xvEPA
United States
Environmental Protection
Agency
Office of Research and
Development
Washington, DC 20460
EPA/600/R-98/011B
January 1998
Blind-B Performance
Evaluation Study
A Statistical Evaluation
of the October 21, 1997 Data
006EC898COV-011B
-------
Blind-B
Performance Evaluation Study
October 21, 1997
Environmental Protection Agency
National Exposure Research Laboratory
Environmental Sciences Division
Las Vegas, Nevada
-------
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
OFFICE OF RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT
NATIONAL EXPOSURE RESEARCH LABORATORY
ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES DIVISION-LAS VEGAS
P.O. BOX 93478
LAS VEGAS, NEVADA 89193-3478
(702/798-2100)
Dear Participant,
Enclosed are the results of the Environmental Sciences Division (ESD-LV)
Performance Evaluation Study for Blind-B; October 21, 1997.
The known value for each analysis was determined by gravimetric methods,
checked by chemical analyses performed by ESD-LV's Radiochemlstry Laboratory,
and compared to the participating laboratories' grand average.
The expected precision, determined by the known value, was taken from
Table 3. Laboratory Precision: One Standard Deviation Values and Control Limits
for Various Analyses", which is based on data accumulated over the years by the
Performance Evaluation Program, and can be found in the Environmental Radioactivity
Performance Evaluation Studies Program and Radioactive Standards Distribution
Program information brochure.
Please take a few minutes to review this report and the analytical data your
laboratory submitted to us. If there are any apparent discrepancies, please notify us
immediately.
We encourage you to make use of the computer-automated data-entry system
that has been in place for some time now. As the number of participants increases,
and it becomes unrealistic for us to receive results by mail or FAX, the computer
system will be our only avenue for accepting data.
If you have any questions or comments, please send a message via the data-entry
system or contact Stephen Pia at 702/798-2102 or Patricia Honsa at 702/798-2141.
Stephen Pia
Team Leader
RADQA Program
Enclosure
-------
NOTICE
This material has been funded wholly by
the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
It has been subjected to the Agency's review,
and has been approved for publication as
an EPA document.
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997 1/44
The following pages consist of separate sections for each of the nuclides in this study with four
parts per section. After the first, each part is separated from the next by a new page or n thick
horizontal bar. The first page of each section is a statistical summary for the nuclide and starts
with a statement of the known value, the control limits, and the warning limits.
The warning limits are placed at two normalized standard deviations above and below the
known value and the control limits are three normalized standard deviations above and below
the known value. If you keep control charts, these values will be useful for anticipating problems
with the accuracy of your analytical methods.
The coin shaped pie chart at the top of the summary page shows the fate of all the samples
sent out in number and percentage terms. The pie chart starts at the top and rotates clockwise.
The first sector represents those participants who submitted analytical results within both the
warning and control limits. The next sector represents those who are in the warning region but
not out of control. The third sector represents those who are out of control, but have passed
the outlier test. The fourth sector represents those who have failed the outlier test. The last
sector represents those participants who have failed to respond properly. This is the case if no
analytical results were returned, or less than three determinations were reported, or if the results
were received too late. The reeding on the edge of the coin is spaced at one percent intervals, and
the sector shading becomes darker as the data reliability decreases. Sectors with zero width are
not shown.
The table in the center shows a number of statistical quantities calculated from the submitted
data based on the mean and median values in relation to the known value, both before and after
outlier removal. The lower pie chart uses the same construction as the upper chart and shows
the distribution of properly submitted data in terms of deviation from the known value divided
into sectors representing one, two, three, and greater than three normalized standard deviations.
The second part is an alphabetical listing, in lab-code order, of submitted data and several
calculated quantities. An entry that is shaded has been rejected because of one of the reasons
listed above or failure of the outlier test. The fifth and sixth columns are a measure of laboratory
precision. The Range analysis is a normalized value that you may use to keep precision control
charts. The eighth and ninth columns are the differences from the mean of all non-outliers and
from the known value, respectively. If this value is between 2.0 and 3.0, your analytical process
precision is in the warning zone; if it exceeds 3.0 it is out of control. A tag symbol may appear in
the last column. Each page with tags has a symbol definition summary, at the bottom. If there is
no tag symbol, the data is within the control limits, but it may be in the warning zone.
The third part is a three-column listing of result average, tag symbol, and lab-code in average
order excluding those labs not responding properly. In this order, all outliers and out-of-control
results appear at the top or bottom of the list.
The last part is two bar chart displays showing frequency distributions of responding
participants. The first chart places the known value at the center and a bar at each 0.2 unit of
expected precision. The second chart places the mean of the reported measurements at the center
and a bar at each 0.2 unit of standard deviation. In both cases, a bar includes those results within
0.1 unit up to the maximum of six. Any results more than six units from the center value are
shown cumulatively by a shaded bar one past the sixth unit. If the central tendency of the known
value distribution falls away from the center, an error in accuracy is indicated. If the distribution
is broad, poor precision is indicated. The mean value distribution is similar but uses the average
and standard deviation of reported results as its basis.
-------
2/44 ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
The Range AnaIysis(R + SR) is calculated from the range, mean range and standard error of
the range values. The range is the difference between the maximum and minimum results for the
laboratory. The mean range is calculated by multiplying the expected precision by 1.693(for three
results). The standard error of the range is calculated by multiplying the mean range by 2.575(for
three results), subtracting the mean range from this product, and dividing the result by 3. If the
range is greater than the mean range, then the range analysis is calculated by subtracting the
mean range from the range, dividing the result by the standard error of the range and adding 1.
If the mean range is greater than or equal to the range, then the range analysis is calculated by
dividing the range by the mean range.
The normalized deviation of the mean from the grand average is calculated from the deviation
of the mean from the grand average and the standard error of the mean values. The deviation of
the mean from the grand average is calculated by subtracting the grand average from the
average of the laboratory's three results. The standard error of the mean is calculated by
dividing the expected precision by the square root of 3(the number of results). The normalized
deviation of the mean from the grand average is calculated by dividing the deviation of the mean
from the grand average by the standard error of the mean.
The normalized deviation of the mean from the known value is calculated from the deviation of
the mean from the known value and the standard error of the mean values. The deviation of the
mean from the known value is calculated by subtracting the known value from the average of the
laboratory's three results. The standard error of the mean is calculated by dividing the expected
precision by the square root of 3(the number of results). The normalized deviation of the mean
from the known value is calculated by dividing the deviation of the mean from the known value by
the standard error of the mean.
A complete explanation of the statistical calculations involved in the report may be found in
the Environmental Radioactivity Performance Evaluation Studies Program information brochure
[Draft Revision of EPA-600/4-81-004], available from Patricia Honsa, ESD-LV, 702/798-2141.
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
3/44
Gross Beta Statistical Summary 182 Participants
The known value of this nuclide is 143.4 pCi/1 with an expected precision of 21.5; the control limits
are 106.1 to 180.7; the warning regions are 106.1 to 118.5 and 168.3 to 180.7
43(23.6 %) Failed to respond .
6(3.3 %) Outliers '
5(2.7 %) Out of control '
but not an outlier
Statistic
; 115(63.2 %) Within all limits
Respondents
13(7.1 %) In warning zone
but within control
Non-outliers
Mean
Std. Dev.
Variance
%Coef. ofVar.
% deviation of mean from known value
Norm. dev. of mean from known value
Median
% deviation of median from known value
Norm. dev. of median from known value
136.09 Grand Avg 134.27
36.50 14.99
1332.02 224.56
26.82 11.16
-5.09 -6.36
-0.20 -0.61
134.63 134.63
-6.11 -6.11
-0.24 -0.59
11 (7.9 %) More than 3 norm. S.D. ซ,
13(9.4 %) Between 2 and 3 norm. S.D.'
.72(51.8 %) Within 1 norm. S.D.
of known value
1
43(30.9 %) Between 1 and 2 norm. S.D.
-------
4/44
ESD-LV
Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Gross Beta 1
Lab
A
AE
AF
AH
AJ
AK
AL
AP "
AR
AU
AW
AZ
BA
BB
BC
BG
BH
BK
BL
BM
BN
BO
BS
BW
C
CA
CC
CE
CJ
CO
CP
CS
CX
D
DB
DD
DE
DI
DO
DT
DZ
E
EB
EL
EO
Res. 1
150.1
113.8
138.4
138.4
118.3
137.2
134.5
,'"- *ป,'
145.3
121.4
129.4
133.0
144.9
135.2
124.6
-: ' -V ;,''>-
148.0
141.0
^i"-'! ~ '-''<*
134.2
113.1
151.8
143.2
135.9
162.6
f *"" ,
146.4
140.0
110.8
154.7
131.0
117.0
148.0
135.0
129.1
139.7
153.3
120.4
138.4
140.0
143.0
Res. 2
141.7
116.1
145.0
140.7
117.9
139.0
117.5
>'--' v '' '-5งKl-
134.5
125.6
130.5
134.0
147.4
133.0
126.6
^'^^"^--
148.4
141.0
I'lXf^^i:
136.9
108.7
137.8
143.0
136.7
159.4
, ~*'~ "'t'/A.''""
136.6
130.0
121.6
148.8
136.0
106.0
144.0
137.0
130.5
139.8
149.4
125.9
137.3
130.0
141.0
Res. 3
154.0
115.5
143.8
140.0
119.3
134.3
129.1
] ;-,<,,' <"*
138.0
125.8
131.6
136.0
136.5
131.2
125.2
H^V"'-"
146.2
139.0
&y& \%\
133.8
102.8
148.0
143.9
\ -.',ป .'
140.0
149.3
IIIM-V
131.7
140.0
124.3
141.3
127.0
107.0
145.0
138.0
128.5
139.9
152.7
125.0
138.6
110.0
143.0
= No data submitted
0 a
Insufficient
data
X 5
Exper.
Sigma
6.29
1.19
3.52
1.18
0.72
2.37
8.69
' '. v - , ;
5.51
2.48
1.10
1.53
5.71
2.00
1.03
' ,
1.17
1.15
J;! -/ ' ;;
1.69
5.17
7.24
0.47
*
2.17
6.94
x ,v^ f" v "
7.48
5.77
7.14
6.72
4.51
6.08
2.08
1.53
1.03
0.10
2.10
2.95
0.70
15.28
1.15
Rng anal Normalized deviation
(R + SR) Average (grand-avg) (known) Tae
0.338
0.063
0.181
0.063
0.038
0.129
0.467
!->> ./ / - / ,'
0.297
0.121
0.060
0.082
0.299
0.110
0.055
0.060
0.055
0.085
0.283
0.385
0.025
0.113
0.365
" 'V - /
0.404
0.275
0.371
0.368
0.247
0.302
0.110
0.082
0.055
0.005
0.107
0.151
0.036
0.824
0.055
148.60
115.13
142.40
139.70
118.50
136.83
_^J27.03__
- V>viป''> <-vsw'"^''^ป&
139.27
124.27
130.50
134.33
142.93
133.13
125.47
-:;V"-r;^
147.53
140.33
,r:^s?i-C^ilS-
134^97
108.20
145.87
143.37
v;. '^?. ?T^
137.53
157.10
-j;:;:^;^^^p
138.23
136.67
118.90
148.27
13L33
110.00
145.67
136.67
129.37
139.80
. - - \ '*''',
151.80
123.77
138.10
126.67
142.33
TAG SYMBOLS
Determined
to be an
outlier
1.15
-1.54
0.65.
0.44
-1.27
0.21
_:0.58_ _
'/'< \K?y,J''K, ';.!
0.40
-0.81
-0.30
0.00
0.70
-0.09
-0.71
l^^:Vr' : -
1.07
0.49
^K^g4f'fis
0.06
-2.10
0.93
^0.73 _
,i^v:;Wr "',;)!.
0.26
1.84
:f:l!fpi^
0.32
0.19
-1.24
1.13
-0.24
-1.96
0.92
0.19
-0.40
0.45
t * h s *' "' i
1.41
-0.85
0.31
-0.61
0.65
ft = Above
II = Below
0.42
-2.28
-0.08
-0.30
-2.01
-0.53
^1.32^
- "f- /TF*^' ."(ป< ' f-
-0.33
-1.54
-1.04
-0.73
-0.04
-0.83
-1.44
y-7v^r ^
0.33
-0.25
?t$l^iji$?
-0.68
-2.84
0.20
0.00
TT>> "' v
-0.47
1.10
-0.42
-0.54
-1.97
0.39
-0.97
-2.69
0.18
-0.54
-1.13
-0.29
','*
V'/' {>-!^
0.68
-1.58
-0.43
-1.35
-0.09
control limit
control limit
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Gross Beta
Lab Res. 1
Res. 2
Res. 3
\
5/44
Exper. Rng anal Normalized deviation
Sigma (R + SR) Average (grand-avg) (known) Tag \
v_v'*'/^"^:;^^^;;;':^;^r\ / ' _- ^ '--_'; :\^;V .f.r^^f^^^^?
"^r:. ป J.::-V,:vc> ys^^y ^ s$jf&.
149.0
142.7
112.9
150.0
141.0
$p>*j&$#ซ*?
143.0
131.4
127.0
152.3
137.6
( s^> ^ ^ <^AU$f"^>';\'W$. *s* ^v^. -.^ ซ '*^vv, **v^"$* **^'v
* ; *, > "'
130.0
r'.^nv"-'*"
-~vv^ - ~ .--,
^ , s - >" "*
121.1
SS^^Wg*^"
Jfc^f%;^
Ijxx^ - f ;> " ' <-x'4- -X
140.0
141.7
122.5
152.7
_JL35.8_?i
*>\ %x* \"" " ^ ^."!
"Tn^^ฐ^'^:^^^^^ฎ*?- ^-! '""< *
DJX- i ~ ~ > s \\- ,-- ;ฐ;ฐ V-; ' . 'i*-^.- v v-x * - ;\ ; ? \- -
I
,PL .
; ,ilT ' ',
^Li-* ^ ;*ฐ
tw
JE
JG r
JM
JN
JQ
JS
JX
JY
K
KE
KT
KX
L
LE
LF
LL
LR
LT
IMP
MF
MP
MT
MV
MY
NT
100.3
121.2_
r~> s "s -* * ^ - "*x w^
s ,- >'^,.^!'^^ tv^%x-s
,-.;-,: v--*>f->5 -
--.-, x\:, v-,>-> ~~ '*
135.4
,\'v, ~,K -\;*-" "K
136.0
124.6
196.5
143.5
126.0
107.9
14.1.5
157.0
155.0
122.9
151.1
140.0
159.5
129.0
121.5
46;0
169.0
118.5
107.0
124.3
130.1
v?;- "*-' x, -xV"^
~4S,0:'
170.0
106.2
110.5
137.3
128.6
- yv,- - - ซ .
