     Pulmonary Carcinoma from Inhalation Exposure of Animals
        to Beryllium	   21
6-1     Derivation of q-|* for Beryllium	   33
6-2     Beryllium Dose-Response from 10 Inhalation Studies on
        Animals and the Corresponding Potency (Slope) Estimations  . .   34
6-3     Upper-Bound Cancer Potency Estimates Calculated Under
        Various Assumptions 	   37
                                     1x

-------
                            LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
BCF                     B1oconcentrat1on factor
BCR                     Beryllium Case Registry
CAS                     Chemical  Abstract Service
CHO                     Chinese hamster ovary
CS                      Composite score
DNA                     DeoxyMbonuclelc add
DUEL                    Drinking water exposure  level
HA                      Health advisory
NOAEL                   No-observed-adverse-effect level
ppm                     Parts  per million
RfD                     Reference dose
RfDj                    Inhalation reference dose
RfDg                    Oral reference dose
RfD$           '         Subchronlc reference dose
                        Subchronlc Inhalation reference dose
                        Subchronlc oral reference dose
RNA                     Rlbonuclelc add
TLV                     Threshold limit value
TWA                     Time-weighted average

-------
                     1.  ENVIRONMENTAL CHEMISTRY AND FATE

    Beryllium  Is  a  metallic  element   that  belongs  to  Group  IIA  of  the
periodic  table  and  has  an  oxidation   state  of  *2.   Average  crustal  rock
contains  -2.8 yg  berylI1um/g;  beryllium also  occurs  1n. more concentrated
forms  as  a component of  >40 minerals (U.S.  EPA,  1986a).   Average estimates
of abundance 1n earth's crust ranges from 2-10 ppm.
    Beryllium  occurs  1n environmental  samples at concentrations of -0.01-0.1
ng/m3  In  air,  0.05-0.1  yg/g  In  house  dust,   0.01-1.0 ng/g   In  surface
water,  0.3-6.0 yg/g  1n soil  and  0.01  yg/g  1n biological materials.   Some
plants,  such  as  hickory,  may  accumulate  as  much  as  1 yg/g  dry  weight
beryllium  (U.S.  EPA,  1986a).  Physical  properties of beryllium  and  some of
Us compounds are listed In Table 1-1.
    Since most atmospheric  beryl Hum Is  derived from coal  combustion,  1t Is
likely  that  Its  chemical  form would   be  beryllium  oxide.    Conversion  to
Ionized salts  Is  possible,  but  1t has not  been reported.   Removal of beryl-
lium  from  the  atmosphere  takes place  by  wet  and  dry  deposition.    It  Is
reported  that  most  beryllium found 1n stack  emissions  Is  found on particles
<1  ym;  particles  of  this  size  remain  aloft for  -10  days.    Assuming  that
half  of  the beryllium  emitted Into the  atmosphere returns to  earth  as  wet
precipitation, the average  concentration of  beryllium  In rain or  snow  1s
expected to be 0.01 ng/g (U.S. RPA. 1986a).
    Beryllium  from the atmosphere eventually reaches the  soil  and sediment
where  1t  1s  probably  retained In the relatively  Insoluble form of beryllium
oxide  (U.S. EPA, 1986a).  Beryllium  1s strongly fixed In many soils and will
displace  divalent  cations   that  share common   sorptlon sites  In  soils
(Flshbeln. 1981).


0113h                               -1-                              07/24/87

-------







•






|
§
1
**
VI
O
1
. i
*~ S
i 1
£
*0
1
u
1













S
%
J£

W


j
a
a. —
e —
S
a

Is
o
a.
fE

i

B
e



Atomic or
Molecular
Height


^ ^
||



4l

1
U)
u


i

«
^a
3

o

e



a
o

CM


U»
*l
09

U

1|
m «

S





-

f*
1
*
a
r»


BerylltIM
„,
§
OI

esicj
f> •

» —

J
S
o
CN4





in
a

1
«• • M

a ai «
w e •a

?



CM

i

^^
t
i
S
f»


BeryllllM
chloride
u
kO
^^
•1

"oV

a





*

§
w>
1

I

•
Ml 3
n
si

a
V





i

f^
i
i
5
f»


— ^
11
01 ^~

z
3
O


^^
U
V



04






O

III

1 * 3
« •• 9
iti

5
S

t
rn
I

S

^^
i
m
i
S
!••


BeryllllM
nitrate
E

9


^3

d


o
a

i


3
*i
3
m
CM

1
K

«T
i

a





o
01

0>
i
vO
in
i
I



BeryllllM
oxide
o»
§
1^
Ql— »

« Sr*

9 
i.
8 I
I 2
0113h
-2-
07/20/87

-------
    Sufficient  data  could  not  be  located  1n  the  available  literature  to
evaluate  the  fate and  persistence of  beryllium  In  water and  soil.   Since
oxides and hydroxides of  beryllium  are  relatively Insoluble at the common pH
of  natural  water,  most  beryllium  will  be  present  1n  the  sediments.   The
residence time  of beryllium In  the ocean has  been  estimated to  be  about  a
few hundred years  (F1shbe1nt 1981).   An estimated weighted average BCF of 19
for  beryllium  In  the  edible  portion  of fish and  shellfish  suggests  that
beryllium will  not  bloaccumulate  significantly  In  aquatic  organisms  (U.S.
EPA. 1980a).
0113h                               -3-                              11/03/86

-------
           2.   ABSORPTION  FACTORS  IN  HUMANS AND  EXPERIMENTAL ANIMALS
2.1.   ORAL
    Data  regarding  the efficiency of  gastrointestinal  absorption of  beryl-
lium are  equivocal.   In  a study by Crowley et  al.  (1949), rats  were given a
single  oral  dose  of  7Be  solution  by  stomach  tube and  were  sacrificed  8
days  later.   The  7Be content  of the  tissues and  excreta  was  determined.
Following  this  protocol,  the absorption  of  7Be  could  not be  demonstrated,
although  the  authors  reported  that  If any  absorption took  place,  1t  was
<0.2%.
    Furchner et  al.  (1973)  gave  single  oral   doses  of carrier-free  7Be  to
mice, rats, monkeys and  beagle  dogs.   The mice  and rats were  anesthetized
and dosed by oral  Intubation; dogs received a  gelatin capsule  containing the
dose; and monkeys  received  sugar  cubes with the  appropriate dose.   A second
experiment was  also conducted 1n which  rats  Ingested 10 mi of  a saccharin-
glucose  solution  containing 7Be  for  56.days.   Results of both experiments
showed Uttle absorption.  Absorption from a single  dose was  estimated to be
-0.6% with a ur1nary:fecal  ratio  of  0.0011,  while  the  average urlnaryrfecal
ratio during the  56 days  of exposure was 0.0044.   Hyslop  et al. (1943)  also
Indicated that  <1% of Ingested beryllium 1s  absorbed.
    Reeves (1965)  studied  the absorption of  beryllium  In  rats  provided  with
drinking  water  containing  beryllium sulfate.   The  average  dally  beryllium
Intake was  -6.6 or 66.6  yg,  and  the rats were treated for up  to  24 weeks.
Beryllium  Intake  was measured  and  recovery  In  several organs  and  tissues,
urine  and  feces  was  determined.  The  results  showed that  60-90%  of  the
Ingested  beryllium  was  eliminated 1n the feces,  Indicating higher  levels of
absorption  than  studies previously  reviewed.   Total recovery  of beryllium,
however,  ranged  from  60-91%  (average, 79.3%)  of estimated  Intake  values.


0113h                               -4-                              03/05/87

-------
Reeves  (1965)  concluded that because  of  the low  solubility  of beryllium 1n
Intestinal fluid, the compound was  precipitated  as the phosphate and was not
available  for  absorption.   The  author also  surmised  that  most of the beryl-
lium  found In the body  was absorbed  from  the  stomach where  pH  (3.0-3.6 In
the rat)  Is  favorable for  maintaining beryllium  salts  In  their  Ionized and
soluble form.   If  beryllium Is  absorbed  predominantly from  the  stomach, It
1s  reasonable to postulate that absorption would  be dependent  on  gastric
emptying  time,  which can  be highly variable,  thus   leading  to  a  range of
beryllium absorption efficiencies.
2.2.   INHALATION
    Animal studies  Indicate that beryllium  1s  retained and  absorbed  by the
lungs.  In a  study  described by Reeves et  al.  (1967) and  Reeves  and Vorwald
(1967),  rats   were  exposed  to   beryllium sulfate at  an   average  beryllium
concentration  of  35  jig/m", 7  hours/day,  5 days/week  for 72 weeks.   Lung
beryllium  concentrations reached  a  plateau of  -13.5 yg  (In whole  lungs)
after  36  weeks of exposure.  At the  same  time,  a plateau 1n  the beryllium
concentration of the tracheobronchlal lymph nodes was also reached.
    In a  study by Zorn  et  al.  (1977), rats and guinea pigs  were exposed to
beryllium  sulfate  aerosol  with   7Be added  as  the  chloride.  Animals  were
exposed for 3 hours and were  sacrificed  either  Immediately  after  the expo-
sure  period  or 20-408  hours postexposure.   The  total  amount of  beryllium
Inhaled was <3 mg  (of  which,  10 ng was  7Be).   Immediately  following expo-
sure, -5 ng of 7Be was retained,  67% In the lungs and 15X 1n the skeleton.
    Hart et al.  (1984)   exposed  rats  for  1  hour to beryllium oxide  fired at
560°C.   The   average  beryllium  concentration  was  477 ug/m3,  and  90X  of
the particles  had a  mean  diameter  of <1  ym.   At  sacrifice,  the  lungs  of
rats  were  lavaged and  both the  lung  tissue and  lavage fluid  were  analyzed


0113h                               -5-                              03/05/87

-------
for beryllium.  At  2.5  hours  after  exposure,  -200 ng of beryllium was  found
1n  the  lung  tissue.   This  amount   remained  constant  In  rats  sacrificed
throughout the 3-week postexposure period.  The amount of  beryllium  found  1n
the lavage fluid decreased from 280 to 16 ng during  the  3-week  study period.
Hart and  PUtman  (1980) demonstrated the ability  of macrophages to  take  up
particles of  Insoluble  beryllium compounds.  U.S.  EPA  (1986a) Implied  that
Inhaled beryllium  on  contact  with respiratory  epithelium  may  form  Insoluble
phosphates that  are taken up by macrophages.
0113h                               -6-                              11/03/86

-------
                3.   TOXICITY IN HUMANS AND EXPERIMENTAL ANIMALS
3.1.   SUBCHRONIC
3.1.1.   Oral.   Pertinent  data regarding  the  tox1c1ty of beryllium  follow-
ing  subchronlc  oral  exposure   could   not   be  located  In  the  available
literature.
3.1.2.   Inhalation.  Two  types  of disease  resulting  from  Inhalation  expo-
sure  to  beryllium compounds  have been described  In  humans  (Constant1n1d1s,
1978).  The  first  type,  acute  berylHosls.  Is more likely  to occur  shortly
after  a  massive exposure  to beryllium compounds  or  may occur after  a pro-
longed exposure  to  lower concentrations of  beryllium  compounds.   The second
form,  chronic  berylHosls.  1s  highly  variable In onset,  varying with  the
length of  exposure  and  time  from last  exposure.   The chronic  disease  can
develop >20  years after  the last exposure.  Because of the  longer period of
time usually required  to develop  the chronic disease,  1t will  be discussed
1n Section 3.2.2.
    Acute beryll1os1s can affect  any  level of  the respiratory  tract,  causing
rhinitis, pharyngitis,  tracheobronchltls, and  may lead  to  severe pulmonary
Involvement  depending on the exposure  (Constant1n1d1s,  1978).  Inflammation
extending  Into  the  lower   respiratory  tract  tends  to  occur  after  Intense
exposure.  Acute pneumonltls can  also  occur after beryllium  exposure.  The
symptoms of  this syndrome  Include shortness  of breath, malaise,  anorexia,
weight loss, coughing, cyanosis,  tachypnea and tachycardia.  The  majority of
acute cases  of  beryllium disease resolve completely within  a  few months  but
fatal  cases  are not unusual (Dutra,  1948).   It  has  been  estimated  that
chronic  disease may develop  In  "6%  of patients  with  acute  berylllosls
{Hardy, 1965).
0113h                               -7-                              11/03/86

-------
    In the  United  States,  the first  case  of acute berylllosls  was  reported
In  1943  by Van  Ordstrand  et al.  (1943).   In  the  1940s,  hundreds  of  cases
occurred,  but  with  Improvements  1n  working conditions  lowering  beryllium
exposure the number  of cases has  greatly  decreased (U.S. EPA,  1986a).   The
U.S. BCR,  a file on reported cases  of acute and chronic beryllium  disease,
started  1n  1952, lists 215  cases  of  acute disease up  to 1967  (Frelman  and
Hardy, 1970)  and 9  additional   cases  from 1967-1983  (Elsenbud and  11s son.,
1983).
    Several animal  studies  of the  subchronlc  Inhalation tox1c1ty of  beryl-
lium have been  conducted,  and these were reviewed by Vorwald  et al.  (1966).
    In one  study, rats  were  exposed to beryllium sulfate aerosol at concen-
trations  ranging from  2.8-194  yg/m3, 7  hours/day  for  1-560  days.   It  was
stated that exposure  to  2.8 yg/m3  did not  produce  any specific  Inflamma-
tory  abnormalities,  while  exposures   to  21  yg/m3  resulted  1n  significant
Inflammatory changes  In  some  longer  11'ved rats.   At  42  yg/m3,   chronic
pneumonltls  was   noted, while   exposure  to  194  yg/m3  resulted  In  acute
berylHosls.  An  Increased  Incidence of pulmonary cancer was  also noted.
    In a  study by Schepers  et  al. (1957), 115  male  and female Sherman  and
Wlstar rats were  exposed  to  beryllium  sulfate at  an  average   beryllium
concentration  of  12y/ft3  or  35  yg/m3,   8  hours/day,  5  days/week  and  4
hours/day,  1 day/week  for  180 days.   A group  of 139  rats was maintained as
controls.   During  the  exposure  period, 46  beryllium-exposed  rats died  from
(primarily) pleural  pericarditis with  a tendency to chronic  pneumonltls.   No
bacteria were  Isolated, but the. authors   concluded  that the response  was
caused by   an  Infection because  sulfathlazole  treatment had a  beneficial
effect.  At the  end  of  the 6-month  exposure period, 17  rats  were sacrificed.
0113h                               -8-                              03/06/87

