FINAL NESHAP STANDARDS FOR WASTE OPERATIONS:
BASIS FOR IMPACT CALCULATIONS
Prepared for
Chemicals and Petroleum Branch
Emission Standards Division
Office of Air Quality Planning Standards
United States Environmental Protection Agency
February 16, 1990
-------
FINAL NESHAP STANDARDS FOR WASTE OPERATIONS:
BASIS FOR IMPACT CALCULATIONS
Prepared for
Chemicals and Petroleum Branch
Emission Standards Division
Office of Air Quality Planning Standards
United States Environmental Protection Agency
February 16, 1990
-------
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. Introduction *
2. Petroleum Refineries 2
3. Coke By-Product Recovery Pi ants 19
4. Off-site Treatment, Storage, and Disposal Facilities 20
5. Chemical PI ants 23
6. Cost Estimates 28
7- Summary of Nationwide Impacts 29
8. Site-Spec1 fic Analyses 32
9. References 43
Appendix A Additional Details for Petroleum Refinery Estimates
Appendix B Additional Details for Offsite TSDF and Chemical Plant
Estimates
Appendix C Estimates of Fraction Emitted
Appendix D HEM Inputs and Results
Appendix E Cost Estimates
-------
1. INTRODUCTION
This document presents the basis for the revised estimates of
Impacts associated with the control of benzene emissions from waste
operations at petroleum refineries; coke by-product recovery plants;
off-site treatment, storage and disposal facilities; and chemical
plants. The estimates of impacts presented at proposal were revised and
updated to quantify some of the uncertainties identified at proposal.
The only revision required as a result of a change in the proposed
standard was to Include only benzene in aqueous wastes (wastes with 10
percent or more water) 1n the calculation of the 10 Mg/yr benzene
cutoff. The major revisions focused on the following areas:
1. Identification of facilities with benzene wastes.
2. Estimates of the number of waste streams and total quantity of
waste containing benzene.
3. The emission modeling approach, especially the wastewater
collection system and oil-water separators.
4. Accounting for benzene losses prior to the point for which
benzene concentration data were reported.
5. Cost estimates.
6. Providing a range of emission estimates.
7. Updating the estimates of risk and incidence.
8. Performing a more detailed analysis of a few specific sites.
Although these revised impacts are based in part on additional
information, some of which was supplied by commenters on the proposed
rule, many of the uncertainties discussed at proposal still exist.
These uncertainties arise from incomplete site-specific data on waste
3
-------
quantities, benzene concentrations at the point of generation, and was e
management processes. However,, this analysis provides a range of
emission estimates for specific facilities based on reported ranges of
benzene concentration, and also examines the upper and lower bounds of
the uncertainties in the emission estimates for some specific sites.
The emission estimates presented in this analysis are current best
estimates, but the ranges of estimates do not represent the full range
of possible variations. Because of unknown site-specific factors, the
actual emissions from a given facility may be higher or lower than the
estimates presented here for that facility.
2. PETROLEUM REFINERIES
2.1 Ma.jor Wastes with Benzene
The approach for estimating benzene emissions from wastes at
petroleum refineries focused on those major waste streams most likely to
contain benzene. A total of 13 wastewater streams associated with
specific processes was identified based on comments provided by the
American Petroleum Institute (API)1 and on engineering judgements as to
which refinery processes are the most likely to contain benzene. These
processes are listed in Table 2-1 with a typical generation factor in
terms of gallons of wastewater per barrel of process capacity. Capacity
data for the different processes were obtained for 187 petroleum
refineries operating in 1989 from the Oil and Gas Journal.2 For each of
these petroleum refineries, an estimate of the quantity of each
wastewater stream produced was obtained by multiplying the site-specific
capacity data by the generation factors given in Table 2-1. Additional
-------
TABLE 2-1. MAJOR WASTEWATER STREAMS THAT CONTAIN BENZENE AT PETROLEUM REFINERIES
A
Process
1.
2.
3.
4.
6.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
Crude storage
Desalting
Atmospheric
distillation
Gas processing
Catalytic
reforming
Catalytic cracker
Visbreaking
Coking
Naphtha sweetening
Light product storage
Light product storage
Slop oi 1 tank*
Wastewater Source (s)
Residual water in crude
Water washing
Condensed stripping
steam from overhead
accumulator
Caustic and water wash
Condensed stripping
steam from overhead
accumu later
Overhead accumu 1 ators
and steam strippers on
the fractionator, catalyst
regeneration
Accumulator on the
f ractionator
Contact process water and
steam overhead accumulators
Water washers, caustic
washer, spent caustic
Water draw from the
storage tank
Sludges from the tank
Water draws from the
Rate"
(gal/B) Reference Capacity Basisb
2.0
0.002
0.3
0.08
0.22
1.1
O. 06-0. 3
3.1
0.08
0.02-0.2
O.02-O.2
0.2-2
3
3
3
3
3
3
c
3
4
d
d
f
crude oi 1
crude oi 1
crude oi 1
crude oi 1
catalytic reforming
catalytic cracking
visbreaking
delayed coking
catalytic hydrotreating
40% to BOX of crude*
4OX to BOX of crude*
O.O5 to 0.65? of crude?
13. Benzene production
bottom of the sI op oil
tank
Wastewater from BTX
and benzene production
BTX and hydrodeaIkylatlon
-------
,\
" Generation rate in gallons per barrel of capacity for wastewater discharged directly to the sewer.
" The process for which site-specific capacity data from the Oil and Cas Journal^ were used to estimate
wastewater quantity.
c This wastewater is from accumulator on the fractionator. Similar sources include atmospheric
distillation (0.3 gal/B) and naphtha hydrodesulfurization (0.09 gal/B).
^ Assume 1 to 10 percent of that from crude storage.
* From Reference 5, gasoline averages 42 percent of crude oil. Use a range of 4O to 50 percent.
* Assume 10 to 1OO percent of that from crude storage.
9 Based on 1C gallons of wastewater per barrel of crude (Reference 4) and O.I to 1 percent oil
in the wastewater (Reference 6).
-------
details on the capacity data and quantity of major wastewater streams
that contain benzene are given for each refinery in Appendix A.
A range of benzene concentrations was developed for each wastewater
stream to place reasonable bounds on possible concentrations. The
concentration ranges are presented in Table 2-2 and are based on the
expected benzene concentration in the processes, an oil content in the
V
wastewater of 0.1 to 1 percent**, and the partitioning of benzene between
the oilrwater of 80 to 100:1.7 For example, the typical concentrations
of benzene in crude oil are given 1n Table 2-3 and show a range of 700
to 1900 ppm with most at the upper end of the range. These data were
used to estimate the benzene concentration 1n water separated from crude
oil in storage. For the lower end of the range, the partitioning of
benzene between the crude oil and water was estimated as 100:1, and 0.1
percent oil was estimated to be entrained in the water:
concentration 1n water = 700 ppm/100 = 7 ppm
concentration in oil = 700 ppm
concentration in wastewater with 0.1 percent oil =
(0.001) x 700 + (0.999) x 7 = 8 ppm.
For the upper end of the range, the concentration of benzene in the
crude oil was estimated as 1,900 ppm, the partitioning was 80:1, and the
water was estimated to contain 1 percent oil:
concentration in water = 1,900 ppm/80 = 24 ppm
concentration 1n oil = 1,900 ppm
concentration in wastewater with 1 percent oil =
(0.01) x 1,900 + (0.999) x 24 = 43 ppm.
-------
TABLE 2-2. RANGES OF BENZENE CONCENTRATION FOR MAJOR WASTEWATER STREAMS
Dv.^ao. c „ Renzene Concentration (pom)
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
Crude storage
Desalting
Atmospheric distillation
Gas processing
Catalytic reforming
Catalytic cracking
Visbreaking
Coking
Naphtha sweetening
Light product storage (water)
Light product storage (sludge)
Slop oil tanks
Benzene production
8
8
13
13
500
13
13
13
13
13
13
8
180
- 43a
- 43
- 320b
- 320
- 63QC
- 320
- 320
- 320
- 320
- 320
- 320
'- 43
- l,800d
a Based on 700 to 1,900 ppm benzene in crude oil. 0.1 to 1 percent oil in the
water, and benzene partitioning into oil:water of 80 to 100:1.
b Benzene in gasoline ranges from 0.12 to 1.4 percent, most around 1 percent
from Reference 8. Assume 0.1 to 1 percent gasoline with wastewater and
partitioning of 80 to 100:1. (Other sources Indicate that the current
trend is toward higher concentrations of benzene in gasoline; consequently,
the upper end of the range is probably more applicable.)
c Based on the reformer product containing 5 percent benzene and partitioning
of 80 to 100:1.
d Assume that wastewater from contact with BTX or benzene ranges from 10 to
100 percent of saturation (1,800 ppm).
-------
TABLE 2-3. BENZENE CONCENTRATION IN CRUDE OIL8
Type Benzene Concentration (ppm)
Louisiana Gulf 1,500
West Texas 1,800
Venezuelan 1,500
Libyan 700
Nigerian 1,100
Iranian 1,900
-------
A similar approach was used for other benzene wastewaters and the
details are given 1n the footnotes to Table 2-2. If emuls1f1cat1on or
other separation problems occur, the concentration of oil 1n the oily
wastewater may be greater than 1 percent, and the benzene concentration
in the oily wastewater could exceed the upper bound estimate presented
In Table 2-2.
Sludges that contain benzene are also generated at petroleum
refineries. For this analysis, data for sludges with specific RCRA
waste codes were used from the 1987 survey of hazardous waste
generators.10 These wastes Include float from d1ssolved-air flotation
(DAF) units (K048), slop oil solids (K049), heat exchanger sludge
(K050), API separator sludge (K051), and leaded tank bottom (K050). A
typical generation rate for these sludges was derived by taking the
waste quantity data from the survey of hazardous waste generators (shown
1n Table 2-4) for specific facilities and dividing this quantity by the
facility's crude oil capacity. From these results shown 1n Table 2-4, a
median value was chosen for the generation factor. The generation
factor was multiplied by site-specific capacity data to estimate the
quantity of these sludges generated at each of the 187 petroleum
refineries. Typical ranges for the concentration of benzene in these
sludges are also shown in Table 2-4 and were derived from the
concentrations reported from the generator's survey (Table A-4 in
Appendix A).
2.2 Emission Estimates
The primary source for emission estimates for wastewater treatment
systems is the Control Technology Center (CTC) document "Industrial
-------
TABLE 2-4. GENERATION FACTORS FOR RCRA HAZARDOUS WASTES AT PETROLEUM REFINERIES
CRUDE OIL
CAPACITY
FACILITY CITY STATE (BPD)*
DAF FLOAT (1 to 100 ppin benzene):
FINA OIL i CHEMICAL PORT ARTHUR TX 1.00E+05
LION OIL EL DORADO AR 4.80E+04
CONOCO LANDFARM BILLINGS MT 4.85E+04
HUNT REFINING TUSCALOOSA AL 4.45E+04
HUNT REFINING TUSCALOOSA AL 4.45E+04
MARATHON PETROLEUM ROBINSON IL 1.95E+05
QUAKER STATE REFININGEMLENTON PA 6.50E+03
CHEVRON REFINERY PERTH AMBOY NJ 8.00E+04
CHEVRON EL PASO TX 6.60E+04
ATLANTIC REFINING PHILADELPHIA PA 1.25E+05
QUAKER STATE REFININGEMLENTON PA 6.50E+03
AMOCO OIL LANDFARM TEXAS CITY TX 4.20E+05
MARATHON PETROLEUM GARYVILLE LA 2.55E+05
SHELL OIL DEER PARK TX 2.16E+05
MONTANA REFINING CO. BLACK EAGLE MT 6.30E+03
CHEVRON SALT LAKE CITY UT 4.50E+04
CITGO PETROLEUM LAKE CHARLES LA 3.20E+05
CROSS OIL & REFINING SMACKOVER AR 6.77E+03
SHELL OIL DEER PARK TX 2.16E+05
SINCLAIR OIL SINCLAIR WY 5.4QE+04
SLOP OIL SOLIDS (1 to 100 ppra benzene):
SUN REFINING TULSA OK 8.50E+04
CHEVRON PHILADELPHIA PA 1.74E+05
MARATHON PETROLEUM ROBINSON IL 1.95E+05
MARATHON PETROLEUM GARYVILLE LA 2.55E+05
CITGO PETROLEUM LAKE CHARLES LA 3.20E+05
SWEENY REFINERY OLD OCEAN TX 1.75E+05
FINA OIL BIG SPRING TX 5.50E+04
STANDARD OIL OREGON OH 1.71E+05
AMOCO OIL REFINERY YORKTOWN VA 5.10E+04
ATLANTIC REFINING PHILADELPHIA PA 1.25E+05
FRONTIER OIL CHEYENNE WY 3.50E+04
HEAT EXCHANGER SLUDGE (10 to 100 ppra benzene):
QUAKER STATE REFININGEMLENTON PA 6.50E+03
FRONTIER OIL CHEYENNE WY 3.50E+04
CHEVRON EL PASO TX 6.60E+04
CHEVRON PORT ARTHUR TX 3.29E+05
AMOCO OIL REFINERY YORKTOWN VA 5.10E+04
SHELL OIL REFINERY ROXANA IL 2.74E+05
SINCLAIR OIL SINCLAIR WY 5.40E+04
SHELL OIL ANACORTES WA 8.40E+04
AMOCO OIL LANDFARM TEXAS CITY TX 4.20E+05
CHEVRON PASCAGOULA MS 2.95E+05
CHEVRON PORT ARTHUR TX 3.29E+05
RCRA
CODE
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K049
K049
K049
K049
K049
K049
K049
K049
K049
K049
K049
K050
K050
K050
K050
K050
K050
K050
K050
K050
K050
K050
WASTE GENERATION
QUANTITY FACTOR
(Mg/yr) (Mg/yr/BPD)
2.2E+04
1.8E+03
1.1E+03
9.8E+02
7.8E+02
3.4E+03
9.2E+01
1.0E+03
5.1E+02
9.0E+02
4.6E+01
2.8E+03
1.6E+03
1.1E+03
3.1E+01
1.2E+02
8.2E+02
7.3E+00
1.5E+02
1.8E+00
3.9E+04
2.4E+03
2.0E+03
1.9E+03
2.0E+03
9.9E+02
2.5E+02
5.1E+02
1.5E+02
1.0E+02
8.2E+00
5.4E+05
1.4E+03
1 .9E+01
4.9E+01
4.5E+00
2.3E+01
3.6E+00
3.6E+00
8.2E+00
3.6E+00
9.1E-01
2.2E-01
3.7E-02
2.3E-02
2.2E-02
1.8E-02
1.7E-02
1 .4E-02
1.3E-02
7.7E-03
7.2E-03 **
7.1E-03
6.6E-03
6.2E-03
5.3E-03
4.9E-03
2.7E-03
2.6E-03
1.1E-03
6.9E-04
3.4E-05
4.6E-01
1 .4E-02
1.0E-02
7.4E-03
6.4E-03
5.7E-03 ••
4.5E-03
3.0E-03
3.0E-03
8.3E-04
2.3E-04
8.3E+01
3.9E-02
2.9E-04
1.5E-04
8.9E-05
8.3E-05 **
6.7E-05
4.3E-05
1.9E-05
1.2E-05
2.8E-06
\\
-------
TABLE 2-4. GENERATION FACTORS FOR RCRA HAZARDOUS WASTES AT PETROLEUM REFINERIES
(continued)
FACILITY CITY STATE
API SEPARATOR SLUDGE (1 to 100 ppffl
FRONTIER OIL CHEYENNE
SHELL OIL REFINERY ROXANA
SHELL OIL ANACORTES
QUAKER STATE REFININGEMLENTON
ARCO PETROLEUM FERNDALE
PHILLIPS 66 REFINERY BORGER
LION OIL EL DORADO
SHELL OIL REFINERY ODESSA
PHILLIPS 66 WOODS CROSS
SHELL OIL MARTINEZ
AMOCO OIL REFINERY YORKTOWN
CHEVRON PASCAGOULA
AMOCO OIL LANDFARM TEXAS CITY
CONOCO LAMFARM BILLINGS
CONOCO REFINERY BILLINGS
SINCLAIR OIL TULSA
CHEVRON SALT LAKE CITY
MARATHON PETROLEUM GARYVILLE
MARATHON PETROLEUM ROBINSON
CHEVRON PORT ARTHUR
KOCH REFINING ROSEWOUNT
CRYSEN REF I N I NG WOODS CROSS
MONTANA REFINING CO. BLACK EAGLE
ATLANTIC REFINING PHILADELPHIA
CALCASIEU REFINING LAKE CHARLES
CHEVRON EL PASO
CITGO PETROLEUM LAKE CHARLES
COASTAL EAGLE PT. WESTVILLE
MOBIL OIL FERNDALE
CHEVRON REFINERY PERTH AMBOY
TESARO ALASKA PETROLEKENAI
SINCLAIR OIL SINCLAIR
CROSS OIL & REFINING SMACKOVER
SUN REFINING TULSA
CHEVRON REFINERY EWA BEACH
LEADED TANK BOTTOMS SLUDGE (10 to 1
CHEVRON EL PASO
CITGO PETROLEUM LAKE CHARLES
CHEVRON SALT LAKE CITY
AMOCO OIL REFINERY YORKTOWN
KOCH REFINING ROSEMDUNT
CRUDE OIL
CAPACITY
(BPD)*
RCRA
CODE
WASTE GENERATION
QUANTITY FACTOR
(Mg/yr) (Mg/yr/BPD)
benzene):
WY
IL
WA
PA
WA
TX
AR
TX
UT
CA
VA
MS
TX
MT
MT
OK
UT
LA
IL
TX
UN
UT
MT
PA
LA
TX
LA
NJ
WA
NJ
AK
WY
AR
OK
HI
,000
TX
LA
UT
VA
MN
3.50E+04
2.74E+05
8.40E+04
6.50E+03
1.62E+05
1.05E+05
4.80E+04
2.86E+04
2.50E+04
1.40E+05
5.10E+04
2.95E+05
4.20E+05
4.85E+04
4.B5E404
8.50E+04
4.50E+04
2.55E+05
1.95E+05
3.29E+05
2.19E+05
1.25E+04
6.30E+03
1.25E+05
1.20E+04
6.60E+04
3.20E+05
1.09E+05
7.70E+04
8.00E+04
7.20E+04
5.40E+04
6.77E+03
8.50E+04
4.80E+04
ppm benzene)
6.60E+04
3.20E+05
4.50E+04
5.10E+04
2.19E+05
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
:
K052
K052
K052
K052
K052
4.3E+03
1.6E+04
1.6E+03
9.2E+01
2.1E+03
1.1E+03
4.9E+02
2.6E+02
2.3E+02
1.2E+03
3.6E+02
2.1E+03
2.5E+03
2.0E+02
2.0E+02
2.5E+02
1.3E+02
6.3E+02
3.2E+02
5.1E+02
3.1E+02
1.7E+01
6.4E+00
1.2E+02
1.1E+01
5.8E+01
2.2E+02
4.2E+01
2.9E+01
3.0E+01
1.4E+01
7.3E+00
9.1E-01
1.1E+01
1.8EtOO
3.3E+01
9.6E+01
3.6E+00
9.1E-01
9.1E-01
1.2E-01
6.0E-02
1.9E-02
1.4E-02
1.3E-02
1.1E-02
1.0E-02
9.2E-03
9.1E-03
8.7E-03
7.1E-03
7.0E-03
5.9E-03
4.1E-03
4.1E-03
3.0E-03
2.8E-03
2.5E-03 **
1.6E-03
1.6E-03
1.4E-03
1.4E-03
1.0E-03
9.5E-04
9.1E-04
8.8E-04
6.9E-04
3.8E-04
3.8E-04
3.7E-04
1.9E-04
1.3E-04
1.3E-04
1.3E-04
3.8E-05
5.0E-04
3.0E-04
8.1E-05 **
1.8E-05
4.2E-06
* BPD - BARRELS PER DAY.
»• MEDIAN VALUE USED IN THE ANALYSIS.
-------
Wastewater Volatile Organic Compound Emissions—Background Information
for BACT/LAER Determinations."11 Modeling results are presented for
toluene, a compound with a volatility very similar to that of benzene,
in several different types of wastewater treatment units. A typical
layout of a petroleum refinery wastewater treatment system is given in
Figure 2-1. The system is composed of a wastewater collection system
(process drains, sewer lines, lift stations, junction boxes), an oil-
water separator, air flotation unit, equalization basin, clarifier, and
biobasin. For the system 1n Figure 2-1, the oil-water separator is
assumed to be an open unit and the equalization basin is not aerated for
mixing. A second system was constructed in Figure 2-2 with a covered
oil-water separator because some refineries have applied covers to
reduce emissions of volatile compounds.
Each figure presents the distribution of benzene for 1 unit of
benzene that enters the wastewater collection system. For the
collection system, the CTC document provided estimates for 3 model units
with fractions emitted of 0.21, 0.38, and 0.44.11 An average value of
0.34 (34 percent of the benzene entering the collection system is
emitted) was used for the petroleum refinery wastewater collection
system. A fraction emitted of 0.47 from the CTC document was used for
the open oil-water separator, and emissions from the covered oil-water
separator were assumed to be negligible. The results for an aerated
equalization basin were used to simulate the air stripping that occurs
in an air flotation unit (fraction emitted=0.99). For the nonaerated
equalization basin, the CTC document estimates the fraction emitted as
0.4. For the clarifier and biobasin, the fractions emitted were
-------
E = 0.0002
in=l
i
E = 0.34
Collection °-66
System
(fe = 0.34)
E = 0.31
j Open
^ Oil -Water
Separator
(fc = 0.47)
028
-^- Storage
E - 0.069
0.07 _ 0.001
^ DAF
Water
(fe = 0.99)
^- Sludge
E = 0.0004
Float ^
^ Equalization
Basin
(fe = 0
(fe « 0.025)
.4) I
J0.0006
Clarifier
Fraction emitted:
0.34
031
0.069
0.72
(fe = 0.06 to 0.12)
J0.00058
= 0.00002
E = 0.00005
Degraded = 0.00053
FIGURE 2-1. DISTRIBUTION OF BENZENE IN WASTEWATER TREATMENT (open separator)
(E = fraction of original quantity emitted; fe = fraction entering the unit that is emitted)
-------
E = 0.0003
^
ction emitt
0.34
0.129
0.47
E = 0.34
t
roll^rirm °-W
System
(fe = 0.34)
ed:
E = negligible
T Covered
Separator
033
E- 0.129
I
\
0.13 _
^^ DAF
Water
(fe = 0.99)
^- Sludge
E - 0.0004
Float
f
0.001
Equalization
Basin
(fe = 0.
|o.0006
(fe = 0.025) Clarifier
(fe = 0.06 to 0.12)
J0.00058
T
= 0.00002
E = 0.00005
Degraded = 0.00053
FIGURE 2-2. DISTRIBUTION OF BENZENE IN WASTEWATER TREATMENT (covered separator)
(E = fraction of original quantity emitted; fe = fraction entering the unit that is emitted)
-------
estimated as 0.025 and 0.06 to 0.12, respectively. Approximately 88 to
93 percent of the benzene that reaches the blobasln 1s estimated to be
biodegraded.11
Several commenters pointed out that the benzene leaving the oil-
water separator preferentially partitions Into the oil layer. One
commenter stated that 10 to 20 percent of the benzene leaves with the
water?, and another estimated that 10 to 30 percent leaves with the
water.6 For this analysis, a midrange value of 20 percent in the water
(and 80 percent of the benzene removed with the oil) was used. This
approach predicts that 28 to 53 percent of the benzene that enters the
wastewater collection system is recovered with the waste oil from the
oil-water separator. The quantity of sludge (K048, K049, and K051)
removed from these units is estimated to be small relative to the total
wastewater; consequently, fractions emitted with these sludges are not
included 1n the figure. The estimated total fraction emitted for the
two model units ranges from 0.47 (with a covered separator) to 0.72
(with an open separator) with a midrange value of 0.6. The midrange
value was used to estimate emissions from petroleum refinery wastewater
treatment systems.
The most common treatment processes listed for DAF float and slop
oil solids (K048 and K049) from the generator's survey were wastewater
treatment tanks and land treatment. Land treatment was also the most
prevalent process used for the other sludges (K050, K051, and K052). For
these sludges, most of the benzene 1s predicted to be emitted when they
are handled in open sources. For land treatment, a fraction emitted of
0.93 was used, and a value of 0.98 was used for wastewater treatment
-------
(e.g., dewaterlng) followed by land treatment (see Table B-l in Appendix
B, and Appendix C for more details). These fractions emitted were used
with the previously discussed ranges of benzene concentration and
estimated waste quantities for these sludges to estimate a range of
benzene emissions (presented 1n Table A-3 1n Appendix A). However, the
estimated benzene emissions from these sludges are low compared to the
estimated emissions from the wastewater because of the much larger
quantities of wastewater that are generated.
The baseline emission estimates for the petroleum refineries are
summarized in Table 2-5. The range of estimates is based on the
previously discussed ranges used for benzene concentration. The
emissions come primarily from the wastewater from which 60 percent of
the benzene was estimated to be emitted. For the controlled emission
case, an emission reduction of 99 percent was used based on steam
stripping. The control was applied only for those cases in which the
total amount of benzene in aqueous waste exceeded 10 Mg/yr and the
Individual waste stream had a benzene concentration greater than or
equal to 10 ppm. When the lower end of the concentration range 1s used
(minimum case), fewer facilities are controlled. In addition, 3 of the
13 process wastewater streams are not controlled at the lower end of the
concentration range because they were assigned a benzene concentration
of 8 ppm for the minimum case.
The results of this analysis indicated that a range of 52 to 137
petroleum refineries have 10 Mg/yr or more of benzene in their aqueous
waste. A range of 923 to 3,330 Individual waste streams at these
facilities (with 10 Mg/yr or more benzene) are estimated to have a
benzene concentration of 10 ppm or more.
-------
TABLE 2-5. BENZENE EMISSION ESTIMATES FOR PETROLEUM REFINERIES
AQUEOUS (a)
BENZENE (Mg/yr)
No.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
33
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
PLANT
AMERADA HESS
AMERADA-HESS
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO
ANCHOR REF.
ARCO ALASKA
ARCO ALASKA
ARCO PETROLEUM
ASHLAND
ASHLAND
ASHLAND
ATLANTIC REFINING
ATLANTIC RICHFIELD
BARRETT REF.
BELCHER REF.
BERRY PETROLEUM
BIG WEST OIL
BLOOMF I ELD REFINING
BP OIL
BP OIL
CALCASIEU REFINING
CALUMET REFINING COM
CANAL REF.
CENEX REF.
CHAMPLIN PETROLEUM C
CHEMOIL
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CIBRO PETROLEUM
CITGO PETROLEUM
CLARK OIL & REFINING
CLARK OIL & REFINING
COASTAL EAGLE PT.
COASTAL REFINING
COLORADO REF.
CONOCO
CONOCO
CONOCO
CONOCO
CONOCO
CROSS OIL J REFINING
CROWN CENTRAL
CRYSEN REFINING
CRYSTAL REF.
DERBY REFINING COMPA
DERBY REF.
DIAMOND SHAMROCK
DIAMOND SHAMROCK
CITY
PURVIS
PORT READING
TEXAS CITY
MANDAN
SAVANNAH
CASPER
WHITING
YORKTOHN
SALT LAKE CITY
MCKITTRICK
KUPARUK
PRUDHOE BAY
FERNDALE
CANTON
ST. PAUL PARK
ASHLAND
PHILADELPHIA
CARSON
THOMAS
MOBILE BAY
STEVENS
SALT LAKE CITY
BLOOMF IELD
MARCUS HOOK
BELLE CHASSE
LAKE CHARLES
PRINCETON
CHURCH POINT
LAUREL
CORPUS CHRIST I
SIGNAL HILL
PASCAGOULA
PERTH AMBOY
KENAI
SALT LAKE CITY
PORTLAND
PHILADELPHIA
PORT ARTHUR
EL PASO
EL SEGUNDO
HONOLULU
RICHMOND
SEATTLE
ALBANY
LAKE CHARLES
BLUE ISLAND
HARTFORD
WESTVILLE
CORPUS CHRISTI
COMMERCE CITY
SANTA MARIA
PONCA CITY
COMMERCE CITY
WESTLAKE
BILLINGS
SMACKOVER
HOUSTON
WOODS CROSS
CARSON CITY
WICHITA
EL DORADO
SUNRAY
THREE RIVERS
ST
MS
NJ
TX
ND
GA
WY
IN
VA
UT
CA
AK
AK
WA
OH
MN
KY
PA
CA
OK
AL
AK
UT
NM
PA
LA
LA
LA
LA
MT
TX
CA
MS
NJ
AK
UT
OR
PA
TX
TX
CA
HI
CA
WA
NY
LA
IL
IL
NJ
TX
CO
CA
OK
CO
LA
MT
AR
TX
UT
Ml
KS
KS
TX
TX
MINIMUM
2.1E+00
9.9E-01
6.5E+01
4.1E+00
8.2E-01
2.5E+00
3.4E+01
4.3E+00
2.7E+00
2.9E-01
3.5E-01
4.1E-01
1.6E+01
5.5E+00
6.0E+00
1.9E+01
1.3E+01
1.8E+01
3.8E-01
4.2E-01
1 . 1E-01
1.6E+00
1.0E+00
1.3E+01
3. OE+01
3.5E-01
1 .2E-01
5.8E-01
3.3E+00
1.8E+01
4.2E-01
3. OE+01
2.3E+00
6.5E-01
3.0E+00
4.4E-01
1.4E+01
2.9E+01
6.2E+00
2.1E+01
1.8E+00
2.0E+01
1.5E-01
1.3E+00
3. OE+01
7.0E+00
4.9E+00
1.8E+01
1.7E+01
2.4E+00
2.8E-01
1.1E+01
2.7E+00
1.3E+01
3.6E+00
2.0E-01
1 .2E+01
8.2E-01
1.2E-01
2.6E+00
1.8E+00
8.4E+00
3.5E+00
MAXIMUM
2.0E+01
2.4E401
5.6E+02
3.7E401
1.1E+01
2.3E+01
3.2E+02
5.3E+01
2.5E+01
3.8E+00
4.5E+00
5.3E+00
1 .4E+02
4.1E+01
4.1E+01
1.7E+02
7.3E+01
2.1E+02
4.9E+00
4.8E+OT
1.4E+00
1.2E+01
9.5E+00
9.8E+01
3.0E+02
4.5E+00
1.5E+00
4.1E+00
2.3E+01
1.7E+02
5.4E+00
2.7E+02
3. OE+01
8.3E+00
3.8E+01
5.6E+00
1.3E+02
2.9E+02
4.0E+01
1.7E+02
2.9E+01
1.5E+02
1.9E+00
1.6E+01
3.0E+02
4.2E+01
5.8E+01
1.5E+02
1.6E+02
1.6E+01
3.6E+00
1.1E402
2.5E+01
1.6E+02
2.8E+01
2.6E+00
1.1E+02
5.3E+00
1.5E+00
2.9E+01
1.9E+01
6.7E+01
S.OE-fOI
TOTAL WASTE (b)
CONTROLLED (Mg/yr)
MINIMUM
O.OE400
O.OE+00
8.8E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
5.9E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
3.2E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
3.0E+05
1.3E+05
5.0E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1 .9E+05
4.3E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
3.6E+05
O.OE+00
5.6E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
2.1E+05
5.5E+05
O.OE+00
3.0E+05
O.OE+00
2.7E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
7.0E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.9E+05
1.9E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
2.4E+05
O.OE+00
3.8E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
2.2E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
MAXIMUM
1.3E+05
7.6E+04
2.2E+06
2.5E+05
1.0E+05
1.7E+05
1.7E+06
2.9E+05
1.7E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
8.1E+05
2.8E+05
2.8E+05
9.5E+05
5.1E+05
1.1E+06
O.OE+00
5.1E+04
O.OE+00
9.5E+04
O.OE+00
7.0E+05
1.DE+06
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.7E+05
8.2E+05
O.OE+00
1.5E+06
2.9E+05
O.OE+00
2.3E+05
O.OE+00
7.3E+05
1.5E+06
2.8E+05
1.3E+06
2.1E+05
1.1E+06
O.OE+00
1.5E+05
1.7E+06
2.8E+05
3.2E+05
5.3E+05
4.7E+05
1.2E+05
O.OE+00
6.6E+05
1.8E+05
8.6E+05
2.0E+05
O.OE+00
5.2E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.6E+05
1.3E+05
4.5E+05
2.1E+05
BASELINE
EMISSIONS (Mg/yr)
MINIMUM
1.3E+00
5.9E-01
3.9E+01
2.4E+00
4.9E-01
1 .5E+00
2.0E+01
2.6E+00
1.6E+00
1.8E-01
2.1E-01
2.5E-01
9.6E+00
3.3E+00
3.6E+00
1.1E+01
8.0E+00
1.1E+01
2.3E-01
2.5E-01
6.7E-02
9.4E-01
6.2E-01
8.0E+00
1.8E+01
2.1E-01
7.2E-02
3.5E-01
2.0E+00
1.1E+01
2.5E-01
1 .8E+01
1.4E+00
3.9E-01
1 .8E+00
2.6E-01
8.4E+00
1 .7E+01
3.7E+00
1 .2E+01
1.1E+00
1 .2E+01
8.6E-02
7.5E-01
1 .8E+01
4.2E+00
3.0E+00
1.1E+01
1 .OE+01
1.4E+00
1 .7E-01
6.8E+00
1.6E+00
7.5E+00
2.2E+00
1 .2E-01
7.3E+00
4.9E-01
7.1E-02
1 .5E+00
1.1E+00
5.0E+00
2.1E+00
MAXIMUM
1.2E+01
1 .5E+01
3.4E+02
2.2E+01
6.4E+00
1 .4E+01
1.9E+02
3.2E+01
1 .5E+01
2.3E+00
2.7E+00
3.2E+00
8.5E+01
2.5E+01
2.5E+01
1 .OE+02
4.4E+01
1.2E+02
3.0E+00
2.9E+01
8.6E-01
7.5E+00
5.7E+00
5.9E+01
1 .8E+02
2.7E+00
9.3E-01
2.5E+00
1.4E+01
1 .OE+02
3.3E+00
1.6E+02
1 .8E+01
5.0E+00
2.3E+01
3.4E+00
7.5E+01
1.7E+02
2.4E+01
1. OE+02
1 .7E+01
8.8E+01
1 .1E+00
9.7E+00
1 .8E+02
2.6E+01
3.5E+01
9.2E+01
9.4E+01
9.7E+00
2.2E+00
6.5E+01
1 .5E+01
9.4E+01
1.7E+01
1 .5E+00
6.6E+01
3.2E+00
9.1E-01
1 .8E+01
1.1E+01
4. OE+01
1.8E+01
CONTROLLED
EMISSIONS (Mg/yr)
MINIMUM
1.2E-01
1.5E-01
3.4E+00
2.3E-01
6.4E-02
1.4E-01
1.9E+00
3.2E-01
1.5E-01
1.8E-01
2.1E-01
2.5E-01
8.5E-01
2.5E-01
2.5E-01
1.0E+00
4.4E-01
1.2E+00
2.3E-01
2.5E-01
6.7E-02
7.5E-02
6.2E-01
5.9E-01
1.8E+00
2.1E-01
7.2E-02
3.5E-01
1.4E-01
1.0E+00
2.5E-01
1.6E+00
1.8E-01
3.9E-01
2.3E-01
2.6E-01
7.6E-01
1.7E+00
2.4E-01
1.0E+00
1.7E-01
8.8E-01
8.8E-02
9.8E-02
1.8E+00
2.6E-01
3.5E-01
9.3E-01
9.4E-01
9.8E-02
1.7E-01
6.5E-01
1.5E-01
9.4E-01
1.7E-01
1.2E-01
6.6E-01
4.9E-01
7.0E-02
1.8E-01
1.1E-01
4.1E-01
1.8E-01
MAXIMUM
1.3E+00
5.9E-01
5.9E+00
2.4E+00
4.9E-01
1.5E+00
4.8E+00
2.6E+00
1.6E+00
2.3E+00
2.7E+00
3.2E+00
2.2E+00
3.3E+00
3.6E+00
2.9E+00
1.7E+00
2.9E+00
2.9E+00
2.9E-01
8.6E-01
9.4E-OI
5.7E+00
2.3E+00
2.7E+00
2.7E+00
9.3E-01
2.5E+00
2.0E+00
2.1E+00
3.3E+00
4.1E+00
1.4E+00
5.0E+0)
1.8E+00
3.4E+00
2.4E+00
4.5E+00
3.7E+00
4.5E+00
1.1E+00
3.7E+00
UE+M
7.5E-OI
4.4E+00
4.2E+00
2.9E+00
1.5E+00
1.3E+00
1.4E+00
2.1E+00
1.9E+00
1.6E+00
2.1E+00
2.2E+00
1.5E+00
1.4E400
3.2E+00
9.0E-01
1.5E+00
1.1E+00
5.0E+00
2.1E+00
-------
TABLE 2-5. BENZENE EMISSION ESTIMATES FOR PETROLEUM REFINERIES
AQUEOUS (a) TOTAL WASTE (b) BASELINE CONTROLLED
BENZENE (Mg/yr) CONTROLLED (Mg/yr) EMISSIONS (Mg/yr) EMISSIONS (Mg/yr)
NO.
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
PLANT
EDGINGTON OIL COMPAN
EL PASO REFINING
ERGON REF.
EXXON
EXXON
EXXON
EXXON
EXXON
FARMLAND INDUSTRIES
FARMLAND INDUSTRIES
FINA OIL
FINAOIL
FLETCHER OIL & REF IN
FRONTIER OIL
GIANT REFINERY
GOLDEN WEST REFINING
HAWAII INDEP. REF.
HILL PETROLEUM
HILL PETROLEUM
HILL PETROLEUM
HILL PETROLEUM
HOWELL HYDROCARBONS
HUNT REFINING
HUNTWAY REF.
HUNTWAY REF.
INDIANA FARM BUREAU
INTERMOUNTAINREF.
KERN OIL & REFINING
KERR MCGEE
KERR MCGEE
KOCH REFINING
KOCH REFINING
LA GLORIA OIL AND GA
LAKESIDE REF.
LAKETON REFINING
LION OIL
LIQUID ENERGY CORP.
LITTLE AMERICA REF.
LOUISIANA LAND & EXP
LUNDAY-THAGARD CO.
LYONDELL PETROCHEMIC
MANTUA OIL
MAPCO PETROLEUM
MAPCO PETROLEUM
MARATHON PETROLEUM
MARATHON PETROLEUM
MARATHON PETROLEUM
MARATHON PETROLEUM
MIDATLANTIC REF.
MOBIL
MOBIL
MOBIL
MOBIL
MOBIL
MONTANA REFINING COM
MURPHY OIL CORPORATI
MURPHY OIL CORPORATI
NATIONAL COOPERATIVE
NAVAJO REFINING
NEVADA REF.
NENHALL REFINING CO.
OXNARD REF.
PACIFIC REF.
CITY
LONG BEACH
EL PASO
VICKSBURG
LINDEN
BILLINGS
BENICIA
BAYTOWN
BATON ROUGE
PHILLIPSBURG
COFFEYVILLE
BIG SPRING
PORT ARTHUR
WILMINGTON
CHEYENNE
GALLUP
SANTA FE SPRING
EWA BEACH
TEXAS CITY
HOUSTON
ST. ROSE
KROTZ SPRINGS
SAN ANTONIO
TUSCALOOSA
WILMINGTON
BENECIA
MT. VERNON
FREDONIA
BAKERSFIELD
WYNNEWOOD
COTTON VALLEY
CORPUS CHRISTI
' ROSEMOUNT
TYLER
KALAMAZOO
LAKETON
EL DORADO
BRIDGEPORT
CASPER
SARALAND
SOUTH GATE
HOUSTON
THOROFARE
NORTH POLE
MEMPHIS
TEXAS CITY
GARYVILLE
ROBINSON
DETROIT
ST. MARYS
CHALMETTE
TORRANCE
PAULSBORO
BEAUMONT
JOLIET
GREAT FALLS
MERAUX
SUPERIOR
MCPHERSON
ARTESIA
TONOPAH
NEWHALL
OXNARD
HERCULES
ST
CA
TX
MS
NJ
MT
CA
TX
LA
KS
KS
TX
TX
CA
WY
NM
CA
HI
TX
TX
LA
LA
TX
AL
CA
CA
IN
AZ
CA
OK
LA
TX
MN
TX
Ml
IN
AR
TX
WY
AL
CA
TX
NJ
AK
TN
TX
LA
IL
Ml
WV
LA
CA
NJ
TX
IL
MT
LA
Wl
KS
NM
NV
CA
CA
CA
MINIMUM
1.2E+00
1.8E+00
4.9E-01
1. OE+01
3.2E+00
9.3E+00
3.6E+01
3.5E+01
1.6E+00
5.2E+00
5.4E+00
1.4E+01
1.7E+00
2.6E+00
1.7E+00
4.4E+00
4.2E+00
7.9E+00
5.8E+00
9.7E-01
4.1E+00
7.3E-01
2.8E+00
1.6E-01
2.5E-01
1.2E+00
1.7E-01
1.0E+00
3. OE+00
2.3E-01
1.8E+01
1 .6E+01
4.7E+00
3.2E-01
2.4E-01
3.1E+00
2.9E-01
1.8E+00
5.5E+00
2.3E-01
3.4E+01
1.3E+00
3.9E+00
3.8E+00
5.4E+00
1.6E+01
2.0E+01
5.4E+00
3.8E-01
1.8E+01
1 .3E+01
8.4E+00
2.7E+01
1.6E+01
3.8E-01
6.96+00
2.4E+00
6. OE+00
2.6E+00
1.3E-01
9.3E-01
1.3E-01
3.8E+00
MAXIMUM
1.6E+01
1.8E+01
6.3E+00
1.1E+02
2.8E+01
8.5E+01
2.9E+02
3.9E+02
1.1E+01
5.2E+01
3.8E+01
1.1E+02
1 .6E+01
2.9E+01
1.2E+01
2.8E+01
3.5E+01
7.3E+01
6.4E+01
1.2E+01
3.7E+01
6.2E+00
3.2E+01
2.1E+00
3.2E+00
8.7E+00
2.1E+00
8.1E+00
2.8E+01
2.9E+00
1.5E+02
2.0E+02
4.1E+01
2.3E+00
3.1E+00
2.9E+01
3.8E+00
1.6E+01
3.4E+Q1
2.9E+00
2.7E+02
1 .7E+01
4.6E+01
3.8E+01
5.9E+01
1.5E+02
1.4E+02
4.2E+01
2.2E+00
1.7E+02
1.5E+02
8.9E+01
2.1E+02
1.8E+02
3.6E+00
5.6E+01
1 ,9E-f01
7.0E+01
2.3E+01
1.7E+00
7.6E+00
1.6E+00
2.4E+01
MINIMUM
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
2.6E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
5.5E+05
9.0E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1 .5E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
2.3E+05
4.6E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
5.2E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
2.9E+05
2.9E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
3.3E+05
3.8E+05
O.OE+00
4.7E+05
4.3E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
MAXIMUM
1.5E+05
1.0E+05
O.OE+00
6.6E+05
1.9E+05
5.7E+05
2.0E+06
2.3E+06
9.6E+04
2.9E+05
2.4E+05
4.5E+05
1.1E+05
1.7E+05
7.8E+04
1.8E+05
3.0E+05
5.1E+05
3.3E+05
1.2E+05
2.4E+05
O.OE+00
2.0E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.9E+05
O.OE+00
6.1E+05
1.1E+06
2.6E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
2.0E+05
O.OE+00
1.0E+05
2.9E+05
O.OE+00
1.3E+06
1.6E+05
3.3E+05
2.5E+05
3.2E+05
1.1E+06
8.8E+05
2.9E+05
O.OE+00
7.7E+05
7.6E+05
5.1E+05
1.3E+06
9.7E+05
O.OE+00
3.9E+05
1.3E+05
3.8E+05
1.6E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
2.0E+05
MINIMUM
7.3E-01
1.1E+00
3.0E-01
6.3E+00
1 .9E+00
5.6E+00
2.2E+01
2.1E+01
9.5E-01
3.1E+00
3.2E+00
8.3E+00
1.0E+00
1.6E+00
1.0E+00
2.6E+00
2.5E+00
4.7E+00
3.5E+00
5.8E-01
2.4E+00
4.4E-01
1.7E+00
9.7E-02
1.5E-01
7.3E-01
1.0E-01
6.3E-01
1.8E+00
1.4E-01
1.1E+01
9.4E+00
2.8E+00
.9E-01
• .5E-01
.9E+00
.8E-01
.1E+00
3.3E+00
1.4E-01
2.0E+01
7.9E-01
2.3E+00
2.3E+00
3.2E+00
9.9E+00
1.2E+01
3.2E+00
2.3E-01
1.1E+01
7.8E+00
5.1E+00
1.6E+01
9.8E+00
2.3E-01
4.1E+00
1.4E+00
3.6E+00
1 .6E+00
7.9E-02
5.6E-01
7.6E-02
2.3E+00
MAXIMUM
9.5E+00
1.1E+01
3.8E+00
6.8E+01
1 .7E+01
5.1E+01
1 .7E+02
2.3E+02
6.6E+00
3.1E+01
2.3E+01
6.7E+01
9.7E+00
1 .8E+01
7.1E+00
1 .7E+01
2.1E+01
4.4E+01
3.9E+01
7.5E+00
2.2E+01
3.7E+00
1 .9E+01
1.3E+00
1.9E+00
5.2E+00
1.3E+00
4.9E+00
1 .7E+01
1 .8E+00
8.8E+01
1 .2E+02
2.4E+01
1 .4E+00
1.9E+00
1 .7E+01
2.3E+00
9.9E+00
2.1E+01
1 .8E+00
1 .7E+02
1 .OE+01
2.8E+01
2.3E+01
3.5E+01
8.8E+01
8.4E+01
2.6E+01
1 .3E+00
1 .OE+02
9. OE+01
5.4E+01
1 .3E+02
1.1E+02
2.2E+00
3.4E+01
1.1E+01
4.2E+01
1 .4E+01
1 .OE+00
4.6E+00
9.8E-01
1 .5E+01
MINIMUM
9.5E-02
1.1E-01
3.0E-01
6.8E-01
1.7E-01
5.2E-01
1.7E+00
2.3E+00
6.7E-02
3.1E-01
2.3E-01
6.7E-01
9.7E-02
1.8E-01
7.1E-02
1.7E-01
2.1E-01
4.4E-01
3.9E-01
7.6E-02
2.2E-01
4.4E-01
1.9E-01
9.7E-02
1.5E-01
7.3E-01
1.0E-01
6.3E-01
1.7E-01
1.4E-01
8.8E-01
1.2E+00
2.5E-01
1.9E-01
1.5E-01
1.7E-01
1.8E-01
9.9E-02
2.1E-01
1.4E-01
1.7E+00
1.0E-01
2.8E-01
2.3E-01
3.6E-01
8.9E-01
8.4E-01
2.6E-01
2.3E-01
1. OE+00
9.1E-01
5.4E-01
1.3E+00
1.1E+00
2.3E-01
3.4E-01
1.1E-01
4.2E-01
1.4E-01
7.9E-02
5.6E-01
7.6E-02
1.5E-01
MAXIMUM
7.3E-01
1.1E+00
3.8E+00
1.8E+00
1.9E+00
5.6E+00
6.7E+00
6.2E+00
9.5E-01
3.1E+00
3.2E+00
1 .4E+00
1. OE+00
1.6E+00
1. OE+00
2.6E+00
2.5E+00
4.7E+00
3.5E+00
5.8E-01
2.4E+00
3.7E+00
1.7E+00
1.2E+00
1.9E+00
5.2E+00
1.3E+00
4.9E+00
1.8E+00
1.8E+00
1.8E+00
3. OE+00
2.8E+00
1.4E+00
1.9E+00
1.9E+00
2.3E+00
1.1E+00
3.3E+00
1.7E+00
3.7E+00
7.9E-01
2.3E+00
2.3E+00
3.2E+00
3.5E+00
2.7E+00
3.2E+00
1.3E+00
2. OE+00
1.7E+00
5.1E+00
3.8E+00
2.5E+00
2.2E+00
4.1E+00
1.4E+00
3.6E+00
1.6E+00
1. OE+00
4.5E+00
9.7E-01
2.3E+00
XT.
-------
TABLE 2-5. BENZENE EMISSION ESTIMATES FOR PETROLEUM REFINERIES
AQUEOUS (a) TOTAL WASTE (b)
BENZENE (Mg/yr) CONTROLLED (Mg/yr)
No.
127
1 £ /
ion
1 iO
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
sc=:
PLANT
PARAMOUNT PET.
PFNNZOIL
r Liiiitu i u
PENNZOIL
PENNZOIL
PETRO STAR
PHILLIPS
PHILLIPS
PHILLIPS
PLACID REFINING
POWER INE OIL
PRIDE REFINING
QUAKER STATE OIL REF
QUAKER STATE OIL REF
RXK ISLAND REFINING
SAN JOAQUIN REF.
SHELL
SHELL
SHELL
SHELL
SHELL
SHELL
SHELL
SINCLAIR OIL
SINCLAIR OIL
SOHIO
SOMERSET REFINERY
SOUND REF.
SOUTHLAND OIL
SOUTHLAND OIL
SOUTHWESTERN REF IN IN
STANDARD OIL OF OHIO
STANDARD OIL OF OHIO
STAR REF.
STAR REF.
STAR REF.
SUN CO.
SUN CO.
SUN CO.
SUNLAND REF.
TESARO ALASKA PETROL
TEXACO
TEXACO
TEXACO
TEXACO
TOSCO CORP.
TOTAL PETROLEUM
TOTAL PETROLEUM
TOTAL PETROLEUM
TRIFINERY
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
UNITED REF.
UNOCAL
U.S. OIL & REFINING
VALERO ENERGY CORP.
WITCO CORP.
WITCO CORP.
WYOMING REF.
YOUNG REF.
CITY
PARAMOUNT
SHREVEPORT
ROOSEVELT
ROUSEVILLE
NORTH POLE
SWEENY
WOODS CROSS
BORGER
PORT ALLEN
SANTA FE SPRINGS
ABILENE
SMETHPORT
NEWELL
INDIANAPOLIS
BAKERSFIELD
HORCO
DEER PARK
WOOD RIVER
MARTINEZ
ANACORTES
WILMINGTON
ODESSA
TULSA
SINCLAIR
FERNDALE
SOMERSET
TACOMA
SANDERSVILLE
LUMBERTON
CORPUS CHRIST!
LIMA
TOLEDO
DELAWARE CITY
PORT ARTHUR
CONVENT
TOLEDO
MARCUS HOOK
TULSA
BAKERSFIELD
KENAI
EL DORADO
BAKERSFIELD
WILMINGTON
ANACORTES
MARTINEZ
ARKANSAS CITY
ARDMORE
ALMA
CORPUS CHRISTI
WILMINGTON
LEMONT
RODEO
NEDERLAND
WARREN
LOS ANGELES
TACOMA
CORPUS CHRISTI
BRADFORD
OILDALE
NEWCASTLE
DOUGLASVILLE
ST
CA
LA
UT
PA
AK
TX
UT
TX
LA
CA
TX
PA
WV
IN
CA
LA
TX
IL
CA
WA
CA
TX
OK
WY
WA
KY
WA
MS
MS
TX
OH
OH
DE
TX
LA
OH
PA
OK
CA
AK
KS
CA
CA
WA
CA
KS
OK
Ml
TX
CA
IL
CA
TX
PA
CA
WA
TX
PA
CA
WY
GA
MINIMUM
2.9E+00
2.9E+00
6.6E-01
1.3E+00
2.1E-01
1.5E+01
1.8E+00
8.3E+00
3.3E+00
3.5E+00
1.3E+00
5.1E-01
8.3E-01
3.2E+00
5.4E-01
1.6E+01
2.7E+01
2.7E+01
9.7E+00
7.1E+00
1.2E+01
2.9E+00
3.7E+00
4.2E+00
4.6E+00
3.1E-01
3.5E-01
3.2E-01
1.7E-01
1.2E+01
3.0E+01
.2E+01
.6E+01
.6E+01
.4E+01
.7E+01
.6E+01
8.4E+00
6.7E-01
3.9E+00
9.0E+00
5.5E+00
1.1E+01
7.9E+00
1.1E+01
4.4E+00
4.0E+00
3.7E+00
8. €-01
6.3E+00
1 .3E+01
1.1E+01
1.2E+01
4.7E+03
1.2E+01
1.9E400
1.7E+00
7.5E-01
3.2E-01
8.7E-01
2.6E-01
MAXIMUM
1.8E+01
1 .9E+01
6.3E+00
7.0E+00
2.6E+00
1.4E+02
1.5E+01
7.4E+01
2.9E+01
4.0E+01
1.6E401
2.9E+00
4.6E+00
2.8E+01
8.1E+00
1.2E+02
2.3E+02
1.9E+02
9.2E+01
5.7E+01
1 .5E+02
2.0E+01
3.0E+01
3.3E+01
4.4E+01
2.3E+00
4.5E+00
4.1E+00
2.2E+00
1.0E+02
2.7E+02
9.9E+01
.1E+02
.6E+02
.4E+02
.4E+02
.5E+02
6.8E+01
6.0E+00
2.9E+01
8.3E+01
3.8E+01
1 .2E+02
8.6E+01
8.2E+01
3.3E+01
3.6E+01
2.8E+01
1.1E+01
8.0E+01
1.5E+02
1.2E+02
1 .OE+02
3.7E+01
7.6E+01
1.4E+01
3.4E+01
3.8E+00
4.1E+00
7.2E+00
3.3E+00
MINIMUM
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
2.6E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
2.3E+05
3.0E+05
3.4E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
3.8E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.6E+05
3.2E+05
2.2E+05
2.0E+05
3.2E+05
2.7E+05
2.1E+05
2.6E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
3.0E+05
O.OE+00
1.7E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
3.1E+05
2.9E+05
1.5E+05
O.OE+00
1 .5E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
MAXIMUM
1.6E+05
1.7E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
7.9E+05
1.1E+05
4.8E+05
2.0E+05
2.3E+05
1.5E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.9E+05
O.OE+00
8.8E+05
9.6E+05
1.2E+06
6.2E+05
3.7E+05
8.2E+05
1.2E+05
2.1E+05
2.3E+05
3.2E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
4.8E+05
8.4E+05
5.9E+05
6.3E+05
1.1E+06
9.5E+05
5.9E+05
7.6E+05
3.7E+05
O.OE+00
2.6E+05
4.0E+05
2.3E+05
5.3E+05
4.9E+05
5.5E+05
2.3E+05
2.5E+05
1.8E+05
1.0E+05
4.1E+05
7.6E+05
6.3E+05
5.2E+05
2.7E+05
4.8E+05
1.2E+05
1.5E+05
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
BASELINE CONTROLLED
EMISSIONS (Mg/yr) EMISSIONS (Mg/yr)
MINIMUM
1.7E+00
1.7E+00
4.0E-01
8.1E-01
1.2E-01
9.1E+00
1.1E+00
5.0E+00
2.0E+00
2.1E+00
7.5E-01
3.1E-01
5.0E-01
1 .9E+00
3.2E-01
9.6E+00
1.6E+01
1 .6E+01
5.8E+00
4.3E+00
7.0E+00
1.8E+00
2.2E+00
2.5E+00
2.7E+00
1 .9E-01
2.1E-01
1 .9E-01
1.0E-01
7.1E+00
1 .8E+01
7.1E+00
9.4E+00
9.4E+00
8.6E+00
1.0E+01
9.7E+00
5.1E+00
4.0E-01
2.4E+00
5.4E+00
3.3E+00
6.7E+00
4.7E+00
6.8E+00
2.6E+00
2.4E+00
2.2E+00
5.0E-01
3.8E+00
8.0E+00
6.8E+00
7.3E+00
2.8E+00
7.2E+00
1.1E+00
9.9E-01
4.5E-01
1 .9E-01
5.2E-01
1 .6E-01
MAXIMUM
1.1E+01
1 .2E+01
3.8E+00
4.2E+00
1.6E+00
8.7E+01
9.0E+00
4.5E+01
1 .7E+01
2.4E+01
9.7E+00
1.7E+00
2.8E+00
1 .7E+01
4.9E+00
7.4E+01
1.4E+02
1.1E+02
5.5E+01
3.4E+01
9.2E+01
1 .2E+01
1 .BE+01
2.0E+01
2.6E+01
1 .4E+00
2.7E+00
2.5E+00
1 .3E+00
6.1E+01
1 .6E+02
6.0E+01
6.7E+01
9.4E+01
8.2E+01
8.5E+01
8.8E+01
4.1E+01
3.6E+00
1 .8E+01
5.0E+01
2.3E+01
6.9E+01
5.1E+01
5.0E+01
2.0E+01
2.2E+01
1 .7E+01
6.5E+00
4.8E+01
8.8E+01
7.1E+01
6.1E+01
2.2E+01
4.6E+01
8.2E+00
2.0E+01
2.3E+00
2.5E+00
4.3E+00
2.0E+00
MINIMUM
1.1E-01
1.2E-01
3.9E-01
8.1E-01
1.2E-01
8.7E-01
9.1E-02
4.5E-01
1.7E-01
2.4E-01
9.8E-02
3.1E-01
5.0E-01
1.7E-01
3.2E-01
7.4E-01
1.4E+00
1.1E+00
5.5E-01
3.5E-01
9.2E-01
1.2E-01
1.8E-01
2.0E-01
2.6E-01
1.9E-01
2.1E-01
1.9E-01
1.0E-01
6.1E-01
1.6E+00
6.0E-01
6.8E-01
9.4E-01
8.2E-01
8.6E-01
8.9E-01
4.1E-01
4.0E-01
1.8E-01
5.0E-01
2.3E-01
6.9E-01
5.2E-01
5.0E-01
2.0E-01
2.2E-01
1.7E-01
6.5E-02
4.8E-01
8.8E-01
7 2E-01
6.1E-01
2.2E-01
4 6E-01
8.2E-02
2.0E-01
4.5E-01
1 .9E-01
5.2E-01
1.6E-01
MAXIMM
1.7E+00
I.TEtOO
3.8E+00
4.2E+00
1.6E+00
2.4E+00
1.1E+00
S.OEtOO
2.0E+00
2.1E+W
7.5E-01
I.TEfQO
2.8E+00
1.9E+00
4.9E+00
2.9E+00
3.0E+00
3.8E+00
5.8E+00
4.3E+00
2.0E+00
1.8E+00
2.2E+00
2.5E+00
2.7E+00
1.4E+00
2.7E+00
2.5E+00
1.3E+00
1.4E+00
2.4E+00
1.7E+00
1.9E+00
3.4E+00
3.0E+00
1.8E+00
2.3E+00
5.1E+00
3.6E+00
2.4E+00
5.4E+00
3.3E+00
1.1E+W
4.7E+00
1.7E+00
2.6E+00
2,4EtOO
2.2E+00
5.0E-01
3.8E+00
2.0E+00
1.6E+00
1.7E+00
2.8E+00
1.5E+00
1.1E+00
9.9E-01
2.3E+00
2.4E+00
4.3E+00
2.0E+00
(a) Aqueous benzene - quantity of benzene In aqueous wastes (over 10 percent water)
(b) Total waste controlled - total quantity of all wastes (process wastewater, sludges, etc.) with a benzene
concentration of 10 ppra or more at facllIties with 10 Mg/yr or more benzene In aqueous wastes.
-ita ^
-------
3. COKE BY-PRODUCT RECOVERY PLANTS
A review of data presented in the effluent guidelines document12
for this Industry (prepared by the Office of Water) and in the
background document for the benzene NESHAP for coke plants13 indicated
that there are three major benzene-containing wastes. These wastes
include ammonia liquor with benzene concentrations of 3.4 to 182 ppm,
wastewater from the light oil decanter, and wastewater from the wash oil
decanter with combined benzene concentrations of 18 to 97 ppm. The
latter two streams are identified collectively as light oil plant
wastewater. The effluent guidelines document estimates that ammonia
liquor is generated at a rate of about 47 gal/ton of coke and that light
oil plant wastewater is generated at about 54 gal/ton of coke. Ammonia
liquor is routinely stripped in the ammonia stripper, and volatiles are
recycled back to the coke oven gas. However, the ammonia liquor may be
stored 1n open or covered tanks prior to stripping. Some plants also
strip the wastewater from the light oil plant, and others send 1t to the
wastewater treatment system.
The quantity of wastewater and the quantity of benzene in the
wastewater were estimated from the generation factors (gal/ton of coke),
ranges of benzene concentration, and updated information on coke
capacity. Air emission controls are already required for ammonia liquor
tanks at metallurgical coke plants by the benzene NESHAP (40 CFR 61.130,
Subpart L). For the baseline emission estimates, a fraction emitted of
0.03 to 0.18 (see Appendix C) was used for ammonia liquor tanks, and 95-
percent control was applied at metallurgical plants. To reflect that
some plants currently strip light oil plant wastewater, an assumption
-------
was made that 50 percent of this wastewater is stripped and 50 percent
goes to wastewater treatment. The fraction emitted for that portion
going to wastewater treatment was estimated to range from 0.4
(nonaerated equalization basin) to 0.99 (aerated equalization basin).11
A control efficiency of 99 percent was used for wastewater that is
stripped (fraction emitted = 0.01).
The midrange value of fraction emitted was applied to all coke
plants in EPA's data base, in combination with a range of benzene
concentrations and an estimate of waste quantity, to produce a range of
emission estimates. The results for coke by-product plants are
summarized in Table 3-1. From this analysis, a range of 1 to 29 coke
plants is estimated to have 10 Mg/yr or more of benzene in their aqueous
wastes. A range of 2 to 58 waste streams at these plants is estimated
to have benzene concentrations exceeding 10 ppm and may not be
controlled currently.
4. OFF-SITE TREATMENT, STORAGE, AND DISPOSAL FACILITIES (TSDF)
Wastes containing benzene that are shipped offsite for treatment
and disposal were identified from national surveys of hazardous waste
TSDF and generators. A total of 48 facilities receiving these wastes
from offsite is listed in Table 4-1. Additional details on the waste
streams at these facilities are provided in Appendix B (Table B-3),
which provides a listing of the data extracted from the surveys.
The approach used to estimate emissions is essentially the same as
that used at proposal with one major exception. The fraction emitted
for the entire wastewater treatment system was previously estimated as
-------
TABLE 3-1. BENZENE EMISSION ESTIMATES FOR COKE PLANTS
No.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
PLANT
ABC COKE
ACME STEEL
ARMCO INC
ARMCO INC.
BETHLEHEM STEEL
BETHLEHEM STEEL
BETHLEHEM STEEL
BETHLEHEM STEEL
CITIZENS GAS
DETROIT COKE
EM* IRE COKE COMPANY
ERIE COKE
GENEVA STEEL
GULF STATES
INLAND STEEL
KOPPERS
LTV STEEL
LTV STEEL
LTV STEEL
LTV STEEL COMPANY
NATIONAL STEEL
NATIONAL STEEL GROUP
NEN BOSTON COKE
SHARON STEEL
SHENANGO
SLOSS INDUSTRIES
TOLEDO COKE
TONAWANDA
U.S. STEEL CORP.
U.S. STEEL CORP.
WHEELING PITT
CITY
TARRANT
CHICAGO
MIDDLETOWN
ASHLAND
BURNS HARBOR
LACKAWANNA
BETHLEHEM
SPARROWS POINT
INDIANAPOLIS
DETRIOT
TUSCALOOSA
ERIE
PROVO
GADSDEN
E CHICAGO
WOODWARD
CLEVELAND
S CHICAGO
WARREN
PITTSBURGH
GRANITE CITY
ECORSE
PORTSMOUTH
MONESSEN
SHENANGO
BIRMINGHAM
TOLEDO
TONAWANDA
CLAIRTON
GARY
E STEUBENVILLE
ST
AL
IL
OH
KY
IN
NY
PA
MD
IN
Ml
AL
PA
UT
AL
IN
AL
OH
IL
OH
PA
IL
Ml
OH
PA
PA
AL
OH
NY
PA
IN
WV
COKE
CAPACITY
(Mg/yr)
5.8E+05
5.8E+05
.4E+06
.1E+06
.8E+06
.2E+06
.5E+06
.2E+06
4.8E+05
6.2E+05
1.6E+05
2.1E+05
1.2E+06
7.6E+05
1.8E+06
6.9E+05
1.6E+06
6.0E+05
5.4E+05
1.8E+06
6.3E+05
3.5E+05
3.6E+05
2.9E+05
5.2E+05
4.0E+05
1.6E+05
3.0E+05
3.8E+06
5.3E+05
1.5E+06
AOAJEOUS (a) BASELINE
BENZENE (Mg/yr) EMISSIONS (Mg/yr)
MINIMUM
2.7E+00
2.7E+00
6.6E400
4.9E+00
8.2E+00
5.4E+00
7.1E+00
5.7E+00
2.2E+00
2.9E+00
7.5E-01
9.6E-01
5.4E+00
3.5E+00
8.5E+00
3.2E+00
7.2E+00
2.8E+00
2.5E+00
8.3E+00
2.9E+00
1.6E+00
1.7E+00
1.4E+00
2.4E+00
1.8E+00
7.3E-01
1.4E+00
1.8E+01
2.5E+00
7.0E+00
MAXIMUM
3.3£t01
3.3E+01
8.2E+01
6.1E+01
1.0E+02
6.6E+01
8.8E+01
7.1E+01
2.7E+01
3.5E+01
9.2E+00
1.2Et01
6.7E+01
4.3E+01
1.1E+02
4.0E+01
8.9E+01
3.4E+01
3.1E+01
1 .OE+02
3.6E+01
2.0Et01
2.1E+01
1 .7E+01
3.0E+01
2.3E+01
9.0E+00
1 .7E+01
2.2E+02
S.OE^O!
8.7E+01
MINIMUM
4
4
1
8
1
9
1
9
3
5
1
1
9
6
1
5
1
4
4
1
5
2
3
2
4
3
1
2
3
4
1
.7E-01
.6E-01
.1E+00
.4E-01
.4E+00
.2E-01
.2E+00
.8E-01
.9E-01
.OE-01
.3E-01
.7E-01
.2E-01
.2E-01
.5E+00
.6E-01
.2E+00
.7E-01
.3E-01
.4E+00
.OE-01
.7E-01
.OE-01
.3E-01
.1E-01
.2E-01
.3E-01
.4E-01
.1E+00
.2E-01
.2E+00
MAXIMUM
9.9E+00
6.3E+00
1.6E+01
1.2E+01
1.9E+01
1.3E+01
1 .7E+01
1.3E+01
8.1E+00
1 .1E+01
2.7E+00
3.5E+00
1 .3E+01
1.3E+01
2.0E+01
1 .2E+01
1.7E+01
6.5E+00
5.9E+00
2.0E+01
6.8E+00
3.8E+00
6.2E+00
3.2EtOO
5.7E+00
6.8E+00
2-TEtOO
5.1E+00
4.2E+01
5.8EtOO
1 .6E+01
CONTROLLED
EMISSIONS (Mg/yr)
MINIMUM
1 .7E-01
2.5E-01
6.2E-01
4.6E-01
7.6E-01
5.0E-01
6.6E-01
5.3E-01
1 .3E-01
1 .9E-01
1 .3E-01
6.5E-02
5.0E-01
4.2E-01
7.9E-01
2. OE-01
6.7E-01
2.6E-01
2.3E-01
7.7E-01
2.7E-01
1.5E-01
1 .3E-01
1.3E-01
2.2E-01
1 .2E-01
1.3E-01
6.8E-02
3.4E-02
2.3E-01
6.5E-01
MAXIMUM
4.7E-01
4.6E-01
1.1E+00
8.4E-01
1.4E+00
9.2E-01
1.2E+00
9.8E-01
3.9E-01
5.0E-01
2.7E+00
1.7E-01
9.2E-01
6.2E-01
1.5E+00
5.6E-01
1.2E+00
4.7E-01
4.3E-01
1 .4E+00
5. OE-01
2.7E-01
3.0E-01
2.3E-01
4.1E-01
3.2E-01
2.7E+00
2.4E-01
1.7E+00
4.2E-01
1.2E+00
(a) Aqueous benzene - quantity of benzene In aqueous wastes (over 10 percent water).
-------
TABLE 4-1. BENZENE EMISSION ESTIMATES FOR OFF-SITE TSOF
No. PLANT
1 ASHLAND CHEMICAL
2 CALLEIA RES. RECOVER
3 CASMALIA RESOURCES
4 CECOS INT'L
5 CECOS INT'L
6 CECOS INT'L
7 CECOS INT'L
8 CECOS INT'L
9 CECOS INT'L
10 CHEMICAL PROCESSORS
11 CHEMICAL RESOURCES
12 CHEM-CLEAR INC.
13 CHEM-CLEAR INC.
14 CHEM-MET SERVICES
15 CHEM. WASTE MGMT
16 CHEM. WASTE MGMT.
17CID-LANDFILL
18 COMMERCIAL DISPOSAL
19 DELAWARE CONTAINERS
20 ECOLOTEC
21 ENSCO
22 ENVIROSAFE SERVICES
23ENV. ENTERPRISES
24 ENV. WASTE RESOURCES
25 ERIEWAY POLL. CONTRO
26 FRONTIER CHEMICAL
27 GULF COAST WASTE DIS
28 HANSBROUGH ENERGY
29 HERITAGE ENV. SERVIC
30 INDUSTRIAL WASTE REM
31 IT CORPORATION
32 IT CORPORATION
33 IT CORP .-PETROL. WAS
34 MALONE SERVICE CO.
35 MICHIGAN DISPOSAL IN
36PEORIA DISPOSAL CO.
37 PETROCHEM RECYCLING
38 RMT PROPERTIES
39 ROGERS LANDFILL
40 ROLLINS ENV. SERVICE
41 ROLLINS ENV. SERVICE
42 SOLVENT RECOV. SERVI
43 TEXAS ECOLOGISTS
44 TRICIL ENV. SERVICES
45 USPCI GRASSY MT.
46 WASTE CONVERSION
47 WASTE TECH SERVICES
48 WAYNE DISPOSAL
CITY
BOYDCO.
