United States
                   Environmental Protection
                   Agency
Office of Health and
Environmental Assessment
Washington DC 20460
                   Research and Development
EPA/600/S8-83/012 July 1990
&EPA           Project  Summary

                     Health Assessment
                     Document for Nickel
                     The  predominate  atmospheric
                   forms of nickel are as sulfate, oxides,
                   and  complex oxides. Nickel also
                   occurs in ambient and drinking water
                   and soils.
                     Routes of intake  for  man  are
                   inhalation,   ingestion,   and
                   percutaneous  absorption. Pulmonary
                   absorption varies  according  to
                   chemical and  physical form of the
                   compound. While gastrointestinal
                   intake ranges from 300  to  500  pg
                   daily, absorption is only one  to ten
                   percent of intake.  Percutaneous
                   absorption, usually through contact
                   with nickel alloys in the household, is
                   related  to  hypersensitivity and skin
                   disorders. Inhaled nickel compounds
                   lead  to highest levels  in lung, brain,
                   kidney and liver.
                      Nickel exposure  produces
                   chronic  dermatological,  respiratory,
                   endocrine and cardiovascular effects.
                   Reproductive and developmental
                   effects  have been found  in animals
                   but  not humans. Various  nickel
                   compounds have  been tested for
                   mutagenicity, demonstrating  the
                   ability  of nickel compounds  to
                   produce genotoxic  effects;  the
                   translation of these effects into
                   actual mutations  is still not clearly
                   understood. There is evidence both
                   in  humans and  animals  for  the
                   carcinogenicity of nickel in  some
                   forms.  Lifetime  cancer risks for
                   continuous inhalation  exposure at 1
                   i>g nickel/m3 have been estimated for
                   nickel  refinery  dust and  nickel
                   subsulfide-
                     There is a  growing evidence that
                   nickel may be an  essential element
                   for humans.
                     This  Project  Summary was
                   developed by EPA's Environmental
                   Criteria and Assessment Office, Re-
                   search Triangle Park, NC, to announce
key findings  of the research project
that is fully documented in a separate
report of the same title (see Project
Report ordering information at back).


Background

Chemical/Physical Properties of
Nickel and Nickel Compounds
  Nickel  is  found in  nature  as  a
component of  silicate,  sulfide.  or,
occasionally,  arsenide  ores. It is a
valuable mineral commodity because of
its resistance to  corrosion and  its
siderophilic nature  which facilitates the
formation of nickel-iron alloys. Stainless
steel is the most well-known alloy; others
include  permanent  magnet and  super
alloys, used  in radios, generators and
turbochargers, and  copper-nickel alloys,
used  when resistance to extreme  stress
and temperature is  required. Other uses
for nickel  and its  compounds include
electroplating  baths, batteries,  textile
dyes and mordants, and catalysts.
  As a member of the transition metal
series, nickel  is uniquely resistant to
alkalis, but generally dissolves in dilute
oxidizing acids. Nickel may exist in many
oxidation states, the most prevalent being
Ni2*. Of  some commercial and/or
environmental  significance are several
binary nickel compounds including nickel
oxide (both black,  which is chemically
reactive, and  green, which is inert and
refractory) and complex oxides of nickel,
nickel sulfate,  nickel  nitrate,  nickel
carbonate, nickel  hydroxide,  nickel
sulfide, and nickel carbonyl.

Nickel in Ambient Air
  In the atmosphere, nickel is present as
a constituent  of suspended  particulate
matter. The primary stationary source
categories that emit nickel into ambient
air are: primary production sources

