&EPA United States Environmental Protection Agency EPA 231-F-14-003 November 2014 Environmental Justice Key Resources for Building a Community of Practice for Local Use Planning 2014 ------- ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Many individuals and agencies were involved in the creation of this document The document's principal authors and project managers were Samantha Phillips Beers, Erin C. Sullivan, and Reginald Harris from EPA Region III. Much of the research and initial information for this document came from the work of Patricia Salkin from the Touro College Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Center, and other members of the workgroup, including individuals from federal government, state government, and academia. These non-EPA contributors include: Melissa Collier, Mississippi Department of Environmental Quality Megan McConville, National Association of Development Organizations Edith Pestana, National Environmental Justice Advisory Council (NEJAC) member, Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protection Amy Simes, North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources The following also served as peer reviewers for the document: Members of the Local Government Advisory Council (LGAC) Members of NEJAC, particularly: Charlie Chase Michelle Moore Deidre Sanders Nicky Sheats ------- BACKGROUND ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) defines "environmental justice" as the fair treatment and meaningful involvement of all people regardless of race, color, national origin or income with respect to the development, implementation and enforcement of environmental laws, regulations and policies. Supporting environmental justice is important to the current and future health of a community, as it offers an opportunity for residents to communicate their needs and desires. In doing so, residents may have greater pride and ownership in their community, as well as opportunities for greater economic and social success. Plan El 2014 (the Plan) is a roadmap that will help EPA integrate environmental justice into the Agency's programs, policies, and activities. Plan EJ 2014 is named in recognition of the 20th anniversary of President Clinton's issuance of Executive Order 12898, Federal Actions to Address Environmental Justice in Minority Populations and Low-Income Populations. In implementing the Plan, EPA will seek to meaningfully engage with communities and stakeholders. The goals of the plan are to: • Protect health in communities over-burdened by pollution • Empower communities to take action to improve their health and environment • Establish partnerships with local, state, tribal and federal organizations to achieve healthy and sustainable communities. Plan EJ 2014 is not a rule or regulation. It is a strategy to help integrate environmental justice into EPA's daily activities. LOCAL LAND USE PLANNING Strategic planning is an important part in the overall health of a community. When local governments, industry, and the citizens work together there are an array of advantages to the overall success and pride of a community. Planning, siting, and permitting are essential processes to the development and redevelopment of towns and cities across America, whether it is a small, rural town or a large, urban city. The combination of land use planning and environmental justice is a natural fit; when environmental justice concerns are part of the planning process, relationships are formed, value is added, and there is a better sense of cooperation. INTENDED USE This document was created in partnership with EPA and environmental justice professionals from a variety of backgrounds including federal, state and local government and academia. This group researched and created an informational resource to assist local land use planners, community members and other interested parties to make responsible decisions when planning, siting and permitting. The information provided is intended to inform the land use planning process, promote a collaborative decision-making process and support environmental justice. The identified resources emphasize the importance of thinking creatively in order to protect the environmental and public health of the community. This document is not intended to provide hard-and-fast rules or provide a scripted process for linking environmental justice with land use planning; instead, it is meant to inform the process. This document should be consulted early in the land use planning process to allow communities to determine the best way to enhance their unique planning process. While this document provides many useful environmental justice and land use resources, it is not meant to provide an exhaustive list of information. The document was last updated in June 2014 and will be updated ------- in the future to reflect new information as it is made available. For additional information or to notify EPA of a change, please contact Pat Carey at carey.pat@epa.gov or 202-566-0199. The use of environmental justice principles in land use planning originates from a variety of resource categories and topic areas. This document identifies several of each and are described in further detail in the following several pages. First, the information is organized into five categories indicating origin of the resource: Academic Resources (Articles and Books), Federal Resources (Federal Executive Orders, Legislation and Other Resources), State Resources (State Executive Orders, Legislation and Other Resources), and Local Resources (Local Ordinances and Resources). Within each of those categories, the information is further broken down into six informational topic areas: Environmental Justice 101, Environmental Justice and Land Use: Making the Connection, Engaging the Community, Smart Growth, Case Studies, and Policy/Legislation. These six informational topic areas can be used to inform training modules and course planning, as well as provide reading and background on discrete topics. For example, this document could be consulted to provide information to a land use planner who is interested in learning more about Smart Growth. This planner may hold community listening session to learn more about the community's needs and wants. One way to incorporate Smart Growth principles, including the creation of a more walkable community, is to look on the table for resources that are checked ('V") with the Smart Growth indicator. These resources are located throughout the entire document and are easy to locate when following the Smart Growth column on the tables. Additionally, a community member could use this document to learn more about the laws, regulations, and ordinances that pertain to his or her community. For example, an individual living in Hartford, Connecticut would learn that there are several Federal resources (pages 13-15), four resources from the state of Connecticut (page 18), and one resource specifically about the City of Hartford (page 25). HOW THIS DOCUMENT IS ORGANIZED The document presents information in a table that identifies the name of each resource and where to find it, as well as a short description of the information provided by each resource. To make it easier to find specific resources, it is organized into the following categories: 1. Academic Resources (Articles and Books) Pages 7-12 Organized in reverse chronological order, the resources in this section are published journal articles and books that cover a variety of environmental justice and land use topics. Some examples in this section outline specific opportunities for land use decision-makers on how to best incorporate environmental justice. Other resources in this section discuss the history of various environmental justice issues in communities and the changes that have occurred. 2. Federal Resources (Federal Executive Orders, Legislation and Other Resources) Pages 13-15 Organized in chronological order by executive order, legislation and other resources, this section contains Presidential policy directives (specifically Executive Order 12898), the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) that was signed into law on January 1,1970 and EPA products. The EPA resources range from large, Agency-wide environmental justice planning (Plan EJ 2014) to guidance, memorandums and tools to examine environmental concerns in a community. These resources are useful for understanding the larger environmental justice picture. 3. State Resources (State Executive Orders, Legislation and Other Resources) Pages 15-25 Organized by state, this section includes environmental justice executive orders that were signed by state governors, state laws and codes covering a variety of topics under land use ------- planning and public participation, policies, plans, websites and other planning documents. The other resources provide examples of environmental justice and land use planning practices. 4. Local Resources (Local Ordinances and Resources) Pages 25-26 Organized alphabetically, this section contains laws found within municipality codes, and resources created and implemented at the local/municipal level of government These resources range from information on environmental justice ordinances to alliances and networks promoting environmental justice among various parties. The table also indicates to which of the following six informational topics each resource relates: 1. Environmental Justice 101 The history of environmental justice; federal, state, and local laws and ordinances that discuss environmental justice on a broad level; and community-based research and information pertaining to environmental justice. 2. Environmental Justice and Land Use: Making the Connection Examples of incorporating environmental justice into land use planning; state and local laws and ordinances that discuss environmental justice and land use partnering; and other information related to the collaboration of ideas. 3. Engaging the Community Information about public participation and how communities can be involved in the land use planning process. 4. Smart Growth Information related specifically to smart growth and its 10 basic principles: 1) Mix land uses; 2) Take advantage of compact building design; 3) Create a range of housing opportunities and choices; 4) Create walkable neighborhoods; 5) Foster distinctive, attractive communities with a strong sense of place; 6) Preserve open space, farmland, natural beauty and critical environmental areas; 7) Strengthen and direct development towards existing communities; 8) Provide a variety of transportation choices; 9) Make development decisions predictable, fair and cost effective; and 10) Encourage community and stakeholder collaboration in development decisions. 