INDUSTRIAL BOILER
INSPECTION GUIDE
       PEOCo ENVIRONMENTAL

-------
                           EPA-340/1-81-007
    INDUSTRIAL  BOILER
    INSPECTION  GUIDE
                 by
       PEDCo  Environmental, Inc.
          1006 N. Bowen Road
        Arlington, Texas 76012
        Contract No.  68-01-6310
           Task Order No. 9
         Project No.  3560-3-9
    John R.  Busik, Project Officer
   Robert L.  King, Task Manager,  DSSE
Division of Stationary Source Enforcement
  U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
          401 M. STREET, S.W.
        WASHINGTON, D.C.  20460
            October 1,  1981

-------
                                  DISCLAIMER
     This  report  was  furnished to  the  U.S.  Environmental  Protection Agen-
cy (EPA)  by  PEDCo  Environmental,  Inc.,  in  fulfillment  of  Contract  No.
68-01-6301, Task  No.  9.   The  contents  are as  received from  the  contractor.
The opinions,  findings, and conclusions expressed are those of the authors and
not necessarily those of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.   Mention of
company, process,  or product name is not to be considered as an endorsement by
the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
                                       n

-------
                                   CONTENTS
1.  Introduction                                                         1-1
    1.1  How to use this guide                                           1-1
    1.2  How to update this guide                                        1-2

2.  General Inspection Procedures                                        2-1
    2.1  Preparation and file review                                     2-1
    2.2  Performing the inspection                                       2-2
         2.2.1  Pre-entry observations and safety                        2-2
         2.2.2  Plant inspection                                         2-3

3.  Control Equipment Inspection                                         3-1
    3.1  Source identification                                           3-1
    3.2  Inspection procedure                                            3-1
    3.3  Stack observation                                               3-4
    3.4  Fan inspection                                                  3-7
         3.4.1  F-Factor                                                 3-7
    3.5  Control equipment                                               3-12
    3.6  Fabric filter                                                   3-12
         3.6.1  External inspection                                      3-12
         3.6.2  Internal inspection                                      3-20
    3.7  Electrostatic precipitator                                      3-22
         3.7.1  External inspection                                      3-22
         3.7.2  Internal inspection                                      3-31
    3.8  Venturi scrubber                                                3-32
         3.8.1  External inspection                                      3-35
         3.8.2  Internal inspection                                      3-35
    3.9  Cyclones                                                        3-37
         3.9.1  External inspection                                      3-37
         3.9.2  Internal inspection                                      3-40

4.  Boiler Inspection                                                    4-1

Appendices:
 A.  Checklist forms                                                     A-l
 B.  Sample boiler inspection report                                     B-l

Glossary
Bibliography

-------
                                LIST OF FIGURES


Number                                                                   Page

 3-1      Source Identification Checklist                                3-2

 3-2      Example of Boiler Equipment Identification Form                3-3

 3-3      Example of Visible Emission Observation Form                   3-5

 3-4      Example of Fan Data Sheet                                      3-8

 3-5      Photograph of an Oxygen Meter On a Boiler Control  Board        3-11

 3-6      Example of Fabric Filter Description Data Sheet                3-13

 3-7      Photograph of Fabric Filter, Showing Upper and Lower Catwalk,   3-15
           Compartment Access Doors, and Magnehelic  Gages.

 3-8      Cross Section of Fabric Filter, Showing Filter Internals and   3-16
           a Pressure Gage

 3-9      Fabric Filter Compartment External Inspection                  3-17
                                    ®
 3-10     Photograph of a Magnehelic  Gage Measuring Overall  Pressure    3-18
           Drop of a Fabric Filter During Normal  Service

 3-11     Photograph of a Magnehelic  Gage Measuring the Static          3-19
           Pressure of the Dirty Side of a Fabric Filter

 3-12     Diagram of Electrostatic Precipitator Showing One  Field and    3-23
           One TR Set

 3-13     Example of ESP Description Data Sheet                          3-24

 3-14     General Relationship Between SCA and Sulfur Content For a      3-26
           Cold-Side ESP Operating At 300°F

 3-15     Example of ESP Electric Data Checklist                         3-27

 3-16a    Relationship Between Collection Efficiency and Specific        3-29
           Corona Power for Fly Ash Precipitators;  Based On  Field
           Test Data

-------
                              FIGURES (continued)


Number                                                                    Page

 3-16b    Efficiency Versus Specific Corona Power Extended to High        3-29
           Collection Efficiencies; Based On Test Data On Recently
           Installed Precipitators

 3-17     Example of External ESP Inspection Form                         3-33

 3-18     Flow Diagram of a Typical Venturi Scrubber System               3-34

 3-19     Example of Venturi Scrubber Description Data Sheet              3-36

 3-20     Flow Diagram of a Dry Cyclone Collector                         3-38

 3-21     Example of Cyclone Description Data Sheet                       3-39

 4-1      Example of Boiler Description Data Sheet                        4-3

 4-2      Example of Boiler Instrumentation Data Sheet                    4-6

-------
                                LIST OF TABLES


Number                                                                   Page

  3-1     Plume Characteristics and Combustion Parameters                3-6

  3-2     F-Factors for Various Fuels                                    3-9

  3-3     Effects of Changes From Normal Operation On ESP Control        3-28
           Set Readings
                                       VI

-------
                                   SECTION 1
                                 INTRODUCTION

1.1  HOW TO USE THIS GUIDE
     This inspection guide  has  been prepared under the  direction  of the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to assist state and local agency person-
nel  in the  inspection of  industrial  boilers  and  associated air  pollution
control systems.   It describes  various kinds of industrial boilers and pollu-
tion control  equipment, and outlines inspection procedures for these systems.
It  does not  provide  in-depth  coverage  of environmental  regulations  because
regulations  vary  from  state  to state and are  subject  to  revision.   Although
this guide  includes a  brief  discussion  of  pollutants  generated  by boilers,
the  inspector  should  study current  state  and Federal  regulations  regarding
these pollutants.
     This manual is intended as a field guide only; it should not be construed
as a detailed design manual.   Additional technical details  pertaining  to the
operation of  boilers and  their associated pollution  control  equipment  can be
found  in various  available  publications.   Selected sources  are  listed  in the
bibliography.
     In many cases inspectors have to cover a large number of sources and thus
have little  time  to spend with each  individual  source.   Although  most of the
sources they  inspect are  in compliance, some are regularly out of compliance.
These  noncomplying sources,  especially if they  are large  emitters,  require
more individual  attention.   Concentrating  on  violators will  improve overall
compliance  and air  quality more  than  repeated  visits  to sources  that are
usually in  compliance.  Of  course,  each agency will  have  to strike a balance
and determine  how  its  resources should be spent to achieve continuing compli-
ance and good air quality.
     This inspection guide  assists  the inspector in determining the actual or
probable reason for a violation.  With this knowledge he or she can exert more
pressure on  the source to come into compliance.  In some cases, the knowledge
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide                                Introduction
10/81                                  1-1

-------
the  inspector  acquires  may help  the  source  to  identify the problem.   The
inspector  should,  however,  be cautious  not  to  recommend  specific  remedial
action.   For  example,  if torn bags  are noted  in one compartment of  a  fabric
filter,   it  is  all  right for  the  inspector  to inform the source, but  not to
instruct the source  to  repair  or replace the  bags,  keep the compartment iso-
lated, or  to  take any  other specific action.   Having been  informed  that the
bags are torn,  it  is up to the source to do whatever is necessary to maintain
the equipment properly.   The danger in giving  specific directions is that the
source may blame the inspector and the agency he  represents for any problems
that result from following those directions.

1.2  HOW TO UPDATE THIS GUIDE
     This  guide  is  presented in  loose-leaf  notebook  style  to allow  easy
updating.  The  notebook  style  also makes it simple  to  add or delete material
as  appropriate.   The guide  is designed  to  be  revised or  updated as  new data
become available.  The  sectional  page-numbering  system allows for easy inser-
tion of  new pages  or the updating of existing  pages.  The name of the section
appears  at the bottom right of each page as shown below:
Title                                                           Section  Title
Issue Date                        Page Number
     An  actual  example of the page numbering system is as follows:
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide               General  Inspection Procedures
10/81                                 2-1
New Page
     When a new  page containing  additional  data is  sent to  the user, it will
be numbered as follows:
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide          General Inspection Procedures
1/82                                  2-1.1
     This page would be inserted between pages  2-1 and 2-2.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                Introduction
10/81                                 1-2

-------
Revised page

     If  page  2-1  is revised,  it  will  be reissued with  the  same page number,

the issue date of the revision, and the revision number.

Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide               General Inspection Procedures
9/82-Rl                               2-1

     This page  will replace  the  superseded  page  2-1  that was  issued 10/81.
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide                              Introduction
10/81                                  1-3

-------
                                   SECTION 2
                         GENERAL INSPECTION PROCEDURES

     Careful preparation and planning are vital to a successful boiler inspec-
tion.   Your inspection will  be meaningful  only if you  know what information
you  want  to collect  and  are  familiar  with the equipment at  the site.   Time
invested in  a  file  review will reduce your  field  time and that of the source
representative.  Also,  if you  can  obtain all  the required  data during your
inspection,  you  will  avoid  later  time-consuming  efforts  to  secure  missing
data.   Furthermore,  if  you  do your homework, plant personnel will view you as
a professional,  and are  more likely to provide the  complete  information you
need and to  cooperate  with  the agency you  represent  to  meet clean-air objec-
tives.   The guidelines  outlined below  will  help you  conduct  a  successful
boiler  inspection.

2.1   PREPARATION AND FILE REVIEW
     The  first step  in preparing  for  an inspection  is to  review  available
agency  data  regarding the  specific  boiler.   Note  the type  of  boiler  and the
pollution control equipment  that  will  be inspected,  and  become familiar with
that equipment by  reviewing  appropriate sections  of  this guide.  Also check
the following file items:
     1.    Pending compliance schedules
     2.    Construction and/or operating permits
     3.    Past conditions of noncompliance and citizen complaints
     4.    Frequency of malfunction reports
     5.    History of abnormal operations
     6.    Stack test data.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide               General Inspection Procedures
10/81                                 2-1

-------
     The  file  review  should summarize  permit  data  and  previous  inspection
information.   Stack  test data  and  previous  inspection  reports  will  indicate
the  normal  range  of operating  conditions  for  the  boiler and  its  pollution
abatement equipment  so that  you can detect any deviations  from those  condi-
tions  during  the  inspection.   For  example,  visible  emissions  and  a  lower
pressure drop across  a fabric filter indicate that bags  may be torn or miss-
ing.   If  the  boiler  is  operating at  an abnormally high  rate  (look  at steam
production or fuel consumption  rates),  the pollution control equipment may be
overloaded.   If previous  inspection  reports are available, look for trends in
abatement equipment  operation,  especially  pressure  drops across  fabric fil-
ters,  cyclones,  and  scrubbers.   The  pressure  drop  across  a  fabric  filter
slowly  increases  as  bags  get older  and become  blinded.   Worn  scrubber spray
nozzles decrease  pump pressure  and  cause  the scrubber to become  less  effec-
tive.
     Review all regulations  that apply to  the boilers at the inspection site.
If  the  boiler  is  subject to  an  opacity  limit or a fuel sulfur limit (or cor-
responding S02 emission limit),  read  the stack opacity or collect other neces-
sary data to demonstrate compliance.   The sulfur content of the fuel  is usual-
ly  shown on invoices  from the fuel supplier.  If the boiler is down,  note when
it  is  expected to  start up again.   Some boilers operate only during the win-
ter; others are connected with seasonal  or  cyclic process operations.
     If you are required  to announce your  inspections in advance, a lead time
of  one  day to one week  is  generally adequate to ensure  that necessary plant
personnel  will be  available.   Contact someone at the plant  who has authority
to  release data and  samples and to  arrange  for  access  to specific processes.

2.2  PERFORMING THE INSPECTION
2.2.1  Pre-entry Observations and Safety
     Your inspection  should begin before you enter the plant.  You can legally
photograph the plant  and  read stack opacities (if you are currently certified
to  read visible emissions) without obtaining permission from the source opera-
tor as  long as you are not on  source  property;  however, telephoto lenses may
be  prohibited.   If the boiler  stack appears to be out of compliance  and you
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide               General Inspection Procedures
10/81                                 2-2

-------
can  position  yourself properly  to  do so, make an  opacity  reading and photo-
graph the stack before you enter the plant.
     Always carry a hardhat and safety glasses with sideshields into the plant
with you.   Ear plugs,  goggles,  and  steel-toed  safety shoes  are also recom-
mended;  some  companies  require them.   You are responsible  for providing this
common  safety equipment, and  if you  do  not have it with  you,  the plant may
rightfully refuse or delay your entry.
     Follow safety procedures during the inspection.
     0    Do  not touch pipes, valves, or ducts; they may be hot.
     0    Do  not enter roped-off areas.
     0    Do  not  start  up  a ladder  until  the person  ahead  of you has
          reached a landing.
     0    Do  not  lean on  platform  guardrails; they  may  not  be  secure.
     0    Be  aware of and obey warning signs.
     These are  not  the  only safety rules  you  need  to know.  Some plants that
have unique  hazards,  such  as  toxic  gases,  will  require you  to  carry a mask
during  your   inspection.   Be sure you  understand  how and when  to use  it.   Be
especially  careful  if  construction  is  in  progress;  you  may  encounter trip
hazards,  temporary  platforms,  and  danger from  falling  objects.   Always  be
mindful of your footing, your balance, and what is above you.
2.2.2  Plant  Inspection
     When you arrive  at  the plant,  introduce yourself and contact a responsi-
ble official  to request access to the boiler and boiler operating records.   If
requested, provide proper agency identification.   This should include a photo-
graph and/or  a  physical  description.   Unless your agency instructs you other-
wise, do  not  sign  any forms that limit the  plant's liability for your safety
or restrict the scope of your inspection.
     Interview  the  plant manager or some  other responsible official(s) prior
to the in-plant inspection.   Some of the points for discussion are:
     1.   The purpose of the inspection.
     2.   The type of measurements to be made.
     3.   Any samples to be acquired.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide               General Inspection Procedures
10/81                                 2-3

-------
     4.   The systems to be evaluated.
     5.   Changes in plant management (to be noted in the agency file).
     6.   Process flow sheets to confirm current operational conditions.
     7.   Operating records required by applicable New Source Perform-
          ance Standards (NSPS) and/or for determination of operating
          conditions specified in permits.
     8.   Checklist items that can be filled out during this interview.
     Review applicable regulatory requirements carefully, and discuss specific
applicability to  the source  in  question.  Also,  be prepared  to  discuss the
following:
     1.   Authority for the inspection.
     2.   Agency organization.
     3.   Scope, timing, and organization of the inspection (preferred
          inspection agenda).
     4.   Treatment of confidential data.
     Ask plant  officials  about the operational status of equipment within the
scope of the inspection.  Document the source of all the information collected
during  the  inspection;  for example,  did you  get  the boiler  operating  rate
verbally or read  it from the control board?  If equipment is not operating at
or near  normal  conditions,  note  the reasons why; also note when units will be
operating normally to aid in scheduling followup inspections.  Any information
the source considers to be confidential should be so marked.
     If  the plant  denies  you entry to all  or part of the facility within the
scope of  the  inspection,  note reasons for  refusal,  the  name and title of the
plant official responsible for the refusal, and the precise time of the refus-
al.  Notify  your supervisor  by  telephone  immediately,  but never  attempt to
summarize potential  legal  consequences of the company's refusal to allow you
entry.
     Finally, write  a report  to  document your  inspection.   The  report  will
document any violations and will  also provide baseline data for future inspec-
tions.    Unless  agency  policy dictates  otherwise,  do  not make any comments
about  source  compliance.   List  the  data you  collected  along  with applicable

Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide               General Inspection Procedures
10/81                                 2-4

-------
regulations.   There is  no  benefit in drawing conclusions about  compliance  in
the report, and an incorrect conclusion could damage your agency's  position  if
legal action is taken.
     A sample inspection report is shown in Appendix B.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide               General  Inspection Procedures
10/81                                 2-5

-------
                                   SECTION 3
                         CONTROL EQUIPMENT INSPECTION

     This chapter outlines  a  typical  control equipment inspection  at  a hypo-
thetical plant.  The  inspection  procedure is keyed to several checklists that
are to be filled out during the inspection.

