Technical Documentation
of the
Phase I Extension Reserve
Prepared for:
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
Office of Atmospheric and Indoor Air Programs
Washington, DC 20460
Prepared by:
ICF Resources Incorporated
May 1992
-------
Section 404(a)(2):
Not later than December 31,1991, the Administrator shall determine the total tonnage of reductions in the emissions of
sulfur dioxide from all utility units in calendar year 1995 that will occur as a result of compliance with the emissions
limitation requirements of this section, and shall establish a reserve of allowances equal in amount to the number of tons
determined thereby not to exceed a total of 3.50 million tons. In making such a determination, the Administrator shall
compute for each unit subject to the emissions limitation requirements of this section the difference between:
(A)the product of its baseline multiplied by the lesser of each unit's allowable 1985 emissions rate and its actual 1985
emissions rate, divided by 2,000, and
(B)the product of each unit's baseline multiplied by 2.50 Ibs/mmBtu divided by 2000, and sum the computations. The
Administrator shall adjust the foregoing calculation to reflect projected calendar year 1995 utilization of the units subject
to the emissions limitations of this title that the Administrator finds would have occurred in the absence of the imposition
of such requirements. Pursuant to subsection (d), the Administrator shall allocate allowances from the reserve established
heremunder until the earlier of such time as all such allowances in the reserve are allocated or December 31,1999.
Introduction
This report details the analysis of the size and calculation of the reserve established in
section 404(a)(2) of the Clean Air Act, as amended by the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990
(CAAA). The size of this reserve will determine the total amount of credits available to be used
by Phase I extension units as outlined in §404(d).
Note that the purpose of this analysis is not to estimate the demand for the reserve or
potential claims on and disbursement of the reserve, but simply to calculate the size of the
reserve to determine how much will be available for disbursement.
Summary of Findings
• As noted in the Act, the size of the Phase I reserve is limited to the lesser of 3.5
million tons or a series of calculated Phase I unit reductions.
• Using the procedure as outlined in §404(a)(2) and based on NADB Version 2.1,
the Phase I reserve will in fact equal the 3.5 million ton limit, since the calculated
Phase I unit reductions would exceed 3.5 million tons in all the cases evaluated.
Background on the Reserve Provision
Section 404(a)(2) establishes a reserve, which is defined to equal "the total tonnage of
reductions in the emissions of sulfur dioxide from all utility units in calendar year 1995 mat will
occur as a result of compliance with the emission limitation requirements of this section." This
reserve is created so that Phase I units which employ qualifying Phase I technology (i.e., those
that install retrofit scrubbers or other SO2 removal equipment achieving 90% or better removal
in Phase I) can become Phase I extension units and receive additional allowances. According
06C1082 Page 2
-------
summed over all Phase I affected units, but limited to 3.5 million tons, according to the
formula:
Equation (2)
,nnc r- r _i.f1985 Actual 1985
15*95 Fitfd x mm| en n^^. > en r<«4« I 1995 Fue/ x 23
2,000
2,000
The 1985 actual and allowable SO2 rates from the NADB V2.1 were used to estimate the
size of the reserve. This data has been extensively quality assured and confirmed, for the most
part, by the regulated community as accurate. Note that the use of 1985 actual and allowable
SO2 rates represents a conservative estimate of 1995 rates, and assumes that no additional
restrictions will be placed upon SO2 emissions, either through state or local action or through
the promulgation of PSD or NSPS regulations.
Comments received by EPA on the proposed core rules asserted that Phase n units may
be tempted to switch fuels during Phase I, using the Phase I unit's higher-sulfur content fuel,
which could result in excess emissions in Phase I. The commenters suggested that EPA consider
this potential fuel switching when calculating the size of the Phase I Extension Reserve.
However, this suggestion was not adopted for a number of reasons. First, such switching is
unlikely, given that boilers often are designed to burn only certain types of coal, precluding the
use of high-sulfur coals in boilers not designed for them. Furthermore, existing SO2 emissions
limits at Phase II units would prevent such units from freely switching to higher-sulfur fuels.
Second, EPA would have no way of knowing which units or how many foreseeably could swap
coal supplies in this manner. Finally, the Act specifies the equations by which the size of the
Reserve is calculated, as described above. The equations do not involve any reference to Phase
II unit emissions, or, contrary to comments, to actual Phase I unit emissions for 1995. Thus,
while EPA understands the purpose of the Extension Reserve, EPA does not agree with the
technical nature of these comments or that such coal "swapping" can be dealt with in the
calculation of the Phase I Extension Reserve. Accordingly, such "swapping" was not considered
in the calculations.
Calculation of the Reserve
As mentioned above, there is some uncertainty regarding the calculation of the size of
the reserve since the calculation relies on 1995 projected utilization for Phase I units. Table 1
below presents the results of the size of the Phase I reserve under several cases assuming
different levels of utilization, based on..data from NADB v2,l (more detailed unit by unit
information is presented in Attachments A, B, and C).
As Table 1 shows, the National Allowance Data Base version 2.1 (NADB) produces a
reserve equal to 3.5 million tons under all three cases. Case 1 is calculated from baseline fuel
060082 • • . - Page 4
-------
In summary, in every case, the calculated reductions exceed 3.5 million tons. Even under
a "worst case scenario", where NADB version 2.1 baseline fuel is used and no adjustments are
made for 1995 projected utilization, the reserve would still total more than 3.5 million tons.
