&EPA f.'fi, i of Water Jui, '980 Waifi Copper OOOR80006 Water Quality Standards Criteria Digest A Compilation of State/Federal Criteria ------- NATIONAL SUMMARY OF STATE WATER QUALITY STANDARDS COPPER JULY, 1980 PREPARED FOR UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY CRITERIA AND STANDARDS DIVISION 401 M STREET, S. W. WASHINGTON, D. C. 20460 PREPARED BY NALESNIK ASSOCIATES INCORPORATED 505 ELEVENTH STREET, S. E. WASHINGTON, D. C. 20003 Contract Number 68-01-6058 Project Number WA-80-A055 ------- Introduction This digest was compiled to provide general information to the public as well as to Federal, State, and local officials. It contains excerpts from the individual State-Federal water quality standards establishing pollutant specific criteria for navigable surface waters. The water quality standards program is implemented by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency where responsibility for providing water quality recommendations, approving State-adopted standards for navigable waters, evaluating adherence to the standards, and overseeing enforcement of standards compliance, has been mandated by Congress. The standards program, a nationwide strategy for surface water quality management, contains two major elements: the use (recreation, drinking water, fish and wildlife propagation, industrial, or agricultural) to be made of the navigable water; and criteria to protect these uses. Water quality criteria (numerical or narrative specifications for physical, chemical, temperature, and biological constituents are stated in the July 1976 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency publication Quality Criteria for Water (QCW), order # 055-001-01049-4, price $3.50, available from the Government Printing Office, Washington, B.C. The 1976 QCW, commonly referred to as the "Red Book," is the most current compilation of scientific information used by the Agency as a basis for assessing water quality. This publication is subject to periodic updating and revisions in light of new scientific and technical information. Copper is an essential trace element required in plant and animal metabolism. Most natural waters contain copper at levels not known to have any human or aquatic lexicological effects. Concentrations of copper in water result from metal plating, mining, pesticide production, and electrical products industries. The toxicity of copper to aquatic life is enhanced by lower alkaline conditions and increased water hardness. Copper in sufficiently high concentrations does impart an undesirable taste to water. The 1976 Quality Criteria for Water recommends the following: 1.0 mg/1 (total) for domestic water supplies (welfare) For freshwater and marine aquatic life, 0.1 times a 96- hour LC50 for (total) copper as determined through non- aerated bioassays using a sensitive aquatic resident species. Since water quality standards are revised from time to time, following procedures set forth in the Clean Water Act, individual entries in this digest may be superseded. This digest will be updated periodically. Because this publication is intended for use only as a general information reference, the reader needs to refer to the current approved water quality standards to obtain the latest information for special purposes and applications. These can be obtained from the State water pollution control agencies or the EPA Regional Offices. ------- REFERENCES California Water Quality Standards by River Basins, c.a. 1975 For more detailed information on selected basins, sub-basins and stretches of streams and coastal areas refer to California State Water Quality Standards. D Delaware Water Quality Standards, March 25, 1979 C Idaho Water Quality Standards, c.a. September, 1979 Missouri Water Quality Standards, c.a. February, 1978 £ American Samoa Water Quality Standards, Revised July, 1973 p Territory of Guam Water Quality Standards, Sept. 1975 /-i Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands Water Quality Standards, October 21, 1973 H Virgin Islands Water Quality Standards, Aug. 1973 ENVIRONMENT REPORTER, The Bureau of National Affairs, Inc. Washington, D. C. 20037 1 Pages 701:0501-0509, February 16, 1979 2 Pages 706:1004-1008, July 20, 1979 3 Pages 711-0542-0544, August 5, 1977 4 Pages 716:0603, March 26, 1976 5 Pages 726-:1005, 1011-1013, March 7, 1980 Basic Water Quality Standards adopted May 22, 1979, have not yet been submitted to EPA for formal approval. 6 Pages 731:1002-1009, September 8, 1978 7 Pages 746:1008-1014, October 19, 1979 8 Pages 751:0504-0505, January 25, 1980 9 Pages 765:0512-0515, January 30, 1976 10 Page 761:0503-0504, 1973 ------- 11 Page 766:0504-0509, October 5, 1979 12 Pages 771:0502-0504, September 29, 1978 13 Pages 776:0504-0506, April 10, 1979 14 Pages 781:0501-0502, May 18, 1979 15 Pages 786:0501-0502, August 29, 1975 16 Page 791:0583, May 26, 1978 17 Pages 796:0103-0108, February 16, 1979 18 Pages 801:1001-1002, Sept. 29, 1978 19 Page 806:1003, March 30, 1979 90 Page 811:1043, 1974 21 Pages 816:0602-0607, 0642-0648, 1974 99 Pages 821:0502-0505, June 30, 1978 00 Pages 831:0501-0510, February 21, 1975 94 Page 836:0502, June 30, 1978 OR ^° Pages 841:0507-0537, December 7, 1979 9fi Pages 846:0501-0508, November 17, 1978 97 Pages 851:1001-1023, December 15, 1978 00 Pages 856:1001-1002, July 18, 1978 90 Pages 861:1002-1007, August 11, 1979 on ™ Pages 866:1004-1009, December 28, 1979 31 Pages 871:0501-0506, November 25, 1977 oo Pages 876-1001-1043, May 26, 1978 00 Pages 881:1001-1007, September 21, 1979 04 Pages 886:0513-0524, August 29, 1975 oc Pages 891:1001-1129, November 16, 1979 ------- 36 Pages 901:0501-0505, November 3, 1978 07 °' Pages 906:0501:0506, October 13, 1978 38 Pages 911:0501-0507, June 22, 1979 OQ Pages 916:0541-0544, April 14, 1978 40 w Pages 921:1001-1003, August 13, 1976 41 Pages 926:0541-0563, January 26, 1979 49 ^ Pages 931:0501-0508, May 26, 1978 43 Pages 936:1001-1003, June 27, 1975 44 Pages 941:1001-1005, May 26, 1978 AC. 40 Pages 946:0501-0520, July 14, 1978 46 Pages 951:1002-1003, April 28, 1978 47 Pages 956:1001-1007, January 11, 1980 48 Page 741:1002, November 23, 1979 49 Pages 896:0301-0310, March 31, 1978 ------- COPPER State Alabama 1. Criteria Value in mg/1 Not Specified Toxic Substances narrative: only such amounts, whether alone or in combination with other substances as will not render the waters unsafe or unsuitable as a source of water supply for drinking or food-processing purposes, or injurious to fish, wildlife and aquatic life. Toxic Substances narrative: only such amounts, whether alone or in combination with other substances or wastes, as will not: render the water unsafe or unsuit- able for swimming and water-contact sports; be injurious to fish, wildlife and aquatic life or, where