-------
(nickel ore mining/smelting and nickel
matte  refining);  combustion  and
incineration sources (coal and oil burning
units in utility, industrial, commercial and
residential use  sectors,  and  municipal
and sewage sludge incinerators);  high
temperature  metallurgical  sources (steel
manufacturing,    nickel    alloy
manufacturing,  secondary  nickel
smelting, secondary nonferrous  metals
smelting, and iron and steel foundries);
chemical and catalyst sources  (nickel
chemical manufacturing, electroplating,
nickel-cadmium  battery manufacturing
and  catalyst  production,  use  and
reclamation); and  miscellaneous sources
(co-product  nickel  recovery,  cement
manufacturing,  coke  ovens,  asbestos
mining/milling and cooling towers).
   While nickel in  its elemental  state can
be  measured  in  the  ambient  air,
determination of specific compounds  is
difficult to achieve. Techniques used  to
break  down  inorganic  compounds into
their ionic or atomic states change the
form of the compound in the attempt  to
determine the total concentration of the
element. In addition,  the very low level  of
nickel  present in  ambient air  samples
(average  of  0.008 iig/m3;  1982 figures)
complicates  the situation.  Nevertheless,
by analyzing the  physical  and  chemical
properties of nickel,  the forms  of nickel
input  to various  source processes, and
the reaction conditions encountered  in
various source categories,  it is possible
to estimate forms of nickel emitted into
the ambient air.  From such analyses, the
predominant forms appear to  be nickel
sulfate, complex  oxides of nickel and
other  metals (chiefly iron), nickel oxide,
and to a  much  lesser extent,  metallic
nickel  and nickel subsulfide. Of the total
volume of nickel emitted into the ambient
air, the greatest contribution is from the
combustion of fossil  fuels in which nickel
appears  to  be  in the form  of nickel
sulfate, followed  by  lesser amounts  of
nickel oxide and  complex  metal oxides
containing nickel.

Nickel in Ambient and Drinking
Water
   Nickel is  usually found as  Ni2 +  in
aquatic systems. Chemical factors which
can affect the form  of nickel  in aquatic
systems include pH  and the presence  of
organic and  inorganic  ligands.  Nickel  is
found  in  ambient  waters as a result  of
chemical and physical degradation  of
rocks  and soils,  deposition   of
atmospheric  nickel-containing paniculate
matter,  and direct  (and  indirect)
discharges from industrial processes.  Of
the anthropogenic  sources  of  nickel in
water,  primary  nickel  production,
metallurgical  processes,  fossil  fuel
combustion  and  incineration,  and
chemical  and catalyst  production  are
predominant.
   Measurements of  nickel  in  aqueous
environments  are generally reported  as
total nickel. The mean concentration of
nickel in U.S. surface  waters (based upon
1982 figures) ranges from less than 5 vig/l
in the Great Basin of  southern Nevada to
greater than 600 ng/l in the Ohio River
Basin. Concentrations in groundwater are
also highly variable with means ranging
from 4430 ng/l in the  Ohio River basin to
2.95 jig/l in the Upper Mississippi River
basin (based upon 1982 figures). A mean
nickel concentration of 4.8 pg/l  has been
calculated for drinking water from eight
metropolitan areas  (based upon 1970
figures).
   Specific forms  of  nickel in  ambient
waters have not been reported;  however,
inferences of species expected to be
found in effluents can be made  based on
the nature of  source  processes and the
aqueous chemistry  of  nickel.  Nickel
species  in  wastewaters  from the major
anthropogenic  sources  are   likely  to
include dissolved salts (such as sulfates,
chlorides  and  phosphates),  insoluble
oxides of  nickel and other  metals,  and
metallic nickel powder.

