SWRHL-30r FINAL REPORT OF OFF-SITE SURVEILLANCE FOR THE NRX-A4/EST TEST SERIES by the Southwestern Radiological Health Laboratory U. S. Public Health Service Department of Health, Education, and Welfare Las Vegas, Nevada September 19, 1966 This surveillance performed under a Memorandum of Understanding (No. SF 54 373) for the U. S. ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION ------- LEGAL NOTICE This report was prepared as an account of Government sponsored work. Neither the United States, nor the Atomic Energy Commission, nor any person acting on behalf of the Commission: A. Makes any warranty or representation, expressed or implied, with respect to the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of the in- formation contained in this report, or that the use of any information, apparatus, method, or process disclosed in this report may not in- fringe privately owned rights; or B. Assumes any liabilities with respect to the use of, or for damages resulting from the use of any information, apparatus, method, or pro- cess disclosed in this report. As used in the above, "person acting on behalf of the Commission" in- cludes any employee or contractor of the Commission, or employee of such contractor, to the extent that such employee or contractor of the Commission, or employee of such contractor prepares, dissemin- ates, or provides access to, any information pursuant to his employ- ment or contract with the Commission, or his employment with such contractor. 63 ------- SWRHL-30r FINAL REPORT OF OFF-SITE SURVEILLANCE FOR THE NRX-A4/EST TEST SERIES by the Southwestern Radiological Health Laboratory U. S. Public Health Service Department of Health, Education, and Welfare Las Vegas, Nevada September 19, 1966 This surveillance performed under a Memorandum of Understanding (No. SF 54 373) for the U. S. ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION ------- ABSTRACT The Southwestern Radiological Health Laboratory provided off-site radiation surveillance for the NRX-A4/EST Project Rover Reactor test series which took place at NRDS test cell A. Of the six experimental plans in the test series, four resulted in detectable quantities of radioactivity in the off-site area as indicated below: Experimental Plan Date Effluent Trajectory 2B 2/03/66 Northeast quadrant 3 3/03/66 Southerly at about 160° 4 3/16/66 Easterly at 82° 4A 3/25/66 Westerly at 265° Although radioactive effluent was detected off-site from this event, the surveillance indicated that the radiation protection guides established by the Atomic Energy Commission (based on Federal Radiation Council guidelines), Chapter 0524, for the off-site population were not exceeded. The peak off-site potential thyroid exposure was about 36 millirad at Lone Pine, California. ------- TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION 1 OPERATIONAL PROCEDURES 4 A. EXTERNAL MEASUREMENTS 4 1. Ground Monitoring 4 2. Dose Rate Recorders 4 3. Aerial Cloud Tracking 5 4. Film Badges 5 5. Thermoluminescent Dosimeters (TLD) 5 B. ENVIRONMENTAL MEASUREMENTS 5 1. Milk and Water Samples 8 2. Vegetation Samples 8 RESULTS 9 A. EP-2B TEST, February 3, 1966 9 1. Ground Monitoring 9 2. Dose Rate Recorders 9 3. Film Badges and Thermoluminescent Dosimeters 9 4. Air Sampling 9 5. Milk Sampling 9 6. Vegetation Sampling 11 B. EP-2C TEST, February 11, 1966 11 1. Ground Monitoring 11 2. Dose Rate Recorders 16 3. Film Badges and Thermoluminescent Dosimeters 16 4. Air Sampling 16 5. Milk Sampling 16 11 ------- Table of Contents (continued) C. EP-3 TEST, March 3, 1966 16 1. Ground Monitoring 16 2. Dose Rate Recorders 18 3. Film Badges and Thermoluminescent Dosimeters 18 4. Air Sampling 19 5. Milk Sampling 19 D. EP-4 TEST, March 16, 1966 19 1. Ground Monitoring 19 2. Dose Rate Recorders 19 3. Film Badges and Thermoluminescent Dosimeters 19 4. Air Sampling 22 5. Milk Sampling 22 6. Vegetation Sampling 24 E. EP-4A TEST, March 25, 1966 24 1. Ground Monitoring 24 2. Dose Rate Recorders 24 3. Film Badges and Thermoluminescent Dosimeters 26 4. Air Sampling 26 5. Milk Sampling 26 6. Vegetation Sampling 30 7. Thyroid In Vivo Counting 30 8. Water 30 CONCLUSIONS 34 APPENDIX I - Thyroid Dose DISTRIBUTION 111 ------- LIST OF TABLES Table 1. NRX-A4/EST test series data. 1 Table 2. Threshold detectability at time of count of several radionuclides in air samples (90% confidence level). 7 Table 3. Meteorological data supplied by the Environmental Science Service Agency for NRX-A4/EST EP-2B. 11 Table 4. Analyses of air samples collected following NRX-A4/EST EP-2B. 12 Table 5. Meteorological data supplied by the Environmental Science Service Agency for NRX-A4/EST EP-2C. 14 Table 6. Meteorological data supplied by the Environmental Science Service Agency for NRX-A4/EST EP-3. 18 Table 7. Analyses of air samples collected following EP-3. 20 Table 8. Meteorological data supplied by the Environmental Science Service Agency for NRX-A4/EST EP-4. 22 Table 9. Analyses of air samples collected following EP-4. 23 Table 10. Meteorological data supplied by the Environmental Science Service Agency for NRX-A4/EST EP-4A. 25 Table 11. Analyses of air samples collected following EP-4A. 28 Table 12. Analysis of milk samples collected following EP-4A. 29 Table 13. Water Results - NRX-A4/EST EP-4A. 33 Table 14. Peak gamma doses detected off the test range com- plex for NRX-A4/EST. 34 Table 15. Peak iodine concentrations as measured by air samplers. 