U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
OFFICE OF WATER REGULATIONS AND STANDARDS
WASHINGTON DC 20460
RECALCULATION
OF STATE
TOXIC CRITERIA
October 1982
CAMP DRESSER & McKEE, INC
ANNANDALE, VA 22003
-------
RECALCULATION
OF STATE
TOXIC CRITERIA
Prepared For:
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
Office of Water Regulations and Standards
Criteria and Standards Division
401 M Street, SW
Washington DC 20460
By:
Ming P. Wu
Sue A. Hanson-Walton
Larry A. Roesner
Camp Dresser & McKee
7630 Little River Turnpike
Annandale VA 22003
Contract No. 68-01-6403
October 1982
-------
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The material in this report was prepared under the direction of the Criteria and Standards Divi-
sion, Office of Water, of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The authors wish to thank the
professional staff of the Criteria and Standards Division—in particular Patrick Tobin, Acting Divi-
sion Director; Alan Rubin; Frank Gostomski; and Michael Ruggiero—for the suggestions and
assistance they have offered which are reflected throughout. We would also like to acknowledge the
interest and assistance of several people at the EPA Environmental Research Laboratory,
Duluth—Norbert Jaworski, Director; Rosemarie Russo, Deputy Director; Charles Stephan; Ron
Carlson; and Stephen Lozano—in answering our questions on the site-specific protocol and related
computer program which were developed at the Laboratory.
-------
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Mi
SUMMARY vii
SECTION 1. INTRODUCTION 1-1
1.1 BACKGROUND 1-1
1.2 ORGANIZATION 1-1
SECTION 2. APPROACH 2-1
2.1 THE TWO-NUMBER CRITERION 2-1
2.2 RECALCULATION OF SITE-SPECIFIC CRITERIA 2-2
2.3 SPECIES DISTRIBUTION 2-4
2.4 CALCULATION OF MAXIMUM VALUE CRITERIA BY STATE 2-9
2.5 CALCULATION OF THE STATE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERION 2-12
2.6 SAMPLE CALCULATION 2-13
SECTION 3. RESULTS 3-1
3.1 SPECIES DISTRIBUTION BY STATE 3-1
3.2 STATE WATER QUALITY CRITERIA 3-2
SECTION 4. DISCUSSION 4-1
REFERENCES R-1
APPENDICES
A. Resident North American Species of Aquatic Animals Used in Toxicity Tests A-1
B-1. State ID Numbers B-1
B-2. Family ID Numbers B-1
B-3. Species ID Numbers and Family Classification B-2
B-4. Resident Species, by State B-3
B-5. Species Distribution in the United States B-6
B-6. Minimum Data Requirements B-9
C. Toxicity Data for Freshwater Aquatic Life Criteria, by Chemical C-1
D. Toxicity Data for Freshwater Aquatic Life Criteria, by State D-1
E. Recalculation Results E-1
-------
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure Page
1.1 Protocols Proposed by EPA for Site-Specific Criteria Modification 1-2
3.1 Distribution of Daphnia magna in the United States 3-3
LIST OF TABLES
Table Page
2.1 National 30-Day Average Criteria 2-3
2.2 List of Species Names in the Acute Toxicity Data Base 2-5
2.3 List of References Used for Identifying the Geographical Distribution
of the Invertebrate Species 2-8
2.4 National Acute Toxicity Data for Chlordane 2-14
2.5 Resident Species List for Pennsylvania 2-14
2.6 Pennsylvania Resident Species Toxicity Data for Chlordane 2-15
2.7 Pennsylvania Family Acute Toxicity Table for Chlordane 2-15
2.8 National Acute Toxicity Data for Nickel 2-18
2.9 Pennsylvania Resident Species Toxicity Data for Nickel 2-19
2.10 Pennsylvania Resident Family Toxicity Data for Nickel 2-19
2.11 National Chronic Toxicity Data for N ickel 2-21
3.1 Minimum Data Requirements Which Are Not Met by the National Toxicity Data Base 3-4
3.2 Values of v and z in the Maximum Value Criteria Equation, by State 3-8
4.1 Comparison of National and State Maximum Value Criteria 4-2
4.2 Comparison of National and State 30-Day Average Criteria 4-3
-------
SUMMARY
jln an effort to assist the states in adapting the National water quality criteria to local conditions,
EPA nas proposed a series of protocols for consideration. One of the protocols, referred to as the
State Resident Species Recalculation, modifies the National water quality criteria to reflect the state
resident species compositioiQwith the protocol, state water quality criteria may be calculated without
the need for additional toxicity testing. -p/
^fhe state Resident Species Recalculation Protoeol is implemented in this report. Tke-report in-
cludes: a survey of the published literature on the geographical distributions in the United Sta4e»of 95
freshwater species in the national data base; and a recalculation of state water quality criteria for 21
toxic chemicals whose national water quality criteria have been published by EPATj
. Only five percent of the 21 chemicals have met the minimum data requirements on the national
level. The state data base is used to recalculate the maximum water quality criteria even when all of
the data requirements are not satisfied. Sixty-five percent of these have state criteria which are more
stringent than the national criteria. The recalculated instantaneous maximum criteria have been ob-
tained by extrapolation for all cases but two (copper criteria for Maine and New York). The validity of
the state water quality criteria is largely dependent on the correct representation of the sensitivity of
the state resident population by the resident species data base.^i/ithin the framework of the current
guidelines and the resident species recalculation method, the results of this study may always be
modified with additional toxicity data!?
vll
-------
SECTION 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 BACKGROUND
In the Federal Register of 28 November 1980, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) an-
nounced the availability of criteria documents for 64 of the 65 pollutants designated as toxic under
Section 308 (a) (1) of the Clean Water Act. Water quality criteria for 25 of these 65 designated
pollutants were first published in "Quality Criteria for Water" (U.S. EPA, July, 1976), the "Red Book." In
a continuing effort, EPA has revised and expanded the original water quality criteria for the designated
toxic pollutants (43FR21506,18 May 1978; 43FR19028, 5 July 1978; 44FR15926,15 March 1979), leading
to the availability of the criteria documents announced in 1980.
Numerical national water quality criteria have been derived by EPA for 21 of the 65 chemicals ac-
cording to guidelines also published in the Federal Register of 28 November 1980 (45FR79316). These
national criteria are based upon standard toxicity tests performed in the laboratory with a variety of
aquatic species whose combination meets the minimum data requirement (to be discussed in Section
2.1.1).
A subsequent modification to the guidelines published in the Federal Register includes: use of
family rather than species as the biological unit upon which the Final Acute Value (FAV) and the Final
Chronic Value (FCV) are based; a change in the minimum data requirement; and a change in the
method of regression analysis used for calculating the FAV and FCV. The remaining sections of this
report, and the Appendices, are based on this revised methodology.
In recognition of the fact that local environmental conditions may affect the toxicity of a pollu-
tant, EPA intends to give flexibility to the states in the application of the published national water
quality criteria by giving them the option of modifying the criteria through a site-specific analysis. In
the context of this report, the term "site-specific" will be used synonymously with the term "state-
specific."
In an effort to assist the states in adapting the national criteria to local conditions, EPA has
developed a series of protocols (Figure 1.1) whereby the laboratory-based water quality criteria may be
modified by taking local variation in species composition and water chemistry into account. The first
protocol, which is designed to take resident species composition into account, is the subject of this
report. This protocol will henceforth be referred to as the recalculation procedure. The remainder of
this report is based on:
• a survey of the literature on the geographical distribution in the United States of selected freshwater
fish and invertebrates, and
• a recalculation, based on the aquatic species resident in a given state, of the state water quality
criteria for the 21 chemicals whose national water quality criteria have been published.
1.2 ORGANIZATION
The methodology used in this report is outlined in Section 2. The results are presented in Section
3 and in the Appendices. A discussion of the results will be found in Section 4.
1-1
-------
RESIDENT SPECIES EFFECTS
RECALCULATE CRITERIA
USING RESIDENT SPECIES
DATA FROM LITERATURE
NATIONAL
WATER QUALITY
CRITERIA
SITE WATER CHEMISTRY EFFECTS
TEST INDICATOR SPECIES
IN "CLEAN" LABORATORY
AND IN SITE WATER;
MODIFY NATIONAL CRITERIA
RESIDENT SPECIES AND
SITE WATER CHEMISTRY EFFECTS
TEST RESIDENT SPECIES
IN SITE WATER;
CALCULATE NEW CRITERIA
SITE-SPECIFIC
WATER QUALITY
CRITERIA
Figure 1.1 Protocols Proposed by EPA for Site-Specific Criteria Modification
1-2
-------
SECTION 2
APPROACH
2.1 THE TWO-NUMBER CRITERION
The national criteria for the protection of freshwater aquatic life specify both maximum and
30-day average values (the two-number criterion). The cumulative duration of excursions above the
specified 30-day average value is limited to 96 hours in any 30 consecutive days. This two-number,
three-part format of numerical water quality criteria is intended to provide adequate protection for
aquatic life and its uses for both long-term, nearly constant, continuous exposure situations, and
situations of fluctuating concentration including intermittent exposures. The two-number criteria were
derived using the revised methodologies (Guidelines) discussed in Section 1.
2.1.1 The Maximum Value Criterion
The maximum value criterion (also referred to as the Final Chronic Value, FCV) is obtained by
dividing the Final Acute Value (FAV) by the lower of (a) 2, or (b) the acute-chronic ratio. The FAV is
defined as the value which will protect 95 percent of the aquatic organism families in the national data
base from acute toxicity.
The acute toxicity data used for the calculation of the FAV should cover at least eight different
families such that all of the following are included:
1. the family Salmonidae in the class Osteichthyes,
2. one other (preferably warm water) family in the class Osteichthyes,
3. one other family in the phylum Chordata (e.g. fish, amphibian, etc.),
4. a planktonic crustacean (e.g. cladoceran, copepod, etc.),
5. a benthic crustacean (e.g. ostracod, isopod, scud, glass shrimp, crayfish, etc.),
6. an insect (e.g. mayfly, dragonfly, damselfly, stonefly, caddisfly, mosquito, midge, etc.),
7. a family in a phylum other than Arthropoda or Chordata (e.g. Rotifera, Annelida, Mollusca, etc.),
and
8. a family in any order of insect or any phylum not already represented.
2.1.2 The 30-Day Average Criterion
The 30-day average value is defined as the lowest of the following: Final Chronic Value (FCV),
Final Plant Value (FPV), and Final Residue Value (FRV). The FCV may be defined by any of the follow-
ing:
1. the value which will protect 95 percent of the national aquatic organisms from chronic toxicity,
with the national aquatic organism population represented by the species in the national
chronic toxicity data base; or,
2-1
-------
2. the value obtained from dividing the FAV by the acute-chronic ratio; or,
3. the species mean chronic value of an important species, such as a commercially or recrea-
tionally important species.
The acute-chronic ratio is the representative value which characterizes the acute sensitivity of a
species relative to its chronic toxicity.
The FPV is defined as the lowest value in a chronic test with an aquatic vascular plant or in a
96-hour or longer test with an alga. The FRV is calculated by dividing a maximum permissible tissue
concentration by an appropriate bio-concentration factor.
The national 30-day average criteria and the corresponding FCV, FPV and FRV are listed in Table
2.1. There is no 30-day average criterion for Aldrin, Arsenic or Silver. Acute-chronic ratios are available
for 15 chemicals, thus permitting calculation of the FCV from the FAV. The FAVs for Copper and Lead
were also calculated from chronic toxicity data using the revised methodology. Although the acute
toxicity of Zinc is hardness dependent, chronic Zinc toxicity is relatively unaffected by hardness.
Therefore, instead of setting a 30-day average criterion based on the FAV and the acute-chronic ratio,
a value of 47 mg/l was chosen because it represents the chronic value of both a sensitive invertebrate
(Daphnia Magna) in hard water and a moderately sensitive fish (Flagfish) in soft water. The FCVs in
Table 2.1 were calculated using the revised methodology, therefore, they do not necessarily agree with
those published in the Federal Register of 28 November 1980.
2.2 RECALCULATION OF SITE-SPECIFIC CRITERIA
According to the recalculation procedure, site-specific fresh-water aquatic life criteria may be
modified without any additional toxicity testing. The modification procedure may be outlined as
follows:
1. select the appropriate resident species toxicity data from the national data base,
2. calculate the FAV using the site-specific data base and the revised methodology,
3. define the site-specific maximum criteria by dividing the FAV by the lower of (a) 2, or (b) the
acute-chronic ratio,
4. calculate the FCV by either or both of the following steps:
(a) calculate the FCV by dividing the recalculated FAV by the acute-chronic ratio, or
(b) if the national FCV is calculated from chronic toxicity data, calculate the FCV using the
resident species chronic toxicity data, and
5. define the 30-day average value by selecting the minimum of the FRV, FPV, and the
recalculated FCVs.
If there are not enough resident species in the national toxicity data base to meet the minimum
data requirement, additional resident species bioassays in laboratory water may be needed in order to
apply this procedure. The States should decide on the data requirements appropriate for each situa-
tion.
The two-number national criteria have been developed by EPA for 18 chemicals. The derivation of
site-specific (state-specific) criteria for these same 18 chemicals is presented in this report. In addi-
tion, site-specific maximum criteria have been calculated for three other chemicals for which only na-
tional maximum criteria are available.
2-2
-------
Table 2.1 National 30-Day Average Criteria
Final Chronic Value1
Chemical Type 1 Type 2 Type 3
(M9/I) (H9/I) (M9/I)
Aldrin — — —
Arsenic — — —
Cadmium exp[1.05(lnH) -2.93]'
122
Chlordane 3.949/14.0 — —
Chromium 24.327/72.0 — —
CooDcr exp[0.94(lnH)-0.95]
5.78
Cyanide 62.859/14.8 — —
DDT — — —
Dieldrin 3.659/8.5 — —
Endosulfan 0.415/3.9 — —
Endrin 0.402/4.0 — —
Heptachlor — — —
Lead exp[1.22(lnH)-2.6] CXDr35(|n|» 1Q41
Lindane 6.435/25.0 — —
Mercury 0.940/3.0 — —
Nickel exp[0.76(lnH)+4.19]
19.4
PCB's — — —
Selenium 165.297/7.5 — —
Silver — — —
Toxaphene 1.074/123 — _
exp[0.83(lnH)+2.51]
3.0
1Type 1: Calculated by dividing FAV by acute-chronic ratio.
Type 2: Calculated from toxicity data base.
Type 3: Obtained from chronic value of important species.
2FCV1: Final Chronic Value, Type 1.
FCV2: Final Chronic Value, Type 2.
FCV3: Final Chronic Value, Type 3.
FRV : Final Residue Value.
FPV : Final Plant Value.
Final
Residue
Value
0*9/1)
260
0.0043
0.001
0.0019
0.0023
0.0038
0.20
0.014
0.076
Final
Plant
Value
-------
The geographical distribution of those species in the national acute and chronic toxicity data
bases is required for the calculation of the site-specific-water quality criteria. The approach taken in
finding the species distributions is described in Section 2.3 and the calculation of the state maximum
value criteria is described in Section 2.4. The calculation of the state 30-day average criteria is dis-
cussed in Section 2.5. A sample calculation which illustrates all of the procedures involved is
presented in Section 2.6.
2.3 SPECIES DISTRIBUTION
There are 95 biological species represented in the national toxicity data base for the 21 chemicals
discussed in this report. These species are listed in Tables 1 and 3 of each of the criteria documents
(U.S. EPA, 1980). Of these 95 species, 48 are fishes and 47 are assorted invertebrates. The species
tested in order to develop acute toxicity data for each of the 21 chemicals are listed in Table 2.2.
The classification of these species by family, order, class, and phylum is presented in Appendix
A. Appendix A, reproduced from "Guidelines for Deriving Numerical National Water Quality Criteria for
the Protection of Aquatic Life and Its Uses" (U.S. EPA, 1982), is essential for calculating the family
mean acute-chronic values from available species toxicity data, as well as for checking the family
composition of the toxicity data base against the minimum data requirements (Section 2.1.1).
A literature survey was conducted on the distribution of these species in the United States. The
principal reference for identifying the distribution of the listed 48 fish species was the "Atlas of North
American Freshwater Fishes" (Lee et al., 1980). A comparable document is not available for in-
vertebrates. Twenty references were used to identify the geographical distribution of the 47 in-
vertebrate species. A list of invertebrate species and the references used to identify their distribution
is presented in Table 2.3. The information in Table 2.3 results from an extensive survey of the literature,
however, this information should not be considered definitive as voids may exist in reporting the oc-
currence of some species, particularly those which are not of high commercial value.
Since there is no convention for recording the geographic distribution of species (i.e., whether by
state or by river basin drainage or by other geographical features), several formats are seen in the
literature. For the purposes of this report, the state was selected as the most appropriate geographical
delimiter.
2-4
-------
Table 2.2 List of Species Names in the Acute Toxicity Data Base
Species
Planarian (Polyoelis Felina)
Rotifer (Philodina Acuticornis)
Rotifer (Philodina Roseola)
Bristleworm (Nais Sp.)
Worm (Llmnodrilus Hoffmeisteri)
Snail (Amnicola Sp.)
Snail (Campeloma Declsum)
Snail (Qyrulus Clrcumstriatus)
Snail (Physa Heterostropha)
Snail (Physa Integra)
Snail (Physa Sp.)
Cladoceran (Daphnia Carinata)
Cladoceran (Daphnia Magna)
Cladoceran (Daphnia Pulex)
Cladoceran (Daphnia Pulicaria)
Cladoceran (Simocephalus Serrulatus)
Seed Shrimp (Cyprldopsls Vidua)
Copepod (Unidentified)
Isopod (Asellus Brevicaudus)
Isopod (Asellus Communis)
Scud (Gammarus Fasciatus)
Scud (Gammarus Lacustris)
Scud (Gammarus Pseudolimneaus)
Scud (Gammarus Sp.)
Scud (Hyallela Azteca)
Crayfish (Faxonella Clypeata)
Crayfish (Orconectes Nais)
Crayfish (Orconectes Llmosus)
Crayfish (Orconectes Rustic us)
Crayfish (Procambarus Acutus)
Glass Shrimp (Palaemonetes Kadlakensis)
Mayfly (Ephemerella Grandis)
Mayfly (Ephemerella Subvaria)
Mayfly (Hexagenla Bilineata)
•••• E 8 • ^
0 3 « 3 _ «
I ! I I 1 Us
<
-------
Table 2.2 List of Species Names in the Acute Toxicity Data Base (Continued)
Species
Stonefly (Acroneuria Lycorius)
Stonefly (Acroneuria Pacifica)
Stonefly (Claassennia Sabulosa)
Stonefly (Pteronarcella Badia)
Stonefly (Pteronarcys Californica)
Damselfly (Ischnura Verticalus)
Damselfly (Ischnura Sp.)
Damselfly (Unidentified)
Midge (Chironomus Plumosus)
Midge (Chironomus Tentans)
Midge (Chironomus Sp.)
Midge (Tanytarsus Dissimilis)
Caddisfly (Arctopsyche Grandis)
Caddisfly (Hydropsyche Betteni)
Caddisfly (Hydropsyche Californica)
Caddisfly (Unidentified)
American Eel (Anguilla Rostrata)
Coho Salmon (Oncorhynchus Kisutch)
Sockeye Salmon (Orcorhynchus Nerka)
Chinook Salmon (Orcorhynchus Tshawtscha)
Cutthroat Trout (Salmo Clark!)
Rainbow Trout (Salmo Gairdneri)
Atlantic Salmon (Salmo Salar)
Brown Trout (Salmo Trutta)
Brook Trout (Salvelinus Fontinalis)
Lake Trout (Salvelinus Namaycush)
Northern Pike (Esox Lucius)
Mottled Sculpin (Cottus Bairdi)
Longfin Dace (Agosia Chrysogaster)
Stonerotler (Campostoma Anomalum)
Goldfish (Carassius Auratus)
Carp (Cyprinus Carpio)
Golden Shiner (Notemigonus Crysoleucas)
Striped Shiner (Notropis Chrysocephalus)
E g E | °
Hill iMl*til
^i2Sjr£o>>Q*cca>2c
<, £ a
« H m § I f «
« £ 0 0 = 0 ;£
S z a en tn \- N
X X
X XXX
X XX
X XXX
XX X XXXXX
X
X
X
X
X
X
X X
XX X
X
X
X X
X X
X X
X X
X
X
X
X X
XX X
X XXXXXXX
X X
X X
X XX
X
X XX X XX XX X
XX X
xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
X
X X
XXXXXXX X XX
X X
X
XXXXXXX
X
X
X XX
X
X
X
X
X
xxxxxxxxx xxxx
XXXXX X
X
X
X X XX
X XX
X X
X
2-6
-------
Table 2.2 List of Species Names in the Acute Toxicity Data Base (Continued)
Species
Northern Redbelly Dace (Phoxinus EOS)
Bluntnose Minnow (Pimephales Notatus)
Fathead Minnow (Pimephales Promelas)
Northern Squawfish (Ptychocheiluseoregonensis)
Blacknose Dace (Rhlnichthys Atratulus)
Speckled Dace (Rhlnichthys Osculus)
Creek Chub (Semotllus Atromaculatus)
White Sucker (Catostomus Commersoni)
Black Bullhead (Ictalurus Melas)
Brown Bullhead (Ictalurus Nebulosus)
Channel Catfish (Ictalurus Punctatus)
Banded Killifish (Fundulus Diaphanus)
Flagfish (Jordanella Floridae)
Mosquitofish (Gambusia Affinis)
Guppy (Poecilia Reticulata)
Southern Platyflsh (Xiphophorus Maculatus)
Brook Stickleback (Culaea Inconstans)
Threesplne Stickleback (Gasterosteus Aculeatus)
White Perch (Morone Americana)
Striped Bass (Morone Saxatilis)
Rock Bass (Ambloplites Rupestrls)
Green Sunfish (Lepomis Cyanellus)
Pumpkinseed (Lepomis Gibbosus)
Bluegill (Lepomis Macronchirus)
Longear Sunfish (Lepomis Megalotls)
Redear Sunfish (Lepomis Microlophus)
Largemouth Bass (Mlcropterus Salmoldes)
Black Grapple (Pomoxls Nlgromaculatus)
Rainbow Darter (Etheostoma Caeruleum)
Orangethroat Darter (Etheostoma Spectabile)
Yellow Perch (Perca Flavescens)
* 1 1 ! 1 1 1 1 1 1 \, '• r i 1 , 1
<
-------
Table 2.3 List of References Used for Identifying the
Geographical Distribution of the Invertebrate Species
Species
Planarian (Polycelis felina)
Rotifer Philodina acuticornis)
Rotifer (Philodina roseola)
Bristleworm (Nais Sp.)
Worm (Limnodrilus hoffmeisteri)
Snail (Amnicola Sp.)
Snail (Campeloma decisum)
Snail (Gyraulus circumstriatus)
Snail (Physa heterostropha)
Snail (Physa Integra)
Snail (Physa Sp.)
Cladoceran (Daphnia carinata)
Cladoceran (Daphnia magna)
Cladoceran (Daphnia pulex)
Cladoceran (Daphnia pulicaria)
Cladoceran (Simocephalus serrulatus)
Seed Shrimp (Cypridopsis vidua)
Copepod (Unidentified)
Isopod (Asellus brevicaudus)
Isopod (Asellus communis)
Scud (Gammarus fasciatus)
Scud (Gammarus lacustris)
Scud (Gammarus pseudolimneaus)
Scud (Gammarus Sp.)
Scud (Hyallela azteca)
Crayfish (Faxonella clypeata)
Crayfish (Orconectes nais)
Crayfish (Orconectes limosus)
Crayfish (Orconectes rusticus)
Crayfish (Procambarus acutus)
Glass Shrimp (Palaemonetes kadiakensis)
Mayfly (Ephemerella grandls)
Mayfly (Ephemerella subvaria)
Mayfly (Hexagenia bilineata)
Stonefly (Acroneuria lycorius)
Stonefly (Acroneuria pacifica)
Stonefly (Claassennia sabulosa)
Stonefly (Pteronarcella badia)
Stonefly (Pteronarcys californica)
Damselfly (Ischnura verticalus)
Damselfly (Ischnura Sp.)
Damselfly (Unidentified)
Midge (Chironomus plumosus)
Midge (Chironomus tentans)
Midge (Chironomus Sp.)
Midge (Tanytarsus dissimilis)
Caddlsfly (Arctopsyche grandis)
Caddisfly (Hydropsyche bettenl)
Caddisfly (Hydropsyche californica)
Caddisfly (Unidentified)
Reference
Kenk (personal communication)
Pennak, 1978
Brinkhurst et al., 1971
Emerson et al., 1976
Hyman, 1967
Emerson et al., 1976
Brooks, 1957
Ward & Whipple, 1972
Pennak, 1978
Williams, 1972
Hosinger, 1972
Pennak, 1978
Bousfield, 1958
Hobbs, 1972
Holthuis, 1952
Edmunds et al., 1976
Burks et al., 1953
Stark et al., 1976
Baumann et al., 1977
Walker, 1953
Merritt & Cummins, 1978
U.S. Agr. Res. Service, 1965
Merritt & Cummins, 1978
U.S. Agr. Res. Service, 1965
Fischer, 1963
Merritt & Cummins, 1978
2-8
-------
2.4 CALCULATION OF MAXIMUM VALUE CRITERIA BY STATE
2.4.1 Procedures
The calculation of state aquatic life criteria is based on the information in state resident species
lists, and on the species toxicity data for the derivation of national water quality criteria, as presented
in "Guidelines for Deriving Site Specific Water Quality Criteria for the Protection of Aquatic Life and
Its Uses" (U.S. EPA, 1982).
2.4.1.1 Maximum Value Criteria Independent of Hardness
Calculation of the maximum value criteria, for those chemicals whose toxicity is independent of
hardness, is done according to the following procedure:
1. Using the EPA criteria document for the toxic chemical of interest, select from Table 3 the
Species Mean Acute Value (SMAV) for each species resident in the state.
2. For each family with one or more SMAVs available, calculate the Family Mean Acute Value
(FMAV) as the geometric mean of the available SMAVs.
3. Calculate the state Final Acute Value using the procedures outlined below which are dis-
cussed in "Guidelines for Deriving Numerical National Water Quality Criteria for the Protec-
tion of Aquatic Life and Its Uses" (U.S. EPA, 1982):
(a) Order the FMAVs from low to high.
(b) Assign ranks (R) to the FMAVs from "1" for the lowest to "N" for the highest. If two or more
FMAVs are identical, arbitrarily assign them successive ranks.
(c) Calculate the cumulative proportion (P) for each FMAV as R/(N + 1).
(d) Select the four FMAVs which have cumulative proportions closest to 0.05 (if there are less
than 59 FMAVs, these will always be the four lowest FMAVs).
(e) Using the selected FMAVs and Ps, calculate the following coefficients:
M>= _ _
Z(ln FMAV)' - ((I(ln FMAV))2/4) v '
x = (I(ln FMAV))/4 (2.2)
y = (ZvTV4 (2.3)
(f) the State FAV is defined as:
FAV = eA (2.4)
iy (2.5)
2-9
-------
4. the state maximum value criteria is defined as the larger of:
(a) (State FAV)/2, or
(2.6)
(b) (State FAV)/(acute-chronic ratio)
2.4.1.2 Maximum Value Criteria as a Function of Hardness
Hardness has been shown to affect the acute toxicity of six chemicals: Cadmium, Copper, Lead,
Nickel, Silver and Zinc. Therefore, criteria for these six chemicals are determined according to a final
acute equation which expresses the FAV as a function of hardness:
FAV = exp[v(ln(H)) + z] (2.7)
where H is the hardness expressed as mg/l of CaC03, v is the mean acute slope, and z is the final acute
intercept. The parameter v is defined as the arithmetic mean of all the meaningful acute slopes for in-
dividual species (45FR79344, 28 November 1980). The acute slope for an individual species is defined
as the slope of the best fitted line when the species acute values are plotted against the hardness con-
centration in a log-log plot. In other words, for a given chemical the constant value v is assumed ap-
plicable to all species in the acute toxicity data. When calculating the state maximum value criteria,
the same value of v as used for the national calculation was used for the states.
The calculation of a state maximum value criteria is accomplished as follows:
1. Using the EPA criteria document for the chemical of interest, select from Table 3 the species
which are resident in a particular state and record the Species Mean Acute Intercept (SMAI).
The SMAI was calculated as the geometric mean of the available intercepts (y), with y defined
as:
y = w/exp [v(ln H)] (2.8)
where w = the reported LC50, shown in Table 1 of the criteria document.
v = the mean acute slope for the hardness dependence function shown at the bottom
of Table 1 of the criteria document.
H = hardness concentration at which the bioassay was conducted, in mg/l CaCO3.
2. For each family with one or more SMAIs available, calculate the Family Mean Acute Intercept
(FMAI) as the geometric mean of the available SMAIs.
3. Calculate the coefficients x, y, and M for the state Final Acute Equation using the procedure
("a" through "e") outlined in Section 2.4.1.1, substituting "FMAI" for "FMAV".
4. The state Final Acute Equation is defined as:
FAV = exp[v(ln(H) + A] (2.9)
2-10
-------
where A = x + °-05M~ y , (2.10)
and v = mean acute slope for the chemical discussed in step "1".
5. The state maximum value criterion is defined as the larger of:
(a) (state FAV)/2, or
(2.11)
(b) (state FAV)/(acute-chronic ratio)
2.4.2 Computer Program
An interactive FORTRAN program (FOUR.STATE) was used to calculate the state maximum value
criteria. The program is an extended version of a computer program developed at the U.S. EPA En-
vironmental Research Laboratory in Duluth. The Duluth computer program calculates final acute
values by the method described in the Federal Register of 28 November 1980. The Duluth program was
modified to include the following capabilities:
1. Select resident species data from the national data base for any given state,
2. calculate the FMAV of the available resident species,
3. calculate the FAV using the modified methodology, and
4. check the modified state data base against the modified criteria of the minimum data
requirements.
The program operates on five data files:
ACUTE1.DAT Data file of species acute values (LC50 or EC50) as reported in Table 1 of the
criteria documents. The only exception is the species acute value for
Silver for Speckled Dace (Rhinichthys osculus) which is changed from the
published 0.2 pg/l to 20.0
SPECIES.DAT Data file of the species names, their ID numbers and their family ID
numbers. This list contains all species for which an acute toxicity value
was recorded for the 21 chemicals.
FAMILY.DAT Data file of family names and their ID numbers.
CHEMNAME.DAT Data file of 21 chemical names, 18 if which have two-value freshwater
aquatic life criteria, and three of which have maximum criteria.
2-11
-------
SRES.DAT Data file of the resident species in 48 states (Hawaii and Alaska not in-
cluded); both state and species are represented by their ID numbers.
STATENAME.NEW State names of the 48 states for which the freshwater aquatic criteria have
been calculated.
The three data files-ACUTE1.DAT, SPECIES.DAT, CHEMNAME.DAT—were furnished by the U.S.
EPA Environmental Research Laboratory in Duluth.
2.5 CALCULATION OF THE STATE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERION
2.5.1 Procedures
The 30-day average criterion is defined as the minimum of the FCV, FPV or FRY. The three
methods used in deriving the national FCV were also used for deriving the corresponding state FCV. In
cases where the national FCV was derived by dividing the national FAV by the acute-chronic ratio, the
state FCV was derived by dividing the state FAV by the acute-chronic ratio. For a given chemical, the
constant acute-chronic ratio published in the criteria document was used for all states. In the case
where the national FCV was derived from a chronic toxicity data base, such as Copper and Lead, the
same methodology used for calculation of the FAV (Equation 2.9) was used for calculating the state
FCV based on the state resident family chronic toxicity data. The state resident family data base used
for the FCV calculation was calculated by one of the following methods:
1. When chronic toxicity is independent of hardness:
(a) Select the Species Mean Chronic Value (SMCV) of the state resident species from the
national chronic toxicity data base.
(b) For each family with one or more SMCVs available, calculate the Family Mean Chronic
Value as the geometric mean of the available SMCVs.
2. When chronic toxicity is a function of hardness:
(a) Select the Species Mean Chronic Intercept (SMCI) of the state resident species from the
national chronic toxicity data base.
(b) For each family with one or more SMCI available, calculate the Family Mean Chronic In-
tercept (FMCI) as the geometric mean of the available SMCIs.
2.5.2 Computer Program
Whenever sufficient information was available, the computer program was used to calculate five
values—three FCVs, FPV and FRV—for each state. The calculations were done for 18 chemicals (no
30-day average criteria were available for Aldrin, Arsenic and Silver).
2-12
-------
The variation in state resident species would affect two of the FCVs:
1. FCV calculated as FAV divided by acute-chronic ratio, and
2. FCV calculated from the state chronic toxicity data base.
The program reads each of these five values for the specified state and chemical. If a value is not
available, it is set to an arbitrarily high number (9999.0) so that it will not be chosen as the minimum
value. The program then simply compares all five values and chooses the minimum.
2.6 SAMPLE CALCULATION
The calculation of the freshwater aquatic life criteria for Chlordane and Nickel for the State of
Pennsylvania are presented to illustrate the recalculation method.
2.6.1 Chlordane Criteria for Pennsylvania
1. The Maximum Value Criterion
The starting point is the national acute toxicity data base for Chlordane (Table 2.4) where
species ID numbers, names and their species mean acute values are presented. The species
ID number is given in the column "SNO" and the species mean acute value in the column
"LC50," with units of ng/l. With the aid of the resident species list for the State of Pennsyl-
vania (Table 2.5), the resident species toxicity data for the State (Table 2.6) are then readily
prepared by selecting the data for resident species from Table 2.4. The eight species in Table
2.6 represent five families (see Appendices A and B-3). The family acute toxicity table for
Pennsylvania (Table 2.7) is prepared by calculating the Family Mean Acute Value (FMAV) for
each of the eight species shown in Table 2.6. The FMAV is defined as the geometric mean of
the available species mean acute values for species belonging to the family. For example,
carp, fathead minnow and goldfish all belong to the family of Cyprinidae. The FMAV for
Cyprinidae is then calculated as:
(3.0x51.0x82.0)1'3 = 23.2 (2.12)
where 3.0, 51.0 and 82.0 are the species mean acute values of the three species.
Of aquatic organisms resident in Pennsylvania waters, the four families most sensitive to Chlordane,
their rank, cumulative proportion and FMAV are:
2-13
-------
Table 2.4 National Acute Toxicity Data for Chlordane
Rank
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
LC50
(M9/D
3.0000
6.3245
15.0000
25.4808
26.0000
39.9999
44.9999
51.0134
54.7111
55.9999
56.9999
58.2665
81.9998
189.9997
LN LC50
1.0986
1.8444
2.7080
3.2379
3.2581
3.6889
3.8067
3.9321
4.0021
4.0254
4.0430
4.0650
4.4067
5.2470
SNO
68.0
31.0
39.0
58.0
22.0
21.0
61.0
73.0
93.0
54.0
56.0
13.0
67.0
84.0
Species
Carp (Cyprinus carpio)
Glass Shrimp (Palaemonetes kadiakensis)
Stonefly (Pteronarcys californica)
Rainbow Trout (Salmo gairdneri)
Scud (Gammarus lacustris)
Scud (Gammarus fasciatus)
Brook Trout (Salvelinus fontinalis)
Fathead Minnow (Pimephales promelas)
Bluegill (Lepomis machrochirus)
Coho Salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch)
Chinook Salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha)
Cladoceran (Daphia magna)
Goldfish (Carassius auratus)
Guppy (Poecilia reticulata)
Table 2.5 Resident Species List for Pennsylvania
2.0
9.0
20.0
32.0
50.0
62.0
70.0
79.0
90.0
3.0
10.0
21.0
33.0
52.0
63.0
71.0
80.0
91.0
4.0
11.0
24.0
40.0
53.0
64.0
73.0
81.0
92.0
5.0
14.0
25.0
41.0
55.0
66.0
74.0
86.0
93.0
6.0
15.0
28.0
43.0
58.0
67.0
76.0
87.0
94.0
7.0
16.0
30.0
45.0
60.0
68.0
77.0
88.0
95.0
8.0
18.0
31.0
47.0
61.0
69.0
78.0
89.0
96.0
97.0 98.0 99.0 101.0 102.0 4.5
2-14
-------
Table 2.6 Pennsylvania Resident Species Toxicity Data for Chlordane
Rank LC50 LN LC50 SNO Species
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
3.0000
6.3245
25.4808
39.9999
44.9999
51.0134
54.7111
81.9998
1.0986
1.8444
3.2379
3.6889
3.8067
3.9321
4.0021
4.4067
68.0
31.0
58.0
21.0
61.0
73.0
93.0
67.0
Carp (Cyprinus carpio)
Glass Shrimp (Palaemonetes kadiakensis)
Rainbow Trout (Salmo gairdneri)
Scud (Gammarus fasciatus)
Brook Trout (Salvelinus fontinalis)
Fathead Minnow (Pimephales promelas)
Bluegill (Lepomis macrochirus)
Goldfish (Carassius auratus)
Table 2.7 Pennsylvania Family Acute Toxicity Table for Chlordane
Rank
1
2
3
4
5
FLC50
(MQ/D
6.3245
23.2384
33.8620
39.9999
54.7110
LN (FLC50)
1.8444
3.1458
3.5223
3.6889
4.0021
FNO
27
40
38
25
48
Family
Palaemonidae
Cyprinidae
Salmon idae
Gammaridae
Centrarchidae
2-15
-------
R P FMAV Family
(M9/I)
1 0.17 6.32 Palalmonidae
2 0.33 23.24 Cyprinidae
3 0.50 33.68 Salmonidae
4 0.67 40.00 Gammanidae
1. with P calculated as R/(N +1) where N is the total number of families in the State toxicity data
base, which is five in this case. Using the values of FMAV and P for the four most sensitive
families, the coefficients M, x, y and A needed for the State Final Acute Value (FAV) can be cal-
culated by applying the formula suggested in the revised methodology:
M> = Z - [«/W4] =0.044 (2.13)
I[ln FMAV)2] - [(Z(ln FMAV))2/4]
x = [Z(ln FMAV)]/4 = 3.05 (2.14)
y = (Z(vT))/4 = 0.627 (2.15)
A = x + ^£ L =1.13 (2.16)
M
The FAV is:
FAV = eA = 3.10 f*gl\ (2.17)
The State maximum value criterion is defined as the State FAV divided by the smaller of
(a) 2, or (b) the acute-chronic ratio. Since the acute-chronic ratio for Chlordane is 14 (>2), the
maximum value criterion for Chlordane for the State of Pennsylvania is 1.55, which is the State
FAV divided by 2.
2-16
-------
2. The 30-Day Average Criterion
The 30-day average criterion is defined as the minimum of the Final Chronic Value (FGV),
the Final Residue Value (FRV) or the Final Plant Value (FPV). There is no FPV available for
Chlordane. The FRV is 0.0043 ngl\ (see Table 2.1). The final chronic data set is not sufficient for
the calculation of an FCV. The acute-chronic ratio for Chlordane is 14.0 (see Table 2.1) which
gives an FCV for Pennsylvania of 0.22 ngl\, calculated as 3.10/14.0, where 3.10 is the FAV for
Pennsylvania. Comparing 0.22 ^g/l (FCV) with 0.0043 jig/I (FRV), the 30-day average criterion for
Chlordane for the State of Pennsylvania, 0.0043 pg/l, is chosen.
2.6.2 Nickel Criteria for Pennsylvania
1. The Maximum Value Criterion
The acute toxicity of Nickel has been related to the hardness in freshwater by an exponen-
tial equation (U.S. EPA, 1980):
e[0.76 In (hardness) + 2] (2.18)
Since hardness affects acute toxicity, the effect of hardness has to be removed from the labor-
atory observed LCM values. Instead of using observed LC50s as the data base, the acute in-
tercept ez is used. The acute intercept can be viewed as the acute value in the absence of a
hardness effect (i.e., In (hardness) = 0). The national acute toxicity data for Nickel in the
absence of a hardness effect is given in Table 2.8 where the values listed in the column "LC50"
are species mean acute intercepts. Using this as the starting point and following the pro-
cedure described in Section 2.6.1, the resident species toxicity data (Table 2.9) and the resi-
dent family toxicity data (Table 2.10) are prepared.
The four families most sensitive to Nickel in the State of Pennsylvania, their family mean
acute intercept (FMAI), rank (R), and cumulative proportion (P) are:
R P FMAI Family
0*Q/0
1 0.07 4.36 Daphnidae
2 0.14 5.45 Ephemerellidae
3 0.21 5.84 Centrarchidae
4 0.29 5.99 Philodinidae
2-17
-------
Table 2.8 National Acute Toxicity Data for Nickel (in The Absence of Hardness Effect)
Rank
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
LC50
(M9/D
53.9790
78.4561
208.4833
233.5550
301.5102
388.3505
401.2168
439.8254
440.2043
456.6418
506.5306
509.2643
627.1620
658.5149
664.8523
721.1083
731.3375
1007.69
1084.21
1544.49
2029.91
2226.41
LN LC50
3.9886
4.3625
5.3399
5.4534
5.7088
5.9619
5.9945
6.0864
6.0872
6.1239
6.2276
6.2330
6.4412
6.4900
6.4996
6.5808
6.5949
6.9154
6.9886
7.3425
7.6157
7.7081
SNO
13.0
15.0
90.0
33.0
89.0
92.0
2.0
45.0
73.0
84.0
68.0
93.0
53.0
88.0
24.0
4.0
5.0
67.0
42.0
52.0
35.0
81.0
Species
Cladoceran (Daphnia magna)
Cladoceran (Daphnia pulicaria)
Rock Bass (Ambloplites rupestris)
Mayfly (Ephemeral I a subvaria)
Striped Bass (Morone saxatilis)
Pumpkinseed (Lepomis gibbosus)
Rotifer (Philodina acuticornis)
Midge (Chironomus Sp.)
Fathead Minnow (Pimephales promelas)
Guppy (Poecilia reticulata)
Carp (Cyprinus carpio)
Bluegill (Lepomis macrochirus)
American Eel (Anguilla rostrata)
White Perch (Morone americana)
Scud (Gammarus Sp.)
Bristleworm (Nais Sp.)
Snail (Amnicola Sp.)
Goldfish (Carassius auratus)
Damselfy (Unidentified)
Caddisfly (Unidentified)
Stonefly (Acroneuria lycorius)
Banded Killifish (Fundulus diaphanus)
2-18
-------
Rank
Rank
Table 2.9 Pennsylvania Resident Species Toxicity Data for Nickel
LC50 LN LC50 SNO Species
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
(MQ/D
78.4561
208.4833
233.5550
301.5102
388.3505
401.2168
439.8254
440.2043
506.5306
509.2643
627.1620
658.5149
664.8523
721.1083
731.3375
1007.69
1544.49
2226.41
4.3625
5.3399
5.4534
5.7088
5.9619
5.9945
6.0864
6.0872
6.2276
6.2330
6.4412
6.4900
6.4996
6.5808
6.5949
6.9154
7.3425
7.7081
15.0
90.0
33.0
89.0
92.0
2.0
45.0
73.0
68.0
93.0
53.0
88.0
24.0
4.0
5.0
67.0
52.0
81.0
Cladoceran (Daphnia pulicaria)
Rock Bass (Ambloplites rupestris)
Mayfly (Ephemerella subvaria)
Striped Bass (Morone saxatilis)
Pumpkinseed (Lepomis gibbosus)
Rotifer (Philodina acuticornis)
Midge (Chironomus Sp.)
Fathead Minnow (Pimephales promelas)
Carp (Cyprinus reticulata)
Bluegill (Lepomis macrochirus)
American Eel (Anguilla rostrata)
White Perch (Morone americana)
Scud (Gammarus Sp.)
Bristleworm (Nais Sp.)
Snail (Amnicola Sp.)
Goldfish (Carassius auratus)
Caddisfly (Unidentified)
Banded Killifish (Fundulus diaphanus)
Table 2.10 Pennsylvania Resident Family Toxicity Data for Nickel
FLC50
LN(FLCSO) FNO Family
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
78.4560
233.5550
345.4717
401.2168
439.8254
445.5883
607.9420
627.1620
664.8523
721.1083
731.3375
1544.4988
2226.4189
4.3625
5.4534
5.8449
5.9945
6.0864
6.0994
6.4101
6.4412
6.4996
6.5808
6.5949
7.3425
7.7081
19
29
48
7
35
47
40
37
25
10
12
34
44
Daphnidae
Ephemerellidae
Centrarchidae
Philodinidae
Chironomidae
Perchithyidae
Cyprinidae
Anguillidae
Gammaridae
Naididae
Bithyniidae (Bulimidae) (Hydrobiidae)
Hydropsychidae
Cyprinodontidae
2-19
-------
with P calculated as R/(N +1) where N is the total number of families in the State data base,
which is 13 in this case. Substituting these values into equations 2.1 to 2.5, we obtain the
following:
M2 = 0.024 (2.19)
x =5.41 (2.20)
y = 0.411 (2.21)
A = 4.22 (2.22)
The Final Acute Intercept (FAI) is:
FAI = eA = 67.7 (2.23)
and the Final Acute Equation is:
FAV = FAI x el°-76 ln (hardness)] (2.24)
FAV = 67.7 et°-76 ln (hardness)] (2.25)
or
FAV = etO-7^ In (hardness) + A] (2.26)
FAV = el°-76 ln (hardness) + 4.22] (2.27)
Since the acute-chronic ratio for Nickel (19.4) is greater than 2, the maximum value
criteria (MVC) for Nickel for the State of Pennsylvania is:
MVC = (FAI/2)e[°-76 In (hardness)] (2.28)
MVC = 33.8 el°-76 ln (hardness)] (2.29)
or
MVC = el0-76 ln (hardness) + 3.52] (2.30)
2. The 30-Day Average Criterion
The chronic toxicity of Nickel is related to hardness in freshwater in the same way as is
acute toxicity (Equation 2.18). The national chronic toxicity data base (Table 2.11) contains
2-20
-------
only two families which are indigenous to Pennsylvania (Cyprinidae and Salmonidae),
therefore, the FCV cannot be calculated from the State chronic toxicity data base.
Table 2.11 National Chronic Toxicity Data for Nickel
Rank FLC50 LN (FLC50) FNO Family
1
2
3
4
(M9/D
2.5476
7.4587
17.8999
23.7813
0.9351
2.0094
2.8848
3.1689
19
40
38
34
Daphnidae
Cyprinidae*
Salmonidae*
Hydropsychidae
•Indigenous to Pennsylvania.
The available acute-chronic ratio is 19.3 (see Table 2.1) which allows a Final Chronic Equa-
tion to be calculated from the Final Acute Equation:
FCV = FAV/(acute-chronic ratio) (2.31)
With the State Final Acute Equation given by Equation 2.25, the State Final Chronic
Equation is defined as:
FCV = §LIeC°-76 ln (hardness)] (2.32)
FCV = 3.49 et°-76 ln (hardness)] (2.33)
or
FCV = el°-76 ln (hardness) + 1.25] (2.34)
Since there is no FRV or FPV for Nickel, the Final Chronic Equation, which expresses the
Final Chronic Value as a function of hardness, is the Pennsylvania 30-day average criterion
for Nickel.
2-21
-------
SECTION 3
RESULTS
3.1 SPECIES DISTRIBUTION BY STATE
Much of the information used to recalculate water quality criteria by state is presented in Appen-
dix B. Identification numbers assigned to the states and to families in the national data base are listed
in Appendices B-1 and B-2, respectively. Species identification numbers and the corresponding family
classifications are presented in Appendix B-3. State and species are listed by identification number in
Appendices B-4 and B-5, and the distribution in the United States (Hawaii and Alaska are not included)
of the 95 species in the national data base is presented in Appendix B-5.
A complete list of North American species used in toxicity testing (Appendix B-3) includes the
taxonomic families into which each organism is classified. There are 58 families. The relationship of
these families to the minimum data requirements, which are discussed in Section 2.1.1, is illustrated
in Appendix B-6.
The 58 families are arrayed in Appendix B-6 by ID number. The relationship of these families to the
minimum data requirements may be determined by matching the code number in the Figure to each of
the eight specified data requirements. Note that most of the families may satisfy more than one of the
minimum data requirements. For example, after a member of the family Salmonidae has been
selected, there are 14 families which satisfy the requirement for one other member of the class
Osteichthyes, and 20 families remaining which satisfy the requirement for one other family in the
phylum Chordata.
The total number of resident species in the each of 48 states ranges from 39 to 74, approximately
40 to 70 percent of the total species in the national toxicity data base. New York has the greatest
number of resident species while Florida has the least. Eighteen species are present in all 48 states:
rotifer (Philodina acuticornis)
rotifer (Philodina roseala)
bristleworm (Nais spj
worm (Limnodrilus hoffmeisteri)
snail (Gyraulus circumstriatus)
snail (Physa sp.J
cladoceran (Daphnia pulex)
cladoceran (Daphnia pulicaria)
cladoceran (Simocephalus serrulatus)
copepod (unidentified)
scud (Hyallela azteca)
damselfly (Ischnura spj
midge (Chironomus plumsus)
3-1
-------
midge (Chironomus spj
midge (unidentified)
caddisfly (unidentified)
carp (Cyprinus carpio)
large mouth bass (Micropterus salmoides)
There are several species that are widely used in testing but whose actual distribution is limited.
The planarian, Poly eel is felina is indigenous only in Central Europe and is not present in any of the 48
states. (Kenk, personal communication, 1981.) The distribution in the United States of an often studied
laboratory cladoceran, Daphnia magna, is limited. There is no valid record of the natural occurrence of
Daphnia magna east of the Mississippi River. The known distribution of Daphnia magna in the United
States is shown in Figure 3.1, which is modified from "The Systematics of North American Daphnia"
(Brooks, 1957); the distribution range covers 14 of the western states. Daphnia pulicaria is recognized
in Europe but is not listed in "The Systematics of North American Daphnia" (Brooks, 1957). Daphnia
pulicaria and Daphnia pulex are extremely similar in their taxonomy (Herbert, P., personal communica-
tion, 1981.) In this study, it is assumed that Daphnia pulex, which commonly occurs in the states, is the
same as Daphnia pulicaria.
3.2 STATE WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
The state water quality criteria which result from application of the recalculation method are
presented in this report in two formats: first by chemical (Appendix C) and second by state (Appendix
D). The state maximum criteria were calculated whenever the state toxicity data bases contained four
or more families. Since the revised methodology calls for a regression of four data points, the national
value was adopted as the state value whenever the state toxicity data comprised fewer than four
families.
In calculating the national maximum value criteria, the minimum data requirement was met by
only five chemicals (DDT, Cadmium, Chromium, Copper and Zinc). Those elements of the minimum
data requirement which were not satisfied, for each chemical of interest, are indicated in Table 3.1.
The national toxicity data bases for ten chemicals (Aldrin, Chlordane, Dieldren, Endosulfan, Endrin,
Heptachlor, Lindane, PCB, Toxaphene and Arsenic) include no families in phyla other than Arthropoda
or Chordata. The data bases for nine chemicals (Chlordane, Heptachlor, Lindane, PCB, Cyanide,
Arsenic, Lead, Selenium and Silver) include no order of insect other than the one used to meet require-
ment 6, nor do they include any phyla other than Arthropoda, Chordata and one phylum used to meet
requirement 7. Data bases of species for seven of the chemicals fail to meet one requirement and nine
of them fail to meet two. Ninety-seven (97) percent of the state data bases for calculating the state
maximum value criteria do not meet the minimum data requirements. Since the state toxicity data are
always a subset of the national toxicity data, the cause of an inability of most state data sets to meet
the minimum data requirements is insufficient data in the national toxicity data base.
The use of the tables in Appendices C and D is straightforward. For instance, the water quality
criteria for Lindane for the State of Michigan may be obtained from tables of Lindane in Appendix C or
3-2
-------
Figure 3.1 Distribution of Dap/in/a magna in the United States (Modified from Brooks, 1957)
3-3
-------
Table 3.1 Minimum Data Requirements Which Are Not Met
By The National Toxicity Data Base
Criteria'
Chemical Name
Aldrin
Chlordane
Dieldrin
DDT
Endosulfan
Endrin
Heptachlor
Lindane
PCB
Toxaphene
Cyanide
Arsenic
Cadmium
Chromium
Copper
Lead
Mercury
Nickel
Selenium
Silver
Zinc
1234567
X2
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X X
X
8
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
1The eight criteria of the minimum data requirements:
1. The family Salmonidae In the class Osteichthyes.
2. One other family in the class Osteichthyes.
3. One other family in the phylum Chordata.
4. A planktonic crustacean (e.g. conchostracean, cladoceran, or copepod).
5. A benthic crustacean (e.g., crayfish, isopod, ostracod, scud or glass
shrimp).
6. A benthic insect (e.g., a benthic caddisfly, damselfly, dragonfly, mayfly,
midge, mosquito or stonefly.
7. A family In a phylum other than Arthropoda or Chordata (e.g., Rotifera,
Annelida or Mollusca).
8. Any other order of Insect or any other phylum.
2"x" indicates criterion is not satisfied.
3-4
-------
tables for Michigan in Appendix D. The maximum value criterion is 6.60 pg/l, which was obtained by
dividing the State Final Acute Value by 2; the 30-day average criterion is 0.528 ^g/l which was derived
by dividing the State Final Acute Value by acute-chronic ratio of 25 (see Table 2.1). Other useful infor-
mation is also available in these tables. The total number of families in the State resident data base
for Michigan is eight. The four most sensitive families and their FMAVs are:
FMAV
Family
Salmonidae 21.99
Gammaridae 22.44
Centrarchidae 42.20
Ictaluridae 53.07
One may immediately infer from this information that the Michigan FAV for Lindane is lower than
the family mean acute value of the most sensitive family (21.99 ^g/l for Salmonidae). Since the FAV is
the value which corresponds to the fifth percentile, then the FAV should be less than the family mean
acute value of the most sensitive family if the total number of resident families is less than 20.
In all cases, except for those containing less than four resident families, the maximum criteria
may be calculated based on the information given in these tables. Take the maximum value criterion
of Lindane for Michigan as an example, with a total of eight resident families and mean acute values
for the four most sensitive of 21.99, 22.44, 42.20 and 53.07 Mg/l. The coefficients needed for the FAV
can be calculated by substituting these values into equations 2.1 to 2.5, yielding:
M2 = 0.104 (3.1)
x =3.48 (3-2)
y =0.51 (3.3)
A =2.58 (3.4)
The FAV is:
eA = e2-58 = 13.2Mg/l (3.5)
The acute-chronic ratio ranges from 3 (Mercury) to 122 (Cadmium), for the 21 chemicals (see footnote 1
of Table 2.1). In other words, the acute-chronic ratios are greater than 2 for all of the chemicals studied.
The maximum value criterion, which is defined as the FAV divided by the smaller of (a) 2 or (b) the
acute-chronic ratio, may be simply defined as the FAV/2. The maximum value criterion of Lindane for
Michigan is therefore defined as:
FAV/2 = 13.2/2 = 6.6 Mg/l (3.6)
3-5
-------
In selecting the 30-day average criteria, the information presented in Table 2.1 is used. The acute-
chronic ratio is 25.0 which yields the final chronic value of 0.528 Mg/l- Comparing this value with the
available FRV of 100, the 30-day average criterion is chosen as 0.528 i*gl\. The final selection of the
30-day average criterion is indicated in the column (+ +). An "ACR" means that the value was ob-
tained by dividing the FAV with the acute-chronic ratio; "FCV" indicates that the value was calculated
from the chronic toxicity data base; "FPV" indicates that the value was the Final Plant Value; "FRV"
indicates the Final Residue Value; and "SCV'represents the value as the chronic value of important
species.
Whenever the acute toxicity data base does not meet the minimum data requirements, a star (*) is
printed next to the maximum value criterion. If the State data set contains less than four families, "* *"
is printed and the national maximum value criteria is printed as the state maximum value criterion.
The state has three options in these cases: to use the calculated value given in the table; to use the na-
tional criterion; or to conduct additional toxicity tests of additional species so that the state toxicity
data base is adequate to meet the minimum data requirements, and then calculate the criteria. For
more detailed information on meeting the minimum data requirements (so as to decide the test
species for additional tests), a state may refer to the information given in Appendix E. In Appendix E,
the state and chemical as well as the criteria of the minimum data requirements are all represented by
their ID numbers. Appendix B-1 may be used for reference.
One of the minimum data requirements is "the family Salmonidae." Salmonid fish are not
indigenous in four States: Florida, Kansas, Texas and Mississippi. The approach taken in this study
was to relieve these four states from the necessity of meeting this requirement. These four are in-
dicated by a "#" sign to the left of the state's name.
For the six chemicals (Cd, Cu, Pb, Ag, Ni and Zn) whose acute toxicity is dependent on hardness
in water, the values shown in the column "LC50 Value" and the maximum value criteria shown in the
tables of Appendices C and D refer only to the acute intercepts, that is, the value at zero hardness ef-
fect. In order to set appropriate criteria for different hardness conditions, a state should multiply the
maximum value criteria (CR) shown in Appendices C and D by the hardness dependence function:
VCR = CR x exp[v In (H)], Mg/l (3.7)
where VCR = maximum value criteria for a hardness concentration of H mg/l as CaC03
v = the mean acute slope (shown at the bottom of Table 1 of the criteria
document),
H = ambient hardness concentration in mg/l CaCO3.
Equation (3.7) may be written as:
VCR = exp[(v In (H) + z] (3.8)
3-6
-------
with
2 = In (CR) (3.9)
Table 3.2 presents a tabulation of v (the slope) and z (the log intercept) for the maximum value criteria
for the six hardness dependent chemicals.
If the state 30-day average criterion for Lead is chosen as the Final Chronic Value calculated from
the chronic toxicity data base (those noted with FCV), then the values shown in both Appendices
should be multiplied by the hardness dependence function to account for hardness variability (Equa-
tion 3.7) with v equal to 2.35 (U.S. EPA, 1980). For example, the 30-day average Lead criteria for New
York is 0.00004 exp[2.35 (In (Hardness)] which yields a value of 0.39 ngl\ for a hardness of 50 mg/l
CaCO3.
For those cases in Appendices C and D in which the tabulated 30-day average criterion for these
six chemicals is denoted by ACR (meaning the value is the quotient of the FAV divided by the acute-
chronic ratio), an adjustment must be made to reflect ambient hardness. In these cases, Equation 3.7
should be used, in which the tabulated 30-day value is substituted for CR and the result (VCR)
becomes the 30-day average criterion. For example, the 30-day average Cadmium criterion for New
York should be 0.0004 exp[1.05 In (Hardness)], where 0.0004 is taken from Appendix C or D, and 1.05 is
taken from Table 3.2. If the ambient hardness is 50 mg/l as CaCO3, the 30-day average Cadmium
criterion for New York becomes 0.0243 ngl\.
There are two chemicals (Copper and Lead) whose national 30-day average criteria are calculated
from the chronic data base. Of these, the chronic toxicity for Copper is independent of hardness
whereas Lead is dependent on hardness (see Table 2.1).
3-7
-------
Table 3.2 Values of v and z in the Maximum Value Criteria Equation
exp[v(ln(H)) +z], by State
Chemical
State
National
Alabama
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida"
Georgia
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kansas"
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi"
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas'*
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Wyoming
Cadmium
V
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.05
z
-3.61
-4.34
-4.61
-1.56
-4.20
-4.42
-3.96
-3.61
-3.08
-4.83
-4.34
-3,91
-3.96
-1.15
-3.19
-4.34
-3.19
-4.20
-3.86
-3.96
-3.77
-3.86
-2.83
-2.83
-4.71
-5.12
-4.71
-4.07
-3.86
-4.42
-3.54
-3.96
-4.27
-4.20
-4.34
-4.27
-3.96
-3.96
-4.14
-4.14
-4.34
-3.19
-4.71
-4.07
-4.07
-4.34
-4.51
-3.96
-4.71
Copper
V
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
0.94
z
-1.64
-1.98
-2.06
-2.11
-2.06
-2.02
-1.97
-1.95
-2.06
-2.06
-2.16
-1.91
-1.91
-2.02
-2.15
-1.95
-2.10
-1.89
-1.97
-1.93
-1.93
-1.97
-2.06
-2.06
-2.02
-1.90
-2.11
-1.97
-1.97
-1.90
-1.89
-1.97
-1.90
-1.93
-1.99
-2.10
-1.93
-1.97
-2.02
-1.90
-1.99
-2.11
-2.11
-1.97
-1.93
-2.15
-2.02
-1.93
-2.02
Lead
V
1.22
1,22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1,22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
1.22
z
-3.30
3.62
-1.02
-3.35
-1.02
-1.12
2.71
3.60
5.05
2.64
-1.25
-2.83
3.62
-3.35
-3.30
-2.83
-3.30
-3.30
2.17
2.17
-2.92
2.71
-3.35
-3.30
-1.25
-1.25
-1.13
2.37
2.64
-1.25
-2.92
2.64
-1.12
2.17
-2.83
-1.52
2.71
2.71
2.64
-1.12
-2.83
4.73
-1.25
2.37
2.71
-1.52
2.71
-2.92
-1.25
Nickel
V
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
0.76
z
3.49
3.45
3.15
3.37
3.15
3.06
3.50
3.50
3.43
3.40
3.00
3.55
3.51
3.44
3.40
3.45
3.37
3.56
3.50
3.50
3.52
3.44
3.45
3.45
3.08
3.15
3.08
3.50
3.50
3.22
3.56
3.50
3.16
3.50
3.45
3.08
3.52
3.50
3.44
3.23
3,45
3.43
3.08
3.50
3.56
3.00
3.44
3.52
3.08
Silver Zinc
V
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
1.72
z v
-7.54 0.83
-7.96 0.83
-9.12 0.83
-10.82 0.83
-9.12 0.83
-8.11 0.83
-9.72 0.83
-7.54 0.83
-7.54 0.83
-10.82 0.83
-8.11 0.83
- 7.80 0.83
- 7.96 0.83
- 8.47 0.83
- 7.54 0.83
-7.80 0.83
-7.54 0.83
-7.54 0.83
-7.96 0.83
~ 9.72 0.83
- 7.80 0.83
-9.12 0.83
- 10.82 0.83
-11.51 0.83
- 8.80 0.83
- 8.80 0.83
-9.43 0.83
-9.72 0.83
-7.54 0.83
-8.11 0.83
-7.80 0.83
- 7.54 0.83
-8.80 0.83
- 7.80 0.83
-8.87 0.83
-8.25 0.83
-7.96 0.83
-9.72 0.83
-7.54 0.83
-8.80 0.83
-7.80 0.83
-8.80 0.83
-8.11 0.83
-9.72 0.83
-9.72 0.83
-8.25 0.83
- 7.96 0.83
-7.80 0.83
-8.11 0.83
z
1.82
2.13
1.63
1.52
1.62
1.50
2.13
1.89
2.22
2.25
0.99
2.29
2.29
1.61
1.99
2.13
2.10
2.14
2.14
2.13
2.07
2.01
2.04
2.04
1.54
1.76
1.21
2.13
2.12
1.80
2.09
2.12
1.42
2.07
2.13
1.56
2.13
2.13
2.07
1.48
2.13
2.04
1.56
2.13
2.12
0.98
2.03
2.07
1.54
v Slope of hardness effect.
z Acute intercept.
* Use national criteria, state has less than four resident families.
** No Indigenous salmonid fish In state.
3-8
-------
SECTION 4
DISCUSSION
The minimum data requirement, which was discussed earlier, specifies toxicity test results for at
least eight different families. The intent of this requirement is to assure that the organisms considered
in a criterion calculation represent a variety of dissimilar organisms commonly found in the aquatic
environment. The calculation itself is performed on the four most sensitive of the eight families which
are required to satisfy the minimum data requirement.
Over 1,000 cases were considered in this study in order to recalculate criteria for each of 21
chemicals for each of 48 states. The minimum data requirement could not be satisfied in 97 percent of
the combinations of state and chemical examined. In some cases, the minimum data base cannot be
met. According to the literature on species distribution, for example, salmonids simply are not found
in four states: Florida, Kansas, Mississippi and Texas.
For those cases in which the minimum data base could not be satisfied, criteria were calculated
nevertheless if there was information available on at least four families. There were 16 chemicals for
which toxicity test data were available for at least four families in each state. For many states,
however, there were insufficient data for the five remaining chemicals (Arsenic, Chlordane, Endo-
sulfan, Lead and Mercury) to apply the revised methodology. When a state criterion could not be cal-
culated, the national criterion was adopted. This occurred in approximately five percent of the cases
examined.
The recalculated state maximum value criteria are compared qualitatively with the national
values in Table 4.1, and the 30-day average values are compared in Table 4.2. In examining a single
chemical, the state criteria tend to be either predominantly more stringent or predominantly less
stringent than the national value for a given pollutant. The recalculated criteria are more stringent in
65 percent of the cases.
The state-specific criteria which were calculated after removing non-resident families are
presented in Appendix C by chemical and in Appendix D by state. In each case the national criteria
and the state criteria are tabulated together with the number of families in the national data base
which are resident in a given state, and the names of the four families used to recalculate the criteria.
The national value was used as a state value whenever fewer than four families were available.
The information in these Appendices, which should be of immediate use to the states, reflects
the extent of and the limitations imposed by the national data base as constituted when this work was
done. The national data base is not a finished product by any means, however, and EPA is continually
adding new information.
For those cases in which the minimum data requirement was not satisfied, the addition of toxicity
data for new families should improve the quality of recalculated state-specific criteria. Given the large
number of combinations of state and chemical for which the minimum data requirement could not be
met, it is not likely that the national data base will soon be extensive enough to serve all the states for
all the toxic chemicals. This being the case, a state might find it expedient to run selected bioassays
in order to augment the data base for a specific pollutant. By comparing the minimum data require-
ment with the information in Appendix E, state biologists should be able readily to determine those
families for which additional tpxicity test results are indicated.
4-1
-------
Table 4.1 Comparison of National and State Maximum Value Criteria
Alabama
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida"
Georgia
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kansas'*
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi"
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas**
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Wyoming
P » E | 2 E 1
o i • £ - £ == o 2^ = %
Ilillflstllfililsllh
<
-------
Table 4.2 Comparison of National and State 30-Day Average Criteria
Alabama
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida"
Georgia
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kansas"
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi"
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas"
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Wyoming
|
c c I
in
* « __
_
4
_
_
_
4
-
-
4
_
4
4
-
4
_
-
-
-
_
4
+
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
_
-
—
4
_
_
-
4
-
—
-
—
—
—
-
s i 1
ff 5 3 £ 1 c
- i lit |H
i2iQ
44 4 - ' 4
4-4 - 4
- - 4 - 4
4-4 — —
_ _ + _ _
- 4 - 4
4 - 4 - 4
44 4 - 4
44 4 - 4
- 4 - 4 - 4
4 - 4 - 4
4 - 4 - 4
- 4 - 4
44-4
4 - 4 — 4
44-4
- 4 — 4
4 - 4
4 - 4 - 4
44 4 4
44 4 - 4
4 - - 4 - 4
- 4 - 4
4-4 - 4
44-4 - 4
4-4 - 4
44-4
4 — 4 - 4
44-4 - —
44 4 - 4
- 4 - 4
4-4 - 4
4 — 4 - 4
4444
- 4 - 4 - 4
4 - 4 — 4
- 4 — 4
44 — 4
_ _ + _ _
4 - 4 - 4
44 4 4
4-4 — 4
44 — 4
- 4 - 4
- 4 — 4 — 4
44 4 - 4
44 4 - 4
4-4 - 4
•f State 30-day average less stringent than the National value.
- State 30-day average more stringent than the National value.
• No 30-day average value.
" No resident Salmonld families.
4-3
-------
REFERENCES
Baumann, R.W., et al. "The Stoneflies (Plecoptera) of the Rocky Mountains, Memoirs of the American
Entomological Society," 30 November, 1977.
Bousfield, E. L, Freshwater Amphipod Crustaceans of Glaciated North America, The Canadian Field-
Naturalist, Volume 72, No. 2, pages 55-113, April-June, 1958.
Brinkhurst, R., and Jamminson, B., Aquatic Oligochaeta of the World, Oliver and Boyd, Edinburgh,
1971.
Brooks, J.L, The Systematics of North American Daphnia, Memoirs of the Connecticut Academy of
Arts and Sciences, Volume XIII, November, 1957.
Burks, B. D., The Mayflies or Ephemeroptera of Illinois, Bulletin of the Illinois Natural History Survey,
State of Illinois, Department of Agriculture and Education, May, 1953.
Edmunds, George F., et al. The Mayflies of North and Central America, University of Minnesota Press,
Minneapolis, 1976.
Emerson, W.K., and Jacobson, M.K., The American Museum of Natural History Guide to Shells, Alfred
A. Knopf, Inc., New York, 1976.
Fischer, F. C. J., Trichopterorum Catalogus, Volume IV, Hydropsychidae Arctopsychidae, Nederland-
sche Entomologische Vereeniging, Amsterdam, 1963.
Hobbs, H.H., Crayfishes (Astacidae) of North and Middle America, Biota of Freshwater Ecosystems
Identification Manual No. 9 for EPA, May 1972.
Holthus, L.B., A General Revision of the Palaemonidae of the Americas, II. The Subfamily
Palaemonidae, University of South California Press, Los Angeles, California, 1952.
Holsinger, J.R., The Freshwater Amphipod Crustaceans (Gammaridae) of North America, Biota of
Freshwater Ecosystems Identification Manual No. 5 for EPA, April, 1972.
Hyman, L.H., The Invertebrates, Volume VI, Mollusca I, McGraw-Hill, 1967.
Kenk, R., Personal Communication, Division of Worms, Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian In-
stitute.
Lee, D.S., et al. Atlas of North American Freshwater Fishes, North Carolina State Museum of Natural
History, 1980.
