March 2000
Environmental Technology
Verification Report
Paint Overspray Arrester
Columbus Industries
SL-46B
Prepared by
/RTI
Research Triangle Institute
Under a Cooperative Agreement with
oEPA U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Environmental Technology
Verification Report
Paint Overspray Arrestor
Columbus Industries
SL-46B
Prepared by
Kathleen Owen
James Hanley
Jack Farmer
Air Pollution Control Technology Program
Research Triangle Institute
Research Triangle Park, NC 27709-2194
EPA Cooperative Agreement CR 826152-01-2
EPA Project Manager: Theodore G. Brna
Air Pollution Prevention and Control Division
National Risk Management Research Laboratory
Research Triangle Park, NC 27711
March 2000
VI
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Notice
This document was prepared by the Research Triangle Institute (RTI) under Cooperative Agreement No.
CR826152-01-2 with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The document has been subjected
to EPA's peer and administrative reviews and has been approved for publication. Mention of corporation
names, trade names, or commercial products does not constitute endorsement or recommendation for use of
specific products.
vu
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Availability of Verification Statement and Report
Copies of the public Verification Statement and Verification Report are available from the following:
1. Research Triangle Institute
P.O. Box 12194
Research Triangle Park, NC 27709-2194
Web site: http://etv.rti.org/apct/index.html
or http://www.epa.gov/etv (click on partners)
2 USEPA / APPCD
MD-4
Research Triangle Park, NC 27711
Web site: http://www.epa.gov/etv/library.htm (electronic copy)
htto://www. eDa.gov/ncepihom/
Vlll
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Abstract
Paint overspray arresters (POAs) were evaluated by the Air Pollution Control Technology (APCT) pilot
of the Environmental Technology Verification (ETV) Program. The performance factor verified was the
particle filtration efficiency as a function of size for particles smaller than 10 urn. The APCT ETV
Program developed a generic verification protocol for testing filtration efficiency that is based on EPA
Method 319. The protocol was developed by RTI, reviewed by a technical panel of experts, and
approved by EPA. The protocol addresses several issues that Method 319 does not cover, including
periodic testing, acquisition of POAs for testing, and product definition. A Test/Quality Assurance Plan
was prepared which addresses the test procedure and quality assurance and quality control requirements
for obtaining verification data of sufficient quantity and quality to satisfy the data quality objectives.
RTI performed tests on Columbus Industries's SL-46B during the period August 31-September 2, 1999.
Filter efficiencies were determined. For ready comparison, the filtration efficiency requirements of the
National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP) are tabulated with the test results.
The results indicate that the SL-46B met the NESHAP requirements for existing sources.
IX
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Table of Contents
Page
Verification Statement i
Notice vii
Availability of Verification Statement and Report viii
Abstract k
List of Figures xi
List of Tables xi
List of Abbreviations and Acronyms xii
Acknowledgments xiii
Section 1. Introduction 1
Section 2. Verification Test Description 1
2.1. Selection of Paint Overspray Arresters for Testing 3
Section 3. Description of Arrester 3
Section 4. Verification of Performance 3
4.1. Quality Assurance 3
4.2. Results 3
4.3. Limitations and Applications 4
Section 5. References 4
Appendix A. Description of the Test Rig and Methodology A-l
Appendix B. Certificates of Calibration B-l
Appendix C. Fractional Efficiency Data Sheets C-l
-------
Columbus SL-46B
List of Figures
Page
Figure 1. Photograph of the Columbus SL-46B paint overspray arrester iii
Figure 2. Triplicate solid-phase particle removal efficiency curves for Columbus SL-46B paint overspray
arrester 7
Figure 3. Average of the solid-phase particle removal efficiency curves for Columbus SL-46B paint
overspray arrester. 8
Figure 4. Triplicate liquid-phase particle removal efficiency curves for Columbus SL-46B paint overspray
arrester 9
Figure 5. Average of the liquid-phase particle removal efficiency curves for Columbus SL-46B paint
overspray arrester 10
Figure A-l. Schematic illustration of the fractional efficiency test rig A-2
List of Tables
Table 1. Existing Sources: Liquid-Phase Challenge Aerosol Particles iv
Table 2. Existing Sources: Solid-Phase Challenge Aerosol Particles iv
Table 3. New Sources: Liquid-Phase Challenge Aerosol Particles iv
Table 4. New Sources: Solid-Phase Challenge Aerosol Particles iv
Table 5. Test Series 2
Table 6. Summary of Solid-Phase Test Results 5
Table 7. Summary of Liquid-Phase Test Results 6
Table 8. Summary of Pressure Drop Measurements 11
Table A-l. Physical and Aerodynamic Sizing Channels for the Calibration and Test Aerosols A-6
XI
-------
Columbus SL-46B
List of Abbreviations and Acronyms
APCT Air Pollution Control Technology
APPCD Air Pollution Prevention and Control Division
ASME American Society of Mechanical Engineers
cfm cubic feet per minute
cm centimeter
Diam. Diameter
DQO data quality objective
EPA U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
ETV Environmental Technology Verification
fpm feet per minute
ft3 cubic foot
g gram
Geo. geometric
HEPA high efficiency particulate air
ID inside diameter
in. inch
kW kilowatt
L liter
mL milliliter
mm millimeter
m/s meters per second
NESHAP National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants
OPC optical particle counter
Pa pascal
POA paint overspray arrester
PSL polystyrene latex
QA quality assurance
RTI Research Triangle Institute
s or sec second
um or urn micrometer
xu
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Acknowledgments
RTI acknowledges the support of all those who helped plan and conduct the verification activities. In
particular, we would like to thank Ted Brna, EPA Project Manager, and Paul Groff, EPA Quality
Manager, of EPA's National Risk Management Research Laboratory in Research Triangle Park, NC.
Finally we would like to acknowledge the assistance and participation of Mike Haufe of Columbus
Industries.
For more information on the Paint Overspray Arrester Verification Testing, contact
James Hanley
Research Triangle Institute
P.O. Box 12194
Research Triangle Park, NC 27709-2194
(919)541-5811
For more information on the Columbus SL-46B, contact
Mike Haufe
Columbus Industries
2938 State Route 752
Ashville, OH43103
(740) 983-2552
Xlll
-------
Columbus SL-46B
SECTION 1
INTRODUCTION
The U. S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has created the Environmental Technology
Verification (ETV) Program to facilitate the deployment of innovative or improved technologies through
performance verification and information dissemination. The ETV Program is intended to assist and
inform those involved in the design, distribution, permitting, and purchase of environmental technologies.
The U.S. EPA's partner in the Air Pollution Control Technology (APCT) Program is Research Triangle
Institute (RTI). The APCT Program, with the full participation of the technology developer, develops plans,
conducts tests, collects and analyzes data, and reports findings. The evaluations are conducted according to
a rigorous protocol and quality assurance and quality control oversight. The APCT Program verifies the
performance of commercial-ready technologies used to control air pollutant emissions, with an emphasis on
technologies for controlling particulate matter, volatile organic compounds, nitrogen oxides, and hazardous
air pollutants. The Program develops standardized verification protocols and test plans, conducts
independent testing of technologies, and prepares verification test reports and statements for broad
dissemination.
SECTION 2
VERIFICATION TEST DESCRIPTION
The paint overspray arrester was tested in accordance with the APCT "Generic Verification Protocol for
Paint Overspray Arresters"1 and the "Test/QA Plan for Paint Overspray Arresters."2 This protocol
incorporates all requirements of EPA Method 319: Determination of Filtration Efficiency for Paint
Overspray Arresters. Method 3193 is part of the National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants
(NESHAP) for Aerospace Manufacturing and Rework Facilities.4 The protocol also includes requirements
for quality management, quality assurance, procedures for product selection, auditing of the test
laboratories, and reporting format.
Filtration efficiency was computed from aerosol concentrations measured upstream and downstream of an
arrester installed in a laboratory test rig. The aerosol concentrations upstream and downstream of the
arresters were measured with an aerosol analyzer that simultaneously counts and sizes the particles in the
aerosol stream. The aerosol analyzer covered the particle diameter size range from 0.3 to 10 um in a series
of contiguous sizing channels. Each sizing channel covered a narrow range of particle diameters. For
example, channel 1 covered from 0.3 to 0.4 um, channel 2 from 0.4 to 0.5 um, and channel 15 from 7 to 10
um. Using the ratio of the downstream to upstream particle counts for each channel, the filtration
efficiency was computed for each of the sizing channels.
The upstream and downstream aerosol measurements were made while a test aerosol was injected into the
air stream upstream of the arrester [ambient aerosol is first removed from the upstream air with high
efficiency particulate air (HEP A) filters on the inlet of the test rig]. This test aerosol spanned the particle
1
-------
Columbus SL-46B
size range from 0.3 to 10 urn and provided a sufficient upstream concentration in each of the sizing channels
to allow calculation of filtration efficiencies up to 99%.
The following series of tests were performed at a face velocity of 120 fpm (0.61 m/s):
• Three arresters were tested using a liquid-phase aerosol challenge,
• Three arresters were tested using a solid-phase aerosol challenge,
• "No-filter" control tests (one performed prior to each arrester test),
• One HEPA filter control test, and
• One reference filter control test.
The test series is exhibited in Table 5. Additional details on the test procedure are provided in Appendix A.
TABLES. TEST SERIES
RTI Test No.
08319905
08319906
09019901
09019902
09019903
09019904
09019905
09019906
08319904
09019907
09019908
09029902
09029903
09029904
09029905
TYPE OF TEST
No-Filter
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Test
Arrester
X
X
X
X
X
X
HEPA
Filter
X
Reference
Filter
X
Challenge Aerosol
Solid-Phase
Liquid-Phase
-------
Columbus SL-46B
2.1 SELECTION OF PAINT OVERSPRAY ARRESTORS FOR TESTING
The test arresters (SL-46B) were supplied to the test laboratory directly from the manufacturer (Columbus
Industries) with a letter signed by Donald Christopher, Director of Sales, attesting that the 12 arresters were
selected at random in an unbiased manner from a stock of over 100 similar arresters.
SECTION 3
DESCRIPTION OF ARRESTOR
As shown in Figure 1 (page iii), the Columbus SL-46B is a 2-pocket bag filter with nominal dimensions of 24
x 24 x 15 in. (0.61 x 0.61 x 0.38 m). The arrester has an internal frame, and the filter media color is white
upstream and blue downstream. The individual arresters are not labeled, but the box has a label stating the
company name and model number. There is no label indication of the flow direction or filter orientation, so
the industry standard orientation with the bags extended horizontally in the direction of the airflow and the
individual bags side-by-side, as opposed to stacked vertically, was used in the tests.
SECTION 4
VERIFICATION OF PERFORMANCE
4.1 QUALITY ASSURANCE
The verification tests were conducted in accordance with an approved Test/Quality Assurance (QA) Plan.2
The EPA Quality Manager conducted an independent assessment of the test laboratory in August 1999 and
found that the test laboratory was being operated as specified in the Test/QA Plan. Additionally, APCT
Quality Assurance staff have reviewed the results of this test and have found that the results meet data
quality objectives in the Test/QA Plan. Certificates of Calibration for the optical particle counter and the
airflow reference devices are provided in Appendix B.
4.2 RESULTS
Tables 6 and 7 and Figures 2 through 5 summarize the fractional filtration efficiency measurements for the
solid- and liquid-phase tests. Upstream and downstream particle count data for each test are provided in
Appendix C.
The initial (new condition) pressure drop across each test arrester at the 120 fpm (0.61 m/s) test velocity
[for a flowrate of 480 cfm (0.23 mVs)] is shown in Table 8. The pressure drop across the tested arresters
was 0.05 in. H2O (12 Pa) for each of the six arresters tested.
Tables 1-4 (page iv) present the filtration efficiency requirements of the Aerospace NESHAP and the
corresponding efficiencies measured for the tested arrester system. The test results indicate that the tested
arrester met the requirements listed in Tables 1 and 2 for existing sources but not those listed in Tables 3
and 4 for new sources.
-------
Columbus SL-46B
4.3 LIMITATIONS AND APPLICATIONS
This verification report addresses two aspects of paint overspray arrester performance: filtration efficiency
and pressure drop. Users of this technology may wish to consider other performance parameters such as
service life and cost when selecting a paint overspray arrester for their use.
In accordance with the generic verification protocol, this Verification Statement is applicable to paint
overspray arresters manufactured between the publication date of the Verification Statement and 12 months
thereafter.
As stated in Section 1.3 of Method 3193, "for a paint arrester system or subsystem which has been tested
by this method, adding additional filtration devices to the system or subsystem shall be assumed to result in
an efficiency of at least that of the original system without additional testing."
SECTION 5
REFERENCES
1. Generic Verification Protocol for Paint Overspray Arresters, Research Triangle Institute, Research
Triangle Park, NC, August 1999.
2. Test/QA Plan for Paint Overspray Arresters, Research Triangle Institute, Research Triangle Park,
NC, February 1999.
3. Method 319: Determination of Filtration Efficiency for Paint Overspray Arresters. Code of
Federal Regulations, Appendix A to 40 CFR Part 63.
4. National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants for Aerospace Manufacturing and
Rework Facilities. Code of Federal Regulations, Title 40, Part 63, Subpart GG (40 CFR 63.741).