35 Table 16. Estimates of thyroid exposures from peak iodine concentrations. 35 iv ------- LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. Hot line locations following NRX-A4/EST Experiments. 3 Figure 2. Sampling locations following NRX-A4/EST EP-2B. 10 Figure 3. Sampling locations following NRX-A4/EST EP-2C. 13 Figure 4. Sampling locations following NRX-A4/EST EP-3. 17 Figure 5. Sampling locations following NRX-A4/EST EP-4. 21 Figure 6. Sampling locations following NRX-A4/EST EP-4A. 27 Figure 7. Iodine-13 1 in milk, Lone Pine, Calif., following NRX-A4/EST, 3/25/66, EP-4A. 31 Figure 8. Natural vegetation samples along Highway 95. 32 ------- INTRODUCTION As a part of the Rover Program, testing and disassembling of a series of reactors designated NRX is being conducted at the Nuclear Rocket Development Station (NRDS) under the auspices of the NERVA program. The subject of this report is the off-site radiol- ogical surveillance provided by the Public Health Service (PHS) for the Atomic Energy Commission (AEC) in support of the EP-2B, EP-2C, EP-3, EP-4 and EP-4A experiments of the NRX-A4/EST test series. Under a memorandum of understanding with the Atomic Energy Commission, the U. S. Public Health Service conducts a program of radiological monitoring and environmental sampling in the off- site area surrounding the Nevada Test Site and the Nellis Air Force Range (NAFR), which includes the Nuclear Rocket Develop- ment Station and the Tonopah Test Range. For simplicity this area will be called the test range complex throughout this report. The following table lists the operating times and integral powers of each of the experiments covered in this report. Table 1. NRX-A4/EST test series data. Experiment Date EP-2B EP-2C EP-3 EP-4 EP-4A 2/03/66 2/11/66 3/03/66 3/16/66 3/25/66 Time of Operation PST 1116-1123 1459-1510 1220-1230 1422-1443 1310-1316 1550-1605 1004-1020 0933-0948 Mw -sec 3.9 x 4. 3 x 8.7 x 1. 0 x l.OSx 105 105 105 106 106 Radiation Detectable Off -Site Yes No Yes Yes Yes ------- All of the above experiments were conducted at Test Cell A. The reactor was tested in an upright position so that the hydrogen cool- ant exhausted upward along with escaping fission products. The "hot lines" as estimated from ground sampling are presented in Figure 1. The effluent from EP-2C was not detected off-site and is thus not shown in Figure 1. The effluent eventually moved in a south to southeast direction from the test cell. ------- ALAMO PA HRA NA GA T —| 0V. LAKE VADA . NELLIS AIR FORCE RANGE 0 10 20 3O 40 90 ^ss^—^sa- SCALE IN MILES BOULDER CITY Figure 1. Hot line locations following NRX-A4/EST Experiments. ------- OPERATIONAL PROCEDURES A. EXTERNAL MEASUREMENTS 1. Ground Monitoring Ground monitors tracked the reactor effluent passage with portable instruments. Each monitor was equipped with an Eberline E-500B, a Precision Model 111 Standard "Scin- tillator", and a Victoreen Radector Model No. AGB-50B-SR. The Eberline E-500B has a range of 0 to 200 milliroentgens per hour (mR/hr) beta-gamma detection in four scales with an external halogen filled GM tube and a 0 to 2000 mR/hr range, gamma only, from an internal Anton 302 tube. The Precision Model 111 "Scintillator" is used primarily for low level detection and provides for a range of 0 to 5 mR/hr in six scales. The Radector has a range of 0. 05 to 50, 000 mR/hr on two scales. This instrument employs an inert gas ionization chamber. Errors associated with these in- struments are of the order of j^20% as calibrated with 137Cs. 2. Dose Rate Recorders Eberline RM-11 Dose Rate Recorders are placed at twenty-two stations around the test range complex. These recorders utilize a Geiger-Mueller tube detector to document radiation levels at specific locations. The instrument has a 0. 01 to 100 mR/hr range and the gamma dose rate is recorded on a 30-hour strip chart. The RM-11 is accurate to +.20% as calibrated with a cesium-137 source. ------- 3. Aerial Cloud Tracking An Air Force U3-A aircraft, manned by two Public Health Service monitors equipped with portable instruments iden- tical to those of the ground monitors, tracked the reactor effluent to position ground monitors. Public Health Service cloud sampling aircraft were also used as aids in cloud tracking, however their primary purpose was cloud samp- ling in order to determine cloud size and inventory. The results of their sampling are reported separately by the SWRHL Engineering Development Program. 4. Film Badges The experiments took place during the months of February and March. The PHS maintained approximately 74 film badge stations off the test range complex and assigned badges to 144 off-site residents during February, and maintained 77 film badge stations and assigned badges to 132 off-site residents during March. The badge used is made of Du Pont type 555 film. This film is accurate to + 50% in the 20 to 100 mR range and +10% in the 100 to 2000 mR range. The lower limit of detectability is 20 mR. 5. Thermoluminescent Dosimeters (TLD) Approximately 20 TLD's per month were used in the off-site surveillance program. The TLD's are used with read-out equipment manufactured by Edgerton, Germeshausen and Grier, Inc. , and have a lower detection limit of about 5 mR. B. ENVIRONMENTAL MEASUREMENTS One hundred and seven air samplers were routinely operated by the Air Surveillance Network (ASN) in