-------
The  majority  of  these  rats  had  pulmonary  effects  Including  foam-cell
clusters.  Infiltration  of  macrophages,  lobular  septal-cell  proliferation,
and  perlobronchlal  and  alveolar-wall  ep1the!1al1zat1on.  One  rat  exhibited
focal  metaplasia of  alveolar  walls,  another  had  granulomas  1n the  lungs,
while  a  third rat and  possibly  several others had  adenomas.   None of these
lesions were  observed 1n groups  of  three  to  four control  rats/strain sacri-
ficed  every  2  months.   The  surviving rats  (52)  were  then maintained  In
beryllium-free  air  for  up  to  18  months.   In  these  rats,  a  progressive
Increase  In  the frequency of  pulmonary changes  was observed.   Hlstologlcal
examination  of  the  lungs of  these rats  revealed emphysema of  the  atroplc
vesicular  type and  metaplasia  of the  bronchial  epithelium  1n  an unspecified
number of rats.  Pulmonary tumors were also observed (Section 4.2.2).
3.2.   CHRONIC
3.2.1.   Oral.   A  number of  chronic  oral  studies of  beryllium  toxldty are
available.   In  several  early  studies  (Guyatt  et al.,  1933;  Jacobson, 1933;
Kay and Skill, 1934), rickets  was  produced In  young animals by administering
large  doses  of beryllium carbonate (0.1-0.5X,  1000-5000 mg/kg  food).  This
effect  has since  been  regarded  as  an Indirect  result of  the binding  of
phosphate to beryllium  In the  gut  and, consequently, phosphorus  depletion  In
the body.
    The chronic oral  toxldty  of beryllium 1n  rats (Schroeder  and Kitchener,
1975a) and mice  (Schroeder and Kitchener,  1975b)  at a low  dose was studied.
Groups of  52 male and  52 female Long-Evans rats  and 54 male  and  54 female
Swiss mice were provided  with  drinking water containing beryllium sulfate  at
5 ppm  from the sulfate  for their  lifetimes.  Similar groups of rats and mice
were maintained  as  controls.  At  various  Intervals  throughout  the studies,
0113H                               -9-                              03/05/87

-------
body weights of  rats  and mice were recorded.  At the time of  natural  death,
rats and mice  were  dissected  and any gross pathological changes were  noted.
Blood and urine samples were also taken  from rats.
    The  results  In  rats  showed  a slight depression  In  growth of male  rats
from the ages  of 2-6 months, and no  effect  on  the Hfespan of treated  rats
compared with  controls.   Glucose  levels  In  urine of female rats were  higher
than controls  (p<0.025,  Chl-square  analysis),  but  no other differences  were
found  In  analyses  of  urine,  serum glucose  and  cholesterol  or fasting  uMc
add levels  when compared  with controls  (Schroeder v and MHchener,  1975a).
In mice,  no  consistent  difference  between  treated and  control  animals  was
noted (Schroeder and MHchener,  1975b).
    U.S. EPA (1980a,  1986a) reviewed a  2-year  feeding  study  by Horgareldge
et al.  (1977), In  which  rats were  fed  dietary  concentrations of  5,  50  and
5000 ppm beryllium  from  the sulfate.   The 5000 ppm dose level resulted  In  a
slight  decrease 1n body weight.   Carcinogenic effects observed 1n  this study
are discussed 1n Section 4.2.1.
3.2.2.    Inhalation.   In  humans,  Inhalation  exposure  to   beryllium   can
result   In  chronic  berylHosls.   Since this  disease  Is  probably a result of
hypersensltlzatlon  to beryllium, the length of exposure may not be critical.
The disease may  occur  >20 years or more after beryllium exposure  has  ended,
and  stress  conditions   (e.g.,  pregnancy)  can   produce  a  flare-up  of  the
disease (Tepper et  al., 1961).
    Although   fluorescent   lamp  manufacturing   Is  no   longer  a  beryllium
exposure  problem,   chronic  beryl!1os1s  was  first  reported  by  Hardy  and
Tabershaw  (1946), who  presented  data  on  17 cases In  'ndlvlduals employed  In
the fluorescent lamp manufacturing  Industry.  In most patients, the  symptoms
first  appeared  months  or  even  years  after  exposure.   The  majority of
patients were  women  and  most  were younger than  30.  Lung x-rays  Indicated  a

0113h                               -10-                              07/20/87

-------
progression from  fine  granularity  to  a  diffuse retlcular pattern to distinct
nodules  In the third  stage of  the  disease.  In  <2 years of  Illness,  5/17
patients  died.   Disability persisted  1n  most cases, although  some recovery
was noted  1n  two  cases.  Postmortem examination of  the  lungs  of one patient
showed a granulomatous  Inflammation.
    In addition to abnormalities  In lung  X-rays,  other  signs  and symptoms of
the chronic  disease  Include fatigue, chest  pain,  cyanosis, clubbing  of  the
fingers,   hepatomegaly,  splenomegaly,  cardiac  failure,  renal  stones   and
pneumothorax  (Hall et  al.,  1959).   Other  findings  were  hypercalcemla,  hyper -
calcuHa  and osteosclerosls  (Stoeckle  et  al.,  1969),  as well  as  hyper-
uMcemla (Kelley et al.. 1969).
    Hall et  al.  (1959) presented  data  on 601 cases listed In  the  BCR.   The
chronic  disease  accounted  for  61% of  the  cases,  although  28 cases  were
classified as both  acute  and  chronic.   In  men,  227/418 were  acute  cases,
while  In  women,  only  2  cases  were  acute.   The chronic  disease was  more
likely to  be  fatal;  31X of  the chronic disease patients  died  compared  with
6% of  the  acute  cases.  A long  latency period was  Indicated;  In >20X  of  the
cases  recorded  In the  BCR before  1959,  the time since  last exposure  was  >5
years with a maximum of 15 years.
    A  more recent report  (Elsenbud  and  Usson,  1983)  provides data  on  622
cases  of  the chronic  disease.   Among the  cases  examined, 577  were  occupa-
tional ly-exposed  to  beryllium,  42 were  attributed  to  ambient  air  exposure
(areas around plants)  and  23  to  dust exposure  In the  home.   The authors
reported that up  to  40 years  may elapse between Initial  exposure  and onset
of disease, so  that  more  recently exposed  Individuals may still develop  the
disease.
0113h                               -11-                             07/20/87

-------
    Infante et  al.  (I960)  conducted  a mortality  study  on 421  living  white
males listed  In  the  BCR during the period of 1952 through 1975  with  a  diag-
nosis  of beryllium-related  nonneoplastlc  respiratory  symptoms  or  disease.
During  this period,  139 subjects died  from  all causes, compared with  65.89
expected  deaths,  based  on cause-specific mortality rates  for  the  general
white  male population  of  the  United States.   The  excess  of  ~73  deaths
observed  In  this  study   was  predominantly  the  result  of  non-neoplastlc
respiratory disease   (52  deaths)  other  than  Influenza and  pneumonia  (1.6
expected).  Of  the  total  139  deaths, heart  disease was responsible for  31
compared with 29.9 expected,  19  were due to  cancer  (12.41 expected)  and  the
cause of  death  was  unknown  In 15  subjects.   Remaining  deaths  (22  subjects)
were due to all  other causes.
    Evidence that beryllium  exposure  may  result 1n excess deaths from  heart
disease or  respiratory  disease Is  provided  by  a mortality study by  Wagoner
et  al.  (1980).   This  study Involved  a cohort  of.  3055 white male  workers
exposed  to beryllium  for  varying  lengths  of   time  from 1942-1967  at  the
Kaweckl-Berylco   Industries  site  In   Pennsylvania.   During  the  period  of
Investigation, 875 deaths  occurred  compared  with 817  expected.   Significant
Increases  In  deaths  from  heart  disease  [396 observed  vs.  349   expected
(p<0.05)] and  respiratory disease,  other  than  Influenza  and pneumonia  [31
observed vs.  18.7 expected (pO.01)], were  noted.   The expected numbers  of
cases  were based  on  mortality rates  of  1965-1967  for  the  white  male
population of  the United States.
    A number of  Investigators have  studied  respiratory function of beryllium-
exposed workers  (Andrews et al., 1969; Kanarek  et  al.,  1973;  SpMnce et al.,
1978, 1979; Cotes et  al., 1983; Preuss  and  Oster, 1980).  These studies  do
not  clearly  Indicate that  measurements of  respiratory function parameters


0113h                               -12-                             07/20/87

-------
are  related  to  beryllium  exposure.   Cotes  et  al.  (1983)  concluded  that
respiratory  function studies  generally could  not detect  beryllium disease
before  radlographlc changes  appeared,  while  Preuss  and Oster  (1980)  noted
that changes  In vital capacity may occur long before X-ray changes appear.
    Evidence  that chronic  beryllium disease has  an  Immunologlcal component
has been  provided by a  number  of Investigators.   Curtis  (1951) developed a
patch  test   that  was  positive  for  most  cases  of  dermatitis  and  skin-
granuloma,  and  positive for many  cases of  lung  disease  caused  by beryllium
(Nlshlmura,   1966).   The   patch  test,  however,  could  also   Initiate  the
development  of  skin  reactions  or   pulmonary  disease  In  people  exposed  to
beryllium,  but  who had  not shown previous  symptoms of  respiratory Illness
(Sneddon, 1955; Stoeckle et al.. 1969; Rees, 1979; Cotes et al..  1983).
    Williams  and  Williams  (1983)  found  that  the  lymphocyte transformation
test gave a  positive response  In 16  patients with established chronic beryl-
lium disease, while-It was  negative In 10  subjects  with  suspected disease.
Only  two  positive  responses   were   reported  among  117  healthy  beryllium
workers.  Similar results were  also  reported by  Van Ordstrand (1984).  It Is
not  clear  1f  a   positive   test In a  healthy  worker Indicates  that  the
Individual 1s at a higher risk for developing pulmonary disease.
    In an  area  1n Czechoslovakia, where  coal  with a high  beryllium content
1s burned,  Bencko et al. (1980) found that plant workers  and people living
In the vicinity of  the plant had higher levels  of IgG  and  IgA and autoantl-
bodles compared  with an  unexposed  control  group.   Since  many   factors  may
contribute to higher Immunoglobln  levels,  the  significance  of these findings
1s not clear.
    Beryllium sensitivity has  been  observed  1n  some strains  of guinea  pigs
but not others  (Ch1app1no et al., 1969; Reeves  et al.,  1971, 1972;  Barna et


0113h                                 -13-                             07/20/87

-------
al.,  1981).   Because  these  studies were  of relatively  short duration  and
Include  exposure by  Intratracheal  Injection,  they  will  not be  discussed
further.
    Reeves et  al.  (1967)  exposed  groups of 75 male  and 75  female  Sprague-
Dawley rats  to  beryllium sulfate at a mean  concentration of  beryllium of 34
iig/ms,  7  hours/day,   5  days/week  for  up  to  72 weeks.   Control  of  the
exposure  concentration  was poor  (the  standard  deviation of  the mean  level
was  24  ng/m3).   Similar  groups  of  rats  were  maintained  as  controls.
Every month,  three  male and  three  female  rats  from the  exposed  and control
groups were  sacrificed.   Among  the findings were progressive Increases  In
lung  weight  In  the  exposed  rats;  at the  end  of  the  experiment,  the  lung
weights  of  exposed  rats were  on  an average of >4 times those of  controls.
Hlstologlcal examination  of  the lungs showed Inflammatory  and proHferatlve
changes.  Clusters of  macrophages  In  the alveolar spaces were  also  a common
finding.   Granulomatosls  and flbrosls  were only occasionally  seen.   The
proHferatlve changes  ultimately  led  to  the generation of  tumors  In all  the
exposed rats (43/43),  sacrificed or dead  at >13  months.
3.3.   TERATOGENICITY AND OTHER REPRODUCTIVE EFFECTS
    Pertinent da;a  regarding teratogenlc  and other reproductive  effects  of
beryllium  following  oral  or  Inhalation  exposure were  not  located In  the
available literature.
3.4.   TOXICANT INTERACTIONS
    Synerglstlc  offects  of  beryllium  have  been  noted.   Uzawa (1963)  found
that  beryllium  oxide  potentiated  the  carcinogenic effect  of  20-methylchol-
anthrene to a greater  degree  than  did  carbon black.   Stoklnger et al. (1950)
reported  a  synerglstlc effect of  fluoride 1on; beryllium  fluoride  produced
nearly  a  doubling  of  the  acute  toxic  effect  of beryllium sulfate  when
Inhaled at any given concentration.