06C1082 Page 6
-------
ATTACHMENT A- PHASE I RESERVE CALCULATIONS (THOUSAND TONS)
CASE 1:
1985 NADB Baseline
State
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
FLORIDA
FLORIDA
FLORIDA
FLORIDA
FLORIDA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
Plant
COLBERT
COLBERT
COLBERT
COLBERT
COLBERT
E C GASTON
E C GASTON
E C GASTON
E C GASTON
E C GASTON
BIG BEND
BIG BEND
BIG BEND
CRIST
CRIST
BOUEN
BOUEN
BOUEN
BOWEN
HAMMOND
HAMMOND
HAMMOND
HAMMOND
JACK MCOONOUGH
JACK MCDONOUGH
WANSLEY
WANSLEY
YATES
YATES
YATES
YATES
YATES
YATES
YATES
BALDWIN
BALDWIN
BALDWIN
COFFEEN
COFFEEN
GRAND TOWER
HENNEPIN
JOPPA STEAM
JOPPA STEAM
JOPPA STEAM
JOPPA STEAM '
JOPPA STEAM
JOPPA STEAM
KINCAID
KINCAID
MEREDOSIA
VERMILION
BAILLY
BAILLY
BREED
CAYUGA
CAYUGA
CLIFTY CREEK
CLIFTY CREEK
CLIFTY CREEK
CLIfTY CREEK
CLIFTY CREEK
CLIFTY CREEK
ELMER W STOUT
ELMER U STOUT
ELMER W STOUT
F B CULLEY
F B CULLEY
FRANK E RATTS
FRANK E RATTS
GIBSON
GIBSON
GIBSON
GIBSON
H T PRITCHARD
MICHIGAN CITY
PETERSBURG
PETERSBURG
R GALLAGHER
R GALLAGHER
BLR
1
2
3
4
5
1
3
4
5
BB01
BB02
BB03
6
7
1BLR
2BLR
3BLR
4BLR
1
2
3
4
MB1
MB2
1
2
Y1BR
Y2BR
Y3BR
Y4BR
Y5BR
Y6BR
Y7BR
1
2
3
01
02
09
2
1
2
3
4
5
6
1
2
05
2
7
8
1
1
2
1
2
3
4
5
6
50
60
70
2
3
1SG1
2SG1
1
2
3
4
6
12
2
1
2
GEN
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
F4
1
ST2
ST3
6
7
2
3
4
1
2
3
4
2
j
2
2
3
4
5
6
7
1
2
3
1
2
4
2
1
2
3
4
5
6
1
2
3
2
7
8
1
1
2
1
2
3
4
5
6
5
6
7
2
3
1
2
1
2
3
4
6
12
ST1
ST2
1
2
1985
RATE
3.8348
3.8352
3.8348
3.8324
3.816
2.7234
2.7235
2.7235
2.7235
2.7578
4.7513
4.7803
3.3348
4.5301
4.5118
3.0225
i'ofli
3.0225
2.6164
2.6161
2.6161
2.6163
3.9602
3.9722
4.5914
4.5914
3.6889
3.6887
3.6888
3.6889
3.6888
3.6888
3.6888
5.221
5.2186
5.2186
6.7713
6.8505
4.6036
5.2461
3.3316
3.3099
3.3243
3.3273
3.3302
3.3113
6.4153
6.491
4.6601
4.8057
5.5007
5.4372
7.2618
4.5025
4.5046
5.6079
5.6097
5.6052
5.61
5.6116
5.6103
3.3679
3.3782
3.3778
5.6761
5.6748
5.1699
5.1699
4.4881
4.4902
4.4841
4.4835
3.7899
5.1254
3.8922
3.8965
5.4015
5.4187
ANN.
LIMIT
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.68
3.68
3.68
3.68
3.68
5.785
5.785
5.785
5.251
5.251
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
5.34
5.34
5.34
11.82
11.82
5.34
5.162
3.204
3.204
3.204
3.204
3.204
3.204
17.08
17.08
8.81
5.34
5.76
5.76
9.1872
5.5968
5.5968
7.2192
7.2192
7.2192
7.2192
7.2192
7.2192
5.088
5.088
5.088
5.76
5.76
5.76
5.76
4.896
4.896
4.896
4.896
5.76
5.088
5.76
5.76
5.76
5.76
1985
ADJUSTED
BASELINE f
10.859
12.246
12.322
12.331
29.744
14.479
14.833
14.648
15.423
47.874
22.557
22.516
20.869
15.363
22.529
43.814
45.060
57.403
57.390
7.025
7.373
7.129
30.113
15.927
16.483
56.616
52.341
5.766
5.631
5.561
7.130
7.525
19.809
19.485
33.608
35.533
34.042
9.434
28.532
4.725
14.729
10.070
8.614
9.814
9.090
9.132
8.493
25.224
27.793
11.114
7.106
8.925
12.746
14.796
26.696
27.300
16.122
15.852
16.329
16.063
15.487
16.301
3.107
3.818
18.886
3.263
13.576
6.667.
6.788
32.317
32.805
32.861
32.258
4.614
18.649
13.148
25.906
5.396
5.823
BASELINE
X MIN OF I
tATE.LIHIT
19.328
21.799
21.933
21.950
52.944
19.715
20.198
19.946
21.003
66.014
53.586
53.816
34.798
34.798
50.822
66.213
68.096
86.751
86.731
9.190
9.645
9.325
39.392
31.538
32.736
125.466
115.992
10.635
10.386
10.257
13.150
13.879
36.536
35.937
87.733
92.715
88.825
31.940
97.731