applicable, shrimp and crabs; impair the waters for any other usage established for this classification. Toxic substances narrative: Only such amounts, whether alone or in combination with other substances, as will not: be injurious to fish and aquatic life, including shrimp and crabs; exceed one-tenth of the 96-hour median tolerance limit for fish, aquatic life or shellfish, including shrimp and crabs. Toxic Substances narrative: Only such amounts, whether alone or in combination with other substances, as will not: be injurious to fish and aquatic life including shrimp and crabs in estuarine or salt waters or the propagation thereof; not to exceed one-tenth of the 96-hour median tolerance limit for fish and aquatic life including shrimp and crabs in salt and estuarine waters except that other limiting concentrations may be used when factually justified and approved by the Commission. Only such amounts as will not render the waters unsuitable for agricultural irriga- tion, livestock watering, industrial cool- ing, industrial process water supply pur- poses, and fish survival, nor interfere with downstream uses. Designated Stream Use All Public water supply Swimming and other whole body water-contact sports Shellfish harvesting Fish and wildlife Agricultural and industrial water supply -1- ------- State Alabama (con't) Criteria Value in mg/1 Only such amounts as will not render the waters unsuitable for industrial cooling and industrial process water supply pur- poses, nor interfere with downstream water uses. Only such amounts as will not render the waters unsuitable for agricultural irriga- tion, livestock watering, industrial cool- ing, and industrial process water supply purposes, where applicable nor interfere with downstream water use. Designated Stream Use Industrial operations Navigation Alaska 2. Not specified Toxic substances narrative: shall not exceed Alaska Drinking Water Standards or EPA Quality Criteria for Water. Toxic substances narrative: same as I. (A) (i) where contact with a product des- tined for subsequent human consumption is present. Same as L (C) or FWPCA Water Quality Criteria as applicable to substances for stockwaters. Concentra- tions for irrigation waters shall not exceed FWPCA Water Quality Criteria or WQC 1972. Toxic substances narrative: shall not individually or in combination exceed 0.01 times the lowest measured 96-hour LCeo for life stages of species identified by the department as being the most sensivtive, biologically important to the situation or exceed criteria cited in EPA Quality Criteria for Water or Alaska Drinking Water Standards whichever concentration is less. Toxic substances narrative: substances shall not be present which pose hazards to worker contact. All I. Fresh water (A) water supply (i) drinking, culinary and food processing (ii) agriculture, includ- ing irrigation and stock watering (iii) aquaculture (iv) industrial, includ- ing any water supplies used in association with a manu- facturing or production enterprise other than food processing), including mining, placer mining, energy production or deve- lopment -2- ------- State Criteria Value in mg/1 Designated Stream Use Alaska (con't) Toxic substances narrative: same as I. (A) (i.) (B) water recreation (i) contact recrea- tion. Toxic substances narrative: substances shall not be present which pose hazards to incidental human contact. Toxic substances narrative: shall not in- dividually or in combination exceed 0.01 times the lowest measured 96 hour L for life stages of species identified by t department as being the most sensitive, biologically important to the location, or exceed criteria cited in EPA Quality Cri- teria for Water or Alaska Drinking Water Standards whichever concentration is less. Toxic substances narrative: same as I. (A) (iii). Toxic substances narrative: shall not ex- ceed EPA Quality Criteria for Water as applicable to the substance. Toxic substances narrative: same as I. (A) (iv). Toxic substances narrative: same as II. (A) (ii). Toxic substances narrative: same as I. (B) (ii). Toxic substances narrative: same as I. (C). (ii) secondary recreation (C) growth and propa- gation of fish, shellfish, other aquatic life, and wildlife including water- fowl and fur bearers H.Marine water (A) water supply (i) aquaculture (ii) seafood processing (iii) industrial, including any water supplies used in association with a manuf acturingor production enterprise (other than food processing) including mining, placer mining, energy production or development (B) water recreation (i) contact recreation (ii) secondary recreation (C) growth and propa- gation of fish, shellfish, aquatic life, and wildlife including seabirds, water- fowl and furbearers -3- ------- State Criteria Value in mg/1 Designated Stream Use Alaska (con't) Arizona1 Arkansas California Toxic substances narrative:same as I. (C) but excluding the phrase "or Alaska Drinking Water Standards." 1.0 0.05 Toxic substances narrative: Toxic sub- stances shall be kept below levels which are deleterious to human, animal, plant or aquatic life, or in amounts sufficient to interfere with the beneficial use of the water. As a minimum evaluation for the presence of toxic substances, a water shall be evaluated by use of a 96-hour bioassay, guided by the document Stan- dard Methods for the Examination of Wa- ter and Wastewater. The survival of the test organisms shall not be less than that in controls which utilize appropriate ex- perimental water. Not specified Toxic substances narrative: Toxic mate- rials attributable to municipal, industrial, agricultural, or other waste discharges, shall not be present in receiving waters in such quanitities as to be toxic to human, animal, plant or aquatic life or to inter- fere with the normal propagation of aqua- tic life. For any toxicants, concentra- tions in the receiving waters after mixing shall not exceed 0.01 of the 96-hour TLm, unless they can be shown to be non- persistant and noncumulative, and to exhibit no synergistic interactions with other waste or stream components. In no case shall concentrations exceed 0.05 of the 96-hour TL. m Not specified 5.0 0.01 (D) harvesting for con- sumption of raw mollusks or other raw aquatic life Domestic, industrial, recreation, aesthetic Fish, aquatic life and wildlife All All All All (except Basins 2, 5A, 5B, 5C, and 6A) Agricultural uses in Basin 2 only All uses in Basins 5A, 5B, and 5C only -4- ------- State California (con't) Criteria Value in mg/1 0.02 0.005 - 6-month Median 0.020 - Daily Maximum 0.05 - Instantaneous Maximum All waters shall be maintained free of toxic substances in concentrations that are toxic to, or that produce detrimental physiological responses in human, plant, animal, or aquatic life. Compliance with