BROOKLYN
CASMALIA
STAMFORD
NIAGRA FALLS
BRISTOL
WILLIAMSBURG
CINCINNATI
LIVINGSTON
SEATTLE
TULSA
BALTIMORE
CLEVELAND
WYANDOTTE
EMELLE
CALUMET CITY
CALUMET CITY
WEST SPRINGFIEL
COATSVILLE
DAYTON
EL DORADO
OREGON
CINCINNATI
WATERBURY
BEDFORD
NIAGRA FALLS
TEXAS CITY
CROWLEY
INDIANAPOLIS
LEWISBERRY
BENECIA
WESTMORELAND
BUTTONWILLOW
TEXAS CITY
BELLEVILLE
PEORIA
SALT LAKE CITY
NORTH SALT LAKE
CENTREVILLE
BRIDGEPORT
DEER PARK
LINDEN
ROBSTOWN
MUSKEGON HEIGHT
KNOWLES
HATFIELD
GOLDEN
BELLEVILLE
ST
KY
NY
CA
CT
NY
CT
OH
OH
LA
WA
OK
MD
OH
Ml
AL
IL
IL
MA
PA
OH
AR
OH
OH
CT
OH
NY
TX
LA
IN
PA
CA
CA
CA
TX
Ml
IL
UT
UT
MS
NJ
TX
NJ
TX
Ml
UT
PA
CO
Ml
AQUEOUS
BENZENE
2.3E+02
O.OE+00
5.6E-01
1.5E+01
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
2.1E+00
5.1E-01
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
5.1E-01
2.6E-02
3.0E-02
2.7E-02
O.OE+00
6.9E-01
1.6E-02
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
7.5E+00
1.1E-01
1 .3E+01
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.3E+00
4.8E-02
O.OE+00
2.9E+01
3.1E-02
1.0E-03
3.1E-02
1.5E-01
8.3E-01
O.OE+00
5.9E+01
2.3E-02
4.8E-01
2.7E-02
9.3E-02
1.2E+00
2.9E+02
4.0E-03
3.8E+00
O.OE+00
3.6E+00
6.3E+01
2.0E-03
1.0E-03
(a) BASELINE
(Mg/yr) EMISSIONS (Mg/yr)
1.6E+02
1.0E-04
4.3E-01
1.1E+01
<1 .OE-4
9.4E-03
3.0E+00
3.9E-01
<1.0E-4
1.2E-03
3.0E-04
1.8E-02
2.3E-02
1.9E-02
<1.0E-4
5.0E-01
1.2E-02
1.0E-04
6.5E-01
8.3E-01
1 .OE-01
9.5E+00
1.6E-01
<1 .OE-4
8.9E-01
5.3E-03
<1.0E-4
2.1E+01
2.4E-02
<1.0E-4
3.1E-02
1 .4E-01
7.8E-01
<1.0E-4
4.0E+01
1.7E-02
3.7E-01
<1 .OE-4
8.6E-02
1.0E-04
4.4E+01
4.0E-04
2.8E+00
<1 .OE-4
3.1E+00
4.3E+01
<1.0E-4
1.0E-04
CONTROLLED
EMISSIONS (Mg/yr)
1.6E+00
l.OE-04
4.3E-01
1.1E-01
<1 .OE-4
9.4E-03
3.0E+00
3.9E-01
<1.0E-4
1.2E-03
3.0E-04
1.8E-02
2.3E-02
1.9E-02
<1.0E-4
5. OE-01
1.2E-02
l.OE-04
6.5E-01
8.3E-01
1 .OE-01
1 .2E-01
1.6E-01
<1 .OE-4
8.9E-01
5.3E-03
<1.0E-4
2.9E-01
2.4E-02
<1 .OE-4
3.1E-02
1.4E-01
7.8E-01
<1 .OE-4
8. OE-01
1.7E-02
3.7E-01
<1 .OE-4
8.6E-02
1 .OE-04
1.2E+00
4. OE-04
2.8E+00
<1 .OE-4
3.1E+00
1 .2E+00
<1 .OE-4
l.OE-04
(a) Aqueous benzene - quantity of benzene In aqueous tastes (over 10 percent water).
-------
0.97. However, revisions were made to the modeling approach for the
wastewater collection system described in the CTC document,11 and the
revised estimate is a fraction emitted of 0.73 for the wastewater
treatment system. This estimate is an average for the 3 model units
that are described in Reference 11. The revised fractions emitted for
each process sequence are given in Table B-l and the control
efficiencies applied to the processing sequence are given 1n Table B-2
(Appendix B).
In conjunction with changes to the proposed regulation, the revised
analysis included only benzene in aqueous wastes (10 percent or more
water) in determining exceedances of the 10 Mg/yr cutoff. Emission
controls were applied to facilities that exceeded the cutoff. Table 4-1
lists the estimated quantity of benzene in aqueous wastes, the baseline
emission estimates, and controlled emission estimates for the off-site
TSDF. Controls were applied when the quantity of benzene in aqueous
wastes was 10 Mg/yr or more and an individual waste stream had a benzene
concentration of 10 ppm or more. A total of 7 of these TSDF are
estimated to manage wastes with 10 Mg/yr or more of benzene and have 30
waste streams with a benzene concentration of 10 ppm or more.
5. CHEMICAL PLANTS
The data used to identify wastes with benzene at chemical plants
were the same as those used at proposal. However, several revisions
were made in the approach used to estimate emissions. The fraction
emitted for wastewater treatment systems was revised from 0.97 to 0.73
as described in the previous section. This change also affected the
-------
fractions emitted for those processing sequences that included
wastewater treatment. The revised fractions emitted are given in Table
B-l, Appendix B.
The-second change was made to account for benzene volatilized from
the wastewater prior to sampling. The benzene concentration and waste
quantity data for many of the chemical plants were reported for the
equalization basin, after the wastewater had traveled through the
collection system and had been mixed with other wastewater streams. The
results for the model units presented in the CTC document11 showed that
up to 44 percent of the benzene may be emitted in the wastewater
collection system prior to entering the equalization basin. An upper
bound emission estimate was developed to include these potential
emissions from the collection system (based on 44-percent emitted),
which may have occurred prior to the sampling point for the reported
concentration.
Another revision in this analysis was the use of only the quantity
of benzene in aqueous wastes for comparison with the 10 Mg/yr cutoff,
which excludes the quantity of benzene in organic liquids. In addition,
comments were received from specific plants that have already
implemented treatment to strip and recover benzene from their
wastewater. The baseline emission estimates for these plants (Plants
No. 40 and 44 in Table 5.1) were corrected to reflect the current level
of treatment.
The previous discussed changes were applied to EPA's data base with
a total of 132 chemical plants. The results of the revised analysis for
chemical plants are summarized in Table 5.1. A range of 22 to 24 plants
are estimated to have 10 Mg/yr or more of benzene in aqueous wastes, and
-------
TABLE 5-1. BENZENE EMISSION ESTIMATES FOR CHEMICAL PLANTS
AQUEOUS (a) BASELINE CONTROLLED
BENZENE (Mg/yr) EMISSIONS (Mg/yr) EMISSIONS (Mg/yr)
No. PLANT
1 3-M COMPANY
2 ABBOTT LABORATORIES
3 AIR PRODUCTS & CHEM.
4 ALDRICH CHEMICALS
5 ALLIED CHEMICAL
6 ALLIED SIGNAL
7 ALPHA CHEMICAL
8 ALPHA RESINS
9 AMCHEM PRODUCTS INC.
10 AMERICAN CYANAMID
11 AMERICAN CYANAMID CO
12 AMERICAN CYANAMID CO
13 AMERICAN HOECHST COR
14 AMERICAN HOECHST COR
15 AMOCO CHEMICAL
16 ARIS TECH CHEMICAL
17 ATLAKT 1C RICHFIELD
18 ATLANTIC RICHFIELD C
19 ATLANTIC WOOD INDUST
20 ATLANTIC WOOD INDUST
21 ATLANTIC WOOD INDUST
22 AYERST LABS
23 BASF WYANOOTTE CORP.
24 BF GOODRICH
25 BF GOODRICH CHEMICAL
26 BROWN ING MANUF.
27 CAIN CHEMICAL
28 CALGON CARBON
29 CELANESE CHEMICAL
30 CELANESE CORP.
31 CHATTEM CHEMICALS
32 CIBA CORNING
33 CIBA-GEIGY
34 CLARK OIL-CHEMICALS
35 COSAN CHEMICAL
36 COSDEN OIL & CHEMICA
37 DENKA CHEMICAL CO.
38 DEVOE & RAYNOLDS
39 DIAMOND SHAMROCK COR
40 DOW CHEMICAL
41 DOW CHEMICAL
42 DOW CHEMICAL
43 DOW CHEMICAL
44 DOW CHEMICAL USA
45 DOW CORNING
46 DSM CHEMICALS
47 DUPONT
48 DUPONT
49 DUPONT
50 DUPONT
51 E 1 DUPONT DE NEMOUR
52 EASTMAN KODAK
53 EASTMAN KODAK, INC.
54 ETHYL CORP.
55 E.I. DUPONT
56 FIRST CHEMICAL CORP
57 FMC CORP.
58 GAF CORP.
59 GENERAL ELECTRIC
60 GEORGIA GULF CORP.
61 GEORGIA-PACIFIC CORP
CITY
COTTAGE GROVE
WICHITA
WICHITA
MILWAUKEE
IRONTON
BIRMINGHAM
LAKELAND
PERRIS
AMBLER
BRIDGEWATER
LINDEN
HANNIBAL
PASADENA
HOUSTON
TEXAS CITY
HAVERHILL
HOUSTON
MONACA
HAINESPORT
SAVANNAH
PORTSMOUTH
ROUSES POINT
JAMESBURG
AVON LAKE
CALVERT CITY
MORGAN
BRAZORIA
NEVILLE ISLAND
BISHOP
PAMPA
CHATTANOOGA
MEDFIELD
TOMS RIVER
BLUE ISLAND
CARLSTADT
BIG SPRING
HOUSTON
LOUISVILLE
DEER PARK
PLAQUEMINE
DALTON
LEDYARD
PITTSBURG
FREEPORT
MIDLAND
AUGUSTA
LUGOFF
DEEPWATER
GIBBSTOWN
BEAUMONT
ORANGE
RXHESTER
LONGVIEW
BATON ROUGE
PARKERSBURG
PASCAGOULA
BALTIMORE
CALVERT CITY
WATERFORD
PASADENA
PLAQUEMINE
ST
MN
KS
KS
Wl
OH
AL
FL
CA
PA
NJ
NJ
MO
TX
TX
TX
OH
TX
PA
NJ
GA
VA
NY
NJ
OH
KY
UT
TX
PA
TX
TX
TN
MA
NJ
IL
NJ
TX
TX
KY
TX
LA
GA
CT
CA
TX
Ml
GA
SC
NJ
NJ
TX
TX
NY
TX
LA
W
MS
MD
KY
NY
TX
LA
MINIMUM
5.8E+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
4.3E-01
4.0E-03
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
2.0E-03
4.0E-03
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.6E+00
4.0E-01
4.6E-01
9.5E-01
4.2E-01
3.8E-01
O.OE+00
2.1E+01
7.4E-01
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.7E+01
1.4E+00
3.0E-03
9.2E+01
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.0E-03
6.2E-02
O.OE+00
2.0E-03
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.5E+01
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
2.8E+02
7.6E-02
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
6.5E-01
6.5E-01
1.2E+02
1.4E+01
O.OE+00
4.6E+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.3E+01
8.2E-01
O.OE+00
2.4E+00
1.0E+01
O.OE+00
MAXIMUM MINIMUM MAXIMUM MINIMUM MAXIMUM
1.0E+01 4.0E-02 7.2E-02 4.0E-02 7.2E-02
O.OE+00 9.7E-03 1.7E-02 9.7E-03 1.7E-02
O.OE+00 2.4E-02 4.3E-02 2.4E-02 4.3E-02
O.OE+00 1.9E-02 3.4E-02 1.9E-Q2 3.4E-02
7.7E-01 6.0E-04 1.1E-03 6.0E-04 1. IE-OS
7.2E-03 3.0E-03 5.4E-03 3.0E-03 5.4E-03
O.OE+00 9.3E-02 1.7E-01 9.3E-02 1.7E-01
O.OE+00 1.2E-01 2.2E-01 1.2E-01 2.2E-01
O.OE+00 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4
3.6E-03 1.0E-04 1.8E-04 1.0E-04 1.8E-04
7.2E-03 3.0E-03 5.4E-03 3.0E-03 5.4E-03
O.OE+00 <1 .OE-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4
O.OE+00 2.9E+01 5.1E+01 2.9E+01 5.1E+01
O.OE+00 3.0E+01 5.4E+01 3.0E+01 5.4E+01
O.OE+00 8.2E-03 1.5E-02 8.2E-03 1.5E-02
2.9E+00 1.2E+00 2.2E+00 1.2E+00 2.2E+00
7.2E-01 3.7E-01 6.7E-01 3.7E-01 6.7E-01
8.3E-01 3.4E-01 6.1E-01 3.4E-01 6.1E-01
1.7E+00 6.7E-01 1.2E+00 6.7E-01 1.2E+00
7.5E-01 9.1E-02 1.6E-01 9.1E-02 1.6E-01
6.8E-01 2.4E-01 4.3E-01 2.4E-01 4.3E-01
O.OE+00 1.3E-02 2.3E-02 1.3E-02 2.3E-02
3.8E+01 1.5E+01 2.8E+01 1.5E-01 2.8E-01
1.3E+00 3.4E-03 6.1E-03 3.4E-03 6.1E-03
O.OE+00<1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4
O.OE+00 <1. OE-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4
3.1E+01 1.9E+00 3.4E+00 9.5E-02 1.7E-01
2.6E+00 1.6E-01 2.9E-01 1.6E-01 2.9E-01
5.4E-03 2.8E-03 5.0E-03 2.8E-03 5.0E-03
1.7E+02 9.1E+01 1.6E+02 9.1E-01 1.6E+00
O.OE+00 <1. OE-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4
O.OE+00<1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4
1.8E-03 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4
1.1E-01 1.0E-03 1.8E-03 1.0E-03 1.8E-03
O.OE+00 <1 .OE-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4
3.6E-03 1.1E-01 1.9E-01 1.1E-01 1.9E-01
O.OE+00 <1 .OE-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4
O.OE+00 <1. OE-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4
O.OE+00 1.6E-02 3.0E-02 1.6E-02 3.0E-02
2.7E+01 7.0E-01 7.0E-01 7.0E-01 7.0E-01
O.OE+00 2.0E-04 3.SE-04 2.0E-04 3.6E-04
O.OE+00 1.0E-04 1.8E-04 1.0E-04 1.8E-04
O.OE+00 1.6E-03 2.9E-03 1.6E-03 2.9E-03
5.1E+02 5.2E+00 5.2E+00 5.2E+00 5.2E+00
1.4E-01 3.0E-01 5.4E-01 3.0E-01 5.4E-01
O.OE+00 <1. OE-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4
O.OE+00 1.0E-04 1.8E-04 1.0E-04 1.8E-04
1.2E+00 5.6E-01 1.0E+00 5.6E-01 1.0E+00
1.2E+00 1.3E-01 2.4E-01 1.3E-01 2.4E-01
2.2E+02 9.0E+01 1.6E+02 9.0E-01 1.6E+00
2.4E+01 9.9E+00 1.8E+01 9.9E-02 1.8E-01
O.OE+00 1.7E-03 3.1E-03 1.7E-03 3.1E-03
8.3E+00 3.6E+00 6.4E+00 3.6E+00 6.4E+00
O.OE+00 1.5E-03 2.7E-03 1.5E-03 2.7E-03
O.OE+00 <1. OE-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4
2.4E+01 9.8E+00 1.8E+01 9.8E-02 1.8E-01
1.5E+00 8.0E-01 1.4E+00 8.0E-01 1.4E+00
O.OE+00 5.7E-03 1.0E-02 5.7E-Q3 1.0E-02
4.3E+00 9.5E-01 1.7E+00 9.5E-01 1.7E+00
1.8E+01 1.1E+00 2.0E+00 5.6E-02 1.0E-01
O.OE+00 5.2E-02 9.5E-02 5.2E-02 9.5E-02
7
-------
TABLE 5-1. BENZENE EMISSION ESTIMATES FOR CHEMICAL PLANTS
No. PLANT
62 GEORGIA-PACIFIC CORP
63 GLIDOEN COATINGS
64 GOODRICH, (B.F.)
65 GOODYEAR TIRE
66 GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBB
67 GREAT LAKES CHEMICAL
68 HEAT ENERGY TECH.
69 HERCULES
70 HERCULES
71 INT'L FLAVORS & FRAG
72 KERR-MCGEE CHEM. COR
73 KOCH INDUSTRIES-CHEMICALS
74 KOPPERS
75 KOPPERS CO INC
76 LILLY COATINGS
77 LILLY IND. COATINGS
78 MALLINCKRODT CHEM.
79 MARISOL INC.
80 MEAD JOHNSON
81 MINE SAFETY APPL.
82 MOBAY CHEMICAL CORP
83 MOBAY CORP.
84 MOBIL CHEMICALS
85 MONSANTO CO
86 MONSANTO CO
87 MONSANTO CO
88 MONSANTO CO
89 MONSANTO CO
90 MONSANTO CO
91 MONTROSE CHEMICAL CO
92 NEPERA CHEMICAL CO.,
93 NIPRO, INC.
94 NORCHEM CO.
95 NORCHEM, INC.
96 OLIN CHEMICALS
97 OLIN CORP.
98 ORB IS PRODUCTS CORP
99 ORTHO DIAGNOSTICS
100 PARKE-DAVIS
101 PPG INDUSTRIES
102 PPG INDUSTRIES
103 REICHHOLD CHEMICALS
104 REICHHOLD CHEMICALS
105 RE ILLY TAR AND CHEMI
106 RE ILLY TAR AND CHEMI
107 RHONE-POULENC.INC.
108 RUBICON CHEMICALS IN
109 SOUTHLAND CORP.
110 STANDARD CHLORIDE CH
111 STAUFFER CHEMICAL
112 STAUFFER CHEMICAL CO
113 STEPAN CO.
114 S.D.S. BIOTECH CORP.
115 TREMCO INC.
116 TROY CHEMICAL CORP.,
117 UNION CARBIDE
118 UNION CARBIDE
119 UNION CARBIDE CARIBE
120 UNION CARBIDE CORP
121 UNION CARBIDE CORP.
122 UPJOHN CO
CITY
PASADENA
CARROLLTON
HENRY
BEAUMONT
LAPORTE
EL DORADO
DALLAS
GIBBSTOWN
MAGNA
UNION BEACH
MERIDIAN
CORPUS CHRISTI
HOUSTON
BRIDGEVILLE
M3NTEBELLO
DALLAS
RALEIGH
MIDDLESEX
EVANSVILLE
EVANS CITY
NEW MARTINSVILLE
HALEDON
BEAUMONT
SAUGET
ST. LOUIS
ADDYSTON
ALVIN
BRIDGEPORT
ANNISTON
HENDERSON
HARRIMAN
AUGUSTA
CLINTON
MORRIS
AUGUSTA
ST. MARKS
NEWARK
RARITAN
HOLLAND
DELAWARE
NORTON
GULFPORT
ELIZABETH
GRANITE CITY
INDIANAPOLIS
MT. PLEASANT
GEISMAR
GREAT MEADOWS
DELAWARE CITY
BATON ROUGE
EDISON
ELWOOD
HOUSTON
BARBOURVILLE
NEWARK
PENUELAS
SE ADRIFT
PONCE
TEXAS CITY
HAHNVILLE
LA PORTE
ST
TX
TX
IL
TX
TX
AR
TX
NJ
UT
NJ
MS
TX
TX
PA
CA
TX
NC
NJ
IN
PA
WV
NJ
TX
IL
MO
OH
TX
NJ
AL
NV
NY
GA
IA
IL
GA
FL
NJ
NJ
Ml
OH
OH
MS
NJ
IL
IN
TN
LA
NJ
DE
LA
NJ
IL
TX
KY
NJ
PR
TX
PR
TX
LA
TX
AQUEOUS (a) BASELINE CONTROLLED
BENZENE (Mg/yr) EMISSIONS (Mg/yr) EMISSIONS (Mg/yr)
MINIMUM MAXIMUM MINIMUM MAXIMUM MINIMUM MAXIMUM
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 1.9E+00 3.5E+00 1.9E+00 3.5E+00
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 1.1E-03 2.0E-03 1.1E-03 2.0E-03
6.0E-03 1.1E-Q2 1.8E-01 3.3E-01 1.8E-01 3.3E-01
1.0E-03 1.8E-03 7.0E-04 1.3E-03 7.0E-04 1.3E-03
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 5.9E-03 1.1E-02 5.9E-03 1.1E-02
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 1.4E-03 2.5E-03 1.4E-03 2.5E-03
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 1.2E-01 2.2E-01 1.2E-01 2.2E-01
1.6E-01 2.8E-01 1.0E-04 1.8E-04 1.0E-04 1.8E-04
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 9.9E-02 1.8E-01 9.9E-02 1.8E-01
1.7E+00 3.1E+00 1.2E+00 2.2E+00 1.2E+00 2.2E+00
1.4E-02 2.5E-02 1.3E-02 2.4E-02 1.3E-02 2.4E-02
4.0E-03 7.2E-03 3.2E-02 5.7E-02 3.2E-02 5.7E-02
2.1E-02 3.8E-02 1.6E-02 2.9E-02 1.6E-02 2.9E-02
1.3E-01 2.3E-01 9.4E-02 1.7E-01 9.4E-02 1.7E-01
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 2.0E-02 3.7E-02 2.0E-02 3.7E-02
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 2.0E-04 3.6E-04 2.0E-04 3.6E-04
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 4.1E-03 7.4E-03 4.1E-03 7.4E-03
8.0E-03 1.4E-02 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 4.0E-04 7.2E-04 4.0E-04 7.2E-04
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 <1.0E-4 <1.0E^4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4
1.0E+02 1.9E+02 7.6E+01 1.4E+02 7.6E-01 1.4E+00
6.1E-02 1.1E-01 4.4E-02 8.0E-02 4.4E-02 8.0E-02
3.6E+01 6.5E+01 2.3E-02 4.2E-02 1 .2E-03 2.2E-03
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 1.0E-04 1.8E-04 1.0E-04 1.8E-04
3.4E-02 6.1E-02 2.5E-02 4.5E-02 2.5E-02 4.5E-02
3.8E-02 6.8E-02 2.8E-02 5.0E-02 2.8E-02 5.0E-02
1.3E+02 2. €+02 9.8E+01 1.8E+02 1.1E+00 2.0E+00
5.6E-01 1.0E+00 3.5E-01 6.3E-01 3.5E-01 6.3E-01
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 1.4E-02 2.6E-02 1.4E-02 2.6E-02
5.0E+00 8.9E+00 4.7E+00 8.4E+00 4.7E+00 8.4E+00
1.0E+01 1.8E+01 1.1E+00 2.0E+00 5.6E-02 1.0E-01
8.0E-02 1.4E-01 7.5E-02 1.3E-01 7.5E-02 1.3E-01
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 4.5E-03 8.1E-03 4.5E-03 8.1E-03
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1 .OE-4
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 1. IE-OS 2.0E-03 1.1E-03 2.0E-03
3.0E-03 5.4E-03 1.2E-01 2.2E-01 1.2E-01 2.2E-01
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 6.0E-04 1.1E-03 6.0E-04 1.1E-03
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 <1. OE-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4
7.0E+01 1.3E+02 5.1E+01 9.2E+01 5.1E-01 9.2E-01
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 <1. OE-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 1.0E-04 1.8E-04 1.0E-04 1.8E-04
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 6.1E-02 1.1E-01 6.1E-02 1 1E-01
6.0E-02 1.1E-01 4.4E-02 7.9E-02 4.4E-02 7.9E-02
8.0E-03 1.4E-02 5.8E-03 1.0E-02 5.8E-03 1.0E-02
4.0E+00 7.2E+00 3.0E+00 5.5E+00 3.0E+00 5 5E+00
1.2E-01 2.3E-01 9.8E-02 1.8E-01 9 8E-02 1 8E-01
3.6E-01 6.5E-01 2.8E-01 5.1E-01 2.8E-01 5JE-01
1.8E+01 3.2E+01 1.3E+01 2.4E+01 2.0E-01 3.6E-01
6.1E+01 1.1E+02 4.4E+01 8.0E+01 4.5E-01 8 OE-01
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 6.2E-03 1.1E-02 6.2E-03 1.1E-02
1.7E+01 3.1E+01 1.2E+01 2.2E+01 1 .2E-01 2.2E-01
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 <1. OE-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1 OE-4
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 3.9E-02 7.0E-02 3.9E-02 7.0E-02
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 <1. OE-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4 <1.0E-4
O.OE+00 O.OE+00 5.4E-02 9.7E-02 5.4E-02 9.7E-02
5.5E-02 1. OE-01 5.2E-02 9.4E-02 5.2E-02 9.4E-02
5.0E-03 9.0E-03 6.9E-03 1.2E-02 6.9E-03 1.2E-02
4.1E+01 7.4E+01 3.8E+01 6.9E+01 3.8E-01 6.9E-01
5.5E+01 9.8E+01 4.0E+01 7.2E+01 4.0E-01 7.2E-01
8.0E-03 1.4E-02 9.8E-03 1.8E-02 9.8E-03 1.8E-02
1.0E-02 1.8E-02 7.3E-03 1.3E-02 7.3E-03 1.3E-02
-------
TABLE 5-1. BENZENE EMISSION ESTIMATES FOR CHEMICAL PLANTS
AQUEOUS (a) BASELINE
BENZENE (Mg/yr) EMISSIONS (Mg/yr)
No.
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
PLANT
UPJOHN CO., THE
US ARMY MUNITIONS
US INDUSTRIAL CHEW.
USS CHEMICAL
USS CHEMICALS
VISTA CHEMICAL
VISTA CHEMICAL
VULCAN MATERIALS
WITCO CHEMICAL CORPO
WITCO CHEMICAL CORP.
CITY
NORTH HAVEN
KINGSTON
TUSCOLA
IRONTON
FLORENCE
HESTLAKE
BALTIMORE
WICHITA
POINT COMFORT
OILDALE
ST
CT
TN
IL
OH
KY
LA
M)
KS
TX
CA
MINIMUM
1
0
0
0
0
1
4
2
5
1
.2E-02
.OE+00
.OE+00
.OE+00
.OE+00
.5E-01
.2E+02
.2E+01
.6E+00
.8E+02
MAXIMUM
2.2E-02
0. OE+00
O.OE+00
0. OE+00
O.OE+00
2.7E-01
7.6E+02
4.1E+01
1.0E+01
3.3E+02
MINIMUM
1 .8E-02
6.0E-04
8. OE-04
4.3E-03
<1.0E-4
4.4E-02
4. OE+00
2.5E+00
1 .4E+00
1 .3E+02
MAXIMUM
3
1
1
7
<1.
7
7
4
2
2
.3E-02
.1E-03
.4E-03
.7E-03
OE-4
.8E-02
.3E+00
.5E+00
.4E+00
.4E+02
CONTROLLED
EMISSIONS (Mg/yr)
MINIMUM
1.8E-02
6. OE-04
8. OE-04
4.3E-03
<1.0E-4
4.4E-02
4.7E-01
1.2E-01
1.4E+00
1.3E+00
MAXIMUM
3.3E-02
1.1E-03
1 .4E-03
7.7E-03
<1.0E-4
7.8E-02
8.5E-01
2.2E-01
2.4E+00
2.4E+00
(a) Aqueous benzene - quantity of benzene In aqueous wastes (over 10 percent water).
-------
a range of 66 to 72 waste streams had a benzene concentration of 10 ppm
or more and would require control. The number of waste streams is based
on an average of approximately 3 benzene waste streams per facility from
EPA's data base.
6.0 COST ESTIMATES
The major revisions to the cost estimates include the costs
associated with steam stripping and the much larger quantities of wastes
that are expected to be controlled, based on the revised estimates
presented in the previous sections. The cost estimate for steam
stripping was revised to use the updated estimate presented in the CTC
document for control of volatile organic compound emissions from
industrial wastewater treatment.14 The steam stripper design and cost
estimates include a storage tank with a retention time of 48 hours
(where solids may settle or a separate organic layer can be removed),
1,500 meters of piping to transport various wastewater streams to the
centrally located steam stripper, and 0.06 kg of steam per liter of
wastewater. The steam stripper is designed to remove virtually 100
percent of the highly volatile compounds in the wastewater. (Benzene
was used as the controlling compound for design purposes.) The capital
cost for a steam stripper processing 130,000 Mg/yr of wastewater was
estimated as $4.70/Mg of wastewater and the total annual cost was
estimated as $1.70/Mg of wastewater.14
The cost estimates include controls for submerged filling of
containers, 95-percent control devices for tanks, steam stripping of
wastewater, thin-film evaporation for sludges, and incineration of
O
-------
organic liquids and solids. Costs are not included for sludges from the
petroleum refining industry (RCRA waste codes K048-K052). These sludges
are expected to be treated for benzene removal as a result of OSW's land
disposal restrictions, and no significant additional costs are expected
as a result of the NESHAP for benzene waste operations. Additional
details on these cost estimates are provided in Appendix E. The
controls are applied only to those facilities with 10 Mg/yr or more
benzene in aqueous wastes, and to all waste streams (both aqueous and
organic) at these facilities with a benzene concentration of 10 ppm or
more. The revised analysis projects that a range of 82 to 197
facilities may be required to install controls for a range of 1,000 to
3,500 individual waste streams that contain benzene. The total quantity
of benzene-containing waste to be controlled is estimated to range from
21 to 76 million Mg/yr. The vast majority of this quantity of waste is
wastewater that is projected to be steam stripped (20 to 75 million
Mg/yr).
The estimated costs are summarized in Table 6-1. The midrange
nationwide capital cost Is estimated as approximately $250 million. The
midrange total annual cost is estimated as $87 million/yr.
7. SUMMARY OF NATIONWIDE IMPACTS
The nationwide impacts for the benzene waste NESHAP are summarized
in Table 7.1. To estimate health impacts, the minimum and maximum
emission estimates for the baseline and controlled cases were modeled
for each plant using EPA's Human Exposure Model (HEM). Details on the
HEM inputs and the results for maximum risk and incidence are given in
Appendix D.
-------
TABLE 6-1. SUMMARY OF WASTE QUANTITIES AND TOTAL NATIONWIDE COSTS (1986 DOLLARS)
Benzene wast* quantity
(1,000 Mg/yr)
Capital cost
factor (S/Mg)c
Capital cost
(S ml 1 1 ion)
Annua 1 cost
factor ($/Mfl)c
Total annual
cost (3 mlllion/yr)
Containers
1.6
0.83
O.OO1
O.15
O.O002
Tanks
690
4.11
2.8
2.57
1.8
Wastewater
48,000*
4.70d
226
1.7Od
81.6
Organic Liquids,
Sludges Sol ids
248b 12
68
17
14.16 36
3.5 0.4
Total
49,000
—
260
—
87
• Midrange value from an estimated total quantity of 2O to 76 million Mg/yr.
b Sludges from the petroleum refining industry (KO48-KO62) are not included In this total. These
sludges are expected to be treated for benzene removal as a result of OSW's land disposal
restrictions, and no significant additional costs are expected as a result of the NESHAP for
benzene waste operations.
c Cost factors were developed as described in Appendix E except for steam stripping of wastewater
(Reference 14) .
Reference 14.
-------
TABLE 7-1. SUMMARY OF NATIONWIDE IMPACTS3
Impact Baseline Control
Benzene emissions (Mg/yr) 2,020-9,700 (5,900) 216 - 690 (450)
Incidence (deaths/yr) 0.2 - 1 (0.6) 0.02 - 0.07 (0.05)
Maximum risk 1 x 1Q-3 - 2 x 10~3 4 x 10'5 - 8 x 10~5
(2 x ID'3) (5 x 10-5)
Capital cost ($ million) — 250
Total annual cost — 87
($ million/yr)
Quantity of waste controlled — 21 - 76 (49)
(million Mg/yr)
Number of facilities — 82 - 197 (140)
affected0
Number of waste streams ~ 1,000 - 3,500 (2,300)
affectedd
a Estimates are presented as ranges with midrange values in parentheses.
b Controls are applied to all benzene-containing wastes with 10 ppm or more
benzene at facilities with 10 Mg/yr or more benzene in their aqueous
wastes.
c Number of facilities in data base of 398 plants with 10 Mg/yr or more
benzene in aqueous wastes.
d Number of benzene-containing waste streams with 10 ppm or more benzene
at the affected facilities.
-------
Benzene emissions of 2,020 to 9,700 Mg/yr for the baseline are
expected to be reduced to 216 to 690 Mg/yr. These estimates are
obtained from summing the minimum and maximum estimates for the four
industry categories given in the preceding sections. The range
presented for maximum risk 1s based on the highest risk from the HEM for
each of the 4 cases that were modeled (minimum and maximum emissions for
the baseline and after control).
Table 7-2 presents the population exposed at each risk level.
These values were estimated from the midrange of the population
exposures given in Appendix D from the HEM and are rounded to one
significant figure.
8. SITE-SPECIFIC ANALYSES
A more detailed examination was made for several plants to evaluate
the modeling approach described in the preceding sections and to place
bounds on the overall uncertainty in the estimates. Results of the
detailed analysis are then compared to the results estimated for these
plants from the general approach described in previous sections. The
more detailed approach was to develop lower and upper bound estimates
based on the range of benzene concentrations that was reported and to
use information on the sites actual waste processing scheme (when
available). In addition, emissions from wastewater collection systems
were included when the reported waste quantity and benzene concentration
were for combined wastewater streams as they entered wastewater
treatment.
-------
TABLE 7-2. MIDRANGE RESULTS FOR CUMULATIVE POPULATION EXPOSURE
Risk Level
^ 10-3
^ 10-4
> 10-5
^ 10-6
> 10-7
Total population
modeled
Population
Baseline
200
10,000
300,000
5,000,000
70,000,000
700,000,000
Exposurea
Controlled
0
0
9,000
200,000
4,000,000
700,000,000
Calculated from the midrange value of the population exposures given in
Appendix D and rounded to one significant figure.
-------
The results In Tables 8-1 and 8-2 are for two chemical plants that
treat two large wastewater streams that contain benzene. The data for
waste quantity, range of benzene concentrations, and processing sequence
were obtained from responses and processing schematics provided in the
survey of hazardous waste generators. The estimates of the fraction of
benzene emitted In each process were obtained from Reference 11. At the
first plant (Table 8-1). the combined wastewater is processed 1n a
series of tanks that include neutralization, settling, equalization, and
biological treatment. Most of the benzene emissions are projected to
occur prior to biodegradation, and after the blodegradation unit,
benzene emissions are expected to be negligible. The second plant
(Table 8-2) processes the combined wastewater in a series of surface
impoundments. The wastewater is then pumped into tanks and injected
underground.
Plant C in Table 8-3 Includes a petroleum refinery and
petrochemical plant. The data for waste quantity, range of benzene
concentrations, and processing sequence were taken from the survey of
hazardous waste generators. The major waste streams include 15.7
million Mg/yr of wastewater and waste oils that contain benzene. To
estimate the quantity of benzene that entered the wastewater collection
system, a back calculation was performed to account for benzene removed
with the waste oil. This approach yielded an estimate of 53 to 1,600
Mg/yr of benzene. The plant reported the quantity of recovered waste
oil (listed as Item 3 1n Table 8-3) as 62,300 Mg/yr with 1 to 10 percent
benzene, which yields a benzene quantity of 623 to 6,230 Mg/yr. This
reported range is higher than that estimated from the back calculation
-------
TABLE 8-1. PLANT A
Major benzene waste: combined wastewaters
Quantity: 3,740,000 Mg/yr
Rpn?pnp ronrpiitratlon • in tn 100 nnm
Benzene quantity: 37 to 374 Mg/yr
Fraction emitted in collection system (before wastewaters combined)
= 0.21 to 0.44
Range of benzene emissions from collection system:
lower end = 37/(l-0.21) x 0.21 = 10 Mg/yr
upper end = 374/(l-0.44) x 0.44 = 294 Mg/yr
Benzene emissions (Mg/yr)
Processes
collection
neutralization
settling
equalization
biological treatment
settling
adsorption
fea
0.21 - 0.44
0.0092b
0.025C
0.4d
0.12e
e
e
Total
Lower
10
0.3
0.9
14.4
2.6
—
—
28
Uooer
294
3.4
9.3
144
26
—
—
480
a Fractions emitted from Reference 11.
b Use the results for a treatment tank.
c Use the results for a clarifier.
d Based on a nonaerated equalization basin. (If the equalization basin is
aerated, fe = 0.99.)
e Approximately 88 percent is biodegraded. Quantity of benzene left after
biological treatment is assumed to be negligible.
-------
TABLE 8-2. PLANT B
Major benzene waste: combined wastewaters (K011, K013, D002, POOS)
Quantity 1 ?on nnn Mn/\/>-
Benzene concentration: 10 to 100 ppm
Benzene quantity: 13 to 130 Mg/yr
Benzene Emissions (Mq/yr)
Processes
collection
surface impoundments
deep well
fea
0.21 -
0.5 - 1
0.44a
.0°
Lower
3.5
6.5
Upper
102
130
Total 10 230
a From Reference 11.
b From Appendix C.
-------
TABLE 8-3. PLANT C
Major benzene waste: combined wastewaters (K048, K049, K051, XWWL)
Quantity: 15,700,000 Mg/yr
Ronyono r*rtnmn1-r'a + i nn • 1 tn 10 nnm
Benzene quantity: 16 to 160 Mg/yr
Plant C stated that 10 to 30 percent of the benzene is removed
with the water (and 70 to 90 percent is removed with the oil) at the
oil-water separator. Estimate the quantity of benzene (in oil and water)
that entered the wastewater collection system.
lower end - 16/0.3 = 53 Mg/yr
upper end - 160/0.1 = 1,600 Mg/yr
1. Emissions from collection system:
53 x 0.21 = 11 Mg/yr
1,600 x 0.44 = 700 Mg/yr
2. Wastewater treatment (Assumes the oil-water separator is covered and
has negligible emissions.)
Benzene emissions (Mq/vr)
Processes fea Lower Upper
equalization 0.4 6.4
sump 0.005 0.05
flocculation 0.009 0.09
clarifier 0.025 0.24
trickle filter 0.4b 3.7
biotreatment 0.12 0.66
Total 11
3. Waste oil (62,300 Mg/yr) containing 1 to 10 percent benzene is
processed by gravity separation, coalescing plate separation, and
storage in a tank. Use fe = 0.00065° for 3 tanks in series.
(62,300) x 0.01 x (3 x 0.00065) = 1.2 Mg/yr
(62,300) x 0.10 x (3 x 0.00065) = 12 Mg/yr
4. A waste oil from the petrochemical plant (D001) with 1 to 10 percent
benzene and 41,600 Mg/yr is processed by phase separation and storage
in a tank. Use fe = 0.00065 for 2 tanks.
(41,600) x 0.01 x (2 x 0.00065) = 0.5 Mg/yr
(41,600) x 0.1 x (2 x 0.00065) = 5.4 Mg/yr
-------
TABLE 8-3. PLANT C (continued)
5. Total Emissions (Mg/yr)
11 700
11 110
1.2 12
0.5 5.4
24 830
a Fraction emitted, from Reference 11.
b Use the results for a nonaerated equalization tank.
c From Appendix C.
-------
(53 to 1,600 Mg/yr of benzene) and suggests that if the waste oil was
recovered from the wastewater treatment system, actual benzene emissions
from the wastewater system may have been greater than the estimate of 11
to 110 Mg/yr. The overall fraction of the benzene emitted from
wastewater collection and treatment for this estimate ranged from
approximately 0.4 to 0.5. The oil-water separator was reported to be
covered and controlled with negligible benzene emissions. The fractions
emitted for the two organic liquid wastes (waste oil) ranged from 0.0013
to 0.002 for two and three tanks in series, respectively.
A more detailed analysis was performed for one coke by-product
recovery plant (Plant D in Table 8-4) from data submitted by the
company. A large wastewater stream containing a small amount of oil
that floats on the water and a heavier tar layer is placed in open
settling tanks. The oil is skimmed from the top of the water, and the
heavier tar layer is removed from the bottom of the tanks. The
separated water layer is pumped to a storage tank that serves as the
feed tank for a stripper. The benzene concentration in the water
entering the settling tanks was reported (148 ppm), and the
concentrations in the oil (123 ppm), water (84 ppm) and tar (2,500 ppm)
were reported for the different phases removed from the settling tanks.
No data were supplied for the benzene concentrations in the oil and tar
that entered with the wastewater. Although the benzene concentration in
the tar is very high, it is within the range measured in tar as it is
removed from the coke oven gas (1,400 to 4,600 ppm)13.
-------
TABLE 8-4. PLANT D
Description: A wastewater stream composed of a small oil phase that floats
on the water, a large water phase, and a small tar phase (heavier than
wato*^ i^ nvnrpccorl "in nnpn tnn c
-------
The approach in Table 8-4 to estimate benzene losses includes
several conservative assumptions:
• The wastewater is collected and transported in closed piping
from the point of generation to the settling tanks. (Assumes
there are no open sewers, junction boxes, or sumps in the
collection system).
• Benzene emissions from the oil in the settling tank are
neglected. (The benzene concentration in the oil leaving the
settling tank is assumed to be equal to the concentration in
the oil entering the tank.)
• Emissions from the removal, collection, and treatment of the
oil and tar and stripping of the benzene are not included.
The resulting emission estimate of 180 to 240 Mg/yr of benzene is based
on the total quantity of wastewater and decreases in benzene
concentration in the water of 148 to 80 ppm and 148 to 59 ppm. The
concentration reported leaving the feed tank (80 ppm) appears to be
anomalous when compared to the value entering the tank (59 ppm). This
variation may be due to the precision of the analytical method or from
inlet and outlet samples that are not related with respect to time. For
example, the storage tank volume 1s 3 million gallons with a residence
time of approximately 37 hours. If emissions from the settling tank and
feed tank are estimated from the fractions emitted derived for tanks in
Appendix C (0.03 to 0.18), total emissions would range from 26 to 144
Mg/yr.
The results from the detailed analyses are compared with the
results from the general impacts analysis in Table 8-5. The more
-------
TABLE 8-5. COMPARISON OF ESTIMATES USED FOR IMPACTS ANALYSIS
WITH MORE DETAILED ESTIMATES
Facility
Plant A
Plant B
Plant C
Plant D
Benzene Emission
Impacts Analysis
76-140 (108)
98-180 (139)
16-140 (78)
3-42 (23)
Estimates (Mg/yr)a
Detailed
28-480
10-230
24-830
180-240
Analysis*5
(250)
(120)
(430)
(210)
a Midrange values are presented in parentheses.
b From results in Tables 8-1 through 8-4.
-------
detailed analysis yields a wider range in the estimated emissions.
However, significant benzene emissions are projected to occur even for
the lower end of the range. The general analysis appears to provide a
reasonable approximation of the range of benzene emissions.
-------
8. REFERENCES
1. Memorandum. G. F1tzs1mons to Docket. Summary of Meeting with
American Petroleum Institute. December 11, 1989.
2. Annual Refining Survey. Oil and Gas Journal. 87:(12)68-89,
March 20, 1989.
3. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. VOC Emissions from Petroleum
Refinery Wastewater Systems - Background Information for Proposed
Standards. EPA-450/3-85-001a. February 1985. p. 3-8 to 3-11.
4. Finelt, S., J. R. Crump. Predict Wastewater Generation.
Hydrocarbon Processing. 56:(8) 159-166, August 1977.
5. Hoffman, H. L. Petroleum and Its Products. In Riegel's Handbook
of Industrial Chemistry. Van Nostrand Reinhold Co., New York.
1983. p. 495.
6. Docket A-89-06, Item IV-D-59. Comments from Shell Oil Company.
November 10, 1989.
7- Docket A-89-06, Item IV-D-46. Comments from Chevron Corporation.
November 13, 1989.
8. Brownstein, A. M. Trends in Petrochemical Technology. Petroleum
Publishing Co., Tulsa, OK. 1976. p. 18.
9. Howard, P. H., et al. Benzene. Environmental Sources of
Contamination, Ambient Levels, and Fate. EPA 500/5-75-005.
PB-244 139. December 1974. p. 22.
10. Data extracted from the generators survey and TSDR survey are given
in Tables 2-4, B-3, and B-4.
11. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Industrial Wastewater
Volatile Organic Compound Emissions—Background Information for
BACT/LAER Determinations. Control Technology Center. January
1990. Appendix A. Emission Estimates.
12. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Development Document for
Effluent Limitation Guidelines and Standards for Iron and Steel
Manufacturing. Volume II, Cokemaking Subcategory. EPA 440/1-
82/024. May 1982. p. 39-59.
13. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Benzene Emissions from Coke
By-product Recovery Plants - Background Information for Proposed
Standards. EPA-450/3-83-016a. May 1984. p. C-21 to C-29.
-------
8. REFERENCES (continued)
14. Reference 11, Chapter 6. Control Cost Analysis of Steam Stripper
System.
15. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Hazardous Waste TSDF -
Background Information for Proposed RCRA Air Emission Standards:
Volume II, Appendix D. (Draft). March 1988.
16. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Hazardous Waste Treatment,
Storage, and Disposal Facilities (TSDF)--Air Emission Models,
Publication No. EPA-450/3-87-026. December 1987.
17. Docket A-89-06, Item IV-D-48. Comments from Chemical Manufacturers
Association. November 13, 1989. p. 21.
18. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Control Cost and Efficiency
Estimates for Hazardous Waste TSDF Organic Air Emission Regulatory
Analyses (Draft). Emission Standards Division. Research Triangle
Park, NC. April 1988. p. 7-1 to 7-10.
19. Reference 18, p. 8-1 to 8-8.
-------
APPENDIX A
ADDITIONAL DETAILS FOR PETROLEUM REFINERY ESTIMATES
-------
TABLE A-1. PROCESS CAPACITIES FOR PETROLEUM REFINERIES
CAPACITY (1,000 barrels per day) •
PLANT
AMERADA HESS
AMERADA-HESS
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO
ANCHOR REF.
ARCO ALASKA
ARCO ALASKA
ARCO PETROLEUM
ASHLAND
ASHLAND
ASHLAND
ATLANTIC REF IN ING
ATLANTIC RICHFIELD
BARRETT REF.
BELCHER REF.
BERRY PETROLEUM
BIG WEST OIL
BLOOMFIELD REFINING
BP OIL
BP OIL
CALCASIEU REFINING
CALUMET REFINING COM
CANAL REF.
CENEX REF.
CHAMPLIN PETROLEUM C
CHEMOIL
CHEVF':M
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CIBRO PETROLEUM
CITGO PETROLEUM
CLARK OIL & REFINING
CLARK OIL & REFINING
COASTAL EAGLE PT.
COASTAL REFINING
COLORADO REF.
CONOCO
CONOCO
CONC 1
CONCU
CONOCO
CROSS OIL & REFINING
CROWN CE^rRAL
CRYSEN REFINING
CRYSTAL REF.
DERBY REFINING COMPA
DERBY REF.
DIAMOND SHAMROCK
DIAMOND SHAMROCK
EDGINGTON OIL COMPAN
EL PASO REFINING
ERGON REF.
EXXON
CITY ST
PURVIS MS
PORT READING NJ
SALT LAKE CITY UT
CASPER WY
WHITING IN
SAVANNAH GA
MANDAN ND
TEXAS CITY TX
YORKTOWN VA
MCKITTRICK CA
KUPARUK AX
PRUDHOE BAY AK
FERNDALE HA
ASHLAND KY
ST. PAUL PARK MN
CANTON OH
PHILADELPHIA PA
CARSON CA
THOMAS OK
MOBILE BAY AL
STEVENS AK
SALT LAKE CITY UT
BLOOMFIELD NM
BELLE CHASSE LA
MARCUS HOOK PA
LAKE CHARLES LA
PRINCETON LA
CHURCH POINT LA
LAUREL MT
CORPUS CHRISTI TX
SIGNAL HILL CA
PASCAGOUU MS
EL SEGUNDO CA
PORTLAND OR
HONOLULU HI
PORT ARTHUR TX
KENAI AK
PERTH AMBOY NJ
SALT LAKE CITY UT
EL PASO TX
SEATTLE WA
RICHMOND CA
PHILADELPHIA PA
ALBANY NY
LAKE CHARLES LA
BLUE ISLAND IL
HARTFORD IL
WESTVILLE NJ
CORPUS CHRISTI TX
COMMERCE CITY CO
COMMERCE CITY CO
PONCA CITY OK
BILLINGS MT
SANTA MARIA CA
WESTLAKE LA
SMACKOVER AR
HOUSTON TX
WOODS CROSS UT
CARSON CITY Ml
WICHITA KS
EL DORADO KS
THREE RIVERS TX
SUNRAY TX
LONG BEACH CA
EL PASO TX
VICKSBURG MS
BATON ROUGE LA
CRUDE CATALYTIC CATALYTIC VISBREAKING COKING NAPHTHA BENZENE
OIL CRACKING REFORMING SWEETENING PRODUCTION
30
0
40
40
350
28
58
420
51
10
12
14
162
213.4
67.1
66
125
214
13
14.3
3.8
24
16.8
195
171
12
4.1
9.9
40.4
150
14.4
295
330
15
48
329
22
80
45
66
5
270
174
42.8
320
64.6
60
109.3
90.3
28
44
136
48.5
9.5
156.5
6.8
100
12.5
4
29.9
28.5
50
105
41.6
21
16.8
455
16
50
18
13.5
140
26
195
27.5
100
23
25
29
82
5
5.4
89
50
12
70
56
60
22
110
18
22
63
53.3
150
25
26
50
18.5
8
15
46
15.5
40
56
19
14.5
19
45
7
155
5.8
7.6
7
85
12.1
160
9.8
56
52
23.5
20
60
48
5
2.8
37.5
48
1.9
12
52
90
60
67.1
5.5
25
68
34
91
30.5
12
38
28.5
9
7.5
34.5
12.5
27.4
36
3
6.5
4.5
11
29
5.6
90
5.8
28.5
16.6
41
13.5
50
12
56
21 42
32 54
62
3.5
34 67.1
8.5
34
63
14.5 4
10
11 12
20.5
53
12.5
5.5
4
90 2.5
13
45
5.4
30.3
5
5.5
1.5
10
5.3
16
18
4
-------
TABLE A-1. PROCESS CAPACITIES FOR PETROLEUM REFINERIES
CAPACITY (1,000 barrels per day) •
PLANT
EXXON
EXXON
EXXON
EXXON
FARMLAND INDUSTRIES
FARMLAND INDUSTRIES
FINAOIL
FINAOIL
FLETCHER OIL & REF1N
FRONTIER OIL
GIANT REFINERY
GOLDEN NEST REFINING
HAWAII INDEP. REF.
HILL PETROLEUM
HILL PETROLEUM
HILL PETROLEUM
HOWELL HYDROCARBONS
HUNT REFINING
HUNTWAY REF.
HUNTWAY REF.
INDIANA FARM BUREAU
INTERMOUNTAIN REF.
KERN OIL i REFINING
KERR MCGEE
KERR MCGEE
KERR MCGEE
KOCH REFINING
KOCH REFINING
LA GLORIA OIL AND GA
LAKESIDE REF.
LAKETON REFINING
LION OIL
LIQUID ENERGY CORP.
LITTLE AMERICA REF.
LOUISIANA LAND & EXP
LUNDAY-THAGARD CO.
LYONOELL PETROCHEMIC
MANTUA OIL
MAPCO PETROLEUM
MAPCO PETROLEUM
MARATHON PETROLEUM
MARATHON PETROLEUM
MARATHON PETROLEUM
MARATHON PETROLEUM
MIDATLANTIC REF-
MOBIL
MOBIL
MOBIL
MOBIL
MOBIL
MONTANA REFINING COM
MURPHY OIL CORPORATI
MURPHY OIL CORPORATI
NATIONAL COOPERATIVE
NAVAJO REFINING
NEVADA REF.
NEHHALL REFINING CO.
OXNARO REF.
PACIFIC REF.
PARAMOUNT PET.
PENNZOIL
PENNZOIL
PENNZOIL
PETRO STAR
PHILLIPS
PHILLIPS
PHILLIPS
CITY
BENICIA
BILLINGS
LINDEN
BAYTOKN
COFFEYVILLE
PHILLIPSBURG
PORT ARTHUR
BIG SPRING
WILMINGTON
CHEYENNE
GALLUP
ST
CA
MT
NJ
TX
KS
KS
TX
TX
CA
WY
NM
SANTA FE SPRINGCA
EWA BEACH
TEXAS CITY
HOUSTON
KROTZ SPRINGS
SAN ANTONIO
TUSCALOOSA
BENECIA
WILMINGTON
MT. VERNON
FREDONIA
BAKERSFIELD
NYNNENOOD
COHON VALLEY
COTTON VALLEY
CORPUS CHRISTI
ROSEMOUKT
TYLER
KALAMAZOO
LAKETON
EL DORADO
BRIDGEPORT
CASPER
SARALAND
SOUTH GATE
HOUSTON
THOROFARE
MEMPHIS
NORTH POLE
ROBINSON
TEXAS CITY
DETROIT
GARYVILLE
ST. MARYS
CHALMETTE
BEAUMONT
JOLIET
TORRANCE
PAULS80RO
GREAT FALLS
SUPERIOR
MERAUX
MCPHERSON
ARTESIA
TONOPAH
NEWHALL
OXNARO
HERCULES
PARAMOUNT
ROOSEVELT
SHREVEPORT
ROUSEVILLE
NORTH POLE
SWEENY
BORGER
WOODS CROSS
HI
TX
TX
LA
TX
AL
CA
CA
IN
AZ
CA
OK
LA
LA
TX
MN
TX
Ml
IN
AR
TX
IKY
AL
CA
TX
NJ
TN
AK
IL
TX
Ml
LA
WV
LA
TX
IL
CA
NJ
MT
Nl
LA
KS
NM
NV
CA
CA
CA
CA
UT
LA
PA
AK
TX
TX
UT
CRUDE CATALYTIC CATALYTIC VISBREAKING COKING NAPHTHA BENZENE
OIL CRACKING REFORMING SWEETENING PRODUCTION
128
42
130
493
56.5
26.4
100
55
26.5
35
18
40.6
81.5
119.6
67.5
55.3
2.8
44.5
8.4
5.5
20.6
5.7
20
43
33
7.8
125
218.5
55
5.6
8.3
48
10
22
80
7.7
265
45
57
90
195
69.5
68.5
255
5
145
275
180
123
100
6.3
32
92.5
70.9
38
4.5
18.8
4.3
52.3
42.7
8
46.2
15.7
7
175
105
25
64
21
120
155
23
36
22
10.5
12
7.2
13.5
43.5
55
28
20
40
55
17
18.5
14
90
30
41
38
27
85
51
102
98
63
36
2.1
11
35
20
14.5
6
87
60
8.4
28
10
28
123
"16
5.3
34
20
5
6.6
6.8
19
12
23
11.5
12.5
1
6
4
3
8.5
48.5
32
15.7
1
9
6
21
no
10
79
9
18.5
48
1.5
47
103
46
36
23.5
1
8
23
15
7.8
2.5
15
10.5
2
10
5.8
36
26
6
22
15.5
19
23.5
12
6.6
6.8
13.8 12
13
19
10 1.5
6
12
58 15
6 16
3.8
40 10
5
4 22
33
29.5
38 9
48 16
21.5
22 14.5
12
11
53
26.5
11
10
0.6
2
1
10.8
11
2.5
2.5
7
5.6
-------
TABLE A-1. PROCESS CAPACITIES FDR PETROLEUM REFINERIES
CAPACITY (1,000 barrels par day) *
PLANT
PLACID REFINING
POWER INE OIL
PRIDE REFINING
QUAKER STATE OIL REF
QUAKES STATE OIL REF
ROCK ISLAM) REFINING
SAN JOAQUIN REF.
SHELL
SHELL
SHELL
SHELL
SHELL
SHELL
SHELL
SINCLAIR OIL
SINCLAIR OIL
SOHIO
SOMERSET REFINERY
SOUND REF.
SOUTHLAND OIL
SOUTHLAND OIL
UTHWESTERN REF IN IN
4NDARD OIL OF OHIO
STANDARD OIL OF OHIO
STAR REF.
STAR REF.
STAR REF.
SUN CO.
SUN CO.
SUN CO.
SUNLAND REF.
TESARO ALASKA PETROL
TEXACO
TEXACC
TEXACC
TEXACO
TOSCO CORP.
TOTAL PETROLEUM
TOTAL PETROLEUM
TOTAL PETROLEUM
TRI FINERY
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
UNITED REF.
UNOCAL
U.S. OIL & REFINING
VALERO ENERGY CORP.
WITC
WIT;.
HYOM.NG REF.
YOUNG REF-
CITY ST
PORT ALLEN LA
SANTA FE SPRINGCA
ABILENE TX
SMETHPORT PA
NEWELL- WV
INDIANAPOLIS IN
BAKERSFIELD CA
MARTINEZ CA
DEER PARK TX
NORCO LA
ANACORTES WA
WOOD RIVER IL
ODESSA TX
WILMINGTON CA
SINCLAIR NY
TULSA OK
FERNDALE WA
SOMERSET KY
TACOMA WA
LUMBERTON MS
SANDERSVILLE MS
CORPUS CHRISTI TX
TOLEDO OH
LIMA OH
PORT ARTHUR TX
DELAWARE CITY DE
CONVENT LA
TULSA OK
MARCUS HOOK PA
TOLEDO OH
BAKERSFIELD CA
KENAI AK
WILMINGTON CA
ANACORTES WA
EL DORADO KS
BAKERSFIELD CA
MARTINEZ CA
ARKANSAS CITY KS
ALMA Ml
ARDMORE OK
CORPUS CHRISTI TX
RODEO CA
LEMQNT IL
WILMINGTON CA
NEDERLAND TX
WARREN PA
LOS ANGELES CA
TACOMA WA
CORPUS CHRISTI TX
OILOALE CA
BRADFORD PA
NEWCASTLE WY
DOUGLASVILLE GA
CRUDE CATALYTIC CATALYTIC VISBREAKING COKING NAPHTHA BENZENE
OIL CRACKING REFORMING SWEETENING PRODUCTION
47.5
46.6
42.8
6.5
10.5
44
18
140
216
215
84
274
28.6
144
54
50
77
5.5
11.9
5.8
11
104
120.7
171
250
140
225
85
165
125
15
72
75
97
78.2
47
126
53.6
42
60.5
28.5
113
147
68
120
64.6
108
32.8
20
10.8
8.5
12.5
8.8
18.5
12.5
19
67
65
41
94
10.5
42
21
18
25.5
50
55
36
110
65
85
30
87
60
28
36
31.5
55
19
18.5
22.5
58
38
39
20
47
54
4
10
8.5 10.4
2.1
3.4
10
10
28 33
63 101.5
56 21 . 57
25 32
97 64
11 11
24 53 39
14.5
12
11.8
1
30
42 13.7
53 16.2
40
56
40 12
24
39.6
45.6
1.5 1.5
12
38 48
21 20
25 13 24.8
23 11.8
43
16
14
12
34 50.7
29.8 27.9 28.6
14.5 24
32 10.6
16
52 20
6 1
3.3
2.8
20
3.8
0.4
6.5
30.9
3.4
3.4
7
11.4
3
3.5
6
FROM REFERENCE 2.
A-3
-------
TABLE A-2. ESTIMATED HASTE QUANTITIES FOR REFINERY WASTEWATERS
MINIMUM WASTE QUANTITIES (Mg/yr)« MAXIMUM WASTE QUANTITIES (Mg/yr)«
PLANT
EXXON
EXXON
EXXON
EXXON
FARMLAND INDUSTRIES
FARMLAND INDUSTRIES
FINA OIL
FINA OIL
FLETCHER OIL & REF IN
FRONTIER OIL
GIANT REFINERY
GOLDEN WEST REFINING
HAWAII INOEP. REF.
HILL PETROLEUM
HILL PETROLEUM
HILL PETROLEUM
HOWELL HYDROCARBONS
HUNT REFINING
HUNTWAY REF.
HUNTWAY REF.
INDIANA FARM BUREAU
INTERMOUNTAIN REF.
KERN OIL & REFINING
KERR MCGEE
KERR MCGEE
KERR MCGEE
KOCH REFINING
KOCH REFINING
LA GLORIA OIL AND GA
LAKESIDE REF.
LAKETON REFINING
LION OIL
LIQUID ENERGY CORP.
LITTLE AMERICA REF.
LOUISIANA LAND & EXP
LUNDAY-THAGARO CO.
LYONDELL PETROCHEMIC
MANTUA OIL
MAPCO PETROLEUM
MAPCO PETROLEUM
MARATHON PETROLEUM
MARATHON PETROLEUM
MARATHON PETROLEUM
MARATHON PETROLEUM
MIDATLANTIC REF-
. MOBIL
MOBIL
MOBIL
MOBIL
MOBIL
MONTANA REFINING COM
MURPHY OIL CORPORATI
MURPHY OIL CORPORATI
NATIONAL COOPERATIVE
NAVAJO REFINING
NEVADA REF.
NEHHALL REFINING CO.
OXNARO REF.
PACIFIC REF.
PARAMOUNT PET.
PEN.NZOIL
PENNZOIL
FENNZOIL
PETRO STAR
PHILLIPS
PHILLIPS
PHILLIPS
CITY
BEN 1C 1 A
BILLINGS
LINDEN
BAYTOWN ~
COFFEYVILLE
PHILLIPSBURG
PORT ARTHUR
BIG SPRING
WILMINGTON
CHEYENNE
GALLUP
ST
CA
MT
NJ
TX
KS
KS
TX
TX
CA
WY
NM
SANTA FE SPRINGCA
EWA BEACH
TEXAS CITY
HOUSTON
KROTZ SPRINGS
SAN ANTONIO
TUSCALOOSA
BENECIA
WILMINGTON
MT. VERNON
FREDONIA
BAKERSFIELD
WYNNEWOOD
COTTON VALLEY
COTTON VALLEY
CORPUS CHRISTI
ROSEMOUNT
TYLER
KALAMAZOO
LAKETON
ELDORADO
BRIDGEPORT
CASPER
S ARAL AND
SOUTH GATE
HOUSTON
THOROFARE
MEMPHIS
NORTH POLE
ROBINSON
TEXAS CITY
DETROIT
GARYVILLE
ST. MARYS
CHALMETTE
BEAUMONT
JOLIET
TORRANCE
PAULSBORO
GREAT FALLS
SUPERIOR
MERAUX
MCPHERSON
ARTESIA
TONOPAH
NEWHALL
OXNARO
HERCULES
PARAMOUNT
ROOSEVELT
SHREVEPORT
"OJSEVILLE
NORTH POLE
SWEENY
BORGER
WOODS CROSS
HI
TX
TX
LA
TX
AL
CA
CA
IN
AZ
CA
OK
LA
LA
TX
MN
TX
Ml
IN
AR
TX
WY
AL
CA
TX
NJ
TN
AK
IL
TX
Ml
LA
WV
LA
TX
IL
CA
NJ
MT
Wl
LA
KS
NM
NV
CA
CA
CA
CA
UT
LA
PA
AK
TX
TX
UT
1,2,12
3.5E+05
1.2E+05
3.6E+05
1.4E+06
1.6E+05
7.3E+04
2.8E+05
1.5E+05
7.3E+04
9.7E+04
5. OE+04
1.1E+05
2.3E+05
3.3E+05
1.9E+05
1.5E+05
7.8E+03
1.2E+05
2.3E+04
1.5E+04
5.7E+04
1.6E+04
5.5E+04
1.2E+05
9.1E+04
2.2E+04
3.SE+05
6.1E+05
1.5E+05
1.6E+04
2.3E+04
1.3E+05
2.8E+04
6.1E+04
2.2E+05
2.1E+04
7.3E+05
1.2E+05
1.6E+05
2.5E+05
5.4E+05
1.9E+05
1.9E+05
7.1E+05
1.4E+04
4.0E+05
7.6E+05
5.0E+05
3.4E+05
2.8E+05
1.7E+04
8.9E+04
2.6E+05
2.0E+05
1.1E+05
1.2E+04
5.2E+04
1.2E+04
1.4E+05
1.2E+05
2.2E+04
1.3E+05
4.4E+04
1.9E+04
4.8E+05
2.9E+05
6.9E+04
3,4,6,7,8
9.10.11
1.7E+05
5.7E+04
2.6E+05
5.1E+05
1.2E+05
1.5E+04
1.1E+05
6.4E+04
3.1E+04
6.6E+04
2.1E+04
4.5E+04
4.6E+04
1.3E+05
1.2E+05
7.3E+04
1.6E+03
6.8E+04
4.7E+03
3.0E+03
1.2E+04
3.2E+03
1.1E+04
5.4E+04
1.8E+04
4.3E+03
1.8E+05
4.5E+05
8.3E+04
3.1E+03
4.6E+03
5.5E+04
5.5E+03
3.4E+04
4.4E+04
4.3E+03
4.6E+05
2.5E+04
7.8E+04
5.0E+04
2.7E+05
9.6E+04
7.9E+04
2.7E+05
2.8E+03
3.0E+05
4.3E+05
4.1E+05
3.7E+05
2.0E+05
6.7E+03
3.4E+04
1 .CC+05
1.7E+05
4.3E+04
2.5E+03
1. OE+04
2.4E+03
3. OE+04
2.5E+04
1.4E+04
2.6E+04
8.7E+03
3.9E+03
2.3E+05
1.5E+05
2.8E+04
5
8.5E+03
3.0E+03
8.5E+03
3.7E+04
4.9E+03
1.6E+03
1. OE+04
6.1E+03
1.5E+03
2.0E+03
2.1E+03
5.8E+03
3.7E+03
7.0E+03
3.5E+03
3.8E+03
3.0E+02
1 .8E+03
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.2E+03
O.OE+00
9.1E+02
2.6E+03
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1 .5E+04
9.7E+03
4.8E+03
3.0E+02
O.OE+00
2.7E+03
O.OE+00
1 .8E+03
6.4E+03
O.OE+00
3.3E+04
O.OE+00
3.0E+03
O.OE+00
2.4E+04
2.7E+03
5.6E+03
1.5E+04
4.6E+02
1 .4E+04
3.1E+04
1.4E+04
1.1E+04
7.2E+03
3.0E+02
2.4E+03
7.0E+03-
•4.6E+03
2.4E+03
O.OE+00
7.6E+02
O.OE+00
4.6E+03
3.2E+03
6.1E+02
3.0E+03
1 .8E+03
O.OE+00
1.1E+04
7.9E+03
1.8E+03
0.
0.
0.
0.
0.
0.
2.
1.
0.
0.
0.
0.
0.
0.
5.
0.
2.
0.
0.
0.
0.
0.
0.
0.
0.
0.
3.
0.
0.
0.
0.
0.
0.
0.
0.
0.
3.
0.
0.
6.
0.
6.
0.
0.
0.
1.
0.
0.
0.
13
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
8E+04
7E+03
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
5E+03
OE+00
8E+03
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+04
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
OE+04
OE+00
OE+00
9E+03
OE+00
9E+03
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
9E+04
OE+00
OE+00
OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.6E+04
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1,2.12
3.6E+05
1.2E+05
3.6E+05
1.4E+06
1.6E+05
7.4E+04
2.8E+05
1.5E+05
7.4E+04
9.7E+04
5. OE+04
1.1E+05
2.3E+05
3.3E+05
1.9E+05
1.5E+05
7.8E+03
1.2E+05
2.3E+04
1.5E+04
5.7E+04
1.6E+04
5.6E+04
1.2E+05
9.2E+04
2.2E+04
3.5E+05
6.1E+05
1.5E+05
1.6E+04
2.3E+04
1.3E+05
2.8E+04
6.1E+04
2.2E+05
2.1E+04
7.4E+05
1.3E+05
1.6E+05
2.5E+05
5.4E+05
1.9E+05
1.9E+05
7.1E+05
1.4E+04
4.0E+05
7.7E+05
5.0E+05
3.4E+05
2.8E+05
1.8E+04
8.9E+04
2.6E+05
2. CC+05
1.1E+05
1.3E+04
5.2E+04
1.2E+04
1.5E+05
1.2E+05
2.2E+04
1.3E+05
4.4E+04
1.9E+04
4.9E+05
2.9E+05
7. OE+04
3,4,6,7.8
9.10.11
2.0E+05
6.7E+04
2.9E+05
6.3E+05
1.3E+05
2.1E+04
1.4E+05
7.8E+04
3.7E+04
7.5E+04
2.6E+04
6. OE+04
7.1E+04
1.7E+05
1.€+05
8.7E+04
2.2E+03
7.9E+04
6.7E+03
4.4E+03
1.7E+04
4.6E+03
1.6E+04
6.5E+04
2.6E+04
6.3E+03
2.1E+05
5.1E+05
9.7E+04
4.5E+03
6.7E+03
6.7E+04
8.0E+03
3.9E+04
6.4E+04
6.2E+03
5.2E+05
3.6E+04
9.2E+04
7.2E+04
3.1E+05
1.1E+05
9.6E+04
3.3E+05
4.0E+03
3. €+05
5.0E+05
4.6E+05
4.0E+05
2.3E+05
8.3E+03
4.2E+04
1.3E+05
1.8E+05
5.3E+04
3.6E+03
1.5E+04
3.5E+03
4.7E+04
3.5E+04
1.6E+04
3.7E+04
1 .3E+04
5.6E+03
2.8E+05
1.8E+05
3.4E+04
5
8.5E+03
3.0E+03
8.5E+03
3.7E+04
4.9E+03
1.6E+03
1. OE+04
6.1E+03
1.5E+03
2.0E+03
2.1E+03
5.8E+03
3.7E+03
7.0E+03
3.5E+03
3.8E+03
3.0E+02
1.8E+03
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.2E+03
O.OE+00
9.1E+02
2.6E+03
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.5E+04
9.7E+03
4.8E+03
3.0E+02
O.OE+00
2.7E+03
O.OE+00
1.8E+03
6.4E+03
O.OE+00
3.3E+04
O.OE+00
3.0E+03
O.OE+00
2.4E+04
2.7E+03
5.6E+03
1.5E+04
4.6E+02
1 .4E+04
3.1E+04
1.4E+04
1.1E+04
7.2E+03
3.0E+02
2.4E+03
7.0E+03
4.6E+03
2.4E+03
O.OE+00
7.6E+02
O.OE+00
4.6E+03
3.2E+03
6.1E+02
3.0E+03
1 -8E+03
O.OE+00
1.1E+04
7.9E+03
1 .8E+03
13
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
0, OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
2.8E+04
1.7E+03
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
5.5E+03
O.OE+00
2.8E+03
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
3. OE+04
O.OE+00.
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
3. OE+04
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
6.9E+03
O.OE+00
6.9E+03
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.9E+04
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
1.6E+04
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
A-5
-------
TABLE A-2. ESTIMATED WASTE QUANTITIES FOR REFINERY HASTEWATERS
PLANT
PLACID REFINING
POWERINE OIL
PRIDE REFINING
QUAKER STATE OIL REF
QUAKER STATE OIL REF
ROCK ISLAND REFINING
SAN JOAQUIN REF.
SHELL
SHELL
SHELL
SHELL
SHELL
SHELL
SHELL
SINCLAIR OIL
SINCLAIR OIL
SOHIO
SOMERSET REFINERY
SOUND REF.
SOUTHLAND OIL
SOUTHLAND OIL
SOUTHWESTERN REF IN IN
STANDARD OIL OF OHIO
STANDARD OIL OF OHIO
STAR REF.
STAR REF.
STAR REF.
SUN CO.
SUN CO.
SUN CO.
SUNLAND REF.
TESARO ALASKA PETROL
TEXACO
TEXACO
TEXACO
TEXACO
TOSCO CORP.
TOTAL PETROLEUM
TOTAL PETROLEUM
TOTAL PETROLEUM
TRI FINERY
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
UNITED REF.
UNOCAL
U.S. OIL & REFINING
VALERO ENERGY CORP.
WITCO
WITCO
WYOMING REF.
