vvEPA United States Environmental Protection Agency Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macro! nvertebrates Ephemeroptera: Baetidae Plecoptera: Capniidae/Leuctridae Diptera: Simuliidae ------- ------- EPA-260-R-08-014 November 2008 Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macro! nvertebrates Ephemeroptera: Baetidae Plecoptera: Capniidae/Leuctridae Diptera: Simuliidae Prepared by: John Pfeiffer, Ely Kosnicki, Michael Bilger, Brett Marshall1 and Wayne Davis2 1 EcoAnalysts, Inc. 1420S. Elaine St., Suite 14 Moscow, ID 83843 2 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Office of Environmental Information Office of Information Analysis and Access Environmental Analysis Division Washington, DC 20460 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Office of Environmental Information Office of Information Analysis and Access Washington, DC 20460 Printed on chlorine free 100% recycled paper with 100% post-consumer fiber using vegetable-based ink. ------- ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Notice This document has been reviewed and approved in accordance with U.S. Environmental Protection Agency policy. Mention of trade names, products, or services does not convey and should not be interpreted as conveying official EPA approval, endorsement, or recommendation for use. Funding was provided by USERA under U.S. Department of Commerce, Commerce Information Technology Solutions Contract No. 50-CMAA-900065 with Perot Systems Government Services, Inc. and under Contract 68-C-04-006 with Great Lakes Environmental Center, Inc. Suggested citation: Pfeiffer, J., Kosnicki, E., Bilger, M., Marshall, B.D. and W. Davis. 2008. Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates. EPA-260-R-08-014. United States Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Environmental Information, Environmental Analysis Division, Washington, DC. The entire document can be downloaded from: http://www.epa.gov/bioindicators/html/publications.html USEPA Contact: Wayne Davis at davis.wayne@epa.gov Acknowledgements The authors gratefully acknowledge the contribution and reviews by A.J. Smith, Larry Abele, Diana Heitzman, Brian Duffy, Mike Bolton, Greg Pond, Evan Hornig and Keith VanNess. ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Contents Notice v Acknowledgements v Figures vii Introduction x Ephemeroptera: Baetidae A-1 Plecoptera: Separation of Leuctridae and Capniidae B-1 Diptera: Simuliidae C-1 Literature Cited D-1 VI ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Figures Figure A-1. Median caudal filament reduced (Heterocloeon sp.) A-1 Figure A-2. Median caudal filament developed (Baetis sp.) A-1 Figure A-3. Caudal filaments are often damaged, particularly in bioassessment samples A-1 Figure A-4. Hair fringe on the dorsal surface of the femur, tibia and tarsi A-2 Figure A-5. Lateral view of the thorax of Acentrella sp A-2 Figure A-6. Lateral view of P/aud/fus sp. thorax A-3 Figure A-7. Tarsal claw of Heterocloeon sp A-3 Figure A-8. Procoxal gills of Heterocloeon sp A-3 Figure A-9. Lateral view of thorax of Heterocloeon sp A-3 Figure A-10. Labial palps truncate, ventral view. (Centroptilum sp.) A-4 Figure A-11. Labial palps more elongate, sometimes resembling mittens. (Heterocloeon sp.) A-4 Figure A-12. Labrum with deep notch. (Pseudocentroptiloides sp.) A-5 Figure A-13. Labial palps and labium of Pseudocentroptiloides sp A-5 Figure A-14. Notched labrum. (Centroptilum sp.) A-5 Figure A-15. The glossae and paraglossae are often hidden behind the labial palps. (Centroptilum sp.) A-5 Figure A-16. Incisor region of right mandible (lower right) separated nearly to the base. (Centroptilum sp.) A-6 Figure A-17. Maxillary palp of Centroptilum sp A-6 Figure A-18. Incisor regions of mandible separated less than halfway to base. (Procloeon sp.) A-6 Figure A-19. Maxillary palp of Procloeon sp A-6 Figure A-20. Compound gills present. (Callibaetis sp.) A-7 Figure A-21. One simple gill arising from the posterior margin of most abdominal segments. (Baetis sp.) A-7 Figure A-22. Oblique angle of labial palps. (Cloeonsp.) A-8 Figure A-23. Labial palps not truncate and appearing 2-segmented. (Callibaetis sp.) A-8 Figure A-24. Long tarsal claws lack denticles even at high magnification. (400x, Apobaetis sp.) A-9 Figure A-25. Short tarsal claws. Denticles present. (Baetis sp.) A-9 Figure A-26. Labrum of Apobaetis sp. (400x) A-9 Figure A-27. Labial palp. (Paracloeodes sp.) A-9 Figure A-28. Maxillary palp with excavation prior to apex. (Pseudocloeon sp.) A-10 Figure A-29. The scape is the first apparent segment of an insect antenna. (Pseudocloeon sp.) A-10 Figure A-30. Labial palp with large, developed medial process. (Pseudocloeon sp.) A-10 Figure A-31. Antennae are inserted close together forming a raised keel between. (Acerpenna sp.) A-11 Figure A-32. Antennae inserted apart. (Baetis sp.) A-11 VII ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Figures (con't) Figure A-33. Gills on abdominal segment 7 are longer and narrower (arrow) than those on preceding segments. (Acerpenna sp.) A-12 Figure A-34. Dorsal view. (Acerpenna sp.) A-12 Figure A-35. Lateral view of Diphetor hageni A-12 Figure A-36. Ventral view. (Diphetor hageni) A-12 Figure A-37. Baetissp. larvae A-13 Figure A-38. Acentrella turbida in dorsal view A-14 Figure A-39. Lateral margin of the thorax of a late instar Acentrella larva showing the hind wing pad reduced to a small, downward pointing "scale" A-14 Figure A-40. Two late instar Acentrella turbida larvae A-14 Figure A-41. Dorsal view of Acentrella parvulum A-14 Figure A-42. Plauditussp. in dorsal view A-15 Figure A-43. Another Plauditussp. in dorsal view A-15 Figure A-44. Dorsal view of Heterocloeon sp A-16 Figure A-45. Heterocloeon amplum, one of the species formerly in the genus Acentrella sp A-16 Figure A-46. The simplest diagnostic character for Heterocloeon sp., when present, is the occurrence of simple gills arising from the