U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
OFFICE OF WATER REGULATIONS AND STANDARDS
WASHINGTON DC 20460
RECALCULATION
OF STATE
TOXIC CRITERIA
November, 1983
-------
RECALCULATION
OF STATE
TOXIC CRITERIA
Prepared For:
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
Office of Water Regulations and Standards
Criteria and Standards Division
401 M Street, SW
Washington DC 20460
By:
Ming P. Wang
Sue A. Hanson-Walton
Larry A. Roesner
Camp Dresser & McKee
7630 Little River Turnpike
Annandale VA 22003
Contract No. 68-01-6403
November, 1983
-------
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The material in this report was prepared under the direction of the Criteria and Standards Divi-
sion, Office of Water Regulations and Standards, of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The
authors wish to thank the professional staff of the Criteria and Standards Division—in particular
Patrick Tobin, Division Director; Alan Rubin; Frank Gostomski; and Jo Brecher—for the suggestions
and assistance they have offered which are reflected throughout. We would also like to acknowl-
edge the interest and assistance of several people at the EPA Environmental Research Laboratory,
Duluth—Norbert Jaworski, Director; Rosemarie Russo, Deputy Director; Charles Stephan; Ron
Carlson; and Stephen Lozano—in answering our questions on the site-specific protocol and related
computer program which were developed at the Laboratory.
-------
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Mi
SUMMARY vii
SECTION 1. INTRODUCTION 1-1
1.1 BACKGROUND 1-1
1.2 ORGANIZATION 1-3
SECTION 2. APPROACH 2-1
2.1 THE TWO-NUMBER CRITERION 2-1
2.2 RECALCULATION OF SITE-SPECIFIC CRITERIA 2-2
2.3 SPECIES DISTRIBUTION 2-4
2.4 CALCULATION OF MAXIMUM VALUE CRITERIA BY STATE 2-9
2.5 CALCULATION OF THE STATE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERION 2-12
2.6 SAMPLE CALCULATION 2-13
SECTION 3. RESULTS 3-1
3.1 SPECIES DISTRIBUTION BY STATE 3-1
3.2 STATE WATER QUALITY CRITERIA 3-2
SECTION 4. DISCUSSION 4-1
REFERENCES R-1
APPENDICES
A. Resident North American Species of Aquatic Animals Used in Toxicity Tests A-1
B-1. State ID Numbers B-1
B-2. Family ID Numbers B-1
B-3. Species ID Numbers and Family Classification B-2
B-4. Resident Species, by State B-3
B-5. Species Distribution in the United States B-6
B-6. Minimum Data Requirements B-9
C. Toxicity Data for Freshwater Aquatic Life Criteria, by Chemical C-1
D. Toxicity Data for Freshwater Aquatic Life Criteria, by State D-1
E. Recalculation Results E-1
-------
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure Page
1.1 Protocols Proposed by EPA for Site-Specific Criteria Modification 1-2
3.1 Distribution of Daphnia magna in the United States 3-3
LIST OF TABLES
Table Page
2.1 National 30-Day Average Criteria 2-3
2.2 List of Species Names in the Acute Toxicity Data Base 2-5
2.3 List of References Used for Identifying the Geographical Distribution
of the Invertebrate Species 2-8
2.4 National Acute Toxicity Data for Chlordane 2-14
2.5 Resident Species List for Pennsylvania 2-14
2.6 Pennsylvania Resident Species Toxicity Data for Chlordane 2-15
2.7 Pennsylvania Family Acute Toxicity Table for Chlordane 2-15
2.8 National Acute Toxicity Data for Nickel 2-18
2.9 Pennsylvania Resident Species Toxicity Data for Nickel 2-19
2.10 Pennsylvania Resident Family Toxicity Data for Nickel 2-19
2.11 National Chronic Toxicity Data for Nickel 2-21
3.1 Minimum Data Requirements Which Are Not Met by the National Toxicity Data Base 3-4
3.2 Values of vandzin the Maximum Value Criteria Equation, by State 3-8
4.1 Comparison of National and State Maximum Value Criteria 4-2
4.2 Comparison of National and State 30-Day Average Criteria 4-3
-------
SUMMARY
In an effort to assist the States in developing site-specific ambient water quality criteria, EPA
has published a series of protocols as guidance in the Water Quality Standards Handbook. One of
the protocols, referred to as the Recalculation Procedure, modifies the National water quality
criteria to reflect local resident species composition. With the protocol, site-specific water quality
criteria may be calculated.
The Recalculation Procedure is demonstrated in this report. The report includes: a survey of the
published literature on the geographical distributions in the United States of 95 freshwater species
in the national data base; and an illustrative recalculation of state water quality criteria for 21 toxic
chemicals whose national water quality criteria have been published by EPA.
The intended purpose of this report is not to simply provide a list of reevaluated criteria, but
rather to illustrate the principle of recalculating criteria on a site-specific basis. When site-specific
criteria are developed using the Recalculation Procedure, current information should be obtained on
the actual composition of resident species at the site. The most current toxicity data base should
also be used and minimum data base requirements should be met.
-------
SECTION 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 BACKGROUND
In the Federal Register of 28 November 1980, (45 FR 79318) the Environmental Protection
Agency (EPA) announced the availability of criteria documents for 64 of the 65 pollutants designated
as toxic under Section 307(a)(1) of the Clean Water Act. Water quality criteria for 25 of these 65
designated pollutants were first published in "Quality Criteria for Water" (U.S. EPA, July, 1976), the
"Red Book."
Numerical national water quality criteria have been derived by EPA for 21 of the 65 chemicals
according to guidelines also published in the Federal Register of 28 November 1980 (45FR79341).
These national criteria are based upon standard toxicity tests performed in the laboratory with a
variety of aquatic species whose combination meets the minimum data requirement.
A subsequent modification (EPA, 1983) to the 1980 guidelines includes:
• The criterion average concentration is now used as a 30-day average rather than a 24-hour
average,
• The cumulative duration of excursions over the average concentration are limited to 96 hours in
any 30 consecutive days
• The criterion maximum concentration, instead of being equal to the Final Acute Value (FAV), is
defined as half of the FAV
• Use of family rather than species as the biological unit upon which the Final Acute Value (FAV)
and the Final Chronic Value (FCV) are based
• A change in the minimum data requirement
• A change in the method of regression analysis used for calculating FAV and FCV
In recognition of the fact that local environmental conditions may affect the toxicity of a pollu-
tant, EPA has given flexibility to the states in the application of the published national water quality
criteria by supplying guidance for modifying the criteria through a site-specific analysis. In the context
of this report, the term "site-specific" will be used synonymously with the term "state-specific."
In an effort to assist the states in adapting the national criteria to local conditions, EPA (1982) has
developed a series of protocols (Figure 1.1) whereby the laboratory-based water quality criteria maybe
modified by taking local variation in species composition and water chemistry into account. The first
protocol, which is designed to take resident species composition into account, is the subject of this
report. This protocol will henceforth be referred to as the Recalculation Procedure. The remainder of
this report is based on:
• Freshwater aquatic toxicity data base presented in 1980 criteria documents
• Revised methodology for criteria derivation (EPA, 1983)
• Guidelines for deriving site-specific water quality criteria (EPA, 1982)
Since EPA is continuing to revise and expand the original water quality criteria, the data base and
guidelines used in this report may not be consistent with the most recent data base and guidelines
known to the reader. Therefore, the results presented in this report should only be used for illustrative
purposes and should not be directly applied.
-------
RESIDENT SPECIES EFFECTS
RECALCULATE CRITERIA
USING RESIDENT SPECIES
DATA FROM LITERATURE
NATIONAL
WATER QUALITY
CRITERIA
SITE WATER CHEMISTRY EFFECTS
TEST INDICATOR SPECIES
IN "CLEAN" LABORATORY
AND IN SITE WATER;
MODIFY NATIONAL CRITERIA
RESIDENT SPECIES AND
SITE WATER CHEMISTRY EFFECTS
TEST RESIDENT SPECIES
IN SITE WATER;
CALCULATE NEW CRITERIA
SITE-SPECIFIC
WATER QUALITY
CRITERIA
Figure 1.1 Protocols Published by EPA for Site-Specific Criteria Modification
1-2
-------
1.2 ORGANIZATION
The methodology used in this report is outlined in Section 2. The results are presented in Section
3 and the Appendices. A discussion of the results will be found in Section 4.
1-3
-------
SECTION 2
APPROACH
2.1 THE TWO-NUMBER CRITERION
The national criteria for the protection of freshwater aquatic life specify both maximum and
30-day average values (the two-number criterion). The cumulative duration of excursions above the
specified 30-day average value is limited to 96 hours in any 30 consecutive days. This two-number,
three-part format of numerical water quality criteria is intended to provide adequate protection for
aquatic life and its uses for both long-term, nearly constant, continuous exposure situations, and
situations of fluctuating concentration including intermittent exposures. The two-number criteria were
derived using the revised methodologies (EPA, 1983).
2.1.1 The Maximum Value Criterion
The maximum value criterion is obtained by dividing the Final Acute Value (FAV) by 2. The FAV is
defined as the value which will protect 95 percent of the aquatic organism families in the national data
base from acute toxicity.
The acute toxicity data used for the calculation of the FAV should cover at least eight different
families such that all of the following are included:
1. the family Salmonidae in the class Osteichthyes,
2. one other (preferably warm water) family in the class Osteichthyes,
3. one other family in the phylum Chordata (e.g. fish, amphibian, etc.),
4. a planktonic crustacean (e.g. cladoceran, copepod, etc.),
5. a benthic crustacean (e.g. ostracod, isopod, scud, glass shrimp, crayfish, etc.),
6. an insect (e.g. mayfly, dragonfly, damselfly, stonefly, caddisfly, mosquito, midge, etc.),
7. a family in a phylum other than Arthropoda or Chordata (e.g. Rotifera, Annelida, Mollusca, etc.),
and
8. a family in any order of insect or any phylum not already represented.
2.1.2 The 30-Day Average Criterion
The 30-day average value is defined as the lowest of the following: Final Chronic Value (FCV),
Final Plant Value (FPV), and Final Residue Value (FRV). The FCV may be defined by any of the follow-
ing:
1. the value which will protect 95 percent of the national aquatic organisms from chronic toxicity,
with the national aquatic organism population represented by the species in the national
chronic toxicity data base; or,
-------
2. the value obtained from dividing the FAV by the acute-chronic ratio; or,
3. the species mean chronic value of an important species, such as a commercially or recrea-
tionally important species.
The acute-chronic ratio is the representative value which characterizes the acute sensitivity of a
species relative to its chronic toxicity.
The FPV is defined as the lowest value in a chronic test with an aquatic vascular plant or in a
96-hour or longer test with an alga. The FRV is calculated by dividing a maximum permissible tissue
concentration by an appropriate bio-concentration factor.
The national 30-day average criteria and the corresponding FCV, FPV and FRV are listed in Table
2.1. There is no 30-day average criterion for Aldrin, Arsenic or Silver. Acute-chronic ratios are available
for 15 chemicals, thus permitting calculation of the FCV from the FAV. The FAVs for Copper and Lead
were also calculated from chronic toxicity data using the revised methodology. Although the acute
toxicity of Zinc is hardness dependent, chronic Zinc toxicity is relatively unaffected by hardness.
Therefore, instead of setting a 30-day average criterion based on the FAV and the acute-chronic ratio,
a value of 47/jg/l was chosen because it represents the chronic value of both a sensitive invertebrate
(Daphnia Magna) in hard water and a moderately sensitive fish (Flagfish) in soft water. The FCVs in
Table 2.1 were calculated using the revised methodology, therefore, they do not necessarily agree with
those published in the Federal Register of 28 November 1980.
2.2 RECALCULATION OF SITE-SPECIFIC CRITERIA
According to the recalculation procedure, site-specific fresh-water aquatic life criteria may be
developed with a minimum of toxicity testing. The modification procedure may be outlined as follows:
1. select the appropriate resident species toxicity data from the national data base,
2. calculate the FAV using the site-specific data base and the revised methodology,
3. define the site-specific maximum criteria by dividing the FAV by 2,
4. calculate the FCV by either or both of the following steps:
(a) calculate the FCV by dividing the recalculated FAV by the acute-chronic ratio, or
(b) if the national FCV is calculated from chronic toxicity data, calculate the FCV using the
resident species chronic toxicity data, and
5. define the 30-day average value by selecting the minimum of the FRV, FPV, and the
recalculated FCVs.
If there are not enough resident species in the national toxicity data base to meet the minimum
data requirement, additional resident species bioassays in laboratory water may be needed in order to
apply this procedure. The States should decide on the data requirements appropriate for each situa-
tion.
The two-number national criteria have been developed by EPA for 18 chemicals. The derivation of
site-specific (state-specific) criteria for these same 18 chemicals is presented in this report. In addi-
tion, site-specific maximum criteria have been calculated for three other chemicals for which only na-
tional maximum criteria are available.
-------
Chemical
Aldrin
Arsenic
Cadmium
Chlordane
Chromium
Copper
Cyanide
DDT
Dieldrin
Endosulfan
Endrin
Heptachlor
Lead
Lindane
Mercury
Nickel
PCB's
Selenium
Silver
Toxaphene
Zinc
Table 2.1 National 30-Day Average Criteria
Final Chronic Value1
Type 1
Type 2
Final
Residue
Type 3 Value
(M9/D
Final
Plant 30-day2
Value Average
(M9/0 (M9/0
exp[1.05(lnH) -2.93]3
122
3.949/14.0
24.327/72.0
exp[0.94(lnH)-0.95]
5.78
62.859/14.8
3.659/8.5
0.415/3.9
0.402/4.0
exp[1.22(lnH)-2.6]
69.9
6.435/25.0
0.940/3.0
exp[0.76(lnH)+4.19]
19.4
165.297/7.5
1.074/123
exp[0.83(lnH)+2.51]
3.0
5.6
exp[2.35(lnH)-10.4] —
260
0.0043
0.001
0.0019
0.0023
0.0038
0.20
0.014
0.076
160
10
0.3
100
475
26.7
1,000
ACR
FRV
FCV1
FCV2
FCV1
FRV
FRV
FCV1
FRV
FRV
FCV2
FCV1
FRV
— ACR
- FRV
— FCV1
0.38
47.0
FCV1
FCV3
'Type 1: Calculated by dividing FAV by acute-chronic ratio.
Type 2: Calculated from toxicity data base.
Type 3: Obtained from chronic value of important species.
2FCV1: Final Chronic Value, Type 1.
FCV2: Final Chronic Value, Type 2.
FCV3: Final Chronic Value, Type 3.
FRV : Final Residue Value.
FPV : Final Plant Value.
3H: Hardness as mg/l CaC03.
2-3
-------
The geographical distribution of those species in the national acute and chronic toxicity data
bases is required for the calculation of the site-specific water quality criteria. The approach taken in
finding the species distributions is described in Section 2.3 and the calculation of the state maximum
value criteria is described in Section 2.4. The calculation of the state 30-day average criteria is dis-
cussed in Section 2.5. A sample calculation which illustrates all of the procedures involved is
presented in Section 2.6.
2.3 SPECIES DISTRIBUTION
There are 95 biological species represented in the national toxicity data base for the 21 chemicals
discussed in this report. These species are listed in Tables 1 and 3 of each of the criteria documents
(U.S. EPA, 1980). Of these 95 species, 48 are fishes and 47 are assorted invertebrates. The species
tested in order to develop acute toxicity data for each of the 21 chemicals are listed in Table 2.2.
The classification of these species by family, order, class, and phylum is presented in Appendix
A. Appendix A, reproduced from "Guidelines for Deriving Numerical National Water Quality Criteria for
the Protection of Aquatic Life and Its Uses" (U.S. EPA, 1983), is essential for calculating the family
mean acute-chronic values from available species toxicity data, as well as for checking the family
composition of the toxicity data base against the minimum data requirements (Section 2.1.1).
A literature survey was conducted on the distribution of these species in the United States. The
principal reference for identifying the distribution of the listed 48 fish species was the "Atlas of North
American Freshwater Fishes" (Lee et al., 1980). A comparable document is not available for in-
vertebrates. Twenty references were used to identify the geographical distribution of the 47 in-
vertebrate species. A list of invertebrate species and the references used to identify their distribution
is presented in Table 2.3. The information in Table 2.3 results from an extensive survey of the literature,
however, this information should not be considered definitive as voids may exist in reporting the oc-
currence of some species, particularly those which are not of high commercial value.
Since there is no convention for recording the geographic distribution of species (i.e., whether by
state or by river basin drainage or by other geographical features), several formats are seen in the
literature. For the purposes of this report, the state was selected as the most appropriate geographical
delimiter.
2-4
-------
Table 2.2 List of Species Names in the Acute Toxicity Data Base
Species
Planarian (Polycells Fellna)
Rotifer (Philodlna Acuticornis)
Rotifer (Philodina Roseola)
Bristleworm (Nais Sp.)
Worm (Limnodrilus Hoffmeisteri)
Snail (Amnicola Sp.)
Snail (Campeloma Decisum)
Snail (Gyrulus Circumstrlatus)
Snail (Physa Heterostropha)
Snail (Physa Integra)
Snail (Physa Sp.)
Cladoceran (Oaphnia Carlnata)
Cladoceran (Daphnia Magna)
Cladoceran (Daphnia Pulex)
Cladoceran (Daphnia Pulicaria)
Cladoceran (Simocephalus Serrulatus)
Seed Shrimp (Cypridopsis Vidua)
Copepod (Unidentified)
Isopod (Asellus Brevicaudus)
Isopod (Asellus Communis)
Scud (Gammarus Fasciatus)
Scud (Gammarus Lacustns)
Scud (Gammarus Pseudolimneaus)
Scud (Gammarus Sp.)
Scud (Hyallela Azteca)
Crayfish (Faxonella Clypeata)
Crayfish (Orconectes Nais)
Crayfish (Orconectes Limosus)
Crayfish (Orconectes Rusticus)
Crayfish (Procambarus Acutus)
Glass Shrimp (Palaemonetes Kadlakensis)
Mayfly (Ephemerella Grandls)
Mayfly (Ephemerella Subvaria)
Mayfly (Hexagema Bilineata)
6 g E 1 ° e *
o 1 J | s » == -g * ? I £
•iS|li|l_«|-=fT,|3linISi&0
2S^Z£§-5,Q»??&5?S.2S|J:g.S
44Uuuuuaaiuuizji^£za.uinKN<
X
XXX XXX XX
X
XX XX X
X X
X X
X
X
XXX X
X
X X
X
XXXXX X XXXXXXX XXXX
XXX XXXX X X X XX
X
XXX XXXXX X
X
X
X XXXX
X
X X XXXXXX X X
X X XXXXXX X
X XXX X XXX
XX XX X
X
X
XX XX
X
X
X
XX XXXX X
XX XXX
X X
X
2-5
-------
Table 2.2 List of Species Names in the Acute Toxicity Data Base (Continued)
Species
Stonefly (Acroneuria Lycorius)
Stonefly (Acroneuria Paclfica)
Stonefly (Claassennia Sabulosa)
Stonefly (Pteronarcella Badia)
Stonefly (Pteronarcys Californica)
Damselfly (Ischnura Verticalus)
Damselfly (Ischnura Sp.)
Damselfly (Unidentified)
Midge (Chironomus Plumosus)
Midge (Chironomus Tentans)
Midge (Chironomus Sp.)
Midge (Tanytarsus Dissimills)
Caddisfly (Arctopsyche Grandis)
Caddisfly (Hydropsyche Betteni)
Caddisfly (Hydropsyche Californica)
Caddisfly (Unidentified)
American Eel (Anguilla Rostrata)
Coho Salmon (Oncorhynchus Kisutch)
Sockeye Salmon (Orcorhynchus Nerka)
Chinook Salmon (Orcorhynchus Tshawtscha)
Cutthroat Trout (Salmo Clarki)
Rainbow Trout (Salmo Gairdnen)
Atlantic Salmon (Salmo Salar)
Brown Trout (Salmo Trutta)
Brook Trout (Salvelinus Fontmalis)
Lake Trout {Salvelinus Namaycush)
Northern Pike (Esox Lucius)
Mottled Sculpin (Coitus Bairdi)
Longfin Dace (Agosia Chrysogaster)
Stoneroller (Campostoma Anomalum)
Goldfish (Carassius Auralus)
Carp (Cyprinus Carpio)
Golden Shiner (Notemigonus Crysoleucas)
Striped Shiner (Nolropis Chrysocephalus)
c g e Jo
, ! ! ! ! i ! H 1 1 .1 ! „ |
2£n.c.co>.a.2cc<»S =
<
-------
Table 2.2 List of Species Names in the Acute Toxicity Data Base (Continued)
Species
Northern Redbelly Dace (Phoxlnus EOS)
Bluntnose Minnow (Plmephales Notatus)
Fathead Minnow (Plmephales Promelas)
Northern Squawflsh (Ptychocheiluseoregonensls)
Blacknose Dace (Rhlnichthys Atratulus)
Speckled Dace (Rhinichthys Osculus)
Creek Chub (Semotllus Atromaculatus)
White Sucker (Catostomus Commersoni)
Black Bullhead (Ictalurus Melas)
Brown Bullhead (Ictalurus Nebulosus)
Channel Catfish (Ictalurus Punctatus)
Banded Killifish (Fundulus Dlaphanus)
Flagfish (Jordanella Florldae)
Mosquitofish (Gambusia Affinis)
Guppy (Poecilla Reticulata)
Southern Platyfish {Xiphophorus Maculatus)
Brook Stickleback (Culaea Inconstans)
Threespine Stickleback (Gasterosteus Aculeatus)
White Perch (Morone Americana)
Striped Bass (Morone Saxatills)
Rock Bass (Ambloplites Rupestris)
Green Sunfish (Lepomis Cyanellus)
PumpKinseed (Lepomis Gibbosus)
Bluegill (Lepomis Macronchirus)
Longear Sunfish (Lepomis Megalotls)
Redear Sunfish (Lepomis Mlcrolophus)
Largemouth Bass (Mlcropterus Salmoldes)
Black Crappie (Pomoxis Nigromaculatus)
Rainbow Darter (Etheostoma Caeruleum)
Orangethroat Darter (Etheostoma Spectabile)
Yellow Perch (Perca Flavescens)
E g E So g
-| | 1 | I I 1 1 1 * | „ I ! » 1 . 1
se3il&!£ilifl^£38i£§
<
-------
Table 2.3 List of References Used for Identifying the
Geographical Distribution of the Invertebrate Species
Species
Planarian (Polyoelis felina)
Rotifer Philodina acuticornis)
Rotifer (Philodina roseola)
Bristleworm (Nais Sp.)
Worm (Limnodrilus hoffmeisteri)
Snail (Amnioola Sp.)
Snail (Campeloma decisum)
Snail (Gyraulus circumstriatus)
Snail (Physa heterostropha)
Snail (Physa Integra)
Snail (Physa Sp.)
Cladoceran (Daphnia carinata)
Cladoceran (Daphnia magna)
Cladoceran (Daphnia pulex)
Cladoceran (Daphnia pulicana)
Cladoceran (Simocephalus serrulatus)
Seed Shrimp (Cypridopsis vidua)
Copepod (Unidentified)
Isopod (Asellus brevicaudus)
Isopod {Asellus communis)
Scud (Gammarus fasciatus)
Scud (Gammarus lacustris)
Scud (Gammarus pseudolimneaus)
Scud (Gammarus Sp.)
Scud (Hyallela azteca)
Crayfish (Faxonella clypeata)
Crayfish (Orconectes nais)
Crayfish (Orconectes limosus)
Crayfish (Orconectes rusticus)
Crayfish (Procambarus acutus)
Glass Shrimp (Palaemonetes kadiakensis)
Mayfly (Ephemerella grandis)
Mayfly (Ephemerella subvaria)
Mayfly (Hexagenia bilineata)
Stonefly (Acroneuria lycorius)
Stonefly (Acroneuria pacifica)
Stonefly (Claassennia sabulosa)
Stonefly (Pteronarcella badia)
Stonefly (Pteronarcys californica)
Damselfly (Ischnura verticalus)
Damselfly (Ischnura Sp.)
Damselfly (Unidentified)
Midge (Chironomus plumosus)
Midge (Chironomus tentans)
Midge (Chironomus Sp.)
Midge (Tanytarsus dissimilis)
Caddisfly (Arctopsyche grandis)
Caddisfly (Hydropsyche betteni)
Caddisfly (Hydropsyche californica)
Caddisfly (Unidentified)
Reference
Kenk (personal communication)
Pennak, 1978
Brinkhurst et al., 1971
Emerson et al., 1976
Hyman, 1967
Emerson et al., 1976
Brooks, 1957
Ward & Whipple, 1972
Pennak, 1978
Williams, 1972
Hosinger, 1972
Pennak, 1978
Bousfield, 1958
Hobbs, 1972
Holthuis, 1952
Edmunds et al., 1976
Burks et al., 1953
Stark et al., 1976
Baumann et al., 1977
Walker, 1953
Merritt & Cummins, 1978
U.S. Agr. Res. Service, 1965
Merritt & Cummins, 1978
U.S. Agr. Res. Service, 1965
Fischer, 1963
Merritt & Cummins, 1978
2-8
-------
2.4 CALCULATION OF MAXIMUM VALUE CRITERIA BY STATE
2.4.1 Procedures
The calculation of state aquatic life criteria is based on the information in state resident species
lists, on the species toxicity data (EPA, 1980) for the derivation of national water quality criteria and on
"Guidelines for Deriving Site Specific Water Quality Criteria for the Protection of Aquatic Life and Its
Uses" (U.S. EPA, 1982).
2.4.1.1 Maximum Value Criteria Independent of Hardness
Calculation of the maximum value criteria, for those chemicals whose toxicity is independent of
hardness, is done according to the following procedure:
1. Using the EPA criteria document for the toxic chemical of interest, select from Table 3 the
Species Mean Acute Value (SMAV) for each species resident in the state.
2. For each family with one or more SMAVs available, calculate the Family Mean Acute Value
(FMAV) as the geometric mean of the available SMAVs.
3. Calculate the state Final Acute Value using the procedures outlined below which are dis-
cussed in "Guidelines for Deriving Numerical National Water Quality Criteria for the Protec-
tion of Aquatic Life and Its Uses" (U.S. EPA, 1983):
(a) Order the FMAVs from low to high.
(b) Assign ranks (R) to the FMAVs from "1" for the lowest to "N" for the highest. If two or more
FMAVs are identical, arbitrarily assign them successive ranks.
(c) Calculate the cumulative proportion (P) for each FMAV as R/(N +1).
(d) Select the four FMAVs which have cumulative proportions closest to 0.05 (if there are less
than 59 FMAVs, these will always be the four lowest FMAVs).
(e) Using the selected FMAVs and Ps, calculate the following coefficients:
W = I(P) - «Z/P)2/4) (21}
I(ln FMAV)2 - ((X(ln FMAV))*/4)
x = (I(ln FMAV))/4 (2.2)
y = (Z\/P)/4 (2.3)
(f) the State FAV is defined as:
FAV = eA (2.4)
y (2.5)
2-9
-------
4. the state maximum value criteria is defined as the larger of:
(a) (State FAV)/2, or
(2.6)
(b) (State FAV)/(acute-chronic ratio)
2.4.1.2 Maximum Value Criteria as a Function of Hardness
Hardness has been shown to affect the acute toxicity of six chemicals: Cadmium, Copper, Lead,
Nickel, Silver and Zinc. Therefore, criteria for these six chemicals are determined according to a final
acute equation which expresses the FAV as a function of hardness:
FAV = exp[v(ln(H)) + z] (2.7)
where H is the hardness expressed as mg/l of CaC03, v is the mean acute slope, and z is the final acute
intercept. The parameter v is defined as the arithmetic mean of all the meaningful acute slopes for in-
dividual species (45FR79344, 28 November 1980). The acute slope for an individual species is defined
as the slope of the best fitted line when the species acute values are plotted against the hardness con-
centration in a log-log plot. In other words, for a given chemical the constant value v is assumed ap-
plicable to all species in the acute toxicity data. When calculating the state maximum value criteria,
the same value of v as used for the national calculation was used for the states.
The calculation of a state maximum value criteria is accomplished as follows:
1. Using the EPA criteria document for the chemical of interest, select from Table 3 the species
which are resident in a particular state and record the Species Mean Acute Intercept (SMAI).
The SMAI was calculated as the geometric mean of the available intercepts (y), with y defined
as:
y = w/exp[v(lnH)] (2.8)
where w = the reported LC50, shown in Table 1 of the criteria document.
v = the mean acute slope for the hardness dependence function shown at the bottom
of Table 1 of the criteria document.
H = hardness concentration at which the bioassay was conducted, in mg/l CaCO3.
2. For each family with one or more SMAIs available, calculate the Family Mean Acute Intercept
(FMAI) as the geometric mean of the available SMAIs.
3. Calculate the coefficients x, y, and M for the state Final Acute Equation using the procedure
("a" through "e") outlined in Section 2.4.1.1, substituting "FMAI" for "FMAV".
4. The state Final Acute Equation is defined as:
FAV = exp[v(ln(H) + A] (2.9)
2-10
-------
where A = x + -^—t, (2.10)
and v = mean acute slope for the chemical discussed in step "1".
5. The state maximum value criterion is defined as the larger of:
(a) (state FAVJ/2, or
(2.11)
(b) (state FAV)/(acute-chronic ratio)
2.4.2 Computer Program
An interactive FORTRAN program (FOUR.STATE) was used to calculate the state maximum value
criteria. The program is an extended version of a computer program developed at the U.S. EPA En-
vironmental Research Laboratory in Duluth. The Duluth computer program calculates final acute
values by the method described in the Federal Register of 28 November 1980. The Duluth program was
modified to include the following capabilities:
1. Select resident species data from the national data base for any given state,
2. calculate the FMAV of the available resident species,
3. calculate the FAV using the modified methodology, and
4. check the modified state data base against the modified criteria of the minimum data
requirements.
The program operates on five data files:
ACUTE1.DAT Data file of species acute values (LC50 or EC50) as reported in Table 1 of the
1980 criteria documents. The only exception is the species acute value for
Silver for Speckled Dace (Rhlnichthys osculus) which is changed from the
published 0.2 ngl\ to 20.0 pgl\.
SPECIES.DAT Data file of the species names, their ID numbers and their family ID
numbers. This list contains all species for which an acute toxicity value
was recorded for the 21 chemicals.
FAMILY.DAT Data file of family names and their ID numbers.
CHEMNAME.DAT Data file of 21 chemical names, 18 if which have two-value freshwater
aquatic life criteria, and three of which have maximum criteria.
-------
SRES.DAT Data file of the resident species in 48 states (Hawaii and Alaska not in-
cluded); both state and species are represented by their ID numbers.
STATENAME.NEW State names of the 48 states for which the freshwater aquatic criteria have
been calculated.
The three data files-ACUTE1.DAT, SPECIES.DAT, CHEMNAME.DAT—were furnished by the U.S.
EPA Environmental Research Laboratory in Duluth.
2.5 CALCULATION OF THE STATE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERION
2.5.1 Procedures
The 30-day average criterion is defined as the minimum of the FCV, FPV or FRV. The three
methods used in deriving the national FCV were also used for deriving the corresponding state FCV. In
cases where the national FCV was derived by dividing the national FAV by the acute-chronic ratio, the
state FCV was derived by dividing the state FAV by the acute-chronic ratio. For a given chemical, the
constant acute-chronic ratio published in the criteria document was used for all states. In the case
where the national FCV was derived from a chronic toxicity data base, such as Copper and Lead, the
same methodology used for calculation of the FAV (Equation 2.9) was used for calculating the state
FCV based on the state resident family chronic toxicity data. The state resident family data base used
for the FCV calculation was calculated by one of the following methods:
1. When chronic toxicity is independent of hardness:
(a) Select the Species Mean Chronic Value (SMCV) of the state resident species from the
national chronic toxicity data base.
(b) For each family with one or more SMCVs available, calculate the Family Mean Chronic
Value as the geometric mean of the available SMCVs.
2. When chronic toxicity is a function of hardness:
(a) Select the Species Mean Chronic Intercept (SMCI) of the state resident species from the
national chronic toxicity data base.
(b) For each family with one or more SMCI available, calculate the Family Mean Chronic In-
tercept (FMCI) as the geometric mean of the available SMCIs.
2.5.2 Computer Program
Whenever sufficient information was available, the computer program was used to calculate five
values—three FCVs, FPV and FRV—for each state. The calculations were done for 18 chemicals (no
30-day average criteria were available for Aldrin, Arsenic and Silver).
2-12
-------
The variation in state resident species would affect two of the FCVs:
1. FCV calculated as FAV divided by acute-chronic ratio, and
2. FCV calculated from the state chronic toxicity data base.
The program reads each of these five values for the specified state and chemical. If a value is not
available, it is set to an arbitrarily high number (9999.0) so that it will not be chosen as the minimum
value. The program then simply compares all five values and chooses the minimum.
2.6 SAMPLE CALCULATION
The calculation of the freshwater aquatic life criteria for Chlordane and Nickel for the State of
Pennsylvania are presented to illustrate the recalculation method.
2.6.1 Chlordane Criteria for Pennsylvania
1. The Maximum Value Criterion
The starting point is the national acute toxicity data base for Chlordane (Table 2.4) where
species ID numbers, names and their species mean acute values are presented. The species
ID number is given in the column "SNO" and the species mean acute value in the column
"LC50," with units of j^g/l. With the aid of the resident species list for the State of Pennsyl-
vania (Table 2.5), the resident species toxicity data for the State (Table 2.6) are then readily
prepared by selecting the data for resident species from Table 2.4. The eight species in Table
2.6 represent five families (see Appendices A and B-3). The family acute toxicity table for
Pennsylvania (Table 2.7) is prepared by calculating the Family Mean Acute Value (FMAV) for
each of the eight species shown in Table 2.6. The FMAV is defined as the geometric mean of
the available species mean acute values for species belonging to the family. For example,
carp, fathead minnow and goldfish all belong to the family of Cyprinidae. The FMAV for
Cyprinidae is then calculated as:
(3.0.x 51 .Ox82.0)"3 = 23.2 (2.12)
where 3.0, 51.0 and 82.0 are the species mean acute values of the three species.
Of aquatic organisms resident in Pennsylvania waters, the four families most sensitive to Chlordane,
their rank, cumulative proportion and FMAV are:
2-13
-------
Rank
LC50
Table 2.4 National Acute Toxicity Data for Chlordane
LN LC50 SNO Species
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
3.0000
6.3245
15.0000
25.4808
26.0000
39.9999
44.9999
51.0134
54.7111
55.9999
56.9999
58.2665
81.9998
189.9997
1.0986
1 .8444
2.7080
3.2379
3.2581
3.6889
3.8067
3.9321
4.0021
4.0254
4.0430
4.0650
4.4067
5.2470
68.0
31.0
39.0
58.0
22.0
21.0
61.0
73.0
93.0
54.0
56.0
13.0
67.0
84.0
Carp (Cyprinus carpio)
Glass Shrimp (Palaemonetes kadiakensis)
Stonefly (Pteronarcys californica)
Rainbow Trout (Salmo gairdneri)
Scud (Gammarus lacustris)
Scud (Gammarus fasciatus)
Brook Trout (Salvelinus fontinalis)
Fathead Minnow (Pimephales promelas)
Bluegill (Lepomis machrochirus)
Coho Salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch)
Chinook Salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha)
Cladoceran (Daphia magna)
Goldfish (Carassius auratus)
Guppy (Poecilia reticulata)
Table 2.5 Resident Species List for Pennsylvania
2.0
9.0
20.0
32.0
50.0
62.0
70.0
79.0
90.0
97.0
3.0
10.0
21.0
33.0
52.0
63.0
71.0
80.0
91.0
98.0
4.0
11.0
24.0
40.0
53.0
64.0
73.0
81.0
92.0
99.0
5.0
14.0
25.0
41.0
55.0
66.0
74.0
86.0
93.0
101.0
6.0
15.0
28.0
43.0
58.0
67.0
76.0
87.0
94.0
102.0
7.0
16.0
30.0
45.0
60.0
68.0
77.0
88.0
95.0
4.5
8.0
18.0
31.0
47.0
61.0
69.0
78.0
89.0
96.0
-------
Table 2.6 Pennsylvania Resident Species Toxicity Data for Chlordane
Rank
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
LC50
(MQ/D
3.0000
6.3245
25.4808
39.9999
44.9999
51.0134
54.7111
81.9998
LN LC50
1.0986
1.8444
3.2379
3.6889
3.8067
3.9321
4.0021
4.4067
SNO
68.0
31.0
58.0
21.0
61.0
73.0
93.0
67.0
Species
Carp (Cyprinus carpio)
Glass Shrimp (Palaemonetes kadiakensis)
Rainbow Trout (Salmo gairdneri)
Scud (Gammarus fasciatus)
Brook Trout (Salvelinus fontinalis)
Fathead Minnow (Pimephales promelas)
Bluegill (Lepomis macrochirus)
Goldfish (Carassius auratus)
Table 2.7 Pennsylvania Family Acute Toxicity Table for Chlordane
Rank
1
2
3
4
5
FLC50
(M9/D
6.3245
23.2384
33.8620
39.9999
54.7110
LN (FLC50)
1 .8444
3.1458
3.5223
3.6889
4.0021
FNO
27
40
38
25
48
Family
Palaemonidae
Cyprinidae
Salmonidae
Gammaridae
Centrarchidae
-------
R P FMAV Family
(Mfl/D
1 0.17 6.32 Palalmonidae
2 0.33 23.24 Cyprinidae
3 0.50 33.68 Salmonidae
4 0.67 40.00 Gammanidae
1. with P calculated as R/(N + 1) where N is the total number of families in the State toxicity data
base, which is five in this case. Using the values of FMAV and P for the four most sensitive
families, the coefficients M,x,y and A needed for the State Final Acute Value (FAV) can be cal-
culated by applying the formula suggested in the revised methodology:
M> = _ KP) - [d(/P))2/4] _ =OQ44 (2 13)
I[ln FMAV)2] - [(Z(ln FMAV))2/4] '
x = [I (In FMAV)]/4 = 3.05 (2.14)
y = £(\fP))l4 = 0.627 (2.15)
A =x + - = l.l3 (2.16)
The FAV is:
FAV = eA = 3.10 ng/l (2.17)
The State maximum value criterion is defined as the State FAV divided by the smaller of
(a) 2, or (b) the acute-chronic ratio. Since the acute-chronic ratio for Chlordane is 14 (>2), the
maximum value criterion for Chlordane for the State of Pennsylvania is 1.55, which is the State
FAV divided by 2.
-------
2. The 30-Day Average Criterion
The 30-day average criterion Is defined as the minimum of the Final Chronic Value (FCV),
the Final Residue Value (FRV) or the Final Plant Value (FPV). There is no FPV available for
Chlordane. The FRV is 0.0043 ^g/l (see Table 2.1). The final chronic data set is not sufficient for
the calculation of an FCV. The acute-chronic ratio for Chlordane is 14.0 (see Table 2.1) which
gives an FCV for Pennsylvania of 0.22 ^g/l, calculated as 3.10/14.0, where 3.10 is the FAV for
Pennsylvania. Comparing 0.22 /^g/l (FCV) with 0.0043 /jg/l (FRV), the 30-day average criterion for
Chlordane for the State of Pennsylvania, 0.0043 ng/\, is chosen.
2.6.2 Nickel Criteria for Pennsylvania
1. The Maximum Value Criterion
The acute toxicity of Nickel has been related to the hardness in freshwater by an exponen-
tial equation (U.S. EPA, 1980):
e[0.76 In (hardness) + z] (2.18)
Since hardness affects acute toxicity, the effect of hardness has to be removed from the labor-
atory observed LC50 values. Instead of using observed LC50s as the data base, the acute in-
tercept ez is used. The acute intercept can be viewed as the acute value in the absence of a
hardness effect (i.e., In (hardness) = 0). The national acute toxicity data for Nickel in the
absence of a hardness effect is given in Table 2.8 where the values listed in the column "LC50"
are species mean acute intercepts. Using this as the starting point and following the pro-
cedure described in Section 2.6.1, the resident species toxicity data (Table 2.9) and the resi-
dent family toxicity data (Table 2.10) are prepared.
The four families most sensitive to Nickel in the State of Pennsylvania, their family mean
acute intercept (FMAI), rank (R), and cumulative proportion (P) are:
R P FMAI Family
1 0.07 4.36 Daphnidae
2 0.14 5.45 Ephemerellidae
3 0.21 5.84 Centrarchidae
4 0.29 5.99 Philodinidae
2-17
-------
Table 2.8 National Acute Toxicity Data for Nickel (in The Absence of Hardness Effect)
Rank
LC50
LN LC50
SNO
Species
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
53.9790
78.4561
208.4833
233.5550
301.5102
388.3505
401.2168
439.8254
440.2043
456.6418
506.5306
509.2643
627.1620
658.5149
664.8523
721.1083
731.3375
1007.69
1084.21
1544.49
2029.91
2226.41
3.9886
4.3625
5.3399
5.4534
5.7088
5.9619
5.9945
6.0864
6.0872
6.1239
6.2276
6.2330
6.4412
6.4900
6.4996
6.5808
6.5949
6.9154
6.9886
7.3425
7.6157
7.7081
13.0
15.0
90.0
33.0
89.0
92.0
2.0
45.0
73.0
84.0
68.0
93.0
53.0
88.0
24.0
4.0
5.0
67.0
42.0
52.0
35.0
81.0
Cladoceran (Daphnia magna)
Cladoceran (Daphnia pulicaria)
Rock Bass (Ambloplites rupestris)
Mayfly (Ephemerella subvaria)
Striped Bass (Morone saxatilis)
Pumpkinseed (Lepomis gibbosus)
Rotifer (Philodina acuticornis)
Midge (Chironomus Sp.)
Fathead Minnow (Pimephales promelas)
Guppy (Poecilia reticulata)
Carp (Cyprinus carpio)
Bluegill (Lepomis macrochirus)
American Eel (Anguilla rostrata)
White Perch (Morone americana)
Scud (Gammarus Sp.)
Bristleworm (Nais Sp.)
Snail (Amnicola Sp.)
Goldfish (Carassius auratus)
Damselfy (Unidentified)
Caddisfly (Unidentified)
Stonefly (Acroneuria lycorius)
Banded Killifish (Fundulus diaphanus)
-------
Rank
Table 2.9 Pennsylvania Resident Species Toxicity Data for Nickel
LC50 LN LC50 SNO Species
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
Rank
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
78.4561
208.4833
233.5550
301.5102
388.3505
401.2168
439.8254
440.2043
506.5306
509.2643
627.1620
658.5149
664.8523
721.1083
731.3375
1007.69
1544.49
2226.41
Table 2.10
FLC50
(H9/D
78.4560
233.5550
345.4717
401.2168
439.8254
445.5883
607.9420
627.1620
664.8523
721.1083
731.3375
1544.4988
2226.4189
4.3625
5.3399
5.4534
5.7088
5.9619
5.9945
6.0864
6.0872
6.2276
6.2330
6.4412
6.4900
6.4996
6.5808
6.5949
6.9154
7.3425
7.7081
Pennsylvania
LN(FLCSO)
4.3625
5.4534
5.8449
5.9945
6.0864
6.0994
6.4101
6.4412
6.4996
6.5808
6.5949
7.3425
7.7081
15.0
90.0
33.0
89.0
92.0
2.0
45.0
73.0
68.0
93.0
53.0
88.0
24.0
4.0
5.0
67.0
52.0
81.0
Resident
FNO
19
29
48
7
35
47
40
37
25
10
12
34
44
Cladoceran (Daphnia pulicaria)
Rock Bass (Ambloplites rupestris)
Mayfly (Ephemerella subvaria)
Striped Bass (Morone saxatilis)
Pumpkinseed (Lepomis gibbosus)
Rotifer (Philodina acuticornis)
Midge (Chironomus Sp.)
Fathead Minnow (Pimephales promelas)
Carp (Cyprinus reticulata)
Bluegill (Lepomis macrochirus)
American Eel (Anguilla rostrata)
White Perch (Morone americana)
Scud (Gammarus Sp.)
Bristleworm (Nais Sp.)
Snail (Amnicola Sp.)
Goldfish (Carassius auratus)
Caddisfly (Unidentified)
Banded Killifish (Fundulus diaphanus)
Family Toxicity Data for Nickel
Family
Daphnidae
Ephemerellidae
Centrarchidae
Philodinidae
Chironomidae
Perchithyidae
Cyprinidae
Anguillidae
Gammaridae
Naididae
Bithyniidae (Bulimidae) (Hydrobiidae)
Hydropsychidae
Cyprinodontidae
2-19
-------
with P calculated as R/(N +1) where N is the total number of families in the State data base,
which is 13 in this case. Substituting these values into equations 2.1 to 2.5, we obtain the
following:
M2 = 0.024 (2.19)
x = 5.41 (2.20)
y = 0.411 (2.21)
A = 4.22 (2.22)
The Final Acute Intercept (FAI) is:
FAI = eA = 67.7 (2.23)
and the Final Acute Equation is:
FAV = FAI x et°-76 In (hardness)] (2.24)
FAV = 67.7 el0-76 ln (hardness)] (2.25)
or
FAV = el0-76 ln (hardness) + A] (2.26)
FAV = et°-76 ln (hardness) + 4.22] (2.27)
Since the acute-chronic ratio for Nickel (19.4) is greater than 2, the maximum value
criteria (MVC) for Nickel for the State of Pennsylvania is:
MVC = (FAI/2)eI°-76 ln (hardness)] (2.28)
MVC = 33.8 et0-76 ln (hardness)] (2.29)
or
MVC = el0-76 ln (hardness) + 3.52] (2.30)
2. The 30-Day Average Criterion
The chronic toxicity of Nickel is related to hardness in freshwater in the same way as is
acute toxicity (Equation 2.18). The national chronic toxicity data base (Table 2.11) contains
-------
only two families which are indigenous to Pennsylvania (Cyprinidae and Salmonidae),
therefore, the FCV cannot be calculated from the State chronic toxicity data base.
Table 2.11 National Chronic Toxicity Data for Nickel
Rank FLC50 LN (FLC50) FNO Family
1
2
3
4
(MJ/U
2.5476
7.4587
17.8999
23.7813
0.9351
2.0094
2.8848
3.1689
19
40
38
34
Daphnidae
Cyprinidae*
Salmonidae*
Hydropsychidae
'Indigenous to Pennsylvania.
The available acute-chronic ratio is 19.3 (see Table 2.1) which allows a Final Chronic Equa-
tion to be calculated from the Final Acute Equation:
FCV = FAV/(acute-chronic ratio) (2.31)
With the State Final Acute Equation given by Equation 2.25, the State Final Chronic
Equation is defined as:
FCV = ^Ie[°-76 ln (hardness)] (2.32)
FCV = 3.49 et°-76 ln (hardness)] (2.33)
or
FCV = et°-76 ln (hardness) + 1.25] (2.34)
Since there is no FRV or FPV for Nickel, the Final Chronic Equation, which expresses the
Final Chronic Value as a function of hardness, is the Pennsylvania 30-day average criterion
for Nickel.
2-21
-------
SECTION 3
RESULTS
3.1 SPECIES DISTRIBUTION BY STATE
Much of the information used to recalculate water quality criteria by state is presented in Appen-
dix B. Identification numbers assigned to the states and to families in the national data base are listed
in Appendices B-1 and B-2, respectively. Species identification numbers and the corresponding family
classifications are presented in Appendix B-3. State and species are listed by identification number in
Appendices B-4 and B-5, and the distribution in the United States (Hawaii and Alaska are not included)
of the 95 species in the national data base is presented in Appendix B-5.
A complete list of North American species used in toxicity testing (Appendix B-3) includes the
taxonomic families into which each organism is classified. There are 58 families. The relationship of
these families to the minimum data requirements, which are discussed in Section 2.1.1, is illustrated
in Appendix B-6.
The 58 families are arrayed in Appendix B-6 by ID number. The relationship of these families to the
minimum data requirements may be determined by matching the code number in the Figure to each of
the eight specified data requirements. Note that most of the families may satisfy more than one of the
minimum data requirements. For example, after a member of the family Salmonidae has been
selected, there are 14 families which satisfy the requirement for one other member of the class
Osteichthyes, and 20 families remaining which satisfy the requirement for one other family in the
phylum Chordata.
The total number of resident species in the each of 48 states ranges from 39 to 74, approximately
40 to 70 percent of the total species in the national toxicity data base. New York has the greatest
number of resident species while Florida has the least. Eighteen species are present in all 48 states:
rotifer (Philodina acuticornis)
rotifer (Philodina roseala)
bristleworm (Nais sp.J
worm (Limnodrilus hoffmeisteri)
snail (Gyraulus circumstriatus)
snail (Physa sp.J
cladoceran (Daphnia pulex)
cladoceran (Daphnia pulicaria)
cladoceran (Simocephalus serru/atus)
copepod (unidentified)
scud (Hyallela azteca)
damselfly (Ischnura sp.)
midge (Chironomus plumsus)
3-1
-------
midge (Chironomus sp.J
midge (unidentified)
caddisily (unidentified)
carp (Cyprinus carpio)
large mouth bass (Micropterus salmoides)
There are several species that are widely used in testing but whose actual distribution is limited.
The planarian, Polycelis fe/ina is indigenous only in Central Europe and is not present in any of the 48
states. (Kenk, personal communication, 1981.) The distribution in the United States of an often studied
laboratory cladoceran, Daphnia magna, is limited. There is no valid record of the natural occurrence of
Daphnia magna east of the Mississippi River. The known distribution of Daphnia magna in the United
States is shown in Figure 3.1, which is modified from "The Systematics of North American Daphnia"
(Brooks, 1957); the distribution range covers 14 of the western states. Daphnia pulicaria is recognized
in Europe but is not listed in "The Systematics of North American Daphnia" (Brooks, 1957). Daphnia
pulicaria and Daphnia pulex are extremely similar in their taxonomy (Herbert, P., personal communica-
tion, 1981.) In this study, it is assumed that Daphnia pulex, which commonly occurs in the states, is the
same as Daphnia pulicaria.
3.2 STATE WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
The state water quality criteria which result from application of the recalculation method are
presented in this report in two formats: first by chemical (Appendix C) and second by state (Appendix
D). The state maximum criteria were calculated whenever the state toxicity data bases contained four
or more families. This did not necessarily meet the requirements of the revised methodology for
calculating criteria, but was done for illustrative purposes. Since the revised methodology calls for a
regression of four data points, the national value was adopted as the state value whenever the state
toxicity data comprised fewer than four families.
In calculating the national maximum value criteria, the minimum data requirement was met by
only five chemicals (DDT, Cadmium, Chromium, Copper and Zinc). Those elements of the minimum
data requirement which were not satisfied, for each chemical of interest, are indicated in Table 3.1.
The national toxicity data bases for ten chemicals (Aldrin, Chlordane, Dieldren, Endosulfan, Endrin,
Heptachlor, Lindane, PCB, Toxaphene and Arsenic) include no families in phyla other than Arthropoda
or Chordata. The data bases for nine chemicals (Chlordane, Heptachlor, Lindane, PCB, Cyanide,
Arsenic, Lead, Selenium and Silver) include no order of insect other than the one used to meet require-
ment 6, nor do they include any phyla other than Arthropoda, Chordata and one phylum used to meet
requirement 7. Data bases of species for seven of the chemicals fail to meet one requirement and nine
of them fail to meet two. Ninety-seven (97) percent of the state data bases for calculating the state
maximum value criteria do not meet the minimum data requirements. Since the state toxicity data are
always a subset of the national toxicity data, the cause of an inability of most state data sets to meet
the minimum data requirements is insufficient data in the national toxicity data base.
The use of the tables in Appendices C and D is straightforward. For instance, the water quality
criteria for Lindane for the State of Michigan may be obtained from tables of Lindane in Appendix C or
3-2
-------
Figure 3.1 Distribution of Daphnla magna in the United States (Modified from Brooks, 1957)
3-3
-------
Table 3.1 Minimum Data Requirements Which Are Not Met
By The National Toxicity Data Base
Criteria'
Chemical Name 12345678
Aldrln x!
Chlordane x x
Dieldrin x
DDT
Endosulfan x
Endrin x
Heptachlor x x
Lindane x x
PCS x x
Toxaphene x
Cyanide x
Arsenic x x
Cadmium
Chromium
Copper
Lead x x
Mercury x x
Nickel x
Selenium x
Silver x
Zinc
1The eight criteria of the minimum data requirements:
1. The family Salmonidae in the class Osteichthyes.
2. One other family in the class Osteichthyes.
3. One other family in the phylum Chordata.
4. A planktonic crustacean (e.g. conchostracean, cladoceran, or copepod).
5. A benthic crustacean (e.g., crayfish, isopod, ostracod, scud or glass
shrimp).
6. A benthic insect (e.g., a benthic caddisfly, damselfly, dragonfly, mayfly,
midge, mosquito or stonefly.
7. A family in a phylum other than Arthropoda or Chordata (e.g., Rotifera,
Annelida or Mollusca).
8. Any other order of insect or any other phylum.
2"x" indicates criterion is not satisfied.
-------
tables for Michigan in Appendix D. The maximum value criterion is 6.60 ^g/l, which was obtained by
dividing the State Final Acute Value by 2; the 30-day average criterion is 0.528 j^g/l which was derived
by dividing the State Final Acute Value by acute-chronic ratio of 25 (see Table 2.1). Other useful infor-
mation is also available in these tables. The total number of families in the State resident data base
for Michigan is eight. The four most sensitive families and their FMAVs are:
FMAV
Family
Salmonidae 21.99
Gammaridae 22.44
Centrarchidae 42.20
Ictaiuridae 53.07
One may immediately infer from this information that the Michigan FAV for Lindane is lower than
the family mean acute value of the most sensitive family (21.99 ngl\ for Salmonidae). Since the FAV is
the value which corresponds to the fifth percentile, then the FAV should be less than the family mean
acute value of the most sensitive family if the total number of resident families is less than 20.
In all cases, except for those containing less than four resident families, the maximum criteria
may be calculated based on the information given in these tables. Take the maximum value criterion
of Lindane for Michigan as an example, with a total of eight resident families and mean acute values
for the four most sensitive of 21.99, 22.44, 42.20 and 53.07 /^g/l. The coefficients needed for the FAV
can be calculated by substituting these values into equations 2.1 to 2.5, yielding:
M2 = 0.104 (3.1)
x =3.48 (3.2)
y =0.51 (3.3)
A =2.58 (3.4)
The FAV is:
eA = e2-58 = 13.2^9/1 (3-5)
The acute-chronic ratio ranges from 3 (Mercury) to 122 (Cadmium), for the 21 chemicals (see footnote 1
of Table 2.1). In other words, the acute-chronic ratios are greater than 2 for all of the chemicals studied.
The maximum value criterion, which is defined as the FAV divided by the smaller of (a) 2 or (b) the
acute-chronic ratio, may be simply defined as the FAV/2. The maximum value criterion of Lindane for
Michigan is therefore defined as:
FAV/2 = 13.2/2 = 6.6 ngl\ (3.6)
3-5
-------
In selecting the 30-day average criteria, the information presented in Table 2.1 is used. The acute-
chronic ratio is 25.0 which yields the final chronic value of 0.528 ng/l. Comparing this value with the
available FRV of 100, the 30-day average criterion is chosen as 0.528 /jg/l. The final selection of the
30-day average criterion is indicated in the column (+ +). An "ACR" means that the value was ob-
tained by dividing the FAV with the acute-chronic ratio; "FCV" indicates that the value was calculated
from the chronic toxicity data base; "FPV" indicates that the value was the Final Plant Value; "FRV"
indicates the Final Residue Value; and "SCV'represents the value as the chronic value of important
species.
Whenever the acute toxicity data base does not meet the minimum data requirements, a star (*) is
printed next to the maximum value criterion. If the State data set contains less than four families, "**"
is printed and the national maximum value criteria is printed as the state maximum value criterion.
The state has three options in these cases: to use the calculated value given in the table; to use the na-
tional criterion; or to conduct additional toxicity tests of additional species so that the state toxicity
data base is adequate to meet the minimum data requirements, and then calculate the criteria. For
more detailed information on meeting the minimum data requirements (so as to decide the test
species for additional tests), a state may refer to the information given in Appendix E. In Appendix E,
the state and chemical as well as the criteria of the minimum data requirements are all represented by
their ID numbers. Appendix B-1 may be used for reference.
One of the minimum data requirements is "the family Salmonidae." Salmonid fish are not
indigenous in four States: Florida, Kansas, Texas and Mississippi. The approach taken in this study
was to relieve these four states from the necessity of meeting this requirement. These four are in-
dicated by a "#" sign to the left of the state's name.
For the six chemicals (Cd, Cu, Pb, Ag, Ni and Zn) whose acute toxicity is dependent on hardness
in water, the values shown in the column "LC50 Value" and the maximum value criteria shown in the
tables of Appendices C and D refer only to the acute intercepts, that is, the value at zero hardness ef-
fect. In order to set appropriate criteria for different hardness conditions, a state should multiply the
maximum value criteria (CR) shown in Appendices C and D by the hardness dependence function:
VCR = CR x exp[v In (H)], ^g/l (3.7)
where VCR = maximum value criteria for a hardness concentration of H mg/l as CaCO3
v = the mean acute slope (shown at the bottom of Table 1 of the criteria
document),
H = ambient hardness concentration in mg/l CaC03.
Equation (3.7) may be written as:
VCR = exp[(v In (H) + z] (3.8)
with
z = In(CR) <3-9)
3-6
-------
Table 3.2 presents a tabulation of v(the slope) and z(the log intercept) for the maximum value criteria
for the six hardness dependent chemicals.
If the 30-day average criterion for these 6 chemicals is denoted by ACR (meaning the value is the
quotient of the FAV divided by the acute-chronic ratio), the 30-day average value shown in Appendices
C and D refers only to the intercept. In order to set appropriate average criteria, the state should also
multiply the 30-day average criterion shown in Appendices C and D by the same hardness dependence
function used for the maximum value criteria. Equation 3.7 should be used, in which the tabulated
30-day value is substituted for CR and the result (VCR) becomes the 30-day average criterion and the
mean acute slope is used. For example, the 30-day average Cadmium criterion for New York should be
0.0004exp[1.05 In (Hardness)], where 0.0004 is taken from Appendix Cor D, and 1.05 is the mean acute
slope shown in Table 3.2. If the ambient hardness is 50 mg/l as CaCO3, the 30-day average Cadmium
criterion for New York becomes 0.0243 ^g/l.
There are two chemicals (Copper and Lead) whose 30-day average criteria may be calculated from
the chronic data base (as denoted by FCV in Appendices C and D). Of these, the chronic toxicity for
copper is independent of hardness and the values shown in the Appendices will be the 30-day average
criteria. On the other hand, the chronic toxicity for lead is hardness dependent with a mean chronic
slope of 2.35 (see Table 2 of 1980 criteria document for Lead) which is different from the value of the
mean acute slope for lead. In order to set the appropriate 30-day average criterion for Lead, those
states whose 30-day average criterion for Lead is denoted by FCV in Appendices C and D, should
multiply the value shown with the following hardness dependent function:
SCV = Cl x exp(2.35(ln(H)) (3.10)
where
SCV = 30-day average criterion for Lead, if derived from chronic data base,
for a hardness concentration of H mg/l as CaCO3
Cl = 30-day average values shown in Appendices C and D denoted by FCV
H = ambient hardness concentration in mg/l CaC03
In other words, the appropriate 30-day average criterion for Lead may be derived by using equa-
tion (3.7) if the value shown in the Appendices is denoted by ACR, or may be derived by using equation
(3.10) if the value shown in Appendices is denoted by FCV. For example, the 30-day average Lead1
criterion for Mississippi is 0.001 exp(1.22ln(H)) yielding a value of 0.11 /*g/l for a hardness of 50 mg/l
CaCO3 whereas for New York it is 0.00004 exp(2.35ln(H)) yielding a value of 0.39 pg/l for a hardness of
50 mg/l CaCO3. The main difference is that for Mississippi, the mean acute slope is used in the hard-
ness dependent equation since its 30-day average criterion is denoted by ACR while for New York, the
mean chronic slope is used in the hardness dependent equation since its 30-day average criterion is
denoted by FCV.
3-7
-------
Table 3.2 Values of v and z in the Maximum Value Criteria Equation
exp[v(ln(H)) + z], by State
Chemical
State
National
Alabama
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida--
Georgia
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kansas**
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi--
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas**
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Wyoming
Cadmium
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
-3.61
-4.34
-4.61
-1.56
-4.20
-4.42
-3.96
-3.61
-3.08
-4.83
-4.34
-3.91
-3.96
-1.15
-3.19
-4.34
-3.19
-4.20
-3.86
-3.96
-3.77
-3.86
-2.83
-2.83
-4.71
-5.12
-4.71
-4.07
-3.86
-4.42
-3.54
-3.96
-4.27
-4.20
-4.34
-4.27
-3.96
-3.96
-4.14
-4.14
-4.34
-3.19
-4.71
-4.07
-4.07
-4.34
-4.51
-3.96
-4.71
Co)
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
jper
-1.64
-1.98
-2.06
-2.11
-2.06
-2.02
-1.97
-1.95
-2.06
-2.06
-2.16
-1.91
-1.91
-2.02
-2.15
-1.95
-2.10
-1.89
-1.97
-1.93
-1.93
-1.97
-2.06
-2.06
-2.02
-1.90
-2.11
-1.97
-1.97
-1.90
-1.89
-1.97
-1.90
-1.93
-1.99
-2.10
-1.93
-1.97
-2.02
-1.90
-1.99
-2.11
-2.11
-1.97
-1.93
-2.15
-2.02
-1.93
-2.02
Le
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
•ad
-3.30
3.62
-1.02
-3.35
-1.02
-1.12
2.71
3.60
5.05
2.64
-1.25
-2.83
3.62
-3.35
-3.30
-2.83
-3.30
-3.30
2.17
2.17
-2.92
2.71
-3.35
-3.30
-1.25
-1.25
-1.13
2.37
2.64
-1.25
-2.92
2.64
-1.12
2.17
-2.83
-1.52
2.71
2.71
2.64
-1.12
-2.83
4.73
-1.25
2.37
2.71
-1.52
2.71
-2.92
-1.25
Nickel
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
3.49
3.45
3.15
3.37
3.15
3.06
3.50
3.50
3.43
3.40
3.00
3.55
3.51
3.44
3.40
3.45
3.37
3.56
3.50
3.50
3.52
3.44
3.45
3.45
3.08
3.15
3.08
3.50
3.50
3.22
3.56
3.50
3.16
3.50
3.45
3.08
3.52
3.50
3.44
3.23
3.45
3.43
3.08
3.50
3.56
3.00
3.44
3.52
3.08
Silver
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
-7.54
-7.96
-9.12
-10.82
-9.12
-8.11
-9.72
-7.54
-7.54
- 10.82
-8.11
-7.80
-7.96
-8.47
-7.54
-7.80
-7.54
-7.54
-7.96
-9.72
-7.80
-9.12
-10.82
-11.51
-8.80
-8.80
-9.43
-9.72
-7.54
-8.11
-7.80
-7.54
-8.80
-7.80
-8.87
-8.25
-7.96
-9.72
-7.54
-8.80
-7.80
-8.80
-8.11
-9.72
-9.72
-8.25
-7.96
-7.80
-8.11
Zinc
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
0.83
1.82
2.13
1.63
1.52
1.62
1.50
2.13
1.89
2.22
2.25
0.99
2.29
2.29
1.61
1.99
2.13
2.10
2.14
2.14
2.13
2.07
2.01
2.04
2.04
1.54
1.76
1.21
2.13
2.12
1.80
2.09
2.12
1.42
2.07
2.13
1.56
2.13
2.13
2.07
1.48
2.13
2.04
1.56
2.13
2.12
0.98
2.03
2.07
1.54
v Slope of hardness effect.
z Acute intercept.
* Use national criteria, state has less than four resident families.
" No Indigenous salmonid fish in state.
3-8
-------
SECTION 4
DISCUSSION
The minimum data requirement, which was discussed earlier, specifies toxicity test results for at
least eight different families. The intent of this requirement is to assure that the organisms considered
in a criterion calculation represent a variety of dissimilar organisms commonly found in the aquatic
environment. The calculation itself is performed on the four most sensitive of the eight families which
are required to satisfy the minimum data requirement.
Over 1,000 cases were considered in this study in order to recalculate criteria for each of 21
chemicals for each of 48 states. The minimum data requirement could not be satisfied in 97 percent of
the combinations of state and chemical examined. In some cases, the minimum data base cannot be
met. According to the literature on species distribution, for example, salmonids simply are not found
in four states: Florida, Kansas, Mississippi and Texas.
For those cases in which the minimum data base could not be satisfied, criteria were calculated
for illustrative purposes if there was information available on at least four families. There were 16
chemicals for which toxicity test data were available for at least four families in each state. For many
states, however, there were insufficient data for the five remaining chemicals (Arsenic, Chlordane,
Endosulfan, Lead and Mercury) to apply the revised methodology. When a state criterion could not be
calculated, the national criterion was adopted. This occurred in approximately five percent of the
cases examined.
The recalculated state maximum value criteria are compared qualitatively with the national
values in Table 4.1, and the 30-day average values are compared in Table 4.2. In examining a single
chemical, the state criteria tend to be either predominantly more stringent or predominantly less
stringent than the national value for a given pollutant.
The state-specific criteria which were calculated after removing non-resident families are
presented in Appendix C by chemical and in Appendix D by state. In each case the national criteria
and the state criteria are tabulated together with the number of families in the national data base
which are resident in a given state, and the names of the four families used to recalculate the criteria.
The national value was used as a state value whenever fewer than four families were available.
The information in these Appendices, which should be of immediate use to the states, reflects
the extent of and the limitations imposed by the national data base as constituted when this work was
done. The national data base is not a finished product by any means, however, and EPA is continually
adding new information.
For those cases in which the minimum data requirement was not satisfied, the addition of toxicity
data for new families should improve the quality of recalculated state-specific criteria. Given the large
number of combinations of state and chemical for which the minimum data requirement could not be
met, it is not likely that the national data base will soon be extensive enough to serve all the states for
all the toxic chemicals. This being the case, a state might find it expedient to run selected bioassays
in order to augment the data base for a specific pollutant. By comparing the minimum data require-
ment with the information In Appendix E, state biologists should be able readily to determine those
families for which additional toxicity test results are indicated.