Nickel in Soil and Sediment
   Many  of the same  chemical  and
physical  properties  which  govern  the
behavior  of  nickel  in  aqueous
environments  also affect the behavior of
nickel in soils and sediments.   In soils,
nickel may exist in several forms such as
inorganic crystalline  minerals  or
precipitates, as free ion or chelated metal
complexes  in  soil  solution,  and as
complexed with,  or  adsorbed  to,
inorganic cation exchange surfaces such
as clays.
   Naturally occurring nickel  in soils
depends upon the elemental composition
of  rocks in the upper crust  of the earth.
The natural  concentration  of  nickel in
soils usually ranges from 5  to 500 ppm,
with an  average level estimated at 50
ppm. Soils derived  from serpentine rock
(naturally  high in nickel  content)  may
contain  nickel  levels  up to 5000 ppm.
Anthropogenic  sources of nickel to soils
include emissions from primary smelters
and metal refineries,  disposal of sewage
sludge or application  of  sludge as  a
fertilizer, auto emissions,  and  emissions
from electric  power  utilities;  the most
significant of  these  sources being
smelting and  refining operations and
sludge applications. Depending upon tl
source,  nickel soil  concentrations  ha'
been  reported to range from 0.90 pp
(from  auto emissions) to as much
24,000 ppm  (near  metal  refineries)
53,000 ppm (from dried  sludge).  The
figures are based upon elemental nicl
as specific forms of nickel in soils hs
not been reported.

Nickel in Plants  and Food
   The  primary  route  for   nicl
accumulation in  plants is through n
uptake from  soil. Nickel is present
vegetation usually below the 1 ppm le'
although plants grown in serpentine s<
have  been  shown  to  have  me
concentrations as high as 100 ppm.
crops grown in  soils where  sew;
sludge  has  been  applied,  nic
concentrations have  been  reported
range from 0.3 to 1150 ppm.
.   In addition to  nickel uptake via  s<
food  processing methods have  b
shown to  add to nickel  levels  alre
present  in  foodstuffs  via leaching  f
nickel-containing  alloys  in  fo
processing  equipment, the  milling
flour,  and  the catalytic hydrogenatio
fats and oils by  use of nickel catah
The nickel  content of various classe
food has  been  reported  to  range I
0.02 ppm (wet weight) in food items :
as fresh tomatoes, frozen swordfish
pork chops to 9.80 ppm in cocoa.

The Global Cycling of Nickel
   Nickel  in   all  environme
compartments is  continuously transf<
between  compartments  by  na
chemical and physical processes su
weathering, erosion, runoff,  precipit;
stream/river flow and  leaching. N
introduced  into  the environmen
anthropogenic means is  subject tc
same  chemical  and physical  proce
but can account for  increased  anr
concentrations  in  all  environm
compartments.   The  ultimate  sin
nickel is the ocean;  however, the cy
continuous  because  some  nicke
leave  the  ocean  as sea  spray  aei
which burst and  release  minute r
containing particles into the atmospl

Nickel Metabolism

Absorption
   Routes  of nickel intake for ma
animals are inhalation,  ingestioi
percutaneous absorption.  Pare
exposure  of experimental  anim
mainly of  importance in  assessir
kinetics of nickel transport,  distri
and excretion.  Parenteral  expos

-------
humans  to  nickel  from  medications,
 emodialysis  and protheses  can be  a
significant problem to certain sections of
the population.
   The relative amount  of  inhaled nickel
which  is  absorbed   from  various
compartments of the pulmonary tract is a
function of both chemical and  physical
forms.  Insoluble  particulate  nickel
deposited in the various respiratory
compartments  in  both occupationally
exposed  subjects and  the general
population is  very slowly absorbed  with
accumulation over  time.  Experimental
animal data show very slow clearance of
deposited insoluble nickel oxide from the
respiratory tract, moderate  clearance
(around 3 days)  of the carbonate  and
rapid clearance (hours to several days) of
soluble nickel salts. In the case of nickel
oxide, clearance from lung involves both
direct absorption  into the  blood  stream
and clearance via the lymphatic system.
While most respiratory absorption studies
demonstrate  that differences  in
compound solubilities relate to  pulmonary
;learance, with  inert compounds having
'elatively slower  clearance,  the
'elationship of respiratory  absorption to
pathogenic effects is  still not  clearly
jnderstood.
   Gastrointestinal intake  of  nickel by
nan  is relatively high compared to other
oxic  elements  and can be partially
iccounted for by contributions of nickel
:rom   utensils  and   equipment  in
processing and home preparation of food.
Average  human  dietary values  range
rom  300 to 500 ng daily with  absorption
>n the order of one  to  ten percent.
Decent  studies  show  that  nickel
)ioavailability  in  human diets appears to
)e dependent on dietary composition.
   Percutaneous  absorption  of nickel
>ccurs and is related  to nickel-induced
lypersensitivity  and  skin  disorders;
lowever,  the extent  to which  nickel
inters  the bloodstream by way  of  the
 kin cannot be stated at the present time.
'ransplacental transfer of nickel has been
 videnced in  rats and  mice and  several
eports indicate  that such passage  can
 Iso occur in man.

