United States Environmental Protection Agency Office of Air and Radiation Acid Rain Division EPA 430-R-94-002 February 1994 &EPA Do the Acid Rain SO2 Regulations Apply to A Guide for Utilities and Other Electricity Generators ACID 'RAIN PROGRAM ------- Do the Acid Rain Regulations Apply to You? s the unit.. .listed? ...in Table 1, 2, or 3 of 40 CFR 73. (See Appendix D) ...potentially affected? ...an IPP or a QF? a combustion device burning fossil fuel producing electricity for sale in 1985 or on or after 11/15/90? Yes Yes ...that (Das of 11/15/90, had a qualifying power purchase commitment to sell at least 15% of net planned capacity and (2) has net installed capacity < 130% of net planned capacity? Yes No A unit that is exempted or unaffected must continue to meet certain requirements in order to maintain exempted or unaffected status. See the appropriate section of this guide for information on the continuing requirements for your unit. ------- ...a cogenerator? ...an incinerator? ...new? ...that (1) supplied an annual average of 5 1/3 ...that CO combusted<20% fossil fuel (on a ...a unit that commenced commercial of potential electrical output capacity ... Btu basis) on average for the first three years of ... operation on or after 11/15/90? or s; 219,000 MWe-hrs to the grid for sale for ^P operation or from I98S-1987, whichever is any three year period after 11/15/90 and (2) was later and (2) combusted < 20% fossil fuel (on a ~ constructed for the purpose outlined in (1) if Btu basis) on average for any three year period construction commenced on or before 11 /15/90? after 11/15/90? Yes Yes ------- ...using clean fuel? • ...a new unit combusting only fuel with 005% sulfur content by weight and serving generator(s) with total nameplate capacity 25 MWe? i\f ..serving small generator(s)? serving only generator(s) with N nameplate capacity 25 MWe on and after 11115/90? No .retired? .ceased operation. (before it waS issued N an Acid Rain Permit or before the permit istobe renewed)? Yes ...a simple turbine? No .a simple combustion turbine? Noó AffectSd ------- ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This guide was developed by the Acid Rain Division of the Office of Air and Radiation, U.S. Envi- ronmental Protection Agency. This guide was developed and written under the direction of Ms. Kathy Baryiski of the Acid Rain Division. Special thanks to Janice Wagner, Renee Rico, Brian McLean, Tom Eagles, Michael Stenburg, Beth Burns, Donna Attanasio, Bill Bumpers, Gordon Beals, Barbara Cook, Stephen Fotis, Gene Higa, William Marx, Gilbert Sperling, and Margaret Welsh, who reviewed drafts and provided comments. Contractor support was provided by ICF Incorporated. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has reviewed and approved this document for publication. ------- Table of Contents Preface . 1 Overvleiw ............. ................ Iss . . .u•.u•u•us•uI• . .uI .• . .• ill What This Guide Will Tell You v What This Guide Won’t Tell You vii Section 1: DeterminIng Applicability .... . . . I Applying for an Applicability Determination by EPA 2 Affected Units 3 Exempted Units 6 Small New Units Burning Clean Fuels 6 Retired Units 8 Unaffected Units 9 Enslirig Simple Combustion Turbines 10 Existing Units Serving Generators Less Than or Equal To 25 MWe 11 Cogeneration Units 12 Independent Power Pivduction Facilities and Qualifying Facilities 16 Solid Waste Incinerators 20 Section 2: Requirements for Affected and Exempted Units 21 Continuous Emission Monitoring 22 Holding Allowances 22 Designated Representatives 23 Permitting 23 Applying for an Exemption 24 Compliance Timelines 25 Glossary Appendix A: Selected Acid Rain Regulations and Documents Appendix B: EPA Regional and State Office Addresses Appendix C: Applicability Determination Examples Example 1: Listed Unit Example 2: Cogenerator Not Selling Electricity Example 3: Qualifying Facility Example 4: Cogenerator Selling Electricity Example 5: Solid Waste Incinerator Example 6: New, Small, Clean Unit Example 7: Retired Unit Example 8: Existing Simple Combustion Turbine Example 9: Existing Unit Serving A Small Generator Appendix D: Selected List of Units Affected by the Acid Rain Reguiations Appendix E: Certificate of Representation index ------- Preface T his guidance is designed to assist electricity producers in deter- mining whether or not the Acid Rain Program’s sulfur dioxide (SO 2 ) regulations apply to their units. The information provided in this guidance document may be updated as EPA makes additional deci- sions and determinations regarding implementation of the Acid Rain Program. EPA will seek to reconcile implementation of the Acid Rain Program with new legislation, such as the Energy Policy Act of 1992. If desired, the owner or operator of a unit may request that EPA determine if a unit is affected by the regulations under the procedures described in 40 CFR 72.6(c). Publication of this document is not an applicability determination under 40 CFR 72.6(c). If you have further questions on applicability, please call the Acid Rain Hotline at (202) 233-9620, or submit questions in writing to: U.S. EPA Acid Rain Division (6204J) A’fl’N: Applicability 401 M Street, SW Washington, D.C. 20460 Legal Statement This document is intended solely as guidance. It does not represent final Agency action. This document is not intended, nor can it be relied upon, to create any rights enforceable by any party in litigation with the United States. Only a formal applicability determination under the procedures described in 40 CFR 72.6(c) will be enforceable. EPA officials may decide to follow the guidance provided in this document or to vary from it, depending on the specific circumstances encountered. The Agency may change this guidance at any time without public notice. ------- Do the Acid Rain SO 2 Regulations Apply to You? II ------- Overview Q (the approximately 23 million tons of sulfur dioxide (SO 2 ) and 19 million tons of nitrogen oxides (NOr) emitted from all sources in the United States in 1985, about 16 million tons of SO 2 and seven million tons of NO were emitted by electric utility companies. Emissions of SO 2 and NO are the primary causes of acid rain. In order to reduce acid rain in the U.S. and Canada, Title IV of the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990 requires the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to establish a program to reduce emissions, called the Acid Rain Program. The overall goal of the Acid Rain Program is to achieve significant environmental benefits through reductions in SO 2 and NO emissions. To achieve this goal at the lowest cost to society, the Program employs both traditional and innovative market-based approaches for controlling air pollution. In addition, the Program encourages energy efficiency and promotes pollution prevention. Title IV sets as its primary goal the reduction of annual SO 2 emissions by 10 million tons below 1980 levels. Approximately 85 percent of the reduction in emissions is to be achieved by electric utilities. To achieve these SO 2 reductions, the law requires a two-phase tightening of the restrictions placed on fossil fuel-fired power plants. Phase I, which begins in 1995, requires 110 higher-emitting utility plants in 21 eastern and midwestern states to meet an intermediate SO 2 emissions limitation. Phase II, which begins in the year 2000, tightens the annual emissions limitation and expands coverage to most utility units. Under the Program, units are allocated “allowances” by EPA. An allowance is a limited authorization to emit up to one ton of SO 2 during or after a specified calendar year. Once allowances are allo- cated, owners or operators may use their allowances to cover emis- sions, or they may trade their allowances to other units under a market- able allowance program. EPA will keep track of the allowances held by each unit by using the Allowance Tracking System (ATS). I I I ------- Do the Acid Rain SO 2 Regulations Apply to You? Utility units that began operation prior to the passage of the Clean Air Act Amendments (November 15, 1990) are allocated emission allowances based on their historic fuel usage and emission rates specified in Title IV and its implementing regulations. Most units commencing operation from November 15, 1990, through December 31, 1995, will also be allocated allowances under Phase IL* The National Allowance Data Base (NADB), developed by EPA, lists utility units — existing and planned — as well as the information neces- sary to allocate allowances to these units. Units that are affected by the acid rain regulations are required to limit SO 2 emissions to the number of allowances they hold. Some utilities may benefit by selling their allowances while reducing their emissions. Since allowances are fully transferable, these utilities may choose to emit less than their allocated allowances and sell the differ- ence to utilities that would benefit from buying allowances and emit- ting more than their initial allocation. This trading achieves economic efficiency while capping total SO 2 emissions nationwide. * Certain other facilities may be allocated allowances, but they are not subject to emissions limitations under Title IV. These allowances are allocated to provide financial incentives for indirect reductions of SO 2 emissions. Small diesel refining facilities are eligible for allocations based on fuel desulfurization, which will reduce SO 2 emissions from diesel-burning vehicles (see 40 CFR 73 Subpart G). Also, utilities using renewable energy or employing energy conservation measures may be eligible for certain allowances (see 40 CFR 73 Subpart F). 1980 levels of SO 2 Phase I: Emissions standard for higher emitting plants 20 C 0 C o ( 0 E w a) . 15 XC .2.2 .— C E — a t a) w 5— Phase II: Emission standards for most utility plants begin Permanent cap on utility SO 2 emissions 1980 1995 2000 2010 iv ------- Overview In order to maintain a permanent cap on utility SO 2 emissions of 8.95 million tons per year, utility units that begin operation after 1995 generally are not allocated allowances. Affected units not allocated allowances may not emit SO 2 unless they purchase allowances. In any year that a source fails to hold sufficient allowances to cover its emissions, excess emissions penalties will apply. Also, the source must submit a plan to EPA that specifies how the excess SO 2 emissions will be offset, or it will have allowances deducted immedi- ately from its unit account. The Act also calls for a two million ton reduction in NO emis- sions by the year 2000. A significant portion of this reduction will be achieved by requiring coal-fired utility boilers to meet new NO emissions requirements. A marketable allowance program is not part of the NO reduction program. What This Guide Will Tell You This guide is designed to help utilities and other electricity gen- erators determine whether they are affected by the SO 2 and monitoring regulations of the Acid Rain Program. The flow chart on the inside cover provides a quick-reference guide showing categories of units that are affected by, eligible for exemption from, or unaffected by the regulations. The document presents descriptions of these categories, requirements for affected units, and requirements for obtaining exemp- tions. Specific sections of the document are described below. Section 1: Determining Applicability This section outlines how to determine if a unit is affected by the SO 2 and monitoring provisions of the Acid Rain Program. It describes various types of units as defined by the Acid Rain Program and states whether those types are affected by, may be eligible for an exemption from, or are unaffected by the Acid Rain Program. This section also outlines the information that needs to be included in a request for an applicability determination from EPA. V ------- Do the Acid Rain SO, Regulations Apply to You Section 2: Requirements for Affected and Exempted Units A unit that becomes affected by the Program must meet several initial and continuing requirements. This section outlines these re- quirements and provides references for further information. This section also provides compliance timelines for meeting Phase I, Phase I I, and continuous emission monitoring (CEM) requirements, and it lists permit deadlines and dates when units must hold allowances. Appendix A: Selected Acid Rain Regulations and Documents Appendix A lists several acid rain regulations and informational documents, including publication dates and dockets. Appendix B: EPA Regional and State Office Addresses Appendix B presents a Ilist of EPA Regional offices and State environmental offices relevant to the Acid Rain Program. Appendix C: Applicability Determination Examples Appendix C presents several case studies demonstrating how to determine whether the regulations affect certain utility units. Appendix D: Selected List of Units Affected by the Acid Rain Regulations Appendix D provides lists of units affected by the acid rain regu- lations. These lists were published in the Clean Air Act or in regula- tions. Appendix E: Certificate of Representation Appendix E contains the Certificate of Representation form and its instructions. vi ------- What This Guide Won’t Tell You This document does not address Title IV NO control require- ments, which establish new NO emissions limits for existing coal- fired electric utility units. This document also does not address requirements applicable to unaffected units that voluntarily participate in the Acid Rain Program. Sources of SO 2 that are not required to meet Title IV emissions limita- tions may choose to “opt-in” to the Acid Rain Program. The Opt-In Program encourages these sources to reduce emissions of SO 2 in circumstances under which it will be less costly for them to do so than it would be for an affected unit. Note that many units are required to meet SO 2 emissions limita- tions or control requirements under other programs, whether or not they are affected by acid rain regulations. These other limitations may be more stringent than the limitations under Title IV. Non-Title IV requirements are not covered in this guidance. For questions about the Acid Rain Program, or for more informa- tion on the NO requirements or the Opt-In Program, please contact the Acid Rain Hotline at (202) 233-9620. For questions or informa- tion on other Federal or State clean air programs, please contact your State air quality office (see Appendix B). VII ------- Section 1 Determining Applicability I n generaL the acid rain regulations for sulfur dioxide (SO 2 ) are appli- cable to existing utility units serving a generator with nameplate capac- ity of 25 megawatts of electricity (MWe) or greater and almost all new utility units located in the 48 contiguous States and the District of Colum- bia. For the purposes of the Acid Rain Program, the term “utility units” includes units serving generators that supply electricity for sale, whether wholesale or retail. There are, however, applicability exceptions for certain types of units and units meeting specific criteria. These units may be eligible for an exemption or may be unaffected by the acid rain regulations. This section provides the necessary information for determining whether a unit is affected. Note that once a unit becomes affected, it remains affected for the duration of the Program. Section 1 is presented in three parts. The first part describes the characteristics of affected units. The second part describes the characteris- tics of units that may be exempted from certain acid rain regulations. The third part describes six types of units that are unaffected by the regula- tions. Following the descriptions of each of these unit types are checklists of information to include in a request for an applicability determination. If you do not know which type of unit you have, or if you have a unit that may qualify as more than one type, be sure to submit the necessary mate- rial for all potentially relevant categories. I ------- Do the Acid Rain SO Regulations Apply to You? Q ____1 ____ The following are general requirements for filing an applicability determination requës : / The letter requesting ar-i ap- plicabi!it determination must b’e signed by a certifying official.’. ‘/ The letter must pecify the ? unit. Information should include ’. the plant that contains the unit,. the location, of the unit (i.e.,. State and county), the ORISPL r(a plant.cdde used by the; ‘Departnientof Energy) if ppro- priate, and a name or number. for the unit. ,: - / The letter must include the. ifollowing statement: 1 certify unddr peQalty pf law that I have personally ‘examijied, and arñ ’ ; amiiiar ’with, the statements ; nd,. information submitted in, this. .document and all its: ,aV ‘tachrneç its Based on my i 1quiry ‘of those individuals with primary, ;responSibility Lfor obtaining the, information, I cerUf i that th& statements and information ark, to. the dest of my, knowledge: and belief true, accurate, and corn lete. 5j am ‘aware that there are significant’penalties for sub- . ,mitting false, statements and :inforrnetion or omitting required statemeritC and inforrniation, in-, cluding the possibility of fin or imprisonment.” S ‘ The letter’ must be sent’ to the following addr ’ess: U.S. En-. vironmental Protection Agency;i Director, Acid Rain Division (6204J); ATIN: Applicability;, 401 M Street, SW: Washington, DC ‘20460. 5 / The certifying official mi )st send copies ‘of the request to ‘each ”owner or operator of the 4 facility. , ‘ - : ‘ Applying for an Applicability Determination by EPA EPA has adopted a procedure by which owners and operators of any potentially affected unit may choose to ask EPA to determine whether or not Title IV SO 2 requirements apply to their source. See 40 CFR 72.6(c). This procedure is optional ; EPA does not require any owner or operator to request a determination of applicability. Those sources that clearly fit into an unaffected or exempted category should not feel compelled to request an applicability determination. This procedure requires submittal of a written request, including certain information about the unit. In response to that request, EPA will determine if a unit is affected, based on information included in the submittal. EPA will then write a letter stating that the unit is either affected or unaffected. This response letter will constitute final agency action in the absence of an administrative appeal and will be binding upon the permitting authority administering the Acid Rain Program for the unit (i.e., the State or EPA Region). EPA’s determination may be appealed through the Acid Rain Appeals process. If the information originally submitted by the unit was inadequate to make an applicabil- ity determination, EPA may request additional data or write a letter stating that EPA cannot make a determination based on the informa- tion submitted. 