YOUNG REF.
MINIMUM HASTE QUANTITIES (Mg/yr )• MAXIMUM HASTE QUANTITIES (Mg/yr)*
1,2,12 3,4,6,7,8 5 13 1,2.12 3,4,6,7.8 5 13
CITY ST 9,10,11 9,10,11
PORT ALLEN LA 1.3E+05 5.4E+04 3.0E+03 O.OE+00 1.3E+05 6.6E+04 3.0E+03 O.OE+00
SANTA FE SPRINGCA 1.3E+05 8.9E+04 2.6E+03 O.OE+00 1.3E+05 1.06+05 2.6E+03 O.OE+00
ABILENE TX 1.2E+05 2.4E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 1.2E+05 3.4E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
SMETHPORT PA 1.8E+04 3.6E+03_6.4E+02 .(LQEtOQ 1.8E+04 5.2E+03 6.4E+02 O.OE+00
NEWELL WV 2.9E+04 5.8E+03 1.0E+03 O.OE+00 2.9E+04 8.4E+03 1.0E+03 O.OE+00
INDIANAPOLIS IN 1.2E+05 5.3E+04 3.0E+03 O.OE+00 1.2E+05 6. €+04 3.0E+03 O.OE+00
BAKERSFIELD CA 5.0E+04 1.1E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 5.0E+04 1.9E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
MARTINEZ CA 3.3E+05 1.8E+05 8.5E+03 O.OE+00 3.9E+05 2.2E+05 8.5E+03 O.OE+00
DEER PARK TX B.OE+05 2.3E+05 1.9E+04 5.5E+04 6.0E+05 2.8E+05 1.9E+04 5.5E+04
NORCO LA 6.0E+05 2.1E+05 1.7E+04 O.OE+00 6.0E+05 2.7E+05 1.7E+04 O.OE+00
ANACORTES HA 2.3E+05 1.1E+05 7.6E+03 O.OE+00 2.3E+05 1.3E+05 7.6E+03 O.OE+00
HOOD RIVER IL 7.6E+05 3.0E+05 3.0E+04 1.1E+04 7.6E+05 3.7E+05 3.0E+04 1.1E+04
ODESSA TX 7.SE+04 3.3E+04 3.3E+03 1.1E+03 8.0E+04 4.0E+04 3.3E+03 1.1E+03
WILMINGTON CA 4.0E+05 3.7E+05 7.3E+03 O.OE+00 4.0E+05 4.1E+05 7.3E+03 O.OE+00
SINCLAIR NY 1.5E+05 6.2E+04 4.4E+03 O.OE+00 1.5E+05 7.5E+04 4.4E+03 O.OE+00
TULSA OK 1.4E+05 5.5E+04 3.7E+03 O.OE+00 1.4E+05 6.8E+04 3.7E+03 O.OE+00
FERNDALE HA 2.1E+05 8.1E+04 3.6E+03 O.OE+00 2.1E+05 1.0E+05 3.6E+03 O.OE+00
SOMERSET KY 1.5E+04 3.0E+03 3.0E+02 O.OE+00 1.5E+04 4.4E+03 3.0E+02 O.OE+00
TACOMA HA 3.3E+04 6.6E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 3.3E+04 9.6E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
LUM3ERTON MS 1.6E+04 3.2E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 1.EE+04 4.7E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
SANDERSVILLE MS 3.0E+04 6.1E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 3.1E+04 8.8E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
CORPUS CHRIST! TX 2.SE+05 1.3E+05 9.1E+03 1.8E+04 2.9E+05 1.6E+05 9.1E+03 1.8E+04
TOLEDO OH 3.3E+05 2.1E+05 1.3E+04 O.OE+00 3.4E+05 2.4E+05 1.3E+04 O.OE+00
LIMA OH 4.7E+05 2.2E+05 1.6E+04 8.6E+04 4.8E+OS 2.6E+05 1.6E+04 8.6E+04
PORT ARTHUR TX 6.9E+05 3.1E+05 1.2E+04 O.OE+00 7.0E+05 3.7E+05 1.2E+04 O.OE+00
DELAWARE CITY DE 3.9E+OS 1.8E+05 1.7E+04 9.4E+03 3.9E+05 2.1E+05 1.7E+04 9.4E+03
CONVENT LA 6.2E+05 2.SE+05 1.2E+04 O.OE+00 6.3E+05 3.1E+05 1.2E+04 O.OE+00
TULSA OK 2.4E+05 9.3E+04 7.3E+03 9.4E+03 2.4E+05 1.1E+05 7.3E+03 9.4E+03
MARCUS HOOK PA 4.6E+05 2.2E+05 1.2E+04 1.9E+04 4.6E+05 2.6E+05 1.2E+04 1.9E+04
TOLEDO OH 3.SE+05 1.6E+05 1.4E+04 3.2E+04 3.5E+05 1.9E+05 1.4E+04 3.2E+04
BAKERSFiaD CA 4.2E+04 8.4E+03 4.6E+02 O.OE+00 4.2E+04 1.2E+04 4.6E+02 O.OE+00
KENAI AK 2.0E+05 4.0E+04 3.7E+03 O.OE+00 2.0E+05 5.8E+04 3.7E+03 O.OE+00
WILMINGTON CA 2.1E+05 2.9E+05 1.2E+04 O.OE+00 2.1E+05 3.1E+05 1.2E+04 O.OE+00
ANACORTES WA 2.7E+05 1.9E+05 6.4E+03 O.OE+00 2.7E+05 2.2E+05 6.4E+03 O.OE+00
ELDORADO KS 2.2E+05 1.SE+05 7.6E+03 8.3E+03 2.2E+05 1.7E+05 7.6E+03 8.3E+03
BAKERSFIELD CA 1.3E+05 7.7E+04 7.0E+03 O.OE+00 1.3E+05 8.8E+04 7.0E+03 O.OE+00
MARTINEZ CA 3.SE+05 1.5E+OS 1.3E+04 O.OE+00 3.5E+05 1.8E+05 1.3E+04 O.OE+00
ARKANSAS CITY KS 1.5E+05 5.9E+04 4.9E+03 O.OE+00 1.5E+05 7.2E+04 4.9E+03 O.OE+00
ALMA Ml 1.2E+05 5.1E+04 4.3E+03 O.OE+00 1.2E+05 6.2E+04 4.3E+03 O.OE+00
ARDMORE OK 1.7E+05 6.8E+04 3.7E+03 O.OE+00 1.7E+05 8.3E+04 3.7E+03 O.OE+00
CORPUS CHRIST 1 TX 7.9E+04 1.6E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 7.9E+04 2.3E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
RODEO CA 3.1E+05 2.8E+05 1.0E+04 O.OE+00 3.1E+05 3.1E+05 1.0E+04 O.OE+00
LEMONT IL 4.1E+05 2.9E+05 9.1E+03 9.7E+03 4.1E+05 3.3E+05 9.1E+03 9.7E+03
WILMINGTON CA 1.9E+05 2.0E+05 4.4E+03 O.OE+00 1.9E+05 2.2E+05 4.4E+03 O.OE+00
NEDERLAND TX 3.3E+05 1.3E+05 9.7E+03 1.7E+04 3.3E+05 1.6E+05 9.7E+03 1.7E+04
WARREN PA 1.8E+05 6.6E+04 4.9E+03 O.OE+00 1.8E+05 8.2E+04 4.9E+03 O.OE+00
LOS ANGELES CA 3.0E+05 1.3E+05 1.6E+04 O.OE+00 3.0E+05 1.7E+05 1.6E+04 O.OE+00
TACOMA WA 9.1E+04 1.8E+04 1.8E+03 O.OE+00 9.1E+04 2.6E+04 1.8E+03 O.OE+00
CORPUS OR 1ST 1 TX 5.5E+04 9.3E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 5.6E+04 9.8E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
OILDALE CA 3.0E+04 6.0E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 3.0E+04 8.7E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
BRADFORD PA 2.4E+04 4.7E+03 1.0E+03 O.OE+00 2.4E+04 6.8E+03 1.0E+03 O.OE+00
NEWCASTLE WY 3.5E+04 1.3E+04 8.5E+02 O.OE+00 3.5E+04 1.6E+04 8.5E+02 O.OE+00
OOUGLASVILLE GA 2.4E+04 4.9E+03 O.OE+00 .O.OE+00 2.5E+04 7.1E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
• WASTE NUMBERS ARE KEYED TO THE WASTES LISTED IN TABLES 2-1 AND 2-2
AND ARE GROUPED BY SIMILIAR CONCENTRATION RANGES.
1 CRUDE STORAGE 8 COKING
2 DESALTING 9 NAPHTHA SWEETENING
3 ATMOSPHERIC DISTILLATION 10 LIGHT PRODUCT STORAGE (WATER)
4 GAS PROCESSING 11 LIGHT PRODUCT STORAGE (SLUDGE)
5 CATALYTIC REFORMING 12 SLOP OIL TANKS
6 CATA"YT:r CRACKING 13 BENZENE PRODUCTION
7 VISBUEwCING
A-6
-------
TABLE A-3. ESTIMATES FOR RCRA SLUDGES
HASTE QUANTITIES (Mg/yr)
EMISSIONS (Mg/yr)
PLANT
CITY
ST K048 K049 K050 K051
K052
MINIMUM MAXIMUM
BELCHER REF.
HUNT REFINING
LOUISIANA LAM) & EXP
ARCO ALASKA
ARCO ALASKA
CHEVRON
MAPCO PETROLEUM
PETRO STAR
TESARO ALASKA PETROL
INTERMOUNTAIN REF.
BERRY PETrOLEUM
CROSS OIL i REFINING
LION OIL
ANCHOR REF.
ATLANTIC RICHFIELD
CHEMOIL
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CONOCO
EDGINGTD !L COMPAN
EXXON
FLETCHER -IL & REFIN
WITCO CORP.
GOLDEN NEST REFINING
HUNTWAY REF.
HUNTWAY REF.
KERN OIL & REFINING
LUKDAY-THAGARO CO.
MOBIL OIL
NEWHALL REFINING CO.
OXNARO REF.
PACIFIC REF.
PARAMOUNT PET.
POWER INE OIL
SAN JOAQUIN REF.
SHELL OIL
SHELL OIL
SUNLAND REF.
TEXACO REFINING
TEXACO REFINING
TOSCO CORP.
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
UNOCAL
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
COLORADO REF.
CONOCO
STAR REF.
AKOCO
YOUNG REF.
CHEVRON
HAWAII INDEP. REF.
CLARK OIL & REFINING
CLARK OIL iREF.
MARATHON PETROLEUM
MOBIL OIL
SHELL OIL
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
AMOCO CHEMICAL
INDIANA FARM BUREAU
LAKETON REFINING
ROCK ISLAND REFINING
DERBY REF.
DERBY REFINING COMPA
MOBILE BAY
TUSCALOOSA
SARALAND
KUPARUK
PRUDHOE BAY
KENAI
NORTH POLE
NORTH POLE
KENAI
FREDONIA
STEVENS
SMACKOVER
ELDORADO
MCKITTRICK
CARSON
SIGNAL HILL
EL SEGUNDO
RICHMOND
SANTA MARIA
LONG BEACH
BENICIA
WILMINGTON
OILDALE
AL
AL
AL
AK
AK
AK
AK
AK
AK
AZ
AK
AR
AR
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
SANTA FE SPRINGCA
BENECIA
WILMINGTON
BAKERSFIELO
SOUTH GATE
TORRANCE
NEWHALL
OXNARO
HERCULES
PARAMOUNT
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
SANTA FE SPRINGCA
BAKERSFIELO
MARTINEZ
WILMINGTON
BAKERSFIELO
BAKERSFIELD
WILMINGTON
MARTINEZ
WILMINGTON
LOS ANGELES
RODEO
COMMERCE CITY
COMMERCE CITY
DELAWARE CITY
SAVANNAH
DOUGLASVILLE
HONOLULU
ENA BEACH
BLUE ISLAND
HARTFORD
ROBINSON
JOLIET
WOOD RIVER
LEMONT
WHITING
MT. VERNON
LAKETON
INDIANAPOLIS
EL DORADO
WICHITA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CO
CO
DE
GA
GA
HI
HI
IL
IL
IL
IL
IL
IL
IN
IN
IN
IN
KS
KS
1.0E+02
3.2E+02
5.8E+C2
8.6E+01
l.OE+02
1.6E+02
6.5E+02
5.0E+01
5.2E+02
4.1E+01
2.7E+01
4.9E+01
3.5E+02
7.2E+01
1.5E+03
l.OE+02
2.4E+03
1.9E+03
6.8E+01
3.0E+02
9.2E+02
1.9E+02
7.8E+01
2.9E+02
6.0E+Q1
4.0E+01
1.4E+02
5.5E+01
8.9E+02
1.4E+02
3.1E+01
3.8E+02
3.1E+02
3.4E+02
1.3E+02
1.0E+03
1.0E+03
1.1E+02
3.4E+02
5.4E+02
9.1E+02
4.9E+02
7.8E402
8.1E+02
2.0E+02
3.2E+02
1.0E+03
2.0E+02
6.3E+01
3.5E+02
5.9E+02
4.7E+02
4.3E+02
1.4E+03
1.3E+03
2.0E+03
1.1E+03
2.5E+03
1.5E+02
6.0E+01
3.2E+02
2.1E+02
2.2E+02
8.2E+01
2.5E+02
4.6E+02
6.8E+01
8.0E+01
1.3E+02
5.1E+02
4.0E+Q1
4.1E+02
3.2E+01
2.2E+01
3.9E401
2.7E+02
5.7E+01
1.2E+03
8.2E+01
1.9E+03
1.5E+03
5.4E+01
2.4E+02
7.3E+02
1.5E+02
6.2E+01
2.3E+02
4.8E+01
3.1E+01
1.1E+02
4.4E+01
7.0E+02
1.1E+02
2.5E+01
3.0E+02
2.4E+02
2.7E+02
1.0E+02
8.0E+02
8.2E+02
8.5E+01
2.7E+02
4.3E+02
7.2E+02
3.9E+02
6.2E-V02
6.4E+02
1.6E+02
2.5E+02
8.0E+02
1.6E+02
5.0E+01
2.7E+02
4.6E+02
3.7E+02
3.4E+02
1.1E+03
1.0E+03
1.6E+03
8.4E+02
2.0E+03
1.2E+02
4.7E+01
2.5E+02
1.6E+02
1.7E+02
1.2E+00
3.7E+00
6.6EtOO
1.0E+00
1.2E+00
1.8E+00
7.5E+00
5.8E-01
6.0E+00
4.7E-01
3.2E-01
5.6E-01
4.0E+00
8.3E-01
1.8E+01
1.2E+00
2.7E+01
2.2E+01
7.9E-01
3.5E+00
1.1E+01
2.2E-fOO
9.0E-01
3.4E+00
7.0E-01
4.6E-01
1.7E+00
6.4E-01
1.0E+01
1.6E+00
3.6E-01
4.3E+00
3.5E+00
3.9E+00
1.5E+00
1.2E+01
1.2E+01
1.2E+00
3.9E+00
6.2E+00
1.0E+01
5.6E+00
9.0E+00
9.4E+00
2.3E+00
S.TEtOO
1.2E+01
2.3E+00
7.3E-01
4.0E+00
6.8EtOO
5.4E+00
5.0E+00
1.6E+01
1.5E+01
2.3E+01
1.2E+01
2.9E+01
1.7E+00
6.3E-01
3.7E+00
2.4E+00
2.5E+00
3.6Et01
1.1E+02
2.0E+02
3.0E+01
3.5E+01
5.5E+01
2.3E+02
1.8E+02
1.4E+01
9.5E+00
1.7E+01
1.2E+02
2.5E+01
5.4E+02
3.6E+01
8.3E+02
6.8E+02
2.4E+01
l.OE+02
3.2E+02
6.6E+01
2.7E+01
l.OE+02
2.1E+01
1.4E+01
5.0E+01
1.9E+01
3.1E+02
4.7E+01
1.1E+01
1.3E+02
1.1E+02
1.2E+02
4.5E+01
3.SE+02
3.6E+02
3.8E+01
1.2E+02
1.9E+02
3.2E+02
1.7E+02
2.7E+02
2.8E+02
7.0E+01
1.1E+02
3.5E+02
7.0E+01
2.2E+01
1.2E+02
2.0E+02
1.6E+02
1.5E+02
4.5E+02
6.9E+02
3.7E+02
8.8E+02
5.2E+01
2.1E+01
1.1E+02
7.1E+01
7.5E+01
1.2E+00
3.6E+00
6.5E+00
9.7E-01
1.1E+00
1.8E+00
7.3E+00
5.7E-01
5.8E+00
4.6E-01
3.1E-01
5.5E-01
3.9E+00
8.1E-01
1.7E+01
1.2E+00
2.7E+01
2.2E+01
7.7E-01
3.4E+00
1.0E+01
2.1E+00
8.7E-01
3.3E+00
6.8E-01
4.5E-01
1.6E+00
6.2E-01
1.0E+01
1.5E+00
3.5E-01
4.2E+00
3.5E+00
3.8E+00
1.5E+00
1.1E+01
1.2E+01
1.2E+00
3.8E+00
6.1E+00
1.0E+01
5.5E+00
8.7E+00
9.2E+00
2.3E+00
3.6E+00
1.1E+01
2.3E+00
7.1E-01
3.9E+00
6.6E+00
5.2E+00
4.9E+00
1.6E+01
1.5E+01
2.2E+01
1.2E+01
2.8E+01
1.7E+00
6.7E-01
3.6E+00
2.3E+00
2.4E+00
2.4E-04
7.3E-04
1.3E-03
2.0E-04
2.3E-04
3.6E-04
1.5E-03
1.2E-04
1.2E-03
9.4E-05
6.3E-05
1.1E-04
7.9E-04
1.6E-04
3.5E-03
2.4E-04
5.4E-03
4.5E-03
1.6E-04
6.9E-04
2.1E-03
4.4E-04
1.BE-04
6.7E-04
1.4E-04
9.1E-05
3.3E-04
1.3E-04
2.0E-03
3.1E-04
7.1E-05
8.6E-04
7.0E-04
7.7E-04
3.0E-04
2.3E-03
2.4E-03
2.5E-04
7.7E-04
1.2E-03
2.1E-03
1.1E-03
1.8E-03
1.9E-03
4.6E-04
7.3E-04
2.3E-03
4.6E-04
1.5E-04
7.9E-04
1.3E-03
1.1E-03
9.9E-04
3.2E-03
3.0E-03
4.5E-03
2.4E-03
5.8E-03
3.4E-04
1.4E-04
7.3E-04
4.7E-04
4.9E-04
2.3E-02
7.0E-02
1.3E-01
1.9E-02
2.2E-02
3.5E-02
1.4E-01
1.1E-02
1.1E-01
9.0E-03
6.0E-03
1.1E-02
7.6E-02
1.6E-02
3.4E-01
2.3E-02
5.2E-01
4.3E-01
1.5E-02
6.6E-02
2.0E-01
4.2E-02
1.7E-02
6.4E-02
1.3E-02
8.7E-03
3.2E-02
1.2E-02
1.9E-01
3.0E-02
6.8E-03
8.3E-02
6.7E-02
7.4E-02
2.8E-02
2.2E-01
2.3E-01
2.4E-02
7.4E-02
1.2E-01
2.0E-01
1.1E-01
1.7E-01
1.8E-01
4.4E-02
7.0E-02
2.2E-01
4.4E-02
1.4E-02
7.6E-02
1.3E-01
1.0E-01
9.5E-02
3.1E-01
2.8E-01
4.3E-01
2.3E-01
5.5E-01
3.3E-02
1.3E-02
7.0E-02
4.5E-02
4.7E-02
A-7
-------
TABLE A-3. ESTIMATES FOR RCRA SLUDGES
WASTE QUANTITIES
PLAMT
FARMLAND INDUSTRIES
FARMLAND FACILITIES
NATIONAL COOPERATIVE
TEXACO REFINING
TOTAL PETROLEUM
ASHLAND PETROLEUM CO
SOMERSET REFINERY
PENNZOIL
CALCASIEU REFINING
CALUMET REFINING COM
CANAL REF.
CITGO PETROLEUM
CONOCO CHEMICALS
EXXON CORP
HILL PETROLEUM
KERR-MCGEE REF.
KERR-MCGEE REFINING
MARATHON PETROLEUM
MOBIL
MURPHY OIL CORPORATI
PLACID REFINING
SHELL CHEM CO
BPOIL
STAR REF.
CRYSTAL REF.
LAKESIDE REF.
MARATHON PET.
TOTAL PETROLEUM
KOCH REFINING
AMERADA HESS
CHEVRON
ERGON REF.
SOUTHLAND OIL
SOUTHLAND OIL
CENEX REF.
CONOCO REFINERY
EXXON
MONTANA REFINING COM
NEVADA REF.
AMERADA-HESS
CHEVRON
COASTAL EAGLE PT.
EXXON
MANTUA OIL
MOBIL OIL
BLOOMFIELD REFINING
GIANT REFINERY
NAVAJO REFINING
CIBRO PETROLEUM
AMOCO
ASHLAND OIL
STANDARD OIL OF OHIO
STANDARD OIL OF OHIO
SUN CO.
BARRETT REF.
CONOCO
KERR MCGEE
SINCLAIR OIL
SUN REFINING
TOTAL PETROLEUM
CHEVRON
ATLANTIC REFINING
CITY
COFFEYVILLE
PHILLIPSBURG
MCPHERSON
ELDORADO
ARKANSAS CITY
ASHLAND
SOMERSET
SHREVEPORT
LAKE CHARLES
PRINCETON
CHURCH POINT
LAKE CHARLES
WESTLAKE
BATON ROUGE
KROTZ SPRINGS
COTTON VALLEY
COTTON VALLEY
GARYVILLE
CHALMETTE
MERAUX
PORT ALLEN
NORCO
BELLE CHASSE
CONVENT
CARSON CITY
KALAMAZOO
DETROIT
ALMA
ROSEMOUNT
PURVIS
PASCAGOULA
VICKSBURG
LUMBERTON
SANDERSVILLE
LAUREL
BILLINGS
BILLINGS
GREAT FALLS
TONOPAH
PORT READING
PERTH AMBOY
WESTVILLE
LINDEN
THOROFARE
PAULSBORO
BLOOMFIELD
GALLUP
ARTESIA
ALBANY
MANDAN
CANTON
LIMA
TOLEDO
TOLEDO
THOMAS
PONCACITY
NYNNEWOOO
TULSA
TULSA
ARDMORE
PORTLAND
PHILADELPHIA
ST
KS
KS
KS
KS
KS
KY
KY
LA
LA
LA
LA
LA
LA
LA
LA
LA
LA
LA
LA
LA
LA
LA
LA
LA
Ml
Ml
Ml
Ml
UN
MS
MS
MS
MS
MS
MT
MT
MT
MT
NV
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
m
NM
NM
NY
to
OH
OH
OH
OH
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OK
OR
PA
(Mfl/yr)
EMISSIONS
(Mfl^r)
K048 K049 K050 K051 K052 MINIMUM MAXIMUM
4.1E+02
1.9E+02
5.1E+02
5.6E+02
3.9E+02
1.5E+03
4.0E+01
3.3E+02
8.6E+01
3.0E+01
7.1E+01
2.3E+03
1.1E+03
3.3E+03
4.0E+02
2.4E+02
5.6E+01
1.8E+03
1.0E+03
6.7E+02
3.4E+02
1.5E+03
1.4E+03
1.6E+03
2.9E+01
4.0E+01
4.9E+02
3.0E+02
1.6E+03
2.2E+02
2.1E+03
1.2E+02
4.2E+01
7.9E+01
2.9E+02
3.5E+02
3.0E+02
4.5E+01
3.2E+01
O.OE+00
5.8E+02
7.9E+02
9.4E+02
3.2E+02
7.2E+Q2
1.2E+02
1.3E+02
2.7E+02
3.1E+02
4.2E+02
4.8E+02
1.2E+03
8.7E+02
9.0E+02
9.4E+01
9.8E+02
3.1E+02
3.6E+02
6.1E+02
4.4E+02
1.1E+02
9.0E+02
3.2E+02
1.5E+02
4.0E+02
4.5E+02
3.1E+02
1.2E+03
3.1E+01
2.6E+02
6.8E+01
2.3E+01
5.6E+01
1.8E+03
8.9E+02
2.6E+03
3.2E+02
1.9E+02
4.4E+01
1.5E+03
8.3E+02
5.3E+02
2.7E+02
1.2E+03
1.1E+03
1.3E+03
2.3E+01
3.2E+01
3.9E+02
2.4E+02
1.2E+03
1.7E+02
1.7E+03
9.6E+01
3.3E401
6.3E+01
2.3E+02
2.8E+02
2.4E+02
3.6E+01
2.6E+01
O.OE+00
4.6E+02
6.2E+02
7.4E+02
2.6E+02
5.7E+02
9.6E+01
1.0E+02
2.2E+02
2.4E+02
3.3Et02
3.8E+02
9.7E+02
6.9E+02
7.1E+02
7.4E+01
7.8E+02
2.5E+02
2.8E+02
4.8E+02
3.4E+02
8.5E+01
7.1E+02
4.7E+00
2.2EtOO
5.9£tOO
6.5EtOO
4.4E+00
1.8E+01
4.6E-01
3.8E+00
1.0E+00
3.4E-01
8.2E-01
2.7E+01
1.3E+01
3.8E+01
4.6E+00
2.7E+00
6.5E-01
2.1E+01
1.2E+01
7.7E+00
3.9E+00
1.8E+01
1.6E+01
1.9E+01
3.3E-Q1
4.6E-01
5.7E+00
3.5E+00
1.8E+01
2.5E+00
2.4E+01
1.4E+00
4.8E-01
9.1E-01
3.4E+00
4.0E+00
3.SE+00
5.2E-01
3.7E-01
O.OE+00
6.6E+00
9.1E+00
1.1E+01
3.7E+00
8.3E+00
1.4E+00
1.5E+00
3.2E+00
3.6E+00
4.8E+00
5.5E+00
1.4E+01
l.OE+01
1.0E+01
1.1E+00
1.1E+01
3.6E+00
4.2E+00
7.1E400
5.0E+00
1.2E+00
1.0E+01
1.4E+02
6.6E+01
1.8E+02
2.0E+02
1.3E+02
5.3E+02
1.4E+01
1.2E+02
3.0E+01
1.0E+01
2.5E+01
8.0E+02
3.9E+02
1.1E+03
1.4E+02
8.3E+01
2.0E+01
6.4E+02
3.6E+02
2.3E+02
1.2Et02
5.4E+02
4.9E+02
5.6E+02
1.0E+01
1.4E+01
1.7E+02
1.1E+02
5.5E+02
7.5E+01
7.4E+02
4.2E+01
1.5E+01
2.8E+01
1.0E+02
1.2E+02
1.1E+02
1.6E+01
1.1E+01
O.OE+00
2.0E+02
2.7E+02
3.2E+02
1.1E+02
2.5E+02
4.2E+01
4.5E+01
9.5E+01
1.1E+02
1.5E+02
1.6E+02
4.3E+02
3.0E+02
3.1E+02
3.2E+01
3.4E+02
1.1E+02
1.3E+02
2.1E+02
1.5E+02
3.8E+01
3.1E+02
4.6E+00
2.1E+00
5.7E+00
6.3E+00
4.3E+00
1.7E+01
4.SE-01
3.7E+00
9.7E-01
3.3E-01
8.0E-01
2.6E+01
1.3E+01
3.7E+01
4.5E+00
2.7E+00
6.3E-01
2.1E+01
1.2E+01
7.5E+00
3.8E+00
1.7E+01
1.6E+01
1.8E+01
3.2E-01
4.5E-01
5.5E+00
3.4E+00
1.8E+01
2.4E+00
2.4E+01
1.4E+00
4.7E-01
8.9E-01
3.3E+00
3.9E+00
3.4E+00
5.1E-OI
3.6E-01
O.OE+00
6.5E+00
8.9E+00
1.1E+01
3.6E+00
8.1E+00
1.4E+00
1.5E+00
3.1E+00
3.5E+00
4.7E+00
5.3E+00
1.4E+01
9.8E+00
1.0E+01
1.1E+00
1.1E+01
3.5E+00
4.0E+00
6.9E+00
4.9E+00
1.2E+00
l.OE+01
9.3E-04
4.4E-04
1.2E-03
1.3E-03
8.8E-04
3.5E-03
9.1E-05
7.6E-04
2.0E-04
6.8E-05
1.6E-04
5.3E-C3
2.6E-03
7.5E-03
9.1E-04
5.4E-04
1.3E-04
4.2E-03
2.4E-03
1.5E-03
7.8E-04
3.5E-03
3.2E-03
3.7E-03
6.6E-05
9.2E-05
1.1E-03
6.9E-04
3.6E-03
4.9E-04
4.9E-03
2.8E-04
9.6E-OS
1.8E-04
6.7E-04
8.0E-04
6.9E-04
1.0E-04
7.4E-05
O.OE+00
1.3E-03
1.8E-03
2.1E-03
7.4E-04
1.6E-03
2.8E-04
3.0E-04
6.3E-04
7.1E-04
9.6E-04
1.1E-03
2.8E-03
2.0E-03
2.1E-03
2.1E-04
2.2E-03
7.1E-04
8.2E-04
1 .4E-03
1.0E-03
2.5E-04
2.1E-03
8.9E-02
4.2E-02
1.1E-01
1.2E-01
8.5E-02
3.4E-01
8.7E-03
7.3E-02
T.9E-02
6.5E-03
1.6E-02
5.1E-01
2.5E-01
7.2E-01
8.7E-02
5.2E-02
1.2E-02
4.0E-01
2.3E-01
1.5E-01
7.5E-02
3.4E-01
3.1E-01
3.6E-01
6.3E-03
8.8E-03
1.1E-01
6.6E-02
3.5E-01
4.7E-02
4.7E-01
2.7E-02
9.2E-03
1.7E-02
6.4E-02
7.7E-02
6.6E-02
1.0E-02
7.1E-03
O.OE+00
1.3E-01
1.7E-01
2.1E-01
7.1E-02
1.6E-01
2.7E-02
2.8E-02
6.0E-02
6.8E-02
9.2E-02
1.0E-01
2.7E-01
1.9E-01
2.0E-01
2.1E-02
2.1E-01
6.8E-02
7.9E-02
1.3E-01
9.6E-02
2.4E-02
2.0E-01
-------
TABLE A-3. ESTIMATES FOR RCRA SLUDGES
HASTE QUANTITIES (Mg/yr)
EMISSIONS (Mg/yr)
PLANT
CITY
ST K048 K049 K050 KQ51
K052
MINIMUM MAXIMUM
CHEVRON
W^n CHEMICAL CORP.
F OIL COMPANY
C H STATE OIL REF
6. ,iL
SUN PETROLEUM
UNITED REF.
MAPCO PETROLEUM
AMOCO
CHAMPLIN PETROLEUM C
CHEVRON
CHE 40N
COASTAL REFINING
CROWN CENTRAL
DIAMOND SHAMROCK
DIAMOND SHAMROCK REF
EL PASO REFINING
EXXON CORP
FINAOIL
FINA OIL & CHEMICAL
Hl»_ PETROLEUM
H: i. PETROLEUM
Hf lELL HYDROCARBONS
KOCH INDUSTRIES
LA GLORIA OIL AND GA
LIQUID ENERGY CORP.
LYONDELL PETROCHEMIC
MARATHON OIL
MOBIL OIL
PHILLIPS 66 REFINERY
PHILLIPS
PRIDE REFINING
SHELL OIL
SHELL OIL REFINERY
SOUTHWESTERN REFIN IN
STAR REF.
TRIFINERY
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
VALERO ENERGY CORP.
AMOCO OIL REFINERY
BIG WEST OIL
CHEVRON
C-YSEN REFINING
PENNZOIL
PHILLIPS 66
AMOCO OIL REFINERY
ARCO PETROLEUM
CHEVRON
SHELL OIL
SOHIO
SOUND REF.
TEXACO USA
U.S. OIL & REFINING
MIDATLANTIC REF.
QUAKER STATE OIL REF
MURPHY OIL CORPORATI
AK'CO
FRONTIER OIL
LITTLE AMERICA REF.
SINCLAIR OIL
WYOMING REF.
ASHLAND PETROLEUM
PHILADELPHIA PA
BRADFORD PA
ROUSEV1LLE PA
SMETHPORT PA
MARCUS HOOK PA
MARCUS HOOK PA
WARREN PA
MEMPHIS TN
TEXAS CITY TX
CORPUS CHRISTI TX
EL PASO TX
PORT ARTHUR TX
CORPUS CHRISTI TX
HOUSTON TX
SUNRAY TX
THREE RIVERS TX
EL PASO TX
BAYTOWN TX
BIG SPRING TX
PORT ARTHUR TX
HOUSTON TX
TEXAS CITY TX
SAN ANTONIO TX
CORPUS CHRISTI TX
TYLER TX
BRIDGEPORT TX
HOUSTON TX
TEXAS CITY TX
BEAUMONT TX
BORGER TX
SWEENY TX
ABILENE TX
DEER PARK TX
ODESSA TX
CORPUS CHRISTI TX
PORT ARTHUR TX
CORPUS CHRISTI TX
NEDERLAND TX
CORPUS CHRISTI TX
SALT LAKE CITY UT
SALT LAKE CITY UT
SALT LAKE CITY UT
1.3E+03
6.1E+01
1.1E+02
4.7E+01
1.2E+03
1.2E+03
4.7E+02
4.1E402
3.0E+03
1.1E+03
4.8E+02
2.4E+03
6.5E+02
7.2E+02
7.6E+02
3.6E+02
1.5E+02
3.5E+03
4.OE+02
7.2E+02
4.9E+02
8.6E+02
2.0E+01
9.OE+02
WOODS CROSS
ROOSEVELT
WOODS CROSS
YORKTOWN
FERNDALE
SEATTLE
ANACORTES
FERNDALE
TACOMA
ANACORTES
T*. :MA
S MARYS
NEltfLL
SUPERIOR
CASPER
CHEYENNE
CASPER
SINCLAIR
NEWCASTLE
ST. PAUL PARK
UT
UT
UT
VA
WA
WA
WA
WA
WA
WA
WA
WV
WV
Wl
WY
WY
WY
WY
WY
MN
OE+02
2E+01
9E+03
5.OE+02
2.0E+03
7.6E+02
1.3E+03
1E+02
6E+03
1E+02
5E+02
8E+03
,1E+02
8.6E+02
1.4E+02
2.9E+02
1.7E+02
3.2E+02
9.0E+01
5.8E+01
1.8E+02
3.7E+02
1.2E+03
3.6E+01
6.OE+02
5.5E+02
8.6E+01
.OE+02
.4E+02
.6E+01
.6E+01
.3E+02
.9E+02
.5E+02
1.6E+02
3.9E+02
9.0E+01
4.8E+02
9.9E+02
4.8E+01
8.9E+01
3.7E+01
9.7E+02
9.4E+02
3.7E+02
3.2E+02
2.4E+03
8.5E+02
3.8E+02
1.9E+03
5.1E+02
5.7E+02
6.0E+02
2.8E+02
1.2E+02
2.8E+03
3.1E+02
5.7E+02
3.8E+02
6.8E+02
1.6E+01
7.1E+02
3.1E+02
5.7E+01
1.5E-I4D3
4.OE+02
1.6E+03
6.OE+02
l.OE+03
2.4E+02
1.2E+03
1.6E+02
5.9E+02
1.4E+03
1.6E+02
6.8E+02
.1E+02
.3E+02
.4E+02
.6E+02
.1E+01
4.6E+01
1.4E+02
2.9E+02
9.2E+02
2.8E+01
4.8E+02
4.4E+02
6.8E+01
5.5E+02
1.9E+02
2.8E+01
6.0E+01
1.8E+02
2.3E+02
2.OE+02
1.3E+02
3.1E+02
7.1E+01
3.8E+02
1.4E+01
7.1E-01
1.3E+00
5.4E-01
1.4E+01
1.4E+01
5.4E+00
4.7E+00
3.5E+01
1.2E+01
5.5E+00
2.7E+01
7.5E+00
8.3E+00
8.7E+00
4.2E+00
1.7E+00
4.1E+01
4.6E+00
8.3E+00
5.6E+00
9.9E+00
2.3E-01
l.OE+01
4.6E+00
8.3E-01
2.2E+01
5.8E+00
2.3E+01
8.7E+00
1.5E+01
3.6E+00
1.8E+01
2.4E+00
8.6E+00
2.1E+01
2.4E+00
1.0E+01
1.7E+00
3.3E+00
2.0E+00
3.7E+00
1.0E+00
6.6E-01
_ 1E+00
4.2E+00
1.3E+01
4.2E-01
7.0E+00
6.4E+00
9.9E-01
8.1E+00
2.7E+00
4.2E-01
8.7E-01
7E+00
3E+00
9E+00
8E+00
..5E+00
1.0E+00
5.6E+00
4.4E+02
2.1E+01
3.9E+01
1.6E+01
4.3E+02
4.1E+02
1.6E+02
1.4E+02
1.1E+03
3.8E+02
1.6E+02
8.2E+02
2.3E+02
2.5E+02
2.6E+02
1.3E+02
5.2E+01
1.2E+C3
1.4E+02
2.5E+02
1.7E+02
3.OE+02
7.0E+00
3.1E+02
1.4E+02
2.5E+01
6.6E+02
1.7E+02
6.9E+02
2.6E+02
4.4E+02
1.1E+02
5.4E+02
7.2E+01
2.6E+02
6.2E+02
7.1E+01
3. OE+02
5.0E+01
1.OE+02
6.0E+01
1.1E+02
3.1E+01
2.0E+01
6.2E+01
1.3E+02
4.0E+02
1.3E+01
2.1E+02
1.9E+02
3.0E+01
2.4E+02
8.2E+01
1.3E+01
2.6E+01
8.0E+01
1. OE+02
8.8E+01
5.5E+01
1.4E+02
3.1E+01
1.7E+02
1.4E+01
6.9E-01
1.3E+00
5.3E-01
1.4E+01
1.3E+01
5.2E+00
4.6E+00
3.4E+01
1.2E+01
5.3E+00
2.7E+01
7.3E+00
8.1E+00
8.SE+00
4.0E+00
1.7E+00
4.0E+01
4.5E+00
8.1E+00
5.5E+00
9.7E+00
2.3E-01
l.OE+01
4.5E+00
8.1E-01
2.1E+01
5.6E+00
2.2E+01
8.5E+00
1.4E+01
3.5E+00
1.7E+01
2.3E+00
8.4E+00
2.0E+01
2.3E+00
9.7E+00
1.6E+00
3.2E+00
1.9E+00
3.6E+00
1.0E+00
6.SE-01
2.0E+00
4.1E+00
1.3E+01
4.1E-01
6.8E+00
6.2E+00
9.6E-01
7.9E+00
2.7E+00
4.1E-01
8.5E-01
2.6E+00
3.2E+00
2.8E+00
1.8E+00
4.4E+00
1.0E+00
5.4E+00
2.9E-03
1.4E-04
2.6E-04
1.1E-04
2.8E-03
2.7E-03
1.1E-03
9.4E-04
6.9E-03
2.5E-03
1.1E-03
5.4E-03
1.5E-03
1.6E-03
1.7E-03
8.2E-04
3.5E-04
8.1E-03
9.1E-04
1.6E-03
1.1E-03
2.0E-03
4.6E-05
2.1E-03
9.1E-04
1.6E-04
4.4E-03
1.IE-OS
4.5E-03
1.7E-C3
2.9E-03
7.1E-04
3.6E-03
4.7E-04
1.7E-03
4.1E-03
4.7E-04
2.0E-03
3.3E-04
6.6E-04
4.0E-04
7.4E-04
2.1E-04
1.3E-04
4.1E-04
8.4E-04
2.7E-03
8.2E-05
1.4E-03
1.3E-03
2.0E-04
1.6E-03
5.4E-04
8.2E-05
1.7E-04
5.3E-04
6.6E-04
5.8E-04
3.6E-04
8.9E-04
2.1E-04
1.1E-03
2.7E-01
1.3E-02
2.5E-02
1.0E-02
2.7E-01
2.6E-01
1.0E-01
9.0E-02
6.6E-01
2.4E-01
1.0E-01
5.2E-01
1.4E-01
1.6E-01
1.7E-01
7.9E-02
3.3E-02
7.8E-01
8.7E-02
1.6E-01
1.1E-01
1.9E-01
4.4E-03
2.0E-01
8.7E-02
1.6E-02
4.2E-01
1.1E-01
4.3E-01
1.7E-01
2.8E-01
6.8E-02
3.4E-01
4.5E-02
1.6E-01
4.0E-01
4.5E-02
1.9E-01
3.2E-02
6.3E-02
3.8E-02
7.1E-02
2.0E-02
1.3E-02
4.0E-02
8.1E-02
2.6E-01
7.9E-03
1.3E-01
1.2E-01
1.9E-02
1.5E-01
5.2E-02
7.9E-03
1.7E-02
5.1E-02
6.3E-02
5.5E-02
3.5E-02
8.5E-02
2.0E-02
1.1E-01
A-9
-------
TABLE A-4. CONCENTRATION RANGES FROM GENERATORS SURVEY
RCRA
WASTE
CODE(S)
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048K049K051
K048K050K051
K048K050K051
K049
K049
K049
K049
K049K051
K049K051
K050
K050
K050
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K052
K052
WASTE
FORM (a)
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OL
AL
IS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS .
OS
OS
IS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
BENZENE
CONCENTRATION
RANGE
(ppm)
10 to 100
1 to 10
10 to '100
10 to 100
0.01 to 0.1
1 to 10
10 to 100
1 to 10
1 to 10
10 to 100
10 to 100
1000 to 10000
100 to 500
1 to 10
10 to 100
0.1 to 1
1000 to 10000
10 to 100
10 to 100
500 to 1000
100 to 500
0.1 to 1
10 to 100
10 to 100
1 to 10
1 to 10
100 to 500
10 to 100
10 to 100
10 to 100
100 to 500
10 to 100
10 to 100
1 to 10
1000 to 10000
BENZENE
WASTE
QUANTITY
(ton/yr) PROCESSING SEQUENCE
1.7E+03 IMPOUNDMENT, LANDTREATMENT
9.0E+02 AERATION, TANKS
4.0E+00 WASTEWATER TREATMENT
1.6E+02 WASTEWATER TREATMENT, IMPOUNDMENT
2.4E+04 WASTEWATER TREATMENT
9 . 5E+03 IMPOUNDMENT, LANDTREATMENT
1.5E+04
1.8E+04 WASTEWATER TREATMENT
1.8E+04 WASTEWATER TREATMENT
1.8E+04 FILTER, LANDTREAT
1.8E+04 FILTER, LANDTREAT
1.1E+03 LANDTREAT
2.2E+03 LANDTREAT
1.7E+02 OIL SKIM, LANDTREAT
2.1E+03 IMPOUNDMENT, LANDTREATMENT
6.5E+02 WASTEWATER TREATMENT, LAND TREATMENT
8.3E+01 TANKS,OIL SKIM, DEWATER, SOLIDIFY, LANDFILL
4.0E+00 LANDTREAT
4.0E+00 LANDTREAT
1.3E+01 FILTER, CONTAINER, LANDFILL
2.9E+02 DEWATER, LANDTREAT
1.5E+02
2 . 3E+03 SEPARATOR, LANDTREAT
3.4E+02 LANDTREAT
1.8E+03 IMPOUNDMENT, LANDTREATMENT
4.0E+02 OIL SKIM, LANDTREAT
2.2E+02 SEPARATOR, TANKS
9.0E+00 OIL SKIM
7.0E+02 IMPOUNDMENT, LANDTREATMENT
1.8E+03 LANDTREAT
2.4E+02 WASTEWATER TREATMENT .LAND TREATMENT
1.3E+03 CONTAINERS
1.2E+00 WASTEWATER TREATMENT
l.OE+00 TANK, LAND TREATMENT
l.OE+00 TANK
(a) AL = AQUEOUS LIQUID
OS = ORGANIC SLUDGE
OL = ORGANIC LIQUID
IS = INORGANIC SLUDGE
A-10
-------
APPENDIX B
ADDITIONAL DETAILS OF ESTIMATES FOR OFFSITE TSDF AND CHEMICAL PLANTS
-------
TABLE B-l. REVISED FRACTIONS EMITTED FOR PROCESSING SEQUENCES
LISTED IN TABLES B-3 AND B-4 (a)
FRACTION EMITTED
PROCESSING SEQUENCE ORGANIC AQUEOUS
1 CONTAINERS
2 CONTAINERS .LANDFILL
3 CONTAINERS.TANKS
4 CONTAINER, INCINERATION
5 DEWATERING, FILTRATION
6 IMPOUNDMENT
7 IMPOUNDMENT.WWT
8 INCINERATION
9 LAND TREATMENT
10 LANDFILL
11 SOLIDIFICATION
12 SOLIDIFICATION, WASTE PILE
13 TANKS
14 TANKS .DEWATER
15 TANKS, IMPOUNDMENT.WWT
16 TANKS, IMP., SOL., L.TRT., LANDFILL
17 TANKS, INCINERATION
18 TANKS, LANDFILL
19 TANKS.SOLIDIFICATION, INCINERATION
20 TANKS, SOLIDIFICATION, LANDFILL
21 TANKS, SOLIDIFICATION.WASTE PILE
22 TANKS.WWT
23 TANKS,WWT,IMP.,SOL.,L.F.
24 TANKS.WWT, INCINERATION
25 TANKS.WWT, SOL., INCINERATION
26 WWT
27 WWT, LANDFILL
0.0014
0.72
0.0020
0.0015
0.0021
0.76
0.94
0.0001
0.93
0.72
0.68
0.68
0.00065
0.0027
0.94
0.94
0.00075
0.72
0.68
0.72
0.68
0.76
0.99
0.76
0.92
0.73
0.92
0.0014
0.72
0.11
0.0015
0.63
0.76
0.94
0.0001
0.93
0.72
0.68
0.68
0.11
0.67
0.94
0.94
0.11
0.75
0.72
0.75
0.72
0.76
0.99
0.76
0.92
0.73
0.92
(a) REVISED BASED ON A FRACTION EMITTED OF 0.73 FOR WASTEWATER
TREATMENT INSTEAD OF 0.99. ADDITIONAL DETAILS ARE PROVIDED IN
APPENDIX C.
B-l
-------
TABLE B-2. PERCENT CONTROL FOR PROCESSING SEQUENCES
LISTED IN TABLES B-3 AND B-4 (a)
PERCENT CONTROL (b)
PROCESSING SEQUENCE ORGANIC SLUDGE AQUEOUS
1 CONTAINERS
2 CONTAINERS, LANDFILL
3 CONTAINERS, TANKS
4 CONTAINER, INCINERATION
5 DEWATERING, FILTRATION
6 IMPOUNDMENT
7 IMPOUNDMENT.WWT
8 INCINERATION
9 LAND TREATMENT
10 LANDFILL
11 SOLIDIFICATION
12 SOLIDIFICATION, WASTE PILE
13 TANKS
14 TANKS, DEWATER
15 TANKS, IMPOUNDMENT.WWT
16 TANKS, IMP. ,SOL.,L.TRT., LANDFILL
17 TANKS, INCINERATION
18 TANKS, LANDFILL
19 TANKS , SOLIDIFICATION , INCINERATION
20 TANKS, SOLIDIFICATION, LANDFILL
21 TANKS, SOLIDIFICATION, WASTE PILE
22 TANKS.WWT
23 TANKS, WWT.IMP., SOL., L.F.
24 TANKS.WWT, INCINERATION
25 TANKS, WWT.SOL., INCINERATION
26 WWT
27 WWT, LANDFILL
65
—
73
60
75
—
—
0
—
—
—
—
95
79
—
—
83
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
65
98
73
60
75
98
—
0
98
98
98
98
95
79
—
98
83
98
97
97
97
98
98
98
98
—
98
65
—
95
60
99
99
99
0
—
—
—
—
95
98
99
99
95
—
—
—
—
99
99
99
99
99
99
(a) Controls Include steam stripping for aqueous wastes, thin-film
evaporation for sludges, incineration for organic liquids and solids,
and submerge-fi11 for containers. A 95-percent control device is used
for all tanks. Additional details are given in Appendix C.
(b) Rounded to 2 significant figures.
B-2
-------
TABLE B-3. SURVEY DATA FOR OFF-SITE TSDF
(a)
T
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
G
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
G
T
T
T
T
T
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
G
T
T
T
T
T
T
G
G
T
FACILITY CITY
ASHLAND CHEMICAL BOYD CO.
CALLEIA RES. RECOVERYBROOKLYN
CASMALI A RESOURCES CASMALIA
CECOS STAMFORD
CECOS IKT'L LIVINGSTON
CECOS INT'L NIAGRA FALLS
CECOS INT'L CINCINNATI
CECOS INT'L BRISTOL
CECOS INT'L NILLIAMSBURG
CECOS INT'L NILLIAMSBURG
CECOS INT'L NILLIAMSBURG
CECOS INT'L NILLIAMSBURG
CECOS INT'L NILLIAMSBURG
CECOS INT'L NILLIAMSBURG
CECOS INT'L NILLIAMSBURG
CECOS INT'L NILLIAMSBURG
CHEMICAL PROCESSORS SEATTLE
CHEMICAL RESOURCES TULSA
CHEM-CLEAR INC. BALTIMORE
CHEM-CLEAR INC. a EVE LAND
CHEM-MET SERVICES NYANDOTTE
CHEM4ET SERVICES NYANDOTTE
CHEM-MET SERVICES NYANDOTTE
CHEM-MET SERVICES NYANDOTTE
CHEM. NASTE MGMT EMELLE
CHEM. NASTE MGMT. CALUMET CITY
CHEM. NASTE MGMT. CALUMET CITY
CHEM. NASTE MGMT. CALUMET CITY
CHEM. NASTE MGMT. CALUMET CITY
CHEM. NASTE MGMT. CALUMET CITY
CID-LANDFILL CALUMET CITY
BENZENE
CONCENTRATION
ST wt. fractlon(b)
KY
NY
CA
CT
LA
NY
OH
CT
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
NA
OK
MD
OH
Ml
Ml
Ml
Ml
AL
IL
IL
IL
IL
IL
IL
COMMERCIAL DISPOSAL CNEST SPRINGFIELMA
COMMERCIAL DISPOSAL CNEST SPRINGFIELMA
DELANARE CONTAINERS COATSVILLE
DELANARE CONTAINERS COATSVILLE
DELANARE CONTAINERS COATSVILLE
ECOLOTEC DAYTON
ENSCO EL DORADO
ENSCO EL DORADO
ENSCO EL DORADO
ENVIROSAFE SERVICES OREGON
ENVIROSAFE SERVICES OREGON
ENVIROSAFE SERVICES OREGON
ENVIROSAFE SERVICES OREGON
ENVIROSAFE SERVICES OREGON
ENVIROSAFE SERVICES OREGON
ENVIROSAFE SERVICES OREGON
ENVIROSAFE SERVICES OREGON
ENVIROSAFE SERVICES OREGON
ENVIROSAFE SERVICES OREGON
ENVIROSAFE SERVICES OREGON
ENVIROSAFE SERVICES OREGON
ENVIROSAFE SERVICES OREGON
EKV. ENTERPRISES CINCINNATI
ENV. ENTERPRISES CINCINNATI
ENV. NASTE RESOURCES NATERBURY
ERIENAY POLL. CONTROLBEDFORO
ERIENAY POLL. CONTROLBEDFORD
ERIENAY POLL. CONTROLBEOFORD
ERIENAY POLL. CONTROLBEDFORD
FRONTIER CHEMICAL NIAGRA FALLS
GULF COAST NASTE DISPTEXAS CITY
HANSBROUGH ENERGY CROWLEY
PA
PA
PA
OH
AR
AR
AR
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
OH
CT
OH
OH
OH
OH
NY
TX
LA
2.0E-03
1.0E-03
5.5E-05
5.5E-02
5.0E-08
1.0E-09
5.5E-03
5.5E-02
4.4E-06
3.0E-05
7.0E-05
3.5E-02
3.5E-02
5.0E-03
5.0E-03
7.7E-04
5.5E-03
1.2E-03
7.0E-05
7.7E-04
4.4E-D6
1.2E-03
7.5E-04
7.0E-05
5.5E-07
4.4E-06
2.0E-03
6.3E-04
7.5E-04
7.0E-05
5.5E-07
5.5E-05
5.7E-02
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
4.4E-06
4.4E-06
4.4E-06
2.0E-03
4.4E-06
2.0E-03
2.0E-03
1.2E-03
1.2E-03
7.5E-04
7.0E-05
7.0E-05
5.0E-08
5.0E-08
5.0E-08
5.5E-07
5.5E-02
6.4E-01
7.0E-05
7.5E-05
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
5.5E-07
2.0E-03
4
3
6
12
45
45
46
46
15
7
12
15
3
7
10
12
3
4
9
10
12
27
33
3
3
3
4
3
4
4
7
7
10
12
12
16
16
16
17
18
12
12
5
5
5
4
RCRA
CODES
K048K049K050
rsr*rvn
XA34
D001
U044U220U019
K031F006K016
D001
K048
K048K051
K051
K083
K083
K085
K085
K104
F005D001F001
K049
K051
K104
K048
K049
K050
K051
XLEA
K048
K048K049K050
K049K051
K050
K051
K062
F001
0001
F003F005D001
F003F005D001
F003F005D001
D002D006D007
K048
K048
K048
K048K049K051
K048
K048K049K050
K048K049K051
K049
K049
K050
K051
K051
U019
U019
U019
U019
F001F002F003
U019
K051
K035K051U019
K048K050K049
K048K050K049
K048K050K049
F001F002F003
XLEA
K048K049K051
NASTE
FORM (c)
AL
^u
AL
OL
AL
AL
AS
OL
OS
OS
OS
OL
OL
OS
OS
AL
OL
OS
OS
AL
OS
OS
IS
OS
OL
OS
AL
OS
IS
OS
AL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
AS
OS
OS
OS
AL
OS
AL
AL
OS
OS
IS
OS
OS
AL
AL
AL
AL
OL
OL
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
AL
AL
AL
NASTE PROCESS
QUANTITY CODE
(Mg/yr)(d) (e)
1.1E+05
8.0E+01
1.0E+04
2.7E+02
6.9E+03
2.6E+04
9.4E+01
2.6E+02
7.3E+00
1.7E+01
1 .7E+02
2.4E+01
3.3E+01
3.7E+02
3.6E+00
3.2E+02
3.4E+02
4.3E+02
3.7E+02
3.9E+01
O.OE+00
O.OE+00
2.0E+01
1.7E+02
1 .8E+03
8.6E+Q2
7.0E+01
1.3E+02
4.6E+01
6.2E+03
2.9E+04
4.5E+00
3.0E+00
1.5E+04
1.1E+03
O.OE+00
1.4E+02
1.2E+04
6.8E+02
1.2E+04
2.3E401
5.5E+01
3.4E+03
1.3E+03
2.8E+03
2.2E+02
3.6E+01
2.6E+02
1.9E+03
9.1E-01
2.0E+02
9.1E+00
1.3E+03
1.9E+03
1.5E+03
3.6E+00
2.0E+03
1.3E+04
2.6E+02
7.4E+03
8.8E+02
2.5E+02
1 .3E+03
10
17
6
26
13
26
18
13
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
13
13
11
22
10
10
10
10
13
10
10
10
10
10
26
13
13
17
17
17
3
25
25
25
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
13
13
13
13
4
8
22
12
12
12
12
17
9
19
B-3
-------
TABLE B-3. SURVEY DATA FOR OFF-SITE TSDF
(a)
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
G
T
T
T
G
G
G
FACILITY CITY
HANSBROUGH ENERGY CROWLEY
HANSBROUGH ENERGY CROWLEY
HANSBROUGH ENERGY CROWLEY
HANSBROUGH ENERGY CROWLEY
HANSBROUGH ENERGY CROWLEY
HERITAGE ENV. SERVICE INDIANAPOLIS
INDUSTRIAL WASTE REMOLEWISBERRY
IT CORPORATION BENECIA
IT CORPORATION WESTMORELAND
IT CORP .-PETROL. WASTBUTTONWILLOW
IT CORP .-PETROL. WASTBUTTONWILLOW
IT CORP.-PETROL. WASTBUTTONWILLOW
IT CORP.-PETROL. WASTBUTTONWILLOW
IT CORP.-PETROL. WASTBUTTONWILLOW
MALONE SERVICE CO. TEXAS CITY
MICHIGAN DISPOSAL INCBELLEVILLE
MICHIGAN DISPOSAL INCBELLEVILLE
MICHIGAN DISPOSAL INCBELLEVILLE
PEORIA DISPOSAL CO. PEORIA
PETROCHEM RECYCLING SALT LAKE CITY
PETROCHEM RECYCLING SALT LAKE CITY
ROGERS LANDF 1 LL CENTREV 1 LLE
ROLLINS ENV. SERVICESBRIDGEPORT
ROLLINS ENV. SERVICESDEER PARK
ROLLINS ENV. SERVICESDEER PARK
ROLLINS ENV. SERVICESDEER PARK
ROLLINS ENV. SERVICESDEER PARK
ROLLINS ENV. SERVICESDEER PARK
SOLVENT RECOV. SERVICLINDEN
SOLVENT RECOV. SERVICLINOEN
SOLVENT RECOV. SERVICLINDEN
TEXAS ECOLOGISTS ROBSTOWN
TEXAS ECOLOGISTS ROBSTOWN
TEXAS ECOLOGISTS ROBSTOWN
TEXAS ECOLOGISTS ROBSTOWN
TEXAS ECOLOGISTS ROBSTOWN
TEXAS ECOLOGISTS ROBSTOWN
TEXAS ECOLOGISTS ROBSTOWN
TEXAS ECOLOGISTS ROBSTOWN
TEXAS ECOLOGISTS ROBSTOWN
TEXAS ECOLOGISTS ROBSTOWN
BENZENE
CONCENTRATION
ST wt. fractlon(b)
LA
LA
LA
LA
LA
IN
PA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
CA
TX
Ml
Ml
Ml
IL
UT
UT
MS
NJ
TX
TX
TX
TX
TX
NJ
NJ
NJ
TX
TX
TX
TX
TX
TX
TX
TX
TX
TX
TRICIL ENV. SERVICES MUSKEGON HEIGHTM1
USPCI GRASSY MT. KNOWLES
USPCI GRASSY MT. KNOWLES
WASTE CONVERSION HATFIELD
WASTE TECH SERVICES GOLDEN
WASTE TECH SERVICES GOLDEN
WAYNE DISPOSAL BELLEVILLE
UT
UT
PA
CO
CO
Ml
2.0E-03
4.4E-06
1.2E-03
7.0E-05
7.0E-05
7.0E-05
7
7
7
1
1
7
7
7
5
6
.OE-05
.OE-05
.OE-05
.2E-03
.2E-03
.5E-04
.OE-05
.OE-05
.OE-08
.3E-04
1.2E-03
7
1
6
7
A
5
6
1
7
7
5
7
7
1
1
3
1
6
7
7
7
5
5
5
5
1
6
1
1
1
5
.OE-05
.2E-03
.3E-04
.OE-05
.4E-06
.OE-03
.3E-04
.2E-03
.5E-04
.OE-05
.OE-03
.OE-05
.OE-05
.7E-05
.1E-03
.OE-05
.2E-03
.3E-04
.5E-04
.OE-05
.OE-05
.5E-07
.5E-07
.5E-07
.OE-08
.1E-03
-3E-04
.2E-03
.OE-03
.OE-03
.OE-08
4
3
7
12
12
12
12
12
12
7
7
10
12
12
16
9
7
12
7
9
12
3
46
9
7
10
12
46
12
12
18
42
6
7
9
10
12
12
17
17
17
42
9
8
RCRA
CODES
K048K049K051
K048
K049
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K049
K049
K050
K051
K051
U019
K049K051
K049
K051
K049
K049K051
K051
K048
K085
K049K051
K049
K050
K051
K085
K051
K051
U019
K035
K048K051
K049
K049K051
K050
K051
K051
U019
U019
U019
F006
K035
K049K051
K049K050K051
F024
D008
XLEA
WASTE PROCESS
WASTE QUANTITY CODE
FORM (o) (Mg/yr)(d) (e)
AL
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
IS
OS
OS
AL
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
IS
OS
OS
OS
OS
AL
OS
OS
OS
OS
IS
OS
OS
IS
IS
IS
AS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OL
AL
1.3E+04
8.4E+02
1.6E+02
2.2E+02
2.3E+02
4.4E+02
7.3E+00
4.4E+02
2.2E+03
4.2E+02
6.0E+01
8.5E+01
2.8E+03
2.0E+01
1 .6E+01
9.3E+04
3.
2.
1.
7.
9.
2.
2.
8.
6.
1.
6.
4.
1.
1.
2.
7.
4.
5.
1.
2.
4.
1.
9.
5.
2E+02
4E+02
9E+01
6E+02
5E+01
1E-KJ4
3E+02
3E+04
OE+03
6E+03
OE+03
7E+04
8E-01
8E-01
5E+02
3E+00
OE+02
OE+02
8E+03
4E+03
5E+03
2E+01
1E-01
1F+01
9.1F-01
1.
1.
3.
5.
1
1.
1.
4E+02
2E+03
7E+03
3E+04
9E+00
9E+00
1E+04
19
19
19
19
19
24
13
23
7
7
7
7
7
7
13
12
12
12
10
22
22
9
8
20
20
10
20
8
1
1
13
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
14
10
16
21
8
8
13
(a) G •= FROM GENERATOR SURVEY
T - FROM TSDR SURVEY
(b) CONCENTRATIONS ARE FROM GENERATORS SURVEY. WHEN A NUMBER (CODE) FOLLOWS, AN AVERAGE
CONCENTRATION WAS ESTIMATED AND THE CODE IS KEYED TO TABLE B-5. *' m nuw*
(c) WASTE FORMS —
AL - AQUEOUS LIQUID
AS - AQUEOUS SLUDGE
OL = ORGANIC LIQUID
OS - ORGANIC SLUDGE
IS «= INORGANIC SLUDGE
(d) QUANTITY OF WASTE THAT CONTAINS BENZENE.
(e) CODE FOR PROCESSING UNITS, KEYED TO TABLE B-1.
B-4
-------
TABLE &-4. TSDF AN) GENERATORS SURVEY DATA FOR CHEMICAL PLANTS
00
G
G
G
G
G
G
T
T
T
G
G
G
G
G
G
T
G
G
G
G
T
G
G
T
T
G
G
T
T
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
T
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
T
T
T
T
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
FACILITY
3-M COMPANY
3-M COMPANY
AIR PRODUCTS & CHEM.
ALDRICH CHEMICALS
ALDRICH CHEMICALS
ALDRICH CHEMICALS
ALLIED CHEMICAL
ALLIED SIGNAL
ALLIED SIGNAL
ALPHA CHEMICAL
ALPHA RESINS
AMCHEM PRODUCTS INC.
AMERICAN CYANAMID
AMERICAN CYANAMID
AMOCO CHEMICAL
ARIS TECH CHEMICAL
AYERST LABS
BF GOODRICH
BF GOODRICH
BF GOODRICH
BF GOODRICH CHEMICAL
BROWNING MANUF.
CAIN CHEMICAL
CALGON CARBON
CELANESE CHEMICAL
CHATTEM CHEMICALS
CIBA CORNING
CIBA-GEIGY
COSAN CHEMICAL
DEVOE & RAYNOLDS
DON CHEMICAL
DOW CHEMICAL
DON CHEMICAL
DON CHEMICAL
DON CHEMICAL
DON CHEMICAL
DON CORNING
DON CORNING
DON CORNING
DON CORNING
DON CORNING
DON CORNING
DSM CHEMICALS
DUPONT
DUPONT
DUPONT
DUPONT
DUPONT
DUPONT
DUPONT
DUPONT
DUPONT
DUPONT
DUPONT
EASTMAN KODAK
GAF CORP.
GENERAL ELECTRIC
GENERAL ELECTRIC
GENERAL ELECTRIC
GENERAL ELECTRIC
GENERAL ELECTRIC
CITY
COTTAGE GROVE
COTTAGE GROVE
WICHITA
MILWAUKEE
MILWAUKEE
MILWAUKEE
IRONTON
BIRMINGHAM
BIRMINGHAM
LAKELAND
PERRIS
AMBLER
BRIDGENATER
BRIDGEWATER
TEXAS CITY
HAVERHILL
ROUSES POINT
AVON LAKE
AVON LAKE
AVON LAKE
CALVERT CITY
MORGAN
BRAZORIA
NEVILLE ISLAND
BISHOP
CHATTANOOGA
MEDFIELD
TOMS RIVER
CARLSTADT
LOUISVILLE
PLAOUEMAN
PLAOUEMAN
PITTSBURG
PITTSBURG
DALTON
LEDYARD
MIDLAND
MIDLAND
MIDLAND
MIDLAND
MIDLAND
MIDLAND
AUGUSTA
BEAUMONT
BEAUMONT
BEAUMONT
BEAUMONT
LUGOFF
GIBBSTOWN
GIBBSTOWN
DEEPWATER
DEEPWATER
DEEPWATER
DEEPWATER
ROCHESTER
CALVERT CITY
WATERFORD
WATERFORD
WATERFORD
WATERFORD
WATERFORD
BENZENE
CONCENTRATION
ST wt. fraction
MN
MN
KS
Wl
Wl
Wl
OH
AL
AL
FL
CA
PA
NJ
NJ
TX
OH
NY
OH
OH
OH
KY
UT
TX
PA
TX
TN
MA
NJ
NJ
KY
LA
LA
CA
CA
GA
CT
Ml
Ml
Ml
Ml
Ml
Ml
GA
TX
TX
TX
TX
SC
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
NJ
NY
KY
NY
NY
NY
NY
NY
1.1E-01
9.2E-03
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
7.5E-04
5.5E-06
1.1E-03
1.8E-05
1.8E-05
1 .OE-01
1 .OE-01
5.0E-08
5.7E-02
5.5E-05
5.5E-02
3.9E-04
5.SE-02
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
6.3E-01
5.5E-07
5.5E-03
1.3E-01
7.7E-04
5.5E-07
5.5E-07
1.5E-06
7.7E-04
5.5E-07
l.OE-09
3.8E-01
1 .8E-01
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
7.5E-04
7.5E-04
5.5E-07
1.8E-01
5.5E-02
7.5E-04
5.5E-06
1.8E-01
5.5E-07
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
7.5E-04
5.5E-02
5.5E-03
5.5E-05
5.5E-03
1.8E-05
5.5E-07
7.0E-05
5.5E-05
1.8E-01
5.5E-03
5.5E-02
1.8E-01
7.5E-04
5.5E-05
5.5E-06
30
29
24
34
42
43
43
21
21
27
23
44
17
15
17
28
15
17
25
17
23
43
11
12
14
RCRA
(b) CODES
D001
0001
D001
D001F003U117
U211F002U080
D003
K035
K035
K035
D001
D001
D002
D001
X940
D001
K083
D001F003F005
F003
F003
D001
U019
F005
D001
K104
U019
D001
D001
K104
U019
D001
0001
0001
F 0030001
F002
D001
D001
D002
D001D003
D001F003F005
F005
D001D002D003
D001D003F002
U019
D001
U169
K104
D001
D001
K104
U169
K035
K050K051
K051
K104
F002F003D001
D001
D001F002F003
D001F002F003
D001F002F003
XNNS
XLEA
WASTE PROCESS
WASTE QUANTITY CODE
FORM (c) (Mg/yr)(d) (e)
OL
OS
OLAL
OL
OL
OS
OS
AS
AS
OL
OL
OL
OL
IS
OL
AL
OL
OL
OL
OS
AL
OL
AL
AL
AL
OL
OLAL
AL
AL
OL
OS
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
AL
OL
OL
IS
IS
OL
AL
OL
OL
AL
OL
OL
AL
AL
AS
OS
OS
AL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OS
IS
AL
1.9E+02
6.3E+02
5.8E+02
2.5E+02
3.1E+01
1.2E+01
3.9E402
9.1E-01
2.4E+02
1.2E+03
1.6E+03
9.8E+01
9.1E-01
4.1E-f01
1.1E+02
4.2E403
1.7E402
1.1E+01
1.6E+01
1.2E+00
1.5E+01
1.7E+00
1.3E+02
1.9E+03
5.9E+03
3.0E+02
6.1E+00
9.1E-01
9.1E-01
3.0E+01
4.0E+01
5.8E+01
1.5E+01
5.5E+00
2.5E+02
1.3E+02
1.3E403
2.2E+03
5.7E-I01
1.0E+02
4.3E+01
3.3E+02
9.0E+02
1.3E+01
1.4E+02
1.6E+05
5.5E+02
1 .4E+01
1.7E+03
1.0E+02
4.0E+03
6.2E+04
5.6E+03
2.9E+03
6.3E+00
1.4E+03
2.5E+03
3.5E+03
2.5E+03
9.2E+03
3.8E+03
4
4
17
1
1
1
1
24
24
17
17
13
1
1
1
26
1
4
4
4
1
1
13
13
15
13
1
1
1
1
4
4
1
1
28
28
13
13
13
1
1
13
17
1
1
26
13
1
22
13
22
27
27
26
4
17
17
17
4
10
26
-5
-------
TABLE B-4. TSDF AND GENERATORS SURVEY DATA FOR CHEMICAL PLANTS
(a)
G
G
G
T
G
G
G
G
G
G
T
G
G
G
T
T
T
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
T
T
G
G
G
G
G
G
T
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
G
FACILITY
GEORGIA GULF CORP.
GLIDDEN COATINGS
GOODYEAR TIRE
GOODYEAR TIRE
HEAT ENERGY TECH.
HEAT ENERGY TECH.
HERCULES
HERCULES
HERCULES
CITY
PASADENA
CARROLLTON
BEAUMONT
BEAUMONT
DALLAS
DALLAS
MAGNA
GIBBSTOWN
GIBBSTOWN
INT'L FLAVORS i FRAGRUNION BEACH
KOPPERS
LILLY COAT INGS
LILLY COATINGS
LILLY IND. COATINGS
MALLINCKRODT CHEM.
MARISOL INC.
MARISOL INC.
MEAD JOHNSON
MINE SAFETY APPL.
MOBAY CORP.
MOBIL CHEMICALS
MOBIL CHEMICALS
NORCHEM CO.
NORCHEM CO.
NORCHEM, INC.
OLIN CHEMICALS
OLIN CORP.
OLIN CORP.
OLIN CORP.
ORTHO DIAGNOSTICS
PARKE-OAVIS
PARKE-DAVIS
PPG INDUSTRIES
PPG INDUSTRIES
REICHHOLD CHEMICALS
SOUTHLAND CORP.
SOUTHLAND CORP.
SOUTHLAND CORP.
STAUFFER CHEMICAL
STAUFFER CHEMICAL
STEPAN CO.
TREMCO INC.
UN ION CARBIDE
UNION CARBIDE
UNION CARBIDE
UNION CARBIDE
UNION CARBIDE
US ARMY MUNITIONS
US INDUSTRIAL CHEM.
US INDUSTRIAL CHEM.