 ransport and Distribution
   The kinetic processes governing  the
 ansport and distribution of nickel in
 arious organisms are  dependent upon
 te modes of absorption,  the rate  and
 vel  of nickel  exposure, the chemical
 >rm   of  nickel   and the physiological
tatus of the  organism. Absorbed nickel
  carried by the blood,  and although the
 xtent  of   partitioning   between
 rythrocytes and plasma or serum cannot
be precisely stated, serum levels can be
useful indicators of blood burden and, to
a more limited  extent,  exposure  status
(excluding exposure  to insoluble  and
unabsorbed nickel deposited in lungs). In
unexposed  individuals, serum  nickel
values are approximately 0.2 to 0.3 jig/dl.
Albumin is  the main  macromolecular
carrier of nickel  in  a number of species,
including man,  while in man and rabbit
there also  appear  to  be nickel-specific
proteins
   Tissue  distribution of absorbed nickel
appears to be dependent on the route of
intake. Inhaled  nickel  carbonyl  leads  to
highest levels in  lung, brain, kidney, liver,
and adrenals. Parenteral administration of
nickel salts  usually results in highest
levels  in  the kidney,  with significant
uptake shown by endocrine glands, liver,
and  lung. Nickel absorption and  tissue
distribution  following  oral  exposure
appear to be dependent upon the relative
amounts of the agent  employed. Animal
studies suggest  that  a  homeostatic
mechanism exists to regulate low levels
of nickel intake (around  5 ppm), but that
such  regulation  is  overwhelmed  in the
face of large levels of nickel  challenge
   Based  on  animal  studies,   nickel
appears to have  a very short half-time m
the  body of  several  days  with little
evidence for tissue accumulation. Human
studies  have shown that age-dependent
accumulation of  nickel  appears to occur
only in  the case of the lung with other
soft and mineralizing tissues showing no
accumulation.  There are very few data
concerning nickel tissue levels and total
body burden in humans. One estimate is
that  the total  nickel burden in man  is
about 10 mg.

Excretion
   The excretory routes for nickel in man
and  animals depend  in part on  the
chemical forms of nickel and the mode of
nickel intake. Unabsorbed dietary nickel
is lost in the feces. Urinary excretion  in
man and  animals  is usually the  major
clearance  route for absorbed nickel,  with
biliary  excretion   also occurring  in
experimental  animals.  Sweat  can also
constitute a  major  route  of   nickel
excretion.  Recent studies suggest  that
normal levels of  nickel in urine vary from
2 to 4 ug/l
   While hair deposition of nickel also
appears to be an excretory  mechanism,
the relative magnitude  of  this  route,
compared to urinary excretion, is not fully
known at present.
Factors Affecting Nickel
Metabolism
   A number of  disease  states or other
physiological  stresses  can  influence
nickel metabolism  in man.  In  particular,
heart and renal disease, burn trauma, and
heat exposure can either raise or  lower
serum nickel  levels. To  what extent
factors such as age or nutritional status
affect  nickel  metabolism  in man  is
presently  unknown.  In  animals,  both
antagonistic  and  synergistic relationships
have  been  demonstrated  for  both
nutritional factors and other toxicants.