2 ------- Determining Applicability Affected Units EPA has compiled a list of the sources of SO 2 emissions known to be affected by the acid rain regulations. All of these “listed units,” Affected which are discussed below, are Phase I or Phase II affected sources. A list of these units is included in Appendix D. If a unit or source is listed in the appendix, it is affected. Some of these units may be eligible for exemptions from certain Acid Rain Program requirements, as dis- cussed below. See 40 CUR 72.6(a). Listed Units Phase I requirements initially affect only the 263 units at the 110 power plants specifically listed in the Clean Air Act and provided in Table 1 of 40 CFR 73.10 (see Exhibit I of Appendix D). Phase II requirements affect a broader group of utility units. Tables 2 and 3 of 40 CUR 73.10 (see Exhibits 2 and 3 of Appendix D) list approximately 2,300 utility units affected by Phase I I requirements. Additional units may become affected under Phase I if they are either “substitution units” or “compensating units.” Utilities have already notified EPA as to which units will be brought into Phase I in this manner. Substitution units are existing units affected under Phase LI that are designated under approved substitution plans and that accept the emission reduction obligation of a unit required to comply with Phase I. Compensating units are Phase II units that are designated under approved reduced utilization plans and that generate electricity to replace electricity historically generated by Phase I units. Unlisted Units The Appendix D listings do not include all units that are or may become affected. Other potentially affected units include: U Units not in the NADB, U Units that are planned, and U Units owned by industrial or commercial entities that sell electricity. 3 ------- Do the Acid Rain SO: Regulations Apply to You? If a unit is not listed in Appendix D, it may be affected by the acid rain regulations only if it meets all three of the following conditions:* I i The unit is a combustion device. U The unit is fossil fuel-fifed. U The unit supplies electricity for sale or serves an electricity.. generating device that supplies electricity for sale. Definitions Unit vs. Generator A unit is a fossil fuel-fired combustion device, such as a boiler. A generator is a device that produces electricity. A unit may be subject to the acid rain regulations if it provides steam or is capable of providing steam or hot air to a generator that produces electricity. A generator itself is not affected by the acid rain regulations. For the purposes of the Acid Rain Program, a com- bined cycle turbine — a turbine with a heat recovery steam genera- tor — will be treated as a single unit. Combustion Devices A combustion device is a device that initiates the chemical reac- tion of fuel and oxygen with the addition of heat. In the case of a combustion device that uses fossil fuels to produce electricity, the combustion of fossil fuels causes the reaction of carbon and hydrogen in the fuel with oxygen in the air to form carbon dioxide and water vapor. Other substances, such as sulfur in the fuel and nitrogen in the air, may also react with the oxygen and thereby produce air pollutants. Fossil Fuel-Fired A source is “fossil fuel-fired” if it combusts any amount of fossil fuel, no matter how small. The definition of fossil fuel includes natural gas, petroleum, coal, and any form of solid, liquid, or gaseous fuel derived from these materials, such as petroleum coke. The definition of natural gas does not include landfill gas, digester gas, or biomass.** Waste fuels, including anthracite cu lm and bituminous coal waste, are also considered fossil fuels for the purposes of the Acid Rain Program. A unit, by definition, is fossil fuel-fired. Thus, a boiler fueled exclusively by fuels other than fossil fuels is not a “unit” or “utility unit” under the regulations, and therefore is not subject to the acid rain regulations. * See 40 CFR 72.2 for the definition of “utility unit.” * * See preamble to the final acid rain “core” rules, 58 FR 3596, January 11, 1993. Examples of Combustion and Non-Combustion Devices combustion Devices Combustion Turbine. A comb us- tuon turbine uses air heated from the combustion of fuel to spin the turbine in a magnetic field, thus creating electricity. Since it is a device that uses combustion to produce electricity directly, it is a combustion device. Boiler. A boiler is an enclosed de- vice that combusts fuel to produce and transfer heat to recirculating water, steam, or any other me- dium. Since it combusts fuel, it is a combustion device. Non-Combustion Devices The! Coil. A fuel cell relies on a electrochemical reaction of fue’ (usually pure hydrogen) with pure oxygen to yield energy and water. Since this reaction is not produced by the addition of heat, it is not a combustion device. 4 ------- Determining Applicability • Supplies Electricity for Sale Any unit that served a generator producing electricity for sale in 1985 or on or after November 15, 1990, is potentially affected by the acid rain regulations. The sale may be wholesale or retail. The “sale of electricity” is the sale of electrical output or capacity or the sale of steam to a steam-electric generator that produces electrical energy for sale. Units that do not produce electricity or steam for sale are not affected. Also, a unit that produces steam or heat rather than electricity for sale is not affected so long as the purchaser of the steam or heat does not produce electricity for sale. A unit that produces limited amounts of electricity for sale may not be af- fected if the unit’s combustion device is used primarily to produce steam or heat. (See Co generation Unit, below.) Even if a unit meets all three of the conditions discussed above, it may be eligible for an exemption or qualify as one of six types of unaffected units. Exemptions may be granted to new utility units generating less than 25 MWe and using fuel with a sulfur, content less than or equal to 0.05 percent, as well as to units that retire. The six categories of unaffected units are existing simple combustion turbines, existing small units, cogenerators, independent power production facilities, qualifying facilities, and solid waste incinerators. The cat- egories are described below in the sections Exempted Units and Unaf- fected Units. 5 ------- Do the Acid Rain SO, Regulations Apply to You? Exempted Units Two categories of affected utility units may be eligible for ex- emptions from many — but not all — of the acid rain regulations: small new units burning clean fuels and retired units. These exempted units must continue to meet certain continuing requirements of the Acid Rain Program to remain exempted. Please refer to Section 2: Require- ments for Affected and Exempted Units for a list of these requiremen 5 In order for a unit to be considered for an exemption. it must submit an application to EPA . The Agency does not require eligible units to apply for an exemption in cases where the owner of a unit does not want the unit exempted. Units that do not obtain an exemption, however, must fully comply with the Acid Rain Program require- ments. If a unit decides to seek and is granted an exemption, it is not eligible to join the Program on a voluntary basis as a substitution unit, a compensating unit, or an opt-in unit. Small New Units Burning Clean Fuels A utility unit may be granted an exemption from acid rain regula- tions if it meets all three of the following requirements:* U The unit is a new unit (i.e., commenced commercial opera- tion on or after November 15, 1990). U The unit is a small unit (i.e., serves generator(s) with total nameplate capacity of 25 MWe or less). U The unit bums clean fuels (i.e., only fuels with sulfur content of 0.05 percent or less by weight). Although the statutory exemption for existing units that serve generators with nameplate capacities of 25 MWe or less does not sum the nameplate capacities of all the generators served by the unit, the exemption for new units requires that the total nameplate capacity served by the unit be 25 MWe or less. For example, boilers headered to more than one generator (multi-header units) will be treated as serving all generators to which they are headered, regardless of the steam capacity of the boiler. * See 40 CFR 72.7. 6 ------- Determining Applicability A small, ne w unit that is granted an exemption will have to forfeit any allowances it received or was to receive as an initial allocation for all years for which the exemption is granted. Also, if the unit gains an exemption, it must comply with the acid rain regulations for all years prior to January 1 of the year after it is issued the exemption. For information on applying for a new unit exemption see Section 2: Requirements for Affected and Exempted Units. Definitions Commence Commercial Operation A unit “commences commercial operation” when it begins to generate electricity for sale, including the sale of test generation. The National Allowance Data Base (NADB Version 2.11) in- cludes the boiler on-line date and generator on-line date (month and year). For units in the NADB that commenced commercial operation by December 1992, the boiler on-line date in the NADB will be used as the date the unit commenced commercial opera- tion. If a unit is not listed in the NADB or if a unit commenced commercial operation after December 1992, the first commercial on-hne date will be determined in accordance with standards used by the Energy Information Administration (E IA). In general, generator first-electricity dates are reported to the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), Energy Information Administration on Form EIA 86O,* and boiler first-fuel consumption is reported on Form E1A 767.* Each unit should have only one date of commencement of com- mercial operation, even if the unit is relocated or restarted after retirement. However, a unit that was substantially modified before November 15, 1990, may be treated as a unique unit with a new commencement of commercial operation date. Nameplate Capacity “Nameplate capacity” is a measure of the capacity of a generator. For a unit listed in the NADB, the nameplate capacity of a genera- tor is defined as the capacity listed for the generator in the NADB. If a unit is not listed in the NADB, the nameplate capacity will be determined in accordance with the DOE standards using Form EIA-860. Generator nameplate capacity as defined on Form E IA- 860 is the full-load continuous rating of a generator, prime mover, or other electric power production equipment under specific conditions as designated by the manufacturer. Installed generator nameplate rating is usually indicated on the nameplate physically attached to the generator. If more than one capacity appears on the nameplate, the highest capacity is reported on Form EIA-860. * A description of Forms EIA-860 and EJA-767 is provided in the Glosswy. Example of New Commercial Commencement The Tidd plant in Ohio was retired pnor to 1985. The plant was sub- stantially modified and repowered through a clean coal Technology project and began operation again in October, 1990. Therefore, EPA assigned this plant a commenced commercial operation date of October 1990. 7 ------- Do the Acid Rain SO 2 Regulations Apply to You ? Burns Clean Fuel Clean fuels are fuels with sulfur content of 0.05 percent or less by weight. All natural gas, including most “sour” gases, meets this standard. On-road diesel fuel meeting the new requirements of the Clean Air Act (Section 211(i)) will also meet this standard. A unit obtaining an exemption under this provision must test petroleum or petroleum products and gaseous fuels, other than natural gas, according to the appropriate ASTM methods to assure compliance starting on the first day the exemption takes effect . Retired Units A utility unit may be granted an exemption from the acid rain regulations if it retires before the issuance (or renewal) of its Phase H acid rain permit (see 40 CFR 72.8). These “retired” units must docu- ment the actual or expected date of retirement as well as any actions that have been taken to retire the unit and to prevent any further emis- sions of SO 2 and NOR. If the unit gains an exemption, it must comply with the acid rain regulations until January 1 of the year after it is issued the exemption. Therefore, to avoid installation and testing of continuous emission monitoring (CEM) systems required by the Acid Rain Program, a unit must apply for this exemption prior to January 1, 1995. If a retired unit is to resume operation, its Designated Representa- tive must submit an acid rain permit application not less than 24 months prior to January 1, 2000 or the date the unit is to resume operation, whichever is later. For information on applying for a retired unit exemption see Section 2: Requirements for Affected and Exempted Units. 8 ------- Determining Applicability Unaffected Units Some sources of SO 2 emissions that generate electricity for sale or provide steam or heat for electricity generation are not subject to emissions limitations under Title IV. The following six types of elec-. tricity generat1ng units are not affected by the regulations under certain conditions: tJ Existing Simple Combustion Turbines, under 40 CFR 72.6(b)( 1). ( Existing Small Units, under 40 CFR 72.6(b)(2). D Cogenerators, under 40 CFR 72.6(b)(4). Li Independent Power Production Facilities, under 40 CFR 72.6(b)(6). U Qualifying Facilities, under 40 CFR 72.6(b)(5). Li Solid Waste Incinerators, under 40 CFR 72.6(b)(7). Units in each category must meet requirements specific to that category to be unaffected. These requirements are discussed below. A unit need only qualify as unaffected under one of these categories in order to be unaffected. In order to remain unaffected, these units must meet a set of “continuing requirements,” also discussed below. If a facility is unaffected under more than one provision, it will remain unaffected until it loses its unaffected status for all appropriate provisions. For example, if a unit is unaffected as both an IPP and a QF, then it will remain unaffected if it loses its status as unaffected IPP but retains its status as an unaffected QF. The Acid Rain Program does not require an unaffected unit to submit proof of its status. However, units may be required to provide documentation supporting their claim of unaffected status, if requested by EPA or the State or Regional permitting authority. Unaffected units may become affected under certain operating or construction condi- tions. It is the duty of the unit’s owner and operator to meet the re- quirements of the Acid Rain Program if the unit becomes affected. Also, unaffected units may be eligible to opt-in to the Program, as discussed above in What This Guide Won’t Tell You. 9 ------- Do the Acki Rain SO 2 Regulations Apply to You? Submit the following to. have EPA deterthine wh ther your ‘combustion tuthine Is affected: / Information on the, unit’s’ op- erational characteristics (i.e., whether’ the system captures hot aIr exiting the turbine ; through a heat recovery steam: ge erator or a waste heat boiler or lacks such capability), such as a, ystem di gram. / lnfo ’rmation demonstrating that the unit did not use auxil-’ iary firing from 1985 to 1987k. ,nor after, Novembe r 15, 1990. i / The date the unit ’donimenced com ’merciál. operation,. as ‘re , ported to EIA. ‘ ‘ , • ‘ , (1) Existing Simple Combustion Turbines A utility unit is not affected by the acid rain regulations if it meets both of the following conditions: U The unit is a simple combustion turbine. U The unit is an existing unit (i.e., commenced commercial operation before November 15, 1990). Definitions Simple Combustion Turbine For the purposes of the acid rain regulations, a “simple combustion turbine” is defined to include a combined cycle unit that did not use auxiliary firing in 1985 through 1987 and will not use auxil- iary firing at any time after November 15, 1990. A combined cycle unit that uses auxiliary firing during these periods does not qualify as a simple combustion turbine. Combined Cycle Unit In a combustion turbine, air heated from the combustion of fuel causes a turbine to spin in a magnetic field, which, in turn, creates electricity. If the hot air exiting the turbine is captured through a heat recovery steam generator or waste heat boiler, the turbine is a combined cycle unit. Auxiliary Firing In some combined cycle units, additional fuel is burned in a duct or in a heat recovery steam generator in order to enhance the production of steam. This is called auxiliary, or supplemental, firing. Continuing Requirements If a simple combustion turbine installs and uses auxiliary firing, it will become an affected unit. To remain unaffected, a simple combus- tion turbine may not add or begin using auxiliary firing. Examples of Combustion Turbines Example 1: Two simple turbines feed a common header to a single heat recovery steam generator (i.e., together they constitute a com- bined cycle unit) that has auxiliary firing. Neither turbine qualifies as a simple ‘combustion turbine. Example 2: A combustion turbine serves a heat recovery generator that installed a duct burner in 1983. Due to poor efficiency in the duct burner, the duct burner is not uti- lized after 1984, although not re- moved. The turbine is a “simple combustion turbine” as defined. 