USS CHEMICALS
VISTA CHEMICAL
VISTA CHEMICAL
VISTA CHEMICAL
VISTA CHEMICAL
VISTA CHEMICAL
VISTA CHEMICAL
VISTA CHEMICAL
VISTA CHEMICAL
VISTA CHEMICAL
VISTA CHEMICAL
HOUSTON
MONTEBELLO
MONTEBELLO
DALLAS
RALEIGH
MIDDLESEX
MIDDLESEX
EVANSVILLE
EVANS CITY
HALEDON
BEAUMONT
BEAUMONT
CLINTON
CLINTON
MORRIS
AUGUSTA
ST. MARKS
ST. MARKS
ST. MARKS
RARITAN
HOLLAND
HOLLAND
DELAWARE
NORTON
GULFPORT
GREAT MEADOWS
GREAT MEADOWS
GREAT MEADOWS
BATON ROUGE
BATON ROUGE
ELWOOD
BARBOURVILLE
SEADRIFT
SE ADRIFT
SEADRIFT
SEADRIFT
PENUELAS
KINGSTON
TUSCOLA
TUSCOLA
FLORENCE
WESTLAKE
WESTLAKE
BALTIMORE
BALTIMORE
BALTIMORE
BALTIMORE
BALTIMORE
BALTIMORE
BALTIMORE
BALTIMORE
BENZENE
CONCENTRATION
ST wt. fraction
TX
TX
TX
TX
TX
TX
UT
NJ
NJ
NJ
TX
CA
CA
TX
NC
NJ
NJ
IN
PA
NJ
TX
TX
IA
IA
IL
GA
FL
FL
FL
NJ
Ml
Ml
OH
OH
MS
NJ
NJ
NJ
LA
LA
IL
KY
TX
TX
TX
TX
PR
TN
IL
IL
KY
LA
LA
MD
MD
MD
MD
MD
MD
MD
MD
5
5
7
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
1
5
5
5
3
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
3
1
5
5
6
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
8
3
3
5
5
5
8
5
8
5
9
7
7
1
5
5
3
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
.5E-02
.5E-03
.5E-04
.5E-07
.5E-02
.5E-02
.5E-02
.5E-08
.5E-07
.5E-06
.8E-05
.5E-02
.5E-02
.5E-03
.5E-02
.5E-07
.5E-07
.5E-02
.5E-05
.OE-08
.5E-02
.5E-02
.5E-03
.5E-02
.OE-04
.8E-01
.5E-02
.5E-06
.3E-01
.5E-05
.5E-03
.5E-02
.5E-07
.5E-03
.5E-02
.5E-02
.5E-02
.3E-01
.5E-02
.5E-02
.OE-08
.5E-06
.5E-02
.3E-01
.5E-03
.3E-01
.5E-07
.5E-01
.5E-04
.5E-04
.8E-01
.5E-05
.5E-07
.OE-04
.5E-07
.5E-06
.5E-02
.5E-02
.5E-02
.5E-05
.5E-02
31
17
36
36
43
45
17
17
34
45
45
17
RCRA
(b) CODES
D002D003
D001F003F005
D001U044U220
U019
F001F002
F001F002F003
D001F002F005
XWWS
U019
F003
K035
F003F005
F003F005
D001F003F005
K083
U019
U019
F003D001
D001
D001
D001F005
D001D001F001
D001
D001
D001
F003F005
D003
D003
D003
F003
D002
F003F005
F003F005
D001D012D016
D001
F001D001
D002
D001F002
K083
K083
F003
D001
D001
D001
D001
D001
U019
P001U019
D001
D001
D009F003F005
D002
0002
0002
D002
D002
0001
D001
D002
0002
D001 -
HASTE
FORM (c)
AL
OL
OL
AL
OL
OL
OL
OL
AL
AL
AS
OL
OL
OL
OL
AL
AL
OL
OL
AL
OS
OLAL
OLAL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OS
OL
OL
AL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
AL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OS
OL
AL
OL
OL
OL
OL
AL
AL
AL
AL
AL
IS
IS
OS
AL
OL
WASTE PROCESS
QUANTITY CODE
(Mg/yr)(d) (e)
1
1
1
1
2
2
9
1
2
3
1
6
2
.9E+02
.5E-I02
.5E+00
.8E+00
.5E+02
.7E+03
.1E-01
.1E+03
.9E+05
.1E+05
.1E+03
.5E+01
.OE+02
2.1E+01
1
1
3
4
4
1
6
1
1
2
9
4
1
5
2
9
1
1
3
1
1
6
3
6
3
1
1
5
6
1
9
0
1
4
3
1
1
1
8
1
1
9
7
1
5
4
1
.2E+03
.4E+04
.8E+00
.8E+00
.5E-01
.2E+06
.5E+02
.8E+00
.2E+03
.9E+00
.1E-01
.5E+00
.8E+01
.1E+02
.6E+02
.1E-01
.3E+04
.6E+03
.3E+02
.1E+01
.5E+03
.9E+01
.2E+02
.6E+01
.4E+02
.4E+03
.6E+01
.1E+01
.5E+01
.2E+00
.1E-01
.OE+00
.OE+05
.5E-01
.2E+02
.1E+03
.1E-01
.9E+03
.OE+04
.5E+04
5E+04
.5E+04
.5E+03
.6E+01
.5E+00
.8E+02
.8E+01
13
1
26
26
17
17
1
5
5
26
22
1
1
1
8
8
8
1
1
26
13
1
13
1
13
1
17
17
17
17
26
13
13
1
17
13
22
13
8
8
1
1
17
13
2
17
15
1
17
17
1
13
26
26
26
26
8
1
26
13
13
-6
-------
TABLE B-4. TSOF AND GENERATORS SURVEY DATA FOR CHEMICAL PLANTS
(a)
G
G
ir^"?*
FACILITY
VULCAN MATERIALS
WITCO CORP.
CITY
WICHITA
OILDALE
ST
KS
CA
BENZENE
CONCENTRATION
wt. fraction
5.5E-05
9.0E-04
RCRA
(b) CODES
K016
47 U052D007K050
WASTE
FORM (c)
AL
AL
WASTE
QUANTITY
(Mg/yr)(d)
4.1E+05
2.0E+05
PROCESS
CODE
(e)
13
26
(a) G - FROM GENERATOR SURVEY
T - FROM TSDR SURVEY
(b) CONCENTRATIONS ARE FROM GENERATORS SURVEY. WHEN A NUMBER (CODE) FOLLOWS, AN AVERAGE
CONCENTRATION WAS ESTIMATED AND THE CODE IS KEYED TO TABLE B-5.
(C) WASTE FORMS — AL - AQUEOUS LIQUID
AS - AQUEOUS SLUDGE
OL - ORGANIC LIQUID
OS = ORGANIC SLUDGE
IS •= INORGANIC SLUDGE
(d) QUANTITY OF WASTE THAT CONTAINS BENZENE.
(8) CODE FOR PROCESSING UNITS, KEYED TO TABLE B-1.
B-7
-------
TABLE B-5. AVERAGE BENZENE CONCENTRATION VALUES DERIVED FROM GENERATOR SURVEY
RCRA
CONCENTRATION HASTE
CODE CODE(S)
2
2
3
3
3
3
3
3
4
4
5
6
6
7
7
7
7
8
8
8
8
8
8
9
9
10
11
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
.12
12
13
14
15
15
16
17
18
18
18
18
18
K050
K050
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048K049
K048K049
K048K050K051
K048K050K051
K048K049K051
K049
K049
K049
K049
K049
K049
K049
K050
K050
K049
K049K051
K049K051
K050
K050K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K104
K104
K104
K104
U019
U019
U019
U019
U019
U019
U019
BENZENE
WASTE FIRST SECOND CONCENTRATION
FORM (1) SIC CODE SIC CODE (wt. fraction)
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
AL
AL
OS
OS
IS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
IS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
AL
AL
AL
AL
AL
AL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911 1321
2911 1321
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911 2869
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
5171
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2865
2869
2865
2869
8999
2869
8221 8062
7391
4784
2892
2865
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
5.5E-06
5.5E-06
5.0E-08
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
1.0E-09
5.5E-03
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
5.5E-06
3.0E-04
5.5E-03
5.5E-05
5.5E-06
5.5E-05
3.0E-04
5.5E-03
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
5.5E-06
5.5E-07
5.5E-03
7.5E-04
5.5E-07
5.5E-05
3.0E-04
5.5E-07
3.0E-04
3.0E-04
3.0E-04
5.5E-06
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
5.5E-06
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
7.5E-04
5.5E-05
7.5E-04
5.5E-05
5.0E-08
5.5E-07
9.5E-01
5.5E-02
8.3E-01
9.5E-01
1.8E-01
BENZENE AVERAGE (2)
WASTE BENZENE
QUANTITY CONCENTRATION
(ton/yr) (trt. fraction)
4.0E+00
4.0E+00
1.7E+03
9.5E+03
9.0E+02
2.4E+04
4.0E+00
1.6E+02
1 .8E+03
1.0E+03
1 .8E+04
1.8E+04
1.8E+04
2.2E+03
1.1E+03
2.1E+03
1.7E-f02
2.1E+03
2.2E-I03
1.1E+03
4.0E+00
4.0E+00
1.7E+02
6.5E+02
8.3E+01
1 .3E+01
6.9E+02
1 .3E+03
2.9E+02
1 .5E+02
2.9E+02
2.4E+02
2.2E+02
4.0E*02
3.4E+02
1.2E+00
9.0E+00
1 .8E-f03
7.0E+02
1.8E+03
2.3E+03
1.8E+05
1 .9E+03
1.8E+05
1.9E+03
7.6E+03
3.1E+05
1.0E+00
I.OE-HW
4.2E+00
5.0E-01
1.4E+00
5.5E-05
4.4E-06
2.0E-03
5.5E-05
3.0E-C5
1.2E-03
1.2E-03
6.3E-04
7.5E-04
5.5E-07 '
7.0E-05
7.5E-04
5.5E-05
7.7E-04
5.0E-08
5.5E-07
6.4E-01
-------
TABLE 6-5. AVERAGE BENZENE CONCENTRATION VALUES DERIVED FROM GENERATOR SURVEY
RCRA
CONCENTRATION WASTE
CODE COOE(S)
BENZENE
HASTE FIRST SECOND CONCENTRATION
FORM (1) SIC CODE SIC CODE (wt. fraction)
BENZENE AVERAGE (2)
WASTE BENZENE
QUANTITY CONCENTRATION
(ton/yr) (wt. fraction)
19
19
19
19
20
20
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
25
26
26
26
27
28
28
28
28
28
28
28
29
29
29
29
29
29
29
29
29
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
31
D001
D001
D001
D001
D001
0001
D001
0001
0001
D001
D001
D001
0001
0001
D001
D001
D001
D001
0001
D001
D001
0001
D001
0001
D001
0001
D001
D001
0001
0001
0001
D001
0001
0001
D001
D001
D001
D001
D001
D001
D001
D001
0001
0001
D001
D001
0001
0001
D001
D001
D001
D001
0001
IS
IS
IS
IS
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OS
OS
OL
OL
OLAL
IS
OLAL
OLAL
OLAL
OL
OLAL
OLAL
OLAL
OLAL
OLAL
OLAL
OLAL
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
OL
2865
2865
3721
2869
2911
2911
2821
2821
2821
2821
2821
2821
2821
2821
2911
2911
2865
2865
2869
2869
4613
4613
4613
Weighted
2821
4214
2869
4613
4613
4613
2800
2869
2869
2869
2869
2869
2869
2869
2869
2869
2869
2869
2869
2869
2869
2869
2869
2869
2869
2869
2869
2869
2821
2865
2800
2800
2869
2822
2869
2865
4463
average of
2869
1799
4463
2869
2865
2865
2865
2865
2833
2865
2819
2822
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
5.5E-06
5.5E-06
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
3.0E-04
7.5E-04
1.8E-01
7.5E-04
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
3.0E-04
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
5.5E-06
5.0E-08
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
Nos. 21,23,30
5.5E-03
5.5E-06
5.5E-02
5.5E-05
5.0E-08
5.5E-05
5.5E-02
5.5E-03
5.5E-06
5.5E-06
5.5E-06
5.5E-06
3.8E-01
5.5E-02
5.5E-06
5.5E-06
8.3E-01
8.3E-01
5.5E-03
8.3E-01
5.5E-02
1.8E-01
5.5E-06
1.8E-01
1.8E-01
3.0E-04
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
7.5E-04
8.3E+03
1.8E+01
3.0E+00
1.3E+01
4.6E+04
6.9E+04
2.8E+03
1.0E+00
2.7E+02
3.8E+03
1.4E+02
1 .6E+03
3.2E+00
1.6E+03
2.2E+02
6.6E+01
2.0E+01
6.0E+02
2.0E+00
1.3E+01
5.9E+06
2.5E+02
1.2E+03
1.3E+03
5.5E+03
2.0E+00
2.5E+02
5.SE+06
1.2E+03
2.2E+01
1.0E+00
3.6E+01
9.8E+02
4.5E+01
3.1E+03
4.4E+01
7.2E+02
1.3E+03
2.1E+01
O.OE+00
7.3E+01
1.5E+03
1.3E+00
6.3E+01
3.7E+02
3.2E+01
2.4E+03
6.4E+01
7.9E+02
7.2E+01
2.7E+02
2.7E+02
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
1.0E-01
1.3E-02
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
5.5E-06
6.4E-08
5.7E-02
1.5E-06
9.2E-03
1.1E-01
7.5E-04
tf
B-9
-------
TABLE B-5. AVERAGE BENZENE CONCENTRATION VALUES DERIVED FROM GENERATOR SURVEY
RCRA
CONCENTRATION WASTE
CODE CODE(S)
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
33
34
35
36
37
37
38
39
39
39
39
39
39
39
39
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
41
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
0002
D002
D002
D002
D002
D002
D002
D002
D002
D002
D002
D002
D002
D003
D008
F001
F003
F003
K009
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K048
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K051
K052
K052
K035
K035
K083
K083
K085
U052D007K050
D007
BENZENE
WASTE FIRST SECOND CONCENTRATION
FORM (1) SIC CODE SIC CODE (wt. fraction)
AL
AL
AL
AL
AL
AL
AL
AL
AL
AL
AL
AL
OS
OS
OL
OL
OL
OL
OS
AL
OL
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OS
OL
AL
AL
OL
OL
AL
AL
2869
2869 2865
2865
2865
2869
2865
2869
2834
2865
2869
2869
2800
2865
3483
2911
2869
2869
2869
2869
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911 2869
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
2911
(3)
(3)
(3)
(3)
(3)
(4)
3523
5.5E-08
5.5E-02
3.0E-04
5.5E-06
5.5E-07
5.5E-07
5.5E-05
5.5E-03
5.5E-05
5.5E-02
5.5E-07
5.5E-07
5.5E-02
5.5E-06
1.0E-03
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
5.5E-05
5.5E-06
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
5.5E-06
5.5E-06
5.0E-08
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
3.0E-04
5.5E-06
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
5.5E-05
3.0E-04
3.0E-04
5.5E-05
5.5E-07
5.5E-06
3.0E-04
5.5E-03
5.5E-06
1.1E-03
1.8E-05
3.9E-04
3.5E-02
5.0E-03
9.0E-04
5.0E-08
BENZENE AVERAGE (2)
WASTE BENZENE
QUANTITY CONCENTRATION
(ton/yr) (wt. fraction)
7.7E+04
2.1E+02
1.7E+04
1.1E+05
8.8E+04
1.7E+04
2.1E+03
1.4E+04
5.3E+02
3.5E+02
1.4E+03
3.5E+02
6.0E+00
8.0E+00
2.1E+00
7.6E+01
1.3E+01
1.8E+01
1.3E+02
1.8E+04
1.5E+04
4.0E+00
1.6E+02
9.0E+02
9.5E403
2.4E+04
1.7E-f03
9.0E+00
3.4E+02
2.9E+02
4.0E+02
1.8E+03
1.3E+03
7.0E+02
2.9E+02
2.4E+02
2.3E+03
1.5E+02
1.8E+03
2.2E+02
1 .OE+00
1.0E+00
,
„_,_
—
9.4E+02
3.5E-04
5.5E-02
5.5E-06
1.0E-03
5.5E-02
5.5E-02
5.5E-05
1.5E-05
6.9E-05
2.8E-03
1.1E-03
1.8E-05
3.9E-04
3.5E-02
5.0E-03
9.0E-04
5.0E-08
B-10
-------
TABLE B-5. AVERAGE BENZENE CONCENTRATION VALUES DERIVED FROM GENERATOR SURVEY
RCRA BENZENE
CONCENTRATION WASTE WASTE FIRST SECOND CONCENTRATION
CODE COOE(S) FORM (1) SIC CODE SIC CODE (wt. fraction)
49
49
49
49
D007
0007
0007
0007
OL
OS
IS
OL
3728
2911
2813
3471
7.5E-04
5.5E-02
3.8E-01
5.5E-07
BENZENE AVERAGE (2)
WASTE BENZENE
QUANTITY CONCENTRATION
(ton/yr) (wt. fraction)
4.4E+01
6.6E+01
2.0E+00
1.2E+01
3.6E-02
50 K048
AL
2911
2800
5.5E-06
1.8E+04 5.5E-06
(1) WASTE FORM:
AL •= AQUEOUS LIQUID
AS = AQUEOUS SLUDGE
OL - ORGANIC LIQUID
OS = ORGANIC SLUDGE
IS = INORGANIC SOLID
(2) AVERAGE WEIGHTED BY QUANTITY.
(3) FROM REFERENCE 15.
(4) ASSUME THE CONCENTRATION IS HALF THE SOLUBILITY OF BENZENE IN WATER (1,800 ppffl).
B-ll
-------
APPENDIX C: ESTIMATES OF FRACTION OF BENZENE EMITTED
-------
C.I: ESTIMATES OF FRACTION OF BENZENE EMITTED
The estimates of the fraction of benzene emitted from wastewater collec-
tion and treatment units were obtained from Reference 11. This document
describes in detail the emission models that were used and provides sample
calculations. Estimates are presented for toluene, a compound with a
volatility very similar to that of benzene, for three different model
wastewater treatment units. Table C-l provides the fractions emitted for
individual sources in the wastewater treatment system. Three model units were
developed to represent a range of complexity (in the number and types of
wastewater treatment units), and the cumulative fraction emitted for these
model units were estimated. The results for the collection system and for the
entire treatment system are summarized in Table C-2.
Estimates of fractions emitted for other types of sources that process
wastes were taken from a range of values presented in "Hazardous Waste TSDF -
Background Information for Proposed RCRA Air Emission Standards (Draft)"
(referred to as "TSDF BID"). This document provides emission estimates
based on model units and air emission models, developed by the Office of Air
Quality Planning and Standards and published in a report entitled "Hazardous
Waste Treatment, Storage, and Disposal Facilities - Air Emission Models."
These emission factors are average values derived from a range of values
for specific units. Depending on the unit's design and operation, the
emission factor for a specific process at a given facility may be higher or
lower. The emission factors are based on model units and mathematical models
that were derived from mass transfer theory, laboratory measurements, and
field evaluations. A detailed description of the models and comparisons of
the model predictions to field measurements are given in the air emission
models document. The model units used in the emission models were derived
from statistical summaries of design and operating parameters of units
typically found at hazardous waste facilities. For a given type of process,
the emission estimates for the different model units were combined to develop
an average estimate. The average estimate used in this analysis was taken
from the midrange or average value from a group of model units representative
of a single type of source.
C-l
-------
TABLE C-l. FRACTIONS EMITTED FOR COMPONENTS OF A WASTEWATER SYSTEM11
Component Fraction Emitted
Drain 0.061
Manhole 0.0082
Junction box 0.098
Lift station 0.29
Sump 0.005
Open trench 0.045
Equalization basin
(Non-aerated) 0.40
(Aerated) 0.99
Clarifier 0.025
Biobasin
(Aerated) 0.12
(Non-aerated) 0.06
Treatment tank 0.0092
Oil-water separator 0.47
Weir , 0.25
C-2
"/T-
-------
TABLE C-2. CUMULATIVE FRACTION EMITTED FOR THE MODEL UNIT
11
Cumulative Fraction Emitted
Model Unit9
Wastewaterv
Collection1
Entire Wastewater
System
Schematic I
Schematic II
Schematic III
0.38
0.21
0.44
0.47
0.74
1.0d
The 3 model units represent wastewater treatment systems that span a range
of complexity and a number of units. The components in each schematic are
listed below:
Schematic I
• Drains
• Lift station
• Clarifier
• Aeration basin
• Clarifier
Schematic II
Schematic III
Drains
Junction box
Manhole
Oil-water separator
Nonaerated
equalization basin
pH tank
Aeration basin
Clarifier
Drains
Open trench
Sump
Junction box
Lift station
Aerated
equalization basin
pH tank
Weir
Aeration basin
Flocculation tank
Clarifier
blncludes drains, junction boxes, manholes, lift stations, etc. prior to the
equalization basin or clarifier.
clncludes all units from the process drain to the final treatment unit.
dEssentially all of the volatile compounds (e.g., toluene) is estimated to be
emitted because this model unit includes an aerated equalization basin.
C-3
-------
Separate factors were derived for benzene dissolved In other organlcs and
for benzene dissolved 1n water to reflect the effect on the volatility of
benzene. Because of benzene's low solubility 1n water and high vapor
pressure, benzene 1s highly volatile In wastewater or aqueous wastes.
However, when benzene Is dissolved 1n a mixture of similar organic compounds,
it exhibits a lower volatility than in aqueous wastes (when compared at the
same concentration). This distinction is not important for wastes processed
in open area sources with a relatively long retention time because a high
percentage of the benzene will volatilize, whether it is in an organic waste
or wastewater.
The process information from the data sources indicated that the wastes
are usually managed in a series of individual units. For example, a typical
series could include a storage unit, treatment unit, and final disposal. The
percents emitted for the individual units were combined to reflect an overall
percent emitted for each sequence of units. For example, a processing
sequence composed of two individual units, both with a percent emitted of 50,
would yield an overall percent emitted of 75, indicating that 75 percent of
the total benzene in the waste would be emitted. The results for the
processing sequences are summarized in Table B-l and additional details for
individual emission sources are given below.
Containers
Emissions from containers include loading emissions and spills when the
container is filled, and if the container is left uncovered, evaporative
losses from the open surface. Drums are common containers used for liquids,
sludges, and solids. Sludges and sol Ids may also be accumulated and stored in
dumpsters or bins prior to transport or disposal. For container loading and
storage, a percent emitted of 0.14 was estimated for highly volatile compounds
such as benzene. This factor Includes emissions from container loading
(vapor displacement while the container 1s being filled) and spills (0.0001),
and does not include emissions from open containers during storage. This
analysis assumes that containers with benzene-containing wastes are generally
kept covered to minimize emissions as part of routine operating practices for
handling volatile materials.
C-4
-------
Fixation (solidification)
Fixation or solidification involves the addition of a fixative agent to a
fluid waste to produce a solid material prior to land disposal. The analysis
assumes that waste fixation occurs 1n open sources such as drums, pug mills,
or pits with agitation or mixing in the unit. The TSDF BID estimates that
approximately 68 percent of the highly volatile compounds such as benzene are
emitted during the solidification process.
Impoundments
Impoundments are used for storage, treatment, and disposal of liquid
wastes and sludges. Some impoundments have a quiescent surface and others may
have turbulent surfaces with emissions increased because of aeration or
mechanical agitation. They may be operated as flow through systems (such as a
storage or treatment impoundment) or as a disposal unit with only flow in
(e.g., an evaporation pond). A range of emission factors was provided in the
TSDF BID for highly volatile compounds in the different types of impoundments
with values for percent emitted of 75 percent for impoundments used for
storage, 52 percent for treatment, 71 percent for aerated units, and 100
percent for disposal units. The estimates for aerated treatment impoundments
reflects that biodegradation occurs. For the other impoundments, the only
removal mechanisms for benzene considered in the model is loss by air
emissions or removal with the effluent from the impoundment. For this
analysis, a midrange value of 76 percent emitted (52 to 100 percent) was used
for the general category of impoundments because data were not available to
differentiate among the different types of impoundments used for benzene waste
operations. For comparison, Commenter IV-D-48 stated that emission and bio-
degradation models developed by their organization predicted that 72.7 percent
of the benzene would be air stripped from a mechanically aerated impoundment
that is biologically active. The value used in this analysis (76 percent
emitted) is an approximate midrange value. For any given impoundment, actual
emissions may be higher or lower depending on residence time, extent of
aeration, biodegradation, surface area, and other site-specific factors.
C-5
-------
Land Treatment
Land treatment Is a land disposal process that involves spreading the
waste over the ground's surface or injecting/mixing the waste below the
surface. For surface application, the TSDF BID estimates that essentially all
(100 percent) of the highly volatile compounds such as benzene will be
emitted. For subsurface injection, biodegradation is included as a removal
mechanism and approximately 85 percent of the benzene is estimated to be
emitted. For this analysis, a midrange value of 93 percent (85 to 100
percent) was used for this source.
Landfills
Landfills are land disposal units that are generally divided into cells,
which are filled separately, then covered and closed before starting a new
cell. The TSDF BID estimates that the percent emitted for volatile compounds
such as benzene ranges from 0.9 percent for covered and closed landfill cells
to 22 percent for active landfill cells with a midrange value of 11 percent.
This analysis assumes that currently these wastes are solidified prior to
placement in a landfill. Consequently, an estimate of 72 percent emitted was
derived for wastes containing benzene that are landfilled based on the loss of
68 percent during solidification and the loss of 11 percent of the balance in
the landfill.
Fraction emitted = 0.68 + (0.11) x (0.32) = 0.72
Incineration
For waste incineration, a value of 0.01 percent emitted from the TSDF BID
was used. This is based on a required destruction and removal efficiency of
99.99 percent of the principal organic hazardous constituents during hazardous
waste incineration.
Tanks
The waste management unit for some waste streams was identified as
storage or treatment in tanks. An estimate of emissions was derived for
benzene wastes in tanks that is separate from the more extensive treatment
common in wastewater treatment tanks. The approach for covered tanks assumes
that emissions occur primarily from working losses (displacement of vapor from
the tank when waste is pumped in) and that the vapor displacement rate is
C-6
-------
equal to the waste pumping rate. The equations for tank emissions given in
the air emission model report for working (loading) losses were used. For
benzene in organic wastes, the tanks are assumed to be covered with a
residence time that is typically 10 days or more (the turnover factor in the
tank equation equals 1). The vapor phase concentration of benzene in the
tank's headspace was estimated using Raoult's law, a pure component vapor
pressure of 95 mm Hg for benzene, an average molecular weight of 100 for the
waste, and a waste density of 0.8 g/cm (for an organic liquid). The
resulting estimate for benzene dissolved in similar organics when loaded into
a covered tank is 0.065 percent emitted.
Aqueous wastes containing benzene were assumed to be handled in both open
and covered tanks. For open tanks with a residence time of a few hours, the
TSDF BID estimates that approximately 11 percent of highly volatile compound
such as benzene would be emitted. For covered tanks, the tank equations in
the emission model report were used and resulted in a range of 3.2 percent
(for a residence time of 3 hours with the turnover factor equal to 0.18) to 18
percent (for a residence time greater than 10 days and the turnover factor
equal to 1). The midrange value is 11 percent emitted, which was used for
benzene in aqueous wastes placed in covered tanks (with a range of residence
times) and open tanks (with residence times of a few hours). For special
cases in which the tank is aerated or the waste stays in an open tank for
days, the percent emitted would be higher than 11 percent.
The large difference in the percent emitted for benzene in aqueous wastes
compared to organic wastes results from the estimated vapor phase concen-
tration of benzene in the tank's headspace. For a given benzene concentration
in the waste, Raoult's law yields much lower vapor phase concentrations than
those obtained by Henry's law. For aqueous waste containing benzene at about
1,800 ppm (solubility of benzene in water), the vapor phase concentration
above the aqueous waste is estimated to be the same as if pure benzene were in
the tank.
Truck loading
Emissions occur from the displacement of vapors during truck loading and
from spills. The TSDF BID provides an estimate of 0.13 percent emitted for
organic liquids and 0.14 percent for aqueous liquids that contain highly
volatile compounds such as benzene.
C-7
-------
Waste Piles
The TSDF BID estimates that 1.25 percent of highly volatile compounds
such as benzene is emitted from solidified waste that 1s accumulated, stored,
or disposed of in waste piles. An Inherent assumption is that the waste 1s
solidified prior to placement in a waste pile. For this analysis, the
sequence of solidification and placement 1n a waste pile yields an estimate of
68 percent emitted.
Fraction emitted = 0.68 + (0.0125) x (0.32) = 0.68
Fi1tration/Dewateri ng
Filtration/dewatering processes are designed to remove solids, usually as
a sludge, and to produce a liquid waste with low solids content. For the
dewatering of aqueous wastes, the data base did not provide information on the
amount of sludge and wastewater produced. For this analysis, 20 percent of
the waste was assumed to be sludge and 80 percent water. The overall fraction
emitted for dewatering aqueous wastes was estimated from:
fe
dewatering device (treat as a tank) 0.11
sludge (containers) (1-0.11)(0.2)(0.0014) = 0.00025
water layer (wastewater treatment) (1-0.11)(0.8)(0.73) = 0.52
Total =0.63
Similar assumptions were required for filtration or solids removal from
organic wastes. For this case, the waste was assumed to be 20 percent sludge
and 80 percent organic liquid, both of which are loaded into containers. The
overall fraction emitted is estimated from:
fe
filtration (tank) 0.00065
sludge (containers) (0.2)0.0014 = 0.00028
organic liquid (containers) (0.8)0.0014 = 0.00112
Total = 0.0021
Estimates for Processing Sequences
Example calculations for the processing sequences used in this analysis
are given in Table C-3 and the results are summarized 1n Table B-l.
C-8
-------
TABLE C-3. CALCULATIONS FOR PROCESSING SEQUENCES*
2. Containers, landfill
fe = 0.0014 + (1-0.0014) (0.72) = 0.72
3. Containers, tanks
organic: fe = 0.0014 + (1-0.0014)(0.00065) = 0.002
aqueous: fe = 0.0014 + (1-0.0014)(0.11) = 0.11
4. Containers, Incineration
fe = 0.0014 + (-0.0014)(0.0001) = 0.0015
7. Impoundment, wastewater treatment
fe = 0.76 = (1-0.76)) 0.73) = 0.94
14. Tanks, dewater
organic: fe = 0.00065 + (1-0.00065)(0.002) = 0.003
aqueous: fe = 0.11 + (1-0.11)(0.63) = 0.67
15. Tanks, impoundment, wastewater treatment
organic: fe = 0.76 = (1-0.76) 0.73 = 0.<
aqueous: fe = 0.79 + (1-0.79) 0.73 = 0.<
16. Tanks, Impoundment, solidification, land treatment,landfill
.94
.94
Assume that the waste 1s 80 percent water (to wastewater treatment) and 20
percent sludge. Assume 10 percent 1s solidified and landfllled and 10 percent
1s land treated.
fe
Tanks 0.11
Impoundment (l-.ll) 0.76 = 0.68
Water (wastewater treatment) 0.8 (1-0.79) 0.73 = 0.12
Solidify, landfill 0.1 (1-0.79) 0.72 = 0.01
Land treatment 0.1 (1-0.79) 0.93 = 0.02
TOTAL =0.94
17. Tanks. Incineration
organic: fe = 0.00065 + (1-0.00065) 0.0001 = 0.00075
aqueous: fe = 0.11 + (1-0.11) 0.0001 = 0.11
C-9
-------
TABLE C-3. (cont'd)
18. Tanks, landfill
organic: fe = 0.0065 + (1-0.00065) 0.73 = 0.72
aqueous: fe = 0.11 + (1-0.11) 0.72 = 0.75
19. Tanks, solidification. Incineration
organic: fe = 0.00065 + (1-0.00065) 0.68 + (1-0.001) 0.0001 = 0.68
aqueous: fe = 0.11 + (1-0.11) 0.68 + (1-0.18) 0.0001 = 0.72
20. Tanks, solidification, landfill
organic: fe = 0.00065 + (1-0.00065) 0.72 = 0.72
aqueous: fe = 0.11 + (1-0.11) 0.72 = 0.75
21. Tanks, solidify, wastepile
organic: fe = 0.00065 + (1-0.00065) 0.68 = 0.68
aqueous: fe = 0.11 + (1-0.11) 0.68 = 0.72
22. Tanks, wastewater treatment
fe = 0.11 + (1-0.11) 0.73 = 0.76
23. Part 1 - Tanks, wastewater treatment, Impoundment
fe = 0.11 + (1-0.11) 0.73 + (0.73) (0.76) = 0.97
23. Part 2 - (Tanks, wastewater treatment, impoundment) solidification,
landfill
fe = 0.97 + (1-0.97) 0.72 = 0.99
24. Tanks, wastewater treatment, incineration
Use 0.76 from above.
25. Tanks, wastewater treatment, solidification
fe = 0.11 + (1-0.11) 0.73 +(1-0.73) 0.68 = 0.92
27- Wastewater treatment, landfill
fe = 0.73 + (1-0.73) 0.72 = 0.92
*Ca1cu1ations are presented for those processing sequences in Table B-l.
C-10
-------
Controls and Efficiency
The control techniques evaluated Included those that are used to treat
the waste to remove or destroy benzene and other volatile organlcs before the
wastes are placed 1n open or aerated sources (such as Impoundments, open
wastewater treatment tanks, land treatment). Applicable and generally
available treatment technologies include steam stripping for wastewater, thin-
film evaporation for sludges, and waste Incineration or recovery of fuel value
for organic liquids. Emission controls were also evaluated for other waste
management operations that might be used. For example, if storage or other
treatment (pH adjustment, solids settling) is needed ahead of the primary
treatment device, emission sources associated with the storage or treatment
would need to be controlled for benzene emissions. Controls evaluated for
these processes included covers or enclosures vented to a control device.
For tanks used in benzene waste operations, typical controls include
floating roofs, venting to a carbon adsorber, vapor incineration, or other
onsite vapor control systems. Information presented in the TSDF BID Indicate
that these controls are capable of reducing emissions by at least 95
percent. Submerged fill, indicated in the TSDF BID to reduce emissions by
65 percent, is assumed to be used for loading containers and tank trucks, and
containers are assumed to be kept covered except when waste 1s being added or
removed.
For steam stripping and thin-film evaporation, the control efficiency was
calculated as the difference between the estimated emissions of the treatment
process and the emissions from the treatment sequence that 1t replaces or
precedes. The nationwide impacts analysis was made assuming that wastewater
would be steam stripped, aqueous and organic sludges would be processed 1n a
th1n-f1lm evaporator or Incinerator, and organic liquids would be burned (as
hazardous waste or as fuel).
The fraction of benzene 1n the waste that Is emitted during steam
stripping Is estimated to range from 0.007 to 0.014. This estimate 1s based
on assumptions that the stripper will remove 99.5 to 99.9 percent of the
benzene 1n the waste, and that the condenser will condense 90 to 99 percent of
the benzene 1n the overhead vapors. A storage tank with a 95-percent control
device 1s assumed to be placed ahead of the stripper, a 95-percent vapor
control device 1s used on the primary condenser vent, the organic condensate
C-ll
-------
1s loaded Into drums, and the stripper bottoms (effluent) are assumed to go to
wastewater treatment. The process 1s shown schematically 1n Figure C-l. For
this configuration, the range of the fraction of benzene emitted to the air
from the process Is estimated using the material balance 1n Figure C-l and the
emission factors previously discussed.
Source Fraction emitted (fe)
Storage tank 0.11 x 0.05 = 0.0055
Effluent 0.73 x (0.00089 to 0.00445) = 0.00065 to 0.0032
Condenser 0.00045 to 0.00445
Drum loading (0.0014) x (0.35) x (0.80 to 0.88) = 0.00039 to 0.00043
TOTAL 0.007 to 0.014.
For wastewater treatment with an uncontrolled fraction emitted of 0.73, steam
stripping results 1n an overall control efficiency of 98.1 to 99.3 percent.
For the purpose of estimating nationwide Impacts, an efficiency of 99 percent
was used.
Similar design assumptions were required to estimate the efficiency of a
thin-film evaporator. For this device, the benzene removal efficiency was
assumed to be 99 percent, and the condenser was assumed to remove 90 to 99
percent of the benzene in the vapor. Other sources are assumed to be
controlled as described for the steam stripper. The schematic for this
process 1s given 1n Figure C-2 and the fraction emitted 1s estimated as
fol1ows:
Source Fraction emitted (fe)
Storage tank 0.11 x 0.05 = 0.0055
Bottoms (0.0089) x 0.93 = 0.0083 (assumes land treated)
Condenser 0.0044 to 0.00044
Drum loading 0.00039 to 0.00043
TOTAL 0.015 to 0.019
For land treatment and landfllUng, which have estimated uncontrolled
fractions emitted of 0.93 and 0.72, respectively, the calculated control
efficiency was 98.0 to 98.4 and 97.4 to 97.9 percent, respectively. In the
estimates of nationwide Impacts, an average control efficiency of 98 percent
was used.
Waste Incineration is expected to achieve a destruction and removal
efficiency of at least 99 percent, and many Incinerators are required to
achieve 99.99 percent. For this analysis, the fraction emitted for waste
incineration 1s estimated at 0.0001 and is based on a destruction and removal
C-12
-------
0.0055
95% Control
0.111
0.00445 to 0.00045
A
0.00039 to 0.00043
95% Control
0.089 to 0.0089 T
A
Vent
Condenser
Organic condensate
0.80 to 0.88
Vapors
0.89
0.89
Steam stripper
99.5-99.9% removal
Effluent (to WWT)
0.00089 to 0.00445
FIGURE C-l. DISTRIBUTION OF BENZENE EMISSIONS FOR A STEAM STRIPPER
(based on 1 unit of benzene in the waste)
0.0055
1
95% Control
0.11
0.89
0.0044 to 0.00044
A
95% Control
0.088 to 0.0088 Vent
Condenser
Vapors
I O.i
0.00039 to 0.00043
A
Organic condensate
0.79 to 0.87
Thin-film evaporator
99 percent removal
Bottoms (soldify,
landtreat, etc.)
0.0089
FIGURE C-2. DISTRIBUTION OF BENZENE EMISSIONS FOR A TFE (based on 1 unit
of benzene in the waste)
C-13
-------
efficiency of 99.99 percent. (The use of a control efficiency of 99 percent
yielded essentially the same Impacts as 99.99 percent 1n terms of emissions,
maximum risk, and Incidence.) For wastes that are already Incinerated, no
additional controls are included. However, 1f the waste 1s stored 1n
containers or tanks prior to incineration, the containers or tanks would be
controlled as previously discussed.
Fi1trati on/Dewateri ng
The estimate of fraction emitted for filtration/dewatering operations is
based on the assumptions (previously discussed for dewatering) and the
estimated uncontrolled fraction emitted of 0.80. The dewatering device is
treated as a tank, submerged fill is used for containers, and water is steam
stripped:
fe (controlled)
Dewatering device (tank) 0.11 x 0.05 = 0.0055
Sludge (containers) 0.00025 x 0.35 = 0.000088
Water layer (steam strip) 0.063 x 0.01 = 0.0063
TOTAL = 0.012
Percent control =98.1
For the filtration of organics for solids removal, where the uncontrolled
fraction emitted is 0.0021, the fraction emitted is estimated from:
fe (controlled)
Filtration (tank) 0.00065 x 0.05 = 0.000033
Sludge (containers) 0.00028 x 0.35 = 0.0001
Organic liquids (containers) 0.00112 x 0.35 = 0.00039
TOTAL = 0.00052
Percent control = 75
The percent control applied to other specific sources 1s summarized
below:
Percent
Control control Types of sources
Control device for vents 95 enclosed, vented sources (covered
tanks)
Submerged fill 65 container and truck loading
Steam stripping (wastewater) 99 wastewater treatment tanks
Thin-film evaporation
(sludges) 98 land treatment, landfllUng of sludges
Waste Incineration 99.99 disposal or treatment of organic
liquids
C-14
-------
TABLE A-2. ESTIMATED PfASTE QUANTITIES FOR REFINERY WASTEKATERS
PLANT
AMERADA HESS
AJ£RADA-HESS
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO
ANCHOR REF.
ARCO ALASKA
ARCO ALASKA
ARCO PETROLEUM
ASHLAND
ASHLAND
ASHLAND
ATLANTIC REFINING
ATLANTIC RICHFIELD
BARRETT REF.
BELCHER REF.
BERRY PETROLEUM
BIG WEST OIL
BLOOMFIELD REFINING
BP OIL
SPOIL
CALCAS1EU REFINING
CALUMET REF IN ING COM
CANAL REF.
CENEX REF.
CHAMPLIN PETROLEUM C
CHEMOIL
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CIBRO PETROLEUM
CITGO PETROLEUM
.CLARK OIL & REFINING
CLARK OIL & REFINING
COASTAL EAGLE PT.
COASTAL REFINING
COLORADO REF.
CONOCO
CONOCO
CONOCO
CONOCO
CONOCO
CROSS OIL & REFINING
CROWN CENTRAL
CRYSEN REFINING
CRYSTAL REF.
DERBY REFINING COMPA
DERBY REF.
DIAMOND SHAMROCK
"ilAMOND SHAMROCK
EDGINGTON OIL COMPAN
EL PASO REFINING
ERGON REF.
EXXON
MINIMUM WASTE QUANTITIES (Mg/Vr)« MAXIMUM WASTE QUANTITIES (Wg/yr)*
1.2,12 3,4.6,7,8 5 13 1.2.12 3,4.6.7,8 5 13
CITY ST 9.10,11 9.10.11
PURVIS MS 8.3E+04 4.1E+04 1.8E+03 O.OE+00 8.4E+04 4.9E+04 1.8E+03 O.OE+00
PORT READING NJ O.OE+00 7.6E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 7.6E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
SALT LAKE CITY UT 1.1E+05 5.0E+04 2.3E+03 O.OE+00 1.1E+05 6. OE+04 2.3E+03 O.OE+00
CASPER WY 1.1E+05 4.3E+04 2-.-1E+03 O.OE+00- V.1E+05 5.3E+04 2.1E+03 O.OE+00
WHITING IN 9.7E+05 5.3E+05 2.6E+04 3.6E+04 9.7E+05 6.2E+05 2.6E+04 3.6E+04
SAVANNAH GA 7.8E+04 1.6E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 7.8E+04 2.2E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
MANDAN ND 1.6E+05 7.3E+04 3.7E+03 O.OE+00 1.6E+05 8.8E+04 3.7E+03 O.OE+00
TEXAS CITY TX 1.2E+OS 7.1E+05 4.9E+04 1.2E+05 1.2E+06 8.1E+05 4.9E+04 1.2E+05
YORKTOWN VA 1.4E+05 1.3E+05 3.0E+03 O.OE+00 1.4E+05 1.4E+05 3.0E+03 O.OE+00
MCKITTRICK CA 2.8E+04 S.SE+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 2.8E+04 8.0E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
KUPARUK AK 3.3E+04 6.6E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 3.3E+04 9.6E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
PRUOHOE BAY AK 3.9E+04 7.8E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 3.9E+04 1.1E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
FERNDALE *A 4.5E+05 3.0E+05 1.7E+04 O.OE+00 4.SE+05 3.4E+05 1.7E+04 O.OE+00
ASHLAND KY 5.9E+05 2.7E+05 1.6E+04 1.5E+04 5.9E+05 3.2E+05 1.6E+04 T.5E+04
ST. PAUL PARK MN 1.9E+05 7.2E+04 7.2E+03 O.OE+00 1.9E+05 8.9E+04 7.2E+03 O.OE+00
CANTON OH 1.8E+05 7.5E+04 6.1E+03 O.OE+00 1.8E+05 9.1E+04 6.1E+03 O.OE+00
PHILADELPHIA PA 3.5E+05 1.1E+05 1.8E+04 O.OE+00 3.5E+05 1.4E+05 1.8E+04 O.OE+00
CARSON CA 5.9E+05 4.8E+05 1.5E+04 O.OE+00 6.0E+05 5.4E+05 1.5E+04 O.OE+00
THOMAS OK 3.6E+04 7.2E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 3.6E+04 1. OE+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
MOBILE BAY AL 4. OE+04 7.9E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 4.0E+04 1.1E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
STEVENS AK 1.1E+04 2.1E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 1.1E+04 3.1E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
SALT LAKE CITY UT 6.7E+04 2.1E+04 1.5E+03 O.OE+00 6.7E+04 2.7E+04 1.5E+03 O.OE+00
BLOOMFIELD NM 4.7E+04 1.8E+04 8.5E+02 O.OE+00 4.7E+04 2.2E+04 8.5E+02 O.OE+00
BELLE CHASSE LA 5.4E+05 3.4E+05 1.1E+04 8.4E+04 5.4E+05 3.9E+05 1.1E+04 8.4E+04
MARCUS HOOK PA 4.7E+05 1.7E+05 1.5E+04 O.OE+00 4.8E+05 2.1E+OS 1.5E+04 O.OE+00
LAKE CHARLES LA 3.3E+04 6.6E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 3.3E+04 9.6E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
PRINCETON LA 1.1E+04 2.3E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 1.1E+04 3.3E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
CHURCH POINT LA 2.7E+04 5.SE+03 S.8E+02 O.OE+00 2.8E+04 7.9E+03 5.8E+02 O.OE+00
LAUREL MT 1.1E+05 4.1E+04 3.7E+03 O.OE+00 1.1E+05 5.1E+04 3.7E+03 O.OE+00
CORPUS CHRIST 1 TX 4.2E+05 3.3E+05 1.6E+04 1.4E+04 4.2E+05 3.7E+05 1.6E+04 1.4E+04
SIGNAL HILL CA 4. OE+04 8.0E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 4.0E+04 1.2E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
PASCAGOULA MS 8.2E+05 5.1E+05 2.7E+04 1.5E+04 8.2E+05 5.9E+05 2.7E+04 1.5E+04
EL SEGUNDO CA 9.1E+05 2.7E+05 1.8E+04 4.2E+03 9.2E+05 3.6E+05 1.8E+04 4.2E+03
PORTLAND OR 4.2E+04 8.3E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 4.2E+04 1.2E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
HONOLULU HI 1.3E+05 6. OE+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 1.3E+05 7.2E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
PORT ARTHUR TX 9.1E+05 5.0E+05 2.0E+04 2.8E+04 9.2E+05 5.8E+05 2.0E+04 2.8E+04
KENAI AK 6.1E+04 1.2E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 6.1E+04 1.8E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
PERTH AMBOY NJ 2.2E+05 4.4E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 2.2E+05 6.4E+04 Q.OE+00 O.OE+OQ
SALT LAKE CITY UT 1.2E+05 8.9E+04 1.7E+03 O.OE+00 1.3E+05 1.0E+05 1.7E+03 O.OE+00
EL PASO TX 1.8E+05 7. OE+04 7.6E+03 O.OE+00 1.8E+05 8.6E+04 7.6E+03 O.OE+00
SEATTLE WA 1.4E+04 2.8E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 1.4E+04 4.0E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
RICHMOND CA 7.5E+05 2.5E+05 2.1E+04 O.OE+00 7.5E+05 3.1E+05 2.1E+04 O.OE+00
PHILADELPHIA PA 4.8E+05 1.8E+05 1.0E+04 1.5E+04 4.8E+05 2.2E+05 1 .OE+04 1.5E+04
ALBANY NY 1.2E+05 2.4E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 1.2E+05 3.4E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
LAKE CHARLES LA 8.9E+05 6.8E+05 2.8E+04 O.OE+00 8.9E+05 7.6E+05 2.8E+04 O.OE+00
BLUE ISLAND IL 1.8E+05 7.4E+04 9.3E+03 O.OE+00 1.8E+05 9.0E+04 9.3E+03 O.OE+00
HARTFORD IL 1.7E+05 1.4E+05 3.7E+03 O.OE+00 1.7E+05 1.5E+05 3.7E+03 O.OE+00
WESTVILLE NJ 3.0E+05 1.4E+05 1.2E+04 4.4E+04 3.0E+05 1.7E+05 1.2E+04 4.4E+04
CORPUS CHRIST 1 TX 2.5E+05 1.3E+05 8.7E+03 5. OE+04 2.5E+05 1.6E+05 8.7E+03 5.0E+04
COMMERCE CITY CO 7.8E+04 2.8E+04 2.7E+03 O.OE+00 7.8E+04 3.5E+04 2.7E+03 O.OE+00
COMMERCE CITY CO 1.2E+05 4.7E+04 2.3E+03 O.OE+00 1.2E+05 5.8E+04 2.3E+03 O.OE+00
PONCACITY OK 3.8E+05 2.3E+05 1.1E+04 O.OE+00 3.8E+05 2.7E+05 1.1E+04 O.OE+00
BILLINGS MT 1.3E+05 5. OE+04 3.8E+03 O.OE+00 1.4E+05 6.3E+04 3.8E+03 O.OE+00
SANTA MARIA CA 2.6E+04 5.3E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 2.6E+04 7.6E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
WESTLAKE LA 4.3E+05 3.7E+05 8.3E+03 O.OE+00 4.4E+05 4.1E+05 8.3E+03 O.OEtOO
SMACKOVER AR 1.9E+04 3.8E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 1.9E+04 5.5E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
HOUSTON TX 2.8E+05 1.9E+05 1.1E+04 1.1E+04 2.8E+05 2.2E+05 1.1E+04 1.1E+04
WOODS CROSS UT 3.5E+04 6.9E+03 9.1E+02 O.OE+00 3.5E+04 1. OE+04 9.1E+02 O.OE+00
CARSON CITY Ml 1.1E+04 2.2E+03 O.OE+00 O.OEtOO 1.1Et04 3.2E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
WICHITA KS 8.3E+04 6.9E+04 2.0E+03 O.OE+00 8.3E+04 7.7E+04 2.0E+03 O.OE+00
ELDORADO KS 7.9E+04 3.8E+04 1.4E+03 O.OE+00 7.9E+04 4.5E+04 1.4E+03 O.OE+00
THREE RIVERS TX 1.4E+05 5.7E+04 3.3E+03 O.OE+00 1.4E+05 6.9E+04 3.3E+03 O.OE+00
SUNRAY TX 2.9E+05 1.3E+05 8.8E+03 O.OE+00 2.9E+05 1.5E+05 8.8E+03 O.OE+00
LONG BEACH CA 1.2E+05 2.3E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 1.2E+05 3.3E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
EL PASO TX 5.8E+04 3.9E+04 1.7E+03 O.OE+00 5.8E+04 4.5E+04 1.7E+03 O.OE+00
VICKSBURG MS 4.7E+04 9.3E+03 O.OE+00 O.OE+00 4.7E+04 1.3E+04 O.OE+00 O.OE+00
BATON ROUGE LA 1.3E+06 8.7E+05 2.7E+04 O.OE+00 1.3E+06 9.9E+05 2.7E+04 O.OE+00
A-4
-------
APPENDIX D: HUMAN EXPOSURE MODEL
-------
D.I: HUMAN EXPOSURE MODEL
Input parameters were provided for risk modeling performed by EPA's
Pollutant Assessment Branch using the Human Exposure Model (HEM). The key
inputs to the risk analysis were: 1} the benzene emissions from each
facility, 2) the emission point parameters (e.g., temperature and height of
release), and 3) the location of each facility. The emission point parameters
used in the risk analysis were the same for all facilities and are shown 1n
Table D-l. Table D-2 lists each facility and the latitude and longitude used
1n the modeling. The major sources of Information for latitude and longitude
included the survey of hazardous waste treatment, storage, disposal and
recycling facilities; the survey of hazardous waste generators; locations used
for modeling 1n the NESHAP for benzene equipment leaks; a data base developed
by EPA's Pollutant Assessment Branch (ATERIS); and the SARA Title 3 data base.
Four modeling runs were made using the HEM. The results for Cases 1 and 2
(Tables D-3 and D-4) represent the baseline and the estimated minimum and
maximum emissions, respectively. Cases 3 and 4 (Tables D-5 and D-6) represent
the controlled case for the estimated minimum and maximum emissions,
respectively. The population exposure estimates for each risk level are
presented for the 4 cases 1n Tables D-7 through D-10.
The estimates presented 1n the following tables should not be viewed as
site-specific risk estimates because site-specific emission data,
meteorological conditions, source configuration, etc. were not available. The
HEM analysis was performed to develop an estimate of risk for the source
category. Consequently, these estimates are not detailed site-specific
estimates for specific facilities. A detailed site-specific analysis could
result in estimates of risk that are higher or lower than those presented
here.
D-l
-------
TABLE D-l. MODELING ASSUMPTIONS USED IN HEM ANALYSIS
Field
Assumption
Urban/Rural
Type
Height
Cross-sectional area
Diameter
Gas exit velocity
Gas exit temperature
Gas flow rate
Urban
Horizontal
3 m
10 m2
0.1 m
0.01 m/s
298K
0.1 m/s
D-2
-------
TABLE D-2. LOCATIONS USED IN HUMAN EXPOSURE MODEL
PLANT
3-M COMPANY
ABBOTT LABORATORIES
ABC COKE
ACME STEEL
AIR PRODUCTS & CHEW.
ALDRICH CHEMICALS
ALLIED CHEMICAL
ALLIED SIGNAL
ALPHA CHEMICAL
ALPHA RESINS
AMCHEM PRODUCTS INC.
AMERADA HESS
AMERADA-HESS
AMERICAN CYANAMID
AMERICAN CYANAMID CO
AMERICAN CYANAMID CO
AMERICAN HOECHST COR
AMERICAN HOECHST COR
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO
AMOCO CHEMICAL
AMOCO CHEMICAL
AMOCO OIL REFINERY
AMOCO OIL REFINERY
ANCHOR REF.
ARCO ALASKA
ARCO ALASKA
ARCO PETROLEUM
ARIS TECH CHEMICAL
ARMCO INC
ARMCO INC.
ASHLAND CHEMICAL
ASHLAND OIL
ASHLAND PETROLEUM
ASHLAND PETROLEUM CO
ATLANTIC REFINING
ATLANTIC RICHFIELD
ATLANTIC RICHFIELD
ATLANTIC RICHFIELD C
ATLANTIC WOOD INDUST
ATLANTIC WOOD INDUST
ATLANTIC WOOD INDUST
AYERST LABS
BARRETT REF.
BASF WYANDOTTE CORP.
BELCHER REF.
BERRY PETROLEUM
BETHLEHEM STEEL
BETHLEHEM STEEL
BETHLEHEM STEEL CORP
BETHLEHEM STEEL CORP
BF GOODRICH
BF GOODRICH CHEMICAL
BIG WEST OIL
BLOOMFIELD REF IN ING
BPOIL
BP OIL
BROWNING MANUF.
CAIN CHEMICAL
CALCASIEU REFINING
CALGON CARBON
CALLEIARES. RECOVER
CALUMET REFINING COM
CANAL REF.
CASMALIA RESOURCES
CITY
COTTAGE GROVE
WICHITA
TARRANT
CHICAGO
WICHITA
MILWAUKEE
IRONTON
BIRMINGHAM
LAKELAND
PERRIS
AMBLER
PURVIS
PORT READING
BRIDGEWATER
HANNIBAL
LINDEN
HOUSTON
PASADENA
CASPER
MANDAN
SAVANNAH
TEXAS CITY
TEXAS CITY
WHITING
SALT LAKE CITY
YORKTOWN
MCKITTRICK
KUPARUK
PRUDHOE BAY
FERNDALE
HAVERHILL
MIDDLETOWN
ASHLAND
BOYD CO.
CANTON
ST. PAUL PARK
ASHLAND
PHILADELPHIA
CARSON
HOUSTON
MONACA
HAINESPORT
PORTSMOUTH
SAVANNAH
ROUSES POINT
THOMAS
JAMESBURG
MOBILE BAY
STEVENS
BURNS HARBOR
LACKAWANNA
BETHLEHEM
SPARROWS POINT
AVON LAKE
CALVERT CITY
SALT LAKE CITY
BLOOMFIELD
BELLE CHASSE
MARCUS HOOK
MORGAN
BRAZORIA
LAKE CHARLES
NEVILLE ISLAM]
BROOKLYN
PRINCETON
CHURCH POINT
CASMALIA
STATE
MN
KS
AL
IL
KS
Wl
OH
AL
FL
CA
PA
MS
NJ
NJ
MO
NJ
TX
TX
WY
ND
GA
TX
TX
IN
UT
VA
CA
AK
AK
WA
OH
OH
KY
KY
OH
MN
KY
PA
CA
TX
PA
NJ
VA
GA
NY
OK
NJ
AL
AK
IN
NY
PA
M3
OH
KY
UT
NM
LA
PA
UT
TX
LA
PA
NY
LA
LA
CA
LATITUDE LONGITUDE
444730 925430
373423 972554
333457 864649
413922 873732
373423 972554
430206 870105
383055 823952
332950 865452
280600 820027
334700 1171400
400900 751300
311120 892414
403500 741500
403328 743313
395110 912545
403551 741216
293610 950115
293747 950413
425027 1062105
464908 1005215
320638 810730
292158 945545
292228 945530
413700 872900
404730 1115410
371245 762645
351500 1193000
680000 1570000
680000 1570000
485430 1224430
383530 824901
392840 842301
382730 823638
382236 823708
404615 812500
445053 930029
382230 823632
395539 751241
334835 1181420
294245 951430
403921 801834
400545 744952
365500 762000
320000 812000
445337 732812
354000 994500
402300 742700
303500 880000
332500 930000
413805 870738
424937 785133
403649 752145
391245 762745
413010 820010
370319 881951
404730 1115410
364727 1074711
294108 895837
394912 752526
410200 1114000
290300 953600
301430 931635
403000 800500
404324 735724
323512 933048
302412 925148
345144 1203234
D-3
-------
TABLE D-2. LOCATIONS USED IN HUMAN EXPOSURE MODEL
PLANT
CECOS
CECOS INT'L
CECOS INT'L
CECOS INT'L
CECOS INT'L
CECOS INT'L
CELANESE CHEMICAL
CELANESE CORP.
CENEX REF.
CHA&PLIN PETROLEUM C
CHATTEM CHEMICALS
CHEMICAL PROCESSORS
CHEMICAL RESOURCES
CHEMOIL
CHEM-CLEAR INC.
CHEM-CLEAR INC.
CHEM-MET SERVICES
CHEM. WASTE MGMT
CHEM. WASTE MGMT.
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CHEVRON
CIBA CORNING
CIBA-GEIGY
CIBRO PETROLEUM
CID-LANDFILL
CITGO PETROLEUM
CITIZENS GAS
CLARK OIL & REFINING
CLARK OIL & REFINING
CLARK OIL & REF.
COASTAL EAGLE PT.
COASTAL REFINING
COLORADO REF.
COMMERCIAL DISPOSAL
CONOCO
CONOCO
CONOCO
CONOCO CHEMICALS
CONOCO REFINERY
COSAN CHEMICAL
COSDEN OIL & CHEMICA
CROSS OIL & REFINING
CROWN CENTRAL
CRYSEN REFINING
CRYSTAL REF.
DELAWARE CONTAINERS
DENKA CHEMICAL CO.
DERBY REFINING COMPA
DERBY REF.
DETROIT COKE
DEVOE & RAYNOLDS
DIAMOND SHAMROCK
DIAMOND SHAMOCK COR
DIAMOND SHAMROCK REF
DOW CHEMICAL
DOW CHEMICAL
DOW CHEMICAL
CITY
STAMFORD
BRISTOL
CINCINNATI
LIVINGSTON
NIAGRA FALLS
WILLIAMSBURG
BISHOP
PAMPA
LAUREL
CORPUS CHRISTI
CHATTANOOGA
SEATTLE
TULSA
SIGNAL HILL
BALTIMORE
CLEVELAND
WYtoCOTTE
EMELLE
CALUMET CITY
EL PASO
EL SEGUNDO
HONOLULU
KENAI
PASCAGOULA
PERTH AMBOY
PHILADELPHIA
PORT ARTHUR
PORTLAM
RICHMOND
SALT LAKE CITY
SEATTLE
MEDFIELD
TOMS RIVER
ALBANY
CALUMET CITY
LAKE CHARLES
INDIANAPOLIS
BLUE ISLAM
BLUE ISLAND
HARTFORD
WESTVILLE
CORPUS CHRISTI
COMMERCE CITY
WEST SPRINGFIEL
COMMERCE CITY
PONCA CITY
SANTA MARIA
WESTLAKE
BILLINGS
CARLSTADT
BIG SPRING
SMACKOVER
HOUSTON
WOODS CROSS
CARSON CITY
COATSVILLE
HOUSTON
WICHITA
EL DORADO
DETRIOT
LOUISVILLE
SUNRAY
DEER PARK
THREE RIVERS
DALTON
LEDYARD
PITTSBURG
STATE
CT
CT
OH
LA
NY
OH
TX
TX
MT
TX
TN
WA
OK
CA
MD
OH
Ml
AL
IL
TX
CA
HI
AK
MS
NJ
PA
TX
OR
CA
UT
WA
MA
NJ
NY
IL
LA
IN
IL
IL
IL
NJ
TX
CO
MA
CO
OK
CA
LA
MT
NJ
TX
AR
TX
UT
Ml
PA
TX
KS
KS
Ml
KY
TX
TX
TX
GA
CT
CA
LATITUDE
414024
414024
391014
302635
430522
390700
273410
353207
453920
274850
350200
473315
360756
334812
391613
412851
421743
324730
414030
314550
335439
211845
604727
301904
403256
395418
295130
453200
375612
404930
473315
421200
395800
424500
414030
301113
394516
413919
413919
385006
395214
274842
394900
420837
394749
364107
345550
301425
454648
405004
321614
332148
294440
405203
431042
395823
294158
374219
374710
421119
381447
355745
294358
282730
343755
412638
380115
LONGITUDE
725700
725700
843030
904314
785822
840300
974910
1005747
1084530
972520
851800
1221918
955634
1181052
763753
814015
831705
881845
873345
1062341
1182441
1580645
1502652
882837
741610
751231
935830
1223700
1222337
1115530
1221918
711900
741200
735000
873345
932021
860649
874207
824707
900542
750920
972644
1045600
723728
1045630
970525
1203036
931638
1082934
740512
1013517
924244
951030
1115440
845054
755054
951545
971902
965200
830916
854549
1015330
950644
981116
845306
720530
1215115
D-4
-------
TABLE D-2. LOCATIONS USED IN HUMAN EXPOSURE MODEL
PLANT
DOW CHEMICAL
DON CHEMICAL USA
DON CORNING
DSM CHEMICALS
DUPONT
DUPONT
DUPONT
DUPONT
E 1 DUPONT DE KEMOUR
EASTMAN KODAK
EASTMAN KODAK, INC.
ECOLOTEC
EDGINGTON OIL COWAN
EL PASO REFINING
EMPIRE COKE COMPANY
ENSCO
ENVIROSAFE SERVICES
ENV. ENTERPRISES
ENV. WASTE RESOURCES
ERGON REF.
ERIE COKE
ERIEWAY POLL. CONTRO
ETHYL CORP.
EXXON
EXXON
EXXON
EXXON CORP
EXXON CORP
E. 1 . DUPONT
FARMLAND FACILITIES
FARMLAND INDUSTRIES
FINA OIL
FINA OIL & CHEMICAL
FIRST CHEMICAL CORP
FLETCHER OIL & REFIN
FMCCORP.
FRONTIER CHEMICAL
FRONTIER OIL
GAF CORP.
GENERAL ELECTRIC
GEORGIA GULF CORP.
GEORGIA-PACIFIC CORP
GEORGIA-PACIFIC CORP
GIANT REFINERY
GLIDDEN COATINGS
GOLDEN NEST REFINING
GOODRICH, (B.F.)
GOODYEAR TIRE
GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBB
GREAT LAKES CHEMICAL
GULF COAST WASTE DIS
GULF STATES
HANSBROUGH ENERGY
HAWAII INDEP. REF.
HEAT ENERGY TECH.
HERCULES
HERCULES
HERITAGE ENV. SERVIC
HILL PETROLEUM
HILL PETROLEUM
HILL PETROLEUM
HILL PETROLEUM
HOWELL HYDROCARBONS
HUNT REFINING
HUNTWAY REF.
HUNTWAY REF.
INDIANA FARM BUREAU
CITY
PLAQUEMINE
FREEPORT
MIDLAND
AUGUSTA
BEAUMONT
DEEPNATER
GIBBSTOWN
LUGOFF
ORANGE
ROCHESTER
LONGVIEW
DAYTON
LONG BEACH
EL PASO
TUSCALOOSA
EL DORADO
OREGON
CINCINNATI
WATERBURY
VICKSBURG
ERIE
BEDFORD
BATON ROUGE
BEN 1C 1 A
BILLINGS
LINDEN
BATON ROUGE
BAYTOWN
PARKERS8URG
PHILLIPSBURG
COFFEYVILLE
BIG SPRING
PORT ARTHUR
PASCAGOULA
WILMINGTON
BALTIMORE
NIAGRA FALLS
CHEYENNE
CALVERT CITY
WATERFORD
PASADENA
PASADENA
PLAQUEMINE
GALLUP
CARROLLTON
SANTA FE SPRING
HENRY
BEAUMONT
LAPORTE
EL DORADO
TEXAS CITY
GADSDEN
CROWLEY
EWA BEACH
DALLAS
GIBBSTOWN
MAGNA
IIOIANAPOLIS
HOUSTON
KROTZ SPRINGS
ST. ROSE
TEXAS CITY
SAN ANTONIO
TUSCALOOSA
BENECIA
WILMINGTON
MT. VERNON
STATE
LA
TX
Ml
GA
TX
NJ
NJ
SC
TX
NY
TX
OH
CA
TX
AL
AR
OH
OH
CT
MS
PA
OH
LA
CA
MT
NJ
LA
TX
WV
KS
KS
TX
TX
MS
CA
M3
NY
WY
KY
NY
TX
TX
LA
NM
TX
CA
IL
TX
TX
AR
TX
AL
LA
HI
TX
NJ
UT
IN
TX
LA
LA
TX
TX
AL
CA
CA
IN
LATITUDE
301950
285917
433608
332135
300112
394158
395025
341305
300324
431200
322617
394603
335230
314615
331500
331219
414000
404014
413306
322100
420843
412230
302032
380430
454900
403818
302914
294450
391612
395005
370300
321611
295730
302057
334824
391853
430534
410730
370251
424825
294323
294323
301530
352541
325500
335400
410750
295833
293900
331000
292615
340046
301100
211845
325244
395020
404000
394501
294139
302500
324830
292342
292051
343758
380430
334800
375630
LONGITUDE
911430
952409
841324
820458
940156
753026
751750
803805
934444
773831
944124
840800
1180930
1062418
873000
923745
832750
833929
730248
905100
800132
813207
911806
1220830
1082545
741340
911017
950104
814009
991849
953615
1012455
935320
882945
1181700
763737
790326
1044730
882448
734200
950918
950918
912139
1084434
965500
1180200
892004
941304
950200
924500
S45935
860238
922500
1580645
965230
751635
1120500
861717
951415
914500
932430
945336
982736
864135
1220830
1181800
875438
D-5
-------
TABLE D-2. LOCATIONS USED IN HUMAN EXPOSURE MODEL
PLANT
INDUSTRIAL WASTE REM
INLAND STEEL
INTERMOUNTAIN REF.
INT'L FLAVORS & FRAG
IT CORPORATION
IT CORPORATION
IT CORP .-PETROL. WAS
KERN OIL & REFINING
KERR MCGEE
KERR-MCGEE CHEM. COR
KERR-MCGEE REFINING
KOCH INDUSTRIES
KOCH INDUSTRIES
KOCH REFINING
KOPPERS
KOPPERS
KOPPERS CO INC
LA GLORIA OIL AND GA
LAKESIDE REF.
LAKETON REFINING
LILLY COATINGS
LILLY IND. COATINGS
LION OIL
LIQUID ENERGY CORP.
LITTLE AMERICA REF.
LOUISIANA LAND & EXP
LTV STEEL
LTV STEEL
LTV STEEL
LTV STEEL COMPANY
LUNDAY-THAGARD CO.
LYONDELL PETROCHEMIC
MALL INCKROOT CHEM.
MALONE SERVICE CO.
MANTUA OIL
MAPCO PETROLEUM
MAPCO PETROLEUM
MARATHON OIL
MARATHON PETROLEUM
MARATHON PETROLEUM
MARATHON PET.
MARISOL INC.
MEAD JOHNSON
MICHIGAN DISPOSAL IN
MIDATLANTIC REF.
MINE SAFETY APPL.
MOBAY CHEMICAL CORP
MOBAY CORP.
MOBIL
MOBIL CHEMICALS
MOBIL OIL
MOBIL OIL
MOBIL OIL
MOBIL OIL
MONSANTO CO
MONSANTO CO
MONSANTO CO
MONSANTO CO
MONSANTO CO
MONSANTO CO
MONTANA REFINING COM
MONTROSE CHEMICAL CO
MURPHY OIL CORPORATI
MURPHY OIL CORPORATI
NATIONAL COOPERATIVE
NATIONAL STEEL
NATIONAL STEEL GROUP
CITY
LEWISBERRY
E CHICAGO
FREDONIA
UNION BEACH
BENECIA
WESTMORELAND
BUTTONWILLOW
BAKERSFIELD
WYNNEWOOD
MERIDIAN
COTTON VALLEY
CORPUS CHRISTI
CORPUS CHRISTI
ROSEMOUNT
HOUSTON
WOODWARD
BRIDGEVILLE
TYLER
KALAMAZOO
LAKETON
MONTEBELLO
DALLAS
EL DORADO
BRIDGEPORT
CASPER
SARALAND
CLEVELAND
S CHICAGO
WARREN
PITTSBURGH
SOUTH GATE
HOUSTON
RALEIGH
TEXAS CITY
THOROFARE
MEMPHIS
NORTH POLE
TEXAS CITY
GARYVILLE
ROBINSON
DETROIT
MIDDLESEX
EVANSVILLE
BELLEVILLE
ST. MARYS
EVANS CITY
NEW MART INS VI
HALEDON
CHALMETTE
BEAUMONT
BEAUMONT
JOLIET
PAULSBORO
TORRANCE
ADDYSTON
ALVIN
ANNISTON
BRIDGEPORT
SAUGET
ST. LOUIS
GREAT FALLS
HENDERSON
MERAUX
SUPERIOR
MCPHERSON
GRANITE CITY
ECORSE
STATE
PA
IN
AZ
KJ
CA
CA
CA
CA
OK
MS
LA
TX
TX
MN
TX
AL
PA
TX
Ml
IN
CA
TX
AR
TX
WY
AL
OH
IL
OH
PA
CA
TX
NC
TX
NJ
TN
AX
TX
LA
IL
Ml
NJ
IN
Ml
WV
PA
WV
NJ
LA
TX
TX
IL
NJ
CA
OH
TX
AL
NJ
IL
MO
MT
NV
LA
Wl
KS
IL
Ml
LATITUDE
401010
414010
365000
402700
380618
330215
352400
352230
343747
322015
324830
275005
275005
444600
294607
332653
402132
322145
421724
405800
340100
324630
331300
331500
425027
304900
412810
414127
411221
402445
340500
294700
355406
291945
394500
350512
643937
292221
300341
390000
421119
403335
380000
421315
392300
405437
395209
405630
295556
300405
300354
412520
395040
335110
390730
291509
333904
394822
383606
383611
473000
360228
295558
464126
382229
384141
421712
LONGITUDE
765017
872640
1123000
741100
1220703
1154412
1192800
1190118
971015
822854
932430
973115
973115
930230
951014
865759
800441
951645
853500
855000
1180700
965415
924000
973800
1062105
880400
813948
873254
804858
795646
1181500
950400
783339
945418
751500
900500
1471629
945447
903601
874332
830916
743112
873300
833114
811230
795452
803958
741101
895819
940334
940420
881120
751618
1181952
844258
951244
855821
752424
901011
901154
1111700
1150040
895621
920408
974024
900747
890624
D-6
-------
TABLE D-2. LOCATIONS USED IN HUMAN EXPOSURE MODEL
PLANT
NAVAJO REFINING
NEPERA CHEMICAL CO.,
NEVADA REF.