-------
Columbus SL-46B
TABLE 6. SUMMARY OF SOLID-PHASE TEST RESULTS
Filtration Efficiency (%) at Indicated Size Range
OPC Channel Number
Min. Diam. (urn)
Max. Diam. (urn)
Geo. Mean Diam (um)
1
0.45
0.59
0.52
2
0.59
0.73
0.66
3
0.73
0.80
0.77
4
0.80
1.02
0.90
5
1.02
1.44
1.21
6
1.44
1.86
1.64
7
1.86
2.28
2.06
8
2.28
2.85
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
2.85 3.13 4.25 5.66 7.07 7.77 9.88
3.13 4.25 5.66 7.07 7.77 9.88 14.10
2.98 3.65 4.91 6.33 7.41 8.76 11.81
Columbus SL-46B Bag Filter
Run #1 09019902 42 46 50 53 59 64 70 76 81
Run #2 09019904 42 46 50 53 58 64 70 75 81
Run #3 09019906 39 43 47 50 56 61 67 73 79
Average 41 45 49 52 57 63 69 75 80
Interpolated Efficiency Values (%) for Existing Source Criteria:
2.60 um (> 10% required): 75
5.00 um (> 50% required): 92
8.10 um (> 90% required): 98
Interpolated Efficiency Values (%) for New Source Criteria:
0.70 um (> 75% required): 46
1.10 um (> 85% required): 56
2.50 um (> 95% required): 74
85
85
83
84
92
91
90
91
96
96
95
96
97
99
99
99
HEPA Filter Control Test (applicable to both solid and liquid phase conditions)
Run #1 08319904 100 100 100 100 100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
Reference Filter QA Test
Current 08319906
Baseline 08279902
Difference
Acceptable (< 10)
-2
-1
-2
yes
-1
1
-1
yes
-1
1
-1
yes
0
3
-3
yes
0
3
-3
yes
1
3
-2
yes
2
5
-3
yes
6
8
-1
yes
11
12
-1
yes
18
20
-1
yes
39
41
-2
yes
67 79 87 93
66 77 86 92
1201
yes yes yes yes
"No Filter" Control Tests
Run #1 09019901
Run #2 09019903
Run #3 09019905
1.01 1.01 1.00
1.00 1.00 0.99
1.01 1.02 1.01
Penetration For Each Size Range
1.01 1.02 1.00 1.01 0.99 0.99 0.99 0.99
1.01 1.01 1.01 1.01 0.99 0.99 1.00 0.99
1.01 1.02 1.00 1.01 1.00 1.01 1.01 1.00
0.99 0.95 0.95 0.93
1.00 0.97 0.99 0.97
0.99 1.02 0.95 0.93
-------
Columbus SL-46B
TABLE 7. SUMMARY OF LIQUID- PHASE TEST RESULTS
Filtration Efficiency (%) at Indicated Size Range
OPC Channel Number
Min. Diam. (urn)
Max. Diam. (um)
Geo. Mean Diam (um)
1 2
0.28 0.37
0.37 0.47
0.32 0.418
3
0.47
0.52
0.49
4
0.52
0.66
0.58
5
0.66
0.94
0.78
6
0.94
1.22
1.07
7
1.22
1.51
1.36
1.51
1.88
1.68
9
1.88
2.07
1.97
10
2.07
2.83
2.42
11
2.83
3.77
3.26
12
3.77
4.71
4.21
13
4.71
5.18
4.94
14 15
5.18 6.60
6.60 9.43
5.85 7.89
Columbus SL-46B Bag Filter
Run#1 09019908
Run #2 09029903
Run #3 09029905
Average
32 34 35
30 32 34
29 31 33
30 33 34
Interpolated Efficiency Values (%) for Existing Source Criteria:
2.20 um (> 10% required): 68
4.10 um (> 50% required): 88
5.70 um (> 90% required): 95
Interpolated Efficiency Values (%) for New Source Criteria:
0.42 um (> 65% required): 33
1.00 um (> 80% requried): 44
2.00 um (> 95% required): 66
36 41
35 39
33 39
35 40
47
45
45
45
52 61 67
51 59 66
50 58 65
51 59 66
72 80
71 79
70 79
71 80
90
94 95 98
93 96 98
94 95 97
94 95 98
"No Filter" Control Tests
Run#1 09019907
Run #2 09029902
Run #3 09029904
Penetration For Each Size Range
1.00 1.00 1.00 0.99 1.01 1.00 0.99 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.04 0.93 0.97
1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.01 1.03 1.04 1.06 1.01 1.03
1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.01 0.99 0.98 0.98 0.98 1.01 0.99 1.06 0.98 0.98
-------
Columbus SL-46B
-------
Columbus SL-46B
CD
'o
e
LU
g
'-I—'
ro
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0.1
1 10
Aerodynamic Diameter (micrometers)
100
Figure 3. Average of the solid-phase particle removal efficiency curves for Columbus
SL-46B paint overspray arrester.
-------
Columbus SL-46B
o
c
CD
'O
e
LU
C
g
'-I—'
ro
0.1
1 10
Aerodynamic Diameter (micrometers)
100
Figure 4. Triplicate liquid-phase particle removal efficiency curves for Columbus SL-46B
paint overspray arrester.
-------
Columbus SL-46B
o
c
CD
'O
it
LJJ
o
"co
0
0.1
1 10
Aerodynamic Diameter (micrometers)
100
Figure 5. Average of the liquid-phase particle removal efficiency curves for Columbus
SL-46B paint overspray arrester.
10
-------
Columbus SL-46B
TABLE 4
SUMMARY OF PRESSURE DROP MEASUREMENTS
Test No.
09019902
09019904
09019906
09019908
09029903
09029905
Initial Pressure
Drop
(inch H2O)
0.05
0.05
0.05
0.05
0.05
0.05
Initial Pressure
Drop
(Pa)
12
12
12
12
12
12
11
-------
Columbus SL-46B
TABLE 5. EXISTING SOURCES*
LIQUID-PHASE CHALLENGE AEROSOL PARTICLES
Aerodynamic particle
diameter range, um
>5.7
>4.1
>2.2
Filtration efficiency
requirement, %
>90
>50
>10
Filtration efficiency
achieved, %
95
88
68
TABLE 6. EXISTING SOURCES*
SOLID-PHASE CHALLENGE AEROSOL PARTICLES
Aerodynamic particle
diameter range, um
>8.1
>5.0
>2.6
Filtration efficiency
requirement, %
>90
>50
>10
Filtration efficiency
achieved, %
98
92
75
TABLE 7. NEW SOURCES*
LIQUID-PHASE CHALLENGE AEROSOL PARTICLES
Aerodynamic particle
diameter range, um
>2.0
>1.0
>0.42
Filtration efficiency
requirement, %
>95
>80
>65
Filtration efficiency
achieved, %
66
44
33
TABLES. NEW SOURCES*
SOLID-PHASE CHALLENGE AEROSOL PARTICLES
Aerodynamic particle
diameter range, um
>2.5
>1.1
>0.70
Filtration efficiency
requirement, %
>95
>85
>75
Filtration efficiency
achieved, %
74
56
46
* A new source is any affected source that commenced construction after October 29, 1996. An
existing source is any affected source that is not new.
12
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Appendix A
DESCRIPTION OF THE TEST RIG AND METHODOLOGY
TEST DUCT
The tests were conducted in RTFs air cleaner test facility (Figure A-l). The test rig's ducting was
primarily of 24 x 24 in. (0.61 x 0.61m) cross section and made of 14-gauge stainless steel. The blower is
rated at 15 hp (11 kW) with a flow capacity of 3000 cfm (1.4 irf/s) at 13 in. H2O (3200 Pa). The inlet and
outlet filter banks consist of two 24 x 24 x 2 in. (0.61 x 0.61 x 0.05 m) prefilters and two 24 x 24 x 12 in.
(0.61 x 0.61 x 0.30 m) high efficiency particulate air (HEPA) filters rated at 2000 cfm (0.9 irf/s) each. The
system operates at positive pressure to minimize infiltration of room air.
To mix the test aerosol with the air stream, an orifice plate and mixing baffle were located immediately
downstream of the aerosol injection point and upstream of the test arrester. An identical orifice plate and
mixing baffle were added after the 180° bend. The latter downstream orifice served two purposes. It
straightened out the flow after going around the bend, and it mixed any aerosol that penetrated the air
cleaning device. Mixing the penetrating aerosol with the air stream is necessary to obtain a representative
downstream aerosol measurement.
AIRFLOW
Airflow was measured with a 4.00 in. (0.102 m) ID American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME)
flow nozzle. The nominal velocity through the arrester was computed by dividing the volumetric flow by the
nominal face area of the device. Airflow was manually controlled by a 14 in. (0.36 m) diameter butterfly
valve.
OPTICAL PARTICLE COUNTER (OPC)
Aerosol concentrations were measured with a Climet Instruments Model 226 OPC. This OPC uses a
white-light illumination source and has a wide collection angle for the scattered light. The OPC's sampling
rate was 0.25 cfm (0.00012 irf/s).
The output of the OPC was input to a Climet Instruments Model 8040 multichannel analyzer equipped with
Model 05872005 and 05872006 input boards. These boards provide 16 sizing channels covering the range
from 0.3 to 10 um The 8040 was also equipped with a Model CI-298 sequential interface board. This
interface provides a contact closure at the end of each sample and also provides a 15-sec delay in particle
counting after each sample. The contact closure was used to control the operation of electromechanical
valve actuators in the upstream and downstream sample lines. The 15-sec delay allows time for the new
sample to be acquired.
A-l
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Blower
(3000 cfm
at 13 in. H2O)
Exhaust
to
Room
ASME Nozzle
I
Room
Air
iV
=-kd
X
cS
n
— . —
— -— ,.
^
.---^
-^--_
|
i
1
^
5
1
n^
Downstream Mixer v
f \
I ^
r ^ !
1
;.~jjr>— opc ]
<=) ' ^ - |
A '
Inlet Filter /
Bank |
\Device Backup
Section Filter
Upstream Mixer (Used When
Dust-loading)
t i
FlowControl
Overview of Test Duct Configuration (Top View)
Spray Nozzle
Spray Tawar
Syringe Pump
Aenosc I Charge
Nautraizer s.
HEPA
Filter
Bank
Atomizing A r
HEPA Filter
Capsucs
Al r Control Par cl
Air Source
| Test Duct
Aerosol Generation System
(Side View)
/
ff
/
60' Bend to
Poirrl Inlet Upstream
/
/
i
i
/
Vave
Actuator
^
errrinnl
Dpwrstregm Duct
Relay
Box
Multichannel
Anayzer
30 Bend to
P-rir: Inlet Upslream
U^stneam Dud
Machined °Y"
Aerosol Sampling System
(End View)
Figure A-l. Schematic illustration of the fractional efficiency test rig.
A-2
-------
Columbus SL-46B
AEROSOL GENERATION
Two types of challenge aerosols were used: liquid- and solid-phase. The selection of liquid- or solid-phase
challenge aerosol particles is important because, for some types of paint arresters, significantly different
filtration efficiencies will be achieved depending upon the phase of the challenge aerosol particles. (This is
due to particle "bounce" associated with solid-phase particles.) The liquid-phase challenge aerosol is oleic
acid, a non-toxic, low-volatility liquid. The solid-phase aerosol is potassium chloride (KC1) generated from
an aqueous solution. KC1 was selected as the solid-phase aerosol because of its relatively high water
solubility, high deliquescence humidity (85% relative humidity), known crystalline structure (facilitates
complete drying), and low toxicity. The KC1 solution was prepared by combining 0.66 Ib (300 g) of KC1
with 0.035 ft3 (1 L) of distilled water. Both oleic acid and KC1 are compatible with accurate measurement
by the OPC.
The oleic acid or the KC1 solution was nebulized using a two-fluid (air and liquid) air atomizing nozzle (Spray
Systems 1/4 J siphon spray nozzle) as illustrated in Figure A-l (aerosol generation system). The nozzle was
positioned at the top of a 12 in. (0.30 m) diameter, 51 in. (1.3 m) tall transparent acrylic spray tower. The
tower served two purposes. It allowed the salt droplets to dry by providing an approximate 40 sec mean
residence time, and it allowed larger-sized particles (of either KC1 or oleic acid) to fall out of the aerosol.
After generation, the aerosol passed through a TSI Model 3054 aerosol neutralizer (Kr-85 radioactive
source) to neutralize any electrostatic charge on the aerosol (electrostatic charging is an unavoidable
consequence of most aerosol-generation methods).
The KC1 solution or oleic acid was fed to the atomizing nozzle at 1.2 mL/min by means of a pump. Varying
the operating air pressure of the generator allows control of the output aerosol concentration.
AEROSOL SAMPLING SYSTEM
The aerosol sampling lines were 0.55 in. (14 mm) ID stainless steel lines and used gradual bends [radius of
curvature = 2.25 in. (57 mm)] when needed. These dimensions were chosen to minimize particle losses in
the sample lines. A custom-made "Y" fitting connected the upstream and downstream lines to the OPC.
The two branches of the "Y" merged gradually to minimize particle loss in the intersection of the "Y" due to
centrifugal or impaction forces.
Immediately above the "Y," electrically actuated ball valves were installed in each branch (Parker Model
EA Electro-Mechanical Valve Actuator). The opening and closing of the valves were automatically
controlled by the OPC's sequential sampling interface board. The valves take approximately 2 sec to
complete an opening or closing maneuver.
Isokinetic sampling nozzles of the appropriate entrance diameter were placed on the ends of the sample
probes to maintain isokinetic sampling for all the test flow rates.
A-3
-------
Columbus SL-46B
TEST PROCEDURES
The aerosol penetration of the test device was calculated from the average of 10 upstream and 10
downstream samples taken sequentially (i.e., one upstream, one downstream, one upstream, one
downstream,. . . until 10 each were obtained). This sequential sampling scheme was selected to minimize
the effect of aerosol generator variability. Each sample was 2 minutes in duration. The sampling also
included background upstream and downstream measurements at the beginning and end of each test. The
test sequence was as follows:
1. Warm up OPC and install proper sample tips for isokinetic sampling.
2. Install air cleaner test device and bring test duct to desired flow rate.
3. With the aerosol generator off, obtain one measurement each of the upstream and downstream
background particle counts.
4. Turn on the aerosol generator and allow it to run for a minimum of 10 minutes to stabilize.
5. After the stabilization period, obtain 10 upstream and 10 downstream particle counts using a
repeated upstream-downstream sampling sequence until 10 each are obtained.
6. Turn off the aerosol generator. Wait 10 minutes, then obtain one additional upstream and
downstream background measurement.
CONTROL TESTS
In addition to evaluating the test arrester, 0 and 100% penetration control tests and a reference filter control
test were conducted to ensure that reliable measurements are obtained. The 100% penetration test was a
relatively stringent test of the adequacy of the overall duct, sampling, measurement and aerosol generation
system. These tests were performed as normal penetration tests except that the paint arrester was not
used. A perfect system would yield a measured penetration of 1 at all particle sizes. Deviations from 1 can
occur due to particle losses in the duct, differences in the degree of aerosol uniformity (i.e., mixing) at the
upstream and downstream probes, and differences in particle-transport efficiency in the upstream and
downstream sampling lines. Results from the 100% penetration tests were used during data analysis to
correct penetration measurements obtained during the arrester tests.