10 ------- Determining Applicability (2) Ex 5th g iu vL g Than or Eqi n T© A utility unit is not affected if it meets both of the following requiremefl U The unit serves a small generator (i.e., the largest generator served by the unit, on or after November 15, 1990, has a nameplate capacity less than or equal to 25 MWe). U The unit is an existing unit (i.e., commenced commercial operation before November 15, 1990). The term “serve” means either providing steam or being capable of providing steam to a generator. A unit on cold standby is considered capable of providing steam. The only units EPA can confirm through DOEIEIA data as not serving a generator are those units that are reported as. retired. Generators listed in the NADB are defined to have the nameplate capacity listed in the NADB. The regulations are not designed to penalize units that improve efficiency without increasing emissions. Thus, if a generator listed in the NADB is modified to produce over 25 MWe capacity because of significant improvements in turbine effi- ciency only, the units serving this generator do not become affected. For example, a boiler that in 1988 served a generator of 22 MWe nameplate capacity, as listed in the NADB, may retain its unaffected status if that generator is renovated to increase its output capacity from the same steam input. Unaffected units are required to submit informa- tion on improved turbine efficiency only if specifically requested by EPA or the State or Regional permitting authority. However, if a boiler served a generator of 22 MWe nameplate• capacity before November 15, 1990, that is replaced with a new generator of greater than 25 MWe nameplate capacity after November 15, 1990, then that boiler will be affected. Also, if a new generator is hnked to that boiler and if that generator has a nameplate capacity of greater than 25 MWe, the boiler will be affected. On the other hand, if a boiler that serves a generator of 22 MWe nameplate capacity is hnked to a new generator of 5 MWe nameplate capacity, the boiler will not be affected because it is not serving any individual generator of greater than 25 MWe nameplate capacity. SubmIt the fol owIrig have EPA dete rm ne whether your sma l unit is a ected: V The nameplate capacity of all generators served by the unit on or after November 15, 1990. / The date the unit commenced commercial operation. Conthuj g R qemetnt If after November 15, 1990, the existing utility unit serves a generator with a nameplate capacity of greater than 25 MWe, it will become an affected unit. Examples o ExistIng limits Example 1: Unaffected Unit. In 1985, a boiler served a 5 MWe generator and a 45 MWe generator that were used to produce electric- ity for sale. In 1988, the 45 MWe generator was retired. The boiler is not affected because, as of No- vember 15, 1990, it did not serve a generator with nameplate capac- ity greater than 25 MWe. Example 2: Affected Unit. Three boilers, two consuming coal and one burning natural gas, com- menced commercial operation in 1967. The boilers feed a common header that serves two generators, one of 11 MWe nameplate capacity and one of 26 MWe nameplate capacity, that are used to produce electricity for sale. All three boilers are affected because one of the generators has a nameplate ca- pacity greater than 25 MWe. Even if no one boiler could produce enough steam to feed the 26 MWe generator, all boilers are affected. 11 ------- Do the Acid Rain SO, Regulations Apply to You 7 (3) Cogeneration Units A cogeneration unit (or cogenerator) is a unit that produces steam or heat both for direct use and to run an electricity generator. Definition Cogeneratlon Unit A cogeneration unit is a unit that produces electric energy and various forms of useful thermal energy (such as heat or steam) for heating or cooling purposes by using the waste heat of one process as the energy input into a subsequent process. For example, a unit that produces electricity and then uses the waste heat of that process as energy to run a process that cools another unit is a cogenerator. The statute provides that some cogenerators may not be affected by the Title IV regulations. Although many cogenerators were con- structed primarily to serve a specific industrial need, they often sell excess electricity to local utilities for distribution to the utilities’ customers. Because only “utility units” (i.e., units that are used to produce electricity for sale) are affected by Title IV regulations, EPA makes a distinction between cogenerators operating to sell electricity and those operating primarily for self-generation (e.g., boilers for in- house use that do not sell electricity).* The key factors are the portion of “potential electrical output capacity” (a capacity-equivalent of the boiler) sold and the actual MWe-hrs of electrical output sold. Which Cogenerators are Unaffected? For cogeneration units that commenced construction on or before November 15, 1990, a unit is unaffected if it was constructed for the purpose of supplying less than or equal to one third of its potential electrical output capacity or less than or equal to 219,000 MWe-hrs of annual electrical output.** Documents that can be used for determin- ing the purpose of construction include permitting applications, con- struction contracts, and original plant diagrams. In the absence of information regarding the purpose of construction (often the case with very old plants), EPA will assume that actual operations from 1985 through 1987 represent that purpose. If the unit began operations after 1985, EPA will use the operational data for the first three calendar years of operation to make the determination of purpose. * A cogenerator also may be unaffected by the regulations because it is a qualify- ing facility or an independent power production facility. These types of facilities are discussed below. * 1 219,000 MWe-hours is equal to 25 MWe multiplied by 8,760 hours, the number of hours in a year. 12 ------- Determining Applicability Potential electrical output capacity is the MWe capacity rating for the unit, which is equal to 33 percent of the maximum design heat input capacity of the steam generating unit for boilers and simple combustion turbines. The potential electrical output Capacity for these units is calculated using the following equation:* (Maximum Design Heat Input (mniBtu/hr)) X (1,000,000 Btu/l mmBtu) x (33%) x (1 kw-hr/3,413 Btu) x (1 MWe/l,000 kw) = MWe For multi-headered boilers, the potential electrical output capacity for the entire source is equal to the sum of the potential electrical output capacities for each boiler. To compare an individual boiler’s potential electrical output capacity to the generator capacity (in MWe), determine the total generator nameplate capacity (if there are multiple generators) and divide by the boiler’s proportional share of steam based on the unit’s potential electrical output capacity (see example). EPA will work with the unit to determine the appropriate sharing of output capacity. For combined cycle combustion turbines, the Agency will con- sider information as to actual efficiency of a specific system. EPA understands that many combined cycle combustion turbines operate at approximately 50 percent efficiency. Thus, to calculate the actual electrical output, the maximum fuel flow (in mmBtu/hr as an aggre- gate value for the turbine and any supplemental or auxiliary burners) multiplied by 50 percent, should be substituted for the first term in the equation presented above: (Maximum Fuel Flow (mmBtu/hr)) x (1,000,000 Btull mmBtu) x (50%) x (lkw-hr/3,4l3 Btu) x (I MWe/l,000 kw) = MWe For complex multi-headered combined cycle units, the owner/ operator may request to use a formula that more accurately estimates the potential electrical output capacity for the unit(s). To determine whether the unit is affected, compare the potential electrical output capacity to the nameplate capacity of the generator. If the nameplate capacity of the generator is more than one third of the potential electrical output capacity, then the annual sales must be evaluated. If the annual electrical sales exceed 219,000 MWe-hrs, the unit will be affected. The calculation of actual electrical output should incorporate mdirect steam supplied to a steam-electric generator that will produce electrical energy for sale. Convert the Btus of steam sold to MWe-hrs based on the equation for potential electrical output capacity above assunung 33 percent efficiency. Add the MWe-hrs of steam to the direct MWe-hrs supplied for a total. Example of Potential Electrical Output Capacity A boiler has a maximum design heat input capacityof 340 mmBtu/ hr. Using the conversion equation, (340,000,000 Btu/hr) x (1/3) x (1 kw-hr/3,413 Btu) x (1 MWe/ 1,000 kw), this boiler has a potential electri- cal output capacity of 33.2 MWe. Example of Actual Electrical Output from a Cogenerator Providing Steam to a Generator That Provides Electricity A cogeneration unit provides 175,000 MWe-hrs of electricity to the grid and 100 mmBtufhr of steam to a second generator that sells electricity. (100,000,000 Btu/hr) x (1/3) x (1 kw-hrf 3,413 Btu) x (1 MWe/ 1,000kw)x8,76Ohrs/yr= 85,555 MWe-hrs Thus, the total electricity sold is 175,000 + 85,555 = 260,555 MWe-hrs. * Appendix D of 40 CFR 72. 13 ------- Do the Acid Rain S0 Regulations Apply to You? Example of Cogenerator DetermInations Situation I: Boiler 1 (1,024 mmBtu/hr) serves Generator A (50 MWe nameplate) Boiler 2 (4,100 mmBtu/hr) serves Generator B (50 MWe nameplate) To calculate Potential Electrical Output Capacity: Boiler I = (1,024,000,000 Btu/hr) x (33%) x (1 kw-hr/3,413 Btu) x (1 MWe/1,000 kw) = 100 MWe Boiler 2 = (4,100,000,000 Btu/hr) x (33%) x (1 kw-hr/3,413 Btu) x (1 MWe/1,000 kw) = 400 MWe First, compare nameplate capacity of generator served to potential electrical output capacity of boiler: Boiler 1 serves 50 MWe/100 MWe = 50% of potential capacity Boiler 2 serves 50 MWe/400 MWe = 12.2% (Boiler 2 is unaffected because 12.2% is less than 33%.) Because Boiler 1 serves over 50% of potential electrical output capacity, calculate the actual electrical output at 1/3 potential electrical output capacity for Boiler I only: Boiler 1 = 1/3 x 100 MWe x 8,760 hr/year = 292,000 MWe-hrs If Generator A sells less than this every year, Boiler 1 is unaffected as well. Situation II: If Boilers I and 2 are multi-headered to Generators A and B, we compare the proportion of electrical output to total nameplate capacity. Boiler 1 serves 100 MWe/500 MWe (total unit capacity) x 100 MWe (total generator nameplate) = 20 MWe = 20% of its Potential Electrical Output Capacity Boiler 2 serves 400 MWe/500MWe x 100 MWe = 80 MWe = 20% of its Potential Electrical Output Capacity (Result - both boilers are unaffected because both produce less than 33% of potential capacity.) 14 ------- Detei’niining Applicability iñuhig I equüveanents ____ Unaffected cogeneratOrs must continue to supply one-third or less ,subm , the fo l oowmg to 1 df potentia l electrical output capacity or 219,000 MWe-hrs or less of have EPA detemime actual electflca l output to any utility power distribution system for sale whether your annually calculated as an average over any three calendar year penod cogeneration 1 unit ls l atter iNovember 15, 1990 If a cogenerator does not meet this require- affected ment, t will become affected / The date the ui it commenced construction / A system diagram of the steam/electric facil 1 ty ‘ / If the unit commenced con s ruction before Nqvember p15, 1990, information as to the ‘pur pose of the unit and/or steam and electn6ity sales and 1 usel ____________________________________________________ data from 1985 through 1987 Example of Continuing Requirements and Applying the / The na?rieplate capacity of Three-Year Rolling Average 4 each generator served by the Year S sold 210 000 MWe-hrs electricity unit 9 ” The tmaxirnum 4 desidnfl, Year 2 sold 215 000 MWe-hrs electricity b input: (in :mm6tu/hr)ief th. , . unit Year 3 sold 200 000 MWe hrs electricity and of all other units headered 4 so(d 248 000 MWe-hrs electricity to the generators it serves jhe three calendar year rolling average for Years 2 through 4 is / If the facility is in operation 221 000 MWe-hrs Thus if the average electrical outputexceeds thç annual ,electrioal sales (in 1/3 of the potential electrical output capacity in Years 2 through MWe hrs) 4 the unit would become affected beginning in Year 4 / The annual steam sales ______________ (mmBtu) that are used to pro- duce eleatricity 15 ------- Do the Acid Rain SO 2 ReguIatior Apply to You? (4) Independent Power Production Facilities and (5) Qualifying Facilities Certain independent power production facilities and qualifying facilities are not affected by the Acid Rain Program regulations. Definition Independent Power Production Facility (1PP) An “independent power production facility” (IPP) is a source developed, usually by private investors, to serve as a wholesaler of power to a public utility. The Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 (PURPA) provided a loose framework for the IPP industry. IPPs may offer utilities energy at lower cost and lesser risk than building electric plants or purchasing power from other utilities. LPPs and utilities negotiate preliminary power commit- ments, which often include 20- or 30-year terms. After obtaining the commitment, the project developers negotiate fuel supply, transportation contracts, construction contracts, site lease, and other project specifications. For these projects, lenders have recourse only to the assets and cash flows associated with a specific project and not to a parent company or partner companies that provide equity or other assurances. This type of financing is called “nonrecourse project financing.” In order for an IPP project to be unaffected by the Title IV regula- tons, it must meet the following requirements: U The project must be nonrecourse project financed. U The project must sell at least 80 percent of the power gener- ated at wholesale. o The project must have no more than 50 percent direct public utility ownership. This does not preclude indirect ownership of an IPP by a public utility through its unregulated subsid- iaries or affiliates. 16 ------- Determining Applicability Definition Qualifying Facility (QF) A “qualifying facility” (QF) is a qualifying cogeneration facility or qualifying small power production facility as defined under PURPA. Small power production facilities are facilities generating not more than 80 MWe that employ renewable resources — such as water power, solar energy, wind energy, geothermal energy, biomass, or waste — as a primary fuel. In order for a cogeneration facility to be a qualifying facility, it must meet the following requirements: 0 No electric utility or public utility holding company or any organization* owned by either may own more than 50 percent of equity interest in the facility. 0 The unit must meet operating and efficiency standards specified in 18 CFR 292.205. Many cogenerators meet these requirements. In order for a small power production facility to be a qualifying facility, it must meet all three of the following requirements: 0 The unit must use fuel that is composed of more than 75 percent biomass, waste, renewable resources, geothermal resources, or some combination of the above. U Fossil fuels must compose less than 25 percent of the fuel used by the facility. U No electric utility or public utility holding company or any organization* owned by either may own more than 50 percent of equity interest in the facility. As few small power production facilities meet QF fuel require- ments, most QFs are qualifying cogeneration facilities.** In some instances, a qualifying small power production facility may be unaffected under the provisions applicable to solid waste incinerators. Qualifying cogeneration facilities may also be unaffected under the cogenerator provisions, but qualifying cogeneration facilities need only satisfy the provisions for any one of the six types of electric- ity-generating units described (see 40 CFR 72.6(b)) in order to be unaffected. * Organization as defined as “person” in the Federal Power Act, Section 3. This definition includes municipalities as well as other individuals and organizations. ** See 18 CFR 292.204. 17 ------- Do the Acid Rain SO, Regulations Apply to You 2 Example of Whether a Unit Is Affected based on Total Planned Net Output Capacity Example .1: An IPP had qualifying power purchase commitments demonstrating that 100 MWe of capacity was planned and that 17% of its total planned net output ca- pacity would be sold. The facility commences commercial operation with 110 MWe capacity. As such, all units at the facility are unaf- fected (assuming all other require- ments are met) If an additional boiler-generator pair, with the same emission rates as the rest of the facility, is added for more than 20 MWe additional capacity (bringing the total capacity of the facility to over 130 MWe), this new boiler Nould be affected. Example 2: An IPP has a power purchase commitment in 1989 for SO MWe, but the power purchase :ommitment did not list planned capacity. In 1989, the IPP signed a construction contract for two coal- ired boilers and generators, with ?ach generator rated at 50 MWe capacity. In 1992, the IPP signed 3nother power purchase commit- nent for 70 MWe and contracted construction of another 50 MWe lenerator to be served by a gas- red boiler. The entire facility com- nences commercial operation in 1996. From these facts, the total lanned net output capacity of the acilityon November15, 1990 was 100 MWe. However, part of the acuity is affected by the Acid Rain ‘rogram because, as constructed, the facility’s total installed net out- ‘ut capacity is greater than 130% ifthat planned. Because the ernus- don rates of SO 2 and NO of the coal-fired and gas-fired boilers are lifferent, EPA may choose which ioiler is affected. Only one boiler, however, will be affected. While EPA’s rules provide the limit on ownership interest for unaffected independent power production facilities, Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) rules established under PURPA limit ownership interests for QFs. FERC rules generally do not allow a partially or wholly owned subsidiary of an electric utility or electric utility holding company to have more than 50 percent ownership in a qualifying facility. * IPPs and QFs may be regulated under both Title IV and Tide I II. For example, a unit burning waste fuels for more than 20 percent of its fuel may be regulated as both a solid waste incinerator under Title III and as an affected unit under Tide IV. This would occur if “waste fuel,” which is considered a “fossil fuel” under the Acid Rain Pro- gram, is considered also to be a “refuse-derived fuel” under the solid waste incinerator provisions of Title Ill** Which IPPs and QFS are Unaffected? In order for an IPP or a QF to be unaffected, it must meet all three of the following requirements: 0 The facility must meet the definition of an IPP or a QF as described above. U The facility must have, as of November 15, 1990, a “qualify- ing power purchase commitment” to sell at least 15 percent of its total planned net output capacity. U The total installed net output capacity of the facility must not exceed 130 percent of the total planned net output capacity. The total planned net output capacity of a facility is established by reference to the power purchase commitment in place as of Novem- ber 15, 1990 or by reference to other contemporaneous documents, such as submissions to a State environmental authority or construction contracts. For example, a facility with a planned net output capacity of 100 MWe must have, as of November 15, 1990, a qualifying power pur- chase commitment of at least 15 MWe. If the facility has more than one qualifying power purchase commitment, the sum of the committed capacities is compared to the planned capacity (e.g., a facility planned for 200 MWe could have two qualifying power purchase commitments for 15 MWe each and be unaffected). * See 18 CFR 292.206. * * See Title I I I implementing regulations for detai]s. Some Tale I I I regulations, specifically those for non-municipal waste, have not been written at this time. ------- Determining Applicability Definition __________ Qualifying Power Purchase Commitment A qualifying power purchase commitment is a formal agreement or requirement with a utility for the purchase of power Utilities may include cooperative utilities, municipal electric authonties, and other sellers of electricity. The most common type of power comm itment was entered i ip a i purchase commitment is the power sales agreement (PSA). Other types of power purchase commitments include a letter of intent to purchase power at a given pnce, a State regulatory authority order 4It t %tbe \tpower purchase comr to purchase power, and the selection of the facility as the winning bidder in a utility competitive bid solicitation imenttwas entereth tt% Sai i • . /kThe totai pIanned net toutpub To be a qualifying power purchase commitment, the power • . purchase commitment must meet all three of the following + • ror contem oraheoa kdocument l requiremenLs. $t , The commitment must have been entered into on or before November 15, 1990. omm itmentnt t e U At least one of the following two elements must remain unchanged (from November 15, 1990 to the present): the l ident itytof 4he *eIectnca 3o n • t t * i — The identity of the electricity purchaser. a ifl 4 \ — The identity of the steam purchaser and the planned location of the facility a ç M*if the facttttyJhas”commenced l • • O The commitment must not shift or allow the shift of the cost of compliance with the acid rain regulations to the purchaser. If an I PP 4 ,nformat ,on%show - • r e * c Contünuiing Requü eirnents • • •• show4 For IPPs and QFs to remain unaffected, they must continue to meet the definition of an IPP and QF, respectively, and continue to meet the requirements stated above. For example, if an IPP continues cent pA ¼ 4ta 6 to have less than 50 percent direct ownership by a public utility, it will / If an IPP, informat ion that still meet the definition of an IPP and, if it continues to meet the other requirements, will remain unaffected If an IPP or QF adds capacity such that the total installed net output capacity is greater than 130 percent of total planned net output capacity, then either some portion irtg fac iI ity statu s undeNthe or all of the facility — depending on the facility configuration — will become affected. 