United States
                   Environmental Protection
                   Agency	
Robert S. Kerr Environmental
Research Laboratory
Ada OK 74820
                   Research and Development
 EPA/600/S2-88/036 Aug. 1988
&EPA         Project  Summary
                    Factors Affecting Trace Metal
                    Mobility in  Subsurface  Soils
                   J. Kotuby-Amacher and R. P. Gambrell
                    Laboratory and field investigations
                  were  conducted  to  study  factors
                  affecting the mobility of  metals in
                  soils.The project  focused  on
                  subsoils  associated with  waste
                  disposal sites and examined a wide
                  range of conditions  that  might be
                  present influencing  movement of
                  metals.
                    Field and  laboratory  work
                  demonstrated  acidic  wastes
                  associated with a battery recycling
                  operation has combined with the
                  relatively  poor  metal  retention
                  properties of the soils in the area to
                  transport excess lead to the shallow
                  groundwater zone in  a southeastern
                  Louisiana location. Conversely,  field
                  and laboratory data indicate  a soil
                  with a higher clay content and a near
                  neutral to slightly alkaline pH can
                  effectively immobilize high levels of
                  metals such  as  now-closed
                  disposal pits used for metals plating
                  and other waste at an Oklahoma Air
                  Force base.
                    The  study  showed Important
                  interactions between soil types,
                  metals, metal concentrations, and
                  the presence of  additional  non-
                  metallic  waste  materials  (co-
                  wastes) on the movement of metals
                  in subsoils. Disregarding  any of
                  these factors  when evaluating the
                  potential for metals  leaching at a
                  contaminated  site could result in
                  large errors  in predicting  metal
                  mobility  and the potential for
                  groundwater contamination.
                    The most significant  new
                  information from this project pertains
                  to the effects of co-wastes, when
                  present, on facilitating the movement
                  of trace and toxic metals in subsoils.
                  The findings of this project lead to
the  recommendation  that  more
research should be done to: (1)
identify the important characteristics
of various types of  co-wastes that
facilitate metal  mobility, and (2)
quantify these effects to aid  in
development of models predicting
metal mobility in  subsoils. The
particular  metals  present, the
amounts of metals present, and soil
properties must also be considered
as all of these parameters interact in
affecting metal mobility in subsoils.
  This Project Summary was  devel-
oped by EPA's  Robert  S.  Kerr
Environmental Research Laboratory,
Ada, OK, to  announce key findings of
the research pro/ect that Is fully
documented in a separate  report of
the same title (see  Project Report
ordering information at back).

Introduction

Background
  The transport of metals to groundwater
below hazardous waste  sites  is  of
considerable environmental concern. The
movement of a particular  metal  is
determined by the amount and form of
the metal,  the soil's chemical and
physical properties, and the composition
of the soil or waste solution with which
the metal is  associated.  The soil
properties    affecting    metal
retention/release  and transport include
bulk density, surface area, particle-size
distribution,  pH,  redox  status, ion
exchange capacity, amount of organic
matter, type  and amount of metaloxides
present, and type and amount of clay
minerals (Fuller and Warrick, 1985). Soils
with a wide  range of  these  properties
were selected for this study except that
all of the subsoil materials had typically