V.V"-\ - ' -^"
\ -^ - -V- ' -
-^<" x'-
I32-0
145.0
125.1
179.5
136.8
122.0
115.9
142.2
168.0
156.0
119.3
136.0
140.0
146.7
140.0
127.9
; 46.0
170.0
-
i-
110.0
106.9
= No data submitted
data
x =
^ ^ * x
1.00
* v v" \ s *ป ^J- '
<- J, \V s *s* ," ^
\mie;;"
3.84
, !,;, >;
0.055
,"\\\-V;~ J
;;, i5-'''-'V,^
; ,,6j860 f
0.209
'f^W;<*^K-
130.00
j.T-^ X'-x^VSxx- ^"ipSs^
* S-'V 1" > '':v %;-~ SA-V^S
;7- /f-180ซ17?W-;?
117.63
SS^SS^^S33ISSf
nf'^%\ ^-^i^'!":i ^ % v
: -" \C^ v - ** "^ "ป^ l '"- v
4.58
6.26
7.20
1.46
2.64
'V7:;^;y;
;*;;^;-X;r-V
18.77
4.76
.. v ^ - " \ " "
; s ^ * \v "
X* " x-v;1 -
1.91
1 v"~*^ S ^WV\ j -.
"-,;,- " ,\^-~
4.58
1.21
16.50
3.39
3.51
4.15
1.07
5.57
1.00
1.89
7.58
0.00
6.40
6.66
5.86
0:00
0.58
6.30
2.05
^ ซ.v * *
/st\"x\2 V
0.247
0.310
0.387
0.074
0.143
^ ^ f '\ ^^ * O^^V ^""^v 'i "'
v^V X* V<-5.*s>^v- ^A. ^^V^ 7ft
144.00
138.60
120.80
151.67
138.13
^^T?o?T??ป'^?SSSSBfRi
,- \^^0^;;k- -^'A^,;s,>ซ6-5-.ซ,-f
1.031
0.245
\>x -" x ,
''H-ซWง
"<* ^ - C s X "* ^
<\l *ซ^Sซ v"s;
0.093
* % \\^**v\*
"-;-> -\,,/
0.247
0.063
0.907
0.184
0.192
0.220
0.058
0.302
0.055
0.099
0.415
0.000
0.352
0.330
0.321
0.000
0.027
0.338
0.099
1^,0;-%^^
"120.63"
126.63
J-'VV^I^AT^^^-
W^^-^S^^Wvfe^
^^V^*S^ ^j^^ ? ^i^ i^^..^
^ \xa~\; \vJ! li%*'St^*
134.20
\"X" **?>x * % w**sfis ^?f *ฅL**jvi*^?r''^j;
s v^^^^^s " 5^^X
141.00
124.17
179.83
140.43
i \ ^\^\
< ^ *"
122.33
112.53
142.43
162.00
155.00
121.43
143.93
140.00
153.07
132.33
121.87
'"'" -:%46;66:^
169.67
'^r* f^
"" , -. x, ^ ซ
111.57
108.13
TAG SYMBOLS
Determined
to be an
outlier
A* .-.Vs "*.*
5ป.-V^,vซ
-0.34
'vs xKs'i^sSx
J^\^W
~^4i9$*
-1.34
ปซซปT""<>ปf3ซES
^i-6ป08J
\ซJ&^^
^S-i.;^!!^5
0.78
0.35
-1.09
1.40
0.31
^^?Sf
:%^ v.-^
-1.10
-0.62
x-ysyVT^i^
i^sfe.. V'SKS't'i
^v5i"^V <\!f SซC.V<
"tSy" xcs^ii
-6.01
^^X1 ^s!^ ^>^'*s?wsi
^;bf^ซ'
0.54
-0.81
3.67
0.50
^ -.
-0.96
-1.75
0.66
2.23
1.67
-1.03
0.78
0.46
1.51
-0.16
-1.00
^:^7.id
2.85
V" C %
x
-1.83
-2.11
S^^^'^x'V^fjx^^lt^?
-1.08
^te^^&v^$$l?SiSIง>>^2&*l
~|f^"|V^^i^;|i%f^|
l|;^ซSi6ง4J'P^Il
-2.08
w, *V! *^ ^J-Xv,*^ "U %i *S ?"? ^. "^^N^W^^ ^
^tK"-^" ^^^^^^^ ป^o
0.05
-0.39
-1.82
. 0.67
-0.42
5^^5S5^fi*?S3B
ISM^^ifeCTW^SI
-1.83
-1.35
^v^!^ปปFm^M
^^^*^4^*^**^* s^?*^* VV?Js*ฅ
-0.74
* ^ \\ ^XS^^^,^^^'^1-'^^^^*^^'*?'
v>-',\: ~= V\^xl;iซ* l;>\ซ M
-0.19
-1.55
2.94
-0.24
\ - ป
-1.70
-2.49
-0.08
1.50
0.93
-1.77
0.04
-0.27
0.78
-0.89
-1.73
v, -WAV, v^^^'-'-v V-^'li-.':1''^ ^-5^^
v* "''u1' 7'***'"''" s ^V"" X""
2.12
% ซ s 's''v * "^ ' ' "*'
-,x-, ,-~'^
- \ปJC;
-2.56
-2.84
'
ft = Above control limit
& s* Below control limit }
-------
6/44
Gro08
Lab
NA
NH
NJ
NK
NO
O
OB
OF
**'
OMtป*
OS
- 03&V
OY
p\:3
PB
: pu ",:
PG
PM
PQ
PW
Q
QM
QP
QQ
QT
QU
QW
QX
QZ
RB
RD
RF
RG
RI
RK
DD
Jtr
RR
RU
RZ
S
sc
SD
SF
SG
SI
=
10.
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Beta
Res. 1
152.0
132.0
134.0
134.0
117.0
144.9
138.0
88.4
' ; "/ '-,-,'!:""Vi V? ป
.> fSyJ'-'&hp <*|t.
129.0
^';^??2^
115.8
133.0
V4i7^-;:?>
137.4
136.8
i^t;:C3i
\ JV;,,--V- T"-/f
145.8
141.3
134.7
142.8
123.4
128.0
133.0
157.8
128.0
146.0
133.1
-
152.0
156.5
166.0
129.8
151.0
126.0
139.0
150.0
103.0
125.0
Res. 2
155.0
136.0
133.0
132.0
123.0
144.4
128.3
90.9
~?f '**''' '" W*- ^"f
ซs~-t& >vv}*^llt^i
126.0
I^^llS
112.9
?*Pi|
136.2
'xiW$ฃ1c
127.4
140.7
:; '?;;;'-,: ri'vf-v
140.9
140.7
111.8
140.7
126.7
128.1
128.8
153.4
133.0
147.0
135.2
, -, ,- , > ,
155.0
155.0
'Tc-fc^
167.0
'"",'., ~-~
135.2
152.8
123.0
145.7
170.0
96.0
128.0
Res. 3
151.0
145.0
135.0
129.0
130.0
149.3
129.0
95.6
vfi'^^S;'-1"' '
^fsvfe'^ " -"
_ 129.0^
^Si^fe'^*
113.4
134.7
^4Sl,6
141.2
, ,,131.4_
CV"/V<-' tf^ti* XA">
^Kv^''*--"^
137.3
129.3
140.4
147.1
130.9
135.2
135.3
156.9
130.0
148.0
131.4
. ', ,',4>-ป <;- s
156.0
157.1
?', '-; '' '
166.0
125.4
151.2
121.0
142.6
170.0
105.0
122.0
No data submitted
Insufficient
data
x ;
^^^ .-
Exper. Rng anal
Sigma (R + SR) Average
2.08
6.66
1.00
2.52
6.51
2.70
5.41
3.66
'i--"% ,'ป' '' ' ,
>55>'""v --' - ,''"ป
^.^A-.73..,
Iv'-^v'"! ' -
1.55
i"^riSปV/
1.60
31.07
7.13
4.67
;S^.?'v^--- -r
' ^v-;'f^ ' '-
4.27
6.76
15.14
3.26
3.76
4.13
3.30
2.32
2.52
1.00
1.90
"' ,
2.08
1.08
0.58
4.91
0.99
2.52
3.35
11.55
4.73
3.00
0.110
0.357
0.055
0.137
0.357
0.135
0.266
0.198
/ > - ',>V'
;< ,, , ป > -,
0.082
,~ '-,-' c,-
0.080
"" ^k vUEku ""'
j \f*\fvfy j *
0.088
2.235
0.379
0.255
''"l'f*'A1|
'"- '*; ';
0.234
0.330
0.786
0.176
0.206
0.198
0.179
0.121
0.137
0.055
0.104
0.110
0.058
0.027
0,269
0.049
0.137
0.184
0.549
0.247
0.165
152.67
137.67
134.00
131.67
123.33
146.20
131.77
91.63
,,-*, ,^,,- s <*y _,ป;? <'
f*/. '*ซป"' ""' *y&**
1"_J^8.00^
c.,;"rr,.,\:;x^c
114.03
Upl^
134.63
461,6?
135.33
136.30^
;^*,$$'3ff^>ฃy^
141.33
137.10
128.97
143.53
127.00
130.43
132.37
156.03
130.33
147.00
133.23
^ s " >ll>'
154.33
156.20
:
166.33
130.13
151.67
123.33
142.43
163.33
101.33
125.00
TAG SYMBOLS
= Determined
to be an
outlier
=====
Normalized deviation
(grand-avg) (known) Tag
1.48
0.27
-0.02
-0.21
-0.88
0.96
-0.20
-3.44
- >- _ -^ ;--'T^;^ 'vs j^ ';
^>^,'A-*Kf,"^ ^;vsi?4
-0.51
^ฃ\^^^i
-1.63
WIX$f^
0.03
7 'SsJit; "-'
0.09
-ฐ'16 ซ-
^^'^l^-; J^V'l
0.57
0.23
-0.43
0.75
-0.59
-0.31
-0.15
1.75
-0.32
1.03
-0.08
:*"'*' Jf^-< : ป-'''. Tsv
1.62
1.77
',"-' -'->',''"'^ "
2.58
- ;"' '';"* - j'
-0.33
1.40
-0.88
0.66
2.34
-2.65
-0.75
0.75
-0.46
-0.76
-0.95
-1.62
0.23
-0.94
-4.17 JJ
?*r -f, .^ ?v '"^\ ". "
w^\. i'^^V^*^"-
-1.24
ซ*wjvwv.%^.vซv)^(wwjAVfcJ' ^v, A ซy
.jJ? v s f*i<^**'^* *
>V;'> -=^ *jv ซ^ _,
-2.37
spis^
-0.71
-0.65
,"flS *.
.^Oift'A^^*)*^
-0.17
-0.51
-1.16
0.01
-1.32
-1.04
-0.89
1.02
-1.05
0.29
^:ฐ.:8,,2WS^.~,
v '!*; ',: ^wjซ>mซ,s-!
0.88
1.03
W,MWV \ ' V^'^ '<,W-^S'-/JV^Y''";'^''
* .. ^ ""faf ''' ^ ;(**'% \
1.85
- ''" ''""' A!V*/V
-1.07
0.67
-1.62
-0.08
1.61
-3.39 Ji
-1.48
It s Above control limit
Ji = Below control limit Jj
^
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Gross Beta
Lab
SM
SN
SO
SR
ss
sx
sz
T
TD
' TLT
TN
TQ
>,!-
TY
U
UA
-.UBr"
UP
UQ
UY
VA
VC
VH
VI
VJ
VM
VO
VT
W
WE
WH
WO
WR
WW
X
XA
XC
XD
XF
XI
XJ
XK
XL
XM
=
0 B
Real
128.5
149.4
132.4
122.7
123.5
149.0
133.7
135.7
107.9
";,F?:!::^tP
106.5
118.0
11 ' s ' ^ s W* "-"
139.0
129.6
131.0
"V- VVi>-*v
142.5
137.0
126.8
172.5
117.4
129.0
125.0
158.5
135.0
132.0
143.1
125.0
132.4
135.9
128.4
' ,-
147,2
102.5
299.0
129.9
132.0
Res. 2 Res. 3
122.8
153.1
130.5
129.1
125.9
143.0
138.0
137.4
134.8
rfipv! :5
96.7 .
1
124.0
^ \" %%15.VV \. - . O N*
138.0
132.4
132.0
i'-^&rjit^ -'A
144.6
136.0
128.0
175.6
1-1 w,\ \ ,* s
/.'-xVvo". o
105.1
126.0
^_
117.0
152.1
137.0
144.0
133.0
122.0
132.3
136.5
133.1
,
155.5
102.7
292.0
127.8
132.0
119.6
143.3
127.4
115.8
130.5
140.0
133.3
139.6
119.2
^ ^ s ^ ^^v--.^
96.6
118.0
** S% " *** ' "t ' v
139.0
132.4
130.0
v>-y*' r;ฐ-
144.8
132.0
127.1
179.2
-> * "
%s ** > ""
97.1
122.0
128.0
144.5
135.0
141.0
141.8
116.0
133.0
133.6
127.5
,
149.8
108.9
286.0
125.7
134.0
No data submitted
Insufficient
data
X s
Exper. Rng anal
Sigma (R + SR)
4.51
4.95
2.52
6.65
3.56
4.58
2.61
1.95
... J2:6-L .
-. \ ฐ "" * V "' X 5
5.69
3.46;
* ^ ' - > - '1\'v
0.58
1.62
i.qo
- \-;.- '_> -'-\ -
1.27
2.65
0.62
3.35
v
10.23
3.51
5.69
7.01
1.15
6.24
5.49
4.58
0.38
1.53
3.01
4.25
3.64
6.51
2.10
1.15
0.245
0.269
0.137
0.365
0.192
0.247
0.129
0.107
^J).739_
?~STฃ
6.272
0.165
; *>. v, ^<^\>^>\
0.027
0.077
. . OJ?55_
v,vcc r: }
0.063
0.137
0.033
0.184
V ^'X"
- .r s; * ^ ^
0.558
0.192
0.302
0.385
0.055
0.330
0.277
0.247
0.019
0.080
0.154
0.228
0.176
0.357
0.115
0.055
Average
123.63
148.60
130.10
122.53
126.63
144.00
135.00
137.57
__120.63_
SSlPi^
99.93
,, ^l??-0^.
s \ % '^'^^^O^^V^
138.67
131.47
_ ^.ISLOO^
?-'-.^ : ซ'"tl|5:^
143.97
135.00
127.30
175.77
ซv-::7^3
.* "-1: -X\>S
106.53
125.67
<
123.33
151.70
135.67
139.00
139.30
121.00
132.57
135.33
129.67
150.83
104.70
292:33
127.80
132.67
TAG SYMBOLS
Determined
to be an
^^ - '.. '" i
outlier
^_ _^^- ^^^^^^
7/44 j
Normalized deviation
(grand-avg) (known) Tag
-0.86
1.15
-0.34
-0.95
-0.62
0.78
0.06
0.27
^_;1J.O__
^^f^t^-ifcC^iS-
".2.77""^" "
ij:1.15_m ^
i*ง^|5t\ij\V ^<^ Tf "^** ^'^l ^S^.
