REGION 10 DIVE TEAM
www.epa.gov/region10/dive
EPA Region 10 Dive Team
Wyckoff Eagle Harbor Superfund Site Scientific Diving Support 1980-2011
What: The Region 10 dive team was asked to support Wyckoff Superfund Site cleanup through a
variety of activities since the early 1980's. Early work included taking sediment samples at the site and
support during cleanup activities. Between 1993 and 1997, the team monitored eel grass beds to
document potential impacts from capping work. In the 1990's and through 2007, the team was also
asked to 1) install and check sediment traps equipment to monitor the success of placing a layer of clean
riverine sediments over contaminated sediments (largely creosote), 2) conduct surveys during and after
capping contaminated sediments, and 3) placing and monitoring "no anchor buoys" to ensure ongoing
protection of the cap. In 2002, the dive unit was asked to perform an outfall and impact survey for the
Wyckoff treatment plant to support the Region 10 Superfund program and USACE. In 2007, the EPA
Region 10 Dive Team conducted a survey technique for underwater digital photography integrated with
GPS location data as part of a pre-capping debris survey for the EPA Superfund cleanup program,
Bainbridge Island, WA. In 2011, the dive unit was asked to locate and sample flux chambers as well as
solid phase microextraction devices (SPMD/SPME) to monitor the performance of the clean cap at the
site.
Why: The EPA Region 10 dive unit was asked to conduct a variety of samples to both help determine
the cleanup needed at the site, monitor the installation of the cleanup, and later to monitor the
effectiveness of the cleanup. Eelgrass monitoring was conducted to determine what impact capping
might have on nearby eelgrass beds. For pre-capping work, debris locations, photos, and video footage
were necessary to inform bidding contractors of the size and location of debris, should some require
removal, or additional overcapping allowance for cap placement at this Superfund Site. During
Wyckoff treatment plant outfall work, the survey was designed to determine the level of impact of the
outfall on nearby sediment and to observe the outfall to determine if was in need of maintenance. The
outfall discharges treated effluent from the Wyckoff treatment plant which treats creosote contaminated
groundwater as part of a Superfund cleanup of an old wood treating site. Cap monitoring diver survey
objectives were to 1) assess the nature of the cap during and after capping including evidence of
recontamination, 2) evaluate recovery by benthic macrofauna and algae after cap placement, 3) assess
movement of cap sediments (due to resuspension), and 4) maintain "no anchor zone" buoys as they are
an important institutional control for the sediment cap. In 2011, divers were asked to take samples via
SPMDs and flux chamber samples to analyze the degree to which the Wyckoff cap was meeting
performance objectives.
Where: Eagle Harbor, Bainbridge Island, WA.
When: The EPA Region 10 dive unit supported Wyckoff Superfund Site work since the early 1980's.
Eelgrass survey work occurred between October, 1993 to August, 1997. The outfall survey was
conducted in August, 2002, the debris survey in March 2007. Pre-cleanup sampling took place
throughout the 1980's and 1990's. For cap placement, the caps were placed in several phases through
2001. Dive surveys were conducted several times during and after placement. Diver surveys continue in
support of EPA Office of Research and Development (ORD) work to study long-term cap effectiveness
-------
in 2004, 2005, and 2006. Work on "no anchor zone" buoys has taken place in 2006 and 2007.
SPMD/flux chamber work occurred in the fall of 2011.
How: Earlier work at the site included photographing and videotaping biota and sediment type along
transects; measuring cap thickness atop settlement plates; measuring any increases in sedimentation in a
nearby marina, and surveys of nearby eelgrass beds. Divers also helped place and retrieve sediment
traps. Using handtools, divers also install and monitor "no anchor zone" buoys.
Density of eelgrass {Zostera marina L.) was recorded as counts of stalks within 0.1 m2 quadrats; 30
quadrats were placed randomly in a 100 m by 20 m rectangle in the middle of each bed.
For the treatment plant survey, divers located the outfall, took still photos and video, then placed a
transect along which surface sediment samples were taken. Samples of the top 2 cm were collected into
16 oz. jars using pre-cleaned stainless steel spoons with special care to include the very fine flocculent
surface layer. In total, 54 samples were collected from the acute and chronic mixing zone/zone of
deposit.
For pre-capping work in 2007, a survey procedure was conducted where a two person dive team surveys
the underwater environment in search of submerged debris by documenting the seafloor with digital
photos at debris locations along a contour of the shore covering approximately one thousand feet per
transect. An inexpensive recreational Global Positioning System (GPS) device is towed in a raft directly
above the divers which records positions throughout the dive. Commercial software is later used to
relate the GPS information to the digital photos resulting in geo-located digital photos that can be
viewed on a map or Geographic Information System (GIS) for later analysis of the seafloor
environment.
For flux chamber location, surface supplied dive equipment was used to employ arc pattern searches.
Deployment of SPMDs was generally otherwise conducted with SCUBA buddy teams on transects.
Equipment: EPA vessel Monitor was used as the dive platform for all surveys. Early work utilized hi8
video, Nikonos V for still photos, while later work utilized high definition video and compact digital still
cameras. Quadrats were used for eelgrass counts. For mapping work, a GPS device attached to diver-
towed GPS raft, Underwater Digital Camera (Sony HC1 video camera, using still photo capability while
simultaneously recording bottom video), GIS software & Laptop were used to create a map of the
boundary and observations. For 2011 cap monitoring work, surface supplied dive equipment was used
for searches to locate the flux chambers, as well as high definition video and standard definition helmet
cameras. Later in 2011, SCUBA buddy teams on transect lines conducted the bulk of SPMD deployment
and retrieval.
Results: Videos, photos, maps and samples were conveyed to various project staff.