3.1  SOURCE IDENTIFICATION
     You must  identify  the location,  ownership, key  personnel,  and equipment
at the  source.   The  source identification  checklist  (Figure 3-1)  identifies
the facility;  the  boiler equipment, identification  sheet  (Figure 3-2)  identi-
fies the boiler  and  control equipment.   Usually you  can  fill  out both sheets
during  the  file review.   After  you have labeled and  identified each  boiler,
control device,  and  emission  point at the bottom  of  the  diagram (as shown in
Figure 3-2), you can  refer to the equipment and emission  points by code num-
bers in the rest of the report.

3.2  INSPECTION PROCEDURE
     Begin the boiler  inspection  at the stack and  work back through the con-
trol  equipment  and  boiler  to the control room.   This  counterflow  inspection
allows you  to  determine quickly  whether the boiler is in  compliance  and the
extent of inspection required.  If the boiler appears to be out of compliance,
a step-by-step procedure will  allow you to determine why  the boiler is not in
compliance.   An  explanation of  excessive emissions is important  for two rea-
sons.
     1.    Excessive emissions  do not always indicate an  emission  vio-
          lation.  Boilers are  sometimes permitted  to bypass  control
          equipment  during startup  and  shutdown,  or to  exceed normal
          emission  limits during soot blowing or upset conditions.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                Control  Equipment Inspection
10/81                                 3-1

-------
                                  BOILER INSPECTION CHECKLIST

                                    SOURCE IDENTIFICATION

                             Date(s) of inspection
                                        .  2.0. >98O
                             Time in  09CO   Out    / SCO
Company name

Mailing address
rvj

 4O1
                                            Si:
                                              eoooo
         Location of facility
          (Include county)

          Type of industry

          Form of ownership

          Corporate address
         Corporate personnel

         Responsible for
         facility

         Responsible for
         environmental
         matters

         Company personnel
         contacted
         Confidentiality
         statement given to

         State or local
         agency personnel
         Name
                                              Title
Phone
                                        /ova) eeo-oooo
   •f
                    f-
       Wl .
                    Figure 3-1.   Source  identification checklist.
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81                                       3-2
                                Control Equipment Inspection

-------
Source name

Inspector
                  BOILER EQUIPMENT IDENTIFICATION
                  S-l
                       FF-1
                       8-2
              O CO
         B-i


          8-3
          FF-1
 S-l
                    ESP

                      S-i
                                                Date    fttnf,
                                                   S-2
                                                            1
                                                8-3
                                        8-2
                                            S0t 000
                                                    8-2  ~~e  8-Z
Figure  3-2.   Example of boiler equipment  identification form.
Industrial Boiler  Inspection Guide
10/81                                  3-3
                                           Control  Equipment Inspection

-------
     2.   By  identifying  an equipment failure  that  causes  an emissions
          excursion, you will obtain evidence that can be used in court,
          and you will  put  pressure on the source operator to bring the
          source back into compliance quickly.  Sometimes the source may
          not  have  been  aware  of  the cause of  its problem,  and can
          readily make the necessary repairs to remedy it.

3.3  STACK OBSERVATION
     If  it  is  possible to  do  so,  observe  the stack  effluent  and read  the
opacity before  entering the  plant.   Use the visible  emission observation form
(Figure 3-3)  in  this  report  or  one supplied  by your agency for  this purpose.
Windspeed,  sky  condition,  and  other weather data are of legal  importance if
the reading is  challenged,  as  is the diagram in the  lower left corner of this
form.   Take  opacity readings for  an appropriate duration,  depending  on your
state's regulations, and  record the readings on the  form.   Although the regu-
lation may  require  plume opacity  to be  below a certain average  for,  say,  a
5-minute  period,  you  may want  to  take  an opacity reading  for 30  minutes  and
look  for  a  5-minute  period  that exceeds  the limit.  If the  source  has more
than one boiler, be  sure to  identify the boiler being observed under "Point of
Emission."
     If your agency's  policy is  to provide the source with a copy of the form,
have  the  person who receives a copy  sign and date the original  at the lower
right side of the page.
     The  color  of the  plume  can provide a  clue  as  to the way  the boiler is
operating.  To  a certain extent,  it can also  identify excess air conditions
and fuel  quality.   Table 3-1,  which was compiled by EPA's  Control  Programs
Development  Division,   shows  the  effect of combustion  parameters on  plume
appearance.
     If the opacity  is within limits, proceed directly to the control room and
note  the  boiler operating conditions.  If  the boiler is not  operating or is
operating at  a  very low rate,  you  may want  to reschedule the inspection at a
time when the  boiler  will  be operating under  more normal  conditions.   If the
boiler is operating at  a  normal rate, you may either terminate the inspection
or perform  the rest  of the inspection  to  obtain a record of  the operating
conditions for later use.  A description of normal  operating conditions can be
very useful  in the future when you are trying to explain a malfunction.

Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                Control  Equipment Inspection
10/81                                 3-4

-------
SOURCE NAME

ADDRESS
VISIBLE EMISSION OBSERVATION FORM
XV?- /Soc&'L. OBSERVER T. e£*n^J39eZtm.
4*0 / A? <***•» SV,
UfyiAa. . 0 iut«~
DATE ;
/
MINT OF EHISSION S+*cJi S-2 /rvi BoH.
OBSERVATION
POINT tfouvd
V
STACK: DISTANCE FROM
HINDSPEED 5 */»//
^(5 ft HEIGHTS^ ft
DIRECTION iJrttfi,
SKY CONDITION: RjCuJL
COLOR OF EHISSION: 6/uw*»u
RELATIVE HUMIDITY:
BACKGROUND:
BJ£u£. $£*
AMBIENT AIR TEMPERATURE: SP"F ct>t>.

48CF uJ.h.
CERTIFICATION DATE: cWe_ ; I38O
SUMMARY OF AVERAGE OPACITY





Set
Number
1
£.


Time
Start—End
D300-O90B
icoe- locf,


Opacity
Sum Average
3*5 /f.4
190 7.9


Observer x
Sun<> Wind — =» Plume and Stack
rt '


Sou
(
Obse
X^ I
-o-
(valuator's

ao
10
Zo
IS


= T
£f
5
IS
e;
IS
lt>















30
,.f
ID
zs
IS
IS
IS


£
1C
$•
1C
lo
IS~
5















45
/J-
20
IS
10
IB
10



5-
10
S
10
5
S
















30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
4b
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
0






























15






























30






























45






























\
I have received a copy of these opacity
readings.
a,, Yfi . 2?7/9b*fc9f c*4~s
r f /
&, Title: £*^f War. Date: ///z«/*e


• 1 T »
Figure 3-3.   Example of visible emission observation form.

                                        Control Equipment Inspection
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81
                            3-5

-------
       TABLE  3-1.   PLUME CHARACTERISTICS AND COMBUSTION PARAMETERS.
        Plume  color
Possible operating parameters to investigate
        White


        Gray


        Black



        Reddish  brown


        Bluish white
Excess combustion air; loss of burner flame
 in oil-fired furnace

Inadequate air supply or distribution; high
 hydrocarbon emissions

Lack of air; clogged or dirty burners or
 insufficient atomizing pressure; improper
 oil preheat; improper size of coal

Excess furnace temperatures or excess air;
 burner configuration; high NO  emissions
                              K
High sulfur content in fuel; high SO  emis-
 sions
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81
          3-6
                        Control Equipment Inspection

-------
3.4  FAN INSPECTION
     Boiler control equipment restricts the flow of air from the boiler.   This
restriction  is  overcome by  an  induced-draft  fan  between the  boiler and the
stack.  To  evaluate  the fan, you need baseline fan and control equipment data
(taken during a period of good operating conditions).
     Comparing  the fan data  sheet  (Figure 3-4) with  the  baseline  data  sheet
will  indicate  whether the  air  flow  rate  through   the  control   device  has
changed.  Unless you  have  a fan curve from  the manufacturer and are aware of
fan speed and  the  pressure drop across the  fan,  actual  flow cannot easily be
determined;  however, changes from the base case will indicate changes in  flow.
     An increase in flow indicates that the equipment  is operating at a higher
than  normal  rate  or  air  is  leaking into the  system.   Either  condition  could
mean that the  control  equipment is being overloaded.   Such  overloads lead to
reduced bag  life  in  fabric filters and increased emissions from electrostatic
precipitators.   Any  of the  following  may  indicate  that the  system flow has
increased from the baseline condition:
     1.   Increased motor current.
     2.   Lower differential pressure across the fan.
     3.   A more open damper setting.
     Mechanical problems such as  vibration  or loose belts can impair air flow
                                                     ®
and lead to system failure.  You can use a Magnehelic  gage to check fan  pres-
sure  drop  if pressure  taps  are available  on each  side of the  fan.  Use an
induction ammeter  to determine current  flow and a tachometer  to  measure fan
speed.
3.4.1   F-Factor
     Sometimes you will not be able to get a fan curve or other necessary data
to determine the flue gas flow rate from the fan.   Since the flow rate is very
important in evaluating most control equipment, the F-factor method was devel-
oped to estimate this flow.
     The dry and wet  basis F-factors for coal and oil are shown in Table 3-2.
These factors were determined  by  statistical studies of many fuel samples and
are generally accurate  to  within  4 percent.  Application to a specific boiler

Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide                Control Equipment Inspection
10/81                                 3-7

-------
                                         FAN DATA SHEET
            Source name   X
            Inspector
            1.   FAN MOTOR
                Manufacturer
                Model  No.
                     303
                Rated horsepower     4-O
                Volts     Z3Q/MO
                                  1175
Maximum rpm
                Operating  current:  Panel
            2.   DRIVE
                Direct
                     Belt
                Pulley reduction 	
                Audible belt slippage:   Yes
            3.   FAN
Manufacturer	/ymx
Model  No. 	
Fan vibration 	
Gas temperature at inlet, °F
Fan rpm	1115
Fan static pressures:  Inlet _
Differential static  pressures:
Fan housing condition 	
Dampers 	
Fan exit	
Gas flow from fan curve
                                      Date  fW.  20
                                      Fan No.  Fa*n m
                                 Type
TIKK
                                 Maximum amps _
                                 Service factor
                                         Other
                                                 /OS/SI
                                           Other
                                           No
                                                            Service
                                                                      J-. D.
                                              Measured
                                                         Outlet
                                               Panel
                       Figure  3-4.   Example  of fan data sheet.
Industrial Boiler  Inspection  Guide
10/81                                        3-8
                                            Control  Equipment  Inspection

-------
                   TABLE 3-2.  F-FACTORS FOR VARIOUS FUELS.'
Fuel type
Coal
Anthracite .
Bituminuous
Lignite
Oil
Gas
Natural
Propane
Butane
Wood
Wood Bark
Fd
DSCF
106 Btu

10,140
9,820
9,900
9,220

8,740
8,740
8,740
9,280
9,640
Fw
WSCF
10b Btu

10,580
10,680
12,000
10,360

10,650
10,240
10,430
-6
-e
 These  factors  are taken  from Appendix C of Continuous  Air Pollution Source
 Monitoring Systems, EPA 625/6-79-005.
DDSCF stands for dry standard cubic feet.
"WSCF stands for wet standard cubic feet.
 Use  the  bituminous coal  figures  for  sub-bituminous  coal   in  the  absence of
 other data.
*The  moisture  content of  wood is so  variable  that the  moisture of the wood
 being  burned  must be  measured  to determine the  moisture  correction factor.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81
3-9
            Control Equipment Inspection

-------
requires  corrections  for excess air (flue  gas  oxygen content), pressure, and
temperature of the flue  gas.
     Excess  air  (air  beyond  the minimum  amount required  for  combustion) is
used in  all  boilers to  insure  that there  is sufficient oxygen  to burn all the
fuel.  Boiler  and  ductwork leaks add  additional  air (and oxygen) to the  flue
gas.  The flue gas oxygen content must be  known to account for  this excess air
in  the  flue gas.   This method  requires a determination  of oxygen  on  a dry
basis, which  is  the way most boiler  oxygen meters operate.  Figure 3-5 shows
an oxygen meter in a boiler control room.
     A  temperature  correction   is  necessary  because gas  volume  (and  flow)
increase  as  temperature increases.   Gas volume also  increases  as the pressure
decreases.   Pressure  differences  occur  because of  differences  in elevation
above sea level.   If two identical boilers  are fired, one at sea level and one
at  an  elevation  of 3000  ft,  the boiler  at 3000 ft  will  have a  10 percent
greater flue gas flow  rate.
     The  equation  for calculating flue  gas flow  rate and a definition of the
terms is  given below.
              = -  FF  f _   '   ) + (F  - F )1 r       1 f          1
                60 Lhd 120.9  - 0;   C w   VJ L  530  J L30770 - AJ
where   ACFM = Flue gas flow rate in actual cubic feet per minute.
           H = The  boiler fuel  firing  rate in  million  Btu's per  hour.
               This can be calculated from  the  fuel  consumption  rate  and
               the heat content  of the fuel.
          F . = The dry  basis  F-factor from Table 3-2  for the  fuel  being
               fired.    If more than one  fuel  is being fired  a  weighted
               average F-factor  can be used.
          02 = The  flue  gas oxygen  content in  percent  on  a  dry basis.
               This can  be read on the  oxygen  meter if the  boiler  has
               one.
          F  = The wet  basis  F-factor from Table 3-2  for the  fuel  being
               fired.
           T = The flue gas temperature at  the  control device  in degrees
               fahrenheit.   This  is usually   monitored  in  the boiler
               control room.
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide                   Control  Equipment Inspection
10/81                                  3-10

-------
                  Figure 3-5.   Photograph of an oxygen meter
                          on a boiler control  board.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81                                 3-11
Control Equipment Inspection

-------
           A = Altitude above  sea level  in  feet.   If  this  isn't known
               set A equal  to  zero.   The equation is valid to a maximum
               altitude of 10,000 ft.
     As an example,  find  the flue gas  flow  rate  of  a boiler at 1500 ft above
sea level firing 40,000 Ib/h of bituminous coal  with  a heating value of 12,000
Btu/h.   The control room oxygen meter shows an oxygen level of 6 percent after
the air preheater  (the closest point to the control  device that is monitored)
and the gas temperature is 380°F.  The F-factors come from Table 3-2.
     The heat input is calculated first:
     40,000 Ib/h x 12,000 Btu/lb = 480 x 106 Btu/h
     The flue gas flow rate is:
  AfFM - 48° rqft?n (  20'9  1 + no fiftfl - q fi?rm f380 + 460. r    30770   n
  ACFM " "60 [982° (20.9 - 6}   no>680   9.820)] (   ^   ) L30770 . 150gJ
        = 195,000 acfm.
     This  number  is only an estimate,  but  you  will  find  it  very  useful  when
evaluating the control devices described later.