Merritt, R.W., and Cummins, K.W., An Introduction to the Aquatic Insects of North America, Third Prin-
ting, Kendall/Hunt Publishing Company, 1978 (ed.).
Pennak, R.W., Freshwater Invertebrates of the United States, John Wiley & Sons, 1978.
R-1
-------
REFERENCES (Continued)
Stark, B.P., and Gaufin, A.R., The Nearactic Genera of Perlidae (Plecoptera), Miscellaneous Publica-
tion of the Entomological Society of America, Volume 10, No. 1, 1976.
U.S. Agricultural Research Service, A Catalog of the Diptera of America North of Mexico, Agricultural
Handbook No. 276, U.S. Department of Agriculture, August 1965.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Guidelines for Deriving Site-Specific Water Quality Criteria for
the Protection of Aquatic Life and its Uses, 1982.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Ambient Water Quality Criteria for Copper, EPA 440/5-80-036,
1980.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Water Quality Criteria Documents: Availability (45FR79318, 28
November, 1980).
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Guidelines for Deriving Water Quality Criteria for the Protec-
tion of Aquatic Life (43FR21506, 18 May, 1978) and (43FR19028, 5 July, 1978).
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Water Quality Criteria Documents: Availability (44FR15926,15
March, 1979).
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Quality Criteria for Water, 1976.
Walker, E.N., The Odonata of Canada and Alaska, University of Toronto Press, 1953.
Ward, H.B. and Wipple, G.C., Freshwater Biology, Second Edition, 1972.
Williams, W. D., Freshwater Isopods (Asellidae) of North America, Biota of Freshwater Ecosystems,
Identification Manual No. 7, prepared for EPA, May, 1972.
R-2
-------
APPENDIX A
RESIDENT NORTH AMERICAN SPECIES OF AQUATIC ANIMALS USED IN TOXICITY TESTS
This Appendix identifies species of aquatic animals which have been used in toxlcity tests and
have been confirmed to be resident North American species for the purposes of the "Guidelines for
Deriving National Water Quality Criteria for the Protection of Aquatic Life and Its Uses." "North
America" includes only the 48 contiguous states, Canada, and Alaska. Species do not have to be
native to be resident. Other species should be considered resident North American species if they can
be similarly confirmed or if the test organisms were obtained from a wild population in North America.
The sequence for fishes Is taken from A List ol Common and Scientific Names of Fishes from the
United States and Canada. For other species, the sequence of phyla, classes and families Is taken
from the NODC Taxonomic Code, Third Edition, National Oceanographic Data Center, NOAA,
Washington, D.C. 20235, July, 1981, and the numbers given are from that source to facilitate verifica-
tion. Within a family, genera are in alphabetical order, as are species in a genus. An asterisk (*) beside
a common name indicates that the species is nonresident.
Freshwater Species
Class
Freshwater Species
Class
PHYLUM: PORIFERA (36)
Demospongia
3660
Sponglllidae
366301
PHYLUM: PLATYHELMINTHES (39)
Turbellaria Planarlldae
3901
Dendrocelldae
391501
PHYLUM: GASTROTRICHA (44)
Chaetonotoida Chaetonotldae
4402 440201
PHYLUM: ROTIFERA (ROTATORIA1 (45)
Bdelloldea Philodlnldae
4503 450402
Monogononta Brachionidae
4506 450601
Archlannellda Aeolosomatldae
5002 500301
Oligochaeta Lumbriculidae
5004 500501
Tubificidae
500902
Naldldae
500903
PHYLUM: MOLLUSCA (5085)
Gastropoda Vlviparidae
51 510306
Bithyniidae
(Amnicolidae)
(Bulimldae)
(Hydrobiidae)
510317
Common Name
Sponge
Planarian
Planarian*
Planarian
Gastrotrlch
Rotifer
Rotifer
Rotifer
Worm
Worm
Tubificid worm
Tubificid worm
Worm
Worm
Snail
Snail
Species
Scientific Name
Ephydatla fluvlatllls
Planarla gonocephala
Polycells felina
Procotyla fluvlatllls
(Pendrocoelum lacteum)
Lepldodermella squamatum
Phllodlna acutlcornls
Phllodlna roseola
Keratella cochlearls
Aeolosoma headleyl
Lumbrlculus varleaatus
Llmnodrllls hoffmelsterl
Tublfex tublfex
Nalssp.
Blvalvla
(Pelecypoda)
55
Pleuroceridae
510340
Lymnaeldae
Carnpeloma declsum
Amnlcola sp.
Planorbidae
511412
Physldae
511413
Margarltiferldae
551201
Unlonldae
551202
Corblculidae
551545
Plsidildae
(Sphaerildae)
551546
PHYLUM: ARTHROPOPA (58-69)
Crustacea Lyneeidae
61 610701
Sidldae
610901
Daphnldae
610902
Common Name
Snail
Snail
Snail
Snail
Snail
Snail
Snail
Snail
Snail*
Snail
Snail
Snail
Snail*
Snail
Snail
Snail
Mussel
Mussel
Asiatic clam
Asiatic clam
Fingernail clam
Fingernail clam
Fingernail clam
Conchostracan
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Species
Scientific Name
Gonlobasls llvescens
Gonlobasls vlrolnlca
Leptoxls carlnata
(Nttocrls carl natal
(Mudalla carlnata)
Nltrocrls sp.
Lvmnaea catascoplum
(Lymnaea emarglnala)
(Staonicola emarolnata)
Lymnaea elodes
(Lymnaea palustrls)
Lymnaea stagnalls
Lymnaea sp.
Blomphalarla glabrata
Gvraulus clrcumstrlatus
Hellsoma campanulatum
Aplexa hypnorum
Physa (ontlnalls
Phvsa gyrlna
Physa heterostropha
Physa Integra
Maraarltlfera
Margarltltera
Cvrtonalas tampicoenis
Corblcula flumlnea
Corblcula manllensls
Eupera cubensls
(Eupera slngleyl)
Muscullum transversum
(Sphaerlum transversum)
Sphaerlum corneum
Lynceus brachyurus
Dlaphanosoma sp.
Cerlodaphnla retlculata
A-1
-------
APPENDIX A
RESIDENT NORTH AMERICAN SPECIES OF AQUATIC ANIMALS USED IN TOXICITY TESTS
Freshwater Species
Freshwater Species
Class
Bosmlnldae
610903
Polyphemidae
610905
Cyprididae
(Cypridae)
611303
Diaptomidae
611818
Cyclopldae
612008
Asellidae
616302
Qammaridae
616921
Hyalellidae
(Talitridae)
616923
Palaemonidae
617911
Astacldae
618102
Common Name
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran*
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Cladoceran
Ostracod*
Ostracod
Copepod*
Copepod*
Copepod
Copepod
Copepod
Copepod
isopod*
Isopod
Isopod
Isopod*
Isopod
Scud
Scud
Scud
Scud,
Scud
Scud
Glass shrimp
Crayfish
Crayfish
Crayfish
Crayfish
Species
Scientific Name
Daphnia ambig.ua
Daphnia carinata
Daphnia cucullata
Daphnia aaleata mendotae
Daphnia hyallna
Daphnia longispina
Daphnia magna
Daphnia pulex
Daphnia pulicarla
Daphnia slmllis
Daphnia serrulatus
Simocephalus vetulus
Bosmina longlrostris
Polyphemus pediculus
Cypretta kawatal
Cypridopsls vldua
Eudiaptomus padanus
Cyclops abyssorum
Cyclops bicuspldatus
Cyclops vernalls
Eucvclops agllls
Mesocyclops leuckarti
Asellus aquaticus
Asellus brevlcaudus
Asellus communis
Asellus merldlanus
Asellus racovitzal
Crangonyx pseudogracilis
Gammarus fasciatus
Gammarus lacustrls
Gammarus pseudollmnaeus
Gammarus sp.
Hyalella azteca
(Hyalella knlckerbockerl)
Palaemonetes Kadlakensis
Cambarus latlmanus
Faxonella clypeatus
Orconectes llmosus
Orconectes propinquus
Species
Class
Insecta
62-65
Heptageniidae
621601
Baetldae
621602
Ephemerellidae
Caenidae
621802
Ephemerldae
622003
Llbellulldae
622601
Coenagrlonldae
(Agrlonldae)
(Coenagrlidae)
622904
Pteronarcldae
625201
Perlldae
625401
Perlodldae
625402
Dytiscidae
630506
Elmidae
(Elmlnthidae)
631604
Hydropsychldae
641804
Common Name
Crayfish
Crayfish
Crayfish
Crayfish
Crayfish
Crayfish
Crayfish
Crayfish
Mayfly
Mayfly
Mayfly
Mayfly
Mayfly
Mayfly
Mayfly
Mayfly
Mayfly
Mayfly
Mayfly
Dragonfly
Damselfly
Damselfly
Stonefly
Stonefly
Stonefly
Stonefly
Stonefly
Stonefly
Stonefly
Stonefly
Beetle
Beetle
Caddisfly
Caddlsfly
Scientific Name
Orconectes nals
Orconectes rusticus
Orconectes vlrllls
Paclfaslacus trowbrldgll
Procambarus aeutus
Procambarus clarkl
(Procambarus clarkll)
Procambarus slmulans
Procambarus sp.
Stenonema Ithaca
Stenonema rubrum
Calllbaetls sp.
Ephemeral la doddsl
Ephemerella grandls
Ephemeral la subvarla
Ephemerella sp.
Caenls dlmlnuta
Hexagenla blllneata
Hexagenla rlglda
Hexagenla sp.
Pantala hymenea
(Pantala hvmenaeal
Ischnura vertlcalls
Ischnura sp.
Pteronarcella badla
Pteronarcys callfornlca
Pteronarcys dorsata
Pteronarcys sp.
Acroneurla Ivcorlas
Acroneurla paclllca
Claassenla sabulosa
Arcvnoptervx parallela
Stenelmls sexllneala
Arctopsyche grandls
Hydropsyche bettenl
A-2
-------
APPENDIX A
RESIDENT NORTH AMERICAN SPECIES OF AQUATIC ANIMALS USED IN TOXICITY TESTS
Freshwater Species
Freshwater Species
Class Family
Brachycentrldae
641815
Ceratopogonidae
650504
Chlronomldae
650508
PHYLUM: ECTOPROCTA (BRYOZOA) (78)
Phylactolaemata Pectlnatelcldae
7817
Lophopodldae
Plumatellldae
781701
PHYLUM: CHORDATA (8388)
Agnatha
86
Ostelchthyes
8717
Petromyzontldae
860301
Angulllldae
874101
Salmonidae
875501
Esocldae
875801
Cyprlnldae
877601
Common Name
Caddlsfly
Caddisfly
Caddlsfly
Biting midge
Midge
Midge
Midge
Midge
Bryozoan
Bryozoan
Bryozoan
Sea lamprey
American eel
Pink salmon
Cocho salmon
Sockeye salmon
Chinook salmon
Golden trout
Cutthroat trout
Rainbow trout
(Steelhead trout)
Atlantic salmon
Brown trout
Brook trout
Lake trout
Northern pike.
Chlselmouth
Longfln dace
Central stoneroller
Goldfish
Common carp
Zebra danlo*
Zerbraflsh*
Golden shiner
Pugnose shiner
Emerald shiner
Striped shiner
Species
Specie*
Scientific Name
Hvdropsvche callfornlca
Hydropsyche sp.
Brachycentrus sp.
Chlronomus plumosus
Chlronomus tentans
Chlronomus sp.
Tanytarsus dlsslmulls
Pectlnatelia magnlflca
Lophopodella carterl
Plumatella emarglnata
Petromyzon marlnus
Anguilla rostrata
Oneorhynchus aorbuscha
Oncorhynchus klsutch
Oncorhvnchus nerka
Oncorhynchus tshawytscha
Salmo aquabonlta
Salmo elarkl
Salmo oalrdnerl
Salmo salar
Salmo trutta
Saivellnus fontlnalls
Salvellnus namaycush
Esox luclus
Acrochellus alutaceus
Agrosla chrvsogaster
Campostoma anomalum
Carasslus auratua
Cyprlnus carplo
Danlo rerlo
(Braehvdanlo rerla)
Notemloonus crysoleucas
Notropis anogenus
Notropla atherlnoldes
Notropis chrvsocephalus
Class
Family
Catostomldae
877604
Ictalurldae
877702
Clarlldae
877712
Cyprlnodontldae
880404
Poecillldae
880408
Gasterosteldae
881801
Perclchthyidae
Centrarchldae
883516
Common Name
Common shiner
Pugnose minnow
Spottall shiner
Red shiner
Spotfln shiner
Northern redbelly
dace
Bluntnose minnow
Fathead minnow
Northern squawflsh
Blacknose dace
Speckled dace
Rudd
Creek chub
Pearl dace
Tench
White sucker
Black bullhead
Yellow bullhead
Brown bullhead
Channel catfish
Walking catfish
Banded kllllflsh
Flagfish
Mosquitoflsh
Amazon molly
Sallfln molly
Molly
Guppy
Southern platyflsh
Brook stickleback
Threesplne
stickleback
Nlnesplne
stickleback
White perch
Striped bass
Rock bass
Green sunfish
Pumpklnseed
Orangespotted
sunfish
Blueglll
Longear sunfish
Scientific Name
Notropis cornutus
Notropis emlllae
Notropis hudsonlus
Notropis lutrensls
Notropis spectrunculus
Phoxlnus eos
Plmephales notatus
Plmephales promelas
Ptvchochellus oregonensis
Rhlnlchthys atratulus
Rhlnlchthys osculus
Scardlnlus ervthrophthalmus
Semotllus atromaculatus
Semotlius margarlta
Tinea tinea
Catostomus commersonl
Ictalurus melas
letalurus natalls
Ictalurus nebulosus
Ictalurus punclatus
Clarlas batraehus
Fundulus dlaphanus
Jordanella floridae
Gambusla afflnls
Poecllla formosa
Poecllla latlplnna
Poecllla sp.
Poecllla retlculata
Xlphophorus maculatus
Calaea Inconstans
Gasterosteus aculeatus
Pungltlus pungltlus
Morone amerlcana
Morone saxatllls
Ambloplltes rupestrls
Lepomls cyanellus
Lepomls olbbosus
Lepomls humllis
Lepomls macrochlrus
Lepomls meoalotls
A-3
-------
APPENDIX A
RESIDENT NORTH AMERICAN SPECIES OF AQUATIC ANIMALS USED IN TOXICITY TESTS
Freshwater Species
Species
Class Family Common Name Scientific Name
Redear sunfish Lepomls mlcrolophus
Smallmouth bass Micropterus dolomleul
Largemouth bass Micropterus salmoldes
Black crapple Promoxls nlgromaculatus
Percidae Rainbow darter Etheostoma caeruleum
Johnny darter Etheostoma nigfum
Orangethroat darter Etheostoma spactablle
Yellow perch Perca flavescens
Walleye Stlzostedlon vllreum vllreum
Sciaenldae Freshwater drum Aplodlnotus arunnlens
883554
Cichlidae Mozambique Tllapla mossamblca
883561 tilapla
Cottldae Mottled sculpln Cottus balrdl
883102
A-4
-------
ID NUMBER
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
APPENDIX B-1
STATE IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
STATE
NATIONAL
MAINE
NEW HAMPSHIRE
VERMONT
MASSACHUSETTS
RHODE ISLAND
CONNECTICUT
NEW YORK
PENNSYLVANIA
NEW JERSEY
DELAWARE
MARYLAND
VIRGINIA
NORTH CAROLINA
SOUTH CAROLINA
GEORGIA
FLORIDA
WEST VIRGINIA
KENTUCKY
TENNESSEE
ALABAMA
OHIO
MICHIGAN
INDIANA
MISSISSIPPI
WISCONSIN
ILLINOIS
MINNESOTA
IOWA
MISSOURI
ARKANSAS
LOUISIANA
NORTH DAKOTA
SOUTH DAKOTA
NEBRASKA
KANSAS
OKLAHOMA
TEXAS
MONTANA
WYOMING
COLORADO
NEW MEXICO
IDAHO
UTAH
ARIZONA
WASHINGTON
OREGON
NEVADA
CALIFORNIA
ID NUMBER
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
APPENDIX B-2
FAMILY IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
FAMILY
CRYPTOMONADIDAE
AMOEBIDAE
PARAMECIIDAE
SPIROSTOMATIDAE (SPIROSTOMATIDAE)
PLANARMDAE
CHAETONOTIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
AEOLOSOMATIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
NAIDIDAE
VIVIPARIDAE
BtTHYNIIDAE (BULIMIDAE) (HYDROBItDAE)
PLEUROCERIDAE
LYMNAEIDAE
PLANORBIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PISIDIIDAE (SPHAERIIDAE)
LYNCEIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
POLYPHEMIDAE
CYPRIDIDAE(CYPRIDAE)
DIAPTOMIDAE
CYCLOPIDAE
ASELLIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
PALAEMONIDAE
ASTACIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
EPHEMERIDAE (BAETIDAE)
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGRIONIDAE)
PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
HYDROPSYCHIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PETROMYZONTIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ESOCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CLARIIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
POECILIIDAE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SCIAENIDAE
CICHLIDAE
COTTIDAE
RANIDAE
MICROHYLIDAE
BUFONIDAE
HYLIDAE
AMBYSTOMATIDAE
SALAMANDRIDAE
B-1
-------
APPENDIX B-3
SPECIES IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS AND FAMILY CLASSIFICATION
FAMILY ID SPECIES ID
NUMBER NUMBER SPECIES NAME
5 1.00 PLANARIAN (POLYCELIS FELINA)
7 2.00 ROTIFER (PHILODINA ACUTICORNIS)
7 3.00 ROTIFER (PHILODINA ROSEOLA)
10 4.00 BRISTLEWORM (NAIS SP.)
9 4.25 TUBIFICID WORM (TUBIFEX TUBIFEX)
9 4.50 WORM (LIMNODRILUS HOFFMEISTERI)
12 5.00 SNAIL (AMNICOLA SP.)
11 6.00 SNAIL (CAMPELOMA DECISUM)
15 7.00 SNAIL (GYRAULUS CIRCUMSTRIATUS)
14 8.00 SNAIL (LYMNAEA PALUSTRIS)
16 9.00 SNAIL (PHYSA HETEROSTROPHA)
16 10.00 SNAIL (PHYSA INTEGRA)
16 11.00 SNAIL (PHYSA SP.)
17 11.50 FINGERNAIL CLAM (MUSCULIUM TRANSVERSUM)
19 1200 CLADOCERAN (DAPHNIA CARINATA)
19 13.00 CLADOCERAN (DAPHNIA MAGNA)
19 14.00 CLADOCERAN (DAPHNIA PULEX)
19 15.00 CLADOCERAN (DAPHNIA PULICARIA)
19 16.00 CLADOCERAN (SIMOCEPHALUS SERRULATUS)
21 17.00 SEED SHRIMP (CYPRIDOPSIS VIDUA)
23 18.00 COPEPOD (UNIDENTIFIED)
24 19.00 ISOPOD (ASELLUS BREVICAUDUS)
24 20.00 ISOPOD (ASELLUS COMMUNIS)
25 21.00 SCUD (GAMMARUS FASCIATUS)
25 22.00 SCUD (GAMMARUS LACUSTRIS)
25 23.00 SCUD (GAMMARUS PSEUDOLIMNAEUS)
25 24.00 SCUD (GAMMARUS SP.)
26 25.00 SCUD (HYALLELA AZTECA)
28 26.00 CRAYFISH (FAXONELLA CLYPEATA)
28 27.00 CRAYFISH (ORCONECTES NAIS)
28 28.00 CRAYFISH (ORCONECTES LIMOSUS)
28 29.00 CRAYFISH (ORCONECTES RUSTICUS)
28 30.00 CRAYFISH (PROCAMBARUS ACUTUS)
27 31.00 GLASS SHRIMP (PALAEMONETES KADIAKENSIS)
29 32.00 MAYFLY (EPHEMERELLA GRANDIS)
29 33.00 MAYFLY (EPHEMERELLA SUBVARIA)
30 34.00 MAYFLY (HEXAGENIA BILINEATA)
33 35.00 STONEFLY (ACRONEURIA LYCORIUS)
33 36.00 STONEFLY (ACRONEURIA PACIFICA)
33 37.00 STONEFLY (CLAASSENNIA SABULOSA)
32 38.00 STONEFLY (PTERONARCELLA BADIA)
32 39.00 STONEFLY (PTERONARCYS CALIFORNIA)
31 40.00 DAMSELFLY (ISCHNURA VERTICALUS)
31 41.00 DAMSELFLY (ISCHNURA SP.)
31 42.00 DAMSELFLY (UNIDENTIFIED)
35 43.00 MIDGE (CHIRONOMUS PLUMOSUS)
35 44.00 MIDGE (CHIRONOMUS TENTANS)
35 45.00 MIDGE (CHIRONOMUS SP.)
35 46.00 MIDGE (TANYTARSUS DISSIMILIS)
35 47.00 MIDGE (UNIDENTIFIED)
34 48.00 CADDISFLY (ARCTOPSYCHE GRANDIS)
34 49.00 CADDISFLY (CLISTORONIA MAGNIFICA)
34 50.00 CADDISFLY (HYDROPSYCHE BETTENI)
34 51.00 CADDISFLY (HYDROPSYCHE CALIFORNICA)
34 52.00 CADDISFLY (UNIDENTIFIED)
37 53.00 AMERICAN EEL (ANGUILLA ROSTRATA)
38 54.00 COHO SALMON (ONCORHYNCHUS KISUTCH)
FAMILY ID SPECIES ID
NUMBER NUMBER SPECIES NAME
38 55.00 SOCKEYE SALMON (ONCORHYNCHUS NERKA)
38 55.50 PINK SALMON (ONCORHYNCHUS GORBUSCHA)
38 56.00 CHINOOK SALMON (ONCORHYNCHUS TSHAWYTSCHA)
38 57.00 CUTTHROAT TROUT (SALMO CLARKI)
38 58.00 RAINBOW TROUT (SALMO GAIRDNERI)
38 59.00 ATLANTIC SALMON (SALMO SALAR)
38 60.00 BROWN TROUT (SALMO TRUTTA)
38 60.50 GOLDEN TROUT (SALMO AGUABONITA)
38 61.00 BROOK TROUT (SALVELINUS FONTINALIS)
38 62.00 LAKE TROUT (SALVELINUS NAMAYCUSH)
38 62.50 SISCOWET (SALVELINUS NAMAYCUSH SISCOWET)
39 63.00 NORTHERN PIKE (ESOX LUCIUS)
52 64.00 MOTTLED SCULPIN (COTTUS BAIRDI)
52 64.40 SLIMY SCULPIN (COTTUS COGNATUS)
40 65.00 LONGFIN DACE (AGOSIA CHRYSOGASTER)
40 66.00 STONEROLLER (CAMPOSTOMA ANOMALUM)
40 67.00 GOLDFISH (CARASSIUS AURATUS)
40 68.00 CARP (CYPRINUS CARPIO)
40 69.00 GOLDEN SHINER (NOTEMIGONUS CRYSOLEUCAS)
40 69.50 SPOTFIN SHINER (NOTROPIS SPILOPTERUS)
40 70.00 STRIPED SHINER (NOTROPIS CHRYSOCEPHALUS)
40 70.50 RED SHINER (NOTROPIS LUTRENSIS)
40 71.00 NORTHERN REDBELLY DACE (PHOXINUS EOS)
40 72.00 BLUNTNOSE MINNOW (PIMEPHALES NOTATUS)
40 73.00 FATHEAD MINNOW (PIMEPHALES PROMELAS)
40 73.50 NORTHERN SQAUWFISH (PTYCHOCHEILUS OREGONENSIS)
40 74.00 BLACKNOSE DACE (RHINICHTHYS ATRATULUS)
40 75.00 SPECKLED DACE (RHINICHTHYS OSCULUS)
40 76.00 CREEK CHUB (SEMOTILUS ATROMACULATUS)
41 76.50 LONGNOSE SUCKER (CATOSTOMUS CATOSTOMUS)
41 77.00 WHITE SUCKER (CATOSTOMUS COMMERSONI)
42 78.00 BLACK BULLHEAD (ICTALURUS MELAS)
42 79.00 BROWN BULLHEAD (ICTALURUS NEBULOSUS)
42 80.00 CHANNEL CATFISH (ICTALURUS PUNCTATUS)
44 81.00 BANDED KILLIFISH (FUNDULUS DIAPHANUS)
44 82.00 FLAGFISH (JORDANELLA FLORIDAE)
45 83.00 MOSQUITOFISH (GAMBUSIA AFFINIS)
45 84.00 GUPPY (POECILIA RETICULATA)
45 85.00 SOUTHERN PLATYFISH (XIPHOPHORUS MACULATUS)
46 86.00 BROOK STICKLEBACK (CULAEAINCONSTANS)
46 87.00 THREESPINE STICKLEBACK (GASTEROSTEUS ACULEATUS)
47 88.00 WHITE PERCH (MORONE AMERICANA)
47 89.00 STRIPED BASS (MORONE SAXATILIS)
48 90.00 ROCK BASS (AMBLOPLITES RUPESTRIS)
4° 91-00 GREEN SUNFISH (LEPOMIS CYANELLUS)
4? 92.00 PUMPKINSEED (LEPOMIS GIBBOSUS)
48 93.00 BLUEGILL (LEPOMIS MACROCHIRUS)
48 94.00 LONGEAR SUNFISH (LEPOMIS MEGALOTIS)
48 95.00 REDEAR SUNFISH (LEPOMIS MICROLOPHUS)
48 96.00 SMALLMOUTH BASS (MICROPTERUS DOLOMIEUI)
48 97.00 LARGEMOUTH BASS (MICROPTERUS SALMOIDES)
48 98.00 BLACK CRAPPIE (POMOXIS NIGROMACULATUS)
49 99.00 RAINBOW DARTER (ETHEOSTOMA CAERULEUM)
49 100.00 ORANGETHROAT DARTER (ETHEOSTOMA SPECTABILE)
J9 101.00 YELLOW PERCH (PERCA FLAVESCENS)
49 102.00 WALLEYE (STIZOSTEDION VITREUM VITREUM)
50 103.00 FRESHWATER DRUM (APLODINOTUS GRUNNIENS)
B-2
-------
APPENDIX B-4
RESIDENT SPECIES, BY STATE
STATE
ALABAMA
ARIZONA
ARKANSAS
CALIFORNIA
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
FLORIDA
GEORGIA
IPAHO
NUMBER
OF SPECIES
54
50
57
54
64
53
51
39
51
62
2.00
10.00
25.00
45.00
67.00
76.00
90.00
98.00
2.00
13.00
25.00
43.00
60.00
75.00
92.00
4.90
2.00
10.00
23.00
34.00
93.00
70.00
80.00
66.00
4.90
2.00
13.00
25.00
47.00
57.00
69.00
85.00
97.00
2.00
10,00
16.00
37.00
47.00
(2.00
75.00
96.00
2.00
9.00
21.00
43.00
59.00
73.00
88.00
101.00
2.00
9.00
21.00
41.00
60.00
79.00
91.00
102.00
2.00
10.00
26.00
92.00
82.00
97.00
2.00
10.00
26.00
47.00
(1.00
78.00
93.00
102.00
2.00
13.00
25.00
43.00
SPECIES IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
3.00
11.00
26.00
47.00
68.00
77.00
91.00
99.00
3.00
14.00
32.00
49.00
61.00
78.00
93.00
3.00
11.00
24.00
40.00
60.00
72.00
63.00
97.00
3.00
14.00
32.00
48.00
58.00
73.00
87.00
98.00
3.00
11.00
20.00
38.00
48.00
84.00
76.00
97.00
3.00
10.00
24.00
45.00
60.00
74.00
89.00
102.00
3.00
10.00
24.00
43.00
87.00
80.00
92.00
4.60
3.00
11.09
28.00
53.00
83.00
98.00
3.00
11.00
30.00
60.00
67.00
79.00
94.00
4.50
3.00
14.00
32.00
44.00
4.00
14.00
30.00
52.00
69.00
78.00
93.00
102.00
4.00
15.00
36.00
47.00
65.00
80.00
96.00
4.00
14.00
25.00
41.00
04.00
73.00
90.00
98.00
4.00
15.00
36.00
51.00
60.00
75.00
88.00
102.00
4.00
12.00
22.00
39.00
52.00
66.00
77.00
08.00
4.00
11.00
25.00
47.00
61.00
76.00
92.00
4.90
4.00
11.00
29.00
45.00
68.00
81.00
93.00
4.00
14.00
30.00
97.00
84.00
102.00
4.00
14.00
32.00
92.00
98.00
80.00
96.00
4.00
15.00
36.00
45.00
5.00
15.00
31.00
53.00
70.00
79.00
94.00
103.00
7.00
16.00
37.00
52.00
67.00
83.00
97.00
5.00
16.00
26.00
43.00
66.00
76.00
91.00
99.00
7.00
16.00
37 JO
52.00
61.00
78.00
91.00
4.50
5.00
13.00
24.00
41.00
55.00
67XK)
78.00
102.00
5.00
14.00
28.00
52.00
62.00
77.00
93.00
5.00
14.00
28.00
47.00
68.00
83.00
98.00
5.00
15.00
41.00
68.00
85.00
4.90
6.00
15.00
40X10
53.00
69.00
83.00
96.00
7.00
18.00
37.00
47.00
7.00
16.00
40.00
58.00
72.00
80.00
95.00
4.50
8.00
18.00
38.00
55.00
66.00
84.00
96.00
7.00
16.00
27.00
45.00
67.00
77.00
93.00
100.00
6.00
18.00
41.00
54.00
62.00
80.00
92.00
49.00
7.00
14.00
26.00
43.00
57.00
88.00
80.00
4.60
6,00
15.00
32.00
53.00
67.00
79.00
86.00
6.00
15.00
30.00
62.00
74.00
B7XO
97.00
7.00
16.00
43.00
69.00
89.00
7.00
16.00
41.00
68.00
74.00
89.00
87.00
6.00
18.00
38.00
48.00
8.00
18.00
41.00
64.00
73.00
63.00
96.00
11.00
22.00
39.00
67.00
69.00
89.00
101.00
8.00
18.00
30.00
47.00
68.00
78.00
94.00
102.00
11.00
22.00
43.00
55.00
67.00
83.00
93.00
8.00
15.00
32.00
44.00
68.00
71.00
91.00
7.00
16.00
40.00
68.00
88.00
81.00
97.00
7.00
16.00
32.00
93.00
76.00
88.00
88.00
8.00
17.00
46.00
79.00
93.00
8.00
18.00
43.00
81.00
76.00
90.00
98.00
11.00
22.00
39.00
51.00
9.00
24.00
43.00
68.00
74.00
89.00
97.00
12.00
24.00
41.00
58.00
73.00
91.00
102.00
9.00
19.00
31.00
62.00
69.00
79.00
99.00
103.00
12.00
24.00
49.00
59.00
68.00.
84.00
98.00
9X10
16.00
36.00
49.00
60.00
73.00
93.00
8.00
18.00
41.00
98.00
69X0
87.00
98,00
8XM)
18.00
40.00
58.00
77.00
89X0
101 XX)
9.00
18X10
47,00
80.00
99X10
9.00
25.00
45.00
84.00
77X10
91X10
99.00
12.00
24.00
41.00
92.00
STATE
IDAHO
(CONTINUED)
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
NUMBER
OF SPECIES
52
72
64
59
49
57
48
55
62
59.00
84.00
91.00
102.00
2.00
10.00
19.00
31.00
45.00
58.00
88.00
77.00
89.00
96.00
103.00
2,00
10.00
24.00
44.00
96.00
68.00
77.00
90.00
97.00
4.50
2.00
10.00
23.00
41X10
53.00
72.00
80X10
94.00
102.00
2.00
10.00
25.00
49.00
69.00
83.00
97.00
2.00
10.00
23.00
43.00
84.00
73.00
63.00
98.00
4.50
2.00
10.00
25.00
45.00
68.00
79.00
99.00
2.00
9.00
20.00
32.00
52.00
88.00
79.00
96.00
2.00
9.00
18.00
32.00
52X10
68.00
76.00
88.00
98.00
SPECIES IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
56.00
87.00
92.00
4.50
3.00
11.00
21.00
33.00
47X10
60.00
89.00
78.00
90.00
97.00
4.50
3.00
11.00
26.00
45.00
58.00
89.00
78.00
91.00
98.00
3X10
11.00
24.00
43.00
60.00
73.00
81.00
96.00
103.00
3.00
11.00
27.00
47.00
72.00
89.00
98.00
3.00
11.00
24.00
45.00
86.00
74.00
89.00
97.00
3.00
11.00
26.00
47.00
89.00
80.00
97.00
3.00
10.00
22.00
35XH)
93.00
89X10
81.00
97.00
3.00
10.00
20.00
34.00
93.00
87.00
77XKJ
69.00
97.00
57.00
68.00
93.00
73.50
4.00
14.00
23.00
34.00
90.00
62.00
70.00
79.00
91X10
98.00
4.00
14.00
29.00
47.00
60.00
70,00
79.00
92.00
99.00
4.00
14.00
25.00
44.00
63.00
74.00
83.00
97.00
4.50
4.00
12.00
30.00
52.00
73X10
90.00
100.00
4.00
14.00
25.00
47.00
67.00
76.00
90.00
96.00
4.00
14.00
30.00
52.00
70.00
83.00
98.00
4.00
11.00
24.00
40.00
54.00
71.00
88.00
96.00
4.00
11.00
21.00
40.00
64.00
88.00
78.00
90.00
98.00
98.00
73.00
98.00
5.00
15.00
24.00
40.00
52.00
63.00
72XW
80.00
92.00
99.00
5.00
15.00
30.00
60.00
62.00
72.00
80.00
93.00
100.00
5.00
15.00
29.00
45.00
66,00
76.00
88.00
98.00
9.00
1400
40.00
53.00
76.00
91.00
101X10
9.00
15.00
29.00
62.00
88.00
77.00
91.00
99.00
9.00
19.00
31.00
63.00
72.00
89.00
102.00
5.00
14.00
29.00
41.00
59.00
73X10
87XX)
101X10
6.00
14.00
24.00
41.00
68.00
64.00
79.00
91.00
101.00
60.00
75.00
97.00
7.00
16.00
25.00
41.00
53.00
64.00
73.00
81.00
93.00
100.00
7.00
16.00
40.00
52.00
64.00
73.00
81.00
94.00
101.00
7.00
16.00
30.00
46.00
67.00
77.00
90.00
99.00
700
15.00
41.00
86.00
77.00
93.00
102.00
7X»
16.00
30.00
53.00
89.00
78.00
93.00
100.00
7.00
16.00
34.00
54.00
73.00
91.00
103.00
8.00
19.00
28.00
43.00
80.00
74.00
88.00
102.00
6.00
15X10
25.00
43.00
60.00
72.00
81.00
82.00
102.00
61.00
78.00
98.00
8.00
17.00
29.00
43.00
94.00
66.00
74.00
83.00
94.00
101.00
8.00
18.00
41.00
53.00
88.00
74,00
88.00
95.00
102.00
8.00
18.00
31XX)
47.00
68.00
78.00
91.00
109.00
8.00
18.00
43.00
67.00
78.00
94.00
103.00
8.00
18X0
40X10
58.00
70.00
79.00
94.00
102.00
8X10
17.00
41.00
66.00
76.00
93.00
4.50
7.00
16.00
29.00
45.00
61.00
76.00
89.00
4.90
7.00
16.00
26.00
45.00
61.00
73.00
83.00
93.09
4.90
62.00
83.00
101.00
9.00
18.00
30.00
44.00
58.00
67.00
76.00
86.00
95.00
102.00
9.00
21.00
43.00
54.00
87.00
76.00
89.00
96.00
103.00
9.00
21.00
40.00
92.00
69.00
79.00
93.00
101.00
9.00
18.00
44.00
88.00
80.00
96.00
4.50
9,00
19.00
41.00.
60.00
72.00
60X10
96.00
10300
9.00
18.00
43X10
87.00
78.00
94.00
8.00
18.00
30.00
47X10
62.00
77.00
92.00
8.00
17X10
30.00
47.00
64.00
74.00
87.00
94.00
MASSACHUSETTS
B-3
-------
APPENDIX B-4
RESIDENT SPECIES. BY STATE
NUMBER
STATE Of SPECIES
MASSACHUSETTS 61
(CONTINUED)
MICHIGAN 72
MINNESOTA 64
MISSISSIPPI 66
MISSOURI 59
MONTANA 58
NEBRASKA S3
NEVADA 49
NEW HAMPSHIRE 52
9.00
18.00
30.00
52.00
62.00
76.00
87.00
97.00
2.00
10.00
21.00
31.00
44.00
56.00
67.00
74.00
83,00
96.00
103.00
2.00
10.00
22.00
43.00
52.00
63.00
73.00
81.00
96.00
450
2.00
10.00
19.00
34.00
53.00
72.00
8600
96.00
2.00
10.00
24.00
41.00
60.00
70.00
80.00
94.00
102.00
2.00
10.00
17.00
37.00
47.00
61.00
73.00
93.00
4.50
2.00
10.00
18.00
52.00
67.00
76.00
91.00
101.00
2.00
13.00
25.00
45.00
61.00
84.00
4.50
2.00
8.00
18.00
41.00
59.00
73.00
SPECIES IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
10.00
20.00
32.00
53.00
67.00
77.00
£8.00
9800
3.00
11.00
22.00
32.00
45.00
58.00
68.00
76.00
86.00
07.00
4.50
3.00
11.00
24.00
44.00
53.00
66.00
74.00
83.00
97.00
3.00
11.00
23.00
40.00
64.00
73.00
69.00
97.00
3.00
11.00
25.00
43.00
63.00
72.00
83.00
95.00
103.00
3.00
11.00
18.00
38.00
52.00
62.00
76.00
96.00
73.50
3.00
11.00
25.00
53.00
68.00
77.00
92.00
102.00
300
14.00
32.00
47.00
67.00
85.00
73.50
3.00
9.00
22.00
43.00
60.00
74.00
11.00
21.00
40.00
55.00
68.00
78.00
89.00
101.00
4.00
14.00
23.00
33.00
47.00
60.00
69.00
77.00
90.00
98.00
4.00
14.00
25.00
45.00
56.00
67.00
76.00
66.00
98.00
4.00
14.00
24.00
41.00
66.00
76.00
9000
98.00
4.00
14.00
27.00
44.00
64.00
73.00
69.00
98.00
450
4.00
12.00
22.00
39.00
54.00
83.00
77.00
97.00
4.00
12.00
40.00
58.00
89.00
78.00
93X10
103.00
4.00
15.00
36.00
52.00
88.00
81,00
4900
• 4.00
10.00
24.00
45.00
61.00
76.00
14.00
24.00
41.00
56.00
89.00
79.00
90.00
102.00
5.00
15.00
24.00
35.00
50.00
61.00
70.00
78.00
91.00
99.00
5.00
15.00
29.00
46.00
58.00
68.00
77.00
90.00
99.00
5.00
15.00
25.00
43.00
67.00
78.00
91.00
99.00
5.00
15.00
30.00
45.00
68.00
76.00
90.00
97.00
5.00
13.00
24.00
41.00
55.00
67.00
78.00
98.00
5.00
13.00
41.00
80.00
71.00
79.00
96.00
4.50
7.00
16.00
38.00
55.00
75.00
93.00
5.00
11.00
25.00
47.00
6200
77.00
15.00
25.00
43.00
59.00
71.00
60.00
92.00
4.50
7.00
16.00
25.00
40.00
52.00
62.00
71.00
79.00
92.00
100.00
7.00
16.00
30.00
47.00
60.00
69.00
78.00
91.00
101.00
7.00
16.00
26.00
45.00
68.00
79.00
93.00
102.00
7.00
16.00
31.00
47.00
67.00
77.00
91.00
98.00
7.00
14.00
25.00
43.00
57.00
68.00
80.00
101.00
7.00
14.00
43.00
61.00
72.00
80.00
97.00
8.00
18.00
41.00
57.00
78.00
96.00
6.00
14.00
28.00
52.00
68.00
79.00
16.00
28.00
45.00
60.00
73.00
81.00
93.00
800
17.00
29.00
41.00
53.00
64.00
72.00
80.00
93.00
101.00
8.00
18.00
40.00
50.00
61.00
71.00
79.00
93.00
102.00
8.00
17.00
30.00
47.00
69.00
80.00
94.00
103.00
8.00
17.00
34.00
52.00
68.00
78.00
92.00
99.00
8.00
15.00
32.00
44.00
58.00
69.00
91.00
102.00
6.00
15.00
45.00
63.00
73.00
86.00
98.00
11.00
22.00
43.00
58.00
80.00
97X10
7.00
15.00
32.00
53.00
69.00
81.00
17.00
29.00
47.00
61.00
74.00
86.00
96.00
9X10
18.00
30.00
43.00
54.00
66.00
73.00
81.00
94.00
102.00
9.00
21.00
41.00
51.00
62.00
72.00
80,00
94.00
103.00
9.00
16.00
31.00
52.00
70.00
83.00
95.00
4.50
9.00
18.00
40.00
53.00
69.00
79.00
93.00
100.00
9X10
16.00
36.00
45.00
60.00
71X10
92.00
103.00
9.00
16.00
47.00
66.00
74.00
89.00
100.00
12.00
24.00
44.00
60.00
83.00
101.00
16.00
40.00
58.00
71.00
88.00
NUMBER
STATE OF SPECIES
NEW HAMPSHIRE 52
(CONTINUED)
NEW JERSEY 54
NEW MEXICO 61
NEW YORK 74
NORTH CAROLINA 53
NORTH DAKOTA 51
OHIO 68
OKLAHOMA 56
OREGON 52
PENNSYLVANIA 69
88.00
98.00
2.00
900
20.00
41.00
60.00
76.00
68.00
97.00
2.00
10.00
18.00
37.00
48.00
61.00
73.00
66.00
97.00
2.00
9.00
18.00
30.00
45.00
60.00
68.00
76.00
86.00
93.00
101.00
2.00
9.00
21.00
43.00
61.00
77.00
90.00
88.00
2.00
10.00
16.00
45.00
66.00
77.00
91.00
103.00
2.00
10.00
21X10
40.00
50.00
83.00
72.00
80.00
93.00
100.00
2.00
10.00
22.00
31.00
52.00
70.00
83.00
96.00
2.00
13.00
24.00
44.00
56.00
84.00
92.00
4.50
2.00
9.00
20.00
SPECIES IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
89.00
101.00
3.00
10.00
21.00
43.00
81.00
77.00
89.00
98.00
3.00
11.00
22.00
38.00
52.00
64.00
75.00
69.00
98.00
3.00
10.00
21.00
31.00
47X10
61.00
69.00
77.00
87.00
94.00
102.00
3X10
10.00
24.00
45.00
66.00
78.00
91.00
101.00
3.00
11.00
22.00
47.00
69.00
78.00
93.00
4.50
3X10
11.00
24.00
41.00
52.00
64.00
73.00
81.00
94.00
101.00
3.00
11.00
23.00
40.00
53.00
73.00
89.00
97.00
3.00
14.00
25.00
46.00
56XX)
67.00
93.00
73.50
3.00
10X10
21.00
90.00
102.00
4.00
11.00
24.00
45.00
62.00
79.00
90.00
101X10
4.00
12.00
24.00
39.00
53.00
65.00
76.00
91.00
101.00
4.00
11X10
22.00
32.00
52.00
82.00
70.00
78.00
88.00
95.00
103.00
4.00
11.00
25.00
47.00
67.00
79.00
92.00
102.00
4.00
12.00
24.00
52.00
71.00
79.00
96.00
4.00
14.00
26.00
43.00
53.00
68.00
74.00
83.00
95.00
102.00
4.00
12.00
24.00
41.00
58.00
73.00
90.00
98.00
4.00
15.00
32.00
47.00
67.00
68.00
96.00
49.00
4.00
11.00
24X10
92.00
4.50
9.00
14.00
25.00
47.00
67.00
80.00
91.00
102.00
5.00
13.00
25.00
41.00
55.00
66.00
77.00
93.00
102.00
6.00
14.00
23.00
35.00
53.00
63.00
71.00
79.00
89.00
96.00
4.50
5X10
14XU
30.00
52.00
68.00
81.00
93.00
4.50
5X10
13.00
25.00
56.00
72.00
80.00
97.00
5.00
15.00
29.00
44.00
56.00
67.00
76.00
88.00
88.00
103.00
5.00
14.00
25.00
43.00
66.00
76.00
61.00
100.00
7.00
ie.00
36.00
48.00
58.00
75.00
97.00
5,00
14X10
25.00
93.00
6.00
15.00
30.00
52.00
68.00
81.00
92.00
4.50
7.00
14.00
29.00
43.00
57.00
67X10
78X10
94.00
4.50
6.00
15.00
24.00
40.00
58.00
64.00
72.00
80.00
90.00
97.00
6.00
15.00
32.00
53X10
69.00
63.00
95.00
7XK)
14.00
41.00
63.00
73.00
81.00
98.00
7XIO
16.00
30.00
45.00
60.00
68.00
77Xffl
90.00
97.00
4.50
7.00
15XX>
26.00
45.00
67.00
78XK)
93.00
102X10
8.00
17X10
38.00
51.00
60.00
87.00
98.00
6.00
15.00
28.00
96.00
7.00
16.00
32.00
53.00
69.00
83.00
93.00
8X10
16.00
32.00
45.00
58.00
68,00
80.00
95.00
7.00
16.00
25.00
41.00
58.00
66.00
73.00
81.00
91.00
98.00
700
16.00
40.00
sa.oo
74.00
88.00
96.00
8.00
18.00
43.00
66.00
74.00
86.00
101.00
8.00
17.00
31.00
46.00
61.00
69.00
78.00
91.00
98.00
8.00
ie.oo
27JX)
46.00
68.00
79.00
94.00
103.00
11.00
18.00
41.00
52.00
61.00
89.00
101.00
7.00
16.00
30.00
97.00
8.00
18.00
40.00
58.00
74.00
87.00
98.00
9.00
18.00
36.00
47.00
60.00
69.00
83.00
96.00
8.00
17.00
2800
43.00
59.00
67.00
74.00
83.00
92.00
99.00
8.00
18.00
41X10
60.00
76.00
89.00
97.00
9.00
16.00
44.00
67.00
76.00
90.00
102.00
9X10
18.00
35X10
47.00
62.00
70.00
79.00
92.00
99.00
9.00
18.00
30.00
47X10
69.00
80.00
9S.OO
4.50
12X10
22X10
43.00
54.00
62.00
81.00
102.00
8.00
18X10
31.00
B-4
-------
APPENDIX B-4
RESIDENT SPECIES, BY STATE
NUMBER
STATE OF SPECIES
PENNSYLVANIA
(CONTINUED)
RHODE ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
SOUTH DAKOTA
TENNESSEE
TEXAS
UTAH
VERMONT
VIRGINIA
WASHINGTON
69
53
50
53
58
51
52
55
56
SO
32.00
50.00
62.00
70.00
79.00
90.00
97.00
2.00
9.00
21.00
41.00
58.00
69.00
87.00
98.00
2.00
9.00
18.00
43.00
66.00
79.00
93.00
4.50
2.00
10.00
18.00
43.00
63.00
73.00
86.00
101.00
2.00
10.00
23.00
41.00
60.00
72.00
80.00
9500
103.00
2.00
10.00
18.00
41.00
66.00
80.00
95.00
103.00
2.00
13.00
24.00
41.00
52.00
64.00
80.00
101.00
2.00
9.00
20.00
40.00
59.00
68.00
79.00
96.00
2.00
9.00
21.00
35.00
53.00
69.00
81.00
95.00
. 2.00
13.00
22.00
SPECIES IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
33.00
62.00
63.00
71.00
80.00
91.00
98.00
3.00
10.00
24.00
43.00
59.00
73.00
88.00
101.00
3.00
10.00
25.00
4500
67.00
81.00
95.00
3.00
11.00
22.00
45.00
66.00
74.00
90.00
102.00
3.00
11.00
24.00
43.00
64.00
73.00
83.00
98.00
4.50
3.00
11.00
25.00
43.00
67.00
83.00
98.00
4.50
3.00
14.00
25.00
43.00
55.00
67.00
89.00
102.00
3.00
10.00
21.00
41.00
58.00
69.00
81.00
97.00
3.00
10.00
24.00
40.00
58.00
72.00
88.00
98.00
3.00
14.00
24.00
40.00
53.00
64.00
73.00
81.00
92.00
99.00
4.00
11.00
25.00
45.00
60.00
74.00
89.00
102.00
4.00
11.00
26.00
47.00
68.00
83.00
98.00
4.00
12.00
24.00
47.00
67.00
76.00
91.00
103.00
4.00
14.00
25.00
'45.00
66.00
74.00
89.00
97.00
4.00
12.00
26.00
45.00
684)0
84.00
97.00
4.00
15.00
32.00
44.00
57.00
68.00
91.00
4.50
4.00
11.00
22.00
43.00
59.00
71.00
86.00
98.00
4.00
11.00
25.00
41.00
60.00
73.00
89.00
07.00
4.00
15.00
25.00
41.00
55.00
66.00
74.00
86.00
93.00
101.00
5.00
14.00
28.00
47.00
61.00
76.00
92.00
4.50
5.00
14.00
30.00
52.00
69.00
88.00
97.00
5.00
13.00
25.00
52.00
68.00
77.00
93.00
4.50
5.00
15.00
30.00
47.00
67.00
76.00
90.00
98.00
5.00
14.00
27.00
46.00
69.00
89.00
96.00
70)
16.00
36.00
45.00
58.00
73.00
93.00
5.00
14.00
24.00
45.00
60.00
73.00
86.00
101.00
5.00
14.00
28.00
43.00
61.00
74.00
90.00
98.00
7X10
16.00
32.00
43.00
58.00
67.00
76.00
87.00
64.00
102.00
6.00
15.00
30.00
52.00
62.00
77.00
93.00
6.00
15.00
32.00
53.00
74.00
89.00
98.00
7.00
14.00
38.00
53.00
69.00
78.00
96.00
7.00
16.00
31.00
52.00
68.00
77.00
91.00
99.00
7.00
15.00
30.00
47.00
73.00
91.00
100.00
8.00
17.00
37.00
47.00
60.00
75.00
96.00
6.00
15.00
25.00
47.00
61.00
74X10
90.00
102.00
6.00
15.00
30.00
45.00
16.00
76.00
91.00
101.00
8.00
17.00
36.00
45.00
60.00
88.00
77.00
88.00
95.00
4.50
7.00
16.00
32.00
53.00
67.00
79.00
98.00
7.00
16.00
40.00
58.00
76.00
91.00
101.00
a.oo
15.00
37.00
58.00
71.00
80.00
97.00
8,00
17.00
34.00
53.00
69.00
78X10
93.00
100.00
8.00
16X10
31.00
52.00
76.00
93.00
101.00
11.00
18.00
38.00
48.00
61.00
77.00
97X10
7.00
16.00
28.00
52.00
62.00
78.00
92.00
4.50
7.00
16.00
32.00
47X10
67,00
77.00
92X10
102.00
11.00
18.00
37X10
47.00
81.00
69.00
78.00
89.00
96.00
8.00
18.00
40.00
55.00
68.00
81.00
97.00
8.00
17.00
41.00
61.00
77X10
92.00
102.00
9.00
16.00
41.00
60.00
72.00
81.00
98.00
9.00
18.00
40.00
58.00
70.00
79.00
94.00
102.00
9.00
17X10
40.00
53.00
78.00
94.00
102.00
12X10
22.00
39.00
51.00
62.00
78.00
98.00
8XW
18.00
32.00
53.00
63XX)
77X10
93.00
8.00
18.00
34.00
52.00
66.00
79.00
93.00
4.50
12.00
20.00
39.00
STATE
WASHINGTON
(CONTINUED)
WEST VIRGINIA
WISCONSIN
WYOMING
OF SPECIES
50 41.00
55.00
67.00
93.00
73.50
53 V»
10.00
24.00
45.00
84.00
73.00
90.00
99.00
69 2.00
10X10
21.00
31.00
45.00
56.00
68.00
76.00
90.00
98.00
55 2.00
10.00
18.00
38.00
52.00
64.00
76.00
98.00
SPECIES IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
43.00
56.00
68.00
96.00
3.00
11.00
25.00
47.00
66X10
74.00
91.00
102.00
3.00
11.00
22.00
33.00
47.00
60.00
69.00
77.00
91.00
99.00
3.00
11.00
22.00
39.00
55.00
66.00
77.00
97.00
44X10
57X10
75.00
97.00
4.00
14.00
26.00
52.00
67.00
76X10
93.00
103.00
4.00
14X10
23.00
35.00
50.00
61X0
70.00
78.00
92.00
101.00
4.00
12.00
24.00
41.00
57X10
67.00
78.00
98.00
45.00
58.00
78.00
96.00
5.00
15.00
35.00
53.00
68.00
77.00
94.00
4.50
5.00
15.00
24X10
40.00
52.00
62X10
71X10
79.00
93.00
102.00
5.00
13.00
25.00
43.00
58.00
68.00
80.00
101.00
47.00
60XN)
67.00
101.00
7.00
16.00
40.00
58.00
69.00
78X10
96X10
7X»
16.00
25.00
41.00
53.00
64.00
72.00
80.00
84.00
103.00
7X10
14.00
32.00
44.00
60X10
69.00
91.00
102.00
52.00
61.00
91X10
102.00
8.00
18.00
41.00
80.00
70.00
79.00
97.00
8.00
17.00
29.00
43.00
54.00
66.00
73.00
81.00
98.00
4.50
8.00
15.00
36.00
45.00
61.00
73.00
92.00
4.50
54.00
64.00
92X10
4.50
9.00
20.00
43.00
61.00
72.00
80.00
98.00
9.00
18.00
30.00
44.00
56.00
67.00
74.00
86.00
97.00
9.00
16X10
37.00
47.00
62X10
75.00
93.00
B-5
-------
APPENDIX B-5
SPECIES DISTRIBUTION IN THE UNITED STATES
TOTAL NUMBER
OF STATES
STATE IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
TOTAL NUMBER
OF STATES
STATE IDENTIFICATION NUMBEM
ROTIFER (PHILODINA ACUTICORNIS)
ROTIFER (PHILODINA ROSEOLA)
BRISTLEWORM (NAIS SP.)
WORM (LIMNODRILUS HOFFMEISTERI)
SNAIL (AMNICOLA SP.)
SNAIL (CAMPELOMA DECISUM)
SNAIL (QYRAULUS CIRCUMSTRIATUS)
SNAIL (LYMNAEA PALUSTRIS)
SNAIL (PHVSA HETEROSTROPHA)
SNAIL (PHYSA INTEGRA)
SNAIL (PHYSA SP.)
CLADOCERAN (OAPHNIA CARINATA)
CLAOOCERAN (DAPHNIA MAGNA)
CLADOCERAN (DAPHNIA PULEX)
CLADOCERAN (DAPHNIA PULICARIA)
CLADOCERAN (SIMOCEPHALUS SERRULATUS)
14
48
17
14
48
1 23456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 38 37 38 39 40
41 42 43 44 49 46 47 48
1 23456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48
123456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48
123456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31323334353637383940
41 42 43 44 48 46 47 48
123458788 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 38 40
41
123456789 10
11 12 13 14
123496789 10
11 12 13 14 19 18 17 16 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48
1 23*56789 10
11 12 13 14 15 18 17 18 19 20
21222324252827282930
31 32 33 34 35 38 37 38 39 40
41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48
123456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 18 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 28 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
41
23456789 10
12 13 14 15 18 17 18 19 20
22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
323334353637383940
1 23456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21222324252627282930
31323334353837343940
41 42 43 44 45 48 47 48
•32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41
42 43 44 45 48 47 46
323334383940 41 424344
45 48 47 48
123456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21222324252827282930
31323334353637363940
41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48
123456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 28 87 26 2» 30
31323334383637383940
41 42 43 44 45 48 47 48
123458789 10
11 12 13 14 IS 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
CLAOOCERAN (SIMOCEPHALUS SERRULATUS)
(CONTINUED)
SEED SHRIMP (CYPRIDOPSIS VIDUA)
COPEPOD (UNIDENTIFIED)
ISOPOO (ASELLUS BREVICAUDUS)
ISOPOD (ASELLUS COMMUNIS)
SCUD (GAMMARUS FASCIATUS)
SCUD (GAMMARUS LACUSTRIS)
SCUD (GAMMARUS PSEUDOLIMNAEUS)
SCUD (GAMMARUS SP.)
SCUD (HYALLELA AZTECA)
CRAYFISH (FAXONELLA CLYPEATA)
CRAYFISH (ORCONECTES NAIS)
CRAYFISH (ORCONECTES LIMOSUS)
CRAYFISH (ORCONECTES RUSTICUS)
CRAYFISH (PROCAMBARUSACUTUS)
GLASS SHRIMP (PALAEMONETES KADIAKENSIS)
MAYFLY (EPHEMERELLA QRANDIS)
MAYFLY (EPHEMERELLA SUBVARIA)
MAYFLY (HEXAQENIA BILINEATA)
STONEFLY (ACRONEURIA LYCORIUS)
STONEFLY (ACRONEURIA PACIFICA)
STONEFLY (CLAASSENNIA SABULQSA)
STONEFLY (PTERONARCELLA BADIA)
STONEFLY (PTERONARCYS CALIFORNIA)
DAMSELFLY (ISCHNURA VERTICALUS)
DAMSELFLY (ISCHNURA SP.)
48
18
48
4
e
18
9
5
12
11
31
15
27
4
6
7
12
10
9
8
31323334353637383940
41 42 43 44 45 48 47 48
4 7 11 14 19 21 28 29 22 25
16 31 24 48 37 38 43 45
'33458789 10
11 12 13 14 15 18 17 16 19 20
21222324252627282930
31323334353837383940
41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48
30 26 18 24
40 1 11 4 9 8 3 45 17
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 21 22 23 25 26 27 26
1 2 3 7222527323336
38 39 40 41 42 43 44 4S S «
7 22 25 28 28 24 36 30 18 18
1 23456780 10
11 « 13 17 18 19 20 2° 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30 32 S S
1 23456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 28 27 28 29 30
31323334353637SSJS
41 42 43 44 45 48 47 48
20 30 16 15 31 24 3d 14 37
30 35 29 38 37
4 7 8 12 17 8 5
10 1 11
2 3
26 23 28 18 1
20
4 22 41 21 27
20 30 0 16 15 28 23 28 35 16
1 ,J 1 4 22 27 24 29 9 7
13 21 36 8 5 14 19 37 12
3?
» 10 11 12
22 8 25 26
« 24 29 3D
1 22 7 21
333J3940
33363940
36 39 40 41
38 39 40 41
% » » » »
^i
13 14 16
31 11 12 28
12 17 25
4142434445
414249
42 43 44
42 43 44
4445
48 47
46
22 J J2
U2324
JS " '«
282728
» »
2930
33333333"
8-6
-------
APPENDIX B-5
SPECIES DISTRIBUTION IN THE UNITED STATES
__SPEC]ES_
MIDGE (CHIHONOMUS PLUMOSUS)
MIDGE (CHIRONOMUS TENTANS)
MIDGE ICHIRONOMUS SP.)
MIDGE (TANYTARSUS DISSIMIUS)
MIDGE (UNIDENTIFIED)
CADDISFLY (ARCTOPSYCHE GRANDIS)
CADDISFLY (CLISTORONIA MAONIFICA)
CADDISFLY (HYOROPSYCHE BETTENI)
CADDISFLY (HYDROPSYCHE CALIFORNICA)
CADDISFLY (UNIDENTIFIED)
AMERICAN EEL (ANGUILLA ROSTRATA)
COHO SALMON (ONCORHYNCHUS KISUTCH)
SOCKEYE SALMON (ONCORHYNCHUS NERKA)
CHINOOK SALMON {ONCORHYNCHUS TSHAWYTSCHA)
CUTTHROAT TROUT (SALMO CLARK!)
RAINBOW TROUT (SALMO GAIRDNERI)
ATLANTIC SALMON {SALMO SALAR)
BROWN TROUT (SALMO TRUTTA)
BROOK TROUT (SALVELINUS FONTINAUS)
LAKE TROUT (SALVELINUS NAMAYCUSH)
NORTHERN PIKE (ESOX LUCIU3I
MOTTLED 8CULPIN (COITUS BAIROI)
LONGFIN DACE (AQOSIA CHRYSOGASTER)
STONEROLLERICAMPOSTOMA ANOMALUM)
TOTAL NUMBER
OF STATES
STATE IDENTIFICATION NUMBEBS
TOTAL NUMBER
OF STATES
STATE IDENTIFICATION NUMBERS
18
48
9
48
9
48
11
It
10
7
38
12
23
2
31
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 1« 17 18 19 20
21222324252627282930
31323334353837383940
41 42 43 44 45 48 47 48
212223292827282(3239
38 39 40 42 43 48 48 47
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 « « 10
11 12 13 14 19 18 17 IB 19 20
21222324252827282930
31 32 33 34 35 38 37 38 39 40
41 42 43 44 45 48 47 48
21 27 28 38 37
1 23458789 10
11 II 13 14 15 18 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 2» 28 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 38 37 38 39 40
41 42 43 44 45 48 47 48
40 41 42 43 48 48
48 47 48
8 15 21 22 23 25 28 27
27 42 43 48 48
1 2 3
11 12 13
21 22 23
31 32 33
41 42 43
1 2 3
11 12 13
21 22 23
31 33 34
1 11 22
48
345
43 44 45
458789 10
14 15 18 17 18 19 20
24 25 28 27 28 29 30
34353837383940
44 46 48 47 48
10
14 15 18 17 18 19 20
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
39 38 37 41
23252831384548
I 38 39 40 41 42
I 48
7222325282742454848
42 43 44 48 46 )
38 39 40 41
48
23458789 10 11
12 13 14 15 17 18 19 20 81 22
23 25 28 27 32 33 34 M 38 39
40 41 42 43 44 45 46 gj 48
1234567
1 23458789 10
11 12 13 17 18 19 21 22 23 29
26 27 28 29 30 33 34 38 39 40
41 42 43 44 45 48 (47)48
123456788 11
12 13 14 15 17 21 22 25 21 34
38 39 41 42 43 44 45 46Q*p 48
1 33486789 21
22232526273839404243
48 48
3 7 821282728213233
34 38
7 8 11 19 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 2* 30 39 40 41 42
43 45 48
41 44
7 8 11 12 13 14 15 17 18 1»
2021222324252827262*
30313233343836373940
41
GOLDFISH (CARASSIUS AUHATUS)
CARP (CYPRINUS CARPIO)
GOLDEN SHINER (NOTEMIOONUS CRYSOLEUCAS)
STRIPED SHINER (NOTROPIS CHRYSOCEPHALUS)
NORTHERN HEDBELLY DACE (PHOXINUS EOS)
BLUNTNOSE MINNOW (PIMEPHALES NOTATUS)
FATHEAD MINNOW (PIMEPHALES PROMELAS)
NORTHERN SQAUWFISH (PTYCHOCHEILUS OREGONENSIS)
BLACKNOSE DACE (RHINICHTHYS ATRATULUS)
SPECKLED DACE (RHINICHTHYS 03CULUS)
CREEK CHUB (SEMOTILUS ATROMACULATUS)
WHITE SUCKER (CATO8TOMUS COMMERSONI)
BLACK BULLHEAD (ICTALURUS MELAS)
BROWN BULLHEAD (ICTALURUS NEBUL08US)
CHANNEL CATFISH (ICTALURUS PUNCTATUS)
BANDED KILUFISH (FUNDULUS DIAPHANU8)
FLAGFISH (JORDANELLA FLORIDAE)
MOSQUITOFISH (GAMBU8IA AFFINIS)
GUPPY (POECIUA RETICULATA)
SOUTHERN PLATYFISH (XIPHOPHORUS MACULATUS)
BROOK STICKLEBACK (CULAEAINCON8TANS)
16
14
23
9
29
10
40
1
26
6
3
18
4 5 8 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33
34 35 38 37 36 39 40 41 42 43
44 45 46/4T.48
1 2345
11 12 13 14 19
21 22 23 24 25
3132333435
41 42 43 44 45
10
1 2345
11 12 13 14 15
21 22 23 24 25
31 32 33 34 39
44 48
7 8 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
29 26 29 30 31 38
16 17 18 19 20
26 27 28 29 30
3037363940
46 XT) 48
678* 10
16 17 18 19 20
26 27 28 29 30
36 37 38 39 41
1234
33 34 38 40
7 8 22 25 27 32
7 11 12 17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33
34 39 38
12345678 11 12
17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27282930313233343536
373839404142434448
38 42 46 48 47
1 23498789 10
11 12 13 14 15 17 18 19 20 21
222325282728323334
39404142434445404748
123456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 28 27 28 29 30 31
3233343536 37 383940 41
1 23486789 10
11 12 13 14 15 17 18 19 20 21
22232528272829303233
34 35 38 39 40 41 43
4 7 8 11 13 15 17 18 19 20
21222324252827282930
31323334353837383940
41 42 43 44 45 ^f> 48
123456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21222324252827282930
31 32 34 38
4 7 8 9 10 15 18 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 28 27 26 29
30313233343530373839
40 41 43 44 fO«
1 23486789 10
11 12 13 14 21 22 23 25 26 27
28 32 33
7 9 10 11 13 14 15 16 16 19
20 21 22 24 28 27 28 29 30 31
39 38 37 41 42 44 (g) 48
16 37 44 47 48
123478 21 2223 24
28 26 27 28 32 33 34 41
B-7
-------
APPENDIX B-5
SPECIES DISTRIBUTION IN THE UNITED STATES
THREESPINE STICKLEBACK (GASTEROSTEUS ACULEATUS)
WHITE PERCH (MORONE AMERICANA)
STRIPED BASS (MORONE SAXATILIS)
ROCK BASS (AMBLOPLITES RUPESTRIS)
GREEN SUNFISH {LEPOMIS CVANELLUS)
PUMPKINSEEO (LEPOMIS GIBBOSUS)
BLUEGILL (LEPOMIS MACHOCHIRUS)
LONQEAR SUN FISH (LEPOMIS MEGALOTIS)
REDEAR SUNFISH (LEPOMIS MICROLOPHUS>
SMALLMOUTH BASS (MICHOPTEHUS DOLOMIEUI)
LARCEMOUTH BASS (MICROPTERUS SALMOIDES)
BLACK CHAPPIE (POMOXIS NIQROMACULATUS)
RAINBOW DARTER (ETHEOSTOMA CAERULEUM)
ORANGETHROAT DARTER (ETHEOSTOMA SPECTABILE)
YELLOW PERCH (PERCA FLAYESCENS)
WALLEYE (STIZOSTEDION VITREUM VITREUM)
FRESHWATER DRUM (APLOOINOTUS QRUNNIENS)
TOTAL NUMBER
OF STATES
14
32
STATE IDENTIFICA1
46 48
123451
11 12 13 14
ION NUMBERS
! 7 8 9 10
20
46
1?
13
35
12 13 14 15 16 18 19 20 23 24
26 29 31 34 35 36 37 41 43 44
46 46
2 3 4 7 8 9 11 12 13 15
17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 32 33 35 36
7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37
38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46,47.
48 L--
1 23456789 10
11 12 13 14 21 22 23 25 26 29
3438394244454848
23496789 10 11
12 13 14 19 16 17 18 19 20 21
2223242526 27 282930 31
3233343536 37 383940 41
42 43 44 49 46 47 48
7 8 11 15 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 35
36 37 41
7 8 12 13 14 15 18 18 IB 20
21 23 24 26 29 30 31 36 37 41
123456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 29 26 27 28 29 30 32
33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42
43 44 45 **OT}48
123456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 26 29 30
31 32333435383X383940
41 4243444946(47)48
123456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31 32 33 34 35 38 31.36 39 40
41 42 43 44 45 46^47^48
7 8 15 17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
18 19 21 22 23 26 28 29 30 34
35 36 37
123496789 10
11 12 13 14 21 22 23 29 26 27
28 32 33 34 35.37 38 39 41 42
43 44 45
123456789 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 29 26 27 28 29 X
31323334353637383940
41 42 43 44 45 48 *h«
7 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 29
2627282930 31 32333435
36 37 38
B-8
-------
APPENDIX B-8
MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
FAMILY NUMBER
234
10
12
I3|l4
15
16
17
8 (Other phylum than 7)
PHYLUM DELINEATION
18
19
20
21
22J23
24|25
26 27 38 29 30 31
32J33
34|35
8(0t her order than 6)
order the
36
37
38
ORDER DELINEATION
kl |42[43[44|45|46|47|48|49|50|5I
3 (Other than 2)
The eight minimum data requirements are:
1. The family Salmonldae In the class Ostelchthyes.
2. One other family In the class Ostelchthyes.
3. One other family In the phylum Chordata.
4. A planktonlc crustacean (e.g., conchostracean, cladoceran, or copepod).
5. A benthic crustacean (e.g., crayfish, Isopod, ostracod, scud or glass shrimp).
6. A benthic Insect (e.g., a benthic caddlsfly, damsetfly, dragonfly, mayfly, midge, mosquito or etonefly).
7. A family In a phylum other than Arthropoda or Chordata (e.g. Rotlfera, Annelida or Mollusoa).
8. Any other order of Insect or any other phylum.
B-9
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: ALDRIN
STATE
NATIONAL
ALABAMA
ARIZONA
ARKANSAS
CALIFORNIA
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
1 FLORIDA
QEORQIA
IDAHO
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
» KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
MASSACHUSETTS
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
14
7
10
6
9
8
9
9
6
7
8
10
e
7
9
7
7
a
9
9
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
(+)
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
ANQUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ANQUILLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ANOUILUDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ANQUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
ANQUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
ANQUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ANQUILLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ANQUILLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
ANOUILUDAE
7.451
6.000
9.000
10.803
4.903
7.451
10.000
16.000
4.503
7.451
9.000
10,000
7.451
£.000
16.000
16.392
7.451
9.000
10.000
10.603
4.503
7.451
9.000
16.392
4.903
7.451
9.000
16.000
4.503
7.451
9.000
11.314
7.451
10.000
11.314
16.000
4.503
7.451
9.000
10.000
5.241
7.451
9.000
18.382
7.451
8.000
10.000
10.603
7.451
10.000
10.803
16.000
7.451
18.000
16.392
21.000
7.451
10.000
16.000
16.393
4.903
7.451
8.000
10.000
7.451
10.000
16.000
16.392
9.000
11.732
16.000
20.494
7.451
9.000
14.377
16.000
4.503
7.461
9.000
16.000
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
3.388 *
1.402 *
1.928 *
2.181 *
3.363 *
1.433 *
1.520 *
1.796 *
2.690 *
1.763 *
1.668 *
3.230 *
2,827 *
2.773 *
2.454 *
1.774 »
2.646 *
3.313 *
2.749 *
1,520 *
FOOTNOTE "•
•, - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
, , - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: ALDRIN
„„- .JXUXIKSS. »OST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE
MICHIGAN 9 CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
MINNESOTA 7 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ANQUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
« MISSISSIPPI 7 CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
MISSOURI 8 CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
ANQUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
MONTANA 8 CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NEBRASKA 6 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
ANQUILLIDAE
NEVADA 8 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NEW HAMPSHIRE 9 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NEW JERSEY 9 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NEW MEXICO 10 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
NEW YORK 10 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMEREU.IDAE
ANQUILLIDAE
NORTH CAROLINA 9 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NORTH DAKOTA 6 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
OHIO 8 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ANQUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OKLAHOMA 8 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
ANQUILLIDAE
OREQON 8 CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PENNSYLVANIA 10 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
ANQUILLIDAE
RHODE ISLAND 8 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
ANQUILLIDAE
SOUTH CAROLINA 8 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SOUTH DAKOTA 8 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
»« _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES- NATIONAL VALUE USED
1 - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
J _ HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAQE CRITERIA
7.451
9.000
10.803
16.000
5.241
7.451
16.000
16.392
7.451
10.000
16.000
7.451
10.000
16.000
7.491
9000
14.377
16.392
4.503
7.461
10.000
16 000
4.503
7.481
9.000
11.314
4.503
7.451
9.000
11.732
4.S03
7.451
9.000
11.314
4.503
7.461
9.000
10.000
5.241
7.451
9.000
16.000
4.503
7.451
9.000
11.314
4.503
7.461
16.392
21.000
4.503
7.451
16.000
16.392
4.503
7.451
10.000
16.000
7.461
9.000
10.000
10.603
4.603
7.491
9.000
16.000
4.803
7.451
9.000
16.000
4,603
7.451
9.000
11314
4.603
7,461
16.000
16.382
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAQE
2.767 .