the western United States at the time of these experiments. The air sampler used by the ASN is a ------- Gelman "Tempest." The "Tempest" employs a Cast Model 1550 vacuum pump driven by a General Electric 1/2 horsepower motor. The pump runs at 1440 rpm and draws an average flow rate of 10 cfm. During the time of these experiments, wider coverage was being developed in the states of California, Utah and Nevada. Thirty-nine air samplers were located in Nevada. Supplementary temporary air sampler locations were established as deemed necessary to cover cloud passage. All samplers were equipped with Whatman 541 prefilters which have a pore size of 3 - 4 microns. A portion of the routine samplers and all supplementary stations were equipped with MSA Part 46727 charcoal cartridges. This is the chemical cartridge for organic vapors and is impregnated with stable elemental and sodium iodine and should have a fair efficiency for methyl iodine. All air sample prefilters and charcoal car- tridges collected following the NRX/EST series were returned to the Southwestern Radiological Health Laboratory in Las Vegas for analysis. Prefilters were counted for gross beta activity in a Beckman "Wide Beta" low background (6 + 1 cpm beta) proportional system which has an efficiency of approximately 45% for 0. 54 Mev betas. After an initial count, if no significant activity is detected, the filters are counted at five and twelve days after collection. In all other cases, filters are recounted a minimum of three times in the first 48 hours following collection. The computational pro- cedure employed depends upon the assumption that a decay constant can be determined for each individual sample and that this con- stant can then be used to extrapolate the activity to the end of the collection period. For this purpose the general decay equation A/A = e is employed. ------- Filter papers and charcoal cartridges were analyzed for gamma isotopes by placing them directly on a 4"x 4" Nal(Tl) crystal coupled to a TMC Model 404C gamma pulse height analyzer view- ing energies from 0 to 2 Mev. Since it was not possible to define duration of cloud passage at all locations, reported values given as pCi-sec/m3 represent the integrated air concentration. This value is obtained as follows: (activity in pCi) (sampling time in seconds) . , . - ' - = integrated air con- sample volume in m3 centration(pCi-sec/m3). Threshold detectability of several radionuclides is presented in Table 2 and is the result of an examination of previous data col- lected under the following conditions: a. Count time in days after fissioning as indicated by footnotes. b. Prefilters collect unfractionated fission products resulting in a complex spectrum. c. MSA charcoal collects gaseous fission products only (primarily iodines). d. An eight isotope matrix is employed for computation and isotopes other than those examined are present in amounts which are small relative to those eight. e. Natural activity on air samples is approximately five times system background. Table 2. Threshold detectability at time of count of several radio- nuclides in air samples (90% confidence level). Sample type Whatman No. MSA Charcoal 1 - counted at 2 - counted at 131i oil 50° 541 200 200 100 less than 3 days or 13ZTe-I ~^3 l" 135I 14( 1000 500 1000 200 - 400 200 400 100 - 3 days after fissioning. more after fissioning. 'Ba-La 500 200 200 100 . Notes of count 10 min 10 min 10 min 10 min 1 2 1 2 ------- 1. Milk and Water Samples After the release of activity from NRDS, milk samples were collected from dairy farms and farms producing milk for their own consumption which were believed to have been in the cloud path. Each milk sample is counted for 40 minutes using a 400-channel analyzer viewing an energy range from 0 to 2 Mev. All liquid samples are counted in 3. 5 liter inverted well aluminum beakers which are placed over a 4"x4" sodium iodide crystal. The lower limit of detection for 131I and 133 I in milk and water is 20 pCi/1 at time of count, and all results below that value are reported as non- detectable. The reported values have, at time of count, a 2 sigma error estimate of +^15 pCi/1 or + 10%, whichever is greater. 2. Vegetation Samples Vegetation samples were collected in the suspected effluent trajectory to indicate deposition on the ground. They were also obtained at most milk sampling locations, with an effort made to make the sample representative of the cows' feed. These samples were taken as early indicators of where milk might be contaminated and were not intended to yield intake-excretion data. For this reason the vegetation sample results are reported simply as fresh fission products present or not present. ------- RESULTS A. EP-2B TEST, February 3, 1966 A summary of the meteorological conditions on the test day is pre- sented in Table 3. Due to the wind shear which existed on the test day, environmental samples, e.g. vegetation, air and milk were obtained from an azimuth of 270 to 45 . Sample locations are shown in Figure 2. 1. Ground Monitoring There were no detectable dose rates in the off-site area as measured by ground monitors. 2. Dose Rate Recorders There were no detectable dose rates in the off-site area as measured by remote dose rate recorders. 3. Film Badges and Thermoluminescent Dosimeters(TLD's) Film badges and TLD's exposed during February indicated no doses above the detection limit (20 mR and 5 mR respectively) that could be attributed to EP-2B effluent. 