-------
Table 4.1 Comparison of National and State Maximum Value Criteria
jfiiliu
<
-------
Table 4.2 Comparison of National and State 30-Day Average Criteria
E £
I ! ! I '
1 5 3 § i
Alabama • *
Arizona
Arkansas +
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida" +
Georgia
Idaho
Illinois +
Indiana H
Iowa +
Kansas" + H
Kentucky
Louisiana + •*
Maine 4
Maryland 4
Massachusetts 4
Michigan
C i- 0)
= <0 O c
i fe 3 = 1 € S t 1 £
5lSHl||i-llIfflS||o
33&g|22£3:3iig3iliq
+ - 4- + -f- " +
4- + - +
+ - +
4- +
+ 4- -
+ 4- +
+ + + +
+ + 4- 4- +
+ 4- 4- + +
- - - _ + _+ _ +
+ + +
+ + 4- +
+ + 4- +
- -t- + + +
+ 4- +
+ + + +
+ + 4-4-
+ + 4-
+ 4-4-4-
4- + 4- - +
Minnesota
Mississippi"
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas"
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Wyoming
+ State 30-day average less stringent than the National value.
- State 30-day average more stringent than the National value.
No 30-day average value.
" No resident Salmonld families.
4-3
-------
REFERENCES
Baumann, R.W., et al. "The Stonef lies (Plecoptera) of the Rocky Mountains, Memoirs of the American
Entomological Society," 30 November, 1977.
Bousfield, E. L, Freshwater Amphipod Crustaceans of Glaciated North America, The Canadian Field-
Naturalist, Volume 72, No. 2, pages 55-113, April-June, 1958.
Brinkhurst, R., and Jamminson, B., Aquatic Oligochaeta of the World, Oliver and Boyd, Edinburgh,
1971.
Brooks, J.L, The Systematics of North American Daphnia, Memoirs of the Connecticut Academy of
Arts and Sciences, Volume XIII, November, 1957.
Burks, B. D., The Mayflies or Ephemeroptera of Illinois, Bulletin of the Illinois Natural History Survey,
State of Illinois, Department of Agriculture and Education, May, 1953.
Edmunds, George F., et al. The Mayflies of North and Central America, University of Minnesota Press,
Minneapolis, 1976.
Emerson, W.K., and Jacobson, M.K., The American Museum of Natural History Guide to Shells, Alfred
A. Knopf, Inc., New York, 1976.
Fischer, F. C. J., Trichopterorum Catalogus, Volume IV, Hydropsychidae Arctopsychidae, Nederland-
sche Entomologische Vereeniging, Amsterdam, 1963.
Hobbs, H.H., Crayfishes (Astacidae) of North and Middle America, Biota of Freshwater Ecosystems
Identification Manual No. 9 for EPA, May 1972.
Holthus, L.B., A General Revision of the Palaemonidae of the Americas, II. The Subfamily
Palaemonidae, University of South California Press, Los Angeles, California, 1952.
Holsinger, J.R., The Freshwater Amphipod Crustaceans (Gammaridae) of North America, Biota of
Freshwater Ecosystems Identification Manual No. 5 for EPA, April, 1972.
Hyman, L.H., The Invertebrates, Volume VI, Mollusca I, McGraw-Hill, 1967.
Kenk, R., Personal Communication, Division of Worms, Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian In-
stitute.
Lee, D.S., et al. Atlas of North American Freshwater Fishes, North Carolina State Museum of Natural
History, 1980.
Merritt, R.W., and Cummins, K.W., An Introduction to the Aquatic Insects of North America, Third Prin-
ting, Kendall/Hunt Publishing Company, 1978 (ed.).
Pennak, R.W., Freshwater Invertebrates of the United States, John Wiley & Sons, 1978.
R-1
-------
REFERENCES (Continued)
Stark, B.P., and Gaufin, A.R., The Nearactic Genera of Perlidae (Plecoptera), Miscellaneous Publica-
tion of the Entomological Society of America, Volume 10, No. 1, 1976.
U.S. Agricultural Research Service, A Catalog of the Diptera of America North of Mexico, Agricultural
Handbook No. 276, U.S. Department of Agriculture, August 1965.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Guidelines for Deriving Numerical National Water Quality
Criteria for the Protection of Aquatic Life and Its Uses, 1983.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Guidelines for Deriving Site-Specific Water Quality Criteria for
the Protection of Aquatic Life and its Uses, 1982.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Ambient Water Quality Criteria for Copper, EPA 440/5-80-036,
1980.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Water Quality Criteria Documents: Availability (45FR79318, 28
November, 1980).
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Quality Criteria for Water, 1976.
Walker, E.N., The Odonata of Canada and Alaska, University of Toronto Press, 1953.
Ward, H.B. and Wipple, G.C., Freshwater Biology, Second Edition, 1972.
Williams, W. D., Freshwater Isopods (Asellidae) of North America, Biota of Freshwater Ecosystems,
Identification Manual No. 7, prepared for EPA, May, 1972.
R-2
-------
APPENDIX A
RESIDENT NORTH AMERICAN SPECIES OF AQUATIC ANIMALS USED IN TOXICITY TESTS
This Appendix identifies species of aquatic animals which have been used in toxlclty tests and
have been confirmed to be resident North American species for the purposes of the "Guidelines (or
Deriving National Water Quality Criteria for the Protection of Aquatic Life and Its Uses." "North
America" includes only the 48 contiguous states, Canada, and Alaska. Species do not have to be
native to be resident. Other species should be considered resident North American species if they can
be similarly confirmed or if the test organisms were obtained from a wild population In North America.
The sequence for fishes is taken from A List of Common and Scientific Names of Fishes from the
United States and Canada. For other species, the sequence of phyla, classes and families is taken
from the NODC Taxonomic Code. Third Edition, National Oceanographlc Data Center, NOAA,
Washington. D.C. 20235. July. 1981. and the numbers given are from that source to facilitate verifica-
tion. Wtthm a family, genera are in alphabetical order, as are species in a genus. An asterisk (*) beside
a common name indicates that the species is nonresident.
Freshwater Species
Species
Freshwater Species
Class Family
PHYLUM: PORIFERA (36)
Demospongia Spongillidae
3660 366301
PHYLUM: PLATYHELMINTHES (39)
Turbellana Planarudae
3901
Dendrocelidae
391501
PHYLUM: GASTROTRICHA (44)
Chaetonotoida Chaetonotidae
4402 440201
PHYLUM: ROTIFERA (ROTATORIA) (45)
Bdelloidea Philodmidae
4503 450402
Monogononta
4506
Brachionidae
450601
PHYLUM: ANNELIDA (50)
Archiannelida Aeolosomatidae
5002 500301
Ohgochaeta Lumbnculidae
5004 500501
Tubificidae
500902
Naidtdae
500903
PHYLUM: MOLLUSCA (5085)
Gastropoda Vivipandae
51 510306
Bithynndae
(Ammcolidae)
(Bulimidaei
'Hydrobiidaej
510317
Common Name
Sponge
Plananan*
Planarian
Rotifer
Rotifer
Worm
Worm
Tubiflcld worrr
Tubiflcid worrr
Worm
Snail
Snail
Species
Scientific Name
Ephydatia fluvialilis
P[anarja gonocephala
Polyceljs felina
Procotyla fluviatilis
(Dendfocoelurn lacteuml
Lepidodermella squamatum
Philodina acuticornls
Phllodina roseola
KerateHa cochlearis
Aeojosoma he ad ley I
Lumbrlculus varlegatus
Limnodfilis hoffmelsteri
Tubifex tub if ex
Nais sp.
Prlstlna sp.
Campeloma declsum
AmnicoljLSp.
Pleurocerldae
510340
Lymnaeidae
Planorbidai
511412
Physidae
511413
Margaritlferidae
551201
Unlonidae
551202
Corbiculidae
551545
Plsidiidae
(Sphaeriidae)
PHYLUM: ARTHROPOD A (58-69)
Crustacea Lynceidae
61 610701
Sididae
610901
Daphnidae
610902
Bivalvia
(Pelecypoda)
55
Common Name
Snail
Snail
Snail
Snail
Snail
Snail
Snail
Snail
Snail-
Snail
Snail
Snail
Snail'
Snail
Snail
Snail
Mussel
Mussel
Asiatic clam
Asiatic clam
Fingernail clam
Fingernail clam
Fingernail clam
Conchostracan
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Scientific Name
Goniobasis livescens
Goniobasjs virginica
Leptoxis carinate
(Nitocfis carinatal
(Mudaliacarinata)
Nitrocris sp.
Lymnaeacatascopium
(Lymnaea emargjnata)
(Stagnicola emarginata)
Lymnaea elodes
(Lymnaea pal u sir I si
Lymnaea stagnalis
Lymnaea sp.
Biomphalaria glabrata
Gyraulus circumstnalus
Helisoma campanulalum
Aplexa hypnorum
Physa fgntinajis
Physa gyrina
Physa heterostropha
Physa Integra
Margaritlfera
Cyrtonaias tampicoenis
Corbicula fluminea
Corbicula manilensis
Eupera cubensis
(Eupera singleyi)
Musculium transversum
(Sphaerium transversum)
Sphaerium corneum
Lynceus brachyurus
Diaphanosoma sp.
Ceriodaphnia reticulata
-------
APPENDIX A
RESIDENT NORTH AMERICAN SPECIES OF AQUATIC ANIMALS USED IN TOXICITY TESTS
Freshwater Species
Freshwater Species
Bosmmidae
610903
Polyphemidae
610905
Cyprididae
(Cypridae)
611303
Diaptomidae
611818
Cyclopidae
612008
Asellidae
616302
Gammaridae
616921
Hyalellidae
(Talitridae)
616923
Palaemonidae
617911
Astacidae
618102
Species
Common Name
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran*
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Ostracod'
Ostracod
Copepod*
Copepod"
Copepod
Copepod
Copepod
Copepod
Isopod*
Isopod
Isopod
Isopod'
Isopod
Scud
Scud
Scud
Scud
Scud
Scud
Glass shrimp
Crayfish
Crayfish
Crayfish
Crayfish
Scientific Name
Daphnia ambigua
Daphnia carmata
Daphnia cucullata
Daphnia galeata mendotae
Daphnia hyalina
Daphnia longispina
Daphnia maqna
Daphnia pulex
Daphnia pulicana
Daphnia similis
Daphnia serrulatus
Simocephalus vetulus
Bosmina lonqirostris
Polyphemus pediculus
Cypretta kawatai
CypridODSis vidua
Eudiaptomus padanus
Cyclops abyssorum
Cyclops bicuspidatus
Cyclops vernalis
Eucyclops agilis
Mesocyclops leuckarti
Asellus aquaticus
Asellus brevicaudus
Asellus communis
Asellus mendianus
Asellus racovitzai
Cranqonyx pseudogracilis
Gammarus fasciatus
Gammarus lacustris
Gammarus pseudolimnaeus
Gammarus sp.
Hyalella azteca
(Hyalella knickerbockeri)
Palaemonetes kadiakensis
Cambarus latimanus
Faxonella clypeatus
Orconectes limosus
Orconectes propinquus
Insecta
62-65
Heptageniidae
621601
Baetidae
621602
Ephemerellidae
Caenidae
621802
Ephemeridae
622003
Libellulidae
622601
Coenagrionidae
(Agrionidae)
(Coenagriidae)
622904
Pteronarcidae
626201
Perlidae
625401
Perlodidae
625402
Dytiscidae
630506
Elmidae
(Elminthidae)
631604
Hydropsychidae
641804
Common Name
Crayfish
Crayfish
Crayfish
Crayfish
Crayfish
Crayfish
Crayfish
Crayfish
Mayfly
Mayfly
Mayfly
Mayfly
Mayfly
Mayfly
Mayfly
Mayfly
Scientific Name
Orconectes nais
Orconectes rusticus
Orconectes virilis
Pacifastacus trowbrldqii
Procambarus acutus
Procambarus clarki
(Procambarus clarkii)
Procambarus simulans
Procambarus sp.
Stenonema ithaca
Stenonema rubrum
Callibaetis sp.
Ephemerella doddsi
Ephemerella grandis
Ephemerella subvaria
Ephemerella sp.
Caenis diminuta
Mayfly
Mayfly
Mayfly
Dragonfly
Damselfly
Damselfly
Stonefly
Stonefly
Stonefly
Stonefly
Stonefly
Stonefly
Stonefly
Stonefly
Beetle
Beetle
Caddisfly
Caddisfly
Hexagenia bilineata
Hexagenia rigida
Hexagenia sp.
Pantala hymenea
(Pantala hymenaea)
Ischnura verticalis
Ischnura sp.
Pleronarcella badia
Pteronarcys calif ornica
Pteronarcys dorsata
Pteronarcys sp.
Acroneuria lycorias
Acroneuria gacifica
Claassenia sabulosa
Arcynopteryx parallela
Stenelmis sexlineata
Arc tops yc he grandis
Hydropsyche betteni
-------
APPENDIX A
RESIDENT NORTH AMERICAN SPECIES OF AQUATIC ANIMALS USED IN TOXICITY TESTS
Freshwater Species
Species
Brachycentridae
641815
Ceratopogonidae
650504
Chironomidae
650508
PHYLUM: ECTOPROCTA (BRYOZOA) (78)
Phylactolaemata Pectinatelctdae
7817
Lophopodidae
Plumatellidae
781701
PHYLUM: CHORDATA (8388)
Agnatha Petromyzontidae
86 860301
Osteichthyes Anguiliidae
8717 874101
Salmomdae
875501
Esocidae
875801
Cyprinidae
877601
Common Name
Caddisfly
Caddisfly
Caddisfly
Biting midge
Midge
Midge
Midge
Midge
Bryozoan
Bryozoan
Bryozoan
Sea lamprey
American eel
Pink salmon
Cocho salmon
Sockeye salmon
Chinook salmon
Golden trout
Cutthroat trout
Rainbow trout
(Steelhead trout)
Atlantic salmon
Brown trout
Brook trout
Lake trout
Northern pike
Chiselmouth
Longfln dace
Central stoneroller
Goldfish
Common carp
Zebra danlo*
Zerbraflsh"
Golden shiner
Pugnose shiner
Emerald shiner
Striped shiner
Scientific Name
Hydropsyche callfornlca
Hydro psyche sp.
Brachycentrus sp.
Chlronomjjs pjurngsus
Chironomus tentans
Chlronomus sp.
Tanytarsus disslmulls
Pectinatetla magniflca
Lophopodella carter!
Plumatella emarglnata
Petromyzon marlnus
Angullla rostrata
Qncorhynchus gorbuscha
Oncorhynchus kisutch
Oncorhynchus nerka
Oncorhynchus tshawytscha
Salmo aquabonlta
Salmo clarki
Salmo galrdneri
Salmo salar
Salmo trutta
Salvelinus fontlnaljs
Salvellnus namaycush
Esox luclus
Acrochellus alutaceus
Agrosla chrysogaster
Campostoma anomalurn
Carasslus auratus
Cyprlnus carplo
panio rerio
(Brachydanlo rerla)
Notemlflonus crysoleucas
Notropis anoqenus
Notropis alherlnoldes
Notropls chrysocephalus
Freshw;
Family
Catostomldae
877604
Ictaluridae
877702
Clariidae
877712
Cyprinodontidae
880404
Poeciliidae
880408
Gasterosteidae
881801
Percichthyldae
Centrarchldae
883516
iter Species
Common Name
Common shiner
Pugnose minnow
Spottail shiner
Red shiner
Spotfin shiner
Northern redbelly
dace
Bluntnose minnow
Fathead minnow
Northern squawfish
Blacknose dace
Speckled dace
Rudd
Creek chub
Pearl dace
Tench
White sucker
Black bullhead
Yellow bullhead
Brown bullhead
Channel catfish
Walking catfish
Banded klllifish
Flagfish
Mosquitofish
Amazon molly
Sailfln molly
Molly
Guppy
Southern platyfish
Brook stickleback
Threespine
stickleback
Ninespine
stickleback
White perch
Striped bass
Rock bass
Green sunfish
Pumpkinseed
Orangespotted
sunfish
Bluegill
Longear sunfish
Species
Scientific Name
Notropis cornutus
Notropis emiliae
Notropis hudsonius
Notropis lutrensls
Notropis spectrunculus
Phoxlnus eos
Pimephales notatus
Pimephales promelas
Ptvchocheilus oreqonensis
Rhlnichthys atratulus
Rhinichthys osculus
Scardinius erythrophthalmus
Semotilus atromaculatus
Semotilus margarita
Tinea tinea
Catostomus commersoni
Ictalurus melas
Ictalurus natalis
Ictalurus nebulosus
Ictalurus punctatus
Clarias batrachus
Fundulus diaphanus
Jordanella floridae
Gambusia affinis
Pgeciiia formosa
Poecilia latipinna
Poecilia sp.
Poecilia reticulata
Xiphophorus maculatus
Calaea Inconstans
Gasterosteus aculeatus
Punqitius punqitius
Morone americana
Morone saxatllis
Ambloplites rupestris
Lepomls cyanellus
Lepomls qibbosus
Lepomis humllis
Lepomis macrochirus
Lepomis megalotis
A-3
-------
APPENDIX A
RESIDENT NORTH AMERICAN SPECIES OF AQUATIC ANIMALS USED IN TOXICITY TESTS
Freshwater Species
Species
Family Common Name Scientific Name
Redear sunfish Lepomis mjcrolophus
Smallmouth bass Micropterus dolomieui
Largemouth bass Micropterus salmoides
Black crapple Promoxis nigromaculalus
Percidae Rainbow darter Etheostoma caeruleum
Johnny darter Etheostoma nigrum
Orangethroat darter Elheostoma spec labile
Yellow perch Perca tlavescens
Walleye Stizostedion vitreum vitreum
Sciaenldae Freshwater drum Apiodinotus grunniens
883554
Cichlidae Mozambique Tilapla mossambica
883561 tilapia
Cottidae Mottled sculpin Cottus bairdj
883102
-------
APPENDIX B-1
STATE IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
ID NUMBER
2
3
4
5
6
7
a
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
26
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
36
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
STATE
NATIONAL
MAINE
NEW HAMPSHIRE
VERMONT
MASSACHUSETTS
RHODE ISLAND
CONNECTICUT
NEW YORK
PENNSYLVANIA
NEW JERSEY
DELAWARE
MARYLAND
VIRGINIA
NORTH CAROLINA
SOUTH CAROLINA
GEORGIA
FLORIDA
WEST VIRGINIA
KENTUCKY
TENNESSEE
ALABAMA
OHIO
MICHIGAN
INDIANA
MISSISSIPPI
WISCONSIN
ILLINOIS
MINNESOTA
IOWA
MISSOURI
ARKANSAS
LOUISIANA
NORTH DAKOTA
SOUTH DAKOTA
NEBRASKA
KANSAS
OKLAHOMA
TEXAS
MONTANA
WYOMING
COLORADO
NEW MEXICO
IDAHO
UTAH
ARIZONA
WASHINGTON
OREGON
NEVADA
CALIFORNIA
APPENDIX B-2
FAMILY IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
ID NUMBER
FAMILY
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
6
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
CHYPTOMONADIDAE
AMOEBIDAE
PARAMECIIDAE
SPIROSTOMATIDAE(SPIROSTOMATIDAE)
PLANARIIDAE
CHAETONOTIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
AEOLOSOMATIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
NAIDIDAE
VIVIPARIDAE
BITHYNIIDAE (BULIMIDAE) (HYDROBIIDAE)
PLEUROCERIDAE
LYMNAEIDAE
PLANORBIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PISIDIIDAE (SPHAERIIDAE)
LYNCEIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
POLYPHEMIDAE
CYPRIDIDAE (CYPRIDAE)
DIAPTOMIDAE
CYCLOPIDAE
ASELLIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
PALAEMONIDAE
ASTACIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
EPHEMEHIDAE (BAET1DAE)
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGRIONIDAE)
PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
HYDROPSYCHIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PETROMYZONTIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ESOCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CLARIIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
POECILIIDAE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SCIAENIOAE
CICHLIDAE
COTTI DAE
RANIDAE
MICROHYLIDAE
BUFONIDAE
HYLIDAE
AMBYSTOMATIDAE
SALAMANDRIDAE
-------
APPENDIX B-3
SPECIES IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS AND FAMILY CLASSIFICATION
FAMILY ID
NUMBER
5
7
7
10
9
9
12
11
15
14
16
16
16
17
19
19
19
19
19
21
23
24
24
25
25
25
25
26
28
28
26
28
28
27
29
29
30
33
33
33
32
32
31
31
31
35
35
35
35
35
34
34
34
34
34
37
38
SPECIES ID
NUMBER
1 00
2.00
3.00
400
4.25
4.50
5.00
6.00
7.00
8.00
9.00
10.00
11.00
11.50
12.00
13.00
14.00
15.00
16.00
17.00
18.00
19.00
20.00
21.00
22.00
23.00
24.00
25.00
26.00
27.00
28.00
29.00
30.00
31 00
32.00
33.00
34.00
35.00
36.00
37.00
38.00
39.00
40.00
41.00
42.00
43.00
44.00
45.00
46.00
47.00
48.00
49.00
50.00
51.00
52.00
5300
54.00
SPECIES NAME
PLANARIAN (POLYCELIS FELINA)
ROTIFER (PHILODINA ACUTICORNIS)
ROTIFER (PHILODINA ROSEOLA)
BRISTLEWORM (NAIS SP.)
TUBIFICID WORM (TUBIFEX TUBIFEX)
WORM (LIMNODRILUS HOFFMEISTERI)
SNAIL (AMNICOLA SP.)
SNAIL (CAMPELOMA DECISUM)
SNAIL (GYRAULUS CIRCUMSTRIATUS)
SNAIL (LYMNAEA PALUSTRIS)
SNAIL (PHYSA HETEROSTROPHA)
SNAIL (PHYSA INTEGRA)
SNAIL (PHYSA SP.)
FINGERNAIL CLAM (MUSCULIUM TRANSVERSUM)
CLADOCERAN (DAPHNIA CARINATA)
CLADOOERAN (DAPHNIA MAGNA)
CLADOCERAN (DAPHNIA PULEX)
CLADOCERAN (DAPHNIA PULIOARIA)
CLADOCERAN (SIMOCEPHALUS SERRULATUS)
SEED SHRIMP (CYPRIDOPSIS VIDUA)
COPEPOD (UNIDENTIFIED)
ISOPOD (ASELLUS BREVIOAUDUS)
ISOPOD (ASELLUS COMMUNIS)
SCUD (GAMMARUS FASCIATUS)
SCUD (GAMMARUS LACUSTRIS)
SCUD (GAMMARUS PSEUDOLIMNAEUS)
SCUD (GAMMARUS SP.)
SCUD (HYALLELA A2TECA)
CRAYFISH (FAXONELLA CLYPEATA)
CRAYFISH (ORCONECTES NAIS)
CRAYFISH (ORCONEOTES LIMOSUS)
CRAYFISH (ORCONECTES RUSTICUS)
CRAYFISH (PROCAMBARUS ACUTUS)
GLASS SHRIMP (PALAEMONETES KADIAKENSIS)
MAYFLY (EPHEMERELLA GRANDIS)
MAYFLY (EPHEMERELLA SUBVARIA)
MAYFLY (HEXAGENIA BILINEATA)
STONEFLY (ACRONEURIA LYCORIUS)
STONEFLY (ACRONEURIA PACIFICA)
STONEFLY (CLAASSENNIA SABULOSA)
STONEFLY (PTERONARCELLA BADIA)
STONEFLY (PTERONARCYS CALIFORNIA)
DAMSELFLY (ISCHNURA VERTICALUS)
DAMSELFLY (ISCHNURA SP.)
DAMSELFLY (UNIDENTIFIED)
MIDGE (CHIRONOMUS PLUMOSUS)
MIDGE (CHIRONOMUS TENTANS)
MIDGE (CHIRONOMUS SP.)
MIDGE (TANYTARSUS DISSIMILIS)
MIDGE (UNIDENTIFIED)
CADDISFLY (ARCTOPSYCHE GRANDIS)
CADDISFLY (CLISTORONIA MAGNIFICA)
CADDISFLY (HYDROPSYCHE BETTENI)
CADDISFLY (HYDROPSYCHE CALIFORNIA)
CADDISFLY (UNIDENTIFIED)
AMERICAN EEL (ANGUILLA ROSTRATA)
COHO SALMON (ONCORHYNCHUS KISUTCH)
FAMILY ID
NUMBER
SPECIES ID
NUMBER SPECIES NAME
38 55.00 SOCKEYE SALMON (ONCORHYNCHUS NERKA)
38 55.50 PINK SALMON (ONCORHYNCHUS GORBUSCHA)
38 5600 CHINOOK SALMON (ONCORHYNCHUS TSHAWYTSCHA)
38 57.00 CUTTHROAT TROUT (SALMO CLARKI)
38 58.00 RAINBOW TROUT (SALMO GAIRDNERI)
38 59.00 ATLANTIC SALMON (SALMO SALAR)
38 60.00 BROWN TROUT (SALMO TRUTTA)
38 60.50 GOLDEN TROUT (SALMO AGUABONITA)
38 6100 BROOK TROUT (SALVELINUS FONTINALIS)
38 62.00 LAKE TROUT (SALVELINUS NAMAYCUSH)
38 6250 SISCOWET (SALVELINUS NAMAYCUSH SISCOWET)
39 63.00 NORTHERN PIKE (ESOX LUCIUS)
52 64.00 MOTTLED SCULPIN (COTTUS BAIRDI)
52 64.40 SLIMY SCULPIN (COTTUS COGNATUS)
40 65.00 LONGFIN DACE (AGOSIA CHRYSOGASTER)
40 66.00 STONEROLLER(CAMPOSTOMAANOMALUM)
40 67.00 GOLDFISH (CARASSIUS AURATUS)
40 68.00 CARP (CYPRINUS CARPIO)
40 69.00 GOLDEN SHINER (NOTEMIGONUS CRYSOLEUCAS)
40 69.50 SPOTFIN SHINER (NOTROPIS SPILOPTERUS)
40 70.00 STRIPED SHINER (NOTROPIS CHRYSOCEPHALUS)
40 70.50 RED SHINER (NOTROPIS LUTRENSIS)
40 7100 NORTHERN REDBELLY DACE (PHOXINUS EOS)
40 72.00 BLUNTNOSE MINNOW (PIMEPHALES NOTATUS)
40 73.00 FATHEAD MINNOW (PIMEPHALES PROMELAS)
40 73.50 NORTHERN SQAUWFISH (PTYCHOCHEILUS OREGONENSIS)
40 74.00 BLACKNOSE DACE (RHINICHTHYS ATRATULUS)
40 75.00 SPECKLED DACE (RHINICHTHYS OSCULUS)
40 76.00 CREEK CHUB (SEMOTILUS ATROMACULATUS)
41 76.50 LONGNOSE SUCKER (CATOSTOMUS CATOSTOMUS)
41 77.00 WHITE SUCKER (CATOSTOMUS COMMERSONI)
42 78.00 BLACK BULLHEAD (ICTALURUS MELAS)
42 79.00 BROWN BULLHEAD (ICTALURUS NEBULOSUS)
42 80.00 CHANNEL CATFISH (ICTALURUS PUNCTATUS)
44 81.00 BANDED KILLIFISH (FUNDULUS DIAPHANUS)
44 82.00 FLAGFISH (JORDANELLA FLORIDAE)
45 83.00 MOSQUITOFISH (GAMBUSIA AFFINIS)
45 84.00 GUPPY (POECILIA RETICULATA)
45 85.00 SOUTHERN PLATYFISH (XIPHOPHORUS MACULATUS)
46 86.00 BROOK STICKLEBACK (CULAEA INCONSTANS)
46 87.00 THREESPINE STICKLEBACK (GASTEROSTEUS ACULEATUS)
47 88.00 WHITE PERCH (MORONE AMERICANA)
47 89.00 STRIPED BASS (MORONE SAXATILIS)
48 90.00 ROCK BASS (AMBLOPLITES RUPESTRIS)
48 91.00 GREEN SUNFISH (LEPOMIS CYANELLUS)
48 92.00 PUMPKINSEED (LEPOMIS GIBBOSUS)
48 93.00 BLUEGILL (LEPOMIS MACROCHIRUS)
48 94.00 LONGEAR SUNFISH (LEPOMIS MEGALOTIS)
48 95.00 REDEAR SUNFISH (LEPOMIS MICROLOPHUS)
48 96.00 SMALLMOUTH BASS (MICROPTERUS DOLOMIEUI)
48 97.00 LARGEMOUTH BASS (MICROPTERUS SALMOIDES)
48 98.00 BLACK CRAPPIE (POMOXIS NIGROMACULATUS)
49 99.00 RAINBOW DARTER (ETHEOSTOMA CAERULEUM)
49 100.00 ORANGETHROAT DARTER (ETHEOSTOMA SPECTABILE)
49 101.00 YELLOW PERCH (PERCA FLAVESCENS)
49 102.00 WALLEYE (STIZOSTEDION VITREUM VITREUM)
50 10300 FRESHWATER DRUM (APLODINOTUS GRUNNIENS)
-------
APPENDIX B-4
RESIDENT SPECIES, BY STATE
STATE
ALABAMA
CONNECTICUT
NUMBER
OF SPECIES
54
50
57"
54
54
52
51
39
61
52
2.00
10,00
35-00
45.00
67.00
78.00
9000
98.00
2.00
1000
25.00
43.00
60.00
75.00
9200
450
2.00
10.00
23.00
3400
5100
70.00
8000
9600
4.50
2.00
13.00
29.00
47.00
5700
69.00
85.00
9700
2.00
10.00
16.00
3700
4700
62.00
7500
96.00
2.00
9.00
21.00
43.00
5900
73.00
88 00
101.00
ZOO
900
21.00
41 00
60.00
7900
9100
10200
ZOO
1000
2500
5200
61.00
9700
200
10.00
2000
4700
w.oo
78.00
9300
10200
2.00
1300
2500
43,00
SPECIES IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
300
1100
18,00
4700
eaoo
7700
9100
9900
3.00
1400
32.00
45.00
6100
7800
9300
300
it 00
2400
4000
6000
7200
3300
9700
300
1400
32.00
4800
58 00
7300
8700
9600
300
1100
2000
3800
4800
64.00
76.00
9700
300
1000
24.00
45-00
60.00
74.00
89.00
102.00
3.00
10,00
2400
43.00
6700
8000
9200
440
300
1100
2600
5300
eaoo
9600
300
1100
3000
5000
0700
7900
9400
490
300
1400
3200
4400
400
1400
30.00
52.00
69.00
7800
9300
10200
4.00
15.00
36.00
47.00
85.00
80.00
96.00
4.00
14.00
2500
41 00
6400
73.00
9000
98.00
4.00
15.00
3600
5100
60.00
7500
8900
102.00
400
12.00
22.00
3900
52.00
6800
77.00
9800
4.00
11.00
25.00
47.00
61.00
76.00
92,00
430
400
11.00
25.00
45.00
68.00
8100
93.00
400
14.00
3000
6700
8400
102.00
4.00
1400
32.00
5200
68.00
8000
95.00
400
15,00
36.00
45.00
5-00
15,00
3100
53.00
7000
79.00
9400
10300
700
1600
37.00
5200
67,00
33.00
9700
500
1500
26.00
4300
6800
7600
91.00
9900
700
1600
3700
52.00
61.00
75,00
91.00
4.50
5.00
13.00
2400
4100
55.00
67,00
78.00
102.00
5.00
14.00
28.00
5200
62.00
7700
9300
5.00
1400
28.00
4700
69.00
83.00
9600
500
1500
41 00
68.00
8500
4.50
500
1500
4000
5300
6900
83.00
9600
700
16.00
3700
47.00
700
18.00
40.00
58.00
7200
80.00
95,00
450
800
16.00
36.00
55.00
68.00
84.00
98.00
7.00
16.00
27,00
45.00
6700
77.00
9300
100,00
8.00
18.00
4100
5400
6200
8000
92.00
49.00
700
1400
2500
43,00
5700
68.00
80.00
4.50
600
1500
3200
5300
6700
79,00
96.00
600
15,00
30.00
52.00
74.00
87.00
97.00
7,00
18.00
43.00
6900
8BOO
700
1800
4100
58,00
74.00
8800
9700
800
18,00
3800
48.00
8.00
18.00
41.00
64.00
73.00
83.00
9600
1100
22.00
39.00
57.00
69.00
89.00
10100
8.00
16.00
30.00
4700
6800
7800
9400
10200
11.00
22.00
43.00
5500
6700
83,00
93.00
8.00
1500
3200
4400
5800
7100
91.00
700
1600
4000
5500
6800
81.00
97.00
700
16.00
32.00
53,00
76.00
88.00
08.00
8.00
17,00
45,00
79.00
93.00
800
18,00
4300
6100
76.00
9000
9800
1100
22.00
39.00
51 00
9,00
24.00
43.00
88.00
74,00
89.00
9700
12,00
2400
4100
58.00
7300
9100
102.00
9.00
19.00
31 00
5200
6900
7900
9500
103.00
12.00
24.00
45.00
5600
6600
84,00
96,00
9.00
16,00
36,00
45,00
6000
7300
93.00
8.00
18.00
41.00
58.00
69.00
8700
9800
8.00
18.00
4000
58.00
7700
89.00
101 00
9.00
18.00
4700
80.00
85.00
900
25.00
45,00
64,00
7700
91.00
9900
1200
2400
4100
5200
STATE
IDAHO
(CONTINUED)
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
NUMBER
OF SPECIES
52
72
64
59
49
57
48
55
62
55,00
6400
9100
10200
2.00
10.00
19.00
31.00
45.00
58,00
68.00
7700
89.00
96,00
10300
2.00
1000
24.00
44.00
5600
8800
7700
9000
9700
4.50
2.00
10.00
23.00
4100
53.00
7200
80 00
9400
102.00
2.00
10.00
25.00
45.00
69.00
33.00
97.00
2.00
10.00
23.00
43.00
64.00
73.00
83.00
96.00
4.50
2.00
10.00
25.00
45.00
68.00
79.00
95.00
200
9.00
20.00
32.00
52.00
68.00
79.00
96.00
2.00
9,00
16.00
32.00
52.00
66.00
76.00
88.00
9600
SPECIES IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
5600
6700
92.00
4.50
3.00
11.00
21.00
33.00
47.00
60.00
69.00
78.00
90.00
9700
450
300
11.00
25.00
45.00
58.00
69.00
7800
9100
9800
3.00
11.00
2400
4300
6000
7300
8100
9600
103.00
3.00
1100
27.00
47.00
72.00
6900
98.00
3.00
11.00
2400
4500
66.00
74.00
89.00
97.00
3.00
11.00
2600
47.00
69.00
60.00
97.00
3.00
10.00
2200
35.00
53.00
69.00
81.00
9700
300
1000
20.00
34.00
63.00
67.00
77.00
89,00
97,00
5700
6800
93.00
73.50
4.00
14.00
23.00
34,00
50.00
62.00
70.00
79.00
91.00
9300
4.00
1400
MOO
4700
60.00
70.00
7900
9200
99.00
4.00
14.00
25.00
44.00
6300
7400
83.00
97.00
4.50
400
12,00
30.00
52.00
7300
90.00
100.00
400
14,00
25.00
4700
6700
76.00
90.00
98.00
4.00
1400
30.00
52.00
70.00
63.00
98.00
4,00
11,00
24.00
40.00
54.00
71.00
86.00
93.00
4.00
11,00
21.00
40.00
54.00
68.00
7800
9000
98,00
5600
7300
9600
5.00
15.00
24.00
40.00
52,00
63.00
72.00
80.00
92.00
99.00
500
1500
30.00
50.00
6200
7200
8000
9300
10000
500
15.00
2900
4500
6600
76.00
86.00
98.00
5.00
14.00
4000
53.00
76.00
91.00
101.00
5.00
1500
29.00
52.00
68.00
77.00
91.00
99.00
500
15.00
31.00
53.00
72.00
89.00
102.00
500
14.00
25.00
41.00
59.00
73.00
87.00
101.00
5.00
14.00
24.00
41.00
58.00
69.00
79.00
9100
10100
60.00
75.00
S7.00
7.00
16.00
25.00
41.00
5300
64.00
73.00
81.00
93.00
100.00
7,00
16.00
40.00
52.00
64.00
73.00
81.00
9400
10100
7.00
1600
3000
4800
6700
7700
9000
99.00
700
1500
41.00
6600
77.00
93.00
102.00
700
16.00
30.00
53.00
89.00
78.00
93.00
100.00
700
16.00
34.00
54.00
73.00
91.00
103.00
600
1500
28.00
43.00
60.00
74.00
8800
102.00
600
1500
25.00
43.00
60.00
72.00
81,00
92.00
102.00
61.00
78.00
96.00
8.00
17.00
29.00
43.00
54.00
6600
7400
83.00
9400
101 00
6,00
16.00
41.00
53.00
66.00
7400
86.00
9500
102,00
8.00
18.00
31.00
4700
6800
7800
9100
10000
8.00
1600
4300
67.00
78.00
94.00
103.00
8.00
18.00
4000
58.00
70.00
79.00
94.00
102.00
8.00
17.00
41.00
66.00
76.00
93.00
4.50
700
16.00
29.00
45.00
61.00
76.00
39.00
450
7.00
16.00
28.00
45.00
61.00
73.00
83.00
93.00
450
6200
83.00
101.00
9.00
1800
30.00
44.00
56.00
67.00
76.00
86,00
95.00
10200
900
2100
43.00
54.00
v67.00
7600
89.00
96.00
103.00
9.00
21.00
40.00
52.00
6900
79.00
93.00
101.00
9.00
18.00
4400
6800
8000
96.00
4.50
9.00
19.00
41 00
60.00
72.00
30.00
95.00
103.00
900
1800
43.00
6700
7800
9400
600
1600
3000
47.00
62.00
7700
92.00
3,00
17.00
30.00
47.00
6400
74.00
3700
94.00
MASSACHUSETTS
B-3
-------
APPENDIX B-4
RESIDENT SPECIES, BY STATE
NUMBER
STATE OF SPECIES
MASSACHUSETTS 81
(CONTINUED)
MICHIGAN 72
MINNESOTA 64
MISSISSIPPI 56
MISSOURI 59
MONTANA SB
NEBRASKA 53
NEVADA 45
NEW HAMPSHIRE 52
9.00
1800
3000
52.00
62.00
76.00
87.00
9700
2.00
1000
2100
31 00
4400
5600
6700
74.00
83.00
96.00
103,00
2.00
1000
2200
43.00
5200
63.00
73.00
81.00
96.00
450
2.00
1000
1900
34.00
53.00
72.00
86.00
96.00
2-00
10.00
24.00
41 00
8000
70.00
8000
94.00
102.00
2.00
10.00
1700
37.00
47.00
61.00
73,00
93.00
4.50
2.00
1000
18.00
52.00
6700
76.00
91,00
101 00
2.00
13,00
25.00
4500
61.00
84.00
450
200
8,00
18.00
4100
5900
73.00
SPECIES IDENTIFICATION HUM
10,00
20,00
32.00
53,00
6700
7700
86.00
98.00
300
11 00
22.00
32,00
4500
58.00
6600
76.00
86.00
9700
450
3.00
1100
24.00
44.00
53.00
6600
74.00
83.00
97.00
3.00
1100
2300
40.00
64.00
73.00
69.00
97.00
3,00
11.00
25.00
43.00
63.00
72.00
83.00
95.00
103,00
3.00
11.00
18.00
38.00
52.00
6200
76.00
96.00
73.50
3.00
11,00
25.00
53.00
68.00
7700
92.00
102.00
3,00
14,00
32.00
4700
67.00
85.00
73.50
3.00
9.00
2200
43.00
6000
7400
1100
2100
40,00
55.00
66.00
7800
89-00
101.00
400
14.00
23.00
33,00
47.00
60.00
69.00
7700
9000
98,00
400
14.00
25.00
45.00
5600
6700
7600
8600
9600
4.00
14.00
24.00
41,00
66.00
76.00
9000
98.00
4.00
14.00
2700
4400
8400
73,00
89.00
9600
4.50
400
12.00
22.00
3900
5400
63.00
7700
97.00
4.00
12,00
4000
58.00
69.00
78.00
93.00
103.00
4.00
15.00
36.00
5200
8600
91.00
49.00
4.00
1000
24,00
4500
6100
76.00
1400
24,00
4100
5800
6900
7900
90.00
102.00
5.00
15.00
24.00
35.00
50.00
61.00
70.00
78.00
91.00
99.00
5.00
15.00
29.00
46.00
68.00
68,00
7700
90.00
99,00
5,00
15.00
25,00
43.00
67.00
78.00
91.00
99.00
5.00
15.00
30.00
45.00
66,00
76.00
90.00
97.00
5.00
13.00
24.00
41,00
55.00
67.00
7800
98.00
5.00
13.00
41.00
60.00
71.00
79.00
9600
4.50
700
16.00
38.00
55.00
75,00
93.00
5.00
11.00
25.00
4700
62-00
77.00
15.00
25.00
43.00
5900
7100
80.00
92.00
4,50
700
16.00
2500
4000
52.00
62.00
7100
7900
92,00
100.00
700
16,00
30.00
47.00
60.00
6900
78.00
91.00
101-00
700
16.00
26.00
4500
63.00
79.00
93.00
102.00
7.00
1600
31.00
47.00
6700
77,00
91.00
98.00
7,00
1400
25.00
43,00
57.00
63.00
80.00
101.00
700
14.00
43.00
61 00
72.00
80.00
97.00
8.00
18.00
41-00
57.00
78.00
9600
600
14.00
28.00
52.00
68.00
79.00
BER5
16.00
2300
4500
60.00
73.00
81.00
9300
800
1700
29,00
4100
53,00
64,00
7200
80.00
93.00
101.00
800
18.00
40.00
5000
6100
7100
79.00
93.00
102.00
8.00
17.00
30.00
47.00
69.00
80.00
94.00
103,00
3.00
1700
34.00
52.00
68.00
78.00
92.00
99.00
8.00
15.00
32.00
44,00
58.00
69.00
91.00
102.00
8.00
15.00
45.00
83,00
73.00
86.00
98.00
. 11.00
22.00
43.00
58.00
80.00
97.00
7.00
15.00
32.00
53.00
6900
81.00
1700
29.00
47.00
61.00
74.00
86.00
96.00
9.00
1800
30.00
43,00
54.00
66.00
73.00
6100
9400
10200
9.00
21.00
4100
5100
6200
7200
80.00
94.00
103.00
9.00
18,00
3100
52.00
7000
83.00
95.00
4.50
9.00
18,00
40.00
53.00
6900
79.00
93.00
100.00
9.00
16.00
36.00
45.00
60.00
7100
92.00
103.00
9.00
16.00
47.00
66.00
74.00
6900
100.00
12.00
24.00
44.00
60.00
8300
101.00
16.00
40.00
58,00
71.00
86.00
SPECIES IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
NEW HAMPSHIRE 52
(CONTINUED)
NEW JERSEY 54
NEW MEXICO 61
NEW YORK 74
NORTH CAROLINA 53
NORTH DAKOTA 51
OHIO BB
OKLAHOMA 56
OREGON 52
PENNSYLVANIA 69
8800
98.00
2.00
9.00
20.00
41.00
60.00
76.00
88,00
97.00
2.00
10.00
18.00
3700
48.00
61.00
73.00
36.00
97.00
2.00
9,00
18.00
30,00
45.00
80.00
68.00
76.00
66.00
93.00
101.00
200
9.00
21.00
43.00
61.00
77.00
90.00
98.00
2.00
10.00
1600
45.00
68.00
77.00
91.00
103.00
2.00
10.00
21.00
40.00
50.00
63.00
72,00
80.00
93.00
100.00
2.00
10.00
22.00
31.00
52.00
70.00
83.00
96.00
2,00
13.00
24.00
44.00
55.00
64.00
92.00
4.50
2.00
9.00
20.00
89.00
101.00
3X10
10.00
2100
43.00
61.00
77.00
89.00
98.00
3.00
1100
22.00
38,00
52.00
64.00
75.00
89.00
98.00
3.00
10.00
2100
31.00
47.00
61.00
69.00
77.00
87.00
94.00
102.00
3.00
1000
24.00
45.00
86.00
78.00
91.00
101.00
3.00
11.00
22.00
47.00
69.00
78.00
93.00
4.50
300
11.00
24.00
41.00
52.00
64.00
73.00
81.00
94.00
101.00
3.00
11.00
23.00
40.00
53.00
72.00
89.00
97.00
3.00
14.00
25.00
45.00
56.00
67.00
93.00
73.50
3.00
10.00
21.00
90.00
102.00
4.00
11.00
24.00
45.00
62.00
79.00
90.00
101.00
4.00
12.00
24.00
39.00
53.00
85.00
76.00
91.00
101.00
4.00
11.00
22.00
3200
52.00
62.00
70.00
78,00
38.00
95.00
103.00
4.00
11.00
25.00
47.00
67.00
79.00
92.00
102.00
4.00
12.00
24.00
52.00
71.00
79.00
96.00
4.00
14.00
25.00
4300
53.00
66.00
74.00
83.00
95.00
102.00
4,00
1200
24.00
41.00
58.00
73.00
90.00
98.00
4.00
15.00
32.00
47.00
57.00
68.00
96.00
49.00
4,00
11.00
24.00
92.00
4.50
5.00
14.00
25,00
47.00
67.00
80.00
9100
102.00
5.00
13.00
25.00
41.00
55.00
66.00
77.00
93.00
102.00
5.00
14.00
23.00
35.00
53.00
63.00
7100
79.00
8900
96.00
4.50
5.00
14.00
30.00
52.00
68.00
81.00
93.00
4.50
5.00
13.00
25.00
58.00
72.00
80,00
97.00
500
15.00
29,00
44,00
58.00
67.00
76,00
86.00
96.00
103.00
5.00
14X10
25.00
43.00
68.00
76XXJ
91X10
100.00
7.00
16.00
36X10
48.00
58,00
75.00
97.00
5.00
14.00
25.00
93.00
6,00
15.00
30.00
52.00
68.00
61.00
92.00
4.50
7.00
14.00
29.00
43.00
57.00
67X10
78.00
94.00
450
6.00
15.00
24.00
40.00
56.00
64.00
72.00
80.00
90.00
97.00
6.00
15.00
32.00
53.00
69.00
83.00
95.00
7.00
14.00
41.00
63.00
73.00
81.00
98.00
7.00
16.00
30.00
45.00
60.00
68.00
77.00
90.00
97X10
4,50
7.00
15.00
28.00
45.00
67.00
78.00
63.00
102.00
8.00
17.00
38.00
51.00
60.00
87.00
98.00
8X10
15.00
28,00
96.00
7.00
16.00
32.00
53.00
69.00
83.00
93.00
8.00
15.00
32.00
45.00
58.00
68.00
60.00
95.00
7.00
16.00
25.00
41.00
58.00
66.00
73.00
81.00
91.00
98.00
7.00
16.00
40.00
58.00
74.00
88.00
96.00
8.00
15.00
43.00
86.00
74.00
66.00
101.00
800
17X10
31.00
46.00
61.00
69.00
78.00
91.00
98.00
8.00
16.00
27,00
46.00
63.00
79.00
94.00
103.00
11.00
16X10
41.00
52.00
61.00
89,00
101.00
7.00
16.00
30.00
9700
8.00
1600
40.00
58,00
74.00
87.00
96.00
9.00
16,00
36.00
47,00
80.00
69.00
83.00
98.00
8.00
17.00
28.00
43,00
59.00
67.00
74.00
83.00
92.00
99.00
8.00
18.00
41.00
60.00
76.00
89.00
97.00
9.00
16.00
44.00
67.00
76.00
90.00
102.00
9.00
18,00
35.00
47.00
62,00
70.00
79.00
92.00
99.00
9.00
18,00
30.00
47.00
69.00
80.00
95.00
4.50
12.00
22.00
43.00
54X10
82.00
91.00
102.00
6.00
16.00
31.00
-------
APPENDIX B-4
RESIDENT SPECIES, BY STATE
NUMBER
STATE OF SPECIES
PENNSYLVANIA
(CONTINUED)
RHODE ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
SOUTH DAKOTA
TENNESSEE
TEXAS
.jTAl
V6BVONT
,|PGISIA
WASHINGTON
os
53
50
53
58
51
52
55
56
50
3200
5000
62,00
7000
7900
90.00
9700
200
900
2100
4100
S8.00
6900
8700
9800
2.00
900
1800
4300
6600
7900
9300
450
2.00
1000
16.00
4300
6300
7300
8600
10100
2-00
10.00
2300
41.00
60.00
72 .00
8000
9500
103.00
2-00
1000
18.00
41.00
6600
WOO
9500
103.00
2.00
13.00
2400
41.00
5200
6400
8000
10100
200
900
2000
40.00
5500
68 00
7900
WOO
200
9,00
2TOO
35,00
5300
MOO
0100
9500
200
1300
2200
SPECIES IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
33.00
52.00
6300
7100
80,00
9100
9800
300
1000
2400
4300
5900
7300
6600
10100
3.00
10.00
25.00
45.00
6700
6100
9500
300
1100
2200
45.00
66.00
74.00
9000
10200
300
1100
2400
4100
6400
73.00
83.00
96.00
4.50
3.00
11.00
25.00
4300
6700
83.00
98.00
450
3-00
14.00
25.00
4300
55.00
S7.00
8900
10200
300
1000
2100
4100
5800
6900
8100
9700
300
1000
2400
4000
5800
7200
88.00
9000
3,00
1400
2400
4000
5300
64.00
73.00
81 00
9200
9900
400
11.00
25-00
4500
60.00
7400
3900
10200
4.00
11.00
2600
4700
88.00
83.00
9600
400
12.00
2400
4700
6700
76.00
91.00
10300
4.00
1400
25.00
4500
68.00
74.00
89.00
97.00
400
1200
2600
45.00
6800
84.00
9700
400
15.00
3200
44.00
5700
68.00
91 00
450
400
1100
2200
43.00
5900
7100
8600
9800
4,00
11.00
25 00
4100
60,00
7300
3900
9700
400
1500
2500
41.00
5500
8600
7400
86.00
93.00
101,00
500
14.00
2800
4700
6100
7600
92.00
450
500
14.00
3000
52.00
6900
6300
9700
5.00
1300
2500
5200
6800
7700
9300
450
500
1500
3000
4700
67.00
76.00
9000
98.00
5,00
1400
27.00
46.00
69.00
8900
93.00
700
1600
3600
45.00
58X10
7300
9300
500
1400
24.00
45.00
00.00
73,00
88.00
101,00
5.00
14,00
28,00
43.00
61.00
74,00
90,00
98,00
700
1600
3200
43.00
58.00
6700
76.00
8700
94,00
10200
600
15.00
3000
5200
6200
7700
93.00
6.00
1500
3200
5300
74.00
8900
9800
700
1400
36.00
5300
6900
78,00
96.00
700
18.00
3100
52.00
88.00
77.00
91.00
99,00
7.00
15.00
30.00
4700
7300
91.00
100.00
8.00
17.00
37.00
47.00
60.00
75.00
9600
3.00
15.00
25.00
4700
6100
7400
9000
102.00
6X10
1500
30,00
45,00
6600
76.00
9100
101 00
800
1700
3600
4500
80,00
68,00
7700
88.00
95,00
450
700
18.00
32.00
5300
6700
79.00
96.00
700
1600
4000
5800
7800
9100
10100
BOO
1500
3700
5800
71 00
8000
9700
8,00
1700
34.00
53.00
89.00
78.00
93.00
10000
800
16.00
31.00
52.00
76.00
93.00
101,00
11.00
18.00
38.00
48.00
61.00
7700
9700
700
18.00
28.00
52.00
6200
78.00
92,00
4.50
700
1800
3200
4700
6700
77,00
9200
10200
11.00
1800
3700
4700
81 00
69.00
7800
8900
9600
6.00
18,00
4000
55,00
63.00
81.00
9700
8.00
1700
4100
81.00
77,00
92.00
102.00
9.00
16.00
4100
8000
7200
8100
9800
9,00
18.00
40.00
58.00
70.00
79.00
94,00
10200
900
17.00
40.00
5300
78.00
94.00
102.00
1200
2200
3900
5100
6200
78.00
9800
800
1800
32 OC
53.00
63.00
7700
9300
8,00
13.00
34.00
5200
88.00
79,00
93.00
450
1200
20.00
39,00
STATE
WASHINGTON
(CONTINUED)
WEST VIRGINIA
WISCONSIN
WYOMING
NUMBER
OF SPECIES
50 41,00
55,00
67.00
93,00
73,50
53 2,00
10.00
24.00
-45.00
64.00
73.00
90.00
99.00
69 200
10.00
2100
3100
4500
58.00
68.00
76.00
90.00
98.00
55 200
10.00
18.00
38.00
52.00
64.00
76.00
96.00
SPECIES IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
43.00
66.00
68,00
96.00
3,00
11.00
25.00
47.00
66.00
74.00
9100
102.00
3.00
11.00
22.00
33.00
4700
60.00
6900
7700
9100
99.00
3.00
1100
22.00
3900
5500
6600
77,00
9700
44.00
57.00
75.00
9700
4.00
14.00
28.00
52.00
67.00
7600
9300
103.00
400
1400
23.00
3500
50.00
61.00
70.00
78.00
92.00
101.00
4.00
12.00
24.00
41.00
5700
6700
7300
9800
45.00
58.00
78.00
9800
500
15.00
35.00
53.00
6800
77.00
94.00
4.50
5.00
15.00
24.00
4000
5200
8200
7100
7900
9300
102.00
500
1300
25.00
- 4300
58.00
68.00
80.00
101.00
47.00
60.00
87.00
101.00
7.00
1600
4000
58.00
69.00
78.00
96.00
7.00
16.00
25.00
4100
5300
84.00
7200
8000
94.00
103.00
700
14.00
32.00
44.00
60.00
69.00
91.00
102.00
52.00
61.00
91.00
102.00
8.00
18.00
41.00
60.00
70.00
7900
97.00
8.00
17.00
29.00
43.00
54.00
66.00
73.00
81.00
96.00
4.50
3.00
15.00
38.00
45.00
61.00
73.00
9200
450
54.00
34.00
92,00
450
9.00
20.00
43,00
61.00
72.00
80.00
98.00
9.00
18.00
30.00
44.00
56,00
67.00
74.00
86.00
97.00
9.00
16.00
37.00
47.00
6200
75.00
9300
-------
APPENDIX B-5
SPECIES DISTRIBUTION IN THE UNITED STATES
SPEOES
ROTIFER (PHILODJNA ACUTICOflNISj
ROTIFER (PHILOOINA HOSEOLAl
WORM ILIMNODRILUS HOFFMEISTSR1)
SNAIL (AMNICOLA SP )
SNAIL (CAMPELOMA OECISUM)
SNAIL (GYflAULUS CIRCUMSTRIATUS)
SNAIL (LYMNAEA PALUSTHIS)
SNAIL (PHYSA HETEROSTROPHAl
SNAIL (PHYSA INTEGRA*
SNAIL (PHYSASPl
CUVDOCEflAN [OAPHNIA CAR1NATA)
CLADOCEHAN (DAPHNIA MAGNA)
CLADOCEHAN (DAPHNIA PUL£X|
CLAOOCERAN IDAPHNIA PULICARIA>
CLADOCEBAN ISIMOCEPHALUS SERRULATUSt
TOTAL NUMBER
OF STATES STATE IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
an,
48
41
14
48
48
41
48
17
14
48
48
46
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 a 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 3S 35 36 37 38 39 40
41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48
123456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 16 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 23 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
41 42 43 44 45 48 47 46
11 12 13 14 15 15 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 26 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 28 27 23 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 36 39 40
41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48
123456789 10
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 26 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
41
123456789 10
11 12 13 14
123456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
123456769 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 3B 37 38 39 40
41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48
123456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
1 234567B910
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
41
123456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48
32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41
42 43 44 45 46 47 48
32 33 3d 38 39 40 41 42 43 M
45 46 47 48
1 23456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48
123456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48
1 23456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
SPECIES
CLADOCERAN (SIMOCEPHALUS SERRULATUS)
(CONTINUED)
SEED SHRIMP (CYPRIDOPSIS VIDUA)
COPEPOD (UNIDENTIFIED)
ISOPOO (ASELLUS COMMUNIS)
SCUD (GAMMARUS FASCIATUS)
SCUD (GAMMARUS LACUSTHIS)
SCUD (GAMMAHUS PSEUDOLIMNAEUS)
SCUD (HYALLELA AZTECA)
CRAYFISH (ORCONECTES NAIS)
CRAYFISH (ORCONECTES LIMOSUS)
CRAYFISH (OHCONECTES HUSTICUS)
CRAYFISH (PROCAMBARUS ACUTUS)
GLASS SHRIMP (PALAEMONETES KADIAKENSIS)
MAYFLY (EPHEMERELLA GflANDIS)
MAYFLY (EPHEMEHELLA SUBVARIA)
MAYFLY (HEXAGENIA BILINEATA)
STONEFLY (ACRONEURIA LYCORIUS)
STONEFLY (ACHONEURIA PACIF1CA)
STONEFLY (CLAASSENNIA S ABU LOS A)
STONEFLY {PTERQNARCELLA BADIA)
STONEFLY (PTERONAHCYS CALIFORNIA)
DAMSELFLY (ISCHNURA VERTICALUS)
DAMSELFLY (ISCHNURA SP.)
T°OF STATES^ STATE IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
4B 31 32 33 34 35 36
41 42 43 44 45 46
18 4 7 11 14 19 21
16 31 24 46 37 38
48 123456
11 12 13 14 15 16
21 22 23 24 25 26
31 32 33 34 35 36
41 42 43 44 45 46
4 30 26 18 24
g 40 1 11 4 9 8
18 345678
13 21 22 23 25 28
21 1 2 3 7 22 25
38 39 40 41 42 43
48
10 7 22 25 26 28 24
ai 123456
11 12 13 17 18 19
24 25 26 27 26 29
38 39 40 41 42 43
11 12 13 14 15 16
21 22 23 24 25 26
31 32 33 34 35 36
41 42 43 44 45 46
5 30 35 29 38 37
12 10 1 11 4 7 8
2 3
25
31 20 30 10 16 15 26
31 1 11 4 22 27
8 13 21 36 8 5
25
15 7 8 21 22 25 28
31 29 30 36 37
2, 38 39 40 41 42 43
48 22 1 234
9 10 11 12 13 14
4 22 8 25 26
3 19 24 29 30 31 11
7 1 22 7 21 12 17
12 33 38 39 40 41 42
47 48
10 33 38 39 40 41 42
9 38 39 « 41 42 43
8 38 39 40 41 42 43
33 123456
11 12 13 14 15 17
22 23 24 25 26 27
35 36 37
4» 123456
21 22 23 24 25 26
31 32 33 34 35 36
41 42 43 44 45 46
37 38 39 40
47 48
26 29 22 25
43 45
7 6 9 10
17 18 19 20
27 28 29 30
37 38 39 40
47 48
3 45 17
9 10 11 12
27 28
27 32 33 38
44 45 46 47
36 30 16 19
7 8 9 10
20 21 22 23
30 32 33 36
44 45 46 47
17 18 19 20
27 28 29 30
37 38 39 40
47 48
12 17 6 5
23 28 35 18
24 29 9 7
14 19 37 12
26 19 20 24
44 45 46 47
5678
15
12 26
25
43 44 45 46
43 44 45 48
44 46 47
44 45
7 8 9 10
18 19 20 21
28 29 30 34
7 8 9 10
27 28 29 30
37 38 39 40
47 48
-------
APPENDIX B-5
SPECIES DISTRIBUTION IN THE UNITED STATES
SPECIES
MIDGE (CMiRONOMUS PLUMOSUSi
MIDGE ICHlRONOMUS TENT ANSI
MIDGE iCHlRONOMUS SP <
MlOGE iTANYTAOSUS OlSSWLISi
MIOGE ^UNIDENTIFIED)
CADDlSFLY ARC-OOSYCMEGRANDiSi
-4DCS*'> HYDROFSYCHE BETTENH
CADDiSFLY IHYDRCPSYCME CAU^ORNiCA,
CADDlSFLY (UNIDENTiBiEDi
SOCKEYE SALVON .QNCOflHYNCHUS NEflKA,
C'J~p-POAT TROUT 'SALVO CLARKl)
PAiSBCA -POJT
-------
APPENDIX B-5
SPECIES DISTRIBUTION IN THE UNITED STATES
SPECIES
THflEESPINE STICKLEBACK (GASTEROSTEUS ACULEATUS)
WHITE PERCH (MORONE AMERICANA)
STRIPED BASS IMORONE SAX ATI LI Si
STATE IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
flOCK BASS (AMBLOPUTES HUPESTRISl
GREEN SUNFISM (LEPQMIS CYANELLUS)
PUMPKINSEED ILEPOMIS GIBBOSUSI
BLUGGILL ILEPOMIS MACROCHIRUSI
LONGEAR SUNFISH ILEPOMIS MEGALOTIS)
REDEAR SUNPtSH (LEPOMIS MICROLOPHUSj
SMALLMOUTH BASS (MlCROPTERUS OOLOMIEUI)
LARGEUOUTH BASS (MICHOPTERUS SALMOIOES)
BLACK CRAPPIE (POMOXIS NIGROMACULATUS)
RAINBOW DARTER (ETHEOSTOMA CAEHULEUM)
ORANGGTHROAT DARTER lETHEOSTOMA SPECTABILE)
YELLOW PERCH (PEHCA FLAVESCENS)
WALLEYE (STIZOSTEDION VITREUM VITREUM)
FRESHWATER DRUM IAPLODINOTUS GHUNNIENS)
a 3 4 7 8 9 11 12 13 15
1? 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 32 33 35 36
7 6 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 38 37
38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47
34 38 39 42
12 13 14 15 16 17 IB 19 20 21
2! 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31
32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41
4J 43 44 45 46 47 46
i 27 28 29 30 31 35
11 12 13 14 15 17 IS 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 32
33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42
43 44 45 46 47 48
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 IB 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 3S 39 40
41 42 43 M 45 46 47 46
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 3B 39 40
41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48
123456769 10
11 12 13 14 21 22 23 25 26 27
28 32 33 34 35 37 38 39 41 42
43 44 45 46 47
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 26 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48
7 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35
36 37 38
-------
APPENDIX B-6
MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
FAMILY NUMBER
I |z|3|4 5 6 7 8|9 10 ll|l2|l3]J4 I5JI6 17 I8|l9|202l 22\23 24|25|26|27|28|29 30 31 32J33 34J35 ^37 38 39 4o|4l [42 43|44|45|46|47|48|49|5o|si
8 (Other phylum than 7)
3 (Other than 2)
8(0ther order than 6)
order im
PHYLUM DELINEATION
ORDER DELINEATION
Tne e-gnt r
n data requirements are:
1 The family Salmonidae in the class Osteichthyes.
2 One o her family in the class Osteichthyes
3- One o her family in the phylum Chordata.
4 A oianKionic crustacean (e g . concnostracean, cladoceran, or copepod).
5 A sen me crustacean le g crayfish isopod, oslracod. scud or glass shrimp).
insect le g a benmic caddlsfly. cjamselfly. dragonfly, mayfly, midge, mosquito or slonefly).
T a pnytum olher lhan Arthropoda or Chordata (e.g. Rotlfera. Annelida or Mollusca).
oroer of tnsecl or any other phylum.
