United States Environmental Protection Agency Environmental Research Laboratory Duluth MN 55804 Research and Development EPA/600/S3-85/049 Aug. 1985 f/EPA Project Summary Reproduction and Distribution of Fishes in a Cooling Lake: Wisconsin Power Plant Impact Study Dennis W. Rondorf and James F. Kitchell Spatial and temporal patterns during reproduction and early life history of fishes were studied in a manmade cool- ing lake. Lake Columbia, impounded in 1974, near Portage, Wisconsin, has an area of 190 ha, a mean depth of 2.1 m, and a 15°C temperature gradient de- rived from the thermal effluent of a 527-MW fossil-fueled generating sta- tion which began operation in 1975. The lake was initially colonized by fishes when filled with Wisconsin River water. Observations suggested a de- cline of species diversity of the fish community due to: (1) direct action of upper lethal temperatures, (2) absence of colonization by warm-water, lake- dwelling species, and (3) lack of recruit- ment for certain species. Spatial and temporal patterns of spawning of black crappie (Pomoxis nigromaculatus) were altered by a rapid rise in water temperatures following plant startup after a 3-week shutdown. Water temperatures above expected spawning temperatures reduced avail- able spawning area and induced aggre- gation of sexually mature black crappie at coolest available temperatures. Ele- vated temperatures subsequently short- ened the spawning season, induced resorption of ova, and caused loss of secondary sexual characteristics. A second generating unit began opera- tion in February 1978. Spawning of black crappie and white bass (Morone chrysops) occurred 1 month earlier dur- ing the spring of 1978 than in 1977. Species abundance of larval fish catches was greater in 1978 when the spawning season was not unusually abbreviated, as in 1977. After initially drifting with water current, juvenile stages of sunfish (Lepomis sp.) and giz- zard shad (Dorosoma cepedianum) re- sponded to changes in the thermal gra- dient by horizontal and vertical shifts in abundance. This Project Summary was developed by EPA's Environmental Research Lab- oratory, Duluth, MN, to announce key findings of the research project that is fully documented in a separate report of the same title (see Project Report order- ing information at back). Introduction Impoundment of a man-made cooling lake provides an opportunity for develop- ment of a recreational fishery. Thermally elevated areas of a cooling lake can increase angler use in temperate climates (McNurney era/. 1977). Because the cool- ing lake is a relatively small man-made system, it has greater potential and flexi- bility for recreational fishery management than many systems. Fish management strategies of stock- ing or fish harvest for temperate lakes based on surface area of morphoedaphic characteristics are not valid for lakes sub- stantially altered by thermal input. The elevated thermal conditions of cooling lakes create temporal and spatial limita- tions of organisms native to nearby lakes. Growth (Bennett and Gibbons 1974), dis- tribution (Merriman and Thorpe 1976), and reproduction (Bennett and Gibbons 1975, Kaya 1977) are modified in ther- ------- 4 mally altered areas. Lake Columbia, lo- cated at the Columbia Generating Station near Portage, Wisconsin, provided an opportunity for research and development of management strategies specifically for cooling lakes in the Great Lakes region. As a subproject of an assessment of a developing cooling lake ecosystem (Lo- zano et al. 1978), this study of fishes con- cerned the reproductive responses of adults and distributional patterns of adult, larval, and early juvenile forms in Lake Columbia. The objectives were (1) deter- mine changes in species composition of the fish population; (2) delineate temporal and spatial limits of fish reproduction; and (3) determine distributional patterns of larval and early juvenile fishes. Relative Abundance of Fishes New impoundments are known for the dramatic changes they cause in fish communities after filling. Studies sug- gest these changes can be attributed to changes of biotic and abiotic characteris- tics of the impoundment (Jenkins and Morals 1971). In the cooling lake envir- onment, the effects of the unique thermal regime are imposed on these expected changes in the fish community. There- fore, the first objective was to determine if changes in species composition of