Control of Emissions from Idling Locomotives In 2008, The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) adopted new more stringent emissions standards and mandated the application of idle-emission controls on newly manufactured and remanufactured locomotives. This fact sheet provides technical back- ground on the issue of locomotive idling and describes what EPA is doing to reduce emissions from this source. (/: u ct ｣ C ｣ l-L- Why do railroads allow locomotives to idle? During normal railroad operations, locomotives sometimes must wait for freight cars to be switched and/or picked up, for another train to clear track on which the locomotive is to proceed, or for mechanical service. Historically, locomotives have been left idling while they are waiting. In some cases, there are practical or safety reasons why locomotives need to be left idling. In other cases, locomotive operators might simply idle the engines due to custom, habit, or misunderstandings about diesel engines. As we describe in this fact sheet, EPA is working to address all of these causes. The reasons why current locomotives may need to be left idling can be technological or related to worker and passenger needs. First, diesel engines can be difficult to start in extremely cold temperatures, especially larger diesel engines such as those used in locomotives. Also, locomotive engines are typically designed to use water without antifreeze because water is more efficient at cooling the engine. However, the water can freeze in cold weather and crack the engine block. As a result, shutting locomotives off in cold weather has historically been avoided as much as possible. Locomotive engines may also need to idle in order to maintain critical functions such as air pressure for the braking and starting systems and battery charge. Maintaining air pressure for braking is especially important since it can directly affect safety. Finally, in some cases, locomotives will idle to supply air-conditioning or heat to its crew and/or passengers, in part to comply with regulations and contractual requirements related to working conditions for the crew. (Note that the requirements related to working conditions are not regulated by EPA). United States Environmental Protection Agency Office of Transportation and Air Quality EPA420-F-08-014 March 2008 ------- What is EPA doing to control idle emissions from locomotives? EPA is working hard to reduce emissions from locomotives, both while they are pulling freight and while they are idling. However, the Clean Air Act does not give EPA unlimited ability to regulate locomotives. Section 213(a)(5) and related provisions provide EPA the authority to establish emission standards for newly manufactured and remanufactured locomotives, as well as to prohibit railroads or anyone else from tampering with emission controls. For locomotives not yet required to use the idle reduction technologies, the Clean Air Act provisions do not appear to provide EPA with particular authority to prevent railroads from allowing them to idle. Thus, as described below, EPA's regulatory efforts to reduce emissions from idling locomotives focus on requiring the application of automatic idle reduction technologies to the locomotives themselves rather than directly regulating when railroads may allow locomotives to idle. EPA's 2008 rulemaking represents an important step in its efforts to reduce emissions from idling locomotives, which began in 1998, when EPA finalized emission standards for locomotives that provided significant emission reductions for all types of operation. Those initial standards went into effect in 2000. In addition to applying to all newly manufactured locomotives, the standards also require most existing locomotives be retrofitted with emissions controls when they are remanufactured. (This generally happens every five to 15 years, depending on the locomotive). These retrofit requirements have already begun reducing emissions from existing locomotives. Note that by requiring overall reductions in emissions, the requirements have led to locomotive exhaust being cleaner when a locomotive is idling, and will continue to make them even cleaner in the future. In our 2008 rulemaking we adopted new requirements to further reduce emissions from idling locomotives by requiring technology that reduces the amount of time a locomotive spends idling and applying tighter emission standards to new locomotives generally. EPA is requiring that all newly manufactured and nearly all remanufactured locomotives be equipped with idle reduction technology that will automatically shut locomotives down if they are left idling unnecessarily. While such devices cannot eliminate all idling, they can reduce most unnecessary idling. These automatic controls offer more opportunities for a locomotive to be shut down by monitoring multiple critical system parameters to determine when it is safe to shut down a locomotive, U relieving crews that may not have the manpower to monitor all of these parameters. In the field, these devices have proven themselves to be safe, reliable and