-------
low levels of organic matter. Soil organic
matter,  at  levels commonly found  in
surface  soils  and sediments, is one  of
the primary immobilizing processes for
trace and toxic metals (Gerritse and van
Driel, 1984;  Levi-Minzi  et  al. 1976).
Subsoils, usually beginning 15 to 30 cm
beneath the surface, generally contain  so
little naturally-occurring  organic matter
that  it  becomes important to focus on
other metal retention  processes  in the
region  between  surface  soils  and
groundwater.
  The  greater the  concentration of a
specific pollutant in the  soil, the  more
likely it is to move through the soil. When
the concentration of a metal exceeds the
capacity of the soil to retain it, migration
may take place  as if the soil were  an
inert, porous medium (Fuller, 1980).
  Solution  composition will also greatly
affect metal  retention  and  movement.
Doner (1978)  reported that the mobility of
Ni, Cu, and Cd through soil columns was
1.1 to  4 times greater  in CI"  solutions
than in  CICV solutions, with  the greater
effect  seen  for Cd.  Perchlorate  was
reported to not complex metals.  In most
of the  cases studied  by Benjamin and
Leckie (1982), addition of Cf or SO42'
reduced Cd  retention  indicating  that
chloro- and  sulfato-  complexes are
retained less strongly by the soil than are
uncomplexed Cd ions. Garcia-Miragaya
and Page (1976) found that Cd retention
decreased in the order (same  ionic
strength): CI4"  >  SCU2" >CI~.  Brown
(1979)  stated  that  the formation  of
complexes of Pb  with  various anions
such as CI", F,  CO32', HC03',  and
OH" increased the concentration of Pb
in natural waters by preventing Pb  from
taking  part in other chemical reactions,
primarily adsorption,  which would lower
the solution concentration.
   Knox and Jones (1979) reported that
all of three  sanitary landfill leachates they
tested were able to complex  Cd to some
extent,  although their ability to  do  so
varied,  and in  some  cases  might well
have been insufficient to greatly  affect
metal retention. The reaction between Cd
and leachate appeared to  be  mono-
nuclear and predominately the result of a
1:1  complex formation.  Although  fatty
acids were the most important com-
plex-forming fraction  in one  leachate
studied, other organic compounds,  such
as fulvic acid, were important in the other
two leachates. Thus, the degree of metal
immobilization or transport depends
upon interaction between soil properties,
amount of metals  present,  and  the
properties  of the  leachate  phase with
which the metals are associated.
  An aerobic environment  increases the
solubility and mobility of metals  (Fuller,
1980; Bates, 1980),  or decreases  the
solubility  of metals (Page  and  Pratt,
1975),  depending  on  the absence  or
presence  of sulfides and  other  redox-
active  components  in  the system
(Gambrell, et  al.  1980; Khalid  et  al.,
1981).   The    adsorption   and
coprecipitation of trace and  toxicmetals
with colloidal hydrous oxides  is  an
important  process  in decreasing  metal
availability in some soils. The oxides and
hydroxides are favored  by an increase in
pH  and/or redox potential. When hydrous
Fe and Mn oxides are reduced, the trace
and toxic metals which are coprecipitated
with or  retained  by the oxides may  be
released (Thibodeaux,  I979).  The
formation of insoluble metal sulfide
precipitates  limits  the  bioavailability  of
most  metals in some  strongly reduced
soils and  sediments.  In general, where
sulfides  are not present, as in most
subsoils, a moderately low  pH and redox
potential  environment  favors the
relatively  bioavailable soluble  and
exchangeable chemical forms of  metals
while higher pH and  oxidation  levels
favor  sparingly  soluble,  oxidized
compounds. Cadmium, however, has
been  found  to show  the opposite redox
effects  in sediments (Gambrell, et  al.
I976). In  surface soils  and  sediments,
oxidizing,  weakly acid conditions  greatly
increases levels  of soluble and  weakly
acid conditions greatly increases levels
of soluble and exchangeable Cd.
  There  are a  number of reviews and
reports  on factors  affecting the mobility
and plant availability of trace and toxic
metals.  Much of this work has focused
on  topsoils  or sediments  containing  an
appreciable  amount of naturally occurring
organic  matter  compared to  subsoils.
Soil humic material is known to be very
effective in  immobilizing most trace and
toxic metals.  Since subsoils contain
much less  organic matter and are the
primary  transport  media  if metals
contamination of groundwater is to occur,
research  efforts  should  be  directed
toward  processes  regulating  metal
mobility in subsoils.
  The objectives of this project were as
follows:

  (1) To identify soil physical and
chemical properties  regulating  the
mobility  of  metals in  subsurface  soil
materials. This  research focused  on
subsoils between  the contaminated  soil
at  or  near  the  surface  and  the
groundwater. Much has been  published
on  the mobility and biological availability
of metals in surface soils and sedimenl
Factors  affecting the mobility of meta
from waste disposal sites in subsoils hi
received comparatively little attention.

