REPORT FOR CONSULTATION ON THE COMMONWEALTH OF PUERTO RICO AIR QUALITY CONTROL REGION U. S. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH, EDUCATION, AND WELFARE PUBLIC HEALTH SERVICE ------- REPORT FOR CONSULTATION ON THE COMMONWEALTH OF PUERTO RICO AIR QUALITY CONTROL REGION U. S. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH EDUCATION AND WELFARE PUBLIC HEALTH SERVICE National Air Pollution Control Administration May 1970 ------- TABLE OF CONTENTS Section I The Regional Approach to Air Quality Control and a Federal Proposal for the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico Preface Introduction The Regional Approach Designation of Air Quality Control Regions The Si ze of a Reg ion Procedure for Designation of Regions The Federal Propose I Secti on II Ana lysis and Propose I for the Commonwea Ith of Puerto Rico. Air Quality Control Region by the Department of Health of Puerto Rico, Environmental Health Services, Air Pollution Control Program Description of the Region Engineering Factors Evaluation Emission Inventory Meteorology Urban Factors Eva luation Population Industry Regional Arrangements Regional Planning The Proposed Reg ion Page 1 2 2 4 4 6 8 10 11 11 22 27 27 29 30 37 39 ------- SECTION I THE REGIONAL APPROACH TO AIR QUALITY CONTROL AND A FEDERAL PROPOSAL FOR THE COMK>NWEALTH OF PUERTO RICO ------- REPORT FOR CONSULTATION ON THE PUERTO RICO AIR QUALITY CONTROL REGION Pre fa ce The Secretary, Department of Health, Education, and Welfare is directed by the Clean Air Act, as amended, to designate air quality control regions prior to the adoption by the State (territory) of air quality standards and plans for the implementation of the standards. The establishment of airquality control regions has to this point been the result of Federally initiated action, specifying areas where regions should be desig- nated, and formally proposing for Consultation with State and local authorities, bound- aries for those regions. The Stat~ (territory) may upon their own initittive, recommend to the National Air Pollution Control Administration boundaries For air quality control regions. The Department of Health of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico has initiated a proposal for region boundaries under that pol icy. The boundary proposal is based upon a consideration of technical and non-technical factor related to the air pollution problem in an urban area. The recommendation for region boundaries should also consider all the relevant engineer- ing and urban factors. The Region boundaries proposed in the report reflect consideration of avail- able and pertinent data; however the boundaries remain subject to revision suggested by consultation between Federal and State {territory} authoritres. Forma I designation wi II be witheld pending the outcome of the meeting. This report is intended to serve as the starting point for the consultation. ------- - 2 - IN'TRODOCTION Air pollution, because of its direct relationship to people and their acti- vities, is an urban problem. Urban sprawls often cover thousands of square miles; they quite often include parts of more than one state and almost always are made up of se'le- ra I municipa lities. Air pollution, therefore, also becomes a regional problem, and the collaboration of several local governmental jurisdictions is prerequisite to the solution of the problem in any given area. Air quality control regions are meant to define the geographical extent of air pollution problems in different urban areas and the combina- tion of jurisdictions that must contribute to the solution in each. The regional approach set up by the clean Air Act is illustrated in Figure 1. Tbe approach involves a series of steps to be taken by Federal, State, and local govem- ments, beginning with the designation of regions, the publication of air quality criteria, and the publication of information on available control techniques by the Federal Govern- ment . Following the completion of these three steps, the Governors ()f the States affec- ted by a region must file with the Secretary within 90 days a letter of intent, indicating that the States will adopt within 180 days ambient air quality standards for the pollutants covered by the published criteria and control technology documents and adopt within an additional 180 days plans for the implementation, maintenance, and enforcement of those standards in the designated air quality control regions. The Federal legi~lation provides for a regional attack on air pollJtion a nd, at the same time, allows latitude in the form which regional efforts may take. While the Secretary reserves approva I authority, the States involved in a designated region assume the responsibility for developin~ standards and an implementation plan which in- eludes administrative procedures for abatement and control. ------- HEW DESIGNATES AI R QUALITY CONTROL REGIONS. HEW DEVELOPS AND PUBLISHES AI R QUALITY-cRITERIA BASED ON SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE OF AIR POLLUTION EFFECTS. HEW PREPARES AND PUBLISHES REPORTS ON AVAILABLE CONTROL TECHNIQUES STATES INDICATE THEIR INTENT TO SET STANDARDS. (PUBLIC HEARINGS) STATES SET AI R QUALITY STANDARDS FOR THE AIR QUALITY CONTROL REGIONS. STATES SUBMIT STANDARDS FOR HEW REVIEW. STATES ESTABLISH COMPREHENSIVE PLANS FOR IMPLEMENTING AIR QUALITY STANDARDS. \.0) I Figure 1 FLOW DIAGRAM FOR ACTION TO CONTROL AIR POLLUTION ON A REGIONAL BASIS, UNDER THE AIR QUALITY ACT. STATES SUBMIT IMPLEMENTATION PLANS FOR HEW REVIEW. STATES ACT-tO CONTROL AIR POLLUTION IN ACCORDANCE WITH AIR QUALITY STANDARDS. AND PLANS FOR IMPLEMENTATION. ------- - 4 - The basic objectives in the designation of an air quality control region is that it be self-contained, i.e. that the transfer.of air pollution out of or into a region is minimized. This objective recognizes the fact that an air quality control region cannot be delineated in a way to make it completely independent with respect to the air pollution problem. Because air pollutants can be carried long