Reuse and the Benefit to Community: PMC Groundwater Superfund Site Technical Appendix

Reuse and the Benefit to Community
PMC Groundwater Superfund Site
Technical Appendix
Beneficial Effects: Employment Information for On-site Jobs
The Hoovers/Dun & Bradstreet (D&B) database provided information on the number of employees and sales volume for on-site businesses. D&B provides information
on businesses and corporations. It maintains a database of over 179 million companies globally and over 53 million professional contact names using a variety of
sources, including public records, trade references, telecommunication providers, newspapers and publications, and telephone interviews. The Data Universal
Numbering System (DUNS) number is a unique nine-digit identification number assigned by D&B to each business and its location within the D&B database for
identifying each business.
Beneficial Effects: Wage and Income Information for On-site Jobs
The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) provided wage and income information. The BLS is a governmental statistical agency that collects, processes, analyzes and
disseminates essential statistical data to the American public, the U.S. Congress, and other federal agencies in the broad field of labor economics and statistics. The data
provided by the BLS has high standards of accuracy and consistently high statistical quality, and impartiality in both subject matter and presentation.
The BLS Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages database provided average weekly wage data for each of the businesses located at the PMC Groundwater
Superfund site. Average weekly wage data were identified by matching the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) codes corresponding with each type
of business with weekly wage data for corresponding businesses in Emmet County. If not available at the county level, wage data were sought by state or national level,
respectively. In cases where wage data were not available for the six-digit NAICS code, higher level (less detailed) NAICS codes were used to obtain the wage data.
To determine the annual wages (mean annual) earned from jobs generated by each of the businesses located at the PMC Groundwater Superfund site, the average
weekly wage figure was multiplied by the number of weeks in a year (52) and by the number of jobs (employees) for each of the businesses.
For more information on reuse at Superfund sites, please visit: http://www.epa.gov/superfund/programs/recvcle/.
October 2014

-------
Table 1: PMC Groundwater Superfund Site Businesses: NAICS Code and Title, Employees, Average Weekly Wage, Annual Wages, Total Annual Wage
per Employee and Annual Sales	
On-site Business
NAICS
Code3
NAICS Title
Number of
Employees'5
Average Weekly
Wage (2012)°
Annual Wage
(Mean Annual)
per Employee
Total Annual
Wages'1
Annual Sales
(2012)b
Crinnion Agency
524210
Insurance Agencies and
Brokerages
2
$1,062.00
$55,224.00
$110,448.00
$140,000.00
Fraternal Order of
Eagles Inc.
813410
Civic and Social
Organizations
6
$511.00
$26,572.00
$159,432.00

Total


8


$269,880.00
$140,000.00
a NAICS code provided in D&B unless otherwise noted.
b Data are from D&B. For employee data, if D&B indicated a range, the lowest number is used.
c Average weekly wage per employee is based upon BLS 2012 Average Weekly Wage data.
dTotal annual wage figures were derived by multiplying "Number of Employees" by "Annual Wage (Mean Annual) per Employee."
2

-------
Beneficial Effects: Property Values and Local Tax Revenue Generated from Property Taxes
Property records are made available by the City of Petoskey at http://gis.emmetcountv.org/apps/taxparcelviewer/ and
https://is.bsasoftware.com/bsa.is/AssessingServices/ServiceAssessingSearch.aspx?i=l&appid=0&unit=717. Property tax values are estimated based on
property type information found in the property record, 2013 millage rates for Petoskey City obtained from
http://www.michigan.gov/documents/taxes/2013 Total Rates 450527 7.pdf.
Table 2. 2013 Property Values for the PMC Groundwater Superfund site
Parcel
Address
Assessed Value
Taxable Value
Estimated Tax

(2013)a
(2013)
(2013)
Notes
52-19-06-127-005
202 INGALLS AV
$151,000.00
$92,412.00
$3,204.79

52-19-06-127-006
201 INGALLS AV
$74,500.00
$62,464.00
$2,166.21

52-19-06-127-007
325 WATER ST
$72,300.00
$61,644.00
$2,137.78

52-19-06-127-008
317 WATER ST
$16,500.00
$7,948.00
$323.32
Fraternal Order
of Eagles
52-19-06-127-009
313 WATER ST
$153,300.00
$87,747.00
$3,569.50
Fraternal Order
of Eagles
52-19-06-127-012
203 INGALLS AV
$50,700.00
$41,369.00
$1,434.65

52-19-06-127-013
326 W LAKE ST
$40,200.00
$29,842.00
$1,034.90

52-19-06-127-014
322 W LAKE ST
$79,500.00
$40,140.00
$1,392.03

52-19-06-127-015
318 W LAKE ST
$32,600.00
$15,124.00
$524.49

52-19-06-127-016
316 W LAKE ST
$32,600.00
$16,059.00
$556.92

52-19-06-127-017
310 W LAKE ST
$40,800.00
$34,406.00
$1,193.18

52-19-06-127-018
313 WATER ST
$13,500.00
$11,125.00
$385.81

52-19-06-127-019
406 W LAKE ST
$64,800.00
$52,428.00
$1,818.17

52-19-06-127-020
314 W LAKE ST
$48,700.00
$40,038.00
$1,388.49

52-19-06-127-021
332 W LAKE ST
$41,700.00
$19,877.00
$689.32

52-19-06-201-003
101 E LAKE ST
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
City of Petoskey
52-19-06-201-004
250 WATER ST
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-101
250 WATER ST #1
$189,100.00
$176,537.00
$6,122.20
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-102
250 WATER ST #2
$189,100.00
$158,209.00
$5,486.59
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-103
250 WATER ST #3
$189,100.00
$176,537.00
$6,122.20
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-104
250 WATER ST #4
$153,800.00
$123,225.00
$4,273.37
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-105
250 WATER ST #5
$142,700.00
$134,656.00
$4,669.79
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-106
250 WATER ST #6
$153,800.00
$121,245.00
$4,204.70
Sunset Shores
3

