Bibliography on


            ASBESTOS IN SCHOOLS
                     by


  Michelle S. L. Lee, Reference Librarian
                January 1985
            Headquarters Library
Information Management and Services Division
    U.S.  Environmental Protection Agency
         401 M St.,  S.W.  PM-211-A
          Washington,  D.C.   20460
               (202) 382-5922

-------
                BIBLIOGRAPHY ON ASBESTOS IN SCHOOLS


     Asbestos is  known  to  be  a  potential  hazard  to  the  health  of
millions of  people  today.   The problem of asbestos  in  school  build-
ings is getting more and more  attention.

     At the Headquarters Library, requests  for  information on asbestos
in schools have been coming from  individuals and organizations in both
the public  and  private  sectors.   This bibliography of  EPA reports,
books, periodical articles, and regulatory citations is an introduction
to the literature on the subject.   At  the end of the bibliography is a
brief list of referral points  for more information.

     All the material listed in the  bibliography  is available  in the
Headquarters Library.   The bibliography  is  divided  by  format,  and
many citations are annotated.

     The EPA  reports  citations are  listed  in  alphabetical  order  by
title, followed by abstracts quoted from EPA Publications Bibliography.
Citations followed by (f)  are  available in mi crofiche.

Airborne Asbestos Levels in Schools.   By  Paul  C.  Constant, Jr.,  et_
FT  EPA-560/5-83-003.  Jun. 1983.  NTIS PB84-129683.  18 6p.

   "Air and bulk samples were  collected from 48 units at 25 different
   schools of an  urban  independent  school  district. These  were  ana-
   lyzed respectively by transmission electron microscopy and polarized
   light microscopy  techniques for  asbestos   fiber  concentrations."
Asbestos
Analysi s
Lentzen .
- C o n t a i n i
Qual
EPA
i ty As
-560/1
ng
su
3-
Mate
ranee
80-23,
rials in
Program.
Aug.
School Buildings: Bui
By
80.
E. P.
NTIS
Brant"
PB8021
ly, Jr.
7243.
k Sample
and
32p.
D.t.
(f)
   "EPA  has initiated  a   quality   assurance  (QA)   program for labo-
   ratories claiming  capability  in  the  polarized  light  microscope
   (PLM) analysis  of  bulk  samples   for  asbestos.   Commercial  and
   non-commercial laboratories participating in  the  program  received
   samples of  four  fibrous  materials:  chrysotile,   anthophyl1ite,
   fiberglass,  and mineral wool."

Asbestos - Containing  Materials  in School  Buildings: Bulk Sample
Analysis  Quality Assurance Program.  By  E~iP~.B r a n 11 y,  Jr.   E~PA-
560/5-81-001.  Mar. 81. PB81-225849. 34p.   (f)

   "The second   round   of  the  Environmental  Protection  Agency  (EPA)
   voluntary quality  assurance  (QA)  program   for   commercial  labo-
   ratories claiming   capability  in  the  polarized  light  microscope
   analysis of  bulk samples  for  asbestos  was  conducted in August  and
   September, 1980."

Asbestos - Containing Materials in  School  Buildings  :  A Guidance
Document.   Part 1.  By Office of Toxic  Substances,  E.P.A.   EPA560/1-
82-002.  Mar. 1979.  NTIS PB82-225962.  73p.   (f)

-------
   "Recently there  has  been  an  increasing  awareness  of  the  sig-
   nificance of  environmental  factors   in   causing  illness.   The
   fibrous mineral  known  as  asbestos,  used  in many different kinds
   of products  and  applications,  has   entered  the  environment  in
   both occupational and non-occupational settings."

Asbestos - Containing Materials in School Buildings: Guidance for
Asbestos Analytical Programs. By D.  Lucas,  et_ al .   EPA-560/ 13-80-
017A.  Dec. 1980.   NTIS PB 81-243586.  10 6p.  (TJ

   "This document is one in a series prepared in support of the EPA
   asbestos-in-schools program.  It  was  developed  to provide guid-
   ance to local  school  officials  and their  staffs  in determining
   the presence  or  absence  of asbestos  in  school  buildings.  Data
   and information  generated  during the EPA technical  assistance
   program have  been  used  to design a  rigorous  sampling  and anal-
   ysis scheme for  bulk materials."