distances, the air over a region can be subjected occasionally or even frequently to trace amounts of pollution from other cities and individual sources located outside its boundaries. Under specific and episodic conditions such contributions can even reach signi ficant quantities. The problem of a boundary designation is further compounded in that urban areas generally do not end abruptly but are surrounded by activities that can contribute to the pollution of the urban area as well as be the recipients of its generated pollution. Consideration of all these possibilities would result in regions substantially larger than is practical or even necessary to get to the brunt of the problem. The primary question, therefore, becomes one of relative mognit.ude and frequency. The boundaries of regions, however, should encompass areas that contain sources that add significantly to the pollution load of the air as well as the areas that are significantly and continously affected by it. For this purpose, the'delineation of regional boundaries is based on evaluation of annual and seasonal air pollutant emissions and resultant ambient concentrations rather than those based on short-term and specific conditions. . The selection of regional boundaries should not be based solely on today's conditions and needs but, perhaps more importantly I should give consideration to future development and growth of the area. For this purpose, extensive consideration should be given to prescribed metropolitan plgns as well as the forecasted growth. Such con- siderations should result in the designation of regions that will contain the sources and receptors of regional air pollution for a number of years to come. This is not to say ------- - 5 - that,the regional boundaries should remain stationary and unchanged. Periodic review of boundaries is desirable, and changes in the boundary should be considered if condi- tions warrant. The delineation of region boundaries solely on the basis of source locations and distributional patterns of ambient air pollution would most likely result in regions that do not follow any existing governmental boundaries, are difficult to define, and, more importantly, extremely difficult it not impossible to administrate. It is for this purpose that existing juristictional entities are reviewed and wherein practical the boundary lines of a region should include that combination of whole jurisdictions that encompasses the problem area . There can be exceptions to this philosophy, however. The presence of overly large jurisdictions, marked topographical features (mountains), or notable differen- ces in development within a given jurisdiction may, in some cases, make it desirable to include only portions of some jurispictlo,ns. A region, then, will represent a balance between the various objectives discussed so far to the extent that any two of them lead to different conclusions. The strengh of some factors over others may lead to region boundaries which exclude some sour- ces of pollution that might affect the air quality of part or all of the nearby region under certain conditions. Even though the impact of such sources would probably be minimal, the implementation plan required under the Clean Air' Act for the region should provide a mechanism for the control of point sources that are located just beyond the region bounda ry . Such a provision would be consistent with the basic objective of provinding desirable air quality within an area being designated as an air quality control region. Information on current industrial, commercial, and residential land use, transportation system, and population density is of direct value in that it illustrates gene- rally the location of industry and people in an urban area. Furthennore, it is through ------- - 6 - an evaluation of estimated patterns of urbanization that the air quality control region can be designed to provide for future growth and expansion of the urban area. Figure 2 summarizes the the procedure used by the National Air Pollution Control Administration for designating air quality control regions. A preliminary delineation of the region is developed by bringing together two essentially separate studies--the "Evaluation of Engineering Factors, II and the II Eva luation of Urban Factors. II The study of "Engineering Factors" indicates the location of pollution sour- ces and the geographic extent of serious pollutant concentrations in the ambient air. Pollution sources are located by an inventory of emissions from automobiles, industrial activities, space heating, waste disposal, and other pollution generators. Pollution concentrations in the ambient air are estimated from air quality sampling data and from a theoretical diffusion model. 'Nhen it exists, air quality sampling data is more reliable than the theoretical diffusion model results since the data is directly recorded by pollu- tion measuring instrument3. Unfortunately, in many cases extensive air quality sampling data is available for only one or two pollutants. The study of "Urban Factors" encompasses all non-engineering considera- tions. It reviews existing governmental jurisdictions, current air pollution control pro- grams, present concentrations of population and industry, and expected patterns of urban growth. Other non-engineering factors are discussed when they are relevant. As a whole, the study of urban factors indicates how Jorge an air quality control region must be in order to encompass expected growth of pollution sources in the future. It also considers which group of governmental jurisdictions will most effectively administer a strong regional air quality controJ'program.' ------- ENGINEERING EVALUATION .. . EMISSIONS INVENTORY . TOPOGRAPHY . ~ETEOROLOGY . AIR QUALITY ANALYSIS EXISTING AIR QUALITY DATA DIFFUSION MODEL OUTPUT ~ Ir PRELIMINARY CONSULTATION FORMAL .. .. DELINEATION WITH STATE AND .. DESIGNATION BY I I OF REGIONS ... LOCAL OFFICIALS SECRETARY.HEW URBAN FACTORS EVALUATION ~ ~ . JURISDICTIONAL BOUNDARIES . URBAN.INDUSTRIAL CONCENTRATIONS . COOPERATIVE REGIONAL ARRANGEMENTS . PATTERNS AND RATES OF GROWTH - . EXISTING STATE AND LOCAL AIR POLLUTION CONTROL PROGRAMS & LEGISLATION Figure 2. FLOW DIAGRAM FOR THE DESIGNATION OF AIR QUALITY CONTROL REGIONS. ...., ------- - b - The conclusions of the engineering study are combined wi~h the results of the urban factors study to form the basis of an initial proposal for an air quality control region. As shown in Figure 2, the proposal is then submitted for consultation with State and local officials. After reviewing the suggestions raised during the con- sultation, the Secretary formally designates the region with a notice in the Federal Register and notifies the governors of the State affected by the designation. The body of this report contains a proposal for the boundaries of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico Air Quality Control Region and supporting studies on engineering and urban factors. The report itseif is intended to serve as the background document for the formal consultation with appropriate State and local authorities. THE FEDERAL PROPOSAL The National Air Pollution Control Administration has reviewed the proposal and supportive discussion prepared by the Department of Health of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico. NAPCA concurs with the findings of the Department and proposes an air quality control region consisting of the entire Commonwealth of Puerto Rico consisting of the following jurisdictions of the Commonwealth: Puerto Rico and surrounding islands; Vie~es and surrounding islands; and Culebras and surrounding islands. ------- c: - '" - The three objectives outlined earlier as factors considered for the size of a region are met by the proposed delineation. Since the entire jurisdictional area of Puerto Rico is proposed, all of the sources and receptors would be located in one region. It follows that all of the population, both at present and in the future would also be located within the proposed region. The third objective, that the region boundaries be compatible with unified and cooperative governmental administration, can be best met by including the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico in its entirety. Air pollution control activities for the island of Puerto Rico and all of its overseas territories are officially conducted under the preventive functions authorized by the Commonwealth to the Puerto Rico Department of Health. The proposed Region is considered to be one which will be capable of maintaining and, hopefully, improving the air quality of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico. ------- SECTION II ANALYSIS AND PROPOSAL FOR THE CO!M)NWEALTH OF PUERTO RICO AIR QUALITY CONTROL REGION COMMONWEALTH OF PUERTO RICO Department of Health Environmental Health Service Air Pollution Control Program San Juan, Puerto Rico May 1970 ------- - 10 - Description of the Region The commonwealth of Puerto Rico is an Island located (centered) at latitude 18015' and longitude 66030', approximately 1,600 miles southeast from New York and 1,059 miles east southeast from Miami, Florida. With a territorial extension of 3,434 square miles the Island is the most easterly and smaller of the Major Antilles. The territorial jurisdiction of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico includes three (3) other islands, i.e., Vieques (17 sq. miles), Mona (15 sq. miles), Cu1ebras (11 sq. miles) and some small barren islands. Puerto Rico is a hilly, tropical Island. The soil of the coastal plains are fertile and there are many lush valleys, but there are dry areas in the South which need irrigation. The climate is mild with a mean temperature of 76Op. A central mountain range extends from East to West with the highest elevation at Cerro Puntas (1338) meters). ------- - 1..1.. - ENGINEERING FACTORS EVALUATION The engineering evaluation for the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico area was based primarily on a study of topography, air pollutants emissions, meteorology and air quality levels. The air pollutant emissions data used was based on an emission inventory conducted in 1966. An updated emission inventory of the San Juan Metropolitan Area was conducted by the National Air Pollution Control Administration and is summarized in this report. Air quality levels were based on data produced by the five (5) air sampling stations (permanent) established in the Island by the National Air Surveillance Network (NAPCA) and operated by the Department of Health. Emission Inventory - Puerto Rico Department of Health The emission inventory performed by the Air Pollution Control Program 1966 and the one under realization was based on estimates rather than measured emissions. Approximately 2,400 air pollution potential sources were personally interviewed and an inventory questionnaire was filled. The emission estimate was calculated for five air pollutants, i.e., oxides of sulfur, oxides of nitrogen, hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide, and particulate matter. Sulfur oxides, total particulates and carbon monoxide are considered to indicate the general geographic extent of the overall air pollution problem. Sulfur oxides and nitrogen oxides emissions illustrate to a fair degree the contribution of fuel ------- - 12 - burning activities for stationary sources to the overall problem. Carbon monoxide emissions provide a good indication of the con- tribution of gasoline powered motor vehicles on the regional air pollution pattern. Particulate matter emissions represent the extent of refuse disposal, or incinerations, sugar cane field burning, and the impact of metallurgical and mineral products industries. Table 1 shows the results of the emission inventory. To make a better representation of the overall problem the emission estimates are calculated by towns and then added to form cores of emission areas which naturally correspond to urban concentrations. Some major pollution sources are established outside the core areas and will be identified accordingly. Emission