-------
Parcel
Address
Assessed Value
Taxable Value
Estimated Tax

(2013)a
(2013)
(2013)
Notes
52-19-06-201-107
250 WATER ST #7
$153,800.00
$123,225.00
$4,273.37
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-108
250 WATER ST #8
$153,800.00
$127,080.00
$4,407.06
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-109
250 WATER ST #9
$153,800.00
$127,080.00
$4,407.06
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-110
250 WATER ST #10
$176,700.00
$176,700.00
$6,127.85
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-111
250 WATER ST #11
$193,000.00
$193,000.00
$6,693.12
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-112
250 WATER ST #12
$176,700.00
$176,700.00
$6,127.85
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-113
250 WATER ST #13
$176,700.00
$165,273.00
$5,731.57
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-114
250 WATER ST #14
$176,700.00
$159,205.00
$5,521.13
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-115
250 WATER ST #15
$176,700.00
$142,093.00
$4,927.70
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-116
250 WATER ST #16
$153,800.00
$144,588.00
$5,014.23
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-117
250 WATER ST #17
$153,800.00
$153,800.00
$5,333.69
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-118
250 WATER ST #18
$153,800.00
$144,588.00
$5,014.23
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-119
250 WATER ST #19
$188,800.00
$188,800.00
$6,547.47
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-120
250 WATER ST #20
$188,800.00
$176,128.00
$6,108.01
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-201-121
250 WATER ST #21
$188,800.00
$176,128.00
$6,108.01
Sunset Shores
52-19-06-206-101
200 W LAKE ST #1
$156,600.00
$156,600.00
$5,430.79
Water St. Condos
52-19-06-206-102
200 W LAKE ST #2
$160,100.00
$160,100.00
$5,552.17
Water St. Condos
52-19-06-206-103
200 W LAKE ST #3
$156,600.00
$156,600.00
$5,430.79
Water St. Condos
52-19-06-206-104
200 W LAKE ST #4
$156,600.00
$153,600.00
$5,326.76
Water St. Condos
52-19-06-206-105
200 W LAKE ST #5
$156,600.00
$156,600.00
$5,430.79
Water St. Condos
52-19-06-206-106
200 W LAKE ST #6
$156,600.00
$156,600.00
$5,430.79
Water St. Condos
52-19-06-206-107
200 W LAKE ST #7
$83,900.00
$83,900.00
$2,909.60
Water St. Condos
52-19-06-206-108
200 W LAKE ST #8
$83,900.00
$64,409.00
$2,233.67
Water St. Condos
52-19-06-206-109
200 W LAKE ST #9
$11,100.00
$9,728.00
$337.36
Water St. Condos
52-19-06-206-110
200 W LAKE ST #10
$11,100.00
$9,728.00
$337.36
Water St. Condos
52-19-06-206-111
200 W LAKE ST #11
$11,100.00
$9,728.00
$337.36
Water St. Condos
52-19-06-206-112
200 W LAKE ST #12
$11,100.00
$9,728.00
$337.36
Water St. Condos
52-19-06-206-113
200 W LAKE ST #13
$11,100.00
$9,728.00
$337.36
Water St. Condos
52-19-06-206-114
200 W LAKE ST #14
$11,100.00
$9,728.00
$337.36
Water St. Condos
52-19-06-206-115
200 W LAKE ST #15
$85,600.00
$65,638.00
$2,276.29
Water St. Condos
52-19-06-206-116
200 W LAKE ST #16
$85,600.00
$65,638.00
$2,276.29
Water St. Condos
52-19-06-206-117
200 W LAKE #17
$28,700.00
$28,700.00
$1,167.50
Water St. Condos
Total
$5,873,400.00
$5,184,173.00
$180,530.38

-------
a The Emmet County assessed value is 50 percent of estimated market value. For more information, see
http://www.petoskev.us/departments/finance/assessing.
Table 3. Summary of 2013 Property Values by Development1

Total
Assessed
Average
Assessed
Total Taxable
Total
2013 Tax
Total
Parcels
Sunset Shores
$3,583,300.00
$162,877.27
$3,264,797.00
$113,221.20
22
Water Street Condominiums
$1,377,400.00
$81,023.53
$1,306,753.00
$45,489.61
17
Single Family Homes
$742,900.00
$57,146.15
$516,928.00
$17,926.75
13
Fraternal Order of Eagles
$169,800.00
$84,900.00
$95,695.00
$3,892.82
2
City of Petoskey
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
1
Grand Total
$5,873,400.00
$106,789.09
$5,184,173.00
$180,530.38
55
1 These parcels do not include two parcel records, one each associated with the Sunset Shores and Water Street Condominium developments. These parcels are labeled
for administrative purposes only and have $0 value.
5

-------