0.35
-0.23
w^-0.26__^
4^' ^'.. -;- Hฅ si/3f^
0.78
0.06
-0.56
_ ^_3.34 %
\A- '^^ ^V * ^S ^ ^ ^
-x\V-\v;-'-;''i'--, IU
-2.23
-0.69
* N > N
-0.88
1.40
0.11
0.38
0.40
-1.07
-0.14
0.09
-0.37
/
1.33
-2.38
1&73
-0.52
-0.13
IT == Above
-1.59
0.42
-1.07
-1.68
-1.35
0.05
-0.68
-0.47
-1.83 ^ _
i^Ipl^IISI
-3.50 U
^JSU -
^X^v ^Vftl^^^^^ix^^
-0.38
-0.96
^-1.00 ^^
!^งPi^^t$^
0.05
-0.68
-1.30
^2.61 ^
t'-i;^1*S
;,v;:>v -^-;"",ปVy
-2.97
-1.43
x - ,. , . > -^
-1.62
0.67
-0.62
-0.35
-0.33
-1.80
-0.87
-0.65
-1.11
, 't*'''
.^ ^* \
s N
0.60
., v.i
-3.12 li
12.00 x i
-1.26
-0.86
control limit
JJ. = Below control limit j
-------
8/44 ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Gross Beta
Lab Res. 1 Res. 2
XN JOp.O 96.4
Exper. Rng anal
Res. 3 Sigma (R + SR)
96.5 2.05 0.099
Normalized deviation
Average (grand-avg) (known) Tag
_ 97.63 _;2.95___ -3.69 _
ฃy>
Data sorted by Laboratory Average
Average Tag
29.13 x
45.00 x
51.33 x
91.63 H
97.63 U
99.93 U
101.33 U
104.70 U
106.53
108.13
108.20
110.00
111.57
112.53
114.03
115.13
117.63
118.50
118.90
120.00
120.63
120.63
120.80
121.00
121.43
121.87
122.33
122.53
123.33
123.33
123.33
123.63
123.77
124.17
124.27
125.00
125.47
125.67
126.63
126.63
= No data submitted
1 0 s Insufficient data
Lab
P
M
FN
OF
XN
TN
SG
XJ
VI
MY
BN
CX
MV
K
OY
AE
FL
AJ
CO
TQ
TD
I
HI
WO
L
LT
JY
SR
VO
SC
NO
SM
DZ
JN
AU
SI
BC
VJ
ss
m
Average Tag
126.67
127.00
127.03
127.30
127.80
128.00
128.97
129.37
129.67
130.00
130.10
130.13
130.33
130.43
130.50
131.00
131.33
131.47
131.67
131.77
132.33
132.37
132.57
132.67
133.13
133.23
134.00
134.20
134.33
134.63
134.97
135.00
13500
135.33
135.33
135.67
136.30
136.67
136.67
136.83
TAG SYMBOLS
x s Determined to be an
Lab
EB
QT
AL
UY
XL
OS
QP
DD
X
FE
SO
RZ
QZ
QU
AW
UA
CS
U
NK
OB
LR
QW
WR
XM
BB
RD
NJ
JE
AZ
PB
BM
UQ
SZ
WW
PG
W
PM
DB
CJ
AK
Average Tag
137.10
137.53
137.57
137.67
138.10
138.13
138.23
138.60
138.67
139.00
139.27
139.30
139.70
139.80
140.00
140.33
140.43
141.00
141.33
142.33
142.40
142,43
142.43
142.93
143.37
143.53
143.93
143.97
144.00
144.00
145.67
145.87
146.20
147.00
147.53
148.27
148.60
148.60
150.83
151.67
ft s Above control
outlier ^ = Below control
^^^^^^= =^==
Lab
QM
C
T
NH
E
HL
CE
GZ
TY
WE
AR
WH
AH
DE
LF
BK
JS
JM
Q
EO
AF
SD
KE
BA
BS
QQ
LE
UP
sx
GQ
D
BO
O
RB
BH
CP
SN
A
XF
S
limit
limit
^
-------
r - -S'
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997 9/44
Gross Beta
Average Tag
151.67
151.70
151.80
152.67
153.07
154.33
% responding labs
~
Dntn sorted by Laboratory Average
Lab Average Tag Lab Average Tag Lab
HK 155.00 KX 166.33 RR
VT 156.03 QX 169.67 MF
DT 156.20 RI 175.77 VA
NA 157.10 . CA 179.83 JQ
LL 162.00 KT 189.17 x FJ
RG 163.33 SF 292.33 x XK
451.67 x PD
Frequency distribution
ill I
m ....iBlllllllHlM . .
ฐ -'6 ' -4 -2 ' 6 ' +2 ' ^ +6
Normalized deviation of the mean from the known value
% responding labs Frequency distribution
10 --
M>l_.
-Illllllllll-l.. _
ฐ "-'6 . ' -4 ' -'2 ' 6 ' V2 ' A +6
Normalized deviation of the mean from the grand average
. s No data submitted TAG SYMBOLS ft s Above control limit
0 = Insufficient data x = Determined to be an outlier U- = Below control limit J
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
10/44
Strontium-8B Statistical Summary 182 Participants
The known value of this nuclide is 38.0 pCi/1 with an expected precision of 5.0; the control limits
are 27.3 to 44.7; the warning regions are 27.3 to 30.2 and 41.8 to 44.7
114(62.6 %) Failed to respond ,
2(1.1 %) Outliers
9(4.9 %) Out of control
but not an outlier
Statistic
,. 42(23.1 %) Within all limits
Respondents
15(8.2 %) In warning zone
but within control
Non-outliers
Mean
Std. Dev.
Variance
%Coef. ofVar.
% deviation of mean from known value
Norm. dev. of mean from known value
Median
% deviation of median from known value
Norm. dev. of median from known value
36.04
7.25
52.52
20.11
0.11
0.01
35.83
-0.46
-0.02
Grand Avg 35.30
5.91
34.98
16.76
-1.95
-0.12
35.67
-0.93
-0.06
13(19.1 %) Mora than 3 norm. S.D.
13(19.1 %) Between 2 and 3 norm. S.D.
25(36.8 %) Within 1 norm. S.D.
of known value
Between 1 and 2 norm. S.D.
-------
11/44
Strontium-89
Lab Res. 1
A
AE
AF
AH
AJ
AK
AL
AP
AR
AU
AW
AZ
BA
BB
BC
BO
BH
BK
BL
BM
BN
BO
B8
BW
C
CA
CC
GE
CJ
GO
CP
CS
CX
D
DB
DD
DE
DI
DO
DT
DZ
E
EB
EL
EO
=
L,
36.0
46.0
37.0
40.0
30.0
37.0
' -
'/' " '"^'
47.0
34.0
36.0
44.0
*'v"
27.0
.<'
29.0
28.0
40.0
-
36.0
36.0
29.0
-i, '
36.0
28.0
18.0
35.0
21.0
67.0
35.0
44.0
34.0
39.0
42.0
37.0
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Res. 2 Res. 3
37.0
45.0
38.0
' ' ," ":.'-
41.0
34.0
40.0
., ' ' - i ''' i-
'' ?~':~^*&
45.0
36.0
35.0
43.0
/''"'4'-?':ซ!'4i>4
28.0
/"" "' '-/-f; <%'
31.0
,:-,. - ;, "- -i >/.--{
33.0
40.0
37.0
34.0
30.0
>-.<^^x
35.0
;
28.0
18.0
24.0
27.0
64,0
36.0
46.0
34.0
38.0
35.0
34.0
.*.
36.0
45.0
39.0
39.0
34.0
37.0
43.0
36.0
36.0
44.0
,*': ''- v - -
30.0
C~fef'v'
26.0
.'*> \ - -
38.0
40.0
37.0
32.0
33.0
f" '<. * -. -j^
"V'- * > s " -
37.0
--. * ^ '
27.0
20.0
31.0
30.0
58.0
36.0
42.0
33.0
42.0
39.0
39.0
No data submitted
Insufficient
data
X 3
Exper. Rng anal
Sigma (R + SR)
0.58
0.58
1.00
; v, - ~'! . '
1.00
2.31
1.73
> "-_.
2.00
1.15
0.58
0.58
,,:'-,-,-- . .'ป, ,
1.53
- > : < '..
2.52
5.00
0.00
0.58
*
2.00
2.08
.'' 1? , - -
1.00
'- -"'*-,,' -,
0.58
1.15
5.57
4.58
4.58
0.58
2.00
0.58
2.08
3.51
2.52
0.118
0.118
0.236
~xv-- '; '< ':
0.236
0.473
0.354
;;'i,<^* .'*'
0.473
0.236
0.118
0.118
".>.' .
0.354
-,. <* ~
0.591
_, J- ''
1.345
0.000
0.118
0.473
0.473
-. \
0.236
0.118
0.236
1.570
1.120
1.120
0.118
0.473
0.118
0.473
0.827
0.591
Average
36.33
45.33
38.00
*; X^-, ^':rซ, -'< =
40.00
32.67
38.00
>'
#;l#t-^!S3
45.00
35.33
35.67
_4aL67_
,lx,:%;;^^.
28.33
-y: ;-;>- ^. -rVw*
28.67
/';V; **:*?.&;;
33.00
40.00
<' , -t -
36.67
v, ;;:---,' ::r^
"f-"?', <" :.^:* -?'*.. '"^"
34.00
30.67
.^"J''7"e~?E
;: ','*".. ^rti^v
36.00
->.'* ' ; r ';....<
27.67
18.67
30.00
26.00
68.00
35.67
44.00
33.67
39.67
38.67
36.67
TAG SYMBOLS
Determined
.
to be an
-
outlier
Normalized deviation
(grand-avg) (known) Tag
0.36
3.48
0.94
OJy'.y ^-/V;"'!,
1.63
-0.91
0.94
^f^V;^1 ',\_ " ~\
^I^JT'O', ^
3.36
0.01
0.13
__2;90 ^
?Upl>?^.. ':- :-
..J2.41_ t
?^l|\\'%~x?' '\f~~
-2.30 ^
/^V-'p^v-'-'
-0.80
1.63
> i*) --"-*_*". ' * -*< f-
-. ^ ^ , * -.J s *
0.47
'^J,Cl'!-:t:^{
"<-\v:-''$^ - ,,"-!';-
-0.45
,. .ปyฎ- ^~-
iS^SSff^
^t^^-""^-!'-'^'-
_0.24_ ^^
,ป..-'-^, <:;,r,^.
-2.64
-5.76
-1.84
-3.22
9;6d
0.13
3.01
-0.57
1.51
1.17
0.47
1T s Above
11 5 Below
=====
0.12
3.23 tt
0.69
'v^sf Ky*&3
1.39 1
-1.15
0.69
,';'. ^c"/'';-ปlB
*U4r- iv-'Vf^
3.12 fr'
-0.23
-0.12
2Xป^
>, -,.;- 1!->: ป -;
-2.66
v- ;^!,:':;ซ^
-2.54 _
- \\:r; -t9^\;>
-1.04
1.39
\-Vh!-*' "'J-*f^
0.23
'* "~\vl ' -*'ci-
_VปTr ?* * ''*f\-
-0.69
-1.85^^
"'??SSP
f> " >>>'*> ;f'-
^.9-.99ปs. - -T-
{***. X. O '''''' '' ^J1
-2.89
-6.00 U
-2.08
-3.46 U
' ' " ,:'
9.36 x ;
-0.12
''/- - , *' "
2.77
-0.81
* -
1.27
0.92
0.23
', . ..'.;.'
control limit
control limit J
~'~ " " - &
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
12/44
Strontium-89
Exper. Rng anal Normalized deviation
Lab Res. 1 Res. 2 Res. 3 Sigma (R + SR) Average (grand-avg) (known) Tag
JER*< --;-r>t^<~tfe^r ": >--v " ' ~ ':. => f-v X*:^*%^.B^^^Pi^^^t^
EV }-~-^^:%?>.: : * - -,; <-... - -, "; - v *-: 'x^i^^^yw.^^^^l^
,. , . '," .). -. " ~, ' > ' -. \ * . ^ if \ ''?''.'". ^ s \' ^ i ,* \ 5 v * A^* i *" ^ ^\ v s Os"1 A v. ws * K *" ^ * *y i\-vs #* ^if*
____ \ ^j* ^ ^ '' \ -i %ซS jN- ''" ^ "" "" ^ * * ^J1 % \ S < V^ <ป ^**ssia
SVVT . ^ v , ^ . 'vNiv. 'j .^v^.f.^ '\ ^, 4 * C*.* ^W-K;!
EX
FE
FP
39.0 40.0
0.58 0.118
39.67 1.51
GO 45.0 42.0 47.0 2.52 0.591
44.67 3.25
BK 34.0 35.0 35.0 0.58 0.118
34.67 -0.22 -0.46
42.0 42.0 0.00 0.000
32.67 -0.91 -1.15
0.58 0.118
33.0 33.0
JE
JG
JM
JN
JQ
JS
JX
JY
K
BE":
KT
KX
L
LEJ"
LF
LL
LR
LT
M
MF
MP
MT
MV
MY
N
29.0
35.0 36.0 36.0 0.58 0.118
37.0 35.0 35.0 1.15 0.236
-\- --r^^:l;^;x^j(\v^t'v
35.67 0.13 -0.12
35.67 0.13 -0.12
,- s
36.0
42.0
29.0
33.0
38.0
45.0
33.0
29.0
37.0
39.0
40.0
35.0
30.0
1.00
16.46
2.52
3.06
2.08
0.236
5.621
0.591
0.709
0.473
^ ^ \ ^ , *" ^ * * ^ ซ,%v--7^*i
- ' ,N A.A
-*-- ^\> ~-~%tปyVx
1.27
-1.85
>> \
= No data submitted
0 = Insufficient data
TAG SYMBOLS
Determined to be an outlier
ft s Above control limit
II = Below control limit
-------
13/44
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Strontium-89
Lab Res. 1
Exper. Rng anal Normalized deviation
Res. 2 Res. 3 Sigma (R + SR) Average (grand-avg) (known) Tag
'NA1?;
30.0
32.0
26.0 3.06 0.709 29.33 -2.07 -2.31
" ,y *ป *' \ C* " ;""> '; X; >*"" * wซ, - v crซ'<^-f.