1.525 *
2.395 *
2.551 *
2.638 *
1 333 *
1 7VI
1-73S *
1 770 *
1.798 *
1.928 *
1.829 *
1.796 *
1.090 *
1.369 *
1.470 *
3.337 *
1.565 *
1.520 *
1.736 *
1.366 *
C-1
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: ALDRIN
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
TENNESSEE 7
» TEXAS 7
UTAH 9
VERMONT 9
VIRGINIA 9
WASHINGTON 8
WEST VIRGINIA 5
WISCONSIN 8
WYOMING 8
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CYPR1NIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (-*•) ( + ) (++)
4503 1.402 *
7.451
10.000
16.000
7.451 2.646 *
10.000
16.000
18.392
4.503 1.874 *
7.451
9.000
10.000
4.503 1.770 *
7.451
9.000
11.732
4.503 1.520 •
7.451
9.000
18.000
7.451 3.242 *
9.000
10.803
11.314
4.603 1.144 »
7.451
16.000
16.392
7.451 2.844 *
10.803
16.000
16.392
4.503 1.433 *
7.451
9.000
16.392
TOXICANT: ARSENIC
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
NATIONAL 8 QAMMAHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
ALABAMA 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
ARIZONA 6 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ARKANSAS 5 SAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CALIFORNIA 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COLORADO 6 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CONNECTICUT 4 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DELAWARE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
1 FLORIDA 5 DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GEORGIA 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
IDAHO 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHABCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ILLINOIS « QAMMARIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
INDIANA S DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
IOWA 5 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
» KANSAS 4 DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OYPHINIOAE
KENTUCKY 6 QAMMARIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
LOUISIANA 4 DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
MAINE 3 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SO VALUE
(+)
878.999
1794.245
14128.643
18487.430
1046.139
13339.965
1&487.430
19484.938
1794.245
14128.643
16487.430
19484.938
678.999
1046.139
16467.430
19484.936
1794.245
14128.643
18487.430
19484.938
1794.245
13339.965
16487.430
19464.938
1046.139
14128.643
19484.938
20194.383
1046.139
13339.985
16487.430
19464.938
1046.139
18487.430
19484.938
26041.875
1046.139
14128.843
16487.430
19484.938
1794.245
14128.643
19484.938
20194.383
678.999
1046.139
13339.969
16487.430
1046.139
13339.966
6487.430
19484.938
878.999
104S.139
6487.430
9464.938
1048.139
6467.430
9464.938
20194.383
876.999
1048.139
3339.985
6487.430
1046.139
8487.430
9484.938
20194.383
1046.139
4883.94B
CYPRINIDAE 15659.936
FOOTNOTE
* - UNITS IN MICROORAMS PER LITER
+ ., — FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FHV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE .
., , SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
MARYLAND 4 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
MASSACHUSETTS 5 OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
• — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
*• _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES- NATIONAL VALUE USED
» — NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
t - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30.0AY AVERAGE CRITERIA
0.000
1046.139
4126.643
9484.938
M194.383
1046.139
4128.643
6467.430
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
1+) (+) (++)
113.263 *
171.818 *
407.358 *
42.377 *
363.446 *
407.265 *
141,620 *
171.816 »
156.035 *
171.493 *
350.957 *
58.104 *
171.818 *
42.377 *
140.493 t
98.104 *
140.493 *
113.263 *
141.620 *
171.493 *
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: ARSENIC
STATE
MICHIGAN
MINNESOTA
* MISSISSIPPI
MISSOURI
MONTANA
NEBRASKA
NEVADA
NEW HAMPSHIRE
NEW JERSEY
NEW MEXICO
NEW YORK
NORTH CAROLINA
NORTH DAKOTA
OHIO
OKLAHOMA
OREOON
PENNSYLVANIA
RHODE ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
SOUTH DAKOTA
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
e
t
i
4
e
i
5
4
6
e
e
4
5
S
e
4
5
4
4
9
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC80 VALUE
( + )
OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
OAPHWOAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
8AMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
878.996
1040.139
141 J8 643
16487.430
1046.139
14128643
16487.430
19484.938
878.999
104S.139
18487.430
19484.038
1044.139
16487.430
19464.938
20194.383
1794.245
14128.843
16487.430
19484.938
1794.245
14128.843
18487.430
19484838
1794.249
14128.843
16487.430
19484.938
1046.139
14126.643
15869.938
19484.938
1046.139
14128.843
18487.430
19484.938
1794.249
14128.843
16487.430
18484.938
878.999
1040.139
14128.643
16487.430
1048.139
14128.843
19484.938
26041.875
1794.248
13339.985
16487.430
19484.938
1046.130
14128.643
18487.430
19484.938
878.999
1046.139
13339.985
1 MS? ,430
1794.245
14128.643
19484.938
26041,876
1048.136
14128.843
18487.430
19484.938
1046.139
14128.843
19484.938
20184.383
1048.139
14128.643
19484.938
28041.878
1794.243
13339.968
16487.430
19484.938
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 90-DAY AVERAGE
<+> ( + ) (++)
58.980 *
171.493 *
42.377 *
140.493 *
407358 *
363.448 *
383.448 *
148.092 *
171.493 *
407.398 *
58.980 *
132.343 *
363.601 *
171.493 »
58.104 *
286.699 *
171.493 *
141.620 *
132.343 *
363.801 *
FOOTNOTE
» — UNITS IN MICHOGRAMS PER LITER
» f — FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: ARSENIC
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
TENNESSEE 8
1 TEXAS 4
UTAH 6
VERMONT 4
VIRGINIA 4
WASHINGTON 5
WEST VIRGINIA 5
WISCONSIN e
WYOMING 6
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
14-1
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRABCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
.. _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
» - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
S — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM ANDKJR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
878.999
1048.139
13330.986
16487.430
1046.139
16487.430
19464938
20194.383
1794.245
14128,643
16487.430
18484.938
1046.139
14128.043
19859936
19464.938
1048.139
14128.043
19484938
20194.383
1794.245
14128.643
19484938
22039.902
1046.139
14128,643
16487430
19464.936
876.999
1046.130
14128.643
16487430
1794.245
14126.643
16437.430
19464.938
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
58.104 *
140.493 *
407.358 *
148.092 *
141.620 *
343.846 *
171.493 #
56.980 it
407.356 * '
C-3
-------
APPENDIX C
TOX1CITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: CADMIUM
STATE F
NATIONAL
ALABAMA
ARIZONA
ARKANSAS
CALIFORNIA
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
• FLORIDA
GEORGIA
IDAHO
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
* KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
MASSACHUSETTS
C-4
NUMBER OF
UIILIES TESTED
18
14
13
12
14
12
18
17
13
14
12
15
14
13
12
14
12
16
17
16
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODQNTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
LC50 VALUE
( + ) W)
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.660
0.044
0.163
0.864
1.147
0.034
0.163
0.496
1.147
0.864
1.147
2.860
6.987
0.046
0.163
0.496
1.147
0.044
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.034
0.684
1.147
1.630
0.044
0.864
1.147
1.630
0.163
0.864
2.860
6.987
0.034
0.163
0.864
2.860
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.660
0.084
0.163
0.864
1.147
0.064
0.163
0.664
1.147
0.864
1.147
1.630
2.660
0.163
0.864
2.860
6.987
0.044
0.163
0664
l!l47
0.163
0.864
2.860
6.987
0.026
0.864
1.147
1.630
0.034
0.884
1.147
1.630
0.034
0.864
1.147
1.630
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 3D-
0.027
0.013
0.010
0.211 «
0.015
0.012
0.019
0.027
0.048 *
0.008 •
0.013
0.020
0.019
0.317 *
0.041 *
0.013
0.041 *
0.015
0.021
0.019
DAY AVERAGE
*•) (++) ID
0.0004 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0001 ACR
0.0034 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0003 ACR
0.0004 ACR
0.0007 ACR
0.0001 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0003 ACR
0.0003 ACR
0.0051 ACR
0.0006 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0006 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0003 ACR
0.0003 ACR
FOOTNOTE
* — UNITS IN MlCROGRAMS PER LITER
t t _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: CADMIUM
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN 15
MINNESOTA 14
* MISSISSIPPI 13
MISSOURI 13
MONTANA 12
NEBRASKA 12
NEVADA 12
NEW HAMPSHIRE 15
NEW JERSEY 17
NEW MEXICO 15
NEW YORK 17
NOflTH CAROLINA 16
NORTH DAKOTA 12
OHIO 14
OKLAHOMA 14
OREGON 13
PENNSYLVANIA 16
RHODE ISLAND 16
SOUTH CAROLINA 15
SOUTH DAKOTA 13
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
CYPRINODONTIOAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYID'AE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
«« _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
* - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
t - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OS
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
50 VALUE
(+> at
0.048
0.864
1.147
1.630
0.048
0.864
1.147
1.630
0.163
0.864
1.147
2.860
0.163
0.864
1.147
2.860
0.034
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.034
0.163
0.496
2.860
0.034
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.034
0.864
1.147
1.630
0.034
0.884
1.147
1.630
0.034
0.163
0.496
1.147
0.048
0.864
1.147
1430
0.034
0464
1.147
1.630
0.044
0.496
1.147
1.630
0.034
0464
1.147
1.630
0.044
0.163
0.864
1.147
0448
0.163
0.496
1.147
0.034
0464
1.147
1.630
0.034
0.664
1 147
1430
0.034
0464
1.630
2860
Ol496
1.147
1.630
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+i m
0.023
0.021
0.059
0.059 *
0.009
0.006 *
0.009
0.017
0.021
0.012
' 0.029
0.019
0.014
0.01S
0.013
0.014
0.019
0.019
0.016 *
0.016
30-DAY
(+) (4
0.0003
0.0003
0.0009
0.0009
0.0001
0.0001
0.0001
0.0002
0.0003
0.0002
0.0004
0.0003
0.0002
0.0002
0.0002
0.0002
0.0003
0.0003
0.0002
0.0002
AVERAGE
+ ) 01
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: CADMIUM
TOXICANT: CHLORDANE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAQE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC«0 VALUE
Ltl_
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 90-DAY AVERAOE
VERMONT
WEST VIRGINIA
WYOMING
SALMONIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
SALMONIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINOOONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINOOONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
0.013
0.0002
ACR
ACR
ACR
O.OM
0.183
0.884
1.147
0.183 O.M1 • 0.0006
0.884
2.880
8.487
0.034 0.000 0.0001
0.183
0.406
1.147
0.034 0.017 0.0002 ACR
0.884
1.147
1.430
0.034 0.017 0.0002 ACR
0.884
1.147
1430
0.048 0.013 0.0002 ACR
0.406
1.147
2S80
0X04 0.011 0.0001 ACR
0.804
1.147
OO48 0.019 0.0003 ACH
0.684
1.147
0.034 0.009 0.0001 ACR
0.499
1.147
2.880
ARKANSAS
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
GEORGIA
I KANSAS
MARYLAND
MASSACHUSETTS
PALAEMQNIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PAUEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMAHIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRAACHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECIUIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYFfHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
13.000
23.238
35.249
6.325
23.238
29.481
54.711
19.000
23738
28.000
33.862
6.32S
23.238
94.711
0.000
2*000
43.739
94.711
19.000
23.238
25.481
28.000
94.711
19.684
29.481
40.000
64.711
19.884
04.711
190400
0.000
19884
94.711
0.000
15.000
2*238
1.974 *
**
1.974 *
**
0.042 *
4O2S1
SJ2S
40X100
43.317
43.327
94.711
6.323
8*238
40.000
84.711
04.711
0.000
OJXK)
23J38
25.481
94.711
0.000
0.329
1.974 *
**
54.711
65.000
12.371
24.000
50.200
0.000
40.000
40.044
04.711
1.974 *
**
8.017
0.0043 FflV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0X1043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
40X100
94.711
FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
ACR cgJp^DTA^Eo CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
- FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
- STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
— NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
- HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAOE CRITERIA
C-5
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: CHLORDANE
TOXICANT: CHLORDANE
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
STATE
MICHIGAN
*
MINNESOTA
» MISSISSIPPI
MISSOURI
MONTANA
NEBRASKA
NEVADA
NEW HAMPSHIRE
NEW JERSEY
NEW MEXICO
NEW YORK
NORTH CAROLINA
NORTH DAKOTA
OHIO
OKLAHOMA
OREGON
PENNSYLVANIA
RHODE ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
SOUTH DAKOTA
FAMILIES TESTED NAME
5 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
4 CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
C6NTRARCHIDAE
3 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
3 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRABCHIDAE
6 PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
4 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
6 CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
4 CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
4 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
6 PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
5 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
4 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
5 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
5 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
5 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONtDAE
QAMMARIDAE
5 CYPWNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
5 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
4 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
3 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
5 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LC50 VALUE
1+)
6.325
23.238
32.249
43.739
23.238
32.249
40.281
54.711
6.325
23.238
54.711
0.000
S.325
23.238
54.711
0.000
15.000
23.238
26.000
40.044
23.238
33.662
54.711
58.267
15.684
26.000
33.862
64.711
12.371
26.000
33.662
54.711
15.684
33.862
40.000
54.711
18.000
23-238
26.000
33.862
6.325
23.238
32.248
40.281
15.684
33.862
40.000
54.711
23.238
25.481
26.000
54.711
6.325
23.238
33.862
40.000
6.325
23.236
25.481
26.000
15.684
26.000
43.739
54.711
6.325
23.236
33.862
40.000
23.236
33.882
40.000
64.711
15.684
33.862
64.711
0.000
23.238
25.481
26.000
54.711
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-
I-H (
1.511 *
7.511 *
1.974 *
**
1.074 *
**
5.061 *
7.016 *
4.693 »
3.113 *
4.569 *
5.588 *
1559 *
4.569 *
6.084 *
1.550 *
1.825 *
4.357 *
1.550 *
7.675 *
1,974 *
**
6.084 «
DAY AVERAGE
+) (++)
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FBV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
FOOTNOTE
t — UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
t t _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACFl COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
,a SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
TENNESSEE 4
1 TEXAS 4
UTAH 6
VERMONT 4
VIRGINIA 4
WASHINGTON 6
WEST VIRGINIA 3
WISCONSIN 5
WYOMING 6
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME L
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDA6
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRABCHIDAE
PTEHONARCIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMQNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTBARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
* * — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
II - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
1 - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
C60 VALUE
(+1
6.325
23.238
25.481
54.711
6.325
23,238
54.711
190.000
15.000
23.238
26.000
33.662
12.371
32.249
33.662
64.711
23.238
13.862
40.000
54.711
15.000
15.664
26.000
43.739
23,238
33.682
64.711
0.000
6.325
23.238
32.249
43.739
15.000
23.238
26.000
33.862
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (4) (++)
1.232 * 0.0043 FHV
0.556 * 0.0043 FRV
S.588 * 0.0043 FBV
3.272 * 0.0043 FRV
7.675 * 0.0043 FRV
3.775 * 0.0043 FRV
1.974 * 0.0043 FHV
1.511 * 0.0043 FRV
S.588 * 0.0043 FRV
-------
TOXICANT: CHROMIUM
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: CHROMIUM
STATE
NATIONAL
ALABAMA
ARIZONA
ARKANSAS
CALIFORNIA
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
» FLORIDA
GEORGIA
IDAHO
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
« KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
MASSACHUSETTS
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
10
6
7
5
7
g
6
6
6
6
5
7
6
6
5
7
5
5
0
6
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PHILOOINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
POECILIIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
LC50 VALUE
67400
6399.976
8994.790
24892428
8998.790
24892428
30454.750
57461.672
(399.970
6996.790
29999.867
30454.750
67.000
(998.790
24892428
57461.672
6390.975
6998.790
30454.750
6399.978
6988.790
24892428
57461.672
8998.790
24892428
30454.750
57461 672
8998.790
24892.828
30454.750
68989.781
6998.790
248*2428
29999467
30484.750
6996.790
24692.828
30464.750
63804.148
8399.976
. 6998.790
57461.672
63804.148
67.000
6998.790
24892.828
30454.750
6998.790
24892428
30454.750
57461472
67400
6996.790
24892.828
57481472
6996.790
24882,828
30454.750
57461.67]
67400
6998.790
248*2428
30454.750
6996.790
24802428
30484.750
57481472
6998.790
24892428
30454.7(0
40837.609
6998.790
30484.750
(7461472
8998.790
24(82428
30454.750
97481472
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
12.164
1(92.459 *
1140.847 *
2.505 *
1140.847 *
781.038 *
1892.459 *
1538,742 *
2124.123 *
1604473 *
540.895 *
6.387 *
1692.459 *
3.407 *
1548.824 *
5.387 t
154(424 *
1811.186 *
1692.459 *
1692,459 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
10.0 FPV
0.0685 ACR
10.0 FPV
10.0 FPV
10.0 FPV
10.0 FPV
10.0 FPV
10.0 FPV
10.0 FPV
0.1498 ACR
10.0 FPV
0.0946 ACR
10.0 FPV
0.1496 ACR
10.0 FPV
104 FPV
10.0 FPV
10.0 FPV
FOOTNOTE
* - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
, , _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
STATE
MICHIGAN
MINNESOTA
« MISSISSIPPI
MISSOURI
MONTANA
NEBRASKA
NEVADA
NEW HAMPSHIRE
NEW JERSEY
NEW MEXICO
NEW YORK
NORTH CAROLINA
NORTH DAKOTA
OHIO
OKLAHOMA
OREGON
PENNSYLVANIA
RHODE ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
SOUTH DAKOTA
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
6
6
6
6
6
7
6
6
6
7
7
6
6
6
8
6
6
6
8
6
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC60 VALUE
GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CHIRONOM1DAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PEBCtCHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
CYPRINIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
* * _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
t - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
| - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
. APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM ANDJOH
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
87.000
6998.790
24892428
57461472
6896.790
24892428
874(1.672
59899.703
(7.000
8898.790
24892428
30454.750
6996.790
24892428
30454.750
67481472
6399.976
6998.790
24892428
57461.672
8399.976
8998.790
24882428
30454.780
6399.976
8998.790
29999467
63804.148
6998.790
24892428
30454.750
40637400
8898.790
24892428
30454.750
63804.148
6389.974
6998.790
24892428
30454.750
67400
6996.790
24892428
30484.750
6996.790
24892428
30454.750
63804.148
6399.976
6988.790
24892428
57481.672
6988.790
24892428
S7461472
89899.703
67400
6998.790
24892.828
30454.790
(399.978
8996.790
30454.750
63804.148
6998.790
24892.628
30464.750
57461.872
8996.790
2489242S
30454.750
57461472
(998.790
24892826
30484.750
63804.148
6399.876
6998.790
24882428
57481472
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
3.407 *
1531.490 *
4.108 *
1548424 *
781.036 *
1208.844 »
719454 *
1980.335 *
1604473 *
1208.844 *
5.387 *
1604473 *
781.038 *
1531.480 *
8.949 *
718.704 *
1682.489 *
1892.459 *
1604.673 *
761438 *
JO-DAY AVERAGE
0.0846 ACR
10.0 FPV
0.1141 ACR
10.0 FPV
10.0 FPV
10.0 FPV
10.0 FPV
10,0 FPV
10.0 FPV
10.0 FPV
0.1496 ACR
10.0 FPV
10.0 FPV
10,0 FPV
0.1930 ACR
10.0 FPV
10.0 FPV
10.0 FPV
10.0 FPV
104 FPV
C-7
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: CHROMIUM
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME
TENNESSEE 7 GAMMARIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
* TEXAS 7 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
UTAH g DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
VERMONT 5 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
VIRGINIA 6 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
WASHINGTON 5 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
WEST VIRGINIA 5 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
WISCONSIN 6 GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
WYOMING 6 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
LC50 VALUE
(•*•)
67.000
6996.790
24892.828
30454.750
6998.790
24892.828
29999.867
30454.750
6399.976
6996.790
30454.750
57461.672
6998.790
24892.828
40637.609
63804.148
8998.790
24692.828
30454.750
57481.672
8399.976
6998.790
63604.146
81251.078
6996.790
24892.828
57461.672
63804.148
67.000
6998.790
24892.828
57461.672
6399.976
8998.790
24892.828
67461.672
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+1 (+) (++)
5.387 * 0.1496 ACR
2271.128 * 10.0 FPV
784.448 * 10.0 FPV
1446.932 « 10.0 FPV
1692.459 * 10.0 FPV
469.609 * 10.0 FPV
1352.297 * 10.0 FPV
3.407 * 0.0948 ACR
781.033 * 10.0 FPV
•f - UNITS IN MICflOGRAMS PER LITER
+ f - FPV
FRV
ACR
FCV
C-8 SCV
FINAL PLANT
FINAL RESIDU
I/ALUE
E VALUE
COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: COPPER
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 23
ALABAMA 17
ARIZONA 13
ARKANSAS 15
CALIFORNIA 13
COLORADO 13
CONNECTICUT 18
DELAWARE 18
* FLORIDA 16
GEORGIA 16
IDAHO n
ILLINOIS 19
INDIANA 19
IOWA 17
* KANSAS 14
KENTUCKY 16
LOUISIANA 19
MAINE 20
MARYLAND 16
MASSACHUSETTS 19
* ~ rAILEO T0 MEET "'NIMUM DATA CRITERIA
— STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILI
$ - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE *?E
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME I
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
PLANORBIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
PLANORBIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
S NATIftMAi UAI
MUNAL VALUE USED
I1U Akinu-iB
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA " "'""""
CM VALUE MAXIMUM
(+) W <+) O)
0.305 0.194
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256 0.137
0.759
0.995
1.022
0.305 0.126
0.759
1.345
1.424
0.296 0.121 *
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.305 0.128
0.759
1.345
1.401
0.305 0.133
0.769
0,995
1.309
0.256 0.139
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.266 0.142
0.769
0.995
1.022
0.256 0.127 *
0.769
0.995
1.345
0.258 0.127 *
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.305 0.118
0.759
1.345
1.424
0.266 0.146
0.769
0.996
1.049
0.266 0.146
0.799
0.995
1.049
0.256 0.133 *
0.759
0.995
1346
0.256 0.116 *
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.288 0.142
0.769
0.996
1.022
0.256 0.123 *
0.759
0.995
1.236
0.258 0.151
0.759
0.995
1 345
0^256 0.139
0.769
1J45
0.250 0.145
0-709
0995
V348
30-DAY
( + )
5.48818
9.42403
3.77456
4.79332
2.74196
9.85862
7.43115
8.30804
6.30441
9.39244
3.11336
4.99843
9.42403
4.95643
9.26331
4.79332
9.09372
7.22020
6.36390
8.47114
AVERAGE
(++)
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: COPPER
STATE
MICHIGAN
MINNESOTA
* MISSISSIPPI
MISSOURI
MONTANA
NEBRASKA
NEVADA
NEW HAMPSHIRE
NEW JERSEY
NEW MEXICO
NEW YORK
NORTH CAROLINA
NORTH DAKOTA
OHIO
OKLAHOMA
OREGON
PENNSYLVANIA
RHODE ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
SOUTH DAKOTA
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
19
18
16
16
13
15
12
18
18'
10
20
18
15
19
17
12
19
16
17
15
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE •
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIOAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
PLANORBIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIOAE
+ •- UNIT!
» t - FPV
FHV
ACR
<+> (6)
0.255
0.759
0.995
1.339
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.258
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256
0.759
0.995
1345
0.305
0.759
0995
1.345
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.305
0.759
1.345
1.424
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.258
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.266
0.759
0.999
1.345
0.305
0.769
0.995
1.022
0.256
0.759
0.996
1.345
0.256
•0.759
0.995
1.022
0.306
0.759
1.345
1.401
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.266
0.759
0.996
1.345
0.256
0.759
0.996
1.345
0.306
0.769
0.996
1.022
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + 1 <$)
0.145
0.139
0.127
0.127 *
0.132
0.150 *
0.121
0.139
0.139
0.150
0.151
0.139
0.150
0.146
0.137
0.122
0.146
0.139
0.133 *
0.150
( + 1 (++I
4.79332 FCV
9.57750 FCV
4.4S175 FCV
9.67750 FCV
0.01505 FCV
9.92406 FCV
9.07713 FCV
7.43115 FCV
8.30804 FCV
9,89662 FCV
6.32754 FCV
7.62932 FCV
9.92406 FCV
9.57750 FCV
4.82476 FCV
0.01447 FCV
8.62836 FCV
7.43118 FCV
6.24143 FCV
9.92406 FCV
i IN MICROORAM8 PER LITER
FINAL PLANT VALUE
SStiSfSHSlS* CH«ON.C RATW METHOD
FINAL CHRONN"
U VALUE
TOXICANT: COPPER
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
TENNESSEE
1 TEXAS
UTAH
VERMONT
VIRGINIA
WASHINGTON
WEST VIRGINIA
WISCONSIN
WYOMING
17
15
12
18
19
11
17
19
13
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC60 VALUE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
PLANORBIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIOAE
TUBIFICIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
1 - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
$ - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
(») M
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.022
0.258
0.759
0.999
1.345
0.305
0.759
1.345
1.424
0.258
0.759
0.995
1.345
0£56
0.759
0.99S
1.346
0.305
0.759
1.345
1.401
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.34S
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.339
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) W) ( + > (++)
0.137 4.79332 FCV
0.121 * 8.66591 FCV
0.121 2.89135 FCV
0.139 7.83485 FCV
0.145 8.38350 FCV
0.116 9.64928 FCV
0.133 0.42403 FCV
0.145 4.79332 FCV
0.132 9.85882 FCV
C-9
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: CYANIDE
STATE
NATIONAL
ALABAMA
ARIZONA
ARKANSAS
CALIFORNIA
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
1 FLORIDA
GEORGIA
IDAHO
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
* KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
MASSACHUSETTS
C-10
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
10
6
6 •
6
5
6
6
7
5
6
6
8
6
8
6
7
5
7
8
7
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
FERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRA RCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
LC50 VALUE
(+)
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
57.000
. 83.000
114.316
207.998
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
83.000
114.316
167.000
207.956
76.707
83.000
114.316
207.956
57.000
83.000
114.316
207.958
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
57.000
83.000
114416
125.121
83.000
114.316
306.484
317.999
78.707
83.000
114416
317.999
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
67.000
83.000
114.316
125.121
57.000
83.000
114.316
125.121
83.000
114416
125.121
167.000
83.000
114.316
125.121
207.958
57.000
83.000
114.316
167.000
63.000
114.316
207.998
431.499
83.000
102.000
103.227
125.121
76.707
63.000
114416
125.131
78.707
83.000
114416
125.121
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+1
31.429 *
15.459 •
28.920 *
27.567 •
19.982 *
15.459 *
28.920 *
21.460 *
18.087 *
14.897 *
28.920 *
22.192 *
20.746 *
33.249 *
27.174 *
18.831 *
16.127 *
35.949 *
30.219 *
29.583 *
30-DAY AVERAOE
( + 1 (++)
4.2472 ACR
2.0690 ACR
3.9081 ACR
3.7279 ACR
2.6482 ACR
2.0890 ACR
3.8081 ACR
23990 ACR
2.4414 ACR
1.9808 ACR
3.9081 ACR
2.9935 ACR
23035 ACR
4.4930 ACR
3.8722 ACR
2.5178 ACR
2.1792 ACR
4.8579 ACR
4.0838 ACR
3.9977 ACR
+ — UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
t t - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: CYANIDE
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
MICHIGAN 8 SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
MINNESOTA 8 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
1 MISSISSIPPI 6 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
MISSOURI 5 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
MONTANA 8 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
NEBRASKA 6 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
NEVADA 8 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
NEW HAMPSHIRE 6 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
NEW JERSEY 8 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
NEW MEXICO 7 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PERCIDAE
NEW YORK 8 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
NORTH CAROLINA 7 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
NORTH DAKOTA 6 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
OHIO 8 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
OKLAHOMA 8 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
OREGON 5 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
PENNSYLVANIA 7 . SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
RHODE ISLAND 6 SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SOUTH CAROLINA 7 SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SOUTH DAKOTA 6 SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PERCIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
« - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
* - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
50 VALUE
(+)
76.707
83.000
114418
129.121
76.707
83.000
114416
125.121
83X00
114.316
167.000
207.958
83.000
114.316
207.958
431.499
76.707
83.000
114.318
125.121
76.707
83.000
114418
128.121
76.707
83X00
121.020
125.121
78.707
83.000
114.316
126.131
76.707
83.000
114.316
129.121
76.707
83.000
114418
125.121
76.707
63X00
114416
128.121
78.707
83.000
114416
12S 12
67.000
83.000
1 14.316
128.121
76.707
83X00
114416
126 121
93.000
114418
167.000
71707
63.000
1 14.316
129 121
76,707
83000
114416
128.121
78.707
83000
114416
126.121
76.707
83X00
114.318
128.121
67X00
83.000
114.318
129.121
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+)
30.219 *
30.219 *
27.567 »
16.127 *
28.920 *
26.920 *
28.459 *
28.920 »
30.219 *
29.583 *
30.219 *
29.583 *
20.748 *
30.219 *
19.407 *
28435 *
29.883 *
28.930 *
29.883 »
20.746 *
30-DAY
(+)
4.0838
4.0836
3.7279
2.1792
3.9081
3.9061
3.6458
3.9081
4.0838
3.9977
4.0638
3.9977
28035
4.0836
23225
3.8141
3.9977
33011
3.9977
23038
AVERAOE
(++)
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: CYANIDE
STATE
TENNESSEE
» TEXAS
UTAH
VERMONT
VIRGINIA
WASHINGTON
WEST VIRGINIA
WISCONSIN
WYOMING
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
7
7
9
7
6
6
6
7
6
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
<+) (+) (+) (++)
57,000 18.631 * 2.5176 ACR
83.000
114.316
167.000
83.000 28.174 * 3.8072 ACR
114.316
129.121
207956
76.707 28.225 * 3.8141 ACH
83.000
114.316
76707 29.983 * 3.8977 ACR
83.000
114.316
71707 28.920 * 3.9081 ACR
83.000
114.316
125121
76.707 28.920 * 3.9081 ACR
83.000
114.316
129.121
76.707 20.506 * 2.7713 ACR
83.000
114.316
76707 29.583 * 3.9977 ACH
83.000
114.316
76707 28.920 » 3.9081 ACH
83.000
114.316
125,121
* _ UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
t f _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE _
ACfl COMPUTEC I BV ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
SCV SENN*siTOERSP6CIE8LCH(>ONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: DDT
STATE
NATIONAL
ALABAMA
ARIZONA
ARKANSAS
CALIFORNIA
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
« FLORIDA
QEORQIA
IDAHO
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
• KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
MASSACHUSETTS
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
20
8
11
9
10
10
7
9
7
7
11
14
10
12
7
6
9
9
10
11
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
A8ELLIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMAHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMAAIDAE
ASTACIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PEHCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ESOCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIOAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ESOCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PEHCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
ASTACIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
.. _ gTATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
II - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONIO PISH IN STATE
I - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAQE CRITERIA
{+)
1.323
1.599
1.700
2.234
0.976
3.000
3.234
4.102
1.323
1.999
3.000
3.282
0.978
2.409
3.234
4.000
1.323
3.000
3282
6.921
1.323
3.000
3.096
4.678
0.978
1.596
1.864
3.006
0.976
1.595
1.664
3000
0.976
3.000
3.263
17.088
0.976
3.000
4.102
6.151
1.323
1.598
3.000
3.282
0.976
1.995
1.684
1.700
0.976
1.695
1.684
3.000
0.976
1.595
1.664
1.700
0.976
1.595
2.409
3.904
0.978
3.000
4.000
4.102
0.976
3.000
3.234
4.102
0.976
1.89S
2.398
3.000
0.976
1.898
1.884
3.000
0.976
1.995
1.884
3.000
FRESHWATER AOUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
0.850
0.344
0.479
0.355
0.442
0.510
0.318
0.344
0.190
0.249
0.479
0.480
0.397
0.462
0.283
0.338
0.364
0.354
0.367
0.370
*
*
*
+
*
*
* -
^
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
(+)
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
{++)
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FFIV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FRV
C-11
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: DDT
STATE
MICHIGAN
MINNESOTA
• MISSISSIPPI
MISSOURI
MONTANA
NEBRASKA
NEVADA
NEW HAMPSHIRE
NEW JERSEY
NEW MEXICO
NEW YORK
NORTH CAROLINA
NORTH DAKOTA
OHIO
OKLAHOMA
OREGON
PENNSYLVANIA
RHODE ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
SOUTH DAKOTA
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
13
12
10
10
13
9
11
8
9
12
14
9
10
13
9
11
12
a
8
11
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
ASELLIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ESOCIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ESOCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ESOCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
LCSO VALUE
( + )
0.976
1.995
2.234
3.000
0.976
1.S95
1.700
2.234
0.67«
3X100
3.234
• 4.000
0.976
1.700
2.409
3.234
1.323
1.595
1.700
3AM
1.323
1.595
1.700
3.282
1.323
1.59S
1.900
3.000
0.97t
1.595
3.000
3.006
0.97>
1.399
1.864
3.000
1.323
1.596
3.000
4.102
0.976
1.995
1.700
2J34
0.976
1.595
1464
3.000
1.323
1.S9S
1.700
3.000
0478
1.595
1.664
1.700
0.976
2.409
3.000
3-234
1.323
1.995
1.900
3.000
0.976
1.999
1.664
1.700
0.978
1.S9S
1.664
3.000
0.976
1.985
3.000
3.570
1.323
1.595
1.700
3.000
TOXICANT: DDT
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+)
0.410 *
0.434 *
0.385 •
0.366 *
0.510 *
0.432 *
0.501 *
0.323 *
0.344 *
0.459 *
0.456 *
0.344 *
0.472 »
0.471 *
0.377 *
0.501 »
0.482 *
0.331 *
0.305 *
0.449 »
30-DAY AVERAGE
<+> (++>
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0X010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
* — UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
« f — FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
C-12
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC V*
CUE
STATE
TENNESSEE
« TEXAS
UTAH
VERMONT
VIRGINIA
WASHINQTON
WEST VIRGINIA
WISCONSIN
WYOMINQ
NUMBER OF
FAMI
LIES TESTED
9
10
12
9
8
11
6
12
10
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SCIAENIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
*• - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
1 - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
! - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
:» VALUE
(+)
0.978
3.000
3.234
4.102
0.976
1.595
2.409
3.234
1.323
1.&B5
3.000
3.096
0.978
1.59K
1.700
2.234
0.978
1.995
1.664
3.000
1.323
1.996
3.000
3.282
0.976
3.904
7.840
10.000
0.976
1.595
2.234
3.000
1.323
1.595
3.000
3.282
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
<+) ( + ) (++)
0.364 * 0.0010 FRV
0.357 * 0.0010 FRV
0.903 * 0.0010 FRV
0.401 * 0.0010 FRV
0.331 * 0.0010 FRV
0.479 * 0.0010 FRV
0.210 * 0.0010 FRV
0.397 * 0.0010 FRV
0.4S3 » 0.0010 FRV
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: DIELDRIN
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
ALABAMA
ARIZONA
ARKANSAS
CALIFORNIA
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
» FLORIDA
GEORGIA
IDAHO
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
* KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
MASSACHUSETTS
12
5
9
I
8
8
e
e
4
5
8
7
5
5
4
5
5
5
6
6
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCM VALUE
f + l
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIOAE
POECILIIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERUDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERUDAE
ASELUDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
4.503
5.000
5.452
8.000
2.459
10.811
20.000
30.102
2.458
4.503
8.000
10.811
5.000
10*11
20.000
30.102
4.503
5.452
8.000
10*11
2.459
8.000
10,811
24.000
2.459
8.000
14.450
30,102
2.459
0000
10.811
41.000
4.603
14.480
41.000
231.052
2.459
8.000
10.811
41.000
3.873
8.000
10.811
24.000
5.000
6.452
10.811
20.000
5.452
10.811
30.102
231.052
10*11
20.000
30.102
231.052
10*11
30,102
190.745
738.989
2.468
5.000
10.811
30.102
10*00
10*11
20.000
30.102
8.000
10.800
22.101
231.052
5.154
8.000
10*11
30.102
2.459
8.000
14.460
30.102
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + > ( + > I++)
1.830 *
0.452 *
0.788 *
1.207 *
1.544 *
0.632 *
0.471 *
0.382 *
0.251 *
0.338 *
1.037 *
1.120 *
0.297 *
0.832 *
0.438 *
0.338 *
2.569 *
0.390 *
1,037 *
0.471 *
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FHV
0.0018 FflV
0.0019 FHV
0.0019 FHV
0.0019 FHV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0,0018 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0018 FRV
0.0018 FRV
0.0018 FHV
0.0018 FRV
0.0018 FHV
0.0018 FRV
0.0018 FHV
0,0018 FRV
, - UNITS IN MICROORAMS PER LITER
, , - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
SCV SENSITIVE S
>F(*IE$ CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: DIELDRIN
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE
MICHIGAN 7 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
MINNESOTA 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
» MISSISSIPPI S ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
MISSOURI 5 CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
MONTANA 8 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERUDAE
NEBRASKA 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
gLMONjgj.
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
NEW HAMPSHIRE « SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NEW JERSEY 8 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NEW MEXICO 8 SALMONIDAE
NEWMEAII^ EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERUDAE
NEW YORK 7 SALMONIDAE
NEW Tim* EPHEMEHELLIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
NORTH CAROLINA 6 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NORTH DAKOTA 5 5*fSS3JU
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
OH|0 8 SALMONIDAE
U CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OKLAHOMA 7 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OREGON 7 SALMONIDAE
0 EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
RFKlNftYLVANIA 7 SALMONIDAE
PENNSYLVANIA EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
RHODE ISLAND « SALMONIDAE
RHODE ISUAHU ° EPHEMERELUDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SOUTH CAROUNA 5 "JjBSJJL*.
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SOUTH DAKOTA S SALMONIDAE
SOUTH DAKOTA o CENTRARCHIDAE
PERUDAE
CYPRINIDAE
tt ~~ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES—NATIONAL VALUE USED
1 - NO INOIOENOUSSALMONIO FISH IN STATE
1 - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLV 'EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
5.452
8.000
10.811
20.000
3.873
10.811
30 102
231.052
5.000
10.811
20.000
30.102
10*11
20.000
30.102
231.062
5.154
8.000
10.811
24.000
2.469
10*11
30.102
180.745
2.459
4.503
8.000
10.811
2.459
8.000
14.460
22.101
2.469
8,000
10*11
41.000
2.458
8.000
10.811
24400
3*73
8.000
10*11
20.000
2.469
8.000
10.811
41.000
2.469
10.811
30.102
190.746
2.459
10*11
20.000
30.102
2.459
10*11
20.000
30.102
5.452
8.000
10.811
24.000
2.459
8.000
10*11
50.000
2.458
8.000
14.480
30.102
2.468
8.000
10.811
41.000
2.468
10.811
24.000
30.102
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
1.556 *
0.211 *
1.115 *
0.832 *
1.381 *
0.121 *
0.746 t
0.549 *
0.382 *
0.632 *
1.080 *
0.382 *
0.148 *
0.506 *
0.5S1 *
1*76 *
0.637 *
0.471 *
0.338 *
0.480 *
0.0019
0.0019
0.0018
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
0.0019
FHV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FRV
FHV
FRV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FHV
c-i:
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: DIELORIN
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
TENNESSEE 5
# TEXAS 6
UTAH 8
VERMONT 6
VIRGINIA 6
WASHINGTON 8
WEST VIRGINIA 4
WISCONSIN 6
WYOMING 8
C-14
TOXICANT: ENDOSULFAN
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME LCM VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
SALMONIDAE
CENTR
PALAE
CYPRIh
POECIL
CENTR
PALAE
CYPRII*
ARCHIDAE
MONIDAE
IDAE
IIOAE
ARCHIDAE
WONIDAE
IDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEM
CENTR
PERLID
SALMO
EPHEM
CENTR
CYPRII*
SALMO
EPHEM
CENTR
CYPRU
ERELLIDAE
AHCHIDAE
AE
NIDAE
ERELLIDAE
AHCHIDAE
IDAE
NIDAE
ERELLIDAE
ARCHIDAE
IIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEM
CENTR
PERLIC
SALMC
CENTR
CYPRN
DAPHN
SALMO
CENTR
PALAE
CYPRir
SALMC
EPHEM
CENTR
PERLIC
ERELLIDAE
ARCHIDAE
AE
NIDAE
ARCHIDAE
IDAE
IDAE
NIDAE
ARCHIDAE
MONIDAE
IIDAE
NIDAE
ERELLIDAE
ARCHIDAE
AE
( + ) ( + ) ( + 1 (++)
2459 0.452 « 0.0019 FRV
10.811
20.000
30.102
4.503 1.066 * 0.0019 FRV
10.811
20.000
30.102
2.459 0.832 * 0.0019 FRV
8.000
10.811
24.000
2.459 0.549 * 0.0019 FRV
8.000
14.460
22.101
2.459 0.485 * 0.0019 FRV
8.000
10.811
30.102
5.452 1.456 * 0.0019 FRV
8.000
10.811
24.000
2.459 0.105 * 0.0019 FRV
10.811
30.102
231.052
5.452 1.335 * 0.0019 FRV
10.811
20.000
30.102
2.459 0.832 * 0.0019 FRV
8.000
10.811
24.000
FOOTNOTE
+ — UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
«. f _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE
NATIONAL
ALABAMA
ARIZONA
ARKANSAS
CALIFORNIA
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
* FLORIDA
GEORGIA
IDAHO
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
» KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
MASSACHUSETTS
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
9
5
8
4
7
8
6
5
3
4
7
8
6
5
^
4
5
3
4
6
6
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCM VALUE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE {AGRIONIDA
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
QAMMARIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE {AGRIONIDA
SALMONIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGRIONIDA
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGRIONIDA
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGRIONIDA
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGRIONIDA
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
» - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
t - HARDNESS EFFECT
APPLY EQUATION 3.7
NTERCEPT VALUE
TO DETERMINE MAXIM
UM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
E)
E)
E)
E)
E)
E)
(+)
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.884
1.279
3.240
3.811
0.884
1.279
2.300
3.700
1.279
3.240
3.811
87.850
0.884
1.279
3.700
3.811
0.884
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.884
1.279
3.240
3.811
0.684
3.240
3.811
8.000
3.700
3.811
87.850
0.000
0.684
3.240
3.811
67.850
0.884
1279
2.300
3.811
0.884
1.279
3.240
3.611
0.884
1.279
3.240
3.811
3.240
3.811
6.000
1.279
3.240
3.811
87.850
0.864
1.279
3.240
3.811
1.279
3.811
87.650
0.000
1.279
3.240
6.800
87.680
0.884
1.279
3.240
3.811
0.884
1.279
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(*)
0.208 t
0.137 •
0.184 *
0.038 *
0.155 *
0.196 *
0.149 *
0.147 *
0.208 *
**
0.019 *
0.170 *
0.149 *
0.149 *
0.381 *
0.038 *
0.137 *
0.208 *
**
0.043 *
0.149 *
0.149 *
(•*>
0.1084
0.0701
0.0944
0.0185
0.0793
0.1003
0.0762
0.0781
0,1084
0.0096
0.0670
0.0762
0.0762
0.1800
0.0185
0.0701
0.1084
0.0218
0.0762
0.0762
(++I
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: ENDOSULFAN
TOXICANT: ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN 6
MINNESOTA 6
MISSISSIPPI 3
MISSOURI 4
MONTANA 6
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
( + )
SALMONIDAE 0.6*4
CYPRINIDAE 1.279
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240
CENTRARCHIDAE 3.S11
SALMONIDAE 0.664
CYPRINIDAE 1.279
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240
CENTRARCHIDAE 3.611
CYPRINIDAE 1.279
CENTRARCHIDAE 3.811
COENAQRIONIDAE(AORIONIDAE) 87.660
CYPRINIDAE
U.UUU
1.279
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240
CENTRARCHIDAE 3.111
COENAGRIONIDAE(AGRIONIDAE) 87.690
SALMONIDAE 0,664
CYPRINIDA6
PTERONAHCIDAE
NEBRASKA 6
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
NEVADA 6
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECIL
DAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
NEW HAMPSHIRE 6
NEW JERSEY 5
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN
CATOST
DAE
OMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
NEW MEXICO 8
NEW YORK 6
NORTH CAROLINA !
NORTH DAKOTA 7
OHIO e
OKLAHOMA 9
OREGON 9
PENNSYLVANIA 6
RHODE ISLAND 6
SOUTH CAROLINA 4
SOUTH DAKOTA 7
CENTRA
GAMMA
RCHIDAE
RIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN
PTERON
CATOST
DAE
ARCIDAE
OMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN
CATOST
CENTRA
SALMOr
CATOST
CENTRA
QAMMA
DAE
OMIDAE
RCHIDAE
IIDAE
OMIDAE
RCHIDAE
RIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN
CATOST
CENTRA
SALMOr
CYPRIN
CATOST
CENTRA
SALMOh
CYPRIN
CENTRA
QAMMA
DAE
OMIDAE
RCHIDAE
IIDAE
DAE
OMIDAE
RCHIDAE
IIDAE
DAE
RCHIDAE
RIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRA
GAMMA
RCHIDAE
RIDAE
1.ZW
2.300
3.240
0.184
1.279
3.240
3.811
0.964
3.700
3.811
5.800
O.S64
1.279
3.240
3.811
0.664
3.240
3.811
8.000
0.684
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.684
1279
3.240
3.811
0.664
3240
3.811
8.000
0.664
1.279
3.240
3.811
0.6(4
1.279
1240
3411
0.664
1.279
3.811
5.800
0.684
3.811
5.800
COENAORIONIDAEIAQRIONIOAE) 87.660
SALMONIDAE 0.6(4
CYPRIN
CATOST
DAE
OMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN
CATOST
CENTRA
DAE
OMIDAE
RCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CATOST
CENTRA
OMIDAE
RCHIDAE
1279
3.240
3.811
0.664
1.279
3.240
3.811
0.6(4
3.240
3.811
COEN AORIONIOAE (AORIONIDAE) 87.650
SALMONIDAE 0.0(4
CYPRIN
CATOST
DAE
OMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
1.279
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 10-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (+) (++)
0.149 *
0.148 *
0.208 *
**
0.036 *
0.196 *
0.149 *
0.109 *
0.149 *
0.147 *
0.196 *
0.149 *
0.147 *
0.1(1 *
0.149 *
0.106 *
0.029 *
0.149 *
0.149 *
0.019 *
0.161 *
0.0782
0.0782
0.1064
0.0185
0,1003
0.0762
0.0844
0.0782
0.0781
0.1003
0.0762
0.0791
0.0823
0.07(2
O.OB45
0.0148
0.0762
0.0762
0.0096
0.0823
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACH
FOOTNOTE
* - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
., ,. _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
ACR KS^STO CHRON,C RAT,O METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
STATE
TENNESSEE
• TEXAS
UTAH
VERMONT
VIRGINIA
WASHINGTON
WEST VIRGINIA
WISCONSIN
WYOMING
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
S
4
8
6
6
6
6
6
8
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME tCW VALVE
(+)
SALMONIDAE 0.664
CYPHINIDAE 1.279
CATOSTOMIDAE 3.240
CENTRARCHIDAE 3.811
CYPRINIDAE 1279
POECILIIDAE 3.700
CENTRAHCHIDAE 3.811
COENAQRIONIOAEIAGRIONIDAE) 87.650
SALMONIDAE 0.66*
CYPRINIDAE 1.279
PTERONARCIDAE 2.300
CATOSTOMIDAE 3240
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
. . _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
« _ NO INDIGENOUS 8ALMONID FISH IN STATE
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OH
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
0.664
1 279
3240
3.811
0.664
1.279
3.240
3.811
0.664
2.300
3.811
6.800
0.664
1278
3240
3.811
0.664
1279
3240
3.811
0.664
1279
2.300
3.240
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + ) <*) (++>
0.137 * 0.0701 ACR
0.039 * 0.0198 ACR
0.198 * 0.1003 ACR
0.149 * 0.0762 ACR
0.149 * 0.07(2 ACR
0.1(3 * 0.0787 ACR
0.137 * 0.0701 ACR
0.149 * 0.0762 ACR
0.196 * 0.1003 ACR
C-1.
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA. BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: ENDRIN
TOXICANT: ENDRIN
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC90 VALUE
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAOE
STATE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 90-DAY AVERAOE
(+) 1+) (++)
ARKANSAS
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
GEORGIA
MASSACHUSETTS
QASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440
SALMONIDAE 0.468
PERLIDAE 0.493
PTERONARCIDAE 0.847
SALMONIOAE 0.894
CYPRINIOAE 0.732
POECILIIDAE 0.750
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
SALMONIDAE 0357
PERLIDAE 0.483
PTERONARCIDAE 0.647
POECILIIDAE 0.949
CYPRINIDAE 0.732
POECILIIDAE 0.790
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
PALAEMONIDAE 1.265
QASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440
SALMONIDAE 0488
PERUDAE 0.493
POECILIIDAE 0.949
SALMONIDAE 0.320
PERLIDAE 0.493
PTERONARCIDAE 0.647
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
GASTEROSTEIOAE 0.440
SALMONIDAE . 0.666
CENTRARCHIDAE 1X111
CYPRINIDAE 1.088
QASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440
SALMONIDAE 0.604
POECILIIDAE 0.750
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
CYPRINODONTIDAE 0.890
POECILIIDAE 0.949
CENTRARCHIDAE 1X111
CYPRINIDAE 2.100
SALMONIDAE 0.558
POECIUIDAE 0.790
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
COENAOHIONIDAE(AORIONIDAE) 1.800
SALMONIDAE 0.468
PERLIDAE 0.493
PTERONARCIDAE 0.847
POECILIIDAE 0.790
SALMONIOAE 0.701
CYPRINIDAE 0.732
POECIUIDAE 0.790
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
SALMONIDAE 0.701
CYPRINIDAE 0.732
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
COENAORIONIDAEIAQRIONIDAE) 1.800
CYPRINIDAE 0.732
POECIUIDAE 0.750
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
PALAEMONIDAE 1.285
CYPRINIDAE 0.732
POECIUIDAE 0.750
CENTRARCHIDAE 1X111
COENAGRIONIOAEIAQRIONIDAE) 1.800
SALMONIDAE 0.884
CYPRINIDAE 0.732
POECIUIDAE 0.790
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
SALMONIDAE 0.471
CYPRINIDAE 0.732
POECIUIDAE 0.710
CENTRARCHIDAE 1X111
OASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440
SALMONIDAE 0.458
CYPRIN1DAE 0.562
COENAQRIONIOAEIAORIONIDAE) 1.800
OASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440
SALMONIDAE 0.526
CYPRINIDAE 0.732
POECIUIOAE 0.730
QASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440
SALMONIDAE 0.938
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
CYPRINIDAE 1.086
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECIUIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
0-625
0.732
0.7SO
1.011
0.687
0.732
0.750
1.011
0.732
0.780
1.011
1.265
0.732
0.790
1.011
1.266
0.363
0.493
0.647
1.011
0.566
0.732
1.011
0.133
0.232 *
NEW HAMPSHIRE
NEW JERSEY
NEW MEXICO
NORTH CAROLINA
NORTH DAKOTA
0.0023
0.0023
FRV
PENNSYLVANIA
RHODE ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
SOUTH DAKOTA
COENAQR10NIDAE(AQRIONIOA£) 1.800
PERUDAE 0.320
SALMONIDAE 0.357
PTERONARCIDAE OJ40
POECIUIOAE 0.049
SALMONIDAE 0.556
CYPRINIOAE 0.562
CENTRARCHIDAE 14111
COENAORIONIDAEIAQfilONIDAE) 1.800
QASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440
SALMONIDAE 0.998
POECILIIDAE 0.790
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
SALMONIDAE 0.357
PERUDAE 0.493
PTERONARCIDAE 0.847
POECILIIDAE 0.750
QASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440
SALMONIDAE 0.687
CYPRINIDAE 0.732
POECILIIDAE 0.790
SALMONIDAE 0.556
POECILIIDAE 0.790
CENTRARCHIDAE 1X11
COENAQRIONIDAE(AQRIONIDAE) 1.800
SALMONIDAE OM4
CYPRINIOAE 0.732
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
QAMMARIDAE 6.874
SALMONIDAE 0.566
CYPRINIDAE 0.732
POECILIIDAE 0.750
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
SALMONIDAE 0.894
CYPRINIDAE 0.732
POECILIIDAE 0.790
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
PERUDAE 0.320
QASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440
SALMONIDAE 0.466
PTERONARCIDAE 0.540
OASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440
SALMONIDAE 0.968
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
CYPRINIDAE 1.068
OASTEROSTEIOAE 0.4*0
SALMONIDAE 0.966
CENTRARCHIDAE 14111
CYPRINIDAE 1.086
SALMONIDAE 0.556
POECILIIDAE 0.790
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
COENAOHIONIDAEIAORIONIDAE) 1.800
PERUOAE 0.493
SALMONIDAE 0.894
CYPRINIOAE 0.732
CENTRARCHIDAE 14111
0.0023 FRV
0X023 FRV
00023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0X023 FRV
0X023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0X023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
OXO23 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0X023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
C-16
FOOTNOTE
t - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
• t - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
** — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES—NATIONAL VALUE USED
* — NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
I - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
-------
, APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: ENDRIN
NUMBER OF
8™E FAMILIES TESTED
TENNESSEE 9
• TEXAS 8
UTAH g
VERMONT e
VIRGINIA g
WASHINGTON 10
WESTVIROINIA 6
WISCONSIN 8
WYOMING g
TOXICANT: HEPTACHLOR
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
(+)
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
0.694
0.732
0.750
1.011
0.949
1.011
1.086
1.285
0.367
n4QA
PTERONARCIDAE 0.647
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
SALMONIDAE 0.566
CYPRINIDAE 0,562
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
COENAGRIONIDAE(ASRIONIDAE) 1.800
SALMONIDAE 0.596
CYPRINIDAE 0.732
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
COENAQRIONIDAE(AQRIONIDAE) 1.600
QASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440
SALMONIDAE 0.498
PERLIDAE 0.493
PTERONARCIDAE 0.77S
SALMONIDAE 0.566
CYPRINIDAE 0.732
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
COENAQRIONIDAE(AORIONIDAE) 1.800
SALMONIDAE 0.626
CYPRINIDAE 0.732
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
PALAEMONIDAE 1.295
SALMONIDAE 0.357
PERU DAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
U.4N3
0.647
1.011
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAOE
0.284 * 0.0023 FRV
0,418 * 0.0023 FRV
0.126 * 0.0023 FRV
0.141 * 0.0023 FRV
0.175 * 0.0023 FRV
0.165 * 0.0023 FRV
0.163 * 0,0023 FRV
0.231 * 0.0023 FRV
0.128 * 0.0023 FRV
t _ UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
, t - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
ACR ESSJSOW «S? TO CHRONIC RAT,O METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
STATE
NATIONAL
ALABAMA
ARIZONA
ARKANSAS
CALIFORNIA
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
• FLORIDA
1 QEORQIA
IDAHO
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
• KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
MASSACHUSETTS
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
10
5
6
5
7
7
5
4
4
7
6
5
5
4
4
5
4
5
6
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAOE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTEflONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
** _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
• - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
i - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
0.995 0.251 *
1.800
2.800
7.800
1.600 0.243 *
13.058
24.771
60.748
0.995 0.142 *
2.800
13.068
29.000
1.800 0.202 *
7.800
24.771
60.748
2.800 0.898 *
26.000
29.000
29.498
0.999 0.125 *
2.800
13.098
26.000
13.058 3.521 *
26.000
47.329
50.748
13.058 3.521 *
26.000
47.329
60.748
24.771 2.873 *
90.748
148.000
319.999
13.098 0.857 *
24.771
50.748
319.999
0.9D6 0.117 *
2.800
17.703
26.000
1.800 0.311 *
24.771
28.488
47.329
24.771 8.107 *
29.498
47.329
90.748
1.800 0.245 *
20.000
47.328
50.748
7.600 0.768 *
26.000
50.748
179.608
13.068 1.384 *
24.771
50.748
179.508
1.800 0.208 *
24.771
50.748
81.900
29.000 7.775 *
60.748
81.900
100.897
28.000 9.159 *
33.702
47.329
60.748
13.098 3.521 *
26.000
47.329
50.748
0.0036
0.0038
0,0038
0.0038
0.0038
0.0038
0.0038
0.0038
0.0038
0.0038
0.0038
0.0036
0.0038
0.0038
0.0038
0.0038
0.0038
0.0038
0.0038
0.0038
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FHV
FHV
FHV
C-17
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA. BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: HEPTACHLOR
TOXICANT: HEPTACHLOR
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAOE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
(+1
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) l+l (++>
NEW HAMPSHIRE
NEW JERSEY
NEW MEXICO
NORTH CAROLINA
NORTH DAKOTA
PENNSYLVANIA
RHODE ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
SOUTH DAKOTA
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
A8TACIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CVPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PERUDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
1.600
26.000
29.496
97.048
17.703
26.000
37.046
50.746
1.600
24.H1
90.746
179.506
1.800
7.800
24.771
90.746
0.999
2.600
26.000
29.000
13.096
26.000
S&S66
178.506
0.900
13.056
».000
29.000
13.058
29.000
90.746
13.066
28.000
47.329
90.748
0.995
1BCO
13.058
24.771
1.800
17.703
24.771
37.048
13.056
24.771
47.329
50.746
13058
26.000
29.000
98.506
1.800
13.058
24.771
47.329
1.600
7.800
13.058
24.771
0.900
28.000
20000
29.498
1400
13.098
24.771
47.329
13.068
20.000
47.329
90.748
13.068
24.771
90.748
319.999
5.800
13.068
26.000
29.000
0.857
0.0038 FHV
0.0038 FRV
0.0036 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0036 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0036 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0039 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PERUOAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
WEST VIRGINIA
WYOMINQ
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PERUOAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
1.800 0.243 *
13.058
24.771
90.748
1.800 0.234 *
7.800
24.771
90.748
0.995 0.129 »
£800
13.096
26.000
13.058 3.708 *
28.000
37.048
90.748
13.068 3.448 »
24.771
47.329
80.748
1,100 0.112 *
2.600
26.000
29.000
13.068 1.429 *
26,000
90.748
179.908
1JOO 0.331 *
28.000
29.498
37.048
0.995 0.125 *
2.600
13.068
28.000
0,0038
FRV
C-18
FOOTNOTE
* - UNITS IN MICROOHAMS PER LITER
t » - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
KV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
- FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
- STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
— NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
— HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM ANCHOR
30-DAY AVERAQE CRITERIA
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: LEAD
STATE
NATIONAL
ALABAMA
ARIZONA
ARKANSAS
CALIFORNIA
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
» FLORIDA
OEOflGIA
IDAHO
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
* KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
MASSACHUSETTS
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FAMILIES TESTED NAME
7 QAMMARIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
6 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
4 QAMMARIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
6 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
4 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
4 CENTRARCHIDAE
POECIUIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
4 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
5 DAPHNIDAE
ALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
5 QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
4 QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
3 CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
5 QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
3 CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
3 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
LCSO VALUE
<+) (1)
1.161
4.020
60.082
356.792
158.196
356.792
455.019
603.845
4.020
80.062
356.792
455.015
1.161
398.792
466.015
803.845
4.020
80.082
308.792
455.015
4.020
166.156
368.792
456.015
80.082
356.792
455.016
803.845
158.198
455.015
803345
814.803
495.015
532.856
803.845
814.803
80.062
495.015
803.845
814,803
4.020
80062
358.782
465.019
1.161
168.196
366.792
. 455.015
196.198
358.792
459.019
803.845
1.161
358.792
459.019
803.846
368.792
456.015
803.649
mi56
358.792
459.016
396.7(2
455.015
803.845
0000
40629
167.991
803.845
0000
84062
396.792
456.015
603.645
80.082
368.792
455.015
803.645
TOXICANT: LEAD
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
<+) (I)
0.037 *
37.382 *
0.359 *
0.035 *
0.359 *
0.326 *
14.989 *
36.499 *
155.455 *
14.070 *
0.287 *
0.059 *
37462 *
0.035 *
0.037 *
**
0.050 *
0.037 *
**
0.037 *
**
14.988 *
14.989. *
3»DAY AVERAOE
(+) (++) If)
0.00003 FCV
0.00004 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.00004 FCV
4.4479 ACR
0.00004 FCV
0.00002 FCV
0.00004 FCV
0.00004 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.00004 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.00004 FCV
FOOTNOTE *
+ — UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
t , _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUUO BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
STATE
MICHIGAN
MINNESOTA
» MISSISSIPPI
MISSOURI
MONTANA
NEBRASKA
NEVADA
NEW HAMPSHIRE
NEW JERSEY
NEW MEXICO
NEW YORK
NORTH CAROLINA
NORTH DAKOTA
OHIO
OKLAHOMA
OREGON
PENNSYLVANIA
RHODE ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
SOUTH DAKOTA
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
5
4
4
3
9
5
8
4
4
5
S
4
5
4
5
9
4
4
4
S
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME L
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECELIIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDA6
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
. « _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
( - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAQE CRITERIA
560 VALUE
<+) <*>
1.161
80.062
356.792
455.010
80.062
358.792
455.015
803.845
1.181
358.792
456.016
803.646
396.792
496.016
603.645
0.000
4.020
80.062
358.792
455.015
4.020
80.062
356.792
465.015
4.020
80.062
466.015
932^58
80.082
157.991
455.015
803.845
60.082
455.015
803.845
814.803
4.020
60.062
356.792
455.015
1.161
80.082
358.792
465.016
80.082
466.015
803.849
814.803
4.020
158.158
358.792
456.019
60.082
356.792
456.016
803.445
1.161
158.196
356.792
495.016
4.020
80.082
455.015
803.845
80.062
358.792
455.015
803.846
80.062
358.792
465.019
803.645
80.082
465.015
803.846
814.803
4.020
158.198
368.792
455.015
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(•*•) <*>
0.054 *
14.969 *
0.035 *
0.037 »
**
0.287 *
0.287 *
0.322 *
10.748 *
14.070 *
0.287 *
0.064 *
14.070 *
0.326 *
14.969 *
0.099 *
0.219 *
14.989 *
14.969 *
14.070 *
0.325 *
30-DAY
<+) (-H
0.00004
0.00004
0.0010
0.00003
0.00003
0.00004
0.00003
0.00003
0.00004
0.00004
0.00004
0.00003
0.00003
0.00004
0.00003
0.00002
0.00004
0.00003
0.00003
0.00003
AVERAQE
FCV
FCV
ACR
FCV
(
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FOV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
FCV
C-19
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: LEAD
TOXICANT: LINDANE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TE8TEO
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
(+) 16)
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM SO-DAY AVERAGE
1+) IB (+) (++) (*)
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCM VALUE
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAOE
(tl (*) (+t)
WASHINGTON
WEST VIRGINIA
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PHtLODINIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAC
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHtLODINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
1.161
158.156
358.792
499.015
358.792
459.019
532856
803445
4.020
80.062
356.782
499.015
0.287
398.702
4S9.01S
80.082 10.748 *
197.081
499.015
14.980
4.020 0.219 * 0.00002 FCV
80.082
456.015
803.845
80.092 14.980 * 0.00004 FCV
368.792
455.015
803.845
1.181 0.094 * 0.00004 FCV
80.082
358.792
455.015
4.020 0.287 * 0.00003 FCV
80.082
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
485.015
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MASSACHUSETTS
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ICTALUfllDAE
SALMONIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
ASELLIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
PERCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PERCIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
10.000
21.088
22.437
52.871
32.031
52.871
93.068
94.805
14.188
42.198
53.088
2.000
10.000
52J71
53.089
21.988
42.198
53.068
8.004 2.320 *
42.198
48.000
53.068
10488 1.629 *
14.198
42.198
88.000
6.004 1.498 *
10.488
42.199
44.000
44.000 10.720 *
52.871
112.694
138.000
37.688 10.138 *
52.S71
53.066
112.894
16.385 8480 *
42.168
2.011
1(466
52.871
10.468 2.889 *
18.458
82.871
OJS2 *
94.605
8.004 1.133 *
10.000
82.671
58,066
46.277 13.938 *
52.871
53.066
4.856 *
•4.000
10.000
2.000
10.468
42.198
42.188
93.066
46.000
10.466
18.933
42.196
64.000
10.488
14.198
42.198
0.2574 ACR
0.7600 ACR
0.4086 ACR
0.0198 ACR
0.8814 ACR
0.1896 ACR
0.1483 ACR
0.1196 ACR
0.8675 ACR
0.8110 ACR
0.9343 ACR
0.1809 ACR
0.2148 ACR
0.0281 ACR
1.1512 ACR
0.0906 ACR
1.1149 ACR
0.3*44 ACR
0.197* ACR
0.1798 ACR
C-20
FOOTNOTE
•f — UNITS IN MICROGHAMS PER LITER
•f > — FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
* - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-OAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: LINDANE
„,._ NUMBER OF
8T*TE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN g
MINNESOTA g
* MISSISSIPPI 5
MISSOURI g
MONTANA g
NEBRASKA g
NEVADA g
NEW HAMPSHIRE 0
NEW JERSEY 7
NEW MEXICO 7
NEW YORK 7
NORTH CAROLINA 7
NORTH DAKOTA g
OHIO g
OKLAHOMA 6
OREGON 7
PENNSYLVANIA 7
"HODE ISLAND 6
SOUTH CAROLINA 9
SOUTH DAKOTA 7
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCU VALUE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
PERC4DAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
(+)
21.988
22.437
42.198
93.088
18.355
22.437
42.198
93.066
10.000
52.871
944)06
2.000
52.871
93.066
94809
18.933
42.198
48.000
93.088
14.198
42.198
93.068
684)00
14.198
42.198
48.000
93.066
14.198
42.198
48.000
68.000
10.468
14.158
42.198
44.000
14.196
48.000
92.871
93.088
18.399
22.437
52.871
93.068
10.488
14.198
52.871
84.000
32.031
42.198
48.000
93.066
10.488
14.198
92471
93.066
32.031
48.000
92.871
93.068
21.988
42.196
48.000
68000
10.488
14.198
92.871
93.088
10.486
14,158
42.198
98.000
37.669
52.871
68.000
112.694
8.004
42.198
48.000
93.066
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM SO-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (
6.801 *
5.618 *
2.174 *
0.289 *
7.340 *
4.196 *
5.390 *
4.220 *
2.423 *
4.794 *
9.097 *
1.992 *
13.875 *
2288 *
13.466 *
7.738 *
2.099 *
1.829 *
10.829 *
2.320 *
H I++I
0.9281 ACR
0.4494 ACR
0.1730 ACR
0.0228 ACR
0.5872 ACR
0.3358 ACR
0.4312 ACR
0.3378 ACR
0.1938 ACR
0.3839 ACR
0.4049 ACR
0.1961 ACR
1.1099 ACR
0.1812 ACR
1.0772 ACH
0.6190 ACR
0.1679 ACR
0.1493 ACR
0.8680 ACR
0.1S98 ACR
FOOTNOTE
* - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
» > _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COM PUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SOU SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: LINDANE
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
TENNESSEE 9
« TEXAS 6
UTAH 8
VERMONT 6
VIRGINIA 6
WASHINGTON 6
WEST VIRGINIA 9
WISCONSIN 8
WYOMING 8
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCU VALUE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
PERCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
*• _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
• — NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
t - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
1+)
8.004
924171
93.066
94.809
52.871
93.068
68.000
94.809
14.198
42.198
48.000
93.086
14.168
22.437
42.198
68.000
10.488
14.198
52.871
88.000
21968
42.198
46.000
64.000
14.158
42.198
93066
94.805
21.988
22,437
42.198
934166
14.198
42.198
464)00
834)66
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 80-DAY AVERAGE
<+) (+) (4-4-1
1.607 * 0.1285 ACR
17.797 * 1.4237 ACH
8.119 * 0.4098 ACR
3.342 * 0.2713 ACR
1.740 * 0.1392 ACR
8.282 * 0.8826 ACR
3.348 * 02676 ACR
6.801 * 0.9281 ACR
8.119 * . 0.4098 ACR
C-21
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: MERCURY
STATE F
NATIONAL
ALABAMA
ARIZONA
ARKANSAS
CALIFORNIA
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
• FLORIDA
GEORGIA
IDAHO
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
1 KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
MASSACHUSETTS
C-22
TOXICANT: MERCURY
NUMBER OF
MULIES TESTED
g
9
9
4
9
9
5
9
3
9
5
6
9
3
2
4
4
6
9
9
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
ASTACIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
NAIDIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
LC50 VALUE
<+)
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.299
10.000
20.000
248.599
783.471
5000
10.000
248.596
783.471
10.000
20.000
783.471
989.998
9.000
10.000
244.299
783471
6.000
10.000
248.999
783.471
10.000
90.000
246.999
783.471
(0.000
50.000
248.595
783.471
204X10
783.471
990.998
0.000
20.000
248.599
783.471
899.88B
5.000
10.000
248.595
783.471
10.000
244.259
783.471
999.998
10.000
244.259
783.471
999.999
10.000
783.471
899.998
0.000
783.471
999.996
0.000
10.000
248.599
783.471
999.998
20.000
240.000
783.471
999.998
10.000
50.000
240.000
783.471
10.000
50.000
244.256
783471
10.000
90.000
248.585
783.471
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + ) ( + ) (++)
0.470 * 0.20 FRV
0.347 * 0.20 FRV
0.101 * 0.0871 ACR
0.170 * 0.1133 ACR
0.101 * 0.0674 ACR
0.101 * 0.0871 ACR
0.829 * 0.20 FRV
0.629 * 0.20 FRV
0.470 * 0.20 FRV
**
2.048 * 0.20 FRV
0.101 * 0.0671 ACR
1.000 * 0.20 FRV
0.606 * 0.20 FRV
0.470 * 0.20 FRV
**
0.470 * 0.20 FRV
**
0.838 * 0.20 FRV
1.884 * 0.20 FRV
0.767 * 0.20 FRV
0.831 * 0.20 FRV
0.629 * 0.20 FRV
- UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
- FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE
MICHIGAN
MINNESOTA
* MISSISSIPPI
MISSOURI
MONTANA
NEBRASKA
NEVADA
NEW HAMPSHIRE
NEW JERSEY
NEW MEXICO
NEW YORK
NORTH CAROLINA
NORTH DAKOTA
OKLAHOMA
OREGON
PENNSYLVANIA
RHODE ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
SOUTH DAKOTA
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
7
5
4
3
9
4
5
9
4
9
6
4
t
»
5
S
7
5
4
5
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME U
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMON 1 DAE
PHILODINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
* - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
1 - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
:w VALUE
(+)
10.000
244.299
783.471
999.999
10.000
246.695
783.471
998.988
10.000
20.000
783.471
998.986
10.000
783.471
999.996
0.000
5.000
10.000
244.299
783.471
8.000
248.996
783.471
999.996
9.000
10.000
248.599
783471
10.000
50.000
248.505
783.471
10.000
24&59S
783471
888986
s!ooo
10.000
246.695
783471
10.000
50.000
248486
783.471
10.000
246486
781471
999.996
8.000
10.000
248.596
783.471
10.000
246408
763.471
999.996
10.000
20.000
246.999
783.471
tax
10.000
244,268
783.471
10.000
50.000
248486
783.471
10.000
60.000
248.699
783.471
20400
783471
899.998
5.000
10400
248495
783.471
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(•*•)
1.222 *
0.806 *
0.170 *
0.470 *
**
0.101 *
0.240 *
0.101 *
0.629 *
0.839 *
0.101 *
0.764 *
0.839 *
0.101 *
1403 *
0.347 *
0.101 *
0.819 *
0429 *
1.860 *
0.101 *
»DAY AVERAOE
( + ) (++)
020 FRV
0.20 FRV
0.1133 ACR
020 FRV
0.0874 ACR
0.1602 ACR
0.0671 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
04671 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
04671 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
04874 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
0.0671 ACR
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: MERCURY
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
"ATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCM VALUE MAXIMUM 80-DAY AVERAGE
l+l 1+1 (+) (++>
TENNESSEE
TEXAS
UTAH
VERMONT
VIRGINIA
WASHINGTON
WEST VIRGINIA
WISCONSIN
WYOMING
4 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIOIDAE
3 ASTACIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
5 DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
5 GAMMARIOAE
ASTACIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
6 QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
5 DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
6 OAMMARIDAE
ASTACIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
7 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
5 DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
10.000 0.639 *
248.595
783.471
989.995
20.000 0.470 *
783.471 **
999.096
0000
5.000 0.101 *
10.000
248.595
783.471
10.000 0.529 *
50.000
246.595
783.471
10.000 0.764 *
50.000
248.59!