sources are grouped in six general categories which repr«~sent the bulk of the emitters. These categories are industrial emissions, transportation, electrical power production, sugar mills, and refuse disposal. The industrial emissions are further subdivided into the emissions from fuel combustion and the manufacturing processes. Transportation emissions include the release of pollutants into the atmosphere from motor vehicles, aircraft and ships while at , . harbor. Sugar mills emissions include the estimated discharge of contaminants, from fuel combustibn (mostly bagasse) and the burning of sugar cane field contributes in a great degree to the emission estimate levels attributed to the s~gar mills category. ------- AIR POLLUTION ESTIMATE EMISSIONS FROM SELECTED SOURCES IN PUERTO RICO 1965-66 (tons/day) ~ Industries Fuel I Processes and Power Sugar Open-burning Region Combustion Operation Transportatio~2). Plants Mills (3) (Disposal) North 10.4 78.8 226.8 . 2262.6 157.6 . South 215.5 . 21.7 403.2 128.8 678.8 930.3 . Eas1- 5.1 2.2 252.0 339.4 292.5 West 3.0 4.3 226.8 1.3 452.5 162.7 - GI I N«theast 138.6 49.9 1411.2 188.9 37.7 77.2 T onv day 529.5 2520.0 319.0 3771.0 1 , 620.3 Tonvyear 148, 166 919,800 116,435 592,047 591,300 (1) Does Not include emissions from Union Carbide, Caribe Nitrogen and Puerto Rico Chemical Co. (2) Includes Motor Vehicles and ~essels on ports (information obtained from Public Works Dept. Vehicles Registration Report and the Statical Report of Ports Authority - 1966) . (3) Includes sugar cane field burning TABLE I ------- 1--- - l~ - Refuse disposal emissions include only the air pollution from the 71 open burning dumps operated throughout the Island. In- cinerators are being used more and more to dispose of household refuse, but they have not been included in the inventory yet due to their small contribution to the problem. Emission Inventory - National Air Pollution Control Administration The National Air Pollution Control Administration conducted an emission inventory within the Metropolitan San Juan Area. Based upon 1969 data, the San Juan survey included nine municipalities shown in Figure A. A complete report of this study will be issued by NAPCA in early sWIlIIle.r, 1970. The results of two important aspects of this study -- emission densities and emissions by various source categories -- are summarized in the following portion of this report. A grid coordinate system, shown in Figure A, was used to define the geographical distribution of air pollutant emissions. The grid coordinate system used was the Universal Transverse Mercator (UTM) System. Grid squares are 5 or 10 kilometers on a side, depending on the intensity of urban development in an area. The estimated emissions of each of the three pollutants (by grid zone) were expressed as average daily emissions in tons/sq. mile on an annual basis. Annual average emission densities were calculated by dividing the total quantity of pollutants emitted in each of the grid zones by the total land area of the zone. ------- SAN JUAN, PUERTO RICO, METROPOLITAN AREA z. J + r 72000 \ / ,7' ~~ " ./- , '-'" -"\J ' ~ ~ "'" ,~ fOA BAJA ,. .I 3. u. II J+ 3S" .. """ ... .. \ " LINA ' 1)64000 JP -to ., +1. .. $"1 S"z. $"3 s. ~r. 4' 4" r- --- - ~ f '---'"\ .. \ 1"' s? all I F11 ~o ,2- TOA \ ALTA, ~ ? ) ~ ~ ~ \ . ( \. RIO \ TRUJI L LO \, \ J 56000 \ "--;...--,,-,-,.,.., I' lAY AMON , GUAY I-'PIEDRAS, ALTO "I '-I v... I-' I-' l I-' \ v:> JLI-' I-' g ~ ~ ~ ~ g 'j. ~ ~ " I ~ 0 0) 0 , o (' (c j...'T'~ ....-=:'-/--:~-~ \A\ \ , I' 0 I 2 :) 4 5 10 , \. ,......... - -.......L- .. --- - ./ N SCALE OF HILES " ' '\.-/' I '.-J GRID COORDINATE SYSTEM FIGURE A. s-s .. ------- .'---. -16- .- -~~. Figure B shows the mean daily emission density of sulfur oxides, by study area grid zone. Highest densities are found in industrial areas surrounding San Juan Bay and in the northern portion of Guaynabo, averaging over one ton per square mile ~d:aily. Gr-id 27 has over one- half the total sulfur oxide emissions in the entire San Juan Metropolitan Area, with the m.ajor contributions by a. large point source located in the grid. Relatively high emission densities are found throughout the remainder of Catano, San Juan, and northern Rio Piedras municipalities. Figure C shows the mean daily emission density of particulates by study area grid zone. The highest densities are found in Grids 6 and 8, with point sources the major contributors. Relatively high densities were found in San Juan, northern Guaynabo and Bayamon, and in eastern Carolina municipalities. Figure D shows the mean daily emission density of carbon monoxide densities are highest in the more densely populated portions of the region. Over 85% of the carbon monoxide emissions were from transpor- tation sources and this aspect can be observed by the higher emission densities along the major traffic arteries out of San Juan -- Route 1 to the south, Route 2 to the West, and Routes 3 and 26 to the east. Table I-A summarizes the air pollutant emissions in the 9-municipality study area. About 98% of all sulfur oxide emissions are the result of fuel combustion, with over 82% of total area sulfur oxide emissions the result of fuel combustion in steam-electric power plants. Particulate emissions are relatively low in the area, with transportation sources ------- SAN JUAN, PUERTO RICO, METROPOLITAN AREA \ / .. ;r- . ~ ---i 4S". J . r /- .. , '-"" -"\J ,. .I c , ~ IS" lOA BAJA 3. u.. IS S+ .. "'" '1 UNA b .. r- ---. - , l..._~ , ., \ , so, S'1 so, ;> TOA , ALTAI \ ~ . I RIO . .., \..... -"",- ') IA Y AMON, GUA Y PIEDRAS I C' . - 'if' l-j l '\ I . ( \. ....L---__r-. ''\. (. \ ' J---~ ,-, 'J a....- - , '- ~) .) , (, 0 I 2 3 4 5 10 -; \ \ ~\ ,~ - -1- .. --. - ,/ HI SCALE OF HILES 2 " j ,,/ Sulfur Oxi~es, tons/mi -day D 0 - 0.10 mBI 0.20 - 1.00 ~ O. 10 - O. 20 FIGURE B. SULFUR OXIDE EMISSION DENSITY BY GRID, 1969 Over 1.00 S'$" I ..... " I \ ------- r-- --- - i' ~-'" , SAN JUAN, PUERTO RICO, METROPOLITAN AREA u. _/- ~ "'-'" - "\J " '"' S., F, ~O ,7-. ;> ~ TOA \, I ALTA I \ ~ )., ~ ( , RIO 'TRUJILLO \ '., '- --..,-.') IA YAMON, GUAY PIEDRAS, A LTO C' - - '1/ l-) l "'\ I ( \ ,,1-----/--\ ''\, (. ~ i ,>-'T',) ;-;;-; 1"1 ,~ ,-,~\ r' \. --' - -...i..