0113h                               -14-                              07/20/87

-------
                              4.   CARCINOGEMICITY
4.1.   HUMAN DATA
4.1.1.   Oral.   Berg and  Burbank  (1972)  studied  the  relationship  between
trace metal concentrations  In  drinking water  and cancer deaths In 15 regions
of  the  United  States,  10  of  which Included  entire  states that  were rela-
tively well-sampled.   In the  analysis,  both  frequency of  detection  and the
average  detected  concentration of  the metal  were  considered.  Correlation?
between  beryllium  concentration  and  cancer   death  rate  were significantly
positive  for  cancers  of the  breast,  bone and  uterus, with  probability of
positive association  ranging from  0.006-0.040.   Mortality rates  for  regions
with  beryllium In  the  water  were  excessive  only  for nonwhlte  males.   The
highest  mean   level  of   beryllium  was  0.3   yg/l  found   1n  Delaware,
Maryland, West  Virginia  and Kentucky.   The  results of  this  study are based
on  Imperfect  analytical  methods  and sampling, and  the positive associations
for beryllium 1n drinking water and cancer  are not  proof of cause and effect
relationships (U.S. EPA.  1986b).
4.1.2.   Inhalation.   Infante  et al.  (1980)  studied  lung cancer  mortality
by  the  retrospective cohort method In white  males  listed In  the  BCR.   The
study cohort  Included  421  members of  the BCR, 15 years after  the onset of  beryllium exposure vs.  2.81
expected (p<0.01).  These expected  lung  cancer deaths  were calculated from a


0113H                               -15-                             11/03/86

-------
NIOSH life table program, which has been  shown  to  result  In an 11% excess  1n
the calculated expected number of lung cancer deaths  (Wagoner  et  al.,  1980).
Adjusting the  number  of expected deaths,  the  Infante et al.  (1980)  p value
1s reduced to  one  of  borderline significance (6 observed vs.  3.21  expected;
p<0.09).
    Infante et  al.  (1980) also  divided  the cohort on  the  basis of  "acute"
vs. "chronic"  beryllium disease.  Subjects  were considered  acute If  the  BCfi
records Indicated a diagnosis of chemical bronchitis  or pneumonUls  or other
acute respiratory Illness at time of entry  Into the registry.   Subjects were
called chronic If BCR records Indicated a diagnosis of  pulmonary  flbrosls  or
some recognized  chronic  lung condition at  time of entry Into  the  registry.
The remaining  cases,  which  could  not  be designated as  chronic, were con-
sidered by  Infante et  al.  (1980)  to  be  acute  If the  onset of  the  disease
occurred within  1  year  of Initial  exposure.  These designations  are  not  the
medically accepted definitions of acute and  chronic beryllium.disease; cases
of beryllium disease  lasting <1  year  are acute, while  those  lasting  >1 year
are chronic  (U.S.  EPA,  1986a).   The authors found no  significant  excess  In
lung cancer  In  their  chronic  respiratory  disease group of  198 persons  (1
observed  death  vs.  1.38  expected);   however,   1n their  acute  re:p1ratory
disease group  of 223  subjects,  they observed  6 lung cancer deaths  vs. 1.91
expected (p<0.05)  and,  1n the Interval of  >15  years  since  Initial  onset  of
beryllium exposure.  5  observed  cancer  deaths   vs.  1.56  expected  (p<0.05).
The expected  deaths  used for  these comparisons were also  determined using
the NIOSH life tables, so the results must be regarded as  questionable.
    A number of  studies of lung cancer  1n  beryllium exposed worker? from  two
plants  have  been  conducted  (Bayllss  et  al.,  1971;  Bayllss  and  Lalnhart,
1972; Bayllss and Wagoner, 1977; Wagoner et  al., 1980;  Hancuso and El-Attar,

0113H                               -16-                             11/03/86

-------
1969;  Mancuso,  1970,  1979,  1980).   These  studies have  been  described  1n
detail 1n U.S. EPA (1986a,b) and are summarized In Table 4-1.
    In  an  evaluation  of  the  total  database  regarding the  relationship  of
lung  cancer  with occupational  exposure to  beryllium,  the U.S.  EPA (1986a)
noted  several limitations.   None of these studies  are  Independent since all
are studies  of  basically the  same  group of workers.   Extensive cooperation
existed  between  the authors  of all these  studies;  they all  used  the NIOSH
life  table  program known  to produce an  11% underestimate  of expected lung
cancer  deaths  at the  time.   Furthermore,  the  authors  could  not adequately
address  the confounding effects  of  smoking  or  of  exposure to other potential
carcinogens  received  during   prior  and  subsequent   employment  1n  other
non-beryllium Industries  In the area known  to  produce  potential carcinogens
(especially  In  beryllium workers with  short-term  employment).   Problems  In
design  and  execution  of  the  studies  (e.g..  Incomplete  delineation  of  the
cohort)  further  weaken the  findings.   There appeared  to be  a  tendency for
the  authors   to  overemphasize   the  positive  nature of   their   results  and
minimize the  contribution  of qualifying  factors.   If   the problems  In these
studies  were addressed,  the  finding  of  a  significant  excess  risk  would
probably no  longer  be apparent,  although  the possibility  remains  that  a
portion  of  the remaining  excess lung  cancer  risk  may be partially  due  to
beryllium  exposure.   Thus,  U.S. EPA  (1986a,b) concluded that  despite  the
problems with  the  epidemiology studies, they  must be considered to  be  at
least suggestive of a carcinogenic risk 1n humans.
4.2.   BIOASSAYS
4.2.1.   Oral.   Chronic  oral  studies  of  beryllium have  not  resulted  In
statls-  tlcally  significant Increases  1n tumors In  treated  animals  compared
with  controls.   Schroeder  and  Kitchener  (1975a,b) provided  mice  and rats


0113h                               -17-                             03/05/87

-------




















01
"c
1


1

•^

«
|

o

^^
- I
SB 3
™ **

^
c
VI
b.
1
w
a
e
e
o
VI

I

















0)
u
6
41
i»
0*

41



v*

^m
a
Ml
0)
ac
i^
4>
U
e
e>
e
a
Ik
41

U




o a.
••* O 1
3,3

5si
41 M-




e e
e o
VI •••
~ i

CL •
5

^V

CF»
^
VI *
Wl •

•" 
,.
Iv

o



i







MI
a
e/i
a*

r»
•A

1
CM

•o
o
u
41
k
41
o
VI
4?


3C vi
VI 41

S 3
• 09
S3
CM
on
•O i—
e
• *
VI k


f e

IV 
3.28 a

o
CO
on

^ »
41 •
e ^
a"
CM





^ .
VJ1
O
— o

rt ""
S* Urf
VI ««
^^ ^*
^)
«r —
.. £"2.
1v So

e iv



vn
^%




«
a
4^
i
a

r*
vO

"7
(M


41

|
V*

i
y*

jfo.
TJ >• —
IV «• £
«— * VI
1 — HI 41
S2S 3
2
4^

e
k
e iv

a •—
w 4
e i















^
y
41



vO



^»
a
i
sf
^* *•
li
ii

•

cf
1
on
VI
«< e

k IV
a o>
u
41 »
VI 1^
<"• » «•

2T! a
u •« o.
e a «
vi 7 k

CA ««
a •-
S^v.
•^n 4i

o
r*

c-
^
a

a
u
e




^^ ^M
*- O
m
U V
•t M rQ
" o a 41
C i— i— vi
a> •>»•>. — *
I * • • »— o
a n an >»>» «—
j«cnj«^
4i vi vi iv 09 r>
Ik iv iv •"
e 41 4i a.
>l >• VI «•
e « a
o ta>ft ». e
Iv^^ a — S
k AIV •- a a
•3 S.



5
^%




"3
§
u
IV
e
s
J=

«r oa

on on
i e i
r» 
SS3
on

on

m
O
VI
a
u
e
2
e
e vi
v ••
ill
• Urf k
O — IV
V 0.
Q.CM « — •
— CM -0 .—
O
— . • o» .
• • wu — e o
J-2IS.
§^'I
* «-«..
M • 1 VI ~
•V <3*«V •*•-
41 — •- iv •
v -out

1 >» *•-«
>. VI — O
g 2 £ ~o

- g


—
SS —
k O% CB




s
i
01
i
a*

oa

en
i
CM
on


01

a
.a
V*

i
IV


VI
(M 41
CM*-

II.
1  •*
sii
0
09

^
^
a
VI
a
u
e





~ **•
s ~-
|«
— 0
u V
a—
i!
wt •
flE ^1
w»
•o —
gs
"5 as

E



fS
an





e
a
|Q
41 ««
VI k
a «
W J<
VI k
>s

CO

9^
1
O*


«»

I
M
•»

I
V*

.

i w
kfl 4>
Si i












1

U
&

01
u

—
1
fcff
J3
e
M
o"

..
e
i

e

1
u
§
«•
*~
^
k
«
VI
a
k
4B
i
oa
JC

^*
e
IV
VI
e
e
4>
VI
41
k

VI
I ^
on a
^» u
« k
a, ^
• u

41 M;
w
k H
a
a *M
 oo
0113h
-18-
11/03/86

-------
with  drinking  water containing beryllium  sulfate at 5  ppm beryllium.   They
reported  a  slight Increase  1n  leukemlas  1n female  mice (9/52 treated, 3/47
control)  (Schroeder  and Kitchener.  1975b),  and a  slightly higher Incidence
of  grossly  observed  tumors  In   male rats   (9/33  treated.  4/26  control)
(Schroeder  and Kitchener,  1975a).   These  Increases were  not statistically
significant In either species.
    In  a  study by Horgareldge  et  a "I.  (1975),  groups of  50 Wlstar rats were
provided  with  diets  containing beryllium  sulfate  at  0,   5,  50  or  500  ppm
beryllium for  104 weeks.   The highest survival  rate and the least number of
pathological lesions  (of  all treated groups) were  found 1n the highest dose
group.  Retlculum cell  sarcoma In  the lung was seen 1n all  dose groups  and
1n controls, and  the same lesions were seen In lymph  nodes, bone marrow and
unspecified abdominal  organs.   The Incidence of  lung  retlculum cell  sarcoma
was higher  In  males  than females and  was  statistically significant In males
at  the two  lower doses  but  not  at  the  high  dose.   Although  the  authors
stated  that  "there was probably no  statistical  difference In retlculum-cell
sarcoma between  the  observed  Incidence 1n  the  different groups" and that
"there  Is  no dose-Incidence relationship,   with  the  highest  Incidence
occurring  In  the low-level  group,"  their  tabular  data  show  statistical
significance.  In an analysis  of-this  study,  U.S.  EPA  (1986b)  determined
that the  Incidence of lung  retlculum cell  carcinoma In males was significant
by the  Fisher  exact  test  1n  the two lowest groups (5 ppm,, p=0.0065;  50 ppm,
p»0.036).    This   study  Is  considered to  be  suggestive  of  a  carcinogenic
response  to Ingested  beryllium,  but the lack of  a  response at the high dose
and the fact that  the study  was not published  or (presumably) peer-reviewed,
severely limits Interpretation as  a positive study (U.S. EPA, 1986b).
0113h                               -19-                             11/03/86

-------
4.2.2.   Inhalation.  Numerous  animal  studies  have Indicated  that  Inhala-
tion exposure to beryllium and  beryllium-containing  substances  may  result  In
pulmonary  tumors.    These  studies  are   briefly  presented  In  Table  4-2.
Schepers et  al.  (1957)  noted eight  hlstologlcally  distinct types  of  tumors
1n  the  lungs   of   exposed   rats.    Intrathoradc  metastases  were  commonly
observed and transplantations were frequently successful.
    In  the  series  of experiments  by Vorwald (1953, 1962),  the  Incidence  of
lung tumors  In exposed rats  appeared to  be  weakly  positively correlated with
exposure concentration and duration.  Reeves and Deltch  (1969),  on  the other
hand,  stated that   tumor  yield  In  rats  depended on age  at exposure  rather
than on  duration of exposure.  These Investigators  determined  that exposure
for only  3 months  at  an early  age gave a  tumorlgenlc  response similar  to
exposure for 18 months.   Reduced  tumor  counts were  observed  1n rats exposed
for 3  months later  In  life.   In  all  cases, a  latency  period of  -9  months
from Initiation of  exposure seemed to be  required.
    Of  20  female  rhesus  monkeys  Intermittently exposed  to beryllium phos-
phate,  beryllium  sulfate or  beryllium   fluoride  for 8  months,  lung  tumors
were observed In only one  (Schepers, 1964).   Intermittent  exposure  of  rhesus
monkeys  for  >36 months  to  beryllium sulfate,  however,  was associated  with
development of lung tumors In 8/11 (Vorwald, 1968).
4.3.   OTHER RELEVANT DATA
    In addition to  being a carcinogen  In laboratory animals  following Inha-
lation exposure, beryllium has  also been shown to  be  carcinogenic  following
Intratracheal  and   Intravenous   Injections,  and   Implantation  Into   bone.
Several  studies  (Vorwald  and  Reeves,   1959;  Spencer et   al.,  1968,  1972;
Ishlnlshi  et al.,   1980;  Groth  et  al.,  1972, 1976,  1980;  Groth and  McKay,
1971)  Involved  Intratracheal  administration of beryllium and  compounds Into
rats  and  one  study  (Vorwald   et  al.,  1966)  Involved   rhesus  monkeys.