extremely cost effective by r y providing reduced fuel consumption that can pay for the equipment in short order. We believe the cost savings associated with these devices will provide significant incentives for railroads to fully utilize this equipment. o 品-H in zn 品-H a w Our regulations also include a rigorous emission testing program to make sure locomotives comply with our emission standards for their operational life. Our complete program will reduce NOx, HC, and PM emissions by about 90 percent. These standards will also significantly reduce smoke emissions and exhaust odors. In designing this locomotive emission-control program, we established several provisions to ensure that emissions are reduced at all operating conditions, including while idling. First, we require that most locomotives comply with the emission standards over two different duty cycles: a high-power cycle that represents cross-country operation and a low-power cycle that Control of Emissions from Idling Locomotives 2 ------- represents freightyard operation. To comply with these requirements, locomotive manufacturers need to reduce emissions for all power levels from idle to full power. We also require railroads to improve their maintenance practices so that when locomotives are idling, their emissions are kept as low as would be expected from a brand new locomotive. Finally, we require that malfunctioning idle reduction equipment be repaired in a timely manner. When will these mandatory emission reductions occur? Emission standards and other requirements began reducing idle emissions as early as 2000. However, because it is common for locomotives to remain in service for as long as 50 years, the number of new ultralow-emission locomotives in a railroad's fleet will be small during the start of this program. Therefore, we have designed other parts of our program to achieve more immediate reductions, such as the requirement that older locomotives be retrofitted with emission controls when they are remanufactured and provisions that require the use of automatic engine-shutdown features. Even so, it may take several years before these regulatory improvements approach full effectiveness as the fleet turns over from older locomotives to new less polluting locomotives. What are railroads doing to control idle emissions from locomotives? EPA has been working with the nation's major railroads to implement voluntary efforts to reduce idle emissions beyond the mandated reductions. All Class I railroads have joined the SmartWay Transport Program: CSX Transportation, Norfolk Southern, Canadian National Railway, BNSF Railway Co., Canadian Pacific Railway, Kansas City Southern Railway, and Union Pacific Railroad Co. As part of their SmartWay commitment, each railroad has submitted action plans describing the steps they are taking to significantly reduce carbon dioxide, NOx, and PM emissions, and to conserve considerable amounts of diesel fuel. Every Class I railroad action plan includes efforts to reduce idling through a variety of technologies and strategies, including automatic engine stop-start systems, auxiliary power units or diesel-driven heating systems, electrical shorepower connections, and company idle-shutdown policies. What can I do about locomotives idling in my neighborhood? You should first contact the local railroad facility and ask about its operating practices, including the shutdown policy. If they are unable to help you, you might want to contact the corporate headquarters. Addresses and phone numbers for the major railroads are listed below. h o 品-H in in 品-H a w BNSF Railway CN (includes Canadian National Railway 2650 Lou Menk Dr. and its U.S. operating sumsidiaries, Fort Worth, TX 76131-830 including Grand Trunk Western, Illinois 800-795-2673 Central and Wisconsin Central). 935 de La Gauchetier St. W. Montreal, Quebec H3B2M9 Canada 888-888-5909 Control of Emissions from Idling Locomotives 3 ------- Canadian Pacific Railway (Includes CSX Transportation 500 lines) 500 Water St. 501 Marquette Ave. Jacksonville, FL 32202 Minneapolis, MN 55402 904-359-3100 1-800-776-7912 Kansas City Southern Railway Company Norfolk Southern Corp. PO Box 219335 3 Commercial Pi. Kansas City, MO 64121-9335 Norfolk, VA 23510-2191 816-983-1303 757-629-2600 Union Pacific Railroad 1400 Douglas St. Omaha, NE 68179 888-877-7267 CO H U d W o 品-H CO CO 品-H a w For More Information About EPA's Locomotive Control Program You can access documents related to our regulation of locomotives on EPA's Office of Transportation and Air Quality Web site at: www.epa.gov/otaq/locomotv.htm Documents related to EPA's voluntary idle-reduction programs are available at: www.epa.gov/smartway/idling.htm For further information, please contact us at: Contact for Regulatory Programs Assessment and Standards Division U.S. EPA 2000 Traverwood Drive Ann Arbor, MI 48105 734-214-4636 asdinfo@epa.gov Contact for Voluntary Programs SmartWay Transport Partnership U.S. EPA 2000 Traverwood Drive Ann Arbor, MI 48105 734-214-4767 smartway_transport@epa.gov Control of Emissions from Idling Locomotives 4 ------- |