NEW BOSTON COKE
NEWHALL REFINING CO.
NIPRO, INC.
NORCHEMCO.
NORCHEM, INC.
OLIN CHEMICALS
OLINCORP.
ORB IS PRODUCTS CORP
ORTHO DIAGNOSTICS
OXNARD REF.
PACIFIC REF.
PARAMOUNT PET.
PARKE-OAVIS
PENNZOIL
PENNZOIL
PENNZOIL COMPANY
PEORIA DISPOSAL CO.
PETRO STAR
PETROCHEM RECYCLING
PHILLIPS
PHILLIPS 66
PHILLIPS 66 REFINERY
PLACID REFINING
POWER INE OIL
PPG INDUSTRIES
PPG INDUSTRIES
PRIDE REFINING
QUAKER STATE OIL REF
QUAKER STATE OIL REF
REICHHOLD CHEMICALS
REICHHOLD CHEMICALS
RE ILLY TAR AND CHEMI
RE ILLY TAR AND CHEMI
RHONE-POULENC.INC.
RMT PROPERTIES
ROCK ISLAND REFINING
ROGERS LANDFILL
ROLLINS ENV. SERVICE
ROLLINS ENV. SERVICE
RUBICON CHEMICALS IN
SAN JOAQUIN REF-
SHARON STEEL
SHELL CHEM CO
SHELL OIL
SHELL OIL
SHELL OIL
SHELL OIL
SHELL OIL
SHELL OIL REFINERY
SHENANGO
SINCLAIR OIL
SINCLAIR OIL
SLOSS INDUSTRIES
SOHIO
SOLVENT RECOV. SERVI
SOMERSET REFINERY
SOUND REF.
SOUTHLAND CORP.
SOUTHLAND OIL
SOUTHLAND OIL
SOUTHWESTERN REFININ
STANDARD CHLORIDE CH
STANDARD OIL OF OHIO
STANDARD OIL OF OHIO
CITY
ARTESIA
HARRIMAN
TONOPAH
PORTSMOUTH
NENHALL
AUGUSTA
CLINTON
MORRIS
AUGUSTA
ST. MARKS
NEWARK
RARITAN
OXNARD
HERCULES
PARAMOUNT
HOLLAND
ROOSEVELT
SHREVEPORT
ROUSEVILLE
PEORIA
NORTH POLE
SALT LAKE CITY
SWEENY
WOODS CROSS
BORGER
PORT ALLEN
SANTA FE SPRING
DELAWARE
NORTON
ABILENE
NEWELL
SMETHPORT
ELIZABETH
GULFPORT
GRANITE CITY
INDIANAPOLIS
MT. PLEASANT
NORTH SALT LAKE
INDIANAPOLIS
CENTREVILLE
BRIDGEPORT
DEER PARK
GEISMAR
BAKERSFIELD
MONESSEN
NORCO
ANACORTES
DEER PARK
MARTINEZ
WILMINGTON
WOOD RIVER
ODESSA
SHENANGO
SINCLAIR
TULSA
BIRMINGHAM
FERMDALE
LINDEN
SOMERSET
TACOMA
GREAT MEADOWS
LUMBERTON
SANDERSVILLE
CORPUS CHRIST!
DELAWARE CITY
LIMA
TOLEDO
STATE
NM
NY
NV
OH
CA
GA
IA
IL
GA
FL
NJ
NJ
CA
CA
CA
Ml
UT
LA
PA
IL
AK
UT
TX
UT
TX
LA
CA
OH
OH
TX
wv
PA
NJ
MS
IL
IN
TN
UT
IN
MS
NJ
TX
LA
CA
PA
LA
WA
TX
CA
CA
IL
TX
PA
WY
OK
AL
WA
NJ
KY
WA
NJ
MS
MS
TX
DE
OH
OH
LATITUDE
325230
411837
380300
384557
342055
332135
414818
412128
332054
301033
404400
403438
341218
375831
335143
424751
401600
322812
412750
404720
643937
404815
290424
405348
354205
302835
335400
401704
410001
322754
403700
414637
403915
302520
384946
394419
351212
405027
395500
310946
394800
294343
301223
352235
400946
295942
483000
294255
380121
334800
385026
314905
402849
414700
360728
333341
484937
403651
370300
471535
405408
310100
314700
274816
393354
404636
414045
LONGITUDE
1041750
740832
1171500
825601
1183025
820458
901745
882542
815624
841325
741000
743905
1191100
1221254
1181045
860652
1100120
934613
794122
894544
1471629
1115500
954510
1115626
1012205
911240
1180200
830545
813701
994248
803730
782812
741305
890100
895420
861306
871220
1115510
861500
911856
752100
950549
910039
1190405
795347
902735
1223304
950733
1220607
1181800
900424
1021920
800334
1070730
955945
864804
1224133
741507
843700
1222409
745226
892800
890200
972524
753847
840627
832645
D-7
-------
TABLE D-2. LOCATIONS USED IN HUMAN EXPOSURE MODEL
PLANT
STAR REF.
STAR REF.
STAR REF.
STAUFFER CHEMICAL
STAUFFER CHEMICAL CO
STEPAN CO.
SUN CO.
SUN PETROLEUM
SUN REFINING
SUNLAND REF.
S.D.S. BIOTECH CORP.
TESARO ALASKA PETROL
TEXACO REFINING
TEXACO REFINING
TEXACO REFINING
TEXACO USA
TEXAS ECOLOGISTS
TOLEDO COKE
TONAHANDA
TOSCO CORP.
TOTAL PETROLEUM
TOTAL PETROLEUM
TOTAL PETROLEUM
TREMCO INC.
TRICIL ENV. SERVICES
TRIFINERY
TROY CHEMICAL CORP.,
UNION CARBIDE.
UNION CARBIDE
UNION CARBIDE CAR 1 BE
UNION CARBIDE CORP
UNION CARBIDE CORP.
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
UNION OIL OF CALIFOR
UNITED REF.
UNOCAL
UP JOHN CO
UP JOHN CO., THE
US ARMY MUNITIONS
US INDUSTRIAL CHEM.
USPCI GRASSY MT.
USS CHEMICAL
USS CHEMICALS
U.S. OIL & REFINING
U.S. STEEL CORP.
U.S. STEEL CORP.
U.S. STEEL CORP.
VALERO ENERGY CORP.
VISTA CHEMICAL
VISTA CHEMICAL
VULCAN MATERIALS
HASTE CONVERSION
HASTE TECH SERVICES
WAYNE DISPOSAL
WHEELING PIH
WITCO CHEMICAL CORPO
WITCO CHEMICAL CORP.
WITCO CORP.
WITCO CORP.
WYOMING REF.
YOUNG REF.
CITY
CONVENT
DELAWARE CITY
PORT ARTHUR
BATON ROUGE
EDISON
ELWOOD
TOLEDO
MARCUS HOOK
TULSA
BAKERSFIELD
HOUSTON
KENAI
BAKERSFIELD
EL DORADO
WILMINGTON
ANACORTES
ROBSTOWN
TOLEDO
TONAWANDA
MARTINEZ
ALMA
ARDMORE
ARKANSAS CITY
BARBOURVILLE
MUSKEGON HEIGHT
CORPUS CHRISTI
NEWARK
PENUELAS
SEADRIFT
PONCE
TEXAS CITY
HAHNVILLE
LEMONT
NEDERLAND
RODEO
WILMINGTON
WARREN
LOS ANGELES
LA PORTE
NORTH HAVEN
KINGSTON
TUSCOLA
KNOWLES
IRONTON
FLORENCE
TACOMA
CLAIRTON
GARY
PROVO
CORPUS CHRISTI
BALTIMORE
WESTLAKE
WICHITA
HATFIELD
GOLDEN
BELLEVILLE
E STEUBENVILLE
POINT COMFORT
BRADFORD
OILDALE
OILDALE
NEWCASTLE
DOUGLASVILLE
STATE
LA
DE
TX
LA
NJ
IL
OH
PA
OK
CA
TX
AK
CA
KS
CA
WA
TX
OH
NY
CA
Ml
OK
KS
KY
Ml
TX
NJ
PR
TX
PR
TX
LA
IL
TX
CA
CA
PA
CA
TX
CT
TN
IL
UT
OH
KY
WA
PA
IN
UT
TX
MD
LA
KS
PA
CO
Ml
WV
TX
PA
CA
CA
WY
GA
LATITUDE
300632
393515
295301
303034
403100
412630
413652
394845
360825
352235
294130
604727
352235
374710
334730
483034
274700
414010
425856
380121
432244
341220
370242
364500
431300
274816
404400
180000
283038
180000
292227
295642
414020
300000
380300
334630
415000
340400
294236
412230
363158
394755
404908
383530
385838
471535
401825
413701
401802
274900
391138
301520
373500
401730
394742
421330
402036
283900
415748
352505
352505
435047
334500
LONGITUDE
905402
753745
935752
911110
742500
881700
833140
752451
960115
1190405
951000
1502652
1190405
965200
1181408
1223437
974000
832931
785619
1220607
843730
970500
970042
834000
861800
972524
741000
664425
964659
664425
945633
902923
880010
935845
1221530
1181730
791500
1181500
950450
725230
823746
882100
1131233
824901
843715
1222409
795230
872000
1114428
972930
763249
931631
972501
751709
1050351
833100
803625
963400
783742
1190035
1190035
1041249
844500
D-8
-------
TABLE D-3. HEM RESULTS FOR CASE 1 (BASELINE MINIMUM)
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
SIC-
CAS«
Page 1 of 9
-Ha
Cone
1.68E+02
1.54E+02
1.30E+02
9.96E+01
7.14E+01
6.13E+01
5.42E+01
5.28E+01
3.43E-I-01
3.22E+01
2.97E+01
2.91E+01
2.86E+01
2.46E+01
2.14E+01
2.00E+01
1.95E+01
1.93E+01
1.89E+01
1.87E-(-OX
1.82E+01
1.75E+01
1.60E+01
1.59E+01
1.57E-I-01
1.41E+01
1.41E+01
1.40E+01
1.40E+01
1.33E+01
1.20E+01
1.17E+01
1.15E+01
1.14E+01
1.13E+01
1.12E+01
1.10E+01
1.10E+01
1.10E+01
1.09E+01
1.08E+01
1.04E+01
1.04E+01
1.02E+01
9.75E+00
x i •
People
a
1
6
1
<1
3
16
3
<1
1
<1
1
<1
<1
<1
18
<1
<1
2
a
i
11
i
10
4
a
54
1
<1
1
97
<1
1
<1
111
<1
1
2
17
4
4
2
<1
1
1
u m -
Exposure
3.58E4-01
1.56E+02
7.92E+02
8.20E+01
2.B5E+01
2.11E-I-02
9.56E+02
1.35E+02
1.77E+00
4.63E+01
4.42E-01
1.64E+01
1.35E+01
1.18E+00
8.84E-01
3.57E-I-02
2.99E+00
3.85E+00
4.00E+01
3.73E+00
1.23E+01
1.96E+02
1.48E+01
1.58E+02
6.31E+01
1.46E4-00
7.66E+02
1.75Et01
6.24E+00
1.46E+01
1.16E+03
4.05E+00
1.12E+01
5.40E-01
1.25E+03
1.43E-fOO
1.01E+01
1.66E+01
1.82Ef02
4.09E1-01
4.21E+01
l.SlE^Oi
1.16E+00
6.53E*-0;
1.1 -;£"'.• i
--Minim
Lifetime
Incidence
2.97E-04
1.30E-03
6.58E-03
S.80E-04
2.37E-04
1.75E-03
7.93E-03
1.12E-03
1.47E-05
3.84E-04
3.67E-06
1.36E-04
1.12E-04
9.83E-06
7.33E-06
2.96E-03
2.48E-05
3.20E-05
3.32E-04
3.10E-05
1.02E-04
1.63E-03
1.23E-04
1.31E-03
S.24E-04
1.21E-OS
6.36E-03
1.45E-04
5.18E-05
1.21E-04
9.63E-03
3.36E-05
3.32E-05
4.48E-06
1.04E-02
1.19E-05
8.34E-05
1.38E-04
1.51E-03
3.39E-04
3.49E-04
1.50E-04
9.64E-06
S.42E-OS
3.45E-05
Max Risk
1.39E-03
1.28E-03
1.08E-03
8.27E-04
S.93E-04
S.09E-04
4.50E-04
4.3BE-04
2.84E-04
2.67E-04
2.47E-04
2.41E-04
2.37E-04
2.04E-04
1.77E-04
1.66E-04
1.62E-04
1.60E-04
1.57E-04
1.55E-04
1.51E-04
1.45E-04
1.33E-04
1.32E-04
1.30E-04
1.17E-04
1.17E-04
1.17E-04
1.16E-04
1.10E-04
9.96E-05
9.70E-05
9.S3E-05
9.43E-05
9.3BE-05
9.32E-05
9.12E-05
9.11E-05
9.09E-05
9.08E-OS
8.98E-05
8.66E-05
8.62E-05
8.44E-05
8.09E-OS
Cone
5.86E-03
2.65E-03
2.33E-03
2.39E-03
1.84E-03
2.22E-03
2.25E-03
3.44E-04
1.35E-03
1.88E-03
1.42E-03
8.67E-04
9.00E-04
4.84E-04
6.28E-04
7.16E-04
4.11E-04
1.77E-04
5.71E-04
7.95E-04
6.33E-04
4.55E-04
5.36E-04
5.47E-04
3.10E-04
9.48E-OS
1.93E-04
3.67E-04
8.14E-05
8.41E-05
4.04E-04
4.19E-04
2.70E-04
4.66E-04
1.82E-04
6.41E-04
2.20E-04
3.22E-04
2.94E-04
2.69E-04
1.78E-04
4.03E-04
4.08E-04
3.14E-04
4.39E-04
People
382,000
361,000
327,000
392,000
857,000
4,750,000
52,700
893,000
1,220,000
707,000
3,380,000
772,000
695,000
2,590,000
346,000
556,000
4,900,000
125,000
3,070,000
1,140,000
397,000
7,970,000
228,000
5,420,000
8,320,000
339,000
1,940,000
313,000
364,000
344,000
333,000
377,000
1,270,000
2,060,000
8,090,000
1,190,000
2,670,000
399,000
a, 460, 000
2,920,000
8,070,000
720,000
359,000
1,270,000
159,000
u m — -
Exposure
4.07E+04
1.06E+04
1.17E+05
1.70E+04
9.52E+03
6.06E+04
3.40E-I-04
1.36E-1-04
1.02E+04
2.10E+04
2.66E+04
1.37E+04
1.11E-I-04
1.75E+04
1.46E+03
2.15E+04
1.98E+04
3.82E4-02
1.69E+04
5.43E+03
6.30E+03
3.97E+04
2.36E+03
3.48E+04
3.98E+04
6.25E+03
2.08E+04
1.52E+03
1.67E+03
4.26E+03
1.35E+04
3.25E+03
3.51E+03
6.95E+03
3.78E+04
2.23E+04
9.45E+03
1.85E+03
2.78E4-04
7.74E+03
2.38E4-04
2.00E+03
2.57E+03
2.39E-I-03
2.27E+03
Annual
Incidence
0.0048
0.0013
0.014
0.0020
0.0011
0.0072
0.0040
0.0016
0.0012
0.0025
0.0032
0.0016
0.0013
0.0021
0.0002
0.0026
0.0023
<0.0001
0.0020
0.0006
0.0007
0.0047
0.0003
0.0041
0.0047
0.0007
0.0025
0.0002
0.0002
0.0005
0.0016
0.0004
0.0004
0.0008
0.0045
0.0026
0.0011
0.0002
0.0033
0.0009
0.0028
0.0002
0.0003
0.0003
0.0003
Repeat
Interval
210.
790.
72.
500.
890.
140.
250.
620.
830.
400.
320.
620.
760.
480.
5,800.
390.
430.
22,000.
500.
1,600.
1,300.
210.
3,600.
240.
210.
1,400.
400.
5,600.
5,000.
2,000.
620.
2,600.
2,400.
1,200.
220.
380.
890.
4,600.
300.
1,100.
350.
4,200.
3,300.
3,500.
3,700.
352 ASHLAND CHEMICAL BO7D
132 MOBAt CHEMICAL CORP NEW M
7 WITCO CORP. OILDA
108 DUPONT BEAUH
121 MONSANTO CO ALVIN
394 WASTE CONVERSION HATFI
103 CELANESE CORP. PAMPA
92 UNION CARBIDE CARIBE PONCE
10 STANDARD CHLORIDE CH DELAW
47 PARKE-DAVIS HOLLA
388 MICHIGAN DISPOSAL IN BELLE
124 UNION CARBIDE CORP TEXAS
266 AMOCO TEXAS
290 SHELL OIL DEER
355 HANSBROUGH ENERGY CTOWL
209 EXXON CORF BATON
58 BASF W7ANDOTTE CORP. JAMES
304 ARCO PETROLEUM FERND
150 CHEVRON RICHM
218 BP OIL BELLE
286 MOBIL OIL BEAUM
149 CHEVRON EL SE
207 CITGO PETROLEUM LAKE
190 AMOCO CHEMICAL WHITI
72 STAUFFER CHEMICAL CO EDISO
267 CRAMPLIN PETROLEUM C CORFU
381 CECOS STAMP
51 FIRST CHEMICAL CORP PASCA
281 KOCH INDUSTRIES CORFU
270 COASTAL REFINING CORFU
247 STANDARD OIL OF OHIO LIMA
201 ASHLAND PETROLEUM CO ASHLA
71 SOUTHLAND CORP. GREAT
188 SHELL OIL WOOD
169 SHELL OIL WILHI
214 MOBIL CHALM
271 CROWN CENTRAL HOUST
109 E I DUPONT DE NEMOUR ORANG
161 MOBIL OIL TORRA
176 UNION OIL OF CALIFOR RODEO
172 TEXACO REFINING WILMI
213 MARATHON PETROLEUM GARYV
293 STAR REF. PORT
217 SHELL CHEM CO NORCO
186 MARATHON PETROLEUM ROBIN
-------
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maximua-
Lifetime
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
TABLE D-3. (continued)
SIC»
CAS"
Mininu»
Cone People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 2 of 9
9.61E+00
9.46E+00
9.27E+00
9.12E+00
8.55E+00
8.22E+00
8.09E+00
7.87E+00
7.63E+00
7.43E+00
7.36E+00
7.19E+00
7.08E+00
7.04E+00
6.84E+00
6.22E+00
6.07E4-00
5.86E+00
5.83E+00
5.68E+00
5.55E+00
5.48E+00
4.40E+00
4.37E-t-00
4.18E-MJO
3.95E-f-00
3.84E+00
3.81E+00
3.80E+00
3.79E+00
3.69E+00
3.59E+00
3.56E+00
3.49E+00
3.49E+00
3.46E+00
3.35E+00
3.28E+00
3.24E+00
3.1SE+00
3.15E+00
2.97E+00
2.90E+00
2.88E+00
2.84E+00
207
1
46
1
<1
33
1
13
<1
2
<1
9
2
21
<1
18
6
44
27
<1
1
<1
<1
18
<1
1
3
<1
<1
<1
<1
21
1
89
1
13
4
5
1
<1
<1
1
<1
<1
112
1.99E+03
7.90E+00
4.25E+02
8.34E+00
4.91E-02
2.68E+02
4.52E+00
9.90E+01
9.01E-01
1.68E+01
8.75E-01
6.33E+01
1.63E+01
l.SOE-t-02
1.12E-01
1.09E+02
3.45EH-01
2.59E+02
1.58E+02
3.89E-01
8.10E+00
2.26E+00
7.95E-02
7.66E+01
1.01E-01
3.20E+00
1.12E+01
1.28E-I-00
6.70E-02
9.56E-02
1.16E+00
7.62E-1-01
3.81E+00
3.11E+02
3.01E+00
4.56E+01
1.36E+01
1.75E+01
3.93E+00
6.40E-01
5.66E-01
3.24E+'3G
5.05E-01
1.25E-H30
3.18E-': J
1.65E-02
6.56E-05
3.53E-03
6.93E-05
4.0BE-07
2.23E-03
3.75E-05
8.22E-04
7.48E-06
1.39E-04
7.26E-06
5.26E-04
1.35E-04
1.24E-03
9.31E-07
9.08E-04
2.86E-04
2.15E-03
1.31E-03
3.23E-06
6.72E-05
1.B8E-05
6.60E-07
6.36E-04
8 .37E-07
2 .66E-05
9.27E-05
1.06E-05
5.56E-07
7.94E-07
9.61E-06
6.32E-04
3.16E-05
2.58E-03
2.50E-05
3.78E-04
1.13E-04
1.45E-04
3.26E-05
5.31E-06
J.70E-06
J.69E-05
4.19E-06
1.04E-05
3.64E-03
7.97E-05
7.85E-05
7.69E-05
7.57E-05
7.10E-OS
6.83E-05
6.72E-05
6.53E-05
6.33E-OS
6.17E-05
6.11E-05
5.97E-05
5.87E-05
5.85E-05
5.68E-05
5.16E-05
5.04E-05
.86E-05
. 84E-05
.71E-05
.60E-05
.55E-05
3.65E-05
3.63E-05
3.47E-05
3.28E-05
3.19E-05
3.16E-05
3.16E-05
3.15E-05
3.06E-05
2.98E-05
2.95E-OS
2.90E-05
2.90E-OS
2.87E-05
2.78E-05
2.72E-05
2.69E-05
2.63E-05
2.61E-05
2.46E-05
2.41E-OS
2.39E-05
2.36E-05
2.73E-04
7.50E-05
6.12E-05
2.52E-04
S.24E-05
4.02E-04
2.34E-04
3.10E-04
2.67E-04
3.24E-04
2.60E-04
1.02E-04
2.17E-04
2.76E-04
2.68E-04
2.19E-04
1.04E-04
2.28E-04
2.24E-04
1.10E-04
2.67E-04
4.27E-05
4.03E-05
2.62E-04
7.75E-05
5.88E-04
5.65E-05
4.36E-OS
9.87E-05
1.30E-04
1.53E-04
2.09E-05
4.80E-05
1.14E-04
2.94E-OS
1.26E-04
3.05E-05
1.16E-04
6.31E-05
1.38E-03
6.02E-05
1.32E-04
3.70E-05
1.10E-04
8.87E-04
8,640,000
228,000
338,000
171,000
230,000
817,000
388,000
4,840,000
1,510,000
826,000
1,900,000
12,700,000
225,000
4,450,000
1,400,000
6,550,000
7,880,000
4,900,000
4,440,000
3,080,000
838,000
151,000
249,000
1,190,000
379,000
2,450,000
134,000
17,500
763,000
137,000
4,830,000
382,000
3,220,000
2,680,000
259,000
697,000
88,000
6,360,000
325,000
2,560,000
192,000
55,300
1,760,000
38,900
2,030,000
5.84E+04
4.34E+02
9.11E+03
4.39E-f02
2.92E+02
1.15E+04
2.17E+03
2.32E+04
2.35E+03
5.39E+03
3.67E-t-03
2.93E+04
1.92E+03
1.37E+04
2.53E+03
1.16E+04
1.15E+04
3.79E+-04
1.38E+04
2.97E-I-03
2.78E+03
1.61E+02
4.89E+02
8.54E+03
4.21E+02
1.38E+04
7.13E+02
4.13E+01
6.24E+02
7.05E+02
7.56E-I-03
1.45E+03
1.62E+03
7.18E+03
8.18E+02
2.20E+03
3.55E-I-02
1.14E+04
1.79E+03
3.49E+04
2.15E+02
2.57E+02
l.lSE-f-03
9.73E-I-01
1.94E+04
0.0069 140.
0.0001 19,000.
0.0011 930.
0.0001 19,000.
<0.0001 29,000.
0.0014 730.
0.0003 3,900.
0.0028 360.
0.0003 3,600.
0.0006 1,600.
0.0004 2,300.
0.0035 290.
0.0002 4,400.
0.0016 620.
0.0003 3,300.
0.0014 730.
0.0014 730.
0.0045 220.
0.0016 610.
0.0004 2,800.
0.0003 3,000.
<0.0001 52,000.
0.0001 17,000.
0.0010 990.
0.0001 20,000.
0.0016 610.
0.0001 12,000.
<0. 0001200, 000.
0.0001 14,000.
0.0001 12,000.
0.0009 1,100.
0.0002 5,800.
0.0002 5,200.
0.0009 1,200.
0.0001 10,000.
0.0003 3,800.
<0.0001 24,000.
0.0013 740.
0.0002 4,700.
0.0041 240.
<0.0001 39,000.
<0.0001 33,000.
0.0001 7,300.
<0.0001 87,000.
0.0023 430.
175 UNOCAL LOS A
309 TEXACO USA AHACO
292 SOUTHWESTERN KEFININ CORFU
288 PHILLIPS SWEEN
306 SHELL OIL ANACO
249 SUN CO. TOLED
295 UNION OIL OP CALIFOR WEDER
237 COASTAL EAGLE PT. WESTV
187 MOBIL OIL JOLIE
354 ENVIROSAFE SERVICES OREGO
224 KOCH REFINING ROSEM
238 EXXON LXNDE
208 CONOCO CHEMICALS WESTL
263 SUN PETROLEUM MARCU
179 STAR REF. DELAW
189 UNION OIL OF CALIFOR LEMON
174 UNION OIL OF CALIFOR WZLMZ
257 ATLANTIC REFINING PHILA
262 BP OIL MARCU
45 VISTA CHEMICAL BALTI
248 STANDARD OIL OF OHIO TOLED
307 SOHIO FERND
110 EASTMAN KODAK, INC. LONGV
215 MURPHY OIL CORPORATI MERAU
199 TEXACO REFINING EL DO
284 LVONDELL PETROCHEMIC HOUST
196 FARMLAND INDUSTRIES COFFE
317 SINCLAIR OIL SINCL
183 HAWAII INDEP. REF. EWA B
107 DOW CHEMICAL USA FREEP
240 MOBIL OIL PAULS
397 TEXAS ECOLOGISTS ROBST
164 PACIFIC REF. HERCU
278 HILL PETROLEUM HOUST
282 LA GLORIA OIL AND GA TYLER
279 HILL PETROLEUM TEXAS
255 TOTAL PETROLEUM ARDMO
184 CLARK OIL K REFINING BLUE
171 TEXACO REFINING BAKER
374 ROLLINS ENV. SERVICE DEER
264 UNITED REF. WARRE
287 PHILLIPS 66 REFINERY BORGE
310 U.S. OIL t REFINING TACOM
276 FINA OIL BIG S
98 AMERICAN HOECHST COR HOUST
-------
TABLE D-3. (continued)
Sumaary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maxiaun-
Lifetiae
Cone People
2.83E+00
2.80E+00
2.76E+00
2.75E+00
2.70E+00
2.70E+00
2.69E+00
2.55E+00
2.47E+00
2.40E+00
2.37E+00
2.33E+00
2.27E+00
2.23E+00
2.21E+00
2.21E+00
2.18E+00
2.16E+00
2.10E+00
2.08E+00
2.04E4-00
2.01E+00
1.98E+00
1.95E+00
1.92E+00
1.90E+00
1.87E+00
1.80E+00
1.80E+00
1.77E+00
1.72E+00
1.69E+00
1.66E+00
1.66E+00
1.61E+00
1.60E+00
1.57E+00
1.57E+00
1.54E+00
1.51E+00
1.49E+00
1.41E+00
1.38E+00
1.37E+00
1.32E+00
13
3
105
<1
1
4
15
3
25
4
7
1
<1
3
1
34
7
28
6
14
1
2
2
7
<1
1
2
<1
48
1
16
30
<1
<1
12
12
4
<1
3
<1
2
<1
2
3
13
Exposure
3.64E+01
9.68E+00
2.91E+02
1.07E+00
3.45E+00
1.04E+01
3.96E+01
7.70E+00
6.06E+01
8.49E+00
1.55E+01
1.48E+00
1.23E-01
5.70E+00
1.16E+00
7.43E+01
1.61E+01
5.97E+01
1.28E+01
2.98E+01
1.09E+00
3.35E+00
3.04E+00
1.34E+01
4.35E-01
1.56E+00
4.08E+00
1.34E-01
8.70E+01
1.14E+00
2.71E-KH
5.09E+01
9.06E-02
2.92E-02
1.92E+01
1.84E+01
6.76E+00
6.69E-01
4.35E+00
2.97E-01
3.14E+00
1.38E-)i
2.93EfOO
3 . 7 IE -i-OO
i. "£>.;;
Incidence
3.02E-04
8.04E-05
2.41E-03
8.87E-06
2.86E-05
8.60E-05
3.28E-04
6.39E-05
5.03E-04
7.05E-05
1.29E-04
1.23E-05
1.02E-06
4.73E-05
9.60E-06
6.16E-04
1.34E-04
4.95E-04
1.07E-04
2.48E-04
9.05E-06
2.78E-05
2.53E-05
1.11E-04
3 61E-06
1.29E-05
3.38E-05
1.11E-06
7.22E-04
9.47E-06
2.25E-04
4.22E-04
7.52E-07
2.43E-07
1.59E-04
1.53E-04
5.61E-05
5.55E-06
3.61E-05
2.47E-06
J.61E-05
1.14E-06
2.44E-05
3.08E-05
U47E-04
Max Risk
2.35E-05
2.32E-05
2.29E-05
2.28E-05
2.24E-05
2.24E-05
2.23E-05
2.12E-05
2.05E-05
1.99E-05
1.96E-05
1.94E-05
1.88E-05
1.85E-05
1.83E-05
1.83E-05
1.81E-05
1.80E-05
1.74E-05
1.72E-05
1.70E-05
1.67E-05
1.64E-OS
1.62E-05
1.59E-05
1.58E-05
1.55E-OS
1.50E-OS
1.49E-05
1.47E-05
1.43E-05
1.40E-05
1.38E-05
1.38E-05
1.34E-05
1.32E-05
1.31E-05
1.30E-05
1.28E-05
1.25E-05
1.24E-05
1.17E-05
1.14E-05
1.13E-05
1.10E-05
SIC»
M
Cone
1.05E-04
5.07E-05
4.07E-05
2.18E-05
9.01E-05
9.91E-05
4.39E-05
3.27E-04
1.58E-04
1.11E-04
7.92E-05
5.61E-05
3.97E-05
1.45E-05
2.34E-OS
5.75E-05
1.14E-04
5.37E-05
8.94E-05
3.34E-05
3.63E-05
S.OOE-05
8.55E-05
1.27E-04
3.67E-05
S.45E-05
5.04E-05
5.23E-05
8.16E-05
1.49E-05
2.20E-05
2.87E-05
2.92E-05
4.31E-05
1.99E-05
5.04E-05
2.90E-05
5.68E-05
2.54E-05
1.88E-05
1.20E-04
2.55E-05
7.91E-05
1.10E-05
2.51E-OS
CA
i
n i •
People
1
8
1
2
3
1
1
2
1
2
8
11
10
1
1
2
.970,000
147,000
,550,000
34,700
,380,000
,280,000
625,000
364,000
494,000
,810,000
676,000
,640,000
75,300
893,000
92,200
381,000
,170,000
92,800
,090,000
921,000
110,000
,630,000
971,000
434,000
428,000
158,000
555,000
154,000
,760,000
102,000
111,000
,170,000
75,300
763,000
,600,000
78,500
,500,000
204,000
115,000
108,000
,220,000
924,000
,160,000
859,000
,590,000
u a - -
Exposure
2.70E+03
5.73E+02
1.14E+04
1.19E+02
6.19E+02
3.53E+03
1.74E+03
1.95E+03
3.48E+03
3.64E+03
1.25E+03
1.52E+03
7.71E+02
5.75E+02
6.74E+01
2 . 57E+03
2.94E+03
1.40E+03
1.45E-I-03
1.44E+03
1.54E-I-02
1.56E4-03
5.15E+02
1.23E+03
2.90E+02
1.63E+02
6.52E+02
7.00E+01
2.92E-4-03
8.65E+01
1.08E+03
4.73E+03
5.66E+02
2.73E+02
5.06E+03
5.83E+02
3.46E+03
3.78E+02
2.19E+02
2.91E+02
2.35E+03
3.24E+02
8.01E+02
5.02E+02
2.16E+03
Annual
Incidence
0.0003
0.0001
0.0013
<0.0001
0.0001
0.0004
0.0002
0.0002
0.0004
0.0004
0.0001
0.0002
0.0001
0.0001
3
15
71
14
2
4
4
2
2
6
5
11
15
<0. 0001130
0.0003
0.0003
0.0002
0.0002
0.0002
<0.0001
0.0002
0.0001
0.0001
<0.0001
<0.0001
0.0001
3
2
6
5
5
55
5
16
6
29
52
13
<0. 0001120
0.0003
<0.0001
0.0001
0.0006
0.0001
<0.0001
0.0006
0.0001
0.0004
<0.0001
<0.0001
<0.0001
0.0003
<0.0001
0.0001
0.0001
0.0003
2
97
7
1
15
31
1
14
2
22
38
29
3
26
11
17
3
Repeat
Interval
,100.
,000.
740.
,000.
,000.
,400.
,800.
,300.
,400.
,300.
,800.
,500.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,300.
,900.
,000.
,800.
,800.
,000.
,400.
,000.
,900.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,900.
,000.
,800.
,800.
,000.
,000.
,700.
,000.
,400.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,600.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,900.
Fag* 3 of 9
319 ASHLAND PETROLEUM ST. P
198 NATIONAL COOPERATIVE HCPHE
165 PARAMOUNT PET. PARAH
273 DIAMOND SHAMROCK REF THREE
387 CECOS INT'L WILLI
346 U.S. STEEL CORP. CLAIR
253 SINCIAZR OIL TULSA
277 FINA OIL 6 CHEMICAL PORT
268 CHEVRON EL PA
222 MARATHON PET. DETRO
285 MARATHON OIL TEXAS
178 CONOCO COMME
314 AMOCO CASPE
91 ONION CARBIDE PENUE
252 KERR HCGEE HYHNE
203 PENNZOIL SHREV
27 REILLY TAR AND CHEHI INDIA
145 LION OIL EL DO
185 CLARK OIL & REF. HARTF
297 AMOCO OIL REFINERY SALT
200 TOTAL PETROLEUM ARKAN
177 COLORADO REF. COMME
303 AMOCO OIL REFINERY TORKT
135 LOUISIANA LAND £ EXP SARAL
30 VULCAN MATERIALS HI CHI
101 CAIN CHEMICAL BRA2O
216 PLACID REFINING PORT
225 AMERADA HESS PURVI
153 EXXON BENIC
126 WITCO CHEMICAL CORPO POINT
231 CONOCO REFINERY BILL!
154 FLETCHER OIL & REFIN WILHI
316 LITTLE AMERICA REF. CASPE
182 CHEVRON HONOL
236 CHEVRON PERTH
245 AMOCO KANDA
64 INT'L FLAVORS t FRAG UNION
291 SHELL OIL REFINERY ODESS
230 CENEX REF. LAURE
232 EXXON BTT.T.T
246 ASHLAND OIL CANTO
302 PHILLIPS 66 MOODS
193 ROCK ISLAND REFINING INDIA
77 GENERAL ELECTRIC WATER
341 LTV STEEL CLEVE
-------
TABLE D-3. (continued)
Summary foe BENZENE
with a Unit Risk of
REFINERIES
8.30E-06
-Maximura-
Lifeti»e
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
SIC*
CAS-
--Mini
Cone People
Annual Repeat
Exposure Incidence Interval
Page 4 of 9
S o u r c
1.29E+00
1.26E+00
1.23E+00
1.21E+00
1.19E+00
1.19E+00
1.18E-I-00
1.18E+00
1.13E+00
1.13E+00
1.12E+00
1.08E+00
1.06C4-00
1.05E+00
1.03E+00
1.02E+00
1.02E+00
1.02E+00
1.01E+00
9.86E-01
9.51E-01
8.68E-01
8.60E-01
8.55E-01
8.50E-01
8.47E-01
8.43E-01
7.74E-01
7.63E-01
7.58E-01
7.44E-01
7.44E-01
7.32E-01
7.07E-01
6.79E-01
6.63E-01
6.55E-01
6.42E-01
6.36E-01
6.33E-01
6.10E-01
5.93E-01
5.79E-01
5.58E-01
5.40E-01
2
42
1
14
16
<1
1
36
<1
17
44
8
1
28
71
2
13
22
2
35
13
1
2
4,530
2
35
<1
3
1
37
1
10
1
2
14
<1
46
265
<1
<1
6
7
1
<1
<1
2.82E+00
5.22E+01
1.28E+00
1.74E+01
1.92E+01
3.01E-01
9.78E-01
4.25E+01
2.87E-02
1.94E+01
4.88E+01
8.29E-4-00
9.22E-01
2.97E+01
7.32E-I-01
2.18E+00
1.37E+01
2.23E+01
2.17E+00
3.45E+01
1.24E+01
7.17E-01
1.83E+00
3.88E-I-03
1.48E+00
2.96E+01
2.03E-02
2.01E+00
7.43E-01
2.82E*-01
8.30E-01
7.64EfOO
4.35E-01
1.11E4-00
9.24E+00
2.58E-01
3.00E+01
1.70E4-02
2.26E-01
2.10E-01
3.83E-I-00
4.34Z>00
3.49E-01
4.58E-0:
9.-11E— ::
2.34E-05
4.33E-04
1.06E-05
1.44E-04
1.60E-04
2.49E-06
8.12E-06
3.52E-04
2.38E-07
1.61E-04
4.05E-04
6.88E-05
7.66E-06
2.47E-04
6.08E-04
1.81E-05
1.14E-04
1.85E-04
1.80E-05
2.86E-04
1.03E-04
5.95E-06
1.52E-05
3.22E-02
1.23E-05
2.46E-04
1.69E-07
1.67E-05
S.17E-06
2.34E-04
6.89E-06
6.34E-05
3.61E-06
9.19E-06
7.67E-05
2.14E-06
2.49E-04
1.41E-03
1.87E-06
1.75E-06
3.18E-OS
3.60E-OS
2.90E-06
3.80E-07
7.81E-07
1.07E-05
1.04E-05
1.02E-05
l.OOE-05
9.86E-06
9.84E-06
9.83E-06
9.79E-06
9.41E-06
9.36E-06
9.30E-06
.97E-06
.80E-06
.70E-06
. 58E-06
. 50E-06
.48E-06
.44E-06
. 35E-06
8.18E-06
7.89E-06
7.20E-06
7.14E-06
7.10E-06
7.05E-06
7.03E-06
6.99E-06
6.43E-06
6.33E-06
6.29E-06
6.18E-06
6.18E-06
6.08E-06
5.87E-06
5.64E-06
5.50E-06
5.44E-06
5.33E-06
5.28E-06
5.2SE-06
5.07E-06
4.92E-06
4.81E-06
4.63E-06
4.48E-06
7.64E-06
4.81E-OS
4.27E-05
1.94E-OS
2.19E-05
1.73E-05
2.00E-05
1.77E-05
4.00E-05
2.06E-05
2.77E-04
9.23E-06
1.93E-OS
2.79E-05
1.26E-05
2.47E-05
1.07E-06
3.55E-OS
9.24E-06
8.34E-05
1.93E-05
4.47E-05
2.66E-05
6.83E-04
1.30E-05
7.17E-05
1.56E-05
9.29E-06
1.33E-05
2.73E-05
1.62E-OS
1.70E-05
4.52E-05
2.01E-05
1.08E-05
2.12E-05
4.32E-06
9.40E-05
1.03E-OS
1.92E-05
1.22E-05
7.82E-04
2.49E-05
3.29E-OS
6.90E-06
358,000
2,310,000
415,000
921,000
463,000
69,300
725,000
8,630,000
5,490,000
2,790,000
8,180,000
837,000
207,000
1,160,000
131,000
196,000
1,060,000
2,190,000
335,000
2,910,000
2,690,000
1,030,000
4,560,000
2,380,000
61,000
2,910,000
379,000
810,000
300,000
1,190,000
248,000
4,530,000
495,000
2,110,000
12,200,000
551,000
338,000
8,730,000
• 929,000
790,000
325,000
349,000
4,490,000
326,000
1,760,000
2.14E+02
3.48E+03
1.56E+02
8.40E+02
1.32E+03
4.07E-MJ2
3.29E+02
4.55E+03
1.07E+03
4.29E+03
3.95E+04
5.82E+02
7.42E+01
1.66E+03
5.22E+02
2.49E+02
6.15E+02
1.20E+03
3.31E+02
4.49E-I-03
1.03E+03
5.49E+02
9.87E+02
2.40E+04
5.15E+01
3.85E+03
8.48E+01
5.51E-I-02
7.48E+01
2.07E+03
3.85E-I-01
6.37E+02
1.12E+03
3.61E+02
2.34E+03
9.56E+01
6.44E+02
1.32E-I-04
2.80E+02
3.67E+02
6.83E+02
3.14E+03
6.59E+02
1.37E+02
2.14E+02
<0.0001 39,000.
0.0004 2,400.
<0.0001 54,000.
0.0001 10,000.
0.0002 6,400.
<0.0001 21,000.
<0.0001 26,000.
0.0005 1,900.
0.0001 7,800.
0.0005 2,000.
0.0047 210.
0.0001 14,000.
(0.0001110,000.
0.0002 5,100.
0.0001 16,000.
<0.0001 34,000.
0.0001 14,000.
0.0001 7,000.
<0.0001 25,000.
0.0005 1,900.
0.0001 8,200.
0.0001 15,000.
0.0001 8,500.
0.0028 350.
<0. 0001160, 000.
0.0005 2,200.
<0.0001 99,000.
0.0001 15,000.
<0. 0001110, 000.
0.0002 4,100.
<0. 0001220, 000.
0.0001 13,000.
0.0001 7,500.
<0.0001 23,000.
0.0003 3,600.
<0.0001 88,000.
0.0001 13,000.
0.0016 640.
<0.0001 30,000.
<0.0001 23,000.
0.0001 12,000.
0.0004 2,700.
0.0001 13,000.
<0.0001 62,000.
<0.0001 39,000.
296 VALERO ENERGY CORP. CORFU
343 LTV STEEL COMPAHT PITTS
80 ARIS TECH CHEMICAL HAVER
298 BIQ WEST OIL SALT
195 DERBT REFIHINO COMPA WICHI
315 FRONTIER OIL CHETE
348 U.S. STEEL CORP. PROVO
152 EDGINGTON OIL COMPAN LONG
330 INLAND STEEL E CHI
44 FHC CORP. BALTI
147 ATLANTIC RICHFIELD CARSO
244 CIBRO PETROLEUM ALBAN
260 PENN20IL COMPANY ROUSE
342 BETHLEHEM STEEL CORP BETRL
289 PRIDE REFINING ABILB
313 MURPHY OIL CORPORATI SUPER
280 HOWELL HYDROCARBONS SAN A
338 ARMCO INC MIDDL
323 GULF STATES GAOSD
173 TOSCO CORP. MARTI
359 ERIEWAY POLL. CONTRO BEDFO
349 WHEELING PITT B STE
57 ATLANTIC WOOD INDUST HAINE
97 AMERICAN HOECHST COR PASAD
241 BLOOMFIELD REFINING BLOOM
168 SHELL OIL MARTI
194 DERBY REF. EL DO
320 ABC COKE TARRA
380 IT CORP.-PETROL. WAS BUTTO
369 ECOLOTEC DAYTO
211 HILL PETROLEUM ST. R
162 NEWHALL REFINING CO. NEWHA
274 EL PASO REFINING EL PA
398 DELAWARE CONTAINERS COATS
235 AMERADA-HESS PORT
36 DOW CHEMICAL PLAQU
294 TRIFINERY CORFU
156 GOLDEN WEST REFINING SANTA
300 CRYSEN REFINING WOODS
322 KOPPEES WOODW
159 KERN OIL I REFINING BAKER
269 CHEVRON PORT
239 MANTUA OIL THORO
191 INDIANA FARM BUREAU MT. V
308 SOUND REF. TACOM
-------
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with i Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maxinum-
Lifetime
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
TABLE D-3. (continued)
SIO
CAS-
--Mininum--
Conc People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 5 of 9
5.12E-01
5.01E-01
5.00E-01
5.00E-01
4.74E-01
4.30E-01
4.18E-01
4.08E-01
4.08E-01
3.97E-01
3.92E-01
3.87E-01
3.73E-01
3.67E-01
3.62E-01
3.60E-01
3.59E-01
3.58E-01
3.54E-01
3.52E-01
3.32E-01
3.30E-01
3.27E-01
3.24E-01
3.16E-01
3.14E-01
3.10E-01
3.08E-01
3.07E-01
3.05E-01
3.00E-01
2.91E-01
2.78E-01
2.78E-01
2.69E-01
2.68E-01
2.59E-01
2.56E-01
2.50E-01
2.46E-01
2.45E-01
2.45E-01
2.34E-01
2.33E-01
2.32E-01
265
44
4
705
<1
<1
13
71
<1
<1
1
<1
4
6
20
1
54
16
17
49
<1
9
2
16
1
<1
<1
54
65
1
15
3
3
1
2
<1
<1
<1
(1
50
10
3
28
1
1
1.36E+02
2.22E+01
1.89E+00
3.52E+02
1.32E-02
1.74E-02
5.43E+00
2.88E+01
3.18E-02
9.02E-02
4.76E-01
1.11E-01
1.32E+00
2.27E+00
7.31E+00
5.05E-01
1.9SE+01
5.57E+00
6.13E+00
1.72E+01
1.56E-01
2.94E-I-00
5.06E-01
5.24E+00
3.83E-01
1.27E-01
6.78E-02
1.65E+01
2.00E+01
4.25E-01
4.47E+00
7.77E-01
7.48E-01
1.85E-01
4.07E-01
2.29E-02
5.83E-02
3.86E-03
2.66E-02
1.22E+01
2.48E+00
8.41E— H
6.50E+00
2.31E-01
1.55E-::
1.13E-03
1.84E-04
1.57E-05
2.92E-03
1.09E-07
1.44E-07
4.51G-OS
2.39E-04
2.64C-07
7.49E-07
3.95E-06
9.23E-07
1.10E-05
1.89E-05
6.07E-05
4.19E-06
1.61E-04
4.62E-05
5.09E-OS
1.43E-04
1.29E-06
2.44E-05
4.20E-06
4.35E-05
3.1BE-06
1.05E-06
5.63E-07
1.37E-04
1.66E-04
3.53E-06
3.71E-05
S.45E-06
6.21E-06
1.54E-06
3.38E-06
1.90E-07
4.84E-07
3.20E-08
2.21E-07
1.01E-04
2.06E-OS
0.98E-06
5.39E-05
1.92E-06
1.29E-06
4.2SE-06
4.16E-06
4.15E-06
4.15E-06
3.94E-06
3.57E-06
3.47E-06
3.39E-06
3.38E-06
3.29E-06
3.25E-06
3.21E-06
3.10E-06
3.05E-06
3.01E-06
2.98E-06
2.98E-06
2.97E-06
2.94E-06
2.92E-06
2.76E-06
2.74E-06
2.71E-06
2.69E-06
2.62E-06
2.60E-06
2.57E-06
2.56E-06
2.55E-06
2.53E-06
2.49E-06
2.41E-06
2.31E-06
2.31E-06
2.23E-06
2.22E-06
2.15E-06
2.12E-06
2.07E-06
2.05E-06
2.03E-06
2.03E-06
1.94E-06
1.94E-06
1.92E-06
7.49E-05
3.31E-05
1.08E-05
6.35E-04
7.94E-06
1.88E-05
4.30E-05
6.36E-06
1.64E-05
7.53E-06
7.64E-06
1.39E-05
1.73E-05
1.31E-05
1.22E-05
1.84E-05
1.28E-05
6.58E-05
1.53E-05
1.29E-05
1.51E-05
4.84E-06
1.17E-05
2.27E-06
6.15E-06
6.04E-06
6.70E-05
8.41E-06
5.23E-06
1.05E-05
1.S4E-05
1.74E-05
1.50E-05
1.13E-05
3.91E-OS
7.49E-06
1.15E-04
1.02E-05
2.43E-04
5.10E-06
1.26E-05
1.19E-05
2.41E-04
8.18E-06
7.28E-06
8,730,000
424,000
197,000
2,210,000
925,000
279,000
2,580,000
8,200,000
3,430,000
30,900
325,000
6,100,000
3,810,000
6,100,000
807,000
927,000
6,210,000
287,000
2,180,000
1,670,000
1,000,000
1,240,000
4,400,000
1,230,000
325,000
126,000
924,000
562,000
1,310,000
297,000
2,410,000
9,580
1,190,000
110,000
935,000
574,000
626,000
4,450,000
4,870,000
83,000
2,070,000
234,000
455,000
209,000
511,000
1.05E+04
4.76E+02
B.03E+01
1.36E+04
2.04E+02
1.52E+02
6.35E+02
1.40E+03
4.07E+02
6.22E+00
2.17E+02
7.95E+02
5.67E+02
8.21E+02
5.01E+02
1.47E+02
1.31E+03
3.18E+02
5.37E+02
9.11E+02
2.15E+02
1.96E+02
2.88E+02
8.58E+01
1.74E+02
1.04E+01
1.91E+03
3.75E+02
7.88E+02
9.69E+01
8.28E+02
3.31E+01
6.27E+02
1.52E+02
7.64E+02
3.42E+01
1.97E+03
4.11E+02
2.41E+04
2.97E+02
2.17E+02
3.51E+01
8.60E+02
2.59E+01
9.04E+01
0.0012 800.
0.0001 18,000.
<0. 0001110, 000.
0.0016 620.
<0.0001 41,000.
<0.0001 56,000.
0.0001 13,000.
0.0002 6,000.
<0.0001 21,000.
<0.0001 39,000.
0.0001 11,000.
0.0001 15,000.
0.0001 10,000.
0.0001 17,000.
<0.0001 57,000.
0.0002 6,400.
<0.0001 27,000.
0.0001 16,000.
0.0001 9,300.
(0.0001 39,000.
(0.0001 43,000.
(0.0001 29,000.
(0.0001 98,000.
(0.0001 48,000.
<0. 0001810, 000.
0.0002 4,400.
(0.0001 22,000.
0.0001 11,000.
(0.0001 87,000.
0.0001 10,000.
<0. 0001250,000.
0.0001 13,000.
(0.0001 56,000.
0.0001 11,000.
<0. 0001250, 000.
0.0002 4,300.
(0.0001 21,000.
0.0029 350.
(0.0001 28,000.
(0.0001 39,000.
<0. 0001240, 000.
0.0001 9,800.
<0. 0001330, 000.
(0.0001 93,000.
166
332
259
275
393
180
78
148
62
* 301
170
368
350
327
324
312
326
223
325
383
337
335
331
4
167
229
265
334
256
339
345
318
329
227
299
39
254
67
258
233
87
311
74
151
46
POHERINE OIL
ARMCO INC.
WITCO CHEMICAL CORP.
EXXON CORP
PETROCHEM RECYCLING
AMOCO
NEFERA CHEMICAL CO.,
CHEMOIL
DUPONT
PENNZOIL
SUNLAND REF.
CHEM. HASTE MGMT.
DETROIT COKE
LTV STEEL
SLOSS INDUSTRIES
QUAKER STATE OIL REF
ACHE STEEL
TOTAL PETROLEUM
NATIONAL STEEL
CECOS IHT'L
LTV STEEL
TONAMAHDA
U.S. STEEL CORP.
ALPHA RESINS
SAN JOAQUIN REF.
SOUTHLAND OIL
MAPCO PETROLEUM
NATIONAL STEEL GROUP
CHEVRON
NEW BOSTON COKE
SHENANGO
WYOMING REF.
CITIZENS GAS
ERGON REF.
CHEVRON
RUBICON CHEMICALS IH
SUN REFINING
MONSANTO CO
CHEVRON
MONTANA REFINING COM
ATLANTIC RICHFIELD C
HIDATLANTIC REF.
MONTROSE CHEMICAL CO
CONOCO
DOW CORNING
SANTA
ASHLA
BRADF
BAYTO
SALT
SAVAN
HARRI
SIQNA
DEEPW
ROOSE
BAKER
CALXIM
DETRI
S CHI
BIRMI
NEWEL
CHICA
ALMA
GRANT
CINCI
HARRE
TONAW
GARY
PERRI
BAKER
SANDE
MEMPH
ECORS
PORTL
PORTS
SHENA
NEWCA
INDIA
VICKS
SALT
GEISM
TULSA
BRIDG
PHILA
GREAT
MONAC
ST. M
HENDE
SANTA
MIDLA
-------
Suranary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maximum-
Lifeti«e
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
TABLE D-3. (continued)
SIC-
CAS»
Hi n i
Cone People
Annual Repeat
Exposure Incidence Interval
Pag* 6 of 9
2.26E-01
2.07E-01
1.99E-01
1.89E-01
1.86E-01
1.84E-01
1.81E-01
1.76E-01
1 .72E-01
1.65E-01
1.56E-01
1.52E-01
1.47E-01
1 .37E-01
1 -34E-01
1.32E-01
1.21E-01
1.20E-01
1 . 18E— 01
1.16E-01
1.15E-01
1.15E-01
1.15E-01
1.13E-01
1.06E-01
l.OOE-01
9.67E-02
9.44E-02
9. 25E-02
9.08E-02
8.85E-02
8.33E-02
8.19E-02
7.21E-02
6.84E-02
6.69E-02
6.16E-02
5.83E-02
5 .47E-02
5.09E-02
5.01E-02
4.82E-02
4.77E-02
4.14E-02
4.11E-02
1
12
2
723
6
1
40
1
<1
2
111
4
2
1
<1
12
3
7
<1
17
22
35
163
24
40
9
2
1
1
1
6
28
<1
106
1
163
10
38
1
21
70
<1
48
<1
1
1.33E-01
2.55E+00
4.11E-01
1.36E+02
1.13E+00
1.04E-01
7.24E+00
1.96E-01
4 .64E-03
3.31E-01
1.73E+01
6.06E-01
2.93E-01
1 . 21E-01
2 .20E-02
1.53E+00
3.9SE-01
7.79E-01
8 . 13E-04
2.00E+00
2.56E+00
4 .OOE+00
1.87E+01
2.66E+00
4.22E+00
9.43E-01
2.40E-01
5 . 46E-02
8 . 83E-02
6.45E-02
5.27E-01
2.33E+00
1 .82E-02
7.65E+00
7.43E-02
1.09E+01
6.16E-01
2.22E+00
3 . 86E-02
1.05E+00
3.52E+00
2.69E-OJ
2.31E+00
1.35E-0:
2.07E-0:
1
2
3
1
9
8
6
1
S
2
1
5
2
i
1
1
3
6
6
1
2
3
1
2
3
7
1
•4
5
•4
1
1
6
6
9
5
1
3
2
i
1
I
i
. 10E-06
.12E-05
.41E-06
.13E-03
. 35E-06
.65E-07
. 01E-05
. 63E-06
. 85E-08
.75E-06
. 43E-04
. 03E-06
.43E-06
. OOE— 06
.83E-07
.27E-05
. 28E-06
. 46E-06
. 75E— 09
. 66E-05
.12E-05
. 32E-05
. 55E-04
.20E-05
.50E-05
82E-06
.99E-06
. 54E-07
. 33E-07
.35E-07
. 38E-06
.93E-05
. 51E-07
.35E-05
.17E-07
.06E-05
. 11E-06
. 84E-05
.71E-06
. 92E-05
. 24E-08
.91E-05
.53E-07
.72E-07
1.88E-06
1.72E-06
1.6SE-06
1.57E-06
1.54E-06
1.S3E-06
1.50E-06
1.46E-06
1.43E-06
1.37E-06
1.29E-06
1.26E-06
1.22E-06
1.14E-06
1.11E-06
1.09E-06
l.OOE-06
9.93E-07
9 .79E-07
9.59E-07
9.55E-07
9.52E-07
9.51E-07
9.35E-07
8.79E-07
8.30E-07
8.03E-07
7.83E-07
7.68E-07
7.54E-07
7.34E-07
6.91E-07
6.80E-07
5.98E-07
5.68E-07
.55E-07
.11E-07
.84E-07
.54E— 07
.23E-07
.16E-07
.OOE-07
3.96E-07
3.44E-07
3.41E-07
6
7
6
1
3
8
5
3
J
7
2
1
4
3
a
2
2
4
2
6
3
2
5
2
2
4
4
3
2
4
2
2
2
2
3
3
7
1
1
8
7
4
2
2
1
.22E-06
. 76E-06
.12E-06
.25E-04
.32E-06
. 26E-06
.33E-06
. 84E-06
. 64E-06
.52E-06
.52E-06
.57E-06
.16E-06
. 96E-06
. 58E-06
.32E-06
.66E-06
. 84E-06
.49E-06
. 01E-06
.07E-06
. 03E-06
.97E-05
. 59E-05
.79E-06
. 49E-06
.18E-06
. 01E-06
. 32E-06
.65E-06
.43E-06
. 90E-06
.72E-06
.39E-05
.S1E-06
.49E-05
.42E-07
.30E-06
.02E-07
.01E-07
.71E-07
.16E-06
.41E-07
.25E-06
2
1
8
8
2
1
2
2
2
2
4
2
1
2
13
2
12
12
2
2
278,000
,110,000
225,000
92,400
327,000
,150,000
,530,000
248,000
230,000
166,000
,090,000
,090,000
168,000
97,800
168 ,000
,690,000
834,000
506,000
144 ,000
,390,000
93,500
,540,000
,640,000
,440,000
609,000
831,000
,790,000
42 ,300
389 ,000
292,000
297,000
,340,000
103,000
,270,000
372,000
,640,000
,300,000
,600,000
253,000
,500,000
,900,000
,520,000
,760,000
364,000
223,000
9.36E+00
1.89E+02
5.59E+01
1.13E+03
1.67E+02
1.43E+02
8.58E+02
9.11E+00
5.18E+00
3.02E+01
5.21E+02
1.52E+02
9.37E+00
8 . 26E+00
5 . B9E+00
8.31E+01
3.33E+01
1.74E+02
2 .58E+00
2.41E+02
3.09E+01
1.76E+02
2.33E+03
5.64E+02
1.67E+02
1.34E+02
1.96E+02
2 . 50E+00
7.81E+00
l.OOE+01
2.25E+01
1.90E+02
1 . 98E+00
1.05E+03
2.25E+01
1.36E+03
4.29E+02
9.69E+01
2.33E+02
3.16E+02
9.26E+00
7.75E+01
4.96E+00
1.21E+01
<0. 0001900, 000.
<0.0001 45,000.
<0. 0001150, 000.
0.0001 7,500.
<0.0001 51,000.
<0.0001 59,000.
0.0001 9,800.
<0. 0001930, 000.
<0. 0001280, 000.
0.0001 16,000.
<0.0001 55,000.
<0. 0001900, 000.
<0. 0001100,000.
<0. 0001250, 000.
<0.0001 48,000.
<0.0001 35,000.
<0. 0001270, 000.
<0.0001 48,000.
0.0003 3,600.
0.0001 15,000.
<0.0001 51,000.
<0.0001 63,000.
<0.0001 43,000.
<0. 0001840, 000.
<0. 0001370, 000.
<0.0001 44,000.
0.0001 8,000.
<0. 0001380, 000.
0.0002 6,200.
0.0001 20,000.
<0.0001 87,000.
<0.0001 36,000.
<0.0001 27,000.
<0. 0001910, 000.
<0. 0001110, 000.
<0. 0001 ***********
<0. 0001690, 000.
20 GOODRICH, (B.P.) HENRY
347 SHARON STEEL HONES
204 CALCASIEU REFINING LAKE
251 CONOCO PONCA
155 WITCO CORP. OILDA
129 ATLANTIC HOOD INDUST PORTS
160 LUNDAY-THAGARD CO. SOUTH
212 KERR-MCGEE REFINING COTTO
146 ANCHOR REF. HCKIT
202 SOMERSET REFINERY SOHER
158 HUNTWAY REF. WILMI
305 CHEVRON SEATT
228 SOUTHLAND OIL LUHBE
144 CROSS OIL I REFINING SHACK
12 OLIN CORP. ST. H
181 YOUNG REF. DOUGL
11 ALPHA CHEMICAL LAKEL
221 LAKESIDE REF. KALAM
283 LIQUID ENERGY CORP. BRIDG
88 CALGON CARBON NEVIL
353 ENSCO EL DO
116 HEAT ENERGY TECH. DALLA
112 GEORGIA-PACIFIC CORP PASAD
333 BETHLEHEM STEEL CORP SPARR
163 OXNARD REF. OXNAR
340 TOLEDO COKE TOLED
61 DUPONT GIBBS
104 COSDEN OIL & CHEMICA BIG S
205 CALUMET REFINING COM PRINC
192 LAKETON REFINING LAKET
53 REICHHOLD CHEMICALS GULFP
89 KOPPERS CO IRC BRIDG
372 ROGERS LANDFILL CEHTR
336 BETHLEHEM STEEL LACKA
16 NIPRO, INC. AUGUS
111 GEORGIA GULF CORP. PASAD
73 TROY CHEMICAL CORP., NEWAB
122 S.D.S. BIOTECH CORP. HOUST
220 CRYSTAL REF. CARSO
66 MOBAY CORP. HALED
70 REICHHOLD CHEMICALS ELIZA
377 IT CORPORATION BENEC
157 HUNTWAY REF. BENEC
117 KOCH INDUSTRIES CORFU
42 VISTA CHEMICAL WESTL
-------
Suanary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maxinun-
Lifetiae
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
TABLE D-3. (continued)
SIC* CAS-
Minimum--
Cone People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 7 of 9
4.02E-02
3.57E-02
3.30E-02
3.1SE-02
2.S9E-02
2.52E-02
2.49E-02
2.44E-02
2.39E-02
2.3SE-02
1.87E-02
1.81E-02
1.74E-02
1.70E-02
1.49E-02
1.45E-02
1.24E-02
1.15E-02
9.76E-03
9.58E-03
9.31E-03
9.10E-03
8 .85E-03
6.79E-03
5.66E-03
4 .44E-03
4 . 23E-03
3 .65E-03
3 .64E-03
3.63E-03
3.39E-03
3 .37E-03
2.62E-03
2 .51E-03
2.25E-03
2.24E-03
2.07E-03
2 .OOE-03
1 . 61E-03
1.31E-03
23
233
80
<1
1
2
2
<1
8
<1
<1
20
10
17
7
10
54
230
360
<1
497
<1
<1
<1
387
S25
1
1
1
1
2
<1
175
15
50
1
57
77
4
1
345
9.26E-01
8.32E+00
2.62E+00
4.20E-03
1.49E-02
4.13E-02
4.60E-02
4.12E-03
1.86E-01
2.85E-03
4.23E-03
3.66E-01
1.66E-01
2.96E-01
1.02E-01
1.38E-01
6.73E-01
2.64E+00
3.51E+00
2.19E-05
4.62E+00
2.61E-03
2 .49E-03
4 . 30E-0-4
2.63E+00
3 . 92E-02
2.97E+00
5 . 85E-0 .
2.78E-03
4 . 97E-03
7 .64E-03
1 .83E-04
5.94E-01
4 .98E-02
1.31E-01
1 . 70E— 03
1.29E-01
1.73E-01
8.25E-02
1 . 02E-I;.:
1.1CE- •:
7.68E-06
6.91E-OS
2.18E-05
3.48E-08
1.24E-07
3.42E-07
3.82E-07
3.42E-08
1.54E-06
2.37E-08
3.51E-08
3.04E-06
1.38E-06
2.46E-06
8.43E-07
1.14E-06
5.59E-06
2.19E-OS
2.92E-OS
1.81E-10
3.84E-05
2.17E-08
3 . 57E— 09
2.18E-05
2.47E-05
2 . 30E-08
4 . 12E— 08
6 . 34E— 08
1.52E— 09
4.93E-06
4 . 13E— 07
1.09E-06
L .41E-08
1.07E-06
1.43E-06
6.85E-08
9.17E-06
3.34E-07
2.96E-07
2.73E-07
2.61E-07
2.15E-07
2.09E-07
2.07E-07
2.03E-07
1.99E-07
1.95E-07
1.55E-07
1.50E-07
1.45E-07
1.41E-07
1.24E-07
1.20E-07
1.03E-07
9.54E-08
8.10E-08
7.95E-08
7.73E-08
7.55E-08
7.54E— 08
7.34E-08
.25E— 08
5.99E— 08
.64E-08
.96E— 08
.70E-08
.64E— 08
. 68E-08
. 51E-08
.03E— 08
. 02E-08
3.02E— 08
2.82E-08
2.80E-08
2.18E-08
2.08E— 08
1.87E-08
1.86E-08
1.71E-08
1.33E— 08
1.08E-08
2.33E-04
7.45E-04
6.74E-07
1.06E-06
9.3SE-07
8.64E-07
4.3SE-07
4.64E-07
3.46E-07
1.94E-07
3.40E-07
4.52E-06
1.03E-05
9.45E-07
4.73E-07
6.78E-07
1.70E-07
3.76E-05
7.21E-05
3.32E-07
4.39E-06
3.26E-07
2.65E— 07
1.56E-07
1.02E— 07
1.22E-04
1 . 88E— 07
2.51E-05
2.44E— 07
1.54E— 07
2.48E— 07
2.25E— 08
7.00E— 08
9.81E— 08
2.39E-05
9.20E— 08
7.31E-05
2.70E— 08
2.31E-06
7.51E-07
2.13E-08
7.20E-06
547,000
284,000
9,100,000
1,800,000
395,000
1,570,000
3,100,000
2,540,000
2,060,000
309,000
425,000
333,000
2,690,000
1,150,000
2,680,000
4,250,000
1,940,000
2,360,000
76,500
1,260,000
189,000
6,100,000
1 ,730,000
2,240,000
425,000
1,170,000
27,100
406,000
189 , 000
415, 000
649 ,000
328,000
1,970,000
469,000
60,000
804,000
354,000
2,000 , 000
824,000
2,210,000
2., 090, 000
158,000
7.74E+02
1.11E+03
1.31E+02
1.32E+01
6.47E+00
1.84E+01
4.77E+01
3.63E+01
1.97E+01
1.57E+00
2.35E+00
7.30E+01
5.06E+02
2.29E+01
2.54E+01
4.13E+01
1.83E+01
2.95E+02
5.11E+01
1.80E+00
4.16E+01
1.87E+01
1.49E+00
4.77E+00
9. 45E— 01
7.93E+00
3.34E+01
3 . 17E+00
2.61E+02
4.90E— 01
5.59E— 01
1.12E+00
3.23E— 01
2.02E+00
4.56E— 01
3.56E+01
4.07E+00
1.34E+02
6 . 21E-01
2.22E+01
3.85E-I-01
2.07E+00
8.00E— 02
1.12E+01
0.0001 11,000.
0.0001 7,600.
<0.0001 64,000.
<0. 0001640, 000.
<0. 0001460, 000.
<0. 0001180, 000.
<0. 0001230, 000.
<0. 0001430, 000.
<0.0001"*********
<0. 0001120, 000.
0.0001 17,000.
<0. 0001370, 000.
<0. 0001330, 000.
<0. 0001200, 000.
<0. 0001460, 000.
<0.0001 29,000.
<0. 0001170, 000.
<0.0001***********
<0. 0001200, 000.
<0. 0001450, 000.
<0. 0001250, 000.
<0.0001 32,000.
<0. 0001240, 000.
<0.0001 63,000.
<0. 0001380, 000.
<0. 0001220, 000.
<0.0001***********
<0. 0001750, 000.
219 STAR RET. CONVE
226 CHEVRON PASCA
6 LILLY COATINGS MONTE
48 3-M COMPANY COTTA
120 MOBIL CHEMICALS BEAOH
82 MONSANTO CO ADDYS
364 CHEM-CLEAR INC. BALTI
365 CHEM-CLEAR INC. CLEVE
9 UPJOHN CO.,THE NORTH
2 MONSANTO CO ANNIS
29 AIR PRODUCTS K CHEM. WICHI
344 ERIE COKE ERIE
100 ATLANTIC RICHFIELD HOUST
376 HERITAGE ENV. SEEVIC INDIA
118 KOPPER5 HOUST
366 CHEM-MET SERVICES WZAND
382 CECOS INT'L BRIST
328 BETHLEHEM STEEL BURNS
139 MAPCO PETROLEUM NORTH
41 UNION CARBIDE CORP. HAHNV
321 EMPIRE COKE COMPANY TUSCA
363 CID-LANDFILL CALUM
23 REILLY TAR AND CHEMI GSANI
115 GOODYEAR TIRE fc RUBB LAPOR
28 ABBOTT LABORATORIES WICHI
370 FRONTIER CHEMICAL N1AGR
272 DIAMOND SHAMROCK SUNRA
99 AMOCO CHEMICAL TEXAS
134 HUNT REFINING TUSCA
33 GAP CORP. CALVE
85 USS CHEMICAL IEONT
54 MALLINCKRODT CHEM. RALEI
102 CELANESE CHEMICAL BISHO
81 BF GOODRICH AVON
18 NORCHEM CO. CLINT
242 GIANT REFINERY QALLU
1 ALLIED SIGNAL BIRMI
210 HILL PETROLEUM KROTZ
5 DOW CHEMICAL PITTS
128 HERCULES MAGNA
50 MONSANTO CO ST. L
361 CHEMICAL PROCESSORS SEATT
197 FARMLAND FACILITIES PHILL
3 GREAT LAKES CHEMICAL EL DO
261 QUAKER STATE OIL REF SMETH
-------
TABLE D-3. (continued)
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maxinua-
Lifetiae
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
SIC"
CAS-
Mini
Cone People
Annual Repeat
Exposure Incidence Interval
Page 8 of 9
^^^^
o
«*J
V
>
1.23E-03
1.20E-03
1.07E-03
1.05E-03
1.01E-03
8.83E-04
7.76E-04
7.53E-04
7.52E-04
7.13E-04
6.99E-04
6.86E-04
6.63E-04
6.19E-04
5.53E-04
5.27E-04
5.16E-04
4.78E-04
4.58E-04
3.69E-04
3.68E-04
3.50E-04
3.32E-04
3.28E-04
3.12E-04
2.85E-04
2.01E-04
1.91E-04
1.68E-04
1.44E-04
1.43E-04
1.41E-04
1.34E-04
1.31E-04
1.17E-04
1.14E-04
1.14E-04
7.75E-05
7.75E-05
7.45E-05
7.30E-05
7.30E-05
7.11E-05
6.31E-05
5.67E-05
22
11
<1
<1
<1
1,150
2
1
491
<1
22
10
601
14
4
1
360
170
5
1,270
38
1,450
<1
36
4
860
22
12
598
1,850
23
2,170
1,980
<1
5
24
29
4
<1
<1
2
1
5
33
581
2.70E-02
1.30E-02
8.92E-05
7.49E-05
1.16E-06
1.02E+00
1.46E-03
9.66E-04
3.69E-01
2.15E-04
1.54E-02
6.86E-03
3.99E-01
8.42E-03
2.39E-03
3.42E-04
1.86E-01
8.13E-02
2.19E-03
4.70E-01
1.40E-02
5.07E-01
5.66E-05
1.17E-02
1.26E-03
2.45E-01
4.43E-03
2.22E-03
1.01E-01
2.66E-01
3.29E-03
3.05E-01
2.65E-01
3.38E-05
5.85E-04
2.73E-03
3.31E-03
3.33E-04
2.15E-06
1.28E-06
1.80E-0-!