this objective will be determined by use of indicator organisms, analyses of species diversity, population density, growth anomalies, bioassays of appro- priate duration or other appropriate methods as specified by the Regional Board. The survival of aquatic life in surface waters subjected to a waste discharge, or other controllable water quality factors, shall not be less than that for the same water body in areas unaffected by the waste discharge, or when necessary for other control water that is consistent with the requirements for "experimental water" as described in "Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Waste- water", latest edition. As a minimum, compliance with this objective as stated in the previous sentence shall be evalu- ated with a 96-hour bioassay. In addition, effluent limits based upon acute bioassays of effluents will be pre- scribed where appropriate, additional numerical receiving water objectives for specific toxicants will be established as sufficient data become available, and source control of toxic substances will be encouraged. Designated Stream Use All uses in Brian Creek Basin (part of Basin 6 A) only. Ocean waters only All -5- ------- State Colorado' Connecticut Criteria Value in mg/1 0.005-0.04 (Depending on water hardness and/or alkalinity) or bioassay application factor of 0.1 0.2 1.0 Toxic substances narrative: Substances attributable to human-induced discharges not otherwise controlled by permits, BMP's, or plans of operation approved by the Division, shall not be introduced into the waters of the State...in amounts, con- centrations, or combinations which are... toxic to humans, animals, plants, or aqua- tic life. Not specified Toxic substances narrative: Note 4. The waters shall be free from chemical cons- tituents in concentrations or combinations which would be harmful to human, animal or aquatic life for the most sensitive and governing water use class. Criteria for chemical constitutes contained in the Quality Criteria for Water (EPA) shall be considered and used as guidance. In areas where fisheries are the governing conside- rations and approved limits have not been established, bioassays are necessary to establish limits on toxic substances, the recommendations for bioassay procedures contained in "Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater" and the application factors contained, in Quality Criteria for Water (EPA) shall be considered. For public drinking water supplies, the raw water sources must be of such a quality that EPA limits as defined by the Safe Drinking Water Act (PL 93-523), or state limits if more strin- gent, for finished water can be met after conventional treatment. Toxic substances narrative: None in con- centrations or combinations which would be harmful to human, animal or aquatic life or which would make the waters un- safe or unsuitable for fish or shellfish or their propagation or impair the waters for any other uses. (See Note 4. above). Designated Stream Use Aquatic life Agricultural Domestic water supply All All All Coastal and marine water uses -6- ------- State Delaware B Florida Q Georgia Criteria Value in mg/1 Not specified Toxic substances narrative: None in con- centrations harmful (synergistically or otherwise) to humans, fish, wildlife and aquatic life as presecribed by EPA's Quality Criteria for Water, 1976. 0.3 0.015 0.03 0.5 Minimum criteria for all waters at all times at all places: shall be free from domestic, industrial, agricultural, or other man-induced non-thermal components of discharges which, alone or in combination with other components of discharges (whether thermal or non-thermal) are acutely toxic; or are present in concen- trations which are carcinogenic, muta- genic, or teratogenic to human beings or to significant locally occurring, wildlife or aquatic species; or pose a serious dan- ger to the public health, safety, or wel- fare. General criteria for toxic substances (applied to all surface waters except within zones of mixing): substances in concentrations which injure, are chroni- cally toxic to, or produce adverse physio- logical or behavioral response in humans, animals, or plants - none shall be present. Not specified Toxic substances narrative: No material or substance in such concentration that, Designated Stream Use All All Potable water supplies shellfish propagation (sur- face waters); recreation, propagation and manage- ment of fish and wildlife (marine waters) Recreation, propagation and management of fish and wildlife (fresh waters) All except above uses All All All Drinking water supplies -7- ------- State Criteria Value in mg/1 Designated Stream Use Georgia (con't) Hawaii Idaho 10 after treatment, would exceed the requirements of the Environmental Pro- tection Division and the latest edition of the Federal Drinking Water Standards. Toxic wastes narrative: None in concen- trations that would harm man, fish and game or other beneficial aquatic life. Toxic substance narrative: None in con- centrations that would prevent fish survival. Toxic substances narrative: Free from toxic substances discharged from munici- palities, industries or other sources in amounts, concentrations or combinations which are harmful to humans, animals or aquatic life. Not specified Toxic substances narrative: All waters shall be free of substances attributable to domestic, industrial, or other controllable sources as follows: toxic substances at levels or combinations sufficient to be toxic or harmful to human, animal, plant or aquatic life or in amounts sufficient to interfere with any beneficial use of the water. As a minimum, evaluation by use of a 96-hour bioassay described in the most recent edition of Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Waste- water shall be conducted. Survival of test organisms shall not be less than that in controls which utilize appropriate experi- mental water. Not specified 0.05 The following general water quality stan- dards will apply to waters of the State, both surface and underground, in addition to the water quality standards set forth for specifically classified waters. Manual Recreation; fishing, propa- gation of fish, shellfish, game and other aquatic life Agricultural: industrial; navigation All All All All Domestic Water Supplies -8- ------- State Idaho (con't) Illinois11 Indiana 12 Criteria Value in mg/1 Sections 1-2200.04 —1-2200.06 will, how- ever, apply only to surface waters. As a result of man-caused point or nonpoint source discharge, waters of the State must not contain: (1-30-80) .01 Hazardous Materials. Hazardous materials (see Manual Section 1-2003.17) in concentrations found to be of public health significance or to adversely affect designated or protected beneficial uses. (1-30-80) .02 Deleterious