  (2)  To  show  for a  number  of kt
metals  the  important  interaction
between metal  concentrations,  wasi
mixtures, and soil  properties in reg(
lating the mobility of metals.  It is w<
documented that  all   metals do m
respond  identically  to  mobilizatioi
immobilization  processes  in  soil.
addition to  soil  properties  and th
particular metals present,  there are tv\
other important factors that may influent
the  mobility of metals in subsoils: (1) th
concentrations of metals present, and (i
the  presence of other  types of waste
that may influence the mobility of metal
These  two  factors  have  particule
relevance to  waste sites  presenting
threat  to  groundwater  and   wer
considered in planning  this study. Th
interaction between the  four  factor
mentioned above were studied in th
context of hazardous waste disposal site
which represent the greatest potentii
threat to groundwater contamination  b
metals.

  In a hazardous waste  dump or landfil
a variety of types of  waste  may  b
present  that become mixed  with metal
at or beneath the site. Mixtures of metal
and other  wastes may interact  t
influence the  mobilization of  metals. Th
presence of toxic  metals  with  acidi
wastes,  for  example, would  greatl
enhance the  leaching of metals beneat
the initial  disposal zone  towar
groundwater.  This  is  a  set  o
circumstances that  has  not   bee
thoroughly addressed in the  toxic metal
studies  associated   with  sludge
amended  soils  or dredged materials a
very acidic  conditions   are  very rarel
encountered  in these  situations.  Alsc
certain organic   wastes  in  higl
concentration may affect the mobility c
metals.  It is likely  there  are  man'
locations where waste  mixtures an
present that may  enhance or  havi
already  enhanced the leaching of metal
to groundwater. The concept of facilitate!
transport of metals in waste mixtures ha;
not yet  received the research attention i
deserves. This  project  was  designed t<
begin to examine this topic.
  The  greatest  potential  threat  fo
groundwater contamination  by  toxn
metals  comes  from the  many illegal
poorly planned,  and/or  poorly managei
hazardous  waste disposal sites  in  thi
country. Many of these  were establishet

-------
and used prior to the knowledge we now
have on groundwater contamination and
the better regulatory restrictions of recent
years. It is  not unreasonable to expect a
combination  of coarse-textured sub-
surface soils,  high  concentrations  of
metals,  and the presence of co-wastes
that  tend  to  mobilize  metals at  a
substantial number of these sites.

Procedure
  Field  and  laboratory  studies were
conducted  to examine factors affecting
the mobility of metals in  subsoils. The
experimental  approaches  for these
studies are summarized below.

Field Studies
  The objectives of the field studies were
to determine  the distribution of forms of
trace and toxic metal contaminants in the
subsoil at sites  with known or suspected
potential for groundwater contamination.
Soil  cores were  taken  to a  depth
generally between 2 and 3 meters at the
sites with a  hydraulically-driven 4.75-
cm stainless steel coring tube. The plan
was to obtain duplicate cores within the
disposal zone and two additional pairs of
cores over  increasing distances from the
disposal ozone where  possible.  The
cores were sectioned with depth in the
field, stored in  plastic bottles, and then
returned to the lab for analysis.
  The field studies were  planned to be
coordinated with laboratory studies  in
terms  of  the  soil  materials  and  the
contaminants  present.  Assistance  in
locating and accessing  contaminated
field sites was obtained from the USEPA,
U.S. Air Force, the  Louisiana Department
of Environmental Quality (DEQ), and the
Louisiana Department of  Transportation
and  Development  (DOTD). We were
seeking five  sites with  known metal
contamination problems.
  Though  considerable  effort  was
expended  in  identifying  the  sites,
securing authorization for access to the
sites, sampling, and analyzing samples,
this effort  was  only partially successful
because clear indication of high  metals
contamination was  not apparent in core
samples from several of the locations.
Two  of the  most  promising  sites  in
Louisiana were unavailable at the last
minute, and  alternative  sites  were
selected.