The 0% penetration test was performed by using a HEPA filter rather than a paint arrester. This test
confirmed the adequacy of the instrument response time and sample line lag. The 0% penetration test was
performed on a monthly basis.
The reference filter control test consisted of performing a solid-phase efficiency test on the same filter
during each ETV test. The reference filter data from each test were compared to the original, baseline
reference filter data to determine if there was any substantial change in the test system between the tests.
DATA ANALYSIS
Nomenclature
P = Penetration corrected for P100 value
D = Downstream particle count
Db = Downstream background count
U = Upstream particle count
Ub = Upstream background count
P100 = 100% penetration value determined from the control tests
Overbar: denotes arithmetic mean of quantity
A-4
-------
Physical »
Pparticle
Po
^ Physical 1
CCF, X
Aero
Columbus SL-46B
Analysis of each test involves the following quantities:
! P100 value for each sizing channel from the blank (no-filter) test,
! 2 upstream background values,
! 2 downstream background values,
! 10 upstream values with aerosol generator on, and
! 10 downstream values with aerosol generator on.
Using the values associated with each sizing channel, the penetration associated with each particle sizing
channel was calculated as:
P = {(D -Db) /(U- Ub)} /P100 .
Filtration efficiency was then calculated as:
Filtration Efficiency (%) = 100 (1 - P).
DEFINITION OF PARTICLE DIAMETER
Over the 0.3 to 10 urn diameter size range, the "aerodynamic" particle diameter is often of more
significance than the physical diameter (as measured by the OPC) relative to aerosol filtration and aerosol
deposition within the human respiratory tract. The aerodynamic diameter (DAero) is related to the physical
diameter (DPhysical) by:
A
Aero
where
Pparticle is the density of the particle in g/cm3.
p0 is unit density of 1 g/cm3.
CCFPhysical is the Cunningham Correction Factor at Dphysical.
CCFAero is the Cunningham Correction Factor at DAero.
X is the dynamic shape factor.
Note: due to the interdependence of Daero and CCFAero, the equation is solved iteratively.
For oleic acid droplets having a density of 0.89 g/cm? and being spherical (X=l\ the aerodynamic diameter
will be about 6% smaller than the measured diameter.
KC1 has a density of 1.98 g/cm3. The KC1 particles form from the evaporation of aqueous solution droplets.
Because KC1 has an inherent cubic crystalline structure, it is expected that the KC1 particles will be cubic or
relatively compact cubic clusters; however, their actual shape, or range of shapes, is unknown. Because
the shape factor is unknown, the shape factor for KC1 is assigned a value of 1 and the diameter is termed
the "nominal" aerodynamic diameter.
The aerodynamic diameters associated with the 15 OPC sizing channels are tabulated in Table A-l for oleic
acid and KC1. Also listed is the physical diameter size range for each channel based on the manufacturer's
calibration curve using monodisperse polystyrene latex (PSL) spheres.
A-5
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Table A-l. Physical and Aerodynamic Sizing Channels
for the Calibration and Test Aerosols
OPC Channel
Number
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
Particle Diameter Size Range (um)*
PSL
Physical
Diameter
0.3-0.4
0.4-0.5
0.5 - 0.55
0.55-0.7
0.7-1.0
1.0-1.3
1.3-1.6
1.6-2
2-2.2
2.2-3
3-4
4-5
5-5.5
5.5-7
7-10
OLEIC ACID
Aerodynamic
Diameter
0.28 - 0.37
0.37 - 0.47
0.47 - 0.52
0.52 - 0.66
0.66 - 0.94
0.94 - 1.22
1.22-1.51
1.51 -1.88
1.88-2.07
2.07 - 2.83
2.83 - 3.77
3.77-4.71
4.71 -5.18
5.18-6.60
6.60 - 9.43
KC1
Nominal
Aerodynamic
Diameter
0.45 - 0.59
0.59 - 0.73
0.73 - 0.80
0.80 - 1.02
1.02- 1.44
1.44- 1.86
1.86-2.28
2.28 - 2.85
2.85-3.13
3.13-4.25
4.25 - 5.66
5.66 - 7.07
7.07 - 7.77
7.77 - 9.88
9.88-14.1
"The particle diameter size ranges are defined as greater than the indicated lower limit and less than or
equal to the indicated upper limit.
A-6
-------
Columbus SL-46B
APPENDIX B
Certificates of Calibration
B-l
-------
Columbus SL-46B
B-2
-------
Columbus SL-46B
«![>,, O40FB:OOl-19
PUGS 1 OF 1
LITTER OF CSRTIFTKRTTOW
FLOW BLEMEHT
M*ME; ..... RESEARCH TO i MOM; inst
ORDER NUMBER :__ _ 00161 ____
HSRIRM ORDER
772900
Miriam Instrument certifies that th« completed i.PK umi t has been
sulibrated and cort*l*t«d at a«v*r«l points of Clow rat» using * M»ri»rn
Standard, whirh in controlled per th* calibcation system r«gui rBmenta of
S540-1 and traoeabl* to the Nalrinn*! Tnatituts of Standards and
loci-y The nolleetiwis laneertainty of th« »eftBu»-»m GQMDITION:_J/_I
LEFT CONftTTTOW i t/ In Tolerance
BT
oiit of Tolerance
Out of Tolerance
WA
NB
CflLIIWlftON IWTSRVM,: TO BB DET-ERHIMID BY CUSTOMER BASED OH IJSAOE yP LPS,
P&TB OT LAif_CfcL _ _ - PATE OF HBCT CA,L ............
FLOW SrfcMB*»D
SCT1M. KO,
*h« LFE unit Ustftd hsreon has been successfully calibratsd in
with M«rlam Tn»tr«rn«nt Ptoc*dur« A-AS
QKIM.TTV ASSURAHCB INSPECTCR
HER ran IMSTROMEHT
QUALITY HflSURAHCE MANAOBf
MBRIJUI IWSTIWKSNT
10920
MJU
B-3
-------
Columbus SL-46B
CLIMET INSTRUMENTS COMPANY
13SO WESTCOLTON AVE . REDLANDS, CA 82374 • PHONE: (909) 799-2718 • FAX: (90S) 793-1738
CERTIFICATE OF CALIBRATION
INSTRUMENT CALIBRATED
MODEL:
aerosol particle counter, S/N
CONTROL NUMBER:
DATE CALIBRATED: ? I /*? I 9*7 NEXT CALIBRATION: _fL
RECOMMENDED CALIBRATION INTERVAL: 4 months
12-ea O
CALIBRATED BY
APPROVED BY
TRACEABIUTY STATEMENT
This instrument has been calibrated in accordance with ISO 10012-1/ANSI
Z540-1 (which replaces MIL-STD-45662A) and relevant portions of Federal Standards
209, ASTM F-50, F322, and F328.
Temperature and Relative Humidity are not controlled during calibration because
of the wide operating range of the instrument. The operating limits of this instrument
TEMPERATURE:
HUMIDITY:
30"FTO122°F
0-100%, non-condensing
All test equipment used in the calibration of Climet Instruments' producte is
calibrated at six-month intervals by an outside calibration service. Calibration
certificates for each piece of test equipment are on file at Climet; copies will be
supplied if requested.
Calibration traceabitity to a National Measurement Standard (NMS) is established
by using mono-disperse latex spheres as a calibration standard. These spheres are
sized by methods traceable, by lot number, to the National Institute of Science and
Technology.
E:\WPDOCS\Doc Control\Certs\CERTS\STATEM~ 1 .WPD
Certification Form 1 of 3, Revision: July 01, 1993
B-4
-------
Columbus SL-46B
APPENDIX C
Fractional Efficiency Data Sheets
Key to notation used in the following tables:
Diam.: Particle Diameter (um)
Geo.: Geometric
U. Bckgrnd: The upstream background particle counts measured with the
aerosol generator off.
Upstream: The upstream particle counts measured with the aerosol generator
on.
D. Bckgrnd: The downstream background particle counts measured with the
aerosol generator off.
Downstream: The downstream particle counts measured with the aerosol
generator on.
Meas. Penetration: The penetration computed as:
, , „ , ,. ( Downstream • • D. Bckgrnd )
Meas. Penetration • •- -
( Upstream • • U. Bckgrnd )
PI00 Correction Values: Penetration values measured with no filter in the test section.
These values are used to correct subsequent penetration
measurements for particle losses within the test duct and sampling
system.
Corrected Penetration: The measured penetration corrected by the PI00 values:
„ , „ . Meas.Penetration
Corrected Penetration • •
PI 00 Correction Values
Corrected Efficiency (%): 100 x (1 - Corrected Penetration )
DQO Data Quality Objective
C-l
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Test No. 08319905
No Filter
Solid-Phase
Particle Counts per
OPC Channel Number
Min. Diam. fum)
Max. Diam. (urn)
Geo. Mean Diam (urn)
ENTER DATA BELOW
U. Bckgrnd 1 0108-31-1999 14:59:10 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 15:07:03 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 15:09:33 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 15:12:03 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 15:14:33 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 15:17:03 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 15:19:33 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 15:22:03 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 15:24:33 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 15:27:03 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 15:29:33 01:00
U. Bckgrnd 1 0108-31-1999 15:42:22 01:00
ENTER DATA BELOW
D. Bckgrnd 2 0108-31-1999 15:00:25 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 15:08:18 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 15:10:48 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 15:13:18 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 15:15:48 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 15:18:18 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 15:20:48 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 15:23:18 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 15:25:48 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 15:28:18 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 15:30:48 01:00
D. Bckgrnd 2 0108-31-1999 15:43:37 01:00
Meas. Penetration
P100 correction values
Corrected Penetration
Corrected Efficiency (%)
Data Acceptance Criteria:
Total Challenge Counts for Each Channel:
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Standard Deviation of Penetration for Each Channel :
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Maximum observed particle concentration (#/cc):
Data Quality Objective: max. allowable cone. (#/cc):
Does this meet the DQO:
1
0.45
0.59
0.52
0
10370
10380
10650
10640
10940
10460
9885
10230
10340
10450
0
0
10520
10410
10990
10960
10690
10230
10510
10360
10770
10740
0
1.02
1.00
1.02
-2
104345
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
18.6
<23
Yes, I
2
0.59
0.73
0.66
0
15750
15600
15730
16030
15800
15910
15090
15730
15290
15610
0
0
15630
15920
16090
16240
16090
15400
15800
15250
16080
16000
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
156540
>500
Yes
0.03
<0.10
Yes
3
0.73
0.80
0.77
0
4882
4987
5131
5129
5085
4990
4634
5097
4868
5053
0
0
4955
5153
5044
4987
5177
5015
5018
4938
5300
4976
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
49856
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
4
0.80
1.02
0.90
0
8816
8793
8807
9227
9056
8819
8351
8913
8967
8870
0
1
8923
8849
9325
9458
9203
8934
9089
9070
9429
9378
0
1.03
1.00
1.03
-3
88619
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
5
1.02
1.44
1.21
0
13400
13390
13620
13960
13800
13480
12910
13650
13670
13840
0
0
13290
13720
14270
14370
14030
13730
13930
13860
14420
14570
0
1.03
1.00
1.03
-3
135720
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
Indicated OPC Channel (1-Minute Samples @ 7.1 L/min)
6
1.44
1.86
1.64
0
7912
8106
8191
8221
8412
8162
7824
8061
8102
8021
1
0
7829
8127
8277
8519
8425
8106
8090
8239
8570
8515
0
1.02
1.00
1.02
-2
81012
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
7
1.86
2.28
2.06
0
10600
10450
10410
10840
10710
10660
10120
10460
10290
10460
0
0
10390
10640
10840
11050
10860
10560
10720
10880
11160
11020
0
1.03
1.00
1.03
-3
105000
>500
Yes
0.03
<0.10
Yes
8
2.28
2.85
2.55
0
11080
11180
11140
11250
11460
11340
10980
11550
11450
11430
0
0
11140
11150
11300
11440
11440
11250
11710
11370
11940
11730
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
112860
>500
Yes
0.03
<0.10
Yes
9
2.85
3.13
2.98
0
2687
2714
2703
2735
2730
2675
2655
2877
2900
2948
0
0
2589
2634
2719
2738
2787
2788
2934
2908
3042
2848
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
27624
>500
Yes
0.06
<0.10
Yes
10
3.13
4.25
3.65
0
5886
5835
5916
6029
5849
5885
5778
6122
6002
6074
0
0
5884
5853
5760
6018
6088
5840
6293
6085
6307
6242
0
1.02
1.00
1.02
-2
59376
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.30
Yes
11
4.25
5.66
4.91
0
3247
3378
3441
3499
3369
3334
3492
3603
3546
3621
0
0
3388
3460
3360
3505
3573
3443
3773
3805
3813
3800
0
1.04
1.00
1.04
-4
34530
>500
Yes
0.07
<0.30
Yes
12
5.66
7.07
6.33
0
1096
1149
1095
1168
1160
1184
1254
1303
1285
1313
0
0
1109
1092
1095
1128
1191
1185
1245
1246
1236
1295
0
0.98
1.00
0.98
2
12007
>500
Yes
0.09
<0.30
Yes
13
7.07
7.77
7.41
0
196
175
220
194
211
223
196
213
233
209
0
0
190
163
189
177
190
206
215
195
190
210
0
0.93
1.00
0.93
7
2070
>500
Yes
0.11
<0.30
Yes
14
7.77
9.88
8.76
0
308
312
308
326
300
316
331
336
348
346
0
0
273
261
292
313
318
312
329
357
302
380
0
0.97
1.00
0.97
3
3231
>500
Yes
0.12
<0.30
Yes
15
9.88
14.10
11.81
0
194
187
229
183
225
219
206
248
257
200
0
0
196
194
220
176
179
170
219
213
195
200
0
0.91
1.00
0.91
9
2148
>500
Yes
0.13
<0.30
Yes
Jappliesto all channels)
C-2
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Test No. 08319906
Reference
Solid-Phase
Particle Counts per Indicated OPC Channel (1-Minute Samples @ 7.1 L/min)
OPC Channel Number
Min. Diam. fum)
Max. Diam. (urn)
Geo. Mean Diam (urn)
ENTER DATA BELOW
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 08-31-1999 16:01:17 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 16:07:52 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 16:10:22 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 16:12:52 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 16:15:22 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 16:17:52 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 16:20:22 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 16:22:52 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 16:25:22 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 16:27:52 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 16:30:22 01:00
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 08-31-1999 16:38:25 01:00
ENTER DATA BELOW
D. Bckgrnd 201 08-31-1999 16:02:32 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 16:09:07 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 16:11:37 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 16:14:07 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 16:16:37 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 16:19:07 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 16:21:37 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 16:24:07 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 16:26:37 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 16:29:07 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 16:31:37 01:00
D. Bckgrnd 201 08-31-1999 16:39:40 01:00
Meas. Penetration
P100 correction values
Corrected Penetration
Corrected Efficiency (%)
Data Acceptance Criteria:
Total Challenge Counts for Each Channel:
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Standard Deviation of Penetration for Each Channel :
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Maximum observed particle concentration f#/cc):
Data Quality Objective: max. allowable cone. (#/cc):
Does this meet the DQO:
1
0.45
0.59
0.52
0
10590
10350
10460
10350
10700
10600
9249
10430
10190
10440
0
0
10050
10140
12710
10270
10520
10350
10680
10440
10380
10280
0
1.02
1.02
1.01
-1
103359
>500
Yes
0.08
<0.10
Yes
18.4
<23
Yes,
2
0.59
0.73
0.66
0
15890
15700
15650
15330
16170
15710
13520
15870
15450
15640
0
0
15320
15350
15630
15390
15600
15940
16040
15620
15420
15420
0
1.01
1.01
0.99
1
154930
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
3
0.73
0.80
0.77
0
4992
4968
4878
5022
5099
4930
4393
5043
4923
5192
0
0
4863
4966
5014
5107
5023
4966
5091
5081
4900
4773
0
1.01
1.01
0.99
1
49440
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
4
0.80
1.02
0.90
0
9003
9027
9084
8885
9369
9030
7789
8905
8870
8973
0
0
8668
8820
8844
9116
9316
9177
9104
8880
8743
8711
0
1.00
1.03
0.97
3
88935
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
5
1.02
1.44
1.21
0
14010
13760
13900
13930
14080
14010
12080
13770
13380
13470
0
0
13330
13230
13410
14040
14400
14410
13980
13510
13410
13270
0
1.00
1.03
0.97
3
136390
>500
Yes
0.06
<0.10
Yes
6
1.44
1.86
1.64
0
8197
8112
8106
8075
8326
8355
7181
8287
8016
7918
0
0
7849
7761
7850
8151
8195
8255
8201
7863
7843
7808
0
0.99
1.02
0.97
3
80573
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
7
1.86
2.28
2.06
0
10810
10590
10640
10710
10950
10650
9241
10760
10410
10440
0
0
10220
10150
10250
10620
10420
10440
10540
10290
10150
10130
0
0.98
1.03
0.95
5
105201
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
8
2.28
2.85
2.55
0
11670
11780
11690
11400
11860
11700
9778
11190
11140
11100
0
0
10480
10640
10670
10950
11090
10850
10560
10600
10260
10140
0
0.94
1.01
0.92
8
113308
>500
Yes
0.06
<0.10
Yes
9
2.85
3.13
2.98
0
2947
2925
2967
2914
3024
2716
2342
2926
2664
2711
0
0
2546
2541
2538
2559
2613
2671
2455
2326
2382
2449
0
0.89
1.01
0.88
12
28136
>500
Yes
0.08
<0.10
Yes
10
3.13
4.25
3.65
0
6204
6142
6164
6112
6389
6141
5126
5931
5821
5689
1
0
4932
5013
5144
5089
4967
5110
4705
4720
4638
4489
0
0.82
1.02
0.80
20
59719
>500
Yes
0.06
<0.30
Yes
11
4.25
5.66
4.91
0
3693
3670
3834
3671
3722
3597
2979
3408
3481
3379
0
0
2226
2306
2226
2380
2290
2196
2127
2009
2018
1856
0
0.61
1.04
0.59
41
35434
> 500
Yes
0.06
< 0.30
Yes
12
5.66
7.07
6.33
0
1230
1252
1322
1260
1300
1231
1065
1176
1092
1191
0
0
394
433
431
485
450
417
410
354
339
345
0
0.33
0.98
0.34
66
12119
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.30
Yes
13
7.07
7.77
7.41
0
205
220
234
227
248
187
172
186
207
196
0
0
42
45
43
59
42
46
28
55
41
44
0
0.21
0.93
0.23
77
2082
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.30
Yes
14 15
7.77 9.88
9.88 14.10
8.76 11.81
0 0
333 236
323 238
394 234
364 243
346 234
365 231
318 180
329 207
305 260
309 191
0 0
0 0
35 22
52 18
52 20
55 14
40 22
50 21
42 23
45 8
38 13
40 7
0 0
0.13 0.07
0.97 0.91
0.14 0.08
86 92
3386 2254
> 500 > 500
Yes Yes
0.02 0.03
< 0.30 < 0.30
Yes Yes
(applies to all channels)
C-3
-------
Columbus SL-46B
OPC Channel Number
Min. Diam. (urn)
Max. Diam. (um)
Geo. Mean Diam (um)
ENTER DATA BELOW
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-01-1999 09:04:01
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 09:10:37
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 09:13:07
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 09:15:37
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 09:18:07
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 09:20:37
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 09:23:07
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 09:25:37
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 09:28:07
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 09:30:37
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 09:33:07
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-01-1999 09:43:23
ENTER DATA BELOW
D. Bckgrnd 2 01 09-01-1999 09:05:16
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 09:11:52
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 09:14:22
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 09:16:52
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 09:19:22
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 09:21:52
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 09:24:22
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 09:26:52
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 09:29:22
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 09:31:52
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 09:34:22
D. Bckgrnd 2 01 09-01-1999 09:44:38
Meas. Penetration
P100 correction values
Corrected Penetration
Corrected Efficiency (%)
Data Acceptance Criteria:
Total Challenge Counts for Each Channel:
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Standard Deviation of Penetration for Each Channel
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Test No.
No Filter
Solid-Phase
09019901
Particle Counts per Indicated OPC Channel (1-Minute Samples @ 7.1 L/min)
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
1
0.45
0.59
0.52
0
10810
11670
11490
11580
11180
10840
10450
11130
10400
10590
1
0
11700
12070
11360
11450
11280
11010
10830
10590
10410
10670
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
110140
>500
Yes
0.06
<0.10
Yes
2
0.59
0.73
0.66
0
16630
17540
17310
17260
16950
16370
15400
16310
15580
15970
1
0
17400
17680
17260
17220
16890
16180
16190
16000
15430
15970
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
165320
>500
Yes
0.06
<0.10
Yes
3
0.73
0.80
0.77
0
5286
5507
5388
5626
5413
5130
4977
5295
5122
5066
0
0
5640
5530
5470
5338
5421
5291
5488
4980
4918
4945
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
52810
>500
Yes
0.06
<0.10
Yes
4
0.80
1.02
0.90
0
9389
9976
9765
9945
9457
9292
8999
9515
9108
9260
1
0
9967
10090
9883
9764
9385
8995
9489
9238
9142
9317
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
94706
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
5
1.02
1.44
1.21
0
14050
15260
14990
14960
14320
13860
13710
14440
13830
14530
3
0
15130
15210
15160
14850
14280
14020
14690
14350
14080
14480
0
1.02
1.00
1.02
-2
143950
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
6
1.44
1.86
1.64
0
8572
8778
8941
8931
8469
8436
8169
8711
8474
8462
1
0
8870
9180
8870
8817
8397
8279
8578
8470
8232
8543
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
85943
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
7
1.86
2.28
2.06
0
10940
11600
11460
11700
11240
10850
10650
11140
10690
10850
3
0
11480
11590
11670
11530
11190
10860
11160
10990
10570
10940
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
111120
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
8
2.28
2.85
2.55
0
11600
11940
11850
11890
11530
11310
11360
12070
11320
11570
0
0
11950
11840
11620
11560
11520
11070
11820
11470
11090
11380
0
0.99
1.00
0.99
1
116440
>500
Yes
0.03
<0.10
Yes
9
2.85
3.13
2.98
0
2752
2854
2773
2764
2797
2669
2746
2992
2811
2774
0
0
2864
2754
2715
2727
2645
2719
2901
2911
2735
2793
0
0.99
1.00
0.99
1
27932
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
10
3.13
4.25
3.65
0
6039
6289
6070
6275
5991
5841
6010
6312
6035
6309
1
0
6137
6169
6018
6071
5827
5726
6452
6233
5885
6062
0
0.99
1.00
0.99
1
61171
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.30
Yes
11
4.25
5.66
4.91
0
3691
3684
3561
3723
3594
3559
3617
3978
3628
3810
0
0
3756
3624
3485
3611
3549
3447
3892
3728
3621
3749
0
0.99
1.00
0.99
1
36845
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.30
Yes
12
5.66
7.07
6.33
0
1175
1203
1205
1218
1190
1198
1349
1427
1303
1369
0
0
1230
1188
1208
1179
1205
1203
1313
1322
1329
1323
0
0.99
1.00
0.99
1
12637
>500
Yes
0.09
<0.30
Yes
13
7.07
111
7.41
0
174
225
211
193
189
184
254
242
204
227
0
0
216
184
181
170
204
201
229
212
199
201
0
0.95
1.00
0.95
5
2103
>500
Yes
0.15
<0.30
Yes
14
111
9.88
8.76
0
306
326
313
323
307
360
329
410
340
349
0
0
307
290
295
309
310
296
330
350
349
343
0
0.95
1.00
0.95
5
3363
>500
Yes
0.11
<0.30
Yes
15
9.88
14.10
11.81
0
235
206
178
184
211
234
228
239
231
241
0
0
176
200
191
195
204
179
226
224
212
224
0
0.93
1.00
0.93
7
2187
>500
Yes
0.13
<0.30
Yes
Maximum observed particle concentration (#/cc):
Data Quality Objective: max. allowable cone. (#/cc):
Does this meet the DQO:
19.4
<23
Yes, (applies to all channels)
C-4
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Test No. 09019902
Arrester
Solid-Phase
Particle Counts per Indicated OPC Channel (1-Minute Samples @
OPC Channel Number
Min. Diam. (urn)
Max. Diam. (urn)
Geo. Mean Diam (urn)
ENTER DATA BELOW
U. Bckgmd 1 01 09-01-1999 09:58:40 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 10:05:14 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 10:07:44 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 10:10:14 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 10:12:44 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 10:15:14 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 10:17:44 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 10:20:14 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 10:22:44 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 10:25:14 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 10:27:44 01:00
U. Bckgmd 1 01 09-01-1999 10:35:36 01:00
ENTER DATA BELOW
D. Bckgmd 2 01 09-01-1999 09:59:55 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 10:06:29 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 10:08:59 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 10:11:29 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 10:13:59 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 10:16:29 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 10:18:59 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 10:21:29 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 10:23:59 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 10:26:29 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 10:28:59 01:00
D. Bckgmd 2 01 09-01-1999 10:36:51 01:00
Meas. Penetration
P100 correction values
Corrected Penetration
Corrected Efficiency (%)
Data Acceptance Criteria:
Total Challenge Counts for Each Channel:
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Standard Deviation of Penetration for Each Channel :
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Maximum observed particle concentration (#/cc):
Data Quality Objective: max. allowable cone. f#/cc):
Does this meet the DQO:
1
0.45
0.59
0.52
1
10290
10350
10650
10670
10590
10650
8385
10450
10400
10040
1
1
6091
6300
6083
6035
5930
6001
6145
5854
6106
5921
0
0.59
1.01
0.58
42
102475
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
17.7
< 23
Yes,
2
0.59
0.73
0.66
1
15710
16000
15830
15790
16010
15500
12720
15360
15150
15500
0
1
8570
8730
8489
8447
8301
8309
8507
8343
8119
8222
0
0.55
1.01
0.54
46
153570
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
3
0.73
0.80
0.77
0
4881
5039
5008
4953
5038
4993
4116
4915
4943
4915
0
0
2462
2629
2399
2382
2380
2333
2545
2518
2484
2438
0
0.50
1.00
0.50
50
48801
>500
Yes
0.03
<0.10
Yes
4
0.80
1.02
0.90
1
8697
8832
8973
8854
9021
8867
7259
8867
8915
8663
0
0
4101
4191
4215
4027
4087
4054
4240
4114
4205
4236
0
0.48
1.01
0.47
53
86948
>500
Yes
0.03
<0.10
Yes
5
1.02
1.44
1.21
0
12990
13520
13460
13470
13780
13410
11070
13610
13380
13510
0
0
5445
5807
5508
5277
5590
5439
5553
5603
5628
5616
0
0.42
1.02
0.41
59
132200
>500
Yes
0.03
<0.10
Yes
6
1.44
1.86
1.64
0
7763
8139
8005
8136
8359
8037
6717
8190
8041
8149
1
0
2882
2954
2887
2683
2773
2820
2984
2933
2902
2847
0
0.36
1.00
0.36
64
79536
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.10
Yes
7
1.86
2.28
2.06
0
10320
10610
10710
10450
10640
10510
8656
10410
10420
10430
0
0
3223
3249
3147
3154
3052
3022
3207
3262
3135
3139
1
0.31
1.01
0.30
70
103156
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.10
Yes
8
2.28
2.85
2.55
0
10660
10910
10910
10500
10980
10840
9230
11100
10900
10990
0
0
2564
2607
2476
2415
2464
2375
2687
2623
2680
2652
0
0.24
0.99
0.24
76
107020
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.10
Yes
9
2.85
3.13
2.98
0
2521
2452
2500
2408
2466
2426
2268
2706
2574
2674
1
0
450
490
478
414
442
422
549
533
556
475
0
0.19
0.99
0.19
81
24995
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.10
Yes
10
3.13
4.25
3.65
0
5489
5567
5668
5550
5741
5547
4835
5899
5731
5781
0
0
815
839
799
739
790
791
916
891
851
849
0
0.15
0.99
0.15
85
55808
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
7.1 L/min
11
4.25
5.66
4.91
0
3300
3356
3420
3300
3453
3330
3029
3611
3494
3506
0
0
240
289
277
249
235
250
304
307
337
294
0
0.08
0.99
0.08
92
33799
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
)
12
5.66
7.07
6.33
0
1106
1161
1205
1126
1124
1148
1097
1191
1233
1283
0
0
42
61
45
31
30
32
46
51
43
33
0
0.04
0.99
0.04
96
11674
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
13
7.07
7.77
7.41
0
203
192
185
191
183
195
169
211
205
199
0
0
4
1
4
3
3
3
7
4
3
5
0
0.02
0.95
0.02
98
1933
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
14
7.77
9.88
8.76
0
286
313
314
291
312
285
300
313
353
330
0
0
10
3
4
3
5
4
7
5
10
6
0
0.02
0.95
0.02
98
3097
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
15
9.88
14.10
11.81
0
195
206
231
199
234
212
203
243
217
224
0
0
1
2
2
0
5
3
3
6
2
0
0
0.01
0.93
0.01
99
2164
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
(applies to all channels)
C-5
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Test No. 09019903
No Filter
Solid-Phase
Particle Counts per Indicated OPC Channel (1-Minute Samples @
OPC Channel Number
Min. Diam. fum)
Max. Diam. fum)
Geo. Mean Diam (urn)
ENTER DATA BELOW
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-01-1999 10:48:48 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 10:54:10 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 10:56:40 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 10:59:10 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 11:01:40 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 11:04:10 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 11:06:40 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 11:09:10 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 11:11:40 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 11:14:10 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 11:16:40 01:00
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-01-1999 11:26:58 01:00
ENTER DATA BELOW