base of the procoxae (arrows) A-16 Figure A-47. Heterocloeon sp. larvae sometimes have a heavily scleritized ridge in addition to a row of denticles on thetarsal claw A-16 Figure A-48. Dorsal view of the abdomen of Pseudocentroptiloides sp A-17 Figure A-49. The deeply cleft labrum of Pseudocentroptiloides sp A-17 Figure A-50. Dorsal view of Centroptilum sp A-18 Figure A-51. Dorsal view of Procloeonsp A-18 Figure A-52. The banding on the caudal filaments of Centroptilum sp. and Procloeon sp A-18 Figure A-53. Dorsal view of Cloeonsp A-19 Figure A-54. Close-up of the compound gills of Cloeonsp A-19 Figure A-55. Dorsal view of Callibaetis sp A-20 Figure A-56. Ventral view of the head of Callibaetis sp A-20 Figure A-57. Ventral view of the palps of Callibaetis sp A-20 Figure A-58. Dorsal view of Apobaetissp A-21 Figure A-59. Dorsal view of Paracloeodes sp A-21 Figure A-60. Dorsal view of Pseudocloeon sp A-22 Figure A-61. Ventral view of the head of Pseudocloeon sp A-22 Figure A-62. Dorsal view of Acerpenna pygmaea A-23 Figure A-63. Gill 7 of Acerpenna pygmaea A-23 VIM ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Figures (con't) Figure A-64. Dorsal and lateral views of Diphetor hageni. A-24 Figure A-65. The reduced, bifid prostheca on the right mandible of Diphetor hageni A-24 Figure A-66. Baetis intercalaris, a common species in the mid-Atlantic A-25 Figure A-67. The labial palps of Baetis tricaudatus A-25 Figure B-1. Ventral view of the abdominal segments of Allocapnia sp. (Capniidae) B-1 Figure B-2. Ventral view of the abdomen of Leuctra sp. (Leuctridae) B-1 Figure B-3. Dorsal view of Leuctridae (top) and Capniidae (bottom) abdomens B-2 Figure B-4. Dorsal view of a late instar Capniidae larva thorax (Allocapnia sp.) B-2 Figure B-5. Dorsal view of a late instar Leuctridae larva thorax (Leuctra sp.) B-2 Figure C-1. Head lacking labral fans (Twinniasp.) C-1 Figure C-2. Anal sclerite "Y" shaped. Dorsal view of end of abdomen of Twinnia sp C-1 Figure C-3. Head with labral fans present (Simulium sp.) C-1 Figure C-4. Anal sclerite "X" shaped. Compound anal gills are visible just to the left of the sclerite (Simulium sp.) C-1 Figure C-5. Dorsum of Prosimulium sp. head C-2 Figure C-6. Ventral view of Prosimulium sp. head C-2 Figure C-7. Antenna of Prosimulium sp C-2 Figure C-8. Dorsum of Grenierasp. head C-2 Figure C-9. Lateral view of Stegopterna sp. abdomen C-3 Figure C-10. Hypostomal teeth of Stegopterna sp C-3 Figure C-11. Ventral view of the posterior of Greniera sp C-3 Figure C-12. Ventral view of Simuliumsp. head C-4 Figure C-13. Compound anal gills, present in some species of Simulium sp C-4 Figure C-14. Anal gills consisting of three simple lobes (Cnephia sp.) C-4 Figure C-15. Posterior of Cnephia sp. abdomen C-5 Figure C-16. Venter of the head of Cnephia sp C-5 Figure C-17. Posterior of Greniera sp. abdomen C-5 Figure C-18. Lateral view of Grenierasp C-6 Figure C-19. Ventral view of Grenierasp. head C-6 IX ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Introduction As the use of biological monitoring becomes more prevalent, biological monitoring data are being collected by a variety of state, federal, tribal and local governments as well as watershed groups, conservation districts, and volunteer organizations. To ensure that the maximum benefits are realized from these data, it is important to maintain consistency in the collection, identification, analysis, and reporting of biological data. One difficulty in using benthic macroinvertebrates as indicators of stream water quality has been that some taxonomic groups have undergone frequent and extensive systematic revision, making data consistency problematic. One of the groups commonly encountered that has recently undergone revision is the mayfly (Ephemeroptera) family Baetidae. The genera covered in this key include: Acentrella, Acerpenna, Apobaetis, Baetis, Barbaetis, Callibaetis, Centroptilum, Cloeon, Diphetor, Heterocloeon, Paracloeodes, Plauditus, Procloeon, Pseudocentroptiloides, and Pseudocloeon. The key to genera of the family Baetidae is based on keys in Merritt and Cummins (1996) and Lugo-Ortiz and McCafferty (1998). The distributional data is based on Randolph (2002). Larvae of the black fly (Diptera) family Simuliidae have proven to be among the more difficult macroinvertebrate groups to identify to the generic level. The following genera are covered in the key: Cnephia, Ectemnia, Greniera, Prosimulium/Helodon, Simulium, Stegopterna, and Twinnia. The key to the genera of Simuliidae is based on the genus key by Adler, et al. (2004). Finally, separation of larvae of the stonefly (Plecoptera) families Leuctridae and Capniidae can be difficult, especially in early instars. The most reliable character to separate the two taxa, the membranous pleural fold on the venter of the abdomen, is often difficult to see in preserved specimens. The key to distinguishing these two genera is based on Stewart and Stark, 2002. The purpose of this document is to help improve accuracy and consistency of taxonomist identifications in the mid-Atlantic Region by providing the most recent information available and by clarifying difficult couplings with photographs. The following keys are designed to be used in the mid-Atlantic region, covering the states of Delaware, District of Columbia, Maryland, Pennsylvania, Virginia, and West Virginia. Several taxa not documented from these states but occurring in adjacent regions have been included. ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Ephemeroptera: Baetidae 1. Median caudal filament reduced, approximately 1/10 or less length of cerci (Fig. A-1) 2 1'. Median caudal filament longer, usually 1/2 to sub-equal in length to cerci (Figs. A-2 and A-3) 4 Figure A-1. Median caudal filament reduced (Heterocloeon sp.). Figure A-2. Median caudal filament developed (Baef/ssp.). Figure A-3. Caudal filaments are often damaged, particularly in bioassessment samples. Look for broken filaments. If the broken median filament is approximately the same diameter as the cerci, its length was likely to have been sub-equal or greater in length than that of the cerci. Ephemeroptera: Baetidae A-1 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates 2. (1) Usually with a row of fine setae on dorsal margin of femur, tibia, and tarsus (Fig. A-4); hind wing pads reduced to a small "scale" (Fig. A-5) Acentrella 2'. Tibia and tarsus without dorsal row of fine setae, although dorsal setal row often present on femur; hind wing pads absent or reduced, but not as above 3 Figure A-4. Hair fringe on the dorsal surface of the femur, tibia and tarsi. The hair fringe is apparent on all legs, but may be worn or broken on older specimens. (Acentrella sp.) Figure A-5. Lateral view of the thorax of Acentrella sp. Hind wing pads reduced to a small, downward-pointing "scale". This can be difficult to discern, particularly in immature specimens. A-2 Ephemeroptera: Baetidae ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates 3. (2') Claws with a single row of denticles; hind wing pads absent and posterior lateral margin of metanotum approximating a right angle in lateral view (Fig. A-6); procoxal gills never present Plauditus 3'. Claws with two rows of denticles or one row of denticles and a parallel ridge in place of second row (Fig. A-7). (Note that magnification of 400X is usually required to see these characters); some species with simple gills on procoxa (Fig. A-8); hind wing pads reduced but present (Fig. A-9) Heterocloeon Figure A-6. Lateral view of Plauditus sp. thorax. Posterior lateral margin of metanotum (arrow) visible under front wing pad forming a right angle. Even in late instar larvae such as this, no trace of a hind wing pad is present. Compare to Figures A-5 and A-9. Figure A-7. Tarsal claw of Heterocloeon sp. In this species, there is one row of denticles with a ridge in the place of the second row of denticles (400x). Figure A-8. Procoxal gills of Heterocloeon sp. The simple gill on the procoxa usually sticks out away from the body and can best be seen against a dark background. Figure A-9. Lateral view of thorax of Heterocloeon sp. Hind wing pads are reduced but visible (arrow). Ephemeroptera: Baetidae A-3 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates 4. (1') Apex of labial palps simple and truncate (Fig. A-10); caudal filaments with distinct banding every 3rd or 5th segment 5 4'. Labial palps variable but never truncate as above (Fig. A-11); caudal filaments not banded every 3rd or 5th segment 7 Figure A-10. Labial palps truncate, ventral view. (Centroptilum sp.) Figure A-11. Labial palps more elongate, sometimes resembling mittens. (Heterocloeon sp.) A-4 Ephemeroptera: Baetidae ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates 5. (4) Labrum w/deep triangular median notch on anterior margin (Fig. A-12); Labial palps broadly truncate and paraglossae broad and longer than glossae (Fig. A-13); claws longer than respective tarsi; gills simple (not known from states included in this key, but found in adjacent states (OH) Pseudocentroptiloides 5'. Labrum with smaller, squared median notch along anterior margin (Fig. A-14); paraglossae sub-equal to glossae (Fig. A-15); claws usually shorter than respective tarsi; gills simple or compound 6 Figure A-12. Labrum with deep notch. (Pseudocentroptiloides sp.) Figure A-13. Labial palps and labium of Pseudocentroptiloides sp. ase of glossae and paraglossae Figure A-14. Notched labrum. The "smaller" notch is clearly visible using a dissecting scope. (Centroptilum sp.) Figure A-15. The glossae and paraglossae are often hidden behind the labial palps. However, you should be able to discern them without removing the palps. All that is necessary to determine is whether they are about the same length, or the outer structures (paraglossae) are much longer. (Centroptilum sp.) Ephemeroptera: Baetidae A-5 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates 6. (5') Incisor of mandible usually separated to base (Fig. A-16); maxillary palps 3-segmented with segment 3 as long or longer than segment 2 (Fig. A-17); gills simple; cerci with lateral setae absent in distal fourth; abdomen with lateral spines absent or reduced Centroptilum 6'. Incisor of mandible usually separated less than half the distance to base (Fig. A-18); maxillary palps 2 or 3-segmented with segment 3 shorter than segment 2 when present (Fig. A-19); gills usually compound; cerci with lateral setae usually present to tip; abdomen with lateral spines well developed on at least segments 8 and 9 Procloeon Figure A-16. Incisor region of right mandible (lower right) separated nearly to the base. This character can usually be seen by pushing down on the head to spread the mouthparts. (Centroptilum sp.) Figure A-17. Maxillary palp of Centroptilum sp. The second and third segments of the maxillary palp are about equal in length. Figure A-18. Incisor regions of mandible separated less than halfway to base. (Procloeon sp.) Figure A-19. Maxillary palp of Procloeon sp. The third (apical) segment is much shorter than the second. A-6 Ephemeroptera: Baetidae ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates 7. (4') Compound gills present (Fig. A-20) (Cloeon, Callibaetis) 8 7'. All gills simple (Fig. A-21) 9 Figure A-20. Compound gills present. These often appear as two separate gills arising from the same base near the posterior margin of each abdominal segment. (Callibaetis sp.) Figure A-21. Simple gills. One simple gill arising from the posterior margin of most abdominal segments. (Baetis sp.) Ephemeroptera:Baetidae A-7 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates 8. (7) Labial palps 3-segmented, obliquely truncate (Fig. A-22); hind wing pads absent; recurved flaps on gills folded dorsally Cloeon &. Labial palps appearing 2-segmented, long and "spoon-shaped" (Fig. A-23); hind wing pads present; recurved flaps on gills folded ventrally