3.5  CONTROL EQUIPMENT
     Boiler pollution  control  equipment  may consist of  a fabric  filter,  an
electrostatic  precipitator (ESP), a  cyclone,  or  a  venturi  scrubber.   Some
boilers (especially  gas-fired  units)  have no control  equipment.   Each collec-
tor is discussed separately.

3.6  FABRIC FILTER
3.6.1  External Inspection
     Excessive emissions  usually indicate either that some bags are defective
or missing or that  the  fabric filter is being bypassed.  Emissions  will  in-
crease  somewhat  immediately after a  compartment  has  been cleaned,  but  they
should decline steadily once the compartment is back on line.
     Figure 3-6 is  an example  of a  fabric filter data  sheet.   As indicated,
you should sketch  the layout of  the  compartments  and  duct work on the bottom
of this sheet and indicate the orientation of the various components.   Be sure
to label  the fabric  filter so that  you can  refer to  individual compartments
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                   Control  Equipment Inspection
10/81                                 3-12

-------
Source name
Inspector
                              FABRIC FILTER DESCRIPTION
                                         Date
                                                            20}  81
                   AC.  G
                                         Fabric filter No.
                                                                  FF-1
Date  Installed
1915
                                         Manufacturer  (J> 5,
                                                                        Cs>.
     Total filter area, ft
                                     ,OOO
     Air/cloth ratio:  Net  2,
                                   Lua*
                                         Gas flow, acfm   #f% OOO
                                         Gross        2.0
     Cleaning system:  Type
                     Cleaning frequency
     Operating temperature
     Comments
                Pressure drop before cleaning
                Cleaning controlled by  AP 	
                         3BO'F
                                                   3 I
                                                                    u).
                                                        Time   &  /irs
                                                                     CM/Vl&nt~
                           •fagf  ~™c  'oa<3f
                  SKETCH THE FABRIC FILTER AND LABEL THE COMPARTMENTS
FROM
 0-1 o~et B-
                 t  f
                 t  I
JT
r L°
e
e
c
f

\ ^
    Figure 3-6.   Example of  fabric  filter description  data  sheet.
                                                   Control Equipment Inspection
Industrial  Boiler  Inspection Guide
10/81
                                      3-13

-------
later.   It is  usually convenient  to  use  the  plant's designation  for  each
compartment.  Other  information that  is  entered on this data  sheet  can  help
you determine the  overall  condition of the unit.   In  general,  high air/cloth
ratios reduce fabric  filter life and increase dust  penetration.   The current
trend is  to use reverse-air cleaning systems and  air/cloth  ratios of 2.0 cfm
per square  foot.  Typical  bag life on such systems appears to be 3 to 4 years.
     Sometimes fly ash will blind the filter fabric over a period of months or
years.  Overcoming this problem may necessitate an increased cleaning frequen-
cy.   Immediately after  each cleaning  the  pressure drop  will  return  to its
minimum value,  and  the pressure drop will  increase  slowly  as fly ash accumu-
lates on the fabric until  the unit is cleaned again.
     Begin  the  fabric filter inspection by checking each  individual  compart-
ment.   A  typical  system has walkways and access doors  to the fabric filter at
two levels.   Each  compartment  or group of compartments driven by a common fan
should have a differential  pressure  gage or manometer with  which to measure
the static  pressure  on the clean side and the dirty side and the differential
pressure  across  the bag.    Note  that  the  pressure drop should  be  the same on
all compartments using the same fan.
     Figure 3-7  is a  photograph of a fabric filter  taken  from  the walkway at
the  tube   sheet  level.  This  photograph  also shows a higher  walkway,  which
provides  access  to the tops of  the bags.   The access  doors  and  the  pressure
gages (mounted to the  left of each door) are also clearly visible.   Figure 3-8
shows the fabric filter internals and the pressure gage.
     The  checklist  in Figure 3-9  should  be used  during your inspection.  At
each  compartment,  measure  the  clean-side,  dirty-side, and  overall  pressure
drop  across the  filter.    Figure 3-10  shows a  pressure  gage  measuring the
pressure drop across  the  filter during normal  service.  Figure 3-11 shows the
gage when  the clean-side  pressure tap is vented;  the  gage shows static pres-
sure on the dirty  side.   If the  unit  is  operating;  the pressure on the dirty
side will  always be higher than that on the clean-side.
     If possible, disconnect the plant gages and check  the lines with a porta-
ble differential pressure gage.  Obtain permission from a plant representative
before you  do this.   If several of the permanent gages are defective, suggest
that  the  plant   install proper connections  for easy attachment of a  portable
gage during future  checks.   A  plugged line on the dirty side of a compartment
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                Control Equipment Inspection
10/81                                 3-14

-------
       Figure 3-7.   Photograph of fabric filter,  showing upper and lower
           catwalk,  compartment access doors,  and Magnehelic   gages.
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81
3-15
            Control Equipment Inspection

-------
BAG TENSION SPRINGS
        BAG CAPS
         TUBESHEET 	»-"LTJ"Lru-H
                                                    PRESSURE
                                                      GAGE
                                                 ASH  HOPPER
  Figure 3-8.  Cross section of fabric filter,  showing
          filter internals and a pressure gage.
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81                                 3-16
                                       Control  Equipment Inspection

-------
                          FABRIC FILTER COMPARTMENT EXTERNAL INSPECTION
           Source name  XVZ  ^

           Inspector
     Date    nsv. 2.0j 198O

     Fabric filter  No.    FF-1
           1.   Static pressure (inches W.G.)
Compartment
A
e
c.
D
e
F


Plant's instruments
Clean
side
-3
-
-------
            Figure 3-10.   Photograph of a Magnehelic  gage measuring
         overall  pressure drop of fabric filter during normal  service.
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81
3-18
            Control Equipment Inspection

-------
      Figure 3-11.   Photograph of a Magnehelic  gage measuring the static
           pressure of the dirty side of a fabric filter.   The clean
                     side tap is vented to the atmosphere.
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81
3-19
            Control Equipment Inspection

-------
is a  common problem.   The  static pressure  of a plugged line will  read zero
after it has been vented, and it should be repaired.
     At  the  end of  this check you  should be able to  identify  any  defective
gages  and  the  pressure  drop across  the  filter system.  The  results  in  the
example  shown  in Figure 3-9  indicate that gages on Compartments C  and  E  are
defective because their readings differ considerably from the inspector's test
gage.   The  zero-pressure drop for Compartment D suggests that  the compartment
is isolated.
     Listen  and feel  for  air  leaks  into the  filter  system.    Leaks  usually
occur  around the access doors  or  at  joints  in the ductwork.  Check the con-
dition of  the  door  gaskets.   Air  leaks cause localized cooling  that  can,  in
turn, cause condensation and corrosion of internal  parts.
     The isolation check is  also  shown in Figure 3-9.   To perform this check,
have the operator  isolate  each compartment,  one at a  time,  and  read the opa-
city for at least 5 minutes  after  each  isolation.  Use the  plant's  opacity
meter,   if  one  is  available.   At  some well-instrumented installations  each
compartment will have its own opacity monitor, and the  isolation  of individual
compartments will  not be  necessary.   If the  filter  system has  an  automatic
cleaning cycle, this  must  be  locked out during  the  test  so that only  one
compartment is  isolated at a time.
     If  opacity decreases  when a particular  compartment is  isolated,  inspect
the compartment internally to determine the problem.   In many installations it
is impossible  to isolate a compartment and enter it when the unit is on line.
Be sure to follow all plant safety procedures, and have someone from the plant
accompany you when you enter a compartment.
3.6.2  Internal Inspection
     An internal inspection can clearly pinpoint the cause of a malfunction by
revealing that bags are torn or missing.  Certain safety precautions should be
observed to  guard  against  heat,  toxic gases, and low  oxygen  levels.   Always
work closely with the plant personnel, and be sure that a plant representative
accompanies you on any internal inspection.   Ask for  and  follow plant safety
procedures.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                Control Equipment Inspection
10/81                                 3-20

-------
     If the  boiler  is not operating, make  sure  the  fabric filter compartment
has been  vented  and cooled.   This is the  safest condition for conducting the
inspection.
     In rare  situations  a compartment can be entered  while  the fabric filter
is  operating.   Make  sure  the compartment  is  locked out  and  that  the boiler
operator knows you are planning to enter it.  Enter the compartment slowly and
be  prepared  to  leave immediately if heat seems excessive or if you detect any
sulfurous odor, which indicates leaks in the valves isolating the compartment.
If  necessary, wear  a dust mask to prevent  inhaling  fly ash.   If you have any
doubt about the safety of entering the compartment, stay out.
     When you enter a compartment,  always have  a  second person wait outside.
Compartment doors cannot be  opened  from the inside,  and you  would be trapped
if  the  door  should  close.   If there  is any  question about  the  air quality
inside, use an oxygen supply or stay out.
     An excessive  accumulation of ash  on  the  clean side  is  the  most obvious
sign of  trouble in  a fabric filter.   You should  make  an internal  inspection
before anyone else  enters the compartment and disturbs the ash accumulations.
Filter bags  usually  fail  at the bottom where the  bag attaches to  the tube
sheet,  and  fly  ash  may accumulate around torn  bags.   The bags should be dry.
Check them for the presence of oil,  which may have dripped on the filters from
the shaker  mechanism,  or for dampness,  which may have resulted from a section
of the fabric filter running below dewpoint.
     Any  air leaks  into  the  compartment  can  cause  local  condensation  and
corrosion.   Check  around doors,  and  note  the  condition of  the  door gasket.
Check the hopper for incomplete solids removal  and corrosion.
     Hopper problems  are a common cause of  fabric  filter failure.   A bridged
or  plugged  hopper will  fill  up with fly  ash  and restrict the gas  flow in a
compartment  until that compartment  becomes  useless.   Hoppers  usually have an
access  hatch  for inspection.  Only plant personnel  should open hopper doors.
Be  especially careful;  if the hopper is full,  you could be buried in fly ash.
     Fly ash  in  the hopper will harden  if exposed to water.   Condensation and
hopper plugging can result from hopper heater failure, air leaks in the hopper
walls,  or leakage through the hopper di.scharge valve.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                Control Equipment Inspection
10/81                                 3-21

-------
3.7  ELECTROSTATIC PRECIPITATORS
     The electrostatic  precipitator  (ESP)  is  the most complex  of  the control
systems  discussed in  this report.   As shown  in Figure 3-12,  ESP's contain
alternating rows  of  plates and wires.   A  high voltage field  within the ESP
charges fly ash particles as they pass through the ESP system and attracts the
particles  to  the plates, where they  collect.   (This is the same  type  of at-
traction that pulls hair to a comb or brush on a dry day.)
     A  transformer  rectifier  (TR) set  produces  the  high  voltage  in an  ESP.
The TR  set converts  the plant voltage  (normally  220 or 460 V a.c.) to 30,000
to 60,000 V d.c.   Each TR set (and the wires and plates connected to it) forms
one field,  and the  typical  ESP  has  three or more  fields.   Figure  3-12  is  a
simplified schematic of  an ESP.   The first field  removes  50 to 75 percent of
the fly ash  entering   an  ESP,  and  each  of the  additional  fields  removes  a
portion of the remaining fly ash.
3.7.1   External Inspection
     Figure 3-13 is an example of an ESP description data sheet for a hypothe-
tical  ESP  system.  A comparison of the sample information  with design data or
past operating data  indicates  a change in ESP efficiency.   (The amount of the
change  can be estimated  by  using a power  calculation,  shown  later.)  Sketch
the ESP at the bottom of the data sheet; show each field, the direction of the
gas flow, and the location of the ESP relative to the boiler and stack.
     Three variables  tend to affect the ESP efficency.  They are:
     1.    Specific Collection Area.   The  specific collection area (SCA)
          usually  ranges from  200  to 800  square  feet  per  1000 actual
          cubic feet per minute (acfm).   To determine the SCA  in square
          feet per 1000  acfm, divide the actual cubic feet per minute of
          gas flow into  the  square feet of the  plate area and multiply
          by  1000.   An  increase in the SCA increases the  efficiency of
          the ESP.   Operating  the ESP equipment at  gas  flows above  the
          design rate will reduce the SCA and the efficiency.
     2.    Temperature.    Gas  temperature also  affects the  efficiency of
          an  ESP.  Hot-side  ESP's,  which operate  at 600°  to 700°F,  are
          not as  sensitive to  temperature  changes  as  cold-side ESP's,
          which operate  at 300° to 400°F.   A gas temperature decrease of
          15° to 20°F can cause a noticeable reduction in the efficiency
          of a cold-side ESP.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                Control Equipment Inspection
10/81                                 3-22

-------
            FROM PLANT
           POWER SUPPLY
                           PRIMARY CURRENT
                           220 OR  460 VOLTS
                          ALTERNATING CURRENT
                           SECONDARY CURRENT
                          30,000 TO 50,000 VOLTS
                            DIRECT CURRENT
 RECORD VOLTS AND AMPS
•RECORD KILOVOLTS AND MILLIAMPERES
    Figure 3-12.   Diagram of electrostatic  precipitator, showing  one field
    and  one TR set.   Additional  fields are  normally  used.   Each has its own
                  TR  set and each is electrically independent.
Industrial  Boiler  Inspection Guide
10/81                                    3-23
  Control  Equipment  Inspection

-------
                                       ESP DESCRIPTION
             Source name   XY2  eJhJLdbuz*,   Date     /Inf.  20. 738O
             Inspector   _f£.  r^^n^i^,     ESP No.     «P-2
Date  Installed
                     aji
Manufacturer   U.S.   €SP  C*.
Total ft  plate area
Gas flow, acfm
                                  Design
Actual   45o.
                                           Actual      4*£ 7
             SCA, ft'/lOOO acfm       Design _
             Temperature, °F         Design   32QV      Actual
             Coal sulfur content, %   Design    i.Q *?•     Actual     Q.7 /o
             Face velocity, ft/m      Design    "2.^0 **/*!  Actual
                SKETCH THE ESP AND LABEL THE  FIELDS (TR SET).
                                             N
                   9-f*    H-rft  3ft
  8-3


t
T
V
                                                    ^/5 TACK.
                                                       5-Z
                  TK-l
  Figure 3-13.   Example  of ESP  description data sheet.
Industrial  Boiler  Inspection Guide
10/81                                      3-24
                                             Control  Equipment  Inspection

