April 2022 Inventory of U.S. Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Sinks 1990-2020: Updates for Gas STAR and Methane Challenge Reductions This memo documents the updates implemented in EPA's 2022 Inventory of U.S. Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Sinks (GHGI) due to reassessing Natural Gas STAR ("Gas STAR") reductions and incorporating Methane Challenge reductions. Additional considerations for using reductions data in the GHGI were previously discussed in a memo released in September 2021 (Inventory of U.S. Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Sinks 1990- 2020: Updates Under Consideration for Gas STAR and Methane Challenge Reductions).1 1 Background and Previous (1990-2019) GHGI Methodology For a limited number of emission sources within Natural Gas Systems, EPA applies methane (CH4) emission factors (EFs) from a 1996 Gas Research Institute (GRI) and EPA study (GRI/EPA study) across the entire 1990- 2019 time series.2 These EFs are representative of technologies and practices in the early 1990's, but not necessarily of more recent operations. Industry practices and technologies have evolved significantly in the 25 years since the release of the GRI/EPA study. For these emission sources, the methodology first estimated "potential" emissions with the GRI/EPA factors and then estimated "net" emissions by subtracting voluntary emissions reductions reported under EPA's Gas STAR program from the potential emissions.3 Throughout this memo, this is called a "potential methodology". Most other GHGI emission source calculation methodologies have been updated to use EFs developed from subpart W data or a recently published methane emissions study; throughout this memo, this is called a "net methodology". Within the Gas STAR program, voluntary emission reductions are classified as either short- or long-term reductions. Short-term reductions are assumed to be 1-year reductions and in the GHGI are only applied to calculated potential emissions in the specific year of implementation. In contrast, long-term reductions are those reductions which extend beyond the specific year of implementation. Most of these long-term reductions are the result of capital investments in new equipment, controls, etc. For these sources, the Gas STAR program assigns a "sunset date", which is the length of time a technology or practice could be considered to generate emission reductions for the purposes of Gas STAR after implementation. For long-term reductions, the "sunset date" is either 7 or 10 years. For purposes of the GHGI, EPA assumes that all reported long-term reductions are permanent (i.e., Gas STAR "sunset dates" are ignored and the identified reductions are applied to the implementation year and all subsequent years). The net effect of this assumption is that the total annual quantity of long-term reductions gradually increases over time as more reductions are reported to Gas STAR. In the previous GHGI (i.e., 1990-2019 GHGI), Gas STAR reductions were applied to the following sources: • Production Segment o Gas engines o Compressor starts o Other (for activities not assigned to a particular GHGI emission source) • Transmission and Storage Segment o Pipeline leaks o Dehydrator vents (Transmission) o Engines (Transmission) o Station venting (Transmission) 1 https://www.epa.gov/system/files/documents/2021-09/2022-ghgi-update-gas-starmc_sept-2021.pdf 2 GRI/EPA 1996. Methane Emissions from the Natural Gas Industry. EPA-600/R-96-080. June 1996. 3 In addition to adjustments for voluntary reductions, regulatory reductions are also applied for one source in the GHGI-production segment dehydrator vents, to reflect NESHAP reductions. Other sources covered by regulations (such as NSPS) are calculated with a net methodology. Page 1 of 17 ------- April 2022 The most recent Gas STAR reduction data that were incorporated into the GHGI were for 2013. These 2013 year reductions were then carried forward as proxy data for the 2014 through 2019 emission years without new reductions data being incorporated. Table 1 (Production Segment) and Table 2 (Transmission and Storage Segment) present the numerical Gas STAR reductions used and reported in the previous GHGI. Reductions are only presented for inventory years 1990, 2005, and 2015-2019 (i.e., the years shown in the main text of the previous GHGI report); Appendix A presents the numerical Gas STAR reductions for the entire 1990-2019 time series in the previous GHGI. Table 1. Annual Production Segment Gas STAR Reductions for 1990, 2005, and 2015-2019 (mt CH4) in the Previous (2021) GHGI. Source 1990 2005 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Gas Engines 0 96,625 139,167 139,167 139,167 139,167 139,167 Compressor Starts 0 182 512 512 512 512 