the fish population occurred with time. Methods Composition of the fish community and the relative abundance of adults at loca- tions in Lake Columbia were assessed using fyke nets. Netted fish were identi- fied, measured for total length, and weighed. Water temperatures were mea- sured at 0.5, 1.0, 1.5, and 2.0-m depths when nets were set and raised. Die! temperature changes were continually monitored with recording thermographs. The number of fish per fyke net set— catch per effort (CPE)—was used as a measu re of the relative abundance of fish species over time. Species diversity of the fish population in quarterly fyke net catches was calculated using the Shan- non and Weaver (1963) general index of diversity (H). Results The Shannon-Weaver diversity index suggested a decline in diversity of quar- terly catches that began in the winter of 1975-76 and continued through the fall of 1976 (Figure 1). I n fall 1976 only 34% of the catch was similar to that of the summer quarter 1975. Species diversity did not return to 1975 levels (Figure 2). 2.0-1 I I <3 1.0- Percent similar to first sample J S F 1975 V W S 1976 l W rlOO -50 to I Q. S 1977 Figure 1. Shannon-Weaver diversity index (H) and percent similarity to first sample of quarterly fyke net catches in Lake Columbia. Changes in the diversity of fyke net catches were attributed to a decline of CPE for some species and numerical dom- inance by others. The mean quarterly CPE of centrarchids in Lake Columbia (Figure 2A) indicated that the abundance of purnpkinseedsunfish(/.epo/r7/s<7/6A0si/s) declined somewhat between July 1975 and August 1977. The mean CPE for white bass(Morone chrysops)(Figure 2B) was high in the winter quarter samples. Bluegill (Lepomis macrochirus) catches increased dramatically, while gizzard shad (Dorosoma cepedianum) CPE in- creased from none caught during the first quarter to a CEP >5 in 1977 (Figure 2B). Bluegill and gizzard shad length frequen- cies indicated successful growth and reproduciton in the new lake environ- ment, as evidenced by increased CPE. Other fish species common to the Wis- consin River were collected in Lake Columbia. The relationship between changes in relative abundance, final temperature preferenda, and upper incip- ient lethal temperatures of the most abundant species in fyke net catches is shown in Figure 3. Yellow perch (Perca flavescens) and walleye (Stizostedion vitreum) made up <0.5% of all catches. Species at low abundance that decreased in CPE included quillback (Carpoides cyprinus), smallmouth buffalo (Ictiobus bubalus). and carp (Cyprinus carpio) (Fig- ures 2C, 3). Minnow trap catches indi- cated fathead minnows (Pimephales promelas] and mud minnows (Umbra limi) were abundant when the plant began 60-i 40- 20- o 15- 1 /0" << c *** o 7.5- 1- 0.5- , Bluegill '--_/ /\' f-B. crappie -Pumpkinseed ® V-.,,---.. /._/V. pfte © '"' Buffalo sp. I ' "\-Carp .Quillback SFWSSFWSS 1975 1976 1977 Figure 2. Mean catch per effort in fyke nets during quarterly sampling periods in Lake Columbia. ------- operation in March 1975, but abundance declined by July. The mean quarterly CPE of northern pike declined 99% between the first and third year of the study and disappeared from catches during the summer quarter of 1976 (Figure 2B). Bluegill abundance increased more than eight-fold between the first and third years (Figure 3). This species was well adapted for the cooling lake environment because of its relatively high thermal preference, abilityto forage in open water, and the presence of suitable spawning habitat. Reproduction of Fishes Thermal requirements for reproduction of a species are one of the primary limits to distribution and abundance (Alderdice and Forrester 1968, Hokanson 1977). Temperature and photoperiod are envi- ronmental factors important in the recru- desence of gametogensis of many t°ie- osts (De Vlaming 1972, 1974, Schreck 1974, Hokanson 1977). The unique ther- mal regimes in the cooling lakes create temperatures during winter and early spring at or above those associated with the initiation of spring spawning. The thermal gradient was expected to deter- mine the spatial and temporal location of spawning within limits of photoperiod control. Thus, the second objective was to study the temporal and spatial limits of reproduction within Lake Columbia. Methods White bass and black crappie were selected for study because adults were growing well but did not appear to