-------
     3.   Coal sulfur  content.   ESP  efficiency generally increases with
          the sulfur content  of the  coal burned in the boiler.  This is
          especially true  when the  sulfur  content is  less  than 1 per-
          cent.
Figure 3-14 will  serve as  a rough guide for  estimating the  effect of changes
in SCA and  coal  sulfur content on the efficiency of a cold-side ESP; however,
it should not be used  for estimating an absolute efficiency.
     Check the ESP  control  system thoroughly.  Control  panels usually include
primary  and   secondary current and  voltage  meters  and  a  spark  rate  meter.
Record the  voltage, amperage,  and  spark rate  for each  section,  as  shown  in
Figure 3-15.   It  is  not unusual for the spark  rate meter to be out of order.
The  other  gages  on the control  panel  will  jump when the field  sparks.   When
the spark meter is not operating, you can determine the  spark rate by counting
the number of times these meters oscillate in 30 seconds and  multiplying by  2.
You should compare  the control room readings with calibrated or design values
for  each section.   If a  daily log  is  kept,  check  it to  determine  whether
readings are  representative.    Data  drift  indicates such problems  as  air in-
leakage  at air heaters or  in ducts leading to the ESP,  fly  ash buildup on ESP
internals,  and/or deterioration of  electronic components.  Also note inopera-
tive meters,  the number of power  supplies  on manual  control,  and power sup-
plies  on automatic  control that  are set for operating  voltages  below design
specifications (such as might be done to reduce wire breakage.)  Record all  of
the information  that  is called for on the ESP electrical data checklist (Fig-
ure 3-15).
     Table 3-3 lists  some  common operating  problems  and how  they affect ESP
electrical  parameters.   Figures 3-16a and 3-16b show ESP collection efficiency
as a function of  power consumption.  You can use these  curves  to obtain a rough
estimate of efficiency, but  keep in mind the  extreme variations and the lack
of data at high efficiencies (>98 percent).
     In  general,   the corona  voltage  should be  35  kV or higher,  the secondary
current  (milliamperes)  should  increase  or  stay constant  as  you  move from the
inlet to the  outlet of the ESP, and  the spark rate should  be about 10 sparks
per minute.
     From the  data  presented  earlier in Figure 3-13,  you  can  draw the fol-
lowing conclusions:

Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide                Control Equipment Inspection
10/81                                 3-25

-------
     o
     o
    CM
         700
         600
         500
         400
         300
         200
         100
                                                          99.9
                                                          99.5
                                                          99.0
                          1.0            2.0


                                  SULFUR IN COAL.  %
                  3.0
4.0
              Figure 3-14.   General  relationship between SCA and

            sulfur content for a cold-side ESP operating at 300°F.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide

10/81
3-26
            Control Equipment Inspection

-------
O 3
^ Q.
00 C
M VI
  r+
  -J
  ^*
  D)
  00
  O
  (V
  -J
  v>

  r»
  <-»•
  ^*
  o
  Q.
  re
ro
  o
  O
  •o
  n
ESP ELECTRICAL DATA
Location
BotigK.
0-3













TR set
No.
±
2
3











Primary
voltage, V
Present
420
4ZO
420











Base
4ZO
480
480











Primary
current A
Present
75
230
230











Base
75
2.38
238











Secondary
Voltage, kV
Present
50
4$
45











Base
So
So
So











Secondary
current, MA
Present
4*o
$00
600











Base
4co
Goo
800











Spark rate,
sparks/ml n
Present
7
3
3











Base
10
6
2












  re
  o
                                 Figure 3-15.   Example  of ESP electrical data checklist.

-------
O 3
CD C
l-i in
                                       TABLE 3-3.  CHANGES FROM  NORMAL ESP OPERATION.
f
QJ
as
o
-j
i— i
tn
\o
O
O

C
I-J
LJ.
n>






o
o
3
O
m
JO
c
-a'
3
(D
Cl'
3
•o
*-»
Primary
voltage,
V, a.c.
300
260


350

300-350

280
180
0-300





0

330



265


Primary
current,
A, a.c.
50
55


40

50-60

52
85
0-50





100+

50



50


Secondary
current,
mA, d.c.
200
230


175

20-250

210
300
0-200





0

200



200


Condition
Normal full load
System load off by 1/2


System load constant, but
increase in dust load
Gas temperature increases

Gas temperature decreases
ESP hopper fills with dust
Discharge electrode breaks





Transformer- rectifier
shorts
Rapper on discharge system
fails


Rapper on collection plate


Effect
--
Gas volume and dust concentration decrease;
efficiency increases because of reduced
gas velocity.
Efficiency increases.

Efficiency rises; sparking increases
because of increased resistivity.
Efficiency decreases.
Efficiency decreases.
Efficiency may fall to 0 (may vary between 0
and normal if top part of electrode is left
swinging inside the ESP). Instrument fluc-
tuates violently. Arcing can be heard out-
side the ESP.

No current passes from TR set to the ESP.
Efficiency falls to zero.
Dust builds up on discharge electrodes.
Resistance increases because corona dis-
charge decreases. Additional voltage is
required to keep current constant.
Sparking increases. Voltage must be re-
duced to keep current constant.

U)

ro
oo

-------
                                  THEORETICAL CURVE _
                                    FOR k = 0.55
                              25   50   75  100  125  150
                         CORONA POWER,  watts/1000 acfm
 Figure 3-16a.  Relationship between collection efficiency and specific
    corona power for fly ash precipitators; based on field test data.
                      ^99.9

                      § 99.8
                      fc 99
                      S-99.5

                      6  "
                      £  98

                      ~  95
                      U-
                      uj  90

                      o  80
                      P  70
                      a  50
                      o
                      o
0   100  200  300 400  500  600
CORONA POWER, watts/1000 acfm
        Figure 3-16b.   Efficiency versus specific corona power extended
              to high collection efficiencies; based on test data
                     on recently installed precipitators.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81
          3-29
                      Control Equipment Inspection

-------
     1.    The gas flow through the ESP is lower than the design rate.
          This results in an increase in the SCA and tends to increase
          the unit efficiency.

     2.    The operating temperature is below the design temperature.
          This tends to reduce the overall  efficiency of the unit.

     3.    The 0.7 percent sulfur content of the coal is less than the
          design value of 1.0 percent.  This tends to have an adverse
          effect on the efficiency of the unit.

     Because  the relative  effects of  these three  factors are difficult  to

estimate, you cannot  readily determine  if the overall effect is beneficial  or

detrimental.  From the sample electrical data in Figure 3-15, however, you can

conclude the following:

     1.    The ESP secondary  current  increases from inlet to outlet; all
          fields appear to be operating.

     2.    The design and operating power per  1000 acfm (sometimes called
          corona power) can  be  calculated  from the data in Figures 3-13
          and 3-15.   The  power  in watts,   supplied  by each TR set,  is
          calculated by multiplying  the kilovolts (kV) by the milliamps
          (mA) of each TR  set shown  in Figure 3-15.  The total power is
          the sum of  the  power  of the three TR sets.  Figure 3-13 shows
          the airflow  to be 500,000 acfm; so dividing the total power by
          500 yields the power per 1000 acfm:
          Design = <50><400> + (50^°°> * ^50^80°) = 180 watts/1000 acfm


          Operating = (50)(400) + (45)(500) + (45)(600) = ]54 watts/1000 acfm


Based on the  curve  in Figure 3-15b, this  decrease  in  power reduces estimated

efficiency from 99.50 to 99.25 percent, which results in a 50 percent increase
in emissions  from  the unit (0.75 percent instead of 0.50 percent of the inlet

fly ash particulates).
     The  spark rate  usually  limits  the  secondary  voltage.   As  voltage  in-
creases both  ESP efficiency and spark rate  increase  until  excessive sparking

overrides efficiency  gains  from the higher voltage.  A  spark is a short cir-

cuit that  causes  a  momentary voltage drop  and loss of  efficiency.   Over 20

sparks per minute is excessive, and the efficiency of a unit that isn't spark-

ing can be increased by increasing the voltage.


Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide             Control Equipment Inspection
10/81                                 3-30

-------
     Spark  rate  decreases in  each  field as  you move  from  the dirty  to the
clean gas  side  of the ESP.  This is because most of the fly ash is removed in
the first  field,  and the heavy fly ash  concentration  promotes sparking.   The
spark rates  shown in Figure  3-15 are low enough  to indicate that the voltage
could be increased, especially in the last two fields.
     If the  plant is in violation of opacity  or mass  emission regulations, a
solution to the problem might be:
     1.    To  increase the voltage  in  the  last  two  ESP fields  to the
          design rate of 50 kV.
     2.    To  increase  the temperature  of  the gas  into the  ESP  to the
          design level of 320°F.
Rapper/Vibrator Inspection—
     Mechanical, electrical,  or air operated rappers or vibrators  periodically
remove  accumulated  fly ash  by shaking  the  plates  and wires.  These  are re-
ferred  to  simply  as  rappers  throughout the rest  of this  discussion.   Rappers
can be  located on  the top and/or side  of  the ESP.  They operate  on  a timed
cycle,  and you  should be able to hear them turn on and off.   Obtain a diagram
of the  rapping  system sequence from the plant personnel,  and verify that all
rappers are  operating.   Irregular  sounds  from  an  individual  rapper indicate
that it either  is operating  improperly or is broken.   Check rapping intensity
and frequency against  design  and past performance.   The  rapping  intensity of
electric rappers  is  usually  indicated by volts or amps; the rapping intensity
of air-operated rappers is indicated by air pressure.   In general,  an increase
in either intensity or frequency of the rapping will result in increased emis-
sions because dislodged  fly  ash  can become reentrained in the flue gas and be
carried out  the  stack.   On  the  other  hand,  insufficient rapping  can allow
solids to build up on the plates, which reduces ESP efficiency.
3.7.2  Internal  Inspection
     The ESP  can be  entered  only if  the  control  device is  not  being used.
Unlike  fabric  filters, sections  of  an  ESP  cannot  be  isolated and bypassed.
Before  entering  the  ESP,  be sure the  electrical  supply  is  locked out,  and
follow all of the safety procedures for entering a fabric filter  described in
Section 3.6.2.

Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide             Control Equipment Inspection
10/81                                 3-31

-------
     Look for  missing wires.   A  row of  wires should be between  each  row of
plates  in  a  regular pattern.   Missing wires  reduce efficiency.    Check  for
warped plates, especially  in large ESP's.   A warped plate that is  closer than
usual to a wire  can cause premature sparking  that  reduces  the voltage  in the
entire  field.   Look  for  signs  for corrosion,  especially  around the  doors.
Corrosion around joints usually indicates that air leaks are causing localized
cooling and  condensation.   General  corrosion  of the  ESP internals  indicates
that the  unit has  been  operated  at low gas temperatures (below the sulfuric
acid dew point).
     More than 1/4  inch  of ash coating on wires or plates probably means that
the  internals  are  not being rapped enough.  An  ash  coating will  insulate the
wires and plates and reduce efficiency.
     Suspension  insulators,  which support and  isolate  the  high-voltage parts
of an ESP,  are housed in a plenum (called the penthouse or top housing)  on top
of  the  ESP  that  is  fan-pressurized with filtered  air  to prevent  ash  from
leaking out  of  the  ESP  onto  the insulators.   Ash accumulations  can cause
arcing and may short the wires or plates to the ESP housing.   Check to  see if
the ventilation fan is running, and note the condition of the filters.  If the
boiler is down,  inspect  the insulators for ash  deposits  and signs of arcing.
Make sure the ESP is deenergized before entering the top housing.   Figure 3-17
is an ESP inspection checklist for the rappers and the top housing.

3.8  VENTURI  SCRUBBERS
     Venturi   scrubbers  wet  the  fly  ash  and  capture  it  in a water stream.
Figure 3-18  is  a flow diagram of a typical venturi  scrubber.  Ash-laden air
enters the scrubber and  accelerates to a high velocity in the venturi throat.
Gas  velocities in  the throat section vary from  100  to 500 ft per  second, and
gas  pressure drops  are  from 10 to  30  inches  of water.  Typical water flow in
this system is 2 to 5 gal/min per 1000 acfm.
     Water can be  injected  into  the  top of  the venturi,  as shown in  Fig-
ure 3-18,  or  directly into  the throat.   The high-velocity gas stream  in the
throat atomizes  the  liquid  and maximizes contact between  the dust particles
and the water droplets.   The water droplets themselves collide and  agglomerate
in  the  divergent section  of the  venturi.   A 90 degree  elbow  at  the venturi

Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide                Control Equipment Inspection
10/81                                 3-32

-------
                        EXTERNAL ESP INSPECTION
           Source name  XV£
           Inspector   c^.
           Rappers
           Rapper location:  Top
           Rapper type:   Air	
                                    Date    flfir,  24.  I3&0
                                    ESP No.     ESP- .2
                                          side      yes
                             Electrical
Rapping frequency:  TR No. 1    £ *»&*, .
                  TR No. 3     l
	Mechanical
 TR No. 2 	5
 TR No. 4
           Top housing condition      £Sf
                                         tq  -
           Insulator condition     ESP
                                       -
                                                   *)>*<** ^4-6-0—
           Fan and purge-air filter  condition     F^LfLfc*.   LA
                                                                  £K
Comments
   Figure  3-17.   Example of  external ESP inspection  form.
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81
                                 3-33
                                               Control Equipment Inspection

-------
O =3
\ Q.
00 C
   -J
   •j.
   Q»
   00
   O
   m
   -t
   3
   VI
  •o
   (V
   o
   o
  o.
  n
               CONTAMINATED
                  FLUE GAS
 I
U>
CONVERGENT
 SECTION
     VENTURI
      THROAT

  DIVERGENT
   SECTION

   DIRECTIONAL
    CHANGE  IN
   ELBOW CAUSES
    ADDITIONAL
   IMPACTION AND
     DROPLET
  AGGLOMERATION
                                     SCRUBBING
                                  -WATER SPRAYS
                                   INTO VENTURI.
                                                                                 FLY ASH PARTICLES
                                                                                    AND GAS IN
>                                              TURBULENT
                                             1IXING SECTION
   TO
SEPARATOR
WATER IS SPRAYED
  INTO VENTURI
 INLET AND WETS
 ASH  PARTICLES.
                                DETAIL OF VENTURI
                                                                                 VENTURI  THROAT 	
  o
  o
  o
  JO
  C
  (D
                                                          CLEAN WATER RETURNS
                                                              TO VENTURI
                                                                              SETTLING POND
                                                                                                               WATER/AIR
                                                                                                               SEPARATION
                                                                                                                CHAMBER
                                                                                                                     CLEAN GAS
                                                                                                                        OUT
                                                                                                        WATER/ASH
                                                                                                       SLURRY  FLOWS
                                                                                                        BY GRAVITY
                                                                                                          TO THE
                                                                                                      SETTLING POND.
  v>
  TJ
  tt>
  n
                Figure  3-18.   Flow diagram of  a typical  venturi  scrubber system.