D. Bckgrnd 2 01 09-01-1999 10:50:03 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 10:55:25 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 10:57:55 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 11:00:25 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 11:02:55 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 11:05:25 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 11:07:55 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 11:10:25 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 11:12:55 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 11:15:25 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 11:17:55 01:00
D. Bckgrnd 2 01 09-01-1999 11:28:13 01:00
Meas. Penetration
P100 correction values
Corrected Penetration
Corrected Efficiency (%)
Data Acceptance Criteria:
Total Challenge Counts for Each Channel:
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Standard Deviation of Penetration for Each Channel :
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Maximum observed particle concentration (#/cc):
Data Quality Objective: max. allowable cone. (#/cc):
Does this meet the DQO:
1
0.45
0.59
0.52
1
11000
10540
10500
10650
10750
10590
10940
10710
10800
10650
0
0
10970
10570
10720
10870
10990
10530
10990
10690
10660
10600
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
107130
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.10
Yes
18.4
<23
2
0.59
0.73
0.66
2
16170
15750
15770
15850
15920
15760
15870
15890
16140
15900
0
0
16390
15880
15620
15810
16070
15810
16310
15850
15770
15460
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
159020
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.10
Yes
3
0.73
0.80
0.77
0
5096
5095
5096
5147
5040
4962
4998
5009
5168
5088
0
0
5241
4931
5025
5161
5133
4908
5197
4908
4626
5007
0
0.99
1.00
0.99
1
50699
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
4 5
0.80 1.02
1.02 1.44
0.90 1.21
0 0
9168 14340
9015 13800
9028 13780
8844 13570
8978 13740
9061 13680
9096 13950
9114 13840
9281 14300
9104 13670
0 0
1 0
9466 14380
8914 14080
8916 13340
9278 13650
9201 13980
9025 13760
9297 14310
9039 14220
9078 13950
9056 13900
1 0
1.01 1.01
1.00 1.00
1.01 1.01
-1 -1
90689 138670
> 500 > 500
Yes Yes
0.02 0.03
<0.10 <0.10
Yes Yes
6 7
1.44 1.86
1.86 2.28
1.64 2.06
0 0
8401 10890
8283 10790
8070 10450
8032 10290
8220 10540
8242 10580
8259 10760
8200 10600
8225 10840
8254 10410
0 0
0 1
8570 11110
8385 10680
8068 10460
8384 10610
8236 10800
8181 10500
8610 10950
8397 10700
8263 10680
8098 10460
0 0
1.01 1.01
1.00 1.00
1.01 1.01
-1 -1
82186 106150
> 500 > 500
Yes Yes
0.03 0.03
<0.10 <0.10
Yes Yes
8
2.28
2.85
2.55
0
11250
11170
11260
11070
11230
11130
11420
11470
11400
11560
0
0
11060
11170
10940
11390
11190
11110
11310
11160
11320
11280
0
0.99
1.00
0.99
1
112960
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.10
Yes
9
2.85
3.13
2.98
0
2705
2700
2617
2710
2664
2816
2770
2953
2674
2691
0
0
2566
2664
2670
2671
2754
2685
2785
2681
2730
2731
0
0.99
1.00
0.99
1
27300
> 500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
10
3.13
4.25
3.65
1
5960
5924
5899
5631
5892
5989
6047
5930
6042
5865
0
1
5944
5853
5898
5822
5935
5834
6093
5766
5911
5968
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
59179
>500
Yes
0.03
<0.30
Yes
7.1 L/min)
11
4.25
5.66
4.91
0
3559
3720
3524
3520
3509
3490
3708
3598
3732
3629
0
0
3453
3569
3519
3496
3490
3540
3621
3586
3634
3648
0
0.99
1.00
0.99
1
35989
>500
Yes
0.03
<0.30
Yes
12
5.66
7.07
6.33
0
1191
1196
1182
1203
1239
1264
1278
1279
1302
1324
0
0
1256
1160
1208
1243
1208
1215
1367
1272
1299
1223
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
12458
>500
Yes
0.06
<0.30
Yes
13
7.07
7.77
7.41
0
203
208
202
208
209
207
205
208
212
217
0
0
172
196
199
205
208
211
211
210
207
204
0
0.97
1.00
0.97
3
2079
> 500
Yes
0.06
< 0.30
Yes
14
7.77
9.88
8.76
0
315
347
314
342
291
351
352
330
344
415
0
0
320
310
314
336
329
338
346
347
335
385
0
0.99
1.00
0.99
1
3401
>500
Yes
0.11
<0.30
Yes
15
9.88
14.10
11.81
0
221
210
240
215
244
245
238
211
252
229
0
0
224
216
200
224
221
214
233
225
242
240
0
0.97
1.00
0.97
3
2305
>500
Yes
0.08
<0.30
Yes
Yes, (applies to all channels)
C-6
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Test No.
Arrester
Solid-Phase
09019904
Particle Counts per Indicated OPC Channel (1-Minute Samples @
OPC Channel Number
Min. Diam. (urn)
Max. Diam. (urn)
Geo. Mean Diam (urn)
ENTER DATA BELOW
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-01-1999 11:42:36
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 11:50:26
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 11:52:56
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 11:55:26
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 11:57:56
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 12:00:26
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 12:02:56
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 12:05:26
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 12:07:56
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 12:10:26
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 12:12:56
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-01-1999 12:20:50
ENTER DATA BELOW
D. Bckgrnd 201 09-01-1999 11:43:51
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 11:51:41
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 11:54:11
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 11:56:41
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 11:59:11
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 12:01:41
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 12:04:11
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 12:06:41
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 12:09:11
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 12:11:41
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 12:14:11
D. Bckgrnd 2 01 09-01-1999 12:22:05
Meas. Penetration
P100 correction values
Corrected Penetration
Corrected Efficiency (%)
Data Acceptance Criteria:
Total Challenge Counts for Each Channel:
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Standard Deviation of Penetration for Each Channel
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Maximum observed particle concentration (#/cc):
Data Quality Objective: max. allowable cone. (#/cc):
Does this meet the DQO:
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
1
0.45
0.59
0.52
0
10940
10560
10340
10400
10260
10060
9895
10180
10100
10080
0
0
6073
6153
6234
5967
6104
5941
5876
5783
5957
5930
0
0.58
1.00
0.58
42
102815
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.10
Yes
18.2
<23
Yes,
2
0.59
0.73
0.66
0
16320
16210
15530
15600
15380
15260
14710
15190
14960
15260
0
0
8539
8634
8667
8374
8274
8366
8121
8174
8340
8512
0
0.54
1.00
0.54
46
154420
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.10
Yes
(applies to
3
0.73
0.80
0.77
0
5102
5178
4816
5019
4993
4790
4744
4846
4871
4999
0
0
2494
2596
2606
2508
2471
2292
2295
2376
2441
2518
0
0.50
0.99
0.50
50
49358
>500
Yes
0.03
<0.10
Yes
4
0.80
1.02
0.90
1
9421
9009
8749
8967
8840
8630
8428
8764
8861
8801
1
0
4150
4280
4208
4081
4031
4071
4086
4221
4253
4297
0
0.47
1.01
0.47
53
88470
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.10
Yes
5
1.02
1.44
1.21
1
14200
13620
13250
13560
13350
13210
13260
13600
13340
13590
0
0
5658
5910
5709
5486
5665
5441
5734
5719
5696
5899
0
0.42
1.01
0.42
58
134980
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.10
Yes
6
1.44
1.86
1.64
0
8497
8304
8007
8179
7815
7664
7832
7853
8022
8034
0
0
2879
2963
2967
2896
2856
2881
2801
2846
2933
3025
0
0.36
1.01
0.36
64
80207
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.10
Yes
7
1.86
2.28
2.06
0
10870
10590
10490
10560
10390
10180
9842
10310
10350
10270
0
0
3182
3317
3285
3211
3100
2999
3148
3104
3307
3210
0
0.31
1.01
0.30
70
103852
> 500
Yes
0.01
<0.10
Yes
8
2.28
2.85
2.55
0
11250
10950
10710
10780
10910
10550
10670
10960
11150
11120
0
0
2589
2771
2726
2679
2581
2522
2673
2676
2750
2841
1
0.25
0.99
0.25
75
109050
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.10
Yes
9
2.85
3.13
2.98
0
2678
2787
2617
2548
2581
2536
2710
2746
2770
2813
0
0
484
536
477
490
463
491
516
568
571
549
0
0.19
0.99
0.19
81
26786
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.10
Yes
10
3.13
4.25
3.65
0
5937
5807
5767
5649
5704
5468
5859
5951
6018
6082
0
0
813
911
868
849
826
804
927
850
961
955
0
0.15
1.00
0.15
85
58242
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
7.1 L/min)
11
4.25
5.66
4.91
0
3546
3578
3423
3473
3529
3354
3566
3657
3889
3689
0
0
262
314
311
265
262
260
317
320
348
361
0
0.08
0.99
0.09
91
35704
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
12
5.66
7.07
6.33
0
1238
1209
1116
1138
1268
1165
1300
1263
1329
1312
0
0
30
43
42
43
54
41
53
51
57
60
0
0.04
1.00
0.04
96
12338
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
13
7.07
7.77
7.41
0
214
211
210
209
191
191
206
206
210
258
0
0
10
4
4
9
3
1
3
7
8
9
0
0.03
0.97
0.03
97
2106
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.30
Yes
14
7.77
9.88
8.76
0
355
321
319
343
356
327
357
383
355
385
0
0
4
5
6
3
4
5
6
8
12
7
0
0.02
0.99
0.02
98
3501
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
15
9.88
14.10
11.81
0
234
237
234
240
238
220
263
242
257
258
0
0
2
6
2
2
1
3
0
0
4
8
0
0.01
0.97
0.01
99
2423
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
all channels)
C-7
-------
Columbus SL-46B
OPC Channel Number
Min. Diam. fum)
Max. Diam. fum)
Geo. Mean Diam (urn)
ENTER DATA BELOW
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-01-1999 13:16:06
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 13:22:40
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 13:25:10
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 13:27:40
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 13:30:10
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 13:32:40
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 13:35:10
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 13:37:40
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 13:40:10
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 13:42:40
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 13:45:10
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-01-1999 13:58:01
ENTER DATA BELOW
D. Bckgrnd 2 01 09-01-1999 13:17:21
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 13:23:55
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 13:26:25
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 13:28:55
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 13:31:25
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 13:33:55
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 13:36:25
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 13:38:55
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 13:41:25
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 13:43:55
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 13:46:25
D. Bckgrnd 2 01 09-01-1999 13:59:16
Meas. Penetration
P100 correction values
Corrected Penetration
Corrected Efficiency (%)
Data Acceptance Criteria:
Total Challenge Counts for Each Channel:
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Standard Deviation of Penetration for Each Channel
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Maximum observed particle concentration (#/cc):
Data Quality Objective: max. allowable cone. (#/cc):
Does this meet the DQO:
Test No. 09019905
No Filter
Solid-Phase
Particle Counts per Indicated OPC Channel (1-Minute Samples @
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
-I
1
0.45
0.59
0.52
0
10440
10570
10590
10640
10660
10310
9261
10240
10400
10360
0
2
10680
10510
10480
10440
10450
10500
10590
10370
10420
10380
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
103471
> 500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
18.1
<23
Yes,
2
0.59
0.73
0.66
0
15790
16020
15990
16010
15370
15470
14080
15630
15520
15350
0
0
16160
15820
15770
15890
15770
15840
15880
15380
15680
15390
1
1.02
1.00
1.02
-2
155230
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
3
0.73
0.80
0.77
0
5120
5153
5024
4966
5005
5090
4546
5099
4953
5041
0
0
5077
5013
5053
4912
5151
5051
5011
5040
5123
4969
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
49997
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
4
0.80
1.02
0.90
0
8990
9077
9087
8961
8759
8688
8093
8982
9102
8996
0
0
9008
8921
8934
8923
8994
8854
9257
9038
9021
8907
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
88735
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
5
1.02
1.44
1.21
0
13900
13900
13560
13990
13540
13420
12410
13890
13990
13700
0
0
14040
13830
13920
13460
13580
13550
14220
14360
14040
13690
0
1.02
1.00
1.02
-2
136300
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
678
1.44 1.86 2.28
1.86 2.28 2.85
1.64 2.06 2.55
000
8194 10690 11170
8284 10770 11150
8432 10640 11070
8386 10750 11290
8048 10580 10810
8007 10390 10700
7298 9392 10090
8171 10500 11300
8271 10690 11680
8178 10400 11200
000
1 0 0
8313 10780 11250
8179 10590 10980
8037 10900 11100
8095 10380 10730
8109 10540 10980
7980 10490 10870
8366 10770 11370
8191 10310 11050
8100 10760 11540
8094 10470 11020
000
1.00 1.01 1.00
1.00 1.00 1.00
1.00 1.01 1.00
0-10
81269 104802 110460
> 500 > 500 > 500
Yes Yes Yes
0.04 0.04 0.04
<0.10 <0.10 <0.10
Yes Yes Yes
9
2.85
3.13
2.98
0
2613
2667
2750
2676
2637
2537
2526
2854
2818
2765
0
0
2558
2695
2672
2605
2704
2625
2729
2803
2826
2832
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
26843
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
10
3.13
4.25
3.65
0
5746
5912
5982
5858
5785
5424
5510
6007
6313
6007
0
0
5863
5827
5828
5773
5731
5745
6094
5940
6141
5952
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
58544
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.30
Yes
7.1 L/min)
11
4.25
5.66
4.91
0
3503
3554
3498
3530
3497
3401
3437
3809
3741
3666
0
0
3548
3485
3530
3411
3480
3475
3817
3686
3661
3535
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
35636
> 500
Yes
0.05
<0.30
Yes
12
5.66
7.07
6.33
0
1214
1239
1250
1249
1170
1197
1184
1344
1358
1359
0
0
1224
1235
1181
1205
1184
1164
1338
1310
1294
1299
0
0.99
1.00
0.99
1
12564
>500
Yes
0.08
<0.30
Yes
13
7.07
7.77
7.41
0
165
200
212
204
203
175
194
217
223
225
0
0
206
225
188
171
210
188
233
216
209
219
0
1.02
1.00
1.02
-2
2018
>500
Yes
0.14
<0.30
Yes
14
7.77
9.88
8.76
0
374
317
372
303
322
305
347
355
387
392
0
0
305
339
298
342
324
290
338
352
374
341
0
0.95
1.00
0.95
5
3474
>500
Yes
0.12
<0.30
Yes
15
9.88
14.10
11.81
0
205
212
238
231
238
253
242
256
255
244
0
0
202
209
172
211
219
228
223
243
270
239
0
0.93
1.00
0.93
7
2374
>500
Yes
0.13
<0.30
Yes
(applies to all channels)
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Test No.