4. Air Sampling The air sampler prefilters obtained from Twin Springs Ranch, Diablo and Hiko, Nevada, contained less than 0. 2 pCi/m I. These were the only air samples that contained fresh fission products. A summary of the air data is presented in Table 4. 5. Milk Sampling Milk was sampled at four different locations following EP-2B, as shown in Figure 2. None of the samples contained radioiodine. ------- 0 10 20 30 40 SO SCALE IN MILES ARIZONA • Positive Air Samples D Negative Air Sa'fnples A Negative Milk Samples Figure 2. Sampling locations following NRX-A4/EST EP-2B. ------- 6. Vegetation Sampling Vegetation samples collected following EP-2B contained no activity above background levels. Table 3. Meteorological data supplied by the Environmental Science Serivce Agency for NRX-A4/EST EP-2B. Sky condition : clear Visibility : unrestricted Upper air data at: Jackass Flats, Nevada 1000 PST 2/03/66 Height (Ft. MSL) SFC 3,615 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000 10, 000 11,000 12,000 13,000 14,000 15,000 Wind Pressure (Deg/Kts) (mb) 110/13 090/11 100/12 170/08 180/13 190/18 200/22 220/20 220/17 220/17 220/20 220/23 230/20 900 887 854 822 792 762 734 706 679 653 629 605 581 _ Dew Temgerature point < c) (°c) 8. 8 6.0 4. 0 2. 2 0.3 -1.5 -2.8 -1.9 -1.9 -2.8 -4.8 -7. 1 -9.6 - 6. 1 - 9. 1 -12. 0 -14. 5 -16.9 -19.4 -22. 7 -23. 7 -22.5 -16.2 -16.4 -18.4 -20. 7 Relative Humidity (%) 37 33 30 28 26 24 20 17 19 35 40 40 40 SFC - Surface B. EP-2C TEST, February 11, 1966 Environmental samples (air, milk and vegetation) following EP-2C did not contain fresh fission products. Sample locations are shown in Figure 3. Ground monitoring and dose rate recorders also yielded no positive measurements. Meteorological observations on the test day are presented in Table 5. 1. Ground Monitoring As a result of aerial cloud tracking information, ground moni- toring was performed south of NRDS following the first 11 ------- Table 4. Analyses of air samples collected following NRX-A4/EST EP-2B, February 3, 1966. Air Location Volume (m3) Hwy. Maint. Stn. , Diablo, Nevada Hike, 49? Nevada Twin Springs Rn. Warm Springs, Nev. Date Time On 2-3 Q700 1 2-3 0800 2-3 1030 Date Gross Beta Activity Time Prefilter at end of Off collection pCi-sec* -3 (PCi/m3) m3 A 1U 2-4 0700 2-4 0800 '°2 2'2 2-4 0930 Col- Gamma pulse height analysis lee- Activity (pCi/m3) at end of tor collection P C P C P c 1 31 l ND ND ND ND ND ND 132! ND ND ND ND ND ND 133! 0. 17 ND 0. 18 ND 0. 16 ND 135I ND ND ND ND ND ND ND - not detectable P - prefilter C - charcoal cartridge * - the time shown on the running time meter is used in calculating pCi- sec rather than the time on and time off reported by the station operator. This is done —3 because the two do not always agree due to power failures, etc. m ------- PA HRA NA GA T LAKE NEVADA , NELLIS AIR FORCE RANGE 0 10 20 30 40 50 5^5ia=te=^! SCALE IN MILES ARIZONA ALLEY FURNACE CR. NAT. MON. D Neeative Air Samples DEATH \Q VALLEY hHAHRUMP A Negative Milk Samples Figure 3. Sampling locations following NRX-A4/EST EP-2C. ------- Table 5. Meteorological data supplied by the Environmental Science Service Agency for NRX-A4/EST EP-2C. Clouds Visibility Upper air Height (Ft. MSL) SFC 3,615 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000 10,085 11,000 12,000 13,000 14,000 15,000 : 0.4 altocumulus, 0.5 cirrus ^unrestricted data at: Wind (Deg/Kts) 090/08 000/00 080/02 020/06 030/12 040/15 030/15 030/17 010/19 020/27 360/28 010/27 010/32 Jackass Flats, Nevada 1 Pressure Temperature (mb) (°C) 900 888 853 820 794 759 730 700 674 646 622 597 574 3. 7 2. 5 - 1.9 - 2.6 - 1.6 - 2.8 - 4.4 - 6.2 - 7.9 - 9.5 -10.8 -12. 0 -13.3 000 PST Dew Point <°C) - 4.0 - 7. 1 -19. 3 -20.9 -21. 6 -23.9 -25. 12 -26. 7 -28. 2 -29. 0 -28. 5 -28.5 -28.4 2/11/66 Relative Humidity (%) 56 49 25 23 20 18 18 18 18 19 22 24 27 SFC - surface 14 ------- Table 5. Meteorological data supplied by the Environmental Science Service Agency for NRX-A4/EST EP-ZC(continued) Clouds Visibility : 0. 3 cirrus : unrestricted Upper air data at: Jackass Flats, Nevada 1615 PST Height (Ft. MSL) SFC 3,615 4,000 5, 000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000 10,000 11,000 12,000 13,000 14,000 14,200 15,000 Wind (Deg/Kts) 240/04 230/05 248/04 325/04 356/06 348/09 327/08 323/18 323/18 330/19 336/18 336/29 340/29 331/28 Pressure (mb) 896 884 850 820 788 760 730 704 676 650 625 600 596 577 Temperature <°C) 8.9 7.0 3.8 1.0 0.3 - 1. 1 - 2.8 - 4.3 - 4.9 - 6.6 - 8.8 -11.0 -11.4 -11. 1 2/1 Dew Point <°C) -15.6 -15. 7 -16.6 -18. 3 -20. 6 -22. 5 -23.9 -25. 8 -23.5 -21.5 -21.0 -20.9 -20. 7 -21. 5 1/66 Relative Humidity (%) 16 18 21 22 19 18 18 17 22 30 37 44 46 42 SFC - surface 15 ------- segment of EP-2C. The second segment of EP-2C resulted in a split cloud with one section headed tPwards the north* east and the other towards the south, It was predicted that the cloud towards the northeast would eventually move towards the southeast and thus sampling was performed along Hwy. 95. All ground monitoring was negative. 2. Dose Rate Recorders No increase in activity above background was indicated on recorders including those from Pahrump, Lathrop Wells, and Indian Springs, Nevada. 3. Film Badges and Thermoluminescent Dosimeters Film badges and TLD's exposed during February indicated no doses above the detection limit (20 mR and 5 mR respec- tively) that could be attributed to EP-2C effluent. 