783.471
5.000 0.101 *
10.000
244.259
783.471
10.000 0.764 *
50.000
246.595
783.471
10.000 1.222 *
244.259
783.471
999.908
6.000 0.101 *
10.000
248.595
783.471
0.20 FflV
0.20 FHV
0.0671 ACR
0.20 FHV
0.20 ' FRV
0.0674 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
0.0671 ACR
TOXICANT: NICKEL
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCJO VALUE
(+) (8)
NATIONAL
ALABAMA
ARIZONA
ARKANSAS
CALIFORNIA
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
« FLORIDA
GEORGIA
IDAHO
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
• KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
MASSACHUSETTS
It
11
10
10
10
9
12
12
11
10
8
13
12
11
10
11
10
13
12
12
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PEBCICHTHYIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILONNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.458
301.510
325842
401.217
66.077
301.510
401.217
439,825
78.498
325442
401.217
439.825
85.077
301.510
401.217
439.825
65.077
401 .217
439.825
509.264
78.458
401.217
439.825
444.717
78.458
401.217
439.825
444.717
78.458
301.510
401.217
439425
78.498
301410
325.842
401 .217
85477
401 .217
439425
444.717
78.486
233.555
301.510
341472
78.456
301410
348.472
401.217
78.455
328442
401.217
439826
78.456
301410
325442
401.217
78.458
301410
315.842
401217
78.456
301410
401.217
4J9-B2S
76.458
361380
401.217
439.825
78.456
345.472
401.217
439425
78.488
346.472
401.217
439.825
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM »DAY AVERAGE
I*) (» (+) <++) Ol
32.914 *
31.618 *
23.345 •
29.224 *
23.385 *
21.349 *
33.128 *
33.128 *
30436 *
29.888 *
20.057 *
34.981 *
33472 *
31.086 *
29.888 •
31.618 *
29.005 *
35.268 *
33.129 *
33.129 *
3.3931 ACR
3.2596 ACR
2.4087 ACR
3.0127 ACR
2.4087 ACR
2.2009 ACR
3.4152 ACR
3.4152 ACR
3.1791 ACR
3.0791 ACR
2.0177 ACR
3.6082 ACR
3.4404 ACR
3.2047 ACR
3.0791 ACR
3.2806 ACR
2.9901 ACR
34345 ACR
3.4153 ACR
3.4153 ACR
FO?TN - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
™R COMPUTED •YEACUTE!TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE w
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
. . _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
f - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
J - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
AFPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
C-23
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: NICKEL
STATE
MICHIGAN
MINNESOTA
» MISSISSIPPI
MISSOURI
MONTANA
NEBRASKA
NEVADA
NEW HAMPSHIRE
NEW JERSEY
NEW MEXICO
NEW YORK
NORTH CAROLINA
NORTH DAKOTA
OHIO
OKLAHOMA
OREGON
PENNSYLVANIA
RHODE ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
SOUTH DAKOTA
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
13
11
11
11
9
10
9
12
12
11
13
12
10
12
11
9
13
12
11
11
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
POECILIIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
(+) (S)
78.456
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.456
325.842
401.217
439.825
78.458
301.510
325.842
401.217
78.456
301.510
345.472
401.217
65.077
401.217
439.825
444.717
65.077
301.510
401.217
439.825
65.077
401.217
439.825
456.642
78.458
345.472
401.217
439.825
78.458
345.472
401.217
439.825
65.077
301.510
401.217
439.825
78.456
345.472
401.217
439.825
78.458
345.472
401.217
439.825
65.077
325.842
401.217
439.825
78.456
345.472
401.217
439.825
78.456
301.510
329.842
401.217
66.077
301.510
401.217
439.825
78.456
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.456
401.217
439.825
444.717
78.458
401.217
439.825
444.717
65.077
325.842
401.217
439.825
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (S)
33.660 *
31.086 *
31.618
31.576 *
21.717 *
23.365 *
21.658 *
33.129 *
33.129 •
25.017 *
35.068 *
33.129 *
23.512 *
33.129 *
31.616 *
21.753 *
33.660 *
33.128 *
31.123 *
25.188 *
( + ) (++) (1)
3.4906 ACR
3.2047 ACR
3.2596 ACR
3.2553 ACR
2.2388 ACR
2.4087 ACR
^
2.2327 ACR
3.4153 ACR
3.4153 ACR
2.5790 ACR
3.6172 ACR
3.4153 ACR
2.4238 ACR
3.4153 ACR
3.2596 ACR
2.2425 ACR
3.4906 ACR
3.4152 ACR
3.2085 ACR
2.5966 ACR
FOOTNOTE
* - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
+ f - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDU
ACR COMPUTED BY
FCV FINAL CHRON
E VALUE
ACUTE TO CHRC
C VALUE
}NIC RATIO METHOD
;.34 SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: NICKEL
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
TENNESSEE 11
» TEXAS 11
UTAH 9
VERMONT 12
VIRGINIA 13
WASHINGTON 8
WEST VIRGINIA 11
WISCONSIN 13
WYOMING 9
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTflAflCHIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
« — NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
$ — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIM
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
UM AND/OR
(+> It)
78.486
301.510
325.842
401.217
78.456
301.510
401.217
439.825
65.077
301.510
401.217
439.825
78.456
345.472
401.217
439.825
78.456
345.472
401.217
438.825
68.077
401.217
439.825
444.717
78.458
328.842
401.217
439.825
78.456
233555
345.472
401.217
65.077
401.217
439.825
444.717
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 90-DAY AVERAGE
«•> (>) (+> <++) II)
31.618 * 3.2596 ACR
30.838 * 3.1791 ACR
21.753 * 2.2425 ACR
33.129 * 3.4153 ACR
35.088 * ' 3.6172 ACR
20.057 * 2.0877 ACR
31.086 * 3.2047 ACR
33.860 * 3.4906 ACR
21.717 * 2.2388 ACR
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: PCBS
STATE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCHVALUE
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
TOXICANT: PCBS
STATE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
ALABAMA
5 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
IZi LU
2.000 0.137 *
6411
32401
M.563
2.000 0.064 *
8.611
32,801
'T'
0.014
0.014
IT.TI_
FRV
FRV
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
LCSOVALUE
1*1
FRESHWATER AOUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
L!J 1+1 (++)
ARIZONA
ARKANSAS
CALIFORNIA
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
» FLORIDA
QEOHQIA
IDAHO
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
• KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
MASSACHUSETTS
COENAQRIONIDAE (AQRIONIDAE) S8S.S42
SALMONIDAE 2.000
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.300
CYPRINIDAE 32.801
0.000
CENTRARCHIOAE «.«11 0.520 * 0.014
CYPRINIOAE 32.101
QAMMARIDAE 82.064
COENAQRIONIOAE (AORIONIDAE) 282442
SALMONIDAE 2.000 0.137 * 0.014
CENTRARCHIOAE 2.300 •*
CYPRINIDAE 32.801
0.000
SALMONIOAE 2.000 0.137 * 0.014
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.300 **
CYPRINIDAE 32.801
0.000
SALMONIDAE 2.000 0.060 * 0.014
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.300
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
QAMMARIDAE 107.664
SALMONIDAE 2.000 0.020 * 0.014
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.300
QAMMARIOAE 107.664
COENAQRIONIDAE (AQRIONIDAE) 282.842
CENTRARCHIOAE 6.611 0.137 * 0.014
0.000 **
0.000
0000
SALMONIDAE 1000 0.137 * 0.014
CENTRARCHIDAE 6.811 **
COENAQRIONIDAE(AQRIONIDAE) 262442
0000
SALMONIDAE £000 0.137 * 0.014
CENTRARCHIOAE 2.300 **
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
0400
SALMONIDAE 2.000 0.137 * 0.014
CENTRARCHIDAE 6.611
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
QAMMARIDAE . M.M3
SALMONIDAE 2.000 0.131 * 0.014
CENTRARCHIDAE 6.611
CYPRINIOAE 32.801
GAMMARIDAE 107.684
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.300 0.131 * 0.014
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
GAMMARIDAE W4S3
COENAORIONIDAE (AQRIONIOAE) 262.642
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.300 0.137 * 0.014
CYPRINIOAE 32.601 **
COENAQRIONIDAE (ASRIONIDAE) 262442
0000
SALMONIDAE 2.000 0.144 * 0.014
CENTRARCHIDAE 6.611
CYPRINIDAE ' 32.601
CENTRARCHIDAE 6411 0.137 * 0.014
CYPRINIOAE 32.601 **
0.000
(LOGO
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.300 0.137 * 0414
CYPRINIOAE 32.601 **
COENASRIONIDAEIAQRIONIDAE) 262.642
0.000
SALMONIOAE 2.000 0.060 * 0.014
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.300
CYPRINIDAE 32.801
QAMMARIDAE 107484
SALMONIDAE 2.000 O.OBO * 0.014
CENTRARCHIOAE 2.300
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
QAMMARIDAE 107.664
« MISSISSIPPI
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
2.000
2.300
32.601
M.B53
2.000
2.300
32.601
107.664
6.S11
32.801
•2.054
NEW HAMPSHIRE
NEW JERSEY
FRY
NORTH CAROLINA
NORTH DAKOTA
FRV
FRY
OREQON
PENNSYLVANIA
RHODE ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
SOUTH DAKOTA
COENAORIONIDAE (AQRIONIDAE) 2SU42
CENTRARCHIDAE 6.611
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
COENAQRIONIDAE (AQRIONIDAE) 282.842
0000
SALMONIDAE 2400
CENTRARCHIDAE 2 300
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
0.000
SALMONIDAE 2.000
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.300
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
COENAQRIONIDAE (AGRIONIDAE) 282.842
SALMONIDAE 2.000
CENTRARCHIDAE 13Ot>
0.000
0.000
SALMONIDAE 2.000
CENTRAHCHIDAE 2.300
CYPRINIOAE 32.801
COENAGHIONIDAE(AaRIONIDAE) 282.842
SALMONIDAE 2400
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.300
QAMMARIOAE 107.664
COENAQRIONIDAE (AORtONIDAQ 282442
SALMONIDAE 2.000
CENTRARCHIDAE 6411
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
0000
SALMONIDAE 2.000
CENTRARCHIOAE 6.611
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
QAMMARIDAE M.883
SALMONIDAE 2.000
CENTRARCHIDAE 6.811
QAMMARIDAE 107484
COENAQRIONIDAE (AQRIONIDAE) 262.642
SALMONIDAE 2.000
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.300
CYPRINIDAE 32401
0.000
SALMONIDAE 2400
CENTRARCHIDAE 6.811
CYPRINIDAE 32401
QAMMARIDAE 107484
SALMONIDAE 2.000
CENTRARCHIDAE 8.611
CYPRINIOAB 32.601
QAMMARIDAE 82.0S4
SALMONIDAE 2.000
CENTRARCHIDAE 2400
0.000
0400
SALMONIDAE 2400
CENTRARCHIDAE 8411
CYPRINIDAE 32401
QAMMARIDAE 107.664
SALMONIDAE 2.000
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.300
CYPRINIDAE 32.801
QAMMARIOAE 107464
SALMONIDAE 2.000
CENTRARCHIDAE 6411
COENAQRIONIDAEIAORIONIDAE) 282.842
0.000
SALMONIDAE 2400
CENTRARCHIDAE 2400
CYPRINIDAE 32.801
0.000
0.083 *
0420 »
0.137 .
**
0.024 *
0.020 *
0.137 *
**
0.131 *
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
0,014 FRV
0.014 FRV
0.014 FHV
0.014 FRV
0414 FRV
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
« - UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
« , _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
• - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
• - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONIO FISH IN STATE
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
C-25
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA. BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: PCBS
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
TENNESSEE 5
« TEXAS 3
TOXICANT: SELENIUM
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
LCW VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
<•*•) <+) < + ) (++)
2.000 0.144 ft 0.014 FRV
6.611
32.801
82.054
6.611 0.137 ft 0.014 FRV
32.801 ft ft
STATE
NATIONAL
ALABAMA
ri
NUMBER OF
MILIES TESTED
10
a
COENAQRION IDAE (AQBIONIDAE) 282.842
UTAH 3
VERMONT 5
VIRGINIA 9
WASHINGTON 2
WEST VIRGINIA 4
WISCONSIN 5
WYOMING 3
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
0.000
2.000 0.137 ft 0.014 FRV
2.300 ft ft
32.601
0.000
2.000 0.080 ft 0.014 FRV
2.300
32.601
107.884
2.000 0.131 * 0.014 FRV
6.611
32.601
107.664
2.000 0.137 ft 0.014 FRV
2.300 ft*
0.000
0.000
2.000 0.024 ft 0.014 FRV
2.300
32.601
(AQRIONIDAE) 282.842
2.000 0.063 ft 0.014 FRV
2.300
32.601
99.553
2.000 0.137 ft 0.014 FRV
2.300 ft*
32.601
0.000
FOOTNOTE
» — UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
t > - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
:-26
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
ARIZONA
ARKANSAS
CALIFORNIA
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
• FLORIDA
GEORGIA
IDAHO
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
t KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
MASSACHUSETTS
8
7
8
7
6
8
8
8
7
8
7
8
7
a
7
5
7
7
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILV
NAME LC
HYALELLIDAE(TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TAUTRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TAUTRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TAUTRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TAUTRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
POECILIIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HVALELLIDAE (TALITRIOAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
1 - NO INDIGENOUS SAL
t - HARDNESS EFFECT
APPLY EQUATION 3.7
MON
NTEF
TOt
ID FISH IN STATE
CEPT VALUE
1ETERMINE MAXIM
UM ANOfOR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
SO VALUE
(+)
339.999
1992.474
6499.979
8479.723
339.999
3889.989
7049.806
9002.438
339.999
1992.474
S479.723
9002.438
339.999
3889.989
9002.438
12999.949
339.999
1992.474
8479.723
9002.438
339.999
1992.474
7049.806
9002.438
339.999
3868.988
8479.723
9002.436
339.999
3889.989
7049.806
12999.945
339.999
3889.989
8499.979
12999.949
339.999
3869.989
8479.723
12999.945
339.999
1992.474
8479.723
9002.438
339.999
3889969
7049.808
9002.438
339.999
3889.969
7049.606
9002.438
339.999
3889.981
9002.438
12999.945
339.999
3889.989
9002.438
12999.945
339.999
3869.989
7049.806
9002.438
339.999
3889.989
9002.438
12899.948
339.999
3108.149
3889.989
10199.973
339.999
3689.989
8479.723
9002.438
339.999
3889.989
8479.723
9002.438
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMU
(+)
82.648
74.102
80.182
56.854
60.162
94.887
54.280
67.472
67.806
M.269
52.431
74.102
64.634
85.749
58.854
74.102
58.854
48.810
82.801
82.801
H
ft
*
*
ft
ft
*
ft
ft
ft
ft
ft
ft
ft
ft
ft
ft
ft
ft
ft
ft
30-DAY
( + )
22.0399
19.7604
16.0431
15.1611
16.0431
14.8364
14.4747
17.9928
18.0818
17.8705
13.9619
19.7804
17.2889
17.5329
15.1611
19.7804
15.1611
12.4828
16.7489
16.7489
AVERAGE
(-M-)
ACfl
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: SELENIUM
TOXICANT: SELENIUM
ST.TC NUMBER OF
ST*TE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN
MINNESOTA
* MISSISSIPPI
MISSOURI
MONTANA
NEBRASKA
NEVADA
NEW HAMPSHIRE
NEW JERSEY
NEW MEXICO
NEW YORK
NORTH CAROLINA
NORTH DAKOTA
OHIO
OKLAHOMA
OREGON
PENNSYLVANIA
RHODE ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
80UTH DAKOTA
t
9
7
7
7
7
8
6
8
8
8
7
7
9
9
6
7
6
7
7
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCM VALUE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 3889.989
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
CYPRINIDAE 9002.438
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 3869,989
SALMONIDAE 6479.723
CYPRINIDAE 9002.438
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.999
OAPHNIDAE 3889.989
CYPRINIDAE 9002.438
POECILIIDAE 12599.948
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 3889.989
CYPRINIDAE 9002.438
POECILIIDAE 12599.946
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 1992.474
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
CYPRINIDAE 9002.438
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 1992.474
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
CYPRINIDAE 9002.438
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 1992.474
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
POECILIIDAE 12999.945
HYALELLIDAE (TALITfilDAE) 339.999
CYPRINIDAE 3109.149
DAPHNIDAE 3889.989
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
HYALELUOAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 3889.989
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
POECILIIDAE 12999.945
HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 1992.474
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
CYPRINIDAE 9002.438
HYALELUOAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 3889.989
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
CYPRINIDAE 9002.438
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 3889.989
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
POECILIIDAE T2999.94B
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 1992.474
SALMONIDAE 7049.808
CYPRINIDAE 9002.438
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 3889.989
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
CYPRINIDAE 9002.436
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.99)
OAPHNIDAE 3889.989
SALMONIDAE 7049.808
CYPRINIDAE 9002.438
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.99)
DAPHNIDAE • 1992.474
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
PHYSIDAE 24099.883
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.99)
DAPHNIDAE 3889.989
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
CYPRINIDAE 9002.438
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.99)
DAPHNIDAE 3689.98)
8ALMONIOAE 8479.723
CYPRINIOAE 9002.43)
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 3889.989
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
POECILIIDAE 12899.946
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 1992.474
SALMONIDAE 7049.808
CYPRINIDAE 9001.438
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
<+) (+1 I++)
72.017 *
81.976 *
58.894 *
58.684 *
62.431 *
52.431 *
94.141 *
68.744 *
88.289 *
60.182 *
72.017 *
57.35) *
64.687 *
81.978 *
84.085 *
29.603 *
62.801 *
64.280 *
97.398 *
94J87 *
19.2044 ACR
21.6601 ACR
15.1611 ACR
18.1611 ACR
13.9616 ACR
13.9816 ACR
14.4376 ACR
15.6849 ACR
174709 ACR
16.0431 ACR
19.2044 ACR
15.Z055 ACR
14.8384 ACR
21.8601 ACR
22.4228 ACR
7.8941 ACR
18.7489 ACR
14.4747 ACR
19.2999 ACR
14.8384 ACH
FOOTNOTEuN|Ts ^ MicROGRAMS PER LITER
, , _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
STATE
TENNESSEE
» TEXAS
UTAH
VERMONT
VIRGINIA
WASHINGTON
WEST VIRGINIA
WISCONSIN
WYOMING
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
8
6
7
6
6
6
7
7
7
MOOT SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME LCM VALUE MAXIMUM 90-DAY AVERAGE
HYALELLIDAE (TAUTHIOAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
OAPHNIDAE •
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIOAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TAUTRIOAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
1 - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONIO FISH IN STATE
i - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
339.999 ' 74.102 * 19.7804
7049.606
9002.438
339.999 69.749 * 175329
3889.989
9002.438
ACR
ttCR
12899.945
•WJ 52.431 » ,3.98,6 ACH
8479.723
9002.438
339.999 58.744 * 15.8849 A^-B
3109.149
847»>23
3069960
8479.723
tCR
9002.438
339.999 29.603 * 7.8941 AHP
1992.474
8479.713
24089.863
339.999 62.801 * 16.7489 AM
8479.723
9001.438
339.999 62.801 « 16.7489 ACR
3889.989
8479.723
9001438
339.999 82.431 * , 13.9816 ACR
1902.474
8479.723
9002.438
C-27
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: SILVER
STATE
NATIONAL
ALABAMA
ARIZONA
ARKANSAS
CALIFORNIA
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
11 FLORIDA
GEORGIA
IDAHO
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
* KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
MASSACHUSETTS
C-28
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
9
5
5
5
5
6
4
3
3
4
6
6
5
5
3
6
3
2
5
4
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
COTTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
SALMONIDAE '
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
COTTIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
LCSO VALUE
<+> It)
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
0.002
0.006
0.021
0.112
0.004
0.011
0.112
5.517
0.002
0.006
0.021
0.112
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.021
0.011
0.021
0.112
5217
0.021
0.112
5517
0.000
0X112
0.112
5.517
0.000
0.004
0.021
0.112
5.517
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.021
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
0.011
0.112
4.106
5.517
0.011
0.112
5.517
0.000
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
0.011
0.112
S.517
0.000
0.011
5517
0.000
0.000
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
0.011
0.021
0.112
5.517
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAOE
<+> (!) (+1 <++) (1)
0.00053 *
0.00035 *
0.00011 *
0.00002 *
0.0001 1 *
0.00030 *
0.00006 *
0.00053 *
**
0.00053 *
**
0.00002 *
0.00030 *
0.00041 *
0.00035 *
0.00021 *
0.00053 *
**
0.00041 *
0.00053 *
*•*
0.00053 *
**
000035 *
0.00006 *
t - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
» „ _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: SILVER
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
MICHIGAN 6
MINNESOTA 5
t MISSISSIPPI 5
MISSOURI 4
MONTANA i
NEBRASKA 5
NEVADA 5
NEW HAMPSHIRE 4
NEW JERSEY 3
NEW MEXICO 6
NEW YORK 6
NORTH CAROLINA 3
NORTH DAKOTA 5
OHIO g
OKLAHOMA 6
OREGON 8
PENNSYLVANIA 5
RHODE ISLAND 4
SOUTH CAROLINA 3
SOUTH DAKOTA 9
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME L
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
COTTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
• - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
t - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OH
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
BM VALUE
(+1 (II
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
0.011
0.021
0.112
4.106
0.004
0.011
0.112
5.517
0.004
0X111
0.112
5.517
0.002
0.011
0.021
0.112
0.002
0.011
0.021
0.112
0.002
0.004
0.021
0.112
0.011
0.021
0.112
5.517
0X121
0.112
6.517
0.000
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.021
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
0.021
0.112
5.517
0.000
0.002
0.011
0X121
0.112
0.004
0.011
0X121
0.112
0.011
0.021
0.112
4.106
0.002
0.004
0.004
0X121
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
0.011
0.021
0.112
5517
0.021
0.112
5.517
0000
0.002
0.011
0.021
0.112
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
<+> (II <+l (++>
0.00041 *
0.00011 *
0.00002 *
0.00001 *
0.00015 *
0.00015 *
0.00008 t
0.00006 *
0.00063 +
**
0.00030 *
0.00041 *
0.00053 *
**
0.00015 *
0.00041 *
0.00014 *
0.00026 *
0.00035 *
0X0006 *
0.00053 *
0.00019 *
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: SILVER
STATE
TENNESSEE
« TEXAS
UTAH
VERMONT
VIRGINIA
WASHINGTON
WEST VIHQINIA
WISCONSIN '
WYOMING
TOXICANT: TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
6
4
6
4
4
6
5
6
6
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
COTTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRA flCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
(+) II)
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
0.011
0.112
4.106
5.517
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.021
0.011
0.021
0.112
6.517
0.011
0.021
0.112
5.517
0.002
0.004
0.004
0.021
0404
0.011
0.021
0.112
0.004
0.011
0421
0.112
0.002
0.004
0.008
0.021
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + ) (J) (+> (++)
0.00041 *
0.00015 *
0.00030 *
0.00006 *
0.00006 *
0.00025 *
0.00035 *
0.00041 *
0.00030 *
FOOTNOJEUN|TS |N M1CBOGRAMS PER LITER
+ + _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALJE
STATE
NATIONAL
ALABAMA
ARIZONA
ARKANSAS
CALIFORNIA
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
* FLORIDA
GEORGIA
IDAHO
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
« KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
MASSACHUSETTS
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
12
7
11
8
9
9
7
6
10
9
8
9
6
7
7
7
S
8
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPfflNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
8ALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
•** _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
• — NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
t - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
l+l
1.300
2.827
3.547
4.725
3.547
4.725
8433
9.190
1.300
2.827
2.848
3.547
3.000
3.647
4.725
8.033
1.300
2.848
3347
S.781
1.300
2.627
2.646
3.547
2.846
6.678
7.429
12400
'2448
4.103
5.251
9.782
4.193
4.725
8.782
14.379
3.547
4.725
&129
9.983
1.300
2.627
2448
3.000
3447
4.725
4444
8.033
3447
4.728
4.944
8433
2.846
3.000
3447
' 6433
2.848
3447
8433
12.000
3.547
4.725
5.251
8.033
3447
4.729
8.033
6.97!
2400
9.195
6450
12400
2448
3400
7.128
8.033
2448
3.647
8.978
7.429
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM JO-DAY AVERAGE
( + >
0437 *
. 1.159 *
0.562 *
0.941 *
0.445 *
0.525 *
0.913 *
1.084 *
0.980 *
1.095 *
0.594 *
1.321 *
1284 *
0.780 *
0.531 *
1269 *
1.187 *
0481 *
0.775 *
0419 *
(+-)
0.0067
0.0188
0.0091
0.0152
0.0072
0.0085
0.0148
0.0176
0.0159
0.0173
0.0091
04214
00208
0.0128
04102
0.0205
04193
0.0094
04126
0.0149
(++)
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
C-29
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: TOXAPHENE
STATE
MICHIGAN
MINNESOTA
» MISSISSIPPI
MISSOURI
MONTANA
NEBRASKA
NEVADA
NEW HAMPSHIRE
NEW JERSEY
NEW MEXICO
NEW YORK
NORTH CAROLINA
NORTH DAKOTA
OHIO
OKLAHOMA
OREGON
PENNSYLVANIA
RHODE ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
SOUTH DAKOTA
C-30
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
9
8
7
7
10
7
10
7
8
10
9
8
8
9
8
8
9
7
6
9
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
1CTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCIDAE
PERLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIOAE
FOOTNOTE
•> - UNITS
+ .,. _ FPV
FRV
ACR
FCV
SCV
LCSO VALUE
2.848
3.547
5.781
6.033
2448
3.547
5.223
8.033
3447
4.725
8.033
14479
3.000
3.547
4.725
8.033
1400
2.627
2.848
3.547
2448
3.547
6478
8.033
2448
3.000
3.547
6.678
2.848
6.185
6478
12.000
2448
4.193
6.678
6.762
1400
2.627
3.547
4.725
3.547
4.725
5.223
8433
3.000
4.725
6478
8.129
2448
3.547
8433
9.190
3447
4.725
6.676
8.033
3.547
4.725
8433
9.190
2448
3.000
5.781
7.210
3.547
4.725
8.678
8.433
2.848
6478
7.429
12400
4.725
8.129
9.963
12.000
1400
2.848
3447
6.251
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
0.943 *
0.907 *
0.907 *
0.905 *
0.543 *
0451 *
0.914 *
0488 *
1445 *
0.494 *
1.340 *
1.093 *
0.808 *
1458 *
1.206 *
0450 *
1430 *
0.913 *
1.700 *
0.484 *
0.0153 ACR
0.0147 ACR
0.0147 ACR
0.0147 ACR
0.0088 ACR
0.0138 ACR
0.0148 ACR
0.0144 ACR
0.0169 ACR
04080 ACR
0.0217 ACR
0.0177 ACR
04131 ACR
0.0220 ACR
0.0196 ACR
04138 ACR
04216 ACR
0.0146 ACR
0.0276 ACR
04075 ACR
IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
FINAL PLANT
FINAL RESIDU
COMPUTED BY
FINAL CH RON
/ALUE
E VALUE
ACUTE TO CHRONIC F
C VALUE
ATIO METHOD
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
STATE FAMILIES TESTED
TENNESSEE 8
» TEXAS 8
UTAH 10
VERMONT 7
VIRGINIA 7
WASHINGTON 10
WEST VIRGINIA 8
WISCONSIN 9
WYOMING 10
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
** — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIE
I - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONIO FISH IN STATE
$ - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIM
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERCIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERCIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
S— NATIONAL VALUE USED
UM ANLWOR
3.547
4.725
5-251
8.033
3.547
4.725
6.433
12400
1.300
2.627
2448
3.547
2448
6.165
6478
12.000
4.725
6478
8.033
12.000
1.300
2.300
2448
3.000
2448
3.547
6478
8.033
2448
3447
5.781
8433
1.300
2427
2448
3447
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
1404 * 04212 ACR
1.059 * 0.0172 ACR
0.543 * 0.0068 ACR
0466 * 04144 ACR
1.643 * 0.0267 ACR
0.554 « 0.0090 ACR
0412 * 04132 ACR
0.943 * 0.0153 ACR
0.543 * 0.0088 ACR
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: ZINC
STATE
NATIONAL
ALABAMA
ARIZONA
ARKANSAS
CALIFORNIA
COLORADO
CONNECTICUT
DELAWARE
* FLORIDA
QEORQIA
IDAHO
ILLINOIS
INDIANA
IOWA
» KANSAS
KENTUCKY
LOUISIANA
MAINE
MARYLAND
MASSACHUSETTS
NUMBER OP
FAMILIES TESTED
15
12
11
10
It
10
13
13
12
11
t
13
13
11
10
12
11
13
13
13
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
{+) 01 (+) (1) _(+! (**l
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHVIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
13.737 8.148
41.988
48.881
92.797
21.223 8.395
28.243
41.968
49.284
13.737 5.083
40264
49.989
92.757
21.223 4,593 *
41.988
92.757
288.588
13.737 5.043
47.228
49.2(4
92.757
13.737 4.488
38.872
41.988
92.757
21.223 8.451
41.968
51.845
92.757
21.223 8.627
28243
41.968
92.757
21.223 9.1(8 *
41.968
49.284
84.887
21.223 9.488 *
41 906
48.550
49.284
13.737 2.702
41.218
92.797
270.855
21.223 9.829
38.698
41.966
48.264
21.223 9.S29
38.699
41.918
49.284
21,223 4.992 *
41.988
92.757
288,588
21.323 7.336 *
41.988
49.284
92.757
21.223 8,395
29.243
41.968
49.284
21.223 8.13! *
41.988
49.284
81.418
21223 «.S32
41.988
73X117
92.757
21223 8.523
41.968
56088
92.757
21.223 8.451
41.968
51.845
92.757
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
FOOTNOTE
« - UNITS IN MICROGHAMS PER LITER
t , _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT: ZINC
STATE
MICHIGAN
MINNESOTA
• MISSISSIPPI
MISSOURI
MONTANA
NEBRASKA
NEVADA
NEW HAMPSHIRE
NEW JERSEY
NEW MEXICO
NEW YORK
NORTH CAROLINA
NORTH DAKOTA
OHIO
OKLAHOMA
OREGON
PENNSYLVANIA
RHODE ISLAND
SOUTH CAROLINA
SOUTH DAKOTA
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
12
12
11
11
10
11
10
13
13
12
13
13
11
12
12
10
13
13
12
12
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
(+) Ml
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
POECIUIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHIIODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
1 - NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
$ - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM ANCHOR
30-DAY AVERAOE CRITERIA
21223
41.966
44.B47
92.737
21223
36.672
41.966
92.757
21223
41.968
49284
92.757
21223
41.960
492(4
92.797
13.737
41.9(6
98.455
92.757
13.737
41.988
4(550
49284
13.737
49.989
92.757
251.441
21223
41.988
50XM4
92.757
21223
41.9(6
4&560
92.757
13.737
41.968
492(4
49.9(9
21223
41278
41.986
92.797
21223
412(8
48.580
(2.787
13.737
2(243
41288
92.757
21223
41.986
48.580
92.757
21223
28243
41.988
49284
13.737
47229
4(284
92.757
21223
41568
49289
92.757
21223
41.968
51JM5
92.757
21223
41.966
48.650
92.757
13.737
28243
41.968
92.757
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM »DAY AVtRAQE
<+) 0) (+> f**i
7.891
7.440
7.684
7.684 *
4.677
5.799 *
3248
8.408
8298
(.035
8.056
« .298
4.146
7.951
8J99
4.744
8.405
8491
7*1 *
4.399
47.0000
47.0000
47.0000
47.0000
47.0000
47.0000
47.0000
47X1000
47.0000
47.0000
47.0000
47.0000
47.0OOO
47.0000
47.0000
47.0000
47.0000
47X000
47X1000
47.0000
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
SCV
C-31
-------
APPENDIX C
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY CHEMICAL
TOXICANT: ZINC
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
STATE FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (» (+) <» ( + ) (++)
TENNESSEE 12
* TEXAS 11
UTAH 10
VERMONT 13
VIRGINIA 13
WASHINGTON 9
WEST VIRGINIA 11
WISCONSIN 12
WYOMING 10
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
21.223 8.395
26.243
41.966
49.264
21.223 7.684 *
41.966
49.264
92.757
13.737 4.780
49.264
49.969
92.757
21.223 8.451
41.966
51.845
92.757
21.223 8.298
41.966
46.550
92.757
13.737 2.652
47.229
92.757
315.021
21.223 7.606
41.966
46.550
92.757
21.223 7.891
41.966
44.947
92.757
13.737 4.647
41.968
49.969
92.757
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
C-32
FOOTNOTE
* - UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
t > _ ppv FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA CRITERIA
** — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES—NATIONAL VALUE USED
* — NO INDIGENOUS SALMONID FISH IN STATE
t - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 37 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND/OR
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE ALABAMA
TOXICANT
ALORIN
ARSENIC
W CADMIUM
CHIORDANE
CHROMIUM
* COPPER
CYANIDE
DOT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCM VALUE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
14 CENTRARCHIOA6
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
7 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
8 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
5 DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
14 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
8 PALAEMONIDAE .
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
4 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
10 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
8 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
17 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
« SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
OAMMARIOAE
8 DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
12 POECIUIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
5 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
7.451
8.000
8.000
10.803
4.503
7.451
10.000
16.000
878.109
1794245
14128.843
18487.430
1048.139
13339.985
18487.430
19484.938
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.044
0.183
0.864
1.147
6.329
15.000
23.238
32249
6.325
23.238
23.48!
54.711
67.000
6399.078
8998.790
24892.828
8998.790
24882.828
30494.750
57461.672
0.305
0.759
0.099
1.345
0.258
0.758
0.999
1.022
78.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
97.000
83.000
114.316
207.998
1.323
1.899
1.700
2.234
0.976
3.000
3.234
4.102
4.503
5.000
8492
8.000
2499
10.811
20.000
30.102
0.884
1.279
2.300
1240
0.884
1.279
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAOE
It) 1+) (++)
3.388 *
1.402 •
113.283 *
171.818 *
0.027
0.013
1.974 *
1.232 *
12.184
1892.469 »
0.194
0.137
31.429 *
19.459 *
0.690
0.344 *
1.830 *
0.452 *
0.206 •
0.137 *
0.0004 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
9.48S1S FCV
9.42403 FCV
42472 ACR
2.0890 ACR
04010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
OJ»1» FRV
0.1084 ACR
0.0701 ACR
FOOTNOTE ~~~~
t - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
t * _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE .
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: ALABAM
TOXICANT
ENORIN
HEPTACHLOR
$$ LEAD
UNDANE
MERCURY
tt NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
t SILVER
TOXAPHENE
IA
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 17
STATE 8
NATIONAL 10
STATE 9
NATIONAL 7
STATE 4
NATIONAL 10
STATE 9
NATIONAL 9
STATE 9
NATIONAL 16
STATE 11
NATIONAL 9
STATE 4
NATIONAL 10
STATE S
NATIONAL 9
STATE 6
NATIONAL 13
STATE 7
HOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LOW VALUE
1+1
QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERU DAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECIUIOAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
8AIMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.847
0.894
0.732
0.750
1.011
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
1.800
13.068
24.771
50.748
1.161
4.020
80.082
358.792
158.158
398.792
459.019
603.845
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.871
32.031
52.871
93068
84.805
9.000
10X00
31.633
244.258
10.000
20.000
248.996
783.471
85.077
233.9U
348.472
401217
78.458
301.510
325.842
401.217
2.000
6.611
32.801
99.563
2.000
6.811
CYPRINIDAE 32401
COeNAQRIONIDAE(AGHIONIDAE) 282.842
HYALELLIDAEfTALITRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 1992.474
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYAULUDAE(TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERUDAE
TERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
$ - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
U - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERASE CRITERIA
S4N.979
S479.723
339.989
3869.969
7049.606
•002.438
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
1.300
2.627
3.547
4,725
3.547
4.729
8.033
8.190
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM tt-DAY AVERAQE
0.201 *
0.280 »
0251 *
0.243 *
0.037 *
37.382 *
3.218 *
9.751 *
0.470 * '
0.347 *
32.814 *
31.618 *
0.137 *
0.054 *
82.546 *
74.102 *
0.00053 *
0.00039 *
0.537 *
1.199 *
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00004 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.7800 ACR
020 FRV
020 FRV
3J931 ACH
3.2598 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACR
19.7604 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.018S ACR
0-1
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: ALABAMA STATE: ARIZONA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT
S ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV ALDRIN
PHYSIDAE 41.966
SALMONIDAE 48.861
PHILODINIDAE 92.757
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE 21.223 8.395 47.0000 SCV
SALMONIDAE 26.243
PHYSIDAE 41.966
PERCICHTHYIDAE 49.264
ARSENIC
$t CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
tS COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 14
STATE 10
NATIONAL 8
STATE 6
NATIONAL 16
STATE 13
NATIONAL 8
STATE 7
NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
NATIONAL 23
STATE 13
NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
NATIONAL 20
STATE 11
NATIONAL 12
STATE 9
NATIONAL 9
STATE 8
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50VALUE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
PAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
PLANORBIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
POECILIIDAE
FOOTNOTE * ~ FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
. - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER ** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
* , _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE » - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FSV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3
7 TO DETERMINE MAXIM
UM CRITERIA
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD IS — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC-VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
n 0 SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.603
4.503
7.451
9.000
10.000
878.999
1794.245
14126.843
16487.430
1794.245
14128.643
18487.430
19484.938
0.048
0.498
1.147
2.860
0.034
0.163
0.498
1.147
6.325
15.000
23.238
32.249
15.000
23.238
26.000
33.862
87.000
6399.978
6998.790
24892.828
8399.976
8998.790
29999.867
30454.750
0.305
0.759
0.996
1.345
0.305
0.759
1.345
1.424
76.707
83.000
114.318
125.121
78.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
1.323
1.595
3.000
3.282
4.503
5.000
5.452
6.000
2.459
4.503
8.000
10.811
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.700
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
3.388 .
1.928 *
113.263 *
407.358 *
0.027
0.010
1.874 *
5.771 *
12.184
1140.647 *
0.194
0.128
31.429 *
28.920 *
0.650
0.479
1.830 *
0.788 *
0.208 *
0.184 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
0.0004 ACR
0.0001 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.46618 FCV
3.77458 FCV
4.2472 ACR
3.9081 ACR
0.0010 FHV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1084 ACR
0.0944 ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: ARIZONA
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
M LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
*» NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
> SILVER
TOXAPMENE
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
FAMILIES TESTED NAME LOW VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
<+) (+) (+) !**>
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
17 QASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440 0.201 *
SALMONIDAE 0.468
PERLIDAE 0.493
PTERONARCIDAE 0.647
10 SALMONIDAE 0.357 0.133 *
PERLIDAE 0.493
PTERONARCIDAE 0.647
POECILIIDAE 0.949
10 PTERONARCIOAE 0.995 0.251 *
PALAEMONIDAE 1.600
PERLIDAE 2.800
ASTACIDAE 7.800
a PTERONARCIDAE 0995 0.142 *
PERLIDAE 2.800
SALMONIDAE 13.058
CENTRARCHIDAE 26.000
7 QAMMARIDAE 1.161 0.037 *
DAPHNIDAE 4.020
SALMONIDAE 80.062
CYPRINIDAE 358.792
6 DAPHNIDAE 4.020 0.359 *
SALMONIDAE 80.062
CYPRINIDAE 358.792
CENTRARCHIDAE 455.015
10 ASELLIDAE 10.000 3.218 *
SALMONIDAE 21.986
QAMMARIDAE 22.437
CENTRARCHIDAE ' 52.871
t SALMONIDAE 14.196 5.119 *
CENTRARCHIDAE 42.198
QAMMARIDAE 46.000
ICTALURIDAE 53.068
9 DAPHNIDAE 9.000 0.470 »
OJAMMARIDAE 10.000
ASTACIDAE 31.623
SALMONIDAE 244.259
9 DAPHNIDAE 9.000 0.101 *
OAMMARIDAE 10.000
SALMONIDAE ,248.695
PHILODINIDAE 783.471
IB DAPHNIDAE 69.077 32.914 *
EPHEMERELLIDAE 233.999
CENTRARCHIDAE 345.472
PHILODINIDAE 401.217
11 DAPHNIOAE 78.456 31.618 *
PERCICHTHYIDAE 301.610
CENTRARCHIDAE 329.842
PHILODINIDAE ' 401.217
5 SALMONIDAE 2.000 0.137 *
CENTRARCHIDAE 6.611
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
SAMMARIDAE 99.593
4 SALMONIDAE 2-000 0.054 *
CENTRARCHIDAE 8.611
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
COENAQRIONIDAE (AQRIONIDAEI 282.842
10 HYALELLIDAEITALITRIDAE) 339.999 82.649 *
DAPHNIDAE 1992.474 ,
CYPRINODONTIOAE 8499.979
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
8 HYALELLIDAEfTALITRIDAEI 33B.999 74.102 *
DAPHNIDAE • 3869.986
SALMONIDAE 7049.806
CYPRINIDAE 9002.438
9 DAPHNIDAE 0.002 0.00093 *
COTTIDAf. 0.004
CYPRINIDAE 0.006
CYPRINODONTIDAE 0.012
5 COTTIDAE 0.004 0.00036 *
CYPRINIOAE 0.01 1
SALMONIDAE 0.021
CENTRARCHIDAE 0.112
12 PERLIDAE 1-300 0.937 *
PTERONARCIDAE 2.627
ICTALURIDAE 3.947
CENTRARCHIDAE 4,725
7 ICTALUHIDAE 3.547 1.159 *
CENTRARCHIDAE 4.72S
CYPRINIDAE 8.033
SALMONIDAE 9.190
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.4095 ACR
0.20 FRV
^
0.0671 ACR
3.3931 ACR
3.2506 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACR
19.7004 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0188 ACR
FOOTNOTE
' . - UNITS IN MICHOQRAMS PER LITER
* . _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACH COMPUTED SY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: ARIZONA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM »DAY AVERAGE
(+) (+1 1*1 i.ui
t ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
( - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
IS • _ HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA -
13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV
41.986
46.881
9S.757
21.223 8.399 47.0000 SCV
26.243
41.966
48.264
D-3
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: ARKANSAS
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
(I CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
OIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
14
6
8
5
18
12
8
3
10
5
23
15
10
6
20
9
12
6
9
4
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
ANGUILLIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
ASELLIDAE
PQECIUIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONABCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
\t |
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
7.451
8 000
16.000
16.392
878.990
1794 245
14126443
16487.430
878.999
1046.139
16467.430
19484.938
0.046
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.864
1.147
2 goo
6'.987
6.329
15.000
23.238
32.249
6.329
23.236
54.71 1
0.000
67.000
6399.976
6998.790
24692.826
67.000
6996.790
24692.826
57461 .672
0.309
0.759
0.995
1.349
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.345
76.707
83.000
114.3H
125.121
83.000
114.316
167,000
207.958
1.323
1595
' 1.700
2.234
0.976
2.409
3.234
4.000
4.503
5.000
5.492
8.000
5000
10.611
20.000
30.102
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
1.279
3.240
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM TODAY AVERAGE
<*)
3.388 *
2.181 *
113.263 *
42.377 *
0.027
0.211 *
1.974 *
1.974 *
12.164
2.505 *
0.194
0.121 *
31.429 *
27.987 «
0.650
0.355
1.630 »
1,207 *
0.208 *
0.036 *
1*1 (++)
0.0004 ACR
0.0034 ACR
0,0043 FHV
0.0043 FRV
ff.3376 ACR
0.0699 ACR
9.46618 FCV
4.79332 FCV
4.2472 ACR
3.7279 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1094 ACR
0.0169 ACR
CENTRARCHIDAE 3.611
COENAGRtONIDAE(AGRIONIDAE) 87.650
. - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
4.4 _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESII
ACO COMPUTED
FCV FINAL CHHC
H)E VALUE
BY ACUTE TO CH
>NIC VALUE
IONIC RATIO METHOD
STATE: ARKANSAS
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME ICM VALUE
ENDRIN NATIONAL - 17 OASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 10 CYPHINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTEHONAHaDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 5 PALAEMONIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
** LE*D NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 4 GAMMAHIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL ,0 ESSST
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRABCHIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
MERCURY • NATIONAL « DAPHNIDAE*
GAMMARIOAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 4 QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PHILOOINIOAE
M NICKEL NATIONAL 16 "DAPHNKJAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
-„, CHIRONOMIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
( + 1
0.440
0.466
0.493
0.647
0.732
0.790
1.011
1.269
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
1.800
7.800
24.771
50.746
1.161
4.020
80.012
368.792
1.161
398.792
495.019
803.845
10.000
21.986
22.437
92.871
2.000
10.000
52.871
53.066
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.299
10.000
20.000
783,471
999.99S
69.077
233.999
345.472
401217
78.496
325842
401.217
439.829
2400
6.611
32.601
9B.993
6.611
32.601
92.094
SELENIUM ki.-rmu , COENAGRIONIDAE(AafflONIOAE1282i41
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELLIDAE (TAUTRIDAE) 339.999
OAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
..... SALMONIDAE
STATE . 1 HYALEUIOAE
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: ARKANSAS
STATE: CALIFORNIA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY '
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC60 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAQE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE
{+) (+) (+J (++)
1 ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13.737 6.148 * 47.0000 SCV . ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRABCHIDAE
PHYSI
SALMC
PHILO
STATE 10 DAPHh
PHYSI
PHILO
CYPRI
DAE 41.966 ASELLIOAE
>NIOAE 48.861 EPHEMERELLIDAE
DINIDAE 92.757 SALMONIDAE
IIDAE 21.223 4,593 * 47.0000 SCV STATE 9 CENTHARCHIDAE
DAE 41.986 EPHEMERELLIDAE
DINIDAE 92.757 PERCICHTHYIDAE
VIDAE 266.588 SALMONIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
St CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMAftlDAE
PHYSI DAE
STATE 14 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 6 CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
C6NTHARCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 7 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
* COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMQNIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIOAE
ASEUIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 8 POECILIIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL » SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
FTEHONARCIDAE
CATO8TOMIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POEOIUIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
FOOTNOTE * — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
+ - UNITS IN MICROORAMS PER LITER ** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
» « —FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE t — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EOUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACH COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD « - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE ~ 30-DAY AVERAQE CRITERIA
(+)
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
7.451
9.000
10.000
10.803
878.999
1794,845
14128.843
16487.430
1T9434S
14128.643
18487.430
19484.938
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.880
0.048
0.163
0.496
1.147
&32S
15.000
23238
32.249
23238
26.000
43.739
54.711
67.000
8399.976
6988.790
24892.828
8399.978
8998.790
29999.887
30484.750
0.305
0.758
0.995
1.345
0405
0.759
1.345
1.401
78.707
83.000
114.318
128.121
76.707
83.000
114.316
207.958
1.323
1.595
1.700
,2.234
1.323
3.000
3.282
8.921
4.503
5.000
6.452
8.000
4.503
5.462
8.000
10.811
0.864
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.884
1.279
3.700
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAQE
(+1
3.388 *
3.383 *
113.283 *
383.448 *
0.027
0.015
1.874 *
7.044 *
12.184
1140.847 *
0.184
0.128
31.429 *
19.582 *
0.880
0.442 *
1.830 *
1.544 *
0208 *
0.158 *
(+)
0.0004
0.0002
0.0043
0.0043
0.3378
10.0
5.46618
2.74195
4.2472
2.8482
0.0010
0.0010
0.0019
0.0019
0.1084
0.0793
(++)
ACR
ACR
FRV
, FRV
ACR
FPV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
D-5
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: CALIFORNIA
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOH
$S LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
S SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONA
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
17
10
10
7
7
8
10
7
9
9
16
10
5
3
10
8
9
9
12
9
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
( + )
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PERLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIOAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIOAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLI DAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
CENTRAACHIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.847
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.949
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
2.800
26.000
29.000
29.498
1.161
4.020
60.002
398.792
4.020
80.062
358.792
459.015
10.000
21.988
22.437
92.871
21.988
42.198
48.000
53.068
5.000
10.000
31.823
244.259
9.000
10.000
244.299
783.471
65.077
233.999
349.472
401.217
69.077
301.910
401.217
439.825
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.553
2.000
2.300
32.601
0.000
339.999
1992.474
6499.979
8479.723
339.999
1992.474
8479.723
9002.438
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.002
0.006
0.021
0.112
1.300
2.627
3.647
4.725
1.300
2.648
3.947
5.761
STATE: CALIFORNIA
ii'ZSinii*'™ *«S!nIv! UFE ^uU^fe NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30.DAY AVEH*°E TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
Lil LtJ (++> /.Ll 14.1 /4.1 (4.4.1
0.201 *
0.144 *
0.251 *
0.898 *
0.037 *
0.359 *
3.216 *
8.518 *
0.470 *
0.101 *
32.914 *
23.365 *
0.137 »
0.137 *
. **
82.648 *
60.182 *
0.00093 *
0.00011 *
0.537 *
0.445 *
* — UNITS IN MICflOQRAMS PER LITER
«. » - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
D-6
FRV
ACR
FCV
SCV
FINAL RESIC
COMPUTED
FINAL CHRC
UE VALUE
BY ACUTE TO CHF
NIC VALUE
"•O^3 FRV $ ZINC NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
nnim cou PHILODINIDAE
°-°°23 FRV STATE 11 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
0.0036 FRV PHILODINIDAE
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.6814 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.0874 ACR
3.3931 ACR
2.4087 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FflV
22.0396 ACR
18.0431 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0072 ACR
ADDJ v e™iATirtii J INTERCEPT VALUE
ONIC RATIO METHOD £t «rrLT CUUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
APPl V pnilATlrikl J -1 Trt nCTrZ.^*'"^^
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE M-DAY AVERAGE" CHrreBuT'1™""11* ""*""*"* *NB
13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV
41.986
46.861
92.757
13.737 5.043 47.0000 SCV
47.229
49.264
92.757
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: COLORADO
TOXICANT
ALORIN
ARSENIC
« CADMIUM
-
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
« COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUM6EH Of
FAMILIES TEST
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
ED
14
8
8
6
18
12
8
6
10
23
13
10
e
20
10
12
8
9
8
NAME
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
PHYSIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TU8IFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
EALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIBAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONAHCIOAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
LC50VALUE
(+)
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.603
4.503
7.451
9.000
16.392
878.999
1794.245
14128.643
16487.430
1794,245
13339.955
16487.430
19484.938
0.048
0.496
1 147
2.860
0.044
0.496
1 147
2.860
8.325
19.000
23.238
32£49
15.000
23.238
25.481
26.000
67,000
6399.978
6998.790
24892.626
6399.976
6998.790
24892.826
57461.672
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.346
0.306
0.759
0.995
1.309
76.707
83.000
114.316
126.121
57.000
83.000
114.316
207.958
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
1.323
3.000
3.096
4.878
4.503
5.000
5.452
8.000
2.459
8.000
10.811
24.000
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664
1.879
2.300
3.240
FRESHWATER AOIMT1C LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
( + 1
3.368 *
1.433 *
113.263 t
407.265 *
0.027 *
0.012
1.974 *
6.226 *
12.164
781.038 *
0.194
0.133
31.429 *
15.469 *
0.660
0.510 *
1.830 *
0.632 *
0.208 *
0.196 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
<+) (++)
0.0004 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.46618 FCV
9.85862 FCV
4.2472 ACR
2.0680 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0,0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.1003 ACR
FOOTNOTE
* — UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
» » -, FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDE
ACR COMPUTED B
FCV FINAL CHRON
E VALUE
1 ACUTE TO CHRi
1C VALUE
DNIC RATIO METHOD
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: COLORADO
NUMBED OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME L(
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17 QASTEROSTEIDAE
8ALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 9 SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE .
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 7 PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LEAD NATIONAL 7 OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
»0 VALUE
(+)
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.647
0.320
0.493
0.647
1.011
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
0.99B
2.800
13.058
26.000
1.161
4.020
80.062
358.792
4.020
158.156
356.792
455.015
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.871
8.004
42.196
48.000
ICTALURIDAE N.WC
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE 5.000
8AMMARIDAE 10.000
ASTACIDAE t 31.623
SALMONIDAE 244.259
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE 5.000
QAMMARIDAE 10.000
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
M NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 9 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PCB8 NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELLIDAE(TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIOAE
SALMONtDAE
STATE 7 HYALELLIDAE(TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
$ SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIOAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
SALMONIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 9 PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
St - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
X4B.9V3
763.471
65.077
233.556
345.472
401.217
85.077
401.217
439.825
509.2*4
2.000
8.611
32.601
99.553
2.000
2.300
32,601
0 000
339J99
1992.474
6499.979
8479.723
339.999
1992.474
7049.808
9002.438
0.002
0.004
0008
0'.012
0.002
0.004
0.005
0.021
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.725
1.300
2.827
2.848
3.547
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+1
0.201 *
0.112 *
0.251 »
0.125 *
0.037 *
0.325 *
3.218 *
2.320 *
0.470 *
0.101 *
32.914 *
21.349 *
0.137 *
0.137 *
**
82.848 *
54.887 *
\
0.00053 *
0.00030 *
0.537 *
0.525 *
30-DAY
l+l
0.0023
0.0023
0.0038
0.0038
0.00003
0.00003
0.2574
0.1856
0.20
0.0671
3.3931
2.2009
0.014 '
0.014
22.0395
14.6364
0.0087
0.0085
AVERAQE
(++)
FHV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
D-7
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: COLORADO
STATE: CONNECTICUT '
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
( + ) (+) (+) (++)
ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13.737 6.148 * 47.0000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTBARCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.968 . ASELLIDAE
SALMON IDAE 48.861 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 8ALMONIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE 13.737 4.466 * 47.0000 SCV STATE 9 SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE 38.872 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.966 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 ANOUILL10AE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 4 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
It CADMIUM NATIONAL 16 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PEHCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
$ COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIOAE
STATE 18 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIOAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 7 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE e SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL g SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE « SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTBARCHIOAE
FOOTNOTE * — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
» - UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER ** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES- NATIONAL VALUE USED
, . _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE 3 — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD St — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
A SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
60 VALUE
( + )
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
4.503
7.451
9.000
16.000
878.999
1784.245
14128.643
16487.430
1048.139
14128.843
19484.938
20194.383
0.048
0.498
1.147
2.860
0.034
0.864
1.147
1.830
6.325
15.000
23.238
32.249
23.238
33.862
40.000
54.711
67.000
(309.976
6998.790
24699.828
6996.790
24892.828
30454750
57481.672
0.305
0.759
0.996
1.345
0.256
0.769
0.996
1.345
76.707
83.000
114.316
128.121
78.707
83.000
114.316
12S.i:i
1.323
1.595
1.700
2234
0.976
1.595
1.864
3.008
4.503
5.000
5.462
8000
2.459
8.000
14.460
30.102
0.864
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664
1.279
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+)
3.388 *
1.520 *
113.263 *
141.620 *
0.027 *
0.019
1.974 *
7.675 *
12.1(4
1892.459 *
0.194
0.139
31.429 *
28.920 *
0.660
0.318 •
1.830 *
0.471 *
0.208 »
0.149 *
30-DAY AVEKAQE
(•H (++)
0.0004 ACR
0.0003 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.4(618 FCV
7.43115 FCV
4.2472 ACR
3.9081 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.10(4 ACR
0.0762 ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: CONNECTICUT
STATE: CONNECTICUT
TOXICANT
6NDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
« LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
M NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
« SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
17
9
10
5
7
4
10
6
9
5
te
12
6
9
10
6
9
4
12
7
NAME
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTEHONARCIDAE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRtNIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRtDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE {TALITRI DAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CYPRINODONTIDA6
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERCIDAE
LC50 VALUE
J + )
0.440
0,468
0.493
0.647
0.440
0.558
1.011
1.066
0.995
1.800
2.800
7800
13.056
26.000
47,329
50.748
1.161
4.020
80.082
358.792
60.062
358.792
455.015
803.645
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.871
10.488
14.158
42.198
68.000
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
10.000
50.000
248.595
783.471
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.458
401.217
439.825
444.717
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.553
2.000
2.300
32.601
107.884
339.999
1992.474
6499.979
8479.723,
339,999
3889.989
8479.723
9002.438
0.002
0.004
0.008
0.012
0.011
0.021
0,112
5.517
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.725
2.848
6,678
7.429
12.000
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(*)
0.201 *
0.153 *
0.251 *
3,521 *
0.037 *
14.969 *
3,218 *
1.829 *
0.470 *
0.629 *
32.914 *
33.128 *
0.137 *
0.060 *
B2.648 *
54.280 *
0.00053 *
1
0.00008 *
0.537 *
0.913 *
FOOTNOTE
, - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
« 4 _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV
ACR
FCV
SCV
FINAL RESIOU
COMPUTED BY
FINAL CHRON
E VALUE
ACUTE TO CHRC
C VALUE
SO-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) l*+'
0.0023 FRV $ ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0.0023 FRV STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.1463 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
3.3931 ACR
3.41S2 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22,0395 ACfl
14.4747 ACH
0.0087 ACR
0.0148 ACR
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
• * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
$ - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
NIC RATIO METHOD If - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-OAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
(+) (•*•) (+} (•*••*•)
13.737 8.148 * 47.0000 SCV
41.966
48.861
92.757
21.223 8.451 * 47.0000 SCV
41.968
51.845
92.757
0-9
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: DELAWARE
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
tt CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
* COPPER
CYANIDE
DOT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTI
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
•D
14
9
I
9
18
17
8
4
10
<
23
18
10
7
20
e
13
6
g
5
NAME
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
CVPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
PHY8IDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIflONOMIDAE
PHVSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIOAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
POECIUIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
LCSO VALUE
( + )
7.451
8.000
9.000
10403
4.503
7.451
9.000
11.314
878.999
1794.245
14128443
16187.430
1048.139
13339.985
18487.430
19484.938
0.048
0.498
1.147
2.880
0.044
0.884
1.147
1430
6.325
15.000
23.238
32.249
15.884
25.481
40400
54.711
87.000
8399478
8998.790
24892428
8998.790
24892.828
30454.750
88999.781
0.30S
0.759
0.999
1.345
0.2W
0.759
0.995
1.022
78.707
83.000
114.318
125.121
57.000
83000
114.316
125.121
1.323
1.895
1.700
2.234
0.978
1.596
1.884
3400
4.503
5.000
5.452
6000
2.459
8.000
10411
41.000
0.884
1279
2.300
3.240
0.884
3.240
3.811
6.000
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+)
3.388 *
1.796 *
113.263 *
171.818 *
0.027
0.027
1.974 *
4.120 *
12.164
1538.742 *
0.194
0.142
31.429 *
21.460 *
0.850
0.344 *
1430 *
0.382 *
0.206 *
0.147 •
M-DAY AVERAGE
(+) <++)
0.0004 ACR
0.0004 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.48818 FCV
8.30804 FCV
4.2472 ACR
2.8999 ACR
0.0010 FRV
04010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FHV
0.1084 ACR
04751 ACR
FOOTNOTE
r - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
D-10
* + —
FPV FINAL PLANT
FRV FINAL RESIDl
ACR COMPUTED B
FCV FINAL CHOt»
VALUE
X. VALUE
Y ACUTE TO CHR
IIC VALUE
ONIC RATIO METHOD
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: DELAWARE
NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17
STATE 10
'
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10
STATE 5
JJ LEAD NATIONAL 7
STATE 4
LINDANE NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
MERCURY NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
«J NICKEL NATIONAL 18
STATE 12
PCBS NATIONAL 5
STATE 4
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10
STATE 8
$ SILVER NATIONAL 9
STATE 3
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12
STATE 8
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECIUIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ASELUIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRIMDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SO VALUE
( + 1
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.847
0.440
0.894
0.750
1.011
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
13.058
26.000
47.329
50.748
1.161
4.020
80.062
358.792
158.158
455.015
803.845
814.803
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.871
8.004
10.488
42.198
44.000
5.000
10.000
31423
244.259
10400
50.000
248.595
783.471
85.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
76.456
401.217
439425
444.717
2.000
6411
32.801
99453
2.000
2400
107.664
COENAGRIONIDAEIAQRIONIDAE) 282442
HYALELLIDAE
-------
APPENDIX 0
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: DELAWARE STATE: FLORIDA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAOE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE
(+1 (+) (+) <++)
ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.968 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48.861 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE 21.223 6.627 47.0000 SCV STATE 6 CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE 26.243 PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.968 CYPRtNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 ANOUILLIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE,
(4)
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
7.451
10.000
11.314
18.000
878.999
1794.245
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(•*•)
3.388 *
2.690 *
113.283 *
{*} (++)
SALMONIDAE 14128.643
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
M CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 13 PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 8 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
$ COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 16 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFJDISAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE » DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 7 DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 4 POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE •
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 3 POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
8487.430
1046.139
6487.430
9484.938
28041.675
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.880
0.163
0.884
2.880
8.987
8325
15.000
23.238
32.249
15.684
54.711
190.000
0.000
87.000
6398.978
6998.790
24892.828 '
6998.790
24892.828
29999.887
10454.750
0.305
0.759
0,995
1.345
0.258
0.759
0.995
1.345
78.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
63.000
114.318
308.484
317.999
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.978
3.000
3.283
17.088
4.503
5.000
6,452
8.000
4.503
14.480
41.000
231.052
0.684
1.279
2.300
3.240
3.700
3.811
158.035 *
0.027 *
0.046 *
1.974 *
1.974 *
**
12.164
*
2124.123 *
0.194 *
0.127 *
31.429 *
16.067 *
0.660 *
0.150 *
1.830 *
0.251 *
0.208 *
0.208 *
**
0.0004 ACR
0.0007 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.46818 FVC
6.30441 FCV
4.2472 ACR
2.4414 ACR
0,0010 F(W
0.0010 FBV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0,1064 ACR
0.1064 ACR
COENAORIONIOAE(AGRIONIDAE) 87.850
* - UNITS IN MICROORAMS PER LITER ** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
».,_FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE $ - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD «( - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
0.000
.
D-11
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: FLORIDA
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
H LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
W NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
I SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
17
6
10
4
7
4
10
5
9
3
16
11
5
1
10
8
g
3
12
8
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRI NODONTI DAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRI NIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PHILO DINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
HYALELLIOAE (TALITRIOAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
POECILIIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CVPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
(4)
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.647
0.850
0.949
1.011
2.100
0.999
1.800
2.800
7.800
24.771
90.746
146.000
319.999
1.161
4.020
80.062
398.792
496.019
632.656
803.845
814.803
10.000
21.968
22.437
52.871
44.000
52.871
112.694
136.000
9.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
20.000
783.471
999.998
0.000
65.077
233.555
349.472
401.217
78.466
301.510
401.217
438.625
2.000
6.611
32.801
99.553
6.611
0.000
0.000
0.000
339.999
1991474
6499.979
6479.723
339.999
3869.989
6499.979
12599.945
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.012
0012
0.112
5.617
0.000
1.300
2.627
3.647
4.725
4.193
4.726
6.782
14.379
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+)
0.201 *
0.232 *
0.251 *
2.873 *
0.037 *
199.499 *
3.218 *
10.720 *
0.470 *
0.470 *
**
32.914 *
30.838 *
0.137 *
0137 »
**
82.648 *
97.806 »
0.00053 *
0.00063 *
**
0.937 *
0.980 «
(+) (++)
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
4.4479 ACR
0.2674 ACR
0.8575 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
3.3931 ACR
3.1791 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACR
18.0616 ACR
04067 ACR
0.0159 ACR
FOOTNOTE
. — UNITS IN MICBOGRAMS PER LITER
» t — FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
3-12
FRV
ACR
FCV
SCV
FINAL RESIOU
COMPUTED B\
FINAL CHRON
E VALUE
ACUTE TO CHRO
C VALUE
NIC RATIO METHOD
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: FLORIDA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY - FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
* ZINC NATIONAL 19 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
• — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
( - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
SS - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
(+1 (+1 (+1 <++!