10.875
38.015
16.132
13.799
15.722
14.562
14.630
13.606
80.909
90.203
25.896
17.076
24.548
34.651
53.724
60.099
61.488
45.206
44.461
45.764
45.057
43.454
5*232
6*449
31 .896
9.261
38.522
. 17.233
17.545
72.520
731677
72.315
. 8.744
47.442
25.587
50.472
14.573
15.777
MSELINE (
x 2.5
13.573
15.308
15.403
15.414
37.179
18.098
18.541
18.309
19.279
59.843
28.196
28.145
26.087
19.204
28.161
54.767
56.325
71.754
71.738
8.782
9.217
8.911
37.641
19.909
20.603
70.770
65.426
7.207
7.039
6.952
8.912
9.406
24.761
24.356
42.010
44.416
42.552
11.792
35.666
5.906
18.411
12.587
10.767
12.268
11.363
11.415
10.617
31.530
34.742
13.892
8.883
11.157
15.933
18.495
33.370
34.125
20.153
19.814
20.411
.20.079
19.359
20.377
3.884
4.773
23.607
4.079
16.971
8.333
8.484
40.396
41.006
41.077
40.323
5.768
23.311
16.435
32.383
6.745
7.279
CASE 1:
(ATE/LIMIT-2.5
X BASELINE
5.755
6.491
6.531
6.536
15.764
1.617
1.658
1.637
1.724
6.171
25.391
25.671
8.711
15.594
22.662
11.446
11.772
14.997
14.993
0.409
0.428
0.414
1.751
11.629
12.133
54.697
50.566
3.427
3.347
3.306
4.238
4.473
11.775
11.582
45.723
48.299
46.273
20.148
62.065
4.969
19.604
3.545
3.032
3.455
3.200
3.215
2.990
49.379
55.462
12.003
8.193
13.391
18.719
35.228
26.729
27.363
25.053
24.647
25.352
24.978
24.095
25.351
1.348
1.677
8.289
5.182
21.551
8.900
9.061
32.124
P. 644
.600
.992
2.976
24.131
9.152
18*089
7.828
8.498
FILE:PHASE1.WK3
PAGE A-1
-------
ATTACHMENT A— PHASE I RESERVE CALCULATIONS (THOUSAND TONS)
CASE 1:
1985 NADB Baseline
State
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
Plant
CONESVILLE
CONESVILLE
CONESVILLE
CONESVILLE
EASTLAKE
EASTLAKE
EASTLAKE
EASTLAKE
EASTLAKE
EDGEWATER
GEN J M GAVIN
GEN J M GAVIN
KYGER CREEK
KYGER CREEK
KYGER CREEK
KYGER CREEK
KYGER CREEK
MIAMI FORT
MIAMI FORT
MIAMI FORT
MIAMI FORT
MUSKINGUM RIVER
MUSKINGUM RIVER
MUSKINGUM RIVER
MUSKINGUM RIVER
MUSKINGUM RIVER
NILES
NILES
PICWAY
R E BURGER
R E BURGER
R E BURGER
R E BURGER
W H SAMMIS
W H SAMMIS
W H SAMMIS
WALTER C BECKJORD
WALTER C BECKJORD
ARMSTRONG
ARMSTRONG
BRUNNER ISLAND
BRUNNER ISLAND
BRUNNER ISLAND
CHESWICK
CONEMAUGH
CONEMAUGH
HATFIELD'S FERRY
HATFIELD'S FERRY
HATFIELD'S FERRY
MARTINS CREEK
MARTINS CREEK
PORTLAND
PORTLAND
SHAWVILLE
SHAWVILLE
SHAWVILLE
SHAWVILLE
SUNBURY
SUNBURY
SUNBURY
SUNBURY
SUNBURY
SUNBURY
ALLEN
ALLEN
ALLEN
CUMBERLAND
CUMBERLAND
GALLATIN
GALLATIN
GALLATIN
GALLATIN
JOHNSONVILLE
JOHNSONVILLE
JOHNSONVILLE
JOHNSONVILLE
JOHNSONVILLE
JOHNSONVILLE
JOHNSONVILLE
BLR
1
3
4
1
2
4
5
13
1
2
1
2
3
4
5
5-1
5-2
6
7
2
3
4
5
1
2
9
5
6
7
8
5
6
7
5
6
1
2
1
2
3
1
1
1
2
3
1
2
1
2
1
2
3
4
1A
1B
2A
2B
3
4
1
2
3
1
2
1
2
3
4
1
10
2
3
4
6
GEN
1
3
4
2
4
5
4
1
2
1
2
3
5
5
6
7
2
3
5
1
2
3
3
4
5
5
6
7
5
6
1
2
1
2
3
1
1
1
2
3
1
2
1
^
2
3
4
3
3
3
3
4
1
3
1
2
1
2
3
4
1
10
2
3
4
6
1985
RATE
4.7281
4.7287
4.7284
4.875
4.7796
4.7806
4.7815
4.7937
4.8324
2.6159
6.0173
6.0365
5.7582
5.7594
5.7567
5.7583
5.7568
3.9605
4.1054
3.0054
0
7.5259
7.5266
7.5196
7.5183
7.4022
5.1714
6)2045
5.0273
5.0336
5.1885
5.2056
3.4911
3.4937
3.64
4.1367
4.1192
2.812
2.8126
2.7682
2.7682
2.7682
2.5869
3.5331
3.5456
3.3774
3.3837
3.3808
2.7175
2.7175
2.9801
2.9366
3.1918
3.1751
3.169
3.164
2.7482
2.7481
2.5662
2.5662
2.5662
2.5662
3.5442
3.6278
3.5827
4.7087
4.7325
4.3909
4.3254
4.3701
4.3738
3.023
3.0122
3.005
3.0216
3.0063
2.9749
2.9691
ANN.