-------
outlet  causes  particles to  impinge  on the  wet surface  for  further particle
removal and  liquid  agglomeration.   The wet exhaust air  then  enters  a cyclone
or baffle  separator,  where  the  liquid separates from the  gas  by centrifugal
force or impaction  and  drains out the bottom of the separator.   The  clean gas
discharges at the top of the separator.
     Venturi efficiency can be adjusted by increasing or decreasing the liquid
flow rate.   Also,  some  Venturis  have adjustable throats  to accommodate vari-
able gas  flows.   The collection  efficiency of  a  venturi  scrubber  increases
with energy consumption.
3.8.1  External Inspection
     To evaluate venturi scrubber performance,  first confirm water circulation
through the  system.   Figure  3-19  is an example of  a data sheet for describing
the venturi scrubber.   Sketch the scrubber system on the form and identify the
orientation  of the  various  system  components.   The additional  information
called  for  on this form will  help  you to determine  the  overall  condition of
the  unit.    In  general, low  pump  pressure indicates  erosion of  the  nozzles
and/or  the  pump impeller,  which  results  in  an increase  in  the  water spray
droplet size and a reduction in particle collection efficiency.   Baseline data
are very useful when evaluating a venturi.
     Venturi scrubbers  are  usually  not used for particulate  control  on coal-
fired boilers because the sulfur in the coal forms  sulfuric acid in the water.
If the  pH  of the  water falls below 6, the acid will attack carbon steel.   The
pH is easily measured with pH paper.   Scrubbers are sometimes used on wood- or
bark-fired  boilers.   Caustic is  sometimes added to the water  to control  pH.
     If the  recirculation  water  is  not settled or  otherwise cleaned  properly,
solids  in the  water can erode or plug the nozzles.   The water can also get so
dirty that it will  not effectively collect additional  solids.
3.8.2  Internal Inspection
     During  the  internal  inspection, check  the  spray  nozzles  for scaling,
corrosion, or  erosion.   Venturi  internals are susceptible to corrosion, espe-
cially  around  welds and  at  the bottom  of the  skirt that forms  the venturi
cone.   Turbulent   conditions  in  the  venturi  zone  accelerate  venturi  skirt
corrosion by removing the particulate buildup and thereby exposing fresh metal
to continuous attack.

Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                Control Equipment Inspection
10/81                                 3-35

-------
          Source name
          Inspector _
                  VENTUR1 SCRUBBER DESCRIPTION
                    rJ^JL^uS^    Date    n/nr.  2.0.  I38&
                                    Scrubber No.     \1-J-
Type of scrubber
Manufacturer _ U.S.
                                              Installation date    1312.
Gas  flow, acfm
Gas  temperature, °F
Pressure drop across the scrubber,  in. water
Liquid flow, gal/min
Nozzle pressure, psi
Liquid pH

Comments
 Design
40,000
  3SQ'f
                                                                   Actual
                                                      IZQ<
                                                       6.5
                                                                    AZOcL
                                 SKETCH THE VENTURI SCRUBBER
                                                                  r» ST/»C K.
         Figure  3-19.    Example  of venturi  scrubber  description data  sheet.
Industrial Boiler  Inspection Guide
10/81                                      3-36
                                              Control  Equipment Inspection

-------
3.9  CYCLONES
     Cyclones are commonly used to control particulate emissions from boilers.
They come  in  many different sizes and  shapes,  but the principle of operation
is the  same  in  all  units.  As shown in Figure 3-20, the cyclone consists of a
cylindrical section  on top  of a conical section.  The  dust-laden  air enters
the cylindrical  section tangentially, and the centrifugal force created by the
air as  it spins  around in  the  cyclone pushes the particulate  matter to the
wall.   Air flows spirally downward through the unit and then upward out of the
unit through  the  central  exhaust.   The conical section accelerates the circu-
lating air and increases the centrifugal forces that push the particles to the
wall  of the  cyclone.   The  particles  then  slide  down  the cyclone  wall  and
through  a  valve  into  a collection  chamber.   A system  consisting  of several
smaller cyclones is generally more efficient than a single large cyclone.  For
a multiple-cyclone unit to  operate at maximum effiency, dust distribution and
the pressure drop across each cyclone must be relatively equal.
3.9.1   External  Inspection
     Air  leaks  in the  body  of  the collector or through the bottom valve are
the most  common  external  problems  encountered with cyclone collectors.  These
leaks create  turbulence within the cyclone and cause a net loss in collection
efficiency.   Figure 3-21  is an  example of  a  cyclone-description  data sheet.
Sketch the cyclone collector on this sheet  and  show  its orientation relative
to the  boiler and other equipment.  The  additional  information  called for on
this form  will  help you to determine the  overall  condition of the collector.
The seal between the collection hopper and the cyclone must be  well  maintained
to prevent air  from  leaking into or out of the cyclone.  If the ash discharge
valve fails  or  the collection  hopper  fills  up and blocks  the discharge from
the cyclone,  material  may accumulate  inside  to  the  point that the cyclone
ceases to function.
     A  cyclone  system  has an  optimum  gas flow rate at  which  particulate re-
moval  efficiency  is highest.   Excessive gas flows  occur when  the  boiler load
is very  high, and lower air flows  occur when the boiler  load is  low.  Well-
designed  systems provide for  the  recycling  of  boiler  stack gases during
periods  of low  boiler  load  so as  to  maintain optimum air velocities in the
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                Control Equipment Inspection
10/81                                 3-37

-------
                                              CLEAN AIR
                                                 OUT
                                                             DIRTY AIR
                                                                 IN
                           TOP VIEW OF CYCLONE
                                    CLEAN AIR OUT
 OUTLET PIPE EXTENDS
   INTO THE CYCLONE
 TO PREVENT INLET AIR
 FROM SHORT-CIRCUITING
DIRECTLY TO THE OUTLET




c
\
1
1
1
1
it
t:1

•. '• ••.'.
... , :l
'<* ' DTRTY AIR
£ "•-:'. • '• INLET

              SLEEVE TO
             PREVENT ASH
             FROM BLOWING
                 OUT
            THE SPINNING AIR FORCES THE
           ASH TO THE WALL OF THE CYCLONE
          A SLOW-SPEED MOTOR TURNS
         THE  "STAR"  VALVE THAT  SEALS
         THE COLLECTION  HOPPER FROM
                THE CYCLONE
                                          PARTICULATE
                                           COLLECTION
                                             HOPPER
                                            OR DRUM
             Figure  3-20.  Flow diagram of a dry cyclone collector.
 Industrial Boiler  Inspection Guide
 10/81
3-38
            Control Equipment Inspection

-------
CYCLONE DESCRIPTION
Source Name XY2 dh,

Solids discharge rate, characterize T^v^Lwy va£v4. iltji
fuma aZl~
A
T /'O/OI
Comments:


SKETCH THE CYCLONE SYSTEM
f-f>f* -J "/• 	 > /5r/»CK.)
_ •*! 1 ^*^___^/
R0"-f ^ •) 1 1
v -M
i

           Figure 3-21.   Example of cyclone description data sheet.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81                                 3-39
Control Equipment Inspection

-------
cyclone.   In some multiple-cyclone systems, operators can handle reduced loads
by shutting  off one  or  more banks.   You should note  this  under "Comments."
3.9.2  Internal Inspection
     During the internal  cyclone inspection,  be sure to note plugged or eroded
hoppers .  and  tubes.   Also,  look for  eroded  inlet vanes  and hopper  short-
circuiting.   Call any problems  to the attention of  the plant representative.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide             Control Equipment Inspection
10/81                                  3-40

-------
                                   SECTION 4
                               BOILER INSPECTION

     In the course of your inspections of pollution control equipment you will
find that  gas,  oil,  and coal are three principal boiler fuels.   The following
paragraphs  briefly  describe the  characteristics of boilers fired  by each of
these fuels.
     Gas-fired boilers rarely have significant pollution control problems, and
there  should be  no visible  emissions  from the stack.   Carbon  monoxide and
nitrogen  oxides limits  for boilers  covered  by NSPS  restrict the  range of
allowable operating conditions for these boilers.  Generally, you will only be
able to check  excess  air readings to estimate whether the boilers are running
properly.    Most gas-fired boilers  are  equipped with an  oxygen monitor.   The
oxygen  level  at the boiler outlet  should  be well  under 5 percent;  if it ex-
ceeds this amount,  nitrogen oxides emissions may be excessive.   Typical oxygen
levels will  be  less  than 1 percent.  For these boilers, you should be able to
obtain steam rates  in  pounds per hour,  steam pressure,  and steam temperature.
Fuel consumption rates also may be available.
     Most oil-fired boilers  use  either  No. 2 oil or No.  6 oil.   The operating
problems of  boilers  fired with No.  2 oil are not much different from those of
gas-fired boilers.   There  should be no visible  emissions  from  the stack, and
sulfur dioxide  emissions will be very  low.   The  oxygen  level  in  the boiler
exhaust gas  will generally be 1  to 2 percent.   Any visible particulate matter
indicates unburned carbon and calls for an increase in excess air.  You should
be able to  obtain  a recent fuel   analysis  showing  the sulfur and heat content
of the  fuel.  Visible  emissions from the  stack may be a problem  on boilers
firing No. 6 oil.  The sulfur content of this grade of oil is above 1 percent,
and the vanadium content often causes the further oxidation of sulfur dioxide
to sulfur  trioxide, which produces  an acid  mist plume.   Generally this plume
will be white.   If  the boiler is out of adjustment,  however,  unburned carbon
may cause a black plume.  Because No.  6 oil is heavy and difficult to atomize,

Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                           Boiler Inspection
10/81                                 4-1

-------
it  requires  preheating and  atomization  (mechanical, hot air,  or  steam).   In
many installations, oil burners  must be cleaned at  least  once per shift.   If
you  note  a  plume  opacity  problem,  determine when  the  burners were  last
cleaned.   These boilers  are also  equipped with  soot  blowers,   and  special
provisions in  the  regulations  may allow some opacity excursions  during soot-
blowing  operations.   Opacity  excursions may  also  occur  during  startup  and
shutdown.
     Coal-fired boilers include  hand-fired,  stoker-fired,  and pulverized-coal
units.    The  hand-fired boilers  generally do not have  sophisticated controls,
and they tend to smoke considerably, especially when the furnace box is opened
up  to  add coal.   The operation  of stoker-fired boilers requires  careful  ad-
justments of stoker  feed,  overfire air, and underfire  air.   Pulverized coal-
fired  boilers  are  usually equipped  with  sophisticated  combustion-control
systems.   During  your inspection,  count the number  of pulverizers that  are
running.   If  one or  more  pulverizers  are  not operating, the  coal  going into
the boiler  could be  too  coarse, which can cause  excessive  particulate emis-
sions.   This might not be the cause, however,  if boiler rate has been reduced.
Use  a  recent  fuel  analysis to  determine  whether the  boiler is  meeting  S02
restrictions.
     Figure 4-1  is  an example of a boiler-description data  sheet.  The data
sheet is  shown  filled out in Appendix B.  The  boiler  designation  (Line 1) is
taken from  Figure  3-2 (boiler  equipment identification).  Use  two columns to
indicate  boilers  that burn  more  than one  type of  fuel  during the  year.
Describe the boiler operation by listing the capacity factor and the number of
days of  operation for each  fuel  (Lines  2  and 3).    Show the  average capacity
factor  and  days-of operation for  the  previous  calendar year  or for a recent
12-month period.   If  the  calendar year is  not used,  note this in the comments
section.  The  capacity  factor  is the ratio of the average  steam output to the
rated steam output of the boiler.
     Enter the  boiler manufacturer  on Line 4 and  the  installation date  (to
determine  if  the boiler  is  an  NSPS  unit)  on  Line  5.   Indicate  the  type of
boiler  (e.g.,   fire-tube,  water-tube,  pulverized-coal,  underfeed  stoker) on
Line 6.
     Fuel  data  are entered on Line 7a through  g.   These include  the  type of
fuel (oil, gas,  coal, bagasse,  etc.) and the sulfur, ash,  and heat content of
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                           Boiler Inspection
10/81                                 4-2

-------
O =>
•*x Q.
00 C
  1
  ^*

  0*
  CD
  O
  n
  -j
  •a
  n
  rt
  C
  «J.

  Q.
U)
  00

  O
  n
  v>
  •o
  (D
  n

C. BOILER DATA
1. Boiler designation (Checklist B)
2. Average capacity factor during 19 	 *
3. Hours of operation during 19 	
4. Boiler manufacturer
5. Year boiler placed in service
6. Type of boiler
7. Fuel data
a . Type
b. Sulfur content (coal and oil
only)**
c. Ash content (coal only)**
d. Heat content**
e. Rated maximum consumption**
f . Actual maximum consumption**
g. Consumption during inspection**
8. Steam production
a. Rated maximum production**
b. Actual maximum production**
c. Production during Inspection**






















































Additional comments

Average capacity factor Is based on 7e, rated maximum fuel consumption.
»*
Give units.

                                 Figure 4-1.   Example of  boiler description  data sheet.

-------
the fuel.  The  rated  maximum fuel consumption refers  to  the boiler nameplate
capacity; the actual  maximum fuel consumption is the  maximum  historical  rate
for the  boiler  operation.   Indicate  units of measurement for all  data in this
table.   Data  on the  ash  content of  coal  and the sulfur contents  of  oil  and
coal  allow  you  to estimate  particulate  and  sulfur dioxide  emissions.   For
example, if a boiler  burns bituminous coal with a 3.3 percent ash content and
a 0.7 percent sulfur  content and is  equipped  with  a cyclone collector, emis-
sions calculations (based on AP-42)  can be made as follows:
     Particulate emission factor = 2 x ash content
     (Ib/ton coal burned)
                                 = 2 x 3.3
     Particulate emission factor =6.6 Ib/ton of coal burned
     Sulfur oxides emission factor = 38 x sulfur content
     (Ib/ton coal burned)
                                   = 38 x 0.7
     Sulfur oxides emission factor = 26.6 Ib/ton of coal burned.
     Emission  levels   generated   from AP-42  data  are  approximate.   Only  an
on-site  source  test can  provide  data of sufficient accuracy for initiation of
legal action.   AP-42 data may indicate if a stack test is required.
     If  a  boiler that  is  designed to  burn coal with an ash content  of 9.0
percent and a heating value of 11,470 Btu/lb burns coal with an ash content of
20  percent  and  a heating  value  of  9,600  Btu/lb,  the coal-handling  and  the
ash-handling systems may be overtaxed when the boiler operates at capacity.   A
boiler  requires  a significantly  greater quantity of  coal  to meet the steam
load  demand  when it  burns a coal  of a  lower grade than it  was  designed to
burn.  When ash-removal  facilities  are not adequate, burning lower-grade coal
can impair ESP efficiency or even damage the ESP (e.g., warped plates, shorted
electrodes) by overfilling the ash hoppers.
     Steam production  data are  summarized on Lines 8a, b,  and c.   Fuel  con-
sumption  and  steam production  should  correspond.    Although  both  items  are
included on the  checklist,  most  sources maintain records  for  only one of the
parameters.   If  both  are  recorded,  the numbers  can  be crosschecked to deter-
mine consistency.

Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                           Boiler Inspection
10/81                                 4-4

-------
     Generally, boiler instrumentation data (for inclusion in Figure 4-2) will
be available  from  the  control  room.   All of  the  data called for on this form
will not be available for most industrial boilers because small boilers gener-
ally are  not well-instrumented.  Be  sure  to  indicate units for  all  data re-
corded on  this  form,  and be aware that instruments will  sometimes give faulty
readings.
     Lower-than-specified exhaust  temperatures may indicate that  a boiler is
operating under high excess air conditions,  which reduce boiler efficiency and
increase nitrogen  oxides  emissions.   Sometimes,  however, low temperatures may
be caused by air in-leakage after the combustion chamber.
     Note the oxygen level of the exhaust gas.  Typical oxygen levels for good
boiler operation  are 0.5 to 1  percent  for  gas-fired boilers, 1  to 3 percent
for oil-fired boilers,  5 to 6 percent for pulverized-coal-fired boilers, and 7
to 8  percent for  stoker-fired  boilers.   (A 5 percent oxygen  level  in boiler
exhaust gas  is equivalent to  about  20  percent excess air.)   Note that these
conditions represent oxygen  levels  at the boiler firebox outlet, and they may
differ significantly  from oxygen  levels  in  the  stack because  of in-leakage
through ductwork and the air preheater.
     Large industrial  boilers  maintain  opacity  records  in  the  control room.
Inspect opacity charts  for  the 24 hours preceding  the  inspection to identify
any irregularity  in  the boiler operation.   Most  opacity meters  automatically
calibrate  at regular  intervals.   This  shows  on  the strip  chart as  a short
spike  to   100  percent   opacity.   If  the boiler  has  a  continuous SO   or NO
                                                                     /\       /\
meter,  the past performance should also be checked.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                           Boiler Inspection
10/81                                 4-5

-------
O 3
^v Q.
00 C
M V>
  <•«•
  -J
  _4.
  01
  -o
  m
  n
4*
                                                     0.  INSTRUMENTATION DATA
1. Boiler designation
2. Steam production*
3. Fuel consumption*
4. A1r flow
5. Exhaust gas
a. Temperature*
b. COz*
c. 02*
d. S02*
e. NOX*
f. Opacity*
6. Fuel pressure (oil or
gas)*
7. Fuel temperature/oil only*







































                    Additional observations:
  CD
  o
  ft)
  -j
                    Give units.
  n
  d-
                                 Figure  4-2.   Example  of boiler  instrumentation data sheet.

-------
                                  APPENDIX A

                         BOILER INSPECTION CHECKLISTS


     This appendix provides blank  checklists  that may be copied and used when

conducting boiler inspections.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                  Appendix A
10/81                                 A-l

-------
                           BOILER INSPECTION CHECKLIST
                              SOURCE IDENTIFICATION
                      Date(s) of inspection 	
                      Time in           Out
Company name
Mailing address
Location of facility
 (Include county)
 Type of industry _
 Form of ownership
 Corporate address
Corporate personnel           Name                 Title            Phone
Responsible for
facility              	  	  	
Responsible for
environmental
matters
Company personnel
contacted
Confidentiality
statement given to
State or local
agency personnel
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide                                Appendix A
10/81                                  A-2

-------
                       BOILER EQUIPMENT IDENTIFICATION


Source name	      Date _

Inspector   	
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                  Appendix A
10/81                                  _

-------
SOURCE NAME,

ADDRESS
VISIBLE EMISSION OBSERVATION FORM

                    OBSERVER
                    DATE
POINT OF EMISSION
OBSERVATION
POINT
STACK: DISTANCE FROM
WINDSPEED




HEIGHT
DIRECTION
SKY CONDITION:
COLOR OF EMISSION:
RELATIVE HUMIDITY:
BACKGROUND:


AMBIENT AIR TEMPERATURE:
CERTIFICATION DATE:




SUMMARY OF AVERAGE OPACITY
Set
Number




Time
Start—End




Opacity
Sum




Observer x
Sunx> Wind — ^ Plume and
OC=T
Sou
c
Obse
*ce
>
*ver
V
Average




Stack
——
Remarks:


0
i
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
II
12
n
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
0






























15






























30






























45












•


















30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
0






























15






























30






























45































                                         I have received a copy of these opacity
                                         readings.
Evaluator's Signature:
                                         Title:
                                             Date:
   Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide
   10/81                              A-4
                                             Appendix A

-------
                                FAN DATA SHEET

Source name                                   Date
Inspector	       Fan No.
1.   FAN MOTOR
     Manufacturer
     Model No. 	  Type
     Rated horsepower 	
     Volts	  Maximum amps _
     Maximum rpm 	  Service factor
     Operating current:  Panel 	Other _
2.   DRIVE
     Direct	Belt	Other
     Pulley reduction 	
     Audible belt slippage:  Yes 	No
3.   FAN
     Manufacturer
     Model No. 	Service
     Fan vibration
     Gas temperature at inlet, °F
     Fan rpm 	
     Fan static pressures:   Inlet	Outlet	
     Differential static pressures:  Measured 	Panel
     Fan housing condition 	
     Dampers 	
     Fan exit 	
     Gas flow from fan curve
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide                                  Appendix  A
10/81                                  A~5

-------
                             FABRIC  FILTER DESCRIPTION

 Source name                              Date
 Inspector   	  Fabric  filter  No.
 Date installed                           Manufacturer
                      2
 Total  filter area,  ft  	  Gas  flow,  acfm
 Air/cloth ratio:   Net 	  Gross  	
 Cleaning system:   Type 	
                   Cleaning  frequency
                   Pressure drop before cleaning
                   Cleaning controlled  by  AP 	  Time
 Operating temperature 	
 Comments
                SKETCH  THE  FABRIC  FILTER  AND  LABEL  THE  COMPARTMENTS
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide                                Appendix A
10/81                                  A-6

-------
Source name

Inspector
                  FABRIC FILTER COMPARTMENT EXTERNAL INSPECTION
Date
Fabric filter No.
1.   Static pressure (inches W.G.)
Compartment








Plant's instruments
Clean
side








Dirty
side








Differential








Inspector's instruments
Clean
side








Dirty
side








Differential








Comments:  (Note any in-leakage of air or signs of corrosion.)
2.   Isolation check
Isolated compartment
Opacity
A

B

C

D

E

F

Comments:
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81                                A-7
                        Appendix  A

-------
                              ESP  DESCRIPTION
Source name
Inspector


Date
ESP No.
Date installed
Manufacturer
2
Total ft plate area
Gas flow, acfm
SCA, ft2/! 000 acfm
Temperature, °F
Coal sulfur content, %
Face velocity, ft/m
Design
Design
Design
Design
Design
Actual
Actual
Actual
Actual
Actual
                 SKETCH THE  ESP AND LABEL THE FIELDS  (TR SET)
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81
                              Appendix  A
A-8

-------
O 3
--» Q.
CO C
—i 
   -5
  T3
   n>
   O
   n-

   o


   o
   c
  vo
                                                          ESP  ELECTRICAL DATA
Location














TR set
No.














Primary
voltage, V
Present














Base














Primary
current, A
Present














Base














Secondary
Voltage, kV
Present














Base














Secondary
current, mA .
Present














Base














Spark rate,
sparks/mi n
Present














Base














   CO
   3
   Q.
   —j.
   X

-------
Source name 	
Inspector 	
Rappers
Rapper location:  Top
Rapper type:  Air 	
                           EXTERNAL ESP INSPECTION
        Date
 Rapping frequency:  TR No. 1
                    TR No. 3
 Top  housing condition 	
        ESP No.
               Side
Electrical
Mechanical
                TR No.  2
                TR No.  4
 Insulator condition
Fan and purge-air filter condition
Comments
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81                                 A-10
                                   Appendix A

-------
                     VENTURI SCRUBBER DESCRIPTION

Source name                              Date
Inspector	  Scrubber No.
Type of scrubber	  Installation date
Manufacturer
                                                  Design         Actual
Gas flow, acfm                                  	     	
Gas temperature, °F                             	     	
Pressure drop across the scrubber, in. water    	     	
Liquid flow, gal/min                            	     	
Nozzle pressure, psi                            	     	
Liquid pH                                       	     	

Comments
                          SKETCH THE VENTURI SCRUBBER
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                 Appendix A
10/81                                A-ll

-------
                              CYCLONE DESCRIPTION
Source Name                               Date
Inspector	   Cyclone No.
Type of cyclone	   Installation date_
Manufacturer                         	
                                                        Design      Actual
Gas flow, acfm                                         	    	
Gas temperature, °F                                    	    	
Pressure drop across the collector, in.  water          	    	
Audible air leakage at hatches	
Solids discharge rate, characterize_
Comments:
                           SKETCH THE CYCLONE SYSTEM
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                Appendix A
10/81                                   A-12

-------
O 3
•^ Q.
00 C
— i V)
rf
-s
to
DO
0
CD
-s
t—t
3
(A
•o
n>
0
r+
o'
3
CT>
C
Q-
fB
3=-
_^
CO
BOILER DATA
1. Boiler designation (Checklist B)
2. Average capacity factor during 19 	 *
3. Hours of operation during 19 	
4. Boiler manufacturer
5. Year boiler placed in service
6. Type of boiler
7. Fuel data
a . Type
b. Sulfur content (coal and oil
only)**
c. Ash content (coal only)**
d. Heat content**
e. Rated maximum consumption**
f. Actual maximum consumption**
g. Consumption during inspection**
8. Steam production
a. Rated maximum production**
b. Actual maximum production**
c. Production during inspection**






















































O>
3
CL

X
    Additional  comments
    **
 Average capacity factor is based on 7e,  rated maximum fuel  consumption.
k
 Give units.

-------
ndustrial Boiler Inspection Guide
0/81 A'1 4
INSTRUMENTATION DATA
1. Boiler designation
2. Steam production*
3. Fuel consumption*
4. Air flow
5. Exhaust gas
a. Temperature*
b. C02*
c. 02*
d. S02*
e. NOX*
f. Opacity*
6. Fuel pressure (oil or
gas)*
7. Fuel temperature/oil only*













-

























•a
•a
CD
3
a.

x
    Additional observations:
     Give units.

-------
                                  APPENDIX B

                        SAMPLE BOILER INSPECTION REPORT


     This appendix contains  an  example  inspection report.   If your agency has

no particular report design,  you may want to use this format.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                  Appendix B
10/81                                 B-l

-------
                           BOILER INSPECTION REPORT
                                  RST COMPANY
                             1500 COMMERCE STREET
                           LIMA, MISSISSIPPI  39121

     On April 16, 1981, Bruce Williams inspected the boilers at RST Company in
Lima, Mississippi.   During this  boiler  inspection Mr. Tim Hume,  Chief Engi-
neer, and Mr. Barry Jones, Plant Supervisor, accompanied me.

PROCESS DESCRIPTION
     RST Company  manufactures fertilizers  at  this location.   Two coal-fired
(spreader stoker)  boilers (B-l  and  B-2) are  associated  with  the fertilizer
plant.    These  boilers  provide process  steam  for the  plant and  heating  for
office areas.  The plant receives sized coal with an average sulfur content of
0.7  percent  and  a  heat content  of  about 13,800 Btu/lb.   These  figures were
obtained from coal company invoices.
     Flue gas from each boiler discharges into a multicyclone to remove parti-
culate matter.
     A common  vacuum type ash handling  system  is used to  convey bottom ash
from the boilers  and fly ash  from the multicyclone  to a silo.   Ash stored in
the  silo is  removed by truck to a disposal  site.  Water is mixed with the ash
during truck loading to minimize dusting.
Applicable Regulations
     The "Air Quality  Regulations"  (APC-S-1) of the Mississippi Air and Water
Pollution Control  Commission  are applicable  to  this  facility  and  regulate
opacity,  particulate mass emissions,  and S02 as follows:
     Opacity -  not to exceed 40 percent
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                  Appendix B
10/81                                 B-2

-------
     Mass Emissions - not to exceed the amount given by

                    E=0.8803Q-°-1665

              where E = allowable emissions in lb/106 Btu
                    Q = heat input, 106 Btu/h

     Sulfur Dioxide - not to exceed 4.8 lb/106 Btu heat input.


RESULTS OF INSPECTION

     The  visible  emission readings  showed an average opacity of  19  percent.

Table 1 estimates  the  particulate  emissions from Boilers 1 and 2  at  0.42 lb/
106  Btu.   The  allowable  emissions  are  0.49 lb/106  Btu  for  Boiler 1   and

0.42 lb/106 Btu for  Boiler  2.   Sulfur dioxide emissions for both  boilers are
estimated at 0.99 lb/106 Btu.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                  Appendix B
10/81                                 B-3

-------
                  TABLE 1.   PARTICULATE EMISSION EVALUATION.
               Particulate emission   Allowable
   Process    estimate  (1b/106 Btu)  emission*1
                                  particulate
                                  (1b/106 Btu)
Boiler No.  1
Boiler No.  2
         0.42
         0.42
            0.49
            0.42
      Maximum heat
   inputc (106 Btu/h)

         33.0
         83.0
                 TABLE 2.   SULFUR DIOXIDE EMISSION EVALUATION.
   Process

Boiler No.
Boiler No.
  Sulfur dioxide
emission estimate0
   (1b/106 Btu)

       0.99
       0.99
  Allowable sulfur
  dioxide emission
estimate5 (1b/106 Btu)

        4.8
        4.8
  Maximum heat
inputc (106 Btu/h)

      33.0
      83.0
 Calculated from AP-42 data.

 Calculated using Mississippi State Regulations.

CSupplied by RST Company.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81
                        B-4
                                                      Appendix B

-------
                         BOILER INSPECTION CHECKLISTS
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                  Appendix B
10/81                                 B-5

-------
                           BOILER INSPECTION  CHECKLIST
                              SOURCE IDENTIFICATION
                      Date(s)  of inspection
                      Time in
                                   HRs,  Out
                                                /3/e>
Company name
Mailing address
                 ffS T
                                                         "3 3 ' 2,
Location of facility   S<^»n£  CL*L,  -vn/xx^-M^  atLthjl^A/ .   ff) OM-00 00
                                                                            - oo oo
                                                                             ooo
k&O) GQG-Qi
 (OOP) t>oo~ooc>o
 Industrial  Boiler Inspection  Guide
 10/81                                 B"6
                                                                    Appendix B

-------
                     BOILER EQUIPMENT IDENTIFICATION
Source name   ffS7~
Inspector    8/
                                            Date
     N
                  8-1
                         S-l

                         f-n

                         c-i
        8-1    La.