Materials: Deleterious materials (see Manual Section 1-2003.06) in concentrations that impair designated or protected beneficial uses without being hazardous. (1-30-80) 0.2 Waters shall meet the following standard at any point at which water is withdrawn: water shall be of such quality that with treatment consisting of coagulation, sedi- mantation, filtration, storage and chlori- nation, or other equivalent treatment pro- cesses, the treated water shall meet in all respects 5.0 (Treated) 1.0 Toxic substances narrative: Freedom from matter in concentrations or combi- nations toxic to human, animal, plant or aquatic life of other than national origin. Any substance toxic to aquatic life shall not exceed 0.1 of the 96-hour TLm for native fish or essential fish food organisms. Not Specified Designated Stream Use All Public and food processing water supply Secondary contact and indigenous aquatic life AU All -9- ------- State Indiana (con't) Iowa 13 Criteria Value in mg/1 Toxic substances narrative: free from sub stances attributable to municipal, indus- trial, agricultural, and other land use practices or other discharges which are in amounts sufficient to be toxic to humans, animals, aquatic life or plants. As a guideline, toxic substances should be li- mited to the 96-hour median lethal con- centration (LC50) for biota significant to the indigenous aquatic community. Toxic substances narrative: shall not ex- ceed 0.1 of the 96-hour median lethal concentration for important indigenous aquatic species. More stringent applica- tion factors shall be used when justified. Concentrations of organic contaminants which can be demonstrated to be persis- tent, to have a tendency to bioconcen- trate in the aquatic biota, and are likely to be toxic on the basis of available scientific evidence, shall be limited as determined by the Board. Toxic substances narrative: shall not be present after conventional treatment in such levels as to prevent meeting the Drinking Water Standards adopted by the Indiana State Board of Health or by the Indiana Environmental Management Board. 0.02 1.0 Toxic substances narrative: All waters, at all times, at all places shall be free from substances attributable to wastewater discharges or agricultural practices in concentrations or combinations which are toxic or harmful to human, animal, or plant life. Designated Stream Use AU Aquatic life; fish Potable supply Wildlife, fish, aquatic and semiaquatic life, secondary recreation Potable water supply AU -10- ------- State Criteria Value in mg/1 Designated Stream Use Iowa (con't) Kansas 14 Kentucky 15 Louisiana 16 Toxic substances narrative: all sub- stances toxic or detrimental to aquatic life shall be limited to non-toxic or non- detrimental concentrations in surface waters. Toxic substances narrative: all substances toxic to humans shall be limited to non- toxic concentrations. Not specified General criteria: the individual and cumulative effect of waste discharges to waters shall be guided by both the pri- mary and secondary drinking water regu- lations (40 CFR 141) and EPA criteria for water quality. Pollutional substances contributed by man-made sources shall be controlled so that all waters are free from public health hazards or nuisance conditions at all times. Toxic substances narrative: Toxic sub- stances or toxic synergistic effects of substances from man-made sources shall be limited to concentrations in the re- ceiving water that will not be harmful to animal, plant or aquatic life. 1.0 Surface waters shall not be aesthetically or otherwise degraded by substances that injure, be toxic to or produce adverse physiological or behavioral responses in humans, fish, shellfish, and aquatic life. The allowable instream concentration of toxic substances, including pesticides, shall not exceed 0.01 of the 96-hour median lethal concentration cn or 0.1 of the 96-hour LC 5Q for noncumulative and nonpersistent toxic materials using a representative indigenous aquatic organism. Not specified Primary contact; wildlife, fish, aquatic and semi- aquatic life and secondary contact Potable water supply All AU All Domestic water supply AU Warmwater aquatic habitat All -11- ------- State Louisiana (con't) Maine 17 Maryland 18 Massachusetts 19 Criteria Value in mg/1 Toxic substances narrative: free from such concentrations of substances attri- butable to waste water or other dis- charges sufficient to injure or are toxic or produce adverse physiological response in humans, animals, fish, shellfish, wildlife, or plants. Shall not be present in quantities that alone or in combination will be toxic to animal or plant life. In all cases the level shall not exceed the TLm 96/10. Bioassay techniques will be used in evaluating toxi- city utilizing methods and species of test organisms suitable to the purpose at hand. Toxic substances shall not exceed the levels established by the USPHS drinking water standards latest edition. Not Specified Toxic substances narrative: no waste sub- stances containing chemical constituents which would be harmful to humans, ani- mal or aquatic life. Not specified Toxic substances narrative: at all times free from toxic substances attributable to sewage, industrial waste, or other waste in concentrations or combinations which are harmful to human, animal, plant or aquatic life. Not specified Toxic substances narrative: free from pollutants in concentrations or combina- tions that are toxic to humans or aquatic life. For each class, the most sensitive benefi- cial uses are identified and minimum cri- teria for water quality in the water column are established. The minimum criteria in Reg. 3.4 have been developed by applying the criteria contained in the Designated Stream Use All Public water supply All All All All All All -12- ------- State Massachusetts (con't) Michigan 20 Criteria Value in mg/1 EPA publication Quality Criteria for Water (EPA-440/9-76-023) to account for local conditions including, but not limited to: (a) The characteristics of the biological community (b) Temperature, weather and flow characteristics, and (c) Synergistic and antagonistic effects of combinations of pollutants. The Division will use the EPA publication entitled Quality Criteria for Water, EPA-440/9-76-023 as guidance in establi- shing case-by-case discharge limits for pollutants not specifically listed in these standards but included under the heading "Other Constituents" in Regulation 3.4, for identifying bioassay application factors and for interpretations of narra- tive criteria. Where the minimum cri- teria specifically listed by a Division in this part differ from those contained in the federal criteria, the provisions of the specifically listed criteria in these stan- dards shall apply. Not Specified. Toxic substances