Laboratory Studies
  Three  laboratory  studies  were
conducted to examine factors affecting
metals  movement  in subsoils.  These
included batch and column transport
studies. The first batch study focused on
retention of a number of metals (Cd, Ni,
Pb, and Zn) in many soil types with and
without the presence of a  simulated co-
waste. The  term  co-waste refers  to  a
non-metallic waste material that may be
present  at  a  disposal site,  possibly
facilitating  the  mobility of  metals.
Calculations of adsorption coefficients
and  regression analyses were  used  to
examine the  effects of  specific soil
properties  and  the presence of  a
leechate on metal retention. Because of
the importance of soil redox potential on
the environmental chemistry of metals,  a
second  batch  study  was done  with Cd
and  Pb and various  co-wastes in fewer
soil materials,  but under different purge
gases simulating aerobic and  anoxic
conditions in the  subsoil materials. The
column transport study included two soil
materials receiving two levels each of Pb
and  Cd  associated with four leaching
solutions.

Results and Discussion

Field Studies
  Of the field  sites studied, a lead-acid
battery reprocessing location yielded the
most information in  terms of  metals
contamination  which  has  apparently
moved to shallow groundwater. A waste
disposal pit  for metals and  other
materials at another Air Force base may
have also  contributed   to  shallow
groundwater contamination by metals.
The  data collected at an arsenic dipping
vat, a metal waste disposal pit at another
Air  Force  base  in  OK,  and  an oil
reprocessing site in  Louisiana  did  not
indicate significant metals  transport was
occurring in the subsoils associated with
these sites.
  A  brief summary of the results  from
the field study sites is given below.


Kolin Arsenic Dipping Vat
   It is acknowledged that As (arsenic) is
not a metal.  But, for simplicity  in this
report where the focus of  the project is
mentioned,  the terms trace metals and
toxic  metals are  used and intended  to
include As.
  This was the site of a concrete-lined
dipping  vat  used to treat  livestock to
remove parasites. A shallow groundwater
sample  taken  from very  near the pit
contained about  0.3 mg/l As or,  for
comparison purposes, this  was about six
times USEPA  drinking water quality
criteria. Levels exceeding 500 jig/g total
As in the soil were found to a depth of
about 0.5 meters  in cores taken from
very near the  vat. Five of six samples
above the 0.5 meter depth contained 180
ng/g As or higher. However, beneath 1.5
meters,  levels  dropped   to   near
background. The high total  levels near
the surface supported elevated levels of
water and acid-extractable  As. These
forms dropped to near background levels
beneath about 1.5 meters.
  Maximum As levels  in the shallow
subsoil vs. deeper subsoil suggested that
most of the As associated with the pit
may be retained strongly  by  the soil at
this  site  such that  leaching  beneath at
least a couple of meters may  have been
negligible. However,  it should  be
acknowledged that the history of use of
this  cattle-dipping vat is not known and
the first sampling occurred about  three
decades  after its use was discontinued.
The  possibility of transformations
between  different  species of As with
different mobilities and the presence of a
crack in  the concrete liner  of the  pit
complicated evaluating the data obtained
at this site. Therefore, it is possible that
considerable  As   may  have  been
transported from the  site during the
intervening years for which there is no
current evidence.

Combustion, Inc.
  Combustion Inc. is a site where waste
oil  was  stored   in  pits   for   later
reprocessing. The now-closed facility is
a  Superfund site.  Cores taken  to  2
meters depth at the edge  of an oil  pond
particularly recommended  to us by DEQ
personnel,  as  well  as additional  cores
taken in  the  area, did  not indicate
elevated metal concentrations  over levels
typically found  in uncontaminated  soils.
At this time, we do not know if additional
exhaustive  sampling   would  have
indicated very  localized areas of metal
contamination at the site, or whether DEQ
was basing their  belief of metals
contamination at this site  on  unreliable
information.