For eelgrass surveys, shoot density differed; the Wyckoff bed (nearest the sediment cap) consistently
had the least amount of eelgrass and the Murden Cove bed (to the north of Eagle Harbor) the most.
Changes within beds appeared to be related to the natural cycle of winter reduction rather than the
movement and subsequent deposition of cap sediment. Variability among divers in counting stalks was
highest when the density was high and within 1 or 2 stalks when density was low.
-------
Cap surveys that took place between 2001 and 2007 found that the cap was smooth in the south part of
the harbor and "hummocky" in the north. A lot of woody debris was present. Creosote "marbles" were
observed in the south on two occasions (see pictures below). Some settlement plates were lost (tipped
over, broken, dragged, buried). Divers could feel the difference in substrate type (sand placed over
mud). Recovery by macrofauna was rapid. Anemones pulled up through the cap and crab, flatfish, and
drift algae were common. Polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) were detected in samples from the
sediment traps (see photo below) at times. Only minor accumulations of sediment occurred around
stakes in a nearby marina. Nearby eelgrass beds were probably not affected. A survey was conducted in
December, 2003 of areas that formerly seeped or pooled creosote (Area 4 within figure below) which
was capped in 2000-2001. Life on the cap included various types of anemones including the frilled
anemone (Metridium senile), seastars including the sunflower star (Pycnopodia helicmthoides) sea
lettuce (Ulva), unidentified bivalves, unidentified tube worms, and sporadic eel grass (Zostera marina).
Several fish including unidentified sole, ratfish (Hydrolagus colliei), and other unidentified small fish
were seen on the bottom or above the cap in addition to various crab- including dungeness (Cancer
magister). "No anchor zone" buoys were placed in 2006 and replaced in 2007.
More details: http://yosemite.epa.gov/rlO/cleanup.nsf/sites/wyckoff
Video: Surface Sediment Sampling Techniques. (2 minutes. Total file size 27 MB Windows Media
format)
Video: Creosote marbles and pools on the bottom of Eagle Harbor
(2 minutes. Total file size: 18 MB. Quicktime format)
Video: Pre-capping debris survey. March 8. 2007 (20 minutes, 158 MB, Quicktime format)
Duncan. P.B. and D.W. Kama. 1996. Eelgrass surveys in Eagle Harbor. WA. following capping of
adjacent contaminated sediments. Proc. Amer. Acad. Underwater Sci. 1996 Sci. Diving Symp. p. 107-
111. (6 pp, 300 KB pdf)
Contact information: Rob Pedersen, (206) 553-1646, pedersen.rob@epa.gov. Chad Schulze,
schulze.chad@epa.gov. Tim Siwiec, siwiec.tim@epa.gov. Sean Sheldrake, Sheldrake.sean@epa.gov
-------
Photos:
Diver monitored sediment stakes
-------
Creosote pools that were prevalent in nearshore areas before dredging/capping that divers were asked to
photo document and map.
-------
Bottom dump barge placing cap material .
-------
Diver placing a sediment trap offsite (note no personal protective equipment in use).
Measuring the outfall diameter
for treatment plant operators.
-------
View of algal growth along the treatment plant outfall
Diver carefully collecting a surface sediment sample
-------
Wyckoff Subtidal Survey Transects
EPA Region 10 Dive Team
fiErarriraft GSS20SI)
DSC00110
wyckoff site
Seattle
Legend
Photo of Submerged Object
Area Covered by Divers
Wyckoff Subtidal Survey Transects: March 8th 2007
wsmmm
Si'-' '¦
^ ¦ - » ___
£ ¦ ¦ '"
PmPtK'' ~ ' i>' "~
\!^^gCeS?
Subtidal
1'22?50603
¦ &£ ii ^
> -- ' ¦ -- ' at 1:• ! * 1
03/08/2007;
An object located as part of the pre-capping survey in 2007.
-------
Ds:eoo;i:o6i
[SUSticlall
An object located as part of the pre-capping survey in 2007.
Area 1
Capped in 1994
Area 2
Capped in 1994
Sheet-pile Wall
Perimeter.
Area 4
GappecHn
2000-2001
Former
Wyckoff
Facility
Pilot Scale Sheet-Pile Wall
Test Pilot Area
Map of areas capped at the Wyckoff Site. Note that parts of Area 4 were capped again in 2008.
-------
K2SD33
Picture of an eelgrass bed being mapped in 2007.
-------
Diver mapping the perimeter of the eelgrass bed at the Wyckoff Superfund Site
-------
Bainbridge
Island
Legend
Transect 4 Photo Locations: SS.TS: 10:41-11:04am
Transect 6 Photo Locations: SS.TS: 11:17-11:34am
Transect 10 Photo Locations: LM. BD; 12:40-1:11pm
Boundary Photo Locations: LM. BD: 130-1:57pm
Sediment Sample 03 Photo Location: LM. BD: 2:25-2:37pm
i
&
%
1
'
Approximate!
HEelgrassJ
iBoundaryJ
Th® O S Environmental Piowct
But cofnpuM rapranataton le
may have fcwr vw1i«l by Bw EPA This data ra re
Wyckoff Eelgrass Survey Sept 6th 2007 ?
.« Heatton by an mdepmJen! protwjiwial qualified !o v«lfy such
data « aitorniaaon Th» EPA « (itamaHn iiowi
" '« any loss or Injuiy resulting from re»ance
» in n Ufrt TS. September 6th 2007
US ACE/US EPA
5 ¦
-------
p
Diver conducting eelgrass counts near the Wyckoff Superfund Site.
-------
Photo of a flux chamber sampled in 2011, at right.
Surface supplied dive equipment was used to search for flux chambers in 2011.
-------
I *-£iI }
Diver using a helmet camera to show objects to topside support.
Return to EPA Reeion 10 Dive Team homepage.
------- |