Arrester
Solid-Phase
09019906
Particle Counts per Indicated OPC Channel (1-Minute Ss
OPC Channel Number
Min. Diam. (urn)
Max. Diam. (urn)
Geo. Mean Diam (urn)
ENTER DATA BELOW
U. Bckgmd 1 01 09-01-1999 14:19:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 14:24:18
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 14:26:48
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 14:29:18
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 14:31:48
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 14:34:18
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 14:36:48
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 14:39:18
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 14:41:48
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 14:44:18
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 14:46:48
U. Bckgmd 1 01 09-01-1999 14:57:24
ENTER DATA BELOW
D. Bckgmd 2 01 09-01-1999 14:20:15
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 14:25:33
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 14:28:03
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 14:30:33
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 14:33:03
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 14:35:33
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 14:38:03
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 14:40:33
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 14:43:03
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 14:45:33
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 14:48:03
D. Bckgmd 2 01 09-01-1999 14:58:39
Meas. Penetration
P100 correction values
Corrected Penetration
Corrected Efficiency (%)
Data Acceptance Criteria:
Total Challenge Counts for Each Channel:
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Standard Deviation of Penetration for Each Channel
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Maximum observed particle concentration f#/cc):
Data Quality Objective: max. allowable cone. (#/cc):
Does this meet the DQO:
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
1
0.45
0.59
0.52
0
10710
10340
10490
10340
10070
10360
10520
10440
10100
10480
0
0
6401
6431
6566
6351
6401
6176
6468
6246
6510
6409
0
0.62
1.01
0.61
39
103850
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.10
Yes
17.9
<23
Yes,
2
0.59
0.73
0.66
0
15960
15310
15500
15580
15340
15650
15410
15640
15390
15320
0
0
9146
9063
8945
8886
8950
8738
8937
8811
9002
9213
0
0.58
1.02
0.57
43
3
0.73
0.80
0.77
0
5062
4816
4933
4970
4851
4920
4930
4952
4911
4964
0
0
2668
2689
2672
2691
2637
2606
2593
2704
2688
2635
0
0.54
1.01
0.53
47
155100 49309
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.10
Yes
(applies to a
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.10
Yes
4
0.80
1.02
0.90
0
9167
8930
8885
8903
8744
9018
9015
8926
8712
8748
0
0
4538
4546
4474
4511
4414
4366
4344
4535
4521
4594
0
0.50
1.01
0.50
50
89048
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.10
Yes
5
1.02
1.44
1.21
0
13880
13430
13680
13570
13280
13480
13670
13780
13210
13360
0
0
6260
6228
6098
6041
6034
5951
6166
5996
6093
6250
0
0.45
1.02
0.44
56
135340
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.10
Yes
6
1.44
1.86
1.64
0
8321
7968
7909
8080
7972
8021
8092
8062
7758
7994
0
0
2990
3167
3138
3102
3108
2990
3095
3066
3282
3091
0
0.39
1.00
0.39
61
80177
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.10
Yes
7
1.86
2.28
2.06
0
10710
10330
10450
10600
10280
10370
10640
10490
10470
10410
0
0
3566
3542
3533
3524
3455
3351
3438
3443
3688
3629
0
0.34
1.01
0.33
67
104750
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.10
Yes
8
2.28
2.85
2.55
0
11050
10960
10840
10670
10750
10920
10830
10790
10780
10750
0
0
3011
3094
3039
2778
2879
2712
2877
3009
2977
3017
0
0.27
1.00
0.27
73
108340
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.10
Yes
9
2.85
3.13
2.98
0
2624
2574
2698
2538
2613
2643
2567
2693
2575
2666
0
0
607
594
546
561
530
539
547
565
545
567
0
0.21
1.01
0.21
79
26191
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.10
Yes
imples@ 7.1 L/min)
10
3.13
4.25
3.65
0
5820
5835
5702
5791
5636
5692
5569
5682
5695
5564
0
0
963
1030
979
951
903
967
888
926
977
977
0
0.17
1.01
0.17
83
56986
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
11
4.25
5.66
4.91
0
3502
3482
3525
3537
3566
3528
3676
3535
3412
3414
0
0
361
346
345
332
355
299
301
356
339
309
0
0.10
1.00
0.10
90
35177
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
12
5.66
7.07
6.33
0
1240
1271
1280
1252
1238
1234
1202
1222
1234
1184
0
0
55
65
58
75
48
54
45
59
58
55
0
0.05
0.99
0.05
95
12357
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
13
7.07
7.77
7.41
0
195
211
202
199
225
226
225
218
183
199
0
0
4
5
9
8
6
3
4
3
3
3
0
0.02
1.02
0.02
98
2083
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
14
7.77
9.88
8.76
0
351
360
324
305
354
329
343
311
342
325
0
0
7
8
9
11
9
6
5
7
7
7
0
0.02
0.95
0.02
98
3344
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
15
9.88
14.10
11.81
0
230
261
232
217
234
243
232
235
223
224
0
0
3
3
9
2
2
3
0
2
7
9
0
0.02
0.93
0.02
98
2331
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
II channels)
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Test No. 08319904
HEPA
Solid-Phase
Particle Counts per Indicated OPC Channel (1-Minute Ss
OPC Channel Number
Min. Diam. (urn)
Max. Diam. (urn)
Geo. Mean Diam (urn)
ENTER DATA BELOW
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 08-31-199913:21:20 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 13:30:30 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 13:33:00 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 13:35:30 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 13:38:00 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 13:40:30 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 13:43:00 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 13:45:30 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 13:48:00 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 13:50:30 01:00
Upstream 1 01 08-31-1999 13:53:00 01:00
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 08-31-1999 14:03:28 01:00
ENTER DATA BELOW
D. Bckgrnd 2 01 08-31-1999 13:22:35 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 13:31:45 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 13:34:15 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 13:36:45 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 13:39:15 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 13:41:45 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 13:44:15 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 13:46:45 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 13:49:15 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 13:51:45 01:00
Downstream 2 01 08-31-1999 13:54:15 01:00
D. Bckgrnd 2 01 08-31-1999 14:04:43 01:00
Meas. Penetration
P100 correction values
Corrected Penetration
Corrected Efficiency (%)
Data Acceptance Criteria:
Total Challenge Counts for Each Channel:
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Standard Deviation of Penetration for Each Channel :
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Maximum observed particle concentration (#/cc):
Data Quality Objective: max. allowable cone. (#/cc):
Does this meet the DQO:
1
0.45
0.59
0.52
0
9906
10140
10410
10020
10100
9782
8866
9952
10040
9933
0
0
12
10
8
7
9
12
5
12
9
7
0
0.00
1.01
0.00
100
99149
>500
Yes
0.00
<0.10
Yes
17.7
<23
2
0.59
0.73
0.66
0
15210
15260
15560
14890
14850
14920
13340
14880
14910
14870
0
0
21
14
19
14
18
17
20
16
17
20
2
0.00
1.00
0.00
100
148690
>500
Yes
0.00
<0.10
Yes
3
0.73
0.80
0.77
0
4721
4804
4867
4814
4829
4769
4235
4725
4738
4601
0
0
2
3
4
6
4
2
4
5
5
1
0
0.00
1.01
0.00
100
47103
>500
Yes
0.00
<0.10
Yes
4 5
0.80 1.02
1.02 1.44
0.90 1.21
0 0
8631 13060
8950 13360
9101 13840
8556 13350
8570 13280
8396 12730
7393 11380
8314 12550
8308 12870
8359 12770
0 0
0 0
11 12
9 17
5 14
10 14
8 15
7 19
5 13
6 11
10 5
6 16
2 1
0.00 0.00
1.00 1.01
0.00 0.00
100 100
84578 129190
> 500 > 500
Yes Yes
0.00 0.00
<0.10 <0.10
Yes Yes
6 7
1.44 1.86
1.86 2.28
1.64 2.06
0 0
7586 10050
7959 10180
8060 10440
7905 10220
7877 10120
7719 10000
6768 8732
7560 9809
7608 9800
7614 9846
0 0
0 0
6 10
8 13
8 17
10 8
8 5
11 11
7 9
4 9
10 7
9 8
0 2
0.00 0.00
1.01 1.02
0.00 0.00
100 100
76656 99197
> 500 > 500
Yes Yes
0.00 0.00
<0.10 <0.10
Yes Yes
8
2.28
2.85
2.55
0
11040
11250
11550
11320
11290
11070
9584
10470
10540
10330
0
0
9
13
10
7
4
9
7
6
6
11
2
0.00
1.03
0.00
100
108444
>500
Yes
0.00
<0.10
Yes
9
2.85
3.13
2.98
0
2743
2837
2828
2790
2726
2828
2284
2506
2540
2503
0
0
6
2
1
1
1
0
3
2
3
1
1
0.00
0.99
0.00
100
26585
>500
Yes
0.00
<0.10
Yes
imples @ 7.1 L/min)
10
3.13
4.25
3.65
0
5920
6030
6156
6017
5961
5833
5022
5235
5386
5398
0
0
2
1
7
5
5
8
3
2
8
3
1
0.00
1.01
0.00
100
56958
>500
Yes
0.00
<0.30
Yes
11
4.25
5.66
4.91
0
3442
3564
3569
3444
3453
3446
2752
3100
3184
3046
0
0
1
5
0
0
1
1
2
4
0
2
0
0.00
1.01
0.00
100
33000
>500
Yes
0.00
<0.30
Yes
12
5.66
7.07
6.33
0
1149
1170
1175
1167
1288
1167
939
1034
1015
1069
0
0
1
0
2
2
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0.00
1.01
0.00
100
11173
>500
Yes
0.00
<0.30
Yes
13
7.07
7.77
7.41
0
191
200
204
201
211
174
160
182
158
168
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0.00
1.01
0.00
100
1849
>500
Yes
0.00
<0.30
Yes
14
7.77
9.88
8.76
0
297
303
309
320
336
323
254
302
261
289
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0.00
0.95
0.00
100
2999
>500
Yes
0.00
<0.30
Yes
15
9.88
14.10
11.81
0
193
204
222
176
209
218
147
179
187
189
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0.00
0.88
0.00
100
1924
>500
Yes
0.00
<0.30
Yes
Yes, (applies to all channels)
C-10
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Test No. 09019907
No Filter
Liquid-Phase
Particle Counts per Indicated OPC Channel (1-Minute Samples @
OPC Channel Number
Min. Diam. (um)
Max. Diam. (um)
Geo. Mean Diam (um)
ENTER DATA BELOW
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-01-1999 15:17:44 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 15:30:34 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 15:33:04 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 15:35:34 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 15:38:04 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 15:40:34 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 15:43:04 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 15:45:34 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 15:48:04 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 15:50:34 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 15:53:04 01:00
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-01-1999 16:01:18 01:00
ENTER DATA BELOW
D. Bckgrnd 2 01 09-01-1999 15:18:59 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 15:31:49 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 15:34:19 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 15:36:49 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 15:39:19 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 15:41:49 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 15:44:19 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 15:46:49 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 15:49:19 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 15:51:49 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 15:54:19 01:00
D. Bckgrnd 2 01 09-01-1999 16:02:33 01:00
Meas. Penetration
P100 correction values
Corrected Penetration
Corrected Efficiency (%)
Data Acceptance Criteria:
Total Challenge Counts for Each Channel:
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Standard Deviation of Penetration for Each Channel :
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Maximum observed particle concentration (#/cc):
Data Quality Objective: max. allowable cone. (#/cc):
Does this meet the DQO:
1
0.28
0.37
0.32
0
9945
9982
9368
9694
10000
10080
9919
10170
10250
10860
0
0
9910
9838
10470
9742
9727
9677
10060
9801
10370
10280
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
100268
>500
Yes
0.05
O.10
Yes
17.2
<23
Yes,
2
0.37
0.47
0.42
0
15570
15680
15140
15650
15750
15810
14980
16450
16180
16880
0
0
15470
15510
16400
15400
15340
15130
15700
16200
16780
16180
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
158090
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
(applies to
3
0.47
0.52
0.49
0
5556
5531
5286
5604
5547
5606
5340
5711
5756
5975
0
0
5562
5431
5729
5393
5494
5392
5728
5640
5958
5675
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
55912
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
4
0.52
0.66
0.58
0
10250
10190
9648
10050
10030
10160
9936
10210
10230
10950
0
0
10010
9775
10300
9800
9855
9748
9889
10220
10610
10090
0
0.99
1.00
0.99
1
101654
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
5
0.66
0.94
0.78
1
15420
15050
14630
15020
15550
15650
14920
15830
15660
16060
0
0
15390
15230
15970
14930
15390
14870
15410
15640
16080
15730
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
153790
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
6
0.94
1.22
1.07
1
10900
11060
10740
10780
11040
10840
10220
11350
11190
11820
0
0
11080
10870
11320
10750
10740
10530
11090
11030
11610
11110
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
109940
>500
Yes
0.05
O.10
Yes
7
1.22
1.51
1.36
0
17910
17730
17120
17600
17880
17890
16930
18350
17970
19150
0
0
17640
17670
18020
17580
17120
17090
17780
17740
18790
18000
0
0.99
1.00
0.99
1
178530
>500
Yes
0.04
O.10
Yes
8
1.51
1.88
1.68
1
12720
12720
12380
12960
12810
13210
12420
13270
13060
13720
0
1
12890
12760
13310
12630
12760
12760
12850
13130
13520
13050
1
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
129270
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
9
1.88
2.07
1.97
0
2961
2921
2759
2897
2974
2956
2924
3027
3057
3050
0
0
2940
2845
3109
2790
2838
2967
3023
2876
3084
3001
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
29526
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
10
2.07
2.83
2.42
0
6976
6991
6707
6923
7005
7113
6724
7327
7105
7358
0
0
6981
7006
7172
6745
6830
7076
7055
7239
7350
7117
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
70229
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
7.1 L/min)
11
2.83
3.77
3.26
0
4087
4061
3945
4101
4170
4131
4024
4194
4157
4374
0
0
4116
4208
4314
4193
4096
4030
4078
4167
4307
4096
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
41244
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.30
Yes
12
3.77
4.71
4.21
0
1115
1102
1056
1102
1107
1163
1096
1146
1109
1186
0
1
1108
1079
1204
1069
1138
1146
1086
1165
1203
1160
0
1.02
1.00
1.02
-2
11182
>500
Yes
0.06
<0.30
Yes
13
4.71
5.18
4.94
0
163
166
145
189
153
164
151
194
165
172
0
0
171
172
177
153
166
168
174
172
177
194
0
1.04
1.00
1.04
-4
1662
>500
Yes
0.12
<0.30
Yes
14
5.18
6.60
5.85
0
270
260
252
272
268
275
266
293
275
277
0
0
232
257
252
260
238
250
271
236
261
269
0
0.93
1.00
0.93
7
2708
>500
Yes
0.06
<0.30
Yes
15
6.60
9.43
7.89
0
154
163
129
125
153
138
138
165
166
159
0
0
137
136
154
153
121
148
148
149
150
152
0
0.97
1.00
0.97
3
1490
> 500
Yes
0.12
<0.30
Yes
all channels)
C-ll
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Test No.