Tinker Air Force Base, Waste
Pit #2 and Waste Pit #1
  According to  Air Force personnel and
maps provided us, our Waste Pit #2, "A"
core samples were  collected  within the
old waste  disposal pit (now covered and
not  discernible from the surrounding
landscape).  Neither  these samples nor
two  additional  pairs of  core samples
taken downslope from the disposal pits
showed concentrations  of any  metals
measured above typical  soil background
levels.
  At this  site,  reliable  information is
available  that high  levels  of  metals are

-------
associated with the site. This information
comes from personnel familiar with the
operations of  the  site years  ago and
much more  recent metal survey  work
done  at  the  site.  Though  a geologist
working with us believed we were in the
pit based on examining the core material
collected, we can only surmise now that
our cores missed the actual disposal pit,
possibly  penetrating  an adjacent  zone
disturbed for  some other  purpose.
Nevertheless, the  lack of metals  from
deep  cores obviously very  close to the
actual pit and additional downslope cores
indicates the  subsurface soil at this site
does  very  effectively immobilize  high
concentrations of metals.  The laboratory
work  with  control soil  from  the site
confirms  this  conclusion.  Similarity, high
concentrations of metals were not found
at another waste  disposal site sampled at
Tinker Air Force Base.

Robins Air  Force Base
  As  for Tinker  Air  Force  Base, maps
and information  from personnel familiar
with the former waste disposal operations
at this base were made available to us.
Though covered  with soil when disposal
operations ceased, visual  confirmation of
the disposal pits was possible at this site.
  Beneath the cap or cover soil placed
on  the pits, the  core  samples  were
saturated with a black, oily liquid from
organic wastes also dumped at the site.
This  necessitated special  precautions
working  with this  possible hazardous,
volatile organic waste, and complicated
sample processing using  conventional
methods of characterizing  the  form  of
metals present in soil materials. Thus, a
complete chemical characterization  of
the site was  not completed in time for
this report.
  Many samples from several cores at
this site  were highly  contaminated with
Cd, Cr, Cu,  Ni, Pb, and Zn. In addition,
cores from an adjacent area between the
disposal pits and the surrounding swamp
were  also saturated  with the same oily
liquid  as the pit samples,  and also
contained some  of the highest levels of
metals. Clearly, this is a site with a high
potential for  metals  movement through
subsoils, possibly facilitated by high
levels of  organic  waste present.  If
information  that our Core E samples
were  taken away from the disposal area
is  correct,  then the  data  indicate
substantial  movement of  several metals
has occurred in the shallow  groundwater.

Pontchatoula Battery
   The study  site at Pontchatoula Battery
was the  former  location of  a pile of old
automobile and marine batteries awaiting
reprocessing to reclaim the Pb. The pile
was  reported  to be 100  meters X  30
meters X 10 meters  high at one  time.
The  battery  cases  were not  stacked
upright and apparently cracked in many
cases such that substantial quantities of
concentrated sulfuric acid  containing  Pb
spilled from  the  pile  onto  the  soil.
Surface soil samples contained several
thousand ng/g  Pb  and another zone of
excess Pb concentrations  was  found at
the surface  of  the shallow groundwater
just over a  meter  beneath the surface.
Elevated  Pb in the  shallow groundwater
zone at a depth of over 2 meters in what
was  believed  to  be a  control  area
(several hundred meters away  from the
battery  storage  site)  suggested  Pb
transport  in   groundwater  may  be
occurring at this location.
  This is an example of  a  worst  case
situation  for metals mobility. The surface
and subsurface soil at the site is coarse
textured  containing  relatively  low levels
of clay and hydrous iron oxides that
would  normally  be   effective  in
immobilizing Pb. An important additional
circumstance is the presence  of  large
quantities of spilled,  strong  acid which
acidified the soil  to   the   shallow
groundwater. This  apparently  facilitated
transport of this metal through the soil.