3.72E-03
3.33E-0-
2.0SE-03
3.361-.:
2.24E-07
1.08E-07
7.40E-10
6.21E-10
9.59E-12
8.46E-06
1.21E-08
8.02E-09
3.07E-06
1.78E-09
1.28E-07
5.70E-08
3.31E-06
6.99E-08
1.98E-08
2.84E-09
1.54E-06
6.75E-07
1.82E-08
3.90E-06
1.16E-07
4.21E-06
4.70E-10
9.73E-08
1.05E-08
2.04E-06
3.67E-08
1.84E-OB
3.34E-07
2.21E-06
J.73E-08
2.54E-06
2.20E-06
2.BOE-10
-I.85E-09
2.26E-08
2.75E-08
2.77E-09
1.79E-11
L.06E-11
1..49E-09
3.09E-10
2.76E-09
1.73E-08
J.21E-07
1.02E-08
9.92E-09
8.89E-09
8.73E-09
8.35E-09
7.33E-09
6.44E-09
6.25E-09
6.24E-09
S.91E-09
5.80E-09
5.70E-09
5.50E-09
5.14E-09
4.59E-09
4.37E-09
4.28E-09
3.97E-09
3.80E-09
3.06E-09
3.05E-09
2.91E-09
2.75E-09
2.72E-09
2.59E-09
2.37E-09
1.67E-09
1.59E-09
1.40E-09
1.19E-09
1.19E-09
1.17E-09
1.11E-09
1.09E-09
9.72E-10
9.50E-10
9.50E-10
6.44E-10
6.43E-10
6.18E-10
6.06E-10
6.06E-10
5.90E-10
5.24E-10
4.71E-10
1.17E-04
3.24E-08
2.01E-08
1.82E-08
5.85E-08
5.72E-05
2.23E-08
3.91E-08
9.99E-06
4.96E-08
4.49E-04
8.28E-09
4.31E-06
2.23E-08
2.26E-08
1.93E-07
3.81E-06
1.46E-05
7.69E-09
1.82E-07
6.57E-09
1.13E-05
4.70E-09
1.72E-08
5.15E-07
3.08E-06
1.92E-05
3.28E-09
2.08E-06
1.32E-06
3.91E-06
4.91E-06
2.63E-06
1.85E-09
1.23E-09
1.55E-09
1.36E-09
3.68E-09
3.84E-09
3.63E-09
2.96E-09
3.10E-09
3.15E-09
7.81E-06
4.49E-07
34,800
902,000
200,000
2,590,000
362,000
34,300
386,000
294,000
221,000
12,700,000
252
13,300,000
357,000
435,000
483,000
2,450,000
76,500
206,000
12,500,000
556,000
613,000
432,000
300,000
415,000
2,580,000
89,200
34,800
2,610,000
108,000
551,000
24,400
281,000
180,000
573,000
1,330,000
5,190,000
13,800,000
1,780,000
460,000
3,440,000
4,570,000
4,810,000
2,200,000
6,710
163,000
6.89E+00
2.73E+00
2.16E-02
S.15E-01
1.71E-01
9.50E+00
1.02E-01
7.37E-02
1.19E+01
1.17E+01
1.19E-01
4.79E+00
9.51E+00
6.50E-01
1.47E-01
5.39E+00
2.70E+00
1.89E+01
1.64E+00
3.33E+00
4.08E-01
2.75E+01
1.68E-02
4.86E-01
1.47E+01
2.33E+00
1.13E+00
1.91E-01
1.26E+00
2.57E+00
5.36E-01
9.66E+00
3.07E+00
4.61E-02
1.17E-01
1.65E-01
1.54E+00
9.24E-02
1.17E-02
6.67E-02
1.09E-01
1.45E-01
1.23E-01
1.49E-01
4.93E-01
(0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001890,000.
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001710,000.
<0.0001720,000.
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001890,000.
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001 ***********
<0.0001450,000.
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001310,000.
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001570,000.
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
-------
Suamary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-MaxiBun-
Lif«ti»e
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
TABLE D-3. (continued)
SIC« CAS-
Minimum
Cone People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 9 of 9
4.62E-OS
2.74E-05
1.38E-05
9.42E-06
3.68E-06
l.OOE-38
l.OOE-38
769
1,310
43
489
203
3.55E-02
3.58E-02
5.93E-04
4.61E-03
7.46E-04
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
2.95B-07
2.97E-07
4.92E-09
3.82E-08
6.20E-09
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
3.83E-10
2.27E-10
1.14E-10
7.82E-11
3.05E-11
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
7.57E-07
5.73E-07
S.93E-08
2.70E-06
4.51E-08
l.OOE+38
l.OOE+38
118,000
423,000
87,400
536
552,000
3.63E-01
1.72E+00
1.25E-01
4.73E-03
1.15E-01
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
<0.0001 ***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
52 KERR-MCGEE CHEM. COB KESID
392 PEORXA DISPOSAL CO. PEORI
123 UNION CARBIDE SEADR
234 NEVADA REF. TOHOP
37 ETHYL CORF. BATON
130 ALDRICH CHEMICALS MZI.HA
136 ARCO ALASKA KUPAR
701,000,000 1.44E+06
0.17
5.9
Overall
-------
TABLE D-4. HEM RESULTS FOR CASE 2 (BASELINE MAXIMUM)
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
— Maximum —
Lifetiae
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
SIC»
CAS*
--Minimum--
Conc People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 1 of 9
2.78E+02
2.47E+02
2.35E+02
2.21E+02
2.05E+02
1.93E+02
1.79E+02
1.69E+02
1.68E+02
1.61E+02
1.50E+02
1.48E+02
1.46E+02
1.42E+02
1.41E+02
1.34E+02
1.29E+02
1.27E+02
1.22E+02
1.15E+02
1.15E+02
1.11E+02
1.07E+02
1.07E-I-02
1.04E+02
1.03E+02
1.03E+02
9.82E+01
9.75E+01
9.50E+01
9.32E+01
9.23E+01
8.87E+01
8.70E-H01
8.27E-I-01
8.06E+01
7.97E+01
7.80E+01
7.76E+01
7.72E+01
6.90E+01
6.88E+01
6.82E+01
6.75E+01
6.70E+01
1
<1
6
18
<1
<1
1
<1
<1
1
10
111
11
1
2
<1
<1
17
1
4
<1
4
97
<1
<1
<1
1
1
18
3
2
<1
2
1
<1
<1
46
9
1
6
<1
1
18
13
1
2.81E+02
1.17E+02
1.43E+03
3.95E+03
9.90E+00
3.86E+01
1.48E+02
3.38E+01
3.58E+01
1.49E+02
1.49E+03
1.64EH-04
1.64E+03
9.62E+01
2.99E+02
1.38E+01
5.13E+01
2.10E+03
1.34E+02
4.30E+02
S.10E+01
4.33E*02
1.04E+04
1.36E+01
1.16E+01
3.58E+01
8.61E+01
8.99E+01
1.72E+03
2.43EM) .
1 .S2E+Oi
I.IOE^OI
2.04E+02
7.96E*01
9.76E+00
3.83E+00
3.66E+03
6.87E+02
4.98E-I-01
4.38E*0:
3.96E-01
8.04E<-01
1.20E+0:
s.soz-i-c:
3.7-=Z-:.
2.34E-03
9.71E-04
1.18E-02
3.28E-02
8.21E-OS
3.21E-04
1.22E-03
2.80E-04
2.97E-04
1.23E-03
1.23E-02
1.36E-01
1.36E-02
7.99E-04
2.48E-03
1.1SE-04
4.26E-04
1.74E-02
1.12E-03
3.57E-03
4.24E-04
3.59E-03
8.59E-02
1.13E-04
9.64E-05
2.97E-04
7.15E-04
7.46E-04
1.43E-02
I.01E-03
1.34E-03
9.10E-05
1.70E-03
6.61E-04
8.10E-05
3.18G-05
3.03E-02
5.70E-03
4.13E-04
3.64E-03
3.29E-06
•i . 68E-04
9.96E-03
7.05E-03
3.11E-04
2.30E-03
2.0SE-03
1.9SE-03
1.83E-03
1.70E-03
1.60E-03
1.49E-03
1.40E-03
1.39E-03
1.34E-03
1.24E-03
1.23E-03
1.21E-03
1.18E-03
1.17E-03
1.11E-03
1.07E-03
1.05E-03
1.01E-03
9.S4E-04
9.51E-04
9.23E-04
8.90E-04
. 88E-04
. 61E-04
.58E-04
.55E-04
.1SE-04
.09E-04
7.88E-04
7.74E-04
7.66E-04
7.36E-04
7.22E-04
6.86E-04
6.S9E-04
6.62E-04
6.48E-04
6.44E-04
6.41E-04
5.73E-04
5.71E-04
5.6SE-04
5.60E-04
5.56E-04
4.77E-03
7.80E-03
4.20E-03
7.92E-03
4.04E-03
8.23E-03
4.31E-03
1.55E-03
5.86E-03
5.38E-03
S.16E-03
2.39E-03
3.80E-03
4.94E-03
4.27E-03
8.99E-04
3.31E-03
3.39E-03
7.73E-04
2.32E-03
6.66E-04
1.83E-03
3.60E-03
6.10E-03
4.08E-03
3.70E-03
8.17E-04
1.97E-03
4.05E-03
6.19E-04
3.60E-03
3.25E-03
2.72E-03
2.40E-03
2.89E-03
3.30E-03
S.26E-04
1.10E-03
2.39E-03
1.33E-03
5.04E-04
3.10E-03
2.41E-03
2.66E-03
1.94E-03
361,000
695,000
327,000
556,000
2,590,000
1,140,000
392,000
125,000
382,000
228,000
5,420,000
8,090,000
7,970,000
397,000
3,070,000
339,000
857,000
8,460,000
344,000
2,920,000
364,000
8,070,000
333,000
1,190,000
359,000
377,000
228,000
2,670,000
52,700
893,000
720,000
1,900,000
225,000
171,000
1,510,000
2,060,000
338,000
12,700,000
1,270,000
7,880,000
230,000
159,000
6,550,000
4,840,000
388,000
1.92E+04
9.61E+04
2.11E+05
2.38E+05
1.46E+05
5.62E+04
3.06E+04
3.35E+03
4.07E+04
2.37E+04
3.29E+05
4.95E+05
3.32E+05
4.92E+04
1.27E+05
5.93E+04
1.71E+04
3.21E+05
3.91E+04
8.13E+04
1.37E+04
2.45E+05
1.21E+05
2.12E+05
2.57E+04
2.88E+04
4.73E+03
8.45E+04
6.13E+04
2.45E+04
1.79E+04
4.60E+04
2.41E+04
4.18E+03
2.55E+04
4.93E+04
7.84E+04
3.18E+05
1.82E+04
1.46E+05
2.36E+03
1.60E+04
1.27E+05
1.99E-1-05
1.80E+04
0.0023
0.011
0.025
0.028
0.017
0.0067
0.0036
0.0004
0.0048
0.0028
0.039
0.059
0.039
0.0058
0.015
0.0070
0.0020
0.038
0.0046
0.0096
0.0016
0.029
0.014
0.025
0.0031
0.0034
0.0006
0.010
0.0073
0.0029
0.0021
0.0055
0.0029
0.0005
0.0030
0.0058
0.0093
0.038
0.0022
0.017
0.0003
0.0019
0.015
0.024
0.0021
440.
88.
40.
35.
58.
150.
280.
2,500.
210.
360.
26.
17.
25.
170.
67.
140.
490.
26.
220.
100.
620.
34.
70.
40.
330.
290.
1,800.
100.
140.
340.
470.
180.
350.
2,000.
330.
170.
110.
27.
460.
58.
3,600.
530.
66.
42.
470.
132 MOBAY CHEMICAL CORF HEW N
266 AMOCO TEXAS
7 VflTCO CORP. OILOA
209 EXXON CORP BATON
290 SHELL OIL DEER
218 BP OIL BELLE
108 DUPONT BEAUN
304 ARCO PETROLEUM FERND
352 ASHLAND CHEMICAL BOYD
207 CITGO PETROLEUM LAKE
190 AMOCO CHEMICAL WHITI
169 SHELL OIL WILMI
149 CHEVRON EL SE
286 MOBIL OIL BEAUM
150 CHEVRON RICHM
267 CHAMPLIN PETROLEUM C CORPU
121 MONSANTO CO ALVIN
161 MOBIL OIL TORRA
270 COASTAL REFINING CORPU
176 UNION OIL OF CALIFOR RODEO
281 KOCH INDUSTRIES CORFU
172 TEXACO REFINING HILMI
247 STANDARD OIL OF OHIO LIMA
214 MOBIL CHALK
293 STAR REF. FORT
201 ASHLAND PETROLEUM CO ASHLA
309 TEXACO USA ANACO
271 CROWN CENTRAL HOUST
103 CELANESE CORF. FAMPA
92 UNION CARBIDE CARIBE PONCZ
213 MARATHON PETROLEUM GAR7V
224 KOCH REFINING ROSEM
208 CONOCO CHEMICALS WESTL
288 PHILLIPS SWECH
187 MOBIL OIL JOLIE
188 SHELL OIL HOOD
292 SOUTHWESTERN REFININ CORFU
238 EXXON LINDE
217 SHELL CHEM CO NORCO
174 UNION OIL OF CALIFOR WILMI
306 SHELL OIL ANACO
186 MARATHON PETROLEUM ROBIN
189 UNION OIL OF CALIFOR LEMON
237 COASTAL EAGLE FT. WESTV
295 UNION OIL OF CALIFOR NEDER
-------
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maxinum-
Lifetiae
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
TABLE D-4. (continued)
SIC» CAS.
--Mini
Cone People
Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Pag* 2 of 9
S o u r c
6.69E+01
6.46E+01
6.17E+01
6.13E+01
6.10E+01
5.79E+01
5.27E+01
5.23E-KH
4.92E+01
4.68E+01
4.31E+01
3.92E+01
3.88E+01
3.87E+01
3.84E+01
3.70E+01
3.58E+01
3.52E+01
3.26E+01
3.22E+01
3.20E+01
3.20E+01
3.14E+01
3.03E+01
3.03E+01
3.00E+01
2.97E+01
2.82E+01
2.68E+01
2.65E+01
2.60E+01
2.58E+01
2.53E+01
2.48E+01
2.46E+01
2.46E+01
2.37E+01
2.25E+01
2.25E+01
2.21E+01
2.17E+01
2.14E+01
2.11E+01
2.10E+01
2.09E-I-01
33
21
<1
3
207
1
<1
1
<1
1
27
<1
<1
89
3
4
IB
<1
3
13
44
1
<1
1
<1
4
<1
4
1
2
<1
7
1
<1
6
2
<1
1
1
15
1
<1
2
<1
<1
2
1
3
2
1
8
2
2
8
6
1
1
9
3
1
1
6
5
1
4
1
2
5
2
1
1
4
1
2
5
4
1
3
4
1
3
9
2
2
3
1
8
4
3
1
.18E+03
.37E+03
.18E+00
.11E+02'
. 27E+04
. 34E+01
.18E+01
.95E+01
.07E-01
.83E+01
.17E-I-03
.23E+01
.35E-01
.45E+03
.12E+02
.42E+02
.27E+02
. 39E+00
.13E+02
.24E+02
.42E+03
.59E+01
.52E-01
. 62E-I-01
.02E+01
. 22E+02
.42E-01
.14E+02
.93E+01
.76E+01
.59E-01
.69E+02
.15E+01
.46E+00
.51E+02
.77E+01
.21E+00
.41E+01
-73E+01
.25E-I-02
.38E+01
.84E-01
,56E*01
.6tiE-njO
.1 ,E-O:
1.S1E-02
1.14E-02
2.64E-05
1.75E-03
1.05E-01
6.92E-04
1.81E-04
2.4SE-04
6.70E-06
S.67E-04
9.71E-03
1.02E-04
7.76E-06
2.86E-02
9.27E-04
1.18E-03
S.20E-03
4.47E-05
9.38E-04
3.52E-03
1.18E-02
2.15E-04
4.S8E-06
2.18E-04
8.46E-05
1.01E-03
3.67E-06
9.43E-04
2.43E-04
4.78E-04
3.81E-06
1.40E-03
2.61E-04
3.71E-05
1.25E-03
3.13E-04
7.64E-05
2.00E-04
2.26E-04
2.70E-03
1.14E-04
7.33E-06
3.78E-04
3.04E-05
9.44E-06
5.55E-04
S.36E-04
5.12E-04
5.09E-04
S.06E-04
4.81E-04
4.37E-04
4.34E-04
4.09E-04
3.88E-04
3.58E-04
3.25E-04
3.22E-04
3.22E-04
3.19E-04
3.07E-04
2.97E-04
2.92E-04
2.71E-04
2.67E-04
2.66E-04
2.65E-04
2.60E-04
2.52E-04
2.51E-04
2.49E-04
2.47E-04
2.34E-04
2.23E-04
2.20E-04
2.16E-04
2.14E-04
2.10E-04
2.06E-04
2.04E-04
2.04E-04
1.97E-04
1.87E-04
1.86E-04
1.83E-04
1.80E-04
1.77E-04
1.75E-04
1.75E-04
1.73E-04
3.27E-03
2.53E-03
2.43E-03
2.22E-03
1.73E-03
3.38E-03
4.11E-04
1.56E-03
1.93E-03
2.25E-03
1.66E-03
1.63E-03
7.19E-04
1.27E-03
6.65E-04
1.36E-03
2.14E-03
7.40E-04
S.91E-04
1.17E-03
1.25E-03
4.76E-03
8.14E-04
2.56E-04
3.47E-04
2.73E-04
1.42E-03
5.58E-04
1.19E-03
1.56E-04
6.76E-04
8.64E-04
6.60E-04
4.75E-04
1.05E-03
1.06E-03
1.88E-04
3.04E-04
4.38E-04
3.61E-04
5.22E-04
6.28E-04
1.94E-04
2.69E-04
3.66E-04
4
1
4
8
1
4
4
2
2
1
4
4
2
3
8
2
3
1
1
817,000
,450,000
,220,000
,750,000
,640,000
707,000
151,000
772,000
,400,000
838,000
,440,000
,830,000
379,000
,680,000
134,000
,280,000
,190,000
,900,000
147,000
697,000
,900,000
,450,000
763,000
259,000
17,500
88,000
,380,000
,320,000
55,300
358,000
763,000
676,000
313,000
192,000
,090,000
971,000
34,700
,220,000
325,000
625,000
,640,000
346,000
335,000
,760,000
75,300
9.34E+04
1.26E+05
1.S4E+04
6.06E+04
3.71E+05
3.78E+04
1.S5E-I-03
2.47E+04
1.82E+04
2.34E+04
1.02E+05
8.02E+04
3.90E+03
7.96E+04
7.13E+03
4.85E+04
6.98E+04
3.56E+04
6.69E+03
2.05E+04
2.07E+05
1.11E+05
5.15E+03
7.11E+03
3.29E+02
3.17E+03
2.66E+04
7.17E+04
2.33E+03
4.39E-t-03
4.28E+03
1.36E+04
2.74E+03
1.69E+03
1.70E+04
6.39E+03
1.03E+03
1.03E+04
1.24E+04
1.43E4-04
1.42E+04
1.46E+03
6.95E+03
8.33E-I-03
7.10E-F03
0.011
0.015
0.0022
0.0072
0.044
0.0045
0.0002
0.0029
0.0022
0.0028
0.012
0.0095
0.0005
0.0094
0.0008
0.0058
0.0083
0.0042
0.0008
0.0024
0.025
0.013
0.0006
0.0008
<0.0001
0.0004
0.0032
0.0085
0.0003
0.0005
0.0005
0.0016
0.0003
0.0002
0.0020
0.0008
0.0001
0.0012
0.0015
0.0017
0.0017
0.0002
0.0008
0.0010
0.0008
90
67
460
140
23
220
5,400
340
460
360
82
110
2,200
110
1,200
170
120
240
1,300
410
41
76
1,600
1,200
26,000
2,700
320
120
3,600
1,900
2,000
620
3,100
5,000
500
1,300
8,200
820
680
590
590
5,800
1,200
1,000
1,200
249 SUN CO. TOLED
263 SUN PETROLEUM M&RCU
10 STANDARD CHLORIDE CB DELAW
394 WASTE CONVERSION HATFI
175 UNOCAL LOS A
47 PARTE-DAVIS HOLLA
307 SOHIO PERND
124 UNION CARBIDE CORP TEXAS
179 STAR REF. DELAW
248 STANDARD OIL OF OHIO TOLED
262 BF OIL MARCU
240 MOBIL OIL PAULS
199 TEXACO REFINING EL DO
278 RILL PETROLEUM HOUST
196 FARMLAND INDUSTRIES COFFX
346 U.S. STEEL CORP. CLAIR
215 MURPHT OIL CORPORATI MERAU
58 BASF W7ANDOTTE CORP. JAMES
198 NATIONAL COOPERATIVE MCPHE
279 HILL PETROLEUM TEXAS
257 ATLANTIC REFINING PHILA
284 LYONDELL PETROCHEMIC HOUST
183 HAWAII INDEP. REF. EWA B
282 LA GLORIA OIL AND GA TYLER
317 SINCLAIR OIL SINCL
255 TOTAL PETROLEUM ARDMO
388 MICHIGAN DISPOSAL IN BELLE
72 STAUFFER CHEMICAL CO EDISO
287 PHILLIPS 66 REFINERY BORGE
296 VALERO ENERGY CORF. CORPU
182 CHEVRON HONOL
285 MARATHON OIL TEXAS
51 FIRST CHEMICAL CORP PASCA
264 UNITED REF. WARRE
185 CLARK OIL & REF. HARTF
303 AMOCO OIL REFINERY YORKT
273 DIAMOND SHAMROCK REP THREE
164 PACIFIC REF. . HERCU
171 TEXACO REFINING BAKER
253 SINCLAIR OIL TULSA
178 CONOCO COMME
355 HANSBROUGH ENERGY CROWL
323 GULF STATES GADSD
310 U.S. OIL t REFINING TACOM
314 AMOCO CASPE
-------
Sunnary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maximum-
Lifetiae
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
TABLE D-4. (continued)
SIC-
CAS-
--Mini
Cone People
Annual Repeat
Exposure Incidence Interval
Page 3 of 9
2.08E+01
2.07E+01
2.07E-t-01
2.06E+01
2.05E+01
1.99E+01
1.98E+01
1.98E+01
1.96E+01
1.94E+01
1.91E+01
l.SlE-t-01
1.78E+01
1.76E-I-01
1.73E+01
1.67E+01
1.66E+01
1.65E+01
1.63E+01
1.63E+01
1.62E+01
1.56E+01
1.56E+01
1.52E+01
1.52E+01
1.49E+01
1.48E+01
1.46E+01
1.44E+01
1.41E+01
1.40E+01
1.39E+01
1.39E+01
1.37E+01
1.35E+01
1.34E+01
1.33E+01
1.33E+01
1.32E+01
1.27E+01
1.21E+01
1.20E+01
1.19E4-01
1.16E+01
1.12E4-01
12
1
1
3
<1
28
5
2
14
13
4
13
105
<1
42
14
48
2
1
3
25
<1
30
36
1
34
<1
12
28
54
22
8
2
16
<1
16
71
<1
<1
44
7
2
1
<1
2
2.47E+02
1.08E+01
2.02E+01
6.24E+01
8.90E+00
5.49E+02
1.06E+02
2.99E+01
2.82E+02
2.50E+02
6.76E+01
2.43E+02
1.88E-1-03
1.31E+00
7.17E+02
2.27E-I-02
8.00E+02
3.59E+01
1.34E+01
4.22E+01
3.98E+02
3.93E-01
4.70E+02
5.48E4-02
8.11E+00
5.01E+02
8.08E-01
1.69E+02
4.08 E-hO 2
7.66 EtO 2,
3.06E+02
1.07E+02
2.32E+01
2.22E-I-02
2.65E+00
2.12E+02
9.45E4-02
4.41E-COO
3.35E+-00
5.51Et02
8.31E4-01
2.56E1-01
9.3-1E+00
1.13E+-00
2.35£(-01
2.
9.
1.
5.
7.
4.
a.
2.
2.
2.
5.
2.
1.
1.
5.
1.
6.
2.
1.
3.
3.
3.
3.
4.
6.
4 .
6.
1.
3.
6 .
2.
3.
1.
1.
2.
1.
7.
3.
Z.
1 .
6 .
2 _
3.
9.
L.
OSE-03
OOE-05
68E-04
18E-04
38E-05
55E-03
79E-04
48E-04
34E-03
07E-03
61E-04
01E-03
56E-02
09E-05
95E-03
89E-03
64E-03
98E-04
11E-04
50E-04
30E-03
26E-06
90E-03
55E-03
73E-05
16E-03
71E-06
40E-03
39E-03
36E-03
54E-03
88E-04
92E-04
84E-03
20E-05
76E-03
84E-03
66E-05
78E-05
57E-03
90E-04
13E-04
17E-05
40E-06
9SE-04
1.73E-04
1.72E-04
1.72E-04
1.71E-04
1.70E-04
1.65E-04
1.65E-04
1.64E-04
1.63E-04
1.61E-04
1.58E-04
1.50E-04
1.48E-04
1.46E-04
1.43E-04
1.39E-04
1.37E-04
1.37E-04
1.35E-04
1.35E-04
1.35E-04
1.29E-04
1.29E-04
1.26E-04
1.26E-04
1.24E-04
1.23E-04
1.21E-04
1.20E-04
1.17E-04
1.16E-04
1.16E-04
1.1SE-04
1.14E-04
1.12E-04
1.11E-04
1.11E-04
1.10E-04
1.10E-04
1.05E-04
l.OOE-04
9.97E-05
9.89E-05
9.63E-05
9.28E-05
2.57E-04
2.19E-04
4.87E-04
2.65E-03
7.80E-04
4.94E-04
7.03E-04
5.79E-04
3.15E-04
7.21E-04
8.84E-04
3.45E-04
2.63E-04
5.12E-04
6.60E-04
2.67E-04
7.51E-04
4.44E-04
2.75E-04
1.95E-04
1.04E-03
5.49E-04
2.65E-04
2.29E-04
2.71E-04
3.88E-04
2.60E-04
4.62E-04
3.83E-04
1.93E-04
4.88E-04
1.19E-04
3.45E-04
2.52E-04
1.68E-04
1.72E-04
1.63E-04
4.02E-04
1.93E-04
3.13E-03
7.88E-04
6.91E-04
6.13E-04
2.10E-04
8.96E-04
11,600,000
92,200
1,270,000
364,000
38,900
92,800
6,360,000
399,000
921,000
1,970,000
3,810,000
2,590,000
8,550,000
154,000
2,310,000
12,200,000
2,760,000
555,000
725,000
810,000
494,000
5,490,000
8,170,000
8,630,000
110,000
381,000
75,300
78,500
1,160,000
1,940,000
2,190,000
837,000
1,630,000
463,000
108,000
111,000
131,000
790,000
69,300
8,180,000
434,000
1,160,000
1,030,000
924,000
1,220,000
6.54E+04
6.32E+02
6.31E+03
1.58E+04
6.92E+02
1.29E+04
6.67E+04
3.33E+03
1.36E+04
1.85E+04
2.90E4-04
2.96E+04
7.34E+04
6.85E+02
4.78E-I-04
5.75E+04
2.69E-I-04
5.74E+03
4.52E+03
1.16E+04
2.28E+04
1.48E-I-04
4.36E+04
5.87E+04
1.15E+03
1.74E+04
5.05E+03
5.35E+03
2.27E-I-04
2.08E4-04
1.65E+04
7.51E+03
1.08E+04
1.52E+04
2.60E+03
8.41E+03
6.74E+03
7.70E+03
4.54E+03
4.46E+05
7.61E+03
7.00E+03
7.54E+03
2.67E-(-03
1.76E-I-04
0.0078
0.0001
0.0007
0.0019
0.0001
0.0015
0.0081
0.0004
0.0016
0.0022
0.0034
0.0035
0.0087
0.0001
0.0057
0.0068
0.0032
0.0007
0.0005
0.0014
0.0027
0.0017
0.0052
0.0070
0.0001
0.0021
0.0006
0.0006
0.0027
0.0025
0.0020
0.0009
0.0013
0.0018
0.0003
0.0010
0.0008
0.0009
0.0005
0.053
0.0009
0.0008
0.0009
0.0003
0.0021
130.
13,000.
1,300.
530.
12,000.
650.
120.
2,500.
620.
460.
290.
280.
110.
12,000.
180.
150.
310.
1,500.
1,900.
730.
370.
570.
190.
140.
7,300.
490.
1,700.
1,600.
370.
400.
510.
1,100.
780.
560.
3,200.
1,000.
1,300.
1,100.
1,900.
19.
1,100.
1,200.
1,100.
3,200.
480.
236
252
71
277
276
145
184
109
297
319
222
341
165
225
343
235
153
216
348
320
268
330
154
152
200
203
316
245
342
381
338
244
177
195
232
231
289
322
315
147
135
193
349
302
246
CHEVRON
KERR MCGEE
SOUTHLAND CORP.
FINA OIL t CHEMICAL
FINA OIL
LION OIL
CLARK OIL & REFINING
E I DUPONT DE NEMOUR
297 AMOCO OIL REFINERY
ASHLAND PETROLEUM
MARATHON PET.
LTV STEEL
165 PARAMOUNT PET.
225 AMERADA HESS
LTV STEEL COMPANY
235 AMERADA-HESS
EXXON
PLACID REFINING
U.S. STEEL CORP.
ABC COKE
CHEVRON
INLAND STEEL
154 FLETCHER OIL £ REFIH
152 EDGINGTON OIL COMPAN
TOTAL PETROLEUM
PEHNZOIL
LITTLE AMERICA REF.
AMOCO
BETHLEHEM STEEL CORP
CECOS
338 ARMCO INC
244 CIBRO PETROLEUM
177 COLORADO REF.
195 DERBY REFINING COMPA
EXXON
231 CONOCO REFINERY
289 PRIDE REFINING
KOPPERS
315 FRONTIER OIL
147 ATLANTIC RICHFIELD
135 LOUISIANA LAND t EXP
ROCK ISLAND REFINING
349 WHEELING PITT
PHILLIPS 66
246 ASHLAND OIL
PERTH
WYNNE
GREAT
PORT
BIG S
EL DO
BLUE
ORANG
SALT
ST. P
DETRO
CLEVZ
PARAM
PURVI
PITTS
PORT
BENIC
PORT
PROVO
TARRA
EL PA
E CHI
WILMI
LONG
ARKAR
SHREV
CASPE
MANDA
BETHL
STAMF
MIDDL
ALBAN
COMME
WICHI
BILLI
BILLI
ABILE
WOODW
CHEYE
CARSO
SAHAL
INDIA
E STE
MOODS
CANTO
-------
Sunmary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maximum-
Lifetiae
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
TABLE D-4. (continued)
SIC-
CAS-
--MiniBum--
Conc People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 4 of 9
1.11E+01
1.09E+01
1.02E+01
9.65E+00
9.61E+00
.72E+00
.70E+00
.45E-t-00
.20E+00
.OOE+00
7.92E+00
7.89E+00
7.84E+00
7.61E+00
7.47E+00
7.43E+00
7.20E+00
7.17E+00
6.97E+00
6.94E+00
6.88E+00
6.41E+00
6.07E+00 '
5.92E+00
5.84E+00
5.82E+00
5.57£+00
5.55E+00
5.27E+00
5.12E-fOO
5.04E+00
4.93E+00
4.86E+00
4.77E+00
4.77E-»-00
4.56E+00
4.49E+00
4.23E+00
4.11E-t-00
4.11E-I-00
4.07E+00
4.05E+00
4.02E+00
3.99E+00
3.96E+00
3
<1
2
4.79E+02
1.19E+04
l.OSE+04
8.51E+03
5.39E+03
3.28E+04
1.10E+04
2.76E+03
4.12E+03
6.53E+03
2.03E+03
5.20E+03
3.14E+04
1.32E+04
1.20E+05
3.90E+02
1.96E+03
1.81E+04
3.50E+04
1.13E+04
l.BOE-t-04
7.37E+03
5.33E+03
2.64E+03
2.95E+03
3.95E+03
5.15E+03
1.14E+04
1.80E+03
8.38E+04
1.34E+02
1.03E+03
9.80E+02
1.02E+04
0.0002
0.0003
0.0006
0.0008
0.0001
0.0001
0.0006
0.0010
0.0002
0.0043
0.0001
0.0001
0.0014
0.0012
0.0010
0.0006
0.0039
0.0013
0.0003
0.0005
0.0008
0.0002
0.0006
0.0037
0.0016
0.014
<0.0001
0.0002
0.0021
0.0041
0.0013
0.0021
0.0009
0.0006
0.0003
0.0004
0.0005
0.0006
0.0013
0.0002
0.0099
cO.OOOl
0.0001
0.0001
0.0012
5,300.
3,200.
1,600.
1,300.
17,000.
9,600.
1,600.
1,000.
4,200.
230.
9,600.
18,000.
710.
800.
990.
1,600.
260.
770.
3,100.
2,000.
1,300.
4,100.
1,600.
270.
640.
70.
22,000.
4,300.
470.
240.
750.
470.
1,100.
1,600.
3,200.
2,900.
2,100.
1,600.
740.
4,700.
100.
63,000.
8,100.
8,600.
830.
230
291
45
298
211
194
280
294
313
168
110
241
350
324
239
354
173
274
308
335
332
339
162
269
329
166
260
180
148
98
327
326
325
159
167
337
331
334
345
300
156
229
91
191
256
230 CENEX REF.
291 SHELL OIL REFINERY
45 VISTA CHEMICAL
298 BIG WEST OIL
211 HILL PETROLEUM
194 DERBT REF.
280 HOWELL HYDROCARBONS
294 TEIFINERT
313 MURPHY OIL CORFORATI
168 SHELL OIL
EASTMAN KODAK, INC.
241 BLOOMFIELD REFINING
350 DETROIT COKE
324 SLOSS INDUSTRIES
239 MANTUA OIL
354 ENVIROSAFE SERVICES
173 TOSCO CORP.
274 EL PASO REFINING
308 SOUND REF.
335 TONAWANDA
332 ARMCO INC.
339 NEW BOSTON COKE
162 NEWHALL REFINING CO.
CHEVRON
329 CITIZENS GAS
166 POWERING OIL
PENNZOIL COMPANY
AMOCO
CHEMOIL
AMERICAN HOECHST COR
327 LTV STEEL
326 ACME STEEL
325 NATIONAL STEEL
N OIL & REFINING
167 SAN JOAQUIN REF.
337 LTV STEEL
331 U.S. STEEL CORP.
334 NATIONAL STEEL GROUP
SHEBANGO
CEYSEN REFINING
156 GOLDEN WEST REFINING
229 SOUTHLAND OIL
91 UNION CARBIDE
191 INDIANA FARM BUREAU
LAURE
ODESS
BALTZ
SALT
ST. R
EL DO
SAN A
CORFU
SUPER
MARTI
LONGV
BLOOM
DETRI
BIRMI
THORO
ORE GO
MARTI
EL PA
TACOH
TONAW
ASHLA
PORTS
NEWHA
PORT
INDIA
SANTA
ROUSE
SAVAN
SIGNA
HOUST
S CHI
CHICA
GRAHI
BAKER
BAKER
WARRE
GARY
ECORS
SHENA
WOODS
SANTA
SANDE
MT. V
PORTL
-------
TABLE D-4. (continued)
Suanary for BENZENE
with a Unit Risk of
REFINERIES
8.30E-06
-Maxinun-
Lifetiae
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
SIC»
CAS-
M i n i a u •
Cone People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 5 of 9
S o u r c
C*'
3.95E+00
3.92E+00
3.82E+00
3.79E+00
3.59E+00
3.59E+00
3.52E+00
3.46E+00
3.46E+00
3.42E+00
3.18E+00
3.16E+00
3.12E+00
3.01E+00
2.84E+00
2.83E+00
2.70E+00
2.65E+00
2.57E+00
2.57E+00
2.46E+00
2.41E+00
2.39E+00
2.34E+00
2.33E+00
2.27E+00
2.24E+00
2.22E+00
2.22E+00
2.10E+00
2.10E+00
2.03E+00
2.02E+00
2.01E+00
1.96E+00
1.90E+00
1.81E+00
1.77E+00
1.70E+00
1.55E+00
1.55E+00
1.54E+00
1.52E+00
1.42E+00
1.37E+00
705
7
<1
<1
21
1
1
2
<1
1
1
<1
<1
1
12
4
1
16
2
4
3
3
6
50
40
1
<1
1
<1
9
<1
17
1
111
4
2
723
1
12
2
24
4,530
<1
3
40
2.78E+03
2.90E+01
8.69E-01
9.56E-02
7.62E+01
2.39E+00
4.27E+00
5.25E+00
7.82E-01
2.80E+00
2.05E+00
6.40E-01
6.84E-01
2.98E+00
3.50E+01
1.22E+01
3.45E+00
4.12E+01
5.30E+00
9.70E+00
6.68E-M)0
6.44E+00
1.45E+01
1.16E+02
9.34E+01
2.53E+00
2.39E-01
2.30E+00
5.99E-02
1.98E+01
4.73E-OL
3.48E+01
2.83E+00
2.23E<-02
7.82E+00
3.79E+00
1.31E-I-03
1.56E+00
1.97E*01
3.30E+00
3.65E+01
6.98E+OJ
I.OSE-O:
4 . 90Z*0:j
5. 45£-tOL
2
2
7
7
6
1
3
4
6
2
1
5
5
2
2
1
2
3
4
8
5
S
1
9
7
2
1
1
4
1
3
2
2
1
6
3
1
1
1
1
3
5
3
4
4
.31E-02
.41E-04
.21E-06
.94E-07
.32E-04
.98E-05
.55E-05
.36E-05
.49E-06
.32E-05
.70E-05
. 31E-06
. 68E-06
.47E-05
. 91E-04
.01E-04
. 86E-05
.42E-04
. 40E-05
.05E-05
.55E-05
. 34E-05
.21E-04
.64E-04
.76E-04
. 10E-05
. 98E-06
. 91E-05
.97E-07
. 64E-04
. 92E-06
. 89E-04
.35E-05
. 85E-03
. 49E-05
.14E-05
.09E-02
.30E-05
. 64E-04
. 74E-05
. 03E-04
. 79E-02
.71E-08
.06E-05
.52E-04
3.28E-05
3.25E-05
3.17E-05
3.15E-05
2.98E-05
2.98E-05
2.92E-05
2.88E-05
2.87E-05
2.84E-05
2.64E-05
2.63E-05
2.59E-05
2.50E-OS
2.36E-05
2.35E-05
2.24E-05
2.20E-05
2.14E-05
2.13E-05
2.04E-05
2.00E-05
1.99E-05
1.95E-05
1.93E-05
1.88E-05
1.86E-05
1.S4E-05
1.84E-05
1.74E-05
1.74E-05
1.69E-05
1.67E-05
1.67E-05
1.63E-05
1.58E-05
1.51E-05
1.47E-05
1.41E-05
1.29E-OS
1.28E-05
1.28E-05
1.26E-05
1.18E-05
1.13E-05
5.01E-03
2.04E-04
7.25E-05
1.30E-04
2.09E-05
1.46E-04
6.85E-05
5.04E-04
6.61E-05
9.80E-05
2.67E-05
1.38E-03
6.7SE-04
1.06E-04
1.07E-04
5.22E-05
9.01E-05
4.87E-04
7.89E-05
5.55E-05
1.98E-05
1.44E-04
4.28E-05
4.85E-05
6.88E-05
4.95E-05
2.18E-03
7.69E-05
4.70E-05
9.43E-05
9.35E-04
3.71E-05
1.03E-04
3.25E-05
2.02E-OS
5.36E-05
1.20E-03
5.12E-05
3.00E-05
4.79E-05
3.S6E-04
1.23E-03
3.22E-05
6.91E-05
3.60E-05
2,
1,
2,
2,
10,
1,
8 ,
4,
2,
8,
2,
1,
4,
2,
2,
210,000
170,000
30,900
137,000
382,000
110,000
325,000
935,000
428,000
158,000
102,000
560,000
924,000
209,000
110,000
500,000
380,000
287,000
225,000
197,000
859,000
9,580
327,000
83,000
530,000
248,000
870,000
415,000
230,000
831,000
626,000
790,000
927,000
090,000
090,000
168,000
92,400
97,800
690,000
560,000
440,000
380,000
144,000
234,000
609,000
1.08E+OS
5.30E+03
5.99E+01
7.05E+02
1.45E+03
1.96E+03
1.94E+03
9.85E+03
S.22E+02
2.94E+02
1.56E+02
3.49E-I-04
1.92E+04
3.34E+02
2.60E+03
6.24E+03
6.19E+02
2.35E+03
7.22E+02
4.12E+02
9.04E+02
2.74E+02
2.15E+03
2.83E+03
1.11E+04
1.18E+02
2.17E+05
2.80E+02
6.68E+01
2.81E+03
1.59E+04
7.71E+03
8.24E+02
6.72E+03
1.96E+03
1.21E+02
1.09E+04
1.07E+02
1.07E+03
1.78E+03
7.75E+03
4.31E+04
3.33E+01
2.04E+02
2.15E+03
0.013
0.0006
78.
1,600.
<0. 0001140, 000.
0.0001
0.0002
0.0002
0.0002
0.0012
0.0001
<0.0001
<0.0001
0.0041
0.0023
<0.0001
0.0003
0.0007
0.0001
0.0003
0.0001
<0.0001
0.0001
<0.0001
0.0003
0.0003
0.0013
(0.0001
0.026
(0.0001
12,000.
5,800.
4,300.
4,300.
860.
16,000.
29,000.
54,000.
240.
440.
25,000.
3,200.
1,400.
14,000.
3,600.
12,000.
20,000.
9,300.
31,000.
3,900.
3,000.
760.
72,000.
39.
30,000.
<0. 0001130, 000.
0.0003
0.0019
0.0009
0.0001
0.0008
0.0002
<0.0001
0.0013
(0.0001
0.0001
0.0002
0.0009
0.0051
3,000.
530.
1,100.
10,000.
1,300.
4,300.
70,000.
780.
79,000.
7,900.
4,700.
1,100.
200.
(0.0001250,000.
(0.0001
0.0003
41,000.
3,900.
275 EXXON CORP BATTO
27 REILLI TAR AND CHEMI INDIA
301 PENNZOIL ROOSE
107 DOW CHEMICAL USA FREEP
397 TEXAS ECOLOGISTS ROBST
227 ERGON REF. VICKS
170 SUNLAND REF. BAKER
299 CHEVRON SALT
30 VULCAN MATERIALS WICHI
101 CAIN CHEMICAL BRAZO
126 WITCO CHEMICAL CORPO POINT
374 ROLLINS ENV. SERVICE DEER
265 MAPCO PETROLEUM MEMPB
151 CONOCO SANTA
347 SHARON STEEL HONES
64 INT'L FLAVORS I FRAG ONION
387 CECOS IHT'L WILLI
223 TOTAL PETROLEUM ALMA
204 CALCASICU REFINING LAKE
259 WITCO CHEMICAL CORP. BRADF
77 GENERAL ELECTRIC WATER
318 WYOMING REF. NEWCA
155 WITCO CORP. OILDA
233 MONTANA REFINING COM GREAT
160 LUNDAY-THAGARD CO. SOUTH
212 KERR-MCGEE REFINING COTTO
258 CHEVRON PHILA
80 ARIS TECH CHEMICAL HAVER
146 ANCHOR REF. KCKIT
340 TOLEDO COKE TOLED
254 SUN REFINING TULSA
44 FMC CORP. BALTI
312 QUAKER STATE OIL REF NEWEL
158 HUNTWA7 REF. WILMI
305 CHEVRON SEATT
228 SOUTHLAND OIL LUMBE
251 CONOCO PONCA
144 CROSS OIL & REFINING SMACK
181 TOUNG REF. DOUGL
57 ATLANTIC WOOD INDUST HAINE
333 BETHLEHEM STEEL CORP SPARK
97 AMERICAN HOECHST COR PASAD
283 LIQUID ENERGY CORP. BRIDG
311 MIDATLANTIC REF. ST. M
163 OXNARD REF. OXNAR
-------
TABLE D-4. (continued)
Suunary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-MaximuB-
Lifetiae
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
SIC-
CAS-
Mini
Cone People
Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 6 of 9
o
1.20E+00
1.19E+00
1.17E+00
9.90E-01
9.51E-01
8.74E-01
7.63E-01
7.SBE-01
7.52E-01
7.34E-01
7.07E-01
7.05E-01
6.63E-01
6.16E-01
5.83E-01
4.82E-01
4.74E-01
4.60E-01
4.41E-01
4.21E-01
4.17E-01
4.08E-01
3.87E-01
3.81E-01
3.80E-01
3.52E-01
3.32E-01
3.24E-01
2.41E-01
2.17E-01
2.08E-01
2.06E-01
2.06E-01
1.95E-01
1.74E-01
1.70E-01
1.59E-01
1.58E-01
1.50E-01
1.23E-01
1.20E-01
1.17E-01
1.15E-01
1.11E-01
1.05E-01
2
1
1
106
13
7
1
37
13
<1
2
1
<1
48
16
<1
<1
<1
10
28
1
1
<1
20
23
49
1
233
<1
3
17
35
163
497
2
1
6
230
28
1
163
360
22
10
38
2.40E+00
1.14E+00
8.32E-01
1.05E+02
1.24E+01
5.69E+00
7.43E-01
2.82E+01
9.7BE+00
5.72E-02
1.11E+00
4.98E-01
2.58E-01
2.98E+01
9.44E+00
4.12E-02
1.32E-02
6.95E-03
4.47E+00
1.17E+01
2.80E-01
2.39E-01
1.11E-01
7.68E+00
8.74E+00
1.72E+01
1.88E-01
7.54E+01
3.96E-02
7.12E-01
3.59E+00
7.19E+00
3.36E+01
9.70E+01
4.32E-01
9 . 84E-02
9.49E-01
3.63E+01
4.19E+00
1.34E-01
1.96E+01
4.21E-t-01
2.56E+00
I.UE+O;
•i.oc £•!••:•:
i
9
6
a
i
4
6
2
8
4
9
4
2
2
7
3
1
5
3
9
2
1
9
6
7
1
1
6
3
5
2
5
2
3
3
8
7
3
3
1
1
3
2
•)
3
.99E-05
. 46E-06
.91E-06
. 71E-04
.03E-04
.72E-05
.17E-06
.34E-04
.HE-OS
.75E-07
.19E-06
.13E-06
.14E-06
.47E-04
. 84E-05
. 42E-07
. 09E-07
.77E-08
. 71E-05
-71E-05
. 32E-06
.98E-06
.23E-07
.37E-05
. 26E-05
.43E-04
. 56E-06
. 26E-04
.29E-07
. 91E-06
. 98E-05
.97E-05
.79E-04
. 05E-04
. 59E-06
t c rt At
. 16E— 07
. 88E-06
.01E-04
.47E-05
.11E-06
. 63E-04
. 49E-04
.12E-05
. 20E-06
.32E-05
9.92E-06
9.91E-OS
9.73E-06
8.21E-06
7.89E-06
7.26E-06
6.33E-06
6.29E-06
6.24E-06
6.09E-06
5.87E-06
5.S5E-06
5.50E-06
5.11E-06
4.84E-06
4.00E-06
3.94E-06
3.82E-06
3.66E-06
3.50E-06
3.46E-06
3.38E-06
3.21E-06
3.16E-06
3.16E-06
2.92E-06
2.75E-06
2.69E-06
2.00E-06
1.80E-06
1.73E-06
1.71E-06
1.71E-06
1.62E-06
1.44E-06
1.41E— 06
1.32E-06
1.31E-06
1.24E-06
1.02E-06
9.99E-07
9.70E-07
9.55E-07
9.20E-07
8.71E-07
5.46E-05
2.99E-05
6.00E-05
3.29E-04
1.93E-05
3.S4E-05
1.33E-05
2.73E-05
7.74E-05
2.9SE-05
2.01E-05
2.39E-05
2.12E-OS
2.79E-05
4.09E-06
1.35E-05
7.94E-06
1.84E-OS
2.27E-05
4.34E-04
1.31E-05
1.12E-05
1.39E-05
9.49E-05
2.20E-03
1.29E-05
1.49E-05
6.75E-03
1.55E-05
4.79E-06
1.08E-05
3.66E-06
1.08E-04
9.22E-05
7.52E-06
5. 41E— 06
4.37E-06
5.16E-04
5.21E-06
6.86E-06
6.28E-05
8.64E-04
3.07E-06
1.34E-06
2.34E-06
166
389
292
1,270
2,690
506
300
1,190
2,580
3,430
2,110
253
551
2,760
1,230
574
925
4,450
2,070
455
511
278
6,100
333
547
1,670
1,150
284
168
834
2,390
2,540
2,640
189
4,790
42
297
2,360
2,340
372
2,640
76
93
13,300
2,600
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
, 300
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,500
,500
,000
,000
2.19E+02
1.01E+02
1.29E+02
1.45E+04
1.03E+03
1.27E+03
7.48E+01
2.07E+03
1.14E+03
7.32E+02
3.61E+02
5.18E+01
9.56E+01
l.OOE+03
1.54E+02
6.16E+01
2.04E4-02
7.40E+02
3.90E+02
1.55E+03
1.63E+02
1.68E+01
7.95E+02
1.S3E+03
7.31E+03
9.11E+02
2.57E+02
1.01E+04
1.06E+01
5.99E+01
4.33E+02
3.16E+02
4.19E+03
8.73E+02
3.S2E+02
4.50E+00
4.05E+01
4.05E+03
3.42E+02
4.04E+01
2.45E+03
6.12E+02
3.09E+01
7.73E+02
1.74E+02
<0.0001 38
<0.0001 84
<0.0001 65
0.0017
0.0001 8
0.0002 6
<0. 0001110
0.0002 4
0.0001 7
0.0001 12
<0.0001 23
<0. 0001160
<0.0001 88
0.0001 8
<0.0001 55
(0.0001140
<0.0001 41
0.0001 11
<0.0001 22
0.0002 5
<0.0001 52
<0. 0001500
0.0001 11
0.0002 5
0.0009 1
0.0001 9
<0.0001 33
0.0012
<0. 0001800
<0. 0001140
0.0001 19
<0.0001 27
0.0005 2
0.0001 9
<0.0001 24
<0. 0001210
0.0005 2
<0.0001 25
<0. 0001210
0.0003 3
0.0001 14
<0. 0001270
0.0001 11
<0.0001 48
,000.
,000.
,000.
580.
,200.
,600.
,000.
,100.
,400.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,400.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,400.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,500.
,200.
,300.
,000.
840.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,700.
,000.
,000.
,100.
,000.
,000.
,400.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
202 SOMERSET REFINER? SOMER
205 CALUMET REFINING COM PRINC
192 LAKETON REFINING LAKET
336 BETHLEHEM STEEL LACKA
359 ERIEMAY POLL. CONTRO BEDFO
221 LAKESIDE REF. KALAM
380 IT CORP.-PETROL. HAS BUTTO
369 ECOLOTEC OA7TO
78 NEPERA CHEMICAL CO., HARRI
62 DUPONT DEEPW
398 DELAWARE CONTAINERS COATS
220 CRYSTAL REF. CARSO
36 DOW CHEMICAL PLAQU
157 HUNTKAY REF. BENEC
4 ALPHA RESINS PERRI
39 RUBICON CHEMICALS IN GEISM
393 PETROCHEM RECYCLING SALT
67 MONSANTO CO BRIDG
87 ATLANTIC RICHFIELD C MONAC
74 MONTROSE CHEMICAL CO HENDE
46 DOW CORNING MIDLA
20 GOODRICH, (B.F.) HENRY
368 CHEM. WASTE MGMT. CALOM
344 ERIE COKE ERIE
219 STAR REF. CONVE
383 CECOS INT'L CINCI
129 ATLANTIC WOOD INDUST PORTS
226 CHEVRON PASCA
12 OLIN CORP. ST. M
11 ALPHA CHEMICAL LAKEL
88 CALGON CARBON NEVIL
116 HEAT ENERGY TECH. DALLA
112 GEORGIA-PACIFIC CORP PASAD
321 EMPIRE COKE COMPANY TUSCA
61 DUPONT GIBBS
104 COSDEN OIL I CHEHICA BIG S
S3 REICHHOLD CHEMICALS GULFP
328 BETHLEHEM STEEL BURNS
89 KOPPERS CO INC BRIDG
16 NIPRO, INC. AUGUS
111 GEORGIA GULF CORP. PASAD
139 HAPCO PETROLEUM NORTH
353 ENSCO EL DO
73 TROY CHEMICAL CORP., NEWAR
122 S.D.S. BIOTECH CORP. HOUST
-------
TABLE D-4. (continued)
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maxinum-
Lifetine
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
SIC»
CAS»
Minis
Cone People
u m - -
Annual Repeat
Exposure Incidence Interval
Page 7 of 9
9.16E-02
9.02E-02
8.19E-02
7.46E-02
7.39E-02
6.47E-02
5.93E-02
5.67E-02
5.45E-02
4.82E-02
4.67E-02
4.54E-02
4.31E-02
4.24E-02
3.97E-02
3.37E-02
3.14E-02
2.69E-02
2.49E-02
2.44E-02
2.38E-02
2.34E-02
1.72E-02
1.70E-02
1.63E-02
1.59E-02
1.45E-02
1.40E-02
1.35E-02
1.24E-02
1.08E-02
1.01E-02
9.22E-03
9.10E-03
7.99E-03
7.83E-03
7.61E-03
7.34E-03
7.21E-03
6.66E-03
6.57E-03
6.55E-03
6.5JE-03
6.07E-03
5.34E-03
21
70
<1
<1
1
525
80
<1
387
<1
1
2
8
<1
1,450
<1
10
7
2
<1
50
175
<1
17
<1
<1
10
109
<1
54
7
1
22
<1
1
1,150
1
845
28
360
1
2
<1
15
491
1.89E+00
6.33E+00
1.82E-02
3.32E-02
3.73E-02
3.40E+01
4.72E+00
7.55E-03
2.11E+01
2.69E-03
2.68E-02
7.43E-02
3.35E-01
5.14E-03
5.76E+01
7.62E-03
2.98E-01
1.83E-01
4.60E-02
4.12E-03
1.19E+00
4.09E4-00
3 .93E-05
2.96E-01
4 .49E-03
7.74E-04
1.38E-01
1.52E+00
3 .07E-03
6.73E-OL
7.05E-02
1.05E-02
2.03E-01
2.61E-03
8.26E-03
9.03E1-00
5.00E-03
6 .20E+00
2 .OOE-01
2.40E+00
8 .94E-03
1.38E-OZ
3 .30E-0 i
8 . 97E-OI
2.0:2--: :
i
5
1
2
3
2
3
6
1
2
2
6
2
4
4
b
2
1
3
3
9
3
J
2
J
6
1
I
i
5
5
a
i
i
>>
7
4
5
1
1
1
1
i
7
.57E-05
.25E-05
.51E-07
.76E-07
.09E-07
.82E-04
.92E-05
.27E-08
.75E-04
. 24E-08
.22E-07
.16E-07
.78E-06
.26E-08
.78E-04
.32E-08
.48E-06
. 52E-06
.82E-07
.42E-08
. 86E-06
.40E-05
-27E-10
. 46E-06
. 73E-08
43E-09
. 14E-06
.26E-05
. 54E-08
.59E-06
.85E-07
. 73E-08
. 68E-06
.17E-08
.86E-08
.50E-05
. 15E-08
.15E-05
.66E-06
.99E-05
. 42E-08
.14E-07
.74E-09
.44E-07
.18E-05
7.61E-07
7.49E-07
6.80E-07
6.19E-07
6.14E-07
5.37E-07
4.92E-07
4.70E-07
4.52E-07
4.00E-07
3.87E-07
3.77E-07
3.57E-07
3.52E-07
3.30E-07
2.79E-07
2.61E-07
2.23E-07
2.07E-07
2.03E-07
1.97E-07
1.94E-07
1.43E-07
1.41E-07
1.36E-07
1.32E-07
1.20E-07
1.16E-07
1.12E-07
1.03E-07
8.93E-08
8.35E-08
7.65E-08
7.55E-08
6.63E— 08
6.50E-08
6.32E— 08
6.09E-08
5.99E-08
5.53E-08
5.45E-08
5.44E-08
S.43E-08
5.04E-08
4.43E-08
1.44E-06
1.26E-06
2.72E-06
4.34E-07
2.25E-06
2.87E-04
1.21E-06
1.90E-06
9.78E-04
4.71E-07
1.6BE-06
1.56E-06
6.24E-07
3.49E-07
1.28E-03
6.12E-07
1.85E-05
8.52E-07
4.35E-07
4.64E-07
6.63E-04
1.65E-04
5.97E-07
9.45E-07
4.76E-07
2.81E-07
6.78E-07
1.86E-04
2.46E-07
1.70E-07
3.39E-07
4.39E-07
8.77E-04
3.26E-07
2.76E— 07
5.07E-04
.47E— 07
. 05E-05
.02E-07
.92E-05
. 04E-08
.26E-07
1.77E-07
1.66E-07
7.09E-05
12
12
9
1
2
1
2
2
2
3
2
1
1
1
2
4
1
6
1
1
,500,000
,900,000
103,000
364,000
223,000
406,000
,100,000
,800,000
27,100
,520,000
395,000
,570,000
,060,000
309,000
432,000
425,000
,690,000
,680,000
,100,000
,540,000
354,000
60,000
,260,000
,150,000
,730,000
,240,000
,250,000
25,100
425,000
,940,000
708,000
189,000
34,800
,100,000
34,300
158,000
,170,000
76,500
328 ,000
,970,000
469,000
804,000
221,000
4.19E+02
5.68E+02
1.98E+00
8.92E+00
2.18E+01
2.98E+03
2.36E+02
2.38E+01
2.68E+02
9.26E+00
1.17E+01
3.31E+01
3.54E+01
2.82E+00
3.12E+03
4.22E+00
9.11E+02
4.56E+01
4.77E+01
3.63E+01
1.22E+03
2.46E+02
3.24E+00
2.29E+01
2.68E+00
8.58E+00
4.13E+01
3.72E+01
1 . 70E+00
1.83E+01
5.70E+00
8.82E-01
5.17E+01
1.87E+01
1.01E+00
8.42E+01
6.31E+01
7.93E+00
3.49E+01
5. 82E-01
3.63E+00
8.21E-01
7.32E+00
8.44E+01
0.0001 20,000.
0.0001 15,000.
<0. 0001950, 000.
<0. 0001390, 000.
0.0004 2,800.
<0.0001 36,000.
<0. 0001350, 000.
<0.0001 31,000.
<0. 0001910, 000.
<0. 0001720, 000.
<0. 0001250, 000.
<0. 0001240, 000.
<0.0001***********
0.0004 2,700.
0.0001 9,300.
<0. 0001180, 000.
<0. 0001180, 000.
<0. 0001230, 000.
0.0001 6,900.
<0.0001 34,000.
<0. 0001370, 000.
<0. 0001980, 000.
<0. 0001200, 000.
<0. 0001230, 000.
<0. 0001460, 000.
<0. 0001*** ********
<0. 0001160, 000.
<0. 0001450, 000.
<0. 0001100, 000.
<0. 0001130, 000.
<0. 0001240, 000.
<0.0001***********
<0. 0001100, 000.
66
70
372
117
42
134
6
48
272
377
120
82
9
2
133
29
100
118
364
365
210
242
41
376
23
115
366
197
28
382
99
33
141
363
85
243
261
370
140
102
81
18
1
206
66 MOBAY CORP. HALED
70 REICHHOLD CHEMICALS ELIZA
372 ROGERS LANDFILL CENTR
117 KOCH INDUSTRIES CORFU
42 7ISTA CHEMICAL WESTL
134 HUNT REFINING TUSCA
LILLY COATINGS MONTE
3-M COMPANY COTTA
272 DIAMOND SHAMROCK SUNRA
377 IT CORPORATION BENEC
120 MOBIL CHEMICALS BEAUM
82 MONSANTO CO ADDYS
UPJOHN CO.,THE NORTH
MONSANTO CO ARNIS
133 BELCHER REF. MOBIL
29 AIR PRODUCTS I CHEH. WTCHI
100 ATLANTIC RICHFIELD HOUST
PERS HOUST
364 CHEM-CLEAR INC. BALTI
365 CHEM-CLEAR INC. CLEVE
210 HILL PETROLEUM KROTZ
242 GIANT REFINERY GALLU
41 UNION CARBIDE CORP. RAHNV
376 HERITAGE ENV. SERVIC INDIA
23 REILLY TAR AND CHEHI GRANI
115 GOODYEAR TIRE t RUBB LAPOR
CHEM-MET SERVICES WYAND
FARMLAND FACILITIES PHILL
28 ABBOTT LABORATORIES WICHI
382 CECOS INT'L BRIST
99 AMOCO CHEMICAL TEXAS
33 OAF CORP. CALVE
141 TESARO ALASKA PETROL KENAI
CID-LANDFILL CALUM
85 USS CHEMICAL IRONT
243 NAVAJO REFINING ARTES
54 HALLINCKRODT CHEM. RALE I
261 QUAKER STATE OIL REF SMETH
370 FRONTIER CHEMICAL NIAGR
140 PETRO STAR NORTH
102 CELANESE CHEMICAL BISRO
81 BF GOODRICH AVON
18 NORCHEM CO. CLINT
ALLIED SIGNAL BIRMX
CANAL REF. CHURC
-------
TABLE D-4. (continued)
Sunnary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maximum-
Lifetime
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
SIC=
CAS-
-- Minimum --
Cone People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 8 of 9
4.52E-03
4.06E-03
4.04E-03
2.S9E-03
2.60E-03
2.17E-03
2.15E-03
2.07E-03
1.93E-03
1.89E-03
1.84E-03
1.81E-03
1.40E-03
1.36E-03
1.28E-03
1.24E-03
1.11E-03
9.95E-04
9.48E-04
8.15E-04
6.99E-04
6.64E-04
6.63E-04
5.97E-04
5.91E-04
5.61E-04
4.78E-04
4.58E-04
3.68E-04
3.44E-04
2.85E-04
2.59E-04
2.54E-04
2.42E-04
2.37E-04
2.06E-04
1.40E-04
1.39E-04
1.31E-04
1.28E-04
1.22E-04
1.17E-04
1.14E-OJ
1.02E-04
8.31E-05
1
57
77
1
22
598
11
4
<1
<1
23
<1
2
1
<1
10
14
4
1
33
22
1,270
601
<1
36
4
170
5
38
12
860
1,850
2,170
1,980
<1
24
4
<1
1
5
489
5
29
681
769
3.07E-03
2.32E-01
3.11E-01
1.84E-03
5.71E-02
1.30E+00
2.34E-02
8.25E-03
1.60E-04
1.35E-04
4.24E-02
2.08E-06
2.63E-03
1.74E-03
3.87E-04
1.24E-02
1.52E-02
4.30E-03
6.16E-04
2.69E-02
1.54E-02
8.46E-01
3.99E-01
1.02E-04
2.11E-02
2.27E-03
8.13E-02
2.19E-03
1.40E-02
4.00E-03
2.45E-01
4.80E-01
5.50E-01
4.78E-01
6.08E-05
4.91E-03
6.00E-04
3.38E-06
6.70E-05
5.99E-0-4
5.94E-07
5.85E-0^
3.31E-03
6.96E-0:
«.3?e-;:
2.54E-08
1.93E-06
2.58E-06
1.53E-08
4.74E-07
1.08E-05
1.94E-07
6.85E-08
1.33E-09
1.12E-09
3.52E-07
1.73E-11
2.19E-08
1.44E-08
3.21E-09
1.03E-07
1.26E-07
3.57E-08
S.11E-09
2.23E-07
1.28E-07
7.02E-06
3.31E-06
8.45E-10
1 .75E-07
1.88E-08
6.75E-07
1.82E-08
1.16E-07
3.32E-08
2.04E-06
3.98E-06
4.56E-06
3.96E-06
5.05E-10
4.07E-08
4.98E-09
3.22E-11
5.56E-10
4.97E-09
4.93E-07
4.85E-09
J.75E-08
5.77E-07
5.31E-07
3.75E-08
3.37E-08
3.35E-08
2.40E-08
2.16E-08
l.flOE-08
1.79E-08
1.71E-08
1.60E-08
1.57E-08
1.53E-08
1.50E-08
1.16E-08
1.13E-08
1.06E-08
1.03E-08
9.25E-09
8.26E-09
7.87E-09
6.76E-09
5.80E-09
5.51E-09
5.50E-09
4.95E-09
4.90E-09
4.65E-09
3.97E-09
3.80E-09
3.05E-09
2.86E-09
2.37E-09
2.1SE-09
2.11E-09
2.01E-09
1.96E-09
1.71E-09
1.16E-09
1.16E-09
1.09E-09
1.06E-09
1.01E-09
9.72E-10
9.50E-10
8.48E-10
6.90E-10
4.S7E-08
4.16E-06
1.3SE-06
8.39E-08
2.47E-04
2.69E-05
5.84E-08
2.13E-08
3.61E-08
3.28E-08
5.04E-05
1.05E-07
4.02E-08
7.05E-08
8.93E-08
1.49E-08
4.02E-08
4.07E-08
3.47E-07
1.01E-04
4.49E-04
3.28E-07
4.31E-06
8.45E-09
3.09E-08
9.27E-07
1.46E-05
7.69E-09
6.57E-09
5.91E-09
3.08E-06
2.37E-06
8.84E-06
4.74E-06
3.32E-09
2.79E-09
6.63E-09
6.92E-09
5.58E-09
5.67E-09
3.49E-05
1.23E-09
1.36E-09
8.09E-07
1.36E-06
2,000,000
824,000
2,210,000
113,000
34,800
108,000
902,000
2,090,000
200,000
2,590,000
24,400
362,000
386,000
294,000
12,700,000
13,300,000
435,000
483,000
2,450,000
6,710
252
556,000
357,000
300,000
415,000
2,580,000
206,000
12,500,000
613,000
2,610,000
89,200
551,000
281,000
180,000
573,000
5,190,000
1,780,000
460,000
'4,810,000
2,200,000
536
1,330,000
13,800,000
163,000
118,000
1.12E+00
4.00E+01
6.93E+01
1.44E-01
1.46E+01
1.63E+01
4.91E+00
2.07E+00
3.89E-02
9.27E-01
6.92E+00
3.08E-01
1.84E-01
1.33E-01
2.10E+01
8.62E+00
1.17E+00
2.64E-01
9.70E-I-00
1.93E+00
1.19E-01
6.00E+00
9.51E+00
3.02E-02
8.74E-01
2.65E+01
1.89E+01
1.64E+00
4.08E-01
3.44E-01
2.33E+00
4.63E+00
1.74E+01
5.53E+00
8.30E-02
2.98E-01
1.66E-01
2.10E-02
2.61E-01
2.21E-01
6.11E-02
1.17E-01
1.54E+00
8.87E-01
6.53E-01
<0.0001***********
<0.0001210,000.
<0.0001120,000.
<0.0001***********
<0.0001580,000.
<0.0001520,000.
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001400,000.
<0.0001980,000.
<0.0001***********
<0.0001**********»
<0.0001870,000.
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001890,000.
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001320,000.
<0.0001450,000.
<0.0001***********
<0.0001*********«»
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001490,000.
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
5 DOW CHEMICAL PITTS
128 HERCULES HAGNA
50 MONSANTO CO ST. L
3 GREAT LAKES CHEMICAL EL CO
138 CHEVRON KEHAI
143 BERRT PETROLEUM STEVE
76 EASTMAN KODAK ROCHE
361 CHEMICAL PROCESSORS SEAR
19 CLARK OIL & REFINING BLUB
113 GLIDDEN COATINGS CARRO
250 BARRETT REF. THOMA
17 OLIN CHEMICALS AUGUS
114 GOODYEAR TIRE BEAUM
25 US INDUSTRIAL CHEM. TUSCO
56 AMERICAN CYANAMID CO LINOE
68 ORBIS PRODUCTS CORP NEWAR
79 ALLIED CHEMICAL IRONT
96 US ARMY MUNITIONS ICINGS
125 UPJOHN CO LA PO
142 INTERMOUNTAIN REF. FREOO
391 USPCI GRASSY MT. KNOW.
40 STAUFFER CHEMICAL BATON
356 ENV. ENTERPRISES CINCI
14 DOW CHEMICAL DALTO
26 MEAD JOHNSON EVANS
106 DIAMOND SHAMROCK COR DEER
379 CASMALIA RESOURCES CASMA
358 SOLVENT RECOV. SERVI LXNDE
362 CHEMICAL RESOURCES TULSA
119 LILLY IND. COATINGS DALLA
378 IT CORPORATION WESTM
38 GEORGIA-PACIFIC CORP PLAQU
13 ATLANTIC WOOD INDUST SAVAN
95 RHOHE-POULENC.INC. MT. P
8 DOW CHEMICAL LEDYA
55 AMERICAN CYAKAMID BRIDG
83 PPG INDUSTRIES RORTO
93 DUFONT LUGOF
63 HERCULES GIBBS
21 MONSANTO CO SAUCE
234 NEVADA REF. TONOP
351 COMMERCIAL DISPOSAL WEST
360 CALLEIA RES. RECOVER BROOK
75 AYERST LABS ROUSE
52 KERR-MCGEE CHEM. COR MERID
-------
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
— Haximuni-
Lifetiae
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
TABLE D-4. (continued)
SIC.