narrative: (1) toxicity of undefined toxic substances not included in (2) and (3) below shall be determined by development of 96-hour TLm's or other appropriate effect end points obtained by continuous-flow or in situ bioassays using suitable test organisms. Shall not exceed safe concentrations as determined by applying an application factor, based on knowledge of behavior of toxic substances and organisms to be protected, to the TLm or other appropriate effect end point. (2) defined toxic substances shall be limited by application of recommenda- tions contained in the chapter on Fresh- Designated Stream Use All All All -13- ------- State Criteria Value in mg/1 Designated Stream Use Michigan (con't) Minnesota 21 Mississippi .22 Missouri water Organisms, Report of the NTAC to Secretary of the Interior, WQC, 1968, or by application of any toxic effluent stan- dard, limitation or prohibition promul- gated by EPA pursuant to section 307(a) of PL92-500, whichever is more restric- tive. (3) shall not exceed the permissible inor- ganic chemicals criteria for raw public water supply in Report of the NTAC to Secretary of the Interior, WQC, 1968. 1.0 0.01 or 0.1 x 96 TLm 96-hour TLm for indigenous fish and fish food organisms should not be exceeded at any point in the mixing zone. Toxic substances narrative: none at le- vels acutely toxic to humans or other animals or plant life. Toxic substances narrative: none at levels harmful either directly or indirectly. Not specified Toxic substances narrative: free from substances attributable to municipal, in- dustrial, agricultural or other discharges in concentrations or combinations which are toxic to humans, animal or other aquatic life. Toxic substances narrative: the concen- tration of toxic pollutants shall not ex- ceed 0.1 of the 96-hour TLm based on available data. 0.02; or 0.1 of 96-hour LC50 concentration of sensitive aquatic resident species 0.5 Public water supply Domestic (Classes A, B, and C); Fisheries and recreation (All classes) AU AU Agriculture and wildlife (Class B) AU AU Shellfish Harvesting Recreation, fish and wildlife. Aquatic life Livestock, wildlife watering -14- ------- State Missouri (con't) Montana 23 Criteria Value in mg/1 1.0 All waters, at all times shall be free from substances or conditions that have a harmful effect on human, animal, or aquatic life. Not completely specified 90 ug/1 (total); 30 ug/1 (dissolved) average daily concentration; 180 ug/1 (total); 40 ug/1 (dissolved) Maximum instantaneous concentration 50 ug/1 (total); 30 ug/1 (dissolved) average daily concentration; 90 ug/1 (total); 30 ug/1 (dissolved) maximum instantaneous concentration Toxic substances narrative: free from substances attributable to municipal, in- dustrial, agricultural practices or other discharges that will create concentrations or combinations of materials which are toxic to human, animal, plant or aquatic life. Toxic substances narrative: no increases above naturally occuring concentrations are allowed. Toxic substances narrative: concentra- tions of toxic substances after treatment for domestic use are not to exceed re- commended limits in latest EPA drinking water standards; maximum allowable con- centrations are to be less than acute or chronic problem levels as revealed by bioassay or other methods. Concentrations of toxic or other delete- rious substances, pesticides and organic and inorganic materials including heavy metals, are not to exceed levels known or demonstrated to be of public health signi- ficance; also maximum allowable concen- Designated Stream Use Drinking water supply All Metal limits for the Clark Fork River (mainstem) from the confluence of Warm Springs Creek to the confluence with Cotton- wood Creek Metal limits for Clark'Fork River (mainstem from the confluence of Cottonwood Creek to the Idaho State line All Water supply (Class A-Closed) Water supply (classes A-Open-D.,, B-D.,, B-D« Fish, aquatic life, wildlife, agriculture, industrial, recrea- tion in and on the water (classes C-Dr C-D2) -15- ------- State Criteria Value in mg/1 Designated Stream Use Montana (con't) Nebraska 24 Nevada 25 trations are to be less than acute or chronic problem levels as revealed by bioassay or other methods. Toxic substances narrative: Concentra- tions of toxic or deleterious substances, pesticides and organic and inorganic materials including heavy metals, are to be less than those demonstrated to be deleterious to livestock or plants or their subsequent consumption by humans or to adversely affect other indicated uses. Not specified Toxic substances narrative: none alone or in combination with other substances or wastes in concentrations rendering the receiving water unsafe or unsuitable for the assigned beneficial uses. Not specified Toxic substances narrative: free from toxic substances attributable to domestic or industrial waste or other controllable sources at levels or combinations suffi- cient to be toxic to human, animal, plant or aquatic life. The presence of toxic materials in a water shall be evaluated by use of a 96-hour bioassay. Survival of test organisms shall not be less than that in control tests which utilize appropriate control water. Failure to determine pre- sence of toxic materials by these methods shall not preclude determination of exces- sive levels of toxic materials on the basis of other criteria or methods. No wastes from municipal or industrial or other con- trollable sources containing arsenic, bari urn, boron, cadmium, chromium, cyanide, fluoride, lead selenium, silver, copper and zinc that are reasonably amenable to treatment or control will be discharged untreated or uncontrolled into the waters of Nevada. In addition, the limits for concentrations of the chemical consti- tuents will provide water quality con- sistant with the mandatory requirements of the 1962 Public Health Service Drinking Water Standards. Agricultural and industrial (other than food processing) All All All All -16- ------- State Nevada (con't) Criteria Value in mg/1 None (zero) Toxic substances narrative: only such amounts as will not render receiving wa- ters injurious to fish or wildlife. Toxic substances narrative: only such amounts as will not render receiving wa- ters injurious to fish and wildlife. Toxic substances narrative: only such amounts as will not impair receiving wa- ters for uses of this class. .26 New Hampshire Not specified Toxic substances narrative: shall be free from chemicals inimical to fish life or the maintenance of fish life Toxic substances narrative: no poten- tially toxic substances unless naturally occurring. Toxic substances narrative: no poten- tially toxic substances in toxic concen- trations or combinations. Bioassay procedures and application factors used in establishing limits