Laboratory Studies
  Most work  with  metal  mobility  and
bioavailability has  been done  with
surface soils containing an  appreciable
organic  matter content  compared to
subsurface soils which are the  transport
media for metals between waste disposal
sites  and groundwater. Data  were
presented illustrating  the  difference
between  surface and subsurface soils on
metal  retention  capacity.  More
importantly,  and pertaining to  the  focus
of this project, the  laboratory  studies
clearly  demonstrated  that  subsoils
differing in  physical  and  chemical
properties  will  show  substantial
differences in  their ability to  immobilize
trace and toxic metals. Sandy soils and
weakly acid  soils are much less effective
in retaining metals than soils near neutral
to alkaline in  pH  and containing high
levels of  clay.
  The amount of metals  present in  the
soil was  shown to be  an important factor
in determining  mobility.  At higher
concentrations  that may  be  associated
with  waste  disposal  sites, many  soils
become  less  effective  in immobilizing
metals. Apparently,  the  immobilization
processes in  soils are  overwhelmed.
However,  as indicated in the previo
paragraph, some soils showed the abil
to effectively  immobilize  very  hii
concentrations of metals.
  Though this project focused on subs
materials, the preceding two paragrap
summarize   findings that  one  mig
expect  based  on previous  work w
surface  soils.  The  paragraph  bel<
briefly  introduces a significant, relative
new research topic.
  A subject  that  has received  minirr
research  attention related  to  met«
mobility in soils is facilitated transport
other  waste materials  that may  I
present. The likely  role of facilitati
transport was evident at two of the fie
sites studied. Both batch  equilibratii
and  column   leaching   studi<
demonstrated the presence of oth
waste materials in addition to metals
concern  can  significantly  enham
mobility  of  metals. The  presence  ai
effects of such co-wastes are importa
factors  that  have been  overlooked ti
often  in  the past  when  evaluating tl
potential for metals  movement  ar
groundwater contamination. The  c
wastes  studied included  a synthel
municipal leachate, a simulated  acid
metals waste, and a synthetic oil fie
waste.  Column   leaching studies cleai
demonstrated complex  formatic
between both Cd and  Pb with differe
components  of the synthetic municip
landfill   leachate  since  two  distm
concentration peaks occurred with time
column eluents.
  Another topic that has  received litl
research  attention is the  influence
subsoil redox  potential  conditions  (
metal mobility. One of the project's bat<
equilibrium retention studies included th
parameter. Under the conditions of tr>
study,  the data suggested soil oxidatk
status may have some influence on met
retention, but the effect was less than tl
other  variables studied in this  proje
(different  metals, metal concentration
soils,  and co-wastes present).


Conclusions and
Recommendations

Field Studies

Kolin As Dipping  Vat
  Our data suggested that As associate
with  this old cattle dipping vat may I
strongly  retained by  the surroundir
subsoil  such that leaching  beneath
couple  of meters  has been  negligibl
However, definite conclusions at this si
are not  possible  because  a chemic

-------
history of the site is not available (the vat
was  last  used decades prior  to any
sampling  at the  site) and because
transformations between  several  species
of As with different mobilities may have
occurred complicating determination  of
what may have happened over the years.
Also, a crack in the concrete walls of the
below-ground  vat  may  have released
As directly into the subsoil zones where
samples  were obtained  making  an
evaluation  of the data difficult. There was
some indication that  iron oxides in  the
subsoils tended to retain the As.

Combustion Inc.
  Contrary to the  information provided
us, metals wastes do not appear to be a
problem at this site based on our limited
sampling.

Pontchatoula Battery
  Lead, usually one of the least mobile of
the common toxic elements in soils, had
moved vertically to shallow groundwater
at a  former battery  recycling plant.
Subsequent lateral movement in  the
groundwater is  also  indicated.  At this
site, Pb movement was facilitated by the
combined  presence of sandy subsoils
and  a co-waste  consisting of  large
quantities of  spilled sulfuric acid.

Tinker AFB
  Field  sampling indicated metals were
not moving appreciably in subsoils from
closed waste disposal pits examined at
Tinker Air  Force Base. Soil properties at
this site apparently result in effective
immobilization. Laboratory  studies with
this soil supported the conclusions that
metals are strongly retained in the soil at
this site relative to other sites and  soil
materials examined.

Robins AFB
  Assuming  disposal  zone boundaries
were  correctly  delineated   on maps
provided  us,  high  concentrations  of
several  metals have  moved  laterally in
shallow groundwater  from   a  closed
disposal site toward an adjacent swampy
area. High levels of organic wastes may
have facilitated metals movement at this
site.

Laboratory Studies
  The laboratory studies demonstrated:

1. Subsoils are generally  less  effective in
  immobilizing metals compared  to
1  surface soils and sediments.
2. The  metal-immobilizing  capacity  of
  subsoils increases with  pH,  clay
  content, cation exchange capacity, and
  hydrous oxide content of the subsoil.
  Several of these factors are related in
  soils such that in general, sandy soils
  offer a high potential for metal mobility
  compared to finer textured soils.