Arrester
Liquid-Phase
09019908
Particle Counts per Indicated OPC Channel (1-Minute Samples @
OPC Channel Number
Min. Diam. (um)
Max. Diam. (um)
Geo. Mean Diam (um)
ENTER DATA BELOW
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-01-199916:09:32 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 16:16:07 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 16:18:37 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 16:21:07 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 16:23:37 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 16:26:07 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 16:28:37 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 16:31:07 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 16:33:37 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 16:36:07 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-01-1999 16:38:37 01:00
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-01-199916:46:24 01:00
ENTER DATA BELOW
D. Bckgrnd 2 01 09-01-199916:10:47 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 16:17:22 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 16:19:52 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 16:22:22 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 16:24:52 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 16:27:22 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 16:29:52 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 16:32:22 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 16:34:52 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 16:37:22 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-01-1999 16:39:52 01:00
D. Bckgrnd 2 01 09-01-199916:47:39 01:00
Meas. Penetration
P100 correction values
Corrected Penetration
Corrected Efficiency (%)
Data Acceptance Criteria:
Total Challenge Counts for Each Channel:
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Standard Deviation of Penetration for Each Channel :
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Maximum observed particle concentration (#/cc):
Data Quality Objective: max. allowable cone. (#/cc):
Does this meet the DQO:
1
0.28
0.37
0.32
0
9434
10010
9905
10330
10020
9650
8633
9366
9297
9478
1
6
6404
6752
6766
6818
6735
6689
6446
6208
6539
6233
0
0.68
1.00
0.68
32
96123
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
16.7
< 23
Yes,
2
0.37
0.47
0.42
0
14920
15710
15760
16240
15680
15440
14110
14600
14440
14690
0
0
9921
10340
10480
10490
10240
10230
9547
9591
9733
9462
3
0.66
1.00
0.66
34
151590
> 500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
(applies to
3
0.47
0.52
0.49
0
5183
5614
5608
5805
5539
5448
4942
5269
4907
5153
1
0
3446
3565
3566
3553
3579
3566
3469
3332
3414
3285
0
0.65
1.00
0.65
35
53468
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
4
0.52
0.66
0.58
0
9539
9986
10030
10350
10260
10170
8903
9667
9379
9633
0
0
5932
6333
6271
6452
6450
6275
6134
5948
6147
6067
0
0.63
0.99
0.64
36
97917
>500
Yes
0.03
<0.10
Yes
5
0.66
0.94
0.78
0
14170
15330
15240
15850
15130
15290
13660
14440
14140
14890
0
0
8473
8914
8964
9101
8807
8633
8537
8506
8981
8535
0
0.59
1.01
0.59
41
148140
>500
Yes
0.03
O.10
Yes
6
0.94
1.22
1.07
0
10310
10890
11030
11300
10890
10810
9454
10150
9730
10140
0
0
5530
5739
5616
5744
5784
5662
5475
5327
5594
5296
0
0.53
1.00
0.53
47
104704
>500
Yes
0.03
O.10
Yes
7
1.22
1.51
1.36
0
16890
17960
17820
18520
17710
17470
15510
16740
16140
16980
0
0
7992
8160
8270
8394
8297
8031
8063
7943
8149
7826
0
0.47
0.99
0.48
52
171740
>500
Yes
0.03
<0.10
Yes
8
1.51
1.88
1.68
0
12350
13290
13020
13430
12920
12810
12340
13190
13060
13380
0
0
4912
5055
5027
5010
5040
4927
5195
5234
5626
5219
0
0.39
1.00
0.39
61
129790
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.10
Yes
9
1.88
2.07
1.97
0
2801
3060
3002
3026
2914
3076
2716
2944
2915
2895
0
0
928
958
1017
949
948
936
969
986
978
987
0
0.33
1.00
0.33
67
29349
> 500
Yes
0.02
<0.10
Yes
10
2.07
2.83
2.42
0
6618
6980
7012
7169
6989
7080
6529
7029
6769
7155
0
0
1839
1934
1996
2039
1950
1909
1997
1941
2118
1999
0
0.28
1.00
0.28
72
69330
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.10
Yes
7.1 L/min)
11
2.83
3.77
3.26
0
3963
4248
4243
4372
4155
4138
3988
4385
4320
4447
0
0
810
790
822
807
793
813
899
890
900
837
0
0.20
1.01
0.20
80
42259
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
12
3.77
4.71
4.21
0
1073
1104
1118
1138
1126
1071
1110
1129
1163
1249
0
0
85
92
99
118
121
124
123
115
134
129
0
0.10
1.02
0.10
90
11281
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.30
Yes
13
4.71
5.18
4.94
0
181
192
160
179
183
177
172
176
160
191
0
0
12
13
4
13
8
9
13
12
19
7
0
0.06
1.04
0.06
94
1771
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.30
Yes
14
5.18
6.60
5.85
0
276
262
255
280
251
255
280
285
284
285
0
0
15
11
10
6
13
12
13
12
11
16
0
0.04
0.93
0.05
95
2713
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
15
6.60
9.43
7.89
0
146
154
151
155
154
148
147
150
135
166
0
0
4
2
2
2
6
4
2
1
3
3
0
0.02
0.97
0.02
98
1506
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
all channels)
C-12
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Test No. 09029902
No Filter
Liquid-Phase
Particle Counts per Indicated OPC Channel (1-Minute Samples @ 7.1 L/min)
OPC Channel Number
Min. Diam. (um)
Max. Diam. (um)
Geo. Mean Diam (um)
ENTER DATA BELOW
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-02-1999 07:38:55
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 07:45:31
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 07:48:01
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 07:50:31
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 07:53:01
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 07:55:31
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 07:58:01
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 08:00:31
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 08:03:01
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 08:05:31
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 08:08:01
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-02-1999 08:15:51
ENTER DATA BELOW
D. Bckgrnd 2 01 09-02-1999 07:40:10
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 07:46:46
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 07:49:16
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 07:51:46
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 07:54:16
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 07:56:46
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 07:59:16
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 08:01:46
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 08:04:16
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 08:06:46
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 08:09:16
D. Bckgrnd 2 01 09-02-1999 08:17:06
Meas. Penetration
P100 correction values
Corrected Penetration
Corrected Efficiency (%)
Data Acceptance Criteria:
Total Challenge Counts for Each Channel:
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Standard Deviation of Penetration for Each Channel
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Maximum observed particle concentration (#/cc):
Data Quality Objective: max. allowable cone. (#/cc):
Does this meet the DQO:
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
1
0.28
0.37
0.32
0
9441
9432
9986
10040
10160
9923
9191
9694
9921
9470
0
0
9676
9338
9723
9650
9659
9925
10030
9888
9667
9680
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
97258
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
16.8
<23
Yes,
2
0.37
0.47
0.42
0
15160
14630
15560
15440
15560
15590
14170
15390
15350
14840
0
0
14960
14650
15020
15090
15590
15510
15450
15660
15140
15360
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
151690
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
(applies to ;
3
0.47
0.52
0.49
0
5418
5208
5369
5394
5524
5472
4967
5414
5454
5263
0
0
5341
5185
5237
5369
5439
5336
5665
5527
5284
5320
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
53483
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
4
0.52
0.66
0.58
0
9811
9565
9985
10010
10240
10270
9306
9845
9885
9457
0
0
9729
9654
9743
9895
9993
10140
10090
9836
9591
9564
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
98374
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
5
0.66
0.94
0.78
0
14740
14570
15670
15380
15860
15490
14100
14970
15060
14310
0
0
14990
14670
14900
15020
15250
15370
15270
15170
14700
15040
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
150150
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
6
0.94
1.22
1.07
0
10420
10320
10750
10720
10870
10890
10070
10760
10580
10300
0
0
10470
10060
10310
10420
10590
10730
10800
10880
10420
10560
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
105680
>500
Yes
0.03
<0.10
Yes
7
1.22
1.51
1.36
0
17510
16980
17920
17970
18330
18290
16370
17420
17640
17150
0
0
17490
17030
17310
17390
17970
17660
18040
17840
17210
17390
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
175580
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
8
1.51
1.88
1.68
0
13830
13550
14350
14110
14410
14270
12200
12890
13010
12920
0
0
13760
13590
13730
13860
14170
14250
13130
13130
12880
12820
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
135540
>500
Yes
0.07
<0.10
Yes
9
1.88
2.07
1.97
0
3141
2981
3250
3126
3177
3254
2782
3043
2852
2949
0
0
3114
2951
3029
3090
3246
3176
2978
3089
2961
2853
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
30555
>500
Yes
0.07
<0.10
Yes
10
2.07
2.83
2.42
0
7360
7169
7461
7507
7557
7500
6544
6876
7082
6935
0
0
7282
7144
7546
7319
7527
7629
7403
7210
6922
6962
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
71991
>500
Yes
0.06
<0.10
Yes
11
2.83
3.77
3.26
0
4457
4422
4583
4593
4798
4771
3876
4065
4304
4085
0
0
4623
4555
4654
4673
4650
4723
4357
4273
4338
4224
0
1.03
1.00
1.03
-3
43954
>500
Yes
0.08
<0.30
Yes
12
3.77
4.71
4.21
0
1252
1212
1227
1295
1334
1286
1088
1089
1125
1115
0
0
1297
1218
1277
1263
1344
1328
1186
1226
1251
1150
0
1.04
1.00
1.04
-4
12023
>500
Yes
0.09
<0.30
Yes
13
4.71
5.18
4.94
0
174
193
201
209
198
202
188
173
193
168
0
0
203
210
186
214
204
226
173
200
200
189
0
1.06
1.00
1.06
-6
1899
>500
Yes
0.11
<0.30
Yes
14
5.18
6.60
5.85
0
298
303
306
322
332
336
281
284
263
293
0
0
311
332
315
315
284
345
304
269
273
307
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
3018
>500
Yes
0.11
<0.30
Yes
15
6.60
9.43
7.89
0
168
170
166
187
198
179
154
151
161
134
0
0
191
164
157
195
178
184
167
174
157
150
0
1.03
1.00
1.03
-3
1668
>500
Yes
0.15
<0.30
Yes
all channels)
C-13
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Test No.