B-9
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: ALDRIN
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE
NATIONAL !d
ALABAMA T
ARIZONA 10
AR",ANS*^ *>
CAU^OBN'A 9
COLORADO 8
CON"JEC~
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: ALDRIN
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME
TENNESSEE ^ SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERC CHTHYIDAE
ANGU LLIDAE
* TEXAS 7 CENTRAHCHIDAE
PERCtCHTHYIDAE
ANGU LUDAE
CYPR NIDAE
UTAH 9 SALMONIDAE
CENTRABCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PERCCHTHYIDAS
VERMONT 9 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPR NIDAE
VIRGINIA 9 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
WASHINGTON 8 CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAS
CYPR NIDAE
WEST VIRGINIA 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CYPR NIDAE
WISCONSIN 8 CENTHARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
WYOMING 8 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
COOTN(T
C2
LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + ) (•*•) ( + ) (++)
4 503 1 402 ,
7451
10000
16.000
7451 2646 *
10.000
16.000
16392
4 503 1 674 *
7451
9000
10000
4.503 1 770 *
7451
9000
11.732
4.503 1 520 *
7451
9000
16.000
7451 3242 *
9,000
10,803
11.314
4 $03 1 144 *
7451
16.000
16.392
7 451 2 644 *
10803
16.000
16392
4503 1433 *
7451
16,392
UNITS iN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: ARSENIC
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY* AVERAGE
( + ) (1-1 < + ) (++»
NATIONAL 8 GAMMAHIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
ALABAMA 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ARIZONA 6 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ARKANSAS 5 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CALIFORNIA 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
[CTALUHIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COLORADO 6 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CONNECTICUT 4 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DELAWARE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
« FLORIDA 5 DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GEORGIA 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTflAHCHIDAE
IDAHO 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ILLINOIS 6 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
INDIANA 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
IOWA 5 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
H KANSAS 4 DAPHNIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
KENTUCKY 6 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
LOUISIANA 4 DAPHNIOAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
MAINE 3 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
MARYLAND 4 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
MASSACHUSETTS 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
» NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
S — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
678,999 113.263 *
1794.245
14128.643
16487.430
1046.139 171.818 *
13339.965
16487430
1S4S4.938
1794.245 407,358 *
14126643
16487.430
19484.938
878.999 42.377 *
1046.139
16487430
19484.938
1794.245 363.446 *
14126.643
16487.430
19484.938
1794.245 407265 *
13339,965
16487.430
19434 936
1046139 141 620 *
14128.643
19484.938
20194.383
1046.139 171.818 *
13339,965
16487.430
19484.938
1046 139 156.035 *
16487 430
26041.875
1046.139 171.493 *
14126.643
16487.430
19484.938
1794.245 350.957 *
14128.643
19484.938
20194363
878.999 58,104 *
1048,139
13339.965
16487.430
1046.139 171.818 *
13339.965
16487.430
19484.938
878.999 42.377 *
1046139
18487430
19484.938
1048.139 140493 *
16487430
19484938
20194.383
878.999 58.104 *
1046.130
3339.965
6487.430
1048 139 140.493 *
6487.430
9484938
20194.383
1046.139 113.263 *
4963.949 +*
5659.936
0000
1046.139 141.620 *
4128.643
9464.938
W194383
1046.139 171 493 *
4128.643
6487.430
9484.938
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOB FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: ARSENIC
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
ViCHlGAN 6
MINNESOTA 5
i MiSS'SSiPPi 5
MISSOURI 4
MONTANA 6
NEBRASKA 5
NEVADA 5
NEW HAMPSHIRE t
NEW JERSEY 5
NEW MEXICO 6
NEW YORK 6
NORTH CAPOUNA 4
NORTH DAKOTA 5
OHIO 5
OKLAHOMA 6
0=£30N 4
PENNSYLVANIA 5
RHODE ISLAND 4
SOUTHCAflCL-.fi 4
SOUTH DAKOTA 5
TOXICANT: ARSENIC
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME ICSOVALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRABCHIOAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMAfllDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUfllDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUfllDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIOAE
CYPfllNIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUHIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
tv,GTNO
878 999 56980 . TENNESSEE 6 GAMMAR10AE
1046 139 DAPHNIDAE
14128843 SALMONIDAE
16487 430 ICTALUHIDAE
1046139 171493 • » TEXAS 4 DAPHNIDAE
14128643 ICTALURIDAE
16487 430 CENTRAHCHIDAE
19484938 CYPfllNIDAE
878999 42377 * UTAH 6 DAPHNIDAE
1046.139 SALMONIDAE
16487430 ICTALURIDAE
19484.938 CENTRARCHIOAE
1046139 140493 * VERMONT 4 DAPHNIDAE
16487430 SALMONIOAE
19484.938 CYPfllNIDAE
20194 383 CENTRARCHIDAE
1794 245 407 358 * VIRGINIA 4 DAPHNIDAE
14128643 SALMONIDAE
16487 430 CENTRARCHIDAE
19484938 CYPRINIDAE
1794 245 363 446 * WASHINGTON 5 DAPHNJDAE
14128643 SALMONIDAE
16487,430 CENTHARCHIDAE
19484 936 PTERONARCIDAE
1794245 363446 * WEST VIRGINIA 5 DAPHNIDAE
14128.643 SALMONIDAE
16487 430 ICTALURIDAE
19484 938 CENTRARCHIDAE
1046 139 148092 * WISCONSIN 6 GAMMARIDAE
14128843 DAPHNIDAE
15659.936 SALMONIDAE
19484 938 ICTALURIDAE
1046 139 171 493 * WYOMING 6 DAPHNIDAE
14128.643 SALMONIDAE
16487 430 ICTALURIDAE
19464 938 CENTRARCHIDAE
1794245 407358 *
14128.643
16487430
19484938
878999 56.980 *
1046 139
14128.643
16487430
1046139 132.343 *
14128.643
19484.938
26041.875
1794.245 363,601 *
13339.965
16487,430
19484.938
1046.139 171 493 *
14128.643
16487430
19484.938
878.999 58104 *
1048139
13339.965
16487430
1794245 266699 *
14128643
19484936
26041875
1046.139 171 493 *
14128643
16467430
19484938
1046,139 141 620 *
14128,643
19484938
20194 383
1046139 132343 *
14126643
19484938
26041.675
1794245 363601 *
13339.965
16487430
19484938
UNITS IN MiC POOH AMU P£« LITER • - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
ACR COMMUTED Fjr ACUtt IQ CHRONIC flATIO METHOD I - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
876.999 58.104 *
1046.139
13339.965
16487.430
1046139 140.493 *
18487430
19484,938
20194.383
1794.245 407.358 *
14128.643
16467.430
19484.938
1046.139 148.092 *
14126.643
15659.936
19464.938
1046.139 141.620 *
14126.643
19484,938
£01 94.383
1794545 343.846 *
14128.643
19484938
22039.902
1046139 171 493 *
4128643
16487430
19484.936
878999 56.980 *
1048139
14128643
16487430
1794.245 407358 *
14128.643
6487.430
9484.938
C-3
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: CADMIUM
NATIONAL 16 SALMONIDAE
DAPMNIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
PMYSIDAE
ALABAMA 14 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ARIZONA 13 SALMONIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ARKANSAS 12 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CALIFORNIA 14 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
OAPHNIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
COLORADO 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CONNECTICUT 16 SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPfllNODONTIDAE
DELAWARE 17 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
« FLORIDA 13 PEHCICHTHYIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
GEORGIA na SALMONIDAE
P6RCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
IDAHO 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
ILLINOIS 15 SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
INDIANA 14 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMAftlDAE
IOWA 13 DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIOAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PHYSIDAE
* KANSAS 12 PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
KENTUCKY 14 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
LOUISIANA 12 PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
MAINE 16 SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
MARYLAND 17 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
MASSACHUSETTS 16 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
FOOTNO
C-4
LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
< + ) (I) { + ) IS) l + ) !•*••*•) IS)
0.048 0.027 0.0004 ACR
0496
1 147
2860
0044 0013 00002 ACfl
0163
0864
1 147
0034 0010 00001 ACR
0)63
0496
1 147
0,864 0211 * 00034 ACR
1 147
2.360
6987
0.048 0.015 00002 ACR
0.163
0496
1 147
0.044 0.012 00002 ACR
0496
1.147
2860
0.034 0.019 0X03 ACR
0,864
1 147
1 630
0.044 0,027 0.0004 ACR
0.884
1 147
1630
0 163 0046 * 00007 ACR
0.864
2.660
6987
0034 0008 . 00001 ACR
0163
0864
2.860
0048 0013 0.0002 ACR
0.496
1 147
2.860
0.064 0.020 0 0003 ACR
0,864
1 147
0.084 0,019 0.0003 ACR
0.163
0.664
1 147
0,864 0317 * 00051 ACR
1 147
1.630
2860
0 163 0.041 • 00006 ACR
0.864
2.860
6.987
0044 0013 00002 ACR
0 163
0864
1 147
0163 0.041 * 0.0006 ACR
0864
2,660
6937
0026 0015 00002 ACR
0364
1 147
1 630
0 034 0 021 0.0003 ACR
0.864
1 147
1630
0034 0019 00003 ACR
0.864
1 147
1630
E
UNITS IN MICROGHAMS PER LITER
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: CADMIUM
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
m (it [+) (J) (•*•) (-*•+) (*)
MICHIGAN 15 SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPfllNODONTIDAE
MINNESOTA 14 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
* MISSISSIPPI 13 PEHCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
MISSOURI 13 PERCICHTHYIOA6
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
PHYSIDAE
MONTANA 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
NEBRASKA 12 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIOAE
NEVADA 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
NEW HAMPSHIRE 15 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
NEW JERSEY 17 SALMONIOAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
NEW MEXICO 15 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
NEW YORK 17 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
NORTH CAROLINA 16 SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
NORTH DAKOTA 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
OHIO 14 SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
OKLAHOMA 14 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMAHIDAE
OREGON 13 SALMONIDAE
PEHCICHTHYID'AE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PENNSYLVANIA 16 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
RHODE ISLAND 16 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SOUTH CAROLINA 15 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SOUTH DAKOTA 13 SALMONJDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
»* _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
tf - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
0.048 0.023 0.0003 ACR
0.664
1 630
0.048 0,021 0.0003 ACR
0.864
1.147
1630
0.163 0,059 0.0009 ACR
0664
1 147
2.860
0.163 0059 * 0,0009 ACR
0.664
1 147
2.860
0.034 0.009 0.0001 ACR
0496
1 147
2.660
0.034 0.006 * 0.0001 ACR
0 163
0496
2.B60
0.034 0.009 0,0001 ACR
0496
1.147
2.660
0.034 0.017 0.0002 ACR
0.864
1.147
1 630
0034 0021 0,0003 ACR
0.864
1.147
1 630
0.034 0.012 0.0002 ACR
0.163
0.496
1.147
0.048 0.029 0,0004 ACR
0.664
1 147
1.630
0.034 0.019 0.0003 ACR
l'l47
1.630
0.044 0.014 0.0002 ACH
0.496
1.147
1.630
0,034 0.015 0.0002 ACR
0.884
1.147
1 630
0.044 0.013 00002 ACR
0.163
0.864
1.147
0.048 0.014 0.0002 ACR
0.163
0.496
1.147
0.034 0.019 00003 ACR
0.664
1.147
1.630
0.034 0.019 0.0003 ACR
0.864
1 147
1 630
0.034 0.016 * 0 0002 ACR
0.664
1.630
2.860
0.044 0016 00002 ACR
0.496
1 147
1630
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT; CADMIUM
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
TENNESSEE '4 SALMONIDAE
PERC1CHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
. TEXAS 12 PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODIN10AE
LTAH 12 SALMONIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
vgawONT 15 SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIOAE
GAMMARlDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
VIRGINIA 15 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
WASHINGTON 12 SALMONIOAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
PHYSIDAE
WEST VIRGINIA 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
PHYSIDAE
WISCONSIN 13 SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
WYOMING 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
PHYSIDAE
COOTHOT
<•*•)
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: CHLORDANE
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN 5
MINNESOTA 4
* MISSISSIPPI 3
MISSOURI 3
MONTANA 6
NEBRASKA 4
NEVADA 6
NEW HAMPSHIRE 4
NEW JERSEY 4
NEW MEXICO 6
NEW YORK 5
NORTH CAROLINA 4
NORTH DAKOTA 5
OHIO 5
OKLAHOMA 5
OREGON 5
PENNSYLVANIA 5
RHODE ISLAND 4
SOUTH CAROLINA 3
SOUTH DAKOTA 5
-6
NAME
PALAEMONIOAE
CYPR NIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMAfllDAE
SALMONIDAE
CVPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPR NIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPR NIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPR NIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPB NIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
- UNITS
~ Tl
FCV
scv
TOXICANT: CHLORDANE
LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LOW VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
i+) (*) (+) (++) (-M (+j (+) (++i
8325 1 511 * OCXW3 FRV TENNESSEE 4 PALAEMONIDAE
23238 CYPHINIDAE
32.249 SALMONIDAE
43 739 CENTRARCHIDAE
23 238 7 51 1 * 0 0043 FRV * TEXAS 4 PALAEMONIDAE
32,249 CYPH1NIDAE
40 281 CENTRARCHIDAE
54.711 POECILIIDAE
6.325 1 974 * 0 0043 FHV UTAH 6 PTERONAflCIDAE
23238 ** CYPHINIDAE
54711 GAMMARIDAE
0,000 SALMONIDAE
6.325 1 974 * 00043 FRV VERMONT 4 CYPRINIDAE
23 238 ** GAMMARIDAE
54.711 SALMONIDAE
0.000 CENTRARCHIDAE
15.000 5061 * 00043 FRV VIRGINIA 4 CYPHINIDAE
23238 SALMONIDAE
26.000 GAMMAHIOAE
40 044 CENTRARCHIDAE
23.238 7 016 * 0.0043 FRV WASHINGTON 6 PTERONAflCIDAE
33.662 CYPRINIDAE
58.267 SALMONIDAE
15.684 4 693 * 0 0043 FRV WEST VIRGINIA 3 CYPfllNIDAE
26.000 SALMONIDAE
33882 CENTRARCHIDAE
54,711
12.371 3.113 * 00043 FRV WISCONSIN 5 PALAEMONIDAE
26.000 CYPRINIOAE
33862 GAMMARIDAE
54.711 SALMONIDAE
15.684 4569 * 00043 FHV WYOMING 6 PTERONAHCIDAE
33.862 CYPRINIDAE
40.000 GAMMARIDAE
54.711 SALMONIDAE
15,000 5536 * 00043 FRV
23.236
26000
33.662
6325 1.559 * 00043 FflV
23238
32.249
40.261
15 684 4,569 * 0.0043 FRV
33,662
40,000
54711
23.238 6084 * 0.0043 FHV
25.461
26,000
54.711
6.325 1.550 * 0.0043 FHV
23236
33.862
40.000
6.325 1.825 * 0.0043 FRV
23.238
25.481
26000
15664 4357 * 00043 FRV
26.000
43,739
6325 1,550 * 0.0043 FRV
23.238
33662
40,000
23238 7675 * 0,0043 FRV
33.862
40.000
54711
15684 1 974 * 00043 FRV
33.662 * *
54.711
0000
23.238 60S4 * 0.0043 FflV
2546)
26.000
54.711
IN MICHOGRAMS PER LITER * — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
FINAL RESIDUE VALUE » — NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
6.325 1.232 * 0.0043 FRV
23.238
25.481
54.711
6325 0.558 * 0.0043 FRV
23,236
54.711
190.000
15.000 5.586 * 0.0043 FRV
23.236
26000
33862
12.371 3.272 * 0.0043 FHV
32.249
33.862
54711
23.238 7.875 * 0.0043 FRV
33.862
40.000
54.711
15.000 3.775 * 0.0043 FRV
15.684
43.739
23.238 1.974 * 0.0043 FRV
33.862 +*
54.711
0,000
6,325 1.511 * 0.0043 FRV
23.236
32.249
43.739
15.000 5.588 * 0.0043 FRV
23.238
26000
33862
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: CHROMIUM
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 10
ALABAMA 6
ARIZONA 7
ARKANSAS 5
CALIFORNIA 7
COLORADO 6
CONNECTICUT 6
DELAWARE 6
i FLORIDA 6
GEORGIA 6
IDAHO 5
ILLINOIS T
INDIANA 6
IOWA 6
• KANSAS 5
KENTUCKY 7
LOUISIANA 5
MAINE 5
MARYLAND 6
MASSACHUSETTS 6
NAME
GAMMAfllDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PH1LOD1NIOAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
CYPRINIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
CYPHINIOAE
PHILOOINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPHINIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
POEC1LIIDAE
PEHC1CHTHYIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPH1NIDAE
SALMONIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHILOD NlDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHILOD NlDAE
PHYSIDAE
PEHCiCHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PEROCHTHYIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
PHILOOINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PERCiCHTHYIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
FOOTN
LC 50 VALUE
67000
6399976
6998790
24692 828
6998790
24692 826
30454 750
57461 672
6399976
6998790
29999867
30454750
67.000
6998.790
24892.826
57481 672
6399976
6999790
29999867
30454750
6399978
6998790
24692 828
57461 672
6998790
24892 828
30454750
57481 672
6998790
24892 828
30454 750
68999781
6998790
24892 828
29999667
30454750
6998.790
24892.828
30454,750
63804.148
6399.976
8998.790
57461,672
63804148
67,000
6998790
24892.828
30454750
6998790
24392828
30454 750
57461 672
67000
6998790
24692 828
57461 672
6998790
24892 828
30454750
57461 672
67000
6998,790
24892 828
30454,750
6998.790
24892.828
30454.750
57461,672
6998.790
24892.828
30454.750
40637609
8998.790
24892 828
30454750
57461 672
6998790
30454750
57461 672
MAXIMUM . 34-DAY AVERAGE
1+1 ( + > ( + + »
12 164 03378 ACR
1692459 * 10.0 FPV
1140647 * 100 FPV
2.505 * 00695 ACR
1140847 * 10.0 FPV
781 038 * 10.0 FPV
1692.459 * 100 FPV
1536742 * 100 FPV
2124123 • 100 FPV
1604.673 • 10.0 FPV
540.695 * 10.0 FPV
5.387 * 0.1496 ACR
1692459 * 10.0 FPV
3,407 + 00946 ACR
1546824 * 10.0 FPV
5367 * 0.1496 ACR
1546.624 * 10.0 FPV
1811.166 * 10.0 FPV
1692459 * 10.0 FPV
1892459 * 10,0 FPV
OTE
- UNITS IN MiCROORAMS PER LITER
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: CHROMIUM
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
MICHIGAN 6 GAMMAfllDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
MINNESOTA 8 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
M MISSISSIPPI 6 GAMMARIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
MISSOURI 5 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
MONTANA 6 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NEBRASKA 7 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
NEVADA 6 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
SALMONIDAE
NEW HAMPSHIRE 6 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NEW JERSEY 6 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
NEW MEXICO 7 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
NEW YORK 7 GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
NORTH CAROLINA 6 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONiOAE
NORTH DAKOTA 6 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OHIO 6 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
OKLAHOMA 8 GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
OREGON 6 DAPHNIDAE
PHILOOINIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PENNSYLVANIA 8 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
RHODE ISLAND 6 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SOUTH CAROLINA 6 PHILODINIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIOAE
SOUTH DAKOTA 6 DAPHNIDAE
PHILOOINIOAE
CYPHINIDAE
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
APPLY EQUATION 3 ! TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM ANDJOR
30'OAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
(+) 1+) (+) (++)
67000 3,407 * 0,0948 ACH
6998790
24892 828
57461.672
6998790 1531.490 * 10.0 FPV
24892 826
57461 672
59899.703
67.000 4.108 * 0 1141 ACR
6998.790
24892.828
30454.750
6998790 1546.824 * 10.0 FPV
24892 828
30454.750
57481.672
6399.976 781 038 * 10.0 FPV
6998790
24892.828
57481.672
6399 976 1208 644 * 10 0 FPV
6998790
24892828
30454.750
6399.976 719.954 * 10.0 FPV
6998.790
29999.367
63804.148
6998.790 1960.335 * 10.0 FPV
24892.826
30454.750
40637609
6998.790 1604.673 * 10.0 FPV
24892.826
30454750
33804.148
6399.978 1208-644 * 10.0 FPV
6998.790
24892.828
30454.750
67.000 5.387 * 0. 1 496 ACR
6998.790
24892.823
30454.750
6998.790 1604.673 * 10.0 FPV
24892.628
30454,750
63804 143
6399 976 761.038 * 10.0 FPV
6998790
24892.823
57461,672
6996.790 1531.490 * 100 FPV
24892.828
57461 672
59899.703
67 000 6.949 * 0 1930 ACR
24892.828
30454750
6399 976 718.704 * 10.0 FPV
6998.790
30454750
63804.148
6996 790 1692.459 * 10.0 FPV
24892.828
30454750
57461 672
6996 790 1692.459 * 10,0 FPV
24692.828
30454.750
57461.672
6998.790 1604,673 * 10.0 FPV
30454750
63604.148
8399976 781.038 * 10,0 FPV
6998.790
)7461 672
C-7
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: CHROMIUM
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIV
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME
TENNESSEE 7 GAMMARIDAE
PH LODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
* TEXAS 7 PH LODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
UTAH 6 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
VERMONT 5 PHILODtNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
VIRGINIA 6 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
WASHINGTON 5 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
WEST VIRGINIA 5 PH LODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
WISCONSIN 6 GAMMAR1DAE
PH ODINIDAE
PH SIDAE
CY RINIOAE
WYOMING 6 DA HNIDAE
PH OOINIDAE
PH SIDAE
CYPHINIOAE
E RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (+) <+) (++)
67 000 5 387 * 0 1496 ACR
6998 790
24892 828
30454 750
6998 790 2271 128 * 100 FPV
24892 823
29999.867
30454 750
6399 976 764 448 * 100 FPV
6998790
30454 750
57461 672
8998.790 1448 932 * 100 FPV
24892.626
40637,609
63804 148
6996.790 1692459 * 10.0 FPV
24892 828
30454 750
57461 672
6399.976 465 609 * 100 FPV
6998.790
63804148
81251,078
6998.790 1352.297 * 100 FPV
24892.828
57461.672
63804148
67000 3.407 * 00946 ACR
6998,790
24892.828
57461 672
6399976 781038 * 10,0 FPV
6998.790
24892 828
57461 672
- UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
C.8
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC HATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: COPPER
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 23
ALABAMA 17
ARIZONA 13
ARKANSAS 15
CALIFORNIA 13
COLORADO 13
CONNECTICUT 18
DELAWARE 18
* FLORIDA 16
GEORGIA 16
IDAHO 11
ILLINOIS 19
INDIANA 19
IOWA 17
» KANSAS 14
KENTUCKY 18
LOUISIANA 15
MAINE 20
MARYLAND 18
MASSACHUSETTS 19
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIHONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
PLANORB1DAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
PLANOHBIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
» - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
» — NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 37 TO DETERMINE MAXIM
30-OAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
UM AND'OR
0.305 0194 5.46618
0.759
0.995
1.345
0,256 0.137 9:42403
0759
0.995
1022
0.305 0.128 3.77458
0759
1.345
1.424
0.256 0.121 * 4.79332
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.305 0.128 2.74195
0.759
1345
1.401
0.305 0.133 985862
0.759
0.995
1.309
0256 0.139 7.43115
0.759
0.995
1.345
0,256 0142 8.30804
0.759
0.995
1.022
0.256 0.127 * 6.30441
0759
0.995
1345
0.250 0.127 * 9,39244
0759
0995
1.345
0.305 0.115 3.11336
0.759
1.345
1,424
0.256 0.143 4.95343
0.759
0.996
1.049
0.256 0148 9.42403
0759
0.995
1 049
0,256 0.133 * 4,95843
0.750
0,995
1.345
0253 0.116 * 9.26331
0,759
0.999
1,345
0.256 0.142 4.79332
0.759
0,995
1022
0.256 0.123 * 9.09372
0.759
0.995
1 236
0.256 0.151 7.22020
0.759
0995
1.345
0,256 0.139 8 38350
0759
0.995
1.345
0256 0145 8,47114
0.759
0.995
1.345
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: COPPER
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN 19
MINNESOTA is
• MISSISSIPPI 16
MISSOURI 16
MONTANA 13
NEBRASKA 16
SEXACA 12
NEW HAMPSHIRE 18
NEW JERSEY 18
NEW MEXICO 6
NEA TGQ* 'fj
SQ°TM CAROLINA ifi
t*QB~n DAKOTA 15
OHIO 19
OKLAHOMA 17
OREGON 12
PENNSYLVANIA 19
RHODE ISLAND '6
SOUTH CAROLINA 17
SOUTH DAKOTA 15
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIF CIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIOAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIF CIDAE
PLANORBIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIF CIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIOAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
OAPHN DAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIF CIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIOAE
TUBIF CIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIOAE
TUBIFICIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIOAE
TUSIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
FOOTNOTE
- UNIT
- . - FPv
ACR
FCV
SCV
LC50 VALUE
( + ) (1)
02S6
0759
0995
1 339
0,256
0759
0.995
1 345
0256
0.759
0995
1345
0256
0759
0995
1345
0305
0.759
0995
1345
0305
0759
0995
1345
0.305
0.759
1345
1.424
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256
0759
0995
1.345
0305
0759
0995
1345
0.256
0.759
0.995
1345
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.305
0759
0.995
1.022
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.345
0256
0759
0.995
1022
0.305
0.759
1345
1401
0.256
0.759
0.995
1345
0.256
0.759
0.995
1345
0.256
0759
0,995
1,345
0,305
0799
0995
1022
FINAL PLANT v
TOXICANT: COPPER
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME L
0.145 4 79332 FCV TENNESSEE 17 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
0 139 9 57750 FCV » TEXAS 15 DAPHNIDAE
CHIflONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
0 127 4 45175 FCV UTAH 12 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
PLANORBIDAE
0127 * 957750 FCV VERMONT IB DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
0 132 001505 FCV VIRGINIA 19 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
0150 * 992408 FCV WASHINGTON 11 OAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
0 121 9.07713 FCV WEST VIRGINIA 17 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
0 139 7.431 15 FCV WISCONSIN 19 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIOAE
0 139 B 30604 FCV WYOMING 13 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIOAE
0.150 985862 FCV
0.151 532754 FCV
0139 762932 FCV
0.150 992406 FCV
0 145 9.57750 FCV
0 137 4.82475 FCV
0 122 0.01447 FCV
0.145 8.62836 FCV
0.139 7.43115 FCV
0.133 * 8.24143 FCV
0.150 9.9240B FCV
SENSITIVE 3PECIES CHRONIC VALUE 3Q.DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
,50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
0256 0,137 479332 FCV
0759
0995
1 022
0256 0,121 * 8.56591 FCV
0.759
0995
1 345
0^305 0121 2.89135 FCV
0.759
1.345
1 424
0256 0,139 763485 FCV
0.759
0995
1 345
0.256 0145 8.38350 FCV
0759
0.995
1.345
0.305 0.116 9.64928 FCV
0,759
1.345
1 401
0.256 0133 9.42403 FCV
0759
0.995
1345
0256 0145 4.79332 FCV
0.759
0.995
1.339
0 305 0.132 9.85862 FCV
0759
0995
1345
C-9
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
OXICANT: CYANIDE
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 10
ALABAMA 6
ARIZONA 6
ARKANSAS 6
CALIFORNIA S
COLORADO 6
CONNECTICUT 6
DELAWARE 7
FLORIDA 5
GEORGIA 6
IDAHO 6
ILLINOIS 8
INDIANA 6
IOWA 8
KANSAS 6
KENTUCKY 7
LOUISIANA 5
MAINE 7
MARYLAND 8
MASSACHUSETTS 7
10
NAME
SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PERCIOAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPR NIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PERC DAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMAHIOAE
DAPHN DAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIOAE
DAPHN DAE
CENTflARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PEHCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CENTHAflCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PEHCIOAE
- UNITS
. * - FPV
ACR
FCV
SCV
( + )
76.707
83.000
114316
125121
57.000
83,000
114.316
207.956
76.707
83.000
114.316
125 121
63000
114.316
167.000
207958
76707
83000
114316
207.958
57.000
63.000
114.316
207958
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
57.000
83000
114.316
125.121
83,000
114316
306.484
317.999
76.707
63,000
114.316
317.99S
76707
83.000
114.316
125121
57.000
83000
114316
125121
57.000
83.000
114.316
125.121
83,000
114316
125 121
167.000
83.000
114.316
125 121
207956
57.000
83.000
114316
167000
33.000
114.316
207.958
431.499
83.000
102.000
103.227
125121
76707
83000
114.316
125.121
76707
33.000
125121
( + ) ( + ) (•<"«•)
31.429 « 42472 ACfl
15.459 * 20890 ACR
26.920 * 3 9081 ACR
27587 * 3.7279 ACH
19.582 * 2.6462 ACR
15.450 * 20890 ACR
28920 * 3.9081 ACR
21 460 * 2 8999 ACH
18.067 * 2.4414 ACR
14.657 * 1.9806 ACR
26.920 * 3.9081 ACH
22.152 * 29935 ACH
20.746 * 28035 ACR
33.249 * 4.4930 ACR
27 174 * 3.6722 ACfl
18631 * 2.5176 ACR
16127 * 2.1792 ACR
35949 * 4.8579 ACH
30.219 * 4.0836 ACR
29.583 * 39977 ACH
IN MICHOGHAMS PER LITER
FINAL PLANT VALUE
COMPUTED 8
FINAL CHRO
Y ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
1C VALUE
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: CYANIDE
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN 6
MINNESOTA 8
H MISSISSIPPI 6
MISSOURI 5
MONTANA 6
NEBRASKA 6
NEVADA 6
NEW HAMPSHIRE 6
NEW JERSEY 8
NEW MEXICO 7
NEW YOHK 8
NORTH CAROLINA 7
NORTH DAKOTA 6
OHIO 8
OKLAHOMA 8
OREGON 5
PENNSYLVANIA 7
RHODE ISLAND 6
SOUTH CAROLINA 7
SOUTH DAKOTA 6
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARGHIDAE
PEHCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTflARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PEHCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PEHCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRAflCHIDAE
PEHCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
** _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
# — NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
3 - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIM
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
UM AND/OR
76.707 30 S19 *
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707 30.219 *
83.000
114.316
125.121
83.000 27.567 *
114.316
167.000
207.956
83.000 16.127 *
114.316
207.953
431.499
76.707 28.920 *
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707 28.920 *
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707 28.459 *
83.000
121.020
125.121
76.707 28.920 *
63.000
114.318
125.121
76.707 30.219 *
63.000
114.316
125.121
76.707 29.583 *
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707 30.219 *
63.000
114.316
125.121
76.707 29.583 *
83.000
114.316
125.12
57.000 20.746 *
83.000
114.316
125.121
78.707 30.219 *
63.000
114.318
125,121
57.000 19.407 *
83.000
114.316
167.000
76.707 28.225 *
33.000
114.316
125121
78.707 29.583 *
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707 28.920 *
83.000
114.316
125,121
78,707 29.583 *
33.000
114.316
125.121
57.000 20.746 *
83.000
114.316
125.121
30.0AY
4.0838
4.0836
3.7279
2.1792
3.9081
3.9081
3.8458
3.9061
4,0836
3.9977
4.0836
3.9977
2.8035
4.0836
2.6225
3.8141
3.9977
3.9081
3,9977
2,8035
AVERAGE
ACR
ACR
ACH
ACR
ACH
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACH
ACH
ACR
ACR
ACfl
ACR
ACR
ACfl
ACH
ACH
ACR
ACR
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
OXICANT: CYANIDE
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
TENNESSEE
TEXAS 7
UTAH 5
VERMONT 7
VIRGINIA 6
WASHINGTON 6
WEST VIRGINIA 6
WISCONSIN 7
WYOMING 6
NAME
SALMON 1 DAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERC1OAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIOAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMON 1 DAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPRIN1DAE
SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PERCIOAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PEHClDAE
fOC-fuoTe
FRV
f>CV
LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
1+) 1+) (+) I + + )
57.000 16,831 * 25178 ACR
93.000
114316
167.000
93.000 28 174 * 3,8072 ACR
1U-316
125,121
207-958
76707 28.225 * 3.8141 ACR
83000
114316
125121
76,707 29583 * 3.9977 ACR
63.000
114.316
125121
76707 28920 * 3.9081 ACR
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707 26.920 * 3 0061 ACR
B3.000
114316
125 121
78.707 20508 * 2.7713 ACR
83000
114.316
207958
76707 29.583 * 39977 ACR
83.000
114318
125,121
76.707 28920 * 3.9081 ACR
83.000
114,318
125121
iN MPCROOPAMSPER LITER
FINAL PLANT VALUE
PINAL RESIDUE VALUE
FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: DDT
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 20
ALA6AMA 8
ARIZONA 11
ARKANSAS 9
CALIFORNIA 10
COLORADO 10
CONNECTICUT 7
DELAWARE 9
* FLORIDA 7
GEORGIA 7
IDAHO 11
ILLINOIS 14
INDIANA 10
IOWA 12
» KANSAS 7
KENTUCKY 8
LOUISIANA 9
MAINE 9
MARYLAND 10
MASSACHUSETTS 1 1
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (+) (+1 (++1
DAPHNIDAE
PEHClDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
ASELLIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTHAflCHIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ESOCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ESOCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ASTACIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
ASELL10AE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIOAE
DAPHNIOAE
PERCIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
1 - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
1-323 0.650
1 595
1 700
2,234
0,976 0.344 *
3000
3,234
4 102
1323 0,479 *
1 59S
3000
3282
0976 0.355 *
2.409
3.234
4.000
1.323 0.442 *
3.000
3.282
6.921
1.323 0.510 *
3.000
3.096
4.878
0.976 041 8 *
1595
1.664
3006
0 S76 0.344 *
1.S95
1.664
3.000
0.976 0.150 *
3.000
3.263
17068
0976 0.246 *
3.000
4102
8151
1.323 0.479 *
1.595
3.000
3.282
0.976 0.460 *
1.595
1.664
1,700
0.876 0.357 *
1-595
1.664
3.000
0-978 0.462 *
1.S95
1.664
1.700
0.976 0.283 *
1.S95
2.409
3.904
0.976 0.338 *
3.000
4.000
4.102
0.976 0.364 *
3.000
3.234
4.102
0.976 0.354 *
1.S95
2,356
3000
0 976 0 357 *
1 595
1664
3000
0976 0370 *
1.595
1 664
3.000
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0,0010
0.0010
0,0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
00010
0.0010
00010
0.0010
0.0010
0,0010
0.0010
0.0010
FRV
FRV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
C-11
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: DDT
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN 13
MINNESOTA t2
* MISSISSIPPI 10
MISSOURI 10
MONTANA 13
NEBRASKA 9
NEVADA 11
NEW HAMPSHIRE 8
NEW JERSEY 9
NEW MEXICO 12
NEW YORK 14
NORTH CAROLINA 9
NORTH DAKOTA 10
OHIO 13
OKLAHOMA 9
OREGON 11
PENNSYLVANIA 12
RHODE ISLAND 6
SOUTH CAROLINA 8
SOUTH DAKOTA 11
C-12
NAME
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
ASELLfDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ESOCIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIOAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARiDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PEHCIDAE
PTERONARC1DAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOC DAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ESOCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHN DAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ESOCIDAE
DAPHN DAE
PEHCIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
ASTAC DAE
OAPHNIOAE
PERCIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
TOXICANT: DDT
LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
0,976 0410 « 0.0010 FHV TENNESSEE 9 DAPHNIDAE
1 595 ASTACIDAE
2 234 PALAEMONIDAE
3,000 CENTRARCHIDAE
0.976 0.434 * 0 0010 FRV » TEXAS 10 DAPHNIOAE
1 595 PERCIOAE
1 700 ASTACIDAE
2234 PALAEMONIDAE
3 000 PERCIDAE
3,234 GAMMAHIDAE
4000 CENTRARCHIDAE
0.976 0,366 * 00010 FRV VERMONT 9 DAPHNIDAE
1.700 PERCIDAE
2 409 ESOCIDAE
3.234 GAMMARIDAE
1.323 0.510 * 0.0010 FRV VIRGINIA 8 DAPHNIDAE
1.595 PERCIDAE
1 700 GAMMARIDAE
3,000 ASTACIDAE
1.323 0,432 * 0.0010 FHV WASHINGTON 11 DAPHNIDAE
1 595 PERCIDAE
1 700 GAMMARIDAE
3,282 CENTHARCHIDAE
1.323 0 501 * 0.0010 FHV WEST VIRGINIA 6 DAPHNIDAE
1 595 CENTRARCHIDAE
1.900 SALMON1DAE
3.000 SCIAENIDAE
0978 0323 * 0.0010 FHV WISCONSIN 12 DAPHNIDAE
1 595 PERCIDAE
3.000 GAMMARIDAE
3 006 ASTACIOAE
0.976 0.344 * 0.0010 FflV WYOMING 10 DAPHNIDAE
1 595 PERCIDAE
1 664 GAMMARIDAE
3.000 CENTRAflCHIDAE
1.323 0.459 * 00010 FRV
1 595
3,000
4102
0.976 0.456 * 0.0010 FHV
1.595
1 700
2.234
0.976 0.344 * 00010 FflV
1595
1664
3000
1.323 0472 * 00010 FRV
1 595
1,700
3.000
0,976 0.471 * 0,0010 FRV
1 595
1.664
1.700
0.976 0377 * 0.0010 FflV
2,409
3000
3234
1,323 0501 * 00010 FflV
1 595
1900
3000
0976 0.462 * 0.0010 FRV
1 595
1 664
1.700
0.976 0331 * 0.0010 FHV
1,595
1 664
3.000
0,976 0305 * 0,0010 FRV
1 595
3,000
3570
1 323 04B5 * 00010 FRV
1 595
1 700
3000
- UMTS IN MICHOGRAMS PEH LITER * - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE * - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FlbH IN STATE
SO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAQE
0976 0.364 * 0.0010 FRV
3.000
3.234
4102
1.595
2.409
3234
l!595
3.000
3096
0978 0401 * 0.0010 FRV
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.978 0.331 * 0.0010 FRV
1.595
1.664
3.000
1.323 0-479 * 0.0010 FRV
1 595
3,000
3.282
0.976 0.210 * 0.0010 FRV
3904
7,840
10,000
0.976 0397 * 0.0010 FRV
1.595
2234
3,000
1.323 0.463 * 0.0010 FHV
1.595
3.000
3.282
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: DIELDRIN
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 12
ALABAMA 5
ARIZONA 9
ARKANSAS 6
CALIFORNIA B
COLORADO 8
CONNECTICUT 6
DELAWARE 8
• FLORIDA 4
GEORGIA 5
IDAHO 6
ILLINOIS 7
INDIANA 5
IOWA 5
t KANSAS 4
KENTUCKY 5
LOUISIANA 5
MAINE 5
MARYLAND 6
MASSACHUSETTS 8
NAME
POECIUIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECIL IDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
POECIUIDAE
CENTHARCHIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERUOAE
ASELUDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHIN DAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PAtAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ASELUDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPHIN DAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
SALMONIOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
LC50 VALUE
4503
5000
5.452
8000
2459
10.611
20000
30102
2459
4.503
8.000
10.611
5.000
10811
20000
30102
4503
5.452
8000
10611
2459
8000
10.611
24000
2459
8.000
14460
30102
2459
8.000
10.811
41 000
4503
14.460
41.000
231.052
2.459
10411
41.000
3.873
8.000
10.811
24.000
5.000
3.452
10.611
20.000
5.452
10.811
30102
231.052
10411
20000
30102
231052
10.811
30.102
190.745
739.999
2459
5.000
10.811
30.102
10800
10811
20000
30102
6000
10800
22101
231052
5154
8000
10611
30.102
2.459
8,000
14460
30 102
MAXIMUM
1.830 *
0.452 *
0786 *
1 207 *
1 544 *
0632 *
0471 *
0382 *
0.251 *
0339 *
1.037 *
1 120 *
0,297 *
0832 *
0439 *
0.338 *
2669 *
0390 •
1037 *
0471 *
30-DAY
0.0019
0:0019
0:0019
0.0019
00019
00019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0010
00019
00019
00019
00019
AVERAGE
FRV
FRV
FHV
FHV
FRV
FflV
FHV
FHV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FflV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
. . _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
t-CV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITH/E SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: DIELDRIN
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN 7
MINNESOTA 5
» MISSISSIPPI 5
MISSOURI 5
MONTANA 8
NEBRASKA 4
NEVADA 8
NEW HAMPSHIRE 6
NEW JERSEY 8
NEW MEXICO 3
NEW YORK 7
NORTH CAROLINA 6
NORTH DAKOTA 5
OHIO 8
OKLAHOMA 7
OHEGON 7
PENNSYLVANIA 7
RHODE ISLAND 8
SOUTH CAROLINA 5
SOUTH DAKOTA 6
• FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
** - STATE HAS LESS THAN * RESIDENT FAMILI
I HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
30 DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (+) ( + 1 (++1
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAFICHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASELUDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTHARCHIOAE
PEHUDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PERUOAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PEHLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
UM ANOlOR
5452 1.556 *
8.000
10611
20000
3.873 0511 *
10411
30.102
231.052
5.000 1.115 *
10411
20.000
30.102
10.811 0.832 *
20.000
30102
231.052
5154 1361 *
8.000
1041 1
24.000
2.459 0.121 *
10.811
30.102
190,745
2.459 0.746 *
4.503
8.000
1041 1
2.459 0.549 *
6.000
14.460
22.101
2.459 0.362 *
6.000
10411
41.000
2.4S9 0.632 *
8.000
10.611
24.000
3473 1.060 *
8.000
10411
20.000
2459 0.362 *
8.000
10.811
41.000
2,459 0.146 *
10.811
30.102
190.745
2.459 0.506 *
10.811
20.000
30.102
2.459 0.581 *
10.611
20.000
30.102
5452 1.376 *
8.000
10.611
24.000
2.459 0.637 *
6000
10.811
20.000
2459 0.471 *
8.000
14.460
30102
2459 0339 *
8.000
10.811
41.000
2.459 0490 *
10.811
24.000
30.102
00019
00019
0,0019
00019
0.0019
00019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
00019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
FHV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FHV
FHV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FflV
FRV
C-13
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: DIELDRIN
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME
TENNESSEE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
» TEXAS 6 POECIL IDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
UTAH 6 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PEHLIDAE
VERMONT 6 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
VIRGINIA 6 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
WASHINGTON 8 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
WEST VIRGINIA 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
WISCONSIN 6 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
WYOMING 6 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PEHLIDAE
~'-° "JC
C M
LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAQE
{+) <+) (+) (*+)
2459 0452 * 00019 FHV
10811
20000
30.102
4503 1066 * 0,0019 FHV
10811
20000
30.102
2,459 0632 * 00019 FRV
8000
10.811
24.000
2459 0.549 * 0.0019 FRV
8.000
14,460
22 101
2459 0465 * 0.0019 FHV
6,000
10811
30102
5.452 1.456 * 00019 FHV
B.OOO
10.811
24,000
2459 0,105 * 00019 FRV
10811
30.102
231052
5.452 1.335 * 00019 FRV
10.611
20.000
30.102
2.459 0.632 * 0.0019 FHV
8.000
10,811
24000
E,>N"S,NMiCfiOGRAMS PER LITER
FR, FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
CC . CINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SC . SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: ENDOSULFAN
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 9
ALABAMA 5
ARIZONA 8
ARKANSAS 4
CALIFORNIA 7
COLORADO 8
CONNECTICUT 6
DELAWARE 5
* FLORIDA 3
GEORGIA 4
IDAHO 7
ILLINOIS 6
INDIANA 6
IOWA 5
ft KANSAS 4
KENTUCKY 5
LOUISIANA 3
MAINE 4
MARYLAND 6
MASSACHUSETTS 6
* - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIV
NAME LCSO VALUE
SALMONIDAE 0,664
CYPRINIDAE 1,279
PTERONARCIDAE 2.300
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240
SALMONIDAE 0664
CYPRINIDAE 1 279
CATOSTOMIDAE 3,240
CENTHARCHIDAE 3811
SALMONIDAE 0664
CYPRINIDAE 1.279
PTERONARCIOAE 2.300
POECILIIDAE 3.700
CYPRINIDAE 1.279
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240
CENTHAHCH1DAE 3811
COENAGRIONIDAE(AGRIONIDAE) 87.850
SALMONIDAE 0.664
CYPHINIDAE 1.279
POECILIIDAE 3.700
CENTRAflCHIDAE 3811
SALMONIDAE 0.664
CYPRINIDAE 1.279
PTEHONARCIDAE 2.300
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240
SALMONIDAE 0.664
CYPRINIDAE 1,279
CATOSTOMIDAE 3 240
CENTRARCHIDAE 3,811
SALMONIDAE 0.664
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240
CENTHARCHIDAE 3.811
GAMMARIDAE 6.000
POECILIIDAE 3.700
CENTRARCHIDAE 3.811
COENAGRIONIDAE(AGfllONIDAE) 87650
0.000
SALMONIDAE 0.664
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240
CENTRARCHIDAE 3.811
COENAGHIONIDAE{AGRIONIDAE) 87.650
SALMONIDAE 0.664
CYPRINIDAE 1.279
PTEHONARCIDAE 2.300
CENTHAHCHIDAE 3.611
SALMONIDAE 0.664
CYPRINIDAE 1,279
CATOSTOMIDAE 3240
CENTRARCHIDAE 3,811
SALMONIDAE 0.664
CYPHINIDAE 1.279
CATOSTOMIDAE 3,240
CENTRAHCHIDAE 3.811
CYPRINIDAE 1,279
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240
CENTRAHCHIDAE 3811
GAMMARIDAE 6.000
CYPH1NIDAE 1,279
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240
CENTRARCHIDAE 3.81 1
COENAGRIONIDAE(AGRIONIDAE) 87.650
SALMONIDAE 0.664
CYPHINIDAE 1.279
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240
CENTRAHCHIDAE 3.811
CYPRINIDAE 1 279
CENTRARCHIDAE 3.611
COENAGHIONIDAE(AQRIONIDAE) 87650
0.000
CYPHINIDAE 1.279
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240
GAMMARIDAE 5.800
COENAGHIONIDAE(AGRIONIDAE) 87650
SALMONIDAE 0.664
CYPHINIDAE 1.279
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240
CENTRAHCHIDAE 3.811
SALMONIDAE 0.664
CYPRINIDAE 1.279
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240
CENTHARCHIDAE 3.811
UM ANDIOR
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIF
MAXIMUM 30-DAY
0.208 *
0137 *
0 184 *
0.036 *
0,155 *
0.196 *
0149 *
0.147 *
0.208 *
0.019 *
0.170 *
0149 *
0149 *
0.351 *
0036 *
0.137 *
0208 *
**
0043 *
0,149 *
0149 *
01064
0.0701
0.0944
0.0185
0.0793
0.1003
0.0762
0.0751
0.1064
00096
0.0870
0.0762
0.0762
0.1800
0.0185
0.0701
0 1064
0.0218
00782
00762
CRITERIA
AVERAQE
(•f+1
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACH
ACR
ACR
ACH
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACH
ACH
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACH
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: ENDOSULFAN
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN 5
MINNESOTA 6
« MISSISSIPPI 3
MISSOURI 4
MONTANA 6
NEBRASKA 6
NEVADA 6
NEW HAMPSHIRE G
NEW JERSEY 5
NEW MEXICO 8
NEW YORK 6
NORTH CAROLINA 5
1ORTV DAKOTA 7
OHIO 6
OKLAHOMA 5
OREGON 5
PENNSYLVANIA 6
RHODE ISLAND 8
SOUTH CAROLINA 4
SOUTH DAKOTA 7
TOXICANT: ENDOSULFAN
NAME LCH VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AV{E+RAOE 8TATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC60 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAV 'AVERAGE
SALMONIDAE 0 664 0.149 « 0.0762 ACR TENNESSEE 5 SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN DAE 1,279 CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOM 1 DAE 3.240 CATOSTOM 1 DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE 3.811 CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE 0.664 0.149 * 0,0762 ACR 1 TEXAS 4 CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE 1.279 POECILHDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE 3540 CENTRARCHIDAE
0.664 0,137 * 00701 ACR
1.279
3.240
3.811
1579 0.039 * 0.0198 ACH
3.700
3.811
CENTRARCHIDAE 3.811 COENAGHIONIDAE(AGHIONIDAE) 87.650
CYPRINIDAE 1 279 0.208 * 0.1064 ACR UTAH 8 SALMONIDAE 0664 0 196 * 0 1003 Am
CENTRARCHIDAE 3811 • * CYPHINIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGRIONIDAE) 87 650 PTERONARCIDAE
0.000 CATOSTOMIOAE
CYPRINIDAE 1579 0.036 * 0.0165 ACH VERMONT 6 SALMONIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240 CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE 3,61 1 CATOSTOMIDAE
COENAGHIONIDAE (AGRIONIDAE) 87.650 CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE 0.664 0 196 * 0,1003 ACH VIRGINIA 6 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE 1579 CYPRINIOAE
PTERONAHCIDAE 2.300 CATOSTOMIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE 3540 CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE 0.664 0 149 * 0.0762 ACR WASHINGTON 6 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE 1.279 PTERONAHCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE 3540 CENTRAHCHIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE 3,811 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE 0.664 0 165 * 0,0644 ACR WEST VIRGINIA 5 SALMONIDAE
POECIUIDAE 3.700 CYPHINIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE 3611 CATOSTOMIDAE
GAMMARIDAE 5 600 CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE 0 664 0 149 * 0.0762 ACR WISCONSIN 6 SALMONIDAE
CYPHIN DAE 1579 CYPHINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE 3540 CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE 3611 CENTRAHCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE 0.664 0147 * 0.0751 ACR WYOMING 8 SALMONIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240 CYPRINIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE 3.811 PTERONAHCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE 6.000 CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE 0664 0,196 * 0.1003 ACR
CYPHIN DAE 1579
PTEHONARCIDAE 2.300
CATOSTOMIDAE 3540
SALMONIDAE 0664 0.149 * 0.0762 ACR
CYPRINIDAE 1.279
CATOSTOMIDAE 3540
CENTRARCHIDAE 3.811
SALMONIDAE 0.664 0,147 * 00751 ACH
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240
CENTHARCHIDAE 3.811
GAMMARIDAE 6000
SALMONIDAE 0.664 0161 * 0.0823 ACR
CYPRINIDAE 1,279
CATOSTOMIDAE 3540
CENTRARCHIOAE 3 81 1
SALMONIDAE 0.664 0 149 * 0.0762 ACH
CYPRINIDAE 1579
CATOSTOMIOAE 3540
CENTRARCHIDAE 3.811
SALMONIDAE 0,664 0,106 * 0.0545 ACH
CYPRINIDAE 1579
CENTRARCHIDAE 3.811
GAMMARIDAE 5.800
SALMONIDAE 0.664 0 029 * 0.0148 ACR
CENTRARCHIDAE 3.811
GAMMARIDAE 5.600
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGHIONIDAE) 87650
SALMONIDAE 0.664 0.149 * 0.0762 ACR
CYPHINIDAE 1579
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240
CENTRARCHIDAE 3.811
SALMONIDAE 0.664 0.149 » 00762 ACH
CYPRINtDAE 1579
CATOSTOMIDAE 3,240
CENTRARCHIDAE 3811
SALMONIDAE 0664 0.019 * 0,0096 ACH
CATOSTOMIDAE 3 240
CENTRAHCHIDAE 3611
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGHIONIDAE) 67650
SALMONIDAE 0664 0.101 * 00823 ACR
CYPRINIDAE I ?79
CATOSTOMIOAE 3240
CENTHARCHIDAE 3 81 1
FOOTNOTE
1.279
2.300
3.240
0,664 0.149 * 0.0762 ACH
1.279
3.240
3,611
0.664 0 U9 * 0 0762 ACR
1579
3540
3.811
0.664 0.153 * 0.0787 ACR
2.300
3.611
5.800
0.664 0,137 * 0.0701 ACR
1579
3.240
3.811
0 664 0 149 * 0.0762 ACR
1579
3540
3,611
0.664 0.196 * 0.1003 ACR
1579
2-300
3.240
C-15
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: ENDRIN
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE
( + )
NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ALABAMA 8 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ARIZONA 10 SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ARKANSAS 10 CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CALIFORNIA 10 GASTEHOSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
POECILIIDAE
COLORADO B SALMONIDAE
PEHLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CONNECTICUT 9 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DELAWARE 10 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
* FLORIDA 6 CYPRINODONTIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GEORGIA 8 SALMONIDAE
POECIL IDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAEIAGH ONIDAE)
IDAHO 10 SALMONIDAE
PERL DAE
PTERONARCIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ILLINOIS 11 SALMONIDAE
CYPR NIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
INDIANA 7 SALMONIDAE
CYPR NIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGRIONIDAE)
IOWA B CYPRINIDAE
POEC LIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
» KANSAS 7 CYPRINIDAE
POEC L IDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAGRIONIOAE (AGRIONIDAE)
KENTUCKY B SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LOUISIANA 8 SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
MAINE 8 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGH ONIDAE)
MARYLAND 1 1 GASTEHOSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
MASSACHUSETTS 9 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPH1NIOAE
- UNITS IN M
P V FINA
0.440
0468
0493
0.647
0.694
0732
0750
1 011
0.357
0.493
0.647
0.949
0.732
0.750
1.011
1 205
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.949
0.320
0.493
0,647
1.011
0.440
0.558
1.011
1.086
0.440
0894
0.750
1.011
0.850
0.949
1.011
2.100
0.558
0750
1.011
1.800
0.468
0.493
0,847
0750
0,701
0.732
0.750
1.011
0.701
0.732
1.011
1,800
0.732
0750
1.011
1.265
0732
0,750
1011
1800
0.694
0.732
0.750
1.011
0471
0732
0,750
1.011
0.440
0.458
0562
1.800
Od40
0526
0732
0.750
0.440
0.556
1 Oil
1 086
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
0201 » 0.0023 FHV
0.280 * 0.0023 FHV
0,133 * 0,0023 FHV
0.283 * 0.0023 FRV
0.144 * 00023 FHV
0112 * 0.0023 FHV
0.153 * 0.0023 FRV
0,164 * 00023 FRV
0.232 * 00023 FRV
0.170 * 0.0023 FRV
0.191 * 0.0023 FHV
0.294 * 00023 FHV
0.197 * 0.0023 FHV
0.271 * 0.0023 FRV
0208 * 0.0023 FRV
0.280 * 00023 FHV
0.190 * 00023 FRV
0088 * 0.0023 FRV
0188 * 00023 FRV
0.153 * 00023 FHV
CROGRAMS PER LITER
L RESIDUE VALUE
L CHROf*
1C VALUE
C-16 s v SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: ENDRIN
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN 10
MINNESOTA 8
« MISSISSIPPI 9
MISSOURI 9
MONTANA 9
NEBRASKA 6
NEVADA 10
NEW HAMPSHIRE 6
NEW JERSEY 10
NEW MEXICO 10
NEW YORK 11
NORTH CAROLINA 9
NORTH DAKOTA 8
OHIO 9
OKLAHOMA 10
OREGON 10
PENNSYLVANIA 10
RHODE ISLAND 9
SOUTH CAROLINA 8
SOUTH DAKOTA 7
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
** — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILII
* - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FiSH IN STATE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIM
30 DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
NAME LC50 VALUE
< + )
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGRIONID/
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
POECILIIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGHIONID/
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PEHLIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
POECILIIDAE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGHIONID/i
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRA HCHIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PEHLIDAE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
0.625
0732
0.750
1.011
0.687
0.732
0.750
1.011
0.732
0.750
1.011
1.265
0.732
0750
1.011
1.285
0.383
0.493
0,647
1.011
0.558
0.732
1.011
E) 1.800
0.320
0.357
0.540
0.949
0.556
0.562
1 011
E) 1.800
0.440
0.558
0.750
1.011
0,357
0.493
0.847
0.750
0.440
0.687
0.732
0750
0.556
0.750
1.011
E) 1.800
0.8B4
0.732
1,011
5874
0556
0.732
0.750
1.011
0.694
0.732
0.750
1.011
0.320
0.440
0.486
0.540
0440
0.558
1.011
1.086
0.440
0556
1.011
1.086
0.556
0750
1.011
COENAGRIONIDAE(AGHIONIDAE) 1.800
PERLIDAE 0.493
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
S— NATIONAL VALUE USED
UM AND/OR
0.894
0.732
1.011
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CaiTFBl*
MAXIMUM
< + >
0.265
0.276
0277
0.277
0.133
0.153
0.099
0.141
0.168
0,148
0.205
0.178
0.072
0.233
0.286
0.144
0.158
0.153
0.170
0191
„
*
*
it
*
*
*
*
*
^
#
30-DAY
( + )
00023
0.0023
0.0023
0.0023
0,0023
0.0023
0.0023
0.0023
0.0023
0.0023
0.0023
0,0023
00023
00023
0.0023
0.0023
0.0023
0.0023
0.0023
00023
AVERAGE
(++)
FHV
FRV
FHV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FRV
FHV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FHV
FRV
FHV
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: ENDRIN
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
TENNESSEE 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
POECIUIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
I TEXAS 3 POECIUIDAE
CENTHARCH10AE
CYPHINIDAS
PALAEMONIDAE
UTAH 9 SALMONIDAE
PERUDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
VERMONT 8 SALMONIDAE
YPRIN DAE
ENTRARCHIDAE
OENAGRIONIOAE (AGH1ONIDAE)
VIRGINIA 9 ALMONIDAE
YPRINIDAE
ENTRARCHIDAE
COENAGHIONIDAEIAGRIONIDAE)
WASHINGTON 10 GASTEROSTE1DAE
SALMONIDAE
PERUDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
WEST VIRGINIA 6 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAGHIONIDAEIAGRIONIDAE)
WISCONSIN 8 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTfURCKIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
WYOMING 9 SALMONIDAE
PERLIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
C°.OTNOUUNa-, ,M
!PV !NA
O.S94 0.284 * 0.0023 FRV
0.732
0.750
1011
0949 0418 » 0.0023 FRV
1011
1,086
1265
0357 0 125 * 00023 FRV
0.493
0647
1 Oil
0556 0.141 * 00023 FRV
0562
1 011
1.800
0556 0.175 * 0.0023 FHV
0.732
1.011
1.800
0.440 0.165 * 0.0023 FHV
0.488
0.493
0775
0.556 0153 * 0.0023 FHV
0.732
1.011
1 800
0625 0.231 * 0.0023 FHV
0732
1.011
1.265
0.357 0.125 * 0.0023 FRV
0493
0.647
1.011
fPOGHAMO PEH LUER
L KE^ICiUfc VALUt
L CHRONIC /ALU6
'_,CJ ENSITIVE SPECIE:',. CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: HEPTACHLOR
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 10
ALABAMA 5
ARIZONA 8
ARKANSAS 5
CALIFORNIA 7
COLORADO 7
CONNECTICUT 5
DELAWARE 5
* FLORIDA 4
GEORGIA 4
IDAHO 7
ILLINOIS 6
INDIANA 5
IOWA 5
» KANSAS 4
KENTUCKY 4
LOUISIANA 5
MAINE 4
MARYLAND 5
MASSACHUSETTS 5
II - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONIO FISH IN STATE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAX^
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
<+) m (+1 (++i
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
PEHLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERLIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
POECIUIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PALAEMONIOAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
_S — NATIONAL VALUE USED
UM AND'OR
0.995 0.251 *
1 800
2.800
7.800
1.800 0.243 *
13.058
24.771
50.748
0.995 0.142 *
2.600
13.058
26.000
1600 0.202 *
7.800
24.771
50748
2.600 0.898 *
26000
29.000
29498
0.995 0.125 *
2.800
13.058
26000
13.058 3.521 *
26.000
47329
50.748
13058 3.521 *
26.000
47329
50.748
24.771 2J73 *
50.748
146.000
319.999
13.058 0.657 *
24.771
50.748
319.999
0.995 0.117 *
2.800
17.703
26.000
1.800 0.311 *
24.771
29.498
47.329
24.771 8.107 *
29.496
47.329
50.748
1.600 0.245 *
26.000
47.329
50.748
7.800 0.786 *
26.000
50.748
179.508
13.056 1.384 *
24771
50.748
179.508
1.800 0.208 *
24771
50.748
81 900
29000 7,775 *
50748
81.900
100.697
26.000 9-159 *
32702
47.329
50.748
13.056 3.521 *
26.000
47.329
50.746
0.0036
0.0038
0.0038
0.0036
0.0036
0.0038
0.0036
0.0038
0.0036
0.0036
0.0038
0.0038
0.0038
0.0038
0.0038
0.0036
0.0036
0.0036
0.0038
0.0038
FHV
FHV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FRV
FHV
FRV
FRV
C-17
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: HEPTACHLOR
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN 6
MINNESOTA 5
» MISSISSIPPI 4
MISSOURI 5
MONTANA 7
NEBRASKA 4
NEVADA 7
NEW HAMPSHIRE 5
NEW JERSEY 5
NEW MEXICO 7
NEW YORK 6
NORTH CAROLINA 5
NORTH DAKOTA 5
OHIO 6
OKLAHOMA 7
OREGON 6
L 6
RHODE ISLAND 5
SOU H CAROLINA 4
SOUTH DAKOTA 6
C-18
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMAfllDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHN DAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRAflCHIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CYPRINIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAflCHIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAflCHIDAE
GAMMAfllDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMAfllDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHN DAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
ASTAC DAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMAfllDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTflAHCHIOAE
DAPHN DAE
CYPHINIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
FOOT
1 800
26000
29.498
37048
17.703
26,000
37 046
50,748
1BOO
24.771
50.746
179.508
1600
7800
24771
50748
0995
2800
26000
29000
13.056
26000
58.566
179,508
0.800
13.058
28.000
29000
13058
26,000
28.000
50,746
13.056
26000
47329
50746
0995
2.600
13.058
24.771
1.800
17703
24771
37.048
13058
24.771
47.329
50746
13056
26.000
29000
58566
1.800
13056
24.77)
47,329
1 800
7800
13058
24.771
0.900
26.000
29000
29498
13056
24,771
47.329
13.056
26.000
47329
50748
13058
24771
50.748
319.999
2.800
13058
26000
29000
OTE
- UNITS IN MICROGRAIK
FRV FINAL RESIDUE
ACR COMPUTED 6V
TOXICANT: HEPTACHLOR
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
0331 . 00038 FRV TENNESSEE 5 PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAflCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
5374 * 0.0038 FRV — # TEXAS 6 PALAEMONIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
0 118 * 00038 FHV UTAH 7 PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
0202 * 0.0038 FHV VERMONT 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRAflCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
0.101 * 0.0038 FRV VIRGINIA 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
1 440 * 0.0038 FHV WASHINGTON 7 PTEflONAHCIDAE
PERLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
0160 * 00038 FHV WEST VIRGINIA 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
3696 * 0,0038 FRV WISCONSIN 8 PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAG
SALMONIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
3.521 * 0 0038 FRV WYOMING 7 PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
0.128 * 00036 FRV
0.333 * 0.0038 FRV
3446 * 0.0038 FHV
3.360 * 0.0036 FHV
0.269 * 00038 FRV
0393 * 00038 FRV
0136 * 0.0038 FRV
0.289 . 00038 FRV
3.521 * 0.0038 FHV
0857 * 0,0038 FHV
0.805 * 00038 FRV
S PER LITER * - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
VALUE # - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
1,800 0.243 * 0.0038 FRV
13.058
24.771
50.748
1.800 0.234 * 0.0038 FHV
7,600
24771
50748
0.995 0.125 * 00038 FRV
2,800
13.058
26.000
13.058 3.705 * 0.0038 FRV
26.000
37046
50.748
13.058 3.446 * 0.0036 FfW
24.771
47.329
50.748
1.100 0.112 * 0.0038 FRV
2,600
26.000
29.000
13.058 1.425 * 0.0038 FRV
50.748
178.508
1.600 0.331 * 0.0038 FRV
26,000
29.498
37.048
0.995 0.125 * 0.0036 FRV
2.800
13.058
26.000
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXIOITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: LEAD
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
STATE FA E
NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
ALABAMA 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
ARIZONA 6 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ARKANSAS 4 GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CALIFORNIA 6 OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COLORADO 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CONNECTICUT 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DELAWARE 4 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CfPHiNiDAE
* FLORIDA 4 CENTRARCHIDAE
POEC1LIIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GEORGIA 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPflfNIDAE
IDAHO 5 DAPHNIDAE
ALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
[LUNG'S •> GAMMAHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
INDIANA 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPfliNIDAE
CENTRAHCH1DAE
PHILODINIDAE
FOWA 4 GAMMARIDAE
CYPfliNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
• KANSAS 3 CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
KENTUCKY 5 GAMMAHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LOU'SlANA 3 CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
MAINE J SALMONIDAE
C-CPRIN1DAE
PHILODINIDAE
MARYLAND 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
VASSAGMUSETTS A SALMON1DAE
CYPHINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
( + t (I)
1 161
4020
80.062
358792
158.156
358.792
455 015
603.845
4.020
80.062
358.792
455.015
1.161
358.792
455.015
603.845
4020
80.062
358.792
455.015
4.020
158.156
358.792
455.015
80.062
356.792
455.015
803.845
158.156
455.015
603.846
455.015
532.856
803.845
814803
80.062
455.015
803.845
814803
4.020
80.062
358.792
455.015
1.161
158.156
358.792
455.015
158.156
3S8.TB2
455015
803.845
1.161
358.792
455.015
803.845
356.792
455.015
. 303.845
0,000
1 161
158.158
358-792
455.015
358782
455.015
603.845
0000
40329
157.991
803-845
0.000
80.062
358.792
455.015
803.845
80062
388 792
485,016
803645
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
(->•) (1)
0.037 *
37,382 *
0359 *
0.035 *
0.359 *
0.325 *
14.969 *
36.495 *
155455 *
14.070 *
0.287 *
0.059 *
37.382 *
0.035 *
0037 *
**
0.059 *
0037 *
0.037 *
**
14,969 it
14.069 *
( + 1 (-M
0.00003
0.00004
0.00003
0.00003
0.00003
0.00003
0.00003
000004
4.4479
0.00004
0.00002
0.00004
0.00004
0.00003
000003
0.00004
000003
0.00003
0.00003
000004
-) m
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
ACR
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
TOXICANT: LEAD
STATE
MICHIGAN
MINNESOTA
M MISSISSIPPI
MISSOURI
MONTANA
NEBRASKA
NEVADA
NEW HAMPSHIRE
NEW JERSEY
NEW MEXICO
NEW YORK
NORTH CAROLINA
NORTH DAKOTA
OHIO
OKLAHOMA
OREGON
PENNSYLVANIA
RHODE ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
SOUTH DAKOTA
FAMILIES TESTED NAME
5 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
4 GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
3 CYPRINIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
6 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
4 SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
5 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
4 SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
5 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
5 OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
4 SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIOAE
PHILOOIN10AE
CYPRINIDAE
5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTHARCHIOAE
LCSO VALUE
(+) (I)
1.161
60.062
358792
455.015
80.062
358,792
455.015
803.845
1.161
358.792
455.015
803,845
358.792
455.015
603645
0.000
4.020
80.082
358.792
455.015
4.020
80.062
358.792
455.015
4020
80.082
455.015
532,856
80.062
157.991
455.015
603,845
80.082
455.015
803.845
814.803
4.020
60.062
358.792
455.015
1.161
60.082
358.792
455.015
80.062
455.015
303.845
814.603
4.020
158.156
358.792
455.015
80.082
358.792
455.015
803.645
1.161
158.156
358.792
455.015
4.020
80.062
455.015
803.645
80.062
358.792
455.015
803.845
80.062
358.792
455.015
603.845
30.062
455.015
603.645
814.803
4,020
158.156
358792
455.015
MAXIMUM
( + ) <$)
0.054 *
14.969 *
0035 *
0.037 *
**
0.287 *
0.287 *
0.322 *
10.748 *
14.070 *
0287 *
0.054 *
14.070 *
0.325 *
14.969 *
0.059 *
0.219 *
14.969 *
14.969 *
14.070 *
0.325 *
30-DAY
0.00004
0.00004
0,0010
0,00003
000003
000004
0.00003
0.00003
0.00004
0.00004
0.00004
0.00003
0.00003
0.00004
0.00003
0.00002
000004
0.00003
0.00003
0.00003
E CRITERIA
AVERAGE
FCV
FCV
ACH
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
"OOtNOTE
- UNITS IN MICROQHAMS PER LITER
FHV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED 0r ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV HNAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
* - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
J - HARDNESS EFFECT WTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30.DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: LEAD
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + ) ($) (+) (*) ( + ) (++) (J)
TENNESSEE S GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHtNIDAE
CENTRAHCHIOAE
• TEXAS 4 CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
UTAH 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
VERMONT 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
CENTflARCHlDAE
PHILODINIDAE
VIRGINIA 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPfllNIDAE
CENTHARCHlDAE
PHILODINIDAE
WASHINGTON 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
WEST VIRGINIA 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
WISCONSIN 5 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHtNIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
WYOMING 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
C-20
1.161 0059 * 000004 FCV
156 156
358792
455015
358 792 113 577 * 3 2496 ACR
532.856
803845
4,020 0.287 * 0.00003 FCV
80.062
358.792
455.015
80.062 10.748 * 0.00003 FCV
157991
455.015
803.845
60062 14969 * 000003 FCV
358.792
455.015
803845
4020 0219 * 000002 FCV
80.062
455015
803.845
80.062 1 *.969 * 000004 FCV
358.792
455.015
803.845
1.161 0.054 * 0.00004 FCV
60.062
358.792
455,015
4.020 0287 * 000003 FCV
60.062
358.792
455.015
- UNITS IN MICROGHAMS PER LITER
- FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: LINDANE
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
ALABAMA 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
ARIZONA 8 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
ARKANSAS 6 SALMONIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CALIFORNIA 7 SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
COLORADO 7 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CONNECTICUT 6 GAMMAHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PEflCIDAE
DELAWARE 7 SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
» FLORIDA 5 ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
GEORGIA 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
IDAHO 6 SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
ILLINOIS 9 ASELLIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
INDIANA 8 GAMMAHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALUfllDAE
IOWA 8 SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALUPIDAE
« KANSAS 6 CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALUWOAE
PERCIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
KENTUCKY 6 SALMONIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALUfllDAE
LOUISIANA 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
ICTALUfllDAE
CYPRINIDAE
MAINE 6 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PERCIDAE
MARYLAND 7 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
MASSACHUSETTS 7 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
• * — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
» - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
10.000 3.218 * 0.2574 ACR
21.968
22.437
52.871
32.031 9751 * 07800 ACR
52.671
53.066
94.805
14.158 5119 * 04095 ACR
42.198
48,000
53.066
2.000 0,245 * 0.0195 ACR
10.000
52.671
53.066
21.988 8.516 * 0.8814 ACR
42.198
46.000
53.066
8.004 2320 * 0.1856 ACR
42.198
48.000
53.066
10.438 1 829 * 0.1463 ACR
14.158
42.198
68.000
8,004 1.496 * 0.1198 ACR
10.468
42.196
44.000
44.000 10.720 * 0.8575 ACR
52.871
112.694
138.000
37.669 10.138 * 0.8110 ACR
52.871
53.066
112.694
18.355 6.680 * 0.5343 ACR
42.198
48.000
84,000
10.000 2.01 1 * 0.1609 ACR
10.468
18.456
52.871
10488 2.885 * 0.2140 ACR
18.456
52.871
53.066
2,000 0,352 * 0.0281 ACR
10.488
42.198
53.066
42.196 14.391 * 1.1512 ACR
53.066
68.000
94.805
8.004 1.133 * 0.0908 ACR
10.000
52.871
53.066
45.277 13.938 * 1.1149 ACR
52.871
531)66
94.805
15-889 4.556 * 0.3644 ACR
32.000
48.000
68.000
10,488 2.473 * 0.1978 ACR
16.933
42198
64.000
10.488 2.245 * 0,1796 ACR
14.158
42.198
53.086
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
OXICANT: LINDANE
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN 8
MINNESOTA 9
MISSISSIPPI 5
MISSOURI 8
MONTANA 8
NEBRASKA 6
NEVADA 9
NEW HAMPSHIRE 8
NEW JERSEY 7
NEW MEXICO 7
NEW YORK 7
NORTH CAROLINA 7
NORTH DAKOTA 6
OHIO 8
OKLAHOMA 6
OREGON 7
PENNSYLVANIA 7
RHODE ISLAND 6
SOUTH CAROLINA £
SOUTH DAKOTA 7
MOST SENSITIV
NAME
SALMONIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDA6
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARtDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPHINIDAG
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
tCTALURlOAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARJDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
ICTALUHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRA HCHI DAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTflARCHIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALUR
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: MERCURY
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 9
ALABAMA 5
ARIZONA 5
ARKANSAS 4
CALIFORNIA 5
COLORADO S
CONNECTICUT 5
DELAWARE 5
• FLORIDA 3
GEORGIA 5
IDAHO 5
ILLINOIS 6
INDIANA 5
IOWA 3
» KANSAS 2
KENTUCKY 4
LOUISIANA 4
MAINE 6
MARYLAND 5
MASSACHUSETTS 5
C-22
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDE
NAME
DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAG
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
AST AC DAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PHILOD NIOAE
NAIDIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
NAIDIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
NAIOIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
PHILODINIDA6
NAIDIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
NAIDIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
NAIDIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
FOOTNOTED
, . _ FPV
FRV
ACH
SCv
NT FAMILY
LC50 VALUE
5.000
10000
31 623
244259
10.000
20.000
248.595
783471
5.000
10000
248595
753471
10000
20000
783,471
5000
10.000
244.259
783471
5,000
10000
248,595
783.471
10.000
50.000
248.595
783.471
10.000
50.000
248595
733.471
20000
783.471
999.995
0.000
20.000
248.595
783.471
999.993
5.000
10.000
248.595
783.471
10.000
244259
783,471
999996
10.000
244.259
783471
999.998
10.000
783.471
999.995
0000
753.471
99999B
0,000
0.000
10000
248.595
763471
999.998
20.000
240.000
783.471
999996
10.000
50.000
240000
783,471
10,000
50000
244,259
783.471
10000
50.000
248595
783471
FINAL PLANT v
FINAL RESIDUE
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) I*) (++)
0,470 * 020 FRV
0.347 * 0.20 FRV
0.101 * 0.0671 ACR
0170 * 01133 ACR
0101 * 0.0674 ACH
0 101 * 0.0671 ACR
0.629 * 020 FRV
0.629 * 0.20 FRV
0470 * 020 FHV
2.046 * 0.20 FRV
0.101 * 0.0671 ACR
1000 * 0.20 FHV
0806 * 020 FRV
0.470 * 0.20 FRV
0470 » 0.20 FRV
0,639 * 0.20 FHV
1.664 * 0.20 FRV
0767 * 0.20 FHV
0631 » 0.20 FRV
0629 * 0.20 FRV
ftLUE
VALUE
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: MERCURY
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + ) < + ) 1 + ) (+-+1
MICHIGAN 7 GAMMAHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
MINNESOTA 5 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
» MISSISSIPPI 4 GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
MISSOURI 3 GAMMAHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
MONTANA 5 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NEBRASKA 4 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
NEVADA 5 DAPHNlOAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
NEW HAMPSHIRE 5 GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
NEW JERSEY 4 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
NEW MEXICO 5 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NEW YORK 6 GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NORTH CAROLINA 4 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
NAIDIDAE
NORTH DAKOTA 5 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
OHIO 6 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
OKLAHOMA 5 GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
OREGON 5 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
PENNSYLVANIA 7 GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
RHODE ISLAND 5 GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SOUTH CAROLINA 4 ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
SOUTH DAKOTA 5 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
» - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
10,000 1 222 * 0.20 FHV
244259
783.471
999.998
10.000 0.808 * 0.20 FRV
248.595
783.471
999.998
10.000 0.170 * 0.1133 ACR
20.000
783.471
10.000 0.470 * 0.20 FRV
733.471 **
999.998
0.000
5.000 0.101 * 0.0674 ACH
10.000
244.259
783.471
5.000 0.240 * 0.1602 ACH
246595
783.471
999.996
5.000 0.101 * 0.0671 ACR
10.000
248.595
763.471
10.000 0.629 * 0.20 FRV
50.000
246.595
783471
10 000 0.639 * 0.20 FRV
248.595
783.471
999.996
5000 0.101 * 0.0671 ACR
10.000
248.595
763.471
10.000 0.764 * 0.20 FRV
50.000
248.595
763.471
10.000 0.639 * 0.20 FRV
248.595
753.471
999.996
5000 0.101 * 0.0671 ACR
10.000
248.595
783.471
10.000 1.003 * 0.20 FRV
248.595
763.471
999.998
10.000 0.347 * 0.20 FHV
20,000
246595
783.471
5.000 0.101 * 0.0674 ACH
10.000
244259
783.471
10.000 0.915 * 050 FRV
50.000
248.595
783.471
10.000 0.629 * 0.20 FRV
50.000
248.595
783,471
20.000 1 680 * 0.20 FRV
248.595
753.471
999.993
5.000 0101 * 0.0671 ACH
10000
248595
783.471
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: MERCURY
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30- DAY AVERAQE
(+» < + > 1+) (+*)
TENNESSEE * GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
NAID1DAE
* TEXAS 3 ASTACIDAE
PHILODIN10AE
NAID10AE
UTAH 5 DAPHNIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
VERMONT 5 GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
VIRGINIA 6 GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
WASHINGTON 5 OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PHILODINIOAE
WEST VIRGINIA 6 GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
WISCONSIN 7 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
WYOMING 5 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
FOOTNOTE
Fflv
•X;
10000 0.639 * 0.20 FRV
246.595
783471
999998
20,000 0.470 * 020 FRV
783471 **
999998
0.000
5,000 0.101 * 0,0671 ACR
10.000
248595
783.471
10000 0629 * 0.20 FRV
50.000
248595
783471
10000 0764 * 0.20 FHV
50.000
248595
783.471
5.000 0 101 * 0.0674 ACR
10.000
244,259
783471
10.000 0.764 * 0.20 FRV
50000
248595
783.471
10.000 1 222 « 0.20 FRV
244.259
783.471
999998
5.000 0.101 * 00671 ACR
10000
248595
783471
j IN MlCHOGRAMS PER LITER
FIN&L PLANT VALUE
FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: NICKEL
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL ie
ALABAMA 11
ARIZONA 10
ARKANSAS 10
CALIFORNIA 10
COLORADO 9
CONNECTICUT 12
DELAWARE 12
» FLORIDA 11
GEORGIA 10
IDAHO 8
ILLINOIS 13
INDIANA 12
IOWA 11
It KANSAS 10
KENTUCKY 11
LOUISIANA 10
MAINE 13
MARYLAND 12
MASSACHUSETTS 12
• - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
• - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
J - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXI
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) it) ( + ) 0) r+) (++i in
DAPHNIOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
rfUM ANOIOR
65.077 32914 *
233.555
345.472
401 217
78.456 31.618 *
301 510
325.842
401.217
65077 23.365 *
301.510
401.217
439.825
78.456 29.224 *
325.842
401.217
439.825
65.077 23.365 *
301.510
401.217
439.825
65077 21.349 *
401.217
439825
509.264
78.456 33.128 *
401.217
439.825
444.717
78.456 33 128 *
401.217
439.825
444.717
78458 30838 *
301 510
401217
439825
78456 29868 *
301.510
325642
401.217
65.077 20 057 *
401.217
439.825
444.717
78.456 34981 *
233.555
301.510
345.472
78.456 33.372 *
301510
345472
401.217
78.456 31.066 *
325.842
401.217
439.825
78.456 29868 *
301.510
325.842
401.217
78.456 31618 *
301.510
325.842
401.217
78.456 29005 *
301.510
401.217
439.825
78456 35.255 *
388.350
401.217
439825
78456 33.129 *
345472
401 217
439825
78456 33.129 «
345472
401 217
439825
3.3931
3.2596
2,4087
3.0127
2,4087
2.2009
3.4152
3.4152
3.1791
3.0791
2.0877
36062
3.4404
3.2047
3.0791
3.2596
2.9901
36345
3.4153
3.4153
ACH
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACH
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
C-23
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT; NICKEL
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN 13
MINNESOTA 11
• MISSISSIPPI <1
MISSOURI 11
MONTANA 9
NEBRASKA 10
NEVADA 9
NEW HAMPSHIRE 12
NEW JERSEY 12
NEW MEXICO 1!