LIMIT
5.4336
5.4336
5.4336
5.4336
5.4144
5.4144
5.4144
5.4144
5.4144
3.264
7.1136
7.1136
7.872
7.872
7.872
7.872
7.872
4.8
5.28
4.8
4.8
6.2016
6.2016
6.2016
6.2016
6.2016
5 472
9)504
8.6592
8.6592
8.6592
8.6592
4.2816
4.2816
4.2816
6.8928
6.8928
3.552
3.552
3.56
3.56
3.56
2.492
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3 56
3)56
3.56
3.56
3:8
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3 56
4.45
4.45
4.45
4.45
4.45
4.45
3.026
3.026
3.026
3.026
3.026
3.026
3.026
1985
ADJUSTED
BASELINE
sTsii"
3.915
4.396
39.016
6.243
6.909
8.014
11.610
30.806
4.043
63.261
64.446
15.427
14.849
14.328
14.968
14.995
9.107
30.809
0.265
0.265
11.901
11.334
11.163
9.421
32.372
5.555
7.279
3.947
2.465
2.457
8.623
9.945
19.333
37.017
34.579
7.157
18.413
11.530
12.345
22.210
24.883
43.059
31.334
48.124
53.342
30.262
29.859
32.215
10.125
10.257
4.751
8 217
8)266
11.339
11.262
3.079
9.740
1.400
1.399
1.400
1.400
12.258
13.415
12.533
69.360
75.872
14.108
13.847
16.018
17.006
6.231
6.429
6.729
6.388
6.589
6.315
7.182
BASELINE
X MIN OF
RATE, LIMIT
7.957
9.257
10.394
95.103
14.920
16.516
19.158
27.827
74.432
5.288
190.330
194.514
44.417
42.761
41.241
43.095
43.162
18.034
63.242
0.399
0.000
36.901
35.143
34.613
29.213
100.379
14.364
18.882
12.244
6.197
6.185
22.369
25.884
33.747
64.664
62.934
14.803
37.924
16.211
17.361
30.741
34.440
59.599
39.042
85.013
94.565
51.103
50.517
54.456
13.758
13.936
7.079
13 113
13)123
17.966
17.817
4.231
13.384
1.796
1.796
1.796
1.796
21.723
23.879
22.309
154.325
• 168.815
30.973
29.946
35.000
37.191
9.418
9.683
10.110
9.651
m
10.662
BASELINE
x 2.5
4.207
4.894
5.495
48.771
7.804
8.637
10.017
14.512
38.507
5.054
79.076
80.558
19.284
18.561
17.910
18.710
18.744
11.384
38.511
0.332
0.332
14.876
14.167
13.953
11.776
40.465
6.944
9.098
4.934
3.081
3.072
10.778
12.431
24.166
46.272
43.224
8.946
23.017
14.412
15.432
27.762
31.103
53.824
39.168
60.155
66.678
37.827
37.323
40.268
12.656
12.821
5.938
10.235
10.271
10.333
14.174
14.078
3.849
12.176
1.750
1.749
1.750
1.750
15.323
16.769
15.666
86.699
94.840
17.635
17.308
20.023
21.258
7.789
8.036
8.411
7.985
8.237
7.894
8.977
CASE 1:
RATE/LIMIT-2.5
x BASELINE
3.750
4.363
4.898
46.332
7.116
7.879
9.141
13.315
35.925
0.234
111.254
113.957
25.133
24.200
23.331
24.385
24.418
6.650
24.730
0.067
-0.332
22.026
20.976
20.660
17.437
59.914
7.420
9.784
7.311
3.115
3.113
11.591
13.453
9.581
18.392
19.710
5.857
14.907
1.799
1.930
2.978
3.337
5.774
-0.125
24.858
27.887
13.276
13.193
14.187
1.101
1.115
1.140
1.787
2.842
2.790
3.793
3.739
0.382
1.208
0.046
0.046
0.046
0.046
6.400
7.110
6.643
67.626
73.975
13.338
12.638
14.978
15.933
1.629
1.646
1.699
1.666
1.668
. 1.500
1.684
FILE:PHASE1.WK3
PAGE A-3
-------
Attachment B:
Phase I Reserve Calculations
1995 Utilization - EPA High Base Case
06C1082
-------
ATTACHMENT B — PHASE I RESERVE CALCULATIONSCTHOUSAND TONS)
CASE 2:
1995 EPA HIGH BASE CASE
State
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
IOWA
IOWA
IOWA
IOWA
IOWA
IOWA
KANSAS
KENTUCKY
KENTUCKY
KENTUCKY
KENTUCKY
KENTUCKY
KENTUCKY
KENTUCKY
KENTUCKY
KENTUCKY
KENTUCKY
KENTUCKY
KENTUCKY
KENTUCKY
KENTUCKY
KENTUCKY
KENTUCKY
KENTUCKY
MARYLAND
MARYLAND
MARYLAND
MARYLAND
MARYLAND
MARYLAND
MICHIGAN
MICHIGAN
MINNESOTA
MISSISSIPPI
MISSISSIPPI
MISSOURI
MISSOURI
MISSOURI
MISSOURI
MISSOURI
MISSOURI
MISSOURI
MISSOURI
MISSOURI
MISSOURI
MISSOURI
MISSOURI
MISSOURI
MISSOURI
MISSOURI
MISSOURI
NEW HAMPSHIRE
NEW HAMPSHIRE
NEW JERSEY
NEW JERSEY
NEW YORK
NEW YORK
NEW YORK
NEW YORK
NEW YORK
NEW YORK
NEW YORK
NEW YORK
NEW YORK
NEW YORK
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
Plant
R GALLAGHER
R GALLAGHER
TANNERS CREEK
WABASH RIVER
WABASH RIVER
WABASH RIVER
WABASH RIVER
WABASH RIVER
UARRICK
BURLINGTON