10 ------- Do the Acid Rain SO ReguTations Apply to You? merQiaI operaJon after January ’. 1, 1985 hform tiono, o$era • ‘is 4 , c- ‘ ‘X \ ’ • \ ‘ , ‘• , rnformat o pn operatpons; in -. k zt985i986; ar d i98Z as well ••1• . a fo ’the yearsL1991 on t ‘ lnformat:on proyided on Form 767 of*4he Department of En- . Ad in t ttd (ElA)flickidirig: M 4 Da Jsed by the uçnt inciuding: Btits ,of aste fuel and Btus l of i u’mê ’d (6) Waste e ito rs If a unit is a “solid waste incinerator” that produces electricity for sale or provides steam or heat for electricity generation, it may be affected by the acid rain regu1ations . A solid waste incinerator is a unit that burns nonhazardous solid wastes from commercial or industrial establishments or the general public (e.g., residences). For example, a QF that bums municipal solid waste is a solid waste incinerator and may be unaffected under this provision if it meets the requirements discussed belOw. The definition of a solid waste incinerator does not include the following categories of facilities: c i Incinerators of hazardous wastes; Materials recovery facilities;” ci Qualifying facilities that burn homogeneous wastes (except for. refuse-derived fuel), including tires and used oil; and ci Air curtain incinerators burning wood wastes, yard wastes, and clean lumber. Which So d Waste linchierators a è Unaffected? Solid waste incinerators burning less than 20 percent fossil fuels (on a Btu, or heat input, basis) are not affected by the acid rain regula- tions. The unit must meet this requirement on average for the three years from 1985 to 1987 or for the first three calendar years of opera- tion if the unit began operation after 1985. Solid waste incinerators may also be subject to other control, technology-based requirements under the Clean Air Act. — :ample of Three-Calendar- Year Rolling Basis it I - burns 16% fossil fuel, raged over the year it 2- burns 16% fossil fuel r3- burns 19% fossil fuel it 4- burns 31% fossil fuel three calendar year rolling av- eforyears lthrough 3 is 17%. iever, the three calendar year ng average for years 2 through 22%, making the unit affected inning in Year4. (Note that the must have allowances for Year January 30 of Year 5.) Conthn fing eq re ents An unaffected solid waste incinerator must continue to combust less than 20 percent fossil fuels (on a Btu basis) on three-calendar-year rolling average for any period after November 15, 1990, in order to stay unaffected. Fuel consumption for most units is reported to the Department of Energy, Energy Information Administration, in’Btus, on Form EIA-767. • 20 ------- DJT © 0 : o o1 , unit must comply with acid rain regulations, including t . holçling allowances sufficient to cover its annual SO 2 emissions, acid rain permit (which is part of the unit’s general air p rrnit), having a Designated Representative (DR), and installing and koperating ystems that continuously monitor emissions of SO 2 , NOR, and other related pollutants These requirements are discussed below Th onl jway an affected unit may avoid the full requirements of the Acid Rain Program is by qualifying for an “exemption,” as de- scribed in S ctzon 1 Even if a unit is awarded an exemption, it is subject to certain minimum requirements Inlorthation presented in this section is provided as summary ,guidance for the Acid Rain Program requirements This section also pr wides corhphance timehnes for Phase I and Phase II of the Program as well as fcir continuous emission monitoring (CEM) For more detailed infc mation on the regulations, please refer to 40 CFR 72-78, OtnCali ctheAèjd Rain ]H [ otline at (202) 233-9620. 21 ------- Do the Acid Rain SO, Regulations Apply to You Continuous Emission Monitoring Each affected unit must continuously measure and record its emissions of SO 2 , NOR. and carbon dioxide, as well as volumetric flow, opacity, and diluent gas, unless otherwise specified in regula- tions at 40 CFR 75. Most units must be equipped with a continuous emission monitoring (CEM) system. CEM systems are critical to the Acid Rain Program for several reasons: C) They ensure compliance with the emissions limitations. C) They instill confidence in allowance transactions by certify- ing the existence and quantity of the commodity being traded. U They track the progress of the Program. The CEM rule (40 CFR 75) also contains provisions for initial equipment certification procedures, periodic quality assurance and quality control procedures, recordkeeping and reporting, and proce- dures for filling in missing data periods. Affected units are required to report emissions data to EPA ’s Emission Tracking System on a quar- terly basis. Please refer to the compliance timeline table at the end of this section for dates by which installation and certification testing of CEM systems must be complete. Holding Allowances Each affected unit must hold an allowance for every ton of sulfur dioxide emitted during a calendar year. To support this requirement, EPA has developed an electronic recordkeeping and notification system, called the Allowance Tracking System (ATS), to keep track of allowance transactions and the status of allowance accounts. ATS will provide the official tally of allowances by which EPA will determine compliance with the emissions limitations. An ATS account has been established for each unit listed in Exhibits 1, 2, and 3 of Appendix D. EPA will open an account for affected units not listed in Exhibits 1, 2, or 3 of Appendix D upon submittal of Certificate of Representation for the source identifying a Designated Representative. Once EPA receives a Certificate of Repre- sentation, it will establish an account for each unit at the source. This certificate must be submitted to EPA with or-prior to the permit appli- cation for the unit. Any other party interested in participating in the trading system may open an ATS account by submitting a general account application to EPA. What Are the Monitoring Renuirements? The owner or operator of an affected unit must install CEM system on the unit and pro- vide emission reports to EPA unless otherwise specified in the regulations. CEM systems include the following: O An SO 2 pollutant concen- tration monitor O A NO pollutant concentra- tion monitor O A volumetric flow monitor O An opacity monitor o A diluent gas (oxygen or C0 2 ) monitor that monitors CO 2 O A data acquisition and han- dling system (computer- based) for recording and performing calculations with the data. Refer to 40 CFR 75 for excep- tions and other additional re- quirements. 22 ------- Requirements for Affected and Exempted Units The ATS also provides the allowance market with a record of who is holding allowances, the date of allowance transfers, and the allowances transferred. The ATS does not, however, record the price or other terms associated with allowance trades; such information is better collected and reported by the private sector through established exchanges or other trade information brokers. Each affected unit must hold sufficient allowances in its account by January 30 (or, if January 30 is not a business day, the first business day thereafter) to cover its emissions for the previous year. For ex- ample, a new affected unit that commences commercial operation during 2002 must hold sufficient allowances in its account to cover its emissions of SO 2 during the year 2002 by January 30, 2003. If a unit emits more tons of SO 2 than allowances it holds in its account, the additional tons of SO 2 emitted and not covered by allow- ances are called “excess emissions.” Under the Acid Rain Program, if a unit has excess emissions, it must pay $2,000 (adjusted by the Con- sumer Price Index) per ton of excess emissions and submit an offset plan. The offset plan tells how many allowances are to be deducted from the unit’s allowance account for future years to offset the previ- ous year’s excess emissions. Thus, a unit must make up for all excess emissions. Designated Representatives Each source must appoint one individual, the Designated Repre- sentative, to represent the owners and operators of the source in all matters relating to the holding and disposal of allowances for its affected or exempted units. The Designated Representative is also responsible for all submissions pertaining to permits, compliance plans, emission monitoring reports, offset plans, compliance certifica- tion, and other required information. To specify a Designated Repre- sentative, complete the Certificate of Representation. The Certificate of Representa1 ion form and instruction are provided in Appendix E. Permitting The Designated Representative for each affected source is re- quired to file a permit application for the source and a compliance plan for each affected or exempted unit at the source with the permitting authority. The permitting authority is either the approved State permit- ting authority or EPA. Contact the EPA Regional office to determine the appropriate permitting authority for your unit(s). See Appendix B. For exempted units, the exemption itself serves as a permit for the unit. Both permits (for affected units) and exemptions (for exempted units) must be renewed every five years. What information Is Contained in ATS Accounts? ATS accounts include the name and address of the au- thorized account representa- tive (the official contact per- son for the account); the allowances in current and fu- ture subaccounts; and a record of allowance transfers to and from the account. Information in the ATS accounts is avail- able to the public. What information Must Be included In Permit Applications? The source must complete standard forms when applying for an acid rain permit. The forms request information about the Designated Repre- sentative, general plant infor- mation, specific unit informa- tion, and a compliance plan for each affected unit. Forms can be obtained from a per- mitting authority. Please refer to Appendix B. ------- Do the Acid Rain SO, Regulations Apply to You? The Acid Rain Program operating permit details the specific program requirements and compliance options chosen by each source. The permits and compliance plans aim to provide flexibility, which is a goal of the Acid Rain Program as a whole; permits and compliance plans are designed to complement the marketable allowance program and foster trading. The permits and compliance plans also let sources fashion a compliance strategy tailored to their individual needs. The permit stipulates the initial annual allowance allocation for each affected unit at a source. The permit application must certify that each unit’s account will hold a sufficient number of allowances to cover the unit’s SO 2 emissions for the year and that the unit will comply with the applicable NO limit. In addition, the compliance plans may specify alternative measures that will be taken to ensure compliance. Permits are subject to public comment before approval. Applying for an Exemption Small, new units burning clean fuel and retired units that meet the requirements stated in Section 1: Exempted Units can apply for an exemption with the permitting authority. The Designated Representa- tive for a small, new unit can apply for an exemption. Any allowances allocated to a small, new unit must be surrendered for any year for which the unit is exempted. For retired units, the Designated Representative must submit a petition for written exemption to the permitting authority on or before (1) the deadline for submitting an acid rain permit application for Phase H, or (2) if the unit has a Phase II acid rain permit, the deadline for reapplying for that permit. The petition for written exemption must contain: I ] Identification of the unit, U The applicable deadline for submission, U The actual or expected date of retirement of the unit, U A description of any actions that have been or will be taken with regard to the retirement of the unit, and U The following statement: “I certify that this unit [ ‘is’ or ‘will be’ as applicable] permanently retired on the date specified in this petition and will not emit any sulfur dioxide or nitro- gen oxides after such date.” This information must be supplied to the permitting authority on forms as stipulated by the permitting authority. 24 ------- Requirements for Affected and Exempted Units A retired unit obtaining an exemption must comply with the monitor- ing requirements, as previously discussed, unless an exemption from these requirements is obtained from the permitting authority. Units that will be permanently retired prior to January 1, 1995 can be exempted from install- ing and certifying a continuous emission monitoring system if the Desig- nated Representative completes a written exemption petition prior to the deadline for completion of certification tests for the continuous emission or opacity monitoring systems. Retired units will retain any allowances they are allocated in 40 CFR 73. An exempted unit shall not resume operation unless the Designated Representative submits an acid rain permit application for the unit not less than 24 months prior to the later of January 1, 2000 or the date the unit is to resume operation. A unit must comply with all of the acid rain regulations as of the earlier of the date an exemption expires or the date a permit application is submitted (or re- quired to be submitted). The exemption of a small, new unit or a retired unit will take effect beginning January 1 of the year following the issuance of the written exemption. Compliance Timelines The following table indicates when a specific type of unit becomes affected by the acid rain regulations, the deadline for that unit to apply for an acid rain permit, the deadline for completing continuous emission and opacity monitoring compliance testing, and the first date on which a unit is required to hold allowances. ------- Do the Acid Rain SO 9 Regulations Apply to You? Compliance T meIines t it i ;s im it i First Date to Hold Sii .i iiisT i p t A llowa:c: for Previous February 15, 1993 Ndvember15 it i993*fl \ *, January 30, 1996 assai l Pbls% P th 1aterbf anuiy ’ The later of Feb r ua r y 15 the atakf1Nov&nbe (15 f The later of Jan 30 1996 1993, or 90 days before the or Jan. 30 of the year after plan is activated the plan is activated wn ka t asa a Phase ll JanuatyW ’ 2 %k January I, 1996 fle later of Jantfaqfl, January 30, 2001 aasa ’a i $M \ k tat ? commence rcommem ia k a a a i e i ;fl \ aJ np Ist a t k wn i &ana & ia sa tu N iatsqtsnk n PhaseMI ’ffhe later bffIM fl j rhelater o J iu jij j The later of January 30 J I 200O )To 0 daft i199 ?t 7 rfte? W 2001 or January 30 of commencement ofreb year after unit commences ‘commercial operationmbutkk ommerciaL operation*nob commercial operation fh iate ofêJanuary3lW$ The later of January 30, Januar 2bOó ot90ThW 5frdà9 it 2001 or January 30 of ‘wi- ‘tt fltt ,t ‘flQ & ’ w after $hewnit beginnoPn . serves generator , th t $ year after unit is affected sewe a¼genentor M ith ”fl4 nameplate capacity > 25 a la m k 253 ? S i l l S The later of January I, TheMater ’oNJanuary4* >n % The later of January 30, r ’ waa ’ wt.’e ’ “ i S ” ‘ ‘ ,t ’ud ‘ w r * a i a ’ i 5S January t, 2O00 or 90 days 1998, or 24 months before i1995’pr days ,after’ ‘ ‘a 2001 or January 30 of auxiliary finng commences au iiary finng ponimences year after unit is affected S f ‘ u S The later of January 30, , ‘_w, ‘,, ,5 ‘j , , ‘ “ k , ‘ wy ’ w S a Januasy 1 200O ’or k9G liayst d995kor 90days after ktbeS i 200 1 or January 30 of ‘ a ’k “a er a ”3 calendamyext factlity ifai ls;to meetdhen5a year after unit is affected “ t ” w RhaseJibThq later oftpRaM The later oQJanuar.1?IttSkl The later of January 30, 2001 or January 30 of tiñt ?f il ’ kP o itM year after unit is affected ‘ p ’*: ’ ‘k iaaass flneet4he$efinition$fjam “ Kdefinition ofk qualifying: jg 111111 Th ek? 4 bf ami tYI1W The later of January 30, 2001 or January 30 of q kk ‘ k ’ M + ‘kO ,i \ M 9 facdit fa i ls toa i t )rqee t di$a