on toxic substances shall, as a minimum, be no less rigorous than the recommendations for bioassays and application factors con- tained in the National Technical Advisory Designated Stream Use Drinking water supply (with treatment by disin- fection only) suitable for aquatic life habitat, wild- life propagation, agricul- tural, recreation, boating, esthetics Drinking water supply (with treatment by disin- fection and filtration only), agricultural, aquatic life and wildlife propagation, recreation, industrial and esthetics Drinking water supply (following complete treat- ment), agricultural, aqua- tic life, wildlife propa- gation, recreation, and industrial Boating and esthetics, aquatic life, agricultural and industrial (except for food processing purposes) All Fish life or the mainten- ance of fish life Water supply All except water supply -17- ------- State Criteria Value in mg/1 Designated Stream Use New Hampshire (con't) New Jersey 27 Committee's report to the Secretary of the Interior on WATER QUALITY CRITERIA, April 1, 1968 or latest revi- sion thereof. Not specified Toxic substances narrative: shall not ex- ceed l/20th of the TL50 value at 96 hours. Combinations of toxic substances will be based on the same principle. Toxic substances narrative: a concentra- tion of a persistent pesticide shall not exceed 1/100 of the TL50 at 96 hours as determined by appropriate bioassay. Toxic substances narrative: no man-made wastewater discharges. Toxic substances narrative: none, either alone or in combination with other sub- stances, in concentrations as to affect humans or be detrimental to the natural aquatic biota or to other designated uses. None which would cause drinking water standards to be exceeded after appro- priate treatment. Toxic substances narrative: none either alone or in combination with other sub- stances; in concentrations as to affect humans or be detrimental to the natural aquatic biota or to other designated uses. All All Maintenance of natural state quality (Class FW-1 waters designated to be set aside for posterity to re- present the natural aquatic environment and its asso- ciated biota) Public water supply (after treatment); propagation of natural biota; primary eon- t act recreati on; * i ndustri al and agricultural water sup- ply; shellfish harvesting; secondary contact recrea- tion; migration of anadro- mous fish; maintenance of wildlife; other reasonable uses Propagation of natural bio- ta; primary and secondary contact recreation; indus- trial and agricultural water supply; shellfish harvest- ing; migration of anadro- mous fish; maintenance of wildlife; other reasonable uses -18- ------- Bf« wtkfe * to te in tte MNKtie COM KwYflrfc*9 U All fresh waters only Toaie ntataaces narrative: none in All amounts ttet win be injurious to fiih life AeB&l^ or thtit «MM t^frir MKofthe AD ------- State North Carolina (con't) Criteria Value in mg/1 Toxic substances narrative: none (zero) Designated Stream Use Water supply for drinking, culinary or food processing purposes A-l North Dakota 31 Ohio32 0.05 0.1 Toxic substances narrative: free from substances attributable to municipal, industrial, or other discharges or agri- cultural practices in concentrations or combinations which are toxic or harmful to human, animal, plant or resident aqua- tic life. Mixing zones narrative: the 96-hour TLm for indigenous and/or resident fish and fish food organisms shall not be exceeded at any point in the mixing zone. 0.005-0.145 depending on water hardness (CaCO3) 0.005 0.005-0.145 depending on water hardness (CaC03) 0.005-0.145 depending on water hardness (CaCOq) case by case variations 1.0 0.5 0.005 0.1 x 96-hour LC50 0.005-0.145 depending on water hardness (CaCO3) All (Class I and IA) All Classes H and HI All All Warm water habitat Note A Exceptional warmwater habitat; coldwater habitat; Note A « Seasonal warmwater habitat; Note A Limited warmwater habitat; Note A Public water supply Note A Agricultural water supply; Note A All Lake Erie Note B All Ohio River uses All Lower Cuyahoga River uses -20- ------- State Ohio (con't) Criteria Value in mg/1 General narrative: free from substances resulting from human activities in con- centrations toxic or harmful to human, animal or aquatic life and/or are rapidly lethal in the mixing zone. Antidegradation policy: present ambient water quality will be maintained for all toxic substances. Designated Stream Use All All Oklahoma' 33 Toxic substances narrative: 0.01 times 96- hour TLm or LC50 for representative aquatic species. Persistent toxicants shall not exceed 0.01 times 96-hour TLm or LC50. TLm or LC50 shall be deter- mined by static or dynamic bioassays. At least 90 per cent of the volume of the mixing zone shall not exceed at any time the 24- to 96-hour TLm or LC50 for representative aquatic species. Note A: see exceptions under Ohio Admi- nistrative Code Regulations 3745-1-08- (C)(l) for certain stream segments. Note B: see exceptions under Ohio Administrative Code Regulations 3745-1- 11(C) for certain areas. 1.0 Toxic substances narrative: waters will not be toxic to humans, fish and wildlife, and other terrestrial and aquatic life, nor detrimental to any beneficial use inclu- ding continued ingestion by livestock or use for irrigation. Toxic substances shall not be present in quantities which allow significant bioaccumulation and/or bio- magnification in the food chain. Toxic substances narrative: toxic sub- stances not removable by ordinary water treatment techniques shall not exceed the limits in Section 4.1 of the Oklahoma Water Quality Standards. Warmwater habitat; excep- tional warmwater habitat; coldwater habitat; seasonal warmwater habitat; limit- ed warmwater habitat. All Lake Erie uses Public and private water supplies All Public and private water supplies -21- ------- State Oklahoma (con't) Oregon 34 Pennsylvania 35 Criteria Value in "ng/1 Toxic substances narrative: concentra- tions of nonpersistent toxic substances shall not exceed 0.1 of the 96-hour LC50 for the most sensitive indigenous species. Concentrations of persistent toxicants shall not exceed 0.05 of the 96-hour LC50, for the most sensitive indigenous species. Bioassay data for Pimephales pro mm el as (Fathead minnow) and/or Lepomis macrochirus (Bluegill) shall be used in determining compliance. Mixing zones narrative: shall not exceed the 96-hour TLm for the most sensitive indigenous species. General water quality standards applic- able to all waters except where super- seded by special water quality standards applicable to specifically designated waters. No wastes shall be discharged and no activities shall be conducted which either alone or in combination with other wastes or activities will cause toxic con- ditions that are deleterious to fish or other aquatic life or affect the potablity of drinking water. 