DES MOINES
GEORGE NEAL
MILTON L KAPP
PRAIRIE CREEK
RIVERSIDE
QUINDARO
COLEMAN
COLEMAN
COLEMAN
COOPER
COOPER
E W BROWN
E W BROWN
E W BROWN
ELMER SMITH
ELMER SMITH
GHENT
GREEN RIVER
H L SPURLOCK
HMP&L STATION 2
HMP&L STATION 2
PARADISE
SHAWNEE
C P CRANE
C P CRANE
CHALK POINT
CHALK POINT
MORGANTOWN
MORGANTOWN
J H CAMPBELL
J H CAMPBELL
HIGH BRIDGE
JACK WATSON
JACK WATSON
ASBURY
JAMES RIVER
LABADIE
LABADIE
LABADIE
LABADIE
MONTROSE
MONTROSE
MONTROSE
NEW MADRID
NEW MADRID
SIBLEY
SIOUX
SIOUX
THOMAS HILL
THOMAS HILL
MERRIMACK
MERRIMACK
B L ENGLAND
B L ENGLAND
DUNKIRK
DUNKIRK
GREENIDGE
MILLIKEN
MILLIKEN
NORTHPORT
NORTHPORT
NORTHPORT
PORT JEFFERSON
PORT JEFFERSON
ASHTABULA
AVON LAKE
AVON LAKE
CARDINAL
CARDINAL
BLR
3
4
U4
1
2
5
6
4
1
11
1
2
4
9
2
C1
C2
C3
1
2
1
2
3
1
2
5
1
N1
H2
3
10
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
12
4
5
1
5
1
2
3
4
1
2
3
1
2
3
1
2
MB1
MB2
1
2
1
2
3
4
6
1
2
1
2
3
3
4
7
11
12
2
GEN
3
4
1
2
3
6
4
1
7
1
2
5
ST2
1
3
1
2
1
3
1
2
4
1
1
2
3
10
1
2
ST1
ST2
ST1
ST2
1
2
6
4
5
1
5
1
2
3
4
1
2
3
1
2
3
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
3
ST4
4
1
2
ST1
2
3
3
4
5
8
9
2
1985
• RATE
5.4199
5.4269
5.6091
3.7661
3.7713
3.764
3.7744
3.7857
5.8668
4.8274
3.5802
2.9635
5.2991
3.9545
4.4999
4.2728
3.8024
3.7305
3.783
2.7418
2.7846
3.201
3.2012
3.2012
5.1412
5.2396
5.4423
3.5776
3.4829
4.1466
4.1464
4.7975
6.0228
3.1018
3.0964
2.4985
2.5413
2.6631
2.6311
3.5048
3.5032
2.5571
3.4701
3.29
10.1751
5.8773
4.3282
4.3329
4.3354
4.3132
8.6342
8.4137
8.4834
5.9262
6.0171
5.7098
4.5865
4.5744
7.5541
7.5374
3.5719
3.5824
3.8979
4.043
3.0689
3.0136
3.2948
3.0288
3.0167
2i6451
2.6579
2.6505
2.6994
6.6461
4.0299
1995 EPA HIG BASELINE
ANN. BASE CASE X MIN OF
LIMIT BASELINE RATE, LIMIT
5.76
5.76
7.968
3.8784
3.8784
3.8784
3.8784
3.8784
5.76
5.34
4.45
5.34
5.34
5.34
2.67
4.628
4.628
4.628
2.937
2.937
5.34
5.34
5.34
5.34
5.34
5.0463
4.0673
5 34
4.628
4.628
5.073
1.116
3.115
3.115
3.115
3.115
3.115
3.115
4.3432
4.3432
2.88
4.272
4.272
10.68
8.188
4.272
4.272
4.272
4.272
11.481
11.481
11.481
8.9
8.9
8.01
4.272
4.272
7.12
7.12
4
4
5.5776
5.5776
3.8
3.8
3.8
3.8
3.8
2.996
2.996
2.996
2.996
2.996
8.736
4.464
4.464
6.7968
6.7968
9.7
9.7
28.2
4.1
4.1
4.1
4.5
15.2
14.3
10.6
1.5
1.0
7.7
1.9
6.0
7.5
7.6
7.6
7.9
8.0
15.4
5.8
8.6
21.3
7.7
13.4
27.2
4.2
19.8
7.9
8.2
53.6
4.4
11.8
11.8
22.2
22.2
32.2
32.2
16.0
17.8
11.3
13.4
29.4
15.3
5.8
33.4
33.4
33.4
33.4
11.9
11.9
11.9
37.2
37.2
23.8
28.0
28.0
11.5
18.6
6.7
19.1
7.9
9.8
10.6
10.3
. 7.1
10.7
10.8
27.4
27.4
27.6
13.9
14.0
15.0
0.0
30.4
32.4
32.7
26.287
26.320
79.088
7.721
7.731
7.716
8.492
28.771
41.184
25.585
2.685
1.482
20.402
3.757
13.500
10.013
14.449
14.176
14.943
10.967
21.441
9.283
13.765
34.093
19.794
35.105
•MS
34.481
16.379
17.000
128.573
2.455
18.301
18.269
27.733
28.208
42.876
42.361
28.038
31.178
14.448
23.250
48.363
77.840
17.044
71.342
71.342
71.342
71.342
51.373
50.062
50.476
110.227
111.918
67.947
59.808
59.808
40.940
66.216
11.966
34.212
15.397
19.811
16.265
15.520
11.697
16.204
16.290
36.391
36.238
36.679
18.421
18.896
49.846
0.000
61 .502
86.456
86.204
CASE 2:
BASELINE RATE/LIMIT-2.5
X 2.5 x BASELINE
12.125 14.162
12.125
35.250
5.125
5.125
5.125
5.625
19.000
17.875
13.250
1.875
1.250
9.625
2.375
7.500
9.375
9.500
9.500
9.875
10.000
19.250
7.250
10.750
26.625
9.625
16.750
34.000
5.250
24.750
9.875
10.250
67.000
5.500
14.750
14.750
27.750
27.750
40.250
40.250
20.000
22.250
14.125
16.750
36.750
19.125
7.250
41.750
41.750
41.750
41.750
14.875
14.875
14.875
46.500
46.500
29.750
35.000
35.000
14.375
23.250
8.375
23.875
9.875
12.250
13.250
12.875
8.875
13.375
13.500
34.250
34.250
34.500
17.375
17.500
18.750
0.000
38.000
40.500
40.875
14.195
43.838
2.596
2.606
2.591
2.867
9.771 .