Bulk  Sample Analysis for Asbestos Content:  Evaluation of the
Tentative Method .~"ByETP"!  Brantly  Jr. ,  et  TTEPA- 600/4-82-021.
Apr. 1982.  NTIS PB82-196841.  13 6p.  (f)

   "The U.S.   Environmental   Protection   Agency  (EPA)  asbestos-in-
   schools program was established in March, 1979 to provide infor-
   mation and   technical  assistance  to   the  public  for  addressing
   problems presented  by  asbestos-containing insulation  materials
   in school  buildings."

Evaluation of  the Asbestos-in-Schools Identification and Notifi -
cation RuTi"!By  Janet Greenblatt.  EPA-5 60 / 5-84-005.   0~ct~;T9~84.
(NoNTIS number assigned yet)

Indoor  Air Pollution:  An Emerging Health Problem. By General
Accounting Office.   CED-80-111.    Sept.   1980,   NTIS  PB81-160087.
46p.  (f)

   "Traditionally it has been  presumed  that  a person was protected
   from polluted  air  when  indoors.   Recent research  has  shown,
   however, that  this  may  not  always   be  true.    Various  harmful
   pollutants  including radon, formaldehyde,  and   nitrogen dioxide
   have been  found  in the air  in  homes,  offices,  schools, and  even
   in recreational facilities."
Interim
sul at
Mar.
i on
82.
Meth
Samp
NTI
od for the Det
les. By D. E.
S PB83-153643,
ermi nation
Lent
54 p.
zen ,
(f)
of
et_
Asbestos 1
ll-
EPA-
n Bui
600/4
k I
-82
n-
-020.
   "This report presents  information  on the development  and  char-
   acterization of the  standard  procedures  for  analysis  of  bulk
   samples with polarized  light  microscopy  (PLM)  and  x-ray  dif-
   fraction (XRD), and  includes  the  interim method  for  the deter-
   mination of asbestos  in bulk insulation  samples."
                                -2-

-------
Measurement of  Asbestos  Air Pollution Inside  Buildings  Sprayed
with Asbestos.  By P. Sebastien, ejt_ aj_.  EPA-5 60/13-80-02 6.  August
1980. NTIS PB81-147001.   75p.

   "This report is a translation of a document prepared in 1977 for
   the French  Ministry  of Health  and  the  French  Ministry  for the
   Quality of  Life-Environment on the measurement  and assessment of
   airborne asbestos levels in buildings throughout Paris."


                               BOOKS

Citations are  in alphabetical order by title:

TITLE                                                       CALL NO.
Asbestos: An  Information Resource.  By Richard J. Levine.   RA  1231
    SRI International, U.S. National Cancer Institute,      .A8S18
    Prevention Branch,  c!978.

Asbestos and  Disease.  By  Irving J. Selikoff, e_t^ aj_.  New   RC  775
    York : Academic  Press,  c!978.                          .A8S44

Asbestos in Schools: A Dilemma: Report.  By General         TD  887
    Accounting Office.Washington, D. C.  : U.S. G.A.O.,    .A8U534
    C1982.

Asbestos in the Environment.  By J. R. Kramer, et_ 
-------
      "Airborne  particulate  samples were  collected  in several public
      schools  before  and  after  friable  asbestoscontaining  insulation
      material had  been  removed  from  ceilings.   Transmission elec-
      tron microscopy  with  selected  area electron diffraction tech-
      niques facilitated  fiber identification and counting.  Asbestos
      fiber concentrations in indoor air were in  the  range  5-40 mg/M3
      before insulation  removal.   Measurements  made one  week after
      removal  showed  reductions of 56-90%."

"Arizona's School  Asbestos  Program."   By Mike J. Charette.   Journal
of Environmental Health.  Vol.  45,  No.  3,   Nov.  - Dec.  1982,  pp.
135-37.

      "The state of Arizona  Dept. of Education operates a  successful
      program  to  remove Asbestos-containing  building materials from
      schools.   Drawing  from the expertise  of the  Dept.  of  Health
      Services,  Bureau  of   Environmental  Hygiene   and  Sanitation,
      Bureau of  Waste  Control,  and eliciting  cooperation  of  school
      officials.  Includes an asbestos  detection/control flowchart."


"Asbestos."   Clean Air  (England).   Vol. 13,  No. 2,  1983,   p.  57.


"The  Asbestos Dilemma:  Detection,  Regulatory Options,  and   Statis-
tical Approaches to  Identification."   Hypotenuse.   July-Aug. 1983.
pp.  10-19.