0.005 Special water quality standard applicable to: Main stem Klammath River; Multnomah Channel; Main stem Williamette River; Main stem Columbia River from eastern Oregon-Washington border westward to Pacific Ocean; Main stem Grande Ronde River; Main stem Walla Walla River; Main stem Snake River in and adjacent to Oregon. 0.005 Special water quality standard applicable to Rouge River Basin; Umpqua River Basin; .vicKenzie River Basin; Santiam River Basin. 0.1 and/or 0.1 x 96-hour LC50 Toxic substances narrative: shall not be inimical or injurious to the designated water use. Designated Stream Use Aquatic life All All All All AU All -22- ------- State Rhode Island 36 Criteria Value in mg/1 Not Specified None in concentrations or combinations which would be harmful to human, animal or aquatic life or which would make the waters unsafe or unsuitable for fish or shellfish or their propagation, impair the palatability of same, or impair the waters for any other uses. None in concentrations on combinations which would be harmful to human, animal or aquatic life or which would make the waters unsafe or unsuitable for fish of shellfish or their propagation, or impair the water for any other usage assigned to this Class. None in concentrations or combinations which would be harmful to human, animal or aquatic life or which would make the waters unsafe or unsuitable for fish or shellfish or their propagation, or impair the water for any other usage assigned to this Class. Waters shall be free from chemical constitutents in concentrations or combi- nations which would be harmful to human, animal, or aquatic life for the appropriate most sensitive and governing water class use or unfavorably alter the biota. In areas where fisheries are the governing considerations and approved limits have not been established, bioassays shall be performed as required by the appropriate agencies. The latest edition of the federal publication Water Quality Criteria will be considered the interpretation and application of bioassay result. Bioassays shall be performed according to the latest edition of Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater (APHA). For public drinking water supplies, the limit prescribed by the United States Environmental Protection Agency will be used where not superseded by more strin- gent state requirements. Designated Stream Use All Class SA/SAm Class SB Class SC -23- ------- State 37 South Carolina South Dakota 38 Tennessee 39 Criteria Value in mg/1 Not specified Toxic substances narrative: none (zero). Toxic substances narrative: none in amounts exceeding limitations established and adopted by the Department of Health and Environmental Control. Toxic substances narrative: none alone or in combination with other substances or wastes in sufficient amounts to be inju- rious to edible fish or shellfish or the culture or propagation thereof. Toxic substances narrative: shall be free from toxic substances attributable to sewage, industrial waste, or other waste in concentrations or combinations which are harmful to human, animal, plant or aquatic life. Not specified Concentrations of chemicals toxic to humans, animals, plants, or the most sensitive stage or form of aquatic life, greater than 0.1 times the median toler- ance limit for short residual compounds or 0.01 times the median tolerance limit for an accumulative substance or substances exhibiting a residual life exceeding thirty days in the receiving waters. Median tolerance limits shall be determined in accordance with section 34:04:02:06. Concentrations specified for toxic materials shall be based on daily averages, but the concentrations shall not exceed one hundred and twenty-five per cent of the value specified in this section at any time or at any point in the receiving water. The instream concentrations of toxic pollutants shall not exceed 1/10 of the 96- hour LC50 based upon available data using one or more of the most sensitive organ- Designated Stream Use AU Domestic and food pro- cessing; trout fishing; out- standing recreational . or ecological resources Direct water contact (swimming); domestic supply; propagation of fish; industrial; agricultural Shellfish harvesting; direct water contact (swimming); crabbing; commercial fish- ing; propagation of marine fauna and flora All AU AU Aquatic life. -24- ------- Criteria Value in mg/1 Designated Stream Use (eont) isms significant to aquatic community of the waters under consideration. Cumula- tive substance may be further limited on a case-by-case basis. Toxic substances narrative: No toxic sub- stances added that will produce toxic con- ditions that materially affect man or ani- mals; impair the safety of a conven- tionally treated water supply; affect the water for industrial processing, fish or aquatic life, man or animal, livestock and wildlife, navigation, irrigation. Not specified toxic substances narrative: the surface waters of the State shall be maintained so that they will not be toxic to man, fish and wildlife, and any other terrestrial and aquatic life. Toxic substances narrative: toxic mate- rials not removable by ordinary water treatment techniques shall not exceed USPHS Drinking Water Standards or those established by EPA pursuant to the Safe Drinking Water Act. For a general guide, with respect to fish toxicity, receiving waters outside mixing zones should not have a concentration of nonpersistent to- xic materials exceeding 0.1 of the 96-hour TLm, where the bioassay is made using fish indigenous to the receiving waters. For persistent toxicants, concentrations should not exceed 0.05 of the 96-hour TLm. All All Public drinking water supplies Utah 41 0.01 dissolved (disapproved by EPA, promul gation pending) 0.2 Toxic substances narrative: it shall be unlawful to discharge or place any waste or other substance in concentrations or combinations which produce undesirable physiological responses in desirable resi- dent fish, or other desirable aquatic life, as determined by bioassay or other tests. Aquatic life Agriculture AU -25- ------- State Vermont 42 Virginia Washington 44 Criteria Value in mg/1 Not Specified Wastes discharged to waters of the State shall contain no chemical or radiological constituents which would be inconsistent with the water uses associated with the assigned water class. Discharge of radioactive material to waters of the State shall not exceed the lowest practicable limits after utilization of the latest technological development and equipment for control of radioactive emissions. In no event shall the discharge of such materials exceed the limits established by the Agency of Human Services. There shall be no discharge of wastes containing any of the prohibited sub- stances set forth below in detectable amounts either to waters of the State or to a municipal wastewater collection and/or treatment facility except in those cases where a process water contains an incoming level of a prohibited substance due to natural or other causes. In such cases the concentration of the prohibited substance or substances in the actual wastes discharged shall not be increased. 