        6-2
          -2
                          60,000
                       5 - £
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81                              B-7
                                                            Appendix B

-------
SOURCE NAME   /?ST

ADDRESS  ISOO
                         VISIBLE EMISSION OBSERVATION FORM

                                             OBSERVER
                                             DATE
POINT OF EMISSION S+a-JL 5~2. ffn^nv ber&*. 8 -1 )
OBSERVATION
POINT Qsim<*J jt
/
^

STACK: DISTANCE FROM 60-feHEIGHT ^p-ft
WINDSPEED 5Vb /0 MyoA DIRECTION S U/
SKY CONDITION: r^^uJ^j
COLOR OF EMISSION: ^^1
RELATIVE HUMIDITY: ° ^
BACKGROUND:
uJLte. t&rviA
-JGVo
^
AMBIENT AIR TEMPERATURE: &5°F
CERTIFICATION DATE:

WOA^JI

O I
G 1
SUMMARY OF AVERAGE OPACITY
Set
Number
/



Time
Start—End
1053- 1105



Opacity
Sum
Se>&



Observer x
Sun-6- Wind — ^ Plume and
ocr:
Sou
Obse
-ce
rver
X
Average
Zo<&



Stack
Remarks:


0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
II
12
n
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
0
15"
10
^o
25
25
20
























15
/S"
20
2.0
zs
20
SO
























30
20
'5
25
25
20
Zo
























45
25
20
20
30
25
20






•


















30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
0






























15






























30






























45































Evaluator's Signature:
                                         I  have received a copy of these opacity
                                                     .
                                         Title: 4JLJ£^U
                                                                      Date:
     ndustrfal Boiler Inspection Guide
     10/81                                 B-8
                                                                              ppendix B

-------
SOURCE NAME  RST

ADDRESS    / 5*00
                    VISIBLE EMISSION OBSERVATION FORM
                                        OBSERVER
                                        DATE
                                                   OpsuJ!
                         'SI
POINT OF EMISSION 5 ' +a.JL S - 2. / F/iem ^5°E
CERTIFICATION DATE:

WlcvLcJi '%L
SUMMARY OF AVERAGE OPACITY
Set
Number
/



Observe
Sunxjv
Time
Start—End
1107- 1113



Opacity
Sum Average
y-ss 19. o



" X
Wind — i* Plume and Stack
Sou
Obse
S
rver
X
Remarks:


0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
n
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
0
Zo
ZO
15
10
15
ZO
























15
Zo
Z0
IS
10
ZO
BO
























30
Zo
zr
IB
1?
2^
2r
























45
Zo
zr
IB

2S
2£






•


















30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
3S
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
0






























15






























30






























45































I have received a copy of these opacity
readings. . ..
Evaluator's Signature:

      8.
Industrial  Boiler  Inspection Guide
10/81
Title:.

 B-9
                                                                 Date:
                                                                       Appendix 6

-------
                               FAN DATA SHEET
Source name   ff ST
Inspector     3 ,
1
     FAN MOTOR
     Manufacturer
                                              Date
                                              Fan No.
                            t* ' -> ,  r gtvi L& ,
                                                               /6   19 & /
                                                        F - I
                                                             i 6-2)
Model No. y-O&
Type Tin.
/c
Rated horsepower 4
-------
                                FAN  DATA  SHEET
 Source name    ff 5T
 Inspector    0.
Date
                                             Fan  No.   F-Z.
                                                            t  16, /3?l
1.    FAN MOTOR
     Manufacturer
                         U.S.
Model No. BO1
$
Type TEfC

Rated horsepower "7 £
Volts E3O,
/
Maximum rpm
Operating current:

17 GO
Panel
Maximum amps / $O /
Service factor /, /_5"
Other
90


     DRIVE
     Direct
                           Belt
     Pulley reduction
     Audible belt slippage:   Yes
      Other
                                                  No
               X
 3.   FAN
     Manufacturer
     Model No.
                          U,  5,   F
     Fan vibration 	
     Gas temperature at inlet,  °F
     Fan rpm 	
                                                   Service
     Fan static  pressures:  Inlet	•
     Differential  static pressures:  Measured
     Fan housing condition 	
     Dampers 	
     Fan exit
                                                Outlet
                                                       Panel
                                      a   Q-Tdja/K-
     Gas flow from fan curve
Industrial  Boiler  Inspection Guide
10/81                                B-ll
                                                                 Appendix B

-------
Source Name  fPST
             *~^
                             CYCLONE DESCRIPTION
                                         Date
Inspector  8-
                                         Cyclone No.     C- 3.
Type of cyclone_
Manufacturer    U> S»
                                         Installation date
Gas flow,  acfm
Gas temperature,  °F
Pressure drop across  the  collector, in. water
Audible air leakage at  hatches	
                                                       Design      Actual
                                                       350        3B0
Solids discharge  rate,  characterize
                          SKETCH THE CYCLONE SYSTEM

FLi>e JAS I
ft** e-i
C-l
-J'r -T
>LF-3L

 Industrial Boiler Inspection  Guide
 10/81                                B-12
                                                                   Appendix B

-------
Source Name_
Inspector	
                              CYCLONE DESCRIPTION
                                         Date
                                                            /&
                                         Cyclone No.
Type of cyclone  JYLuJfct*. -
Manufacturer	J4. S,
                           c^
                                         Installation date
Gas flow, acfm
Gas temperature,  °F
Pressure drop across  the  collector,  in. water
Audible air leakage at hatches	
                                                       Design      Actual
                                                      30,000     £0,300
                                                       35O
Solids discharge rate,  characterize
                           SKETCH THE CYCLONE SYSTEM
  Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide
  10/81                                 B-13
                                                                    Appendix B

-------
ndustrial Boiler Inspection Guide
0/81 B-14
BOILER DATA
1. Boiler designation (Checklist B)
2. Average capacity factor during 19735k
3. Hours of operation during 19 	
4. Boiler manufacturer
5. Year boiler placed in service
6. Type of boiler
7. Fuel data
a. Type
b. Sulfur content (coal and oil
only)**
c. Ash content (coal only)**
d. Heat content**
e. Rated maximum consumption**
f. Actual maximum consumption**
g. Consumption during inspection**
8. Steam production
a. Rated maximum production**
b. Actual maximum production**
c. Production during inspection**
8-1
o.ZS"
398O (b/f|
19^O "'/A
1C 8O '*»/Ai

Z+,000 lk/h
13) ZOO lb/h
ie>,?oe> */h
G-'Z
O.to
4973
AC& \>o*Jb+ Cer.
/3S &
SpSVLajt* St>&^

$ Ztu**U*10tA4. C&CL&.
0.7?*.
(o *?•
fSfS&O 8TtJ/IB
£,000 Ib/h
4- $eo lk/h
*te>oo ty/h

GO; 000 M/h
*t-Q)OO0 Ib/h
*t-Oj600 '^//i


















T3
T3
ft)

Q.
     Additional  comments
CO
     **
 Average capacity factor is based on 7e, rated maximum  fuel  consumption.
k
 Give units.

-------
ndustrial Boiler Inspection Guide
0/81 B-15
INSTRUMENTATION DATA
1. Boiler designation
2. Steam production*
3. Fuel consumption*
4. Air flow
5. Exhaust gas
a. Temperature*
b. C02*
c. 02*
d. S02*
e. NOX*
f. Opacity*
6. Fuel pressure (oil or
gas)*
7. Fuel temperature/oil only*
8-1
IG>, YOO {Vh
IGXO '* /h


-3&0* F

4-*?o


Zff


3-Z.
? 0,600 U>/h
*tOOO 'b/fr


3 (oO^F

5*7*


£0















    Additional observations:
                                  au/i.
•a
•o
o.
X


DO
Give units.

-------
                                 CALCULATIONS


                             PARTICULATE EMISSIONS



This calculation applies to both boilers (B-l and B-2).


From AP-42 (page 1.1-3, 12/77 edition) particulate emissions in Ib/ton of coal

without any control device are given by 13A, where A equals percent ash.


     13 x 6 = 78 Ib/ton coal


The coal heat content is


     13,800 Btu/lb x 2000 Ib/ton = 27.6 x 106 Btu/ton


Based on the minimum efficiency of a cyclone (AP-42, p.  1.1-2,  12/77 edition),
controlled emissions are


     78 x (1 - 0.85) = 11.7 Ib/ton


In terms of pounds per million Btu's the emissions are


        11-7    = 0.42 lb/106 Btu
     27.6 x 106



The allowable emission rate is calculated by


      E= 0.8803Q-0'1665


where E = allowable emission, lb/106 Btu

      Q = maximum heat input, 106 Btu/lb



111

     c _ n QQn, ,2400 Ib/h x 13,800 Btu/1b^-o-1665
     t — U.ooUo ^	"\ft& 	'



       = 0.49 lb/106 Btu


B-2

     c _ n QQno ,6000 Ib/h x 13.800 Btu/lbx-o.i66s
     t - U.OOUJ t	J-Q6 	'



       = 0.42 lb/106 Btu


Both boilers are in compliance.  Boiler B-2 is just at the limit.



Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                  Appendix B

10/81                                 B-l6

-------
                              FLUE GAS FLOW RATE


     The flue gas flow rate is calculated using F-factors for bituminous coal.
The  F-factors  are  from "Continuous Air Pollution Source  Monitoring  Systems,"
EPA 625/6-79-005, page C-7.   The  boiler elevation is about  1000  ft  above sea
level .
B-1
B-2
H = 1680 Ib/h x 13,800 Btu/lb = 23.2 x 106 Btu/h
                                             .380
Arfm _ 23.2
Acfm ~
                   20.9
                     20.9  .
                        -  }
                                                            460 .
                                                         530
          = 8237 acfm
   H

Arf_
Acfm
            4000 Ib/h x 13,800 Btu/lb = 55.2 x 106 Btu/h
            55.2       ,   20.9  >                   -   380 + 460
                       ,
                       (
                   20.9 - 5
                                >
                                }
                                                         530
          = 20,300 acfm
                                                                 ,
                                                                 (
                                                                      30770
                                                                  30770 -  1000
                                                                              .
                                                                              }
                                                                      30770
                                                                  30770 -  1000
                                                                              .
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide
10/81
                                      B-17
                                                                    Appendix B

-------
                 PHOTOGRAPH NO.  1.   RST Company t>oiler stacks.
                  S-l  is on the left and S-2 is on the right.
Industrial
10/81
Boiler Inspection Guide
Appendix B
                           B-18

-------
                                   GLOSSARY
AIR HEATER  OR AIR  PREHEATER  - A  heat transfer device that heats  air  coming
     into the boiler with flue gas exhausting from the boiler.   This conserves
     energy and makes the boiler more efficient.

AIR INFILTRATION  - The  leakage of  air through cracks or other  openings  into
     the boiler duct system or control device.

ANALYSIS,  PROXIMATE -  A method  of  reporting  fuel  composition in terms  of
     moisture, volatile  matter, fixed carbon,  and ash, as a percentage  of the
     total weight of the fuel.

ANALYSIS, ULTIMATE  - An exact chemical analysis of the  fuels,  including  car-
     bon, hydrogen, sulfur,  nitrogen, oxygen, and ash  content.

ANTHRACITE - A type of coal, mined mostly in Pennsylvania that  contains  a  high
     fixed carbon content and low amount of volatile material.

ASH -  The incombustible solid matter in fuels,  usually mineral  in composition.

ASH-FREE BASIS -  A method of reporting fuel analyses  in which ash content is
     deducted and  the  other  constituents  are  recalculated to total  100  per-
     cent.

ASH PIT -  A pit  or hopper  located below  the  boiler where ash  accumulates
     until it is removed.

ATOMIZER  -  A device that reduces  liquid  into a very fine spray  for  combus-
     tion purposes.

AVAILABLE DRAFT -  The  draft that is utilized to force air into the combustion
     chamber  and  to  force  gaseous  combustion  products  out  of the  boiler.


                                      B

BAFFLE -  A  plate  or wall that deflects and changes the course  of  a  gas  or a
     liquid.

BAG FILTER - Another term for a fabric filter.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                    Glossary
10/81                                 1

-------
BANKING -  This term  applies  to stoker  boilers.   It refers  to  burning solid
     fuels at  a  very  slow rate in order  to  maintain ignition.   This is some-
     times done  when  steam is  not needed,  but the operator  does  not  want to
     shut the boiler down completely.

BASE LOAD - The rate at which a boiler is usually operated for long periods of
     time.

BITUMINOUS COAL  - A  coal  commonly  found in the  Appalachian  Region.   Heating
     values are typically 10,000 to  14,000 Btu/lb.

SLOWDOWN  -  The periodic or continual  removal  of small  amounts  of water from
     the  boiler  drum  to reduce  the  concentration  or  buildup  of  dissolved
     impurities and sludge.

BLOWER - A fan used to move air under pressure.

BOILER HORSEPOWER - A term sometimes used to denote the capacity of a boiler.
     One  boiler  horsepower  is equivalent  to 33,472 Btu/h of  steam  output.

BRITISH THERMAL UNIT (Btu) - The amount of heat required to raise the tempera-
     ture of 1 Ib of water 1°F; 1  Btu is about 252 calories.

BUNKER-C OIL  - Sometimes called residual  fuel  oil or No.  6 fuel  oil.   This is
     a viscous, low-grade oil  that must be heated before it can  be atomized in
     a boiler.
CAPACITY FACTOR -  The  ratio of the boiler  steam  production rate to its maxi-
     mum design steam load.

CHAIN GRATE STOKER  -  A stoker that has a moving endless chain as a grate sur-
     face.   Coal  is  fed directly  onto  this  chain from  a hopper  and moves
     across the combustion section of the boiler.

COMBUSTION RATE -  The  amount of  fuel  fired per unit of time,  such  as  pounds
     of coal  per hour,  or gallons of oil per hour.

CONDENSATE -  Water that has been condensed from steam.
DAMPER - A  device  for regulating the flow of gas or air by partially blocking
     the path of flow.

DAMPER LOSS - The reduction in static pressure of gas or air flowing through a
     damper.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                     Glossary
10/81                                   2

-------
DESIGN LOAD -  The  maximum steam production rate  that  a boiler is designed to
     produce.

DEW POINT - The  temperature at which condensation  begins.   References to the
     dew point of  flue  gas usually refer to the temperature at which sulfuric
     acid will begin to condense.

DIRECT-FIRED BOILER - A pulverized-coal  boiler that is  fed  directly from the
     coal pulverizers; it has no pulverized coal surge hold system.

DISTILLATE FUELS  - Liquid  fuels  distilled from  crude petroleum of a higher
     grade than No. 5 or No. 6 fuel oils.

DOWNCOMER - A boiler tube through which liquid flows downward.

DRUM --A cylindrical shell  designed to withstand  high  internal  pressures in
     which the steam separates from the water and leaves the boiler.

DRY STEAM - Steam containing no moisture,  or superheated steam.
ECONOMIZER -  A device  designed  to transfer heat from  the  gaseous  combustion
     products to the boiler feedwater.

EFFICIENCY - The  ratio  of the amount of energy leaving the boiler in steam to
     the amount of energy fed to the boiler in fuel.

ENTRAINMENT -  The conveying  of  droplets of  water  from the  boiler  by steam.

EVAPORATION RATE  -  The  number of pounds of water evaporated per unit of time.

EXCESS AIR -  Air  supplied to burn the fuel  in excess of the air theoretically
     required for complete oxidation.
FEEDWATER - Water introduced into the boiler to replace lost steam and conden-
     sate.  This water includes returning condensate, as well as treated fresh
     water.

FEEDWATER TREATMENT - A treatment of boiler feedwater by the addition of chemi-
     cals,  ionic  exchange,  and  deaeration  to remove minerals  and  gases that
     would be harmful to the boiler.

FIREBOX -  A term  sometimes  used to describe  the  furnace section of a boiler.

FIRE POINT  -  The  lowest temperature at which  fuel  oil  gives off enough vapor
     to burn continuously when ignited.


Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                    Glossary
10/81                                 3

-------
 FIRE  TUBE - A boiler design  in which the  hot combustion products pass through
      the  tubes and  the water  is on the outside of the tubes.

 FLAME DETECTOR  -   A  device  that  indicates the  presence  of a  flame  in the
      boiler.  This  is usually part of the  safety system.

 FLUE  - A  passage for the  gaseous products  of combustion.

 FLUE  GAS  -  The gaseous products of combustion that  leave the  boiler.

 FLY  ASH  - The fine particles of  ash that are carried  out  of a boiler by the
      combustion  gases.

 FORCED-DRAFT  FAN - A  fan that supplies air under  pressure to the combustion
      chamber  of  the boiler.