-13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV
41.960
48.681
92.797
21.223 9.169 * 47.0000 SCV
41.996
49.2(14
64.687
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: QEORQIA
TOXICANT
_
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
X CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
* COPPER
CYANIDE
DOT
DIELDRIN
6NDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
i NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
14
7
8
5
18
14
8
3
10
6
23
16
10
6
20
7
12
5
9
4
NAME
CENTRARCHIOAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTflARCHIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
LCSO VALUE
( + )
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
4,503
7.451
9.000
10.000
878.999
1794.249
14128.643
16487.430
1046.139
14128.643
16487.430
19484.938
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.890
0.034
0.163
0.864
2.960
8.325
15.000
23.238
32.249
19.664
33.362
54.711
0.000
67.000
8399.976
6998.790
24692,328
6998.790
24892.826
30454.750
63804.148
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.345
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707
63.000
114.316
317.999
1.323
1.595
1.700
2234
0.976
3.000
4.102
8.151
4.503
5.000
5452
8.000
2.459
8.000
10.811
41 000
0.684
1 279
2.300
3.240
0.664
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+)
3.366 *
1.763 *
113.263 *
171.493 *
0.027
0.008 *
1.974 *
1.974 it
12.164
1604.673 +
0.194
0.127 *
31.429 *
14.657 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
(•*•) (++)
0.0004 ACR
0.0001 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.46618 FCV
9.39244 FCV
4.2472 ACR
1.9806 ACR
STATE: QEORQIA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE
ENORIN NATIONAL 17 QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 9 SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
COENAQRIONIDAE (AGRIONIDA
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
5$ LEAD NATIONAL 7 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 5 ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
t$ NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPAINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
(+)
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.647
0.558
0.790
1.011
E| 1.800
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
13.058
24.771
50.748
319.999
1.161
4.020
80.062
358.792
80.082
455.015
803.845
814.803
10.000
21.863
22.437
52.871
37.669
52.871
53.066
112.694
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
20.000
248.595
783.471
999.998
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.456
301.510
325.842
401.217
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.553
2.000
6.611
FRESHWATER AOUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
<+)
0.201 *
0.170 *
0.251 *
0.857 *
0.037 *
14.070 *
3.218 *
10.136 *
0.470 *
2.048 *
32.914 *
29.866 *
0,137 *
0.137 *
**
30-DAY
(•*•)
0.0023
0.0023
0.0038
0.0038
0.00003
0.00004
0.2574
0.8110
0.20
0.20
3.3931
1.0791
0.014
0.014
AVERAGE
C++)
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
COENAGHIONIDAE(AQRIONIDAE)282.842
0.650
0.245 *
1.830 *
0.339 *
0.208 *
0.019 it
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.0096 ACR
COENAQRIONIOAE(AGRIONIDAE) 87.850
FOOTNOTE
* - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
* *. _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUF.
FRV FINAL RF.SIDL
IE VALUE
ACR COMPUT'ED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHROU
IIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDA6)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIOAE
STATE 8 HYALELLIDAE (TAUTRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
S SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 4 COTTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE
PTEBONABC1DAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 6 ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
** _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
S — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
St - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3,7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
0.000
339.999
1992.474
6499.979
8479.723
339.999
3869.989
8479.723
2599.945
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.004
0.021
0.112
5.517
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.725
3.547
4.725
8.129
9.963
82.646 *
66.265 *
0.00053 *
0.00002 *
0.537 *
1.065 *
22.0395
17*705
0.0087
0.0173
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACfl
D-13
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: GEORGIA
STATE: IDAHO
TOXICANT
$ ZINC
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC60 VALUE MAXIMUM 90-DAY AVERAGE
<+) (+1 <+> (++)
NATIONAL 1! DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
STATE 11 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
13.737 6.146
41. gee
48.681
92.757
21.223 0.468 *
41,906
46.550
49.284
47.0000 SCV
47.0000 SCV
I OF
FAMILIES TESTED
MOST SENSITI
RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM JO-DAY AVERAGE
(+1 (+) (+»)
NATIONAL
STATE
U CADMIUM
STATE
NATIONAL
DDT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NATIONAL
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
NATIONAL
STATE
14 CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
8 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
B QAMMAHIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
5 OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIOAE
12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIOAE
8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
8 PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
10 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODIHIDAE
PHY8IDAE
8 OAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
11 OAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
PLANORBIDAE
10 SALMONIDAC
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
8 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRAftCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
20 DAPHNIDAE
PCRCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAG
11 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
12 POECIUIDAE
A8ELUDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
8 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERU DAE
9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
7 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
1.974 *
7.491 3.388 *
8.000
9.000
10.803
5.241 1.888 *
7.451
9.000
18492
878.999 113.283 *
1794.245
14128.643
18487.430
1794.245 390.967 *
14128.843
19484.938
20194.383
0.048 0.027
0.498
1.147
2.MO
0.048 0.013
1.147
2.880
8.325
15.000
23.238
32J49
15.000
23.238
28.000
40.281
87.000
8399.978
8998.790
24892.826
8390.978
8998.790
57481.872
83804.148
0.305
0.759
0.908
1.346
0.305
0.759
1.345
1.424
78.707
83.000
114.318
125.121
78.707
83XNX)
114.316
126.121
1.323
1.M6
1.700
2.234
1.323
1.496
3.000
3.282
4.603
5.000
5.452
8.000
3.873
8.000
10.811
24.000
0.864
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.«54
1.279
2300
3.611
31.429 *
28.920 *
1.830 *
0.208 *
0.0004 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.48816 FCV
3.11336 FCV
4.2472 ACR
3.9081 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1084 ACR
0.0870 ACR
0-14
FOOTNOTE
* — UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
, , — FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
— FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
- STATE HAS LE8S THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
- HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
— HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: IDAHO
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
it LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
8* NICKEL
PC8S
SELENIUM
i SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TEST!
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
D
17
10
10
7
7
5
10
a
9
9
18
8
5
3
10
7
9
8
12
10
NAME
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMO
PERLID
PTERO
SALMO
PERLID
PTERO
POECIl
PTEFO
PALAE
PERLID
ASTAC
PTERO
PERLID
SALMO
CENTR
GAMM/
DAPHN
SALMO
CYPRIH
OAPHN
SALMO
CYPRII".
CENTR
ASELLI
SALMO
OAMM/
CENTR
SALMO
CENTR,
GAMM/
1CTALU
DAPHN
GAMM/
ASTAC
SALMO
DAPHN
GAMM/
SALMO
PHILOC
DAPHN
EPHEM
CENTH,
PHILOC
NIDAE
AE
MARCIDAE
NIDAE
AE
MAHCIDAE
IIDAE
MARCIDAE
4ONIDAE
AE
DAE
MAHCIOAE
AE
NIDAE
ARCHIDAE
kRIDAE
IDAE
NIDAE
IDAE
IDAE
NIOAE
IDAE
ARCHIDAE
DAE
NIDAE
kRIDAE
ARCHIDAE
NIDAE
ARCHIDAE
kRIDAE
HI DAE
DAE
kRIDAE
DAE
NIDAE
DAE
kRIDAE
NIDAE
INIDAE
DAE
ERELLIDAE
MtCHIDAE
MNIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILOC
CHIROI
CENTR
SALMO
CENTR
CYPRIN
GAMM/
SALMO
CENTR
CYPRIN
INIDAE
JOMIDA6
MTCHIDAE
NIDAE
MKHIDAE
IDAE
kRIDAE
NIDAE
IRCHIDAE
IDAE
HYALELLIDAEITALITRIDAE)
DAPHN
CYPRIN
SALMO
DAE
ODONTIDAE
NIDAE
HYALELLIDAEtTALITRIDAE)
OAPHN
SALMO
CYPRIN
DAPHN
COTTID
CYPRIN
CYPRIN
DAPHN
COTTID
CYPRIN
SALMO
DAE
NIDAE
IOAE
DAE
AE
IDAE
ODONTIDAE
DAE
AE
IDAE
NIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERO
ICTALU
CENTR
PERLID
PTERO
CENTR
1AHCIOAE
RIOAE
tRCHIDAE
AE
tIARCIDAE
\HCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
LC80 VALUE
(*)
0.440
0.498
0.493
0.847
0.488
0.493
0.847
0.790
0.999
1.800
2.800
7.800
0.995
2.800
17.703
28.000
1.191
4.020
80.082
358.792
4.020
80.082
398.792
498.019
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.871
18.355
42.198
48.000
84.000
5.000
10.000
31.823
244.259
5.000
10.000
248.599
783.471
89.077
233.583
349.472
401.217
89.077
401.217
439.829
444.717
2.000
8.811
32.801
99.953
2.000
2.300
32.801
0.000
339.999
1992.474
8499.979
8479.723
339.999
1992.474
8479.723
9002.438
0.002
0.004
0.008
0.012
0.002
0.004
0.008
0.021
1.300
2.827
3.947
4.729
1.300
2.827
2.848
3.000
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+)
0.201 .*
0.191 *
0.291 *
0.117 *
0.037 *
0.287 *
3.218 *
8.880 *
0.470 *
0.101 *
32.914 *
20.057 *
0.137 *
0.137 *
**
82.848 *
52.431 *
0.00053 *
0.00030 *
0.537 *
0.584 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
( + 1 (++)
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00002 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.9343 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.0871 ACR
3.3931 ACR
2.0877 ACR
0.014 FHV
0.014 FHV
22.0395 ACR
13.9818 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0091 ACR
f
FOOTNOTE
+ - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
FPV
FRV
ACR
FCV
SCV
FINAL PLANT
FINAL RESID
VALUE
JE VALUE
COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: IDAHO
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
$ ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODIN1DAE
STATE 9 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
** — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
St - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
SO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (+) (+) (++)
13.737 8.148 * 47.0000 SCV
41.988
48.881
92.757
13.737 2.702 * 47.0000 SCV
41.218
92.757
270.898
D-15
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: ILLINOIS
TOXICANT
ALDHIN
ARSENIC
JJ CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
f COPPER
CYANIDE
DOT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
14
10
8
e
18
15
8
5
10
7
23
19
10
8
20
14
12
7
9
g
NAME
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELUDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARQOAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMA RIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ESOCIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELUDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LCSO VALUE
<+)
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.603
7.451
8.000
10X100
10.803
878.999
1794.245
14128.643
16487.430
878.999
1046.139
13339.989
18487.430
0.048
0.498
1.147
2.880
0.064
0.183
0.864
1.147
6.32S
15.000
23.238
32.249
6.325
23.238
40.000
43.327
67.000
8399.976
8998.790
24892,828
67.000
6998.790
24692.828
30454.750
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256
0.759
0.999
1.049
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
97.000
83.000
114.316
125.121
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.976
1.598
1.684
1.700
4.503
5.000
5.452
8.000
5.000
6.492
10.811
20.000
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664
1.279
3.240
3 .811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+)
3.388 *
3.230 *
113.283 *
98.104 «
0.027
0.020
1.974 *
1.497 *
12.164
6.367 *
0.194
0.148
31.429 *
22.152 *
0.850
0.480 *
1830 *
1.120 *
0.208 *
0.149 *
30-DAY AVERAQE
It) (++)
0.0004 ACR
0.0003 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
0.1496 ACR
5.46618 FCV
4.99843 FCV
4.2472 ACR
2.9936 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.0762 ACR
FOOTNOTE
* — UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
. » — FfV FINAL PLANT VALUE
D-16
FHV
ACR
FCV
SCV
FINAL RESIDU
COMPUTED Bl
FINAL CHflON
E VALUE
ACUTE TO CHR
1C VALUE
DNIC RATIO METHOD
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: ILLINOIS
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC60 VALUE
ENORIN NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 11 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 6 PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
IS LEAD NATIONAL 7 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 5 QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 9 ASELUDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 6 QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
U NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL S SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELUOAE (TAUTHIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 8 HYALELUDAE(TAUTRIDAE»
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
$ SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
com DAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 6 COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALUfllDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 9 ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
t - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
It - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
1±1_
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.647
0.701
0.732
0.750
1.011
0.995
1.800
2400
7.800
1.800
24.771
29.498
47.329
1.161
4.020
80.082
358.792
1.161
198.198
368.792
455.015
10.000
21.9S8
22.437
82.871
10.000
10.488
18.466
62.671
s.ooo
10.000
31423
244.289
10.000
244.289
783.471
999.996
89.077
233.655
345.472
401.217
78.458
233.555
301.810
345.472
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.553
2X100
6411
32401
99.553
339999
1992,474
6499.979
8479.723
339.999
3089.989
7049406
9002.438
0.002
0.004
0.008
0.012
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
1.300
2427
3.547
4.725
3.547
4.725
4.944
8.033
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(*>
0.201 *
0.294 *
0.251 *
0.311 *
0.037 *
0.059 *
3.218 *
2X111 *
0.470 *
1.000 *
32414 *
34.981 *
0.137 *
0.137 *
62.648 *
74.102 *
0.00053 *
0.00041 *
0.537 *
1.321 *
30-DAY
1*1_
0.0023
0.0023
0,0038
0.0038
0.00003
0.00004
0.2574
0.1609
0.20
0.20
3.3931
3.6082
0414
0.014
22.0396
19.7804
0.0087
0.0214
AVERAGE
(++)
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FBV
FHV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: ILLINOIS STATE: INDIANA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCM VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCW VALUE
<•(•> (+1 (+) (+-M
t ZINC NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE 13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV ALORIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.966 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48.861 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE 21.223 9.829 47.0000 SCV STATE 8 CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE 36.699 PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.966 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE 49.264 ANQUILLIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 SAMMARIDAC
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 9 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
« CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 14 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODtNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 PHILOD1NIDA6
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
( COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
' CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 19 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
ASTACIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OAPHNIOAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE • SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
t - UNITS IN MICROSRAMS PER LITER ** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
. » _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE J - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD « - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
(+)
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
7.451
10.000
10.603
16.000
878.999
17*4.249
14128.843
16487.430
1049.139
13339.989
16487.430
19484.936
0.048
0.498
1.147
2.860
0.084
0.163
O.W4
1.147
6.329
)9.0M
23.238
32.2*9
23.238
40.000
43.327
54.711
67.000
63*9.976
6908.790
24892828
6998.780
24892.828
30454.790
57461.672
0.305
0.759
0.095
1.345
0.296
0.799
0.99B
1.049
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
57.000
83.000
114.316
129.121
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.»76
1.846
1.664
3.000
4.503
8.000
«.4«2
8.000
5.462
10.611
30.102
231.052
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664
1.279
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+)
3.388 *
2.827 *
113.263 *
171.818 *
0027
0.019
1.974 *
8.051 *
12.164
1692.469 *
0.194
0.146
31.429 *
20.746 *
0.650
0.357 *
1.830 *
0.297 *
0.208 »
0.149 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (++)
0.0004 ACR
0.0003 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
6.46818 FCV
0.42403 FCV
4.2472 ACR
2.8035 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.0762 ACR
D-17
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: INDIANA
W
w
$
TOXICANT
ENDR1N
HEPTACHLOR
LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
NICKEL
FOBS
SELENIUM
SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
17
7
10
5
7
4
10
8
9
5
16
12
5
5
10
7
9
5
12
8
NAME
QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMC
PERLIC
PTERO
SALMC
CYPRI
CENTS
COENJ
PTERO
PALAE
PERLIC
ASTAC
CENTR
SALMC
QAMM
DAPHK
NIDAE
>A£
NARCIDAE
NIDAE
JIDAE
ARCHIDAE
QRIONIDAEIAQRION
NARCIDAE
MONIDAE
)AE
IDAE
ARCHIDAE
NIDAE
ARIDAE
IDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHK
SALMC
CYPRI
SALMC
CYPRN
CENTR
PHILO
ASELL
SALMC
QAMM
CENTR
GAMM
SALMC
CENTH
ICTALL
OAPHN
QAMM
ASTAC
SALMC
QAMM
SALMC
PHILOC
NAIDIO
DAPHN
EPHEM
CENTH
PHILOC
OAPHN
PERCIC
CENTR
PHILOI
SALMO
CENTR
CYPRN
QAMM
SALMO
CENTR
CYPRtt
QAMM
IDAE
NIDAE
JIDAE
NIDAE
(IDAE
ARCHIDAE
3INIDAE
DAE
NIDAE
ARIDAE
ARCHIDAE
ARIDAE
NIDAE
ARCHIDAE
RIDAE
IDAE
»«DAE
DAE
NIDAE
tRIDAE
NIDAE
)INIDAE
AE
IDAE
ERELLIDAE
ARCHIDAE
JINIDAE
IDAE
5HTHYIDAE
ARCHIDAE
IINIDAE
NIDAE
ARCHIDAE
(IDAE
tRIDAE
NIDAE
ARCHIDAE
IIDAE
IRIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIDAE)
OAPHN
CYPRIK
SALMO
HYALE
DAPHN
SALMO
CYPRI K
DAPHN
COTTIC
CYPRI K
CYPHIN
COTTIC
CYPBIK
SALMO
CENTR
PERLID
PTERO
ICTALU
CENTR
ICTALU
CENTR
SALMO
IDAE
ODONTIDAE
NIDAE
-LIDAEfTALITWDAE)
IDAE
NIDAE
IDAE
IDAE
AE
IDAE
ODONTIDAE
AE
IDAE
NIDAE
ARCHIDAE
AE
NARCIDAE
RIDAE
ARCHIDAE
RIDAE
ARCHIDAE
NIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
D-18
LC50VALUE
0.440
0.468
0493
0.647
0.701
0.732
1.011
IDAE) 1.800
0.995
1.600
2.800
7.800
24.771
20.498
47.329
50.748
1.161
4.020
80.082
958.792
158.156
358.792
455.015
803.845
10000
21.988
. 22.437
52.871
10.488
18.>56
52.871
53.088
5.000
10.000
31.823
244.259
10.000
244.259
783.471
999.998
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.458
301.610
345.472
401.217
2.000
8.611
32.601
B9.553
2.000
6.611
32.601
107.864
339.999
1992.474
6499.979
8479.723
339.999
3869.989
7049.608
9002.438
0.002
0.004
0.008
0.012
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.725
3.547
4.725
4.844
8.033
STATE: INDIANA
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
0.201 *
0.197 *
0.251 *
3,107 *
0.037 *
37.382 *
3.218 *
2.885 *
0.470 *
0.808 *
32.914 *
33.372 *
0.137 *
0.131 *
82.648 *
64.834 *
0.00053 *
0.00035 *
0.537 *
1.284 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FHV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00004 FCV
0.257* ACR
0.2148 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
3.3031 ACR
3.4404 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FHV
22.0395 ACR
17.2889 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0208 ACR
FOOTNOTE
» — UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
» + — FPV
FHV
ACR
FCV
SCV
FINAL PLANT
FINAL RESIDU
COMPUTED B
FINAL CHSON
VALUE
E VALUE
< ACUTE TO CHRC
1C VALUE
>NIC RATIO METHOD
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT
$ ZINC
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
• — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
$ - HARDNESS EFFECT
APPLY EQUATION 3
U - HARDNESS EFFECT
APPLY EQUATION 3
INTERCEPT VALUE
7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
INTERCEPT VALUE
7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV
41.988
48.861
92.757
21.223 9.829 47.0000 SCV
36.899
41.966
49.264
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: IOWA
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
U CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
J COPPER
CYANIDE
DOT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER Of
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 14
STATE 7
NATIONAL 8
STATE 9
NATIONAL 18
STATE 13
NATIONAL 8
STATE 4
NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
NATIONAL 23
STATE 17
NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
NATIONAL 20
STATE 12
NATIONAL 12
STATE 9
NATIONAL 9
STATE 9
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ANQUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
PHYSIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
QAMMAHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TU8IFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ESOCIDAE
POECIUIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
QAMMARIDAE
LC50 VALUE
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
7.451
16.000
16.392
21.000
878.098
1784.249
14128.643
16487.430
878.999
1046.138
18487.430
18484.838
0.048
0.486
1.147
2.860
0.884
1.147
1.630
2X80
6.325
19.000
23.238
32.249
6.329
23.238
40.000
94.711
67.000
6399.878
6998.790
24882.828
87X00
8888.780
24892.828
97461.672
0.309
0.798
0.885
1.345
0.256
0.798
0.889
1.345
76.707
83.000
114.316
129.121
83.000
114.319
129.121
167X00
1.323
1.S89
1.700
2.234
0.876
1.589
1.664
1.700
4.503
9.000
9.492
8.000
10X11
20.000
30.102
231.092
0.664
1.278
2.300
3.240
1.278
3.240
3.811
8X00
STATE: IOWA
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
3.388 *
2.773 *
113.283 *
42.377 *
0.027
0.317 *
1.874 *
1.203 *
12.164
3.407 *
0.194
0.133 *
31.428 *
33.249 *
0.690 *
0.462 *
1X30 *
0.832 *
0.208 *
0.391 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
0.0004 ACR
0.0091 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
0.0846 ACR
9.46818 FCV
4.99843 FCV
4.2472 ACR
4.4830 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0018 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.1800 ACR
'
FOOTNOTE
» — UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
» + _ FPV
FRV
ACR
FCV
SCV
FINAL PLANT
FINAL RESIDL
COMPUTED B
FINAL CHRON
VALUE
E VALUE
< ACUTE TO CHRi
1C VALUE
ONIC RATIO METHOD
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
M LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
1$ NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
t SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 17
STATE 8
NATIONAL 10
STATE 9
NATIONAL 7
STATE 4
NATIONAL 10
STATE 8
NATIONAL 9
STATE 3
NATIONAL 16
STATE 11
NATIONAL 9
STATE 4
NATIONAL 10
STATE 8
NATIONAL 8
STATE 5
NATIONAL 12
STATE 8
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERUDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECIUIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERUDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
ASELUDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
COENAORIONIDAE(AQRK)NIDA
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECIUIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PERUDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
• — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
I — HARDNESS EFFEC
APPLY EQUATION
tt - HARDNESS EFFEC
APPLY EQUATION
T INTERCEPT VALUE
3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIH
T INTERCEPT VALUE
3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIM
UM CRITERIA
UMAND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
0.440
0.488
0.493
0.647
0.732
0.790
1.011
1.265
0.895
1.800
2.800
7.800
1.800
26.000
47.329
50.748
1.161
4020
80.062
398.782
1.161
398.792
499.015
803X45
10X00
21.988
22.437
92X71
2.000
10.488
'42.188
53.096
9.000
10X00
31.623
244.259
10X00
783.471
898.888
0000
69.077
233.595
349.472
401.217
78.498
329X42
401.217
438X29
2X00
6.611
32X01
88X53
2.300
32.801
99X93
E) 282.842
338.888
1882.474
6481.878
8479.723
338888
3659.868
8002.436
2989.845
0.002
0.004
0.006
0X12
0.011
0.112
4.108
9.917
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.725
2X48
3.000
1547
8.033
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
0.201 *
0.271 *
0.291 *
0.245 *
0.037 *
0.035 *
3.218 *
0.392 *
0.470 *
0.470 *
**
32.914 *
. 31.086 *
0.137 *
0.131 *
82X48 «
65.749 *
0.00093 *
0.00021 *
0.937 *
0.780 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.2974 ACR
0.0281 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
3.3831 ACR
3.2047 ACR
0X14 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACR
17X328 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0128 ACR
D-19
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: IOWA
STATE: KANSAS
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCM VALUE
( ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHYSID
SALMOI
PHI LOO
STATE 11 DAPHN
PHYSID
PHILOD
CYPRIN
AE 41.966 ASELUDAE
4IDAE 48.861 EPHEMERELLIDAE
NtDAE 92.757 SALMONIDAE
DAE 21.223 4.992 * 47.0000 SCV STATE 5 CENTRARCHIDAE
AE 41.966 PERCICHTHYIDAE
NIDAE 92.757 ANGUILUDAE
DAE 266.568 CYPRINIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 4 DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE -
$$ CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 12 PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 2 CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE !
STATE 5 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE i
PERCICHTHYIDAE 3
CYPRINIDAE t
* COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 14 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 7 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 4 CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 8 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 4 CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
7.451
10.000
18.000
18.392
878.999
1794 241
4128.843
8487.430
1048.139
8487.430
9484.936
10194.383
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.880
0.183
0.884
2.880
6.987
6.325
15.000
23.236
32.249
23.238
54.711
0.000
0.000
87.000
63*9.976
8998.790
.4892.828
6998.790
4882.828
D4S4.750
7461.672
0.305
0.769
0.995
1.348
0.258
0.759
0.999
1.345
78.707
83,000
114.316
125.121
83.000
114.316
125.121
207.958
1323
1.895
1.700
2.234
0.978
1.595
2.409
3.904
4.503
5.000
5.452
8.000
MXB11
30.102
190.745
739.999
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
1.279
3.240
3411
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
3.388 *
2.454 *
113.263 *
140.493 *
0.027
0.041 *
1.974 *
1.974 *
**
12.164 *
1546.824 *
0.194
0.118 *
31.429 *
27.174 *
0.650
0.283 *
1.830 *
0.439 *
0.208 *
0.036 *
30-DAY
0.0004
0.0006
0.0043
0.0043
0.3378
10.0
5.48818
9.28331
4.2472
3.6722
0.0010
0.0010
0.0010
0.0019
0.1084
0.0185
AVERAGE
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
FPV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
COENAGRIONIDAEIAQRIONIDAE) 87.850
D-20
FOOTNOTE * — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
» - UNITS IN MICHOGSAMS PER LITER •• - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
+ t -FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE $ - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD tt - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: KANSAS
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
t* LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
** NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
t SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
17
7
10
4
7
3
10
6
9
2
16
10
5
3
10
7
B
3
12
g
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
GASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440
SALMONIDAE 0.468
PERLIDAE 0.493
PTERONARCIDAE 0.647
CYPRINIBAE 0.732
POECILIIDAE 0.750
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
COENAORIONIDAEIAQRIONIDAE) 1.800
PTERONARCIDAE 0.995
PALAEMONIDAE 1.800
PERLIDAE 2.800
ASTACIDAE 7.800
ASTACIDAE 7.800
CENTRARCHIDAE 26.000
DAPHNIDAE 50.748
CYPRINIDAE 179.508
QAMMARIDAE 1.181
DAPHNIDAE 4.020
SALMONIDAE 80.082
CYPRINIDAE 358.792
CYPRINIDAE 358.792
CENTRARCHIDAE 455.015
PHILODINIDAE 803.845
0.000
ASELLIDAE 10.000
SALMONIDAE 21.988
QAMMARIDAE 22.437
CENTRARCHIDAE 52.871
CENTRARCHIDAE 42.198
ICTALURIDAE 53.068
PERCIOAE 68.000
CYPRINIDAE 94.805
DAPHNIDAE 5.000
QAMMARIDAE 10.000
ASTACIDAE 31.623
SALMONIDAE 244.259
PHILODINIDAE 783.471
NAIDIDAE 999.998
0.000
0.000
DAPHNIDAE 65.077
EPHEMERELLIOAE 233.555
CENTRARCHIDAE 345.472
PHILODINIDAE 401.217
DAPHNIDAE 78.456
PERCICHTHYIDAE 301.510
CENTRARCHIDAE 325.842
PHILODINIDAE 401.217
SALMONIDAE 2.000
CENTRARCHIDAE 6.611
CYPRINIDAE 32.801
QAMMARIDAE 99.553
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.300
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
COENAQRIONIDAE (AQRIONIDAE) 282.842
0.000
HYALELLIDAEfTAUTRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 1992.474
CYPRINODONTIDAE 8499.979
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
HYALELLIDAE(TALITRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 3889.989
CYPRINIDAE 9002.438
POECILIIDAE 12599.945
DAPHNIDAE 0.002
COTTIDAE 0.004
CYPRINIDAE 0.000
CYPRINODONTIDAE 0.012
CYPRINIDAE 0.011
CENTRARCHIDAE 0.112
PHILODINIDAE 5,517
0.000
PERLIDAE 1.300
PTERONARCIDAE 2.627
ICTALURIDAE 3.547
CENTRARCHIDAE 4.725
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.848
ICTALURIDAE 3.547
CYPRINIOAE 8.033
PERCIDAE 12.000
STATE: KANSAS
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
0.201 *
0.208 *
0.251 *
0.768 *
0.037 *
0.037 *
**
3.218 *
14.391 *
0.470 *
0.470 *
**
32.914 *
29.868 *
0.137 *
0.137 *
**
82.848 *
58.854 *
0.00053 *
0.00063 *
**
0.537 *
0.831 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.2574 ACR
1.1512 ACR
0.20 FHV
0.20 FHV
3.3931 ACR
3.0791 *CR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FHV
22.0395 ACR
15.1611 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0102 ACR
FOOTNOTE
* - UNITS IN MICROORAM6 PER LITER
* t — FPV FINAL PLANT
FRV FINAL RESIDU
ACR COMPUTED B
FCV FINAL CHRON
VALUE
E VALUE
r ACUTE TO CHHC
1C VALUE
NIC RATIO METHOD
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT
M ZINC
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC80 VALUE MAXIMUM 30- DAY AVERAGE
NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
• — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
•• - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
« - HARDNESS EFFECT
APPLY EQUATION 3
SI - HARDNESS EFFECT
APPLY EQUATION 3
INTERCEPT VALUE
7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
INTERCEPT VALUE
7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV
41.966
48.881
92.757
21.223 7.338 * 47.0000 SCV
41.986
49.254
92.757
D-21
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: KENTUCKY
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
SI CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
$ COPPER
CYANIDE
DOT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TEST
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
ED
14
7
8
8
18
14
8
3
10
7
23
18
10
7
20
8
12
5
e
5
NAME
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
SALMONIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LCM VALUE
( + )
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
4.503
7.451
8.000
10.000
878.899
1794.245
14128.843
18487.430
878.999
1048.139
13339.965
18487.430
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.044
0.163
0.884
1.147
6.325
15.000
23.238
32.249
23.238
25.481
54.711
0.000
67.000
6399.976
8998.790
24802.828
87.000
6998.790
24892.828
30454.750
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.258
0.759
0.995
1.022
78.707
63.000
114.316
125.121
57.000
83X00
114.316
167.000
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.978
3.000
4.000
4.102
4.503
5.000
5.452
8.000
2.459
5.000
10.811
30.102
0.864
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.884
1.279
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+)
3.388 *
1.774 *
113.263 *
58.104 *
0.027
0.013
1.974 *
1.974 *
**
12.184
5.387 *
0.194
0.142
31.429 *
18.831 *
0.650 «
0.338 *
1.830 *
0.338 »
0.208 *
0.137 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
(•M (++)
0.0004 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
0.1498 ACR
5.46818 FCV
4.79332 FCV
4.2472 ACR
2.5178 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1084 ACR
0.0701 ACR
FOOTNOTE
> — UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
» „ _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDU
ACR COMPUTED B\
FCV FINAL CHRON
E VALUE
ACUTE TO CHfi
C VALUE
3NIC RATIO METHOD
D.?9 SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: KENTUCKY
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME L<
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SI LEAD NATIONAL 7 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 5 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 4 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
» NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIOAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 6 HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
( SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
corn DAE
CYPHINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 6 COTTIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 7 ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
• — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
S — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
It - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
;so VALUE
(+)
0.440
0.488
0.493
0.647
0.894
0.732
0.750
1.011
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.600
13.058
24.771
50.748
179.508
1.181
4.020
80.062
358.792
1.161
158.156
358.792
485.015
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.871
8.004
10.000
62.871
53.068
5.000
10.000
31423
244.259
10.000
246.590
783.471
999.998
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.458
301.510
325.842
401.217
2.000
6.611
32.601
09.553
2.000
6.611
32.601
92.054
339.999
1992.474
8499.979
8479.723
339.989
3869.969
7049.608
9002.438
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
1.300
2.827
3.547
4.725
3.647
4.725
5.251
8.033
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(•M
0.201 *
0.280 *
0.251 *
1.384 *
0.037 *
0.059 *
3.218 *
1.133 *
0.470 *
0.639 *
32.914 *
31.618 *
0.137 *
0.144 *
82.648 *
74.102 *
0.00053 *
0.00041 *
0.537 *
1.266 *
30-DAY
4+)
0.0023
0.0023
0.0038
0.0038
0.00003
0.00004
0.2574
0.0906
0.20
0.20
3.3931
3.2598
0.014
0.014
22.03*3
19.7804
0.0087
0.0205
AVERAQE
( 4.4.)
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FHV
ACR
Acn
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: KENTUCKY STATE: LOUISIANA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCW VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCW VALUE
$ ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIOAE 13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIOAE
PHYSIDAE 41.966 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48.881 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE 21.223 8.396 47.0000 SCV STATE 7 CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE 28.243 PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.966 ANQUILLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE 49.264 CYPRINIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 6 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 4 DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
tt CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 12 PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 6 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 5 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
$ COPPER NATIONAL 23 OAPHNIDAE
CHiRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 15 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
E8OCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 9 DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECIUIOAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 3 CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAQRIONIOAEfAQRIONIDA
KWINUIC tt _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
»« I FPV FINAL PLANT VALul * - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FHV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACH COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD » - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30.DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
7.451
10.000
16.000
16.332
878.999
1794.245
4128.643
KM87.430
1046.139
6487.430
19484.938
20194.383
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.880
0.163
0.884
2.860
6.987
6.325
15.000
23.238
32.249
6,325
23.238
54.711
66.000
67.000
6399.976
6098.790
24892.828
6998.790
24892.828
30454.750
57481.672
0.305
O.TM
0.995
1.345
0.256
• 0.759
0.995
1.2384
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
83.000
114.316
207.958
431.499
1.323
1.SW
1.700
2.234
0.976
3.000
3.234
4.102
4.503
5.000
5452
8.000
10.800
10.811
20.000
30.102
0.684
1.279
2.300
3.240
1.279
3.811
•) 87.680
0.000
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
3.388 *
2.646 *
113.263 *
140.493 *
0.027
0.041 *
1.974 *
1.097 *
12.164
1546.824 *
0.194
0.123 *
31.429 *
16.127 *
0.650
0.364 *
1.830 *
2.569 *
0.208 *
OJ08 *
**
0.0004 ACR
0.0006 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
f
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.48618 FCV
9.09372 FCV
4.2472 ACR
2.1792 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.1084 ACR
D-23
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: LOUISIANA
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
M LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
M NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
t SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TEST
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
ED
7
6
10
5
7
3
10
5
9
4
18
10
5
2
10
7
9
3
12
7
NAME
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILMDAE
CENTHAHCHIOAE
PTERONARCIOAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPfllNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHiflONOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIOAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
LCSOVALUE
(+)
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.647
0.471
0.732
0.750
1.011
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
1.800
24.771
50.748
81.900
1.161
4.020
80.062
358.792
358.792
455.015
803.845
0.000
10.000
21.968
22.437
52.671
45.277
52.671
53.066
94.805
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.258
20.000
240.000
783.471
998.996
66.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.458
301.910
401,217
439.825
2.000
8.611
32.801
99.953
6.611
32.801
0.000
0.000
339.999
1992.474
6499.979
8479.723
339.999
3889.969
9002.436
12599.945
0.002
0.004
0.008
0.012
0.010
0.112
5.617
0.000
1.300
2.827
3.547
4.725
3.547
4.725
8.033
8.672
FRESHWATER AOUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
( + )
0.201 *
0.190 *
0.251 *
0.208 *
0.037 *
0.037 *
**
3.218 *
13.938 *
0.470 *
1.864 *
32.914 *
29.005 *
0.137 *
0.137 *
**
82.648 4
58.854 *
0.00053 *
1.00053 *
**
0.937 *
1.187 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
( + ) (++)
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.2574 ACR
1.1149 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
3.3931 ACR
2.9901 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACR
15.1811 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0193 ACR
FOOTNOTE
» — UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
t t — FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
D-24
FRV
ACR
FCV
SCV
FINAL RESIDU
COMPUTED B\
FINAL CHRON
E VALUE
ACUTE TO CHRC
1C VALUE
NIC RATIO METHOD
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: LOUISIANA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AOUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
i ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
S — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
It — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
50 VALUE MAXIMUM SO-DAY AVERAGE
(*) (+» (+) (++)
13.737 8.148 47.0000 SCV
41.966
48.861
92.757
21.223 8.135 * 47.0000 SCV
41.086
49.284
481.416
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MAINE
NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ALDRIN NATIONAL
STATE
ARSENIC NATIONAL
STATE
JJ CADMIUM NATIONAL
STATE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL
STATE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL
STATE
$ COPPER NATIONAL
STATE
CYANIDE NATIONAL
STATE
DDT NATIONAL
STATE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL
STATE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL
STATE
14
8
6
3
18
16
6
3
10
6
23
20
10
7
20
9
12
6
9
4
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC60VALUE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ANQUILLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
POECILIIOAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.603
9.000
11.732
16.000
20.494
678.999
1794.245
14128.643
18487.430
1048.139
14983.949
19859.936
0.000
0.048
0.498
1.147
2.660
0.026
0.664
1.147
1.630
8.329
15.000
23.238
32.249
12.371
26.000
60.200
0.000
67.000
8399.976
8998.790
24892.828
8998.790
24892.826
30494.790
40637.609
0.306
0.799
0.996
1346
0256
0.799
0.998
1.349
78.707
83.000
114.316
129.121
63.000
102.000
103.227
125.121
1.323
1.596
1.700
2.234
0.978
1.595
2.398
3.000
4.503
6.000
5.453
6.000
8.000
10.800
22.101
231.062
0.684 '
1.279
2.300
3.240
1.279
3.240
5.800
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
3.386 *
3.313 *
113.263 *
113.263 *
**
0.027
0.019
1.974 *
1.974 *
+*
12.164
1811.186 *
0.194
0.151
31.429 *
35.949 *
0.660
0.394 *
1.630 *
0.390 *
0.206 •
0.043 +
0.0004 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
6.46616 . FCV
7.22020 FCV
4.2472 ACR
48579 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FHV
-
0.1064 ACR
0.0218 ACR
(,,
STATE: MAINE
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
M LEAD
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
17 QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
8 QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
0.440
0.488
0.493
0.847
0.440
0.498
0.582
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
0.201
0.0023
MERCURY
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
SELENIUM
S SILVER
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
COENAGRIONIDAEIAQRIONIDAE) 87.690
COENAGRIONIDAEIAQRIONIDAE) 1.800
10 PTERONARCIDAE 0.996
PALAEMONIDAE 1.800
PERLIDAE 2.800
ASTACIDAE 7.800
4 QAMMARIDAE 29.000
DAPHNIDAE 50.748
SALMONIDAE 81.900
CYPRINIDAE 100.697
7 QAMMARIDAE 1.161
DAPHNIDAE 4.020
SALMONIDAE 60.062
CYPRINIDAE 398.792
3 SALMONIDAE 40.629
CYPRINIDAE 157.991
PHILODINIDAE 603.849
0.000
10 ASELLIDAE KLOOO
SALMONIDAE 21.968
QAMMARIDAE 22.437
CENTRARCHIDAE 52.871
6 SALMONIOAE 16.889
CENTRARCHIDAE 32.000
QAMMARIDAE 48.000
PERCIDAE 88.000
9 DAPHNIDAE 5.000
QAMMARIDAE 10.000
ASTACIDAE 31.623
SALMONIOAE 244.259
6 QAMMARIOAE 10.000
ASTACIDAE 60X100
SALMONIOAE 240.000
PHILODINIDAE 783.471
16 DAPHNIDAE 85.077
EPHEMERELLIDAE 233.555
CENTRARCHIDAE 349.472
PHILODINIDAE 401.217
13 DAPHNIOAE 76.486
CENTRARCHIDAE 388.350
PHILODINIDAE 401.217
CHIRONOMIDAE 439.82S
9 SALMONIDAE 2.000
CENTRARCHIDAE 6.811
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
QAMMARIDAE 99.963
3 CENTRARCHIDAE 2JOO
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
COENAGHIONIDAE (AQHIONIDAE) 282.842
0.000
10 HYALELLIOAE(TALITRIDAE) 339.999
OAPHNIDAE 1992.474
CYPRINODONTIDAE 6499.979
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
9 HYALELLIDAEfTALITRIDAE) 330.999
CYPRINIDAE 3108.149
OAPHNIDAE 3669.989
SALMONIOAE 10199.973
9 OAPHNIDAE 0.002
CCTTIOAE 0.004
CYPRINIDAE 0.008
CYPRINODONTIDAE 0.012
2 CYPRINIDAE 0.011
PHILODINIDAE 6.617
0.000
0.000
12 PERLIDAE 1.300
PTERONARCIDAE 2.627
ICTALURIDAE 3.547
CENTRARCHIDAE 4.725
7 CENTRARCHIDAE 2.000
CYPRINIDAE 6.166
SALMONIDAE . 6.900
PERCIDAE 12.000
3.219 *
0.137 *
**
82.648 *
46.810 *
0.00063 *
**
0.537
0.981
22.0395
12.4828
ACR
ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0094 ACR
FOOTNOTE
t - UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
* » — FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV • FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
— FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
- STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
- HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
- HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
3Q.QAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
0-25
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MAINE STATE: MARYLAND
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 39-DAY AYEHAOE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE
ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIOAE 13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIOAE
PHYSIDAE 41.968 ASELUDAE
SALMONIDAE 48.861 EPHEMERELUDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE 21.223 8.532 47.0000 SCV STATE 9 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.966 EPHEMERELUDAE
SALMONIDAE 73.017 SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 ANQUILLIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 6 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 4 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SI CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIOAE
STATE 17 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPBIMODONTIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
t COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 18 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
FOOTNOTE * — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
+ - UNITS IN M1CROGRAMS PER LITER * * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
, , _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE » - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD it — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
-,.£ SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
7.451
8.000
9.000
0.803
7.451
9.000
14.377
16.000
878.999
1794.245
14128.643
16487.430
1046.139
14128.643
19464.936
20194.383
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.034
0.864
1.147
1.630
6.325
15.000
23.238
32.249
23.238
40.000
40.044
54.711
67.000
8399.976
6998.790
24892.828
8998.790
24892.828
30454.750
57481.672
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.345
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.976
1.595
1.664
3.000
4.503
6.000
!.452
6.000
5.154
8.000
10.811
30.102
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664
1279
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
3.388 *
2.749 *
113.263 *
141.620 *
0.027
0.021
1.974 *
8.017 *
12.184
1692.459 *
0.194
0.139
31.429 *
30.219 *
0.850 *
0.357 *
1430 *
1.037 *
0208 +
0.149 *
39-DAY AVERAQE
0.0004 ACR
0.0003 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
546618 FCV
6.36350 FCV
4.2472 ACR
4.0836 ACR
0,0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.0762 ACH
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MARYLAND
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
tt LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
U NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
J SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTI
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
D
17
11
10
5
7
4
10
7
9
5
16
12
5
5
10
7
9
5
12
8
NAME
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMO
PERLID
PTEHO
NIDAE
AE
•4ARCIDAE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMO
CYPRIN
POECIL
NIDAE
IDAE
IIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAE
PERLID
ASTAC
CENTP,
SALMO
GAMMA
DAPHN
JON IDAE
AC
DAE
WCHIOAE
NIDAE
kRIDAE
DAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHN
SALMO
CYPRIN
IDAE
NIDAE
IDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRIN
CENTR
PHILOC
IDAE
ARCH IDAE
INIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMO
GAMMA
CENTR
GAMMA
SALMO
CENTR/
ICTALU
NIDAE
kRIDAE
^RCHIDAE
kftlDAE
NIDAE
IRCHIDAE
RIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMA
ASTACI
SALMO
RIDAE
DAE
NIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACI
SALMO
PHILOO
DAPHN
EPHEM
CENTR,
PHILOC
DAPHN
CENTR,
PHILOC
CHIHOI
DAE
NIDAE
INIDAE
DAE
ERELLIDAE
WCHIDAE
INIDAE
DAE
WCHIDAE
INIDAE
JOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTR,
CYPRIN
GAMMA
SALMO
CENTFU
CYPRIN
GAMMA
IRCHIDAE
IDAE
kRIDAE
NIDAE
IRCHIDAE
IDAE
RIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHN
CYPRIN
SALMO
DAE
ODONTIDAE
NIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIDAE)
DAPHN
SALMO
CYPRIN
DAPHN
COTTID
CYPRIN
CYPRIN
COTTID
CYPRIN
SALMO
CENTR/
DAE
NIDAE
IDAE
DAE
AE
IDAE
ODONTIDAE
AE
IDAE
NIDAE
VRCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTESOf
ICTALU
CENTR/
WHCIDAE
IIDAE
kRCHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALU
SALMO
RIDAE
IIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
LCSO VALUE
1 + )
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.647
0.440
0.926
0.732
0.750
0.999
1.800
2.800
7.800
28.000
32.702
47.329
50.748
1.161
4.020
80.062
358.792
80.062
398.792
455.015
803.845
10.000
21,988
22.437
52.871
10.488
18.933
42.198
64,000
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
10.000
50.000
244.259
783.471
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
78456
345.478
401217
439.625
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.553
2.000
2.300
32.801
107.884
339.999
1992.474
6499.979 .
8479.723
339.999
3889.989
8479.723
9002.438
0.002
0.004
0.008
0.012
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.725
2.848
3.000
7.128
8.033
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(4.)
0.201 *
0.188 *
0.251 *
9.199 *
0.037 *
14.969 *
3.218 *
2.473 *
0.470 *
0.631 *
32.914 *
33.129 *
0.137 *
0.080 *
82.646 *
62.801 *
0.00053 *
0.00036 *
0.537 •
0.775 *
90-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (++)
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0036 FRV
0.0036 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.02574 ACR
0.1978 ACR
0.20 FRV
0,20 FRV
3.3931 ACR
3.4193 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.9399 ACR
16.7489 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0126 ACR
FOOTNOTE
* - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
, , - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACP. COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: MARYLAND
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
S ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOCHNIOAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
J - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
SS - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
U VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (+) (+) (+*)
13.737 6.148 * 47.0000 SCV
41.986
48.881
92.757
21.223 8.523 47.0000 SCV
41.966
S8.086
92.757
D-27
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MASSACHUSETTS
STATE: MASSACHUSETTS
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
14
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDJ
EPHEME
*E
1ELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ARSENIC
$S CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
$ COPPER
CYANIDE
DOT
DIELDRIN
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
9
8
5
18
16
8
4
10
6
23
SALMON
CENTRAf
EPHEME
DAE
1CHIDAE
1ELLIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIC
SALMON
AE
DAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMON
ICTALUH
DAE
DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIC
GAMMAF
AE
IDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNi:
GAMMAF
AE
IDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERON
CYPRINI
4RCIDAE
3AE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMON
GAMMAF
IDAE
1IDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNII
PHILODI
)AE
MIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSID*
PERC1CI-
E
THY1DAE
CYPSINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
19
10
7
20
PHYSID;
E
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDX
E
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNI
CENTRA
DAE
RCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRA
RCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
11
12
6
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCID/
GAMMA
kE
FIIDAE
ASTACIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIC
A6
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ENDOSULFAN
NATIONAL
STATE
9
6
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHIN
DAE
PTERONARCIBAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHIN
CATOST
DAE
OMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
n.js
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
4.503
7.451
9.000
16.000
878.999
1 794.245
14128.643
19487,430
1046.139
14128.643
16487.430
19484.938
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.880
0.034
0.864
1.147
1.630
6.325
16.000
23.238
32.249
23.238
33.862
40.000
64.711
87.000
6399.976
6996.790
24892.828
6998.790
24892.826
30454.750
57461.672
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.345
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
78.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.976
1.595
1.664
3.000
4.503
5.000
5.452
3.000
2.469
8.000
14.460
30.102
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664
1.279
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(•f) ( + » (++)
3.388 *
1 .520 *
113.263 *
171.493 *
0.027
0.019
1.974 *
7.675 *
12.164
1692.459 *
0.194
0.145
31.429 *
29.583 *
0.650
0.370 *
1.830 *
0.471 *
0.208 *
0.149 *
0.0004 ACR
0.0003 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.46618 FCV
8,47114 FCV
4.2472 ACR
3.9977 ACR
0.0010 FHV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FHV
0.1064 ACR
0.0762 ACH
FOOTNOTE
* - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
, , _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUf,
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCM VALUE
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 9 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
JI LEAD NATIONAL 1 QAMMAH1DAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
GAMMAHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 7 GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 gAPHNIDAE^
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 5 GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
U NICKEL NATIONAL 18 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL S SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 7 HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE}
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
$ SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINOOONTIDAE
STATE 4 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PEHLJDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 8 CENTHARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
It _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
t - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
it - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.647
0.440
0.559
1.011
1.086
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
13.058
26.000
47.329
50.748
1.161
4.020
80.062
358.792
80.062
358.792
455.015
803.845
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.671
10.488
14.158
42.198
53.066
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
10.000
50.000
248.595
783.471
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.456
345.472
401.217
439.825
2.000
6.611
32.801
99.553
2.000
2.300
32.601
107.684
339.999
1992.474
8499.979
8479.723
339.999
3869.989
8479.723
9002.436
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.011
0.021
0,112
5.517
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.725
2,846
3,547
6.678
7.429
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERA3E
0.201 *
0.153 *
0.251 *
3.521 *
0.037 *
14,969 *
3.218 *
2.245 *
0.470 *
0.629 *
32.914 *
33.129 *
0.137 *
0.060 *
82.648 *
62.801 *
0.00053 *
0.00008 *
0.537 *
0.919
0.0023 FRV
0,0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0,00003 FCV
0.00004 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.1796 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
3.3931 ACR
3.4153 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0396 ACR
18.7489 ACR
0,0087 ACR
0.0149 ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MASSACHUSETTS
STATE: MICHIGAN
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AOUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCW VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
(+) .. 1+) 1+) <*+>
S ZINC NATIONAL IS DAPHNIDAE 13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE «1.966 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48.861 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE 21.223 8.4S1 47.0000 SCV STATE 9 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHYSIOAE 41.966 EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 51.845 SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 ANOUILLIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 6 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 6 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
M CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
OAMMARIDAE
PHYSIOAE
STATE 15 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CHLOHDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAe
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 5 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 8 QAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
$ COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIOAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 19 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE a SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIOAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
ASTACIDAE
OIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECIUIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE » SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
t - UNITS IN MICROORAMS PER LITER ** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
» + _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE » • - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FHV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD $S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FIMALCHTONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
50 VALUE
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
7.451
9.000
10.803
16.000
878.999
1794.345
14128.643
18487.430
878.999
1046.139
14128.043
16467.430
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.048
0.864
1.147
1.630
8.325
15.000
23.238
32.249
8.3W
23.238
32.249
43.739
87.000
6399.976
6996.790
24862.823
67.000
8996.790
24892.828
57481.872
0.305
0.759
0.995
1,345
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.330
76.707
83.000
114.316
128.121
76.707
03.000
114.316
125.121
1.323
1.698
1.700
2.234
0.976
1.59S
2.234
3.000
4.503
5.000
5.4S2
8.000
5.452
8.000
10.811
20.000
0.684
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664
1.279
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
3.388 *
2.767 *
113.263 *
56.980 *
0.027
0.023
1.974 *
1.511 *
12.164
3.407 *
0.194
0.145
31.429 *
30.219 *
0.650
0.410 *
1.830 *
1.550 *
C.J08 *
0.149 *
30-DAY AVERAQE
0.0004 ACR
0.0003 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 fan
0.3378 ACR
0.0946 ACR
5,46618 FCV
4.79332 FCV
4.2472 ACR
4.0836 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.0762 ACR
D-29
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MICHIGAN
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
SS LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
SS NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
$ SILVER
TOXAPHEN6
NUMBER OF
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
17
10
10
e
7
5
10
a
8
7
16
13
5
5
10
8
9
6
12
9
NAME
GASTEHOSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERUDAE
PTERONARC1DAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAEfTALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
COTTIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
OENTRARCHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
LCSO VALUE
(+)
0.440
0.468
0,493
0.647
0.625
0,732
0.750
1.011
0,995
1.800
2800
7.800
1.800
26.000
29.498
37.048
1.181
4.020
80.062
358.792
1.161
80.062
398.792
455.015
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.871
21.988
22.437
42.198
53.086
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
10.000
244.259
783.471
999.998
85.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.456
233.555
345.472
401.217
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.553
2.000
2.300
32.601
99.553
339.999
1992.474
8499.979
8479.723
339.999
3869.989
8479.723
9002.438
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.725
2.848
3.547
5.781
8.033
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+)
0.201 *
0.265 *
0.251 *
0.331 *
0.037 *
0.054 *
3.218 *
6.601 *
0.470 *
1.222 *
32.914 *
33.660 *
0.137 *
0.063 »
82.648 *
72.017 *
0.00053 *
0.00041 *
0.537 *
0.943 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
1+) (++)
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00004 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.5261 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
3.3931 ACR
3.4908 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
_
22.0395 ACR
19.2044 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0153 ACR
FOOTNOTE
, _ UNITS IN MICROGHAMS PER LITER
* i - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
D-30
FHV
ACR
FCV
scv
FINAL RESIDU
COMPUTED B1
FINAL CHRON
E VALUE
1 ACUTE TO CHB<
1C VALUE
>NIC RATIO METHOD
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: MICHIGAN
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
t ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
* - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
t - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 37 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
$1 - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
<+> (+) ( + ) (++)
13.737 8.148 * 47.0000 SCV
41.968
48.861
92.757
21.223 7.891 * 47.0000 SCV
41.966
44.947
92.757
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MINNESOTA
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
tt CADMIUM
CHLOROANE
CHROMIUM
t COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
14
7
8
5
18
14
a
4
10
a
23
18
10
8
20
12
12
6
9
6
NAME
CENTRARCHIOAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAflCHIOAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMAPIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMAPIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINOOONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSFDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMON IOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMON IOAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LC80 VALUE MAXIMUM
7.451 3.388 *
8.000
9.000
10.803
5.241 1.525 *
7.451
18.000
16.382
878.999 113.283 *
1794.245
14128.643
18487.430
1048.139 171.493 *
14128.843
16487.430
19484.936
0.048 0.027 *
0.498
1.147
2.860
0.046 0.021
0.864
1.147
1.830
6.325 1.974 *
15.000
23.238
32.249
23.238 7511 *
32.249
40.281
54.711
67.000 12.184
8399.978
8996.790
24882.828
6996.790 1531.490 *
24882.828
57461.872
59899.703
0.305 0.194 *
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.250 0,139
0.759
0.995
1 345
78.707 31.429 *
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707 30.219 *
63000
114.316
125121
1323 0.660 *
1.695
1.700 •
2234
0.976 0.434 *
1.696
1.700
2234
4.503 1.630 *
5.000
5.452
8.000
3.673 0.211 *
10.611
30.102
831.052
0.664 0.206 *
1279
2.300
3240
0.864 0.149 *
1.279
3.240
3811
30-DAY AVERAQE
0.0004 ACR
0.0003 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.46618 FCV
957750 FCV
4,2472 ACR
4.0836 ACH
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FHV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
00762 ACR
f-
FOOTNOTE
- UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
* » - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: MINNESOTA
NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17
STATE 8
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10
STATE 5
W LEAD NATIONAL 7
STATE 4
LINDANE NATIONAL 10
STATE 8
MERCURY NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
M NICKEL NATIONAL 16
STATE 11
PCBS NATIONAL 5
STATE t>
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10
STATE 9
( SILVER NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12
STATE 8
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERU DAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PERUDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE '
CYPRINIDAE
• * _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
$ - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
U - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.847
0.667
0.732
0.750
1.011
0.995
1.600
2.800
7.800
17.703
26.000
37.048
50.748
1.181
4.020
80.062
358.7S2
80.062
358.792
456.015
803.845
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.871
18.355
22.437
42.198
53.086
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
10.000
248.595
783,471
999 9BB
85.077
233.655
345.472
401217
78.458
328.842
401217
439.625
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.563
2.000
2.300
32801
107.664
339.999
1992.474
8499.979
6479.723
339.999
3889.989
8479.723
9002.438
0.002
0,004
0.006
0.012
0.011
0.021
0.112
4.108
1.300
2.827
3.547
4.725
2849
3.547
5223
8.033
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
0.201 *
0.278 *
0.251 *
5.374 *
0.037 *
14.989 *
3.218 *
5.618 *
0.470 *
0.808 *
32.914 *
31.088 *
0.137 *
0.060 *
62.646 *
81.976 *
0.00063 *
0.00011 *
0.637 *
0,907 *
30-DAY
0.0023
0.0023
0.0038
0.003B
0.00003
0.00004
02574
0.4494
0.20
0.20
3.3931
3.2047
0.014
0.014
22.0395
21.8801
0.0087
0.0147
AVERA06
FRV
FHV
FHV
FRV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FHV
FRV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
D-31
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
TATE: MINNESOTA STATE: MISSISSIPPI
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAOE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
(+1 (+1 (+) (++)
ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV ALORIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.986 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIOAE 48.861 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE 21.223 7.440 » 47.0000 SCV STATE 7 CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE 36.872 ASELLIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.966 PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 ANOUILLJOAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL B OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 5 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
t$ CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 13 PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CVPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 8 QAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
* COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 18 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIOAE
TUBIFICIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
E8OCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIOAE
ASELLIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 0 ASELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 3 CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
,50 VALUE
(+)
7.451
6.000
9.000
10.803
7.451
8.000
10.000
16.000
878.999
1794.245
14128.643
18467.430
878.999
1046.139
18487.430
19484.938
0.048
0.498
1.147
2.660
0.183
0.864
1.147
2.860
6.325
15,000
23.238
32.249
6.325
23.238
54.711
0.000
67.000
6399.976
6996.790
24892428
67.000
8908.790
24892.828
30454.750
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.345
76.707
83.000
114.318
125.121
93.1X0
114.318
167.000
207.998
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.978
3.000
3.234
4.000
4.503
9.000
9.492
8.000
6.000
10.611
20.000
30.102
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
1.279
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+)
3.388 *
2.395 *
113.263 *
42.377 *
0.027
0.059 *
1.974 * .
1.974 *
**
12.184
4.108 *
0.194
0.127 *
31.429 *
27.587 *
0450 *
0.385 *
1.830 *
1.115 *
0.208 *
0.208 »
**
30-DAY AVERAOE
<+) (++>
0.0004 ACR
0.0009 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
0,1141 ACR
5.48618 FCV
4.45175 FCV
4.2472 ACR
3.7279 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1084 ACR
0.1084 ACft
COENAQRIONIDAE(AQRIONIDAE) 87.660
FOOTNOTE * — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
t - UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER ** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
» t — FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE S — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD M - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
,, SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
0.000
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MISSISSIPPI
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
tt LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
U NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
t SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
17
9
10
4
7
4
10
5
9
4
16
11
5
4
10
7
NAME
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMO
PERLID
PTERO^
NIDAE
»E
MRCIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECIL
CENTR/
PALAEfc
PTEROh
PALAEH
PERLID
ASTACI
IDAE
kRCHIDAE
IONIDAE
ARCIDAE
IONIDAE
\E
DAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTR/
DAPHN
CYPRIN
RCHIDAE
DAE
DAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHN
SALMO
CYPRIN
DAE
1IDAE
DAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPHIN
CENTR/
PHILOD
ASELLK
SALMO
QAMMA
CENTR/
AEELLII
CENTR/
ICTALU
CYPRIN
DAPHN
QAMMA
ASTACI
SALMO
GAMMA
ASTACI
PHILOD
NAIDID/
DAE
RCHIDAE
NIDAE
ME
•ilDAE
RIDAE
IRCHIDAE
>AE
IRCHIDAE
1IDAE
DAE
DAE
RIDAE
ME
4IDAE
RIDAE
5AE
NIDAE
IE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEM
CENTRA
PHILOD
.RELLIDAE
RCHIDAE
NIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIC
CENTRA
PHILOD
HTHYIDAE
RCHIDAE
NIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTR*
CYPRIN
QAMMA
CENTRA
CYPRIN
QAMMA
COENAC
HYALEL
DAPHNI
CYPRIN
SALMOK
RCHIDAE
DAE
RIDAE
RCHIDAE
DAE
RIDAE
iRIONIDAEIAQ
LIDAEfTALITRI
DAE
3DONTIDAE
IIOAE
RION
3AE)
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
OAPHNI
CYPRIN
POECILI
DAE
DAE
DAE
» DAPHNIDAE
6
12
7
COTTID/
CYPRIN
CYPRIN
COTTIDJ
CYPRIN
CENTRA
PHILOO
PERLIO/
PTEHON
ICTALUF
CENTRA
ICTALUf
CENTRA
CYPRIN
IE
DAE
3DONTIDAE
kE
DAE
RCHIDAE
NIDAE
kE
ARCIDAE
IDAE
RCHIDAE
IDAE
RCHIDAE
DAE
DAPHNIDAE
LC50 VALUE
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.647
0.732
0.750
1.011
1.265
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
1800
24.771
60.748
179.508
1.161
4.020
80.062
398.782
1.161
358.792
455.015
803,645
10.000
21.968
22.437
52.871
10.000
92.871
63.066
94.805
6.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
10.000
20.000
783.471
999.998
65.077
233.655
345.472
401.217
78.458
301.510
325.842
401.217
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.553
6.611
38.601
92.054
DAE) 282.842
339.989
1892.474
6499.979
8479.723
339.999
3889.989
9002.438
12589.845
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.004
0.011
0.112
5.517
1.300
2.627
3.647
4.725
3.647
4.725
8.033
14.378
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
0.201
0.277 *
0.251 *
0.118 *
0.037 *
0.035 *
3218 *
2.174 *
0.470 *
0.170 *
32.914 *
31.818 *
0.137 *
0.520 *
82.648 *
66.854 *
0.00063 *
0.00002 *
0.537 *
0.907 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.0010 ACR
0.2574 ACR
0.1739 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.1133 ACR
3.3931 ACR
3.2596 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.03W ACR
15.1811 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0147 ACfl
,*
FOOTNOTE
- - UNITS IN MICROSRAMS PER LITER
, , _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: MISSISSIPPI
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
1 ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
~~
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
I - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
IS - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30.DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV
41.986
48.861
62.757
21.223 7.684 * 47.0000 SCV
41.968
49.264
92.767
D-33
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MISSOURI
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
SS CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
S COPPER
CYANIDE
DOT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
14
6
8
4
18
13
6
3
10
5
23
16
10
5
20
10
12
5
9
4
NAME
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
ANGJILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ESOCIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIOAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LC60 VALUE
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
7.451
10,000
16.000
16.392
878.999
1794.245
14128.643
18487.430
1046.139
18487.430
19484.938
20194.383
0.048
0,496
1.147
2.880
0.163
0.664
1.147
2.860
6.325
15.000
23.238
32.249
6.325
23.238
54.711
0.000
67.000
6399.976
6996.790
24892.828
6998.790
24892.826
30454.750
57461.672
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.296
0.759
0.999
1.345
78.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
83.000
114.316
207.958
431.499
1.323
1.695
1.700
2.234
0.976
1.700
2.409
3.234
4.503
5.000
5.452
8.000
10.811
20.000
30.102
231.062
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
1.279
3.840
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
3.388 *
2.551 *
113.263 *
140.493 *
0.027 *
0.059 «
1.974 •
1.974 t
**
12.184
1548.824 *
0.194
0.127 «
31.429 t
16.127 *
0.650
0.366 •
1.630 t
0.832 *
0.208 *
0.036 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
0.0004 ACR
0.0009 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.48618 FCV
9,57790 FCV
42472 ACR
2.1792 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1084 ACR
0.0189 ACR
COENAGRIONIOAE(AGRIONIDAE) 87.850
FOOTNOTE
t — UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
t . _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
0-34
FRV FINAL HESIOL
ACR COMPUTED B
FCV FINAL CHRO»
IE VALUE
Y ACUTE TO CHR
1C VALUE
DNIC RATIO METHOD
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: MISSOURI
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17 QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 9 CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 5 PALAEMONIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
it LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 3 CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 0 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 3 GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
IS NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
COENAORIONIDAE (AORIONIDA
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 7 HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
t SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 4 COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE
PTEHONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
$ - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
» - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
0440
0.466
0.493
0.647
0.732
0.790
1.011
1.265
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
1.800
7.800
24.771
50.748
1.161
4.020
80.062
358.792
358.792
459.015
803.845
0.000
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.671
2.000
62.871
53.068
94.805
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
10.000
783.471
999.998
0.000
96.077
233.565
346.472
401.217
78.496
301.810
345.472
401.217
2.000
8.611
32.601
98.553
6.611
32.601
E) 262.642
0.000
338.998
1992,474
8499.979
8479.723
339.999
3869.969
9002.438
12599.949
0.002
0.004
0.000
0X112
0.004
0.011
0.112
6.617
1.300
2.627
3.947
4.725
3.000
3.547
4.725
8.033
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
0.201 *
0.277 *
0.251 *
0202 *
0.037 *
0.037 *
**
3.218 *
0.385 *
0.470 *
0.470 *
**
32.914 *
31.576 «
0.137 *
0.137 *
*»
82.648 *
56.864 *
0.00053 *
0.00001 *
0.537 •
0,905 *
30-DAY
0.0023
0.0023
0.0038
0.0038
0.00003
0.00003
0.2574
0.0228
0.20
0.20
3.3931
3.2993
0.014
0.014
22.0396
15.1611
0.0087
0.0147
AVERAOE
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
PRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
TATE: MISSOURI STATE: MONTANA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
(+) (+) 1+) (++)
ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.968 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48.861 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 SALMONIDAE
STATE It OAPHNIDAE 21.323 7.884 * 47.0000 SCV STATE 8 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.986 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE 49.264 SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 CYPRINIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 8 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
B CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
FTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 6 PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CVPRINIDAE
$ COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
KRCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
' QAMMARIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIOAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 PDECIL1IDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERUDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIOAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
OATOSTOMIDAE
FOOTNOTE * — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
+ - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER ** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
. » _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE 1 - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD SS - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
50 VALUE
7.451
8.000
9.000
10,803
7.451
9.000
14.377
18.392
878999
1794245
14126.643
16487.430
1794.245
14128.843
16487.430
19484.938
0.048
0.498
1.147
£880
0.034
0.498
1.147
2.880
6326
15.000
23.238
32249
15.000
23.238
26.000
40.044
87,000
6399.978
6998.790
24692.628
6399978
6998.790
24892628
57461.672
0.305
0.759
0.998
1345
0.308
0.759
0.985
1.345
76.707
83.000
114,316
125.121
78.707
83.000
114,316
125.121
1323
1,596
1.700
2.234
1323
1.595
1.700
&000
4,503
5.000
6.452
8.000
6.154
8.000
10,811
24,000
0884
1279
2300
3240
0.654
1279
2,300
3.240
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(-O
3.388 *
2.638 «
113.263 *
407.356 *
0.027
O.OD9
1.974 *
5.061 *
12.164 *
781.038 *
0.194 *
0.132 *
31.429 *
28.920 *
0.660
0.510 *
1.830 «
1.381 *
0208 *
0.198 *
SO-DAY AVERAGE
(•*•) (++)
0.0004 ACR
0.0001 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.46618 FCV
0.01S05 FCV
42472 ACR
3.9061 ACfl
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1084 ACR
0.1003 ACR
D-35
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: MONTANA
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOH
« LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
K NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
( SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TEST
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
ED
17
9
10
7
7
5
10
8
9
5
16
9
5
3
10
r
9
5
12
10
NAME
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRAFtCHIDAE
PT6RONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTHARCHIDA6
ASEtLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRABCHIDAE
CYPWNIDAE
HYALELLIOAECTALirfllOAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
LC50 VALUE
( + )
0,440
0.468
0.493
0.647
0.383
0.493
0.647
t.011
0.995
1.600
2.800
7.800
0.995
2.800
26.000
29.000
1.181
4.0ZO
80.082
358.792
4.020
80.062
358.792
459.015
10.000
21.988
22.437
82.871
18.933
42.198
48.000
53.066
5.000
10.000
31.823
244.259
5,000
10.000
244.259
783.471
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
65.077
401.217
439.825
444.717
2.000
6.811
32.601
99.553
2.000
2.300
32.801
0.003
336,999
1992.474
8499.979
8479.723
339.999
1992.474
8479.723
9002.438
0.002
0.004
0,009
0.012
0.002
0.011
0.021
0.112
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.725
1,300
S.627
2.848
3.547
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
_ (+) .
0.201 *
0.133 *
0.251 *
0.101 *
0.037 *
0.287 *
3.218 *
7.340 *
0.470 *
0.101 *
32.814 *
21.717 *
0.137 *
0.137 *
**
62.848 *
52.431 *
0.00053 *
0.00015 *
0.537 *
0.543 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) <++)
0.0023 FSV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.5872 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.0674 ACR
3.3931 ACfi
2.2388 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FHV
22.0399 ACR
13.9816 ACR
/
0.0087 ACR
o.ooaa ACR
FOOTNOTE
i- — UNITS IN MICROORAMS PER LITER
+ + _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
D-36
FRV
ACR
FCV
SCV
FINAL RESIOU
COMPUTED 8
FINAL CHRON
E VALUE
1 ACUTE TO CHR<
1C VALUE
DNIC RATIO METHOD
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: MONTANA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
t ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
• — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
J - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
U — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EOUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
M VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (+) (+) <++>
13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV
41.986
48.881
92.757
13.737 4.677 47.0000 SCV
41.966
68.459
92.757
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NEBRASKA
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
ft CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
t COPPER
CYANIDE
DOT
OIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OP
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
14
e
§
t
18
12
e
4
10
7
23
16
10.
8
JO
9
12
4
»
8
NAME
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
ANOUILLIOAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTflAHCHIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIPICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LC60 VALUE
(•»)
7,451
8.000
9.000
10.803
4,503
7.451
10.000
te.ooo
878.M9
1794245
14128.643
16487.430
1794.243
14128.84)
18487.430
19484.938
0.046
0.4M
1.147
2.960
O.M4
0.183
0.498
2.MO
6.32!