-. v . ' j * ^ >-.*.<'
PA
PB
PD
PG
PM
PQ
PW
Q
QM
QP
QQ
iQT
QU
QW
QX
QZ
RB
RD
RF
RG
RI
RK
RP
RR
RU
RZ
S
sc
SD
SF
SG
SI
38.0
35.0
38.0
46.0
36.0
39.0
36.0
38.0
44.0
36.0
40.0 1.00
39.0 2.08
39.0
42.0
If , *Zs- "
'^ss ^ S
36.0
0.58
2.00
0.00
0.236
0.473
0.118
0.473
0.000
39.00 1.28 1.04
36.67 0.47 0.23
38.33
1.05
44.00 3.01
36.00 0.24
0.81
2.77
0.00
38.0
33.0
21.0
34.0
29.0
35.0
29.0
29.0
32.0
35.0
35.0
28.0
30.0
32.0
32.0
1.73
2.65
4.93
1.15
3.00
0.354
0.591
1.120
0.236
0.709
36.00
30.00
26.67
32.67
32.00
0.24
-1.84
-2.99
-0.91
-1.14
0.00
-2.08
-3.23
-1.15
-1.39
= No data submitted
0 = Insufficient data
TAG SYMBOLS
x s Determined to be an outlier
ft s Above control limit
Ji = Below control limit
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
14/44
Strontium-89
Lab Res. 1
Res. 2 Res. 3
Exper. Rng anal Normalized deviation
Sigma (R + SR) Average (grand-avg) (known) Tag
6L
SM
SN
SO
SR
88
33.0
27.0
24.0
sz
T
TD
UK
UP
UQ
UY
VA
VC
VH
VI
VJ
VM
VO
VT
W
WE
WH
WO
WR
WW
X
XA
XC
XD
XF
XI
42.0
35.0
34.0
25.0
24.0 23.0
39.0
34.0
30.0
4.93
2.08
1.120
27.33
-2.76
-3.00
31.0
36.0
35.0
5.69 1.570
1.00 0.236
2.65 0.591
0.473
37.33 0.71 0.46
35.00 -0.10 -0.35
33.00 -0.80 -1.04
ซ" ! ',' -' ': '
27.0 25.0 27.0
34.0
35.0
34.0 40.0
65 0.591 44.00 3.01 2.77
"~ ,-, ' " - - \- "\~ป Y-"-~; " ~ *? : *!%fc'$-nฎv:>-f '-^ ", t~\y>-~~-^- vs?,*r "~^S^|~^^**'"*''* -x*' '''Vs'i^'' '' -\fปi,,
s '- "- ,'. *V ,V -ฐ^' '^'-.-<-'-!~;^V--*!\: -"'"'^'s?' ^,",-Cf. - ;Vs:?->y ^^iVwl
. - ; ,\;f> v^?l^V^^t^-^^V^->;^^
\ \, . - ' - V L '-^ *C" ,= >X' ,,r ^ :; ^,^r ^\,;|^^|1ซ^J
1.15 0.236 _ J ^ ,26.33^^ ^ j3.ll ^-3;35^ J ^
^ ^ "*" * ^ - ^ ^ * ^ o"" \ i v\x ^ > v-!"\\\-ปo^^ *"^" *^o *" *" "\ ^ซ ^^ ^ ^.^ ^xt; *H*t^v s*v
';' x\ป -> x^^% i*\ 4^-^V^\\^ ^^V+^sv^Wv^!
-- ^- '"'-^t ^x"-\ ^ ^ VVN \vv^ *" x: ^%% ซ ^ i5-*.\% *v*\* ^s^^^x ^>^v* ^
-%"; -;--; .-x."-; o* :--;H^. ^^v^^^^^*%^v^
o AC A 7no m An n 94 n on
36.0
36.0
3.46 0.709
0^58 0.118
38.0
36.0
37.0
1.00 0.236
37.00
XJ
XK
XL
XM
24.0
45.0
46.0
16.0
47.0
42.0
= No data submitted
0 = Insufficient data
29.0
49.0
44.0
x =
6.56
2.00
2.00
2.020
0.473
0.473
TAG SYMBOLS
Determined to be an
23.00
47.00
44.00
outlier
-
-4.26
4.05
3.01
ft s Above
II s Below
...
-4.50
3.81
2.77
control
control
'i
limit
limit \
-#
-------
15/44 ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Strontium-89
Lab Res. 1 Res.
-..-JSR&'&l!'-' >*'ฐVr" *v" >'*%'
'/? ..- , * - ' f '',*'*'' ,** ' ' ' ' v ,. ' " ' "}. &%'
v-XOV*^,^ , ^,VK /lv^
Exper. Rng anal
2 Res. 3 Sigma (R + SR)
^X'<'-*"V/C:- - ' " ' ' '-"'
Normalized deviation
Average (grand-avg) (known)
'.",' V' '" A^U^^to^vi'^^^-^^^O
'' " * % - '':< \ '"^; S^^\ ^ X ^"^^vr'^ ^ * *^> ' S^V% V OX
- ' "'- ' ; ":: -: ^~'^^ป^c^^^T *' y^f--
Tag
\> -,,
\ i *V '"
X**x
Data sorted by Laboratory Average
Average Tag
18.67 41
23.00 41
24.67 41
26.00 41
26.33 41
26.67 41
27.33
27.67
28.33
28.67
29.33
30.00
30.00
30.67
30.67
31.00
32.00
32.33
32.33
32.67
32.67
32.67
% responding labs
10-
-6 -4
Lab Average Tag
CS 33.00
XK 33.00
SS 33.67
D 34.00
VI 34.67
SD 35.00
SM 35.33
CP 35.67
BC 35.67
BH 35.67
NJ 35.67
SC 35.67
CX 36.00
M 36.00
CA 36.00
JS 36.00
SI 36.33
TQ 36.67
LT 36.67
SF 36.67
JE 37.00
AK 37.00
37.33
Frequency distribution
. -L--illlii-ป
T I T I T
Lab Average Tag
TD 38.00
BL 38.00
DT 38.33
C 38.67
HK 39.00
T 39.67
AW 39.67
W 40.00
K 40.00
JY 40.00
DE 42.00
AZ 42.33
VO 43.67
S 44.00
QZ 44.00
CJ 44.00
A 44.00
QM 44.67
EL 45.00 ft
BO 45.33 ft
X 47.00 ft
L 58.00 x
SZ 63.00 x
1 -- -- .
+2 ' *4
Lab
AL
AF
QU
EB
Q
FE
E
PB
BM
AJ
I
LF
BA
XM
UP
QW
DO
GQ
AU
AE
XL
LE
DD
|
+6
Normalized deviation of the mean from the known value
= No data submitted
0 = Insufficient data
TAG SYMBOLS ft s Above control
x s Determined to be an outlier 41 s Below control
limit
limit
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
16/44
Strontium-89
% responding labs
Frequency distribution
10
0-ซH
-4-2 0 +2 +4
Normalized deviation of the mean from the grand average
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
17/44
Strontium-90 Statistical Summary 182 Participants
The known value of this nuclide is 22.0 pCi/1 with an expected precision of 6.0; the control limits
are 13.3 to 30.7; the warning regions are 13.3 to 16.2 and 27.8 to 30.7
109(59.9 %) Failed to respond ;
1(0.5 %) Outliers
3(1.6 %) Out of control
but not an outlier
Statistic
; 64(35.2 %) Within all limits
Respondents
* 5(2.7 %) In warning rone
but within control
Non-outliers
Mean
Std. Dev.
Variance
% Coef. of Var.
% deviation of mean from known value
Norm. dev. of mean from known value
Median
% deviation of median from known value
Norm. dev. of median from known value
21.85
4.30
18.47
19.67
-0.66
-0.03
21.33
-3.03
-0.16
Grand Avg 21.53
3.29
10.86
15.31
-2.15
-0.14
21.17
-3.79
-0.25
4(5.5 %) Mora than 3 norm. S.D. ป,
5(6.8 %) Between 2 and 3 norm. S.D.'
. 54(74.O %) Within 1 norm. S.D.
of known value
ป 1O(13.7 %) Between 1 and 2 norm. S.D.
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Strontium-90
Exper
Sigma
Normalized deviation
Average (grand-avg) (known) Tag
20.33 -0.41 .Q.58
23.67 0.74 0.58
21.33 -0.07 -0.23
Rnganal
(R + SR)
-0.30
1.20
0.51
-0.76
0.05
0.118
0.473
0.118
0.473
0.236
0.709
0.118
21.6.7
21.67
18.67
28.00
30.00
16.00
23.33
DE
DI
DO
DT
DZ
E
EB
EL
EO
24.0
20.0
23.0
25.0
23.0
19.0
22.0
24.0
21.0
21.0
25.0
22.0
21.0
20.0
25.0
22.0
21.0
27.0
22.0
20.0
20.0
s No data submitted
.0 B
Insufficient
=^=^====
data
~ ;
X 5
0.58
1.00
1.15
1.15
0.58
1.00
1.15
0.118
0.236
0.236
0.236
0.118
0.236
0.236
24.33
21.00
21.67
25.67
22.33
20.00
20.67
<
TAG SYMBOLS
Determined
to be an outlier
in-.. . . .- I, ^ ^ ^
0.97
-0.18
0.05
1.43
0.28
-0.53
-0.30
1T s Above
0.81
-0.35
-0.12
1.27
0.12
-0.69
-0.46
control limit
!! s Below control limit
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
19/44
Strontium-90
Lab Res. 1
Res. 2
Exper. Rng anal Normalized deviation
Res. 3 Sigma (R + SR) Average (grand-avg) (known) Tag
1.53 0.354
1.09 0.92
u^ *.\j.\j j.u.v io.y \J.\J\J U.UWF IB.m
22.0^ 5l.o'"IirTw""""" 0.238
25.0 26.0 1.53 0.354
JS
JX
JY
K
24.0 22.0 23.0 100 0^236
22.0 21.0 20.0
21.0 20.0 21.0
.. ,
23.00 0.51 0.35
s st-o-;;s- "*^ ^^^;^\-^; ^ ^-^ซ\"^^ ^ j^*'- ^-,4-
-">>>,-> ^"-"'-V^-v1 -Q^- "^"f;
21.00 -0.18 -0.35
KT
KX
L
LE
LF
LL
LR
LT
M
MF
MP
MT
MV
MY
N
21.0
11.0
27.0
33.0
23.0
22.0
13.0
23.0
28.0
25.0
22.0
15.0
23.0
26.0
26.0
1.00 0.236
0.58 0.118 ซw.wi -v/.v/v -\r.-nj
0.58 0118 21.67 0.05 -012
2.00 0.473 13.00 -2.95 -3.12 U
2.31 0.473 24.33 0.97^ 0.81
3.61
1.53
0.827
0.354
29.00 ฃ59 2.42
24.67 1.09 0.92
s No data submitted
0 = Insufficient data
TAG SYMBOLS
Determined to be an outlier
& Above control limit
s Below control limit
-------
Strontium-
Bea.l R.,.2
NA
NH
NJ
NK
NO
O
OB
He,. 3
Expe
r.
anal
Normalized deviation
(known)
Tag
19.0
21.0
,18.0 1.53
_ __ ,
ฐ354
OX
0YJ
-ฃ'
fa
PB
PD:
PG
PM
PQ
PW
Q
QM
QP
QQ
QT
QU
QW
QX
QZ
KB
RD
RF
RG
RI
RK
RP
RR
RU
RZ
S
sc
SD
SF
SG
SI
24.0
26.0
<"-'> "S'':"ซ7'
24.0
0.58
0.118 24.33 0.97 0.81
1 ' - .^.^^^r'^'^itl-^^ilisaSi- :';Sซ;-X^
.... - ?*'-< -. -^yc.~:* v^a-t'-!.!-.'-"!* **?:y~.V*K&S
24.0
13.0
20.0
19.0
20.0
24.0
13.0
20.0
19.0
20.0
24.0
13.0
19.0
18.0
=,, \,',.
20.0
0.00
0.00
0.58
0.58
0.00
;' - ''* "-,-ls;, '..- -"*:' '--|!i>ป;$xi...ซ.'ii)^c-= v-'~-"^4>.^"ป!'>''
0.118 19.67 -0.64 -0.81 '"' '
0.118
0.000
18.67
"
20.00
-0.99
-0.53
. '<
-1.15
*> *" ;VV-J
-0.69
19.0
23.0
24.0
21.0
20.0
20.0
24.0
24.0
23.0
20.0
20.0
23.0
24.0
19.0
21.0
0.58
0.58
0.00
2.00
0.58
0.118
0.118
0.000
0.473
0.118
19.67
23.33
24.00
21.00
20.33
-0.64
0.63
0.86
-0.18
-0.41
J, J; ,UrX-, 'ป?'
- .-,'.'<'?- ,- ';,:*;."
5V ' 'x- 'iV-' *';!V
- -,->, , ?%& ., -,,^
-0.81
0.46
0.69
-0.35
-0.58
s No data submitted
0 s Insufficient data
TAG SYMBOLS
x = Determined to be an outlier
tt s Above control limit
U s Below control limit
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
21/44
Strontium-90
Exper. Rng anal Normalized deviation
Lab Res. 1 Res. 2 Res. 3 Sigma (R + SR) Average (grand-avg) (known) Tag
14.0
2.52 0.591 ^16.67 ./1-68 -1.85
" %^ ' , ' % "" ^ ".- s ^* ^ \"^-. S^ "^*J>* S^~ ^t^ ^"^^'XV jj-v \ *J? ^ ^' '3^'*'\? J ^V^^V^S^^VJ^*^^
1.00 0.236
s^ *s^ซ^ (* v
' < , - --- , ---, - ':\: -- -*
3.06 0.709
1.00 0.236
2.52 0.591
24.00 0.86 0.69
22.67 0.39 0.23
19.00 -0.88 -1.04
21.67 0.05 -0.12
1.00 0.236
12.00 -3.30 -3.46
VO
VT
W
WE '
WH
WO
WR
ww
X
XA
xc
XD
XF
XI
XJ
XK
XL
XM
22.0 20.0 18.0
22.0 20.0 21.0
2.00 0.473 20.00 -0.63 -0.69
., vv
1.00 0.236 21.00 -0.18 -0.35
^x'-^o-srwi'''?'
'\ ^ W*** ^ ^
25.0
\% *v'
22.0
25.0
t s ^ v\
20.0
26.0
20.0
- ; V -;-:;-^-W^^S^^-W^SS
''>''" s* <- '-"-;'.- .\r^^''\X<^'V >?"ป'"''Sh''"A "' ;\ lv>\" i: ^ *^
'^ ","--' i '" -.%-; .ป""-'-','<""--<-!---' -' ฐ'-;^s> *!-<>;x
0.58 0.118 25.33 1.32 1.15
1.16
0.236
20.67
-0.30 -0.46
-,~ " "--.:"- ~ .. ----4,ป&i'
~>s;\s-' -ซ'--!s ,ป"&'
-K. ^\'.^^t;-;S|
>.C,t;' -> \ --;;,-" ----- --^ป-V*
'- -T , ol -T - i>^~-
- _- ' ' - - :s <-,'*--
, - - - - - -V
~ >. % Ji "S!
-. ^ W v
26.0
19.0
23.0
26.0
20.0
22.0
27.0
21.0
22.0
0.58 0.118
1.00 0.236
0.58 0.118
26.33
20.00
22.33
1.66
-0.53
0.28
1.50
-0.69
0.12
s No data submitted
0 = Insufficient data
TAG SYMBOLS
x s Determined to be an outlier
IT = Above control limit
Ji = Below control limit
-------
22/44 ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Strontium-90
Lab Res. 1 Res.