NEW YORK 13
NORTH CAROLINA 12
NORTH DAKOTA 10
OHIO 12
OKLAHOMA 11
OHEGON 9
PENNSYLVANIA 13
RHODE ISLAND 12
SOUTH CAROLINA 11
SOUTH DAKOTA 11
C-2d
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
DAPHNIOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
DAPHNIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
POECILIIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PH1LOD1N10AE
CHIRONOMIDAE
OAPHNIOAE
C6NTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
DAPHNIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHlHONOMlDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTHAflCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
: . i FPVT
ACR
FCV
SCV
( + ) (*)
76456
233555
345 472
401217
78456
325 B42
439 625
76456
301.510
325642
401 217
78456
301 S1C
345472
401 217
65077
439 625
444 717
65,077
301,510
401.217
439 625
65,077
401217
439 825
456642
76456
345.472
401 217
439 825
78.456
345,472
401.217
439.825
35-077
301.510
401,217
439 825
78.456
345472
401-217
439 625
78,456
345472
401 217
439.825
65.077
325.642
401.217
439 625
78.456
345472
401 217
439 825
78456
301 510
325842
401 217
65077
301 510
401 217
439.825
78456
233555
345472
401217
76456
401 217
439,625
444717
78456
401,217
439825
444 717
65077
325842
401 217
439825
5 nNALCPL°AC
COMPUTE
FINAL CHR
SENSITIVE
TOXICANT: NICKEL
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + ) W ( + ) <+ + ! ID ...-..-
33660 * 34906 ACR TENNESSEE 11 DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
31066 * 32047 ACH * TEXAS 11 OAPHNIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
31 61B 32596 ACR UTAH 9 DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
31576 * 32553 ACH VERMONT 12 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
21 717 * 2 2388 ACR VIRGINIA 13 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
23365 * 24087 ACH WASHINGTON 8 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
21 656 * 2 2327 ACR WEST VIRGINIA 11 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRAflCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
33 129 * 3 4153 ACH WISCONSIN 13 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
33129 * 3,4153 ACR WYOMING 9 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
25,017 * 25790 ACfl
35,088 * 3.6172 ACR
33 129 * 3.4153 ACR
23512 * 24238 ACR
33129 . 34153 ACR
31 618 * 32596 ACR
21 753 * 22425 ACR
33,660 * 3,4906 ACR
33128 . 34152 ACR
31 123 * 32085 ACR
25 IBS * 25966 ACR
RAMS PER LITER * — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
NT VALUE ** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
DUE VALUE x - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
ONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OH
SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE SO-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
| + ) (1) 14) l») l + ( 1++J II)
78,456 31.618 * 32596 ACR
301.510
325.842
401 217
76.456 30.B38 * 3 1791 ACR
301.510
401.217
439.625
65 077 21.753 * 2 2425 ACR
301 510
401.217
439.825
78456 33.129 • 3,4153 ACR
345472
401,217
439.625
76 456 35.038 * 3.6172 ACR
345.472
401.217
439825
65,077 20,057 * 2.0677 ACR
401 217
439.825
444,717
76 456 31.086 * 3.2047 ACR
325-842
401.217
439.825
78.456 33.860 * 34906 ACR
233.555
345472
401217
65.077 21.717 * 22388 ACR
401.217
439,625
444,717
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: PCBS
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE
I*)
NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE 2.000
CENTRAHCHIDAE 6611
CYPRINIDAE 32601
GAMMARIDAE 99553
ALABAMA 4 SALMONIDAE 2 000
CENTRARCHIDAE 6611
CYPHINiOAE 32601
COENAGHIONIDAE {AGRIONIDAE) 262 642
ARIZONA 3 SALMONiOAE 2.000
CENTHARCHIDAE 2.300
CYPHINIDAE 32601
0000
ARKANSAS 4 CENTHARCHIDAE 6811
CYPHINIDAE 32601
GAMMARIDAE 92054
COENAGRIONIDAE
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: PCBS
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME
TENNESSEE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
» TEXAS 3 CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE
UTAH 3 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
VERMONT 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
VIRGINIA 3 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
WASHINGTON 2 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
WEST VIRGINIA 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE
WISCONSIN 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
WYOMING 3 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
T
C-26
LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + > (+) (+) (++)
2000 0144 * 0.014 FHV
9611
32601
92054
6.611 0.137 * 0.014 FRV
32601 **
AGRION!DAE}282842
0000
2000 0 137 * 0,014 FHV
2,300 **
32,601
0000
2.000 0.060 * 0014 FRV
2300
32.601
107664
2000 0131 * 0014 FHV
6.611
32.601
107664
2.000 0137 * 0.014 FRV
2.300 *»
0000
0.000
2.000 0.024 * 0014 FRV
2300
32.601
AGRIONIDAE) 282.842
2000 0.063 * 0.014 FRV
2300
32.601
99.553
2000 0137 * 0014 FRV
2300 *•
32601
0,000
- UNITS IN MICHOGRAMS PER LITER
- FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FHV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHHONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: SELENIUM
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 10
ALABAMA 8
ARIZONA 8
ARKANSAS 7
CALIFORNIA 8
COLORADO 7
CONNECTICUT 6
DELAWARE 8
* FLORIDA 8
GEORGIA 8
IDAHO 7
ILLINOIS 8
INDIANA 7
IOWA 8
» KANSAS 7
KENTUCKY 8
LOUISIANA 7
MAINE 5
MARYLAND 7
MASSACHUSETTS 7
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MA>
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
NAME LC50 VALUE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
HYALELLIOAE (TALITHIOAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALGLLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
POECILIIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIOAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIOAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
CYPHINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIOAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
IMUM AND/OR
339.999
1992.474
6499,979
6479 723
339.999
3869.989
7049.606
9002438
339.999
1992474
8479.723
9002.438
339.999
3669989
9002.438
12599.945
339.999
1992474
8479.723
9002.438
339.999
1992.474
7049.606
9002.438
339.999
3869.989
8479.723
9002436
339,999
3869.989
7049.606
12599.945
339999
3869.989
6499.979
12599.945
339999
3869.989
8479.723
12599 945
339.999
1992 474
6479.723
9002.436
339.999
3869.989
7049.608
9002.438
339999
3889.989
7049.606
9002.436
339.999
3669.989
9002.436
12599.945
339.999
3869.989
9002438
12599.945
339.999
3669.989
7049,606
9002438
339.999
3669.989
9002-438
12599.945
339.999
3105.149
3869969
10199.973
339.999
3869.989
8479.723
9002.438
339.999
3869.939
3479.723
9002.438
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+> (•*•) (++»
82648 *
74 102 *
60.162 *
56.854 *
60.162 *
54.887 *
54.260 *
67472 *
67806 *
06,265 *
52.431 *
74.102 *
64.634 *
65.749 *
56.854 *
74102 *
56854 *
46.810 *
62.801 *
62801 *
22.0395 ACR
19.7604 ACfl
16.0431 ACfl
15.1611 ACR
160431 ACR
14.6364 ACR
14.4747 ACR
17.9926 ACR
18.0818 ACR
17.6705 ACR
13.9816 ACR
19,7604 ACR
17.2869 ACR
17.5329 ACR
15.1611 ACR
19 7604 ACR
151611 ACR
12.4826 ACS
18.7469 ACR
16.7469 ACR
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: SELENIUM
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN 3
MINNESOTA 9
. MISSISSIPPI 7
MISSOUR' 1
NEW HAMPSHIRE 6
NEW JERSEY 8
NEW MEXICO 8
NEW YORK 8
NORTH DAKOTA 7
OKLAHOMA 9
RHODE ISLAND 8
SOUTH CA°OLlNA 7
NAME
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE ITALITRIDAE)
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE fTALlTRlDAE}
OAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILHOAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRlDAE)
OAPHNIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
OOECILMOAE
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OAPHNlOAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
POECILIIDAE
HYALELLIOAE fTALITRIDAE)
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIOAE fTALITHIDAE)
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITR1DAE)
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHIN DAE
HYALELLIDAE (TAUTRlDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPfl NIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECIL IDAE
HYALELLIDAE fTALITHIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE fTAUTRlDAEl
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPfllNIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONiOAE
PHYSIDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE fTALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILMDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
r'J?"'TE,JNFTs
FHV
ACR
FCV
scv
TOXICANT; SELENIUM
LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE STATE FAMILIES TESTED M°ST ^NAME^ RESIDEN|[(
1 + ) 1 + ) ( + ) (•*• + )
3669969 DAPHNIDAE
ea79 7Z3 SALMONJOAE
9002.436 CYPfllNIDAE
339 999 81.976 « 21 8601 ACR » TEXAS 6 HYALELLIDAE fTALITHIDAE)
3869989 DAPHNIDAE
8479723 CYPRINIDAE
9002438 POECILIIDAE
339 999 56 654 . 15.161 1 ACR UTAH 7 HYALELUOAEfTALITHIDAE)
3889989 DAPHNIDAE
9002 438 SALMONIDAE
12599945 CYPRINIOAE
339.999 56854 * 15 1611 ACfl VERMONT 6 HYALELLIDAEfTALITRIDAE}
3869989 CYPRINIDAE
9002436 DAPHNIDAE
12599 945 SALMONIDAE
1992474 DAPHNIDAE
9479723 SALMONIDAE
9001438 CYPRINIOAE
1992.474 DAPHNIOAE
8479 723 SALMONIDAE
9002436 PHYSIDAE
1992474 OAPHNIDAE
6479 723 SALMONIDAE
12599.945 CYPHINIDAE
339.999 58 744 * 15,6649 ACR WISCONSIN 7 HYALELLIDAEfTALITRIDAq
3105.149 DAPHNIOAE
3869.969 SALMONIDAE
8479723 CYPRINIDAE
339999 66285 * 176705 ACH WYOMING 7 HYALELLIDAE fTALITHIDAE)
386998 DAPHNIDAE
647972 SALMONIDAE
1259994 CYPRINIDAE
339 999 60 162 * 16 0431 ACR
1992.47
8479.72
9002436
339.999 72.017 * 19.2044 ACfl
3869.969
8479.723
9002438
3869989
8479723
12599.945
339.999 54.867 * 14.6364 ACH
1992 474
7049606
9002438
3869.989
6479.723
9002438
339999 64.085 * 224226 ACR
3669989
7049.606
9002438
1992 474
8479 723
£4099863
3669989
6479 723
9002438
339 999 54 280 * 14 4747 ACR
3669989
8479 723
9002438
339999 57358 » 15.2955 ACR
3869969
8479 723
12599945
1992 474
7048606
9002138
FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OH
SO VALUE MAXIMUM 30- DAY AVERAGE
(+) I*) (+) ( + + )
339 999 74.102 * 19 7604 ACR
3869989
7049606
9002.436
339.999 65.749 * 175329 ACR
3869.989
9002.438
12599.945
339.999 52431 * 13.9816 ACR
1992,474
6479.723
9002,438
339.999 58,744 * 15.6649 ACR
3105 149
3669.989
9479.723
386&9B9
8479 723
9002438
1992474
8479.723
24099.863
3869989
8479.723
9002.436
339.999 62 601 * 16.7469 ACR
3669.989
8479 723
9002.436
339999 52.431 * 13.9816 ACR
199S.474
8479.723
9002.438
C-27
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
OXICANT: SILVER
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 9
ALABAMA S
ARIZONA 5
ARKANSAS 5
CALIFORNIA 5
COLORADO 6
CONNECTICUT 4
DELAWARE 3
FLOHIDA 3
GEORGIA 4
IDAHO 6
ILLINOIS 6
INDIANA 5
IOWA 5
KANSAS 3
KENTUCKY 6
LOUISIANA 3
MAINE 2
MARYLAND 5
MASSACHUSETTS 4
-28
NAME
DAPHN DAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINOOONTIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNtOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPHINIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPR1NIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
CYPRINOOONTIDAE
C6NTRARCHIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
COTT DAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPflIN DAE
SALMONIDAE
com DAE
CYPflIN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHIN DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHIHONOMIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
PHILOD NIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPHIN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
FOOTNOT
LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + ) (J) ( + ) (1) ( + ) I-t-M III
0.002 0 00053 *
0004
0006
0.01Z
0 004 0.00035 *
0011
0,021
0112
0.002 000011 .
0006
0021
0 112
0 004 0 00002 *
0.011
0112
5517
0002 000011 *
0006
0021
0.112
0.002 0.00030 *
0.004
0006
0.021
0011 000006 *
0021
0112
5.517
0.021 0 00053 *
0,112 **
5517
0,000
0012 0.00053 *
0112 **
5517
0.000
0.004 000002 *
0,021
0113
5517
0 002 0.00030 *
0.004
o.ooe
0021
0004 0.00041 *
0011
0021
0112
0 004 0 00035 *
0011
0,021
0112
0011 000021 *
0,112
4 106
5.517
0011 000053 *
0.112 **
5517
0000
0,004 000041 *
0011
0021
0112
0.011 0.00053 *
0.112 **
5517
0000
0.011 000053 *
5517 ».
0.000
0.000
0 004 0 00035 *
0.011
0021
0112
0011 000006 *
0.021
0113
5517
UNITS IN MlCROGRAMS PER LITER
FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: SILVER
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN 6
MINNESOTA 5
H MISSISSIPPI 5
MISSOURI 4
MONTANA 5
NEBRASKA 5
N EVADA 5
NEW HAMPSHIRE 4
NEW JERSEY 3
NEW MEXICO 6
NEW YORK 6
NORTH CAROLINA 3
NORTH DAKOTA 5
OHIO 6
OKLAHOMA 6
OREGON 6
PENNSYLVANIA 5
RHODE ISLAND 4
SOUTH CAROLINA 3
SOUTH DAKOTA 5
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMIL
* — NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
S _ HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM
(+t i« (+) m
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHIHONOMIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPfllNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
COTTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCH1DAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCH10AE
ES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
VI UM ANO'OR
0 004 0 00041
0.011
0.021
0112
0.011 0.00011
0.021
0.112
4.106
0 004 0.00002
0011
0.112
5517
0.004 0.00001
0.011
0.112
5.517
0.002 0.00015
0011
0.021
0.112
0.002 0.00015
0.011
0.021
0112
0002 000003
0,004
0.021
0.112
0.01 1 0.00006
0.021
0.112
5.517
0021 000053
0.112 *
5.517
0.000
0,002 0 00030
0004
0,006
0021
0.004 0.00041
0.011
0.021
0 112
0 021 0 00053
0,112 *
5517
0000
0.002 0.00015
0.011
0021
0.112
0.004 0.00041
0011
0021
0112
0.011 0.00014
0.021
0112
4,106
0.002 0.00026
0004
0004
0.021
0.004 0.00035
0.011
0021
0,112
0.011 0.00006
0021
0 112
5,517
0.021 0 00053
0112 *
5517
0.000
0002 0.00015
0.011
0.021
0.112
ATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
30-DAY AVERAGE
^
*
*
*
*
•*
*
*
*
*
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: SILVER
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
< + ) 0) (-*-) (1) < + ) < + + >
TENNESSEE 6 COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
, TEXAS •> CYPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHILOOINIOAE
UTAH 6 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
VERMONT 4 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
VIRGINIA 4 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
WASHINGTON 6 DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
COTTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
WEST VIRGINIA 5 COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
WISCONSIN 6 COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
WYOMING 6 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
0.004 0.00041 *
0,011
0,021
0112
0.011 000015 *
0.112
4.106
5.517
0.002 0 00030 *
0004
0006
0021
0.01 1 0 00006 *
0.021
0112
5517
0011 000006 .
0021
0112
5517
0 002 0.00026 *
0.004
0.004
0.021
0.004 0 00035 *
0.011
0.021
0112
0.004 000041 *
0.011
0.021
0.112
0.002 000030 *
0004
0.006
0021
<-'. 1 HNAL CMPONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 12
ALABAMA 7
ARIZONA 11
ARKANSAS 8
CALIFORNIA 9
COLORADO 9
CONNECTICUT 7
DELAWARE 8
* FLORIDA 6
GEORGIA 6
IDAHO 10
ILLINOIS 9
INDIANA 8
IOWA 9
N KANSAS 6
KENTUCKY 7
LOUISIANA 7
MAINE 7
MARYLAND 8
MASSACHUSETTS 8
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME LOGO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+> <+) (+1 I + + I
PERLIOAE
PTEHONAR.CIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PEHLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERCIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PEHLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCIDAE
CENTRAHCH10AE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
* "- FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
* * _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
» - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
1.300 0.537 *
2.627
4.725
3,547 1.159 *
4.725
8.033
8.190
1.300 0.582 *
2.627
2,648
3347
3.000 0.841 *
4.725
8.033
1.300 0.445 *
2.848
3547
5,781
1.300 0.525 *
2.627
2.848
3547
2.848 0913 *
6678
7429
12000
2.848 1,084 *
4 193
5.351
6.782
4.193 0.960 *
4.725
6.782
14.379
3347 1.065 *
4.725
8.129
9963
1.300 0564 *
2.627
2.848
3.000
3.547 1.321 »
4725
4944
8.033
3347 1.284 *
4.725
4.944
8.033
2346 0780 *
3.000
3347
8.033
2.848 0.631 *
3.547
8.033
12000
3547 1-265 *
4725
5.251
8.033
3.547 1.187 *
4725
8.033
8,672
2.000 0.561 *
6.165
6.550
12.000
2.6-16 0.775 *
3000
7 128
8.033
2646 0.919 *
3.547
6.678
7429
0.0087 ACR
0 0188 ACR
0 0091 ACH
00152 ACH
0.0072 ACH
0.0085 ACfl
0.0148 ACR
0.0176 ACR
0.0159 ACR
0.0173 ACR
0.0091 ACR
00214 ACR
0 0208 ACR
0.0126 ACR
0.0102 ACR
0.0205 ACR
0.0193 ACR
00094 ACR
0.0126 ACH
0.0149 ACR
C-29
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: TOXAPHENE
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN 9
MINNESOTA 6
« MISSISSIPPI f
MISSOURI 7
MONTANA 10
NEBRASKA 7
NEVADA 10
NEW HAMPSHIRE 7
NEW JERSEY 6
NEW MEXICO 10
NEW YORK 9
NORTH CAROLINA 6
NORTH DAKOTA 8
OHIO 9
OKLAHOMA 8
OREGON a
PENNSYLVANIA 9
RHODE ISLAND 7
SOUTH CAROLINA 6
SOUTH DAKOTA 9
C-30
NAME
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
ENTflAHCHIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPP.INIDAE
PEHLIDAE
PTEHONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
ICTALURIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PEHLIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPHIN DAE
ICTALURIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPH1NIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPflIN DAE
PERCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCIOAE
PERLIDAE
CENTflARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POOTN
LCSO VALUE
( + )
2846
3,547
5.761
8.033
2646
3547
5.223
6033
3.547
4725
8.033
1 4.379
3.000
3-547
4.725
3033
1 300
2.827
2,648
3547
2.643
3547
6.676
9033
28*6
3.000
3.547
6678
2.846
6.165
6676
12.000
2646
4 193
6676
6782
1.300
2627
3.547
4.725
3.547
4.725
S223
8,033
3,000
4725
6,678
8129
2,848
3.547
8.033
9.190
3.547
4.725
6.676
6.033
3.547
4.725
8,033
9,190
2646
3.000
5781
7.210
3547
4725
6.678
8433
2.648
6676
7429
12000
4725
8.129
9.963
12000
1300
2848
3547
5.251
- UNTSIN MICHOGRA
- FP FINAL PLANT
AC COMPUTED B
FC FINAL CHRON
TOXICANT: TOXAPHENE
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) [+) (++) (+) <+) (+) <-HO
0943 * 00153 ACR TENNESSEE 8 ICTALURIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
0907 * 0.0147 ACR * TEXAS 8 ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERCIDAE
0.907 * 00147 ACH UTAH 10 PEHLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
0 906 * 0.0147 ACR VERMONT 7 CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PERCIDAE
0.543 * 0.0068 ACR VIRGINIA 7 CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPfllNIOAE
PERCIDAE
0,65-. * 0 0136 ACR WASHINGTON 10 PERLIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
CENTflARCHIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
0914 * 0,0146 ACR WEST VIRGINIA 6 CENTHAHCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
0.886 * 0.0144 ACR WISCONSIN 9 CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
1 045 * 00169 ACH WYOMING 10 PERLIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
0494 * 0.0080 ACR
1 340 * 00217 ACR
1.093 * 0.0177 ACR
0,606 * 00131 ACR
1.359 * 0.0220 ACR
1206 * 00196 ACH
0850 * 0,0138 ACR
1.330 * 0.0216 ACH
09)3 * 00148 ACR
1 700 * 00276 ACR
0.464 * 00075 ACR
MS PER LITER • - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
E VALUE II — NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD J - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
C VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
3,547 U04 * 0.0212 ACR
4.725
5.251
8.033
3.547 1.059 * 0.0172 ACR
4.725
8.433
12.000
1.300 0.543 * 0,0038 ACR
2.627
2.648
3.547
2.848 0,866 * 0.0144 ACR
6.165
6676
12000
4.725 1.643 * 0,0267 ACR
6.676
6,033
12.000
1.300 0.554 * 0.0090 ACR
2.300
2.848
3.000
2.648 0.812 * 0,0132 ACR
3.547
6.678
B.033
2.848 0.943 * 0.0153 ACR
3.547
5.781
6.033
1300 0543 * 0.0088 ACR
2627
2.846
3.547
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: ZINC
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE
< + ) (1)
NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
ALABAMA 12 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
ARIZONA 11 DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
ARKANSAS 10 OAPHN DAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRIN1DAE
CALIFORNIA It OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
COLORADO 10 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILOOINIOAE
CONNECTICUT 13 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DELAWARE 13 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
* FLORIDA 12 OAPHNIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CVPRINODONTIDAE
GEORGIA it DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDA6
IDAHO 9 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODNIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
ILLINOIS 13 OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHY1DAE
INDIANA 13 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
IOWA 1 1 DAPHN DAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
• KANSAS 10 DAPHN DAE
PHYSIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
KENTUCKY 12 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
LOU'S1 AN* it DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PEHClCHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
MAINE 13 DAPHN DAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
VAP'^ANO ij OAPHNlOAE
PHVSlDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHiLOD NIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
tOOTNO
13737
41966
48.881
92.757
21 223
26243
41 966
49264
13737
49264
49969
92757
21.223
41 966
S2757
266588
13737
47 229
49264
92 757
13737
36672
41966
92.757
21.223
41 966
51845
92757
21 223
28243
41966
92757
21.223
41.966
49264
64667
21.223
41.966
46550
49,264
13.737
41 218
92757
270655
21 223
36.699
41 966
49264
21 223
36899
41,966
21.223
41 966
92.757
266 568
21.223
41 966
49264
92.757
21223
26243
41966
49284
21.223
41966
49264
81416
21223
41*36
73017
92757
21 223
41966
56085
92767
21.223
41 966
61 645
92757
H
UNITS IN MICROG
FPV FINAL PLAN
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + ) (*) ( + ) I+ + )
6148 470000 SCV
8.395 47 0000 SCV
5083 470000 SCV
4593 • 470000 SCV
5043 470000 SCV
4,468 47 0000 SCV
8.451 47.0000 SCV
6,627 470000 SCV
9 165 * 470000 SCV
9488 * 470000 SCV
2 702 47.0000 SCV
9829 470000 SCV
9829 470000 SCV
4992 * 470000 SCV
7336 * 470000 SCV
8 395 47 0000 SCV
6 135 * 470000 SCV
8.532 47 0000 SCV
8,523 47 0000 SCV
8451 470000 SCV
AWS PER LITER
T VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: ZINC
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN 12
MINNESOTA 12
» MISSISSIPPI 11
MISSOURI 11
MONTANA 10
NEBRASKA 11
NEVADA 10
NEW HAMPSHIRE 13
NEW JERSEY 13
NEW MEXICO 12
NEW YORK 13
NORTH CAROLINA 13
NORTH DAKOTA 11
OHIO 12
OKLAHOMA 12
OREGON 10
PENNSYLVANIA 13
RHODE ISLAND u
SOUTH CAROLINA 12
SOUTH DAKOTA 12
• - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + ) fit 1 + ) (SI ( + 1 u.j.1
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PEflCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
OAPHNIOAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOOINIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM ANDIOR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
21.223 7,891
92J57
21.223 7.440
36.872
41.966
92.757
21.223 7.684
41.966
49.264
92.757
21.223 7.684 *
49.264
92.757
13.737 4677
56.455
92,757
13.737 5799 *
41.966
46.550
49,264
13.737 3446
49969
92.757
251.461
21.223 8.408
41.966
50.064
92.757
21.223 8.298
41.966
46450
92.757
13.737 6.035
41.966
49.284
49.969
21.223 8056
41.278
41.966
92.757
21.223 8.298
41.966
46450
92757
13737 4146
26.243
41.966
92.757
21.223 7.951
41966
46450
92757
21.223 8 395
26.243
41.966
49.264
13.737 4.744
47.229
49.264
92757
21 223 8.405
41 966
49.969
92757
21.223 8.451
41,966
518^5
92757
21 223 7.951 *
41 966
46550
92757
13 737 4.399
26.243
41 966
92.757
47.0000
47.0000
470000
47.0000
47.0000
47.0000
47.0000
47.0000
47.0000
47.0000
470000
47.0000
47.0000
47.0000
470000
470000
47.0000
47.0000
47.0000
47.0000
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
C-31
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: ZINC
STATE
TENNESSEE
« TEXAS
UTAH
VERMONT
VIRGINIA
WASHINGTON
WEST VIRGINIA
WISCONSIN
WYOMING
FAMILIES TESTED NAME
12 DAPHNlDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
11 DAPHNlDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
10 DAPHNlDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
13 OAPHNlDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
13 DAPHNlDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
9 DAPHNlDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
11 OAPHNlDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
12 OAPHNlDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
10 DAPHNIOAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM
( + ) (D ( + ) 10
21.223 8.395
26243
41 966
49264
21.223 7684 *
41 966
49264
92.757
13737 4780
49.264
92.757
21 223 6.451
41.966
51 845
92.757
21 223 B.298
41.966
46.550
92.757
13.737 2.652
47.229
92757
315.021
21 .223 7 606
41.966
46.550
92757
21 223 7 691
41.966
44.947
92.757
13.737 4647
41.966
49.969
92.757
30-DAY AVERAGE
(•»•) (++)
47 0000 SCV
47 0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47 0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47 0000 SCV
- UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
- FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRY FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
— FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
— STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES—NATIONAL VALUE USED
— NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
- HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: ALABAMA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDE
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME
ALDHIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELL DAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
ABSENlC NATIONAL 6 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 5 OAPHNIOAE
SALMONIOAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMWAfllOAE
PHYSIOAE
STATE 14 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PTEHONAHCIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIOAE
C-aOVUV NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHN DAE
PHILODINIOAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 PHiLODINIDAE
PHYSTDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
S COPPER N*T CNA(_ 23 DAPHNIDAE
CH1RONOMIOAE
PHYSIOAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 17 DAPHN DAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSiDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CENTHARCHIOAE
PERCiDAE
STATE f, SAL'/ONJDiE
DAPHNlOAE
CfPBiN OAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMAR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: ALABAMA STATE: ARIZONA
(+1 (+» l*> <++)
PHYSIDAE 41 966 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48 861 EPHEMERELL1DAE
PHILODINIOAE 92 757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHN DAE 21 223 8395 470000 SCV STATE 10 SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE 26 243 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41 966 EPHEMEHELUDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE 49 264 PERCICHTHYIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SS CADMIUM NATIONAL 16 SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 13 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 7 PTGflONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 7 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SS COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIOAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIOAE
PLANORBIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PEHCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CENTflARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIOAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAfc
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 9 SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
EPHEMEHELUDAE
CENTRARCHIDAG
GNDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARC10AE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTEHONAHCIDAE
POECILIIOAe
c:C"SOTE * - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
(-*-) < + ) ( + ) ( + + )
8.000
9.000
10.803
4.503 1 926 *
7.451
9.000
10.000
876.999 1 13 263 *
1794245
14128.643
16487.430
1794.245 407358 *
14128.643
16487.430
19484.936
0.048 0 027 0.0004 ACR
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.034 0.010 00001 ACR
0.163
0.496
6325 1974 * 0.0043 FRV
15.000
23238
32249
15,000 5.771 * 0.0043 FRV
23236
26.000
33.862
67.000 12.164 0.3378 ACR
6399.976
6998.790
24892.828
6399.976 1140647 * 10.0 FPV
6996790
29999.867
30454.750
0.305 0.194 5.46618 FCV
0.759
0.995
1345
0.305 0.128 3.77456 FCV
0.759
1345
1.424
76.707 31 429 * 4.2472 ACR
83.000
114,316
125121
76.707 28,920 * 39081 ACR
83000
114,316
125.121
1.333 0,650 0.0010 FRV
1.595
1.700
2,234
1.323 0.479 0.0010 FRV
1.595
3.000
3.262
4503 1.830 * 0,0019 FfW
5.000
5 432
8.000
2459 0.788 * 0.0019 FRV
4503
8.000
10.811
0.664 0,208 * 0 1064 ACR
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664 0 184 * 0.0944 ACR
1279
2.300
3700
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: ARIZONA
STATE: ARIZONA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME
SALMONIDAE
PERLIOAE
PTERONARODAE
STATE 10 SALMONIOAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
POEC LIIDAE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 8 PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SI LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPR NIOAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCH1DAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIOAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 5 OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
W NICKEL NATIONAL 16 OAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 11 OAPHNIOAE
PERC CHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL •• SALMONIOAE
CENTRAHCHIOAE
CYPHINlOAE
GAMMARIOAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPfilNIDAE
LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY
0440 0,201 * 00023
0468
0493
0647
0357 DIM * 00023
0493
0647
0949
0995 0251 * 00038
1 800
2800
7.BOO
0995 0 142 * 00038
2800
13058
26000
1 161 0037 * 000003
80062
358792
4 020 0 359 * 0 00003
80062
358792
455,015
21988
22437
52871
14156 5119 * 04095
42198
48000
53066
5,000 0470 * 020
10000
31 623
244259
5.000 0101 * 0.0671
10000
248595
783471
65077 32.914 * 33931
233.555
345472
401217
76456 31618 * 32596
301510
325642
401.217
2000 0137 * 0.014
6611
32601
99553
2000 0054 * 0114
6611
32601
COENAGRIONIDAE [AGRIONIDAEi 282 842
DAPHN DAE
CYPRINOOONTIOAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
I S'L /£« NATIONAL 9 OAPHNIDAE
COTTIOAE
CYPfli NIDAE
CYPHINOOONTIDAE
STATE 5 COTTlOAi
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
TO/APHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 1 ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EQOTNOT
1992 474
6499979
8479723
3869989
7049606
9002438
0002 000053 *
0004
0006
0012
0004 0.00035 *
0011
0021
0112
1300 OS37 * 00067
2627
3547
4725
3547 1 159 • 001B8
4 725
8033
9*90
E
UNITS IN MlCHOORAMS PER LITER
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
FCV HfjAL CHRONIC VALUE
-=E ,OX,C,NT «s!5KSn """asr™""?
FRV J ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
FHV STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
fm PERCICHTHYIDAE
FHV
FCV
FCV
ACR
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACH
FRV
FfiV
ACR
ACR
• - - SrATE°HA0S JsS THA'N 4 Rt°SIDENTEFAMIL.ES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
APPLV EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
:« VALUE «™K!*TER *2SJr UFE CAVERME
13.737 6.148 470000 SCV
41966
48,661
92.757
21.223 8395 470000 SCV
28543
41,966
49.264
D-3
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: ARKANSAS
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 6 CENTRARCHIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMON DAE
ICTALURIOAE
STATE 5 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
» CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMON DAE
DAPHNIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
CHLOROANE NATIONAL 6 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPH1N DAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPR1N DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 5 GAMMAH DAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
COPPEfl NATIONAL 23 DAPHN DAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFIC DAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFIC DAE
OAPHN DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHN DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERODAE
ESOQDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 9 OAPHN DAE
ASTAC10AE
PALAEMONIDAE
ASELLIDAE
DIELOHIN NATIONAL 12 POECIL IDAE
ASELLIOAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
STATE 6 ASELLIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMON10AE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
CATOSTOMlDAE
STATE 4 CYPHINlOAE
CATOSTOMlDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
:
D-d 1
LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + ) ( + ) (•*•) (+-O
8000
9000
10603
7 451 2 181 *
16000
16392
878999 113263 *
1794245
14128643
16467 430
878999 42377 *
1046 139
16487 430
19464936
0046 0027 00004 ACH
0496
2860
0664 0211 • 00034 ACR
1 147
2660
6987
6325 1 974 * 0.0043 FHV
15000
23238
32,249
6325 1 974 * 00043 FHV
23 236 * *
54711
0,000
6399976
6998790
24892 626
67000 2505 * 00695 ACR
6998790
24692 826
57461 672
0305 0194 546618 FCV
0759
0995
1 345
0759
0995
1 345
83000
114316
125 121
83000 27587 * 37279 ACH
114316
167000
207958
1 595
1 700
2234
0976 0355 00010 FRV
2409
3234
4000
4503 1 630 * 0X19 FRV
5000
5452
8000
5000 1 207 * 00019 FRV
10811
20X0
30102
1 279
2300
3240
1.279 0036 * 00185 ACR
3240
381)
- UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
PCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCv SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: ARKANSAS
NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ENDHIN NATIONAL 17
STATE 10
HEPTACHLOR
STATE 5
SJ LEAD NATIONAL 7
STATE 4
LINDANE NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
NATIONAL 9
STATE 4
II NICKEL NATIONAL 16
STATE 4
STATE 7
S SILVER NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
STATE 8
NAME LCSO VALUE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTEHONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIOAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
0440
0.468
0.493
0.647
0.732
0.750
1.011
1.265
1.800
2.800
7800
1.600
7.800
24.771
50.748
1.161
4020
80.062
358.792
1 161
358.792
455,015
803.845
10.000
21.968
22,437
52.871
2.000
10.000
52.871
53.066
5.000
10000
31.823
244.259
10000
20.000
763.471
65.077
233.555
345472
401217
325.842
401.217
439 925
6.811
32.601
99.553
6,611
32601
92054
COENAGHION1DAE[AGRIONIDAE) 282.842
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINVDONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE(TALITRIDAE)
OAPHN IDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
com DAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
JJ _ HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
1992.474
6499.979
8479 723
339.999
3869.969
9002438
2599.945
0002
0.004
0.006
0012
0,004
0.01
0,11
5.51
1.30
2.62
3.54
4.725
3.000
3.547
4.725
8,033
MAXIMUM
0,201 *
0.263 *
0502 *
0.037 »
0035 *
3518 *
0.245 *
0470 *
0.170 *
32.914 *
'
0,520 *
*
56.854 *
0.00053
0,00002
0.537 *
0.941 *
30-DAY
0.0023
0.0023
0.0038
0.0038
0.00003
0.00003
0.2574
00195
0.20
0.1133
3.3931
0.014
'
15.1611
*
0.0087
0.0152
AVERAGE
FHV
FRV
FRV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACR
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: ARKANSAS STATE: CALIFORNIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LOW VALUE MAXIMUM M-DAY AVERAGE
1 + ) (•*•) (+) l-t-t-l
$ ZINC NATIONAL 15 OAPHN DAE 13 737 6 148 * 47,0000 SCV ALDHIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHYS10AE 41966 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48 881 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE 92 757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE 21.223 4.593 * 47 0000 SCV STATE 9 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41 966 EPHEMERELL10AE
PHILOOINIDAE 92 757 PERCICHTHYJOAE
CYPR1NIDAE 266 568 SAUMONIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMON IOAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
SI CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 14 SALMONIDAE
PERC1CHTMYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIOAE
PTEHONAflCIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 6 CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 7 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
S COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TU8IFICIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHN10AE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 8 POECILIIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECIL1IOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CQO'NOTE • - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
, . - ff, FINAL PLANT VALUF I - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3,7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 3Q.DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
( + ) (•*•) ( + 1 (++)
7.451 3.358 *
8,000
9.000
7,451 3.383 *
9,000
10000
10603
876.999 1 13.263 *
1 794.245
14128.643
16467430
14128643
16487430
19464938
0.048 0.027 0.0004 ACR
0.496
1.147
2660
0.048 0015 0.0002 ACR
0,163
0.496
1.147
6325 1974 * 0.0043 FRV
15000
23238
32.249
23.238 7.044 * 0.0043 FRV
26.000
43739
54.711
67.000 12.164 0.3378 ACR
6399.976
6998.790
24892.826
6399.976 1140.647 * 10.0 FPV
6996.790
29999.867
30454.750
0.305 0.194 5.46616 FCV
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.305 0.128 2.74195 FCV
0.759
1.345
1.401
76.707 31.429 * 4.2472 ACR
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707 19.582 * 2.6462 ACR
83.000
114.316
207.958
1.323 0.650 0.0010 FHV
1 595
1.700
2^34
1.323 0.442 * 0.0010 FRV
3.000
3.282
6.921
4.503 1.830 * 0 0019 FRV
5.000
5.452
6.000
4.503 1.544 * 0.0019 FRV
5452
8,000
10611
0,664 0.208 * 0.1064 ACR
1.279
2.300
3,240
0.664 0.155 * 00793 ACR
1.279
3.700
3.811
D-5
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: CALIFORNIA
NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ENORIN NATIONAL 17
STATE 10
STATE 7
SI LEAD NATIONAL 7
STATE 6
LINOANE NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
MERCURY NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
NICKEL NATIONAL 16
STATE 10
PC0S NATIONAL 5
STATE 3
SELENIUM NATIONA 10
STATE 5
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12
STATE 9
D-8
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
GASTEROSTEIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARC1DAE
GASTEHOSTEIOAE
SALMONIOAE
PERLIDAE
POSCILIIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PERLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRlN DAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHIN DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAG
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMON DAE
PHILOD NIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
SALMON DAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPRlNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMON DAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
CYPRlNIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHN I DAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRlN DAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRlN DAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRlN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
0.440
0468
0.493
0647
0440
0468
0493
0949
1,800
2600
7800
2.800
26.000
29000
29,498
1 161
4020
80062
358792
4020
60,062
358792
455,015
10000
21 988
22.437
52871
21.988
42198
48.000
53.066
5000
10,000
31623
244,259
5.000
10000
244.259
783471
65.077
233,555
345472
401217
65077
301 510
401.217
439825
2000
6.611
32601
99553
2.000
2300
32,601
0000
1992 474
6499.979
6479 723
1992,474
8479 723
9002,438
0.004
0006
0.012
0002
0.006
0021
0112
1300
2627
3547
4725
1.300
2.646
3547
5781
UNITS IN MICROGRA
- FPV FINAL PLANT
FHV FINAL RESIOU
ACS COMPUTED BY
STATE: CALIFORNIA
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
0 201 * 0.0023 FHV S 2INC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDA6
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0144 * 0.0023 FRV STATE 11 DAPHNIDA6
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
*
0698 * 00038 FRV
0037 * 000003 FCV
0359 » 0,00003 FCV
3216 * 02574 ACR
8.518 * 0,6814 ACR
0470 * 020 FRV
0.101 * 0,0674 ACR
32.914 + 33931 ACR
23.365 * 2.4087 ACH
0.137 * 0.014 FHV
0137 * 0.014 FRV
82648 * 220395 ACR
*
*
000011 *
0537 * 0.0087 ACR
0445 * 00072 ACR
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
ALUE S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETF.HMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
13.737 6.14B 47.0000 SCV
41.966
48,861
92.757
13.737 5.043 47.0000 SCV
47.229
49.264
92.757
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: COLORADO
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME
ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELL OAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPHINIOAE
ARSENIC NAT.ONAL 6 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
SI CADMIUM NATIONAL '6 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARlOAE
PHYSIDAE
OLQRDANE NATIONAL 6 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 6 PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CHRQMIUW NATIONAL 10 GAMMAHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
PHkODlNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
S COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIF1C1DAE
STATE 13 OAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
C'A*! DE NATIONAL >0 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
DC" NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMAfllDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
SALMONIDAE
ASELL DAE
SALMONlOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMEflELLiDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
ENDOSULPAN --ATONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
PTERONARC1DAE
CATOSTOMIOAE
STATE e SALMONlOAE
CVPRlNIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
'CO-NO-
LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30. DAY AVERAGE
(+) 1+) (+) (++)
7451 3386 *
6000
9000
10603
4 503 1 433 *
7451
16,392
876999 113,263 *
1794,245
14128643
16487 430
1794245 407285 *
13339 965
16467430
19464938
0046 0027 * 00004 ACR
0496
1 147
2860
0044 0.012 00002 ACR
0496
1 147
2360
6 325 1 974 * 0.0043 FRV
15000
23238
32249
15 000 6 226 * 0,0043 FHV
23236
25481
26000
67000 12.164 03376 ACR
6399976
6996790
24892.826
6399976 761038 * 100 FPV
6998.790
24892 826
57461672
0.305 0194 5.46618 FCV
0759
0995
1 345
0305 0)33 9.85862 FCV
0.759
1 309
76 707 31 429 * 4 2472 ACR
83.000
114316
125121
57 000 15 459 * 2 0690 ACR
83000
114,316
207956
1 323 0.850 00010 FRV
1 595
1 700
2234
1 323 0510 * 0.0010 FHV
3000
3096
4878
4503 1 830 * 00019 FRV
5.000
5452
8000
2459 0632 * 00019 FRV
8.000
10811
24000
0664 0208 * 01064 ACR
1 279
2300
3240
0684 0 196 * 0.1003 ACH
1 279
2300
3240
'JN'TO (N MICROGRAMS PER LITEH
**••/ HNAL PLANT VALUE
FBV PiNAL RESIDUE VALUE
ecv FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: COLORADO
Tnv.*.UT ,- NUMBEn OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 9 SALMONIDAE
PEHLIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTEflONAHCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 7 PTEflONAflCIDAE
PEflLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
GAMMAfllDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
» NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 9 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 SALMONIDAE
CENTRAflCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELUOAEfTALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPH1NODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 7 HYALELLIOAEfTALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
$ SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
STATE 9 PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCH 1 DAE
ICTALURIDAE
• * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
0.440 0201 * 0.0023 FRV
0,466
0.493
0.647
0.320 0.112 * 0.0023 FRV
0.493
1.011
0.995 0.251 * 0 0038 FRV
1300
2.800
7.300
0.995 0125 * 0.0038 FRV
2300
13.058
26.000
1.161 0.037 * 0.00003 FCV
4.020
60.062
356792
4.020 0.325 * 0.00003 FCV
158 156
358.792
455.015
10.000 3.218 * 0.2574 ACR
21.9S8
22.437
52.671
8.004 2.320 * 0 1856 ACR
42.198
46000
53.066
10000
31.623
244259
5.000 0.101 * 0.0671 ACH
10.000
246.595
783,471
65.077 32.914 * 3.3931 ACR
233.555
345.472
401.217
65 077 21.349 * 2.2009 ACR
401.217
439.825
509.264
2000 0.137 * 0.014 FRV
6611
32.601
99553
2.000 0.137 * 0014 FRV
2.300 **
32.601
339999 82,646 * 220395 ACR
1992.474
6499.979
8479.723
339.999 54.687 * 146364 ACR
1992.474
7049.606
9002.438
0.002 0.00053 *
0.004
0.006
0,012
0.002 0.00030 *
0004
0006
0.021
1 300 0 537 * 0 0087 ACR
2627
3.547
4.725
1 300 0 525 * 0 0085 ACR
2627
2643
3.547
D-7
-------
APPENDIX 0
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: COLORADO
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
OAPHNIOAE
SALMONJDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE: CONNECTICUT
NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ALDH1N NATIONAL
STATE
ARSENIC NATIONAL
STATE
SI CADMIUM NATIONAL
STATE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL
STATE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL
STATE
$ COPPER NATIONAL
STATE
CYANIDE NATIONAL
STATE
DDT NATIONAL
STATE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL
STATE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL
STATE
14
9
a
4
18
16
8
10
6
23
18
10
6
20
7
12
6
9
G
MOST SENSITIVE RESfPENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
< + ) (+) (+) <++(
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMAftlOAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUGIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMAfllDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONtDAE
CYPHINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
7451 3.386 *
8.000
9.000
10.803
4.503 1.520 *
7.451
9.000
16.000
878.999 113.263 *
1794.245
14128.043
16487.430
1048.139 141 620 *
14128643
19484.938
20194.383
0.048 0.027 *
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.034 0.019
O.S64
1.147
1.630
6.325 1.974 *
15000
23.238
32.24S
33.238 7.875 *
33.882
40.000
54.711
67.000 12.164
6399.978
8998.790
24692.828
8998.790 1692459 *
24892.828
30454.750
57461 672
0.305 0.194
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256 0.139
0.759
0.995
1345
76.707 31.429 *
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707 28920 *
83.000
114,316
125.121
1.323 0.650
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.976 0.318 *
1.595
1.884
3.006
4.503 1.330 *
5.000
5.452
8.000
2 459 0.471 *
8.000
14.460
30.102
0.664 0.208 *
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664 0.149 *
1.279
3.240
3811
0.0004 ACfl
0.0003 ACfl
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.46618 FCV
7.43115 FCV
4.2472 ACfl
3.9081 ACR
00010 FRV
00010 FRV
00019 FRV
00019 FRV
0 1064 ACR
0 0762 ACR
- UNITS
ACR
SCv
IN MICRO-GRAMS PER LITER
FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
SENS.T . £ SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
• * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE L
APPLY EQUATION 37 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30 DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
SEO
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: CONNECTICUT
NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ENOHlN NATIONAL 17
STATE 9
STATE 5
SS LEAD NATIONAL 7
STATE 4
UNDANE NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
MERCURY NATIONAL 9
STATS 5
SI NICKEL NATIONAL 16
STATE 12
PCBS NATIONAL 5
STATE 5
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAM
NAME LC50V
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARC1DAE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
AST AC DAE
SALMONIDAE 1
CENTRARCHIOAE 21
GAMMARIOAE 4
DAPHNIDAE 5<
GAMMARlDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE 8(
CYPHINIDAE 35J
SALMONIDAE 8<
CYPRIN 10 A E 351
CENTRARCHIDAE 45,
PHILODINIDAE 80,
ASELLIDAE 1
SALMONIDAE 2
GAMMARlDAE 2
CENTRARCHIDAE 5,
GAMMARlDAE 1
SALMONIOAE 1
CENTRARCHIDAE 4
PEHCIDAE 6f
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARlDAE 1
ASTACIDAE 3
SALMONIDAE 24'
GAMMARIOAE 1
ASTACIDAE 5t
SALMONIDAE 24f
PHI LOO NIDAE 76,
DAPHNIDAE 6,
EPHEMERELLIDAE 23,
CENTRARCHIDAE 34
PHILODINIDAE 40
OAPHNIDAE 7
PHILODINIDAE 40
CHIHONOMIDAE 43,
CENTRAHCHIDAE 44<
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE 3
GAMMARIOAE 9f
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPRIN DAE 3
LY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE
LUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY
+) (+) {+)
440 0201 * 00023
468
493
647
440 0 153 * 0.0023
556
011
086
BOO
800
800
056 3.521 * 00036
.000
329
748
161 0037 * 000003
020
062
792
062 14969 • 000003
792
015
.845
000 3-218 * 02574
988
437
871
483 1 829 * 0 1463
158
198
000
,000 0.470 * 020
000
623
259
000 0.629 * 020
000
595
471
.077 32914 * 3.3931
.555
.472
217
456 33,128 * 3,4152
217
825
717
,000 0,137 * 0.014
,611
601
553
.000 0.060 * 0.014
300
601
GAMMARlDAE 107664
DAPHNIDAE 1992474
ST*TE 6
SS 5>L./e» NATIONAL fl
STATE 4
HA ON L 2
STATE 7
CYPHINODONTIDAE 64^
SALMONIDAE B47<
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRTDAE) 33
DAPHNIDAE 386
SALMONIDAE 847
CYPRIN DAE 900'
DAPHNIDAE
COTTlOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CfPRiNIDAE
SALMOniOAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
,979
.723
.999 54260 * 144747
.969
723
438
002 0 00053 *
004
006
,012
.011 000006 *
021
112
PHILODINIDAE 5517
PTERONARClDAE 2 627
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE t
CENTRARCHIDAE t
SALMONIDAE (
CYPRINIDAE
725
848 0913 * 00148
429
STATE: CONNECTICUT
CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT
( + +•)
FRV S ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
FRV STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
FRV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FHV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACH
*
ACR
AMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
13.737 8148 * 470000 SCV
48.661
92.757
21.223 6.451 * 470000 SCV
41,966
51 645
92757
PEPC1DAE 12000
- NiTS IN MiCROORAMS PER LITER
. - - t-/ FINAL PLANT VALUF
HI FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
<-„« COMPUTED 8Y ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO MET
CV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
CV SENSiT
VE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
• - - STATE HAS L SS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
J - HARDNESS E FECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUA ON 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
HOD H' - HARDNESS E FECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EOUA ON 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVER GE CRITERIA
D-9
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: DELAWARE
STATE: DELAWARE
ALDRIN NATIONAL 14
STATE 9
ARSENIC NATIONAL 6
STATE 5
« CADMIUM NATIONAL 18
STATE 17
CHLOHDANE NATIONAL 8
STATE 4
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
I COPPER NATIONAL 23
STATE 18
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
DDT NATIONAL 20
STATE 9
DIELORIN NATIONAL 12
STATE 6
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
D-10
CENTHARCHIDAE
ASELLIOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHN OAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTEHONARCIDAE
CYPHINIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPHIN DAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHVSIDAE
TUBIFIC DAE
DAPHN DAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
DAPHN DAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
AST AC DAE
POECILI DAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTEHONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
:.-
7451 3388 *
8000
9.000
10.803
4 503 1 796 *
9000
11.314
878,999 113263 *
1794245
14128,643
16487430
1046.139 171,818 *
13339.965
16487430
19484938
0,048 0,027 0,0004 ACR
0496
1 147
2860
0.044 0027 00004 ACR
0,884
1 147
1630
6.325 1974 * 00043 FRV
15,000
23238
32.249
15.884 4120 * 0.0043 FRV
25.481
40.000
54.711
67.000 12.164 0 3378 ACR
6399.978
6998.790
24892.628
6998 790 1538 742 * 10.0 FPV
24892,828
30454750
68999781
0.305 0194 546618 FCV
0759
0995
1.345
0256 0142 8.30804 FCV
0.759
0995
1 022
76 707 31 429 * 4 2472 ACR
83.000
114.316
125.121
57 000 21 460 * 2.8999 ACR
83000
114.316
125.121
1 323 0650 00010 FRV
1,595
2.234
0976 0.344 * 00010 FRV
1 595
3000
4,503 1.830 * 0.0019 FRV
5.000
5.452
8,000
2459 0382 * 00019 FRV
8.000
0 684 0.208 * 0 1064 ACH
1 279
2300
0664 0147 * 00751 ACR
6000
UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
FHV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17 GASTEHOSTEIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PERLIDAE
PTEHONARCIDAE
STATE 10 GASTEROSTEIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SS LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMAHIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPfllNIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
GAMMAHIOAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
MERCUHY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMAHIOAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 5 GAMMAHIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
$1 NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
0440 0,201 * 0,0023 FHV
0468
0493
0647
0440 0.184 * 00023 FHV
0.750
1 011
0.995 0.251 * 0.0038 FHV
1.800
2,800
7600
13056 3.521 * 00038 FHV
26.000
47329
50748
1 161 0.037 r 0.00003 FCV
4.020
80062
358792
158,156 36.495 * 0.00004 FCV
455 015
803.845
614803
10.000 3.218 * 0 2574 ACH
21.988
22.437
52871
8 004 1 498 * 0 1 198 ACR
10.488
42.198
44.000
5,000 0.470 * 0.20 FHV
10000
31.623
244.259
10000 0629 * 020 FRV
50000
248.595
783.471
65 077 32.914 * 3,3931 ACH
233,555
345472
401.217
78456 33128 * 34152 ACR
401.217
439,825
444717
2000 0 137 * 0014 FHV
6.611
32.601
99.553
2000 0.020 * 0.014 FHV
2,300
107.664
COENAGRIONIDAE(AGRIONIDAE) 282.842
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339 999 82.646 * 22.03S5 ACH
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 8 HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
S SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 3 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE
PTEHONAHCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 8 CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
« - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
S — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
1992 474
6499979
8479 723
339 999 67.472 * 17,9926 ACH
3869989
7049.606
2599.945
0002 000053 *
0.012
0.021 0.00053 *
0,112 **
5.517
1.300 0.537 * 0.0087 ACR
2627
3.547
4.725
2.648 1,084 * 0.0176 ACH
4193
5,251
6,782
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: DELAWARE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMON I DAE
PHILOOIN1DAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
13737
41966
46.661
92757
21223
26243
41966
92757
STATE: FLORIDA
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
Si CADMIUM
CHLOHOANE
S COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE 1
FAMILIES TESTED NAME
NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 6 CENTRARCHIDAE
P6RCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRIN10AE
ANGUILLIDAE
NATIONAL 6 GAMMAfllOAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNfDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NATIONAL 16 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMAflJDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 13 PERCICHTHYIDAE
OAPHN1DAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
NATIONAL 6 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POEOLIIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PEflCICHTHYIDAE
NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 16 OAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFIDISAE
NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PEfiCIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRA RCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 7 DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 4 POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OAPHNIOAE
NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIOAE
STATE 3 POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LC50 VALUE
(+)
7451
6.000
9.000
10.603
7451
10.000
11.314
16.000
678999
1794.245
14126.643
16487430
1046,139
16467430
19464.938
2604 1.875
0046
0.496
1.147
2660
0.163
0664
2.660
6.987
6.325
15,000
23.236
32249
15.684
54.711
190000
0000
6399.976
6996790
24692628
6996.790
24892.628
29999.667
30464.750
0.305
0759
0.995
1345
0.256
0759
0.995
1.345
76.707
83000
114.316
125.121
83.000
114.316
306484
317999
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.976
3.000
3.263
17.086
4.503
5.000
5.452
8000
4,503
14,460
41000
231.052
0,664
1279
2,300
3240
3.700
3.811
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+t m (++)
3.388 *
2.690 *
113263 *
156035 *
0.027 * 00004 ACR
0.046 * 0.0007 ACR
1.974 * 0.0043 FHV
1.974 * 00043 FRV
12164 03378 ACR
2124 123 * 100 FPV
0.194 * 5,46618 FVC
0.127 * 630441 FCV
31.429 * 42472 ACR
18.067 * 2.4414 ACR
0.650 » 0,0010 FRV
0.150 * 00010 FRV
1830 * 00019 FRV
0251 * 0.0019 FRV
0203 * 01064 ACR
0.208 * 0 1064 ACR
**
COENAGRIONIDAE(AGfilONIDAE) 67.650
0-000
= ',-,-'< O-E
_ i>n>Tls IN MiCHOGRAMS PER LITER
. . _. efj UNAL PLANT VAI.UF
BP, JMNAL RESIDUE VALUE
PC, UNA!. CHRONIC VALUE
• * _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
J - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: FLORIDA
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
a LEAD
LIN DANE
MERCURY
M NICKEL
PCBS
S SILVER
TOXAPHENE
D 12
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTEflQNAHCIDAE
STATE 6 CYPRINODONTIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTflARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 4 CENTRARCMIOAE
DAPHN DAE
POECILIIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN OAE
STATE < CENTRARCHIDAE
POECIL IDAE
PHILOO NIDAE
CYPRIN OAE
NATIONAL 10 ASELUDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
STATE 5 ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
NATIONAL 9 DAPKNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIOAE
STATE 3 ASTACIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
NAIDlDAE
NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 11 DAPHN DAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
CHIflONOMIDAE
NATIONAL 5 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 1 CENTflAflCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPHINODONTIOAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 8 HYALELLJDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
POECIL IDAE
NATIONAL 9 DAPHN DAE
COTTlDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIOAE
STATE 3 CYPRINODONTIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTflAflCHIDAE
STATE 6 ICTALURIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
. - _ FPV
ACR
SCV
0,440
0.468
0.493
0647
0850
0949
1 011
2.100
0995
1800
2600
7800
24771
50.748
148.000
319999
1.181
4.020
80.062
358.792
455015
532.856
803.845
814.803
10.000
21.988
22437
52,871
44.000
52.871
112.694
136.000
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
20000
783.471
999998
0.000
65,077
233.555
345.472
401.217
76.456
301.510
401.217
439,825
2000
6.611
32601
99,553
0.000
0.000
0.000
1992!474
8499.979
8479723
339.999
3869.989
S499979
12599.945
0002
0.004
0,006
0012
0.012
0112
5,517
0.000
1.300
2627
3547
4 725
4,193
4725
6.782
14379
STATE: FLORIDA
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME CCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
0201 * 00023 FRV I ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0232 * 00023 FRV STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINODONTIOAE
0.251 * 00036 FHV
2.873 * 0.0038 FRV
0037 * 000003 FCV
155,455 * 4.4479 ACR
3.218 * 02574 ACR
10720 * 0.8575 ACR
0470 * 0,20 FRV
0.470 * 0.20 FRV
32.914 * 3.3931 ACR
30.838 * 31791 ACR
0137 * 0014 FRV
**
67.806 * 16.0816 ACR
000053 *
000053 *
0537 * 0.0067 ACR
0960 * 00159 ACR
• - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
13737 6,148 470000 SCV
41.966
46.861
92.757
21.223 9.165 * 47.0000 SCV
41.966
49264
64.B67
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: GEORGIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME
ALDR V NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONlDAE
STATE - SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
ASSEMC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIOAE
ICTALURIOAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
X CADMtuV NATIONAL id SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 14 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
OAPHNIOAE
PHYSIDAE
CHLOnDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIOAE
PT6RONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 PHILODINIOAE
PHYSIDAE
PEHCICHTHY1DAE
SALMONIDAE
S CO°PEf NAT Qsj4L 23 DAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFIC DAE
STATE 16 DAPHNIDAE
CMIRONOM1DAE
PHYSIOAE
TUBIFODAE
C'AVDE \*TIQNAL ,0 SALMONlDAE
DAPHNIOAE
PEHCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHJNIOAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
STAT£ 7 DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
J EL^S '. NATtONAi. ^ COBOL 1DAE
ASELL DAE
SALMONlDAE
EPHEMERELLiOAE
STATE 5 SA-.MONJOAE
EPHEMEPELLIOAE
CENTPARCHiOAE
^Po'SoiOAE
STATE .- SAL'viONiDAE
FRV
AC*
LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30. DAY AVERAGE
(+) )+) 1+) I++)
7451 3388 «
8000
9000
10803
4 503 1 763 *
7 451
9000
10000
878999 113263 *
1794245
14128643
16467 430
1046139 171493 »
14128643
16467 430
19484 938
0048 0027 00004 ACR
0496
1 147
2660
0034 0006 * 0.0001 ACR
0163
0864
2860
6325 1 974 * 00043 FRV
15000
23238
32249
15684 1974 . 00043 FHV
33662 **
54 711
0000
67.000 12 164 0,3376 ACR
6399976
6998790
24892 828
8996 790 1604 673 * 10.0 FPV
24892 826
30454750
63604 148
0305 0194 546618 FCV
0759
0.995
1 345
0256 0 127 * 9.39244 FCV
0.759
0995
1 345
76 707 31 429 * 4 2472 ACR
83000
114316
125 121
76707 14657 • 19806 ACR
83000
114316
317999
1 323 0650 00010 FRV
1 595
1 700
2234
0976 0245 * 00010 FHV
3000
4 102
8151
4503 1 830 * 00019 FHV
5000
5452
8000
2459 0339 » 00019 FRV
8000
10811
41000
0664 0206 * 0,1064 ACH
1279
2300
3240
0664 0019 * 00096 ACR
3.240
DAE) 87690
FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
STATE: GEORGIA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTEHONAHCIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIOAE
POECILIIOAE
CENTRAHCHIOAE
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGRIONID/
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PEHLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
K LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMAHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 OAPHNIDAE
GAMMAHIOAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 5 ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAID1DAE
SS NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 SALMON10AE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGRIONIDA
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONtDAE
STATE 8 HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
S SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
com DAE
CYPHINIDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
STATE 4 COTTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE
PTEHONAHCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
STATE 6 ICTALURIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
0.440
0.468
0.493
0,647
0,556
0.750
1.011
E) 1,800
0.995
1,800
2.800
7.800
13.058
24.771
50,748
319999
1 161
4,020
60062
358,792
80.062
455,015
803.845
814.803
10,000
21.938
22437
52.671
37669
52.871
53068
112.694
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
20.000
248.595
763.471
999.996
65,077
233.555
345.472
401.217
76456
301 510
325642
401.217
2000
6611
32601
99553
2000
6611
E) 282.842
0.000
339999
1992 474
6499.979
6479.723
339.999
3869,969
6479,723
12599.945
0002
0.004
0006
0.012
0.004
0.021
0.112
5.517
1300
2.627
3.547
4.725
3.547
4725
8 129
9,963
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
0201 *
0 170 *
0.251 *
0.657 *
0.037 *
14.070 *
3218 *
10136 *
0.470 *
2.048 *
32.914 *
29866 *
0.137 «
0.137 *
82.646 *
66265 *
0.00053 *
000002 *
0.537 *
1.065 it
0.0023
00023
0.0038
0.0038
0.00003
000004
0.2574
0.81 10
0.20
0.20
33931
3.0791
0.014
0014
22.0395
17.6705
00087
00173
FRV
FHV
FHV
FHV
FCV
FCV
ACH
ACH
FRV
FHV
ACR
ACR
FHV
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACH
ACH
D-13
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: GEORGIA STATE: IDAHO
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSOVALUE MAXIMUM VHMt AVERAGE
(+) ( + ) [+) I+ + ) (+) 1+) (+) (++)
j 2,NC NATIONAL 15 OA HN DAE 13737 6148 470000 SCV ALDRlN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
PH SIDAE 41 966 ASELLIDAE
SA MONIDAE 48861 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PH LOD NIDAE 92 757 SALMONIDAE
STATE il DA HNIDAE 21 223 9 468 * 470000 SCV STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
STATE DA HNIDAE *U£ 4W CENTRARCHIDAE
SA MONIDAE 46550 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PGHCICHTHYIDAE 49 264 CYPRINIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SI CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 6 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 6 PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMON IDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
PHI LODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
S COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
PLANORBIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 8 SALMON 1 DAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PT6RONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
7.451 3 388 *
8.000
9000
10,603
5241 1.668 *
7451
9.000
16,392
878,999 113.263 *
1794.245
14126.643
16487.430
1794245 350,957 *
14128.643
19464.938
20194383
0.048 0.027 0.0004 ACR
0.496
1.147
2860
0,048 0.013 00002 ACR
0.496
1.147
2.860
6.325 1.974 * 0.0043 FRV
15.000
23,238
32.249
15,000 5.042 * 0.0043 FRV
23.238
26.000
40.281
67.000 1 2, 164 04378 ACR
6399.976
6998.790
24892.826
8399.976 540.695 * 10.0 FPV
8998.790
57461.872
63804,148
0,305 0.194 5.48818 FCV
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.305 0.115 3.11336 FCV
0.759
1.345
1.424
76.707 31.429 * 4.2472 ACR
83,000
114.316
125121
76.707 28.920 * 39081 ACR
83.000
114.318
125.121
1.323 0,650 0.0010 FRV
1.595
1.700
1.323 0.479 * 0.0010 FRV
1.595
3.000
3282
4,503 1.830 * 0.0019 FRV
5000
5.452
6.000
3.873 1.037 * 0.0019 FRV
6.000
10.811
24000
0.664 0.208 * 0.1084 ACR
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.684 0.170 * 0.0870 ACR
1 279
2.300
3311
-------
APPENDIX 0
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: IDAHO
TOXICANT
SS LEAD
UNDANE
MERCUBY
IS MCKEL
PCBS
FAMILIES TESTED NAME
NATIONAL i( GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 10 SAUMONIDAE
PEHLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
POECILIIQAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIOAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 7 PTERONARCIDAE
PEHLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
NATIONAL 7 GAMMARlDAE
DAPHNIDAG
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE S DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
NATIONAL 9 DAPNN DAE
GAMMARlDAE
ASTAC DAS
SALMONIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIOAE
EPHEMEREU1OAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 8 DAPHN DAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTHARCHIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRlN DAE
GAMMARlDAE
ST4T£ 3 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 7 MYALELLlDAE (TALITR
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRlN DAE
NAT,OM*L 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIOAE
CYPBINIDAE
CYPRINODONT10AE
ST*T£ 6 DAPHNIDAE
COTTiOAE
CYPH1NIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PTEHONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRAftCHIDAE
STATE 10 PERLIOAE
PTERONARClDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
- -
LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM
0440 0201 *
0468
0493
0647
0 468 0 191 *
0493
0647
0750
1.800
2600
7600
0995 0.117 *
2600
17703
26000
1161 0037 *
4020
80062
358792
4 020 0.267 *
SO 062
356792
455015
10000 3216 *
21986
22437
52.671
18355 6630 *
42198
46000
64000
5000 0470 *
10.000
31,623
244 259
5000 0 101 *
10000
248595
783471
65.077 32.914 »
233555
345472
401 217
65077 20,057 *
401 217
439.625
444717
6611
32601
99553
2000 0137 *
2300 **
32601
0000
1992474
6499979
6479 723
DAEI 339999 52431 *
1992 474
6479 723
9002436
0 002 0 00053 *
0004
0006
0012
0002 000030 *
0004
0006
0021
2627
3547
4725
1300 0564 *
2627
2846
3000
£
UNITS IN M1CROGRAMS PER LITER
STATE: IDAHO
A?,f rll1"? L'FE ^.'.Lll'nE NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC60 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
0 0023 FHV I ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
««, „ PHILODINIDAE
0,0023 FRV STATE 9 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
00036 FRV CYPRINIDAE
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0 00002 FCV
02574 ACR
0 5343 ACR
0.20 FRV
0,0671 ACR
3.3931 ACR
20677 ACR
0014 FRV
139616 ACR
0067 ACR
0 0091 ACR
* • - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RFSlOENT FAMILIES- NATIONAL VALUE USED
3 - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
13737 6146 * 47.0000 SCV
41.966
46661
92757
13.737 2.702 * 47.0000 SCV
41 213
92.757
270.655
D-15
-------
APPENDIX 0
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: ILLINOIS
ALORIN
ARSENIC
SI CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
J COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
D-16
NATIONAL 14 CENTflARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 10 CENTRARCHIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
OAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
STATE 6 GAMMAfllDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 15 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
GAMMARtDAE
STATE 5 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 7 GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
NATIONAL 23 DAPHN DAE
CHI RO NOW 1 DAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 19 DAPHNIDAE
CHlRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
NATIONAL 10 SALMON10AE
OAPHN DAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
NATIONAL 20 DAPHN DAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 14 OAPHN DAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ESOCIDAE
NATIONAL 12 POECIUIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 7 ASELL DAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIOAE
NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
PTERONAHClOAE
CATOSTOMIOAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
CYOfilNlDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
= CO-N
LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) [ + ) (+1 (++)
7451 3388 *
8 000
9000
10603
7451 3,230 *
6,000
10.000
10.803
878.999 113263 *
1794245
14128643
16467430
678999 58 104 *
1046.139
13339985
16467 430
0046 0,027 00004 ACR
0496
1,147
2860
0,064 0.020 0.0003 ACR
0 183
0.864
1 147
6325 1974 * 00043 FHV
15000
23.238
32249
6.325 1 457 * 0 0043 FRV
23238
40.000
43.327
67000 12 164 03378 ACfl
6399976
6998.790
24892.628
67 000 5 387 * 0 1496 ACR
6998.790
24B92.B26
0.305 0.194 5.46616 FCV
0 759
0995
1345
0,256 0 146 4 95&W FCV
0759
0995
1.049
76 707 31 429 * 4.2472 ACR
83000
114316
125121
57000 22152 * 29935 ACR
63000
114.316
125.121
1.323 0650 0,0010 FRV
1 595
1 700
2234
0976 0,480 * 00010 FHV
1 595
1 664
1700
4.503 1 830 * 0.0019 FHV
5000
5452
eooo
5000 1 120 * 00019 FRV
5452
10.611
20000
0 664 0.208 * 0 1064 ACR
1 279
2300
3240
0664 0149 . 0.0762 ACR
1 279
3811
ccv FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: ILLINOIS
NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ENDHIN NATIONAL 17
STATE 11
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
SJ LEAD NATIONAL 7
STATE 5
L1NDANE NATIONAL 10
STATE 9
MERCURY NATIONAL 9
STATE 6
W NICKEL NATIONAL 18
PCBS NATIONAL 5
STATE 5
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
I SILVER NATIONAL 9
STATE 6
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12
STATE 9
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECIUIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERL10AE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
HYALELLIOAEfTALITRIDAE)
OAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE fTALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALUfllDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
I — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLr EQUATION 37 TO DETERMINE MAXJIi
30 DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
rfUM AND
0440
466
493
647
701
732
750
011
905
.800
BOO
800
BOO
24.771
29498
47.329
1,161
4,020
60,062
356-792
1 161
158.156
358.792
455.015
10,000
21.936
22,437
52.671
10,000
10.4S8
18.456
52.871
5000
10.000
31,623
244.259
10.000
244.259
783.471
999.998
85.077
233 555
345.472
401.217
23&5S5
301.510
345.472
2.000
8,611
32.601
99,553
2000
6.611
32.601
99.553
339.999
1992.474
6499.979
8479 723
339.999
3669.989
7049.606
9002.436
0.002
0004
0.008
0,012
0004
0011
0.021
0.112
1.300
2.627
3547
4.725
3,547
4,725
6^033
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
0.201 *
0.294 *
0,251 *
0.311 *
0.037 *
0.059 *
3.218 *
2.01 1 *
0,470 *
1.000 *
32.914 *
. 1 *
0.137 *
0.137 *
82,648 *
74.102 *
0.00053 *
0.00041 *
0.537 *
1.321 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
0 0023 FHV
0.0023 FRV
00038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0 00003 FCV
000004 PCV
0,2574 ACR
0,1609 ACR
0.20 FflV
0.20 FHV
3,3931 ACR
'
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACR
197604 ACR
0 0087 ACR
00214 ACR
-------
APPENDIX 0
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
TATE: ILLINOIS STATE: INDIANA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
?,NC NATIONAL '» DAPHNIOAE 13 737 6 148 47,0000 SCV ALDHIN NATIONAL 14
PHVSiDAE 41 966
SALMONIDAE 48861
PHILODINIDAE 92757
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE 21 223 9 829 47 0000 SCV STATE 8
SALMONIDAE 38,699
PHYSIDAE 41966
PERCICHTHYIOAE 49264
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8
STATE 5
IS CADMIUM NATIONAL 18
STATE 14
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 6
STATE 4
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
J COPPER NATIONAL 23
STATE 19
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
DOT NATIONAL 20
STATE 1
OIELDRIN NATIONAL 12
STATE 5
GNDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9
STATE 6
NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
< + ) i + ) < + J I-*--*-)
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
SALMONIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
C6NTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELL1DAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
' N," IN MironQH*W& PER MTEfi •• - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
" CP "'= -IMA P ANT VALUF S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
to' c,NAi oe<,r)i,E VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
AtP rr,Wpi iTcVBV ACUTE fOTHRONiC RATIO METHOD H - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
c< , en, A, r-HflONI'" -/AL'JE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXI
' r j ' i'l' iTi^t ' PEC IE' 'MHQNIC VALUE 30'DAV AVERAGE CRITERIA
MUM AND
7451 3.388 *
6000
9000
10803
7 451 2.027 *
10000
10.603
16000
876999 113.283 *
1794.245
4128.643
16467430
1046.139 171.818 *
3339965
6467.430
9464.938
0.048 0.027
0.496
1.147
2.660
0.064 0019
0163
0664
1 147
6.325 1974 *
15000
32.249
23238 8051 *
40000
43.327
54.711
67000 12.164
6399.976
6998.790
24692.828
6998,790 1692 459 *
24692828
30454750
57461.672
0.305 0.194
0759
0.995
1,345
0.258 0148
0,759
0995
1.049
76.707 31.429 *
63.000
114.316
125121
57000 20748 *
63000
114.316
125121
1.323 0.650
1.S95
1 700
2234
1595
1664
3000
4503 1.830 *
5,000
5452
8.000
5452 0.297 *
10.611
30102
231.052
0,664 0.208 *
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664 0.149 *
1279
3.240
3.811
0.0004
00003
0.0043
0.0043
0.3378
10.0
5.46618
9.42403
4.2472
2.6035
00010
0.0010
00019
0.0019
01064
00762
ACR
ACH
FRV
FRV
ACR
FPV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
FRV
FHV
ACR
ACH
D-17
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: INDIANA
STATE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL
STATE
II LEAD NATIONAL
STATE
LINOANE NATIONAL
STATE
MERCURY NATIONAL
STATE
SI NICKEL NATIONAL
STATE
PCBS NATIONAL
STATE
SELENIUM NATIONAL
STATE
S SILVER NATIONAL
STATE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL
STATE
D-lg
STATE: INDIANA
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
7 SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAGRlONIDAEIAGRIONIC
10 PTERONAHCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
5 CENTfiAflCHIOAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
7 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOD1NIDAE
10 ASELLIDAg
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
8 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
9 DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
5 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOD NlDAE
NAIDIOAE
16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOD NlOAE
12 OAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOD NlDAE
5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPfltNlDAE
QAMMARlOAE
5 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMAfllOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIOAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
9 DAPHN DAE
COTTIDAE
CYPfllNIOAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
5 COTTIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
12 PERLIDAE
PTERONAP.CIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTBAHCHIOAE
8 ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
— UNITS
+ (•*•)
468
493
647
,701 0197 .