15.000
23.238
32.249
23.238
33.882
54.711
68.267
87.000
8399.978
8998.790
24892.828
6399.476
8998.790
24892.828
30454.790
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.348
0.306
0.759
0.995
1.345
78.707
83.000
114.318
125.121
78.707
83.000
114.318
125.121
1.323
1.598
1.700
2.234
1.323
1.605
1.700
3.282
4.903
5.000
5.452
8.000
2.459
10.811
30.102
190.745
0.164
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.884
1.279
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
<+)
3.388 •
1.333 •
113.263 *
303.446 *
0.027 *
0.008 *
1.974 *
7.018 *
12.184
1208.844 *
0.194
0.150 *
31.429 *
28.920 *
0.650
0.432 *
1.830 *
0.121 *
0.208 *
0149 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (++>
0.0004 ACR
0.0001 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.48818 FCV
9.92408 FCV
4.2472 ACR
3.9061 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FHV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.0782 ACR
i*
FOOTNOTE
, - UNITS IN MICROSRAMS PER LITER
^ « _ FPV FINAL PUNT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: NEBRASKA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17 QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERU DAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAQRIONIDAS (AORIONIDA
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PEFHJDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
« LEAD NATIONAL 7 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
PERCIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 4 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
M NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 6 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
< + >
0.440
0.468
0.483
0.847
0.558
0.732
1.011
E) 1.600
0.995
1.800
2.800
7800
13.098
26.000
88.566
179.508
1.161
4.020
80.082
358.792
4.020
80.062
358.792
455.015
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.871
14.158
42.198
53.085
68.000
5.000
10.000
31.623
244259
5.000
248.899
763.471
999.998
65.077
345.472
401.217
65.077
301.610
401.217
439.825
2.000
8.611
32.601
99.853
2.000
2.300
32.801
COENAGRIONIDAE(AQRIONIDAE) 282.842
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 H YALELUDAE (TALITRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 7 HYALELLIDAEfTALITRIOAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
1 SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERUDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 7 CENTRARCHIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
• * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
( - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
|« - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
1892.474
8499.979
6479.723
339.999
1902.474
6479.723
9002.436
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.002
0.011
0.021
0.112
1.300
2J27
3,547
4.729
2446
3.547
6.678
8.033
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+1
0.201 *
0.153 *
0251 *
1.440 *
0.037 *
0.287 *
3.216 *
4.196 *
0.470 *
0.240 *
32.914 *
23.385 *
0.137 *
0.024 *
82.648 *
52.431 *
0.00053 *
0.00019 *
O.S37 *
0.851 *
30-DAV
(+(
0.0023
0.0023
0.0038
0.0038
0.00003
0.00004
0.2574
0.3356
0.20
0.1802
3.3931
2.4087
0.014
0.014
22.0395
13.9816
0.0087
0.0138
AVERAQE
(++)
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FCV
FCV
ACR
.ACR
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
D-37
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NEBRASKA STATE: NEVADA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM »DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LOW VALUE
$ ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41866 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 43.861 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNIOAE 13.737 5.799 * 47.0000 SCV STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.988 CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIOAE 46.550 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYDIAE 49.284 CYPRINIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 6 SAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
I* CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CHLOHDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 6 CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
SALMONIOAE
$ COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
PLANORBIOAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIOAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
GAMMARIOAE
DIELORIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
EPHEM6RELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
FOOTNOTE * — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* — UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER •* — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
* + - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE 1 — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD It - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
1 ia SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.603
4.503
7.451
9.000
11.314
878.999
1794.245
14128.643
16487.430
1794.245
14128.643
18487.430
18484.938
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.880
0.034
0.496
1.147
2.860
8.325
15.000
23.238
32.249
15.684
26.000
33.682
54.711
87.000
6399.976
6996.790
24892.828
6399.976
8998.790
28999.867
83804.146
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.305
0.759
1.345
1.424
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707
83.000
121.020
125.121
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
1.323
1.595
1.800
3.000
4.503
5.000
5.452
6.000
2.459
4.503
6.000
10.811
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.864
3.700
3.611
5.800
FRESHWATER AOUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
3.368 *
1.738 *
113.263 *
383.446 *
0.027 *
0.009
1.974 »
4-693 »
12.164 »
719.954 *
0.184
0.121
31.429 *
28.459 *
0.650
0.501 *
1.830 *
0.748 *
0.208 *
0.185 *
'
30-DAY AVEAAQE
0.0004 ACR
0.0001 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACfl
10.0 FPV
5.46618 FCV
9.07713 FCV
4.2472 ACH
34488 ACH
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.0844 ACR
I
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NEVADA
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
MEPTACHLOR
SS LEAD
LINDANE
MERCUPY
SS NICKEL
PCSS
SELENIUM
$ SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 17
STATE 10
NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
NATIONAL 7
STATE 6
NATIONAL 10
STATE 9
NATIONAL 9
STATf 5
NATIONAL 16
STATE 9
NATIONAL 5
STATE 2
NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
NATIONAL 12
STATE 10
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSOVALUE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMO
PERLID
PTERO
PERLID
SALMO
PTERO
POECIL
NIDAE
AE
4ARCIDAE
AE
NIDAE
4ARCIDAE
IDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAE*
PERLiD
ASTAC
PTERO
SALMO
CENTR
QAMM;
/IONIDAE
AE
DAE
4ARCIDAE
NIDAE
kRCHIDAE
RIOAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHM
SALMO
CYPRIN
DAPHN
SALMO
CENTH
POECIL
ASELLI
SALMO
GAMHV
CENTH
SALMO
CENTR
GAMU/
ICTALU
DAPHN
OAMM;
ASTAC
SALMO
DAE
NIDAE
IDAE
DAE
NIDAE
tRCHIDAE
IDAE
DAE
NIDAE
RIDAE
^RCHIDAE
NIDAE
kRCHIDAE
RIDAE
RIDAE
OAE
RIDAE
DAE
NIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMM/
SALMO
PHILOO
RIDAE
NIDAE
INIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
EPHEM
CENTH
PHILOD
ERELLIDAE
\RCHIDAE
INIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILOD
CHIHOf
POECIL
INIDAE
IOMIDAE
IDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTR
CYPRIN
QAMM/
S.RCHIDAE
(DAE
RIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRJ
IRCHIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHN
CYPRIN
SALMO
DAE
ODONTIDAE
NIOAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHN
SALMO
POECIL
DAPHN
COTTID
CYPRIN
CYPRIN
DAPHN
CYPRIN
SALMO
DAE
NIDAE
IDAE
DAE
AE
IDAE
ODONTIDAE
DAE
IDAE
NIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERO*
ICTALU
4ARCIDAE
RIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CENTRARCMIDAE
PTERO*
ICTALU
SALMO
JARCIDAE
RIDAE
NIDAE
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.647
0.320
0.357
0.540
0.949
0.999
1.800
2.600
7.800
0.900
13.098
28.000
29.000
1.161
4.020
80.062
358.792
4.020
80.062
455.019
932.656
10.000
21.988
22,437
92.871
14.198
42.198
4B.OOO
93.068
9.000
10.000
31.623
244.299
9.000
10.000
246.995
783.471
69.077
'233.969
349.472
401.217
69,077
401.217
439.825
456.842
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.993
2.000
2.300
0.000
0.000
339.999
1992.474
6490.978
8479.723
339.999
1992.474
8474.713
1259994!
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.01!
0.002
0.004
0.021
0.112
1,300
2.627
3.947
4.729
2.848
a.ooo
3.947
6.678
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
0.201 *
0.099 *
0.2S1 *
0.160 *
0.037 *
0.322 *
3.218 *
9.390 *
0.470 *
0.101 *
32.914 *
21.698 *
0.137 *
0.137 *
**
82.648' *
94.141 *
0.00093 *
0.00008 *
0.937 *
0.914 •
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.4312 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.0871 ACR
3.3931 ACR
2.2327 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0399 ACR
14.4378 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0148 ACR
ft1
FOOTNOTE
. - UNITS IN MICROORAMS PEB LITER
« , -FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: NEVADA
TOXICANT
$ ZINC
NUMBED OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSOVALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
1 - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
(S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3,7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
13.737 6.146 47.0000 SCV
41.9(6
48.8(1
92.757
13.737 3.346 47.0000 SCV
49.9(8
S2.757
251.4(1
D-39
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NEW HAMPSHIRE
STATE: NEW HAMPSHIRE
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
1$ CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
$ COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TEST
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
ED
14
9
8
4
18
15
8
4
10
6
23
18
10
.6
20
a
12
6
9
6
NAME
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMOMDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
QAMIUARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIOAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PSRCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOC1DAE
OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LC50 VALUE
( + )
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
4.503
7.451
9.000
11.732
878.999
1794.245
14128.643
16487.430
1046.139
14128.643
15659.936
19484.936
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.034
0.864
1.147
1.630
6.325
15.000
23.236
32.249
12.371
26.000
33.862
54.711
67.000
6399,976
6998.790
24892.328
6996.790
24892.828
30454.750
40537.809
0.305
0.7S9
0.995
1.345
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.345
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707
63.000
114.316
125.121
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.976
1.595
3.000
3.006
4.503
5.000
5.452
6.000
2.459
6.000
14.460
22.101
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664
1.279
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVEHAOE
(+) (+) (++)
3.386 •
1.770 »
T1 3,263 *
148.092 *
0.027 0.0004 ACR
0.017 0.0002 ACR
1.974 * 0.0043 FRV
3.113 * 0.0043 FRV
12,164 0.3376 ACR
19W.335 » 10.0 FPV
0.194 5.46618 FCV
0.139 7.43115 FCV
31.429 * 4.2472 ACR
26.920 * 09001 ACR
0.650 0,0010 FRV
0.323 * 0.0010 FHV
1.830 * 0.0019 FRV
0.549 * 0.0019 FRV
0.206 * 0.1064 ACR
0.149 * 0.0762 ACR
FOOTNOTE
t — UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
» + _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIOU
ACR COMPUTED B
FCV FINAL CHHON
E VALUE
< ACUTE TO CHRONiC RATIO METHOD
1C VALUE
-Ijn SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
SJ LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
$4 NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
( SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 17
STATE 8
NATIONAL 10
STATE 5
NATIONAL 7
STATE 4
NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
NATIONAL 8
STATE 6
NATIONAL 16
STATE 12
NATIONAL 5
STATE 4
NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
NATIONAL B
STATE 4
NATIONAL 12
STATE 7
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC
OASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTeRONARCIOAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAORIONIOAS (AGHIONItW
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPHINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
CENTHAROHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPfilNIDAE
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGRIONIOA
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIOAE
HYALELLIDAE fTALITRIDAE)
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION
tt - HARDNESS EFFEC
APPLY EQUATION
3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIM
T INTERCEPT VALUE
3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIM
UM CRITERIA
UM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
•SO VALUE
(°M
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.847
0.556
O.S62
1.011
El 1,300
0.995
1500
2.600
7.800
13.058
29.000
29.000
50.748
1.161
4.020
80.062
358.792
80.062
157.991
455.015
B03.B45
10.000
21.886
22.437
52.871
14.158
42.198
48.000
68.000
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
10.000
50.000
248.595
783.471
65.077
233.555
343.472
401.217
78.456
345.472
«H.Z<7
439.826
2.000
6.611
32.801
99.553
2.000
2.300
32.601
E) 282.842
339.999
1992.474
6499.979
6479.723
339.999
3105.149
3M9.M9
8479.723
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.011
0.021
0.112
6.517
1.300
2.627
3547
4.729
2.846
6.165
6.676
12.000
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
1*1
0.201 *
0.141 *
0.251 *
3.696 *
0.037 *
10.748 *
3218 *
4,220 »
0.470 *
0,629 *
32.914 *
33.129 *
0.137 *
0.024 *
82.848 it
58.744 *
000053 *
0.00006 *
0.537 *
0.868 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
(+•) (t+)
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.3376 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
3.3931 ACR
3.4153 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
Z2.039S ACR
15.8649 ACR
0,0087 ACR
0.0144 ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, By STATE
TATE: NEW HAMPSHIRE STATE: NEW JERSEY
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME ICM VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE
(») (+) (+) (+*•
2INC NATIONAL 15 OAPHNIDAE 13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.908 ASELUOAE
SALMONIDAE 48.861 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE 21.223 H.408 47.0000 SCV STATE 9 SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.966 CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE 50.064 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 CYPRINIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUSIDAE
STATE i DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
W CADMIUM NATIONAL IS SALUONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 17 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINOOONTIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPfllNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHY8IOAE
STATE 8 PHIIODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIOAE
SALMONIDAE
S COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 18 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 8 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
A8TACIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELUDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMAHIDAE
» - UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER ** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
, t-FFV FINAL PUNT VALUE * - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE ' APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD it - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
(+)
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.603
4.503
7.451
9.000
11.314
878.899
1794.245
14118.843
18487.430
1048.139
14128.843
18487.430
19484.838
0.048
0^496
1.147
2.860
0.034
0.884
1.147
1.630
6.325
15.000
93.238
35.249
15.684
33462
40.000
94.711
67.000
8309.978
6988.790
24882.828
6996.790
24882828
30454.750
83604.148
0.304
0.759
0.996
1.345
0.256
0.759
0.89$
1.345
76.707
sum
114.316
125.121
7S.707
83.000
114.318
125.121
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.978
1.595
1.994
3.000
4.503
5.000
1452
8.000
2.4»
8.000
10.811
41.000
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664
1440
3.811
6.000
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+)
3.388 *
1.796 *
113.263 *
171.493 *
0.027
0.021
1.974 *
4.569 *
12.164
1804.673 *
0.194
0.139
31.429 *
30.219 *
0.850
0.344 *
1.830 *
0.382 *
0.208 *
0.147 *
(+) (++)
0.0004 ACR
0.0003 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
„
0.3376 ACR
10.0 FPV
S.48618 FCV
8.30804 FCV
4.2472 ACR
4.0836 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.0751 ACR
D-41
-------
APPENDIX 0
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NEW JERSEY
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50VALUE MAXIMUM
1+) (•>•>
ENORIN NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440 0.201 *
SALMONIDAE 0.468
PERLIDAE 0.493
PTEHONARCIDAE 0.647
STATE 10 GASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440 0.168 *
SALMONIDAE 0556
POECILHDAE 0.750
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE 0.995 0.251 *
PALAEMONIDAE 1,800
PERLIDAE 2,800
ASTACIDAE 7.800
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE 13.058 3.521 »
CENTflARCHIDAE 26.000
GAMMARIDAE 47.329
DAPHNIDAE 50.748
S3 LEAD NATIONAL 7 GAMMARIDAE 1.161 0.037 *
DAPHNIDAE 4.020
SALMONIDAE 80.362
CYPRINIDAE 358792
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE 80.062 14.070 t
CENTRARCHIDAE 455.015
PHILOWNIDAE 803.845
CYPRINIOAE 614.803
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE 10,000 3.218 «
SALMONIDAE 21.988
GAMMARIDAE 22.437
CENTRARCHIDAE 52.871
STATE 7 OAMMARirAE 10.488 2.423 t
SALMONIDAE 14.158
CENTRARCHIDAE 42.198
ICTALURIDAE 44.000
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE 5.000 0.470 *
GAMMARIDAE 10.000
ASTACIDAE 31.823
SALMONIDAE 244.259
STATE 4 GAMMARIDAE 10000 0636 *
SALMONIDAE 248,595
PHILODINIDAE 783.471
NAIDIDAE 999.998
« NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE 65.077 32,914 t
EPHEMERELLIDAE 233.555
CENTRARCHIDAE 3<5.472
PHILODINIDAE 401.Z17
STATE 12 DAPHNIDA6 78.456 33.128 *
CENTHARCHIDAE 345.472
PHILODINIDAE 401.217
CHIROWOMIDAE 439.825
PC3S NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE 2.000 0.137 .
CENTRAHCHIDAE 6.611
CYPfWIDAE 32.901
GAMMARIDAE 99-553
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE 2.000 0.020 *
CENTRAHCHIDAE 2,000
GAMMARIDAE 107.634
COENAGRIONIDAE (AGHIONIDAE) 282 ,842
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELLIDAEfTALITRIDAE) 339.999 62.648 *
DAPHNIDAE 1992,474
CYPRINODONTIDAE 6499.979
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
STATE 3 HYALELLIDAECTALITRIDAE) 339.999 66.265 *
DAPHNIDAE 3889989
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
POECILUDAE 12599.915
S SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE 0.002 0.00053 *
COTTIOAE 0.004
CYPRINIDAE 0.006
CYPRINQDONTIOAE 0.012
STATE 3 SALMONIDAE 0.021 0.00053 *
CENTRARCHIOAE 0.112 ft
PHILODINIDAE 5.517
0.000
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE 1.300 0.537 *
PTERONARCIDAE 2.627
ICTALUBIDAE 3.S47
CENTRARCHIDAE 4.735
STATE 8 CENTRARCHIDAE 2.648 1.043 *
ICTAUJWDAE 4.193
SALMONIDAE 6.678
CYPRINIOAE 8.782
FOOTNOTE
> — UNITS IN MICHOQHAMS PER LITER
-, ,. _ FPV FINAl- PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRO
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
30-DAY AVERAGE
(•«•> (++)
0.0023 FBV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00004 FCV
0.2974 ACR
0.1338 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FBV
3.3931 ACR
3.4153 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACR
17,6705 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0169 ACR
NIC RATIO METHOD
1.4-y SC\f SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE-. NEW JERSEY
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCM VALUE MAXIMUM 3COA.Y AVERAQE
S ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSICAL
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
t - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
It — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
(±1 (±J l + l (*•»)
13.737 8.148 47.0000 SCV
«18W
48.881
92.757
21.223 8.298 47.0000 SCV
11966
46.550
92.75T
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NEW MEXICO
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
JI CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
* COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
OIELDHIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
D
14
10
6
6
18
15
8
6
10
7
23
18
10
7
20
12
12
g
9
a
NAME
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIOAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIOAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
•SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
LC50 VALUE
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
4.503
7.451
9.000
10.000
878.999
1794.245
14128.643
16487.430
1794.245
14128.643
18487.430
19484.938
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.034
0.163
0.496
1.147
6.325
15.000
23.238
32.249
15.000
23.238
26.000
33.662
67.000
6399.976
6996.790
24892.828
6399.976
6998.790
24692.828
30454.750
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.303
0.759
0.995
1.345
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707
83.000
114.316
125121
1.323
1.695
1.700
2.234
1.323
1496
3.000
4.102
4.803
5.000
5.452
6.000
2.459
6.000
10.811
24.000
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664
1,279
2.300
3.240
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(•M
3.388 *
1.926 *
113.263 *
407.358 *
0.027
0.012
1.974 *
5.589 *
12.164 *
1208.644 *
0.194
0.150
31.429 *
29.583 *
0.050
0.459 *
1.830 *
0.632 *
0.206 *
0.196 *
JO-DAY AVERAQE
1+1 (++)
0.0004 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.46618 FCV
9.85862 FCV
4.24724 ACR
3.9977 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.1003 ACR
,
FOOTNOTE
* - UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
, » _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
STATE NEW MEXICO
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17 QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 10 SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
POECILIIDAE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 7 PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
W LEAD NATIONAL 7 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
M NICKEL NATIONAL 16 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELUDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 8 HYALELLIOAE (TAUTRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
1 SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 10 PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
$ — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
M - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAQE CRITERIA
SO VALUE
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.647
0.357
0.493
0.647
0.750
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
0.995
2800
13.058
24.771
1.161
4.020
60.062
358.792
4.020
60.062
358.792
455.015
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.871
14.158
48.000
52.871
53.066
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
5.000
10.000
248495
783.471
65.077
233455
345.472
401.217
68.077
301.510
401.217
439.825
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.553
2.000
6.611
32.601
0.000
339.999
1992.474
6499.979
6479.723
339.999
1992474
8479.723
9002.438
0.002
O.OO4
0.006
0.012
0.002
0.004
0.008
0.021
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.725
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.725
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
0.201 *
0.146 *
0.251 *
0.128 *
0.037 *
0.287 •
3.218 *
4.794 *
0.470 *
0.101 *
32.914 *
25.017 *
0.137 *
0.137 *
**
82.648 *
60.162 *
0.00053 *
0.00030 *
0.637 *
0.494 *
30-DAY
0.0023
0.0023
0.0038
0.0038
0.00003
0.00004
0.2574
0.3835
0.20
0.0671
3.3931
8.5790
0.014
0.014
22.0395
16.0431
0.0087
0.0080
AVERAQE
(++)
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
CM3
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NEW MEXICO STATE: NEW YORK
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME tC
CH It) 1+) I++)
S ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIOAE
PHYSIDAE 41.966 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48.861 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE 13.737 6.035 47.0000 SCV STATE 10 SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.966 CENTRARCHIDAE
PEflCICHTHYIDAE 49.264 EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 49.989 ANGUILLIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 6 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 6 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
it CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDA6
STATE 17 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIOAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 5 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 7 QAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDA6
PERCICHTHYIDAE
1 COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 20 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PEHCIOAE
STATE 8 SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
1 STATE 14 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DIELQRIN NATIONAL 12 POECIUIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
FOOTNOTE * — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
» - UNITS IN MICHOORAMS PER LITER ** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
t , — FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE S — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACH COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD U - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
! AA SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
SO VALUE
( + )
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
5.241
7.451
9.000
16.000
876.999
1794.245
14126.643
18487.430
878.999
1048.139
14128.643
18487.430
0.048
0.496
1,147
2.880
0.048
0.884
1.147
1.830
6,325
15.000
23.236
32.249
6.325
23.238
32.249
40.281
87,000
8399.978
6998.790
24892.826
67.000
8998.790
24892.828
30454.750
0.305
0.759
0.099
1.345
0.258
0.758
0895
1.345
T6.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707
63.000
114.316
125.121
1,323
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.976
1.599
1.700
2.234
4.503
5.000
9.452
8.000
3.873
8.000
10.811
20.000
0.864
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.864
1.278
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
( + )
3.388 •
1.829 *
113.263 *
58.980 *
O.OS7
0.029
1.974 *
1.559 *
12. ISA
5.387 *
0.194
0.151
31.429 *
30.219 *
0.850
0.458 *
1.830 *
1.080 *
0.208 *
0.149 *
30-DAY
(•f )
0.0004
0.0004
0.0043
0.0043
0.3378
0.1498
5.48818
5.32754
4.2472
4.0838
0.0010
0.0010
0.0019
0.0019
0.1064
0.0782
AVERAQE
(+•*•}
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
FBV
FRV
ACR
ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NEW YORK
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
« LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
M NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
1 SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TEST!
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
ID
17
11
10
8
7
5
10
^
7
9
6
16
13
5
5
10
8
9
g
12
9
NAME
GASTEROSTEIOAE
SALMC
PERLIC
PTEBO
GASTE
SALMC
CYPRI
POECI
PTERO
PALAE
PERLIC
ASTAC
PALAE
SALMC
CENTR
GAMM
JNIDAE
WE
NARCIDAE
ROSTEIDAE
1IMIDAE
MIDAE
LIIDAE
NAHCIDAE
MONIDAE
)AE
IDAE
MONIDAE
(NIDAE
ARCHIDAE
ARIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
OAPHN
SALMC
CYPRI
GAMM
SALMC
CYPfll
CENTR
II DAE
MDAE
•4IDAE
ARIDAE
JNIDAE
JIDAE
ARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMC
GAMM
CENTR
NIDAE
ARIDAE
IARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAMM
CENTR
ICTALl
DAPHN
OAMM
ASTAC
SALMC
AfllDAE
ARCHIDAE
RIDAE
IOAE
AfllDAE
IDAE
NIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTAC
SALMC
PHILO
DAPHN
EPHEM
CENTR
PHILO
OAPHIt
CENTR
PHILO
CHIRO
IDAE
MDAE
3INIOAE
IDAE
ERELLIDAE
ARCHIOAE
DINIDAE
IDAE
ARCHIDAE
3INIDAE
NOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTR
CYPRN
OAMM
SALUC
CENTR
CYJW
QAMM
HYALE
DAPHN
CYPRK
SALMC
HYALE
DAPHN
SALMO
CYPRIIi
DAPHN
conic
CYPRU
CYPR»
COTTIC
CYPRIh
SALMO
CENTR
PERLID
PTEHO
ICTALU
CENTR
ICTALU
CENTR
SALMC
ARCHIDAE
4IDAE
ARIDAE
NIDAE
ARCHIDAE
4IDAE
ARIDAE
LLIDAEfTALITR
IDAE
JODONTIOAE
NIOAE
LLIDAEfTALITR
IDAE
NIDAE
JIOAE
IDAE
)AE
JIDAE
JODONTIDAE
IAE
4IDAE
NIDAE
ARCHIDAE
AE
NARCIDAE
RIDAE
ARCHIDAE
RIDAE
ARCHIOAE
NIOAE
DAE)
DAE)
CYPRINIDAE
LC80 VALUE
0.440
0.4(8
0.493
0.647
0.440
0.987
0.7J2
0.750
1.800
2.800
7.800
1.800
17.703
24.771
37.048
1.1(1
4.020
80.062
358.792
1.161
80.0(2
398.792
455.015
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.871
18.355
22.437
52.871
53.0(0
6.000
10.000
31.823
244.259
10.000
90.000
248.S95
783.471
(9.077
233.55S
345.472
401.217
78.496
345.472
401.217
439825
2.000
8.611
32.801
99.553
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.W3
339.999
1992.474
8499.979
8479.723
339.999
38(9.989
8479.723
9002.438
0.002
0.004
0.000
0.012
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
1.300
2.827
3.547
4.725
3.547
4.725
6.293
8.033
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
( + )
0.201 *
0.205 *
0.291 «
0.333 *
0.037 *
0.054 *
3.218 *
5.057 *
0,470 *
0.764 *
32.914 *
39.088 *
0.137 *
0.137 *
82.648 *
72.017 *
0.00053 *
0.00041 *
0,537 •
1.340 *
39-DAY AVERAGE
< + ) (*•+)
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 PCV
0.00004 FCV
0.2574 ACH
0.4045 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
3.3931 ACR
3.6172 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.039S ACR
19.2044 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0217 ACR
'
FOOTNOTE
* - UNITS IN MICflOGRAMS PER LITER
» » —
FPV
FRV
ACR
FCV
SCV
FINAL PLANT
FINAL RESIDU
COMPUTED Bl
FINAL CHRON
VALUE
E VALUE
1 ACUTE TO CHRC
1C VALUE
NIC RATIO METHOD
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: NEW YORK
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
* ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
(
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
• • - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
$ — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
» — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
(0 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + ) (+) (*) (++)
13.737 6.148 » 47.0000 SCV
41.968
48.881
92.757
21.223 8.058 47.0000 SCV
41.276
41.988
92.757
0-45
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NORTH CAROLINA
STATE NORTH CAROLINA
TOXICANT
ALORIN
ARSENIC
JI CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
S COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TEST
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
ED
14
9
8
4
18
16
8
4
10
6
23
18
10
7
30
9
12
6
9
5
NAME
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIOAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
E80CIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIOAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
LC50 VALUE
^+)
7.451
8000
9.000
10.603
4.503
7.451
9.000
11.314
878.999
1794.245
14128.643
16487.430
1046.139
14128.643
19464.938
26041.875
0.048
0.498
1.147
2.860
0.034
0.864
1.147
1.630
8.326
15.000
23.238
32.249
15 684
33.862
40.000
54.711
67.000
6399976
6998.790
24892.828
6996.790
24892.828
30454.750
63804.148
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.2S6
0.759
0.995
1.345
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.976
1.599
1.864
3.000
4.503
5.000
S.4S2
8.000
2.459
8.000
10.611
41.000
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664
3.240
3.811
6.000
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
1+) (*> <++)
3.368 *
1.796 *
113.263 *
132.343 *
0.027 0.0004 ACR
0.019 0.0003 ACR
1.974 + 0.0043 FflV
4.969 * 0.0043 FRV
12.164 0.3378 AC«
1604.673 * 10.0 FPV
0.194 5.46619 FCV
0.13S 7.62932 FCV
31.429 * 4.2472 ACR
29.583 * 3.9977 ACR
0650 0.0010 FRV
0.344 0.0010 FRV
1630 * 0.0019 FRV
0.382 * 0.0019 FRV
0.208 * 0.1054 ACP
0.147 * 0.0751 ACR
FOOTNOTE
T - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
•*• + —
FPV FINAL PLANT
FRV FINAL RESIOU
ACR COMPUTED BY
FCV FINAL CHRON
MLUE
E VALUE
ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
C VALUE
i AK SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
M LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
$S NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
$ SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 17
STATE 9
NATIONAL 10
STATE 9
NATIONAL 7
STATE 4
NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
NATIONAL 9
STATE 4
NATIONAL 16
STATE 12
NATIONAL 5
STATE 4
NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
NATIONAL 9
STATE 3
NATIONAL 12
STATE 8
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME L
QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERUDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAQRIONIDAE (AORIONID
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERUDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRIMDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
CENTPAHCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
COENAQRIONIDAE (AORIONID*
HYALELLIDAEITAUTRIOAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIOAE ITALITfllDAE)
CAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
com DAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PERUDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
1 — HARDNESS EFFEC
APPLY EQUATION 1
M - HARDNESS EFFEC
APPLY EQUATION 3
r INTERCEPT VALUE
.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIM
r INTERCEPT VALUE
.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIM
Ut CRITERIA
JMAND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
C 60 VALUE
<+)
0.440
0.466
0.493
0.647
0.556
0.750
1.011
»E> 1.600
0.995
1.600
2.800
7.600
13.058
24.771
47.329
50.748
1.161
4.020
60.062
358.792
80.062
455.015
803.645
814.803
10.000
21.968
22.437
52.671
10.468
14.158
52.871
64.000
9.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
10.000
248.995
783.471
999.996
69.077
233.569
345.472
401.217
78.456
345.472
401.217
439.825
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.653
2.000
6.611
107.664
E) 262.642
339.900
1992.474
6489979
8479.723
339.999
3869.999
6479.723
12599.045
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.021
0.112
5.517
0.000
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.725
3.000
4.725
8.678
6.129
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(4)
0.201 *
0.178 *
0.251 *
3.446 *
0.037 *
14.070 *
3,218 *
1.952 *
0.470 *
0.639 *
32.914 *
33.129 *
0.137 *
0.047 *
82.646 *
57.358 *
0.00053 »
0.00053 *
**
0.537 *
1.083 *
30-DAY AVERAOE
(*) (++)
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.1561 ACR
0.20 FRV
0,20 FRV
3.3931 ACR
3.4153 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0396 ACR
15.299! ACR
0.0067 ACR
0.0177 ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NORTH CAROLINA
STATE: NORTH DAKOTA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AOUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCU VALUE MAXIMUM 30-OAY AVERAOE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LOW VALUE
( + ) ( + ) (tl <++>
5 ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13.737 >.148 47.0000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.988 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48.881 EPHEMEHELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE 21.223 8.298 47.0000 SCV STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.988 CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE 46.950 CYPRINIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 CYPRINODONTIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMON IOAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
*J CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 5 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 SAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
t COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 15 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE •
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CAT08TOMIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
FOOTNOTE * ~~ FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
" - UNITS IN MICROQSAMS PER LITER " * * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
, ». _ ffv FINAL PLANT VALUE 1 - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 37 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD It - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
TOV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3 7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-OAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
(+)
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.603
4.503
7.451
16.392
21.000
878.999
1794.245
14128.643
18437.430
1794.249
13339.965
16487.430
19484.838
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.890
0.044
0.496
1.147
1.630
6.325
15.000
23.838
32.249
23.238
25.451
26.000
54.711
87.000
6399,878
6898.790
24892.828
6399.976
6998.790
24892.B28
57491.672
0.305
0.759
0.99S
1.345
0.305
0.7S9
0.995
1.022
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
57.000
83.000
114.316
1ZS.121
1.323
1.595
1.700
2 .234
1.323
1.595
1.700
3.000
4,503
5.000
5.452
8.000
2.459
10.811
30.102
190.745
0.6W
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664
1.278
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAV AVERAQE
3.388 *
1.090 *
113.263 *
383.801 *
0.027
0.014
1.974 *
8.084 •
12.164
781.038 »
0.184
0.190
31.429 *
20.748 *
0.850
0.472 *
1.830 *
0.148 *
0.208 *
0.161 *
(+)
0.0004
0,0002
0.0043
0.0043
0.3378
10.0
5.46618
9.92408
4.2472
24035
0.0010
0.0010
0.0018
0.0019
0.1064
0.0823
(++)
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
FFV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
D-47
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: NORTH DAKOTA
STATE: NORTH DAKOTA
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
SJ LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
JJ NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
S SILVER
TOXAPHENE
D-4B
NUMBER OF
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
FAMILIES TESTED MAME LC» VALUE MAXIMUM
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
17 GASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440 0.201 *
SALMONIDAE 0.468
PERLIDAE 0.493
PTERONARCIDAE 0.647
6 SALMONIDAE 0.694 0.072 *
CYPRINIDAE 0.732
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
GAMMAHIDAE 5.874
10 PTERONARCIDAE 0.995 0.251 *
PALAEMONIDAE 1.800
PERLIDAE 2.800
ASTACIDAE 7.800
5 SALMONIDAE 13.058 3.380 *
CENTRARCHIDAE 26.000
QAMMARIDAE 29.000
DAPHNIDAE 58.588
7 QAMMARIOAE 1.161 0.037 *
DAPHNIDAE 4.020
SALMONIDAE 80082
CYPRINIDAE 358.792
5 DAPHNIDAE 4.020 0.325 *
SALMONIDAE 158.158
CYPRINIDAE 398.792
CENTRARCHIDAE 455.015
10 A3ELLIDAE 10.000 3.213 •
SALMONIDAE 21.988
QAMMARIDAC 22.437
CENTRARCHIDAE 52.871
8 SALMONIDAE 32.031 13.875 «
CENTRARCHIDAE 42.198
QAMMARIDAE 48.000
ICTALURIDAE 53.066
9 DAPHNIDAE 5.000 0.470 «
QAMMARIDAE 10.000
ASTAODAE 31.623
SALMONIDAE 244.259
5 OAPHNIDAE 5.000 0.101 *
QAMMARIDAE 10,000
SALMONIOAE 248.595
PHILODINIDAE 783.471
16 OAPHNIDAE 65.077' 32.814 »
EPHEMERELLIDAE 233.555
CENTRARCHIDAE 345.472
PHILODINIDAE 401.217
10 DAPHNIDAE 65.077 23.512 *
CENTRARCHIDAE 325.842
PHILODINIDAE 401.217
_ CHIRONOMIDAE 439.925
5 SALMONIDAE 2.000 0.137 *
CENTRARCHIDAE 8.611
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
QAMMARIDAE 99.553
3 SALMONIDAE 2.000 0.137 *
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.300 **
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
o.ooo
10 HYALELLIDAE(TALITRIDAE) 339.999 62.648 *
DAPHNIDAE 1992.474
CYPRINODONTIDAE 6499.978
SALMONIDAE • 8479.723
7 KYALELLIDAE(TALITRIDAE) 333.999 54.887 *
DAPHNIDAE 1992.474
SALMONIDAE 7049.806
CYPRINIDAE 9002.438
9 DAPHNIDAE 0.002 0.00053 *
COTT1DAE 0.004
CYPRINIDAE 0.006
CYPRINOOONTIOAE 0.012
5 OAPHNIDAE 0.002 0.00015 *
CYPRINIDAE 0.011
SALMONIDAE 0.021
CENTRARCHIDAE 0.112
12 PERLIDAE 1.300 0.537 *
PTERONARCIDAE 2.6S7
ICTALURIOAE 3.547
CENTRARCHIDAE 4.725
8 CENTRARCHIDAE 2,848 0.806 *
ICTALURIOAE 3.547
CYPRINIOAE 8.033
SALMONIDAE 9.100
FOOTNOTE
•h — UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
* » —FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRO
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC60 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
0.0023 FRV $ ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0.0023 FRV STATE 11 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0.0038 PRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.2574 ACR
1.1099 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.0671 ACR
3,3931 ACR
2.4238 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACft
14.6364 ACS
0.0087 ACR
0.0131 ACR
• — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
• * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
t - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
NIC RATIO METHOD » - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 37 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
13.737 8.148 47.0000 SCV
41.966
46.861
82.757
13.737 4.148 47.0000 SCV
26.243
41.986
92.757
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: OHIO
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
« CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
1 COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
14
8
8
S
18
14
8
5
10
6
23
19
10
a
20
13
12
6
9
8
NAME
CCNTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ANGMLLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNtOAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIOAE
OAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
CYFRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTO ARCHIOAC
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
ESOCIDAE
POECIUIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMON 1 DAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
LCSO VALUE
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
4.503
7.451
18.000
16.392
878.999
1794.245
14128.843
18487.430
1048.139
14128.543
16487.430
19484.938
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.880
0.034
. 0.864
1.147
1.830
6.329
16.000
23.236
32.249
6.325
23.236
33.882
40.000
67.000
6399.976
8996.790
24892828
8998.780
24892.128
57481.J72
59896.703
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.266
0.799
0.995
1.345
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
1.323
1.59S
1.700
2,234
0.978
1.595
1.M4
1.700
4.503
6.000
5.452
0.000
2.458
10.811
20.000
30.102
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
OW4
1.279
3.240
3.111
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
3.388 *
1.389 *
113.283 •
171.493 *
0.027
0.015
1.974 *
1350 *
12,194
1531.490 *
0.194
0.145
31.429 *
30.219 *
0.690
0.471 *
1.830 *
0.50* *
0.208 *
0.149 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
0.0004 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0,0043 FRV
f
0.3378 ACR
10B FPV
5.46618 FCV
8S7750 FCV
42472 ACR
4.0838 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1004 ACR
0.0782 ACR
r>
FOOTNOTE
» - UNITS IN MICROGflAWS PER LITER
t t - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACH COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRO.NIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: OHIO
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE » SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE « PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
« LEAD NATIONAL 7 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE t QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 8 QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
W NICKEL NATIONAL It DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL S SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE ! SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELLIDAE
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: OHIO STATE: OKLAHOMA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AOUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TiSTED NAME LCSOVALUE MAXIMUM 30 DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
< + ) ( + ) ( + ) (++>
$ ZINC NATIONAL IS DAPHNIDAE 13.737 8.148 47.0000 SCV ALDRIN, NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.96$ ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48.861 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE 21.223 7.951 47.0000 SCV STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
PHYSIOAE 41.966 CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE 48.550 PERC1CHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 ANQUIU.IOAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 6 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
» CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 14 SALMONIDAE
PEBCICHTHY10AE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTEHONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 5 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 8 QAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
$ COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIOAE
CH1RONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 17 DAPHNIOAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PEHCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE ) DAPHNIDAE
ASTACIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL » SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CAT08TOMIOAE
STATE 5 SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
FOOTNOTE * — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
. — UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER ** — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
» » — FPY FINAL PLANT VALUE 1 — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRY FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD U - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
iKn SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAQE CRITERIA
60 VALUE
<•*•>
7.451
8.000
•.000
10.603
4.503
T.451
10.000
16.000
878999
1794.245
14128.643
1B4B7.430
878.999
1048.139
13330.965
18487.430
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.044
0.163
0.884
1.147
8.325
15.000
23.23B
32249
6.325
23.238
29.481
26.000
87.000
«39«,976
6998.790
24892.828
87.000
6998.790
24892.828
30454.760
0.309
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256
0.709
0.095
1.022
78.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
57.000
83.000
114.316
167.000
1.323
1.595
1.700
3.234
0.976
2.409
3.000
3234
4.503
0.000
5.452
8.000
2.459
10.811
20.000
30.102
0.084
1.279
2.300
3.540
0.694
1.279
3.811
5.800
FRESHWATER AOUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
( + )
3.383 *
1.470 *
113.263 *
58.104 *
0.027
0.013
1.974 *
1.825 *
12.184
8.949 *
0.194
0.137
31.429 *
19.407 *
0.650
0.377 *
1.830 *
0.581 *
9.208 *
0.106 *
30-DAY AVERAQE
(+) (++)
0.0004 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.337S ACR
0.1930 ACR
5.46818 FCV
4.62475 FCV
4.2472 ACR
26225 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.001) FRV
0.0011 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.0545 ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: OKLAHOMA
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
M LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
M NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
* SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
17
10
10
7
7
5
10
e
9
5
18
11
t
5
10
g
9
»
12
8
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LOW VALUE
QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMO
PERLID
PTERO
SALMO
CYPRIK
POECIL
CENTR
PTEHO
PALAE
PERLID
ASTAC
PALAE
ASTAC
SALMO
CENTR
QAMM/
DAPHN
SALMO
CYPRir
QAMM;
SALMO
CYPR^
CENTR
ASELLI
SALMO
QAMIkU
CENTR
SALMO
GAMM;
CENTH
ICTALU
DAPHN
QAMM/
ASTAC
SALMO
QAMM>
ASTAC
SALMO
PHILOC
DAPHN
EPHEM
CENTR.
PMILOt
DAPHN
PERCIC
CENTR
PHILOC
SALMO
CENTR;
CYPHIN
GAMM/
SALMO
CENTR
CYPRIH
GAMM>
NIDAE
AE
VARCIDAE
NIDAE
IDAE
IIDAE
ARCHIDAE
NAHCIDAE
JONIOAE
AE
OAE
tlONIDAE
OAE
NIDAE
AHCHIDAE
kRIDAE
IDAE
NIDAE
IDAE
kRIDAE
NIDAE
IDAE
•RCHIDAE
DAE
NIDAE
kRIDAE
•RCHIDAE
NIDAE
kRIDAE
»HCH1DAE
RIDAE
IDAE
kRIDAE
DAE
NIDAE
kRIDAE
DAE
NIDAE
INIDAE
IDAE
ERELLIDAE
HHCHIDAE
INIDAE
IDAE
HTHYIDAE
URCHIDAE
INIDAE
NIDAE
4HCHIDAE
IDAE
kRIDAE
NIDAE
URCHIOAE
IDAE
kRIDAE
HYALELLIOAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHN
CYPRIM
SALMO
IDAE
ODONTIDAE
NIDAE
HVALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHN
SALMO
CYPRIK
DAPHN
COTTID
CYPRIK
CYPRIK
CVPRIN
SALMO
CENTR
CHI HO
IOAE
NIDAE
IDAE
IDAE
AE
IDAE
ODONTIDAE
IDAE
NIDAE
URCHIDAE
JOMIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERO
ICTALU
CENTR
ICTALU
CENTR
CYPRUS
MARCIOAE
RIDAE
HRCH1DAE
RIDAE
MWHIDAE
IDAE
SALMONIDAE
(+)
0.440
0.498
0.493
0.647
0.694
0.732
0.750
1.011
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
1.800
7.800
13.058
24.771
1.181
4.020
80.082
358.792
1.181
158.156
358.792
455.015
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.871
32.031
48.000
52.871
53.088
8.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
10.000
20.000
248.595
783.471
85.077
233.555
349.472
401.217
78.458
301.510
325.842
401217
2.000
8.811
32.801
99.853
2.000
8.811
32.601
92.054
339.899
1*92.474
8499.979
8479.723
339.999
3889.989
7049.808
9002.438
0.002
0.004
0.008
0.012
0.011
0.021
0.112
4.108
1.300
2.627
3.947
4.725
3.547
4.729
8.033
9.190
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30.BAY AVERAGE
l + t
0.201 »
0.289 »
0.251 *
0.393 •
0.037 »
0.058 *
3.218 *
13.468 *
0.470 *
0.347 t
32.914 t
31.818 *
0.137 »
0.144 »
62.848 *
84.085 »
0.00053 *
0.00014 *
0.537 •
1.208 *
(+) <++)
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
00036 FRV
0.00003 FCV
O.K003 FCV
0.2574 ACR
1.0772 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FHV
3.3931 ACR
3.2598 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACR
22.4228 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0198 ACR
(*
FOOTNOTE
<• - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
» * _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACH COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHROMIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: OKLAHOMA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AOUATO LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAOE
$ ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODIN1DAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PEFtCICHTHYIOAE
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
» — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
» - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAOE CRITERIA
(+] (+1 (+) (++)
13.737 8.1*8 47,0000 SCV
41.966
48.861
92.757
21.223 6.3M 47.0000 SCV
28.243
41.966
49.264
D-51
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: OREGON
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
SS CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
$ COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TEST
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
ED
14
6
8
4
18
13
a
5
10
6
23
12
10
5
20
11
12
7
Q
S
NAME
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONABCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTHARCHIDA6
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHJDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIOAF
E5OCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
PTEHONARCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
&ALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
LC50 VALUE
1+)
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
7.451
9.000
10.000
10.803
878.999
1794.245
14128.643
16487.430
1794.245
14128,643
19484.938
26041.875
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.880
0.048
0.183
0.496
1.147
6.325
15.000
23.238
32.249
15.884
26.000
43.739
54.711
67.000
6399.976
6998.790
24892.828
6399.976
8998.790
30454.750
63804.148
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.305
0.759
1.345
1.401
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
78.707
83.000
114.318
125.121
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
1323
1.595
1.900
3.000
4.503
9.000
5.452
8.000
5.452
8.000
10.611
24.000
066*
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664
3.611
5.800
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(*) < + ) (•+•+•)
3.388 *
3,337 *
113.263 *
289.699 «
0.027 0.0004 ACR
0.014 00002 ACR
1.974 » 0.0043 FRV
4.357 * 0.0043 FRV
12.164 0.3378 ACR
718.704 * 10.0 FPV
0.194 5.48618 FCV
0.122 0.01447 FCV
31.429 * 4.2472 ACR
28.2Z5 * 3.8141 AGR
0.650 0.0010 FRV
0.501 * 0.0010 FRV
1.830 * 0.0019 FRV
1.376 » 0.0019 FRV
0.208 « O'.10«4 ACR
0.029 * 0.0148 ACR
STATE: OREGON
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOH
tS LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
SS NICKEL
peas
SELENIUM
» SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 17
STATE 10
NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
NATIONAL 7
STATE 5
NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
NATIONAL 16
STATE 9
NATIONAL 5
STATE 2
NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
NATIONAL 8
STATE 6
NATIONAL 12
STATE 8
COENAGRIONIDAEfAGRIONIDAE) 87.650
FOOTNOTE
1- — UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
D-52
+ + —
FPV FINAL PLANT
FRV FINAL RESIDU
ACR COMPUTED BY
FCV FINAL CHRON
/ALUE
S. VALUE
ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
C VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME L
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHISAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
3AMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
3AMMARIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIOAE
SAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
HYAUEUlOAEfTAUTRIDAE)
PAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
H YALEUIDAE (TALITRI DAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
COTTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
1 - HARDNESS EFFECT
APPLY EQUATION 3.7
it — HARDNESS EFFECT
APPLY EQUATION 3.7
NTERCEPT VALUE
TO DETERMINE MAXIM
NTERCEPT VALUE
TO DETERMINE MAXIM
UM CRITERIA
UMAND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
:M VALUE
( + )
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.847
0.320
0.440
0.488
0.540
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
0.900
26.000
29.000
29.498
1.161
4.020
80.082
358.792
4.020
80.062
455.016
603.845
10000
21.988
22.437
52.871
21.988
42.198
48.000
88.000
5.000
10.000
31.823
244.259
5.000
10.000
244.259
783.471
B&.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
85.077
301.510
401.217
439.825
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.653
2.000
2.300
0.000
0.000
339.999
1992.474
6499.979
6479.723
339.999
1992.474
6479.723
94099.883
0.002
0.004
0.004
0.012
0.002
0.004
0.004
0,021
1.300
2.627
3.647
4.725
2.848
3.000
5.781
T.210
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+}
0.201 *
0.144 it
0.251 *
0.136 *
0.037 *
0.219 *
3.218 *
7.738 *
0.470 *
0.101 *
32.914 *
21.753 *
0.137 *
0.137 *
42.548 *
29.603 *
0.00053 *
0.00026 *
0.537 *
0,850 *
30-DAY AVERAOE
(+) <•*•+)
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
DOOM FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00002 FCV
0.2574 ACR.
08190 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.0074 ACR
3.3931 ACR
2.2425 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0315 ACB
7.8941 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0136 ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: OREGON STATE: PENNSYLVANIA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AOUATIC UFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSOVALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAOE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE
— (*i i+) (+) («)
* 2INC NATIONAL 1S DAPHNtBAE 19.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
PHVSIDAE 41.988 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 4».B91 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE W.7S7 SALMONIOAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE 13.737 4.744 47.0000 SCV STATE 10 SALMONIOAE
SALMONIOAE 47.229 CENTRARCHIDAE
PEflCICHTHYIDAE 49.284 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 ANOUILLIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL > QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
8ALMONIDAE
ICTALUSIDAE
STATE 8 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALUR1DAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
JJ CADMIUM NATIONAL It SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
OAMMARIOAE
CYPRINOOONTIDAE
CHLOROANE NATIONAL t PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 5 PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE » PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
S COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIOAE
CH1RONOMIOAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIOAE
STATE 1> DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIOAE
TUBIFICIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
9AMMARIDAE
ESOCIDAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECIUIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELUOAE
STATE 7 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELUOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
ENOOSULFAN NATIONAL < SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE • SALMONIDAE
CYPNINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
myi iNUit MICROORAMS PER LITI* •* - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
I* FW FINAL PLANT VALUE » - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD it - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APP^EOUATION3JTO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
(+)
7.451
8.000
8.000
10.803
4503
7.4S1
9.000
10.000
878.989
1794.245
14128.643
16487.430
1046.139
14128.043
18497.430
19434.938
0.048
0.49S
1.147
2.860
0.034
0.864
1.147
1.630
8.325
15.000
23.238
32249
8.325
23.238
33.682
40.000
87.000
8389.878
$898.790
24692.828
8998.790
24892.828
30454.750
97491.072
0.305
0.798
0.995
1.345
0.298
0.75*
0.995
1.345
70.707
83.000
114.318
125.121
79.797
83.000
114.318
121.121
1.323
1.995
1.700
2.234
0.978
1.595
1.684
1.700
4.503
5.000
5.452
8.000
2.459
8.000
10.811
20.000
0.884
1.27»
2.300
3.240
0.684
1.279
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AOUATIC UFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAOE
(*)
3.388 *
1.585 *
113-283 *
171.493 *
0.027 *
0.019
1.974 *
1.550 *
12.114
1692.458 *
0.194
0.14S
31.428 *
29.583 *
0.650
0.482 *
1.830 *
0.837 *
0.208 4
0.149 *
(+) !++>
0.0004 ACR
0.0003 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
(
5.48818 FCV
8.82839 FCV
4.2472 ACR
3.9977 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1084 ACR
0.0782 ACR
D-53
-------
APPENDIX 0
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: PENNSYLVANIA
STATE: PENNSYLVANIA
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOP.
SS LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
SS NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
i SILVEH
. TOXAPH6NE
NUMBER OF
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
17
10
10
a
7
t
10
7
9
7
16
13
5
5
15
7
a
5
12
9
NAME
SASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIOAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GENTBARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
ASELLIOAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMUARIDAE
ASTACIDAE:
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRAFCHIOAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CVPRINIPAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRAP.CHIDAE
CYPHtNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIOAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIOAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALUfllDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAC
LOW VALUE
0.440
0.46S
0.493
0.647
0.440
0.556
1,011
1.086
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
1.800
13.058
24.771
47.329
1.161
4.020
60.062
358.792
80.062
356.792
455.015
803.845
10.000
21.983
22.437
62.871
10.488
14.158
52.871
53.066
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
10.000
50.000
248.595
783.471
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.456
233.555
345.472
401.217
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.553
2.000
6.611
32.601
107.664
339.999
1992.474
6499.879
6479.723
339.999
2869.969
8479.723
9002.438
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.725
3.547
4.725
6.678
8.433
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
0.201 *
0.156 «
0551 *
0.269 *
0.037 *
14.989 *
3.218 *
2.099 *
0.470 *
0.915 *
32.914 *
33.390 *
0.137 *
0.131 *
82.348 *
62.301 *
0.00053 *
0.90035 *
0.537 *
1.330 *
FOOTNOTE
* - UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
D-54
ft — FPV
FRV
ACR
FCY
SCV
FINAL PLANT
FINAL RESIDL
COMPUTED B
FINAL CHKOK
VALUE
E VALUE
f ACUTE TO CHRC
1C VALUE
30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 10-DAY AVERAGE
00023 FRV S ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
0.0023 FRV STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0.0033 FRV
0.003ft FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00004 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.1679 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
3.3931 ACR
3.4906 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACR
1S.7469 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0216 ACR
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
t - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
NIC RATIO METHOD SI — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
13.737 8.148 47.0000 SCV
41.968
48.861
92.757
21.223 1.405 47.0000 SCV
41.986
49.999
92.757
-------
STATE: RHODE ISLAND
APPENDIX D
TOXiCITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: RHODE ISLAND
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
14
9
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCEO VALUE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPH
EMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
ARSENIC
*• CADMIUM
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
8
4
18
ANUUILLIUAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
IOTA
LURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
* COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
16
a
4
10
6
23
18
10
6
20
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPR NIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYS DAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOM1DAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBtFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
tSUWUAt
GAMMARIDAE
8 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
12
6
g
e
ASTACIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALM
JNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
OATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOS
TOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
4.503
7.451
9.000
16.000
878.999
1794.245
14128.643
18487.430
1046.139
14128.643
19484.938
20194.363
0.048
0,498
1.147
2.B60
0.034
0.864
1.147
1.630
6.326
15.000
23.238
32.249
23.233
33.862
40.000
54.711
87.000
6399.979
6988.790
248S2.B2B
6998.790
24892.828
30454.750
57461.872
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.346
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
78.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.976
1.595
1.664
3.000
4.503
5.000
S.452
8.000
2.459
6.000
14.480
30.102
0.604
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.664
1.279
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
<+) 111 1**)
3.388 *
1.520 *
113.263 *
141.820 *
0.027 0,0004 ACR
0.019 0,0003 ACR
1.974 * 0.0043 FRV
7*75 * 0.0043 FRV
12.164 0.3378 ACR
1892.459 * 10.0 FPV
0.194 5.48818 FCV
0.139 7.43115 FCV
31.429 * 4,2472 ACR
28.920 * 3.9081 ACR
0.650 0.0010 FRV
0.331 * 0.0010 FRV
1.830 * 0.0019 FRV
0.471 * 0.0019 FRV
0.298 * 0.1064 ACR
0.149 * 0.0762 ACR
ft*
* — UNITS IN MICHOGHAMS PER LITER
» + - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV
ACR
FCV
SCV
FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC BATIO METHOD
FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
NUMBER OF "08T S£NSIT IVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE
f A)
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17 GASTEROSTEI DAE
SALMONIOAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 9 GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCtDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
** LEA0 NATIONAL 7 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 8 GAMMARIDAE
SAXMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 5 GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
„ . PHILODINIDAE
S* NICKEL NATIONAL 18 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEKEFIELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
„„ CENTRARCHIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 5 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELUDAEITALITHIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 6 HYALELLIDAE(TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
1 SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 4 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 «RUDAEIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 7 CENTRAHCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERCIDAE
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDSNT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
1 - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
II - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
0.440
0-488
0493
O647
0.440
0.556
1.011
1.086
0.095
1.600
7 BOO
13.056
26.000
47 329
50.748
1.161
4 020
80062
358.712
80.M2
358.792
455.015
803.845
10.000
21.988
22.437
53.871
10.468
14.158
42.198
68.000
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
10.000
50.000
248.585
783.471
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.458
401 217
439.825
444.717
2.000
6,811
32.801
99.553
2.009
2.300
32.801
107.864
339.999
1992.474
6499.979
8479.723
339.991
3866.989
84T&723
9002.436
0.002
0 004
0.012
0.011
0 021
0.112
B.S17
1.300
2.827
3 547
4725
2.848
6.678
7426
12.000
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
0.201 »
0.153 *
0.251 *
3.521 *
0.037 *
14.989 *
3.218 *
1.829 *
0.470 *
0.629 *
32.914 *
33.126 *
0.137 *
0.080 *
82.648 *
54.280 *
0.00053 *
0.00008 *
0.537 *
0.913 *
'^'
0.0023
0.0023
0.0038
0.0038
0.00003
0.00003
0.2574
0.1463
0.20
0.20
3.3931
3.4152
0.014
0.014
22.0395
14.4747
0,0087
0.0148
'"'
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
" FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
FflV
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
D-SS
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: RHODE ISLAND
STATE: SOUTH CAROLINA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC UFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30.DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT
( + > ( + ) < + ) (++)
S ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIOAE 13.73? 6.148 47.0000 SCI/ ALDRIN
PHYSIDAE 41.966
SALMONIDAE 43.881
PHILOOINIDAE 92.757
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE 21.223 8.491 47.0000 SCV
PHYSIDAE 41.986
SALMONIOAE 51.845
PHILODINIDAE 92.757
ARSENIC
SI CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
t COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DIELORIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 14
STATE 8
NATIONAL 8
STATE 4
NATIONAL 18
STATE 15
NATIONAL 8
STATE 3
NATIONAL 10
STATE 8
NATIONAL 23
STATE 17
NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
NATIONAL 20
STATE 8
NATIONAL 12
STATE S
NATIONAL 9
STATE 4
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME L
CENTRA RCHIOAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
BALMONIDAE
CENTAARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAC
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OAUMARIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIOAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUeiFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PEPCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERC4DAC
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ASTACIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECIUIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
:§o VALUE
( + )
7.4S1
8.000
9.000
10.803
4.503
7.451
9.000
11.314
978.998
1794.245
14128. M3
10487.430
1040.139
14128.643
194*4.938
20041875
0.048
0.408
1.147
2.860
0.034
0.884
1.830
2.860
8.325
15.000
23.236
32.249
15.684
33.862
54.711
0.000
07.000
8398.978
0998.790
24862.826
8888.780
24882.828
30454.750
63804.148
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.258
0.759
0.995
1.345
78.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
78.707
83.000
114.318
125.121
1.323
1.585
1.700
2.234
0.978
1.505
3,000
3.570
4.503
8.000
5.452
8.000
2.459
8.000
10.811
41.000
0.854
1.278
2.300
3740
0.684
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AOUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(*)
3.388 *
1.73B it
113.283 *
132.343 *
0.027
0.018 *
1.874 *
1.874 *
*»
12.184
1804.873 *
0.194
0.133 *
31.429 *
29.583 *
0,650
0.305 *
1.830 *
0.339 *
0.208 *
0.019 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
<+) (++)
0.0004 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.48618 FCV
8.24143 FCV
42472 ACR
3,8877 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
00019 FRV
0.1084 ACR
0.0008 ACR
COENAaRIONIOAE(AQRIONIDAE) 87.850
FOOTNOTE • - FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
. - UNITS IN MICROQflAMS PER LITER • * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
, » — FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE t — HARDNESS EFFEC
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EOUATION .
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD it - HARDNESS EFFEC
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION S
1 INTERCEPT VALUE
17 TO DETERMINE MAXIM
r INTERCEPT VALUE
1.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIM1
JM CRITERIA
JMAND
ice SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: SOUTH CAROLINA
STATE: SOUTH CAROLINA
TOXICANT
ENDRIM
HEPTACHLOR
«* LEAD
LINOANE
MERCURY
M NICKEL
Peas
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
17
8
10
4
7
4
10
5
9
4
1B
11
5
3
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCM VALUE
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMC
PERLIC
PTEHO
SALMC
POECI
CENTR
COEW
PTERO
PALAE
PEflLIC
ASTAC
NIDAE
AE
NARCIDAE
NIDAE
.IIDAE
ARCHIDAE
GRIONIDAEIAQRION
NARCIDAE
MONIDAE
AE
DAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTR
DAPHK
CYPRIf
ARCHIDAE
IDAE
illDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHf>
SALMC
CYPRI
IDAE
NIDAE
JIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTR
PHILO
CYPRI)
ARCHIDAE
>INIDAE
IIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMC
QAMM
NIDAE
ARIDAE
CENTHARCMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTR
PERCH
CYPRI)
ARCHIDAE
)AE
JIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMM
ASTAC
SALMC
ARIOAE
DAE
NIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMC
PHILO
NAIDID
NIDAE
JINIDAE
AF
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEM
CENTR
ERELLtDAE
ARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILO
CHIRO
JINIDAE
NOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTR
CYPRI»
QAMM
ARCHIDAE
IIDAE
fcRIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTR
ARCHIDAE
m
0.440
0.488
0.493
0.647
0.556
0.750
1.011
DAE) 1.800
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
13.058
S4.771
90.748
319.999
1.181
4.020
80.002
358.792
80.082
455.015
803.845
814.803
10.000
21.988
21437
52.871
37.889
52.871
88.000
112.894
5.000
10.000
31.823
244.259
20.000
248.995
783.471
999.998
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.495
401.817
439.825
444.717
2.000
6.611
32.801
99.553
2.000
6.811
FRESHWATER AOUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
m
0.201 *
0.170 *
0.251 *
0.657 *
0.037 *
14.070 *
3.218 *
10.826 *
0.470 *
1.880 *
32.914 *
31.123 *
0.137 *
0.137 *
**
m <*•+)
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.2974 ACR
0.8880 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
3.3931 ACR
3.2069 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
TOXICANT
$ ZINC
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
I-H ( + ) <+) <++)
13.737 8.148 47,0000 SCV
41.968
48.861
92.757
21.223 7.991 * 47.0000 SCV
41.986
48.950
92.757
COENAQFIIONJ DAE (ASRIONIDAE) 282.842
SELENIUM
* SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
10
7
9
3
12
6
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHN
CYPRir
IDAE
IODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIDAE)
DAPHU
SALMC
POECI
IDAE
NIDAE
IIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIt
CYPRI»
CYPRII
SALMO
CENTH
PHILOI
AE
IIDAE
IODONTIDAE
NIDAE
ARCHIDAE
>INIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERO
ICTALU
NARCIDAE
RIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRIh
SALMC
IDAE
NIDAE
PERCIDAE
0.000
339.999
1992.474
8499.979
8479.723
339.981
3869.989
8479.723
12599.945
0.002
0.004
0.005
0.012
0.021
0.112
5.817
0.009
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.725
4.729
8.129
9.963
12.000
82.948 *
57.356 *
0.00053 *
0.00053 *
ft*
0.537 *
1.700 *
22.0398 ACR
15.2959 ACR
0.0067 ACR
0,0276 ACH
FOOTNOTE
t - UNITS IN MICROORAMS PER LITER
» + _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
• • - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
» - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
U - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
D-S7
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: SOUTH DAKOTA
STATE: SOUTH DAKOTA
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
St CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
I COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TEST
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
&
14
3
e
5
18
13
a
5
10
e
23
IS
10
0
20
11
12
6
9
7
NAME
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTJURCHIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
IGTALURIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CYPRINDDONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONAHCIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAPHNIDAE
CENTRAflCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIOAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
ICM VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(•*•) 4~H (-H (+-O
7.451 3.388 *
8.000
9.000
10.803
1.503 1.389 *
7.451
16.000
16.392
878.999 113.283 *
1794.245
14126.643
16487.430
1794.245 363.601 +
13339.965
18487.430
19484.936
0.048 0.027 0.0004 ACR
0.496
1.147
2.880
0.044 0.016 0.0002 ACR
0.490
1.147
1.630
6.325 1.974 * 0.0043 FRV
15.000
23.238
32.249
23.238 6.084 * 0.0043 FRV
25.481
26.000
64,711
67.000 12.164 0.3378 ACR
6399.976
8998.790
24892.828
6399.976 781.038 « 10.0 FPV
8998.790
24892.828
57461.672
0.305 0.194 5.46618 FCV
0.759
0.996
1.345
0.305 0,150 9.92408 FCV
0.759
D.9B5
1.022
76.707 31.429 * 4.2472 ACR
63.000
1 14.316
125.121
57.000 20.746 * 2.6035 ACR
83.000
114.316
125.121
1.323 0,650 0.0010 FRV
1.595
1.700
2.234
1.323 0.489 * 0.0010 FRV
1.5S5
1,700
3.000
4.503 1.830 * 0.0019 FRV
5.000
5.452
8.000
2.459 0.490 * 0.0019 FRV
10.811
24.000
30.102
0.664 0200 t 0.1064 ACR
1.279
2.300
3.240
0664 0.181 * 0.0823 ACR
1.279
3.240
3.811
FOOTNOTE
• — UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PE« LITER
3-58
t 4 —
FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
IS LEAD
LIN DANS
MERCURY
» NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
$ SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 17
STATE 7
NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
NATIONAL 7
STATE 5
NATIONAL 10
STATE r
NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
NATIONAL 16
STATE 1 1
NATIONAL i
STATE 3
NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
NATIONAL 12
STATE 9
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME L
QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTPARCHIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRIMODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TAUTRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRIMIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
com DAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
CENTFIAHCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
• — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
$ - HARDNESS EFFECT
APPLY EQUATION 3
U — HARDNESS EFFEC1
APPLY EQUATION 3
INTERCEPT VALUE
.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIM
INTERCEPT VALUE
7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMl
JU CRITERIA
JM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
CM VALUE
(+)
0.440
0.466
0.493
0.647
0.493
0.694
0.732
1.011
0.9S5
1.800
2.800
7.800
2.800
13.058
28.000
29.000
1.181
4.020
80.082
358.792
4.020
158.158
358.792
455.015
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.871
8.004
42.198
48.000
53.088
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.259
5.000
10.000
248.595
783.471
88.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
65.077
325.842
401,217
439.825
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.563
2.000
2.300
32.601
0.000
339.999
1992.474
6499.979
8479.723
339.999
1992.474
7049.WS
9002.438
0002
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.002
0.011
0.021
0.112
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.7S5
1.300
2.848
3.547
5.2S1
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+>
0.201 *
0.191 *
0.251 *
0.605 *
0.037 *
0.325 *
3.219 *
2.320 *
0.470 *
0.101 *
32.914 *
25.188 *
0.137 *
0.137 *
**
82.648 *
54.887 *
0.00053 *
O.OC015 *
0.637 *
0.464 *
3W3AY AVERAGE
(+) (++)
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.003D FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.185D ACR
0.20 FRV
0.0671 ACR
3.3931 ACR
2.5968 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACR
14.6364 ACR
0.0087 AC*
0.0075 ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: SOUTH DAKOTA
STATE: TENNESSEE
TOXICANT
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
1*1
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM M-DAY AVENUE
«+> 1+1 <++>
NUMIEROF
FAMILIES TESTED
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
LCM VALUE
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
12 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
13.737
41.9M
48.M1
92.757
13.737
26.243
41.966
92.757
$S CADMIUM
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
t COPPER
STATE
DOT
NATIONAL
NATIONAL
NATIONAL
STATE
14 CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELL1DAE
EPHEMERELUOAE
SALMONIDAE
7 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
8 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
e 8AMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
OAMMARIOAE
PHYSIDAE
14 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
8 PALAEUONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRIN1DAE
QAMMAHIDAE
4 PALAEMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
10 QAMMARIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
7 3AMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
17 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHY3IDAE
SALMONIDAE
10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
7 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
3AMMARIDAE
20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
3AMMARIDAE
• DAPHNIDAE
A8TACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
12 POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
t SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
I SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIOAE
9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
7.4S1
8.000
9.000
10.803
4.503
7.451
10.000
18.000
878.999
1794.249
14121.843
16487.430
B78.V99
1048.139
13338.969
16487.430
0.048
0.498
1.147
2.860
0.044
0.163
0.864
1.147
9325
16,000
23.238
32-249
8.325
1.332
25.481
54.711
67.000
8399.976
6996,790
24892.828
67.000
6996.790
30454.750
0.306
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256
0.759
0.895
1.022
76.707
83.000
114,316
125.121
87.000
83.000
114.316
167.000
1.323
1.599
1.700
2.234
0.976
3.000
3.234
4.102
4.503
5.000
5.492
8.000
2.459
10.811
20.000
30.102
0.664
UTS
2.300
3240
0.664
1.279
3.240
3.811
0.137 *
0.0004 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
0.1496 ACR
8.4M18 FCV
4.79332 FCV
4.2472 ACR
2.5176 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.0701 ACR
FOOTNOTE
* — UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
, , _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
— FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
- STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
- HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
- HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 9.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
D-59
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: TENNESSEE
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
« LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
W NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
S SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TEST!
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
D
17
B
10
5
7
i
10
5
9
4
16
11
5
S
10
8
9
6
12
8
NAME
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECtLIIDAE
CENTRAPCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRA RCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
1CTALURIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIOAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHIUJDINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMEP.ELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHVIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURtDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
LC50 VALUE
( + )
0.440
0468
0.483
0.647
0.694
0.732
0.750
1.011
0.985
1.600
2.800
7800
1.600
13.058
24.771
50.748
1.161
4.020
80.082
399.792
1.181
158.198
398.792
4S5.01S
10.000
21.988
92.437
52.871
3.004
S2.S7t
93.068
94.805
S.OOO
10.000
31.623
244.299
10.000
248.595
783.471
999.899
88.077
233.555
34S.472
401.217
78.498
301.910
329.842
401.217
2.000
8.811
32.801
99.593
2.000
8.611
32.601
92.094
339.999
1992.474
8499.979
8479.723
1M.9M
3889.98)
7049.800
9002.43)
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.042
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
1.300
2.827
3.847
4.729
1.547
4.725
1.291
8.033
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+)
0.201 *
0.284 *
0.291 *
0.243 *
0.037 *
0059 *
3.218 «
1.007 «
0.470 *
0.839 *
32.914 *
31.618 *
0.137 *
0.144 *
82,848 *
74.102 *
0.00093 *
0.00041 *
0.937 »
1.304 *
30-DAY AVERAOE
(*) <++)
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00004 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.1289 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
3.3931 ACR
3.2596 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0399 ACR
19.7904 ACR
0.0067 ACR
0.0212 ACR
FOOTNOTE
<• - UNITS IN MICROCRAMS PER LITER
» 4 - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
D-60
FRV
ACR
FCV
SCV
FINAL RESIDU
COMPUTED Bl
FINAL CHRON
E VALUE
ACUTE TO CHHC
1C VALUE
NIC RATIO METHOD
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: TENNESSEE
NUMBER OF HOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME 1C
S ZINC • NATIONAL 19 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
t - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
(S - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVEHAQE
(+) <+) ( + ) (++)
13.737 8.148 47.0000 SCV
41.966
48.861
92.737
21.223 8.399 47.0000 SCV
28.243
41.968
49.284
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: TEXAS
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
** CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
* COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
14
7
8
4
18
12
B
4
10
7
23
15
10
7
20
10
12
6
9
4
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME ICW VALUE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNICAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
POECILIIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TU8IFCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PEP.CIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIPAE
POECIUIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAQRIONIDAE
( + )
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
7.451
10.000
18.000
16.392
878.999
1794.245
14128.643
18487.430
1046.139
16487.430
19484.938
20194.383
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.880
0.183
0.864
2.860
6.987
8.325
15.000
23.238
32.249
8.325
23.238
54.711
190.000
67.000
6389.978
6998.790
24892.828
6988.790
24802.8:8
29999.867
30454.750
0.305
0.759
0.965
1.34S
0.256
0.759
0.885
1.345
76.707
63.000
114.318
125.121
83.000
114.316
125.121
207.956
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.976
1.599
2.409
3.234
4.503
5.000
5.452
6.000
4.503
10.611
20.000
30.102
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
1.279
3.700
3.811
IAQRIONIDAE) 8.7.650
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 3UAY AVCMOE
(+)
3388 *
2.646 *
113.263 *
140.493 *
0.027
0.041 *
1.974 *
0.558 *
12.184
2271,128 *
0.194
0.121 *
31.429 *
28.174 *
0.690
0.357 *
1.830 *
1.066 t
0.208 «
0.039 *
+ ) (++)..