3. Metals tend to be more mobile in soils
  as their concentration increases. This
  is likely due to high  levels  exceeding
  the  capacity  of  various immobilizing
  processes.

4. One  of the important aspects of this
  study was the demonstration  that the
  presence of  co-wastes containing
  complexing anions, competing cations,
  or high acid contents tend to  facilitate
  metal movement in soil. In particular, a
  synthetic municipal  landfill leachate
  studied resulted in  substantially less
  retention of metals by most  of the soil
  materials studied.

5. Results  of short-term  laboratory
  studies suggested oxidized subsoils
  tend  to  be   more effective  in
  immobilizing  metals than  anoxic
  subsoils, but the differences found in
  this  preliminary  study were relatively
  small.

6.There are  important  interactions
  affecting metal mobility  between: (1)
  the  kinds of  metals  present, (2) the
  amounts of  metals  present,  (3) soil
  properties,  and (4)  the  presence  of
  co-wastes.  For example,  whether  or
  not  the presence of a particular co-
  waste will have no effect, a moderate
  effect,  or a  very large effect on the
  mobility of metals can depend on the
  properties of the soil material.

Complimentary Findings of
Field  and Laboratory Studies
  Though a  quantitative relationship
between  field  and lab results was not
attempted, the laboratory data  supported
the findings of the field studies.  Using
the same or  very  similar  subsoil
materials, the lab studies demonstrated
the  effective  metal  immobilizing
characteristics  of the subsoil at the
Tinker  AFB site where field  sampling
indicated metal movement is apparently
not a problem.
  In contrast, lab studies demonstrated
coarse-textured  subsoils permitted
leaching  of Pb,  normally considered a
relatively immobile toxic  metal.  The
additional presence of other  simulated
wastes substantially facilitated release
and transport of Pb and other metals.This
helped  explain shallow  groundwater
contamination  by Pb  at an  old  battery
recycling  plant  and  the  apparent
movement  of  Pb and other  metals at
another Air Force base disposal site.
  A  major  finding  of  this  work
representing a  relatively  new research
topic  was the demonstration that several
types of non-metallic wastes can greatly
facilitate the movement of  metals in
subsoils.


Recommendations
  The findings of this project lead to the
recommendation that the presence of
waste  materials other than  metals at
disposal sites must be  considered in
evaluating the  potential  for metals
contamination of groundwater. Additional
research   should  be  done on:  (1)
identifying  the important components of
various types of co-waste that facilitate
metal  mobility  in  soils,  and,  (2)
quantifying these effects to aid in  model
development.  Also, the  interaction
between subsoil properties,  kinds  and
amounts of metals  present,  and kinds
and  amounts  of  co-wastes present
should receive more research attention in
order  to  develop models  that  will
adequately predict metals  movement
under the range of conditions  associated
with waste disposal sites.


Literature Cited
Bates, M. H. 1980. Fate and transport of
   heavy  metals. Presented at Seminar
   on  Ground  Water Quality,  Oklahoma
   Center   for  Continuing Education,
   University  of  Oklahoma,, Norman,
   Oklahoma, 24 July, 1980.

Benjamin,  M. M., and J. O. Leckie. 1982.
   Effects  of complexation by Cl, 564,
   and 8303  on adsorption behavior of
   Cd on  oxide  surfaces.  Environ. Sci.
   and Technol.  16:162-170.

Brown, D. W.  1979. Adsorption of  lead
   from  solution  on  the  quartz- and
   feldspar-containing  silt fraction of  a
   natural  streambed sediment.  In: E.A.
   Jenne  (ed.)  Chemical Modelling in
   Aqueous Systems,  ACS  Symposium
   Series   93.  American  Chemical
   Society.  Washington,  D.C.  (pp. 237-
   260).

Doner, H. E. 1978. Chloride as a factor in
   mobilities of Ni(ll), Cu(ll), and Cd(ll) in

-------
  soil. Soil  Sci. Soc. Am. J. 42:882-
  885.