Arrester
Liquid-Phase
09029903
Particle Counts per Indicated OPC Channel (1-Minute Samples @ 7.1 L/min)
OPC Channel Number
Min. Diam. (urn)
Max. Diam. (urn)
Geo. Mean Diam (urn)
ENTER DATA BELOW
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-02-199908:34:21 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 08:43:26 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 08:45:56 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 08:48:26 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 08:50:56 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 08:53:26 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 08:55:56 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 08:58:26 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 09:00:56 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 09:03:26 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 09:05:56 01:00
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-02-199909:18:43 01:00
ENTER DATA BELOW
D. Bckgrnd 201 09-02-199908:35:36 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 08:44:41 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 08:47:11 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 08:49:41 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 08:52:11 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 08:54:41 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 08:57:11 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 08:59:41 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 09:02:11 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 09:04:41 01:00
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 09:07:11 01:00
D. Bckgrnd 201 09-02-199909:19:58 01:00
Meas. Penetration
P100 correction values
Corrected Penetration
Corrected Efficiency (%)
Data Acceptance Criteria:
Total Challenge Counts for Each Channel:
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Standard Deviation of Penetration for Each Channel :
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Maximum observed particle concentration (#/cc):
Data Quality Objective: max. allowable cone. (#/cc):
Does this meet the DQO:
1
0.28
0.37
0.32
0
9180
10370
10680
10570
10570
10320
9828
9860
9582
9633
0
0
6599
7456
7470
7669
7372
7176
6644
6472
6855
6637
1
0.70
1.00
0.70
30
100593
>500
Yes
0.06
<0.10
Yes
17.7
<23
Yes,
2
0.37
0.47
0.42
0
14020
16470
17100
16890
16780
16180
15390
15030
14930
14860
0
0
10010
11510
11700
11260
11300
11060
10040
9948
10170
10230
1
0.68
1.00
0.68
32
157650
>500
Yes
0.06
<0.10
Yes
(applies to
3
0.47
0.52
0.49
0
5076
5672
6010
5876
5935
5855
5617
5394
5269
5370
1
0
3367
4012
4048
4054
3990
3780
3586
3485
3444
3554
1
0.67
1.00
0.66
34
56074
>500
Yes
0.06
<0.10
Yes
4
0.52
0.66
0.58
0
8959
10720
10900
10770
10800
10310
10210
10120
9749
9981
0
0
6287
7043
7026
6966
6886
6695
6429
6161
6546
6422
0
0.65
1.00
0.65
35
102519
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
5
0.66
0.94
0.78
0
13800
16010
16660
16550
16550
15720
15430
15170
14950
15220
2
0
8598
9967
10040
9946
9706
9550
9240
9021
9467
9310
1
0.61
1.00
0.61
39
156060
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
6
0.94
1.22
1.07
0
9927
11580
11920
11810
12010
11170
10800
10550
10470
10320
2
0
5523
6651
6389
6546
6416
6266
5754
5783
5747
5646
1
0.55
1.00
0.55
45
110557
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
7
1.22
1.51
1.36
0
16470
19040
19460
19150
19390
18540
18140
17800
17500
17530
2
0
8088
9582
9466
9510
9217
9126
8795
8597
8977
8795
0
0.49
1.00
0.49
51
183020
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
8
1.51
1.88
1.68
0
12180
14010
14400
14130
14470
13610
14770
14900
14440
14480
0
0
5119
5971
5753
5886
5750
5379
6105
5796
5939
5975
0
0.41
1.00
0.41
59
141390
>500
Yes
0.03
<0.10
Yes
9
1.88
2.07
1.97
0
2678
3201
3394
3197
3224
3056
3205
3248
3147
3234
1
0
951
1125
1099
1159
1067
1128
1068
1043
1092
1132
0
0.34
1.00
0.34
66
31584
>500
Yes
0.03
<0.10
Yes
10
2.07
2.83
2.42
0
6789
7504
7891
7634
7743
7311
7555
7569
7425
7460
1
0
1999
2191
2289
2325
2257
2139
2280
2183
2225
2231
0
0.30
1.01
0.29
71
74881
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.10
Yes
11
2.83
3.77
3.26
0
3976
4539
4668
4526
4547
4322
4755
4755
4621
4615
1
0
840
955
960
957
898
938
1058
1028
1033
998
0
0.21
1.03
0.21
79
45324
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.30
Yes
12
3.77
4.71
4.21
0
1092
1218
1258
1298
1268
1201
1323
1304
1366
1366
0
0
147
128
155
151
133
139
150
173
167
148
0
0.12
1.04
0.11
89
12694
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
13
4.71
5.18
4.94
0
134
213
210
211
211
161
213
220
198
187
0
0
10
22
11
11
9
7
18
17
18
14
0
0.07
1.06
0.07
93
1958
>500
Yes
0.03
<0.30
Yes
14
5.18
6.60
5.85
0
289
306
335
297
286
270
304
334
353
314
0
0
8
15
15
12
11
9
13
15
13
19
0
0.04
1.01
0.04
96
3088
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
15
6.60
9.43
7.89
0
158
174
154
171
168
180
204
208
186
188
0
0
3
3
2
2
3
3
6
5
3
5
0
0.02
1.03
0.02
98
1791
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
all channels)
C-14
-------
Columbus SL-46B
Test No. 09029904
No Filter
Liquid-Phase
Particle Counts per Indicated OPC Channel (1-Minute Samples @ 7. 1 L/min)
OPC Channel Number
Min. Diam. (urn)
Max. Diam. (urn)
Geo. Mean Diam (urn)
ENTER DATA BELOW
U. Bckgmd 1 01 09-02-1999 09:36:31
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 09:43:09
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 09:45:39
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 09:48:09
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 09:50:39
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 09:53:09
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 09:55:39
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 09:58:09
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 10:00:39
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 10:03:09
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 10:05:39
U. Bckgmd 1 01 09-02-1999 10:13:29
ENTER DATA BELOW
D. Bckgmd 2 01 09-02-1999 09:37:46
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 09:44:24
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 09:46:54
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 09:49:24
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 09:51:54
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 09:54:24
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 09:56:54
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 09:59:24
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 10:01:54
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 10:04:24
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 10:06:54
D. Bckgmd 2 01 09-02-1999 10:14:44
Meas. Penetration
P100 correction values
Corrected Penetration
Corrected Efficiency (%)
Data Acceptance Criteria:
Total Challenge Counts for Each Channel:
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Standard Deviation of Penetration for Each Channel
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Maximum observed particle concentration (#/cc):
Data Quality Objective: max. allowable cone. f#/cc):
Does this meet the DQO:
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
01:00
1
0.28
0.37
0.32
0
10020
9787
9729
10040
9813
9623
9340
9524
9405
9498
0
0
9786
9726
10130
9989
10040
9420
9779
9101
9409
9452
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
96779
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
16.5
< 23
Yes,
2
0.37
0.47
0.42
0
15730
15740
16040
15840
15370
14740
14740
15030
14780
15120
0
0
15150
15290
16050
15820
15720
15050
15490
14860
15220
14910
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
3
0.47
0.52
0.49
0
5487
5537
5713
5515
5572
5271
5207
5134
5190
5260
0
0
5490
5284
5515
5576
5580
5245
5364
5119
5404
5161
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
153130 53886
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
(applies to a
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
4
0.52
0.66
0.58
0
10040
9707
10090
9783
9866
9399
9424
9079
9014
9114
0
0
9735
9763
10080
9879
9446
9186
9531
9288
9262
9028
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
95516
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
5
0.66
0.94
0.78
0
15180
14830
15470
15490
15280
14330
14250
14200
14240
14180
0
0
14980
14930
15700
15270
15030
14110
14750
14260
14280
14260
0
1.00
1.00
1.00
0
147450
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
6
0.94
1.22
1.07
0
11050
10730
11080
10910
10760
10380
10490
10650
10280
10910
1
0
10730
10790
11010
11290
11140
10560
10840
10250
10870
10540
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
107240
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
7
1.22
1.51
1.36
0
18130
17830
18230
17890
17880
16870
16840
16690
16890
17050
0
0
17320
17550
18190
18100
17370
16880
17190
16810
17100
16780
0
0.99
1.00
0.99
1
174300
>500
Yes
0.05
<0.10
Yes
8
1.51
1.88
1.68
0
13490
12730
13310
13040
13270
12240
12460
11680
11830
11580
0
0
12810
13010
13470
12840
11950
11600
12060
12190
11420
11870
0
0.98
1.00
0.98
2
125630
>500
Yes
0.08
<0.10
Yes
9
1.88
2.07
1.97
0
3079
3021
2947
2884
2963
2848
2811
2646
2660
2717
0
0
2866
2938
3006
2880
2709
2652
2808
2782
2663
2701
0
0.98
1.00
0.98
2
28576
>500
Yes
0.07
<0.10
Yes
10
2.07
2.83
2.42
0
7308
7022
7425
7137
7165
6623
6830
6565
6334
6521
0
0
7040
7049
7382
7060
6645
6472
6523
6617
6500
6551
0
0.98
1.00
0.98
2
68930
>500
Yes
0.07
<0.10
Yes
11
2.83
3.77
3.26
0
4309
4106
4206
4206
4131
3865
3846
3595
3675
3655
0
0
4280
4240
4354
4157
3814
3769
3802
3999
3765
3812
0
1.01
1.00
1.01
-1
39594
>500
Yes
0.09
<0.30
Yes
12
3.77
4.71
4.21
0
1146
1143
1095
1166
1180
1081
1130
963
1011
954
0
0
1162
1118
1198
1146
1056
982
1040
1091
978
985
0
0.99
1.00
0.99
1
10869
>500
Yes
0.11
<0.30
Yes
13
4.71
5.18
4.94
0
199
142
172
190
154
145
162
151
171
140
0
0
177
183
201
171
149
161
209
163
160
145
0
1.06
1.00
1.06
-6
1626
>500
Yes
0.18
<0.30
Yes
14
5.18
6.60
5.85
0
281
297
281
267
251
252
275
230
241
237
0
0
280
303
270
261
260
225
243
252
244
210
0
0.98
1.00
0.98
2
2612
>500
Yes
0.13
<0.30
Yes
15
6.60
9.43
7.89
0
148
148
158
166
166
156
147
132
118
143
0
0
161
173
164
153
123
151
148
119
131
124
0
0.98
1.00
0.98
2
1482
>500
Yes
0.16
<0.30
Yes
II channels)
C-15
-------
Columbus SL-46B
OPC Channel Number
Min. Diam. (um)
Max. Diam. (um)
Geo. Mean Diam (um)
ENTER DATA BELOW
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-02-1999 10:27:0701:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 10:33:41 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 10:36:1101:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 10:38:41 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 10:41:1101:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 10:43:41 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 10:46:1101:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 10:48:41 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 10:51:1101:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 10:53:41 01:00
Upstream 1 01 09-02-1999 10:56:1101:00
U. Bckgrnd 1 01 09-02-1999 11:04:1401:00
ENTER DATA BELOW
D. Bckgrnd 2 01 09-02-1999 10:28:2201:00
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 10:34:5601:00
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 10:37:2601:00
Downstream 2
Downstream 2
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 10:44:5601:00
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 10:47:2601:00
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 10:49:5601:00
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 10:52:2601:00
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 10:54:5601:00
Downstream 2 01 09-02-1999 10:57:2601:00
D. Bckgrnd 2 01 09-02-1999 11:05:2901:00
01 09-02-1999 10:39:5601:00
01 09-02-1999 10:42:2601:00
Meas. Penetration
P100 correction values
Corrected Penetration
Corrected Efficiency (%)
Data Acceptance Criteria:
Total Challenge Counts for Each Channel:
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Standard Deviation of Penetration for Each Channel:
Data Quality Objective:
Does this meet DQO:
Maximum observed particle concentration (#/cc):
Data Quality Objective: max. allowable cone. (#/cc):
Does this meet the DQO:
Test No. 09029905
Arrester
Liquid-Phase
Particle Counts per Indicated OPC Channel (1-Minute Samples @
1 2
0.28 0.37
0.37 0.47
0.32 0.42
0 0
9105 13860
10010 15610
10320 16250
10340 16460
10450 16410
10540 16540
9803 15690
10400 16360
10390 16080
10600 16600
0 0
0 0
6411 9541
7147 11070
7043 10660
7432 11370
7593 11290
7257 11140
7620 11530
7337 11230
7423 11370
7344 11000
0 0
0.71 0.69
1.00 1.00
0.71 0.69
29 31
101958 159860
> 500 > 500
Yes Yes
0.05 0.05
<0.10 <0.10
Yes Yes
17.8
<23
3 4
0.47 0.52
0.52 0.66
0.49 0.58
0 0
4947 9378
5375 10310
5847 10580
5781 10720
5858 10570
5893 10750
5530 9962
5774 10430
5841 10350
5837 10640
0 0
0 0
3236 6074
3749 6863
3540 6715
3962 7016
3915 7144
3821 7135
4023 7174
3786 6981
3978 7041
3761 6723
0 0
0.67 0.66
1.00 1.00
0.67 0.67
33 33
56683 103690
> 500 > 500
Yes Yes
0.05 0.04
O.10 O.10
Yes Yes
5
0.66
0.94
0.78
0
14270
15950
16430
16650
16330
16900
15650
15900
16080
16420
0
0
8651
9914
9528
10100
10270
9871
10000
9960
10020
9763
0
0.61
1.00
0.61
39
160580
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
6
0.94
1.22
1.07
0
9736
10940
11540
11720
11410
11800
10880
11470
11520
11680
0
0
5408
6401
5931
6590
6516
6344
6586
6431
6431
6232
0
0.56
1.01
0.55
45
112696
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
7
1.22
1.51
1.36
0
16390
18560
19050
19180
19280
19730
18360
19310
19090
19730
0
0
8089
9465
9090
9718
9627
9464
9592
9428
9493
9370
0
0.49
0.99
0.50
50
188680
>500
Yes
0.04
<0.10
Yes
8
1.51
1.88
1.68
0
13670
14880
15210
15430
15220
15400
13730
14400
14240
14520
0
0
5539
6157
5918
6282
6473
6148
6011
5700
5832
5798
0
0.41
0.98
0.42
58
146700
>500
Yes
0.03
O.10
Yes
9
1.88
2.07
1.97
0
2887
3200
3313
3427
3405
3446
3112
3226
3140
3343
1
0
987
1140
1089
1185
1170
1142
1154
1098
1155
1083
0
0.34
0.98
0.35
65
32499
>500
Yes
0.03
O.10
Yes
10
2.07
2.83
2.42
0
6855
7844
7901
8116
7841
8189
7328
7545
7539
7787
0
0
2030
2399
2275
2443
2403
2312
2231
2244
2169
2244
0
0.30
0.98
0.30
70
76945
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.10
Yes
7.1 L/min)
11
2.83
3.77
3.26
0
4407
4839
4938
4978
4930
4801
4354
4416
4708
4649
0
0
915
1019
958
1093
995
968
1018
967
949
939
0
0.21
1.01
0.21
79
47020
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.30
Yes
12
3.77
4.71
4.21
0
1200
1313
1375
1311
1319
1359
1194
1314
1248
1288
0
0
157
152
153
120
172
169
152
150
155
130
0
0.12
0.99
0.12
88
12921
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
13
4.71
5.18
4.94
0
196
215
219
202
228
216
202
238
177
197
0
0
22
14
11
10
17
13
9
15
14
11
0
0.07
1.06
0.06
94
2090
>500
Yes
0.02
<0.30
Yes
14
5.18
6.60
5.85
0
311
334
347
355
327
335
293
330
279
301
0
0
10
20
18
24
15
17
13
12
10
16
0
0.05
0.98
0.05
95
3212
>500
Yes
0.01
< 0.30
Yes
15
6.60
9.43
7.89
0
186
185
203
201
176
188
154
154
159
188
0
0
7
4
3
2
4
6
7
4
8
3
0
0.03
0.98
0.03
97
1794
>500
Yes
0.01
<0.30
Yes
Yes, (applies to all channels)
C-16
------- |