4. Air Sampling As a result of aerial cloud tracking information, air samples were collected southeast of NRDS. No air samples were found to contain fresh fission products. 5. Milk Sampling A milk and feed sample collected from Dansby Ranch near Lathrop Wells, Nevada did not contain fresh fission products. C. EP-3 TEST, March 3, 1966 A summary of meteorological conditions on the EP-3 test day is presented in Table 6. Environmental sampling locations (air and milk) are shown in Figure 4. 1. Ground Monitoring As a result of aerial cloud tracking, ground monitoring was 16 ------- TWIN ^ NYAL* SPRING RN. „ ADAVEN 2 MEWCASTLE^*jCEDAR CITY ENTERPRISE ' KANARRAVILLE ALAMO PA HRA NA GA T —I 0V LAKE NEVADA i NELLIS AR ZONA • Positive Air Samples D Negative Air Samples A PAH RUMP LAS VEGAS A Negative Milk Samples BOULDER CITY ^ 7 .VA LL \A FURNACE CR. -O1 NAT. MON. Figure 4. Sampling locations following NRX-A4/EST EP-3. ------- Table 6. Meteorological data supplied by the Environmental Science Service Agency for NRX-A4/EST EP-3. Sky condition : 2/10 Clouds : Cumulus Visibility : unrestricted Upper air data at: Jackass Flats, Nevada 1325 PST 3/3/66 Height (Ft. MSL) SFC 3,615 4, 000 5, 000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9, 000 10, 000 11,000 12,000 13,000 14,000 15,000 Wind (Deg/Kts) 030/06 020/06 360/08 340/11 330/13 320/14 320/12 330/11 340/11 350/08 330/04 330/41 330/69 Pressure (mb) 894 882 849 815 784 754 726 697 666 638 610 584 559 Temperature r\ ro 5.6 3.5 0.7 - 2.2 - 5.2 - 7.9 -10.7 -13.9 -17. 1 -19.6 -21.8 -19.0 -19.4 Dew Point -10.6 -11. 6 -13.8 -16.3 -18.3 -20.4 -22.5 -24. 7 -26. 7 -29. 7 -32.6 -32. 3 -33. 0 Relative Humidity 30 32 33 33 35 36 37 40 43 40 37 30 29 SFC - surface performed along the eastern side of the Amargosa Valley along a hot line of 160 . A monitor on Hwy. 95 located 17 miles ESE of Lathrop Wells, measured intensities of less than 0. 01 mR/hr above background during the interval of 1505 to 1540 hours PST. Positive dose rates -were not meas- ured at other monitored locations. 2. Dose Rate Recorders No increase in activity above background was indicated on any of the dose rate recorders. 3. Film Badges and Thermoluminescent Dosimeters Film badges and TLD's exposed during March indicated no doses above the detection limit (20 mR and 5 mR respectively) that could be attributed to EP-3 effluent. 18 ------- 4. Air Sampling Air samples from two locations contained l 3 3I on the pre- filters and cartridges. A summary of the air data is presented in Table 7. 5. Milk Sampling Milk and feed samples were obtained from those locations shown in Figure 4 following the EP-3 test. The samples indicated no activity above background levels. D. EP-4 TEST, March 16, 1966 The EP-4 Test resulted in detectable levels of radioactivity in the off-site area. Meteorological conditions on the test day are presented in Table 8. Environmental sampling locations (air and milk) are shown in Figure 5. 1. Ground Monitoring Highway 93 was monitored between Glendale and Alamo during the approximate time of cloud passage. Levels of less than 0. 03 mR/hr above background were detected from 36 miles NE of Glendale to Alamo. 2. Dose Rate Recorders Dose rate recorders at Warm Springs Ranch, Caliente, Alamo, Pioche and St. George did not indicate dose rates on March 16 and 17 above the local background levels (<0. 02 mR/hr). 3. Film Badges and Thermoluminescent Dosimeters Film badges and TLD's exposed during March indicated no doses above the detection limit (20 mR and 5 mR respectively) that could be attributed to EP-4 effluent. 19 ------- Table 7. Analyses of air samples collected following EP-3. Air Location Volume (m3) Ash Meadows, Nevada Jet. Ash Meadows Rd 195 and U S 95 Pahrump, Nevada 479 Date Date Gross Beta Activity Col- Gamma pulse height analysis Time Time Prefilter at end of lee- Activity (pCi/m3) at end of On Off collection tor collection pCi-sec -3 isir (pCi/m3) m3 P ND 1300 0720 >-6 106 C N° 3-3 3-4 A4 P ND 1046 1030 ' C ND 132J ND ND ND ND 1 33j 1 35 j 2. 2 ND 2. 0 ND 0.57 ND 0. 79 ND ND - not detectable P - prefilter C - charcoal cartridge ------- PAHRANAGAT LAKE NEVADA , N ELLIS 0 10 20 30 40 90 dS^^^S^^^^E SCALE IN MILES ARIZONA ALLEY\V ,* FURNACE CR. • Positive Air Samples D Negative Air Samples A Negative Milk Samples Figure 5. Sampling locations following NRX-A4/EST EP-4. ------- Table 8. Meteorological data supplied by the Environmental Science Service Agency for NRX-A4/EST EP-4. Sky condition Clouds Visibility : 14,000 Sctd. , high : 0.4 altocumulus, 0 : unrestricted thin broken . 6 cirrostratus Upper air data at: Jackass Flats, Nevada, 1005 PST, Height (Ft. MSL) SFC 3,615 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000 10,039 11,000 12,000 13,000 14,006 15,000 Wind Pressure (Deg/Kts) (mb) 240/10 889 230/10 879 200/09 850 210/10 815 270/10 785 300/15 755 290/17 728 280/14 700 270/18 674 270/25 649 270/33 624 280/45 600 280/51 576 Temperature <°C) 15.2 12.5 9. 5 6.5 5.9 3.4 0.9 - 2.0 - 4.5 - 5.6 - 7.5 - 9.4 -11.0 3/16/66 Dew Point - 5.8 - 6.5 -7.6 - 9.4 -10.8 -13.4 -16.0 -18. 9 -21. 1 -24.0 -26.6 -28.8 -29.6 Relative Humidity 23 26 29 31 29 28 27 26 26 22 20 19 20 SFC - surface 4. Air Sampling Samples containing radioiodines were obtained from Alamo, Butler Ranch turnoff and Highway 93, Warm Springs Ranch, Glendale and Caliente, Nevada, and Cedar City and Parowan, Utah. Negative samples were obtained at other locations as shown in Figure 5. Table 9 presents the results of air filter analyses. 