23.309
12.335
0.810
0.232
10.777
1.382
6.000
0.638
4.949
4.676
5.068
0.967
2.191
2.033
3.015
7.468
10.169
18.355
34.630
2.263
9.731
6.504
6.750
61.573
-3.045
3.551
3.519
-0.017
0.458
2.626
2.111
8.038
8.928
0.323
6.500
11.613
58.715
9.794
29.592
29.592
29.592
29.592
36.498
35.187
35.601
63.727
65.418
38.197
24.808
24.808
26.565
42.966
3.591
10.337
5.522
7.561
3.015
2.645
2.822
2.829
2.790
2.141
1.988
2.179
1.046
1.396
o.ooo
23.502
45.956
45.329
FILE: PHASE1.WK3
PAGE B-2
-------
ATTACHMENT B — PHASE I RESERVE CALCULATIONS(THOUSAND TONS)
CASE 2:
1995 EPA HIGH BASE CASE
State
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
WEST VIRGINIA
WEST VIRGINIA
WEST VIRGINIA
WEST VIRGINIA
WEST VIRGINIA
WEST VIRGINIA
WEST VIRGINIA
WEST VIRGINIA
WEST VIRGINIA
WEST VIRGINIA
WEST VIRGINIA
WEST VIRGINIA
WEST VIRGINIA
WEST VIRGINIA
WISCONSIN
WISCONSIN
WISCONSIN
WISCONSIN
WISCONSIN
WISCONSIN
WISCONSIN
WISCONSIN
WISCONSIN
WISCONSIN
WISCONSIN
WISCONSIN
WISCONSIN
Plant
JOHNSONVILLE
JOHNSONVILLE
JOHNSONVILLE
ALBRIGHT
FORT MARTIN
FORT MARTIN
HARRISON
HARRISON
HARRISON
RAMMER
KAMMER
RAMMER
MITCHELL
MITCHELL
MT STORM
MT STORM
MT STORM
EDGEWATER
GENOA
NELSON DEWEY
NELSON DEWEY
NORTH OAK CREEK
NORTH OAK CREEK
NORTH OAK CREEK
NORTH OAK CREEK
PULL I AM
SOUTH OAK CREEK
SOUTH OAK CREEK
SOUTH OAK CREEK
SOUTH OAK CREEK
BLR
7
8
9
3
1
2
1
2
3
1
2
3
1
2
1
2
3
B1
1
2
1
3
4
8
5
6
7
8
GEN
7
8
9
3
1
2
1
2
^
2
3
1
2
1
4
ST3
1
2
2
3
4
8
5
6
7
8
1985
RATE
2.9806
2.9558
3.0184
3.2217
2.808
2.808
4.35
4.35
4.35
7.5126
7.5136
7.5132
2.6007
2.6021
2.8669
2.866
2.856
4.2714
3.9697
4.6204
4.8344
3.7951
3.9127
3.8921
3.8806
3.9001
3.9038
3.7652
3.9218
3.9044
1995 EPA HIG BASELINE
ANN. BASE CASE x MIN OF
LIMIT BASELINE RATE, LIMIT
3.026
3.026
3.026
2.848
2.759
2.759
4.5568
4.5568
4.5568
7.89
7.89
7.89
12
12
4.097
4.097
*«RS
99.9
99.9
99.9
99.9
99.9
99.9
99.9
99.9
99.9
99.9
9r«9
Vy«y
5.7
5.7
5.7
9.4
33.8
37iO
37.0
37.0
12.2
12.2
12.2
47.0
47.0
34 5
34!5
34.0
15.9
19.3
5.9
5.7
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
6.5
11.4
11.4
13.6
13.6
8.495
8.424
8.602
13.386
46.627
46.903
80.475
80.475
80.475
45.827
45.833
45.831
61.116
61.149
49.454
49.439
31:11!
38.308
13.630
13.778
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
12.675
22.252
21.462
26.668
26.550
CASE 2:
BASELINE RATE/LIMIT-2.5
x 2.5 X BASELINE
7.125
7.125
7.125
11.750
42.250
42.500
46.250
46.250
46.250
15.250
15.250
15.250
58.750
58.750
43.125
43.125
42.500
19.875
24.125
7.375
7.125
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
8.125
14.250
14.250
17.000
17.000
1.370
1.299
1.477
1.636
4.377
4.403
34.225
34.225
34.225
30.577
30.583
30.581
2.366
2.399
6.329
6.314
6.052
14.083
14.183
6.255
6.653
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
4.550
8.002
7.212
9.668
9.550
TOTALS: 4,610.20 9,634.65 5,762.75 3,871.90
FILE: PHASE1.WK3
PAGE B-4
-------
ATTACHMENT C — PHASE I RESERVE CALCULATIONSUHOUSAND TONS)
CASE 3-
1995 EPA LOU BASE CASE
State
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
ALABAMA
FLORIDA
FLORIDA
FLORIDA
FLORIDA
FLORIDA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
GEORGIA
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA °
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
INDIANA
Plant
COLBERT
COLBERT
COLBERT
COLBERT
COLBERT
E C GASTON
E C GASTON
E C GASTON
E C GASTON
E C GASTON
BIG BEND
BIG BEND
BIG BEND
CRIST
CRIST
BOUEN
BOUEN
BOUEN
BOUEN
HAMMOND
HAMMOND
HAMMOND
HAMMOND
JACK MCDONOUGH
JACK MCDONOUGH
UANSLEY
UANSLEY
YATES
YATES
YATES
YATES
YATES
YATES
YATES
BALDUIN
BALDUIN
BALDUIN
COFFEEN
COFFEEN
GRAND TOWER
HENNEPIN
JOPPA STEAM
JOPPA STEAM
JOPPA STEAM
JOPPA STEAM
JOPPA STEAM
JOPPA STEAM
KINCAID
KINCAID
MEREDOSIA
VERMILION
BAILLY
BAILLY
BREED
CAYUGA
CAYUGA
CLIFTY CREEK
CLIFTY CREEK
CLIFTY CREEK
CLIFTY CREEK
CLIFTY CREEK
CLIFTY CREEK
ELMER U STOUT
ELMER U STOUT
ELMER U STOUT
F B CULLEY
F B CULLEY
FRANK E RATTS
FRANK E RATTS
GIBSON
GIBSON
GIBSON
GIBSON
H T PRITCHARD
MICHIGAN CITY
PETERSBURG
• PETERSBURG
R GALLAGHER
R GALLAGHER
BLR
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
BB01
BB02
BB03
6