512 Other 0 100,762 104,624 104,624 104,624 104,624 104,624 Total 0 197,569 244,304 244,304 244,304 244,304 244,304 Table 2. Annual Transmission and Storage Segment Gas STAR Reductions for 1990, 2005, and 2015- 2019 (mt CH4) in the Previous (2021) GHGI. Source 1990 2005 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Pipeline Leaks 0 0 1,213 1,213 1,213 1,213 1,213 Dehydrator vents 0 2,718 2,819 2,819 2,819 2,819 2,819 Engines 0 83,207 126,910 126,910 126,910 126,910 126,910 Station Venting 0 126,310 136,856 136,856 136,856 136,856 136,856 Total 0 212,235 267,799 267,799 267,799 267,799 267,799 2 Update Implemented in the 2022 GHGI 2.1 Gas STAR EPA replaced the Gas STAR data currently used in the GHGI with a revised dataset including reductions from 1990-20194, adjusted to remove reductions for sources calculated with net methodologies. EPA continued to treat long-term Gas STAR reductions in the revised dataset in the same manner as the previous GHGI approach wherein those reductions are assumed to be permanent (see Section 1). Reduction data for 2019 were applied for 2020, as 2020 data were not yet available. As part of the overall reassessment of the Gas STAR reductions, EPA examined every Gas STAR activity (i.e., the list of technologies and practices implemented by companies to mitigate emissions) in the Production, Transmission and Storage, and Distribution segments.5 First, EPA assigned each Gas STAR reduction activity in the Production segment and the Transmission and Storage segment to a GHGI emission source; in a few instances, a Gas STAR reduction activity was assigned to two GHGI emissions sources. EPA also assigned relevant Gas STAR reduction activities in the Distribution segment to specific Distribution segment emission sources: pressure relief valve releases, pipeline blowdowns, and mishaps (dig-ins). The Gas STAR reductions data assessed included a total of 102 Production segment reduction activities, 58 Transmission and Storage segment reduction activities, and 37 Distribution segment reduction activities. 4 https://edap.epa.gov/public/extensions/NGS/Accomplishments.html 5 EPA did not analyze the Gas STAR activities for the Processing segment as most Processing sources are quantified with net methodologies. Page 2 of 17 ------- April 2022 EPA then assessed which Gas STAR reduction activities were related to a GHGI emission source which still used the "potential methodology" (e.g., the GHGI emission source calculation methodology still relied on data from the 1996 GRI/EPA study) versus the "net methodology" (i.e., the GHGI emission source calculation methodology had been updated to use emissions data from subpart W or a recently published methane emissions study). EPA removed the reduction activities related to a GHGI emission source with a "net methodology" from further analysis. A total of 40 Production segment reduction activities, 23 Transmission and Storage segment reduction activities, and 12 Distribution segment reduction activities were determined to use the "potential methodology". These activities are presented below in Table 3 (Production Segment), Table 4 (Transmission and Storage Segment), and Table 5 (Distribution Segment). As indicated in the footnotes for Table 3 and Table 4, a few reduction activities were assigned to two GHGI emissions sources for which one source used the "net methodology" and the other source used the "potential methodology". For these activities, the reductions were adjusted using a ratio of source-specific emissions versus overall emissions. For example, the reductions from the Production segment reduction activity (i.e., "Capture and use gas released from gas-operated pneumatic pumps") were reduced by the ratio of Kimray pump emissions to the sum of Kimray pump and chemical injection pump emissions. Likewise, the reductions from the three Transmission and Storage segment reduction activities that were assigned to two GHGI emission sources (see the last three rows of Table 4) were reduced using similar ratios. Table 3. Gas STAR Production Segment Reduction Activities Assigned to GHGI Emission Sources with a Potential Methodology Gas STAR Reduction Activity GHGI Emission Source Reduce methane emissions from compressor rod packing systems Compressors Automate compressor systems operations to reduce venting Compressors/Compressor Blowdowns Lower compressor purge pressure for shutdown Compressor Blowdowns Redesign blowdown/alter ESD practices Compressor Blowdowns Reduce emissions when taking compressors offline Compressor Blowdowns Convert engine starting to nitrogen and/or C02 rich gas Compressor Starts Convert to low pressure compressor starters Compressor Starts Install electric motor starters Compressor Starts Reduce gas venting with fewer compressor