Callibaetis » Oblique Angle formed by truncate palpi Photo: S.K. Burian Figure A-22. Oblique angle of labial palps. Cloeon is usually found in seasonal wetlands; rare in stream bioassessment samples. (Cloeon sp.) Figure A-23. Labial palps not truncate and appearing 2-segmented. This taxon is more common in stream bioassessment samples but is also collected from ephemeral habitats. (Callibaetis sp.) A-8 Ephemeroptera:Baetidae ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates 9. (7') Claws without denticles and long, equal to or greater than half the length of their respective tarsi (Fig. A-24) (Apobaetis, Paracloeodes) 10 9'. Claws with denticles and shorter, less than half the length of their respective tarsi (Fig. A-25) 11 Figure A-24. Long tarsal claws lack denticles even at high magnification. (400x, Apobaetis sp.) Figure A-25. Short tarsal claws. Denticles present. Total length less than 50% of tarsus. (Baetis sp.) 10. (9) Claws sub-equal to length of tarsi (Fig. A-24); labrum without median notch on anterior margin (Fig. A-26) (not recorded from the mid-Atlantic, but found in adjacent states) Apobaetis 10'. Claws about half the length of tarsi; labrum with median notch; labial palps notched as in Fig. A-27. (not recorded from the mid-Atlantic, but found in adjacent states NY, OH) Paracloeodes Figure A-26. Labrum of Apobaetis sp. (400x). Unlike other Baetidae, there is no median notch on the front margin of the labrum. Figure A-27. Labial palp. (Paracloeodes sp.) Ephemeroptera: Baetidae A-9 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates 11. (9') Maxillary palps with sub-apical excavation (Fig. A-28); antennal scape with distal lobe (Fig. A-29); labial palp often with well developed medial process (Fig. A-30) Pseudocloeon 11'. Maxillary palps and scape not as above, medial process may or may not be developed 12 Figure A-28. Maxillary palp with excavation prior to apex. (Pseudocloeon sp.) Figure A-29. The scape is the first apparent segment of an insect antenna. (Pseudocloeon sp.) Figure A-30. Labial palp with large, developed medial process. (Pseudocloeon sp.) A-10 Ephemeroptera: Baetidae ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates 12. (11') Antennae inserted close together forming a raised keel between insertion points (Fig.A-31) 13 12'. Antennae inserted apart, area between antenna insertions points not raised (Fig. A-32) 14 Figure A-31. Antennae are inserted close together forming a raised keel between. (Acerpenna sp.) Figure A-32. Antennae inserted apart. In these taxa, the area between the antennae (frons) is relatively flat and does not form a keel. (Baetis sp.) Ephemeroptera:Baetidae A-11 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates 13. (12) Lateral gills present on abdominal segment 1; gill on abdominal segment 7 pointed and narrower than preceding gills (Fig. A-33); Labial palp with well developed medial process (similar to Fig. A-30); tuft of setae on right mandible between incisors and molar region (Fig. A-34) Acerpenna 13'. Gills absent on abdominal segment 1 (Fig. A-35); gill on abdominal segment 7 rounded and similar in shape to gills on preceding segments; prostheca on right mandible reduced; bifid and serrate on inner margin (Fig. A-36); generally brown without distinct marking; occasionally light lateral margins on abdominal segments Diphetor hageni Figure A-33. Gills on abdominal segment 7 are longer and narrower (arrow) than those on preceding segments. (Acerpenna sp.) Figure A-34. The tuft of setae between the molar region (right bottom) and the incisors (left bottom) is located proximal to the incisors best viewed at 400x. Dorsal view. (Acerpenna sp.) Figure A-35. Lateral view of Diphetor hageni. On the first abdominal segment, no gill or gill scar is present on the posterior lateral margin (black arrow). Even though the gills on following segments may be missing, a darkened gill scar is usually visible (yellow arrows). Figure A-36. In Diphetor, the prostheca is reduced to a bifid (forked) hair. This species is often misidentified as Baetis. Ventral view. (Diphetor hageni) A-12 Ephemeroptera: Baetidae ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates 14. (12') Antennae long, length greater than twice the length of the head capsule; color variable (Fig.A-37) Baetis 14'. Antennae short, sub-equal in length to head capsule; color pale with dark pigment bands encircling some abdominal segments (in the mid-Atlantic, known only from southern Virginia) Barbaetis Figure A-37. Baetis sp. larvae have long antennae. This is one of the most commonly collected baetid taxa in North America. (Baetis tricaudatus) Ephemeroptera: Baetidae A-13 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Acentrella sp. The genus Acentrella sp. is a common component of the baetid community in mid-Atlantic streams. The fringe of fine hairs present on the femur, tibia, and tarsus is the easiest character to use in distinguishing this genus. In older specimens this fringe may be worn or broken but is usually still apparent. One species (Acentrella turbida) is recorded from the region. A second species (Acentrella parvulum), has been recorded from Ohio westward, and may eventually be found in the mid-Atlantic. Additional References: Jacobus, L.M. and W.P. McCafferty. (2006). A new species of Acentrella Bengtsson (Ephemeroptera: Baetidae) from Great Smoky Mountains National Park, USA: Aquatic Insects, v. 28, p. 101 -111. McCafferty, W.P., Wigle, M.J. and R.D. Waltz. (1994). Systematics and biology of Acentrella turbida (McDunnough) (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae). Pan-Pacific Entomologist 70[4], 301-308. Morihara, O.K. and W.P. McCafferty. (1979). The Baetis Larvae of North America (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae). Transactions of the American Entomological Society 105, 139-221. Wiersema, N.A. (2000). A new combination for two North American small Minnow Mayflies (Ephemeroptera: Baetidae). Entomological News 111[2], 140-142. Figure A-38. Acentrella turbida in dorsal view. The body form superficially resembles that of Heptageniidae in many eastern specimens. Figure A-39. Lateral margin of the thorax of a late instar Acentrella larva showing the hind wing pad reduced to a small, downward pointing "scale". Figure A-40. Two late instar Acentrella turbida larvae. Figure A-41. Dorsal view of Acentrella parvulum. This species has not been recorded from the mid- Atlantic, but has been found in Ohio. A-14 Ephemeroptera:Baetidae ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Plauditus sp. The genus Plauditus sp. was erected in 1998 encompassing species which were previously placed in the genera Baetis sp. and Barbaetis sp. (Lugo-Ortiz and McCafferty, 1998). Species within the genus have a reduced median caudal filament and lack a hind wing pad. They are generally small, rather fragile baetids. Plauditus sp. is common in stream bioassessment samples from the mid- Atlantic. Additional References: Lugo-Ortiz, C.R. and W.P. McCafferty. (1998). A new North American genus of Baetidae (Ephemeroptera) and key to Baetis complex genera. Entomological News 109[5], 345-353. Morihara, O.K. and W.P. McCafferty. (1979). The Baetis Larvae of North America (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae). Transactions of the American Entomological Society 105, 139-221. Figure A-43. Another Plauditus sp. in dorsal view. Figure A-42. Plauditus sp. in dorsal view. The wing pads are dark because this specimen was about to emerge when collected. The body is shaped fundamentally different from most Acentrella sp. Ephemeroptera:Baetidae A-15 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Heterocloeon sp. The genus Heterocloeon sp. was recently revised by McCafferty et al. (2005). Several species formerly included in the genera Acentrella sp. and Plauditus sp. were moved into Heterocloeon sp. Therefore, many of the species recently moved into Heterocloeon will not key correctly in older keys. Additional References: McCafferty, W.P., Waltz, R.D., Webb, J.M. and L.M. Jacobus. (2005). Revision of Heterocloeon McDunnough (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae). Journal of Insect Science, v. 5. lnsectscience.org/5.35 Morihara, O.K. and W.R McCafferty. (1979). The Baetis Larvae of North America (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae). Transactions of the American Entomological Society 105, 139-221. Muller-Liebenau, I. (1974). Rheobaetis, a New Genus from Georgia (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae). Annals of the Entomological Society of America 67:555-567. ^m ••^•^^•^^H ^H Figure A-44. Dorsal view of Heterocloeon sp. Figure A-45. Heterocloeon amplum, one of the species formerly in the genus Acentrella sp. Figure A-46. The simplest diagnostic character for Heterocloeon sp., when present, is the occurrence of simple gills arising from the base of the procoxae (arrows). This can usually be observed without high magnification. They are more durable than abdominal gills and are usually attached to even severely damaged specimens. However, they can be very difficult to see in rotting or digested specimens. Figure A-47. Heterocloeon sp. larvae sometimes have a heavily scleritized ridge in addition to a row of denticles on the tarsal claw. In this image the ridge occurs in the foreground and the denticles arise behind the ridge in the background. This feature occurs in taxa that may not exhibit procoxal gills. A-16 Ephemeroptera:Baetidae ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Pseudocentroptiloides sp. The genus Pseudocentroptilodes sp. has not been recorded from the states comprising the mid- Atlantic, but occurs in Ohio. Additional References: Waltz, R.D. and W.P. McCafferty. (1989). New species, redescriptions, and cladistics of the genus Pseudocentroptiloides (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae). Journal of the New York Entomological Society 97[2], 151-158. Figure A-48. Dorsal view of the abdomen of Pseudocentroptiloides sp. Figure A-49. The deeply cleft labrum of Pseudocentroptiloides sp. Ephemeroptera:Baetidae A-17 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Centroptilum sp./Procloeon sp. Both Centroptilum sp. and Procloeon sp. are found throughout the mid-Atlantic. Both genera have truncate labial palps and tails banded every 3rd to 5th segment. Additional References: Lowen, R.G. and J.F. Flannagan. (1991). Four Manitoba species of Centroptilum Eaton (Ephemeroptera): Baetidae) with remarks on the genus. Pages 189-205 in Overview and Strategies of Ephemeroptera and Plecoptera, J. Alba-Tercedor and A. Sanchez-Ortega, eds.The Sandhill Crane Press, Inc. Gainesville, Florida, USA. Lowen, R.G. and J.F. Flannagan. (1992). Nymphs and imagoes of four North American species of Procloeon Bengtsson with description of a new species (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae). The Canadian Entomologist 124:97-108. Wiersema, N.A. (1999). Two new species of Procloeon (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae) from Texas. Entomological News 110(1):27-35. Figure A-50. Dorsal view of Centroptilum sp. Figure A-51. Dorsal view of Procloeon sp. Figure A-52. The banding on the caudal filaments of Centroptilum sp. and Procloeon sp. are often visible even if the majority of the cerci are missing. A-18 Ephemeroptera:Baetidae ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Cloeon dipterum The genus Cloeon sp. consists of one species in North America, Cloeon dipterum. This taxon occurs in permanent and temporal pools and other small, quiet water bodies, and therefore is rarely collected in bioassessment samples. Figure A-53. Dorsal view of Cloeon sp. Figure A-54. Close-up of the compound gills of Cloeon sp. Ephemeroptera:Baetidae A-19 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Callibaetis sp. Callibaetis sp. is primarily a mayfly of lentic habitats, but