      "The EPA  regulations   that  took   effect  in June   1983   require
      that school buildings  be inspected for the presence of  friable
      asbestos.  Since the late 1970s,   asbestos-containing materials
      have been  removed  from  thousands  of  schools.  Although  the
      substance  is  known  to be  toxic,  no one  knows for  sure  what
      risks are  associated  with  low levels  of  exposure.   The  cost
      effectiveness of  several  alternatives  for  regulating asbestos
      is discussed.   A   discussion  of  statistical  approaches  to
      identification and  asbestos hot-lines  are included."

"Asbestos: Still a Danger in Schools."  By  Elaine  S.  Knapp.   State
Government News.  Vol. 27,  No.  3, Mar.  1984.  pp.  4-9.

      "The use of asbestos materials in schools buildings  was  common
     from the mid-1940s  until  EPA  banned sprayed asbestos in 1973.
     The agency  requires schools to  inspect for the material  and
     notify parents  and  employees  of   asbestos  hazards;  no   removal
     or abatement is required by EPA.   However,  a recent  EPA report
     found that  many  schools  did not  meet  its   June  1983 deadline
     for asbestos detection, recordkeeping,  and notification.   The
     problem is  attracting national  attention."

"Congress Ready  to  Examine  Asbestos  Compensation  Issue;  But Regu-
lation Lags."   By Kathy Koch.   Congressional Quarterly Weekly
Report.   Vol.  40, Feb. 6, 1982.  pp.    204-205,


                                -4-

-------
"Extrapolation from Occupational Studies: A Substitute for Environ-
mental Epidemiology."   By  Philip    E.   Enterline.   Envi ronmental
Health Perspectives.  Vol. 42, Dec. 1981.  pp. 39-45.

     "Three linear  models-based  on data  from  the  U.S.,  Canada, and
     the U.K.-for extrapolating  occupational  data  to general  envi-
     ronmental exposures  are  described.  The  models  are  applied to
     asbestos exposures resulting  from  heat  shields  in  hair dryers
     and asbestos  exposures  in public  school  buildings;  cancer
     mortality from these  exposures  are predicted.   Linear  models
     are compared to  a  curvilinear dose-response  curve  which  shows
     little response  at low  levels of  exposure.   Asbestos exposure
     in school buildings  poses  more  of  a  risk than  hair dryers."

"Federal  Regulation  -  Too  Little   :  the  Consumer  Product  Safety
Commission and  Asbestos."   By   Howie  Kurtz.   Washington Monthly.
Vol. 9, No. 10, Dec.  1977,  pp.  28-31.

     "The manufacturers of  asbestos  products  have known  for  years
     that asbestos  can  hurt people, just as they  knew  50 years ago
     that they were destroying  the  lungs  of their  workers.   They
     took a calculated  risk that the  hapless bureaucrats  in
     Washington world not  take their  products off  the market in the
     near future.   So far, that  risk  has paid off."

"Huge Cost  of  Removing Asbestos  Daunts Schools."   By   William  E.
Schmidt.   New York  Times.   Oct.  5,  1983.  P. A21.

     "A recent report  by  the  U.  S.  Dept.  of  Education  indicates
     that it will  cost  about $1.4  billion  to  remove asbestos  from
     14,000 private and public school  buildings around the country.
     Many school   officials  are   alarmed  about where  they will  be
     able to  find  money  to  finance  these   renovations.   Removal
     costs are estimated to run  about $100,000 per school  building,
     and  a recent survey indicates  that over half  of  the  schools in
     the  U.S.  have  not yet  identified  and reported on  asbestos-
     containing buildings  in their  areas,"


"New Study  Shows  States  Not  Regulations,  Funding School  Asbestos
Cleanup."  AFL-CIO/CLC Service Employees International  Union
Newsrelease.  Apr.  3,  1984.

     "A new study released  by the  Union  shows little is  being  done
     at the state level  to combat asbestos contamination of schools.
     This expensive  cleanup  undertaking  is   being   advocated  to
     reduce the  future  incidence  of  asbestos-related diseases  in
     children and school workers.  Although  EPA regulations require
     school  districts  to  inspect  for  friable asbestos  and  report
     findings.   There   are  no  regulations   governing or  mandating
     removal activities.  A  lack  of  state  funds and  legislation
     supporting asbestos removal  is also noted."
                                -5-

-------
"Pollution Topics."   Environmental  Health.   Vol. 91,  No.  12, Dec.
1983.  p. 339.