startups and improved ignition Compressor Starts Replace gas starters with air or nitrogen Compressor Starts Replace ignition/reduce false starts Compressor Starts Install condensers on glycol dehydrators Dehydrator Vents/Kimray Pumps Install flash tank separators on glycol dehydrators Dehydrator Vents/Kimray Pumps Reduce glycol circulation rates in dehydrators Dehydrator Vents/Kimray Pumps Replacing glycol dehydrators with desiccant dehydrators Dehydrator Vents/Kimray Pumps Reroute dehydrators/tank vents to flare or station suction Dehydrator Vents/Kimray Pumps Reroute glycol skimmer gas Dehydrator Vents/Kimray Pumps Shutdown glycol dehydrator stripping gas in winter Dehydrator Vents/Kimray Pumps Catalytic converter installation Engines Convert natural gas-fired generator to solar power Engines Install automated air/fuel ratio controls Engines Install electric compressors Engines Install electric motors Engines Install lean burn compressor Engines Page 3 of 17 ------- April 2022 Gas STAR Reduction Activity GHGI Emission Source Install pilotless burner controls Engines Turbine fuel use optimization Engines DI&M at compressor stations Equipment Leaks DI&M at remote sites Equipment Leaks DI&M: leak detection using IR camera/optical imaging Equipment Leaks DI&M: leak detection using lower emission threshold Equipment Leaks DI&M: survey and repair leaks Equipment Leaks Install plugs on valves and open ended lines Equipment Leaks Test and repair pressure safety valves Equipment Leaks Capture and use gas released from gas-operated pneumatic pumps Kimray Pumps/Chemical Injection Pumps3 Convert water tank blanket from natural gas to C02 Produced Water Install flash tank separator on water gathering system Produced Water a Kimray pumps use a potential methodology and chemical injection pumps use a net methodology. Table 4. Gas STAR Transmission and Storage Segment Reduction Activities Assigned to GHGI Emission Sources with a Potential Methodology. Gas STAR Reduction Activity GHGI Emission Source Install condensers on glycol dehydrators Dehydrator Vents Install flash tank separators/controls on transmission sector glycol dehydrators Dehydrator Vents Replace glycol dehydrator with separator and in-line heaters Dehydrator Vents Reroute dehydrators/tank vents to flare or station suction Dehydrator Vents Reroute glycol skimmer gas Dehydrator Vents Install automated air/fuel ratio controls Engines Install electric compressors Engines Install electric motor starters Engines Install electric motors Engines Install lean burn compressor Engines Replace gas starters with air or nitrogen Engines Replace ignition/reduce false starts Engines Use of turbines at compressor stations Engines DI&M: aerial leak detection using laser and/or infrared technology Pipeline Leaks Inspect/repair valves during pipeline replacement Pipeline Leaks Pipeline replacement and repair Pipeline Leaks Design isolation valves to minimize gas blowdown volumes Station Venting Lower compressor purge pressure for shutdown Station Venting Move in fire gates at compressors Station Venting Reduce emissions when taking compressors offline Station Venting/Compressors3 Inject blowdown gas into low pressure mains or fuel gas system Station Venting/Pipeline Venting3 Redesign blowdown/alter ESD practices Station Venting/Pipeline Venting3 a Station venting uses a potential methodology and pipeline venting and compressor emissions are estimated using net methodologies. Page 4 of 17 ------- April 2022 Table 5. Gas STAR Distribution Segment Reduction Activities Assigned to GHGI Emission Sources with a Potential Methodology. Gas STAR Reduction Activity GHGI Emission Source Install excess flow valves Mishaps (Dig-ins) Reduced emissions through third-party damage prevention Mishaps (Dig-ins) Inject blowdown gas into low pressure mains or fuel gas system Pipeline Blowdown Install overpressure protection system Pipeline Blowdown Redesign blowdown/alter ESD practices Pipeline Blowdown Reduce/downgrade system pressure Pipeline Blowdown Reduce/downgrade system pressure (manual) Pipeline Blowdown Use automated systems to reduce pressure Pipeline Blowdown Use hot taps for in-service pipeline connections Pipeline Blowdown Use pipeline pump-down techniques to lower gas line pressure Pipeline Blowdown Test and repair pressure safety valves Pressure Relief Valve Releases Test gate station pressure relief valves with nitrogen Pressure Relief Valve Releases Tables 6, 7, and 8 present a summary of the year 2019 Gas STAR reductions by GHGI emission source (all Gas STAR reductions are summed together for a common GHGI emission source) for the Production segment, the Transmission and Storage segment, and the Distribution segment, respectively. Appendix B presents the complete time series