7
1BLR
2BLR
3BLR
4BLR
1
3
4
MB1
MB2
2
Y1BR
Y2BR
Y3BR
Y4BR
Y5BR
Y6BR
Y7BR
1
2
Si
02
09
2
2
3
4
5
6
1
2
05
2
7
8
1
1
2
1
3
4
5
6
50
60
70
2
3
1SG1
2SG1
1
2
3
4
6
12
1
1
2
GEN
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
ST4
5
1
ST2
ST3
6
7
1
2
3
4
1
2
3
4
1
2
2
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
1
2
1
2
4
2
1
2
3
4
5
6
1
2
3
2
7
2
1
3
4
5
6
5
6
7
2
3
1
2
1
3
4
6
12
ST1
ST2
1
2
1985
RATE
3.8348
3.8352
3.8348
3.8324
3.816
2.7234
2.7235
2.7235
2.7235
2.7578
4.7513
4.7803
3.3348
4.5301
4.5118
3.0225
3.0225
3.0225
3.0225
2.6164
2.6161
2.6161
2.6163
3.9602
1381
4.5914
3.6889
3.6887
3.6888
3.6889
3.6888
3.6888
3.6888
5.221
5.2186
im
6.8505
4.6036
5.2461
3.3316
3.3099
3.3243
3.3273
3.3302
3.3113
6.4153
6.491
4.6601
4.8057
5.5007
5.4372
7.2618
4.5025
4.5046
5.6079
5.6097
5.6052
5.61
5.6116
5.6103
3.3679
3.3782
3.3778
5.6761
5.6748
5.1699
5.1699
4.4881
4.4902
4.4841
4.4835
3.7899
5.1254
318965
5.4015
5.4187
1995 EPA LOU BASELINE
ANN. BASE CASE X MIN OF
LIMIT BASELINE RATE, LIMIT
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.68
3.68
3.68
3.68
3.68
5.785
5.785
5.785
5.251
5.251
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
4.4322
5.34
5.34
5.34
11.82
11.82
5.34
5.162
3.204
3.204
3.204
3.204
3.204
3.204
17.08
17.08
8.81
5.34
5.76
5.76
9.1872
5.5968
5.5968
7.2192
7.2192
7.2192
7.2192
7.2192
7.2192
5.088
5.088
5.088
5.76
5.76
5.76
5.76
4.896
. 4.896
4.896
4.896
5.76
1:76
5.76
5.76
12.9
12.9
12.9
12.9
30.2
13.2
13.2
13.2
11.9
44.0
21.4
21.4
21.4
17.5
26.3
42.0
41.9
52.5
52.5
5.6
5.6
5.4
20.5
14.9
14.9
50.9
50.9
5.6
5.8
5.8
7.2
7.2
18.3
18.3
27.6
27.6
27.6
14.8
23.8
5.1
10.7
7.5
7.5
7.5
7.5
7.5
7.5
30.6
30.6
10.7
5.2
6.5
13.0
22.9
16.0
15.6
14.6
14.6
14.5
15.4
14.8
14.8
6.8
6.8
28.2
3.0
. 7.9
3.8
3.8
31.7
31.7
31.7
31.7
3.1
28.1
16.1
28.9
9.7
9.7
22.962
22.962
22.962
22.962
53.756
17.974
17.975
17.975
16.205
60.672
50.839
51.149
35.682
39.638
59.330
63.473
63.321
79.341
79.341
7.326
7.325
7.063
26.817
29.503
29.593
112.799
112.799
10.329
10.697
10.698
13.280
13.280
33.753
33.753
72.050
72.017
72.017
50.108
81.521
11.739
27.617
12.015
12.015
12.015
12.015
121015
12.015
98.154
99.312
24.932
12.495
17.877
35.342
83.148
36.020
35.136
40.938
40.951
40.638
43.197
41.526
41.516
11.451
11.486
47.627
8.514
22.415
9.823
9.823
71.136
71.170
71.073
71.063
5.874
71.486
31.332
56.304
26.197
26.281
CASE 3:
BASELINE RATE/LIMIT-2.5
x 2.5 x BASELINE
16.125
16.125
16.125
16.125
37.750
16.500
16.500
16.500
14.875
55.000
26.750
26.750
26.750
21.875
32.875
52.500
52.375
65.625
65.625
7.000
7.000
6.750
25.625
18.625
18.625
63.625
63.625
7.000
7.250
7.250
9.000
9.000
22.875
22.875
34.500
34.500
34.500
18.500
29.750
6.375
13.375
9.375
9.375
9.375
9.375
9.375
9.375
38.250
38.250
13.375
6.500
8.125
16.250
28.625
20.000
19.500
18.250
18.250
18.125
19.250
18.500
18.500
8.500
8.500
35.250
3.750
9.875
4.750
4.750
39.625
39.625
39.625
39.625
3.875
35.125
20.125
36.125
12.125
12.125
6.837
6.837
6.837
6.837
16.006
1.474
1.475
1.475
1.330
5.672
24.089
24.399
8.932
17.763
26.455
10.973
10.946
13.716
13.716
0.326
0.325
0.313
1.192
10.878
10.968
49.174
49.174
3.329
3.447
3.448
4.280
4.280
10.878
10.878
37.550
37.517
37.517
31 .608
51.771
5.364
14.242
2.640
2.640
2.640
2.640
2.640
2.640
59.904
61.062
11.557
5.995
9.752
19.092
54.523
16.020
15.636
22.688
22.701
22.513
23.947
e.026
.016
2.951
2.986
12.377
4.764
12.540
5.073
5.073
31.511
31.545
31.448
31.438
1.999
36.361
11.207
20.179
14.072
14.156
FILE: PHA5ET.UK3
PAGE C-1
-------
ATTACHMENT C — PHASE I RESERVE CALCULATIONS(THOUSANO TONS)
CASE 3:
1995 EPA LOU BASE CASE
State
S^—SS SS B SS SSSS
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
OHIO
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
PENNSYLVANIA
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
TENNESSEE
Plant
CONESVILLE
CONESVILLE
CONESVILLE
CONESVILLE
EASTLAKE
EASTLAKE
EASTLAKE
EASTLAKE
EASTLAKE
EDGEUATER
GEN J M GAVIN
GEN J N GAVIN
KYGER CREEK
KYGER CREEK
KYGER CREEK
KYGER CREEK
KYGER CREEK
MIAMI FORT
MIAMI FORT
MIAMI FORT
MIAMI FORT
MUSKINGUM RIVER
MUSKINGUM RIVER