XN;'> ' :""' ' ~ ':;-
XO ': ''' > ' ,} -.-'
(m
Average Tag
12.00 U
13.00 Jl
13.00 li
16.00
16.67
17.67
18.00
18.67
18.67
19.00
19.33
19.33
19.33
19.67
19.67
19.67
19.67
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.00
20.33
% responding labs
10' -----------
-6 -4
= No data submitted
0 = Insufficient data
Exper. Rng anal Normalized deviation
2 Res. 3 Sigma (R + SR) Average (grand-avg) (known)
'.':. ''- ' '" - - <'"'- \. ฃ,*;,<,:,: v ,-v & :/ป",<, .^--4*
''-:' ' - - '- < >~ .:.^^:^K:^>^
Data sorted by Laboratory Average
Lab
VI
QM
LE
CX
SM
AJ
GQ
QW
CO
T
NJ
BA
AL
S
QU
I
AK
XL
VO
TQ
QZ
EB
CA
SI
Average Tag Lab
20.33 BM
20.33 A
20.67 X
20.67 K
20.67 EL
20.67 AU
21.00 W
21.00 SF
21.00 JY
21.00 HK
21.00 DO
21.00 BO
21.33 C
21.33 BC
21.33 AF
21.67 TD
21.67 L
21.67 DT
21.67 CJ
21.67 CE
21.67 BB
22.33 XM
22.33 E
22.67 SZ
Average Tag
23.00
23.00
23.00
23.33
23.33
23.67
23.67
24.00
24.00
24.00
24.33
24.33
24.33
24.67
24.67
24.67
25.00
25.33
25.67
26.33
28.00
28.33
29.00
30.00
45.33 x
Frequency distribution
.
Ilili . -.. -
-2 6 +2 +4
Normalized deviation of the mean from the known value
.)
Tag
" '-'
i
Lab
JS
BH
AZ
SC
D
BL
AE
ss
SD
Q
PB
LF
DE
M
JE
FE
AW
WR
DZ
XK
CP
UP
LT
CS
DD
m
+6
TAG SYMBOLS ft s Above control limit
x s Determined to be an outlier & = Below control limit J
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997 23/44
Strontium-90
% responding labs Frequency distribution
10
-6 -4 -2 6 +2
Normalized deviation of the mean from the grand average
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
24/44
Cobalt-60 Statistical Summary 182 Participants
The known value of this nuclide is 10.0 pCi/1 with an expected precision of 5.0; the control limits
are 1.3 to 18.7; the warning regions axe 1.3 to 4.2 and 15.8 to 18.7
72(39.6 %) Failed to respond .
1(O.5%) Outliers *'
Statistic
108(59.3 %) Within all limits
Respondents
- 1 (O.5 %) In wanning zone
but within control
Non-outliers
Mean
Std. Dev.
Variance
% Coef. of Var.
% deviation of mean from known value
Norm. dev. of mean from known value
Median
% deviation of median from known value
Norm. dev. of median from known value
10.55
2.03
4.13
19.26
5.55
0.27
10.00
0.00
0.00
Grand Avg 10.46
1.81
3.28
17.30
4.65
0.26
10.00
0.00
0.00
1(O.9 %) More than 3 norm. S.D. ซ.
1(O.9 %) Between 2 and 3 norm. S.D.
. 93(84.5 %) Within 1 norm. S.D.
' of known value
15(13.6 %) Between 1 and 2 norm. S.D.
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Normalized deviation
(grand-avg)' (known)
Exper
Sigma
Rnganal
(R + SR)
0.118
0.000
0.000
0.118
0.118
0.236
11.33
10.00
10.00
10.33
10.67
10.67
0.473
0.118
0.118
0.236
0.236
0.354
0.000
10.67
10.67
13.33
11.33
11.67
11.67
10.00
0.118
10.67
0.07
0.23
DZ
E
EB
EL
EO
s
0 a
AW.W
9.0
9.0
9.0
ซIK
J.4.V/
'"' ' .:^'ฅ:i;>s.-";^?:
. - -:-:' -:' '.-' . .: ..!-.
10.0
10.0
9.0
':;^.::;:y :^:^?H:^SS%:J|^
O.U
'"";- '';..y;:VV|-:'!.:|!:;'' ";."':!
10.0
9.0
9.0
iilllll
No data submitted
Insufficient
data
X s
z.uu
;:.::':.< : '; '"-' : " '
0.58
0.58
0.00
:ฃ$:ฃvฃ: ;:!::> ".': '"' '''; f '"'' :'-.:'"="':
U.473
.;."'" . '. ! --' ".": :''-: :, ,;.: . J . '-. .' ,'.
0.118
0.118
0.000
10
'..
9
9
00
'"'.'' 'vS-Sy:
67
33
9.00
': .:'''
;;::;;..; :::
':Wi
TAG SYMBOLS
Determined
to be an outlier
-0.16
.:5'^:^!^:''::^^:S'?:^::-:::^:^:^:':-/^ &?5:$ :
-0.28
-0.39
-0.51
ft = Above
Jl a Below
0.00
:;K^:-:v-S -tt.:;':; W VE'W'^s v ;'' ': >' ^
i8$|:i::ฃ '^-X '(K^1' ":' ' -^ ''\i>*:?':??
-0.12
-0.23
-0.35
;!$v:::j^
control limit
control limit
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
26/44
Cobalt-60
Lab Res. 1
Exper. Rng anal Normalized deviation
Res. 2 Res. 3 Sigma (R + SR) Average (grand-avg) (known) Tag
BRฃ; "*^&^;.:-\
jjy;'- V'-"'' :'*" ,x":ฃ:'
0.00 0.000
0.58 0.118
JE
JG
JM
JN;
JQ^
JS
JX
JY
K
KE
KT
KX
L
LE
LF
LL
LR
LT
M
MF
MP
MT
MV
MY
N
10.0 10.0 11.0
10.0 11.0 12.0
10.0 12.0 9.0
10.0 9.0 ^lO-O
^ \ ^ * * '-.H, V . ^ *'^X
10.0 10.0 10.0
9.0 9.0 9.0
s .%>ป^>tA. x^ป>* ^^"x*"^ \*- * Y^T*(''VS" "s 5^ % ^* ^^v s y
"\\C? ^^^^^?^>--;,;^:^-
12.0
12.0
14.0
10.0
9.0
10.0
9.0
10.0
8.0
9.0
12.0
10.0
13.0
15.0
9.0
10.0
9.0
11.0
7.0
10.0
11.0
100
12.0
11.0
10.0
10.0
10.0
11.0
8.0
10.0
0.00
0.00
0.58
1.15
1.00
2.65
0.58
0.00
0.58
0.58
0.58
0.58
0.118
0.000
0.000
9.67
10.00
9.00
-0.28
-0.16
-0.51
-0.12
x *v '
0.00
-0.35
">
0.118
0.236
0.236
0.591
0.118
0.000
0.118
0.118
0.118
0.118
11.67
10.67
13.00
12.00
""^ \^ V "
9.33
10.00
9.33
10.67
7.67
9.67
0.42
0.07
0.88
0.53
-0.39
-0.16
-0.39
-.-. ^ ^.w. <
0.07
-0.97
-0.28
0.58
0.23
1.04
0.69
-0.23
0.00
-0.23
0.23
-0.81
-0.12
= No data submitted
0 = Insufficient data
x =
TAG SYMBOLS
Determined to be an outlier
tt = Above control limit
$ = Below control limit
-------
27/44
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Cobalt-60
Lab Res. 1
''TV A x. --1
;:! llA - ' *
NH
NJ
NK
NO
O
OB
OF*. '--, ' ,,/,'
OM
ii. ' **t ' 1
' oS*"1' ' " ' * ^-^
'bxv;< "'''''
?/!?>'' "
P
PA:""*' ;
PB
PD
PC' '*
PM
PQ ?'
PW
Q
QM
QP
QQ
QT
QU
QW
QX
QZ
^*"
RB
RD
AmM^
RF
RG
RI
RK
RP
RR
RU
RZ
s
cr<
9.0
9.0
8.0
15.0
13.0
10.0
X ~- ' ,, ' ',-
i'i *' * '-
9.0
" z~-s "-Stt-A* f
^ ,' '*ป *^*
>ฃ}' f'^3\
X/ '{$& $
8.0
' ;.:;-;:^
10.0
10.0
, -. '- -
14.0
,- -',-. ,
9.0
12.0
14.0
10.0
10.0
10.0
12.0
12.0
10.0
7.0
8.0
on
Res. 2
> '*
9.0
9.0
8.0
18.0
11.0
10.0
X.- Z ''"\'7i .."Ts
X'f'-'-^^'.'W:^
9.0
* < 'V .ฃ *"ป; 'f <*J
<;V ฃ ', v!'*",'
17.0
*' *., * 's
10.0
7.0
15.0
10.0
ป'-;;'v^-' ';-fe
10.0
11.0
11.0
15.0
10.0
' * ' ''
* ., -->,-,'
,"" , *.'". '
7.0
9.0
100
Exper.
Res. 3 Sigma
9.0
10.0
7.0
20.0
11.0
10.0
,iฃ/ซ4T"/'Cฃ"t'" '
';;,^t''>'~A-;:,x-!%t;> /,'';',' -
8.0
*Jงi'&"y^*"-*ปA'4 "^ " s " '"
^^^s^'^^r'jE *T^'
i^f^f^v^
'C!,ซf?*%>/' --*,''' %;
15.0
^;ixr -,
10.0
9.0
iH -"'','
10.0
;^^.;v'.;<- --'-
10.0
9.0
12.0
9.0
^^^v^'V <
9.0
12.0
12.0
13.0
11.0
> & " ' -
""-1:-V>"^'.'
/ ""- ' " '
5.0
9.0
10.0
0.00
0.58
0.58
2.52
1.15
0.00
^ ' "
"-,''; - '-"^
0.58
-+
x!" '
f- ;>">'
>"S , '
3.61
0.00
1.00
3.51
0.58
2.52
1.53
0.58
^ V, U/
0.58
1.00
0.58
1.53
0.58
1.15
0.58
0.58
Rnganal
(R + SR)
0.000
0.118
0.118
0.591
0.236
0.000
, ' ' ' * ',<
- - >*,, '..*,,
0.118
^ % ' j < '" " ." A
-^' V^'' ' T**3^"i
y':-^c,:~f^
'' , " './" V u
0.827
, ' ' ' ;.-
0.000
0.236
0.827
- :'. / '<-
0.118
0.591
0.354
0.118
0.118
0.236
0.118
0.354
0.118
0.236
0.118
0.118
Normalized deviation
Average (grand-avg) (known) Tag
9.00
9.33
7.67
17.67
11.67
10.00
' ' "Vs,"* y ""y^-y^
'?-";-','"- '^'"9^'ฐ^
8.67
f { \ * v-fs * ^ -**^ ^-xST^ ''X^^^
' ^ity*'- 4^'^i^^^l^
*ฎ^J^OT
*C ^ ^t'^S^^^H?
f s *x.,"i'v ^*i^v" ^y^sfe,*--
1 f*^ * " ซv^ 5
12.00^
""f/i-'t^;^
10.00
10.00
----- *' <,',$ :''=i^
9.67
9.33
13.67
,.?51^.,
*.V, WA!-"f>*"-^
9.67
11.00
11.67
13.33
10.33
/ ~\
->
' ; -"-*ซ'\
" ' . '' -"
6.33
8.67
9.67
"'^
-0.51
-0.39
-0.97
2.49
0.42
-0.16
5SFI\?ฃJ7"ฃ?C'"'!'
&^'ftVf:-^r
-0.62
^*^?^> 55*^^*5. i;^ ^
^'^js>' 't' , L ^t'''*4^^''?^^.^^'*'-1^*' ^"J?^*"
**>? *vf' vL^ rf^x^ i?,' ^^ ^'o
|t"^l%;^^
l^i^i ''^2/v-^'i ;-Fซ?
_^0.69^__^M
^v^;;"r,V^; ''' *?i
0.00
0.00
-, .;X - i;- ;?*f-s
1.21
-:'->'>!''"'%^- -*rv
-0.12
0.35
0.58
1.15
0.12
'".;>'ฅ;;,
% . <%^"*<*
'. ''ป:''.:'
i\^^' ^,;^^;
7" ""''' v ' x "* *** " ""' ^^^^5
v[ ^; \~" !. ' 'i^'^v ^ ^ ^v ^,
"% ^'Av-;;-*- ,,'
," , . ,;>- -.*,,- ^
v , x '' , '* , > * ' *
" , -' ;-'/- ''-*'?::'
-1.27
-0.46
-0.12
0.118 8.67
0.236 11-67
0.236 11.00
TAG SYMBOLS
x s Determined to be an outlier
0.58
1.15
1.00
-0.62
0.42
0.19
-0.46
0.58
0.35
ft = Above control limit
U = Below control limit
-------
Cobalt-60
Lab Res. 1
SL
SM
SN
SO.
SR
ss
sx
sz
T
TD
ISฃ
TQ
TS
IT
u
YTA "
^J*m*
UK
UP
:UQ
UY
VA
VC
VH
VI
VJ
VM
VO
VT
W
WE
WH
WO
WR
WW
X
XA
XC
XD
XF
XI
XJ
XK
XL
XM
: ',:;,: c.X-y:,fe<
10.0
9.0
', , " ' r,'',-\,-
12.0
11.0
10.0
10.0
8.0
14.0^ ^
i;4?ฃ:>:i
8.0
;? -? 0 Vrr.- ;
" ;>-- *. -. J \ * , -; ^
' *'-.-,
SNX , '^
^ \ *' s %i iV ; V;
^ \ '''< s -- * ^ \ ^
17.0
10.0
;"^lv
12.0
15.0
9.0
>' :>'^\^;
7.0
'' ' - s.
* \ ^ "
' - ,-,"; '.y~.
9.0
11.0
9.0
.'; - -^
11.0
10.0
9.0
18.0
9.0
10.0
8.0
ESD-LV
Res. 2
,c>-\C.v;^
13.0
.^$.0^_
v--"-A\ J.f;^;s-
14.0
10.0
10.0
9.0
8.0
,^JM,..
9.0
^'H-'*>,;^> V
v ^ ^ <.\ ^- f\^ ^ ^
^ ,"^V v;//V\s,*
\*%^ ^.\ ^^N" ^ -, Os - <""*
--,> \^x* s ^^j-^
16.0
^_11.0 ^
:-^',k3:ป'--v -1- '
12.0
12.0
10.0
'" ^\ " -y .
W,V * v=; v*
_8.0_
^.^ ^ _v " %
"* \ i"- '
-:r^^i?^s, -
n!o
11.0
12.0
s>^$;uv'-
V^'1^"'' ^b
1LO
10.0
9.0
15.0
10.0
10.0
10.0
'' ''.. :
Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Res. 3
;A -=4, -.
11.0
9.0
\' i^r^;^1
12.0
9.0
10.0
11.0
10.0
14.0
*r " -*^;'- "
! \
9.0
sb Vts s ""
J-,,;-{ -; ,
>'; > ;' ป,\ -
'-1 ,' -Tc1^1'
; vv ^ s .
13.0
11.0
>:-'^,<
11.0
14.0
10.0
-V<--,v
9.0
tซ :-' - . . -
;", -! ' , 'i.\- "
15:0
10.0
8.0
~\ x\ -
d-;---
10.0
11.0
8.0
13.0
10.0
11.0
9.0
s No data submitted
0 =
Insufficient
data
x =
28/44
Exper. Rng anal Normalized deviation
Sigma (R + SR) Average (grand-avg) (known) Tag
1.53
0.58
, --- , - ' ;"-\\
1.15
1.00
0.00
1.00
1.15
1.15
, " : -;;; / '
0.58
, ;,
2.08
0.58
0.58
1.53 .