 FOULING  - Accumulation  of refuse in  gas  passages  or absorbing surfaces which
      results  in  undesirable restrictions to the flow of gas or heat.

 FRIABILITY  -  The  tendency of a  lump of  coal  to crumble  or  break into small
      pieces.

 FUEL  BED  -  The layer of burning coal  on a  stoker boiler grate.

 FUEL-BED  RESISTANCE -  The static pressure differential necessary to drive air
      through  a fuel bed.


                                      G

 GAGE  PRESSURE -  The pressure  above atmospheric pressure.

 GRATE -   The  surface  on  which  the  fuel  is  supported  and  burned in a stoker
      boiler.
                                      H

 HANDHOLE  - An  opening  in  the pressure portion of a boiler, generally  no  larger
      than 6  in.  in  its  longest dimension.

 HAND  LANCE  - A pipe carrying air,  steam, or water under  high pressure for the
      manual  cleaning  of  ash and  slag  accumulations  from heat-transfer sur-
      faces.

 HOGGED  FUEL  -  Wood  refuse that has  been chipped or shredded by a machine  known
      as a hog.

 HOPPER  -  A chamber  or  bin used for  holding  solid fuel  or  ash.
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide                                     Glossary
10/81                                    4

-------
HYDROSTATIC TEST - A test of the strength and tightness of a vessel by filling
     the  vessel  with  water,  sealing it off,  and  then pressurizing the water.
IGNITION - Lighting of the boiler.

IGNITION TEMPERATURE - The lowest temperature of a fuel at which combustion is
     self-sustaining.

INCHES WATER  GAGE  (w.g.)  - A term for measuring low pressure or pressure dif-
     ferentials.  One inch of water is 0.036 Ib per square inch.

INDUCED-DRAFT FAN - A fan on the exhaust side of the boiler that draws combus-
     tion gases from the boiler.


                                      L

LAGGING - A term usually meaning insulation.

LIGNITE - A low-Btu, high-moisture coal usually found west of the Mississippi.

LIVE STEAM - Steam that has been generated, but has not yet been used.

LOAD FACTOR  -  The  ratio of the  average  load in a given period to the maximum
     load carried during that period.
                                      M

MAKEUP WATER  -  Water added to the  boiler  to make up for losses through blow-
     down, leakage, steam losses, etc.
                                      N

NATURAL  CIRCULATION  - The  circulation  of water through a  boiler  by means of
     differences in density rather than a pump.

NATURAL  GAS  - Gaseous  fuel occurring  in  nature,  consisting predominantly of
     methane.
ORSAT - An  apparatus used to measure  certain  constituents  of flue gas by se-
     quential absorption in chemical solutions.
Industrial  Boiler Inspection Guide                                     Glossary
10/81                                   5

-------
OVERFIRE AIR  - Air  for  combustion admitted  into the furnace  above  the fuel
     beds to complete the combustion of unburned hydrocarbons.
PASS - A  confined  passageway through which a  fluid  flows  in one direction to
     be heated.

PEAK LOAD - The maximum load that a boiler can carry for a  stated short period
     of time.

PITOT TUBE - An instrument used to measure the velocity of  gas flowing through
     a section of duct.

PLENUM -  An  enclosure through  which  gas  or air  passes  at  low  velocities.

PNEUMATIC CONVEYING - Transporting fuel  through a conduit by air.

PREHEATED AIR - Air that has been heated above ambient temperature.

PRESSURE   DROP  - The  difference  in  pressure  between two  points along  a  gas
     flow path,  caused by resistance to  flow.

PRIMARY AIR - Air  introduced with the  fuel at the  burner.  This is sometimes
     referred to as pulverizer air in pulverized coal boilers.

PRIMARY AIR FAN - The fan used to supply primary air.

PRODUCTS   OF  COMBUSTION -  The gases and solids  resulting  from the  combustion
     of fuel.

PROXIMATE ANALYSIS - See "Analysis, Proximate."

PUFF - A  minor combustion explosion within the boiler furnace.

PULVERIZER  -  A  machine that  reduces coal  to a  fineness suitable  for burning
     in suspension.

PULVERIZER AIR  - Air that passes through the pulverizer to dry and convey the
     pulverized coal to the combustion chamber and direct-fired systems, or to
     a storage bin.

PULVERIZED  FUEL -  Solid  fuel  reduced to a finely crushed or powdered state.

PULVERIZED  COAL BOILER -  Sometimes  called  a  PC boiler.   Coal  is  ground into
     a powder and  blown  into the firebox with  hot  air for combustion.  About
     80 percent of the ash in the coal is carried out in the flue gas.

PYRITES - A compound of iron and sulfur  occurring naturally in coal.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                    Glossary
10/81                                 6

-------
RADIATION  LOSS  - A term  used  in boiler heat balance  calculations  to account
     for total  heat  losses  by  conduction,  radiation,  and  convection  from the
     furnace box to the ambient air.

RATED CAPACITY  -  The  manufacturer's  stated capacity rating  for  the equipment
     in question.

RAW WATER - Water supplied to the plant before any treatment.

REFRACTORY - A  heat-resistant  material  used to line boiler  combustion areas.

REGISTER - An apparatus  used to regulate the direction  of flow of combustion
     air.

REHEATER -  Heat transfer equipment to  heat  steam after it  has  given up some
     of its original  heat.

REHEATING - The  process of adding heat to steam to raise its temperature after
     it has done part of its work.

REINJECTION - The procedure of  returning a portion of the collected fly ash to
     the furnace  to  complete the combustion of any residual  carbon in the fly
     ash.

RETORT - A  channel  in an underfeed stoker through which fuel is forced upward
     into the fuel bed.

RETRACTABLE BLOWER -  A soot blower that can be mechanically extended and then
     retracted into the boiler.

RIFFLE - A  device for taking a  representative  sample  of coal by repetitively
     splitting the sample into  smaller portions.

RISER TUBE  - A  tube  through which  steam  and  water  pass up  into  the boiler
     drum.

ROTARY VALVES -  A device that  maintains an airtight seal as it dumps ash from
     the bottom  of an ash hopper.

RUN OF MINE - Unscreened coal as it comes out of the mine.
                                      S

SCALE - A hard coating of mineral on internal boiler surfaces.

SCREW FEEDER - A means of conveying coal or ash by a screw that rotates
     inside a pipe.   This is sometimes called a screw conveyor.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                    Glossary
10/81                                 7

-------
SECONDARY AIR - Air for combustion to supplement the primary air.

SECONDARY COMBUSTION - Combustion occurring as a result of ignition at a point
     beyond  the  normal  furnace combustion chamber.  This  is  sometimes called
     delayed combustion.

SOOT  BLOWER - A  mechanical  device  that uses high-pressure  steam or  air  to
     remove  accumulated  material  from  the  fire  side of a  heat  transfer sur-
     face.

SPECIFIC  HEAT  -  A quantity of  heat  expressed in Btu's required  to  raise the
     temperature of 1 Ib of a material by 1°F.

SPREADER  STOKER  - A  device  that throws  coal  onto the surface  of a  grate  by
     means of mechanical  feeders above the grate.

STANDARD  AIR - Dry air  at atmospheric  pressure  and 70°F.  This  term is used
     in combustion calculations.

STEAM QUALITY - The vapor percent by weight in a steam/water mixture.

STOKER BOILER  -  A boiler in which solid fuel  is fed onto a grate in  the fire-
     box  and burned.   See  Traveling  Grate,  Chain Grate,  Vibrating Grate, and
     Spreader Stoker.  Stokers usually have low fly ash carryover.

SUBBITUMINOUS  COAL -  A  medium-quality  coal  usually  rated between  9500 and
     13,000 Btu/lb.

SUPERHEAT  - To  raise the temperature  of steam above its saturation point.

SURFACE BLOWOFF -  The removal  of water  or foam  from the surface of  the water
     in the boiler drum.

SURFACE  MOISTURE   -  The  portion  of  coal  moisture  that comes  from  external
     sources such  as water  seepage,  rain,  snow, etc.;  sometimes called free
     moisture.
TANGENTIAL FIRING - A method of firing in which burners located in the furnace
     walls fire tangentially to an imaginary circle within the furnace.

THEORETICAL AIR - The quantity of air required for perfect combustion.

TRAVELING-GRATE STOKER -  A stoker similar to a chain-grate stoker except that
     the grate is driven by chains but is separate from the chains.

TUYERES - Air  entry ports into the combustion  zone  that restrict the flow of
     ash back into the air plenum.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                    Glossary
10/81                                 8

-------
                                      u

ULTIMATE ANALYSIS - See "Analysis, Ultimate."

USE FACTOR - The ratio of hours of operation to total hours in a given period.
VERTICAL FIRING -  An  arrangement of firing in which the air and fuel  are dis-
     charged vertically into the furnace.

VIBRATING GRATE  STOKER -  A stoker in  which vibration and  gravity move coal
     along a grate that is inclined downward.  Typically the grate is  vibrated
     for about 5 seconds every 2 minutes.

VOLATILE MATTER  - The gaseous products given  off when a fuel  is  heated when
     prescribed conditions.
                                      W

WASTE HEAT - Heat recovered from exhaust flue gases and used for other process
     purposes, such as drying grains or processing ores.

WATER TUBE  - A boiler  construction method whereby water to be  heated passes
     inside a tube with the fire on the outside of the tube.

WINDBOX  -  A plenum  below the  grate  of a  stoker boiler, or  surrounding the
     burner of other  types  of boilers, in which  air,  under pressure, is sup-
     plied for the combustion of fuel.

WINDBOX  PRESSURE  -  The  static pressure in the windbox  of a burner or stoker.
ZONE CONTROL -  The  control  of air flow into individual zones below the bed of
     a stoker boiler.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                     Glossary
10/81                                  9

-------
                                 BIBLIOGRAPHY
Air Pollution Control,  Industrial  Guide to.  Handbook, EPA-625-6-78-004, June
     1978.

Combustion  Evaluation,  APTI  Course  427,  Student  Manual,  EPA  450/2-80-063,
     February 1980.

Confined  Space  Entry,  Recommendations  for.  Addendum  for  use  with  Workshop
     Volume II.   U.S. Environmental  Protection  Agency,  Office of Enforcement,
     March 1980.

Counterflow  Inspection  Procedures   for  Performance  Baseline Assessment  and
     Routine Evaluation.  (Draft report for the Environmental  Protection Agen-
     cy, Division of Stationary Source Enforcement.)  By J.  R. Richards, PEDCo
     Environmental, Inc.,  February 1980.

Data Validation Scheme for Pulverized Boilers, A.    By C.  Bruffey and
     W.  G. DeWees,  PEDCo Environmental,  Inc., undated.

Electrostatic Precipitation  of  Fly  Ash.   By  H.  J.  White,  APCA,  July 1977.

Electrostatic Precipitators,  Operation and  Maintenance of.   Vol.  V.   Refer-
     ence  Material  for Technical  Workshop  on Evaluation  of  Industrial  Air
     Pollution Control Equipment Operation and Maintenance Practices.   (Draft)
     U.S.  Environmental Protection Agency  Office  of Enforcement,  July 1979.

Electrostatic Precipitators, Operation  and  Maintenance of.   Michigan Chapter,
     East Central Section, of APCA, April  1978.

Electrostatic Precipitators,  Selected Articles on, Vol.  IV,  Reference Mate-
     rial for Boiler Compliance Inspection Workshop for EPA Region III, Draft,
     EPA Office of Enforcement, January 1981.

Electrostatic Precipitator  Performance,  Inspection Manual  for Evaluation of.
     By M. Szabo, Y. Shah, and S.  Schleisser, PEDCo Environmental, Inc., Janu-
     ary 1981.

ESP  Inspection  Procedures  -  Operator  and  Control  Agency  Roles  in  Ensuring
     Continuous  Compliance.  By J.  R. Richards, R.  Hawks,  and M. Szabo, PEDCo
     Environmental, Inc.,  undated.

ESP Performance  Analysis  and Diagnosis of  Internal  Conditions from Operation
     and  Maintenance  Recordkeeping.   By  S. Schliesser,  PEDCo Environmental,
     Inc., undated.

Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                Bibliography
10/81                                 1

-------
Fabric Filters.  By  C.  M.  Schmidt,  Schmidt Associates, Inc., Cleveland, Ohio,
     undated.

Fabric Filter  Experience  With a Utility Boiler,  Pennsylvania  Power and Light
     Co., Sunbury  SES  - Presentation Outline.  By  D.  J.  Murphy,  Sunbury SES,
     undated.

Fabric Filters,  Operation and  Maintenance of.   Vol.  VI.   Reference Material
     for  Enforcement  Workshop on Plant  Inspection  and Evaluation Procedures.
     Draft.   U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Enforcement, July
     1979.

Fabric Filters, Selected Articles on.  Vol. V.  Draft.   Reference Material for
     Boiler  Compliance Inspection  Workshop  for  EPA  Region III,  Draft,  EPA
     Office of Enforcement, January 1981.

Filter Media and  Fabric   Filter  Aspects  for Coal-Fired  Boiler and  S02  Dry
     Scrubbing  Applications.    Condensed  Handbook.    By. L. Bergmann,  Filter
     Media Consulting, Inc.,  no date.

Flue Gas  Desulfurization  Systems, Selected Articles on.   Vol.  VI.   Reference
     Material for Boiler Compliance Inspection Workshop for U.S. Environmental
     Protection Agency, Office of Enforcement, January 1981.

Industrial Boilers,  Good  Operating Practices  for.   By C.  M.  Schmidt,  Schmidt
     Associates, Inc., Cleveland, Ohio, November 1979.

Observer's Checklist  Package  for EPA Reference  Test  Methods  and  Continuous
     Emission  Monitor  Certification.   Draft.  U.S. Environmental  Protection
     Agency Office of Enforcement, June 1980.

Observing Compliance  Tests.   Vol. IX.   Draft.  U.S.  Environmental  Protection
     Agency,  Office of Enforcement, July 1979.

Opacity  as  an  Indicator  of  Control  Equipment Performance.   By  Kirk Foster,
     U.S.  Environmental   Protection  Agency,  Office  of   Enforcement,  and
     G. Saunders, PEDCo Environmental, Inc., November  1978.

Particulate  Source  Sampling  at  Steam Generators  with Intermittent Soot Blow
     ing.  By  J. W.  Peeler,   Entropy  Environmentalists,  for  K.  Foster,  DSSE,
     October 1978.

Power from Coal.  Special  report by editors of Power,  February 1974.

Process and Control Equipment Flow Charting Techniques.  Vol. III.  Draft.  By
     J. R. Richards,  PEDCo Environmental, Inc., for U.S.  Environmental  Protec-
     tion Agency, Office of Enforcement,  February 1979.

Pulverized Coal-Fired  Utility Boiler, Practical  Operating Aspects  of a.   By
     T. Malinky, Pennsylvania Power  &  Light Co.,  York  Haven,  Pennsylvania,
     undated.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                Bibliography
10/81                                 2

-------
Smoke-Stack  Plumes,  Their  Opacity and  Visual   Effects.   By W. Conner,  U.S.
     Environmental Protection Agency,  Research  Triangle  Park,  North Carolina,
     undated.
Industrial Boiler Inspection Guide                                Bibliography
10/81                                 3

-------