be pro- ducing young.' Temporal patterns of reproduction were determined by monitoring the maturity of white bass and black crappie from the initiation to the completion of spawning during the springs of 1977 and 1978. The percent gonad weight of total body weight or gonadosomatic index was calculated as a measure of maturity at 2-week inter- vals starting in February 1977. Spatial limitations of spawning relative to the thermal gradient were examined during the springs of 1977 and 1978. Relative abundance of sexually mature fish at varous locations in Lake Columbia was determined by fyke net sampling and regression analysis methods(Rondorf and Kitchell, 1983). Thermal exposure of adult black crappie was estimated from equa- tions describing distribution of adults and the thermal gradient. Preferred Temperature ± S.D. Incipient Lethal Temperature Percent Decrease/Increase Gizzard shad Bluegill Black Bullhead Black crappie Yellow perch White bass Pumpkinseed Carp Carpsucker sp. Buffalo sp. Northern pike 20 30 40 Temperature (CJ 100 800 Results A rapid rise in water temperatures fol- lowing a 3-week power plant shutdown during 1977 stimulated spawning, re- duced available spawning area, and in- duced aggregation of black crappie at coolest available water temperatures. Elevated water temperatures subsequent- ly induced resorption of black crappie ova, loss of secondary sexual characteristics, and were probably near upper lethal temperatures of embryo and larval stages. A temporally shortened spawning season was associated with a rapid rise in water temperatures, while additional thermal input by the Columbia II generating unit caused spawning to occur 30 days earlier in the spring. Distribution of Larval Fishes Larvae of many spring spawning fishes initially disperse into limnetic waters (Faber 1967, Werner 1969, Netsch et at. 1971, Amundrud et al. 1974, Kelso and Ward 1977) and later aggregate as juve- niles in littoral areas that have higher water temperatures. Juvenile fishes ex- hibit thermoregulatory behavior in the laboratory (Cherry et al. 1977) and after reviewing temperature preference data Reproductive Guild N. Litho-pelagophil G. Lithophil G. Lithophil G. Phytophil N. Phyto-Lithophil N. Phyto-Lithophil G. Polyphil N. Phytophil N. Psammophil N. Phytophil N. Phytophil Reference Preferred. Lethal a.b a,c a.d.e a,b a,c a.e a.b a.b a.e f,e N = nonguarding spawners G = guarding spawners Figure 3. Percent increase or decrease in abundance of selected fishes in Lake Columbia. Preferred and upper incipient lethal temperatures of fish are from other sources fReutter and Herdendorf 1974.bBrungs and Jones 1977;c Cherry eta\. 1977;" Hart J 952;'Cvancaraeta\. 1977; 'Coutant 1977). ------- of fish, Coutant (1977) concluded that laboratory and field results were reason- ably consistent. During the development of thermoregulatory behavior, increasing mobility probably facilitates the ability of individual juveniles to thermoregulate. However, little is known about the thermal responsiveness of pelagic larvae and early juveniles of fish when distributed in the limnetic zone. Therefore, an objective of this study was to describe distributional responses of pelagic larvae and juvenile fish to changes in the thermal gradient. Certain abiotic factors—i.e., temperature— are correlated with year-class strength of some fish populations (Kramer and Smith 1962, Koonce et al. 1977). Methods Gizzard shad and bluegill, two species whose populations increased in the cool- ing lake, were studied to determine how the larval forms responded to the dynamic heterothermal environment of the cool- ing lake. Additional observations were designed to investigate factors affecting the relative abundance of larval fish. Time of capture, depth of capture, station loca- tion, and die! movement patterns were examined. Tows to assess horizontal distribution patterns were made at a depth of 0.5 m between 1900 and 2400 h central stand- ard time (CST). Clear plexiglass traps equipped with lights were used to collect larval fish. Larval and juvenile fish were preserved in the field then counted and identified in the laboratory. Data were analyzed using mathemati- cal methods to describe horizontal distri- bution patterns. Results Species diversity of larval fish catches was low in 1977 when water tempera- tures increased rapidly. The median tem- perature of capture of larval Lepomis sp. and gizzard shad was