of Gas STAR reductions of each emission source in Tables 6, 7, and 8. Table 6. Year 2019 Production Segment Gas STAR Reductions by Emission Source (mt CH4). GHGI Emission Source Gas STAR Reductions Compressor Blowdowns 4,499 Compressor Starts 16,954 Compressors 48 Dehydrator Vents/Kimray Pumps 50,911 Engines 32,147 Equipment Leaks 85 Kimray Pumps 166 Produced Water 1,023 Total 105,833 Table 7. Year 2019 Transmission and Storage Segment Gas STAR Reductions by Emission Source (mt CH4). GHGI Emission Source Gas STAR Reductions Dehydrator Vents 4,089 Engines 132,410 Pipeline Leaks 590 Station Venting 21,418 Total 158,507 Page 5 of 17 ------- April 2022 Table 8. Year 2019 Distribution Segment Gas STAR Reductions by Emission Source (mt CH4). GHGI Emission Source Gas STAR Reductions Pressure Relief Valve Releases 0a Pipeline Blowdowns 2,202 Mishaps (Dig-ins) 1,383 Total 3,586 a Gas STAR reductions were not reported for pressure relief valve releases in year 2019; however, reductions were reported for other years in the time series. In order to correspond with GHGI emission sources, EPA disaggregated Gas STAR reductions for production segment "dehydrator vents/Kimray pumps" and "equipment leaks" to the individual GHGI emission sources. EPA applied the average source-specific distribution of emissions over the entire time series to estimate the reductions for each emission source (e.g., production segment separator emissions account for 48 percent of equipment leak emissions over the 1990-2020 time series and EPA assigned 48 percent of the equipment leak Gas STAR reductions to separators): • Dehydrator vents/Kimray pumps o Dehydrator vents - 24 percent o Kimray pumps - 76 percent • Equipment leaks o Heaters - 9 percent o Separators - 48 percent o Dehydrators - 6 percent o Meters/piping - 37 percent 2.2 Methane Challenge EPA's Methane Challenge Program has collected reductions data starting with reductions reported for 2016. EPA incorporated these data into the GHGI. Methane Challenge data are available for two commitment options (Best Management Practice Commitment Option (BMP) and the ONE Future Emissions Intensity Commitment Option [ONE Future]) and reductions for both commitment options are considered. BMP partners make a commitment to implement mitigation activities for specific emission sources and the list of emission sources varies by industry segment. ONE Future partners make a commitment to achieve a ONE Future-defined target segment intensity rate by 2025 for all their operations in the segment and may implement mitigation activities for any of their emission sources to achieve that rate. For both options, partners report the emissions reductions achieved in a given year as a result of implementing specific mitigation activities to achieve their commitment. BMP emissions reductions are available for years 2016-2019 and ONE Future emissions reductions are available for years 2017-2019.6 Table 9 presents the Methane Challenge reductions by industry segment and emission source for 2016-2019. Table 9 also shows the Methane Challenge emission sources that are related to GHGI emission sources with a potential methodology. 6 https://www.epa.gov/natural-gas-star-program/methane-challenge-program-accomplishments Page 6 of 17 ------- April 2022 Table 9. Methane Challenge CH4 Emission Reductions by Emission Source (mt CH4) and Identification of Sources That Use a Potential Methodology. Methane Challenge Emission Source 2016 2017 2018 2019 GHGI Emission Source Uses a Potential Methodology? Transmission Segment Transmission Pipeline Blowdowns 4,787 58,113 98,147 74,971 No Equipment Leaks [transmission station leaks] 0 3,411 8,314 15,118 No Reciprocating Compressors 0 621 583 911 No Pneumatic Controllers 0 6 184 215 No Distribution Segment Distribution Mains 2,449 8,974 8,709 9,652 No Distribution Services 1,014 3,126 2,528 2,682 No Distribution Pipeline Blowdowns 0 4 802 192 Yes Pressure Relief Valves 0 789 52 47 Yes Onshore Production Storage Tanks 0 0 0 14 No Gathering and Boosting Reciprocating Compressors 0 0 0 196 No Only two sources with Methane Challenge reductions use a potential methodology in the GHGI and both are in the distribution segment. For 2016-2019 in the 2022 GHGI, distribution pipeline blowdown emissions average 4,400 mt CH4 and pressure relief valve releases average 1,300 mt CH4. 