5. Case Studies Historic environmental justice cases and/or lessons learned from examples of environmental justice being incorporated into decision-making and land use planning. 6. Policy/Legislation Summaries of or direct links to federal, state or local environmental and/or environmental justice laws (i.e., statute enacted by legislature), regulations (i.e., directive made and maintained to implement the authority of laws), and policies (i.e., system of laws, regulatory measures, courses of action, and funding priorities intended to accomplish certain goals). In addition, recurrent environmental justice and land use themes appear across the resource categories and informational topics highlighted in the guide. Each theme has a corresponding code represented in parentheses below. If applicable, the resources in the tables starting on page 6 will contain these theme codes at the end of the citation. • Activism (ACT) - The act of campaigning to promote, impede or direct social or environmental change. • Air (AIR) - Environmental impacts and health burdens due to poor air quality resulting from close proximity to an environmental hazard. ------- • Buffering (BU) - A sufficient zone (e.g., geographic area) or structure (e.g., sounds walls) between a facilities and a community to protect the public from pollutants (e.g., noise, air, water, land). • Community Benefit Agreement (CBA) - A legally binding contract negotiated between a developer and a coalition representing a broad spectrum of community members impacted by the development In exchange for community members' support for the project, the developer agrees to provide certain benefits (e.g., funding for affordable housing and open space). • Demographics (DEM) - Socioeconomic characteristics of a population expressed statistically, such as age, sex, race, national origin, education level, income level, etc. • Goods Movement (GM) - Environmental pollution associated with the transportation of freight (e.g., seaports, airports, railways, truck lanes, logistics centers, border crossings). • Hazardous Waste Facilities (HWF) - Facilities that treat, store, recycle, incinerate or transfer hazardous wastes from at least two producers of hazardous wastes. • Illegal/Open Dumps (I/OD) - The improper disposal of any waste including household trash, tires, barrels, demolition/construction waste, appliances, metal or any material that will rust, rotor burn. • Industry (IND) - Environmental and health burdens on a community associated with the zoning and operation of industrial facilities. • Meaningful Involvement/Decision-Making (MI/DM) - Provides the opportunity for: people to participate in decisions about activities that may affect their environment and/or health; the public's contribution to influence the regulatory agency's decision; consideration of the public's concerns in the decision-making process; and decision makers to seek out and facilitate the involvement of those potentially affected. • NEPA (NEPA) - The National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) established U.S. policy promoting the enhancement of the environment and also established the President's Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ). • Public Equality (PE) - Equal access to public goods and services as it relates to environmental justice and land use planning. • Public Health (PH) - The health impacts to a community attributed to environmental pollution. • Public Outreach (PO) - The act of providing information and/or services to populations that might not otherwise have access to the information/services. • Siting and Permitting (SP) - The process of selecting a location and receiving the authority to construct and build a new facility. • Solid Waste Facilities (SWF) - Structures or systems designed for the collection, processing or disposal of solid wastes, including hazardous wastes, and includes transfer stations, processing plants, recycling plants and disposal systems. • Title VI (T6) - Actions related to Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color or national origin in any program or activity receiving federal financial assistance. In order to read the full content of the resource, click on the hyperlink or copy and paste the citation into an Internet search engine. The majority of the resources listed below include hyperlinks; however, there are several resources that are not available online. Working Together for Environmental Justice ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning Academic Resources (Articles and Books) Organized in chronological order, starting with the most recent document. David W. Case, The Role of Information in Environmental Justice, Mississippi Law Journal, Volume 81:4 (2012). Surveys important developments in the generation, use and promotion of public access to information relevant to such efforts. MI/DM Robert D. Bullard, et al.. Environmental Health and Racial Equity: Building Environmentally Just, Sustainable, and Livable Communities, Environmental Justice Resource Center (2011). An account of events, individuals and organizations that have shaped the environmental justice movement over the past two decades. Patricia E. Salkin, Environmental Justice and Land Use Planning, American Planning Association f20101. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm7abstract id=1827195 Explores opportunities for members of planning and zoning boards, professional planning staff and local elected officials to incorporate environmental justice principles into land use decision-making. Tonya R. Lewis, The Plenary Power of States to Protect Citizens from Environmental Hazards: Who's Failing? New York State: A Case in Point, 17 Buffalo Environmental Law lournal 43 f2009-101. http://wings.buffalo.edu/law/beli/archive.htmttl7 Accentuates the current and pressing evolution of the state's role in ensuring that all humans attain the ubiquitous right to clean air, water and land. Robert D. Bullard et. al.. Toxic Wastes and Race at Twenty: Why Race Still Matters After All of These Years, 38 Environmental Law 371 (2008). http://www.sph.umich.edu/svmposium/2010/pdf/bullardl.pdf This report commemorates and updates the 1987 landmark report Toxic Wastes and Race in the United States and takes stock of progress achieved over the last 20 years. Robert W. Collin, Environmental Justice in Oregon: It's the Law, 38 Environmental Law 413 f20081. http://ulpdx.pbworks.eom/f/EI Oregon law 2008.pdf As states grapple with new policy approaches and processes to begin resolution of environmental injustices, the issues, approaches and observations from the first of state level environmental justice task forces and commissions can inform all stakeholders of their efficacy. Michael Gerrard & Sheila Foster, The Law of Environmental Justice: Theories and Procedures to Address Disproportionate Risk, 2nd Edition, American Bar Association (2008). http://books.google.com/books/about/The Law of Environmental Iustice.html?id=ZY- GOnNPIDgC Comprehensively examines the sources of environmental justice law and how evolving regulations and important court decisions impact projects around the country. Patricia E. Salkin & Amy Lavine, Negotiating for Social Justice and the Promise of Community Benefits Agreements: Case Studies of Current and Developing Agreements, 17 Journal of Affordable Housing & Community Development Law 113 (2008). http://digitalcommons.tourolaw.edu/ cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1519&context=scholarlvworks Details community benefit agreements and discusses benefits that the developer will provide to the community in exchange for the community's support, or quiet acquiescence, of its proposed development. CBA Patricia E. Salkin & Amy Lavine, Understanding Community Benefits Agreements: Equitable Development, Social Justice and Other Considerations for Developers, Municipalities and Community Organizations, 26 UCLA Journal of Environmental Law & Policy 291 (2008). http://digitalcommons.tourolaw.edu/ cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1522&context=scholarlvworks Provides a history and context of community benefit agreements and discusses how they allow community groups to address a multitude of impacts and opportunities that they host community may not have legal authority or political will to discuss otherwise. CBA Environmental Justice 101 v' v' v' •/ v' •/ •/ v' Environmental Justice and Land Use: Making the Connection •/ Engaging the Community v' v' Smart Growth Case Studies v' v' v' v' v' v' Policy/Legislation v' v' v' v' ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning Academic Resources (Articles and Books) Organized in chronological order, starting with the most recent document. Patricia E. Salkin & Amy Lavine, Understanding Community Benefits Agreements, The Practical Real Estate Lawyer (July 2008). http://files.ali- aba.org/thumbs/datastorage/lacidoirep/articles/PREL0807-Salkin-Lavine thumb.pdf Describes how community benefit agreements have opportunities and traps for developers, municipalities and community organizations. CBA Tony Arnold, Planning for Environmental Justice, 59 Planning & Environmental Law 3 (2007). Explores how environmental justice and good land use planning are inseparably connected. Charles Lee, 1982 Warren County Protests: Environmental Justice Twenty-Five Years Later, 1 Golden Gate University of Environmental Law Journal 53 (2007). The 1982 protesters against the dumping of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) in Warren County, North Carolina had no idea of the momentous changes that were to come. Patricia E. Salkin, Understanding Community Benefit Agreements: Opportunities and Traps for Developers and Community Organizations, in Land Use Institute: Planning, Regulation, Litigation, Eminent Domain and Compensation, 1407 ALI-ABA (2007). http://community- wealth.org/content/understanding-communitv-benefit-agreements-opportunities-and-traps- developers-municipalities Describes how community benefit agreements specify the benefits that the developer will provide to the community in exchange for the community's support of its proposed development CBA Uma Outka, NEPA and Environmental Justice: Integration, Implementation, and Judicial Review, 33 Boston College Environmental Affairs Law Review 601 (2006). http://lawdigitalcommons.bc.