near 30°C. Tem- peratures > 31 °C during thermal stratifi- cation reduced the abundance of gizzard shad completing die! vertical movements. After initially drifing with the current, Lepomis sp. and gizzard shad responded to water temperature changes by hori- zontal shifts in abundance with a mode at 28° to 31 °C. Conclusions Observations suggest that the species diversity of fish in Lake Columbia, Wis- consin, declined during the first year of thermal input by the plant. Habitat modi- fication, such as reduced vegetation as a direct result of thermal input, may be the reason for the decrease in abundance of some species. The decline in species diversity was accentuated by fish mortal- ity from temperatures exceeding upper lethal limits, an absence of colonization of warm-water lake-dwelling species, and limited reproductive success. Thermal inputs by the power plant mod- ified temporal and spatial characteristics of spawning white bass and black crap- pie. Resumption of plant operation follow- ing a 3-week shutdown resulted in a rapid increase in water temperatures that stimulated spawning, reduced available spawning area, and induced aggregation of sexually mature black crappie at cool- est available water temperatures. Water temperatures above expected spawning temperatures induced partial resorption of ovaries, loss of secondary sexual char- acteristics, and abbreviation of spawning duration. The combined operation of the Columbia I and II generating units in- duced spawning about 1 month earlier than when only Columbia I was operating. The rapid increase in water tempera- tures that induced spawning and subse- quent gonadal resorption in 1977 was associated with a lower number of spe- cies of larval fishes. If a number of species were stimulated to spawn, then a greater number of ichthyoplankton species would be expected at that time, but this was not observed. Therefore, factors associated with the increase in temperatures must have been responsible for reducing ich- thyoplankton species abundance. The number of species of larval fishes was lower during 1977 when water tempera- tures increased rapidly and reproductive responses were aberrant. This may ex- plain the limited reproductive success observed for some species successful as adults in the cooling lake environment. Larval and early juvenile stages of blue- gill and gizzard shad were responsive to temperature changes within the thermal gradient. Larval forms initially drifted downstream. Pelagic larval and juvenile stages of bluegill and gizzard shad were most abundant at 28° to 31 °C and were capable of responding to changes in the thermal gradient induced by changing air temperatures. Larval gizzard shad exhib- ited reduced diel vertical movements when temperatures were > 31 °C. Pelagic larval and early juvenile forms responded to thermal dynamics of the cooling lake by modifying horizontal and vertical distribu- tion patterns. Recommendations 1. The disappearance of aquatic vege- tation should be expected in cooling lakes with heavy thermal loading. Management to enhance fish popu- lations of species that require vege- tation to spawn should not be attempted. 2. Initiation of spawning was approx- imately 1 month earlier with the thermal input of two 527-MW gen- erating units. If fishery manage- ment agencies protect spawning adult fish during spring by closed season, the regulations may not be applicable to cooling lake fisheries. The accelerating of spawning dur- ing spring can provide the oppor- tunity to open a fishery while other temperate lake fisheries are closed during normal reproductive season. 3. Power plant shutdowns are often scheduled during spring but rapid temperature increases when plants resume operation can cause aber- rant reproductive responses in spring-spawning fish. The opera- tion and more than one generating unit may be beneficial because additional units buffer the effects of rapid changes in temperature of a single unit. 4. Successful reproduction of fish in a cooling lake is spatially limited to water temperatures within the ther- mal tolerance limits of reproduc- tion. Cooling lake water tempera- tures and corresponding areas can be estimated during planning. De- sign should provide adequate area with water temperatures within the thermal tolerance limits of oogene- sis, spawning, and incubation dur- ing spring. 