5. Milk Sampling Milk and feed samples were obtained in the area of the effluent path on March 17, at locations shown in Figure 5. All results were negative. At all sampled locations the animals were not yet on pasture. 22 ------- Table 9. Analyses of air samples collected following EP-4. ro Air Date Date Gross Beta Activity Location Volume Time Time Prefilter at end of (m3) On Off collection. pCi-sec .. lft- Alamo, Nevada Butler Ranch turnoff and Hwy 93, Nevada Glendale Jet. , Nevada Caliente, Nevada Warm Springs Rn. , Nev Cedar City, Utah Parowan, Utah 489 20 96 348 502 372 448 (PCi/m3) 3-16 3-17 0750 0800 3-16 3-16 1350 1600 3-16 3-16 1230 1718 ^0 ^835 »•" 3-16 3-17 0800 1010 3-16 3-17 n ,, 1515 1250 °'36 3-15 3-16 2230 2230 m 3 560 8700 13000 470 250 270 220 Col- Gamma pulse height lee- Activity (pCi/m3)at tor collection. 2 131 J 132 j 133 j p C P C P C P C P C P C p C 0. 35 25 ND 2.4 1.6 0. 57 0. 58 0.21 ND 0. 30 0. 37 0. 18 ND 75 ND 4.6 1.2 1.6 0.47 0.42 ND ND ND ND 0.82 24 6.1 . 73 1. 7 1.2 0. 98 0. 34 ND 0. 35 0.85 0.41 analysis end of 135 j ND ND 7.9 9.6 1.7 0.91 ND ND ND ND ND ND ND - not detectable P - prefilter C - charcoal cartridge -- - sample not obtained ------- 6. Vegetation Sampling An experiment to compare fallout trays versus vegetation samples was conducted by PHS on the Nevada Test Site. o The results from both clearly indicated a hot line of 82 at a distance of 14 miles from Test Cell A, or 6 miles south of CP-1 on the Mercury Highway. E. EP-4A TEST, March 25, 1966 Radioactivity was detected off-site following the EP-4A Test. Meteorological conditions on the test day are presented in Table 10. 1. Ground Monitoring Monitors located on Highway 95 detected cloud passage with survey instruments. Monitoring was performed along high- ways in a south-southwesterly quadrant from the test site. A monitor located 14 miles SE of Beatty, along Highway 95, detected an external gamma dose of 2. 7 mR (integrated exposure from E-500B) due to cloud passage. The infinite dose at this unpopulated location is estimated to be 17 mR. Ground monitors were able to locate activity (<0. 03 net mR/hr) in the area between Lone Pine, California and Stovepipe Wells. 2. Dose Rate Recorders The RM-11 dose rate recorder at Beatty, Nevada, indicated a dose rate of up to 0. 02 mR/hr above background between 1330 and 1830 hours on March 25. A dose of 0. 05 mR above background was calculated by integration of the dose rate with time. The other recorders did not show a significant exposure above background. 24 ------- Table 10. Meteorological data supplied by Environmental Science Service Agency for NRX-A4/EST EP-4A Sky condition Clouds Visibility Upper air data Height (Ft. MSL) SFC3.615 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000 10, 000 11,000 12,000 13,000 14,000 15,000 : 7000' Sctd. , High : 0.4 Stratocumulus Sctd. , 0. 1 Cirrostratus : unrestricted at: Jackass Flats, Nevada 0940 Wind (Deg/Kts) 100/08 100/08 100/09 080/07 070/09 080/10 080/11 080/13 080/15 080/21 080/24 090/26 080/33 Pressure (mb) 889 875 847 816 785 756 729 703 674 649 622 599 575 Temperature <°0 17.8 16.0 12.4 9.1 6.2 3.3 0.3 - 2. 2 - 5. 7 - 7.6 - 9.4 -11. 3 -13. 0 PST 3/25/66 Dew Point (°C) - 2.5 - 4.6 - 6. 1 - 6.7 - 8. 1 - 9.0 -10. 5 -11.5 -11. 0 -14. 9 -16.5 -21.5 -26.6 Relative Humidity (%) 25 24 27 32 35 40 44 49 66 56 56 43 31 SFC - surface 25 ------- 3. Film Badges and Themoluminescent Dosimeters Film badges and TLD's exposed during March indicated no doses above the detection limit (20 mR and 5 mR respectively) that could be attributed to EP-4A effluent. 4. Air Sampling Samples containing fresh fission products were obtained at several locations. All sampled locations are shown in Figure 6. The peak concentrations in air were detected at Lone Pine, California where it is estimated the potential thyroid exposure was 3. 6 mR, primarily due to inhalation of 131 I and 133I. This assumes that all the 131I and 133I as collected on the prefilter and charcoal cartridge are bio- logically available for thyroid uptake from inhalation. A summary of the air sampling data is presented in Table 11. 5. Milk Sampling Milk and feed samples were obtained at several locations in California and Nevada as indicated in Figure 6. Radio- iodine was detected in milk from Lone Pine, Independence, and Big Pine, California. The peak concentration was 140 pCi of 131T/liter and 230 pCi of 133 I/liter; this occurred in Lone Pine milk collected from the evening milking on March 27. Milk sampling results are presented in Table 12. The potential thyroid dose to an infant's thyroid from 131I ingestion at Lone Pine is estimated to be 22 millirad. The 133 I ingestion dose is estimated to be 3 mrad. The cows' feed at the three locations was primarily made up of dry feed (hay), and less than 10% of the total intake was grass. A plot of the radioiodine concentrations in milk is presented 26 ------- C\) ^J Positive Air Samples Negative Air Samples A Positive Milk Samples A Negative Milk Samples Figure 6. Sampling locations following NRX-A4/EST EP-4A. ------- Table 11. Analyses of air samples collected following EP-4A. [SJ oo Air Location Volume (m3) Beatty, Nevada 442 Hwy. 95, 15 mi NW of Lathrop Wells, Nev. Hwy. 95, 25 mi NW 4g of Lathrop Wells, Nev. Lathrop Wells, Nev. 473 Scotty's Jet., Nev. 299 Stovepipe Wells, Calif. 