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1101&context=ealr Although the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) provides the structure for federal environmental decision-making, is it effective as a tool for addressing environmental justice? NEPA Patricia E. Salkin, Intersection Between Environmental Justice and Land Use Planning, 56 Planning & Environmental Law 5-7 (2006). http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm7abstract id=1029861 Environmental justice goes to the core of traditional land use decisions: choosing sites for locally unwanted land uses; the process for deciding where to site these unwanted land uses, including the location and timing of public hearings; and sociological factors, including which groups hold the political power inherent in land use decisions. CBA Robert D. Bullard, The Quest for Environmental Justice: Human Rights and the Politics of Pollution. Sierra Club Books (2005). http://www.worldcat.org/title/quest-for-environmental- iustice-human-rights-and-the-politics-of-pollution/oclc/57201640 A collection of essays that capture the voices of those who are battling environmental injustice and human rights abuses at the grassroots level around the world and challenging government and industry policies and globalization trends that place people of color and the poor atspecial risk. Suellen T. Reiner, The Next Frontier: Land-Use Planning and Environmental Justice, in Current Trends & Practical Strategies in Land Use Law & Zoning, ABA-TPSLUZ Chapter 6 f20051. http://www.worldcat.org/title/current-trends-and-practical-strategies-in-land-use-law- and-zoning/oclc/123907385 A compilation of significant trends in land use law, featuring landmark court decisions from the U.S. Supreme Court, federal district courts and state high courts. Patricia E. Salkin, Environmental Justice and Land Use Planning and Zoning, 32 Real Estate Law Journal 429 (2004). http://www.albanvlaw.edu/glc/publications/glo/Documents/Environmental%20Iustice%20and %20Land%20Use%20Planning%20and%20Zoning.pdf Analysis of the importance of local land use laws to achieve sustainability, and how environmental justice goes to the core of traditional land use decisions. Environmental Justice 101 v' •/ •/ v' •/ v' •/ •/ Environmental Justice and Land Use: Making the Connection v' •/ •/ •/ Engaging the Community v' v' v' v' v' Smart Growth v' Case Studies v' v' v' v' v' v' Policy/Legislation v' v' v' v' ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning Academic Resources (Articles and Books) Organized in chronological order, starting with the most recent document. Eileen Gauna & Sheila Foster, Environmental Justice: Stakes, Stakeholders, Strategies, 30 Human Rights Magazine 4 (2003). http://www.americanbar.org/publications/human rights magazine home/human rights volSO 2003/fall2003/irr hr fall03 stakes.html Explores the U.S. environmental justice movement and how it was propelled into mainstream political discourse and popular consciousness by grassroots activism. ACT Sten-Erik Hoidal, Returning to the Roots of Environmental Justice: Lessons from the Inequitable Distribution of Municipal Services, 88 Minnesota Law Review 193 (2003). Provides a review of several environmental justice court decisions. Linda Breggin, A Citizen's Guide to Using Federal Environmental Laws to Secure Environmental Justice, Environmental Law Institute (2002). http://www.eli.org/research- report/citizens-guide-using-federal-environmental-laws-secure-environmental-iustice This handbook highlights sections of environmental laws that can be used to support and help advance environmental justice goals. Juliana Maantay, Zoning Law, Health, and Environmental Justice: What's the connection?, 4 Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 572 (2002). http://www.lehman.cunv.edu/deannss/geographv/publications/ILME Maantav.pdf Explores the relationship between land use laws and environmental equity, and the implications of these laws for public health. PH Sarah J. Farhat, Environmental Racism: The PIBBY Principle, 33 McGeorge Law Review, 295 (2002). Defines "environmental justice," reviews the background of the movement, and examines the existing law at the federal and state levels of government and observes that there is no such existing law at the local level. Sara Pirk, Expanding Public Participation in Environmental Justice: Methods, Legislation, Litigation and Beyond, 17 Journal of Environmental Law & Litigation 207 (2002). http://www.temple.edu/lawschool/iilpp/EnvironmentalRoundtableResearchDocs/Pirk%20- %20Expanding.pdf Explores how citizens of communities of color and low socioeconomic status can get involved in solving environmental problems in their neighborhoods for an equal voice in decision-making. DEM, MI/DM Clifford Rechtschaffen & Eileen Gauna, Environmental Justice: Law, Policy and Regulation, Carolina Academic Press (2002). http://www.cap-press.com/pdf/1181.pdf Provides students with a comprehensive introduction to environmental justice, whether or not they have prior background in environmental law. Tessa Meyer Santiago, An Ounce of Prevention is Worth a Pound of Cure: State Preemption of Local Siting Authority as a Means for Achieving Environmental Equity, 2 1 Virginia Environmental Law Journal 71 (2002). http://www.veli.org/an-ounce-of-preemption.html Explores how environmental racism exists where communities of color are made to bear a disproportionate burden of a siting decision and how preventing undesirable land uses in minority neighborhoods through judicial remedies is an uphill challenge. Toby Bernstein, Opportunities for Advancing Environmental Justice: An Analysis of U.S. EPA Statutory Authorities, Environmental Law Institute (2001). http://www.eli.org/research- report/opportunities-advancing-environmental-iustice-analvsis-us-epa-statutorv-authorities Analyzes EPA's jurisdiction over many core environmental justice issues, especially the prevention and control of industrial pollution. IND Michael B. Gerrard, "Environmental Justice and Local Land Use Decision-making," in Trends in Land Use Law from A to Z: Adult Uses to Zoning, Patricia E. Salkin, Edition, American Bar Association (2001). Examines the effects of zoning laws on environmental justice and local land use decisions that affect the community's environment. Environmental Justice 101 •/ v' •/ v' v' •/ v' Environmental Justice and Land Use: Making the Connection •/ •/ v' •/ v' Engaging the Community v' Smart Growth Case Studies v' v' v' v' Policy/Legislation v' v' v' v' v' v' ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning Academic Resources (Articles and Books) Organized in chronological order, starting with the most recent document. Paul M. Hendrick, Racism in American Land Use Decisions: The Slicing of the American Pie, 2 Florida Costal Law Journal 395 (2001). http://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?collection=iournals&handle=hein.iournals/fdi2&div=5 2&id=&page Explores the subtle legacy of racism that persists in American land use planning and environmental regulatory decisions. Craig Anthony Arnold, Land Use Regulation and Environmental Justice, 30 ELR 10395 (2000). http://elr.info/news-analvsis/30/10395/land-use-regulation-and-environmental-iustice Explores the relationship between environmental justice and land use regulation and planning — a relationship thatlawyers, scholars, judges and policymakers must increasingly understand. Matthew B. Leveridge, Should Environmental Justice be a National Concern? A Review and Analysis of Environmental Justice Theories and Remedies, 15 Journal of Natural Resources & Environmental Law 107 (1999-2000). http://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?collection=iournals&handle=hein.iournals/inatrenvll5 &div=10&id=&page Analyzes arguments presented by the different studies of environmental justice theories and remedies. Robert D. Bullard, Leveling the Playing Field through Environmental Justice, 23 Vermont Law Review 453 (1999). https://litigation- essentials.lexisnexis.com/webcd/app?action=DocumentDisplav&crawlid=l&doctype=dte&docid =23+Vt.+L.+Rev.+453&srctvpe=smi&srcid=3B15&kev=c589fc305348a7af3913750c35afla3b Explores the current environmental protection model and offers an alternative framework for addressing environmental inequities, disparate impacts and unequal protection. Jimmy White, Environmental Justice: Is Disparate Impact Enough? 50 Mercer Law Review 1155 (1999). https://litigation- essentials.lexisnexis.com/webcd/app?action=DocumentDisplavSi.crawlid=lSi.doctvpe=citeSi.docid=5 0+Mercer+L.+Rev.+1155&srctvpe=smi&srcid=3B15&kev=ld9cc02f82e7316fa21681fle97d033c Examines how lack of resources, political power and practical knowledge have proven all too often to be insurmountable obstacles to the resolution of conflicts over the siting of hazardous waste producers or handlers. HWF Craig Anthony Arnold, Planning Milagros: Environmental Justice and Land Use Regulation, 76 Denver U.L.R.1 C1998"). http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm7abstract id=1040501 Documents the disproportionately higher amount of industrial and other non-residential land uses in census tracts where low-income people of color live, based on a study of 31 census tracts in seven cities nationwide. IND,DEM Christopher Billias, Environmental Racism and Hazardous Facility Siting Decisions: Noble Cause of Political Tool? 4 Race & Ethnic Ancestry Law Journal 36 (1998). http://scholarlvcommons.law. wlu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1059&context=crsi Analyzes the development of environmental racism by surveying scientific studies dealing with this issue and examines the actions taken by the executive and legislative branches in response to environmental racism. HWF Sheila Foster, Justice from the Ground Up: Distributive Inequities, Grassroots Resistance, and the Transformative Politics of the Environmental Justice Movement, 86 California Law Review 775 (1998). http://scholarship.law.berkelev.