0.05 0.1 x 96-hour LC50 Toxic substances narrative: free from toxic substances attributable to sewage, industrial waste, or other waste in con- centrations, amounts, or combinations which are inimical or harmful to human, animal, plant, or aquatic life. Not Specified Toxic substances narrative: toxic material concentrations shall be below those which adversely affect public health, and the natural aquatic environment. Designated Stream Use AH Public water supply (at raw water intake point). All AU All All uses for extraordinary (class AA) and lake class waters -26- ------- State Criteria Value in mg/1 Designated Stream Use Washington (con't) 45 West Virginia A C Wisconsin 47 Wyoming Toxic substances narrative: toxic mate- rial concentrations shall be below those which adversely affect public health, or which may cause acute or chronic toxic conditions to the aquatic biota. Deleterious concentrations of toxic, or other nonradioactive materials, shall be determined by the department in consi- deration of the "Quality Criteria for Water," published by EPA 1976, and as revised, as the authoritative source for criteria and/or other relevant informa- tion, if justified. Not specified Toxic substances narrative: not to exceed 0.1 of the 96-hour TLm. No sewage, industrial wastes or other wastes present in any of the waters of the State shall have concentrations of mate- rials poisonous to human, animal, or aqua- tic life. Not specified Toxic substances narrative: substances in concentrations or combinations which are toxic or harmful to humans shall not be present in amounts found to be of public health significance, nor which are acutely harmful to animal, plant or aquatic life. Toxic substances narrative: the intake water supply will by appropriate treat- ment and adequate safeguards meet the PHS Drinking Water Standards, 1962. Not specified Toxic substances narrative: none in con- centrations or combinations attributable to or influenced by the activities of man which would damage or impair the normal growth, function or reproduction of hu- man, animal, plant or aquatic life. Maxi- mum allowable concentrations shall be All uses for excellent (class A), good (class B), and fair (class C) waters All All All All All Public water supply All All -27- ------- State Wyoming (con't) Criteria Value in mg/1 based on latest edition of Quality Criteria for Water by EPA and/or more generally accepted scientific information. Designated Stream Use American Samoa Not Specified Free from substances or combinations thereof attributable to sewage, industrial wastes, or other wastes which may be toxic to humans, other animals, plants, and aquatic life. Substances of unknown toxicity; All efflu- ents containing foreign materials shall be considered harmful and not permissible until acceptable bioassay tests have shown otherwise. It is the obligation of the person producing the effluent to demonstrate that it is harmless, at the request of the Environmental Quality Commission. Compliance with Section VLB. of these Standards will be determined by use of indicator organisms, analysis of species diversity, population density, growth anomalies, bioassays of appropriate dura- tion or other appropriate methods as specified by the Environmental Quality Commission. The survival of aquatic life in surface waters shall not be less than that for the same water body in areas unaffected by sewage, industrial wastes or other activi- ties of man, or, when necessary, for other control water that is consistent with the requirements for "experimental water" as described in Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater (latest "edition). As a minimum, com- pliance with the objectives as stated in the previous sentence shall be evaluated with a 96-hour bioassay. In addition, effluent limits based upon acute bioassays of effluents will be pres- cribed where appropriate; additional AH All -28- ------- State Criteria Value in mg/1 Designated Stream Use American Samoa (con't) District of Columbia Guam Puerto Rico 49 numerical receiving water objectives for specific toxicants will be established as sufficient data become available; and source control of toxic substances will be encouraged. 96 hour LC50 x 0.1 1.0 Toxic substances narrative: The waters shall at all times be free from: toxic substances attributable to sewage, indus- trial waste, or other waste in concentra- tions or combinations which interfere di- rectly or indirectly with water uses, or which are harmful to human, animal, plant, or aquatic life. 0.01; or 0.01 x 96-hour LC50 1.0 In order to provide maximum protection for the propagation of fish and wildlife, concentrations of toxic substances shall not exceed levels calculated by multi- plying the application factors by the 96- hour LC50 values determined using the receiving water in question and the most sensitive species of aquatic organism affected. When the concentration based on the. 96- hour LC50 data exceeds the maximum numerical limits, the numerical limits shall constitute the criteria. The application factors and maximum numerical limits are derived from the NAS-NAE 1972 Report of the Committee on Water Quality Criteria. 0.05 0.04 Toxic substances narrative: shall not con- tain substances in concentrations or com- binations which are toxic or which pro- duce undesirable physiological responses Aquatic life Domestic Water Supply All All Drinking water supply All surface waters of the Territory except 2c All (coastal waters) All (surface waters) AU -29- ------- State Criteria Value in mg/1 Designated Stream Use Puerto Rico in human, fish or other animal life, and (con't) plants. When two or more toxic materials are present at the same time, the chronic effect of such combinations shall be taken into account and the applicable standard shall be determined by bioassay or other approved method. Trust Territory of Not specified All the Pacific Islands Free from substances or combinations All thereof attributable to sewage, industrial wastes, or other wastes toxic to humans, animals, plants and aquatic life. IT Virgin Islands AH surface waters shall be free of sub- AH stances attributable to municipal, indus- trial, or other discharges or wastes in concentrations or combinations which are toxic or which produce undesirable physiological responses in human, fish and other animal life, and plants. -30- ------- |