0113h                               -20-                              03/05/87

-------


01
s
01
at

o
e
a u
a> 
^ ' u
J2 ^ e
£ -si
TABLE 4-2
Pulmonary CarclnoM fron Inhalation Exposure of Antaals to Bery
Weekly
Compound Species Atmspherlc Exposure Duration of Exposure
Concentration Tine (Months) Pul
{mq/m* as Be) (hours)
^
in on
-
en r~  OD *• *—
(ii i—
^i «rt ^i
IA
*
u.
3
1
*>^
i.
0)
W 0^ 0R W* Qn
en on en en en
va *o (••.
i-'-enAf£««
CM CM CM CM CM ^* f^ • 01 01 01 0> Ctt
enonenencn'"''^000 *
oiot-^eeeee
SS5S'S5SSSSSS§!
— » X X K X X
a 4= ^ j= « «
i— « O O O O O
*v vb. jo ^i ^ ^ ^a
Or^oinm vif^cneMenin^vn
en CM Lf> en r- a— CM
0113h
-21-
11/03/86

-------

4)
u
S
1»
•V
<*•>
4»
OB
|
<*» ^
0 U
l»
41 t»
u O
e
41 »
•o u.
— •«
= §
^"* •
3
GU
4)
b.
3
VI
X «•»
Duration of E
(•onths
*2 -
f- 3 41 VI
J< VI • u
11=1
^^ **
we?
w> **
4)  e •
II!

VI
«
u
4)
o.
«/>


•w
e
3
1
u

CM en en en
(^ ^B ^9 ^9
9* 91 91 9%
F— »~ »~ *•*
«A CD x9 P» ..A^^i«9«i9^>«O<*O«iiO^
. " . . - 	 - - «*
b^bW WWbbl^WWWWW
4l^4l4)>A4l4l4l4l4>4l4>4l4l4l^l-u
a. -» a. a, 4> 0,0.0.0.0.0,0.0,0,0,4) 41 «
i;^^^£^^i£££^j£s>ss»
£££££££££££££££55£

VI »/» «» Wl W<

eB«CMCMVCMCMp>r>
n F- i— CM ^ >— "- CMCM^f— •—
iti t
eo ^ f <«
i-SSSS55^5S5:S53SSS

I.ssSsS|8|-s||§gas
IA CD r+ 2S ^- 09
« rt r>
rt
w«
£. s: >, 5
,? « « e
1 » 1 1 5 8
i o. • • a, vi i—
• & vi i- «
1AM VI VI«^IQttb
S3 3 3 — 41 — L.
vi e v> vi vivividevivi^
S £ Z> 4) •»4>-»j3---'«3
I & 2 ^ SfSSaSSvT
5 «
4» 10 *
2 t 1
!•• (^ ^
i-03
5 - =
1 I III
^T ^^ ^^ ^R «h
** ^ ^ — J »
1 1 111
0113H
-22-
03/05/87

-------
a
u

u
c
4*
1_
<*»
Si

\
9 w
b»
11 "fl
U <^
e
u »
•O u
u e
e o
a
vi
1-
j!
i
^s«-
* "" £ a
uj£
-1*
U — '

W*
I

•o
e
3
e
u

at on at
^ 
-------
Incidence of  beryllium Induced lung cancers ranged  from  0-100%.   Generally,
a  latency,  period  of  at  least  6  months  and,  preferably,  9  months  was
required.   These  studies have  been  reviewed and evaluated  In other  recent
U.S.  EPA (1986a,b) analyses.   It  1s beyond  the scope of  this document  to
reproduce these data,  particularly  since  these data are  not  useful  for risk
assessment.  The most  detailed  studies of  Intratracheal Injections  of  beryl-
lium were reported  by Spencer  et al. (1965, 1968,  1972).  In  these studies*
beryllium oxide fired  at different  temperatures  was Injected  Intratracheally
Into rats.  The results showed that the beryllium  oxide  fired  at  the  lowest
temperature (500°C)  had the greatest  carcinogenic  potency.   This  beryllium
oxide also  had the greatest  surface area  when  compared  to beryllium oxide
fired at 1100 or 1600'C.
    Intravenous Injection and  subperlosteal or  Intraosseous  Implantation  of
beryllium and  several  of Its  compounds have been shown to result  In  osteo-
sarcomas  In rabbits  (Nash,  1950;  Outra   and  Largent, I960;  Kawada,  1963;
Fodor,  1971;   Komltowskl,  1969; Tapp,  1969;  Yamaguchl  and  Katsura,  1963;
Gardner  and Hesllngton, 1946;  Barnes et al.,  1950; Slssons, 1950;  Cloudman
et al.,  1949;  Hoagland  et al.,  1950; Janes et  al..  1954;  Kelly  et  al., 1961;
Hlgglns  et  al.,  1964:  Nazabraud,  1975)  and mice  (Cloudman  et al.,  1949).
The Incidence  of osteosarcoma  ranged from  0-100% by either route  of adminis-
tration.  A latency period  of >9 months  seemed  to be required.
    Beryllium  has  been  studied  1n mutagenlclty  assays.   Beryllium  sulfate
was negative  In several tests  conducted   In Salmonella  typhlmurlum both  In
the presence and absence of S9  (Simmon, 1979a; Rosenkranz and  Polrler, 1979;
Arlauskas et  al.,  1985; Simmon  et  al.,  1979).  Beryllium was  also negative
In the pol assay  (Rosenkranz and Lelfer, 1980) and  the HP2 system (Ishlzawa,
1979) 1n Escher1ch1a coll and  In Saccharomvces cerevlslae 03  (Simmon  et al.,


0113h                               -24-                             07/20/87

-------
1979;  Simmon.  1979b).   Positive  reports  In  microorganisms  Include  the
fluctuation  test  1n  S.  typhlmurlum strain  TA100  (Arlauskas et  al.,  1985),
the  rec  assay  In Bacillus  subtnis  (Kanematsu et  al.f  1980;  Kada  et  al.,
1980)  and  the Induction of  DNA  protein  adducts  1n E..  coll  (Kub1nsk1 et al..
1981).
    Other  studies  of  the  genotoxlc   potential   of  beryllium   In  cultured
mammalian  cells  have been  reported.   Mlyakl  et al.  (1979)  demonstrated the-
Induction  of  8-azaguan1ne-res1stant  mutants  by beryllium chloride In Chinese
hamster  V79  cells.   Hsle  et  al.   (1979a,b)  reported  the  Induction  of
8-azaguan1ne-res1stant  mutants   In  CHO cells  exposed  to beryllium  sulfate.
Larramendy et al.  (1981)  reported  that beryllium sulfate Induced chromosomal
aberrations In Syrian hamster embryo cells and In  human lymphocytes  and that
beryllium  sulfate  caused   a  dose-dependent  Increase  In  sister-chromatld
exchanges  In  both  Syrian  hamster  cells  and  human  lymphocytes.   These
results, however,  showed Increases  In slster-chromatld exchanges  that  were
<2-fold, so  that the dose-response  relationship suggested  by  Larramendy et
al. (1981) may be somewhat tenuous.
    Williams  et   al.  (1982)  found  that  beryllium  sulfate  did  not  Induce
unscheduled  DNA   synthesis   In  rat primary  hepatocyte cultures.   Beryllium
sulfate also  resulted  1n  no chromosomal effects In  human  flbroblasts  (UI 38
cells) (Paton and Allison,   1972).   In. vitro exposure of rat liver  cells to
beryllium  resulted  In  Us  binding  to  phosphorylated non-hlstone  proteins
(Parker  and  Stevens,  1979).   Perry  et al.  (1982)  found  that  exposure  of
cultured  rat  hepatosomal  cells  to   beryllium  reduced  the  glucocortlcold
Induction  of tyros1r»e  transamlnase  activity.   In  a  DNA  fidelity  assay,
beryllium  Increased  the mlslncorporatlon of  nucleotlde bases In  the  daughter
strand of  DNA synthesized In vitro from polynucleotlde  templates  (Zakour et


0113h                               -25-                             07/20/87

-------
al.,  1981).   Beryllium  has also  been  Investigated  for  Its  effect on  the'
transcription of  calf thyrous  DMA  and phage T^  DNA by  RNA  polymerase  (from
E_.  colD  under  controlled  conditions.   Beryllium  Inhibited  overall  tran-
scription  but  Increased  RNA Initiation, Indicating  the Interaction of  the
metal with the DNA template  (Nlyogl et al.,  1981).
4.4.   HEIGHT OF EVIDENCE
    Beryllium  has  been  shown  to  be   clearly  carcinogenic  In  laboratory
animals  following  Inhalation exposure and Injection  (see Sections 4.2.2.  and
4.3.).   Epidemiology  studies of  Inhalation  exposure  (see Section 4.1.2.)  are
suggestive  but   have   been   judged  Inadequate  to  demonstrate   or  refute  a
carcinogenic potential 1n humans.
    From the available data, IARC  (1980) concluded that  there  1s sufficient
evidence  that   beryllium Is  carcinogenic  In animals,  but  ep1dem1olog1cal
evidence that  occupational  exposure  to  beryllium may  lead  to  an  Increased
lung  cancer  risk  Is only limited.   This description Is  consistent  with  the
IARC Group 2B classification.
    Applying the U.S.  EPA (1986d)  guidelines  for  carcinogen  risk assessment,
the evidence from the Inhalation  animal  studies  1s judged  to  be sufficient
that bery'illjm Is an  animal  carcinogen.  U.S.  EPA (1986a)  concluded that  the
human  evidence  Is "Inadequate"; therefore*  according to the guidelines  for
evaluating the weight  of evidence  of  carclnogenlclty  to  humans,  beryllium 1s
most appropriately classified  1n Group B2,  a  probable human  carcinogen  (U.S.
EPA,  1986a).  The weight of evidence for beryllium's  carcinogenic  potential
from  oral  exposure  Is  much  less  certain  given  that  there  are  only  two
studies  thai: provide  only suggestive  evidence  of  carcinogenic  activity.  The
data  presented   In  these  studies   contain  Inconsistencies  that  give  low
confidence  to  quantitative  analysis.   The  U.S.  EPA Carcinogen  Assessment
Group lus stated that  Ingested beryllium may be capable of Inducing a human
0113h                               -26-                             07/20/87

-------
carcinogenic  response  (unlike  some  other  metal  for  which  carcinogenic
activity  has  not been  detected) and  therefore caution  should  be exercised
until   further   research   Is   available   to  define  the  oral  carcinogenic
potential of beryllium.
0113h                               -27-                             07/20/87

-------
                     5.   REGULATORY  STANDARDS  AND  CRITERIA

    Occupational standards  for  beryllium and compounds  have  been developed.
The  ACGIH  (1986)  TLV-TWA  for  beryllium  and  compounds  Is  0.002 jig/m3  (2
mg/m*,)  based  primarily  on  Industrial experience.   The ACGIH  committee  1s
currently reviewing  the  data  regarding beryllium.   OSHA  (1985)  standards for
beryllium  are   2   ug/m3  as   the  8-hour  TWA,   5   yg/m3   as   the  celling-
limit  and  25  yg/m3  as  the  maximum  peak  above  the celling  concentration
to which an Individual can be exposed for 30 minutes during an 8-hour shift.
    A  number  of ambient water  quality  criteria  values  for beryllium  have
been  derived.   U.S.  EPA (1980a,  1982),  using  the  statistically Insignifi-
cant  excess  of grossly  observed  tumors  at  all  sites  1n male rats  from the
Schroeder and  Kitchener  (1975a)  study and  the  linearized  multistage model,
determined  that a  water  concentration of  68  ng/i corresponds  to a  risk
level  of 10~><>   This  value  Is  based on  a  dally  Intake of  2 l of  water
and 6.5 g fish and  shellfish  for  a  70  kg human, and a BCF  of 19.  This value
was also  presented  In a more recent U.S. EPA (1986b)  analysis.   A toxlclty-
based  ambient  water  level   of  17.8  yg/l   was  also  calculated  from  the
Schroeder and  MHchener  (1975a)  study  by using  the 5  ppm drinking  water
level  as a  NOAEL   (U.S.  EPA.  1980a,  1982).   An equivalent  dose of  0.538
mg/kg/day was  estimated  by  assuming  water  consumption of  0.035  I/day and
estimating  the  body weight of  exposed rats  at  0.325 kg.   Th? water  concen-
tration  from  this  NOAEL  1s equivalent to 0.0377  mg/day  for  a  70  kg human.
An  RfD of  5.0xlO~» mg/kg/day  (0.377  mg/day)  based on the  5  ppm  NOAEL  In
the Schroeder  and  Kitchener,  1975a) study  has  been derived by  the U.S. EPA
(1986c).
0113h                               -28-                             07/20/87

-------
    The U.S. EPA (19865) derived the following HAs for beryllium:

               1-day HA for a 10 kg child. 26 mg/i
               1-day HA for a 70 kg adult. 96 mg/i
              10-day HA for a 10 kg child. 2.6 mg/t
              10-day HA for a 70 kg adult, 9.6 mg/i


An  RfO  of 0.005 mg/kg/day  has  also been derived based on  the  Schroeder  and

Kitchener (1975a) rat study (U.S. EPA 1986c).
0113h                               -29-                             07/20/87