5. Pelagic larval stages drift down- stream in a recirculating cooling lake and will subsequently be en- trained by the power plant if cooling lake turnover time is not adequate to permit metamorphosis into the more mobile early juvenile stages. Entrainment should be accepted as a part of the cooling lake environ- ment, however, careful design can minimize entrainment of larval and early juvenile stages. Additional generating units should be aug- mented by increasing cooling lake area and volume or by providing cooling towers to increase lake turn- over time. ------- 6. Early juvenile fish in pelagic stages are mobile and respond to thermal gradients and water currents by congregating in preferred habitats. Cooling lake design can increase juvenile nursery areas and species diversity by providing heterogene- ous habitats with a diversity of water depths, substrates, and shore- line configurations. These design modifications would not inhibit the cooling capacity of the lake because cooling is most dependent on sur- face area. 7. After power plant operation began, species diversity declined as a few eurythermal species incresed in abundance and other species de- clined. Sport fish should be stocked early in the operation of the lake so that juveniles can utilize forage species likely to become abundant after the power plant begins opera- tion. Thermally tolerant nest-guard- ing Centrarchids and Ictalurids, such as largemouth bass and chan- nel catfish, are likely to be the most successful native species in cooling lakes and should be preferred for initial stocking. 8. After the power plant begins opera- tion, water temperatures of the cooling lake may exceed the upper lethal limits of popular cool water sport fish resulting in fish kills. Design can create thermal refugia using water depth and circulation patterns. Fishery managers andthe public should anticipate fish kills as a part of starting the long-term management of a cooling lake, but recurrent fish kills can be avoided through careful design. 9. Largemouth bass, a species sus- ceptible to over-harvest, was caught at the highest rate by angling near the outfall in winter (0.28 bass/ cast) and in cool water near the intake in late spring (0.27 bass/ cast: Lozano et at. 1978). Thus, the area near the intake nad outfall should be permanently closed to fishing to protect summer and win- ter aggregations of fish under sea- sonally extreme thermal conditions. 10. Small reservoirs are often subject to over-exploitation of sport fish populations, particularly when fish are spatially limited by temperature or lake morphometry. Thus, when power plant security is designed, consideration should be given to minimize over-harvest of fish in outfall and intake areas and reduce potential conflicts between power plant security and fisherman. References Alderdice, D. P., and C. R. Forrester. 1968. Some effects of salinity and tempera- ture on early development and survival of the English sole (Parophrys vetulus). J. Fish Res. Bd. Can. 13:799-841. Amundrud, J. R., D. J. Faber, and A. Keast. 1974. Seasonal succession of freeswimming perciform larvae in Lake Opinion, Ontario. J. Fish Res. Bd. Can. 31:1661-1665. Balon, E. K. 1975. Reproductive guilds of fishes: A proposal and definition. J. Fish. Res. Bd. Can. 32:821-864. Bennett, D. H., and J. W. Gibbons. 1974. Growth and condition of juvenile large- mouth bass from a reservoir receiving thermal effluent. In: J. W. Gibbons and R. R. Sharitz (eds.) Thermal ecology. AEC Symposium Series, CONF- 730505, NTIS. National Technical In- formation Service, Springfield, Virginia. p. 246-254. Bennett, D. H., and J. W. Gibbons. 1975. Reproductive cycles of largemouth bass (Micropterus salmoides) in a cooling reservoir. Trans. Am. Fish. Soc. 104:77- 82. Brungs, W. A. and B. R. Jones. 1977. Temperature criteria for freshwater fish: Protocol and procedures. EPA- 600/3-77-061. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Cincinnati, Ohio. Cherry, D. S., K. L. Dickson, and J. Cairns, Jr. 1977. Preferred, avoided, and lethal temperatures of fish during rising tem- perature conditions. J. Fish. Res. Bd. Can. 34:239-246. Coutant, C. C. 1977. Compilation of temperature preference data. J. Fish. Res. Bd. Can. 34:739-745. Cvancara, V. A. S. F. Steiber, and B. A. Cvancara. 1977. Summer temperature tolerance of selected species of Missis- sippi River acclimated young of the year fishes. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 56A:81 - 85. De Vlaming, V. L. 1972. Environmental control of teleost reproductive cycles: A brief review. J. Fish. Biol. 4:131-140. De Vlaming, V. L. 1974. Environmental and endocrine control of teleost repro- duction. In: C. B. Schreckfed.) Control of sex in fishes. COM-75-10484, NTIS. NationalTechnical Information Service, Springfield, Virginia, p. 13-83. Faber, D. J. 1967. Limnetic larval fish in northern Wisconsin lakes. J. Fish. Res. Bd. Can. 24:927-937. Hart, J. S. 1952. Geographic variations of some physiological and morphological characters in certain freshwater fish. University of Toronto Biology Series No. 60. University of Toronto Press, Toronto, Canada. 79 pp. Hokanson, K. E. F. 1977. Temperature requirements of some percids and adaptations to the seasonal tempera- ture cycle. J. Fish. Res. Bd. Can. 34:1524-1550. Jenkins, R. M., and D. I. Morais. 1971. Reservoir sport fishing effort and harv- est in relation to environmental vari- ables. In: G. E. Hall (ed.) Reservoir fisheries and limnology. Special Publi- cation No. 8. American Fisheries Soci- ety, Bethesda, Maryland, p. 371 -384. Kaya, C. M. 1977. Reproductive biology of rainbow and brown trout in a geother- mally heated stream: The Firehole River of Yellowstone National Park. Trans. Am. Fish. Soc. 106:354-361. Kelso, J. R. M., and F. J. Ward. 1977. U nexploited percid populations of West Blue Lake, Manitoba, andtheir interac- tions. J. Fish. Res. Bd. Can. 34:1655- 1669. Koonce, J. F., T. B. Bagenal, R. F. Carline, K. E. F. Hokanson, and M. Nagiec. 1977. Factors influencing year-class strength of percids: A summary and a model of temperature effects. J. Fish. Res. Bd. Can. 34:1900-1909. Kramer, R. H., and L. L. Smith, Jr. 1962. Formation of year classes in largemouth bass. Trans. Am. Fish. Soc. 91:29-41. Lozano, S. J., D. W. Rondorf, and J. F. Kitchell. 1978. Assessment of a cooling lake ecosystem. Tech. Rept. WIS-WRC- 78-08. Water Resources Center, Uni- versity of Wisconsin, Madison, Wis- consin. 108 pp. McNurney, J. M., H. M. Dreier, and M. A. Frakes. 1977. Analysis of sport fishing in a reservoir receiving a thermal efflu- ent. 39th Midwest Fish and Wildlife Conference, Madison, Wisconsin. Merriman, D., and L. M. Thorpe (eds.). 1976. The Connecticut River ecological study. Monograph No. 1. American Fisheries Society, Bethesda, Maryland. 252 pp. Netsch, N. F., G. M. Kersh, Jr., A. Houser, and R. V. Kilambi. 1971. Distribution of young gizzard and threadfin shad in Beaver Reservoir. In: G. E. Hall (ed.) Reservoir fisheries and limnology. Spe- cial Publication No. 8. American Fisher- ies Society, Bethesda, Maryland, p. 95-105. Reutter, J. M., and C. E. Herdendorf. 1974. Laboratory estimates of the sea- sonal final temperature preferenda of ------- some Lake Erie fish. 17th Conf. Great Lakes Res. 1974:59-67. Rondorf, D. W., and J. F. Kitchell. 1983. Reproduction and distribution of fishes in a cooling lake. Wisconsin Power Plant Impact Study. U.S. Environmen- tal Protection Agency, Duluth, Minne- sota. 58 p. Schreck, C. B. (ed.). 1974. Control of sex in fishes. COM-75-10484, NTIS. Na- tional Technical Information Service, Springfield, Virginia. 106 pp. Shannon, C. E., and W. Weaver. 1963. The mathematical theory of communi- cation. University of Illinois Press, Urbana, Illinois. 117 pp. Werner, R. G. 1969. Ecology of limnetic bluegill (Lepomis macrochirus) fry in Crane Lake, Indiana. Am. Midi. Nat. 81:164-181. Dennis W. Rondorf and James F. Kitchell are with Water Resources Center, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wl 53706. Gary E. Glass is the EPA Project Officer (see below). The complete report, entitled "Reproduction and Distribution of Fishes in a Cooling Lake: Wisconsin Power Plant Impact Study," (Order No. PB 85-217 669/AS; Cost: $10.00, subject to change) will be available only from: National Technical Information Service 5285 Port Royal Road Springfield, VA 22161 Telephone: 703-487-4650 The EPA Project Officer can be contacted at: Environmental Research Laboratory U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Duluth, MN 55804 •fr U. S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE: 1985/559-111/20636 ------- United States Environmental Protection Agency Center for Environmental Research Information Cincinnati OH 45268 .::-9 Official Business Penalty for Private Use $300 EPA/600/S3-85/049 OOOC329 PS U S ENVIR PROTECTION AGENCY REGION 5 LIBRARY 230 S DEARBORN STREET CHICAGO IL 60604 ------- |