CAS-
H i n i •
Cone People
u a - -
Annual Repeat
Exposure Incidence Interval
Page 9 of 9
7.45E-05
7.30E-05
2.74E-05
2.48E-05
6.62E-06
l.OOE-38
l.OOE-38
<1
2
1,310
43
203
1.28E-06
1.80E-04
3.58E-02
1.07E-03
1.34E-03
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
1.06E-11
1.49E-09
2.97E-07
8.86E-09
1.12E-OS
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
6.18E-10
6.06E-10
2.27E-10
2.06E-10
5.49E-11
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
3.63E-09
2.96E-09
5.73E-07
1.07E-07
8.13E-08
l.OOE+38
l.OOE+38
3,440,000
4,570,000
423,000
87,400
552,000
6.67E-02
1.09E-01
1.72E+00
2.25E-01
2.07E-01
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
396 WATNE DISPOSAL BELLS
373 ROLLINS ENV. SERVICE BRIDQ
392 PEORIA DISPOSAL CO. PEORI
123 UNION CARBIDE SEADR
37 ETHtL CORP. BATON
130 ALDRICH CHEMICALS MILWA
136 ARCO ALASKA KUPAR
701,000,000 S.85E+06 1.0
0.95
Overall
-------
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maximun-
Lifetiae
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
TABLE D-5. HEM RESULTS FOR CASE 3 (CONTROLLED MINIMUM)
SIC- CAS-
M i n i n u •
Annual Repeat
Cone People Exposure Incidence Interval
Page 1 of 9
S o u r c
4.40E+00
3.79E+00
3.59E+00
2.84E+00
2.70E+00
2.48E+00
2.23E+00
2.22E+00
2.18E+00
2.06E+00
1.94E+00
1.77E+00
1.72E+00
1.70E+00
1.68E+00
1.61E+00
1.57E+00
1.54E+00
1.50E+00
1.48E+00
1.46E+00
1.43E+00
1.42E+00
1.37E+00
1.34E-fOO
1.30E+00
1.27E+00
1.23E+00
1.22E+00
1.15E+00
1.15E+00
1.13E+00
1.11E+00
1.07E+00
1.07E+00
1.06E+00
1.04E+00
1.04E+00
1.03E+00
1.02E+00
9.96E-01
9.85E-01
9.51E-01
9.37E-01
9.25E-01
<1
<1
21
112
1
<1
3
18
7
<1
<1
1
3
<1
<1
1
4
1
10
111
11
1
2
3
<1
6
17
1
1
4
< j.
17
4
97
<1
1
<1
<1
1
13
1
1
13
2
<1
7.95E-02
9.S6E-02
7.62E+01
3.18E+02
3.45E+00
1.17E+00
5.70E+00
3.96E+01
1.61E+01
9.92E-02
3.87E-01
1.14E+00
5.91E+00
3.39E-01
3.58E-01
1.49E+00
6.76E-I-00
1.56E+00
1.49E+01
1.65E+02
1.64E+01
9.66E-01
3.01E+00
3.71E-t-00
1.39E-01
7.92E-t-00
2.10E+01
1.28E+00
1.35E+00
4.31E+00
5.12E-01
1.94E+01
4.33E-I-00
1.04E+02
1.36E-01
9.22E-01
1.17E-01
3.59E-01
8.64E-01
1.37E-t-01
8.20E-01
9.01E-J1
1.24E-H01
1.63E+00
l.lCE-Oi
6.
7.
6.
2.
2.
9.
4.
3.
1.
8.
3.
9.
4.
2.
2.
1.
5.
1.
1.
1.
1.
8.
2.
3.
1
6
1
1
1
3
4
I
3
8
1
7
9
2
60E-07
94E-07
32E-04
64E-03
86E-05
73E-06
73E-05
29E-04
34E-04
23E-07
21E-06
47E-06
90E-05
81E-06
97E-06
24E-05
61E-05
30E-05
24E-04
37E-03
36E-04
02E-06
50E-05
08E-05
15E-06
58E-05
75E-04
06E-05
12E-05
58E-05
25E-06
61E-04
60E-05
61E-04
13E-06
65E-06
68E-07
98E-06
7.17E-06
1.14E-04
•5.80E-06
7.48E-06
1.03E-04
L.35E-05
?.12E-07
3.65E-05
3.15E-05
2.98E-05
2.36E-05
2.24E-05
2.06E-05
1.85E-05
1.84E-05
1.81E-05
1.71E-05
1.61E-05
1.47E-05
1.43E-05
1.41E-05
1.39E-05
1.34E-05
1.31E-05
1.2BE-05
1.25E-05
1.23E-05
1.22E-05
1.19E-05
1.18E-05
1.13E-05
1.11E-05
1.08E-05
1.05E-05
1.02E-05
1.02E-05
9.56E-06
9.53E-06
9.36E-06
9.24E-06
.91E-06
.90E-06
.79E-06
.65E-06
.61E-06
.58E-06
. 48E-06
.27E-06
.17E-06
7.89E-06
7.77E-06
7.68E-06
4.03E-05
1.30E-04
2.09E-05
8.87E-04
9.01E-05
7.82E-05
1.45E-05
7.95E-05
1.14E-04
4.05E-05
8.24E-05
1.49E-05
6.22E-05
1.55E-05
5.86E-05
5.39E-05
2.90E-05
2.65E-05
5.18E-05
2.40E-05
3.82E-05
4.96E-05
4.30E-05
1.10E-05
9.02E-06
2.33E-05
3.40E-05
4.27E-05
7.74E-06
2.83E-05
6.68E-06
2.06E-05
1.83E-05
3.61E-05
6.12E-05
1.93E-05
4.10E-05
3.71E-05
8.19E-06
1.07E-06
2.39E-OS
1.97E-05
1.93E-05
3.62E-05
3.26E-05
249,000
137,000
382,000
2,030,000
1,380,000
695,000
893,000
556,000
1,170,000
2,590,000
1,140,000
102,000
4,750,000
125,000
382,000
228,000
10,500,000
361,000
5,420,000
8,090,000
7,970,000
397,000
3,070,000
859,000
339,000
327,000
8,460,000
415,000
344,000
2,920,000
364,000
2,790,000
8,070,000
333,000
1,190,000
207,000
359,000
377,000
228,000
1,060,000
392,000
2,670,000
2,690,000
720,000
1,900,000
4.89E+02
7.05E+02
1.45E+03
1.94E+04
6.19E+02
9.63E+02
5.75E+02
2.39E+03
2.94E+03
1.46E+03
5.63E+02
8.65E+01
1.70E+03
3.36E+01
4.07E+02
2.37E+02
3.46E+03
1.06E+02
3.30E+03
4.96E+03
3.33E+03
4.94E+02
1.27E+03
5.02E+02
5.94E+02
1.17E+03
3.22E+03
1.56E+02
3.92E+02
8.15E+02
1.37E+02
4.29E+03
2.45E+03
1.21E+03
2.13E+03
7.42E+01
2.58E+02
2.89E+02
4.74E+01
6.15E+02
1.70E+02
8.47E+02
1.03E+03
1.80E+02
4.62E+02
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
<0
0
<0
<0
<0
0
<0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
<0
<0
0
<0
0
0
0
0
<0
<0
<0
<0
0
<0
0
0
<0
0
.0001
.0001
.0002
.0023
.0001
.0001
.0001
.0003
.0003
.0002
.0001
.0001
.0002
17,000
12,000
5,800
430
14,000
8,800
15,000
3,500
2,900
5,800
15,000
97,000
5,000
.0001250,000
.0001
.0001
.0004
.0001
.0004
.0006
.0004
.0001
.0002
.0001
.0001
.0001
.0004
.0001
.0001
.0001
.0001
.0005
.0003
.0001
.0003
21,000
36,000
2,400
79,000
2,600
1,700
2,500
17,000
6,600
17,000
14,000
7,200
2,600
54,000
22,000
io,ooa
61,000
2,000
3,400
7,000
4,000
.0001110,000
.0001
.0001
33,000
29,000
.0001180,000
.0001
.0001
.0001
.0001
.0001
.0001
14,000
50,000
10,000
8,200
47,000
18,000
110 EASTMAN KODAK, INC. LONG7
107 DOW CHEMICAL USA FREEP
397 TEXAS ECOLOGISTS ROBST
98 AMERICAS HOECHST COR ROUST
367 CECOS INT'I, WILL!
266 AMOCO TEXAS
91 UNION CARBIDE PENUE
209 EXXON CORP BATOR
27 REILLT TAR AND CHEMI INDIA
290 SHELL OIL DEER
218 BP OIL BELLE
126 WITCO CHEMICAL CORPO POIHT
394 WASTE CONVERSION HATFI
304 ARCO PETROLEUM FERND
352 ASHLAND CHEMICAL BOTD
207 CITGO PETROLEUM LAKE
64 IRT'L FLAVORS t FRAG UNION
132 MOBAY CHEMICAL CORP NEW M
190 AMOCO CHEMICAL WHITI
169 SHELL OIL WILMI
149 CHEVRON EL SE
286 MOBIL OIL BEAUM
150 CHEVRON RICHM
77 GENERAL ELECTRIC WATER
267 CHAMPLIN PETROLEUM C CORPU
7 WITCO CORP. OILDA
161 MOBIL OIL TORRA
80 ARIS TECH CHEMICAL HAVER
270 COASTAL REFINING CORPU
176 UNION OIL OF CALIFOR RODEO
281 KOCH INDUSTRIES CORPU
44 FMC CORP. BALTI
172 TEXACO REFINING WILMI
247 STANDARD OIL OF OHIO LIMA
214 MOBIL CHALM
260 PENNZOIL COMPANY ROUSE
293 STAR REF. PORT
201 ASHLAND PETROLEUM CO ASHLA
309 TEXACO USA ANACO
280 HOWELL HYDROCARBONS SAN A
108 DUPONT BEAUM
271 CROWN CENTRAL HOU5T
359 ERIEWAY POLL. CONTRO BEDFO
213 MARATHON PETROLEUM GARYV
224 KOCH REFINING ROSEN
-------
TABLE D-5. (continued)
Summary foe BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maxinum-
Lifetiae
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
SIC»
CAS«
Minimum
Cone People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 2 of 9
S o u r c
8.89E-01
8.73E-01
3.60E-01
8.55E-01
8.49E-01
8.29E-01
8.09E-01
8.04E-01
7.99E-01
7.83E-01
7.80E-01
7.74E-01
7.63E-01
7.58E-01
7.44E-01
7.15E-01
7.07E-01
6.93E-01
6.91E-01
6.85E-01
6.84E-01
6.81E-01
6.76E-01
6.73E-01
6.70E-01
6.63E-01
6.61E-01
6.48E-01
6.42E-01
6.36E-01
6.15E-01
6.13E-01
6.10E-01
5.95E-01
5.69E-01
5.57E-01
5.51E-01
5.42E-01
5.39E-01
5.30E-01
5.28E-01
5.00E-01
4.94E-01
4.74E-01
4.71E-01
2
1
2
4,530
2
<1
<1
<1
46
9
1
6
1
37
10
13
2
<1
1
2
18
42
13
1
33
<1
<1
21
1
a
-------
TABLE D-5. (continued)
Sunnsry for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
SIC-
CAS"
Pag* 3 of 9
- H a x i a
Cone People
4.69E-01
4.33E-01
4.0BE-01
4.0BE-01
3OCC1 rt 1
. 96E— 01
3.93E-01
3.92E-01
3.89E-01
3.89E-01
3.87E-01
3.85E-01
3.59E-01
3.59E-01
3.52E-01
3.43E-01
3.27E-01
3.24E-01
3.23E-01
3.21E-01
3.21E-01
3.20E-01
3.16E-01
3.15E-01
3.14E-01
3.07E-01
3.05E-01
3 .04E-01
3.04E-01
3.01E-01
2.91E-01
2.91E-01
2.78E-01
2.73E-01
2.72E-01
2.69E-01
2.68E-01
2.65E-01
2.62E-01
2.59E-01
2.56E-01
2.49E-01
2.47E-01
2.46E-01
2.46E-01
2.45E-01
1
27
71
<1
<1
<1
1
<1
89
<1
3
1
18
49
<1
3
16
13
1
44
1
<1
1
<1
65
1
<1
<1
4
3
1
1
3
44
1
<1
2
<1
7
<1
<1
6
50
2
10
u a -
Exposure
6.8SE-01
1.18E+01
2.88E+01
3.18E-02
9 . 02E— 02
1.23E-01
4.76E-01
9.38E-03
3.46E+01
1.11E-01
1.12E+00
5.04E-01
6.30E+00
1.72E+01
1.77E-02
1.13E+00
5.24E+00
4.26E+00
4.63E-01
1.42E-MH
2.60E-01
5.56E-0'
3.83E-OI
1.27E-01
2.00E+01
2.63E-01
1 . 02E-01
1.26E-0.:
1.22E*0'i
7.77E-01
1.64E-01
1.85E-01
7.10E-01
1.20E+01
2.94E-01
2.29E-OJ
5.77E-0,
4.61E-0
1.70E+0'.
3.86E-0:
4.49E-0 :
l.SlEri.
1.22E-M: .
3.73E-')
2.43t-.
Lifetime
Incidence
5.69E-06
9.76E-05
2.39E-04
2.64E-07
7.49E— 07
1.02E-06
3.95E-06
7.78E-OI
2.87E-04
9.23E-07
9.30E-06
4.19E-06
5.23E-05
1.43E-04
1.47E-07
9.41E-06
4.35E-OS
3.53E-OS
3.84E-06
1.1BE-04
2.16E-06
4.61E-08
3 . 18E-06
1 .05E-06
1.6SE-04
2 . 18E-06
8 , 50E— 07
1.04E-07
1.01E-05
6.45E-06
1 .36E-06
1.53E-06
5.90E-06
9 . 99E-05
2.44E-06
1.90E-07
4.79E-06
3.82E-08
1.41E-05
3.20E-08
3.72E-07
1.25E-05
1.01E-04
3.14E-06
;.06E-05
Max Risk
3.90E-06
3.59E-06
3.38E-06
3.38E-06
3 . 29E-06
3.26E-06
3.25E-06
3.23E-06
3.22E-06
3.21E-06
3.19E-06
2.98E-06
2.98E-06
2.92E-06
2.85E-OS
2.72E-06
2.69E-06
2.68E-06
2.67E-06
2.67E-06
2.66E-06
2.62E-06
2.62E-06
2.60E-06
2.55E-06
2.S3E-06
2.53E-06
2.53E-06
2.50E-06
2.41E-06
2.41E-06
2.30E-06
2.27E-06
2.26E-06
2.24E-06
2.22E-06
2.20E-06
2.17E-06
2.1SE-06
2.12E-06
2.07E-06
2.05E-06
2.04E-06
2.04E-06
2.03E-06
H i n i •
Cone People
2.26E-05
1.66E-05
6.35E-06
1.64E-05
7.52E— 06
1.63E-05
7.63E-06
7.21E-06
1.27E-05
1.39E-05
6.67E-06
1.84E-05
2.15E-05
1.29E-05
1.35E-OS
5.93E-06
2.27E-06
1.18E-05
1.8SE-05
1.25E-05
4.77E-05
8.20E-06
6.14E-06
6.04E-06
5.22E-06
2.57E-06
3 . 48E-06
8.94E-06
2.74E-06
1.74E-05
8.67E-06
1.13E-05
3.28E-06
1.79E-05
1.20E-05
7.49E-06
1.57E-06
6.79E-06
8.67E-06
1.02E-05
4.77E-06
1.05E-05
5.09E-06
1.06E-05
1.26E-05
4
8
3
4
2
6
1
1
1
1
4
2
1
4
2
2
838,000
,440,000
,200,000
,430,000
30,900
,830,000
325,000
379,000
,680,000
,100,000
134,000
927,000
,190,000
,670,000
,220,000
147,000
,230,000
697,000
707,000
,900,000
,450,000
763,000
325,000
126,000
,310,000
259,000
17,500
346,000
88,000
9,580
772,000
110,000
810,000
424,000
55,300
574,000
358,000
763,000
676,000
,450,000
192,000
,090,000
83,000
971,000
,070,000
u • - -
Exposure
2.35E+02
1.03E+03
1.40E+03
4.07E+02
6.22E-fOO
8.05E+02
2.17E-1-02
3.91E+01
7.98E+02
7.95E+02
7.1SE+01
1.47E+02
7.01E+02
9.11E+02
1.02E+02
6.71E+01
8.58E+01
2.06E+02
2.10E+02
2.08E+03
1.12E-4-03
5.18E+01
1.74E+02
1.04E+01
7.87E+02
7.14E+01
3.30E+00
2.08E+01
3.19E+01
3.31E+01
1.37E+02
1.51E+02
1.95E+02
2.58E+02
2.34E+01
3.42E+01
4.40E+01
4.30E+01
1.36E+02
4.11E+02
1.70E+01
1.71E+02
2.97E+02
6.41E-H01
2.17E+02
Annual
Incidence
<0
0
0
<0
<0
0
<0
<0
0
0
<0
<0
0
0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
0
0
<0
<0
<0
0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
.0001 36
.0001 8
.0002 6
.0001 21
.0001 10
.0001 39
.0001220
.0001 11
.0001 11
.0001120
.0001 57
.0001 12
.0001 9
.0001 83
.0001130
.0001 98
.0001 41
.0001 40
.0002 4
.0001 7
.0001160
.0001 48
.0001810
.0001 11
.0001120
.0001410
.0001260
.0001250
.0001 62
.0001 56
.0001 43
.0001 33
.0001360
.0001250
.0001190
.0001200
.0001 62
.0001 21
.0001500
.0001 49
.0001 28
.0001130
.0001 39
Repeat
Interval
,000.
,200.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,300.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,100.
,500.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
248 STANDARD OIL OF OHIO TOLED
262 BP OIL MARCO
148 CHEMOIL SIGNA
62 DUPONT DEEPW
301 PEHNZOIL ROOSE
240 MOBIL OIL PAULS
170 SUNLAHD REF. BAKER
199 TEXACO REFIRINO EL DO
278 HILL PETROLEUM HOUST
368 CHEM. WASTE HGHT. CALUH
196 FARMLAND INDUSTRIES COFFE
312 QUAKES STATE OIL REF NEWEL
215 MURPHY OIL CORPORA!! MERAO
383 CECOS INT'L CINCI
10 STANDARD CHLORIDE CH DELAW
198 NATIONAL COOPERATIVE MCPHE
4 ALPHA RESINS PEfiRX
279 HILL PETROLEUM TEXAS
47 PARKE-DAVI5 HOLLA
257 ATLANTIC REFINING PHI LA
284 LTONDELL PETROCHEMIC HOUST
183 HAWAII INDEP. REF. EWA B
167 SAN JOAQUIN REF. BAKER
229 SOUTHLAND OIL SANDE
256 CHEVRON POHTL
282 LA GLORIA OIL AND GA T7LER
317 SINCLAIR OIL SINCL
355 HANSBROUGH ENERGY CROWL
255 TOTAL PETROLEUM ARDHO
318 WYOMING REF. NEWCA
124 UNION CARBIDE CORP TEXAS
227 ERGON REF. VTCKS
320 ABC COKE TARRA
332 ARMCO INC. ASHLA
287 PHILLIPS 66 REFINERY BOHGE
39 RUBICON CHEMICALS IN GEISM
296 VALERO ENERG7 CORP. CORPU
182 CHEVRON HONOL
285 MARATHON OIL TEXAS
67 MONSANTO CO BRIDG
264 UNITED REF. WARRE
185 CLARK OIL & REF. HARTF
233 MONTANA REFINING COM GREAT
303 AMOCO OIL REFINERY TORKT
87 ATLANTIC RICHFIELD C MONAC
-------
TABLE D-5. (continued)
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maximum-
Lifetime
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
SIC"
CAS»
H i n i » u •
Cone People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 4 of 9
2.45E-01
2.38E-01
2.34E-01
2.33E-01
2.32E-01
2.27E-01
2.26E-01
2.25E-01
2.2SE-01
2.22E-01
2.18E-01
2.12E-01
2.10E-01
2.10E-01
2 .08E-01
2.07E-01
2 . 06E— 01
2.00E-01
1.99E-01
1.99E-01
1.99E-01
1.97E-01
1.95E-01
1.95E-01
1.95E-01
1.92E-01
1.92E-01
1.85E-01
1.84E-01
1.80E-01
1.80E-01
1.80E-01
1.77E-01
1 .77E-01
1.76E-01
1.72E-01
1.72E-01
1.67E-01
1.67E-01
1.66E-01
1.65E-01
1.65E-01
1.63E-01
1.62E-01
1.57E-01
3
<1
28
1
1
1
1
1
<1
15
1
<1
12
<1
1
3
<1
28
5
6
2
14
<1
13
54
17
4
6
1
40
U
105
2
<1
1
1
<1
14
54
48
2
2
25
15
-1
8.41E-01
9.25E-02
6.50E+00
2.31E-01
1.55E-01
2.43E-01
1.33E-01
2.74E-01
7.48E-02
3.27E+00
1.39E-01
3.69E-02
2.49E+00
1.14E-02
1 . 09E-01
6.25E-01
8 . 93E-02
5.51E+00
1.06E+00
1.23E*00
4.10E-01
2.83E*00
2.99E-IK
2.51E+00
1.05E+01
3.32E+00
6.79E-01
1.13E+00
1.04E-01
7.23E*-',
8.43E-0,:
1.89E+01
2.74E-01
1.31E-02
1.96E-01
1.68E-01
4 . 63E-02
2.27E+00
8.95E+00
8.04E+OC
3.61E-01
3.31E-:.
3.9°E+0'-
:. J2E«-0 '
6.31E-.-
6.98E-06
7.68E-07
5.39E-05
1.91E-06
1.29E-06
2.02E-06
1.10E-06
2.27E-06
6.21B-07
2.71E-05
1.15E-06
3.06E-07
2.07E-05
9.48E-08
9 . 04E— 07
5.19E-06
7 . 41E— 07
4.5BE-05
8 . 83E-06
1.02E-05
3 .40E-06
2.35E-05
2.48E-07
2.0SE-05
3.75E-05
2 76E-05
5.63E-06
9.34E-06
3.65E-07
, .OOE-05
7.00E-07
I.S7E-04
2.28E-06
1 .09E-07
1.63E-06
L.39E-06
3 . 85E— 08
1.89E-05
7.43E-05
6.67E-05
3.00E-06
2.74E-06
3.31E-05
:.01E-05
5.24E-06
2.03E-06
1.98E-06
1.94E-06
1.93E-06
1.92E-06
1.88E-06
1.88E-06
1.87E-06
1.87E-06
1.84E-06
1.81E-06
1.76E-06
1.74E-06
1.74E-06
1.73E-06
1.72E-06
1.71E— 06
1.66E-06
1.65E-06
1.65E-06
1.65E-06
1.64E-06
1.62E-06
1.62E-06
1.61E-06
1.59E-06
1.59E-06
1.S4E-06
1.53E-06
1.50E-06
1.49E-06
1.49E-06
1.47E-06
1.47E-06
1.46E-06
1.43E-06
1.42E-06
1.39E-06
1.39E-06
1.38E-06
1.37E-06
1.37E-06
1.35E-06
1.35E-OS
1.30E-06
1.19E-05
1.89E-06
2.41E-04
8.17E-06
7.28E-06
3.06E-06
6.22E-06
4.39E-06
6.82E-06
3.63E-06
5.25E-06
2.70E-06
2.59E-06
3.67E-06
2.20E-06
2.65E-05
7.83E— 06
4.96E-06
7.06E-06
7.12E-06
6.11E-06
3.17E-06
4.11E-06
7.24E-06
6.95E-06
8.27E-06
8.88E-06
3.31E-06
8.26E-06
5.33E-06
8.20E-06
2.64E-06
6.33E-06
5.15E-06
3.83E-06
4.04E-06
3 .64E— 06
2.67E-06
4.56E-06
7.54E-06
4.46E-06
7.52E-06
1.04E-05
8.35E-06
3.10E-06
234,000
34,700
455,000
209,000
511,000
3,220,000
278,000
325,000
790,000
625,000
1,640,000
1,760,000
11,600,000
75,300
92,200
364,000
38 ,900
92,800
6,360,000
6,100,000
225,000
921,000
4,900,000
1,970,000
6,210,000
2,180,000
3,810,000
327,000
1,150,000
8,530,000
1,000,000
8,550,000
4,400,000
154 ,000
248,000
1,270,000
230 ,000
12,200,000
562,000
2,760,000
555,000
166,000
494,000
2,410,000
8,320,000
3.51E+01
1.03E+01
8.60E+02
2.58E+01
9.04E+01
1.03E+02
9.36E+00
1.25E+02
1.30E+02
1.44E+02
1.42E+02
8.39E+01
6.58E+02
7.13E+01
6 . 35E+00
1.5BE+02
6.95E+00
1.30E+02
6.90E+02
4.45E+02
5.59E+01
1.37E-1-02
1.98E+02
1.86E+02
7.09E+02
2.91E+02
2.91E-I-02
1.67E+02
1.43E+02
8.57E+02
1.17E+02
7.3BE+02
1.56E+02
6.88E+00
9.10E+00
5.25E+01
5.17E+00
5.75E+02
2.03E+02
2.70E+02
5.77E+01
3.02E+01
2.29E+02
4.49E+02
3.98E+02
<0. 0001240, 000.
<0. 0001820, 000.
0.0001 9,800.
<0. 0001330, 000.
<0.0001 93,000.
<0.0001 82,000.
<0. 0001900, 000.
<0.0001 68,000.
<0.0001 65,000.
<0.0001 59,000.
<0.0001 59,000.
<0. 0001100, 000.
0.0001 13,000.
<0. 0001120, 000.
<0.0001 53,000.
<0.0001 65,000.
0.0001 12,000.
0.0001 19,000.
<0. 0001150, 000.
<0.0001 62,000.
<0.0001 43,000.
<0.0001 45,000.
0.0001 12,000.
<0.0001 29,000.
<0.0001 29,000.
<0.0001 51,000.
<0.0001 59,000.
0.0001 9,800.
<0.0001 72,000.
0.0001 11,000.
<0.0001 54,000.
<0. 0001930, 000.
<0. 0001160, 000.
0.0001 15,000.
<0.0001 41,000.
<0.0001 31,000.
<0. 0001150, 000.
<0. 0001280, 000.
<0.0001 37,000.
0.0001 19,000.
<0.0001 21,000.
311 MIDATLANTIC REF. ST. M
273 DIAMOND SHAMROCK REF THREE
74 MONTROSE CHEMICAL CO HENCE
151 CONOCO SANTA
46 DOW CORNING HIDLA
164 PACIFIC REF. HERCU
20 GOODRICH, (B.F.) HENRY
171 TEXACO REFINING BAKER
322 KOPPERS HDODW
253 SINCLAIR OIL TULSA
178 CONOCO COKHE
310 U.S. OIL I REFINING TACOM
236 CHEVRON PERTH
314 AMOCO CASPE
252 KERB MCGEE WYNNE
277 FINA OIL t CHEMICAL PORT
276 FINA OIL BIG S
145 LION OIL EL DO
184 CLARK OIL fc REFINING BLUE
327 LTV STEEL S CHI
204 CALCASIEU REFINING LAKE
297 AMOCO OIL REFINERY SALT
58 BASF WYANDOTTE CORP. JAMES
319 ASHLAND PETROLEUM ST. P
326 ACME STEEL CHICA
325 NATIONAL STEEL GRANI
222 MARATHON PET. DETRO
155 WITCO CORP. OILDA
129 ATLANTIC WOOD INDUST POSTS
160 LUNDAY-THAGARD CO. SOUTH
337 LTV STEEL WARRE
165 PARAMOUNT PET. PARAM
331 U.S. STEEL CORP. GARY
225 AMERADA BESS PURVI
212 KERE-MCGEE REFINING COTTO
71 SOUTHLAND CORP. GREAT
146 ANCHOR REF. MOCIT
235 AMERADA-HESS PORT
334 NATIONAL STEEL GROUP ECORS
153 EXXON BENIC
216 PLACID REFINING PORT
202 SOMERSET REFINERY SOMER
268 CHEVRON EL PA
345 SHENANGO SHEHA
72 STAUFFER CHEMICAL CO EDISO
-------
Sunmary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maxiaun-
Lifetiae
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
TABLE D-5. (continued)
sic-
CAS-
Mini
Cone People
Annual Repeat
Exposure Incidence Interval
Page 5 of 9
1.56E-01
1.56E-01
1.53E-01
1.53E-01
1.52E-01
1.50E-01
1.49E-01
1.47E-01
1.47E-01
1.45E-01
1.43E-01
1.41E-01
1.40E-01
1.39E-01
1 . 37E— 01
1.37E-01
1.36E-01
1.35E-01
1.34E-01
1 .34E-01
1.33E-01
1.33E-01
1.31E-01
1.30E-01
1.27E-01
1.21E-01
1.21E-01
1.21E-01
1.20E-01
1 .18E-01
1.17E-01
1.16E-01
1.15E-01
1.15E-01
1.15E-01
1.12E-01
1.12E-01
1.12E-01
1.10E-01
1.09E-01
1.06E-01
l.OOE-01
9.70E-02
9.68E-02
9.67E-02
30
111
36
1
4
34
<1
2
12
54
4
1
8
2
1
16
<1
16
71
1
<1
12
20
44
7
3
2
7
-------
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
TABLE D-5. (continued)
SIC» CAS>
Page 6 of 9
-Max
i n u n -
Cone People
9.61E-02
9.56E-02
9 .49E-02
9.44E-02
9.30E-02
9 .24E-02
9.07E-02
9.06E-02
8.97E-02
8.85E-02
8.76E-02
8.51E-02
8.33E-02
8.24E-02
8 .19E-02
8.03E-02
7.53E-02
7.23E-02
7.20E-02
6.84E-02
6.16E-02
6.11E-02
5.94E-02
5.84E-02
5.83E-02
5.59E-02
5.46E-02
5.09E-02
5.01E-02
4.82E-02
4.77E-02
4.14E-02
4.11E-02
4.09E-02
3.97E-02
3.91E-02
3.48E-02
3.30E-02
3.15E-02
3.14E-02
3.04E-02
2.66E-02
2.52E-02
2.49E-02
2.44E-02
a
2
1
1
9
1
1
3
<1
6
<1
46
28
2
35
1
35
1
1
10
24
7
265
38
<1
1
21
70
<1
48
< 1
1
265
705
106
2
80
< 1
d
4
16
2
2
<1
Exposure
2.17E-02
2.16E-01
7.78E-02
5.46E-02
8.27E-01
8 . 82E— 02
6.44E-02
2.43E-01
1.B1E-02
5.27E-01
2.11E-03
3.90E+00
2.33E+00
1.76E-01
1 .82E-02
2.81E+00
4.54E-02
2.53E+00
4.28E-02
7.43E-0:
6.16E-01
1 .4-iE+OO
4.34E-01
1.55E+01
2.22E+00
2.26E-02
3 . 86E-02
1.05E+00
3.52E+-0'
2.69E —
2.30EHJ
1 .85E-0.:
2.07E-0:
1.08E+01
2.79E+01
4.15E+OC
5.27E-0:
2.62E+CK
4.20E-OJ
6.87E-0:
1.17E-01
4. HE-..
4.13E-: !
4.60E-0.
4.1:2-
Lifetime
Incidence
1.80E-07
1.79E-06
6.46E-07
4.54E-07
6.87E-06
7.32E-07
5.35E-07
2.02E-06
1.51E-07
4.38E-06
1.75E-08
3.24E-05
1.93E-05
1.46E-06
1.51E-07
2.33E-05
3.77E-07
2.10E-05
3.55E-07
6.17E-07
5.11E-06
1.20E-05
3.61E-06
1.28E-04
1.84E-05
1.87E-08
3 . 20E— 07
3.71E-06
2.92E-05
:.24E-08
L.91E-05
I . 53E-07
1.72E-07
3.99E-05
2.32E-04
3.44E-05
4.37E-07
2.18E-05
3.48E-08
5.70E-08
9.68E-07
3.44E-06
3.42E-07
3.82E-07
3.42E-08
Max Risk
7.97E-07
7.93E-07
7.88E-07
7.83E-07
7.72E-07
7.67E-07
7.53E-07
7.52E-07
7.45E-07
7.34E-07
7.27E-07
7.07E-07
6.91E-07
6.84E-07
6.80E-07
6.67E-07
6.25E-07
6.00E-07
5.97E-07
5.68E-07
5.11E-07
5.07E-07
.93E-07
.84E-07
.84E-07
.64E-07
.53E— 07
.23E-07
4.16E-07
4.00E-07
3.96E-07
3.44E-07
3.41E-07
3.39E-07
3.29E-07
3.24E-07
2.88E-07
2.73E-07
2.61E-07
2.60E-07
2.52E-07
2.21E-07
2.09E-07
2.07E-07
2.03E-07
M
Cone
1.84E-06
4.16E-06
2.72E-06
3.01E-06
1.36E-06
2.32E-06
4.64E-06
4.88E-06
3.90E-05
2.43E-06
1.63E-06
5.62E-07
2.90E-06
1.98E-06
2.72E-06
6.80E-06
3.24E-06
6.12E-06
4.4SE-06
3.81E-06
7.42E-07
1.41E-05
7.82E-05
8.54E-06
1.30E-06
2.44E-06
1.85E-06
8.02E-07
7.01E-07
4.71E-07
2.16E-06
2.41E— 07
1.25E-06
5.98E-06
5.04E-05
1.30E-05
5.05E-06
6.74E-07
1.06E-06
6.78E-06
1.12E-06
4.89E-06
8.64E-07
4.35E-07
4.64E-07
i n i
•
People
428
826
158
42
1,240
389
292
1,190
2,560
297
379
338
2,340
196
103
2,910
4,490
2,910
495
372
13,300
2,440
349
8,730
2,600
279
253
12,500
12,900
2,520
2,760
364
223
8,730
2,210
1,270
935
9,100
1,800
924
2,280
287
1,570
3,100
2,540
,000
,000
,000
,300
,000
, 000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
u » - -
Exposure
1.45E+01
6.92E+01
8.16E+00
2.50E+00
5.52E+01
7.80E+00
l.OOE-fOl
2.04E+02
9.91E+02
2.25E+01
8.82E+00
8.37E+01
1.90E+02
2.00E+01
1.98E+00
3.66E+02
8.57E+01
3.29E+02
1.11E+02
2.25E+01
4.29E+02
3.06E+02
3.15E+02
1.20E+03
9.69E+01
1.97E+01
4.01E+00
2.33E+02
3.16E+02
9.26E+00
7.74E+01
4.96E+00
1.21E+01
8.41E+02
1.08E+03
5.71E+02
9.S8E+01
1.31E+02
1.32E+01
1.93E+02
3.98E+01
2.36E+01
1.84E+01
4.77E+01
3.63E+01
Annual
Repeat
Incidence Interval
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
0
<0
<0
0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
0
0
0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
.0001580
.0001120
.0001150
.0001840
.0001 41
.0001 8
.0001370
.0001960
.0001100
.0001 44
.0001420
.0001 23
.0001 98
.0001 26
.0001 76
.0001380
.0001 20
.0001 28
.0001 27
.0001 7
.0001 87
.0001430
.0001 36
.0001 27
.0001910
.0001110
.0001690
.0001 10
.0001 7
.0001 15
.0001 85
.0001 64
.0001640
.0001 44
.0001210
.0001360
.0001460
.0001180
.0001230
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,500.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,800.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
30 VULCAN MATERIALS WICHI
354 ENVIROSAFE SERVICES ORE GO
101 CAIN CHEMICAL BRAZO
104 COSDEN OIL t CHEMICA BIG S
335 TONAWANDA TONAW
205 CALUMET REFINING COM PRINC
.192 LAKETON REFINING LAKET
329 CITIZENS GAS INDIA
374 ROLLINS ENV. SERVICE DEER
53 EEICHHOLD CHEMICALS GULFP
194 DERBY REF. EL DO
294 TRIFINERY CORFU
89 KOPPERS CO INC BRIDG
313 MURPHY OIL CORPORATI SUPER
372 ROGERS LANDFILL CEHTR
168 SHELL OIL MARTI
239 MANTUA OIL THORO
173 TOSCO CORP. MARTI
274 EL PASO REFINING EL PA
16 NIPRO, INC. AUGUS
73 TROY CHEMICAL CORP., NEffAR
333 BETHLEHEM STEEL CORP SPARR
269 CHEVRON PORT
166 POWERINE OIL SANTA
122 S.D.S. BIOTECH CORF. HOUST
180 AMOCO SAVAN
220 CRYSTAL REF. CARSO
66 MOBAY CORP. BALED
70 REICHHOLD CHEMICALS ELIZA
377 IT CORPORATION BENEC
157 HUNTWAY REF. BENEC
117 KOCH INDUSTRIES CORFU
42 VISTA CHEMICAL WE STL
156 GOLDEN WEST REFINING SANTA
275 EXXON CORP BAYTO
336 BETHLEHEM STEEL LACXA
299 CHEVRON SALT
6 LILLY COATINGS MONTE
48 3-M COMPANY COTTA
265 MAPCO PETROLEUM MEMPH
346 U.S. STEEL CORP. CLAIR
223 TOTAL PETROLEUM ALMA
82 MONSANTO CO ADDYS
364 CHEM-CLEAR INC. BALTX
365 CHEM-CLEAR INC. CLEVE
-------
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maxiaun-
Lifetime
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
TABLE D-5. (continued)
SIC- CAS-
Kiniaua
Cone People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 7 of 9
S o u r c
2.39E-02
2.35E-02
2.25E-02
2.10E-02
2.07E-02
1.87E-02
1.82E-02
1.74E-02
1.70E-02
1.49E-02
1.45E-02
1.24E-02
9.58E-03
9.31E-03
9.10E-03
9.08E-03
8.85E-03
7.53E-03
7.21E-03
7.00E-03
6.23E-03
5.98E-03
5.59E-03
4.44E-03
4.23E-03
3.82E-03
3.65E-03
3.64E-03
3.63E-03
3.37E-03
3.35E-03
3.25E-03
2.51E-03
2.25E-03
2.24E-03
2.07E-03
1.61E-03
1.33E-03
1.31E-03
1.20E-03
1.18E-03
1.07E-03
1.05E-03
1.01E-03
7.76E-04
8
(1
(1
(1
13
(1
723
10
17
7
10
54
(1
497
(1
(1
(1
(1
28
20
230
7
1
1
1
23
1
2
(1
15
163
233
1
57
77
4
1
1
845
11
360
(1
(1
(1
2
1.86E-01
2.85E-03
2.40E-03
4.74E-03
2.70E-01
4.23E-03
1.32E-1-01
1.66E-01
2.96E-01
1.02E-01
1.38E-01
6.73E-01
2.19E-05
4.62E-I-00
2.61E-03
2.49E-03
4.30E-OJ
1.70E-03
2.00E-01
1.41E-01
1.43E-M)0
3.92E-0.:
5.85E-0.!
4.59E-03
2.78E-OJ
8.78E-02
4.97E-03
7.64E-0?
1.83E-0
4.98E-0 :
5.46E-01
7.57E-Oi
1.70E-0:
1.29E-OI
1.73E-01
8.25E-02
1.02E-0:
7.63E-0 •
1.10E+00
1.30E-0:
4.23E-0:
8.92E-. j
7.49E-! :
l.ll'E-0
1 . itiE— -
1.54E-06
2.37E-08
1.99E-08
3.94E-08
2.24E-06
3.51E-08
1.09E-04
1.3BE-06
2.46E-06
8.43E-07
1.14E-06
5.59E-06
1.81E-10
3.84E-05
2.17E-08
2.07E-08
3.57E-09
1.41E-08
1.66E-06
1.17E-06
1.19E-05
3.25E-07
4.85E-08
3.81E-08
2.30E-08
7.29E-07
4.12E-08
6.34E-08
1.52E-09
4.13E-07
4.53E-06
6.28E-06
1.41E-08
1.07E-06
1.43E-06
6.85E-08
8.49E-09
6.34E-09
9.16E-06
1.08E-07
3.51E-06
7.40E-10
U.21E-10
9.S9E-12
1.21E-08
1.99E-07
1.95E-07
1.87E-07
1.75E-07
1.72E-07
1.55E-07
1.51E-07
1.45E-07
1.41E-07
1.24E-07
1.20E-07
1.03E-07
7.95E-08
7.73E-08
7.55E-08
7.54E-08
7.34E-08
6.25E-08
5.99E-08
S.81E-08
5.17E-08
4.96E-08
4.64E-08
3.68E-08
3.51E-08
3.17E-08
3.03E-08
3.02E-08
3.02E-08
2.80E-08
2.78E-08
2.70E-08
2.08E-08
1.87E-08
1.86E-08
.71E-08
.33E-08
.10E-08
.08E-08
.92E-09
-75E-09
.89E-09
.73E-09
.35E-09
6.44E-09
3.46E-07
1.94E-07
2.19E-05
9.39E-06
2.14E-06
3.40E-07
1.20E-05
1.03E-05
9.45E-07
4.73E-07
6.78E-07
1.70E-07
3.32E-07
4.39E-06
3.26E-07
2.65E-07
1.56E-07
1.37E-07
1.02E-07
1.74E-06
2.04E-05
1.88E-07
2.44E-07
1.54E-07
2.48E-07
2.21E-05
2.25E-08
7.00E-08
9.81E-08
9.20E-08
1.74E-06
6.77E-05
2.70E-08
2.31E-06
7.51E-07
2.13E-08
4.66E-08
4.79E-08
7.20E-06
3.24E-08
8.6BE-06
2.01E-08
1.82E-08
5.85E-08
2.23E-08
2,060,000
309,000
4,870,000
626,000
2,580,000
425,000
92,400
2,690,000
1,150,000
2,680,000
4,250,000
1,940,000
1,260,000
189,000
6,100,000
1,730,000
2,240,000
425,000
1,170,000
333,000
2,360,000
708,000
189,000
415,000
649,000
547,000
328,000
1,970,000
469,000
804,000
2,640,000
284,000
2,000,000
824,000
2,210,000
2,090,000
113,000
395,000
158,000
902,000
76,500
200,000
2,590,000
362,000
386,000
1.97E+01
1.57E+00
2.17E+03
1.60E+02
3.15E+01
2.35E+00
1.09E+02
5.06E+02
2.29E+01
2.54E+01
4.13E+01
1.83E-t-0:
l.aOE+00
4.16E+01
1.87E+01
1.49E+00
4.77E+00
9.45E-01
7.93E+00
2.82E+01
1.60E+02
3.17E+00
4.90E-01
5.59E-01
1.12E+00
7.34E+01
3.23E-01
2.02E+00
4.56E-01
4.07E+00
6.80E+01
1.01E+02
6.21E-01
2.22E+01
3.85E-f01
2.07E+00
8.00E-02
3.32E-01
1.12E+01
2.73E+00
6.15E+00
2.16E-02
5.15E-01
1.71E-01
1.02E-01
<0.0001430,000.
<0.0001***********
0.0003 3,900.
(0.0001 53,000.
<0.0001270,000.
<0.0001 ***********
<0.0001 77,000.
0.0001 17,000.
<0.0001370,000.
<0.0001330,000.
<0.0001200,000.
(0.0001460,000.
(0.0001***********
<0.0001200,000.
(0.0001450,000.
(0.0001***********
(0.0001***********
(0.0001***********
(0.0001***********
(0.0001300,000.
(0.0001 53,000.
(0.0001***********
(0.0001***********
(0.0001***********
(0.0001***********
(0.0001110,000.
(0.0001***********
(0.0001***********
(0.0001***********
(0.0001***********
(0.0001120,000.
(0.0001 83,000.
(0.0001***********
(0.0001380,000.
(0.0001220,000.
(0.0001***********
(0.0001***********
(0.0001***********
(0.0001750,000.
(0.0001***********
(0.0001***********
(0.0001***********
(0.0001***********
(0.0001***********
(0.0001***********
9 UPJOHN CO.,THE NORTH
2 MONSANTO CO ANNIS
258 CHEVRON PHILA
254 SUN REFINING TULSA
78 NEPERA CHEMICAL CO., HARRI
29 AIR PRODUCTS I CHEN. WICHI
251 CONOCO PONCA
100 ATLANTIC RICHFIELD HOUST
376 HERITAGE ENV. SER7IC IRDIA
118 KOPPERS HOUST
366 CHEM-MET SERVICES WTAND
382 CECOS INT'L BRIST
41 UNION CARBIDE CORP. HAHNV
321 EMPIRE COKE COMPANY TUSCA
363 CID-LANDFILL CALOM
23 REILLY TAR AND CHEMI GRANI
115 GOODYEAR TIRE t RUBB LAPOR
28 ABBOTT LABORATORIES WICHI
370 FRONTIER CHEMICAL NIAGR
344 ERIE COKE ERIE
328 BETHLEHEM STEEL BURNS
99 AMOCO CHEMICAL TEXAS
33 GAT CORP. CALVE
85 USS CHEMICAL IRONT
54 MALLINCKRODT CHEM. RALE!
219 STAR REF. CONVE
102 CELANESE CHEMICAL BISHO
81 BF GOODRICH AVON
18 NORCHEM CO. CLINT
1 ALLIED SIGNAL BIBMI
111 GEORGIA GULF CORP. PASAD
226 CHEVRON PASCA
5 DOW CHEMICAL PITTS
128 HERCULES MAGNA
50 MONSANTO CO ST. L
361 CHEMICAL PROCESSORS SEATT
3 GREAT LAKES CHEMICAL EL DO
120 MOBIL CHEMICALS BEAUM
261 QUAKER STATE OIL REF SMETH
76 EASTMAN KODAK ROCHE
139 MAPCO PETROLEUM NORTH
19 CLARK OIL fi REFINING BLUE
113 GLIDDER COATINGS CARRO
17 OLIN CHEMICALS AUGUS
114 GOODYEAR TIRE BEAUM
-------
TABLE D-5. (continued)
Sumnary foe BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Ma x i n u • -
Lifetime
Cone People Exposure Incidence (tax Risk
SIC-
CAS«
Hi n i •
Cone People
u a - -
Annual Repeat
Exposure Incidence Interval
Page 8 of 9
7.53E-04
7.52E-04
7.13E-04
6.99E-04
6.86E-04
6.63E-04
6.50E-04
6.19E-04
5.53E-04
5.47E-04
5.27E-04
5. 16E-04
4.78E-04
4.S8E-04
3.69E-04
3 . 68E-04
3.50E-04
3 .32E-04
3 . 28E-04
3.12E-04
2.85E-04
2.39E-04
2.35E-04
2.01E-04
1.91E-04
1.68E-04
1.44E-04
1.43E-04
1.41E-04
1.41E-04
1.34E-04
1.31E-04
1.17E-04
1.14E-04
1.14E-04
9.28E-05
7.86E-05
7.75E-05
7.75E-05
7.45E-05
7.30E-05
7.30E-05
7.11E-05
6.30E-05
5.67E-05
1
491
<1
22
10
601
525
14
4
387
1
360
170
5
1,270
38
1,450
<1
36
4
860
50
175
22
12
598
1,850
23
2,170
109
L.980
(1
5
24
29
22
1,150
4
<1
<1
2
1
5
33
oSl
9.66E-04
3.69E-01
2.15E-04
1.54E-02
6.86E-03
3.99E-01
3.41E-01
8.42E-03
2.39E-03
2.12E-01
3.42E-0<1
1 .86E-01
8.13E-02
2 .19E-03
4 .70E-01
1 .40E-02
5.07E-01
5.66E-05
1 .17E-02
1.26E-03
2 .45E-01
1.19E-02
4 .HE-O:
4.42E-02
2 . 22E-02
1 .OOE-Ol
2 . 66E-01
3 .28E-03
3.05E-01
1 .53E-0 .
2.65E-01
3 . 38E-05
5.85E-OJ
2.73E-03
3.31E-03
2.04E-03
9.07E-02
3 .33E-0-
2.15E-0.',
1.28E-0'
1.80E-0-
3.72E-0:-
3.33E-0-
2 . OSE — .'-
3.J62-. .
8
3
1
1
5
3
2
6
1
1
J.
1
6
1
i
i
4
4
9
1
2
9
3
3
1
U
1
2
2
L
2
•1
£
2
1
1
i
I
I
1
3
2
1
3
.02E-09
.06E-06
.78E-09
.28E-07
.70E-08
.31E-06
.83E-06
.99E-08
.98E-08
.76E-06
.84E-09
.54E-06
.75E-07
.82E-08
. 90E-06
.16E-07
. 20E-06
.70E-10
.73E-08
. 05E-08
.04E-06
.90E-08
. 41E— 07
. 67E-08
. 84E— 08
. 33E-07
. 21E— 06
.73E-08
. 54E-06
. 27E-07
.20E-06
. 80E-10
.85E-09
. 26E-08
.75E-08
.69E-08
.53E-07
.77E— 09
.79E-11
-06E-11
.49E-09
.09E-10
-76E-09
.73E-08
.21E-07
6.2SE-09
6.24E-09
5.91E-09
5.80E-09
5.70E-09
5.50E-09
5.39E-09
5.14E-09
4.59E-09
4.54E-09
4.37E-09
4.28E-09
3.97E-09
3.80E-09
3.06E-09
3.05E-09
2.90E-09
2.75E-09
2.72E-09
2.59E-09
2.37E-09
1.98E-09
1.95E-09
1.67E-09
1.59E— 09
1 .39E-09
1.19E— 09
1.18E-09
1.17E-09
1.17E-09
1.11E-09
1.09E-09
9.72E-10
9.50E-10
9.50E-10
7.70E-10
6.53E-10
6.44E-10
6.43E-10
6.18E-10
6.06E-10
6.06E-10
5.90E-10
5.23E-10
4.71E-10
3
9
4
4
8
4
2
2
i
y
i
3
1
/
1
6
1
4
1
5
3
6
1
1
3
2
1
3
4
1
1
1
1
1
1
a
i
3
3
3
i
3
3
7
4
.91E-08
.99E-06
.96E-08
. 49E-04
.28E-09
.31E-06
.88E-06
. 23E-08
. 26E-08
.82E-06
.93E-07
. 81E-06
. 46E-05
. 69E-09
.82E-07
.57E-09
.13E-05
.70E-09
.72E-08
.15E-07
. 08E-06
.65E-06
. 66E-06
.91E-05
.28E-09
.08E— 06
. 32E-06
.90E-06
.91E-06
. 87E-06
.63E-06
. 85E-09
.23E-09
. 55E-09
.36E-09
.83E-06
.10E-06
. 68E-09
. 84E-09
.63E-09
.96E-09
.10E-09
.15E-09
. 81E-06
.49E-07
12
13
2
i2
2
2
1
5
13
1
3
4
4
2
294,000
221,000
,700,000
252
,300,000
357,000
406,000
435,000
483,000
27,100
,450,000
76 ,500
206,000
,500,000
556,000
613 ,000
432,000
300,000
415,000
,580,000
89,200
354,000
60 ,000
34,800
, 610 ,000
108 ,000
551 ,000
24 ,400
281,000
25 ,100
180 ,000
573,000
,330,000
,190,000
,800,000
34,800
34,300
,780,000
460,000
,440,000
,570,000
,810,000
,200,000
6,710
163,000
7.37E-02
1.19E+01
1.17E+01
1.19E-01
4.79E+00
9.51E+00
2.99E+01
6.50E-01
1.47E-01
2.69E+00
5.39E+00
2.70E+00
1.89E+01
1.64E+00
3.33E+00
4.08E-01
2.74E+01
1.68E-02
4.86E-01
1.47E+01
2.33E+00
1.22E+01
2.47E+00
1.13E+00
1.91E— 01
1.26E+00
2.57E+00
5.36E-01
9.66E+00
3.75E-01
3.07E+00
4.61E-02
1.17E-01
1.65E— 01
1.54E+00
5.21E-01
8.46E-01
9.24E— 02
1.17E-02
6.67E-02
1.09E-01
1.45E-01
1.23E-01
1.49E-01
4.93E-01
<0. 0001710, 000.
<0. 0001720, 000.
<0. 00 01 ***********
<0. 0001890, 000.
<0. 0001280, 000.
<0. 0001450, 000.
<0. 0001310, 000.
<0. 0001570, 000.
<0. 0001690, 000.
<0.0001**"""***
<0. 0001870, 000.
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0. 0001 ***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0. 0001 ***********
25 US INDUSTRIAL CHEM. TOSCO
206 CANAL REF. CHURC
56 AMERICAN CYANAMID CO LINDE
391 USPCI GRASSY HT. ENOHL
68 ORBIS PRODUCTS CORP NEWAR
356 ENV. ENTERPRISES CINCI
134 HUNT REFINING TDSCA
79 ALLIED CHEMICAL IRONT
96 us ARK; MUNITIONS KINGS
272 DIAMOND SHAMROCK SURRA
125 UPJOHN CO LA PO
140 PETRO STAR NORTH
379 CASMALIA RESOURCES CASMA
358 SOLVENT RECOV. SERVI LINDE
40 STAUFFER CHEMICAL BATON
362 CHEMICAL RESOURCES TULSA
133 BELCHER REF. MOBIL
14 DOW CHEMICAL DALTO
26 MEAD JOHNSON EVANS
106 DIAMOND SHAMROCK COR DEER
378 IT CORPORATION WESTM
210 HILL PETROLEUM EROTZ
242 GIANT REFINERY GALLU
138 CHEVRON KERAI
119 LILLY IND. COATINGS OALLA
143 BERRY PETROLEUM STEVE
38 GEORGIA-PACIFIC CORP PLAQU
250 BARRETT REF. THOMA
13 ATLANTIC WOOD INDUST SAVAN
197 FARMLAND FACILITIES PHILL
95 RHONE-POULENC.INC. MT. P
8 DOW CHEMICAL LEDYA
351 COMMERCIAL DISPOSAL WEST
55 AMERICAN CYANAMID BRIDG
360 CALLEIA RES. RECOVER BROOK
141 TESARO ALASKA PETROL KEHAI
243 NAVAJO REFINING ARTES
83 PPG INDUSTRIES HORTO
93 DUPONT LUGOF
396 WAYNE DISPOSAL BELLE
373 ROLLINS ENV. SERVICE BRIDG
63 HERCULES GZBBS
21 MONSANTO CO SADGE
142 INTERMOUNTAIN REF. FREDO
75 AYERST LABS ROUSE
-------
Suaaary for BENZENE REFXRERIE5
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maxinum-
Lifeti»e
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
TABLE D-5. (continued)
SIC=* CAS-
--Mini
Cone People
Annual Repeat
Exposure Incidence Interval
Page 9 of 9
4.62E-05
2.74E-05
1.38E-05
9.41E-06
3.68E-06
l.OOE-38
l.OOE-38
769
1,310
43
489
203
3.S5E-02
3.S8E-02
5.93E-04
4.60E-03
7.46E-04
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
2.95E-07
2.97E-07
4.92E-09
3.82E-08
6.20E-09
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
3.83E-10
2.27E-10
1.14E-10
7.81E-11
3.05E-11
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
7.57E-07
5.73E-07
5.93E-08
2.70E-06
4.51E-08
l.OOE+38
l.OOE+38
118,000
423,000
87,400
536
552,000
3.63E-01
1.72E+00
1.25C-01
4.73E-03
1.15E-01
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
<0.0001***********
52 KERR-MCGEE CHEH. COR HERID
392 PEORIA DISPOSAL CO.. PEORZ
123 UNION CARBIDE SEADR
234 NEVADA REF. TONOP
37 ETHYL CORP. BATON
130 ALDRICB CHEMICALS HIIMA
136 ARCO ALASKA KUPAR
701,000,000 1.75E+05
0.021
48.
Overall
-------
TABLE D-6. HEM RESULTS FOR CASE 4 (CONTROLLED MAXIMUM)
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-MaxinuB-
Lifetime
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
SIC- CAS-
- - H i n i
Cone People
Annual Repeat
Exposure Incidence Interval
Page 1. of 9
5 o u r c
9.45E+00
8.69E4-00
8.55E+00
7.92E+00
7.86E+00
6.92E+00
6.26E+00
6.07E+00
6.03E+00
5.91E+00
5.87E+00
5.54E+00
5.48E+00
5.23E+00
5.12E+00
4.74E+00
4.74E+00
4.51E-I-00
4.46E+00
4.37E-I-00
4.32E+00
4.19E+00
4.1BE+00
4.08E+00
4.02E+00
4.02E+00
3.97E+00
3.95E+00
3.94E+00
3.92E+00
3.84E+00
3.81E+00
3.81E+00
3.80E+00
3.79E+00
3.75E+00
3.74E+00
3.69E+00
3.64E+00
3.59E+00
3.56E+00
3.55E+00
3.49E+00
3.49E+00
3.49E+00
1
13
<1
<1
2
<1
11
6
10
2
18
1
<1
71
112
6
1
<1
<1
18
<1
1
<1
<1
<1
3
<1
1
65
7
3
<1
<1
<1
<1
<1
10
<1
2
21
1
1
1
89
1
7.90E+00
1.17E+02
4.91E-02
1.43E-01
1.37E+01
1.21E+00
7.03E+01
3.45E+01
6.19E+01
1.25E+01
1.05E-1-02
4.82E+00
2.26E+00
3.69E+02
S.73E+02
2.97E+01
5.76E+00
2.18E-01
8.91E-01
7.66E+01
2.04E+00
2.83E+00
1.01E-01
1.45E+00
1.62E+00
1.03E+01
3.26E-01
3.64E+00
2.57E+0:
2.90E-I-01
1.12E+01
8.66E-01
1.28E+00
6.69E-0:
9.56E-02
4.20E-01
3.71E+01
1.16E+00
6.32E+00
7.62E+01
2.37E+0;
3.81E+.: .
4.24E+0-:
3.11E4-0:
3.01EV.
6.56E-05
9.70E-04
4.07E-07
1.19E-06
1.13E-04
l.OOE-05
5.83E-04
2.86E-04
5.13E-04
1.04E-04
8.70E-04
4.00E-05
1.88E-05
3.06E-03
4.76E-03
2.47E-04
4.78E-05
1.81E-06
7-.39E-06
6.36E-04
1.69E-05
2.35E-05
8.36E-07
1.20E-05
1.35E-05
8 .52E-05
2.71E-06
3.02E-05
2.13E-03
2.41E-04
9.27E-05
7.19E-06
L.06E-05
5.55E-07
7.94E-07
3.48E-06
3.08E-04
9.61E-06
5.25E-05
6.32E-04
1.97E-05
3.16E-05
3.52E-05
:.58E-03
2.50E-05
7.85E-05
7.21E-05
7.09E-05
6.57E-05
6.52E-05
5.74E-05
S.20E-OS
S.04E-OS
5.01E-05
4.90E-05
4.88E-05
4.60E-05
4.55E-05
4.34E-05
4.25E-05
3.93E-05
3.93E-05
3.74E-05
3.70E-05
3.63E-05
3.5BE-05
3.48E-05
3.47E-05
3.39E-05
3.34E-05
3.33E-05
3.29E-05
3.28E-05
3.27E-05
3.25E-05
3.19E-05
3.16E-05
3.16E-05
3.15E-05
3.15E-05
3.11E-05
3.11E-05
3.06E-05
3.03E-05
2.98E-05
2.9SE-05
2.95E-05
2.90E-05
2.90E-05
2.90E-05
7
9
6
7
1
8
1
1
1
1
2
1
4
8
1
9
9
8
4
2
1
1
7
6
7
2
2
1
6
2
6
7
4
9
1
1
1
1
1
2
1
4
6
1
2
. 49E-05
.11E-06
. 24E-05
.25E-05
.20E-04
. 84E-05
.63E-04
. 04E-04
.38E-04
.79E-04
. 11E-04
. 01E-04
.27E-05
.15E-05
. 60E-03
.47E-05
.23E-05
. 89E-05
. 09E-OS
. 62E-04
.36E-04
. 46E-04
.75E-05
.S8E-05
.75E-05
. 62E-05
.34E-04
.32E-04
.70E-05
. 04E-04
.65E-05
.23E-05
.36E-05
.87E-05
.30E-04
. 48E-04
.29E-04
.53E-04
.41E-04
.09E-05
.45E-04
.80E-05
. 81E-05
.14E-04
.94E-05
228
1,060
230
249
61
1,760
7,970
7,880
4,530
3,070
556
207
151
8,200
2,030
325
325
2,590
125
1,190
695
397
379
929
126
893
326
228
1,310
1,170
134
30
17
763
137
359
5,420
4,830
720
382
110
3,220
325
2,680
259
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,900
,500
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
4.34E+02
5.22E-I-03
2.92E-M32
8.80E+02
4.77E+02
2.74E+03
1.42E+04
1.15E+04
5.16E+03
5.31E+03
6.33E+03
3.88E+02
1.61E+02
1.80E+04
3.50E+04
5.30E+03
2.62E+03
3.21E+03
8.84E+01
8.53E+03
1.68E+03
1.45E+03
4.21E-I-02
1.79E+03
1.33E+02
1.03E+03
9.74E+02
5.81E+02
1.01E-I-04
5.30E+03
7.13E+02
5.97E+01
4.13E+01
6.24E+02
7.05E+02
9.30E-t-02
8.21E-I-03
7.55E+03
7.01E+02
1.45E+03
1.94E+03
1.62E+03
1.93E+03
7.17E1-03
8.18E+02
0.0001
0.0006
<0.0001
0.0001
0.0001
0.0003
0.0017
0.0014
0.0006
0.0006
0.0008
<0.0001
<0.0001
0.0021
0.0041
0.0006
0.0003
0.0004
<0.0001
0.0010
0.0002
0.0002
0.0001
0.0002
<0.0001
0.0001
0.0001
0.0001
0.0012
0.0006
0.0001
19,000
1,600
29,000
9,600
18,000
3,100
590
730
1,600
1,600
1,300
22,000
52,000
470
240
1,600
3,200
2,600
95,000
990
5,000
5,800
20,000
4,700
63,000
8,100
8,700
15,000
840
1,600
12,000
<0. 0001140, 000
<0. 0001200, 000
0.0001
0.0001
0.0001
0.0010
0.0009
0.0001
0.0002
0.0002
0.0002
0.0002
0.0009
0.0001
14,000
12,000
9,100
1,000
1,100
12,000
5,800
4,300
5,200
4,400
1,200
10,000
309 TEXACO USA ANACO
280 HOWELL HYDROCARBONS SAN A
306 SHELL OIL ANACO
110 EASTMAN KODAK, INC. LONGV
241 BLOOKTIELD REFINING BLOOM
308 SOUND REF. TACOM
149 CHEVRON EL SE
174 UNION OIL OF CALIFOS W1LMI
162 ireWHALL REFINING CO. NEWHA
150 CHEVRON RICHH
209 EXXON CORP BATON
260 PENNZOIL COMPANY ROUSE
307 SOHIO FERND
148 CHEMOIL SIGNA
98 AMERICAN HOECHST COR HOUST
159 KERN OIL & REFINING BAKER
167 SAN JOAQUIN REF. BAKES
290 SHELL OIL DEER
304 ARCO PETROLEUM FERND
215 MURPHY OIL CORPORATI MERAU
266 AMOCO TEXAS
286 MOBIL OIL BEAUN
199 TEXACO REFINING EL DO
300 CRYSEN REFINING WOODS
229 SOUTHLAND OIL SANDE
91 UNION CARBIDE PENUE
191 INDIANA FARM BUREAU MT. V
207 CITGO PETROLEUM LAKE
256 CHEVRON PORTL
27 REILLY TAR AND CREMI INDIA
196 FARMLAND INDUSTRIES COFFE
301 PENNZOIL ROOSE
317 SINCLAIR OIL SINCL
183 HAWAII INDEP. REF. EWA B
107 DOW CHEMICAL USA FREE?
293 STAR REF. PORT
190 AMOCO CHEMICAL MHITI
240 MOBIL OIL PAULS
213 MARATHON PETROLEUM GART7
397 TEXAS ECOLOGISTS ROBST
227 ERGON REF. VICKS
164 PACIFIC REF. HERCU
170 SUNLAND REF. BAKER
278 HILL PETROLEUM ROUST
282 LA GLORIA OIL AND GA TYLER
-------
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maximum-
Lifetime
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
TABLE D-6. (continued)
SIC- CAS-
Minimum
Cone People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 2 of 9
S o u r c
3.45E+00
3.35E+00
3.28E+00
3.24E+00
3.18E+00
3.16E+00
3.15E+00
3.09E+00
3.02E+00
2.99E+00
2.96E+00
2.90E+00
2.89E+00
2.88E+00
2.83E+00
2.83E+00
2.80E+00
2.78E+00
2.76E+00
2.75E-I-00
2.71E+00
2.70E4-00
2.69E+00
2.68E+00
2.56E+00
2.55E+00
2.50E+00
2.47E+00
2.46E+00
2.40E+00
2.40E+00
2.40E+00
2.38E+00
2.38E+00
2.37E+00
2.35E+00
2.33E+00
2.33E+00
2.33E+00
2.31E+00
2.28E+00
2.27E+00
2.25E+00
2.22E+00
2.21E+00
13
4
5
1
1
111
<1
1
<1
1
1
<1
<1
<1
4
13
3
1
105
<1
<1
1
15
<1
2
4
4
25
3
4
3
1
17
6
7
6
50
<1
1
40
<1
< 1
1
1
1
4
1
1
3
2
3
5
1
1
2
3
5
5
1
1
3
9
2
2
1
2
3
3
1
5
9
9
6
6
8
6
2
3
1
1
1
1
2
I
9
1
1
2
2
1
.55E+01
.36E+01
.75E+01
.93E+00
.05E+00
.50E+02
.66E-01
.98E+00
.05E+00
.96E+00
. 24E+00
.05E-01
.79E-01
. 25E+00
.22E+01
.64E+01
.68E+00
.81E+00
.91E+02
.07E-t-00
.81E-01
.45E+00
.95E+01
.27E-01
.26E+00
.64E+00
.36E+00
.06E+01
.68E+00
.49E+0'.
.41E-KK
.19E+00
.94E-K01
.44E+01
.55E+01
.43E+01
.16E+02
.77E-01
.48E-I-00
.28E+01
.02E+00
.23E-01
.SIE+OI;
.30E-I-C .
.IfE*'.
3.78E-04
1.13E-04
1.45E-04
3.26E-05
1.70E-05
2.91E-03
4.69E-06
1.64E-05
8.67E-06
2.46E-05
2.69E-05
4.19E-06
4.80E-06
1.04E-05
1.01E-04
3.02E-04
8.04E-05
2.34E-05
2.41E-03
8.87E-06
2.33E-06
2.86E-05
3.28E-04
1.06E-06
4.37E-05
8.00E-05
7.77E-05
5.03E-04
5.55E-05
7.05E-05
5.32E-05
1.82E-05
3.27E-04
1.20E-04
1.29E-04
1.18E-04
9.59E-04
2.30E-06
1.23E-05
7.70E-04
3.45E-06
1.02E-06
2.09E-05
1.91E-05
9.60E-06
2.87E-05
2.78E-05
2.72E-05
2.69E-05
2.64E-05
2.62E-05
2.61E-05
2.56E-05
2.50E-05
2.48E-05
2.46E-05
2.41E-05
2.40E-05
2.39E-05
2.35E-05
2.35E-05
2.32E-05
2.30E-05
2.29E-05
2.28E-05
2.25E-05
2.24E-05
2.23E-05
2.22E-05
2.12E-05
2.12E-05
2.08E-05
2.0SE-05
2.04E-05
1.99E-05
1.99E-05
1.99E-05
1.97E-05
1.97E-05
1.96E-05
1.95E-05
1.94E-05
1.94E-05
1.93E-05
1.92E-05
1.90E-05
1.88E-OS
1.87E-05
1.84E-05
1.83E-05
1.26E-04
3.05E-05
1.16E-04
6.31E-05
2.67E-05
5.10E-05
6.02E-05
9.52E-05
1.08E-04
1.05E-04
1.32E-04
3.70E-05
1.23E-04
1.10E-04
5.22E-05
1.05E-04
5.06E-05
4.77E-05
4.07E-05
2.18E-05
1.82E-05
9.01E-05
4.39E-05
1.10E-04
7.84E-05
5.51E-05
6.16E-05
1.58E-04
1.9BE-05
1.11E-04
1.43E-04
6.61E-05
6.38E-OS
4.25E-OS
7.92E-05
4.20E-05
4.83E-OS
8.23E-05
5.61E-05
6.84E-05
1.33E-05
3.97E-OS
4.92E-OS
7.69E-OS
2.34E-05
6
8
1
1
1
10
1
8
1
2
2
3
a
1
•1
8
697,000
88,000
,360,000
325,000
102,000
,090,000
192,000
,270,000
377,000
209,000
55,300
,760,000
,140,000
38,900
,500,000
,970,000
147,000
361,000
,550,000
34,700
339,000
,380,000
625,000
,060,000
225,000
197,000
,920,000
494,000
859,000
,810,000
9,580
171,000
,460,000
327,000
676,000
327,000
83,000
,900,000
,640,000
,530,000
364,000
75,300
248,000
415,000
92,200
2.20E+03
3.55E+02
1.14E+04
1.79E+03
1.56E+02
1.06E+04
2.15E+02
7.24E+02
8.40E+02
3.31E+02
2.57E+02
1.15E+03
8.42E+02
9.73E+01
6.24E+03
2.70E+03
5.73E+02
1.92E+02
1.14E+04
1.19E+02
1.20E+03
6.19E+02
1.74E+03
1.64E+03
7.17E-MJ2
4.09E+02
1.77E+03
3.48E+03
9.04E+02
3.64E+03
2.73E+02
1.15E+02
6.04E+03
2.14E+03
1.25E+03
2.11E+03
2.82E+03
1.16E4-03
1.52E+03
1.10E+04
2.73E+02
7.71E+02
1.17E+02
2.80E+02
6.74E+01
0.0003
<0.0001
0.0013
0.0002
<0.0001
0.0013
<0.0001
0.0001
0.0001
<0.0001
<0.0001
0.0001
0.0001
<0.0001
0.0007
0.0003
0.0001
<0.0001
0.0013
<0.0001
0.0001
0.0001
0.0002
0.0002
0.0001
<0.0001
0.0002
0.0004
0.0001
0.0004
<0.0001
<0.0001
0.0007
0.0003
0.0001
0.0003
0.0003
0.0001
0.0002
0.0013
<0.0001
0.0001
<0.0001
<0.0001
3,800.
24,000.
740.
4,700.
54,000.
800.
39,000.
12,000.
10,000.
25,000.
33,000.
7,300.
10,000.
87,000.
1,400.
3,100.
15,000.
44,000.
740.
71,000.
7,000.
14,000.
4,900.
5,200.
12,000.
21,000.
4,800.
2,400.
9,300.
2,300.
31,000.
73,000.
1,400.
3,900.
6,800.
4,000.
3,000.
7,200.
5,500.
770.
31,000.
11,000.
72,000.
30,000.
<0. 0001130, 000.