year after unit is affected qmeeuutekdefimtion oftann definitien oNndependent i e n , ’ “ek nrt* ”tk n + ’ independent$Ower \ , Power J ?roducuoi aFaeihtyM 111111 te l The later of January 30, kJanuarY4L \ ’2O0O or :9Oq p i 2001 or January 30 of k Z+ + t ” + ” ' fl€ ’ ‘Vk “tSkAkk ’w++ % days after S 9 ca1endan kyear c$endar year iperiodtdurmgr year after unit is affected es e s S jje ‘\;fl Category Unit Listed in Table I of 40 CFR 73.10 Substitution or Compensating Unit Unit Listed in Tables 2 or 3 of 40 CFR 73.10 (other than a substitution or compensating unit) A New Affected Unit The later of January 1, 1998, or 24 months before the date the unit commences operation A Previously Affected Existing Small Unit that fails to meet continuing requirements The later of January 1, 1998, or 24 months before the unit begins to serve a generator with nameplate capacity > 25 MWe A Previously Affected Existing Simple Combustion Turbine that fails to meet continuing requirements A Previously Unaffected Cogenerator that fails to meet continuing requirements The later of January 1, 1998, or March 1 of the year following 3 calendar years during which continuing requirements are not met A Previously Unaffected Qualifying Facility that fails to meet the definition of a qualifying facility The later of January 1, 1998, or March 1 of the year following the year during which the facility fails to meet the definition of a qualifying facility A Previously Unaffected Independent Pàwer Production Facility that fails to meet the definition of an independent power production facility The later of January 1, 1998, or March 1 of the year following the year during which the facility fails to meet the definition of an independent power production facility A Previously Unaffected Solid Waste Incinerator that fails to meet continuing requirements The later of January 1, 1998, or March 1 of the year following 3 calendar years during which continuing requirements are not met 2A ------- Requirements for Affected and Exempted Units Examples of Compliance Schedules Case 1: A previously unaffected cogeneration unit exceeds the 1/3 potential electrical output capacity and 219,000 MWe hours criteria, when averaged, for 1993, 94, and 95. The unit must: No later than March 30, 1996, complete CEMS tests. No later than January 1, 1998, submit a permit application. No later than January 30, 2001, hold allowances to cover 2000 emissions. Case 2: A previously unaffected solid waste incinerator combusts greater than 20% fossil fuel, when averaged, for 2003, 04, and 05. The incinerator must: No later than March 1, 2006, submit a permit application. No later than March 30, 2006, complete CEMS tests. No later than January 30, 2007, hold allowances to cover 2006 emissions. Case 3: A boiler that commenced operation in 1965 serving a 21 MWe generator has that generator replaced on June 1, 1996 with a 27 MWe generator. The boiler must: No later than August 29, 1996, complete CEMS tests. No later than January 1, 1998, submit a permit application. No later than January 30, 2001, hold allowances to cover 2000 emissions. Case 4: An unaffected IPP with 100 MWe total planned net output capacity in 1996 installs that capacity with three natural gas fired turbines. On November 11, 2002, the facility commences commercial operation of another natural gas turbine of 40 MWe (it has the same emission rate as the other turbines). The original three turbines remain unaffected. The new turbine must: No later than November 11, 2000, submit a permit application. No later than January 29, 2003, complete CEMS tests. No later than January 30, 2004, hold allowances to cover 2003 emissions. a Notes on the timelines: For Phase I units, if the unit was shut down and not yet operating by November 15, 1993, then all monitonng certification tests must be completed no later than 90 days after the unit recommences commercial operation (not to exceed the date the unit is turned over to the dispatcher). For Phase II units, if the unit was shut down and not yet operating by January 1, 1995, then all monitonng certification tests must be completed no later than 90 days after the units recommences commercial operation (not to exceed the date the unit is turned over to the dispatcher). The allowance holding date (allowance transfer deadline), if January 30 is not a business day, is the first business day thereafter. ------- Glossary Many of these definitions have been paraphrased from the definitions included in the Code of Federal Regulations (40 CFR 72.2). References have been provided where applicable. The Code of Federal Regulations also contains additional definitions relating to the Acid Rain Program that are not included here. Acid Rain Permit: The acid rain portion of a source’s operating permit. It is the legally binding document specifying acid rain requirements applicable to an affected source. See 40 CFR 72.2. Affected Unit: A unit that is subject to any acid rain emissions reduction requirement or acid rain emissions limitation. See 40 CFR 72.2. Allowance: Under the Acid Rain Program, an authorization to emit up to one ton of sulfur dioxide during or after a specified calendar year. Auxiliary Firing: The use of fuel in addition to the primary fuel supply to enhance the production of steam. For example, a cogeneration facility in which the energy input to the facility is first used to produce power, and the waste heat is used to provide useful steam where additional natural gas firing is used to boost the steam/thermal process. This addition of natural gas is called auxiliary firing. See 18 CFR 292.202. Boiler: An enclosed fossil or other fuel-fired combustion device used to produce and transfer heat to recirculating water, steam, or any other medium. See 40 CFR 72.2. Certifying Official: The person required to sign a request for an applicability determination by EPA. For a corporation, this should be the president, secretary, treasurer, or vice-president in charge of a principal business function, or other person who performs similar policy or deci- sion-making functions. For a partnership or sole proprietorship, this should be a general partner or the proprietor. Clean Fuels: Fuels with sulfur content of 0.05 percent or less by weight. Cogeneration: The combined production of power and useful heat that uses the reject heat of one process as the energy input into a subsequent process. These processes may be for industrial, commercial, heating, or cooling purposes. See 18 CFR 292.202. Cogeneration Unit: A unit that has equipment used to produce electric energy and fonns of useful thermal energy (such as heat or steam) for industrial, commercial, heating, or cooling purposes, using the reject heat of one process as the energy input into a subsequent process; a unit that uses cogeneration. These units are also known as “cogenerators.” See 40 CFR 72.2, Federal Power Act Section 3(l8)(A), and 18 CFR 292.202. Combined Cycle Unit: A unit that uses a heat recovery steam generator or waste heat boiler to capture hot air exiting a steam turbine. Combustion Device: A device that initiates the chemical reaction of fuel and oxygen with the addition of heat. ------- Do the Ac,d Rain Regulations Apply to You? Commence Commercial Operation: To begin to generate electricity for sale, including the sale of test generation. See 40 CFR 72.2. Commence Construction: To undertake a continuous program of construction or enter into a contractual obligation to undertake and complete, within a reasonable amount of time, a con- tinuous program of construction. See 40 CFR 72.2. Compensating Unit: A unit not otherwise subject to acid rain regulations during Phase I that is designated as a Phase I unit in a reduced utilization plan. See 40 CFR 72.2. Construction: The fabrication, erection, or installation of a unit or any portion of a unit. See 40 CFR 72.2. Designated Representative: The person authorized by the owners and operators of an affected source to represent the source in matters pertaining to the Acid Rain Program. See 40 CFR 72.2. Direct Public Utility Ownership: Direct ownership of equipment and facilities by one or more corporations, the principal business or which is the sale of electricity to the public at retail. See 40 CFR72.2. Emissions: Air pollutants exhausted from a unit or source into the atmosphere. See 40 CFR 72.2. Exemption: An authorization by the EPA Administrator, under 40 CFR 72.7 or 72.8, that exempts a utility unit from certain acid rain regulations. Existing Unit: A unit that commenced commercial operation before November 15, 1990, that served, on or after that date, a generator with nameplate capacity greater than 25 MWe, and that is not a simple combustion turbine. See 40 CFR 72.2. Facility: Any institutional, commercial, or industrial structure, installation, plant, source, or build- ing. For the purposes of the Acid Rain Program, this usually refers to an independent power production facility or a qualifying facility. See 40 CFR 72.2. Form EIA-767: Steam-Electric Plant and Design Report submitted to the Department of Energy containing boiler and fuel consumption information. To obtain this form, write to: US Depart- ment of Energy, Energy Information Administration (ETA), EI-521, Mail Stop: BG-094 (Form EIA-767), Washington, DC, 20585. Form EIA-860: A Department of Energy form completed by each electric utility that operates a power plant in the United States or plans to operate the plant within 10 years of the filing of the form. The form includes site information, generator information, operations, energy sources, and capacity. For the purposes of Form 860, an electric utility is a corporation, person, agency, authority, or other legal entity or instrumentality that owns or operat s facilities within the United States for the generation, transmission, distribution, or sale of electric energy primarily for use by the public. To obtain this form, write to: US Department of Energy, Energy Infor- mation Administration (ETA), EI-52l, Mail Stop: BG-094 (Form EIA-860), Washington, DC, 20585. Fossil Fuel: Natural gas, petroleum, coal, or any fuel derived from such material. See 40 CFR 72.2. G lossarv -2 ------- G!ossar,’ Fossil Fuel-Fired: Combustion of fossil fuel or any derivative of fossil fuel, alone or in combina- tion with any other fuel, independent of the percentage of fossil fuel consumed in any calendar year. See 40 CFR 72.2. Generator: A device that produces electricity and was or would have been required to be reported as a generating unit pursuant to the United States Department of Energy Form 860(1990 edition). See 40 CFR 72.2. Independent Power Production Facility (IPP): An electricity-generating facility that is generally not regulated by State public utility commissions and that sells power at wholesale, usually to public utilities. See 40 CFR 72.2. Listed Units: Units that are listed in Tables 1, 2, or 3 of 40 CFR 73.10 (Exhibits 1, 2, and 3 of Appendix D). These units are affected (unless exempted) by either Phase I or Phase II of the acid rain regulations. Multi-header Generator: A generator served by ductwork from more than one unit. See 40 CFR 72.2. Multi-header Unit: A unit with ductwork serving more than one generator. See 40 CFR 72.2. Nameplate Capacity: The maximum electrical generating output that a generator can sustain over a specified period of time when not restricted by deratings. This figure is listed in the NADB and on Form EIA-860 for most utility units. See 40 CFR 72.2. National Allowance Data Base (NADB): A data base established by EPA in order to calculate Acid Rain Program SO 2 emissions allowances. Version 2.11 includes detailed information on 3,800 boiler-generator pairs and lists the boiler on-line date and generator on-line date. Most of the boilers and turbines listed in the data base are affected units. See 40 CFR 72.2. New Unit: A unit that commences commercial operation on or after November 15, 1990, including any such unit that serves a generator with a nameplate capacity of 25 MWe or less or that is a simple combustion turbine. See 40 CFR 72.2. Nonrecourse Project Financing: Financing in which lenders have recourse only to assets and cash flows associated with a specific project and not to a parent company or partner companies that provide equity or other assurances. See independent power production facilities and 10 CFR 715.3. Opt-In: To participate in the Acid Rain Program voluntarily. Units that opt-in to the Program are given emissions allowances that can be sold to other units, with some restrictions. Exempted units (i.e., retired units and new units that are granted an exemption) and units otherwise af- fected are not allowed to opt-in to the Program. Note that the Opt-In Program has not been finalized as of January 1, 1994. Phase I Unit: Any affected unit that is subject to an acid rain emissions reduction requirement or acid rain emissions limitation beginning in the period from January 1, 1995, to December 31, 1999. All Phase I units continue to be affected in Phase 11. See 40 CFR 72.2. Phase II Unit: Any affected unit that is subject to an acid rain emissions reduction requirement or acid rain emissions limitation only after January 1, 2000. See 40 CFR 72.2. ------- Do the Acid Rain Regulations Apply to You? Potential Electrical Output Capacity: The MWe capacity rating for a unit. For simple combus- lion turbines and boilers, this rating is equal to 33 percent of the maximum design input capac- ity (in mmBtu/hr) of the steam generating unit converted to MWe. See 40 CFR 72.2. Power Purchase Commitment: A commitment or obligation of a utility to purchase electric power from a facility pursuant to a power sales agreement, a State regulatory authority order, a letter of intent to purchase power from the source at a previously offered or lower price, or a utility competitive bid solicitation that has resulted in a winning bidder. See 40 CFR 72.2. Power Sales Agreement (PSA): A legally binding agreement between a qualifying facility, an independent power production facility, an new independent power production facility, or a firm associated with such facility and a regulated electric utility that establishes the terms and conditions for the sale of power from the facility to the utility. See 40 CFR 72.2. Qualifying Facility: A qualifying small power production facility or a qualifying cogeneration facility as administered under the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC). See 18 CFR 292 and Federal Power Act, Sections 3(17)(C) and 3(18)(B). Qualifying Power Purchase Commitment: A power purchase commitment in effect as of November 15, 1990, that meets the following requirements: U The identity of the electrical purchaser does not change, or U The identity of the steam purchaser and the planned location of the facility do not change, and U The cost of compliance with the acid rain regulations are not allowed to shift to the pur- chaser. See 40 CFR 72.2. Retired Unit: A unit that has ceased operation and certified that it will not recommence operation. See 40 CFR 72.8. Simple Combustion Turbine: A unit that is a rotary engine driven by a gas under pressure that is created by the combustion of any fuel. This includes combined cycle units without auxiliary firing and combined cycle units with auxiliary firing that did not use auxiliary firing in 1985 through 1987 and will not use auxiliary firing at any time after November 15, 1990. See 40 CFR 72.2. Solid Waste Incineration Unit: A distinct operating unit of any facility that combusts any solid waste material from commercial or industrial establishments or the general public. This does not include most materials recovery facilities, qualifying small power production facilities, or air curtain incinerators. See Clean Air Act, Section 129(g)(1). Source: Any governmental, institutional, commercial, or industrial structure, installation, plant, building, or facility that emits or has the potential to emit any regulated air pollutant under the Clean Air Act. See 40 CFR 72.2. Substitution Units: An affected unit that is designated as a Phase I unit in a substitution plan under 40 CFR 72.41. See 40 CFR 72.2. Total Nameplate Capacity: The sum of the nameplate capacities to which a unit is headered. G IossArv4 ------- Glossary Unaffected Unit: A unit that is not subject to any acid rain emissions reduction requirement or acid rain emissions limitation. Unit: A fossil fuel-fired combustion device. See 40 CFR 72.2. Utility: Any facility, company, or person that sells electricity. See 40 CFR 72.2. Utility Unit: A unit owned or operated by a utility that serves a generator that produces electricity for sale. This includes, in some instances, electrical generating equipment owned or operated by entities that are not public utilities, such as manufacturers and independent power producers. This does not include units that did not serve a generator in 1985 or on or after November 15, 1990. This also does not include most cogeneration units. See 40 CFR 72.2. e ------- Appendix A Selected Acid Rain Regulations and Documents The Acid Rain Program regulations and documents have been produced as a series and include those listed below: Auctions, Direct Sales, and Independent Power Producers Written Guarantee 40 CFR 72 Final December 17, 1991, 56 FR 65592 Additional materials located in EPA Air Docket A-91-32. Acid Rain Program: General Provisions and Permits, Allowance System, Continuous Emis- sion Monitoring, Excess Emissions, and Administrative Appeals 40 CFR 72, 73, 75, 77, and 78 Final January 11, 1993, 58 FR 3590 Additional materials located in EPA Air Dockets A-90-38 (for permits-related materials), A-91-43 (for allowance systems), A-90-5 1 (for continuous emission monitoring), A-91 -68 (for excess emis- sions), and A-91-69 (for the general docket). Acid Rain Allowance Allocations and Reserves 40 CFR 72, 73, and 75 Final March 23, 1993, 58 FR 15634 Additional materials located in EPA Air Docket A-92-06. Acid Rain Provisions: Notice of Availability of the National Allowance Data Base Revised Final Data Base, version 2.11, March 23, 1993, 58 FR 15720 Additional materials located in EPA Air Docket A-92-07. Acid Rain Program: Nitrogen OxIdes Emission Reduction Program 40 CFR 76 Proposed November 25, 1992, 57 FR 55632 Additional materials located in EPA Air Docket A-92-15. Acid Rain Program: Permits and Allowance System (Opt-In) 40 CFR 74 Proposed September 24, 1993, 58 FR 50087 Additional materials located in EPA Air Docket A-93-15. ------- Do the Acid Rain SOp. Regulations Apply to You? Acid Rain Program: Permits and Allowance System (SubstItution & Compensating Units) 40 CFR 72 and 73 Proposed November 18, 1993, 58 FR 50949 Additional materials located