Nickel Toxicology

Subcellular and Cellular Aspects
of Nickel Toxicity
   Nickel, as the  divalent ion, is known to
bind to a variety of biomolecular species,
such as  nucleic  acids  and  proteins, as
well as their constituent units.  Strongest
interactions  occur  with sulfhydral. aza-
and amino groups with binding  to peptide
(amido) and carboxylate  ligands also
possible.
   A number of  reports in  the literature
describe various  in vivo  and in vitro
effects of  various  nickel  compounds on
enzyme systems as well  as nucleic acid
and protein  biosynthesis. In particular,
effects are seen on drug- detoxifying
enzymes in various tissues, enzymes that
mediate carbohydrate  metabolism  and
enzymes that  mediate transmembrane
transport, such as ATPase.
   A number of ultrastructural alterations
are seen  in cellular organelles  from
experimental animals exposed  to various
nickel  compounds   Most of  these
changes  involve  the  nucleus and
mitochondria  and range  from  slight
changes in conformation  to  evidence  of
degeneration.
   The  behavior  of  cells  in culture
exposed to nickel  compounds  has been
reported from different laboratories.
Nickel ion, at varying levels, affects both
viability  and  phagocytic   activity   of
alveolar macrophages, which may explain
the role of nickel in retarding  resistance
to respiratory  tract infections  in animal
models.
   Nickel-induced  human  lymphocyte
transformation  has been studied  as a
sensitive in vitro  screening technique for
nickel hypersensitivity and this procedure
appears to be a reliable alternative  to
classical patch testing.
   Various studies  have been directed to
the response of  cells  in culture  to

-------
insoluble  nickel  dusts which  are
implicated in  human  and experimental
animal carcinogenesis.  In particular, rat
embryo myoblasts show drastic reduction
of mitotic  index  and viability when
exposed to nickel subsulfide.

Acute Effects of Nickel
Exposure
   In  terms of human health effects,
probably  the  most  acutely toxic  nickel
compound  is  nickel carbonyl,  Ni(CO)4
exposure to which has been through acci-
dental release  to  nickel-processing
workers. Acute nickel carbonyl poisoning
is clinically  manifested   by  both
immediate  and  delayed symptomology.
With the  onset of the delayed, insidious
symptomology  there  are constnctive
chest pain, dry coughing,  hyperpnea,
cyanosis, occasional  gastrointestinal
symptoms,  sweating, visual disturbances,
and  severe weakness. Most of these
symptoms  strongly resemble those  of
viral pneumonia.
   The lung is the target organ in nickel
carbonyl  poisoning in both  man  and
animals.  The  pathological pulmonary
lesions  observed in acute  human
exposure include pulmonary hemorrhage,
edema,  and  cellular derangement.
Patients surviving an acute episode  of
exposure may be  left  with  pulmonary
fibroses.

Chronic Effects of Nickel
Exposure

Dermatological  Effects
   Nickel dermatitis and  other  derma-
tological  effects of nickel  have  been
documented  in both nickel  worker
populations and populations at large.
Originally considered to be a problem in
occupational medicine,  the more recent
clinical and  epidemiological  reports
suggest that nonoccupational  exposures
to nickel-containing commodities  may
present  significant  problems to  the
general  populace.  Nonoccupational
exposure  to  nickel  includes  nickel-
containing jewelry,  coins,  tools,  cooking
utensils,  stainless   steel  kitchens,
prostheses, and clothing fasteners.
   Clinically, nickel dermatitis is usually
manifested   as   a   papular   or
papulovesicular  dermatitis  with  a
tendency toward lichenification, having
the characteristics  of atopic  rather than
eczematous dermatitis. The hand eczema
associated  with nickel allergy appears to
be of the pompholyx  type,  i..e.,  a
recurring itching eruption with deeply
seated fresh vesicles and little erythema
localized  on the palms, volar  aspects,
and sides of fingers.
  A role for oral  nickel in dermatitic
responses  by sensitive  subjects  has
recently been  described. Nickel-limited
diets  in  one clinical  trial  resulted  in
marked improvement of hand eczema in
half of the  subjects while in  a second
study,  nickel  added  to the  diets  of
patients  appeared to  aggravate  the
allergic response. Further study of  oral
nickel-nickel sensitivity relationships
should be conducted.
  Nickel-containing   implanted
prostheses   may provoke flare-ups  of
nickel  dermatitis  in  nickel-sensitive
individuals.  The  extent of this problem
appears to  depend on the relative ease
with which nickel can be solubilized from
the  surface of the  devices by  action  of
extracellular fluid.
  The underlying mechanisms of nickel
sensitivity  presumably include  diffusion
of nickel through the skin and subsequent
binding of nickel ion.
  Useful animal  experimental  models of
nickel sensitivity  are few and have been
conducted  only under  very specialized
conditions.