386 Lone Pine, Calif. 432 Bishop, Calif. 398 Barstow, Calif. 546 Date Time On 3-25 0753 3-25 1130 3-25 1055 3-25 0640 3-25 1705 3-25 1140 3-25 0948 3-25 1010 3-25 0700 Date Gross Bet Time Prefilter Off colle (pCi/m3) 3-26 0733 3-25 1545 3-25 1540 3-26 0605 0905 3-26 0930 650 3-26 0624 ms 4'7 a. Activity Col- Gamr at end of lee- Acti\ :ction tor pCi-sec ,n-3 131 r 2 X 1 U 1,400 990 2,400 600 1, 700 2,400 56, 000 490 510 P C P C P C P C P C P C P C P C P C J. ND 1.2 ND ND ND ND 1.9 ND ND ND 6.7 2.4 61 25 ND ND ND ND na pulse height rity (pCi/m3 ) at collection 1 32 j 1 33 J 1 ND ND ND 6.1 ND 6.0 ND ND ND ND ND 1.2 ND 12 ND ND ND ND 0.87 ND 5.6 16 7.9 11 ND 0.56 1.5 0.56 ND 6.8 70 74 0.86 ND 0. 50 ND analysis end of 35I ND ND ND 1.6 ND 23 ND 0.63 ND ND ND 3.0 ND ND ND ND ND ND ND - not detectable P - prefilter C - charcoal cartridge ------- Table 12. Analysis of milk samples collected following EP-4A. Location Lone Pine, Calif. Independence , California Zucco Ranch Big Pine, Calif. Date Collected 3/26-am 3/27-am 3/27-pm 3/28-am 3/28-pm 3/29-am 3/29-pm 3/30-pm 3/31-am 3/31-pm 4/01-am 4/02-am 4/03-am 4/04-am 4/11-am 3/29-pm 3/30 3/31-am 4/01-am 3/26-am 3/27 3/28-am 3/28-pm 3/29-am 3/30-am 3/30-pm 3/31-am A A\^O\^IAV^^ \S± Radioiodine in feed. X X -- ' X X X X X X X X -- -- X ND X X X ND X X ND -- -- ND ND ND ^-*u- i A.** i it* KS VAJ. u v* height analysis (pCi/liter) 1 31j 1 33 j ND 110 140 100 100 60 90 70 50 90 60 50 50 30 ND ND 20 ND ND ND 30 40 ND 20 ND 50 180 230 70 40 ND 30 ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND ND - not detectable x - radioiodine present -- - sample not collected 29 ------- in Figure 7. The 3 I level was observed to decay with a half-life of 4. 5 days, close to the 5 day value assumed by the Federal Radiation Council. 6. Vegetation Sampling Vegetation samples were taken on Highway 95 north and southeast of Beatty to determine a hot line and cloud profile at that distance. As seen in Figure 8, the peak occurred at 10 miles SE of Beatty, or 24 miles at 260° from Test Cell A. Vegetation samples, containing fresh fission products, other than the samples previously mentioned (milk results and Highway 95), were also obtained at Barstow, Inde- pendence (Loden Ranch), Olancha (Hayhorst Ranch), and Stovepipe Wells, California. Milk samples were not available from Stovepipe Wells, but milk from the other locations did not show the presence of fresh fission pro- ducts because the cows were not on fresh feed. 7. Thyroid In Vivo Counting Thyroid in vivo counting was performed on two ground moni- tors who were located on Highway 95 during cloud passage. In both cases the thyroid doses were negligible. 8. Water Water samples containing fresh fission products were obtained from Lone Pine and Olancha, California. The results are given in Table 13. The water was not used for human consumption. 30 ------- 300 200-- tf w H en 8 90- 10- 70- 60- 50-- 40-- 30-- 20-- 10- * * 25 MARCH 27 * * * 29 31 DATE 1 2 APRIL Figure 1. IODINE-131 IN MILK, LONE PINE, CALIFORNIA FOLLOWING NRX-A4/EST, 3/25/66, EP-4A. 31 ------- Figure 8 NATURAL VEGATATION SAMPLES ALONG HIGHWAY 95 HOT LINE AT 260" MONITOR'S THYROID DOSES-O.O-mRAD 864 MILES NORTH 202 BEATTY 468 . MILES 10 12 14 SOUTH 18 20 ------- Table 13. Water Results--NRX-A4/EST EP-4A pCi/liter Location Date 131I 132I Lone Pine, Calif. 3_2? Lone Pine Dairy Lone Pine Calif. ^ J5Q ?() 1 mi south o', ^-28 .HO ND Hay ho r si. Hancn 33 ------- CONCLUSIONS The effluent from four of the tests in the NRX-A4/EST series was detected off-site. The potential population doses were insignificant compared to the AEC Standards. The AEC radiation protection standards for the average dose to a suitable sample of population are : whole body radiation - 170 millirem/year thyroid exposures - 500 millirem/year The peak external gamma doses detected off-site from the various tests are given in Table 14. Table 14. Peak gamma doses detected off the test range complex for NRX-A4/EST. (Populated locations noted) Test EP-2B EP-2C EP-3 EP-4 EP-4A EP-4A Hwy. 95 Hwy. 93 Beatty, Location , 17 mi SE of Lathrop Wells between Glendale & Alamo Nevada (populated) 14 mi SE of Beatty on Hwy. 95 Dose or dose rate not detectable not detectable < 0. 01 mR/hr <0. 03 mR/hr < 0. ImR 17mR Table 15 gives the peak radioiodine levels as measured from the air samplers (prefilter and charcoal cartridge). Fresh fission products were detected off-site following all tests except EP-2C. (1) U.S. Atomic Energy Commission Manual Chapter 0524, Standards for Radiation Protection. 34 ------- Table 15. Peak iodine concentrations as measured by air samplers. Col- Iodine concentration Test EP-2B EP-3 EP-4 EP-4A Location Hiko, Nevada Jet. Ash Meadows Road and U S 95, Nevada Butler Ranch turnoff and U S 93, Nevada Lone Pine, Calif. lec- tor P C P C P C P C in pCi/m 3 (End of collection) 1 31j 1 3Zj 1 33j 1 35 i ND ND ND ND 25 ND 61 25 ND ND ND ND 75 ND ND 12 0. 18 ND 2.2 2.0 24 6.1 70 74 ND ND ND ND ND 7.9 ND ND Collection Time(hrs) 19.7 18. 