732
011
AE] ,800
995 0.251 *
800
800
800
29.498
47329
50748
1.161 0037 *
4,020
80.062
358.792
158.156 37362 *
356.792
455015
803,845
10000 3.218 *
21 gas
22.437
52.671
10488 2685 +
18 '58
52671
53.066
5.000 0.470 *
10.000
31.623
244.259
10000 0606 *
244,250
783.471
999.908
85.077 32.914 *
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.458 33372 *
301510
345.472
401.217
2.000 0137 *
6,611
32,601
99,553
2000 0.131 *
32601
107,864
1992.474
0499.979
8479.723
3869969
7049.606
9002436
0.002 0 00053 *
0.004
.006
012
004 0 00035 *
011
021
112
.300 0.537 *
627
547
725
. ,547 1 284 *
944
033
IN MIC ROGRAMS PER LITER
( + ) (++) (•*•) <•*•) (•••) (++)
AP
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0 0023 FRV STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
0 0038 FRV
0 0038 FflV
0,00003 FCV
0.00004 FCV
0,2574 ACR
02146 ACR
0.20 FRV
020 FRV
3.3931 ACR
3 4404 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22 0395 ACR
17 2689 CH
0.0087 ACR
0 0206 ACR
5 - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ALUE 30 DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
470000 SCV
41 '966
46,661
92757
21 223 9629 47.0000 SCV
36.699
41 966
49.264
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: IOWA
TOXICANT
"
ARSENIC
SS CADM'i/M
L
O°QV'UV
1 COPPER
C-AMDE
DDT
SAT.O-vAl. U CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELL DAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONlDAE
STATE 7 CENTHARCMIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CYPRlNODONTlDAE
NUT -0", A L 8 GAMMARlDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONlDAE
ICTALURIOAE
STATE 5 GAMMARlDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
NATIONAL 18 SALMONlDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
PHYSIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
CYPRlNODONTlDAE
PHYSIDAE
PTEHONAHCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMAPIDAE
STATE 4 PALAEMONIOAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
CENTBAHCHIDAE
S-1TIONAL 10 GAMMARlDAE
DAPHN DAE
PHILOD1NIOAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 GAMMARlDAE
PHILODINlDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NATIONAL 23 OAPHNIDAE
CHiflONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 17 DAPHN DAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUSIF CiOAE
NAT ONAi. 10 SALMONlDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
S"A-£ 8 DAPHN DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCiDAE
GAMMARlDAE
PEHCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
STATE 2 OAPHNIDAE
PERC'OAE
GAMMARlDAE
ESOCIDAE
ASELUOAE
SALMONlDAE
EPHEMERELLiDAE
PALAEMONIOAE
CVPBlN DAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRlN DAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMlDAE
S-*T£ 5 CYPPIN DAE
CATOSTOMiDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
: '"'.C'E
1*«
*.'• '
(*l < + > ( + ) I + + )
7*51 .1388 *
8000
9000
10803
7 *5l 2 773 »
16000
16392
21000
878999 113263 *
179*2*5
1*1286*3
16487 *30
878 999 42 377 *
1046 139
16487 430
1948*938
00*8 0,027 00004 ACR
0496
1 147
2860
1 1*7
1 630
2860
6325 1 97* * 0.00*3 FRV
15000
23238
32249
6 325 1 203 * 0,0043 FflV
23238
40000
54711
67000 12 16* 03378 ACR
6399976
6998.790
24892 828
67000 3407 * 00946 ACR
6898790
2*892 828
57461 972
0305 0.194 546618 FCV
0.759
0995
13*5
0 256 0 133 * * 958*3 FCV
0759
0995
1 345
76 707 31 ^29 * 4,2472 ACR
83000
114 316
125 121
83000 33249 . 44930 ACR
114 316
125121
167000
1 595
1 700
223*
0976 0462 * 00010 FRV
1 595
1 664
1 700
5000
5*52
8000
20000
30102
23) 052
1279
2300
3,2*0
1 279 0,351 * 0 1800 ACR
3240
3611
6000
"l^to^UE
£i, '_•!'.'!: ^PEC S3 CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: tOWA
NUMBER OF
ENDflIN NATIONAL 17
STATE 8
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10
STATE 5
H LEAD NATIONAL 7
STATE *
LINDANE NATIONAL 10
STATE 8
MERCURY NATIONAL 9
STATE 3
« NICKEL NATIONAL 16
STATE 11
PCBS NATIONAL 5
STATE 4
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
GASTEHOSTEIDAE
SALMONlDAE
PEHLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
PERLIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTflARCHIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONlDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
ASELLIOAE
SALMONlDAE
GAMMARlDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONlDAE
GAMMARlDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALUHlDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONlDAE
GAMMARlDAE
PHILODINlDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINlDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINlDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
SALMONlDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
0.440
0468
0,493
0,647
0,732
0,750
1.01)
1.285
0.995
1600
26.000
1.161
SO 062
358792
1 161
358792
455.015
803845
10.000
21 388
22.437
52.871
2.000
10.488
42.198
53,066
5.000
10.000
31.623
244259
10.000
783471
999.998
0.000
65.077
233.555
3*5472
401 217
78456
325.8*2
401.217
439.825
2.000
6611
32.601
99.553
2.300
32.601
99,553
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGRIONIDAE) 282 842
STATE 8
I SILVER NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
STATE 9
• • STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMIL
APPLY EQUATION J 7 TO DETERMINE MAX!
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIOAE
SALMONIOAE
HYALELLIOAEfTAUTFIIOAEl
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRIN10AE
POECILIIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
CYPRlNODONTlDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHILOD1NIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONtDAE
ICTALURIOAE
CYPRINIOAE
ES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
UJM CRITERIA
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30 DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
1992474
6499979
8479723
339.999
3869989
9002438
2599.945
0004
0,006
0.012
0112
4 106
5.517
2.627
3,547
4725
2,848
3.000
3.547
8.033
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
0.201 *
0271 *
0251 *
0.245 *
0.037 *
0.035 *
3.218 *
0.352 *
0470 *
0.470 *
32,914 *
31.086 *
0.137 *
0.131 *
*
65749 *
000053 *
'
'
0.780 *
0.0023 FRV
0,0023 FRV
0.0033 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0,00003 FCV
0,2574 ACH
0.0281 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
3.3931 ACR
3.2047 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
'
1 7 5329 ACH
'
0.0126 ACfl
D-19
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
TATE: IOWA STATE: KANSAS
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
1+) (+) (+) !++)
ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHN DAE 13737 6148 470000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14
PHYSIDAE 41 986
SALMONIDAE 46861
PHILODINIDAE 92757
STATE 1 1 DAPHN DAE 21 223 4 992 » 47,0000 SCV STATE 5
PHYSIDAE 41966
PHILODINIOAE 92757
CYPRIN DAE 266568
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8
STATE 4
SS CADMIUM NATIONAL 18
STATE 12
CHLOHDANE N IONAL 8
STATE 2
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10
STATE 5
S COPPER NATIONAL 23
STATE 14
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
DDT NATIONAL 20
STATE 7
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12
STATE 4
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9
STATE 4
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUSIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRAflCHIDAE
PEflCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRAflCHIDAE
CYPH1NIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
JO VALUE
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
7.451
10.000
16000
16.392
878999
1794 245
4128643
6467.430
1046.139
6487430
9484,938
201 94.383
0.046
0496
1.147
2.860
0.163
0.864
2.860
6987
15XJOO
23.238
32,249
23.238
54.711
0.000
0.000
67000
6399976
6998790
4892.628
6996.790
4892.828
304 54.750
7461.672
0.305
0759
0,995
1.345
0.256
0.759
0.995
1 345
76.707
63.000
114.316
125.121
83.000
114316
125.121
207956
1 323
1,595
1.700
2234
0.976
1,595
2409
3.904
4.503
5.000
5.452
8.000
10.811
30.102
190,745
739.999
0664
1.279
2,300
3240
1.279
3240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
3.388 *
2.454 *
113,263 *
140.493 *
0.027
0.041 *
1974 *
1.974 *
**
12.164 *
1548,624 *
0.194
0.116 *
31.429 *
27174 *
0.650
0.263 *
1.830 *
0.439 *
0208 *
0.036 *
30-DAY
00004
0.0006
0.0043
0.0043
0.3378
10.0
5.46618
9.26331
4,2472
3.8722
0.0010
0.0010
0,001 9
0.0019
0.1064
00185
AVERAGE
ACR
ACR
FHV
FRV
ACR
FPV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FHV
FHV
FHV
ACH
ACH
COENAGH1ONIDAE(AGRIONIDAE) 67.650
,,-, SCv SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30 DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: KANSAS
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDE
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME
CSIRII-J NATONAL 17 GASTEHOSTEIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PERL1DAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ST*TE 7 CVPRINIDAE
POECILMDAE
NT FAMILY
LC50 VALUE
I*)
0440
0493
0647
0732
0750
CENTRARCHIOAE 1 011
COENAGRIONIDAErAGHIONiDAE) 1 800
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLiOAE
AST AC DAE
STATE 4 ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
STATE - CVPRINIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PHILODINIQAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 6 CENTRAHCHIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
PERCIDAE
CYPfllNIDAE
WESCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTAC OAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 2 PHILODINIDAS
NAIDIDAE
« NiC<£- NATIONAL 16 OAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
CENTRAHCHIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
PCBS NAT'ONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPPIN DAE
GAVVAfllOAE
S**T£ 3 CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPRiN DAE
COENAGHlONlOAE (AGfllON
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTlDAE
SALMON lOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CfPRiN DAE
POECIUIOAE
S S'_/E= VATfONAL 9 DAPHNlOAE
CYPPlNODONTlDAE
STATE 5 CYPfliN DAE
PHILOCilNiDAE
&TEPONAPCIDAE
CV&P'IMDAE
PEPC-DAE
- • •',- 'I
»r^
1800
2800
7600
7800
26000
50748
179508
4020
80.062
358792
358792
455015
803845
0000
21983
22437
42 198
53066
68.000
94805
5000
10 000
31623
244,259
783471
999996
0000
0000
65,077
233555
345472
401 217
78456
301510
325842
401 217
2000
6611
32601
99553
2300
32601
IQAEI2B2842
0000
1992 474
6499979
8479 723
3669969
9002438
12599945
0002
0.004
0006
0.012
0.011
5517
0000
2627
3647
A 7V>
2646
3547
8033
12000
•';".,r-"°r
HWAi "Eb'D
' ','V (••"[ Mj f
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE
MAXIMUM 30- DAY
l+l (+)
0201 * 00023
0 208 * 0 0023
0 788 * 0 0038
*
0037 * 000003
574
14391 * i 1512
0470 * 0.20
0 470 * 0 20
32914 « 3.3931
29888 * 30791
0 137 * 0.014
0137 * 0014
82648 * 22 0395
*
000053 *
000053 •
**
053 *
0631 * 00102
Ufc /ALMt
4lC VALl.lt
STATE: KANSAS
^unl'nc Tn»,^.UT NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCM VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
1+1 ( + ) f + l i + \ n-t- \
PRV SS ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
FHV STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
FHV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
• . _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLV EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
HOD U - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
30'DAV AVERAGE CRITERIA
13737 6148 470000 SCV
41,966
46.861
92757
21.223 7336 * 47.0000 SCV
41 966
49.264
92.757
D-21
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: KENTUCKY
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDEN
ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
1CTALUH1DAE
STATE 6 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SS CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 14 SALMONIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
CHLOROANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHN DAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 7 GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
S COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHN DAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFIC DAE
STATE IB DAPHN DAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PERCIOAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
DAPHN10AE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DOT NATIONAL 20 DAPHN DAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 8 OAPHN DAE
ASTAC DAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILI DAE
ASELL10AE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
CYPRIN DAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
CATOSTOMtOAE
CENTRAflCHIDAE
- - - FPV
FRV
n •>-> scv
(+) (+> (+) (++)
7451 3388 *
8000
9.000
10.603
4.503 1 774 *
7.451
8000
10000
878999 113,263 .
1794 245
14128643
16487430
878 999 58 104 *
1046.139
13339.965
16467430
0048 0.027 0,0004 ACR
0496
2860
0.044 0,013 0.0002 ACR
0163
0.664
1 147
6325 1974 * 00043 FHV
15.000
23236
32249
23,236 1 974 * 00043 FHV
25481 **
54.711
0.000
67000 12 164 0.3378 ACR
6399 976
6996790
24692 626
67000 5387 * 01496 ACR
6998.790
24892.828
30454 750
0.305 0.194 5.46618 FCV
0759
0,995
1.345
0256 0 142 479332 FCV
0759
0995
1 022
B3'000
114,316
125121
57.000 18.631 * 2.5176 ACH
83000
114.316
167000
1 323 0.650 * 00010 FRV
1 595
1 700
2.234
0.976 0338 * 00010 FRV
3.000
4000
4.102
4503 1 830 * 00019 FRV
5000
5452
a ooo
2.459 0.338 * 0,0019 FHV
5000
10.611
30102
1279
2.300
3240
0 664 0 137 * 0 0701 ACR
1279
3240
3811
IN MICROGflAMS PER LITER
FINAL PLANT VALUF
FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
STATE: KENTUCKY
NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC BO VALUE MAXIMUM
ENDRIN NATIONAL
STATE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL
STATE
SS LEAD NATIONAL
STATE
LINDANE NATIONAL
STATE
MERCURY NATIONAL
STATE
SS NICKEL NATIONAL
STATE
STATE
SELENIUM NATIONAL
STATE
S SILVER NATIONAL
STATE
STATE
** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FA
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE M
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE M
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
17 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PEHLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
6 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
7 GAMMAHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHIN1DAE
5 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CSNTHARCHIDAE
6 SALMONIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
9 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
4 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
11 DAPHNIDA6
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
10 HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
8 HYALELLIDAE (TAL1TRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
9 DAPHNIDAE
com DAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
8 COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
7 ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
MILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
AXIMUM CRITERIA
AXIMUM AND
0 440 0.201 *
0466
0.493
0.647
0.694 0.280 *
0.732
0,750
1 011
0.995 0.251 *
1.800
2.800
7.800
13.058 1.384 *
24.771
50748
1 79.508
1.161 0.037 *
4.020
80.062
358.792
1.161 0059 *
158.156
358,792
455.015
10.000 3.218 *
21.988
22.437
52871
8.004 1,133 *
10,000
52.871
53.066
5.000 0.470 *
10.000
31.623
244.259
10.000 0 639 *
248.595
783.471
999.998
65.077 32.914 *
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.456 31.616 *
301.510
325.842
401.217
tan
32.601
99553
2.000 0.144 *
6.611
32.801
92.054
339.999 82.648 *
1992,474
6499.979
8479.723
339.999 74.102 *
3869.989
7049.606
9002438
0.002 0 00053 *
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.004 0.00041 *
0011
0.021
0.112
2^627
3,547
4.725
3.547 1265 *
4.725
5251
8,033
AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
30-DAY AVERAGE
0.0023 FHV
0.0023 FHV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0,00003 FCV
0.00004 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.0906 ACft
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
3.3931 ACR
3.2596 ACR
'
0014 FRV
22,0395 ACR
19.7604 ACR
0.0067
0.0205 ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: KENTUCKY STATE: LOUISIANA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
(+1 f-O (+) <++»
S ZINC ^ATrONAL i5 DAPHN DAE 13737 6 M8 470000 SCV ALORIN NATIONAL 14 CENTHAflCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41 966 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48 861 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92 737 SALMONIOAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIQAE 21 223 9395 4Toooo scv STATE 7 CENTRARCHIOAE
SALMONIOAE 26 243 PEHCICHTHYIOAG
PMYSlDAE 41 966 ANGUILLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE 49 264 CYPRINIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 6 GAMMARIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
ICTALUHIDAE
STATE 4 DAPMNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCH10AE
CYPRINIOAE
K CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIOAE
GAMMARIOAE
PHYSIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYS10AE
STATS 5 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
$ COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOM1DAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 15 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYS10AE
SALMONIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 9 DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OIELORIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIOAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 3 CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE(AGRIONIDA
-' ' "UNITS IN WICOOCRAMS PER LITER * • - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
"PV PINALKANTVA.UF i - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
K>J t'Ht-i. "t'lCiUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3? TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
*r-u GOMPMif, 8r ACUTE TOCHRONtC HATlO METHOD IS - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
" ; CTNAL r MBQWC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
so VALUE MAXIMUM SO-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (+) (+) (++)
74S1 3388 »
8,000
9.000
10.603
7.451 2646 *
10.000
16,000
16.392
878.999 113.263 *
1794.245
14128.843
16487430
1046.139 140493 *
18487,430
9464.938
20194383
0.048 0027 0.0004 ACR
0496
1.147
2.860
0 163 0.041 * 0.0006 ACR
0864
2.860
6987
6.325 1.974 * 0.0043 FRV
15000
23238
32,249
6,325 1.097 * 0.0043 FRV
23.238
54.711
56000
67000 12164 0,3378 ACR
6399.976
6998.790
24892.628
6993790 1546824 * 100 FPV
24892.626
30454.750
57461.672
0.305 0.194 546618 FCV
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256 0.123 * 909372 FCV
0.759
0995
12364
76 707 31 429 * 4.2472 ACR
83.000
114.316
125121
83.000 16.127 * 21792 ACR
114316
207.958
431.499
1.323 0.650 0.0010 FRV
1.595
1 700
2,234
0.976 0.364 * 00010 FRV
3000
3234
4 102
4.503 1 630 * 0.0019 FHV
5000
5.452
6000
10.800 2569 * 0.0019 FRV
10811
20000
30102
0.664 0208 * 01064 ACR
1.279
2300
3.240
1.279 0.208 * 0.1064 ACR
3.811 **
I) 87650
0.000
D-23
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: LOUISIANA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME
ENDRIN NATIONAL 7 GASTEHOSTEIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PERU DAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POEC1LIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
HEPTACMLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 5 PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
$$ LEAD NATIONAL 7 OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
STATE 3 CYPHIN DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOO NIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
CYPRIN DAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 4 ASTACIDAE
SALMON DAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
U NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PEflCICHTHYIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 2 CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALEUIDAE fTALlTRIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CYPHINODONTIOAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 7 HYALELLIDAE (TALITH1DAE
DAPHN DAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILI DAE
S SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 3 CYPH1NIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALUHIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 7 ICTALUHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
LC50 VALUE
0,440
0.468
0,493
0,647
0471
0732
0750
1011
0995
1 800
2.800
7.600
1 BOO
24771
50.748
81.900
1 161
4020
80062
356.792
358.792
455,015
603,645
0.000
10.000
21.986
22.437
52671
45,277
52,871
53.066
94,605
5,000
10.000
31.823
244.259
20,000
240,000
763.471
999.998
65.077
233.555
345472
401.217
76.456
301510
401,217
439825
2.000
6.611
32801
99.553
8.611
32.801
O.OCO
0000
339.999
1992.474
6499979
8479723
339.999
3869969
9002.438
12599.945
0.002
0,004
0006
0012
0.010
0112
5.517
0.000
1.300
2627
3.547
4725
3547
4.725
8.033
6672
STATE: LOUISIANA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCGO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + ) ! + ) (++> ( + ) (-*-) (+> (++>
0.201 * 0.0023 FRV S ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0 190 * 0.0023 FRV STATE 11 OAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
0.251 * 00038 FRV
0.206 * 0,0038 FHV
0.037 * 000003 FCV
0,037 * 000003 FCV
**
3.218 * 0.2574 ACR
13938 * 1 1U9 ACR
0.470 * 020 FRV
1.664 * 0.20 FRV
32914 * 3.3931 ACR
29.005 * 2.9901 ACR
0.137 * 0.014 FRV
0.137 * 0014 FRV
82846 * 22.0395 ACR
56,854 * 151611 ACR
0.00053 *
1.00053 *
0537 * 0.0087 ACR
1187 * 00193 ACR
- - - FPV
ACF
FCV
rvox SCV
COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD JS - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FINAL CHRO
SENSITIVE S
•IIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
ECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
13.737 6.148 470000 SCV
41.966
48661
92.757
21.223 8.135 * 47.0000 SCV
41.966
49.264
481.416
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MAINE
TOXICANT
ALDS'N
ARSENIC
SS CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
I COPPER
CYANfDE
DOT
Df£(.Q**tit
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE
NATIONAL i« CENTRARCHIOAE
ASELLIDAE
EPMEMERELLIOAE
SALMONIOAE
STATE 8 EPHEMERELL1DAE
CYPRINIDAE
ANGUlLLIDAE
PERC1CHTHYIDAE
NATIONAL a GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 3 DAPMN10AE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHlNlOAE
NATIONAL '8 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYS10AE
STATE ie SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMA RiDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPftiNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE S PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PEROCHTHYIDAE
CYPH1N DAE
NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUB1FIC10AE
STATE 20 DAPHNIDAE
CHfRONOMiDAE
PHYSIDAE
TuSiFiC DAE
NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 7 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRA RCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCIDAE
NATIONAL 20 DAPHNlOAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 9 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
MAriONAL '•'* POEC1LIIDAE
ASELL DAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 5 EPH£MEflEU.IDA£
SALMONIOAE
OAPHNIDAE
CYPflJMIDAE
PT £ RON A RC1 D AE
CATOSTOMlDAe
STATE 4 CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIOAE
7461
8.000
9.000
10,603
9.000
11 732
16000
20494
878999
1794245
14126 643
16487430
1046.139
14963 949
15659936
0.000
0.048
0.496
2.860
0.026
0864
1 147
1.630
6.325
15.000
23.238
32,249
12371
26.000
50.200
0.000
67000
6399976
6998790
248S2 628
6998.790
24892828
30454.750
40637.609
0.305
0759
0995
1345
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.345
76707
63.000
114316
125.121
83.000
102.000
103.227
125,121
1323
1.595
T 700
2234
0.976
1.595
2358
3.000
4.503
5000
5.452
8000
8000
10800
22101
231052
1279
3,240
1279
3240
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
3388 *
3.313 *
113263 *
113.263 *
0 027 0.0004 ACR
0.015 0 0002 ACR
1.974 * 0.0043 FRV
1 974 * 0 0043 FRV
12.164 0 3378 ACR
1811.186 * 10.0 FPV
0.194 546618 FCV
0.151 7.22020 FCV
31 429 * 4 2472 ACR
35.949 * 48579 ACR
0650 00010 FRV
0 354 * 0.0010 FRV
1 630 * 0,0019 FRV
0.390 * 00019 FRV
0208 * 01064 ACR
0043 » 0.0218 ACR
STATE: MAINE
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
S$ LEAD
UN DANE
MERCURY
SI NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
s SILVER
T XA N
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSOVALUE
r + i
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
COENAGRiONIOAEjAGWONIOAE) 87.660
'jO~'
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MAINE
STATE: MARYLAND
[•*•> ( + ) (+) (++)
ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13,737 6 146 47 0000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL
PHYSIDAE 41 966
SALMONIDAE 48-661
PHILODNIDAE 92757
STATE 13 DAPHN DAE 21 223 8532 470000 SCV STATE
PHYSIDAE 41966
SALMONiOAE 73017
PHILODINIDAE 92,757
ARSENIC NATIONAL
STATE
M CADMIUM NATIONAL
STATE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL
STATE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL
STATE
S COPPER NATIONAL
STATE
CYANIDE NATIONAL
STATE
DDT NATIONAL
STATE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL
STATE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL
STATE
OF
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
ESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM
(+) (+)
9
8
Itt
17
8
10
6
23
18
10
e
20
10
12
6
9
6
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARlDAE
ASTACIDAE
POECILIIOAE
ASELUDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
^OOTHOTE * - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
7.451 3 386 *
6.000
9.000
0.603
7.451 2.749 *
9.000
14,377
16000
878.999 113.263 *
1794.245
14128.643
16467.430
1046.139 141.620 *
14125,643
19484.938
20194,363
0.048 0.027
0.496
1.147
2.660
0.034 0.021
0.864
1.147
1.630
6.325 1.974 *
15.000
23.236
32.249
23.238 8.017 *
40,000
40.044
54711
67.000 12.184
6996.790
24692 628
6996.790 1692.459 *
24892.628
30454.750
57461.672
0.305 0.194
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256 0.139
0.759
0.995
1.345
76.707 31.429 *
83.000
114.316
125.121
78.707 30519 *
63.000
114.316
125.121
1.323 0.650 *
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.976 0.357 *
1.595
1.864
3.000
4.503 1630 *
5,000
5.452
8.000
5.154 1.037 *
8.000
10.811
30.102
0.664 0.206 *
1279
2.300
3.240
0.664 0.149 *
3.240
3811
30-DAY
0.0004
0,0003
0.0043
0.0043
0.3378
10,0
546618
8.36350
4.2472
4.0836
0.0010
0.0010
0.0019
0.0019
0.1064
00762
AVERAGE
(+•*•)
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
FPV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
FRV
FHV
ACR
ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MARYLAND
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ENC""N NATIONAL '<"
STATE ' 1
ST4T6 5
SS LEAD NATIONAL 7
STATE *
UMDASe NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
UERCUflY NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
H NlCKEi- NATIONAL 16
S-ATE 12
=C3S NAT'0-.AL 5
STATE 5
0 >. 0
STB'E 7
-> L 9
ST*TE 5
STATE D
STATE: MARYLAND
NAME
GASTEROSTEiDAE
SALMONIDAE
PEHLIOAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
GASTEftOSTEiDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECIL IOAE
PALAEMONiDAE
PEHLIOAE
AST AC 1 DAE
CENTRAHCHIOAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNlOAE
GAMMAHlDAE
OAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHiNiOAE
SALMQNIOAE
CYPRiNiDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PMILODlNlDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMAHlDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
OAPHNIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTAClOAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTAClOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODlNIDAE
OAPHNIOAE
EPHEMF.RELLIDAE
CENTHAHCHlQAE
PHILODlNIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRAHCHIOAE
PHILOO NIDAE
CHIHONOMIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRiN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPRIN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINOOONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLlDAE fTALITHIDAEl
OAPHNtDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIOAE
COniDAE
CYPP'NPDAE
CYPRlNODONTIDAE
COTTlOAE
SALMONIDAE
PTEP-ONARCiDAE
CENTRAHCMIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHiN DAE
Rv
C •
C -
1+) (+1
0 440 0 201 *
0466
0493
0647
0440 0 188 *
0526
0.732
0750
1 600
2,aoo
7800
26000 9159 *
32702
47329
50746
1 161 0037 *
4020
80062
358792
80.062 14969 *
356792
455015
803645
10000 3.216 *
21 988
22437
52871
10188 2473 *
18.933
42196
64000
5 000 0 470 *
10000
31823
244 259
10000 0631 *
50000
244 259
783471
65.077 32914 *
233555
345472
401 217
78456 33.129 *
W5472
401 217
439825
2.000 0 137 *
6611
32,601
99553
2.000 0060 •
2300
32601
107664
1992474
6499979
6479 723
339-999 62 801 *
3869989
6479723
9002438
0-004
0006
0012
0.004 0 00035 *
0,011
0021
0112
1300 0537 *
2627
3.547
4725
2648 0775 *
3000
7128
8033
VN*lV;£/MLJ L '
',0>/P','-tD ti< ACUTE tOCH
OENV'i/E. SPECIES CMRQNi
l + ) — '**' ( + ) ( + ) ( + 1 ( + 4-1
00023 FHV » ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODlNIDAE
0.0023 FRV STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
"
0 0038 FHV
0,00003 FCV
0,00003 FCV
0.02574 ACH
0 1976 ACR
0 20 FRV
0 20 FRV
33931 ACR
34153 ACR
0014 FHV
0014 FHV
22 9395 ACR
16 7469 ACR
0 0087 ACR
0012B ACR
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
RON i' RATIO METHOD JS - HARDNESS EFPECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
VALUE 30 DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
13.737 6.146 * 47.0000 SCV
46861
92757
21.223 8.523 470000 SCV
41 966
56065
92.757
D-27
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MASSACHUSETTS
STATE 9
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8
STATE 5
SS CADMIUM NATIONAL 18
STATE 16
CHLOHOANE NATIONAL 8
STATE A
STATE 6
I COPPER NATIONAL 23
STATE 19
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
STATE n
STATE 6
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9
STATE 6
D-28
NAME
ASELUOAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONlDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
EPHEMEP.ELLIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONlDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONlDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONlDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONlDAE
DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTI0AE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
SALMONlDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PHILOO NIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTMYIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFIC DAE
DAPHN DAE
CHIHONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONlDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMON DAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESCCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHN DAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONlDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONlDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONlDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
CATOSTOWlDAE
SALMONlDAE
CYPRIN DAE
CATOSTOUIDAE
SC .
STATE: MASSACHUSETTS
i+) (+) (+) (++) [+) (+) ( + ) (++)
3 000 SALMONlDAE 0 468
10 803 PTERONAHCIDAE 0.647
4 503 1 520 * STATE 9 GASTEROSTEIDAE 0 440 0 153 * 0.0023 FRV
7 451 SALMONlDAE 0,556
9000 CENTRAHCHIDAE 1 OH
16000 CYPRINIDAE 1 086
878 999 1 13 263 * HEPTACHLOfl NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE 0.995 0.251 * 0 0036 FRV
179.1 245 PALAEMONIDAE 1.300
4128 643 PERLIDAE 2.800
6487 430 ASTACIDAE 7.800
1046 139 171 493 * STATE 5 SALMONlDAE 13.058 3.521 * 00036 FRV
4128643 CENTRARCHIDAE 26 000
6487 430 GAMMARIDAE 47 329
9484938 DAPHNIDAE 50 74B
0048 0027 00004 ACR SS LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIDAE 1 161 0.037 * 0.00003 FCV
0496 DAPHNIDAE 4.020
1 147 SALMONlDAE 80.062
2 860 CYPHINIDAE 358 732
0 034 0 019 0 0003 ACR STATE 4 SALMONlDAE 80 062 14 969 * 0.00004 FCV
0864 CYPRINIOAE 358.792
1 147 CENTRARCHIDAE 455.015
1 630 PHILODINIDAE 803,345
6 325 1 974 * 0 0043 FRV LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE 10 000 3.218 * 0.2574 ACR
15.000 SALMONlDAE 21.988
23 238 GAMMARIDAE 22.437
32 249 CENTRARCHIDAE 52 871
23238 7675 . 00043 FHV STATE 7 GAMMARIOAE 10,488 2245 * 01796 ACR
33862 SALMONlDAE 14.158
40 000 CENTRARCHIDAE 42 198
54711 ICTALUHIDAE 53068
6399 976 GAMMARIDAE 10.000
6998790 ASTACIDAE 31 G23
24892 828 SALMONlDAE 244,259
6998 790 1692 459 * 100 FPV STATE 5 GAMMARIDAE 10.000 0 629 * 0,20 FRV
24892 828 ASTACIDAE 50.000
30454 750 SALMONlDAE 248.595
57461 672 PHILODINIDAE 783.471
0 305 0 194 5 46618 FCV JS NICKEL NATIONAL IB DAPHNIDAE 65.077 32.914 * 3 3931 ACR
0759 EPHEMERELLIDAE ' 233555
0 995 CENTRARCHIDAE 345 472
1 345 PHILODINIOAE 401.217
0 256 0 145 8 471 14 FCV STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE 78 456 33,129 * 3.4153 ACR
0 759 CENTRARCHIDAE 345 472
0995 PHILODINIDAE 401.217
1 345 CHIRONOMIDAE 439825
76 707 31 429 * 4 2472 ACR PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONlDAE 2 000 0.137 * 0.014 FRV
83 000 CENTRARCHIDAE 6.611
114 316 CYPRINIDAE 32.601
125 121 GAMMARIDAE 99553
76707 29583 « 39977 ACR STATE 5 SALMONlDAE 2.000 0 060 » 0.014 FHV
83 000 CENTHAflCHIDAE 2.300
1 '4 316 CYPRINIDAE 32.801
125 121 GAMMAHIDAE 107.684
1 595 DAPHNIDAE 1992474
1 700 CYPRINODONTIDAE 6499.979
2 234 SALMONlDAE 8479.723
0976 0370 « 00010 FRV STATE 7 HYALELLIDAE fTALITRIDAE) 339.999 62.801 * 16.7469 ACR
1595 DAPHNIDAE 3869989
1 664 SALMONlDAE 8479.723
3 000 CYPRINIDAE 9002 438
5000 COTTIDAE 0.004
5^52 CYPHINIDAE 0.006
8 000 CYPHINODONTIDAE 0 012
2 459 0 471 * 0.0019 FRV STATE 4 CYPRINIDAE 0.01 1 0 00008 *
8 000 SALMONlDAE 0.021
14460 CENTflARCHIDAE 0.112
30 102 PHILOOINIDAE 5517
0664 0208 * 01064 ACR TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE 1300 0.537 * 0,0087 ACR
1 279 PTERONARCIDAE 2.627
2 3°0 ICTALURIDAE 3 547
3 2AO CENTHARCHIDAE 4.725
0664 0149 * 00762 ACR STATE 8 CENTHAHCHIDAE 2.848 0.919 0.0149 ACH
1 279 ICTALURIDAE 3547
3240 SALMONlDAE 6.678
SENS-'VE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MASSACHUSETTS STATE: MICHIGAN
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC L IFF c-MTFRU
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50VALUE MAXIMUM M-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSOVALUE MAXIMUM M^AY AVERAGE
1+1 - '*' i+l - -- (**1 ( + 1 ( + 1 [+1 /4.4.1
S ;t\C NATIONAL '5 DAPHNIDAE 13737 6 U8 470000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTHAHCHIDAE
PMVSiDAE 41966 ASELLIDAE
SALMONiDAE 48.861 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE 92 757 SALMONIDAE
STATE '3 DAPHNIDAE 21 2J3 8451 470000 SCV STATE 9 CENTFtARCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41 966 EPHEMERELLIOAE
SALMONIDAE 51 645 SALMONIDAE
PHILOD N1DAE 92 757 ANGUILLIOAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 3 GAMMAHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 6 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
1CTALUHIDAE
SI CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 15 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 5 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILOOI NIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
I COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIF1CIDAE
STATE 19 DAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTFtARCHIDAE
PERC10AE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCH10AE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 13 OAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMAFtlDAE
ASTACIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
FCV f tHAt CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
flCv IflH'jrtiVt SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
7451 3.388 *
8000
BOOT
10803
7451 2.767 *
9.000
10.803
16.000
878.999 113.263 *
1794.245
4128.643
6467430
878.999 56.980 *
1046 139
4126.643
6487.430
0.048 0.027 0.0004 ACR
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.046 0,023 0.0003 ACR
0.864
1.147
1.830
6.325 1.974 * 00043 FRV
15.000
23236
32249
6.325 1.511 * 0.0043 FRV
23238
32249
43.739
67.000 12.184 04378 ACR
6399976
6998.790
4892.828
67000 3.407 * 0.0946 ACR
6998.790
4892J28
7461.672
0.305 0.194 5.46618 FCV
0.759
0.995
1345
0,256 0.145 4.79332 FCV
0.759
0.995
1.339
76707 31.429 * 42472 ACR
63.000
114316
125.121
76.707 30.219 * 4.0836 ACR
83.000
114.316
125.121
1.323 0.650 0.0010 FHV
1.595
1.700
Z234
0.976 0.410 * 00010 FRV
1.595
2.234
3.000
4.503 1.830 * 0.0019 FHV
5.000
5.452
8.000
5452 1556 * 0.0019 FRV
6.000
10.811
20.000
0.664 0208 * 0.1064 ACR
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664 0.149 * 0.0762 ACR
1.279
3.240
3611
D-29
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MICHIGAN
STATE: MICHIGAN
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
JJ LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
SI NICKEL
PC8S
S SILVER
TOXAPHENE
FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50VALUE MAXIMUM
(•*) ( + )
NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEIOAE
SALMONIOAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 10 SALMONIDAE
CYPHINlDAE
POECILMDAE
CENTflARCHIOAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 6 PALAEMONIDAE
CENTHAflCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMAftlDAE
NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIDAE
OAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINlDAE
STATE 5 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINlDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTAC10AE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 7 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIOAE
NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOOINIOAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
NATIONAL 5 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINlOAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINlOAE
GAMMAfllOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 8 HYALELUDAE (TALITRlDAE)
DAPHNlOAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINlDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINlDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 6 COTTIDAE
CYPRINlDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
NATIONAL 1< PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALUHtOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 9 CENTRAHCHIOAE
ICTALUfl'DAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRlNlDAE
0 440 0 201 *
0468
0,493
0647
0,625 0265 *
0732
0750
1011
iaoo
2600
7800
1,800 0331 *
26.000
29499
37048
1161 0037 *
4020
60062
358792
1 161 0054 *
80062
358792
455015
21966
22437
52871
21 938 6 601 *
22437
42 198
53.066
5000 0470 +
10,000
31623
244.259
10000 1222 *
244 259
783471
999.993
65077 32914 *
233,555
345472
401 217
73.456 33.860 *
233.555
345472
401 217
2000 0.137 •
6.611
32601
99553
2 000 0 063 *
2300
32601
99553
1992474
6499979
8479723
339999 72017 *
3869 989
6479 723
9002438
0004
0006
0012
0.004 0.00041 *
0011
0021
0.112
1 300 0 537 *
2627
3547
4725
2 848 0 943 *
3547
5781
8033
30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) ( + + )
0 0023 FRV
0 0023 FRV
0 0038 FRV
0 00003 FCV
0 00004 FCV
0 5281 ACR
0 20 FRV
020 FHV
3.3931 ACR
3.4906 ACR
0.014 FRV
0,014 FHV
192044 ACR
00087 ACR
00153 ACH
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
48861
92.757
21 223
- UNITS IN
ACR CO
scv se
VHCROGRAMS PER LITER
At. RESIDUE VALUE
MPUTED BY ACUTE TOCHR
AL CHRONIC VALUE
MSiTiVE SPECIES CHRONIC
•* - STATE HAS LESS TH
ONIC RATIO METHOD
VALUE
APPLY
it - HARDf*
APPLY
EQUATION 3 7
EQUATION 37
N 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
TO DETERM
TO DETEHM
NE MAXI
NE MAXI
HUM CRITERIA
MM AND
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MINNESOTA
STATE: MINNESOTA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE R
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME
ASELLiDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ANGUILUDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 6 GAMMAHIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
SALMONIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 5 OAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 14 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNlOAE
GAMMARIDAE
CVPRINODONTIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPHIN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATg 4 CYPRIN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
PHILOD NlDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 5 PMILOOINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
CYPRIN DAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
! COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNlOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFIC'DAE
S~*"E 16 DAPHNlDAE
CHIHONOMlDAE
PHVSiDAE
TU8IFICIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
CENTRAflCHIDAE
PERC1DAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PERODAE
DD* •<4"'GNA_ 20 DAOHNIOAE
PE°OOAE
ESOCiDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PERCiDAE
ESOCiDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
DAPHNlDAE
E'COS.i^A% •,«TlOhA-_ 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
CATOSTOMiDAE
S~AT£ f, SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
c •-,-:- NO
SIDENT FAMILY
LC50 VALUE
a ooo
9000
10803
5241
7451
16000
16392
878999
1794245
4128643
6407430
1046 139
4128.643
6487430
9464938
0496
1 147
2860
0046
0364
1 147
1630
15000
23236
32249
23236
32249
40281
54.711
6399 976
6996790
24892.828
6998.790
24692 828
57461 672
59899.703
0305
0759
0995
1 345
0256
0759
0995
1 345
83000
114316
125 121
76707
33.000
114316
125121
1323
1.595
1 700
2234
0976
1595
1 700
2-234
5,000
5 452
8000
3873
10811
30102
231 052
0664
1 279
2 300
3240
0664
1 279
3.240
3,811
E
C« COMPUUD
CV SENSITIVE S
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM DO-DAY AVERAGE
1 525 *
113263 *
171493 *
0027 * 0,0004 ACR
0021 0,0003 ACR
7511 * 0.0043 FRV
12 164 0,3378 ACR
1531 490 « 10.0 FPV
0 194 * 5.46618 FCV
0 139 9 57750 FCV
*
30219 * 40836 ACR
0650 * 00010 FRV
0434 * 00010 FRV
FR
'
0211 * 00019 FRV
0208 . 01064 ACR
0149 * 00762 ACR
AMS PE« LITER
at ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIOAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
HEPTACHLOH NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
DAPHNlDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
C6NTHARCHIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 5 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
S5 NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNlDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNlDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAe
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELLIDAEfTALITHIDAE)
DAPHNlDAE
CYPHINODONTIOAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 9 HYALELLIDAEfTALITRIDAE)
DAPHNlDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
S SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNlDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPHtNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 5 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 8 CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
Z 1~FA7"LED TO'MEET "MINIMUM~DATA REQUIREMENT
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
J - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
Ii - MAttONESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30 DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
.440 0.201 * 0 0023 FRV
.468
493
647
687 0278 * 00023 FHV
732
750
011
.995 0.251 * 00038 FHV
300
300
600
1 703 5.374 * 0,0038 FRV
26.000
37.048
50.746
4.020
80.062
358.792
80,062 14,969 * 0.00004 FCV
358.792
455.015
803.645
21 988
22.437
52.871
16.355 5.618 * 0.4494 ACR
22.437
42196
53.066
10.000
31 .623
244 259
10000 0.608 * 020 FRV
246595
763471
999.998
65.077 32.914 * 3.3931 ACR
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.456 31.086 * 3.2047 ACR
325.842
401.217
439.325
2.000 0.137 * 0.014 FRV
6.611
32601
99.553
2000 0.060 * 0014 FRV
2300
32.601
107.664
339999 82.648 * 220395 ACH
1992.474
6499.979
3479.723
339.999 81.976 * 21 8601 ACR
3669.989
6479.723
9002438
0 002 0.00053 *
0004
0.006
0.012
0011 0.00011 *
0.021
0112
4 106
1 300 0.537 * 00067 ACR
2.627
3.547
4.725
2346 0.907 * 0.0147 ACR
3547
5.223
6-033
D-31
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MINNESOTA
PHYSIO
SALMO
STATE: MISSISSIPPI
NAME LC 50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT
<+) <+) <+) (++)
AE 41 966
-JlDAE 46861
PHILOO NIDAE 92757
SALMO
PHYSIO
PHILOD
D-32
-JIDAE 36872
AE 41 966
NIDAE 92757
ARSENIC
IS CADMIUM
CHLOHDANE
CHROMIUM
$ COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DIEilDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
MOST SENSITIVE accinFNT FAMI1V FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM
(+1 <+>
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATS.
= 3C~NOTE * — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQU
- UNiTS IN MlCROGRAMS PER LITER ** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FA
14 CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
7 CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
ANGUlLLIDAE
8 GAMMARIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
5 GAMMAfllDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
13 PEflCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRlNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
3 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRlNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
10 GAMMARIDAE
OAPH NIDAE
PHILOOI NIDAE
PHYSIDAE
6 GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
18 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIOAE
TUBIFICIDAE
10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
6 DAPHNIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRlNIDAE
20 OAPH NIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
10 DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
ASELLIDAE
12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMEH6LLIDAE
5 ASELLIDAE
C6NTHARCH1DAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRlNIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
3 CYPRlNIDAE
CENTRAHCHIOAE
COENAGRIONIDAE fAGfllONIDA
REMENT
LILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
AXIMUM AND
7 451 3 368 *
8000
9000
10.803
7451 2,395 *
8,000
10.000
16.000
878999 113.263 *
1794.245
4126.643
6487430
878999 42377 *
1046,139
6487430
9484,938
0 048 0.027
0496
1 147
2.660
0163 0.059 *
0,864
1.147
2860
8325 1974 *
15,000
23.236
32.249
6.325 1.974 *
23.238 **
54.711
0000
67.000 12.164
6399.976
6998790
4892.826
67.000 4.108 *
6998790
4892.826
J0454.750
0.305 0.194
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256 0.127 *
0.759
0.995
1.345
78.707 31.429 *
83.000
114.316
125.121
83.000 27587 *
114318
167000
207,958
1.323 0.650 *
1 595
1.700
2.234
0,976 0.365 *
3.000
3.234
4,000
4 503 1 .830 *
S.OOO
5452
a ooo
5.000 1 115 *
10.611
20.000
30.102
0.664 0,206 *
1,279
2300
3.240
1 279 0.208 *
3811 **
) 87,650
0000
30. DAY AVERAGE
0.0004 ACR
0.0009 ACR
00043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3376 ACR
0.1141 ACR
5,46618 FCV
4.45175 FCV
4.2472 ACR
3.7279 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FHV
00019 FRV
00019 FflV
0.1064 ACR
0.1064 ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MISSISSIPPI
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM
ENDR N SA-,ONAL i GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALWONIOAE
PEHL'DAE
PTeRONARCtDAE
POECiL IDAE
CENTRARCHiDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
HEETACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTEHONAHDDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
AST AC OAE
STATE 4 PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
L-APHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAP-IN DAE
SAiA'ONiDAE
ST4T£ J GAWWAOiDAE
CESTRARCHiOAE
OHILOD NOAE
GAWMARiOAE
STATE ' flSELiJOAE
CENTRARCHiDAE
ICTALJHIOAE
ASTAODAE
SALMOMDAE
STATE 4 GAMMARiQAE
AST AC DAE
PHILODINIDAE
NA1DIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STA-g 11 DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PCBS NATiONAL 5 SALMON DAE
CENTHAHCHlDAE
CYPR1NIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
S'ATg 4 CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPRlN DA6
GAMMARIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGfllON
DAPHNIOAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECIL1IDAE
1 S'-.'E* •.i-iO-.jii. 9 DAPMN DAE
COTTlDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
S'A'E 5 COmDAE
CYPP-IN DAE
CENTPAPCHIQAE
PMiLODNiDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHiDAE
S-A-E 7 iCTAjjRiDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHIN OAE
DAPHNIOAE
ecV-NOTE •
- - FPV
0440 0201
0468
0493
0647
0 732 0 277 *
0750
1 Oil
1 265
0995 0.251 *
1800
2800
7800
1800 0118 *
24 771
50746
179 506
1 161 0,037 *
4020
80062
358792
1161 0035 .
358792
455015
803845
10000 3,218 *
21968
22437
52,871
10000 2174 *
52871
53066
94805
5 000 0.470 *
10000
31 623
244 259
10000 0170 *
20000
783 471
999996
65077 32914 .