"Removal and  Disposal  of  An Environmental  Carcinogen:  Asbestos."
By Severio  D.  Fodero.   Journal  of  Environmental  Health.   Vol. 40,
No. 3, Nov.-Dec. 1977.   pp.  133-137.

      "This article  details  the  removal  and  disposal  of  asbestos
      ceiling material  in a  Yale  University  building.  The removal
      process utilized  a  water and  wetting  agent  technique used by
      firefighters and  the  debris  disposal  was  in  a   sanitary  land-
      fill, following federal  regulations for the handling  of
      hazardous materials."

"School' Asbestos Control  Program."   By  John  D.  Dekany.    EPA. Pre-
sented at National  Environmental  Health  Association 43rd Annual
Educational Congrence.   Charl eston,  June  23-28,  1979.   pT8~A~(9).


          FEDERAL REGISTER AND CODE OF  FEDERAL REGULATION


Citations are in. reverse chronological  order:

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION  AGENCY,   40  CFR  Part   763 Asbestos  in
Schools; [OPTS-211012C;  TSH-FRL  2608-3],   49  FR  31302,  Aug.  6,
1984.

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION  AGENCY,   40  CFR  Part   763 Asbestos  in
Schools; Response to Petition, [OPTS-211012C;  TSH-FRL-2608-3], 49 FR
24552, Jun. 14,  1984.

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY,   [OPTS-211012B , TSH-FRL2595-8] ,  49
FR 22407, May 29, 1984.

CONSUMER PRODUCT  SAFETY  COMMISSION,    16  CFR   Ch.   II  Regulatory
Flexibility Act;  Semiannual  Regulatory  Flexibility  and  Unified
Agendas,  49 FR  16578, Apr.  19, 1984.

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION  AGENCY,   40  CFR  Part   763 Response  to
Citizen's Petition   on   Asbestos;   Public  Meeting,   [OPTS-211012A;
TSH-FRC2566-5],  49 FR 15094, Apr.  17,  1984.

DEPARTMENT OF LABOR, Occupational Safety and Health Administration.
29 CFR Parts  1910   Occupational   Exposure to  Asbestos,  [Docket No.
H-033C],  49 FR  14116, Apr.   10,  1984.

VETERANS ADMINISTRATION,   48 CFR Chapter  8  Administration Regula-
tions, 49 FR 12582, Mar. 29,  1984.

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION  AGENCY,   40   CFR  Part   763  Asbestos; Res-
ponse to Citizens'  Petition,  [OPTS-211012; TSH-FRL-2506-3],    49 FR
8450, Mar. 7, 1984.


                                -6-

-------
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION  AGENCY,   [ODRM-FRL-249 61 ],  48  FR   51838,
Nov. 14, 1983.

DEPARTMENT OF  LABOR,  Occupation  Safety  and  Health  Administration
29 CFR  Part  1910.   Occupational Exposure to  Asbestos,  [Docket No.
H-0330],  48 FR 51086, Nov. 4,  1984.

CONSUMER PRODUCT  SAFETY  COMMISSION,   16  CFR  Ch.  II  Regulatory
Flexibility Act;  Semiannual  Regulatory  Flexibility  and  Unified
Agendas,  48 FR 48064, Oct. 17,  1983.

DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION, 48 FR  45280, Oct. 4, 1983.

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY,   [OPRM-FRL-2435-1],  48  FR   41809,
Sept. 19, 1983.

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY,  40 CFR Part 763 Asbestos; Friable
Asbestos-Containing Materials in  Schools;  Identification  and  Noti-
fication, [OPTS-61004B; TSH-FRL-20 64-3], 47 FR 23360, May 27,  1983.

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY,  40 CFR Part 707  Asbestos   Export
Notification, [TSH-FRL-1881-5;  OPTS-120001C], 46 FR 37608, Jul. 21,
1981.

DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION, Office of  Elementary and Secondary  Educa-
tion, 34  CFR  Parts  230 and  231 Asbestos  Detection  and  Control:
Local Educational   Agencies;  Asbestos   Detection   and  State   Plan:
State Educational  Agencies, 46  FR 4536, Jan.  16,  1981.
Contact points in order to get more information:


If you should have  any  questions  about  this  asbestos bibliography,
please refer to  Ms.  Michelle Lee  in  the  EPA Headquarters Library,
Tel: (202) 382-5921.

Additional information on EPA's asbestos program is available from:

    The Exposure  Evaluation  Division, Office of  Toxic  Substances,
    EPA.   Tel: (202) 382-3569.