3 Time Series Considerations Gas STAR reductions are available over the entire time series. Methane Challenge data are available for year 2016 forward. With the exception of the long-term GasSTAR reductions discussed in Section 2.1, EPA applied the reductions data only to the years reported and did not make adjustments to other years of the time series. Upon comparing the reductions data to the potential emissions over the time series for each emission source, there were a number of instances where the reductions exceeded the potential emissions resulting in "negative emissions". The sources with calculated negative net emissions (and years of negative emissions) include: • Production Segment o Compressor blowdowns (2001-2020) o Compressor starts (1994-2020) o Dehydrator vents (2010-2011) • Transmission segment o Dehydrator vents (1997-2020) o Pipeline leaks (1998-1999, 2007-2012, 2014, 2017-2018) • Distribution segment o Pipeline blowdowns (1997, 2005-2006) o PRV releases (2002) Page 7 of 17 ------- April 2022 EPA removed Gas STAR reductions entirely for sources with more than 10 years of negative calculated emissions (i.e., production segment compressor blowdowns and compressor starts, and transmission segment dehydrator vents and pipeline leaks). For the remaining sources with negative emissions (i.e., production segment dehydrator vents and distribution segment pipeline blowdowns and PRV releases), calculated negative emissions occur for a maximum of three years in the time series. EPA replaced the negative net emissions value with zero for the years of negative net emissions for these sources. 4 National Emissions Estimates Tables 10, 11, and 12 present the impact of Gas STAR and Methane Challenge voluntary reductions, along with regulatory reductions, for the Production, Transmission and Storage, and Distribution segments in the GHGI. Appendix C presents the complete time series of reductions used for each emission source in the 2022 GHGI. The reductions in Tables 10 - 12 and Appendix C reflect the adjustments presented in Section 2 (to disaggregate emissions) and Section 3 (to exclude certain reductions that resulted in negative net emissions values). Table 10. Year 2019 Production Segment Potential and Net Emissions with Reductions (mt CH4). Parameter Emissions/Reductions Previous (2021) GHGI Emissions/Reductions Current (2022) GHGI Potential Emissions 3,992,187 3,801,962 Gas STAR Reductions 236,934 84,380 Regulatory Reductions3 7,370 7,370 Net Emissions 3,747,883 3,710,212 a. Regulatory reductions include the impacts of EPA National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP) regulations for dehydrator vents. Table 11. Year 2019 Transmission and Storage Segment Potential and Net Emissions with Reductions (mt CH4). Parameter Emissions/Reductions Previous (2021) GHGI Emissions/Reductions Current (2022) GHGI Potential Emissions 1,746,133 1,736,643 Gas STAR Reductions 267,799 153,828 Net Emissions 1,478,334 1,582,815 Table 12. Year 2019 Distribution Segment Potential and Net Emissions with Reductions (mt CH4). Parameter Emissions/Reductions Previous (2021) GHGI Emissions/Reductions Current (2022) GHGI Potential Emissions 559,880 559,199 Gas STAR Reductions 0 3,586 Methane Challenge Reductions 0 239 Net Emissions 559,880 555,375 5 Requests for Stakeholder Feedback EPA sought stakeholder feedback on the approaches under consideration through two 2021 webinars, in the September 2021 memo, and in the public review draft of the GHGI. EPA received stakeholder comments on Page 8 of 17 ------- April 2022 the September 2021 version of the memo and through the public review draft of the Inventory. Stakeholder feedback is summarized here. Stakeholders agreed with using updated Gas STAR reductions and with the incorporation of Methane Challenge reductions. One stakeholder supported the approach of treating long-term reductions as permanent reductions instead of applying long-term reductions that incorporate sunset dates. The requests for stakeholder feedback below were not updated for this memorandum and are copied from the September 2021 memorandum: EPA seeks stakeholder feedback on the update under consideration discussed in this memo and the questions below. 1. Are the Gas STAR reduction activity assignments to GHGI emission sources in Tables 3-5 appropriate? 2. Are there any Gas STAR activities identified in Tables 3 - 5 as having a potential methodology that should be considered to have a net methodology? 3. Are there other data sources available to quantify emissions or reductions for the identified sources? Page 9 of 17 ------- April 2022 Appendix A. Previous (2021) GHGI Gas STAR Reductions A-l. Previous (2021) GHGI Annual Production Segment Gas STAR Reductions for 1990-2019 (mt CH4). GHGI Source 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 Gas Engines 0 0 0 3,217 6,845 12,456 20,855 28,958 34,950 43,414 Compressor Starts 0 0 0 0 0 3 5 6 117 117 Other 0 0 0 5,562 20,524 29,361 59,362 60,621 75,855 81,560 Total 0 0 0 8,778 27,369 41,820 80,222 89,586 110,922 125,091 GHGI Source 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Gas Engines 51,862 60,473 69,101 74,801 87,824 96,625 103,170 110,329 115,060 