279 HILL PETROLEUM TEXAS
255 TOTAL PETROLEUM ARDMO
184 CLARK OIL & REFINING BLUE
171 TEXACO REFINING BAKER
126 WITCO CHEMICAL CORPO POINT
169 SHELL OIL WZLHI
264 UNITED REF. VfARRE
217 SHELL CHEM CO NORCO
201 ASHLAND PETROLEUM CO ASHLA
151 CONOCO SANTA
287 PHILLIPS 66 REFINER? BORGE
310 U.S. OIL t REFINING TACOH
218 BP OIL BELLE
276 FINA OIL BIG S
64 INT'L FLAVORS t FRAG UNION
319 ASHLAND PETROLEUM ST. P
198 RATIONAL COOPERATIVE MCPHE
132 MOBAY CHEMICAL CORP HEW M
165 PARAMOUNT PET. PARAM
273 DIAMOND SHAMROCK REF THREE
267 CHAMPLIN PETROLEUM C CORPU
387 CECOS INT'L WILL!
253 SINCLAIR OIL TULSA
188 SHELL OIL HOOD
204 CALCASIEU REFINING LAKE
259 WITCO CHEMICAL CORP. BRADF
176 UNION OIL OF CALIFOH RODEO
268 CHEVRON EL PA
77 GENERAL ELECTRIC WATER
222 MARATHON PET. DETRO
318 WTOMING REF. . NEWCA
288 PHILLIPS SWEEN
161 MOBIL OIL TORRA
155 WITCO CORP. OILDA
285 MARATHON OIL TEXAS
7 WITCO CORP. OILDA
233 MONTANA REFINING COM GREAT
224 KOCH REFINING ROSEM
178 CONOCO COMME
160 LUNDAY-THAGARD CO. SOUTH
281 KOCH INDUSTRIES CORPU
314 AMOCO CASPE
212 KERH-HCGEE REFINING COTTO
80 ARIS TECH CHEMICAL HAVER
252 KERR MCGEE WYNNE
-------
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maxinum-
Lifetime
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
TABLE D-6. (continued)
SIC- CAS«
--HinimuB--
Conc People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 3 of 9
S o u r c
2.21E+00
2.20E+00
2.20E+00
2.16E+00
2.13E+00
2.10E+00
2.10E+00
2.08E+00
2.08E+00
2.04E+00
2.03E+00
2.03E+00
2.01E+00
2.01E+00
2.01E+00
2.00E+00
1.99E+00
1.98E+00
1.95E-I-00
1.95E+00
1.92E+00
1.89E+00
1 .88E+00
1.87E+00
1.83E+00
1.80E+00
1.80E+00
1.79E-I-00
1.76E+00
1.72E+00
1.72E+00
1.70E+00
1.70E+00
1.69E+00
1.68E+00
1.68E+00
1.6BE+00
1.66E+00
1.66E+00
1.66E+00
1.62E+00
1.61E+00
1.59E+00
1.57E+00
1.57E+00
34
1
<1
28
<1
9
6
1
14
1
17
9
2
2
1
111
207
2
7
4
<1
2
46
2
1
<1
48
1
1
16
3
27
4
12
30
1
<1
<1
<1
21
97
12
12
18
<1
7.42E+01
2.58E+00
5.94E-02
5.96E+01
2.70E-01
1.98E+01
1.28E+01
1.91E+00
2.98E+01
1.09E+00
3.48E+01
1.79E+01
4.63E+00
3.35E+00
2.81E+00
2.21E+02
4.12E+02
3.04E+00
1.34E+01
7.77E+00
2.27E-01
3.76E+00
8.61E+01
4.08E+00
1.02E+00
1.33E-01
8.70E+01
1.48E+00
1.55E+00
2.71E+01
5.91E+00
4.62E+01
6.60E+OC
1.96E+01
5.09E-KH
1.85E+00
3.58E-01
9.06E-02
2.92E-OJ
3.53E+01
1.56E+0:
1.92Ei-;.
1.8-lE + Oi
2.7fiE+01
6.6SE-:.
6.16E-04
2.14E-05
4.93E-07
4.95E-04
2.24E-06
1.64E-04
1.06E-04
1.S8E-OS
2.48E-04
9.04E-06
2.89E-04
1.48E-04
3.85E-05
2.78E-05
2.34E-05
1.84E-03
3.42E-03
2.53E-05
1.11E-04
6.45E-05
1.88E-06
3.12E-05
7.15E-04
3.38E-05
8.49E-06
1.11E-06
7.22E-04
1.22E-05
1.29E-05
2.25E-04
4.90E-05
3.83E-04
5.48E-05
1.62E-04
•J.22E-04
1.54E-05
2.97E-06
7.52E-07
2.43E-07
2.93E-04
1.30E-03
1.59E-04
1.53E-04
2.29E-04
5.55E-06
1.83E-05
1.83E-OS
1.83E-05
1.80E-05
1.76E-05
1.74E-05
1.74E-OS
1.73E-05
1.72E-05
1.69E-05
1.69E-05
1.69E-05
1.67E-05
1.67E-05
1.6«E-05
1.66E-05
1.65E-05
1.64E-05
1.62E-05
1.61E-05
1.59E-05
1.57E-05
1.56E-OS
1.55E-05
1.S2E-OS
1.49E-05
1.49E-OS
1.49E-05
1.46E-05
1.43E-05
1.43E-05
1.41E-05
1.41E-05
1.40E-05
1.40E-OS
1.40E-05
1.39E-05
1.38E-05
1.38E-05
1.37E-05
1.34E-05
1.34E-05
1.32E-05
1.30E-05
1.30E-OS
5
9
4
5
1
9
8
4
3
3
3
2
6
5
1
3
5
8
1
2
6
5
1
5
5
5
8
4
5
2
6
6
2
2
2
1
5
2
4
6
5
1
5
5
5
.74E-05
.92E-05
.67E-05
. 36E-05
. 21E-04
.43E-05
.93E-05
.17E-05
.33E-05
. 63E-05
.71E-05
.87E-05
.16E-OS
.OOE-05
.03E-04
.23E-05
. 64E-05
.55E-05
.27E-04
. 01E-05
.71E-05
.33E-05
. 24E-05
. 04E-05
. 29E-05
. 23E-05
. 16E-05
.31E-05
. 08E-05
. 20E-05
.22E-05
.54E-05
.79E-05
.97E-05
.87E-05
.06E-05
. 86E-05
.91E-05
.31E-05
. 49E-05
.43E-05
. 99E-05
.03E-05
.53E-05
.68E-05
381
159
230
92
1,190
831
2,090
2,670
921
110
2,790
12,700
225
1,630
927
8,090
8,640
971
434
2,090
1,510
168
338
555
388
154
2,760
392
97
111
4,750
4,440
8,070
1,690
8,170
344
382
75
763
4,450
333
11,600
78
6,550
204
,000
,000
,000
,800
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,800
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,300
,000
,000
,000
,000
,500
,000
,000
2.57E+03
5.14E+02
6.64E+01
1.40E+03
4.22E+03
2.81E+03
1.45E+03
1.79E+03
1.44E+03
1.54E+02
7.71E+03
8.27E+03
5.46E+02
1.56E+03
8.19E+02
6.68E+03
1.21E+04
S.15E+02
1.23E+03
1.9SE+03
5.92E+02
1.20E+02
1.85E+03
6.51E+02
4.91E+02
7.00E-MU
2.92E+03
3.06E+02
1.06E+02
1.08E+03
1.70E+03
4.04E+03
3.74E+03
1.06E+03
4.73E+03
5.39E+02
4.07E+02
5.66E+02
2.72E+02
3.22E+03
1.82E+03
5.06E+03
5.82E+02
2.92E+03
3.78E+02
0.0003
0.0001
3,300.
16,000.
<0. 0001130, 000.
0.0002
0.0005
0.0003
0.0002
0.0002
0.0002
<0.0001
0.0009
0.0010
0.0001
0.0002
0.0001
0.0008
0.0014
0.0001
0.0001
0.0002
0.0001
<0.0001
0.0002
0.0001
0.0001
6,000.
2,000.
3,000.
5,800.
4,700.
5,800.
55,000.
1,100.
1,000.
15,000.
5,400.
10,000.
1,300.
700.
16,000.
6,900.
4,300.
14,000.
70,000.
4,600.
13,000.
17,000.
<0. 0001120, 000.
0.0003
<0.0001
<0.0001
0.0001
0.0002
0.0005
0.0004
0.0001
0.0006
0.0001
<0.0001
0.0001
<0.0001
0.0004
0.0002
0.0006
0.0001
0.0003
<0.0001
2,900.
28,000.
80,000.
7,800.
5,000.
2,100.
2,300.
7,900.
1,800.
16,000.
21,000.
15,000.
31,000.
2,600.
4,600.
1,700.
14,000.
2,900.
22,000.
203 PENNZOIL SHREV
186 MARATHON PETROLEUM ROBIN
146 ANCHOR REF. HCKIT
145 LION OIL EL DO
214 MOBIL CHALM
340 TOLEDO COKE TOLED
185 CLARK OIL & REF. HARTF
271 CROWN CENTRAL ROUST
297 AMOCO OIL REFINERY SALT
200 TOTAL PETROLEUM ARKAR
44 PMC CORP. BALTI
238 EXXON LINDE
208 CONOCO CHEMICALS WESTL
177 COLORADO REF. COMME
312 QUAKER STATE OIL REF NEWEL
158 HUNTWAX REF. WILMZ
175 UNOCAL LOS A
303 AMOCO OIL REFINERY TORKT
135 LOUISIANA LAND I EXP SARAL
305 CHEVRON SEATT
187 MOBIL OIL JOLIE
228 SOUTHLAND OIL LUMBE
292 SOUTHWESTERN REFININ CORFU
216 PLACID REFINING PORT
295 UNION OIL OF CALIFOR NEDEB
225 AMERADA HESS PUR7I
153 EXXON BENIC
108 DUPONT BEAUM
144 CROSS OIL & REFINING SHACK
231 CONOCO REFINERY BILLI
394 WASTE CONVERSION HATFI
262 BP OIL MARCU
172 TEXACO REFINING WILMI
181 YOUNG REF. DOUGL
154 FLETCHER OIL & REFIN WILMI
270 COASTAL REFINING CORPU
352 ASHLAND CHEMICAL BOYD
316 LITTLE AMERICA REF. CASPE
182 CHEVRON HONOL
263 SUN PETROLEUM MARCU
247 STANDARD OIL OF OHIO LIMA
236 CHEVRON PERTH
245 AMOCO MANDA
189 UNION OIL OF CALIFOR LEMON
291 SHELL OIL REFINERY ODESS
-------
TABLE D-6. (continued)
Sunmary for BENZENE
with a Unit Risk of
REFINERIES
8.30E-06
-Maxinun-
LifetiM
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
SIC*
CAS-
HinimuM
Cone People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 4 of 9
a
A
1.55E+00
1.54E+00
1.S4E+00
1.51E+00
1.51E+00
1.49E+00
1.46E+00
1.45E+00
1.42E+00
1.41E+00
1.41E+00
1.38E+00
1.37E+00
1.36E+00
1.32E+00
1.30E+00
1.29E+00
1.26E+00
1.26E+00
1.21E+00
1.19E+00
1.19E+00
1.19E+00
1.19E+00
1.19E+00
1.18E+00
1.18E+00
1.16E+00
1.13E+00
1.13E-I-00
1.08E+00
1.05E+00
1.03E+00
1.02E+00
1.02E+00
1.01E+00
9.75E-01
9.51E-01
9.50E-01
8.69E-01
8.68E-01
8.46E-01
8.42E-01
7.74E-01
7.63E-01
2
3
4,530
<1
<1
2
4
<1
3
<1
<1
2
33
40
13
1
2
44
42
14
<1
16
2
<1
1
1
36
1
<1
13
8
28
71
2
22
2
18
13
3
7
1
35
<1
3
1
3.30E+00
4.35E+00
6.98E+03
1.04E-02
2.97E-01
3.14E+00
5.62E+00
5.77E-01
4.86E+00
2.32E-02
1.38E-01
2.93E+00
4.48E+01
5.41E+01
1.77E+01
1.90E+00
2.82E+00
5.58E+01
5.22E+01
1.74E+01
8.16E-02
1.92E+01
2.38E+00
3.00E-01
1.13E+00
9.78E-01
4.24E+01
8.26E-01
2.87E-02
1.42E+01
8.2BE+00
2.97E+01
7.31E+01
2.18E+00
2.23E+01
2.17E+00
1.72E+01
1.24E-KH
2.43E+00
5.66E+00
7.17E-01
2.96E*Oi
2.03E-0:
2.01E+0:
7.42E-C-.
2.74E-05
3.61E-05
5.79E-02
8.65E-08
2.46E-06
2.61E-05
4.66E-05
4.79E-06
4.04E-05
1.92E-07
1.14E-06
2.43E-05
3.72E-04
4.49E-04
1.47E-04
1.58E-05
2.34E-05
4.63E-04
4.33E-04
1.44E-04
6.77E-07
1.60E-04
1.98E-05
2.49E-06
9.39E-06
3.12E-06
3.52E-04
6.86E-06
2.38E-07
1.1SE-04
6.87E-05
2.47E-04
6.07E-04
1.81E-05
1.85E-04
1.80E-05
1.43E-04
1.03E-04
2.01E-05
4.69E-05
5 . 9SE-06
2.46E-04
1 . 69E-07
1.67E-05
6.17E-06
1.29E-05
1.28E-05
1.28E-05
1.26E-05
1.25E-05
1.24E-05
1.21E-05
1.20E-05
1.17E-05
1.17E-05
1.17E-05
1.14E-05
1.14E-05
1.13E-05
1.10E-05
1.08E-05
1.07E-05
1.05E-05
1.04E-05
l.OOE-05
9.87E-06
9.85E-06
9.85E-06
9.84E-06
9.84E-06
9.83E-06
9.78E-06
9.66E-06
9.41E-06
9.37E-06
.96E-06
.70E-06
.57E-06
.49E-06
.44E-06
.35E-06
.09E-06
7.89E-06
7.89E-06
7.21E-06
7.20E-06
7.03E-06
6.99E-06
6.43E-06
6.33E-06
4.79E-05
2.54E-05
1.23E-03
3.19E-05
1.88E-OS
1.20E-04
5.37E-05
3.73E-05
6.87E-05
5.53E-05
2.55E-05
7.91E-05
6.70E-05
3.57E-05
2.51E-05
6.25E-05
7.64E-06
4.91E-05
4.81E-05
1.94E-05
2.30E-05
2.19E-05
5.43E-05
1.73E-05
2.97E-05
2.00E-05
1.77E-05
5.95E-05
4.00E-05
4.44E-05
9.22E-06
2.79E-05
1.26E-05
2.46E-05
3.55E-05
9.24E-06
4.05E-05
1.93E-05
6.19E-06
3.52E-05
4.47E-05
7.16E-05
1.56E-05
9.29E-06
1.33E-05
4,560
115
2,380
144
108
1,220
2,280
857
234
1,400
924
1,160
817
609
2,590
838
358
4,900
2,310
921
3,080
463
166
69
389
725
8,630
292
5,490
4,840
837
1,160
131
196
2,190
335
52
2,690
' 893
506
1,030
2,910
379
810
300
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,300
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,700
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
1
2
4
3
2
2
1
1
2
5
3
8
1
2
2
6
2
8
3
8
6
1
2
4
1
3
4
1
1
3
5
1
5
2
1
3
6
1
2
1
5
3
8
5
7
.78E+03
.19E+02
.31E+04
.31E+01
.91E+02
.35E-I-03
.92E+03
.93E+02
.03E+02
.22E+02
.24E+02
.01E+02
-92E+03
.14E+03
-16E+03
.52E+02
.14E+02
.15E+03
.48E+03
.40E+02
.23E+02
.32E+03
. 18E+02
.07E+02
.OOE+02
. 29E+02
.54E+03
. 29E+02
-07E+03
.33E+03
. 81E+02
. 66E+03
.22E+02
. 48E+02
.20E+03
.31E+02
.12E+02
.03E+03
.45E+02
.27E+03
.49E4-02
. 85E+03
.48E+01
.SlE-f-02
.48E+01
0.0002
<0.0001
0.0051
4,700.
38,000.
200.
<0. 0001260, 000.
<0.0001
0.0003
0.0002
<0.0001
<0.0001
0.0001
<0.0001
0.0001
0.0002
0.0003
0.0003
0.0001
<0.0001
0.0010
0.0004
0.0001
0.0001
0.0002
<0.0001
<0.0001
<0.0001
<0.0001
0.0005
<0.0001
0.0001
0.0004
0.0001
0.0002
0.0001
(0.0001
0.0001
<0.0001
0.0001
0.0001
<0.0001
0.0002
0.0001
0.0005
<0.0001
0.0001
29,000.
3,600.
4,400.
44,000.
42,000.
16,000.
26,000.
11,000.
4,400.
3,900.
3,900.
13,000.
39,000.
1,000.
2,400.
10,000.
14,000.
6,400.
39,000.
21,000.
84,000.
26,000.
1,900.
66,000.
7,800.
2,500.
15,000.
5,100.
16,000.
34,000.
7,000.
25,000.
14,000.
8,200.
34,000.
6,700.
15,000.
2,200.
99,000.
15,000.
<0. 0001110, 000.
57 ATLANTIC WOOD INDUST HAINE
230 CENEX REF. LAURE
97 AMERICAN HOECHST COR PASAD
283 LIQUID ENERGY CORP. BRIDG
232 EXXON BILLI
246 ASHLAND OIL CANTO
346 U.S. STEEL CORP. CLAXR
121 MONSANTO CO ALVIN
311 HIDATLANTIC REF. ST. M
179 STAR REF. DELAW
302 PHILLIPS 66 WOODS
193 ROCK ISLAND REFINING INDIA
249 SUN CO. TOLED
163 OXNARD REF. OXNAR
341 LTV STEEL CLEVE
248 STANDARD OIL OF OHIO TOLED
296 VALERO ENERGY CORP. CORFU
257 ATLANTIC REFINING PHILA
343 LTV STEEL COMPANY PITTS
298 BIG WEST OIL SALT
45 VISTA CHEMICAL BALTI
195 DERBY REFINING COMPA WICHI
202 SOMERSET REFINERY SOMER
315 FRONTIER OIL CREYE
205 CALUMET REFINING COM PRINC
348 U.S. STEEL CORP. PROVO
152 EDGINGTON OIL COMPAN LONG
192 LAKETON REFINING LAKET
330 INLAND STEEL E CHI
237 COASTAL EAGLE PT. WESTV
244 CIBRO PETROLEUM ALBAN
342 BETHLEHEM STEEL CORP BETHL
289 PRIDE REFINING ABILE
313 MURPHY OIL CORPORATI SUPER
338 ARMCO INC MIDDL
323 GULF STATES GADSD
103 CELANESE CORP. PAMPA
359 ERIEWAY POLL. CONTRO BEDFO
92 UNION CARBIDE CARIBE PONCE
221 LAKESIDE REF. KALAM
349 WHEELING PITT E STE
168 SHELL OIL MARTI
194 DERBY REF. EL DO
320 ABC COKE TARRA
380 IT CORP.-PETROL. WAS BTJTTO
-------
TABLE D-6. (continued)
summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maxinua-
Lifetiae
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
SIC=
CAS«
— — Mininun--
Conc People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 5 of 9
7.58E-01
7.44E-01
7.34E-01
7.32E-01
7.14E-01
7.07E-01
7.00E-01
6.79E-01
6.63E-01
6.54E-01
6.42E-01
6.33E-01
6.18E-01
6.11E-01
5.95E-01
5.83E-01
5.79E-01
5.79E-01
5.23E-01
5.12E-01
5.01E-01
4.82E-01
4.74E-01
4.60E-01
4.41E-01
4.31E-01
4.30E-01
4.21E-01
4.17E-01
4.08E-01
3.87E-01
3.73E-01
3.67E-01
3.62E-01
3.59E-01
3.58E-01
3.54E-01
3.52E-01
3.51E-01
3.32E-01
3.32E-01
3.30E-01
3.27E-01
3.10E-01
3.09E-01
37
1
<1
1
1
2
1
14
<1
46
265
<1
<1
48
<1
16
1
1
1
26S
44
<1
<1
<1
10
3
<1
28
1
1
<1
4
6
20
54
16
17
49
<1
<1
1
9
2
<1
1
2.82E+01
B.29E-01
5.72E-02
4.35E-01
5.80E-01
1.11E+00
4.94E-01
9.24E+00
2.58E-01
3.00E+01
1.70E+02
2.10E-01
3.19E-02
2.96E+01
8.83E-03
9.44E+00
8.33E-01
3.49E-01
2.95E-01
1.36E+02
2.22E+01
4.12E-02
1.32E-02
6.95E-03
4.47E+00
1.30E+00
1.74E-02
1.17E+01
2.80E-01
2.39E-01
1.11E-01
1 .32E+00
2.27E+00
7.31E+00
1.95E-KH
5.57E-I-00
6.13E+00
1.72E+01
5.38E-02
1.56E-01
1.88E-01
2.94E»CC
5.06E-01
6.78E-C:
3.0:s-:;
2.34E-04
6.88E-06
4.75E-07
3.61E-06
4.81E-06
9.19E-06
4.10E-06
7.67E-05
2.14E-06
2.49E-04
1.41E-03
1.75E-06
2.64E-07
2.45E-04
7.33E-08
7.84E-05
6.91E-06
2.90E-06
2.45E-06
1.13E-03
1.84E-04
3.42E-07
1.09E-07
5.77E-08
3.71E-05
1.08E-05
1.44E-07
9.71E-05
2.32E-06
1.98E-06
9.23E-07
1.10E-05
1.89E-OS
6.07E-05
1.61E-04
4.62E-05
5.09E-05
1.43E-04
•1.47E-07
1.29E-06
1.56E-06
2.44E-05
-I.20E-06
5.63E-07
2.51E-06
6.29E-06
6.17E-06
6.09E-06
6.08E-06
5.93E-06
5.87E-06
5.81E-06
5.64E-06
5.50E-06
5.43E-06
5.33E-06
5.25E-06
5.13E-06
5.07E-06
.93E-06
.B4E-06
. 80E-06
. 80E-06
. 34E-06
. 25E-06
. 16E-06
4.00E-06
3.94E-06
3.82E-06
3.66E-06
3.S8E-06
3.57E-06
3.SOE-06
3.46E-06
3.38E-06
3.21E-06
3.10E-06
3.05E-06
3.01E-06
2.98E-06
2.97E-06
2.94E-06
2.92E-06
2.92E-06
2.76E-06
2.75E-06
2.74E-06
2.71E-06
2.57E-06
2.57E-06
2.73E-05
1.62E-05
2.95E-05
4.S2E-OS
1.06E-04
2.01E-05
2.37E-05
1.08E-05
2.12E-OS
4.32E-06
9.39E-05
1.92E-05
2.43E-05
2.77E-05
2.85E-05
4.09E-06
3.38E-05
2.49E-05
1.56E-05
7.49E-05
3.31E-05
1.35E-05
7.94E-06
1.84E-05
2.27E-05
5.S2E-05
1.88E-05
4.34E-04
1.31E-05
1.12E-05
1.39E-05
1.73E-05
1.31E-05
1.22E-05
1.28E-OS
6.58E-05
1.53E-OS
1.29E-05
7.40E-06
1.51E-05
1.49E-OS
4.84E-06
1.17E-05
6.69E-05
7.28E-06
1,190,000
248,000
3,430,000
495,000
2,450,000
2,110,000
253,000
12,200,000
551,000
338,000
8,730,000
790,000
1,220,000
2,760,000
3,380,000
1,230,000
707,000
4,490,000
772,000
8,730,000
424,000
574,000
925,000
4,450,000
2,070,000
364,000
279,000
455,000
511,000
278,000
6,100,000
3,810,000
6,100,000
807,000
6,210,000
287,000
2,180,000
1,670,000
4,900,000
1,000,000
1,150,000
1,240,000
4,400,000
924,000
1,270,000
2.07E+03
3.85E+01
7.32E+02
1.12E+03
2.49E+03
3.61E+02
5.14E+01
2.34E+03
9.56Ef01
6.43E+02
1.32E+04
3.67E4-02
1.84E+02
9.93E+02
5.33E+02
1.54E+02
3.78E+02
6.59E+02
2.47E+02
1.05E+04
4.76E+02
6.16E+01
2.04E+02
7.40E+02
3.90E+02
3.29E+02
1.52E+02
1.55E+03
1.63E+02
1.68E+01
7.95E+02
5.67E+02
8.21E+02
5.01E+02
1.31E+03
3.18E+02
5.37E+02
9.11E+02
3.56E+02
2.15E+02
2.57E+02
1.96E+02
2.88E+02
1.91E+03
9.45E+01
0.0002 4,100.
<0. 0001220, 000.
0.0001 12,000.
0.0001 7,500.
0.0003 3,400.
<0.0001 23,000.
<0. 0001160, 000.
0.0003 3,600.
<0.0001 88,000.
0.0001 13,000.
0.0016 640.
<0.0001 23,000.
<0.0001 46,000.
0.0001 8,500.
0.0001 16,000.
<0.0001 55,000.
<0.0001 22,000.
0.0001 13,000.
<0.0001 34,000.
0.0012 800.
0.0001 18,000.
<0. 0001140, 000.
<0.0001 41,000.
0.0001 11,000.
<0.0001 22,000.
<0.0001 26,000.
<0.0001 56,000.
0.0002 5,400.
CO.OOOl 52,000.
<0. 0001500, 000.
0.0001 11,000.
0.0001 15,000.
0.0001 10,000.
0.0001 17,000.
0.0002 6,400.
<0.0001 27,000.
0.0001 16,000.
0.0001 9,300.
C0.0001 24,000.
<0.0001 39,000.
<0.0001 33,000.
<0.0001 43,000.
<0.0001 29,000.
0.0002 4,400.
<0.0001 89,000.
369 ECOLOTEC DAYTO
211 HILL PETROLEUM ST. R
62 DUPOHT DEEPW
274 EL PASO REFINING EL PA
284 L70NDELL PETEOCHEMIC ROUST
398 DELAWARE CONTAINERS COATS
220 CRYSTAL REF. CARSO
235 AMERADA-HESS PORT
36 DOW CHEMICAL PLAQU
294 TRIFINERY CORPU
156 GOLDEN WEST REFINING SANTA
322 KOPPERS WOODW
10 STANDARD CHLORIDE CH DELAW
157 HUNTWA7 REF. BENEC
388 MICHIGAN DISPOSAL IN BELLE
4 ALPHA RESINS PERRI
47 PARKE-DAVIS HOLLA
239 MANTUA OIL THORO
124 UNION CARBIDE CORP TEXAS
166 POWERINE OIL SANTA
332 ARMCO INC. ASHLA
39 RUBICON CHEMICALS IN GEISM
393 PETROCHEM RECYCLING SALT
67 MONSANTO CO BRIDG
87 ATLANTIC RICHFIELD C MONAC
277 TINA OIL t CHEMICAL PORT
180 AMOCO SAVAN
74 MONTROSE CHEMICAL CO HENDE
46 DOW CORNING MIDLA
20 GOODRICH, (B.F.) HENRY
368 CHEM. WASTE MGMT. CALUM
350 DETROIT COKE DETRI
327 LTV STEEL S CHI
324 SLOSS INDUSTRIES BIRMI
326 ACME STEEL CHICA
223 TOTAL PETROLEUM ALMA
325 NATIONAL STEEL GRANI
383 CECOS INT'L CINCI
58 BASF WYANDOTTE CORP. JAMES
337 LTV STEEL WARRE
129 ATLANTIC WOOD INDUST PORTS
335 TONAWANDA TONAW
331 U.S. STEEL CORP. GAR?
265 HAPCO PETROLEUM MEMPH
71 SOUTHLAND CORP. GREAT
-------
Sunnary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-MaxinuB-
Lifetiae
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
TABLE D-6.
SIC- CAS-
(continued)
Minimum
Cone People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 6 of 9
3.08E-01
3.05E-01
3.04E-01
3.00E-01
2.9BE-01
2.82E-01
2.78E-01
2.68E-01
2.S9E-01
2.53E-01
2.50E-01
2.41E-01
2.17E-01
2.08E-01
2.07E-01
2.06E-01
2.06E-01
1.98E-01
1.95E-01
1.74E-01
1.73E-01
1.71E-01
1 .70E-01
1.59E-01
1.54E-01
1.54E-01
1.50E-01
1.45E-01
1.23E-01
1.15E-01
1.13E-01
1.11E-01
1.05E-01
9.56E-02
9.16E-02
9.02E-02
8.97E-02
8 .19E-02
7.46E-02
7.39E-02
7.21E-02
7.06E-02
5.93E-02
5.67E-02
5.17E-02
54
1
<1
15
44
4
3
2
<1
1
35
<1
3
17
12
35
163
2
497
2
<1
1
1
6
705
7
28
54
1
22
24
10
38
2
21
70
<1
<1
<1
1
106
<1
80
<1
723
1.65E+01
4.25E-01
1.26E-02
4.47E+00
1.30E+01
1.14E+00
7.48E-01
4.07E-01
5.83E-02
3.15E-01
8.76E+00
3.96E-02
7.12E-01
3.59E+00
2.55E+00
7.19E+00
3.36E+01
2.99E-01
9.70E+01
4.32E-01
3.91E-02
1.40E-01
9 . 84E-02
9.49E-01
1.08E+02
1.12E+00
4.19E-fOO
7.88E-fOO
1.34E-01
2.56E+00
2.66E+00
1.11E+00
4.00E+00
2.16E-01
1.89E+00
6.33E+00
1.81E-02
1.82E-02
3.32E-02
3.73E-02
7.65E+00
7.52E-};
4.72E+Q-
7.55E-OJ
3.73E+0.
1.37E-04
3.53E-06
1.04E-07
3.71E-05
1.08E-04
9.43E-06
6.21E-06
3.38E-06
4.84E-07
2.61E-06
7.27E-05
3.29E-07
5.91E-06
2.98E-05
2.12E-05
5.97E-05
2.79E-04
2.48E-06
8.05E-04
3.59E-06
3.25E-07
1.16E-06
8 . 16E— 07
7.88E-06
9.00E-04
9.32E-06
3.47E-05
6.S4E-05
1.11E-06
2.12E-05
2.20E-05
9.20E-06
3.32E-05
1.79E-06
1.57E-05
5.2SE-05
1.51E-07
1 . 51E— 07
2.76E-07
3.09E-07
6.35E-05
.J.24E-08
3.92E-OS
<;.27E-08
3.10E-04
2.56E-06
2.53E-06
2.53E-06
2.49E-06
2.47E-06
2.34E-06
2.31E-06
2.23E-06
2.15E-06
2.10E-06
2.08E-06
2.00E-06
1.80E-06
1.73E-06
1.72E-06
1.71E-06
1.71E-06
1.64E-06
1.62E-06
1.44E-06
1.44E-06
1.42E-06
1 .41E-06
1.32E-06
1.2SE-06
1.27E-06
1.24E-06
1.20E-06
1.02E-06
9.55E-07
9.35E-07
9.20E-07
8.71E-07
7.93E-07
7.61E-07
7.49E-07
7.45E-07
6 .80E-07
6.19E-07
6.14E-07
5.98E-07
5.86E-07
4.92E-07
4.70E-07
4.29E-07
8.41E-06
1.05E-05
8.94E-06
1.54E-05
7.36E-05
5.58E-06
1.50E-05
3.91E-05
1.15E-04
6.60E-06
2.12E-05
1.55E-05
4.79E-06
1.08E-05
7.76E-06
3.66E-06
1.08E-04
5.79E-06
9.22E-05
7.52E-06
3.31E-06
4.90E-06
5.41E— 06
4.37E-06
1.95E-04
2.02E-04
5.21E-06
1.99E-06
6.86E-06
3.07E-06
2.59E-05
1.34E-06
2.34E-06
4.16E-06
1.44E-06
1.26E-06
3.90E-05
2.72E— 06
4.34E-07
2.25E-06
2.39E-05
6.85E-05
1.21E-06
1.90E-06
3.41E-05
562
297
346
2,410
8,180
8,320
1,190
935
626
313
2,910
168
834
2,390
2,110
2,540
2,640
399
189
4,790
428
158
42
297
2,210
349
2,340
1,940
372
93
2,440
13,300
2,600
826
12,500
12,900
2,560
103
364
223
1,270
4,870
9,100
1,800
92
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,300
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,500
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,400
3.75E+02
9.69E+01
2.08E+01
8.28E+02
1.05E-I-04
7.17E+02
6.27E+02
7.64E+02
1.97E+03
2.74E+01
1.14E+03
1.06E+01
5.99E+01
4.33E+02
1.89E+02
3.16E+02
4.19E+03
3.33E+01
8.73E+02
3.52E+02
2.61E+01
1.47E+01
4.50E+00
4.05E+01
4.20E+03
8.14E+02
3.42E+02
2.14E+02
4.04E+01
3.09E+01
5.64E+02
7.73E+02
1.74E+02
6.92E+01
4.19E+02
5.68E-I-02
9.91E+02
1 . 98E+00
8.92E+00
2.18E+01
1.05E+03
6.82E+03
2.36E+02
2.38E+01
3.09E+02
<0
<0
<0
0
0
0
0
0
0
<0
0
<0
<0
0
<0
<0
0
<0
0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
0
0
<0
<0
<0
<0
0
0
<0
<0
0
0
0
<0
<0
<0
0
0
<0
<0
<0
.0001 22
.0001 87
.0001410
.0001 10
.0012
.0001 12
.0001 13
.0001 11
.0002 4
.0001310
.0001 7
.0001800
.0001140
.0001 19
.0001 45
.0001 27
.0005 2
.0001250
.0001 9
.0001 24
.0001320
.0001570
.0001210
.0005 2
.0001 10
.0001 25
.0001 39
.0001210
.0001270
.0001 15
.0001 11
.0001 48
.0001120
.0001 20
.0001 15
.0001 8
.0001950
.0001390
.0001 8
.0008 1
.0001 36
.0001350
.0001 27
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
800.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,300.
,000.
,400.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,700.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,500.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,200.
,000.
,000.
,000.
334 NATIONAL STEEL GROUP ECORS
339 NEW BOSTON COKE PORTS
355 HANSBROUGH ENERGY CROWL
345 SHENANGO 5HENA
147 ATLANTIC RICHFIELD CARSO
72 STAUFFER CHEMICAL CO EDISO
329 CITIZENS GAS INDIA
299 CHEVRON SALT
254 SUN REFINING TULSA
51 FIRST CHEMICAL CORP PASCA
173 TOSCO CORP. MARTI
12 OLIN CORP. ST. M
11 ALPHA CHEMICAL LAKEL
88 CALGON CARBON NEVIL
347 SHARON STEEL HONES
116 HEAT ENERGY TECH. DALLA
112 GEORGIA-PACIFIC CORP PASAD
109 E I DUPONT DS NEMOUR ORANG
321 EMPIRE COKE COMPANY TUSCA
61 DUPONT GIBBS
30 VULCAN MATERIALS WICHI
101 CAIN CHEMICAL BRAZO
104 COSDEN OIL fc CHEMICA BIG S
53 REICHHOLD CHEMICALS GULFP
275 EXXON CORP BAYTO
269 CHEVRON PORT
89 KOPPERS CO INC BRIDG
381 CECOS STAHF
16 NIFRO, INC. AUGUS
353 ENSCO EL DO
333 BETHLEHEM STEEL CORP SPARK
73 TROY CHEMICAL CORP., NEHAR
122 S.D.S. BIOTECH CORP. HOUST
354 ENVIROSAFE SERVICES OREGO
66 MOBAY CORP. HALED
70 REICHHOLD CHEMICALS ELIZA
374 ROLLINS ENV. SERVICE DEES
372 ROGERS LANDFILL CERTR
117 KOCH INDUSTRIES CORPU
42 VISTA CHEMICAL HESTL
336 BETHLEHEM STEEL LACXA
258 CHEVRON PHILA
6 LILLY COATINGS MONTE
48 3-M COMPANY COTTA
251 CONOCO PONCA
-------
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maxinum-
LifetiM
Cone People Exposure Incidence Max Risk
TABLE D-6. (continued)
SIC' CAS«
--Minimum--
Conc People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 7 of 9
oO
4.82E-02
4.54E-02
4.31E-02
4.24E-02
3.73E-02
3.37E-02
3.14E-02
2.69E-02
2.49E-02
2.44E-02
1.81E-02
1.72E-02
1.70E-02
1.63E-02
1.59E-02
1.45E-02
1.42E-02
1.35E-02
1.24E-02
1.15E-02
1.08E-02
1.01E-02
9.75E-03
9.10E-03
8.15E-03
7.99E-03
7.61E-03
7.30E-03
7. 21E-03
6.79E-03
6.61E-03
6.57E-03
6.55E-03
6.54E-03
6.07E-03
6.02E-03
5.66E-03
5.31E-03
4.52E-03
4.06E-03
4.04E-03
3.39E-03
2. 89E-03
2.62E-03
2.5BE-03
<1
2
8
<1
13
<1
10
7
2
<1
20
<1
17
<1
<1
10
23
<1
54
230
7
1
360
<1
233
1
1
845
28
387
360
1
2
<1
15
163
525
491
1
57
77
175
1
50
22
2.69E-03
7.43E-02
3.35E-01
5.14E-03
4.85E-01
7.62E-03
2.98E-01
1.83E-01
4.60E-02
4.12E-03
3.66E-01
3 . 93E-05
2.96E-01
4.49E-03
7.74E-04
1.38E-01
3.27E-01
3 . 07E-03
6.73E-01
2.64E+00
7.05E-02
1.05E-02
3.51E+00
2.61E-03
1.90E-I-00
8.26E-03
5.00E-03
6.17E+00
2.00E-01
2.63E+00
2.38E+00
8.94E-03
1.38E-02
3.30E-0-1
8.97E-02
9.83E-01
2.97E+00
2.61E+00
3.07E-03
2.32E-01
3.11E-01
5.94E-01
1 . 84E-0^
1.31E-01
5.67E-;:
2.24E-08
6.16E-07
2.78E-06
4.26E-08
4.03E-06
6.32E-08
2.48E-06
1.52E-06
3.82E-07
3.42E-08
3.04E-06
3.27E-10
2.46E-06
3.73E-08
6.43E-09
1.14E-06
2.71E-06
2.54E-08
5.59E-06
2.19E-05
5.85E-07
8.73E-08
2.91E-05
2.17E-OS
1.58E-05
6.86E-08
4.15E-08
5.12E-05
1.66E-06
2.18E-05
L.98E-05
7.42E-08
1.14E-07
2.74E-09
7.44E-07
8.16E-06
2.46E-05
2.16E-05
2.54E-08
L.93E-06
2.58E-06
4.93E-06
1.53E-08
1.09E-06
•I.71E-07
4.00E-07
3.77E-07
3.57E-07
3.52E-07
3.10E-07
2.79E-07
2.61E-07
2.23E-07
2.07E-07
2.03E-07
1.50E-07
1.43E-07
1.41E-07
1.36E-07
1.32E-07
1.20E-07
1.18E-07
1.12E-07
1.03E-07
9.54E-08
8.93E-08
8.35E-08
8.10E-08
7.55E-08
6.76E-08
6.63E-08
6.32E-OB
6.06E-08
5.99E-08
5.63E-08
5.49E-08
5.45E-08
5.44E-08
S.43E-08
5.04E-08
5.00E-08
4.69E-08
4.41E-08
3.75E-08
3.37E-08
3.35E-08
2.82E-08
2.40G-08
2.18E-08
2.14E-08
4.71E-07
1.56E-06
6.24E-07
3.49E-07
3.84E-06
6.12E-07
1.85E-05
8.52E-07
4.35E-07
4.64E-07
4.52E-06
5.97E-07
9.45E-07
4.76E-07
2.81E-07
6.78E-07
8.21E-05
2.46E-07
1.70E-07
3.76E-05
3.39E-07
4.39E-07
7.21E-05
3.26E-07
1.70E-04
2.76E-07
4.47E-07
4.02E-05
1.02E-07
1.22E-04
4.89E-05
4.04E-08
1.26E-07
1.77E-07
1.66E-07
3.14E-06
2.51E-05
7.05E-05
4.87E-08
4.16E-06
1.35E-06
2.39E-05
8.39E-08
7.30E-05
2.46E-04
2,
1,
2,
2,
2,
2,
3,
2,
1,
1,
1,
2,
4,
1,
2,
6,
1,
1,
2,
2,
2,
520,000
570,000
060,000
309,000
580,000
425,000
690,000
680,000
100,000
540,000
333,000
260,000
150,000
730,000
240,000
250,000
547,000
425,000
940,000
360,000
708,000
189,000
76,500
100,000
284,000
415,000
649,000
158,000
170,000
27,100
76,500
328,000
970,000
469,000
804,000
640,000
406,000
221,000
000,000
824,000
210,000
60,000
113,000
354,000
34,800
9.26E+00
3.31E+01
3.54E+01
2.82E+00
5.67E+01
4.22E+00
9.11E+02
4.56E+01
4.77E+01
3.63E+01
7.30E+01
3.24E+00
2.29E+01
2.68E+00
8.58E+00
4.13E+01
2.73E-I-02
1.70E+00
1.B3E+01
2.95E+02
5.70E+00
8.82E-01
5.10E+01
1.87E+01
2.54E+02
1.01E+00
2.02E+00
6.27E+01
7.93E+00
3.34E+01
3.46E+01
5.82E-01
3.63E+00
8.21E— 01
7.32E+00
1.22E+02
2.60E+02
8.39E+01
1.12E+00
4.00E+01
6.93E+01
3.56E+01
1.44E-01
1.34E+02
1.45E+01
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
.0001910
.0001250
.0001240
.0001150
.0001 9
.0001180
.0001180
.0001230
.0001120
.0001370
.0001980
.0001200
.0001 31
.0001460
.0001 29
.0001170
.0001450
.0001 33
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,300.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
.0001***********
.0001130,000.
.0001250
.0001240
.0001 69
.0001 32
.0001100
.0001210
.0001120
.0001240
.0001 63
.0001580
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
,000.
377 IT CORPORATION BENEC
82 MONSANTO CO ADDTS
9 UPJOHN CO.,THE NORTH
2 MONSANTO CO ANNIS
78 NEPERA CHEMICAL CO., HARRI
29 AIR PRODUCTS I CHEM. WICHI
100 ATLANTIC RICHFIELD BOOST
118 KOPPERS HOUST
364 CHEN-CLEAR INC. BALTI
365 CHEN-CLEAR INC. CLEVE
344 ERIE COKE ERIE
41 UNION CARBIDE CORP. HAHNV
376 HERITAGE EOT. SERVIC INDIA
23 REILLY TAR AND CHEMI GRANI
115 GOODYEAR TIRE I RUBB LAPOR
366 CHEN-MET SERVICES WYAND
219 STAR REF. CONVE
28 ABBOTT LABORATORIES WICHI
382 CECOS INT'L BRIST
328 BETHLEHEM STEEL BURNS
99 AMOCO CHEMICAL TEXAS
33 GAF CORP. CALVE
139 HAPCO PETROLEUM NORTH
363 CID-LANDFILL CALUM
226 CHEVRON PASCA
85 USS CHEMICAL IRONT
54 HALLINCXHODT CHEN. RALE I
261 QUAKER STATE OIL REF SMETH
370 FRONTIER CHEMICAL NIAQR
272 DIAMOND SHAMROCK SUNRA
140 PETRO STAR NORTH
102 CELANESE CHEMICAL BI5HO
81 BF GOODRICH AVON
18 NORCHEM CO. CLINT
1 ALLIED SIGNAL BIRMI
111 GEORGIA GULF CORP. PASAD
134 HUNT REFINING TUSCA
206 CANAL REF. CHURC
5 DOW CHEMICAL PITTS
128 HERCULES MAGNA
50 MONSANTO CO ST. L
242 GIANT REFINERY GALLU
3 GREAT LAKES CHEMICAL EL DO
210 HILL PETROLEUM KROTZ
138 CHEVRON KEHAI
-------
TABLE D-6. (continued)
Suamary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
-Maxiaum-
Lifetiae
Cone People Exposure Incidence Hax Risk
SIC»
CAS*
Mininun
Cone People Exposure
Annual Repeat
Incidence Interval
Page 8 of 9
2.39E-03
2.15E-03
2.15E-03
2.07E-03
2.00E-03
1.93E-03
1.89E-03
1.83E-03
1 . 81E— 03
1. 40E-03
1.28E-03
1.24E-03
1.23E-03
9.48E-04
8.82E-04
6 .99E— 04
6.64E-04
6.63E-04
5.97E— 04
5.91E— 04
5.61E-04
4.76E-04
4 . 58E— 04
3.98E-04
3 . 68E-04
3 .44E-04
2.85E-04
2.59E-04
2.54E-04
2.42E-04
2.37E-04
2 .06E-04
1.40E-04
1.39E-04
1.31E-04
1.28E-04
1.21E-04
1.17E-04
1.14E-04
1.02E-04
8.31E-05
1
598
11
4
109
<1
(1
. 39E-- :
1.14E-08
1.07E-05
1 .94E— 07
6.85E-08
1.81E— 06
1 . 33E-09
1.12E— 09
1 . 73E-11
2 . 19E-08
3.21E-09
1.03E-07
2.24E-07
1 . 26E— 07
3 . 57E— 08
5.11E-09
8.45E-06
2 .22E— 07
1 .28E-07
7.02E-06
3.31E-06
8 .45E— 10
1 . 75E— 07
1.88E-08
6.75E-07
1 .82E-08
4.78E-06
1 .16E-07
3 . 32E-08
2 .04E-06
3 .98E-06
4.56E-06
3.96E-06
5.05E-10
4 . 07E— 08
4.98E-09
3.22E-11
5.56E-10
4 .97E-09
4 . 90E— 07
4.8SE-09
2.75E-08
5.77E-07
5.31E-07
1.99E-08
1.79E-08
1.79E— 08
1.71E-08
1.66E— 08
1 . 60E— 08
1.57E-08
1 . 52E-08
1 . 50E-08
1.16E— 08
1.13E-08
1.06E-08
1.03E-08
1.02E-08
9 . 25E-09
8 . 26E— 09
7.87E-09
7.32E-09
6 .71E— 09
5.80E-09
5.51E-09
5.50E-09
4.95E-09
4.90E— 09
4.65E-09
3.97E-09
3 . 80E— 09
3.30E-09
3 . 05E— 09
2.86E-09
2.37E-09
2.15E-09
2.11E-09
2.01E-09
1.96E-09
1 . 71E— 09
1.16E-09
1.16E-09
1.09E-09
1.06E-09
1 . OOE-09
9.72E-10
9.50E-10
8.48E-10
6.90E-10
8.63C-08
2.67E-05
5.84E-08
2.13E-08
2.67E— 05
3 . 61E— 08
3.28E-08
5.01E-05
1.05E— 07
4.02E-08
7.05E— 08
8.93E-08
1.49E-08
1.17E-04
4 . 02E-08
4.07E-08
3.47E-07
5.72E-05
l.OOE-04
4.49E-04
3.28E-07
4.31E-06
8.45E-09
3.09E-08
9.27E-07
1.46E-05
7. 69E— 09
1.28E-05
6 . 57E— 09
5.91E-09
3.08E-06
2.37E-06
8.84E-06
4.74E-06
3.32E-09
2.79E— 09
6.63E-09
6.92E-09
5.58E-09
5.67E-09
3.47E— 05
1.23E-09
1.36E-09
8.09E-07
1.36E-06
395
108
902
2,090
25
200
2,590
24
362
386
294
12,700
13,300
34
435
483
2,450
34
6
556
357
300
415
2,580
206
12 ,500
432
613
2,610
89
551
281
180
573
5,190
1,780
460
4 ,810
2,200
1,330
13,800
163
118
,000
,000
,000
,000
,100
,000
,000
,400
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,800
,000
,000
,000
,300
,710
252
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,200
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
,000
5
1
4
2
5
3
9
6
3
1
1
2
8
6
1
2
9
9
1
1
6
9
3
8
2
1
1
3
3
2
4
1
5
8
2
1
2
2
2
1
1
8
6
-98E-01
.62E+01
.91E+00
.07E+00
. 34E+00
.89E-02
.27E-01
.87E+00
.08E-01
. 84E-01
.33E-01
.10E+01
.62E+00
.88E+00
.17E+00
. 64E-01
.70E+00
.49E+00
.91E+00
.19E-01
.OOE+00
.51E+00
.02E-02
.74E-01
.65E+01
.B9E+01
.64E+00
.12E+01
.44E-01
.33E+00
.63E+00
.74E+01
.53E+00
.30E-02
.98E-01
.66E-01
.10E-02
. 61E-01
. 21E-01
.17E-01
.S4E+00
.87E— 01
. 53E-01
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
<0
.0001520,000.
.0001***********
.0001400,000.
.0001980,000.
.0001***********
.0001870,000.
.0001890,000.
.0001***********
.0001890,000.
.0001320,000.
.0001450,000.
.0001270,000.
.0001490,000.
.0001***********
.0001***********
.0001***********
.0001***********
.0001***********
120 MOBIL CHEMICALS BEAUM
143 BERRY PETROLEUM STEVE
76 EASTMAN KODAK ROCHE
361 CHEMICAL PROCESSORS SEATT
197 FARMLAND FACILITIES PHILL
19 CLARK OIL & REFINING BLUE
113 GLIDDEN COATINGS CARRO
250 BARRETT REF. TROMA
17 OLIN CHEMICALS AUGUS
114 GOODYEAR TIRE BEAUM
25 US INDUSTRIAL CHEM. TUSCO
56 AMERICAN CYANAMID CO LINDE
68 ORBIS PRODUCTS CORP NEWAR
141 TESARO ALASKA PETROL KENAI
79 ALLIED CHEMICAL IRONT
96 US ARMY MUNITIONS KINGS
125 UPJOHN CO LA PO
243 NAVAJO REFINING ARTES
142 INTERMOUNTAIN REF. FREDO
391 USPCI GRASSY MT. KNOWL
40 STAUFFER CHEMICAL BATON
356 ENV. ENTERPRISES CINCI
14 DOW CHEMICAL DALTO
26 MEAD JOHNSON EVANS
106 DIAMOND SHAMROCK COR DEER
379 CASMALIA RESOURCES CASMA
358 SOLVENT RECOV. SERVT LINDE
133 BELCHER REF. MOBIL
362 CHEMICAL RESOURCES TULSA
119 LILLY IND. COATINGS DALLA
378 IT CORPORATION MESTM
38 GEORGIA-PACIFIC CORP PLAQU
13 ATLANTIC WOOD INDUST SAVAN
95 RHONE-POULENC.INC. NT. P
8 DOW CHEMICAL LEDYA
55 AMERICAN CYANAMID BRIDO
83 PPG INDUSTRIES NORTO
93 DUPONT LUGOF
63 HERCULES GIBBS
21 MONSANTO CO SAUGE
234 NEVADA REF. TONOP
351 COMMERCIAL.DISPOSAL WEST
360 CALLEIA RES. RECOVER BROOK
75 AYERST LABS ROUSE
52 KERR-MCGEE CHEM. COR MERID
-------
Sunmary for BENZENE REFINERIES
with a Unit Risk of 8.30E-06
TABLE D-6. (continued)
SIC- CAS»
-Ms
Cone
7 . 45E— 05
7. 30E-05
2 .74E-05
2 . 48E— 05
6 .62E-06
l.OOE-38
l.OOE-38
Kin
People
<1
2
1,310
43
203
u m -
Exposure
1 .28E-06
1 .80E-04
3 .58E-02
1 . 07E-03
1 .34E-03
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
Lifetine
Incidence
1 . 06E-11
1.49E-09
2 .97E-07
8 .86E-09
1.12E-08
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
Max Risk
6 . 18E-10
6.06E-10
2.27E-10
2.06E-10
5.49E-11
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
M
Cone
3.63E— 09
2.96E-09
5.73E-07
1.07E— 07
8.13E-08
l.OOE+38
l.OOE+38
i n i m
People
3,440 , 000
4,570 ,000
423,000
87,400
552,000
u a - -
Exposure
6 . 67E— 02
1.09E-01
1.72E+00
2. 25E— 01
2.07E-01
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
Annual
Incidence
Repeat
Interval
Page 9 of 9
396 WAYNE DISPOSAL BELLE
373 ROLLINS ENV. SERVICE BRIDG
392 PEORIA DISPOSAL CO. PEORI
123 URION CARBIDE SEADR
37 ETHXL COUP. BATON
130 ALDRICH CHEMICALS MILWA
136 ARCO ALASKA KUPAR
701,000,000 5.70E+05 0.066
15.
O V • t • 1 1
O
-------
Summary for BENZENE
Maximum Radius « 50.0 KB
TABLE D-7. POPULATION EXPOSURE RESULTS FOR CASE 1 (BASELINE MINIMUM)
REFINERIES SIC- CAS*
Pag*
Level Concentration Population
Exposure
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
1.68C+02
l.OOE+02
5.00E4-01
2.50E+01
l.OOE+01
5.00E+00
2.50E+00
l.OOE+00
5.00E-01
2.50E-01
l.OOE-01
5.00E-02
2.50E-02
l.OOE-02
5.00E-03
2.50E-03
l.OOE-03
5.00E-04
2.50E-04
l.OOE-04
5.00E-05
2.50E-05
l.OOE-05
5.00E-06
2.50E-06
l.OOE-06
5.00E-07
2.50E-07
l.OOE-07
5.00E-08
2.50E-08
l.OOE-08
5.00E-09
2.50E-09
1.20E-09
<1
49
156
493
2,220
7,250
21,900
78,000
193,000
404,000
1,150,000
2,770,000
6,120,000
18,200,000
42,100,000
85,100,000
170,000,000
239,000,000
301,000,000
380,000,000
434,000,000
475,000,000
525,000,030
559,000,000
580,000,000
601,000,000
617,000,000
629,000,000
6-17,000,000
664 ,000,000
675,000 ,000
690,000,000
699,000,000
701,000,000
701,000,000
3.5BE+01
5.65E+03
1.22E+04
2.28E+04
4.79E+04
8.24E+04
1.32E+05
2.16E+05
2.96E+05
3.70E+05
4.B3E+05
5.93E+05
7.09E+05
8.91E+05
1.06E+06
1.21E+06
1.34E+06
1.39E>06
1.42E+06
1.43E+06
1.43E+06
1.43E+06
1.44E+06
1.44E+06
1.44E+06
1.44E+06
1.44E+06
1.44E+06
1.44E+06
1.44E4-06
1.44E+06
1.44E+06
1.44E+06
1.44E+06
1.44E+06
using a Risk Factor of 3.JOE-06
Level Risk Level f-i\
1.39E-03
l.OOE-03
5.00E-04
2.50E-04
l.OOE-04
5.00E-05
2.50E-05
20
97
286
;,590
5,380
1",300
Hazard
2.97E-04
2.16E-02
7.51E-02
1.43E-01
3.39E-01
5.96E-01
9.92E-01
-------
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
l.OOE-05
5.00E-06
2.50E-06
l.OOE-06
5.00E-07
2.50E-07
l.OOE-07
5.00E-08
2.50E-08
l.OOE-08
5.00E-09
2.50E-09
l.OOE-09
5.00E-10
2.50E-10
l.OOE-10
5.00E-11
2.50E-11
l.OOE-11
5.00E-12
2.50E-12
l.OOE-12
5.00E-13
2.50E-13
l.OOE-13
5.00E-14
2.50E-14
9.93E-15
57,900
155,000
336,000
928,000
2,190,000
4,960,000
14,400,000
33,800,000
71,600,000
151,000,000
222,000,000
284,000,000
365,000,000
420,000,000
465,000,000
515,000,000
551,000,000
576,000,000
596,000,000
613,000,000
625,000,000
643,000,000
660,000,000
672,000,000
687,000,000
698,000,000
701,000,000
701,000,000
1.61E+00
2.28E+00
2.91E+00
3.81E+00
4.66E+00
S.62E+00
7.05E+00
8.39E+00
9.71E+00
1.10E+01
1.15E+01
1.17E+01
1.18E+01
1.19E+01
1.19E+01
1.19E+01
1.19E+01
1.19E+01
1.19E+01
1.19E-M31
1.19E+01
1.19E+01
1.19E-I-01
1.19E-I-01
1.19E+01
1.19E+01
1.19E-I-01
1.19E+01
TABLE 0-7. (continued)
Pag*
-------
TABLE D-8. POPULATION EXPOSURE RESULTS FOR CASE 2 (BASELINE MAXIMUM)
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
Maximum Radius - 50.0 Ka
SIC-
CAS«
L*val Concentration Population
Exposure
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
2.78E+02
2.50E4-02
l.OOE+02
5.00E+01
2.50E+01
l.OOE+01
5.00E+00
2.50E+00
l.OOE+00
5.00E-01
2.50E-01
l.OOE-01
5.00E-02
2.50E-02
l.OOE-02
5.00E-03
2.50E-03
l.OOE-03
5.00E-04
2.SOE-04
l.OOE-04
5.00E-05
2.50E-05
l.OOE-05
5.00E-06
2.SOE-06
l.OOE-06
5.00E-07
2.50E-07
l.OOE-07
5.00E-08
2.SOE-08
l.OOE-08
5.00E-09
2.50E-09
1.20E-09
1 2
1 J
577 t
3,040 3
8,890 4
34,300 t
77,100 ]
170,000 3
580,000 ;
1,580,000 :
3,710,000 2
11,200,000 <
25,100,000 !
55,800,000 <
135,000,000
211,000,000
288,000,000
359,000,000
399,000,000
435,000,000
472,000,000
496,000,000
517,000,000
554,000,0')0
574,000,000
588,000,000
611,000,000
624,000,000
637,000,000
654,000 ,000
668 ,000,000
680,000 ,000
694,000,000
700,000 ,000
701,000,000
701,000,000
.81E-I-02
.81E+02
.21E+04
.56E+05
.55E+05
.22E+05
.12E+06
.44E+06
[.OSE-t-06
I.73E+06
I.47E+06
I.60E+06
>.55E-t-06
i.61E+06
'.85E+06
.40E+06
.68E+06
. 80E+06
.83E+06
.84E+06
.85E+06
.8SE+06
.85E+06
.85E+06
.85E+06
.85E+06
.85E+06
. 85E+06
. 85E+06
.85E+06
.85E+06
.85E+06
.85E+06
-85E+06
.85E+06
.85E+06
Using a Risk Factor of 2.30S-06
Level Risk Level pcp
, 30E-03
.OOE-03
.OOE-0-1
.50E-04
.OOE-04
5.00E-05
1
385
: . -190
• ",270
:;,joo
•53,200
Hazard
2.34E-03
5.07E-01
1.8BE+00
3.41E+00
5.93E+00
8.63E+00
-------
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
2.50E-05
l.OOE-05
5.00E-06
2.50E-06
l.OOE-06
5.00E-07
2.50E-07
l.OOE-07
5.00E-08
2.50E-08
l.OOE-08
5.00E-09
2.50E-09
l.OOE-09
5.00E-10
2.50E-10
l.OOE-10
5.00E-11
2.50E-11
l.OOE-11
5.00E-12
2.50E-12
l.OOE-12
5.00E-13
2.50E-13
l.OOE-13
5.00E-14
2.50E-14
9.93E-15
138,000
451,000
1,190,000
2,990,000
9,050,000
20,000,000
45,500,000
116,000,000
190,000,000
268,000,000
347,000,000
389,000,000
426,000,000
465,000,000
490,000,000
511,000,000
547,000,000
570,000,000
535,000,000
606,000,000
621,000,000
634,000,000
650,000,000
665,000,000
677,000,000
692,000,000
699,000,000
701,000,000
701,000,000
1.12E+01
1.58E+01
2.09E+01
2.71E+01
3.62E+01
4.37E+01
5.26E+01
6.35E4-01
6.48E+01
7.16E+01
7.29E+01
7.33E+01
7.34E+01
7.35E+01
7.35E+01
7.35E+01
7.35E+01
7.35E+01
7.35E+01
7.35E+01
7.3SE+01
7.35E+01
7.35E+01
7.35E+01
7.35E+01
7.35E+01
7.35E+01
7.3SE+01
7.35E+01
TABLD D-8. (continued)
Pag*
-------
TABLE D-9. POPULATION EXPOSURE RESULTS FOR CASE 3 (CONTROLLED MINIMUM)
Sumnary for BENZENE REFINERIES
Maximum Radius « 50.0 Km
SIC»
CAS«
Fag*
Laval Concentration Population
Exposure
N
A
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
a
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
4.51E+01
2.50E+01
l.OOE+01
5.00E+00
2.SOE+00
l.OOE+00
5.00E-01
2.50E-01
l.OOE-01
5.00E-02
2.50E-02
l.OOE-02
5.00E-03
2.50E-03
l.OOE-03
5.00E-04
2.50E-04
l.OOE-04
5.00E-05
2.50E-05
l.OOE-OS
5.00E-06
2.SOE-06
l.OOE-06
5.00E-07
2.50E-07
l.OOE-07
5.00E-08
2.50E-08
l.OOE-08
5.00E-09
2.50E-09
1.20E-09
201
1,140
11,100
22,300
73,500
198,000
480,000
1,800,000
4,690,000
10,100,000
21,700,000
42,400,000
86,200,000
195,000,000
297,000,000
397,000,000
504,000,000
555,000,000
580,000,000
600,000,000
616,000,000
629,000,000
646,000,000
664,000,000
675,000,000
690,000,000
699,000,000
701,000.000
701,000,000
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
5.97E+02
2.05E+03
9.51E+03
1.33E+04
2.10E+04
2.96E+04
3.91E+04
5.89E+04
7.84E+04
9.76E+04
1.15E+05
1.29E+05
1.45E+05
1.62E+05
1.69E+05
1.73E+05
1.75E+05
1.75E+05
1.75C+05
1.75E+05
1.75E+05
1.75E+05
1.75E+05
1.75E+05
1.75E+05
1.75E+05
1.75E+05
1.75E+05
1.75E+05
Using a Risk Factor of 8.30E-06
Level Risk Level
3.74E-04
:.50E-04
l.OOE-04
5.00E-05
2.50E-05
l.OOE-05
5.00E-06
2.50E-06
l.OOE-06
Population
64
373
:•. 260
13,300
56,600
Hazard
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
1.71E-03
1.45E-02
7.08E-02
1.03E-01
1.59E-01
-------
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
5.00E-07
2.50E-07
l.OOE-07
5.00E-08
2.50E-08
l.OOE-08
5.00E-09
2.50E-09
l.OOE-09
5.00E-10
2.50E-10
l.OOE-10
5.00E-11
2.50E-11
l.OOE-11
5.00E-12
2.50E-12
l.OOE-12
5.00E-13
2.50E-13
l.OOE-13
5.00E-14
2.50E-14
9.93E-15
156,000
370,000
1,390,000
3,530,000
8,530,000
18,500,000
34,800,000
71,700,000
170,000,000
269,000,000
371,000,000
486,000,000
544,000,000
575,000,000
596,000,000
613,000,000
625,000,000
642,000,000
660,000,000
672,000,000
687,000,000
698,000,000
701,000,000
701,000,000
2.27E-01
3.00E-01
4.52E-01
5.98E-01
7.74E-01
9.27E-01
1.04E+00
1.17E-I-00
1.32E-t-00
1.39E+00
1.43E+00
1.45E+00
1.45E+00
1.45E+00
1.45E+00
1.45E+00
1.45E-fOO
1.45E4-00
1.45E+00
1.45E+00
1.45E+00
1.45E-1-00
1.45E+00
1.4SE+00
TABLE D-9. (continued)
Pag«
-------
TABLE D-10. POPULATION EXPOSURE RESULTS FOR CASE 4 (CONTROLLED MAXIMUM)
Summary for BENZENE REFINERIES
Maximum Radius a 50.0 Km
SIC-
Page
CAS-
Level Concentration Population
Exposure
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
8.12E+01
5.00E+01
2.50E+01
l.OOE+01
5.00E+00
2.50E+00
l.OOE+00
5.00E-01
2.50E-01
l.OOE-01
5.00E-02
2.50E-02
l.OOE-02
5.00E-03
2.50E-03
l.OOE-03
5.00E-04
2.50E-04
l.OOE-04
5.00E-05
2.50E-05
l.OOE-05
5.00E-06
2.50E-06
l.OOE-06
5.00E-07
2 . 50E-07
l.OOE-07
5.00E-08
2.50E-08
l.OOE-08
5.00E-09
2.50E-09
1.20E-09
272
2,300
19,900
43,100
95,400
330,000
800,000
2,180,000
7,310,000
16,600,000
32,100,000
78,900,000
154,000,000
263,000,000
391,000,000
455,000,000
502,000,000
552,000,000
574,000,000
588,000,000
610,000,000
624,000,000
637,000,000
654,000,000
668,000,000
680,000,000
694,000,000
700,000,000
701,000,000
701,000,000
O.OOE-t-00
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
1.51E+03
8.09E+03
3.40E+04
5.01E+04
6.83E+04
1.04E+05
1.35E+05
1.82E+05
2.59E+05
3.25E+05
3.78E+05
4.50E+05
5.02E+05
5.41E+05
5.63E+05
5.67E+05
5.69E+05
5.70E+05
5.70E+05
5.70E-I-05
5.70E+05
5.70E+05
5.70E+05
5.70E+05
5.70E+05
5.70E+05
5.70E+05
S.70E+05
S.70E+05
5.70E+05
Using a Risk Factor of 8.30E-06
Level Risk Level Population
6.74E-04
5.00E-04
2.50E-04
l.OOE-04
5.00E-05
2.50E-05
l.OOE-05
5.00E-06
45
1,480
Is,100
35,700
Hazard
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
O.OOE+00
2.64E-03
4.84E-02
2.48E-01
3.82E-01
-------
TABLE D-10. (continued)
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
2.50E-06
l.OOE-06
5.00E-07
2.50E-07
l.OOE-07
5.00E-08
2.50E-08
l.OOE-08
5.00E-09
2.50E-09
l.OOE-09
5.00E-10
2.50E-10
l.OOE-10
5.00E-11
2.50E-11
l.OOE-11
5.00E-12
2.50E-12
l.OOE-12
5.00E-13
2.50E-13
l.OOE-13
5.00E-14
2.50E-14
9.93E-15
78,500 !
255,000
619,000 ]
1,650,000 ]
5,700,000 ;
13,600,000 ;
26,900,000 :
65,500,000
130,000,000
231,000,000
368,000,000
440,000,000
491,000,000
543,000,000
569,000,000
584,000,000
606,000,000
621,000,000
633,000,000
650,000,000
665,000,000
677,000,000
692,000,000
699,000,000
701,000,000
701,000,000
>.29E-01
7.91E-01
L.04E+00
L.40E+00
t.01E+00
E.55E+00
I.02E+00
.61E+00
.06E+00
. 42E+00
.65E+00
.70E+00
.72E+00
.73E+00
.73E+00
.73E+00
.73E+00
.73E+00
.73E+00
.73E+00
.73E+00
.73E+00
.73E-I-00
.73E+00
.73E+00
. 73E+00
Page
-------
APPENDIX E.I: COST FUNCTIONS
The cost of applying emission controls to benzene waste operations was
estimated by developing cost functions for each type of emission control. For
each cost function, the quantity of waste to be treated or otherwise con-
trolled was used as the Independent variable. Total nationwide costs of
emission controls were estimated by applying the cost function for each
control to the total nationwide waste quantity to which each control 1s
applied. A brief discussion of the basis for each cost function used 1n this
analysis Is presented below and the functions are summarized 1n Table E-l.
Steam Stripping
The costs for steam stripping were taken from Reference 14. The basic
design Includes a storage tank, feed preheater, steam stripping tray column,
primary condenser, overhead collection decanter, flame arrestor, and pumps.
The storage tank 1s sized to provide a retention time of 48 hours. This tank
can be used to allow settling o.f sol Ids or separation of organic and aqueous
phases. A total of 1,500 m of connective piping 1s included to transport
various process wastewaters to the centrally located steam stripper. The
column height 1s 18.3 m with a total of 31 sieve trays. The design steam rate
1s 0.06 kg steam per liter of wastewater. Emphasis was placed on generating a
design that would be most cost effective, be within practical design
parameters, and would remove virtually 100 percent of the highly volatile
compounds. (The controlling compound used for design purposes was benzene.)
The cost estimate used in this analysis is based on a steam stripper that
treats about 300 L/min of wastewater (130,000 Mg/yr). The total capital cost
was estimated as $610,000 or $4.70 Mg of wastewater. The total annual cost of
$230,000 per year yields an annual cost function of $1.70/Mg of wastewater.
Thln-FUm Evaporator
Cost estimates for thin-film evaporation (TFE) were taken from the TSDF
cost document.18 The TFE cost 1n that document Is based on a design that
includes a waste storage (feed) tank, preheater, three side-entry feed mixers,
condenser, condensate storage tank, decanter, and a heated surface area of 10
square meters. The unit 1s designed to process 17,600 Mg/yr of sludge. The
total capital cost was estimated at $1.2 million ($68/Mg) with a total annual
E-l
-------
TABLE E-l. COST FUNCTIONS USED FOR BENZENE-CONTAINING WASTES ($1986)
Cost functions ($/Mg)
Control Applied to CapitalAnnual
Submerged fill Containers, tank trucks 0.83 0.15
95% control device Tank vents 4.11 2.57
Steam stripping Wastewater treatment 4.70 1.70
Thin-film evaporation Land disposed sludges 68 14.16
Waste Incineration Organic liquids ~ 35
E-2
141
-------
cost of $249,000 ($14.16/Mg). This estimate has limitations similar to those
for steam stripping. For example, economy of scale 1s not considered 1n the
use of the average cost function, and a specific plant may Incur higher or
lower costs depending on the quantity of waste and the amount of steam
required.
Waste Incineration Costs
Waste Incineration costs are also presented 1n the TSDF cost document for
different types of waste streams as follows:19
Cost ($ Mg)
Waste type Capital Annual
Organic sludge/slurry 469 70
Organic solid 284 64
Organic liquid (U009) 440 70
For the purpose of estimating nationwide costs, organic liquids are the major
type of waste stream considered for Incineration. However, many organic
liquids have a recoverable fuel value and might be burned onsite 1n existing
boilers or furnaces. If the waste 1s shipped to a hazardous waste
incinerator, a facility would incur an annual disposal cost for that waste but
would not incur the capital cost of constructing an Incinerator. A cost of
$35/Mg was used for Incineration of organic liquids based on a range of $0
(burning to recover and use the heating value) to $70/Mg for disposal 1n a
hazardous waste Incinerator as estimated in the TSDF cost document. For a
specific facility's waste, the cost of incineration may be higher or lower
than the midrange estimate depending on the heating value of the waste and
other characteristics, such as water, sol Ids, metals, or chlorine content.
Submerged Fill and Tank Controls
The costs for submerged fill and for tank controls were taken from the
TSDF BID.15. The cost estimates In that document were developed for model
units that were derived statistically from data on the types of units found at
hazardous waste facilities. The TSDF BID developed cost estimates for a range
of model wastes to represent the types of wastes handled at these facilities.
The estimated cost for submerged fill for containers and tank trucks is
$0.83/Mg capital cost and $0.15/Mg for total annual cost.
E-3
HZ-
-------
The TSDF BID evaluated the emission control costs for several types of
tanks, including open, covered, and aerated. The level of detail available
from the data base for benzene-containing wastes was not sufficient to allow
Identification of the different tank types; consequently, an overall average
cost was used for all tanks. The types of controls used in the cost estimate
include covers for open tanks, Internal floating roofs for covered tanks,
venting to a carbon adsorber, and venting to an existing control device. An
average cost was estimated based on the costs given in the TSDF BID for 20,000
gallon tanks that are either open or covered:
Tank
Type
Covered storage
Covered treatment
Open treatment
Waste
quantity
(Mg/yr)
4,000
28,000
28,000
Capital
cost
($/Mg)
11.1
0.46
0.77
Annual
cost
($/Mg)
5.2
0.24
0.27
Average 4.11 1.90
The total annual cost was estimated using the average values given above and a
capital recovery factor of 0.163 (10 years at 10 percent Interest) as
$2.57/Mg. As Illustrated above, costs can vary significantly depending on the
type of tank and quantity of waste. For this analysis, sufficient data were
not available to differentiate among open, covered, and aerated tanks. For
any given facility, the costs for controlling tanks may be higher or lower
than that given by the average cost function.
E-4
------- |