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1579Si.context=californialawrev lew Examines the environmental justice movement from the "ground up," from the perspective of the predominantly poor, African-American residents of Chester, Pennsylvania, who attempted to stop the clustering of waste facilities in their community. HWF Environmental Justice 101 •/ v' v' •/ •/ Environmental Justice and Land Use: Making the Connection •/ v' •/ •/ Engaging the Community v' Smart Growth Case Studies v' v' v' Policy/Legislation v' v' v' v' v' v' 10 ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning Academic Resources (Articles and Books) Organized in chronological order, starting with the most recent document. Stephen M. Johnson, NEPA and SEPA's in the Quest for Environmental Justice, 30 Loyola of Los Angeles Law Review 565 (1997). http://digitalcommons.lmu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2027&context=llr Examines how strong state environmental policy acts [SEPAs] and a strong National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) are necessary to address environmental justice concerns on a national scale effectively. NEPA Alice Kaswan, Environmental Justice: Bridging the Gap Between Environmental Laws and "Justice," 47 American University Law Review 221 (1997). http://www.wcl.american.edu/iournal/lawrev/47/kaswan.pdf Takes a step toward bridging the gap between environmental laws and justice by exploring some of the conditions under which environmental laws can contribute to social and political debates about fair treatment. Daniel Kevin, "Environmental Racism" and Locally Undesirable Land Uses: A Critique of Environmental Justice Theories and Remedies, 8 Villanova Environmental Law Journal 121 C1997"). http://digitalcommons.law.villanova.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1199&context=eli Critically examines some of the major assumptions underlying environmental justice by addressing the impact, or lack thereof, on minorities. DEM Robert Bullard, Unequal Protection: Environmental Justice and Communities of Color, 2nd Edition, Sierra Club Books (1996). http://books.google.com/books/about/Unequal Protection.html?id=Kp4NAAAAYAAI Through case studies, shows how environmental laws have been inconsistently applied, so that people of color suffer disproportionately from public health hazards, and documents the strategies and struggles of grassroots groups now building coalitions among community activists and traditional environmentalists. ACT Rodger C. Field, Siting, Justice and the Environmental Laws, 16 Northern Illinois University Law Review 639 (1996). https://litigation- essentials.lexisnexis.com/webcd/app?action=DocumentDisplavSi.crawlid=lSi.doctvpe=citeSi.docid =16+N.+Ill.+U.+L.+Rev.+639&srctvpe=smi&srcid=3B15&kev=9511a97ad6aadd497b8b689dc3f76 528 Reviews the issue of environmental justice, the government's response, and its implications for industrial development. IND Benjamin A. Goldman & Laura Fitton, Toxic Wastes and Race Revisited (1994). http://www.worldcat.org/title/toxic-wastes-and-race-revisited-an-update-of-the-1987-report- on-the-racial-and-socioeconomic-characteristics-of-communities-with-hazardous-waste- sites/oclc/301710871 An update of the 1987reporton the racial and socioeconomic characteristics of communities with hazardous waste sites. DEM, HWF R.D. Bullard ed.. Confronting Environmental Racism: Voices From the Grassroots, South End Press (1993). http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/773307.Confronting Environmental Racism Describes how people of color in urban and rural areas are the most likely victims of industrial dumping, toxic landfills, uranium mining and dangerous waste incinerators. DEM, HWF, I/OD Vicki Been, What's Fairness Got to do With It? Environmental Justice and the Siting of Locally Undesirable Land Uses, 78 Cornell Law Review 1001 (1993). http://www.temple.edu/lawschool/iilpp/EnvironmentalRoundtableResearchDocs/Been%20- %20Whats%20Fairness.pdf Details how policymakers and local land use officials struggle to cope with the "not in my backyard" syndrome in attempting to site locally undesirable land uses, such as homeless shelters, drug or alcohol treatment centers and waste disposal facilities. Environmental Justice 101 v' v' •/ •/ v' v' Environmental Justice and Land Use: Making the Connection v' •/ •/ Engaging the Community v' v' Smart Growth Case Studies v' v' v' v' Policy/Legislation v' v' v' v' v' 11 ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning Academic Resources (Articles and Books) Organized in chronological order, starting with the most recent document. Robert D. Bullard, Race and Environmental Justice in the United States, 18 Yale Journal of International Law 319 C1993"). http://vale.edu/glc/aces2/18YaleIIntlL319.pdf Analyzes the causes and impacts of environmental inequities in the United States by examining the links between institutional racism and ecological disparities, focusing on how institutional racism affects siting of hazardous waste facilities, and surveying the efforts of communities to achieve environmental justice. HWF Michael R. Greenberg, Proving Environmental Inequity in Siting Locally Unwanted Land Uses, 4 Risk: Issues in Health & Safety 235 (1993). http://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?collection=iournals&handle=hein.iournals/risk4&div=2 5&id=&page Reviews how locally unwanted land uses (LULUs) cause tension and political conflict. Dollie Burwell, Reminiscences from Warren County, in Proceedings of the First National People of Color Environmental Leadership Summit, Charles Lee Edition. (1992). Documents the demonstration and protests in Warren County, North Carolina, one of the first cases of environmental justice in the United States and set a precedent for other environmental justice cases. Robert D. Bullard, Dumping in Dixie: Race, Class and Environmental Quality, Westview Press f 1990"). http://www.ciesin.columbia.edu/docs/010-278/010-278chpt2.html Explores the environment-development dialectic conflict and residual impact of the industrial policy (i.e., "any job is better than no job") on the Southeastern United States' ecology. DEM United Church of Christ Commission for Racial Justice, Toxic Wastes and Race in the United States: A National Study on the Racial and Socioeconomic Characteristics of Communities Surrounding Hazardous Waste Sites (1987). http://www.ucc.org/about-us/archives/pdfs/toxwrace87.pdf The first national report to comprehensively document the presence of hazardous wastes in racial and ethnic communities throughout the United States. DEM, HWF U.S. General Accounting Office, Siting of Hazardous Waste Landfills and their Correlation with Racial and Economic Status of Surrounding Communities, app. I at 9 (1983). http://archive.gao.gov/d48tl3/121648.pdf Provides information on the racial and economic characteristics of communities surrounding four hazardous waste landfills in three southeastern states. DEM Environmental Justice 101 - - ' v' Environmental Justice and Land Use: Making the Connection v' Engaging the Community Smart Growth Case Studies ' - ' - - Policy/Legislation 12 ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Federal Resources Federal Executive Orders, Legislation and Resources Organized by executive order and memorandums, legislation and other resources. Federal Executive Orders and Memorandums Executive Order No. 12898, Federal Actions to Address Environmental Justice in Minority Populations and Low-Income Populations (February 11, 1994), 3 C.F.R. 859 (1995). http://www.epa.gov/region2/ei/exec order 12898.pdf Outlines federal agency responsibilities for addressing environmental justice. Memorandum on Environmental Justice by William J. Clinton (February 11, 1994) http://www.presidencv.ucsb.edu/ws/index.php?pid=49639&st=&stl Details the scope and intent of Presidential Executive Order 12898. Memorandum of Understanding on Environmental Justice and Executive Order 12898 (August 2011) http://epa.gov/environmentaliustice/resources/publications/interagency/ei-mou-2011-08.pdf Declares the continued importance of Executive Order 12898, renews the process, establishes structures and procedures, and identifies particular areas of focus to be included in Agency environmental justice efforts. ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ Federal Legislation National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 §102, 42 U.S.C. §4332 (2000). http://www.epw.senate.gov/nepa69.pdf Established the Council on Environmental Quality. Federal decision-makers must consider environmental effects of federal actions, and give the affected community a chance to comment on the process. ^ ^ Federal Resources U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Plan EJ (2014). http://www.epa.gov/compliance/environmentaliustice/plan-ei/index.html Roadmapfor addressing environmental justice concerns in federal government. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Creating Equitable, Healthy, and Sustainable Communities: Strategies for Advancing Smart Growth, Environmental Justice, and Equitable Development (2013). http://www.epa.gov/smartgrowth/pdf/equitable- dev/equitable-development-report-508-011713b.pdf Builds on past successes and offers approaches to shape development that responds to the needs and reflects the values of other low-income, minority, tribal and overburdened communities. DEM U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, EJView. http://epamapl4.epa.gov/eimap/entry.html Mapping tool allows user to screen for potential environmental justice concerns based on multiple factors affecting a community. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Title VI Public Involvement Guidance for EPA Assistance Recipients Administering Environmental Permitting Programs (2006). http://www.gpo.gov/fdsvs/pkg/FR-2006-03-21/html/06-2691.htm Discusses approaches and suggests tools recipients may use to help enhance the public involvement aspects of their permitting programs and address potential issues related to Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. T6 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of the Inspector General, EPA Needs to Conduct Environmental Justice Reviews of its Programs, Policies and Activities (2006). http://www.epa.gov/oig/reports/2006/20060918-2006-P-00034.pdf Office of the Inspector General [OIG) report that shows that EPA senior management have not sufficiently directed program and regional offices to conduct environment justice reviews in accordance with Executive Order 12898. U.S. Government Accountability Office, Environmental Justice: EPA Should Devote More Attention to Environmental Justice When Developing Clean Air Rules (2005). http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d05289.pdf Government Accountability Office [GAO) report that shows when drafting the three clean air rules, EPA devoted insufficient attention to environmental justice. AIR ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ 13 ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Federal Resources Federal Executive Orders, Legislation and Resources Organized by executive order and memorandums, legislation and other resources. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of the Inspector General, EPA Needs to Consistently Implement the Intent of the Executive Order on Environmental Justice Report Number 2004-P-00007 (2004). http://www.epa.gov/oig/reports/2004/20040301-2004-P-00007.pdf Details that EPA has not fully implemented Executive Order 12898 and provided recommended corrective actions. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Guidance to Environmental Protection Agency Financial Assistance Recipients Regarding Title VI Prohibition Against National Origin Discrimination Affecting Limited English Proficient Persons (2004). http://www.gpo.gov/fdsvs/granule/FR-2004-06-25/04-14464/content-detail.html Provides a general framework that EPA-assisted programs and activities may use to provide meaningful access to limited English proficient persons. T6 U.S. Commission on Civil Rights, Not in My Backyard: Executive Order 12898 and Title VI as Tools for Achieving Environmental Justice (2003). http://www.usccr.gov/pubs/enviust/ej0104.pdf Reveals some of the success in implementing Executive Order 12898 and the principles of environmental justice, and details the problems and shortcomings that remain. T6 National Academy Of Public Administration, Addressing Community Concerns: How Environmental Justice Relates to Land Use Planning and Zoning (2003). http://www.epa.gov/compliance/ei/resources/reports/annual-proiect-reports/napa-land-use- zoning-63003.pdf Examines the roles of federal, state and local governments in responding to public concerns about environmental justice issues. National Environmental Justice Advisory Council, Integration of Environmental Justice in Federal Agency Programs (2002). http://www.epa.gov/compliance/ei/resources/publications/neiac/integration-ei-federal- programs-030102.pdf Provides advice and recommendations on federal government efforts toward integrating environmental justice into agency policies, programs and activities consistent with the existing laws and Executive Order 12898. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Draft Title VI Guidance for EPA Assistance Recipients Administering Environmental Permitting Programs and Draft Revised Guidance for Investigating Title VI Administrative Complaints Challenging Permits (2000). http://www.epa.gov/civilrights/docs/frn t6 pub06272000.pdf Title VI guidance that strikes a balance between EPA's strong commitment to civil rights enforcement and the practical aspects of operating permitting programs. T6 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, General Counsel Memorandum, EPA Statutory and Regulatory Authorities Under Which Environmental Justice Issues May Be Addressed in Permitting (2000). http://www.epa.gov/environmentaliustice/resources/policv/ei permitting authorities memo 1 20100.pdf Analyzes a number of statutory and regulatory authorities under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act [RCRA); the Clean Water Act [CWA); the Safe Drinking Water Act [SDWA); the Marine Protection, Research, and Sanctuaries Act; and the Clean Air Act [CAA) that the Office of General Counsel (OGC) believes are available to address environmental justice issues during permitting. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Final Guidance for Incorporating Environmental Justice in EPA's NEPA Compliance Analysis (1998). http://www.epa.gov/compliance/environmentaliustice/resources/policv/ei guidance nepa epa Guidance intended to improve the internal management of EPA with respect to environmental justice under. NEPA •/ v' v' ^ ^ v' v' v' v' v' 14 ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Federal Resources Federal Executive Orders, Legislation and Resources Organized by executive order and memorandums, legislation and other resources. Executive Office of the President, Council on Environmental Quality, Environmental Justice: Guidance Under the National Environmental Policy Act (December 10, 1997). http://www.epa.gov/compliance/ei/resources/policv/ei guidance nepa ceql297.pdf Reviews the guidance that assists federal agencies with their NEPA procedures so that environmental justice concerns are effectively identified and addressed. NEPA U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Environmental Equity: Reducing Risks for All Communities C1992"). http://www.epa.gov/environmentaliustice/resources/reports/annual- proiect-reports/reducing risk com voll.pdf Provides a summary and recommendations for EPA action on environmental equity issues. U.S. General Accounting Office, Siting of Hazardous Waste Landfills and their Correlation with Racial and Economic Status of Surrounding Communities (1982). http://archive.gao.gov/d48tl3/121648.pdf Provides information on the racial and economic characteristics of communities surrounding four hazardous waste landfills in three southeastern states. DEM, HWF ^ v' ^ ^ Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning State Resources State Executive Orders, Legislation, and Resources Organized alphabetically by state. University of California Hastings College of Law, Environmental Justice for All: A Fifty-State Survey of Legislation, Policies, and Initiatives, 4th Edition (February 15, 2010). http://gov.uchastings.edu/public-law/docs/eireport-fourthedition.pdf Comprehensive survey of state environmental justice laws, policies and cases prepared by the University of California - Hastings College of the Law and the American Bar Association. ALABAMA Executive Order No. 26, Alabama Commission on Environmental Initiatives (April 26, 2000). http://www.isu.edu/depart/epic/executiveorder26.html Established the Alabama Commission on Environmental Initiatives to develop quality options to encourage the long-term protection of Alabama's natural environment and public health. PH Alabama Code § 22-30-5. l(c) (d) Restriction on Number of Commercial Hazardous Waste Treatment Facilities or Disposal Sites per County; Legislative Approval of Sites (2005). http://codes.lp.findlaw.eom/alcode/22/l/30/22-30-5.l Addresses the siting of commercial hazardous waste treatment facilities or disposal sites. HWF Alabama Code § 22-30-12(g) Permit Program (2005). http://codes.lp.findlaw.eom/alcode/22/l/30/22-30-12 Addresses the public notice requirements for permit applications for a hazardous waste treatment, storage or disposal facility. HWF Alabama Code § 22-22A-6 Environmental Management Commission (2005). http://codes.lp.findlaw.eom/alcode/22/l/22A/22-22A-6 Creates and details the responsibilities of a seven member Environmental Management Commission of the Alabama Department of Environmental Management. v' •/ V v' v' / V v' V / V 15 ------- Alabama Department of Transportation, Statewide Transportation Plan Update. http://cpmsweb2.dot.state.al.us/TransPlan/SWTP/Docs/ALDOTSWTPFINAL.pdf Presents long-range, multimodal assessments of the state's transportation program. CM v' ALASKA Alaska Department of Transportation and Public Facilities, Civil Rights Office: Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and Environmental Justice. http://www.dot.alaska.gov/cvlrts/titlevi.shtml Website that provides information and links to environmental justice resources. T6 •/ v' ARIZONA Arizona Revised Statute § 9-461.05(e) General Plans (1996). http://www.azleg.state.az.us/FormatDocument.asp?inDoc=/ars/9/00461- Q5.htm&Title=9&DocType=ARS Addresses policies for maintaining a broad variety of land uses. Arizona Department of Environmental Quality (ADEQ), Environmental Permits and Approvals Near Learning Sites. http://www.azdeq.gOV/ceh/download/050713-1103.0.pdf Establishes a procedure for reviewing permit applications and requesting plan approval for operations which may impact learning sites to ensure that the protection of children at learning sites is considered before a permit or plan approval is issued by ADEQ. SP •/ v' v' v' ARKANSAS Arkansas Code Annotated § 8-6-1501, Legislative intent (2008). http://law.iustia.com/codes/arkansas/2010/title-8/chapter-6/subchapter-15/8-6-1501 Comprehensive and regionalized approach to solid waste management. SWF Arkansas Code Annotated § 8-6-1504, Presumption against certain sites (2008). http://law.iustia.com/codes/arkansas/2010/title-8/chapter-6/subchapter-15/8-6-1504 Addresses the permitting of the construction or operation of any high-impact solid waste management facility. SWF v' v' v' CALIFORNIA California Government Code § 65040 http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displavcode?section=gov&group=65001-66000&file=65040- 65040.14 Establishes that the Office of Planning and Research will serve the Governor and Cabinet as staff for long-range planning and research, and constitute the comprehensive state planning agency. California Public Resources Code § 71301 http://law.onecle.com/california/public-resources/71301.html Addresses the development of environmental educational principles for elementary and secondary school pupils. California Public Resources Code § 44004 http://law.onecle.com/california/public-resources/44004.html Addresses the permit process for existing and new solid waste facilities. SWF California Health and Safety Code §§ 25400.10-25400.4 http://ca.regstodav.com/law/hsc/ca.regstodav.com/laws/hsc/calaw- hsc DIVISION20 CHAPTER6p9pl.aspx Addresses the requirements for the cleanup of hazardous chemicals. HWF Senate Bill 375, 2007-2008 Session (California 2007). http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/pub/07-08/bill/sen/sb 0351- 0400/sb 375 bill 20080822 amended asm v87.html Addresses the requirements for transportation planning activities. CM v' v' v' v' v' v' 16 ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning State Resources State Executive Orders, Legislation, and Resources Organized alphabetically by state. Assembly Bill 2843, 2005-2006 Session (California 2006). http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/pub/05-06/bill/asm/ab 2801- 2850/ab 2843 bill 20060929 chaptered.pdf Addresses the California Health and Safety code as it relates to communities of minority or low- income populations. PH, DEM California Governor's Office of Planning & Resources (OPR), Environmental Justice in State Government (October 2003). http://opr.ca.gov/docs/OPR El Report