    The Asbestos  Action  Program  in EPA,  Office of  Pesticides  and
    Toxic Substances.  Tel:  (202) 382-3949.

    The EPA  - Toxic  Substances Control  Act (TSCA),  Office of Toxic
    Substances.   Tel:  800-424-9065.   (554-1404  in  the  Washington
    Area).

Additional information  on  the  effects  of asbestos  on   health  is
available from  Asbestos,  National  Cancer  Institute, Bethesda,  MD
20205.  Call  800-638-6694; in MD, 800-492-6600.


                                -7-

-------
         CURRENTLY AVAILABLE GTS PUBLICATIONS ON ASBESTOS
Title

Asbestos-Containing
Materials in School
Buildings:  A Guidance
Document Part 1
(COOOQO)

Asbestos-Containing
Materials in School
Buildings:  A Guidance
Document Part 2
(coongo)

Support Document
Commercial and
Industrial Uses of
Asbestos, Economic
Analysis of Reporting
Forms, Proposed Rule
Section 8(a) Toxic
Substances Control Act

Support Document for
Proposed Rule on School
Buildinas.  Health Effects
and Magnitude of Exposure.
Proposed Rule, Section 6,
Toxic Substances Control Act

Support Document for
Asbestos-Containing Materials
in Schools, Economic Impact
Analysis of Identifcation
and Notification, Proposed
Rule, Section 6, Toxic
Substances Contol Act

Asbestos-Containing Materials
in School Buildings:  Bulk
Sample Analysis Quality
Assurance Program (Round One)

Asbestos-Containing Materials
in School Buildings:  Bulk
Sample Analysis Ouality
Assurance Program (Round Two)
EPA
Number
NTIS
Number
EPA 560/1-82-002   PB 82-225-962
EPA 450/2-78-014   PB 82-225-970
EPA 560/4-81-001   PB 81-156-168
EPA 560/12-80-003  PB 81-141-657
EPA 560/12-80-004  PB 81-141-640
EPA 560/13-80-23   PB 80-217-243
EPA 560/5-81-001   PB 81-225-849
Asbestos in Schools
EPA 560/5-81-002   PB 81-225-823

-------
Title

Asbestos Analytical
Programs Bulk Sample
Analysis:  New York City
and Maryland

Measurement of Asbestos
Air Pollution Inside
Buildinqs Sprayed with
Asbestos:  Paris

Identifying Potential
Asbestos Exposures in
Schools:  The Montgomery
County Experience

Asbestos-Containing
Materials in School
Buildings, Guidance for
Asbestos Analytical Programs

Asbestos-Containing
Materials in School
Buildings, Guidance for
Asbestos Analytical Programs;
Statistical Background
Document

Identifying Potential
Asbestos Exposures in
Schools:  The New York
City Experience

Characteristics of the
Asbestos Exposure Assessment
Algorithm

Airborne Asbestos Levels
in Schools:   A Design Study

Guidance for Controlling
Friable Asbestos-Containing
Materials in Buildings

Airborne Asbestos Levels
in Schools

Evaluation of the Asbestos-
In-Schools Identification
and Notification Rule
EPA
Number
NTIS
Number
EPA 560/13-80-21   PB 81-146-722
EPA 560/13-80-026  PB 81-147-001"
EPA 560/13-80-039  PB 81-243-502
EPA 560/13-80-017A PB 81-243-586
EPA 560/13-80-017B PB 82-225-343
EPA 560/5-81-in    PB 83-256-214
EPA 560/5-81-005   PB 83-253-500
EPA 560/5-81-006   PB 83-253-492
EPA 560/5-83-002   PB 83-214-924
EPA 560/5-83-003   PB 84-129-683
EPA 560/5-84-005   PB 85-135-085

-------
Title

Asbestos In Buildings:  A
National Survey of Asbestos-
Containing Friable Materials

Evaluation of Asbestos
Abatement Techniques:
Phase I - Removal

Evaluation of Asbestos
Abatement Techniques:
Phase II - Encapsulation

Asbestos In Buildings:
Guidance for Service and
Maintenance Personnel

Transport of Airborne
Asbestos Fibers Within a
Building
EPA
Number
NT IS
Number
EPA 560/5-84-006   PB 85-136-653
EPA 560/5-85-019
EPA 560/5-85-020
EPA 560/5-85-018
EPA 560/5-85-021
   NTIS PB number will be assigned when document is published.

-------