-------
                              6.   RISK ASSESSMENT
6.1    SUBCHRONIC REFERENCE DOSE (RfD$)
6.1.1.   Oral   (RfO-g).    Beryllium  has   been   shown   to   be   clearly
carcinogenic  by  other  routes  of  exposure, although  for the oral  route the
evidence  Is  less  certain.   A plausible  upper  bound  estimate  of  q, * has
been  calculated.    Therefore,   H  1s  not  appropriate   to  derive  an  RfDcn
                                                                           oU
value for beryllium or  Us compounds.
6.1.2.   Inhalation   (RfD-,).    Numerous   experiments   using   laboratory
animals  have  Indicated that  beryllium 1s carcinogenic  following Inhalation
exposure; therefore, an RfDej value will  not be derived.
6.2.   REFERENCE OOSE (RfD)
6.2.1.   Oral   (RfOQ).    Beryllium   has   been   shown   to   be   clearly
carcinogenic  by  other  routes of  exposure, and  a q,*  has  been  calculated
for  oral exposure.   Therefore.  It   1s  not appropriate to  derive  an  RfO.
value.
6.2.2.   Inhalation  (RfD.).   Beryllium  has been  shown  to  be  carcinogenic
1n  laboratory animals  by the  Inhalation  route;  therefore,  an RfD,  value
will not be derived.
6.3.   CARCINOGENIC POTENCY (q^)
6.3.1.   Oral.   Beryllium  has   been shown   to  be   clearly   carcinogenic
following   Inhalation   exposure,   Intratracheal   Injection.   Intravenous
Injection and Implantation.  To what  extent beryllium Is carcinogenic by the
oral  route  1s largely  uncertain,  due to the fact that  oral  absorption data
are conflicting.   Hyslop  et al.  (1943),  Crowley  et al.  (1949)  and Furchner
et al. (1973) Indicate  that absorption Is  <1X,  while  Reeves (1965) estimated
that absorption may range  from  10-40% of  the  Ingested dose.  If beryllium Is
absorbed  following oral  exposure,   evidence  from other  routes  of  exposure
Indicate that  It  Is also likely  to  be a carcinogen by  the oral  route.  The

0113h                               -30-                              07/20/87

-------
hypothesis  Is  that  beryllium's  solubility In the gastrointestinal system may
be  the  key to better characterizing  the  oral  carcinogenic risk of beryllium
and  Its  salts.   This  hypothesis,  however,  has not  been  fully developed.
Because  beryllium  may  pose  a  carcinogenic  risk  by   the  oral  route  of
exposure,  a  default  position  has  been  adopted  for  calculating  a  q,*
despite  the  clear   presence of  significant  tumor  Incidences  1n  the  two
chronic  oral  studies.   The  presumption  Is  that the  risk  would not  be any
higher  than  that estimated  from  a  nonsignificant  (negative)  study  and that
the  value derived  1s  of  lower  confidence In  estimating an upper  limit  of
possible risk.   The  derived  estimate  1s thought to be only a plausible upper
bound due  to  the hypothesis that the  solubility of beryllium salts  may be a
differentiating  factor In beryllium's cancer risk from oral exposure.
    In  the Schroeder and  Kitchener  (1975a,b)   studies,  rats and mice were
provided  with  drinking water containing  5 ppm  beryllium sulfate throughout
their lifetime.   Male rats showed a  statistically  Insignificant Increase In
the  Incidence  of grossly observed  tumors,  while female  mice showed  a small
Insignificant  excess of  lymphoma  leukemlas.   In  an  unpublished study  by
Horgareldge et al.  (1975),  rats were exposed  to beryllium at concentrations
of 5, 50  or  500  ppm 1n the diet for  2  years.   The  data  from this study were
analyzed by  U.S. EPA (1986b),  which  found a  significantly  higher  number  of
retlculum cell sarcomas  In the  two  lower  dose male groups.  The relationship
between  the  dose and  response was  Inverse;  the most  significant  response
occurred at 5 ppm, and  no  significant response occurred  at 500 ppm.   Because
of the lack of dose-response, the limitations In design  and execution of the
study and  because these results have never been published,  the Horgareldge
et al.  (1975)  study cannot  be  used to calculate a q *; however,  the study
does provide evidence that beryllium 1s carcinogenic following oral exposure.

0113h                               -31-                             07/20/87

-------
    U.S.  EPA  (1986b),  using Global 82  (Howe and Crump,  1982),  calculated a
q *  from  the  nonsignificant  tumor  Incidence  data  In  male  rats  from  the
Schroeder  and  Kitchener  (1975a) study.  The  data used to  calculate  the  q,*
of  4.86  (mg/kg/day)"1  1s  presented  1n  Table 6-1.   The  water  Intake  value
derived  to determine  the  dose  level  used  1n  the q,*  calculation was  not
provided.
6.3.2.    Inhalation.   Beryllium  has  been   found  to  be   carcinogenic   Irv
numerous  animal  studies.   Unfortunately,  the animal  studies  are  not  well-
documented and many  were conducted  at one dose  level.  The U.S.  EPA  (1986a)
has used  data  from 10 studies  to  calculate  potency  estimates.   These  esti-
mates are presented  In Table 6-2.   Except for the Reeves  and  Deltch  (1969)
study,  the  estimates  were derived  using   the  linear  nonthreshold  dose-
response  model,  which  provides  conservative  risk   estimates.   The  risk
estimate  from  the  Reeves   and  Deltch (1969)  study  was  calculated using  a
multistage model  AOOLLI-83  developed  by  Crump  and  Howe  (1984).  All  risk
estimates  were calculated  with and  without  surface area   correction.   The
surface  area  correction Is used to  correct  for  higher  metabolic rates  In
smaller animals.  Because beryllium seems  to  be  sequestered In  the  lungs  and
the dose may  not  be  affected  by  metabolism.  It  Is uncertain  whether  the
surface area correction  should be  used.   Using  both  methods,  q  *  values  of
4.9x10"*   to   4.3   (ug/mT1  were   derived.   The   magnitude   of   the  q^
value appears  to depend, as a  function  of   Its  solubility,  on  the  form  of
beryllium  used In the  experiment.   Beryl ore  1s  the least potent of the four
compounds, while beryllium sulfate Is the most potent.
    The  U.S.   EPA  (1980a)  has   recommended  a  q^* from  human  epidemiology
data.   However,  this   Is   an   external  review  draft  currently  undergoing
revision  by  the Agency.   This  ep1dem1olog1cal  data  has been  judged  to  be
Inadequate for demonstrating or refuting a carcinogenic effect.

0113h                               -32-                             07/20/87

-------
                                   TABLE 6-1
                       Derivation of q-j* for Beryllium3

Reference:  Schroeder and Kitchener, 1975a
Species/sex:  rat/male
Route/vehicle:  oral/drinking water
Length of exposure (1e) =1126 days
Length of experiment (LE) = 1126 days
Llfespan of animal (L) = 1126 days
Body weight * 0.325 kg (measured)0
Tumor site and type:  gross tumors, all sites
Experimental
Exposure
0
5 mg/l
Human q-j* * 4.86
Transformed Dosec
(mg/kg/day)
0
0.455
(mg/kg/day)"1
Incidence
No. Responding/No. Tested
4/26
9/33
aSource: U.S. EPA, 19866
DBody weight average  for  both  sexes  estimated  from tabular  data  provided
 by Investigator.
cEst1mat1on based on the assumption that rats consumed 0.35 i of water/day.
0113h                               -33-                             07/20/87

-------










V*
e
e

|
vi
wu
4)
0
u
c
4)
O

e


§

^1
41
O
U
5
••
e

pa ""
- 1
2 <
5 e
^ o
^t
41
3
§
^
*^
e
a
!
^
41
u*
I
i/t
0)
ae
i
0)
VI
o
o
§
£
u
41
CD








U
S
41
41
Of


1-0
0 «
— ll
•— a.-
« e i
j* >— — •
V ~X
I H —
X —*
3C urf
§

e •• •
e 4» 19 •
J*
o- c a

u

^ c
•< o
u u
<• 41

X W X

S-o
= §
•— o
11
W«
4»
U
a»
*
n
vn
0

.
2
S
!•

*


•« n
i i
a a

f» vO



9«(Vi
,J ^1








* i



•

a
•y



o
vn




g/Be/M*.
ours /week
13 Months
S JB

n m a
n n  3
A V

wt
^^
SB

f^t

9*
w*
41 .
Af—
«* *9
^s

W» 0


^ n
t i
0 0

wr»«n



— WO
I— sO








* 1





?
^9
m


a.
es«




tig/Be/H*.
ours /week
7.5 Months

• ^
mm e
n n 
V •—
^E ^3

""~



e o
o a
CO WO



vn ie
u> 0>








^ ,





0
f^



,_
P^
fm



ng/Be/M*.
ours/week
6.5 Months

r» w
ram a
 •— c <« > -—
JE>O u 4t«- Ol «( —
U9> o •*» ai «i J o^^ oa«A n*o oe
>— (MO at

'•





* i * i * i * i * i





1 S 2 '2
^» tn & 9* of



•— • rfi *^ ^
^ O n» vo ac
S *


M
« • >» «
.M «< >J(«t fcJCWI -1— v» *J<<^
oi e H4IA H «• .e • — ^ •4it9
•t!9 • S> »* ^, ai — • e -< -S.4IX
• Si ^ S c t»xc >.4>e a» s o
• x, 4»>a ai>.a a» -- o ao ^ j
•x v» wr> aa vi L: •-•/•• oa •» • •XM
4IU- X.k I7> V. ^ — 0» 1- 3
ease 01300 »3co o> a i— a a o
•x o — a o f- e f a k i— ox
o>£ s f- -c 4> r» f
a u ooi. • i- o — L. • i_
ma *ma mma cvjea mma
9> n u. rxnv. .•><•>«. -a ~ >+. nnit.

1, 1^ t i^


>. e >•«. at >»>».
L. 3 t. — w k. i—
a> •— 41 3 41 41 3




0113H
-34-
07/20/87

-------
e
u

41
U
e
01
01
01
gg



I'-
.cu
«- o>
01 O 1



B — 01


^™ ^™
^ l/»
-I-
e «- •
J1S £"«>
i £•
3 S 01
«§ —
*m
3
< o
01 —
w u
 k
3 e
«/> u

b. U
e Q o» 01
^ h- u at
s e
a. «.

151
^is|

?sss
•» a. w — •
— X C
V) ^M O
u
ie.
~ o «•
^^ "•
>»•» a.
0) •* 01
oo e L.
•1 3
e u vi
 x
hU


If
ao



VI
01
U
01
Ok
CO
an
01 —
^L *V
^m f^ k
u 0t O
 k »»
k • W
•o m o am o



1 !
• 0> •- 0»
*— •* f~ •*
1—19 1— 19
>»»«.
k ^— U ^*
01 3 01 3
A VI A vi



VI
•9 VI >»
01 3 01
^3. S-S
S» .8
Q

U
i
e
01
£
-
«

|
C


e
4J
U
e
o
li

i£
2 *
e£
J«
** ^»
*• ,£

xi
«••
S JI
'•
||

Is
-» a.
Sx
«
-1
" 8

e
* S
11
||
3-

*" tt
tt •
If
^. o

<9 "Sa

I !|
. MO
a «- a,
•0 K
U *O VI
«. e k.
3 >• 3
e — o
 V>f

|

•o
01
8
tf*
•
*tt
i
S1
**
£
i
„

JC
u
i


o
(4.


en
JS
u
s
tt
a

e
01
01
01
OK
Ok
U
K
(|

VI
|
1/9
^
*
U
o

L

VI 3
O vi
Ok >«
51

'I
*o 5
"S-o -o
re »
5* 1
H =
U VI
fc* «•
•
41 A vi
e u
— « «•
"| *
TI >
a 01 *.
>« a


















































•o
01
o
^L
V
1.

e
«
     0113h
-35-
07/20/87

-------
    The usual approach In risk assessment  1s  to  accept the most conservative
estimate   of   carcinogenic  risk,   which  In   this  case   would  be   4.3
(vg/m*)"1,  calculated  from  the  rat  study  by   Vorwald  et   al.   (1966).
The U.S.  EPA  (1986a)  suggested  that the use  of  this animal  potency  estimate
would overestimate  the  human risk and  Is  not consistent  with  human experi-
ence  In  the  beryllium  Industry.   Therefore,  U.S.  EPA  (1986a)  recommends
2.4xlO~3   (vg/m3)"1   as    the   estimate   of   risk   associated   with   \
ng/m3 of  beryllium 1n  air.   This  estimate  1s  the  geometric mean  of  eight
q.j*s  calculated  on  the   basis  of  human  data  under  various  assumptions
(Table  6-3).   The  estimate  of  2.4x10""  dig/m*)"1  could  be  considered
to be an  upper-bound  estimate  of the cancer  risk  because  low dose linearity
Is assumed  In the extrapolation and  the  95X upper  confidence  limits  of the
relative  risks  are  used  In the  calculations.   Transforming  to  units  of
(mg/kg/day)"1,   the  unit   risk   of   2.4xlO~»   Ug/m")"1   Is   equivalent
to 8.4 (mg/kg/day)"1.
    Because  the carcinogenic  potency  seems   to  be  related to  beryllium's
solubility,   the   U.S.   EPA  (1986a)   cautions   that    beryllium   species
Identification  Is  likely  to  be  a   very   Important  aspect   of  properly
characterizing  the  possible  oral   or   Inhalation  exposure  risk  to  humans.
U.S. EPA  (1986a)  Is an  external  draft  document  that Is  currently undergoing
revision,  therefore a  final  recommended unit  risk  (q,* value)  will  have to
await the flnallzatlon of this  document.
0113h                               -36-                             07/20/87

-------
                                   TABLE 6-3

                Upper-Bound Cancer Potency Estimates Calculated
                          Under Various Assumptions3
Beryllium
Concentration
In Workplace f/L
(vg/m3)
100 1

0.25

1000 1

0.25

Effective
Doseb
Ug/m3)
21.92

5.48

219.18

54.79

95X Upper -Bound
Estimate of
Relative Risk
1.98
2.09
1.98
2.09
1.98
2.09
1.98
2.09
Cancer Potency0
Ug/m3)'1
1.61xlO"3
1.79xlO"»
6.44x10"'
7.16xlO"3
1.61x10"*
1.79x10"*
6.44x10"*
7.16x10"*
^Source: U.S. EPA, 1986a

^Effective  dose  Is  calculated  by multiplying  the  beryllium  concentration
 In the  workplace by the  factor  (8/24)x(240/365)x(f/L) (f -  years exposed;
 L - years at risk).

cFor a  given effective  dose (d) and  a  relative risk  (R),  the carcinogenic
 potency  1s  calculated  by the  formula B =  (R-l)  x 0.036/d, where 0.036 Is
 the estimated lung cancer mortality rate In the United States population.
0113h
-37-
07/20/87

-------
                                7.   REFERENCES

ACGIH  (American  Conference  of  Governmental  Industrial  Hyglenlsts).   1986.
Documentation of Threshold Limit Values and Biological Exposure  Indices,  5th
ed.  Cincinnati,  OH.  p. 56-57.