0.58
-
1.00
-
3.06
0.58
2.08
0.58
0.58
0.58
2.52
0.58
0.58
1.00
' ^ ^ ; ^ * * -
0.354
0.118
-^--;.\ง^Sk%^
11.33
. J^67.v.,.w
C, 'vx>:5 ,~|p^ti^: ?.
12.67
10.00
10.00
10.00
8.67
_^JL3.33^_
8.67
'!W%"v^^^F'>
ifl >S^::>?:^C^^ฅ'':--?x^
^^^l^^c^
;v' s,-% ^ ""0 v.1*^ ^ *
;\~ , , X^V ^^ ^-v-^:;T^;;c
11.67
10.67
9.67
v^5^ ^ซJ*^ ^" 4 ^ ^"^X*/*
.-:;. -t'-lVV:t '"'
10.67
10.33
8.67
15.33
9.67
\-\ * -v
10.33
"' / .'
9.00
-, \ >) _!
TAG SYMBOLS
Determined
to be an
outlier
0.30
-0.62^^^
-Ifi^f^'^v^i
0.76
-0.16
-0.16
-0.16
-0.62
..HSU^-
-0.62
T^^^rSs
^x^^lfcl:^
^f^^^v^
yV "*ฃHV^j*
^i*ซv!|^,Ht"
^0.42
0.07
-0.28
\ W.S^VN'.v. \ Wl^ .^VW.-.VrtfW%
vi>- '\\'f'^
T'-'^f^T
0.07
-0.05
-0.62
1.69
-0.28
" s' \ \- ^ i\
;- :' ^ V ' -
-0.05
-0.51
" v , ' '
IT s Above
i^|^^*^
0.46
JX46^_
il'|S3k*%I^;i?
0.92
0.00
0.00
0.00
-0.46
1.15
OL46
^^^^^^^^^^^^^
1.85
0.23
0.58
1.27
-0.12
-,e"^V^I^%
-0.69
^f|vS|>|i|||iS|
^ss $.ซJ^;f^\^;j^\^.^^3iซ&*
^lฅ|~l^lw
Q.5S
0.23
-0.12
J^^T^S,^*^
;i?\\>^p|ป^
0.23
0.12
-0.46
1.85
-0.12
^>j?^if^ji
,\,V S;^"\^
012
^;^**I3
^ - " >P?
-0.35
:>V,!;t:^^
-- "* S * "" "^ ^^^A^^V
control limit
li = Below control limit
-------
29/44 ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1907
Cobalt-60
Lab Res. 1 Res. 2
- JENx '?* ' x/ '* < -.;<' * /- -V'- ,-,-<-
Trt^''!-'' "''?''' " -"-'' r'' ',''"' ^^?'^''
*V -''' '*..'." '"'"':'.
Exper. Rng anal
Res. 3 Sigma (R + SR)
-'vV^V- ' .:'---'
V;V'V '".';(f '/'"' ' , ' ; ,.
Normalized deviation
Average (grand-avg) (known) Tag
-: ฐ '' >' - ' :^vCT &'$& ^CC?^&^&
v,'cป^\,.v ,'; ^ r \/l^^^-^:f~^^:s^ff^^t^,.
"*X*x^
fS^
* ^
Data sorted by Laboratory Average
Average Tag
5.00
6.33
7.00
7.67
7.67
8.00
8.67
8.67
8.67
8.67
8.67
8.67
8.67
8.67
9.00
9.00
9.00
9.00
9.00
9.00
9.33
9.33
9.33
9.33
9.33
9.33
9.33
9.67
9.67
9.67
9.67
9.67
9.67
9.67
9.67
9.67
|| = No data submitted
105 Insufficient data
Lab
IU
RZ
FE
NK
MV
VI
WW
TQ
T
SN
SD
S
OM
AU
XK
NH
K
EL
AH
A
Q
NJ
M
LR
EB
BB
AZ
XA
W
VC
SC
QT
QP
PW
MY
JS
Average Tag
9.67
9.67
9.67
10.00
10.00
10.00
10.00
10.00
10.00
10.00
10.00
10.00
10.00
10.00
10.00
10.00
10.00
10.00
10.00
10.00
10.33
10.33
10.33
10.33
10.33
10.33
10.33
10.33
10.67
10.67
10.67
10.67
10.67
10.67
10.67
10.67
10.67
TAG SYMBOLS
x s Determined to be an
_ ...
Lab
I
E
BC
SZ
sx
ss
PD
PB
OB
LT
JY
HK
GQ
DT
DE
D
CA
BL
BK
AF
XF
WR
QZ
JM
JE
FL
C
BM
WO
VT
UP
MP
L
DO
CJ
CE
BO
Average Tag
10.67
10.67
11.00
11.00
11.00
11.00
11.00
11.33
11.33
11.33
11.33
11.67
11.67
11.67
11.67
11.67
11.67
11.67
11.67
11.67
12.00
12.00
12.67
13.00
13.00
13.00
13.33
13.33
13.33
13.67
13.67
13.67
14.00
15.33
15.33
17.67
20.33 x
ft s Above control
outlier ^ s Below control
..
Lab
BN
AK
SI
QU
JG
FJ
AE
SM
CP
BH
AW
VO
UY
SF
QW
O
KX
HL
CX
CS
P
LF
SR
LE
BA
AJ
TD
QX
CO
VA
QM
PM
AL
X
UK
NO
DD
limit
limit I
#
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
30/44
Cobalt-60
% responding labs
Frequency distribution
10
t
-4 -20 +2 44
Normalized deviation of the mean from the known value
% responding labs
Frequency distribution
20
10
r*-f-
JjL
-k -2 ' 6 . +2
Normalized deviation of the mean from the grand average
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
31/44
Cesium-134 Statistical Summary 182 Participants
The known value of this nuclide is 41.0 pCi/1 with an expected precision of 5.0; the control limits
are 32.3 to 49.7; the warning regions are 32.3 to 35.2 and 46.8 to 49.7
72(39.6 %) Failed to respond ,
4(2.2 %) Outliers
1 (O.5 %) Out of control
but not an outlier
Statistic
; 88(48.4 %) Within all limits
Respondents
17(9.3 %) In warning zone
but within control
Non-outliers
Mean
Std. Dev.
Variance
%Coef. ofVar.
% deviation of mean from known value
Norm. dev. of mean from known value
Median
% deviation of median from known value
Norm. dev. of median from known value
37.67
5.95
35.40
15.79
-8.12
-0.56
37.50
-8.54
-0.59
Grand Avg 37.83
2.87
8.23
7.58
-7.73
-1.10
37.67
-8.13
-1.16
5(4.5 %) More than 3 norm. S.D.
17(15.5 %) Between 2 and 3 norm. S.D.
41(37.3 %) Within 1 norm. S.D.
of known value
47(42.7 %) Between 1 and 2 norm. S.D.
-------
32/44
Cesium-134
Lab Res. 1
A
AE
AF
AH
AJ
AK
AL
AP
AR
AU
AW
AZ
BA
BB
BC
BO
BH
BK
BL
BM
BN
BO
BS
BW
C
CA
CC
CE
CJ
CO
CP
CS
CX
DB
DD
DE
DI
DO
DT
DZ
E
EB
EL
EO
=
0 s
40.0
41.0
41.0
35.0
33.0
36.0
54.0
'' ,' I"1" " - "'\
' -"' '..s'^l^-l?''*'*
35.0
37.0
41.0
38.0
38.0
37.0
/'- >;'V' ':~:'
42.0
36.0
41.0
39.0
38.0
44.0
42.0
36.0
39.0
42.0
38.0
40.0
38.0
39.0
37.0
79.6
36.0
39.0
36.0
38.0
33.0
40.0
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Res. 2 Res. 3
41.0
38.0
39.0
38.0
36.0
35.0
47.0
'< - ?C'; ,V/r'~;>r
36.0
39.0
40.0
39.0
39.0
37.0
:" V^I/'^-'t
42.0
36.0
39.0
38.0
37.0
43.0
41.0
37.0
.
39.0
41.0
38.0
40.0
39.0
35.0
36.0
TfcO -
37.0
40.0
34.0
40.0
32.0
38.0
40.0
40.0
40.0
39.0
33.0
36.0
45.0
/^ .. .-
^^ '
36.0
38.0
41.0
38.0
41.0
36.0
- ** f , * r
40.0
36.0
37.0
40.0
38.0
44.0
42.0
39.0
-%-> v
38.0
41.0
40.0
36.0
38.0
41.0
36.0
80.0
37.0
40.0
36.0
37.0
33.0
40.0
No data submitted
Insufficient
data
X 3
Exper.
Sigma
0.58
1.53
1.00
2.08
1.73
0.58
4.73
'. .. ' ' *s
'"" ~~ ' -.
0.58
1.00
0.58
0.58
1.53
0.58
:-
1.15
0.00
2.00
1.00
0.58
0.58
0.58
1.53
0.58
0.58
1.15
2.31
0.58
3.06
0.58
0.58
0.58
0.58
1.15
1.53
0.58
1.15
Rnganal
(R + SR)
0.118
0.354
0.236
0.473
0.354
0.118
1.120
. ' -.-. ' -. ' '
-'- V^ &'-'' l^--
0.118
0.236
0.118
0.118
0.354
0.118
*" .-
0.236
0.000
0.473
0.236
0.118
0.118
0.118
0.354
'c.
0.118
0.118
0.236
0.473
0.118
0.709
0.118
0.118
0.118
0;118
0.236
0.354
0.118
0.236
Normalized deviation
Average (grand-avg) (known) Tag
40.33
39.67
40.00
37.33
34.00
35.67
48.67
" '^ "' r;'?" ':iS^';.
't^'Jv' r^v'/y^l^
35.67
38.00
40.67
38.33
39.33
36.67
*"r-'^x'< -";/ V^-.-|?b
41.33
36.00
39.00
39.00
37.67
43.67
-". " i
'' ' - ,v,;> ;i'.
41.67
37.33
-; ,\, '',,-: ',.'*"-"?;'
38.67
41.33
38.67
38.67
38.33
38.33
36.33
70.33
36.67
39.67
35.33
38.33
32.67
39.33
TAG SYMBOLS
Determined to be an
-^ ^" ii " """ '
outlier
.
0.87
0.64
0.75
-0.17
-1.33
-0.75
3.75
'^v'/V/
^^(4,'C - ,
-0.75
0.06
0.98
0.17
0.52
-0.40
-f- V -*i ^s>
1.21
-0.63
0.41
0.41
-0.06
2.02
5 > ',
'-v.--^ '' '
1.33
._;9-17~
&$* -/'<---
0.29
1.21
0.29
0.29
0.17
0.17
-0.52
14.38
-0.40
0.64
-0.86
0.17
-1.79
0.52
-0.23
-0.46
-0.35
-1.27
-2.42
-1.85
2.66
\r /,/ .\^ซ&- ;>-'> >ll^ V-ซi:*x;
-1.85
-1.04
-0.12
-0.92
-0.58
-1.50
Y^'^'^r-^v
0.12
-1.73
-0.69
-0.69
-1.15
0.92
' .- ;-:- '\ -, *-',
,U ->,!-,_- ^\ '!,,,--
0.23
-1.27 %^^_
; &!X.f' - ?:; X'^y"- i^ ป,
-0.81
0.12
-0.81
-0.81
-0.92
-0.92
-1.62
'
13.28 x
-1.50
*
-0.46
-1.96
*
-0.92
-2.89
-0.58
ft s Above control limit
Ji = Below control limit J
-------
Cesium-134
Lab Res. 1
Res. 2
Res. 3
Exper. Rng anal Normalized deviation
Sigma (R + SR) Average (grand-avg) (known) Tag
lUlg CLUdl 11UI UlUllXCU UCVlttLlUU
(R + SR) Average (grand-avg) (known) T
, . ..'ซiv/-\..- ^^^il^V^'Mf^"^^^-^
- -- - -, " sx>o~ \i-,-v < - ^.s'-l T'V -^V-^>\-- ,JUS v-!^~
- >'<.'": ^<\;^^:^;^^:!;^^^i^^;f^%-
-, ,,-,' ,,--- -o,-,=~:v ;-^-\-vx.vVvvVป.-->-xi ซ*-|;v-.:--.' ' : '-"^ !Xt't^-^^%^^^<'^\^'-^'xVV^!^^-s**,V
4.62 0.945 IHJ-^..-- ^ฃ$*v*-~~ซ^
0.00 0.000 36^00 -0.63 -1.73
1.53 0.354 37.67 -0.06 -1.15
" " r^^V .JV V^.01 X^XC*^1?^ ^S^ T*^C
O /-."* ฐ * s . A>s vA * v.\ O .* w ^-\ s i.\* > s ". s s ^ -.X *ป\ \<\ \ " sv*%w s\\ -^ ^
_ 0.00 .0;|^,^^^JW-W_^_ 0.75^ ^,^545^^^,,
ER
EV
EX
FE
FJ
FL
FN
Cfcs
GQ
39.0
36.0
36.0
31.0
36.0
38.0
31.0
? . -"
36.0
39.0
40.0
40.0
ffl
HK
HL
HP
HX
I
m;;(
iu
j
JE
JG
JM
JN
JQ
JS
JX
JY
K
38.0
38.0
37.0
37.0
40.0
41.0
38.0
37.0
36.0
36.0
33.0
39.0
40.0
37.0
40.0
\ t "X l^V"
VC^ -
33.0
38.0
38.0
37.0
2.89 0.591
0.58 0.118
1.53 0.354
34.67 -1.10
38.33 0.17
38.33 0.17
'T' ' ft-: ^'T^T^-V1-;;:- V-^jr-^Cs ~;V?\\ซ,T5v^i\*^
. * ** i ^'''' ^ %Vv "" "I ' " ^'V ''' '"V ."'' > 'Os '"'V s%-'\.'k ^ ' '''^
ป. *, s x~x- x^,-_ ,,_,< -; ! \;-,^\;-
33.0
40.0
35.0
37.0
24.0
30.0
--* ^, ^\^s^V""
1 ^ " -X'' *
40.0
38.0
44.0
40.0
-\"S ' !, '
36.0
36.0
33.0
35.0
24.0
29.0
-" " ^ \\ -
* ?"
39.0
39.0
44.0
41.0
- - \ , , -
36.0
36.0
35.0
>-,
36.0
25,0
30.0
No data submitted
0.58
0.58
0.00
0.58
1.73
2.31
1.15
1.00
0.58
0.58
, - \;o"'~-
x '
0.118
0.118
0.000
0.118
0.354
0.473
0.236
0.236
0.118
0.118
: '''""'*';; r^x";-;>>
'\"v ': ~,:V<^-
39.67
38.33
44.00
40.67
^-M^^ Ss\^-Vf
35.00
37.33
34.33
36.00
24.33
29.67
'.',' '.?'-; -,S;A,''
TAG SYMBOLS
\^ ^^\V ^'- , vVs5"^
.~;\X/V^' '' v y
0.64
0.17
2.14
^0.98
\,s __ ^J!;'-'' '^ -v-.\
-0.98
-0.17
-1.21
-0.63
-4.68
-2.83
ft s Above
JL = Ralnnr
^ -x\s N N*\**\ ^ ป|% ;~ s
:
-------
ESD-LV Performs
Evaluation: Blind
Normalized deviation
). (known)
s No data submitted
0 = Insufficient data
TAG SYMBOLS
x = Determined to be an outlier
It s Above control limit
= Below control limit
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
35/44
Cesium-134
Lab
Res. 1
Res. 2
Res. 3
Exper.
