wEPA
United States
Environmental Protection
Agency
Office of the
Administrator
[Mail Code 1 802]
Project XL: City of
Fort Worth, Texas
EPA-100-F-00-041
September 2000
(http://www, epa.gov)
POL
r.coxoM
IN NO VAT
WHAT IS
PROJECT XL?
X* Pro/erf •
SUMMARY OF
THE FORT
WORTH
PROJECT
SUPERIOR
ENVIRONMENTAL
PERFORMANCE
Project XL, which stands for "excellence and Leadership," is a national initiative that
tests innovative ways of achieving better and more cost-effective public health and
environmental protection. The information and lessons learned from Project XL are
being used to assist the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in redesigning
its current regulatory and policy-setting approaches. Project XL encourages testing of
cleaner, cheaper, and smarter ways to attain environmental results superior to those
achieved under current regulations and policies, in conjunction with greater
accountability to stakeholders. It is vital that each project tests new ideas with the
potential for wide application and broad environmental benefits. As of September
2000, over forty pilot experiments are being implemented and several additional
projects are in various stages of development.
As part of their program to address urban blight, the city of Fort Worth faces significant
costs for the demolition of dozens of abandoned structures containing asbestos
bearing materials. Under this XL project, the city will test the effectiveness of an
alternative, less costly method for demolishing such structures compared to the
method required by the Clean Air Act. The project consists of three phases. In Phase
1, the city will test its method by monitoring asbestos emissions from the demolition of
a structure containing asbestos, but not subject to the federal asbestos standard by
virtue of its classification as a residential building with four or fewer dwelling units. In
Phase 2. the city will monitor asbestos emissions as it demolishes two additional
structures, one using the federally mandated method and the other using the
alternative method. If the tests in the first two phases are successful, Fort Worth will
be allowed to conduct a specific number of demolitions using its method during the
final phase of the project.
Two agreements will be executed under this project. The first agreement lays out the
phased approach for the project and the asbestos monitoring plan the city will use
during Phase 1. Later, stakeholders will develop the final project agreement covering
the last two phases of the project. This XL project, EPA's 46'". was signed on
September 29, 2000.
The city of Fort Worth intends to demonstrate that its method for demolishing
structures containing asbestos will protect the public from asbestos emissions as well
as the current federal method does. Moreover, the city expects that their innovative,
lower-cost demolition method will allow them to accelerate the pace of demolitions,
thereby eliminating sites potentially harboring illegal activities and reducing community
safety/health hazards associated with abandoned structures.
FLEXIBILITY
The city does not need regulatory flexibility to perform Phase 1 of the project, since the
structure being demolished will not be subject to the requirements of the federal
asbestos standard. However, for any demolitions performed during Phases 2 and 3
using the Fort Worth method, the city will need flexibility from the federal hazardous air
pollutant standard for asbestos. Specifically, the city seeks flexibility to replace work
practice requirements in the standard, which require asbestos removal prior to
demolition, with their asbestos-in-place wet demolition techniques. With this flexibility,
the city estimates that the cost of demolitions could be reduced by up to two-thirds.
Page 1
-------
STAKEHOLDER
INVOLVEMENT
Fort Worth has contacted a number of community groups to discuss the project, and
will conduct a public meeting prior to the demolition during Phase 1 of the project. A
more formal stakeholder process, including national environmental groups as well as
community representatives, will be conducted for negotiation of the final project
agreement and implementation of Phases 2 and 3.
APPROACHES
TO BE TESTED
CONTACTS
Will the Fort Worth method for demolition of structures containing asbestos be as
protective of public health as the current federal method?
> Will the Fort Worth method reduce the costs of demolitions, thereby helping to
accelerate the city's program against urban blight?
EPA Region 6:
EPA Headquarters:
City of Fort Worth:
Adele Cardenas
David Beck
Kathryn Hansen
(214)665-7210
(919) 541-5421
(817)871-8136
FOR ELECTRONIC
INFORMATION
More information about this XL project, or the Project XL Program, is available on the
Internet at http://www.epa.qciv/proiectxl under "Information on Specific XL Projects," or
via Project XL's Information Line at (202) 260-5754.
Page 2
------- |