Andrews, J.L., H. Kazeml and H.L. Hardy.  1969.   Patterns  of  lung dysfunction-
In chronic beryllium  disease.   Am.  Rev.  Resplr. 01s.  100:  791-800.   (Cited
In U.S. EPA,  1986a)

Arlauskas,  A., R.S.  Baker, A.N. Bonln, K.R. Tandon,  P.T.  Crisp and  J.  Ellis.
1985.   NutagenlcUy  of metal  Ions  In  bacteria.   Environ.  Res.   36(2):
379-388.

Barna, B.P., T.  Chiang,  S.G.  P1llar1sett1 and S.D.  Deodhar.  1981.   Immuno-
loglc  studies  of experimental  beryllium  lung disease  In  the  guinea  pig.
Cl1n. Immunol. Immunopathol .   29:  402-411.  (Cited  1n U.S.  EPA, 1986a)

Barnes, J.N., F.A. Oenz and H.A. Slsson.   1950.  Beryllium bone  sarcomata In
rabbits.  Br. J.  Cancer.  4:  212-222.   (Cited  In U.S. EPA,  1980a. 1986b)
       ,   O.L.  and  U.S.  Lalnhart.   1972.   Mortality  patterns  1n  beryllium
production workers.   Presented  at the  Am.  Ind. Hygiene  Assoc.  Conf.   OSHA
Exhibit No. 66. Docket No.  H005.   (Cited 1n  U.S.  EPA,  1986a,b)
0113h                               -38-                             11/03/86

-------
Bayllss,  D.L.  and  J.K.  Wagoner.   1977.   Bronchogenlc  cancer and  cardlo-
resplratory  disease  mortality  among  white males  employed  In a  beryllium
production facility.   OSHA  Beryllium Hearing,  1977,  Exhibit  13.F.   (Cited In
U.S. EPA, 1986a,b)

Bayllss.  O.L.,  U.S.  Lalnhart, L.J.  Crally,  R. Llgo, H. Ayer  and  F.  Hunter.
1971.   Mortality patterns  In  a  group  of  former  beryllium   workers.   In.:.
Trans.  334rd Ann.  Meeting AGCIH,  Toronto, Canada,   p. 94-107.   (Cited  1n
U.S. EPA, 1986a,b)

Bencko,  V.,  E.V. VoslHevo and  K.  Symon.   1980.   Immunologlcal  aspects  of
exposure  to  emissions  from  burning  coal  of  high beryllium content.  Environ.
Res.  22: 439-449.  (Cited In U.S. EPA. 1986a)

Berg,  J.W.  and   F. Burbank.   1972.   Correlations between-carcinogenic  trace
metals  In water  supply  and  cancer  mortality.  Ann.  N.Y.  Acad.  Sc1.   199:
249-261.  (Cited 1n U.S.  EPA.  1980a, 1986b)

Chlapplno, 6.,  A.  Clrla  and E.C. V1g11on1.  1969.   Delayed-type hypersensl-
tlvlty  reactions  1n   beryllium   compounds:  An  experimental  study.    Arch.
Pathol.  87:  131-140.

Cloudman,  A.M.,  D.   Vlnlng,  S.   Barkulls   and  J.J.  Nlckson.   1949..   Bone
changes  following Intravenous  Injections of beryllium.  Am. J.  Pathol.   25:
810-811.  (Cited 1n U.S.  EPA,  1980a, 1986b)
0113h                               -39-                             03/05/87

-------
Constantlnldls,  K.   1978.   Acute and  chronic  beryllium disease.   Br.   J.
Clln. Pract.  32: 127-136.

Cotes, J.E., J.C. Gllson, C.B. NcKerron and P.O. Oldham.  1983.  A  long-term
follow-up  of  workers exposed  to beryllium.   Br.  J. Ind. Ned.   40:  13-21.
(Cited In U.S. EPA.  1986a)

Crowley,  J.F.,   J.G.  Hamilton and  K.J.  Scott.    1949.   The  metabolism   of
carrier-free radloberylHum In the rat.   J.  Blol. Chem.   177: 975-984.

Crump, K.  and R. Howe.   1984.   The multistage  model  with a  time-dependent
dose  pattern  applications to carcinogenic  risk  assessment.   Risk  Anal.   4:
163-176.  (Cited 1n  U.S.  EPA. 1986a)

Curtis. G.H.  1951.   Cutaneous hypersensltlvHy due  to beryllium: A  study  of
thirteen cases.  Am. Ned. Assoc.  Oermatol. Syphllol.  6:  470-482.   (Cited  In
U.S. EPA. 1986a)

Outra, F.R.  1948.  The pneumonltls and granulomatosls peculiar  to  beryllium
workers.  Am.  3. Path.   24:  1137.  (Cited  In Constantlnldls,  1978}

Dutra.  F.R.  and  E.J.  Largent.   1950.   Osteosarcoma  Induced  by   beryllium
oxide.  Am. J. Pathol.   26:  197-208.   (Cited In U.S.  EPA.  TiSOa,  1986a)

Elsenbud,  M.  and J.  Llsson.  1983.  Epldemlologlcal  aspects  of beryllium-
Induced  nonmallgnant  lung  disease:  JO-year  update.   J. Occup.  Ned.  25:
196-202.  (Cited In  U.S.  EPA, 1986a)


0113h                               -40-                             03/05/87

-------
Flshbeln,  L.   1981.   Sources, transport and alterations  of  metal  compounds:
An   overview.    1.   Arsenic,  beryllium,  cadmium,   chromium,   and   nickel.
Environ. Health Perspect.  40: 43-64.

Fodor, J.  1971.  Hlstogenesls of  bone  tumors  Induced by  beryllium.   Magyar.
Onkol.  15: 180-184.   (Cited 1n U.S. EPA, 1980a, 1986b)

Frelman, D.G.  and H.L.  Hardy.   1970.   Beryllium  disease.   The relation  of
pulmonary pathology to clinical course  and prognosis  based  on  a study of 130
cases from the  U.S.   Beryllium Case Reg. Hum.  Pathol.  1:  25-44.   (Cited  1n
U.S. EPA, 1986a)

Furchner,  J.E.,  C.R.  Richmond and  J.E. London.  1973.   Comparative  metabo-
lism of  radlonucHdes  In mammals:  VII.  Retention of  beryllium  1n  the mouse,
rat, monkey and dog.   Health Phys.   24:  292-300.

Gardner, L.V.  and  H.F.   Hesllngton.   1946.    Osteosarcoma  from  Intravenous
beryllium compounds In  rabbits.   Fed.  Proc.   5:  221  .   (Cited  In U.S.  EPA,
1980a, 1986b)

Groth, O.K.  and  C.R.  MacKay.  1971.   Chronic pulmonary  pathology   1n  rats
after Intratracheal Injection.  Toxlcol. Appl. Pharmacol.  19:  392.   (Cited
1n Drury et al., 1978; U.S.  EPA,  1980a)

Groth,  O.K.,  L.P.  Scheel  and  G.R.  MacKay.   1972.   Comparative pulmonary
effects  of Be and As  compounds  In rats.  Lab.  Invest.  26:  447-448    (Cited
1n U.S.  EPA.  1986b)

0113h                               -41-                            03/05/87

-------
Groth,  D.H.,  L.  Stehler and  G.  HacKay.   1976.    Interactions  of mercury,
cadmium,  selenium,  tellurium, arsenic  and  beryllium.    In:   Effects  and
Dose-response Relationships  of Toxic  Metals,  G.F.  Nordberg,  Ed.  Elsevler
Publishing Co., Amsterdam,   p. 527-543.   (Cited  In Orury et al., 1978; U.S.
EPA. 1966b)

Groth, D.H., C. Komm1hen1 and  G.R. MacKay.   1980.   CardnogenlcHy of  beryl-
lium hydroxide  and alloys.   Environ. Res.   21:  63-84.   (Cited  1n U.S. EPA,
1980a, 1986a,b)

Guyatt,  B.L.,  H.O.  Kay and  H.D.  Branlon.   1933.  Beryllium  rickets.   J.
Nutr.  6: 313-324.  (Cited In U.S.  EPA,  1986a)

Hall. T.C.. C.H. Wood,  3.D.  Stoeckle and  L.B. Tepper.  1959.   Case data from
the  Beryllium  Registry.  Am.  Ned.  Assoc. Arch. Ind.  Health.   19: 100-103.
(Cited 1n U.S.  EPA, 1986)

Hardy,  H.I.   1965.  Beryllium poisoning  -  Lessons In  control  of man-made
disease.  New Eng. J. Hed.   273: 1193.   (Cited  In Constantlnldls,  1978)

Hardy,  H.L.  and   I.R.  Tabershaw.   1946.   Delayed  chemical   pneumonltls
occurring In workers exposed to beryllium compounds.  J. Ind.  Hyg. Toxlcol.
28: 197-211.   (Cited In U.S.  EPA,  1986a)

Hart, B.A. and O.G. PUtman.   1980.  The  uptake of  beryllium by  the alveolar
macrophage.  J.  Retlculoendothel.  Soc.  27:  49-58.   (CUed  In  U.S. EPA,
1986a)


0113h                               -42-                            03/05/87

-------
Hart,  8.A., A.G.  Harms en,  R.B.  low  and R.  Emerson.   1984.   Biochemical,
cytologlcal  and  hlstologlcal alterations 1n rat  lung  following  acute beryl-
lium  aerosol exposure.  Toxlcol.  Appl.  Pharmacol.  75:  454-465.   (Cited  In
U.S. EPA. 1986a)

Hlgglns,  G.H.,  8.M.  Levy  and  B.L.  Yolllck.   1964.  A transplantable beryl-
lium-Induced chondrosarcoma  of rabbits.   J.  Bone  Joint  Surg.   46A:  789-796.
(Cited In U.S. EPA, 1980a. 1986b)

Hoagland, M.B.,  R.S.  Grler and M.B. Hood.   1950.   Beryllium and growth.   I.
Beryllium-Induced  osteogenlc  sarcoma.   Cancer  Res.  10:  629-635.   (Cited  In
U.S. EPA, 1980a, 1986b)

Howe, R.B.  and Crump,  K.S.   1982.   A computer  program to extrapolate quantal
animal  toxldty  data  to  low  doses.   Office of  Carcinogen Standards,  U.S.
Dept. of Labor under contract 4105C252C3.  OSHA, Washington, DC.

Hs1e, A.M.,  M.P. Johnson,  D.B.  Couch,  et al.  1979a.   Quantitative mammalian
cell  mutagenesls  and  a  preliminary  study  of  the mutagenlc  potential  of
metallic compounds.  Ir»: Trace  Metals  In Health  and Disease, N.  Kharsch,  Ed.
Raven Press, New York.  p. 55-69.  (Cited 1n  U.S. EPA.  1986a)

Hs1e. A.U..  J.P.  O'Neill. J.R.  San  SavastIan,  et  al..  1979b.   Quantitative
mammalian  cell   genetic  mutagenldty  of seventy  Individual  environmental
agents  related  to  energy  technology   and three  subfractlons   of  crude
synthetic oil  In  the  CHO/HGPRT system.   Environ. Scl.  Res.   15:  291-315.
(Cited In U.S.  EPA. 1986a)


0113h                               -43-                              03/05/87

-------
Hyslop, F.,  E.D.  Palmes,  W.C. Aford, A.R.  Monaco and L.T. Falrhall.  1943.
The  toxlclty of  beryllium.   Allied  Institutes  of  Health,  Washington,  DC.
NIH Bull No. 181.   (Cited  1n U.S.  EPA, 1986a)

IARC  (International Agency  for  Research  on Cancer).  1980.  IARC Monographs
on the  Evaluation  of  the Carcinogenic Risk  of  Chemicals to Man.  Beryllium
and beryllium compounds.   WHO, IARC,  Lyon,  France.   Vol.  45, p. 68328-68356.