233555
345472
401 217
78456 31618 *
301 510
325842
401 217
2 000 0 137 *
6611
32601
99553
6611 0520 *
32601
92054
DAE) 282 842
339 999 82 648 *
1992474
6499979
8479 723
339 999 56 854 •
3869989
9002438
12599 945
0.002 000053 *
0004
0006
0012
0004 0,00002 *
0011
0112
5517
1300 0537 *
£627
3547
4725
3 547 0 907 »
8033
14379
FINAL PLANT VALUF
FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ciMAt CHRONIC VALUE
STATE; MISSISSIPPI
0 0023 FHV $ ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIOAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0 0023 FHV STATE 1 1 DAPHNIDA6
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
00038 FRV PHILODINIDAE
0 0038 FflV
0 00003 FCV
00010 ACH
0,2574 ACR
0 1739 ACR
0.20 FRV
01133 ACR
3.3931 ACH
3 2596 ACR
0.014 FHV
0014 FRV
22 0395 ACR
151611 ACH
00087 ACR
00147 ACR
« • STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV
41.986
43.861
92757
21 223 7.634 * 47 0000 SCV
41.966
4S.264
92.757
D-33
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICPTY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MISSOURI
STATE: MISSOURI
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
IS CADMIUM
MLORQANE
CHROMIUM
I COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DSELORIN
ENDOSUIFAN
D-34
NATIONAL 14 C£*JTRARCH!DAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SAi-MONiDAE
STATE 6 CENTRARCHIQAE
PERClCHTHYlDAE
ANGLJILLIOA6
CYPRSN Qȣ
NATIONAL 9 GAMWARIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONiDAg
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 4 DAPHN DAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NATIONAL IB SALMONIOAg
DAPHNSOAE
QAMMARIDA6
PHYSlOAE
STATE 13 PERClCHTHYlDAE
DAPMNIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
PHYS DAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMAR1DAE
STATE 3 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTHARCH10AE
NATIONAL !0 GAM-MA^DAE
DAPHN DAE
PHILQDINIOAE
PHYSlDAE
STATE 5 PHILOO NiDAS
PHYSlDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
CYPfliNIQAE
NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDA6
CHfHQNOMIOAE
PHYSlDAE
TUBtRC DAE
STATE 16 DAPHNIDAE
CHlftONOMIDAE
PHYSSDAE
TUBIFIC DAE
NATIONAL 10 SALMON DAE
DAPHNIDAE
CeNTRARCHIOAE
PERClDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINtDAE
PHYSlOAE
NATIONAL 10 OAPHNJDAE
PERClDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMAfl-.OA£
ESOClOAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
NATIONAL 12 POECIL IDAE
ASEU-IDAE
SALMONIDAE
PALAEMONIQAE
CYPRIN DAE
DAPHNIDAE
NATiONAL 9 SALMONIDAi
CYPRlN DAE
PTERONARClQAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 4 CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAGRtONIDAE sAGRION
~. UNI'
FRV
SCV
( + ) ( + ) 1 + ) (•(-+)
7 «51 3 338 *
8000
9000
10 803
7 451 2.551 *
10,000
16000
16392
376999 1U263 *
1794345
U-S2S643
1648743Q
1046139 140493 *
164B7 430
20194383
0048 0.027 » 00004 ACR
0496
1 147
2.860
0163 0,059 * 00009 ACR
3B64
2S6C
1SOOO
23,538
32249
6,326 1 974 * 0.0043 FRV
23238 **
54 711
0000
67 000 12 '64 0.3378 ACS
6399 976
6998790
24892 628
6993 790 154S824 * 10,0 FPV
24892.826
30454.750
57461. 67Z
0,305 0194 546618 FCV
0759
0995
1345
0256 0127 * 957750 FCV
0995
1 345
76 707 31 429 * 4.2472 ACR
33000
114.316
'25.121
83.000 16 127 * 2 1792 ACR
U431G
207 358
431499
1 323 0,650 00010 FRV
1 595
! 700
2234
i>00
2.409
3234
4503 1 830 * 00019 FRV
5000
5452
8.000
10 81 1 0.832 * 0 0019 FRV
20000
30 102
231 052
0 864 0 203 * 0 1064 ACR
1 279
2.300
32«!
1 279 0036 * 0-01 85 ACR
3240
3.BH
DAE! S765C
FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
SALMONIDAE
PERU DAE
PTERONARCIQAE
STATE 9 CYPHINIOAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTEHONARCfOAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERUDAE
ASTACfOAE
STATE 5 PALAEMONIDAE
ASTACIDAE
OAPHNiDAE
SS LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONiDAE
CYPHINIOAE
STATE 3 CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHIIOD1NSDAE
SAIMONIOAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCMiDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHN1DAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 3 OAMMARIDAE
PHIIODINIOAE
NAID1DAE
IS NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHGMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHItODINJDAE
STATE 11 DAPHN10AE
PERCIChTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHiDAE
PHiLODtNiDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAg
GAMMAfllDAE
STATE 3 CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CO£NAGR!QNIDA£{ASRIQNIOA
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELLIDAEfTALITRIDAG)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTSDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
1 SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIOAE
COTTSDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
STATE 4 COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
TOXAPHgNE NATIONAL 52 PERL1DAE
PTEHONAHCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTHA^CHSDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3-7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TQ DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
(+) (+1 1+) <++)
0468
0,493
0,647
0.732 O.J77 * 0.0023 FBV
0,750
1.011
1.266
0 995 0,251 * 0.0038 FRV
1 600
2.800
7.800
1 800 0.202 * 0,0038 FRV
7,800
2*. 771
50.748
1.161 0.037 * 0.00003 FCV
4,020
30.062
358.792
358792 0.037 * 0.00003 FCV
455,015 **
S03.845
0.000
21S83
33,437
52.871
2.000 0.285 * 0.0228 ACR
52J7t
53.066
94,805
5,000 0.470 * 050 FRV
10.000
31623
244,259
10,000 0 470 * 0.20 FRV
763.471 *»
999 998
0,000
65.077 3S.fl14 * 3.3831 ACfl
233.555
345.472
401,217
78.458 31.578 * 3.2553 ACfl
301.510
345472
401.217
2,000 0.137 * 0.014 FRV
6.611
32.801
99.553
6.611 0.137 * 0.014 FHV
32601 +*
E} 282.542
0,000
339.999 82.648 * 22.0395 ACfl
1992.474
8499.979
8479723
3sss!&es
9002,438
2599.945
0,002 0.00053 *
0.004
0.006
0,012
0,004 Q 00001 *
0.011
0.112
5,517
1.300 0.537 * 0,0087 ACW
2827
3,547
4.725
3.000 0.905 * 0.0147 ACfl
3.547
4,725
8.033
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MISSOURI
STATE: MONTANA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE HE-anPNT
(+) 1+) (+) (++)
;:\C \ATiQSAL 15 OAPMNiDftE 13 737 6 148 47 0000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRAHCHIDAE
•>SiDA£ 41 966 ASELLIDAE
; ^LD^,o|6 11*11 EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE i i PHtw DAE 21 223 7 684 * 47 0000 SCV STATE 8 CENTRAHCKMDAE
Qr!?«L*.n.c «2f! EPHEMERELLIDAE
Joo USS 92 5£ cS5S!KE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
SS CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CHLOHDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINtDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE B PTERONARCIOAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILOOINIOAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRI NIDAE
S COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIRCIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIRCIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIOAE
ESOC10AE
GAMMARIOAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
OIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILItOAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIOAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
F*W FINAL wEoioue VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 r TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
SCi> SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30 DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
7.451 3.368 *
8.000
9000
10.603
7451 2.638 *
9,000
14377
16.392
678.999 113263 *
1794.245
14128.643
16487430
1794245 407358 *
14128643
16487430
19484,938
0048 0.027 0.0004 ACR
0.496
1 147
2.860
0.034 0,009 0.0001 ACR
0.498
1.147
2860
6.325 1.974 * 00043 FRV
15.000
23236
32.249
15.000 5061 * 0.0043 FRV
23.238
26000
40.044
67.000 12164 * 0.3378 ACR
6399.976
6998790
24692 826
6399.976 781.038 * 100 FPV
6998790
24892.828
57461.672
0305 0194 * 546618 FCV
0759
0995
1 345
0.305 0. 1 32 * 0.01 505 FCV
0759
0.995
1345
76.707 31.429 * 4 2472 ACR
83.000
114316
125.121
76.707 28.920 * 3.9081 ACR
83,000
114316
125121
1323 0.650 00010 FHV
1.595
1,700
2234
1.323 0.510 * 0.0010 FRV
1 595
1.700
3000
4503 1830 * 0,0019 FRV
5.000
5452
8000
5154 1381 * 0.0019 FflV
8000
10811
24000
0664 0208 * 01064 ACR
1.279
2300
3240
0664 0196 * 01003 ACR
1 279
2.300
3.240
D-35
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MONTANA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
NO IN NA 1 NAL 17
STATE 9
HEPTACHLOfl NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
IS LEAD NATIONAL 7
STATE 5
LINDANE NATIONAL 10
STATE 8
MERCURY NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
II NICKEL NATIONAL Ib
STATE 9
PCBS NATIONAL 5
STATE 3
SELENIUM NAL 0
STATE 7
S SILVER NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
STATE 10
D-36
STATE: MONTANA
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTEHON6RCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONAflCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PTERONARCiDAE
PERLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
GAMMAfllDAE
DAPMN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRAflCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHGMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODlNIOAE
DAPHN DAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIflONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMON DAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OAPHN DAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTflARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
- - - FPV
ACR
FCV
SCu
(•*•) (•*•)
0468
0493
0647
0383 0133 *
0493
0,647
i 011
0995 OZ51 *
1800
2600
7800
0,995 0 101 *
2 BOO
26,000
29000
1161 0037 *
4020
80062
358792
4 020 0 2B7 *
80062
358792
455,015
21986
22,437
52871
18933 7 WO *
42 198
48.000
53.066
5 000 0.470 *
10.000
31,623
244 259
5.000 0101 *
10.000
244 259
783471
65.077 32.914 *
233.555
345472
401 217
65077 21.717 *
401217
439,825
444717
2000 0 137 *
6611
32601
99553
2000 0.137 *
2300 • »
32601
0000
1992 A7a
6499.979
8479 723
1992474
8479 723
9002438
0002 000053 *
0004
0006
0012
0002 000015 •
0011
0021
0 112
1 300 0 537 *
2627
3547
4725
1 300 0 543 .
2627
2648
3.547
FINAL PLANT VALUE
30 DAY
< + )
00023
00038
00036
000003
000003
0.2574
0.5672
0.20
00674
3.3931
2.2388
0.014
0014
'
13 1
00087
00083
FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC
VALUE
(++) ( + ) ( + ) (-*•) (++)
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
FRV STATE 10 OAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
FRV
FRV
FCV
FCV
ACS
ACR
FflV
ACR
ACH
ACR
FRV
FRV
*
ACR
ACR
ACR
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
8148 "0000 SCV
41.966
48.861
92.757
13737 4677 470000 SCV
41 966
56.455
92757
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NEBRASKA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
STATE 6
STATE 5
STATE ir
™
S COPs£a SAT,QNAL 23
STATE 16
S-i'E 6
03- -.A'O-.A.. e»
$**'£ 9
—
NAME
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SitMONJOAE
SALMON'DAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
?APHN,DAE
SAL^OMDAE
CENTRAftCH.SAE
T4PHVDAE
SALMON lOAE
PERCiChTHYiOAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHVSIQAE
PTERONARClDAE
CYPOiNlOAE
GAM MAPI DAE
CVPSlNIDAE
SALWOMDAE
CENT»A«CH|OAE
DAPHNIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PwiLODiNiDAE
PHYSlDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSlDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIPONOM'DAE
DAPHNIDAE
C-iRONOWiOAE
OAP-MDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERODA.E
ESOCIDAE
CENTHARCHIOAg
POECILMDAE
ASELLIDAE
SAL-/ONIDAE
EPHEMEHELLiDAE
SALMONIOAE
Sir
i*i (+)
8000
9000
10803
4 503 1 333 *
7451
10000
18000
1794245
6487430
1794 245 363446 *
4128643
9484 938
0496
2660
0 034 0 006 *
0 163
0496
2860
15000
23238
32249
23238 7016 *
33862
54711
56267
6399976
6998790
24892 826
6399976 1208644 *
6996790
24692.828
30454750
0305 0.194
0759
0.995
1345
0305 OtSO *
0759
0995
1 345
83000
125121
76 707 28 920 *
83000
125 121
1 323 0 650
1 595
1 700
2234
1 323 0 432 *
1 595
1 700
3282
4503 1830 •
5000
5452
8000
2459 0121 *
10811
30 102
190745
1 279
2300
3240
0664 0149 *
1 27B
3240
00004 ACH
00001 ACR
0 0043 FRV
10 0 FPV
546616 FCV
9 92408 FCV
42472 ACR
39061 ACR
0,0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
00019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0 0762 ACR
STATE: NEBRASKA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 3Q.DAY AVER AGE
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERUDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIOAE
CYPHINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
0440 0.201 * 0.0023 FRV
0.468
0,493
0.647
0.556 0,153 * 0.0023 FRV
0.732
1 011
COENAGRIONIDAE(AGRIONIDAE) 1 800
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONAHCIDAE 0 995 0 251 * rt HOIfi PRtf
PALAEMONIDAS
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
M LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMAHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIOAE
GAMMARIOAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
PERCIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 4 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
M NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CEN7RARCHIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIOAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
COENAGRIONIOAE (AGRION
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIOAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 7 HYALELLIOAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
1 SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
CYPRtNODONTIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PEHLIDAE
PTERONARClDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
STATE 7 CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
1 600
2800
7800
13 058 1,440 * 0.0036 FRV
26000
56566
179503
1 161 0.037 * 000003 FCV
4020
80062
356.792
4020 0.287 * 0.00004 FCV
80062
358792
455.015
10000 3.218 * 0.2574 ACR
21.986
22437
52871
14 158 4196 * 0.3356 ACR
42198
53066
66000
5000 0470 * 0,20 FRV
10000
31623
244 259
5.000 0.240 * 0 1602 ACR
246.595
763471
999998
85.077 32.914 * 33931 ACR
233.555
345472
401 217
65077 23.365 * 2.4087 ACR
301510
401.217
439825
2000 0137 * 0.014 FRV
6611
32601
99553
2.000 0.024 * 0.014 FRV
32601
I DAE) 282 842
1992 474
6499.979
8479.723
339999 52.431 * 13.9616 ACR
1992474
6479.723
9002.436
0.002 0.00053 *
0.004
0006
0012
0002 0.00015 *
0011
0021
0112
1 300 0 537 * 0 0067 ACR
2627
3547
4725
2648 0.851 * 0.0138 ACR
3547
6.678
8033
- - UNITS IN MICUOOHAW;, PER LITER
FH'j MNAL RESIDUE VALUE
• • - STATE HAS LESS TH»
APPLY EQUATION 3 7
APPLY EQUATION 37
N 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NEBRASKA STATE: NEVADA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCBO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) <+) (+) (++) <+> <+> !+> <++)
S ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13 737 6 148 47 0000 SCV ALDHIN NATIONAL 14 CENTHARCHIDAE
PMVSIDAE 41 966 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48 861 EPHEMEHELLIDAE
PHfLODINIDAE 92 757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 1 1 DAPHNIDAE 13 737 5 799 * 47 0000 SCV STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41 966 CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIOAE 46,550 EPHEMEHELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYOIAE 49,264 CYPRINIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTflARCHIDAE
W CADMIUM NATIONAL IB SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 6 CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
SALMONIDAE
S COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIHONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
PLANORB1DAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PEHCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
COO'NOT£ . _ FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
- UNITS IN MICRO-GRAMS PER LITER * * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
._ _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE s - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ccv FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
n.Tft SCv SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30 DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
7.451 3388 *
8000
9.000
10603
4,503 1 730 *
7,451
9000
11.314
378.999 113.263 *
1794.245
14128.643
16487.430
1794.245 363.446 *
14128.643
16487.430
19464.938
0046 0.027 * 0.0004 ACH
0496
1.147
2.660
0,034 0,009 0.0001 ACR
0496
1 147
2.660
6.325 1.974 * 0.0043 FflV
15.000
23.238
32.249
15.684 4.693 * 0.0043 FRV
26000
33.662
54.711
67.000 12,164 * 0.3378 ACR
6399.976
6996.790
24692.828
6399.976 719,954 * 10,0 FPV
6998.790
29999.867
63804.148
0.305 0.194 5.46618 FCV
0.759
0,995
1345
0.305 0.121 9.07713 FCV
0759
1.345
1424
BsioOO
114.316
125.121
76.707 26.459 * 3,8456 ACR
63.000
121.020
125.121
1.323 0,650 0.0010 FRV
1.595
1 700
2.234
1,323 0,501 * 0.0010 FRV
1,595
1.900
3,000
5.000
5452
8.000
2.459 0.746 * 0.0019 FRV
4.503
8.000
10.811
0.664 0.206 * 0.1064 ACR
1.279
2.300
3.240
0664 0,185 * 00844 ACR
3.700
3,611
5800
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NEVADA
STATE: NEVADA
TOXICANT
ENOP'N
SS LEAD
U NC-iE-
PC8S
S SIJ./SB
TOxAP-E'-e
NUMBER OP MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE
( + )
NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEiOAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PTERONAHClDAE
POECiLIIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERUDAE
ASTAC1DAE
STATE 7 PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMACIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 9 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMAfilOAE
iCTALURiOAE
GAMMARIDAE
AST AC 1 DAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLiDAE
CENTHARCHIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 2 SALMONIDAE
CENTPAflCHiDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTlDAE
SALMOMDAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIOAE
POECiLIIDAE
COTTiDAE
C'PR'NiDAE
CVP»iNOOONTiDAE
STATE ' OAPHNIOAE
C'ORiMDAE
SALMOMOAE
NATIONAL 12 PEftL'0*6
PT6°ONA»CiOAE
iCTALUftiDAE
CENTRAOCHlDAE
PTERONAPClDAE
ICT 6 !_'„"»' DAE
c',0'i.OTt
AC*
eCV
SCV
0440
0468
0493
0647
0320
0357
0540
0949
0995
1 900
2800
7800
0,900
13058
26000
29000
1 161
4020
80062
358792
4020
80062
455015
532856
10000
21986
22437
52871
14158
42198
48000
53.066
5000
10000
31623
244 259
5.000
10000
248,595
783471
65077
233555
345472
401217
65077
401 217
439825
456.642
2000
6611
32601
99553
2000
2300
0000
0000
339999
1992474
6499 979
8479 723
339999
1992 474
8479 723
12599945
0002
0,004
0006
0012
0002
0004
0,021
0112
1 300
2627
3547
4725
2848
3.000
3547
6078
y IN WlC"OCj
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE
MAXIMUM 30-DAY
1+) (+)
0201 . 00023
0 099 * 0 0023
0251 * 0,0036
0 160 * 00036
0037 * 000003
0322 * 000003
3218 * 02574
5390 * 0,4312
0470 * 020
0101 * 00671
32914 * 33931
21656 * 22327
0.137 * 0014
0 137 * 0.014
»*
82648 . 220395
54141 * 14.4376
000053 *
000008 *
0537 * 00087
0914 * 00146
RAMS PER LITER
•*T VALUE
FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SENSiTivE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
CAVERAQE TOXICANT «JI!{ ?«?««,, M°ST 8ENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCMVALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
FRV S ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
Fflv STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
FRv POECIUIOAE
FRV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
• • _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES- NATIONAL VALUE USED
j _ HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30'DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV
41966
46,661
92757
13,737 3.346 47.0000 SCV
49.969
92,757
251 .461
D-39
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NEW HAMPSHIRE
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME
ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 9 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 4 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
IS CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 15 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CHIORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 CYPHfNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHN DAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
S COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHN DAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUB
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NEW HAMPSHIRE STATE: NEW JERSEY
( + > < + t ( + ) (T-+) * Lt
S Z.NC NATIONAL 11 ^JJ«J« ^737 6148 470000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48.881 poScMcnci , m«c
PHILODINIDAE 92 757 - C^nSS
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE 21 223 8 408 47.0000 SCV STATE 9 SALMONIDAE
ULMnwILp W nu CENTRARCHIDAE
PHit onVNinAF 09 7*7 EPHEMERELLIDAE
rniLuuiniuAfi a/ /a' CYPHINIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMAHIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
SI CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 57 SALMONIOAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARC1DAE
CYPR1NIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 CYPRIN1DAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
I COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICEDAE
STATE 16 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
STATE 9 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
ASTACIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIOAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
,.',i", il, Mir, KOGFIAMS PER LITER ** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
c K t PlNAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLV EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
/•' f COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD « - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
'S, • iLNSHivE &PECIE5 CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) ( + ) (j.1 [4.+ 1
1— I Hi \Zl \T+i
7451 3.386 *
8.000
9.000
10.803
4.503 1 796 *
7.451
9.000
11 314
873.999 113283 *
1794.245
14128.643
16487430
1046.139 171.493 *
14128.643
16487430
19484.938
0.048 0.027 0.0004 ACR
0.496
1.147
2-660
0.034 0.021 0.0003 ACR
0.884
1.147
1 630
6.325 1.974 * 0.0043 FRV
15.000
23238
32.249
15.684 4.569 * 0.0043 FRV
33.662
40.000
54.711
67.000 12.164 0.3378 ACH
6399.976
6996.790
24892J26
6998.790 1604.673 * 10.0 FPV
24692.826
30454750
63804.148
0.305 0.194 5.46618 FCV
0.759
0.995
1.345
0256 0.139 8 308W FCV
0.759
0.995
1.345
76.707 31 429 * 4.2472 ACR
83.000
114.316
125121
76.707 30.219 * 40836 ACR
B3.000
114.316
125.121
1.323 0.650 0.0010 FHV
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.976 0.344 * 0.0010 FRV
1.595
1664
3.000
4.503 1830 * 0.0019 FRV
5.000
5.452
8.000
2.459 0.382 * 0.0019 FRV
8.000
10.811
41.000
0 664 0.208 * 0 1 064 ACR
1.279
2300
3.240
0664 0.147 * 0.0751 ACR
3.240
3,811
6.000
D-41
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NEW JERSEY
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTElDAE
SALMONIOAE
PEHLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONlDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTAC1DAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
» LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCH10AE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPR1NIOAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
STATE 7 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 OAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 4 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
SS NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHN DAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
(+)
04*0
0468
0493
0647
0556
0750
1011
1.800
2800
7800
13058
26000
47329
50748
1 161
4020
60,062
356.792
80,062
455015
803845
614803
10000
21 988
22.437
52871
10488
14158
42 198
44,000
5000
10000
31623
244 259
10000
248.595
733471
999.998
65.077
233 555
345.472
401 217
78456
401 217
439 825
2000
6611
32.601
99.553
2.000
2300
107 664
COENAGRIONIDAE lAGRIONIDAEl 282 842
DAPHN DAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 8 HYALELUDAE ITALITR
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILI OAE
COTTIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINOOONTIDAE
STATE 3 SALMONIOAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PHILODIN10AE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRAHCMIDAE
STATE 8 CENTRAHCHIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CVPR1N DAE
- -
n.4?
1992.474
6499 979
8479.723
DAE) 339 999
3869 989
8479 723
12599,945
0,004
0006
0.012
0021
0.112
5.517
0000
2627
3547
4725
2846
4193
6678
6782
UNITS IN MICROGHA*
< + ) (•*)
0.201 * 0 0023
0 166 * 00023
*
3521 * 0.0038
0 037 * 0 00003
14,070 * 000004
3218 * 02574
2 423 • 0 1936
0470 * 020
0 639 * 0 20
32.914 * 3.3931
33129 * 34153
0137 * 0014
0.020 * 0014
*
66.265 * 176705
*
0.00053 *
*
1045 * 00169
*S PER LITER
ALUE
STATE: NEW JERSEY
AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30. DAY AVERAGE
< + + ) ( + ) ( + ) (•••) ( + + )
FRV S ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
FflV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FHV
FRV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACH
ACH
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
13.737 6.146 47.0000 SCV
41.966
4B.B61
92.757
4-K968
46550
92,757
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NEW MEXICO
NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
a^DR'N NATIONAL 14
STATE 10
iOSEMC NATIONAL 8
STATE 6
M C*DWi!/W NATIONAL 18
STATE 15
NAT
^
STATE $
CHROU1UU NA7>C"«AL 10
STATE 7
S COPPER NATIONAL 23
s TE
STATE 7
3" NATIONAL 20
STA-E 12
D.EuORlN NATIONAL '2
STATE 3
ENDCSUL.FAN NATIONAL 9
STATg 8
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50VALUE
1 + 1
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIOAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTMYIOAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMAfliDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHH.OD NiDAE
PHYSIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PMYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBtFIC DAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFIC DAE
DAPHN' DAE
PEHCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAPHN DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PEP-C'DAE
ESOCiDAE
GAMMAPlDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECIUIDAE
ASEUJDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLtOAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRiN DAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
rCOT,
8000
9000
10,803
4.503
7451
9,000
10000
878999
14128643
16487430
1794245
14128643
16487 430
19484938
0048
0496
1 147
2860
0034
Oi63
0*96
1 147
6325
15000
23238
32249
15000
23236
26000
33662
67000
6399976
6998790
24892 826
6399976
6998790
24892 628
30454750
0305
0759
0995
1 345
0759
0.995
1345
63000
125 121
76707
63 000
11016
125121
1 323
1595
1700
2234
1 323
1 595
3000
4 102
4503
5000
5452
8000
2459
8000
10,811
24000
0.664
1279
2300
3240
06&4
1279
2300
3240
on
- UMTS IN MICP.OGW
- PPV FINAL PLANT
ACR COMPUTED B
FCV FINAL CHRO
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
I*) !+) <++)
3.386 •
1926 .
113263 *
407 358 *
0.027 0 0004 ACR
0.012 0.0002 ACR
1 974 * 00043 FRV
5588 * 00043 FRV
12.164 . 03378 ACfl
1208644 * 10.0 FPV
0.194 548618 FCV
0 150 9 85862 FCV
29583 * 39977 ACR
0 650 0.0010 FRV
0459 . 00010 FflV
1 830 » 00019 FRV
0632 . 00019 FRV
0208 * 01064 ACR
0196 * 01003 ACR
MS PER LITER
VALUE
Y ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
HIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: NEW MEXICO
NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ENOflIN NATIONAL 17
STATE 10
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
$$ LEAD NATIONAL 7
STATE 5
STATE 7
MERCURY NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
SS NICKEL NATIONAL 16
STATE 11
PCBS
STATE 3
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10
STATE 8
I SILVER NATIONAL 9
STATE 6
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12
STATE 10
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
( + )
OASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTEflONARCIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTEHONAflCIDAE
POEClLHDAE
PTEHONAflCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIOAE
ASTACIDAE
PTEHONARCIDAE
PEHLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMAfliDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPfliNIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRlNIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMAfliDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
ICTALUH1DAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
SENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYAL.ELL1DAE (TALITRIDAE)
OAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIOAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRlNODONTIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTT1DAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CTALUfllOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CTALUR1DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
* • - STATE HAS LESS THAN * RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
J - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
3Q.DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
0440
0,493
0.647
0.357
0,493
0.647
0750
0995
1.800
2800
7600
099S
2.800
13.058
24.771
1 161
4.020
80.062
358.792
4.020
80062
358792
455015
21.968
22437
52.871
14 158
46000
52.871
53066
5000
10000
31623
244.259
5,000
10000
248.595
763471
65077
233.555
345472
401-217
301.510
401.217
439825
6611
99553
2000
6611
3260)
0.000
339-999
1992 474
6499979
6479.723
339,999
1992.474
6479,723
9002.438
0002
0004
0.006
0.012
0,002
0004
0006
0.021
1.300
2,627
3547
4725
1 300
2.627
3547
4 725
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30- DAY AVERAGE
0,201 *
0148 »
0.251 *
0.128 *
0,037 *
0287 *
*
4794 »
0470 Ir
0101 *
32.914 ,
25017 *
0137 *
*»
82648 *
60,162 *
000053 *
0.00030 *
0.537 *
0494 *
0.0023
0.0023
0,0038
0.0038
000003
0.00004
0.2574
0.3835
0.20
0.0671
3.3931
2.5790
0.014
22.0395
160431
0.0087
00080
FRV
FRV
FHV
FRV
FCV
FCV
ACH
ACR
FRV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FHV
ACfl
ACR
ACR
ACR
D-43
-------
APPENDIX Q
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NEW MEXICO STATE: NEW YORK
(*) ( + ) (•••) (++> <+) < + ) ( + ) (+•»•)
S ZINC NATIONAL >5 HN10AE 3 737 6 148 47 0000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
SIDAE 1 966 ASELLIDAE
MONIOAE 8 861 EPHEMERELLIDAE
ODINlDAE 2 757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 12 HNIDAE 3737 6035 470000 SCV STATE 10 SALMONIDAE
SIDAE 1 966 CENTHARCH10AE
CICHTHYIDAE 49 264 EPHEMERELLIDAE
MONIDAE 49 969 ANGUILLIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL B GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATS 6 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUHIOAE
IS CADMIUM NATIONAL 1B SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 17 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPH1NODONTIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTEflONARCIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 5 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMAHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 7 GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PEflCICHTHYIDAE
S COPPER NATIONAL z3 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 20 DAPHNIDAE
CHIHONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTflARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDA6
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 14 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DIELORIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
= CC*NOT£ * - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
•> j j scv SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30 DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
7.451 3,388 *
6000
9.000
10.B03
5.241 1.829 *
7.451
9,000
16000
876 999 113.263 *
1794 246
1412B643
16467430
878999 56980 *
1046.139
14128.643
16487430
0.048 0027 0.0004 ACR
0.496
1 147
2.860
0.048 0.029 0.0004 ACR
0.864
1 147
1.630
6.325 1.974 * 0.0043 FRV
15.000
23236
32.249
6.325 1,559 * 0.0043 FRV
23236
32,249
40281
67000 12.164 0,3378 ACR
G399 976
6996790
24892 828
67.000 5.387 * 0.1496 ACR
6998790
24892 828
30454.750
0.305 0.194 5.46618 FCV
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256 0.151 5.32754 FCV
0759
0.995
1 345
76 707 31 429 * 4 2472 ACR
83.000
H4316
125121
76.707 30219 * 4,0836 ACR
83000
114.316
125.121
1.323 0.650 0.0010 PRV
1595
1.700
2.234
0976 0.456 * 0.0010 FRV
1.595
1.700
2.234
4.503 1.830 * 0.0019 FRV
5.000
5.452
8000
3673 1,080 * 00019 FRV
8,000
10.611
20000
0,664 0208 * 01064 ACR
1.279
2300
3240
0.664 0.149 * 00762 ACR
1.279
3.240
3.811
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NEW YORK
STATE: NEW YORK
TOXICANT
ENDfliM
SS LEAD
U sCXEt
PCSS
S S>./£0
FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC 50 VALUE MAXIMUM
t + l < + )
\A''ONAi. 17 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERL'OAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 1 ' GASTEROSTEiDAE
SALMON10AE
OPRINIDAE
POECILiiDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERUDAE
ASTAClDAE
STATE 6 PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONiOAE
CENTRARCHiDAE
GAMMARlDAE
DAPMMDAE
SALMON lOAg
CYPP.INIDAE
STATg <, GAWUAPUDAE
SALVONIOAE
CTpqiNrOAE
SAL'-'O'JiOAE
GAWWARlOAE
STAT£ SAi-WOMDAE
GA'^WA«(DAE
icTAi.uR'Oae
GAMMARIDAE
ASTAClDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 6 QAMMAfllDAE
ASTAClDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
EPHEMEftELLIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
S~**= 13 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHlO^E
PHILODINIDAE
CHiPOMOMiCAE
CENTpftpCHiDAE
CYPPiNlQAE
GAWVAPIOA6
STATE 5 SA^VON-DSE
r ypaiM jAE
GA'/'^SPiDAE
DAPHNIDAE
C-PRiNODONTiDAE
5AUVONiOA£
DAP-iN.DAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPR'NiOAE
COTTIDAE
CYPfllNIOAE
CYPRlNODONTlDAE
$-*'£ 6 COTTlDAE
CYPRiNIDAE
SALVONIDAE
CENTRARCMIDAE
PTEOONARCIDAE
iCTALUHIDAE
CENTftAPCHlDAE
STATE 'i iCTALUSiDAE
CENTRAflCHIQAE
SAL'/OrilOAE
CfPPINlDAE
I°?"'Vf,J,.,-
fPf
0440 0201 •
0468
0493
0647
0440 0205 *
0687
0732
0750
0995 0251 *
1600
2600
7800
1 800 0 333 *
17703
24771
37048
1 161 0,037 *
4020
60,062
358792
1 161 0054 *
80.062
358 792
4550)5
10000 3.218 *
21988
22437
52871
18355 5057 *
22437
5287:
53066
5 000 0 470 *
10000
31 623
244259
10000 0764 *
50000
248595
783,471
65077 32914 .
233555
345472
401 217
78 456 35 088 *
345472
401.217
439 825
2000 0,137 *
6611
32601
99553
2000 0137 *
6611
32601
99553
339999 62648 *
1992474
6409979
8479723
339999 72017 *
3869989
8479723
9002438
0002 000053 *
0004
0006
0012
0004 000041 *
0011
0021
OH2
1 300 0 937 *
2827
3547
4725
3 547 1 340 *
4725
5223
8033
IN '/iCBOGRAML PER LITER
t-iNAL PLANT VALUt
CINAL oEi,(DUE VALUE
Hr,ii_ CHUQNiC VALUE
'.,lNT,iiivE SPECIES CHRONIC V
« SIl? UFE TSn- NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT
30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME L
0 0023 FHV I ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
„„„,,„ _,, PHILOOINIDAE
0.0023 FRV STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIOAE
00018 FRV PHIL001N,D«E
00038 FRV
0 00003 FCV
0.00004 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0 4045 ACR
0.20 FRV
020 FHV
3 3931 ACR
3.6172 ACR
0014 FRV
0014 FRV
22 0395 ACR
192044 ACR
0 0087 ACR
002' 7 ACR
• * _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
NIC RATIO METHOD IS - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 37 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
ALUE 30 DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
60 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
13737 8 148 * 470000 SCV
41 966
48861
92757
21 223 8056 470000 SCV
41.276
41966
92.757
D-45
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NORTH CAROLINA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME
AIDRIN NATIONAL U CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONfDAE
STATE 9 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIOAE
CYPHINIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 4 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDA6
SS CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 16 SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINOOONTIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTflARCHIDAE
DAPHN DAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 PHILODINIOAE
PHYSIOAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
S COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIF CIDAE
STATE IB DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIF CIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PERCIOAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
PERCIOAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 9 DAPHN DAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECIL IDAE
ASELL DAE
SALMONtOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIOAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CCC~NOTE
- UNITS
. - - FPV
0-«6 scv
LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30. DAY AVERAGE
1+) (+) <+) (+-O
7451 3388 *
8000
9000
10803
4 503 1 796 *
7451
9000
878999 113263 *
1794245
14t28.643
16467 430
1046 139 132.343 *
14128643
19484,938
26041 675
0048 0027 0,0004 ACR
0496
1 147
2,860
0034 0,019 00003 ACfl
0364
1.630
15.000
23238
32249
15684 4.569 * 00043 FRV
33.862
40000
54711
6399,976
6998 790
24892 828
6998 7M 1604,673 * 10.0 FPV
24892 828
30454.750
63804 1 AB
0.305 0194 5.46618 FCV
0.759
0995
1 345
0,258 0139 762932 FCV
0759
0995
1 345
76707 31 429 * 42472 ACR
83000
114 316
125 121
76 707 29 533 * 3 9977 ACR
83.000
114316
125 121
1 595
1 700
2234
0976 0344 00010 FRV
1 595
1 664
3000
4503 1 630 * 00019 FHV
5000
5452
3000
2459 0.382 * 0.0019 FRV
8000
10.811
41000
0664 0208 * 01064 ACR
1279
3240
0664 0147 * 00751 ACR
3240
38H
6000
IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
FINAL PLANT VALUE
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: NORTH CAROLINA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ENDHIN NATIONAL 17
STATE 9
HEPTACHLOR N TIONAL 10
STATE 5
SS LEAD NATIONAL 7
STATE 4
STATE 7
STATE 4
SS NICKEL NATIONAL 16
STATE 12
PCBS NATIONAL 5
STATE 4
STATE 7
S SILVER NATIONAL 9
STATE 3
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12
STATE 8
NAME LCBO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) { + ) 1+) (++)
GASTEHOSTEIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
0.440 0.201 *
0468
0.493
0647
0,556 0.178 *
0750
1.011
COENAGRIONIDAE(AGRIONIOAE) 1 300
PALAEMON1DAE
PERLIOAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAS
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTflARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMEflELLIOAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
1.300
2.800
7.800
13.058 3.446 *
24.771
47.329
50748
1 161 0037 *
4.020
80,062
358792
80.062 14.070 *
455.015
803.845
814.803
21 938
22.437
52.871
10.463 1.952 *
14.156
52.871
64.000
10.000
31.623
244259
10.000 0.639 *
243.595
783.471
999.996
65.077 32.S14 *
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.456 33129 *
345,472
401217
439.825
2.000 0 137 *
6.611
32.601
99.553
2.000 0,047 *
6,811
107.664
COENAGR[ONIDAE(AGRIONIDAE) 282.642
DAPHNIDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONAflCIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
S — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DEI EHMINE MAXIMUM AND
1992.474
8499.979
8479.723
339.999 57 358 *
3669,939
8479.723
12599,945
0.002 000053 *
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.021 0.00053 *
0.112 **
5.517
0.000
1.300 0.537 *
2.627
4725
3.000 1093 *
4725
3.676
8129
0.0023
0.0023
0.0038
0.0038
000003
0.00003
0.1561
0.20
3.3931
34153
0014
0.014
22.0395
15.2955
00087
0,0177
FHV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FCV
FCV
ACR
FRV
ACH
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACH
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NORTH CAROLINA
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
DAPHNlDAE
PHVSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODlNIOAE
DAPHNlDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
92757
21 223
41966
46.550
92757
STATE: NORTH DAKOTA
NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ALDRIN NATIONAL 14
STATE 8
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8
STATE 5
M CADMIUM NATIONAL IB
STATE 12
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8
STATE 5
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 1O
STATE 6
$ COPPER NATIONAL 23
STATE 15
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
DDT NATIONAL 20
STATE 10
D1EIDHIN NATIONAL 1
STATE 5
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9
STATE 7
NAME
CENTRAflCHIDAE
AS6LLIOA6
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIOAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPHtNOOONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTEHONAHCIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
PHILOD1NIDAE
PHYSIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
PEHCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LC50 VALUE
(*)
745i
8,000
9.000
10803
4503
7451
16.392
21 000
878,999
1794.245
14128.643
16487430
1794.245
13339.965
16467430
19484936
0.046
0,496
1,147
2660
0.044
0,496
1.147
1 630
6.325
15.000
23.236
32249
23 238
25461
26000
54711
67000
6399.976
6998790
24892.828
6399.976
6998.790
24892.828
57461.672
0.305
0.7S9
0.995
1.345
0.305
0759
0.995
1.022
76.707
63.000
114316
125121
57000
83000
114316
125.121
1.323
1595
1.700
2.234
1.323
1 595
1.700
3.000
5000
5452
8.000
2.459
10.611
30.102
190.745
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664
U79
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
1+) (+) (++1
3366 *
1 090 *
113.263 *
363601 *
0027
0.014
1.974 *
6.064 *
12,164
781.038 *
0.194
0.150
31.429 *
20.746 *
0,650
0472 *
1 830 *
0148 *
0208 *
0 161 *
0,0004 ACR
00002 ACH
0 0043 FRV
0.0043 FHV
0.3376 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.46618 FCV
9.92406 FCV
4.2472 ACR
2 6035 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FHV
00019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.0823 ACR
«.,
" MiCHQGHAMO e£R LifEH
INAL "E'jIDUE VALUE
1
- FAILED
- STATE
- HARON
APPLY
30'DAY
TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
HAS LESS THAN i RESIDENT FAMILIES- NATIONAL
ESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
OUATlON 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
VALUE USED
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE- NORTH DAKOTA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PEHLlDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONJOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
PAUEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTAC DAE
STATE 5 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPKNIOAE
S LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASSLLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTAC DAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONtOAE
PHILODINIDAE
I NICKEL NATIONAL 16 OAPHNIOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
STATE 10 OAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOO NIDAE
CHIHONOMIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CGNTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINiOAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHIN DAE
OAPHN DAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONtOAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPHIN DAE
SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
corn DAE
CYPRIN DAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE
PTEHONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
0440
0468
0,493
0647
0.694
0732
1 011
5674
1 600
2800
7,800
13058
26.000
29000
58566
1 161
4020
80062
358792
4020
158 156
356.792
455015
10,000
21,986
22437
52.871
32.031
42198
48,000
53066
5000
10000
31623
244 259
5000
10000
246 595
783.471
65,077
233.555
345,472
401217
85.077
325 642
401 217
439,825
2000
6611
32.601
99553
2,000
2300
32601
0000
1992.474
6499,979
6479.723
1992,474
7049606
9002 438
0002
0004
0006
0012
0.002
0011
0.021
0112
1300
2627
3547
4725
3547
8033
9190
STATE: NORTH DAKOTA
( + ) ( + ) [++) < + J <-*•) < + > <++)
0201 *
0072 *
1 *
336C *
0037 .
0325 *
3,218 *
13875 *
0470 *
0 101 *
32.914 *
23512 *
0.137 *
0137 *
'
*
000053 *
000015 *
0537 *
*
- UMTS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
0 0023 FRV S ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0,0023 FRV STATE 11 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
'
00036 FRV
0 00003 FCV
0,00003 FCV
0.2574 ACH
1.1099 ACR
0 20 FRV
00671 ACR
3 3931 ACR
2 4238 ACR
0014 FRV
0,014 FRV
"
0.0067 ACH
0.0131 ACH
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
•48
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC
VALUE 30 DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
13.737 6.14B 470000 SCV
41.966
48,861
92757
13,737 4.146 47.0000 SCV
26.243
41,966
92757
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: OHIO STATE: OHIO
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRFSHWATFfi AOHATir i IPP f OITCOIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAX!MUM 30-DAY AVEHAQE TOXICANT FAMIUES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MWUMUM XS?Y AVERAGE
Ai_t)aiN NATIONAL u CENTRARCHIOAE 7 451 3388 • ENDHIN NATIONAL 17 OASTEROSTEIDAE
ASELL DA£ flOOO SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE 9 000 P6RLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 10 803 PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE 4,S03 i Jen * STATE g SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE 7 451 CYPRINIDAE
ANGLMLLIDAE '6 000 POECILIIDAE
ClPRtNlOAE '6332 CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHN
SALMO
ICTALU
STATE 5 DAPHN
SALMO
ICTALU
CENTR
DAPHN
GAMM
PHYSIC
STATE 14 SALMO
DAPHN
GAMM
CYPRlN
DAE 1794 245 PALAEMONIOAE
NiDAE 14128643 PEHLIDAE
RiDAE 16487 430 ASTACIDAE
DAE 1046 139 171 493 » STATE 6 PALAEMONIDAE
NIDAE 14128 643 SALMONIDAE
RIDAE 16487 430 CENTRARCHIDAE
ARCHIOAE 19484 938 GAMMARIDAE
NIDAE 0 048 0 027 0 0004 ACR M LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMAHIDAE
DAE 0496 DAPHNIDAE
RIDAE I 147 SALMONIOAE
AE 2860 CYPRINIDAE
NIDAE 0034 0015 00002 ACR STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
DAE 0 664 CYPRIN10AE
RiDAE 1 147 CENTRARCHIDAE
ODONTlOAE i 630 PHILODINIDAE
PTERONARClDAE 15000 SALMONIDAE
CYPfllNlOAE 23 238 GAMMARIOAE
GAWMARIDAE 32 248 CENTHARCHIDAE
STAT£ 5 PAi_AEMONIDAE 6.325 1 550 « 00043 FRV STATE 8 GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE 23 238 SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE 33862 CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE 40 000 ICTALURIDAE
DAPHN
PHILOC
PHYSIC
STATE 6 PHILOC
PHYSIC
CYPRir.
CHIRO
S COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHN
CHIRO
PHYSIC
TUBiFI
STATE 19 DAPHN
CHIRO
PHYSIC
TUBlFI
DAPHN
CENTR
PEflCIC
STATE 6 SALMO
DAPHN
CENTR
PERCIC
PERCIC
ESCCIC
GAMM
STATE 13 OAPHN
PERCIC
GAMM
ESOCi
SEwO '. -.fiTO'.Ai. 12 PCECr
ASELL
SAL'/O
EPHEM
S'ATE £, SALMG
PALAE
CATOS
DAE 6399 976 GAMMARIDAE
INIDAE 6998 790 ASTACIDAE
AE 24692 828 SALMONIDAE
INIDAE 6993790 1531 490 * 10,0 FPV STATE 6 GAMMARIDAE
AE 24892 826 SALMONIDAE
IDAE 57461 672 PHILODINIDAE
4OMIOAE 59899 703 NAIDIDAE
DAE 0 305 0 194 5 46618 FCV IS NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIOAE
40MIOAE 0 759 EPHEMERELLIOAE
AE 0.995 CENTRARCHIDAE
; DAE 1 345 PHILOOINIOAE
DAE 0 256 0 145 9 57750 FCV STATE 12 OAPHNIDAE
\)OMIDAE 0 759 CENTRARCHIOAE
AE 0995 PHILODINIDAE
,IDAE 1 345 CHIRONOMIDAE
NIDAE 76707 3V42S * 4.2472 ACR PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
OAE 83 000 CENTRARCHIDAE
ARCHIDAE 114 316 CYPRINIDAE
AE 125 121 GAMMAH10AE
NIDAE 76 70? 30 219 * 4 0836 ACR STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
DAE 83,000 CENTRARCHIDAE
ARCHIDAE 114316 CYPRINIDAE
AE 125121 GAMMAfltOAE
AE 1 595 DAPHNIDAE
A£ 1 700 CYPRINODONTIDAE
»HIDAE 2-234 SALMONIDAE
OAE 0 97B 0 471 * 0 0010 FHV STATE 9 HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
AE 1 595 DAPHNIDAE
1HIDAE 1 684 SALMONIDAE
AE 1 700 CYPHINIDAE
.DAE 4 503 1 830 • 0 0019 FHV S SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIOAE
DAE 5000 COTTIOAE
NiDAE 5452 CYPRINIDAE
EP.ELUDAE oooo CYPRINODONTIDAE
NJDAE 2459 0506 * 0,0019 FRV STATE 6 COTTIDAE
ARCHIDAE 10811 CYPRINIDAE
/ON'DAE 20000 SALMONIDAE
,DAt 30102 CENTRAHCHIOAE
MDAE 0664 0208 * 0 1064 ACR TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE
(DAE , STB PTERONARCIOAE
jAorinAE 2300 ICTALURIDAE
TOM'&AG 3240 CENTRARCHIDAE
,IOA£ 0664 0149 * 00762 ACR STATE 9 ICTALURIDAE
IOAe T 270 CENTRAHCHIOAE
TOMiOAE 3240 SALMONIDAE
ARCHIDAE 3811 CYPRINIDAE
. . _ FP/ FINAL PUNT VALUE i - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
0,440 0201 * 0.0023 FRV
0.468
0493
0.647
0.556 0.233 * 00023 FRV
0732
0.750
1.011
0995 0251 » 00038 FRV
1800
2.600
7800
1,800 0289 * 00038 FRV
13.058
24771
47.329
1 161 0037 * 000003 FCV
4020
60062
358792
80062 14.969 * 000004 FCV
358792
455 015
603.345
10.000 3 216 * 0.2574 ACR
21936
22437
52,871
10488 2266 * 01812 ACR
14 158
52.871
53,068
5.000 0470 * 0.20 FRV
10.000
31.623
244259
10.000 1 003 * 0.20 FHV
248.595
783.471
999.998
65.077 32.914 • 3 3931 ACR
233555
345472
401 217
78 456 33.129 * 3 4153 ACR
345472
401.217
439825
2000 0.137 * 0.014 FRV
6.611
32.601
99553
2.000 0.131 * 0014 FRV
6611
32601
107664
339999 82648 * 22.0395 ACR
1992.474
6499979
3479 723
339999 81976 * 21.8601 ACR
3869989
8479.723
9002433
0.002 0.00053 *
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.004 0.00041 *
0.011
0.021
0112
1 300 0.537 * 0.0087 ACR
2627
3.547
4,725
3 547 1.359 * 0.0220 ACR
4725
6.678
8.033
D-49
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: OHIO STATE: OKLAHOMA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA TOXICAN FAMU.MBETE°TED
( + ) ( + ) ( + ) ( + + )
J ZiNC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13737 6148 470000 SCV ALDHIN NATIONAL 14
SALMONIOAE 48861
PHIL001N1DAE 92.757
STATE 12 OAPHN DAE 21 223 7951 470000 SCV STATE 8
PHYSIOAE 41 966
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8
STATE 6
$S CADMIUM NATIONAL 18
STATE 14
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 6
STATE 5
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10
STATE 8
I COPPER NATIONAL 23
STATE 17
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10
STATE B
DDT NATIONAL 20
STATE 9
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12
STATE 7
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME LC*n VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIOAE
ANGUILLIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHN1DAE
CHIHONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
P6RCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
PEHCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PQECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMFDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
. . _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
p CIQ SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
(+) (+)
7.451 3.368 *
8,000
9.000
10.803
4.503 1.470 *
7-451
10.000
16.000
678.999 113263 *
1794,245
14126643
16487.430
878.999 58.104 *
1046.139
13339965
16487.430
0.048 0.027
0496
1 147
2.860
0,044 0.013
0163
0364
1 147
6.325 1.974 *
15000
23.238
32.249
6,325 1.825 *
23,238
25.481
26.000
67,000 12.164
6399.976
6996.790
24692 828
67 000 6,949 *
6998.790
24692,628
30454750
0.305 0.194
0.759
0995
1 345
0,256 0.137
0,759
0995
1022
76.707 31 429 *
63.000
114.316
125.121
57.000 19.407 *
63000
114.316
167,000
1 323 0.650
1 595
1.700
2,234
0978 0.377 *
2409
3.000
3,234
4.503 1.630 *
5.000
5452
8.000
2,459 0,561 *
10811
20000
30.102
0,664 0 208 *
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664 0.106 *
1.279
3.811
5.600
{+)
0.0004
0.0002
0.0043
0.0043
0.3378
0.1930
5,46618
4 62475
4.2472
2.6225
00010
0.0010
0.0019
0.0019
0.1064
00545
{+ + )
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FHV
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACH
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: OKLAHOMA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE
ENDRiN NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEIOAE
SALMONlDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 10 SALMONlDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECIUIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
HEPTACHLOH NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMON1DAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 7 PALAEMONIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SS LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONlDAE
CYPHINIDAE
STATE 5 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
L1NDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONlDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
STATE G SALMONlDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 OAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIOAE
STATE 5 GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONlDAE
PHILODINIDAE
IS N.CKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNIDAE
PERC1CHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE .
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONlDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONlDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CYPH1NODONTIDAE
SALMONlDAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMONlDAE
CYPRlN DAE
S SILVEO NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTiDAE
CYPflIN DAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 6 CYPflIN DAE
SALMONlDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CHIHONOMIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
STATE 8 ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONlDAE
*00-HOT|i
- - - i-Pv
FfiV
SCV
0440
0468
0493
0647
0694
0732
0750
1011
0905
1600
2600
7600
1800
7800
13058
24771
1 161
4020
SO 062
358792
1 161
158 156
358792
455.015
10000
21966
22437
52671
32031
48000
52871
53086
5000
10000
31623
244259
10.000
20000
248595
763471
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
78456
301 510
325.642
401 217
2000
6611
32601
99553
2000
6.611
32601
92054
1992.474
6499979
8479 723
3869969
7049606
9002438
0002
0004
0006
0012
0.011
0.021
0 112
4 106
2627
3547
4725
3547
4725
6.033
9100
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE
MAXIMUM 30-DAY
(+) <+>
0201 *
0298 *
0251 *
0393 *
0037 *
0059 *
3.218 *
13466 *
0470 *
0347 *
32.914 •
31.618 *
0137 *
0 144 *
.
64086 *
0.00053 «
000014 .
0 537 *
1206 *
0.0023
00023
00036
00036
000003
0.00003
0.2574
1 0772
020
020
3.3931
32596
0014
0014
'
0.0087
0.0196
FINAL PLANT VALUE
FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
STATE: OKLAHOMA
C.Ru»nA
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: OREGON
TOXICANT
ALDRtN
ARSENIC
IS CADMIUM
CHLOHOANE
S COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
0-52
FAMILIES TESTED NAME
NATIONAL 14 CENTHAHCHIDAE
ASELLIOAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIOAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
STATE 4 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NATIONAL ib SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHVSIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE S CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
DAPHN DAE
PHIUODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHN DAE
PHILODINIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
NATIONAL tj DAPHNIDAE
CHIHONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIF CIDAE
SALMONIDAE
NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PEHCIOAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMAH10AE
STATE 11 OAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
NATIONAL 12 POECIL IDAE
ASELL DAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PEHLIDAE
NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTEHONARC1DAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CO6NAGRIONIDAE
LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
[ + ) (•*•) ( + ) <++)
7451 3386 *
8.000
10803
9000
10000
10803
878999 113,263 *
1794 245
14128643
16487430
1794245 286699 *
14126643
19464.938
26041 87S
0048 0027 00004 ACR
0495
2860
0163
0496
6325 1 974 * 0.0043 FRV
15.000
23236
32249
15684 4357 * 0.0043 FRV
26000
43739
54711
6399976
6998 790
24892 826
6399 976 718 704 * 100 FPV
6998 790
30454 750
63804 146
0.305 0194 546618 FCV
0759
0995
1 345
0 305 0 122 001447 FCV
0759
1 345
1 401
76707 31 429 * 4 2472 ACH
83000
114316
125.121
76707 28.225 * 38141 ACR
63000
114.316
125121
1323 06SO 00010 FRV
1 595
1 700
2234
1 323 0501 * 0,0010 FRV
1 595
1 900
3000
4,503 1.830 * 00019 FRV
5000
5452
8000
5452 1376 * 00019 FRV
8000
10.811
24000
0664 0208 » 01064 ACR
1 279
2.300
3240
0664 0029 * 00148 ACR
3611
5800
AGRIONIDAE) 87650
- UNITS IN MlCROGHAMS PER LITER
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: OREGON
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOH
II LEAD
LIN DANE
IS NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
I SILVER
TOXAPHENE
UnCT CCNGITIVF OPSHIFNT CAMH V
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
NATIONAL
STATE
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
17
10
10
6
7
10
7
5
9
5
2
10
6
9
6
12
8
NAME LCSO VALUE
GASTEHOSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTEHONARCiDAE
PERLIDAE
GASTEHOSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAg
PEHLIOAE
ASTACIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
ASELLIOAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
'CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMAFIIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
HYALELLIDAE fTALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE fTALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
com DAE
CYPHINIDAE
CYPHINODONTlDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
COTTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTEflONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
SS — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30 DAY AVERAGE CflFTEHIA
0440
0.466
0493
0,647
0320
0.440
0,468
0.540
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
0.900
26,000
29.000
29.498
1.161
4020
80.062
358.792
4.020
60.062
455.015
803.845
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.671
21.986
42 198
46.000
68.000
5,000
10.000
31.623
244259
5,000
10000
244 259
783.471
65.077
233555
345.472
401.217
65077
301.510
401.217
439.825
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.S53
2000
2.300
0.000
0.000
339.999
19S2.474
6499979
8479.723
339.999
1992474
8479.723
24099.663
0002
O.OtM
0.006
0.012
0.002
0004
0.004
0.021
1.300
2627
3.547
4.725
2,848
3.000
5761
7.210
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
0.201 *
0 144 *
0.251 *
0.136 *
0.037 *
0219 *
3.218 *
7738 *
0.470 *
0.101 *
32.914 *
21.753 *
0.137 *
0137 *
**
82.648 *
29,603 *
0.00053 *
0.00026 *
0.537 *
0.850 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
( + ) (++)
0 0023 FRV
0 0023 FRV
0.0038 FHV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00002 FCV
0 2574 ACR
0.6190 ACR
0,20 FHV
0.0674 ACR
3.3931 ACR
2.2425 ACR
0014 FHV
0.014 FHV
22 0395 ACR
78941 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0138 ACH
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: OREGON
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
1 + )
DApHNtDAE 13737
PH*SIDA£ J'966
SflLMONiDAE 48861
PHILODIMDAE 927S7
DAPHNIDAE O737
SALMONIOAE ^:zg
PERCiCHTHYIOAE 49264
PHtLODiNiDAE 92757
STATE: PENNSYLVANIA
TOXICANT FAMII
ALDRIN NATIOh
CHLORDANE NATIONAL
CHROMIUM NATIONAL
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL
CENTflARCMIDAE
ASELL1DAF
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
SALMnwinAF
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUfllDAE
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUfllOAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
CYPRlNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRlNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
GAMMAfllDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILOOINIOAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRlNIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIOAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIOAE
DAPHNIOAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ESOCIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRlNIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
( + )
7.451
8,000
9,000
10.303
4.503
7.451
9000
16000
678.999
1794.245
14128,643
16487430
1046139
14128.643
16487430
19484938
2.880
0.034
0864
1 147
1630
6325
15.000
23238
32249
6.325
23.238
33.862
40.000
67000
6399976
6998790
24692 828
6993790
24692828
30454750
57461 672
0.305
0759
0.995
1 345
0256
0759
0995
125.121
76.707
83000
2.234
0.976
1.595
1 664
5000
5.452
8000
2459
8,000
2300
3240
0664
H AQUATIC L
30-DAY
_L±>
0.0004 ACR
0.0003 ACR
00043 FRV
00043 FRV
0,3376 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.46618 FCV
8.62836 FCV
4.2472 ACR
39977 ACH
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.0762 ACR
'.iTS IN '."CROGRAMS PER LiU"
t-, ffi<.L PLANT VALUF
f. ' NAL BtStDUE VALIJE
ow CHP/PUTEO BY ACUTE TO ' n
- STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL V
- HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIM'JM CRITERIA
- HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
-------
APPENDIX 0
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: PENNSYLVANIA
STATE: PENNSYLVANIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME
SALMONIDAE
PERUOAE
STATE 10 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPftlNIDAE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARC1DAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERUDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 6 PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
OAMMARIOAE
OAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHtOAE
PHILODINIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL '0 ASELilDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 7 GAMMARtDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTAC DAE
SALMONIOAE
STATE 1 GAMMARIDAE
ASTAC DAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHN DAG
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHN DAG
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
S SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 5 COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 9 ICTALURIDAE
CENTflAflCHIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPfllNIOAE
=OO*NOTE
- - - FPV
ACR
0.5.1 scv
LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM
1 + ) (+)
0440 0201 *
0*68
0493
0647
0440 0158 •
0556
5011
1 086
0995 0251 *
1 BOO
2,800
7800
1 BOO 0 269 *
13058
24771
47329
1 161 0037 .
A 020
80062
358.792
80,062 14 969 *
356792
455015
603845
10000 3,218 *
21 986
22437
52,871
10438 2099 *
14 158
52.871
53066
5,000 0470 *
10000
31,623
244 259
10000 0915 .
50.000
248 595
783,471
65077 32 914 *
233555
345,472
401 217
78,456 33,860 •
233555
345.472
401217
2000 0137 *
6611
32601
99553
2000 0131 •
6611
32.601
107664
339999 82648 .
1992,474
6499 979
8479723
339 999 62 801 *
2869 989
8479 723
9002438
0 002 0 00053 *
0004
0006
0012
0 004 0 00035 *
0011
0021
0112
1 300 0 537 *
2627
3547
4725
3 547 1 330 *
4725
6678
8433
FINAL PLANT VALUF
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC V
30-DAY
(•*•)
00023
00023
00036
0,0038
0,00003
000004
0.2574
0 1679
0.20
0.20
33931
34906
0014
0014
22.0395
167469
0.0087
00216
LUE
AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO V LUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(++) +) (+) (+) (++)
FRV S ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHN10AE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
FRV STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
FRV
FHV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACH
ACR
• - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
737 6.148 47.0000 SCV
.966
861
757
223 8.405 470000 SCV
966
4996.9
92757
-------
APPENDIX 0
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: RHODE ISLAND
NUMBER OF
TOXI eSTED
ALDR1N NATIONAL 14
STATE 9
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8
STATE 4
IS C4QMIUM NATIONAL 18
STATE 16
CHLOROANE NATIONAL 8
STATE 4
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
I COPPER NATIONAL 23
STATE 18
STATE 6
DOT NATIONAL 20
STATE 8
DIELOfllN NATIONAL 12
STATE 6
STATE e
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELL DAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
SALMONIDA6
SALMON! DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
ANGUU-LIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUR10AE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONJOAE
CENTRARCH10AE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPWNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYS1DAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
OAPHN1DAE
CHiRONOMIDAE
PHYS DAE
TUBiFlCiDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYS DAE
TuB'F CIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PERC DAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PEP-C DAE
DAPHN DAE
PEflC DAE
ESOCIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMAfllDAE
ASTACIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELUDAE
SALMONtDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRIHIDAE
CVPRINIDAE
PTERONAHClDAE
SALMONIDAE
C'TOSTOMIDAE
-GC NOT
1 + )
7451
8000
9000
10803
4503
'451
9000
16,000
876996
1794245
141286*3
18487430
1046.136
14128843
19484938
20194.383
0.048
0498
1 147
2880
0034
0864
1 147
1630
8325
15 000
23238
32249
23236
33862
40000
54711
67000
6399975
6998790
24892 626
6996790
24692 828
30454750
57481 672
0305
0-759
0.995
1345
0.256
0759
0.995
1345
83.000
in 316
125 121
76707
83.000
114316
125 121
1 323
1 595
1 700
2234
0976
1 595
1 &64
3000
4503
5.000
5452
6-000
2459
8000
14400
30102
1 279
2300
06ft4
1 279
3240
EUHH< IN MICP.OGRAM'
STATE: RHODE ISLAND
uFjfSuATEft ^UI'v UFE C.HS'* NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
- VU SJ*' . -1++I 1+) ( + 1 f + l (+4-1
3388 * ENDRIN NATIONAL 17 GASTEHQSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLtOAE
PTERONARCIOAE
1 520 * STATE 9 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
1 13-263 • HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PER LI DAE
ASTACIDAE
141.620 + STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
0027 00004 ACR SS LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
0.019 0 0003 ACR STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
1 974 * 00043 FRV LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
7875 * 00043 FRV STATE 6 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIOAE
12 164 03378 ACR MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIOAE
SALMONIDAE
692 459 * 10 0 FPV STATE 5 GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0.194 5 46618 FCV II NICKEL NATIONAL 16 OAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
0 139 7 43115 FCV STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
28 920 * 3 9081 ACR STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
0650 00010 FRV SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELLIDAEfTALITHIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
0 331 * 0 0010 FRV STATE 6 HYALELLIDAE fTALITHIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
1 830 * 00019 FRV I SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
0 471 * 0 0019 FfiV STATE 4 CYPfllNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOD1NIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
0 149 * 0 07S2 ACR STATE 7 CENTRARCHIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
0440 0.153 * 00023 FRV
0.556
1.011
0.995 0.251 * 0,0036 FHV
1.800
7.800
13.058 3.521 * 0.0038 FHV
26000
47.329
50.748
1.161 0.037 * 000003 FCV
60.062
358.792
60.062 14.969 * 0.00003 FCV
358792
455.015
803845
10 000 3 218 * 0.2574 ACR
21.986
22.437
52671
10.468 1.829 * 0.1463 ACR
14.158
42198
66.000
5.000 0470 * 020 FRV
10.000
31623
244.259
10.000 O.B29 * 0.20 FRV
50.000
248.595
783471
65077 32.914 * 3.3931 ACR
233.555
345.472
401.217
78456 33.128 * 3.4152 ACR
401217
439.625
444717
6611
32.601
99553
2000 0.060 * 0014 FRV
2300
32601
107664
339999 82.648 * 220395 ACR
1992474
8499979
8479723
339.999 54.260 • 14.4747 ACR
3669.989
6479723
9002.436
0.002 0.00053 *
0004
0006
0.012
0.011 0.00006 *
0.021
0112
5.517
1.300 0.537 * 0.0087 ACR
2.627
3.547
4.725
2.848 0.913 * 0,0148 ACR
8.678
7429
12000
D-55
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE; RHODE ISLAND STATE: SOUTH CAROLINA
|+) (+) (+) (++) 1+) <+) 1+) (++)
J Z'NC NATIONAL. 15 DA HN DAE 13737 6148 470000 SCV ALDR1N NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
PH StDAE 41 966 ASELLIDAE
SA MONIDAE 48 881 EPHEMERELL1DAE
PH OD NIDAE 92 757 SALMONtOAE
STATE 13 DA HN DAE 21 223 8451 470000 SCV STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
PH SlOAE 41966 CENTRARCMIDAE
SA MONIDAE 51 B45 EPHEMEHELLIDAE
PH 00 NIDAE 92757 CYPRINIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 4 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAG
CYPRINIDAE
SI CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
PHYSIOAE
STATE 15 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHI LOOI NIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
I COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 17 DAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
E5OCIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
STATE 8 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTflAFICHIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMEflELLlDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
7 451 3 388 *
8000
9000
10,603
4 503 1 738 *
7,451
9000
11 314
878999 113,263 *
1794,245
14123643
16487430
1046.139 132.343 *
14128.643
19484936
26041 875
0.048 0.027 0.0004 ACR
0.496
1 147
2,860
0.034 0.016 * 0.0002 ACfl
0864
1 830
2,860
8325 1.974 * 00043 FRV
15.000
23.238
32.249
15.684 1 974 * 0.0043 FRV
33.862 **
54.711
0000
67000 12.164 0.3378 ACR
6309.976
6996.790
24892.828
6998.790 1604.673 * 10.0 FPV
24692.828
30454.750
83804.148
0.305 0.194 5,46618 FCV
0.759
0.995
1.345
0,258 0.133 * 8.24143 FCV
0.759
0.995
1345
76 707 31 429 * 4 2472 ACR
83,000
114.316
125.121
76.707 29583 * 3.9977 ACfl
83000
114.316
125.121
1.323 0.650 0.0010 FRV
1595
1.700
2.234
0976 0.305 * 00010 FRV
1.595
3000
3570
4.503 1 830 * 0.0019 FRV
5,000
5452
8.000
2459 0.339 * 0.0019 FRV
8000
10811
41000
0664 0.208 * 0.1064 ACR
1.279
2.300
3240
0.664 0.019 * 0.0006 ACR
3.240
3811
COENAGRIONIDAE(AGRIONIDAE) 87.650
= 00"NOTE * - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
. . _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE s — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FHV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: SOUTH CAROLINA
STATE: SOUTH CAROLINA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SFNSITIWP ncomcur CAU.I v -„«!,..,. -^
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME
ENORIN NATIONAL 17 QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARClDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
LC SO VALUE
0,440
04&8
0493
0647
0558
POECILHDAE 0 750
CENTRARCHIOAE 1 Oil
COENAGRIONIDAE (AQRlONIDAE) 1 800
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARClDAE 0.995
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
DAPHNlDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PH1LOOJNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
UN DANE NATIONAL 10 ASELL1DAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNlDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 4 ASTAClOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAID10AE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODNIDAE
STATE 11 OAPHNiDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
°CBS NAT.ONAj. 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 SALVONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGRION
DAPHN DAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILHOAE
* S'LVE° '.A-IONAL 9 OAPHNIDAE
corn DAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPHINODONTIOAE
STATE 3 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE * CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPfliNiOAE
SALMONIDAE
PE&CFDAE
=0 Of NOTE
. - _ rpv
«»
1800
2800
7800
13058
24771
50748
319999
402C
80062
356792
80062
455015
803845
814803
10000
21988
22437
52671
37669
52871
68000
112694
5,000
10000
31.623
244259
20000
248595
783471
999998
233.555
401217
78456
401217
439 825
4*4 717
2000
8611
32801
99553
2.000
6611
DAE) 282 842
0000
1992 474
6499979
3479 723
3889989
8479 723
12599945
0002
0004
0006
0.012
0021
0112
5517
0000
1 300
2627
3547
4725
#723
6120
9.963
12000
PINAL PLAN
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AV(E+R*°E TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO
f-fl ( + 1 4.1 /j.j.1
' ' — •• — : : — : ~-i ITT>
0201 . 0.0023 FRV S ZINC NATiONAL 15 DAPHN.DAE 13.737 6,148 470000 SCV
PHYSIDAE 41 966
SALMON IDAE 48,861
PHYSIDAE 41 aes ''^ * 47.0000 SCV
SALMONIDAE 46 550
0.25, , 0003J FRV PH,LOOIN,D« 92757
0857 * 00038 FRV
0,037 * 000003 FCV
14 070 * 0.00003 FCV
3218 * 0.2574 ACR
10825 * 08860 ACR
0.470 * 0.20 FRV
1 680 * 0.20 FRV
32 914 * 3 3931 ACR
31.123 . 32085 ACR
0.137 * 0014 FRV
0 137 * 0,014 FRV
82648 * 220395 ACR
57356 * 15.2955 ACH
000053 *
000053 *
0,537 * 00087 ACR
1 700 * 00276 ACR
• - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
T VALUF 1 - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
D-57
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: SOUTH DAKOTA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
[ + ) (•*•) ( + ) ( + + )
ALDHIN NATIONAL 14 CENTHAflCHIDAE
ASELLIOAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 6 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 13 SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CHLOHDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 5 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPHIN10AE
S COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYS10AE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE IS DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DOT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMAfllDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNIOAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
DIELORIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIOAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
SNDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPfllNIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
7451 3.388 *
6000
9000
10803
4503 1369 *
7451
16000
16392
878999 113263 *
1 794 245
14128643
16487 430
1794245 363.601 *
13339965
16J87430
19484938
0496
1 147
2.860
0.044 0.016
0496
1 147
1630
6325 1.974 *
15000
23.233
32249
23238 6,084 .