Respiratory Effects
  Noncarcmogenic  effects of nickel  in
the  human respiratory tract mainly derive
from studies of  nickel  workers in certain
production  or use  categories  who have
been exposed to various forms of nickel.
In the aggregate, assessment of available
human and animal  data  show  two areas
of possible concern for humans: (1) direct
respiratory effects such as asthma, nasal
septal perforations,  and chronic rhinitis
and sinusitis; and (2)  increased risk for
chronic  respiratory  tract  infections
secondary to the effect of nickel on  the
respiratory immune system.

Endocrine Effects
  A numberjaf effects of nickel on endo-
crine-mediated physiological processes
have  been   observed.  In carbohydrate
metabolism, nickel  induces a rapid
transitory hyperglycemia in rats, rabbits,
and domestic  fowl  after  parental
exposure  to nickel  (II) salts. These
changes may be associated with effects
on alpha and beta cells in the  pancreatic
islets of Langerhans. Nickel also appears
to  affect  the  hypothalamic  tract  in
animals, decreasing  the  release  of
prolactin. Decreased iodine uptake by the
thyroid has also been observed when
nickel chloride  is  inhaled or ingested.
Human  endocrine  responses to nickel
have been poorly studied,  although
hyperglycemia has  been reported  in
workmen accidentally exposed to  nick
carbonyl.

Cardiovascular Effects
   Experimental  and clinical  observ
tions suggest  that exogenous nickel
ion, and  possibly endogenous nickel
has a marked  vasoconstrictive action
coronary vessels. Recent  studies sh<
that such action  may  be operative
patients with ischemic myocardial mji
and in  burn  patients. Whether excessi
nickel  exposure  in occupational
nonoccupational  populations  coi
exacerbate ischemic heart  disease
enhance  the risk of myocardial infarct
in  subjects with coronary artery disec
is unknown but merits further study.

Reproductive and Developmen
Effects
   Exposure to nickel has been showr
cause   both  reproductive   a
developmental effects  in  expenmei
animals;  however, such effects have
been noted in man.
   Specific reproductive effects seer
male rats include degenerative  chan
in  the   testis,   epididymis  e
spermatozoa. Limited studies in fen
rats and  hamsters suggest an effect
embryo  viability  and  the implanta
process.  Such  effects have been note
animals exposed  to excess  amount;
nickel.  In  contrast,  it  has  bi
demonstrated that a deficiency of die
nickel  can  also  lead  to  reproduc
effects in the form of reduced litter s
and decreased viability of newborn.
   With respect to developmental toxi
nickel  exposure  of animals  prio
implantation has  been  associated
delayed  embryonic development
possibly  with  increased resorpti
Structural malformations have been n
in  avian species exposed to  nickel :
While  similar  malformations  have
been  seen in  mammals, the data
been  lacking in  sufficient  detail m<
determinations  about  signifiCt
difficult.  Teratogenic  effects  of  n
carbonyl  in  mammals  have  t
demonstrated in two rodent species.