Infante,  P.F.,  J.K.  Wagoner  and  N.I.  SpMnce.    1980.   Mortality  patterns
from lung cancer and non-neoplastlc respiratory disease among white  males  1n
the United States  Beryllium Case Registry.   Environ.  Res.   21: 35-43.

Ish1n1sh1, N., M.  Mlzunoe, T. Inamasu and A. Hlsanagel.  1980.   Experimental
study on cardnogenlcHy of beryllium oxide and arsenic  trloxlde to  the lung
of  the rats  by  Intratracheal   Instillation.   Fukuokd  Igaku Zasshl.   71:
19-26.  (Cited In  U.S. EPA.  1986a)

Ishlzawa,  M.  1979.   Mutagenldty  testing  of carcinogens  using  E_.  coll  WP2
strains carrying plasmld  PKM  101.   Mutagen. Toxlcol.  8:  29-36.  (Cited  In
U.S.  EPA.  1986a)

Jacobson,  S.A.  1933.   Bone lesions  In  rats produced by the substitution  of
beryllium for calcium  In  the diets.   Arch.  Pathol.   15: 18-26.

Janes, J.M.,  G.K.  H1gg1n  and  J.F.  HerMck.  1954.  Beryllium-Induced osteo-
genlc  sarcoma  In  rabbits.   J.  Bone  Joint  Surg.   36B:  543-552.   (Cited  In
U.S.  EPA,  19803, 1986b)


0113h                               -44-                              03/05/87

-------
Kada, T.,  K.  Hlrano  and  Y.  Shlrasu.   1980.   Screening of environmental  chem-
ical mutagens  by  the rec assay system with  Bacillus  subtnis.   In:  Chemical
Hutagens:  Principles  and Methods  for Their Detection, F.J. de  Serres and  A.
Hollaender.  Ed.   Plenum Press. New  York.   p.  149-173.   (Cited  1n U.S.  EPA,
1986}

Kanarek,  O.J., R.A.  Walner,  R.I.   Chamber!1n,  A.L.  Weber and H.   Kazeml,
1973.   Respiratory  Illness  In a  population  exposed to  beryllium.   Am.  Rev.
Resplr. DIs.  108: 1295-1302.

Kanematsu,  N., N.  Hara  and  T.  Kada.   1980.   Rec  assay and  mutagenlclty
studies on  metal  compounds.   Mutat.  Res.  77: 109-116.   (Cited  In U.S.  EPA,
1986a)

Kawada, M.   1963.   Experimental  studies on beryllium osteoma,  especially  on
the method  of  producing  the  tumor.   Jlnkejlkal Ned.  J.   10: 208-210.  (Cited
In U.S. EPA, 1980a, 1986b)

Kay, H.D.  and  O.L.  Skill.  1934.   Prevention and cure of  beryllium  rickets.
Blochem. J.  28: 1222-1229.   (Cited  1n U.S.  EPA.  1986a)

Kelley,  U.N..   J.E.   Goldflnger  and  H.L.  Hardy.   1969.   HyperuMcemla  In
chronic beryllium disease.   Ann.  Intern.  Ned.  ,70:  977-983.  (Cited  In  U.S.
EPA. 1986a)

Kelly,  P.J., J.A.  Janes and  L.F.A. Peterson.  1961.   The effect  of beryllium
on  bone.   J. Bone  Joint Surg.   43A:  839-844.   (Cited  In U.S. EPA, 1980a,
1986b)

0113h                               -45-                             03/05/87

-------
Kom1towsk1,  0.   1969.   Morphogenesis  of  beryllium-Induced  bone  tumors.
Patol. Pol.  1: 479.  (Cited In U.S.  EPA, 1980a,  1986b)

Kub1nsk1,  H.,  G.E.  Gutzke and Z.O. Kub1nsk1.  1981.  DMA-cell-binding  (OCB)
assay  for  suspected  carcinogens  and  mutagens.   Nutat.  Res.   89:  95-136.
(Cited In U.S. EPA.  1986a)

Larramendy,  M.L.,  N.C.   Popescu  and  J.A.  Dlpaolo.   1981.   Induction  by
Inorganic  metal  salts  of  sister  chromatld exchanges and  chromosome  aberra-
tions  In  human  and  Syrian  hamster  cell  strains.   Environ.  Nutagen.   3:
597-606.  (Cited In  U.S.  EPA, 1986a)

Nancuso, T.F.   1970.   Relation of duration  of  employment and  prior  Illness
to respiratory  cancer  among  beryllium workers.   Environ. Res.  3:  251-275.
(Cited In U.S. EPA,  1986a.b)

Nancuso,  T.F.   1979.   Occupational  lung cancer  among  beryllium workers  1n
dusts and  disease.   In:  Proc. Con1:. Occup.  Exp. to Fibrous  and Partlculate
Dust and  Their  Extension Into the Environment,  R.  Lemen and  J. Dement,  Ed.
Pathrotox Publishers,  Inc.  (Cited In U.S. EPA,  1986a,b)

Nancuso, T.F.  1980.  Mortality  study of  beryllium  Industry  workers'  occupa-
tional lung cancer.   Environ. Res.  2":  48-55.   (Cited  In U.S. EPA,  1986a,b)

Nancuso, T.F.  and A.A. El-Attar.  1969.   Epldemlologlc  study of the  beryl-
lium  Industry:  'Cohort methodology and  mortality studies.   J. Occup.  Ned.
11: 422-434.  (Cited In U.S. EPA, 1986a,b)

0113h                               -46-                             03/05/87

-------
Nazabraud, A.  1975.   Experimental  production  of  bone sarcomas  In the rabbit
by  a  single local  Injection  of  Be.  Bull. Cancer.  62: 49.   (Cited  In U.S.
EPA. 1980a, 1986b)

N1yak1, M., N. Akamatsu, T. Ono  and H.  Koyama.  1979.  Nutagenlclty of metal
cations In  cultured cells  from Chinese hamsters.  Hutat.  Res.   68:  259-263.
(Cited 1n U.S. EPA, 1986a)

Morgareldge, K.,  G.E.  Cox and O.E. Bailey.   1975.   Chronic  feeding  studies
with beryllium  sulfate In rats.   Food  and Drug  Research  Laboratories, Inc.
Final Report to  the Aluminum Company of America,  Pittsburgh,  PA.  (Cited In
U.S. EPA, 1980a, 1986b).

Morgareldge, K.,  G.E.  Cox,  O.E.  Bailey and N.A.  Gallo.   1977.   Chronic oral
toxldty of beryllium In the rat.  Toxlcol. Appl.  Pharmacol.  41: 204-205.

Nash, P.   1950.   Experimental production  of  malignant tumors  by beryllium.
Lancet.   1: 519.  (Cited 1n U.S.  EPA, 1980a,  1986b)

N1yog1,  S.K.,  R.P.  Feldman and  D.J. Hoffman.   1981.   Selective  effects  of
metal Ions  on  RNA  synthesis  rates.   Toxicology.   22: 9-21.   (Cited  In U.S.
EPA, 1986a)

NIOSH  (National  Institute   of  Occupational   Safety  and  Health).    1972.
Criteria  for  a  recommended   standard...occupational  exposure  to beryllium.
GPO, PHS  Pul.  No.  1000,  Ser. 10,  No.  30, Washington,  DC.  (Cited  1n U.S.
EPA. 1986a)


0113h                               -47-                             03/05/87

-------
Nlshlmura, H.   1966.   Clinical and  experimental  studies on acute  beryllium
disease.  Kagoya J. Ned.  Sc1.  18:  17-44.   (Cited  In U.S. EPA.  1986a)

OSHA  (Occupational Safety  and Health  Administration).  1985.   Safety  and
Health Standards.  Code of Federal  Regulations.  29: 1910.1000.

Parker, V.H. and  C.  Stevens.  1979.   Binding of beryllium  to  nuclear  acidic
proteins.  Chem. 81ol. Interact.   26: 167-177.   (Cited In U.S.  EPA,  1986a)

Paton,  G.R.  and   A.C.  Allison.    1972.    Chromosome damage  1n  human  cell
cultures Induced by metal salts.   Mutat.  Res.  16(3): 332-336.

Perry,  S.T.,  S.B.  Kulkarnl, K.L.  Lee  and  F.T.   Kenney.   1982.   Selective
effect  of  the  metallocarclnogen  beryllium  on  hormonal  regulation of  gene
expression  In  cultured  cells.   Cancer  Res.   42:   473-476.   (CHed 1n  U.S.
EPA, 1986a)

Preuss, 0.  and  H. Oster.   1980.   Zur GesundheltzgefShrdung durch  Beryllium
aus  Heutiger  S1cht  [The  current  view  of  beryllium as a health  hazard].
Arbeltsmed.  Sozlalmed.   Pr3vent1smed.   15:  270-275.   (Cited  1n  U.S.  EPA,
1986a)

Rees,  P.J.   1979.   Unusual  course  of beryllium lung disease.   Br. J.  01s.
Chest.  73: 192-194.   (Cited 1n U.S.  EPA,  1986a)

Reeves, A.L.  1965.   The absorption  of  beryllium  from  the gastrointestinal
tract.  Arch.  Environ. Health.  11:  209-214.


0113h                               -48-                              03/05/87

-------
 Reeves,  A.L.  and  0.  Oeltch.   1969.   Influence  of  age on  the  carcinogenic
 response  to  beryllium  Inhalation.    In.:   Proc.   16th   Inter.  Cong.  Occup.
 Health,  Tokyo,  Japan,  S.  Harlshlma,  Ed.   Japan  Industrial  Safety  Associa-
 tion, Tokyo. Japan,  p. 651-652.  (Cited In U.S. EPA, 1986a)

 Reeves, A.L. and  A.J.  Vorwald.   1967.   Beryllium carclnogenesls.   II. Pulmo-
 nary  deposition  and  clearance  of  Inhaled beryllium  sulfate  1n   the  rat_
 Cancer Res.  27: 446-451.  (Cited 1n U.S. EPA, 1986a)

 Reeves, A.L.,  D.  DeHch and A.J.  Vorwald.   1967.   Beryllium carclnogenesls.
 I.  Inhalation  exposure or  rats to beryllium  sulfate aerosol.   Cancer  Res.
 27: 439-445.

 Reeves, A.L., R.H.  Swanborg,  E.K.  Busby and N.D.  Krlvanek.   1971.   The role
 of  l.mmunologlc  reactions  In  pulmonary  berylHosls.   in:   Inhaled  Particles
 III, Vol. 2, W.H. Walton,  Ed.   Urwln  Brothers,  Ltd.,  Surry, UK.   p.  599-608.
 (Cited In U.S.  EPA, 1986a)

 Reeves, A.L., N.O.  Krlvanek,  E.K.  Busby and R.H.  Swanborg.   1972.   Immunity
 to pulmonary berylllosls In guinea pigs.   Int.  Arch.  Occup.  Environ. Health.
 29: 209-220.  (Cited 1n U.S. EPA. 1986a)

 Rosenkranz, H.S. and Z. Lelfer.  1980.   Detecting the DNA-mod1fy1ng  activity
 of chemicals using  ONA po1ymerase-def1c1ent Escherlchla coll.   In_:  Chemical
 Nutagens:  Principles and Methods for their  Detection, Vol.  6,  F.J.  de Serres
 Ann A. Hollaender, Ed.  Plenum  Press.  New  York.   p.  109-147.   (Cited In U.S.
 EPA. 1986a)


0113h                               -49-                             03/05/87

-------
Rosenkranz,  H.S.  and  L.A.  Po1r1er.   1979.   Evaluation  of the  mutagenldty
and  ONA-modifying  activity of  carcinogens and  noncarclnogens   1n  mlcroblal
systems.  J. Natl.  Cancer Inst.   62:  873-891.   (Cited In  U.S.  EPA,  1986a)

Schepers.  G.W.H.   1961.   Neoplasla  experimentally  Induced  by   beryllium
compounds.  Prog. Exp. Tumor Res.  2: 203-224.

Schepers,  G.W.H.   1964.   Biological action  of  beryllium:  Reaction  of  the
monkey to Inhaled aerosols.  Ind. Med.  Surg.   33:  1-16.

Schepers, G.U.H.  1971.  Lung tumors of primates and  rodents. II.   Ind. Ned.
40: 23-31.  (Cited  In U.S.  EPA,  1986a)

Schepers, G.W.H., T.M.  Ourkan,  A.B.  Oelahant  and  F.T.  Creedon.   1957.   The
biological  action   of  Inhaled   beryllium' sulfate:   A   preliminary  chronic
toxlclty study on rats.  Am. Med. Assqc.  Arch. Ind.  Health.   15:  32-38.

Schroeder,  H.A. and  M.   Kitchener.   1975a.   Life-term  studies   In  rats:
Erfects  of  aluminum,  barium,  beryllium   and  tungsten.    3.  Nutr.   105(4):
421-427.

Schroeder,  H.A.  and  H.  MHchener.   1975b.    Life-term  effects  of mercury,
muthyl  mercury,  and  nine   other  trace metals  on  mice.   J.  Nutr.   105(4):
452-458.