- - --- - ./ N """., "'''' " ~ ''\./' I Particulates, tons/mi2-day '.-J D 0 - O. H1 ~ O. 20 - 1. 00 ~ 0.10 - 0.20 . Over 1.00 '4 .I ~ ~ ~ 3. , ~ .. ;r- S'S \ , FTGURE C. 'I" TOA BAJA .4 -'"' .. \ UNA b - )) ). '~ .:r . ., ., PARTICULATE EMISSION DENSITY BY GRID, 1969 ------- SAN JUAN, PUERTO RICO, METROPOLITAN AREA r- --- - " ./- - .. "'-"" - \J 14 .I 3. - """" ''\ UNA b , , ... " t ~ TOA \' f .41.1 U I ).. ~ I ' nUJI LLO '\ '"1 \.....----'-"""'v'1. j . A Y AMON l GUA Y l PIE DR AS I ALTO, ~ 7 r) '. .--1- -/-- \ . ~ i .~'T'J ;-,;; ,~'\.._~\ ~-\, \. ~ - --L- ' -- - ,/ N SCALE OF HILES " ), " /' I Carbon Monoxide, tons/mi2-day ".-J , 0 0 - O. 50 ~ 2 .00 - 5.00 ~ 0.50 - 2.00 FIGURE D. CARBON MONOXIDE EMISSION DENSITY BY GRID, 1969 Over 5.00 ~-~ , ~S' \ ------- -20- Su}~Y OF AIR POLLUTANT EMISSIONS IN . METROPOLITAN SAN JUAN, PUERTO RICO (TONS/YEAR) TABLE 1-A SOURCE CATEGORY SULFUR OXIDES PARTIC- ULATES CARBON MONOXIDE TRANSPORTATION Road Vehicles 502 899 83,792 Other 1,966 2,041 3,6276 Sub-Total 2,468 2,941 120,068 COMBUSTION OF FUELS Industry 11,814 722 63 Steam-Electric Plants 73,428 1,877 37 Residential 0 0 0 Connnercial & Institutional 1,000 124 12 Sub-Total 86,243 2,724 113 REFUSE DISPOSAL Incineration 0 0 0 Open Burning 98 1,577 8,381 Sub-Total 98 1,577 8,381 INDUSTRIAL PRO~ESS 183 395 13 , 681 GRAND TOTAL 88,994 7,639 142,244 ------- , , S" S? FlI ..... , ) ~ TOA I'" 0 n. ( ALTA I ", . \ ' ( \ RIO IUUJILLO'\ ~ \.... I ' '"l --..~r~\/'('IIAYAMON l \ PIEDR~ ALTO, ~ { (' t' ~ ---, ,5 - ......... - .../ - - ',- " , (. I (,....Y r. " ~ .~ ,...{ r) '- ./" - ~ ...""'-- - ,/ N SCALE OF MtLES ') .. \, /' I LEGEND ", -.: J + r ./ - .. '-" -"\J'" . ,. IS' ~ TOA C BAJA ., ~ . 3. U. :u 3+ 3S' Y / ~~ .. If,. 'U 47 r-- --- - ~ . 3. 40 ., .1. ... -...... ... \ LI~A b ... S1.. "'3 ... .~-~ S'S , \ FIGURE E. LOCATION OF MAJOR POINT SOURCES. ~ Steam-Electric Plant 1!1 Ai rpo rt . Industry o Commercial or Institutional . Federal Facility ------- -2'- contributing 38%, fuel combustion 36%, and refuse disposal 21%. As mentioned earlier, carbon monoxide emissions are primarily from transportation sources. The only other significant contribution to carbon monoxide emissions are industrial process losses. Meteorology The island of Puerto Rico is located in the eastern Caribbean; the region of the trade winds. This wind pattern is one of the most steady and persistent on the earth. The wind blows from easterly directions most of the time, and air motions from the west are rare. The prevailing wind direction over the Island is east-north-east. The wind is almost constantly from the ocean during daylight hours. Usually after sunset the wind shifts to the south or southeast, off the land. Radiational cooling frequently causes land wind at night, consequently, somewhat lower nighttime temperatures occur than would normally be experienced with sea breezes. This daily variation in the circulation pattern of surface winds is a contributing factor to the delightful climate of the Island. Figure 3 shows average wind roses for San Juan for the period 1955-60. Roses shows typical winter month (February), typical summer month (August) and on annual summation. (Figures 4 and 5). Puerto Rico is in the tropical hurricane region where the season for these storms begins June 1 and ends November 30. Several hurricanes affect this area every season, but weather records shows that only six of these storms have caused winds of hurricane intensity in the Island during the past 60 years. ------- - 7.3 - WIND ROSE FOR SAN JUAN International Airport Showing Speed and Direction Frequency for 1955-60 SPEED CLASSES P-3 ~I 8-12 13-18 19-24 N 4-7 r o 5 I iIIII.' 10 15 20 , . . PERCENT SCALE 25 I FIGURE 3 ------- - 24- WIND ROSE - SAN JUAN Internationa I Airport Direction Frequency Distribution 1955-60 TYPICAL WINTER MONTH [~.~ ~... o 5 10 N r 15 PERCENT SCALE FIGURE 4 20 - _J 25 ------- - 25- WIND ROSE - SAN JUAN International Airport Direction Frequency Distribution 1955-60 TYPICAL SUMMER MONTH f .... f'" : CALM .. 11 .3% .'1 l o 5 10 15 ":==J 20 25 PERCENT SCALE FIGURE 5 ------- -26 - The thermal stratification in the low levels over Puerto Rico is usually characterized as "conditionally unstable." An inversion is frequently observed near 6,000 feet, which is characteristic phenomena of the trade winds regime. In the surface layer, below the inversion, the air has a rather large moisture content. The air above the inversion is dry. The inversion provides an upper lid to convection. Nighttime radiation inversions at the surface are frequently observed in winter; they are less frequent in summer. A typical temperature profile at San Juan in winter shows a pronounced ground inversion extending to an altitude of about 400 feet. Such an inversion would normally disappear late morning or in the afternoon. ------- ~7- URBAN FACTORS EVALUATION Present population and population growth patterns are important: in the overall air pollution problem, since human activity is the ultiu~te cause of air pollution and humans are the ultimate victims. Industry is the most definite sample of human activity, thus its inclusion in this report is of prime importance. Existing govern- mental structures must also receive consideration since the Clean Air Act, as amended, specifically notes that regions must be based on jurisdictional boundaries. Only a combination of several juris- dictions or part thereof can provide a genuine regional approach to the overall problem. The following discussion of urban factors will present these considerations as they apply to the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico. Population The population of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico as of November, 1969 was 2,796,900 persons. The distribution of this population throughout the Island and its territories is illustrated in Figure 6. The figure above represents a