Mutagenic Effects
   Various inorganic compounds of r
have been tested  for mutagenicity
other genotoxic effects in a variety c
systems. From these tests  it appear
nickel  may  induce gene mutatioi
bacteria  and cultured mammalian
however, the evidence  is fairly  we
addition, nickel  appears  to in
chromosomal  aberrations in  cul

-------
mammalian  cells and  sister chromatid
sxchange in  both cultured  mammalian
cells and human  lymphocytes. However,
the induction of chromosomal aberrations
in vivo  has not  been  observed.  More
definitive  studies  are  needed  to
determine whether or  not  nickel  is
clastogenic.  Nickel does appear  to have
the ability to induce morphological cell
transformations in vitro and  to  interact
with DNA  resulting in crosslinks  and
strand breaks.  In aggregate, studies have
demonstrated  the  ability  of  nickel
compounds to induce genotoxic  effects;
however, the translation of these effects
into actual  mutations  is still  not clearly
understood.

Carcinogenic  Effects
   There is evidence both in humans and
animals  for the carcinogenicity of nickel,
at least in  some  forms.  The  human
evidence of a cancer risk is strongest via
inhalation in the  sulfide  nickel matte
refining  industry.  This evidence includes
a consistency  of findings across many
different studies  in  several different
countries, specificity of tumor site  (lung
and nose), high relative risks, particularly
for  nasal cancer, and  a dose-response
relationship by length of exposure. There
are also animal  and in  vitro  studies on
iickel compounds which  support the
concern  that nickel, at least in some
 orms,  should  be  considered
;arcinogenic. The animal  studies  have
employed mainly injection as the  route of
exposure with  some  studies  using
nhalation as the  exposure  route. While
he majority  of the compounds tested in
he injection studies have caused tumors
it the injection site only, nickel  acetate,
when tested in strain A mice, and nickel
:arbonyl, at toxic  levels,   have  also
:aused  distal  site primary  tumors.  The
elevance of injection site, only tumors in
inimals  to  human carcinogenic  hazard
'ia  inhalation,  ingestion, or  cutaneous
•xposure is uncertain. Orally,  in animals,
hree low-dose drinking  water studies and
me  diet study  with soluble  nickel
 ompounds have not shown any increase
 i tumors. Thus, nickel at least in some
orms,   should  be  considered
 arcinogenic to humans via  inhalation,
 'hile  the evidence  via  ingestion is
 (adequate.
   Based on analysis of all  the available
 ata there are  only  three compounds or
 lixtures of nickel compounds that can
 urrently be classified as either Group A
known   human  carcinogens)  or B
  irobable human carcinogens), according
  the Environmental Protection Agency's
 lassification  scheme  for  evaluating
carcinogens .  Nickel  refinery  dust  from
pyrometallurgical  sulfide  nickel matte
refineries  is classified as Group A. The
fact that  nickel subsulfide is a major
nickel  component  of  this  refinery  dust,
along with the evidence from animal and
in vitro studies, is sufficient to conclude
that nickel subsulfide  is also in Group A.
While there  is inadequate evidence  from
epidemiologic  studies with  regard  to
evaluating the  carcinogenicity  of nickel
carbonyl,  there is sufficient  evidence
from animal studies  to  classify   it  as
Group B2. The carcinogenic potential of
other  nickel compounds remains  an
important  area  for  further investigation.
Some  biochemical  and  in  vitro
toxicological studies seem to indicate the
nickel  ion as  a potential  carcinogenic
form of nickel and nickel compounds. If
this is true,  all  nickel  compounds might
be  potentially carcinogenic with potency
differences related  to their ability to enter
and make the carcinogenic form of nickel
available to  a susceptible cell.  However,
at  the present  time,   neither  the
bioavailability   nor  the carcmogenesis
mechanism  of nickel  compounds is well
understood.
   Quantitatively, several data  sets  from
nickel refinery workers provide sufficient
exposure-response information  both for
testing  model  fits and for  estimating
incremental  unit cancer risk.  While the
data partially support the use of both the
additive and multiplicative excess  risk
models, neither is entirely satisfactory.
Using both models and four data sets, a
range of incremental unit risks from  1.1 x
10-5 (jig/m3)-i to 46 x 1(M (ng/m3)-i has
been calculated. Taking the midpoint of
this range,  the  quantitative incremental
unit risk estimate for nickel refinery  dust
is 2.4  x 1Q-4 (ng/m3)-i;  the quantitative
unit risk estimate  for  nickel  subsulfide,
the most  carcinogenic nickel compound
in animals is twice  that for nickel refinery
dust. Comparing the  potency  of nickel
subsulfide to 55 other compounds which
the Environmental Protection Agency has
evaluated  as suspect  or  known human
carcinogens, nickel subsulfide would  rank
between the  second and third quartiles.