0.0004 ACR
0.0006 ACR
0,0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10,0 FPV
5.48618 FCV
6.56581 FCV
4.2472 ACR
33072 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1084 ACR
0.0198 ACR
*
FOOTNOTE
* - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
r +
- FPV FINAL PLANT \
FRV FINAL RESIDU
ACR COMPUTED BY
FCV FINAL CHRON
;ALUE
I VALUE
ACUTE TO CHRONIC 1
C VALUE
UTIO METHOD
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: TEXAS
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LOW VALUE
ENDR1N NATIONAL 17 QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 8 POECILIIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10 PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 6 PALAEMONIDAE
ASTACIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
M LEAD NATIONAL 7 QAMMARIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMDNIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 4 CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
POeCIUIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
LINDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 6 CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
PERCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 3 ASTACIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDIDAE
JJ NICKEL NATIONAL 18 DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
COENAQRIONIDAE (AGRIQNIDA
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELLIDAEfTALITRIDAE)
DAWN1DAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 8 HYALELUDAEfTALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
POECILIIDAE
$ SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 4 CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 8 ICTALUHIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PERCIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES- NATIONAL VALUE USED
» - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
H - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
4+)
0.440
0.4S8
0.493
0.647
0.949
1.011
1.089
1.265
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
1.600
7.800
24.771
80.748
1.161
4.020
80.062
358.792
363.702
459.015
S32.U6
803.849
10.000
21.986
22.437
52.871
52.671
53.066
88.000
94.805
5.000
10.000
31.823
2444S6
20.000
763.471
999.998
0.000
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.486
301.510
401.217
436.825
2.000
6.611
32.601
98,553
6.611
32.601
E) 282.842 .
0.000
339.999
1*92.474
6499.079
8479.723
339.699
3889.969
9002.438
12599.S45
0.002
0.004
0.008
0.012
0.011
0.112
4.108
5.517
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.725
3.547
4726
8433
12.000
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
( + )
0.201 *
0.418 *
0.251 *
0.234 *
0.037 *
113.577 *
3.218 *
17.797 *
0.470 «
0.470 *
**
32.914 *
30.838 *
0.137 *
0.137 *
**
82.648 *
85.749 *
0.00053 *
0.00015 *
0.537 *
1.069 *
(•H
0.0023
0.0023
0.0038
0.0038
0.00003
3.2496
0.2574
1.4237
0.20
0.20
3.3931
3.1791
0.014
0.014
22.0395
17.5329
0.0087
0.0172
(4*+)
FRV
FRV
FRV
FRV
FCV
ACR
ACR
ACR
^
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
ACR
ACR
D-61
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: TEXAS
STATE: UTAH
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCMVALUE
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
1 + ) 1+1 (++1
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
LCSO VALUE
l+l
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAOE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMOMDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
PHILOOINIDAE
13.737
41.966
48.861
92.7S7
21.223
41 .gee
49.284
92.757
U CADMIUM
STATE
STATE
$ COPPER
CYANIDE
ENOOSULFAN
14 CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELUDAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
SALMONIDAE
9 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
PERCICHTMYIOAE
8 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
tCTALURIDAE
6 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
IB SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
12 SALMONIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
B PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
6 PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
10 QAMMAfltDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
6 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIOAE
12 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIOAE
PLANORBIOAE
10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
PERCIDAE
S SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
12 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
12 POECILIIDAE
ASELUDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
8 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIOAE
« SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
8 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
7.451
6.000
9.000
10.603
4.503
7.451
9.000
10.000
878.999
1794.249
14138.643
16467.430
1794.249
14126.643
16467.430
10484.938
0.046
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.034
0.163
0.496
1.147
6.325
15.000
23.236
15.000 5.966 *
23.238
26.000
3&S62
67.000 12.164
6399.976
6996.790
24892428
6399.976
6988.790
30454.790
$7461.672
0.305
0.769
0.986
1.343
0.906
0.769
1.345
1.4J4
76.707 31.429 *
63.000
114.316
126.121
76.707 28.225 *
63.000
114.316
125.121
1.323 0.680
1.565
1.700
764.446 *
0.194
0.121
1.323
1.696
3.000
3.096
4503
5.000
5.452
8.000
2.499
8.000
10.611
24000
0.664
1.270
2.300
3J40
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.503 *
1.630 *
0 .208 *
0.0004 ACR
0.0001 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3371 ACR
S.4861S FCV
2.80135 FCV
4.2472 ACR
3.6141 ACR
0.0015 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.1003 ACR
D-62
FOOTNOTE
t — UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PCR LITER
, .> _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
— FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
- STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
— HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
- HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAOE CRITERIA
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: UTAH
TOXICANT
ENDHIN
HEPTACHLOR
M LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
M NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
* SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TEST
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
STATE: UTAH
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
ED NAME LCM VALUE MAXIMUM
(+) t+)
17 QASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440 0.201 *
SALMONIDAE 0.468
PERLJDAE 0.493
PTERONARCIOAE 0.647
9 SALMONIDAE 0.397 0,125 *
PERLIDAE 0.493
PTERONARCIDAE 0.647
CENTRARCHIOAE 1.011
10 PTERONARCIDAE 0.895 0.251 «
PALAEMONIDAE 1-800
PERLIDAE 2800
ASTACIDAE 7.800
7 PTERONARCIDAE 0,965 0.126 *
PERLIDAE 2J»0
SALMONIDAE 13.0S8
CENTRAHCHIDAE 26.000
7 QAMMARIDAE 1.161 0.037 *
DAPHNIDAE 4.020
SALMONIOAE. 80.062
CYPRINIDAE 398.792
! DAPHNIDAE 4.020 0287 *
SALMONIDAE 80,062
CYPRINIDAE 398.7B2
CENTRARCHIDAE 499.015
10 ASELLIDAE 10.000 3218 *
SALMONIOAE 21888
QAMMARIDAE 22.437
CENTRAflCHIDAE 92.671
8 SALMONIDAE '4.158 5.119 *
CENTRARCHIDAE 42.196
QAMMARIDAE 48.000
ICTALURIDAE 53.088
9 DAPHNIDAE 5.000 0.470 *
QAMMARIDAE 10.000
ASTACIDAE 31.623
SALMONIDAE 244.299
9 DAPHNIDAE &000 0.101 *
OAMMARIDAE 10.000
SALMONIDAE 248.545
PHILODINIDAE 783.471
16 DAPHNIDAE 68.077 32.914 *
EPHEMER6LUDAE S33.655
CENTRARCHIDAE 345.472
PHILOD1NIDAE 401217
9 OAFHNIOAE W-077 21.753 *
PERCICHTHYIDAE 301.810
PHILODINIDAE 401217
CHIRONOMIDAE 439.825
5 SALMONIDAE 2.000 0.137 *
CENTRARCHIDAE 6.611
CYPRINIDAE 32.60t
QAMMARIDAE 99.553
3 SALMONIDAE 2.000 0.137 *
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.300 **
CVPRINIDAE 32.801
0.000
10 HYALELLIDAE(TAUTRIOAE) 339.808 82.948 *
DAPHNtOAE 1992.474
CYPHINODONTIOAE 6499.979
SALMONIDAE 6479.723
7 HYALELUDAEITAUTFIlDAE) 339.049 &2.431 »
DAPHNIDAE 1992.474
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
CYPRINIDAE 9002.438
9 DAPHNIDAE 0.002 0.00063 »
COTTIDAE 0-004
CYPRINIDAE 0.006
CYPRINOOONTIDAE 0.012
6 DAPHNIDAE 0.002 0.00030 *
COTTIDAE 0.004
CYPWMIDA,6 0-006
SALMONIDAE 0.021
12 PERLIDAE 1.300 M37 *
PTERONARCIDAE 2.627
ICTALUHIDAE 3.547
CENTRARCHIDAE 4.725
10 PEHLIDAE 1^00 0.543 *
PTERONARCIDAE 2.627
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.848
ICTALURIDAE 3,547
FOOTNOTE
. _ UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
* * - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE
30-DAY AVERAQE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
<+> (++)
0.0023 FRV I 2INC NATIONAL 15 OAPHNIDAE
PHYSIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0.0023 FRV STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PEflCICHTHYIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
0.0036 FRV
0.0036 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
02574 ACR
0.4095 ACR
020 FRV
0.0871 ACR
3.3931 ACR
2.2426 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACR
13.9816 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0088 ACR
/*
* — FAILED TO MEbl MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* • — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
$ - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACB COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD M - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FGV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE TODAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
6DVALUI MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(t) (+) <+) (-H-)
13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV
41.966
48.861
92.757
13.737 4.780 47.0030 SCV
49.884
4t.989
9J.757
D-63
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXIC IT Y DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: VERMONT
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
tt CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
S COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
OIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL 14
STATE 9
NATIONAL B
STATE 4
NATIONAL 18
STATE 15
NATIONAL 8
STATE 4
NATIONAL 10
STATE 5
NATIONAL 23
STATE 18
NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
NATIONAL 20
STATE S
NATIONAL 12
STATE 6
NATIONAL 9
STATE 6
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELL
EPHE»
SALMC
SALMI
CENTF
EPHEH
CYPRI
QAMM
DAPH
SALMC
ICTAL
DAPH
SALMC
CYPRI
CENTF
SALMC
DAPH
GAMM
PHYSI
SALMC
DAPH
GAMM
CYPRI
PALAE
PTERO
CYPRI
GAMM
CYPRI
QAMM
SALMC
CENTF
3AMM
DAPHr
PHILO
PHYSI
PHILO
PHYSI
CYPRI
SALMC
DAPHI*
CHIRO
PHYSI
TUBIF
DAPW
CHIRO
PHYSI
TUBIF
SALMC
DAPHI*
CENTF,
PERCI
SALMC
DAPHI*
CENTfi
PERCI
DAPHI>
PERCI
ESOCI
QAMM
DAPHI.
PERCI
ESOCI
3AMM
POECI
ASELL
SALMC
EPHEIU
SALMC
EPHEM
CENTR
CYPRI
SALMC
CYPRI
PTEHO
CATOS
DAE
4EREUIDAE
JNIDAE
3NIDAE
ARCHIDAE
HERELLIDAE
NIDAE
AHIDAE
JIDAE
JNIDAE
JRIDAE
JIDAE
JNiDAE
NIOAE
ARCHIDAE
)NIDAE
JIDAE
ARIDAE
DAE
1NIDAE
JIDAE
ARIDAE
NODONTIDAE
MONIDAE
NARCIDAE
MIDAE
ARIDAE
MIDAE
ARIDAE
JNIDAE
ARCHIDAE
ARIDAE
JIDAE
DINIDAE
DAE
DINIDAE
3AE
MIDAE
JNIDAE
IDAE
NOMIDAE
3AE
CIDAE
IDAE
NOMIDAE
ME
CIDAE
NIDAE
IDAE
ARCHIDAE
ME
NIDAE
IDAE
ARCHIDAE
ME
IDAE
ME
ME
ARIDAE
IDAE
ME
ME
ARIDAE
JIDAE
DAE
NIDAE
ERELLIDAE
NIDAE
ERELLIDAE
ARCHIDAE
JIDAE
NIDAE
JIDAE
NARCIDAE
TOUIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRI
CATOS
JIDAE
TOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
3-6.4
LCM VALUE
(+1
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
4.503
7.451
9.000
11.732
878.999
1794.245
14129.643
16487.430
1046.139
14128.643
15659.836
19484938
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.034
0.864
1.147
1.630
6.325
15.000
23.238
32.249
12.371
32.249
33.862
54.711
67.000
6399.976
6908.790
24892.828
6998.790
24892.828
40637.609
63304.148
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.345
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.976
1.595
1.700
2.234
4.503
5.000
5.452
8.000
2.459
8.000
14.460
22.101
0.684
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.684
1.279
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+•}
3.388 *
1.770 *
113.263 *
148.092 *
0.027
0.017
1.974 *
3.272 *
12.164
1448.932 *
0.194
0.139
31.429 *
29.583 *
0.650
0.401 *
1.830 *
0.549 *
0.208 *
0.149 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (•*•+)
0.0004 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.45618 FCV
7.63485 FCV
4.2472 ACR
3.9677 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FHV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.0762 ACR
FOOTNOTE
* — UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
+ » — FPV
FRV
ACR
FCV
SGV
FINAL PLANT
FINAL RESIOU
COMPUTED B
FINAL CHRON
VALUE
E VALUE
1 ACUTE TO CHR
1C VALUE
DNIC BATIO METHOD
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: VERMONT
NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17
STATE 8
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10
STATE 5
SS LEAD NATIONAL 7
STATE 4
LINDANE NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
MERCURY NATIONAL 9
STATE 5
M NICKEL NATIONAL 16
STATE 12
PCBS NATIONAL 5
STATE 5
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10
STATE 8
t SILVER NATIONAL 9
STATE 4
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12
STATE 7
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50 VALUE
GASTEROSTEIDAE •
SALMONIDAE
FERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
COENAQRIONIOAE (AQRION1DA
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
FERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
CAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMAFIIDAE
HYALELLIDAEfTALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIDAE)
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PERU DAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERCIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
•• — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
J - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIM
SS — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXSM
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
UM CRITERIA
UMAND
(+&
0.440
0.488
0.493
0.847
0.556
0.582
1.011
E) 1.800
O.W5
1.800
2.600
7.800
13.058
26.000
37.048
50.748
1.161
4.020
80.062
358.792
80.062
157.991
455.015
803.845
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.871
14,158
22.437
42.196
68.000
5.000
10.000
31.823
244.259
10.000
50.000
248.595
763.471
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.456
345.472
40U17
439625
2.000
6.011
32.601
99.553
2.000
2.300
32.601
107.064
33Q.99Q
1992.474
6490.679
8479.723
339.999
3105.149
3869.989
8479.723
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.011
0.021
0.112
5.517
1.300
2.627
3.647
4.725
2.848
6.165
6.878
12.000
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+1
0.201 *
0.141 *
0.251 «
3.705 *
0.037 *
10.748 *
3.218 *
3.392 *
0.470 *
0.629 •
32.914 *
33.129 *
0.137 *
0.060 *
82.648 *
58.744 *
0.00053 *
0.00006 *
0.537 *
0.686 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
< + ) ( + •*•)
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.2574 ACR
02713 ACR
0.20 FHV
0.20 FRV
3.3931 ACR
3.4153 ACR
0.014 FHV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACR
15.6649 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0144 ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
TATE: VERMONT STATE: VIRGINIA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE
(+i (+) (+) ft**"**!
ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV AIDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTHARCHIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.986 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE 46.861 EPHEMERELUDAE
PHILODINIDAE 82757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE 21.223 8.451 47.0000 SCV STATE 9 SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE 41.966 CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE 51.845 EPHEMERELUDAE
PHILODINIDAE 82.757 ANQUILLIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIOAE
STATE 4 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
$f CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 15 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 4 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE .
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 3AMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 6 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PERCICHTHYIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
S COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFIGIOAE
STATE 19 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
E8OCIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
STATE 8 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
ASTACIPAE
DIELDRIN NATIONAL 12 POECILIIDAE
A8ELUOAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELUDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
FOOTNOTE * — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
» - UNITS IN MICROORAMS PER LITER ** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
* * _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE t - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
ACH COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD It - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
(•*• )
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
4.503
7.451
9.000
16.000
878.009
1704.245
14128.643
16487.430
1048.130
14128.643
18484.938
20184.383
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.860
0.034
0.8S4
1.147
1.630
6325
15.000
23.238
32.249
23238
33.862
40.000
64.711
67.000
6389.978
6908.780
24882.828
6888.790
24882.828
30454.790
57461.8T2
0.305
0.759
0.99S
1.34S
0.296
0.799
0.885
1.345
76.707
83.000
114.316
129.121
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
0.976
1.596
1.664
3.000
4.503
6.000
5.452
8.000
2.458
8.000
10.811
30.102
0.684
1.270
2.300
3.240
0.664
1.279
3.240
3.611
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY
(+) (+)
3.388 *
1.920 *
113.263 *
141.620 *
0.027 0.0004
0.017 0.0002
1.974 * 0.0043
7.675 * 0.0043
12.164 ~ 0.3378
1602.459 10.0
0.104 5.46618
0.145 8.38350
31.429 * 4.2472
28.920 * 3.9081
0.650 0.0010
0.331 * 0.0010
1.830 * 0.0018
0.465 * 0.0018
0.208 * 0.1064
0.149 * 0.07W
AVERAOE
(•*•+)
ACR
ACR
FRV
FRV
ACR
FPV
FCV
FCV
ACR
ACR
FRV
FHV
FRV
FRV
ACR
ACR
D-65
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA. BY STATE
STATE: VIRGINIA
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOH
a LEAD
LIN DANE
MERCURY
SI NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
5 SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TEST
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
ED
17
9
10
9
r
4
10
6
9
6
18
13
9
9
10
6
9
4
12
7
NAME
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALM
PERU
PTER
SALM
CYPR
CENT
COEN
PTEFU
PALA
PERL
ASTA
SALM
CENT
GAMV
DAPH
OAMIl
DAPH
SALM
CYPR
SALM
CYPR
CENT
PHILC
ASELI
SALM
QAMM
CENT
QAMM
SALM
CENT
PERC
DAPH
GAMM
ASTAC
SALM
GAMM
ASTAC
SALM
PHILO
DAPH
EPHEI
CENTF
PHILO
DAPH
CENTF
PHILO
CHino
SALMI
CENTF
CYPRI
QAMM
SALMC
CENTF
CYPRI
QAMM
ONIDAE
DAE
3NARCIDAE
ONIDAE
NIDAE
RARCHIDAE
AGRIONIDAClAORIOh
3NARCIDAE
EMONIDAE
DAE
SIDAE
ONIOAE
RAHCHIDAE
ARIDAE
NIDAE
ARIDAE
NIDAE
ONIDAE
NIDAE
ONIDAE
NIDAE
RARCHIDAE
DINIDAE
IDAE
ONIDAE
ARIDAE
URCHIDAE
ARIDAE
3NIDAE
URCHIDAE
DAE
NIDAE
ARIDAE
IDAE
3NIDAE
ARIDAE
IDAE
JNIDAE
DINIDAE
IIDAE
JERELLIDAE
ARCHIDAE
DIN1DAE
4IDAE
ARCHIDAE
OINIDAE
NOMIDAE
JNIDAE
1ARCHIDAE
NIDAE
ARIDAE
JNIDAE
ARCHIDAE
UIDAE
ARIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIDAE>
DAPHI
CYPRI
SALMC
HYALE
DAPHf
SALMC
CYPRI
DAPHr
COTTI
CYPRI
CYPRI
CYPHI
SALMC
CENTP
PHILO
PERLIC
PTEFtO
ICTALL
CENTP
CENTH
SALMC
CYPRIt
IIDAE
NODONTIDAE
JNIDAE
LLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
IIDAE
NIDAE
MIDAE
IDAE
JAE
4IDAE
WDONTIDAE
4IDAE
NIDAE
ARCHIDAE
DINIDAE
AE
NARCIDAE
RIDAE
ARCHIDAE
ARCHIDAE
NIDAE
(IDAE
PERCIDAE
3-66
LC50 VALUE
It)
0.440
0.468
0493
0.647
0.556
0.732
1.011
IIDAE) 1.800
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
13.058
24.771
47.329
50.748
1.161
4.020
80.062
396.792
80.062
358.792
455.015
803.845
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.971
10.488
14.158
52.871
68.000
5.000
10.000
31.123
244.259
10.000
90.000
248.599
783.471
6S.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
78.458
345.472
401.217
439.829
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.593
2.000
8.611
32.601
107.684
339.999
1992.474
8499.979
8479.723
339.999
3869.989
8479.723
9002.438
0.002
0.004
0.008
0.012
0.011
0.021
0.112
5.B17
1.300
2.627
3.947
4.725
4.725
6.878
8033
12000
STATE: VIRGINIA
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+)
0.201 *
0.175 *
0.251 *
3.446 *
0.037 t
14.969 *
3.218 *
1.740 *
0.470 *
0.764 *
32.914 *
3s.oaa *
0.137 *
0.131
82.848 *
54.280 *
0.00053 *
0.00008 *
0.537 *
1.843 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) C++)
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00003 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.1392 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FRV
3.3931 ACR
3.6172 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACR
14.4747 ACR
0.0067 ACR
0.0267 ACR
FOOTNOTE
t - UNITS IN MICHOGBAMS PER LITER
, » _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRY
ACR
FCV
SCV
FINAL RESIDUE
COMPUTED BY
FINAL CHflONI
VALUE
ACUTE TO CHflO
C VALUE
NIC RATIO METHOD
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
TOXICANT
t ZINC
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
FAMILIES TESTED NAME L
NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PH1LODINIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* * — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
1 — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7
J$ - HARDNESS EFFECT 1
APPLY EQUATION 3.7
TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
1TEBCEPT VALUE
TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
M-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA J
C80 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
(+> (+) (+1 (++>
13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV
41.988
48.661
92.757
21.223 8.298 47.0000 SCV
41.988
48.550
92.757
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: WASHINGTON
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
a CADMIUM
CHLORDANE
CHROMIUM
J COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TEST)
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
0
14
a
8
i
18
12
8
«
10
5
23
11
10
e
20
11
12
8
9
e
NAME
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIOAE
EPHEMEHELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
SALMONIOAE
CYPRINIOAE
8AMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
3AMMARIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIOAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTHARCHIDAE
POECILIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
LCSO VALUE
<+)
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
r.451
9.000
10803
11.314
S76.999
1794.245
14128.643
1 6487.430
1704.24S
14128.643
19484.938
22039602
0.048
0.498
1.147
2.880
0.048
0.498
1.147
2.880
6.325
15.000
23.238
32.249
15.000
15.884
2S.OOO
43.739
(7.000
6399.978
6998,790
24892.828
0399.978
6998.790
63804.148
81251.078
0.305
0.759
0.995
1445
0.305
0.759
1.345
1.401
78.707
83.000
114,318
125.121
78.707
83.000
114.318
125.121
1.323
1.595
1.700
2.234
1.323
1.595
3.000
3.282
4.503
5.000
5.492
8,000
5.452
8.000
10.811
24.000
0.884
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.884
2.300
3.811
5.800
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(+)
3.388 *
3.241 *
113.283 *
343.846 *
0.027
0.013
1.174 *
3.775 *
12.164
485.809 *
0.194
0.118
31.429 *
28.920 *
0.650
0.479 *
1.830 *
1.458 *
0208 *
0.153 *
10-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (++1
0.0004 ACR
0.0002 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.46818 FCV
9.84928 FCV
4.2472 ACR
3.9081 ACR
0.0010 FBV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1084 ACR
0,0767 ACR
ef
FOOTNOTE
» - UNITS IN MICHOORAMS PER LITER
, f - FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FBU FIUAI RESIDUE VALUE
ACR
FCV
SCV
COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FINAL CHROI>
1C VALUE
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: WASHINGTON
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17 QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
STATE 10 GASTEftOSTEIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PERUDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
HEPTACHLOH NATIONAL 10 PTERONAHCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
STATE 7 PTERONARCIDAE
PERUOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
« LEAD NATIONAL 7 QAMMARtDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
STATE 9 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
UNDANE NATIONAL 10 ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
MERCURY NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 5 DAPHNIDAE
OAMMARIOAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
M NICKEL NATIONAL 16 OAPHNIOAE
EPHEMERELUOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 8 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PCBS NATIONAL 5 SALMONIOAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 2 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10 HYALELUDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINOOONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE 8 HYALELUDAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHYSIDAE
$ SILVER NATIONAL 9 DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
STATE 8 DAPHNIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
COTTIDAE
SALMONIOAE
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12 PERUDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
STATE 10 PERUDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
ICTALURIDAE '
* * — STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
t - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
U - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
80 VALUE
(*)
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.847
0.440
0.488
0.403
0.775
0.995
1.800
2.800
7.800
1.100
2.800
26.000
29.000
1.161
4.020
80.062
358.792
4.020
80.082
45S.015
803.845
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.871
21.988
42.198
48.000
84.000
6.000
10.000
31.823
244.269
5.000
10,000
244.259
783.471
65.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
65.077
401.217
439.825
444.717
2.000
6.011
32.801
9B.S53
2.000
WOO
0.000
0.000
339.999
1992.474
8498.978
4476.723
338.999
1992.474
8479.723
240W883
0.002
0.004
0.008
0.012
0002
0.004
0.004
0.021
1.300
2.827
3.547
4.725
1.300
2.300
2.848
3.000
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
(•»)
0.201 *
0.165 *
0.251 *
0.112 *
0.037 *
0.219 *
3.218 *
8.282 *
0.470 *
0.101 *
32.914 *
20.057 *
0.137 *
0.137 *
**
82.648 *
28.803 *
0.00053 *
0.00026 *
0.537 *
0.554 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (++)
0.0023 FRV
00023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00002 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.8625 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.0674 ACR
3.3931 ACR
2.0677 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACR
78941 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0090 ACR
D-67
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: WASHINGTON
STATE: WEST VIRGINIA
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LOW VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE TOXICANT
<*> <+> (+) <++)
ZINC NATIONAL IS DAPHNIDAE 13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV ALDRIN
PHYSIDAE 41.968
SALWONIDAE 48.861
PHILODINIDAE 82.757
STATE 9 DAPHNIDAE 13.737 2.952 47.0000 SCV
SALMONIDAE 47.229
PHILODINIDAE 82.757
GAMMARIDAE 315,021
ARSENIC
« CADMIUM
CHLOHDANE
*
CHROMIUM
t COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
DIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
NATIONAL 14 CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
STATE S SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ANQUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NATIONAL 8 QAUMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMARIOAE
PHYSIDAE
NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPftlNIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
STATE 3 CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
NATIONAL 10 OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 5 PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRON OMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 17 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
STATE S SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
E80CIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
STATE 6 DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIOAE
8CIAENIDAE
NATIONAL 1! POECILIIDAE
ASELUDAE
SALMONIOAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 4 SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE t SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
FOOTNOTE * — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
. - UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER ** - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
> « _ FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE S - HARDNESS EFFEC
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION
OCR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD (S - HARDNESS EFFEC
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION
T INTERCEPT VALUE
3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
T INTERCEPT VALUE
9.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
oa SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
SO VALUE
<+)
7.491
«.000
9.000
tO.803
4403
7.451
18.000
16.392
878.990
1794.245
14128.8+3
18487.430
1048.139
14128.143
18487.430
19484.938
0.048
0.498
1.147
2.890
0.034
0.884
1.147
2.880
8.325
18.000
23.238
32.249
23.236
33.882
S4.711
0.000
57.000
8399.978
8998.790
24892.826
6996.790
24342.828
57481.872
83804.148
0.308
0.759
0.998
1445
0.250
0.760
0.995
1.345
78.707
83.000
114.318
128.121
78.707
83.000
114.318
207.958
1.323
1.596
1.700
3.234
0.976
3.904
7.840
10.000
4,503
8.000
6.452
8.000
2.459
10.811
30.102
231.052
0.864
1.279
2.300
3.240
0.684
1.279
3.240
3*11
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
( + )
3.388 *
1.144 *
113.283 *
171.493 *
0.027
0,011
1.974 *
1.974 *
**
12.164
1352.297 *
0.194
0.133
31.429 *
20.508 *
0.650
0.210 *
1.830 *
0.105 *
0.206 *
0.137 *
30-DAY AVERAGE
(+) (++I
0.0004 ACR
0.0001 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.48618 FCV
9.42403 FCV
4.2472 ACR
2.7713 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.0701 ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: WEST VIRGINIA
STATE: WEST VIRGINIA
TOXICANT
ENDHIN
HEPTACHLOH
t LEAD
LINDANE
MERCURY
NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
17
6
10
4
7
4
10
5
9
6
18
11
5
4
10
7
»
5
12
6
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC60 VALUE
CASTEROSTEIDAE 0.440
SALMONIDAE 0.468
PERLIDAE 0.493
PTERONARCIDAE 0.647
SALMONIDAE 0.556
CYPRINIDAE 0.732
CENTRARCHIDAE 1.011
COENAQRIONIDAE(AQRIONIDAE) 1.800
PTEHONARCIDAE 0.995
PALAEMONIDAE 1.800
PERLIDAE 2.800
ASTACIDAE 7.800
SALMONIDAE 13.058
CENTRARCHIDAE 26.000
OAPHNIDAE 50.748
CYPRINIDAE 179.506
QAMMARIDAE 1.161
DAPHNIDAE 4.020
SALMONIDAE 80.062
CYPRINIDAE 368.792
SALMONIDAE 60.062
CYPRINIDAE 358.792
CENTRARCHIDAE 455.015
PHILODINIDAE 803.645
ASELLIDAE 10.000
SALMONIDAE 21.988
QAMMARIDAE 22.437
CENTHARCHIDA6 62.871
SALMONIDAE 14.158
CENTRARCHIDAE 42.198
ICTALURIDAE 53.066
CYPRINIDAE 94.805
DAPHNIDAE 5.000
QAMMARIDAE 10.000
ASTACIDAE 31.623
SALMONIDAE 244.259
QAMMARIDAE 10.000
ASTACIDAE 60.000
SALMONIDAE 248.595
PHILODINIDAE 783.471
DAPHNIDAE 68.077
EPHEMERELLIDAE 233.555
CENTRARCHIDAE 345.472
PHILODINIDAE 401.217
DAPHNIDAE 78.458
CENTRARCHIDAE 325.842
PHILODINIDAE 401.217
CHIRONOMIDAE 439.825
SALMONIDAE 2.000
CENTRARCHIDAE 8.611
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
GAMMARIDAE 99.553
SALMONIDAE 2.000
CEOTRARCHIDAE 2.300
CYPRINIDAE 32.601
COENAQRIONIDAEIAQRIONIDAE) 282.842
HYALELLIOAEITAUTRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 1992.474
CYPRINODONTIDAE 6499.979
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
HYALELLIDAE(TALITRIDAE) 339.999
DAPHNIDAE 3869.889
SALMONIDAE 8479.723
CYPRINIDAE 9002.438
DAPHNIDAE 0.002
COTTIDAE 0.004
CYPRINIDAE 0.006
CYPRINODONTIDAE 0.012
COTTIDAE 0.004
CYPRINIDAE 0.011
SALMONIDAE 0.021
CENTRARCHIDAE 0.112
PEP.LIDAE 1.300
PTERONARCIDAE 2.627
ICTALURIDAE 3.547
CENTRAHCHIOAE 4.725
CENTRARCHIDAE 2.848
ICTALURIDAE 3.547
SALMONIDAE 6.678
CYPRINIDAE 8.033
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
0.201 *
0.153 *
0.251 *
1.425 *
0.037 *
14.969 *
3.218 *
3.346 *
0.470 *
0.764 *
32.914 it
31.086 *
0.137 *
0.024 *
82.648 *
62.601 *
0.00053 *
0.00035 *
0.537 *
0.812 it
30-DAY AVERAQE
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00004 FCV
0.2574 ACR
0.2676 ACR
0.20 FHV
0.20 FRV
3.3931 ACR
3.2047 ACR
0.014 FHV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACR
16.7469 ACR
0.0067 ACR
0.0132 ACR
f
FOOTNOTE
* — UNITS IN MICROQRAMS PER LITER
. , -FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDU
t VALUE
ACR COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC50 VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAQE
$ ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 11 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
• * - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
t - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
U - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV
41.866
48.881
92.757
21.223 7.606 * 47.0000 SCV
41.966
48.550
92.757
0-69
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: WISCONSIN
TOXICANT
ALDRIN
ARSENIC
JS CADMIUM
CHLOROANE
CHROMIUM
S COPPER
CYANIDE
DDT
OIELDRIN
ENDOSULFAN
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
14
8
8
6
18
13
8
5
10
8
23
19
10
7
20
12
12
6
9
6
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCSO VALUE
( + )
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
EPHEMERELLIOAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRA RCHIDAi
SALMONIDAE
ANGUILLIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARtDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIOAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERCIDAC
DAPHNIDAE
PEflCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
GAMMARfDAE
ASTACIDAE
POEC1LIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRtNIDAE
PTERONARCJDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIOAE
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
7.451
10.603
16.000
16.392
678.999
1794.245
14128.643
16487.430
878,999
1046.139
14128.643
16487.430
0.048
0.496
1 147
2,860
0.048
0.864
1.147
1.630
6.325
15.000
23.238
32249
6.325
23.238
32.249
43.739
67.000
8399.976
6996,790
24892.828
67.000
6998.790
24802828
57461.672
0.305
0.759
0.995
1 345
0.256
0.759
0.995
1.339
76.707
83000
114.316
125.121
76.707
83.000
114.318
125.121
1.323
1,595
1.700
2.234
0.976
1.595
2.234
3.000
4.503
5.000
6.452
8.000
5.462
10.811
20.000
30.102
0.664
1.27B
2.300
3.240
0.664
1.279
3.240
3.811
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
3.388 *
2844 *
113.263 *
56.980 *
0.027 0.0004 ACR
0.019 0.0003 ACR
1.974 * 0.0043 FRV
1.511 * 0.0043 FRV
12.184 0.3378 ACR
3.407 * 0.0946 ACR
0.194 5.46616 FCV
0.145 4.79332 FCV
31.429 * 4.2472 ACR
29.583 * 3.9977 ACR
0.650 0.0010 FRV
0.397 * 0.0010 FRV
1.830 * 0.0019 FRV
1.335 * 0.0019 FRV
0.208 * 0.1084 ACR
0.149 * 0.0762 ACR
FOOTNOTE
» — UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
+ * —
FPV FINAL PLANT
FRV FINAL RESIDL
ACR COMPUTED B
FCV FINAL CHRON
VALUE
E VALUE
Y ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD
1C VALUE
_ ,„ SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: WISCONSIN
NUMBER OF
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED
ENDRIN NATIONAL 17
STATE B
HEPTACHLOR NATIONAL 10
STATE 6
$1 LEAD NATIONAL 7
STATE 5
LINDANE NATIONAL 10
STATE 8
MERCURY NATIONAL 9
STATE 7
U NICKEL NATIONAL 16
STATE 13
PCBS NATIONAL 5
STATE S
SELENIUM NATIONAL 10
STATE 7
I SILVER NATIONAL B
STATE «
TOXAPHENE NATIONAL 12
STATE 9
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LC50VALUE
t*)
GASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIOAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PALAEMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMAfiiDAE
OAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
OAMMABIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
GAMMAfllDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
NAIDtOAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTHABCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE.
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
KYALELLIOAE (TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIOAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITHIDAB
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CEMTHAHCHIDAE
CEMTRARCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
t « _ STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES— NATIONAL VALUE USED
t - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIH
SJ - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3,7 TO DETERMINE MAX*
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
UM CRITERIA
UMANO
0.440
0.468
0.493
0.647
0.625
0.732
1.011
1.265
0.995
1.800
2.800
7 .BOO
1.800
26.000
29.498
37.048
1.161
4.020
80.062
358.792
1.161
80.062
358,792
495.016
10.000
21.988
22.437
52.871
21.988
22.437
42.198
53.066
5.000
10.000
31.623
244.258
10.000
244.259
783.471
SM.M6
85.077
233.555
345.472
401.217
76.458
233.555
345.472
401.217
2.000
6.611
32.601
99.553
2.000
2.300
32.601
99.553
339.9M
1992.474
6499.979
8479.723
339.999
3889.988
8479.723
9002.438
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.004
0.011
0.021
0.112
1.300
2.627
3.547
4.725
2.848
3.547
8.781
8.033
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
<+) < + ) (++)
0.201 *
0.231 *
0.25t *
0.331 *
0.037 *
0.054 it
3.218 *
6.601 *
0.470 t
1.222 *
32.914 *
33.860 *
0.137 *
0.063 *
82.648 *
62.801 *
0.00053 *
0,00041 *
0.537 *
0.943 *
0.0023 FRV
0.0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.0038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0.00004 FCV
0.2874 ACR
0.5281 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.20 FHV
3.3931 ACR
3.4908 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACR
16.7469 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0153 ACR
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOB FRESHWATER AQUATtC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
TATE: WISCONSIN STATE: WYOMING
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LOW VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAQE TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LC
(+) <+) (+) «•+!
ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIDAE 13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV ALDRIN NATIONAL 14 CENTRAHCHIDAE
PHYSIDA6 41.968 ASSUIDAE
SALMONIDAE 46.661 EPHEMEHELLIDA6
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 SALMONIDAE
STATE 12 DAPHNIDAE 21.223 7.891 47.0000 SCV STATE 8 SALMONIOAE
PHYSIDAE 41.866 CENTHARCHIOAE
SALMONIDAE 44.947 EPHEMERELLIDAE
PHILODINIDAE 92.757 CYPRINIDAE
ARSENIC NATIONAL 8 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
STATE 8 DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
Si CADMIUM NATIONAL 18 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 12 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CHLORDANE NATIONAL 8 PALAEMONIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
OAMMARIDAE
STATE 6 PTERONARCIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CHROMIUM NATIONAL 10 QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
STATE 8 DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
PHYSIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
$ COPPER NATIONAL 23 DAPHNIDAE
CKIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
STATE 13 DAPHNIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
PHYSIDAE
TUBIFICIDAE
CYANIDE NATIONAL 10 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PEBCIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
CENTHAHCHIDAE
PERCIDAE
DDT NATIONAL 20 DAPHNIDAE
PERCIDAE
ESOCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PEFCIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
DIELQHIN NATIONAL 12 POEC1LIIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
STATE 6 SALMONIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERU DAE
ENDOSULFAN NATIONAL 9 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
STATE 8 SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CATOSTOMIDAE
FOOTNOTE ~~~ • — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
" _ UNITS IH MICR06BAMS PER LITER ** - STATE HAS LESS THAN « RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
t . FPV FINAL PLANT VALUE * - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FRV FINAL RESIDUE VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITSRIA
ACB COMPUTED BY ACUTE TO CHRONIC RATIO METHOD tt - HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
FCV FINAL CHRONIC VALUE APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
SCV SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE 80-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
SO VALUE
1+)
7.451
8.000
9.000
10.803
4.503
7.451
9.000
16.392
876.969
1794.245
14128.843
10487.430
1794.245
14128.643
18487.430
19484.938
0.048
0.496
1.147
2.880
0.034
0.496
1.147
2.860
8.325
15.000
23.238
32.249
15.000
23.238
26.000
33.862
«7.000
6398976
6958,760
24882.828
8399.976
6998.790
24892.828
07461.672
0.305
0.759
0.995
1.345
0.305
0.769
0.995
1.345
76.707
S3. 000
114.316
125.121
76.707
83.000
114.316
125.121
1.023
1.505
1.700
2.234
1.323
1.595
3.000
3,282
4.603
5.000
6.452
8000
2.459
8.000
10.811
94.000
0.684
1.278
2.300
3.240
0.664
1.279
2.300
3.240
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM
{+>
3.388 *
V433 *
113.263 «
407.358 *
0.027
0.009
t.974 *
5.588 *
12.184
781.038 *
0.194
0.132
31.429 *
28.920 «
0.650
0.463 *
1.830 *
0.632 *
0.208 *
0.196 *
JO-DAY AVERAQE
1+) (++)
0.0004 ACR
0.0001 ACR
0.0043 FRV
0.0043 FRV
"
0.3378 ACR
10.0 FPV
5.46618 FCV
9.85862 FCV
4.2472 ACR
3.8081 ACR
0.0010 FRV
0.0010 FHV
0.0019 FRV
0.0019 FRV
0.1064 ACR
0.1003 ACR
D-71
-------
APPENDIX D
TOXICITY DATA FOR FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA, BY STATE
STATE: WYOMING
TOXICANT
ENDRIN
HEPTACHLOR
Ji LEAD
LINDANG
MERCURY
It NICKEL
PCBS
SELENIUM
i SILVER
TOXAPHENE
NUMBER OF
FAMILIES TESTED
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
NATIONAL
STATE
17
9
10
7
7
5
10
8
9
5
16
9
5
3
10
7
9
6
12
10
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY
NAME LCBO VALUE
QASTEROSTEIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PEHLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
SALMQNIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTftARCHIDAE
PTERONARCIOAE
PALAEMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
ASTACIDAE
PTERONAHCIDAE
PERLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPHINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
ASELLIDAE
SALMONIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
QAMMARIDAE
ICTALUHIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
QAMMAHIDAE
ASTACIDAE
SALMONIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
EPHEMERELLIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
CHIRONOMIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIOAE
GAMMARIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
HYALELLIDAE (TALITRIDAE)
0APHNIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
SALMONIDAE
HYALELUOAE {TALITRIDAE)
DAPHNIDAE
SALMONIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIDAE
CYPRINIDAE
CYPRINODONTIDAE
DAPHNIDAE
COTTIOAE
CYPRINIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
CENTRARCHIDAE
PERLIDAE
PTERONARCIDAE
CENTRAHCHIDAE
ICTALURIDAE
<-M
0.440
0.488
0.493
0.647
0.357
0.493
0.647
1.011
0.995
1.800
2.800
7800
0.995
2.800
13.058
28.000
1.161
4.020
80.062
3BB.792
4.020
80.082
358.792
455.015
fO.OOO
21.983
22.437
52.671
14.158
42.198
48,000
53.088
5.000
10.000
31.923
244,259
5.000
10.000
348.595
783,471
85,077
33355,5
345.472
401.217
85.077
401,217
439.825
444.717
2000
6.611
32 SOI
99.553
2.000
2,300
32,601
0.000
339,999
1992474
6499.979
8479,723
339.999
1992.474
8479.723
9002436
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.012
0.002
0,004
0.006
0.021
1.300
2.827
3.547
4.725
1.300
2.627
2848
3.547
FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAQE
(+)
0.201 »
0.125 *
0.251 *
0.125 *
0.037 »
0.287 *
3.218 *
5.119 *
0.470 »
0.101 *
32.914- »
S1.717 *
0.137 *
0.137 t
**
62.648 *
52431 *
0.00053 *
0.00030 *
0.537 *
0,543 *
(*) (++)
0.0023 FBV
0,0023 FRV
0.0038 FRV
00038 FRV
0.00003 FCV
0,00003 FCV
fl.2574 ACfl
04095 ACR
0.20 FRV
0.0671 ACR
3.3931 ACR
5.2388 ACR
0.014 FRV
0.014 FRV
22.0395 ACR
13.9416 ACR
0.0087 ACR
0.0088 ACR
FOOTNOTE
t — UNITS IN MICROGRAMS PER LITER
3-72
t « — FPV
FHV
ACR
FCV
SCV
FINAL PLANT
FINAL RESICHJ
COMPUTED B
FINAL CHRON
VALUE
E VALUE
t ACUTE TO CHBC
1C VALUE
)NIC RATIO METHOD
SENSITIVE SPECIES CHRONIC VALUE
STATE: WYOMING
NUMBER OF MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILY FRESHWATER AQUATIC LIFE CRITERIA
TOXICANT FAMILIES TESTED NAME LCSO VALUE MAXIMUM 30-DAY AVERAGE
$ ZINC NATIONAL 15 DAPHNIOAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
STATE 10 DAPHNIDAE
PHYSIDAE
SALMONIDAE
PHILODINIDAE
* — FAILED TO MEET MINIMUM DATA REQUIREMENT
* « - STATE HAS LESS THAN 4 RESIDENT FAMILIES-NATIONAL VALUE USED
1 { _ HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM CRITERIA
U — HARDNESS EFFECT INTERCEPT VALUE
APPLY EQUATION 3.7 TO DETERMINE MAXIMUM AND
30-DAY AVERAGE CRITERIA
«•) <+) < + > (++>
13.737 6.148 47.0000 SCV
41.988
48.861
92.757
13.737 4.847 + 47.0000 SCV
41.966
49.969
•2.757
-------
APPENDIX E
RECALCULATION RESULTS
ALDRIN
A B
T
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
e
9
10
n
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
26
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
IRSENIC
A B
IT TT
12 1
12 2
12 3
12 4
12 5
12 6
12 7
12 8
12 9
12 10
12 11
(2 12
2 13
12 14
2 15
2 16
2 17
2 16
2 19
2 20
2 21
2 22
2 23
2 24
2 25
2 26
2 27
2 28
2 29
2 30
2 31
C
TT
B
9
9
9
9
9
10
10
e
9
g
B
e
8
7
6
5
7
7
7
8
9
e
7
g
10
7
7
A
6
7
e
8
e
5
8
7
8
8
e
a
9
10
8
B
e
g
c
T
3
4
4
5
4
4
6
5
5
9
4
4
4
4
5
5
5
g
e
5
9
g
g
5
8
g
5
5
4
5
4
D
6.77544
8.62517
3.53950
3.53950
3.03909
3.03909
3.03909
3.6S814
3.18941
3.59180
3.59180
5.49744
3,03909
3.59180
3.47503
3.52505
5.36018
226722
3.54744
2.80346
2.60346
2.73738
5.53449
5.65470
4.78954
568878
848080
3.04911
5.54667
5 10268
06192
5.29145
2.18099
2.7373B
2.66557
4.90740
2.93943
5.29145
5.27613
2.86675
2.86675
3 85605
3.33624
3.74818
3.85609
6.48464
6.67460
3.47503
6 76577
0
225.52565
0.00000
296.18365
296.1836S
342.98863
283.23920
283.23920
113.95972
342.98663
342.98863'
343.63538
283.23920
263.23920
264.68555
264.68555
342:98863
312.07068
342.98663
116.20842
116.20642
34363538
342.98663
113.95972
343 63538
84 75481
11345972
11620842
34246663
64.75481
280.98602
84.75481
280.98602
E F
00000070 4824293B
00000078 29 40 37 47
00000078 384829 40
00000076 384829 40
0000007 384829 37
0000007 384829 37
0000007 38 48 29 37
0000007 384829 37
0000007 384829 37
0000007 38 48 29 40
0000007 38482940
0000007 48293637
0000007 384629 37
0000007 38 48 29 40
0000507 384829 40
0000507 364829 47
1000967 48 47 40 37
0000567 3848 37 40
0000067 38 48 24 47
0000067 36 48 47 37
00000 7 38 48 47 37
00000 7 38 48 37 40
00000 7 482938 37
00000 7 48 47 38 37
10000 7 48 24 47 37
00000 7 48 38 37 40
00000 7 48 24 47 38
00000 7 38 48 37 40
10000 7 48 37 40 44
10000 7 48 47 37 40
10000 7 48 24 37 40
00000 7 48 47 37 40
00000 7 38 48 40 44
00000 7 3848 37 40
00005 7 38 48 47 37
10005 7 48 47 37 40
00000 7 3848 47 37
10000 7 48 47 37 40
00000070 48293840
00000070 38482940
00000070 38462940
00000070 38 48 29 47
00000070 38482940
00000070 38 46 29 47
00000070 384829 47
00000070 482938 40
00000070 48 29 47 38
00000070 38482940
00000070 .46 29 47 38
E f
00305 7 1938400
00005 7 19 38 40 48
00005 7 19384048
00005 7 19 38 42 48
00005 7 19364840
00005 7 19364840
00000 7 25 19 38 42
00005 7 19 38 42 48
00009 7 19 38 42 48
00005 7 19 38 42 48
00005 7 19364840
00009 7 19384640
00005 7 19384840
00005 7 19384840
00005 7 19 38 42 48
10005 7 19 42 48 40
00005 7 19 36 4J 48
00000 7 29 19 38 42
00000 7 25 19 38 42
00005 7 19 38 42 48
00009 7 19 38 42 48
00000 7 25 19 38 42
00005 7 19 38 42 46
10000 7 29 It 42 48
00000 7 25 19 38 42
00000 7 29 19 38 42
00009 7 19 38 42 48
10000 7 25 19 42 48
10005 7 19424840
10000 78 25 19 42 48
10005 78 19424840
a
7.45060 7.99B99
8.99999 11.73188
4.50313 7.45060
4.50313 7.45060
4.50313 7.45080
4.50313 7.45060
4.50313 7.45060
5.24109 7.45060
4.50313 7.45060
4.50313 7.45090
4.50313 7.45060
7.45080 8.99899
4,50313 7.45060
4.50313 7.45080
4.50313 7.45060
7JS080 9^99999
4.50313 7.45060
4.50313 7.45060
4.50313 7.45080
4.90313 7.45080
4.90313 7.49080
7.49060 8.99999
7.45060 9.99999
7.45060 7.99999
7.45060 10.80319
7.45080 7.99999
5.24109 7.49060
7.45080 15.99998
7.45060 9.99999
7.45060 7.99999
7.45060 9.99999
4.50313 7.45060
4.50313 7.45060
4.50313 7.45060
7.45060 9.99999
4.50313 7.45060
7.45080 9.99999
7.49060 8.99999
4.50313 7.45060
4.50313 7.45060
4 50313 7.45060
5.24109 7.45080
4.90313 7.49080
4.50313 7.45060
7.45080 8.99999
7.45060 8.99999
4.50313 7.45060
7.45060 8.99999
a
878.99878 1794.24536
1046.13916 14963.951
1046.13916 14128.844
1048.13916 14128.844
1048.13916 14128.844
1046.13916 14128.644
1046.13916 14128.644
878.99878 1048.13916
1048.13916 14128.844
1046.13916 14128.844
1048.13916 13339.966
1048.13916 14128.844
1048.13916 14128.844
1048.13916 14128.844
1048.13916 14128.844
1046.13916 14128.844
1046.13916 16487.433
1046.13916 14128.644
878.9*878 1046.13916
878.99878 1046.13916
1048.13916 13339.966
1048.13916 14128.844
678.99878 1046.13916
1046.13916 13339.966
878.99878 1046.13916
878.99878 1046.13916
678.99878 1046.13916
1046.13916 14128.644
678.99878 1046.13916
1046.13916 16487.433
878.99878 1048.13916
1046.13916 16487.433
COLUMN KEY:
A CHEMICAL ID
B. STATE ID
C. NO. OF RESIDENT FAMIUE
D. FINAL ACUTE VALUE (FAV)
8.99999
15.99998
8.99999
8.99999
8.99999
8.99999
8.99999
8.99999
8.99999
8.99999
8.99999
14.37683
6,99999
8.99999
8.99999
1V31370
15.99996
7.99999
9.99999
9.99999
15.99998
10.80319
10.80319
9.99999
15.99998
9.99999
15.99998
16.39186
15.99998
15.99998
15.99998
16.39186
15.99998
9.99999
15.99996
9.99999
15.99098
14.37683
8.99999
8.99999
8.99999
8.99999
8.99999
8.99999
10.60319
9.99999
8.99999
9.99999
14128.644
15659.937
15659.937
15659.937
16487.433
19464.941
19484.941
14128.644
16487.433
16487.433
16467.433
19484.941
19484.941
19484.941
19484.941
16487.433
19484.941
16487.433
13339.988
13339.986
16487.433
16487.433
14128.644
16467.433
18487.433
14128.644
13339.996
16487.433
16487.433
19484.941
18487.4J3
19484.941
S
10.80319
20.49368
11.73188
11.73188
15.99998
15.99998
15 99998
15!99998
15.99998
11.31370
11.31370
15.99998
15,63998
11.31370
11.31370
15!99998
16.39188
9.99999
15.99998
15.99998
16.39188
15.99998
15.99998
15.99998
16.39186
10.80319
16.39186
20.99998
16.39186
16.39186
16.39186
20.99998
16.39186
15.99998
16.39166
15.99998
16.39186
16.39186
16.39186
16.39186
16J9186
9.99999
9.99999
11.31370
10.80319
11.31370
10.80319
16487.433
0.00000
19484.941
19484.941
19484.941
20194.366
20194.386
18487.433
19484.941
19484.941
19484.941
20184.386
20194.386
26041.878
26041.878
19484.941
26041.878
194B4.941
16487.433
18487.433
19484.941
19484.941
16487.433
19484.941
19484.941
18487.433
16487.433
19484.941
19484.941
20194.386
19484.941
20194.388
E. EIGHT
f. FOUR
0. FAMIL
ARSENIC (ConllniMd)
A B C D E F
12 33 5 727.20286 00005 78 19 38 42 48
12 34 5 726.89221 00005 78 19 38 42 48
12 35 280.98602 10005 78 19424840
12 36 116.20842 00000 78 25193842
12 37 280.98802 10005 78 19 42 48 40
12 39 814.71533 00005076 19384248
12 40 814.52979 00005078 19 38 42 48
12 41 814.71533 00005078 19 38 42 48
12 42 701.91382 00005078 19384840
12 43 814.71933 00005078 IB 38 42 48
12 44 614.71533 00005076 19 36 42 48
12 45 667.69226 00005076 19 38 48 32
12 46 573.39660 00005678 19364840
12 48 5 726.89221 00005678 19 36 42 48
CADMIUM
A B C D E F
13 0 18 0.05331 00000000 38 19 25 16
13 1 16 0.02957 00000000 38192544
13 2 19 0.03361 00000000 38 19 25 44
13 3 15 0.0336) 00000000 38192S44
13 5 16 0.03766 00000000 38 19 25 44
13 6 16 0.03768 00000000 38 19 25 44
13 7 17 0.05738 00000000 38192544
13 9 17 0.04210 00000000 38 19 25 44
13 10 17 0.05323 00000000 38192544
13 11 17 0.04210 00000000 38 19 25 44
13 12 15 0.03361 00000000 38192544
13 13 16 0.03768 00000000 38192544
13 14 16 0.03159 00005000 38 19 44 16
13 15 14 0.01678 00005000 36 47 19 16
13 16 13 0.09204 10005000 47 19 16 7
13 17 12 0.02102 00000000 38 10 25 16
13 18 14 0.02895 00000000 38 47 19 25
13 19 14 0.02696 00000000 36 47 19 25
13 21 14 0.02986 00000000 38 18 25 44
13 22 15 0.04877 00000000 3B192944
13 23 14 0.03744 00000000 38 47 19 25
13 24 13 0.11793 '10000000 47 19 25 16
13 25 13 0.03761 00000000 36192544
13 26 15 0.04099 00000000 38 47 19 25
13 28 13 0.63411 10000000 19 25 44 16
13 29 13 0.11793 10000000 47 19 25 16
13 30 12 0.42257 10000000 19 25 16 7
13 31 12 0.06204 10005000 47 19 16 7
13 32 12 0.02832 00000000 38192544
13 33 13 0X13178 00000000 38 19 25 44
13 34 12 0.01266 00005000 38 47 19 16
13 35 12 0.08204 10005000 47 19 16 7
13 36 14 0.02695 00000000 36 47 19 25
13 37 12 0.06204 10006000 47 19 18 7
13 38 12 0.01899 00*000000 38 19 25 16
13 39 12 0.01899 00000000 38 19 25 16
13 40 12 0.02467 00000000 38 19 25 16
13 42 12 042882 00000000 38 19 25 16
13 43 12 0.01797 00000000 38 47 19 29
13 44 13 0.02000 00000000 38 47 19 25
13 45 12 0.02882 00000000 38 19 25 16
13 46 13 0.02729 00000000 38 47 19 25
13 47 12 0.01899 00000000 SB 19 25 16
13 48 14 0.02999 00000000 36 47 19 25
CHLORDANE
* I ? o * f
2 1 3 0.00000 00340 7 4025380
224 6.22810 00040 40293848
2 4 6.54425 00040 40253848
2 4 15.34912 00040 40382548
2 4 19.34912 00040 40382548
2 4 1944912 00040 40382548
2 8 3.11714 00040 2740293*
2 5 3.09937 00040 27403825
2 4 9.13705 00040 40 38 25 48
2 10 4 6.24052 00040 '40382548
CRITERIA (A NUMBER SIGNIFIES A CRITERIA NOT SATISFIED)
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILIES
Y MEAN ACUTE VALUE FOR FOUR MOST SENSITIVE SPECIES
1794.24536
1794.24538
1794.24538
1046.13918
878.99878
1046.13916
1794.24538
1794.24536
1794.24536
1794.24536
1794.24538
1794.24538
1794.24538
1794.24536
1794.24536
1794 24536
1794i24538
0.04761
0.02644
0.03407
0.03407
003107
043407
0.03407
0.04761
003407
0.03407
0.04389
0.03407
0.03407
0.03407
0.03407
0.03407
0.18279
0.03407
0.04389
0.04389
043407
0.04761
0.08389
0.16279
0.04761
0.06389
004761
046438
0.16279
0.86438
0.16279
0.04389
0.04389
0.03407
0.16279
0.04389
0.16279
0.03407
0.03407
0.04389
0.03407
0.04761
0.03407
0.03407
0.04761
0.04761
0.03407
0.04761
6.32456
12.37093
1S.370B3
12.37093
23,23838
23^3838
23.23838
- 6.32459
6.32455
15.68437
15.68437
0
13339.966
13339.966
14128.644
16487.433
1046.13916
18487.433
1412B.644
14126444
13339.966
14128.644
14128.644
44128.644
14126.644
14128.644
14128.644
14128444
a
0.49564
0.86438
0.86438
0.86436
046438
0.88438
0.86438
0 86438
046438
0.86438
0.86438
0.86438
0.86438
0.66438
0.16279
0.86438
0.86438
0.16279
0.16279
049438
0.86438
0.16279
0.86438
0.88438
0.16279
088436
V14678
0.86438
1.14678
0.86436
0.4B584
0.49584
0.16279
046438
0.16279
0.86438
0.49584
0.49584
0.49584
0.16279
0.49584
0.16279
0.16279
0.49584
0.16279
0.49584
0.16279
..Q
U.M9B6
26.99997
28.99997
32.24899
33.86196
33.86198
33.86198
23.23838
23.23838
33.88198
25,48079
16487.433
16487.433
16487.433
19484.941
13339.966
19484.941
16487.433
16487.433
16467.433
16487.433
19484.941
18487.433
16487.433
19484.941
19484.941 '
16487.433
16487.433
1.14678
1.14678
1.14678
1.14678
1.14678
1.14678
1.14878
l!l4678
1.14678
1.14678
1.14678
1.14678
1.63031
0.66438
2.88002
1.14678
0.88438
0.89438
M4678
1.14678
0.88438
1. 14676
1.14678
0.86438
1 14678
V63031
1.14678
2.86002
246002
U4678
0.49564
246002
0.86438
2.86002
1.14678
1.14678
1.14678
0.49564
1.14678
0.49584
0,49964
1.14678
0.49564
1.14678
0.49564
23^3B3fi
50.19954
3345198
3341198
39.99995
sgiggoos
32.24899
33.88198
39.99999
39.99995
19484.941
19484.941
19484.941
20194.386
16487.433
20194.389
19484.941
19484.941
19484.941
19484.941
20194.386
19484.941
19484.941
22039.906
26041.878
19484.941
19484.941
2.86002
1.83031
1.63031
1.63031
143031
1.63031
1.83031
1.63031
1.63031
1.83031
1.83031
1.83031
1.83031
2.86002
2.86002
6.98878
2.86002
1.14678
1.14678
143031
1.83031
1.14678
246002
1.63031
1.14678
1 83031
248002
2.86002
6.98678
6.98676
1.63031
1.63031
2.86002
6.98678
1.14678
6.96678
2.86002
248002
2.86002
1.14678
2.86002
1.14678
1.14878
2.88002
1.14678
2.86002
1.14678
snoit
0.00000
54.71104
94.71104
54.71104
54.71104
64.71104
40.28093
39.99999
54.71104
54.71104
E-1
-------
APPENDIX E
RECALCULATION RESULTS
CHLORDANE (ConliiUMd)
A. B
2 11
2 12
2 13
2 14
2 15
2 16
2 17
2 18
2 19
2 20
2 21
2 22
2 23
2 24
2 25
2 26
2 27
2 2E
2 29
2 30
2 31
2 32
2 33
2 34
2 35
2 36
2 37
2 38
2 39
2 40
2 41
2 42
2 43
2 44
2 45
2 46
2 47
2 48
CHROMIU
fr 4
14 1
14 2
14 3
14 4
14 5
14 6
14 7
14 8
14 9
14 10
14 11
14 12
14 13
14 14
14 15
14 16
14 17
14 18
14 19
14 20
14 21
14 22
14 23
14 24
14 25
14 26
4 27
4 28
4 29
4 30
4 31
14 32
14 33
14 34
14 35
14 36
14 37
14 38
14 39
14 40
14 41
14 42
E-2
CD E F 0 8
00000608
CRITERIA NOT SAT
ES
IOST SENSITIVE SP
SFIED)
ECIES
F
19 7 47 40
8399.97559
19 7 45 47 8399.97959
19 7 47 38 6399.97559
19 7 45 38
19 7 45 47
F
S 36 16 9
9 35 16 9
9 39 16 9
9 39 16 9
9 35 16 9
9 35 16 9
9 35 16 9
19 35 16 9
19 35 16 9
19 36 16 9
19 36 16 38
19 35 16 9
19 35 16 9
19 35 16 9
19 35 16 9
19 35 16 9
19 35 18 9
19 39 16 9
19 3! 16 38
19 35 16 38
19 39 16 38
19 35 16 9
19 39 6 38
19 39 6 38
19 35 6 9
19 35 8 38
19 35 6 38
19 35 6 9
19 35 8 9
19 35 6 9
19 35 6 9
19 35 16 38
19 35 16 38
19 35 16 38
19 35 16 9
19 35 16 9
19 35 16 38
19 36 16 9
19 35 16 9
19 35 16 9
19 35 16 36
19 35 16 9
19 35 9 15
19 35 9 15
19 39 9 15
19 35 9 38
IB 35 S 38
19 35 9 15
19 35 9 38
F
38 19 48 49
19 48 38 49
38 19 48 49
38 19 48 49
38 19 48 49
38 19 48 49,
38 19 48 49
36 19 48 49
38 19 48 49
38 19 48 49
38 19 48 49
38 19 48 49
38 19 48 49
38 19 48 49
38 19 48 49
38 19 48 40
18 48 45 40
36 19 48 40
38 19 48 25
38 19 48 25
36 19 48 40
38 19 48 49
38 19 48 49
S399.97559
9399.97559
0.30611
0.25587
0.25567
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
025587
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
0.25567
0.25587
025567
0.25567
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
0.25587
0.30511
0.30511
030511
0.25587
0.25567
0.25687
0.30511
0.30511
0.30511
0.30511
0.3051
0.3061
0.3051
0.3051
0.3091
0.3091
0.3051
'WoW"
82.99980
76.70687
76.70667
76.70867
76.70667
76.70867
76.70667
76.70867
76.70887
96.99990
76.70667
76.70667
76.70867
76.70867
76.70867
82.99980
76.70B67
96.98990
96.99990
56.99990
76.70867
76.70967
a
699879004
6998.79004
6998^79004
699879004
6998.79004
a
0.75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.79873
0.79873
0.75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.79873
0.75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.7S873
0.75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.79873
0.76873
0.75873
0.75873
0.79673
0.75873
0.79873
0.7S873
0.75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.76873
0.78873
0.79873
0,75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.75873
0.75973
0.79873
0.79873
0.75873
. a
82.99986
10199974
82.99980
82.99960
82.99960
82.99980
82.99980
62.99960
82.99980
82.99980
82.99980
82.99960
82.99980
82.99980
82.99980
82.99980
114.31995
82.99980
82.99980
82.99980
82.99980
82.99980
82.99980
30454.793
29999.871
30454!753
29999.871
29999.871
0.99(28
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99628
0.99526
0.99528
0.99526
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99928
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99528
0.99S28
0.99926
0.99928
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
114.31555
103.22679
114.31555
114.31555
114.31555
114.31555
114.31555
11431555
114.31555
114.31555
114.31955
114.31955
114.31555
114.31959
114,31555
114.31555
306.48419
114.31555
114.3155S
114.31555
114.31555
114.31656
114.31555
57481.879
30454.753
63B04J56
63804.156
30454.753
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.02215
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.02215
1.02215
1.02215
1.34462
1.33946
1.04852
1.34462
1.33946
1.04892
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.23598
1.02215
1.02215
134462
1.34482
1.02215
1.34462
1.34462
1.34462
1.30928
1.34462
1.42372
1.42372
1.42372
1.40105
1.40109
1.42372
1.40105
125.12128"
125.12128
125,12128
125.12128
125.12128
125,12128
126.12128
125.12128
129.12128
125.12128
129.12128
125.12126
125.12128
125.12128
125.12128
317.99933
317.99933
207.95767
166.99973
166.99973
207.95767
129.12128
125.12128
-------
APPENDIX E
RECALCULATION RESULTS
CYANIDE (ConllniiMO DIELORIN
A_ B C D E F 0 ABCD
It 23 6 41.49266 0000560
11 25 7 59.16601 00000
11 26 8 44.30383 00000
11 27 8 60.43829 00005
11 28 8 68.49722 10000
11 29 5 32.25363 10005
11 30 6 55.17302 10000
11 31 5 32.25363 10005
11 32 6 41.49266 00005
11 33 6 41.49268 00005
11 35 8 54.34859 10005
11 38 8 38.81360 00000
1 37 7 53.34795 10005
1 38 6 57.64061 00005
1 39 6 57.84061 00005
1 40 8 30.91743 00000
1 41 7 59.16901 00005
1 42 6 57.64061 00005
11 44 6 5784061 00005
11 45 6 57.84061 00000
11 46 5 56.44991 00005
11 47 6 56.91640 00005
11 48 5 39.16408 00005
DDT
<\ ,P. .<= D E
8 0
8 0
0 0
0 0
6 0
8 0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
7
8 38 19 48 49 56.99990 82.89980 114.31555 125.12128 3 0
8 19 48 25 40 82.99980 114.31559 166.88973 207.9S767 3 1
8 38 18 48 49 76.70667 82.99880 114.31555 125.12128 3 2
8 38 19 48 49 56.89980 82.99980 114.31555 125.12128 3 3
8 38 19 46 49 76.70667 82.99980 114.31555 125.12128 3 4
8 19 48 49 25 82.89880 114.31555 129.12128 166.98973 3 9
8 19 48 40 16 62.99980 114.31555 207.85767 431.48868 3 e
8 19 48 25 40 82.98980 114.31555 166.89873 207.95767 3 7
8 19 46 40 16 82.99980 114.31555 207.85767 431.48866 3 8
8 38 19 46 49 58.89880 82.89980 114.31555 125.12128 3 s
6 38 19 48 49 56.89990 82.88980 114.31555 125.12128 3 10
8 38 19 48 49 76.70667 62.89980 114.31555 . 125.12128 3 "
8 18 48 48 40 82.99980 114.31555 125.12128 207.85767 3 12
8 38 18 46 25 56.89890 62.89980 114.31559 166.99873 3 13
8 18 48 49 40 62.89860 114.31555 125.12128 207.99767 . 3 "
8 38 19 48 49 76.70687 82.99980 114.31555 125.12128 3 15
8 36 19 48 49 76.70667 82.99980 114.31555 125.12128 3 16
3 38 19 48 40 56.99990 62.99980 114.31555 207.95767 3 "
8 38 19 48 49 76.70867 82.99880 114.31555 125.12128 3 18
8 38 19 48 49 76.70867 82.99880 114.31555 125.12128 3 19
78 38 19 48 49 78.70667 82.99980 114.31596 125.12128 3 21
78 38 19 48 49 78.70667 82.89980 114.31559 125.12128 3 22
78 36 19 48 49 76.70667 62.99880 114.31559 125.12128 3 23
78 38 18 48 49 76.70667 62.99880 121.02043 129.12126 3 2I
78 38 19 48 40 76.70667 82.99880 114.31555 207.85787 3 25
3 26
3 27
3 28
3 29
3 30
3 31
3 32
3 33
3 34
- „ S 35
0 20 1.30035 0000000
1 9 0.70761 0000007
2 6 0.04651 0000007
3 9 0.80229 0000007
4 11 0.74011 0000007
5 8 0.66248 0000007
6 7 0.63513 0000007
7 14 0.91121 0000007
9 12 0.92461 0000007
9 9 0.66869 0000007
10 9 0.68965 0000007
11 10 0.71450 0000007
13 9 0.68865 0 0 0 0 0 (
14 8 0.60945 0 0 0 0 0 C
15 7 0.49037 0 0 0 0 0 (
16 7 0.30026 10000
17 6 0.41916 00005
18 8 0.67512 00000
19 9 0.72705 00000
20 8 0.68885 00000
21 13 0.94208 00000
22 13 0.82091 00000
23 10 0.71450 00000
24 10 0.76862 10000
29 12 0.79341 00000
26 14 0.95824 00000
27 12 0.86858 00000
28 12 0.92461 00000
29 10 0.73268 00000
30 8 0.70942 00000
31 9 072705 00000
32 10 0.94438 00000
33 11 0.97022 00000
34 9 0.86411 00005
35 7 0,56598 10000
36 8 0.75472 00000
37 10 0.71393 10000
38 13 1.02084 000000
39 10 0.92966 000000
40 10 1.02085 000000
41 12 0.91832 000000
42 It 0.05851 000000
43 12 1.00663 000000
44 11 0.95851 000000
45 11 0.95851 000000
49 11 1.00195 000000
48 10 0.88312 000000
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7 <
7 (
7 (
7 (
7 (
7 (
7 (
7 (
7 <
7 C
0 19 48 39 25 1.32334 1.58948 1.70000 2.23432 •> 37
19 49 48 25 0.87585 1.58549 2.35604 3.00000 | M
19 49 25 46 0.97585 1.S9549 3.00000 3.00597 3 jg
19 49 39 25 0.97585 1,98949 1.70000 2.23432 3 4,,
19 49 25 29 0.07595 1.98949 1.66407 3.00000 3 Jj
19 48 25 28 0.87585 1.58549 1.66407 3.00000 3 42
19 49 25 48 0.97585 159549 1.66407 3.00557 J «
19 49 39 25 0.87585 159549 1.70000 2.23432 3 44
19 49 25 39 0.87595 1.59549 1.66407 1.70000 3 4!