in EPA Air Docket A-93-40. To obtain a copy of any of these documents, call the Acid Rain Hotline at (202) 233-9620. A-2 ------- Appendix B: EPA Regional and State Office Addresses Contacts Region I JFK Building One Congress Street Boston, MA 02203 (617) 565-3800 FAX#: (617)565-4939 Region 2 Jacob K. Javitz Federal Building 26 Federal Plaza New York, NY 10278 (212) 264-2301 FAX#: (212) 264-7613 Region 3 841 Chestnut Building Philadelphia, PA 19107 (215) 597-9390 FAX#: (215) 597-3156 345 Courtland Street, NE. Atlanta, GA 30365 (404) 347-3043 FAX#: (404) 347-3059 Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard (A-i 8J) Chicago, IL 60604 (312) 353-2212 FAX#: (312)353-1661 Region 6 First Interstate Bank Tower 1445 Ross Avenue (MC6T-AN) Dallas, TX 75202-2733 (214) 655-7200 FAX#: (214) 655-2164 Region 7 726 Minnesota Avenue (ARTX/ARBRJPERM) Kansas City, KS 66101 (913) 551-7404 FAX#: (913) 551-7065 Region 8 999 18th Street, Suite 500 (8ART) Denver, CO 80202-2466 (303) 293-0946 FAX#: (303) 294-7559 Region 9 75 Hawthorne Street (A-3-1) San Francisco, CA 94105 (415) 744-1219 FAX#: (415)744-1076 Region 10 1200 Sixth Avenue (AT-082) Seattle, WA 98101 (206) 553-4152 FAX#: (206)553-0110 Region 4 EPA Regional D l ------- Do the Acid Rain Regulations Apply to You? State Contacts Alabama Environmental Management Department 1751 Congressman W.L. Dickinson Drive Montgomery, AL 36130 (205) 271-7706 FAX#: (205) 271-7950 Arizona Environmental Quality Department 3033 N. Central Avenue Phoenix, AZ 85012 (602) 207-2300 FAX#: (602) 207-2218 Arkansas Department of Pollution Control and Ecology P.O. Box 9583 Little Rock, AR 72219 (501) 570-2130 FAX#: (501) 562-4632 Calitorn la California Air Resources Board P.O. Box 2815 Sacramento, CA 95812 (916) 445-4383 FAX#: (916) 322-6003 California Environmental Protection Agency 555 Capitol Mall, Suite 235 Sacramento, CA 95814 (916) 445-3846 FAX#: (916) 445-6401 Colorado Office of Environment Colorado Department of Health 4300 Cherry Creek Drive South, OE-B2 Denver, CO 80222-1530 (303) 692-3099 FAX#: (303) 782-4969 Connecticut Department of Environmental Protection 79 Elm Street Hartford, CT 06106 (203) 566-2110 FAX#: (203) 566-7932 Delaware Natural Resources and Environmental Control P.O. Box 1401 89 Kings Highway Dover, DE 19903 (302) 739-4403 FAX#: (302) 739-6242 District of Columbia Department of Consumer arid Regulatory Affairs Environmental Regulation Administration 2100 Martin L. King, Jr. Avenue, SE Washington, D.C. 20020 (202) 404-1136 FAX#: (202) 404-1141 Florida Department of Environmental Regulation 2600 Blair Stone Road Tallahassee, FL 32399-2400 (904) 921-9717 FAX#: (904) 487-4938 Georgia Department of Natural Resources 205 Butler Street, S.W., Suite 1252 Atlanta, GA 30334 (404) 656-4713 FAX#: (404) 656-0770 Idaho Division of Environmental Quality 1410 N. Hilton Street Boise, ID 83720 (208) 334-0502 FAX#: (208) 334-0417 Illinois Illinois Environmental Protection Agency 2200 Churchill Road P.O. Box 19276 Springfield, IL 62794 (217) 782-339’7 FAX#: (217) 782-9039 Indiana Indiana Department of Environmental Management 100 N. Senate, Room 1301 Indianapolis, IN 46204 (317) 232-8162 FAX#: (317)232-8564 ------- Appendix B Iowa Environmental Protection Division Iowa Department of Natural Resources Wallace State Office Building Des Moines, IA 50319 (515) 281-6284 FAX# (515) 281-8895 Kansas Department of Health and Environment 900 S.W. Jackson, Suite 901 Topeka, KS 666 12-1290 (913) 296-0461 FAX#: (913) 296-6231 Kentucky Natural Resources and Environmental Protection Cabinet 5th Floor, Capital Plaza Tower Frankfort, KY 40601 (502) 564-3350 FAX#. (502) 564-4245 Louisiana Department of Environmental Quality P.O. Box 44066 Baton Rouge, LA 70804 (504) 765-0639 FAX#: (504) 765-0746 Maine Department of Environmental Protection State House Station 17 Augusta, ME 04333 (207) 287-2812 FAX#: (207) 287-7826 Maryland Department of Environment 2500 Broening Highway Baltimore, MD 21224 (410) 631-3084 FAX#: (410) 631-3888 Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection One Winter Street Boston, MA 02108 (617) 292-5856 FAX#: (617) 556-1049 Environmental Affairs Executive Office One Winter Street Boston, MA 02108 (617) 727-9800 FAX#: (617) 727-2754 Michigan Department of Natural Resources Box 30028, Steven 1. Mason Building Lansing, M l 48909 (517) 373-2329 FAX4#: (517) 335-4242 Minnesota Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 520 Lafayette Road, 6th floor St. Paul, MN 55 155-3898 (612) 296-7303 FAX#: (612) 296-7923 Mississippi Department of Natural Resources Box 10305 Jackson, MS 39289-1305 (601)961-5000 FAX#: (601) 354-6965 Missouri Department of Natural Resources 205 Jefferson Street, P.O. Box 176 Jefferson City, MO 65102 (314)751-4422 FAX#: (314) 751-7627 Montana Environmental Sciences Division Department of Health and Environmental Science Cogswell Building Helena, MT 59620 (406) 444-3948 FAX#: (406) 444-1374 Nebraska Environmental Control P.O. Box 98922 Lincoln, NE 68509 (402) 471-2186 FAX#: (402) 471-2909 Nevada Environmental Protection Division Nevada Department of Conservation and Natural Resources 333 West Nye Lane Carson City, NV 89710 (702) 687-4670 FAX#: (702) 687-5856 ------- Do the Acid Rain Regulations Apply to You? New Hampshire New Hampshire Department of Environmental Services Hazen Drive, P.O. Box 95 Concord, NH 03301 (603) 271-3503 FAX#: (603) 271-2867 New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection and Energy 401 East State Street - CN 402 Trenton, NJ 08625 (609) 292-5617 FAX#: (609) 984-3962 New Mexico Department of Environment P.O. Box 26110 Santa Fe, NM 87503-0968 (505) 827-2850 FAX#: (505) 827-2836 New York Environmental Conservation Department 50 Wolf Road Albany, NY 12233 (518) 457-3446 FAX#: (518) 457-6996 North Carolina Environmental Protection North Carolina Department of Environment, Health and Natural Resources P.O. Box 27687 Raleigh, NC 27611-7687 (919) 715-4140 FAX#: (919)715-3060 North Dakota Environmental Health Section 1200 Missouri Avenue, Box 5520 Bismarck, ND 58502-55 20 (701) 221-5150 FAX#: (701) 221-5200 Ohio Ohio Environmental Protection Agency P.O. Box 1049 1800 Watermark Drive Columbus, OH 43266-0149 (614) 644-2782 FAX#: (614) 644-3184 Oklahoma Oklahoma Department of Environmental Quality 1000 N.E. 10th Street Oldahonia City, OK 73117-1299 (405) 271-8056 FAX#: (405) 271-7339 Oregon Department of Environmental Quality 811 S.W. Sixth Avenue Portland, OR 97204-1334 (503) 229-5395 FAX#: (503) 229-6124 Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Resources 400 Market Street Hamsburg, PA 17105-2063 (717) 787-5028 FAX#. (717) 783-8926 Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management 9 Hayes Street Providence, RI 02908 (401) 277-2771 FAX#: (401) 277-6802 South Carolina Environmental Quality Control Department of Health and Environmental Control 2600 Bull Street Columbia, SC 29201 (803) 734-5360 FAX*: (803) 734-5199 South Dakota Department of Environment and Natural Resources 523 E. Capitol Avenue Pierre, SD 57501 (605) 773-5559 FAX#: (605) 773-6035 Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation 21st Floor, L & C Tower 401 Church Street Nashville, TN 37243-0435 (615) 532-0109 FAX#: (615) 532-0120 B-4 ------- Appendix B Texas Wyoming Texas Natural Resource Conservation Commission Department of Environmental Quality 1700 North Congress, Room 123 Herschler Building, 4th Floor West Austin, TX 78701 Cheyenne, WY 82002 (512) 463-7901 (307) 777-7938 FAX#: (512) 475-2332 FAX#: (307) 777-7682 Utah Department of Environmental Quality 168 North 1950 West P.O. Box 144810 Salt Lake City, UT 84116-4810 (801) 536-4400 FAX#: (801) 538-4401 Vermont Vermont Agency of Natural Resources 103 S. Main Street, Building 1-South Waterbury, VT 05676 (802) 241-3600 FAX# (802)244-1102 Virginia Department of Environmental Quality 9th Street Office Building Richmond, VA 23219 (804) 786-0044 FAX# (804) 371-8333 wasnungcon Department of Ecology P .O. Box 47600 Olympia, WA 98504-8711 (206) 407-7001 FAX#: (206) 493-9495 West Virginia Natural Resources Department 800 Washington Street Charleston, WV 25305 (304) 558-2754 FAX#: (304) 348-2768 Wisconsin Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources P.O. Box 7921 Madison, WI 53707 (608) 266-2121 FAX#: (608) 266-6983 ------- Appendix C Applicability Determination Examples This appendix provides examples illustrating how to work through the flow chart to determine applicability of the Acid Rain Program to a specific unit. Each example includes facts about a hypothetical unit, the applicability decision for that unit, and an annotated flow chart. r’ I ------- Do the Acid Rain Regulations Apply to You? Example 1: Listed Unit Facts: This unit is listed in Table 2 of 40 CFR 73.10 (Exhibit 2 of Appendix D). A prospective owner wants to buy the unit and convert it to bum only non-fossil fuels. The unit will continue to supply steam to a 50 MWe capacity generator that sells electricity. 1. The unit is listed in Table 2, so continue to the next decision point. Is the unit... ‘MU ..Jlstsd? — .1 ...,nlabkl.2 .or3of4OCFR7 5ee Appendix D lItt:te4 ii f cog twrati)r Yes ------- Appendix C Decision: The unit is affected even if it is converted to consume non-fossil fuels. Note that the unit will retain its allowance allocation even though it uses non-fossil fuels. Mfl ifl(;IIlerdtOf? newi ..a s n1pk ne t Th srvin iu,aH gun iatut L ;) Tr ... I 2. Afthough the unit will use clean fuel, it serves a 50 MWe generator, so it is affected. ------- Do the Acid Rain Regulations Apply to You? Example 2: Cogenerator Not Selling Electricity Facts: This unit is not listed in Tables 1, 2, or 3 of 40 CFR 73.10 (Exhibits 1, 2, or 3 of Appen- dix D). The cogenerator commenced commercial operation in 1988 and burns primarily coal, but also some wood waste and natural gas. The cogenerator was constructed to supply steam to an industrial facility. Neither the cogenerator nor the industrial facility has sold any electricity since the commencement of operations. Is the unit... 1. The unit is not listed in Tables 1, 2, or 3, so proceed to the next decision point. 2. The unit is a combustion device burning fossil fuel, but its output does not go to the production of electricity for sale, so it is ...Usted? ..inTabI ! ,2 ,or3of4OCF lSee App ndhc D) LI rn PI’ U I? QF! a gt n.iatm ? 4 ------- Appendix C Decision: The unit is unaffected, because its output does not go to the production of electricity for sale. If the industrial facility buying the steam was using it to produce electricity that was then sold to the public utility grid, then one would have to continue through the flow chart to determine whether the unit is affected. a ltnb n ? Ii II • •usmg dean fuel C-5 ------- Do the Acid Rain Regulations Apply to You? Example 3: Qualifying Facility Facts: There are two oil- and gas-fired boilers headered to one generator at this facility. In 1986, during the planning of the facility, the facility owners filed for self-certification of quali- fying cogeneration facility status with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC). The facility is the subject of a power sales agreement, executed in 1987, for 40 MWe with a utility. The facility’s construction contract specifies a generator of 50,000 kVA at a power rating of 85% (equivalent to 42.5 MWe). The facility also has a steam sales agreement with a local prison. The facility was completed and commenced opera- tion in 1992 with a 43 MWe nameplate capacity generator. The power sales agreement has not been changed or amended. The unit is not listed in Tables 1, 2, or 3 of 40 CFR 73.10 (Exhibits 1, 2, or 3 of Appendix D). Is the unit... 1. The unit is not listed in Tables 1, 2, or 3, so proceed to the next decision point. 2. The unit is a combustion device burning fossil fuel producing electricity for sale, so proceed through the next decision points. ...Ilsted? 3. The facility meets the requirements for an unaffected qualifying facility, so it is unaffected ...potentiafly affected? ...thatfl)asot1t 0. Yes had a quaHlylng pr)wnr purchase _ agreement to tell at least 15% of net planned capacity and 123 has Lj net installed capac,tt, c 130% of net planned capacuyt J , , es I a ------- Appendix C Decision: Neither boiler at this facility is affected. The facility meets the requirements for an unaffected qualifying facility: LI It meets the definition of a qualifying facility; LI It had a qualifying power purchase commitment as of November 15, 1990; and LI It has installed capacity less than or equal to 130% of its planned net capacity. II ‘K ‘a Ins Invi attn I II a t pLn ts,rm* ? r ! t svin sanafl — th&i*i I 5U II I I 4 •. a a C-7 ------- Do the Acid Rain Regulations Apply to You? Example 4: Cogenerator Selling Electricity Facts: An industrial company built a cogeneration facility to serve the company’s adjacent manufacturing plant. The facility commenced commercial operation with a single boiler- generator pair in 1991. The boiler has a maximum design heat input of 1,024 mmBtu/hr (which calculates to potential electrical output capacity of 100 MWe), and the generator has a nameplate capacity of 75 MWe. When the needs of the manufacturing plant are low, the industrial company sells the excess power to a public utility. The amount of electricity sold to the public utility (gross sales) in any one year has not exceeded, and is not expected to exceed, 200,000 MWe-hrs. The unit is not listed in Tables 1, 2, or 3 of 40 CFR 73.10 (Exhibits 1,2, or 3 of AppendixD). 2. fres a 1. The unit is not listed in Tables i, 2, or 3, so proceed to the next decision point. The unit is a combustion device burning fossil fuel producing electricity or sale, so proceed through the next decision 3. Is the unit .Hstd? The unit is a cogenerator selling less than 219,000 MWe-hrs of electrical output to the grid and construction commenced after 11/15/90, so it is • unaffected. an IPP or a QF? aofl buchondev e n cogensrator? pp ,uppllid I averageo( 1 13 iI I.c t a p 4capacs1y )• 21LQOOMivito Ib.gc Idk r ,.I.(or prrlod afier 11/15 190 ai,d 12) w the a C-8 ------- Appendix C Decision: The unit (boiler) is unaffected because it meets the requirements for an unaffected cogenerator. The gross annual electricity sales are less than or equal to one-third of the potential electrical output capacity or less than or equal to 219,000 MWe-hrs. First, calculate the potential electrical output capacity (100 MWe), then compare this to the generator nameplate capacity. In this example, 75% of the boiler’s capacity can be used to generate electricity. Because this level (75%) is greater than one-third, calculate the maximum number of MWe-hrs that could be sold at one-third potential electrical output capacity. This figure is 292,000 MWe-brs (see Example of Cogenerator Determina- tions on page 14 of Section 1). Since 200,000 MWe-hrs (the amount of the unit’s gross electricity sales) is below both the 292,000 MWe-hrs and 219,000 MWe-hrs criteria, the boiler is unaffected; U4;U 49 d cw a__ a pJt hH n ? rn aU II • n ung ;. k 4bfl mel? + c-9 ------- Do the Acid Rain Regulations Apply to You? 2. Example 5: Solid Waste Incinerator Facts: A solid waste incinerator commenced operation in the 1970s and generally consumes 25 to 30% of its fuel in the form of number 2 diesel fuel. By 1995, the facility expects to consume less than 20% fossil fuels by burning more consumer waste. It is not listed in Tables 1,2, or 3 of 40 CFR 73.10 (Exhibits 1, 2, or 3 of Appendix D). flt uatawTa ed v3 had a qualltyln pow , purchase pcio o l e ectri .I apcity anienttc&f atreasUS%of No No netplannedcapacityand(2)hac . net lns&afl ed c pac fl 3O% of co ucted fr* l w surpool outl Ined in Ii ) f net planned capac y crerucilon commenced on or betliwe Il/i ...anIPPoraQF? . ...a cogenerator? 1. The unit is not listed in Tables 1, 2, or 3, so proceed to the next decision point. The unit is a combustion device burning fossil fuel producing electricity for sale, so proceed through the next decision points. Is the unit... listed? p . ...potentially affected? I. c-b ------- Appendix C Decision: The facility is affected because it consumed greater than 20% fossil fuels during the baseline period, 1985-1987. The current and future consumption rates are irrelevant in this case. 3. The unit is an incinerator, but it combusted >20% fossil fuels during the baseline period 1985 to 1987. Because the unit does not qualify as exempt or unaffected under any subsequent provision in the flow chart, it is affected. No a simple turbine? ii ‘11 att cap dty 1fl5/90? ‘II c-Il ------- Do the Acid Rain Regulations Apply to You? Example 6: New, Small, Clean Unit acts: A unit is planned to commence commercial operation in March 1998. It is not listed in Tables 1, 2, or 3 of 40 CFR 73.10 (Exhibits 1, 2, or 3 of Appendix D), nor is it listed in the National Allowance Data Base (NADB). It is planned to consume at least 90% natu- ral gas, so its fuels average sulfur content will be below 0.05% by weight. The boiler will serve one generator with nameplate capacity of 15 MWe. ‘11 a 2. 1. The unit is not ilsted in Tables 1,2, or 3, so proceed to the next decision point. The unit is a combustion device burning fossil fuel producing electricity for sale, so proceed through the next decision points. p. Is the unit Ist.d? ...a ccg.nsrator? Yes I- a C-i.2 ------- Appendix C Decision: The unit is eligible for the exemption as a small, new unit burning clean fuels. It re- ceived no allowance allocation initially, so it does not need to forfeit allowances. The unit may be able to avoid the requirements to install and test CEMS by receiving its exemp- tion before January 1, 1998. Without this exemption, the unit would be required to install and certify CEMS within 90 days of the unit’s commencement of commercial operation (see Compliance Timelines) in June 1998. if the unit files for and receives its exemption in 1997, the exemption goes into effect January 1, 1998, in time to avoid the requirements to install and certify CEMS (see 40 CFR 72.7(c) and 75.4(b)(1)). 