121,762 Compressor Starts 117 179 179 179 182 182 182 189 197 395 Other 76,656 83,116 77,643 95,796 99,957 100,762 93,875 98,577 107,160 102,361 Total 128,635 143,768 146,923 170,777 187,962 197,569 197,226 209,096 222,417 224,517 GHGI Source 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Gas Engines 132,021 135,866 138,672 139,167 139,167 139,167 139,167 139,167 139,167 139,167 Compressor Starts 512 512 512 512 512 512 512 512 512 512 Other 104,184 99,639 99,772 104,624 104,624 104,624 104,624 104,624 104,624 104,624 Total 236,718 236,017 238,956 244,304 244,304 244,304 244,304 244,304 244,304 244,304 A-2. Previous (2021) GHGI Annual Transmission and Storage Segment Gas STAR Reductions for 1990-2019 (mt CH4). GHGI Source 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 Pipeline Leaks 0 0 0 0 0 33 0 0 0 0 Dehydrator vents (Transmission) 0 0 0 0 0 0 755 3,249 3,225 3,182 Engines (Transmission) 0 0 0 2,803 7,725 12,547 15,909 19,339 40,719 45,526 Station Venting (Transmission) 0 0 0 2,740 1,416 5,161 7,239 23,627 42,847 58,878 Total 0 0 0 5,543 9,141 17,742 23,904 46,215 86,790 107,586 GHGI Source 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Pipeline Leaks 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1,136 Dehydrator vents (Transmission) 2,718 2,718 2,718 2,718 2,718 2,718 2,840 2,819 2,819 2,819 Engines (Transmission) 49,291 54,241 68,381 72,424 77,975 83,207 87,797 94,454 103,082 116,170 Station Venting (Transmission) 77,530 106,355 119,998 125,039 127,850 126,310 146,461 129,026 161,055 136,592 Total 129,539 163,313 191,098 200,181 208,543 212,235 237,097 226,299 266,956 256,718 Page 10 of 17 ------- April 2022 GHGI Source 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Pipeline Leaks 0 2,773 4,199 1,213 1,213 1,213 1,213 1,213 1,213 1,213 Dehydrator vents 2,819 2,819 2,819 2,819 2,819 2,819 2,819 2,819 2,819 2,819 (Transmission) Engines (Transmission) 119,382 121,688 124,050 126,910 126,910 126,910 126,910 126,910 126,910 126,910 Station Venting (Transmission) 135,250 134,419 135,824 136,856 136,856 136,856 136,856 136,856 136,856 136,856 Total 257,451 261,700 266,891 267,799 267,799 267,799 267,799 267,799 267,799 267,799 Page 11 of 17 ------- April 2022 Appendix B. Updated Gas STAR Reductions Appendix B reflects the updated Gas STAR reductions data that was assessed for the 2022 GHGI, and does not include adjustments other than treating long-term reductions as permanent reductions (i.e., these data do not reflect the adjustments presented in Section 2 (to disaggregate emissions) and Section 3 (to exclude certain reductions that resulted in negative net emissions values)). B-l. Annual Production Segment Gas STAR Reductions, by GHGI Emission Source, for 1990-2019 (mt CH4). GHGI Source 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 Compressors 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Compressor Blowdowns 0 0 0 46 61 94 94 95 95 103 Compressor Starts 0 0 0 391 6,891 6,893 9,939 12,705 12,893 12,816 Dehydrator Vents/Kimray Pumps 0 0 0 3,766 5,051 6,862 12,391 20,007 22,873 22,769 Engines 0 0 0 3,037 3,847 5,831 8,618 8,323 6,259 9,123 Equipment Leaks 0 0 0 0 9 250 594 790 9,678 14,378 Kimray Pumps 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 65 0 Produced Water 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total 0 0 0 7,240 15,858 19,931 31,636 41,920 51,864 59,189 GHGI Source 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Compressors 0 0 0 0 0 2,790 957 451 984 981 Compressor Blowdowns 125 3,828 4,132 9,103 4,450 4,450 5,407 5,908 6,244 6,161 Compressor Starts 12,833 13,030 13,116 13,118 13,707 14,269 14,344 14,379 17,705 15,416 Dehydrator Vents/Kimray Pumps 24,369 28,742 26,836 30,737 32,510 35,434 43,333 52,245 63,917 70,806 Engines 9,498 9,790 10,472 7,928 15,928 12,250 13,399 18,650 17,646 20,610 Equipment Leaks 8,117 9,082 9,097 22,792 24,792 20,118 29,246 23,927 42,160 39,416 Kimray Pumps 0 0 0 0 0 0 42 822 2,530 424 Produced Water 628 628 628 628 628 628 686 1,023 1,023 1,023 Total 55,570 65,099 64,282 84,306 92,015 89,939 107,414 117,405 152,208 154,836 Page 12 of 17 ------- April 2022 GHGI Source 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Compressors 333 1,769 48 48 48 51 51 48 48 48 Compressor Blowdowns 19,802 4,510 4,500 5,211 5,224 5,566 4,633 4,499 4,499 4,499 Compressor Starts 16,126 15,240 15,238 15,927 15,932 15,909 15,909 15,909 15,909 16,954 Dehydrator Vents/Kimray Pumps 76,552 82,728 48,177 49,987 49,987 50,043 50,125 51,798 50,125 50,911 Engines 29,069 29,208 29,074 28,817 30,100 32,255 30,938 44,629 31,396 32,147 Equipment Leaks 50,043 48,832 13,191 12,261 5,102 4,049 6,477 2,700 23 85 Kimray Pumps 278 166 166 166 167 166 166 166 166 166 Produced Water 1,023 1,023 1,023 1,023 1,023 1,023 1,023 1,023 1,023 