population annual increase of 1.3% over the previous year. The influx of immigrants to the Island was the most important factor contributing to that increment. In 1967 and 1968 the immigration was an adverse factor due to the exodus of nativ~ to the United States. Also, in these two years the lowest population expansion was registered since 1960, due to the decreasing birth rate. This decrease is the result of a vast program of family p,lanning developed primarily at the large urban centers. ------- POPULATION DISTRIBUTION BY MUNICIPALITIES (1969) ~ 1 ADJUHTAS 2 AGUADA :3 AGUADILLA 1+ AGUAS BUENAS 5. AIBONITO b AAASCO 7 AREcmo B ARROY'O 9 BARCELONETA 10 BARRANQUITAS 11 BAVAWON 12 CABO ROJO 13 CAGUAS " 1If CAJ.IUY 15 CAROLINA 1~ CATANO 1 CAnv 1 CEIBA 19 CIALItS o La Mona 3 MUNICIPALITIES 20 CIDRA 21 COAMO 22 COMERIO 23 COROZAL 21+ CULEBRA 2.5 DORADO 20 FAJARDO 27 GliAr."lCA 28 Gt:AYAMA 29 jiJAYAr:ILLA .30 GUAVNABO 31 GURABO 32 HATJI.LO .33 HOR}.UGUEROS 34 HUIoIAC 1.0 35 ISABELl. .36 JAYUVA 37 JUANA DJAZ 38 JUNCOS 3~ LAJAS ;j. LARllis Ij. LAS MARIAS ~~ LAS PIEDRAS ""'LOIZA 1.j.I.j.~ LUQUILLO " Ml'NATI 't MARICAO 47 MAUNABO 4B MAVAGUEZ- 49 WOCA ~ WOROVIS 1 NAGUABO NARANJITO 5.3 OROCOVIS 54 PATILLAS 55 PEMUELAS 56 PONCE 57 QUEBRADILLAS FIGURE" 6 53 RINCON 59 RIO GRANDE 60 SABANA GRANDE 61 SALINAS 62 SAN GERMAN 63 SAN JUAN (C8Plt8I) 61+ SAN LORENZO 65 SAN SEBASTIAN 61i SANTA ISABEL 67 TOA ALTA 68 TOA BAJA !6& ~~~O ALTO 1 VEGAALTA VEOA BAJA VlEQUU VILLALBA 75 YABUCOA 76 VAUCO (.) I' "1\ ~24 to 11 . ." ~ . Cule ras I ..., CD ~ o' . .~; :qu.es Each Dot Represents 1,000 persons. J ------- -29~ Before 1965, two different rates of popu1a.tion growth were experienced. The first period, which covered from 1950 to 1960, was characterized by a very low population growth rate. The value of 0.63% annual increment was registered during that decade. This was mainly due to a high emigration rate for that per~od. The second period from 1960 to 1965 marked the highest population growth rate in Puerto Rico's history with a 2.5% for 1963 and 2.0% for 1964. The increment was mainly due to a low emigration rate and very low descent in birth rate for that period. In 1965, the emigration rate increased again, a tendency which continued until 1968, as the population growth rate kept decreasing. 1969 marks the year when, due to an increase of immigrants, the population growth rate has increased sharply. At present, the population distribution in the Island is 52% in the urban areas and the remaining 48% in rural zones. The urban figure shows an increment of 18% since 1960. Following the above tendency, it is expected that 53% of the population will reside in urban areas for 1970, and for 1980 this value should increase to 62.2%. This marked increasedin urban population (almost two-thirds of the total) would inevitably result in a sharp augmentation of the air pollution problem. Industry Until World War II, the Island's economy was primarily agricultural, depending heavily on such crops as sugar c~ne, tobacco, coffee, and citrous fruits. During the last two decades there has been a dramatic ------- -30- The system also includes one (1) gas turbine power plant on the West Coast and eight (8) small hydroelectric plants and numerous auxiliary jet engine power plants scattered throughout the Island. This program, together with the industrialization activities, calls for the establishment of a new stearn power plant in the southern portion of the Island. Regional Arrangements The Department of Health serves the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico including its overseas territories. The Department activities cover both preventive and curative functions. In many cases, the latter is conducted in coordination and collaboration with municipal governments. Air pollution control activities are conducted under the preventive functions of the Department. (See Figure 8) The Air Pbllution Control Program, officially supported by Act 157, has the responsibility to develop and implement a compre- hensive control program for the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico; develop air pollution control regulations to be enforced through a permit and registration system; develop and operate a complaint system as part of the enforcement activities; study and evaluate the air pollution potential and maintain surveillance over pollution levels as part of the air pollution emergency plan; prepare and administer Federal project grants; offer technical assistance to other governmental agencies, industry, and persons concerned with air pollution control; ------- -31- \ transition toward industrialization instrumented through an organized plan to provide incentives to attract mainland capital investment. The plan was a success and has resulted in the establishment of new factories and other businesses in the Island at an average rate of over one per day for the last two fiscal years. More than half of the new establishments will be located outside the San Juan Metropolitan Area. Ninety-three percent of the most important projects will be established in municipalities throughout the Island where unemployment has reached critical levels. The first phase of the industrialization program calls for the establishment of light and moderate factories. Textiles, clothing, food, rum and chemicals are some examples of the first industries assisted or promoted in the Island. The present phase of industrial- ization is aimed for the installation of heavy industry. These a,:tivities have resulted in the establishment of the three refineries, several petrochemicals, foundries, pharmaceuticals, etc...(Table 2). Table 3 gives an idea of the magnitude of industry development in terms of net income. Figure 7 shows a graphical representation of this, and Figure 8 shows the distribution of manufacturing establishments throughout the Island. Industrialization requires, among other things, great amounts of electrical power. The Government has developed an intense program of power production and distribution. At present, there are three(3) steam power plants, two on the North Coast and one in the South. ------- MANUFACTURING ESTABLISHMENTS AND MAJOR INDUSTRY GROUP IN PUERTO RICO 1969 Major Industry Health Districts Areas : Northeast : North : East South . West : Total . Food and kindred products 166 . 