25481
26000
54711
67000 12164
6399 976
6998 790
24892 628
6399,976 761 036 *
6998790
24392 823
57461 673
0.305 0. 194
0.759
0.995
1345
0305 0150
0759
0995
1022
83,000
125,121
57000 20746 *
83000
114316
125 121
1.323 0.650
1595
I 700
2234
1 323 0 465 *
1 595
1.700
3000
4.503 1 830 *
5000
5452
8000
2 459 0 490 *
10,811
24000
30102
0,664 0208 «
1 279
2300
3240
0,664 0161 *
1 279
3240
3.811
0 0002 ACR
0 0043 FRV
00043 FRV
0,3378 ACR
100 FPV
5,46618 FCV
9 92408 FCV
2 6035 ACR
00010 FRV
00010 FRV
00019 FRV
00019 FRV
0 1064 ACR
0 0823 ACH
STATE: SOUTH DAKOTA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17
STATE 7
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
SI LEAD NATIONAL 7
STATE 5
LINDANE NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
MERCURY NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
II NICKEL NATIONAL 16
PCBS NATIONAL 5
STATE 3
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
I SILVER NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12
STATE 9
NAME
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTEHONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIHONOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIOAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE}
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
com DAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALUH10AE
SALMONIDAE
LC50 VALUE
( + 1
0.440
0463
0.493
0347
0.493
0.694
0.732
1.011
0995
1.800
2,800
7800
2.800
13.058
26000
29.000
1.161
4.020
80.062
358.792
4.020
158156
358.792
455.015
10.000
21.988
22.437
52671
8,004
42.198
46000
53.066
5.000
10.000
31623
244.259
5.000
10.000
246.595
783.471
65,077
233555
345.472
401.217
325.842
401217
439,825
2,000
6611
32,601
09.553
2,000
2.300
32.601
0000
339.999
1992.474
6499979
8479 723
339.999
1992.474
7049.606
9002,438
0,002
0004
0.006
0.012
0002
0,011
0.021
0.112
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.725
1.300
2.648
3.547
5.251
MAXIMUM
( + )
0.201 *
0.191 *
0.251 *
0.605 *
0.037 *
0.325 *
3.218 *
2320 *
0470 *
0.101 *
32914 *
*
0137 *
0,137 *
**
82,646 *
54.887 *
0,00053 *
000015 *
0,537 *
0464 *
30-DAY
( + )
0.0023
00023
0.0038
0,0036
000003
000003
0.2574
0,1856
0.20
0.0671
3.3931
1
0,014
0.014
220395
14.6364
0.0087
0.0075
CRITERIA
AVERAGE
( + + )
FRV
FRV
FHV
FHV
FCV
FCV
ACH
ACR
FHV
ACR
ACR
FHV
FHV
ACR
ACH
ACR
ACfl
AC
FC
sc
TS IN MICROGflAMS PER LITER
C.NAL PLANT VALUE
FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CH
FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
• — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * - STATE HAS Lf SS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES — NATIONAL VALUE USED
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
RONIC RATIO METHOD
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIM
30 DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
M A
D
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: SOUTH DAKOTA STATE: TENNESSEE
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FHESHWATPB iOiiaTir 1 ICF rnrrcniA
TOX.CANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50VALUG MAXIMUM 30-DAV AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCMVALUE MAXIM™ SJI? SlOE
'*' (+) '*> (++l ( + 1 1+) (+1 (++1
J ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13 737 6 148 47 0000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHVSIDAE 41 966 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48 881 EPHEMERELLIOAE
PHlLODINtDAE 92 757 SALMONIOAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE 13 737 4 399 4? oooo scv STATE i SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE 26 243 CENTRAHCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41 966 PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE 92.757 ANQUILLIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 6 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
11 CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 14 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PTEflONARCIDAE
CYPfllNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 PALAEMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIOAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 7 GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
$ COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 17 OAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
eSOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 9 DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DIELDHIN NATIONAL 12 POECIU1DAE
ASELLIOAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTEHONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
1 CQO-NOTE ~ " • - FAILECTTOMEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
.. _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE I - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
CCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
7451 3.388 *
8.000
9,000
10.603
4.503 1402 *
7.451
10.000
16.000
878.999 113.263 *
1794,245
14128.643
16487.430
678.999 58.104 *
1046.139
13339.965
16487400
0048 0.027 0.0004 ACR
0.496
1.147
2.B60
0.044 0.013 0.0002 ACR
0.183
0.864
1.147
6.325 1 974 * 0.0043 FRV
15.000
23.238
32.249
6.325 1 232 * 0.0043 FRV
23.236
25.481
54.711
67.000 12.164 0.3378 ACR
6399.976
699S.790
24692.828
67.000 5.387 * 01496 ACR
6998790
24892.826
30454.750
0.305 0 194 5.46618 FCV
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256 0.137 4.79332 FCV
0.759
0995
1.022
76.707 31.429 * 4.2472 ACR
63000
114.316
125.121
57 000 16,631 * 2.5176 ACR
83.000
114.316
187.000
1.323 0650 0.0010 FRV
1.595
1.700
2.234
0976 0.364 * 0.0010 FRV
3.000
3.234
4102
4503 1830 * 00019 FRV
5000
5452
8.000
2.459 0.452 * 0.0019 FRV
10.811
20000
30.102
0.664 0.208 * 0.1064 ACR
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664 0.137 * 0.0701 ACR
1.279
3.240
3811
D-59
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: TENNESSEE
ENDHIN NATIONAL
STATE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL
STATE
II LEAD NATIONAL
STATE
LINDANE NATIONAL
STATE
MERCURY NATIONAL
STATE
M NICKEL NATIONAL
STATE
PCBS NATIONAL
STATE
SELENIUM NATIONAL
STATE
I SILVER NATIONAL
STATE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL
STATE
17 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTEflONARCIOAE
9 SALMONIDAE
CYPfilNIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
10 PTEflONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACfDAE
5 PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
7 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
5 GAMMARIOAE
SALMONJDAE
CYPfllNIOAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
9 DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
4 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
NAIDIDAE
16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
11 DAPHNIDAE
PEflCICHTHYIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINrOAE
GAMMARiDAE
5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
10 HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIOAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
8 HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
9 OAPHNIOAE
corn DAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
6 COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
12 PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
6 ICTALURIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
LC50 VALUE
< + )
0440
0468
0493
0647
0,694
0732
0,750
1 011
0995
1600
2800
7,800
1 600
13058
24771
50,743
1,161
4020
80,062
1,161
158.156
358792
455,015
10000
21 988
22437
52871
8004
52.871
530S6
94.805
5000
10.000
31,623
244 259
10,000
248595
783.471
999.998
65077
233.555
345.472
401 217
78456
301510
325.B42
401.217
2000
6.611
32601
99553
2000
6611
32601
92054
339.999
1992 474
6499979
8479,723
339999
3869,989
7049606
9002438
0.002
0004
0.006
0.012
0004
0,011
0021
0112
1 300
2.627
3547
4725
3547
4725
5251
8033
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
0201 * 00023 FRV
0264 * 00023 FRV
0.251 * 00038 FRV
0,24,1 * 00036 FHV
0.037 * 0.00003 FCV
0059 * 000004 FCV
3.218 * 0.2574 ACR
1607 * 0 1265 ACR
0.470 « 0.20 FRV
0,639 * 020 FRV
32914 * 3.3931 ACR
31616 * 32596 ACR
0.137 * 0.014 FHV
0.144 . 0014 FRV
B2648 * 22.0395 ACR
74 102 « 197604 ACR
0.00053 *
0.00041 *
0537 » 0.0087 ACR
1304 * 0.0212 ACR
STATE: TENNESSEE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
I ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
13.737 6.148
41.968
48861
92.757
21 223 8.395
26.243
41966
49.264
1+) (++)
470000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
, . _ fpv FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
PCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
J — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIM
UM CRITERIA
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: TEXAS
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE
I*)
ALDRlN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELUDAE
EPHEMERELLiDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 7 CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 4 OAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SS CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 12 PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHVS DAE
PHILODINIDAE
C-LOHQANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMQNIOAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 PALAEMONlDAE
CYPHINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMAHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHtLOOINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 7 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
1 COPPER SAT.ONAL 23 OAPHNIDAE
CHlRONOMlDAE
PHYSIDAE
TuBiF CPDAE
STATE 15 OAPHNIOAE
CHlRONOMlDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIOAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 7 OAPHNIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PERC DAE
CYPRINIDAE
DOT NATIONAL 20 OAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PEHCIOAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONlDAE
D'ELDO'* NATIONAL 12 POEClL IDAE
ASELUDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 0 POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONlDAE
CYPHINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 4 CYPRINIOAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
7451
8000
9000
10603
7451
10000
16000
16.392
878.999
1794.245
14128.643
16487430
1046139
16437430
19404,936
20194383
0048
0.496
I 147
2860
0163
0864
2860
6987
6-325
15.000
23.238
32.249
6.325
23238
54711
190.000
67000
6399976
6998,790
24892828
6996790
24692.828
29999887
30454750
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0256
0759
0995
1445
76707
83.000
114.316
125 121
83000
114.318
125121
207958
1323
1,595
1 700
2234
0976
1 595
2409
3234
4503
5000
5452
8.000
4.503
10611
20000
30102
1 279
2-300
3240
1279
3700
3611
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
! + ) ( + ) (+•*-)
3388 *
2848 *
113263 *
140 493 *
0.027 0 0004 ACR
0.041 * 0.0008 ACR
1974 * 00043 FRV
0,558 * 00043 FRV
12164 03378 ACR
2271 128 * 10.0 FPV
0.194 5.46618 FCV
0 121 * 6.56591 FCV
31429 * 42472 ACH
28174 * 3.8072 ACR
0.650 0.0010 FRV
0357 * 00010 FRV
1830 * 00019 FRV
1068 * 00019 FRV
0039 * 00198 ACR
COENAORIONIDAE [AQR10NIDAE) 87650
. . _ FPV
FRV
SCv
PINAL PLANT VALUE
FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
SENSITIVE SPEC
IES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: TEXAS
NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ENORIN NATIONAL
STATE
HEPTACHLOH NATIONAL
STATE
U LEAD NATIONAL
STATE
LINDANE NATIONAL
STATE
MERCURY NATIONAL
STATE
U NICKEL NATIONAL
STATE
PCSS NATIONAL
STATE
SELENIUM NATIONAL
STATE
S SILVER NATIONAL
STATE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL
STATE
17
8
10
6
7
4
10
8
9
3
16
11
5
3
10
8
9
4
12
a
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PEHUDAE
PTEHONAHCIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
PALAEMONlDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONlDAE
PERUDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONlDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
ASELUDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
PERCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMEREUJDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHlRONOMlDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGHIONID*
HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECIUIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPHINIOAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHlRONOMlDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PER LI DAE
PTERONARCIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERCIDAE
0.440
0.488
0.493
0.647
0.949
1.011
1265
0.995
1.800
24.771
4.020
60.062
358 792
358.792
455.015
532.856
803.845
10.000
21.988
22.437
52-671
52-871
53.066
68.000
94.805
5.000
10000
31623
244.259
20000
783471
999.998
0.000
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
78456
301 510
401217
439.825
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.553
6.611
32.801
E) 282.842
0.000
339.999
1992474
6499979
8479.723
339.999
3869989
9002.438
12599.945
0.002
0.004
0.006
0012
0.011
0.112
4.106
5.517
1 300
2.627
3.547
4.725
3.547
4.725
8.433
12.000
FRESHWATER AQUATIC UFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
0201 *
0418 *
0251 *
0234 *
0.037 +
113.577 *
3218 *
17.797 *
0.470 *
0.470 *
32-914 *
30.838 *
0.137 *
0.137 *
82.646 *
65749 *
0.00053 *
0.00015 *
0537 *
1.059 *
0.0023
00023
0.0036
00038
0.00003
3.2496
0.2574
1.4237
020
020
3.3931
3.1791
0.014
0.014
22.0395
175329
0.0087
0.0172
' • • '
FHV
FHV
FHV
FRV
FCV
ACR
ACR
ACR
FRV
FHV
ACR
ACR
FHV
FHV
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
D-61
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: TEXAS STATE: UTAH
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + ) ( + ) ( + ) <++) ( + ) ( + ) < + > < + + >
I ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHN DAE 13737 6148 * 470000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRAHCHIOAE
PHYSIDAE 41 966 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48,661 EPHEMEHELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92 757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNIOAE 21 223 7.584 * 470000 SCV STATE 9 SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41 966 CENTRARCH1DAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE 49 264 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE 92 757 PERCICHTHYIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SI CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 12 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 6 PTEHONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
I COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOM1DAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
PLANORBIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DIELDHIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
END05ULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPH1NIOAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
COOTNOTE * _ FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
n F.1 SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30 DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
7.451 3.386 *
8.000
9.000
10.803
4 503 1.874 *
7.451
9.000
10.000
878.999 113.203 *
1794.245
14125.643
16487.430
1794.245 407.358 *
14128.643
16487.430
19484.938
0.048 0.027 0.0004 ACR
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.034 0.009 0.0001 ACR
0.163
0.496
1.147
6.325 1.974 * 0.0043 FHV
15.000
23.238
32.249
15000 5563 * 0.0043 FRV
23.238
26.000
33.862
67000 12.164 03378 ACR
6399.976
6998.790
24692.828
6399.976 764448 * 10.0 FPV
6998.790
30454.750
57461.672
0.305 0.194 5.46618 FCV
0759
0.995
1.345
0.305 0.121 2.69135 FCV
0.759
1.345
1.424
76.707 31 429 * 4 2472 ACR
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707 28.225 * 38141 ACR
83.000
114316
125.121
1.323 0.650 0.0010 FRV
1.595
1700
2234
1323 0.503 * 0.0010 FRV
1.595
3.000
3.096
4.503 1.630 * 0,0019 FRV
5.000
5.452
8000
2.459 0.632 * 00019 FRV
6.000
10.811
24.000
0.664 0.208 * 0.1064 ACR
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664 0.196 * 0 1003 ACH
1.279
2.300
3540
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: UTAH
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 9 SALMONIDAE
PERLIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERQNARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACiDAE
STATE 7 PTERONARCIOAE
P6RL10AE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
» LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPfllNIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTR.ARCH1DAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE B SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 5 OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PH1LODIN1DAE
a NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PH1LODINIDAE
STATE 9 DAPHNIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPfliN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPfllNIDAE
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELLIDAEfTALITRIQAE)
DAPHNIOAE
CYPRINODONTIOAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 7 MYALELLIDAEfTAUTRIDAE)
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPfllNIDAE
I Sn.'€? NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIOAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
TOXAPWENE MATiQNAL 12 PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 10 PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
FOOTNOTE
- UNIT
. . _ FPV
FBV
SCV
LCM VALUE
< + )
0440
0.468
0493
0.647
0357
0493
0.647
1.011
0.995
1 BOO
2600
7600
0995
2600
13.058
26000
1,161
4.020
80,062
358792
4020
60.062
356.792
455.015
10.000
21.988
22437
52.671
14,158
42 198
46000
53066
5.000
10000
31823
244.259
5.000
10000
248.595
783471
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
65.077
301.510
401217
439.825
2.000
8.611
32.601
99.553
2.000
2,300
32.601
0.000
339.999
1992.474
8499.979
8479723
339.999
1992 474
8479723
9002438
0002
0004
0006
0.012
0.002
0.004
0006
0021
1300
2627
3547
4725
1300
2927
2848
3,547
& IN MlCBOGBAM
PINAL PLANT v
FINAL RESIDUE
STATE: UTAH
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
— 1-±± itJ — <++l (+1 m (4i (4.4.1
0 201 * 0,0023 FRV S ZINC NATIONAL 15 OAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0 125 * 00023 FRV STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYJDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0.251 • 0.0038 FHV
0125 * 00036 FRV
0037 * 0,00003 FCV
0267 * 0,00003 FCV
3216 * 0.2574 ACR
5.119 * 04095 ACR
0470 * 020 FRV
0101 * 00671 ACR
32.914 * 33931 ACR
21.753 * 2.2425 ACR
0.137 * 0014 FRV
0.137 * 0014 FRV
•**
62.846 * 22.0395 ACR
52431 * 139818 ACR
000053 *
0.00030 *
0.537 * 00087 ACH
0543 * 00088 ACR
ULUE L t HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
VAl UF APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV
48461
92.757
13.737 4,780 47.0000 SCV
49.264
49.969
92.757
D-63
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: VERMONT
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDE
ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIOAE
ePHEMERELLIOAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 9 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
CYPfllNIDAG
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 4 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
IS CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 15 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPHINODONTJOAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
PHILODINIOAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 5 PHILODINIOAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
S COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYS DAE
TUBIF CIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PEHCIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PEHCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPMNIOAE
PEflCIDAE
ESOC DAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 9 DAPHN DAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
DIELDHIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIOAE
CYPHlNIOAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
- JNIT
n.fij sc .
>JT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
7451 3388 *
8000
9000
10803
4503 1.770 *
7451
9000
11 732
878999 113263 *
1 794 245
14128643
16487 430
1046139 148092 *
14128643
15659936
19484 938
0048 0027 00004 ACR
0496
1 147
2860
0034 0017 00002 ACR
0864
1 147
1 630
6,325 1971 * 00043 FRV
15000
23238
32249
12371 3272 * 00043 FRV
32249
33.862
54711
67000 12 164 03378 ACH
6399 976
6998790
24892 828
6998 790 1448 932 * 100 FPV
24692 828
40637609
63804,148
0305 0 194 546618 FCV
0,759
0995
1345
0759
0995
1 345
76 707 31 429 * 4 2472 ACR
83000
H4316
125 121
76 707 29 583 » 3 9977 ACH
83000
114316
125,121
1 323 0650 00010 FRV
1595
1 700
2234
0976 0401 * 00010 FRV
1595
1 700
2234
4503 1 830 * 00019 FHV
5000
5452
2459 0549 » 00019 FHV
8000
14460
22,101
0664 0208 . 01064 ACR
1 279
2300
3240
0664 0149 * 00762 ACR
1 279
3240
3811
'X^'sS^E
SENSiWE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: VERMONT
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17 GASTEHOSTEIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PERLIDAE
PTEfiONARCIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CYPfllNIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGHIONIDA
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONAHC1DAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PEHLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
C6NTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
» LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLFDAE
SALMONIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
GAMMAHtDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 5 GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SI NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAg
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
pcss NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAG
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELLIDAE (TALlTRlDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINOOONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 6 HYALELLIOAE (TALlTRlDAE)
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
S SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
STATE 4 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PEHLIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
STATE 7 CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PEHCIDAE
• - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
•* - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
0440 0201 * 0.0023 FRV
0468
0493
0.647
0556 0.141 « 0.0023 FRV
0562
1.011
E) 1800
0995 0.251 * 0,0038 FRV
1 800
2800
7.800
13,058 3 705 * 0.0038 FRV
26000
37048
50.748
1 161 0037 * 000003 FCV
4.020
80.062
356792
80,062 10.748 * 000003 FCV
157.991
455.015
803.845
10.000 3.218 * 0.2574 ACR
21,986
22437
52,871
14158 3,392 * 02713 ACR
22437
42 198
68.000
5000 0470 * 0.20 FRV
10,000
31.623
244 259
10000 0.629 * 0,20 FRV
50.000
248.595
783.471
65,077 32.914 * 3.3931 ACR
233555
345,472
401,217
345 472
401.217
439.825
2.000 0 137 * 0014 FRV
6,611
32601
99,553
2,000 0.060 * 0014 FRV
2300
32.601
107.664
339 999 82 648 * 22.0395 ACR
1992.474
6499,979
8479 723
339,999 58 744 * 15 6649 ACR
3105,149
3869.989
8479.723
0002 0.00053 *
0.004
0.006
0,012
0011 000006 *
0,021
0112
5.517
1 300 0.537 * 0.0087 ACR
2627
3.547
4725
2,848 0886 * 0.0144 ACR
6 165
6.678
12.000
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: VERMONT
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMON! DAE
PMILODiNIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
13737
41966
48 Ml
92757
21223
41.966
STATE: VIRGINIA
NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ALDRIN NATIONAL 14
STATE 9
N L
STATE 4
S3 CADMIUM NATIONAL 18
STATE 15
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8
STATE 4
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
S COPPER NATIONAL 23
STATE 19
STATE 6
DDT NATIONAL 20
STATE 8
OIELDHIN NATIONAL 12
STATE 6
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9
STATE 6
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) < + ) ( + 1 (++1
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIOAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
7.451 3.388 *
8000
9.000
10,603
4.503 1.520 *
7.451
9.000
16.000
1794.245
14128.643
16487430
1046139 141.620 *
14128.643
19484938
20194.383
0.046 0.027
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.034 0.017
0.864
1.147
1.630
6.325 1.974 *
15.000
23238
32249
23.238 7.675 *
33.862
40.000
54.711
67.000 12.164
6399.976
6998.790
24892.828
6998.790 1692-459
24892.626
30454.750
57461.672
0.305 0 194
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256 0.145
0.759
0.995
1.345
76.707 31.429 •
63.000
114.316
125.121
76.707 28.920 *
63.000
114316
125121
1.323 0,650
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.976 0.331 *
1.595
1.664
3.000
4.503 1.830 *
5.000
5.452
8.000
2.459 0485 *
8.000
10.611
30.102
0.664 0.208 *
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664 0.149 *
1.279
3.240
3.811
0.0004
0.0002
0.0043
0.0043
0.3378
10.0
5.46618
838350
42472
39081
00010
00010
0.0019
0,0019
0.1064
0.0762
ACR
ACR
FHV
FRV
ACH
FPV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
FRV
FHV
ACR
ACR
COCTNOTE
A n
f V
COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHHON
FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
1C RATIO METHOD
LUE
I "" FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
• • STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL
I HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
» - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30.0AY AVERAGE CRITERIA
VALUE USED
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE; VIRGINIA
TOXICANT
ENDHIN
IS LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
II NICKEL
PCBS
I SILVER
0-66
FAMILIES TESTED NAME
NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTEHONARCIDAE
STATE 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
COENAGfliONIDAElA
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTAC DAE
STATE 5 SALMON I DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHN DAE
NATIONAL 7 GAMMAHIDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NATIONAL 10 ASELL DAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
STATE G GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTflARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
NATIONAL 9 OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIOAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 6 GAMMAHIDAE
ASTAC DAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NATIONAL 16 DAPHN DAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOM1DAE
NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHIN DAE
' GAMMAHIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPHINOOONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NATIONAL 9 OAPHN DAE
com DAE
CYPRINIOAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE A CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOD1NIOAE
PTERONARClOAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTBARCHIDAE
STATE 7 CENTHARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERCIDAE
(+) <+>
0440 0201 *
0468
0493
0647
0.556 0.175 *
0732
1 011
3RIONIDAE) 1.800
0995 0251 *
1-800
2.800
7800
13 058 3 446 *
24771
47,329
50748
1.161 0,037 *
4020
80,062
358.792
80062 14,969 *
358792
455015
803 645
10.000 3.218 *
21 988
22437
52.671
14158
52.871
68.000
5.000 0,470 *
10000
31623
244 259
10000 0764 *
50.000
246 595
763.471
65077 32914 *
233 555
345.472
401217
78456 35.068 *
345472
401.217
439 625
2000 0137 *
6.611
32601
99553
2.000 0 131
6.611
32601
107664
1992474
6499,979
8479 723
3869.989
8479 723
9002438
0,002 000053 «
0004
0,006
0.012
0.011 000006 *
0021
0112
5517
1 300 0 537 *
2627
3547
4 725
4725 1643 *
6678
8033
12.000
~L.wTS IN WICROGRAMS PER LITER
SC. SENSiT^E SCEOeSCHBQfgic
STATE: VIRGINIA
30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + ) ( + + ) < + ) ( + ) 1 + ) <++)
0 0023 FRV S ZINC NATIONAL 15 OAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0 0023 FRV STATE 13 DAPHNIOAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0 0038 FHV
0 0038 FRV
0,00003 FCV
0 00003 FCV
0 2574 ACR
0 1392 ACR
0 20 FRV
0 20 FRV
3 3931 ACH
36172 ACR
0014 FHV
0.014 FRV
22 0395 ACR
14.4747 ACH
0.0087 ACR
0.0267 ACR
• - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
•'ALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
13737 6,148 470000 SCV
41.966
48.661
92.757
21223 8.29B 470000 SCV
41966
46,550
92757
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: WASHINGTON
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ALDR'N NATIONAL 14
STATE 8
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8
STATE 5
S3 CADMIUM NATIONAL 10
STATE 12
CHLCPiJANE NATIONAL 8
STATE 6
CHROMU 0
STATE 5
1 COPPE0 -.ATrONAL 23
STATE 11
CYANJOE N ATONAL 10
STA'E 6
DOT NATIONAL 20
STATE 11
S>£LDB *t NATIONAL 12
STATE B
ENDOSUL^AH .'.AT'OSAL 9
STATE 6
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINlDAE
GAMMARIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
PHYSIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPHfNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
CYPRINlDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINlDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMlDAE
PHYSIOAE
TUBrFICIDAE
DAPHNtDAE
CHIHONOMIDAE
TTjeiFlClDAE
SALMONIOAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRAHCHIOAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOC10AE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILHDAE
ASELLJDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPR1NIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SAtMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OAMMAR1DAE
( + 1
7451
8000
9,000
10303
7451
9000
10,803
11314
878999
1794,245
14128043
16487430
1794 245
14128.643
19484938
22039902
0048
0496
2860
0048
0496
1 147
2860
6325
15000
23238
32249
15.000
15.684
26000
43739
6399.976
6998790
24892 828
6399976
6998790
63604 146
81251.078
0305
0759
0995
1 345
0305
0759
1345
1 401
76707
83000
114316
125121
76707
83000
114316
125 121
1323
1595
1700
2,234
1323
1 595
3000
3.282
4503
5000
5452
5452
8000
10811
24000
0064
1279
2.300
3240
0804
2300
3,811
5.800
( + )
3388 *
3242 *
113,263 *
343846 *
0.027
0.013
1.974 *
3775 *
1 ]
465.609 *
0194
0.116
31429 *
28.920 *
0650
0.479 *
1830 *
1 456 *
0206 *
0.153 *
00004
00002
00043
0.0043
03376
100
546618
964928
4.2472
39061
00010
00010
00019
00019
0,1064
00787
ACR
ACH
FRV
FRV
FPV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
FHV
FRV
ACR
ACR
STATE: WASHINGTON
"UMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCMVALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
ENDRIN
LINDANE
MERCURY
SS NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
S SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIOAE
PTEHONAHCIDAE
STATE 10 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 7 PTERONARCIOAE
PERLIDAE
CENTHAflCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINlDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE e OAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINlDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 2 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
NATIONAL 10 HYALELLIDAEfTALITRlDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 6 HYALELUDAEfTALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIOAE
com DAE
CYPRINlDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINlDAE
COTTlDAE
SALMONIDAE
NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
STATE 10 PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
0 440 0.201 *
0.468
0.493
0.647
0.440 0 165 *
0,468
0493
0.775
1800
2.800
7.800
1 100 0112 *
2800
28000
29.000
4020
80062
358792
4020 0219 *
80.062
455015
803845
10000 3218 *
21.988
22437
52871
21988 8.282 *
42198
48.000
64000
5.000 0.470 *
10000
31.623
244259
5000 0.101 *
10000
244259
783471
65077 32.914 *
233.555
345472
401217
65077 20.057 *
401.217
439825
444.717
2.000 0.137 *
6611
32601
99553
2000 0 137 *
2300 **
0.000
0000
339999 82.646 *
1992474
6499979
8479723
339.999 29.603 *
1992474
8479723
24099863
0 002 0.00053 *
0.004
0006
0.012
0.002 0.00026 *
0004
0004
0021
1 300 0.537 *
2627
3547
4725
1300 0.554 *
2.300
2.648
3000
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
00038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0 00003 FCV
0 00002 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.6625 ACR
020 FRV
00674 ACR
3.3931 ACR
2 0677 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FHV
22.0395 ACH
7,8941 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0090 ACR
— ^vj-'.on — "
- - - FPV
III
(N MICROGRAMS "EO iiUfl
FiNAt "lANT /AlUF
tiNAL RESIDUE VAIUC
t 'NAL C-HHONJC VALUE
I - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAX
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAX
IMUM CRITERIA
IMUM AND
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: WASHINGTON
STATE: WEST VIRGINIA
(+) f+) (+) (•*•+)
ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13737 6148 470000 SCV ALDHIN NATIONAL 14 CENTHAHCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41 966 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48 861 EPHEMEHELLIDAE
PHILOD NIDAE 92 757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 9 DAPHN DAE 13 737 2 652 47 0000 SCV STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE 47 229 CENTRAHCHIOAE
PHILOO NIDAE 92757 ANGUILLIDAE
GAMMARIDAE 315 021 CYPRINIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
M CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMON10AE
PTEHONARC1DAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
PAPH NIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 5 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
I COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TU8IFICIDAE
STATE 17 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
eSOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SCIAENIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHfOAE
CCC*'.0TE * _ FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
RQ SC. SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
7451 3.388 *
6.000
9.000
10.803
4.503 1 144 *
7451
16.000
16.392
878.999 113263 *
1794.245
4128.643
6467430
1046139 171.493 *
4128,643
6487.430
9484938
0048 0.027 00004 ACR
0.496
1.147
2860
0034 0,011 00001 ACR
0.664
1,147
6.325 1 974 * 0 0043 FRV
15.000
23,236
32,249
23238 1974 * 00043 FRV
33862 **
54.711
0.000
67000 12 164 0.3378 ACR
6399.976
6996790
24892 828
6998790 1352297 * 100 FPV
24892.828
57461.672
63804 148
0.305 0194 546618 FCV
0.759
0995
1345
0.256 0.133 942403 FCV
0759
0.995
1.345
76.707 31.429 * 4 2472 ACR
83000
114316
125.121
76.707 20.508 * 2.7713 ACH
83.000
114,316
207,958
1 323 0,650 0,0010 FRV
1 595
1.700
2.234
0.976 0210 * 0.0010 FRV
3.904
7840
10000
5000
5.452
3.000
2.459 0.105 * 0.0019 FRV
10.611
30,102
231 052
0664 0208 * 0.1064 ACR
1.279
2.300
3.240
0,664 0.137 * 00701 ACR
1 279
3.240
3611
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: WEST VIRGINIA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE
ENORIN NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMOMDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINlOAE
CENTRARCHlDAE
COENAGRIONIDAEi
lEPTACHLOH NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHlDAE
DAPHNlDAE
CYPRIN DAE
»> LEAD RATIONAL GAMMAHIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPflIN DAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
CENTRARCHlDAE
PHILOD NiDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHlDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINlDAE
MERCUSf NATIONAL 9 DAPHNlDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 6 GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
» VCKEL NATIONAL IB DAPHNlDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PHILODINlDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNlDAE
CENTRARCHlDAE
PHILODINIOAE
CH1RONOMIDAE
PCBS SA-iQNAL. 5 SALMON rD AE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPRINlOAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHlDAE
CYPRINlDAE
COENAGRIONIDAEi
SELEN ^V NATIONAL 10 HYALELLIDAE fTAyT
DAPHNlDAE
CYPHINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNlDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINlDAE
I S ^6R NATIONAL 9 DAPHNlDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINlDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STaTE 5 COTTIDAE
CYPRIN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHlDAE
-OXAPH6--E NA' ONAL 12 PERLIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHlDAE
STATE 6 CENTRARCHlDAE
ICTALURtDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
(•*•)
0440
0468
0493
0.647
0.556
0,732
1,011
kORIONIDAE) 1,800
0995
1.600
2.600
7800
13056
26.000
50748
179508
1.161
4020
80062
358792
60062
358792
455015
603845
21 988
22437
52671
14156
42.198
53066
94.805
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
10,000
50000
248.595
763471
65.077
233,555
345.472
401217
78.456
325.642
401.217
439.625
2000
8.611
32.601
99553
2000
2300
32601
GRiONiOAE)282642
BlDAE) 339 999
1992474
8490979
8479723
3689989
6479 723
9002436
0002
0004
0-008
0012
0004
0011
0.021
0112
1 300
2627
3547
4725
2848
3547
6678
8033
- UNITS IN MiCROG
STATE: WEST VIRGINIA
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(•*•) (+) (++)
0 201 * 0 0023 FRV J ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNlDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0 153 • 0.0023 FRV STATE 11 DAPHNlDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0251 « 00038 FHV
1 425 * 0,0036 FRV
0.037 * 000003 FCV
14969 * 0.00004 FCV
1
3.348 * 0,2676 ACR
0.470 » 0.20 FHV
0764 * 0.20 FHV
32.914 * 33931 ACR
31086 « 32047 ACR
0137 * 0014 FRV
0.024 * 0.014 FRV
62848 * 220395 ACR
'
000053 *
0537 * 00087 ACR
O.BiZ * 00132 ACR
IT ,,»i nc • uAQnuccc eceeft INTFRI-.PPT VAI IIP
FHV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
BCv SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
(+) (+) {+) (++)
13,737 6 148 470000 SCV
41.966
46.861
92.757
21.223 7.606 * 47 0000 SCV
41.966
48.550
92,757
D-69
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE; WISCONSIN
NUMBER OF
ALDRIN NATIONAL 14
STATE B
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8
STATE 6
11 CADMIUM NATIONAL 18
STATE 13
CHLOHOANE NATIONAL 8
STATE 5
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
S COPPER NATIONAL 23
STATE 19
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
STATE 12
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12
STATE 6
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9
STATE 6
D-70
STATE: WISCONSIN
NAME
CENTRARCHIOAE
ASELL DAE
EPHEMEPELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMOMDAE
DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIOAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHILODlNIOAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPHIN DAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHN DAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYS DAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIOAE
DAPHN DAE
PEHCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAPHN DAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PEHCIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIOAE
GAMMAHIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTAC DAE
POEClLIIOAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMOMDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONAPCIDAE
CATOSTQMIOAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPHINIDAE
CATCS^OMlDAE
LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC 50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (+) (+) (++) (+1 (+) (+> <++)
7 451 3 386 * ENDHIN NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEIDAE
8000 SALMONIOAE
9000 PERLIDAE
10803 PT6HONARCIDAE
7451 2844 * STATE B SALMONIDAE
10603 CYPHINIOAE
16 000 CENTRARCHIDAE
16392 PALAEMONIDAE
ara 999 1 13 253 * HEPTACHLOH NATIONAL 10 PTERONAHCIDAE
1794 245 PALAEMONIDAE
14128643 PEflLIDAE
16487430 ASTACIDAE
B7B.999 56960 * STATE 6 PALAEMONIDAE
1046 139 CENTHAHCHIDAE
14128643 SALMONIDAE
16487430 GAMMARIDAE
0040 0027 00004 ACH SS LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIDAE
0496 DAPHNIDAE
1 U7 SALMONIDAE
2860 CYPRINIDAE
0 048 0 019 0,0003 ACR STATE 5 GAMMARIDAE
0864 SALMONIDAE
1 147 CYPRINIDAE
1 630 CENTRARCHIDAE
6 325 1 974 , 0 0043 FRV LINDANE NATIONAL 10 AS6LLIDAE
15000 SALMONIOAE
23238 GAMMAHIDAE
32 249 CENTRARCHIOAE
6 325 1 51 1 * 0 0043 FHV STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
23 238 GAMMAHIOAE
32 249 CENTRARCHIDAE
43739 ICTALURIDAE
67000 12164 03378 ACH MERCURY NATIONAL 9 OAPHNIDAE
6399 976 GAMMARIDAE
6998 790 ASTACJDAE
24B92 828 SALMONIDAE
67 000 3 407 * 0,0946 ACH STATE 7 GAMMAHIDAS
6996790 SALMONIDAE
24892,828 PHILODINIDAE
57461 672 NAIDIDAE
0 305 0 194 5 46618 FCV IS NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
0759 EPHEMERELLIDAE
0 995 CENTHAHCHIDAE
1345 PHILODINIDAE
0,256 0 145 4 79332 FCV STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
0 759 EPHEMEHELLIOAE
0995 CENTRARCHIDAE
1 339 PHILODINIDAE
76 707 31 429 * 4.2472 ACR PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
63.000 CENTRARCHIDAE
125 121 GAMMARIDAE
76 707 29 583 • 3 9977 ACR STATE 5 SALMONIOAE
83 000 CENTRARCHIDAE
114316 CYPRINIDAE
125121 GAMMARIDAE
1 595 DAPHN10AE
1 700 CYPRINODONTIDAE
2.234 SALMONIDAE
0 976 0 397 * 0-0010 FRV STATE 7 HYALELLIDAE CTALITHIDAEJ
1 595 DAPHNIDAE
2234 SALMONIDAE
3000 CYPRINIDAE
4 503 1,830 * 0,0019 FRV S SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
5000 COTTIDAE
5 452 CYPHINIDAE
8 000 CYPRINODONTIDAE
5 452 1 335 * 0 0019 FRV STATE 6 COTTIDAE
'0811 CYPHiNIDAG
20 000 SALMONIDAE
30 102 CENTRARCHIDAE
0 664 0 208 * 0 1064 ACR TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE
1 279 PTERONARCIDAE
2300 ICTALUHIDAE
3 240 CENTHAHCHIDAE
0664 0149 * 00762 ACH STATE 9 CENTHAHCHIDAE
1 279 ICTALUHIDAE
3240 SALMONIDAE
3 811 CYPRINIDAE
0440 0.201 * 00023 FRV
0.468
0.493
0.647
0625 0,231 * 0.0023 FRV
0.732
1.011
1.265
0.995 0.251 * 0.0038 FRV
1 600
2.800
7,800
1.800 0.331 * 00038 FRV
26.000
29.496
37048
1.161 0037 * 0.00003 FCV
4.020
80.062
358792
1 161 0,054 * 0.00004 FCV
50062
356792
455.015
10.000 3.218 * 0.2574 ACR
21 988
22437
52.871
21 988 6.601 * 0.5281 ACR
22.437
42.198
53066
5.000 0470 * 0.20 FHV
10.000
31623
244.259
10.000 1 222 * 020 FRV
244,259
783471
65.077 32914 * 33931 ACH
233 555
345472
401217
78.456 33.860 * 3.4906 ACR
233555
345.472
401,217
2.000 0.137 * 0.014 FHV
6.611
99553
2000 0,063 * 0.014 FRV
2.300
32.601
99.553
1992^474
6499.979
8479.723
339.999 62 601 * 16,7469 ACR
3869,989
8479.723
9002438
0.002 000053 *
0.004
0.006
0.012
0004 000041 *
0.011
0.021
0 112
1.300 0.537 * 0,0067 ACH
2,627
3.547
4.725
2 648 0.943 * 0.0153 ACR
3,547
5.781
8.033
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: WISCONSIN STATE: WYOMING
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
S ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13,737 6 148 47 0000 SCV ALDHIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRAHCHIDAE
PHYSiOAE 41 966 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48661 EPHEMEHELUDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92 757 SALUONIDAE
PHYSlDAE 41.966 CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE 44 947 EPHEMGRELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92,757 CYPRINIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 6 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
SJ CADMIUM NATIONAL 16 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSlDAE
STATE 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSlDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTEflONARClDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 6 PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSlDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSlDAE
CYPHINIDAE
S COPPER NATIONAL 23 OAPHN10AE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSlDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIOAE
TUBIFICIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
OAPHN1DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECIL11DAE
ASELLIOAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
ENOOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 8 5ALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
CATOSTOMIOAE
'-' - MNII-., IN MirttOORAMS PER LITEH • • - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
- - - '*, F.NAL PLANT VALUE s - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
n> / FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 r TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
=cv FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
'^C - SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30'DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
SO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
7,451 3.388 *
8.000
9.000
10.803
4.503 1.433 *
7451
9.000
18.392
678.909 113.263 *
1794245
4128,643
6487430
1794.245 407.358 *
4126.643
6467.430
9484.936
0.046 0027 00004 ACR
0.496
1 147
2380
0.034 0 009 0.0001 ACR
0496
1 147
2380
8.325 1.974 * 0,0043 FRV
15000
23.238
32249
15.000 5.586 * 0.0043 FRV
23238
26.000
33.662
67.000 12 164 03376 ACR
6399976
6998790
4892.828
6399.976 761 038 * 10.0 FPV
6996790
4892.828
7461.672
0.305 0,194 546618 FCV
0.759
0995
1.345
0305 0.132 9.65862 FCV
0.759
0.995
1.345
76.707 31.429 * 42472 ACR
83000
114.316
125121
76.707 28.920 * 3.9081 ACR
83.000
114.316
125.121
1.323 0.650 0.0010 FRV
1,595
1.700
2234
1323 0.463 * 00010 FRV
1.595
3000
3.282
4.503 1.630 * 0.0019 FRV
5.000
5452
8.000
2.459 0.632 * 0.0019 FRV
8.000
10.811
24.000
0.664 0.206 * 01064 ACR
1 279
2.300
3.240
0664 0.196 * 0.1003 ACR
1279
2.300
3240
D-71
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: WYOMING
STATE: WYOMING
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
ENDRlN NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 9 SALMONIDAE
PERLIOAE
PT6HONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
HEPTACHLOH NATIONAL 10 PTEHONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
AST AC DAE
STATE 7 PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
I LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHN DAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTAC1DAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHN DAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
I NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHN DAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOO NIDAE
STATE 9 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOM1DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 SALMONIDAE
CSNTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 7 HYALELLIDAE(TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTI DAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHN IOAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 10 PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAe
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
ACR
11 SCV
( + )
0.440
0468
0493
0,647
0357
0493
0647
1.011
0995
1800
2800
7800
0995
2.800
13058
26.000
1 161
4020
80062
358792
4020
80,062
358792
455,015
10000
21988
22.437
52871
14 158
42.196
46000
53.066
5.000
10.000
31.623
244 259
5,000
10.000
248.595
783.471
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
65.077
401.217
439 825
2,000
8611
32,601
99553
2.000
2300
32,601
0000
1992 474
6499979
8479,723
339999
1992.474
8479 723
9002438
0.002
0.004
0,006
0.012
0002
0.004
0006
0.021
1.300
2827
3547
4725
1300
2627
2.848
3547
COMPUTED
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM '" nAV Ai/eoinc rntifANT FAUII ice TPSTPH UAUF i rviUAi nc UAVIUUU SO-DAY AVERAGE
0201 *
0.125 *
0251 *
0125 *
0037 *
0287 *
3218 *
5.119 *
0.470 *
0.101 *
32914 *
21717 *
0.137 *
0137 *
62648 *
52431 *
0.00053
000030
0.537 *
0543 *
BY ACUTE TO C
(+) (++)
0 0023 FRV I ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMON10AE
PHILODINIDAE
0 0023 FHV STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0.0038 FHV
0.0038 FRV
000003 FCV
000003 FCV
0 2574 ACR
0 4095 ACH
0.20 FHV
0.0671 ACR
3 3931 ACH
2.2368 ACR
0014 FRV
0014 FRV
22 0395 ACR
139816 ACR
*
0.0087 ACH
00088 ACR
HRONIC RATIO METHOD SS - HARDNESS EPFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
C VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
(+) (+) < + ) (++I
13.737 6,148 470000 SCV
41.966
48,861
92757
13.737 4.647 * 47.0000 SCV
41.966
49.969
92.757
-------
APPENDIX E
RECALCULATION RESULTS
ARSENIC (Continued)
A B C D E F
0 14 6.77544 000000
1 8 662517 000000
2 9 3.53950 000000
393 53950 000000
4 9 303909 000000
5 9 303909 000000
6 9 3.03909 000000
7 10 3.65814 000000
8 10 3.16941 000000
9 9 3.59180 000000
10 9 3.59180 000000
11 9 549744 000000
12 9 303909 000000
1393 59130 000000
U 8 3.47503 000050
15 7 352505 000050
16 6 5.38018 1 00056
17 5 2.28722 000056
18 7 3.54744 000006
19 7 2.30346 000006
20 7 2.80346 000006
21 8 2 73738 000006
22 9 553449 000000
23 8 5.65470 000006
24 7 478954 100006
25 8 568878 000006
26 10 6.46080 000006
27 7 3.04911 000006
28 7 5.54667 100006
29 6 5.10268 100006
30 6 4 36192 100006
31 7 5.29145 000006
32 6 2 18099 000006
33 8 2.73738 000000
34 6 2.66557 000056
35 5 4.90740 1 00056
37 7 5.29145 100006
38 8 527613 000000
39 8 2.86675 000000
40 8 286675 000000
41 10 3.85605 000000
42 8 3.33624 000000
43 9 3.74818 000000
44 10 3.85605 000000
45 8 6.48464 000000
46 8 6.67460 000000
47 8 3 47503 000000
48 9 6.76577 000000
0 48 24 29 38 7.45060
8 29 4Q 37 47 899999
8 38 48 29 40 450313
8 38 48 29 40 4.50313
8 38 48 29 37 4.50313
8 38 48 29 37 4.50313
8 38 48 29 37 4.50313
8 38 48 29 37 5.24109
8 38 48 29 37 4.50313
8 38 48 29 40 4.50313
8 38 48 29 40 4.50313
8 48 29 38 37 7.45060
8 38 48 29 37 4.50313
8 38 48 29 40 4.50313
8 38 48 29 40 4.50313
8 38 48 29 47 450313
8 48 47 40 37 7.45060
8 38 48 37 40 4.50313
8 38 48 24 47 4.50313
8 38 48 47 37 4.50313
8 38 48 47 37 4.50313
8 38 48 37 40 4 50313
3 48 29 38 37 7 45060
8 48 47 38 37 7.45060
8 48 24 47 37 7.45060
8 43 38 37 40 7.45060
8 48 24 47 38 7.45060
8 38 48 37 40 5.24109
8 48 37 40 44 7.45060
8 48 47 37 40 7.45060
8 . 48 24 37 40 7.45060
8 48 47 37 40 7.45060
8 38 48 40 44 450313
8 38 48 37 40 4.50313
8 38 48 47 37 4.50313
8 48 47 37 40 7.45060
8 48 47 37 40 7.45060
0 48 29 38 40 7.45060
0 38 48 29 40 4.50313
0 38 48 29 40 4.50313
0 38 48 29 47 4.50313
0 38 48 29 40 5.24109
0 38 48 29 47 4.50313
0 38 48 29 47 4.50313
0 48 29 38 40 7.45060
0 48 29 47 38 7.45060
0 38 48 29 40 4.50313
0 48 29 47 38 7.45060
ARSENIC
A B C D E F
20 8 226 52585 000000
2 ' 3 0.00000 003056
2 ?- 4 296 18365 000056
2 :i 4 296.18365 000056
2-1 5 342.98663 000056
25 4 283.23920 000056
26 4 283.23920 000056
27 6 113.95972 000006
28 5 342.98663 000056
29 5 34298663 000056
2 10 5 343.63538 000056
2 11 4 283.23920 000056
2 12 4 283.23920 000056
12 13 4 264.68555 000056
2 14 4 264.68555 000056
2 15 5 342.98663 000056
2 16 5 31207068 100056
2 17 5 342.98663 000056
2 IB 5 156.20842 000006
2 19 6 116-20842 000006:
2 20 5 343.63538 000056
2 21 5 342.98663 000056
2 22 6 113.95972 000006
2 23 5 343.63538 000056
2 24 5 84 75481 100006
2 25 6 11395972 000006
2 26 6 116.20842 000006
2 27 5 34298663 000056
2 28 5 84 75481 1 00006
2 29 4 28098602 100056
2 30 5 84 75481 100006
2 31 4 280 98602 100056
8 .25 19 38 42 878.99878 1
8 19 38 40 0 1046.13916
8 19 38 40 48 1046.13916
8 19 38 40 48 1046.13916
8 19 38 42 48 1046.13916
8 19 38 43 40 1046.13916
B 19 38 48 40 1046.13916
8 25 19 38 42 878.99878 1
8 19 38 42 48 1046.13916
8 19 38 42 48 1046.13916
8 19 38 42 48 1046.13916
8 19 38 48 40 1046.13916
8 19 38 48 40 1046.13916
8 19 38 48 40 1046-13916
8 19 38 48 40 1046.13916
8 19 38 42 48 1046.13916
8 19 42 48 4Q 1046.13916
8 19 38 42 48 1046.13916
8 25 19 38 42 878.99878 1
8 25 19 38 42 873.99378 1
8 19 38 42 48 1046-13916
8 19 38 42 48 1046.13916
8 25 19 38 42 878.99878 1
8 19 38 42 48 1046.13916
6 25 19 42 48 878.99878 1
8 25 19 38 42 878-99878 1
8 25 19 38 42 878.99878 1
8 19 38 42 48 1046-13916
5 25 19 42 48 878.99878 1
8 19 42 48 40 1046.13916
3 25 19 42 48 878.99878 1C
G A B C D E
7.99999 8.99999 10.80319 12 32 5 727.20288 000056
1 1 . 731 88 1 5.99998 20.49388 1 2 33 5 727 20288 000056
7.45060 8.99999
7.45060 8.99999
7.45060 8.99999
7.45060 8.99999
7.45060 8.99999
7.45060 8.99999
7.45060 8.99999
7.45060 8.99999
7.45060 8.99999
8.99999 14.37683
7.45060 8.99999
7.45060 8.99999
7.45060 8 99999
7.45060 8.99999
999999 11.31370
7.45060 15.99993
7.45060 7.99999
7.45060 9.99999
7.45060 9.99999
7.45060 15.99998
8.99999 10.80319
9.99999 10.80319
7.99999 9.99999
10.80319 15.99998
7.99999 9 99999
7.45060 15.99998
15.99998 16.39186
9.99999 1599998
7.99999 15.99998
9.99999 15.99998
745060 16.39186
745060 15.99998
7 45060 9.99999
9.99999 15.99998
9.99999 15.99998
8.99999 14.37683
7.45060 8.99999
7.45060 8.99999
7.45060 8.99999
7.45060 8.99999
7 45060 8.99999
7.45060 8.99999
8.99999 10.80319
8.99999 9.99999
7.45060 8.99999
8.99999 9.99999
1.73188 12 34 5 726.89221 000056
1.73188 12 35 4 280.98602 1 00056
5.99998 12 36 6 116.20842 000006
599998 12 37 4 280.98602 100056
5.99998 12 38 6 814 71533 000050
5.99998 12 39 6 814.71533 000050
5.99998 12 40 6 814.52979 000050
1.31370 12 41 6 814.71533 000050
1.31370 12 42 5 701.91382 000050
599998 12 43 6 814.71533 000050
5.S3998 12 4 6 814.71533 000050
131370 12 5 5 68769226 000050
131370 12 6 4 573.39880 000056
999999 12 7 5 726.89221 000056
5.99998 12 8 5 726.89221 000056
6.39186
9 99999
599998 CADMIUM
5.99998 A B C D E
6.39186 I3 0
5.99998 ,3 ,
5.99998 13 2
5.99998 ,3 3
6.39186 13 d
0.80319 I3 5
639186 13 6
0.99998 13 7
639186 13 8
6.39186 ,3 9
639186 ,3 10
0.99998 , 3 , ,
639186 13 12
5.99998 13 13
6.39186 13 ,4
5.99998 13 ^g
6.39186 ,3 16
6.39186 13 17
6.39186 13 lg
6.39186 13 13
9.99999 13 20
6.39186 13 21
9.99999 13 22
9.99999 13 23
1.31370 ,3 24
0.80319 13 25
1.31370 13 26
0.80319 13 27
13 28
13 29
13 30
G 13 31
8 0.05331 000000
6 0.02957 000000
5 0.03361 000000
5 0.03361 000000
6 0.03768 000000
6 0.03768 000000
6 0.03768 000000
7 0.05738 000000
6 0.03768 000000
7 0.04210 000000
7 0.05323 000000
7 0.04210 000000
5 0.03361 000000
6 0.03768 000000
F
8 19 38 42 48
8 19 38 42 48
8 19 38 42 48
8 19 42 48 40 -
8 25 19 38 42
8 19 42 48 40
8 19 38 42 48
8 19 38 42 48
8 19 38 42 48
8 19 38 42 48
8 19 38 48 40
8 19 38 42 48
8 19 38 42 48
8 19 38 48 32
8 19 38 48 40
8 19 38 42 48
8 19 38 42 48
F
00 38
00 38
00 38
00 38
00 38
00 38
00 38
00 38
00 38
00 38
00 '38
00 38
00 38
00 38
5 0.03159 00005000 38
4 0.01678 00005000 38
3 0.09204 10005000 47
2 0.02102 0 0 0 '0 0 0
4 0.02695 000000
4 0.02695 000000
4 0.02695 000000
4 0.02986 000000
5 0.04677 000000
4 0.03744 000000
3 0.11793 100000
3 0.03761 000000
5 0.04099 000000
4 0.04202 000000
3 0.63411 1 00000
3 0.11793 100000
2 0.42257 1 00000
00 38
00 38
00 38
00 38
00 38
DO 38
DO 38
DO 47
DO 38
00 38
DO 38
00 19
DO 47
30 19
2 0.08204 10005000 47
496395? 5659937 000000 13 33 " °-03'78 00000000 38
4128644 5659937 19484™° 13 34 '2 a01256 00005000 38
4 28644 5659937 948494 13 35 12 °-08204 10005000 47
4 28644 6487433 948494 13 36 " °02695 00000000 38
4 28644 948494? 20194386 13 37 "• °°8204 10005000 47
4 28644 948494 20 94 386 13 38 " °-01899 00000000 38
4C1701K I^JeSl ?6.!a7 411 13 39 12 °-01899 00000000 38
4?28644 SIS W8494? <3 « 12 0.02467 00000000 38
4 28644 6487433 948494 '3 "' 15 °-02453 00000000 38
3339966 6487433 948494 13 42 12 °02682 00000000 38
4128644 9484941 20194386 13 43 '2 0'01797 00000000 38
4 28644 948494 20 94386 13 « " " O'02000 00000000 38
4 28644 948Y94 2604^878 13 45 12 °°2682 00000000 38
4 28644 948494 2604 878 13 « 13 °02729 00000000 38
4 28 644 6487433 19484941 '3 " 12 °-°"»*> 00000000 38
648?:«3 1948494? 26041:878 « 48 » °°2999 00000000 38
4128.644 16487433 19484.94)
46.13916 13339.966 16487.433
46.13916 13339.966 16487.433 CHIORDANE
3339966 16487433 19484941 ABC D E
4128.644 16487.433 19484941 208 3.94866 000000
4613916 14128.644 16487.433 2 1 3 0.00000 003 06
3339.966 16487.433 19484.941 224 6.22610 000 06
46.13916 16487.433 19484.941 234 6.54425 000 06
46.13916 14128.644 16487.433 244 15.34912 000 06
46.13916 13339.966 16487.433 254 15.34912 000 06
4128.644 16487.433 19484.941 26 4 • 15.34912 000 06
46.13916 16487.433 19484.941 275 3.11714 000 06
6487.433 19484.941 20194.386 285 3.09937 000 06
46.13916 16487.433 19484.941 294 9.13705 000 06
8 19 42 48 40 1046.13916 16487.433 19484.941 20194.386 2 10 4 8.24052 000 06
COLUMN KEY
A CHEMICAL ID
B STATE ID
C. NO Of RESIC
E. EIGHT CRITERIA (A NUMBER SIGNIFIES A CRITERIA NOT SATISFI
F FOUR MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILIES
ENT FAMILIES G. FAMILY MEAN ACUTE VALUE FOR FOUR MOST SENSITIVE SPEC
9 25 16
9 25 44
9 25 44
9 25 44
9 25 44
9 25 44
9 '25 44
9 25 44
9 25 44
9 25 44
9 25 44
9 25 44
9 25 44
9 25 44
9 44 16
7 19 16
9 16 7
9 25 16
7 19 25
7 19 25
7 19 25
9 25 44
9 25 44
7 19 25
9 25 16
9 25 44
7 19 25
9 25 44
5 44 16
9 25 16
5 16 7
9 16 7
9 25 44
9 25 44
7 19 16
9 16 7
7 19 25
9 16 7
9 25 16
9 25 16
9 25 16
7 19 25
9 25 16
7 19 25
7 19 25
9 25 16
7 19 25
9 25 16
7 19 25
F
8 27 32 40 25
8 40 25 38 0
8 40 25 38 48
8 40 25 38 48
8 40 38 25 48
8 40 38 25 48
8 40 38 25 48
8 27 40 25 38
8 27 40 38 25
3 40 38 25 48
8 40 38 25 48
EDt
ES
D FINAL ACUTE VALUE (FAV)
1794.24536
1794.24536
1794.24536
1046.13916
878.99878 1
1046.13916
1794.24536
1794.24536
1794.24536
1794.24536
1794.24536
1794.24536
1794.24536
1794.24536
1794.24536
1794.24536
1794.24536
0.04761
0.02644
0.03407
0.03407
0.03407
0.03407
0.03407
0.04761
0.03407
0.03407
0.04389
0.03407
0.03407
0.03407
0.03407
0.03407
0.16279
0.03407
0.04389
0.04389
0.04389
0.03407
0.04761
0.06389
0.16279
0-04761
0-06389
0.04761
0.86438
0.16279
0.86438
0.16279
0.04389
0.04389
0.03407
0.16279
0-04389
0.16279
0.03407
0.03407
0.04389
0-03407
0.04761
0.03407
0.03407
0.04761
0.04761
0.03407
0.04761
6.32455
12.37093
12.37093
12.37093
23.23838
23.23838
23.23838
6.32455
6.32455
15.68437
15.68437
G
3339.966 16487.433 19484.941
3339.966 1 6487.433 19484.94 1
4128.644 16487.433 19484.941
6487.433 19484.941 20194.386
46. 1 391 6 1 3339.966 1 6487.433
6487.433 19484.941 20194.386
128.644 16487.433 19484.941
128.644 16487.433 19484.941
339.966 16487.433 19484.941
128.644 16487.433 19484.941
128.644 19484.941 20194.386
1 28.644 1 6487.433 1 9484.94 1
128.644 16487.433 19484.941
128.644 19484.941 22039.906
1 28.644 1 9484.94 1 2604 1 .878
1 28.644 1 6487.433 1 9484.94 1
128.644 16487.433 19484.941
G
0.49564 1.14678 2.86002
0.86438 1.14678 1.63031
0.86438 1.14678 1.63031
0.86438 1.14678 1.63031
0.86438 1.14678 1.63031
0.86438 1.14678 1.63031
0.86438 1.14678 T.63031
0.86438 1.14678 1.63031
0.86438 1.14678 1.63031
0.86438 1.14678 1.63031
0.86438 1.14678 1.63031
0.86438 1.14678 1.63031
0.86438 1.14678 1.63031
0.86438 1.14678 1.63031
0.86438 1.63031 2.86002
0.16279 0.86438 2.86002
0.86438 2.86002 6.98678
0.86438 1.14678 2.86002
0.16279 0.86438 1.14678
0.16279 0.86438 1.14678
0.16279 0.86438 1.14678
0.86438 1.14678 1.63031
0.86438 1.14678 1.63031
0.16279 0.86438 1.14678
0.86438 1.14678 2.86002
0.86438 1.14678 1.63031
0.16279 0.86438 1.14678
0.86438 1.14678 1.63031
1.14678 1.63031 2.86002
0.86438 1.14678 2.86002
1.14678 2.86002 6.98678
0.86438 2.86002 6.98678
0.49564 1.14678 1.63031
0.49564 1.14678 1.63031
0.16279 0.49564 2.86002
0.86438 2.86002 6.98678
0.16279 0.86438 1.14678
0.86438 2.86002 6.98678
0.49564 1.14678 2.86002
0.49564 1.14678 2.86002
0.49564 1.14678 2.86002
0.16279 0.49564 1.14678
0.49564 1.14678 2.86002
0.16279 0.49564 1.14678
0.16279 0.49564 1.14678
0.49564 1.14678 2.86002
0.16279 0.49564 1.14678
0.49564 1.14678 2.86002
0.16279 0.49564 1.14678
G
14.99998 23.23838 32.24899
25.99997 50.19954 0.00000
25.99997 33.86198 54.71 104
32.24899 33.86198 54.71 104
33.86198 39.99995 54.71104
33.86198 39.99995 54.71 104
33.86193 39.99995 54.71104
23.23838 32.24899 40.28093
23.23838 33.86198 39.99995
33.86198 39.99995 54.71104
25.48079 39.99995 54.71104
E-1
-------
APPENDIX E
RECALCULATION RESULTS
CMLORDANE Continued) C
2 '2
; 13
? 14
2 18
2 16
2 1?
2 18
2 IB
2 20
2 21
2 22
2 23
2 24
2 25
2 26
2 2'
2 2fl
2 29
2 30
2 31
2 32
2 33
2 34
2 35
2 36
2 37
2 38
2 39
2 40
2 41
2 42
2 43
2 44
2 45
2 48
2 47
2 48
CHROMIUM
ABC
TT TT Ti
14 2
14 3
14 4
14 5
14 6
4 7
4 8
4 9
4 10
4 12
4 13
4 15
4 16
4 17
14 18
14 19
14 JO
14 21
14 22
U 23
t4 24
14 25
14 J7
14 28
14 29
4 30
4 31
4 32
4 33
4 3d
j 35
14 36
14 37
14 36
id 39
1J 40
4 11
E-2
'< 1 t/05
0 00000
n 0X00
0 0X00
000000
246420
246420
309937
302199
1610177
000000
302199
291331
1502123
2 40522
000000
000000
2 '9377
12 16771
12 16771
1403268
000000
364929
1 1 1655
1012206
11 17580
12 45222
11 17580
10 08393
11 17580
11 54149
755015
8 71353
6 9 38545
6 1408880
D
24 52*48 t
3622 37207 0
3920 66992
2397 86377
338491846
338491346
1077488
3384 91846
3209 34570
3077 48486
3384 91846
3384 91846
3209 34570
320934570
320934570
424824512
2704 59375
10 77488
1077488
338491B46
3062 93096
881313
3334 9<846
821666
681313
1077488
3062 98096
681313
3093 64844
501090
3093 84844
1562 07563
156207568
24*728809
3093 64844
138961?