will often occur in bioassessment samples from pools or slow streams. The large, "spoon-shaped" palps are distinctive among North America Baetidae. Additional References: Check, G.R. (1982). A revision of the North American species of Callibaetis (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae) PhD Dissertation, University of Minnesota. Figure A-55. Dorsal view of Callibaetis sp. Figure A-56. Ventral view of the head of Callibaetis sp. Figure A-57. Ventral view of the palps of Callibaetis sp. A-20 Ephemeroptera:Baetidae ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Apobaetis sp./Paracloeodes sp. Neither of these genera have been recorded from the states comprising region 3, but have been found in adjacent states and may eventually be encountered in the Region. Additional References: McCafferty, W.P. and D.R. Lenat. (2003). A new Nearctic Paracloeodes (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae). Entomological News 114:33-36. McCafferty, W.P. (2000). A new Nearctic species of Apobaetis (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae). Entomological News, 111:265-269. Figure A-58. Dorsal view of Apobaetis sp. This is a genus of large, sandy rivers. The labrum without a median notch and the long claws help to separate this genus from other baetids. MMM Figure A-59. Dorsal view of Paracloeodes sp. Ephemeroptera:Baetidae A-21 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Pseudocloeon sp. The species in this genus were formerly in the genus Labiobaetis sp. and are often listed as such in older keys. Pseudocloeon sp. is found throughout the mid-Atlantic. Additional References: McCafferty, W.P. and R.D. Waltz. (1995). Labiobaetis (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae): new status, new North American species, and related new genus. Entomological News 106[1], 19-28. Morihara, O.K. and W.P. McCafferty. (1979). The Baetis Larvae of North America (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae). Transactions of the American Entomological Society 105, 139-221. Figure A-60. Dorsal view of Pseudocloeon sp. Figure A-61. Ventral view of the head of Pseudocloeon sp. The subapical excavation on the maxillary palp is an easily visible character to identify this genus. A-22 Ephemeroptera:Baetidae ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Acerpenna sp. Acerpenna sp. is common throughout the mid-Atlantic. The genus is separated from other Baetidae by the narrowed gill on abdominal segment 7 which is dissimilar from proceeding gills, antenna inserted close together forming a raised keel, and a well developed median projection on the labial palp. Additional References: Waltz, R.D. and W.P. McCafferty. (1987). New genera of Baetidae for some Nearctic species previously included in Baetis Leach (Ephemeroptera). Annals of the Entomological Society of America 80[5], 667-670. Morihara, O.K. and W.P. McCafferty. (1979). The Baetis Larvae of North America (Ephemeroptera: Baetidae). Transactions of the American Entomological Society 105, 139-221. Figure A-62. Dorsal view of Acerpenna pygmaea. Figure A-63. Gill 7 of Acerpenna pygmaea. Ephemeroptera:Baetidae A-23 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Diphetor hageni This genus is monotypic, with Diphetor hageni as the sole species assigned to the genus. D. hageni occurs throughout the mid-Atlantic and are fairly common in stream bioassessment samples. The absence of gills on abdominal segment 1 and the reduced prostheca are reliable characters for identifying this genus. Additional References: Waltz, R.D. and W.P. McCafferty. (1987). New genera of Baetidae for some Nearctic species previously included in Baetis Leach (Ephemeroptera). Annals of the Entomological Society of America 80[5], 667-670. Morihara, O.K. and W.P. McCafferty. (1979). The Baetis Larvae of North America (Ephemeroptera: Baetidae). Transactions of the American Entomological Society 105, 139-221. Figure A-64. Dorsal and lateral views of Diphetor hageni. Figure A-65. The reduced, bifid prostheca on the right mandible of Diphetor hageni is distinctive for NA Baetidae, but requires slide mounting the mandible and a magnification of around 400x. A-24 Ephemeroptera:Baetidae ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Baetis sp. The genus Baetis sp. is often the most common mayfly component of bioassessment samples. Additional References: Morihara, O.K. and W.R McCafferty. (1979). The Baetis Larvae of North America (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae). Transactions of the American Entomological Society 105, 139-221. Weirsema, N.A., Nelson, C.R. and K.F. Kuehnl. (2004). A New Small Minnow Mayfly (Ephemeroptera: Baetidae) from Utah, USA. Entomological News 115:139-145. Figure A-66. Baetis intercalaris, a common species in the mid-Atlantic. Figure A-67. The labial palps of Baetis tricaudatus. Ephemeroptera:Baetidae A-25 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Barbaetis sp. Barbaetis benfieldi, the only species now assigned to this genus, is recorded from the southeastern U.S. and is known in the mid-Atlantic only from southern Virginia. Additional References: Waltz, R.D., W.R McCafferty and J.H. Kennedy. (1985). Barbaetis: A new genus of eastern Nearctic mayflies (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae).The Great Lakes Entomologist 18[4], 161-165. Description of Barbaetis benfieldi, the sole species in the genus. A-26 Ephemeroptera:Baetidae ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Plecoptera: Separation of Capniidae and Leuctridae Separation of larvae of the families Leuctridae and Capniidae can be difficult, especially in early instars. The most reliable character to separate the two taxa, the membranous pleural fold on the venter of the abdomen, is often difficult to see in preserved specimens. The pleural fold reaches to abdominal segment 9 on Capniidae (Fig. B-1), while in Leuctridae the pleural fold ends at abdominal