57 66 90 96 . 475 . . Tobacco manufacturers 9 : 13 27 6 2 57 Textile mill products 23 : 15 13 14 13 78 Apparel and related products 182 : 36 91 53 99 : 461 Papel and al I ied products 92 : 10 15 18 16 : 151 I Printing, publ ish ing & all ied industries w N Chemicals and allied products 70 7 6 12 12 : 107 Products of petroleum & coal 31 9 14 6 60 Rubber products leather and leather products 14 : 17 23 15 12 81 lumber 128 : 39 37 51 45 : 300 Furniture Stone, day and glass products 105 : 45 An 25 32 . 247 "tV . Fabricated metal products 162 : 15 39 25 25 : 266 Machinery 30 6 11 9 57 Transportation Equipment Table 2 ------- Cont. 2 Ma jor Industry Health Districts Areas Northeast North East South West . Total . ., Electrical machinery, equipment & suppli~s 58 9 25 5 6 103 Instruments and related products 12 9 3 4 29 Hotel (1) 43 2 3 5 6 59 Guest houses ( 1 ) 32 1 2 2 2 39 laundries, laundries services & cleaning 110 . 20 25 . 23 16 194 . & dyeing plants (2) . Hospitals (3) 43 . 20 25 : 29 21 138 . I W Quarry (4) w 27 6 11 : 28 10 82 Micellaneous manufacturing Industries 64 5 14 13 20 116 Totals 1,401 . 324 491 : 432 452 3, 100 . Puerto Rico Department of labor - 1968 Employment Estatistic Bureau (1) Economic Development Administration, Department of Tourism - Official List of Hotels and Guest Houses- Summer 70 (2) Information obtained from the Emission Inventory taken by the Air Pollution Control PrQgram, Dept. of Health - 1969-70 (3) Puerto Rico Department of Health - Registry of Hospitals and Nursing Homes 1969-70 (4) Puerto Rico Department of Publ ic Works - list of Permits Issued for the Extraction of Material from the Surface of the Earth - Private 1969 Table 2 ------- NET INCOME ORIGINATED BY INDUSTRIES ~ (in million dollars) Industrial Group 1966 1967 1968 1969 1. Food and Kindred products 25.0 29.6 35.9 41.8 2. Tobacco Manufacturers 26.0 27.9 32.4 32.3 Tobacco stemming 3.8 3.5 3.5 3.7 Cigars and Cigarettes 22.8 24.4 28.9 28.6 3. Textile Mill products 21.7 23.3 27.5 33.2 4. Apparel and Related products 65.8 103.2 122.9 151 .9 I v.> ~. 5. Lumber and wood products; 8.8 10.0 11.1 13.5 Furniture and Fixture, 6. Editorials and printings 1.6 2.0 2.8 3.6 7. Chemicals and Allied products 56.0 78.5 87.7 92.8 8. Stone, clay and glass products 22.5 23.5 26.2 27.7 9. Machinery and metal products 85.1 ::. 97.3 115.7 137.1 I I 10. Papel products 3.3 3.8 5.0 5.7 II. Steel products 26.9 35.5 44.3 48.9 I I 12. Other Manufacturing industries 53.6 58.5 62.3 80.8 Total 416.4 493.2 573.8 669.4 Table 3 ------- ,~-.-'-"""- ..~-.--.. .._- j' : . :-~~ _.~ :-:-'~1-~~-: ~-~ f ~.::F:;- :---:--;-- -~ ~_.~ ! . -.-.-. - ._..- -.- .--.-. --'--'.-. -~...---_.. ....~-- '--'--"-'- ";..'- .- ..---..,.... . .' , . . . '-r"-?--'-""''''''~~._;''._-_''" .- -...- '.. ..~..~_.._- - t.-......~ .. - .-.-. . " 'NE.T IN<:OME ~fROM MANUFACTUf{I~(3 E~TABLISHMENTS .,.,- ..._-'.'.' , . .. .1 n ....~_.:.-7.:-"'~~~-~-""::i~-~-~-.'; _. .. .- '-_.-.-_..-. : MillronsQr'[)oftar$~J ......: . -.-. ....":... --: "-'-""~""f~--:' . \. .:..:.'" . i.. . -:: 1.' .:. ~~.: l" -. :-- .~~~: j.-; . .... -.. h - -~ I ". I ; r- .-- r" .- i--'''''':i' f . \ i .. i f 1:. ~' . .. j I. i i . I I. I . [." i-- O' j !--.~" ~- -. I L-.:.__.:"-= ,.. --. -"".---.' . 'f-- . . '-..- .-,. - ., J:. I .. \ ,. !'.. , . , ., . ;. ---: ~-- '800C-c ... . '- .'........--.. --. --- . " h:_....-I-. - ~r "." ~_._<~- .., -.-. .- ...-! -. ..'--- ._--...-._--. , . - .. - - .;. - .-.. 'j 100 d"r :.... ::. i j . 1.. L - -.-----t-- -,.---.- --:--!'''-:--r-- \. ._.......n""'r- ..----- .... ., -:--- "~o:o ~-. or -~-;o ... ,. .. 0'0 --'r .L..-.:.:..-: '.."",,::.' ~~'~~:~-;'~-!:-:-"_O":h:-:- .i . ! . .' . --,--_O-~ .'..--- .-.r w.. .~' ...- - :600:. , ' -i... .'--"'_""_'0_"_- .-.--. .-". -- - .O~ O' - ...j~~-_.~+[L:f'~:=I._...~... '. : . ;' :::-..;~ ... ... :f::."::. -.1. 400.. ..---~. °r- '--.:-"-.-:';----- ., . 300 ';"----,. .~ .. -~. ~ :- -,'-. '200 , ., 100 o I,.. ~ --- ~_.. .-...1---... . :":...:::,. .. . . I :.....--.:--.-:- ---:.., .. --O_.-i-- .--..-.--. -..... .~ .. ---,.. '-'''''''-.- - ---. -. - .,~ '.'-----'-- . . ' .. ., .. --_4' ---_..--~-, --~. ..... -- --.---. . ..~~.._-,--_.O.-..._- -.---,-..-, - Figure 7 --. .-. ..- -.- - ..-- '-. i. . T-~':'''-'' .....-'.. i ! , 4_. _..........J , , I , ~ I W \.II w..:.f i ..', : :-j r-' .t-..~--:- i ------- DISTRIBUTION BY MUNICIPALITIES OF MANUFACTURING ESTABLISHMENTS IN PUERTO RICO (1968) tV 1 ADJUNTAS 20 .:2 AGUADA 21 .3 -: AGUADILLA 22 4 AGUAS BUENAS 23 5 AI..BONITO 24 6 ANASCO 25 7. AREcmo 20 SARROY'O 2 9 B\RCELONETA 26 1D BARRANQUITAS 29 11 BAY AMON .30 12 CABO ROJO .31 13 CAGUAS .32 14 CAMUY .33 15 CARO~INA .34 l~ ~~~o j~ 18 CEIBA 37 19 CIALES .38 Q 3 MUNICIPALITIES CWRA COMIO COMERIO COROZAL CULEDRA DORADO FAJARDO . GlIAf."JCA GL"AYAMA oJt'AY ANILLA GUAYNABO GURABO HATII.LO HORMIGUER05 HUWACAO ISABELl. JAVUYA JUANA DlAZ JUNCOS FIGURE 8 39 LAJAS qo LAR~S 41 LAS MARIAS 42 LAS PIEDRAS 4"1 LOIZA ~ LUQUILLO !fi M.ANATI 440 MARICAO 47 MAUNABO 4-8 MAYAGUEZ 49 MDCA ~o MDROVIS 1 NAGUABO 2 NARANJITO ~ OROCOVJS P ATJL LAS 5 PENUELAS b PONCE 57 QUEBRADILLAS ~24 .. fJ . Qi . . t..J Q\ U RINCON RIO GRANDE 6 SABANA GRANDE 1 SALINAS . 