Sigma
Rng anal
(R + SR)
Normalized deviation
Average (grand-avg) (known) Tag
0.06 -1.04
1.44 0.35
-0.75 -1.85
38.00
42.00
35.67
0.118 35.33
.0
1.00
3.06
,-.-.
3.21
2.31
1.15
1.15
1.00
1.73
1.53
vo
VT
38.
41.0
33.0
36.0
3.51
1.00
2.00
4.36
0.58
0.58
4.51
2.65
1.120
0.591
37.67
39.00
w
WE
WH
WO
WR
WW
X
XA
XC
XD
XF
XI
XJ
XK
XL
XM
39.0
30.0
37.0
41.0
35.0
36.0
36.0
38.0
36.0
" \-' :^;'';' "
' " ' >*-* ,y ->-
37.0
38,0
37.0
42.0
39.0
'
37.0
36.0
38.0
34.0
39.0
34.0
35.0
39.0
- +
,.
36.0
: \\ .-
37.0
3 No data submitted
0 =
Insufficient
data
x =
1.53 0.354
\
3.51 0.827
1.00 0.236
3.51 0.827
4.04 0.827
1.73 0.354
-
0.58 0.118
1.00 0.236
TAG SYMBOLS
Determined to be an
==^^=^===
,^37.67^
*v ' ^v<^-r- >
"V s
33.67
38.00
37.33
37.33
38.00
36.33
37.00
outlier
====^=
-oj*L_~^
x- .;^tx t,,^?;'-""'-^'
'*""" \!' * ' s "- '''
-1.44
0.06
-0.17
-0.17
0.06
^
-
-0.52
-
-0.29
-">> ; - 'ฐ'->
It = Above
Ji s Below
=
-1.16 _^,,^
W^f'^^&l
Y
-1.62
* ,
*
-1.39
. \ " ^ **
' v. -\*.ft...
control limit
control limit
Jj
-------
(l~
[36/44 ESD-LV Performance Eval^o^ Blind-B. 21-Oct.lM7 ^\
f Cesium-134
Lab Res. 1 Res. 2
Exper. Rnganal
Res. 3 Sigma (R + SR)
Normalized deviation
}
1
Average (grand-avg) (known) Tag |
Data sorted by Laboratory Average
Average Tag Lab 1 Averaซป TOป T u i ป
lolx) x
20.00 x
24.33 x
29.67 Jl
32.67
33.00
33.67
33.67
33.67
34.00
34.33
34.33
34.33
34.33
34.33
34.67
34.67
35.00
35.00
35.00
35.33
35.33
35.33
35.67
35.67
35.67
35.67
35.67
35.67
36.00
36.00
36.00
36.00
36.33
36.33
36.33
5 No data submitted
0 a Insufficient data
Lab
P
IU
MV
MY
EB
SF
WO
NK
FE
AJ
TQ
SX
SR
8D
M
Q
HI
SC
s
LR
VI
OM
DT
VC
UK
SZ
PM
AU
AK
MP
JY
FJ
BK
XF
NJ
D
Average Tag
36.67
36.67
36.67
36.67
36.67
36.67
36.67
37.00
37.00
37.00
37.00
37.00
37.33
37.33
37.33
37.33
37.33
37.33
37.33
37.67
37.67
37.67
37.67
38.00
38.00
38.00
38.00
38.00
38.00
38.33
38.33
38.33
38.33
38.33
38.33
38.33
38.67
TAG SYMBOLS
x = Determined to be an
Lab
SN
SI
PW
JS
JM
DE
BC
XK
UP
TD
QZ
I
X
ww
NH
LT
K
CA
AH
W
VO
FL
BN
XA
WR
UY
T
QT
AW
L
HL
HK
E
CX
CS
BA
PD
Average Tup
38.67
38.67
38.67
39.00
39.00
39.00
39.00
39.00
39.33
39.33
39.67
39.67
39.67
40.00
40.00
40.00
40.00
40.33
40.67
40.67
41.00
41.33
41.33
41.33
41.33
41.67
41.67
41.67
42.00
42.00
42.00
42.33
43.67
44.00
45.67
48.67
79.33 x
IT a Above control
outlier U = Below control
Lab
CP
CO
CE
VT
SM
JE
BM
BL
EL
BB
KX
DO
AE
QP
QM
GQ
AF
A
LF
AZ
O
ss
RZ
CJ
BH
QX
QU
C
VA
PB
JG
QW
BO
LE
NO
AL
DD
limit
limit
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997 37/44
Cesium-134
% responding labs Frequency distribution
10-
OJปT
-6 -4 -2 0 +2
Normalized deviation of the mean from the known value
% responding labs ___ Frequency distribution
10-
T I
-6 -4 -2 0 +2 +4
Normalized deviation of the mean from the grand average
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
38/44
Cesium-137 Statistical Summary 182 Participants
The known value of this nuclide is 34.0 pCi/1 with an expected precision of 5.0; the control limits
are 25.3 to 42.7; the warning regions are 25.3 to 28.2 and 39.8 to 42.7
71 (39.0 %) Fallsd to respond ;
5(2.7 %) Outliers
1(O.5 %) Out of control
but not an outlier
Statistic
100(54.9 %) Within all limits
Respondents
5(2.7 %) In warning zone
but within control
Non-outliers
Mean
Std. Dev.
Variance
%Coef. ofVar.
% deviation of mean from known value
Norm. dev. of mean from known value
Median
% deviation of median from known value
Norm. dev. of median from known value
35.56
5.54
30.68
15.58
4.59
0.28
35.00
2.94
0.18
Grand Avg 35.51
2.40
5.78
6.77
4.45
0.63
35.00
2.94
0.42
6(5.4 %) More than 3 norm. S.D
5(4.5 %) Between 2 and 3 norm. S.D
77(69.4 %) Within 1 norm. S.D.
of known value
in 1 and 2 norm. S.D.
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Cesium-137
I Lab
I1
A
AE
AF
AH
AJ
AK
AL
KAPl!
L'AHlI
AU
AW
AZ
BA
BB
BC
NiirpKi
litwpf
BH
BK
BL
BM
BN
II n^*v
B0
BSlfi?
B'wil
c
CA ...
CCR*
CE
rn
CO
CP
cs
nX
D
DB
DD
DE
DI
DO
DZ
E
EB
EL
EO
= No
Res. 1 ReS. 2
34.0 33.0
34.0 34.0
36.0 37.0
32.0 34.0
35.0 32.0
35.0 35.0
31.0 36.0
34.0
34.0
33.0
31.0
34.0
34.0
W/rnimmmmt
36.0
35.0
33.0
35.0
37.0
35.0
:'. ' ';'..^'-i ':>.. ":::- :i-!':'
V4&%$$tf&&&$.
34.0
35.0
36.0
37.0
32.0
35.0
36.0
28.0
34.0
:-.:. .,'- '' ':. :.
;::""-::'":;-/^:,f-'
vi&Ei
32.0
35.0
34.0
34.0
35.0
34.0
32JQ
35.0
31.0
31.0
36.0
36.0
37.0
36.0
35.0
35.0
36.0
36.0
.*V:K**;:x-:":*~:-.< ~,...: :.ซ>:<ป;ซ,,,
Sli*iiSSSii!5Si'SiIiiii
183111111111
33 0
ซ,J6J)..
36.0
36.0
33.0
35.0
41.0
38.0
34.0
33.0
' '. .'.'..''.'::.'-'.. ' f .' f'-ff .-ฃ.*' :
......... .;,.-,.:;.
40.0
37.0
34.0
36.0
33.0
':-''!:^&Kii&m
Res. 3
-~ ^
33.0
35.0
40.0
37.0
35.0
34.0
34.0
^BiiliRi
:^^!:Sfe::iS::::-::::::::;:;:::::::;;^>!:::i:::::
- .- --... ..-, -.-..-. : :::: ::::.:-:-;.:.:.;.; .
35.0
36.0
34.0
30.0
37.0
35.0
38.0
35.0
32.0
34.0
37.0
,37-0
llitilllfilll
33 0
_J5.0
36.0
35.0
35.0
34.0
39.0
35.0
34.0
tilfllilf
v:;::S& 7fi fl X-^XX;-
#S^'fW$t#$&
33.0
tฃ W-'^~ ''"': '''&-ฃ'':i$':f-
39.0
33.0
'"'-,-..' ''.'"''''" '"' " v !' ...''
34.0
35.0
34.0
lilt^f
data submitted
|^0 s Insufficient
data
-
Exper.
Sigma
^
0.58
0.58
2.08
2.52
1.73
0.58
2.52
liiiiiiiit
153
1.00
1.53
0.58
1.53
1.00
1.00
0.58
1.53
0.58
0.58
1.00
ซgf;sas:s>js;W!!
|!-ปf:sSss;;5s*SSs s
i:::;::.::;;-':-:::^:.:.:-^::':':f:;:yj>:':;::.j:::'':^-;:
IlllilllfilSI
0.58
__0.68
0.00
1.00
1.53
0.58
2.52
5.13
0.00
0.58
^w.;-.!';Pf^^
:;V:'.- ?.": :--i--:::'?---fr'-'-:- ':'/
2.65
2.08
0.00
0.58
0.58
>':":-' ''!: '-'/'-^
Rnganal
(R + SR)
0.118
0.118
0.473
0.591
0.354
0.118
J).591
SSsivSwS^
0^54""**
0.236
0.354
0.118
0.354
__0^36/
Q^g""*"-
0.118
0.354
0.118
0.118
0.236
oils V'''''"'T:'
,,,,,,,,,.9.:.i18...
0.000
0.236
0.354
0.118
0.591
1.345
0.000
iililliiliillll
%iz:'-t$$(f^si&%K$
0.118
' . ||,K. ';'-- :..;-..-... .1 '.->:....... ';\',;&:''v!'';:
0.591
0.473
'' :. *"1 ;:'..';'
0.000
0.118
0.118
''''' ''" ' '': '. ' '. '' ". .v .''. .
Average
33.33
34.33
37.67
34.33
34.00
34.67
_33.67m
;^^Wi5^^^:^:S:ii^^^
33.67
35.00
32.67
30.67
35.67
35.00
37.00
35.33
33.33
34.67
36.67
36.00
:ป*ป?*<:*--:>*::*:-
vii^!*::^ii!iS!SiS!i
3333
35.33
3600
36.00
33.33
34.67
38.67
33.67
34.00
ilflSitl
.'!"1'S vi'Si:SS
::. "... ;...:;: 5 ::i::i/S
38.00
34.67
'. .:.'::.'::';:.;: ,:>:;::ซ:;>...;:
'- '.i:-"'':."'ir>::'::il:i:-
34.00
35.33
33.67
''!':lMw!Sl
TAG SYMBOLS
x = Determined
====^=== =
to be an outlier
- __
=====
Normalized
(grand-avg
^* O
-0.75
-0.41
0.75
-0.41
-0.52
-0.29
-0.64
-0.64
-0.18
-0.99
-1.68
0.05
-0.18
W^KKHSm^tsssms:
0.52
-0.06
-0.75
-0.29
0.40
0.17
-0.75
-0.06
6.17
0.17
-0.75
-0.29
1.09
-0.64
-0.52
-0.99
5>S:?:>:!S:?::: H-:" v; '::i-S V:::"/:.^:';:::-^': : ':?::
0.86
-0.29
wmm ซ'ซ:.# ป:
* ฅ*&?&?&' ^vi'ii;"...:'. -'' i'.:;i
-0.52
-0.06
-0.64
tl s Above
U s Below
===;
deviation
}_ (known) Tag
^O23
0.12
1.27
0.12
0.00
0.23
-0.12
^1**"**
0.35
-0.46
-1.15
0.58
.... ฐ-35
j^'-* "
0.46
-0.23
0.23
092
V.<7ซ
_0.69_
-023
\J *tA\J
0.46
^^^^KBW^SBWsjSffl
0.69
0.69
-0.23
0.23
1.62
-0.12
0.00
llIIlilBSii!P
i'il4;4^'.iSI>x'^^ II
-0.46
:;ซ?!ซ:
S^^^^W?.*^^
1,39
0.23
:f?:::':>::5?..-/ซV ;f rx'- .:.ซป.
^.;/.'.-'-.5Ci^'l'-.*ซft":*'l
0.00
0.46
-0.12
.^^^^^Mll
1 ' """" II
control limit
control limit 1
Jj
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
40/44
Cesium-137
Lab
Res. 1
Exper. Rng anal Normalized deviation
Res. 2 Res. 3 Sigma (R + SR) Average (grand-avg) (known) Tag
EX
FE
34.0 39.0
?; -\'>j '.- "'
37.0
2.52
FJ
FL
38.0
37.0
37.0
36.0
38.0
33.0
0.58
2.08
ii(tx.- ,..^~sy< .V^^-j*;
0.591 36.67 0.40 0.92
..-A-
0.118 37.67 0*76 1.27
0.473 35.33 -0.06 0.46
36.0
36.0
36.0
0.00
"$*&
HK 37.0
HL 40.0
35.0
37.0
37.0
JE
JO
JM
JQ
JS
JX
JY
K
36.0
5LO
35.0
33.0
^X ^ W<)
37.0
33.0
35.0
37.0
36.0
-. 0 t" <
" ->V \
33.0
36.0
33.0
38.0
37.0
38.0
35.0
62-0
36.0
34.0
\ s
^:..Ji'.
36.0
35.0
Kf
KX
L
LE
35.0
35.0
44.0
35.0
37.0
41.0
38.0
33.0
42.0
0.58
1.73
1.73
1.00
0.58
0.58
0.58
0.58
1.15
1.73
2.00
1.53
0.000 36.00 0.17 0.69
0.118 37.33^ 0.63 1.15
0.354 38.00 0.86 1.39
,,-, ^^^\^I^^^|^?^@|jปl,
0.354 36.00 0.17 0.69
0.236 36.00
;fv"t.-/'^
0.118
0.17
0.69
0.11S
0118
0.236
0.354
0.473
0.354
36.33
33.67
-0.64 -0.12
* v- ' ^^c-^ft^- -*" 5rosW" "ซ **** <3Kt
> x - t^" Xftt ซ ^ VV - %V " *0i" N "V. ^"'' * sj
'^f^C^^^^^^rt*
v\s ;^*^'.* ^r^V'^*-1 " ^^?
- ^ ^ซs
,--ซ.^
36.00
35.00
42.33
0.17
-0.18
2.36
0.69
0.35
2.89
LF
LL
LR
LT
M
MF
MP
MT
MV
MY
N
3
37.0
-.
33.0
35.0
36.0
32.0
31.0
31.0
> .:; 'v'V ; '..,'
36.0
.
32.0
35.0
34.0
35.0
31.0
30.0
,' ""'':'';..: ;": ''.