segment 7 or before (Fig. B-2). Figure B-1. Ventral view of the abdominal segments of Allocapnia sp. (Capniidae). The pleural fold is a crease that runs just inside the lateral margin of each abdominal segment from segments 1 through 9. It is visible just inside the top and bottom margins of the abdomen as a darker line, easiest to see on the bottom side in this photo (arrow). Figure B-2. Ventral view of the abdomen of Leuctra sp. (Leuctridae). The pleural folds on Leuctridae are often difficult to see, as in this specimen. In this genus, the most commonly found Leuctridae in Region 3, the pleural fold is from segments 1 -4 (arrow). Plecoptera: Capniidae/Leuctridae B-1 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates The shape of the abdomen can also aid in the separation of the two families; this character is generally easier to see than the pleural folds. The abdomen of Leuctridae is generally parallel sided, while in Capniidae the abdomen appears wider at the distal end (Fig. B-3). In Capniidae, the length of the hind wing pad is generally less than twice the greatest width (Fig. B-4). In Leuctridae, the length of the hind wing pad is 2-1/2 to 3 times the greatest width (Fig. B-5). Figure B-3. Dorsal view of Leuctridae (top) and Capniidae (bottom) abdomens. Note abdominal segments 6 to 8 on Capniidae are wider than the proximal and distal segments, while in Leuctridae the width of the segments are relatively uniform throughout. Figure B-4. Dorsal view of a late instar Capniidae larva thorax (Allocapnia sp.). The length of the hind wing pad is shorter than twice its greatest width. In this genus, commonly collected in bioassessment samples in Region 3, the hind wing pads are truncate; in most other Capniidae, the hind wing pads are more rounded. Figure B-5. Dorsal view of a late instar Leuctridae larva thorax (Leuctra sp.). The length of the hind wing pads of this common eastern genus is approximately three times the greatest width. B-2 Plecoptera: Capniidae/Leuctridae ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Diptera: Simuliidae 1. Labral fans absent (Fig. C-1); anal sclerite 'Y' shaped (Fig. C-2); lateral margins of head strongly convex Twinnia 1'. Labral fans present (Fig. C-3); anal sclerite 'X' shaped (Fig. C-4); lateral margins of head slightly convex 2 Figure C-1. Head lacking labral fans (Twinnia sp.). Figure C-2. Anal sclerite "Y" shaped. Dorsal view of end of abdomen of Twinnia sp. Figure C-3. Head with labral fans present (Simuliumsp.). Figure C-4. Anal sclerite "X" shaped. Compound anal gills are visible just to the left of the sclerite (Simulium sp.). Diptera:Simuliidae C-1 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates 2. (1) Postocciput nearly complete dorsally, enclosing cervical sclerites (Fig. C-5); median tooth of hypostoma compound (Fig. C-6); usually with 3rd antennal segment dark with 1st and 2nd segments light (Fig. C-7) Prosimulium/Helodon 2'. Cervical sclerites free (Fig. C-8); median tooth of hypostoma single (Fig. C-10 and C-12); antennal pigment not as above 3 Figure C-5. Dorsum of Prosimulium sp. head. The postocciput encloses the two cervical sclerites (arrows- compare to Fig. C-8). Figure C-6. Ventral view of Prosimulium sp. head. Note the large, compound median hypostomal tooth. Figure C-7. Antenna of Prosimulium sp. Most Prosimulium have the basal segments of the antenna pale, while the last segment is pigmented. Figure C-8. Dorsum of Greniera sp. head. The cervical sclerites are not enclosed and are visible as two brown spots at the back of the head (arrows). C-2 Diptera:Simuliidae ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates 3. (2) Abdominal segment 9 with transverse midventral bulge (Fig. C-9); Hypostomal teeth in three distinct groups (Fig.C-10) Stegopterna 3. Abdominal segment 9 without transverse midventral bulge although two ventral tubercles sometimes present (Fig. C-11); hypostomal teeth not as above 4 Figure C-9. Lateral view of Stegopterna sp. abdomen. A median, transverse, ventral bulge (arrow) is present on abdominal segment 9. Figure C-10. Hypostomal teeth of Stegopterna sp. The smaller teeth are grouped around the median and lateral teeth. Figure C-11. Ventral view of the posterior of Greniera sp., showing the ventral tubercles (arrows). Diptera:Simuliidae C-3 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates 4. (3) Hypostoma with median tooth and outer lateral teeth moderately large and subequal in height, with three smaller but nearly equal sublateral teeth between (Fig. C-12); anal gills simple or compound (Fig. C-13) Simulium 4'. Hypostoma with teeth otherwise; gills always simple (Fig. C-14) 5 Figure C-12. Ventral view of Simulium sp. head. The lateral (yellow arrows) and median teeth (black arrow) are simple and approximately equal, with three smaller teeth between the median and each lateral tooth. Figure C-13. Compound anal gills, present in some species of Simulium sp. In this lateral view, one major lobe is seen, with the accessory lobes to the right. Other genera have three simple lobes as in Fig. C-14. Figure C-14. Anal gills consisting of three simple lobes (Cnephiasp.). C-4 Diptera:Simuliidae ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates 5. (4) Segment 9 without cone-shaped tubercles (Fig. C-15); teeth of hypostoma uniformly small (Fig. C-16); length of antenna shorter than bases of labral fans Cnephia 5'. Segment 9 with cone-shaped tubercles (Fig. C-17); teeth of hypostoma and length of antenna variable , ,,,..,., , , , ,,,..,., , , , ,,,..,., , , , ,,,..,., , , , ,,,..,., 6 Figure C-15. Posterior of Cnephia sp. abdomen. No lobes or cone-shaped tubercles are present. Figure C-16. Venter of the head of Cnephia sp. Note the small, irregular hypostomal teeth. Figure C-17. Posterior of Greniera sp. abdomen. Two cone-shaped tubercles are present on ab segment 9. Diptera:Simuliidae C-5 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates 6. Abdomen