Oct2003.pdf Provides a brief history of environmental justice, reports on the status ofOPR's efforts, and provides an outline of environmental justice findings, goals and policies for future environmental justice efforts within state government. California Environmental Protection Agency, Environmental Justice Program Home Page. http://www.calepa.ca.gov/Envlustice California EPA website that details the agency's environmental justice policy and procedures. California Environmental Protection Agency, California Air Resources Board, Policies and Actions for Environmental Justice (2001). http://www.arb.ca.gov/ch/programs/ei/eipolicies.pdf Establishes a framework for incorporating environmental justice into the Air Resources Board's programs consistent with the directives of state law. AIR California Governor's Office of Planning & Resources, General Plan Guidelines. http://opr.ca.gov/docs/General Plan Guidelines 2003.pdf Serves as a valuable reference for cities and counties in the preparation of local general plans. California Department of Transportation, Environmental Handbook, Volume I: Guidance for Compliance. http://www.dot.ca.gov/ser/voll/voll.htm Outlines federal and state compliance and public participation. California Energy Commission, Environmental Justice Frequently Asked Questions. http://www.energv.ca.gov/public adviser/environmental justice faq.html Website that provides information and links to environmental justice resources. California Environmental Protection Agency, California Air Resources Board, Air Quality and Land Use Handbook: A Community Health Perspective (2005). http://www.arb.ca.gov/ch/handbook.pdf Guide to air quality and land use issues focused on community health. AIR California Land Use Planning Information Network, http://ceres.ca.gov/planning/ Links to all city and county zoning ordinances in the state. v' •/ •/ •/ v' •/ •/ v' v' v' v' v' v' v' v' v' COLORADO Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment and U.S. EPA Region 8, Colorado Environmental Performance Partnership Agreement (FY2011-2012). http://www.colorado.gov/cs/Satellite ?blobcol=urldata&blobheadernamel=Content- Disposition&blobheadername2=Content- Tvpe&blobheadervaluel=inline%3B+filename%3D%22Colorado+Environmental+Performance+ Partnership+Agreement.pdf%22&blobheadervalue2=application%2Fpdf&blobkev=id&blobtable =MungoBlobs&blobwhere=1251807390280&ssbinarv=true Documents the department's environmental program priorities and activities. Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment, Final Agency- Wide Supplemental Environmental Projects Policy, (Revised May 5, 2008). https://www.colorado.gov/pacific/sites/default/files/DEHS SEP DeptPolicv.pdf Details the policy that is an integral part of each environmental division's Enforcement and Compliance Assurance Policy and procedures. v' v' 17 ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning State Resources State Executive Orders, Legislation, and Resources Organized alphabetically by state. CONNECTICUT Connecticut Department of Energy & Environmental Protection, Environmental Equity Policy. http://www.ct.gov/dep/cwp/view.asp?a=2688&q=322376&depNav GID=1511 Details the policy that carries out its mission in a way that encourages the social and economic development of the state while preserving the natural environment and the life forms it supports. Connecticut Department of Energy & Environment, "The Environmental Equity Movement Fact Sheet" (January 2013) http://www.ct.gov/dep/cwp/view.asp?a=2709&q=324148&depNav GID=1643 Provides a summary of the policy and contact information for grantees. Connecticut Department of Energy & Environmental Protection, Environmental Justice. http://www.ct.gov/dep/cwp/view.asp?a=2688&q=322378&depNav GID=1511 Agency website dedicated to environmental justice policy and issues. Connecticut Department of Energy & Environmental Protection, User's Guide to Environmental Permits. http://www.ct.gov/dep/cwp/view.asp?a=2709&q=324232&depNav GID=1643 A series of fact sheets describing each of its permit programs to help permit applicants and others understand the environmental permitting process. •/ v' v' v' v' v' v' v' v' DELAWARE Delaware Department of Natural & Environmental Resources, South Wilmington Special Area Management Plan. http://www.dnrec.delaware.gov/coastal/Documents/WilmSAMP/WetlandFunctAssessFINAL.pdf A comprehensive plan for the revitalization of South Wilmington. Includes a focus on environmental justice and land use planning. •/ •/ v' v' DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA D.C. Municipal Regulations. Title 10. Comprehensive Plan. http://www.dcregs. dc.gov/ Gatewav/TitleHome.aspx?TitleNumber=10-A Details the comprehensive plan for the District of Columbia. District of Columbia, Advisory Neighborhood Commissions, http://anc.dc.gov/ Considers a wide range of policies and programs affecting D.C. neighborhoods, including traffic, parking, recreation, street improvements, liquor licenses, zoning, economic development, police protection, sanitation and trash collection, and the District's annual budget. District of Columbia, Office of Planning Revised Comprehensive Plan (2006). http://planning.dc.gov/DC/Planning/Across+the+Citv/Comprehensive+Plan A general policy document that provides overall guidance for future planning and development of the city. v' •/ •/ v' v' v' s FLORIDA Florida Revised Statute § 403.723(3) Siting of hazardous waste facilities. http://www.flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2012/403.723 Addresses the facilitation of the siting of proper hazardous waste storage facilities in each region and any additional storage, treatment, or disposal facilities. HWF, SP Florida Revised Statute § 376.78 Legislative intent. http://www.flsenate.gov/laws/statutes/2012/376.78 Addresses the reduction of public health and environmental hazards on existing commercial and industrial sites. PH •/ v' s GEORGIA Georgia Code Annotated § 12-8-25. (4) Sites in certain counties within one-half mile of adjoining county (2004). http://law.iustia.com/ codes/georgia/2010/title-12/chapter-8/e/part- 1/12-8-25 Addresses solid waste disposal facility in certain counties within one-half mile of adjoining county and encourages cooperation between various counties. SWF v' v' 18 ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning State Resources State Executive Orders, Legislation, and Resources Organized alphabetically by state. Georgia Code Annotated § 12-8-26(a). Public meetings on site selection; notice; decision f20041. http://statutes.laws.com/georgia/title-12/chapter-8/article-2/part-l/12-8-26 Addresses the public meeting and notification requirements for solid waste disposal facility site selection. SWF Georgia Regional Transportation Authority, Regional Transit Action Plan (June 30, 2003). http://www.grta.org/ Provides information regarding transit as it relates to environmental justice. CM v' v' v' HAWAII Oahu Metropolitan Planning Organization, What is OMPO? http://www.oahumpo.org/about-mpo/overview/ Responsible for coordinating transportation planning on Oahu. CM Oahu Metropolitan Planning Organization, Environmental Justice in the OMPO Planning Process: Defining Environmental Justice Populations (2004 update). http://www.oahumpo.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/T6-EI OahuMPO.pdf Details how the City of Oahu incorporated environmental justice in the OMPO planning process. SP •/ •/ v' v' IDAHO Idaho Code § 39-3613. Creation of Basin Advisory Groups (West 2009). http://www.legislature.idaho.gov/idstat/Title39/T39CH36SECT39-3613.htm Addresses the creation of basin advisory groups for each of the state's major river basins. Idaho Code § 39-3616. Duties of Each Watershed Advisory Group (West 2009). http://www.legislature.idaho.gov/idstat/Title39/T39CH36SECT39-3616.htm Outlines and details the responsibilities of the basin advisory groups. v' v' ILLINOIS Illinois Compiled Statute 5/22.1 5a. Open Dumping Cleanup Program (2006). http://www.ilga.gov/legislation/ilcs/fulltext.asp?DocName=041500050K22.15a Addresses and details the preventive or corrective action necessary or appropriate to end the threat to the environment and public health as it relates to open dumps. I/OD Illinois Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), "Environmental Justice Policy." http://www.epa.state.il.us/environmental-iustice/policv.html Details Illinois policy that promotes environmental equity in the administration of its programs to the extent it may do so legally and practicably. Illinois Department of Transportation, Community Impact Assessment Manual, Section 2.4. http://www.idot.illinois.gov/Assets/uploads/files/Doing-Business/Manuals-Guides-Si.- Handbooks/Highways/Design-and- Environment/Environment/CommunitvImpactAssessmentManual.pdf Presents information to be used in socioeconomic or community impact assessment, identify data sources, and aid in the evaluation of alternatives for transportation improvements. CM Illinois EPA, Illinois Removes Illegal Dumps, Brochure. http://www.epa.state.il.us/land/illegal-dumping/irid.html Details the Illinois illegal dump policy and provides information on how to report illegal dumps. I/OD •/ •/ •/ •/ v' v' v' v' INDIANA Indiana Department of Environmental Management (DEM), Environmental Justice Policy f20081. http://www.in.gov/idem/files/environmental justice policy A-008-OEA-08-P-R2.pdf Policy to ensure that Indiana DEM and staff treat all members of the public equally and fairly in the conduct of activities and decision-making processes within the agency's jurisdiction. MI/DM •/ •/ v' 19 ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning State Resources State Executive Orders, Legislation, and Resources Organized alphabetically by state. KENTUCKY Kentucky Revised Statute Annotated §§ 224.46-505, et seq. Legislative findings and statement of policy, http://law.iustia.com/codes/kentuckv/2011/224-46/224-46-505 Details the legislation for the regulated handling, treatment, transportation, storage and disposal of hazardous waste. CM Kentucky Transportation Cabinet, Kentucky Highway Design Manual, at HD-402. http://transportation.kv.gov/highwav-design/pages/highwav-design-manual.aspx Establishes uniformity in the interpretation and administration of laws, policies, regulations and procedures applicable to the operation of the Division of Highway Design. v' v' LOUISIANA Louisiana Revised Statute Annotated § 30:2011.2. Environmental Justice (West 2003). http://www.legis.state.la.us/lss/lss.asp?doc=87041 