1,023 Total 193,226 183,476 111,417 113,441 107,583 109,063 109,322 120,772 103,190 105,833 B-2. Annual Transmission and Storage Segment Gas STAR Reductions, by GHGI Emission Source, for 1990- 2019 (mt CH4). GHGI Source 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 Dehydrator Vents 0 0 0 61 74 77 849 3,374 3,371 3,341 Engines 0 0 0 2,803 6,007 9,108 11,438 13,495 35,790 37,132 Pipeline Leaks 0 0 0 136 0 33 465 0 21,251 3,382 Station Venting 0 0 0 1,071 429 1,164 1,650 916 1,239 1,113 Total 0 0 0 4,071 6,510 10,381 14,402 17,784 61,652 44,969 GHGI Source 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Dehydrator Vents 3,219 3,415 3,367 3,318 3,229 3,135 2,860 2,759 2,759 2,759 Engines 38,732 44,477 56,309 57,719 65,869 70,824 73,845 80,627 86,944 98,272 Pipeline Leaks 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 6,929 3,659 4,098 Station Venting 2,246 3,766 2,590 6,563 5,069 2,032 9,255 1,664 6,140 3,350 Total 44,197 51,658 62,266 67,600 74,167 75,993 85,960 91,978 99,502 108,479 GHGI Source 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Dehydrator Vents 2,759 2,759 2,759 2,759 2,759 2,759 2,759 2,759 2,759 4,089 Engines 86,793 87,773 91,931 91,575 95,736 97,156 97,258 97,084 115,091 132,410 Pipeline Leaks 5,066 6,972 6,972 1,919 4,179 1,194 2,534 4,085 4,083 590 Station Venting 3,475 2,541 3,258 3,556 3,243 3,639 18,151 25,998 28,402 21,418 Total 98,093 100,044 104,919 99,809 105,918 104,748 120,701 129,926 150,335 158,507 Page 13 of 17 ------- April 2022 B-3. Annual Distribution Segment Gas STAR Reductions, by GHGI Emission Source, for 1990-2019 (mt CH4). GHGI Source 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 Pressure Relief Valve Releases 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 193 0 Pipeline Blowdowns 0 0 0 963 1,813 1,258 1,555 4,270 1,468 1,550 Mishaps (Dig- ins) 0 0 0 0 0 13 18 39 38 61 Total 0 0 0 963 1,813 1,272 1,573 4,308 1,699 1,611 GHGI Source 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Pressure Relief Valve Releases 0 0 1,490 0 0 1 10 0 143 0 Pipeline Blowdowns 1,502 1,607 3,111 2,645 3,609 5,986 8,804 3,024 3,034 2,652 Mishaps (Dig- ins) 13 42 51 100 343 618 816 2,382 1,101 1,495 Total 1,516 1,650 4,652 2,744 3,952 6,605 9,630 5,406 4,278 4,147 GHGI Source 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Pressure Relief Valve Releases 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Pipeline Blowdowns 3,021 2,200 1,988 2,170 1,871 2,282 2,022 2,334 2,801 2,202 Mishaps (Dig- ins) 1,593 5,441 1,415 1,891 2,054 1,978 2,188 1,420 1,331 1,383 Total 4,614 7,642 3,403 4,062 3,925 4,260 4,209 3,754 4,133 3,586 Page 14 of 17 ------- April 2022 Appendix C. Adjusted Gas STAR Reductions Applied for the 2022 GHGI Update Appendix C reflects the Gas STAR reductions data as applied for the 2022 GHGI, and includes the adjustments presented in Section 2 (to disaggregate emissions) and Section 3 (to exclude certain reductions that resulted in negative net emissions values)). C-l. Annual Production Segment Adjusted Gas STAR Reductions, by GHGI Emission Source, for 1990-2020 (mt CH4). GHGI Source 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 Compressors 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Compressor Blowdowns3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Compressor Starts3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Dehydrator Vents/Kimray Pumps 0 0 0 3,766 5,051 6,862 12,391 20,007 22,873 22,769 Dehy Vents 0 0 0 904 1,212 1,647 2,974 4,802 5,490 5,464 Kimray Pumps 0 0 0 2,862 3,839 5,215 9,417 15,205 17,384 17,304 Engines 0 0 0 3,037 3,847 5,831 8,618 8,323 6,259 9,123 Equipment Leaks 0 0 0 0 9 250 594 790 9,678 14,378 Heaters 0 0 0 0 1 21 51 67 823 1,222 Separators 0 0 0 0 4 120 286 380 4,655 6,916 Dehydrators 0 0 0 0 1 16 38 51 619 920 Meters/Piping 0 0 0 0 3 93 220 292 3,581 5,320 Kimray Pumps 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 65 0 Produced Water 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total 0 0 0 6,803 8,907 12,944 21,604 29,119 38,875 46,270 GHGI Source 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Compressors 0 0 0 0 0 2,790 957 451 984 981 Compressor Blowdowns3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Compressor Starts3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Dehydrator Vents/Kimray Pumps 24,369 28,742 26,836 30,737 32,510 35,434 43,333 52,245 63,917 70,806 Dehy Vents 5,849 6,898 6,441 7,377 7,802 8,504 10,400 12,539 15,340 16,994 Kimray Pumps 18,521 21,844 20,396 23,360 24,708 26,930 32,933 39,706 48,577 53,813 Engines 9,498 9,790 10,472 7,928 15,928 12,250 13,399 18,650 17,646 20,610 Equipment Leaks 8,117 9,082 9,097 22,792 24,792 20,118 29,246 23,927 42,160 39,416 Heaters 690 772 773 1,937 2,107 1,710 2,486 2,034 3,584 3,350 