19 48 25 29 0.97595 1,58549 1.66407 3.00000 3 4.
19 49 25 28 0.97595 168549 1.66407 3.00000 3 4?
19 49 25 28 0.87589 1.58549 _ 1.66407 3.00000 3 45
19 48 25 29 0.87589 1.68549 1.66407 3.09000
19 48 26 28 0.87985 1.50549 1.66407 3.00000
19 48 28 46 0.87595 1.58548 3.00000 347033
19 28 46 38 0.87585 3.00000 4.10227 8.15108 ENDOSULFAN
19 28 48 42 0.87585 3.00000 3.26261 17.08779 A B J
19 48 36 50 0.97595 3.80425 7.63988 9.89989 F ~S~ ~
19 28 24 48 0.97999 3.00000 4.00000 4.10227 S 1
19 28 27 48 0.97985 3.00000 3.23356 4.10227 5 2
19 28 27 48 0.97595 300000 3.23358 4.10227 S 3
19 49 25 39 0.97589 128548 1.66407 ' 1.70000 6 4
19 49 25 28 0.97585 158549 2.23432 3.00000 5 5
19 49 25 28 0.97585 158549 1.86407 3.00000 6 6
19 26 27 24 0.97589 3,00000 3.23356 4.00000 6 7
19 48 25 28 0.97589 1.98948 823432 3.00000 S 8
19 49 29 39 0.87586 1.58548 1.66407 1.70000 5 8
19 48 38 25 0.97585 1.58548 1.70000 2.23432 6 10
IB 48 25 39 0.97589 1.58549 1.66407 1.70000 9 11
19 38 28 27 0.87589 1.70000 2.40881 3.23356 5 12
19 28 27 24 0.97585 2.40681 323356 4.00000 5 13
19 28 27 46 0,97595 3.00000 3.23396 4.10227 5 14
19 49 39 25 1.32334 1.58548 1.70000 3.00000 6 19
19 49 39 a 1.32334 1.58549 1.70000 3.00000 9 18
19 49 38 46 1.32334 1.58549 1.70000 3.28203 5 17
19 48 28 48 0.97585 1.58548 2.40891 3.00425 5 18
19 28 25 27 0.97585 2.40891 3.00000 3.23356 5 19
11 48 28 27 0.97589 1.99548 2.40681 , 3.23356 5 20
> 19 48 38 25 1.32334 1.59648 1.70000 3.00000 5 21
19 48 29 46 1.32334 1.58548 3.00000 3.28203 8 22
1t 25 46 36 1.42334 3.00000 3.08946 447782 9 23
18 48 29 46 1.32334 1.58549 3.00000 4.10227 9 24
19 48 25 48 1.32334 1.58548 3.00000 326203 6 25
19 48 25 48 1.32334 14*548 3.00000 3.08846 6 26
19 48 25 48 1.32334 1.59548 3.00000 3.21203 6 27
19 49 25 48 1.32334 1.58548 3.00000 326203 5 28
19 49 32 25 1.32334 1.68548 1.80000 3.00000 6 29
19 49 32 29 1.32334 1.59548 1.00001 3.00000 6 30 4
19 25 48 36 1.32334 3.00000 3.28203 6.82063 5 31 3
2 3.65822 000 0
6 1.08757 000
6 1.09797 000
6 0.94178 000
6 0.84178 000
6 0.84178 000
7 2.15928 000
7 127308 000
6 0.76375 000
6 2.07374 000
6 0.83063 000
6 0.76375 000
5 047864 000
5 0.67864 000
4 0.50124 1 0 0
4 0.20962 000
5 0.97505 000
5 0.90408 000
5 0.90408 000
6 1.01111 000
7 3.11196 000
5 0.59408 000
6 2.22946 100
6 2.97050 000
7 2.23882 000
5 1.96336 100
S 1.96336 1 0 0
6 2.41439 1 0 0
5 5.13848 000
6 0.28670 000
6 0.97878 000
4 024227 000
4 047880 1 0 0
7 1.12210 000
B 2.13264 1 0 0
6 2.76136 000
E
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 5
0 5
0 5
0 5
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0'
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 5
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0 C
F
7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
!> 7
a 7
3 7
D 7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
0 45 24 36 29
29 36 40 18
38 29 48 40
38 29 48 40
38 29 48 40
38 29 48 40
38 29 48 40
38 29 46 27"
38 29 48 27
38 28 48 40
38 29 48 40
36 29 48 40
36 29 48 40
38 28 46 40
i 38 29 48 40
38 29 48 40
45 48 40 19
38 49 40 19
38 24 48 40
38 48 27 40
36 48 27 40
38 48 27 40
38 29 46 27
36 46 40 19
24 48 27 40
38 48 27 40
24 38 48 27
38 46 40 19
48 27 40 19
48 27 40 19
24 48 27 40
38 48 27 40
38 46 40 19
38 48 33 40
38 48 40 18
48 40 18 28
38 « 27 40
45 48 27 40
> 38 29 48 33
B 126493 00000070 38294833
6 1.26453 00000070 36284833
B 1.26453 000
9 1.57675 000
B 2.91139 000
7 2.75267 000
B 1.48214 000
f B
9 0.41908 A 6 0
0.06528 1 0 0
0.29728 000
029728 000
029726 000
0.29726 000
029728 000
0.29728 000
028728 000
028314 000
028314 000
026728 000
028728 000
029314 000
0.03772 000
0.03772 000
0.00000 100
0.27343 000
0.27343 000
027343 000
028726 000
028728 000
028728 000
028728 000
0.28728 000
0.70214 1 0 0
0.07248 1 0 0
0.07246 1 0 0
0.00000 1 0 0
00070 38294633
00071
D 0 0 7 (
0 0 0 7 C
E
0 0 0 7 (
40071
40071
4 0 0 7 f
4 0 0 7 E
4 0 0 7 i
1007
007
007
007
007
007
007
007
507
607
507
507
6 0
5 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
S 0
6 0
5 0
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
7
38 29 48 33
36 29 48 33
36 45 29 48
45 38 28 48
f
38 40 32 41
40 41 25 31
36 40 41 48
38 40 41 48
38 40 41 48
38 40 41 46
38 40 41 48
38 40 41 48
38 40 41 48
38 41 48 25
38 41 48 25
38 40 41 48
38 40 41 46
38 41 48 25
38 41 48 31
38 41 48 31
45 48 31 0
38 40 41 48
38 40 41 48
38 40 41 48
36 40 41 46
38 40 41 48
38 40 41 48
38 40 41 48
40 48 31 0
38 40 41 48
36 40 41 48
36 40 41 48
40 41 48 25
40 41 46 31
40 41 46 31
40 46 31 0
COLUMN KEY:
A CHEMICAL ID E. EIGHT CRITERIA (A NUMBER SIGNIFIES A CRITERIA NOT SATISFIED)
8. STATE 10 F. FOUR MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILIES
C. NO. OF RESIDENT FAMILIES S. FAMILY MEAN ACUTE VALUE FOR FOUR MOST SENSITIVE SPECIES
D. FINAL ACUTE VALUE (FAV)
Q
4.50275 5.00000 5.45169 7.89999
7.88998 1078999 22.10088 231.05228
2.45947 7.98999 14.45951 22.10068
2.45947 7.99999 14.45851 22.10068
2.45947 7.99899 14.45851 30.10193
2.48847 7.88989 14.45891 30.10193
2.45947 7.89999 14.45951 30.10193
367334 7.988W 10.81058 19.99997
245847 7.88999 1041096 19.89997
2.45947 7.88999 1041058 40.99985
2.45947 7.89888 10.81058 40.98985
5.15366 7.98998 1041056 30.10183
2.45847 7.88899 1041058 30.10183
2.45947 7.89899 10.81058 4088995
2.45847 7.88989 10.81058 40.99995
2.45847 7.98989 1041058 40.99985
4.50275 14.45851 40.89895 231.05228
2.45847 10.81058 30.10183 231.05228
2.45947 5.00000 10.81058 30.10193
2.45947 10.61058 18.98887 30.10183
2.45847 10.81058 18.99887 30.10183
2.49847 10,81048 10.99887 30.10183
5.49168 7.89989 1041056 19.99887
8.45169 1041058 30.10183 231.05226
5.00000 10.81058 18.98887 30.10183
9.45168 10.81058 19.98887 30.10183
9.00000 5.45169 10.81056 1999897
3.87334 10.81056 30.10183 231.05228
1041098 19.88997 30.10193 231.05228
10.81058 18.88997 30.10183 231.05228
5.00000 10.61056 18.99997 30,10193
10.78998 1041058 18.89897 30.10193
2.45847 1041058 30.10183 190.74548
2.49847 1041053 23.88887 30.10183
2.45847 10.81056 30.10183 180.74548
10.61058 30.10183 190.74948 '73899654
2.49847 1041056 18.88887 30.10183
4.50279 10.81058 19.88887 30.10183
9.15386 7.89989 10.81058 23.98887
2.49847 7.88889 10.61058 23.98887
2.45947 7.89899 1041058 23.99897
2.49847 7.89989 10.81056 23.98987
347334 7.89999 10.61056 23.99887
2.45947 7.89899 1041096 23.99997
2.45947 4.50275 7.99998 1041058
5.45169 7.99889 10.81058 23.98887
5.48168 7.89999 10.61M6 23.98887
2.45847 4.50275 7.98899 1041058
4.50275 6.45169 7.98998 10.81058
a
0.66433 127884 2.30000 324037
127864 3.24037 5.79999 87.69022
0.66433 127884 3.24037 3.81051
0.66433 127684 3.24037 3.81051
0.66433 1.27884 3.24037 3.81051
0.66433 127884 3.24037 3.81051
0.66433 127884 3.24037 341051
046433 127684 3-24037 341051
0.66433 127864 3.24037 3.81051
046433 3.24037 3.81051 6.00000
0.66433 324037 3.81051 6.00000
046433 1.27664 3.24037 3.81051
0.66433 1.27864 324037 3.81091
0.66433 324037 341051 6.00000
0.86433 324037 3.81051 87.65022
0.66433 3.24037 3.81051 8749022
3.70000 3.81051 87.65022 0.00000
0.66433 1.27884 3.24037 3.81051
046433 127884 3.24037 341051
0.66433 1.27684 3.24697 3.81061
046433 127684 324037 3.81091
0.66433 127664 324037 341061
0.66433 127664 3.24037 341091
0.69433 1.27664 3.24037 3.81091
127664 341051 87.65022 0.00000
0.69433 127884 3.24037 341051
0.65433 127864 3.24037 341091
0.86433 1.27664 3.24037 3.81051
1.27664 324037 3.81051 6.00000
127864 3.24037 3.81061 87.95022
1.27664 324037 3.61051 87.65022
127884 3.81051 87.89022 0.00000
E-3
-------
APPENDIX E
RECALCULATION RESULTS
ENDOSULFAN (ContlniMd)
• JL
5 32
5 33
5 34
5 35
5 36
6 37
5 38
5 39
5 40
5 41
5 42
5 43
5 44
5 45
5 46
5 47
5 48
ENDRIN
A B
r T
8 1
2
3
4
53
7
8
6 9
6 0
6 1
6 2
6 3
e 4
6 5
e e
6 7
8 8
6 9
6 20
6 21
8 22
8 23
6 24
6 25
e 2e
6 27
6 28
6 29
6 30
6 31
6 32
6 33
E 34
e 35
8 36
6 37
6 38
6 39
6 40
6 41
6 42
8 13
6 44
6 45
6 46
6 47
6 48
HEPTACHL
i. S.
7 0
7 2
7 3
7 4
7 5
7 6
7 ?
7 8
7 9
7 10
7 11
E-4
C D
7 0.32134
7 032134
6 0,29726
4 0.07248
5 0.21274
4 0.07750
8 0.39144
8 0.39144
8 039144
B 039144
7 033933
8 039144
8 0.36816
6 030698
5 005782
8 032949
7 0.30948
C D
17 0.40155
8 0.17608
8 0.28102
8 0.28102
9 0.30539
9 0.30539
9 0.30539
11 0.40949
10 0.31648
10 0.33656
10 0.36749
11 037679
9 0.35042
9 0.35503
8 0.34033
8 0.34033
6 048370
6 0.30600
8 058084
9 0.56869
8 0.56064
9 0.46511
10 0.52998
7 0.39400
9 0.55378
8 0.46210
11 0.58750
8 0.55612
B 054174
9 0,55378
10 0.56548
8 0.37997
6 0.14359
7 0.38272
6 0.30600
7 0.41505
10 0.57646
8 083538
g 0.26608
9 0.24917
9 0.22354
10 029570
10 0.33230
9 0.24917
10 0.26663
10 0.32912
10 0.28380
10 0.19305
10 0.28776
on
-£• "
10 0.50269
4 15.54968
5 7.39130
5 7.40926
S 704294
5 7.04294
5 704294
6 0.66624
6 057862
5 7.04294
5 7.04294
S 1831896
E
0000007
0000007
0000507
1004507
0004007
1004507
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0030007
0030007
0000007
0000007
E
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000507
0000507
1000567
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
1000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
1000007
1000007
1000007
0000007
0000067
0000007
0000507
1000007
0000007
1000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
0000007
E
0000007
0000067
0000067
0000067
0000067
0000067
0000067
0000067
0000067
0000067
F
3 38 40 41 48
t 38 40 41 48
8 38 40 41 48
B 40 41 48 31
6 38 40 48 25
t 40 45 48 31
0 36 40 32 1
•0 38 40 32 1
0 38 40 32 1
0 38 40 32 1
0 38 40 32 8
0 38 40 32 1
0 38 40 32 5
0 38 32 48 25
8 38 48 25 31
8 38 45 48 25
8 38 40 45 «8
F
0 46 38 33 32
0 46 38 40 31
0 38 40 48 31
0 36 40 48 31
0 46 38 48 40
0 46 38 48 40
0 46 38 48 40
0 46 38 40 45
0 46 38 48 40
0 46 38 45 48
0 46 38 45 -48
0 46 3B 40 45
0 38 40 48 31
0 33 45 43 31
0 38 45 48 31
0 33 45 48 31
8 44 45 43 40
B 36 40 45 48
0 38 40 45 48
B 38 40 45 48
8 38 40 45 48
0 38 40 45 48
8 38 40 48 31
0 40 45 48 27
B 38 40 48 27
0 38 40 45 48
8 38 40 45 48
8 40 45 48 27
0 40 45 43 27
0 40 45 48 27
B 38 40 45 48
B 38 40 48 25
8 33 38 40 48
B 38 40 43 31
B 40 45 48 31
8 38 40 45 48
B 45 48 40 27
0 38 33 32 48
0 38 33 32 48
0 38 33 32 48
0 38 33 32 45
0 38 33 32 45
0 38 33 32 48
0 38 33 32 45
0 46 33 33 32
0 33 46 38 32
0 33 38 32 45
0 46 3B 33 45
F
8 32 27 33 2S
I 25 19 38 40
8 38 48 25 19
8 38 48 25 19
8 38 48 26 19
8 38 .48 25 19
B 38 48 25 19
3 27 38 48 25
B 27 38 48 25
B 38 48 25 19
9 38 46 25 19
00000678 48 38 J5 19
0.66433
0.66433
0.66433
1.27884
0.66433
1.27884
0.88433
0.66433
0.66433
0.66433
0.66433
0.66433
0.66433
0.86433
0.66433
0.66433
0.66433
0.44000
0.44000
0.55563
0.55563
0.44000
0.44000
0.44000
0.44000
0.44000
0.44000
0.44000
0.44000
0.55563
0.55563
0.56563
0.55563
0.85000
0^69443
0.69443
0.69443
0.55563
0.62528
0.70057
0.73211
0.62528
0.70057
0.88710
0.73211
0.73211
0.73211
0.47125
0.69443
0.49315
0.55563
0.73211
0.69443
0.94868
0.38261
0.35693
0.31982
0.35893
0.46753
0.35693
0.35693
0.44000
0.32000
0.32000
0.44000
0.99499
26.99997
13.05761
13.05761
13.05761
13.05761
13.05761
t.80000
1.80000
13.05761
13.05761
25.99997
COLUMN KEY
A. CHEMICAL
B. STATE ID
C. NO. OF REE
a
1.27884
1.27884
1.27884
3.24037
1.27884
3.70000
1.27884
1 .27884
1.27684
1.27684
1.27884
1.27884
1.27884
2.30000
3.81051
3.70000
1.27884
G
0.46827
0.45772
0.56177
0.56177
0.55583
0.55583
0.55563
0.68710
0.55583
0.55563
0.69443
053565
0.73211
0.75000
0.75000
0.75000
0.94868
073211
0.73211
0.73211
0.73211
0.73211
0.73211
0.75000
0.73211
0.7321.1
0.73211
0.75000
0.75000
0.75000
0.73211
0.73211
0.69443
0.73211
0.75000
0.73211
1.01097
0.49315
0.49315
0.49315
0.49315
0.49319
0.49315
0.49315
0.46827
0.44000
0.35693
0.46827
Q
1.80000
50.74823
25.99997
25.99997
25.99997
25.99997
25.99997
17.70260
13.05761
25.99997
25.99997
32.70192
ID
I DENT FAMILIES
3.24037
324037
3.24037
3.81051
3.81051
3.81051
2.30000
2.30000
2.30000
2.30000
2.30000
2.30000
2.30000
3.81051
5.79999
3.81051
3.70000
0.493)5
0.58177
1.01097
1.01097
1.01097
1.01097
1.01097
0.73211
1.01097
0.75000
0.75000
0.7321 1
1.01097
1.01097
1.01097
1.01097
1.01097
OJ5COO
0,75000
0.75000
0.75000
1.01097
1.01097
1.01097
0,75000
0.75000
1.01097
1.01097
1.01097
0.75000
1.01097
0.73211
1.01097
1.01097
0.75000
1.08615
0.64675
0.64675
0.84675
0.64675
0.64675
0.64675
0.64875
0.49315
0.46827
0.54000
0.49315
2.80000
SI. 89960
28.99997
37.04762
47.32656
47.32856
47.32856
24.77082
24.77092
47.32858
47.32656
47.32858
HEPTACHLOR (Coollnwd)
A B 9 D E F
3.81051 7 12 5 8.19214 00000678 38 49 25 19
381051 7 13 5 6.19214 00000676 38 48 25 19
3.81051 7 14 4 1.71463 00005678 38 48 19 40
87.65022 7 15 4 1.71463 00005678 38 48 19 40
5.79999 7 16 4 5.74669 10005878 46 19 45 40
67.65022 7 17 4 2.64961 00005678 33 48 19 40
3.24037 7 18 4 2.76728 00005678 3848 19 40
3.24037 7 19 5 0.46503 00000678 27 38 46 19
3.24037 7 20 5 0.48503 00000676 27384819
3.24037 7 21 6 0.57862 00000678 27384825
3.81051 7 22 6 066180 00000678 27 48 38 25
3.24037 7 23 5 16.21363 00000678 48 38 25 19
3.70000 7 24 4 0.23528 10000878 27 48 19 40
5.79999 7 25 6 0.66180 00000678 27483825
87.65022 7 26 6 042179 00000678 27 48 38 25
5.79999 7 27 5 10.74730 00000678 3843 25 19
3.81051 7 26 5 0.49096 10000678 27 48 25 19
7 29 5 0.40407 10000678 27 28 48 19
7 30 5 0.40407 10000878 27 28 48 19
7 31 5 0.41561 00000678 27 48 19 38
7 32 5 6.71926 00000678 38 48 25 19
064675 7 33 6 1.21084 00000078 33 38 48 25
180000 7 34 4 2.68044 00005678 3848 19 40
1 80000 7 35 4 1.57560 10000678 28 48 19 40
lisOOOO 7 36 7 0.7B657 00000678 27 28 30 48
103615 7 37 6 0.48886 10000878 27 28 48 19
1.08615 7 38 7 0.20217 00000078 32334825
075000 7 40 7 0.24958 0000007 32333848
108615 7 41 7 0.25542 0000007 32333848
101097 7 42 7 0.23462 0000007 32333848
(01097 7 43 7 0.24958 0000007 32333848
075000 7 44 8 0.26467 0000007 32333843
1 80000 7 45 7 0.22455 0000007 3233 48 25
I'&OOOO 7 46 6 0.27147 00000078 32 48 25 38
1 60000 7 47 7 0.32023 00000078 32364825
lleoOOO 7 48 7 1.39690 00000073 33 48 25 38
2.10000
1.80000 LEAD
1.01097 . • r n F c
31;]™ 13 0 7 0.07453 00000608 25 19 33 40
in no? <6 1 3 00000° 00345608 38 40 70
•S ™' 16 2 21.49640 000*5 0 3840487
I'Suvvin ™ 3 21, '9640 00045 0 38 40 48 7
IMJQI 16 4 29.53795 00045 0 38 40 48 7
i*uai 1e 5 29.93795 00045 0 3840487
i?nol 1G 6 29.03795 00045 0 3840487
nina? 16 7 0.10871 00040 08 25 38 40 48
5M01 16 B 29.93795 00045 08 38 40 48 7
196491 '* 9 26.14089 00045 08 3646740
ltt*ai 1S 10 72.88985 00045 08 38 48 7 40
101097 16 11 29.S3795 00045 08 384048 7
c,™7 « 12 29.93795 00045 08 384048 7
1 01097 '6 13 28.14089 00045 08 38 48 7 40
180000 " 14 28.14089 00045 08 38 48 7 40
limn 16 1S 26.14089 00045 08 3848740
101087 1S 18 310.91022 10045 03 4845740
i3«Ii< l8 17 29.93795 00045 08 3B40487
10«»7 >B 18 5 0.11728 00040 08 25334048
101M7 1S 19 6 °-11728 00040 08 25334048
ininor 18 20 * 74.76483 00045 0 38 40 48 7
'•™j*J 16 21 4 29.83795 00045 0 3840487
nSmn 16 22 5 0,10871 00040 0 25384048
imnOT '6 23 * 74.76483 00045 0 3840487
no]™ 16 24 * O.C7015 10040 0 2540487
n'TMW 1S 2! ! °-10871 00040 0 25384048
nunm 16 26 5 0.11728 00040 0 25384048
nll«fu» 16 27 4 29.93795 00045 0 38 40 43 -7
niUHU 16 23 4 0.07015 10040 0 2540487
u.ww» 16 29 3 0.00000 10045 0 404370
16 30 4 0.07015 10040 0 2540487
16 31 3 0.00000 10045 0 404370
16 as s DfFma nonns a ia m 4n 4K
7.79999 16 33 9 0,85039 00005 0 19 38 40 48
100.69736 16 34 5 0.57456 00005 0 19384048
50.74823 16 35 3 0.00000 100)45 0 404870
50.74823 16 38 5 0.11728 00040 0 25384048
50.74823 16 37 4 227.15302 10045 0 40 43 45 7
50.74823 16 38 S 0.57458 00005 0 19334048
50.74823 16 39 5 0.57458 00005 0 19384048
37.04762 16 40 6 0.85039 00005 0 19 38 40 46
47.32356 16 41 S 0.57456 00005 0 19384046
50.74323 16 42 5 0.57456 00005 0 19384048
50.74823 16 43 5 0.57456 00005 0 19364046
50.74823 16 44 6 0.71724 OOOOS 0 19334046
E. EIGHT CRITERIA (A NUMBER SIGNIFIES A CRITERIA NOT SATISFIED)
f. FOUR MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILIES
G. FAMILY MEAN ACUTE VALUE FOR FOUR MOST SENSITIVE SPECIES
D FINAL ACUTE VALUE (FAV)
13.05761
13.05761
13.05761
13.05761
2477092
13.05781
13.05761
1.60000
1,30000
1.80000
1.80000
24.77092
1.80000
1 .80W10
180000
17.70260
180000
1,80000
1BOOOC
1.80000
13.05761
2.30000
13.05761
7.79999
1.30000
1.30000
0.99499
0.99499
0.99499
0.99499
0,99499
0.99499
0.99499
1.10000
0,90000
0.90000
2.30000
1.16107
40.52946
80.06241
80.06241
80.06241
80.06241
60.06241
1.16107
80.06241
60.06241
158.15637
80.06241
80.06241
80.06241
80.06241
30.06241
455.01465
80.06241
1.16107
1.16107
158.15637
30.0624)
1.16107
158.15637
1.18107
1.16107
1.16107
80.06241
1.16107
358.79193
1.16107
356.79193
4.01987
4.01987
4.01937
358.7(193
1.16107
358.79193
4.01967
4.01987
4.01987
4.01937
4.01967
4.01987
4.01937
a
24.77092
24.77092
24.77092
24.77092
50.74823
25.99997
24.77092
13.05761
13.05761
13.05761
25.99997
29.49752
24.77092
25.99997
24.77092
25.99997
25.98997
7.79999
779999
24.77092
25.99997
13.05781
25.99997
25.99997
7,79999
7.79999
2.60000
2,60000
2.80000
2.80000
2.80000
2.80000
2.80000
2.80000
25,99997
1305761
25.99997
a
4.01967
157.99112
157.99112
157.99112
353.79193
358.79193
358.79193
80.06241
359.79193
455.01465
455.01465
358.79193
358.79193
455.01465
455.01465
455.01465
532.65571
35879193
158.15637
158.15637
358.79193
353.79193
30.06241
358.79193
358.79193
80.08241
153.19637
353.79193
358.79193
459.01465
358.79193
455.01465
158.15637
153.15637
80.06241
45S.0146S
158.15637
455.01465
30.06241
80.08241
156.15837
80.06241
30.06241
30.06241
30.06241
47.32856
47.32858
50.74623
50.74823
147.99966
50.74823
50.74823
24.77092
24.77092
24.77092
29.49752
47.32858
50.74823
29.49752
29.49752
37.04762
47.32856
24.77092
24.77092
50.74823
28.99997
25,99897
58.56595
50.74323
13.0S761
24.77092
25.99997
13,05761
13.05761
13.05761
17.70260
13.0! 761
13.05761
25.99997
28.99997
25.99997
28.99997
80.0(241
303.34546
455.01465
455.01465
455.01465
455.01465
455.0146S
358.78193
455.01465
603.84546
303.84546
455.01465
455.01465
603.64546
803.34546
803.84546
803.84548
455.01465
356.79193
358.79193
455.01465
455.01465
356.79193
459.01465
455.01465
358.79193
356.79193
455.01465
459.01465
803.84546
455.01465
303.64546
356.79193
368.79193
358.79193
603.64S46
358.70193
532.85571
356.79193
398.79193
356.79193
356.79193
356.79193
358.79T93
358.79193
50.74823
50.74823
319.99933
319.99933
319.99933
179.50781
179.90781
50.74823
50.74823
47.32358
37.04782
50.74823
179.90781
37.04762
47.32856
50.74823
50.74823
50.74823
50.74823
81.89980
58.56595
29.99997
179.50781
179.50781
24.77082
50.74323
23.99997
25.99997
25.99997
24.77092
25.99997
25,99997
25.99897
28.99997
29.49752
28.99997
29.49752
358.79193
0.00000
803.84546
603.34546
603.64946
603.34546
803.64546
455.01465
803.84548
814.60310
614.80310
603.84548
803.84546
814.60310
814.80310
614.80310
814.80310
803.84546
455.01465
455.01465
303,34546
803.34946
455.01465
303.84546
803.84549
459.01465
459.01465
803.84548
803.84548
0.00000
803,84548
0.00000
459.01465
455.01465
455.01465
0.00000
455.01465
303.64546
459.01465
455.01465
455.01465
455.01465
495.01469
455.01465
455.01465
-------
APPENDIX E
RECALCULATION RESULTS
LEAD (Conlinu.d)
MERCURY (Continued)
A_ J_
16 45
16 46
16 47
16 46
LINDANE
f- f
8 1
8 2
8 3
8 4
8 5
8 6
8 7
8 9
8 10
8 11
8 12
8 13
8 14
8 15
8 16
8 17
8 18
8 19
8 20
8 21
8 22
8 23
8 24
8 25
8 26
B 27
8 28
8 29
8 30
8 31
8 32
8 33
8 34
8 35
8 36
8 37
8 36
8 39
8 40
8 41
8 42
8 43
8 44
a 45
8 46
8 47
8 48
MERCURY
4- -L
17 0
17 1
17 2
17 3
17 4
17 5
17 6
17 7
17 8
17 9
17 10
17 11
17 12
17 13
17 14
17 15
17 16
17 17
17 18
17 19
17 20
17 21
17 22
17 23
C
5
5
e
6
W
6
8
6
7
63
6
7
5
5
5
5
6
5
5
8
8
8
5
8
g
6
8
8
6
5
8
7
8
6
8
g
7
7
8
8
8
7
9
7
C
9
6
5
5
5
5
5
6
7
4
5
5
6
4
4
5
3
5
4
4
5
6
7
5
Q
0.43848
0.43848
0.64400
0.71724
6,43501
9.11176
8.44095
6.78459
4.49001
3-65875
3.65875
10.11431
444662
2.99564
4.94561
3.46034
3.90389
21.65018
20.27614
21.43935
8.89240
2.26502
3.21448
19.50106
4.53113
13.20277
5.37087
4.34789
13.20277
4.02269
11.23682
0.70439
0.57080
0.48908
27.67500
27.74971
464000
8.39216
28 78233
2643128
33.59354
14.68027
10.23779
4 84000
948828
13.36940
10.23779
16.56344
15.47593
10.79070
17.03664
D
0.94009
1.53310
1.25855
1.25855
1.29859
1.29855
1.25655
1.52780
142997
1.27818
1.25855
1.26114
1.52780
1.27818
3.35920
4.09633
0.00000
1.52780
1.27818
1.27818
0.69492
2.00637
2.44474
141117
E
000056
000056
000056
000056
E
000000
000006
0 0 0 0 0 E
000006
000006
0 0 0 0 0 E
o o o o o e
000006
000008
000006
000006
000006
000056
000056
100056
000058
000006
000056
000056
000000
000000
000000
100006
000000
000000
000000
000000
000050
000006
0 0 0 0 8 6
000000
000006
000056
100050
000006
1 00056
000000
000000
000000
000006
000000
000000
000006
000000
000000
000900
000006
E
023000
023400
023406
023406
0 J 3 4 0
02340
02340
02340
023 0
023 0
023 0
023 0
023 0
023 0
023 0
023 0
123 0
023 0
023 0
023 0
023 0
023 00
023 00
023 00
F
08 19 38 48 7
08 19 38 48 7
06 19 38 46 45
06 19 38 40 48
F
78 24 38 25 48
78 38 48 25 49
78 36 48 25 49
78 38 25 48 49
78 25 38 48 42
76 25 38 46 49
78 38 25 48 42
78 25 36 48 42
78 38 25 48 42
78 25 36 48 42
78 25 38 48 49
78 25 38 48 42
78 38 48 49 40
78 38 48 42 40
76 42 48 40 45
78 38 48 42 40
78 38 24 48 42
78 38 48 42 40
78 38 48 42 40
78 25 38 48 42
78 38 25 48 42
78 25 36 48 42
78 24 48 42 40
78 38 25 48 42
78 24 25 38 48
76 38 25 48 42
78 38 25 48 42
78 38 48 42 40
78 38 24 48 42
78 36 48 42 40
78 38 48 25 42
78 38 48 25 42
76 38 48 42 49
78 48 42 49 40
78 38 25 48 42
79 46 42 49 40
78 38 48 25 42
76 38 48 25 42
78 38 48 25 42
78 38 25 48 42
78 38 48 25 42
78 33 48 25 42
78 38 48 25 42
78 38 48 25 42
76 38 48 25 49
78 36 48 25 42
78 38 48 25 42
F
00 19 K 28 38
00 29 28 38 7
00 25 28 38 7
00 25 28 38 7
00 26 28 38 7
00 25 28 38 7
00 25 26 38 7
00 25 28 38 7
00 25 28 38 7
00 25 38 7 10
00 25 28 38 7
00 25 28 38 7
00 25 28 38 7
00 25 38 7 10
00 28 38 7 10
00 26 38 7 10
00 28 7 10 0
00 25 28 38 7
00 23 38 7 10
00 29 38 7 10
00 25 28 38 7
00 25 38 7 10
00 25 38 7 10
00 25 38 7 10
4.01987
4.01987
401967
4.01987
9.99999
15.88924
14.15800
14.15800
10.48808
1048808
10.48808
18.35550
10.48SOa
8.00389
10.48606
10.48808
10.48808
37.66935
37.66935
43.99995
14.15800
8.00389
8.00388
32.03120
10.48808
21.98812
10.48808
2148812
9.99999
18.35550
2.00000
2.00000
2.00000
45,27667
32.03120
8.00389
14.15600
42.19788
32.03120
5247122
18.93304
14.15800
6.00389
14.15800
18.35650
14.15800
14.15800
21.98612
21.96812
14.15800
21.96812
5.00000
9.99999
9,89999
9.69999
9.81899
9.88899
9.89899
8.99999
9.99999
9,89999
8.99999
9.89999
9.89899
9.89999
19.99997
19.99997
19.89997
9.99999
9.99989
9.89989
8.99999
8.89999
8.89889
9.89999
COLUMN KEY:
A. CHEMICAL
B. STATE ID
C. NO. OF RE
0
80.06241
80.06241
80.06241
80.08241
a
21.98812
31.99996
42.19788
22.43713
.15800
15800
.15800
.43718
!l5800
0.48808
6.93304
14.15800
14.15800
92.87122
52.87122
9247122
42.19788
8.88999
5247122
52.87122
14.15800
22.43716
1845588
5247122
22.43713
10.48808
22.43718
10.48803
5247122
8.98999
5287122
42.19788
42.19788
42.19788
53.08590
47.89995
93.06990
42.18788
42.18768
42.19704
47.8899!
42.19786
42.19781
42.19788
42.19768
42.19768
42.19788
42.19786
a
9.99989
49.98995
49.99895
49.99989
49.89989
49.89885
49.89895
49.99985
49.99983
246.59476
49.99995
49.99995
4S.8909S
248.59476
246.59478
241.59476
783.47107
49.99995
241.59476
24149478
19.99997
241,99476
244.25837
244.25937
ID
SIDENT FAMILIE
455.01465
455.01465
455.01465
358.79193
22.43718
47.99995
47.99995
42.19786
42.19788
4219768
42.19788
52.87122
52.87122
42.19788
42.19788
42.19786
52.87122
5247122
67.99963
53.06580
112.69353
53.06990
52.87122
53.06590
53.06580
5247122
42.19788
52.87122
53.06590
42.19768
18.45586
42.19788
48.19788
53.06580
52.87122
53.06590
47.99995
47.99995
53.06580
67.99983
5247122
67.99983
47.99995
47.99995
47.99999
5247122
47.99995
47.99995
47.99995
47.99995
47.89995
47.99995
47.99995
31.62273
239.89963
248.58476
248.58476
248.58478
246.59476
248.58476
248.58476
248.58476
783.47107
248.59476
244.25937
248.99476
783.47107
763.47107
783.47107
988.88841
248.59476
783.47107
783.47107
248.59476
783.47107
783.47107
763.47H17
S
803.34546
803.84546
532.85571
455.01465
52,67122
67.89983
67.89983
67.89983
53.08590
6799983
67,99983
53,06590
63,06590
43.99995
43.99995
0399967
67.99983
83.89987
112.69363
112.68353
137.99973
84.80521
53.06590
9440521
9440521
53.06580
53.08590
53.06590
94.80521
53.06590
52.87122
53.08590
53.06580
94.80521
33.06590
94.80521
53.06590
53.06590
67.99983
94.80521
53.06590
94.30521
53.06590
53.06590
53.96580
53.06580
63.99987
53.06580
53.06590
63.99987
67,99963
53.06580
53.06590
244.25837
783.47107
783.47107
783.47107
783.47107
783.47107
783.47107
783.47107
783.47107
888.98841
783.47107
783.47107
763.47107
888.98841
989.19841
889.18841
0.00000
783.47107
989.89841
999.89841
783.47107
989.89841
988.89841
998.89641
E. EIGHT
F. FOUR
Q. FAMIL
A B C D E F
17 24 4 0.33997 12340600 25 28 7 10
17 25 7 2,44474 02340000 2S38710
17 26 6 1.99953 02340000 25 36 7 10
17 27 5 1.61661 02340000 25 38 7 10
17 28 3 0.00000 12340600 25 7 10 0
17 29 3 0,00000 12340600 25 7 10 0
17 30 4 0.33997 12340600 25 28 7 10
17 31 4 3.32863 02340600 28 38 7 10
17 32 3 0.20147 02300600 19 25 38 7
17 33 5 0.20147 02300600 19 25 38 7
17 34 4 0.48080 02305600 19 38 7 10
17 36 5 0.89492 02340600 25 28 38 7
17 37 3 0.00000 12340600 26 7 10 0
17 39 0.20147 02300800! 19 25 38 7
17 41 0.20147 02300600 19 25 38 7
17 42 0.20147 02300800 19 25 38 7
17 43 0.20147 02300600 1925387
17 44 5 0.20147 02300600 1925367
17 45 5 0.20223 02300600 19 25 38 7
17 46 6 0.20223 02300600 19 25 38 7
17 47 5 0.20147 02300600 19 25 38 7
17 48 5 0,20223 02300600 19 29 38 7
NICKEL
A B C D E F
18 0 16 85.82762 10000000 1929487
18 1 13 70.50963 10000000 19 48 7 35
18 2 12 86.25783 10000000 1848735
18 3 12 66.25783 10000000 18 48 735
18 4 12 66.23783 10000000 18 48 7 35
18 5 12 8625604 10000000 1873548
16 6 12 8625604 10000000 1973546
18 7 13 70,17523 10000000 1948735
18 8 13 67.71924 10000000 19 29 48 7
18 9 12 6625763 10000000 19 48 735
18 10 12 66.29604 10000000 19 7 35 48
18 11 12 66.25783 10000000 19 48 7 35
16 12 13 70.17523 10000000 1946735
18 13 12 68.29783 10000000 1948735
18 14 11 68.24532 10005000 1973548
18 15 10 59.73523 10005000 19 47 48 7
18 16 11 61.97644 10005000 1947735
18 17 11 62.17289 10000000 1948735
18 18 11 63.23666 10000000 19 47 48 7
18 19 11 63.23666 10000000 19 47 48 7
18 21 12 66.25783 10000000 19 48 735
18 22 13 67.71824 10000000 18 29 48 7
18 24 11 63.23668 10000000 19 47 48 7
18 25 13 67.71924 10000000 1929487
18 28 13 68.96130 10000000 19 29 47 48
18 27 11 62.17269 10000000 1948735
18 28 11 62.17268 10000000 1948735
18 30 10 58.44781 10000000 19 48 7 35
18 31 10 58.00987 10005000 1947735
18 32 10 47.02316 10000000 19 48 7 35
18 33 11 60.37553 10000000 1948736
18 34 10 46.73035 10003000 1947733
18 39 10 38.73523 10009000 19 47 48 7
18 36 11 63.23886 10000000 19 47 48 7
18 37 11 6147644 10005000 1947735
18 38 8 43.43307 10000000 1973548
18 39 8 43.43307 10000000 1973548
18 40 8 42.68883 10000000 1973548
18 41 11 60.03432 10000000 19 47 7 35
18 42 8 40.11375 10000000 1873548
IB 43 8 43.60687 10000000 19 47 735
18 44 10 46.73039 10000000 1847735
18 45 8 40.11375 10000000 1973548
18 46 B 43.50597 10000000 1847735
18 47 8 43.31558 10000000 1973543
18 48 10 46.73035 10000000 18 47 735
PCB
* ? S P E F
IT 0 6 0.27471 00040078 38 48 40 25
8 1 3 0.00000 10049078-4840 31 0
CRITERIA (A NUMBER SIGNIFIES A CRITERIA NOT SATISFIED)
MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILIES
Y MEAN ACUTE VALUE FOR FOUR MOST SENSITIVE SPECIES
D FINAL ACUTE VALUE (FAV)
9.99889
9.99989
9.99999
9.99999
9.99999
999999
9.99888
19.99997
5.00000
5.00000
5.00000
783.47 107
9.99899
19.99997
5 OOOOO
KOODOO
siooooo
5.00000
5.00000
5.00000
5.00000
5.00000
5.00000
5.00000
66.07671
76.45601
78.45601
78.45601
78.45601
78.45601
7845601
78.43601
76.45601
78.45601
78.45601
78.45801
78.45601
78.47168
78.45601
76.49601
76.45601
78.45601
78.45601
78.45601
76.45601
78.45801
78.45601
8.45601
78.45601
78.45601
78.45801
78.43801
76.45601
78,46601
78.45801
78.45601
65.07671
65.07671
65.07671
78.45601
78.45601
78.45601
69.07671
65.07871
65.07671
65.07671
65.07671
65.07671
69.07671
63.07671
85.07671
63.07671
65.07671
2.00000
2.30000
Q
19.88897
244.25937
244.25937
248.58476
783.47107
783.47107
18.88997
239.89963
8.99999
9.98999
248.59476
898 99841
1899897
783.47107
9 98999
9.98999
9^99989
9^99969
9,99969
9.88999
9.99999
9.99999
9.89999
9.98999
Q
233.55489
388.35048
345.47168
345.47168
345.47168
401.21680
401.21680
345.47166
233.55499
345.47168
401.21960
345.471(8
345.471(8
345.45601
401,21680
301.51019
301.51019
325.84210
301.51019
301.51018
301,51019
345.47168
233.55498
301 .51 019
30141018
233.55488
23345499
325.84210
325.84210
301 .51019
325.84210
30141019
325.84210
325.84210
301.51019
301.51019
30141019
30141019
401.21680
401.21680
401.21680
30141019
401.21680
30141019
301.51019
40141680
30141019
401.21660
30141019
a
6.61059
32.60120
783.47107
763.47107
763.47107
763.47107
999.99841
999.99841
783.47107
783.47107
248.5*476
248.59476
783.47107
0.00000
24849478
999.99841
244 25937
24849476
24849476
24849478
246.59476
248.59476
244.25837
244.25937
248.59476
244.25937
345.47168
401.21680
401-21680
401.21680
401.21680
439.82544
43942544
401.21680
345.47168
401.21680
439.82944
401.21680
401.21680
401.21680
438.82544
325.84210
401.21660
401.21630
325.84210
325.84210
323.84210
401.21680
345.47168
345. -471 6&
325.84210
345.47166
30141019
401.21680
401.21680
345.47168
401.21680
401.21660
401.21660
401.21680
401.21680
325.84210
325.84210
401.21880
433.82544
439.82544
43942544
401.21580
438.82544
401.21680
401.21880
439.82544
401.21680
438.82544
401 .21 HO
32.80120
282.84204
889.99841
999.99841
999.99841
999.89841
0.00000
0.00000
999.99841
999.99641
733.47107
783.47107
999.99641
0.00000
783.47107
0-00000
78147107
783.47107
783.47107
763.47107
783.47107
783.47107
763.47107
783.47107
783.47107
401.21680
439.82544
439.82544
439.82544
43942544
444.71680
•444.71680
439.82544
401.21680
439.62644
444.71680
43942544
439.62644
439.82544
444.71680
401.21680
439.62544
439.92544
401.21680
401.21680
401.21660
439.82344
401.21680
401.21680
40121680
401.21680
345.47168
43942544
43942544
401.21680
43842544
43842544
43942944
438.82544
438.82544
401.21680
401.21880
439.82544
444.71680
444.71680
508.26428
438.82344
444.71880
439.82544
438.62544
444.71680
438.82544
436.64178
438.32S44
88.55391
0.00000
E-5
-------
APPENDIX E
RECALCULATION RESULTS
fCS (ConllmiMJ)
4.
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
g
g
9
g
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
g
9
9
9
9
9
g
9
g
9
9
9
9
9
9
9
SEL
A
19"
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
F.K
_B.
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
g
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
ENIUM
B
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
c_
4
5
5
5
5
5
5
4
4
5
5
4
3
3
4
5
5
4
g
5
4
5
5
5
4
3
4
2
3
3
4
3
5
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
2
2
2
3
C
To"
5
8
6
7
7
a
8
7
8
8
8
9
8
7
7
7
8
9
a
7
7
7
7
7
0
004812
0.11986
0.11988
0.11986
011986
0.27471
026179
0.03963
0.03963
011986
0,26179
0.09408
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
004812
0.28800
0.28800
010748
0 26179
0.12581
0^26179
1.04064
0.12581
0.27471
0.11986
0.26121
000000
1.04064
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.04812
0.00000
0.28800
000000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0 OOOOO
0^00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0
165.2Si66~
93.62001
117.48746
117.48746
125.60231
108.56085
108.56085
144.03363
12560231
132.52921
134.94461
125,60231
10856085
114.71845
114.71545
132.52921
135.61240
125.60231
148.20352
14820352
148.20352
163.95117
14403383
129.66721
113.70836
125.60231
14B.20352
163.95117
131.49722
113.70836
113.70836
113.70836
109.77351
109.77351
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
003
003
000
000
003
003
003
103
000
000
ooo
000
ooo
000
ooo
100
ooo
000
000
1 0 0
1 0 0
1 0 0
1 0 0
ooo
000
000
100
000
100
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
003
003
003
000
ooo
003
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
000
1 0 0
000
000
ooo
000
000
000
000
1 0 0
000
ooo
000
1 0 0
100
1 0 0
1 0 0
000
000
E
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
E
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
507
007
007
007
007
007
007
007
007
007
007
007
507
507
567
507
007
007
507
007
007
007
007
007
007
007
007
507
007
567
567
567
507
507
007
507
567
567
567
567
567
567
567
567
567
567
567
000
360
060
060
060
060
060
060
060
060
060
060
060
060
060
060
060
060
060
060
060
000
060
060
080
060
060
000
000
060
060
060
o e o
0 60
B 38
a 3B
8 38
8 38
8 38
6 38
a 38
6 38
8 38
B 38
8 38
8 38
B 38
8 38
B 48
B 38
a 38
8 38
8 38
3 38
B 38
8 38
8 48
8 38
6 36
B 38
a 48
B 48
B 48
B 48
8 38
3 38
8 38
6 48
8 38
8 48
B 38
B 38
8 38
8 38
8 38
8 38
8 38
8 38
B 38
B 38
8 38
B 26
S 26
8 26
8 26
8 26
8 26
8 26
8 26
8 28
8 26
6 26
8 26
a 26
8 26
8 26
8 26
8 26
8 26
B 26
8 26
8 26
8 26
8 26
8 26
8 26
a 26
8 26
8 26
8 26
8 26
8 28
8 26
8 20
' — *L
F
48 40
48 40
48 40
48 40
43 40
48 40
48 40
48 25
43 25
43 40
46 40
48 25
43 31
48 31
0 0
48 40
48 40
48 40
48 40
48 40
48 40
48 40
40 25
48 40
48 40
48 40
40 25
40 31
40 25
40 0
48 40
48 40
48 40
40 31
48 40
40 31
48 40
48 40
48 40
48 40
48 40
48 40
48 40
48 0
48 0
48 0
48 40
F
19 44
40 19
40 19
19 38
19 38
19 38
19 38
19 38
19 38
19 38
19 38
19 38
19 38
19 38
19 38
19 44
19 38
19 38
19 38
19 38
19 38
19 38
19 38
19 40
19 38
19 38
19 38
19 40
11 40
19 40
19 40
19 38
19 38
31
25
25
25
25
25
25
31
31
25
25
31
0
0
0
31
25
25
31
25
25
25
31
25
25
25
31
0
31
0
0
0
31
0
25
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
38
38
38
40
40
40
40
40
45
45
40
40
45
45
45
45
40
40
40
40
40
40
40
45
40
40
40
45
45
45
45
40
40
200000
200000
200000
200000
200000
200000
200000
200000
2,00000
200000
200000
2.00000
2.00000
2.00000
6.61059
2.00000
2.00000
2,00000
2.00000
2.00000
2.00000
2.00000
6.61059
2.00000
2.00000
2.00000
2.30000
6.61059
6.61059
6.61059
2.00000
2.00000
2.00000
2.30000
2.00000
6.61059
2.00000
2.00000
2.00000
2.00000
200000
2.00000
2.00000
2.00000
2.00000
2.00000
2.00000
339.99908
339.99808
339.99903
339.99808
339.99808
339.99808
339.96908
339.99608
339.99808
339.99808
339.99808
339.99808
338.99808
339.99608
339.99808
339.99808
339.99808
339.99808
339.99908
339.99808
339.99808
339.98808
339.99908
339.99908
339.89808
339.89808
339.89808
339.89808
339.99908
339.99908
339.99908
339.99808
339.99908
COLUMN KEY;
A. CHEMICAL
fl. STATE ID
C. NO. OF RE
G
2.30000
230000
2.30000
2.30000
2.30000
6,61059
6.61059
2.30000
2.30000
230000
6.61059
6.61059
6.61059
6.61059
000000
2^30000
6.61059
6.61059
6.61059
6.61059
2JOOOO
6610S9
32.60120
2.30000
661059
2.30000
32.60120
32.60120
32.60120
32.60120
2.30000
2.30000
2.30000
32.60120
6.61059
32.60120
2.30000
2.30000
2.30000
6.61059
2.30000
2.30000
2.30000
230000
2.30000
2.30000
2.30000
0
1892.47412
3105 14893
3105^14893
3105.14893
3869.98926
3869.98926
3869.98926
3869.98926
3839.98926
386998926
3869.98926
3889.88826
3869.98926
3869.88826
3868.88926
3889.88926
3869.88926
3889.98926
3869.88926
3869.88926
3869.98928
3889.98926
3889.88826
3869.98928
3869.88926
3868.98926
3889.68928
3869.68928
3869.88926
3869.68928
3869.88926
3889.68926
1892.47412
1892.47412
.10
SIOENT FAMI
32.60120
32.60120
32.60120
32.60120
32.60120
32.60120
32.60120
107.66406
107.66406
32.60120
32.60120
107.66406
282.84204
262.84204
0 00000
32.60120
32.60120
32.60120
32.80120
32.60120
32.60120
92.05394
32.60120
32.60120
32.60120
99.55351
282.84204
92.05394
0.00000
32.60120
32.60120
32.60120
282.84204
32.60120
282.84204
32.60120
32.60120
32.60120
32.60120
32.60120
32.60120
32.60120
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
32.60120
6499.97852
3869 98926
3869^98926
3889.98836
8479.72266
8478.72268
8479.72266
8479.72268
8479.72268
8478.72288
7049.60845
8478.72268
8479.72266
8478.72268
8478.72266
8478.72268
6499.97852
8478.72286
7048.60645
7048.60649
7048.60645
8479.72266
8478.72268
7048.60845
8002.43849
8478.72268
7048.60645
8478.72268
6002.43849
8009.43845
6002.43845
8002.43845
7040.80645
7049.60845
JES
282.84204
107.66406
107.68406
107.68406
107.66406
9955351
107.66406
282.84204
28284204
107.66406
107.C6406
282.84204
0.00000
0.00000
282.84204
92.05394
92.05394
282.84204
107.66406
99.55351
10766406
282.84204
99.55351
99.55351
107.86406
282.84204
0.00000
282.84204
0.00000
0.00000
000000
282.84204
0.00000
92.05394
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
000000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
0.00000
8479.72266
10199.974
8479.72266
8479.72266
9002.43945
8002.43845
8002.43945
8002.43849
8002.43945
12588.847
K599.947
8002.43945
8002.43945
12569.947
12586.947
12589.947
12588.947
6002.43945
8002.43945
8002.43949
6002.43945
8002.43945
6002.43949
6002.43945
12596.947
8002,43845
6002.43945
6002.43845
12598.947
12588947
12588.947
12588.947
9003.43945
9002.43949
E. EIGHT
F. FOUH
G. FAMI1
*_ -§-
18 34
18 35
18 36
19 37
19 38
18 39
19 40
18 41
19 42
19 43
18 44
19 45
19 46
19 47
18 48
SILVER
A B
ST T
20 1
20 2
20 3
20 4
20 5
20 6
20 7
20 8
20 9
20 10
20 11
20 12
20 13
20 14
20 IS
20 16
20 17
20 18
20 19
20 20
20 21
20 22
20 23
20 24
20 25
20 26
20 27
20 28
20 29
20 30
20 31
20 32
20 33-
20 34
20 35
20 36
20 37
20 38
20 39
20 40
20 41
20 42
20 43
20 44
20 45
20 46
20 47
20 48
TOXAPHEk
fr f
10 1
10 2
10 3
10 4
10 9
10 6
10 7
10 8
10 9
10 10
10 11
CRITERIA {A N
MOST SENSITIV
.V MEAN ACUTE
C
7
7
9
8
7
7
7
a
7
7
8
6
6
8
8
C
T
2
6
5
3
3
5
4
3
3
4
3
5
6
8
5
6
6
5
5
8
8
*
5
4
S
3
5
5
s
3
6
4
5
6
6
8
6
6
5
6
6
5
9
E
if
7
7
7
8
7
7
B
8
8
8
8
JMBER
EHESI
VALUE
D
104.88212
113.70836
13817023
131.49722
104.86212
104.88212
109.77351
120.32399
104.86212
104.88212
120.32388
59.20579
59.20578
108.28229
120.32386
0
0.00106
0.00000
0,00013
000013
000013
0.00013
000013
0.00082
000071
0.00000
000000
0,00071
000013
0.00000
0.00000
000005
0.00000
000071
0.00082
0.00082
0.00071
000082
0.00082
0.00071
0.00004
000082
0.00082
0.00022
0.00042
0.00003
o.ooo04
0.00000
000030
Q ,000 30
000030
000000
0.00029
000030
000030
000061
0.00061
000061
0.00081
0.00081
0.00023
0.00093
0.00053
0.00017
0.00023
1.07423
1.16160
1.77184
1.77184
1.83820
1.82556
1.82556
2.88047
2.85841
2.08901
2.16707
1.99059
SIGNIFIES A
DENT FAMILI
FOR FOUR tt
E
OOOOO 08
10000 08
OOOOO 08
10000 08
OOOOO 08
OOOOO 08
OOOOO 08
OOOOO 06
OOOOO 08
OOOOO 08
OOOOO 08
OOOOO 08
OOOOO 08
00000608
000
E
00000008
10345608
00045608
00045608
00045608
00045608
000 5608
000 0608
000 5 6 0 B
003 5608
003 5608
000 5608
000 5608
003 5608
00345608
00045608
10045608
00045698
00040608
00040608
0004560B
00045008
00040808
00045608
000 0608
000 0808
000 5008
100 0008
100 9608
100 0608
100 5608
00005608
00005608
10045608
00040008
10045008
00005608
00005808
00005608
00005808
00005608
00005608
00005608
00005608
00005608
00005608
00005608
E
00000070
00000078
00000078
00000078
00000078
00000078
00000076
00000078
00000078
00000078
00000078
00000078
CRITERIA NOT SATISFIED)
:s
OST SENSITIVE SPECIES
28 19
26 19
26 19
28 19
26 19
26 19
26 19
26 19
28 19
28 18
26 19
26 19
28 19
28 19
26 19
19 52
40 7
40 38
40 38
40 38
40 38
40 38
52 40
52 40
38 48
38 48
52 40
40 38
36 48
38 46
52 38
44 48
52 40
52 40
52 40
52 40
52 40
52 40
52 40
52 40
52 40
52 40
40 38
40 48
52 40
32 40
40 48
19 40
18 4B
16 40
40 48
40 38
40 48
19 40
19 52
19 52
19 52
18 62
18 52
19 40
19 40
19 40
19 40
18 40
33 32
48 40
48 40
48 40
48 42
48 38
48 38
42 48
42 48
48 42
48 45
48 42
F
38 40
40 45
38 40
40 45
38 40
38 40
38 40
36 40
38 40
38 40
38 40
38 16
38 18
38 45
38 40
F
40 44
0 0
48 7
48 7
48 7
48 7
48 7
38 48
38 48
7 0
7 0
38 48
48 7
7 0
7 0
48 7
7 0
38 48
38 48
38 48
38 48
38 48
38 48
38 48
48 7
38 48
38 48
48 35
35 7
48 7
48 7
7 0
38 48
38 48
38 48
7 0
48 35
35 7
38 48
40 38
40 38
40 38
40 38
40 38
38 48
52 38
52 38
38 48
38. 48
F
42 48
38 49
38 49
38 48
38 40
40 49
40 49
38 40
38 40
38 40
38 40
38 40
D. FINAL ACUTE VALUE (FAV)
339.88908
339.99908
339,99908
339.88808
339.99908
339.89808
339.89808
339.89806
339.89808
339.98908
339.88908
339.98908
339.88808
339.89908
339,89906
0.00185
0.01083
0.01083
0.01083
001083
0.01083
0.01083
0.00401
0.00401
0.02051
0.02051
0.00401
0.01083
0.02051
0.02051
0.00401
0.01232
0.00401
0.00401
0.00401
0.00401
0.00401
0.00401
0.00401
0.00401
0.00401
0.00401
0.01083
0.01083
0.00401
0.00401
0.01083
0.00185
0.00185
0.00185
0.01083
001083
0.01083
0.00185
0.00185
0.00185
0.00185
0.00185
0.00185
0.00189
0.00165
0.00185
0.00185
0.00185
1.30000
2.00000
2.84828
2.84828
2.84828
2.84828
2.84828
3.94658
3.54858
234828
2.84828
234828
Q
1992.47412
3889.98928
3869.98926
3868.88928
1992.47412
1892.47412
1882.47412
1992.47412
1982.47412
1992.47412
1992.47412
1992.47412
1962.47412
1982.47412
1982.47412
B
0.00401
5.51880
0.02051
0.02051
002051
0.02051
0.02051
0.01083
0.01083
0.11237
0.1 1237
0.01083
0.02051
0.11237
0.11237
0.02051
0.11237
0.01083
0.01083
0.01083
0.01083
0.01083
0.01083
0.01083
0.01083
0.01083
0.01083
. 0.02051
0.1 1237
0.010B3
0.01083
0.11237
0.01083
0.01083
0.01083
0.1 1237
0.02051
0.11237
0.01083
0.00401
0.00401
0.00401
0.00401
0.00401
0.00648
0.00385
0.00385
0.00385
0.00848
Q
2.62678
6.18529
8.16529
8.16529
3.54858
6.67768
6.67760
4.72465
4.72465
4.18275
4.18279
3.00000
8479.72268
8002/43845
7049.60645
800243949
8479.72266
6479.72266
7049.60645
6479.72266
8479.72266
8478.72286
8478.72268
6478.72266
8478.72288
8478.72266
8478.72266
0.00646
000000
0,11237
011237
011237
0,11237
011237
0,02051
002051
551660
5.51660
002051
011237
551860
551660
011237
5,51660
002051
002051
002051
002051
002051
0.02051
0.02051
0,11237
0.02051
0.02051
0.11237
410596
0.11237
0.11237
5.51860
0.02051
0.02051
OO2051
551660
0.11237
4.10596
0.02051
000646
000846
000646
0.00646
0.00646
002051
000401
000401
0.02051
0.02051
3.54658
6.94984
6.87760
6.87760
6.67760
7.42884
7.42884
5.22338
6.87780
6.87760
S.2M72
7.12840
9002.43845
12588.847
9002.43645
12989.847
9002.43845
9002.43945
8002.43845
9002.43845
8002.43945
9002.43945
9002.43945
24089.867
24088.867
12989.847
9002.43845
0.01232
0.00000
5.51660
5.51680
551660
5.51660
5.51660
0.11237
0.11237
0.00000
0.00000
011237
9.51680
0.00000
0.00000
5.51860
0.00000
0.11237
0.11237
0.11237
0.11237
0.11237
011237
0.11237
5.51860
0.11237
0.11237
4.10596
5.91660
5.91660
3.31660
0.00000
0.11237
0.1 1297
0.11237
0.00000
4.10596
5.51660
0.11237
0.02051
0.02051
0.02051
0,02051
0.02051
0.11237
0.02051
0.02051
0.11237
0.11237
4.72465
11.86898
11.88699
11.88899
7.42884
11.66699
1199999
8.03264
8.43262
8.78180
6.78180
8.03264
-------
APPENDIX E
RECALCULATION RESULTS
TOXAPHENE
A_
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
ZINC
*_
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
21
B
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
11
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
-§-
^
2
3
5
7
8
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
26
29
30
31
32
33
34
5
38
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
c
7
3
6
&
6
6
7
8
7
9
9
8
7
9
9
8
9
7
8
7
8
9
7
8
8
8
10
10
9
10
10
10
11
10
8
10
9
_£_
15
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
13
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
13
11
12
13
12
11
11
10
11
11
12
11
10
12
11
10
10
10
12
9
10
D
3,28540
2 18630
3.39942
2.13035
1.95969
1.62407
2.53038
2.60797
2.31836
2.71721
1,88511
2.56776
1 81469
1,68511
2.64224
1.81373
1.55926
1.81022
1.88123
2.37493
1.61550
0.92822
1.70234
1.26260
2.41262
2.11732
1.06697
1.08697
1.04979
0.48850
1.12857
1.08697
1.12374
1.10858
1.69908
1.82814
0.89100
D
12.296^2
17.06346
16.81556
16.90113
16 901 13
1S.90113
16 901 13
16.11268
16.81054
1659572
13^5433
17.04558
16.59572
IB 59572
15^90239
18.93533
15 21240
16 79053
1679053
16.79053
1590239
1576J76
19.65713
15.36834
15.78276
19.65713
14.88030
9.96341
15.36884
9.18501
16.27094
8.29230
670703
1 1 .59874
14.67182
16.79053
15.36884
9.35445
9.29473
8.93250
12.06946
5.40465
9.55917
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
u
o
0
o
o
0
o
0
0
Q
0
0
0
o
0
o
1
o
o
0
0
o
0
0
1
0
0
0
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
o
o
0
o
c
0
0
0
0
c
o
0
o
o
0
o
0
0
o
0
0
0
c
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
o
0
o
0
0
o
0
0
o
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
o
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
c
0
o
0
0
o
0
0
c
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
(
e
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
E
0
0
5
5
5
5
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
5
5
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
E
0
0
0
0
o
0
o
0
0
o
0
0
0
o
5
5
5
0
o
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
5
0
0
5
5
0
5
0
0
0
0
0
0
F
078 48 38 40 49
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
0 7
8 42 48 38 40
8 43 40 38 49
8 42 48 40 38
8 42 48 40 19
B 48 42 38 40
8 42 46 38 40
B 42 48 38 40
8 42 48 40 38
8 42 48 38 40
B 48 42 38 40
8 42 48 38 40
B 42 48 40 19
B 48 42 38 40
B 42 48 38 40
B 48 42 38 40
B 43 38 42 40
B 33 42 48 40
B 38 42 48 40
B 42 48 40 38
9 48 42 40 38
3 33 48 42 38
J 48 42 38 40
9 48 42 40 49
S 42 48 40 39
i 42 48 40 49
) 33 32 48 42
) 33 32 48 42
J 33 32 48 42
J 33 32 42 43
J 33 32 48 42
} . 33 32 48 42
) 33 32 48 42
) 33 32 48 42
1 48 32 38 40
) 48 32 42 38
070 33 48 42 38
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
D 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
•0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
F
0 19 16 38 7
0 19 16 38 7
0 19 16 38 7
0 19 16 38 7
0 9 16 38 7
0 9 16 38 7
0 9 16 33 7
0 9 38 16 7
0 9 16 38 7
0 9 16 38 7
0 9 38 16 7
0 9 16 38 7
0 9 16 38 7
0 9 16 38 7
0 9 16 38 7
0 9 16 38 47
0 9 16 47 44
0 9 16 38 7
0 9 38 18 47
0 9 38 16 47
0 19 38 16 47
0 19 16 38 7
0 19 16 38 7
0 19 38 16 47
0 19 16 47 7
0 19 16 38 7
0 19 38 16 47
0 19 38 16 7
0 19 16 7 40
0 18 16 47 7
0 19 16 7 40
0 1C 16 47 3B
0 19 38 16 7
0 19 38 16 7
0 19 16 38 47
0 19 16 47 7
0 19 38 16 47
0 19 16 47 7
0 19 16 38 7
0 19 16 38 7
0 19 38 16 7
0 19 16 47 38
0 19 38 7 40
0 19 47 30 7
4.72465
3.00000
4.72465
3.54658
4.19275
2.84828
3.54656
3.54658
3.54658
3.54658
2.84828
3.54658
3.54656
2.84828
3.54658
2.84828
2.84828
3.00000
3.00000
3.54658
2.84828
1.30000
2.84826
2.84828
3.54658
3.54658
1.30000
1.30000
1.30000
1.30000
1.30000
1.30000
1.30000
1.30000
2.84828
2.84828
1.30000
13.73706
21.22283
21.82293
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
2122283
2122283
2122283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
13.73706
13,73706
3.73706
21.22283
21.22283
21.22283
13.73706
13.73706
13.73706
13.73706
13.73708
13.73706
COLUMN KEY:
A CHEMICAL ID
B, STATE ID
C. NO. OF RESIC
D FINAL ACUTE
Q
667760
4.72465
6. 12906
4.72465
4.72465
3.54658
4.72465
4.72465
4.72465
4.72465
3.54658
4.72465
4.72465
3.54858
4.72465
3.54658
3.00000
3.54658
3.54658
4.72485
3.54858
2.84828
3.54658
3.54658
4.72465
4,72465
2.82878
2.62678
2,62678
2.62678
2.62678
2,62678
262678
230000
3.00000
300000
284828
Q
41.98642
41.96642
41.96642
41.96642
41.96642
41.93*42
41.96642
41.27646
41.66642
41.96642
26.24273
41.96642
41.96642
41.96642
41.96642
41.96642
41.96642
41.96642
26.24273
26.24273
26.24273
41.96642
41.96642
36.69675
41.98642
41.96642
36.69875
36.87158
41.96642
41.96642
41.96642
41.96642
26.24273
8«4273
41.96642
41.96642
26.24273
41.96642
41.96642
41.96642
38.87227
41.96642
41.21796
49.28382
EN7 FAMILIES
VALUE (FAV)
8.03264
6.67760
9.96253
8.12906
6.78180
6.67760
5.25072
5.25072
8.03264
6.67760
5.78072
4.94449
8.03264
5.78072
4.94449
5.22336
3.54658
4.72465
4.72465
8.03264
8.03264
3.54656
6.67750
8.03284
8.03264
8.43262
2.84828
2.84828
2.84828
3.54658
2.84828
2.84828
2.84828
2.84828
5.78072
3.54658
3.54658
48.86124
73.01714
50.06389
51.84550
51.84550
5184550
51.84550
41.96642
49.96935
46.55005
41.96542
56.08541
46.55005
46.55006
46.55005
46.55005
49.26382
46.55005
41.96642
41.96642
41.96642
46.55005
44.94655
41.96642
49.26382
44.94656
41.96642
41.96642
92.75S65
49.28382
92.75665
49.28382
41.96642.
41.96642
46.55005
49.26382
41.96842
49.26382
56,45534
49.98935
41.98842
49.26382
92756M
49.96935
ZINC (Contlmmd)
A B C D E F
11.99999 21 44 11 10.16535 00000000 19 47 38 7
8.12906 21 45 9 5.30466 00000000 19 38 7 25
11.99999 21 46 10 9.48712 00000000 19 38 47 7
9.96253 21 47 10 6.B9117 00000000 19 38 7 45
14.37916 21 48 11 10.08600 00000000 19 38 47 7
8.03264
3,03264
8.03264
9.19002
8.03264
8.03264
8.03264
14.37916
8.03284
8.03284
8.03264
8.03264
8.03264
8.03264
8.67179
9.19002
5.25072
B 03264
11.93999
9.19002
11.99999
3.54858
3.54658
3.54658
4.72465
3.00000
3.54656
3.54858
3.00000
7.21011
8.67760
5.7807Z
82.75665
92.75665
92.75665
82.75685
82.75665
92.75665
82.75665
92.75665
92.75665
92.75665
92.75665
92.75665
92.75685
92.75665
92.75665
48.26382
64.E6714
92.75685
48.26382
49.26382
49.26382
82.75665
92.75665
49.26382
92.75685
92.75695
49.26382
82.75665
266.56775
92.75665
266.56775
81.41595
82.75665
82.75665
49.26382
92.75662
48.26382
82.75665
82.75665
92.756S5
82.75665
49,96935
570.65472
92.75665
E. EIGHT CRITERIA (A NUMBER SIGNIFIES A CRITERIA NOT SATISFIED)
f. FOUR MOST SENSITIVE RESIDENT FAMILIES
G. FAMILY MEAN ACUTE VALUE FOR FOUR MOST SENSITIVE SPECIES
Q
13.73706 49.26382 49.96935 92.75665
13.73706 47.22923 92.7S665 315.02075
13.73706 47.22923 4926382 92.75665
1373706 49.96935 92.75665 251.46085
13.73706 47.22923 49.26382 92.75665
e-7
------- |