4 3. The unit commenced commercial operation after 11/15/90, so it qualifies as a new unit. incln.rator? a t U1 P ‘ 1 N, U ,’ ...usI combus*ig or 4y 4. The unit meets the definition of using clean fuel, so it qualifies for an exemption. C-13 ------- Do the Acid Rain Regulations Apply to You? Example 7: Retired Unit Facts: A unit is listed in Table 1 of 40 CFR 73.10 (Exhibit 1 of Appendix D). The unit is pres- ently on “cold standby” status; that is, it is not immediately operable but could be brought on-line within 6 months. The owners have decided to formally retire the unit in 1995. * 1. The unit is listed in Table 1, so continue to the next decision point. Is the unit... ..Jst.d? Ii •,tI fIt .4lIY i u ( t( d’ (See Ap *ndi D) I •. )H IPP (U Q1 I i ( flt f itffl ? ‘a C-14 ------- Appendix C Decision: The unit Is eligible for the retired units exemption of 40 CFR 72.8. Because it is a Phase I affected unit, it must meet all applicable Acid Rain Program requirements until January 1 of the year after the unit is granted its exemption. Applicable acid rain require- ments include holding sufficient allowances to cover its annual SO 2 emissions (for emis- sions in 1995 and thereafter), obtaining an acid rain permit, having a Designated Repre- sentative, and installing and operating systems to monitor emissions, as required by 40 CFR75. I.’ in iiiei atur’ 4 J •.a irnpk turbm* ? - ‘a * ,P1vmg Mu 1tJ gent’aat(Pr( •P a U — 2. The unit is not combust- ing any fuel. It has ceased operation and will be formally retired in 1995, so it is eligible for an exemption. C-15 ------- Do the Acid Rain Regulations Apply to You? Example 8: Existing Simple Combustion Turbine Facts: A unit is a simple combustion turbine that is not listed in Tables 1, 2, or 3 of 40 CFR 73.10 (Exhibits 1, 2, or 3 of Appendix D). It commenced commercial operation in 1983 and does not have auxiliary firing. The owner plans to sell it to another utility. That utility plans to move the turbine, refurbish it, and rename it. The turbine is listed in the National Allowance Data Base (NADB) with the 1983 on-line date. 1. Is the unit... The unit is not listed in Tables 1, 2, or 3, so proceed to the next decision point. The unit is a combustion device burning fossil fuel producing electricity for sale, so proceed through the next decision points. ...IIst.d? p U ...anIPPoraQF? ...a ccg.n.rator? . .. . ... ... . ... C-16 ------- Appendix C Decision: The turbine is unaffected as an existing simple combustion turbine. The new dvnër should not change the name of the turbine and should ensure that future subm aisto he Energy Information Administration (EIA) do not change the on-line date to’ avcj id’bec m- ing affected as a new unit. J4. I The unit is an existing combustion turbine, 4 ;Ie 4fl •fuel ‘ 4 ‘1 .t4E I1ftrz1Iol iufl ; , , t t( e t? a 3.. The unit commenced commercial operation before 11/15/90, so it is an existing unit. an Incinerator? H a simpi. turbine? C-17 ------- Do the Acid Rain Regulations Apply to You? Example 9: Existing Unit Serving A Small Generator Facts: A boiler presently serves a generator with nameplate capacity of 18 MWe and, in 1985, served only this generator. The boiler commenced operation in 1963 and sells electricity and steam for industrial process use. Because of increased electrical demand at the industrial site, the owner of the boiler pians to add a generator with nameplate capacity of 8 MWe in 1997. 1. The unit is not listed in Tables 1, 2, or 3, so proceed to the next decision point. 2. The unit is a combustion device burning fossil fuel producing electricity for sale, so proceed through the next decision points. Is the unit IIst.d? p •• r tsntially an IPP or a QF? a cog.n.rator? a . .... .,,.. ... .. C-18 ------- Appendix C Decision: The unit is currently unaffected and would remain unaffected if it adds the 8 MWe generator. The boiler is an existing unit, and all current and planned generators served by it have nameplate capacities of less than 25 MWe (i.e., the statutory cutoff; see Sec- tion 402(8) of the Clean Air Act). However, if the boiler owner replaces the 18 MWe (nameplate) generator with a generator of greater than 25 MWe nameplate capacity, the boiler would become affected, according to 40 CFR 72.6(a)(3)(ii), which affects existing units that serve, on or after November 15, 1990, generators with nameplate capacities greater than 25 MWe. No 4. 3. The unit commenced commercial operation before 11/15/90, so it is an existing unit. The unit is an existing unit serving only generator(s) with nameplate capacity 25MWe, so it is unaffected. It will not become affected in 1997 because the additional generator also has nameplate c j, 25MWe. U incinerator? .new? I 1. Yes J’ ...a simple turbine? ...servlng small generator(s)? leaii fuel? h 4 C-19 ------- •1 . Appendix Selected List of Units Affected by the Acid Rain Regulations Exhibit 1: Units listed in Table I StateName PlantName Boilers MINNESOTA of §73.10 (40 CFR 73) HighBridge 6 lack Watson 4, 5 State Name Plant Name Boilers MISSOURI ALABAMA Asbury I Colbert 1,2,3,4,5 James River 5 E C Gaston 1,2, 3, 4,5 Labadie 1,2, 3,4 FLORIDA Montrose 1,2,3 New Madrid 1,2 Big Bend BBOI, BBO2, BBO3 Sibley 3 Crist 6,7 Sioux 1,2 GEORGIA Thomas Hill MBI. MB2 Bowen IBLR, 2BLR, 3BLR, 4BLR NEW HAMPSHIRE Hammond 1,2,3,4 Merrimack 1,2 Jack McDonough MBI, MB2 Wansley 1,2 NEW JERSEY Yates YIBR, Y2BR, Y3BR. Y4BR, B L England 1,2 Y5BR, Y6BR, Y7BR EW YORK ILLINOIS Dunkirck 3,4 Baldwin 1,2, 3 Greenndge 6 Coffeen NO 1,02 Milliken 1,2 Grand Tower 09 Northport 1,2,3 Hennepin 2 Port Jefferson 3,4 Joppa Steam 1, 2, 3,4, 5, 6 OHIO Kincaid 1,2 Ashtabula 7 Meredosia 05 Avon Lake 11, 12 Vermilion 2 Cardinal 1.2 INDIANA Conesville 1,2, 3,4 Badly 7, 5 Eastlake 1,2, 3,4, 5 Breen I Edgewarer 13 Cayuga 1,2 Gen J M Gavin 1,2 Clifty Creek 1,2,3,4,5,6 Kyger Creek 1,2,3,4,5 Elmer W Stout 50,60,70 Miami Fort 5-1, 5-2, 6.7 F B Culley 2,3 Muskingum River 1.2, 3,4, 5 FrankERatts 1SG I,2SG1 Niles 1,2 Gibson 1,2, 3,4 Picway 9 H T Pritchard 6 RE Burger 5,6,7, 8 Michigan City 12 W H Sammis 5,6.7 Petersburg 1,2 Walter C Beckiord 5,6 R Gallagher 1,2,3,4 PENNSYLVANIA Tanners Creek U4 Armstrong 1,2 Wabash River 1,2, 3. 5, 6 Brunner Island 1,2, 3 Warrick Cheswick I IOWA Conemaugh 1,2 Burlington I Hatfield’s Ferry 1,2, 3 DesMoines 11 MartinsCreek 1,2 George Neal 1 Portland 1,2 Milton L Kapp 2 Shawville 1,2, 3,4 Prarne Creek 4 Sunbury 3,4 Riverside 9 TENNESSEE KANSAS Allen 1,2, 3 Quindaro 2 Cumberland 1,2 Gallalin 1,2,3,4 KENTUCKY Johnsonvilie 1,2,3,4, 5,6, 7, 8. 9, 10 Coleman CI, C2, C3 Cooper 1,2 WEST VIRGINIA E W Brown I, 2, 3 Albright 3 ElmerSmith 1,2 Fort Martin 1,2 Ghent I Harrison 1,2, 3 Green River 5 Kammer I, 2, 3 H L Spurlock I Mitchell 1,2 HMP&LStation2 Hl,H2 MtStorm 1,2,3 Paradise 3 WISCONSIN Shawnee 10 Edgewater 4 MARYLAND Genoa 1 C P Crane 1 • 2 Nelson Dewey 1,2 Chalk Point 1,2 North Oak Creek 1,2,3,4 Morgantown 1, 2 Pulham 8 SouthOakCreek 5,6,7,8 MICHIGAN JHCampbell 1.2 D-i. ------- Do the Acid Rain Regulations Apply to You? Exhibit 2: Units listed in Table 2 of §73.10(40 CFR 73) ALABAMA ARIZONA ARKANSAS CALIFORNIA Plant Name Barry Charles R Lowrnan Cflickasaw Coibert E C Gaston Future Fossil Gadsden Gorgas Greene County James H Mifler Jr Mcintosh-Caes Mcw i llia ms Widows Creek Agua Fria Apache Station Choila Coronado D C Moss Petrie Oils Bend Irvingion Kyrene Navajo Ocoti llo Saguam Springerville West Phoenix Yuma Axis Carl Bailey Cecil Lynch Flint Creek Hamilton Moses Harvey Couch tndependettce Lake Cathenne Mcclellan Na 2— 7246 Robert ERircIne Thomas Fiizhugh White Bluff Aiamitos Avon Broadway Contra Costa Cool Water El Centro El Segundo Enema Etiwanda Gienarm Grayaon Harbor Gen Station Haynta C nn Station Highgrove Humboldt Bay flusters Point Huntington Beach Kern Magnolia Mandalay Martinez Morro Bay Moss Landing Oleuin Olive Ormorid Beach Pittsburg Potrero Redondo Beach San Bernardino. Scattergood Oen Sta Silver Gate South Bay Valley Gen Station Plant Name Bo i lers COLORADO Arapahoe 1,2,3,4 Cameo 2 Cherokee 12,3,4 Comanche 1,2 Craig C1,C2,C3 Hayden I -II,H2 Martin Drake 5,6,7 Nucla Pawnee 1, 1*2 Rawhide 101 Ray f lNixon Valn iont 1, 1 4 NA I 5,11,12 . 13,14,21,22,23,24 Zuni 1,2,3 CONNECTJCIYF Bridgeport Harbor Devon BI-IBI, 81-182, BHB3 3,6,7,8, 4A, 48, SA, 58 English SouthMeadow EB I3, 8814 1 1,12,13 Middletown 1, 2,3, 4 Montville 5,6 New Haven Harbor NH$ I Norwalk Harbor I, 2 DELAWARE EdgeMoor Hay Road Indian River 3,4, 3 * 43 1,2,3,4 Mckee Run 3 Vamisant * 111 DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA Benning IS. 16 FLOR IDA Anclote 1,2 ArvahBHopksns 1,2 Avon Park 2 &g Bead 8801,8802, 3803,3804 CD Mcintosh Jr 1,2,3 Cape Canaveral PCCI, PCC2 Cnst 1,2,3,4,5,6,7 Crystal River Ct 1,2,4,5 **l,*fl,**3,**4 Cutler PCIJS, PCU6 Debary 1*7, 1* 5, 1*9, * 110 Deerhaven DI, 82, ‘NAI, 1 NA2 F J Cannon 0801.0802,0803,0804, 0805.0806 Fort Myers PFM1. PPM2 GE turner 2,3 ,4 HenryOK ing 7,8 Higgins Hookers Point 1,2,3 8301, H302, 1-1803, 11804. 11805,11806, Ind ian River 1,2,3, **( J D Kennedy 8, 9, 10 JR Kelly Smith iRKS 1,2 Larsen Memorial 7, 445, 449 Lauderdale PFL4, PEtS Manatee PMT 1, PMT2 Max im PMRI, FMR2 Nal—7238 Nonhside 1,2, 3 PLBartow 1,2,3 Port Everglades Putna m PPE1. PPE2, PPE3, PPE4 HRSGI 1, }IRSOI2, 1-1RSO2I, 1 1R 5022 Riviera PRV2, PRV3, PRV4 SOPu r dom 7 Sanford PSN3, PSN4, PSN S Scliolz 1,2 Seminole 1,2 Soutliside 1,2,3,4,5 Si IohnsRiverPower 1,2 Stanton Energy Stock island 1,2 I Stock island D I “NAI NA2 Suwannee River I, 2, 3 Tom 0 Smith S-3, S-4 Turkey Point PTPI,PTP2 Veto Beach Municipal 3,4,4*3 1,2,3,4,5 1,2,3 110 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 I 1,2 5,6,7,8,9,10 1,2 1,2,3,4 4*J 1*2 Cr2 C’I’3 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8 1,2,3 1,2,3 1,2, 3,4,4*5 (JIB, U2B 4 15 0T1 G1’2 1*013 *bOT4 1,2,3,4 K-I, K-2 1,2,3 1,2 1,2 1.2 4,6 01 1,2,3 1,2 1,2 1,2 1 ,2.3.4 01 4*1 1.2 1,2 1 ,2 ,3,4 ,5 .6 1,2, 3 81, 82, B3 1,2,3,4,5,6,7.8.9.10 1,2 2.3,4 I, 2,3,4 1,2.3.4.5 1,2,3,4 16, 17 4.5 1,2,3,4,5 1.2.3,4,5.6 1,2.3.4 1.2 3.4,5,6,7 1.2.3.4 1,2,3,4 1 *14 1.2 1.2. 3 1.2,3,4 I,2,3,4.5,6.7,8.6-i,7-I 1.2 ,3.4,5 ,6 0 1 .02 1.2 1.2,3,4.5.6,7 3—I 5,6,7,8, IL 12.13,14.15, 16, 17 1,2 1,2,3 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 1.2,3,4 1 .2,3 .4 Arkwright Atkinson Bowen Hammond 1,2,3,4 A2 . A), A4, A lA, AIR, IBLR. 2BLR, 3BLR, 4BLR 1 .2 .3.4 D-2 ------- Appendix D $lak Plant Name INDIANA Harilee Branch Jack Mcdonough Mcintosh Mcmanus Mitchell Port Wentworth Riverside Scherer Wansley Yates Baldwin Coffeen Collins Crawford Dallman Duck Creek E D Edwards Fisk Grand Tower Havana Hennepin Hutsonville Joliet 29 Joliet 9 Joppa Steam Kincaid Lakeside Marion Meredosia Newton Powerton R S Wallace Venice Vermilion Waukegan Will County Wood River A B Brown Badly Breed Cayuga Clifty Creek Dean H Mitchell Edwardsport Elmer W Stout F B Culley Frank E Ratis Gibson MT Pritchard Merom Michigan City Na 1—7221 Na I -7228 Noblesville Petersburg R Gallagher R M Schahfer Rockport State Line Tanners Creek Wabash River Warrick Whitewater Valley Ames Burlington Council Bluffs Des Moines Dubuque Earl F Wisdom Fair Station George Neal Graettinger Gnnnell Lansing Lime Creek Louisa Maynard Station Milton L Kapp Muscatine Na I —7230 Boilers 1,2,3,4 MBI. MB2 1,2 3 1,2,3,4 12 1,2,3.4 1,2 YIBR, Y2BR. Y3BR. Y4BR, Y5BR. Y6BR, Y7BR, 1.2,3 01,02 1,2,3.4,5 7,8 31. 32, 33 1,2,3 19 07,08,09 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9 1,2 05.06 71, 72,81, 82 5 1,2,3,4,5,6 1,2 7,8, GT2 1,2,3,4 01,02,03,04,05,06 1,2 51, 52, 61, 62 9, 10 1.2,3.4.5,6.7,8 1,2 7,8, 17 1,2,3.4 1,2,3,4,5 1,2, “4 7,8 1,2 1,2,3,4,5.6 4,5,6,11 6-1,7-1,7-2, 8-I 1,2,3,4,5,6,7.8,9, 10,50, 60, 70 1,2, 3 ISGI, 2SGI 1,2,3,4,5 1,2,3,4,5.6 ISGI, 2SGI 4.5,6.12 “I 1*2,1*3 *14 1*5 I, 2,3 1,2,3,4 1,2.3.4 14, 15, 17, 18 MBI. MB2 3.4 Ui, U2, L13. 1.14 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 4 1,2 7,8 1,2.3 *15, 10, II 2 1,2,3,4 * 15 *12 3.4 Ill 1*2 101 2 8,9 1*2 KENTUCKY LOUISIANA Plant Name Ottumwa Pella Praine Creek Riverside Sixth Street Streeter Station Sutherland Arthur Mullergren Cimarron River Coffeyville East 12Th St Garden City Gordon Evans Holcomb Hutchinson Jeffrey Energy Centr Judson Large Kaw Kingman La Cygne Lawrence Mcpherson 2 Mulvane Murray Gill Nearman Creek Neosho Quindaro Ripley Riverton Russell Tecumseh Big Sandy Cane Run Coleman Cooper DBWilson Dale EWBrown East Bend Elmer Smith Ghent Green River H L Spurlock Henderson I Hmp&L Station 2 I KSmith Mill Creek Na I —7220 Paradise Pineville RD Green Robert Reid Shawnee Trimble County Tyrone A B Paterson A B Paterson Arsenal Hill Big Cajun I Coughlin D G Hunter Doc Bonin Dolet Hills Houma Lieberman Little Gypsy Louisiana I Louisiana 2 Michoud Monroe Morgan City Natchitoches Ninemile Point Opelousas R S Nelson Rodemacher Ruston Sterlington Teche Waterford I & 2 Willow Glen 6,7,8 3.4 9 1,2.3.4,5 7 1,2,3 4 4 S-2 1.2 SGU I 1,2.3.4 1.2. 3 4 1,2, 3 1*9 1.2 2,3,4,5 1*7, *18 1.2,3,4 NI 7 1,2 1*2 3 39,40 1 I, 1* 12 9.10 BSIJI, BSU2 3, 4, 5, 6, II 12, *113 CI, C2, C3 1,2 WI 3,4 1.2. 3 2 1,2 1.2,3,4 1,2,3,4,5 1,2 6 HI, H2 1,2,3,4 *13, *14, *15 1,2,3 3 01,02 RI 1,2,3.4,5,6,7,8,9.10 1,2.3,4,5 3 4 5A IBI, 1B2,2Bl,2B2, 2B3 6.7 3,4 1,2, 3 IS, 16 3.4 1,2, 3 IA, 2A, 3A 10,11,12 1,2, 3 Il, 12 4 10 1,2.3,4,5 10 1,2,3,4,6 1,2 2, 3 10, 7AB 2, 3 1,2 1,2,3,4,5 Boilers ILLINOIS KANSAS IOWA D-3 ------- Do the Acid Rain Regulations Apply to You? MAINE MARYLAND MASSACHUSEflS MIC HIGAN MINNESOTA MISSISSIPPI Plant Name Hol lers St 1 Plant Name Rollers MISSOURI Graham Station Mason Steam William F Wyman 5 3,4,5 1, 2,3,4 Asbury Blue Valley Chamois I 3 2 Columbia 6, 7,8 Brandon Shores CPCrane Chalk Point Coal Gas Ccl Coal Gas Cc 2 Dickerson Easton 2 Gould Street HerbertAWagner Morgantown Nanticoke Perryman RPSmith Riverside Vienna Westport 1,2 1,2 1.2. 3,4, ‘GT3, 1 1 0T4, fl(fl **al* . 1 ** 3, I*C4 1,2, 3 1*26, 1*27 3 1,2,3,4 , 2 • 1 STl 1*52, 1*61, * 162 9, I I 1,2,3 ,4,5 8 34 Combustion Turbine I Combustion Thrbine 3 Empire Energy Center Grand Avenue H’thom latan James River Jim Hill Lake Road Meramec Montrose Na 1—7223 Na 1—7226 New Madrid Rg 1 &2 Rush [ sland “NA4, 11 NAS, ‘ 1 NA6, 1 1 NA7 1’3 *14, 11 1’.Ifl, 11 Nfr3 * 17,1*9 5 I, * 12 3. 4. s. G’r2 1* 1 ,2,3 ,4 6 1,2, 3,4 1 2.3 1*1, 1 *2, 1 13 **J 1 2 I’ ll, *fl 1,2 Brayton Point Canal Cannon Street 1,2,3,4 1 2 3 Sibley Sikeston Sioux Southwest 1,2 ,3 I 1,2 1 Cleary Flood Kendall Square Mount Tom Mystic NewBoston SalemHarbor Somerset 8.9 I. 2. 3 I 4. 5, 6, 7 1 ,2 1.2.3,4 1,2,3.4,5,6.7,8 MONTANA Thomas Hill Co lstrip FrankBird JECorette Lewis & Clark M B I, M32, MB3 1,2, 3,4 I 2 BI Waters River 1*2 NEBRASKA West Spnngfield 1, 2, 3 Bluffs C W Burdick 4 B-3 BCCObb Belle River ConnersCreek DanEKarn De lray Eckert Station Endicoct Generating Erickson Greenwood Harbor Beach 1,2,3,4,5 1. 2 15,16,17,18 1,2,3.4 7 ,8,9,10, 1 1, 12 1,2,3,4,5,6 I I I I Canaday Gerald Gentleman Ste Haroldkramer HssnngsEnergyCtr Len Wnght Na I — l Jl9 Nebraska City North Omaha Platte Sheldon I 1,2 1,2 ,3,4 1 a • 1 NA2 1, 2, 3,4,5 I 1, 2 JR Sims 3 NEVADA JCWesdock J H Campbell J R Whiting James De Young Marysvtl le Mistetsky Monroe Presque Isle 7.8 1,2,3 1.2,3 5 9. 10, 1 1 ,12 5 6, 7 1,2,3,4 2, 3, 4, 5,6,7,8,9 Clark Fort Churchill Harry Allen Mohave North Valmy Reid Gardner Sunnse 1,2,3 1 2 *9, 1*2 4*3, * 14 , 1 1 G’fl 1 1 GT4 1 ,2 1,2 1.2,3,4 I RiverRou ge Shim StClair Trenton Channel Wyandotte 491 E. 48Th Street 1,2,3 3 1,2,3,4,5,6,7 16, 17, 18, 19,9A 5, • 7, °8 NEW HAMPSHIRE Tracy Merrimack Newinston Sc uller 1 ,2,3 1 ,2 I 4, 5, 6 NEW JERSEY Allen S King BlackDog Clay Boswell Fox Lake Future Base High Bndge Hoot Lake MLHibbard Minnesota Valley Nal—7237 Northeast Station Riverside Sherburne County SilverLake Syl Laskin I 1 .2.3.4 I, 2. 3,4 3 I ll 3,4,5.6 2 ,3 3,4 3 1*2 NBPP 6.7,8 I, 2, 3 4 1, 2 B L England Bergen Burlin gion Butler Deepwater Gilbert Hudson Kearny Linden Mercer Na 3—7 141 Na4—7 142 Na 5—7217 Na6—72l8 Sayreville Sewaren Werner 1.2,3 1.2 7 * 14 1,3,4,5 6,8 9 Dl, 02,03,04,05,06,07 1 2 7 ,8 2,4,11,12,13 1 2 **j 0*2 Ill *4 1 *42 * 11 1*2 02.03.05, 06,07,08 1, 2, 3, 4,5 04 Baxter Wilson Delia Gerald Andrus JackWatson Moselle Natehea RD Morrow Rex Brown Sweatt VictorJDaiiieljr Wright 1.2 t,2 1 1 ,2,3,4,5 . 3 *16 *47 I 1,2 3,4, IA, LB 1, 2 1,2 W4 NEW MEXICO Cunningham Escalante Four Corners Maddox North Lovington Person Reeves Rio Grande San iuan 121 B. 1 22B 1, 1*2 1,2, 3,4, 5 1 1 3,05lB S2 3,4 I 2,3 6:7.8 1,2,3,4 rs A ------- Appendix D Plant Name Albany Arthur Kill Astona Bowline Point CR Huntley Charles Poletti Danskammer Dunkirk B F Barrett East River Far Rockaway Glenwood Goudey Greenidge Hickling Jennison Loveti Milliken Northport Oswego Port Jefferson Ravenswood Rochester 3 Rochester 7 Roseton S A Carlson Somerset Waterside 59Th Street 74Th Street NORTH CAROLINA Asheville Belews Creek Buck Cape Fear Chffside Dan River GGAIIen LV Sutton Lee Marshall Mayo Riverbend Roxboro W H Weatherspoon NORTH DAKOTA OHIO Antelope Valley Coal Creek Coyote Dakotas Leland Olds Milton R Young R M }leskett Stanton Acme Ashtabula Avon Lake Bay Shore Cardinal Conesville Dover Eastlake Edgewater Gen J M Gavin Gorge Hamilton JMStuart Killen Station Kyger Creek Lake Road Lake Shore Miami Fort Muskingum River Niles 0 H Hutchings Ptcway Poston R E Burger Refuse & Coal Richard Gorsuch Ttdd Toronto W H Sammis W H Zimmer Walter C Beckjord Woodsdale Boilers 1,2,3,4 20,30 10,20,30,40,50 1,2 63, 64,65,66,67, 68 001 1,2,3,4 1,2,3,4 10,20 50,60,70 40 40,50 11, 12,13 4,5,6 1,2,3,4 1,2,3,4 3.4,5 1,2 1,2,3,4 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 1,2,3,4 10. 20, 30 1.2,3,4,7,8,12 1,2,3.4 1,2 9, 10,11,12 41,42,51,52,61,62,80,90 110 120, 121. 122 1,2 1,2 5, 6, 7, 8. 9 3,4,5,6 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 1,2.3 1,2,3,4,5 1.2,3 1,2,3 1,2,3,4 IA, lB 7,8,9, 10 1,2, 3A, 3B, 4A, 4B 1,2,3 BI, 82 1,2 SI I 1,2 B 1,82 B2 I, ID 9.11,13,14,15, 16.91, 92 7,8.9,10,11 9.10.11.12 1,2.3,4 I, 2,3 1.2,3.4,5.6 * 16 1,2.3,4,5 II, 12,13 1,2 25. 26 9 1,2,3.4 2 1,2,3,4,5 6 18, 91, 92. 93, 94 6,7,8,5-1.5-2 1,2,3,4,5 1.2 H-I. H-2, H-3, H-4, H-5, H-6 9 1,2,3 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8 001,002,003,004,005,006 1,2,3,4 *9 9.10,11 1,2,3,4,5,6,7 1,2.3,4,5,6 **GTI ‘ GT2, ‘0T3 • 1 GT4, **GT5, ‘ 1 0T8, ** ‘j ’9, 1 GT 10, 1 GT 1 I, **GTl2 OREGON PENNSYLVANIA RHODE ISLAND SOUTH CAROINA Plant Name Anadarko Arbuckle Comanche Conoco Grda Horseshoe Lake Hugo Inola Mooreland Muskogee Mustang Na 1 —5030 Northeastern Ponca Riverside Seminole Sooner Southwestern Tulsa Boardman Armstrong Bruce Mansfield Brunner Island Cheswick Conemaugh Cromby Delaware Eddystone Elrama FR Phillips Front Street Hatfield’S Ferry Hoitwood Homer City Hunlock Power Keystone Marcus Hook Refinery Martins Creek Mitchell Montour New Castle Portland Richmond Schuylkill Seward Shawville Southwark Springdale Sunbury Titus Warren Williamsburg Manchester Street South Street Canadys Steam Cross Dolphus M Grainger H B Robinson Hagood Jeffenes Mcmeekin Na 4—7210 Urquhait W S Lee Wateree Williams Winyah Big Stone Huron Mobile Pathfinder Allen Bull Run Cumberland Gallatin John Sevier Johnsonville Kingston Watts Bar Boilers 3 ARB 7251,7252 *9 $12 1.2 6.7.8 Ill 1.2, 3 3.4.5,6 1,2,3,4 ‘ 2 *13 3301,3302. 3313. 