Separators 3,904 4,369 4,376 10,963 11,925 9,677 14,068 11,509 20,279 18,959 Dehydrators 519 581 582 1,459 1,587 1,288 1,872 1,531 2,698 2,523 Meters/Piping 3,003 3,360 3,366 8,433 9,173 7,444 10,821 8,853 15,599 14,584 Kimray Pumps 0 0 0 0 0 0 42 822 2,530 424 Produced Water 628 628 628 628 628 628 686 1,023 1,023 1,023 Total 42,612 48,242 47,034 62,085 73,858 71,220 87,663 97,119 128,258 133,260 Page 15 of 17 ------- April 2022 GHGI Source 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Compressors 333 1,769 48 48 48 51 51 48 48 48 48 Compressor Blowdowns3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Compressor Starts3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Dehydrator Vents/Kimray Pumps 75,140b 79,345b 48,177 49,987 49,987 50,043 50,125 51,798 50,125 50,911 50,911 Dehy Vents 18,372 19,855 11,562 11,997 11,997 12,010 12,030 12,431 12,030 12,219 12,219 Kimray Pumps 58,179 62,874 36,614 37,990 37,990 38,033 38,095 39,366 38,095 38,692 38,692 Engines 29,069 29,208 29,074 28,817 30,100 32,255 30,938 44,629 31,396 32,147 32,147 Equipment Leaks 50,043 48,832 13,191 12,261 5,102 4,049 6,477 2,700 23 85 85 Heaters 4,254 4,151 1,121 1,042 434 344 551 229 2 7 7 Separators 24,071 23,488 6,345 5,898 2,454 1,947 3,115 1,299 11 41 41 Dehydrators 3,203 3,125 844 785 327 259 415 173 1 5 5 Meters/Piping 18,516 18,068 4,881 4,537 1,888 1,498 2,396 999 9 31 31 Kimray Pumps 278 166 166 166 167 166 166 166 166 166 166 Produced Water 1,023 1,023 1,023 1,023 1,023 1,023 1,023 1,023 1,023 1,023 1,023 Total 155,886 160,342 91,679 92,302 86,427 87,587 88,780 100,364 82,782 84,380 84,380 a EPA removed Gas STAR reductions entirely for sources with more than 10 years of negative calculated emissions: compressor blowdowns and compressor starts. b EPA reduced GAS STAR reductions for dehydrator vents (2010-2011) to prevent negative calculated emissions. C-2. Annual Transmission and Storage Segment Adjusted Gas STAR Reductions, by GHGI Emission Source, for 1990-2020 (mt CH4). GHGI Source 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 Dehydrator Vents3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Engines 0 0 0 2,803 6,007 9,108 11,438 13,495 35,790 37,132 Pipeline Leaks3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Station Venting 0 0 0 1,071 429 1,164 1,650 916 1,239 1,113 Total 0 0 0 3,874 6,436 10,272 13,088 14,410 37,029 38,246 GHGI Source 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Dehydrator Vents3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Engines 38,732 44,477 56,309 57,719 65,869 70,824 73,845 80,627 86,944 98,272 Pipeline Leaks3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Station Venting 2,246 3,766 2,590 6,563 5,069 2,032 9,255 1,664 6,140 3,350 Total 40,978 48,243 58,900 64,282 70,938 72,856 83,101 82,291 93,084 101,622 GHGI Source 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Dehydrator Vents3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Engines 86,793 87,773 91,931 91,575 95,736 97,156 97,258 97,084 115,091 132,410 132,410 Pipeline Leaks3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Station Venting 3,475 2,541 3,258 3,556 3,243 3,639 18,151 25,998 28,402 21,418 21,418 Total 90,268 90,314 95,189 95,131 98,980 100,796 115,408 123,082 143,493 153,828 153,828 a EPA removed Gas STAR reductions entirely for sources with more than 10 years of negative calculated emissions: dehydrator vents and pipeline leaks. Page 16 of 17 ------- April 2022 C-3. Annual Distribution Segment Adjusted Gas STAR Reductions, by GHGI Emission Source, for 1990-2020 (mt CH4). GHGI Source 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 Pressure Relief Valve Releases 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 193 0 Pipeline Blowdowns 0 0 0 963 1,813 1,258 1,555 3,407a 1,468 1,550 Mishaps (Dig- ins) 0 0 0 0 0 13 18 39 38 61 Total 0 0 0 963 1,813 1,272 1,573 3,446 1,699 1,611 GHGI Source 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Pressure Relief Valve Releases 0 0 l,092a 0 0 1 10 0 143 0 Pipeline Blowdowns 1,502 1,607 3,111 2,645 3,609 3,855a 3,973a 3,024 3,034 2,652 Mishaps (Dig- ins) 13 42 51 100 343 618 816 2,382 1,101 1,495 Total 1,516 1,650 4,254 2,744 3,952 4,474 4,798 5,406 4,278 4,147 GHGI Source 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Pressure Relief Valve Releases 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Pipeline Blowdowns 3,021 2,200 1,988 2,170 1,871 2,282 2,022 2,334 2,801 2,202 2,202 Mishaps (Dig- ins) 1,593 5,441 1,415 1,891 2,054 1,978 2,188 1,420 1,331 1,383 1,383 Total 4,614 7,642 3,403 4,062 3,925 4,260 4,209 3,754 4,133 3,586 3,586 a EPA reduced GAS STAR reductions for pressure release valves (2002) and pipeline blowdowns (1997, 2005-2006) to prevent negative calculated emissions. Page 17 of 17 ------- |