MUSKINGUM RIVER
MUSKINGUM RIVER
MUSKINGUM RIVER
NILES
MILES
PICUAY
R E BURGER
R E BURGER
R E BURGER
R E BURGER
U H SAMMIS
U H SAMMIS
W H SAMMIS
WALTER C BECKJORD
WALTER C BECKJORD
ARMSTRONG
ARMSTRONG
BRUNNER ISLAND
BRUNNER ISLAND
BRUNNER ISLAND
CHESWICK
CONEMAUGH
CONEMAUGH
HATFIELD'S FERRY
HATFIELD'S FERRY
HATFIELD'S FERRY
MARTINS CREEK
MARTINS CREEK
PORTLAND
PORTLAND
SHAWVILLE
SHAWVILLE
SHAWVILLE
SHAWVILLE
SUNBURY
SUNBURY
SUNBURY
SUNBURY
SUNBURY
SUNBURY
ALLEN
ALLEN
ALLEN
CUMBERLAND
CUMBERLAND
GALLATIN
GALLATIN
GALLATIN
GALLATIN
JOHNSON VI LLE
JOHNSON VI LLE
JOHNSONVILLE
JOHNSONVILLE
JOHNSONVILLE
JOHNSONVILLE
JOHNSONVILLE
BLR
1
3
4
1
3
4
5
13
1
2
1
3
4
5
5-1
5-2
6
7
1
2
4
^
2
9
5
6
7
8
6
7
5
6
2
2
^
1
^
2
3
1
2
1
2
2
3
4
1A
1B
2A
2B
3
4
1
2
3
1
2
1
3
4
1
10
3
4
5
6
GEN
1
3
4
1
3
4
4
2
1
2
3
4
5
5
6
7
1
2
/
5
2
3
3
5
6
7
5
6
1
2
1
2
3
1
1
2
2
1
2
1
2
2
3
4
3
3
3
3
4
1
2
3
1
2
1
2
3
4
1
10
2
3
4
5
6
1985
RATE
4.7281
4.7287
4.7284
4.875
4.7796
4.7806
4.7815
4.7937
4.8324
2.6159
6.0173
6.0365
5.7582
5.7594
5.7567
5.7583
5.7568
3.9605
4.1054
3.0054
0
7.5259
7.5266
7.5196
7.5183
7.4022
5.1714
5.1885
6.2045
5.0273
5.0336
5.1885
5.2056
3.4911
3.4937
3.64
4.1367
4.1192
2.812
2.8126
2.7682
2.7682
2.7682
2.5869
3.5331
3.5456
3.3774
3.3837
3.3808
2*7175
2*9801
2.9366
3.1918
3.1751
3.169
3.164
2.7482
2.7481
2.5662
2*5662
2 1 5662
3.5442
3.6278
3.5827
4.7087
4.7325
4.3909
4.3254
4.3701
4.3738
3.023
3.0122
3.005
3.0216
3.0063
2.9749
2.9691
1995 EPA LOU BASELINE CASE 3:
ANN. BASE CASE x MIN OF BASELINE RATE/LIMIT-2.5
LIMIT BASELINE RATE, LIMIT
5.4336
5.4336
5.4336
5.4336
5.4144
5.4144
5.4144
5.4144
5.4144
3.264
7.1136
7.1136
7.872
7.872
7.872
7.872
7.872
4.8
5.28
4.8
4.8
6.2016
6.2016
6.2016
6.2016
6.2016
5.472
5.472
9.504
8.6592
8.6592
8.6592
8.6592
4.2816
4.2816
4.2816
6.8928
6.8928
3.552
3.552
3.56
3.56
3.56
2.492
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
3.56
4.45
4.45
4.45
4.45
4.45
4.45
3.026
3.026
3.026
3.026
3.026
3.026
3.026
• ••••••••••••••• •••••••••• ••— — •—
4.2 9.929
4.2
5.8
38.9
7.2
7.2
7.2
12.9
30.4
3.3
70.9
70.9
12.1
11.7
11.6
11.7
11.9
2.9
0.0
5.9
24.9
7.9
7.9
8.6
8.6
3l:l
5.6
1.7
3.5
0.0
5.4
5.4
17.2
33*8
12i8
21.6
11.0
11.0
21.3
25.0
48.3
28.6
47.2
47.2
34.0
34.0
30.6
9.3
9.3
8.6
13.3
8.2
8.2
8.9
8.9
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
7.3
9.9
9.1
9.1
9.1
.68.6
68.6
14.0
14.0
15.5
15.5
3.0
3.7
3.0
3.0
3.0
3.0
3.0
9.930
13.712
94.819
17.207
17.210
17.213
30.919
73.452
4.316
213.313
213.994
34.837
33.692
33.389
33.686
34.253
5.743
0.000
8.866
0.000
24.496
24.496
26.667
26.667
98.916
14.480
14.528
5.274
8.798
0.000
14.009
14.055
30.023
59.044
61.516
26.475
44.487
15.466
15.469
29.481
34.603
66.852
35.636
83.381
83.676
57.416
57.523
51.726
12.636
12.636
12.814
19.528
13.086
13.018
14.102
14.080
0.000
8.000
.000
0.000
9.367
12.703
16.126
16.198
16.198
152.635
152.635
30.736
30.278
33.868
33.897
5*573
4! 508
4.532
4.509
4.462
4.454
x 2.5 x BASELINE
5.250
5.250
7.250
48.625
9.000
9.000
9.000
16.125
38.000
4.125
88.625
88.625
15.125
14.625
14.500
14.625
14.875
3.625
0.000
7.375
31.125
9.875
9.875
10.750
10.750
39.875
7.000
7.000
2.125
4.375
0.000
6.750
6.750
21.500
42.250
42.250
16.000
27.000
13.750
13.750
26.625
31.250
60.375
35.750
59.000
59.000
42.500
42.500
38.250
11.625
11.625
10.750
16.625
10.250
10.250
11.125
11.125
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
9.125
12.375
11.375
11.375
11.375
85.750
85.750
17.500
17.500
19.375
19.375
3.750
4.625
3.750
3.750
3.750
3.750
3.750
4.679
4.680
6.462
46.194
8.207
8.210
8.213
14.794
35.452
0.191
124.688
125.369
19.712
19.067
18.889
19.061
19.378
2.118
0.000
1.491 .
-31.125
14.621
14.621
15.917
15.917
59.041
7.480
7.528
3.149
4.423
0.000
7.259
7.305
8.523
16.794
19.266
10.475
17.487
1.716
1.719
2.856
3.353
6.477
-0.114
24.381
24.676
14.916
15.023
13.476
1.011
1.011
2.064
2.903
2.836
2.768
2.977
2.955
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.242
0.328
4.751
4.823
4.823
66.885
66.885
13.236
12.778
14.493
14.522
0.785
0.948
0.758
0.782
0.759
0.712
0.704
FILE: PHASE1.WK3
PAGE C-3
------- |