5 2.2 23.8 ND - not detectable P - prefilter C - charcoal cartridge Assuming a person were present at the location where the iodine concen- trations in Table 15 were measured, the potential thyroid exposure from inhalation of radioiodine can be estimated (Appendix 1). These estimates are given in Table 16. It was assumed that the iodine from both the filter and charcoal cartridge was biologically avail- able to the thyroid. Table 16. Estimates of thyroid exposures from peak radioiodine air concentrations. _ T . Dose to thyroid in _ Test Location ,/?\ Total millirad v^/ 1 31j* 1 33j** EP-2B EP-3 EP-4 EP-4A Hiko, Nevada Jet. Ash Meadows Rd. and US 95, Nevada Butler Ranch turnoff and US 93, Nevada Lone Pine, Calif. ND ND <0. 1 2.52 < 0. 1 < 0. 1 < 0. 1 1. 14 < 0. 1 < 0. 1 < 0. 1 3. 7 (2) Based on ICRP "Standard Man", Publication 2(1959) 131 3.42 x 10"' millirad ><• Conversion factor for J I dose ~ :—^ -8 . . _ ••**.* 133 T j pCi-sec/mJ 9.21 x 10 millirad vv Conversion factor for JJI dose — -.—: pCi-sec/m A 35 ------- The potential exposures in Table 16 are less than 1% of the AEC standard for the thyroid exposure to a suitable sample of the popu- lation(500 millirern per year). Radioiodine was not detected in milk except for the EP-4A test (cows were not on fresh feed or green chop for the EP-4 test). The peak milk concentration for the EP-4A test occurred in Lone Pine, California (140 pCi/liter of 131I and 230 pCi/liter of 133I). The half-life in milk was observed to be about 4. 5 days or about that (3) assumed by the Federal Radiation Council. From data given in (3) FRC No. 5 Page 14, it is estimated that the thyroid dose to a child with a 2 gram thyroid would be 22 millirem(mrem) due to 3 I ingestion. The parameters for the FRC dose model for 131I in milk are generally based on average values. A refinement of the 13II cal- culation, based on specific information from the samples at Lone Pine, indicates a potential dose around 16 mrad from the 131I (peak occurred earlier than in FRC-model and effective half-life of 31I in milk was about 4. 5 versus 5 days). It should be noted that the estimated half-life was based on limited data, but it appears that the potential dose was less than that based on the FRC assumptions. An additional 3 millirern exposure could have resulted from ingestion of 133 I in milk, resulting in a total exposure about 19 mrem(based on parameters from event). Assuming the inhalation close to a child •r is about three times that of an adult , the inhalation dose would be about 11 mrem(from Table 16). Thus an estimate of the total poten- tial dose would be 30 mrem or about 6% of the AEC standard for a suitable sample of the population. Using the FRC assumptions the potential dose would have been about 7% of the AEC standard. (3) Background Material for the Development of Radiation Protection Standards, Federal Radiation Council Report No. 5, July 1964. * Based on child with 2 gram thyroid breathing 6 m3/day and other parameters equivalent to those of ICRP(Appendix 1). 36 ------- Appendix I Thyroid Dose Thyroid Dose (D) rads = f x 3> ? x 1Qio dis x g> ^ ^ J()4 sees curie-second a sec-curie day meter3 •00 x E x 1. 6 x 10~6 6r^S x B x — x -rrr ergs x \ e "' dt mev M 100 ^=^=- ) Te gram fa = fraction of inhaled iodine that reaches thyroid = . 23 E = energy to thyroid/disintegration = .23 mev 131I E = energy to thyroid/disintegration = . 54 mev I "~4 t B = breathing rate = 2. 32 x 10 m /second — = mass of thyroid = -r— grams m 20 Te = effective half-life = 7. 6 days 131 I Te = effective half-life = . 87 days 133I Rad = 1.97 x 102 x E x Te curie-sec -7 3.42 x 10 millirad curie-sec pCi-sec/M3 ( 131I) M3 Rad = 9.21 x 10"8 millirad ^^^"^^^^^^^^ — 7. t-J. A. A \j IIIJL J.XA i ena / curie-sec ^ T-J-JT ( r-T3— pCi-sec/M ------- DISTRIBUTION & 1 - 15 SWRHL, Las Vegas, Nevada 16 James E. Reeves, Manager, NVOO/AEC, Las Vegas, Nevada 17 Robert H. Thalgott, NVOO/AEC, Las Vegas, Nevada 18 Henry G. Vermillion, NVOO/AEC, Las Vegas, Nevada 1Q D. H. Edwards, Safety Evaluation, NVOO/AEC, Las Vegas, Nev. 20 D. W. Hendricks, Rad. Safe. Br., NVOO/AEC, Las Vegas, Nev. £1 Central Mail & Records, NVOO/AEC, Las Vegas, Nevada 22 A. J. Whitman, NTSSO, NVOO/AEC, Mercury, Nevada 23 - 24 R. Decker, SNPO, Washington, D. C. 25 D. Smith, SNPO-C, Cleveland, Ohio 26 - 27 J. P. Jewett, SNPO-N, Jackass Flats, Nevada 28 - 31 R. Nelson, SNPO-N, NRDS, Jackass Flats, Nevada 32 William C. King, LRL, Mercury, Nevada 33 Roger Batzel, LRL, Livermore, California 34 H. L. Reynolds, LRL, Livermore, California 35 - 36 H. T. Knight, LASL, Jackass Flats, Nevada 37 P. Gothels, LASL, Los Alamos, New Mexico 38 H. S. Jordan, LASL, Los Alamos, New Mexico 39 Charles I. Browne, LASL, Los Alamos, New Mexico 40 William E. Ogle, LASL, Los Alamos, New Mexico 41 H. G. Simens, NTO, Aerojet-General Corp., Jackass Flats, Nev. 42 G. Grandy, WANL, NRDS, Jackass Flats, Nevada 43-44 E. Hemmerle, WANL, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 45-46 S. Z. Mikhail, NRDL, San Francisco, California 47 - 48 M. I. Goldman, NUS, Washington, D. C. 49 - 50 J. Mohrbacher, Pan Am. World Airways, Jackass Flats, Nev, 51 P. Allen, ARL, ESSA, Las Vegas, Nevada ------- 52 H. Booth, ARL, ESSA, Las Vegas, Nevada 53 C. Anderson, EG&G, Las Vegas, Nevada 54 Byron Murphey, Sandia Corporation, Albuquerque, New Mexico 55 Brig. Gen. Edward B. Ciller, DMA, USAEC, Washington, D. C. 56 - 57 Chief, NOB/DASA, NVOO/AEC, Las Vegas, Nevada 58 - 62 Charles L. Weaver, USPHS, NCRH, Rockville, Md. 63 Victor M. Milligan, REECo, Mercury, Nevada 64 Nevada Southern University, Library, Las Vegas, Nevada 65 - 66 DTIE, USAEC, Oak Ridge, Tennessee ------- |