Other Toxic Effects
   Except  for acute fatal exposures  to
nickel carbonyl,  nickel  compounds
appear to possess low general neurotoxic
potential.  Lesions observed  in neural
tissue by  nickel carbonyl include diffuse
punctate  hemorrhages,  neural fiber
degeneration, and marked edema.
   Nickel  subsulfide, when administered
intrarenally  to  rats,  provokes  a
pronounced, dose-dependent  erythro-
cytosis associated with erythroid hyper-
plasia in bone marrow.
   The  effects of nickel  chloride on the
cellular and humoral immune responses
of mice have been studied.  Of  particular
note is the ability of  nickel chloride to
suppress the activity  of natural killer cells
within 24 hours of a  single intramuscular
injection. Such cells are thought  to  be
one of the  first lines  of  nonspecific
defense against certain types of infection
and tumors.


Nickel as an Essential Element
   There is a growing  body of  literature
which  establishes an  essential  role for
nickel, at least in experimental animals.
   One  key  criterion   for   element
essentiality-existence  of  specific nickel-
deficiency   syndromes—is  reasonably
satisfied for  nickel. Various researchers
have shown different systemic lesions in
various animals deprived of dietary
nickel. Nickel deprivation  has an effect on
body weight, reproductive capability, and
viability  of offspring  and  induces  an
anemia through  reduced absorption  of
iron. Both  antagonistic and synergistic
interactions of  nickel   with   various
compounds have been  noted  to  affect
nutritional requirements.
   Nickel also appears to be required in
several proteins and enzymes. Jack bean
urease  (and  possibly  rumen  microbial
urease) has been shown to be  such  an
enzyme. Recent  studies on the  activation
of the calmodulin-dependent phospho-
protein  phosphatase,  calcineurin,
suggests that nickel II may play  a physio-
logical role in the structural  stability and
full activation of this particular enzyme.
   Further information in support of nickel
as an essential element  is the  apparent
existence of  a homeostatic mechanism
for regulating nickel metabolism and the
existence of  nickel proteins in  man and
rabbit. Although the evidence for the role
of nickel in  human  physiology is  not
conclusively  established,  the transitory
rise in circulatory nickel observed shortly
after parturition  has been  linked to a
possible role  in control  of atonic bleeding
and placenta! separation.


Populations at Risk
   Among various subgroups of the U.S.
population who may be at special risk for
adverse effects of nickel  are those who
have nickel hypersensitivity and suffer
chronic  flare-ups  of skin disorders with
frank  exposure.  Within  this category
would  be  individuals  predisposed  to

-------
sensitization to nickel by virtue of familial       The extent to which nickel in inhaled    exposing the conceptus to nickel. Ther
history. In terms of  the  extent of nickel    cigarette smoke  is  a cofactor in  the    is no  information at present that nicki
exposure  among hypersensitive  individ-    demonstrated  association of smoking    exposure in  utero  under conditions  <
uals, women who are housewives seem    with various respiratory disorders is not    nickel exposure encountered by pregnai
to be at particular risk. However, no data    defined at present, since  various studies    women  in the  U.S.  population leads  '
base exists by  which to determine  the    have presented conflicting information.       adverse effects.
prevalence of nickel hypersensitivity  in       Nickel crosses  the placental barrier in
the general U.S.  population.                 animals and  apparently  in  man,  thus

-------