Simmon,  V.F.   1979a.  in  vitro  mutagenldty  assays of  chemical carcinogens
and  related  compounds with Salmonella tvphlmurlum.  J.  Natl.   Cancer  Inst.
62: 893-899.  (Cited In U.S. EPA, 1986a)

0113h                               -50-                             03/05/87

-------
Simmon,  V.F.   1979b.   In. vitro assays for  recomblnogenlc  activity  of  chemi-
cal  carcinogens  and related compounds with Saccharomyces  cerevlslae D3.   J.
Natl. Cancer Inst.  62: 901-909.  (Cited In U.S. EPA. 1986a)

Simmon,  F.V.,  H.S.  Rosenkranz,  E. Zelger and  L.A.  Po1r1er.  1979.   Nutagenlc
activity  of  chemical  carcinogens and  related compounds In  the  Intraperlto-
neal  host-mediated  assay.   J.  Natl.  Cancer  Inst.   62:  911-918.   (Cited  In
U.S. EPA, 1986a)

Slssons,  H.A.   1950.    Bone sarcomas produced  experimentally In the  rabbit
using  compounds  of beryllium.   Acta Un1o.  Int.  Contra.  Canerum.   7:  171.
(Cited In U.S. EPA. 1980a.  1986b)

Sneddon, I.B.  1955.  Beryl11os1s: A case report.  Br. Ned. J.  1:  1448-1450.
(Cited 1n U.S. EPA. 1986a)

Spencer, H.C.,  J.C.  Jones, J.S.  Sadek.  K.B.  Dodson and A.H.  Morgan.   1965.
lexicological  studies  on  beryllium  oxides.  Toxlcol.  Appl.  Pharmacol.   7:
498.  (CHed 1n U.S. EPA. 1986a).

Spencer, J.C., R.H. Hook,  J.A.  Blumenshlne. S.B. McColHster,  S.E.  Sadek  and
J.C. Jones.  1968.  Tox1colog1cal studies  on  beryllium oxides  and beryllium-
containing   exhaust   products.    AMRL-7R-68-148.   Aeromedlca.1  Res.   Lab.,
Wright-Patterson AFB.  Dayton.  OH.  94 p.   (Cited In U.S.  EPA. 1980a,  1986a,b)
0113h                               -51-                             03/05/87

-------
Spencer.  H.C.,  S.B.  NcColllster,   R.3.   Koclba,   C.G.   Humlston   and   6.L.
Sparschu.   1972.    lexicological  evaluation  of   beryllium  motor   exhaust
products.   AMRL-72-118.    Aeromedlcal    Aeromedlcal   Res.   Lab.,   Wright-
Patterson A.F.B., Dayton, OH.  94 p.   (Cited In U.S. EPA,  1980a,  1986a,b)

Sprlnce,  N.L.,  D.J.  Kanarek,  A.L.  Weber,  R.I.  Chamber 1 In  and  H.  Kazeml.
1978.   Reversible  respiratory  disease  In  beryllium workers.    Am.   Rev.
Resplr. D1s.  117: 1011-1017.  (Cited 1n U.S.  EPA,  1986a)

Sprlnce,  N.L.,  D.J.  Kanarek,  A.L.  Weber,  R.I.  Chamber 11n  and  H.  Kazeml.
1979.   Reversible  Interstitial   disease  In  beryllium  workers.   Am.   Rev.
Resplr. D1s.  119: 237.  (Cited In U.S.  EPA, 1986a)

Stoeckle,  J.D.,  H.L.  Hardy  and  A.L.  Weber.    1969.    Chronic   beryllium
disease:  Long-term  follow-up  of  sixty  cases  and  selective  review  of  the
literature.  Am. J.  Ned.  46: 454-561.   (Cited  In  U.S.  EPA, 1986a)

Stoklnger, H.E., G.F. Sprague III, R.H. Hall, N.J;.  Ashenburg, J.K.  Scott  and
L.T.  Steadman.    1950.   Acute  Inhalation  of  beryllium.   Arch.  Ind.   Hyg.
Occup. Ned.  1: 379-397.  (CUed In  U.S. EPA,  19865)

Tapp,  E.   1969.    Osteogenlc  sarcoma  1n  rabbits  following   subperlosteal
Implantation of  beryllium.   Arch. Pathol.  88: 09-',5.   (CUed  In U.S.  EPA,
1980a, 1986b)

Tepper, L.B.,  H.L.  Hardy  and P.I. Chamberlln.   1961.  Toxlclty of  Beryllium
Compounds.  Elsevler  Publishing  Co.,  New  York.   (Cited   In Constantlnldls,
1978)

0113h                               -52-                             03/05/87

-------
U.S.  EPA.  1980a.   Ambient Water  Quality  Criteria Document  for Beryllium.
Prepared  by the  Office of Health and Environmental Assessment, Environmental
Criteria  and   Assessment  Office,  Cincinnati,  OH  for  the  Office of  Water
Regulations   and  Standards,   Washington.   DC.    EPA   440/5-80-024.    NTIS
PB-81-117350.

U.S.  EPA.  1980b.   Guidelines  and  Methodology Used  1n  the  Preparation  of
Health  Effect  Assessment  Chapters  of  the  Consent  Decree  Water  Criteria
Documents.  Federal Register.  45(231): 49347-49357.

U.S.  EPA.  1982.   Errata   for  Ambient  Water  Quality  Criteria Documents.
Prepared  by the  Office of Health and Environmental Assessment, Environmental
Criteria  and   Assessment  Office,  Cincinnati,  OH  for  the  Office of  Water
Regulations and Standards, Washington, DC.

U.S.  EPA.   1984.   Methodology and Guidelines  for  Reportable Quantity Deter-
minations Based  on  Chronic  Toxldty Data.  Prepared by the Office of Health
and  Environmental  Assessment,  Environmental Criteria  and Assessment  Office,
Cincinnati,  OH  for  the   Office  of  Solid  Waste  and   Emergency  Response,
Washington, DC.

U.S.  EPA.   1986a.   Health  Assessment Document  for Beryllium.   Prepared  by
the  Office  of Health  and  Environmental  Assessment,  Environmental  Criteria
and  Assessment  Office, Research Triangle  Park. NC.   External  Review Draft.
EPA 600-8-84-0268.
0113h                               -53-                             07/20/87

-------
U.S. EPAo  1986b.  Drinking Water Criteria  Document  for  Beryllium.   Prepared
by the Office of  Health  and Environmental Assessment,  Environmental  Criteria
and  Assessment  Office,  Cincinnati,  OH  for  the  Office  of  Drinking  Water,
Washington, DC.

U.S.  EPA.   1986c.   Integrated Risk  Information  System (IRIS).   Reference
Dose  (RfO) for   Oral  Exposure  for   Beryllium.    Online  (verification  date
12/02/85).   Office of  Health  and  Environmental  Assessment,  Environmental
Criteria and Assessment Office, Cincinnati,  OH.

U.S.  EPA.   1986d.   Guidelines for 'Carcinogenic  Risk  Assessment.   Federal
Register.  51(185): 33992-34003.

Uzawa, T.  1963.   H1stopatholog1cal  studies on pulmonary reaction  to beryl-
lium  oxide 1n  rats.    Experimental  tumorous  action  of BeO  combined  with
carcinogenic hydrocarbons.  Bull.  Tokyo Ned.  Pent. Univ.  9:  440.   (Cited In
U.S. EPA. 1980a,  1986b)

Van  Ordstrand,  H.S.   1984.   Value of the  lymphocyte blast  transformation
test  for  beryllium  hypersensltlvHy  1n beryllium  workers:  A  twelve-year
experience.  Iri:  Occupational  Lung Disease,  J.B.L.  Gee,  W.K.C. Morgan  and
S.M. Brooks, Ed.   Raven Press, New York.   p. 220-221.  (Cited  1n U.S.  EPA,
1986a)

Van Ordstrand,  H.S., R.  Hughes  and  M.G. Carmody.  1943.  Chemical  pneumonia
In workers  extracting  beryllium  oxide.  Report  of  three cases.   Cleveland
Cl1n. Q.   10:  10-18.   (Cited In U.S. EPA,  1986a)


0113h                               -54-                             03/05/87

-------
i '  >  »
        Vorwald,  A.J.   1953.   Adenocardnoma  In  the  lung of  albino  rats  exposed to
        compounds  of beryllium,   in:  Cancer  of  the Lung  - An  Evaluation of  the
        Problem.   Proc.  of  the Scientific  Session,  Annual  Meeting,  November.   Am.
        Cancer Soc., New York.  p. 103-109.  (Cited In U.S. EPA, 1986a)

        Vorwald.  A.J.    1962.   Progress  report   (unpublished).   Grant No.  F-253-6.
        Am. Cancer Soc.  (Cited In U.S. EPA, 1986a)

        Vorwald,  A.J.  1968.   Biologic  manifestation  of  toxic Inhalation  In monkeys.
        In.: Use  of  Nonhuman Primates In Drug  Evaluation,  H.  Vagtborg, Ed.   Univ. of
        Texas Press, Austin, TX.  p. 2.  (CHed In U.S. EPA,  1986a)

        Vorwald,  A.J. and  A.L. Reeves.   1959.  Pathologic changes  Induced  by beryl-
        lium compounds.  Arch. Ind. Health.  19:  190-199.  (Cited In U.S.  EPA, 1986b)

        Vorwald,  A.J., P.C. Pratt and  E.J.  Urban.  1955.  The  production  of pulmo-
        nary cancer  In  albino rats  exposed  by Inhalants to an  aerosol  of  beryllium
        sulfate.  Acta. Un1o.  Int. Cancrum.  11:  735.   (Cited  In U.S. EPA,  1986a)

        Vorwald,  A.J.,  A.L.  Reeves  and E.J.  Urban.   1966.   Experimental  beryllium
        toxicology.  lt±: Beryllium -  Its  Industrial Hygiene  Aspects,  H.E.  Stoklnger,
        Ed.  Academic Press, New York.  p. 201-234.  (Cited 1n U.S. EPA, 1986a)

        Wagner, W.D., D.H.  Groth, J.L.  Holtz,  G.E. Madden and H.E. Stoklnger.  1969.
        Comparative  chronic  Inhalation  toxlclty  of  beryllium ores,  bertrandlte  and
        beryl,   with  production  of  pulmonary  tumors  by  beryl.   Toxlcol.  Appl.
        Pharmacol.  15:  10-29.
       0113h                               -55-                             03/05/87

-------
Wagoner,  J.K.,  P.P.  Infante  and  O.L.  Bayllss.   1980.   Beryllium: An  etlo-'
logic  agent  In  the  Induction  of  lung cancer,  nonneoplastlc  respiratory
disease  and  heart  disease  among  Industrially  exposed  workers.   Environ.
Res.  21: 15-34.

Weast,  R.C..  Ed.   1983.   Handbook  of  Chemistry  and  Physics,  64th ed.   CRC
Press Inc., Boca Raton,  FL.  p. B-74.

Williams,  W.J.  and  W.P.  Williams.   1983.   Value of  beryllium  lymphocyte
transformation  tests In  chronic beryllium disease and  In  potentially  exposed
workers.  Thorax.   38:  41-44.  (Cited 1n  U.S.  EPA, 1986a)

Williams, G.H., M.F. Laspla  and V.C, Dunkel.   1982.  Reliability  of  hepato-
cyte  primary  culture/DMA  repair  test  In  testing of  coded carcinogens  and
non-carcinogens.  Mutat. Res.  97:  359-370,   (Cited 1n  U.S.  EPA,  1986a)

Yamaguchl,  S.   and  H.  Katsura.   1963.   Study  of experimental  osteosarcoma
Induced  by  beryllium.   Trans.  Soc.  Pathol.  Jap.   52:  229.  (Cited  1n  U.S.
EPA, 1980e, !986b)

Zakour,  R.A.,   L.K.  TkeshelashvlH, C.W.  Shearman,  R.M.  Koplltz and  L.A.
Loeb.   1981.    Metal-Induced  Infidelity  of  DNA  synthesis.   J.  Cancer  Res.
Clln. Oncol.  99:  187-196.  (Cited In U.S.  EPA,  1986a)

Zorn, H.t  T.  Stlefel  and  H.  Diem.   1977.   Die Bedeutung des  Berylliums  und
seiner  Verblndungen  fur  den  Arbe1tsmed1z1ener—2.   Mlhellung [The  signifi-
cance  of  beryllium  and   Us  compounds  for  occupational  medicine  profes-
sionals].  Abl.  Arbeltsmed.  27: 83-88.   (Cited 1n U.S.  EPA, 1986a)

0113h                               -56-                              03/05/87

-------
                               a
                               w
                               a*
                               4>
       P  -rr r'
                               e
                               u
                               o»
                               i—  «»
                               2S
                               U  3
                               W  Vt
                               a. e
                               x  &
                               LU  X
                                         GO
                                         en
                     e
                     «o
                        • (/) A
                     t-  U  • vO
                     ai  a> 3 ao
                     •o  e   en
                     9t  9i ••«—
                     o j= •«
                     u.  u en  •
                     £ •** r- <
                     u — an o.
                     c/> X (— uj
     i
«  O —•
 r—»rf <•

 *. ^
   i  cn
 .. o a
 a» >- —
 e» x
 e cn en
                                                             19   i/i
                                         i
                                                             O X U
                                                             e « e*
        4»  0)
        •** _j
 I       rq >s
 C 0  C ^ sO
 l«  •  l« 1^ f—
** o •****>.
 e   «o e us
   Swi    01 •«—
   e    I
— O  • —  X
 U -~ «  l_
 «> H-  g a» -o
 o.<«< Q.
 x u  o» x  >t
 .
        e ** o»
       — a» ^
        w u. v,
       'O— W

       --•
       >» U. Ift
        o» o> cn

        g«t
       ui 3 O
                                         1
                                         IQ

                                         e
                                                                            1
                                                                            I/I
                                                                            0)
                                    w

                                    a*

                                   "o
                                    a

                                   
-------