62 SAN GERMAN 63 SAN JUA." (C8Pitel) 64 SAN LORENZO 65 SAN SEBASTIAN 60 !ANT A ISABEL 67 TOA ALTA 68 TOA BAJA 69 TRUJILLO ALTO 70 UTUADO 71 VEGA ALTA 72 VEGA BAJA 7.3 VJEQUU 74 VILLALBA 75 VABUCOA 76 YAUCO ~ (.) Each Dot Represents one uabl ishment . ------- -37- develop and offer training courses; and collaborate with the Air Pollution Advisory Board in their activities. The program responsibilities are implemented through regional representative offices to expedite and economize the operations on a centralized basis. Air pollution control activities are conducted at loc&l levels in coordiration and with the collaboration of the respective Sanitation Office. The annual budget of the program including Federal funds is about $217,000. ReKional PlanninK The Planning Board of Puerto Rico is responsible for planning and coordinating the economic, social and physical development in the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico. In the execution of such respon- sibility the Board serves as an advisory body to the Governor and as a regulatory agency. The regulatory function is centered in the preparation and implementation of a Master Plan for the development of the Island resources. In conjunction with this function, the Board is responsible for developing and implementing rules, regulations and other measures to guarantee benefits from the community from this development. Based on the above objective, the Planning Board and the Department of Health combine their efforts to obtain better living conditions for the community. Regu1atory activities are conducted in close coordination through a building permit system where hopefully, most social activity are surveyed and sanctioned. ------- -3R- At present, the Planning Board has the intention to adopt performance ~Itandards for urban areas to help in the regulation of land use. Formalizing the zoning ordinances in such standards will translate the classical light, medium and heavy industrial uses into well defined, meaningful terms, dealing with environmental effects. Any performance standards set in the air pollution field by the Planning'Board would be in harmony with air quality and emission control standards adopted by the Department of Health, considering the jurisdiction of the latter over air pollution control matters. The performance standards. would in this capacity strengthen the control program by providing guidelines to the planning activities and to the building permit system operated by the Planning Board. The Department would absorb most of the technical decisions and all the field work to be conducted as part of its approval system and coordinate the control work to be conducted by the Planning Board through their performance standards. ------- -39- THE PROPOSED REGION Subject to the scheduled consultation, the Departmen~~ of Health of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico recommends that the Secretary, Department of Health, Education and Welfare designate the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico as an oir quality control region consisting of the following jurisdictions of the Commonwealth: Puerto Rico and surrounding islands Vieques and surrounding islands Culebras and surrounding islands As so proposed, the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico Air Quality Control Region would consist of the territoria I area encompassed by the outermost boundaries of the proposed jurisdictions. The proposed Region is shown in Figure 10. The proposed jurisdictions are shown in Figure 11 -. 13. Discussion of Propose I To be successful, an air quality control region should meet three basic con- ditions. First, its boundaries should encompass most pollution sources as well as most people and property affected by those sources. Second, the boundaries should encompass those locations where industrial and residential development will create significant air pollution problems in the future. Third, the boundaries should be chosen in a way which is compatible with and even fosters unified and cooperative governmental administration of the air resources throughout the reg ion. The proposed region of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico includes all of the pollution sources and population affected by those sources, and is governed exclusively by the government of the Commonwealth pf Puerto Rico. The Commonwealth provides ample area for expansion, both industria I and residentia I. Moreover, all expansion will ------- 00 ° (.U o 00 ° 0'1 I I -, 00' ° o o '" s:2na COMMONWEALTH OF PUERTO RICO . ..- I PUERTO RICO Sea Ie 1" = 67°00" 66°45 II 66°30" 660 15 .. ----.-- .. Figure 10 I 4:- o I .~ ~~as 13 mi. .~'> C:;eques I - n_-U ------- -41- be within the proposed boundaries of the region. The "Evaluation of Engineering Factors" discussed to some extent the first of the basic conditions, and the "Evaluation of Urban Factor", the second and third conditions. Numerous complaints received about air pollution problems and sampling and studies conducted in relation with them tend to demonstrate the existence of several polluted areas within the region. Generally, these areas are confined to the neighborhood of moderate or heavy pollution sources. The severity of the air pollution problem is related to the spread among pollution sources. At present, no major air pollution condition exists over the region. Climatological and macrometeorological conditions provide rather constant ventilation of the area assuring to some extent the impossibility that air pollution episodes could occur in the region. Nevertheless, micrometeorological conditions within the entire resion and the foregoing discussion tends to indicate that steps must be taken now to adopt and enforce air quality and emission standards, and establish an effective control program to confront the rapidly increasing menace of air pollution. ------- 1- 2- 3- 4- 5- 6- EPA Library -42- 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111 1111 T 12776 REFERENCES Compilation of Air Pollutant Emission Factors. USDHEW-PHS Publication No. 999-AP-42 Environmental Health Series NAPCA. Manua I ~r the Development of State Recommendations for Air Quality Control Regions. USDHEW-PHS Publication (NAPCA) Local Climatological Data. U.S. Department of Commerce, Weather Bureau, San Juan, Puerto Rico Isla Verde Airport (1955-60; 1967) Monthly Vital Statistics Report. Department of Health of Puerto Rico. Demographic Registry and Statistics Division (Nov. 1969) Economic Report to the Governor. Governor Office, Planning Board \)f Puerto Rico Social and Economic Analysis Bureau (1969) The 1970 World Almanac. Reader's Digest, M~xico ------- |