Fuller, W.  H.  1980. Soil modification to
  minimize movement of pollutants from
  solid waste operations. CRC Grit. Rev.
  in Environ. Control 9(3):213-269.

Fuller, W.  H., and  A. W. Warrick. 1985.
  Soils  in   Waste  Treatment  and
  Utilization: Volume 1, Land Treatment;
  Volume II, Pollutant  Containment,
  Monitoring, and  Closure.  CRC Press,
  Inc., Boca Raton,  Florida,  (268  and
  235 p.).

Gambrell, R. P., R. A. Khalid, V .R.  Col-
  lard, C. N. Reddy, and W. H. Patrick,
  Jr.  1976. The effect of pH and redox
  potential on heavy metal chemistry in
  sediment-water systems  affecting
  toxic  metal  bioavailability.  In:
  Dredging: Environmental  Effects  and
  Technology Proceedings of WODCON
  VII  San Francisco,  California,  10-12
  July, 1976 (pp. 581-600).

Gambrell, R. P., R. A. Khalid, and W. H.
  Patrick, Jr. 1980. Chemical availability
  of mercury, lead, and zinc  in Mobile
  Bay sediment suspensions as affected
  by  pH  and  oxidation-reduction
  conditions. Environ.  Sci.  Technol.
  14:431-436.

Garcia-Miragaya,  J.,  and  A.  L.  Page.
  1976. Influence of  ionic  strength and
  inorganic  complex formation on the
  sorption of trace amounts  of Cd by
  montmorillonite.  Soil Sci. Soc. Am J.
  40:658-663.

Gerritse, R. G., and W. van Driel. 1984.
  The relationship between adsorption
  of trace metals, organic  matter,  and
  pH  in  temperate soils.  J. Environ.
  Qual. 13:197-204.

Khalid, R.  A., R. P. Gambrell, and W. H.
  Patrick, Jr. 1981. Chemical availability
  of  cadmium  in Mississippi  River
  sediment. J.  Environ. Qual. 10:523-
  528.

Knox,  K., and P. H. Jones.  1979. Com-
  plexation of heavy metals in sanitary
  landfill  leachates.  In:  Proceedings
  International  Conference  on
  Management  and Control  of Heavy
  Metals  in the Environment, London,
  September, 1979 (pp. 244-248).
Levi-Minzi,  R., G. F. Soldatiri, and R.
   Riffaldi. 1976. Cadmium adsorption by
   soils. J.  Soil Sci.  27:10-15.

Page, A. L., and P. F. Pratt. 1975. Effects
   of  sewage  sludge  or  effluent
   application to soil  on the movement of
   nitrogen,  phosphorus, soluble salts,
   and trace elements to groundwater. In:
   Proceedings of the  1975 National
   Conference on  Municipal Sludge
   Management and  Disposal,  (pp. 179-
   187)

Thibodeaux,  L.  J.  1979.  Chemo-
   dynamics, John Wiley and Sons, New
   York (501 p.).

-------
  L. Kotuby-Amacher and R. P.  Gambrell  are  with the Center for  Wetland
    Resources, Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA 70803-7511.
  Bert E. Bledsoe is the EPA Project Officer (see below).
  The complete report, entitled  "Factors Affecting Trace Metal Mobility in
    Subsurface Soils," (Order No. PB 88-224 8291AS; Cost: $19.95, subject to
    change) will be available only from:
       National Technical Information Service
       5285 Port Royal Road
       Springfield, VA22161
       Telephone:  703-487-4650
  The EPA Project Officer can be contacted at:
       Robert S. Kerr Environmental Research Laboratory
       U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
       P.O. Box 1198
       Ada, OK 74820
United States
Environmental Protection
Agency
Center for Environmental Research
Information
Cincinnati OH 45268
     BULK RATE
POSTAGE & FEES PAID
         EPA
  PERMIT No. G-35
Official Business
Penalty for Private Use $300

EPA/600/S2-88/036
        0000329   PS

        U S  gNVIR PROTfCTION  AGIMCY
        REGION  5  LIBRARY
        330  S  DEARBORN  STREET
        CHICAGO              IL   6060*

-------