Outlines a study to examine the relationship between the emission of air pollutants and the discharge of wastes by facilities located in or near residential areas. SWF, AIR v' MAINE Maine Revised Statute, § 4324(3). Responsibility for Growth Management; Citizen Participation f20011. http://law.iustia.com/codes/maine/2012/title30a/chapterl87/section4324 Addresses citizen participation in the development of a growth management program, municipalities or multi-municipal regions may adopt growth management programs. MI/DM v' v' MARYLAND Executive Order Number 01.01.2001.01, "Commission on Environmental Justice and Sustainable Communities" (Mar. 9, 2001), reprinted in 28-7 Maryland Regulation 674 (Apr. 6, 2001"). http://www.dsd.state.md.us/co mar/ getfile.aspx?file=0 1.0 1.200 1.0 l.htm Establishes a Commission on Environmental Justice and Sustainable Communities. Maryland House Joint Resolution 6, 2000 Leg., 414th Session (Maryland 2000) http://mgaleg.marvland.gov/2000rs/fnotes/bil 0006/hi0006.PDF Addresses environmental justice concerns within Anne Arundel County due to its high cancer mortality rate. PH Maryland Code Annotated, Environmental § 1-602(B). Public Participation in Permitting Process (2009). http://www.epa.gov/reg3wcmd/RCRA State Star/md/authorization/prOl/md prOl stats acm 1996andl999supp.pdf Addresses the public participation and notification requirements for the permitting process of waste disposal facilities. PO, SWF Maryland Department of Environment, Environmental Performance Partnership Agreement. http://www.mde.state.md.us/aboutmde/DepartmentalReports/Pages/aboutmde/reports/partn ershipagree.aspx Documents the department's environmental program priorities and activities. v' v' v' v' v' v' v' v' v' MASSACHUSETTS Executive Office of Environmental Affairs, Environmental Justice Policy (Issued Oct. 9, 2002). http://www.mass.gov/eea/grants-and-tech-assistance/environmental-iustice-policv.html Provides information and details regarding the state environmental justice policy. Massachusetts Office of Geographic and Environmental Information, MassGIS News Item. http://www.mass.gov/anf/research-and-tech/it-serv-and-support/application-serv/office-of- geographic-information-massgis/ Comprehensive statewide database of spatial information for mapping and analysis. CIS Solid Waste Master Plan: 2006 Revision (June 2006). http://www.mass.gov/eea/docs/dep/recvcle/priorities/swmprev.pdf Revisions and updates to Beyond 2000 Solid Waste Master Plan (Beyond 2000 Plan). •/ •/ v' v' v' v' 20 ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning State Resources State Executive Orders, Legislation, and Resources Organized alphabetically by state. Revisions to the Facility Site Assignment Regulations (implemented on June 8, 2001). http://www.mass.gov/eea/agencies/massdep/recYcle/regulations/310-cmr-16-000.html See Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection, Final Amendments to 310 CMR 16.00: Site Assignment Regulations. SP Smart Growth / Smart Energy Toolkit, Advancing Environmental Justice in the Commonwealth, http://www.mass.gov/envir/smart growth toolkit/pages/mod-ei.html Provide guidance to municipalities and developers on how to better engage environmental justice populations in the planning and development process. MI/DM Massachusetts Department of Conservation and Recreation, Urban Forestry Environmental Justice Pilot Grant Program, Application Guidelines. http://www.mass.gov/eea/docs/dcr/stewardship/forestrv/urban/docs/urban-forestrv-ei-pilot- grant-program.doc Details the grant program with the goals of advancing environmental equity, improving environmental quality, and building local capacity for urban and community forestry. v' v' v' v' v' v' v' v' v' v' v' v' MICHIGAN Michigan Department of Environmental Quality, Environmental Justice Working Group. Executive Directive 2007-23. http://www.michigan.gov/documents/deq/deq-ei-ExecDirective- 2007-23 248346 7.pdf Establishes a working group to promote environmental justice issues. v' v' MINNESOTA Minnesota Statute § 116.07. Powers and Duties; Permits, Hazardous Waste Facilities (2008). https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/?id= 116.07 Addresses the permitting and siting process of hazardous waste facilities. SP v' v' MISSISSIPPI Executive Order MJF 98-1, Mississippi River Corridor Task Force (January 7, 1998). http://doa.louisiana.gov/osr/other/mjf99-8.htm Establishes and details the responsibilities of the Mississippi River Corridor Task Force. CM Mississippi Code Annotated § 17-17-151 (4). Demonstration of need by applicants for permits to operate commercial hazardous waste management facilities (2008). https://law.resource.org/pub/us/code/ms/ms.xml.2010/2010/title-17/17/17-17- 151/index.html Addresses the application and permitting process for the siting and operation of commercial hazardous waste management facilities. SP •/ v' s MISSOURI Missouri Department of Natural Resources, Fiscal Year 2000 Integrated Strategic Plan. http://www.dnr.mo.gOV/s plan/fv2000/issue 4.htm Documents the department's environmental program priorities and activities. v' MONTANA Montana Code Annotated § 75-20-102. Policy and Legislative Findings, Montana Major Facility Siting Act f 20111 http://leg.mt.gov/bills/mca/75/20/75-20-102.htm Details the legislation regarding the Montana Major Facility Siting Act. SP Montana Code Annotated § 75-20-104. Definitions, Montana Major Facility Siting Act (2011). http://leg.mt.gov/bills/mca/75/20/75-20-104.htm Details the definitions and information as it relates to the Montana Major Facility Siting Act. SP Montana Code Annotated § 75-20-232. Criteria for Identifying Proposed Facilities that Qualify for Expedited Review, http://codes.lp.findlaw.eom/mtcode/75/20/2/75-20-232 Addresses the department's responsibility to make significance determinations of the impacts associated with a proposed facility. SP v' •/ •/ s v' s 21 ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning State Resources State Executive Orders, Legislation, and Resources Organized alphabetically by state. NEW JERSEY Governor Jon S. Corzine, Governor of New Jersey, Executive Order 131. Environmental Justice. http://www.state.ni.us/infobank/circular/eoiscl31.htm Outlines the State of New Jersey's responsibility for addressing environmental justice. New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection, Environmental Justice Task Force Advances Petitions to Address Community Environmental and Public Health Concerns f20051. http://www.state.ni.us/dep/newsrel/2005/05 0083.htm Petition to address environmental and public health concerns raised by residents in Ringwood, Newark and Linden. New Jersey Department of Transportation, Context Sensitive Design, A community-based approach to transportation. http://www.ni.gov/transportation/eng/CSD/ Details the state transit approach as it relates to environmental justice. CM New Jersey Department of Transportation, Environmental Justice Guidelines. http://www.state.ni.us/transportation/eng/documents/DPPD/pdf/Environmental Justice Asses ment Guideline.pdf Details the state environmental justice regulations and guidelines. New Jersey Department of Transportation, Civil Rights/ Affirmative Action, Environmental Justice, http://www.state.ni.us/transportation/business/civilrights/ei.shtm Details the effort to address the interests and concerns of low-income and minority populations in transportation planning and project development that parallels the intent of Executive Order 12898. New Jersey Department of Transportation, 2030 New Jersey Statewide Long-Range Transportation Plan, Potential 2030 Goals, Objectives, and Performance Indicators (2005). http://www.state.ni.us/transportation/works/nichoices/pdf/GoalsObiectivesIndicators.pdf Provides information about the New Jersey statewide transportation plan, including how it relates to environmental justice. CM New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection, Camden Waterford South Air Toxics Pilot Project, http://www.state.ni.us/dep/ei/camden/ Details the pilot project, including the development of tools that can be used to quickly assess air quality (especially air toxics) problems in a community. AIR New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection, Paterson City - Compliance and Enforcement Sweep, http://www.state.ni.us/dep/enforcement/paterson/paterson.html Details the mobilization and investigations of the Paterson City compliance and enforcement sweep. New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection, Camden City Initiative. http://www.ni.gov/dep/enforcement/camden.html Details the mobilization and investigations of the Camden City compliance and enforcement sweep. •/ v' S •/ •/ v' S v' S v' S v' S v' S v' S v' S NEW MEXICO "Environmental Justice Executive Order," Executive Order 2005-056 (November 18, 2005). http://www.nmenv.state.nm.us/Iustice/EO 2005 056.pdf Outlines the State of New Mexico's responsibilities for addressing environmental justice. New Mexico Administrative Code § 20.9.2.7. Recycling and Illegal Dumping, Definitions (2007). http://www.nmenv.state.nm.us/swb/pdf/RAID%20rules%20draft%2008-21-06%20filed.pdf Addresses the eligibility criteria for the Recycling and Illegal Dumping Fund as it relates to transporting, processing, storage, recycling, use, abatement and generation of scrap tires. I/OD New Mexico Administrative Code § 20.9.3.8 (D)(2). Solid Waste Facility Permits and Registrations, Permit Application Requirements (2007). http://www.nmcpr.state.nm.us/nmac/parts/title20/20.009.0003.pdf Addresses permit requirements regarding the transportation, storage, transfer, processing, transformation, recycling, composting, nuisance abatement and disposal of solid waste. CM •/ •/ v' S v' 22 ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning State Resources State Executive Orders, Legislation, and Resources Organized alphabetically by state. New Mexico Environment Department, Environmental Justice Listening Sessions Final Report f20041. http://www.nmenv.state.nm.us/Iustice/Reports/NMEDFinalReport-Dec07-04.pdf Details the extent and nature of environmental justice concerns in New Mexico. New Mexico Environment Department, NMED releases Solid Waste Regulation Revisions with Historic Environmental Justice Provisions, (April 5, 2006). http://www.nmenv.state.nm.us/OOTS/PR/SW%20EI%20Provisions%20PR.pdf Addresses impacts to underserved communities through formal, state government policies. New Mexico, Opinion of the