454225586
156207563
156207568
156207566
0
•) o
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
0
0
6
5
5
5
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 I
0
0
0
0
5
5
0
0
0
0
o e
0 6
E
0 0
6
:
e
0
6
! 6
1081 38940 000056
7 8
6
8
a
8
B
8
8
a
8
6
8
8
8
a
a
e
e
B
8
3
a
a
8
8
B
6
8
8
6
B
8
8
6
8
B
0 2
2
2
2
2
i
2
40 25 33 48 23 23338 39 99995 40 04399 54 71 104
40 38 25 48 2323838 3386198 3999996 5471104
40 38 25 43 15 68437 33 86198 39 99995 54 71104
40 38 48 0 15 68437 33 86198 54 71104 0 00000
40 38 48 0 15 68437 33 86198 54 71 104 000000
40 43 45 0 15 66437 54 71104 189 99966 0 00000
40 38 48 0 2323638 3386198 54 71104 000000
40 38 48 0 23 23838 25 48079 54 71104 0 00000
27 40 38 48 6 32455 23 23538 25 48079 54 71 104
27 40 38 48 632455 2323833 2543079 5471104
27 40 38 25 6 32455 23 23838 33 86198 39 99995
27 40 25 36 632455 2323838 3224899 437392B
40 25 38 46 2323338 3999995 4332893 5471104
27 40 46 0 632455 2323838 5471104 000000
27 40 25 38 632455 2323636 3224399 4373926
27 40 25 38 6 32455 23 23838 39 99995 43 32693
40 25 38 48 23 23836 32 24899 40 28093 54 71 104
27 40 25 48 6 32455 23 23838 39 99995 54 71 104
27 40 48 0 632455 2323838 5471104 000000
27 40 4fl 0 632455 2323638 5471104 000000
27 40 48 38 6.32455 23 23838 54 71 104 55.99992
40 38 25 48 23 23636 25 48079 25 99997 54 71104
40 38 25 48 2323838 2548079 2599997 5471104
40 38 48 19 33,23838 338619B 5471104 5826653
40 48 0 0 2 23838 5471104 000000 000000
27 40 38 25 32455 23 23838 25 48079 25.99997
27 40 48 45 32455 23 23838 54 71 104 169 99966
32 40 25 38 1 99998 2323838 25,99997 4004399
32 40 25 38 1 99998 2323838 25.99997 33,86198
32 40 38 25 1 99998 2323838 2548079 2599997
32 40 25 38 1 99998 23.23838 2599997 33.86198
32 40 25 38 1 99998 2323333 2599997 4023093
32 40 25 38 1 99998 2323838 2599997 3386198
32 40 25 38 1 99998 23.23833 2599997 33.86198
32 40 25 38 1 99998 15,68437 2599997 4373926
40 25 38 48 i 68437 2599997 4373926 5471104
40 25 38 46 1 68437 2599997 33.68198 54.71104
40 25 38 48 2323838 2599997 4373926 5471104
F G
l
19
19
19
8 19
47 40 699879004 24892832 30454.753 40637.617
47 40 6998 79004 24892 832 30454 753 40637 61 7
40 38 699879004 24892832 40637617 63804 156
47 40 699879004 24892832 30454 753 57461 679
47 no 899879004 24892832 30454753 57461679
16 47 6699988 699879004 24692832 30454753
47 40 6998 79004 24892,832 30454 753 57461 679
47 36 6998 79004 24692 632 30454 753 63604 156
47 36 6998 79004 24892 832 30454 753 68999 796
47 40 6998 79004 24892 832 30454 753 57461 679
47 40 6998 79004 24892.632 30454 753 57461 679
47 38 699B 79004 24892 832 30454 753 63804 156
47 38 699879004 24892832 30454 733 63804 156
47 36 6998 79004 24892 832 30454 753 63804 156
45 47 699879004 24892.832 29999371 3Q454 753
40 38 6998 79004 24892.332 57461 679 63304 156
16 47 6699938 8998.79004 24892332 30454753
16 47 66 99988 6998.79004 24B92 832 30454 753
47 40 699879004 24892832 30454753 57461679
40 35 6998.79004 24692832 57461679 59899710
16 40 6699988 699879004 24B92832 57461679
47 40 6998 79004 24892 832 30454 753 57461 679
16 47 66 99968 6996 79004 24392 832 30454 753
16 40 66 999B3 6998 79004 24892 832 57461 679
16 47 66 99988 6998 79004 24892 832 30454 753
40 35 6993 79004 24892 832 57461 679 59899 710
16 40 66 99988 6998 79004 24692 632 57461 679
47 40 6998 79004 24892 832 30454 753 "57461 679
16 40 66 99988 6998 79004 24392 832 57461 679
47 40 6998 79004 24892 832 30454 753 5746 1 679
16 40 639997559 699879004 24892832 57461679
16 40 6399 97559 6998 79004 24892 332 57461 679
16 47 6399 97559 6998 79004 24892.832 30454 753
47 40 699879004 24892.832 30454753 57461679
16 47 6699988 699879004 24892832 30454753
16 40 6399 97559 6998 79004 24892 632 57461 679
16 40 6399 97559 6993 79004 24892 832 57461 679
16 40 6399 97559 6998 79004 24892 632 57461 679
40 38 639997559 699879004 57461679 63804.156
HROMIUM (Conllnuad)
BCD F
43 6
44 7
45 5
46 6
48 7
OPPER
_§_ _
0
1 2
2
3
4
5
6
7
3
9
10
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
ANIDE
t T
2
3
5
8
9
10
12
13
18
19
20
21
22
152689502 0000 605 9
2281 69336 0000 608 9
931.21777 0000 608 9
143740869 0000 603 9
1439.90771 0000 608 9
2281 69336 0000 608 9
3 0.38709 0 0
0 0 30222 0 0
B 0,27787 0 0
8 027737 0 0
9 028994 0 0
8 027787 0 0
8 027787 0 0
0 030222 0 0
9 026994 0 0
8 0.27787 0 0
3 0.23446 0 0
8 027787 0 0
9 028994 0 0
8 027787 0 0
7 026600 0 0
6 0,25432 0 0
0 25432 1 0
0,26600 0 0
0.28446 0 0
0 27347 0 0
0 27347 0 0
9 028994 0 0
9 029007 0 0
9 029539 0 0
6 025432 1 0
9 029007 0 0
9 0.29539 0 0
6 0.27787 0 0
7 026600 1 0
6 0,25432 1 0
5 024283 1 0
5 024635 0 0
6 029905 0 0
4 0.23152 1 0
5 024283 1 0
3 0,26342 0 0
3 026342 0 0
3 026513 0 0
6 0.29905 0 0
C D
00000
00000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
5000
3000
5000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
0000
5000
05000
05000
00000
00000
00000
E
45
38
47
45
45
F
9 33
9 35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
33
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
33
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
40
47
40
38
38
47
"6 9~
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6 3
6 '
6
6
6
6
6 38
6 36
6 36
6 9
6 38
6 33
6 9
6 33
6 33
6 9
6 9
6 9
6 9
6 38
6 38
6 38
6 9
6 9
6 38
6 9
6 9
6 9
6 J8
6 9
9 15
9 15
9 15
35 9 38
35 9 33
35 9 15
35 9 38
F
71 89795 00000606 1946354
5734061 00005608 38 19 48 4
59 16601 00000608 36 19 48 4
59 16601 00000608 38 19 48 4
5916601 00000608 3
6043829 00000608 3
4291940 00005608 3
6043629 00000608 3
5784061 00005608 3
5916601 00005608 3
29.31423 00005606 3,
36,13332 10005606 1
3726158 00000608 3
3726158 00000608 3
30.91743 00005603 3
8 6043829 00003008 3
8 6043629 00000603 3
B 19 46 4
8 19 48 4
8 19 43 4
B 19 48 4
B 19 48 4
8 *9 4B 49
8 19 46 49
3 19 48 49
B 19 48 40
9 48 45 40
B 19 48 40
8 19 48 25
B 19 46 25
B 19 46 40
B 19 48 49
B 19 48 49
G
6399 97559 6998 79004
6399 97559 6998 79004
6399.97559 6998.79004
6399.97359 6998.79004
6399 97559 6998 79004
6399 97559 6998 79004
Q
0.30511 07587
0.25567 0.7567
0.25567 0 7587
0.25567 0,7567
0 25587 0 75B7
0.25587 0,7387
0 25587 0 7587
0 2S5B7 0.7587
0 25587 0,7587
0 25587 0 7587
0.25587 0.7587
0.25587 0.7587
0.25587 0.7587
0,25587 0.7587
0.25587 0 7587
0 25587 0.7587
0.25587 0,7587
0.25567 0.7587
025587 0.7587
0.25587 0.7587
0.25587 0.7587
0,25587 0 75873
0 25587 0 75873
0.25537 0 75873
0,25587 0 75873
0.25587 0 75373
0.25587 0.75873
0.25587 0.75873
0 25587 0,75873
0 255B7 0 75873
025587 0,75873
0 25587 0.75873
0.30511 075873
0.30511 0.75873
0.30511 0.75873
0,25587 0.75873
0.25587 0.75873
0.25537 0.75873
0,30511 075373
0.3051 1 0.75873
030511 0.75873
0.3051 1 0.75873
0.30511 0.75873
0.30511 0.75873
0.30511 075873
0.30511 0.75873
0,30511 0.75873
030511 075373
0.30511 075873
Q
76 70667 82.99980
8299980 10199974
76 70667 82 99980
76.70667 82.99980
76.70667 32.99950
76 70667 82.99980
76 70667 82.99980
76.70667 8299980
76.70667 82.99980
76.70667 82.99980
56 99990 82,99950
76 70667 82 99980
76 70667 62 99980
76.70667 82.99980
76.70667 82.99980
76.70667 82.99980
82.99980 114.31555
76.70667 82.99950
56 99990 62.99980
56.99990 82 99980
56 99990 82.999BO
76.70667 52 99950
76.70667 82,99980
29999.871 30454 753
63804156 81251.093
30454 753 63804 156
29999.871 63804.156
29999 871 30454 753
099528
099528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99526
099528
099528
0,99528
0.99523
099328
0.9952B
0.99528
099528
0,99528
0,99528
099523
099528
0.99528
099528
099323
0.99528
0.99528
0,99523
099528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99525
0,99528
0,99528
099523
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99328
0.99526
0.99526
0.99528
0.99526
099528
0.99528
0.99528
099528
1 34462
1,34462
1.34462
1 34462
1 34462
1 ,34462
1 34462
34462
34462
34462
.34462
34462
34462
34462
34462
34462
,34462
02215
.34462
34462
34462
34462
,34462
34462
34462
.02215
02215
02215
34462
33946
04852
34462
33946
.04352
34462
34462-
.34462
34462
2359B
.02215
.02215
.34462
.34462
02213
34462
,34462
34462
30926
.34462
42372
42372
,42372
40105
40105
42372
40105
1431555 12512123
03,22679 125,12128
4,31555 125.12128
431555 (2512128
431555 12512128
431555 125.12128
4.31553 125.12128
4,31555 12512128
431555 12512128
431535 12512128
4.31555 12512126
431555 12512128
431555 125 12128
431555 125 12123
4,31555 12512128
4.31555 317.99933
06.48419 31799933
431555 20795767
431355 16699973
431355 16699973
4.31555 207 95767
4.31535 12512123
4,31555 12512128
-------
APPENDIX E
RECALCULATION RESULTS
CYANIDE (Continued)
5_ _§- S. _
0 E F Q
S'360
91743
C?35
i6f '
ez25
• i;-
" C1 .> 0 5 t-
C1 " 0 6
•/ " 6
00? 0
0 0 0 5 C
•3 C 0 5 6
00056
00006
00056
00056
? 0 0 0 6
; o o s e
8 38 19 46 49 5699990 83.99960
B 19 48 25 40 62 99980 1 14 31555 6
8 38 19 46 49 76 70667 8! 99980
3 38 19 48 49 56 99990 62 99960 1
8 38 19 48 49 7670667 82 9980 1
8 )9 48 49 25 8299980 114 1555 2
8 19 48 JO 16 8299980 114 i555 0
8 19 48 25 40 8399930 114 1555 6
8 19 46 40 16 82 99980 1 14. 1555 o
B 36 19 48 49 5699990 82.99980 1
8 38 19 48 49 5699990 8299980 1
8 38 19 48 49 7670667 8299980 I
3 19 48 49 40 8399960 11431555 2
B 36 19 J* 25 5699990 8? 99960 1
8 19 48 d9 40 8299960 11431555 2
8 36 19 48 49 7670667 82 99980 1
8 38 19 48 49 76 70667 82 999BO 1
8 38 19 48 40 5699990 6299960 1
B 38 19 48 49 7670667 8299980 1
8 38 19 48 49 75 7066? 82 99980 1
6 38 1 46 49 7670667 8299980 1
6 38 1 48 49 7670667 8299980 1
8 38 1 48 49 7670667 8299980 1
8 38 1 48 49 76 7Q667 62 99980 1
: : 0 5 6 7 8 38 19 48 40 7670667 8299980 '
F F Q
c : c- : 5
•: : c o
>6£e5 c -: o •:
3945 c : •: "
9037 o o : :
J0026 -000
1916 0003
-<•; oooo
2-'^ 0 C 0 0
.3585 OOOO
H2C5 OOOO
1'A' H 0 0 0
•45-; :•• ooo
6562 "000
JJ4- c 0 0 0
rfj2i : ;< o o
2*6' :- : o o
3Z65 :• •: 00
^42 'j ' 0 C
i"i 0:00
0
oc-es 00 rJ *•>
OC'ti 1 0 fj fi
I6J12 OOOO'
0 19 49 39 25 ' 32334 1 59549
3 i 49 48 25 097595 159549
B 1 49 25 48 0 97595 1 59549
6 ' 49 39 25 0.97595 1 59549
3 5 49 25 2E 0 97595 1 59549
9 i 49 2E 28 0 97595 1 59549
S i 49 25 48 097595 1 59549
8 19 49 39 25 0 97595 1 59549
8 9 49 25 39 09'S95 '59549
8 9 49 25 28 0 97595 1 59549
8 9 49 25 26 0 97595 1 59549
8 9 49 25 36 097595 159549
e 9 49 25 :e o 97595 1 59549
8 19 49 25 28 097595 159549
a 19 49 26 46 097595 159549
a 19 2B 48 38 097595 300000
B 19 28 48 42 097595 300000
B 19 48 38 50 0 97595 3 90425
B 19 28 24 48 0 97595 3 00000
B 19 28 27 48 0 97595 3 00000
8 19 28 27 46 097595 300000
8 '9 49 25 39 097595 159549
8 19 49 25 36 0 97595 1 59549
B 19 49 25 38 097595 159549
8 19 28 27 24 0 97595 3 00000
8 19 49 25 28 0 97595 1 59549
8 i9 49 25 39 097595 1 59549
19 49 39 25 097595 159549
19 49 25 39 097S95 159549
1 39 28 27 0 97595 i 70000
i 28 27 24 097595 240691
1 38 27 48 097595 300000
1 49 39 25 1 32334 1 59549
1 49 39 25 1 32334 1 59549
1 49 39 46 1 32334 1 59549
i 49 2B 46 097595 1 59549
t 28 25 27 097595 8 40891
( « 28 27 097595 159549
1 49 39 25 i 32334 1 S9549
i 49 25 48 ) 32334 1 59549
1 26 48 36 1 32334 3 00000
i 49 25 48 i 32334 1 595*9
1 49 25 48 i 32334 1 50549
t 49 25 4B i 32334 1 69549
i 49 25 48 1 32334 1 59549
19 40 25 46 1 32334 1 59549
IB 49 33 25 1 32334 1 99549
19 49 33 25 1 32334 i S9549
19 25 48 36 1 32334 3 00000
COLUMN KEY
A CHEMICAL ID
B STATE ID
C HO Of RESIDENT FAMILIES
0 FINAL ACUTE VALUE (FAV)
431555 12512128
6 99973 207 95767
4 1555 125.12126
4 1555 125 12128
4 1555 13512128
5 2128 16699973
7 5767 431 49868
6 99973 207 95767
7 3767 431 49866
4 1555 125 12126
4 1555 12512128
4, 1555 125 12128
5 2128 207.95767
4 1555 16699973
S 2138 20795767
4 1555 12512128
4 1555 12512128
4 1555 20795767
4 1555 12512126
4 1555 12512128
4 1555 135 12128
4 1555 125 12128
4 1555 125 1212B
.02043 125 12128
431555 20795767
70000 2.23432
35604 3 00000
00000 3 00557
70000 2 23432
66407 3.00000
66407 3 00000 ^
66407 300557
70000 2 33432
66407 1 70000
66407 t 00000
66407 3 00000
66407 300000
66407 3 00000
66407 3 00000
3 00000 3 57033
4 10227 B 15109
326381 1706779
7 83989 9 99999
00000 4 10227
3,23356 4 10227
323356 4 10227
66407 1 70000
3 23432 3 00000
66407 300000
3 23356 4 00000
2 23432 3 00000
664Q7 i 70000
70000 2 33432
66407 ' 70000
240891 323356
3 23356 4 00000
323356 4 10227
1 70000 3 00000
170000 300000
i 70000 3 28203
2 40891 3 90425
3 00000 3 33356
240891 323356
1 70000 3 00000
3 00000 3 28203
3 09646 4 67783
300000 410327
3 00000 3 28203
300000 309646
3 00000 3 28303
3 00000 3 26203
1 90000 300000
1 90000 300000
3 38203 6 92063
f FOUR MO
G FAMILY ME
ELOHIN
B C D
0 12 365922 000
1 5 077913 0 0
3 6 1 09757 0 0
4 6 094178 00
5 B 094178 00
6 B 0.94178 0 0
7 7 2 15928 0 0
6 7 1 27306 0 0
9 6 076375 0 0
10 6 076375 0 0
11 6 207374 0 0
13 6 076375 0 0
16 4 050124 1 0
17 4 020962 0 0
18 5 067505 0 0
20 5 0.90409 0 0
21 6 1.01111 0 0
22 7 3111% 00
23 5 059409 0 0
24 5 222945 1 0
25 6 267050 0 0
26 7 223992 0 0
28 5 166336 1 0
29 5 1 66336 0
30 6 241439 10
31 5 513848 0 0
32 5 029670 0 0
33 6 0 97979 0 0
34 4 024227 0 0
35 4 067890 i 0
36 7 1 12210 0 0
37 6 2 13254 1 0
38 8 2.76136 0 0
39 8 1 26453 0 0
40 6 1 26453 0 0
47 8 1 49214 0 0
48 6 308791 0 0
NDOSULFAN
0 9 041506 0
i 4 008528 1
2 6 029728 0
3 6 029728 0
4 6 029728 0
5 6 029728 0
6 6 039728 0
7 6 029728 0
6 6 029726 0
9 5 0293U
10 5 029314
11 6 029728
12 6 029728
13 5 029314
14 4 0.03772
15 4 003772
16 3 0.00000
17 5 027343
18 5 027343
1950 27343
20 5 0 27343
21 6 0.29728
22 6 0.39728
23 6 0.29728
24 3 000000
25 6 0 29728
26 6 0 29728
27 8 0.29728
28 5 0 70214
29 4 007248
30 4 0 07248
31 3 000000
E F
000
3000
OOOO
OOOO
oooo
oooo
oooo
oooo
oooo
oooo
oooo
0056
0056
0006
0006
0006
0006
OOOO
0006
0006
0006
0006
0006
0006
0006
0006
0006
OOOO
0056
0006
0006
0006
OOOO
OOOO
OOOO
OOOO
oooo
E
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 5
0 5
0 5
0 5
0 5
0 S
0 5
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 5
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 5
0 5
0 5
SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILIES
AN ACUTE VALUE FOR FOUR MOST SENSITIVE SPEC
8 29 36 40 19
8 38 29 46 40
8 38 29 48 40
8 38 29 46 40
8 36 29 48 40
B 36 £9 46 40
8 38 29 48 27
8 38 29 48 27
B 38 29 48 40
6 38 29 48 40
8 38 29 48 40
3 38 29 48 40
8 38 39 46 40
8 38 29 48 40
8 45 48 40 19
6 36 48 40 19
8 38 24 46 40
8 36 48 27 40
B 36 46 27 40
8 36 48 27 40
8 38 29 48 27
8 38 46 40 19
8 24 48 27 40
3 38 48 27 40
8 24 38 48 27
8 38 48 40 19
8 48 27 40 19
8 48 27 40 19
8 24 48 27 40
8 38 48 27 40
8 38 48 40 19
8 38 48 33 40
8 38 48 40 19
8 48 40 19 26
8 38 48 27 40
8 45 48 27 40
0 38 29 43 33
0 38 29 48 33
0 38 29 48 33
0 38 29 48 33
0 38 29 48 33
0 38 29 48 33
0 38 45 29 46
0 38 29 48 33
0 38 29 48 33
0 38 45 29 46
0 45 38 29 46
0 38 40 32 41
8 40 41 25 3i
6 38 40 41 48
8 38 40 41 46
8 38 40 41 48
8 36 40 41 48
8 38 40 41 48
36 40 41 48
36 40 41 48
38 41 48 25
38 41 48 25
38 40 41 48
38 40 41 46
38 41 48 25
38 41 48 31
36 41 48 31
45 48 31 0
38 40 41 48
38 40 41 46
8 38 40 41 46
8 36 40 41 48
8 38 40 41 48
6 36 40 41 48
8 38 40 41 48
8 40 48 31 0
8 36 40 41 48
6 36 40 41 48
6 38 40 41 48
8 40 41 48 25
8 40 41 46 31
B 40 41 46 31
8 40 48 31 0
1ED)
IES
450275
799999
2 45947
245947
2,45947
2 45947
245947
3.87334
2 45947
2.45947
2 45947
515386
2 45947
245947
2 45947
2 45947
450275
2 45947
2.45947
245947
2 45947
2 45947
545169
545169
500000
545169
500000
3.87334
10.81056
10.81058
500000
1079999
2.4594
24594
2.4594
10-81056
24594
45027
5)5386
2 45947
2 45947
2 45947
387334
2.45947
2 45947
545169
545169
245947
4.50275
0.66433
127884
0.66433
066433
066433
066433
066433
066433
066433
0.66433
0.66433
066433
066433
066433
066433
066433
370000
0.66433
0.66433
0.66433
066433
0,66433
066433
0.66433
1 27864
066433
066433
066433
127684
1 27864
127884
1.27884.
500000
1079999
799999
799999
799999
7.99999
799999
799999
799999
799999
799999
799999
799999
799999
799999
799999
14 45951
1081056
500000
10.81058
10.8 105B
10.81058
799999
10.81058
1081058
10.81058
545169
1081058
1999997
19.99997
10.81058
1081058
1081058
1081058
1081058
30 10193
1081058
1081058
7.99999
799999
7,99999
450275
7^99999
450275
5 45169
G
1 27884
3.24037
127884
1 27884
1.27884
1.27884
1.27884
1.27884
1.27884
324037
3 24037
1 27884
1 27864
324037
324037
3.24037
381051
1.27684
127864
127384
1,27884
127684
1 278B4
1278B4
361051
127884
1 27684
1 27864
324037
324037
324037
3.81051
5 45169
22.10068
14 45951
144595!
14 45951
14 45951
14 45951
1031056
1081058
1081058
1081058
1081058
1081058
'081058
10.81058
1081058
4099995
30.10193
1081058
19.99997
19.99997
19.99997
10.81058
30 10193
19 99997
19 99997
10.61058
30 10193
30 10193
30 10193
1999997
1999997
30 10193
2399997
30 10193
19074548
19-99997
1999997
1081058
1081058
10-61058
10 81058
10-81058
1081058
799999
1061058
10.81058
799999
799999
230000
579999
3.24D37
3 24037
3 24037
324037
3.24037
324Q37
3.24037
3.81051
381051
3.24037
3.24037
381051
381051
3.81051
87.65022
324037
3.24037
3.24037
3.24037
324037
3 24037
3.24037
8765022
3 24037
3.24037
3 34037
3,81051
381051
381051
8765022
7.99999
231.05228
22 10068
22 10068
30 10193
3010193
30 10193
1999997
19.99997
40.99995
4099995
30 10193
30.10193
40.99995
40 99995
4099995
231 05228
231.05228
3010193
3010193
30 10193
30 10193
1999997
231 05228
30 10193
30 10193
19.99997
231 05228
231 05228
231.05228
30 10193
30 10193
19074548
30.10193
19074548
73999854
30 10193
30 10193
2399997
2399997
23.99997
2399997
2399997
23.99997
1081058
23.99997
23.99997
1081058
10.81058
3.24037
87.65022
3.81051
381051
361051
3 81051
381051
381051
381051
600000
6.00000
381051
361051
600000
8765022
6765022
000000
381051
381051
361051
3.81051
381051
361051
3,81051
0.00000
3,81051
381051
381051
600000
87,65022
87.65022
000000
-------
APPENDIX E
RECALCULATION RESULTS
9144 000000
8816 000000
0698 003000
3782 003000
2Qdg 000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000050
000050
000050
000000
000000
000000
000000
100000
000000
000006
100000
100000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
000000
00006
e o o o c 6
000006
H
B 35 40 41 48 066433 27884
B 38 40 i 4@ 066433 27884
8 38 40 1 48 066433 27884
8 40 41 8 3i i 27884 24037
8 38 JO B 25 066433 27884
& 40 45 8 31 i 27884 70000
0 38 40 2 4i 066433 27384
0 33 40 24i 086433 27884
0 38 40 2 41 066433 27884
0 38 40 2 4i 066433 27884
0 38 40 2 48 066433 27384
0 38 40 2 ^1 066433 27884
0 38 40 2 45 066433 27884
0 38 32 8 25 0 66433 30000
8 38 48 5 31 086433 81051
B 38 45 48 25 0 66433 70000
3 38 40 45 43 066433 27884
F G
3~ 46 38 33 32 044000 046827
3 46 38 40 31 04dOOO 045772
3 38 40 48 31 0 55563 0 56177
3 38 40 48 31 055563 056177
3 46 38 48 4Q 0 44000 0 55563
3 46 38 48 40 0 44000 0 55563
3 46 38 48 40 044000 055563
3 46 38 40 45 044000 068710
3 46 38 48 40 0 44000 0 55563
3 46 38 45 48 0 44000 0 55563
D 46 38 45 48 0 44000 0 69443
0 46 38 40 45 044000 052595
0 38 40 48 31 055563 073211
0 38 45 48 31 0 55563 0 75000
0 38 45 B 31 0 55563 0 75000
i 36 45 8 3i 0 55563 0 75000
1 38 40 8 31 055563 073211
B 38 40 5 4B 069443 073211
0 33 40 5 48 069443 073211
8 33 40 45 4fl 0 69443 0 7321 1
8 38 40 45 48 055563 073211
0 3B 40 45 48 0.62528 0 73211
8 36 40 48 31 0 70057 0 73211
0 40 45 8 27 0 7321 1 0.75000
8 38 40 B 27 062528 073211
0 38 40 5 48 070057 073211
B 38 40 5 48 068710 073211
6 40 45 8 27 073211 075000
0 40 45 8 27 073211 075000
0 40 45 8 27 073211 075000
8 38 40 5 48 047125 073211
3 38 40 8 25 069443 073211
8 33 38 0 43 0 49315 0 69443
24037
24037
24037
81051 8
81051
81051 8
30000
30000
30000
30000
30000
30000
30000
381051
379999 8
81051
70000
56177
01097
01097
01097
01097
01097
73211
01097
75000
375000
373211
01097
01097
01097
01097
01097
075000
075000
075000
075000
075000
.01097
01097
01097
075000
075000
1 01097
1 01097
1 01097
075000
101097
81051
81051
81051
65022
79999
65022
24037
24037
24037
24037
81051
24037
70000
79999
65022
79999
81051
80000
80000
80000
08615
08615
08615
75000
08615
01097
01097
75000
80000
80000
BOOOO
60000
10000
80000
01097
01097
01097
01097
01097
BOOOO
26491
26491
01097
01097
26491
26491
26491
01097
87367
073211 01097
8 38 40 4B 31 055563 073211 101097 BWKW
8 40 45 48 31 073211 075000 101097 30000
8 38 40 45 48 0 69443 0 7321 1 0 75000 01097
8 45 48 40 27 094868 1 01097 1 08615 26491
0 38 33 32 48 038261 049315 064675 01097
0 38 33 32 43 0 35693 0 4931 0 64675 01097
0 36 33 32 48 0 31982 0 4931 0 64675 01097
0 38 33 32 45 0 35693 0 4931 0 64675 75000
0 33 33 32 45 046753 04931 064675 75000
0 38 33 32 48 035693 04931 064675 01097
0 38 33 32 45 0 35893 0 4931 0 64675 94868
0 46 38 33 32 0 44000 0 4682 0 49315 77460
0 33 46 38 32 0 32000 0 44000 0 46327 54000
0 33 38 32 45 032000 035693 054000 94868
0 46 38 33 45 0 44000 0 46827 0 4931 5 94868
8 32 27 33 26 0 99499 1 80X0 S 80000 79999
B 25 19 36 4Q 2899997 5074823 8189980 10069736
B 38 48 25 19 1305761 2599997 2899997 5 74823
8 38 48 25 19 13 05761 25 99997 37 04762 50 74823
8 38 48 25 19 1305761 3599997 4732856 5074823
8 38 48 25 19 13 05761 25 99997 47 32856 SO 74823
9 38 48 25 19 13 05761 25 99997 47 32656 50 74623
8 27 38 48 25 180000 1770260 2477092 3 04762
6 27 38 48 25 180000 1305761 2477092 4 32856
8 38 46 25 19 13 05761 25 99997 4? 32856 50 74823
o 38 48 25 19 13 05761 25 99997 47 32356 50 74823
8 48 38 25 19 2599997 3270192 4732356 5074823
EPTACHLOR (Continued)
B C D E F 0
16
1-8
20
22
23
24
26
27
23
29
30
32
33
W
35
37
38
39
40
46
48
AD
-
19
22
23
24
25
26
27
30
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
689214
689214
171463
1 71463
574669
284961
2 76726
048503
048503
0.57862
066180
16.21363
0 23523
0.66180
062179
1074730
049096
040407
0.40407
041561
1,21034
288044
1 57560
078657
046836
0 20217
024958
024958
025542
023482
024958
023467
022455
027147
0.32023
139690
D
007458
0.00000
21 49&40
21 49640
29 93795
29 93795
2993795
0 10871
29 93795
28 14089
72.98985
29 93795
29.93795
28 14089
28 14089
23 14089
31091022
2993795
011728
011728
7476483
29 93795
010871
7476483
0.07015
0.10371
0 1 1 728
29.93795
0.07015
0.00000
0.07015
0.00000
0.65039
065039
0.57456
000000
0 11728
227 15302
057456
057456
0.65039
057456
0.57456
057456
44 6 071724
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
o
o
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
3
o
o
0
0
0
o
o
0
0
0
o
o
0
0
0
0
0
o
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
o
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
E
0 0
0 0
•
8 38 48 25 19 1
8 38 48 25 19 1
8 38 43 19 40 1
8 38 48 19 40 1
8 48 19 45 40 2
3 38 48 19 40 1
3 38 48 19 40 1
3 27 38 48 19
3 27 38 48 19
3 27 38 48 25
3 27 48 38 25
8 48 38 25 19 2
3 27 48 19 40
3 27 48 38 25
8 27 48 38 25
8 38 48 25 19 1
8 27 48 25 19
8 27 26 48 19
8 27 28 48 19
8 27 46 19 38
8 38 4B 19 40 1
8 26 48 19 40
8 7 28 38 48
8 7 28 48 19
B 2 33 48 25
8 2 33 38 48
3 2 33 38 48
8 2 33 38 48
S 2 33 38 48
8 2 33 38 48
3 2 33 33 48
8 2 33 48 25
8 32 43 25 38
B 32 38 48 25
8 33 48 25 38
p
3 0 8 25 19 38 40
508 38 40 70 4
.05761 24 77092 47 32856 50 74623
05761 24 77092 47 32B56 50 74823
OS761 24,77092 50 74623 319 99933
.05761 24 77092 50 74823 319 99933
77092 50 74823 147,99966 319 99933
.05761 25 99997 50 74823 179 50731
OS761 24 77092 50 74823 179 50781
80000 13,05761 24.77092 50 74823
.80000 13 05761 24 77092 50 74823
80000 13 05761 24 77092 47 32856
.BOOOO 25.99997 2949752 37,04762
77092 29.49752 47,32856 5074823
,90000 24.77092 50.74823 179.50781
.80000 25.99997 29,49752 37.04762
.80000 24 77092 29,49752 47 32656
.70260 25.99997 37.04762 50.74823
.30000 25.99997 47.32856 50,74823
.80000 779999 2477092 5074823
.80000 7.79999 2477092 50,74823
.80000 24 77092 50,74823 81.89980
05761 25.99997 28 99997 58.56595
.05761 25^99997 58.56595 179!s0781
.79999 25.99997 50 74823 1 79 50781
80000 7 79999 13 05761 24.77092
80000 779999 2477092 5074823
99499 2,80000 25.99997 28.99997
99499 2 80000 13 05761 25 99997
,99499 2 80000 13 05761 25 99997
99499 2,80000 13,05761 24 77092
99499 2 80000 1 7 70260 25 99997
.99499 2 80000 13 05761 25 99997
99499 2,80000 13,05761 25.99997
10000 2 80000 25.99997 28 99997
.90000 25 99997 28 99997 29 49752
90000 13 05761 25 99997 28.99997
80000 25 99997 23.99997 29 49752
G
16107 4.01937 80.06241 353 79193
.52946 157.991 12 603.84546 0.00000
j 0 8 33 40 48 7 60.0524 157.991 12 455.01465 803.84546
BOB 38 40 48 7 60.0624 157.99112 455.01465 B03.B4546
306 38 40 48 7 80,0624 35879193 455.01465 803,64546
306 38 40 48 7 60.0624 356.79193 455,01465 603,64546
i 0 6 38 40 48 7 60,062* 358.79193 455.01465 603.64546
08 25 38 40 48 1.1610 80.06241 358.79193 455.01465
08 38 40 48 7 80 0624 356 79193 455 01465 803.84546
08 38 48 7 40 60.0624 455.01465 603.64546 614,80310
08 38 48 7 40 158 1563 455.01465 603.64546 814 80310
308 38 40 48 7 60,0624 358.79193 455 01465 B03.8454B
08 36 40 48 7 800624 35879193 455.01465 603.84546
i 0 8 38 46 7 40 800624 455,01465 803,64546 61 .80310
08 38 46 7 40 80.0624 455,01465 803,84546 81 .80310
BOB 38 48 7 40 80,0624 455.01465 30384546 81 80310
B 0 8 48 45 7 40 45501465 532 85571 303.84546 81 .60310
BOB 38 40 48 7 80,06241 358,79193 455,01465 80 84546
B 0 6 25 38 40 48 1 16107 158.15637 35879193 455.01465
508 25 38 40 48 1.16107 158 15637 358 79193 455.01465
BOB 38 40 48 7 158,15637 358.79193 455,01465 803.84546
B 0 8 33 40 48 7 80 06241 356 79193 455 01465 803.84546
BOB 25 38 40 48 1 16107 8006241 353.79193 455.01465
BOB 38 40 48 7 158.15637 358.79193 455,01465 303 84546
503 25 40 48 7 1 16107 35879193 45501465 303.84546
BOB 25 38 40 48 1 16107 8006241 358,79193 45501465
B 0 8 25 38 40 48 1.16107 158.15637 35879193 455.01465
BOS 38 40 48 7 30 06241 356 79193 455.01465 303.B4546
B 0 a 25 40 48 7 1 16107 358.79193 455.01465 803.84546
508 40 48 7 0 358.79193 455.01465 803.84546 0.00000
SOS 25 40 48 7 116107 35879193 455.01465 803.64546
BOB 40 48 7 0 358.79193 455.01465 803.64546 0,00000
BOB 19 38 40 48 4.01937 158.15637 353,79193 455.01465
B 0 3 19 38 40 48 4.01987 158.15637 358.79193 455.01465
BOS 19 38 40 48 4.01987 8006241 35879193 455.01435
SOS 40 48 7 0 358.79193 455.01465 603,84546 0.00000
BOB 25 38 40 48 1 16107 158 15637 35879193 455.01465
SOS 40 48 45 7 356 79193 455.01465 532.B5571 603.64546
08 19 36 40 48 4 01987 80.06241 358 79193 455 01465
08 19 38 40 48 4.01987 8006241 358.79193 455.01465
08 19 36 40 48 4.01987 156.15637 35879193 45501465
08 19 38 40 48 4 01937 30 06241 356 79193 455,01465
506 19 36 40 48 4,01987 80,06241 358.79193 455.01465
08 19 38 40 48 4.01937 8006241 35879193 455.01465
08 19 36 40 48 401987 80,06241 35879193 455,01465
COLUMN KEY
A CHEMICAL ID E EIGHT CRITERIA (A NUMBER SIGNIFIES A CRITERIA NOT SATISFIED]
-------
APPENDIX E
RECALCULATION RESULTS
MERCURY IContlnuad)
ABC. D
E F Q
'f J^ * 043848 00005608 19 38 48 7 401987 8006241 45501465 80384546
'? 46 •• C J364S 00005608 19 38 48 7 4 01987 8006241 455 01465 803 84546
'c- 4r <• : ----J 0
LIN DANE
ABC D
8 ; 6 9 ''1-f, 0
826 844095 0
8366 "54S9 0
34-4 43:: • o
3 5 63 365?-* 0
8663 65*-; 0
8 ' t •; -'iv 0
8 5 7 4 -9'S5 C
3 ? 7 4 J466;
-• '; ; ^^(i C.
; -: 5 %t$:4; :
= :: ^ -?K-;* ;
I -* ; e \--s- :
s x s j :r:e? o
s Is s C ".-:•* 0
1 t.'
5 0
E
) 0
0 0
0 D
) 0
( 5 >
! 0
^ ^
"• 0 1
: o
0 0
0 C
0 0 1
= 36 e o-sc?:e o : c
53-5 2' 3-*CC C i :
83; s ;• -49— c o c
8 j3 - 6*300 CCO
i 34 6 = ;?;•£ coo
i ;= e :s -i:j; ' o o
: j- 6 ::*:<-':3 0 O 0
: :<- 6 j**3:-*j i o o
: -i 6 •-!£•:;- 000
; •- 8 ' - Z"~* 0 C 0 !
a -;: i «•*::: c c £ <
s -:- " ??::2s 0 0 C
a w 6 *: 2j"J Q 0 0
8 *5 ft -5 «:•« 0 0 0
8 *6 " *: -='552 0 ". 0 •
a *7 9 •". 7i": o c o c
a 48 7 '7£3Sfti 0 f. 0 :
MEBCURi
ABC D
i 6 •':-•'. o
2 i ' 25855 0
3 5 i 25B5S 0
174 51 25355 0
! 7 5 5 1 25fi55 Q
17 6 5 ' 25855 0
17 7 6 c-t'c~ 0
• 7 n 5 • 2',- 'i o
'7 T2 S ' S2~i' 0
17 !3 * ' ?'g-£ o
17 14 4 '; JiWj 0
17 15 5 4 :%3~j 0
T7 16 3 ; r/7,r, 1
17 17 6 • ti?%' 0
f? '6 4 - JTi'i 0
17 2C 5 ', */^j; C
17 22 7 2*4*74 0
17 2j 5 16H17 0
B B U B 19 38 4H 4<. 401987 8006241 45501465 53285571
S 6 0 8 19 38 40 48 401987 8006241 35879193 45501465
F G
0 8 ?J 38 25 J8 999999 21 98812 22 43718 52 67122
0 : 8 J8 JO :e J" 15 88924 31 99996 47 99995 67,99983
J ? 8 36 at* :t> 4Q 14 15800 42 19788 4799995 6799983
3 T 8 IB ri 46 J« U 15800 22 43718 42 19788 67 99983
) ~ 3 :<> IE" 4o 4.- 1048808 4 15800 02 19788 5306590
0 ' 8 :t JB 4B •"' '048808 14 15800 42 19768 6799983
) ' 6 ;<> Jb 4*5 4;i 10 48808 14 15800 42 19768 67 99983
0 " S -•(• ;e Jo 4? 18 35550 22 43718 52 87122 53 06590
0 - 8 :!• 3B Jo J; 1048808 14 15800 5287122 5306590
: "8 ;? ja Jt! J? 1048608 14 15800 42 19788 4399995
: 7 8 .'B 25 JM J: 8 00389 10 43808 42 19788 43 99995
0 "8 25 36 Jb J2 10 48808 18 93304 42 19788 63 99987
0 ' S :* 36 4g 44 1046808 14 15800 5287122 67 9B983
0 - 3 :& 3f 46 4: 1048B08 14 I5800 52a7122 6399987
S ' 3 3B J6 49 40 3766935 5267122 6799983 11269353
5 ' 8 36 JP 4: 4,.i 3766935 5287122 5306590 1 1269353
5 - 8 J* 48 4U 40 1415800 4219788 5306590 948052
0 - 6 ?e 24 48 42 800389 999999 5287122 5306590
S - 8 3* 45 JZ Jr. 8 00389 52 87122 5306590 94 80521
5 - 8 38 48 2 40 3203120 5287122 5306590 9480521
) "8 25 38 8 42 1048808 u 15800 5287122 5306590
) 78 38 25 8 42 2i 98812 22 43718 42 19788 53 06590
0 ? 8 25 38 8 42 10 48808 18 45586 52 87122 53 06590
0 * 8 24 48 2 40 9 99999 52 87 1 22 53 06590 94 80521
0 ?6 38 25 8 42 21 98812 22 43718 42 19788 53 06590
) 78 24 25 30 48 9 99999 10 48808 1845586 52 87122
1 78 38 25 S 42 is 35550 22 43718 42 19788 53 06590
i ~ 8 38 25 6 42 2 00000 10 48808 42 19788 53 06590
5 7 8 38 48 2 40 2 00000 52 87122 53 06590 94 80521
0 7 3 38 2J 8 42 2 00000 9 99999 52 87122 53 06590
5 ' 6 38 48 2 40 45 27687 52 87122 53 06590 94 80521
0 7 a 38 46 5 42 32 03120 42 19788 47 99995 53 06590
0 7 B 38 48 5 42 8 00389 42 19788 47 99995 53 06590
5 78 38 48 42 49 14 15800 42 19788 53 06590 67 99983
5 78 48 42 49 4Q 42 19738 53 06590 67 99983 94 60521
0 78 38 25 48 42 3203120 4799995 5287122 5306590
E 78 48 42 49 40 5287122 5 06590 6799983 9480521
0 75 36 48 25 42 1893304 4 19766 4799995 5306590
0 78 38 48 25 42 14 15800 4 19768 47 99995 53 06590
0 78 38 48 25 42 800389 4 19788 4799995 5306590
D '8 38 25 48 42 1415800 4 99995 5 87122 5306590
D 78 38 48 25 42 1835550 4 19788 4 99995 6399987
0 78 3P 48 25 42 1415800 4 19788 4 99995 5306590
j 7 a _" 4fl 25 42 141S800 4219788 4 99995 5306590
7 h ... 4? 25 42 2198812 4219788 499995 6399987
7 •- :- ~y, 25 49 21 98812 42 19768 4799995 6799983
: 7 - •'. 4* :C 42 14 15300 42 19788 4799995 5306590
- 7 - in 4D y_, 4? 21 93812 42 19783 47 99995 53 06590
E F G
- :•-_-. -. "< Jt 28 jfi 5 00000 9 99999 31 62273 244 2593
;• & -jfc 7 999999 4999995 3999963 783 710
0 2' 2fc ^ 7 999999 4999995 4859476 783 7lO
0 25 2o 'B T 999999 4999995 4859476 783 710
0 25 28 38 7 999999 4999995 4859476 783 710
0 25 28 38 7 999999 4999995 4859476 783 710
0 25 28 38 7 999999 4999995 4859476 783 710
0 25 28 38 7 999999 4999995 4859476 783 710
0 25 28 38 7 999999 4999995 4859476 783 7iO
0 25 38 7 10 9 99999 248 59476 83 47107 999 9984
0 25 28 36 7 999999 4999995 4859478 783 710
0 25 28 3fl 7 999999 4999995 4425937 783 710
0 25 28 38 7 999999 4999995 4859476 783 710
0 25 38 7 10 9 99999 248 r^476 83 47107 999 9984
0 28 38 7 10 19 99997 248 59476 83 47107 999 9984
0 28 38 7 10 19 99997 248 59478 83 47107 999 9984
0 23 7 10 0 19 99997 783 47107 999 99841 0 00000
B C_ D E F
24 4 0 33997 2 40600 25 28 10
25 7 2 44474 02 40000 25 38 10
26 8 1 99953 02 40000 25 33 10
27 5 1 61661 02 40000 25 38 10
28 3 000000 12 40600 25 71 0
29 3 000000 12 40600 25 71 0
30 4 033997 12 4060 25 28 10
3143 32883 02 4060 28 38 1
32 5 020147 02 0060 19 25 38
33 5 0 20147 02 0060 19 25 38
34 4 0,48080 02 0560 19 38 1
35 2 000000 12 4560 7 10
36 5 069492 02 4060 25 28 38
37 3 000000 12 4080 28 7 10
38 5 0 2022 02 0060 19 25 38
39 5 02014 02 0060 19 25 38
40 5 02014 02 0060 19 25 38
4150 2014 02 00600 19 25 38
42 5 02014 02 00600 19 25 38
43 5 020147 02 00600 19 25 38
44 5 020147 02 00600 9 25 38
45 5 0.20223 02 00600 9 25 38
46 5 020223 02 00600 9 25 36
4750 20147 02 00600 9 25 36
CKEL
BCD E F
0 16 6582762
1 13 7050983
2 12 66 25783
3 12 6625733
4 12 66 25783
5 12 6625604
6 12 66 25604
7 13 70.17523
8 13 6771924
9 12 66 25783
10 12 6625604
11 12 6625783
12 13 7017523
13 12 6625783
14 11 66.24532
15 10 59.73523
16 11 6167644
17 11 62 17269
18 11 63.23666
19 11 6323666
20 11 6323666
21 12 6625783
22 13 6771924
23 12 66 74388
24 11 63 23666
25 13 6771924
26 13 6996130
27 11 62 17269
28 1) 62 17269
29 11 6315296
31 10 5800987
32 10 4702316
33 11 50 37553
34 10 46 73035
35 10 5973523
36 11 6323666
37 11 6167644
38 9 43 43307
39 9 43 43307
40 9 42 69863
41 11 5003452
42 8 4011375
43 9 43 50597
44 10 46 73035
45 8 4011375
46 9 43 50597
47 9 4331558
48 10 46 73035
0000 00 19 29 48 7
0000 00 1948735
0000 00 19 48 7 35
0000 0 19 48 7 35
0000 0 19 48 7 35
0000 0
0000 0
0000
0000
0005
0005
0005
00 0000
00 0000
00 0000
00 5000
00 0000
00 0000
00 5000
00 5000
00 0000
00 5000
00 0000
00 0000
00 0000
00 0000
0000000
0000000
0000000
9 7 35 48
9 7 35 48
9 48 7 35
9 29 48 7
9 48 7 35
9 7 (5 48
9 48 7 35
9 48 7 35
9 48 7 35
9 7 35 48
9 47 48 7
9 47 7 35
9 48 7 35
9 47 48 7
9 47 48 7
9 48 7 35
9 29 48 7
9 47 48 7
9 47 48 7
9 29 48 7
9 29 47 48
9 48 7 35
9 48 7 35
9 47 48 7
9 47 7 35
9 48 7 35
9 48 7 35
9 47 7 35
9 47 48 7
9 47 48 7
9 47 7 35
9 7 35 48
9 7 35 48
9 7 35 48
9 47 7 35
9 7 15 48
9 47 7 35
9 47 7 35
0000000 19 71548
0000000 19 47 735
0000000 19 735 45
0000000 19 47 735
0 25 28 3* 7 9 99999 49 99995 48 69476 783 4710
0 25 38 7 10 9 99999 248 59476 83 47107 999 9984
0 25 28 18 7 9 99099 19 99997 248 59476 783 4710 PCB
0 n Tfl 7 10 Q 40flafl ?4H
-------
APPENDIX E
RECALCULATION RESULTS
PC 3 (Continued)
A B C D E f G
2 -l Q04fli2 0004
16
18
20
12
24
25
26
28
29
30
32
13
34
35
36
40
42
«e
46
LENIUM
B
' TT "i
5
7
a
10
12
13
17
IB
20
21
23
2S
26
0 i '986 000
0 03963 003
003963 003
0 09*08 003
0 00000 003
000000 1 0 3
004812 000
0 28800 000
0 28800 000
0 10748 000
026179 000
0 12581 000
026179 000
1 04064 1 0 0
012581 000
027471 000
0 i 1936 000
026121 100
000000 i C 0
04064 i 0 0
000000 1 0 0
000000 000
000000 000
004812 0 0 C
000000 i 0 0
028800 0 C 0
000000 i 0 0
000000 000
000000 000
000000 000
000000 000
000000 000
000000 000
000000 003
000000 0 0 i
000000 003
000000 000
076 36 J8 40 31 200000 230000 3260120 28284204
0 8 38 4B 40 25 200000 2 300 DO 3260120 10766406
Q
o
f)
o
6
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
a 'IS, 4B 40 25 2 00000 2 300DO 32 60120 107 66406
B 36 48 40 25 2 00000 2 30000 32 60120 107 66406
8 38 48 0 25 2 00000 2 30000 32 60120 107 66406
8 36 46 0 25 200000 6 61059 32 60120 99 55351
8 38 48 0 25 2 00000 6 61059 32 60120 107 66406
6 38 48 5 31 2 00000 2 30000 107 66406 282 84204
8 38 48 5 31 2 00000 2 30000 107 66406 282 84204
8 38 48 0 25 2 00000 2 30000 32 60120 107 66406
8 38 48 0 25 2 00000 6 61059 32 60120 107 66406
B 38 '8 5 3' 2 OOOOC 6 61059 107 66406 282 84204
8 38 48 i 0 2 00000 6 61059 282 84204 0 00000
8 38 48 1 0 2 00000 6 61059 282 84204 0 00000
8 IB 0 0 0 6 61059 0 00000 0 00000 0 00000
3 38 48 40 31 2 00000 2 30000 32 60120 282 84204
8 38 48 40 25 2 00000 6 61059 32 60120 92 05394
8 36 48 40 25 200000 661059 3260120 9205394
8 38 fl8 40 31 2 00000 6 61059 32 60120 262 84204
8 38 48 ^0 25 2 00000 2 30000 32 60120 99 5535
6 38 48 40 25 2 00000 6 61059 32 60120 107 66406
8 SB 40 25 31 6 61059 32 60120 92 05394 282 84204
6 38 48 40 25 2 00000 2 30000 32 60120 99 55351
8 38 48 40 25 2 00000 6 61059 32 60120 99 55351
8 38 48 40 25 2 00000 2 30000 32 60120 107 66406
8 48 40 25 31 230000 3260120 9955351 28284204
8 48 40 3i 0 6 61059 32 60120 282 84204 0 00000
8 48 40 25 (i 6 61059 32 60120 92 05394 282 84204
8 48 40 0 0 6 61059 32 60120 0 00000 0 00000
8 38 48 40 0 2 00000 2 30000 32 60120 0 00000
8 38 48 40 0 200000 230000 3260120 000000
8 38 48 0 M 2 00000 2 30000 32 60120 282 64204
8 48 40 i 0 2 30000 32 60120 282 84204 0 00000
8 38 48 0 25 2 00000 6 61059 32 60120 92 05394
8 48 40 1 0 661059 3260120 28284204 000000
8 38 48 0 0 2 00000 2 30000 32 60 120 0 00000
B 38 48 40 0 2 00000 2 30000 32 601 20 0 00000
6 38 48 40 0 2 00000 2 30000 32 601 20 0 00000
8 38 48 40 0 200000 661059 3260120 000000
8 38 48 40 0 2 00000 2 30000 32 60120 0 00000
8 38 48 40 0 2 00000 2 30000 32 60120 0 00000
8 38 48 40 0 200000 2 30000 3260120 000000
8 38 48 0 0 2 00000 2 30000 0 00000 0 00000
8 38 48 0 0 200000 230000 000000 000000
8 38 48 0 0 2 00000 2 30000 0 00000 0 00000
8 38 48 40 0 2 00000 2 30000 32 601 20 0 00000
D E F G
93 62001 00300608 26 40 19 38 339 99908 3105 14893 3869 98926 10199 974
117 48746 00000608 2640193S 339 9990B 3105 14893 386998926 847972266
11748746 00000608 26 40 19 38 33999908 310514893 386998936 847972266
25 60231 00000608 26 19 38 40 339 99908 3869 98926 8479 72266 9002 43945
08 56085 00000608 26 19 38 40 339 99908 3869 98926 8479 72266 9002 43945
4403363 00000608 26 19 38 40 33999908 388998926 847972266 900243945
25 60231 00000608 26 19 38 40 339 99908 3869 98926 8479.72266 9002 43945
32 5292i 00000608 26 19 38 45 339 99908 3869 98926 8479 72266 12599.947
34 94461 00000608 26 19 38 45 339 9990B 3869 98926 7049 60645 12599 94
08 56085 00000608 26 19 38 40 339 99908 3869 98926 8479 72266 9002 4394
u 71645 00000608 26 19 38 45 339 99908 3869 98926 8479 72266 12599 94
i J 71645 00000606 26 19 38 45 339 99908 3869 98926 8479 72266 12599 94
13252921 00000608 2693845 33999908 386998926 847972266 1259994
135 61240 10000608 26 9 44 45 339 99908 3869 98926 6499 97852 12599 94
25 80231 00000608 26 9 38 40 339 99908 3869 98926 8479 72266 9002 4394
J8 20352 00000608 269384Q 33999908 386998926 704960645 90024394
48203S2 00000608 26 9 38 40 33999908 386998926 704960645 90024394
13 70836 10000608 26 19 40 5 339 99908 3869 98926 9002 43945 12599 94
25 6023 1 00000606 2619380 339 99908 3869 98926 8479 72266 9002 4394
4820352 OOOOOS08 26 19 38 0 33999908 386998926 704960645 900243945
63 951 1 7 00000008 25 19 38 0 339 99908 3S69 98926 8479 72266 9002 43945
j8 e 31 -19722 '0000008 26 19 40 E 339 99908 3869 98926 9002 43945 '2599 947
79 ' 13 70636 i 0 C 0 0 6 0 8 2619405 339 99908 3869 98926 9002 43945 1 2599 947
3; - 1137Q836 10000608 25 19 40 5 33999908 386998926 900243945 12599947
3 ; ' 113 70836 i 0 0 C 0 6 0 8 26 19 40 45 339 99908 3869 98926 9002 43945 12599 947
3; 7 iQ9 77351 OC000608 26193840 339 99908 1992 47412 7CM9 60645 9002 43945
13 7 109 77351 00000608 36 19 3S 40 339 99908 1992 47412 7049 60645 9002 43945
COLUMN KEY
A CHEMICAL ID E EIGHI
C NO Of RESIDENT FAMILIES G FAHl
0 FINAL ACUTE VALUE fFAV)
P.fi I __ ,
SELENIUM (Co
B
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
43
45
46
48
SILVER
A B
2rT ~o~ ~
20 i
20 2
20 3
20 4
20 5
20 7
20 8
20 9
20 10
20 11
20 12
20 13
20 14
20 15
20 16
20 17
20 18
20 19
20 20
20 21
20 22
20 23
20 24
20 25
20 26
20 27
20 28
20 29
20 30
20 31
20 32
20 33
20 34
20 35
20 36
20 37
20 39
20 40
20 41
20 42
20 44
20 45
20 46
20 47
20 48
TOXAPHENE
A B
'lO" -jj-
10 1
10 2
10 3
10 4
10 5
10 6
10 7
10 8
ntlnued)
D E F
104 86212 00000608 2693840
11370836 10000 08 26 9 JO 45
168 17023 00000 06 2693840
131 49722 10000 8 2694045
104 86212 00000 8 2693640
10486212 00000 8 26938 40
109 77351 00000 8 2693640
120 32399 00000 8 26938 40
104 86212 00000 8 2693840
10486212 00000 8 2693840
1 20 32399 00000 8 26933 40
59 20579 00000 8 2693816
59 20579 00000 8 2693816
10828229 00000 08 2693845
120 32399 00000 08 2693840
D E F
000000 1 0 3
000013 000
000013 000
000013 000
000013 000
000013 000
000082 000
000071 000
000000 003
000000 003
000071 000
000013 000
000000 003
000000 003
000005 000
000000 1 0 0
000071 000
000082 000
000082 000
000071 000
000082 000
000082 000
000071 000
OOOD04 1 0 0
000082 000
000082 000
000022 000
000042 1 0 0
000003 1 0 0
000004 1 0 0
000000 1 0 0
000030 000
000030 000
000030 000
000000 1 0 0
000029 000
000030 1 0 0
000061 0000
000061 0000
000061 0000
000061 0000
000023 0000
000053 0000
608 40 7 0 0
608 40 33 48 7
608 40 38 48 7
608 40 38 48 7
608 40 38 48 7
608 40 38 48 7
603 52 40 38 48
608 52 40 38 48
608 38 48 7 0
608 33 48 7 0
608 52 40 3S 48
60S 40 33 48 7
0 0 8 38 48 7 0
608 38 48 7 0
608 52 38 48 7
608 44 48 7 0
608 52 40 38 48
603 52 40 38 48
608 52 40 38 48
603 52 40 38 46
008 52 40 38 48
608 52 40 38 48
603 52 40 38 48
608 52 40 48 7
608 52 40 38 48
608 52 40 38 48
008 40 38 48 35
008 40 48 35 7
608 52 40 48 7
608 52 40 48 7
608 0 48 7 0
608 9 40 38 48
608 9 40 33 48
608 9 4Q 38 48
608 0 48 7 0
008 40 38 48 35
008 40 48 35 7
608 19 52 40 36
608 19 52 40 36
608 19 52 40 38
608 19 52 40 38
608 19 40 38 46
608 19 40 52 38
0,00053 00005608 19 40 52 38
0 00017 00005608 19 40 38 48
0 00023 00005608 19 40 38 48
D E F
77194 00000078 48 40 38 49
83820 00000078 48 62 38 40
82556 00000076 4838 40 49
62556 00000078 4838 40 49
63047 00000078 42483840
65941 00000078 42 48 38 40
10 9 8 08901 00000078 48 42 38 40
10 10 8 .16707 00000078 48 42 38 40
Q
339.99906 1992.47412 8479 72266 9002.43945
339.99908 3869.98926 9002.43945 12599.947
339.99908 3869 98926 7049 60645 9002.43945.
339.99908 3869,98926 9002.43945 12599947
339.99908 199247412 84 972266 900243945
339,99908 1992.47412 84 9.72266 9002.43945
33999908 199247412 70 960645 900243945
339.99908 1992.47412 84 9.72266 9002.43945
33999908 199247412 84 972266 900243945
339,99908 199247412 84 972266 900243945
339.99903 1992,47412 84 9.72266 900243945
33999908 1992.47412 84 972266 24099667
33999908 199247412 84 9.72266 24099.867
339.99908 1992.47412 34 9.72266 12599.947
339.99908 1992.47412 84 9.72266 9002.43945
G
0 00185 0 00401 0 00646 0 01232
0 01083 5 51660 0 00000 0 00000
001083 002051 0 11237 551660
001083 002051 011237 551660
001083 002051 011237 551660
001083 002051 0 11237 551660
001083 002051 0 11237 551660
0 00401 0 01083 0 02051 0 1 1237
0 00401 0 01083 0 02051 0 1 1237
002051 0 11237 551660 000000
002051 0 11237 5.51660 000000
000401 001083 002051 0 11237
0 01083 0 02051 0 1 1237 5 51660
002051 011237 551660 000000
002051 0 11237 551660 000000
0 00401 0 02051 0 1 1237 5 51660
001232 0 11237 551660 000000
000401 001083 002051 0 11237
000401 001083 0,02051 0 11237
0 00401 0 01083 0 02051 0 1 1237
0 00401 001083 0 02051 0 1 1237
0 00401 0 01083 0,02051 0 11237
0 00401 001083 0 02051 0 1 1237
0 00401 0.01083 0.02051 0 1 1237
0.00401 0.01083 0 11237 5.51660
0 00401 0 01083 0.02051 0.1 1237
0 00401 0 01083 0 02051 0 11237
0 01083 0.02051 0 1 1237 4 10596
001083 0 11237 4 10596 S 51660
0 00401 0 01083 0 1 1237 5 51660
0 00401 0 01083 0 1 1237 5.51660
001083 011237 551660 000000
000185 001083 0,02051 011237
000185 001083 002051 0 11237
0 00185 001083 0 02051 0 1 1237
0 01083 0 1 1237 5,51660 0 00000
0 01033 0 02051 0 1 1237 4 10596
001083 0 11237 4 10596 551860
0.00185 0,00401 0.00646 0.02051
0 00185 0.00401 0.00646 0 02055
0 00185 000401 0 00646 0.02051
0 00185 0 00401 0 00646 0.02051
0,00185 0 00646 0 02051 0 11237
0 00185 0 00385 0 00401 0 02051
0,00185 0 00385 0 00401 0 02051
000185 000385 002051 0 11237
0,00185 0 00646 0 02051 0.11237
G
1 30000 2 62678 3 54658 72465
200000 616529 654964 1 99999
284828 616529 667760 1 99999
284828 616529 6.67760 1 99999
284828 3.54658 667760 42884
2,84828 667760 742884 1 99999
284828 667760 742884 1 99999
354658 72465 522336 03264
354653 72465 6,67760 ,43262
2 84828 19275 6 67760 78180
2,84328 19275 525072 781OT
2 84828 00000 7 12840 8 03264
-------
APPENDIX E
RECALCULATION RESULTS
3 26540 000000 8 4B 38 40 49 4 72465
218630 000000 8 4? 48 38 40 3 00000
339942 000050 8 48 40 38 49 472465
213035 000050 8 4J 48 40 38 3.54658
19)969 100050 8 42 48 40 19 419275
162407 C 0 0 0 5 0 8 J8 42 38 40 284828
2 53038 000000 8 42 48 38 40 3 54658
2.60797 000000 8 4S 48 38 40 3 54658
231836 000000 8 4 2 je 40 38 3 54658
188511 000000 8 48. 42 36 40 2 84828
2 56776 000000 8 42 48 38 40 3 54658
181469 100000 8 43 43 40 19 3 54658
188511 000000 6 46 42 38 40 234828
264224 000000 8 4? SB 38 40 354658
181373 000000 8 48 42 38 40 2 84828
155926 000000 8 48. 38 42 40 2 84828
181022 000000 8 38 42 48 40 3 00000
188123 000000 8 38 42 48 40 3 00000
2 37493 000000 8 42484038 3.54658
161550 000000 8 48 42 40 38 2 84828
092822 000000 0 33 48 42 38 1.30000
170234 000050 8 48 42 38 40 2.84828
1 26260 10005078 48 42 40 49 2 84826
241262 00000078 4? 48 40 38 354858
211732 10000078 4J 48 40 49 354658
108697 00000070 33 32 48 42 130000
10869? 00000070 33 32 48 42 1.30000
104979 00000070 33 32 48 42 130000
098850 00000070 33 32 42 48 130000
112857 00000070 33 32 48 42 130000
108697 00000070 33 32 48 42 1 30000
1 12374 00000070 33 32 48 42 1.30000
i 10658 00000070 33 32 48 42 1 30000
169908 00000070 46 32 38 40 284828
187814 00000070 48 32 42 38 2 84828
0 89100 00000070 33 48 42 38 130000
_=_ D E F
0 12.29622 00000000 9 16 38 13 73706
17 063*6 00000000 9 16 38 2V22283
1681558 00000000 9 16 38 2122263
1690U3 00000000 9 13 38 2122283
169QH3 30000000 9 16 38 2122283
1890113 00000000 9 16 38 2122283
1690H3 00000000 9 16 38 2122283
1611268 00000000 938 16 2122283
168IQ54 COOOCOOO 9 16 38 21 22283
1659572 00000000 9 16 38 2122283
13 25433 00000000 938 IB 2122283
1704558 00000000 9 16 38 21 22283
1659572 00000000 9 18 38 2122283
1659572 OOOOOCOO 19 16 38 2122233
1590239 00005000 19 16 38 2122283
1893533 00005000 19 16 38 4 2122283
1833065 t 0 0 0 5 0 C 0 19 16 47 4 2122283
1521240 00000000 '9 16 38 2122283
1679053 00000000 19 38 16 4 21 22283
16 79033 00000000 19 38 16 4 21 22233
16790*3 00000000 19 33 16 4 2122283
5590239 00000000 19 16 38 21 22283
578279 00000000 19 18 38 2122283
965713 00000000 19 18 '6 4 21 22283
536884 10000000 19 16 47 2122283
5 78276 OOCOOOOO 19 18 38 2122283
4 88030 00000000 19 38 16 2122283
998341 10000000 19 16 74 2122283
1536884 10000000 19 16 47 2122283
91B5C1 iQCOOOOO 19 18 74 21 22263
1627094 00005000 19 16 47 38 2122283
629230 00000000 19 38 16 1373706
879703 00000000 19 38 16 1373706
11 S98?4 00005000 1916384 373706
1457182 10005000 19 16 47 2122283
1679053 00000000 19 38 16 4 2122283
1536884 10005000 19 16 47 2122283
935442 00000000 19 16 38 1373708
929473 00000000 19 16 38 1373706
8 93250 00000000 19 38 16 13 73706
1206944 00000000 1« 18 47 38 1373706
5 '0465 00000000 19 38 7 40 13 73706
9 559" 00000000 1947307 13 73706
6 67760
472465
812906
4 72465
472485
354658
4 72465
4 72465
4 72465
4 72465
3.54668
472465
4 72465
3 54653
4.72485
3 54658
3 00000
3 54858
3 54658
472465
3 54658
284823
3 54653
3.54658
472485
472465
2 62076
262678
2 82878
262678
2 62678
2 62878
262678
230000
300000
3 00000
2,84828
Q_
41 96642
41 96642
41 96642
4196642
4196642
4196642
4196642
4127646
4196642
41.96642
2624273
4196642
41 96642
4196642
4196642
4196642
4196642
4196642
2624273
26 24273
26.24273
41 96642
4196642
3669375
4196642
4196642
36 69875
3687158
41 96642
4196642
4198642
41 96642
2624273
26 24273
4196642
41 98842
2624373
4198642
4196642
4196642
38 87227
4196642
41 21796
49 26382
3 03284
667760
996253
812906
676180
667760
525072
5 25072
a 03264
667760
578072
4 94449
8 03264
S 78072
4 94449
5 22336
3.54658
4 72465
4 72465
803264
6 03264
354658
6 67760
803264
8 03264
8 43282
284828
2.84828
284828
354658
2.34828
2 34828
2.84828
234828
573072
354658
3.54658
43,36124
7301714
5006339
51 84550
51 84550
51 84550
51 84550
41 96842
49 96935
4655005
41 96642
5608541
4655005
4655005
4655005
4655005
4926332
4855005
41 96642
4196642
4196642
4655005
44 94655
4196642
4926382
44 94655
41 96642
4196642
92 75665
4926382
9275665
4926382
4196642
4196642
4655005
4926332
41 96642
49 26382
66 45534
4996935
4196642
4926382
92 75865
49 96935
812906
11 99999
996253
1437916
8 03264
603264
S 03264
919002
6 03264
8 03264
303264
1437916
8 03264
8 03364
803264
8 03264
803264
803264
867179
919002
11 99999
354656
3.54656
354658
472465
300000
354658
354658
300000
721011
667760
578072
9275665
92.75665
92.75665
9275665
9275665
9275665
9275665
9275665
92.75665
9275665
92.75665
92.75665
9275665
9275665
9275665
4926382
6436714
92.75665
4926382
4926382
4926382
9275665
9275665
4926382
9275665
9275665
49 26382
9275665
266.56775
9275665
266 56775
81 41595
92 75665
9275665
4926382
9275685
49 26382
9275665
92 75665
9275665
9275665
49 96935
270 65472
9275665
19 47 38
19 38 7
19 38 47
13.73706
1373706
13 73706
13 73706
13 73706
49 26382 49.96935
47 2Z923 92 75665
47 22923 49 26382
49 96935 92.75665
47 32923 49.26332
9275665
315.02075
92.75665
251 46085
9275665
COLUMN KEY
A CHEMICAL 10
8 STATE ID
C NO Of RESIDENT FAMILIES
D PlNAL ACUTE VALUE (FAV)
E EIGHT CRITERIA (A NUMBER SIGNIFIES A CRITERIA NO1 CATISFIED1
F FOUR MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILIES
G FAMILY MEAN ACUTE VALUE FOR FOUR MOST SENSITIVE SPECIES
------- |