greatly expanded at segment 5; teeth of hypostoma small and indistinct; anal sclerite absent Ectemnia 6'. Abdomen not greatly expanded as above (Fig. C-18); lateral teeth of hypostoma large and pronounced (Fig. C-19); anal sclerite present; rare, generally found in small headwater streams and seeps Greniera Figure C-18. Lateral view of Greniera sp. The abdomen tapers gradually towards the posterior, with no abrupt bulge at segment 5. Figure C-19. Ventral view of Greniera sp. head. Note the large lateral hypostomal teeth and the smaller, recessed median tooth. C-6 Diptera:Simuliidae ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates Literature Cited Adler, PH., Currie, D.C. and D.M. Wood. (2004). The Blackflies of North America. Comstock Publishing, Cornell Press, Ithaca, NY. 941pp. Check, G.R. (1982). A revision of the North American species of Callibaetis (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae). PhD Dissertation, University of Minnesota. Edmunds, G.R, Jr. and R.D. Waltz. (1996). Ephemeroptera. In An Introduction to the Aquatic Insects of North America, Third Edition. Merritt, R.W. and K.W. Cummins, eds. Kendall/Hunt Publishing, Dubuque, Iowa. 862 pp. Jacobus, L.M. and W.P McCafferty. (2006). A new species of Acentrella Bengtsson (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae) from Great Smoky Mountains National Park, USA. Aquatic Insects, v. 28, p. 101-111. Lowen, R.G. and J.F. Flannagan. (1991). Four Manitoba species of Centroptilum Eaton (Ephemereoptera:Baetidae) with remarks on the genus. Pages 189-205 in Overview and Strategies of Ephemeroptera and Plecoptera, J. Alba-Tercedor and A. Sanchez-Ortega, eds. The Sandhill Crane Press, Inc. Gainesville, Florida, USA. Lowen, R.G. and J.F. Flannagan. (1992). Nymphs and imagoes of four North American species of Procloeon Bengtsson with description of a new species (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae). The Canadian Entomologist 124:97-108. Lugo-Ortiz, C.R. and W.P. McCafferty. (1998). A new North American genus of Baetidae (Ephemeroptera) and key to Baetis complex genera. Entomological News 109(5): 345-353. Lugo-Ortiz, C.R., McCafferty, W.P. and R.D. Waltz. (1999). Definition and reorganization of the genus Pseudocloeon (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae) with new species descriptions and combinations. Transactions of the American Entomological Society 125(1-2): 1-37. McCafferty, W.P. (2000). A new Nearctic species of Apobaetis (Ephemeroptera: Baetidae). Entomological News 111:265-269. McCafferty, W.P. and D.R. Lenat. (2003). A new Nearctic Paracloeodes (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae) Entomological News 114:33-36. McCafferty, W.P. and R.D. Waltz. (1995). Labiobaetis (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae): new status, new North American species, and related new genus. Entomological News106[1], 19-28. McCafferty, W.P, Wigle, M.J. and R.D. Waltz. (1994). Systematics and biology of Acentrella turbida (McDunnough) (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae). Pan-Pacific Entomologist 70[4], 301-308. Literature Cited D-1 ------- Taxonomic Aids for Mid-Atlantic Benthic Macroinvertebrates McCafferty, W.P., Waltz, R.D., Webb, J.M. and L.M. Jacobus. (2005). Revision of Heterocloeon McDunnough (Ephemeroptera: Baetidae). Journal of Insect Science, 5:35. lnsectscience.org/5.35 Merritt, R.W. and K.W. Cummins. (1996). An introduction to the aquatic insects of North America, Third Edition, Kendall/Hunt Publishing Company, Dubuque, Iowa, USA. 862p. Morihara, O.K. and W.P. McCafferty. (1979). The Baetis Larvae of North America (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae). Transactions of the American Entomological Society 105, 139-221. Muller-Liebenau, I. (1974). Rheobaetis, a New Genus from Georgia (Ephemeroptera: Baetidae). Annals of the Entomological Society of America 67:555-567. Randolph, PR. (2002). Atlas and Biogeographic review of the North American Mayflies (Ephemeroptera). PhD Dissertation, Department of Entomology, Purdue University. 514 pp. Stewart, K.W. and B.P Stark. (2002). Nymphs of North American Stonefly Genera, Second Edition. The Caddis Press, Columbus, Ohio. 510 pp. Waltz, R.D. and W.P. McCafferty. (1987). New genera of Baetidae for some Nearctic species previously included in Baetis Leach (Ephemeroptera). Annals of the Entomological Society of America 80[5], 667-670. Waltz, R.D. and W.P. McCafferty. (1989). New species, redescriptions, and cladistics of the genus Pseudocentroptiloides (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae). Journal of the New York Entomological Society 97[2], 151-158. Waltz, R.D., McCafferty, W.P. and J.H. Kennedy. (1985). Barbaetis: A new genus of eastern Nearctic mayflies (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae).The Great Lakes Entomologist 18[4], 161-165. Weirsema, N.A., C.R. Nelson and K.F. Kuehnl. (2004). A New Small Minnow Mayfly (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae) from Utah, USA. Entomological News 115:139-145. Wiersema, N.A. (1999). Two new species of Procloeon (Ephemeroptera:Baetidae) from Texas. Entomological News 110(1):27-35. Wiersema, N.A. (2000). A new combination for two North American small minnow mayflies (Ephemeroptera: Baetidae). Entomological News 111(2):140-142. D-2 Literature Cited ------- ------- xvEPA United States Environmental Protection Agency Please make all necessary changes on the below label, detach or copy, and return to the address in the upper left-hand corner. If you do not wish to receive these reports CHECK Q. HERE detach, or copy the cover, and return to the address in the upper left-hand corner. PRESORTED STANDARD POSTAGE & FEES PAID EPA PERMIT No. G-35 Office of Environmental Information Office of Information Analysis and Access Environmental Analysis Division Washington, DC 20460 Official Business Penalty for Private Use $300 EPA-260-R-08-014 November 2008 ------- |