36.0
35.0
34.0
35.0
35.0
30.0
31.0
No data submitted
0.58 0.118
1.53 0.354
0.58 0.118
1.00 0.236
1.73 0.354
0.58 0.118
0.58 0.118
TAG SYMBOLS
Determined to be an
36.33
: -;;;?: '.-:*
33.33
34.67
35.00
- ',-'-: \
34.00
30.67
30.67
outlier
...,O.J8_v.^
'- ;':v^\-> %\
-0.75
-0.29
-0.18
- ; "
-0.52
-1.68
-1.68
ft = Above
Ji = Below
,.0.81>w ^
^^^:^ซsf*
-0.23
0.23
.0.35^^
,--\- v,.^ -\-.ซ
-------
41/44
Cesium-137
Lab Res. 1
NA
NH
NJ
NK
NO
O
OB
OP
OM
W-?-^.,:, ;-,
37.0
35.0
34.0
39.0
42.0
36.0
,' -,: ;?dt ^
39.0
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Res. 2
: >,&%%"*
39.0
34.0
32.0
44.0
40.0
37.0
TK'f2'f5-
38.0
-fc I* ' ' > if > ,?" '^ff * *;>ฃ%" "5*"* y"ป'ซ'"-Jf
os /; - 'i;^:v^^%fMf
otf
pw;
PA
PB
PD
PG
PM
PQ
PW
Q
QM
QP
QQ
QT
QU
QW
QX
QZ
RB
RD
RF
n fi '
RG
RI
RK
RP
RR
RU
RZ
S
sc
SD
SF
SG
SI
?ฅx':31
?/: ,!|Cd|^
V-5 .O--*f;?
32.0
35.0
'Ifrx:^^
33.0
-: 1? ~. ''<
35.0
32.0
42.0
35.0
35.0
40.0
35.0
41.0
36.0
38.0
32.0
36.0
32.0
32.0
37.0
4C'"fii!&
" vO^>
32.0
35.0
'"'V-^M'
38.0
' * ^:X:
33.0
37.0
38.0
35.0
' V^r
36.0
40.0
43.0
39.0
38.0
\< %
' ^ -* ',
***ซ,"/ '
*"/j
38.0
34.0
34.0
33.0
34.0
40.0
Res. 3
,,:;-i^ - , ,
39.0
36.0
33.0
46.0
36.0
37.0
- *"$&<$ฃ'? "-'": -
CN-*.>^%~^-"!X:"
39.0
^Mii'ฃ*fCj&<
&&ฃ&/?*Mi&
^f/yfty*. $'$' '>>ฃ;v*f*\ *<
Exper.
Sigma
s
1.15
1.00
1.00
3.61
3.06
0.58
ซ' ' * / " ><
0.58
g|;j-^;
Ir^vH'''^
Rnganal
(R + SR) Average
.
0.236
0.236
0.236
0.827
0.709
0.118
1 ' ' --'l*?ง
0.118
^J;f ;'^
v* f- "" % '''^ ^
*ซ ^*. * , <#;\'\
> ' *t '* / . *
, '- V
38.33
35.00
33.00
43.00
39.33
36.67
^?"43!u-\r .>,<;-:;?:?
0.98
-0.18
-0.87
2.59
1.32
0.40
'if^WS^V^
L09
^^^fe^^fe
'^-^H'V*^'
1.50
0.35
-0.35
3.12 ft
1.85
0.92
^J?|v^t^ซ^-
1.62
gg|3?
SflifcM
S^^So^^*S"5iob -"' ''"-. ii346t^
32.0
38.0
ftf^}>--U- '
33.0
/<;;, v--^ -
35.0
37.0
37.0
35.0
- ! -~'.;>i-, ; ป ''
33.0
38.0
38.0
41.0
^37.0
'',' :^-~*S''"' ;'
' ' ^'^ ^ .
*'"'.
' * '\, ' "' -
''-' *<*
..'..**
37.0
33.0
34.0
34.0
34.0
34.0
s No data submitted
0 3
Insufficient
data
X H
.' : \ > ' - j
0.00
1.73
'" ' -* ~,
2.89
1.15
2.89
2.65
0.00
1.53
1.15
4.04
1.15
1.00
;- -. '
0.58
1.00
1.15
1.00
1.15
3.00
.' ' '"
0.000
0.354
0.591
0.236
0.591
0.591
0.000
0.354
0.236
0.945
0.236
0.236
0.118
0.236
0.236
0.236
0.236
0.709
^*7 "-I", ''-. *%*
32.00
36.00
"'':\- -'-IT ;^
34.67
\'f ,; " , .V-< - '
34.33
35.33
39.00
35.00
.^..^W'^ir.
34.67
39.33
38.67
40.33
37.00
>",' ;"";ฐ|."
,- -
,
37.67
33.00
34.67
33.00
33.33
-
37.00
TAG SYMBOLS
Determined
to be an
outlier
"S^>*"-Vi-''% ':, *
-1.22
0.17
*$&g?!^W: W-
' _^_ J-0.29^ _"
lC?^i^-,C^v^
-0.41
-0.06
1.21
-0.18
^^s^Tj^I
-0.29
1.32
1.09
1.67
0.6^ %i
~ ""' 'f ""_7; ?'.' .-Tsf '?' -:
f " .' S *'* ' ' '' '
; \ s"" "
' \' . ,.';" ' ^ ', ''*.
'' * ' "" ~" .".<
-. "-,.*.
'-, ,""-':-; ;''.';
0.75
-0.87
-0.29
-0.87
-0.75
0.52
ft s Above
Jl = Below
X^v*'--' f,-?l;\ . '''#-"' "'
-0.69
0.69
"5;J^=|^^1
0.23* "*'" "**!
^?^l^^ilf
0.12
0.46
1.73
0.35
I^p'l^^tH
0.23
1.85
1.62
2.19
1.04
^;-;;.r^j"r;:; '!
*-:*;^;'ซ'i I
; ' '!",:.
' ^ A*^ %W'':'
,.''' t'^^j\*'^;
j^lV'-^^^^V
-- '-^ ' '/k^-*^
? ^^^t'V^*!
f /.-"i'K*ปp*
1.27
-0.35
0.23
-0.35
-0.23
"" v ^
1.04
control limit
control limit
-------
Cesium- 137
Lab Res. 1
8L
SM.
SN
'4 - -
SO
SR
ss
sx
sz
T
TO
" ซปซ'
\r^'-~
~ TK-
TQ
% * A Cง **
" ifBryi'
"uv::
.UA
UK
UP
X<* >*: '
XX%r
^^
UY
VA
VC
VH
VI
VJ
VM
VO
VT
W
WE
WH
WO
WR
WW
X
XA
XC
XD
XF
XI
XJ
XK
XL
XM
38.0
37.0
<' V
33.0
40.0
34.0
36.0
34.0
34.0
' % ^ ^ s s ซ ss% ^ %
->\-v-v^'l -,-~i^s
! -"-* ' r"l;-"-J--^
35.0
:-\ ป" * V .; ''.
X ' ->X> " '- . N\N
- -" -,''',.!
40.0
36.0
o v ' ^ ' * s " '- s*
- ^ \,
35.0
43.0
34.0
36.0
\ v %
. 33.0
40.0
36.0
40.0
33.0
33.0
40.0
33.0
..
35.0
39.0
ESD-LV
Res. 2
* .. v\-
37.0
35.0
'J s * X \
31.0
38.0
31.0
33.0
34.0
36.0
'""V ""T1"'. -^ vซฃvv\ N^ V**"
^*,v^^^^)?
^iC,'> -%;?> x
34.0 ^
v^lfei?
v^vrj^j?1'
r^^^'C- A "
30.0
36.0
^, *; iss "f
\ ** 5 n s
39.0
41.0
34.0
39.0
' :*< v : ^i:.
t , "~ - ;'-"
33.0
42.0
33.0
-
40.0
35.0
32.0
40.0
35.0
37.0
37.0
Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Res. 3
36.0
34.0
>'; : r '
33.0
37.0
32.0
31.0
36.0
39.0
^V ~* "' '
,' X-. <.'--'!"-'' '
\\VV'^-^- -
34.0
;i;^>;:"
"ป" Vfx!-' \
>>,".;,
35.0
36.0
" ^v^1 ^ ^""v s ^
\~v\"
35.0
39.0
34.0
--;- V; '"
33.0
^^^i r?
' v^
32.0
41.0
34.0
,
40.0
35.0
31.0
38.0
34.0
37.0
38.0
s No data submitted
0 s
Insufficient
data
x =
Exper. Rng anal
Sigma (R + SR) Average
- ,
1.00
. 1;53 ^ __>%
:,",'^ -v- "'' .
1.15
1.53
1.53
2.52
1.15
2.52
X^ " ^ '*'* " ^
;'.,-. ,,"' C-v-^.X":i'X"
% J.,0.68^
-;, ^-s ;, y:X-s;-tJ
^.-;;,t,. V^lv'-,
" % \4\ -."M^r % "* x
5.00
0.00
11 s% " " ' ; " ^X "" " ^^"^
N - \ ^ '
" *
2.31
2.00
0.00
ฐ - ~.\
3.00
;"'"';"/ ' ' " r
'" .,:"-- -ฐ. v
0.58
1.00
1.53
0.00
1.15
1.00
1.15
1.00
1.15
1.00
0.236
0.354
0.236
0.354
0.354
0.591
0.236
0.591
^"" % * ^" "SJ^
- * :> -\ -^
S!'i-%
0.118
'''^i-vs-
ff'^^
vWi\
1^345
0.000
X '.? XX" "
- * " ^ *- *
0.473
0.473
0.000
; ! "
0.709
"y "/^
o_ \ \ -.
0.118
0.236
0.354
0.000
0.236
0.236
0.236
0.236
0.236
0.236
-, - ซ>t--:v -V?
37.00
,._.35.,33 ,
"; ' ; >^57s' '? ;
32.33
38.33
32.33
33.33
34.67
36.33
T? ^'T* s "! '5S V % "
*.-: V- -; >>4%Q-!*
{ป>f-il$ฃ^iN\ 'vfc
^J^4,33
<-:lf;^|งง^|
!f>V^|"^^
35.00
36.00
s s ; \ ^ N ^ '$*>' ^^ ^ C'^>C1
* s V* v^^s 5 ^ *"* * s^s
-^ s " ฐs " ',"^\ N C~v\ i-
36.33
41.00
34.00
- -:,- ,v,~-'^i>v!
36.00
"T? "'^T'S^S^
^-^V^'^
32!67
41.00
34.33
40.00
34.33
32.00
39.33
34.00
; -' ^ \
"\' ^ "
36.33
38.00
,%
TAG SYMBOLS
Determined to
be an
outlier
42/44
Normalized deviation
(grand-avg) (known) Tag
;-"";- \v-.^ ivii
0.52
^^06^
'\ '\-,'-- x^?'"-';??'^^-
-l!lO
0.98
-1.10
-0.75
-0.29
0.28
""vv-xr-.'v* '" *
;vX%tH;v.v?1:;X^
&SrfSI4
-0.99
1.90
-0.41
- , " s^
X " "' ' t
1.55
-0.41
-1.22
1.32
-0.52
-.s^ * 0^^ ,..,,.. ^ v^, ^s ,
-Xs-^- '-r^" ^
0.28
0.86
X
$ s Above
JJ. = Below
:v^|.^v^4*^
1.04
0.46
^{^S:-xr5tซ^
-0.58
1.50
-0.58
-0.23
0.23
0.81
^ "X o"1 ' s f i* v>** " ^^ " * X"1?
^felv^k*^
i~^^~KsW^|S
* 6.12
^lfplsปlf
^^tfelt
^-fc%f%!ra
&5ฅ^J|5S|||*|P|l
0.35
0.69
^^^^^^S*'^*^1^^-^^'
fe^fi^SJ.. ^'^p** ^M^>*
,- \s v*!ซ'*" ^\ x^v-i.% vv
0.81
2.42
0.00
c"'?^ip5*i<{ง
0.69
^^^s^fs
iSSi^i
-0.46
2.42
>--''
2.08
0.12
-0.69
1.85
0.00
VSTC- " ^ ;" , "^ sw V1* T^X-
feฃ-v>vS'.!p$.|54
0.81
,A
ป
1.39
^
" .,
control limit
control limit
-------
"
43/44 ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
Cesium-137
Lab Res. 1 Res. 2
XO '/ :r'ฃ:
Exper. Rng anal
Res. 3 Sigma (R + SR)
; w>~, -/ ; - - " '". "
Normalized deviation
Average (grand-avg) "(known)
I *v';;
I
Tag
III
Data sorted by Laboratory Average
Average Tag
14.00 x
17.67 x
24.33 x
30.67
30.67
30.67
32.00
32.00
32.33
32.33
32.67
32.67
32.67
33.00
33.00
33.00
33.33
33.33
33.33
33.33
33.33
33.33
33.33
33.33
33.67
33.67
33.67
33.67
33.67
34.00
34.00
34.00
34.00
34.00
34.00
34.33
34.33
s No data submitted
1 0 s Insufficient data
Lab
P
IU
HI
MY
MV
BA
WW
PB
sx
SR
VO
DE
AZ
SD
S
NK
SZ
SF
LR
JS
CO
C
BL
A
K
EL
CX
AU
AL
XA
VC
MP
E
D
AJ
WR
W
Average Tag
34.33
34.33
34.33
34.33
34.67
34.67
34.67
34.67
34.67
34.67
34.67
34.67
34.67
35.00
35.00
35.00
35.00
35.00
35.00
35.00
35.33
35.33
35.33
35.33
35.33
35.33
35.67
35.67
36.00
36.00
36.00
36.00
36.00
36.00
36.00
36.00
36.00
TAG SYMBOLS
x s Determined to be an
^ ^ ~" "" * " ."-.-".-.'.'
Lab
TQ
PW
AH
AE
T
SC
QT
PM
LT
DT
CP
BM
AK
UK
QP
NJ
M
L
BC
AW
SN
Q
FL
EB
CA
BK
JM
BB
VI
UP
PD
KX
JE
I
GQ
CJ
CE
Average Tag
36.00
36.33
36.33
36.33
36.33
36.33
36.67
36.67
36.67
37.00
37.00
37.00
37.00
37.33
37.67
37.67
37.67
38.00
38.00
38.00
38,33
38.33
38.67
38.67
38.67
39.00
39.33
39.33
39.33
40.00
40.33
41.00
41.00
42.33
A
43.00 It
51.33 x
75.67 x
Lab
BO
XF
UY
TD
LF
JY
OB
FE
BN
SM
SI
QZ
BH
HK
RZ
FJ
AF
XK
HL
DO
SS
NH
QW
OM
CS
QM
X
QU
o
wo
QX
VT
VA
LE
NO
JG
DD
It s Above control limit
outlier jj 5 Below control limit_
' " "- '
-------
ESD-LV Performance Evaluation: Blind-B, 21-Oct-1997
44/44
Cesium-137
% responding labs
Frequency distribution
10
-A 0 +2 +4
Normalized deviation of the mean from the known value
% responding labs
Frequency distribution
10
u
ill^.
-4-20+2 +4
Normalized deviation of the mean from the grand average
------- |