Attorney General 08-03 (citing Colonias Development Council vs. Rhino Environmental Services, Inc., 138 New Mexico 133, 117 P.3d 939) (2005) Addresses the requirements of agencies promulgating regulations to consider public input as it relates to environmental justice. MI/DM v' v' •/ v' v' NEW YORK New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYDEC), Recommendations for the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Environmental Justice Program (2002). http://www.dec.nv.gov/docs/permits ei operations pdf/eifinalrpt.pdf Recommendations for how environmental justice can be incorporated into permit review, State Environmental Quality Review Act procedures, and some components of the NYDEC enforcement, public participation and grants programs. SP New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, Environmental Justice and Permitting. DEC Policy, http://www.dec.nv.gov/docs/permits ei operations pdf/eipolicv.pdf Assists NYDEC staff, the regulated community and the public in understanding the requirements and review process. SP New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, Environmental Justice Interagency Task Force: Draft Recommendations (June 10, 2009). http://www.dec.nv.gov/docs/permits ei operations pdf/drftplneiintertskfrce.pdf Recommendations for the development of policies and actions that embrace environmental justice principles and work towards environmental equity. v' •/ v' v' v' v' NORTH CAROLINA North Carolina General Statute § 153A-136(c). Regulation of Solid Wastes (2005). http://law.onecle.com/north-carolina/153a-counties/153a-136.html Addresses regulations that require the review of alternative sites and socioeconomic/demographic data, and a public hearing prior to selecting or approving a site for a new sanitary landfill. DEM/SP North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR), Cumulative and/or Secondary Impacts Evaluation Process for Department Level Projects. http://portal.ncdenr.0rg/c/document librarv/get file?uuid=04dcde6d-8cOb-48eO-8194- 2bc6221253bO&groupId=38355 Creates a system for DENR to evaluate cumulative and/or secondary impact (CSI) information as part of the State Environmental Protection Act or environmental permit requirements. •/ v' v' v' OREGON Oregon Revised Statute § 195.305. Land Use Regulations (Amended 2013). https://www.oregonlegislature.gov/bills Iaws/lawsstatutes/2013orsl95.html Addresses legislation related to just compensation for changes to industrial zoning. IND •/ v' PENNSYLVANIA Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, Environmental Justice Work Group Report to the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (2001). http://files.dep.state.pa.us/PublicParti cipation/Office%20of%20Environmental%20Advocacv/E nvAdvocacvPortalFiles/2013/Environmental Justice Work Group lune 2001.pdf Analysis and recommendations of Pennsylvania's environmental justice policy. •/ v' 23 ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning State Resources State Executive Orders, Legislation, and Resources Organized alphabetically by state. RHODE ISLAND Rhode Island General Laws § 23-19. 14-5(a). Environmental Equity and Public Participation f20031. http://www.lawserver.com/law/state/rhode-island/ri- laws/rhode island general laws 23-19-14-5 Requires agencies to consider what effects cleanups will have on the populations surrounding a site and consider the issues of environmental equity for low income and racial minority populations. DEM, SWF Rhode Island General Laws § 23-19-13.4. Host community assessment committee; Definition; Funding: Powers and duties (2003). http://www.lawserver.com/law/state/rhode-island/ri- laws/rhode island general laws 23-19-13-4 Addresses the community notification process as it relates to solid waste disposal licenses. SWF •/ v' v' v' UTAH Utah Department of Environmental Quality, Division of Solid and Hazardous Waste RCRA Program, Performance Partnership. http://www.deq.utah.gov/Admin/Planning/PPA/docs/2005/Sep/2005%20DSHW-GOALS- FINAL.pdf Documents the department's environmental program priorities and activities. v' VERMONT Vermont Agency of Natural Resources, Environment 2001, "Waste." http://www.anr.state.vt.us/anr/envrpts/Env01/waste.htm Provides information on environmental risk, environmental justice and state regulations. Vermont Environmental Conservation, Performance Partnership Agreement 2007-2009. http://www.anr.state.vt.us/dec/epappa/PPA2007-2009/Final PPA 2007 to 2009.pdf Documents the department's environmental program priorities and activities. v' v' v' VIRGINIA Virginia Code Annotated § 10.1 - 1408.1 etseq, Virginia Waste Management Act. http://lis.virginia.gov/cgi-bin/legp604.exe?000+cod+10.1-1408.1 Addresses the application, notification, selection and siting process of sanitary landfills or other facilities for the disposal, treatment or storage of non-hazardous solid waste. SWF Virginia Code Annotated § 67-201(d). Development of the Virginia Energy Plan. http://lis.virginia.gov/cgi-bin/legp604.exe?000+cod+67-201 Establishes theplanfor Virginia to develop a comprehensive energy plan covering a 10-year period that is consistent with the objectives in the Commonwealth Energy Policy. Executive Summary, Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission of the Virginia General Assembly, Solid Waste Facility Management in Virginia: Impact on Minority Communities (January 1995). http://leg2.state.va.us/dls/h&sdocs.nsf/4d54200d7e28716385256ec!004f3130/b9bdf4f9e5dd5 82e8525616a006fl778?OpenDocument Details whether a pattern of discrimination has developed in the process for siting and monitoring solid waste facilities which disproportionately exposes minorities to health risks. SP, SWF •/ •/ v' v' v' WASHINGTON Washington Administrative Code § 463-60-101. General - Consultation (2004). http://apps.leg.wa.gov/WAC/default.aspx?cite=463-60-101 Addresses the requirements for pre-application consultation and public notification and involvement MI/DM v' v' WEST VIRGINIA West Virginia Department of Environmental Protection (WVDEP), Permit Hearings and Appeals Guide, http://www.dep.wv.gov/environmental- advocate/Documents/Permit%20Hearings%20and%20Appeals%20Guide.pdf Details WVDEP's policies on public notification and public participation. MI/DM v' v' 24 ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning State Resources State Executive Orders, Legislation, and Resources Organized alphabetically by state. WYOMING Wyoming Statute Annotated § 35-12-104 Industrial Development Information and Siting Act f20041.http://legisweb.state.wv.us/statutes/statutes.aspx?file=titles/Title35/T35CH12.htm Addresses the siting process for industrial facilities. SP, IND Wyoming Department of Environmental Quality, Welcome to Industrial Siting. http://deq.state.wy.us/isd/isdcouncil.htm Reviews the socio-economic and environmental impacts of industrial facilities before issuing a permit for construction. SP •/ v' ^ v' Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning Local Resources Local Ordinances and Resources Organized alphabetically. City of Cincinnati, Ohio, Environmental Justice Ordinance (June 24, 2009). http://www.vorvsenergv.com/uploads/file/26337.pdf First local ordinance in the nation to require an environmental justice permit for new or expanding industrial facilities, which must demonstrate they will not cause health problems to the community. SP City of Cincinnati, Ohio, Office of Environment and Sustainability. http://www.cincinnati-oh.gov/oes/ City website provides information about the implementation of the city's Environmental Justice Ordinance. City of Columbus, Georgia, Planning Department, Environmental Justice. http://www.columbusga.org/planning/transportation/Environmental-Iustice/ City website defines environmental justice, noting that federally-funded transportation programs must consider effects on minority and low-income communities. District of Columbia, Comprehensive Plan. http://planning.dc.gov/DC/Planning/Across+the+Citv/Comprehensive+Plan Addresses environmental justice through monitoring of environmental impacts, zoning changes, mitigation of impacts through buffering/sound walls and outreach to disadvantaged communities. BU District of Columbia, Office of Enforcement and Environmental Justice. http://green.dc.gov/service/fines-and-tickets-office-enforcement-and-environmental-iustice Seeks to ensure that low-income, minority and non-English speaking residents have meaningful opportunities to participate in environmental decision making. MI/DM City of Hartford, Connecticut, Your Health and Your Environment. http://hartford.gov/hhs City website addresses lead poisoning, asthma, air quality, open space, brownfields and environmental justice. PH v' v' v' v' v' v' v' v' v' v' v' v' s 25 ------- Environmental Justice in Land Use Planning Local Resources Local Ordinances and Resources Organized alphabetically. City of Jacksonville, Florida, Brownfields Coalition. http://www.coi.net/Departments/Planning-and-Development/Communitv-Planning- Division/Brownfields-Program/Brownfields-Coalition.aspx Environmental justice working group focused on public outreach in the City of Jacksonville. PO City of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, Department of Public Health, Environmental Justice Policy. http://www.phila.gov/health/pdfs/airmanagement/Environmental%20 Justice Brochure.pdf Calls for fair treatment and participation of all groups when developing, implementing and enforcing environmental laws; modeled after the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection Policy No. 012-0501-002. MI/DM City of San Francisco, California, Department of the Environment, Environmental Justice. http://www.sfenvironment.org/education-equitv/environmental-justice City program promotes meaningful involvement of all groups when making decisions related to land use, renewable energy, reduction of greenhouse gases, air quality and food availability. MI/DM City of Seattle, Washington, Executive Order 05-08. http://www.seattle.gov/civilrights/Documents/TITLE-VI-PLAN-5-28-14.pdf Requires greater public outreach to ethnic and culturally diverse communities. PO Seattle Public Utilities, Environmental Justice Network in Action. http://www.seattle.gov/util/AboutUs/SPUandtheCommunitv/Environmental lustice/index.htm Alliance between utility and community-based organizations, to promote environmental justice related to facilities needed for waste removal, recycling and water and sewer systems. v' S ^ ^ ^ ^ S ^ ^ ^ 26 ------- |