3314 2 1501, 1502 I • 2, 3 1.2 8002, 8003, 80 1N, 8 OlS 1402, 1403, 1404 ISO 1.2 1.2, 3 1,2,3 1.2 1.2 71,81 1.2,3,4 1.2, 3.4 1.2.3,4,5.6 7,8.9,10 1,2,3 17 1.2, 3 6 1,2 1.2, 3,4 1.2,3,33 1,2 1,2, 3,4,5 1,2 63.64 12, 14, 15 1,2,3,4 II, 12, 21,22 77,88 3,4, IA, IB,2A,2B 1,2, 3 1,2,3,4 11 6,7,12 121, 122 CAN I, CAN2, CAN3 1.2 1,2 *14, HAGI, HAG2, HAG3 1,2, 3,4 MCMI, MCM2 1 1 ST 1 URQI, URQ2, URQ3 1,2, 3 WATI, WAT2 WILl 1.2,3,4 11 2A, *128 II, 12, 13 1,2, 3 1,2 1,2.3,4 1.2.3,4 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 A.B.C. D NEW YORK OKLAHOMA SOUTH DAKOTA TENNESSEE 0-5 ------- Do the Actd Rain Regulations Apply to You? Plant Name Baikra Plant Name Bo i le n TEXAS Trin idad 7,8,9 BarneyMDavis 1,2 Tw inCak 1 ,2 Rig8mwn 1 .2 VHfiraunig 1,2 ,3 Bryan 6 Valley 1,2,3 CE Newman W I tS Victona 5.6,7,8 Cedar Bayou CBY I, C8Y2. CBY3 WA Pansh WAN, WAP2, WAR), WAP4, Coleto Creek I , WAPS, WAP6, WitP7, WAPE Co hn I WBTuttle 1,2,3,4 Concho 2,4.5,6,7 Webster WERl, WEB2, W883 Dal las 3 ,9 Welsh 1, 2 ,3 Daosby Wi lkes 1,2 .3 DnckerCc’eek 1,2 UTA H Decorr lo va 1 B OISSI IT A I - i Deepwattr DWP L,DW 92,OWP3,DWP4, Carbon 1,2 DWP5, DWP6, DWP9 ESios lin i Gadaby 1 .2,3 EagleMountain 1,2,3 Hale Forest Grove •9 Ilunter(Eniery) 1.2.3 Huntington 1 2 Fort Phantom I, 2 Intenasountarn I SGA, 2SGA Qenenc Stat Gibbons Creek I VERMONT Graham 1.2 JCMcneii GieensBeyou GHYI,08Y2,GBY3,08 14, •na cn G8Y S BremoRh iff 3 ,4 Gi98 *9 , *2 Qiesapeake 1,2,3,4 0s99 ‘9. “2, “ Chesterfield 3.4,5,6, ‘8A, $*IS Handley 2,3,4,5, IA, 18 CLinch River 1, 2,3 Harnngton Station 0613.0628, 0638 Clover 1,2 Hira inClar ice HOC1,HOC2,HOCS,HCJC4 Glen tyn 6,51 52 Holly Ave 1,2 Possum Point 1.2,3,4,5 Holly Street 1,2,3,4 Potomac River 1.2 .3,4,5 JESpruce **l,**2 Yorktown 1.2,3 JL Bmcs 1,2 I I Deely 1,2 WASHINGTON Jones Siauois 15th. 1523 Ceniraha RW21, BW22 KnoxLee 2 ,3,4,5 KettleFa l ls La Palms 7 Staif l leton 1, 2.3 Lake Creek 1,2 WF!ST VIRGIN iA Lake hubbai’d 1 ,2 Aibright 1.2,3 Laredo 1,2,3 FonMartin 1 .2 Leon Creek 3,4 Mamaosi 1,2,3 LewisCreek 1.2 Limestone LZM LLIM2 JohnEAmos 1 .2,3 Kasniner 1 ,2 .3 LonCHi l l .2,3,4 Kanawba tiver 1 ,2 Lone Star 1 Mitche ll 1.2 Malakoff “t , ”l Mountasneer(130 1) I MartinLake 1,2 ,3 MtStonn 1,2,3 Miss ion ltoad Phu l Spori II,2I.31,4 1,5 1 Montice llo 1,2,3 Pleasants 1,2 Morgan Creek 3.4, 5,6 Riveavifle i. E Moirrikam Creek 2,6 ,1,8 , 3A. 38 2 NaI— .72l6 Nal— .72 19 “I . ’ 2 WISCONSIN Na Z—4274 “NA I Alma 34 ,B5 Neches 1 1 , 13,15,18 BayFron i 1.2,3 ,4 .5 Newman 1.2.3, “4 Blourit Street 3, 5,6,7,8,9, it Nichols Station 14 18, 1428, 1433 Columbia 1.2 NorthLake 1.2 ,3 Combustionturbine (*2 North Main 4 Cominetee 25 Norib Tenas 3 Edgewazer 3,4,5 NuecesBay 5 ,6,7 Genoa 1 OWSommers .2 JPMadgett St OakCreek I Mamiowoc 6,7,8,9 Oklaunion I Na—7222 “1 PH Robinson P}IRI, PHR2, PHR3. P1184 Na I — 7203 “Cr3, “Cr4 Paint Creek 1.2.3,4 Nat —7205 “1, “2”3 Parkdale 1,2,3 Na i “ 1 Pen man Basin 5.6 Na4 “ 1 Pirkey I Nelson Dewey 1.2 Plan iX 1118, 1128,1138 , 1148 NorthOakCreek 1,2,3,4 Powerlaae Plant 2.3 Pleasant Prairie 1,2 R W Miller 1 ,2,3 Port Washington 1.2,3.4.5 Ray Olinger 8W2, 8W3, CEl Pultiamn 3,4,5,6, 7, 8 toPecos 3,6 RoekR,ver 1,2 RrverCrest I SouthOakCreek 5,6,7,8 Sabine 1 ,2 ,3 .4 ,5 Sconeman 81,82 Sam flenron SR8I. SRB2, SRB3, S1t84 Valley I , 2, 3,4 Sam Seymour 1.2. 3 West Mannette “33 SanAngelo 2 Weston 1,2 ,3 San Miguel “2 SM-I WYOMING Saadow Dave Johnston 841, 8W42, 8W43, 9W44 Seaho lm J un Bridger SW ? 1, 8W72, 8W73, 8W74 SunG ideon 1,2,3 LaramueR iver 1,2,3 Spencer 4, 5 SuykerCreek 1,2 Naughion I 2.3 TCFerguaori Wyodak BW91 T I - I Wharton T1 IW I,THW2 Inp One Ui, U2, “3, “4 Tolk Station 1718, 1728 Tradinghouse 1, 2 ------- Appendix D Exhibit 3: Units Listed in Table 3 of §73.10 (40 CFR 73) SMk fit ALABAMA Mcwilliams 1*4 ARIZONA Springerville 3 CALIFORNIA Harbor Gen Station *90, 1 1 10A, 11 10B FLORIDA GWIvey 1*22 Indian River 1 D Intercession City 1*7,1*8,1*9, **fl Lauderdale 1 4GT1, 1 1 4GT2, ‘ 1 5GT1, • 1 5G’fl Martin 1 1 35T 1 1 4ST, 1 1 3GT1 **3Gfl, 11 4GT1, 1 1 40T2 ILLINOIS Lakeside GTI INDIANA Na 1—7228 1*1, * 12, 1*3 IOWA Nal—7230 * 11 KANSAS Wamego 1 NA I MARYLAND Coal Gas Cc I 1 1 CT2 Easton 2 * 125 Perryman 1*51 MINNESOTA Nal—7237 I ll MISSISSIPPI Moselle 1*4, 1*5 MISSOURI Combustion Turbine 1 *11 Combustion Turbine 2 1*2 Empire Energy Center 1*3 Lake Road * 18 NEBRASKA Nal—70 19 1 NA I NEVADA Clark * 19, 1*10 Harry Allen 1 1 GT1, 11 GT2 NEW JERSEY Butler 1*1, 1*3 Nal—7 139 I ll Na2—7 140 I ll OHIO Dover * 17 Woodsda le 11 GT6, 1 GT7 PENNSYLVANIA Trenton Cogen Proj “I SOUTH CAROLINA NaI —7l06 1 1 GTI Na2—7 107 1 GT2 Na3—7 108 **GT3 SOUTH DAKOTA Ci * 15 TEXAS R W Miller 1*4, 1*5 Twin Oak 2 UTAH Bonanza 1*2 VIRGINIA Clover 1,2 East Chandler 1*2 WISCONSIN Combustion Turbine 1*1 Concord *11,1*2,1*3,1*4 Nal—7203 **Cl,**Cfl Na2 I II I I 1, 1*2, 1*3, 1*4 D-7 ------- Appendix E Certificate of Representation A Certificate of Representation with instructions is attached. E-1 ------- Under the Acid Rain Program (at 40 CFR Subpwt B), the owners and operators for each affected source must designate a representative, and may designate an alternate, to act on their behalL The owners and operators must choose the representative through a process that ensures that all owners and operators have notice regarding the selection. All affected units at a source must have the same designated representative. T ipe or complete this form using black ink It you need more space, photocopy the pertinent page. When you have completed the form, Indicate the page order and total number of pages( g, 1o14,2of4,etc.)intheboXesifl the upper right hand corner of each page. You must submit one Certificate of Representation form with onoinal signatures and three photocopies. Remember that under 40 CFR 72.21, the designated representative must notify each owner and operator of all Acid Rain Program submissions. If you need assistance, call the Mid Rain Hotline at (20Z 233-9620. STEP 1 NADB is the National Allowance Data Base for the Acid Rain Program. To obtain the database on diskette or in hard copy, call the Acid Rain Hotline. This data file is in dBase format for use on an IBM-compatib le PC. It requires 2 megabytes of hard drive memory. STEP 2 The designated representative must be a natural person and cannot be a company. Please enter your firm name and address as you would like it to appear on all correspondence. STEP 5 See 40 CFR 72.2 for the definitions of “owner and “operator.” You may enter a person’s or a company’s name. identify each unit at this source that is owned or operated by the named party by providing the boiler identification number listed for the unit In the NAD For new units not listed in NADB, use the boiler number you have assigned. The state or local regulatory authority means the Public Utility Commission or other rate-making authority. As designated representative, yo are responsible for a!! submissions and allowance transactions relating to the units at that source. You and the alternate designated represertattle are liable for acts or omissions within The scope of your responsIbIlitIes under the Acid Rain program. EPA wW not Issue an Acid Rain permit or record an allowance transaction until It has received a complete Certificate of Representation. Submission instructions Mail this form to: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Acid Rain Program (8204J) Attention: Designated Representative 401 M Street, SW. Washington, D.C. 20460 For Ph... II sources, submit this form by November 17,1994. If you wish to participate In the annual auctions and sales of allowances prior to that date, submit the form earlIer. EPA will not issue proceeds from auctions or sales to a unit until it receives a complete certificate of representation. Submit a revised Certificate of when any Information changes. notified of changes to owners within 30 days. Paperwork Burden Eethnats The burden on the public for collecting arid repofling information under this request Is estimated at 35 hours per rasper,... $end cwiunente regardIng this collection of Information, Including suggestions for reducing the burden, to: Chief, Information Policy Branch (PM-223), U.S. Errdrorvnentai Pretectiun Agency, 401 M Street. SW. Washington, D.C. 20460 end to: Paperwork Reduction Project (OMB#2060.0221), Offic. of Information and Regulatory Affairs, Office of Management and Budget, Washington. D.C. 20503. Do not send your tense to these ad&ssus see th• subnzlul.n Instructions above. Acid Rain Program Instructions for Certificate of Representation (40 CFR 7224) Representation EPA must be and operators ------- United States Environmental Protection Agency Acid Rain Program 0MB No. 2060-0221 Expires 6-30-95 STEP 2 Enter requested information for the designated representative Name Address Fax Number Phone Number STEP 3 Enter requested Information for the alternate designated representative (optional) Name Address Phone Number Fax Number STEP 4 Complete Step 5. reed the certifications and sign and date I certify that I was selected as the designated representative or alternate designated representative, as applicable, by an agreement binding on the owners and operators of the affected source and each affected unit at the source. I certify that I have given notice of the agreement selecting me as the designated representative or alternate desiQnated representative, as applicable for the alfected 8ource and each affected unit at the source identified in this certificate of representation, daily for a period of one week in a newspaper of general circulation in the area where the source is located or in a State publication designed to give general public notice. I certify that I have all necessary authority to carry out my duties and responsibilities under the Acid Rain Program on behalf of the owners and operators of the affected source and of each affected unit at the source and that each such owner and operator shall be fully bound by my actions, inactions, or submissions. I certify that I shall abide by any fiduciary responsibilities imposed by the agreement by which I was selected as designated representative or alternate designated representative, as applicable. I certify that the owners and operators of the affected Source and of each affected unit at the source shall be bound by any order issued to me by the Administrator, the permitting authority, or a court regarding the source or unit. Where there are multiple holders of a legal or equitable title to, or a leasehold interest in, an affected unit, or where a utility or industrial customer purchases power from an affected unit under life-of-the-unit, firm power contractual arrangements, I certify that: I have given a written notice of my selection as the designated representative or alternate designated representative, as applicable and of the agreement by which I was selected to each owner and operator of the affected source and o each affected unit at the source; and Allowances and the proceeds of transactions involving allowances will be deemed to be held or distnbuted in proportion to each holder’s legal, equitable, leasehold, or contractual reservation or entitlement or, if such multiple holders have expressly provided for a different distnbution of allowances by contract, that allowances and the proceeds of transactions involving allowances will be deemed to be held or distributed in accordance with the contract. The agreement by which I was selected as the alternate designated representative includes a procedure for the owners and operators of the source and affected units at the source to authonze the alternate designated representative to act in lieu of the designated representative. l— STEP 1 Identify the source by plant name. State. and ORIS code from NADB Certificate of Representation Page For more information, see instructions and refer to 40 CFR 72.24 This submission is: New Revised Plant Name State ORIS Code EPA Form 7610-1(11-92) ------- Plant Name (from Step 1) Certificate - Page 2 Peg. 0 of 0 Certification I am authorized to make this submission on behalf of the owners and operators of the effected source or affected units for which the submission is made. I certify under penalty of law that I have personally examined. and am familiar with, the statements and information submitted in this document and all its attachments. Based on my inquiry of those individuals with primary responsibility for obtaining the information, I certify that the statements and Information are to the best of my knowledge and belief true, accurate, and complete. I am aware that there are significant penalties for submitting false statements and information or omitting required statements end infoimation, including the possibility of fins or imprisonment. Signature (designated representative) Data Signature (alternate) Date STEP 5 Provide the name of every owner and operator of the source and each affected unit at the source. Identify the units they own and/or operate by boiler lD# from NADB, For owners only, Identify each state or local utility regulatory authority with jurisdiction over oath owner Name 101 IDS ID, D l Regulatory Authorities ID , 0* lot l OS lOt I0 1 Owner Operator ID , lOt 101 lDt Name Owner Operator lOt lO S 101 lOt D I D l 101 lOt 101 0* D I 0 5 lOS 101 Regulatory Authorities Mama ID . I C C ID, l Ot lOt lOt 0 Owner Operator 0 1 (01 Regulatory Authonties ID , tot 10* D C ID , Name lbS lOt lO S (D C 101 I01 lot Owner Operator D C Regulatory Authorities 01 (D C IDI tOt lot ID I lot EPA Porrn76lO-1 (11-92) ------- Index A Acid Rain Appeals process 2 Acid Rain Hotline i, vii, 21 actual electrical output 13, 14, 15 affected units v, 1, 3-5, 21-27 Allowance Tracking System iii, 22, 23 accounts 22, 23 allowances iii, iv, v, vi, ix, 7, 20-27 allowance accounts 22, 24 allowance allocation iv, v, 7, 24 allowance tranactions 22 allowance transfers 23 buying allowances iv annual electrical sales 13, 15 annual steam sales 15 applicability determination i, v, ix, 1, 2, 10, 11, 15, 19, 20 Applying for an Exemption ix, 2, 6, 8, 24-25 ATS See Allowance Tracking System auxiliary firing 10, 26 B biomass 4, 17 boilers v, 6, 11, 12, 13, 14, 18 C CEM See continuous emission monitoring certifying official 2 Clean Air Act iii, iv, 3, 8, 20 clean fuels ix, 6, 8 coal v, vii, 4, 7, 11, 18 coal-fired v, vii, 18 cogeneration units ix, 5, 9, 12-15 cold standby 11 combined cycle 4, 10, 13 combined cycle combustion turbines 4, 13 combined cycle units 10, 13 combustion devices 4 commence commercial operation iv, 6, 7, 10 compensating units 3, 6 competitive bid solicitation 19 compliance certification 23 compliance plans 23, 24 compliance timelines ix, 21, 25-27 continuing requirements 6, 9, 10, 11, 15, 19, 20, 26 continuous emission monitoring ix, 8, 21, 22, 25 data acquisition and handling system 22 emission reports 22 monitoring reports 23 recordkeeping 22 reporting 22 rule 22 cooperative utilities 19 D Designated Representatives ix, 8, 21, 22, 23 digester gas 4 diluent gas monitor 22 E economic efficiency iv electric utility companies iii, vii, 17, 18 electric utility holding companies 17, 18 electricity for sale 1, 4, 5, 7, 9, 11, 12, 20 electricity generators v, 12 emission rates iv, 18 emissions limitations iii, iv, vii, 9, 22 energy efficiency iii Energy Information Administration 7, 10, 20 Energy Policy Act of 1992 i equipment certification procedures 22 excess emissions v, 23 exempted units vi, ix, 5, 6-8, 21, 23, 24 existing simple combustion turbines ix, 5, 9, 10 existing small units 5, 9, 11 existing units ix, 1, 3, 6, 11 F Federal Energy Regulatory Commission 18, 19 Federal Power Act 17 FERC See Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Form EIA-767 5, 7, 20 Form EIA-860 5, 7 fossil fuel-fired iii, 4 fossil fuels 4, 17, 20 fuel cell 4, 5 G general account application 22 generators ix, 1, 4, 6, 11, 13, 14, 15, 18 geothermal energy 17 Index-i. ------- Do the Acid Rain Regulations Apply to You’ H hazardous wastes 20 heat recovery steam generator 4, 10 historic fuel usage iv homogeneous wastes 20 I incinerators ix, 5, 9, 17, 20 independent power production facilities ix, 5, 9, 16- 19, 27 IPP See independent power production facilities L landfill gas 4 letter of intent 19 listed units 3 M market-oriented allowance program 24 market-based approaches iii marketable allowance program iii, v, 24 materials recovery facilities 20 maximum design heat input 13, 15 maximum fuel flow 13 minimum requirements 21 monitoring systems 8, 22, 25 multi-header units 6 multi-headered boilers 13 municipal electric authorities 19 municipal solid waste 20 N NADB See National Allowance Data Base nameplate capacity 1, 6, 7, 11, 13, 14, 15, 26 National Allowance Data Base iv, 3, 7, 11 natural gas 4, 8, 11, 27 nitrogen oxides iii, v, vii, 8, 18, 21, 22, 24 NOx pollutant concentration monitor 22 nonhazardous solid wastes 20 nonrecourse project financing 16 N0 See nitrogen oxides 0 offset plans 23 on-line date 7 opacity monitoring systems 22, 25 ORISPL 2 P permit applications 8, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27 permits 8, 23, 24, 25 permitting authority 2, 9, 11, 23, 24, 25 petroleum 4, 8 Phase I hi, 3, 21, 26, 27 Phase II ui, iv, 3, 8, 21, 24, 26, 27 planned net output capacity 18, 19, 27 potential electrical output capac- ity 12, 13, 14, 15, 27 power sales agreement 19 preliminary power commitments 16 PSA See power sales agreement public utilities 16, 17, 19 Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 16, 17, 18 PURPA See Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 Q QF See qualifying facilities qualifying cogeneration facilities 17 qualifying facilities ix, 5, 9, 16-19, 20 qualifying power purchase commitment 18, 19 quality assurance and quality control 22 R refuse-derived fuel 1&, 20 renewable resources 17 retired units ix, 3, 6, 8, 24, 25 S self-generation 12 simple combustion turbines ix, 5, 9, 10, 13 small generators 11 small new units burning clean fuels ix, 3, 6-8, 24 small power production facilities 17 small units 5, 6, 9 SO 2 pollutant concentration monitor 22 solar energy 17 solid waste ix, 5, 9, 17, 18, 20, 26, 27 solid waste incinerators ix, 5, 9, 17, 20 State environmental authority vii, 18, 19, 23 State or Regional permitting authority 9, Ii. steam 4, 5, 6, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 15, 19, 20 steam sales 15 substantially modified 7 substitution units 3, 6 lndex-2 ------- Index T technOlOgy-based requirements 20 total installed net output capacity 18, 19 total nameplate capacity 6, 13 total planned net output capacity 18, 19, 27 turbines ix, 5, 9, 10, 13, 27 turbine efficiency 11 U unaffected units vii, ix, 5, 9-20 .unit 4 unit account v unlisted units 3-5 utility competitive bid solicitation 19 utility units iii, iv, v, vi, 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 12 V volumetric flow monitor 22 w waste fuels 4, 18, 20 waste heat 10, 12 waste heat boiler 10 water power 17 wind energy 17 wood 20 Y yard wastes 20 lndex-3 ------- |